SCRIPTORUM CLASSICORUM

BIBLIOTHECA OXONIENSIS

OXONII
E TYPOGRAPHEO CLARENDONIANO
LONDINI ET NOVI EBORACI
APUD HENRICUM FROVVDE
PLATONIS OPERA

RECOGNOVIT
BREVIQVE ADNOTATIONE CRITICA INSTRVXIT

lOANNES BURNET
IN VNIVERSITATE ANDREANA LITTERARVM GRAECARVM PROFESSOR
COLLBGII MERTONENSIS OLIM SOCIVS

TOMVS II

TETRALOGIAS III-IV CONTINENS

OXONII
ONII
E TYPOGRAPHEO CLARENDONIANO
 OXONII
Excudebat Horatius Hart
Typographus academicus

Pfl
 -5.

PRAEFATIO
In tetralogiis III-IV recognoscendis eandem fere
rationem quam in prioribus secutus sum ; cuni autem
nec Parmenidem nec Philebum ediderit M. Schanz>
in illo viam monstravit vir doctus W. W. Waddell,
qui Clarkianum (B) et Marcianum (T) in suam editio-
nem cum pulvisculo excussit, in hoc ipse Marcianas
lectiones primus in lucem protuh*.
Quod ad recensionem attinet, fateormihi codicum
lectiones perpendenti in dies magis probari quae in
prioris voluminis praefatione breviter exposui, unam
eandemque recensionem omnes quotquot extant Hbros
exhibere, alterius recensionis vestigia tantum apud
antiquos scriptores et in codice Vindobonensi (W)
inveniri. omnes libros ad unum eundemque archety-
pum referendos esse, eumque post sextum saeculum
exaratum, certissimum est et ab Alphonso Schaeffer,
qui acerrime Schanzianas rationes impugnavit, con-
ceditur ^, cui quidem ego ita adsentior ut negem ulla
vestigia recensionis in Clarkiano (B) extare, quippe
cuius errores calHgraphi sint dihgentissime litterulas
exscribentis,sermonem et doctrinam parum callentis.
neque hoc mihi probavit Schaeffer, in libros alterius
famiUae lectiones ex antiqua recensione inrepsisse,
quod in Vindobonensi (W) et adfinibus eius ipse factum
esse contendo. scio equidem vel in deterrimis Hbris
optimae notae lectiones passim inveniri, sed plerasque
* Quaestiones Platonicae (Argentorati m.dccc.xcvui).
 PRAEFATIO
a viris doctis post renatas litteras inter legendum
adscriptas. qui Venetum 189 (2) et Coislinianum 155
(r), ut his utar, corrigebant, permultas Heindorfi
aliorum emendationes praecepere, quibus ut suum
cuique tribui debet, ita coniectura non memoria niti
eius modi lectiones fatendum est.

Quod mihi obiecit censor benevolentissimus H. Diels,

me testimonia antiquiorum scriptorum parum respe-
xisse, id cuius modi sit alio loco exponam, in hoc
volumine viro humanissimo, ut par erat, satis facere
studui. quamquam non me fugit quam lubrica res
sit eius modi testimonia adhibere. Hcet enim scriptores
saepissime ex antiqua recensione veram lectionem
servaverint, at certum est codices Procli Olympiodori
aliorum ex libris Platonicis interpolatos esse. non
satis est igitur eorum testimonia ex optimis editionibus
descripsisse ex ipsorum verbis, si qua fieri possit,
:

lectio quam quisque habuerit eruenda erit. nunc

autem si hic illic antiquioris recensionis sinceram
memoriam reciperare contigerit, contenti esse debe-
bimus.
lOANNES BURNET.
Scribebam Andreapoli
e collegio S. Salvatoris ei D. Leonardi
mense Martio m.dcccc.i.

In Convivio et Phaedro lectiones Oxyrhynchitas

commemoravi, et in Convivio codicis Vindobonensis
(W) collationem a viro doctissimo Hermanno Schoene
confectam adhibui.
lOANNES BURNET.
Andreapolt
mense Aprili m.cm.x.
 6

4 J>

DIALOGORVM ORDO
TOMVS I

TETRALOGIA I ED. STEPH.

EVTHYPHRO ! PP- 2-1

Apologia Socratis . . . . I. pp. 17-42

Crito I. pp. 43-54
Phaedo !
PP' 57-118

Tetralogia II
Cratylvs I-
PP- 383-440
Theaetetvs ! PP- 142-210
SOPHISTA ! PP^ 216-268
Politicvs II. pp. 257-311

TOMVS II

Tetralogia III
Parmenides III. pp. 126-166
Philebvs II. pp. 11-67
Symposivm III. pp. 172-223
Phaedrvs III. pp. 227-279

Tetralogia IV
Alcibiades I II. pp. 103-135
Alcibiades II II. pp. 138-151
Hipparchvs II. pp. 225-232
Amatores ! PP- 132-139
 DIALOGORVM ORDO

TOMVS III

Tetralogia V
Theages I. pp. I2I-I31
Charmides II. pp. 153-176
Laches II. pp. 178-201
Lysis II. pp. 203-223

Tetralogia VI
evthydemvs I. pp. 271-307
Protagoras . L pp. 309-362
GORGIAS I. pp. 447-527
Meno . II. pp. 70-100

Tetralogia VII
HlPPIAS maior III. pp. 281-304
HlPPIAS MINOR I. pp. 363-376
lo . I. pp. 530-542
Menexenvs . II. pp. 234-249

TOMVS IV
Tetralogia VIII
Clitopho III. pp. 406-410
Respvblica . II. pp. 327-621
Timaevs III. pp. 17-105
Critias . III. pp. I06-I2I
 DIALOGORVM ORDO
^
TOMVS V
Tetralogia IX
MlNOS . II. pp. 313-321
Leges . II, pp. 624-969
Epinomis II. pp. 973-992
Epistvlae . III. pp. 309-363

Definitiones III. pp. 4II-4I6

NOeEYOMENOI
De Ivsto III. pp. 372-375
De Virtvte III. pp. 376-379
Demodocvs III. pp. 380-386
SlSYPHVS III. pp. 387-391
Eryxias III. pp. 392-406
AXIOCHVS III. pp. 364-372
A

SIGLA
B= cod. Bodleianus, MS. E. D. Clarke 39 = Bekkeri 9t
T = cod. Venetus Append. Class. 4, cod. = Bekkeri
i t

W cod. Vindobonensis 54, suppl. phil. Gr. 7 Stallbaumii

= =
Vind. I

C = cod. Crusianus sive Tubingensis = Stallbaumii %

D = cod. Venetus 185 = Bekkeri n
G = cod. Venetus Append. Class. 4, cod. 54 = Bekkeri A

V = cod. Vindobonensis 109 = Bekkeri *

Oxy. = Papyrus Oxyrhynchita (Grenfell et Hunt
V, pp. 243 sqq.)

Recentiores manus librorum B T W litteris b t w significantur

 ,/

nAPMENIAH2
KE<I>AA02

'ETretSr) 'AdrjvaCi oiKoOiv e/c KAa^o/xerwv a(^t.K6y.i6a, a

Kar ayopav kviTV\o]X(V 'ASeijuarro) re Ka\ TkavKOiVi' Kai
fiov ka^6nvos Trji \i.p6s 6 ' Ab(CiJ.avTos, Xatp', l(/)rj,
Kci^aAe, *cat fi tov biri t&v rTjSe c5j; rjixeXs bvvaTOL, <^p6.(e.
'AAA.a /xey bri, etTroy eyw, Trtipcijut ye ^tt' avro rouro, 5
8erj(ro'/xei'o? vptMV.

Ae'yots Ai^, e<^Tj, rrji' b4ricn.v.

Kal ^yo) etiToy Toi abK<f)(a vp.5iv rw ofiofxrjTpiia t( ^v b

ovoyxi; ov yap yAixvr\p.ai.. irat? 8e 'jtou Tjy, oTi to TrpoTcpov
fTTbrifjLr](ra bfvpo ck K\aCop.(V(av' ttoAvs be rjbr] \p6vos k^
iKiivov. roi fxkv yap Trarpt, boKd, riupiAajUTrrjy Svofxa.
Ylavv ye, l<|)rj. 5
Avrw bi ye;
^AvTi(f)biv. aWa tl /xaAtora TTVvddvr];

OtSe, etiroi' eyw, TroAtrat r' e/iot eJo-i, /xoAa ^iAdco^oi,

dKrjKo'ao-( re ort ouros 6 'Avri^wj; nu^oSwpw rirt ZT/rwroy
eraipu) TroAAa eyrer^x^ff. ''Ci^ roi/s Ao'yous, ovs irore Su)- C
Kptirr/? Kai Zr/i^coy Kal Ilap/xeytSr/j SieA^x^^*'"**'^ ToAAdKts
oKOVo-as Tov nv6ob(apov diro/iinj/xoyevet.

nAPMENEIAH2 constanter B bs r<^ T Proclus: om. B

b6 avT^Styf. a.vri<pwv' B: airrf Sfye avri<put'' T Adimanto tribuens
b 8 t' ffxol ci. Stephanus t : noi T : /40 B
PLATO, VOL. II. 1
126 c nAATQNOS
^A\r]dfj, (l>r], \4ycLs.

5 TovTO)V Toivvv, ettTov, heofiida 8ia/cou<rat.

'AAA.' ov xaXeTTov, 4<f>r]' fxcLpdiKLOv yap cov avrovs ev

IxdXa 8ie/xeXe7T;crfj;, eTrei vvv ye Kara rbv TTaintov re Kal
6p.<avvfxov Ttpos iTnriKTj to. iroKKa bLaTpCjSet.. dAA.' ei Set,

XoiiJi.v TTap' avTov apTL yap vd4vb( oiKaSe otxcrai, oiKei Se

lo iyyvs V MeAiT?;.
127 Tairra eiiroyres ilSahCCofxev, Kal KaTe\6.^oyi.(v tov 'Av-
TL(j)6)VTa oXkol, x.<^Xlv6v TLva x^^^^fi eK8t8oyra o-Keu(icraf

eTretS?) 8e iKeCvov aTTr]XKayr) ot re d8eA0oi iXeyov awrw

Si; ereKa TTapelixfv, aveyvdtpLo-iv re /xe eK r^s TTpoTepas
6 embrjfxCas KaC /xe ijo-Trd^ero, Kai beofxivtav rjix&v bLekdelv tovs
koyovs, To ixV TTp&Tov &KVL
7T(LTa fxivTOL Sttjyetro. e^r;

8e
TToAv
brj
yhp (f)r) cpyov LVaL
6 ^AvTL<f)&v XeycLV tov
I
Ilv66bo)pov OTL cLipCKOLVTo TT0T ds HavadrjvaLa tcl [xeydka
b Zriv(av re Kai UapixevCbrjs. tov fxkv ovv Ylapfi.vCbriv ev
fxd\a ifbrj TTp(rj3vTr]V elvaL, (r<f)6bpa 7To\l6v, Ka\6v 8e
Kayadbv Tr]v d\ffLv, Trept ^Tr] /xdAio-ra -Trei^re Kai k^rfKOVTa'

Zrfvot)va be iyyvs t6v TeTTapaKovTa T^Te etvaL, evfx-qKr]

5 8c Kai yapCevTa ibelv, kcu \eye<r6aL avTov TratStKa tov

YlapfxevCbov yeyovevaL. KaTokveLv be avTovs e<f)rf Trapa roi

C Y[v6ob<3i)poi eKTos TeCxovs ev KepafieLK^' ol brf Kal d<\)LKe<r6aL

Tov re ScoKpdrr; Kat dAAous rtvds fxer avTOV ttoWotI/s,

eiTLdvfxovvTas dKoSo-at tS)V tov Zr]vo)vos ypafXfxdTU)v TOTe

yap avTCL ttp&tov vtt eKeCvo)V Kop.L<r6rfvaL ScoKpdr?; be elvaL

5 T^Te cr<f)6bpa veov. dvayLyv<aaKeLv ovv avTois tov ZrfVO)va

avTov, Tov be TlapfxevCbrfv tvx^^lv e^o) ovTa' Kal eivat TTdvv

^paxy Irt AotTrdy t&v \6yo)v dvayLyvo)<rKOfxevo)v, rfvCKa

d avrds re eTreto-eA^cti' e<f)r] 6 IIv66bo)pos 4io)6ev Kai rdy

IIapfi.evCbr]v fxer airrov Koi ^ ApL<TTOTe\r] tov tS)V TpLdKOVTa

c5 iioKovffai B Proclus : oKovaai T c8 8?] ioKti Heindorf

a4 B
irapetjuev : T
jrope^^fie' : iraprintv G B om.TProclus
a^ ;u :

a8i<l>lK0ivr6 B : aptKovr^ T b 2 jJSij T 5)j B : b 4 rwv

G 4tuv B T
: TerrapdKOVTa T Tf<r(rap<iKovTa B
:
 nAPMENIAHS ia7d

yv6fXvov, Koi (T[xiKp cLTTa tTL k^naKovcraL TUiV ypafxixa.-

T(t)V ov ixrjv avTos ye, ak\a koI irpoTepov aKrjKoivaL tov

Zi^vctivos. 5

Tov ovv ScoKpaTTj aKovcravTa TrdXiy t KeAeCtrai ttiv

7tp(aTr\v vTTodicnv tov itpdiTOV koyov avayv&vaL, Kal ava-

yvoo(r6L(rr}s, liCis, (})dvaL, S) Zrivodv, tovto Aeyeiy; ci iroWa
eoTi To. ovTa, w? apa bd avTo, o[xol(x re elvaL Kal avofxoLa,
TovTo be brf abvvaTov ovt yap tcl dvojxoLa ofxoLa ovtc tcl

ofxoLa dv6p.0La olov re flvaL; ov\ ovrcu k4yLs;

OvTd), (f)dvaL Tov Zr]V(t)va. 5
OvKOvv L dbvvaTov Td re dvdfxoLa ofxoLa elvaL Kal tcl

ofxoLa dvdfxoia, dbvvaTov bi] Kal ttoWcl cTvaL; ei ydp ttoWcl

etr], 7rd(r}(oi dv tcl dbvvaTa. dpa tovt6 ((ttlv o ^ovkovTai
(Tov ol k6yoL, ovK dkXo TL 1] bLafxdx^o-OaL Trapd irdvTa Ta
ky6fxva 0)? ov TTokkd eoTi; Kal tovtov avTov oUl aoL lo
TKfxrfpLov LvaL Ka(TTOv T&v k6yu)V, coore KOLL
^yfj
Toa-avTa
TKfxrfpLa TTap\(rdaL, 6(rov(nTp k6yovs y4ypa(f)as, o)? ovk
eoTi TToAXd; ovro) kiyeis, rj eyo) ovk opd&s KaTafxavddvo) ; 128
OvK, dAAd, (f)dvaL tov Zrjv(t)va, Kok&s (rvvfJKas okov t6
ypdfxfxa 6 ^ovkcTaL.
Mavddvoo, elTTCLV tov ^Kpdri], o) YlapfKVLbi], otl Zrjvoiv
6b ov fxdvov Trj dkkr] aov 0iAia ^ovkTaL w/cetcSo-^ai, dAAd 5

Kal rw (TvyypdfLfxaTL. tovtov ydp yypa(f) TpdiTov TLvd

0TTp (Tv, fXTaj3dXko)v 8c ^/btas Treipdrai e^aTrardy ws Tp6v
TL kyu)v. (Tv fLV ydp V Tols TTOLrjfxacTLV kv (f)rjs eiyat to
TTav, Ka\ TOVT(t)v TKfxrfpLa TTapcxv Kak&s re Kat ci!' 6b 8c b
aS ov TToAAd (f)rfa-Lv eirai, TKfxrfpLa 8e kol ovtos -ndfXTTokka
Kal TTaf/.p.ydr] 7rape'xerat. to ovy tov fikv ^v (f>dvaL, tov
8e p,r] TTokkd, Kal ovt(os kKaT^pov kdycLV &(tt fxrfbev tS)v

e 9 aov oi B et in ras. T orot ol G a 5 a-ov] fort. <roi Hein-

:

dorf oiKdwffOai pr. B pr. T (corr. B't) olKftovadcu al. Proclus :

a 7 Svep Proclus '6yirep B S*ir(p T : fKrafiiWwv B /x(Tafia\ii)V

: :

T Proclus a8 li/ ^fjr T tv e<p-ns B Proclus b i t B 7 T

: :

b 2 Ka\ T : om. B
1*
128 b nAAT12N02
5 avToiV dpr\Kivat hoK^iv ayjihov tl Xeyovras TavTu, VTrkfj

rjixas Tovs aWovs (f)a(vTat vfxiv to. elprifxiva clprjaOat.

NaC, (f)dva(. tov Zr]vo)va, S Sw/cpare?. <rv 8' ovv Trjv

dXrjdetav tov ypdp.\xaTos ov TravTaxov f]cr6r](rai. KatTOi

C &(nTp ye ai AaKaivat crKvXaKes (v ixcTadeXs T Kal l)(vvcts
Tci XexOevTa' dkXa irpGiTov fx^v cre tovto \av6dvt, oti ov
navTdiiacrtv ovTOi (rejxvvveTat t6 ypdp.p,a, &aT direp (Tv

kiyets btavor}6v ypa(f>ijvat, tovs dvdpoltTTOvs 8e (iTtKpVTTTO-

5 picvov &s Tt ixiya htairpaTToix^vov' akka (tv ixev ftTrey t&v

(Tvix^c^riKOTaiv Tt, ((TTt bi t6 ye dkrf^es ^&q^etd rts TavTa
[Tct ypdpLixaTa] T(a Yiapixevtbov koyco Trpos tovs iiTtxctpovvTas
d avTov KOi}p.(^btv b)s ei V eo-ri, iTokkd Kai yeAoia (rvixj3aivt

TTa(r\tv T(o Aoyo) Kal kvavTta avTS>. dvTiAeyei bi} ovv

TovTo t6 ypdixixa Trpos tovs Ta iTokka kiyovTas, Ka\ dvT-
aiTobtboicTt TavTa Koi n^A.eico, tovto ^ovk6p.Vov br)kovv, ws
5 en yeAotorepa iTdcryot dv avT&v rj vTT66<rts, et TTokkd
k(rTtv, ri rj tov ly eti^ai, ei Tts tKavSts TT^tot. btd TotavTriv
bri (fitkovtKiav vtto viov ovtos iixov ypd(f>ri, Kai Tts avTo
eKAe\//-e ypa(f)V, mctt^ ovb j3ovkva-aa-6at ^yVTO etr'

e ^otcrTOV avTo eis t6 (fi&s eire ixrj. TavTrj ovv cr kav6dvt,

Si Sco/cpares, ori ovx. ^'^'"^ ^^<"^ cfitkovtKias otei avro yeypd-
<p6at, dAA' vtt6 TTp(r^vTpov (f>tkoTtpiias' iiTci, 5ttp y
tTTOV, ov KaK&s d7njKa(ras.
5 'AAA' dTToSexo/xat, cfidvat t6v "SKaKpdTri, Kal rjyovpLat ws
Ae'yets Xtv. Tob^ bi p.ot eiTre'* ov vofxiC^ts tvat avT6 Ka6'
129 avT6 et8os Tt dixot^rriTOS, Kal rw TotovTio av dkko rt ivav-

Tiov, h icrTtv dvdixotov TovTotv 8e bvotv Svtoiv /cai ifxk Ka\

(T^ Kal raAAa h br} TroAAa KakovfXV fXTakafi.^dvtv ; koX
TO. fxiv Trfs dfiot^TrfTos fiTakap.(3dvovTa ofxota yiyvcr6at

5 TavTri re Koi KaTa TocrovTov da-ov dv fXTakap.^dvri, tu 8e

b 7 S' odv BT: yovp Heindorf e 7 tA ypa,ij,/xara om. Proclus

d 4 TaiiTct Schleiermacher TovTa B om. T : d 5 j B T Proclus: :

7]el vulg. d 7 vfov ovTos B^ T Vfvovros pr. B e i odv :

T Proclus y' olv B : a i aS B Proclus om. T :

 :
:

nAPiMENIAHii laga

Trjs avoixoioTYiTos avofxoLa, to, bi afX(\)OTip(x)V afX(j)OTpa; ct

dc Kal rrdvTa (vavTioDV ovtodv apL(f)OTp(ov p,Ta\afx(3dv(i,

Kal eoTt Tw fxeTexeiv dp,(f)oiv ojuotci re Kal dvofxoia avTO.

avT0i9, tC davpiacrTov; fLjAei' yd avTO, to. ojxoid rts aTT- b 5 ^aIA

i^awiv avofxoia yt,yvofX(va i} ra avojxoi,a ofxoia, re/)as av
otftai ?]i;" et 8e to. tovtodv fxiTi)(ovTa dfX(j)OTp(ii)V dfX(f)6Tepa

(XTroc^atVet ireTiovdoTa, ovbev ffxoiyc, S) Zi]vo)V, aTOTTOv boKfl,

ovb4 y 1 tv ^TTavTa aTro^atVci rts ro> fXfT^x^LV tov hos 5

Kat ravra raura TroAAa rw ttAt/^ovs av juterexetr. _gAX et ^.'ii.*v4t

'^'^**^
o ^crrty ev, avTo tovto ttoAAo aTToSet^ft xat av ra TroAAa 87/ '^'^"

roCro 6avfxd<rop,ai. koI Trept roiy aAAcor aiTdvT())V C <i^ \^51<.

cr, ?/8rj

wo-avro)?' et fiei' avra ra yerrj re ai etS)? ej' awors aTTO-^

(f)aivoL TdvavTia TavTa irddif Tida-xpvTa, d^Lov davfxaCeiv

(l 8'
(fx( ev TLS aTToSet^et ovra Kal iroAAd, ri davfxaarov,
kfy(i)v, orav fxfv ^ovXrjTaL TroAAa d7T0(f)fjvaL, u)S ^rcpa fxkv 5

Ta 6771 8e^td fxov ka-TLV, cre/oa 8e rd ctt' dpta-Tpd, kol eTepa

fxkv To. TTp6a-6(v, erepa 8e tol oTTLo-dfv, Kai dvo) Kal KaTO)

aaavToos 7rA7;^oi>9 ydp oXfxaL fXiT^yo) orai' 8e eV, epet o)?

eirrd iffxGtv ovto)V eis eyw et/xt dvOpo^iTos fXiTi\o)V kol tov d
kvos' &(rTi dkrfdif d7ro0aivet dfX(f)6Tpa. idv ovv rts roiaOra
eTrtxetpfj TroAAd xat ey tovtov diro^fiaLveLV, kCOovs Kal ^Xa
KOL Ta TOLavTa, tI (f)rfa-ofXV avTov TroAAd Kai kv drrobeLKVvvaL,
ov To h> TToAAd ov8e 'rd 7roAAd ev, ovbe tl davfxaa-Tov 5
K4yLV, dAA' &TT(p dv TTavTes opiokoyoLfXfV edr 8e' rts &v ^, ,^
i>vvbrf eyo) (keyov TTp&Tov fxkv 8tat/>7)rat x.^^P'?
avrd Kad ,

avrd rd et87j, olov dju,otoV7]rd re Kat dro/iotoVrjra Kat ttA^^oj eV

Kat rd ev Kal arda-Lv Ka\ Ktvrfo-LV kol TrdvTa to. rotaCra, e
eira v kavTols ravTa bvvdfXva (rvyKpdvvv(r6aL Kal 8ta-
KpLV(T6ai d7T0(f)aLvri, dyaifxyfv dv yo)y , (f)if, 6avfxa(rrS)S, o)

b I iiirtifKuvtu T : i.ve<pa.ivtTo B b4 hoKu T SoKt tlvai B

:

Proclus C 4 Kol wo\ka ovra pr. T C 5 ivo<l>Tivai Simplicius

B
airo(paivfiv T Proclus d
i fifiuv'] fjikv Simplicius iyd) om.
Simplicius da air o<paiv 1 1 "B airoipaivoiT ds TaiirJ' scripsi
:

TauTb Simplicius (toutcD D TouTi B T ) d^ TlSimpliciug.: om.

: BT
d6 c5j/ BT: t Simplicius e 1 t5 om. Simplicius
 129 6 nAATi2N02
Zjjvoiv. Tavra 8e avbpdo)s fxkv Ttavv i^yovy.ai, TreTrpayixa- n
^ TV(r6ai' 7To\v p.(.vTav w8e fwXKov, ws Kiyu>, ayaa-6(Cr]v ei ^
i^'*
^ Tts Xoi Ti]V avTTjV TavTtjv aTTopCav (V avTols Tols etbea-L

130 7ravro8a7rci)S itkeKop.ivrjv, wo-Trep kv rois 6p()fXVot,s 8i7jA0ere,

ovTOiS Kal kv Tols koyLo-fXia kaix^avofxivoLs eTriSei^ai.

AiyovTos brj, c(j>rj 6 Hv66b(iipos, tov ^(aKpdTovs raCra
atros' ixev ^ar) oieo-^ai e(^' e/cacrrou ax6(r6ai tov re Tlap-
5 p.ivCbr]V Kol Tov Xrivuiva, tovs 8e Tiavv re avrw TTpoa-iyjtLV

Tov vovv KoX 6aixa eis aAA.^Aovs ^keiiovTas jxeLbLav ws

ayafxivovs tov ^(aKpaTr). oirep ovv kol Trava-a[XVOV airrov
etirety tov TlappLevCbriv' '12 SwKpares, (f)dvaL, ws a^tos et

b aya(r6aL t^s opfxrjs Trjs eTrt rovs Aoyous. xat fxoL etTre',

avros 0"u ovrco bLrjprja-aL ws Aeyeis, x<^P'^ M^^ f'^^ aura

aTTa, x^i^pts Sf T^ T0VT(i>v av }XiTe\ovTa; KaC tC ctol boKii
etvaL avTr) djxoLOTrfs x^P^^f V^ rjfxels 6p.oL6Tr]Tos exofxev, Kal

5 ei; br) Kal Trokka Kal TrdvTa ocra vvvbrj Zrfvoivos {fKoves;
"'Ejuotye, (f)dvaL tov "ZooKpdTr].

'H Kttt TCL TOLavTa, eiTrety tov YlapfxevCbrfv, olov bLKaCov

TL elbos avTo Ka6^ avTo Koi Kakov Ka\ dya6ov ^ai Trarrcov
av t5)v tolovtcov;
10 Nai, (f)dvaL.

C Tt 8', dv6p(airov elbos xa^pis rjfxciv Kal tS)V oXol 17/u.ets ecrfxev

TTdvTO)V, avTd TL elbos dv6p(aTT0V r) Trvpos r] Kal vbaTOs;

'Ei dTTOpCcL, <f)dvaL, jroAAaKts 8r/, o) TiapfxevCbrj, Trept avT(av

yeyova, Trorepa xpi] (f)dvaL &(ntep irepl eKeCvo^v rj akkcos.

5 'H Kat Trept T&vbe, S ^(OKpaTes, b, ko.I yekola bd^eLev av
eTvaL, oXov 6pl^ Kal Trrfkbs Kal pviros r] dkko tl aTLfxdTaTOv

re Kat ^avk^TaTov, diropeLS eireXPV 4^dvaL Kal tovtoov

d eKaa-Tov elbos etrat x^^P'^ ^^ dkko av ij (Lv (tl^ ijfxels

fxeTaxeLpL(6fxe6a, eire Kat fxrf;

e6 Ta{irii)v T : om. B a4 &' addidi a 5 t B : ye T

b4 oSt)? ^ dfioiorris B : avToof/.oi6Tr}s T b 7 TOiavTa B : roidSe T
Proclus Tbr T t6v Te B : c 2 ti B : tJ> T c6 ti T 8t: B
d I ad tj &y Ti scripsi (aS twu &v Heindorf ) : twTuv. ^ S' B T Proclus
 IlAPiMENIAHS i3od

Ovdaixm, (pdvai tov Sco/cpdrr;, ctAAa ravra fXv ye &iTfp

6p<aixV, Tavra koI elvaL' ci8os 8e n avrwy olrjOijvat nvai

fxr] \iav 17 aTOTrov. T/Srj fiivToi itot4 ijl koI HOpa^i fxrj tl 5

ri TTcpi TTavTitiv TavTov TTiTa OTOV TavTYj cttG), (f)ivy<av

otxotxai, SeiVa? /btr; Trore eis riya j3v66v <f)\vap(as e/uTrco-wv

bi.a(f)Oapu)' (Kl(r 8' ovj; a^iK6p.ivo<s, ds h. vvvhr\ iXiyofxev

(ibr] ex^i-v, TTcpl fKiiva TTpay[xaTv6iiVos Siarpi^w.

Ne'os yap ei ert, ^ayai tov TlappLfvCbrjv, SwKpare?, e
Kai ov^jra) o-ou dyreiXrjTrrai <^tXo(ro^ia o)? eri avTiXTi\j/(Tat.

Kar (p.r]v bo^av, otc ovbkv airriav dri/itdoreis' vvv 8e ert

TTpbs dvdp^oTTODV dTToj3X(TTLS bo^as bto. Trjv rjKiKiav. ro'8e

8' (wv fxoi, eiTre'. 8oKet o-oi, ws (^rfy, eZrat ei8r; drra, wr rd8e 5

rd dAAa fxfTakajxfidvovTa rds TT(ovvfxias avToiv Wxfi.v, olov

ofxoLOTrjTos .fxkv fXTaka^6vTa ofxoLa, fxiyidovs 8e /xeyaAa, 131

xdAAovs 8e kol bLKaLO(rvvr}s bUaid re Kat KaAd yLyv(T9aL;
Yldirv ye, (})dvaL tov ScoKpdrr/.
OvKour r/rot oAou tov et8ovs 17 fx4povs iKaoroy t6 /xera-
XafL^dvov /xeroAa/x/Sdvei; ^ dAArj ris dy ixcTdXrfxj/LS x^op'^ 5
rovrcoy yivoLTo;
Kai TTws di;; etTrer.

no'repoi; ovr 8oKet <rot oAoy t6 eiSos ey kKd(rT<f etrai

raiy TroAAcSy |y ov, r/ ttms;

Tt ydp KcoAvet, (})dvaL t6v ScoKpdrr/, S rTap/xeyiSrj, [ly 10

eii^at];

*Ey dpa ov Kal TavTov (v TroAAotj Kai xoi^pls ov^tlv 5\ov b

dfxa fvicTTaL, kol ovtcos avT6 avrov \(i)p\s hv elr/.

OvK dv, ei ye, (f)dvaL, ohv [et] ^/xe'pa [etrj] /;tta Kat ff

avTif ovaa iroWaxov dfxa eo-rt Kai ovbcv tl fxdWov avrrf

d3 fj.(uB: om. T
d6 ffruT-.iffrwB d^ riva fivdiu B riva. :

&$v0ov T : Aldina riv' &^veov Stephanus

Tj/' S/iuflo' (p\v<ipias Par.
:

1836, Procli C D, Synesiiis Origenes <p\vaplav B T 63 avrhv pr. B :

658' olv Proclus oZv BT

ilvai tSrj B Proclus
: (Ut) etvat T :

a 2 5e T T B : a 10 ec fhai seclusi ive7vai Schleiermacher :

b I Kol X"P^^ ^ X^P^* ^ ^ ^ (Vfffrai pr. T ei' (TTa* B t

:

b 3 ef 7 B Proclus flvai T u om. Proclus

: rfrj secl. Heindorf
I3ib nAATI2N02
5 avrri^ x^P^^ (cttiv, ei ovtco Koi (KacrTov twv eib&v Iv ^v
TracTLV a}xa TavTov etrj.
'HSecos ye, (fyavai., S) Sc)KpaTes, ey Tamov afia TroAAaxou
Trotciy, oloy et iotio) KaraTrerao-as ttoAAous avdpfaiiovs <^air]s
%v eirt TroAAots eti^ai oAoi'' r/ ov ro roiovroi' ^yf; Aeyeir;
C "Icra)?, (^&vai.

^H ovy oAoj; e0' eKao-ro) ro ia-Tiov ettj ay, 17 /xe'pos avTov

aAAo eTr' SAAo);
Mepos.
6 Mepto-ra apa, (f)dvaL, co "SifaKpaTfs, c(ttlv avTo. Ta et8jj,

Kat TO, p.iTi)(0VTa avrQv ixepovs av p.iTi\oi, koX ovktl iv

kKda-Ti^ o\ov, aXka p.ipos kKaa-TOV av eir;.

^atyerat ouro) ye.

'H ovv kQikria-iLs, S) SwKpares, <f>dvaL to kv elbos ^fuv
10 rfj dXrjdeia p.pL(adaL, Kal ^tl tv ^crTai;
Ovbafxw, eLTTelv.

"Opa ydp, (f)dvaL' d avTo to fxiyedos fiepLtLS Koi ^Kaa-Tov

d. Tbiv irokk&v fj.ydXu)V fjLeyiOovs pApiL a-fXLKpoTipio avrov tov

fxeycdovs fxiya ca-TaL, apa ovk dXoyov (f^avHTaL;
Udvv y, i<\>rf.

Tt 8e; tov Xaov fxipos (Kaa-Tov afxLKpov diToka^ov tl

5 e^et 0) eAarroi'i ovtl avTov tov ta-ov t6 exor to-oy r&) ecTTaL;

^AbvvaTov.
'AAAa Tov a-fXLKpov fx^pos tls rffx&v e^et, tovtov be avTov
t6 crfXLKp6v fxelCov ea-TaL are fxepovs kavTOv ovtos, Kal ovrco
brf avTo t6 crfXLKpov /uetfoi' 4a-TaL' w 8' h,v TTpocrT(6fj t6
e d<f)aLp64v, tovto crp.LKp6T(pov iaTaL dAA' ov fxit^pv rf TrpCv.

OvK hv yivoLTO, <f)dvaL, tovto ye.

T^2;a OVV TpOTTOV, flTTCLV, O) '2.<OKpaT(S, tS)V fibOtV (TOL

hS%vivT: ivB b7 B T c7 "" T

7 : ? &i/ Ifr,] %vfin
C9^]cIB:^T d2 ipavurai T : ipalverai. B d4 ixipos Proclus :

fMfpovs B /ji4povs T
: d7 iA.Xet . . . e 2 rovr6 ye spuria iudicabant
nonnulli apud Proclum d 7 avrov BT Proclus : aiirh Heindorf:
aZ Schleiermacher
 nAPMENlAHS i3ie

rd aAAa /xeraA^x/^erai, /lAT/re Kora /utepj; /m^re Kara 6\a

fxeToXan^dveiv bvvdixeva; 5

Ou fxa Tov Aia, (j^dvai, ov fioi boKii vko\ov flvai to

ToiovTov ovbajx&s biopCaacOai.
Ti 8e 877; TTpbs Tobi TTws ex*'^>

T6 TTOior;

Oi/aat (re eic tov Totovbc (V cKatTTov flbos oiecr^ai eivai* 132
oTav 7ro'AA' drra fxeydKa (tol bo^rj (tvat, fiia ris lo-coy SoKei

i8e'o f} avTT) eirai eiri Trdi^ra iSo^yrt, odcv ^v to niya fiy^

itvai,

'AXtfdij Ae'yeis, (f)dvai. 5

Ti 6' avro ro fieya Kal raAAa to. /ueydAa, cav i>cravT(t)s
TTf ^v)(TJ iiTi TrdvTa tbrjs, ovxt ^v tl av fiiya (f^av^LTat, m
raura Trdrra /xeydAa (f)aLV(r6aL;

"Eot/cey.

"AAAo dpa etbos fxcyddovs dva(f>avricrcTai, Trap' avro re r6 10

fxiy(dos yyov6s Kal Ta fLiTiyovTa avTOV' koX eTrt rovrots av

nd(TLv ^Tepov, <S TavTa irdvTa fXyd\a ^crTaL' fcai ovkTL brf b
h> (KaCTTOV (TOL T&V (Iboiv i(TTaL, dXKd d-n^Lpa to TTkifdos..
'AAAd, (f)dvaL, S) YlapfXfvCbri, tov ScoKpdrTj, pLif t&v dboiv
^Ka^TTov 77 TovTcov voTffxa, Kal ovbafxov avT(o TrpoarfKr] eyyC-
yvecrOaL dAAo^t 7/ ev xf/vxoXs' ourco ydp dv iv ye (Ka^rrov fttf 5
cai ovK dv TL TTd(rxoL h vvvbi] eAe'yero.
Tt ovv; (f)dvaL, er iKacTTOv ^(ttl Tm> voiffxdTcov, vorffxa 8e

ovbcvos;
'AAA' dbvvaTov, ltt(iv. 10
'AAAd TLvos;
Nai.
"Oyros 17 ovK ovTos; C
"Oi^ros.

a2 iroi 8<{{j7 B Proclus S6^ti ffoi T

: a 3 ^ oiTi) B Proclus :
oSttj T a7 o5 T Proclus avrov B : a 8 iriina B -eCyra :

ivdyKJi T Proclus b 4 jj tovtuv B Proclus toi5t' p T vpoaiiKij

:

Proclus : vpotrriKti BT b 5 > B t T

'
:
 ;

I33C nAATONOS
Ov\ kvos Tivos, o ttI Tiaaw iKiivo ro vorjixa cTror voel,

fxCav Tiva ova-av ibiav;

5 Nat.
Etra ovK etSos eo-rai roCro t6 voovy.ivov ^v ^Xvai, ai\ ov
To avTo kin Tracnv;
'AvdyKrj av (f)aCvTai.
Tt 8e 8?7; eiTrety tov HapfjievCbriv, ovk avdyKr] if raAAa
lo (pfis tG)V tlhSiV /uerexeiy 57 8oKet o-ot ck vornxaTOiv (Kaa-Tov
^ai Kal irdvTa voiiv, 7/ vornxaTa ovTa dvorjTa etyat;
'AAA' ov8e tovto, (f)dvai, exei Ao^yoy, dAA', w UapfxfvCbr],
d fiaXiara efxoLye KaTa<f)aCvTaL c58e exeiv to. fiV etSrj TavTa
a)a-'jTp TTapabcCyfxaTa ka-TavaL iv t^ (f)va-L, tcl be aAAa roiJrots

ioiKCVai Kal eivat 6fX0L(afxaTa, Kal rf /xe'^e^is avrrj rots aAAots

yLyv(rdaL twv elb&v ovk aAArj -as rf elKaa-OfjvaL avTols.

5 Ei OVV TL, (f>r], OLKV T^ WL, oloV T KLV0 TO etSo?

fxrf ofxOLov eii^at rSt fiKaaOevTL, Kad' ocrov avT^ d(j)<t)fi.oi(a6r]

rf (rTL TLS fxrfxavTf t6 OfxoLov fxi] ofxoCto ofXOLOv etyat;

OVK CCTTL.
To 8e ofxoLov rw 6fxoC<a dp ov fxeydkrf dvdyKr] kvos tov
e aijTOV [dboVS^ fXT\LV;

'AvdyKrj.
OS 8' av TCL Sfxoia fXTyovTa ofxoLa rj, ovk Klvo ca^TaL
avro t6 elbos;
5 YlavTdTraa-L fXV ovv.
OvK dpa oXov T TL rw eiSet ofxoLov eiyai, ov8e t6 etbos

aAAfa)' i 8e /x?/, Trapa t6 etSos dei dAAo dva(f>avrfa-TaL ei8os,

133 Kat dv Klv6 ro) dfxoiov ij, Tpov av, Kal ovbiiroTe TravcreTaL
det KaLv6v elbos yLyv6fXVov, kdv to c?6os rw kavTov fXTX0VTL
ofioiov yCyvrJTai.

C3 fTrhv vou Procli B : iwhv vouv T : ihrov voe7v B C 9 avdyKj)

f Waddell : a.vdyKri t) B
avdyKri : T
jj : avdyKTj d Proclus C 10 SokcT
BT Proclus: SoKf7v vulg. da ^c BT Stobaeus : om. Proclus
d6 S/Moiov flvai B Proclus ; elvai ofioiov T e i tthovs secl. Jackson
a I iKf7v6 T(f T Proclus iKtivif rb B (sed
: tf in ras.) ^J ^ B T
 :

nAPMENIAHS I33a

'AA>;^e(rrara A.eyei?.
OvK apa o^oLOTTjTL Takka tu)v dboiv ^eraAayx/Sayei, aAAa 5

Ti oAAo 8et ^T^reiy ^ fXTaKafil3avi.

"Eot/cey.

'Opas ovv, cf)dvaL, a SwKpares, oa"q f] a/nopLa kdv tls a)s

ctSrj ovTa avra Kad' avTo. hLopL^r^TaL;
KflX fxdXa. lo

Ev TOLWV lo-Ol, <f)dv(lL, OTL o)S (TTOS etTTetr ov^eVco aTrrr;

avT^s oo"Tj eo-riy rj aTropCa, et ^v etSos ^Kaa-Tov tS>v ovTcav b
aet rt d(f)opL0iJ.vos 6i]a-(LS.
riw? 8?/; etTTeti'.

rioAAa p.v Kal &AAa, <f)dvaL, fx4yLa-Tov 8e Tobe. et rts

(^atrj /xrjSe irpoa-riKeLV avTa yLyvtaa-Kfa-OaL ovTa TOLavTa old 5

(f^ajxev bdv (TvaL tcl et8r/, rw ravra kiyovTL ovk av exot ris

(vbeC^aa-daL otl \/^et;8erat, et jitT/ TroAAwy pikv tvxol cfJiiTiLpos

(i)V 6 dp.^La-fi'i)T5)V Ka\ p.i] d(f)Vi]s, e^e'Aot 8e Trdvv TroAAa xat

TTOppcoOev TTpayy.aTivoixivov tov kvhiLKvvfiivov ^TreadaL, dAA'

diTLdavos elr] 6 dyvooa-Ta dvayKd^cav avrd eZrat. C

Tlfj h], S) TlapiJ.VLbr] ; (f)dvaL tov ^(OKpaTr].
Ort, S) SwKpares, oi/xat av /cat rre Kai oAAor, ooris
avTifv TLva KaO^ airrriv kKd(rTov ovcTLav TLd^TaL etmi, o/uoAo-
y^o-at dv irp&Tov piV ]xr]bep.Lav avT5)V eXvaL ev rjp.lv. 5
riais yap dv avTij Kad^ avTr]v Tl eiry; (f)dvaL tov ^ooKpdTr].
KaX.&s Aeyets, eiTrery.

OvKovv Kal oaaL tQv Ib^m' Trpbs dAAr/Aas eto-ir at ela-Lv,

avrai Ttpos avTas Tr)V ova-iav i\ovcrLV, dK)C ov irpos Ta irap

ripXv e?re 6p.oL(i)p.aTa eire oirj] bi^ tls avrd TidfTaL, &v fjfXHS d
IXCT(\0VT(S etrai iKaara fTTOvojxaCdiXfda' Ta 8e iTap f]yLLV
'

TavTa oixcovvfxa ovTa (kuvols avrd au iTpos airra ((ttlv

dAA' ov TTpos TCL iXbr], Kal kavTOiv dAA' ovK fKCLVOi)V d(ra av
dyojLtd^erat ovroos. 5

a8 T Proclus om. B
a>j b i i T Proclus ^ B
: b 7 fj.(v T :

om. BProclus c i ef?} B Proclus &/ fir) T avayKd(wv avrci :

B Proclus avTo. avayKa^wv T

: C4 eKiarov B aJ>ToS iKiarov T :
I33d nAATXlNOS
ns Aeycis; <f)dvai tov ^(aKpdTrj.
Olov, <f>dvaL Tov TlapiJ.(vCbriv, ef tls rfy.S>v tov SctrTrdrrjj t)

hovKos kcTTiv, ovK avTov hieriTOTov Stjttov, o eoTt 8eo"7rdTr;s,

e kKiivov hovKos ka-Tiv, ov8e avroi; 8ovAov, o eori hovkos,
hea-TTOTrjs 6 Seo-Trdrrjs, dAA' dvdpoiiTOS uiV dvdpta-nofv d[x<f)6Tpa

TavT ((TTtv' avTTi 8e 6eo-7roTeia oiiT^j SouAeta? eo-Tii' d eo-Tt,

Kttt SouAeta wo-avTO)? avTr) SouAeta avTrjs hcariroTcCas, ctAA' ov

6 Ta cv fjixiv TTpbs exetva Tr)y hvvafjnv e^et ov8e exetya tt/jos fffJLds,

aAA', & Aeyw, avra avT&v Ka\ irpbs avTa (Kelvd Te eo-Tt, Kat
134 Ta Tiap fjfXLV oio-avTOis Trpbs avTd. 7] ov ixavddv^is kiyoi;
YVdvv y', etTreiy Tbv ^oiKpdTr], fxavddvo).
OvKOVV Kal in<TTriixr], <fidvai, avTr; jxkv b t<TTi fTTKTTrifxr]

Trjs o eo-rti; dAr^^eta avTrjs dv iKeCvrjs elrj eTTKTTrjixri;

5 Hdvv ye.

'Exdo-Trj he av t&v eTTKTTrnx&v, rj eorty, eKd^TTOv T&v

ovTOiv, 6 i(TTiv, eirj av iiTKrTiiixr)' r; ov;
NaC.
*H 8e Trap' r/jLtti' eiTKrTriixri ov Trjs Trap fipZv dv dkriOeCas
10 etrj, Kai av kKd<rTrj f} irap' fiixlv e7rto-Tr//b(.rj Totv iTap fjixlv

b ovTOiv kKd<rTov dv kTTicmiixii <Tvix^aCvoi etrai;

'ArdyKr;.
'AAAd ixriv avTd ye Ta etdr;, ws o/xoAoyeis, oi/Te (t^ofxiv
ovre Trap' i^jLtty otdi^ re eij^at.

5 Ov ydp ovv.

rLyv<acrKiTai 8e' ye ttou vtt^ avTov tov etSous tov tijs

TTL(TTrifxris avTCL tol yevyf h (ttlv Ka<TTa;

NaC.
"O ye i7|uets ovk iyjifxiv.

10 Ov ydp.
Ovk dpa vTTo ye fjfx&v yLyv<o<TKTaL Tuiv ilhSiv ovhiv,
eTretS^ avTrjs iiTLCTTrip.ris ov fXTXOfXV.

e 1 t) i<m T : ^(TTi B a6 aS r&v B : avrSiv T b4 of^Ji'

Te B : oXovrai T
 ;

nAPMENIAHv X84b

OvK (OiKev.

" k.yvui(TTov &pa rjft.iv koI avro t6 KaXov o eori Kal

t6 aya66v Kal TrdvTa h brf s i8eas avras ov(ras VTToXa/x^ti- c
vofxev.

KLvbvvevL.
"Opa 8ri hi roijTov beivoTcpov Tobe.
To TTolov; 5

<J>a6;s av ttov, elTrep ^ariv avTO ri yevos iinaT-qixr^s, ttoKv

avT6 6,Kpi^(rTpov elvaL 17 Tr]v Trap^ r}pXv einarrifMrjV, Kal

KoXXos Kal raAAa Trarra ovrco.

Nai.
OvKovv elirep ri 6Xko avTrjs iTn<TTrjixr)9 fxeTe\i, ovk av rira 10

fijaXXov rf de6v ^air/s ^X^'^ ''^^ dKpi^e<TT6.Tr]v eTnaTrjfJLrjv

^AvdyKT].
'Ap' ovv otos re av ^orat 6 ^eos tcl Ttap fjfuv yLyv<aa-KLV d
avTrjv eTTLO-Trifxrjv ^x^^'
1 L yap ov;
"Otl, 4<f)ri 6 UapfiLevLbris, w/AoXoyTjrai "^fuv, d) ^<it>KpaTes,

fx-qTe eKeiva to. etbri Trpos tol Trap^ rjfiZv TrfV b-vvafXLV ^xcv rfv 5
e\eL, fxriTe to. rtap rifXLV Trpos eKeiva, dAA' ovra Trpos avra
eKdTcpa.
'ilfAoAo^yTjrai yap.

OvKovi; d irapa roi ^fo) avrrj iarlv ^ aKpijBea-TdTr]

bea-TTOTeCa *cai aijTri r] aKpLJSeaTdTr] iiTLa-Trifxr), ovt hv r) 10

Seo-TToreia r] KeLV(av rjfi&v ttot av bea^TToa-eLev, ovt &v
TTLaT^p.ri rifxds yvoCr] ovbi tl dWo t&v irap' rffXLV, dAAa e
ofxoC^as rjfXfLS re iKeCvoiV ovk dpxofxev r?) ttafi rffxXv dpxfi
ovbe yLyv<aaKOft,(v tov deCov ovbev Trj rifxeTepci iiTLaTrifxri,

iKtLVoC rc aC KaTo. t6v avT6v koyov ovre SecrTrorai fifioiv

flalv ovTe yLyv<aaKOV(rL tcl dvdp<aTTLa TTpdyfxaTa deol 6

3vT9.

h 14 T]/uvB : ^|urf ^(TTi T Proclus c6irouT: fjolSB e 10 KaAo

B : iwi) T d 1 1 oir' tn' T : oih' Iki' ^ B Proclus
 ;

i34e nAATX2N02
'AAAa fjLri Kiav, e^rj, (i)) davfiaaroi v Aoyos, ei tis tov
Oebv d7rooTe/37/(rei tov etSerat.
TaOra /aeWot, S SwKpares, e</)rj 6 Ilap/xeviSTjs, xai Iri

135 oAAa Trpos roi/rois Trdvv TToAAa avayKoiov exety ra elSrj, eJ

eto-iy avrat at tSeat t&v ovTUiV koX opteirat rts airro ri

iKacTTOv etSos* (oore aTropeti' re roy aKOVovTa koX afX(f>La-j3r]-

rety cbs ovt ^(ttl TavTa, ei re ort /liaAto-ra etr/, ttoAAt) avdyKr]

5 avra eii^at r^ ovOpcaTiivrf (^xkt^l ayvcoa-Ta, Kal raCra kiyovTa

hoKLV re ri Ae'yety Kat, o aprt eAe'yo/xei', OavfiaarTSii ws
Suo-ayaireio-roy etyat. xai avbpbs Trdvv fxkv V(f)vov9 tov
bvvrfo-ofxivov fj.a6iv ws eo-rt yeVos rt e/cdo-rou /cai ovcria avrr)

b Ka0' avrr/i', ert 8e 6avft.aa-TOTipov tov evpifa-ovTos Koi dKkov

hvvrfa-ofiuivov StSd^at TavTa TrdvTa tKarcdS bLVKpLvrfa-dfivov.
Suyxcopo) o-ot, ((j)rf, w riap/xey^Srj, 6 SwKpdnjs' Trdvu ydp
/xoi Kara vovv Ae'yets.

5 'AAAd fi4vTOL, etTrey 6 ria/j/xeytSrjs, et ye rts 8^, &

2()K/)ares, aS fxrf edo-et ei8r/ rcSi/ ovTcav etmt, ets Trdvra rd
z^urS^ Kai dAAa TOLavTa aTTO^k^-^as, fxrfbi tl opietrai eiSos
eyos kKd(rTov, ovbe ottol Tpe^eL rffv bLavoLav lei, fxrf &v
C lb4av T&v ovTiov (Kaa-Tov Trfv avrifv det etz^at, Kai ovrtos Trfv
Tov 8taAeyeo-^at bvvafXLV TrarrdTrao-t bLa(f)dpL. tov toloIjtov
fxhf ovv fXOL SoKets Kat fxakkov fja-6rf(rdaL.

^Akrf6rj Ae'yeis, (f)dvaL.

5 Tt ovv 7rotr/o-ets </)tAoo-o0tas 7re'pt; Trfj Tpi^^rf dyvoovfXV(i)v

T0VT(t)V;

Ov irdvv fxoL boK& Ka6opav iv ye tS) TrapovTL.

Tlp<a ydp, eiTretr, Trplv yvfivaa-6rfvaL, S) 2(^Kpares, opt-

^eo-^ai eTTixcLpels Kakov re' rt Kat StKaioy Kal dyadbv Koi ^v
d ^Kaa-Tov T&v (IbCiv. kvevorfaa yap Kal iTpiarfv (tov aKovcov

67^ add. Heindorf e 8 awoffTepijfffi Stephanus airoffrep^ifffif :

BT as eKaffTOv^ an eKaffTOv Heindorf a? eixpvovs (^Se7v')

Heindorf b 2 Zvvr\ff6fjLevov pr. T TavTa irdvTa B Proclus :

irdvra ravTa T l> 5 ye Tts S^fi B Proclus 5Vj ye tis T b 6 edffr)

:

BT b 7 /i^) SfTi B /iij5' Stj T: e 5 wt) B T iro7 Prochis :

c8 ir/)$ B T Kp<^riv Proclus (et mox iirexeipeis) yp. irp<fir}v T

: :
 nAPMENIAHS I35d

biaXeyojxevov ivdabc 'ApKTToreAfi ra)6e. Ka\r] juer ovv Kal

diCa, ev Xcrdi, rj op/ur) ^v 6pjLt3j im tovs \6yovs' ^Xkvotov 8e

(ravTov Koi yvfxvaa-aL fiakkov bia rrjs boKOvarrjs axpV^TOv
flvai Kal KaXoviJLivrjs vtto tS)v iroXXoiV aboX.(rxCas, lcos ert 5

vios 1* l 8e firj, (re Sia^ev^erai r) akriOeta.

TCs ovv 6 TpoTTos, (^avai, Ylapp.vChr\, rTjs yvjxva^rCas;

OvTos, iiTtiv, ovTTcp r]Kov(ras ZrjViavos. irKriv tovto yk

aov Koi irpos roCSroy ^ydcrOriv (Ittovtos, Sti. ovk eXas iv roTs e
opcofxivois ovbe Trepl raSra Trjv -nXdvriv iin^rKOTrciv, dXAa irepl

(KfXva h /xdAi(rra tis av koyta Ad^Sot Kai etbr] hv rjyria-aiTo

(ivai.

AoKi ydp jxoi, (f>ri, TavTi] ye ovbfv xaXiTTov etvat KCit 5

ofxoLa Kal dv6]xoLa KaX dXko otiovv to, ovTa TTaa-xpvTa

d7ro</)aivety.

Kat KaX&s y, ^(f>ri. XPV ^^ '^^'- '"o^^ ^''^ TTpbs tovt(o

TTOLeXv, ]xr] ]x6vov ct etrrti' cKaarTov viTOTL6i]X(vov (TKOTTilv tol

avfxlSaCvovTa ex Trjs VTTodia-(os, aWa kol ei [xr] lo-rt to avro 136

roi5ro viroTCOeaOai, d ^ovK^l fxaWov yvixvaa-Orjvai.
riws kiycLs; (pdvaL.
OXov, (i(^ri, d ^ovkiL, Trept rat;r?js r^s viTodia-eoos rj^

Zrjvoav viTiOiTo, et iTokXd ia-Ti, tC XPV <rvix^aCvHV KaX avTols 5

rois TToAAots iTpos avra kol TTpos to %v kol rw ei^i Trpds re

a^o icai TTpos rd TroAAd* Kai av ei ]xr] ia-TL TToXXd, iraAti

o-KOTTetv rt o^vix^ria-cTaL Kal t(o kvl Kal tols TroAAots Kat jrpoj

avrd Kat irpds oAATjAa* Kai av^ts aZ idv vTTodfj et iarTLv b

6]xoL6Tr]s rj et ixr] iarLv, tC i<f>* kKaTipas r^s vTTo6ia-(as
(rv]x^r]a-TaL koX avTols toIs vTTOTeOelaLV kol toIs dAAots Kat
TTpos avTo. Kal TTpos dAArjAa. Kat irepi dvo]xoCov 6 avrbs
Adyos KOi irepi KLvr]a-(as Kal Trepi arda-eois Kal Trepi yvia-(i)s 5

Kai (f)dopds Kal Trept avror rov eirat Kat tov fxr] etrat* Kat

d4 yiixva&ai B Proclus yvnvaa-ov T : d.8 otros T Proclus:

oStws B eliTfv B T flirf7v Proclus
: e i flus iv T cW' B
:

e 3 eWTj B T Proclus : IJSt? vulg. a 6 re T : 76 B Proclus

b 1 av9is T a\no7s B
:
 :

136 b nAATilNOS:
cri \6y(f, TrfpL otov hv del vTTodfj ws ovtos Kal its ovk ovtos
Koi 6tlovv &kko irdOos Trda-xovTos, fiei a-KOTTfXv to, avfjiPaC-

C vovra irpos avro Kal Trpos Iv (Kaa-Tov t&v akXuiv, otl &v
TTpoekrf, Kal TTpbs TrAcio) Koi irpbs avp.iTavTa wcrauTcos* kox
Th.\ka av TTpbs avTo. t koI TTpbs 6.kko oti, hv irpoaipfj dei,

edvTc &)s ov VTToOfi o vTTCTideao, avTe ws fJLrj ov, el /xeXAeis

5 Tfk^tiis yvp.vaa-dp.evos KvpC(as bio-^ea-daL to dkr]des.

^ApL-fixavov y ^(f>r], keyeis, S Ilapp.evCbr}, TTpayp.aTeCav,

Kol ov acfiobpa p.avddvoi. dkkd p.0L tC ov bLrjkdes avrbs

vTTodep.ev6s tl, tva pMkkov Karajua^o);
d rioXv ^pyov, <f)dvaL, Si Sw/cpares, Trpoo-rdTrets ws rrfkLK^be.
'AA.A.d av, elTTelv tov Sw/cpdrrj, Zrjvaiv, tC ov bLrjkdes
rjfuv;

Kal Tov 2.r]V(iiva i^r\ yekda-avTa <f>dvaL' Avtov, ui

5 ^(OKpaTes, beu>p.eda Uapp.evCbov p.ri yap ov <f)avkov tJ o

kiyei. rj ovx bp&s ocrov epyov TrpoaTdrreLS ; el p.ev ovv
TrkeCovs ^p.ev, ovk hv d^Lov i]v beladaL' diTpeTTrj yap to.

TOLavTa TTokkoiV evavTCov keyeLV akkois re Kal Tr)kLK0VT(a'

e dyvoova-LV ydp ol iTokkol otl dvev Tavrqs ttJs 8td nrdvTdiV
bLe^dbov T Kal iTkdvrfs dbvvaTov evrvxdvTa roi dk-qdel vovv
(T^^^eXv. lyo) p.V ovv, Si YIapp,evCbr], 2a)cpdret avvbeop.aL, tra

Kai avros bLaKovao) 8id xpdvov.

5 TavTa brf etiroVros tov 2.r\voivos, e^r] 6 ^AvTL(f)Civ <f)dvaL

Tbv Ylvd6b(opov, avTov re Seicr^at tov Ilapp.evCbov Kal Tbv

'ApLa-TOTekr] Kal tovs dAAous, evbeC^aadai b k4yoL Kal
p.r] akkois TTOLelv. Tbv ovv TIapp.evCbr]V' 'AvdyKr], ^dvaL,
TTeCOeadaL. KaCTOL boKG> poL Tb tov l^vKeCov lttttov TTeirov-

137 OivaL, & eKelvos d6kr]Tfj ovtl kol TTpea-j3vTep(a, v(f)' app.aTL

p.ekkovTL dyoiVLelcrdaL Kal bi epiTeLpCav Tpep.ovTL Tb \xekkov,

b7 &< B : o5v T c 3 &J' T : oZv B irpoaip^ aUI B Proclus :

al(\ vpoaipv T c 4 virtrideiTo T : virorlOeaBt B c5 Stitl/tirOai T

Si6}f/t(T6t B c 6 y T om. B : C8 ti Vra T : rXya B : riva al,

d5 Stiifitea T
StdntBa B
: 63 ffxf^tv T :
?x<' ^ Proclus e4 Sta-
Kova-o) B Proclus iKoi<ro) : T
 T ;

nAPiMENlAHS 137 a

favTov aTTfiKa^coy clkojv <f)r] Kal avros ovto) 77/3CO-/3vt)js S)i;

(15 rbv epoiTa avayKd^ea-dai Uvav Kayca /xot boK& fXffJLvrjfifvos

fxdXa ^fSua-dai. tt&s XPV TrjXiKovbf ovra hiavivaai tolovtov 5

re Kol TocrovTov ireAayo? koyctiv o/uws be bel yap \api(((r6ai,
ktieibr) Kai, b Zi]VO)v Aeyet, avrot k(r\xV. -noOiv ovv bi]

dp^ofxfda Kal Ti irp&Tov vTTodr](r6fXda; rj ^ovXecrdc, eTrct- b

bi]TTp boKL TTpayfxaT^Kabr] Traibidv naiCav, a7r' efxaurov
dp^oofxai. Kal rfjs ifxavTov vTTodicncas, Trept tov kvos avTov

vTiodefxevos, efre ^v kariv etre fxr] <tv, ri \fn] crvfx^aivnv

Yldvv fxkv ovv, (f>dvat Tbv Zrfvoova. 5

Tis ovv, etTreir, fxol OTroKptyetrat; 7/ 6 ve<aTaTOs; i^/ciara

ydp dv TTokvTrpayfxovol, fcai h oteroi fAoAto-ra dv aTTOKpivoiTO'

Kal dfxa (fxol dvaTTavXa dv eh] r) iKeivov dTTOKpi^TLs.
"Erotfxos o-oi, 0) Uapfxevibr], (f)dvai,, tovto, tov ^ApKTTo- C
re'ATj' ffxk ydp Ae'yets tov ve(aTaTov Ae'ya)y. dAAo ep(aTa ws
oTTOKp tyovnxe'i;ou.
Etey br'], (f)dvaL' et (v ka-TLv, oAAo rt ovk dv dr] ttoAAo
To iv; Yl&s ydp dv; Ovre dpa fxipos avTOv ovTe okov 5
ovro 6er etrat. Ti 8?;; To fxepos ttov dXov fxepos ka^Tiv.
Nai. Ti 6e to okov; ov\l ov dv fxipos fxrjbkv oTrr} oAor dv
ctr]; TTain; ye.- ^Afx(f)OTepo)s dpa to ^v eK fxepGiv dv eXr],

oKov re ov Kal fxeprf 'typv. ^AvdyKr]. ^Ap.(f)OTepo)s dv dpa

ovTcos To kv TroAAo etT/ oAA' ovx ev. ^AkrjOrj. Aet be ye d
fxr] iroAAa oAA' ^v ovro eti^ot. Aet.' Ovr' opo oAoy eo-rat

oiJre fxeprf e^ei, et kv ecrTaL to ev.

Ov ydp.
OvKovv et ytxfbev e\eL fxepos, ovt dv dpxr]v ovre TekevTi]v
ovTe fxeaov expL' fxeprf ydp dv ifbr] avTov Ta roioura etTj.- 5

^Opd&s. Kot fir]v TekevTrj ye KOt dpxh TTepas eKdarov.

rieSs b ov; "ATreLpov dpa to ^v, el fxrjTe dpxr]v firjTe reAeu-
Tr]V Ix^'* "'ATreipoy. Kot dvev arxr]p.aTos dpa' ovre ydp

a5 Btavfvarai T Siavvffai B
: a 6 ire\ayos Stephanus c Ficino
et sicProclus legisse videtur ir\^eo$ B a 7 ft Bekker 6
: : BT
b r ip^ofjifea T (sed o ex u) Proclus i^^ufnda B e i tovto B T
: :

Toinov vulg. C 6 S\ov fxtpovs B fitpos S\ov T d 4 ^x** ^

:

fXV B d 8 tx*' T fxv ^ T^P B T yhp hv vulg.

: :

PLATO, VOL. II. 2


137 e nAATX2N02
e oTpoyyvKov ovn ev64os /xercxet. Tl&s; 2Tpoyyv\ov y4 irov

(CTTL TOVTO ov hv To. iCT^aTa TTavTaxrj aiTo tov ixea-ov t<rov

.aTT^)(i]. Nat.^ Kal fxi]V v6v ye, ov av t6 fxfaov ajxcf^oiv

TOLV f(ryaToiv kTriTipoa-Qev

f].
Ovtcos. Ovkovv \xipr] av
5 tyoi To ^v Ka\ TToXKa av iXr], eire vd4os (Tyr]]xaTos etre

TTpi.(f)povs ix(T\OL. Ylavv ]x\v ovv. Ovre apa (v6v ovtc

138 TTpL<f)pS koTLV, TTL7Tp Ovbc ]Xpr] XL. ^Op6(aS.
Kal ixi]v tolovtov ye ov ovba]xov hv Lrj' ovt yap V
a\\<a ovT v avT(ti et?]. IlS>s bt]; 'Ev a\X.<o ]XV ov
KVK\<ji TTOV av 7TpLX0LT0 VTt' KLV0V V W VLr], Kol

5 TToWayov av avTov aiTToiTo TroAXoty tov 8e kvos re Ka\

a]Xpovs Kcu kvk\ov 1X1] ]XTXovtos abvvaTov TToWaxv kvk\(o
aTTT<T6aL. ^KbvvaTov. 'AAAa ]xr]v avTo ye V eairrw ov
Kav kavT^ eirj TTpLyov ovk aWo rj avTo, ^XiT^p koll v
b eairrw eiTj* V ro) yap tl etvat ]xi] ttPL\ovtl abvvaTov.-
^XbvvaTov yap. Ovkovv Tpov ]XV av tl etr; avro to
7TpLX0V, TpOV b TO TT^pL^yOJX^VOV OV yap 6\oV y a]X(f>(t}

TavTov a]xa iTL(TTaL Ka\ TTOLrja-^L' Ka\ ovtoo t6 ^v ovk hv

5 eij; ert v aWa bvo. Ov yap (wv. Ovk apa a-TLV ttov

t6 ^V, ]Xr]T V aVT^ ]xi]T V 6.\\<0 v6v. OvK ^OTLV.

"Opa br], ovTCDS xov et olov re eariy eo-rdrat rj klvl-

Tt yap -"Ort kivov]Xv6v ye

Nat.
cr6aL. bi] ov/' r) (f)poLTO i]

C dXAototro av avrai yap pi,6vaL KLvrjacLS. 'AAAotov-

]XVov bc t6 kv kavTov abvvaT^v ttov V Irt etyat. 'A8v-
vaTov.
rat.
OiiK apa Kar
'AAA' apa rw
a\\oL(oaLv ye Ktretrat.
(f)pcr6aL; "la-(t)s. Kat
Ou
]xi]V et <f)poLTo
(f>aiv-

5 TO <EV, rjTOL V T<a aVT(a aV TTpL(f)pOLTO KVK\<0 r] ]XTa\-

Adrroi ^(apav hepav e^ cTepas. 'Ardy/crj. Ovkovv kukAo)
]XV TTpL(f)p6]XV0V klTL ]X<TOV ^Jir]KVaL aVayKr], KOL rd

e I yUTexf t Proclus : /ttrexoi BT 63 anfxv Tb : hv xj? pr. B

64 ff T: etn B a^ fveii] hv eJij T
Heindorf: &/ ei/ tlri B:
a8 iavT^ B favTh T Proclus
: avro Diels : avrS B T Proclus
b I tJvai T ffrj B : b 2 avrh^ avrov Schleiermacher b 6 fv6v
T: tv 6v B b 7 iarrtv T om. B b 8 -ye b Proclus al. : re pr.
:

B T Stobaeus c 2 irov iv tri tJvai B : Hti irov tivai T

 ;
nAPMENIAHS 138 c

irepl t6 jjiicrov (fxpofifva ciAAa /btepij

X^'^ (avrov' w 5e

/ij/Tf joicVov /iXT/Te fj.cpS>v TTpocnfiKd, Tiy fxrfx^avrj tovto kvkAw d

ttot' eTTi Tou p.((rov fvexOfjvaL; Ov8e/xia.
'AAAa 8t/ x^apav
a/btci/Sov oAAot' oAAo^i yiyreTai Kai ovtco KiyeiTai; KiTTfp
ye 8^. OvKovv (Tvai fxev ttov v tivi ovt^ abvvaTov
(f>dvr); Nai. -'Ap' ovv yiyvfcrdai. tTi. abvvaT(OTpov; 5

OvK (vvooi OTT?/.- Et v Tfa) Ti ytyvfTai, ovK avdyKr] p.rfT

770) kv ^KfLvta ilvai ti (yyiyvofxevov, fxrfT tTt e^o) iKiivov

TTavTaiTacTLv, ciTTep rjbrf iyyiyvcTaL; WvdyKri. Et apa tl

aAAo TretVcTat tovto, (Kdvo av fxovov TTacrxot ov fxtprf eiTj* e

To fxkv yap dv tl avTov rjbrf kv Kiv<a, t6 8c I^co eir/ dfxa'

t6 bf fxif x^^' H-^PV "^X ^'^'^ ''^ '^^^ ((TTaL TpoTTca ovbevl
okov dfxa fxrfTC ivTos etyat Tiros fxrfTC e^o). 'AXrfdrf, Ov
be fxrfT fUprf fl^rl fxrfTf oXov Tvyxd.vL 6v, ov ttoAv cti 5

dbvvaT(oTpov iyyLyvcr6aL ttov, fxrfTC KaTa fXiprf fxrfT KaTa

okov iyyLyv6fXVov; <i>atvcTai.- Ovt' dpa ttol i6v Kal V
TO) yvyvofxevov x^^po-v oAAaTTct, ovr iv tw avTta TTfpt^pepo- 139
fxfvov ovT dkXoLovfXiVov. OvK KoTa OLK. Trao-ay dpa
KLvrfo-LV t6 %v aKLvrfTov. 'AAAa
'Aku^tjtoi'. fxrfv Kal (IvaC
yk <pafXV v tlvl avT6 dbvvaTov. <t>ap.V ydp. Ov8' dpa
TTOTf iv T<S avT(o i(TTLv. ^Ti dv "Oti iv exctVw 5

etJj iv w Tfa) avTio (cttlv. brf;-

Yldvv fxkv
ifbrf

ovv. 'AAA' ovt ev

avT<a ovT v aAAfa) olov t ^v avT<a evelvaL. Ov ydp
OVV. OvbTT0T dpa <rTl t6 kv V TW aVT^. OvK OLKV.
AAAa fxrfv t6 ye fxrfbTTOT iv tw avT<D ov ovt rfcrvxCo-V b
ayet ov^' loTTjKer. Ov yap olov t. To ^v dpa, ws ioLKV,
OVT a-TrfKV OVT KLVLTaL. OvKOW 8tJ (f)aLVTaL y.

Ovb fxrfv TavTov ye ovt Tp<o ovt eavTSt crTaL, ou8'

av TpoV 0VT aVTOV OVT kTpOV dv CITJ. Ilfj brf -"ETepof 5

d 3 i.fi(iPoi.- T aiitificov B : d 4 avr^ pr. B T avrh b vulg.

:

d 6 /A^e ir B )UTj5*ir T : d 7 /x^' (ri Heindorf fi^fri B T

: :

/ti^t ri vulg. d 8 IJSrj T : 8)j B iyylyvfrai T eu ylyvtrai B

:

65 ilffX] iffrl Helndorf 0.6 rif cojrif BT Proclus rh ainh al.

:

a7 ivfivai b : iv tJvai BT b i tii' T : om, B b 5 ir^ T rivi B :

2*


139 b nAATIiNOS
fxev TTov kavTov ov kvos (repov av etr) Kal ovk av eu; ev.
'AXrjOfj. Kat ixrjv tovtov ye ercpo) ov kKeivo av etrj, avTO
ovK av eir]' ow av coore ovtuis ctrj oTrep eorti', ev, a\\
iTepov ivos. Ov yap TavTov ovv. fxev apa erepfa) ri cTcpov
kavTov ovK lo-rctt. Ov yap. "Erepoy 8e ye fTtpov ovk
eo-rat, eco? Sy ^ ^v ov yap kvl Trpoa-rjKei ere/ao) rtyos

5 etyat, aAAa ij.6v(a fTcpio eTcpov, akXio 6e ovbevC. 'OpOias.

T(S /uey apa ^v (Ivat, ovk lo-rat (Tcpov rj oiei; Ov
brJTa. AX.X.a p.r]v et p.r] tovt(o, ovx eavrw eo-rat, et 6e jbt?)

avrw, ov8e avro* avTo be /:xrj8a/utfj oi Tpov ovbevos ea-TaL

d Tpov. 'Op^ws. OvSe ju.^1^ TavTov ye eavroi ia-Tai. Hois
5' oi!; Ovx ^Trep rou eros (fyva-is, avTr] brjirov Kal tov
TavTov. TC bi]; -"Ori ovk, eTreibav tovtov yivr^TaC r<i) rt,

fv yCyv(Tai.
'A\Aa rt ixr]v; Tots 7ro\Aots Tavrbv yevo-
5 ]j.evov TTokXa avdyKr] yCyvea-Oai, dAA.' ovx ^v. 'AAt;^^.
'AAA' et t6 ^v Kal t6 TavT6v /X7j8a/xf) bia<^ipi, oTTOTe ri

ravroi^ yCyvTO, det av ^v cyCyveTo, Kal oTTOTe ^v, tov-

e Tov. Yldvv ye. Et dpa to ^v kavT<a tovtov eo-rat, ov\
iv eauro) iaTai' kolI ovT(a ev ov ovx ^v eo-rat. dAAd jx-qv

TOVTo ye ddwaroi^* dbvvaTov dpa Kal tQ kvl rj eTepov Tpov

iXvai r] kavT^ tovtov. 'ASwaroy. Ovtod br] eTcpov ye
5 r] TavT^v t6 ^v ovt' av avT(a ovt' dv erepo) eitj. Ov yap
ovv.
Ovbk d]X0l6v TlVt <TTai 0V8' dv6]JL0L0V OVT aVTia OVT

ere'/3({).
]Xr]V

^T^ 87/; -"Ort t6 tovt^v ttov ttt:ov66s d]xoi.ov.

Nat. Toi; 8e ye kvos \(i>p\s (f)dvr] rf)y (fyvciv t6 rav-
140 Tov. 'E(f)dvr] ydp. ^'AAAd ^xqv e? rt ttttov6 x^P'-^ '"''^

^v eiyat t6 iv, rrAeta) dv etrat TTTT6v6ot rj V, tovto 8e

dbvvaTov. Nai. Ovba]x&s eariv dpa tovt^v ttttov66s

etrat rd %v ovt dAAo) ovt kavTia. Ov (f>aCvTaL. Ou8e

C5 frepov T Proclus om. B C7 rovr(f> T: oSto B
:

di 76 Proclus om. B T : da aurii Proclus oStt/ B: ovt^ T :

Toi; ToiiToO T tovtoC B : 64 H] S^ ^ Heindorf: 8' Waddell tj

e 7 oiir' eavr^ T ovrii,v avrif B :


nAPMENIAHi; i4oa

ofioi.ov apa bvvaToi' avro ^lvat ovt6 aAA(p ovre kavr^, Ovk 5

ioiMV. Ovb( ixi]v (Tepov ye ir^Trovdev (IvaL t6 (v Kal yap

ovT( irAeio) av tttt6v6oi etrai 7) (v. riAeico ydp. To y p.r}v

Tpov TTeiTOvOos kavTov aXkov avofxoLov &v etrj eavrai

rj 5AA&), eiTrep
1]

to Tavrov TTfTTOvdbs
1/

6p.oi.ov.
'Op^ws.T6 7/

b
8e yt v, 0)5 ioiKV, ovbapCis (Tpov TTeiTovdos ovbap.m
av6p.oi6v eo-TiJ' ovtc avr<S ovre erepo). Ov yap ovy.

Oure &pa opioiov ovTf av6pot.ov ovd* erepo) ovt eaurai hv et7j

ro er. Ov (fyaCvcTai. 5

Kai /bi7;y toiovt6v ye oy ovre lo-oi; ovTe avicrov ecrrai

ovre eavro) ovTi 3AA<i). IItJ; -"lo-oy p.\v dv t&v avT<av
pfTpoiv eo-rai e/cetVo) w Si' laor fj.
Nat. Met^oi' 8e ttov

1] ikaTTOV ov, oXs pkv av crvpp^Tpov 7/, pkv ikaTT^voiV

t5>v C
jrAeia) /uterpa e^et, rwi^ 8e pL(i0vo)V eAarrci). Nai. Ots 8'

Si' /X7J (TvppeTpov, tG)V p.(v (rpi.KpoTp(av, T&v 8e /u,et^oVo)r

peTpoiv eorat. n&)? yap ov; Ovkow d87;raroi' to pij

p.T\ov Tov avTov pfTpo^v T&v avToiv flvai oAAcor 5

m^TLVoivovv Totv
1}

avTOiv;
'A^i^i^aroi;. "lo-oi p.v
7]

apa oirr

2 eairro) ovt aAAo) pi) tu>v avT&v /xerpcoi; ov. Ovkow

<f>aivTaL ye.
'AAAa eiT/

prjv TrAetoVcai; ye p.Tp<tiV ov tj eAar-

t6vO}V, 0(T0)V1Tp pTpO}V, TOCTOVTOOV Kal pp5>V aV iXt]' KaL

ovrco av ovktl %v (crTaL dAAa TO(ravTa o^raiTep Ka\ to. d

pfTpa. 'Op^ws. Et ye pTpov 8e ei^os eiTj, lo-or av yi-
yvoLTo tovto
Tia pTp(a' abvvaTov 8e (f)avr], L(rov t<o avTo
(TvaL.
Ovre apa
'E</)dr7j pTpov
yap. ei^o? peT^xov ovTe
TToW&v 0VT 6kLyo)V, ovT To TTapdiTav TOV aVTOV pT\OV, 5

ovT kavTO) "TTore, o)? Oik(v, eo-rat lo-oi' ovt aAAo)* ovt av
pdCov ovbt kkaTTov ovT (avTov ovT Tpov. riayrairaort

ptV OVV OVTO).

Tt 8e'; TTpecriSvTepov i] recorepoi' 7*; rl/r avTijv 7/AiKtai' e
exeti' To v boKL ro) 8v7'ar6y eirat; Tt 87/ ydp ov; Ort
b 7 TT^ ; BT : add. 5^ in marg. t d3 t^] avr^ B : t^ T
e 2 Ty] T<f BT


140 e nAATHNOS
TTOV TfkLKCav ixkv Ti]v avTr]V fX^*^ V ^'^^ V o.W(o iaoTriTos
Xpovov Kal ofwiorqTOS /xe^e^ei, (av \4yoiXV ov /xcTcrrai
5 TO) (vC, ovT ofiOLOTriTos ovT iaroTTjTos.
'EAeyojLiey yap
ovv. Kat jxrjv Kal otl avofJLOLOTriTos Te Kal avL(r6Tr]Tos ov
fxcTexcL, Kal tovto eXeyofjiev. Tldvv jxev ovv. Ilws ovv
141 olov Te efTTat Ttyoy rj TTp(rj3vTpov r] v(aTpov ctvat ij tijv

avTr]V rjKLKLav ^\(eLV tw toioutoj^ ov; OvbajxGts. Ovk apa

hv eXri v<aTp6v ye ovbe irpe^rjivTepov ovbe Tr]v avTi]v
rjXLKLav e^oy to V ovt avT(a ovt aAXw. Ov (\>aLVTaL.
5 'Ap' ovv ov8e V XP^^*? ''"^ TiapoLTiav bvvaLTo av eti^at to V,
ei TOlovTov Lr]; ?/ ovk avdyKt], idv tl ?] v \p6v(a, det

avTo avTov TTp(r^vTpov yLyv(r6aL; ^ AvdyKr]. Ovkovv

t6 ye 7rp(r^vTpov dei vOiTpov iTp(T^vTpov; Ti ]xr]v;

b ^To Trp eo-^VTe/3or dpa kaxxrov yLyv6]XVov kox V(aTpov

cavTov d]xa yCyv^TaL, etTre/? /xe'AA.et Xlv otov Trp(r^vTpov
yiyvr^TaL. Yi.5>s Ae'yet5;
^128e" bid(j)opov Tpov Tpov
ovbcv 8et yLyv(TdaL 7/817 ovtos bLa(f)6pov, dAAa tov fxkv

5 r]br] ovTos ?/8r/ etrat, tov 8e yyov6TOs yyovvaL, tov 8e

]X\XovTos //e'AAety, tov 8e yLyvo]XVov ovtc yyovvaL ovt
]X\X.LV ovT LvaL TTO) bLd(j)opov, dAAtt yiyv^crdaL kcll dAAo)?
C ovk LvaL.
'AydyKi/ ydp br].
'AAAa ]xr]v t6 ye TTp(rj3vTpov
bLa(f)op6Tr]s V(t)Tpov (rTlv KOL ovbv6s dAAou. -"Eo-Tt ydp.
To apa TTp(r^vTpov kaxrrov yLyv6]xVov dvdyKr] kox
V(OTpov d]xa kavTov yiyv^crdaL. "EotKey. -'AAAd ]xr]v Ka\

5 ]xr]T kavTov yiyv(rdaL XP^^'^^ P-W^ eAdTTco, dAAd

TrAeico

Tov X(rov xpoi^oi Kat yiyv(rdaL kavTut koI etyat Kat yyo-
VvaL Koi ]XXXLV (T(TdaL. \vdyKi]
^
ydp ovv Ktti Tavra.
AvayKr] dpa kaTiv, s 0LKV, o(ra ye V xpdv(a eorh'
d Kat ]XTXL TOV TOtOVTOV, Ka(TTOV avToiv TrjV aVTr]V T

e 6 avjffOTTjToy T Proclus : Iff^TtiTOS B a 2 t^] t^ B T a3 "ye

T : om. B b3 ylyvT^Tai scripsi yiyvfTai B T
: Staupopov
TW: 5m<^^poy B Proclus b^ Sid(popov3: Ti>Sid(popovT Ci yitp
S^ Schanz yap &v B : ydp
: T C5 yiyvf(r0at xP^''o*' ^
XP^*'"*'
yiyv((r9a( T

nAPMENIAHS i4id

avTo avT^ rjkiKiav ex^LV kuI TTpea-^vrepov re avrov aiJ.a Kal

veu>Tcpov ytyv(r$at. Ktvbvvevct.

'AAAa fxr^v tw ye kvl TOiv

TOtovTOiV TTa6r}ixdT(av ovbkv ixeTtjv.' Ov yap ixeTrjv. Ovbe

apa xpovov avT(a /xereoTti^, ov8' loriy V Ttvt xp6v<f. 5

OvKovv bi], (0? y b Aoyos aXpiX.

Tt ovv; To i]v Ka\ to ykyovt koX to kyiyvfTo ov xpovov
[xide^tv boKei (rrjixaivetv tov Trore yeyovoTos; Kdt jowiAa.

Tt be; t6 e(TTat Ka\ to yevrj^reTai Kal to yevrjOrj^reTat ov e

Tov eiretTa [tov fxeXXovTos]; Nai. To 8e br] co-rt Kat

To yiyverat ov tov vvv TrapovTOs; YlAvv fxev ovv. Et

apa t6 ^v fxr]bafxf} ixr]bev6s />ierexci xpoVov, ovTe irore

yeyovev ovt' eyiyvfTo ovt rjv TTOTe, ovTe vvv yeyovev oxrre 5

yiyveTat ovTe ovt iiretTa yevq^reTat ovTe yevr]6r]-

o-erai ovre lo-rai.

e(TTtv,

'AArj^eo-rara. "Eo-rw/ ovv ovcrias ottcos

av Ti fxeTCKTxoi aXkoos 1] KaTO. TovTOiV Tt; OiiK e(TTtv.

OvbafLGiS apa t6 kv ovcrias fiere'xet. Ovk eotKev. OvbafxGiS
apa loTt t6 ^v.- Ov (^aiveTat. Ov8' apa ovroos Ifrrtr 10

c5o-re ^v eXvat' eirj yap hv ijbr] 6v Kal oixrias fxeTexov

oAA' ois ^otKev, t6 ^v ovTe ev earTtv ovTe eaTtv, ei 8et rai

roi&iSe Ao'ya) Ttt^TTevetv. Kti^Swevet.

*0 be fxr] lort, 142
TOVT(a ro) fxr] ovTt etr] av rt avrai t/ avTOv; Kai tt&s;

Ov8' apa ovofxa ecTTtv avTi^ ovbe Koyos ovbe Tts eiTt-

(TTrjfir] ovbe atcr6ria-ts ovbe bo^a. Ov (paiveTat. Ov8' ovo-

ftdferai apa ovbe Ae'yerat ovSe So^d^erat ovbe ytyv(a(rKeTat, 5
ovbe Tt Tbiv ovToiV avTov aia-6(xveTat. Ovk H eotKev.

bvvoT^v aiiv TTepl t6 ^v ravra ovTOis exetv; Ovkovv e/uotye

8o*cet.

BovAet ovv em Tr]V vTTodea-tv TTaktv e^ dpx^? eTrai^eA- b

6oifxev, eav ri rffxiv eiTavtova-tv dAAoioz' <f)avi]; Hdiw piev

d6 (uf>7BT: ^pe? apogr. Stud. er yfyqO-fiafrai] yeytyrjcreTai

Schleiermacher, at vide Proclum e 2 rod /xeWovroi seclusi rov :

secl. Heindorf wov G. Hermann

: e ri J/'| ft> hv legendum susp.
Heindorf /xtrfxoy] f*^(r4xoi legendum susp. Heindorf a 2 o^^
BT : -^ aiirif vulg. b 2 <pay^ T : (pavfiri B


i4ab nAATHNOS
ovv i^ovXofxai. OvKovi> '^v ei ((ttlv, (pafxev, ra (Tv}i^ai-
vovra TTcpl airrov, TToia Trore Tvyx^avei. ovTa, 6io/uoAoyT;rea
5 Tavra' ovx ovrco; Nai. "Opa br) e^ apxrjs. ^v i ia-Tiv,
apa oXov re avTo dvai fxev, ova-Cas be ixrj iiiTiyeiv; Ovy^
olov re. OvKovv koI tj ovaia tov kvos elr] av ov TavTov
ovira T(o kvi' ov yap h.v iKeivrj ^v fKeivov ovo-ia, ovV hv
C eKHVo, t6 fv, Kivr]s fXTel\v, dAA.' ofxoiov hv -^fv \eyeiv h>
re eiyai koX kv ev. vvv 8e ov\ avrr} (o-tIv t} vTToOea-is,

ei kv V, Ti XPV (J^vixjSaiveLv, dAA' et ev (ttlv' ovx

oijT<a; Yldvv fxkv ovv. Ovkovv ws dAAo tl a-r]p.aivov to
h ^aTL Tov v; 'AvdyKr}. ''Apa ovv dAAo rj otl ovaias
/xere'xei t6 ev, tovt av etTj to Xeyofxevov, (TreLbdv tls
av\Xril3br]v eiTrr; ort kv eaTLv; Udvv ndAtr 8^ ye. Ae'yw-
fXV, kv ei eaTLV, tl avfx^rfaeTaL. aKoireL ovv et ovk dvdyKrj
TavTrfv Trjv viroOeaLV tolovtov ov t6 ^v arfp.aivLV, olov
d fxipr) \Lv; YlSts;
^X28e' et t6 eaTi tov v6s ovtos
\4yeTaL /cai t6 ^v tov ovtos kvos, iarrL be ov t6 avT6 r} re
ovaia Kal t6 v, tov avrov 8e Kivov ov viredefxeda, tov
Vos ovTos, apa ovk dvdyKr) t6 fxv okov kv 6v eTvaL avTo,
5 TOVTOV be yiyveadaL fxopLa t6 re ^v KOt t6 etrat;
'AvdyKr/.
^ndrepoi' ovv eKaTepov Toiv fxopioiv tovtcov fxopLov fxovov

TTpoaepovfxev, rf tov 6\ov fxopLov t6 ye fx6pL0V Trpoaprf-

Tov; Tixv 6\ov. Kai oAor dpa iaTi, 6 av V rf, kol
fx6pLov e^ei. Udvv ye. Ti ovv; TUiV fxopioiv eKdrepov
e TovTCtiV Tov v6s ovTos, t6 T V kol t6 ov, dpa diTo^eiiTeaOov
rf t6 V tov LvaL fxopiov rj t6 6v tov v6s fxopiov; Ouk
h.v etrf. ^ndAty dpa Kal TiHv p.opi(t)v kKdrepov t6 re V

b4 ai/rov BT : avrS Stephanus b 8 yap tiv T : yap B C 3 ?v

V, Ti] %v evTi B; ev TiT c6 Tis T : t B c8 f B : om. T
da \fyeTai Kal T \fy(Tai Kal rh ev tov ovtos \tyfTai koX B
: ou B :

om. T d 4 axiro B T avrov vulg. d 8 iftv B tav T

: : tv f T :

iv^ pr. B dg fi6pwv^ fi6pia Heindorf 62 flvat] 6vros tlvai

Bekker nopiov pr. T : ix6piov B t Simplicius secl. Schleiermacher
:

ixopiov BT Simplicius: n^ptov vulg. : secl. Schleiennacher



nAPMENIAHS i42e

io-^t Koi t6 6v, koX yiyveTaL t6 (Xdxta-Tov k Suoii' av

fxopiOLv t6 ixoptov, Kot KaTo. t6v avr6v koyov ovT(as aeC, 5

oTiTTep av fxopiov yivrjTaL, tovtm tco fxopLO) del lo-xef t6

T( yap ^v t6 6v dei icrxei Kal t6 6v t6 iv coo-re dvdyKt]

StT det yLyvopiivov /xTjSeiroTc ^v eirai. IlavTdT:a<TL fxv 143

ovv. OvKovv aitiLpov av t6 ttA^^os ovT(a t6 ev ov elr];
"KoiKfV.
"IOl brj KOL Tfjbe TL. Ylfi; Oixrias (f>afxev jttcrexea' to
ev, 810 i(TTLv; Nai. Kai Sia Tairra hr) t6 h> 6v nokka 5

<f)dvr]. OvTO). TC avT6 t6 8e; iv, 87/ (f)aix(v ovcria^

/xeTe'xetr, kdv avro Tr] hLavoicx fxovov Kad^ avro Ad/Sto/xei'

dvev TovTov ov (f>afxfv fxTi\(LV, dpd ye er fxovov (f^avrj-

(TCTaL rf Kal TTokka t6 avro tovto; "Ev, oTfxai eycoye.

