Professional Documents
Culture Documents
LEGIFA<K
;ËyC@J<DFI@E<K:CyD<E:<yC@8I;JDC
<EG8IK<E8I@8K8M<:1
P:LM>E:G=L<:I>
GIyJ<EK8K@FE<K<EA<LO;LGIFA<K½N8JK<C8E;J:8G<¾
¾O9KL=D9F<K;9H=¿=KLMF=AFKL9DD9LAGFEGFME=FL9D=$MFH9QK9?=N9DDGFFz<=<MF=K
;GMN=JL=KH9JMF=;MAJ9KK=<=;<&
Jz?zFzJ9LAGF=LJ=;Q;D9?=
<aZjn^Zgg^l^o^g]^gmlnke^fZk\a_kZg
Zblienl]^+))fbeebhgl]^]bldl'Bek^ikl^gm^]^l
mhgg^l ]^ fZmkbZnq jnb i^no^gm% l^ehg e^nkl nlZ`^l ^m e^ \hfihkm^f^gm ]^l \hglhffZm^nkl% ]^o^gbk
kZib]^f^gm]^l]\a^mlhnmk^\hgl^kol]Zgle^lmbkhbkllZgll^kobk'<aZjn^Zgg^%]Zgle^fhg]^^g&
mb^k%]^lfbeebhgl]^mhgg^l]^]bldllhgmc^mleZihn[^ee^':ikl\hee^\m^%belohgmk^chbg]k^e^lnlbg^l
]Íbg\bgkZmbhghne^l\^gmk^l]Í^g_hnbll^f^gmihnkmk^ebfbgl%Zo^\ng^iZkm]^oZehkblZmbhgg^k`&
mbjn^'
C\i\ZpZcX^\eË\jkgXjd`j\egcXZ\\e=iXeZ\Xcfijhl\c\:;g\lkki\kiXej]fid^mkbgc^\m]Zgle^\r\e^
]^ob^]^fZmkbZnqbg]nlmkb^el'C\i\ZpZcX^\[l[`jbg\id\kkiX`kcËZfefd`\`dgfikXek\[Ële\i\jjfliZ\efe
i\eflm\cXYc\1c\gkifc\'
MFHJGB=L?DG:9DIMA9;LAGFF=<=KD=NA=JK=L<=K=FB=MPz;GDG?AIM=K$z;GFGEAIM=K=LKG;A9MP&
,%0.mhgg^l]^<=lhgmg\^llZbk^lihnk\hnokbk+))Hf+]niZkobl]^eÍam^e]^obee^#!^q^fie^
]^eb^n\hak^gm"^mZiihkm^knglmh\dfbgbfng]^fZmbk^k^\r\e^kihnki^kf^mmk^e^eZg\^f^gmeZik^&
fbk^Öebk^]^k^\r\eZ`^^m]^oZehkblZmbhg]^<=Ögl]b]Z\mbjn^l^g?kZg\^^giZkm^gZkbZmZo^\<he]bld'
:n]^e]^eZl^glb[beblZmbhg^m]nf^llZ`^oab\nei^g]Zgmlhg^qihlbmbhg%e^\r\e^]^ob^]^¿PZlm^
EZg]l\Zi^Àbfiebjn^]^ghf[k^nqZ\m^nkl^mi^kf^m]^\hg\kmbl^kngikhc^m]^\kZmbhg]^Öebk^'
K=FKA:ADAK9LAGF=L;GDD=;L=
¿PZlm^EZg]l\Zi^À^lmngiZrlZ`^]rgZfbjn^\hfihl]^+.))))<=\hee^\mlZnikl]Íhk`Zgbl&
f^liZkm^gZbk^l'E^l,%0.mhgg^l]^<=g\^llZbk^lZkZeblZmbhgi^kf^mm^gmeZ_hbl]^l^glb[bebl^k3
&^gZfhgme^liZkm^gZbk^lZnmkble^\mb_]^<='
&e^`kZg]in[eb\i^g]Zgmlhg^qihlbmbhg^meZ\hee^\m^ihnklnbob^Znmhnk]^eÍh^nok^'
&^m]ÍZiihkm^keZfZmbk^g\^llZbk^eÍ^gmk^ikbl^<he]bldihnkeZg\^keZik^fbk^Öebk^]^k^\r&
\eZ`^^m]^oZehkblZmbhg]^<=Ögl]b]Z\mbjn^l^g?kZg\^'
I^g]ZgmeZikbh]^]Í^qihlbmbhgleflk`c[\ZXcZlc`ek\iXZk`]fblZnihbgmiZkIkb\^pZm^kahnl^<hhi^kl&>\h&
[beZgi^kf^m]^f^lnk^ke^lbfiZ\ml^gobkhgg^fmZnq^obmliZkeZ\hee^\m^]^l\]'
E^liblm^l]ÍhimbfblZmbhgljnblhgmfbl^l^gh^nok^iZkeÍ^gl^f[e^]^lZ\m^nkl]^eZÖebk^hgmmb]^g&
mbÖ^liZkIkb\^pZm^kahnl^<hhi^kl&>\h[beZgZnfhr^g]^l^lhnmbel]ÍoZenZmbhg^m]^\hgl^be'
@EK<EK@FE8IK@JK@HL<
MF=;MAJ9KK=EGFME=FL9D=<GFLDÌ9H=;LHMAKK9FL;9;@==FJz9DALzMF=?J9F<=NMDFzJ9:ADALz&
<^mm^bglmZeeZmbhglÍbgl\kbm]Zglng^lkb^]^ikhc^ml]^]b__k^gm^l\a^ee^lZrZgm^g\hffngng^k×^qbhg
Znmhnk]niZrlZ`^%]^eÍ\heh`b^^m]^]^lfZmkbZnqbg]nlmkb^el'¿PZlm^EZg]l\Zi^Àkoe^e^ihm^gmb^e
^meÍZli^\mik\b^nq]Íngh[c^mhk]bgZbk^3e^<='
<^iZrlZ`^ZkmbÖ\b^e^lmng^oh\Zmbhg]n]l^km%]^l]\a^mm^kb^l`b`Zgm^ljn^loblb[e^lhnbgoblb[e^l%]^
eZ_kZ`bebm]^eZgZmnk^^m]n\ebfZm'
P:LM>E:G=L<:I>
J@DLC8K@FE ;< CË@EJK8CC8K@FE ½N8JK< C8E;J:8G<¾ JLI C< G8IM@J
;<CË?åK<C;<M@CC<;<G8I@J%
EFLM<CC< :FCC<:K< 8LGIßJ ;L >I8E; GL9C@: J<EJ@9@C@J8K@FE
FLK@C;<:8C:LC
Nghnmbe]^\Ze\ne]o^ehiiiZkIkb\^pZm^kahnl^<hhi^kl>\h[beZg%fbl^gieZ\^lnke^lbm^%i^kf^mmkZ]^
_Zbk^e \h&[beZg]n\r\e^]^ob^]^e bglmZeeZmbhg'>g^__^m%e^k^\r\eZ`^]n]bljn^_Zohkbl^e \hghfb^ghg
g`eb`^Z[e^] ng^g^k`b^_hllbe^mklbfihkmZgm^3e^imkhe^'
D
[gZadYfk]jYj][Yd[md
[`Yim]bgmj]f^gf[lagf\mfgeZj]\]k;<'<N<Yhhgjl
khYjd]knakal]mjk&
FLK@C;<:8C:LC
=>LBFI:<MLÃE:<HEE><M>
=>LBFI:<MLEHKL=NIKH<{={=>K{@{G{K:MBHG
=>L{<HGHFB>L=ÍBFI:<MLI:KE>K><R<E:@>'
:FLG< ;< CË@EJK8CC8K@FE ½N8JK< C8E;J:8G<¾ JLI C< G8IM@J ;<
CË?åK<C;<M@CC<;<G8I@J%
E8GG<;<:;
JKIL:KLI<GFIK8EK<
FLK@C;<:8C:LC
[\j`dgXZkj~cXZfcc\Zk\
[\j`dgXZkjcfij[lgifZ[[\i^eiXk`fe
\k[\jZfefd`\j[Ë`dgXZkjgXic\i\ZpZcX^\%
C<:P:C<;<M@<;<N8JK<C8E;J:8G<
(
:FCC<:K<J<EJ@9@C@J8K@FE
Xlgi
j[\jfi^Xe`jd\jgXik\eX`i\j
/
I<:P:C8><
)
I8D8JJ8><;<J;@JBJ
JKF:B8><
.
