P.T.

RAGA PERKASA EKAGUNA

TENDER EVALUATION TECHNICAL
GENERAL
All tenderers should be requested to confirm compliance with the project specification in its entirety. At the moment we cannot assume compliance by omission.
BIDDER

MAN Industries

JINDAL

WELSPUN

THYSSEN KRUPP
Mannex Asia

CORUS

SPL/MKT/VC/PP/1004/AHRPE-3-REV.5

WGSRL/Q.62200705

AP-0380

OX050020

19th April 2005

14th April 2005

4th May 2005

11th February 2005

6th May 2005

1. Material
specification

Compliant with API 5L for

supply of X65 LSAW
linepipe.
No evidence of
compliance with the
project specifications:
UJPKH-KV-O000-PL-SP7201-D3
Or
UJPKH-AH-O000-GESP-9535-D1

Compliant with API 5L for

supply of X65 LSAW
linepipe.
No evidence of
compliance with the
project specifications:
UJPKH-KV-O000-PL-SP7201-D3
Or
UJPKH-AH-O000-GESP-9535-D1

Compliant with API 5L for

supply of X65 LSAW
linepipe.
No evidence of
compliance with the
project specifications:
UJPKH-KV-O000-PL-SP7201-D3
Or
UJPKH-AH-O000-GESP-9535-D1

Compliant with API 5L for

supply of X65 LSAW
linepipe.
No evidence of
compliance with the
project specifications:
UJPKH-KV-O000-PL-SP7201-D3
Or
UJPKH-AH-O000-GESP-9535-D1

Compliant with API 5L for

supply of X65 LSAW
linepipe.
Largely compliant with
the project specifications:
UJPKH-KV-O000-PL-SP7201-D3
Or
UJPKH-AH-O000-GESP-9535-D1 but with
deviations as discussed
below.

2. Sour service

Compliant in that the

linepipe shall be in
accordance with NACE
MR-01-75 for sour
service.

Not compliant at the

moment but testing
proposed to confirm
acceptance.

Compliant in that the

linepipe shall be in
accordance with NACE
MR-01-75 for sour
service.

Compliant in that the

linepipe shall be in
accordance with NACE
MR-01-75 for sour
service.

Compliant in that the

linepipe shall be in
accordance with NACE
MR-01-75 for sour
service, however,
linepipe suitable for
bends has not been
offered due to TMCP
route of manufacturing
linepipe. Tenderer should
be requested to provide
quotation for linepipe
suitable for induction
bending.

Quotation reference
Date of quotation
Technical requirement

BIDDER

MAN Industries

3. Raw material
properties

Not compliant.
There has been no
information provided.

Proposed chemistry and

manufacturing route
should be capable of
satisfactorily achieving
the requirements.

Not compliant.
There has been no
information provided.

Not compliant.
There has been no
information provided.

Tenderer has proposed

deviation in the Ca
treatment to allow
superior product to be
manufactured. On
technical grounds this is
considered acceptable.

4. Mill certificate

Not compliant.
None provided.

Not compliant.
None provided.

Not compliant.
None provided.

Not compliant.
None provided.

Not compliant.
None provided.

5. Testing
MPQ
SSCC
HIC

Not compliant.
There has been no
information provided.

Compliant.

Compliant.

Not compliant.
There has been no
information provided.

Compliant.

5. Inspection by:
DNV / SGS / Lloyds /
BV

To purchasers account.

To purchasers account.

To purchasers account.

To purchasers account.

To purchasers account.

Proposal requires
clarification for the
supply via coil, which
implies a different
manufacturing route.

Clarification to tenderers
comments.
5.2.3(b). Maximum
hardness is 248Hv10 as
per NACE MR-01-75.
6.3 Tenderers proposal
to conduct UT of body
and MPI of ends is
considered acceptable.
The requirements of
appendices A and B
should be clarified in
view of recent
discussions and the rewriting of the
specification.

6. Comments

JINDAL

WELSPUN

THYSSEN KRUPP
Mannex Asia

CORUS

In general the tender is

well presented and
covers the specification
requirements. The
tenderer has proposed
several deviations to the
specification that require
assessment.
In principal the reviewer
finds none of the
proposed deviations
detrimental to the quality
of the pipe.