"Ib^DfXfV bri' dkko TL Tpov fxv dvdyKr] t?V ovcriav avTOV b

eii^ai, fTcpov 8e avro, etTre/) fxi] ovcria t6 V, dXk ws ev
ov(rias fXfTia-x^v.
'Ardy/crj. Ovkovv et hepov fXV r] ovaia,

Tpov bi t6 'iv, ovT Tw e^ t6 ^v t?/? ovcrias eTepov

ovT tS> ovcria (tvaL rj ovcria tov kvos dAXo, dAAd tw eTe/aw ->

Te Kai dAAo) eTcpa dkkr]koi)V. Yldvv fxev ovv. "Q.o-tc

OV TaVTOV i(TTLV OVT TO) 1^1 OVT T|/ OV(ri(l TO Tp0V.

rTws ydp;
Ti ovv; dv 7Tpok<afX6a avT&v etTe /3ovAei ttji; ovcriav C
Kat t6 TpOV LT Tr]V OVO-iaV Ka\ t6 V LT t6 ^V Kal TO
Tpov, ap ovK V Kd(rTr] T7/ T:poaip(rL TTpoaLpovfxedd TLV

& 6p6^s exet KaAeto-^at d/A(|)OTe'pa); Ilais; ^'ilSe* eo-Ttr

ovcriav eiTreti^;
^Eo-Tti'. Kat av^ts etTretr Kat eV; 5

TovTo. -'Ap' ofvv ovx KdTpov avTolv etpr/Tai; Nat. Tt

8' oTav etTTco o^o-ia t Kal V, dpa ovk dfxcj^OTcpo); Udvv
ye. Ovkovv Kal idv ovcria re Kat Tpov i) Tp6v T Kal
V, Kal ovToi) 77 afTaxws e^' Kd<rTOV dfx0a) Ae'ya); Nat.
e6 Towry T^ fjiOpiif B pr. T a^ toiKfv B : l^oi/te 7 T a6 rt
* B
8(B: : Tj 5t} T b I If5a>/X6'] dSufJifv BT b2 t^vcrta B : oii<rias l'

vovffiasBT:
v oixrios tvbs oiktio vulg. C3 tii/ & T : ri vetpB C4 &/i-

lOTfpit!
(ftor T : iLfx^oTepa, B C9 iKa.trrov B : (Kacrrov T
 :

143 d nAATi2N02
d ^O. 8' av a/x0a) op6u>s 7rpo(rayopevr}(rdov, apa olov re aiKfxo
fxev avTU) elvai, bvo 8e /x^;- Ovx olov re.
*i2 8' h> bvo
^ov, <rTL Tis ixrjx^avrj [xi] ov\ kKCLTfpov avTolv kv eirai;

Ov8e/Aia. Tovtwv apa eTreiTre/) arvvbvo (KacrTa o-v/x/3aiyci

5 eirai, Kai kv av eir] (KacrTov. Et

^airerai. 8e kv (Kaa-Tov

avTUiV eoTi, (rvvTeOivTOS kvos 6Troi.ovovv ffnviovv <rvQvyia

ov Tpia yiyrerai to. iravTa; Nai. Tpia 8e ov TrepiTTa
Kol bvo apTia; Y\S>s 8' ov; Tt 8e; hvolv ovtoiv ovk

e avdyKr) eivai Kat bCs, koI Tpi&v ovtoov Tpis, etTre/) VTrdpxei
tS> re 8vo to b\s (V Kal roi rpta to Tpls fv; ^AvdyKr].
Avoiv 8e ovToiv Kal bls ovk dvdyKr} bvo bls etvai; Kal

TpiSiv *cai TpXs ovK dvdyKrj av Tpia rpls ilvai; XlGts 8'

5 ov; ^Tt 8e; Tpmv ovTOiV Kal bls ovtcov Kal bvolv ovtoiv
Kal Tpls ovTOiv ovK dvdyKr} re rpta 8ts etyat xat bvo
Tpis; IToAA.T/ ye. -"Aprta re apa dprtaKts av ctr] Kal

144 TrepiTTd TrepiTTdKLS Kal dpTia irfpiTTdKLS kol 7re/3trra dprta-

Kts.
"'Eo-rti^ ovTOii. Et ovv TavTa ovrcos X^' ^'^' '"'^"

dpLdfxov VTroXeiirea-OaL ov ovk dvdyKr] elvai; Ovbapi&s

ye. F.l dpa ecTTLv ev, dvdyKr) Kai dpLd]xbv eivat. ^Av-

5 dyKr].
'AAXa ixr]v dpLOfxov ye ovtos TroXXd hv eir; Kai

TrkrjOos aTTeipov T(av ovT(av' r] ovk dircLpos dpLdpibs irkqdu

Ka\ }XTiyu)V ov(rias yiyvcTaL; Kat Trdvv ye. Ovkovv et

irds dpidjxbs oixrias /xere'xet, Kai Tb ]x6piov Ka(rTov tov

dpi6]Xov /xere'xot dv avTrjs;Nai.
b 'Em Trdi^ra dpa TroWd ovTa r] oixria vev4ixr]TaL Kal

ovbevbs dTro(rTaTei t5>v ovtu>v, ovtc tov cr]XLKpoTdTOV ovtc

Tov ixeyi(TTOv; 17 tovto pikv Kal dKoyov epi^rdaL; tt&s ydp av
br] ov(ria ye T(av ovt(ov tov diroa-faTol; Ovba]x5>s. Kara-
5 KKepixdTiaTai dpa b>s olov re (T]xiKp6TaTa KaX jxeyicrTa KaX

di6B:5T d 3 m^) T om. B _ d^ avv.

6.z Si]^B: S>T :

Svo Stephanus Svo B: a-vv SvoT

o5i/ ez re
: . 64 oS om. pr. . . T
e6 T6 rpia B rpia re T: Svo rpts in marg. b et legit Procl. suppl. :

rpia Sis B SU rpia T

: a 6 &irfipos B &irfipov T a 7 ovcrias T :

ovcria B b 4 8^ B T ^ Stobaeus rov T rov B

:
airo- :

ffraroir} Stobaeus airoararfl B

: airo<rrarei T :


nAPMENIAHS I44b

navTox/as ovra, Kal \xey.ipia-Tai iravTMV fxdkLorTa, Kal ((ttl

fxepri aTTipavTa ttjs ovaias. -"Exci ovto>. YikelaTa apa ((ttI C

to. fjLiprj avTTJs. Tlkela-Ta fxivTOi. Tiovv; ((ttl tl avT&v o
ea-TL fxev fxipo^ rqs ova-Las, ovbev p.ivTOL fxepos; Kai its

dv [tol] tovto yivoLTo; 'AAA.' ei-jrep ye olfxaL (aTLV, dvdyKri

avTo dL, ^coa-TTep Sr 7/, V yi tl eTvaL, fxr]h(V be dbvvaTov. 5

'AmyKTj. Upbs aTTavTL dpa [(Kaa-TU)] tw tt)?' ovaias fiepei

Trpoaea-TLV to tv, ovk dTTokdiTOfxevov ovt a-fXLKpoTepov ovt

fXL(ovos fxepovs ovT dkkov ovhevos. OvT(a.^Apa ovv tv

ov TTokka\ov dfxa okov (cttl; tovto ddpeL. 'AAA' d6p& d
Kal dpSi OTL dbvvaTOV. MefxepLapidvov dpa, CLTTcp fxif dkov
aAAcoy ydp ttov ovbafxas afxa diTaaL toIs Trjs ovcTLas fxepeaLV

TTapeaTttL fxefxepLO-fxevov. Nat. Kal fU]V t6 ye fxepLaTOV

rj

TTokkif dvdyKrf elvaL ToaavTa da-aiTep fxepr].

'Ai^ayKTj. Ovk 5

dpa dkrjdrj dpTL kkeyofxev keyovTCS a>s iTkelaTa fxiprf rf ovaia

VVfxr]fxevr] etr]. ovbe ydp TrAeto) tov evbs vevep.r]TaL, dkk
Lo-a, b)s eoLKe, tw evr ovTe ydp Tb dv tov evbs dirokeLTTeTaL
(mre rb ^v tov ovtos, oAA' e^LO-ova-Qov bvo ovTe del TTapd
TTdvTa. TlavTdTTaaLv ovt(o (f^aCveTaL. To 'ev dpa avTO
KeKepfxaTLafxevov viTb Trjs ova-Cas TTokkd Te kol aiTeLpa to
TTkrjdos eaTLV. 4>aiyeTat. Ov fxdvov dpa Tb dv ev iroXka 5

eo-Tii', dAAa kol avTb Tb ^v virb tov ovtos bLavevefxrffxevov

TTokkd dvdyKrf elvaL. riai^Td-Trao-t fxev ovv.

Kai fxrfv oTi ye okov to fxopLa fxopLa, ireTTepaa-fxevov dv

etrf KaTa Tb okov Tb ev r] ov iTepLe\eTaL vtto tov okov Ta
fxopLa; ^AvdyKT].
'AAAct p.ifv t6 ye iTepLeyov tTepas dv eir/. 145
rTciis 8' ov;- To %v dpa dv ev tc ^oti ttov Kal 'TToAAd, Kat

oAoi^ Kat pidpLa, kol TTeTTepaap.evov kol dTTeLpov iTkrfOeL.'

4>ati^CTat. ^Ap ovv ovk, eTTeCiTep TTeirepacrfxevov, Kal ea-)(aTa

B T t?> roiovro ci. Hermann

4 Toi rovro : (Xtrfp B Tciirep : T
C5 fua-irepSxrvfp T
B : C 6 ^Katrry vel delendum vel fKdtrrorf
scribendiim susp. Stallbaum d^ 7ro/ T: irajj B ojua iracri
malit Heindorf 65 ^v tv B Procl. suppl. ev T tv tiv Thomson : : :

oy Stallbaum a.2 ttv secl. Heindorf



i45a nAATONOS
5 X'*^'
'A2'ay/C7j. Tt be; ei 6\ov, ov koI apxrjv av e)(06 Kai

fjiiaov Kal TeXevrriv; i] oXov t4 ti, oXov eti;ai 6,VV Tpiutv

TOVTOiv; KCLV Tov V OTiAJVV avT&v aTTOcrTaTfj, idekrjcrei. Iri
oKov elvai; Ov/c e^e\?j<7ei. Kat apxqv 877, <2s loi/cer, Kai
b reXeirr^i' Kal p.icrov ^xoi. hv to V. 'AAAa -"Exoi. p.7]v t6
ye \x(Tov Xcrov tG>v ka-yaTOiV a7re'xei* ov yap h,v 6,Xkoi9 ]xi(Tov

etr]. -Ov yap. Kat cr^ripLaTos brj tlvos, ws eotxe, roiovTor

ov [xeTexpi hv t6 ev, j/rot evdeos 77 orTpoyyvkov y rtro?

5 pLCLKTov e^ ap,<\)olv. Mere'xot yap &v.
'Ap' ovv ovTOis ex^^ ^^'^ avTo re kv kavT^ ^crTai, /cai ev
akk(o; U&s; T<av /ue/ooiv t:ov CKacrTov Iv rw oAo) ecrri /cat

ovhikv fKTOs Tov okov. Ovrco. riai^ra 8e ra jxepr] virb tov

c oAou 7repie'xerat; Nai. Kat p,i]v to. ye Trarra piipr] to.

avTov To V ecrrt, xai ovt( rt -nkiov ovTe ekaTTov ?/ irai^ra.

Ov ydp. -OvKovv Kal to okov to iv (cttiv; TiSts 8' ov;

Et apa iravTa to, ]iipr] kv ok(a Tvyx<i,vet ovTa, ((tti, 8e rci re
5 TrdvTa t6 ev Kal avT6 t6 okov, Tre/aiexerat 8e VTro tov okov
To. TrdvTa, viro tov kvos av nepUypiTO t6 'iv, KoiX ovTOis av
rjbr] t6 kv avT6 kv kavT^ et?/. <I>ati;erai. .'AAAa \xivTOi to

ye oAov av ovk iv rots p,ipe(Tiv (ttiv, ovtc iv Tracrii; oiJre

d iv TivL et ydp iv 7rp.(Tiv, dvdyKr] Kal kv kvi' ev tlvi, yap

kvl jur) 6v ovK av (tl ttov bvvaLTO ev ye aTraa-LV eiz^at* et 8e
TOVTO ixkv t6 ^V Tciv dlTdvTOOV k(TTi, t6 bk Okov kv TOVTla
p,r] VL, TTMS TL iv ye rots Tid^nv ere'orrat; Ovbap,S>s.
5 Oii8e ]ir]V iv rtcri tQv ]xepm>' et yap kv tlctX t6 okov eiT/,

t6 TTkiov dv kv tS> ikdTTOVL etr/, o eo-rty dbvvaTOV. ^Abv-

vaTov ydp. M^ 6v b' kv Trkioa-LV /xi/8' iv kvl /xt/S' kv diTaaL
rots jxipeaL t6 dkov ovk dvdyKr] kv kTipia tlvI elvaL r/ ]xrjbafxov

e ert eiyai; ^AvdyKT]. Ovkovv fxribap.ov fxkv 6v ovbkv dv et?/,

okov bk dv, eTreiS?/ ovk iv avTS) iaTtv, dvdyKrj iv aAAw

a5 S'; B 5' et T
i'] ov koI T
hai in ras. ovk B : a 7 rov :

Schleiermacher BT b i exoi &y

: ex<" ^ ^X<"^ &'... exe 1
rov . .

e 2 TJ T To B :d I rtvi] riffi Schleiermacher d 4 evt corr.

Ven. 189 eA B ev\ T : fvtffrai Par. 1836
: %v tffrai BT :


nAPMEMAIlii: I45e

(Ivai; riajT ye.

'Ht fxh''apa to (v 6\ov, (v aAAw ((ttLv

rj 8e To. TtavTa iiipr\ ovTa Tvyxavei, avTo iv kavT&' Kal

ovTOi To ^v avdyKr] avTo tc iv avT& (tvai, Kal kv (T^poj, 5

'ArayKrj.
Ovro) 87/ TT(f)VK6s To V ap ovK dvayKri /cai Kivelcrdai

KoX kfTTdvai; Ilfj; ^EoTTjKe jueV ttoi, eiTrep avTo fv kavT(a

kcTTiv' ev yap kv\ ov kox (k tovtov p.ij [XTal3alvov (V rw 146
avro) dv ei?], (v kavTQt. "Eorc ydp. To b4 ye fv rw avT^
aei ov eoToy 8?/7roi) dvdyKri dei eimi. Ilayu ye.^ Tt 8e; ro
(V erepo) det 02^ ov to evavTiov dvdyKrj jUTjSeVor' e^* ravral
eiyat, pLi^biTTOTe 8e or ey ro) avro) /XTjSe eo"rd^'at, ju,?/ eo-ros

8e Kti^eio-^at; OvTUis.
'AmyKr; dpa t6 ^v, airro re h>
5

eavT(a dei ov Kal kv kTip(a, dei KivelcrOaC re Kai eo-rdrai.

^^atyerai.

Kai fX7]v TavTov ye 8et etrai avT6 (axrrS) Kal (Tcpov

karjTov, Kal rois dAAots otxravT^as TavTov re Kat erepor eii^at, b
eiTrep Kai Ta TrpocrOev t:Ttov6v. IIws; Ilav ttov TTp6s

diTav wSe exfi, V Tavrov ((ttiv rj (Tfpov rj eav fxi] tovt^v

fjLrfb^ (Tfpov, fxepos dv etrj tovtov TTp6s 6 ovTOis \i, if s
ff

Trpos fxepos oXov dv eirj. <t>atyerat. -'Ap' ovv t6 ^v avT6 5

avrou fJLfpos ia-Tiv; Ovbafjiuts. Ov8' dpa wy Trpos fJiipos

aiiT^ avTov o\ov dv

'AAA' dpa eir/, Trpos kavT6 fjL^pos ov. Ov ydp olov
re. (Tepov eo-rti kvos t6 Ov Ou8'
iv; brJTa. C
dpa kavTov ye eTcpov dv (irf. Ov Et ovv
fi4vT0i. fJL-qre

Tpov fJLrfT dX.ov fJLifTe fxepos avrd kavTo TTp6sovk eoTLV,

dvdyKrf ifbrf TavTdv etvat avT6 kavT(a; Tt t6
'Ai^dyKrj. 8e;
kTepuidt dv avT6 kavTOv ev rw avrw ovtos kavTfa ovk dvdyKrf
airrd kavTov (Tfpov eTvai, eiTrep Kal kTpo>6i eo-rat;
^E/xotye
5

8oKet. Ovro) fxrfv f(f)dvrf ^xov t6 ^v, avTo re kv kavT(a dv

dfia Kox kv kTep(a.
'Ec^di^rj ydp. -"Erepoi^ dpa, &)s 0LKV,

ftrf TavTif dv kavTov t6 ^v.

"EotKer. Ti ovv; ei tov tl d
(Tipov (o-tlv, ovx kTepov dvTos Tpov iCTTaL;
'At'dyKrj.

a3 f(TThs BT : iixriiis vulg. b4 ^^ T : om. B c r ovh'

B : ovK T d I ef rov t G : d rovr\ B T


I46d nAATllNOS
OvKovv ocra fXT) kv kcmv, aTTavd^ erepa tov kvos, Kal to fv
T&v ju)/ v; riais 8' ov; "Erepor apa hv (irj to ti; t&v
5 aX\o)v. "ETcpov. "Opa 6ry* avTo re TavTov kox to iT^pov
ap' ovK ivavTia akkrikoi.s; YlSiS 8' ov; -'H ovv fdiXrjaeL

TaVTOV iv TW (T^piO 7] TO TpOV (V TavT^ TT0T (Tvai; OvK

e^eAT/cret. Et apa to (Tepov kv T(a avT(^ fxr]bTroT ta-Tai,
ovhiv ecrri TSiV ovtcov kv w ecrrty to cTcpov yjpovov ovbiva'
e ei yap ovtlvovv eiJj V ro), Klvov av tov xpovov kv tovt^
iir] To Tpov. ovx ovTcos; OvToos. 'E7rei8^ 8' ovhiiroTi
er rw avr^ ioTLV, ouSeTrore ev tlvl t&v ovtcov hv eir/ t6
Tpov. ^AX.r)6rj. apa OijT iv rois /u^ kv ovtc iv rw ert
5 eveCr] av to (Tcpov. Ov yap ovv. Ovk apa ro) ere'/3(ri y' av
etr; t6 ^v t&v fxr] ^v ou8e to. p.r] ty tov eros eTcpa. Ov ydp.
Ov8e /AT/y kavTols ye Tip av etr/ akXr\\oiv, ]j.i] ]iTiyovTa^

147 Tov cTepov. Tlws ydp; Et 8e jjl^tc avTols (Tcpd ia-TL ]Jir]Ti

rw ov av t6 eTcpa LvaL
kTep<a,

dWrjKcov;
'AAAa TtdvTr]

'EK</>evyot.
rjbr] K(j)evyoL

fx-qv ovbc tov kvos ye

]j.r]

/u.erexfi

TO. ]xr) ev ov yap av fxrj kv ^v, dXXd ttj] av kv ^v. ^AXrfOrj.

5 Ovb^ av dpL9]x6s eir/ apa to. ]xr] V' ovbc ydp dv ovtco /xr/ ev
^v TtavTdTiaa-Lv, dpLOfxov ye ^xpvTa. Ov ydp ovv. Tt 8e';

Ta fxr] kv tov kv6s dpa fxopLd ia-TLv; ^ Kav ovtco /ieretxf tov
evos rct fxr] ev; Meretxet'. Et dpa TrdvTr] t6 fxkv ev ia-TL,

b rd 8e fxr] ev, ovt dv ]x6pLov t&v /xr/ ^v t6 kv etr/ ovt dkov

ws ^xopmv ovtc av Ta ]xr] ^v tov eros ]x6pLa, ovTe dka ws
fxopiip rw kvL. Ov 'AAAa ydp. fxrfv <f)afiV Ta ]xr]T fxdpLa

]xrJT oAa ]xi]T TavTa

T(pa dAAr/Acoi; tmaOaL dAAr/Aois'.

.5 "Fi^f^afxev ydp. ^&fX(V dpa Kal t6 kv irp^s Ta fii] ey ovtcos

exoy t6 avT6 etrat aurots; ^u>]XV. To kv dpa, ws eoLKev,

Tp6v re T&v dXX(ov ia-Tlv /cai kavTov KaX tovt^v iKeivoLS re

Kat kavT^. Ktrdwevei <f)aivea-$aL ex ye tov X6yov.

d
7 t{)B : om. T 65 eVejTj] fv etrj B: firiT a2 ijSrj tiv

iK(p(iyoi B : ti.v fjSr) iK(f>vyoi T 8k4 ^v aWd B : ^ aWd T

a8 rrdvTTi B : rravrl T ba fjLopiaiv corr. Ven. 189: fxopiov BT:
fiopiov vulg. fx6pia T : fxopiovB b 5 tw T : t^ B


nAPMENIAHS 147C

'Ap' ovv Kal 6}ioi6v re koX avojxoLov (avT(a T Kal Tois C

aWois; -"lo-fos.
'E7rei5Tj yovv (Tcpov t5>v akkoiv i(f)dvrj,

Kal TokXd TTOV (Tpa av Kivov (trj. Ti fJLrjv; Ovkovv

OVTiOS Tp0V TOiV dWoiV, c5(r7rC/) Kal TdXka fKflVOV, Kal 0VT
IjmXXov ovt iJTTOv; Ti yap dv; Et dpa p.r\T fxdWov 5
/ix7/T rJTTov, 6/1X010)?. Ntti. OvKovv fj
iTcpov flvai TriTTOvdfV
T<av dX\u>v Kat TaXXa iKcCvov ixravTOis, Tavrrj tovtov dv
"KiTTOvOoTa (l(v To T ^v Tols dXXoLS Kttt rSAAa ro) kvL
riws Aeycis; ^Q.bc (Kaarov t&v ovojidTOiv ovk iiri tivi d
KoXeis; Eyooye. Ti ovv; to avTo ovofxa (tirois dv ttXco-
vdKis rj diTa^; "Eyfoye. YloTfpov ovv idv fikv oTra^ (tiTrjs,

(Kclvo TTpoa-ayopevcts oviTip icTTi, Tovvofxa, idv 8c TroXAaxiy,

ovK iKdvo; 7/ idvTc diTa^ idvTc TToXXdKis ravTov ovofxa 5

4>0iy^ri, TToXXrf dvdyKrj ae TavTov Ka\ Xiyav dei; Ti fxrfv;

OvKovv Ka\ To Tpov ovofxd i<mv iiri tivi; Yldvv yt.
Oray dpa avTo (f)diyyrf, idvTi diTa^ idvTC TToXXdKis, ovk C
7r oAAo) ovbe dXXo rt dro/xa^eis 7/ iKclvo ovTTfp rjv ovofxa.
AvayKrj. -"Oray brj Xiy(ofi.v otl iTipov fxkv raAAa rov kvos,
(Tepov be t6 ^v t(ov dXXoov, b\s to Tepov Itt6vt(s ovbiv rt
fxdXXov eir' dXXrj, dAA' eTr' iKeivi] Trj (f)V<ri avTO aei XiyofXiV 5
rja-TTep rjv Tovvofxa. Ildvv piev ovv. -^Hi dpa ^Tcpov t&v
aXXoiv t6 kv Ka\ raAAa tov kvos, Kar avTd t6 (Tepov TTfTTOV- 148
^cyat ovK dXXo dXXd t6 avT6 dv TTeiTOvd^s ftrf t6 kv rots
aAAoiy t6 bi ttov ravrw TreTroy^os ofxoiov ovyj.; Nai.
Ht brf t6 ^v Tpov T&v dXXcov TTiTTovdev (Tvai, Kar avTo
TovTo diTav aTTaaiv dfxoiov dv etrf diTav ydp aTrdvTutv iTcpov 5
ia-Tiv. "EoiKfv. 'AAAa fxrjv t6 ye dp.oi.ov rw dvop.oii^

(vavTiov. Nat. Ovkovv kox. t6 (Tfpov tS> ravroi. Kat

TovTo. 'AAAa p.rjv Ka\ tovt6 y i^dvrj, wy dpa t6 %v toXs

C5 Si/ B : om. T ea iKitvo B: kCivo T e6f]^^B:i5T:j

viilg. Kar avTo rh Thomson Kara ravrh B T KOTot rh ravrh
a I : :

Heindorf: Kara ravrhv rh StaWbaum koto t' a5 ri Waddell Kfirov-

:

Ofvai B T TrcirovOfv (Ivai in marg. rec. t

: a 2 Ij/ B T / vulg. ;

a 6 oA\a ij.))v B aAA' ifv T t^: avofioi<f\ rf 6fxoi<f> B : ruv avo/jLoiaiv T

a 7 ravr^ in marg. T out^ B T :


I48b nAATilNOS
b aA.Aoi9 ravTov. 'E^ar); ydp. TovvavTLov 5e ye Trddos ^(ttI
To eiyot ravTov rots aAAoi? to) Tpov (Ivai t&v dWoiv.
Yidvv ye.
^Ht ye [xrfv ^repov, op.oiov Nat.
i(f)dvr). ^^Ht

apa TavTov, eorat TovvavTiov

Nai.
dv6p.oiov jcara TsdOos roi

5 ojjLOLovvTi Tra^et. bijxoCov be ttou to (Tcpov; 'Avo-

fjLOia>a-i. dpa to TavTov, ij ovk (vavTiov lorai tw kTtpio
c "Eot/cei'. "OpiOiov dpa koX dv6p.oi.ov eorai to ^v tois aA.Aot5,

?7 y:>iey Tpov, op.oiov, 17 8e ravTov, dv6p.oiov. "Exci ydp ovv

hrf, ws OLKev, Kal tolovtov Xoyov. Kai ydp T^vh^ ^x^'-'

Tiva; ^Ht tovtov TreTrov^e, p.i] akXoXov TmiovdivaL, p.i]

5 dA.Xotoy 8e TreTroy^os /x?) dv6p.oLov, p,r] dv6p.OLov 8e ojxolov

LvaL' 8' aAAo TreTTOvOev, dWoLov, dXkoLov be &v dv6p.oLov

flvaL. fi

^A)\.r]6i] Ae'yets.~TavToi' Te dpa ov t6 kv Tots aAAots

Kai OTt ^Tp6v kcTTL, KaT dpi.(f)6Tpa Kal KaTa kKdTcpov, op.oL6v

d Te dv Lrj KOL dv6p.oLov Tois aAAots. Tldvv ye. Ovkovv

Kal kavT^ o)(ravT(tis, eTretTrep eTcpdv Te eauTou Kal TavTov
kavTia i(f)dvrj, Kar dp.<f)6Tpa Kal KaTa KdTpov 6p.0L6v Te

xat dv6p.oLov <f)avr](rTai; ^AvdyKrj.^

5 Tt 8e br]; Trept tov a7rTe<r^at to kv avTov Kal t5)V aAAcoy
KCLL Tov p.r] dTrT(rdaL irept tt&s Xl, crKoVet. SKOTro).' Auto
ydp TTov V avT(^ oAfa) ro ly (f)dvr] ov.
'O/a^&i?. OvKouy
Kat v Tots aAAoi? to ^v; Nat. '^Hi ixkv dpa kv toIs aAAot?,

e Tdv aAAwy ditTOLTO dv 17 be avTo kv kavT^, tS>v p.V dXX(ov

dr[LpyoLTo aTTT^crOaL, avro Se avTov d-jrroLTo dv kv kavT&
6v. I^aiveTat. Ovtco jxV brj diTTOLTO dv to kv avTov Te
Kai T&v dXkot)V. -"AirTotTo. Tt 8e rfjb^; dp" ov Trdv to

5 pJXkov d\ff(r$aL tlvos (f)$rjs 8et Ki(rdai Klv(^ ov /jieAAet

dTTTa-6aL, TavTr]V T-qv bpav KaT^xov 77 dv p.T KLvr]v r)

[e8/oa] r] dv Kr]TaL, drrT^TaL; 'AvdyKr]. Kai to kv dpa

et )ue'AAet airro avrov d\f/(r6aL, (f)^rjs 8et v6vs ^xera cauro

b 5 &fioiov B : 6fj.oiov T b 6 ri rahriv T roajT^v B : d. 3 koX

Kara T: :oi B e 6 Karexov T om. B adci. in marg. b
: : 67 tSpa
om. Bekker : eSpav Heindorf ^ B T fort, ^v
: j? : airrerai] ov
aif/erat Heinciorf

nAPMENIAHS 148 e

Ki(rdai., Ti]V ixofxevqv x<iipav Kariypv KCvi]9 h> ^ avro

fOTiv. Afi yap Ovkovv
ovv, bvo fiej/ ov to ^v TTOirja-dev 10

av TavTdi Kal kv hvolv ^wpaiy &p.a yivoLTo- lcos 8' hv h', 149
Ov yap 'H
17

ovK iOiKrja-d.; ovv. avTy] apa avdyKT] tQ hl

fxi/iT hvo flvai fxriTe &'7TT(r6aL avTio avTov.' *H avTi^.
'AAA'
ovbf ixr]v T&v S,k\(ov a^eTaL. Ti 877; "On, (fyafxcv, t6
/xeAAoy a\lfcrdaL ^(aph ov i^pe^rjs 8et Klv(o (IvaL ov jXiWeL 5
&\{/((rdaL, TpiTov 8e avT&v iv fxicr^a [xr]bv eimi. 'AAtj^^.
Avo &pa 8et t6 oXiyLcrTov (TvaL, et /xe'AAet &\}/ls etrai.' Aei.
'Eay 8e toXv bvoLV opoLV TpLTov iTpoayevqTaL (^rjs, avTo,

fXv TpCa ia-TaL, ai 8e a\}/LS bvo. Kat Nai. ovrco br] b

ad v6s TTpocryLyvo]XVOV \XLa /cat a\/^ts TrpocryLyviTaL, Kal
(rvix^aiviL Tas a\l/(Li tov TTXriOovi tG>v apLQ}xuiv fXLa (XdTTovs

eimt. w yap tcl iTp&Ta bvo eTrAeoi/eKTr/o-ey t&v a\j/((i)v 19

t6 TrAetw etrat t6v dpLd[x6v rj ras ayj/eLS, r&i to-<i> TOVT^a Kal 5
6 cTretra dpLdixos Tras TTacroiv tQv d\{/((av TrAeoi^eKret* ijbr]

yap t6 AotTroy afxa v re roi dpLdfx^ TrpocryiyviTaL koX /xia c

&\\/L9 rais dyf/(crLV. ^Opd&s. -"Oo-a apa eo-rty tcl ovTa t6v
dpLdjxov, det juia al d\l/LS eAarrous eto-ty avT&v. 'AAtj^^.
Ei 8e ye kv fxovov kcrTiv, bvds 8e /xt/ ccttlv, d\l/LS ovk dv
ftr]. n<Ss ydp; Ovkovv, (f)afXv, Ta dXXa tov eros ovt 5

^v icTTLV ovT p.iTiyiL avTov, iLTTfp ctAAtt io-Tiv. Ov ydp.'

OvK dpa livio-TLv dpL6fx6s iv rots aAAois, evos fxr] ivovTos iv
avTOLS. ncSs ydp; Our' apa iv i(rTL Ta dXXa ovTe bvo ovtc
oAAou dpL6fxov ^yovTa 6vop.a ovbiv. Ov. To ^v dpa fxovov d
eo-riy (v, Kal bvds ovk dv ei/. Ov (f)aiv(TaL. '^A^ls dpa
OVK (o-TLv bvolv fxr] ovTOLV. OvK (crTLV, -Oilr' dpa t6 %v t&v
aX\<t}V aTrrerat ovt Ta dXXa tov (vos, iTreiiTfp d\f/LS ovk

69 ivT : om. B e 10 yiip oiv T : yap B Troffi<T(ifv T : iroi-fifffi

tvB a 5 c(<|/erOai B : a\i/aadai T a6 &\p(a6ai B : &nTta6ai T

a7 oKlyKTTov T oKiyoffrbv B : a8 opoiv BT Procl, suppl. : 6vtoiv
(om. Tolv) Heindorf del. Bekker : : 6/i({/ojv Turicenses ^ItjsT : ef ^s B
b 3 Twv kpi^ixwv B T t}>v : apt6fi.hv Heindorf b 4 a^ptwv T iWuv : B
c I ?> B ?i/ T
: 07 ^vTTiv b Hv iffTiv T pr. B
: iv6vTos b :

1/ 6vTos pr. B 6vtos T : d 2 fv secl. Schleiermacher

PLATO, VOL. 11. 3


I49d nAATnNOS
5 ^(TTiv, Ov yap oSy. Ovrco 6r) Kara Ttavra ravra to ^v
T&v T 6.\K(t)v Kol kavTov airTCTaC t koI ovy^ ^TTTcrat.
"EoiKev.
'Ap' ovv Kal tcrov ((ttI Kal &vi(rov avria tc Kal rots
^A.Aots; ITcS?; Ei fj.(i^ov etrj to kv rj roAAa rj ekaTTov,
e 77 av ra aAAa tov kvos /xet^co r/ eAcirrco, apa ovk hv rw piev

^v iivaL To kv Kal raAAa aAAa tov kvbs ovt tl ixeC^(o

ovT TL X.(iTT(a hv eiTj dAArjAcov avrats ye rai;raty rats
ovcrCaLs; dAA' et fxev Trpos tS) TOLavTa etz^at kK(XTpa icroVryra

5 (xoLcv, icra hv etry irpos aAArjAa* et 8e tcl ixev piiycdos, t6

8e aixLKpoTrjTa, tj Kal niycOos jLtey t6 ^v, crixLKpoTrjTa 8e
raAAa, OTTOTep^a /utey ro) eiSet joteye^os irpocreLrj, juet^oy &v
eir/, 0) 8e crp.LKp6Tris, (KaTTOv; 'AyciyKr]. Ovkovv icTTOv

yi TLV TovT(t) etbrj, t6 re ixeyedos Kal r) crixLKp^Trjs; ov yap

10 6,v TTOv ixri SvT ye kvavTm re dAArjAoty eirrjy Kat kv roiy
150 oZcTLV eyyLyvoL(rdr]v. ITws yap av; Ei apa ev r ez^i

kyyCyviTaL, kv oAo) hv kv ixip^L avTOV

ez^etrj.

(TixLKp6Tris

'Ai^ciyKrj. ^Ti
rJTOL
8' et ey oAo) eyyCyvoLTo;
rj

ov^xj, rj e^
to-ou hv ro) ez^i 8t' oAou avTov TiTaixivr) eirj r; Treptexoucra

5 auro'; Arjkov Srj. -'Ap' oSi' ouk e^ to-ou p.V ovcra r) crfXL-

Kp^Trjs rw kvl Xcrri hv avr&) etrj, Treptexoucra 8e /xe^^tov;

IIcSs 8' ou; Aumroi' oSi' crixLKp^TriTa Xcrriv ro) eti^at r/ /xet^co

Kai ixeycOovs re Kat dAAa

^'ASwaroy. 'Ey
rtyc)?, TTp(XTTLV To, to^c^rr/ros',

b /x^ ra eaur^s; ixkv SA^ apa roi ert ovk

hv eir/ crixLKp^Trjs, dAA' eiTre/), ey p.ipL.
Nat Ov8e ye ev
Trayrt av ro) ixcpeL' ei 8e /Arj, raiyra 770tr/cret ctTrep 7r/)os to
okov L(rri (TTaL ri ixl(u)V tov ixipovs iv w hv det (vfj.
5 'AytiyKr/. OvbcvC Trore apa kvicTTaL t&v ovtoov (rixLKp6Tr]s,

IxrJT V ixepeL ixrJT ev oAcp eyyLyvop.evri' ovbe tl ecTTaL

d8 post iffov rasura quattuor litterarum in B e i a5 tSaa.o T

ourcb iAAo B 63 i\drTw T &\\o, eAaTTw B : e 5 tJ) Se Par. 1810
ri 5^ BT 6 9 76 al. re B T :a 5 oSv B : om. T /jikv odcra T :

fifvovcra B b 2 ouSe ^e Hermann oi^Te ye : B oiki yt T o6roi ye

: :

Heindorf b3 Troffiffei T : ttoj^o-j? B b5 evftrrai T : Iv eo-rai B


nAPMENIAHS I50b

(TfjLiKpov TTkrjv avTrjs a-fjiLKpoTrjTOi. OvK OLKV. Ovf apa

fieyedos kvi(TTaL iv avT^' ju,er^ov yap av tl etr} aAAo Kal
TrKrjv avTov pi.eye6ovs, iKclvo iv w to piiyedos eveCrj, Kal c
Tavra (rpnKpov avTia ovk ovtos, ov avdyKr} VTrepex^LV, idvircp
pAya' TOVTO 8e dhvvaTov, eiTfLbri a-p.LKp6Tr]s ovhap.ov VL.
fl

'AAtj^^. 'AAAa fxi]v avro fj.iy(6os ovk dkkov fxelCov rf

avTrjs (TfjuLKpovrfTos, ovhi a-fiLKpoTrfs dXkov ikaTTOV rj avTOV 5

fxeyidovs. Ov Ovtc ydp. dpa Ta dXka /xeiX''^ tov kvos

ovbe eAdrr&), fxrfTe fxiye^os firfTf. (rfXLKpoTrjTa expvTa, ovt
avro) ToijTO) Trpbs t6 ^v ^x^tov rrfv bvvap.LV Trfv tov imep- d
^X^t^ 'fctt T;7repexeo-0at, dAAa Trpos dAATyAco, oiire av t6 ^v

TovTOLV ovbe tQ>v dkkoiiv fxcL^ov dv ovb^ ikaTTov etTj, fxrjTC

fJLiyedos fxrfTc a-p.LKp6TriTa ^X^^' Ovkovv (fjaLveTaC ye. -'A/o'

ovv, ei /liTjre /xet^oy /XTjre ekarrov t6 ev tujv dkkoiv, dvdyKrf

avro K(Cv(ov p.rfTi vinpiyjeLV fxrfT^ VTrepix^adaL;
'Aydyxrj.
5

OvKovv t6 ye /x?jre VTTepixov p,rfT VTrepiyofxevov TTokkrf

dvdyKrf e^ to-ow etyat, e Xaov 8e ov taov etyat. nws ydp
Kai
ov; p.r]v kol airrd ye t6 kv 7Tp6s kavT6 ovtcos dv expL' e
fXT^i fxiy6os iv kavT^ p.rfT crfXLKpoTrfTa ixov ovt dv VTTep-
iyoLTO ovT av virepixoL kavTov, dkk^ e ta-ov ov Xcrov dv cXrf

eairro). Yldvv fuv ovv. To kv dpa kavT(o re Kat roty

dAAots to"02; dv (Xrf. tati^erat. Kai fxrfv avro' ye iv kavT^ 5

Sv Kal irept eauro dv (Xrf e^co^er, Kai TrepLixov p.ev fxel^ov

dv kavTov eXrf, TrepLexop.evov he ekarTov, kcu ovrco /xet^oi' dv 151
KOL ikaTTOv fXrf avT6 kavTov t6 ev. EXrf ydp dv. Ovkovv
Ka\ Tdbe dvdyKr), fxrfbev etyat eKT^s tov kv6s re Kat tSjv
dkk(nv ;YlSts ydp ov; 'AAAd pi.r}v Kal elvaC ttov 8et t6 ye
6v det. Nat. Ovkovv t6 ye ev r<j) 6v iv p.eCCovL eo-rat 5

likaTTOV ov; ov ydp dv dAAcoy eTepov iv kTip(i> eirj. Ov

ydp. 'ETretS^ 8e ovhev eTepov ecrTL x^^P'? t^^ dAAcoy Kat

b7 avTTJs B : ai/TTJs rrjs T 2 avr^ BT : avrov vulg.

d. I avrii rovTO) T : avr^ rovr<f pr. B extrov T : 4x.^ra) B
d3 Kttl BT : T Kal vulg. ad rh euT : ouTy ivB e3 tiv ftri B :

tdd elV; T e 5 7 T : Te B a3 t<$5 BT : t^ vulg. &$ ^v

ry B : f; r(p pr. T

I5ia nAATi2N02
Tov kvos, 8et 8e avTct. iv ro) elvat, ovk avdyKt] yjbr] iv aAA?j-
Aois elvai,, rd re oAAa iv rw kvl Kal t6 ^v kv rois aAAots,
b 1) ^rjbafxov ilvai; <l>aiVcrai. -"Ori ix\v apa rb ^v iv toIs
aAAois (vecTTi,, fJieC^a) hv etrj to. aAAa tov kvos, TTepUxovTa
avTo, To 8e ^v ekarrov t&v aAAcoi', TTepieyoixivov otl bk to.
aAAa kv rw kvC, to ^v t5)V akkcav KaTO, tov avTov koyov
5 ixelCov av eir], Ta 8e aAAa tov kvbs eAarro). "EoiKfv. To
^v apa tcrov re Kal pLil^ov Kal ekarTOV icrTLV avTO re avTov
Kal tG)V dkkoiv. ^^aiyerai. Kat fji.rjv etrrcp ixelCov Kal eAar-
Tov Kal t(Tov, tcrcav &v etr; ixTp(ov Kal irkei.ovctiv /cai kkaTTovoov
C avrw Kat rots aAAot?, eiretS^ be ixeTpcav, Kal ixepSiv. H&s
6' oi; "laiiiv ixkv dpa ixeTpcov ov koI Trketovcov Kal eAar-
Tovcov, Kal dpi.6iJ.(a ekaTTOv dv Kal Trkeov eir/ avTO re avTov
Kal T&v dkk(ov Kal t(Tov avT(a re Kai roij aAAots KaTo.
5 ravra. ricSs; ^D^vnep ixeiCdv eo-rt, TrAeioVcoy ttou Kal
IxiTpctiv dv et?7 avr&v, o(r(av 6e piiTpcov, Kal ixep&v Ka\ 5>v
ekaTTov, 0)cravT(ji)S' koI ols taov, KaTa Tairrd.' Ouroos.
OvKovv kavTOV ixei^ov Kai ikaTTov ov Ka\ tcrov taoov dv etrj

d jueV/scoy Kat nkeiovoiv Ka\ ekaTTovoov avrw, eTretS?) bc /xeVpoor,

Kat piep&v; Vl&s 8' ov; "lcroiv pikv dpa fxep&v ov avT^
tcrov dv t6 Trkrjdos avT^ etr/, TrAetoVcoy 8e Ttkiov, kkaTTovoov

8e ekaTTOv t6v dpi6p.6v avTov. iJati^erat.^ ^Ovkow Kai

5 TTpos Takka oxravTOis ^^et t6 ev; oTi ixev ixu^ov avTG>v

(f)a(vTai, dvdyKrj itkiov eimt Kai tov dpi.dix6v avT&v otl

8e crixiKpoTepov, ekaTTOv otl 8e tdov ixeyeOeL, tcrov Ka\ t6

Trkrjdos elvaL toIs akkoLs; 'AmyKr/. Ovto) 8t) a?, d>s

e eoLKe, t6 kv kol tcrov koX iTkeov Ka\ ^kaTTov t6v dpLdix6v

avTo re auroi; lcrrai Kat t5)V dkXo)v. "Eo-rai.

'A/a' ovv KoX xpovov ixeTe\eL t6 ev, kcu ecrTL re Kai yi-
yveTai ve(aTep6v re Kai TTpe(rj3vTepov avTO re eaurou Kai t&v
5 ^AAcoy, Kat ovtc vecaTepov ovTe Trpecr^vTepov ovTe kavTov
ovTe tS)v dkkoov, xpoVou ixeTeyov; Ylm; 'Etrat ixev itov

c3 ixfv B : om. T c 7 TauTa T : TaOra B


nAPMENlAHS I5ie

avro) vTTap\(i, etirep h' ((ttlv. Nai. To bk elvuL aWo tC

fOTiv rj p.e6^is ovarias /xcra xpovov tov TrapovTos, cocnTep

To ^v fxeTa Tov TrapeXrjXvOoTos Kal av t6 icrTai juera tov 152
piikXovTos ovcTias eori Kocvcavia; "EaTL ydp. Mtrexft fJ-^v

6.pa xpovov, eLTTep Kal tov cTvaL. Udvv ye. Ovkovv Tropevo-

p.evov Tov xpovov; Nat.

'Aei apa Trpea-^vTepov yCyvfTaL
kavTov, eLTTep TTpoip)(eTaL KaTo, xpovov.' -AvdyKr]. .'Ap' ovv 5

fJLfpLVrnxeOa otl vcMTepov yLyvofxevov to TTpea-^VTepov iTpecr^v-

Tepov yCyveTaL; Me/xvrifjLeOa. Ovkovv cTTeLbr] TTpea-^vTepov

kavTOv yCyveraL to ev, vecoTepov av yLyvofxevov kavTov TTpe-

a-^vTepov yCyvoLTo; 'Ayay/crj. TCyveTaL fxev hrj vediTcpov b

re KoX TTpea-^VTepov avTov ovtco. Nai. Etrri 8e TTpea-^v-

Tepov ap ov\ oTav KaTa tov vvv xpovov rj yLyv6p.evov tov

jxeTa^v Tov qv re Kal ^a-Tai; ov ydp ttov TTopevoixevov ye
eK Tov TTOT^ els To eireLTa vTrep^-qa-eTaL to vvv. Ov ydp, 5

^kp ovv ovK eiTCa^eL TOTe tov yCyvea-QaL TTpea-^vTepov, eTrei-

bav r^ vvv evrvxjl' 'f"^ ov yCyveTaL, dAX' l<rrt tot ybrj c
TTpea-j^VTepov; TrpoLov yap ovk dv iTOTe Kr\(\)6eCr\ vtto tov
vvv. To yap TTpoiov ovrois ^x^'- ^^ dfX(j)OTe po>v e(f)aTTTear6ai,
8'
Tov re vvv kol tov eiTeiTa, tov fxev vvv d<f)Lfxevov, tov
eireLTa eTTLkafx^avofxevov, fxeTa^ dfx(f)OTep(i)V yLyvofxevov, 5

Tov Te eireLTa Kal tov vvv.- ^Akr]6rf. Ei be ye dvdyKT] fxy

TTapekdelv to vvv ttolv to yLyvofxevov, eTreLbdv KaTa tovto t/,

eTrCayeL de\ tov yCyvea^aL Kal ea-TL TOTe tovto otl dv Tvxy d
yLyv6p.evov, ^airerai.' Kat to kv dpa, oTav Trpea-jSvTepov
yiyvdfxevov evTvxr] rw vvv, eTrea-x^v tov yCyvea-dai /cat eo-rt

TOTe TTpea-^vTepov. Udvv fiev ovv. Ovkovv ovirep eyCyveTO

'TTpea-^VTepov, tovtov Kal ea-TLV eyCyveTO b\ avTOv; ^Nai. 5

"Etrri 8e t6 Trpea-^vTepov veoiTepov TTpea-fBvTepov; .^'Eo-rty.

Kai ve(j)Tepov dpa TOTe avTov ecTTL t6 ev, otav TTpecr^v-

Tepov yLyvofxevov einrvxrf r<S vvv, ^AvdyKr], To ye fxrfv

a2 KOtvwvia BT : Koiv(i>viai vulg. fifTfXfi B : /xtrfxttv T

ba airov^^ iv rov B : avrov* T d 3 t^ vvv T rh. vvv
: B d 4 ov-
iTfp T : ov irtpt B
PI.ATO, VOL. II. 3#*

153 e nAATONOS
e vvv det Trdpe(TTL T<a kvl bia iraiTos tov eimf i<rTi, yap dei
vvv oTavTtip .ricSy yap ov; 'Aei dpa eo-ri re Kal ylyvcTai
fj.'

irpicr^vTipov kavTov koL vc<aTpov to ^v. "'EotKer. nAetoo 8e

Xpovov avTo kavTOv ^ yCyvcTai,
^(ttlv rj tov iaov; Tbv ta-ov.

5 i'AAAa fxriv tov ye Xcrov xpovov 17 yiyv6y.evov ^ ov rriv

avTTjv TjkiKCav Ix^*' nciis' 8' ov; Tb 8e ttji^ avT-qv rjMKCav

iyov ovTi TTpea-IBvTepov ovTe v<aTp6v kariv. Ov ya.p.

To %v apa Tov tcrov yjiovov avTo kavT^ koI yiyv6p.ivov Ka\
ov ovT v<aTpov ovT 7rpa-j3vTpov koVTOV koTiv ovhk yCyv-
10 rat. Ou \xoi 8oKet. .Tt 8e; roSy dA.Awi'; Ovk ^xat Aeyetr.

153 To'8e ye fxriv Ix^^^ Ae'yety, Srt rd dAAa tov kv6s, etirep

^Tpd ka-TLV, dAAd /irj Tpov, TrAeio) eo-riv kv6s' Tpov fxkv
yap ov V hv r^v, ^Tpa 8e ovTa TrAetcD kvos ka-Ti koa. TrkfjOos

av ^x*"* "Exot yccp dv. ITA^^os 8e ov dpi.dp.ov iTkeCovos

5 av jaerexot ?/ tov kv6s. Tl5>s 8' ov; Tt oZv; dpLdfxov

(f)ri(rop.V Ta TrAetcD yCyvcrdaC re /cai yeyovevai, Trpdrepoy, rj

Ta kkdrro); ^Td kkdTToo. ^To oAtyto-roy dpa TTpwTov tovto

b 8' eoTt rd er. rj ydp; Nat. ndyrcoy dpa t6 ^v Trp&Tov
yiyov T<i)V dpi.9fj.6v kx6vT<av' Ix^' ^^ ^**^ rdAAa Trdi^ra

dpiOfxdv, eiirep dAAa Kal fxrj dkko kcrrCv. "'Exfi ydp.

UpiaTov 8e ye olfxai yyov6s TrpdTcpov ykyove, rd 8e dAAa
v(rTpov, TO. 8' va-Tpov yeyovoTa v(aTpa tov TrpoTepov
5

yeyovoTos' kcu ovrcos hv etr/ rdAAa v(aTpa tov kv6s, t6 8e

ty Trpa-^VTpov t&v dAAcor. Eirj ydp dv.

Ti 8e rd8e; dp' dv eirj t6 ^v Trapd <f)va-LV Tr}v avTov

C yyov6s, 17 obijvaTov;- 'AhvvaTov. 'AAAd p.rfv fxiprf ye Xov
k<j)dvr} rd ^v, ei 8e fUpt], Kal dpyjfv kol TkVTr}v Kal fXcrov.

Na^. OvKovv TrdvT(i)V irp&Tov dpxrj yCyvTaL, Kal avTov

Tov kvos Kat kKda-TOV t&v dkk(*)V, Kal fXTd rrfv dpyrjv Kal

5 roAAa irdvTa fxiypL tov Tkkovs; 'T^ fxrfv; Kai pJifv fxdpLa

y (j)rf(rofXV ravT' clvaL rrdvTa rdAAa tov dkov re Kai kv6s,

e 9 ou8f Heindorf oirt B T : a 7 oXiynTrov Tb : oXiyoffrhv pr. E

Procl. suppl. bs Tci S' Z<TTepov B : ra 5' HffrtpaT b6 rdi,\\a
delendum ci. Stallbaum
 nAPMENIAHS 153C

avTo be Keivo iifxa rj) TeXevrf] yiyovivai h' re Kal okov.

<I>7/(ro/xev yap. .Tt AfVT?; 8e yc oi/xat vVraror yiyrerat, rovro)
8'
&iM To tv TT4<l>VKe yiyvicrdaL' &(tt dTrep avayKt] avTo to d
hf fjLr) TTapa (f^va-iv yCyv<T0ai, afxa TfXevTf] hv yeyovos varaTOv
av T&v aXXoiv 7re<^UK09 ett] yLyvea-dai. *PaCvTai. Newre/ooi;
apa tS>v aXXoov t6 ev ia-Ti, to, 8' &\Xa tov kvos Trpia-fivTcpa.
OvTOis av fxoi (^aCviTai. Ti 8e hr\; apxrjv ri aWo fxipos 5

oTtow Tov v6s rj aAAou otovovv, kavmp fiepos y aXXa fJLi]

fiipt], OVK avayKalov ^v (Tvai, fxepos ye ov; ^AvdyKT].

OvKOvv t6 ^v afxa re rw Trpwro) yiyvofxiv(a yCyvoiT &r Kat
apia ro) Seurepo), Kat ovbv6s aTtokiC-niTai t&v akk(t}V yiyvo- e
fxfvoov, oTLTTfp &v Trpoa-yCyvrfTaL oT^aovv, ^wy &v Trp6s t6
ia-)(aTov 8Lk66v okov ey yivr]TaL, ovt fxiaov ovTe irpdTOv

OVT (T-)(^dTOV OVT oAAoU Ovbv6s dlTokfL^fidcV iv TT] yivicTiL.

^kkrfdr]. riao-ty apa rots aAAots Trfv avTXfV rfkLKCav lo-xei t6 5

iV uta-T et fxi] Trapa <f)varLV Tri^VKiv avT6 t6 iv, ovt

npoTfpov ovTi varepov t&v akk(ov yeyov^s hv eir;, dAA' afxa,
Kal KaTCL TovTov t6v koyov t6 V Ttav &kk(tiv ovT TTpfa-j3vTpov 154
ovT v(aTpov av fXr], ov8e raAAa tov evos' Kara 8e t6v
TTp6(rdv TTp<r^vTp6v re Kai v((aTpov, Kal raAAa eKcCvov
b)a-avTOiis. IJdvv fxkv ovv.- ."Eo-rt fxfv brf oijtoos ^xov re Kat
yeyovos. dXka tC av Trept tov yCyvea-dai avT6 TTpea-jSvTcpov 5

re Kat V(aTpov tS>v dkkoiv Ka\ raAAa tov kvos, Kal /XTjre
v(aTpov fxr]T TTpea-^vTfpov yCyvccrdaL; dpa axriTep Trept tov
LvaL, ovTO) Ktti TTept Tov yCyv(r6aL ^X^' V kTipois; Ovk
\o) kiyLV.- 'AAA' eyo) To^rovbc ye* et Kat eorti; TTpia-jBvTepov b
Tpov Tpov, yCyva-6aC ye avro TTp<T^vTpov TL t) ws t6
TTp&TOV vdvs yv6fXV0V bLr]VyK Trj ^AtKta OVK dv TL

bvvaLTo, ovb^ av t6 v(aTpov ov ^tl V(aTpov yCyv(T6aL'

dvCcroLs yap la-a TTpoa-TL6fXva, XP^^V "^^ '^^^ aAAo) OT^aovv, 5

C8 Se 7 otixai T : i\ oJfiai 7 B di rh ty post avrh secl. ci.

Heindorf da TA<wrt)BT: ttj tAj-7J al. 63 %v y4ini)rai
T : tyyfyTjrai B vptirov oijTf iax<i-Tov B : ^<rx<iTow oijTt irptirov T
bI 1 Kal ia-Tiv scripsi Sti i /col ^(Ttiv
: T : koI ^(ttiv Srt B
b2 7 T : Tf B b4 o5 Tb T : airrh B


154 b nAATXlNOS
i(Tut Troiei bLa(f>ipiv act o(T<aiTp hv t6 irpQTov bieviyKrf.
riws yap ov; Ovk apa t6 ye ov tov [kvbs] ovtos yiyvoiT

C 6.V TTOTC Trp(rl3vTpOV Ovbe V(aTpOV, lTTp i<rio bia(f)pt. dei

TTjv rfXiKiav akX.* <tti. koX yyov 7rp(r^vTpov, to b

V(aTpov, yLyvTai 8' ov. ^PsX-qOy]. ^Kat to V apa ov t6v

aWdiv ovTOiv ovT Trp(r^vTp6v TTorc ovT v(aTpov yCyvTai..

5 Ov yap oZv. "Opa b\ ei T^8e 'npcr^vTpa at v(aTpa

yCyvTai. -11^ brj; .'Ht t6 t ^v twv akkcov (f)dvr] irpc-

cr^vTcpov Kat ToAAa tov v6s. ^Tt oZv; -"OTaj; to iv t&v

aXkoov T:p(r^vTpov ttX.lu> ttov yjp6vov yiyov^v r\ to.

d oAAa. ^Nat. riaXty

fj,

8?) (tk6ttL' av jrXeWi Kat eXtiTTOi^i

Xp6v(a TTpo^rTLd&fxcv tov Lcrov \p6vov, 5,pa t<o i<ra> ]iopl(o

bLo((rL TO itXov tov iXaTTOvos rj a-ixLKpoTp<a; ^HLKpoTcpco.

OvK apa ea-TaL, otltt^p to TTpStTov r^v TTpbs TaXAa r}kLKL(L

5 bLa(\>pov ro ^v, tovto koX eis to TTLTa, a\X.a Xa-ov Aa/i/Saror

Xp6vov TOLS aWois ckarTov dei tt) rj\LKL(i 8tot<Tet avr&v i]

7Tp6Tpov r] ov; ^Nat.. Ovkovv t6 ye HkaTTOv bLa<\)pov

e ^AlKia 1Tp6s TL T] TTp6Tp0V V(aTp0V yiyVOLT av r] V T(0
TTp6a-0V rrpbs exeti^a TTpbs h ^v TTpa-^vTpov TTp6Tpov;
NewTepor. Et 8e Klvo V<aTpov, ovk KLva av tcl akka
npbs To kv TTpo-^vTpa rj TTp6Tpov; Ilavv ye. ^To ]XV

B V(aTpov &pa y^yovbs TTp(r^vTpov yiyvTaL iTpbs to iTp6-

Tpov yyov6s T Kal TTp^a-^vr^pov ov, Ho-tl 8e ovbeiTOTc
TTp^a-jSvTcpov, akXa yiyvTai det Kivov TTp^a-jivT^pov iKclvo
]iV yap TtI t6 V(aTpov iTTLbibaa-LV, t6 8' em t6 TTpca^v-
155 Tpov. r6 8' av iTpca-^vTcpov rov yecoTepov V(oTpov yiyv^raL
b)aavr(os. I6jfr yap avroLV ls r6 ivavriov ro ivavriov
dAAT^Aotr yiyv(r6ov, t6 ]XV v(6rpov iTp^^r^vrepov rov
tTp^a^vripov, r6 8e TTp^cr^vTcpov V(OTpov rov V(or4pov'

5 yv4(r9aL b^ ovk hv oto) Te etTrji'. et yap yivoLvro, ovk

hv ^TL yiyvoLvro, dAA' etey av. vvv 8e yiyvovrai fxiv

b 7 iv in ras. B ivhi secl. Schleiermacher c i oiSh B :

oHre T C 2 tJ 5e T : r^Se B 03 yiyvfrai T : om. B a,a rh

ivavrlov bis scripsit T : semel B


nAPMENIAHS I55a

7Tp(r^VTpa aA.A?/Aa)y koI v<aT(pa' t6 plkv kv tG>v aWutv

V<aTpov yiyveTai., otl Trp^cr^vTipov (f)dvri ov Kal irpoTepov
yfyovos, to. Se aAAa tov kvos iTpicr^vTfpa, oti va-Tcpa b
yiyov. KaTo. 8e tov avTov \6yov koll roAAa ovto) Trpos
t6 V ta-\i,, (TTdbriTrep avrov Tip^a-^vT^pa i(pdvri Kal npo-
repa ytyovoTa. 4>aiyrai yap ovv ovtcos. Ovkovv if /xer

ovbev Tpov (Tepov TTpecrjSvTcpov yiyveraL ov6e V((aTpov, 5

KaTO. t6 ia-(a dpLdfx^ dAA^Aa)^ det hia^ipnv, ovt to kv
tS>v aX\()v irp(r^vTepov yiyvotT av ov6e V(aTpov, vre
raAAa tov (vos'
fj
8e dAAw det p.opm 8ta^e'/3eiy dvdyKri
Ta TipoTipa T(av v(rTp(ov yv6pLva Kal to. vo-repa t&v C
TTpoTp())v, TavTi] hr\ dvdyKrj Trpa-^vTpd re Kat V(aTpa
d\\ri\(ov yiyv(r6ai Td re dAAa tov kvos Kal t6 v tG)V
d\\(ov; Tldvv /xey ovv. Kard 8t; iTdvTa raura t6 kv avTd
T avTOv Kal tS)V dWiav 7Tp(r(SvTpov Kal v(aTpov eo-rt 5

re Kai yl.yvTai, /cat ovt Trp^a^vT^pov ovt V(aTpov ovt

(rTi.v ovT yiyvTai ovt ovtov ovt tS)v d\\(t)v. Ylav-
reAcSs pkv ovv. .'E7rei8T) 8e xp^vov f;tere'x^ei t6 ^v koX tov
TTpa-j3vTp6v re koi V(aTpov yiyvcaOai., ap' ovk dvdyKr\ kou. d
TOV TTOre p.T\LV Kttt TOV ilT^LTa Kal TOV VVV, LTTp yj)6v0V

HTyL; ^\vdyKr\. "^Hv dpa t6 V koI iaTL Kal a-TaL KCtx

yiyvTo Kal yiyveTat Kal yvri(rTaL. Tt fMriv; Kat &v eiJj

TL Kiv(a Kat Kivov, Kal T/y xat eoTty xai ^crraL. Xldw 5

ye. Kai eiri o-r>;/xr; hr] Lr] dv avTov Ka\ h6^a Koi aLO-drja-is,

etire/) Kai vvv rjfx^is Trept avrou iTdvTa TavTa TTpdTToiiV.

Op6G)s Ae^yeis. Kat ovop.a 8t; Kat Ao'yos eo-rtf avT(a, Kal
6vop.aCTai Kal \yTaL' Ka\ oaaiT^p koX TTp\ to. dWa t&v e
rotourojy ruy^dyei ovTa, kol 7re/)i t6 V crTLV. YlavT\S)S
]lV OVV \L OVTOiS.

Ert hr] t6 TpiTOV \yo)]XV. to kv l (rTLV olov

hL\r]\vdapLv, dp^ ovk dvdyKT] avro', ^v re ov Ka\ iToWd Ka\ 5

b 2 oStw B : Toxntf T e i irpl ri &\\a b : irtpl tSaAo T :

piTTcb &\\a B


155 e nAATliNOS
/xT/re V jJiijTe TtoWa Kal /lAcrexor xpovov, otl \xkv ^cttiv (V,
ovcrias /xerexety TioTi, ort 8' ovk <ttl, fxi] yi.eT\'iiv av ttotc

ovaias; ^AvdyKt]. .'Ap' ovv, otc /xerexfi olov re eo-rai

t6t fxr] )aere'xetr, 7*; otc /xt/ /xere'xei, \xeTi\iiv; Ovy^ olov
lo Ti. .'Ey aAAo) apa XP^^V fxeTiyjei Koi kv aAAw ov /xere'xef
oiJrw ya/3 ai' ]x6vm tov avTov ]i(Ti\0L re Kat ov fxeTfxoi-
156 'Opd<as.
OvKovv eo-rt Kat ovtos xpovos, 6t ]XiTdKa]x^avei
Tov uvai KoX 6t aTraAAarrerat avTov; rj iras oXov re eo-rai
TOT ]x\v exety to avT6, totc 6e ]xr] exeti', eav ]xrj TtoTi kox

Xafx^dvj] avTo Koi d(f)Cr\; Ovha^xm. To hr] oixrCas /Aera-

5 Xafxfidvuv dpd ye ov yCyvca-dai. KaAets; ."EycDye. To 8e

a7raAAarreo"^at ova-Cas dpa ovk d-ndkkvcrOaL; Kat Tidvv ye.
To ^y hr'], ws eotKe, \a]x^dvov re Kat
*Ey dcf^ikv ovcrCav yCyveTaC-
b re Kat d7ro'AAurai. .'AvdyKTj. 8e Kat TroAAd ov Kal
yi.yv6]XVov Kal dtToKkvfXivov dp ov\, oTav ]XV yCyvr]Tai ev,

t6 TToAAd etyat aTrdAADrat, oTav 8e TToAAd, rd v (IvaL

aTrdAAurat; Tldvv ye. *Ey 8e yLyv6]xevov koX TroAAd a/)'

5 ovK dvdyKr] bLaKpCvea-QaC re Kat a-vyKpCvea-QaL; rioAATy ye.

Kal ]xr]v dv6]xoL6v ye Kat 6]xoLov oTav yCyvrfTaLf 6]xoLovcr6aC
re Kat dvo]xoLova6aL; Nat. Kat otov ^xcX^ov Ka\ (kaTTov
KOL Lcrov, av^dva-6aC re Kat cfi^CvfLv Kal icrovcr6aL; Ovrcos.
C "Orai' 8e klvov]X(v6v re XaTr^TaL Ka\ oTav kcTTos em to
KLVLcr6aL /xera/3dAA7/, ^ei S^ttou avrd ye /jir/8' ev ert XP^^V
elvaL. IToi)? 67/;^ ^"Eo-rdy re irpoTcpov va-Tepov KLV^LcrdaL kcu

TTpoTcpov KLVov]Xvov vaT^pov kcrrdvaL, dvV ]xkv TOV ]X(Ta-

5 jSdkkfLv ovx otdv re eo-rat raura rrdo-xety. H&s ydp;

Xpdvos 8e' ye ouSeis (cttlv, kv w ri oX6v re d]xa ]xr]T KLVLcr6aL

/x7/re eo-rdi^at.^ Ov ydp ovv. .'AAA' ovbe ]xr]V /xera^dAAei

dvV Tov ]XTal3dkkLV. OuK etKds.ndr' ovv /jtera/3dAAet;
cwT ydp eords ov ovt klvov]Xvov /xera^dAAet, ovt kv
d XP^^V 02;. Ov yap ovv. -'Ap' ovv ecTTL to aToitov tovto,

e B ou/t6Tx*''r
II ov fieTfxoi : as ^eT om. B a 7 yiyvfral :

T Byiyverai T
: c 4 /xei'] /u^f Heindorf C 9 &/... /ucto-
fidWei B &/... /j.fTafid\\fi T &j/ . fifrafidWoi corr. Par. 1809
: : . . .
 :

nAPMENIAHS i56d

V tri TOT av iXrj, OTC fX7a/:JaAAei; To itolov br]; To

^ai(f)vr]s. To yap k^ai^vr\<i Toiovbc ti lotKe arjixaivfiv, ws

f^ (KLVOV ix(Talid\Xov eis kKaTfpov. ov yap ck ye tou

eoTarat eorwToy Iti /iACTa/3aAAei, ov8' k rfjs Kivrfa-<os -i

Kivovjxivrjs Ti fxeTa/3aAAef dAAa ^ e^ai^^rrjs avTr; (f)va-i.s

aTOTios T6S kyKd6r]Tai ^iTa^v Trjs Kivrja^as tc xat crTao-ews,

ey Xp6v(f ovbevl ova^a, Kal els Tavrrjv br] Kal ck Ta^TT/s to tc e
Kivovfxevov ixeTa^dWd CTri to eo-Tarat Kat t6 eo-Tos cTri t6
Ktreto-^at. Kti^Suyevet. Kat t6 ^v brj, eiTrep i(TTr]K(. Te Kat

KtrctTat, /xeTa/3aAAot ay e<^' kKanpa ]x6v(os yap av ovT^as

dfx(f}6T(pa TTotot fteTa/3aAAoy 8' e^ai</)rrjs' /xeTa/3aAAct, KUt 5

OTC /ACTa^SaAAct, ey ovSert xp6v(a av eXr], ov8e KtrotT' az'

TOTc, ou8' &y a-Tair]. Ov yap. -'Ap' ovy oi/Taj Kat Trp^s tcs
aAAas ]XiTa^okas ^xii^-STav k tov etrat cts t6 aTro^AAfo-^at
/xcTa/SaAA?/ 17 ck toi; p.r] ctra: cts t6 yiyva-6ai,, [x^Ta^v 157
Tiv(t)V t6t( yiyviTai Kivr\(T(av T Kal a-Tdcr((t)v, Kal ovTe
i(TTL t6t ovt ovk iCTTi,, ovT yiyvTai. ovT dTToAAuTat;
."EotKc yovv. KaTa br] tov avTov K6yov Koi c^ kvos
CTTt TToAAa 161; Kat iK TToAAwy e(/)' ^V OVT V ia-Tiv ovTe 5
TToAAd, ovT biaKpivfTai ovt (TvyKpiviTai. Ka\ e^ ofxoiov
cTrt dv6]xoiov Ka\ e^ dvo]xoiov cTri ofxoLov iov ovtc ofxoLov
ovT dv6]xoLov, ovTe dpLOLovfxcvov ovT dvofxoLovfxevov Kal
K a-fXLKpov CTTt fxiya Kal CTri lo-oi' koi ets Ta ivavTia b
t6z; ovT( a-fXLKpov ovt fx^ya ovt laov, ovT av^av6p.ivov
ovT (\)6lvov ovtc laovfxivov etr/ dv. Ovk toLK. Tavra
br] TOL TTa6ri]xaTa TrdvT dv Trda^oL tu (v, ct (ttlv.- 17$
6 ov; S

Tt 8e Tots dAAoty irpoa-qKOL dv TTda-\(LV, Ir et co-Tir,

apa ov aKCTTTiov; SKCTrreW. Aeyoj/icy brj, v ct eo-Tt,
ToAAa Tov kvos tl xP^ TtiirovdivaL; Ae'yco/xer.' Ovkovv

d. 3 T0i6vhf B : ToiovTov T d4 ye B : T T e i ovStyl : T

ou5'
(vl B (et mox) a i nfTafidWri B : ^eTojBotij pr. T (ut videtur)
/UToj8oXj7 al. b4 ti ((TTiv^ (V e* eVTi Heindorf


I57b nAATllNOS
fTreiTre/) aAAa tov kvos (o-tlv, ovt to (v (tti raAAa* ov
C yap av aAAa tov kvos ^v. 'Op6u>s. Ovbk fxrjv (TTipiTai

y TTavTdiracn tov kvbs roAAa, dAAa fxcTex Trrj.-^Hfj 6^;

"Otl ttov to, a\ka tov kvos fxopia iXOVTa aXka kariv el yap
pLopLa pit] ex^' T^avTfXCiS av V eir;. ^Opdois. Mopta 6e

5 ye, (f>a[xcv, tovtov <rTlv 5 hv okov fi.

fpapikv ydp. .'AAAa
IJ.r}V t6 ye oXov ev e/c TTo\X<av dvdyKT] eTvaL, ov ((TTaL fxopLa
TCL fxopLa' iKacTTov ydp tS)V ixopmv ov TroXkciv ixopLov xpV
fivaL, dAAa oKov. H&s tovto; Ei tl TTokX&v fxopLov tr},

d V oTs avTo etr/, kavTov re bi]TT0V fxopLov <rTaL, o icTTLV

dbvvaTov, Kal tS>v dAAcov 8^ kvos kKdo-Tov, eiTrep kol iTdvTCiiv.

kvbs ydp fxrf ov fXopLOV, TTkrfV tovtov tu>v dAAcoy ^a-raL, Kal

OVTOiS kvbs kKdcTTOV OVK (CTTaL fXOpLOV, fXrf OV bk p.6pL0V kKdiTTOV

5 ovbevbs TuiV iToXkSiV (o-TaL. fxrfbevbs bk ov TTdvTcav tovtohv
TL LVaL, oiv Ovbcvbs OvbV kcTTL, Kttl fx6pL0V Kal dAAo OTLOVV
dbvvaTov [eiyai]. 4>aiveTai ye brf. Ovk dpa T<av iToXkciv

ovbk TTdvTCtiV Tb fxdpLov fx6pLov, dAAd fXLas TLvbs Ibeas Kal

e kv6s Tivos K<x\ovfXV o\ov, e^ aTTdvTOiv v T\Lov yyov6s,
TovTov fxopLov dv T^ fx6pLov 17/. .riarrdirao-i fxkv ovv. Et
dpa rdAAa fx6pLa e^et, Kav tov oKov re kcll kvbs fXT)(OL,
Wdvv ye. -^Ey dpa oXov t\Lov fx6pLa Xov dvdyKrf etyat

5 rdAAa tov kv6s. ^AvdyKrf. Kat fxifv Kal iTcpl tov fxopCov ye
kKdcTTov 6 avTbs Xdyos' Kal ydp tovto dvdyKrf /xerexeti^

158 Tov kvos. et ydp Ka<rTOV avr&v fx6pL6v icTTL, t6 ye Ka<rTov

etmt v brjiTov <rr}fxaLVL, d(f)(DpL<rfXVov fxkv T(av dAAwi^, Kad'
avTb bk ov, eiTrep Kaa-Tov (rTaL. ^OpdOis. Mere'xoi 8e' ye
av Tov kvbs brfkov otl dAAo ov rf v ov ydp dv p.TLXV,

5 dAA' 771' dv airrb V. vvv 8e kvl fxkv LvaL TTkrfV avT(o ro) kvl

dbvvaTov TTov. ^AbvvaTov. .Mere'xti' bi ye tov kvbs dvdyKrf

TM T oAw Kai tS fxopit^. Tb fxkv ydp ^v dkov eo-rat, ov

h9 oi/T('] (^oijTt ToAAo i(TT\ tJ) !>') oi/T Buttmann : oii5e Stallbaum
C2 /i*Tx<T: /iT'xToi B 05 i &>'T ^of B
: d.6 SivT AcB :

d7 (Ivai secl. Heindorf 64 tvT : iav B e 6 tovto B toutou T :

a I 7 T : Te B a 5 avTh (tJ) Heindorf a6 -ye T : om. B



nAPMENIAHS I58a

fMopia Ta fiopia- t6 8' av cKaarov ^v fxopiov tov 6\ov, o av p

pLOpiov o\ov. OvTOis. OvKovv Tpa ovTa Tov kvos p.idi^ct b
Ta fjt.TexovTa avTov; Ilws 8' ov; Ta 8' cre/aa tov kvos
TToWd Ttov &v eiTj* ei yap fxrfTe ^v firfT kvbs ttAcico trj

TaAAa tov kvos, ovbkv av etrj. Ov yap ovv,

'ETrel 8e' ye TrAeiaj kvos eort to. re tov kvbs fiopiov koa. to. 5

Tov kvos o\ov fiiTiypvTa, ovK dvdyKif ijbif irXrfdeL diTdpa

eirai aura ye eKetm Ta fiCToXafx^dvovTa tov kvos; YlQis;
i28e iScofier. aAAo rt ov\ %v ovTa ovb( ficTi^f^ovTa tov kvos
t6t, ot p.TaKafJ.^dvi avTov, /leraAa/x^aret; Arjka brf.
OvKovv TrKifdr] ovTa, kv ols to V ovk vi; YlXrfOrf pLVTOi. C
-Tt ovv; ei kdiXoLficv Trj biavoLa t&v TOLOVTOiv d(^klv b>s

oXoL re ka^fxiv otl oAtyioTor, ovk dvdyKi] /cat to d^aipe^er

eKetro, eiTrep tov kvos /x?/ fiT\0L, TrKfjdos etyai fcat ovx v;
'Ai;ay*C7j. Ovkovv ovt(i)S dei (tkottovvtcs avTrfv Kad^ avTifv 5

Trfv kTpav <f>v(rLV tov ei8ou? oa-ov av avrrjs dei 6p5ip.v &7rLpov
etrrat TrA^^ei; na^;rd7ra<rt fikv ovv. Kai p.i]v TTLbdv ye
^v Kaa-T0v piopLov fiopLov yvr)TaL, Trepaj 7/8/ ex^t Trpoy d
dAArjAa koi irpos t6 okov, Kal t6 okov irp6s tcl fxopLa.
Ko/xtSf/ pt.v ovv. Tois dAAots 8t/ tov evo? avfx(iaLVL k fXv
Tov eyos Kat e^ kavT&v KOLV(t)vr]a-dvT(av, ws olkv, Tp6v tl
yLyv(TdaL iv kavTois, 6 brf Trepas TrapcVxe irpos dAAr/Aa' ff 5
8' kavTdv (f)va-LS Kad^ kavTO. dTTLpLav. <l>atyerai. ^Ovrco 87/

rd dAAa tov kv6s Kal oAa Kai Kard fiopLa dTretpd re eo-rt

Kat TripaTos fXT\L. I\dw ye.

OvKow Kat ofxoLd re Kat dvofxoLa dAA7/Aots re Kat eaurots; e
IIt/ 87/; '^Hi fXV TTOV d7TLpd kaTL KaTCL Trfv kavTOiv (fyvaiv

irdvTa, TavT^v TTTTOv66Ta dv eir/ TavTrf. Yldvv ye. Kai firfv

ff
ye dirayra TtipaTos fxcTiycL, Ka\ TavTrf irdrr' dv eiT/ ravrw

a8 %"] ov al. b i n6piov SKov] fxopiov vel fiopiuv iXov Schleier-

Bekker
macher B ^17 hvT
b3 &/ firTj b 6 <J8r; B 5^ T
: irA^et :

S,ir(ipa. B 6,K(ipa irA.^flf T

: b 8 f5/xi/] ctSw/uei' B T
j 03 i\i-
yiffrhv (sic) B (cf. 149 a, 7) oKiyftrrov T C5 orKoirovvTfi pr. T
:

Damascius ffKoirovvri B
: d i fn6piov bis B semel T d 6 airdpiav :

T dwfipta B
: e2pT:iB e4^T:({B


158 e nAATilNOS
5 TTeiTovOoTa. .Flws 8' ov; .^Ht 8e ye Tif.Tr^pacr^j.iva tc etmt
Kal aTretpa TTiTTovOev, ivavTia TrdOri dAA?jAots ovra ravTa to.

159 TTadr] TTiTov6V. .Nat. -Ta 8' kvavTia ye ws olov re dyo-

/LtotoVara. .Tt /xrjy; -Kara /xey apa kK6.Tepov rb TTados
oixoLa av (Xrj avTO. re avrots xat dAA,7/Aots, KaTo. 8' aix(f)6Tpa

afx<poTep(i)s evavTKOTaTo. re Kai avofwt.6TaTa. Kti'8wewei.

5 OvT(t> 81) Ta a.\Ka avra re avrots Kal dA.A.?/A.ots o/notd re Kal
av6fxoLa av eirj. .Oyrcos, .Kat TavTO. br] koI erepa dXKi]k(i)v,
Kol Ki,vov[Xva Kal kcTTSiTa, Koi TtdvTa to, evavTia Ttddr] ouKeVt
XaAeTrws ivpri(rop.ev TTTTov66Ta rdAAa tov kv6s, cTretTre/) Kat
b TavTa i(pdvr] TreTTovddTa. 'Op^ws Ae'yeis.

OvKovv, et rai5ra fxev 178?/ ew/xey &s (pcwepd, cTTLa-KoiToifXfV

8e TraAti; ey et ^(ttlv, dpa Kal ov^ oilrcos exct rd dAAa roi;

kvbs 7] ovTUi ndvov; Ildvv [lev ovv. Aeyco/xev brj ef dpxv^

5 ^y et eo-rt, rt XP^ '"'d dAAa tov kvbs TTTTov6evaL.-^A4y(aixv
yap. 'Ap ovv ov xojpls ixkv Tb ^v tG)V dAAcoy, X'^?''^ ^^
rdAAa roii kvbs etvaL; Tt 8^; ."Ori ttov ovk ^(ttl Ttapa
TOVTa Tpov, 6 dAAo ]XV kcTTL Tov kv6s, dAAo 8e T&V &KX(OV
C Trdvra yap dpr]TaL, OTav pr]dfi t6 re ev kuI rdAAa Ildyra
ydp. .OvK dpa er' ecrriy cTepov tovtu^v, kv w t6 re ^v av
etr] T(a avT^ Kal rdAAa. Ov ydp. OvbeiroTe apa ev ravT^
kcTTL Tb %v Koi rdAAa. Ovk (olkcv. Xo)pU dpa; Nat.
5 Ou8e fxrjv ]x6pLd ye exety (pafxkv Tb ws dXr]Om
ev. ricSs,

yap; .Oiir apa okov ei?/ av rb V kv rois dAAots ovre ]x6pL(i

avTov, ei x<wpts re' eo-rt twv dkk(t)v Kal ]x6pLa ]xr] exei.^ Ilws
d ycLp; Ov8ei'i dpa Tp6TT(a ]xerixf><- ^v rdAAa tov kv6s, fxr^Te

Kard ]x6pL6v tl avrov ]xr]T Kard oAoi; ]XTXOVTa.' .Ouk

0LKv. Ovbafxfj dpa V rdAAd kcTTW, ovb^ exfi kv kavTols
ey ovbiv. Ov yap ovv. Ov8' dpa TroAAd eo-rt rdAAa- ^v

e5j;T:(B ai veirovOev. vai. B : irenovOdvai T a 5 to

&K\a ai/rd re B TS.\Ka Tavrd re T
: b 2 ovkovv] fort. ti olv Heindorf
ei BT om. al.
: i^fjKv] iwfj.fvBT iwicrKovolnfvBT: iiricrKoirufj.evz.\.
b 7 fivai B om. T : c 7 x*'] *XJ? ^ ^ ^^ y^P ^ '
7^9 "^ ^


nAPiSIEXIAHS iSgd

yap av rjv (.KacTTov avT&v \x6piov tov okov, ei TToXKa rjv 5

vvv 8e ovT (V ovT TToXXa oijTe okov ovt fxopui ia-Ti raAAa
Tov kvos, eTTciSj) avTov ovdap.fj /xerexet. OpOan. Ovb apa
bvo ovbf TpCa ovre avTO. eort Ta aXka ovtc (VCOttlv ev avTots,
eiTrep tov kvos TTavTa\fi (TT^piTau Ovtms.
Ovb\ ofxoLa apa Koi av6p.0La ovre avra. eori t^ kv\ tol

aAAa, ovre evea-TLV iv avTOLS opLOL^Trjs Kal dro/xoioTTjs* et

yap opLOLa kol av6p.0La avTO. dr] rj exoi (v kavTols 6p.0L6Tr]Ta

Kal dyojLioioVrjTa, bvo ttov elbrj (vavTLa dAATyAots exot av V 5

eavTots To. aXXa tov kv6s. <f>aiyeTat. "^Hv bc ye abvvaTov

bvoLV TLVOLv \x.TyjeLV h. fxrjb^ kvos [xeTexoL. ^AbvvaTov.
OijT^ apa ojxoia ovr dyo'/xQtd eo-riz; ovr afX(f)6Tpa TaAAa.
ofxoLa fXV yap av ovTa ^ avofxoLa kvbs ^v tov Tpov etbovs l6o
jueTe'xoi, ovra bvolv tolv kvavTLOLV TavTa 8e
afX(f)6Tpa 8e

abvvaTOV <})dvrf. ^AXrjdi].

Ovb' apa TCL avTCL ovb^ Tpa, ovbk KLVovfXva ovbk ka-T&Ta,

ovb yLyv6fXva ov8e CLTToXXvfxeva, ovb fXLC(D ovbe eAaTTO) 5

ouSc to-a* ovb aXXo ovbkv ttttov6 t&v tolovt(>)v et yap

Ti tolovtov TT^TTOvOivaL VTTOfXVL To. dAAa, Kai ez'os Kat bvoTv
Kal TpL&v Kal 77 eptTTOu Kat dpTLOV fX0^L, &v avTOLs dbvvaTov
(f)dvrf fXTX(l-V TOV v6s ye TTaVrp TTaVTCOS a-TpOfXVOLS. b
'AArj^e'o-TaTa. Ovra) bi] %v et (ttlv, TrdvTa T Io-tl to V
KOL ovbk V ia-TL Kal TTpos kavTo Kal TTpos TCL aXXa b^aavTo^s.

rTai^TeAois fXV ovv.

Etev et 8e 87) pij] (rTL to er, Tt XPV ffVl^iio-^VLV dp' ov 5

a-K^TTTeov fXTa TOVTo; 'LkTTTov ydp. Tis ovv hv eiJ] auTtj

i] VTT6d(rLs, et kv fxi] ^cttlv; dpd tl bLa^ip^L Trjabe, l p.r]

v fiT| iaTLv; ALa(j)pL fxivTOL, ALa(f)pL fxovov, Tf Kal Tray

TovvavTiov ea-TLV cIttcIv l fxr] ly ixr] iarTi tov ei ^v fxrf C

d8 (Vftrriv^ tv i(mv B T 63 ivitmv B : i/ i<rriv T e4 ^ B :

^T a I yh.p tiv T : -yip B a 3 i.ivvarov T a^vvara B : b3 ouSe

fv T : ouSfV B Ttt fiWo] riWa, Koi ToAAa Heindorf b6 toOto
T : toCto B


i6oc OAATaNOS
((TTLv; Tlav rovvavTLOv. ^Ti 8' ei rts Aeyoi d /xey^^os

/A^ ia-TLV fi (TfxiKpoTris fxrj io-Tiv 7/ Tt a\ko T<av tolovtu>v,

apa <^' K(i.crTov hv br]koL otl hepov tl Aeyot to ov; /jitj

6 Yldw y. OvKovv Kal vvv brjXol otl hepov Aeyei tS>v aXkcav
To fir] 6v, oTav eLirr] Ir et fxr] ((ttl, Kal l(rfx(v o Ae'yet;

"lcTfJ.ev. Ylp&Tov pikv apa yv<aa-T6v tl Ae'yet, i-n^LTa (Tcpov

tS>v akkodv, oTav eiTrrj iv, eire to etyai avT(a Trpo^rdels eire

d To p.r] (TvaL' ovbcv {yap) rJTTOV yLyvdtaKiTaL, tl to ky6p.ivov

]xr] clvaL, Kai ort bLa(j)opov t5>v akXoiV. r/ ov; ^XvayKr].'
^Slbi apa kcKTeov e^ apxvs> ^v et ixr] ((ttl, tl xPV ^TvaL.

TTpSiTov fXV ovv avT<a TovTO VTTap\LV bel, 0)5 eotKer, etrat

5 avTov in(TTrifJ.r]v, rj //?j8e ort Ae'yerat yLyvco(TKa-0aL, oTav rts

eiTrr/ er ei fxi] fo-TLV. .'AAr/^r/. Ovkovv kol tcl dkka Tpa

avTov flvaL, rj /xr]8e (kclvo Tpov t&v dkk(i)V keyecrdaL;
Hdw ye. Kat cTepoLdTris dpa (o-tIv avria iTpbs Trj e'7no-rr//Ar/.

e ov yap Tr]V tG>v dkkoiv kTpoi6Tr]Ta kiyeL, oTcev to ^v cTcpov

Toiv dkkoov k4yr], dkka Tr]V (Kclvov. 4>atVerat.^ Kai fxr]V

Tov ye cK([vov Kal tov tlvos Ka\ tovtov Kal tovt(o Kal tovtoov
Kal TrdvTUiV tG>v tolovto)V /xere'xf t to fxrj ov V' ov ydp av

5 t6 iy eAe'yero ov8' dv tov kvbs hepa, ovb' KLV(a dv tl rjv

ov8' (KLVov, ovb' dv TL (keycTo, et fxrJTe tov TLvbs avT(a pLeTrfV

fxrfTi T(Jiv dkk(t)v TovTOiiv OpOm.-hElvaL fxev 8r/ rw kvl

ovx_ ol6v re, eiTrep ye fx-q (ttl, /xere'xfti' b\ i:oXk5>v ovb\v

l6l KcoAt^et, dAAa /cat dvdyKr], ei7re/3 t6 ye (V Klvo Kal /xr/ aAAo
firi (TTLV. et {xevTOL fxriTi Tb ey pi.r]T eKLVo /xr/ ecrrat, dAAa
7re/)i dAAou tov 6 k6yos, ovbe ^diyyi(TdaL bei ovbev et be to

kv KLVo Kot /xr) dAAo vir^KeLTaL pir] etrat, Kai tov eKeCvov

5 Kat dkk(t}v TTokk(av dvdyKr] avT(a ixiTeivaL. Kai Trdrr; ye.

Kat dvofiOL^Trfs dpa icrTLV avTut irpbs rd dAAa* rd ydp

dkka Tov kvbs cTepa ovTa kTcpola Kal etr/ Nai.
dv. ^Td

C3 Ti HWo B : &\\o Ti T C 4 \eyoi B XeV T 05 \(yfi :

T : \fyoi B dI ovSIp . .d 2 fhat T om. B (add. in marg. b)

. :

yiip apogr. : om. Tb e 4 eV B om. T : a 2 yu^ ^o-toi B :

/u^Jt' ^(Tto* T a6 iffrlv avrif B avT(f iariv T

:
 .

nAPMENlAHS i6ia

8' hepoXa ovk akkoia; Uios Ta

8' ov; 8' dAAota ovk
avofxoLa; ^Avoixoia fxfv oiv. Ovkovv diicp t& hl av6iJ.oid b
eoTi, br]\ov oTi avofMo[<o rd ye av6}xoM dvofioia hv ftrj.
AfjKov. Fitr] 8r; av Kal t^ kvl di^OjUotoVr/y, Trpbs rjv to,

dXka dv6pMi,a avT^ <ttiv. "EotKfr.Ei 8^ 8^ t&v dXXoiv

dvoixotdTTjs ca-Ttv avT(a, dp* ovk dvdyKrj eavTov opLOidTrjTa 5
avTco iXvai; YlSis; Et kvos dyo/xoioV)js lo-rt tm kvi, ovk
dv TTOV TTcpl Tov ToiovTov 6 koyos (trj otov Tov kvos, ovb* dv
rj vTT6de<Tis etr) TTcpl kvos, dXXd Trepi aAAou ?*/ kv6s. Yldvv
ye. Ov hd 8e' ye. Ov 8^ra. Aei dpa 6fxoi.6Tr]Ta roi ei;i C
avroi; eavroi eirai. Aei.
Kai fxriv ovf av ttrov y eo-rt rot? dXA.ots* et ydp etr;

t<Toy, ctr/ re dv r/8r; Kai dfxoiov dv (trj avTols Kard ttjv

i<r6Tr]Ta. TavTa 8' dfx(j)6Tpa dhvvaTa, elTrep /u.r/ eo-riv ev.' 5

'ASwara.. -'77^18^ 8e ovk dAAois Spa ovk
dvdyKr] Kal roAAa eKetVw
lo-rt rots

fxr] t<Ta eirat;

lo-oy,

'Aydyfcrj Td 8e
fxr] t<ra ovk dvi<ra; Na^. ^Td 8e drio-a ov T<a dv(a-<a

avL(ra; H&s 8' ov; Kai drto-oVr/ros 8^ /xerexet to ^v,

Tipbs rjv rdAAa avT(^ e<rTLV dvKra; .Mere^xet. ^"AAAd /ueVrot d
dyto-oVr/ros yc ^o-ri fxiyedos re koi <rfXLKp6Tr]s. "Eo-rt ydp.