I<$JKF:B8><
*
GIF;L:K@FE
;@D<EJ@FEJF:@8C<
!XjjfZ`Xk`fe:XiXmXejiX`c
-
;yDFEK8><
+
DFEK8><
,
<OGFJ@K@FEJ<EJ@9@C@J8K@FE
EFLM<CC<:FCC<:K<8LGIßJ;L>I8E;GL9C@:
FLK@C;<:8C:LC
(
:FCC<:K<J<EJ@9@C@J8K@FE
Xlgi
j[\jfi^Xe`jd\jgXik\eX`i\j
/
I<:P:C8><
)
I8D8JJ8><;<J;@JBJ
JKF:B8><
.
I<$JKF:B8><
*
GIF;L:K@FE
;@D<EJ@FEJF:@8C<
!XjjfZ`Xk`fe:XiXmXejiX`c
( -
;yDFEK8><
+
DFEK8><
:FCC<:K<<KJ<EJ@9@C@J8K@FE ,
<OGFJ@K@FEJ<EJ@9@C@J8K@FE
EFLM<CC<:FCC<:K<8LGIßJ;L>I8E;GL9C@:
FLK@C;<:8C:LC
FYa\Zk`]1 :fcc\Zk\[\),'''':;*#.,kfee\j
J\ej`Y`c`jXk`feXlki`[\j[Z_\kjXlj\`e[\j\eki\gi`j\j\k[\j`ejk`klk`fejgXik\eX`i\j%
J\ej`Y`c`jXk`feXloÔc`
i\j[\i\pZcX^\gfjj`Yc\j[Xejle\[dXiZ_\[\i\jgfejXY`c`k
jfZ`Xc\\k\em`ifee\d\ekXc\%
:FCC<:K<
@;<EK@=@<IC<J>@J<D<EKJ1
$^`j\d\ek[`]]ljg\ijfee\c1gXik`Zlc`\ij:;fYjfc
k\j[\dlj`hl\j&Ôcdj&glYc`Z`kX`i\j&cf^`Z`\cj %
$^`j\d\ek[`]]ljgif]\jj`fee\c1<eki\gi`j\j&@ejk`klk`fej&yZfc\j&Le`m\ij`kj&8jjfZ`Xk`fej%
j\im`Z\`e]fidXk`hl\j#XiZ_`m\j%%% %:feÔ[\ek`Xc`k[\j[fee\j^XiXek`\%
$i\Ylkjgfk\ek`\cj[\j\eki\gi`j\jgif[lZki`Z\j[\:;%
;@JGFJ@K@=;<C8:FCC<:K<1
:_Xhl\gXik\eX`i\&gXik`Z`gXekfi^Xe`j\cXZfcc\Zk\jc\Zk`m\\kjËhl`g\[\Zfek\e\lij\e]feZk`fe[\j\j
Y\jf`ejj\cfeleZX_`\i[\jZ_Xi^\j[Ôe`gXi:fc[`jb%
<egXiXcc
c\#le[`jgfj`k`][\Zfcc\Zk\jgZ`Ôhl\[\jYf`k`\ijg\lkki\d`j\egcXZ\%
J<EJ@9@C@J8K@FEXlgi
j[\jfi^Xe`jd\jgXik\eX`i\j
Gij\ekXk`fe\kZfddle`ZXk`fem`jl\cc\[lgifa\kXlkfli[\jgf`ekj[\Zfcc\Zk\ZiXej#X]ÔZ_\#`ekiXe\k#
aflieXlo`ek\ie\j%%% %
:fe]i\eZ\jXlkfli[\jk_dXk`hl\j1
$Xik\k[\m\cfgg\d\ek[liXYc\
$gl`j\d\ek[\ji\jjfliZ\jeXkli\cc\jgfcpZXiYfeXk\[l:;`jjl[lgkifc\ %
$i\ZpZcX^\%
Xe`d\jgXic\jXik`jk\j\kc\j\og\ikjgXik\eX`i\j1:fc[`jb\kGi`Z\nXk\i_flj\:ffg\ij$<ZfY`cXe%
)
I8D8JJ8><;<J;@JBJ<KJKF:B8><
I8D8JJ8><
;`jgfj`k`][\kiXejgfikfgk`d`jXlgcXe\em`ifee\d\ekXcgXiGi`Z\nXk\i_flj\:ffg\ij$<ZfY`cXe%
KiXejgfik\]]\ZklgXi:fc[`jb%>iXkl`kgflic\kiXejgfik[\j[`jbjgflic\YifpX^\%
JKF:B8><
C\j:;#jË`cjjfekZfej`[ijZfdd\[Z_\kj#[f`m\ekki\jkfZbj[Xejle\e[if`kX^i%
!Fgk`fe(JkfZbX^\~cË\eki\gk:fc[`jbgi
j[\GXi`jgf`ekj[\Zfcc\Zk\ \kgi
j[lc`\lgfk\ek`\c
[\Zflkli\
!Fgk`fe)%JkfZbX^\@eZ`eiXk\li[Ë<mipX^igflijkfZb\ic\j[Z_\kj%g`jk\~mXc`[\i
*
GIF;L:K@FE
E8GG<;<:;1:flkli\[\j:;jliledX`ccX^\Ôc\k
8k\c`\i[\gif[lZk`fe[\cËXjjfZ`Xk`fe:XiXmXejiX`c;m\cfgg\d\ek\jklefi^Xe`jd\[\]fidXk`feZi\e
)''(%Gclj`\lij gc\j [\ ]fidXk`fe j\ jfek [m\cfggj 1 c\j 8k\c`\ij [\ G[X^f^`\ G\ijfeeXc`jj# c\ gc\
cl[`hl\i\^iflgXekcXcl[fk_
hl\\k\eÔec\:_Xek`\iZfc\#jkilZkli\hl`[`jg\ej\[\j]fidXk`fejc`e^l`j$
k`hl\j\k[\jZflijgiXk`hl\jZflkli\ %
JKIL:KLI<GFIK8EK< (
jkilZkli\Zf$Zfel\#df[lcXYc\ :FCC<:K<J<EJ@9@C@J8K@FE
Xlgi
j[\jfi^Xe`jd\jgXik\eX`i\j
Z_f`o[\jdXki`Xlo%
FLK@C;<:8C:LC / )
I<:P:C8>< I8D8JJ8><;<J;@JBJ
JKF:B8><
Leflk`c[\ZXcZlc[m\cfgggXiGi`Z\nXk\i_flj\:ffg\ij<ZfY`cXe%
. *
+
I<$JKF:B8>< GIF;L:K@FE
;@D<EJ@FEJF:@8C<
!XjjfZ`Xk`fe:XiXmXejiX`c
DFEK8>< -
;yDFEK8><
+
DFEK8><
yhl`g\k\Z_e`hl\% ,
Fgk`d`jXk`fe[\jkiXejgfikj\k[lk\dgj[\dfekX^\%
<OGFJ@K@FEJ<EJ@9@C@J8K@FE
EFLM<CC<:FCC<:K<8LGIßJ;L>I8E;GL9C@:
FLK@C;<:8C:LC
,
<OGFJ@K@FE&EFLM<CC<:FCC<:K<8LGIßJ;L>I8E;GL9C@:
J<EJ@9@C@J8K@FE&FLK@C;<:8C:LC
F\lmi\
Flk`c[\ZXcZlc
Gf`ek[\Zfcc\Zk\Xlkfli[\cËf\lmi\%
;li\[\cË\ogfj`k`fe
(
:FCC<:K<J<EJ@9@C@J8K@FE
Xlgi
j[\jfi^Xe`jd\jgXik\eX`i\j
8e`dXk`fejXlkfli[\cËf\lmi\1
:fe]i\eZ\j\kZfddle`ZXk`fe%%% /
I<:P:C8><
)
I8D8JJ8><;<J;@JBJ
JKF:B8><
. *
- I<$JKF:B8>< GIF;L:K@FE
;@D<EJ@FEJF:@8C<
!XjjfZ`Xk`fe:XiXmXejiX`c
;yDFEK8>< - +
yhl`g\k\Z_e`hl\% ;yDFEK8>< DFEK8><
Fgk`d`jXk`fe[\jkiXejgfikj\k[lk\dgj[\[dfekX^\% ,
<OGFJ@K@FEJ<EJ@9@C@J8K@FE
EFLM<CC<:FCC<:K<8LGIßJ;L>I8E;GL9C@:
FLK@C;<:8C:LC
.
I<$JKF:B8><
/
I<:P:C8><#(
i\Ôc`
i\[\i\ZpZcX^\[\j:;fYjfc
k\j\e=iXeZ\
Gi`j\\eZ_Xi^\gXi:fc[`jb
:fc[`jbXkYk`[Xejle\[dXiZ_\[\dXeX^\d\ek\em`ifee\d\ekXchl`Zfej`jk\#\eki\Xlki\j#~`ejZi$
`i\c\jdXk`
i\jiZlgi\j[Xejlegifa\k[\[m\cfgg\d\ekcfZXcflZ_Xhl\kXg\[lgifa\k\k[lgifZ$
\jj\jkmXcl\\ek\id\jfZ`Xlo\k\em`ifee\d\ekXlo%
GXiX`cc\lij#j\j]flie`jj\lijjfekZf$X^i\j#jXZfejfddXk`fe\jkiX`jfee\#cXkiXXY`c`k[li\ZpZcX^\
j\iX\]]\Zk`m\\kZfeÔ\~lefi^Xe`jd\`e[g\e[Xek¿
E><=
C<:;#EFKI<D8K@ßI<GI<D@ßI<
<aZjn^Zgg^%]Zgle^fhg]^^gmb^k%]^lfbeebhgl]^mhgg^l]^]bldllhgmc^mleZihn[^ee^'
Belohgmk^chbg]k^e^lnlbg^l]Íbg\bgkZmbhghne^l\^gmk^l]Í^g_hnbll^f^gmihnkmk^ebfbgl'
E^i\ZpZcX^\eË\jkgXjd`j\egcXZ\\e=iXeZ\Xcfijhl\c\:;g\lkki\kiXej]fid^mkbgc^\m]Zgle^
\r\e^]^ob^]^fZmkbZnqbg]nlmkb^el\hff^3
E^lib\^lZnmhfh[be^l
E^lfZmbk^lik^fbk^lihnke^lieZlmbjn^l!e^l]bljn^llhgm[khrl^gng^ln[lmZg\^l^f[eZ[e^
]n`kZob^k%jnb^lmo^g]n]^l^gmk^ikbl^ljnbe^_hg]^gm^me^\hgo^kmbll^gm^gieZlmbjn^"
E^fZmkb^e]^[nk^Zn
E^l[hm^l^me^liZgg^Znq]ÍZeZkf^%eÍ\eZbkZ`^^meÍblheZmbhg]^l\[e^le^\mkbjn^l'
E^l<=lhgmc^ml]Zgle^lihn[^ee^lghkfZe^l'EÍebfbgZmbhg]hbmmk^\ahblb^^g]^kgb^kk^\hnkl\Zklbe^
<=[ke^mkl[b^g%bef^mmkZ[^Zn\hni]^m^fil!]^l\^gmZbg^l]ÍZgg^l"l^]\hfihl^k]Zglng\^gmk^
]Í^g_hnbll^f^gm'
GfliiXgg\c#c\j:;\k;M;hl`jfeka\kjjfek[\jjfliZ\j[\^Xjg`ccX^\\k[Ëe\i^`\`dgfikXek\j\k\ekiX$
e\ekle\g\ik\[\i\jjfliZ\jgiZ`\lj\j%
($JFE:P:C<;<M@<<JKKIßJ@DG8:K8EKJLICË<EM@IFEE<D<EK
E^l<=^m=O=lhgm_Z[kbjnliZkmbk]^ghf[k^nqfZmkbZnq%]hgm\aZ\ng]blihl^]^lhgikhik^\r\e^]^
ob^%bfiebjnZgmeÍnmbeblZmbhg]^eÍg^k`b^^meZikh]n\mbhg]^]\a^ml'<^lfZmkbZnq]hbo^gm_Zbk^eÍh[c^m]^
mkZgl_hkfZmbhgZoZgm]Ímk^nmbebl]ZgleZ_Z[kb\Zmbhg]^l]bldl'Hgk^mkhno^3
eÍ:enfbgbnf3Bllnikbg\biZe^f^gm]^eZmkZgl_hkfZmbhg]^eZ[Znqbm^'E^fbg^kZb]^;Znqbm^^lmmkZgl_hkf
^gng^ln[lmZg\^Zii^e^¿Zenfbg^ÀiZk]bo^klikh\]l]hgme^eZoZ`^%e^[khrZ`^%eZ]bllhenmbhg^m
e^ÖemkZ`^'EÍZenfbg^jnbklnem^]^\^ikh\^llnl^lm^glnbm^mkZgl_hkf^^gZenfbgbnfiZke^[bZbl]Íng
ikh\^llnlZii^eeZÊ_nlbhgËmkl\hglhffZmkb\^]Íg^k`b^'>glnbm^%e^fmZe^lmfbl^g_hkf^^mkhne'
L^ehgLHLIeZgm^%eÍZenfbgbnf^lmeZobg`mbf^k^llhnk\^ghgk^ghno^eZ[e^Zf^g^]bliZkZbmk^]n_Zbm
]^eÍ^qiehbmZmbhganfZbg^bgm^glbo^'E^lmh\d^lm^lmbf+.fbeebZk]l]^mhgg^l]Zgle^l`bl^f^gml^q&