Eo-riy dpa KaX p.eye66s Te Kal <TfLLKp6Tr\s rw roiovro)
kvi; ^Kti^^wciJet. .Meye^oy fxr]v Kal (rfXLKp6Tr]s det d<f>i-

<TTaTOv dXXr]\oLv. Mera^v

Ildyv ye. dpa tl avToXv det 5
eoTii'. Eo-rtv. ovv
"'ExetsdAAo tl eiTreti' fxeTo^v avro^iv
r/ lo-oVrjra; Ovk, dXXd Toiko. -"Ora) dpa lort fxiyedos Kal
(TfXLKp6Tr]s, e<TTL KoiX l^T^Tqs avT<a /xera^ii tovtolv ovcra.
<i>a^i^erat. T^ br] kvl fxr] Svtl, &)? lotKc, Kai la6Tr]Tos dv e
fxereCr] Kal fxeyidovs Kal <rfXLKp6Tr]Tos. "EotKcy.
Koi fxrfv Kal ovtrtas ye ^ei avrd fxtTixiLV irr/. YlGts
8r/; "Exeir avrd 8et ovT<i)S ws kiyofxev ei ydp fxr] ovrcos Ix**

b4 ;T: ^B C2 tTj/oiT: om. B C3 7'T:om. B d6fort.

ainoTv (tiv) Heindorf e i 5^ Par. 1810 Heindorf e Ficino 8i B T :

e2 fitrfiT) T : /jLfrlri B e 3 /ca) fxijv Koi B koI fxiiv T

: 64 ex*]
fxv BT : fxoi Coisl.
 .

i6ie nAATflNOS
5 oi/K av oKrjdi] \iyoi.\xev ijixeis k^yovrei ro V //?) elvar d
8e aXrjOfj, brjKov oti ovra avTO, X^yoiiiV. ov\ o^Toas;
Ouro) ^ikv ovv. 'E7ret8^ 8e ^ajuev dArj^^ k4yLV, avdyKrj
57

162 rjfxlv (f)dvaL Kal ovTa kiynv. 'Ardyxjj. ."Eo-tw; dpa, ci)S

^oiKe, ro ^y ovK ov ei yap p.r] ecrrai /utj oi', dAAd irry roC
eiyat dvr\cr(i Trpbs to fjLrf etvai, evOvs ^(TTaL 6v. .nai^rdTratri

fxkv ovv. Aei apa avro becrfjLOV exfti' tov fxrj et^at t6 ftvaL

5 /xr) ov, ei fie'AA.ei p.r} eiyat, 6[xolu)S &<n:cp to ov ro jtx^ 5v

exfty fxr] itvaL, tva reA.e'cos aS [eti^ai]
fi'
o^oos ydp av t6 re
ov /xdAto-r' av ei?j /cat ro /xt) oy ovk hv eir;, fxeTiyovTa to
fxkv ov ovaias tov ilvaL Sv, fxr] ova-Cas 8e rou (jxr]) eti^at ]xr]

b oy, ei [xekkeL reAecos eii^at, ro 8e ]xr] ov [xr] oixTLas [xkv tov /xt/

eivat [fxr]] ov, ova-ias be tov (TvaL fxr] ov, et kol to fxr] ov av
Tikitiis fxr] eo-rat. .'AAr/^eWara. Ovkovv eiretTrep rw re
oyrt rou fxr] cTvaL Kal r3 /x^ oyrt tov etyat fxiTforTL, koI rw
5 eyi, e7ret8^ ovk eo-rt, tov etvat dvdyKr] /xeretrat ets ro /xr/

etvat. AvdyKr].' Kai ovo"ta 8r/ <^aiyerat rw ei^t, et /*r/

((TTLV. ^Jatyerat. Kat fxr] ova-ia dpa, etTrep fxr] ((ttlv.

Tl(as 8' ov;

Olov re ovv t6 ^ypv ttcos fxr] ^X'^'-^

otJro), /x^ fXTa^dkkov
ro e/c Tavrqs Ttjs e^ecos; -Ovx otoV re. Hdv dpa t6 tolovtov
C /xera^oAr/y o-r//xaii'ei, 6 av ovrco re Kai /x^ ovrcos exr/.
rTcSs 8' ov; .Mera^SoA^ 8e KLvr]a-LS' */ rt (ftrjaofxfv; KCvr]-
o-tff. OvKow t6 kv 6v re Kat ovk ov e(f)dvr]; Nat.^ Ovrcos
apa Kal ov^ ovTOiS ^X^^ (paiveTaL, "'EoiKey. Kat klvov-

5 fxfvov dpa t6 ovk &v ^v ire^ayrai, ewetTrep Kat fxeTa^okr]v

eK Tov etrat Im t6 fxr] eiyai exor. Ktr8wet;ei. .'AAAd fxr]v

et fxrfhafxov yk kaTL t&v ovTOiV, ons ovk ^aTLV ftiTcp fxr] eaTLV,
ov8' hv fXiOiaTaLTo Trodkv iroL. nciJs' ydp; Ovk dpa rai ye
d fXTal3aivLv klvoIt dv. Ou ydp. Ou8e fxr]v kv r&i avrw

a a ToC Ttri Procl. suppl. : t^s rov B : t rov B* T a 6 6?/ seclu-

dendum vel ttv scribendum ci. Shorey a 8 fitv %v B n^v T :

/ttj) add. Shorey b 2 ju}> secl. Shorey b 9 ttws T ir B :c 5 Ii'

ir(pavrai] ifxwf^pavrai B fvirt<pavrai T
: C 7 ye] t B T C 8 /Jif6l-
(Trair6 T jujfl' t(rrair6 B
: t^ T t^ B :
 ; :

nAPMENIAHS i62d

av (rTp<f)Oi,TO' TavTov yap ovbafxov ^Trrerai. 6v yap efrrt

t6 TavTov To be /xt) ov cv ro) t&v ovtcov abvvaTov elvaL.

^AbvvaTOv ydp. Ovk apa to iv ye /xr/ ov crTp4(f)(r6ai. av
bvvaiTO V cKeCvio kv w /xt) ea-Tiv. Ov yap ovv. Ovbe ixrjv 5
aWoLovTai ttov to kv kavTov, ovt t6 6v ovt t6 /x^ ov
ov yap av rjv 6 Aoyos Iri Trepi roi; cvo^, eiTTep i^AXoiouro
avTo kavTov, aWa TTcpl aXkov tlvos. ^Op6S>s. Et 8e ixrJT

aWoLOVTaL p.riT ev ravrai 0Tpe</)erai /UT/re fX(Ta^aLVCL, ap'

av ini TL KLvoLTo; ITws' yap; T6 ye p.r]v aKLvrfTov avdyKy) e
i]crv\Lav aycLV, t6 be r}(rvxd.Cov eo-rarat. 'AvdyKrj. To ^v
apa, 0)9 OLKv, ovK 6v ^(TTrjKi re Kal Kti^eirai. "Eolkcv.
Kat fJLr]v ei77ep ye Kti^etrat, fxiydkt] dvdyKr] avrQ dXkoLov-
(rdaL' OTrj] ydp dv tl KLvridfj, Kara TO(rovTov ovk46^ axravToos 163
iXL 0)? etxey, dA\' ere'pco?. Ovtci^s, Klvov]XVov br] t6 ^v
Kal dAAotoirrai. KatNat. ixr]v ixr]baixi] ye klvov]XVOV
ovbafxfj dv dAAototro. Ov ydp. .^Ht fxev dpa Ktz^etrat t6
ovK 6v ^v, dAAoiouraf 17 8e p.r] Ktretrai, ovk dWoLovraL.-
5
Ov ydp. To dpa ^v fxr] 6v dAAotourat re Kat ovk dAAoi-
oSrat. ^^aiVerat.' ^To 8' dXXoLovfXVov dp* ovk dvdyKX]
yLyv<rdaL fXV ^T^pov rj irpoTepov, aTTokXv^rdaL 8e k rfjs
Ttporipas t6 8e dkkoLOVfXVov b
/XT/re
e^ecos*

d7rdAAvo"^at;
'AmyKTj.^
fxrf

Kai t6 v dpa
/XT/re

p.r]
yiyvecrdaL
6v dkkoLov-
fi.Vov fXV yLyvTaL re Kai aTroAAurat, fxrf dkkoLovfi,Vov 8e
ovT yLyvTaL ovT dTroAAuraf Kal ouro) t6 ^v /at) 6v yiyveTaL
T Kal dTroAAurai, Kat ovt yiyvTaL ovt dTTokkvraL,- Ov 5
ydp olv.

AZ6ls dpxw ravrd

rjfxlv
brf

<{>(WLTaL cLTTcp Kal

Tt\ rrfv

vvv rf erepa.
'AAAd
t(afXV irdAiy 6\l/6fXV0L

XPH'
ei

Ovkow
^v l /tT/ eo-rt, (f)api.v, tl xPV '^^P'-
o-^tov crvfxfiaivLV c
Nai. .To 6e fxrf ^cttlv oTav kiy(afXV, dpa fxrf tl dkko

a 2 (lx(v T ^x B : 8)j Heindorf e Ficino : Si BT a4 &j/ T

om. B ^T:eZB a5^T:iB b^ oifre ylyutTai T : ov
yiyvfrai B b 6 yiip olv ^ : ydp T C2 tj HWq B : &X\o ri T
 f

i63C nAATX2N02
a-qfxaCvei rj ovarCas aTrova-iav rovTta &> hv <\)5iixn> /xtj ilvai;
OvSer aXko. YloTipov ovv, orav (f)&fMV fxrf elvaC tl, ttods

5 ovK ctvaC (f)aixv avTO, iro)? 8e elvai; t/ tovto t6 /xt; lort

Xeyofxevov aTrAo)? <Tr]fiaCvL otl ovbafx&s ovbafxi] Io-tlv ovbe

TTT} ixiTiXiL ov(rCas To y /XT/ ov; ' A7r\ov(rTaTa fxkv ovv.

OvT apa (TvaL bvvaLTo hv t6 [xrf ov ovt oAAcos ovbafx&s
d oixrCas ixiTi\Lv. Ov ydp. ^To be yCyvea-OaL Kal t6 aTroA-

Xvcr$aL fxrf tl aXKo rfv rf t6 fx\v oixrCas fxeToKafx^avcLV, t6

8' airoXXvvaL oixrCav; Ovbev aAAo. ^Q,l b4 ye fxrjbev

ToijTov fXTea-TLV, ovT av Xafx^6.voL ovt aTtoKKvoL avTO.

5 riwy yd.p; 'To) kv\ apa, eireiS^ ovbafxr} ((ttlv, ovt fKTCov
ovT aTTaKKaKTeov ovt fxeTaKrfiTTiov ovcrCas ovbafx&s.
EIkos. OvT dpa aTToAAirrat t6 fxrf ov kv ovre yCyveTai,
eTTeCTtep ovbafxfj /xerexfi ovaCas. Ov (f)aCvTaL. Ovb' dp'

e dAAoiouTai ovbafxr\' rjbrf yap av yCyvoLTO re Kal aTroKKijoLTO

TOVTO 'JTd(rxov.~~AKr}drf. .Ei be firf aAAoioirrat, ovk dvdyKrf

fxrfbe KLViiadaL; Ovbe

^Avdyiof. fxrfv ka-TovaL (^rfaofxev to

fxrfbafxov ov t6 yap eoros rw ev avTU) tlvl bei del eTvaL.

5 Tw avT&' 770)5 yap Ovt(o
ov; brf av t6 fLrf 6v fxrfTe TTOTe

kcTTdvaL fxrfTi KLvdcrOaL Keyu^fxev. M^ ydp ovv. ^"AAAa

fxrfv ovb' eaTL ye avT^ tl tZv 6vtu)V' rjbrf ydp dv tovtov
164 fxtTeypv [ovros] ovaCas fxcTexoL. ArjKov. Oure dpa fxiyedos
ovTe (TfXLKpoTrfs ovTe laoTrfs avT^ ^o-tlv. Ov Ovbe ydp.
fxrfv bfxoLOTTfs ye ovbe eTepoLortfs ovTe TTp6s avro ovre iTpos
TaAAa eXrf hv avTQ. Ov ^aCveTaL. ^Tt b4; TSAAa icrO^

5 0TT(i)s dv eXrf avT<a, el fkrfbev avT^ beX eTvaL; Ovk ea-TLV.

OvTe dpa ofxoui ovTe dvofxoLa ovTe TavTa ovff tTepd Icttlv
avrQ tcl ^iAAa. Ov ydp.' ^Ti b4; t6 eKeCvov rj t6 ^KeCvio
if TO TL rf To tovto rf to tovtov t/ aAAov r/ aAAo) t/ TTOTf t/

C3^B:ftT c8 (ivai T : om. B d2 ^c Heindorf

^ BT d4 &I' Kafifiipoi T : avaXafifiivoi B 64 Se? del BT
a(\ SeT vulg, e 5 t$ aiiT^' BT (alteri tribuit B) : rh avT6. al,
e 7 rovTov B rovro : T : rov al. Heindorf a i ovro^ seclusi
rov ovros Stallbaum a3 -ye B : re T ou5i T : oHrf B a 4 tSaAo
clVj T ^Xa
: tXn B


nAPMENIAHS i64b

ejTCira ?/ vvv ri iTnarriixr] ^ bo^a ri al(rdr](ns 77 Adyos 17 b

oifo/Lia 17 aAAo ortow t&v 6vtoi)v TTcpl t6 /xt/ 6v ^aTai; Ovk
eorai. Ovto) 8^ kv ovk 6v ovk ^x(l ttcos ovbanf]. Ovkovv
bri eoiKiv ye ovbaiii] ^xn-v.

"Eri bii \4yoi)iJiV, ^v el /x^ eo-rt, raAXa ri XP) "^^- 5

iTov6(vaL. Aeyco/xct' yap. ."AAAa /j.eV ttov bel avTo. (Ivai'

ci yap iiribi aXka ia-TLV, ovk hv irc/)l t&v aAAwy Aeyotro.

Ovrco. Ei be Trept tuiv aAAcoy 6 Ao'yos, to. ye aAAa erepa
k(TTLV. rj ovK (TTL T(o avT^ /caAets t6 re aAAo Kai to
iTepov; "'Eycoye. -"Erepoy bi yk ttov (paixev to iTepov etrai c
kTipov, KaX To akXo bri oAAo eij^at aAAov; Nat. Kat rois
^AAotj apa, et p.iKkeL akka eti^at, eo-rt rt ov akka f(rTaL.'
'ArciyKrj. ^T( bri ovv hv ftri; tov fxkv yap kvbs ovk ioraL
akka, firi ovtos ye. Ov y&p. 'AAAT/Acoy apa eo-rt* tovto 5
yap avrots Irt AeiTrerai, 7/ ixrjbevbi etz/at aAAots.' ^Opdais.
Kara ttAt/^t/ &pa iKaara dAA^Acor aAAa ecrrt* KaTO, tr

yap ovK av old re ftri, /u^ ovtos kvos. dAA' e/caoros, wy

0LKV, 6 OyKOS aVT(aV a7TLp6s i(rTL TTkriOiL, KCLV Tb a-fjiLKpo- d
TaTov boKovv etyai Ad/8r/ rts, u>a-TTp ovap fv i/Tryo) ^atrerat
^aL(f)vris avTl kvbs bo^avTos flvaL TroAAd Kai dj^rt a-fjLLKpo-

T<xTov iTap.p.iyi6is iTpbs rd Kpit.aTL^6p.va e^ avTov.' ^Op66-

TaTa. iToioTJrcoy 67) oyKiov dAAa akkrikcov av etT/ rdAAa, 5

ct ei^ds ixri ovtos akka koTLV.' Ko/xtSr/ ixkv ovv.- Ovkow

TToAAot oyKOL (crovTaL, ets CKacrros (f)aLv6pL(vos, 6)V 8e ov,
etiTfp Iv {xri lorat; Ovrco. Kat apLdixbs 8e etrat avT&v
b6^L, ctiTep KOL kv ^Kaa-TOV, TTokkoiv ovT(v. T\a.vv ye.
Kai rd ixkv bri dprta, rd 8e Trcptrrd kv airrols ovTa ovk
akri^as <})aLV(Tai, cTwcp ly fxri ^orai. Ov yap o^v. Kat
ix-qv Kal crpiLKp^TaTov ye, <j)aix4v, 8o'^et kv avrots ivfivaL'

b5 Ti B : om. T b 6 &\\a fitv vov T dAXct niiv wov B : ci rh

T : om. B e6 ^ T e B
: d 8 oSrw T om. B e i Si^fi :

T : S6^(ifv B 63 <l>aivfTai] <pavfirai Thomson e4 8<J|ei tV

Heindorf : SdftJt' BT ^;'*?'^] tv efi^oi B : eri^ot T


i64e nAATXlNOS
5 (fyaiverat be tovto TroAAa Kal ixcydXa Trpos (KacrTov Totv

165 TToXXwv 0)? (rij,iKp&v 6vT(t>v. nSs 8' ov; Kai t(Tos tirfv

rois TToAAois Kal (T\j.iKpois Ka(rTos oyKOS bo^a^rdrjcrfTat.

eivai' ov yap hv fxcTijSaivev e/c ixcCCovos ds fXarrov (f>aLv6-

jxevos, TTplv eis t6 [xeTa^v bo^iiev ekdelv, tovto 8' cZrj h.v

5 (pdvTaa-fxa i(Torrjros. EIkos. Ovkovv Kal TTpos aX.Kov oyKOV

Trepas X^^> o.vt6s ye Trpbs avTov ovre dpxrjv ovt irepas
ovTi p.i(Tov ^xuiv; n?) bri; "Oti det avTUiV oTav tCs tl

Xd/377 Trj bLavoCa &s Tt, tovtohv ov, Trp6 re Trjs dpxrjs dXkr)
b dei (paCvTai dpxv> p^^rd re TrjV reAeirr^y (Tcpa vTTokwirop.ivr}
reA.eur77, ev re rw //ecra) dAAa [xe^raCTepa tov fx4(rov, crixiKpd-

Tepa 8e, 8td ro /u^ Swao-^at evbs avTa>v efcdo-rou \a}x^d-

ve(T6ai, aTe ovk ovtos tov kv6s. ' AkrjOea-TaTa. pvTrrecr^ai

5 br] oiju,at KepfxaTtC^ixivov dvdyKr\ "ndv to ov, o av rts Ad/3r;

Trj biavoCq' oyKos ydp ttov dvev kvbs dei kapL^dvotT av.-^
Tldvv fxkv ovv. Ovkovv t6 ye toiovtov TT^pp^adev fxev

C bp5>vTi Ka\ dfx^kv ^v (f)aCv(T6at dvdyKrj, iyyvdev 8e Kat dv

voovvTi TTkrf6et diTetpov kv ^Ka^TTOv (f)avrjvat, etTTep (TTepeTat

Tov kvbs fxrf ovTos; ^AvayKatoTaTov fxev ovv. Ovro) brf

6,TTLpd re Koi irepas ex^^"^'^ '^^'- ^^ '^"' TToAAd eKa(TTa raAAa

5 bet (f)aCve(T6at, ev ei fxrj kcTTtv, rdAAa 8e tov kv6s. ^Aet

ydp. OvKovv KoX bfxotd re /cat dvdfxota bd^et eXvat; illrj

bri; .Oloy icrKLaypa(f>r]}xeva diro^TTdvTL fikv kv TrdvTa <f>aLvp-

fxeva TavTbv (f>aCv(T6at TTeiTov^ivat kcu ofxota etvat. Udjw
d ye. ripoo-eA^oVrt 8e' ye TToAAd xat eTepa Kal rw tov eTcpov
(f>avTd(Tp.aTL kTepoXa kcu dvdfxoLa eaurots. Ovro). Kat
oixoiovs brf Kal dvofxoCovs tovs oyKovs avTovs re avroty
dvdyKrj (f)atV(T6aL xai dAArjAots. Hdvv fxev ovv Ovkovv
5 KoX Tovs avTovs KOL kTepovs dkk-qku^v, Kal aiTTOfxevovs Kal

a 2 (T/j.iKpo7s T B : a 4 S6^fiev T S6^eiv B

a/xiKphs a6 yt :

Hermann re B T : a 7 rt T om. B b 2 fieffalTfpa T fiea-alrepa

: :

TiB b3 5T:ora. B b5S^B:S^T b 6 oW T om. B :

b7 ir6ppa>dev pievv6ppu6ev T B C i ej' <paivear0ai b efKpaiveaOai

: :

Tpr. B 6^v voovvTiT o^ivovTiBProch snppl. : 05 Se7(paive<r0ai

T Si) <paiveff0ai B
: TSWa corr. Veri. 189 &\\a B iAAck T : :


nAPMENIAHS i65d

XW/51S favT&v, Kol KLvovfxivovs Trdcrai KLvrjcreis Kal lo-rcSras

TrdvTrj, Kal yiyvoijAvovs koI aiToXXvixivovs Kal iJLrjbcTcpa, Kal
Trdvra wov ra rotavra, & bKkOdv cvireres ijbr] fifuv, eZ jevbs

fxri ovTos TroWa eoriy. ' A\ri6i(rTaTa /xey ovv. e

"Eti bri 6.1:0^ eXdovTCS ttAXiv iirl T-qv apxw ftwco/ier, ly

el iiri i<TTi, TakXa b\ tov
kvos, tC xPV (^i^o-i- EiTrcojuey
yap ovv. OvKovv ey ixev ovk icrrai ToXka. YlS>s yap;
Ovbi ixriv TtoKkS. ye* ey yap iToKkois ova-iv iveCr] hv Kal ^v. 5

ei yap fxribcv avT&v iarlv V, ^Trayra ov8ey ea-Ttv, u)crT

ovb^ hv TToXXa eirj. ^AXriOrj. M^ evovTOs 8e ci^o? iv Tols

8,kkoLS, ovT TToXXa ovT v T^kka. Ov
icTTL Ov8e ydp.'

ye 0atrerat ^v ovbe Ttokkd. Ti rSAAa t&v

877; ."Ort ixri 166
ovTOiv ovbevL ovbaixrj ovbaix&s ovbeixCav KOLVOivCav e^et, ovbi
Ti T&v fxri ovTOiv Trapa t&v dkkoiv r<t) kcTTLV ovb\v yap
ixipos kcTTL Tols p.ri ovcTLV, ^Akr]6ri. Ov8' dpa bo^a tov
ix-q ovTOs irapd tols dkXoLs karlv ovbi tl ^dvTaa^xa, ovb\ 5

bo^d^TaL ovbaixr} ovbaix&s to ixri 6v eTTt t&v dkko>v. Ov

ydp ovv. ''Ei; apa et /xt) eaTLv, ovbe bo^dC^TaC tl tS>v

dkXoiv ^v cTvaL ovbe TTokkd' dvev ydp kvbs TTokka bo^daaL b

d8vyaroi'.'
'A8tJi;aroy ydp. ^*Ey dpa ei ixrj ^ori, raXAa ovt
^aTLV ovt 8oa^erai ^v ovbe iTokkd. Ovk ^olkV. Ov8' dpa
o/x,ota oii8e dvoixoLa. Ov ydp. .OiiSe /xrjy Ta avTd ye ou8'
^Tpa, ovb aTTTOixeva o\^\ X^^P^^' ^^^ dkka oaa iv toTs TTpo- 5
adcv bLrik6oixv ws (\)aLv6p.va axrrd, tovtohv ovt tl eaTLV ovt
(f>aCvTaL raAAa, ^v et /ut) ^cttlv. 'Akridr]. Ovkow Kai
avkk-qlSbriv el lttolixV, ^v et /i^ ^aTLV, ovbiv iaTLV, dp6oiS C
hv eXiTOLixev; ITayrdTrao-t ixV ovv. ELpria6o> toCvvv tovto
T Kal OTL, 0)5 OLKV, ^V LT ^aTLV e?re IXri aTLV, aVTO T Kal
rSAAa Kal iTpbs avrd Koi Trpbs dAA7jA.a -jrdyra TTdvTcos eori re
Kai ovK aTL Kal (f)aCvTaC re Kai ov (f>aCvTaL. ^'AATj^eVrara. 5

d7 irdvTT) B :T d 8 ijSr) rifx7v B rifuv tjSri T

iravraxri 6 2 irdXiv
:

B om. T 03 r&Wa B &\\a T 65 ivelri] tv ftr, B ^7; T

M
: : :

a2 ovSf T T ovS' ?Tt B : a6 Schleiermacher vTrh B T :

a7 ovS^ B oiAT T
: b 5 &\\a B r&Wa T :
 l^

#IAHB02

2i2KPATH2 HPllTAPXOS *IAHB02 St. II

p. II
2i2. "Opa 877, Opwrapxfj '"i^oi Aoyoy fxiXkeis Trapa ^iXri- a
^ou h\i(r6ai. vvvX Ka\ Trpoy rtya roy itap^ r}\nv djLK^io-^Tjreiv,

eay /x7y crot Kara vovv 77 Aeyoju.6yos. ^ovX.(l (rxryK<f)aX.ai(>)- b

(r(a[jL6a cKdrepov;
nP12. Odiyu juh; oSv.

S12. ^Ckrj^os juey toIwv ayadov Hvai (f)r}(TL to x^^^pdv

Tratri ^woi? Kal Tr]V rjbovrjv Kal TepyjrLV, Kal o(ra tov yivovs 5
o-ri TovTov (TV}X(\>uiva' To 8e irap' rfixcov a[X(f)ia-j3riTrifxd eo"rt

firj TavTa, aXXa t6 (f^povdv Kal to volv Kai fJLfj.in](r6ai kol

TCL rotJrcoy av (rvyyevrj, bo^av re dpdrjv /cat akr]6is \oyL(rfJLOvs,

TTJs ye rfbovifs dfxiivo) kol Awco yLyva-6aL crvfXTTaarLV o^raTtep

avTSiV hwaTO, fxcTaka^iLV bvvaTols 8e fXTaa-\Lv d)(f)e\Lfx<a- C

TOTov aTTavTo^v LvaL TidcrL rocs ovo-t re Kai i(rofXVois. fxoiv

ov\ ovTd) TTcos \4yofXV, 0) <i>tA7j/3e, (KaTcpoL;

<I>I. Yldirrcov fxkv ovv fxaXia-Ta, S) ^(aKparcs.
212. Ae'xr/ 8^ tovtov Tbv vvv bLbofxfvov, S) YlpdiTapxf, 5
Aoyoi';
nPX2. ^AvdyKrf 8exeo-0ai* 4>tA77j3os ydp iffXLV 6 Ka\6s
aTretpr/Kei'.

a 2 wvl B : vvv T riv Schleiermacher : tuv BT b i ^ck B :

tiv T b 7 /ic^uK^crdai T t^ fitnyrjcOat B

:

PLATO, VOL. II. 4

iic nAATHNOS
2i2. Aei 8t) irepl avT<av rpoTTi^ TravTi ToXi^Ois tttj TTfpav-
10 drjvai.;

d nPI2. Aet yap oSv.

SX2. "Wi bri, Trpos tovtois biop.o\.oyr]<T(ii)fX(.6a Koi Tohe.

nPi2. To TTolov;

2i2. *X2y yw i7ju,c5y eKaTepos i^iv ^j/vxijs Kal bi.dd(riv

5 a'7T0(f>aivei.v tlvo. iTrix^ipjjo^ei r^v bvvafxevrjv avOp^airois 'nacri.

Tov fSiov vbaCp.ova irapeyjnv. ap' ovx ovtu)s;

nPI2. OvT(t) pikv ovv.

2X2. OvKovv v/xeis pikv ttjv tov xaipav, Tjfxeis 8' a5 ttjv

Tov (\>poveiv;
lo nP12. "Eo-Ti raSrq.
2X2. Ti 8' &1' ciA.X?7 ns K/seirrcoy ToijT^ov (}>avf}; fx&v ovk,
e ay /xey ^^oz^rj fxaXXov (paivrfTai (Tvyyevrfs, rfTT(iip.e6a ,uey

apL(f)6Tpoi Tov TavTa )(ovTos /3e/3aico9 jStov, K/aaret 8e 6 r^s

12 rfbovifs Tov Trjs (ppovrf(r(tis;

nPX2. Nai.
2X2. '^Ay 8e ye (f>povrf(rei, viKd, fxkv ^p6vrf(ns Trfv rfboviqv,
ff 8e ^rrarat; raS0' ovro)? ofiokoyovfxevA (f>aT, rf tt&s;

5 nPX2. 'E/xoi yow 6oKei.

2X2. Tt b^ *iA^'/3a); rt (f)rjs;

4>I. 'E/xoi /xei' TT(xvT(as viKav rfbovrf boKi Koi 8o'et* (tv 8e',

ripcSrapxf avros yv(a(rri.

nPX2. ITapaSovs, S <i>tArj/3e, j^/xi;' roi' Ao'yoi^ ovk &v

10 ^Ti Kvpios etrfs ttjs TTpos 2coKp(ir?7 6/xoAoyta? 7/ Kat rov-
yayrtoy.

b ^I. 'AAr/^T/ Ae'yeis* dAAa yap a(f>o(novfxai koI fxaprvpofxai

vvv avTrfv Trjv de^v.

nPX2. Kat rffXiS (roi tovto>v ye avT&v (rvfXfx6pTvpS hv

ifXV, 0)? TavTa eAeyes h. Aeyeis. dAAa 8^ rd /ierd raCra

d4 '^yuwi/ B : avT&v T e i ^5o>'^] ^8o>'^ BT a 3 7 BT :

om. al. a4 dfxoKoyovfifva T : ^/toA.o^oS^uej' & B a7 ScB :

8' S T a9 pl\7i$e T : (plKrjfios B b3 76 BT : om. vulg.

b4 t7/nei> corr. Ven. 189 : ?i/j.fp BT
 ;

*IAHBOS xab

k^s, S> ^(oKpaTeSy o/xcos Koi f>iera 4>tA^/3ou k6vtos rj ottcos 5

hv ed(\ri Treipw/xe^a TTfpaCveiv.

212. rTeipareoy, 077' avTrjs 8t/ t^s ^eou, ^v o8e ^A(f)pobiTr]v
fxkv kiyicrdai (f)r}(n, to 8' okqOicrTaTov avTi]s ovo^ia 'HSorT/i
eiz^ai.

OPil. 'Op^oVara. 10

2i2. To 8' e/xor 8e'o9, o) Op&irapj^e, del Trpos ra rcSy ^eoji; C

ovofMaTa ovK ((ttl Kar avOpoiiTov, aXXa Trepa tov ^i^yCcrTov

(f)6j3ov. Kal vvv Trjv /xey 'A(f)pobCTr}v, oirr] (kcCvji (f>C\ov,

Tavrr] TTpocrayoptvo)' Tr]V 8e r]bovr]V olba ws eo-rt ttoikCXov,

Kox oTT(p iiTTOv, om cKiCvqs fjfJMS apxofxivovs ivdv[j.lcr6a(, 8et 5

Kal (TKOTrilv rjvTLva (f)V(riv exet co-rt yap, aKovdv fxkv ovtoos
aTrXats, 'iv tl, ]xop(f)as 8e br^trov iravToCas etArj<;^e /cat rt^a
TpoTTOV avofxoCovs aXkqXais. t8e yap' i]bicr6ai. fx4v <f>aixv

Tov aKokacTTaCvovTa av6p(x)TT0v, ^8eo-^at 8e Kat tov (ro)(f)po- d

vovvTa avT(a tQ> cro)(f>povtiv ijbe^rdaL 8' av Kal tov avor]TaC-
vovTa Kal avorjTcov bo^Qv Kal (kTrCbo^v fXcrT6v, ^8e<T^at 8' av
Tov (ppovovvTa avT(a rw (f^poveiv Kal tovto)V tG>v r}bovQ>v
(KaTepas tt&s av rts ojxoCas akXrjkaLS elvaL Kiyo)V ovk av6r]Tos 5
(f)aCvoLTo vbCKO)s;

nPX2. EtVt ]XV yap o.tt' kvavTCoiv, o) Sw/cpares, ai/rat

TTpayfxaTO)v, ov ]xi]v avraC ye dAAr/Aats kvavTCaL. ttG>s yap

fjbovf] ye fjbovr] [/xt/j ovx ofxoL^TaTov &v eiTj, roirro avTo eaurw, e
ttAvto^v xprfixaTov

2X2. Kai yap \p5>]xa, o> banx6vLe, \p(apLaTL' KaTd ye avTO

TOVTO ovbcv 8iotoret To \po>]xa eifat Trav, t6 ye ]xr]v fxiXav
TU) AeuKw Trdrres yLyv(ti(rKOfX(V ws Trpos rai bLd(f>opov etrat 5

xai kvavTL(j)TaTov ov Tvyxo-v^L. koX br] koX cr\rifxa cryrffxaTL

b7 8^ T : 5e B C 6 x<' ^ T iffx^v G : d i HvOpwirov

om. Galenus da 5' o5 T Alexander Aphrodisiensis Se B :

d3 5' a? B : 5' aS Kai T d 4 ippovovvra . <ppovuv T ffaxppovovvTa

. . :

. . . ffu(ppovf7v B d8 axiTal T : aliTai B e i iiSovp ye riSovi}

scripsi riSov^v ye fiSovii
: B : riSovii ye TiSovy T /*}; secl. Badham
Toiho airrh] rh y' avrh ci. Stallbaum e3 XP^^M"'''* ^T XP^^M^c^tos
al. Ast e4 oiiflt' T irS' BT : rb vav vulg. Galenus
I2e nAATX2N0S
Kara Tavrov yevei ixiv eori 'nav v, to. 8e ixeprj rois fxep(nv

13 avTov Ta ixV ivavTKaTaTa a\Xi]\o(.s, to. 8c 8ta</)oporrjr' iypvTa

fxvpLav TTOV TvyxdveL, Kal TroWa (Tcpa ovtcds Xov6^ ivpr\-

(TOixev. &<rT TOVT(o y rw \6y<a /^t) TriVreve, roi irdvTa to,

ivavTKaTaTa ^v ttoiovvti, <^o^ovp.ai 8e /u.77 Tivas r]hovas

5 ^Sovais vp'q(ro}j.v kvavTias.

nP12. "lo-o)?' dAXa rt tovO^ r]}xG>v ^Kdylrei tov koyov;
2i2. "Ori Trpoa-ayopeve is avrd dv6p.oia ovTa kTp<a, </)^-

(TO}iiv, 6v6p.aTi.' Aeyets ydp dyaOd irdvT etrai Ta fibea. to

fxkv ovv ixr] ovxL rjbia elvat, Ta -qbea X.6yos ovbels dfx^jyLcr^rjTei'

b KaKa 8' ovTa avr&v Ta TTokkd Kal dyaOd bi, ws ^juets <j)afXV,

ofx<i>s TrdvTa <tv iTpocrayopev^i.s dyaOd avrd, ofxokoy&v dv6p.oia

eii^at, rw k6y<o e? rts o-e Trpoo-arayKa^ot. rt ovv brf Tavrov
fv rats KaKais 6fxoi<i)s Kal kv dyaOais kvov irdcras rfbovds

6 dyaOov etmt irpoaayopcvHs;

nP12. YIQs Ae'yets, u> SwK/oares; oiet ydp Tiva a-vy\oiprf-

<ra-dai., 6ep.Vov rjbovrfv (TvaL TayaOdv, etra dve^<r6ai <rov

C kiyovTos Tas fxv (Ivai TLvas dyadds rfbovds, ras 8e' riras
ere'/oas avr&v Ka^ds;

2X2. 'A\A' ovi; dvofxoiovs ye (^T/o-eis avras dXA.^A.ats eirat

Kai rti^as kvavTias.

5 nP12. Ouri Ka6^ 6<rov ye rfbovai.

2X2. ndAiv ets rov aurov (f)ep6fxc6a k6yov, Il/cxtfra/jxc.

ov8' dpa rfbovrfv rjbovrjs bLd<f)opov, dkkd TTaa-as ofxoias elvaL

(^rf^rofxiv, Ka\ Ta TrapabiiyfxaTa rffxds Ta wvbrf ki\6ivTa

Ovb\v TLTpco<TKL, 1TL(r6fX6a 8e KCLl p0VfXV dlTep 01 TTdvT<t)V

d </)auAo'rarot re /cat jrept Ao'yous dfxa vioL.

nPX2. Td TTota 8^ Ae'yets;

a5 evp^fiaofi ivayrlas B : fvp^ffofiev ivavriais pr. T a6 ^/uwv

BT : ijfuv vulg. a9 oux^ T : ovx B b2 gyua>s] Sfiolais Her-
mann wcJvto T om. B : (fev) dvfiyuojo Hermann b 3 irpo<r-
ovoy/f c{^( Jackson b 4 ^j/i'] ivopuv Thompson ivvouv Apelt :

c T TjSovds B T om. al. : 07 ^5oj/^v T G rjSovii B ?f ot B T : :

om. G C 8 tA vvv 5'}; B 5^ to 'C' T : C 9 ouSeV Tt rpdxru

Jackson Treio-rf^tOo Badham irup6fi.e6a B Trtipoo-tJyueSo T
: :
 <I>IAHB02 I3d

Sn. "Ort <r fXLfxoviJt.VO^ tyo) koI afivvoixfvos iav TokfiQ

Kiyiiv y to avofJLOioTaTov eort t^ avoixoioTaTia TravTcov

o/xotoVaroi^, e^o) ra avra (rot Xeyctr, xat (f^avovix^da. yc 5

vecoTfpoi Tov b^ovTOs, Kal 6 Ao'yos rjfuv eK-Trecrcor otx^y^^eT-at.

TraAty ovy avTov avaKpov(aiJ.da, Kal ra^' ay twres ets raj

ofxoias io-(o$ av ttcos dAAi/Aois o-uyxwpT/o-ai/xey.

nPil. Acye irwj; e

212. 'E/bte ^es vtto o-ou TraAty (poiT<afXVov, S ripwrapxf'
nPi2. To 770101; 877;

2X2. 4>po'j;r70-ts re xai eTTtcrTj/UT/ Kat yous Kat Trdi;^' oTToaa

br] Kar apxas eyo) Oiixivos ilnov ayada, Stepoorw/uei^os 5rt 5

TTor' eoTty ayadov, 5p' ov TavTov Treto-oi^rat roiJro OTrep 6 o-os

Ao'yos;

nPi2. nws;
212. rioAAat re at a-vvaTraa-at, ftna-TrJixat. bo^ova-iv eirat
Kat avoixoioi rti^es avT&v dAAT/Aais* et 8e Kat kvavriai W] 10

yiyvovTai rtr^es, apa d^tos di; eiTjr roC StaAe^yeo-^at yy, et 14

(po^rjOils TovTo avTo ixrjbfixiav avoixoiov (f)air]v fTTia-Triixriv

(TncrTriixri yiyvio-Oai, Kairet^' rnxlv odroos d Adyos uiaiTip

ixvdos aTTokoixiVos oixoiro, aurot 8e a-ia^oineda eirt rtros
dAoytas; 5

nP12. 'AAA' ov ixrfv 8ct tovto ycreo-^ai, TrAf/y rou a-oiOrjvai..

To ye />tT/y /xot lo-oy tov aov re Kat e/xou Adyou ap4crKL'

TToAAat /xey ^Soyal Kat drd/xotot yiyvi^rdoiv, TroAAai 8e
TI LCTTTIIXaL Kal dtd^OpOt.
2X2. Tfjy Toiwv Sta^opdrrjra, w ITpctfrapxf [''ov dya^ou] b
roO r' e/xou Kai tov aov ixrf aiTOKpvTTToixfVoi, KaTaTL64vTs 8c

ets To ix<rov, To\ix&pLV, &v 177/ cAcyxd/xcrot ixrivvauiaL iTOTipov

d6 iKWfaicu rjniv T
^/111/ ^Kirccrci!!' B : d 7 &i' i6vrfs Ven. i8g :

avi6vTts BT d^afla B T ayad6v per errorem Bekker

65 :

e6 iffrlv i,ya06v B: eVrl Td^yaSJc T 6 10 i.v6noioi T av6fioiai B :

a 2 /itrj 5e juia;/ B /t>)5f filav T

: av^fioiov B T &i/- av6/j.oiov vulg. :

a 3 ouTetfy B o&ros T : a 6 Sc? T G Se?' B a 8 ytyvfaOwv']

:

yiyvfo-Oov B T b i tov iyoBov seclusi auctorc Bury b 3 i\fyx6-

fifvoi BT : fXfyxofxivw Grouius : i\tyx6i.fvai Stallbaum
PLATO, VOL. II. i**
i4b nAATilNOS
i]bovi}v rayadov bd Aeyeii' r] (f>p6vi]aiv ij tl Tpirov aAAo etvai.
5 vvv yap ov hr]TTOv irpos ye avTo tovto (^iKovikovihv, ottcos
Tavd^ h 8'
ayo) Tidefxai,, Tavr ^crTai tol viKSiVTa, 77 crv, r<ji

aXTf]6(rTaT(a hd ttov a-vfxpiaxctv ri\ms afjt.<f)(o.

nPX2. Aei yap ovv.

C 22X2. TovTov Toivvv tov koyov en \xakkov hC 6\xo\oyias
/3e/3aicoo-&)/Ae^a.

nPX2. Tov TToTov hi];

2Ii. Tbv Tracri Ttap^xovTa avOpdtTTOis TTpdyfxaTa eKoOcri re

5 Kal aKovcnv vioi.s Kal evioTi.
nP12. Ae'yf a-a(f)(TTpov.

212. Toy wvhr] TrapaTticrovTa Xeyco, (f)va-(i jro)? Tre^f^VKOTa

davfiaaTov. kv yap hif to, TToWa eirai koI t6 tr TToAAa

OavfxaaTov \X$V, Kal pqhiov afX(f)Laj3r]Trjaai. T(a TovTcav

To oTTorepoyow TLOefxevia.

nPI2. 'Ap' ovv Ae'yets oTav ris e/xe ^f/ YIpdTapxpv va

d yeyoi^ora (f)vaL ttoAAous eii^ai TraAtv rovs e)u.e Kal kvavTLovs
dAA^Aois, fieyav Kal afiLKpov TLOefx^vos *cai fSapvv Kal Kov(f)ov
Tov avTov Ka\ aAAa fivpia;
2i2. 2v /Lte'y, S ri/jwra/axe, (tprjKas to. hchrffKVfXfva tG>v

5 OavfxaaT&v iTepl to kv Kal TroAAci, avyKe)(0)prffxiva 8e ws ttos

etTrety vtto Traircoy T/Sr; /at) Seti' rcoz^ rotovrcoy aTTreadaL,
7TaLhapL(ahr] Kal pqhLa Kal a(f)6hpa tols X6yoLS ifxir^hLa

viTo\afxfiav6vT<i)V yiyvcaOaL, eiret fxrfhe tcl rotcx8e, oray riy

e eKcicrroii to. /xe'Ar/ re Kal afxa fx^pr] SteAcoy roi Ac^yco, Trcxi^ra

raura to kv kKuvo etmt Sto/xoAoyr/o-ci/xei^os, eAe^y^r/ KaTa-

yek&v OTL TcpaTa Sir/myKaorat (fxxvaL, t6 re kv ws ttoAAci ecrrt

Kat aTTLpa, Kal tcl TroAAa cws tv fx6vov.

5 nPI2. 2v 8e 8r) rrota, S 2cocpares, ere/)a Aeyeis, & fxrfn^t)

avyKe)(U)pr]fjAva hehrffXiVTaL irepl Tov avTov tovtov \6yov;

b 4 Tt T : om. B b5 toOto corr. Coisl. toCto ^ B T : b 6 oyi]

it^o) B : & 'yi) T b 7 5?B 5^ pr. T G
: C 9 a.ix<pi<r$rjTri<rat
B hv aij.<l)i(r$r)Trj<rai T
: d 2 rtdffxfifos B rtBefxfuovs T
: e i afia
B T &\\a Badham
:
 <I>IAHB02 iSa

2f2. 'OTTOTav, S) TTal, t6 'kv /x^ t&v yiyvoiiivoiv re Kal 15

aTtoWvfifvoov ns TidrJTai, KadaTrcp apTms rjfx^ls tiTTOjuey.

ivTav6ol niv yap Kal to tolovtov iv, oTrep iinop.iv vvvhri,

(TvyKiyjijiiprjTaL to fxr] b^LV eAeyx^ '^' oTav b( ns em avdpcDTTov

(TTiXfi^prj TLdio-OaL KoX ^ovv fva KOL To Kakov ^v Ktti t6 ayaOov 5

V, TTipX TOVTOiV T&V kvdba>V Kal t5)V TOLOVTCaV fl TTOkkrj

(TTTovbr] fXTa StaipeVeco? dii(\)L(T^rfTr](TLS yiyv^TaL.

nPX2. Um;
SH. Ylp5)Tov y.\v et TLvas 8et roiavras eimt /ixoyadas b
vTTokaiJLjBdvfLV dkr]6&s oijo-as' etra ttws aS TavTas, fXLav

kKdaTrfv ovcrav det r^y avr^y Kat fjtT^re yeveo-LV firfTi oK6pov
TTpo(Tbi\ofxivriv, ofxois LvaL (Sc^aLOTaTa fxCav TovTrfv; p,eTa

8e TOVT iv Tols yLyvofxivoLS av Kal aTTeCpoLs LTe 8teo-7ra- 5

(Tfxivrfv Ka\ TToXkd y^yovvlav 6t4ov, eW okrfv axrrrfv avTrjs

\(i)pLS, 6 brf TTdvT(i)V dbvvaT(OTaTov (fiaivoLT av, tovtov koX
%v dfxa iv kvL re Kat ttoAAoi? yCyvecrdaL. TavT (o-tl Ta
irepl Ta TOLavTa ^v Kal Trokkd, dAA' ovk KLva, S) Ilp(aTapx> C
aTTda-rfs aTTopCas airia fxrf Kok&s ofxokoyrfdivTa Kal (ViTOpCas

[dv] av KaAws.

nP12. OvKow xpv Tovd^ fifias, o) ^(aKpaTs, kv r^ vvv

TTp&Tov bLa7Tovrf(raa-daL; 5

212. 'X2s yovv eyco (f^aCrfv dv.

nPXl. Kai Trdi^ras toCvvv rifxds vTTokajSe crvyx^^P^^iv aoL

Tov(rb Ta TOLavTa' '^CkrflBov 8' taois KpdrLO-Tov kv rw vvv

iTTp(OT(OVTa fXrf KLVLV V KfCfXCVOV.

2X2. Eiei'" tt66V ovv tls TavTrfs dp^rfTaL ttoAAt/s ovotjs d

Kai Trayroias Trept to. dix(f)La-^rfTovfX(va fxdxv^; dp' (vdivbe;

nPX2. nd^ey;
2i2. *PafX(v TTOV TavTov ^v kol iroAAd xnro koycov yvyvo-

a 3 vvv Sij T vvv : Se7v B a 7 <rirovSii secl. Badham : erirouSfj

R. G. Bury vov 8^ :
J. B. Bury wov: iiSri Apelt b4 post irpoa--

8X''M*'^*' Jacunam statuit Hoffmann '

'dfius^ '6\(ds Badham ovrws :

Susemihl ^joi/] fort. /t^i/ Zeller c3 &/ secl. Badham c^rovd'

B : TTou TovO' T d i oiv B : oZv &v T d2 tvBfvSe iro0ev
Socrati tribuunt BT d 4 irov BT : irot vulg.
 :

15 d nAAfl2N02
5 fxeva TrepLTpcxfi-v TrdvTr) Ka6' eKaa-Tov t&v k^yo\xiv(uv dci,

Ka\ TiaXai kcu vvv. koX tovto ovTe jxr] TTava~t]TaC Trore ovT^

Tjp^aTo vvv, dXA' ecrTi to tolovtov, cos ipLol (j)aLVTaL, t5)V

koycjv avT&v aOdvaTov tl kol ayrjpoiv Trddos cv rjpXv o hf.

npSiTov avTov yva-dfJ.Vos eKda-TOTe t5>v vioiv, rjo-dds &s

e TLVa a-o(f)Las rjvprjKOis 6r]a-avp6v, v</)' rjbovris (vdova-La t Kal
irdvTa Ktret \6yov ^o-jbteyo?, rore fx(v eirt OdT^pa kvkK&v Kal
a-vfx^vpoiiv ets ^v, tot^ 8e irdkLV dvcLXLTTUiV Kal bLafxepLCcav,
ets aTiopiav avTov piev TTpGtTov Kal fxdXLa-Ta, Kara/3dAA.coi;,

5 bevTepov b' dei roi' kypixevov, dvTi vecaTepos &vt( irpfa-fivTipos

dvTC rj\L^ ciiv Tvyxdvr}, (f)ib6fXV0S ovt iraTpbs ovtc fxrjTpos
i6 oiJre dAAou t&v dKov6vT(ov ovbv6s, oXiyov be Kai tG>v dAAojy

f<f a)y, ov fx6vov t&v dv6p(oTTU)V, eTret IBapj3dpoiv ye ovbevos

hv cf)La-aLTO, (LTrep fxovov kpfxrfvia irodev
^X^'"
nP12. 'Ap', Si SwKpare?, ovx opas rjfxGiV to itkrfOos, otl
5 vioL irdvTfs ka-fxiv, Ka\ ov (f)oj3fi fxrj (tol fxcTa <I>iA^/3ou

(TvviTnO^afxeda, kdv rjfms \oLbopfjs; ofx^as be fxavOdvofxev yap

Aeyet?, et rts Tpdiros ea-TL Ka\ fxrfxavrf Trjv fxkv TOLavTXfv
Tapayrfv rjfXLV efco roii Adyou evfxevtas tto)? d'7reA0eti', obov 8e'

b rti^a KaAAtco TavTrfs eirt tov k6yov dvevpcLV, (tv re irpoQvfxov

TovTO KoiX rjfxels a-vvaKokovOrfa-ofxev ets bvvafXLV ov yap
(TfXLKpos o TrapoiV Adyos, aj SwK/aares.
Si2. Ov ydp ovv, oi Ttalbes, w? (fitfo-LV vfxds irpoa-ayo-

5 pevoiiv 4>tAr//3os. ov fxrfv ecrTL KaKkLoav bbos ou8' hv yevoLTo

rfs eyoi epaa-Trfs fxev dfXL dei, iroAAdKts 8e' fxe rjbrj 8ia(/>v-

yova-a eprffxov Koix diropov KaTea-Trfo-ev.

nPIi. Tis avTr]; AeyeV^co fx6vov.
c 212. ^Hy 8r;A$o-at fxkv ov itdvv x'^^^'^^^' XPW^^'- ^^
TTayxdkeTTOv TrdvTa yap oaa Tex^tfs ex^P-^^^- dvrfvpiOrf
TTWTrore Std TovTrfs (pavepd yeyove. crK^TreL be rjv keyco.

d 7 ^ffri T : cVi B d8 &yr}pwv (sic') B 63 aufiXirTuu B

avtXiTTo' T a 3 fi6vou fpfiijvfa BT : kpirrtvea fi6vov vulg.
b 5 yfvoiTo B : yiyvoiTo T b 6 ^sj <i^) ^s Madvig c i XPV'
(T6ai T :
xp'7''' B c 2 avtvptd^ B : &/ evpfdrj T


a>IAHBOS l6c

nPXi. y\eye ixovov.

Hiii QcQv fjikv eis avOputirov^ 8oVts, a>s yi KaTa(\)aiviTai 5
e/xoi, TTO^ey e/c ^eoi)!' ppL(f)r] 8ia rtros ITpo/xrj^eajs 5/xa
^avoraTO) rti^i Trfpi* cat ot /jiey TraAaiot, KpcLTToves rnxGiv
Kal (yyvTepo) Oidv oIkovvtcs, TavTTjv (prip-rjv irapiboa-av,

u)S e (vos fikv Kal TTokk^v 6vto)v t&v det Xcyonamv etrai,

irepas 8e xat aiTip(av iv avrots crvp.(f)X/rov i\6vT(t)V. 8etv lo

oily i7juia9 tovtoov ovT(t) biaKKoap.r]fji,4v(t)v det /xtai' t8e'ay Trepi d

7rain-os e/cdo-rore deixdvovs C^rety evprj^reiv yap evov(rav
ear ovy p.eTa\a^(Dp.ev, fxeTa p.Cav bvo, ei ttcos eto-t, o-KOTrety,

ei 8e /xr/, r/3ets ?/ rtm akAov aptdp.6v, Kal tS)V %v (Keivcav

(Ka(rTov TiAkiv b)(ravT(ji)S, /xe'x/)t77ep av to Kar ap)(as ev /x?j 5

ort ^v Kal TToAAd Kat aTretpd eo-rt ix6vov tbrj rts, dAAd ai
oTTOo-a* Tr)v 8e tov aiTeCpov Ibeav iTpbs t6 Trkfjdos /x?/ Trpoa--

(j^epdv trpXv &v rts tov apidfxbv avTov iravTa KaTibr] Tbv
IxeTo^v Tov aTTfCpov re Kat tov v6s, t6t 8' rjbr} rd ev
iKacTTOv tG)V TTavTiav ets rd aiTeipov p.(6iVTa yaCpei.v kav.
ol fxkv ovv 6(oC, direp eiTTor, ovrcos ripuv irapibo^rav (rKOiTelv

Koi ixav6dv(Lv kol bLbd(rK(Lv dAA?jAovs' ot 8e vvv rwy dv-

6p(aTT(t)v ao(f)ol kv jxev, 6tt(os av rvx^aa-L, kol TroAAd 6dTT0V 17
Koi jipabvrepov ttolov^tl tov bdovTos, jxeTd 8e Tb ev diTeLpa
ev6vs, rd 8e //eVa a?;rovs eK(f)vyL ols 8taKexwpto"Tat t6 re
oiaAeKrtKois TrdAti' Kat to ipLarLKois rjfxas TTOteto-^at irpbs
dAA?jAous rovy Adyovs. 5
nPX2. Td jxev TT(DS, S) ^coKpaTfS, boK(a aov fxavddvLV,
rd 8e eri aa(f)4(rTpov 8e'o/>tat d Ae'yets aKOvaaL.

212. ^a<f)S fxr\v, S) Hp(aTap-)(> eo-rty iv rots ypdfx-

C 7 ^aforar^ T (sed o in ras.) ; (powwrir^f B Kpeirropfs (ovtss)

Badham c 8 ^/trjv B : <^/xjj T e9 ai T aJ ix B
:

cl 2 ^TjTf?!' T : (y\rwv B ivovaav T : li^oGirav B d3 /it-

AikfiwfKv BT : /caTaA.tf/Sw/ie' Stephanus : x^^ufxfv Badham d^ ?'

iKuvwv'^ iv iKfiv<f> Ast d7 irpo(T<pfp(iv Tb : Trpo<p4p(iv B e i 5'

iJ57j T : 8)j 5? B a i koI TroWh. secl. ohm Stallbaum to iroAAo :

Dindorf a2 /BpaSuTfpoi/l Ppaxvrfpov Badham ri] tA Jackson

a 4 iptariKws T : dpKrriKus B a 7 (ra<p(ar(pov Sto^ai B dto/xai :

(Ta<pf<rrepov T a8 ypJi/jLfia^riv B : ypdufj.a<riv T : vpdyij,a<rtv G

17 a

b
jxacnv b
-TreTratScvorai.
kiyoi, koL
nAATilNOS
kaii^av avTo h> tovtoi^ ota-Trep
^
Kal

nP12. Uois;
212. ^(ovt) ixev rjixiv ka-Ti ttov ^iia 8ta tov (tt6iw.tos
lovcra, Kcd aiTapos av iTXrjdei., TTavTOiV re koX kKaarov.

5 U?a. Ti ixriv;

2i2. Kat ovbev Tep(o ye tovtu^v ia-ixev Troo o-0(f)oi, oirre

OTL t6 aTreipov avTrjs Xa-p,iv ovd^ oti to ev dAX' ori TTocra

T eoTt /cai oTTOta, rouro' e(rri ro ypaixixaTiKov ^KacTTOv
TTOcovv rjixcav.

lo nPX2. 'AkridecTTaTa.
212. Kat /ix^v Kai ro ixova-iKov 6 ruyxa^ei TroioCy, roCr'
eo-rt TavTov.
npi2. n<Ss;
C 2i2. 'Poovri ixev ttov Kal to KaT (Kcivriv Tr^v Ti\vriv e<rrt

ixla iv avTrj.
nPi2. hm 8' ov;
212. Avo 8e dS>p.iv ^apv Kal o^, xai Tpirov oixotovov.

5 ^l
Tws;
nPX2. Ovrfo?.
212. 'AAA.' oijTTO) cro(f)b9 av et?j? rr/;^ ixovaiKriv etScos

raSra /.om, /x?/ 8e etScos a>s y' cttos eiTrety et? TavTa
ovbevbs ato? ecr?/.

10 nPX2. Ov ya/3 ovv.

212. 'AAA', o ^tAe, eTreiSai' kd^jis to. biaan^ixaTa biroa-a

eorrt Tbv apcdixbv Trjs (f)0)vjjs o^vttitos re 7re/3i Kat (BapvTriTOs,

d Kat oTTota, Kat rovs opovs t&v biaa-TrnxaTojv, Kal to. eK tov-

TO)v bcra crvaTriixaTa yeyovev a KartSorres ot iTpoardev iTap-

eboa-av ripXv rot? eiropi.evois eKeivois Kakelv avTO. apixovias,
iv re rats Kivqa-ea-tv av tov (rwftaros eTepa ToiavTa evovTa

b 3 7)[uv T : om, B b 4 &Tr(ipos B : atrflpovs T b6 ovSif

T ovS' fV B
: e I Koi rh T : om. B : Koi Hermann c 8 /nSva
B T om. G: Se flSii>s B : flSiis Se T
 B

<I)IAHB02 i7d

Trddr} yLyv6fJLva, h bi} 8t' dpidixm' fxTpr}dVTa Seir av (f>acn, 5

pvdfiovs Kal piTpa (TTOvofjM^eLV, Kal ap.a (vvoeXv ws oijT<i)

beX TTcpl TraiTos kvos Kal ttoKX&v a-KOTTelv oTav ydp axrra

T kd^r}^ ovTO), t6t iyVov <ro(p6s, oTav t dXXo TUiV tv e

driovv TovTr) a-KOTrovfxevos lArjs, ovt<os ^fX(l)po)v Trept tovto
yeyovas' to 6' di:i.p6v crf kKdcrT(t)V Kca kv eKaorot? 'TtA.^^os

direipov eKdaroTe TTOtet tov (ppovelv Kai ovk eXXoycfxov ov8'

fvdpiOfxov, &T ovk is dpLOfxov ovbeva ev ovbevl TrwTrore 5

aTriSoiTa.

nPi2. KaAAtora, S ^CKrjjBe, e/xotye Ta vvv Aeyo/xem

eiprfKivai (f)aiVTai ScoK/odrrjs.

'Pl. Kdp.ol TavTd-ys avTd' dAAa rt brj ttotc irpos rjpLas 6 18

Adyos ovTOS vvv et/arjrat jcai ri TTore /SouAd/xeros;

212. ^Opd&s /ueVrot Tovd^ VfJMS, 2 IIp(aTapx, rfpdTrjKe

<l>iAi7/3os.

nPI2. ndi/v fXV ovv, Kal d-noKpivov ye avT(a. 5

2X2. Apdo^o) raCra 8teA^a)v (rfxiKpbv tl ire/Ji avrwi^ roi/-

ro)!'. &(n:p ydp %v otlovv et r^s TTore Ad/3ot, tovtov, cos

(f)afxv, ovK ^ir' aTtdpov (\)vaLv 8et ^keiTeLv (v6vs dAA' eTrt

rtm dpL6fx6v, ovrco Kai ro ivavTLOV OTav rts ro aTretpoi'

di^ayxao-^ TrpaiTov kafx^dvLV, fxrf eTri ro ti' ei^v?, dAA.' [eir'] b
dpLdfJudv av TLva irA^^os (Kaarov iyovTd tl KaTavoelv, reAeu-

rdj' re e/c irdvTcav ets eV. TrdAii' 8e kv rots ypdfXfxaaL to

vvv \(y6fX(vov kdj3(i)fii,V.

nPi2. ncSs; 5
2X2. 'ETreiS?) (fxovrfv diretpoi' KarevoT/cey etre rts ^eds
eire Kat ^etos dv6p(OTros d)S Adyos (v AiyvTrr^a @(v6 rtm

ds xaflrj] ^tct^y Poste a5 B outo T

: d6 f^vOfiovs T: apid-
novs B S/ta T : iAAa B d7 outo pr. T G . TaCTti Bt e i Srav
T( B : 2to' 5 T !>' B : ovruv T : &vt<i)v %v Wohlrab e 2 eAps]
^XV^ Adam tovto T : tovtuv B 64 ovS' ivipiBfiov T ovSev' :

aptdfihv B a I cd/uol Badham : /<a2 /xoi B koI ijxoX T

: a 3 tovQ'
T: TaCe' a7 If T : li/ ? B a8 (pvcriv hti^T Su <pvaiv :

vulg. b I rhtv^RT : rhevG iir' secl. Liebhold b2 koto-

'or'] (OTo voD' Apelt b7 fftCd T : 6f{i0 B : in G lacuna
i8b nAATilNOS
TOVTOv yV(<rdaL Xiyojv, os Trpwros ra (fiMVi^evTa iv ro)

aireCpio KaTevorfo-fv ov\ ^v ovtu akka tt\(l(i), kol tt6,\lv

C ^Tepa (fyuivrjs p.ev ov, (f)d6yyov be p.Ti)(OVTa tlvo^, apL6p.ov

be TLva Kal tovtojv elvaL, TpLTOv 8e eiSos ypap.pAT(jdv 8ie-

(rn\<TaTO to. vvv ky6p.va a(f)(i)va rjp.lv t6 /uera tovto Swfpei
TCL T a(j)doyya Kal a(f)0)va p.XpL kvos kK<xa-TOV, Kal tcl (f)(i)irt'j-

5 (VTa Kal Ta /xeVa KaTO, tov avTov Tp^irov, ecos apLdp.ov avTS)V

Xa^MV kvL re kKacrTiii Ka\ (rvp.Tra(rL (ttol^^^clov eTrcoyo/jiacrc'

KaBopiav 8e ws ovhiis r)p.(av ovb^ av ^v avTO KaO^ avTo &vv

7T<xvT(t)V avT&v p.ddoL, TOVTov Tov b(rp.ov av koyL(Tap.VO^ ws
d ovra iva Kal irAvTa rarra iv ttcos Trotourra iiiav e7r' avTol^i

ws ov(rav ypapLp.aTLKr}v Texyrjv i7r(f)dy^aT0 Ttpo^r^Lit^av.

4>I. Tavr' eri (ra(f)(rTpov KLV(ji)v avTa yc TTpos akkrjka,

S) YIpcoTapx^, epLadov to b* avTo p.OL tov Aoyou vvv rc Kal

5 (rfXLKpbv p.Trpo(r6V eWeiTrerai.

212. M&v, S) 4>iA7j/3e, t6 tl Trpbs cttos av Tavr koTLv;

^l. Nat, TOVT (rTLV 6 TT<xkaL ^jjrou/Aei' eyoi re Kal

Up(aTapxos.
2X2. 'H p.r}v tt' avT^ y rjbr} ycyovores Cv^cXtc, wy (ftris,

e TraAai.

<i>I. riais;

2112. 'A/!)' ov TTpl (f)povri(r0)S ^v KOL ^bovrjs rjfXLV e^

apxrj^ 6 koyos, biTOT^pov avTolv aipTOv;
5 4>I. ncSs yap ov;
212. Kal p.r]v v ye K6.Tpov airrolv LvaC <f)aiiV.

<I>I. Yldw pikv ovv.

2X2. Tovr' avT6 toCvvv 17/u.as 6 TTp6(rdv koyos aTrairet,

TT(aS (TTLV V KCU TroAAa aVT&V KdTpOV, KOL Tt5)S /U.7J aiTLpa

19 evdvs, dkkd TLvd Trore dpLdp.6v cKaT^pov ifXTTpoardev KKTr]TaL

Tov d7TLpa avTG)V Ka(rTa y^yovevaL;

h8 tts T us B 05 apidnhv avrwv B T ahrwv a.pi9fi.hv vulg.

:

C 8 Tovrov BT : rovrov 8f G d i irdi/ra Tct ravra B ravra irAvra T

:

d4 T* T : 76 B d9 (^nreirt B f^-qrurt T
: a a vtSV T :

alrhv B
 <I)IAHB02 19 a

nPi2. OvK eis (})avk6v ye (p(jiTi]}xa, 00 4>iA.rj/3e, ovk 016*

ovTii>a TpoTTov KVKk(o TToos TTepLayayoiv ?//ixas ju^e/3A7jKe

SojKpd-njy. cat o-Kdiret 8?) -Trdre/ao? r/ju,&)i; cnTOKpLvelTat to 5

z^i' p(t)T(afji.(vov. X(rois brj yeXolov to e/>te tov koyov 8id-
^oxpi' TraiTeAcos v-TroordyTa bia to /x^ Svmo-^at t6 vvv
ipbaTrjdkv aTTOKpLvacrdaL crol TtakLv tovto 'npoa-T<XTTLV' yekoio-

Tipov 8' oi/xai TToAv ro pirjbdTcpov fjp.(t)V bvva(r9aL. (TKOTTei b

5^ tC bpdcropifv. eiSr/ ydp juoi boKcl vvv epoiTav r)bovijs
i]fjMS 2(OKjodr7/s" eire ((ttlv eire /x?/, Kal oTTO^ra eo-ri Kat OTrota'
rf/y r' aS (\)povr\(Ti(as iripL KaTO, ravrd wo-avrcos.
2X2. 'AAr/^eWara Aeyet?, w Trat KaAAtow /xt/ ydp bvvd- 5

/Lieroi roirro ard iravTos kvos kol 6p.0L0v kcCl TavTov bpav
Kai Tov ivavTiov, ws d irapekdaiv koyos ifirivv^rev, ov8ei? ei?
ovbev ovbevos av r}p.S)v ovbiiroTe yivoLTo d^tos.
nPH. S^e^dr olkv ovtoos, S) SwKpares, ^x^'^* dAAd c
KaAdv fxev to avfXTtavTa yLyv(aa-KeLv rw a-(a(f)povi, bfvrepos
5' etmi ttAoi;? 80/cet fxrf kavddvdv airrov avTov. tl brf fxoL

TOVTO eipr/rai to, vvv; eyw o-ot (f^pdaoo. (tv Tifvb^ rjfxXv Trjv

a-vvova-Lav, o) SwK/sares, eTreScoKas Trdo-t Kat creavT^v TTpos 5

rd SteAeV^at rt twv dvdpojTTLVcov KTYffxdTODV dpLaTov. 4>tAr/-

/3ov ydp eiTrdyros fjbovifv Kal Tepxlriv Kal ^''^P^^ ''"' Trdi'^'

oTrdo-a TOLavT' koTL, (tv itpos avTO. di^retTres ws ov raura

dAA eKetrd eo-rty d iroAAdKt? rjfxds avTovs dvafXLfxvrfaKOfx^v d
kKOVTis, 6pdS>s bpa>VTs, Iv iv fxvTffxrf TTapaKfifxcva kKdT^pa
^aaavL^yfTaL. (f)rjs b\ ws eotKe, crv to TTpocrprf6rfa6fXVOV
opdws afxeivov fibovijs ye dyadov eimt vovv, iTTLOTrffxrfv,

aijvea-LV, riyvrfv Kai Trdrra av Ta tovto)v axryycvif, (d) KTaadaL 5

Sety dAA' ovxi eKetm. rovrcoi' 5?/ /xer' dfX(f)La jBrfTif a(0)s

(KaTiputv k\divTO)v 7//xety o-ot />ierd Tratdtds r/iretAr/o-a/Aei'

wy ovK d(f)rfaofx(v otKabi ae iTplv av tovto)v t5)v koyoov e

b2 ^Sot^v T : B
r]Sovi]v c x*"' ^ ^ ovrws x*"' ^
i

C3 awT^' ouT({i' T : aur6vB ouT<i' Hermann

: d^ & Ven. 189 :

om. BT d6 Sejc B 5*? :T a^</>j(r/3ijT^<rws B ifi<pi(rPr)r-ff :

fftuv T d7 iratSiai T iraiSfias pr. B

:
19 e nAATilNOS
TTepas iKavov yivrjTai rt biopLo-devTOiv, a-v be (rvv\(apr](Tas Kal

ebaxas eis TavO^ rjiuv aavTov, ^/ixets 8e bi] Aeyo/xev, Kaddirep

01 TTalbes, OTL Ttiiv 6p6(as bodivT(v a(f)aCpfa-ts ovk Ioti* iravcraL
5 btj Tov TpoTTOv ripxv aTTavT&v tovtov iirl to, vvv keyopicva.
2i2. Tiva Aeyet?;
ao nPfi. Eis arropCav ipi^dWcov Kal avepcaTStv &v p.rj bvvaC-
pLeO' av LKavrjv a-noKpLcrLV kv roi TrapovTL btbovaL (tql. /lct)

yap oi(aiJL6a rekos rjpuv elvaL t&v vvv Trjv TrdvTdiV f}p.&v

cLTTopCav, ctAA' ei bpav Tovd^ ^jMets dbvvaTOvpiev, o-ot bpacrTeov

5 V7r(r-)(pv ydp. ^ovXevov brj Trpbs raura avTos iroTepov rjbovrjs

ftbr] croL Kal e7rL(rTrjfxr]s bLaLpereov rj Kal kaTeov, et tt?; Ka6^

eTepov TLva TpoTTov oXos T et Kat ^ovkeL br^kStcraC Trtos aXAws
TCL vvv dfxcf)Lcrl3r]Tovp.eva Trap' rfpXv.

b S>i2. Aetroy ]xkv TOLVvv eTL jrpocrboKdv ovbev Sei tov kpA,
eiretS^ tov&' ovtcos etires* to ydp et jBovkeL pr]6ev kveL TTdvra

cfyojSov e/caoTcoi' 7re'pt. Trpbs be av tols fxvqfxr]v TLvd boKL

tCs fLOL beboiKevaL de&v rjfuv.

5 nPii. ITciis br] KoX TCvoiv;

2X2. Aoycav iroTe tlvo^v iTdkaL dKovcras ovap rj kol
iyprjyopois vvv kvvoS) iTepC re rjbovrjs kol (ppovr^creois, ws
ovbeTepov avrolv karL Tdya66v, dXkd &kko tl TpCTov, eTcpov
fuv TOVTOiv, dfiLVov be dfic^olv. KaCTOL tovt6 ye dv ivap-

C yws rjfJLLV cfyavi] vvv, aTrrjAAaKrat fxkv rjbovr] tov VLKdv ro

ydp dya6bv ovk dv Tl Tavrbv avTrj yCyvoLTO. rf ir&s;
nPi2. OvTOiS.
2X2. TStv be ye ets Trjv btaCpea-LV eib&v rjbovrjs ovbev ^tl

5 TTpocrber]a-6fi6a Kar kfxrfV bo^av. TTpoCbv 8' Irt a-acfyearTepov

Set^et.

e 2 Se T : Si) B 6 5 iiravruv rovrov B : TG

airtivrwv rovrcov pr.
a 4 a\\' (l T : dAX)j B bi Se* rhv] SfTrov BT b 3 a5 ro7s B :

avTo7s T (S rovroii t) rayaOSv b8 ^o-tJ B iirrlv aya66v T

: ri
B t om. pr. T
: b 9 Kairoi rovr6 ye Uv Badham : /cl roiovr6 yt hv
B Kat roi oSru ye iiv in marg. B^ Kairoi rovro iav T
: : C 2 ylyvoiro
B yiyvfrai T G yiyvr)rai vulg.
: : C 5 Trpoihv B T : vpoiiiv (et mox
Sd^fi 6 \6yos) vulg. irpoUvri Badham :
 *IAHB02 20 c

nPil. KdAA.ia-T' elirdiV ovrco koI biaTripai.V.

212. Mup' OLTTa Toivvv efXTipo(r6ev eri bLOfji.okoyr]cr(aix6a.

nPI2. Ta TTola;

2X2. T^y Tayadov [xolpav itoTepov avdyKr] reAeoi^ r/ /ut/ d

reXeoy (Ivai;
nPi2. TidvTUiV brjTTOV TekeuiTaTov, w 2wKparey.
212. Ti 8e; Uai^oz^ Tayadov;
nPi2. ITa)? ya/3 ov; Kal TrdifTOiv ye eis tovto bia(f>ipei,v 5

rwz' ovTinv.

212. To8e ye //.T/i', ws olp.ai, irepl avTov dvayKaioTaTov

etrai A.eyeiy, o)? Tray ro yiyywfr/coi; auro 6ripVL Kal k<pUTaL

^ov\6p.evov eAeir Kal Tre/at avro KTr}cra<rdaL, Ka\ tS>v dKkoiV

ovb^v (^povTL^iL Trkrjv t5>v dTTOTeXovfXfvojv dfj.a dya^ols. lo

nPi2. OVK iCTTL TOVTOLS dvTiLTTiLV.

212. "^KO-nSifxiV br) Ka\ KpLV(jiifj.(v tov re rfbovrjs Ka\ tov e
(()poin]cr(t)s^LOV ibovTes x^P^^-
nP12. YIQs et-JTes;
212. MrfT iv r Trjs rfbovrjs kvicrToi (^p6vrf(rLs firfT iv
rw Trjs (l)povrf(r0}S rfbovrf. bel ydp, eiTrep TTOTepov avToiv 5
beopievov 8'
eor' dya66v, fxrfbev /xj/5eyos ert TTpo(rbL(T6aL'
av (f>avrf iT^Tepov, ovk ecrrt ttou rour' ert t6 ovT(as rffxXv 21
dya66v.
nP12. rioiy yap dv;
212. OvKovv iv a-o\ TTeLp<ofxe6a jSa^ravLCovTes TavTa;
nP12. Udvv fxev ovv. 5
212. ^ ATTOKpCvov brf.

nP12. Aeye.
212. Ae'^at' dv, ITpwrapxf) <^ Cw "^^v ^lov aTTavTa
ifbdfxevos Tfbovas ras fxeyicTTas;

d. 5 Sia(f)fp(iv BT : Sia^pfpti vulg. d 9 avrb^ avrh B T

e 5 ir^Tfpov B : Kp^Tfpov T e6 t o-t' ayaBov T ^ittI Taya66v B
:

/iTjSfi' /iijSfj^bs BT : fi.i)Zfvhs firjSiv viilg. erj T : ti B a i v^Tfpov

BT: SrSTfpov vii]g. a8 5f|ojBT: Sffaio viilg. rrpdrapxf
ffi/ B : ffoj irpwTapxf TG
 :

21 a nAATilNOS
lo U?n. Ti 8' ov;
212. 'Ap' ovv eTL TLVos av (TOL TTpoa-bcLV rjyolo, ei tovt

nPil. OvSafiws.
2X2. "Opa 8t/, rou ^povilv kol tov vo^lv kol XoyC^ea-OaL
b TCL hiovTa KoX 6(ra tovtcov d8eA(^a, fj.<av /it) 8eot' av ri;

nPii. Kai tl; TrdvTa yap exot/x' ai ttov t6 xaCpcLV ix'^^'

Si2. OvKow ourto ^oiv det /xer 8ta /3tou rats fxeyLcrTaLs

TjbovaLs xaCpoLS dv;

5 nPn. Tt' 8' 0;

212. NoSy 8c ye Kai p.vrnir]v koX iiTLa-Trifxrfv kol bo^av

fxrj KiKTqfxivos dkr]dr], iTpaTov fxkv tovto avTO, et x,<^LpLS rj

fxr] xaCpcLS, dvdyKt] b-qTTov cre dyi^oeti^, Kv6v ye ovra Trdtrrjs

(f)povri(r(iis;

lo nPH. 'AydyKTj. -

C 212. Kai p.r]v b}(ravT(os iJ.iniiJir]v /xr) KiKrqfxivov dvdyKr]

8?77rou /xr/8' ori irore exat/aes />te/>ty^or^at, r^s r' er rw irapa-

XPVH^ V^ovrjs TTpo(nTLTTTOV<Tr]s /xr/8' ^vtlvovv fjLin^ixr^v vtto-

pAvcLv bd^av 8' av /xr) KKTrifXVov dXrfOrj /Ar) ^o^d^eti' xaipct^'

5 x^tpoj^^Cj KoyLo-fxov 8e arepofxevov /xr/8' ets roi' 7TLTa xp6-

vov b>s ^'^''PV^^'-^ bvvaTov eimt AoytXeo-^at, ^r^v 8e ovk
dvdpdiTTOv ^Cov, dAAd riyos TTkevpLOVos r] t&v oa-a OaXdTTLa
jxeT oaTpiCvoiv ep.\jrvxd ka-TL o-cofxdTbJV. eori raura, ^ 77a/)d

d TavTa exo/xei' dAAa ^taror/^^i^at;

nPX2. Kat TTois;

212. 'Ap' ovv alpfTos rjpuv /3toj d tolovtos;

nP12. Ets d^acrCav TTavTdTTa(rC /xe, ai 2(tfKpares, oSro? d
5 Adyos ifxji^^krfKf rd wi'.

a 12 ex*'^ ^"^
^X"'* ''' ^ ^4 ''''''' ''0*''' -^ '0' T b I /f^
Sfoi' &v Klitsch : finSe dpav BT b 7 j T : Brfjj : om. G
c2 yitrjS'] /t^d'Stallbaum e 3 jurjS' oSi' ^fTJv' fiy^/iriy B : iiv4]ixiiv
jLLTiS' ifivriv oZv T C 4 x'P*"'] M^ ^f suprascr. b : yurjSe x<*'P*"' ^'^
C8 offrptivwv BT : offTpdwv vulg. d i (exoixfv &K\a scripsi
t)^6in(va &\\ci>s B : fxof*,fv &\\(i>s irws T
 T

*IAHB02 21 d

5X2. Mtjtto) Toivvv ixaK6aK(.^<afx^Ba, tov 8e tov vov

/xeraAa/SoWes av jSiov tbuifxcv.

nPI2. Tov TTolov bi] \4ycL9;

512. ^t Ti? Se^air' av av Cw VH^-^v (f)p6vri(nv fxkv Kal

vovv Kal ('iTi.(rTi][xr]v Kal ij.vq]xr]v Traa-av TravTU)V KeKTr]fX(Vos, lo

fibovrjs 8e ]xiTi\<jiv fxriTe fxiya fx^Tc a-jxiKpov, fxr]b' av kvirr^s, e

aWa To TrapaTTav airadr^s TrdvTcav t5>v toiovt(ov.
YlPil. OvbcTcpos 6 I3los, S) ^(aKpaTfs, ifxoLyf TovTOiV
aipcTos, ov8' aXX<a fxrj Trorc, ws ey(op.aL, (f)avfj.

512. Ti 8' 6 a~vvafi(j)6Tpos, w HpaTapxf, f^ dpi(f)0LV 22

a-vixfX(L\d(ls KOLVos yevdfxevos;

nPX2. 'Hbovrjs Aeyeis /cai vov kol (f^povrja-fcas;

5X2. Ovro) Kal t&v tolovtcov [Aeyco] eycoye.

nPX2. rias 87/7roD roirroi' ye aiprjcrerai irpoTepov i] 'Ket- 5
vo)V OTTOTcpovovv, Kal TTpbs TovTOLS [ye] ovx 6 /xei^, 6 8' oil.

5X2. Maz/^aro/ixey ouy ort vvv rffxiv eort ro avfx^alvov

fv TOLs TTapov(rL KoyoLs;
nPX2. Tidvv fxkv ovv, otl ye rpets fxev ^lol irpovTiOr^a-av,
TOLV bvolv 5' ovbeTepos LKavbs ovbe alpcTbs ovtc dvdpcoTToov b
OVTf ^OKOl^ OvbcVL.

5X2. M&v ovv ovK 7/817 TovTOiiv ye Trcpt 8^X01 wy ou-

8e'repos avroty etxe ToyaBdv; r]V ydp dv LKavbs xai re'Xeos
xat irao-t (\>vtoIs kol ^ojots at/aeros, oto^Trep 8waroy rjv ovrcos 5

det 8ta /3tov ^t/i'" et 8e' rts aAAa r/peW rjfxQv, iTapd ^vcrtuu-
ay 7-rji' rov dAr/^cSs atperov kkdfx^aviv dK(ov c dyvoias ?/

riyos drdyKT/s ovk ivbaifxovos.

nPX2. 'Eoi/ce yow rav^' ovto)s e^etv.
5X2. 'X2s /xey Toivvv tttjv ye 4>tA7//3ov ^ew ov 8et 8ta- C
yoeio-^at ravrov xat TayaBdv, LKaviHs ipr](r6ai fxoL 8oKet.

d6 vov T : vvv B T om. B

d8 rhve s ira'T' {&>')
:

Badham ai ti8'T: B
a^ twi/ tooi/ti/ B Ti TotoCToi'
t6S' :

Ktyu seclusi eyw^t om.

: BT
add. in marg. T : a 5 irp^Tfpov T b :

iriTfpov B KiivaivT Kiivwv B: a6 tovtojj yf B toiJtojs T :

a 7 8tj T : ?ti B a g 7 T om, B b i ovSfTepos T oitde-

: :

Tfpoi B b 4 avTo7v T avTwv B : b 7 iAr/flcJj B i\ri9ovs T :

22C nAATnNOS
^I. Ovbc yap 6 <r6s vovs, a> Sw/cpares, l<rTi Tayadov, ctAA.'

e^ci Troi) Tavra (yK\t][xaTa.

5 2X2. Tax' av, S> 4>iA77/3e, o y' e/xos' ou iiivToi tov ye
akr]di,vov afxa Kal Oelov oTixai. vovv, ctAA' aAAcos Trcos exetv.
T(av [xkv ovv VLKrjTrjpiiov Trpbs tov koivov jBiov ovk ap.(l)i(TJir]TGi

TTO) VTtkp vov, TGiV 8e 8^ Seurfpeicoy oplav koX (TKOTtnv \pr} Wpt
d rt bpdcTOfKV' Taxa yap av tov kolvov tovtov IBCov aiTi(ap.i6^

av kK(XTcpo9 6 jxkv Tov vovv acTLov, 6 8' ribovr}v eiyai, xai

ovTO) To ixV ayaOov TovTdiV ap.^0Tip(i)V ovbiTipov hv eir;, Taya
b' h.v atTLOv TLS VTTokajioL TTOTcpov avTuiv etvat. tovtov bi]

5 Trept jcat /utaAAoy ert Trpos ^Lkr]^ov bLa]xa\0L]xr]V hv s ev

T(a /xetKrfa) TOVT(a I3l(o, otl ttot ((ttl tovto o kajBoiV 6 /3tos
ovros ykyov^v alpfTos a[xa kol ayados, ov\ r)bovr] akka vovs
rowro) (rvyyV(rTpov Kal 6]xoL6Tep6v e(rrt, Kai KaTO. tovtov

e Tov k6yov ovT hv tQ>v Trptoretcoy ovb' av tG>v Sevrepetcoi

ribovfj fxeTov akr^dm av Trore Aeyotro* TToppeoTepoi) 8' eo-rt

t&v TpLTL(*)V, et rt ro) e/xo) v(a 8et TTL(rTVLV r]]xas to. vvv.

nPil. 'AAAa ]xrjv, S) 2coKpares, ijxoLye Soxet vvv fxkv

5 7/80^77 o-ot TreTrrcoKeyai Ka^airepet 'TrArjyeto-a vtto t5>v vvvbr}

koydiv t5)V yap VLKr]Tr]pLO)v iTipL ]xayo]xivr] KCLTaL. tov 8e
23 VOVV, OJS OLK, kKT0V 0)5 pL^p6v(x)S OVK aVTeTTOLeLTO T&V
VLKr]Tr]pL(t)V' TCL yap avT eira^ey &v. tu>v 8e 8^ bevTcpemv
eTpr]6iXa-a r]bovr] TTavT(XTTa(TLV av TLva Kal aTifxCav (TXoCr]

Tipos T&v avTrjs cpao-rcSy ov8e yap KLvols er' hv 6]xol(jos

5 (paCvoiTo Kakr].
212. Ti ovv; ovk &]Xlvov avrqv eav rjbr] Kal ]xr] Tr]v

aKpL^(TTaTr]v avTrj TTpo^r^pipovTa l3a.(ravov Kal i^ckeyxovTa

kVTT^LV;

nPX2. Ovbfv Aeyeis, S) 2wK/)ares.

b 2X2. 'Ap' ort t6 abvvaTov etiTov, kvTreLV rjbovrjv;

C 4 ravT^ B : TovTa tcc T d. 3 ovSerepov T : ovSerfpctiv B

d4 irSrtpov BT : Sirortpov vulg. e i oijr' &i/ B : oCr ai T ovS'
5 T : ovS' hv B 64 fiiv T : ora. B e6 naxotxtvrj Bt : fxaxov-
/xtvT] TG
 .

^IAHBOS aab

nPil. Ov \i6vov yc dA\' oti Kai dyvoeis ws ovdcts ttw

o-e 7/|[xci)r /xe^T/o-fi -n-piy dy eis re'Aos e7re^e'A^t/s tovtcov to)

Aoyo).
2il. Ba/3at dpa, w IlpwTapxcj ot^x*^^^ /^^^ A.o'you tov 5
AoiTToi;, (TXfbov 8e ov8e pabCov Ttaw tl vvv. koI yap 8t/

(f>aivTaL hnv aWrji ^rD^avri^i, eirt to, SeuTe/oeia vTrep yov

JTopevoixcvov olov jS^Ar/ ^x^*^ ^Tepa tSi; finrpoa-dev Xoywv
eo-Tt 8e lo-cos ivia Ka\ TavTa. ovkovv Xpr\',

nPli. riois yap ov; 10

2X2. Tr]v hi ye apxw o.yTov 8teuAa/3eto-^ai Treipcofj.eda C

Tt0e'/ieyot.

nPI2. riotW 8^ Ae'yets;

Sli. ndrTa TCL vvv oirra ev tw TrarTt 6txf? 6taAd/3a)/jtey,

fxaWov b\ et ^ovAet, TptXT/. 5

nPil, KaO^ OTL, <f)pdCoLs av;
S12. Ad/Swjuiey dTTa TtSy yw8^ koyutv.
nva. ITota;
212. Tw diov eX^yofXiV ttov to fxkv CLTTdpov Seifat Tatv

ovTo)v, t6 6e ire^pas; 10
nP12. Hdvv fxkv ovv.

2i2. TovTO) 8-^ T&v etSeoi Ta 8vo TL6(a\ii6a, to 8e TpLTov

e^ dp.<f)OLV TOVTOLV CV TL (TVfXpLLCryOiXiVOV , et/xt 8', &)S i0LKV, d
eyo) yeAotds Tts dvdpoiiros Kar dbv Sttords at (rvvapLdfxov-
fXfVOS.

nPX2. TC </)J7S, (iya^e;

2X2. TeTdpTou fxoL yivovs av irpo^rbiLV (fyaiVfTaL. 5
nPX2. Ae'ye Ttros.

2X2. T^s (rvfi.fx(L$a>s tovtoov Trpos dAAr/Aa rrfv aiVtay dpa,

Kai Ti^et fxoL TTpos TpL(rlv exetyots TfTaprov tovto.

b6 ficfSiov e fia.Siov fecit pr. T : haZiov B bg co-ti] effreu Jackson

TaOra BT C i 5i;Ao/3r(r^ai B T : ivKafiucrdai G
C 5 ixaWov . .