iehbmZ[e^l]^;Znqbm^'^gCnbg+))13bek^lm^*,*Zgg^l]^kl^ko^%Znkrmaf^Z\mn^e]^ikh]n\mbhgjnb
^lm]^*2)fbeebhgl]^mhgg^liZkZg'EÍinbl^f^gm]^\^fmZel^kZ]hg\]Ögbmb_^g+*,2'
E^llhnk\^likhob^gg^gm^ll^gmb^ee^f^gm]^EÍNL@L!e^l^kob\^`heh`bjn^]^l>mZmlngbl"'
ammi3((fbg^kZel'nl`l'`ho('<^mm^]Zm^^lm]hgg^mbmk^ink^f^gmbg]b\Zmb_'>ee^i^nm^g^__^moZkb^kl^ehg
e^llhnk\^l^meÍohenmbhg]^ghmk^\bobeblZmbhg']niher\Zk[hgZm^3ng^`Zff^]^ieZlmbjn^%eZ[hkiZkmbk
]^imkhe^[knm^m]n`ZsgZmnk^e^qmkZbml]^eZM^kk^'
]^iher\Zk[hgZm^%ng^`Zff^]^ieZlmbjn^%eZ[hkiZkmbk]^imkhe^[knm^m]n`ZsgZmnk^e^qmkZbml]^
eZM^kk^'
L^ehgLHLIeZg^m^%eÍhkghbk^lmeZjnbgsbf^k^llhnk\^ghgk^ghno^eZ[e^Zf^g^]bliZkZbmk^]n_Zbm]^
eÍ^qiehbmZmbhganfZbg^bgm^glbo^'E^lkl^ko^lg^k`mbjn^lfhg]bZe^l]^imkhe^lhgm^lmbf^l*/-%-
fbeebZk]l]^mhgg^l'>gobkhg.)hgm]cmihfi^l'>gCnbg+))1%bek^lm^-+Zgg^l]^kl^ko^%Zn
krmaf^ Z\mn^e ]^ \hglhffZmbhg jnb ^lm ]^ 1) F[[el(chnk' EÍinbl^f^gm ]^ \^mm^ g^k`b^ _hllbe^ l^kZ
]hg\]Ögbmb_^g+).)'=nfhbgllhnllZ_hkf^\hgo^gmbhgg^ee^'Lhnk\^;ILmZmblmb\ZeK^ob^ph_phke]
>g^k`r+))0'<^mm^]Zm^^lm]hgg^mbmk^ink^f^gmbg]b\Zmb_'>ee^i^nm^g^__^moZkb^kl^ehge^llhnk\^l
^meÍohenmbhg]^ghmk^\bobeblZmbhg'EZ_Z[kb\Zmbhg]Í*(+dbeh]^iher\Zk[hgZm^!i^kf^m]^_Z[kbjn^k,)<="%
g\^llbm^,)f,]^`ZsgZmnk^e%+mZll^l]^imkhe^[knm^m+-ebmk^l]Í^Zn'
]^eZjn^%_Zbm^]ÍZ\krebjn^%ng^Znmk^_hkf^]^ieZlmbjn^'
]ÍHk%ngfmZejnb^lm^qmkZbm]^eZM^kk^'L^ehgLHLIeZgm^%e^lmh\d^lm^lmbf-+)))mhgg^l]Zgle^l
`bl^f^gml^qiehbmZ[e^l'>gCnbg+))13bek^lm^*0Zgg^l]^kl^ko^%Znkrmaf^Z\mn^e]^ikh]n\mbhgjnb
^lm]^+.))mhgg^liZkZg'EÍinbl^f^gm]nfmZecZng^l^kZ]hg\]Ögbmb_^g+)+.'>gff^m^filjn^
e^sbg\^meÍbg]bnf'
]^\hehkZgml\abfbjn^lkZebll^geZ[hkZmhbk^%lhgmihnkeÍ^ll^gmb^ebllnl]^ikh]nbmlimkheb^kljnbikhob&
^gg^gm]^eZM^kk^'
]ÍZnmk^lfZmbk^lm^ee^ljn^eÍ^Zn%e^o^kk^%eÍZk`^gm^me^gb\d^e'
)$C<I<:P:C8><;<J:;&;M;&9FáK@<IJ<JKGIy=yI89C<ÁCË@E:@EyI8K@FE
<hfim^m^gn]nghf[k^bfihkmZgm]^<=o^g]nl%]n\ZkZ\mk^h[lhem^jnÍbei^nmk^ikl^gm^kZnikl]^l
c^ng^l%be^lmbfihkmZgm]^k×\abkZnqZk`nf^gml_ZohkZ[e^lZnk^\r\eZ`^!^g^__^m%e^<=^me^[hmb^k
lhgm]^lfZmkbZnqk^\r\eZ[e^l^gmhmZebm"'
;\jlj`e\j[\kiXej]fidXk`fe[\:;]feZk`fee\ekjlic\k\ii`kf`i\eXk`feXc'Ng`kZg]ghf[k^]^mkZgl_hk&
fZm^nkl]^fZmbk^lieZlmbjn^l!e^l]bldl^me^l[hmb^kl"^qblm^gm^g?kZg\^'Bellhgmlnl^l^mi^no^gm
lb`g^khnlÍ^g`Z`^kknmbebl^ke^lfZmbk^lmkZgl_hkf^l]Zgl]^likhc^mlbg]nlmkb^el_kZg
ZblZo^\ng^
mkZ
Z[bebmli\bÖjn^'
C\gfk\ek`\c[\i\ZpZcX^\j\dYc\`dgfikXekjliGXi`j\kcË@c\[\=iXeZ\%>gk`bhgiZkblb^gg^%1)]^l
fgZ`^llhgmjnbil^gbg_hkfZmbjn^%\^jnbk^ikl^gm^ngmkl`khlihm^gmb^e]^k^\r\eZ`^'Ng^mn]^Z
mf^g^eZnlZgg^he^ohenf^]^iher\Zk[hgZm^k^\r\e^kZm^lmbfienl]^,'/))mhgg^l!ohbk
ienl%mZgm]hggeÍ^__^m]^]lmh\dZ`^]^\^ieZlmbjn^aZnm^oZe^nkZchnm^"'
>gm^kf^]Íg^k`b^g\^llZbk^ihnkeZ[hk^k\^iher\Zk[hgZm^!,'/))')))Td`V#***',1TFC(d`V6-))'2/1
@C iZk Zg"% \^eZ k^ikl^gm^ ikl ]^ ]^nq Zgl ]ÍZnmhghfb^ ihnk e^ \aZn__Z`^ ^m eÍe^\mkb\bm ]n lbm^ ]^
eÍ>\he^Iherm^\agbjn^]^EZnlZgg^'
C\jdXki`Xlohl`Zfdgfj\ekc\[`jbjfek[\jdXk`
i\jj\Zfe[X`i\jki
j[\dXe[\jgXigclj`\lijj\Zk\lij
`e[ljki`\cj%EZk^oZehkblZmbhg]n]bld^gng^k^llhnk\^l^\hg]Zbk^^lm]hg\ienlZoZgmZ`^nl^!fnemb&nlZ`^
]niher\Zk[hgZm^%iherlmrkg^^miZib^k"jn^lZ]^lmkn\mbhg'
C\ i\ZpZcX^\ [l [`jb g\id\k cËZfefd`\ `dgfikXek\ [Ële\ i\jjfliZ\ efe i\eflm\cXYc\1 c\ gkifc\' Nmbebl
ihnk_Z[kbjn^ke^iher\Zk[hgZm^%e^imkhe^oZ]^o^gbkng^k^llhnk\^]^fhbgl^gfhbgl]blihgb[e^^m]^
ienl^gienl\hm^nl^'=ÍZbee^nkl\hgl\b^gml]^\^_Z\m^nkebfbmZgm%e^lbg]nlmkb^el^g`Z`^gm]^lmkZoZnq]^
k^\a^k\a^&]o^ehii^f^gmihnkbfZ`bg^k]^llniihkml[bh&]`kZ]Z[e^l!]bld^gfZl"'
C\i\ZpZcX^\g\id\kleZfY`cXegfj`k`]1
lhbm:eÍg^k`b^g\^llZbk^eÍ^qmkZ\mbhg]nimkhe^%
lhbm;eÍg^k`b^k^jnbl^ihnkmkZgl_hkf^ke^imkhe^^giher\Zk[hgZm^%
lhbm<eÍg^k`b^g\^llZbk^Znk^\r\eZ`^]n<=%
lhbm=eÍg^k`b^k\nik^ehkl]^eÍbg\bgkZmbhg]n]bld'
:$;&<7=
C\i\ZpZcX^\\jkmXcfi`j[Xejc\ZX[i\[l>i\e\cc\[\cË<em`ifee\d\ek
Ihnkebfbm^keZmhgg^]^]\a^mlfgZ`^kl%be^lmk^\hffZg]]^ebfbm^keÍ^g_hnbll^f^gm^meÍbg\bgkZmbhg%
]^oZehkbl^ke^k^\r\eZ`^^meZoZehkblZmbhgfZmbk^%]^k]nbk^eÍbfihkmZmbhg]^fZmbk^ik^fbk^^gknmb&
eblZgme^lfZmkbZnqk\nikl'E^<=^me^;hmb^klhgmmhmZe^f^gm\hg\^kgliZk\^likbg\bi^l'
<eÔe#cXgfglcXk`fej\dYc\gik\~gXik`Z`g\i~Z\kk\]fid\[\i\ZpZcX^\lbhgikhihl^]^l\Z]k^l]^\he&
e^\m^]Zglng^]fZk\a^]Í]n\ZmbhgeÍ^gobkhgg^f^gm'
<HL@G<&:FEK8:K
:KMBLM>L
>ebl^Fhkbg <ef^g\^>ebZk]
^ebl^fhkbg9fZ\'\hf \e^f^g\^'^ebZk]9`fZbe'\hf
$,,!)"/-/,,---/ $,,!)"//,*-,,1-
<HE=BLD <HE=BLDL:KE
=^gbl=:OB=(@kZgm
?bebk^k^\r\eZ`^ --[blkn^]^eZOhm^
0.)*+I:KBL
)20)-/-)/+
ammi3((ppp'\he]bld'_k
IKB<>P:M>KAHNL><HHI>KL LreoZbgE:F;>KMuIabebii^HLL>M
Ikb\^pZm^kahnl^<hhi^kl:]oblhkru>\h[beZg
hnmbel]ÍoZenZmbhg^m\hgl^be /,%kn^]^Obeeb^kl2++)1G^nbeer&Lnk&L^bg^<^]^q
lreoZbg'eZf[^km9_k'ip\'\hf
iabebii^'hll^m9_k'ip\'\hf
:LLH<B:MBHG<:K:O:GL>K:BE *+KN>F:KMBG;>KG:K=
0.)*,IZkbl
ikh]n\mbhg Meiahg^3)*'-,'*,'*,'))
:KMBLM>L
;\gl`j)''/<c`j\Dfi`e\k:cd\eZ\<c`Xi[JdXccD[`ldCXi^\ \ogcfi\ek[\eflm\cc\jmf`\j#g\id\kkXek
~Z_XZle[Ë\em`jX^\ic\jfYa\kj#c\j\jgXZ\j\kc\lijZpZc\j[\m`\Xlki\d\ek1C\i\ZpZcX^\#\em`kXek[\
eflm\cc\jgif[lZk`fej[ËfYa\kj#g\lkki\Zfej`[iZfdd\c\gi\d`\i^\jk\Zf$i\jgfejXYc\[\Z\jXiZ_`$
k\Zk\j$gcXjk`Z`\ee\jhl`eË\e[\d\li\ekgXjdf`ej[\jZiXki`Z\j[\]fid\j\k[Ëdfk`fej%
>EBL>FHKBG
=fid\~cËyZfc\EXk`feXc\Jlgi`\li\[\j8ikj;ZfiXk`]j[\GXi`j#~cX:\ekiXcJX`ekDXik`ej:fcc\^\[\
Cfe[i\j#gl`j~cXKfbpfEXk`feXcLe`m\ij`kpf]Ôe\Xikj~Kfbpf#<c`j\Dfi`eiXc`j\[\jgifa\kj[Xejc\
[fdX`e\[\cX[`i\Zk`feXik`jk`hl\#[\cXjZef^iXg_`\\k[\cËXikZfek\dgfiX`e%
<E>F>G<>>EB:K=
:cd\eZ\ <c`Xi[ \jk [`gcd\ [\ cËZfc\ [ËXiZ_`k\Zkli\ [\ gXi`j DXcXhlX` \e )'')% 8gi
j kif`j Xee\j ~
J_Xe^_X`\cc\i\af`ekcËX^\eZ\Jk\m\e?fccGb`efl\cc\ZfccXYfi\Xlgifa\kMXeb\~J_\eq_\e%;\i\kfli~
GXi`j\edX`)''.#\cc\i\af`ekcËX^\eZ\I\eqfG`Xeffl\cc\jl`kg\e[XekleXe\k[\d`c\gifa\k[\Zflm\ek
gflic\jjf\lijZcXi`jj\j~IfeZ_Xdg~Zk[\cX:_Xg\cc\[\C\:fiYlj`\i%