C7 \oi8a>/ii/ om. B add. in marg.

: B' c 12 tout<b Stallbaum rovrwv :

BT d 2 Ts &f0pa>7ros Badham : ris iKavhs B : tjs iKavus T : tis koI

&V0VS Apelt kot' T : t<{ t' B d5 (palvfrai T : om. B
23 d nAATliNQv;
nP12. MQv ovv (TOL Kol 7re/A7rrov Trpocrbf^qaeL hiaKpLaiv
10 TLVos hvvafxivov;
2X2. Ta^' av ov fxi-\v oXfxai ye kv rw vvv av hi tl hit],

e avyyvaxnj itov /xot crv ixeTahLOiKovTL nefjt.TrTov [l3iov].

UViL Ti fxriv;

212. Hp&Tov [xkv hrj t5)v TeTTapcov to. Tpia 8ieAo/aeyoi,

Ta hvo TOVTMV Treipw/jte^a, 7roA.Aa kKciTcpov fa-yL(Tfj.ivov KaX
5 hLca-TTaa-ixivov IhovTcs, eis ^v TrdkLV kKaT^pov avvayayovTcs,
vorja-ai Trfj irore 171; avT&v tr Kal ttoWcl kKciTepov.
nPX2. Ei fjiOL a-a(f>a-Tpov ert Trept avT&v eiTTOis, Tax o,v

ktioifxriv.

24 2i2. Aeyo) Toivvv to. hvo ct TrpoTidcixaL TavT* etrai aTrep

vvvhi], TO ixkv aitiLpov, to 8e "nipas ^\ov otl hk Tpo-nov

TLva To 6.TTLpov TToAA' eo-rt, TTupAcroixaL (^pd^iLV. To 8e iripas
i\ov rjixas Tre/at/xereVco.

5 nPi2. MeVei.
212. ^KfyfraL 5?/. xaXeTTOv ixkv yap /cat dix(f)La-l3r}Ti]a-Lixov

o KeAet/o) o-e a-K07TLV, o/xco? 8e o^KoVet. OepixoTepov Kal

'^vxpoTcpov iripL TTp&Tov opa 7Tpas ei Trore' tl vorjcraLs dv, t]

t6 ixdkXov re Kat rJTTOV kv avrots otKovi^^re) rots yevecrLV,

b ecoa-TTcp dv kvoLKf]Tov, Tekos ovk dv iiTLTpe^aLTriv yiyvecrdaL'
yevoixevrjs ydp TckevTrjs Kal avTO) TeTekevrqKaTOV,
nPI2. ' Akridea-TaTa Ae'yets.
212. 'Aet 8e' ye, ^aixiv, iv re roi dpixoTp<a Kal \f/vxpoTip(f

5 To ixdkkov re Kat ^^Toy ^vl.

nP12. Kat /xaAa.

212. 'Aet Toivvv 6 koyos i]ixlv crrj/xaiVet TovTOi /x?; re'Aos

\LV aTckrj 8' orre 8?/7rov TrayraTracrir aTretpco yiyvecrOov.

nP12. Kat a-(f)6hpa ye, S> ^WK/jare?.

e r (r{/ ^(to^kIikovti T : (rvfjL/jLfTaditiKovTi B )3io' secl. Schutz :

/8101 Apelt T e5 a i Tai/r' scripsi TaCr' B T

(rvvS.^ovTfs :

a 9 oiKovuTf rec. Coisl. oiKovy B T b r evoiKriTov B T ivoiKiiTov

: :

vulg. ouK &1' T om. B (add. in marg. b)

: b 4 ipvxpoTepti) B :

T$ yfivxpoTfpCfj T b7 ffrffjiaivfi T (rr}fj.aivfi B <rr)fiaivfi rifuv

^yiij' : :

vulg. b 8 oTtA.^ ^cTe T St SnAo'' re B

8' :
 4>IAHB02 24b
212. 'AAA' fv ye, u) (f)ik YIpatTapx^, ^'^eAa/Bey koI io
avy.vr](Tas otl Kal to (T(f)6bpa tovto, o (tv vvv (f)diy^(a, c
Kol To ye rjpifxa ttjv avTr]v bvvaixLV ^yiTOv rai iwXKov re Kal

rJTTov' OTTOV yap hv ivfJTov, ovk iaTov flvai 'nocrov iKaarov,

dAA' dei a-(f)obp6Tpov rjcrvyaLTipov koX TovvavTWV Ifcdcrrats
TTpa^ia-LV e/xTroiowre to irkiov Kal to ekaTTOv aiTfpyd^ecrdov, 5
To 8e TToaov cKf^avCCeTov. h yap ikixOrj vvvbrj, pij) d^avi-
a-avTi To TTOcrov, dAA' eda-avTe avTd re Kal to p.^TpLov (v Trj

Tov /LtaAAoy fcat tJttov Kal a-(f>6bpa Kal ripifj.a ^bpa. iyyV(r6aL, d
avrd Ippet ravra e/c ttjs avT&v yj^pas kv rf ivrjv. ov yap
eri Oepfx^Tepov ov8e \frvxp6Tepov LTr]v av Xa(36vT t6 ttoct^v
irpoxcopeL yap Kal ov fxiviL t6 re depfjL^Tepov dei Kal to
yjnrxfi^Tepov oxravrcos', t6 8e Trocrdi; ^ottj Kai iTpoL^v kiiava-aTO. 5
Kard 8^ rovroi^ tov \6yov dTr^Lpov yiyvoLT dv t6 6epp.6Tpov
Kal TovvavTLov ap.a.
nPi2. ^^atverat yovv, S) ScoKpares' ecrrt 8', Sirep ciires,

ov pqbLa TavTa avviTTicrdaL. t6 8e ets av^ts re Kat av6Ls

icrcris Aex^eVra t6v re epaoT&VTa kol t6v epcorw/aeyoz; tKarws e
hv aviJ.(f)(i)VovvTas dTro(f)rivaLv.

2X2. 'AAA' ev pikv Ae'yets Kat TTiLpaT^ov ovto) Trotety.

VVV (xivTOL &dpL TTJS TOV dTTfCpOV (f)Va())S et TOVTO b^6fJt.da

oTjjLtetoi^, tva ixr] ttovt (tt^l6vtS jxr^KVVoDixcv. 5

nPf2. Td TTotoi' 87) Aeyets;

2X2. 'Ottoo-' dv r]]xZv (f)aCvr]TaL ]xdX\6v t Kal tjttov yLyv6-'
fxva Kal rd cr^obpa Ka\ r]p4]xa b^x^fxeva Kal t6 kCav Ka\ ocra
TOLavra iTdvTa, eis t6 tov diTiCpov yivos ws ets ^v 8et irdyra 25
Tavra TL^evaL, Kard tov ]XTTpoa-6V \6yov ov i(\)a]xiv 6cra

bLi(nTa(TTaL kol bL4(rxi.(rTaL awayay6vTas xpv^o,'- '^ctrd bvvafXLV

fxCav eTTLa~r]]xaCva-6aC TLva (f)vaLV, et fx4fxvr]a-ai.

UVn. Mfxvr]]xaL, 5
212. OvKoSi' Ttt fxr] bcx6fxeva Tavra, tovtcov 8e rd kvavrCa

C 2 fxaWov T BT : t fiaWov vulg. 03 B T om. vulg.

h.v :

d3 efTTji' T : l^ffTr\v B (r; suprascr. rec. b) : {Jttji/ vulg. ^ffrrjv Vat.

:

e2 airo<p-rivMtv BT : airo<f>-fivfitv vulg. a i ytvos T ytvovs B

:
asa nAATi2N02
TtavTa bexdixeva, TTpStTov ixkv to 'lctov kci iaoTriTa, fji(Ta 8e t6
t(rov t6 bnrXda-Lov Kal irav OTLTrep hv Trpos apL6p.6v dpLOfjios

b r] (xiTpov T] TTpos fJLCTpov, TavTa (rvpiTTavTa els to Ttipas

dTToXoyiCopLcvoi Kak&s hv boKolpLev bpdv tovto. rj tt^s a^)

(f)rjs;

nP12. KaAA.io-ra ye, oj ScoK/aares.

5 2X2. Filev' t6 8e TpiTov t6 ixlkt6v ex tovtolv dp.(^olv

TLva Ibeav (fy^qcroix^v ix^Lv;
nPX2. 2u Kca ipLol (fypda-eLS, ws olfJLaL.

2X2. 0eos /xey ovv, avTTcp ye e/xais evxals eTr^Koos

yCyvrjTaL tls OeSiV.
lo nPX2. Evxow ^V '^^'- ffOTrei.

2X2. 2K07r(S" Kat ju,oi 8oKet rts, a> Ilpcorapxf > airwy (^tAos
^/jity vvvbr] yeyov^vaL.

c nPX2. ns Ae'yets tovto Kal tlvl TeKfxr]pL(o XPV'

2X2. 4>pao-a) STyAoz; ort* crv bi ]xol (TVvaKoKov6r]a-ov rw
}\j6y(a.

nPX2. Ae'ye jxovov.

5 2X2. Qep^xoTcpov ((fideyyojxeda vvvb^q ttov tl Kat ^vxpd-

Tepov. ?] ydp;
nPX2. Na^.
2X2. rT/300-^es br] ^r^poTcpov Kal vypoTcpov avTols Ka\
Tr\4ov Kal iXaTTov Kal 6dTTov Ka\ (BpabvTcpov Kal /xei^ov
lo Kai crixLKpoTcpov Kal oiTocra kv ro) TTpoo-dev Trjs t6 ijmXXov
rc Kat rJTTOv bex^l^^Vfl^ iTL6]XV els ^v (pva-ecos.

d nPX2. Trjs Tov direLpov Ae'yets;

2X2. Nat. avix]xLyw 8e' ye ets avrqv t6 ]XTa raOra Tr]v

av Tov Treparo? yivvav.

nPX2. notay;
5 2X2. *Hy Kai vvvbr], biov r]]xds Ka^diTep Tr]v tov aTreCpov
(TVVr]ydyo]X(v ets iv, ovTd) Kal rqv tov Tre/aaroetSou? avva-

b8 Oehs T : 6 0fhs B c i vws BT : irus S^ G d2 <TVfin,lyvv

B : ffvfi,filyvv( T d. 3 aS toO Coisl. : avrov B T
 ;

<I>IAHB02 25 d

yayeiv, ov (rvvi]ydyofj.v, dk)C tcTws koI vvv ravTov bpdaci,

{fl) ToijT(ov dix<f)OTep(t)v crvvayoixivcov KaTa(f)avr]9 KdKcCvq
yVi^(rTai.

nPi2. YloCav Kal tt&s Aeyeis; 10

2X2. Tr]v Tov 1(tov Kal hLirXaa-Cov, koI oTTocrr] Travet Trpos

d\kr]Xa TdvavTia Sta^opcos iyovTa, crvfipLTpa 8e Kal a-vixcfxova G

er^etcra dpiOfxov aTTipyd^iTai.
nPIi. MavOdvo)' (patvr] ydp fxoi Kiydv fxnyvvs Tama
yerefret? Tivds e<^' eKd(rT(ov avTQv (rvpLJSaCvetv.

2>Q. 'Opdois ydp (f^aCvopiai. 5

nPI2. Aiyc ToCvvv.
SX2. 'Apa ovK iv fxkv v6(tols rj ToijT(ov opOri KOivcovCa rqv
vyuCas <f)vcnv (yivvrfcrev;

nPI2. riayraTrao-t jxkv ovv. 36

212. 'Er 8e 6^(1 /cat jSapil Kal Ta\(T xai j3pa8et, direCpoi.s
ov(ri,v, dp ov TavTa [iyyLyvofxeva] Taika' dfxa iripas re
dinipyda-aTo Ka\ fxov^rLKrjv crvfXTracrav TeA,ewrara o^reo-TT/o-aro;
nPO. KaAAto-rti ye. 6

212. Kat fxifv ^v ye yjeLp.(aa-LV Ka\ irvCyicrLV fyyevofxivr]

To fxcv TToAu Atai^ Kai direLpov d^eiAero, t6 6e (fxfxcTpov Kal
&p.a arvfXfX(Tpov dTrrfpyda-aTO.
nP12. Tt fxrfv;

212. OvKovv ^K TovT(>)v StpaC re Kat oa-a Kakd TTavTa b

rifxlv ykyovi, t5)V re dTreCpcov Kal t&v Tiipas x6vT(t)V
avfxfxe L\diin-o)v

nP12. n<Ss S' ov;

212. Kat fiAAa ye 8^ fxvpCa eTrtAei-n-o) Aeycoi', oXov fxtO' 5
vyLiCas KdWos kcCl lcr^^yv, Ka\ kv '^vyals av irdfxiTokka erepa

d 7 oAA' d 9 y(vl](T(Tai. post

. . . e 2 airfpyti^fTai transp. Jackson
d7 jpao-ei (<) Vahlen 5f>a(r B T : Sp^j
: t Apelt d8 (rwayofj.(-
vwv] ffvnfiiayofxfvuv Jackson KiKfivn T : KOKiivris B d lo irolav
B T woi vulg.
: e 3 /tiyj/vy BT : a<p' B
fnyvvfft Klitsch e4 ^^)' T :

ai/r&vT : om. B as
Toi/Ti (toDto fuit) B toCto tA . . . toCto : . . .

ainh T iyyiyv6fxeva seclusi KaWierd B T G fidKKTTi.

a 5 :

vulg. a 6 4yy(voufvri T G iyyfvdfitva B a 7 \iav T Kf7ov B

: ;

b 5 -y* T : om. B
26b nAATilNOS
Koi TrayKaAa. vjSpiv ydp ttov koI crvixTraa-av ttolvtcov ttovi]-

pCav avTt] KaTLbovcra j) ^eo?, S) /caAe ^^iArj/^e, Tripas ovtc

rjbovSiv ovbev ovre iikqa-ixovSiv kvov iv avroiy, vofxov Kal
10 T&^Lv irepas ^yovT fOeTo' Kal arv [xev aTTOKvaLO-aL <^r)j

C avrqv, iyoi b^ tovvovtlov a/noa-GxTaL kiyo). a-oX bi, S

UpaTapxc, TTws ^a^yerai;
nPf2. Kat fxaXa, S) '2<aKpaTs, ixoLy( /cara vovv.
2X2. OvKovv TCL ixcv 877 rpia raura etpqKa, ct a-vvvofis.

y' nPi2. 'AAA' oi/xai Karai^oeiiy %.v ixcv ydp [xol boKfXs t6
^^ aiTCLpov \4yLV, kv 8e Kat bevTcpov t6 iTepas kv roiy ov<ri*
TpLTOV 8e ov a-<j)6bpa KaTi-)(j tC ^ovX^l (f^pdCcLV,
Si2. T6 yap TrXrjdos a-e, S) Oavfxda-LC, i^iiTXri^c ttjs tov
rpCTov yevea-c())S' KaCTOL TTokkd ye Kal to dircLpov irapi-
d a-y^To yivq, ojxms 8' iTTLa-<f)payLa-64vTa r^ roi! jjmXXov Kal
evavTCov yevcL kv k(\>dvr].

nPi2. 'AXy]6ri.

212. Kat fxr]v t6 ye Tripas ovt TToXXa L\'S.v, ovt

5 eSvo-KoXau^o/xey iis ovk rjv ^v <f)va-L.

nPi2. U&s yap dv;

2X2. OvbafxGts. aXXa TpCTOv c})d6L fxc Xiyeiv, ^v tovto
TLdivTa t6 TovT(t)V (Kyovov dTTav, yiv(a-LV ds ova-Cav k

tS)v ixeTCL Tov TripaTos aTTCLpyaa-ixivoiV ixiTpcav,

10 nPX2. "Eixa^ov.
e 2X2. 'AAAa 8^ TTp6s rpto-i riTapTov tl t6t <\)aixv ilvaL

yivos a-KTTTiov' KOLVr] 8' rj aKi^frLS. opa yap et o-oi 8oKet

dvayKalov etyai Trai^ra ra yLyv6ixva b^d TLva atriar

yCyva-6aL.

b8 oijTf fiSovuv ovSkv B : ovSep otre rjSovwv T b 10 ()(^ovt' T :

ixivroiv B a.troKvaiffai (pyls vir doctus in Kidd. Misc, Porson

at<roi
p. 265: aiTOKvas f<pi)s Par. 181 1 : i.iroKvais 4<pi\s BT: atroKv . . . ^<pi)s
G : airoKvav f(pris corr. E vulg. C 4 S^ B : om. T C 6 Aryctf
T : \4yuv B d^ oth-f B T Hre Apelt : : otrf {&s) SchQtz o6t( :

(2t*> Bury otkf B T : ovk Apelt 6.5 tvT: 4vB d 7 ?v

toCto T ^vTiTovTuvB
: d8 tKyovovT : fyyovvB ei (toTs)
Tpjirl Badham t<Jt TG : T6ye B : iroTc t vulg.
 ;

4)IAHB02 26e

nP12. "Efiotyv irm yap hv \<ipls tovtov yiyvoiTo; 5

2X2. OvKovv fi Tov TroiovvTos (j)V(rLS ovbcv 'nX.rjv ovofxaTi

TTJs airias 8ta0/3ei, to bi ttolovv Kal to atTiov ojidm hv

ett] Xcyopievov ^v;
nP12. 'Opdm.
2i2. Kal \xr\v t6 ye Troiovp.ivov aS Ka\ to yi.yv6fj.Vov 27
ovbev TT\r]v 6v6p.aTL, KaddiTep to iwvbi], bia^^ipov ivpr](ro]iV.
t] Tttas;

nPX2. OvTOii.
2i2. 'Ap' ovv riyLTaL pLkv t6 ttolovv det Kara (f)V(rLV, t6 5
bc TT0L0V]XV0V fTTaKoXovOd yLyVOfXfVOV KLV(o;
nPX2. Uavv ye.
212. 'AAAo apa kol ov TavTov atria r' fo-Tl Kal to
bovX.vov ts yiv<TLV atria.
nPi2. Tl ixrjv; 10

212. OvKovv To, fj.V yLyv6]Xva Ka\ k^ Ctv yCyv^TaL TiavTa

To. Tpia Tcapiayj^TO 7]]uv yivr];
nP12. Kai p.6.ka.

212. To 8e 8t) TtavTa Tavra br]p.Lovpyovv kiyo]iV TiTopTov, b

ri]v OLTLav, ? lKavS>s ^Tcpov Kiv(*)V bbr]Xo)fx4vov
nP12. "ETepov yap ovv.
212. 'Op^WS p.r]V \L, bL(t)pL(T]XV(t)V T&V TTTapO)V, kvOS
kKa.(TT(yv p.vr]]xr]s ^veKa k(f)C^s avTO. KaTapL0]xr](Ta<r6aL. 5

nPQ. Tl ]xr]v;

2l2. X\pS)TOV p.'kv TOLVVV &TTLpOV kiyO), bVTpOV bk

TT^paS, 4tTLT iK TOijTOiV Tp(.TOV ]XLKTr]V KoX yyVr]]XVr]V

ovarLav rr]v bk r^s ]XC^(>)s oLTLav Ka\ yV(r0)s TeTdprrjv

\yo)v apa ]xr] TTkr]]X]X\oLr]v av tl; C
nP12. Kai ttS)s;

e 5 rovTov rovroov T
B : roiruv ti Paley
: a6 (iraKoKovde? : T
aKo\ov0f7 B B,ii i^ &v T {a> B b : i Kfyofifv B Aeyo)-
:

/xfv T b 2 S(Sy)\wiA(vov T : StSriKwfJifvwv B b 3 ertpov B :

\'7'M<' T \tyoiA(v
: G
b 7 Se B om. pr. : T c i \fytDv
BT G At-yeo vulg.
: 2po fii) T 5po B :

PLATO, VOL. 11. 5

27 c nAATI2NOS
212. ^epe brj, t6 fx^Ta rovd' rjiuv rts 6 Xoyos, koX tL
TTore l3ov\r}6VTs (is TavTa a^iKo^ida; ap' ov Tobe rjv;

5 bevTipda e^T/rov/xcy TTorepov rjbovrjs yCyvoiT h.v rj (fypovrja-eois.

ovx ovTu>s r^v;

rTPX2. Ouro) fxkv ovv.

2X2. 'Ap' ovv Xcruis vvv, iTTCLbri TavTa ovtoo bifikoixeda,

k6XX.iov hv Kal Trjv KpCcriv eTrtreAeo-ai/xe^a irpcaTov Tiipi koL
lo bevripov, Trepl &v brj t6 Trp&Tov r]p.^ecr^r]Tr](Tay.ev;

nPi2. "l^rm.
d 2i2. "Idi. bri' VLK&vTa fjiev l^e/xey irov tov fxuKT^v ^iov
rjbovrjs re Kal (j)povrj(r ecos. ^v ovtcos;

2X2. OvKow tovtov pikv t6v ^iov op&piev ttov Tis re'

5 eo-ri Kal oTroiov yivovs;

nPi2. 1159 yap ov;
212. Kal p.ipos y avT6v (f^rjcroixev eimt tov TpiTov ot/xat

yivovs' ov yap [6] bvolv tlvolv eo-ri [/uiiKros eKetyos] aXXa

(TvpL-navTOiv tG)V aTrdpoov 11176 tov TtipaTos bebeixivcov, axTTe
10 opd&s 6 vLKr](^6pos ovTos ^ios ixipos cKeivov yiyvoiT &v.
nPI2. 'OpdoTaTa pikv ovv.

e 2X2. Etei;* rt 8e 6 cros, S> 4>tA7j/3e, r^bvs kol aixeLKTos

(ov; iv TivL yivL tG>v dprnxivuiv Keyoixtvos opOSts av Trore
XiyoLTo; c58e 8' a-noKpLvai ixol Trplv airocfiriva^TdaL.

4>I. Aeye p-ovov.

5 2X2. 'HbovT] Kal KvTrr] -nipas ix^Tov, 7) t&v t6 ijJdXkov

re Kai rJTTov beyoixivu>v icTTov;
<J>I. Nai, tS>v t6 imKkov, S) ^(oKpaTes' ov yap h.v r]bovr)

c8 tffus ci. Stallbaum: ds BT 09 kiLkMov &'B KoWlovativ :

T KoWlova hv Iffws vulg.

: d i /xtv B om. T : d 4 re B om. T :

d7 ai/rhv <P'i\(roft.(v T
y' ravrhv itp^fjffanfv B : d8 6 T : om. B :

6 . . . fiiKrhs iKuvos seclusi auctore Jackson niKThv iKuvo SchOtz

Tivo7v T : Tjvuj' B dA.A^ B : a\\' 6 T d9 Twf B : om. T
d 10 opdwsT: dpBhsB e i Koi &ixiktos T Koi /xiKrhs
: B 63 djr<i.
Kpival /xoi T : anoKplvofj.al jxoi B e 6 f<rT6v B
iffriv : T 67 vax'
Twv rh T : vai rhv rh B
 4)IAHB02 27e

TTav ayaObv ^v, ei /x^ a-neipov krvyxave -nec^VKOs Kal TrX^^et

Kal T(a fiaXX.ov.
2X2. Ovbc y av, a 4>iArj/3, XvTrr] irav KaKov oktt' aXXo 28
TL V^V (TKmTiOV 7] T1]V TOV aTTeCpOV (f)V(rLV ws T:apXTaC Tt

fjxpos Tois Tibovais ayaOov. tovtoh 877 (roi t&v aTT^pdvTUiv

y ytvovs eorcoi^* (f)p6vri(TLV be Kal iiTLcrTrifj.rjv Kal vovv eh

tC ttot tS)v TTpoeLprjixevodv, 0) Hp(aTapx4 re /cat 4>iAr;/3e, vvv 5

dfVTfs ovK hv acre^olfjLCv; ov ydp \i.0L boKel (rfXLKpbs ripXv

flvaL 6 KCvbvvos KaTopOdxradL Ka\ jxr] TTepl t6 vvv p(aT(aixcvov.
<1>I. ^ixvvvLS ydp, Si ScoKpares, tov (reaxrrov 6c6v. b
Sil. Kal yap (tv, da kToipi, rqv (TavTov' t6 8' fp(t)T(iifXvov

OfXCOS r)fxlv \KT0V.

nPii. 'Opd&s TOL Ae'yei ^KpaTrfs, S <J>tA.7;/3e, Kat aurw
TTCLCTTioV. 5
<t>I. OvKOvv VTTp ejuoC a~v, Tlp(aTapx, iTporfprf^TaL KiycLv;

nPX2. riayi; ye* vvv fxivTOL axcbov aTTOpS), Ka\ biofxaC

ye, 2) SciJ/cpares, avroV o-e T/jixri' ycvicrOaL TTpo(f)rfTrfv, Xva

fxrfbcv rffiLcls (tol irept t6v ay(avL(TTrfv i^afxapTovovTfS irapa
fxikos (j)6y$(afX6d tl. io

2X2. netcrre'oy, u> ripcora/oxe' ov8e yap xaXcirov ovbcv C

cTTtrarrets. dAA' 6vto)s (T eyco, KaddiTcp etTre 4>tAr7j3oy,

(Tfxvvv(i)v v ro) Trat^eti' kdopv^rfcra, vovv Ka\ iiTLa-Trffxrjv

p6fXvos oTToCov yvovs cTcv;

nPX2. riayrciTrao-t ye, w 2(0Kpares. 6
2X2. 'AAAa pnfv pabLov Trdi/res yap a-vfx(})(i)Vov(TLV ol

(T0(f)0C, kaVTOVS 6VT0)S CrfXVVVOVTS, WS VOVS icTTL l3a(TL\VS rffXLV

ovpavov re Kai yrjs. kol l(to)s v kcyova-L. 8td fxaKpoTpo)V

b\ ei ^ov\L, Trfv ctkc-^lv avTov tov yivovs 7TOLrfa-(afx6a.

e 8 Traviyadov et mox a i irwyKaKov ci. Bekker e 9 t^ T tJ> B :

a I oiSe y T oiSe B : a 2 ws] 5 corr. Par. 1814 $ Paley :

a 3 TouTw scripsi toutwj' B T toOto corr. Ven. 189

: a 4 76 yevovs
:

scripsi ytyovhs B T
: (<ttuv scripsi (crrv B T a 7 (Ivai 6 :

KivSvvos KaropBdauai B 6 KivSvvos dvai Ka\ KaropBuffaffi T

: b4 3
#/\7jj8 T : om. B b 7 vvv fifvroi T : fjikv roiwv B b8 ffe T .

7 B c 7 ivTws B T G oiru vulg.

: c 8 t6 B : om. T
 ; :

a8d nAATX2N02
d nPXi, Aey' OTTcos ^ovXn, ixqtikv fjLrJKOs rjfxlv viroX.oyL^o-

fxevos, S SwKpares, ws ovk aTrex^^o^o/^ifWS.

2i2. KaAws ciTres. ap^oifxida Se ttcos <i58e iiravepoiTStvTes.
nPi2. nws;
6 SX2. Ilorepoy, w Ilpwrapxfj Ta (rvp.TravTa Koi Tobe to
KaXovixevov okov ewirpoTreveiy (f>oi[Xv Tr]v tov aXoyov Kal
dKjj bvvafMi.v Ka\ to ottji iTV)(v, rf TavavTia, KaOdiTep ol
TTpocrdcv rffi&v ^Ktyov, vovv Kal cfipovrfa-Cv Tiva davfiaa-Trfv
o-vvTdTTovcrav bLaKVJScpvav;

e nPX2. OvbV tS>v avT&v, co 6avfi,da-L SwKpares' o

fikv ydp av vvv Xeyei?, ov8e oaiov (IvaC fxoL (\>aLV(TaL. to
8e vovv TidvTa bLaKoa-fxdv avra (f)dvaL Kal Trjs o^e(os tov
Koa-fxov KaX rfKiov kol (X^Xrfvrfs KaX daTcpoiV Kal Trdarfs Trjs

5 TTipL^^opds d^Lov, KoX ovK oAAcos eycoy' &v ttot Trepi avrcSy
ilTTOLfiL ovb' dv bo^daaLfjLL.

212. BovAet brJTd tl Kal rjfxds tols ^fKiTpocrOev ofxokoyov-

20 fxevov a~vfX(f)rfa-cofXV cby rau^' ovt(os ^X^'' '^^'' I^V f^dvov

ol(afX6a bitv ToXKoTpLa avV KLvbvvov \4ycLV, aAAa Kal
a-vyKLvbvvV(OfXV Kal fXT\(i)fXv tov y\r6yov, oTav dvrjp bcLvbs

(f>f}
Tavra fxr] ovrcos dAA' drdtKrcos XLv;

6 nPi2. riciis ydp ovK h.v ^ovkoLfxrfv

212. "Wl b-q, Tov kTTLovTa iTpl ToijTcov vvv rffXLV K6yov
a6pL,
nPX2. Ae'ye fiovov.
212. Ta TTcpl Tr]v t&v croifxdTOiV (f)vaLV aiTdvTcav t&v
lo C^(av, TTvp Ka\ vb(op koI TTVfVfxa Kadopwfxev ttov Kal yrjv
KaddiTep OL XLfxaCdfXV0L, (f^acriv, ivovTa kv ttj avoTdaeL.
b nP12. Kat fxdKa' \Lp,aCdfXda yap ovroos vtt' diTopias
iv Tols vvv KoyoLS.

d 5 irirfpov T irpSTfpov B :rh B om. T Eus. d 7 rb BT

:

om. G T^ vulg.
: e i ovSev twv avrwv B T Eus. oii de7 r&v ivavriwv :

Apelt e vvv \4yeis

2 T G vvv Sij \fyeis B \eyeis :vvv vulg. :

e 4 acrrepwv B liaTpoiv T : 67 S^rci tj B hrira T dfxo\oyoCfx.evov :

B T 6fio\oyovfievois vulg. iifxo\oyrfft.evoi5 Theodoretus

: : a i ravB'
BT : Tovff G
 ;

cl>lAHB02 agb
212. <i>e/5 bi], iTpl kKaa-Tov tQv Trap' jjjjXv Aa/3e to
Toiovbc,
nva. UoXov; 5

2i2. "Ort [XLKpov T TOVTcov Ka(TTov irap' r]\xiv (vcctti.

Kal (f)av\ov Kai ovbafMrj- ovbaix&s lKiKpiVS ov Kal Tr]v

bvvap.iv ovK a^iav t% (^ucrea)? ^x^^* ^^ ^^^ ^^ Xa^o)V Trept

TrdvTUlV VOCL TaVTOV, olov TTVp iO-TL p.V TIOV TTap r][UV,

iari 6' kv Tft) TrarTi. lo

nPI2. Tt ]ji.r]v;

2X2. OvKovv <T]j.LKpov ]x4v TL To nap' rj]iLV Kal da-Oeves c

Kai (l)avX.ov, to b' V T<a TravTl TrXr^dfL Te davpjxcrfov KaX
/caAAet xat Trda-r] hvvd]XiL Trj Trepi to irvp ovar].
nPX2. Kat p.dX.' dArj^ey 6 Aeyets.
2X2. Tt 8e'; Tp4(f)TaL Kal yiyv^TaL kK tovtov koX av^TaL 5
To Tov TravTos rrvp vtto tov Ttap' r]]XLV Trvpos, rj TovvavTLov
vtt' Klvov t6 t' (]x6v Kal t6 a6v Kal t6 t&v aAAcoy C(ao)v

aTTavT layiL Tavra;

nPi2. Tovro p.v ovb' aTTOKpLaeeoi &^lov e/)(OTa?.

2X2. 'Opdm' TavTO. yap epets oijnat 7re/)t Te tt/s iv tols d

C^ois yrjs TTJs ivOdbc Kal Trjs iv T(a iTavTL, Kal t&v &Kk<t)v hi]

TTdvTO)V 6a(t)V r]p(t)Tr]aa oKiyov e^xTTpoaOev. ovtoos diTOKpLvf];

nPi2. Tis ydp diTOKpLVo^xevos aAAcos vyLaiv(t)V dv 7tot
<\)avLr]
g
212. ^xeSoy ovb' oaTLaovv dKKd t6 ]XTd tovto k^rjs

iiTov. TrdvTa ydp r]]XLS Tavra Ta vvvbi] K^yO^VTa dp' ovk

LS ^v avyKi]Xva tSoVTes iT(t)vo]xdaa]XV a&]xa;

nPI2. Tt ]x/]v;

212. TavToy 8^ Aa/3e Kat TTpl TOvb ov Koa^xov Kyo]XV' e

[8ta] Tov avT6v ydp TpoiTov dv tr] ttov a&]xa, ovvOctov 6v
K T&V aVT&V.

b6 vap' secl. Klitsch fvftrrt] fort. fxtv iffri b9 ^(Tt* yufV

T Eus. : fjiev tffri B 05 ai<|<ra( Jackson
Spx^Tai : BT di yiip
B Eusebius : 7* &i/ T : 7' o5 Ast e Ficino {quoqut) d 3 Kivrvv
B om. T Eus.
: e 2 tia secl. Badham
29 e nAATI2N02
nPii, 'Op^orara Aeyet?.
5 2Xi. HoTepuv ovv k tovtov tov <T(afxaTos oAws t6 rcap

riiuv a-&ixa rj k tov Trap' rjfuv tovto Tpe(f)TaC re Kal ocra

vvvbr] TTepl avT&v etTro/xey tX.ri(f)v re Kal ^x^'

nPIi. Kat Tovd^ Tpov, u) 2w/c/3ares, ovk a^iov po)rq-

(recus'.

30 2X2. Ti 8e'; Tobe apa a^iov; ^ Trw? epet?;

nPI2. Aeye to ttoiov.

Si2. To TTap' rifuv crCiim Sp' ov \lrvxw 4>ri(T0fXV ix^Lv;

nPX2. ArjXov ort (^rfcrofL^v.

5 2X2. no^^ev, 0) (f)iX ripwrapxf. ka^ov, e?irep ju?) ro' ye

Tov TravTos o-wjua ifiylrvypv ov Tvy\av, Tavrdt, ye exoy
rovro) Kal ert TTdvnj KaKkiova;
nPX2. A^Xoy w9 ovbafjLoOcv 6,XX.o6V, S) 2wKparey.
2X2. Ou yap TTOU boKOvpLV ye, o) npwrap)(f> Ta Tirrapa
10 KZva, -nipas koI aTrcipov Kal kolvov Kal t6 Trjs ahias yivos
b V aTTaaL TTapTov ivov, tovto v fiV TOLS TTap' rffuv y\rv)(rfv

T TTapiyov kolI a-o)fxaa-KLav cp.TTOLOvv Kal TTTaLaavTOS aoopuiTos

laTpLKrfv KOL v aAAots aAAa crvvTL^kv /cat dKOVfivov TTdaav
Kal TTavToiav cro(f)iav iTTLKak^laOaL, t&v 8' avTav ToijTODV

5 ovTcov V oAo) re ovpavia Ka\ KaTo. fx^ydka fxiprf, Kal TTpocriTL

KaKStv Ka\ l\LKpLV(av, iv roi/rots 8' ovk dpa fXfxrfyavrfa-6aL

Trfv rwy KaWia-Tcov Kal TLfLLcoTdTcov (^vctlv.

C nPX2. 'AAA' ovbafxSiS tovto y hv koyov ^x?'"

2X2. OvKovv et fu] tovto, p.T iK^ivov tov koyov hv
7T6fXVOL ^ikTLOV kiy0LpLV b)S (TTLV, O, TTOkkdKLS lprfKafiV,
aTTCLpOV T iv T(0 TTaVTL TTOkv, Kal TripaS LKaVOV, Kai TLS
5 ctt' avrot? atrta ov (f)avkrf, Koa-piova-d re Kai a-vvTdTTOvaa
ivLavTOVs re Kai &pas Kal fxrjvas, (To<pia kol vovs k^yofxivrf
bLKaLOTaT dv.

e 7 ?x' T Eus. : iffxd B a I 5p T : &^a B a6 Sj/ T Eus. :

4hv B 7 irdvTTi B
a : T om. vulg. 10 a Trepas T : om. B
b^ jro/)xoj'] irapfXiif Beare awfxaiiKiav Eus. : aSifia (rKihv BT
b 3 (TvvTidiv B a-vvTtBiv
: TG b 7 t);j' T Eus. : Sia B
 cl)IAHB02 30 c

nPI2. AiKaiorara 87/ra.

212. ^o(f)ia y.i]v koI vovi avev ^jrvxv^ ovk 6.V TTore

yiVoicr6r\v. 10

nPX2. Ov yap ovv.

212. OvKovv iv fj.ev Trj tov Aio? epeis (f)V(rL j3a(n\iKr}V d

fi(V \lrv)(riv, ^aa-iXiKov 8e vovv kyyiyvecrOai hia njv rfjs

alrias bvva\xiv, kv 5' SAAot? aAAa /caAa, Ka^' ort (piXov

cKaoTois Aeyeo-^at.
nP12. MaAa ye. 5

212. Touroy 6?; tov koyov rjiJ.as firi n ix6.Tr\v ho^rjs, o)

rTpcrtrapxf (iprjKevai, dAA' eo-ri rots /uey TrdAat aiTO(\>r]va-

fUvois d)? dei rou iravTos vovs ^px^^ 0~vpLfxax^os ^K^ivois.

nP12. "Eo-rt yap ovv.

212. Tt) 8e ye ejuf) ^r;r?70"ft TreTroptKcby aTroKpKTiv, 6tl vovs 10

eoTt yevovs t^s roS Trdyrcoy atr^v Aex^eVTos [t&v t(t- e

Tdp(jov, [(Hv] r}v rjfuv ^v tovto]. exety ydp brjirov vvv rffxStv

ijbr} Trfv airoKpLaiv.

nP12. *'Exco Kai fxdXa iKav&s' KaiTOL /ue airoKpLvdfXfvos

eXadcs. 5

212. 'AyaTrauAa ydp, w np(aTap\, Trjs (nrovbrjs yiyv^TaL

fvioT rj TratStd.

nP12. KaAeSs etires.

212. Nvv brfTTov, S) eraipe, ov p.(v yivovs eo-rt KOt rtVa 3^^

77ore bvvafXLv K^KrrjTaL, cr\bbv ^TTieiKws rjfuv tcl vvv

bebrjkodTaL.

nP12. Ildvv fXV ovv.

212. Kai fxrfv rfbovrjs ye uxra&rias irdAai ro yivos f({)dvrf. 5

nP12. Kai fxdXa.

d 3 KadSri T Eus. icadb B e i yevovs rrjs B yevoi^rrris T Por-

: :

phyrius Proclus Olympiodorus Hesychius Suidas schol. rijs secl.

Bekker twv rfTTdpwv rovro secl. Badham . . e 2 &v om.
.

B T add. in marg. T
: ^v om. G (8') ^v Stallbaum e6 rrjs:

(rirovSrjs, & Tlpdrapxe vulg. e 8 koXws T Kal Ka\&5 B 0, : :

Ka\us Hermann a vvv Si) irov

i T vvv Bij vovs B vovs S-fivov : :

Bekker o5 T : 06 B
3ia nAATftNOS
2i2. Meixv(afXda bri Koi Tavra Trepl aii(\iolv, 8tl vovs
fxev atrias ^v crvyyevris Kal tovtov o"x(hbv rov yivovs, rjbovr]

bc aTretpos re avTri Ka\ tov /x?jt h.p^v ixrjTe iiia-a iiriTe tcXos
lo ev avTta acf)' kavTov exoz^ros ixrjbe e^ovTos Trore yevovs.
b nPX2. MejuvTj o-o/xe^a* tt&s yap ov;
212. Aei bri to ixeTo. tovto, ev < re' ea-TLv eKaTepov av-
Tolv Kal bia tC TrdOos yiyvecrOov OTTOTav yiyvria-dov Ibelv
riixas.' TtpCiTov Trjv rjbovriv uxnrep to yevos avTrjs TrpoTepov
5 e^aaavia-aixev, ovToy koI raura irpOTepa. Autttjs be av x&)pis
r?)y ribovriv ovk dv TTore bvvaiixeda iKavSis jSaaaviaai.
nPi2. 'AAX' ei TavTri xpri Tiopeveadai, TavTri 'nopev^p.eda.
S12. Ap' ovv ao\ KaddiTep e/xot (\>aiveTai Ttjs yeveaeois
avT&v Trept;

C nPX2. To TTolov;

2i2. 'Kv ro) KOLV& ixol yevei aixa (f)aiveadov XviTri re Kai
ribovri yiyveadaL KaTa (f)vaLV.

nPi2. Kotj^oy be ye, S) <f)iKe 2wK/5ares, VTTOixiixvrjaKe

6 ^ixds Ti TTore t&v TTpoeLprnxevci^v j3ov\eL brjkovv.

Sf2. "Eo-rat Tavr els bvvapi.LV, w davixdaLe.

nPii2. KaAct>s eiTres.
20. KoLvov Toivvv viTaKOv^api.ev o 8r/ t&v TeTTapcov
TpiTOV ekeyoixev.
lo nPi2. *0 jotera to aTreLpov Ka\ irepas ekeyes, ev w Kai
vyieLav, otp.aL be Kal app.oviav, eTideao;
d 212. KciAAio-r' eiTres. roi' vovv be otl ixdkLaT rjbri

TTpoaeyjE.

nP12. Ae'ye p.6vov.

212. Aeyo) Toivvv r^? apixovias ixev kvoixevrjs rnxlv ev

5 rots C^OLs dp.a kvaLV Trjs (f)vaeoi)s Ka\ yeveaLV akyriboviav ev
rw TOTe yiyveadaL y^povt^.

a9 avr^ T : atJrij B &io iu avrif a<p' favrov BT : a(p' eouroC

4v iavrif vulg. b3 irddos T : irKTJdos B yiyvricrOov B : yl-
yveffdov T eii irlOfffo : KdWia-r' T : irldfis t KdWiffr' B
 *IAHB02 3id

nPi2. ndvv Aeyets dKos.

2ii. riaAii' Se apjxoTTonivqi re Koi eis rriv ovt^s (f^va-iv

airiovoTjs ijbovrjv yCyv(r6aL XeKTiov, d bii bC oA^ycoy Trepl

IxcyioTuiV oTi Td\i.(rTa prjdijvat,. ro

nPi2. Oijutai /xeV o-e dp^ws kiyii.v, ui SwKpares, ifx^pavi- e

oTepov be (ti TavTO, raura Treipw/Ae^a Aeyety.
2i2. OvKOW ra br]iJ.6(nd ttov Kal TTpL(f)avr] pa(TTOV

(Tvvvoelv;

n?n. Uola; 5
2X2. rieii^ ixiv TTOV Awts /cat Xvirq;
UVa. Nai.
212. 'ESwSt) bi, TrA^/aaxris yiyvoixivr] TrdXiv, rjbovrj;
nPi2. Nat.
2X2. A^fos 8' av (\>dopa KaX XvTrr) [xai Avo-is], 77 de rov 10

vypov TTtiAii/ ro ^pavdev TTX.r]povaa bvvapiLS rjbovrj' 8ia- 32

KpiaLS 8e y' av Kai StaAvats 17 irapa (})V(rLV, tov TTVLyovs
Trddr], XvTTrj, KaTo. (pvcrLV 8e TraAti' d7ro'8oo-ts re Kat ^}/v^ls
rjbovr].

nPi2. Tldw ixv ovv. 5

2X2. Kai piyovs rj p.v Trapa (j>v(rLV tov ^oxjv ttjs vypo-
TTITOS TTTJ^LS XVTTT]' TrdkLV 8' etS TaVTOV aTTLOVTOiV Kal bia-
KpLvopAv(tiv fj KaTo. (f)vaLV obbs rjbovr]. Kal kvl Aoyo) (tkott^l
ei o-ot p.TpL0s 6 Aoyos bs av ^tj Tb k tt/s aTreipov Kat
TripaTos KaTo. (\>v(rLV }xy\fvxov yyovbs eiSos, Sirep lAeyoi^ iv b
ro) TTp6(rdV, Stuv ixV tovto (})6Lpr]TaL, Triv fx^v (f)6opav
kvTTTjv etrat, rqv 8' ets r^v avT(av oixriav bbov, TavTr]v 8e
av TTdXLV TTiv dva\(i)pr](TLV iTdvToov r]bovr]v.

d8 avrrjs BT : avrijy Stobaeuslo Sri rdxKrra irtpl fxeyi- d

ffTwv Stobaeus e 2 Tavra B toom. Stobaeus
: ainci T
e 6 vflyri :

B Stobaeus weiVjj
: T e 8 iS(i>Sii B Stobaeus ^SwSp T :

e 10 Koi Kvffis T Stobaeus secl. Schleiermacher koI \v(ns B jcol

: : :

aJo-is ci. Bury a a 7' BT Te G t' Stobaeus : rj om. Sto-:

baeus a^ 5e Stobaeus 5^ BT 5* ^ Heusde : ap ttjs

:

B T Stobaeus rov Stallbaum

: b i iv Ttf irpoaOev ^Afjop Stobaeus
b 2 fjLfv om. Stobaeus b 3 ainwv T avTwv B Stobaeus :
32b nAATONOS
5 nPi2. "Ea-TOi)' boKcX ydp p.0L tvttov ye riva ^xhv.

2i2. ToSro //ey Toivvv ^v eiSos rt^wjme^a Xxnty^s re Koi

r)bovr]9 kv tovtoi^s roty Trddea-iv e/carepois;

nPX2. Keio-0a>.

212. Ti^ei Toivvv avTrjs Trjs '^v)(rjs KaTo. t6 TovTOiv t&v

C 7ra6rifj.dT(av TTpocrboKrjixa t6 fxkv TTpo t&v rjbicav eAwt^ojueyoi' rjbv

Kal dappakiov, to 8e tt/oo tG>v kvnrjpGiV (j^ojS^pbv koI dkyeivov.

nP12. "Eo-rt yap ovv tovO^ rjbovrjs Kal kvTrqs ^Tepov

ei8os, To x^opi? Tov cr<ajxaT0S avTrjs Trjs \(rv\r]s bid Trpoa-boKias

5 yLyv6p.Vov.
212. ^Opdm VTrikalSes. iv yap ToijTois oTp.ai, Kard yt
Tr]v k\i}i]v bo^av, (IkLKpLviaLV re exar^pots yLyvofj.ivoLS, ws
SoKei, Kai dp.LKTOLS kvTTTIS T Kttt ribovr]S, Cp.(f)avks <T(r6aL

d To TTipX Trjv f]bovriv, TTOTcpov okov eo-ri t6 yivos dcnraarTov,

rj TOVTO fXfV T(p(0 TLvl T&V TrpOLpr][J.(V(aV b0T0V rjfUV yV&v,
r]bovr^ 8e Kat kvirr], Ka^direp 6p]X(a kol xlrvxpG Kal Trda-L rotj
rotovrots, tot fxev da-TTaa-Tov avTd, tot be ovk da-TTaariov,

5 0)5 dyadd fxv ovk ovTa, vioT be Kal VLa Se^o/xeya ttjv

T&v dyad&v ia-TLV ot ^va^LV.

ITP12. 'O/a^oVara Ae'yets, ort TavTrf ttt] 8et bLaTToprfdrjvaL

t6 VVV ]XT(ibL(aK6fXV0V.
212. YIp&Tov ixv Toivvv T6b a-vvib(i)fkV [?] ei^Trep

e ovTins ^a-TL t6 ky6fLVov, bLa(^6Lpop.VOiV fXV avTMV dkyr]-

b(ov, dvaa-u>^otxv<ji)v 8e rfbovrj, T(av fxr]T bLa^dLpofj.VO)V

fxrfT dvaa-(oCop.Vo^v vvor]ao)fXV 7re'/9t, rtra Trore ^lv Sei

t6t V Kd(rT0Ls ewttt rots C^ols, oTav o^to)s to-j^rj. (r(f)6bpa

5 8e Ttpocrxo)v t6v vovv eiTre'* dpa ov Ttda-a dvdyKrj iTav iv

r&) t6t Xp6vio C^ov fxrfT tl kvTTLcr6aL fxi]T rfba6aL fxrfT

fxiya fxrfT a-fXLKp6v;

C2 \vin)pS)v T : \wSiv B Stobaeus C4 irpotrSoKias BT Sto-

baeus : irpoffSonlav vulg. d2 rtvl T : om. B d3 5e B re T
:

d4 rSre Se T : rh ri Se B d6 Sre] Sirj? Badham d? 5a-

vopridrjvai Solomon : SiairopfvOTJvai BT : SiadripfvOrivai Stephanus
dg ws secl. Badham e i &\yriS<iv &va<ru^ojxev<i>v T : a\yriSii>v &V
Siaar<i>^ofi4v(i)v B
 <I>1AHB0S 32e

nPIi. 'AvdyKT] fjL(v ovv.

2X2. OvKovv loTi Tis rpiTrj rjfx&v ^ Touxvrq btddecris

irapd T TTjv Tov xaipovTos Kal iiapa tt)v tov kvnovp.ivov; 33

nP12. Ti iiriv;

2i2. "Aye hr] toCwv, ravrr/y TTpodvpxiv ixffxvija-Oai. Trpos

yap Ti]v Trjs fjbovrjs Kpicriv ov afxiKpov fJLep.vi]rrdaL TavTrjV

<rd' rffxlv */ /xry. ^pa)(y bi tl Trept avTrjs, et /3ovA.et, 5

biaTTfpdvoofiev.

nPi2. Aeye ttoXov.

212. [Tfa)] Tov Tov (fipovelv [kXofxiv^o] ^lov ol(j&' ws

TOVTOV TOV TpOTTOV Ovbkv dlTOKOoXveL ^fjv.

nPI2. Tbv Tov ju^ x.^ipLV fxrfbe KvTTL(rdaL Aeyety; b

212. 'EppT/^r/ ydp TTov t6t iv rjj TTapajSokf] tS)V ^ioiv

fxrfbev b(LV fxi]Te p.iya fxr]T a-p.LKpbv xaipiLv rw Tbv tov

voLV Kal (f^povelv fiiov k\ofx4vio.
nPX2. Kal fxdXa ovtcos epprjOr]. 5
2X2. OvKOvv ovTcos &v iKiv(a ye vTrdpxoL' Kal to"cos

ovbev dTOTTov et TTdvTcov T&v /Stcoy efrri OdOTaTo^.

nP12. OvKovv et/cos ye ovtc xaip^LV deovs ovt to
ivavTiov.
2X2. Udvv fxev ovv ovk etKo's' aa-xr]fxov yovv avT(av lo

kKdTepov yLyvofxevov kaTLv. dXKd brf tovto fxev TL /cai et?

aS^i9 iTTLaK(\f/6ixda, idv TTpbs k6yov tl

f\,
xat rw via Trpbs C
Ta bcvTepda, idv fxrf irpbs to, Trptoreta bvv(afxeda TTpoadeLvai,

TTpoaO-qaofxev.

nPX2. 'OpOoTaTa A^yets.

2X2. Kai fxr]v t6 ye eTepov etSos t5>v rfbovGtv, h Ti]s i
"ylrvxvs avTT]s i^pafxev eimt, 8ta fxvr]fxr]s ttclv iaTL yeyovos.
nPX2. Uds;
2X2. Mvqfxrfv, ws eoLKev, otl ttot eaTLV iTpoTepov dva-

eg iinwv BT : rtixlv al. a 4 Taiirrif BT : ravrr)s recc. Bekker

a8 T^; et mox f\o/xfv(f> secl. Badham b3 fieya B fxiyav
: TG
bs ippfOt} T b6 oirws BT : oStoj al. b 8 Ofovs T
tovi:

Ofohs B c I iiriffKfyj/^fifda Bekker : iiri(rKf\f/(ifif9a BT

33C nAATilNOS
\rjTTTOV, Kal KLVbvVVL TTakLV (TL TTpOT^pOV at(Tdr](rLV /XI^TJ/XTjy,

10 ei /xcAAei tcl Trepl ravd^ T)pXv ara Tpoirov (f>avcpd iTrf

yivrj(Ti(rdaL.

212. 0es rwy Trepi to rw/xa ^/xwy eKao-Tore TTaOr^iJidTcov

TCL ixev V T&) (T(ap.aTL KaTacrl^evvvfxeva irplv eTri T7)i' yj/vxqv

bL^\6LV dTTaOrj KLvr]v d(ravTa, tcl be bL dfx^poTv iovTa

5 KaC TLVa (0(7776/3 CrL(r\J.OV iVTLQivTa XhLOV T KOL KOLVOV
KaTp(a.

ma. Keio-^ft).

2i2. Ta /xey bri ixrj 8i' dix^f^olv loirra kav rqv \f/vxr}V

THiSiv (f)&ixv kav6dvLV, to. 8e 84' dfK^olv fxr] kav6dvLV, dp'

10 opdoTaTa povixv;
e nPX2. rTcas ya/) ov;

2X2. To TOLVVV k^krjdevaL /xrjSa/iwy v7To\d^r}9 o)? Xeyw

Xr/^rj? errau^d Trou yV(TLV (ttl ydp \ri6ri jxvqixrfs i^obos,
r) 8' v ro) Aeyo/xei^o) i^vi' ovTro) ykyov^. tov br] ixr\T ovtos
5 /x7/re yeyofdros 770) yiyv^crdaL (f)dvaL TLvd d7ro/3oA?)y dTOTTov.

V yap;
nPi2. Ti /xTji';

212. Td TOLVvv ovoixaTa /xerd/3aAe ixovov.

nPi2. ncSs;
10 212. 'Arrl /xei' rou \kr)6vaL TrfV -^vxqv, otov aTTadiis
avTri yCyvrfTaL t&v cr^LcrixSiV TStv tov cr(apLaTOS, fjv vvv \ri6r]v

34 /caAeis dvaL(r6r](rCav CTTOVopiacrov.

nPi2. "Eixa^ov.
212. Td 8' v vi TTddcL Tr]v \frvxqv Kal t6 (r5>ixa kolx'?]

yiyvofxevov Koivfj /cai KLVL(r6aL, TavTr]v 8' av ri]v KCvr](rLV

5 dvond^(i>v aX(rdr](rLV ovk aTrd TpoiTov (f)6yyoL dv.

C 10 T& irepl B : irepl T Stobaeus :

T om. Stobaeus
: d2 rwp
rhv B d4 5i' T Stobaeus om, B
om. Stobaeus
: d8 5^ BT :

/u^ om. G 64 rov 5^ B rov * T rov Sov D oiiS' ov Stobaeus : : :

6 5 irw Stobaeus irws B irws T : e 10 /te/ om. Stobaeus

: a^ rh
B T G Stobaeus t$ vulg. a 4 5' o5 B T 8); Stobaeus
: a 5 ciTri :

T Stobaeus iiro B
:
 <I>1AHB0S 34
nPil. 'AArj^eWara Kiyets.
SI2. OvKovv i]br] fxavddvotKV b ^ovkoixfOa Ka\iv Trjv

ata-6r](Tiv;

nPi2. Ti fxriv;

2X2. Scorrjptai; toiwv aia-6ria-em ttjv nvrifir]v kiyoav lo

op^ws dv rts Aeyoi Kara ye rr/y e/i^r 8o'^ar.

*>
nP12. 'Op^ois ydp ovv.

212. Mi^T/fxr/s 6e dvdfjivrjariv dp ov biacp^povaav Xiyopav;

nPi2. 'lo-o)?,

2X2. 'A/3' ovv ov Tobf;

nP12. To TToXov; 5

2X2. "Oray & /^iera tov a-(ap.aTos i-naayiv Tioff r} ^XV'

TavT dvev tov a<ii\iaTos avTrj kv kavTf\ ori /xaAto-ra dva-
\aixfidvr], roVc dvaixi}xvr\aKia6ai ttov Xiyo(X(V. ^ ydp;
nPI2. Tldw fx(v ovv.

2X2. Kai /UT/y koI oTav dnroKiaaaa ixvr]p.r]v etr' al<T6r\- lo

o-ecos elr' a5 ixadrnxaTos av6i,s ravrrjy araTToAr/o-T/ iraAty

avTT} h kavTTJ, Kal Tavra a-vfXTTavra dya/WT/o-eis [Kal fxvrifxas] C

TTOV Ae'yo/xey.

nPi2. 'Op^ois Aeyets.

2X2. Ov brf xdpiv aTTavT etpr/rat TavT, eo-ri ro'8e.

nPX2. T6 TTotoi'; 5

2X2. "Iva TTT/ T-ffv yjrvxvs rfbovrfv x^P''^ o-w/xaros ort

/xdAto-ra Kat kvapyiaTaTa kd^oifxiv, koX dfxa TTi.dvfxiav' bi.d

ydp TOVTitiV TTcos raura dfxt^oT^pa olkV br}kova-6ai.

nPX2. Aiycofxcv Toivvv, o) 2&)Kpares, i^Srj to /xerd raCra.

2X2. rToAAd ye Trepi yivicriv rfbovrfs koI TTaaav [Tifv] lo

fxop(f>rfv avTrjs dvayKoiov, a)s eotKe, Ae^yovras o^KOTrety. Kat d

ydp vvv TTpoTfpov iri, (f)alv(Tai krfiTTlov iTTi^vfxCav ctyat tC

TTOT ia-Ti Kai TTOV yCyvTai.

b2 \(yofi,tv T : Kfyw/jLfv B b6 ir66' r\ T : iri.Oii B : ir{{07} ri Turr.

c I Kai fiyiipias secl. Glogl c6 ttjj SchQtz : 5^ Grouius : tjSi]

Hermann : /i^j BT ^vxv^ T : ttjs ^vxv^ B c8 irs T :

wwj B c lo riiv secl. Badham d i avrrjs T : iit^' B

34d nAATiiNOS
nPi2. 2K07ro)/uiey Toivvv ovhiv yap aTroXovixcv,
5 212. *AiTo\ovfXV fxkv ovv [Kal] TavTa ye, Si HpdtTap^^e'
evp6vTS o vvv Cv^ovfxev, airoXovixev ttjv Trept avTo. raOra
aTTopCav.
nP12. 'OpO&s rifxvvoi' to b' ecjie^rjs tovtols TTipa>fj.(da

A.eyeiy.

lO 2i2. OvKOVV VVvbrf TTLVrjV T Kol bi^l/os Kal TToAAa Tpa

e roiaura icfiafxiv eimt Tivas iTTiOvfxias;
nPi2. ^(f)6bpa ye.

212. Upos Ti TTore apa TavTov fikexfravTes cvtu) tto\v

hia(f)(povTa TavO' kvl iTpoa-ayopevofxev 6v6fxaTi;

5 nP12. Ma At" ov pqbLov ta-ois cZirety, &> 2wKparey, aX)C

ojtAcos AefcreW.
2X2. 'EKet^ei; b-q k tS>v avT&v ttoXlv iLvaXd^oifxev,
IWn. U6dv brt;

212. At\//7j ye TTOV kiyofxev kKaa-TOTi tl;

lo nPX2. USis 8' ov;
2X2. Touro 8e y eo-rt KeyoCrat;
nPX2. Tt>7ji;;
2X2. 'Ap' ov?; ro 8i\//^os eo-rty ktTLdvfxia;

nPX2. Nat, TTWfxaT^s ye.

35 2X2. II(opLaTOs, rf TrArjpwo-ecos TTcafxaTos;

nPX2. Olp.aL fxkv TTkr]p<a(r(os,

2X2. *0 Kei^ovjaei^os rjfx&v apa, ws colkcv, eiTLOvfxel TOiv

ivavTioiv rj Trao-xef KvovfXvos yap epa TTkrfpovKrdaL,

5 nPX2. ^a(fi(rTaTd ye.
2X2. Ti ovv; 6 to ttp&tov Kevovfxevos icrTiv omdev etr'

ai(r6rfa-L TrAijpwo-ecos e^aTrrotr' ^y eire fxvrffxr], tovtov o

fxrfT kv rw vvv xp6v(a Traaxet fxrfT kv rw irpoV^ev TrwTTore
eTra^ey;

d 5 ^y B om. T : al secl. Badham d6 d,iro\ovfj,ev B :

om. T e 7 e/c rS>' avruv iriXiv B : irdKiv tK rwv ahrwv T

e9 Sti^fj T S/ifj? B
: hi^fiv vulg.: ye irov B : irou T eKdarroTf ri T :

(Kdcrrov exi B : eKaarorf rts al. 6 14 TrwjuaTos BT : ir6fxaros vulg.

 ;

<1)1AHB0S 35a

nPXi. Kat TT&s; lo

2X2. 'AAAa fxrjv 6 y kin6vyi.5iv tlvos eTn^u/xei, ^a/xeV. t>

nPX2. n&s yap ov;

2X2. Oir/c apa o ye Tra^rxei, tovtov eTri^u/xer. 81^/77 yap>
TovTo be KV(ti(ns' 6 8' Tn6vfj.(l 'Ji\.rip<a(ru>s.

nPX2. Nai. 5

2X2. riArypwcrew? y' apa Trr; n rwy tou 8i\//wi'tos ar

e<^a7rroiro.

nPX2. 'A^-ayKaior.
2X2. To pikv 8t) o-w/ua dSvmroi'' Keyourai ydp irov.

nPX2. Nat. 10

2X2. Tr]v ylfvxhv apa r^s TrAr/pwo-ecos ((fxxTTTecrdat \oltt6v,

Trj fJivrifxrj brjXov ori' rai yap ay er' aAAo) i(f)<x\{raLTO C
nPX2. 2xe8oy ouSeyi.
2X2. Mar^dwju.ey ovi' 6 (Tvix^i^r])^ fnxLV eK rourwy t&v
Koycov;
nPX2. To TTolov; 5
2X2. 2(d/ixaTos ein^ufxiW ou <f)r](nv rjfXLV ovtos 6 \6yos
yLyv(r6aL.
nPX2. nws;
2X2. "Ort roi? K(lvov TTa^rnia^nv kvavTLav del Trayros
^
C^^OV p.r]VV(.L TT]V kTtL)(iLpr]<rLV.

nPX2. Kal fxaka.

2X2. *H 8' 6p/x77 ye eTrt TovvavTLOv ayov(ra 17 rd
TTa6riixaTa StjAoi Trou jxvT^fxr^v ov(rav t&v tols ita^rnxacrLV
ivaVTLUiV.

nPX2. ndw ye. 5

2X2. T^y dpa eTrdyovo-ay eirt rd iTTL6v]xov]Xva aTTobei^as d

]xvr]]xr]v 6 Ao'yo? ^xrj^ crv]X7Ta(rav Tr]v re 6p]xr]v kol iiTi^vfXLav

Kal Tr]v ap)(r]V tov C<aov TTavTOS aTTi^fyr^vfv.

nPX2. 'Op66TaTa.

b6 7' ipa B : ipa T c i r^i BT (rtvi in marg. t) : rf rhi

vulg. It' B : om. T c 3 o2i/ B : yoC/ T
 '

35d nAATXlNOS
5 SX2. Ai.\l/fjv apa rjiJ.&v rb (rc5/xa ri TTCivrjv i) ti. t&v
Touy6T(ov Tr6,<rxiv ovba[xfj 6 koyos aipet.
nPf2. 'AXrj^eoraTa.
212. "Eti bri Kal Tobe irepl TavTO, TavTa KaTavoT^a-oifxev.

fiiov yap eiSoy ri piOL (f>aiveTai ^o^\(a-6ai br]Xovv 6 \6yos

10 rjlUV V TOVTOIS aVToTS'

e nPi2. ^Ev Ticn Kal ttoiou TripL ^Cov (^pd^eis;

212. 'Ey ro) TrXrjpovcrdaL kol KcvovcrdaL Kal iracrLV ocra
irepl cr(aTr)pLav re ecrTL t&v C^^cav Kal Trjv <l)6opdv, Kal et rts

TovT(i)v kv kKaT^pio yLyv6fXVos rjpMV dAyet, Toxf 8e yaipiL

5 Kard rdy fieTa^oXds.

nPX2. "EoTt TavTa.
212. Tt 8' oTav kv p.i(T(a TOVT(av yCyvrjraL;
nP12. U&s V ixi(r(o;

212. Atd fj.V rd Trd^os dXy^, pi,iJi.vrJTaL 8e Totv ^Sewy (c5y)

lo yiVop.iv(x>v TravoLT hv Trjs dXyrjbovos, TrX.rjp&TaL 8e p.riTX<x)' tC

36 T^Te; (^Sniiv rj fxr] (f)&p.cv avTov iv fx4cr<a t&v 7ra6r}fxdT(av ilvaL;

nP12. 4>5jLiey fx\v oZv.

212. Yi6Tpov dkyovv0' 8k(as rj \aLpovTa;

nP12. Md Ar, dXXd 8t7rA7) tlvX kvirr) kvnovfxivov, xard
5 fxkv To crS>ft.a kv rw TTadrjfxaTi, Kard 8e Trfv ylfvxrfv iipocrboKLas
. rtyi 1:66(0.

212. YlSis, S) Up(aTap\, to bLirkovv Tr}s kvTrqs iits; dp

OVK ^(TTL p.V 0T TLS r}p.&V KVOVp.VOS V ikllCbL (f)aVpa TOV
b TTkrfp^a^T^crecr^aL Ka6<rTr]K, tot Se TOvvavTCov dreAirio-rcos

nP12. Kai fxdXa ye.

212. Mwv ovv ovxi. ikTrCCoiV fxev iTkr]p(s)6rf(r(r6aL r&i

5 fKfxvrf(r6aL SoKei ffoi \aCpLV, &fxa b^k KVovfXVos V tovtols

[roty xpo^o*^] dXyetv;

d 5 hv^v .iruviiv T
. . 8/i^j' irtlvriv B : ^/uw' rh rw/xa B
. . t^
. :

T
ffwfia fifiwv e I irept Plov B /3/ow Trept T 64 rorh Stallbaum
: :

r6Tt B T 6 9 oA.7f) B 0X761'' T &v add. corr. Ven. 189 om. B T

: :

e 10 irXiipwTai B imrX^i^pwrai T
: b 6 rols xp^vois secl. Badham
 *IAHB02 36b

2X2. ToVe ap' avOpnmo^ Ka\ roAAa ^oia AuTcirat re 5/xa

Kttl xaCpL.
nPQ,. Kivbvveveu lo

2i2. Tt 8' orai' ayeATr^orcos exjj Kevovixevoi nv^ecrOai

TrArjp&jo-eo)?; ap' ou t6t to hmXovv yCyvoiT hv Trepl Tas
\vTTas Tiddos, o (Tv vvvbi] KaTi.boi)v (arjdrjs dTrAcSs elvai

bnrXovv; C
nPI2. 'AAi/^eo-rara, Si 2w/</)arc?.

2X2. TavTTf br] Tf] (rKe\l/i TOVTOiv t&v TTa6r]fxdT(av Tobe

Xpr](r(afxeda.

nP12. To Ttolov; 5
212. YloTepov aXr^dels TavTas Tas Auiras re Kai rjbovas ij

ylrevbels elvai. Ke^op.ev; rj Tas p.iv Tivas dX.rj6LS, rds 8' ov;
nPX2. YI(as b\ S} 2wKpare?, dv etev '^evbcis rjboval rj

\vTrai;
2X2. TI&s be, w ripwrapxf <p6fioL dv dkr]6Ls rj \jfevbeLs, lo
rj 'npoaboKLai dkq^els ij fxr], rj bo^ai dkr^deis rj ^evbels;
nPX2. Ao^as p.ev ey^ay dv ttov (rvyyjitipoLr]v, to. 8' erepa d
TaVT OVK dv.
2X2. ITcSs </)>/?; Ao'yoi' fxevTOL tlvcl KivbvvVoiJ.ev ov Trdvv
(rpLLKpov e-neyeLpeiv.

nPX2. 'AArj^^ KeyeLS. 5

2X2. 'AAA' el Trpos Ta Trapekr^kvOoTa, w Trat \eivov
Tdvbpos, TTpocrr^KOVTa, tovto (rKeiTTeov.
nPX2. "lo-cos TovTo ye.
2X2. XaipeLV tolvvv bel keyeLV Toh ^AAois fxrJKecrLV 17 Kat
6t(^ovv tQv irapa to TrpocrriKOV keyop.ev(ov. 10
nPX2. 'Op6m.
2X2. Ae'ye 8r/ /xoi* 6avp.a ydp \xi ye ^ei 8id r^Aouj dei e

b 13 vvv 5j) BT : vvv vulg. c6 rebs Tb : om. B c8 5' T ;

om. B ^ T : a< B d.6 Ktlvov rivSpis B : Ktlvov tov avSp6s T

I yap fxf ye B : yhp e^ y T
PLATO. VOL. II. G
36e nAATONOS
irepl TCL avTCL h vvvbrj T:pov6efxe6a aiToptfixaTa. ttws bi] (f)y]i;

i/^euSets, al 8' aXrjdeis ovk ilcrlv rjbovai;

nPI2. ITws yap av;

5 212. Ovre br] ovap ovd^ ^Trap, ws 0r/?, [ecrrti'] ovt* kv
ixaviais ovT kv Trapa^ppocrvvaLs ovbels ead^ oo-tls ttot^ boKel
fjLkv xaCpeLV, xo^^P^i- ^f ou8aju,<S?, ovb' av boKil ixkv kvTrel^o-^aL,
AVTTeLTai ov.

nP12. Tidv6^ ovT(o TavTa, S '2(iiKpaTes, e^^Lv TrdvTes

lo vTTeLkrjcfyanev.

212. 'Ap' ovv 6p6m; v cKeTTTiov etr' 6p6Q>s etre ixr]

TavTa KiyeTaL;
nPX2. "SiKeTTTiov, u>s y iyo) <paLr]v dv.

37 212. ALopL(r(iopL6a br] aa^icrTepov ^tl to vvvbr] Kiy6]iVov

rjbov7]s re Trept Kal bo^s. ^(ttlv ydp ttov tl bo^dC^LV
rjjxTv;

nPI2. NaC.
5 212. Kat ^beadai;
nm. NaL
212. Kat ]xi]v Kal t6 bo^a^oixevov ((ttl tl;
nP12. U(os 8' ov;
212. Kat To ye w t6 rjboixevov ^berai;
lo nP12. Kai irdvv ye.

212. OvKOVv t6 bo^d^ov, avTe 6p6S>s dvTe ixr] 6p65)S

bo^d^-)], To ye bo^dCeLV ovtcos ovbeTTOTe aTToXXv^nv.
b nP12. nois yhp dv;
212. OvKovv Kal t6 rjboixevov, dvTc 6p6&s avTC ju^ 6p6&s
i]br]TaL, t6 ye ovtcos 'qbea-daL brjXov ws ovbeiTOT aTroAet.
nP12. Nat, Kat tov6^ ovtcos ex^'-
5 212. "Oro) TTore ovv br] Tp6iT(a bo^a^jrevbi^s re Kot d\r]di]s

ez rci avTo] ravTa Badham irus Sii <pips; alteri dant B T : Socrati
continuavit Badham e 5 i<TTi.v secl. Stallbaum e 6 vapa-
(pooffivais e ndixais a(ppo<rvvais fecit B irdffais a(ppoffvvais T : 6 13 &s
y T : &)s B a2 rt T : om. B a 7 t< T : periit in B a9 <^
T : a>s B T^ T : periit in B a 12 So^dCri T : So^dffri B b4 rov0'
B : ravd' T 65 oTif) BT : t^ t vulg. 5^ BT : om. vulg.
 cl>IAHB02 37 b

Tjiuv </)iAei y(yv(r6aL, to 6e r?/? yjboviji fxovov akrjd^s,

bo^dCctv 6' oyrcoy koI \aipiiv dix(f)6T(pa o/xoiojs tX.i]x^v

{(TKeTrriov).

U?a. ^KTrr(ov.
2i2. 'Ap' ort bo^rj fikv (Tnyiyvcadov xj/evbos re Kal lo
dXq6ei, Kal iyevero ov ^ovov bo^a 8ia raura dAAa Kal TTOtd c
ri? eKaTepa, (TKeirriov (fyrjs tovt elvai,;

nP12. Nai.
21i. ripof Se ye tovtols, ei fcai ro Trapdirav rjfJLLV tcl fjiiv

ecTTL TToC drra, rjbovr] be Kal kvTTrj fwvov &TT(p carTL, ttoiw rti^e 5

8e ov yCyvecr^ov, Kal Tav6^ rjpXv bLop.oXoyr]T4ov.

nPa. Aj^Aor.
212. 'AAA' ovbev tovto ye j^aAe^Troy tSetr, ort Kat Trotw

rtye* 'TrdAat yap (Liroixev otl /xeydAat re Kal (rp.LKpa\ koX

(r(f)6bpa exdr epat ytyyoyrat, AuTrat re Ka\ rjbovaC. 10

nPi2. riayrdTrao-t ixev ovv. d

212. *Ai; bi ye TTovrjpCa TovTOiv, Si Ilpwrapx^ Trpo^ryCyvrjTaC
TLVL, TTOvrjpdv fikv (^-r](Top.V ovTO) yCyve(rdaL b6^av, irovrfpdv

8e Kat i]bovr]v;
nPi2. 'AAAd ri p.r]v, S) 2<oKpares; 5
212. Tt b\ dv 6p66Tris rj TovvavTCov op^drTjrt rtyi tovtlov
iTpo(ryCyvr]TaL; \iGtv ovk 6p67]v fxkv b6^av ipovfj.V, dv 6p66Ti]Ta
10^7/, TavTov 8e r)bovi]v;

nP12. 'AvayKalov.
212. *Az; 8e' ye dfiapTav6fiivov to bo^a(6fxevov 77, rrjy b6^av e
rdre d/xaprdi^oiio-dy ye ovk 6p6r]v 6fxoXoyr]TOV ov8' 6p6Sts
bo^d^ov(rav;
nPi2. ricSs' ydp av;
212. Tt 5', dv av Xvirqv ij riva ribovifv Trepi to c(^' w 5

b7 elXijxe Stallbaum (tXnipev B T

: b 8 trKfirTfov add. Baiter
b 10 op' Sri T : ipi n B C i iro/o B diroia T C 5 8^ B
: :

T6 T TOiw rfi'* t voiwv rive pr. T iroiuv' rtve B

: : c8 woui
rivf BT c 10 (r<^<<5oo] o-^oSpoJ Ka\ rtavxaiTfoat Cornarius e Ficino
65 ^T: tB
6*
 ;

37 e nAATI2N02
Auirerrat rj TovvavTiov aixapTavova-av i(f)op&ixv, 6pdr}v rj

Xprja-Triv ?/ ri t&v Kak&v ovofJidTcov avTfj T:poa6r\a-op,(v

nPX2. 'AA.A.' ovx oXov re, eiTrep aixapTrjaeTai ye

qbovq.
10 212. Kat /i^y 4olkV ye rjbovi] 7roA.A.aKts ou /xera 8o'^rjs

dp^^s dAAa /xera yf/evbovs rjpuv yiyvea-Oai.

HPil, IToSs yap ov; Ka\ Trjv p^kv bo^av ye, 2 SwK/^are?,
38 V rw rotouro) Kat rore X.4yopLev yfrevbrj, Trjv 8' rjbovrfv avTrjv
ovbels av Trore 'npoaeiiroi xj/evbrj.

212. 'AAAa TTpodvp.ois ap.vveis r&i r^s i^doy^s, w npt^rap^e,

Aoyo) ra yw.
5 nPX2. Ovbiv ye, dAA' aTrep aKovo) X4y(a.

212. Aia(l)ipL 8' ^/Aty ovbiv, S) eratpe, ^ ftera 8o^rjs re

dp0?7S Kai /xer' iTTLarrjfxrjs fjbovri Trjs /jtera rov yj/eijbovs Kal
ayvoias TToAAdKts eKao-rots rnx&v iyyiyvoixivrjs;
b nP12. EtKos' yovv jxr} (T[XLKpov bLa(f)4piV'

212. Trjs br] bia(f)opds avrolv kin decopiav eA^co/xer.

nP12. "Ay' oitri ctol ^airerai.

212. TrjSe 8^ ayo).
5 npi2. nf};
212. Ao'^a, (f)aix(v, fijxTv ia-n fxcv \f/vbris, lori Se Kat
akrjOrjs;

nP12. "EoTiy.
212. "Eirerat fxrjv TavTais, ^ vvvbri eAeyofiey, ^801^ koI
10 XuTnj TroAAdKt?, dArj^et Kat \f/vbL 8dr/ Ae'yco.

nP12. Udvv ye.

212. OuKOW eK ixvrjixris re Kat ato-^rjo-ews 8o'a fipXv kol
To 8ta8odfety eyxetpety yiyveO^ Kd(rTOT;
c nP12. Kai fxdka.

e6 ^T-.fiijB ((popwnfv] (pupwfifv Badham e 7 l^ tj] ^ t^ Stall-

baum a I Xeyo/xfv Stallbaum ^Ktyo/xfv B T r]Sovi)v T TjSofjitvTiv B
: :

a 3 T$ T tJ B: a 8 ayvolas Cornarius avolas B T b 4 TjrSe :

T : TjjSe B : tt^ Se vulg. b 9 7]Sovr] . . . Xutttj T : 7)Sovp . . AiJjnj B

b 13 4yxeipfiv BT: iyxupuv corr. Ven. 184 vulg. (tJ Si' t So^dCeiv
iyxope? Apelt) yiyvtO' Vat. : "yfyj/eo-O' B : yiyvfTat T
 4>IAHBOS 38C

20. 'Ap' ovv TjiJLas w8e Tifpl Tavra avayKOiov riyovjxiB'

X<TXiv;

upa. n<Ss;
2f2. rToXAa/cts ibovTi tivI troppuiOfV /xt) TTdvv o-a^ws Ta 5

Ka9op<a[Xva (TVfJ-j^aCveiv iSovXeaOat Kpivdv (j^aCris av TavO^

aTTep opa;
nPi2. 4>aiT)y av.

2X2. OuKOvi; t6 jMera tovto avTos avTov ovtos av^poiT av

<S8e; 10

nPi2. ncSj;
2X2. Ti iiOT 6.p eoTt to Trapa T-qv Trhpav tovO^ ka-Tdvai
(f)avTaCdiAVov vird tivi bcvbpio; TavT (iTrelv dv Tts Trpbs d
eavTov boK(l ctol, TOLavT arra KaTibwv (^avTacrOevTa avT(a
TTT;

nP12. Tt iirjv;

2X2. 'A/j' ovv /jtera raura 6 tolovtos ws diioKpivdiKvos 5

ay Trpos avroy etTrot tovto, a)S eo-rti' dvOp^aTTOS, iTTiTvx^as

inrdiv;
nPX2. Kat Trdvv ye.
2X2. Kat TTapcvex^ets y av t^x av s eart tlv&v
TTOt/u.eVcoy epyov to KaOop(i)p.evov dyakfJLa TTpoa-eiiroi,. 10

nPX2. MciAa ye.

2X2. Khv ju.ey rty y avrw TrapTj, r(i re Trpos avroi' pr\QivTa e
ivTcCvas els (f^covrjv iTpbs Tbv iTapdvTa avra raCr' ai; TraXty

(f)6ey^aiTo, Kal \dyos brj yiyoviv ovt^os TOTe bd^av

eKaAou/Jtey;

nPX2. Tt>7jy; 5
2X2. *Ai; 8' apa ixdvos ff
tovto Tavrbv TTpbs avTbv biavoov-
uevos, vCoT Kal irAe^ft) xpdvov exwy ev avrw TTopeveTai..

C 9 avrhi avrhv T : owt^ (ravrhv B oStos avtpoir' tiv T : oStwj &/

(poir B &' d2 SoKcrcrot Coisl. ; Sokt] (toiT : SoK-fi^roi B d.6 toCto
T om. B
: eirjTux^s T : iirirvx' cbs B e i /te'' T :om. B
e2 waA/)/ T : iroAot & B 63 oSro)s Bt : oStos pr. T e 6 &j/ 8'

T : oAA' B aurhv^ avrhv T : outJ B

38 e nAATHNOS
nPi2. Tldvv ixkv ovv.

212. Ti oivv; apa croi ^aiVerai rb Tnpl tovtcov oirep

lo [xot;

nPil. To TTolov;

2f2. Aoxei fAoi roVe rjp,S>v 7} i/^ux^ /3i/3Aift) nri Trpoo-eoi-

KeVai.

nPX2. ncSs;
39 *H /xy^jUT/ rais ala-d^a-ecrL avixiTCTrTov<ra eij tovtov
212.
mKeiva a rrcpl Tavr eort ra 'naOrjp.aTa (paCvovTai fxoL
<rx^ebbv ohv ypd(j)(.v fjix&v kv Tals yjrvxals t6t koyovs' Kal

orav fxcv dXrjOi] ypd(j)r) [tovto Tb TTdOrjixa], bo^a re d\r}dr]S

5 Kal A.o'yoi 0,77' avTov (Tvix(3aCvov(Tiv d\r]6?s iv rjjxiv yiyvo-
IxevoL' \j/vbrj b' oTav 6 tolovtos Trap^ rjixlv ypaixfxaTfvs
ypa^r}, TavavTLa toIs dXrjdiaLV a7re'/3/?.

b nP12. Hdvv fxkv ovv Soxei ixoi, Kal a7roe'xo/xai to, pr]divTa
OVTOOS.

2^. 'A7ro8e'xou br] Kal (Tepov brnxLovpybv qfx&v iv TaTs

^vxaXs (V T(o t6t xP^^V yLyvoyiivov.
6 nPi2. TiW;
212. Z(aypd({)OV, bs juera Tbv ypap.ixaTL(TTr]v tS)v Aeyo-
fxivo)v (iKdvas (v r?/ i/a;x|7 T0VT(av ypd(f)L.

nPI2. IIS>s br] TovTov av kol 7ro're keyojxcv;

212. "Oray d^r' o\/rea)s 7/ tlvos dXXr]s ala-6r](T0)s to. t^t^
10 bo^a(6jXva Kal Kiy6p.(va diTayay^av tls tcls tu>v bo^a(r6ivTO)v
C Kal Aex^e^i^rcoy clKdvas iv auro) opa 7rcoy. r/ roCro ovk eo-ri

yLyv6p.ivov Trap r^puv;

nPi2. 20o6pa ixV ovv.

212. OvKow at ]Xv t&v d\r]6S)v bo^dv Ka\ X6yo)V lk6vS
5 dkr]6eXs, al 8e t&v y}r(vbu>v -^(vbels;

nPI2. ITaz^raTrao-tz^.

e9 iTfpl rovrwv T : ire/)! roxmav yvyv6fi(vov B : irspj toCto' yiyvo-

fiivov Apelt e 12 /noi T: om. B a^ toCIto t6 ndOTina secl.
Badham a 7 ypd(pri T : 7pai|'p B : ypa<p^ Apelt b8 Aiyo/xev
B : Aeyoi/uec T
 *IAHB02 39C
212. Ei bt] TavT 6pd(is ilpr\Ka}x,iv, ert Ka\ rohi eTTt

TOVTOIS CrK\jr(iilJl,6a.

nPii. To TTolov;

212. Ei TTpl iJikv tQv ovtcov Kal twv yeyovoTOiv TavTa lo

T}fxiv ovTca TTd<rxiv avayKOiov, irepl 8e t^v pLikXovTOiv ov;

nPi2. Ilepl aTrdvTcav fxev ovv t&v xpdvoiv (ucravrcoy.

2X2. OvKovv at ye 8ta Trjs yfrvxvs avTrjs rjboval Kal XvTTat d

i\4xOr]crav iv toIs TTpotrOfv &)s iTpb t5)v hia tov cw/xaros
rjbovStv Koi XvnSiV TTpoyiyvoivT dv, cSo-^' iffuv (Tvp.^aivi to

TTpoxo-ip^i-v T Kal TTpoKvTTela-dai 776/31 Tov pLiWovTa xpdvov

elvai, yi.yv6p.evov; 5
nPI2. 'AAjj^^o-rara.
212. YldTipov ovv Ta ypdp.p.aTd re koI ^oiypa<pr]}j.aTa, a
(Tfxi.Kp<a TTpoTepov tTi6ep,ev ev rjpuv yiyveo-6ai., Trepl p.ev tov
yeyov^Ta Ka\ tov 7Tap6vTa xpdvov icrTiv, TTep\ be tov p.e\XovTa e
ovK ecTTiv;
nP12. 2<|)o8pa ye.
2i2. "^Apa (Tc\)6bpa Xeyeis, otl iTdvT ecTTl TavTa eA.7rt8es

ds Tov cTretra xpdvov ovo-ai, rjfxeis 8' av bLo. iTavTos tov 5

/Stou del y4fJL0fjLv ekTTibcav;

nPI2. nai^raTrao-i fjLv ovv.

2X2. "Aye brf, TTpbs rots vvv elprffxivois Ka\ ro'8e diT^Kpwau
nPi2. To TTolov;

212. AtKatos dvTfp Ka\ cwe/S^s Kat dyadbs TTdvrcas Sp' lo

ov 6eo(f)i.Xrfs kariv;
nPI2. TtVT^i;;
2X2. Tt 8e'; a8tKo's re Kai TTavTdiraa-i KaKos dp' ov
TovvavTiov eKetVo); 4
nPX2. Uds 8' ov;
2X2. rioAAwi' fxifv ekTribodv, o)s ekeyofxev dpTi, TrSs
dvdpcaTTos yefxei;

d. r avTvs BT : om, vulg. d2 np^frdfv T

irp6<Tdfv i) -Kp^crQfv
:

B: efiwpo(r9fv Coisl. d3 irpoyiyvoivr' recc. : TrpoyiyvoiT B T

d4 ifpoKviruaOcu T : rh Trpo\viru(rBai B a4 'ye/t T : y4 fioi B
4oa nAATX2N0S
5 ma. Ti 8' ov;
212. Aoyoi /lATjy d<nv kv kKddTois fifx&v, hs cAiri6as
dvojJLdCofJLiv;

nPf2. Nar.
212. Kai 8j) /cat ra ^ayrtJcr/xara eCcoypa^Tj/xeVa* Kai
lo rts opa TToXAaKt? laurai xpv(r6v yiyvofx^vov a(f)dovov Koi kir'

avT^ TToWas rjbovds' Kal brj Kal ive^wypacf^rjfjiivov avTov

0' avT^ yaipovTa cr(f)6bpa KaOopa.
b nPX2. Ti 8' oi;
212. TovTddv ovv TTOTepa ^w/xey rots fxev dyaOols wy ro
TioXv Ta yeypap.p.iva TrapaTiOe^rdat dXrfdrj bia t6 ^eo0tAets
etyat, rots 8e KaKols <ws av {t6) ttoXv TovvavrCov, r) jur) (f)S>p,iv;

5 nPi2. Kat \xaka (fyaTiov.

2X2. OvKovv Kttt rots KaKots rjbovai ye ovSey rJTTov

TTapcLcnv C(oypa(f>rifj,4vat, \/^eu8ets 8e aSrat ttoi;.

nPi2. Tt /xr/y;

c 2X2. 4'ei;8eVti' dpa rjbovals Ta iroWd ol TTOvrjpol \aCpov(rtv,

oi 8' dyadot t&v dv6p(aTT(av dXr]6i(Ttv.

nPX2. 'AyayKatoVara \e'yets.

2X2. Eto-ti' 8r; KaTa Tovs vvv AoyoDS v//^eu8et9 cv rats tSiv
5 dvdp(aTT(t)V -yf/vxcus rjbovai, p.ipitpr]fiivat /ueVrot ras oAr/^ets
e-Trl ra yeAoioVepa, Kat AuTrai 8e wo-auro)?.
nPX2. EtVtV.
2X2. OvKovv rjv bo^d^ietv pikv ovtcos aei rw ro TTapdiTav
bo^d^ovTt, pirj eTr' oSo-t 8e jur/8' eTrt yeyovocrt /xrj8e e7r'

lo lcropivots vioT.
nPX2. Hciw ye.
d 2X2. Kai Tamd ye ^y ot/xai ra dTTpyaC6\xva bo^av
\frvbr] T^Te Kal t6 xf/evb&s bo^dC^tv. rf ydp;

B,g (pauTdcrfiara (rct) Bury a lo kavT<f T : eavry B a ii Ve-

^wypa^firmevov B : d^wypa^prifj.fvov T a 12 x^^^povTa T :
x*^P<"'"
Toj B b2 ri T : ou B b4 oS B T oS <tJ>) Stallbaum
:

c8 oj/TOJs B : o^Tws T 09 firovfft pr. B T et mox (niytyov6<n,

hrfffofJifvoLs
 *IAHB02 4od

nPX2. Nai.
212. Ti ovv; ovk avTaTtohoriov rai? XvTrats re KoiX

Tfbovals rqv Tovroiv avTia-Tpocpov 'i^iv kv iKiVois; 5

U?a. U&s;
2X2. 'Hs rjv ixh> yjxip^iv ovTOis aei rw to -napaTTav ottcoo--
ovv Kal eiKrJ )(aipovTi, [xr} [MivToi em rois oSo-t /i/.rj8 7rt

Toiy ycyovocnv kvioTf, TcoXkaKis 8e Kat to-cos 7rA.io-TaKts cTrt

TOts jUTjde fJiiWova-i ttot yevrja-ea-Oai. ^o

nP12. Kat Tau^' ovtcos avayKoiov, &> ^wKpaTe?, ^xitv. e

212. OvKoui' 6 avTos Ao'yos &y etrj Trept (fyojSaiv t Kal
OvpLwv Kal TTavTOiv T(av TOtovTOiv, ws eo-Tt Kat ^^vbij TrdvTa
Ta ToiavTa vioT;
nPi2. Udvv /xei' ovv. 5

212. Tt 8e'; TTOvr^pas bo^as koI \prja-Tas dX.\<as ri

\(fvbLS ytyvofxivas \oixV etTrety;

nPi2. OvK aWm.
2X2. OvS' rjbovds y ol\iai KaTavoov\iV wy dKkov Tivd
TpoTTOV ia\v iTovripal ttAt)!' tw v/^ei>8ets eti^at. lo

nPX2. Udvv [xkv ovv TovvavTiov, 2wKpaTes, ^tprjKas. 4^

o7(e8oz; yap tw \f/vbi, pikv ov Trdvv TTovr\pds dv tis KvTras
T Ka\ r]bovds O^irj, pi.ydXrj 8e dkkr} Ka\ TTokkfj avimnTTOva-as
TTOvripia.