L>E><MBHGIKHC>ML<HFFNGL
IKHC>ML
GN:@><BG>MBJN>,(I:KBL(GNBM;E:G<A>)2
<c`j\Dfi`e:cd\eZ\yc`Xi[1ÈElX^\Z`e\k`hl\Éile`k[\jgifZZlgXk`fejZfddle\j~cX]ifek`
i\[l
[\j`^e`eefmXek#[\cËXikZfek\dgfiX`e\k[l[m\cfgg\d\ek[liXYc\%CËXjj\dYcX^\[Ële^iXe[efdYi\[\
iflc\Xlo[\jZfkZ_jjljg\e[lj\kXZZldlcj]fid\[\jmfcld\jXYjkiX`kjXlok\okli\j[iflkXek\j#~cX]f`j
]Xd`c`
i\j\k`eZfe^il\j%
El`kYcXeZ_\)''0#gif^iXdd\f]ÔZ`\chlXik`\ijX`ek^\idX`e%<^c`j\fi_kf[fo\[\jjX`ekj8iZ_Xe^\j#GXi`j
GN:@><BG>MBJN>+(ENFBG:BK>
<c`j\Dfi`e:cd\eZ\yc`Xi[1(-''gX`cc\j~Yf`i\#epcfe#^i`ccX^\dkXcc`hl\
:\jgX`cc\jiZlgi\jm`\ee\ek[\jj`e\i[\j]fid\jZfliY\jjlile\jkilZkli\i`^`[\\kfik_f^feXc\%;\j
Xdgflc\j~YXjj\ZfejfdXk`fee\i^\k`hl\jfekgcXZ\j[XejZ\j]fid\j[fekc\jZfliY\jjfekleZc`e[Ëf\`c
XlmXj\[Ë8cmXi8Xckf%:\jgX`cc\jkiXejgXi\ek\jjljg\e[l\j#[\gXikc\lihlXek`k\kc^
i\k]fid\ekX`ej`
[\jelX^\j[fekc\jZ\eki\jjfekc\jcXdg\j%<cc\jZi\ekle\\ek`ke\kk\hlXe[\cc\jjfekZfcc\jc\jle\j
XloXlki\jdX`ji\kiflm\ekc\li`e[g\e[XeZ\Xlgi\d`\iZflg[\m\ekm\el%C\jmfcld\jj\kiflYc\ek#cX
cld`
i\\kc\jZfekflij[\m`\ee\ekgcljÕflj[Xejlea\l[Ë\]]\kj[Ëfgk`hl\\kZ`ek`hl\%%
Cld`eX`i\\ogfj~I\$8ik#Xmi`c)''0#^Xc\i`\NXek\[
GN:@><BG>MBJN>*(=N;:B(;>EO>=>K>
:cd\eZ\ <c`Xi[ 1 :fdd\ek f]]i`i le eflm\Xl ÈcXe[dXibÉ Xl Z`\c [\ ;lYX` ~ cX ]f`j gfk`hl\#
]feZk`fee\c#i\jg\Zkl\lo[\cË\em`ifeed\ek6=X`k[Ële\Zfhl\YcXeZ_\iÕ\Z_`jjXek\hl`Ôcki\c\jiXpfej[l
jfc\`c#c\elX^\[\;lYX`Õfkk\(.'d
ki\jXl[\jjlj[ljfc\kf]]i\Xlo_XY`kXekjle\gifd\eX[\XiZ_`k\Z$
kliXc\Xlogf`ekj[\ml\j\oZ\gk`fee\cjjlic\lim`cc\%Lejpjk
d\[\gl`kjZXe[`\eiX]iX`Z_`kc\Yk`d\ek
eXkli\cc\d\ek1cËX`i\oki`\li\jki\]if`[`~(,d
ki\j[\gif]fe[\ligl`jXjg`i[Xejc\jZfcfee\j`jfk_\id\j
gXilejpjk
d\[\gfdg\jfcX`i\gfliki\ÔeXc\d\ek[`]]lj[XejcXZfhl\%
D`jj`fe1ZfeZflij`ek\ieXk`feXccXeZgXiK_pjj\eBilgg
>QIHLBMBHGK>&:KM(:KM>MK><R<E:@>
CË\ogfj`k`feI<$8IKgij\ek\c\jkiXmXlo[\(+Xik`jk\j\k[\j`^e\ijhl`Zfdgfj\ek[\jÅlmi\j`ek^iXek
c\j`dgXZkj[\jZ_Xe^\d\ekjZfcf^`hl\j\ke\i^k`hl\j[Xejefjdf[\j[\m`\j%
8m\Z `ek\cc`^\eZ\# _ldfli \k gfj`\# `cj flmi\ek [\ eflm\cc\j mf`\j# g\id\kkXek ~ Z_XZle [Ë\em`jX^\i c\j
fYa\kj\kc\lijZpZc\j[\m`\Xlki\d\ek%
<hffbllZkbZm(=:3>ebl^Fhkbg&L\gh`kiZab^<ef^g\^{ebZk]
<ef^g\^{ebZk]
9J;@AL=;LMJ=
NgaZ[bmZmihnke^llZglZ[kbl3lnke^lmkZ\^l]^C^ZgikhnoÀ<hg\hnkl<B;;:I%eZnkZm+f^ikbq%
+))+'
<ehn]bg=n[ZbÀ<hg\hnklMarll^gdknii%;^eo]k^=n[Zb%+))2
Nk[ZgdZe^b]hl\hiÀ%<hg\hnkl:kjnbg^%kZf^gZ`^f^gm]^lmhnkllZm^eebm^%F^qb\h+))2
?kZm^kgbm]^lh^nkl\eZkbll^l]^Khg\aZfiÀ%KI;P;nbe]bg`phkdlahi%+))0&+))1
?ehZmbg`AhkbshgÀLb`^Lh\bZe]^OZgd^%La^gsa^g!<abg^"%:`^g\^Lm^o^gAhee%+))/
=PHGKALAGF
>qihlbmbhg\hee^\mbo^K^&:km'@Ze^kb^PZgm^]&IZkbl'&+))1
Gnbm[eZg\a^+))2%>`ebl^hkamh]hq^]^llZbgml:k\aZg`^l%IZkblO
>qihlbmbhg\hee^\mbo^<ehl^ma^Ehhi&FhgZ\h&+))2
{ebl^Fhkbg
=PHGKALAGF
>qihlbmbhg\hee^\mbo^ÊDbm\a^gË%Mamk^]^eZ@Zbmerkbjn^%IZkbl&&+))-
>qihlbmbhg\hee^\mbo^ÊNgbgo^gmZbk^<hgm^fihkZbgË'@Ze^kb^GZmbhgZe^]nC^n]^IZnf^l&IZkbl&+))-