2X2. Tas ixV roivvv TTOvrjpds rjbovds Ka\ 8ia TTOvrjpiav 5

ovaas TOLavTas okiyov vaT^pov povp.V, dv TL boKrj v5)V'

Tas 8e "yjr^vb^ls Kar dkkov TpoiTov iv r]\xiv TTokkds koX ttoA-

\aKi9 ivovaas Te Ka\ yyLyvo\xvas kKT0v. TOVT(a ydp b
lo^oos ^(^pria-o^x^da TTpds Tds KpiaLS.

nPX2. UQ)s ydp ovk; etTrep ye ^Wiv.

2X2. 'AAA', Zi Up(i)Tap)(, eto-iv Ka^d ye Tr\v \xr\v.

e I avayKoiov S> 'Sd/Kparfs B T 5 'XdKpares avayKaTov vulg.

: e 6 Kal
XpTjffToj olim secl. Stallbaum : Kaxp^ficrovs Apelt 69 7' B : 5 T
e 10 (tvai : B
y' eJvai T a i iTa.vv'] Badham
tthv (^) ftpijKas ^
Paley a2 i|>ew5et BT : \\itvhu Badham a3 re T : om. B
8 T : 8 (fai B a6 vtmpov (povfiev T : ixTTfpovfiev B er/ BT :

om, al. b3 76 T : om. B

 ;

4ib nAAT12N02
5 TOVTo 8e t6 boyixa ecos hv K^rjTai. irap^ rjfuv, abvvaTov
avikiyKTov hriiTOV yiyvicrdai.

U?a. KoAo)?.
212. Ilepu<TT(a[j.6a 8?) Kaddirep d6kr]Tal Trpos tovtov av
Tov Xoyov.
10 nPX2. "Iw/Aey.

212. 'AAAa fir]v citoixv, eiTrep fxeiJLVqfxeda, okiyov kv

C roiy -npocr^iv, w? oray ai Xiy6p.vai. (TndvfxiaL kv thxlv Sxn,

bixa dpa roVe t6 (T5)p.a Ka\ xoiph Trjs -^vxvs toIs 7:a6r]fxa(n
SieiArjTrrat.

nP12. Mefxvqix6a Kal irpoepprfdr} ravTa.

6 2X2. OvKovv t6 fxiv iTi.6vfxovv r]v rj ^v)(r] tS>v tov
(TtafxaTOs vavTi<i)V ^c(ov, t6 8e Trfv dkyr]b6va r"] Tiva bid
7Ta6os f]bovr]v t6 (rwjua r]v t6 irapeyofxevov
ITP12. 'Hy ydp ovv.
212. '2vkkoyi^ov brf ro ytyv6fXVov iv tovtols.
10 nP12. Aeye.
d 212. riyveTai Toivvv, oTT^Tav ff
TavTa, dfxa iTapaKexa6ai
kvTTas re koX rfbovds, Ka\ tovtcov al(r6r](reLs ajxa iTap'

dkkr]kas kvavTiuiv ov(tS>v yiyvcr6aL, 6 Ka\ vvvbr] e(f)dvr].

nP12. ^aivTaL yovv.

5 212. OvKovv Ka\ Tdbe eXpr]TaL kol (rvvoifxokoyrjfxivov rjfxlv

ep.TTpoa-de Ketrat;

nP12. To TToXov;

212. *12s t6 fxdkk6v re Ka\ rJTTov dfx(f)(a tovtu) bi\i(76ov,

kvTTrf re Ka\ r]bovr], kol otl t&v diTeipoiv eLTr]v.
lo nP12. Etpr/rat. rt fxi^v;

212. Tts ovv fXTfyavr] raur' 6p6G)S Kpiv(r6aL;

e nP12. Uf] br] Ka\ ttS>s;

h8 irfpuffTdlifitOa B : irpoffiffrdfieda T C i irp6ff0ev B : ^fiirpoffOtv

T wi Srav B ews Srav T eus vulg.
: :C 5 ruv Tb ri)v B :

C 6 tJ 5 T b rohs B : C 7 irc^Oo j T b ir\rjdos B irapiX^t'-^^'"'

:

B irapadfx^f^^fov T
: d 5 ovkovv T om. B d 9 Ittj' B T
:
:

iJTriv vulg. d 1 1 Tis] tIs Stallbaum e i ttj?] irofa Heindorf

 4>IAHB02 4ie

211. Ei To jBovkijjjLa rjfxiv rrjs KpC(r(as tovt(ov kv toiov-

Tois rt(rt hiayvSivai. ^ovkcTat Kaa-TOT tis tovtoov irpos
oAAr/Aay //ei^coy Ka\ tCs c\(xttol>v Kal tCs /uaAAoy Kat Tts
a-(\>ohpoTpa, XvTH] tc -npos r)bovr]v Kal X.v7rr] irpos XviTr^v Kal s
rjbovrj TTpos rjbovrjv.

nPH. 'AAA' eo-Tt TavT(x tc TOi,avTa xat rj ^ov\ria-is Trjs

KpCmois avTr),

2i2. Tt ovv; kv p.\v dyfrei to TroppoiOev Kal kyyvO^v opav

To. p.iyidr] Ti]v ak-qO^iav a(f>avCC(t Kal \l/evbr] Trotet bo^dC^tv, 42
iv XvTTats 8' apa Kal rjbovals ovk eo-Tt . TavTov tovto
ytyvofXivov;
nP12. noAv p.\v ovv fxakKov, ut "EiOiKpaTes.

2X2. 'EvavHov hr] to vvv rw (T]xtKp6v (fXTrpoaOe yiyovev. 5

nPI2. To TTotoz^ Aeyets;
2X2. ToVf ]xkv at ho^at ^evbets re /cat aXr]dels avTat
ytyv6pL(vat Tas kvTras re fcai f]bovas ajxa tov irap' avrais
TtaOijp.aTOs avTrCpTrka(rav.

nPX2. ' Akr]6i(TTaTa. b

2X2. Nw hi ye avrat 8ta to tioppuiOiv re Ka\ kyyvOev
kKaa-TOTe ]XTaj3akk6p.evat .OeoapeicrOat, Kot ap.a Ttdi]xevat
Ttap akkr]kas, at pkv r]bova\ Trapa to kvTrr]pov ^xeC^ovs (f)at-

vovTat Ka\ a-(f)obp6Tpat, kvirat 8' av hia to irap' r]hovas 5

TovvavTCov (KeCvats.
nPX2. 'AvdyKV] ytyveaOat Ta TotavTa hta Tama.
2X2. OvKovv ocr(a ^xeC^ovs t&v ova&v kK(XTepat Ka\ eAdr-
Tovs (patvovTat, tovto aTroTeix6jxevos eKaTepoov t6 (f)atv6]xevov
dAA' ovK ov, ovT avT6 6p65>s (f>atv6]xevov epets, ovb' av C
TTOTe t6 eTTt T0VT(a ]xepos rijs qbovrjs Ka\ Avirrjs ytyv6]xevov

6p66v re Kat oATj^ey roAjoiT/o-et? A^yeiy.

62 ] fo-Ti Apelt (post Tiat distinguens) eq iv fitv T ^<r/ij> :

B a I irot(7 T : iroifiu B a 5 t^ B TG
t : a 7 avTai
tJi
B aZTf
: T : avToi al. a 8 koI i)Zovas B a/xa Kal fiSovas T
S,fJLa :

avrals B T : aiiTovs Coisl. b 2 avToi] avTai B T b 9 tKaTtpwv

Schleiennacher : (KaTfpov BT c 2 tovtw B T tovto vulg. :

C 3 To\firj(Tfis T : ToA./i*7j(rte B
42 c nAATXlNOS
nPH. Ov yap ovv.
5 212. TovToov ToCvvv k^rjs o^^o^cOa iav Tfjbe aTTavTS>ixV
^bovas Ka\ XjjTras yjrevbels Irt [jiaWov i] TavTas ^aii^ojuei^as

T Kol ovcras kv toXs {wot?.

nPi2. Yloias br] Kol tt&s \^yLs;

2X2. Etpr]TaL TTOV TToXkaKLS OTL TTJS (pvoreuis kKd(rT(OV

lo bLa(f)deLpo]Xvr]s /xey (TvyKpL(r(rL koX bLaKpCa-ea-L xai ttAtj-

d p(a(re(rL Kal KV(i>(r(rL KaL tlctlv av^aLS kol (^6l(T(tl XuTrai re

KoX akyr]b6vS koX obvvaL kol tt6.vB' OTTO^ra TOLavT 6v6]j,aTa

Ixet (rv]x^aLVL yLyv^fxeva.

nPX2. Nai, raura Lpr]TaL TToXkaKLS.

5 2X2. Els be ye ttjv avT&v (f)V(rLV oTav KadLo-TrJTaL,

TavTr]v av rrjy KaTao^TaaLV r]bovr]v a.TTf.be^afxeda Trap' r]p.&v

avT&v.
nPX2. 'OpOm.
2X2. Ti 8' oray irepi to (r&fxa ]xr]bv tovtoov yLyv6jXvov
lo f]fx&v fi;

nPX2. rioVe 8e tovt av yivoLTO, m ^(oKpares;

e 2X2. Ovbev TTpos \6yov ka-TLV, S Ilpwra/jxe o (tv vvv
Tjpov To p(aTr]jxa.

npx2. Tt'877;
2X2. AtoVt Tr]v ]xr]v p(aTr](rLV ov KcoAt;eis /xe bLp(r6aL

5 o-e TraAti'.

nPX2. Ilo^ay;
2X2. Et 8' ovv ]xr] yiyvoLTO, S Up^aTapx^, ^r](T(o, to
TOLOVTOV, TL TTOTC ovayKaXov i^ avTov avjxjSaCvcLV rj]XLv;

nPX2. M^ KLVov]xivov tov (Tcajxaros e^' kKaTepa (j)-p,s;

10 2X2. OvTOis.
nPX2. A^Aoi; 87) tovt6 ye, 2<dfc/3ares, ws ovre ^801^7;

ytyi^otr' hv kv rw TOLovna Trore oilr' ay rts AvTrr/.

43 2X2. KaAAio-r' eTTres. dAAa yap 0L]xaL Tobe XeyeLS, ws

C 5 e|^s T :
^l ^s B 6\f/6/jLi6a. B T o\|/cyiieeo vulg.
: C 10 Kol
SiaKpicTe^ri T : om. B e i eVTjV B T om. vulg.
: 64 KWAl^6IS
fie scripsi : /cwAvet 6/ue B : KooAvfffis fxe T
 cI)lAHB02 43a
dei n TOVT(t)v avayKoxov rj^lv avfJijBaCvcLV, o)? ol cro(f)OL

(^acTLV' aii yap &i:avTa 6.v(a re kol Kdro) pei.

nPI2. Aeyouo-i yap ovv, Ka\ boKOvcrC ye ov (f)aij\(os

KiyiLV. 5
212. riajs yap ar, /at} (ftavkoC ye ovtcs; aXka yap vttk-
CTTrjvaL Tov koyov iTrL(f)p6ixVov tovtov ^ovkop.aL. rr/S' oSf
hLovoovixaL (f)vyLV, Kal crv /xot (Tvp.(f)Wye.
nPi2. AeVe ott^.

2X2. TaiJra p.iv toCwv ovrcos ^(tt(, (f)(afXv Trpbs tovtovs' io

o-u 6' aTTOKpLvaL TTOTcpov dct Trdyra, oiroVa 7rdo-;(et rt raii' b

ilx\fnjxo)V, TavT^ aicr6dvTaL to TT&cryov, Ka\ ovt av^avofxevoi
kav6(xvofXV rjixas avTovs ovre tl t&v tolovtoi)V ovbV
TTd(r)(0VTes, rj Trav TovvavTCov.

nPi2. "ATray htiirov TOVvavTCov dkCyov yap Td ye 5

rotaCra kikrjde 'ndvG' rjfms.

212. Ov ToCwv KakQ)S rjfxXv elprjrat to wvbri pr]6iv, ws
at ixcTa^okal KdTO) re Kal dvu) yLyvoixevaL kvTras re koI
rjbovas diTipydQovTaL.

nPX2. Ttjur/y; 10

212. '"l^S' eo-rat KdAAioy Kai dviTTLkriTTTOTepov to kfyo- C

IXfVOV.

nP12. US)s:
212. *12s at ixv ixeydkaL /uerajSoAai kvTras re Kai ^bovas
TTOLOvcTLV Tjpuv, at 8' aS ixiTpLaC re Kat (rixLKpal to irapdTrav 5
ovbiTepa tovto^v.
nP12. ^Op66Tpov ovT(i)s ^ ^KCv(as, S) 2ci)Kpares.

212. OvKovv et raOra ovt(i), iTdkLv 6 vvvbri /jTj^eis /3ios

nP12. noios; lo

212. *0y dAuTToV re Kai dvev \apixovQ)V l^a/xey eTrat.

a3 ^e?] ^eli' ci. Paley a lo rovrovs T tovtois B

: b i ^7r({<ra

BT; Sffa vulg. bs Sira/ 5^ vov TovvavTwv add. in marg. T om.

:

BT : post b6 r)iia.s add. vulg. C 4 ws B om. T

: c 9 &i/
i}#coj T : av-fjKot B
43C nAAT12N02
riPa. 'AATj^eWara Xiyen.
212. 'E/c bri tovtoh' ri^wjuey TpiTTovs i)fuv ^iovs, iva
Tov 8' atl tov 8' era pLi]beTpa.
d ii^v 7]bvv, X.virr]p6v, rj Tro)?

&1' (})air]i (Tv TTepl tovtu>v;

nPil. OvK aA\&)s l[y<jiiy. r] TavTj), Tpeis elvaL tovs jSiovs.

SI2. OvKOVV ovK av etr/ to p.i] XvTtilcrdat TTOTe TavTov ro>

nPI2. ITws yap ^y;

212. 'OTToray ovv aKova-rjs ws rjbiaTov TTavTcav ((ttIv

dA.V7ra)s bcaTeXelv tov ^iov airavTa, tL toO^ v-nokaii^aveis

kiyeiv Tov tolovtov;
lo nPf2. 'H8v XiyeLV ^aiyerai ([xoLye ovtos to ixrj AuTreto-^ai.

e 212. TpL&v ovTdnv ovv r]]uv, &VTLVct}V iBovXcL, TL^eL, KaX-

Xiocriv tva ovoixacrL xpw/jte^a to /xey XP^^'^' '"^ ^' ^pyvpov,

Tpirov be to ixrjbeTepa tovtcov,
nPi2. Ketrat.
5 212. To 8?) iJir]beTpa TovTOiV ecrO'' r^pXv ottcos daTepa
yevoLTO av, \pvarbs r] dpyvpos;
nP12. Kat TT&s av;
2X2. Ov8' &pa 6 ixecros /3tos i]bvs r] XviTrjpos Xeyofxevos

6p6(as civ TTOTe ovt el bo^a(oL tls, bo^dCoLTo, ovt el Xeyoi,

lo XexOeir], Kard ye tov 6p6bv Xoyov.

nP12. rTcSs yap &v;
44 212. 'AXAa [x-qv, S eTOLpe, Xey6vT0iv ye Tavrra kol

bo^aC6vT(i)v al(r6av6]xe6a.
nP12. Kat ixdXa.
212. YloTepov ovv Ka\ xaipeLV otovTaL Tore oTav fxr]

5 AuTTwrrat;
nP12. 4>ao-i yovv.

d3 ovK &\\us T : ^ T om. B

ov Ka\ws d 4 \vire7(Teai
B :

T : \virri<rai B us T: aKovari lam B

d 7 aKovcrTis d8 aAwra>s
SiOTtAe?' B iiaTe\iiv a\virus T
: e i 6vtwv ovv oZv ovtwv BT :

al. e 3 tI firiSeTtpa T fir)d(T(pa B e 5 5^ B T 5 vulg.

: :

69 So^d^oi BT
So^d(ei vulg.
: a^ koJ B T (sed punctis notavit t)
 ; ;

*IAHB02 44a

2X2. OvKovv otovTat t6t yaipew ov yap av tk^yov ttov,

nPI2. KiySwevei.
212. "ifevhrj ye iJ.i]v ho^&Cova-i, Trept tov xaipeLV, e?7rep

Xcopis roS p.r] XviTelcrOai. Kal tov yaipeiv r/ (f^vais (KaTepov. lo

nPX2. Kat jxriv x<^P^^ 7^ V^'
2X2. UoTcpov ovv aip(aix6a irap^ fjixiv TavT^ eTvai, KaOaTrep
6.pTt, Tpia, 7] bvo p.6va, XvTn]v p.V KaKov Tots avOpcairots, b
Ti]V 8' aTtaKkayr^v tQv Xvtt&v, avTo tovto ayadov ov, ^Si)

TTpocrayopevea-dat
nPi2. rTo)? 8t) vvv tovto, S 2()K/3ares, ipiaTiafxida v0*
Tjfi&v avT&v; ov yap iiav66.v(a. 5

2X2. "OiTco? yap tovs TroXefxiovs 4>iA.i/|3ou rouSe, oi ri/jw-

Tap-)(^e, ov fxav66vets;
nPX2. A^yeis 8^ avTovs Tivas;
2X2. Kat fxaXa bdvovs Xeyoixivovs ra TTfpl (fivcrtv, ot to
TrapaTTav rjbovas ov (fyacrtv tvat. lo

nPX2. Tt p,r]v;

2X2. AvTT&v TavTas elvat TTacras aTTO(f)vyas, hs vvv ol Trepi c

<i>tXr//3oy ^8oi^as iiTovofxa^ovcrtv.
nPX2. Tovroi? ovv fifxas iTOTepa TTei^fadat (rvfx^ovkeu ts,
7/ TT&s, oi 2(0 Kpares;

2X2. OvK, dAA' u)a-7Tp pLavTea-t TTpoa-yj)i]a-6ai Ttat, fnav- 5

TcvofXivots ov Tiyvri aXKa Ttvt bvayjepeia. (f)vae(}s ovk ayevvovs
kiav pLp.tai]K6T(x)V Tr]V Trjs fjbovfjs bvVap.IV Kal VV0fLtK6T(0V
ovbev vytS, &aT Kal avTo tovto avTrjs t6 kTTayoiybv yor]TVfxa,
ovx ffbovT^v, tvat. TovTots ft.V ovv TavTa av iTpoayjprfaato, d
aK\}r<xfi.vos Tt KOt Tci akka avT&v bvayepdafiaTa' fXTa 8e
raOra at ye fxot boKovatv fjboval akrf^els etmt 7reu(rr/, Xva
^ ap.(\>o'iv ToXv k6yotv aK^6fXVot Ti]V bvvafxtv avTrjs irapa-

6(0fX6a TTpos Ti]v Kpiatv. 5

nPX2. 'Op^ws Aeyet?.

a 9 Yc /jLijv B : fiev T (/i)ji/ t) b9 ot rh irapdirav T

6vap &irav :

B {yp. 01 rh irapdira* B') d i ovx T : aAA' ovx B fjSovfiv recc.

7}Sov-fi BT d3 at . . . SoKovffiv BT : tl^ . . . SqkSxtiv vulg.
44d nAATf2N02
2X2. MeraStwKiojuey 8^ tovtovs, &(nTp o-y/x/xcixous, Kara
To Ttjs Suo-xepeias avToii' ix^^s. oT/xat yap TOLOvbc ti keyetv
avTovs, apxopiivovs iToOev avoiO^v, ws ei ^ovXrjOelpiev otovovv

e eiSous T^i^ (^vcriv Ih^lv, oXov ttjv tov CTKkrjpov, iroTepov ets Ta
CTKKrjpoTaTa aTTOJSkiTrovTCs ovto)S &v ixakXov awvor](raLp.iv

1] TTpbs TO. TTokkoa-TO, a-KkrjpoTrjTi,; 8et brj (re, a> YlpcoTapx^e,

KaOAiTep ifxoC, Kal tovtols toIs bva-xepia-tv aTTOKptvea-OaL.

5 nPI2. Yldvv fxkv ovv, kol kiy(o ye auTots oti tt/sos to.

TTp&Ta /xeye'^et.

2X2. OvKovv et Kat to Trjs rjbovfjs yivos Ibdv rjvTLvd

TTOT exet (})va-LV ^ovkr]deLp.ev, ovk ds Tas TToKkocTTas rjbovas

45 aTTolSkeTTTiov, dAA' ets tcls cLKpoTdTas Kal acpobpoTdTas

\yop.ivas.
nPi2. nSs dv aoL TavTj} a-vyx(^polr] to. wv.
2X2. 'A/)' ovy, at TTp6\Hpoi ye a?7rep Kat ixiyLcrTat tQ>v

5 ^SorcSy, 6 kiyop.ev TTokkdKLS, at Trepi to aStixd elaLv avTai;

nP12. ITws yap ov;
2X2. IToVe/JOi' ouy Kat /xet^ous eto-t Kat yiyvovTaL TTCpl tovs

KdpLVOVTas V TOLS voaoLS rj iTepl vyLaCvovTas; vkal3r]6oiixev

be 1X7] 7Tpo7TTm diTOKpLVOfXivoL TTTaCa-cofxiv TT-T]. Tdxo- ydp

b ta(as (f^aXjxev hv 7re/)t vyLaCvovTas.

nPi2. EiKos ye.

2X2. Ti 8'; ovx avTai t5>v ffbov&v vTTcp^dXkova-LV, &v &v

KOL (TTLOvfxCaL fxiyLCTTaL TTpoyCyv(avTaL;

5 nPX2. TouTO fx\v dkrfOis.

2X2. 'AAA.' ovx OL iTvpiTTOVTes Kal iv rototJrots voayffxacrLv

ixdfJi-evoL fjMkXov bLyjr&aL Kal pLyovaL kol TTdvTa oTToaa bta
Tov (rdifxaTos d(a6aaL TTaaxd-v, fxdkkov t kvbdq. avyyCyvovTaL

e4 Si/crxepeVjj/ T : Svtrxepaivovcriv B e 5 Stx T om. B:

e6 fieyfdei BT : fj.ey4ei} vulg. a4 ^e T :om. B alirfp'] efirep

Madvig a7 Kol fMel(ovs T : fiei(ovs B a 8 vyiaivovras B rohs :

vyiaivovras T ag ttj? B : ittj; T (alteri

tribuens) vulg. t(x
^Ap T Ttt B b4 TTpoyiyvwvTai Stephanus irpoayiyvovrai B T :
:
70P
b6 aX\' ovx BT: 2p' o5y oux^ vulg. ot B: compendium T: '6ti.

apographa b 8 t' B : S^ T
 0IAHBO2 45b
Koi airoTrkrjpovfji.ivcov fJL^LCovs fibovas 'ia-)(ov(nv ; ?/ tovto ov
(f)ri(TOfXv oKrjOis eirat; lo
nPii. Yliivv fi(V ovv vvv pr)6\v cfiaivcTaL.

212. Ti ovv; opOGis h.v <\>aivoiiXi6a \4yovTs w? ei ns c

Tas iiiyi(rTas rjbovas Ibclv jSovXolto, ovk ds vyUiav dXA' eis

vocrov lovTas bei (TKo-nilv; opa b /U7/ /xe ^yfj bLavoovp.ivov

ipoiTav o"e ei TrAeico yaLpovcrLV ol (r(j)6bpa voaovvTes t&v
vyLaLvovTCtiV, dAA' otov fxiycdos /xe Cv^eLV rjbovrjs, kol to 5
(r(f)6bpa Trept tov TOLoijTov ttov Trore yCyvcTaL kKacrTOT^.
vorj(raL yap 8et (papLfv rjvTLva (f)V(rLV ^x^i Kal TLva kkyovaLV
ol <f>d(rK0VTs /Ar/8' etrat t6 TrapaTrav aim]V.
nPX2. 'AAAa (rx^bbv (iroixaL t& Aoyw crov. d
212. Tdxa,
Hp(aTapx(, ^^X V''"^^^ 8et^ets.
S) dmKpLvaL
ydp' kv vjSpH /AetXofS rjbovds ov TrAetous Ae'ya), rw (T(p6bpa
8e Kai Tfa) /xdAAoy v7re/)exov<ras opa? 17 ey ro) a-(i)(f>povL /Sto);

Aeye 8e 7rpo(rix(^v tov vovv. 5

nPI2. 'AAA' ixa6ov b Ae'yets, xat ttoAw ro bLa(f)4pov

opco. Tovs ixv yap (r<a(f)povds trov Kal 6 7ra/)ot/xia^o'/xyos
eTTtVxet Ao'yos cKaa-rore, 6 ro " /xrjSey dyav " Tra/jaKeAeuo'- e
fXVos, w TTfCOovTaL' To be tG)v d(f)p6v(t)v re Kat v(3pL(TT&v
/xe'x/)t fxavCas rj (T(f)obpa fjbovrf KaTXOva-a irepL^oriTovs
d7re/)ydferat.
2X2. KaAws' xat e? ye roi;^' ovrft)? e^et, 8^Aoy &)? er 5
rtvi TTOvrjpCa, yfrvxvs Kal tov o-w/xaros, dAA' ovk (v dpiTrj
fXfyLo-TaL /xey rjbovaC, ixiyLo-TaL 8e Kat AvTrat yCyvovTaL.

nPi2. Yldvv ixkv ovv.

212. O^Kow rovrcoi' rtms TrpofX^fxevov 8ct a-K0TrL(rdai

rCva TTore Tp^-nov ixova-as ikiyoixev avTas etyat ixeyCa-Tas. 10

b II 031/ vOi' B : oiv T 03 ^7^] rjyft BT 07 Se? T :

Suv B d2 56/|jj] Se^let Heindorf o.Tr6Kpivai Schleier-

macher a.iroKpiv(t B T
: d 6 Ziwptpov B Sid.<popov T d7 i :

BT om. vulg.
: ea we^eoj/Tot T: irudovTi B 63 ^ T tj B :

65 ToOe' T TaCO' B : V BT om. vulg. e 10 i\(yo/ifv B

: :

\eyoixfv T
PLATO, VOL. H. 7
46a nAATilNOS
46 nPX2. 'AvdyKrj.
2i2. S07ret brj ras t&v TOL&vbe vocrrjiJ.dT())v fjbovds, Ttva

TTOTe IxOl^O^i TpdTTOV.

nPH. noiW;
5 212. Tas tG>v do")(r]y.6voiv, hs ots eiTro/xcy bvcrxipeis

fxiaova-i. 7ravTe\<as.

nPi2. UoCas;
2i2. Oroy ras Trjs v/^wpas lao-cis rai TpijBcLV Kal ocra

TOLavTa, OVK aAA.77? beojJLeva (fyapfxd^eo^s' tovto yap br] to

10 Tra^os TfpXv, S Ttpos Oe&v, tl Trore (f)&pLV iyyLyvecrOaL;
TTOTcpov rjbovrjv tj Xvirrfv;

nPX2. 2,vixiJLeLKT0V TovTO y dp\ 0) ^(aKpaTes, eoLKe

yCyvccrOaL tl KaKov.
b 2f2. Ov p.ev br] ^lKt^^ov ye eveKa TTapediiJLrjv tov Xoyov
dAX' dveo tovtcov, w UpcaTapxe, t&v rjbov&v Kal tS>v ravrats
(TTop.evcov, dv fxr] KaTo^dSxTL, (Tyebov ovk dv iroTi bvvaLfxeOa
bLaKpLvaaOaL to vvv ^r\TOvp.evov.
5 nPi2. OVKOVV ItOV 7tI TaS TOVTOiV (rvyyVLS.
212. Tas iv Trj fxeC^eL KOLV(ovov(ras Aeyeis;

nPi2. Yldvv fxkv ovv.

212. Eicrt TOLVVV fxd^iLS aX fxev KaTa to (T&fxa kv avTOLS

C roiy (r(i>fxaa-LV, at 8' avTrfs r^s yjrvxrjs V rr) ^vxfj' Tas 8' av
TTJs yjfvxv^ iio.1 Tov (T<afxaTos dvivpr](TOfxev kvTTas rjbovals

fxeLxOcLcras tot fxv rjbovds tol <TVvafx<f>6Tepa, tot b^ kviras

eTTLKoKovfxevas.
6 nP12. YL5>s;

212. 'OiroVay kv rr) Karao-r<i(ret rts 17 t'^ bLa(f>dopd TavavTLa

dfxa TTdOrj Trd^Txri, TTOTe pLy5>v 6ipr]TaL Kal 6epfxaLv6]xevos

kvLOTe yl/vxTf]TaL, Q(]tS>v oXfxaL to fxev ex^'^> '''^^ ^^ aTraXkaT-

Tea-OaL, to br] keydfxevov TTLKpio ykvKv fxefxeLyfxivov, fxeTa

as otsT: om. B a 12 arifiniKroi' BT -.

eyUjuj/CToc vulg. 7]
&p' B yfT
: b 2 toi5tois T : toiJttjs B C 1 oiit^s ttjs T av :

Trjs B o5 rrjs B out^s T

: C 7 TroTe ^iywy T (sed add. signis
transpositionis) : TroTe fiiywv iroTf B
 *IAHBO:2 46 d

6u(ro7raAAaKn'as Trapov, ayavaKTr\cnv KaX vcmpov (rvvTaaLV d

aypiav Troiei.

nPll. Kal /xaAa aXrjdes t6 vvv \y6p,Vov.

2X2. OvKovv ai rotaCrai /xci^eis al pikv e^ tcrwy t(rt

AuTraii; re Kat i]hovS)V, al 8' K tG>v tTipcav TTXeiovcav; 5

nPi2. ria)? yap ou;

2X2. Aeyt bi] Tas ixiv, oTav irkeiovs kvTiaL tG)V r}Oov(av

yCyvoiVTai, Tas Trjs \{/a>pas Aeyo/ueVa? vvvbi] TOVTas ctyai

Kai Tas t5)V yapyakLcrixwv oTroVay {kv rots) ^vtos to ^iov
^ Kal To </)Aeyjuatror, r?/ Tpiyp^eL 8e xat tt} Kvrjo-CL pi.r} (f)LKvrJTaL 10

TIS, t6 8' (TTLTTokTJS fJiOVOV bLaX^t], TOT (f^epOVTfS CtS TTVp aVTO. C
Kai et? TovvavTLov TTVpiaLS ii^TafiakkovTiS (vlot ap.ri\(xvovs
rjbovds, T0T( 8e TovvavTLov tols ^vt^s Trpos to. tS)v e^o), AvTras

ribovoLS (TvyKepacrOcLcras, ets oTTOTcp^ av p^^^rj, TTapi^ryovTO

T^ To. (rvyK(KpLp.iva ^lcl bLayjdv 1) tol bLaKKpifx4va avyx^^v 5
[Kai] ofjiov kvTTas ribovals TTapaTLdivaL. 47
nPi2. 'AArj^eVrara.
212. OvKow oTTOTav av Trkimv rfbovrj Kara ira) rotaura
Travra (rvp.ixL)(6fj, t6 fi\v VTTop.iyi.tLyp.ivov Trjs kvTrqs yap-
yaAt^et re Kat i]pip.a ayavaKTtiv Trotet, t6 8' av Trjs r]bovi]s 5
TToAv irkiov iyKC-)(yp.ivov crvvTtivtL re Kat (vlot iTr^bav Trotet,
Kai Trai^rota p.v xp(a[xaTa, TTovToXa 8e (Tyj]y'.aTa, iTavTola 8e
TTVvp.aTa aTTpyaC6p.vov TTacrav K7Tkr]^LV Kal /3oas fJLtTa
acjypoaijvris eyepya^erat;
nPf2. MdAa ye. b
2X2. Kai Ae^yety re, Si eratpe, avro'y re Trept kavTov troiiT

d. I ScTTepov T : om. B (rivraffiv Bt : ^iffTounv T d3 j/Pi/

B vvv: S^ T dg ^/ rorj addidi d 10 Kvfjaei Heusde : Kiviiad

BT i^ptKVTJTai T : i<piKV(tTai B e i ri 5' ^tI iro\fjs BT : tA 5'

eirtiroX^y Schiitz e2 irvplais scripsi : airopiats BT 63 irpiy

ra TcS' itpocrTaT tuv B
Wohlrab : irpJw tAj twi/ : T a i Ka\
seclusi a3
To add. Par. 1809: om. BT a^ oSt^sBT:
ouT^s vulg. a 6 Tr\eov T irKflwv B ^yKtx^M*'*''"' B T
: (KKtxv- :

fifvov vulg. a 8 dTrepYoC^^/xej/oj/ Buttmann d.irepya(6fitva B T :

ag ivfpryiC^Tat T dTfpycJfeTO B : ba \tyfii' t? T; \iyttv yt B

7*
 :

47b nAATfiNOS
Kol akkov a>s Tavrais rals fjbovais TepTTOfx^vos olov aiToOvp-
(T/cei* Kal ravTtts yc brj itavTaT^aa-i.v aet /xeraSiw/cet TocrovTi^

5 imkkov ocru) hv aKoXaa-TOTfpos re Kal a(^povi(TTepos o)V

Tvyxdvri, Ka\ KaAet 8r; fieyCa-Tas TavTas, Kal tov kv avTals

OTL juaAicrr' aei ^&VTa ivhaip,ovia-TaTov KaTapL6pLiTai..

nPi2. ITayra, a> 2wK/9ares, to. a-vp.l3aCvovTa Trpos tuiv

TTokXwv av6p<aTT(ov eis bo^av bLeiTepavas.

C 212. rie/at ye tS>v ijbov&v, o) ri/owrapxfj tS^v iv tols
Koivols TTa6riixacrLV avTov tov crco/xaros tS>v iiTLTToXrjs re Kai
cz^ros Kepaa6VTcov iTepl 8e y' &v yf/vxv a-(il>p.aTL TavavTia
a-v}x^dkkTaL, kv-nrjv re dp.a TTpos rjbovip kol rjbovrjv iTpbs

5 kvTTrjv, coa-T ets fXLav diJ.(f)6Tpa Kpdaiv teVai, raura p.TTpo(T6i

ixkv bLrjk6ofXv, b)s, OTTOTav [av\ K(vS>TaL, TTkrjp^aa-eoos CTrt^/ixet,

Kai eATTi^ooy juei' \aLpL, Kevovpi^vos 8e dAyet, TavTa 8e roVe

d fxkv ovK ipLapTvpdjxe^a, vvv 8e kiyop.iV ws ^v)(rjs TTpbs a&fxa
bLa(t>epopivr]s iv TTaaL tovtols iTkri^cL dp.ri)(dvoLS ovaL /xetis
fxCa kvTTrfs re Kai 7]bovrjs avfXTTLTTTiL yevofx^vr).

nPI2. KLvbvvevLS 6p66TaTa kiyiLV.

5 2X2. *'Eri ToCvvv rjfxlv tQv fxeC^nov kviTrjs re Kat fjbovrjs
koLTTTf fxCa.

nP12. riota, (ji^ps;

212. *Hi; avTTfv Trjv \}rvxTiv ^'^V T^okkaKLS kafx^dvuv

avyKpaaLV (f)afxv.

lo nPii^. riciis ovv brj TovT avTo keyofxev;

e 212. ^Opyqv Ka\ (f^d^ov Kal 7t66ov Kal 6pr]vov Kal e/)cora

Kat C^Aoy Kal (t)66vov Ka\ oaa rotaCra, ap' ovk avTrjs Trjs

^lfvxrjs TC6aaL TavTas kviTas TLvds;

b 3 Koi &\\ov T Koi TTtpl &KKOV B yp. t

: b 5 &^ 1*: om. B
b 6 auTo7s T Tavrais B
: b 7 lA.aXKrr' aU\ T fiAKiffra et B :

b 9 ih S6^av secluserim c 3 5e 7' &v Badham 8e rwv B T ^vxh :

scripsi iv ^vxv ^ T
: c 6 o5 secl. Wohlrab Kfvwrat B t
K/ceVcDTot T C 7 ravra Se T toOto St; B d 3 yiyvojxivr)
:

Badham d6 Koiit^T; ^uirrj pr. B (ut videtur) dg ffvyKpairiv

BT: (TvyKpiffiv vulg. e^o/te'] (/^OyueV Bury d 10 out^] o5
Ast
 :

*IAHB02 47 e

nPn. "Eyojye.
212. OvKovv avras ijbovwv ixca-Tas (vprjo-ofxev aycr])(av(>iv ; 5

7) beoixeda VTTOixi.fxv^a-KccrOai [t6 (ev) rois ^v/xois /cat rats

dpyai?,] ro

os r' (f)4r]K TToX.vcf^povd Trep x^^^'''''?^'^''

o? re TToAu yAuKicoi /^teAiro? KaTakei^op.^voio,

Kol Tas fv rots OprjvoLs Kal TvodoLs -qbovas ev A.v7rai9 ovo-aj 48

avap.(fxeiyfxvas;
nP12. Oi/K, dAA' ourco ravrd ye Kai ovk dAAo)? di'

(TvixiSaCvoL yiyv6p.(.va.

2X2. Kai /u^i' Kai rdy ye rpayiKas d((oprj(ri.i, orav lifxa 5

XaCpovTfs Kkd(t)(TL, fxifxvrjcrai.;

nPX2. Tt 8' oi;;

2X2. T7/1/ 8' iv raiy Kto/xwStai? Std^ecrii' ^/xwi' r?/? "^XV^'

ap olcrd* &)j eo-rt Kai^ rourot? /xet^ts AvTnjs re Kat r/Sor?/?;
nPi2. Ov Trdi^v Karaj/ow. 10

2X2. riarrd-Trao-t yap ov pabiov, UptaTapxf, ey roi;r&) b

(Twvoety t6 tolovtov kKdcrTOT TrdOos.
nPi2. OVKOVV &S y (OLK(V kfxoC.

212. Ad/Sco/xeV ye /x?/y avro TocrovT^ii fxaWov ocr(o (TKOTfL'

voT^pov iCTTLV, tva Kal (V dAAot? p&ov KaTafiaOelv tls olos t 5

7/ fxel^LV XvTTrfs re Kot fjbovfjs.

nPi2. Ae'yots dv.

2X2. To' rot vvvbrf prf6(v ovofxa <l>66vov irdTepa XijTrqv
TLva ^vxifs 6if(rLS, ij ttws;
nPX2. Ovrws. 10

2X2. 'AAAd fxrfv 6 (f)6ov(av ye eTrt KOKOt? rots t&v 7re'Aas

ifbofxfvos dva(f)avrfcrTaL.

nPX2. ^(f)6bpa ye. C

e 6 t6 &(Tt' i<p4i]K(v rois dvfio7i koI ra7s 6pya7s rh iroXxMppova. irep x*^*"
ir^vat BT : verba transposuit Stephanus : ro7s . . . rh del. Fischer
iv addidi 8,9 2j ts Homerus (II. xviii. 109): &(Tr( BT
a I irodois Par. 1812 in marg. : irdrois BT bs ^aov B: (idSiovT
48c nAATilNOS
212. KaKov fXTfv ayvoia Ka\ rjv bi] Aeyo/xey a^^Xripav ^^w.
nPI2. TC ixriv;

212. 'Ek 8r) TovTcov ibe t6 yiXolov rjvTLva (f)V(riv ^x^'*

6 nPX2. Aeye fxovov.
2X2. "Eo-riy 8^ TTovrjpCa /xey tis to Kc})dkaiov, e^ecos
nyo? iTTLKkrjv k^yofxdvr]' Trjs 8' av Trao-rjs irovr^pias eoTi
TovvavTLov TrdOos expv rj to Xeyoixcvov virb t&v iv AeA^ois
ypa/x/utarcoi'.

lo nPX2. To " yv&Oi. a-avTov " Ae'yeis, oi "^cdKpaTcs;

d 212. "Eyo^ye. TovvavTLOV ixrjv eKeiVo) 8^Xov ori ro fxrjbaixrj

yLyv(oa-Ki.v avTov kfyoixevov vtto tov ypdjXfxaTos hv eirj.

nPX2. Ti jxrjv;

212. '12 IT/jctfrapxf '7reip&) 8e avro roOro Tpixv tixvi.v.

5 nP12. n?/ 0r/s; ou yctp /at) Swaros S).

212. Ae'yeis 8r/ Setr e/xe rouro 8ieAe'o-^ai ra ySy;

nP12. Ae'ya), Kat beofxaC ye Trpos rw Ae'yeti'.

212. 'Ap' ovv ov tS>v dyvoovvTcov avTovs Kara rpia

dvdyKrj tovto to irddos Trao-xeti (KacrTov;
lo nP12, US>s;
e 212. ripairoi' /xey KaTo, \prfixaTa, bo^d^eiv etrat TrXouo-t-

(HTepov r/ Kara r^y avTutv ovcrCav.

nP12. rioAAot yovv eto-iy to tolovtov TrdOos expvTcs.

212. nAeious 8e ye ot /ietXou? Kat KaAAtovy avrovs bo^d-
5 ^ouo-t, Kal Trai^ra o(ra KaTo. to ccS/xa et^^at bLa(f)p6vT(t>s Trjs
ov(rr]s avrots dkqOiCas.
nP12. riaw ye.
212. IToAv 8e TrAeto^rot ye ot//at Trept ro TpiTOV etSo? ro
rciiy ey raty y\rvyaLS bLrnxapTrjKacrLV, dpcTjj bo^dCovTS
lo ySeArious eain-ovs, ovk om-es.

2 &yvoia Cornarius Hvoia B T i.$\T(pav'] afieXrepiav Jackson

:

c 4 5)j T 8 B : d 4 5^ B Stobaeus 5^ T d 7 \4yco B T :

Stobaeus om vulg, : 63 t5 B T om. Stobaeus

. e 6 avroTs :

B T Stobaeus avrrjs vulg. : e 8 tJ rwv iv ra7s ipvxats Badham :

TovrtDv iv rais \pvxa7s B Stobaeus iv ra7s ^vxa7s rovruv T : 69 aptr^

Stobaeus: d/)T^yBT: d^eT^j' al.
 :

cI)IAHB02 48e

nPi2. 'S,(f)6bpa fj.v ovv.

211. TcSi; apT<av 8' ap' ov (TO(\>Las iT^pi to 'nXrjdos T:6.VT(iis 49

avT\6p.evov yL(TTov ipCboov Kal 8ooo-o0ias eo-rt \frevhovs;

nPa. U(as 8' ov;

2X2. KaKov fjikv btf '^ay a.v ris to tolovtov eiTTcbr dp^ws
hv UTTOL irdOos. 5

nPi2. 2^o'8pa ye.

212. Touro toCwv hi biaipeTeov, S ripwrapxf, Stx^ ^^

fxeXkop.V Tov TtaihiKov lb6vT(s (f)66vov a.TOTTov Tjbovrjs Kal

Xv7:r]S o\l/(T6ai ixti^iv. tto)? ovv Tip.vop.ev biya, Aeyets;

Travres oTrdo-ot TavTrjv Ttjv \}fvbfj b6^av Trepl kavT&v a- b
voriT(os bo^dCov(n, Kada-nep aTiavTOiV av^p^aTTOdv, Kal tovt(ov

avayKaLOTaTOv (iT(r6ai, roty piev p(iip.r]v avT&v Kal bvvap.iv,

Tois be oTp.aL TovvavTiov.

n?n. 'AvdyKT]. 5
212. TavTjj ToCvvv SteAe, Kat oo-ot juey avrwy eto-t p.eT

aadeveCas tolovtol /cat dSvyaroi KaTaye\(ap,evoL TLpxopeLO-daL,

yeXoCovs tovtovs (f>d(rK(>)v elvaL TdX.r}6r] (f>6iy^j' tovs be
bvvaTovs TLp(iipeL(T6aL kol [(Tyypovs (^io^epovs KaX k)(6povs
TTpo(Tayopev(i)V 6p66TaTOV tovtchv cravTco \6yov aTrob(a(reLS. c
dyvoLa yap rj pi.V tG>v la-yypdv e\6pd re Kat al(T\pd
j3Xa^epa yap koX tols iTeXas avTrj re Kai oo-at Ik6vS
avTrjs da-LV 7/
8' d(T6evr}s rjpuv Tr]v tG>v yekoCo>v dkrjxe
Td^LV re Kat (f>va-LV. 5

nPX2. 'Op66TaTa Aeyets. d\\a yap t] tG>v f]bov&v kol

\vTT(iiv /xet^ts ev TovTOLS ovTTO) px)L KaTa(f>avr]S.

a I Trdvrws BT : irav a 2 >pevSovs (sic) B T Kal

Stobaeus :

}\ievSovs vulg. ag
Kfyeis Socrati continuat
irus . . . (post T
Xtyeis add. val supra versum t) Protarcho dat B : Tefxvo/xfv B T
Tf fivwixev vulg. b I irdvTes K.r.e. eidera continuat Stallbaum :

alteri dant B T b 2 tovtwv T tovtov B b 9 koI l(TX"povs

:

(pofiepovs Vahlen <po0epovs koI Iffxvpovs B T

; <pofiepovs koJ at<rxpovs :

Schiitz C I TOvTcov B tovtov T : tovto vulg.

: C 2 &yvota
Cornarius &voia B T
: 03 avT-f) Heusde avTt) B T C 4 avrtjs :

B : ravrrjs T C 5 rd^tv ye (sic) /col B om. T C 7 ovirw T : :

irw B
 ^
:

49C nAATX2N0S
212. Triv TOLWv tov (fiOovov Aa^e bijvainv Trp&Tov.
nPX2. A4y fxovov.
d 212. AvTrr) TL9 abiKos eort ttov Kal rjbovri;

nPvl2. TovTo [xkv avdyKt].

2i2. OvKOVV ^TtI llV TOIS T&V k\6pG)V KaKoXs OVT iihLKOV
ovT (f)6ovp6v kiTTi To \aipuv ;
5 nPi2. Tt ix^qv;

2X2. Ta hi ye t&v (f)[\(tiv bpQtVTa^ iCTTLV otc KaKa fi-q

XvTTeto-^ai, yaipHV 8e, apa ovk ^.hLKov ((ttiv;

nPI2. Um 8' oi;
212. OvKovv Trjv St.yvoi.av lTrop.v otl KaKov Tracriy;
10 nP12. 'Op^cSs.
212. Ttji' ovv tG)V ^l\cov bo^ocro(f)[av Kal bo^OKakCav Kal
e o<ra yurS^ bLr\k6op.V, iv Tpicrlv k4yovTs (tbca-LV yiyvi^rdaL,

yekola p.\v OTtoa-a a^rdevrj, p.Lar]Ta 8' OTToa-a pp(t)ixva, {(f)&-

Hev) rj ju?) (f)(ap.ev OTrep elTTOv dpTL, r-qv tS)V (pCkcov ^lv
TavTrjv oTav 4xV '"^^
'''V^ d^ka^rj rots aAXot?, yeAoiav eti^ai;

5 nP12. ndvv ye.

212. KaKoi' 8' ov^ o/xoA.oyou/xey avrriv dyvoidv ye ovaav

(LvaL;

nP12. 2^o8pa ye.

212. Xatpo/xei' 8e 7^ Awov/xe^a, oTav eir' avrf/ yeAw/xcv;

50 nP12. Arjkov OTL yai.pop.ev.

212. 'HSoz;?/!; 8e e77t rots rwy (f)Lk(jov Ka/cots, ov (f)66vov
e(f)ap.v etvaL tov tovt dTrepyaC6p.V0v;
nP12. 'AyayKr/.
5 212. reAwi^ras dpa rjp.ds eTrt rots rwy ^tAwr yeAot'otj

(f>r](rlv 6 Ao'yo?, KepavvvvTas rjbovi^v av (f)66v(a, kvTTij ti]V

e 8 Aa/Be Svpafxiv BT Svvajxiv\a$ vulg. d i ttou B om. T :

d6 5 BT : om. vulg. d 9 S^wioy Cornarius Svomi' B T :

d 11 rijv B T : t/ vulg. e i vvv StJ B vvv T : 6 2 6ir6(ra

BT; ^ir<{(ra ^)) vulg. ^/xfv add. corr. Ven. 189 e6 i-yroio'
Cornarius : kvoiav BT 75 T om. B: 67 Ii/aj B et (com-
pendio) T : om. vulg. a 3 f<pa/x(v B T (pa/xfv Stallbaum
: a 6 a5
B : om. T
 :

*IAHB02 5oa
Tjbovrjv (TvyKepavvvvaL' tov yap (jidovov 0)p.okoyri(r6ai kvirqv
'^vx^js Tjfuv TraAat, to 8e y(\av r]hovr\v, ctjua yCyv^crdaL 8
TOVTOi iv TOVTOIS Tols yjiOVOLS.
nPi2. 'AAtj^^. lo

2X2. Mr\vvii hr] vvv 6 Xoyoi rjpXv kv dpr\vois t Kal kv b

rpaywS tats (jcai Kw/uwStats), /xt) toZs hpaixacn p.6vov aXXa
Kal TT] Tov j3iov a~vixT7d(rr] TpaycobCci fcat KcojU(i)ia, Xviras
rjhovals ajxa KepdvvvcrOaL, Kal kv aA.Aots 8r; fxvpCoLS.

nPi2. 'AhvvaTov (xr] oixokoyelv raCra, ftj Scoxpare?, ct 5

Kai ri? (^lKovlkol -ndvv Trpo? TavavTCa.

212. 'Opyr/y /x?)i' Kat ttoOov Kal Opijvov Kal (f>6fiov Koi
eptora Kat C^Aoy Kai (fidovov Trpov64]xeda Kal oiT^cra rotaiSra, c
ei' ots <f)a]XV ivprjcr^LV ]XLyvvfXva tcl vvv TroAAclKts

X.ey6ix(va. r/ yop>
nPi2. Nat'.

212. Mavddvopiev ovv ort 6pr]vov -nipL Kat (\)66vov koX 5

cjpy^s TTcii^ra ecrrt to. vvvhi] hLaTrepavdevTa;

nPi2. rici)? yap ov fxav6(xvo]Xv;

2X2. OvKOw TToAAa ert tcl AotTra;

nPX2. Kai Trdvv ye.

2X2. Ata hr] tC fxdX.Lcr6' VTTokafxl3dvLi ix Set^at croi Tr]V 10

ey Trj KCDjucriSta fx^X^Lv; ap ov ttCcttcms ydpLV, otl Tr]v ye V
rotj (\)6^0LS KCIL pO)(TL KCU. rOtS oAAot? pahLOV KpaCTLV TTL- d
Set^at* Xa^6vTa 8e roSro Trapa o-aDrai d^f^^XvaC /xe p.r\KTL

eTr' Klva l6vTa hLV fxr]KvvLV Tovs k6yovs, aAA' airAcSy

Aa^ety roCro, ort Kai a-wfxa dvV y^vyri^i koll ^yr] dvV
o-cojuaros Kai koii^ fter' dAAr/Acoi; v rots TTa6r]fxaa-L /ixeo-rci
5
ecrrt crvyKKpa]Xvr]S r]hovrjs kvTTaLs; vvv ovv Ae'ye 7r(>repa

d(f)Cr]s p. r/ p.cras ttolij(Tls vvKTas; eiircby 8e afXLKpd olpLaC

a 8 ifi/x^s T T^^s 'l'1'X^^ ^ : ^f^i^eerffa Se B 8^: Yi-yveflrfloi T

a 9 roiru Badham rovro B T : bi 5^ BT : Se vulg. b2 (co2
Kw/xcf)Siais add, Hermann ciA.A.ci koI T: dXAo B b^ 7iSova7s
B : rjSovas T b6 ttc^i/i; BT : irdvTTj vulg. C2 $<paf/.fv T
(^a/xf c B d2 aavTCfi T : TavTCfi B d. 6 (ri/y/cf /fpo/xeVrjs Bt
Stobaeus : (rvyKiKtpacrfjiivrfs T d7 ac/x'?;^ T : aipfirfs B
50d nAATX2N02
(Tov TV^cr0aL fJLcdelvaC fxv tovtoov yap cfnavTUiv avpiov
e e^eAT/o-o) croi koyov bovvat, to. vvv 8e iirl to, Aonra jBovkojjiaL

cTTiXXicrdaL irpbs ttjv KpicrLV rjv 4>rArj/3os 7rtr(iTrei.

nPI2. KaXws eiTre?, S ^WKpares* dAA' oo-a AoiTra rjpXv

Sie^eA^e otttj ctol c^lKov.

5 2X2. Kara cfiVcrLV tolvvv p.eTa tcls /xeix^eio-as r]bovas vtto

b-q TLVos avdyKtfs eTTt tcls afx^LKTOvs 7ro/)eDoi//.e^' Ai' ev tQ

fiip^L.

51 nPi2. KdAAto-r' eiTres.

212. 'Eyo) 8^ TT^LpdcropLaL [JLTa^aX(i)V a-rjixaCveLV rjpXv

avras. tols yap ^dcrKovcrL Xvtt&v etvaL 7rav\av irdcras tcls

fjbovas ov Trdvv Trtos TrdOojxaL, dAA' oTrep eiTroy, fxdpTvcrt

5 KaTayj)5>ixaL Ttpos to tlvcls rjbovas eimt boKOVcras, ova-as 8'

ovbapLcas, Kal jxeydkas erepas rtms dfxa /cat TroAAaj ^avTa-

crdeLo-as, etyai 8' avrds avfx-n^vpp.ivas 6p.ov XviraLS re naX
dvaiTavcrecrLV obvvSiV T<av fXiyLaroiv TTfpC re cratfxaTos Kal
ylrvxfjs aTTopias.

b nPI2. 'AArj^ets 8' av TLvas, S) 2(0Kpares, viTokafx^dvuiv

opOcas TLS bLavoolT dv;
2X2. Tds Trept re rd KaAd kcyopieva x/JW/xara Kat Trepi
rd (r)(riixaTa Kal t5)V 6crfx5)V tcls TrAeto-ras xat Tas tG)V

5 (\)66yyii)v KOL ocra tcls ivbeCas dvaLO-O-qTovs ^\0VTa Kol

akvTTOVS ras TTkrjpcacr^LS alcrOrfTCLS Kal rjbcLas [Ka^apds
kVTT&v] TTapabLbcoCTLV.
nPi2. ricSs 87) raura, S 2wK/)are?, av kiyofxev ovtco;
2X2. Ildvv fxkv ovv ovk v6vs brjkd kcrTLV h kiyu), iret-

C paTGOv fxrjv brfkovv. crxrffxdTcov re yap KaAAoj ov^ oiTep

hv VTTokdlSoLev ot TroAAot TTeLpG)fxaL vvv keycLV, rj ((^cov rj

TLV(t)V Q))ypa(prffxdT(i)V, dAA' ev^u ri Aeyw, c^rfcrXv 6 koyos,

a 2 fieraPaX&iv B T fieTa\afii>v t tj/xTv

: B T vfiiv vulg. :

a 5 nphs B compendium T iir\ Coisl.

: rb T re B : a 8 ffd- :

fj,aTos T ffwfxa B
: b 2 rts T om. B b 6 KaBaphs \vnwv:

secl. Badham bg oSi/ secl. Badham c i KaWos (compend.)

T : KaKws B : KaWovs vulg. C2 J^ C^'^'' ^ oTb' C4^'<"'
"^
 :

4)IAHB0S 51C

Koi TTept^epes koI cltto tovtoov bij rci re rois Topvois ytyvo-

fieva iTTiTrebd re Koi o-repea Koi ra rois Kavoai Koi ycaviais, 5

ei" iiov \xav6aviis. TavTa yap ovk eirai TTpos tl KaXa kiyco,

Kaddirep aXXa, dAA' det KoXa Kaff' avTo. Tre^pv Kivai. Kai Tivas
i)hoi)ds oiKeias exeti', ovb\v ^rais t&v Kvi](rc(t>v TTpoa(f)epeLS' d
Kat \p(iiip.aTa br] tovtov tov tvttov ^xovTa [KoXa Kal ijbovds]
dAA' dpa pLavddvojxev, 7/ tt&s;
nPi2. netp(S/xat /xeV, o) SwKpares' Tretpd^Tjrt 8e Kat (tu

a-a(f)4a-Tpov tl XiyeLV. .
5

2i2. Aeyco bi] rjxds t&v (f)66yy(ov rds Aetas Kai Xap,-
TTpds, Tas V TL Ka6apov teto-a? jueAos, ov irpos ^Tepov KoXds
dAA' avrd? Ka6^ avrds eXvaL, Ka\ tovt()v avix(f)VTOvs rjbovds

kiTO]xivas.

nPIi. "Eo-ri ydp ovv Koi tovto. 10

Si2. Td 8e Trepi rds d(Tp.ds tjttov pikv tovt(ov Oclov yevos e

rjbov&v To be ]xr] a-vpi[xefxeLx6aL ev avTaLS dvayKaiovs KviTas,
Kal 0777/ TOVTO Kal v oTcp TvyxdvcL yeyovbs qfxlv, tovt
(KeivoLs Ti6r]ixL dvTicrTpo(\)ov dirav. dAA', et Karayoet?,
raCra etSr/ bvo {S)v) keyofxev r]bov&v. 5
nPll. KaTavoo).
2X2. "Ert br] Toiwv tovtols TTpo(T65)]xev Tas Trept rd
pLa6i]ixaTa r]bovds, et dpa SoKoCcrti' r^ix^LV aSrat TTeivas [xkv jxr] 5^
exeir Tov ]xav6dveLV [xrjbe 8td fxa6rjfxdT()v TTeivr]v dXyqbovas
e^ dpxrjs yLyvofxevas.
nPI2. 'AAA' ovro) (rvvboKeL.
2X2. Tt bi; ]xa6r]ixdT(i)v 7rA7/p&)^eto"ty edv vcTTepov diro- 5

/3oAai 8td r% At/^t/s yryycoyroi, Ka6opas TLvas ev avTals

dXyr]b6vas;

d I Kv^irew/ Heusde : Kiviifffwv BT d2 5^ BT : S^irou vulg.

KaXa Kal ^Sovtis secl. Stallbaum d6 ffX^^ ^^- Bury : ras BT
Tos \elas T : ToAetos B d7 te^o^os (sic) T : jovo^os (sic) B Ka\ii.s
T: om. B ei toiJtwBT: om. vulg. ea dj/o^/caioi/s BT
avayKaias vulg. e4 iKeivois BT : iKeivrjs vulg. e 5 wv
\4yofj.ev Jackson ^eyofifvwv B
: T a3 yiyvo/i4vai T : ytvonfvas B
as irAi;^(i>0c?a'(i' Schiitz ir\rip(6fiffwv
: BT
'52a nAATONOS
nPH. Ou n cf)V(ri ye, dW' h> tktl Xoyicrjxols tov
b TraOtjfjiaTos, orav tls (TTep-qdels kvTrrjdf] bi.a Tr]v xpeiav,

2X2. Kal ixrjv, S) fiaKdpLe, vvv ye rjfxeLS avTO, to. tijs

0j;(recos' fiovov T!adr]p.aTa xcoph tov XoyLcrfxov biaTrepaLVOixev.

nPX2. ^AXrjOrj TOLVvv Aeyeis otl xoopls Xvirrjs rjpXv At/^tj

5 yiyv^TaL kKaaTOTi kv toIs p.adr\ixa(rLV.

212. TavTas tolvvv Tas tQ)V p,a0r]ixaT(av rjhovas aiXLKTOvs

T eimi XvTraLS pr]Tiov kcll ovSa/xwj rwy iroXkSiV avdpcaiTd^v

aXXa T&v (r(f)6bpa oXLyodv.

nPX2. rTws yap ov pr]TOv;

C 212. OvKovv OTi /xerptois rySr/ bLaKKpLiX(9a Xdipls rcis

re KaOapas fjbovas Kal tcls (rx^bbv aKaddpTovs 6p6S)s av

k)(dL(ras, TTpocrd&ixev ro) Xoyo) rats ]XV (rcjyobpaLS rjbovals

ap.TpLav, TOLS b\ fxrj TovvavTLOV ijxixfTpLav Kal {tcls) to

5 ixiya Kal to (rcpobpov av (8exojU.eras), Kal TToXkaKLS Kal

oAiyaKis yLyvoixivas TOLavTas, Trjs tov air^Lpov ye Klvov

Kal rJTTov Kal ixaXXov 8ta re (rw/>taros Kai ^x^^ (pepopiivov
d [Tj-poo-J^w/xey avras etyat yivovs, Tas 8e /xr/ rwv e/i/xerpcoi/.

nPX2. ^OpO^TaTu Aeyet?, w Sw/cparej.

2X2. *'Ert TOLVVV Tvpbs tovtols p.Ta Tavra Tobi avTUiV
bLaOeaTiov.
5 nP12. To Ttotov;

2X2. Tt TTore x/J^ (pdvai irpbs dk-qdeLav etmi; ro Ka6ap6v

re fcal eiAiKptyes ^ ro (r(f)6bpa re Kai ro ttoAv Kai ro /ie'ya
Kot To LTap.6v;
nPX2. Tt TTor' dpa, S) 2coKpares, ^pcorfiy j3ov\6nVos;
' 2X2. M?]8eV, a> ripcorapxfj eiriAeiTrety eAe'yxft)i' r]bovr]s

b I iraO^fiaTos G t : fxaO-fiiJ.aTos BT b2 t^ BT : xat ri vulg.

b4 A^0jj T : dAj0^ B b5 ^^^i/eTot T : ylv^rO^ B b7 \v-
Kais BT : Xvttjjs G om. B c2 &j/ T
C 4 Tay add, Stall-
:

baum c 5 Sfxof^^fas add. Stallbaum e Ficino c 6 t^s B T :

secl. Stallbaum auctore Stephano "y^ ^ * t6 T t6 7' vulg. :

d I TrpotT secl. Stallbaum avTiis corr. Ven. 189 oiiTors B T :

Tos T: Toiy B M^ T: om. B d^ liadeaTeov corr. Ven. 189:

StaBfTfov B T d 8 haixSv scripsi 'tKav6v B T fort. fiaviKdv : :

Apelt
 <J>IAHB0:2 526
re Kal eTrto-r^/juiJjs, d t6 fxev ap' avr&v kKar^pov Kadapov e
eo"7"i, To 8' oi) Kadapov, iva KaOapov kKaTepov iov eis ti]v

KpC<Ti.v iiJLol Kal aol Kal avvcmaa-i ro tcr8e /sao) itapiyr] ttjv

KpCa-LV.

nPX2. 'OpBoTaTa. 5
2i2. 'Wi 8^, Tttpl TrdvToov, oaa KaOapa yivr] 'Kiyo]x.ev,

0VT(iia\ bl.aVOr]6cOIXV' TTp0k6lJ.V0t, TTp&TOV aVT&V V TL

a-KOTTbilXeV,

nPi2. Ti ovv TTpoiktafXfOa; 53

212. To \(vk6v (V rois itpSiTov, ei ^ovkei, Oeaa-afxeOa
yivos.
nPi2. ndvv ixV ovv.

212. rTws ovv av \VKOv Kal tLs KaOapoTt^s i]]xlv eirj; 5

TTOTfpa t6 fxeyia-Tov re Kat TrAeto-roy r] t6 aKpaTiaTaTov, iv
<j) ^pdifxaTos ixr]b(fxia fxolpa dkkr] fxr]bv6s iViirj;
nPX2. AT/Aoy ort t6 }mkia-T dki,KpiVs ov.
212. 'Opd&s. ap ovv ov tovto dkr]64aTaTov, S) Tipta-

Tapyje, koI a/>ta 8r) Kakkia-Tov t&v kcvK&v TrdvTcmv 6-qa-oixev, b

dAA' oi) t6 TrXeto-roi' ovh\ t6 ixiyiarov;
nPi2. 'Op^orara ye.
2X2. 2/iitKpoy apa Ka6ap6v kiVK6v fxefxdyfxivov irokkov
kiVKov kevKOTcpov dfxa kol Kakktov Kai dkr]6iaTipov idv 5

(j)S)lx(v yiyva6aL, TTavTdiiaa-LV kpovixev 6p6S)S.

nPi2. 'Op66TaTa fxkv (xvv.

2X2. Tt ovv; ov hr^TTov iTokk&v ber]a6ix6a iTapabiiyixd-

Toov TOLOVToov (TTL t6v Trjs r^bovrjs iripL koyov, dA\' dpKet
vouv r]fXLV avT66V ws dpa Kai avfxiTaara rfbovi] a-fxiKpa 10

fxeydkrfs Kal okCyi] iTokkrjs, Ka6apa kvTir]S, rjbCtav Kat C

dkr]6aTpa Kai KakkCoiV yCyvoLT dv.

e2 Ihv T : Hdv B 63 ^oio B (talws T : e 7 eV rt T ^y :

riiTi B e8 a'KoirS>iJ.ivB T SiaiTKonwixtv vulg.

: a 2 trpwrov
B vpwTois T
: a 5 &/ B o5 T : a 6 aKpaTfffraTov B T :

aKp6rarov i,sic) marg. t a 7 ^AAtj T oAAo ^ B SaAoi/ Badham

: :

ivti-n B : &j/ elfr; T ag oii B om. T : b^ KtvKov T /coSo- :

pov B
53C nAATilNOS
nPXi. ^(pobpa jjiev ovv, koI t6 ye 7rap6.bii.yixa lKav6v.
2X2. Tt 8e To rotoVSe; apa TTcpl r]bovris ovk aKr]K6ap.iv
5 ws' aet yiviais kcTTiv, ova-Ca b\ ovk ecrrt to Trapa-nav rjbovfjs;

KoiJ.\l/ol yap 8^ rives av tovtov tov koyov eTTtx^etpoCo-t

lxr]vvLV rjpXv, ots 8et x<iptv ^yjeiv.

nPH. Ttg??;
211. AtaTTepavovixaC o-ot rour' avro i7Tavp(>Tu>v, S
d ripwrapxf <^^Ae.

nPX2. Ae'ye Kat ipcaTa ix6vov.

212. ^EaTov brj TLV bvo, to pikv avTo kuO^ avTo, to 8'
dei ((pLejxevov &XX.ov.
5 nPX2. ITa)? TovToo Kal tlv Ae'yets;

212. To [xkv (T[xv6TaTov det iT(f)VK6s, to 8' eAAtTres

eKetVou.
nPIl. Ae'y' ert (ra^i(TTpov.

2X2. riatStKd TTOD Ka\d Kat ayada T9(iopr]KaiXV a[xa

lo Kttt ipacTTas avbp^Covs avT&v.

nPX2. ^(pobpa ye.
2X2. Tovrots tolvvv eotKo'ra bvolv ov(n bvo akka C^ret
e KaTO. TtAvd^ 5a-a \yofXV eiyai.

nPX2. To TpiTOv Ir' p&; Ae'ye cra^aTpov, u> "Ei^aKpaT^s,

OTL A.e'yeis.
2X2. Ovbiv TL ttolklKov, S> ITptorapxf' dAA' 6 Ao'yo9

epecrxrjAet rwy, Ae'yet 8' ort ro VK(x tov t5>v ovto^v

5 /u.ei'

(TT dei, To 8' oS xopiy kKaa-TQT to tlvos VKa yLyv6]XVov

dei yCyveraL.
nPX2. Mo'yts [xadov 8td to ttoXXAkls X^x^rjvaL.
2X2. Tdxa 8' lo-cos, w Trat, fxaXXov ]xa6r]a-6]X6a irpo-
54 eA^o'yros tov Koyov,
nPX2. Tt ydp ov;

c 7 Se? B : S^ T C 9 toOt' out^ T toOto B : d5 roiroi

ex rovrw (sic) T : rovro B (J 8 A.ey' cTi B Aeye : t^ T e 2 t^
rpirov er (pa> Badham : rh rpirov krep<f BT Socrati continuantes
e 5 ToD rwv T : roirwv B e 6 o T : ou B
 4)IAHB0S 54a

212. Avo br] Tabe erepa Xa^UiixiV.

nPi2. Uoia;
2X2. *Ei^ jLtey ri y4v(nv TrdvTOiv, Tr]v be ov<rCav TCpov kv. 5
rrPI2. Avo aT:ob4\oyi.ai (tov raura, ovcriav Kal yivicriv.

2i2. 'OpdoTaTa. iroTepov ovv TOVTOiv ivcKa TTorepou, rr/y

yeVeo-ty ova-ias VKa (f^&fxev rj ttjv ovcriav (Ivai, y^viawi
(VKa;
nPi2. ToSro 6 TTpocrayopfViTai oixrCa et yv4(r(as ivKa 10
rorr' (mv oirep eori, vvv TTVvddvrj;
Si2. <t>aivopLai.

nPX2. Hpos deS>v ap \p.v\ iTravepbiTqs /xe rotoVSe ri; b

Ae'y'j S npcorap)(e, /tAoi, TroVepa TrAotcoy vavirr^yiav iv^Ka
(f)rjs yiyvecrdaL p,a\kov r) TrXota ez^exa vavnr^yias, Kal Trdvd'
oTiocra TOLavT ia-Tiv;

212. Ae'yaj tovt avro, S) TIp^aTapx^. 5

nP12. Tt ovv ovK avTos aTreKpivoo (ravT(a, a> 2wKpares;

2X2. Ovbev 5tl ou* ot) fx^VTOL tov koyov o-u/x/xeVexf.

nPI2. Udvv p.v ovv.

2X2. ^rjfxl br] yvi(reoi9 picv ^veKa (fidpixaKd re Kat irdvTa c

opyava Kal iracrav vXrjv TiapaTiOecrOaL iracTLv, kKd(TTr]v b\
yV(TLv dXkqv dXXrjs ova-ias tlvos kKdcrTTjs evKa yCyvecrOai,
crvp.Traa-av 8e y4vcrLV ovcrias ^VKa yiyveadaL arvp.'nda'r]s.

nPX2. 2a0e'oTara ]Xv ovv. 5

2X2. OvKovv rjbovrj ye, etTrep yivea-is iariv, ^VKd rivos
ova-ias e^ dvdyKr]s yiyvoLT dv.
nPX2. i:C]xr]v;

2X2. To ye ixr]v ov VKa to VKd tov yLyv6]XVov del

yCyvoLT dv, V Tfj Tov dyaOov fxoCpq iK^lvo eo-rt* to bk 10
rtfos VKa yLyv6]Xvov ets dXkr]v, ai dpLcrT, fxolpav dTOV.

b I &I' BT : secl. Badham iirapepwr^s B : iwtputr^s T roiovSe

. . b4 4ffrli/ Protarcho dedit Badham, Socrati dant B T vulg.
b 2 AeV S> Badham Aeyw iS B T fnol B T aoi vulg.
: : b 3 VeKo
ante vavirriyias B T om. al. b 7 ffVfifitTex^ ^ fifrex^
: : T b 9 fiiv
T i/x B
: c 3 yiyvfff&ai C 4 e/6o T om. B
. . C4
. : lvn.Trd,ffr)s
T |u/t7ra(r>7 B
: c 9 rb tVe/cct B t 7$ eVtxa T :
54C nAATX2N0S
nPi2. '
AvayKaioTarov.
d 212. 'Ap' ovv rjbovrj ye eiTTf/) yivea-is ((ttlv, els aWrjv
Tj Ti]v Tov ayadov \xoipav avrrjv TidiVTcs 6p6S>s Orjo-oixev;

nPX2. 'OpdoTaTa \j.\v ovv.

2X2. OvKovv orrep apyo^iivos ititov tovtov tov \6yov, tw

5 }xr\vv(TavTi r^s rjbovfjs irepi t6 yivcri.v \x4v, ovcriav 8e /xjj8'

rjVTLvovv avTrjs (Tvai,, \api.v \iiv 8et* brjXov yap otl ovtos
T&v (jyaa-KovTCtiv i]bovriv a.yadov ilvaL KaToyfX^.
nPI2. '2(f)6bpa ye.
C 2X2. Kal ixrjv avTos ovtos eKacrrore Kal Totv Iv tols
yve(r(rLV aTroTeXovfxivcov KarayeXacrerat.

nPi2. nS>s 8r) Ka\ t;ol(ov Ae'yeis;

212. T(av o(roL ^L(i!>ixV0L rj Treii^r/y 17 bC^av ?/ tl tSiv

5 T0L0VT(iiv, ocra yV(TLS k^LaTaL, x.ai.povcrL 8ia rqv yV(rLV aT

rjbovrjs oikttjs avTrjs, Kai (^acTL Cw ovk av hi^a^rOaL jxi]

bL^iivTs T Kal TTLvwvTs Kal raA.A.a a TLS av eiTTot Trai^ra

TO. Tt6]XVa TOLS TOLOVTOLS 'nadr\lxa(TL [Xr] 'n6.(T\0VTS.

55 nPI2. 'EoiKao-t yovv.

212. OvKovv tQ yCyv^crdaL ye TovvavrCov airavTes to
(f)6LpCr$aL (f)aLIXV 6.V.

nPX2. 'AvayKaioy.
5 2X2. Tr]v br] (\>dopav kcu yVcrLV alpolT av tls Tovd'
aLpov\xvos, dA.X' ov tov TpLTov KLvov ^Lov, Tov V (S /x^re

yjxLpLV \xr\T XvnelcrdaL, <f)povLV 8' 171 [Swaror] ws otoV re

Ka6ap(aTaTa.
nPX2. IIoAAt/ rts, ws OlkV, w ^wKpares, dAoyta (rvfx-

10 l3aLVL yCyvecrdaL, edy rts Tr\v f]bovr]V q)S ayadov rjixlv

TLdfJTaL.

2X2. YloW-q, eTret Kat rr/Se ert ky(OfXV.

nPX2. Ufj;

d 6 ^x**" Sei T ex<' : SfTv B : Se7 txfty vulg. d 7 KarayfKa

B T 7p. KaTaye\d(reTai t
: e i a^rbs scripsi : ainhs B T 6 ourbs
:

Bekker 64^ ireivriv T : -jreivriv B a 2 t^J T :tJi B ye

T om.: B as TiJ B : (5 T a 7 SwotJij' secl. Bekker
 4>IAHB0S 55 b

2X2. ITws ovK aXoyov ecrrt fxrjbcv ayadbv elvai /xrjSe b

Kokov (J.r]T iv crdi^acn ixr\T iv TToAXots aAAots Tikrjv kv

"^VXV' "^* VTavda ribovrjv jxovov, avhpiiav 8e 17 (ra)(f)po(rvvr]V

fj vovv r] TL t5)V aWaiv ocra ayaOa eiAjJX^ '^XV M^Sf^

ToiovTOV (Tvai,; irpos rovrots 8e ert 701 ju.tj ^atpoiTa, dAyowra 5
Se, dyayfcdfeo-^ai <f)dvaL kokov itvai t6t otov aXyfj, k&v 17
apKTTos TTavTOiv, Kal Tov )(atpoyra av, ocr<o pJaWov x^^P^'-'
t6t OTav X^^^PV' '"Ofovra) bLacpipdv iTpbs dp^Triv. C
nPii. ndrr' eoTt TavTa, S> 2w/cpares, o)? bvvaTov
oXoycaTaTa.
212. M^ TOLWv riboinjs /Ltey Trdrrcos k^iTacTLV Trdcrav k-nL-

XLp5)p.v TTOLTqa-acrdaL, vov 8e Kat eTrtonj/ixTjs oroy (j)Lb6p.evoL 5

(r<p6bpa (f)av<apLV' yvvai(i)s 8e', et Tn/ ri cradpov e^et, Tray

TTpLKpovoi)p.v, ft)s ort Kadap(aTaT6v <tt avT&v 0u<ret, roSro

KartSoVres eis r^y Kpi(rLV xP<i^H-(^a rqv Koivriv tols t tovto^v

Kal TOLS TTJS ^bovrjs iXp(rLV d\r]d(rTdT0LS.
nPi2. 'Opdm. 10
2X2. OvKovv qfxlv t6 iAv olpml brniLovpyLK^v eo-rt r^s d
jrepi TCL ixaO-qimTa iiTL^rTriiJi.ris, to 8e Trept TratSetay Kat
Tpo(f)iqv. ri ttS)s;

nPi2. OiJrws.
212. 'Ey bri TOLS xftporexi^tKais bLavorid&ixev TTpSiTa et 5
ro /u,ey TTL(rTriixris avT&v fxdWov x6ixvov, t6 8' ^ttov vl,
Kal bL TCL fj^v Q)s KadapdiTaTa vop.i^LV, Ta 8' &)S aKadap-

T6Tpa.
nP12. OvKoSi; xjyfi'

2X2. Tds Toiwv rjy^ixovLKas 8iaAr;7rre'oy Kd(TTCi)v avT&v 10

Xcopis;

C I TO(rovT<f) B T toitovtov : vulg. c4 /iJ/ wcJi/Twy B : fiivTOi, T

c 6 ?x*0 ^X*^ Wyttenbach c 7 &s Apelt : eois BT e8 Kp^o-']
Kpacriv Schleiermacher tois t t : t^s t B T (sed mox ol toIs B T)
d2 KoJ B ^T : d6 tJ> . . . ^i/i BT Ti : . . . iaTi Schleiermacher ;
Ttf . . . fvi Baiter d7 Sei T : Sii B lucaJBapT^Ttpa BT :

oKoOopTi^aTo vulg.
PLATO, VOL. II. 8
55d nAATXlNOS
nPXi. riotas Koi TT&s;
e 212. 0101 Ttaa&v TTov rex^wi^ ^^ ^i? apL6fir]Ti.Kriv X^^P^Cv
Kal fxcTpr}Ti.Kr}v koI <rTaTi,Krjv, s Ittos eiTreiy (j^avkov to
KaTakeLTroiJicvov eKcio-rrjs &v yCyvot.TO.

nPi2. <I>a0Aoj; jaey 877.

6 212. To yoOy /btera rauT' etKdi^ety AetTTOtr' &y Kat ras

ato-^rjo-ets Kara/xeAeray ejUTretpta Ka^ rtz/t TpijSfi, rats r^s
rroxao-rtK^s "npocryjpuiixivovi bvvdfxeaLV hs ttoAAoi re^x^^as

56 iTTOVoixdCova-i, /xeAeVr; Kai TTovta Trjv piofirfv aTret/ayao-jueVas.

riPX2. 'AvayKaioVara Aeyets.

212. OvKow fiea-Trj fiiv irov fxova-LKrj Trp&Tov, to o-v/x-

<\>uiVov apfxoTTOvaa ov fx4Tp(o dAAa /xeAerjjs aToxaa-p.^, kol

5 a^p.TTaa-a avTrjs avkrjTLK^q, to fxcTpov eKaarr/s xopbrjs ro)

o-roxtiC^fo^^at (f)epofXvr]s drfpevova-a, u)crT iroAv fxepLnyfxevov

exeiy ro /a^ a-a(f)s, a-fxiKpov 8e ro ^c^aLov.

nPX2. "Akrjeia-TaTa.
b 212. Kat /XTJi' laTpLKrjv re Kat yeonpyCav kol Kv^fpvrfTiKrjv

Kal (TTpaTrfyLKrfv oxraTljTios evprfa-ofxev expva-as.

nPX2. Kat ir(ii;u ye.

212. TeKroi^tKT/y 8e' ye oi/xat TrAe^o-rots fx^TpoLS re Kai

6 opyayots xp(afivr]v to. TTokkrfV aKpC^eLav avTr} TTopCCovTa

Ti\VLK(iiTipaV t5)V TTokk&V kTTL(TTr\fxS>V TTapiyiTaL.
npi2. nfj;
212. Kard re vaviTrfyCav kol Kar olKobofxCav Kal kv
JToAAots ^AAois r^s ^kovpyLKr\s. kovovl yap otfxaL Kal

C ropi/ft) XP^rat Kat 8ta/3^rr/ Kat a-T(i.dfxri KaC tlvl iTpoa-ayuiyCia

KKopt.y^Vfx4v(fi.

nP12. Kat Trcivu ye, S 2<tfKpares, dp^oSs Ae'ys.

212. &&fXV ToCvvv 8txf/ ras keyofxivas re^x^as, ras /xcy

e4 ytt^j' 5^ BT : /xevroi vulg. a i aireipyaffnfvas BT : dirfjp^a-

fffjifvovs vulg. ovT^y post a 3 vov transponendum ci. Bury
a5
Kol Kieapi(TriK-fi post ouXrjTJK^ add. corr. Ven. 189 (5 pulsandi facultas
Ficinus : oS irXfiKriKi) Heusde) e 1 irpoffayuyitf rec. t Hesychius
Suidas ir/tocroywye^y B irpoaywyiif T
: :
 ;

4)1AHB02 56C

Ixova-iKrj (TDrcTrojLteVas iv tois ipyoi.i ikaTTovoi d/cpi/Scia? 5

f/.eTta")(ov(ras, Tai 8e TeKTovtKrj TrAeiows.

UVa. KeiV^co.
2X2. TovTcav 8e Tavras aKpi^f.(TTaTa<i eimt re^xms, a?
wvhr] Trpwras eX-nop.iv.

YlVl. ^Api6fxrjTLK7]v (f)aivr} y.01 Xiydv Koi oaas p.iTa 10

ravTTjs T^xvas ((f)diy^(a vvvbrj.

2X2. Hdiw fxev ovv. dAA', nptorapxf Sp' ou Sirrds d
av Kal TavTas \KTeov; ij tt&s;
nPX2. noiaj bi] X4yis;
2X2. ^ Api6p.r]TiKr]v TTp&TOv ap ovk a\\.r]v fxiv Tiva
Ti]v T&v TroKKGiv (f)aTiov, aXXriv 8' av Tr]v t&v </)t\o(ro- 5

(f}OvifT(t)v

nPX2. Uf] TTore 6iopi(rdjueros ovv aX\r]v, Tr]V 8e aX\r]v

^etr; rts av api.6ixr]TiKi]v;

2X2. Ov (TfxiKpbs opos, w npwrapxf* ot /uey ydp ttod

jxovAbas avLcrovs KaTapi6]xovvTa\. t&v Trept api^ixov, oXov 10

oTparoVeSa 8t/o /cat jSovs 8vo xal 8uo to. (r]xiKp6TaTa rj Ka\
To. TTdvT(av ixeyKTTa' ol 8' ovk av iTOTe avroXs crvvaKokovdr]- q
a-Lav, et p.r] fxovdha fxovdbos kKacrrqs t&v fxvpioiv fxr^bffxCav

akXrfv &\kr]s bia(f)povcrdv tls ^^o-ei.

nPX2. Kat fxdka ev Xeyfts ov crfXLKpav bia(f>opav t&v
TTcpl apL6fxov Txrra0vT(av, wo-re koyov ^X'^''^ ^^ avras 5
eifat.

2X2. Tt 8e'; AoytortK^ Kat fXTpr]TLKr] {fj) xard TCKTOVLicqv

Kal KaT kfiTTopLKrfv TTJs KaTCL (f)LKo(TO(f)Lav y(t)pi(TpLas re Kai
koyLafxQtv KaTafXkT(OfXV(ov Trdrepoy m fxCa exarepa kfKriov 57
rj bvo TL6&fXv;
nPX2. Trj TTp6cr6v kmfxevos y(ay h.v bijo Kara ttjv inrfv

'^rj(f>ov TLddrfv kKaTipav tovtu)v.

e6 Tcks T : Tck B c8 &s T

om. B
: C 9 cSi/ S^ B Sj} vvv :

T ifiro/Ufi' T : ftiroifKv B e a fivpiuv B nopiuv T : 63 Tjy

T : Tt B e4 5 BT :
y 5 Vat. 6 7^ add. corr. Ven. 189 :

om. BT as T^ BT : rrjs Coisl. ro75 Bekker

:

8
 :

57a nAATX2N02
5 212. 'Op6&s. ov 8' ^veKa Tavra irporjvcyKayi.iBa eis to
fX(<Tov, apa ivvoeis;
nPX2. "la-cos, aWh <Te ^ovXoifirjv hv SLTTOcjyrjvaa-Oai to
VVV (p(i>T(apt,VOV.

212. AoK(i toCvvv (fMoiye ovtos 6 \6yos, ovx rjrrov ^

lo 0T kiyetv avTov ^pxofxeOa, rais rjbovaZs (r]T&v avTiarpo-
(f)0v evTavOa TTpo^e^kqKevai (tkottS>v S.p<i karri tls eTepas
b aWr) KaOapoiTipa kin(rTrmr]s iTn^rnrJiJ.r), KaOaTrep rjbovijs

Tjbovq.

nPi2. Kai fidXa (ra(}>es tovto ye, otl Tavd^ cvKa tovtohv
imKexfLprfKev.
5 2X2. Ti ovv; ap ovk ev jxV toU ^ixTrpo^rOev tt' aWois
&\Xr]v Txvr]v ov(rav avr]vprjKiv (ra(f)(rTpav Kal a<Ta(f)(rTpav
&\Xr]v &Wr]s;
nPf2. H&vv ixV oZv.

2X2. 'Ey TOVTois 8e ap' ov Ttva t^x^V^ ^^ 6p.<awiiov

lo (j)6y^a.iXV0S, eis bo^av KaTa<rTrj(ras ats fxias, tt6.X.lv d>s

C bvoHv CTravepcoTa tovtolv avToiv to (ra<^es Kal t6 Kadapov

7Tp\ ravTa iTOTepov rj t&v (f>L\o<TO(\>cf6vT(jiv r) fxri <f>i\oa-o-

aKpL^CrTpOV X^^
(f>o6vT(t>V

nP12. Kat ix&\a SoKei ]xol tovto bLp(i>Tav.

5 2X2. TCv^ ovv, a> Tip(aTapx(> vrai bLboixV aTTOKpKTLv;
nPX2. 'X2 "SidiKpaTes, eis Bavixaarov bLa(f>opas fxeyedos
ets a-acf^T^vcLav iTpoe^r^^vdaixev kirLa-TrnxCiv.

2X2. OvKovv aTTOKpLvovix6a paov;

nPX2. Ti ixriv; Ka\ lpria-6<t> ye otl tto^v fXV atTai t&v
lo &\\(i>v txv5>v bLa(f>pova-L, TOVT<av 8' avrCiv aX TTepl Tr]v

a5 wporfveyKifj.eOa T : irpo(rfiveyKdfjL(6a B
a 7 rb T rhv B :

a11 vpofiefi\7)Kfvai] irpo$f$riKfvai Schleiermacher

(TKoiruv] itkovuv
corr. Ven. 189 : ffKoirhv 6x\ois B T : i.\\i\s vulg.
Apelt b5
b 6 avr)vp^Keiv scripsi {iivi\vp^Kei corr. Ven. 189) ivevplffKeiv B T :

avevpiffKei Schfltz koI BT

odffav Kai vulg. : b 10 /UjSs] /Jiias (^oiffijs')
Stallbaum filav Badham
: c i Svo7v (Svroivy Badham avTo7v]
fort. Svroiv Stallbaum C 2 irepl BT
rh irep\ Ven. i8g : re irepl:

vulg. ^ T ^ B : c 5 SlSofiev B StSufjiev T C 8 diiro-

:

Kptvoifneda T : ktroKpivov KaQh. B

 *IAHB02 57d

T&v oyrcos <^iAo(ro</)ovi'rcoj' opfiriv aiirixavov aKpi^iia Ka\ d,

aXr]9(Cq iTipl jJLiTpa re Kal api,6p,ovs bia(f>pov<nv.

2Ii. "EoTO) ravra KaTO, cri, Kal (rol brj TnarevovTis dap-
povvTcs aTioKpi.v6p.ida Tois bi.vois TTepl koyoiiv 6X.Kr]v
nPI2. To Ttolov; 5
2X2. *X2s ilcn. bvo apidp.r]TLKaX Koi bvo p.iTpr\TiKa\ koX
TavTais aAAai rotaurai crvviTiop.ivai o-vxvai, Tr]v bLbvfxoTrjTa

expva-ai TavTrjv, ovopMTOs 8e kvos KeKoirco/xeWi.

nPX2. AtScSju.ey rvxn ayadfj tovtois ots ^rjS beLvovs e
ilvaL Tavrqv Trjv airoKpLa-LV, S) ^wKpaTis.
2X2. Tavray ovv \iyop.v liiLaTrip.as aKpL^cXs p.akLaT
ilvaL;

nPX2. Ylaw p.iv ovv. 5

212. 'AAA' r]p.as, S YipiaTapyje, avaivoLT hv rj tov
bLakiyicrOaL bvvap.LS, et rtj^a Trpo avrrjs ^.kkrjv KpLvaLpLV.

nPi2. Tiva 8e TavTrjv av 6ei kiy^Lv;

2X2. A^Aoy ortr) ttcls av rqv ye vvv kiyop.ivr)v yvoir]' 58
rf]v yap Trept to 6v koI to ovTUis Ka\ to KaTo, Tavrov
det Tte<^VKOs TrdvT(i)s lycoye otfiai rjydicrdaL aijp.iTavTas

5a-0LS vov Ka\ ap.LKpov iTpoa-qpTriTaL p,aKp^ dkridicrTdrqv

LvaL yvGxnv. av 8e rt; ttG>s tovto, oa TipiaTapx^, 8ta- 5

KpivoLs dv;
nPX2. "Hkovov p.V 4y(i)y(, Si 2o)Kpares, c/cdorrore Fop-
yiou 7roAA.dKts d)s rj tov TTeideLv ttoAu 8ta</)^pot TTaa&v Tiyj;Q>v
Trdi^ra ydp V(^' avrr/ SoCAa bC iKOVToiv dAA.' ov 8td jSias b
TTOtotro, Kai pxiKp(o dpiarr] iTacrSiv (tr] tS)v Te\v5>v vvv 8'

ovTe (To\ ovT br] kKiivta ^ovkoip.r]V hv evavTia Ti6ca-6ai.

d1 6vTus secludendum ci. Stallbaum koI T : re /caJ B d2 ixerpa

B : rb, /Jierpa T d 4 airoKptv6fie6a BT : a-iroKpivd/ifOa Stephanus
b\K^\v BT : t d 6 kuI Svo fifrp-qriKal rairats B koI
yp. aKo-fiv :

ravrais T d 7 kwai B T &\\ai Svo vulg. :d 8 6e B om. T :

KfKotvwfjievai B T KfKotvuvrifjifvat vulg.

: a i drti) Thompson Hrii) :

B ort T
: i) iros ttv Madvig leaaav B T a 4 irpoa-fjprrirai T
:

Stobaeus Trpoa-fipiyrai B
: a 5 post rl distinxit Hermann rovra
B T om. vulg.
: a 8 Sia<ptpot B Statptpft T b 2 apiar-n:

Koawv B irairctf;/ apiari) T

:
58 b nAATXiNOS
SX2. " Ta oTrAa " /^ot SoKeis /3ou\Tj0eis elTTclv aicrxyvOels
5 aTToXi.TTeiv.

nPX2. *'E(rrco vvv ravTa Tavrr] oirr] (tol boKfl.

212. 'Ap' ovr airtos ^yo) roC /ixt) Ka\o>$ vTroXa^eiv ce;
nPfl. To TTolov;

/ Sf2. OvK, a> (^tAe npa)rapx.fj tovto eycoye e^^row tto),

C ris Te^vr] rf tCs TTLaT)]fxr] iTacrQiV 6ia^^/3C6 t& fJLcyCa-Trj nal

apC(TTr} Kal TrAeio-ra oxf^ekovaa r)fji.as, aXka tCs ttotc to
(ra(f)S Kal TaKpL(3S Kal to okrfOicrTaTov kiTL(TKOiTiL, kclv ei
(Tp.LKpa kcCl crfji.LKpa ovLvacra, tovt ((ttlv 6 vvv brj CqTovfxev.
5 dA.\' 5pa ov6e yap aiTexOrf^rr) TopyCq., Tfj fiiv cKeCvov
VTTapXfLV Tiyvrf bLboVS ITpOS X/OfiCiy TOLS avdpciiTTOLS KpaTCLV,
8' eiTToy iyo) vvv TTpayfmTiCa, KaOdiTep tov AeuKoC 7re'pt
ff

TOTC ikcyov, Khv ei a-fXLKpov, Kadapov 8' eirj, tov ttoKKov

d Kat firf TOLOVTov bLacf)epLV, rovro) y' avT^ rai dATj^eo-rarcj),

Kat vvv brf crcf)6bpa bLavorf64vTs Kal LKavm bLaXoyLo-dfXfvoL,

/utTyr' e?s rtyas w^eA^ay TTLcrTrfpL&v ^k4\f/avTS fxi^TC TLvas
fvboKLfxCas, dAA' ei rts 7r4cf)VK ttjs '^xrjs rfp.G)v bvvafXLS
5 kpav re tov akrfOovs koX TTavTa eveKa tovtov irpdTTiLV,
TavTrfv (LTTcafxev bLc^epevvrfcrdpievoL to KaOapov vov re Kat
(f)povrf(T())s ei Tamrfv /xdAto-ra eK t&v Ik6t(i)V eKr^o-^at
(f)aLp.V av 7/ rtva tTipav ravrijs KvpL(s)Tpav rjfXLV QrfTrfTiovJ
e nPX2. 'AAAd crKOTTca, kcil xaX.Trbv o1p.aL (Tvyx(pw^^
TLVa dWrfv (TTLaT^qfxrfv rf T^xvrfV Trfs akrfOiCas dyrexfc^at
fmXKov rf TavTrfv.
SX2. 'A/j' ovv (vvo-qa-as to rotoVSe ctprfKas o KiyeLS vvv,
5 b)s at TToAAai Tex^oLi-, ^at oo"ot vrept TavTa TTOT^vrfVTaL,

e I ^ T om. B : ca apiarr} {elvai) corr, Ven. 189 03 tl

BT :
^ Cornarius c4 ovivaffa Bekker : ovi\va(ra B : oviva^ra T :

6vfi(Ta<ra t c6 uirctpx*"'] virepfXf^" Badham (post avOpdiTrots

distingiiens) Kpareiv. p S' BT : KpaTeiv 8'
^ Badham C7 ^yeb
vvv B j/C' ^yi
: T d2 5^ B 5i) vvv
j/Cr : T (sed add. signis trans-
positionisl d^ d\A.'lfTisT: iiAATj rty Bt d6 5if|epew7j-
adfifvoi T : Siepevvriffdfifvot B d7 e/cT^crfloi B : KeKT^crOai T
e5 2oro< Ast : 8(ro BT TauTo] tA i/roCflo Schleiermacher : Tovras
Badham
 <I>IAHBOS Sga
irpSiTov fJ.(V bo^ats xp&VTai Kal tol Trcpl bo^av ^rjroSo-t 59
(TvvTiTay.(.v(as; et re Ka\ TTfpl ^weoos T/yetTai rts frjreir,

oicr^' ort ra Trepi tov Koa-fiov Tovbc, ottt/ re yiyovev Kal

oTTrj 7rao-)(et rt /cat otttj Troier, raura C^ret 8ia ^iov; (f^atfxiv

hv raura, rj iTias; 5
nPii. Ovrojs.
2X2. OvKow 011 Trepi Ta ovra ai, Trept 6e ra ytyv^fxiva
Kal yerTjcro/xeva Kai ytyovoTa rjfi&v 6 tolovtos avtfpfrfTat

TOV TTOVOV;
nPi2. 'AArj^eVrara. lo

212. Tovrcoy ovv rt a-acfifs hv f^aifiiv r?} aKpt/Sco-raTt;

aXr]6iia. yiyv^a-Oai, S>v firfTc etrxe /uijSey irwTrore Kara raura b

jUTj^' e^ei ju,^re ets ro wy Ttapov exet;
nPI2. Kai TrSs;
212. riept ovv Ta fir} KCKTrffjiiva ^i^aioTrfTa firfb^ ffVTivovv
TT&s av Trore /3e/3atoy yiyvo\ff r\fxxv koL otlovv; 6

nP12. Ot/xat juey ovSa/xaiy.

212. Ou8' apa vous ou8e rts eirio-rTj/bitj wcpi avrci eorty
t6 akrfOiaTaTov (yovaa,
nP12. OvKow etKo's ye.

212. Tov fx\v brf o-e Kai e/xe Kai Fopy^av Kal 4>^A.T//3oy lo

XP^ (Tvxva yaipiiv kav, Tob^ 8e biafxapTvpaadat. r^ Ao'y^.

nP12. To TToiov; C
212. '12s t) Trept (Kclva ia-6' rffxiv t6 re /3e'/3atoj; Kal ro
Ka6apov Kat dAT/^es Kat o 8^ KiyofXiV dkiKpivis, Trept ra
dei KaTO. To. avra wo-avro)? afjieiKTOTaTa (tyovTa, rj [bevTepos]
(Kfivcov ort /idAiord eo"Tt oryyei^es" rd 8' dAAa irdyra 5
bfVTepd re Kat vcrTepa \Kt4ov.

a I S6^av B : 8<J|os T a2 (TwrfrafMevws corr. Ven. 189 trui'- :

TfTayfjLfvws B : ^vvTerayfJievws T 1 re] i 8 Schleiermacher

as T6 B om. T : a^ vdtrxei B vdffxv T
: a 11 o5i/ B T :

om. al. b I Tavrh, T : Tavra B b li rJSe 8 T to 6 B :

c 2 ^ Stephanus ^ B T : 03 iKridh T t^ AATjflis B

: c 4 Tek
B : T^ T
(sed mox ^x"''') : rh vulg. (et mox ^x"') Sevrfpos secl.
Hermann SevTtpws corr. Ven. 189
: C 5 tb 8' &\\a T : iAAek B
59C nAATilNOS
nP12. 'AXrjdea-raTa Aeycis.
2X2. Ta 8^ t&v ovofji.6.T(av Trepl to. roiaCra KdiAAtoTa ap'
ov Tols KaXX.C(rTOLs biKaLOTaTov aTTOvefxeiv;
lo nPll. EIkos ye.
d SX2. OvKoSy roSs coTt Kat ^p6vr](ns a y av Tis TLp.rj(ri.

/x.aAtoTa 6v6p.aTa;

UVa. Nar.
2i2. TaSr' tipa ey Taij Trepi ro oy ovTois kvvoiaLS kcrTLV
5 aiTr]KpL^(ap.iva opd&s KCLfxeva KoXeLa-dai.
nPi2. Udvv fxkv ovv.

2X2. Kai ixrjv & ye eis t^v KpC^nv eya> roVe TTapa-)(6}xr]v

ovK 6.X\' ((ttIv 7] TavTa tcl 6v6yi.aTa.

nPX2. Tt p.riv, ut '2u>KpaTs;

lo 2X2. Eier. To pkv br] (f^povrjcre^os rc Kai ribovfjs Trept
e TTpbs TTjv aXXrjX^av /xei^tv et ris (j)aCr] Kadaircpil br]HLOvpyoLS
fjpLLv e^ 3)V rj kv oXs Sei hr]iiLovpyLv tl TTapaK^LaOaL, KoKSiS
&v rw X6y(a a.iTLK6^0L,

nPX2. Kai ^oAa.

5 2X2. To bf] pt.Ta Taika Sp' ov fXiLyvijvai e^jrtxeiprjreW;
nPX2. Tt /u.T^y;

2X2. OvKovv Tdbe TTpoL7rova-L Kal dva]xvr]craaLV f]]ms

avTovs opOoTfpov h.v \ol;
ITPX2. Ta jroia;

10 2X2. *A Kai TTp^Tepov kp.vr]adr]p.V' ev 8' fj irapoLp.La

6o SoKei exety, to KaX b\s kol Tpls t6 ye koX&s Xov iTTavaiTokeLV

ro) \6y(a bflv.
'
nPX2. T^ ]xr]v;

2X2. 4>epe bf] iTpos Atos* oi/xat yap avroixrC jrojs ra rore
5 kiyOivTa prfOfivaL.

npx2. nws;
2X2. ^C\rjj36s (f)r]aL Tf]v f]bovf]v ctkottov opdov ndcTL

d lo Si) T : 5^ -yip B ea 5e? B : 5^) T e lo 5' ^ T : S^ B

a I /ca2 Sis BT : 52s vulg. a4 oSToxri T : ovtu B
 T

4)IAHB02 6oa
(<aoLS ycyovfvaL koI bdv TrdvTas tovtov aroxaC^arOai, Koi
br} Kal TayaOov tovt avTo ilvai av}nTaa-i, KaX hvo ovoixaTa,

ayadbv Kal rjbv, kvi tivl Kal (f)va-eL fJLia tovtu opO&s lo

TidivT )(^eiv' ^(tiKpdTrjS 8' kv fiev ov (f^rjai tovt elvai, bvo b

8e KaOdtTip to. ovoixaTa, Kal t6 re dyadov Kal rjbv bid^fyopov

oAATjXcoy (j)va-tv ex^^^' fmkkov be p.iToypv eij;at tt/s tov

dyaOov fxoCpa? Tr^v (f^povrjo-LV rj Tr\v rjbovrjv. ov TavT ^cmv
re KoX ^v To. totc Xeyopicva, S IIpwTapxf/ 5

nPX2. ^(f)6bpa p.v ovv.

SH. OvKovv Kol Tdbe Kal t^tc kol iwv rjfnv hv avv-
OfjioKoyoLTo;
HPQ.. To TTolov;

212. Trjv Toyadov bLa(f>piv (fyvaLV T^be tS>v aKk(av. lo

nPX2. Tlvl; C
2X2. *I2i Ttap^ir] tovt dei tG>v C^(av bia t^Xovs irdvToos

Kal TrdvTr}, /xTjSeyos kTipov itoTe ^tl TTpoa-bcla-daL, t6 be

iKavov TeXeoiTaToy ^y^LV. ov\ ovT(t>s;

nPX2. OvTO) IJI.V ovv. 5

2i2. OvKOVv To) Ao'ya) eTrcipd^Tj/xey x^^P'* kKdTipov kKa-

Tipov 64vTs eiy tov ^lov kKdaT(>)v, dp.LKTov fikv rjboiniv

(f)povricreL, </)poVrj<nv 8e &a-avT(i)S fibovr]S p.r}b t6 crfjt.LKp6TaTov

l^yovaav;
nP12. 'Hy TauTa. lo

2X2. Mi' o5v ripXv avT&v t6t Tiorripov LKav6v ibo^v

eimi TO); ,
Q
nPX2. Kai TTftis;

2X2. Et 8e' ye T!apr\vk)(Qr]p.iv tl t6t, vvv oaTLaovv

Tiava\a^(i)v dp66Tpov eiirdTft), fxvrjjjLriv Kal (ppdirriaiv Kal

kTTLaTrifxriv Kal d\ri6fj bd^av Trjs avTifs lb4as TL6fXV0S 5

a lo rovru opOus r(64vr' Heindorf rovro : opOws redtu B T b i lj/

Badham irpurov B : h 2 r6 rt BT : rirt rh t kcHL T ol :

ri B b3 fi4roxov B /itrdxov T
: b 7 kuI r6re T r6rf B :

b 10 T^5 T : r6St B roiv B T fxaWov rSiv vulg.: C 8 ixrwirais

ijZov^s B : ^Soi/^s io<ravr<i)i T d. 4 <f>p6vT)<Tiv koX iinariifirtv B : ivt-
ar-t^firfv koX <pp6vriffiv T
 ;

6od nAATllNOS
Kal (TKOTrSiv et rts avev tovtcov 8e^air' av oi Kal otlovv
(IvaL 17 Kal yiyvio-Oai, fj.r] otl 8?/ ye tjbovrjv ei0' ws iTkita-Tr^v

et^' 0)? a-(^ohpoTaTr\v, rjv ixrJTe akr]du>s bo^dCoi. \aipiiv pLrjTc

TO itapaTtav ycyvcoa-KOL tC ttot TreTTOvOe Trddos p.r]T av

e fxvrnxriv tov TrdOovs /JirjS' ovtlvovv \p6vov ^xol. TavTO. 8e
Xeyero) Kal Trept (^povqa^ions, ei ris areu Tsd(n]s rjbovrjs Kal
Trjs j3paxvTdTr]s 8e'atr' hv (f)p6vr]a-LV ^X^lv \xdXXov r) fxeTa
TLvmv rjbov&v r) 'udcras rjbovas x^P^^ (\>povria-iias p.dKKov r)

5 pi.iTd (j)povr]a-(o)s av tlvos.

nPIi. OvK iCTTLv, 0) S<oK/)ares, dAA' ovbev 8et raCrdi ye
7roXA.dKts (TTepcoTdv.

61 212. OvKoSi' rd ye re^Aeoy Kat Trda-LV alpeTov Kal to

TtavTdiraa-LV dyadov ovbiTepov dv tovto)v eir/;

nPX2. ITois ydp dv;

212. To TOLVvv dyadov iJTOL aa(f)&s r] Kai TLva tvttov avTov
5 X.r]TTTiov, Lv, oTrep kkiyo]j.iv, 8eure/oeta dro) bcoaofjiev ^yjxijxiv.
nPX2. ''OpOdTaTa Ae^yei?.

212. Ov/coSy 68oy ]xiv TLva eTri rdya^oy Lkr](f)afXV

rrpa. TiW,-
212. Ka^aTTep et rts rti^a dvOpoTTOv ^Tjroii/ rTJy ourjo-ty

b irp&Tov opd&s tv otKei Trv^otro avTOv, jxiya tl brjirov Trpbs

Tr]v evpecTLV dv exoi tov ^r]Tov]xivov.

nPI2. n<Ss 8' ov;

212. Kai vvv Sr/ rts Adyos ifx-qvvaev r]]XLV, uxxTTep kou.

5 Kar dpyds, fxr] ^Tjrety iv rai d[XLKT(a I3l(o TdyaObv dAA' ey

ro) /xetKrfa).

nPX2. ndyu ye.

2Ii. 'EAttis fxrjv TrAeicov ev r&i fxcLxdivTL koX&s rd
Cr]Tovp.evov iacaOaL (pavep^aTcpov r/ ey roi /iatj;

d7 ^ /cal T : ^ B d8 ^c T : ?}' B : ^ vulg. : I Bekker e Ficino

So^dCoi T : So|ctC"' B e 2 Xeyhu Vahlen : Xfyu B : Keye T ef
Tis T : 7}ts B e6 76T:TeB as irws yiip iy Bt :om. pr. T
a5 i\eyoney T : Kfyofiev B b I ojKet T : ojk^ B iriiOoiTO T :

TtiiOoiTo B b2 &>' txoi T : avfX"'^ ^

 4>IAHB0S 6ib
nPX2. Ylokv ye. lo

211. Tois brj Ocols, o Ylp(aTap)(, tvyo^ivoi KpavvvcoiJ.ev,

6Te AioVu(ros etre "HcpaLcrTos eW ooris d^&v TavTrjv ttjv C
TLjjiijv etA?7X TTJs (rvyKpd(r<DS.
nP12. Hdw fXv ovv.
Si2. Kal p.r]v KaOdirep rjpXv olvoyoois tictX TrapecrTaa-i

Kprjvai. iM^KiTos fJLv av direiKa^oi rts ti]v Trjs rfbovfjs, 5

Trfv bk Ttjs (})pov^(r(os vr)(j)avTLKr}v Kal aoLvov av(rTr]pov

KoX vyL^LVov TLVos vhaTos hs Tipodvp.r\Tiov b)S KciAAtoTa

(rv\xp.iLyvvvaL.

nP12. ITcSs yap ov;

S12. ^(pebr] TTpoTepov apaTracrav rjbovriv ird^rr} (ppovrjcreL d
piLyvvvTs Tov KoAdiis av p.akLcrTa eTrtnJ^ot/xey;
nPI2. "lo-cos.

2X2. *AAA' ovK dcrc^akis.

f]
8e aKLvbvvoTipov hv
fiLyvvoL]JL(v, bo^av ]j.ol 8ok<S rtm diio^rfvacrdaL dv. 5
nP12. Aeye rtra.
212. 'Hy rfpXv r]bovr] re akr]6S>s, s ol6]ii6a, fxdkkov
eTipas dkkr] Kal br] Kal Tiyvr] Ti\vr]s dKpLJSecrT^pa;
nPX2. n&is ydp ov;
2X2. Kat eiTLaT-q^xr] 8r) ki:L(rTr]]xr]s b^d^opos, 17 ]xkv km 10

ra yLyv6]X(va Kal dTTokkvixeva diTo^kiiiovcra, r] 8' eTrt Ta e

]xr]T yLyv6]Xva p/re aTroAAvfiera, KaTa TavTa be Kal
otxravTcas ovra det. TavTr]v ets to dkr]dS TTLa-KOiTov]XVOL
r)yr]a-d]X(6a eKLvr]s dXr]60-T4pav eti^at.

nPX2. ndi^u ]xev ovv dpdGts. 5

2X2. OvKow et TdkrjdiaraTa T]xr]]xaTa kKaTipas XboLfXiv
TTp&Tov (rv]X]XL^avTS, dpa LKavd raura (rvyKKpaixva tov
dyaTTr]T6TaTov ^lov diTpya(rd]Xva TrapiytLV r]]xlv, 1) tlvos
^TL TTpo(rb6]Xda KOL T&v ]xr] ToioijTaiv;

bii Kepavvvwfiev T Athena.eus : KfpavvvofjLeu B C4 iraptarTaffi

BT Athenaeus : irapea-Twffi vulg. C5 /jieKiTos BT : koI ix4\itos
Athenaeus c 7 &j T Athenaeus : om. B d 7 fiaWov T om. B :

d8 5)? /cal BT : 5^ vulg. 64 a\r)0effTepav T aff<pa\fffT4pav B

:
62a nAATi2N0S
62 nPIi. 'E^oi yovv hoKil bpav ovrais.

2i2. "Ea-To) brj Tis Tjiuv <ppov&v 6.vdpu)TT0s avTijs Trepl

bLKaioavvqs oti eaTLV, Kal Xoyov exwv knop.^vov tS> voeXv,

Kal br} Kal iTepl TiHv aKKoiv TrdvTcov tS)V ovTOiv axravTOis
5 bi.avoovp.Vos.

ITPI2. "EoTw yap ovv.

212. 'A/a' ovv ovTos iKav&s TTiaT^ijLr]s e^et, KVKkov p.V
Kal (T(\)aipas avTrjs 7775 O^ias tov \6yov ^(nv, ttjv 8e avOpco-
TrCvr]v TavTr]v a-<f)alpav Kal tovs kvkXovs tovtovs ayvo&v,
b Ka\ xp(ap.(vos ey olKoboiJ.iq Kal Tols ^AAots ojuoicoj Kavoai
Kal Tols kvkXois;
nP12. rekoiav btdLdeaLv rip.&v, S SwKparey, iv Tals
OeiaLS ovaav p.6vov knLaTrip.aLS \iyop.ev.

5 2i2. Yl5>s (f)r]s; -^ tov \lrvbovs Kav6vos 6.p.a kol tov

kvkKov Tr]v ov ^i^aLov ovbi Kadapav Tiyyr^v p.j3\r]Tiov

KOLvfj Kal avyKpaTiov;

nPi2. 'AvayKalov ydp, d /ixe'AA.e4 tls f}p.a>v Kal Tr]V obov
kKaaroTe k^(.vpr]a-iLv ot/ca8e.

C 212. 'H Kai p.ova-LKy]v, rjv 6\iyov ip.T:poa-6iv i<\)ap.iv aTO-

Xdcre(as re Kai jXLix-qa-ecos ]xea-Tr]v ovcrav Ka6ap6Tr]Tos evbeiv;
nPI2. 'AfayKaioi' (\)aiveTaL efxoLye, eLiTep ye fifx&v 6
{Bios eaTaL Kal oiTcoaovv TTOTe ^ios.
5 212. BovAet brJTa, wa-Trep dvpo)pbs ini o^ov tls d)6ov-
fj.evos Ka\ l3LaC6]ievos, f]TTr]6els ava-neTaa-as ras 6vpas a^w
TTaa-as tcls eiTLaTr]p.as eiapelv Kal p.eiyvvcr6aL 6iJi.ov Ka6apq
rqv evbeeaTipav;
d nP12. OvKovv lycoye ot8a, a> 2wK/)aTes, ort rts hv
^kaiTTOLTo TTcio-as \a^o)V tcls aAAas eiTLa-T-qp.as, exo)v tcls

TTpcaTas.

212. Me6L(a bf] TCLS a~v]XTT6aas peiv ets ttjv ttjs 'Opi.rjpov

5 Kat /xdAa iTOLr^TLKrjs jXLayayKeias VTTobo\r]v;

a4 ira.vTOiv B : airivTwv T a9 TouTrji/ T : TavTriv t^v B

b3 Kal TOis] KaivoTs Koi Wohlrab C5 tis B : T
tivos C] ird<ras
Tas T : irdffas B d. 4 S^ T : $^ B d. 5 voiijtiktjs T : iroitjTiKus B
 *IAHB02 6ad
nPI2. Yldvv fxev ovv.

212. MedclvTaf koI Trdkiv eirt ttjv t&v ribov&v Trqyriv

iTfOv. 0)9 yap bLevorjdrjixev avTas fieiyvvvai, to, t&v akr}65iv
y.6pia TTp5>Tov, ovk i^eyevcO^ rjpxv, dkX.a bia t6 irda-av
dyaTrdv kTn(TTr\p.r\v eiy tovtov fxcOitfxev ddpoas Kal irpoarOiV lo
tS)V rjbovcav. e
nPi2. ' AXrieicrTaTa Kiyeis.
SX2. "Q.pa brj j3ovkevcr6aL vQv Kal Trepi rSy rjbov&v,
TTOTcpa Kal TavTas Trda-as d6p6as d(f)T4ov r) koX TovTUiv
TTpdiTas pi.6Tov r)}xiv oaai dXr]6iis. 5
nP,Q. rioAv rt bi.a(\>ipL Trpos y da-<f>aXciav TrptoTas Tas
oAjj^eiy d(f)eLvaL.

2X2. Mc6L(r6(t}v 877. tl be plctcl Taih-a; dp ovk cl fxev

TLves dvayKaXaL, Kaddirep (KeX, (rvfXfxeLKTiov Kal ravraj;

nPi2. Ti 8' oij; Tds ye dvayKaCas briirov6V. 10

2X2. Ei be ye KaC, KadaTrep tcls Texyo.^ irda-as d^ka^is 63

re Kal u)(f)4kLixov ^v k-nCaTaadaL bid ^Cov, Kal vvv bri ravra
keyofxev Trepl t&v ^bov&v, elirep Trda-as -^bovas r]ba6aL bia

^Cov a-vfX(f)pov re rifxlv e<rri kol d^ka^^s diraaL, Trdaas

crvyKpaTiov. 5

nPX2. Yl&s dvv brf irepl avT&v ToijT(i)v keyutfxev; Kal tt&s
TTOLStfxev;

2X2. Ovx rjfids, IIp(oTap\, Siepcoroi' XPV> '""* rfbovds

b^ avTas Kal Tas (f>povrfaLS bLaTTVvdavofxevovs to Toidvbe
dkkrjkcov TTepL. 10

nPX2. To TTolov; b
2X2. *"X2 (f>CkaL, lt rjbovas vfms XP^ TTpoaayopc^eiv

d. 7 fieduprai : fjLeOfivreT B
B T avrii Apelt d. 8 avrhs :

d9 i^fyeveO' Stallbaum : ^le-yev^flr; 63 &pa T ixra B BT :

e 4 a<p(r4ov T aa(pf<Tr(pov B : g6 rt B yt T e8 fiedeltrOwv :

T fj.te(i(r9<i) B
: 5^ T 5j) B 69 rives T rivhs B
: ^Ke? B : -.

iKeivai T (sed /a punctis notatum) a i rhs ex ai fecit T o/ rks :

B a 3 Xeyofxtv corr. Ven. 189 \fy<gfitv B T a 6 A^wjuei'

:

Ven. 189 : Xtyofiev BT ba ^(Xa* corr. Ven. 189: <^(A BT

vfjias rec. t : rifias BT
63b nAATfiNOS
etre aAAw oTiaovv ovoixaTL, ixS>v ovk av be^aicrde ot/cety jxCTa
(f)povri(Teo}i Trao-rjs r/ xcopU tov ^povuv; " otjuai fxkv Trpos

5 raura Tob' avTas avayKaioTaTOV eXvai \iyeiv.

UPQ,. To TToiov;

Sil. "Otl KaO&TTip (fXTTpoa-dcv fpprjOrj, " To fxovov Kal

ep-qfxov etAtKptz^e? etz^at rt yevos oiJre Trdw ri Swarw ovt
C ox^eAt/xoi'* irdvTdiv ye jutjv ^yovfXfOa yev&v apicrTov kv dvB'
kvos ovvotKclv rjfxlv to tov yiyvfaa-KHV raAAa re irdvTa Kal
[av Tr]v] avrqv rnx&v reAeco? eij bvvaixiv CKda-Trjv."
nPi2. " Kat xaAws ye dprfKaTe to, vvv," <f)^a-oixcv.

6 Si2. ^Op6(as. Trdktv toCvvv ixTa tovto ttjv <f>p6vrja-Lv Kal

Tov vovv dvp(t>Tr]Tov' "'Ap' rjbov&v rt TrpocrSeto-^e iv r?/
(rvyKpda-t; " (patjxev hv av tov vovv re koX Trjv (f^povrja-tv
" "
dvepoiiT&VTes. " Yloicov," (f)atV hv taroDS, rjbovQtv;

nPI2. EtKoy.
d 2X2. 'O 8e y rjpATipos koyos ixeTO. tovt eo-rty o8e.
" Ylpos rats aKr]6ia-tv eK^tvats rjbovais," (f^rjcroixev, " Sp' Irt
vpXv Tas jxcyta-Tas rjbovas crvvoiKOVs tvat /cai
7rpoo-8eto-^'

ras (r(f)obpoTdTas; " " Kat Troiis, S) ^(aKpaTcs," io"cos (f>atV

5 av, " at y kprnobi(Tp.aTd re \xvpia rjjxtv iyova-t, Tas \f^vxa.s iv

ats oIkovixv TapdTTOVcrat btd jxavias [fjbovds], Kat yiyva6ai

e re rjpids Trjv dpxrjv ovk e<So-t, Td re ytyvofxcva rjfxSiv TKva ws
rb iroXv, bt dix4X.tav \rj6rjv iixTTOtovcrat, 'KavTditaa-t bta^dei-

povcrtv; dAA' &s re rjbovds dkrjdeis Kal Ka6apds [hs] ctTres,

a-^ebov otKcias rjjxiv vofxt^i, Ka\ Trpbs TavTats ras /Lte^' vytdas
5 Ktti Tov cr()(f)poviv, KOt br) Kal avfXTrda-ris d/oer^s oTToaat
Kadditip 60v oTraSot ytyvofxevat avTrj avvaKo\ov6ovcrt TrdvTj],

b3 6v6fiari. IJ.UV B : T Sf^at(r0f corr. Vat. Sf^a<rdai

6uoixa Tifjiwv :

T (sed i erasum) : B c 3 oS t^c T rijv B secl. Wohlrab

5 lecrflat : :

C 6 ir/)0(r5er(r9e] irpocrSfT^rBai B T C 7 (pouixfv T <pafiev B C 8 irolwv :

T iroro/ B
: (^ojej' B T <paiiJ.ev vulg. : d4 T om. B 5f(ra)s :

d 6 fiavias scripsi (jLavMks r]Sovds B T fiaviKas iirtOvfjLias ci. Stallbaum

: :

e 3 a\\' S,s (secluso mox &s) Hermann 2iA.Aas B dWas T : re :

B T 'ye Hermann
: Tires T e?ire B 4 rairats B T rai^as
: :

vulg. e 6 Trdvr^p T navrl B :

 :

*IAHB02 63e

TaTJTas ixeiyvv rds 6' det /xer' a(f}po(Tvvr)s Kal r^y ^XAtjs
KaKias cTrojueVas iroAATy ttov dXoy^a ro) i^ai iJLi,yvijvaL tov
jBovkofxcvov OTL KakkLCTTriv IbovTa Kal aa-Taa-LaoTOTdTriv ixd^LV
Kal KpaaLV, iv TavTri ixadelv iriLpaa-Qai tl jrore iv t dvOpatTTio 64
Kal rw iravTl T:(f)VKv dyadov Ka\ TLva Ibiav avrfiv (IvaC

TTore fxavTVTOV." dp' ovk kp.^p6v(iis TavTa Kal exoVrtos

kavTov Tov vovv (f)r]a-oixv virip re avroC Ka\ p.vriixris koX

b6^9 6p6fjs diTOKpLvaa-OaL tcl vvv priOevra; 5

nPX2. IlayrdTrao-t ixev ovv.

212. 'AAAd jUTjy KOL T^be ye dvayKOLOV, Ka\ ovk dAAco? dv

TTore yivoLTO ovb^ dv ev.

nPil. T6 TTolov; b
2i2. *i2i ixri ix(L^o[XV dkridcLav, ovk av ttotc tovto
dXridois yiyvoLTo ovb^ av yivofxevov etr/.

nPi2. USts ydp dv;

212. OvbafxQs. dAA' ei rtyos ert 7rpoo-8et rrj crvyKpdcreL 5
TaijT-p, Ae'yere crv xat 4>tArj/3os. e/iAot /xey ydp KaOaTTepii
K^apios TLS da-cafxaTos dp^cov Kak&s iixxf/vxov atafxaTos 6 vvv
koyos dTTLpydcr6aL (f)aLVTaL.

nPf2. Kat iixo\ TOLVvv, a> 2(0Kpares, otiTtt) Aeye 8e8o'^^at.

2i2. 'Ap' ovv eTTt /xer rot? tov dyadov vvv fjbri iTpodvpois C
[Kttt] Trjs olKricr(t)s e</)eo-rdi^at [Trjs tov tolovtov] Aeyorrey
to-&)s 6p6G)s dv TLva Tp^irov (\)0^iXv;
nP12. 'E/xot yovv SoKet.
^A^. Ti brjTa V TTJ avixixL^L TiixL(aTaTov &ixa Ka\ /xdAior' 5
atrtoy etrat Sd^eiev hv rnxLV tov TTaa-LV y^yovivai TTpoa^f^Lkrj
Triv TOLavTriv bLd6aLv; tovto ydp lb6vTS /xerd tovt eiri-

crK\f/6fXda ei^' ribovfj etre roi yoi TTpoa(f)vicrTpov kol

oIkl6tPOv iv ro> Trayrt avVaTriKV.

e 7 TawTOJ :BT TauTTjj t /xlyvv' rhs Heusde : fuyvivras BT

0,1 iv ravrri /xadflv B : /xa0e7v ^ tojJt; T a3 ix^frus T : ^^^^ovtos
B b 2 nl^ofifv T : b2
(il^ufj.(v T o(i' B
Bt b 6 koJ il;/ :

T : Te Kal B b7 ipfo)' .B om. T. C 2 Koi et mox

ffwfiaros :

TTJs Tov ToiovTov sccl.Badham c 3 opOus B 6p6hv T <pa7fifv T :

(pafifv B C 7 ^iriO-Keil/d/ie^o B ^irtffKei^<i/*effo T C 8 ^Soi/j T fjSovii

: :

B t4> c^ B T c^ vulg.
: irpoa^vicrTtpov Heusde irpoff^vds t B T :
 :

64d nAAT12N0S
d nPil. 'OpdSts' TOVTo yap ds Tr]v KpCa-cv rjfuv ea-TL

(rvpL(f)op(aTaTov.

Sf2. Kai pjriv Kal avfnrAcrrfs ye /xet^fo)? ov xaAeTroy Ihelv

TTjv ahCav, bi rjv rj TravTos a^Ca yCyverai rjTLo-ovv rj to
5 TTapairav ovbevos.
nPXl. nois \4yeLs;
2X2. OvbeCs TTOv tovto av6p<aTt(tiV ayvoil.

nPii. To TToZov;

Si2. "Otl fxiTpov Kal ttjs (rvp,p.iTpov <^v(re&)S fxr) tv-

lo )(0V(ra riTL(rovv Kal OTT^acrovv (TvyKpa(TLS iraa-a e^ avdyKrjs
aTToWva-i t6. re Kf.pavvvp.eva Kai irpviTrp) avTr\v' ovSe
e yap KpacTLS akXd tls aKpaTos avp.TT(f)opr]p.4in] aXrjdois

7} TOLavri) yCyvfTaL kKda-TOTe ovtoos toXs KKTr)pi.V0LS avp.'

<f)opd.

nva. "AXrjeia-TaTa.

5 2X2. Nuy 8^ KaTaTT<pevyV rjp.lv rj tov ayaOov h-6vap.LS

eis Trjv Tov KaXov <j)vcriv' p.iTpL6Tr\s yap kol (Tvp.p.eTpCa

k&KKos hrjTTov KoX aperr] TTavTaypv a-vp.j3aCvL yCyvea-daL.

nPX2. Udw p.V ovv.

2X2. Kal p.r]v dXrjdiLdv ye (pap.v avTOLS fv ttj Kpda-L

lo p.p.Lx6aL.

nPX2. Udvv ye.

65 2X2. OvKovv ei p.r] p.La bvvdp.6a Ihict to dya6ov 6r]pvaaL,
(Tvv TpLat \a(36vTS, KdkXeL Kal cTV]ip.TpCq. kcCl dXr]6Cq,

Xy(ap.v b)s TovTo olov %v 6p66TaT &v aLTLaa-aCp.6^ hv t&v

iv TTJ (Tvp.]iC^L, Ka\ Sitt TOVTO ots dya6ov Sv TOLaijTrjv avrrjv

6 yyovvaL.
nPX2. 'Op^oVara ju,ev ovv.
2X2. "Hbr] ToCwv, S) np<oTapxf> LKavbs ripi.LV yivoLT &v
6<rTL<Tovv KpLTrjs ribovrjs re Trepi Kal (f)povr]a-oos, 6it6tPov

d3 Ka\ fiijv K(d B al : ju);' T d4 ^ T ^ B iravrhs T

: :

trivTus B d 7 irov B : irw T d 9 fitrpov B T fiirpov vulg. :

e I (rvfj.ire(f>vpixfV7) Liebhold e 5 rifuv B rinas T : eg avro7s T

ittvrois B aI $ripfv<Tai B yp, t 0n<ravpl(rai T
:
 ^IAHBOS 65b

avTolv Tov apCcTTov avyyV(TTp6v re Kal ri/ui(tfrcpoy iv b

avdpfdTiois re eo-ri koL diois.
nP12. A^Aoy pAv, ofX(t)s 8' ovv rai Aoyo) eTre^eA^ery
/SeArcoy.

2X2. Ka^ tv cKaa-Tov toCwv tQv rpi&v irpbs ttjv f)bovy]v 5

Kal Tov vovv KpivoiiJ,v Sci yap Ibdv Trore'/?^ (o)s) /xaAAoi'

(Tuyyeres iKaaTov axrrav aTTovpLovp.v.

nPX2. KaAAous Kal aXrjdcLas kol fXTpi6Tr}Tos 7re'pi

Ae'yets;

2X2. Nai. irp&Tov 6e' ye oArj^eias ka^ov, S) UpcaTapx^' 10

Kat Aa/3o'juei;os l3k\j/as cis Tpia, vovv Kal akqdiiav Ka\ c
Tibovrjv, TToXvv eTTto^cby )(jp6vov aiioKpi.vai. o-aurui iTOTepov
ffbojnj (TvyyiViCTTepov 7/ yoOs aXrjOetii,

nPX2. Tt 8e xpo^o^ ^et; ttoAi) yap ot/xai bi.a(j)4pTov.

fjbovi]jxkv yap aTrdvTdov akaCovia-TaTov, wy 6e Ao'yoy, Kai er 5
rats ^Sorats' rats Trepi Ta(ppobiaLa, at bf} jxeyL^rTaL boKov(rLV

(IvaL, Kal t6 (TTLopK(LV a-vyyv(t)}xr]v iX\r](f)e Trapa di&v, ws

Kada.TTip TTaibtDV tS)V f]bovS)V VOVV Ovb\ TOV oKCyLaTOV K^KTr]- d
]i.iv(t)V' vovs 8e ?/rot TavTov Kal dA^^eta eo-rty f] irdvToov
ofxoLOTaTov re Kat dATj0e'orraroi;.
2X2. OvKovv To /iera tovto tt^v fx^TpLOTr^Ta oicravroos

aKi\l/aL, TTOT^pov fjbovf] (f)povr](r(t)s r] <f)p6vr]aLS fjbovfjs TrAeio) 5

KKTr]TaL;

nPX2. E{!o-Ke7rro'i; ye fcat TavTr]v a-Kiyj/LV 7r/x)/3e'/3A?jKay

ot/xat yap f]bovf]s jxkv Kal TTipLyjap^Cas ovb\v tS>v ovtoov
TT<f)VKbs a]xiTp(aTcpov evpety av TLva, vov 8e Kat e7rtar7//x7/s

ipLlxTp(oTepov ov8' av iv ttotc. 10

b 3 oiv BT : ai vulg. iirf^tK6uv T : 4ire\6f7v B b6 s

addidi auctore Badham b 10 AajSoS BT:tS \aj8o(; vel vAa/3oC
Stobaeus : (tu A.a/3o0 Bucheler
c5 B ii\a(ovi(rTarov Athenaeus
Eustathius : Stobaeus Eusebius
a\a(ov(crraTov T d i ruiv
B T om. Stobaeus
: fiSovuv B T ijSofnfvwv Eusebius Athenaei E
:

d.4 wffavTws B Stobaeus us oSrus T : dg, 10 afjKrpdrfpov . . .

ifjififrp<iT(pov B T afx(rp6r(pov
: ffifi(rp6r(pov Stobaeus Eusebiiis
. . .

vulg.
PLATO, VOL. U. 9
65e nAATXiNOS
e 2X2. KaAws eiprjnas. ofxcas 8' hi. Aeye t6 Tpaov. vovs
r]p.lv KdWovs ixeTeC\r](f)e "nXdov rj to Trjs rjbovrjs y^vos, &(tt(.

eivai, KaAA.ico vovv rjbovrjs, rj TovvavTiov;

nPI2. 'AAA' ovv (\)p6vr](Tiv jxkv Kal vovv, S) SwKpares,
6 ovbus TTWTTore ovO^ viiap ovt^ ovap al(rxpbv ovTe cibev ovTt
iTTv6r](rV ovbajxfj ovbaix&s ovt yiyv6]j.ivov oi/re ovTa ovTf.

(r6ixevov.

Si2. 'Ope&s.
nPI2. *H8oz;a9 8e ye' irov, Kal TavTa crx^bbv Tas fxeyia-Tas,
lo oTav tbcafx^v rfb6}Xivov ovtlvovv, r/ Tb ycAotoy eTr' avTals r] to
66 TrdvT^av aX(Tyj.(TTOV kir^fxcvov opavTfs avToi re al(Tyyv6]XBa
KoX a(f)aviCovTS KpvirTOfxcv otl /ixdAio-ra, vvktl TzavTa to.

TOLavra 8i8wres, ws (f)&s ov biov opav avTa.

SX2. Yla.vTr] br] (^Tjo-ei?, w YlpdiiTapyi, vtt6 re ayy4k(t)V

5 TrifXTTcav Kal Trapova-L (f)pa.C(ov, ws ^801^^ KTrjfxa ovk ea-TL

TTp&Tov ov8' av biVTepov, oXka Trp&Tov fxiv irr] Trept fxcTpov

Kal To fXTpL0V Kal KaipLov KOL Tta.VTa 67r6a-a xpr] TOLavTa

vofxiCeLV, rffv "^aibLov fiprja-6aL.

nPX2. ^atVerat yovv eK t&v vvv Xeyofxivoov.

b SX2. AeTuTcpov fxr]V iTcpl to ovfXfxiTpov kol Kakbv Kal
Tb reAeov Kat iKai^oy Kat Trdi^d' oTToVa Trjs yeveas av TavTr]s
(o-tCv.

nPX2. "EotKe yovv.

5 SX2. To Toivvv TpLTov, V)S f} fxr] fxavTcCa, vovv Kal

(j)p6vr]a-LV rt^ets ovk &v /xeya rt Trjs akr]6iias irape^ekdoLs.

nPX2. "lo-co?.

e 2 yevos B T fiepos t
: 64 a\\' Stallbaum : 5p' T Stobaeus :

&p' B odv T Stobaeus o5r B : ^^ e6 iirev6ri(rfv BT : inrev6i)<r(v

Stobaeus ovSanri B T Stobaeus : ovSa/xov Eusebius e9 S4 ye
TTov BT : 5e irov Stobaeus : Se ye S^ irov Eusebius ravra BT : rai-
ras vulg. Stobaeus Eusebius a 7 xp^ roLavra B Eusebius : roiavra
Xp^ T Stobaeus a8 vel Trpdrrjv ISeav
aiSiov'] fort. ij.iav rjpTJcreai

Stobaeus r]prjiT6ai
: B etprja-6ai ipacnv T elpri(T6ai (ptxriv vulg. n6prj(T6ai
: : :

(pvartv Badham a 9 yovv B T Stobaeus odv vulg. b 2 yeveas

:

BT : yeve(Tea)s Stobaeus aS raiJTijs B T Stobaeus ravrrjs ad :

vulg.
 4>1AHB02 66b
212. 'Ap' ovv ov T^Tapra, b. Trji ^j/vxv^ avTTJs idefMw,

(TTLo-Triixas Tc Kal T^xvas ^al 8o'as opdas Aex^eto-as, raOr'

elvat Ta irpos tois Tpicrl reVapra, ftTrep tov ayadov yk ecrrt C
/biaXAoy [^] r^s tjSoj/^s orvyyer?/;
nP12. Tdx' "o.v.

Sli. rie^jMirras toCwv, &s ^Soras l^e/xer dAvTrovs opicra-

fievoi, Kadapai eTTOvofxda-avTes ttjs yjfvxrjs avrrjs, eiria-rTj/ixaiy, 5

ras 8e aicr^7;(reo-iy eTro/xems;

npo. 'lo-ws.

212. ""Ektt/ 8' ey yeyea," (f>ri(rlv 'Op^evy, " KarairatJ-

o-are Koa-fiov aoLbijs'" aTap KivbvveveL Kal 6 rjpL^Tcpos

Xoyos kv ^KTr] KaTaiteTtaviiivos ilvaL KpLcnL. to hr] fxeTa lo

raC^' f]fuv ovbcv Kolttov itA^i/ axnrcp K(f)a\r}v aTTobovvaL d

rots (iprjfUvoLS.
nP12. OvKovv XPH'
212. "I^t 8^, To TpLTov rfi o-cor^pi tov avrbv bLafiaprvpd-
fXiVOL XoyOV iTTi^ikdoifXiV. 5

nP12. noioi; 8?7;

212. ^LkrjjBos TOLyadov iTCBcTo rffiiv rfbovrjV ivaL TTacrav

KOL TTaVTfkrj.
nP12. To TpCTov, w 2ci)Kpares, ws loiKas, cAeyes dfyrdtis
Tov e^ dpxrjs eiraraAa/Seiy ^ety Ac)yoy. lo

212. Nat, ro 8e ye ftera rovro dKovoifiev. eyo) ya/a 8^ e

Kari8a)i; ^Trep wvbr] 8teA7]Avda, Kai 8uo-xe/3dyay roi' <I>tA?7/3ou

Ao'yov ov fwvov dAAd Kai dAAcoy iroAAdKts pLvpCcov, (LTTov uts

rfbovrjs ye vovs eiTj fiaKpta jBfXrLov re Kat afi,civov r&J rwr
dvdp(aTTO)v l3C(o. 5
nP12. 'Hi; raura.

b8 5p' oSc rfrapra T

oii 3/>' ou rfTopra : B : oii8' Jackson
5p' oSv
avrrjs idtfaev B
Stobaeus (Qffifv ouTijy T
: rtrapra T Sto-
C i
baeus :rirrapa B ^e T om. B : c 2 ^ secl. Stallbaum
C5 iirt(Tr4]ixais corr. Ven. 189: iirt(rr-{]fias BT c6 rits Bad-
ham : rars BT .Stobaeus (-Koixfvas T Stobaeus : fir6/xtvat B
e2 vC' 5^> B : vvv T
Eusebius : vuj^i vulg. SicA^Auflo T : Svo-xcpc^i^as
SttKilKvOa B e 4 efi; B ; JfTj ftj' T fxoKpif T : fxoKphs B
66e nAATilNOS
2X2. 'TTTOTTTevtiiV 8e ye /cai aXA.a eiyat iroXAa elTTOv ws
1 <f)aVLr] TL TOVTOLV afXcf^oHv ^ikTLOV, VTTip TU)V beVTp(LOL>V
v& TTpos rjbovrfv <rvvhLapLayoLinf]V, rjhovi] h\ Ka\ bevTepcCdiv
10 crTp^(r0LT0.

67 nPIi. Eiire? yap ovv.

212. Kai pLTa TavTd ye TT&VTUiV LKav(aTaTa ToiTOLV ovhi-
Tepov LKavbv k^&vr).
nPf2. 'AX.r]d(rTaTa.

5 2i2. OvKovv TTavT&TTacTLV v rovTO) rw koyt^ koll roOy

o/wqKKaKTo kcu rjbovr] firj tol Tayadov y avTo /xtj8' Tpov
aiiTolv LvaL, (rTpofXVOLV avTapKLas Kal Trjs tov LKavov kol

Tckcov bvv(iixo)s;

UVa. "OpOoTaTa.
10 212. ^avivTO^i b4 y aXAou rpLTOV KpLTT0V0S tovtolv
KaTpov, fxvpL(a y av vov9 rjbovrjs olkl6tPov Kal TTpocr^vi-
(TTpOV TT(^aVTaL VVV Tr) TOV VLKoiVTOS ibcCl.
nPX2. ITcSs yap ov;
212. OvKovv TTip.-iTTOv KaTCL Tr]V Kpi^TLV, rjv vvv 6 Xoyos
15 aTT(t>rivaTO, yiyvoLT av rj Trjs ^bovrjs bvvafXLS.

nPI2. "EoiKev.
b 212. Up&Tov 8e ye ov8' hv ol iTdiVTcs /3oes re Kal Xttttol

Kal TakXa (rvfxiTavTa Orfpia (paxrL rw to yaipLV bL(aKLV'

ots TTKrrevoyres, McnTcp fxdvTLS opvLCTLV, ol TroAAoi KpivovcrL

TCLS rfbovas eis to Cv^ ^M^^ ^^ KpaTiaras ^TvaL, Kal tcws

5 6r]pi(iiv e/3ft)ras oioyrai Kvpiovs eirai pAprvpas pJdXXov rf
TOVS T&V V fXOV(rr] (j)LX0(r6cj)(0 fXfXaVTVfXVO)V Kd(TTOT

XoyoiV.
nPX2. ' AXrjdca-TaTa, S) 2c5Kpare?, elprjcrOai ctol vvv rjbrj

<f)afl.V dTTaVTS.

e8 Tt B : rh T roiroiv T tovtwv B : a 2 iKavirara T ;

iKavdTarov B Toiroiv T Toirciiv B

: ovStTfpov T oi) SfVTtpov B
:

as f<(>(ivrj BT: avt<pa.vT] Eusebius a? ffTepo^xfvoiv corr. Ven.

189 (TTepofxevwv B T
: a 10 tovtoiv T tovtwv B a ii 7' :

oS T aS B : b I ov5' B T Porphyrius ovk vulg. Eusebius :

b 5 fpwTas t 4p&vTas B T :b 7 Xo^o' T AtJ-yoi/ B :

 c|>IAHBOS 67b

212. OvKovv Kot a(f)UT ixe; lo

UVil. 2/xiKpo2' eri 70 AoiTToV, S) 2w/c/)ary ov yap

brjTTov (Tv y dTre/oeis irpoTipos rifx&v, VTTop.vri(r(o 8e (re to.

kcLTToixeva.

b II T^ \oiv6v B: AotirJi/ T b 12 owfpm T: airooc?; B:

airofpfis corr. d diropf?y vulg.
:
k
 :

v^^

2TMn05I0N
St. III
AnOAAOAi2P02 ETAIP02 p. 172

AnOA. AoK(o 1J.0L Trept &v Trvv6avi(r6i ovk d/xeAer)jros a

(Ivai. Kal yap kTvyyjxvov Trp^rjv eis acTTV oXko^^v av(,a>v 4>aATj-
podfV T&v ovv yvo)pifi(ov rts o-nicr^^v KaTihutv p. TToppcodev

iKa\<r, Kal Tra(C<^v afxa Trj Kkrjcrd, '"i2 ^aXr)p(vs," (f>ri,

" ovTos 'ATToWoboiipos, ov TTepLfiivds ;" Kdyo) e7ri(rras Trept- 5

ep.Lva. Kal 0?, " 'A7roAAo'8a)/)e," l^r;, " Kal fxi]v Kal ivayyos
crc e^riTOVv ^ovk6[X(vos bLaTrv6<r6aL Trjv 'Ayd6(i}Vos (rvvovcriav
KOA. ScoKpdrous kou, 'AAKi/3td8ov kol tS>v dAAcoy t5)v t6t iv b
T& <rvvbLirv<a TrapayiVopLiVOiiV, iKpX t&v eptortKwy Adytoy
Tivcs rj(rav' dAAos ya,p tls \iol 8trjyetro aKTjKocos ^olvlkos
Tov 4>tAi7r7ri>, l</)rj 5e Kai o-e eiSeVai. dAAd yap ovh\v eix^e

(ra(f>^s Ae'yeiy. (ru oSy jnot 8t7jyrj(rai' StKaidraros ydp ei 5

rovs Tov (Taipov Adyous d^rayye^AAet^. Trp^Tepov bi fioL,"
8' 6s, " "
rj etTre', crv avTos irapiyivov Tjj (rvvova-Lq TavTjf 7/ ov;
Kdyo) fLTTOv OTL " nayrd^ra^riy eoiKe o-oi ovSer 8trjyet(r^at
(rac\)ks 6 bLr\yovpLiVos, et yecao-ri r^y^ rqv a~vvovcrLav ycyovfvai c
TavTTjv rjv fp(DTqs, ua-Te Kal e)u,e Trapayivia-^aL." " 'Ey(o ye

a I oiiK B T W
vvy ovk Methodius al.
: a4 5 BT 6 al. W :

a 5 'AiroA\({5wpos secl. Badham wfpi^/y<ijTW: ircpi/xei/cts B wepjj :

/uevtrj al. b 2 (TvviflifV(p B Methodius iruj/Secir'*' T (rvvhiircv^

W
: :

W c2 ffol fVe BT ; Kanf Athenaeus iyw y^ Sij, (<pri scripsi

e^co^* 5i7 BT W : tyi yap (l<prt[v) Athenaeus : ty(tiy', <i(pr\ Badham
lyac nAATi2N02
bi]," (j)r]. " Il6dv, ^v 8' yw, o) TXavKdov; ovk ola-B^ on
Trokkiav h(av 'Ayddoiv evddbe ovk Tnb(brifjir]KV, d(\>^ ov 8'

6 eyo) ScD/cparet (rvvbi.aTpi^(x) kclL cTri/jieAes TrciroCrj^aL kKd(rTr]s

rijxipas ilbivai otl h.v k^yrj ^ irpdTTi], ovb^iru) TpCa iTr] i(TTiv;

173 "^po Tov be 'n^pLTpiyjtiv OTrr] tvxoljxl Kal ol6]ji,Vos tI ttol^Iv

d6kL(OTpOS 7] OTOVOVV, OVX ^TTOV 7] (TV VVVL, Ol6iXVOS bflv
ndvTa ]xdXkov TTpdrTiLV 17 (l)L\o(ro(j)lv." Kal os, " Mr]
aKS)TTT," 6(f)r],
" aAA' ctTre ]10l Trore kyiv^To f] (rvvov(rLa

6 avTr]." Kdyo) etTTOi; ort "HaLbav ovtcov r]]x5)v ctl, 6t ti] TTp^oTr]
Tpay(pbL(i kvLKTjcrev ^Aydda^v, r^ {xrTcpaCcL r] ^ tcl kiTLvCKLa

9vV avrds re /cat ot yop^vTaC." " Yidw," ((f)r],

" apa TrdAai,
"
ws ^OLKiv. dXXd tCs a-OL Sirjyeiro; rj avros ^()KpdTr]s;
b " Ov /xd Tov ACa," ^v 8' eyw, " dXA.' 5o-7rep 4>oti;tKt. 'Apto^rd-

87J/XOS ^v TLS, Kvba9r]vaLVS, (r]XLKp6s, dvvTT6br]Tos deC' iTap-

(yy6vL 8' cv Trj crvvov^rCci, ^(aKpdTovs epaarr^s (av kv tols

]xakL(rTa tS)V t6t, d>s e/xot 8oKet. ov fxdvTOL dkkd Kal

5 'SiiOKpdTr] ye eyta 7/8rj dvrjp6]xr]v S)V kKtCvov r^Kovcra, KaC ]xol

b)p,ok6yL Ka9d7Tp (KLV0S 8i?7yetro." " Tt ovv," (f)r],

" ov
bLr]yrj(r(i) ]xol; Trdyrws 8 r] obos rj ets d(rTV e7Ttrrj8eta

TTopevop.ivoLS KoX kiycLV Kal aKoveLv."

OvTO) br] i6vTs d]xa tovs koyovs Trepi avrwy iiTOLOVfxcBa,
C coo-re, oTTCp dpy6]Xivos Lttov, ovk d/xeAer^rcos exw. ct ovv
8et Kat vfxlv bLr]yr]a-a(r9aL, raSra XPV TTOteti'. Kat yap eyo^yc
Kal dAAcos, oTav ]xiv TLvas Trept (f)Lkocro(f)Cas kdyovs r] avros
TTOL&fxaL ^ dkk(i)v aKOVco, xcapls tov ot(r6aL w^eAeicr^ai
5 vTTp(f>v&s 0)? xaCp(t)' oTav 8e dAAous rtms, dAAcos re Kat
rovs v]XTpovs Tovs tS)V 7Tkov(rCo)v KOL xp^J/^ctrto-rtKcSr, avr^s
re dx9o]xaL v]xds re rous TaCpovs eAeci), drt oieo-^e ri ttol^lv

d ovbev 7TOLovvTS. Kal lo-cos au v/Aeis e/AC f]yL(rd KaKobaCfxova

c 4 ivedSe om. Athenaeus a 2 ^ Tb : ^j/ pr. B ^ t : W wvl B :

j/CvTW as TrpciJTj; om. Athenaeus a6 ^^TW: ^B: ^ Schanz

a 8 t/s B Ti T W '
b I &\A.o(r7rep BT W b2 irapa^eYc^yet BT W
W W
:

b4 /cal B : om. T b6 Sir^yfia-o) BT : Siriyfiffri : Siriy^ <tv vulg.

b7 ^ exs BT : fls W dI ejue ^yerff^o BT : rjyfTaBe f/ue W


STMnOSION i73d

(IvaL, Koi oLO^at u/xas akrjdrj oUa-6aL' eyo) ixivTOL v/xas ovk

oLoixaL dAA' ev olba.

ETAI. 'Ael ofxoLos i, &> 'ATroAAoScope* det ydp o-auroV
re KaKr]yopLS Kal tovs akkovs, Kal boKels fJ.0L drex^i^ws 5
Trdi^ras adkCovs fjyda-OaL TrK.i}v ^KaKpaTovs, aito (ravTov

ap^dfiivos. Kal oiToOev Trore Tavrr^v rrjv iTvutwnCav eAa/Ses

To ixakaKos KakeXcrdaL, ovk olba iycayv iv fxkv yap tols
koyoLS dei tolovtos ei, (ravT^ re /cai rois akkoLS dypLaCvLS

TTkrjV '2(t)KpdT0VS. ^

AnOA. '12 (f)LkTaT(, Kal bfjkov ye 8?) ort ovto) bLa- e

voovp.vos Kal TTepl ifxavTov Kal iTepl vfxSiV fxaCvofxaL /cat

'
7TapaTTaC(o;

ETAI. OVK d^LOV TTCpl TOVTODV, ^ AlTokkoboDpC, VVV fpCC^LV

dAA.' OTrep eSed/ne^d (tov, fxf\ dAAco? Troi^crT/s, dAAd 8tr/y7j(rat 5
rtVes 770-ai' ot Ao'yoi.

AnOA. 'H(ray toCvvv ck^lvol rototSe rtye'? pMkkov 8'

e^ dpxfjs vfXLV b)s K(ivos Strjyetro xat eyo) TTiLpd^rofxaL 174

8tTj yr/aao-^ai.

"E^Tj ydp ot ^(OKpdTrj (vtvx^^^Cv kckovfxivov re xat rds

/SAauras iy7ro8e8e/xe'i;oi^, d eKetros oAtyd/cts iiToCfL' Kal pi(rdaL
avTov oTTOL LOL ovTO) Kakos yyVr]pL(vos. 5
Kai Tov (LTTiLV OTL 'EttI beliTVov ds ^Aydd(i)vos. X^^^ V^P
avroi' bL(j)vyov tols (ttlvlkCols, (pojSrjdils tov oxkov ^fxo-

k6yrf(ra 8' ets Trffxepov TTapiar^crdaL. raCra bff e/caAAa)7ri-

(rdfxrfv, tva Kakos iTapd Kakbv tco. dAAd (tv, 77

8' os, ttSis

cxets TTpbs To 0kLV dv UvaL aKkrjTos eTrt Setwoi^; b

Kdyw, (f)rf, etTror ^rt Ovrcoy oTrcos dv (tv /ceAeur/s.

"ETrou TOLVvv, !</))/, tz^a xat T^y rrapoLfxCav bLa(f)6Cp()fXV

fXTa^ak6vTS, d)S d/)a Kat 'Ayd^coi;' eTrt ^airas tacrtr

d8 noKaKhs B : fiai^Khs T W yip] 76 Badham a5 2irot BT

W
:

oirrt b I iOihfiv h.v secl. Cobet Stephanus avttvai

&j/ tVj/ot
BTW W
:

b4 ixfra$a\6vTfs T : /xiTaPdWovrts B Atlienaeus

'Ayddafv Lachmann : ayaBuv BTW
'"
PLATO, VOL. u.
I74b nAATXlNOS
5 avTOfxaTOL ayadoi. "Ofxrjpos /utev yap KLvbvveva ov fxovov
biacpOcipaL akXa Kal v^pia-ai eis TavTr\v ttjv iTapoLiJ.Cav'

TTOLrjaas yap tov \AyapLtxvova bia(f)ep6vT0)s ayadov avhpa

C To. TioKip.LKa, Tov hi M.vikiutv " fxakdaKov aixixrjTriv"

6v<TLav TTOLOVixivov KOL kcTTL&VTOs Tov ^Ayajxiixvovos aKXriTov
kitoLria-iv kXOovTa tov Mei^eAecoy kin Tr^v Ooivriv, Xiipcn ovTa
eiri TTiv Tov aixiivovos.
5 TavT aKova-as etTreiy e0rj "la-ois ixivTOL KLvhvvivaoi Ka\
kyui ov\ 0)5 av Aeyeis, & SwKparej, aXXa fca^' "O^xripov
^avkos (ov eTTi <TO(f)Ov avbpbs UvaL Ooivriv aKXrjTos. opa ovv
aycav ju,e t[ aTTokoyrjcrr}, ws eycb ixkv ovx 6ixo\oyria-<i> aKXriTos
d rJKiLV, dXA' VTTO aOV KK\rilXVOS.
" Svy re bv," i(f)ri,
" ipxpixiv(a Trpb obov
" ^ovXivaoixtOa

OTL epovixev. dAA' tco/xey.

ToLavT arra (r^ds e0rj StaAex^eWas leVat. Tbv ovv

5 2ft)Kpdr?j eauro) tto)? TtpoaiyovTa Tbv vovv Kard r^y 68oj;
nopeviadaL vTToXeLTioixevov, Kal TT^pLixivovTOS ov KeXevcLV
TTpdiivaL ets Tb TTpoadcv. eTretS^ 8e yev^aOaL (ttI Trj olKiq.

e r?) ^AydOoivos, dve(oyixevriv KaTakaix^dveLV ttjv Ovpav, Kai tl

e(j)ri avTodL yeKolov tTaOeLV. oX ixkv yap cvOvs TratSd rti^a

rcSr evboOev aTTavTi^aavTa aycLV ov KaTKLVTo ol dAAot, Kat

KaTakapL^dveLV rjbri {xeWovTas beLTTvelv evOvs 8' ovv o)S

5 ibelv Tbv ^Ayddcava, '12, (f)dvaL, 'ApLaTobrnxe, ei? KoXbv iJKeis

o7TO)s avvbeLTTvriaris' et 8' dAAov rtros evKa ^kdes, eis avOLS

dva^akov, m Kal x^f? Cl'''^^ ^^ ^^^ KoXeaaLixL, ovx oXos t

7/ ibeiv. dAAd ScoKpdrtj rnuv tt&s ovk dyeis;

Kal iy(a, e(f)ri, ixTaaTp(f)6ixevos ovbaixov 6p& 'SiOOKpaTri

e 7, 8 '6pa Ti Badham (vide Ficinus) : &pa rt B : &pa . . . tj T :

W
. . .

W
. . .

2p' . . . rf d2 irph dSov BT : irph 6 rov Homerus K 224

d3 oWct T a\\ ew/xtv
iwfiev W
d 6 iropevSfievov viroKiiirtaQai
: B
Rohde d 7 8^] 8i I Cobet 8' I Baiter e 2 of Photius b oi : :

BT: rhv W
63 twv evSoBtv Porson tw/ fvSov Photius tvSoOtv : :

BTW esSTWr^B e6 o^vvStnrvfia^ps BTW avvStiwvf;- :

a-fts Laur. xiv. 85 e 7 t' ^ T Tf B eg t^pri B TW W : : ?</>t;i'

ovSafiov B oi>Sa,u^ T : W
 )

STMnOSION 174 6

(TTOixevov (ITTOV ovv oTL Koi avToi fjLera '2oi)Kp6.TOVS rJKOijxi, lo

icAjj^ets vir' ckcivov 8eup' im belirvov.

KaK&s y , e0rj, noiSiV <rv' aWa irov i<mv dvTos;

"Oina-div kfxov &fyn 6icrT;ei* oXXa 6avfxa^(t> Ka\ avTos ttov 175
hf eiTj.

Ov <TKi\lrrj, e<pr], -nal, (fxxvai tov *Ayd9(ava, Koi eicrd^eis _

StoKpaTTj; crv 8', ^ 8' os, ^ApKTTobrjfxe, irap' ^Epv^Cfxa)(Ov

KaTaKkLVov. 5

Kat I /xei; Ic^tj dTroi/ifety tov Tralba Xva KaTaKiOLTO' akkov

8e' TLva T<av "naibdiv rJKeLV ayyiXkovTa otl " SfOKpdrrjs ovroy
avayuipricras (v ro) rwy yetroVcov Trpodvp(o ^crTrjKfV, Kaixov
KoXovifTos ovK e^eXei eto-ieWt."
"Atottov y , e</)7j, Ae'yets* ovkovv KaAets avror Kai [xr] 10

d<^T/orets;

Kat os i<f>r] etTrety Mrj8a/ie5s, dXA' eare avrdr. idos yap b

rt roSr' exet* Ivlot^ d-TTOo-rds OTTOt &y rvx?? ta-Tr]K(.v. r\^ti

8' avTLKa, ws eyo) oi/xat. /ir/ ovy Kti/etre, dAA' edre.

'AAA' ovrco XP^ iroteti^, et <roL SoKei, i(f)r] (fxxvaL tov
^Aya6<iiva. dAA' ^/xas, S 7rat8es, rovs dAAous effrtare. 5

7rdin-(os TTapaTLd^Ti otl hv j3ov\.r]<r6, eiretSdy rts v/xtr /xt/

((f)<m]Kr] 6 eyd) ov8e7r<rt7rore (iToCr^^Ta vvv ovv, vo]xC^ovtS

Kal e/i.e v</)' v/xwy KeKAr/o-^at e7rt ^etTri^oy Kat TOvo-8e rovs
dAAovs, 6paTTVTc, Xv v/xds eTratyw/xey. C
Merd raCra l<^rj <T(f>as ]XV ^eiTri^ety, tov 8e 2<0Kpd7Tj
ovK l<TLvai. tov ovv ^ Ayddoova TroAAdKts KeAevetv p.Ta-
TT]X\\fa(TdaL TOV 2<t)Kp(XTr], k 8e OVK av. r]KLV ovv avTov ov

e 10 rJKojyui B'-* T W : tJko ^ij B e 12 7' T W om. B a6 I ix\v

BT W
:

Bast ( Stephanus) :
*V <()7j B : e^w/v T W a8 Kajuou
W : /(al o5 BT a lo KaXds BT : KaA.o?; W in marg. T : /ccUei
rec. b aiiTb'] oSflis Herwerden a 11 o</)Vjo-eiy B W : kip-(\crys T
b2 Tovr B TovTo T toioCto' W b 4 T W om. B
W
: : :
^(fyr)

b6 irdvTfs (sed co s. v. ^tciSi^v tis . . . yui) BT : iirti ris . . . ou

/lij Schmidt
L. infl ov S-f) : tis . . . fi^ Hug : ^*l S-fi tis . . . oi /lij

Schanz fort. iirfiSav avTbs

: fih ^l i^f(TTi]Kri T aipfar^fiKTi
W
. :

: i<pTT-()Kii B e 4 I 5 B : e 8e W : 5i f (t^v 5 fuisse

videtur) outJ' 5 vulg. t 5 ci. Bekker ovk ^Sj' B W ouko' T
W
: : :

oiv om.

^
:

I75C nAATilNOS
5 TroXiiv xpovov ws eico^et hiaTpi\\ravTa, aXKa p.6ikL(TTa (T<f>as

IX(Tovv bdTrvovvTas. Tov ovv ^Ayddoova TvyxAveiv yap

i(T\aTov KaTaKifXVov fxovov Aevp', e0?j (f^dvai, SwKpare?,
Trap' e/xe Kard/cetcro, tva Kal tov (ro(f)OV aTTToixiVos crofv

d a.TTo\ava-(t}, 6 (tol T:pocri(TTi] kv toXs Trpodvpois. hriXov yap

oTi T]vpS avTO Kal e^eis* ov yap hv Trpoaireo-Tjjs.

Kat Tov ^cdKpdTr] Kadi^(T6ai KaX direlv otl Ev hv ^xol,

(f)dvaL, S) ^Aydd(i)V, ei roiouroy ei?j r) (ro(f)La u)(tt ck tov Trkrjpe-

5 (TTepov eis t6 Kcv<aTepov pelv r^pL&v, kav aiTTdopLeda dkkrjkcov,

co(nTep To iv rai? kvKl^lv vbcop to 8ia tov kpiov piov ex r^s

TrXripe^TTepas eis ttjv KcvcdTipav. ei ydp ovtcos Ix^' '^^'- V

e a-o(f)La, TToWov TLfx&fxai Tr)v TTapa (toI KaraKAto"ty ot/xat ydp
jue Trapa a-ov ttoAAtjs Kai KaXijs cro(f)Las 7Tkr]po)6ricrea-0aL. r] [xcv

yap e/xr) (f)av\r] tls hv etr], rj Kal d]X(f)L(r^r]Tr]a-L]xos u>a-TTfp ovap

ova-a, rj 8e (rr] XajXTTpd re Kai TroXX^j; fiTLbo(TLV ^xova-a, rj yc
5 TTapa a-ov veov ovtos otrro) crc^obpa e^\apL^V Kal fK(f)avr]s

iyivcTO TTp^ar^v iv ptdpTva-L tZv 'EXXrjvo^v iTXiov rj TpLo-fxvpCoLS.

'Tj3pLaTr]s et, ec^rj, S) SwKparey, 6 'Ayd6o)v. Kal TavTa

fxev Kal oXCyov vaTepov bLabLKacropic^a eyio re Kat (tv TTcpl

Trjs (ro(\)Las, bLKaa-Tfj yjxafxevoL T<a Atorwo)" vvv be irpos to

lO bCLTTVOV TTp&Ta TpilTOV.

176 Mera raCra, l0?j, KaraKAti^ez^ros tov ^(aKpdTovs Kal

beLTTV^cravTOs Kal tS)v akkoiv, aTTOvbds re (r(pds TTOLr^^raa-^aL,
Kal qaavTas tov 6eov kcll rSXAa to. vo]XL^6]xeva, TpTTa-6aL

TTpbs Tov TTOTov Tov ovv Ylav(ravLav (f)r] koyov tolovtov

5 TLVos KaTdpxeLV. Eter, dvbpes, <f)dvaL, Tiva TpoTTOv pqa-Ta
TTLop.eda; ey&) jxev ovv Xeyw vixlv otl rai oyrt TTdvv xc^frws
ex^) v7t6 tovx^^y TTOTOv KOL beofxaL dvayfrvxv^ tlvos ot/xai
8e Kai vpL&v tovs TTokkovs' TTaprj(rT yap x^^^ aKOTreicr^e
b OVV TLVL TpOTT^a aV b)S pqaTa ITLVOLfXeV.

C 6 rvyxdvfiv BT : twx*'"*' W C8 airTo/j.evos ffov T W : om. B

dI jrpocTfffrrt TW: Trp6(T(a-rw B d.5 ti> BTW: rhv corr. Coisl.
Ktvwrepov re vera BT W e i rifiwfiai T W rifxwft.fv B e3 ^
W
:

KolTW: KalB 64 ^ 7 T tf 76 B e8 fiiv Kal BT

W
:

fxev a5 {laiTra BT W : -q^iara yp. t a8 traprjtrTf BT W :

irapTJrt in marg. rec. b

 STMnOSION I76b

Tbv ovv * Api(rT0(l>6.vr] flTrelv, Tovto /LieVroi ev \cyet?, S)

IlavcTavLa, to iravTl TpoTTto TrapacrKevacracrOai paa-TOiirqv Ttva

Trjs TTOcTfcos' Kal yap aiiTos (ipn. t&v X^^^ fSe^aTrTKrfxevcov.
'AKOV(ravTa ovv avT&v i<f)r] ^'Eipv^ip.aypv tov ^AKOvixevov 5

'H KoXQs, <f)dvai., \4ycTc. Kal ^tl kvos hiofxaL v^uiv aKovaraL
TTbJS exei TTpos To eppwcrOaL ttlvclv, ^Ayd6(*)v(ps).
Ovbaficis, <f)dvaL, ovf avTos eppto/xai.

"F.pp.aLov av Lrj rjfXLV, ^ 8' os, a>? 4olkV, ffxol re koll C

^ ApLcrTohr]p.io KOL (PaCbp^a Kal Tolcrbe, ei vfxels ol bvvaTcaTaTOL

TTivdv vvv aiTfLprjKaT' rjfxels [xkv yap dei abvvaTOL. ^(o-

Kpdrr] 8' e^aipw Xoyov LKavbs yap Ka\ djxcf^oTfpa, wot'
k^apKicriL avT(o oTTOTcp' hv ttol&ix(V. e7rei8^ ovv fxoL So/cei 5

ouSeis T&v 7Tap6vT(i)v irpodvfKos ^X^"' iTpbs Tb ttoXvv iTLveiv

oTvov, L(r(os av eyob Trept tov fX(6v(rKcr6aL oXov (crTL Td\r]6r]

Xcyoov rJTTov dv etrjy dribrjs. e/uoi ydp br] tovto ye ot/mat

KaTdbr]\.ov ytyovfvaL e/c r^s laTpLKrjs, otl \akeTTbv tols d

dvdpcoTTOLS fj ix6r] ((TTLV Kal ovT avrbs K(ov eimt iroppoo
6kr](raLp.L dv ttl^Xv ovt dkX.(o crvfx^ovkV(raLfXL, dW(os re
Kai KpatTraXwi^ra ert ex ttjs TTpoTepaCas.
'AAAa fxr]v, ^(f)r] (f)dvaL vTToXa^ovTa ^aibpov tov MvppLvov- 5
crtoy, ^y(oy (roL eicoda 'rTL6(r6aL dkXios re KOt aTT dv TTp\

laTpLKrjs kiyrjs' vvv 8', dv eu /SovAevcoi^rat, Kai ot AotTTot.

TavTa br] dKOV(ravTas (rvyyjopelv TrdvTas fxr] 8ta fX6r]S e

TTotT/o-ao-^at Tr]v v t<o TTapovTL (rvvovcTLav, dXA.' ovt(o iTLVOVTas

TTpbs r]bovr]v.

'E7ret8^ tolvvv, <f)dvai Tbv ^Epv^Lftaxov, tovto fxkv 8e'-

8oKrat, TTLVLV ocrov dv KacrTos ^ovXrfTaL, TTdvayKS 8e fxr^bev 5

b3 irapaffKtvitraxrOai TW : irapaaKtva^tffOaL B b 5 avTwv T W :

avrhv
ivrhv B ^Epv^i/xaxov
'Epii|//ioxov T Evpv^ifiaxov
'Evpv^ifiaxov : W
"rhv 'Epv^tfiaxov
'Epv^ti B aKov-
W b 'Ayadwvos Vahlen ayddwv
:

xfvov
luLfvov BT 7aydduv B T W : C4 i^atpS)
Heindorf: ^fa/pwBTW C8 otjS^sTW: B a7;\r/s d^ Kpaiira-
Kwvra T W B d5
KpatiraKovvra TW (paTSpov : ipaiSpuv B ftvp-
TW d Aryps B W
:

ptvovatov B /j.vptvova-iov 7 :\tyfti T 5' Si/

W
;

'5 T : 5' oS fd B /SovAevwvrai corr. Coisl. : /SovAwcrai

BTW
i76e nAATONOS
(Ivai, To fMera tovto eia-rjyovixai Tr]V [xev apTi fXcrikOovcrav
avkrjrpCba \aLpHV iav, avXovcrav kavT^ rj av ^ovkrjTai. rais
yvvai,^l TaXs ^vbov, rjpMs 8e 8ia Aoycov dAATjAois (rvvdvai
To rqfJLepov Kal bC oXcav \6yoiV, ei jBovXea-de, ediXu) v\uv

lo ei(Tr]yrj(ra(r6ai.

177 ^avai 8r) ii&VTa^ koX j3ov\cr6aL Kal KekevcLV avTov

f.i(rrfyeL(r6aL. eiireLV ovv tov ^^pv^Lp.ayov otl 'H \xiv fxoL

ap)(rf Tov \6yov ecrri KaTo. Tr]v KvpLmbov MeXavLTnrqv ov

yap ijxbs 6 jxvdos, aWa ^aCbpov rovbe, ov fxdXXco Aeyetr.

5 <i>albpos yap eKacTTOTe TTp6s jU ayavaKTwv Aeyei Ov bHv6v,

(firjcrLV, a> 'Epu^t/xaxe, aAAois piiv tlctl deiav v[xvovs Kai
TTaLdivas LvaL VTTO T&v TTOLr]T&v TTfTTOLrjixivovs, ro) 8e "Epcon,

rrjAiKOvro) ovtl Kal toctovt^o 6(5>, ju.?j8e (va TrwTrore TO(rovT(t)v

b yyov6T(jov iTOLrfTiav TreTrotrjKerai fxrjbev iyK(opi,Lov; ei 8e ^ovXcl

av (rK\l/a(r6aL tovs xP^Jo^tovs (ro(f)L(rTds, 'HpaKXfovs ixkv Kal

aAAcoy kiTaivovs KaTokoyabrjv avyypdcfxLV, wcrTrep 6 ^(Xtlo-tos

Ylp6bLK0s KciL TovTo [Xv r]TT0v Kal davp,a(rT6v, dAA' ^yoiye
5 rjbr] TLvl kveTvypv l3LJ3\L(a dvbpbs (rocfiov, kv w kvrj^rav aAes
CTTaLVov 6av]xda-Lov XpvTs irpbs bxpeXCav, Kal dk\a TOLaxrra

C a-vxva iboLs &v iyKiK(apLLaa-fx4va Tb ovv tolovt(ov fxkv Trepi

TroAA^y onTovbr]V iTOLriqraa-^aL, "'Epcora 8e fxrjbeva tt(o dv6p(aTT(ov

TeTo\ixr]KevaL ds TavTr]vl Tr]v rifxepav d^icos vfxinjaaL' dAA'
ovTcos riixi\r]TaL Toa-ovros Oe^s. TavTa brj ixol boKcl ev
5 \eyLV fi^albpos. eyw ovv TTL6vp.Q> dp,a ixev rovro) ^pavov
(icrcveyKeXv kol \apL(raa-6aL, dp,a 8' ev tco iTap6vTL iTpeTTOv
IXOL SoKet eifai rjixLV tols iTapovcrL Koaixf](raL rbv 6e6v. ei ovv
d a-vvboKei kol vfxlv, yevoLT hv rfixlv iv \6yoLS iKavi] 8iarpt^7j*
8oKet ydp ixoL \privaL eKaarrov r]ixS>v \6yov eiiTelv eiTaLVOv
EpooTos eTri 6e^td ws dv bvvr]TaL KdWLo-Tov, dpyeLV be

6 7 avKr^Tpiba T av\irpiSa B W rjav B i^ ^o' W T

4iiv
W
: : :

a I Kol prius secl. Hermann a 7 iraiavas : traiovas BT :

iraiavas ht bi /iT/Sei'] /trjSe Valckenaer bs avSphs aro^pov

TW : om. B b6 axpeXiay T w<pf\eiay B W 03 atiws T W
W
: :

d|i B d 3 Ka\\i(TTov B T : KdWia-ra



STMnOSION I77d

^i^aibpov TTp&Tov, e7ret8^ koI Trp&iros KaraKtiTai koX 4(ttiv

aixa TTaTi]p tov \6yov. 5
Ovb(LS arot,, Si 'Epu^i/xaxf) (f)dvaL tov ^(DKpaTr], ivavTia
i/rr/^ieirai. ovre yap av ttov eyu) aTTO(f)rj(raLixi, os ovbev
(f>r]ijn aWo (TTicrTaa-dai x] Ta epcoTiKd, ovt ttov 'Ay<x6(ov Kal

Tlav(ravCas, ovbe ]ir]v 'ApL<TT0(\)dvr]s, w Trept ^lovvctov koX e

W(j)pobLTr]v TTd(Ta 7] bLaTpL^r], ovb\ aAXos ovbils TovT(jiv\ S>v

eyo) 6pu>. KaLTOL ovk e^ Xa-ov yCyveTai rjixLV rois vorarots

KaraKet/xeVots* dAA' idv oi TTpoa-Oev iKav&s Kal Kakm
eiTT(t)a-LV, e^apKfo-^L r]pXv. dXkd Tvyr] dyadrj KaTap\iTO) 5

^albpos Ka\ yK(t)]XLa^iT(3i) tov "Epwra.

Taura br] Ka\ oX aAAot Trdyres dpa awicf^acrdv re Kat
eKe\(vov a7Tp 6 ^(t)KpdTr]s. iTdvTcov fxkv ovv h iKaaros 178
eiTrey, ovt TTavv 6 'ApLcrT6br]]xos k]xi]xvr]To ovt av kyo)
h. iKLVos eAeye Trdyra* a 8e jadAto-ra Kai &v eSo^e'

]xoL d^L0fxvr]]x6vVT0V, TovToov vyXv ip& KdcrT0V TOV

k6yov. 5

T\p5)Tov ]xkv ydp, cuo-Trep Aeyo), l</)rj ^albpov dp^d]XVOV

ivOivbe TToOev XeyeLV, otl ]xeyas 6eos eCr] "Epo^s Kal
6av]xacrTos kv dvdpcaTTOis rc Kat ^eoty, TroAAax^ ]J-iV Ka\ dAAr/,
ov\ qKLora 8e Kard Tr]V yivca-LV. to ydp iv tols TTpea^v-
TaTov elvaL tov 6iov tC]xlov, 17
8' 09, TiK]xr]pLov 8e tovtov b
yov^s ydp "Epcoros ovt elaXv oilre Ae^yoi^rat vtt' ovbevos oiJre

tStcorou ovTe TTOLr]Tov, dAA' *Ho-to8os TTp&Tov [XV Xdos (f)r]cr\

yereV^at
avrdp lireira 5
Fat' (vpvaTepvos, iTdvTO)v ^bos dacf^aXes aleC,
778' "E/aos

6 2^6 Aristaenetus om, T W 67 Hpa] a/ua Wyttenbach

BT W
:

a I & '6ffa in marg. t a 4 i^iofivijix^ffVTov B : a^ioiJ.vr}-

W
:

fiSvtVTOv elvai T
a^tofxvrifiovevTWV b a9 irpfff^vTaTov . . tov

W
: .

Oehv npffffivTaTov .
: tSiv Ofuv . B : irpf^rfivTdTois . . . toHv Ofuv T
b a yov^s B T W : yoval Stobaeus
 ^

I78b nAAT12N02;
H(no8<j) 8e Kot 'AKOUtriAccos o-vjlw^tjctii; /xeTct t6 Xaos bvo
TovTO) yevecrdaL, rijv re Koi "Epoira. n.apfji.ivibr]s 8e rrjv
lo yivitriv Xeyei
TtpdiTi.a-Tov ixkv "EpcaTa df&v p/qTicraTo 7t6,vto)V.

C ovTO) TTokkaxodev oixokoydTaL 6 "'Epcos V toXs Trpea-jSv-

TaTos LvaL. TTpear^vTaTos 8e a)v fxfyCcrToov ayadSiV rnilv

aXTLos ea-TLv. ov yap iyoiy' \o) eiTreiy otl p.iL^6v ioTLv
ayadbv (vdvs vi(j^ ovtl t] ipaa-rrjs XPW'^^ '^^'' ^paa-Tf]

5 TratSiKa. yap XPV av6p<oTroLs rjyiLadaL TravTos tov ^lov

o
Tols /xeAAoDo-i KaX&s /3i(oa-eo"^ai, tovto ovt crvyyivLa oXa
Te eixTTOLfLv ovTO) KakS>s ovT Tt/xat ovT tt)\.ovtos ovt aXXo
d ovbiv 0)5 epcos. Kiyo) 8e 8^ tC tovto; T-qv cttl fiV tols
alaxpols ala-xvvrjv, iiTl 8e tois KaXois ^L}\.OTLp.Cav' ov yap
caTLV &VV TOVTO)v ovT ttoKlv 0VT IbLcaTrjv pLy6Xa Kal
Kaka pya ^pya^crdaL. ^rj/xi ToiVw eyo) 6,vbpa oo-tls

5 pq, L TL aia-)(pbv ttol&v KaTabrfXos yCyvoLTO rj TTda-\o)V

VTTO Tov 8i' avavbpCav /x^ dp.vv6ixvos, ovt dv vtto iTaTpbs

o^Oevra o^to)s dAy^crai ovt imb TaCpo)v ovt vtt' aAAou
e 0vbvbs ci)S VTTb TTaLbLK&V. TOVTbv 8e TOVTO Kal rbv p(i)-

[j.Vov 6p5>p.v, OTL bLacf)p6vT0)s Tovs cpaaTCLS ala-xvvTaL,

oTav 6cf)0fi v aia-xp^ tlvl oiv. et ovv (xrj^avT] tis yivoLTo
&(TT tt6X.lv yVa-6aL rj aTpaT^TT^bov ipaaT&v T Kal Trai-

5 bLK&v, ovK a-TLV OTTO)S dv dpLLVOV oiKr]aLav rqv iavTcav r]

d7Tx6[Jl.VOL 7TdvT0)V tS>V aL(r)(J)S)V KOX cf)LX.OTLpLOVp.VOL TTpOS

179 dAA^Aous, Kat ixax^jxevoC y dv fXT dAAT/Acov ot tolovtol
VLK(aV dv okCyoL 6vtS o)S TT0S etTreiy Trdi^Tas dvOpcaTTOvs.
pS)V yap dvr]p v-nb TTaLbLK&v 6cf)$r]vaL rj Xltto^v Td^LV r)

oTrXa d'7To^aX.o)v rJTTov dv brJTTOv bi^aLTo 7/ xmb irdvT^av tS)V

b 8 'H(r<oSy 5 Koi KKovtriXfws dfio\oyei add.

' post b 1 1 itivTOiv BTW :

huc transposuit Schanz auctore F. A. Wolf ffvfi^-ijiriv^l ^vti.^-r\ffiv

Stobaeus d/j.oKoy(7 B T
: W
ante /jKra add. (prjffl B T (gs) <pr)ffi W :

Schanz post ffvfi<pr]ffiv omisi

: c i irpefffivTaros B T irpffffiu- W :

rdrois Stobaeus C 6 ffvyytveta B T ei/yevfia Wyttenbach W :

y
6 5^ secl. Ruckert a i y' iivBT : 5' tivW: y' at Vermehren
 : .