>qihlbmbhg\hee^\mbo^Ê:kmblm[r:kmblmËFhkb:kmFnl^nf%Fhkbmhp^kKhiihg`bAbeelMhdrh&CZihg&+))/
>qihlbmbhg\hee^\mbo^K^&:km'@Ze^kb^PZgm^]&IZkbl'&+))1
>qihlbmbhg\hee^\mbo^<ehl^ma^Ehhi&FhgZ\h&+))2
Gnbm[eZg\a^+))2%>`ebl^hkamh]hq^]^llZbgml:k\aZg`^l%IZkblO
HM:DA;9LAGF'J9<AG
<akhgbjn^;nss:km(:km=o^ehii^f^gm=nkZ[e^(GhieZgm^
ammi3((ppp'g^h&ieZg^m^'\hf(\Zm^`hkr([nssZkm(
GZhrZAZmZd^rZfZ%^qiehlbhg
DZmlnfbDhfZ`ZmZ%ngghno^ZneZg`Z`^`kZiabjn^
@bgsZ%ngZnmk^FhgmiZkgZll^8
ÊJn^ee^ob^]^\ab^g@hh][r^Dbmmr%A^eehJn^&<aZgË
<HE=BLD
<he]bld\k^eZik^fbk^Öebk^]^k^\r\eZ`^]^l<=h[lhem^l]^liZkmb\neb^kl
>g?kZg\^%Zn\ng^Öebk^]^k^\r\eZ`^]^`bl^f^gm]b__nl]^<=(=O=(;hmb^klgÍ^qblm^'FZe`k]^lÖebk^l
hikZmbhgg^ee^l;^kebg%Ehg]k^l^m]Zglienlb^nkliZrlZg`eh&lZqhgl%e^<=gÍ^lmiZl\hglb]k\hff^
ng]\a^m]hgme^l`bl^f^gmllhgmlkl^mbfihkmZgml'
IhnkiZeeb^k\^mm^Z[l^g\^]^k^\r\eZ`^%=^gbl=:OB=Z\k^^gfZb+))2ng^^gmk^ikbl^]^\hee^\m^^m
]^k^\r\eZ`^]^l<=(=O=(;hmb^kl'Beikhihl^ng^`Zff^]^l^kob\^lZnq^gmk^ikbl^l^mZnq\hee^\mbobml
eh\Ze^lihnke^nki^kf^mmk^]Íhk`Zgbl^kZo^\^ee^l]^lÖebk^lli\bÖjn^li^kf^mmZgm3
& ]^\hee^\m^ke^l\hglhffZ[e^lZo^\]^l\hgm^g^nkl\heh`bjn^lZ]ZimlZnikh]nbm<=
!eZ\hee^\m^^lm`kZmnbm^Zn&]^e]^,))d`]^fZmbk^k\nikiZkihbgm]^\hee^\m^"4
& ]^fh[bebl^ke^llZeZkblhne^laZ[bmZgml%
& ]^e^lZ\a^fbg^kcnljnÍng\^gmk^]^lmh\dZ`^^m]^oZehkblZmbhg
& ]^e^lmkZgl_hkf^k^g`kZgnelikmlmk^k^fiehr^kihnk]bo^klnlZ`^lbg]nlmkb^el'
Lhgikhc^mZm[mb]Zglng^]fZk\a^]^fZgZ`^f^gm^gobkhgg^f^gmZejnb\hglblm^%^gmk^Znmk^l%
bgl\kbk^e^lfZmbk^lk\nik^l]Zglngikhc^m]^]o^ehii^f^gmeh\Zehn\aZjn^mZi^]nikhc^m^m]n
ikh\^ll^lmoZen^^gm^kf^lh\bZnq^m^gobkhgg^f^gmZnq'
IZkZbee^nkl%l^l_hnkgbll^nkllhgm\h&Z`k^l%lZ\hglhffZmbhg^lmkZblhgg^%eZmkZ
Z[bebm]nk^\r\eZ`^
l^kZ^__^\mbo^^m\hgÖ^nghk`Zgblf^bg]i^g]ZgmÁ
<he]bldZZ]Zime^\r\e^]^k^\r\eZ`^lnboZgm3
Collecte dans les
Fin de vie du entreprises, les
produit et écoles et les
recyclage équipements
culturels
Valorisation
Tri, broyage,
des matières
conditionnem
en pièces
ent et
automobiles
extrusion
et électriques
Ikb\^pZm^kahnl^<hhi^kl>\h[beZg
E^=iZkm^f^gm=o^ehii^f^gm=nkZ[e^]^Ikb\^pZm^kahnl^<hhi^klZm\k^^g*22,^m\hfim^Znchnk] anb
ienl]^-)\heeZ[hkZm^nkl^qi^kml]nlnc^m^g?kZg\^^m1))]Zgle^fhg]^]Zgl-.iZrl'L^l]hfZbg^l
] bgm^ko^gmbhgohgm]^e Zn]bm]^lbg_hkfZmbhgl]o^ehii^f^gm]nkZ[e^eZfbl^^gieZ\^]^]fZk\a^
lmkZm`bjn^l^giZllZgmiZkeZmkZ]n\mbhg\hg\km^^mhikZmbhgg^ee^]^\^l^gc^nq]ZgleZ\hg\^imbhg]^l
ikh]nbml^ml^kob\^l^m]Zgle^nk\hff^k\bZeblZmbhg'L^l\aZfil]^\hfim^g\^\hnok^gmmhnle^ll^\m^nkl
] Z\mbobm%r\hfikble^l^\m^nkin[eb\gZmbhgZehnbgm^kgZmbhgZe'
ppp'ip\'_k(]]
ppp'^\h[beZg'\hf
LreoZbgE:F;>KM%-,Zgl%Zllh\bk^lihglZ[e^]n=iZkm^f^gm%=>:] >\hghfb^Bgm^kgZmbhgZe^%>L<I'
LreoZbgZk^chbgme^]iZkm^f^gmehkl]^lZ\kZmbhg^g*22-^m^gZZnchnk] anbeZk^lihglZ[bebm'Be^lm
li\bZebl]ZgleZfbl^^gh^nok^]^lmkZm`b^] ^gmk^ikbl^hkb^gm^l]o^ehii^f^gm]nkZ[e^'Bel bfiebjn^