STMnOSION 179 a

aXXaiV, Kol Ttpo tovtov Tfdvdvai ^v TToX.k6.KLS cXolto. kul 5

IxTjv eyKaTaAiTreiy ye tcl 7rat8t/ca rj fxr] ^or]6rjaaL KLvbvvevovTL

ovbds ovToo KaKos 5vTLva ovK &v avTos 6 "EpoDs ivdeov
TTot^o-eie Ttpbs apeT-qv, u)&T o[xolov (IvaL t(o apL(XT<a ipvarcL'

Kal CLTexv^s, o i^r] "Ojxrjpos, fxivos (pLTTVcvaaL kvCoLS b

tQ>v r}p(a(ov tov 6e6v, tovto 6 "Epcos tols kpGxTL TtapiyiL
yLyv6p.vov irap avTov.
Kai p.r]v VTTepaiTo^vfj^rKCLV ye fiovoL k64Xov(TLv ol ep&VTes,
ov p.6vov OTL avbpcs, akka xat at yuz;atKes. tovtov be xat 5
rj rieAiou 6vyaTr]p "AAktjotis LKavr]v [xapTvpLav TTap4xTai
VTT^p Tovb Tov k6yov cis Tovs "EWr^vas, i^cki^^raa-a pL6vr]

V7Tp Tov avTr]s avbpos aTTo6avLV, ovtcov avT^ TraTpos re

KOi fXr]Tp6s, O^S kKiivr] TO(TOVTOV VTTpJ3d\(T0 Trj (f)lkl(l bLCL C
Tov p(DTa, (ooTe diroSet^at avTovs dkkoTpLovs ovTas T(a veX
Kal 6v6fxaTL ]x6vov TTpocrqKovTas, Ka\ tovt kpyacraixivr] to
epyov ovTOt) Kakov eSo^ey pyd(raa-dai ov fxdvov av6p(aTT0LS
dkka Kal ^eots, wore Trokk&v TroAXa Kal Kaka epyao-a/ueVwy 5
vapL6]xr]T0LS br] tlctlv ^bocrav tovto yipas ol dfOL, e^ "AtSou
ai^etyat irdkLV rrjy ^vxrjv, dkka TrfV ^KeCvrjs dvd^rav dya-
a-6VTS T(a py(a' ovt(o Kal dol TTjy iTpl tov Ipcora (riTOvbr^v d
re Kat dpTr]v [xdkLcrTa tlpl&ctlv.} 'Op^e'a 8e tov Oldypov
dTkr] dTTCTT^fx^av ^"ALbov, (^&a^fxa bL^avTS Trjs yvvaLKOs
e0' ^v rJKV, avTr]v 8e ov b6vTS, otl fxak6aKl((r6aL kbo-
KL, &T 5)V KL6ap(ab6s, Kal OV TOkfldv VKa TOV p(s)TOS 5
diTo6vf](TKLv &(T'jTp " kkKr^aTLS, dkkcL bLafxr]yavd<T6aL C^v
icrLVaL LS "ALboV. TOLydpTOL bLCL TaVTa bLKTjV aVT(0 TT-
dcrav, Kol kiTOLr](Tav tov 6dvaTov avTov vtto yvvaLK&v
yv4(T6aL, ovx &(nrp 'AxLkkia tov ttjs 0e'rt8os vbv iHfxr]- e

a 6 fiijv B /t^ T
: W
b 5 ou /x6vov Sri] ov fi6vov oi ci. Stephanus
ohx 8ti ci. Fischer o/B om. : TW
b 7 int^p rovii rov \6yov del.
ci. Stephanus e 6 5^ post eSocrav iterant T 07 aveTvai] W
iivifvai Hommel dAA^ rijv iKfivrjs^ aW' avrifv iKflvrjv Earle
d I Tip Hpytfi secl. Baiter d 3 <pd(rna B (pdvra(Tfj.a T
d 6 SiafirtxavairOai B T Sia/JiTixcu^ccurdai W
: W
: ^wv (ItrUvai B ^v
W
:

Uvai T ^wv Uvai

:

PLATO, VOL. II. .

11
 :

179 e nAATX2N0S
(rav Kol di fxaKdpcov vi^crovs aTTTreix^j/av, ort 7re7rin-//eVos

TTapa TTJs (n]Tpbs q>s cnroOavoiTo airoKnivas "EKTopa, fJLrj

iroi^cras be ToCra oiKabe i\6o)v yrjpaLos TekevT^qa-oi,

5 h6KfJLT]a-V kXia-Oai jSorfOi^aras toj fpaa-Tfj TlaTpoKXia Ka\

i8o TLixtiip-qa-as ov fxovov inr^paTTodavelv aWa Kal iTTairoOaveiv
TereAeuTrj/coVt' o^ei^ 8r) kol VTTepayaadivTis 61 dcol 8ta</)e-
p6vT(i)S avTov TLfxr](Tav, OTL Tov epaarrfv ovtco Trept TTokkov
eTroieiTo. Alaxykos 8e ^Xmpet (fxia-KOiv 'AxiAAea Ua-
5 TpoKKov kpav, os rfv KaXkidiv ov fxovov YlaTp6KX.ov aAA'
apLa Kal tQ>v rfpoiKov aTTdvTcov, Kal (Ti ayiveLOS, eiTCLTa
V(aTpos TToXv, &s (prfaLV "Ofirfpos. aXXa yap T(a ovtl
fxdXLo-Ta pikv ravTrfv Trfv apcTrfv ol diol TLfxStaLV Trfv 7re/)i

b Tov epooTa, fxaWov fxivTOL BavfxdCovaLV Kal ayavTai Kal

V TTOLova-LV oTav 6 ep(afXVos tov kpacTTrfv dyaiTa, rj OTav
6 epaa-Trfs tcl iTaLbLKd, dcLOTcpov yap ipaoTTfs TTaLbLKStv
ivOios ydp ka-TL. 8ta Tama Ka\ tov 'A^iAAea Trfs 'AXKiffa-
5 TtSo? jxaXXov eTifxrfaav, eis fxaKdpcov vqaovs dTTOTTfx\l/avTs.
OfjTOi brf yoi>y (prffXL "E/acoTa deSiV /cai TTp^a-^VTaTOV Ka\

TLfXLdtTaTov Ka\ KvpL(t)TaTov LvaL eis dpeTTfs Ka\- ivbaLfxovias

KTrja-LV dvdpdiTTOLS Ka\ ^wo-t Kai TeAei^TT/o-ao-ir.

C ^albpov fxkv TOLOVTOV Tiva \6yov (firf etTretr, fxeTa be

^^albpov aAAous tlvcls eti^at wy ov Trdvv bLCfxvrffxovcw ois
TTapeLS Tov navcravLov k6yov bLrfyiLTo. diTiXv 8' avToi'
oTt Ov KokGiS fxoL SoKei, S <I>at8/3e, TTpo^e^krfaOaL rffXLV

5 6 Ao'yos, t6 aTTkm ovTUis iTaprfyyekOaL iyKOifXLdCeLv "EpooTa.

et fxev ydp ets -qv 6 "'E/xuy, Kakios &v eixe, vvv be ov ydp
kcTTLV et5* fxrf ovTos 8e kvos 6pd6Tep6v iaTL TTp^Tepov TTpop-
d prfdrjvaL ottoIov Sei eTratretv. eyo) ovv TT^pda-ofxaL tovto

e3 li.voOdvoiro (sic) T W arro6dvoi B 64 iroiijffas Se rovro T W

W
:
:

hvoKrdvas Se rovrov B of(co5' T oiKo&e S'B 65

W $ori6-fi(ras
:

BT : $ori6ri<rai a 5, 6 dA\' a,ua scripsi : aWa &pa T W aWh B

W
:

b6 Ka\ vpetrPvrarov B : irptfffivrarov T koI rifitdnarov B W

om. T (add. in marg. t) b? Kvpicirarov B Kvpi<irfpov: TW
dI 6iro7ov] iirorepov Hermann Sf? BTW (sed Se7 ex 5^ T)
 STMnOSION i8od

kiravopdtiXTacrBai, TtpGiTov p.(.v "Epoira (ppda-aL ov 6ei iirai-^

veiv, eiretra eTraireo-ai a^Coos tov Oeov. TrdvTS yap icr/ici;

oTi ovK ioTLv &vv "EpoiTos 'A0po8iT7;. fnas fxev oZv

ovcrris ets av ^v "Epcas' eTret 8e bvo karov, bvo dvdyKr) 5
brj

Ka\ *'Epcore eii^ai. ttcSs 8' ov Svo ro) ^eci; 57 /xer ye ttou
trpea-^VTcpa Kal d[X7]T(tip Ovpavov 6vydTr]p, fjv hr] Ka\
Ovpaviav T:ovop.dCop.iV 7/ 8e V(OTpa Alos Ka\ ALcavrjs,
rjv bi) Hdvbrjixov Ka\ovfXV. dvayKalov br] Ka\ "E/^cora tov e
fxev Trj kTcpa a-vvepyov Tldvbr]]xov 6pd(as KakelcrdaL, tov be
OvpdvLov. iiraLveLV [xkv ovv 8et TidvTas deovs, h 8' ovv
kKdTipos eiA.r7x.e Treipareoi' eiTreiy. Trao-a yap irpd^LS c!)8'

exef avTT] ec/)' eavr^s TrpaTTOfxivr] ovt KaKr] ovt alayj)d. 5

oioy 6 vvv fifx^LS TTOLOvfxev, r] TTLVLv 7] ab(LV rj bLakiy^adaL, l8l
ovK iaTL TovT(ov avTo Kakov ovbev, dAA' iv Trj irpd^eL, ws
av irpaydf], tolovtov aTri^r]' Kak&s ]XV ydp itpaTTo^xevov
KaL 6p6S)S KaXov yiyv^TaL, /xr) 6p6S)S 8e ala^y^pov. ovrco 8?/

Kat To ipdv Ka\ 6 "Epoos ov irds eo-rt /caAos ov8e a^io? 5

yK(i)]XLd^a6aL, dXKd 6 KakGts iTpoTpiTTdiv epdv.

'O ]Xv ovv rfjs Ilavb-q]xov 'A0po8tr77S ws d\r]6S)S irdv-
br]]x6s iaTL Ka\ ^pyd(TaL otl dv tvxJ]' Ka\ ovtos ioTLV b
ov oi (fiavkoL T(av dv6p(aTt(t)v ip&crLV. ep&cTL 8e 01 tolovtoi
TrpGiTov ]Xv ovx rjrrov yvvaLK&v r] iTaLbuiV, CTTCLTa &v kol
ip&a-L T&v a(i)]idT(iov fxdkkov t) t&v ^x.^v, iTTLTa ws hv
bvvoiVTaL dvor]TOTdT(av, iTpbs to bLaTTpd^acr6ai ]x6vov /3Ae- 5
TT0VTs, d]X\ovvTs 8 Tov KoX&s r] fXT]' odcv br] CrV]X^aLVL
avTols OTL hv Tvx(>a-L tovto TTpdTT^LV, 6]xoL(as ]XV dya66v,
6]xoL(os 8e TOvvavTLOv. aTL ydp Ka\ aTTo r^s 6ov v(OTpas
re 0V0-7/S ttoAu tj ttjs kripas, Koi fXTe)(Ova-r]s iv ttj yVcrL C

d4 ovv BT W
om. Stobaeus d 5 5 5r; B 5 T Stobaeus W
W
: :

d6 fpuTf BT (puna^ Stobaeus rii ded B T rd a Sto- W

W
: :

baeus to 0f<i Cobet

: d 8 Si<iw]s T Si6inis B 65 irparron4vri :

BT W Stobaeus om. Proclus : a 2 ahrh B T Stobaeus aiiri W

W
:

Kad' avTh t T^ B T om. Stobaeus a 5 KoXhs B

: Kok&s T W :

b 8 airh secl. Schanz

11*
i8ic nAATi2N02
Koi dt]\os KOi appevos. 6 8e rr/s Ovpavtas 7:pS)Tov juei' ov
fxerexovo-qs OijXcos dAA' appevos fxovov koI icrTiv ovtos 6

t5>v TTaibcov epcos eTretra i:p(rl3vTpas,vl3pe(t)S apiOLpov odev

6 8?) irrl t6 appV TpiirovTai oi ck tovtov tov epcoros iTTLTTvoi,

To ({)va-L epp(aixVa-Tpov Kal vovv pMkXov exov ayairGiVTes.

Kai TLS hv yvoLt] koX iv avTjj Trj TraLbepaa-TLCf, tovs eiAiKptyws

d vTro TOVTOv Tov ^p(t)Tos tiipiir]]iivovs' ov yap kp&aL TraLboiiv,

dAA' iTTLbav Tjbr] apx^ovTaL vovv ta^eLV, tovto 8e TrArjo-id^et

TO) yVLdaKLV. TTap(TKVa(T]XVOL yap OL]Xai L(TLV 01 V-

TvdV dpx6]Xvai kpdv s tov (3lov cLiTavTa crvvcaofxevoi
5 Kal KOLvrj avix^L(t)a-6]XV0L, dAA' ovk i^aTiaTrjcravTes, iv
d(f)pocrvvr] Xa^6vTS b)s viov, KaTay\daavTS olxr^aeadaL
kii akXov dTTOTpxovTS. XP^^ ^^ ''"' v6]xov etmi ]xr] ipdv
e TTalbcov, tva ]xr] ets dbr]\ov iToXXr] aTTOvbr] dvr]X.LaKT0' t6
ydp tQ)V iraLboiv re'Aos dSrjAoz; 61 reAevra /caKtas KaX dp^Trjs

\lrvxvs T TTpL KOL a-(t)]xaTos. o\ ]XV ovv dyaOoX t6v v6]xov

TOVTOV aVTol aVTOLS k6vTS TLdVTaL, XPW ^^ '^^ TOVTOVS

5 Tovs 7Tavbrj]xovs epacrras TTpoaavayKd^LV t6 tolovtov, coo-Trep

KoX tS)V \vdp(t)V yvvaLKoiv TTpoaavayKd^o]XV avTOvs KaG'

l8a oaov bvvd]X6a p.r] ipdv. oSrot ydp eiaLv ol Kal t6 oveLbos
7TTTOLr]K6TS, u)aT TLvds Tok]mv kyLV 0)? aiaxp6v x^^P*"'

^eaOaL ipaarals' kiyovaL 8e ets tovtovs dTTo^kTTOVTS,

bpCiVTS avT&v Tr]v dKaLpCav Kal dbLKLav,
. eirei ov br]TTov

5 KoajXLODS ye Kat vo]xl]X(i)s otlovv {iTpdy^xa) TTpaTT6]XVov y^6yov

dv bLKams cfiipoL.

Kat br] Kal 6 Trept tov ipoDTa v6]xos iv ]Xv rats dAAaty
TToAeo-t voijaaL pabLos, aTTk&s ydp wpLaTaL' 6 b v6ab
b Kal V AaKbaL]xovL iTOLKCkos. V "HAiSt ]XV ydp Kal ev
Botojrots, Kal ov ]xr] ao(f)ol kyLV, aTTk&s vVO]xo6Tr]TaL

c 3 Kot . . . ^pios secl. SchQtz d a oAA'] a\K' ?) ci. Stephanus

d6 oixftrOai Herwerden ea TeAos secl. Badham 64 XPV
B :
XP^ T W a 2 rtvas BT W : Tiva vulg. a 5 irpay/xa in
marg. t om. BTWb i /cal V AaKeSal/j.ovt secl. Winckelmann
W
:

6 supra eV AaKfSalfjt.ovt add. T b2 o5 yu^ T : ou /i^ B

 2TMn02I0N i8ab

Kakov t6 )(apC(ecr6aL ipaa-Tais, Kal ovk av ris etTTOt ovre

vios ovT TraXaios a>s ala-\p6v, tva oi/xat ju,t) 'npayp.aT

tyuiai.v koyid Treipwfterot TT^Cdeiv tovs v^ovs, are abvva- 5

rot Aeyeti^' ttjs 8e 'Icoz^tas Kat aAAo^i TroXAaxoiS ala-\pov

vivofXLoraL, oo-ot vtto l3ap^dpois oIkovo-lv. toIs yap jSap-

jBdpois 8ta ras Tvpavvibas ala-)(j)6v tovto ye Kat rj ye

0tAo(ro^ia Kat ^ <pt\oyvp.vaa-TCa' ov yap o1p.aL a-VfX(f)4pcL C
rotj dpyova-L (f)povrip.aTa )u.eydAa iyyCyveaOaL t&v dpxo-
p.ev(ov, ovbk (^iAtas icrxvpas Kat Kotycoi^tds, o brj /xdAtora
</)tAet rd re dAAa Trdrra Kat 6 epcos e/xTroteiy. ^pyo) 6e
roSro ffjLadov Kal ol ivddbe Tvpavvoi' 6 ydp 'ApLaroyeC- 5

Tovos p(jt)s Kal fj 'ApixobCov (f)LkCa ^i^aLOS yivop.ivr\ Kar-

e'Avo-er avTa>v Tr]v dpxr]V. ovrcos ov piiv alayjpov kTiOr)

XapC(ea6aL epao-rais, KaKta t&v ^e/iercoy Ketrat, tS>v pi,\v d

dp)(6vT0)v TrAeoye^ta, tGiv b\ dpyop.iv(i)V dvavbpCcL' ov 6e
KaAoi' a-nkCis kvop.Ca-6r], bLa Tr]v tS>v 6p.ivo)V Tr]s ^vxvs
dpyCav. evOdbe 8e TroAi tovtcov KdkhLov v(vofxodiTr]TaL, Kal
07re/3 etTror, ov ptibLOV KaTavorj(raL. iv6vjxr]6evTL ydp ort 5

Ae'yerat KdAAtoy t6 (pavep&s ipdv tov kd6pci, Kat /xdAtora

t5)V yfvvaLOTdToov Kat dpCaro)v, Kdv aiax^Covs dkX(t)v S<rt, Kai

ort av r) TrapaK^kevcns ru kpS)VTL TTapd TidvTo^v 6av]xaaTrj,

ov^ o)s TL aLa-yj)6v ttolovvtl, Kal kkovTL re KaAw SoKet eirat
Kai ixr] ekovTL ala-yjpov, Koix Trpoy t6 iiTLyiLpilv kkiCv i^ov- e
o-tW 6 v6p.os bebo)Ke rai ipaoTrj 6av]xaaTd pya kpya(p]xiv(a
(TtaLVfladaL, h ei rts roA/xwr/ Troteiv dAA' ortow StWKcoy Kat
^ovkopLCVos bLa7Tpd^aa6aL Trkrjv tovto, "^
(f)Lkoao(f)Cas rd /xe'- 183
yiaTa KapiTolT dv oveCbr] et ydp r/ yp-qfW.Ta ^ovkdfx^vos
napd Tov kajBelv 7; dpxp^v dp^at ?/ rti^a dkkr]v bvvap.LV
e^e'Aot Troiety oldiTep ol epaorat Trpds rd iratStKd, iKcretas

bs tJ BTW: del. t c 7 o5 BTW: ow B dzoSS^TW:

011 5e B d4 5e B W d5 om. T fv0vn-neevTi BT W yp. Kal
marg. W
: :

ivedvfx-fieriv in ts T W: dg om. B es & ef TW :

oJel B : yp. koI altl in marg. W a i (pi\o(To<piai secl. ci. Schleier-

macher a2BT:^W a^ fdfKoi B : e\ei T W
 :

iSaa nAATliNOS
5 re Koi diTt/SoATjtreis V rais Ser/creo-ti' TTOLOvfXfvot., Koi opKovs

ofivTljvTfs, Kot KOi/xTjcrets im Ovpais, koX idikovTfs SouAetas

hovkViv oXas ovb^ hv bovkos ovbeCs, e/X7ro8^fotro hv fxrj

TtpaTTilV OVT(i> TrjV TTpa^lV Kal VTTO <f)i\(aV Kal VTTO k\6pQ>v,

b rwy }i\v 6vLbi.(,6vTOdv KokaKeCas koI avekcvdcpCas, t&v 8e

vov6eTovvTO)v Kal alayyvop.iv(av VTTep avT&v rw 8' kpStvTi

irdvTa TavTa ttolovvtl x^P'^ iTTCCTTt,, Kal 6e'8orai VTrb tov

vojxov 6.VV oveCbovs iTpaTTiiv, ws TTayKakov rt TTpayp.a

5 bi.aiTpaTTop.ivov' o 8e Seti^oVaroi^, &s ye kiyov(nv ol ttoA-

Aot, ort Kat 6p.vvvTi p.6v(a (Tvyyv(!>p.r] Trapa de&v (K^dvTi.

rwy opKOiV a(f)pobC(nov yap opKov ov (f)a(rtv eiifat* ovtco

C Kat ot ^eot Kai ot avdpooTTOi TTacrav ^ov(rCav iTeTTOi-^Kacn T(a

ip&VTi, b)s 6 v6p.os (prjarlv 6 ivddbe ravTr\ fikv ovv oir]6eCr]

&v Tis TTayKakov vop.C(i(T6ai iv Trjbe Tjj 7ro'Aei KOt to (pav

Kal t6 (f)Ckovs yCyv(rdai rois ipacrTals. iiTeibav 8e Trai-

5 bay(t)yovs e77to-r7jo-ayres ot Trarepes rots ep(o/xe'vots /x?) e5(ri

8iaAe'ye(r^at rots epacrats, Kat rw TTaibayooy^ TavTa irpo^r-

TTayp.va f\,
^AtKtwrat 8e Kat kTalpoi 6veibC^(t)(Tiv edv rt
6pS)(riv TOiovTov yiyv6p.vov, Kal tovs 6vibCCovTas av ol
d TTp(r^vTpoi fxr] 8taKa)Av(o<n //rj8e AotSopwo-ti^ ws ovk 6p6&s
kiyovTas, ety 8e TavTa rts av ^k\f/as rjyq^raiT hv TTakiv
at(r)(i(rTov to TOiovTov v6dbe voixCCecrdai. t6 8e oi/xat c58'

Ix^ ovx aTrAoui' ecTTiv, oirep e^ 6.p\r]s ekey6r] ovTe Kak6v

5 eii^at avT6 Ka6^ avT6 oijTe aicryjp6v, dkka Kakds piev TTpaT-

T^fxevov Kak6v, ato^pws 8e al(rxp6v. ai(rxp&s p.v ovv

eoTt TTOvrjp^ T Kal TTOvr]pG)S yapC^ecr^ai, Kak5)S be xpr](rT(a
re Kai KaAws. iTovr]p6s 8' eorii' eKeiz^os 6 ipa^TT-qs 6 Trdv-

a6 ofivvvTes secl. Hertz ietKovres BTW: ^efXovras vulg.

b 2 avTwv^l avTOv Orelli b3 irdvTa TavTa B : TavTa irdvTa TW
tireffTt TW erreTai (sic) B b 7 twv opKoiv T W : tuv '6pKov B : Thv
W Stobaeus
:

SpKov al.SpKov (SpKov) Hertz elvai BT Cyrillus thai

B T om. W
:

4/xirolvi/xov Osann e schol. e i 01 (bis) : 06 koI

...07^ secl. Jahn c7 ^ TW 0/ B : ^ oj al. tTaTpoi Heindorf
W
:

fTtpot BTW ovfiZiCovcriv d? koAwj 5e Par. i8io: Ka\hv

8JBTW
 STMnOSION i83e

5t///,09, o tov crunmros \xakkov i) ttj^ ^vyrjs epSiV Koi yap e

ovbi fiovijJLOi icTTLV, aT ovb p.ovip.ovip&v TTpdyfXaTOS.
5/*a yap tQ tov (r(ap.aTos avOet. kqyovTt, ovirep ijpa, " ot-
Xerat aTTOTndfjt.ivos," TToXkovs koyovs Kal VTiocryicr^is KaTai.-
cr)(vvas' 6 8e tov ijOovs xPV^^^^ ovtos ipacrTris bia (3Cov 5

fxfvec, aT piovCfxta avvraKcCs. tovtovs bri /SovXerat 6

fffXTpos vofjLos v Kal Kakois ^acravC^iv, koX Tols fjikv 184

yjxpCcraa-dai, tovs 8e bLa<pvyLv. bLO. Tavra ovv toIs fJ.V

bL<aKiv TTapaK^K^v^Tai, tols 8e (f)vyLV, dyoovod^T&v Kal

(3aa-avCCoiV 7T0Tp(ov ttot karLV 6 ip&v *cat TTOTcpoov 6

pU>fXVOS. OVTUi brj VTTO TaVTTfS TTJS ahCaS TTp&TOV fXV t6 5

I

a\Ca-Ka-daL Taxy ala^pov v^vofXLoraL, tva xpovos iyyivrfTai,

&ff brf Soxet TCL TToWa Kak&s ^aaavC^LV, TTLTa to vtto
\pr]fxdT(av kol vtto iTokLTLK&v bvvdfXcov ak&vaL ala~xp6v,
idv T KaK&s TTdaxoiv TTTrj^r} Kal fxrf KapTprfcrrf, av t b
VpyTovfXVos ls yjnffxaTa rf eij bLaiTpd^^is TTokLTLKas fxrf

KaTa(f)povrfcrrf ovbcv yap 8oKet tovt(ov ovt ^^aLov ovt

fxovLfxov ^Tvai, x(i)pls tov fxrfbl 7T(j)VKvaL aTr' avT&v yV-
vaCav (f)LkCav. fxCa brf k^C-n^TaL rw r]fXTp(a v6fX(o 680'y, et 5

fXkkL Kakas yapL^laOaL ipaaTjj iratStKa. eo-rt yap rjfxiv

vofxos, &a-TTp tt\ toXs kpaoTOLS rfv bovkVLV cdekovTa

ffVTLVovv bovkcCav TratStKots fxff KokaK^Cav eii^at /urjSe eTTo- c
retSioTor, ovtoi) bff Kal akkrj fxCa fx6vrf bovk^Ca KOvcnos
k^ClT^TaL OVK TTOVCbLaTOS' aVTrf 8' eOTiy fj TTpl TrfV dpTrfV.

Vv6fXL(TTai ydp bff fffxlv, edy rty iOdkrf Tivd 6paTTVLV

ffyovfXVos bC KLV0V dfXCv(i)V iaecrOai ff fcara ao(f)Cav TLvd 5

e I ^ TTJs ^f/vxv^ ipwv B : T e 2 Sre ouS*

ipuv ^ T^r ^vxH^ W
TW : ore ou B a ^ia^ivyeiv secl. Badham
i al . . .
Q.S ^^
BT: 877 Ko2 W
bi &v t fvfpyerovnfvos ^V^ avrfvepyfTov/xfvosT :

ba fh xp^^jucTa . voKiTiKas secl. Hirschig b6 ^(tti . . vS/xos

W
. . .

om. Schanz auctore Vermehren b 7 Sxnrfp 2<nr/> B Sto- T :

baeus : &a-irep yap Vermehren Schanz ide\ovTa B T : ideXovTas W

vel ideKovTas Stobaeus C 2 fjila ^uJvrj] /t/a fiLuv B fila fi/6vov T : W :

fiSvTf jttia Stobaeus : fiia ipop.evi^ Usener ftla (rcov ipwfievuv T(p fi/MeTeptfi
:

v6)fiti> Schanz jUta vewv Hug

: C 4 tis iOeAri Tiva B tIs Tiva TW :

Oe\^ Stobaeus c 5 iKeTvov T Stobaeus eKeTvo B W :

 B :;

i84C nAATI2N0S
rj Kara &kko otcovv /xepos apeTrjs, avTr} av rj e^eAoSovAeia
ovK al(Tyjpa etmt ovh\ KokaKeCa. bd 8tj to) vofxo) tovtu)
(rvfij3a\etv eis TavTov, tov rc Trepi r^y Traibepaa-TCav Kal
l d TW TTept Trjv <\)i.ko(TO(^Cav re /<ai rTJz; akkr]v apiTriv, ei

tiikkei a-vfjLJSrjvat. Kakbv yeviardai to ipaaTrj x^P^- 'nai.biKa

(ra(r6ai. oTav yap eis to avTo (k6(a(nv ipaa-Tris re KOt

TraiStKa, voixov ^yjjiv kK^xipos, 6 fjikv xapi(Tap,ivois TTaibiKols
5 VTTrjpiTStv OTLOvv SiKatcos av virrjpeTelv, 6 be rto TroLovvTL
avTov (ro(f>6v re /cat ayadov StKatcos av otlovv av VTTOvp-
yS>v {virovpyeTv), Kal 6 /xev bvvdpievos els (pp6vr](TLv KaX rqv
e &kkr}v apcTrjv avp.^6kXea-6aL, 6 be be6p.evos els itaLbeva-LV
KoX Tr]V akkrjv ao(f)Cav KTaadai, T^Te br) tovt(ov avvL^VTcav
els TavTov t&v v6p.(t)v fxova)(ov evTav6a avpLTrCTTTeL to Kakov
eTvaL TratSiKa epaaTj] yapCaaa^aL, akko6L be ovbap.ov. eTrt

5 rovro) Kat i^aTTaTrj^rjvaL ovbev aia)(^p6v' em be rots aAAots

Tracrt Kat e^airarco/ieVa) alaxvvrjv (f)epeL Kal fxrf. el ydp tls
185 epaaTrj a)s TTkovaC(a TrkovTov eveKa yapLaafievos e^aTTaTr}6eCr]
Kal ixr] kdjSoL yj)r]]j.aTa, dva(f)avevTos tov epaaTov irevr^Tos,
ovbev rJTTOv ala\p6v' boKel yap 6 tolovtos t6 ye avTov
eTTLbei^aL, otl iveKa yj)r]]xdT())v otlovv hv OT^aovv VTTr^peTol,
5 TovTo be ov Kakdv. Kara tov avTov bi] k6yov Kav et rts

&>s dya6^ ^^apLadjxevos kox avTos o)? d}xeCv(*)V kadfxevos 8ta

Tr}v (f)LkCav epaaTOv e^aTTaTr]6eCr}, dva(f>avevT0S iKeCvov KaKov
b Kat ov KeKTr}}xevov dpeTr}v, 6}xo)s Kakr] 77 dTTaTr]' boKel yap
av Kal ovTos to Ka6^ avTov bebr]ko)KevaL, 5ri dpeTrjs y
^veKa KOL Tov ^ekTC(t)v yeveadaL iTdv dv TravTl '7Tpo6v}xr}6eCr},
TOVTO be av irdvT^av KdkkLaTov ovrco TTav TTdvT^as ye Kukbv

C7 Tci> ySfiu Tovru apographa : rtj) fSfKfi rovrif BT W d2 t^ T

T^BW ds &J/TW: oS/ d6 &>'TW: oC B virovpySiv
inrovpyeiy Baiter vnovpywv BT W virovpyeiv vulg. e i ^u/i/SaA-
W
: :

\effOai T : IvfiL^aXiadai B Schutz

eis del. e 2 KTao-floi]
IffraarOai Schanz e 3 ruv vSnwv ciel. Bast a 7 ipaffrov B T W
rov epaffrov al. bi ^ B t W
om. pr. T: b 4 irav Stobaeus
om. BTW
 :

STMnO^llON i85b

apfTTJs y 'iv(.Ka xo-p^C^o^Oai.. ovtos kcTTLV 6 Ttjs ovpavias Otov 5

epcos Kttt ovpavios Koi ttoAAou a^ios koI 7ro'Aet koX IhmTais,
T:oXkr\v eTTt/xeAetay avayKa^uiV TTOiua-OaL Trpbs apeTrjv tov
re ip&vTa avzov avTov Kal tov ipcoix^vov' ol 8' iT^poi C
TiavTis Tijs erepay, ttjs Travbrnxov. TavTo, aoi,, i(f)ri, as ex
Tov Trapaxpfjpia, co 4>at8pe, Trept "Epcoros o-r/jt/3dAAo/xat.

riauo-ariou 8c iravaafxivov 8i8cio-Kot;o-i ydp /xe to-a Xiyeiv

ovrcocrt ot a-o(f)o( e<^Tj 6 'ApiaTobr^fxos bdv pikv ^ ApiaTO(f)dvr] 5
Ae'yetr, Tvx^tv 8e avT^ Tiva ri inrb Trkrjcrixoinjs r) vtto tivos
dAAou Avyya eTrtTreTrrcoKVtai/ Kat ovx. oto'y re etvat kiyeiv,
dAA' etTreii' avTov iv tjj KdT(o yap avrov Tbv laTpbv 'Epu^i- d
ixaxov KaraKeio-^at
"'i2 'Epv^ip.ax, StKatos ei rj Trava-aC

fxe Trjs kvyybs rj Ae'yeiy VTrep e/utoC, ecos hv eyco Travo-co/uat."

Kai roy ^Epv^Cjxaxov etTreiv " 'AAAd TrotTjo^co dix^poTcpa Tavra'
iyoi fxev ydp epai ey r&i o-w /j,e'pet, o-i; 8' e7ret8dy Travcrr), iv 5

ro) e/xo). ey w 8' dr eyo) Ae'yco, edr /uie'i' o-oi idiKrj diTvevcrTl

\ovTi TTokvv xP^vov TTaveo-dai, i) kvy^' ei 8e fxri, vbaTi

dvaKoyxvkuKTOV. ei 8' dpa Trdvv laxvpd icmv, dvaka^div e
rt rotoCroi' otu) KtyTjcrats dv T-t]v plva, Trrdpv Kat edi^ tovto
TTotrja-rjs diTa^ rj bis, Kal ei iTdvv laxvpd icm, TratJo-erai."
**
OvK hv (f)6dvois kiy(ji)v,^' (f)dvaL Tbv ^ ApLcno^dvr]' " iyo)
8e TavTa 7rot7/o-co." 5

EtTreti 8r) rdi; 'Epv^Cfxaxov, AoKet toCvvv fxoi dvayKalov

etmt, e7ret8^ riaDo-ai^ias opixrja-as iirl Tbv koyov KaAcSs ovx
LKavS)s d^rereAeo-e, ^eii' e/xe Tretfida-daL reAo? e^rt^etmt tQ 186
Ao'yo). rd /xey ydp bLirkovv etmt rdy "'E/scora 8oKet ixol

KaAws dteAeo-^at* dri 8e ov p.6vov iarXv eTrt rats \ffVxciLS

b 5 dpT'^s 7' eVeKo T W : apeTTJs evfKa B :cVcko apfTrji Stobaeus

C3 ffvfifia.\\ofj.at TW: avfj.$d\\ofj.ev B \(ytiv BT: om.
C7 W
d. I Thv laTphv T W : Tuv laTpwv B d 6 ir**v XP^'">'' iweiKTTJ
itXovTi W 62 KivTjffais BTW Stobaeus et legit Athenaeus
Kviiaais Wyttenbach e4 <pavai (sic) B : thuv T W
 :

a nAAT12N02
rSiV avdptaitoiv Trpos tovs KaXovs aWa Kal irpos aWa irokX.a

5 Kal V Tols aWois, toIs T (TU)p.a(Ti. t&v TrdvTOiv ^(pcoi' Kal

rois iv Trj y?/ (fiVOfxivoLS Kal i)S fTTOs (lirdv (v Ttatn tois

ov<n, Ka6(apaKvaL /xoi boK& (k ttjs laTpLKrjs, Trjs rf\iTipas

b T\vr]s, &)S fjifyas kol 6avfxaa-Tos Kal (irl Trav 6 ^eos Teivei

Kal Kar dv6p(aTTLva Kal KaTo, ^eia 'npdyp.aTa, dp^ofxaL 8e

diio Trjs laTpLKrjs \(yo)v, iva Kal 7rpeo-j3cua)/iey rqv Tkyvr]v.

1] yap (pva-LS t&v (T^ofxdTOiv Tov bLirXovv "Epcora tovtov x^'*
5 t6 yap vyLcs tov o-w/xaros Kal to voa-ovv oyLoXoyovixiv o)S
fTcpov re Kal dvofxoLov ka-TL, to 8e dvojxoLov dvopiOLoiv citl-

6vixL Kal epfi. aAAos fxv ovv 6 em roi vyi(LV& epoiS, &Xkos
be 6 eTTt rw yoo-wSet. eorty brj, wo-Trep apri HavcravLas
eAeyey rois fxkv dya6oLS Kakbv xapLC((r6aL t&v dv6p(aTT0iv,
8' aKoAaoTots alaxpov, ovTOi Kal ev avTOis tols
C rois (r(afxacrLV

tols fxkv dya6oLS kKacrTov tov (rdtfxaTos Koi vyLeLVoTs KaXov

XapiC^o-6aL Kal 8et, Kat tovto eo-rtv <S ovofxa to laTpLKOv,

TOLS 8e KttKOts Kai voa-<aba-LV aia^ov re Kal 8et dxaptoTeii',

5 et /xeAAei rts tcxvlkos etmt. lo-rt yap laTpLKrj, ws iv

Ke<^aAat<i) etTreti', kTrLaTrffxrf t&v tov (rdifxaTos ipoiTLK&v Trpbs

TrXrfafxovrfv koX Kerwo-tr, Kat 6 bLayLyv(aaKOiv iv tovtols tov

d KaAoV re Kat alaxpbv (pooTa, ovtos eortr 6 iaTpLK(oTaTos,
Kal 6 fXTal3dX.kLv ttol&v, ware dvTL tov hepov epcoros Tbv

Tpov KTda-6aL, Kal ols fxrf (Vio-TLV epcos, Sei 8' eyyeyeo-^ai,

(TTLo-Tdfxcvos ip.TTOLrjaaL KOL iVovTa k^ekiLV, dya6bs dv etrf

5 87j/xtorpyos. 8et yap bif to. e^^to-ra ovTa v rui adfxaTL

(fiLka oXov T eivat Troiety Kai kpdv dXkrfkoiv. ea-TL 8e ex^i<rra

TCL vavTL(aTaTa, \}/vxpbv dcpfx^, TTLKpbv yAuKet, irfpbv iyp^,

e TtdvTa TCL TOLaVTa' TOVTOLS TTLa-Trf6LS epcOTa ifXTTOLrfa-aL KaL

ofxovoLOV 6 rffXTpos TTpoyovos 'Ao-kAtjttios, &s (fiaa-LV otbe ol

b2Kara ravOpdndva Stobaeus Kara rh. 6eia Stobaeus b 3 koJ

BTW: om. Stobaeus b^ ex*'TW: x>? B bs 6ixo\oyov-
fifvws B dfio\oyovfji.ev Stobaeus wsTW
b 7 vyiuv^ Ipus T W
vyif7 voepos
:

B ds KTaffBai B: KTria-a(r0ai TW fpties secl.

Usener d4 (cot . . . f^c^elv secl. Schanz

 STMnOSlON i86e

TTOirjTai Kol eycb T:eC6oixai., (Tvvi(TTr\(riv rrjv rjfiiTipav Tixvrjv.

rj 76 ovv laTpLK-q, axTTTep Kiyoi, iracra hia tov deov tovtov

KV^fpvaTai, b)(TavT(t)s 8e Kal yvixva(mKr\ koI ywpyia' jxov^nKr] 187
Kal iravTl jcarciSr/Xos rai Kal crfXLKpov TrpooriyovTi tov vovv
oTi KaTa TavTo. e;(et tovtols, axTTTcp lo-o)? Kal 'HpaKAeiros
l3ovX.Tai kiynv, ciret tois ye pT^fxacnv ov KaX&s Ac'yei. to
|y ydp (f>r](Ti, " biacf^epofxevov avTo avT^ (Tvix^epiaQai," 5
" &(T7rp apixovCav to^ov t Kal \vpas." fcm 8e ttoAA^
dAoyia apfxovCav (f)dvai hiac^ipicrOaL rj k hi,a<^ipopjiv(tiv ^ti
ivaL. dkXa icrods Tobf ijSovkfTo Kiynv, otl K bLa(f)pofXV(ov
TTpoTepov Tov d^OS Kal ^apios, eTreira varfpov ofxokoyr]- b
crdirrcov yiyovfv vtto ttjs ixova-iKrjs Tixvrjs. ov yap brjiTOV

(K bLa(f>poiXV(t)v ye ^tl tov d^eos Kal fSapios apixovCa av

eiTj" rj ydp app.0VLa a-vfX(f)(avLa iaTLV, avfx^fxovLa 8e ofxokoyLa
TLS ofxoXoyCav 8e e/c bLa(f)(pofXV(ov, eojs dv bLa(f)p(ovTaL, 5
dbvvaTov elvaL' bLa(f)p6p.Vov 8e av Kal fxi] ofxokoyovv dbv-
vaTov dpfioaaL ooaTrep ye Kal 6 pv^fxbs ex tov Tax^os Kal
j3pab4os, e/c bivr]Vyp.V(ov TrpoTcpov, vaTpov 8e dfxoXoyr]- c
o-dyTcoy yyov. ti]v 6e SfxokoyCav TTaaL tovtols, waiT^p
KL ^ laTpLKrf, ivTavdtt rf fxovaLKr] VTC6r]aLV, po)Ta koX
opLovoiav dk\rjko)v efxiTOL-qaaaa' Kal aTLV av fxovaLKr] iTpl
dpfxovCav KoX pvdfxov ipoiTLK&v iTLaTr]fi.r]. koll V fxiv ye 5
avT^ Trf avaTdaL dpp.ovCas T kol pvOfxov ovbV xct^f'"'!' fd
pO)TLKd bLayLyV(oaKLV, Ovde 6 bLTTkovS ipO)S ivTttvdd 770)

iaTLV dAA' eTreiSdi' birf iTpbs tovs dv6p(OTT0vs KaTaxprjadaL

pv6fx<o T Kal dpfiovCq rj iTOLOvvTa, S bi] fxekoTTOLCav KakovaLv, d
T/ \p<afXVOV 6p65)S ToIs TTTTOLr]fxivOLS p.ikaC T K(1L fxiTpOLS,

bif TTaLbeCa Kkr]6r], ivTavda br] Kal xak^TTov Kal dya6ov

brffLLOvpyov Sei. TrdAii' ydp 7/Kei 6 avTos koyos, otl Tolis fXV

KOafXLOLS tG)V dv6p^TT0)V, Ka\ 0)S dv KOafXLC0TpOL yCyvoLVTO 5

01 fXrfTTO) 6vTS, bL yapL^a6aL KOLL (f)VkdTTLV TOV TOijTQ)V

aa fffiiKphv BT : afiiKpif W ci k BTW : om. Vindob. 21

C4 eiA\^Awi/ B: a\\-l)\ois TW o 7 wa> Badham : vus BTW
d2 nirpois BT : f)vdno7s W
iSyd nAATi2N02
epaiTa, koI ovtos ka-Tiv 6 KaXos, 6 ovpavios, 6 ttjs Ovpavias
e ^iova-qs "Epcos' 6 8e YIokvp.vCas 6 TrdvbriiJLos, ov 8et evkalSov-
jxivov TTpoa-(f)pLV ols hv TTpo<T(f)pri, OTTMS av Trjv fxkv r]bovr]v
avTov KapTT(iicrr]Tai,, dKokaa-l.av 8e ixrjbcpLiav e/XTTOiT/o-y/, &aTTip
iv TJj rjfJiCTipa Tiyvr\ /xeya ^pyov Tois TT(pl Trjv o-^oiTOUKriv

5 Ti^^vrfv kTTi,6vp.iai.s KaXQis xprjaOai,, wor' &VV voaov rqv

r]bovr]v KapTTtaaaaOai. kolL iv /lovcriKfj br] Kal iv laTpLKrj
Koi kv ToXs 6XK01.S TTaai. Kal toIs dv6p(tiTTe(oi.s Kal Tois dcCots,
Kad^ oaov TTapeiKeL, (^vXaKT^ov kKaTcpov tov "EpooTa' ^v^arov
188 y^P' ^T^^i- '^ct'
V '^^'^ bipSiV Tov ivLavTov avaTaais ixeaTi]

kcmv d]ji.(f)0Tp(t)v TovTcav, kol iTT^Lbav ]xkv TTpos dXXr]\a tov

Koa]XLOV TV)(r] Ipcoros h vvvbr] eycb iXeyov, Td re 6ep]xd kou.

Ta ^v^pd Kal ^rjpd Kal vypd, kox dp]XOVLav Ka\ KpdaLv kd^r]
5 a(i)(ppova, r]KH (f)ipovTa VTr]pLav re kol vyUiav dv6pu)TT0LS
KciX Tols dWoLS C^^OLS T Kal (f)VTOLS, Kal OvbcV r]bLKr]aiV'
oTav be 6 ]xeTd Tf]S v/Speoos "Epcos iyKpaTiarepos TT(pl Tds
Tov ivLavTov a>pas yivr]TaL, bLi(f)6eLpV re TroAAa Koi -qbLKr^afv.

b OL re ydp X.ol]xoI (f>LkovaL yCyvea^aL eK t&v TOLOVT^av Kal

dkka dvojxoLa TTokkd voar]p.aTa Kal toIs 6r]pCoLS koX toIs
(pVTols' KoX ydp TTdyvai koX ydka^aL kcCl ipvaXfSaL e*c

TTkcove^Cas Kal dKoa]xCas iTcpX dkkqka twv tolovt(i)v yCyvcTaL

5 ip(t)TLKS)V, S)V iiTiaTr]pLr] Trepl daTpoDV re (f)opds Kal ivLavToiv

u>pas daTpovojxCa KakfiTai. eri toCvvv koX al 6vaCaL irao-ai

KoX dis ]xavTiKr] iiTiaTaTel -TavTa 8' eorii' r] TTcpl deovs re

C Ka\ dv^pdiTTOVS TTpOS dkkl^koVS KOiVb)Via OV 7Tp\ dkko tC
ioTLV 7/ Trept "Epcoros (f)vkaKr]V re Ka\ laaiv. iTaaa ydp
daejScLa (f)LkcL yCyvea6ai idv ]xi] tls tS> Koa]xC(a "Epcort

e 4 (pyov rdis B^ T W ^pywvres B e8 TrapeiKei W t irapriKfi

W
: :

BT iveffrov T : tvfCTTov B : %v iarhv a3 Kocrfxiov Bt

Stobaeus : K6<rfiov T A.'7& Stobaeus
iyi} ehfyov'] |r;pa] ra ^rjpa
Stobaeus a 7 irepl] koI irep] Stobaeus a 8 5te<^ejpe(v)
T W Stobaeus Sia<p0fipfi B
: b a TroAAa] Ka\ noWa Stobaeus
b 4 yiyvfTai] yiyvovrai Canter b 5 (popas Stobaeus <popas B W :

W
:

(popas T b6 aj T Stobaeus om. B iraa-ai B Stobaeus &ira<rat

: :

TW b7 iirKrraTft] iirKrrarfl rfxvv Stobaeus C3 dcrejSeia

Stobaeus f) i,<rf$(ia B T
: W
 :

STMnOSION i88c

Xapi^rjrat /xrjSe rifjia re avTov Kal i:pi(T^ivr\ kv "navTi epyw,

aXKa Tov eTcpov, koI irepl yoviai Kal ^cSi^ras koI t(TX.(v- 5

TTjKOTas Kal TTepl Oeovs' h 8?) TTpoariTaKTaL Tjj fiavTLKfj

eTna-K0TT(iv tovs ipwvTas Kal iaTpevuv, koX iaTiv av rj

[xavTLKi] (pikias OeSiV koX avdpooTTcov br]p.Lovpy6s rw eTTi- d

a-Taa-Oai to. KaTO. av6p(oTT0VS epcorixci, ocra TeCvcL iTpos 6epi.LV

Kal eva-ej3(Lav.
OvTcd TToXX7]v Kttl p.ey(xkr]v, /xaAAoy 8e TTa^rav hvva]XLV eyei
(Tv\Xr]fihr]v fjikv 6 ttSs "Epcos, 6 Se Trepi Tayada /^iera a(ti(f)po- 5

(rvvr]s Kal bLKaLoarvvqs a.TTOTekovp.evos Ka\ TTap rjjuv Kal

TTapa 60LS, ovtos rqv ixeyLo-Tr^v bvvafJLLV exet Kal TTaaav r]]iLV

evbaLfxoviav iTapaaKevdCfL Kal dAA.7j\ot? bvvapievovs o/xiXety

Kal (f)LXovs elvaL Kal tols KpcLTToaLV rjfxoiv 6eoLS. tcr^os fiikv

ovv Kal eyo) Tov^EpcoTa kiTaivGiV ttoXXo. TrapaAetTTft), ov fievTOi e

exwy ye. dAA' et rt k^ekLTTov, abv ^pyov, w ^ ApLo-Tocjiaves,

avaTTkrfpSiaaL' rj eX ttcov dAAcos ev v^ ^X^'* ey/cco/itd^ety tov

6e6v, eyKcojuia^e, e-TretS^ Kal Trjs Avyyos TreTraucrat.

'EK8e^dju.eyoy ovv e(f>r] eiTrety tov ^ApLaTo^pdvr] otl Kai 189

/xdA' eTrawaro, ov fxevTOL TTpCv ye tov TTTapfxbv TTpocrevex^rjvaL
avrf], &aT fxe ^aujud^eir ei to KocrfXLOv tov acafxaTos ttl-
6vfXL TOLOVT(tiv -^o^fxiiv Ka\ yapyakLafx&v, oXov Kal 6 iTTappiSs
ioTLV TTavv yap v6vs kiTavaaTo, eTretSrj avrw rbv Trrapfxbv 5
TTpoaifveyKa.
Kai Tbv ^Epv^Lfxaxov, ^lya6, cfidvaL, ^ApLorocfiaves, opa
t( Trotety. ycAcoroTrotets //.eAAcoy Xeyeii', Kal (fivkaKd fxe tov
koyov dyay/cdfei? yCyvea^aL tov aeavTov, idv tl yekoXov b
erTrrjs, i^ov aoL iv eip-qvrf keycLV.
Kai roj; ^ApLaT0(f)dirr] yekdaavra e^iretv Ev Aeyeis,
C 5 rhv Stobaeus irepl rhv B T W
C 6 vpocrrfTaitTai B T W
W
:

vpoTfraKrai Stobaeus C7 ^poSrros Stobaeus ^puras 3T: roi/s ;

ipwras secl. Hermann

a 8 Svvafj.fvovs .
d 3 (va4fieiav Stobaeus affefitiav B T
<pl\ovs B T
. W
Stobaeus (sed ex Svvdfxfvos fecit T)
.
: W
a 7 &yadf <f>(ii/ai TW : &yadf <pavai &yajdt B
 :

iSgb nAATHNOS
'Epu^t/xaxej KaC \xol tcrTdo appr]Ta to. dprjixeva, aXka ^i] /xe

5 <f)ij\aTT, 0)? eyo) ^o/SoCjiiai Trepl tw ix(X\6vT(av pr^dria-eadai,

ov TL p.r] yekoLa tiTTO) tovto /xei' yap hv Kfphos eir; /cai r^s
r]iiiTipas iMov(rr]s ii^LyjiiipLOV aXKa jjlt] KaTay\a(rTa.
Bak(av ye, (f>dvaL, S 'ApL(rT6(f)aves, oUl (K(f)ev$((T6aL'

aXXa irp6(reyje tov vovv Kal ovruis Acye wy b(aa<x>v \6yov.

C icr(t)s piivTOL, hv 8o'^t/ //ot, d^^crco o-e.

Kat /A^i;, oj ^Epv^LfJLax^e, elTrelv tov ^ApL(rTO(f>dvr], &kXr]

yk irr] iv v^ e;(a) Ae'yeiy r] q crv t Kal Hav(ravLas ei7reVr/r.

e/Aol yap boKOvcrLV av6p()7roL iravTdiraaL Tr]v tov ipooTos

5 bvva]iLV ovK ri(r6r]cr6aL, eiret alcr6av6]iVOL ye ]iiyL(rT av
avTov iepa KaTacrKevdcraL kol /3o)/xovs, Kat 6vcrLas hv Trotetv

fjLfyLcrTas, ou^ uxntfp vvv tovt(jov ovbev yCyveTaL irepl avrdv,

biov TtdvTiav /xdtAtora yLyve(r6aL. ((ttl yap 6iG>v (fnkav-

d ^p^ji-noTaTos, iiTLKOvpos re cov t&v dv6p(aTT(t)v Kal laTpbs

TOVToov S)v la64vT(>)v ]XyL(rrr] fvbaL]iovLa hv T(a dv6p(t)T:L<a
yivL eirj. eyo) oSi TrLpd(ro]xaL vpXv lcrr]yq(ra(r6aL Tr]V

bvvajiLV avTOv, v/xet? 8e t&v dkkcov bLbdaKakoL (rcrd.

5 8et 8e Trpwroi; v/xas ]xa6LV Tr]v dv^pcoiTLvr^v (f)ij(riv Kal tcl

Tta^r^pLaTa avrrjs. rj yap TidkaL r]]X(av ^v(rLS'ov\ avrr] ^v

qirep vvv, dkk^ dkkoCa. TrpooTov ]XV yap Tpia r]V Ta yivr]

TCL T&v dv^p^aTTOov, ovx^ w^riTep vvv bvo, &ppV /cat ^rjkv,

e dkka KOL TpLTOV TTpO(rr]V KOLvbv OV d]X(f)OTpO)V TOVTCOV, ov

vvv ovofxa koLTTdv, avTo be ^(f>dvL(rTaL' dvbpdyvvov yap ly
t6t ]xkv -qv KOL etSos Kal ovofxa ef d]X(f>OTp(t)v KOLvbv tov
T dppevos KOL 6r]kos, vvv 8e ovk (rTLV dAA' rj kv dvLbL
5 SvO]Xa KLp.VOV. ilTeLTa okoV ^V KdcrTOV TOV dv6p(i)TtOV Tb

b5 prie-fi<Teff0tti TW : firrvB-fifftffeai B (sed rjr extra versum) : ^Srj

p7}e^ffeffeai Rettig O4 &v0p(i)iroi Bekker : &pep<Diroi BT : 01

&vepuTroi W d4 ffffff0e B effeff0ai T B d6 avrii : aSrij T

W W
:

Eusebius
avri) ^v B T om.
; d 7 irpuTov B T irpwra
W
:
Ti

d8 T& rwv B T rwv W Eusebius Stobaeus e 2 |j/ B : om. T

W
:

Eusebius Stobaeus e 4 Ir ivfiSfi T ^v iv etSft B :

 STMnOSION iSge

1809 (TTpoyyvkov, v&tov ml Trkfvpas kukXo) ^xov, x^lpas

8e TeTTapa^ f'x^' '''*' o-K\r} to. ta-a rats \(p(rLv, koL TTpoa-uiTra

bv eir' avyivi KVKXoTep^l, ofxoia irayTTj* Ke<f)akr]v 8' 7r' igo

aix(j)OTpoi.s Tots -TTpocrwTrois ivavTLOLs KdiJLivoLS [xCav, Kal
S)Ta TiTTapa, KaX alboXa bvo, KaX TaXXa TiavTa cos diro

TOVTOov av TL9 dKd(TLev. iTTopiViTo 8e Kal 6p6ov &<n:(p

vvv, oTTOTepcocrc ^ovXy]6dr]' koX cmoTe Tayy opfxrjcTeLev delv, 5
uKTTTep OL kvI3i(ttS>vt9 Kal eis 6p6bv tcl cTKeXr) irepi^epo'-

pLCVOL KV^LarGi(TL KVKkca, OKTO) t6t ova-i Toty ixeXea-LV

aTTepeLhofxevoL Taxv (j)povTo kukAm. ^v 8e 8ia TauTa TpCa

TCL yivr) kol TOLavra, otl to p.V appev ^v tov tjKlov ttjv b
dpx^y iKyovov, To 8^ 6rjXv t^s yrjs, t6 8e dfX(f)OTp(DV p.Tyov
T^s (TeATjyTjs, Sti Kai r] a-ekrjvri dfx^OTep^av /xeTe'xei' TTpL(f)pr]

8e 877 7J1'
Kai avTa Kat 57 TTopeia avTcov 8ta t6 toXs yoveva-LV

ofxoui LvaL. Tfv ovv Ttfv i(Tyyv hLvd KOL rqv pcafxr^v, Kal 5

Ta (f)povr]fxaTa fxeydka etxov, ktTeyeCprfcrav 8e Tots ^eot?,

Kai 6 Ae'yet "Ofxrfpos irept 'E^tdATou t Kal "Q.tov, Trept

KLVO)v keyeTai, t6 ets t6v ovpavov dvdjSaaLV TTL\Lplv

TTOLeLV, WS TTL6r](T0fXV())V TOtS ^eotS. 6 OVV ZeVS Kai 01 C
dAA.01 deot k^ovkevovTo otl xPV o-^tovs iTOLrja-aL, Kal rfno-

pOVV 0VT ydp OTT(t)S dlTOKTLVaLV LXOV KOL &a"lTp ToivS

yiyaVTas Kpavv(aaavTs to yivos d^avL(raLv at Tiji>toi

ydp avTols Kal iepd rd Trapd t&v dv6p(aTT(t)V -q^j^aviCeTO 5

ovT 0TT(t)S ^v daekyaLveLV, jfxoyLS 8t) d Zevs ei^i^oT^o-as

" Aokw
^X^'^ fxrwavrfv, &)? dv elev
*
Ae'yet oTt /xoi," e<^?j,

T 6.v6poi)TTOL Kal TTOva-aLVTO Tr]S dKokaaias da-devearepoL

yv6fXVOL. vvv fXV ydp ovtovs, i<f>r], 8iaTe/x{ii) 8txci ^Ka^rTOv, d
Kat dfxa fXV da-^evearepoL eaovTUL, dfxa 8e yjpr]aLp.(aTpoL

T}fXLV 8td t6 TTkeiovs t6v dpLdfxdv yeyovivaL' Kal (SabLovvTaL

a 5 0*41' B Stobaeus 4\$(7v T W a7 oKTi) rire B r6r( oKri)

W a8
: :

T: oKTCtf a8 kvk\(i> om.

. air(pfiS6f*.(yoi TW : fiirep (IB6-
BW
. .

/xfyoi B b2 a/Ji<por(puv afi(j>6r(poy T b7 re Kal BT

W
:

W
:

Ktd 03,4 aTOKr(iv(i(v . . . a<f>avi(r(i(v C 5 yap (&) Ast

ipA BT W To lepo Stobaeus C7 ?(^7> ?x*"' ^T (xtiv W
:

W
:
^<l>r)

c8 iv6pwiroi Voegelin : &vdpci)iroi BT

 :

igod nAATflNOS
6p6ol eTTt bvoiv (TKeXolv. cav 6' ^rt boKQcnv a(re\yaiveiv
5 Kal [xri 'dcKotia-Lv r]a-v\iav ayeiv, TraAiy av, l(/)rj, Tejxu) btxa,
locTT ((\) kvos iTopV(rovTaL (TKikovs ao-KtoXia^oi^res." Tavra
(iTTaiV Tp.V Tovs CLvOpdoTTOvs bCxcL, w(nTp ol TCL 6a re/x-

e vovTS Kal /xeAAoyres TapiyiVHV, rj uxntep ol tol wa rai?

OpL^Lv ovTLva 8e re/xot, tov ^AttoWco e/ce'Aeuey t6 re
iTp6(T(>)TTov fXTaa-Tp(f)HV Kal To Tov av\4vos i]p.L(rv TTpos

Trjv TOfxrjv, Lva 6(apLevos Trjv avTOv Tprj^TLv Kojr/xtwre/aos

5 etr/ 6 av6p(t)TT0s, Kal raAAa lacrdaL KXVV. 6 8e t6 re

TTp6a-0)TT0V p.T(rTp(^, KoiX (JVVXK(i)V TTaVTa)(66V TO bipfia
Tt\ Trjv yaoripa vvv KaXovpivr]v, wo-Trep tcl avaTTaaTa
^aXXavTLa, kv (rT6p.a ttol&v aTTcbeL Kara pi.ar]v rrjv yaaTpa,
o 8t/ tov 6pi.(^aXov KaXovai. kcll tcls p.V aAAas pvTLbas
igi Tcis TToAAas e^eAeati^e Kat ra a-Tr\6r\ bLr\p6pov, ^xoov tl

TOLOVTov opyavov olcv cl aKVTOTopoL TTepl Tov KaXaTToba

XaCvOVTS TCLS T&V O-KVT&V pVTtbaS' oXCyas b KaTXLTT,
TCLS TTp\ avTr]v Tr)v yaaTpa Koi tov 6p.(f)aX6v, p.vrjp.^lov

5 etyat Tov TraAatou TTa6ovs.\ eiretST) ovv rj (f)vaLS bL^a

Tp.ri6r], TTO^ovv KaaTov to ^jjLLav to avTov avv^t, Kal
Trept/SaAAoyres tcls x^^P^^ '^^^ (tv]xttXk6p.Vol aXXr]XoLs,
ttl6vixovvtS crvp.(\)VvaL, aiT6vr]aKov vtto Xl]xov Kal Tr]s

b ^AArjs apytas bia t6 fxr]bv 6iXiv X())pls aXk-qXcov ttollv.

Kal oTToVe rt aTTo6Avoi tG)V rjfxLaeoiv, to 6e XL(\)6Lr], to
Xi(f)6v aXXo e^^ret Kat (TweTrAeKero, etre yvvaLKos Trjs

SXrjs VTv\oL rffXLa-i o br] vvv yvvaiKa KaXovpLV etre

5 avbp6s' Kal ovto)s aTT(aXXvvTO. eXerfaas 8e 6 Zevs aAATjy

fxrfxavrfv TTopL^TaL, Ka\ fXTaTi6rfaLV avTutv tcl albola eis

d4 S' ert Stobaeus Se rt BT W d5 OeXuxnv B Stobaeus

W
:

40e\w(nv T ide\ov(rtv: d 6 a<rKoi\i<lCovTes W : a(rKOi>\'t(ovTes BT

d7 oa Ruhnken ex Timaeo wh W e
s. v. : Stobaeus : wta BT i 01
T W Stobaeus om. B 64 W e 8 ^aWdvrta T eeS/jLevos
$a\dvrta W
: :

$d\\ovra B : a Ka\diroSa T BW 2 Ka\6iroSa

T W Stobaeus
:

a6 ^vvpet B a8 B rov
: T
^uveTvai AtjUoO : \i/jlov
Stobaeus: t^sAi^oCW b^ SijvvtrBT: /xijSeW bs airtiWvvro
T W airoWvvro B
:


STMnOSlON igib

To npoa-Qev Tecos yap koX ravra e/croj eixoy, Kal kyivvoiv

KoX eTLKTOv ovK (Is aWrjkovs dAA.' ets yrjv, uta-iTcp ol t^t- C
riyes p.iTi6riKi re ovv ovto) avT&v eis t6 irpocrOiv Koi
hia TovToov TT}v yivi<Tiv kv ahXrfkoLS (noCrja-ev, bta tov
appivos (V rw drik(L, T&vbe ^viKa, tva kv rfj o-d/xttAo/ct)

ap.a p.V ei avr}p yvvaLKi. kvT^yoL, yevvQiv Kal yiyvoLTo to 5

yivos, ap.a 8' ei kol appr]v appVL, i:Xr](rp.ovr] yovv yiyvoLTO
TTJs (Tvvova-ias Kal bLa-navoLVTo Kal eTrt to. epya TpinoLVTo
Ka\ Tov aWov /3iot; eTri/uieAorvro. iaTL hr] ovv e/c too-ov
6 (p(os pi(f)VTos aXKrjKodV rois av6p(aTT0LS Kal ttjs ap)(aias d
(f>V(r(os avvayody^vs Kal kiiLyj^LpSiV TTOLrjaaL kv e/c bvolv Kal
IdaaadaL ttjv (f)vaLv t7]V avOpoiTrivr^v. ^KacrTos ovv rjix(av

ioTLV avdp(oTrov avpL^oKov, aT rer^jj/jieyo? &(nTp al v/^T/rrai,

e^ kvos bvo' C^rei br] det t6 avrov (KacrTos arvp.^o\oVt 5

00-01 p.\v ovv T&v avbpG)V tov kolvov Tfxrip.a da-LV, 6 br]

TOTe avbpoyvvov eKaAetro, (pLX.oyvvaLKes re eicrt Kat ot

-TToAAoi Ta>v pLOL\(av e/c tovtov tov yivovs ycyovacTLV, /cat

oo-ai av yvvaLKfs (\)iKavbpoi re Kat iiOLyjiVTpLaL (k tovtov e

Tov yevovs yiyvovTaL. oaaL be t&v yvvaLK<av yvvaLK^s
Tp.rnxa ila-LV, ov -naw aSrat rots avbpaaL t6v vovv Ttpoa-
i\ova-Lv, dAAa \mXkov -np^s Tas yvvalKas TTpap.[Ji4vaL

elai, Kal al (TaLpiaTpLaL eK tovtov tov yivovs yiyvovTai. 5

ocrot 8e appevos Tjxrjjjid eto-t, tcl appeva bL(aKovcrL, Kat recos

fxfv hv TraiSey S<ny, fire re/ixdYta oyra tov &ppvos, ^tAovo-i

Tovs avbpas Kal \aipovaL avyKaTaKcifxevoL Kal orv/btTreTrAe-

ypUvoL rots dvbpdcrL, Kai etcrti' ovroi ^ikTLOTOL t&v Traibcov 192
Kal fxeLpaKioiv, &t drSpetoVarot wres (f)TucrL. (^ao-t 8e brj

TLVS avTovs dvaicrxiSvTovs etyai, -^^vbojxcvoL' ov yap irn

C 2 ouTwi/ B : avrwv T W : oS Schanz irp6(r9ev BT W : envpotrBfv

Stobaeus C3 yfvea-tv] yevvr)(Tiv Vermehren 5iet. . . 0ii\fi secl.
Jahn c 5 ri B T cJel. W : HppTjv B T
Usener c6
Hppfv W :

al.Stobaeus d 5 Sii B T 8f eKaaroi T : eKaarov BW W

W
:

Stobaeus e z ywaiKhs B T yvvaiKwv 65 0/ B T om. :

W W
:

Stobaeus e 6 Tew j B T Stobaeus em Ast :

PLATO, VOL. II. 12

192 a nAATHNO^*
avaLcr^vvTias tovto bp&a-tv dAA' vtto Oappovs koX avbpeias
5 Kttl appevMTTlas, to 6p,oLov avTols a(nta(6yi.voi.. [xiya 8e
j TeKp.r\pi.ov' Ka\ yap reAeco^eyres iwvoi aTto^aivova-iv ets

Ta tioXltiko. avbpes ol tolovtol, iiTet.bav 6e civbpcoOSta-i,,

b waiSepaoToucri xai Trpos ydjuous koI TraLbomotias ov Ttpoa--

iyova-L tov vovv ^ucret, dAA' vtto tov vopLOV avayKaCovTaL'

dAA' f^apKet avTols /u.er' dAAT^Acoy KaTaCrjv aydpiOLs. 'ndvTcos

fjikv ovv 6 TOLovTos TTaiSe/oaoTT/s re Kat ^tAepaor^? yiyyerat,

5 det ro 0-uyyei'es' aa-naCoix^vos. oTav fikv ovv Kot avrw
Kiv(^ VTV)(r) T(a avTov Tjixia-eL Kat 6 TraLbepaaTrjs Kal
aAAos TTCLS, t6t Kal 6avp.aa-Ta ^KirX.-qTTovTaL (^iAia re Kat
C otKetorTjri Kat epcort, oiiK i64kovTes o)S ^ttos eiTrety X^P'-'
feo-^at dAAT/Ao)!; ovbe a-p.LKpov xpovov. Kal ol StareAoOi^res
fxeT dWrikcov 8ta ^tou oilrot ela-LV, o% ovb^ hv eyoLev eiTreiy

ort ^ovXovTaL a-^ia-i Trap' dAA?/Acov yiyvea-6aL. ovbevX

5 yap hv bo^eLev tovt' elvat r) t5)v d(ppobLai(t)v crvvovaia, b)S

dpa tovtov eveKa ^Tepos eTepoi yaCpeL (rvvu)v ovT(t)s e77t

IJ.eydX.rjs (nrovbrjs' dAA' dAAo rt fiovXoixevr) eKarepov r} \}/V)(r}

d br]ki] eo-Tiv, 6 ov bvvaTaL etTretr, dAAa p.avTeveTaL o /3ov-

Aerat, Kat atvtrrerat. Kai et avrots ev r p,vT(^ KaTaKeL-
fxevoLS eTTLo-Tas 6 H0ato-ros, e)(0)v to. opyava, epoLTO' " Tt
eV^' o ^ovkecrde, u) dv6p(i)TT0L, vjjuv Trap' dXXrjX^DV yeve-
5 a-daL;" Kal ei dTTopovvTas avTovs TrdAty epoiTO' *"Apd ye
rouSe eTTt^D/xetre, er roi avrw yevecrdaL otl p.dXLa-Ta dAA?/-
Aots, wo-re Kai vvKTa koX r}jj.epav p.r] dTToXeLTrecrdaL dAA?/-
Atoy; et yap roijTov eTTt^v/Aetre, ^eAo) v/xds o-vvTrj^aL Kal
e (rviJL(f)va-^a-aL ets ro avro', wo-re 8v' ovras ei^a yeyovevai
Koi e(t)S T av C^re, ws eVa ovTa, KOLvfj dpi(j)OTepovs C^v,y
KoX etTeLbdv dTTo6dvr\Te, eKet av ev "AtSou dyrt bvolv eva
elvat KOLvfj Te6veS)Te' ak)C bpaTe ei tovtov epcLTe Kal

7 b eKirK^firroyrai T : W
eKirXi]rrovra B c 4 ouSf'! Stobaeus :

oiiSev BTW: ouSe scr. recc. c6 xa'pfTW: xa'P"' B d6 ori

. . .d.7 aiToXelvecrdai om. W
d8 ^eAco B WXo) T avvrri^ai
: W
B T : evrfi^ai W 6 (rv/x^pvarjffai B T
i frvtx.<\>v(rai b t W 6 2 f^re
:

wj T W : iririiffeus B

STMnOSION 192 e

i^apKfl vfXLv av tovtov TV-)(i]Ti" TavT aKovaas l(T\iiv otl 5

ov6' h.v cts (^apvrjOeCrj ov8' aX\o tl h.v (})avLri ^ovX6p.evos,

aAA' drexi^ws ototT' hv aKrjKodvaL tovto o TrdA.ai apa tt(-

6vp.il, a-vvekOcbv Kal avvTaKds tw piop.V(o k bvolv cty

yivia-Qai. tovto yap eo-Ti to oiTiov, otl t) apyaia (pva-LS

i)p.S)V Tfv avTr] Kal ^p.iv oAot* tov okov ovv Tr\ ciTLOvp.Lq 10
fcat 8i<o^t Ipcos ovop.a. Kal npo tov, wo-Trep kiya), ^v 193
ripifv, WVL 8e 8td rqv abLKLav bL<oKLa-dr}p.v vtto tov dfov,
KaBainp 'A/)Kd8es vtto AaKebaLpoviayv <p6^os ovv ((ttlv,
eav p.r] K6a-p.L0L S)p.V iTpos tovs Oeovs, ottcos p.r} Kal avdLS
hLaa-\Ladr]a-6pe6a, kol TT(pLLp.ev ^xovtcs u)a-TTp oi iv Tals 5

(TTT/Aats KaTaypa(f)r]v KTtvtto)p.4vol, bLaTTeiTpLa-p.VOL KaTo.

Tas plvas, ycyov^Tes &aTTp kLa-iraL. '

aKKa tovtoov VKa

TTavT avbpa \pr] aTTavTa TTapaKXeva6aL Vcr^LV irept

dovs, tva To. p.v K<f>vy(j)p.V, T&v 8e TV)(0)pLv, 0)9 6 "Kpoos b

7]p.LV r]yp.ODV Kal a-TpaTr]y6s. w p.r]bls kvavTLa TTpaTTTO)
Trpdrret 8' kvavTia ootls dcols a.TTx6(xvTaL (^tAot yap
yv6p.V0L Kai StaAAayeyTCs tw ^eoi ^vpr]aop.V t Kal
VTV^6p.da Tols TTaLbLKOLS TOLS r]p.Tp0LS aVTO)V, h T&V VVV 5

oAtyot 7rotoo-t. Kat p.r] p.0L viToXa^r] ^Epv^Lp.axos, KOi)p.(ob&v

Tov k6yov, u)s rTauo-ai^taj; Kat ^Aya6(t)va Aeyto ta-u)s p.v

yap Kal ovtol tovto)v TvyyavovaLV 6vts KaC eto-tf ap.(f)6Tpoi C

Tr]v <f)vaLV appVs Aeyoj 8e ovv yo)y Ka6^ aiTavToov Kal
avbpStv KaX yvvaLK&v, otl ovto)s hv rjp.&v to yeroj eiJSatjuoi'

ycVOLTO, et KTkaaLpV TOV ^pO)Ta Kal t5)V iraLbLKOiV t6v

avTov KaaTos tvxol ets Tr]V apyaCav aiTk6o)V (f)vaLV. l 5
8e TovTo apLaTov, avayKdLov Kal t&v vvv 7cap6vTO)v to
TovTov yyvTix.To) apLaTov eiyaf tovto 8' eort TratStKwy rvxi^v

e6 li\\o ri B : li\\o Sri TW 67 tovto &] rov ov Badham

e 9 Tovro] TovTov Bast a 5 Sia(rxKT0ri<r6iJ.e6a T 8o(rx;(rff7j(rw- W :

fj.(0a B a 6 KaTaypa<l>i]v B T Karaypaip^ Schneider W Karh. :

W
:

ypa<piiv Ruhnken 5iaireirpi(rfj.evoi T htavfKpi\<rti(voi B b x ci>s

W fwv T W
:

BT : S)v recc. b 6 ^ot B : 05 rvxoi BT : rvxv W

C 6, 7
rovTov
tJ
B
. . . iyyvrdru B T ry : . . . iyyvTdrif) W C 7 rovro TW :

12*
193 c nAATilNOS
Kara vovv avrw TTeef^vKOTiov' ov bij tov alTiov Oebv vixvovvTes
d 6iKat6)S av vfivoiixev "Epcdra, os ev re rai irapovTi rjfjias

TrXetfrTa 6vCvrj(riv eis to oiKelov ay(av, Kal ds to CTretra

ekTrCbas /xeytoTa? 7rape'xerai, r}iJ.&v Ttapeyop.^vcav irpos ^eovs

(V(re^Lav, KaTacTricras rjjxas eis r^i apyaiav (\>v(nv kolI

5 tao-a/xeyos naKapiovs KaX vhai\xovas iroirja-ai.

OvTos, f<f)ri, S) 'Epu^t/xaxfj 6 e/x6s Ao'yos eo-ri Trept

"EpoiTos, dAAotoy rj 6 (tos. uxnrep ovv fberiOrfv (tov, ixrj

koo/awSt/o-tjs avTov, tva Kal t&v XolttS>v aKova-(i)iXV Ti (Kaa-Tos

e epet, ixaXkov 8e ri eKcirepos' 'Ayd^coj; yap Kal Sa)Kpd7Tjs
XoiTTOt.

'AAAd TTeicoixai (toi, i<f)ri (fxxvaL tov ^Epv^iixaypv koX

y&p ixoL 6 koyos r}bi(os fppriOri. kol et ixri a^vvybri Sco-

5 KpaTiL re Kat 'Ayd^covi Seti^ots ovo-t Trepl rd kpuiTLKa, Tt6,vv

h.v (f)o(3oviJi.riv ixr} aTroprjcr^aa-L Xoycov 8td t6 "TToAAd Kai

Trai^roSaTrd elpfja-daL' vvv 8^ op,a)y 6appQ.
194 Tbv ovv ^(aKpdTri etireti' KaAws ydp avrbs riy(oVLa-ai,

S) 'Epv^i/ixax^e* et 8e yivoLo ov vvv eyw et/utt, /idAAoy 8e

ta(i)s oS lo-ojiAat eTretSdy Kat ^Ayddatv e?7rrj eS, Kai p,dA' dy

(f)ofioXo Kal kv TravTl etrjs <2o-7rep eycb vvv.

5 <J>ap/xdrretv /3ovAet jw.e, o) SwKpares, etTreii' rdi^ 'Ayd^coya,

tya dopv^riQS) 8td rd oieo-^ai to OiaTpov TTpoaboKiav ixeydXriv
exety wy ev epowros e/ix.oi;.

'E7rtA7jo-/jtft)i; p.VTh.v etriv, S) 'AydO(av, etireti' rdy So)-

b KpdTri, et i8ft)y r^i; crrji' dvbpeiav Kal ixyaXo(f)poarvvriv

dva^aivovTos ttI Tbv oKpijSavTa ixcto. t&v vttokplt&v, kcCl

l3Xi\fravTos kvavTia ToaovTio OedTpcd, ixiXXovTos iTTLbei^caOaL

cravTov X.6yovs, Kal ou8' dirft^o-rtoSy kKirKayivTos, vvv
6 oiriOeiriv ae Oopv^ricrecrOaL ev(Ka rjjx&v 6X.iy(t)v dv6p(iiTT(i)V.

d I TfTW: om. B d^ d\\o?osTW: a\\'o7osB e6 iirop^fi'

(TttxnT W
airopiiffOD B
: a 2 oS vvv T 01; vvv B a 3 Jfcws 01; W
W
:

T ta-ws ov B ov iffus Schanz post e5 dist. Vahlen b a oKpt-

W
: :

fidvra T W aKpiPavra B
: b 3 ^7rSe(|6(T0a4 B iiriSfl^affOai T :

b s eopvP-fiffeffOai T W
Oopv&rteiiffiffBai B:
 STMnOSION I94b

Tt 8e, (b Sw/cpares; tov ^Ayddctiva <pdvat, ov brjiTov jxe

ovTOi Oedrpov \x(TTov rjyf] u)<tt /cat dyvoHV oti vovv i\ovTi.
oKCyoL ix(})poves ttoXXQv d(f)p6voov </)o/3epcorepoi;
Ov ixevTav /caAajy iTOLOLrjv, (f)dvai, u) 'Aydd(av, ircpl (tov c
TL iyo) dypoLKov bo^d^cov dAX' ev ot8a ort et rio-ti' (VTVxpLS
oifs fjyoLo (ro(f>ovs, fxdWov dv avTu^v ^povTi^oLS rj t&v
TToKX&v. dXXd pLi] ov;( ovrot ijpieXs utfxev rjp.^ls pikv ydp
Kal KL TTaprjpiev Kal 'qp.V twv TTokkS)v et Se aAAots 5
ei^rv^ots (ro</)ots, rcix' dv aio^vroto avrovs, ei ri to-cos

OLOio al(rxpov ov iTOLeLV' rj tt&s Aeyety;

'Akr]drj Ae'yet9, (f)dvaL.

Tovs 8e TToAAovy ovk dv ala^vvoto ei rt ototo ato^poy

TTOLClv; 10

Kat Tov ^albpov i(f)r\ viroXa^ovTa etTreti' 'H ^tAe d

^Aydd(i)v, kdv aTTOKpCvr] 2coKpciret, ovbev ^tl 8totcret auroi
OTTrjovv T&v evddbe otlovv yiyv^crdaL, idv piovov XV ^'''^

StaAeyrjrat, aAAco? re Kat KaAw. eyco 8e rjb^cos /xey aKovd)

^(OKpdTovs bLaX.yopiivov, dvayKalov be p.0L (TTip.Xr]dr]vaL 5

Tov eyK(i)p.Lov rw "Epcort Kat aTTobd^a^rdaL TTap* kvbs kKd(rTov
vp.S>v Tov Xoyov aTTobovs ovv eKcirepos rai ^eoi ovt(ds 'tjbr]

bLaXy4(rd(t).

'AAAa KaAois Ae'yets, w 4>at8pe, <f)dvai tov 'Ayd6o)va, e

Kai ovbev p. K(t)XvL XiyLV ScoKpciret ydp Kal av6is crTaL

TToXXdKLs 8taAe'yeo-^at.

'Eyo) 8e 8^ (3ovXop.aL ttp&tov /xey etTreiy w? xprj p, etireij;,

1TLTa llTLV. boKOVCTL ydp pLOL TTdvTS ol TTp6(rdV lpr]K6TS 5

ov Tov 6ov yK(t)p.LdC(LV dXXci TOVS dv6p(aTT0VS vbaLpLOVLC(lV
tS)V dyad&v S)v d 6os avTois oltlos' ottoIos 8e rts ovtos u)v
TavTa eScopTjo-aro, ovSety ipr]KV. ets 8e TpdiTos 6p6bs iTavTos 195
TTaLVov irept iTairr^s, X6y(p SteA^ety otos oicor airtos (bv

c6 iffwi secl. Schanz ircoj Usener ct tv secl. F. A. Wolf

W
:

C 9 ototo T otoiro B e 4 is B T W vulg. a i opObs B

W
: :

W
jT :

om. T a2 oTs o'ia>v ex emend. T : ofoy i^f BT

I95a nAATilNOS
Tvyxavei. irepl ov av 6 Aoyos 17. ovtm bij tov "KponTa Kal
rjixas biKaLov knaivicrai Ttp&Tov avrov olos kcrTiv, eTretra

5 Tas SoVety. (\>r]}xi ovv iyoi it&vTUiV d^Giv evbatixovuiv ovtoov

"FipMTa, ci ^ejuts Kat avepiecrrjTOv (lirelv, evbaipt.ovi(TTaTov
elvat avT&v, KaWta-Tov ovTa Kal aptcrTov. eoTt 8e /cdAAicrros
oiv rotoVSe. TrpoiTov fxev vewTaTos Oeoiv, S <I>at8pe. fie'ya

b 8e TeKfxrjptov tco Aoyo) avTos Trape^erat, (pevyuiv (fivyfj t6

yijpas, Ta)(y ov brjXov OTf OaTTov yovv tov beovTos rjfxtv

TrpoaepxeTaL. o brj 7re(f)VKev "Epcos fxtcrelv /cat ovb^ evTos

TToWov TrXricrtdCetv. ixeTct be veoiv dei crvvecrTt re Kal ecTTtv

5 6 yap TTakatbs Adyoy ev e)(^et, ws ofxotov d/ioto) det TreAd^et.

eyo) 8e ^atbpco TroAAa dAAa ofxokoySiV tovto ov\ 6p.oXoyQ>,
d)s "E/jcos KpoVou fcai 'laTrerou apxatorepos ecTTtv, akka
C ^i]fxt veuiTaTov avTov eXvat deS>v koX det veov, to. be TraXata
TTpdyixaTa Ttepl deovs, a *Ho-to8os KOt TIapixevtbr]s keyovcrtv,
'AvdyKr] Kal ovk "E/xort yeyovevat, et eKetvot dX.r]0rj eXeyov
ov yap h.v eKTop.ctt ovbe becrp.oX aKXr]X(iiv eyiyvovTo Kot aXXa
5 TToAAd KOLt ^iata, ei "^pois ev avTots ^v, dXXa cfitXia Kot
elpr]vr], &cr'nep vvv, e^ ov "Epw? TUiV OeuiV (SacnXevet. veos
piev ovv eo-rt, Trpds 8e ro) veio aTraXos' TiotriTov 8' eo-rti^

d evber]s olos r]V "Op.rjpos Trpds rd eTrtSet^at Oeov diraXoTr^Ta.

"Op.rfpos ydp "ATr]v 6e6v re' (fir](riv eTvat Kal aTcaX-qv tovs
yovv "nobas avTrjs aTraXovs elvat Xeyoov
Trjs ixevO' aTTaXol TTobes' ov ydp eTr' ovbeos

5 TTiXvaTat, dAA' dpa 77 ye Kar dvbpatv KpdaTa (3aivei.

KaAb) ovv do/cei piot TeKixr]pi(a Tr]v diTaXoTr^Ta diTO^fiaiveiv,

drt ovK eiTt (TKXr^pov jSaivet, dAA' eiTt ixaXOaKov. rai avTco

ha tv Ti W : o5v T b3 epws T W : fpwTos B oiS' ivrhs Sto-

baeus: ou SSyros B: ovS' 6vtos TW b^ irXrifftd^eiv TW Stobaeus :

ir\ri<na.C(i B eo-Tj'] ecTTi v4os Sauppe taTai Diels C2 jrpo-

W Stobaeus
:

y/tara T : ypd/xfiaTa B KapnfviStis T W : irap/xevflSris B

d3 ehai BTW: Stobaeus
(jytia-tv flvat d^ ttjs BT W Stobaeus
W Homeri
:

Tfi Aristarchus Homeri codices (T 92) otSfos BT ovSft

W
:

codices d5 iriKvaTat et ex iriSvaTai T : TrriSvaTai B d 7 t^

avT^ TW Stobaeus : tJ> oiitJ B
 2TMn02ION iQSe

brf Kal j^ixcls ^prjcrofxcOa T^Kjxi^pLio irepX "Epcora ort a7raA.os. e

ov yap 776 yr/? {SaCvet ovb^ eirl KpaviMV, ci icTTtv ov iiavv
liaXaKa, aAA' ev roi? /xaA.aKft)r(irois t&v ovT(av koX ^aivei
Ka\ oIk^Z iv yap ijdea-t Kal \l/vxaXs Oe&v Kal avdpcaTTUiv ttjv
otKr]a-LV LbpvTai, Kal oiK av k^rjs ev TTao-ais rats xj/vxcuSi dAA' 5
j^iyt hv a-Kkr]pbv i]dos exova-j] fVTVXJ], aTiipyeTai, f]
8' hv
^xaXaKov, otKi^erai. a.TTTop.evov ovv det koI ttoo-Iv Kal TravTr]

kv fJLaKaKWTaTOLs Tutv jj.aXaK(OTdT(i)v, aTiaK(aTaTov avdyKr]

elvaL. v(i>TaTos ]Ji.ev bi] ia-Tt /cai d7raA()raro?, Trpbs be 196
TOVTOLs vypbs Tb et8os. ov yap av olos t ^v TrdvTr] Trept-

7TTva-a-(rdaL ovbk bia Trdcrrys ^l/vxrjs Kal (iatoiv to irpatTov

kav6dvLV Kal i^L(i)v, et a-Kkqpbs tjv. avix]JiiTpov 8e Kat
vypas ibias fxeya TK]xr]pLov rj iV(ryr]p.o(Tvvr], bi] 8ta- 5

(f)ep6vT(t)S (K TrdvT(t)V dfxokoyovfxiv^tiS^Fipoiis exf da)(i]jxocrvvr]

yap Kal "Ep^oTt Trpbs dAA^Aovs dcl TroAe/xoy. XP^^^ ^^

/cdAAo? 7/ /car' dvdrj 8tatra tov 6(ov a-r]]xaLVL' dvav6ei ydp
Kal dTTr]v6r]K6TL /cat crcrf/xart Kat ^vxi] Kal dAAcj) 6t(oovv ovk b
ertfet "Epois, ov 8' dv vav6r]s re /cat evco^rjs t6ttos f],

ivTav6a 8e Kai i^et Kai /xeVet.

riept jxev ovv KdXX.ovs tov 6ov Kal raura iKard Kat ert
TToAAd Aetirerat, Trept 8e dpcTrjs "Epcoros /xerd TavTa \ktov, 5
rd ]Xv fxiyLorTOv otl "Epcos ovt d8tKet oi!r' d^iKeirat oiJre
VTTO deOV OVT 6e6v, 0VT VTt' dv6p(i)TT0V 0VT dvdpCOTTOV. OVT
yap avTbs ^ici 7rdo-}(ei, ei ri irda-yeL /3ta ydp "EpooTOS ov^
&TrTTaL' ovT TTotu)v Troiet Trds' yap eKoby "'Epcori arai; C
virqpcTeT, d 8' dv kKwv K6vTt bfxokoyqa-r], (pacrlv " ot TrdAecoy

^acriA^j v6fxoL" btKata etrat. Trpds 8e rrj bLKaLoavvi] (T(i)(ppo-

avvrjs TT\L(TTr]S fXTyL. LvaL ydp bfxoXoyelTat a-(t)(f)pocrvvr]

rd KpaTLV r]bov6iV Kat iTTtdvfXL^v, "EpooTOS 8e fxr]b]XLav 5

ei xPV^^I^fOa W Stohaeus xP'n<ro!>f'.fSa BT 65 l^^yTW: i^

W
:

^y B aa Kal (ante dffiiDi')

BTW
BT: om. a8 tov BT: om. W
bs 5f Stobaeus: om. &^ C2 BTW Stobaeus: &v ris
vulg. irSKfus BTW: rwi' ir^Xfwv Stobaevis 04 irAe/ffTTjs]
Khelarov Cobet Ij/ot BT : om. W

I96c nAATXlNOS
rjbovTjv KpdrTO) cii/ar d be iJttovs, KpaTolvT hv vtto "EputTos,
6 8e KpaTOi, KpaT<av 8e rjbov&v Kal eiiiOvp.iSiv 6 "Epcos 8ia-
(})ep6vT(tiS hv a-axfipovol. Kal p.r\v cls y avbpeCav "Epwri
d " ovb^ "Aprjs avdicTTaTai," ov yap cxet *'E/3cora "Apij?,
alOCEpuis''Apri 'A<f)pobLTr]s, ots Aoyos KpeCTTOiv 8e 6 exoiv
Tov kyop.ivov' Tov 8' avbpiioTaTov t&v akkoiv KpaT&v TrdvTcav
av avbpciOTaTos ctT]. Trcpt /xey ovv btKaioaijvr^s Koi croxPpo-
5 arvvrjs Kal dvbp^Cas tov 60v dprjTat, irepl 8e ao^Cas AciTrerai*

oa-ov ovv bvvaTov, iriipaTiov ixr] kkXiCitdv. koX irpSiTov p.iv,

tv^ av Kal eyo) ttjv ?//xercpay Ti\vr]v TL[JLria-u> wcnrep 'Epu^i-

e liaxos rqv avTOv, TTOLr^Trjs 6 dcbs a-o(f)bs ovTOis &are Kal
clAAoy TTOi^o-ai" Trds yovv Troirjr^s ytyrcrat, " Kav a/xouo-oy

ri To TrpCv," ov av "Epcos a\/njrai. St brj TrpcVci rjiMS

pi,apTVpC(a yjpria-daL, otl Trotrjr?]? 6 "Epcos dyadbs kv K(f)aX.aC<a

5 TTaa-av iroCriarLV rr/y Kara ixova-iKriv' h. ydp rts ^ /xt) e^ct ?)

p.ri 018^, ovT hv kTep(a 8otij ovr' av dkXov 8i8a^eicr. Kat

197 ixkv 87) rTjy yc rwy Cwa)y TroCr]a-LV 'ndvTu^v tls ivavTLCoaeTaL

jxri ovx^ "EpooTos elvaL a-o(f)Cav, 77 yCyvcTaC re Kat (f>VTaL

irdvTa To. (Qa; dXka Trjv tG)v rexJ^wy brnLLovpyCav ovk

X(TiiV, 6tl oS ixkv av 6 debs ovtos 8t8ao-KaAos yivriTaL,
5 eAAo'yt/jios Kai (f)avbs d7re/37j, ov 8' ^v "Epcos jlit) e(/)ci-

^r]TaL, (TKOTeLVos; TO^LKriv ye p.riv j<al iaTpLKrp Kal p.avTiKriv

'AiTokkoiiv dvrivpiv kiTLOvixCas koX ipooTos fjyepiOvevaavTOS,

b coo-rc Kat ovtos "Epo)Tos dv ctrj {xaOriTris, Kal Mouo-ai

ILOva-LKrjs Kal "H^atcrroy xakKcCas Kal 'A^Tjm lo-roupyia?
Kat Zevs Kvficpvdv OfStv re Kat dvdpdiiroDV. oOev bri

Kal KaTccTKevdadri t5>v diS)V tcl TtpdypiaTa "Epcoros (yye-

5 voix4vov, brjkov otl kciAAous aio-)(et yap ovk ^ttl epcos rrpo

Tov bi, cSo-irep ev dpxfi ^Ittov, TTokka Kal b(Lvd Oeols kyCyveTo,

d4 &/ T W : om. B d7 Vi/' a5 T W o5 B : 'Iv olu Stobaeus

W W
:

e2 K&j/ T Kol B 64 BT Stobaeus

W W
:
:
xp'^'^^"-^ xp^*''"'''^**
e5 6X* ^w :
ixV '^ a I fjiev BT : n^v b5 eir scripsi
et sic fort. pr. B (fort. tri Schanz : icniv apogr. D) : fvfffriv T W
Stobaeus : evi corr. b : ovk fvfffriv in marg. rec. b
 SYMnOSION I97b

ft)S Aeyerat, 6ia Trjv rijs 'AvdyKi]s l3acri.ke[av' eTreiSr) 8' 6

^eoy ouros l(|)u, e/c roO epay rwi' KoXCiv TidvT dyada yiyovev
K^ ^eois Ka\ dvdp(oiTOLS.
OvTois e/xot SoKet, S 4>ar8/)e, "'E/aws TrpcSros avros oiiV c
KaAA.iaToy /cat dpLcrTOS fXTd tovto toXs aAAots aAAooy roiourcDy

atrtos etyat. eirepx^erat 8e /xot rt Kai e/x/jter/joj; eiTretr, ort

ovro's eo-rty 6 Trotwi'

lpy]vrjv p-ev iv dvdpuiTtoLS, -TreA^iyet 8e yaAT/i;!]!; 5

vr]VpLLav, dvp.(>iv koltt^v vttvov r' eri K7/8et.

ovtos 8e :7/*as dAAorpiorrjros /xey Kerot, olK^LorqTOS 8e TrAr/poi, d

ras rota(r8e <rwo'8ovs /xer' dAA^Aooi; Trdo-as rt^eis o-uyte^rat,

(V kopTals, (V xopois, ey 6v(TLaL(TL yLyv6pivos 7jy{X(av'

7rpao'rTjra /Aei/ TTopLC(^v, dypLOTrjTa 8' i^opCCcov <^tAo'8a)pos

ev/xeretas, d^topos 8vo-/xeretas* lAecos dya^o's* ^earos o-o^ots, 5

dyao-ros ^eots* {TjAcoros dfxoCpoLS, Krr/ros ev/iot/)ois* Tpv(f)r]s,

dj^poTriTos, x^tS^s yapLT(av, Ifxipov, TTodov TraTTjp' eTTt/xeA^s

dya^o)!', d/AeA^s Ka/caii'' ey 7ro'r&), ey (f)d^(D, iv TTod^a, iv

\6y(o Kv^fpvrJTrjs, e7ri/3dr7js, TrapaordrTjs re Kat (T(arr]p
apKTTos, crvfXTTdvTOiv T ^eoiy Kat dvdp(aiT(i)V Kda-fxos, r]yfX(t)v

KdAAto-ros Kat dptoros, w )(p^ i^TrecrOaL Trdyra dvbpa (f)Vfx-

vovvTa KaAws, <o8^s p.TiyovTa rjv a8et diXyoov TrdvTo^v Oe&v

T Kal dv6p(aTT(>)v v6r]fxa.^ 5
Ovros, e0rj, 6 Trap' e/xoC A()yos, co <i>ar8pe, rw ^eo)

dvaKeL(T6(a, Ta fxv 7rat8tas, Ta 8e o-Trou^rjs /xerptas, Ka^'

ocroy eyo) bvvafxaL, ynTiyoiv.