]^inbljn^ejn^lZgg^llnke^ljn^lmbhglebZgme^]o^ehii^f^gm]nkZ[e^Znlnc^ml]^\hffngb\Zmbhg^m
]^\nemnk^'Be^lmf^f[k^]n\hee^\mb_:]pbl^k%mklhkb^k]^:<B==!:llh\bZmbhg<hffngb\Zmbhg^mBg_hk&
fZmbhgihnke^=o^ehii^f^gm=nkZ[e^"^m^gl^b`g^e >\he^Lnikb^nk^]^<hff^k\^]^IZkbllnke^l
mafZmbjn^l]o^ehii^f^gm]nkZ[e^'
Iabebii^HLL>M%-*Zgl%=bk^\m^nkZnl^bg]n=iZkm^f^gm%<^gmkZe^IZkbl'
Iabebii^Z\hff^g\lZ\Zkkbk^^g*22-Znl^bg] >\h[beZg%ibhggb^k]^l]fZk\a^] ZgZerl^]^\r\e^
]^ob^^m] >\h&<hg\^imbhgZngbo^Znfhg]bZe'BeZ\hg]nbmienlb^nkl\^gmZbg^l]^ikhc^ml] ^\h&\hg\^imbhg
]Zgl]^ghf[k^nl]hfZbg^l'Be^lm^qi^kml]^ljn^lmbhgl]^k^\r\eZ`^^m]^eZfbl^^gieZ\^]^Öebk^l
] ebfbgZmbhg'Iabebii^^lmob\^&iklb]^gm]^e :I>=><!:llh\bZmbhgIkh_^llbhgg^ee^] >qi^kmlihnke^=o^e&
hii^f^gm]^e >\h&<hg\^imbhg"
8JJF:@8K@FE:FDDLE@:8K@FE
:\b]] <K@E=FID8K@FE
GFLIC<;yM<CFGG<D<EK;LI89C<
:<B==^lmng^Zllh\bZmbhg[nmghgen\kZmb_]hgmeZoh\Zmbhg^lm]^\hgmkb[n^kZ\\ek^keZ]b__nlbhg
]^lb]^l^mhnmbelghoZm^nklkihg]ZgmZnq^gc^nq]^]o^ehii^f^gm]nkZ[e^%]^\k^k]^leb^gl^gmk^e^l
bg]bob]nl^me^lkl^Znq%]Í^qikbf^gm^k]^ghno^ee^l_hkf^l]^\heeZ[hkZmbhgl^m]^\hffngb\Zmbhg^m]^
_Z\bebm^keZ\hg\kmblZmbhg]^ikhc^ml]^]o^ehii^f^gm]nkZ[e^'
IZll^nk]Íb]^lÁ
<hglmknbk^e^]o^ehii^f^gm]nkZ[e^^lmngikhc^m\hee^\mb_'Ihnke^f^g^k[b^g%be^lm^ll^gmb^e]^k^×m^k
ZnmZgmjn^ihllb[e^eZ]bo^klbm^meZkb\a^ll^]^lihbgml]^on^':<B==h__k^k`nebk^f^gm]^lmkb[ng^l
]Í^qik^llbhgmhnlmri^l]Íhk`ZgblZmbhgl!Zllh\bZmbhgl%^gmk^ikbl^l%\hee^\mbobml%l^kob\^l]^eÍ>mZm%ngb&
o^klbml%\a^k\a^nklÁ"^m]^li^klhggZebml]Íahkbshglmkl]bo^klZÖg]^_Zohkbl^keZ]b__nlbhg]Íb]^l
hkb`bgZe^l'=^inbl+))+%:<B==ZZbglbZ\\n^beebienl]^.))bgm^ko^gZgmllnk]b__k^gmlmaf^l]n]o^ehi&
i^f^gm]nkZ[e^':<B==\hgmkb[n^]b__nl^ke^]o^ehii^f^gm]nkZ[e^Znikl]n`kZg]in[eb\%ZnmkZo^kl
iZk^q^fie^]n;^`k^^gÖefl_^lmboZe%\hg\hnkl]^kZeblZmbhg]^ih\d^mlÖefl]^fhbgl]^,fbgnm^l
lnke^]o^ehii^f^gm]nkZ[e^'
:LLH<B:MBHG
<:K:O:GL>K:BE
BfieZgm^]Zgle^*,f^%>okr^mObkr&<ambeehg%eÍZllh\bZmbhg<ZkZoZgl^kZbe=^o^ehii^f^gmZihnk
h[c^\mb_eÍbgl^kmbhglh\bZe^^mikh_^llbhgg^ee^^meZenmm^\hgmk^eÍ^q\enlbhg'
Ihnk\^eZ%^ee^]o^ehii^]^lZ\mbhgl]^_hkfZmbhg^g]bk^\mbhg]^lin[eb\l]^[Zlgbo^Zn]^jnZebÖ\Zmbhg
^m`k^]^ljnbi^f^gml_ZohkblZgme^]o^ehii^f^gm]neb^glh\bZe^meÍbgl^kmbhg'
E^loZe^nkl]^eÍZllh\bZmbhglhgme^k^li^\m]^li^klhgg^l%eÍZ\\leÍZnmhghfb^%^me^k^g_hk\^f^gm]^eZ
\bmhr^gg^m'
EÍZllh\bZmbhgZ]o^ehiimkhblZq^l]Íbgm^ko^gmbhg3
&EZ_hkfZmbhgikh_^llbhgg^ee^!Zm^eb^kl]^i]Z`h`b^i^klhggZebl^%_hkfZmbhglebg`nblmbjn^lihnkc^ng^l
^mZ]nem^l%_hkfZmbhgljnZebÖZgm^l"4
&EÍZgbfZmbhg]^]^nqen]hmajn^llbmn^l]Zgle^*,^Zkkhg]bll^f^gm4
&=^nq\aZgmb^kl]Íbgl^kmbhg3\kZmbhgm^qmbe^^ml^kob\^leZi^klhgg^'
<Í^lm]Zglng]^\^l\aZgmb^kl]Íbgl^kmbhgjn^l^_Z[kbjn^kZeZ\nbkZll^]^<=3
E^l_^ff^l]^eÍZm^eb^k]^\kZmbhgm^qmbe^!lbmn]ZgleZ\bm]^eZ`kZg]^;hkg^Obkr<ambeehg"ohgm
mbll^ke^l<=^gmk^^nq%iZkieZjn^]^*/f!l^ehgeZmZbee^]^lZm^eb^kl"%\^lieZjn^ll^khgm^glnbm^Zl&
l^f[e^l]bk^\m^f^gmlnke^lbm^'
mbllZ`^]^l<=Zo^\]nÖe