C3 infjLfrpov B TW Stobaeus : infifrpws Hermogenes c 6 avf/xuv

BTW: Stobaeus
t' avf/x*"' : S' avffiots Hermogenes KoirrjvBTW :

Koirr\v r Stobaeus Koirri 6' G. Dindorf r iv\ k^5 Stobaeus

W
:

Hermogenes : re vtKTjSei B t i^ijkt/S^ T : rt viK-fiiti (in marg. yp.

W
:

KoH vrjKi]S(7) d3 dvffiaiffi : dvaiais BT : (vBv^iiais Stobaeus

ds iKfus ayaJdos BTW: ?A<By O7o0o?s Stobaeus '/A*ws d^ovfJj Usener :

d7 x^'5^s (sic) T (sed i ex ^) x^'?''?* ^ X^^jS^s V* pou T W W

W
: :

Tifiipov B ir6Bov om. Stobaeus d 8 d/xA^y T di/eA7)s B :

4v <p6fi(f 4v irJOy iv v6vuf iv fi.6y(f SchQtz iv ir6v<f iv <f>6fi<( iv ix66<f>

:

iv fnoyci) Jahn iv nr6v<f) iv iv fi69<f iv X6x<f Rettig: alii alia

W
:

ea (cal BT : om. W 6 4 Ka\us

<p6p<i>
BT : /coAtjj Stobaeus : /coAcDs
KoA^J Vlllg.
igSa HAATIINOS
198 EIttovtos be tov ^Ayddcavos irdvTai <j)i] 6 'A/)t(rro8r/juos

dva6opvj3r](raL tovs iTapovTas, ws TrpeTTovTcos tov veaviaKov

(IprjKOTOS Kal avT^ Kal T<a ^ew. tov ovv ^(DKpdTT] elTTelv

^\4\l/avTa ets tov ^Y,pv^ip.ayov, ^Apd croi boK&, <f)dvai, 2)

5 Trat ^AKovpLevov, dbees TraXat b4os bcbievai, dXX' ov p.avTiKSis

h. vvvbr] (Kcyov elTTelv, oti 'AydOoiv 6avixaar&s epol, eyoi 8'

dTTO/DT^O-OtjU.t;

To ixev ^Tepov, <f)dvai tov ^^pv^ip.a\ov, fxavTiK&s p.01

boKiis lpr]K4vai, ori 'Ayddcav ev epet* t6 be o-e aTTop-qcTnv,

10 ovK oTjxai..

b Kat TTcos, S) p.aKdpi., (iireiv tov ^(oKpdTr], ov /xeAAci)

diTopeiv Kttt eyo) jcai aAAos da-TLtrovv, fjL4\k(i)v Ae'^ety fJLeTd

KaXbv o{!rco xai Trai^roSaTroy Aoyoy pr]6VTa; Kal Ta ijiev dXka

ovx^ ojuotcos /xei' 6av]xacrTd' to 8e eTTt reAeur^? tov KaAAovs
5 TSiV 6v0]xdTO)V KoX pqpMTOiV Tis OVK hv ^7T\dyr] dKOVO)V;
eirel iyooye kv6vpi.ovp.evos otl avTos ov\ olos t cropt.aL ov8'

eyyvs tovtojv ovbev Ka\6v elTTelv, vtt' aia^vvris okiyov

C diTobpas <^\6]ir]V, ei 7777 etxor. Kai ydp /xe Yopyiov 6 \6yos
dv]jt.i]xvr](rKev, coare dTex^^s to tov 'Opi'^pov eTTTT6v6r]'
<f)o^ov]X7]v ]xi] ]xoL Te\VTO)V 6 Ayd6o)v Topyiov K(pa\r]v
'

bcLVOv \iyeLV kv rw Aoyw eirl tov i]x6v \6yov iT4p.y}fas avT6v

5 ]X \i6ov Tj] d(f)0)via 770t?jo-etey. Kat evev6r]aa T^Te dpa
KaTayi\aaTos o)V, qviKa vpiv o)]xo\6yovv iv t<o ]xepL ]xe&'

d V]x5)v iyK0)]XLdaea6aL t6v "Epo^Ta Kal e(f)r]v elvaL beLVOs to.

epo)TLKd, ovbev elbios dpa tov TTpdyp.aTOs, w? e8et lyKCD/xtd^eiy

ortow. eyo) p.ev ydp vtt' d(3e\Tepias wftrjy belv Td\r]6r]

\eyeLV iTepX eKdarov tov eyKO)pLLaCopt.evov, Kal tovto ]xev

5 vTTdpxeLV, e avT&v be tovto)v rd KdWiaTa eK\eyopLevovs

o)s evTTpeTTeaTaTa TL6evaL' Kal Trdvv br] pLeya e<f)p6vovv m ev
ep&v, ois elbo)s Tr]v d\r]6eLav tov eiTaLvelv otlovv. t6 be dpa,

a2 nrpeir^vTws b t irpfirovTOS BT W a8 fj.oi SoKe7s B SoKfls

W
: :

(jioi T W b3 oStco Kol iravToSavhv BvavToSavhv oSt T

Koi
W
:

b4 tifvBTW: om. Vind. 21 bs okovwvBT: om. b6 oT6s

t' BT: oTos C4 W ^j/ T^ \6yif) secl. Usener ds afifhTepias
B afi(\TTjplas T
: W


SYMnOSION igSd

ws ioLKv, ov TovTo ^v To /caAo)? kTraiveiv otlovv, aXXa to o)?

lxiy{.(TTa avaTidivat tQ irpayy.aTi Ka\ ws KaAAtora, kav re ?] e

ovTOii^s iyovTa kav re /mtj* et 8e \lrvbfj, ovbev ap' qv iipayp.a.
irpovppridr] ydp, ws eotKey, otto)? KaaT09 rjpL&v tov "Epcora
ey/cco/Liid^eti; 8d^et, ov)( dTTcos eyKcoixLaa-eTat. bia TavTa brj

ot/xat TTavTa Xoyov Ktrowres dvaTiOcTe roi "'Epoort, xat 5

<^are avTov toiovtov re etrat xat roo-ovrcoy airtoi', 0-770)? av

cfjaivrjTaL cl)? KaAAto-ros Kat dptcrro?, S^Aoy ori rots jlit/ ytyrco- 199
0-KOUo'ti' ov ydp brjTTOV rot? ye etSdo-tr' /cal koAw? y' e^et

jcai a-fixv&s 6 ^TiaLVOs. dXXa yap eyo) ovk fjbrj apa tov
TpoTTOv Tov iiraLVOv, ov 8' etSiiby v/xty u>yLoX6yr]a-a koll avTos
iv ro) /xepet eTratveVeo-^at. ^ yAworo-a oi!y vitiayiTo, ^ 8e 5

(f)pr]v ov' yaLpiTiii 877. oy yap Irt eyKco/xtd^a) rouroy Thv

TpoTTOv ov ydp dv bvvaLp.r]v ov p.ivTOL dXXd Ta ye dXr]dri,

ei ^ovXiaOe, e^e'Aa) iliiiLV Kar ffxavTov, ov Trpds rov? b

v/ierepouy Adyovs, tva fxr] yeAcora o(f)X(o. opa ovv, S) <I>at8pe,

et rt Kai roiovrov Adyov 8e'r/, Trept "'Eptoros TdXr]drj Xcyofxeva

dKoveLV, 6vofxd(rL 5e Kat ^eo-ei pr]]xdT(i>v TOLavrr] OTioia bdv
rts Tvyx] k-niXOova-a. 5
Tov ovv ^albpov e^r/ Kai tov^ dAAovs KeAevety Xeyeiv,
0TT1] aVTOS OLOLTO bcLv etTTeii', TavTrj.

Ert Toiwv, (jidvaL, S 4>at8pe, "Trdpes /xot 'Ayd^cova apiiKp'

drra ipiaOaL, tva dvofxoXoyr]adp.VOS Trap' avTOv ovrcos 7/67/

Aeyco. 10

'AAAa irapir]]XL, (f)dvaL tov '^aibpov, dAA' ip^ara. /xerd c

ravra 87/ rdr ^(OKpdTr] i(f)ri ivdivbi ttoO^v ap^acrdai.

Kai fxrjv, u) (f)iX 'Ayd^coi, KaAoly jxoi ebo^as Ka6r]yr]-

craadaL tov Adyov, Xeywv otl iipiaTov fxev 8e'ot clvtov e-TrtSet^ai

d-TTotds rt? (OTLV 6 Epco?, varfpov 8e rd epya avTov. TavTr]v 5

e 4 Z6^u Stephanus 5<J|j? BT W a 2 ybp S-(iirov Cobet yiip Hv

W
:

W
:

irov T : ydp vov B a3 &pa T

fjSri : j^fST/ B a 5 yKwffcra W
W
:

yXwTTa B T b4 ovofjid.<T(i : dv6fjia(Ti BT SSi/ Usener (S^ &/

Stallbaum) :
5' af B :
8' ' TW
I99C nAATaN02
TTjv apxrjv Trdvv ayaiiai. Wi ovv [xol Trepl "EpcaTos, 7rei8^
Ktti raAAa KaAws Kal p.iyaKoTtpmSiS Si^A^es oios eori, *cat

d Tohe diti' TTOTepov iam toiovtos olos (IvaC tlvos 6 "Epm

epcos, 7] ovbevos; p(tiT5> 8' ovk d. ix-qTpos tlvos ^ iraTpos
kcTTiv yeAotoi; yap av eir; to epcaTrjpia ei "EpMs eorii' ipois

[xriTpbs 7] TvaTpos dAA' coo-Trep av el avTo tovto TraTepa

5 ripa>T(ov, apa 6 iraTrip ccttl TraTrjp tivos rj ov; eiTre? av
brjTTov jxoL, et ejSovXov koX&s aTioKpivaa-Qai, ori eoTtj; vios
ye 7) dvyaTpos 6 iraTrip TTaTrjp' r) ov;
ndvv ye, (f)dvat. tov ^Ayddcova.
OvKovv Kal 7] p.^qTrip coa-avTcos ; 'O/xoAoyeio-^at Kai rovro.

e Ert ToCvvv, etTrety tov ScoKparr/, aTioKpivai oAtyfc) TrAetoj,

tVa juaAAoy KaTapiddris 6 j3ov\oixat. ei yap kpoCixriv, " Tt

8e'; dbe\(f)6s, avTo Tovd^ oTrep ^(ttiv, eo-rt tlvos d8eA</)os ?)

ov; " <I>dmt etvat.

5 OvKovv dbX(f)ov ri dbX.<j)rjs; 'OjxoXoyelv.
netpw brj, <f)dvai., Kal tov ipoiiTa etTrety. 6 "Epcos tpcas
((ttIv ovbcvbs ri tlvos;
Udvv ixkv ovv (rTt.v.

200 Touro ixV ToCvvv, etTreti Tbv ^(OKpdTri, <f)vXa^ov Trapa

(ravT(o fXp.vriixevos otov To^rovbe 8e eiire', iroTipov 6 "Ep^os
KeCvov ov ((TTLv ipoos, eTrt^u/jtei avroC r/ ov;
Udvv ye, (f)dvaL.

5 YloTepov excoi; avTb ov eTrt^y/xei re xat epS, e?ra iiTLOvixfX

re Kat epa, 17 ovk XO)v;
OvK e-)(0)v, ws ro etKo's ye, <f)dvaL.

^KoireL 877, etTreiy roy SwKpdrr/, di^rt roC eiKoVo? et

dvdyKri ovrco?, ro kitLdvixovv iiTLdvixeXv ov evbc^s ((ttlv, ri ixri

b kiTLOviXiLV, kav ixri ei^Sees 37; e/xoi /ue^' ydp ^av/xao-rojs 6oKet,

d) ^Ayd6oi)V, s dvdyKri elvaL' (tol 8e Trws;

KdpioC, (f)dvaL, boKeX.

07 oros B : orosT'TW <i i ?pwj?po>sBW: fpy T dp d/io-

Ao^fTo-flaiBTW: 6/^0X07^0-01 vulg. : i/ioA.oyerj' Stallbaum a8 o-fcJirfi

BT : ffKovuv W fMros B T : ejoTs W

 :

STMnOSION aoob
KaAcSs \eyis. ap' ovv ^ovkoLr av Tis ficyas otv \iiyas

(IvaL, rj laxvpbs (ov L(T)(yp6s; 5

'AbvvaTov K T&v u)pLo\oyri[j,ev(tiv.

Ov yap TTou kvh^T]s h.v etrj TovTOiv 6 ye a)V.

^Akridrj \4yLs.

Et yap Kal icr)(ypos wy ^oij\oiTo l<rxypbs elvaL, (jtdvaL rbv

Sco/cparrj, Kal raxvs ol)V Taxys, Kal vyLrjs ol)V vyLrjs tcrcas lo

yap av tls ravra olr^Oeir] koI TrdvTa to. rotaura tovs ovTas
re TOLovTovs Kal i\ovTas Tavra toijt(ov Sirep lx.oi;(n Kal C
(TrLdvp.eLV, tv' ovv ^t) e^aTraTrjd&piCV, tovtov evcKa Xeyco
TovTOLS ydp, 0) ^Ayd6(i>v, et ei^yoers, ^x^i-v /xer ^Kacrra
TovT(ov kv rw TtapovTL dvdyKX) h exouo-iy, kdvT ^ovkcovTai
edvT /X7J, Kal tovtov ye briTrov tls hv TTLdv[xri(rLv; aXA.' 5
oTav TLS keyr) otl eyo) vyLaCvuiV ^ovkofiaL Kal vyLaLVeLV,
Kal ttX.ovto)V jSovkofxaL Kal TTkovrdv, kol ewt^v/Aw avT(av
tovto)v b. ex<w, eiTTOtjiAei' hv avrw ort (tv, a> dvdpa)TT,

TTkovTov KKTr]p.ivos KOL vyULOv KOL lcTxyv jSovk^L Kal eis d

Tov e-ffetra xpovov raura KexT^o-^at, eTret ev rw ye vvv
irapovTL, etre (SovkcL etre jut/, exets* o-KoVei ovi/, orav
TovTo kiyrjs, otl eTrt^u/xo) t&v TTap6vT0t)v, et aA.Xo rt kiycLS
rj Tdbc, oTL ^ovkofxaL to. vvv Ttap^VTa koX cZs tov iTTfLTa 5
Xpovov TTap^LvaL. dkXo tl 6/uioAoyot dv; ^vp.<f)dvaL 4<f)ri rbv
*Ayddo)va.
KIttcXv br) Tbv SooK/jarT/, Ovkow tovto y (.(ttXv KLVov
kpdv, h ovTTo) ^TOLfxov avT^ ecTTLV ovbe ^X^'''
'"^ ^'^ '"^^

iiTeLTa xp6vov TavTa etrat avroi (r(o(6iXva Kal 7Tap6vTa; 10

Yldvv ye, (f)dvaL. e

Kat ovTos dpa Kal aAAos Tras 6 iTTLdvfx&v tov fxri kTOLfxov

1TLdvfXl Kal TOV /XT/ TTapdvTOS, KOL O fXrf 1^^^ '^^'' ^ h-V CrTLV

b6 iifkoKoyriixivwv BT W : b 9 ol B T
6ixo\oyovfj.fv<i)v vulg.
om. W b 11 ravra B : tovtI BT T W
(Katrrov 03 Koara W
/c

W
:

vulg. C7 Ko2 ir\oin-6r>' B irAotn-ri' T : d^ x*'* ^"W

W
:

f Xpj B d 8 ovKovv B ovkovv Sii pr. T

: d 9 rb d 10 irap6vra . . .

secl. Badham dg tJ T Tci B W

d 10 koJ T : /uoi B rek W : :

vvv al. vulg. 6 2 SAA.OJ B d liWos T W :

 2ooe nAATllNOS
avTos Koi ov fvb^-qs ecrri, TOLavT aTTa ka-Tiv S)V rj iTndv^xia

5 re KoL 6 ipois ka-Tiv;

Yi6.vv y', etTreiy.

"Wi 877, (pdvai. Tov SwKparrj, avoiJ.o\oyi]a-(afxe6a ra et/3;-

/xeVa. aAAo rt tcrrti' 6 "Epws Trp&TOV fjikv TivS>v, iiTdTa

TovTu>v &v hv tvhiia TTapfj avrw;
201 Nai, (jidvai,.

'Etti 8^ TOVTOLs dvap.vr)a-6r\Ti tCv(ov e<;^r;(r^a iv roi Xdyo)

tmt roy "Epcora* et 8e ^ovKei, eycu <re dvap.vri(r()>. ot/xat

ycip o"e ovrcoo-t ttcos etTreti', ori rots ^eots KaTi(rKwd(r6r\ tol

5 TtpdypxiTa hC epcora KaAwr" al(Ty^p&v ydp ovk eiij epcoy. o^x

ourcocrt ttcos eAeyes;
EtTrof ycip, ^dvai. tov ^Ayddoiva.
Kai eTTtetKws ye Aeyets, S eratpe, (f)dvaL tov ScoKpcirrj*

Kat et rouro owrcos e^et, aAAo rt 6 *'E|oa)s kciAAous ^v eirj

10 epcos, ala")(ovs 8e ov; 'X2//oA()yet.

b OvKovv wixoXoyrjTaL, ov ivbei]s eo^rt Kat fi^ exei, rourou

e/)ay;

Nat, etTrety.

r 'ErSerjs ap' eo-rt Kat ovk ^x^l 6 "Epcos kciAAos.

5 ^AvdyKrj, (jtdvaL.
Tt 8e'; t6 erSees KciAAous Kat /ixrjSajurj KKTr}p,4vov kciAAos

a/)a Ae'yets o-v Ka\6v eirat;

Ov Sr/ra.

"Eri ovy 6/xoAoyets "Epcora KaAw etj^at, et ravra ourcos

10 exet;
Kai t6v 'Ayd6u)va etTreiy KtrSweuco, S) ScaKpares, ov8ey
et8e'yat b)v totc clttov.

C Kat /xT/y KaAois ye etires, (pdvaL, o) 'Ayd6(DV. dXXd

a-p.LKp6v TL eiTre'* rdyadd ov Kal KoXa 8oKet o-ot etyat;

"E/xotye.

5 T om. W 67 avoiJ.o\oyri<r6/ji.fOa W as epcos BT Oxy. :

6 fpws W a9 T 6] rj s. V. Oxy. b i ixv BT W ba ipai W

C1 *(irai Oxy,


2TMn02I0N 20IC

Ei apa 6 "Epcas t&v KaK^v evbajs eo-rt, to. 8e ayaOa

KaXa, Kctv TU)V ayaOiav ivheris ftrj. 5
'Eyw, (f)dvai, Si ScoAcpares, <rol ovk hv bvvaCfJirjv dvTt-
Xiyeiv, dAA' ovTca^ ex^ero) wy crv Kiyns.
Ov ixkv ovv tt) dX.r]6eLa, (pdvai, w (lakovfieve ^Ayd6(t)V,
bvvacrai, dvTiXiyeLV, tTrei ^(aKpdTa ye ovbev xoA.eTror.

Kai (re /xeV ye ^7877 edcw roi' 8^ Xo'yoi' tov 7re/Ji roS d
"Epcoros, 6v TTOT iJKOva-a yvvaLKos MavTiVLKrji Atori/iay, 17

TavTd re cro^pr] ?]y Kat aAAa TToAAdt Kal ^A6r]vaioLS Trore

6v(rafx4vois Trpb tov Aoijuoi} Se^xa errj dvaj3okr}v iitoiqcrf. ttjs
vocTov, rj br) Ka\ e/xe to. ipcaTiKd (biba^ev ov ovv fKeCvr} -6

eAeye Ao'yoi', T:iLpd(Top.aL vpA.v bLek6eiv ex t5>v oip.okoyr]-

lxiv(i)V efxol Kal 'Ayd6a)VL, avTos ctt' ifxavTOV, oirois dv

bvvoifxaL. Sei br], a> ^Ayd6(i)v, uicnrep av bLr^yrjcr^a, biekdeXv
avTov 7rp5)Tov, tls ((ttlv 6 "Kpoos Kal ttolos tls, eireLTa tol e
epya avTov. boKel ovv fxoL paaTov etrat ovto) bLck^elv, a>s

TTOTe ixe r) ^evr) dvaKpivovda StT^et. cryjebov ydp tl Ka\ eyo)

Trpos avTr]v erepa TOLavTa ekeyov oldTrep vvv Trpbs e/xe

^Ayd6(av, cos eir/ 6 "Epo^s fxeyas deos, etr] be t&v Kak&v 5

^Aeyxe 8?) /ute tovtols toIs koyoLS oXa-nep eyo) tovtov, wy

ovTe Kakos etrj Kard tov e]x6v koyov ovTe dya66s.
Kai eyco, riw? Ae'yets, e(f)r]v, o) Aiori/ota; atVxpoj dpa 6
Epco9 ecrri Kai KaKos;
Kat rj, OvK ev(\)r]]xr]creLs ; e^rj* 7/ otet, ori dv fxr] Kakbv 10

17, dvayKalov avTO elvaL alayjiov;

MdAtoTo ye. 202
H Kat dv ]xi] crocf)6v, dfxa6es; rj ovk r](r6r]craL otl ecrTLV
TL fxeTa^v cro^Las koI dfxa^Cas;

Ti TovTo;

c8 <f)i\t Oxy. d2 fiavTiviKrts BT Oxy. : fiavriKris W d^ [e^iroj?)-

aaro {rr)s s. v. Oxy. d 5 \oyov fKfivrj Af yej' Oxy. d7 in
W W
)

Oxy. : air" BT d 8 5e? 5^ T Oxy. Sf /Atj B S.Tj-yVjirw

BT W
:

Oxy, : Srj riyijffCD Schanz e i oiroios Oxy. 63 yap]

S Oxy. e8 ir<r tipri \c7cts Oxy.
202a nAAT12N02
5 To 6p6a bo^dCcLV koI avev tov fX^Eiv Xoyov bovvai ovk
oTa-9 , (f)r}, OTL ovTe kTtiaTaaBai ka-Tiv akoyov yap Ttpay^a
TtSis av eirj iina-TrifXT]; ovTe aixa6(a yapto tov ovtos
Tvyyavov nm av ur] dim6ia; lcrTt 8e St/ttou Tot.ovTov rf

6p6r\ bo^a, /xera^i (f^povi^a-ccas Kal dfxa^ias.

lo ^Akrjdrj, ^v b' eydt, Xiyas.

b Mt) Toiwv dvdyKa(, o \ir] KaXov ea-Tiv ala^yjiov elvai,

fxrfbe o iMr] dya66v, KaKOV. ovtu) be Kal tov "Epcora eiretS^

avTos oiJLokoyeis fxr] flvai dyadbv firjbe koXov, iir]biv ri
]mkKov olov beiv avTov alcryjiov Koi KaKov klvai, aKkd tl

5 fiTa^v, e<pr], TovToiv.

Kat ]i-qv, r]V 8' eyw, 6]xoX.oyeiTai ye 'napd TrdvTUiV fxiyas
dfos etmt.
T(ov ixT] dboTiov, <pr], TrdvTOiV Aeyetj, 17 koI t&v (IboTOiv;
^VfXTrdvTOiV ]XV ovv.
10 Kal ^ yeXda-aa-a Kat 7r<Ss &v, ((pr], S> ^taKpaTes,
C ofxoX.oyolTo ]x4yas ^cbs etyat Trapa TOVTOiv, ot (pacnv avTov
ovb\ Oeov etyai;
tres ovToi; rjv eyo).

Eis ]xiv, av, jxia 8' eyw.

(t>r],

5 Kdyo) elTTov, IIQ>s tovto, ^(pr]v, Xeyets;

Kat rj, 'Pqbiois, (f)r]. kiye ydp ]xoi, ov irdvTas 6ovs

^fjs vbai]xovas etrat Kat Kakovs; r/ roX/xT/crats dv TLva ]xr]

(fidvaL KoXov re Kat evbaijxova dc&v ctvat;

Ma At' oi/K iy(iiy , (f>r]v.

10 Evbaifxovas 8e 8^ Xeyets ov tovs Tayada Kot tcl Kaka

KKTr]]XVOVS ;

Udvv ye.

d 'AX\a ]xr]V "'Epcora ye a)juo\oyr7Kaj 81' ey8etay tS>v

a5 B T Oxy. to W opeii 8o|aC' T W Oxy. opeoSo^dCfiv B

Kol om. Oxy.
tJ
b5
:

rovroiv fipri Oxy. b6 7 B T Oxy. /xo

:

: W
c 8 eewv BT W Oxy. : e^hv W^
W
(0 s.

ra B
v.) c 10 Ta.yaeh. B T Oxy.
Oxy. om. T StobaeusW
Stobaeus : a.ya.eo\)s /tal rkyaeh. :

d I, 2 tZv Ka\S)v Kvi. tSiv d-yoflwv Stobaeus

 STMnOSION 2oad

ayaOSiv Ka\ Ka\(av Tn6vfX(iv avT&v tovtmv u)V ivberjs

i(TTlV.

'illxoXoyrjKa ydp.

l\S>s Sy ovv ^eoy ei?] 8 ye t&v KaX&v Kal ayadQv &fji,oi.pos; 5

OvbafXbis, (3s y' olkv.
*Opay ovv, (f)ri, otl Kal cru "Ejocora ow ^eoi; rofAi^eis;
T6 oSi^ ay, e(^r/i;, eiTj 6 "Epcos; dvrjTOs;
HKiora ye.
*AAAa T^ fjiriv; 10

"ilcriTep TCL TTpoTepa, ^(f>r], juera^v dvrjTov kol aOavdTOV,

Ti oSy, ftj ALOTLpLa;
AaLixuiv ixiyas, S 2c5/c/3ares* Kal yap Trav to baLpiovLOv

liiTa^v kcTTi O^ov re cai OvrjTov. e

Ttz^a, ^y 6' eycri, hvvap.LV
Ix^^
'Epp,r}ViV0V KOL bLaTTOpdp.VOV deoh TCL Tiap av6p(aTT<j)V

Kal av6p(aTT0Ls tcl Trapa di&v, t&v /xey tcls bei](rLs koI
6v(TLas, tG>v 8e Tas iiTLTA^eLS re Kal d/uot/3as t&v 6v(rL&v, 5

ey jixeVci) 8e oi; d/x</)ore'/)coi' (rvp.TT\r]pol, wcrre ro jroi^ avro

avroi o-ui^SeSeV^at. 8td rovrou Kat 17 p.avTLKi] iTacra X^P^^
Kal 1] T(av Lp(ov Tixyv Ti>i' re Trepi Tas 6v(TLas kol reAerds
Kal Tas eTTwSds Kal rr/y fxavTfiav TTa^rav Ka\ yorjTLav. ^ed? 203
Se av6p(tiTT(a ov fxcLyvvTaL, akka 8td rovrou Trdcrci eo-rtf 1]

6p.LkLa Ktti ^ StciAeKros ^cots iTpbs av6p(aTT0vs, Ka\ eypr]-

yop6(n Ka\ Kadevbov^ri.' Ka\ 6 fxev 'irepl rd rotairra (TO(f)bs

batp.6vLos avr]p, 6 h\ oKKo tl (TO(f)bs (ov rj -Trept T^xvas 5

7] xiLpovpyCas TLvas ^dvavcros. oSroi hr] ol baCfxovfs

ds &v B Oxy. Stobaeus 5' &' TW ruv T W Oxy. Stobaeus

W
: :

y' &j/ B d6 Sj 7' BT : uar ye Oxy. : y' ws :Stobaeus

Sxtt
dii t<pr\ TW Oxy. :((priv B Stobaeus e i ts BT Oxy. om. : W
Stobaeus e 8 reAf tAs T W
Tas rtMras B Oxy Stobaeus
BT W
: .

a I ixavreiav Oxy. Stobaeus fiayyaveiav Geel nayti(u> Badham

W
: :

a 4 (Totphs BT Oxy. <T<poZphs Stobaeus

: a 5 iic B T Oxy. W :

om. Stobaeus a6 ^ BTW:^ irepl Oxy. Stobaeus ^avavaovs

Oxy.
PLATO, VOL. II. 13


203 a nAATliNOS
TToAAot Koi TTavTobaTToi d(nv, cts be tovtoov f(TT\ Ka\ 6
"E/3C0S.

ITarpos 8e, ip 8' eyw, riyos eort Koi /ji)jrpo's;

b .MaKpoTepov p.v, e^i), hir]yr\(Ta(T6ai' ofjLCds 8e o-ot epw.

ore ya/) iyiveTO rj ^A^fypobiTri, rjcTTioivTo ol Oeol ot re aAAoi
Kat 6 r^s MrjTibos vos YIopos. eTretS?) 8e ebiTrvr](rav,

Trpoa-aLT-qcrov^ra otov 8j; evoi-^Cas ovcrrjs a(f)CKTO rj Ilei^ta, Kai

5 ^v irepX Tas Ovpas. b ovv Ylopos p.e6vcr6e\s tov veKTapos

otyos yap oinrd) rjv ets tov tov Aibs KrJTTov elaek6(!bv

fie^apr]p.evos rjvbev. rj ovv Ylevia eTnjSovkevova-a 8ta ttjv

avrrjs aTTopCav TratStoy itoiria-aa-^ai Ik tov Yiopov, KaTa-

C KkiveTai, re Trap' avTw Ka\ eKvrjo-e tov "Epcora. 8to 87; Kat

TTjS ^ Ac^pobiTrjs aKokovdos koI ^epaTTddv yeyovev 6 "Epois,

yevvri6e\s ev.Tois eKeivrjs yeve6kioi.s, Ka\ ap.a (pvaei epa-

(TTi^s u>v Trept To Kokov KaX r^s 'A(f)pobiTrjs Kakrjs ov(rr]s.

5 aTe ovv YIopov Ka\ Ylevias vbs (ov 6 "Epcos ev TOiavTr) tvxj]
Ka6ea-Tr]Kev. Tip&Tov jxev Trevrjs aei eaTi, koX Trokkov beZ
airakos re Kat Kakos, olov oi 7Tokko\ oXovTai,, akka aKkr]pos
d Kat avxp-VP^^ '^ci^ avvTTobr^Tos Ka\ aoLKOs, x<^M<^'''i'^''"^S' dei

u>v Kal acTTpooTos, em 6vpais koX ev bbdis VTTaidpios KOLp.(a-

lievos, Trjv Trjs p.r]Tpbs (pva-Lv ^x^tiv, ae\ evbeiq. ctvvolkos.

KaTCL be av rbv TTarepa eTTijiovkos ea-TL toIs Kakols Kai rots

5 aya^ols, avbpeZos otiv kol irrjs Kat o-vvtovos, 6r]pevTr]S

beLVos, aei TLvas TrkeK^av pir]xavds, Ka\ <f)povr]a-e(i>s eiTL-

6vfJi.r]Tr]s Koi TTopt/xoy, ^Lkoa-o(\)(av bLO. iTavTbs tov (3iov,

beLvbs y6r]s Ka\ (f)apiJ.aKevs Kal cro(f)LcrTi]S' kol ovTe o)?

e addvaTos TTe(f)VKev ovTe ws 6vr]T6s, akka TOTe piev Trjs avTrjs

fjixepas ^dkkeL re Kat ^r), oTav eviTop-qar], TOTe be dTTo6vp-

a7 Kol prius BT W : a 9 rifos eVr! koI

re Koi Oxy. Stobaeus
/uTjTpJis B W et corr. T e(rTi{v)TOxy. ba r]ffriwvro
koI /JLijrposrivos
B^ W
:

B T elffTiwvTo t 'iffriwvro Oxy. b 4 irpoffair^s ovffa B

:

Origenes b6 tlexewv Oxy.

:

01 5^ koI Oxy. S^ BT W
W
:

c 6 Trfviijs B Se? B T Oxy. 5^ d a iTtaidoios B

: WOxy. :

tnraidpiots T d^ ro7s alterum om. Oxy. d 7 ir6pifj.os <pi\offo^S>v

T W Oxy. iroptff/xos (ptXoffSipuv B d 8 Kot prius om. Oxy.
W
:

e I avrrjs om. Oxy. e 2 re T om. B Oxy. :

 STMnOSION 2036

OTKCt, TTdXiv 8e avaj3no(rKTat bta Tijv tov iraTpoi (f>V(nv, tu

6e 7ropt^o/;>iej'oi' det VTreKp^l, axvTe ovTe airopel "Epcoi Trore

ovT TiKovTel, (TOf^ia^ re av koI ap.a6iai ev jx^crio icTTiv. 5

\i yap cS8e. OeSiV ovSeis (pLXocrocf^el ovb' eTri^fjuet (ro(f)os 204
yivicrOaL eort ydp ov8' et rt? dkXos (ro(f)6s, ov (f)i.ko(ro(f)el.

ovb* av ol dfxadcts (f)tko(ro<pov(rtv ov8' iTTtdvixov^rt (ro(f)Ot

yVcrdat' avTo yap tovto eort x^^^'"'^^ dptadia, to fxi]

ovTa Kakov KdyaOov p.r]b\ (f)p6vtp.ov boKctv avT(o etmt 5

tKavdv. ovKovv kiTtQvp.ei 6 /xt) otojuei^os ej^Serjs etz^at ov dv

pi] 0t7]Tat TTtbl(T6at.

TtVes ovv, e(f)r]v eyw, o Atori/xa, ot (f)tko(ro(f)ovvTS, et

joiTjre ot cro(f)ol ]ir]T ot dp.aOels;

Arjkov br], (f)r], tovt6 ye 7/817 Kat TratSt, ort ot pi.Ta^v b

TovT(i)v d]x(f)OTpo)v, b)V dv tr] Kal 6 "Epco?. (rTtv ydp 87) twv
Kakki(rT(t)v 7] (ro(f)ia, "Epcos 8' eo-rty epco? Trept to Kakov,
&(TT dvayKoiov ''E/acora cf)tk6cro(f)OV etmt, (f)tk6a-o(f)ov 8e
wra juera^v etmi (ro(f)Ov Kal dixadovs. atrta 8e avrw Kat 5
TOVT(i)V T] yV(rts' TTaTpos fXV ydp (ro(f)Ov eo-rt Kai evTropou,
p.rjTpbs 8e ov cro(f)rjs Kal diTdpov. r) fXV ovv (pvcrts tov
bai]xovos, cb ^tAe ^(aKpaTes, avrr/* ov 8e o-i; wT/^r/s "Epcora
eii^at, 6av]xa(rTov ovbV irra^es. <^r]6r]s 8e', w? e/xot ^OKei c
TKpLatpo]Xvr] e^ wi^ oi A.e'yety, to ipcafxevov "EpcoTa etmt,
ov t6 pS)V' btd TavTa (rot oTfxat iTdyKakos (f)aivTo 6
"Epcos. Kai ydp lcrri to ipaaTov t6 tS) ovTt Kak6v Ka\
d^p6v Kol T4k0V Kal ]xaKapt(TT6v ro 8e' ye epwy dkkr]V 5

i^e^ay TotavTr]V (^xov, oXav eyo) btrjk6ov.

Kat eycb eiiror, Eiei 877, 2 ^e'yrj, KaAcos ydp Ae'yets*

rotovros wy 6 "Epcos rtm yjpeiav exet rois dv6p(aTT0ts;

Tovro 8r) /xera raSr', ^(pr], S ScoKpares, TTtpd(ro]xai cre d
8t8ci^at. ecrrt /xev ydp 8r/ rotovros Kat ovrco yeyorcbs 6

e3 wciAij' s. V. iterat corr. Oxy. 65 re a5 ko T W : re koI B :

KM (av s. V. ) Oxy. a5 avrifi (awTy) B^^T W Oxy. avrb B b 5^

i
W Oxy.
:

T : 2ti B h 2 tv ffrj Oxy. : & BT W ca e\eyea

Oxy. fi^-a* ffxoTa Oxy.
13*
 W

204(1 nAATONOS
"Epco?, ^(TTL be T&v Ka\&v, ws (tv (f)j]S. ei 8e' tls rjfias

ipOLTO' Tt Toiv KaK&v kcTTLV o *'Epco?, ^l^^^J^po-X^s^Tel^jJ^

5 Kai AioTLiJia; wbe 8e (racfiia-Tcpov (f^o kp5>vt&v Ka\(av' -i*^'*'^
'^*'^
Tikpa;

Kai eyw eiTroy ort Feyetr^ai avT<a.

'A\A.' en TTodel, ^(f>i], rj airoKpL^rLs ep^arqa-LV roiaySe* Tt

^orai Ke(v(a w 01 yevrjTaL tcl Ka\d;
10 Ov '7rai'U e<jf)?]v ert exety eyo) Trpos TavTrjv Trjv p(aTr}(rLV

'^poxetpa)? dTTOKpCvaa-OaL.

e 'AAA', e(/)Tj, (oo-Trep ar et rts /jtera/3aA&)y di^ri roC /caA.o{!

rw dyaO^ XP^H-^^^^ TTVvOdvoLTO' $e'|oe, o) Scixpares, /^0 '

^'^ ''"^ ^'^'
^poSy rcSz! dyaO&v 9I kpa; Tfjl^ t^
rereo-^ai, ^y 8' eyci), avroJ.

5 Kai rt ccrTaL KLV(a w ay y^vr]TaL TdyaOd;

TovT einTop(oTpov, ^v 8' eyco, exco diroKpLvao-daL, otl

cvbaLiJ.(t)v ia-TaL.

205 Kr?]o-et yci/3, e0rj, dyaO&v 01 ev8at/ioi^es fvbaCixoves, Kal

ovkItl Trpoa-bcl ipia-daL "Iva rt 8e /3ovA.erai (vbaCfxddv etmt

6 ^ovX.6ix(vos; dX\a re'Aos 8o/cet exeti' ^ diroKpLa-LS.

^AXrjOrj Ae^yets, etiroi' eyctf.

5 TauTTji; 8^ rTji/ fiovXr}a-LV Koi tov Ipcora rouroi' TTOTepa

KOLVov otet etyat Trcivrcoi' dvdpctnTcav, Kal TTavras TdyaQd
IBovXeadaL avTOLs etvaL deC, r] tt&s Aeyets";
Ovrcos, ^v 8' eyco* kolvov eti^at TrdvTOiv.

Tt 8^ ovv, e(f)ri, & ScoKpares, ov TTcxrras kpdv (f)ap,iv,

b eiTTep ye Trcii^res rwi' avT&v ip&a-L Kai det, dAAci rtMs (paixev

epay, rous ov;

&avfj.dC(, r\v 8' eyco, Kat avTos.

'AAAa /ar/ 6avp,aC, ^^r)- dc^eAoVres yap apa rou IpcorcJs

d4 T6 B Oxy. om. T ds ^p? BTW Oxy. ipS, b vulg.

W Oxy.
: :

d8 er Toeer T W Oxy. B : iTrnro0u e2 'p^ BT : 4pS>

vulg. ai oyaOwi' B as S^ TW: S^B Oxy. a6 offi ehai
BT: fTvox or W b4 T Oxy. etpa : om. B W epwros B W :

4pWVT05 T
 :

STiMnOSION ao5b

TL elbos 6voixa^ofXV, rb tov o\ov k-niTid(.VT^<i ovoixa, epcora, 5

ra 8e oAAa aAAois KaTa\p(afX6a 6v6\xa(nv.

"ila-Trcp tL; rjv 8' eyw.
'^Ha-irep Tobe. oXa-&' otl t:oir]ais kaTi tl TroAv" 7/ yap
TOL K Tov 1X1] ovTos cls To ov LOVTL 6t(oovv ahia TTacra kaTL
TToirja-Ls, c5aT6 Kal al viro Trao-ais rais TiyvaLs ^pyacriaL C
TTOiT/o-eis eto-i Ka\ ol TOVTcav br]fXLOvpyoL TTavTis TVOLrjTai.
^AkrjOi] Aeyeis.

'AAA' ofxdis, 77
8' rj, OLa-&' otl ov KaXovvTaL Troir/rai aAAa
aAAa \ova-LV 6v6]xaTa, 0.1:6 be Trdo-rjs Tijs "TTOtr/o-ecos V 5

p.6piov acpopLcrd^v t6 Trepl ti]V ]xovaLKi]V koX to. fx^Tpa rw

Tov 6\ov 6v6]xaTL 7rpoa-ayopVTaL. Troir/o-is yap tovto
]x6vov KaAetrat, Kat ot ex^^^^^ tovto to ]x6pLov Ti]s TrotT/o-eo;?
TTOLr]Tai.

'A\r]6rj Aeyets, (j)rjv. 10

Ovrco Toivvv Kal Trepi tov cpcoTa. to fxkv K(f)dX.aL6v eori d

Trao-a ^7 twv dya6(av fTTL^vfxia kol tov tvbaLfxoviiv 6 /u,e'-

yLo-Tds re Kat 8oAepos epcos TravTi' dAA' 01 fxkv aWrf

Tp^TrdfxevoL TroAAaxr/ eTr' avTov, t/ KaTO. xprffxaTLafxbv ?/ Kara
(\)LkoyvfxvaaTiav 1] Kara (f)LXo(ro(f)iav, ovt ipdv KakovvTaL 5
ovT ^paarai, ol 8e KaTa ey ri etSo? toWes re Kai eo-Trou-
baKOTes to tov 6\ov ovofxa XcryovcrLV, (pooTa re Kai epdv Kal
epaarai.
Kivbvv(VLS dXrfdi], i(^r]V ly(a, \4yeLV.

Kat Ae'yerat ju,e'i' ye' rts, |0t/, Ao'yoy, w? ot dv to ijfXLa-v 10

(avTu>v ^r/roio-ti', ovrot kpSicrLV 6 8' ejuos Ao'yoj oilre ^/uto-eo's e

(f)r]a-LV ctvaL Tbv ^p(OTa ovt oAov, iav fxrf rvyxdvrf yi ttou,

cb eraipe, dya6bv 6v, eTrel avTu>v ye Kat 7ro'8as Kat x^^P^^

i6\ova-Lv d7:oTfxva-6aL ol dv6p(t)TT0L, idv avTols 8okt/ Ta

bp Toi Vind. 21 : ti BTW : ru Oxy. (in marg. 5) C4 tj 5 rj

Oxy. : iJ8t/ BTW ouBTOxy. : om. W 05 ex""''''' TW Oxy.

f^nvffiv B c6 fiopiov BT Oxy. et 7-^. W : ixSvov W d3 5oApis
BTW O.xy. -KpwTos ci. Schanz d^ Itrxovatv BTW: tfrxov
W
:

Oxy. d 10 lavTwv B T Oxy. auTWf : 63 tTrei T W Oxy. :

i7f\ B
aose nAATXlNO^;
5 kavT&v TTOvripa etvat,. ov yap to eavToiv oTfxaL (Kaa-Toi,

aa-TTa^ovTai, d ixrj ei tls to fJLkv ayaOov oIklov KaKd Kal

kavTov, To be KaKov aXKoTpLov ws ovbiv ye akXo (orlv ov
206 epwaLV avOpcoTTOL ?/ tov ayaOov. ?/ aol boKOva-Lv;
Ma AC ovk ejxoLye, 7/y 8' eyw.
'A/a' ovv, ?/
8' 7/, ovTcos a-nXovv eort \iyLV otl ol

avOpciiiTOL TayaOov epS^a-Lv;

5 Nat, (j)riv,

Ti 8e; ov "npoa-diTkov, ((prj, otl /cai ilvaL t6 ayaOov

avTols ep&a-Lv;
Tlpoa-6eTov.
^Ap' ovv, t(j)r], Kal ov fxovov (JvaL, aXka Kal ael HvaL;
10 Kat TOVTO TTpocrOeTiOV.

"Ea-TLV apa auWri^brjv, (f)ri, 6 epo)? tov to ayadov ovtm

cirai aeL
' AkrjdeoTTaTa, e(f)rjv kydi, keycLS.

b "Ore 8?/ tovto 6 Ipcos eortv dei, ^ 8' ?/, rwy rim rpoTTov
bLuiKovTcav avTo Kal iv tlvl TTpd^eL rj 0-7701)87/ Kat rj avvTacns
epoos hv KakoLTo; tl tovto Tvyx<xvL ov to epyov; ^X^ts
(iTTeLv;

5 Ov ixevTCLV ae, e^rfv eydo, u> ALOTLpia, edavixa^ov (ttX

ao(f)L(i Kal e(})OLT(t)V iTapa o-e avTa TavTa ixaOria-oixevos.

'Akka ky(a aoL, 1(^7/, epw. eort yap tovto tokos iv

KaAw Kai Kara to a&ixa Kal KaTa ttiv yjrvxvv.
MavTeias, rjv 8' eyw, ^eirat 5tl Trore Ae'yets, Kat ov
.av6av(t).

^AAA' iy(a, ?/
8' 17, aa(j)eaTepov epS. Kuouo-tz^ ydp, (j)ri,

S) SwKpares, TTdvTes dv6p()iT0L koX KaTo. to a&fxa Kal Kara

\1/
e 6 Ka\f7 BT W a i Sipdpconoi Bekker &y6punoi B T
: koAt) : :

01 &i/epwvot as ^ S' TjBekker ^Sij BTW

W a^ rayaeoD
W
:

T W rod ayadod B ag oSr B T Oxy. om. a 11 70C t^ :

W
:

W rov tJ T toDto B
: avr^p T : Oxy. avrh B b 1 Sjj] 8e :

W
Oxy. 8 Oxy. ^Stj B TW
11 7j roiu TW^ Oxy. :rhv B :

bs avrh BW Oxy. aur^i/ T airovSy BTW a-vi/Tacrts B

Oxy. (TvffTaixts T: c i ^ 5' W

:

Bekkcr tjS; B T 87; Oxy.

t)

?) : W :

c 2 Kai prius T W Oxy. om. B .

 SYMnOSION ao6c
TYjV yjfvxrjv, Kot ^TreiSay V tivi rjXiKia yevcovTai, TiKTi.v

Tn6v[XL f)ix(av rj <f)V(ns. tCktclv b (V fx^v atVxpw ov

bvvaTai,, iv 8e rw KaAw. r] yap avbpbs Kal yvvaLKos 5
(Tvvovcria t6ko9 kcrTiv. lort 8e tovto Oelov ro irpayp.a,
KaX TovTO kv 6vT]Tu> ovTL TO) ^<j;(i) a6dvaTov iveaTLV, rj Kvrjo-Ls

Kal rj yfvvrja-Ls. tcl 8e iv to) avapix6a-T(a abvvaTov yevi-

(rdai. avapp.oa-Tov 8' e<rTt rb alcrxpbv iTavTl Tca 6^L(a, Tb d
h\ KoXbv apjji^TTov. MoLpa ovv Kal EiAet^vta rj KaWovi]
lcTTL ttJ yevicrcL. Sta TavTa oTav pikv KaAw irpocnTeXdCll
rb Kvovv, Xkicav re yiyi^cTat Kot V(f)paLv6pvov bLax^lTaL
Kal TLKTu Ti Kal yevvq' oTav 8e ala-^p^, a-Kvdpcomv Te 5

tial \vTTovij.Vov o-rcTTretpaTat Kal aTioTpiiT^TaL KaX dvcCWeTaL

Kal ov y(vvq, dkkd Xayov Tb Kvr^fxa j^aAeTTws (/)e'pet. 66V 8?;

Tw KVOVVTL Te Kat ybrj cn:apyQ>VTL Ttokki] rj tttoli^o-ls yiyovi.

Trept To Kakbv 8ia Tb /xeyaArjs Siyos aTToAveti; Tbv ixovTa. e

eo-Tty ydp, S) SwKpares', i(f)r], ov tov Kakov 6 ipcas, ws
(Tv otei.

'AAAa Tt ixr]v;

T^? yivvr]cr(i)s Kal tov t6kov kv tw KaAw. 5

Erer, r]v 8' eyw.
Ilain; /xey ovv, e^rj. Tt 8t} oiii' ti^? yeri^^o-ecoj; oti

deiyeres eo-Tt kol d6dvaTov w? 6vr]T^ 7/ yivvrjcrLs. d6a-

va^rCas 8e drayKatoi' kiTL6v]XLV ixeTa dya6ov eK Tciiy a)/uo- 207
koyr]]xiv(t)V, e?7rep roS dya^ou eauro) eti^ai dei epcos (otCv.

dvayKOLov 87) eK rovrov tov Ao'you Kai r^s d6avacrCas tov

epcora etrat.
Taurci re ovv irdvTa ibCbaa-Ki fX, 6it6t Trepi t&v epco- 5

c 3 T^v B W
Oxy. om. T c 5 t<j> om. Oxy.
: c 7 fvetTriv B
Oxy. : ((TTivTW e8 Ttt B Oxy. TaDra : TW di oiroi/Tt Oxy.
6fi(f! TW: Bt Oxy. d6 awrtreLparat TW: ^v[v^air(ipaTai
Oxy.
0((f
ffvv(TireipfTai B W^ (* s. v.) aveiWfTai B W avetWfiTai T
W Oxy.
: : :

avttKuTat t : aviWeTat Oxy. d8 VToi-qffls T B ; ?roiSj(r<s

ei d)roAv(f TWOxy. : dTroAovcij/ B 67 Yerc (rews Oxy, e8 di-

ytvty] an yevt(Tis Oxy.
207a nAATilNOS
tikG>v Xoyovs ttoioito, Kai Trore r^pero Ti otet, co '2(aKpaTs,

alTiov ilvai TOVTOV tov Ipcoros Ka\ ttjs k-mOvp.ia^s; rj ovk

alaOavif ws huv5>i bi,aTi$eTat TtavTa Ta drjpia iTrabav yev-
vav i7n9vixi](rri, Kal to. Tte^a koX to. TTTrjvd, vocrovvTa re
b TrdvTa Kai ipcoTtK&s hLaTt6ip.eva, TipG>Tov fikv Trepi t6 <Tvp.-

fxiyijvai. dAATjAots, TTi.Ta Trept Trjv Tpocfir^v tov yevojxivov,

KoX (Toijxd icTTiv virep TorjTO)v Kal biap.dxfcOai to. da-devi-
(TTaTa Tois icrxvpordTOi? Kal V7rpa7ro9v^(rKei.v, Kal avTo. r<^
5 Atju.0) TTapaTeLvojjieva coo-r' eKetm eKrpe^ety, Kal dWo irdv

noi.ovvTa. tovs fjikv yap dv9p(07T0vs, e^rj, ototr' dv tis (k

\oyi(riJ.ov TavTa TTOieiv' to. 8e 9r]pia rt? atrta ovt(os epco-
C TLK&s biaTi9cr9aL; exet? XiyeLv;
Kai eyo) av eXcyov otl ovk dbeirjv rj 8' etTrer, Atavo^
ovv 8eti'os' TTore yerTjo-eo-^at rd ipoiTLKd, idv Tavra ixr]

ivvofjs;

5 'AAAd 8id TavTd tol, S) Aiort/xa, oTrep vvvbr] etirov, Trapd

ce rJKd), yvovs otl bLbacrKdXoiiv biop.aL. dAAd p.OL Xiye

Kal TovT(t)V Tr]V ahiav Kal tG)V dAAo>y tQ>v Trept rd epcortKa.
Et Toivvv, l^r/, TTto-revets CKeivov etvai (J^vcth tov epooTa,
ov TtokXdKLS ^p.okoyr]Ka]J.ev, /xr) 9avp.a^. kvTav9a ydp
d Tov avTov iKeiv(a Xoyov r/ 9vr]Tr] (f)va-Ls C^ret KaTa to bvvaTov
dei re etyai Kai d9dvaTos. bvvaTaL 8e ravrrj jxovov, Tjj

yvi(Ti, OTL det KaraAetTret erepov viov dvTL tov TraAaioS,

eTret Kat iv w V Ka(TTOV t&v ^wcoy ^rjv KaAeFrat Kat eti^at

5 To avTO olov eK TtaLbapiov 6 avTos XiyeraL ecos av Trpe-

(r^VTr]s yivrjTaL' ovtos fxivTOL ovbTTOT ra avTa \u)V iv
avTS) opLO)s 6 avTos KaAetrat, dAAd ye'os det yLyv6]XV0s, rd
8e dTroAAvs, Kai Kard rds Tpi^as Kal o-dpKa Kal dcrrd Kai
e atpia Kal crvp.TTav to aS)]xa. Ka\ ]xr] otl KaTo. to crG)]xa,

dAAd KOt Kard Tr]V ^^vyr]V ot TpoiTOL, rd r^j^r], bo^at, iiTL^v-

bs Kttl alterum BT Oxy. : om. W avrh] avru Oxy. Ca o3

fAfyov b : avfXeyou B fe^ fKeyov W
T : e\eyov Oxy, cg dijUoAoyr;-
W W Oxy.
:

(Ta^tj/ Oxy. d2 Te T Oxy. : tJ) B a! T : om. IB

^3 T]! yfVifTti BTW Oxy. : secl. Vcrmehren 02 rpoiroi TW

Oxy. : tJttoi B
 STMnOSION 207 e

fiCaL, fjbovaC, XvTraL, (f)6fto(., tovtcdv (.KacTTa owSeTrore Ta

avTO. TTapecrTLV (KacrTi^, aWa fa [xev yiyveTaL, tci be a-nok-

XvTaL. TTokv be tovtuiv aTOTTcoTepov iTL, OTL Kal al (TtLcrTrjixaL 5

1X7] OTL ai fxkv yCyvovTai, al 8e aTToXXvvTaL ijixXv, Kal ovbe- 208

TTOTC OL avTOL kcr\xiv ovb^ KaTCL Tas kTTLCTTTiixas, aXKa Ka\

ixia kKacTTri tu)V iTTLcrTrjix&v tovtov 'nacryjE.L. o yap Kak^lTai

fxckcTav, 0)? i^Lovarjs (o-tI ttjs TTLa-T7]ixr)S' kridr] yap
(7TLa-T7]fxr}s e^obos, jueAer?? 8e TrdkLV KaLVi]V ijXTTOLova-a clvtI 5
Trjs aTTL0va-r]s ixvqfxriv o-w^ei ti]V iTTLcrTr]ixr]v, u>a-T Tr]V

aVT7]V boKHV (LVai. T0VT(O yhp T<a TpOITiO TTCLV t6 6vr]Tov

a-b)(kTaL, ov ro) TravTaTTao-LV to avTo aet eivat utcrTTep t6
Oelov, akka rw t6 clttlov Kal TTakaLOV[XVov ^Tepov v4ov b
iyKaTakeLTTeLv oXov auro -^v. TavTj] Ty jxr^xo-vfh ^ Sw-

KpaTs, ({)ri, 6vr]T6v adavacrLas )u,ere')(ei, /cat cr&ixa Kal Takka

TTCLVTa' a6dvaTov 8e dkki]. fxr] ovv ^avfxaC^ ei to avTov

aTTo^kdcTTr^ixa </)uo-ei Trav TLixa' ddavaaLas ydp ydpLV TravTl 5

aijTr] 7] (TTTOvbl] Ka\ 6 epCOS TTTaL.

Kat eyo) aKovcras t6v koyov e^avjxaad re Kot etTToy

Etey, "^v 8' eyw, a> crocpcoTdTr] ALOTLfxa, raCra w? dkr]6S>s

OVTO)S ^X^'
Kat 7% dSo-Trep ot reAeot crocf^La-TaL, Ev lo-^t, e07], oj C
SwKpares' eTret ye Kai t&v dv^pcaiTiov et e^e'Aets ets rr/y

^LkoTLixiav fiki^lraL, 6avixd(pLS dv T7]s dkoyCas Trep^ a eyoj

(Lpr]Ka et [xi] ivvoels, kv6vixr]6v,s u)S Seirws StaKeti^rat epcort
Tov ovofxaa-TOL yeveadaL Ka\ Kkeos es t6v det xpovov 5

d6dvaTov KaTa6ia-6aL, kol VTTep tovtov KLvbvvovs re

KLvbvvViv (TOLixoL etVt TTayray ert ixdkkov 77 VTrep tc7)v

TTaCbcav, kol \pr]]xaTa dvakCa-KCLV Ka\ ttovovs TTOViLV ova- d

rtrao-oSi' KOt v7TpaTTo6v7](rKLV. eTrei otet a~v, (f)ri, AkKr]crTLV

es eT( B Oxy. ; ^crriv TW a6 /uv^jurjj'] /xi^ijjur/ Oxy. &'] Ovr)-

rhv'\ ovTiTov B aS 011 T^] ovTU) B bs
wT6x<t Oxy. : ^6t'xjj'
BT W b4 adavaTov W Oxy.BT : a^vvarov Crenzer c r t<p-n

om. W C2 -ye TW B Oxy.

: om. 05 es B : us T W Oxy,
C7 irai/Ttj W naWov B W Oxy. om. T :
 :

2o8d nAATIiNOS
VTrep 'AS/XT/rou aTioOaveiv av, rj 'AxiAAea UaTpoKXio kir-

aTToOaveiv, r] irpoaTToOaveiv rbv vp.iTepov Kohpov virep Ttjs

5 ^ao-iAeta? rwy iraCbcov, pn] olop.ivovs addvaTov ixvriiJ.r]v

apeTrjs nipi kam&v iarea-OaL, fjv vvv 7//xets exofxev; ttoXXov

ye bel, <p'i], aAA' olfxai. vtt^p dper^s aOavaTov Kal ToiavTrjs
bo^rjs evKAeous irdvTes TTavTa ttolovctlv, 6(r(a hv dixeivovs
e uxTL, TO(rovT(o fjidWov' Tov yap dOavaTOV kpSxTLV. ol p.ev

ovv kyKvixoves, i({)r}, Kard Ta (T(i>p.aTa ovtcs TTpds Tas yvvaLKas

/xaAAoj' TpiiTovTaL kcu TavTrj kpoiTLKoi L(nv, 8ta TTaiboyovias

dOavacriav Kca }j.vr\\j.rjv Kal vbaLp.oviav, ws oioyrai, avrots

5 etj TOV ilTLTa \p6vOV TTaVTa TTOpL^^Op.eVOL' oX b\ KaTa TIJV

209 "^fv^ijiv dcrl ydp ovv, l</>7/, o\ kv tols '^vyals kvovctlv tl

p.dXXov ?/ iv Tols (r(aixa(TLV, h ^vxrj TTpo^ri^Kei Kal Kvrj(raL

Kal TeKcTv TL ovv TTpo(rr]KL; (f>p6vrj(riv re Kat Tr]v dXXrjv

dpeTrjv uv 8r/ eto-t Kat ot 7rotJ/rat TTavTes yevvijTopes Kal
5 rcoy brjixLovpyav o(rot kiyovTaL evp^TLKol ctvaL' ttoKv b\

lieyicrTr], (j)r], Kal KaAAto-r/ t7]s (ppovrj^reuis r] Trepl rd TUiV

'TToAewy re Kat otKT/o-ecoy bLaK6cr[j.r](rLs, 8r/ ovoiJ.d ((ttl

(r(a(f)poaijvr] re Kat bLKaLocrvvr] tovt(ov

fj

b' av oTav tls k

b re^oj; eyKVfxoov ff
Tr]v ^vxqv, fjOeos o)V Kal r]KOV(rr]s rrjs

^AtKtas, TiKTLV TC Kal yevvdv rjbr] k-TTLOvp.^, f^ret 8^

ot/xat Kat ovTOs TTepLLcov To KaXbv kv o) dv yevvqa-eLev ev
ro) ydp ala^xp^ ovbeiroTe yevv^a-eL. Ta re ovv (r(i)p.aTa Td
5 KaAa /xaAAoz; r] Ta ato-^^pa do-7ra^erai aTe kvS>v, kcu dv
evTv^rf "^vxfj KaA?/ Kat yevvaiq Kal ev(f)veL, ttuvv 8t/ do-Tra-

^erat ro (rvvaiJ.(f)6Tepov, Kal iTpbs tovtov Tbv dv9p(>)TTOV

evdvs evTTOpeX Aoyoji' Trept dpeTrjs Kal iTepl olov XPV ft'^"'

C rbv dvbpa Tbv dyaObv Ka\ d eiTLTrjbeveLV, Kal eTTL^eLpel

03 &/... C 4 vpoairodave7v om. W

d 6 irepl B T e 2 ra W
Oxy. : om. BT W aa Kal] T[a]e Kai Oxy. a^ T(Ke7v Oxy.
W
:

Kve7i> BT W a 6 Ttt Sommer Tay B T Oxy. : a 7 Sioko-

(Tfiriffis BTW Oxy. SiaKoafjL^ffeis al.
: a8 5' aS TW: S B Oxy.
bi yOeos Parmenticr: 0e7os BTW Oxy. hz emdvu-rt Oxy.
7riey)te7 BT W W
5V] Se hg nepl ai^ (i. e.irepiciiv)B bs ore
. . . b6 do-TTo^fTa: om. W b8 Trep) altcrum secl. Stephanus
 2;TMn02ION 209 c

TraiSevcti'. cnrTo^evos yap oi/jiat tov KaXov koI oixiXiav

avTu>, a TraAat KVL tUtl Kal yevvq, Kal Trapuiv Kal aTtoDV

[Xp.Vr]lXV09, Kttl TO y(VVr]$V (rVV(KTp(f)L KOlvfj IJ.T KLV0V,

aj(rre ttoXv /xet^w KOLVoiVLav ttjs tS>v iraLbwv irpbs a\Xi]\ovs 5
ol tolovtol l(T)(ov(rL Kal (pLXCav ^e^aLorepav, cLTe KakkLovuiV
KCLL adavaTo>Tp(iov iraLboiV KK0LV(avr]K6TS. Kal Tras av
8eatro kavTta TOLovTovi TratSas liaWov yeyovivaL 7/ tov9
avdpcoTrCrovs', Kal ets "Opi]pov aT:of3\\fras kcil *H<Tto8oi^ Kat d
roi;s' ctAAov? ttoli^tcis roi/s ayadovs ^r]\&v, ota Kyova eavTwv
KaTa\LTT0V(rLV, a Klvols aOavaTov k\os koX p.vr]p.i]V ttap-

\TaL avTCL ToLavTa ovra' et bi fiov\L, (f)i], oXovs AvKovpyos

TratSas KareA.t7rero V AaKebaCixovL (To^Tripas Tijs AaKeSat- 5

ixovos Kal W! eTTov etTreti' Trjs 'EAAa8os. tlixlos 8e Tiap

vp.LV Ka\ ^oAcoy 8ta ti]v t&v vop-ctiv yVvr]aLV, Kal aWoL
aWoOL TroWaxpv avbps, Kal V "EAAijat Kat V fiapfidpoLS, e
77oAAa Kat KaAa d7ro(f)r]vdp.VOL pya, yVvr]cravTS iravTOLav
dpTi]V' S>v KOL Upd TToWd i^jbr] yyov 8ta tovs tolovtovs !

TratSas, 5ta 8e tovs dvdpooTTLVOvs ovbv6s ttco.

Taura pLV ovv Ta ipcoTLKa ia-a)y, a> SwK/aares, Kdv crv 5

pLvr]6Lr]S' Ta 8e re'Aea Kat inoTTTLKd, &v VKa Kal Tama 210

crTLV, dv TLS opd&s p.TLr], ovK otS' ei oto's T dv etTJS.

epw pi.V ovv, cf>r], eyo) Kai iTpodvpLLas ovbV dTTo\L^oi'

7TLpoi 8e TT(r$aL, dv ol6s T j7S. 8et ydp, ^(pr]f tov 6p$a)s
l6vTa ttI tovto to TTpdyna dp\a-$ai pLv viov ovra UvaL 5
eirt Ta Ka\d cT(i)p.aTa, Ka\ iTp&Tov p.V, idv 6p$S)S r]yrJTaL

6 r]yovp.Vos, v6s avTov (r(ap.aTOs pdv koX VTav$a yvvdv

Aoyous KoAovy, TTLTa b\ avTov KaTavofjcraL otl to KaAAoy
TO TTL OT^aOVV (r(i)p.aTL rw eTTl Tp(ii (r(ap.aTL db\(f)6v (TTL, b
Kat et 8et StcoKety to eTr' etSet KaAo'i', ttoWi] dvoLa jut/ ovx

TW
C3 irapwi/ KcH airi>p B W Oxy. : anii;/ Kalvapiiv T C 6 /coAAioVwv
Oxy. KoXXiwv Siv U d5
Oxy. KarfAtwev
KareKiirfTo b
W
: :

rb B KaTeKeiireTo T
Oxy.
: d 7 vfuv T ^/ir/ B Oxy, W
<to\(idv :
. . .

e I V prius oin. Oxy. e 3 Ka\a.'] aWa Oxy. fpya kui

Ox3'. a 4 5e] Sf Kai <Tv Oxy. a 7 avThv T Oxy. avrwv B W
W
:

b 1 t6 B Oxy. T^ T : im T6>y B Oxy. kTep^f T W :

2iob nAATI2N0S
V T Kal TavTOV r)yi(r6aL to (ttI iraai.v tois crtaixacn KaAAos*

roGro 8' ivvorja-avTa KaTaa-TfjvaL irdvTcav tQiv Ka\S>v a-cofxaToiv

5 ipaa-TT^v, kvbs be t6 a^obpa tovto yjaXdcTai KaTacppovri-

aavTa Kal a-pnKpov i]yr]a-dfxevov' /utera 5e TavTa to kv rais

yjnxxcus KdXkos TijXLtaTepov rjyria-aa-OaL tov ev rw a-<aixaTL,

&a-Ti Kal iav ttlLkj]S o)V Tr]V \j/vxw ^'? '^^^ (T]XLKpov dvOos

C ex'/, i^apK^lv avT(a Kal epdv Kal KrjbeaOaL Kal tCktclv Koyovs
TOLOVTOVS Ka\ ^^^66^, otTLVS TTOL1]GrOVa-L jieXTLOVS TOVS
veovs, tva dvayKaaOf] av OedaacrdaL to kv toIs iTTLTr]bevp.aa-L
Ka\ TOLS v6]X0LS KakoV KCU TOVT ibelv OTL TTav avTO avT(a
5 a-vyyVS ecTTLV, Lva to Trept to cr&]xa Kakbv (r]XLKp6v tl
rjyr]ar]TaL elvaL' ]xeTa be to, iTTLTr]bV]xaTa cttI Tas TTLaTr]]xas

dyayeiv, tva tbi] av kTTL(rTr]]xS>v KdWos, KaL ^XeTT^av iTpos

d TTo\v rjbr] to Ka\bv ]xr]KiTL to iTap' kvL, coaiTep oiKerrjs,

dyaiT&v TTaLbapiov KaXkos r] dvOpcoTTOv TLvbs r] iiTLTr^bev-

]xaTos kv6s, bovkevoiv (f)av\os Kal a]XLKpok6yos, dXk! eTrt

fj

To TTokv irikayos rerpa/xjueVoj tov Kakov Kal 6(Dp5>v TTok-

5 kovs Kal Kakovs kdyovs koI ^xeyakoTTpeirets TLKT-p Kal bLovor]-

]xaTa iv (pLkoaocjiLq. d(f)d6v(o, (tis dv ivTavda p(aa6eLS Kal

av^r]d(ls KaTLbr] tlvcl iiTLaTr]]xr]V ]XLav T0LavTr]V, ij iaTL Kakov

e TOLOvbe. TTiLpGt bi ]X0L, ^(f)r], Tbv vovv TTpoaixeLV ws oXov

re ]xdkLaTa. os ydp dv ]xixpL ivTav6a Trpbs tcl epcoriKa

TTaLbaycoyr]6r], d(a]xevos i(f)^s re Kai opd&s Ta Kakd, TTpbs

reAo? 7/817 '^^ "^^^ ip(t)TLKS)V i^aL(f)vr]s KaT6\f/eTaL tl 6av-

5 ]xaaTbv Tr]V (fivaLV Kak6v, tovto iKetvo, w 2coKpare?, ov br]

VKV Kul OL ^]X7Tpoa6ev TTdvTes it6vol r]aav, TTpG^Tov ]xev

211 del ov Kal ovTe yLyv6]xevov ovTe dTTokkv]xevov, ovTe av^av6-
jxevov oijTe (P6lvov, ^iTeLTa ov Trj ]xev Kak6v, Trj 8' ala\p6v,
ovbe TOTe ]xiv, Tore be ov, ovbe TTpbs [xev Tb Kak6v, TTpbs

b4 Tovro BW Oxy. : rovrci) T b8 Ktiv Hermann : koI ikv BT

Oxy. KoiiLv W c2 kuI secl. Badham o'lTives B T Oxy. : i

% T Wd
:

rives W 07 'Iva : Iv diSrji B : ivc. eiSri

Coisl.
Oxy, d i tJ]
B T W
Ty Schlciermachcr 5 tIktji corr. : riKTfi
d6 pwOfh W a3 ToTf 5t ] To'5t Sf Oxy.
 STMnOSION 2na
be To alcryjpov, ovb' (vda fxev Kakov, vda b^ ala^pov, ws
TLcrl p.ev ov KaXov, rtfri be aicrxpov ovf av (f)avTa(r6i](reTai. 5

avTio To Kakov oTov ovbe X^^P^^ ^^^ aAA.o

TrpocrooiTov tl

ovbev b)V (TiaiJLa p.T\L, ovbe TLS Xoyos ovb4 T19 irLa-Tri[xr],

Ovbi TTOV OV (V kTp(f TLVL, oloV V ^WW 7] V yf] 7] V OVpttViO

rj V rw aAAo), dAA' avTo Kad^ avTO jue^' avrov p.ovoLbs ael b
6v, TCL be aAAa irdvTa Kaka Klvov p.TypvTa Tpoirov tlvcl
TOLOVTOV, olov yLyVO]XV(iiV T Tdv aWcoV Kal a'K0XXvp.V(iiV
p.r]bV KLVO ]xr]T TL Ttkiov fXTjTf ^kaTTOV yLyvcr6ai firjbe

TrdcrxeLV ]xr]bv. oTav h] tls 0,770 T&vbe bia to opdats iTaL- 5

bpa(rTLV irravLuiV Klvo to KaXov dpyr]TaL Kadopdv, cr^ebov
dv TL aiTTOLTO TOV Tk0VS. / TOVrO ydp br] (rTL TO 6p6&s 7tI

rd epiiiTLKa Uvai 17 vtt' aAAou dy(r6aL, dpxojJ.evov diTo C

Toivbe Tutv Kaku>v Klvov VKa Tov Kakov dei TxavLvaL,

a)cnTp TTava^acrixols xP^l^^^^v, diro kvos tt\ 8t;o kclI otto

bvolv knX TTavTa rd KaAd crcafxaTa, Kal aTTo t&v KoXcav

(r(i)]xdT(ov ttI Ta Kakd TTLTr]bV]xaTa, Kal diTd tS)v e7riTrj8eu- 5
]xdT(ji)v TTL Ta Kakd fxa6r]]xaTa, kcll OTto t&v ixa6r]ixdT(t)V ^tt'

KLVo To pLd6r]]xa TkVTr](raL, o (rTLV OVK dAAov 1] avTOV

KLVOV T(}V KdkoV ]xd6r]]Xa, Kal yvCd aVTO TkVTS)V CrTL

Kdkov. ' VTav6a tov jSlov, S) <^iAe 2(0K/3aTes, e^rj 77 May- d

TLVLKl] ^Vr], LTTp TTOV dkko^L, ^L0)T0V dvdp(aTT(0, 60)]XV(O
avTo To Kakov. b idv ttot Ibrjs, ov Kard xpvcTLOV t Kal
(r6rjTa Kal tovs fcaAovs iTaTbds t kol vavC(rKOvs b6^L croL

etrat, ovs vvv dpS)v KTTTrkr]^aL Kal TOLfxos ei Kal crv Kal 5

dAAot TToAAot, bpG)VTS rd iTaLbLKa Kal crvv6vTS det avToty,

et iT(os oX6v T r]V, ]xr]T (r6LLV fxr]T ttlvLV, dkXd ded^rdai
]x6vov Kal (TvvelvaL. tC biJTa, (f)r], ol6]X6a, et to) yivoLTO

avTo To Kakov Ibelv elkLKpLvis, Ka6ap6v, d]XLKTOv, dkkd Q

a4 ci/doSe 5e Oxy. cly . . a 5 cdffxp^v secl. Voegelin a 6 ahrlp]

W
.

axnh W a8 ttou] iro) b 2 Tp6irov riva B Oxy. : riva rpoirov

W
TW b4 4k(7vo B Oxy. iKfivcpTW bs ^ B : 5^ Si? T
W
:

C 3 eiravafiaffixols T Oxy. (navafiadfiols B C 7 re\fVT7Jffai

W
:

Usener TtKfvri^ari BT W (j? in ras. W) d i fiavriKi) (/c^ in

W
:

ras.) d 3 irore {'Stjs Oxy, iroT() : jS^s B T XP^^'"' Oxy.

d7 eeoo-^ai T W 0ed(ra(Teai B Oxy,
:
2iie nAATONOS
fxi] avaTrkem' aapKm' re avdpoiTTivm' Kal \p(iiixaTm' Ka\
aKkr]<i TToWrjs (j)kvapLas $vr]Ti}S, dXA' avrb t6 deXov Kakbv
bvvatTO piovofLbes KariSeu'; Sp' otei, e0r;, (jiavXov /Sior

212 yCyv<rdaL e/ceto-f (BkeTTOVTOs avOpomov koX eKelvo w Set

6(i)pi.vov Kal (TvvovTOS ovTi^; 7/ ovK kv6v[i^, e^jj, ort kvTav6a

avrw ixova)(Ov yevrj^reTai., opwvTt w opaTov to koKov, tlktIV
ovK ei8a)Xa apeTrjs, aT ovk eib(6kov k^paiTToixivdd, akka
5 akr]drj, aTc tov akri6ovs ((jiaTTTOjjiivio' tk6vtl be apeTrjv
akrjdi] Ktti 6pe-^aiJiev(o vTrapy^eL 6eo(f)LkeL yevi(r6aL, kcll eLTrep

ro) akk(> av6p(aTToi)v adavaT(^ Ka\ eKeLVi^;

b TaSra 877, Z) ^albpi re Kat ot aAAot, e^rj piev Atort/xa,

TreTre tcr/xat 8' eyw* TTeTTeL^rp.evos be TTeLp&ixaL Ka\ tovs akkovs

TTeC^eLV OTL TOVTov Tov KTr\]iaTos Trj av6p(aTTeL(i (f)va-eL crvv-

epybv aixeCva) "Ep^oTos ovk av tls pqbLO)s kd(3oL. bLo 8?;

5 eycoye ^r///,i \pr\vaL iTaVTa avbpa tov "Epcora TL[j,av, Kal

avTbs TLfJL& To. e/MortKa Kat bLa<pep6vT(t)s a(rKM, Ka\ rots
aAAot? TTapaKekevoiiaL, koX vvv re Kat dei eyKw/xtd^w Tr]V

bvvap.LV kcll dvbpeLav Tov^EpodTos Ka6' o(rov ol6s t et/xt. tov-

C Tov ovv Tbv k6yov, S) ^i^albpe, el /xey (3ovkeL, o)? eyK(ap.L0V els

"Epo^Ta v6]XL(Tov elpfj(r6aL, ei be, otl Ka\ ottt/ ^(atpets dvoixd^o)v,

TovTo 6v6pia^e,

Elttovtos be Tavra tov ^o^KpaTovs tovs fxev e-rraLvelv, tov

5 8e ^ ApLcrT0(f)dvr] keyeLV tl eTTL\eLpe'LV, otl iixvrj(r6r] avTov
key(i)V 6 2(iOK/)drrj9 77ept tov kdyov Ka\ e^aL(f)vr]s Tr]v avkeLov
6vpav Kpovo]xevr]v TTokvv \fr6(f>ov TTapacryelv ws Ko)]xacrTO)V, KaL

avkrjTpCbos (f)0)vr]V aKOveLv. Tbv ovv ' Ayd6o)va, ITatSes, (f)dvaL,

d ov (rKe\f/a-de; Ka\ eav ]xev tls tG)V eirLTr^beCoiV r], KoAeire*

ct 8e /17/, Ae'yere ort ov TrCvofxev dAA' dvaTrav6]xe6a rjbr].

e4 ?^ B W Oxy. : om. T a i (^" Se?] & Se? B iSl B S StT

: :

TW a6 06o^i\6? rec. Oxy. BTW t : eeo<pt\7J bi om. Oxy.ii

05 (Trtxeipdv Xtyetv Oxy. C6 avXetou

rt rec. t Oxy. : avXtov
BTW 07 3 "W Ox.y.:
Kpovofify7)v KpoTovfi4vT)v T d.2 aAAa
7rai;o[ju0a] Oxy.
 STMnOSION 2i2d

Kai 011 7:okv va-Tepov 'AAKt/3ta8ov rijV (f)U)viji' aKoveiv iv

Tt] avkfj (T(l)6bpa jxedvovTos Kal iiiyci ^oSiVTos, fpcoTcovTOs
oTTov ^Ayd6(t)v Kal KckevovTos ayeiv Trap' 'Ayd6(ova. dydv 5
ovv avTov TTapa (r(f)as Trjv re avkrjTpiba VTToXa^ovcrav Koi
dXXovi rtms t5)V aKoXovd^av, Kal 7rt(rTi]vai CTTt Tas dvpas
i(rT(f)av(t)pL^vov avTov klttov re rii^i (m(f)dv(a bacrfi Kal e
L(i)v, Kal TaLvCas (XpvTa eTrt Trjs K(f)akTJs Trdvv TToXXds, Kal
eiTrety* "Avbpes, y(aLpeTV [xedvovTa avbpa Ttdvv (r(f)6bpa

b^crd crviJLTTdTrjv, rj aTiLb^iKV dvabri(ravTs piovov 'Ayddo)va,

i(f)' ^irep T]k6ofj.ev; eyo) ydp tol, (f>dvaL, X^^^ H-^^ ^X 5

otos T yv6p.r]v d(f)LK4(r6aL, vvv 8e r]K(t) cTri ttj K(f)aki]

iyutv ras TaivCas, tva dirb ttjs ifJLrjs K(f>akrjs Tr]v tov ao(f)(t)-

rdTOV KOL KakkC(TTov Ke(f>akr]V mv eXiTco ovT(t)crl dvabr]cr(t).

apa KaTaykd(r(rdi p.ov u>s p.6vovTOs; eyo) 8e, Kdv vp.LS

yekaTi, ofJMs V oi3' ori dkr]6r] key(t). dkkd fxoL ktyeTe 213
avT66ev, eirt prjrot? etcrto) rj p.r]; (rv\xiTCcr6e r/ ov;
ndyras ovv dva6opvj3rj(TaL KOt KekeveLv el(rLevaL Ka\
KaTaKkCvecr6aL, Kal tov 'Ayd6(t)va Kakelv airrdv. Kal tov
levaL dydpievov vtto tG)V dv6p(a7T(i)V, Kal TTepLaLpovp,evov dfxa 5
Tas TaLvCas ws dvabr](rovTa, eTTLiTpocr^e tG)V 6(f)6akfxa>v e^ovTa
ov KaTLbelv tov ^(OKpaTr], dkkd Ka6CC(cr6aL Trapd tov 'Ayd-
6(t)va ev jueVo) Sto/cpdrovs re Kai eKeCvov TTapax(t)prj(raL b
yap Tov ^coKpdTT] ws eKeti^oy KartSety. iTapaKa^eCdixevov
be avTov dcTTTdCecr^aC re tov 'Ayd6(t)va Kal dvabelv.
EiTreti; ovv tov 'Aydd(t)va 'T-TroAvere, ffatSes, AkKL^tAbr]v, '

Xva eK TpCT(t)v KaTaKerjTaL. 5

ndvv ye, eLTTeiv tov 'AAKt/3td8?jv dAAa ris rjfXLV o8e
TpCTos (TVjXTTdrqs ; Kal a]xa pLeTacTTpe(f)6fxevov avrbv bpdv

6 2 Ttttj/tas TW Oxy. : nvlas B (et mox) 64 Sflfo-fle B Oxy.

U^aaOf T W ^iTff, B Oxy. : gxfp T W J?Aeo/tev T W Oxy.
:

^X^^oiiev B iyOisOxy. e6 oUi t' T W Oxy. 6ts t' B e 8 iav

W
:

IVa) ovrwal BT Oxy. ^oj' ttirco oinaxA

: Kf<pa\^v : avftirwv ovtuxtI
Winckelmann &3 KfXfvnvTW Oxy. : KfKfvfiB b2 /coTj5e[7j/]
Oxy. KaBiCftv
: BTW b6 J(6 rpiros W Oxy. ^Se rpiros B:
W Oxy.
:

TpjTos 85e T b7 6pav T : 6p^ B

 :

2i3b nAATllNOS
Tov '2(tiKpdTr], ibovTa be di^a7rrj8r/o-at koI eiireiy 'i2 'HpaKAet?,
tovtI tl i]v; ^(i>KpaTr\s ovtos; iXkox^v av fxe evTavda KaTe-
C Keto-o, uxnrep clcadeis (^aicpvrjs avatpaivea-Qai ottov eycb oifxiiv

rJKLCTTd cre eo-eo-^ai. Kat vvv tl rJKCLs; Kal tl av fVTavda

KaTCKkivrjs ; wy ov -napa ^ApL(rTo^avL ov8e et rts dAAos
yeXoios eo-rt re Kat ^ovkeTaL, akka bLefxrjxavricra) oirtos Trapd

5 tS> KaWCcTTio tS)v vbov KaTaKeCcrr].

Kai Tov ^(liKpaTrj, ^AyaOcov, cfidvaL, opa et juot iirafxvveLS'

o)$ (IJ.OL 6 TovTov epcos Tov avdpooTTOv ov (jiavkov TTpayp.a

yiyovev. di: iKeCvov yap tov \p6vov, dcf)^ ov tovtov
d 'qpd(r6riv, ovKeTL i^ecrTCv fxOL ovre Trpoa-jSkiyj/aL ovt 8ia-
kexdrjvaL KakS> ovb^ kvC, rj ovtoctI 0]koTVTTO)v jxe Kal ^OovGtv

davjxacTTa epyd^erat Kai AotSopetrat re Kat rcb x^^P^ ixoyis

aTTex^Tai. opa ovv fxri tl kcCl vvv ipydarfTaL, dkXa 8tdX-
6 ka^ov riixds, r/ edr eTTLXd-pfj jSLa^ecrdaL, eTrdjUDye, o)? eyo)

Trp TOVTOV fxavCav re Kat (^tXepaaTCav irdvv oppcaboi.

'AAA' ovK e(TTL, (f)dvaL tov 'AAKt/3td8rji', ejuot Kat o-oi StaA.-

kayrj. dkka tovtcdv ixev ei? av^ts o-e TLpiCoprjcroixaL' vvv

e b4 ixoL, ^Ayd9oi)v, ^dvai, fxcTdbos t5)V TaLVLuiv, tva dvabricroi)

Kal Triv TOVTOV TavTrivl Trjv OavjxacrTriv K(f)akriv, Ka\ firi jxol

lxix(f)riTaL OTL o-e ixev dvibricra, avTov b\ VLK&VTa iv Xdyots

irdi^ras dvdpooTTovs, ov fxovov TTp^riv &(nTp crv, dAA' det,
5 eiretra ovk dvibrjcra, Kal d//,' avTov ka^ovTa tSiv TaLVL&v
dvabelv tov IlcoKpdrrj Kat KaTaKkCvecrOaL.
'E-jretS^ be KaTiKkCvri, eiTretv Etei' br], avbpes' SoKetre
ydp ixoL vri(f)LV. ovk eiTLTpeTTTeov ovv vpuv, dkka ttotOV'
w/ixoAdyrjrat ydp Tav9' rjixlv. dpxovra ovv alpovixaL Trjs

lo Trdo-ecos, eco? dv v/xets iKai^ws TTCriTe, eixavTov. dXkd 0epe'ra),

b9
Oxy.
W Oxy.
toutJ Tt ^r T B W iWox^f
BTW (deest Oxy.)
B
: TW
toiJt' eiTrfiy
Hermann
et yp.
: 03
tv\oxS>v dis : /co2

B Oxy.
oiiSe TW C4 : oi;t Oxy. e B T\_i\efn)xa.v7i(Tu> 7 i : ou
TW d2 B W (sed supra Oxy.
owTotri *** T xws
(^ 0) : ovTO(r\ {ovroa-l
Coisl.) ds B Oxy. TW
Oavfxa^TTa, ds B : OavjMiata eWjuvi^ai
e I T W Oxy.
dj/oS^o-ft) Ka\ B e8 : T W Oxy.
avaSria-iifjieda ovv
om. B 10 post (peptTO! distinxi
 ISTMnOSION }ji3

\\yd6(ji}V, ct TL ^(TTiv eKTTCD/jta ixiya^ fmWov de ovh(.v bti,

aKka (f)p, Ttal, (f>dvat., tov y^vKrqpa ckcIvov, ibovTa avTov
TrA.eov r) oKTut KOTvXas xcopovvra. tovtov k[n:X.r\(TdyLivov 814
trpSiTov fxkv avTov kKTtifXv, eTrcira rw Sco/cparet KeA.eveiy

^yX^lv KoX dp.a etTTeii'' Vlpos pkv ^(aKpdrrj, Si dvbpcs, t6

(r6(f)i(rixd p.01. ovhiv dnocrov yap av Ki.kivr\ riy, to^tovtov
eKTTtcoy ovh\v imKKov iiri Trore fXidvcrO^. 5
Tov fxkv ovv 2ft)Kpar77 iyxiavTos tov 'jraiSos Trti/ctf roy
8' ^Kpv^ip.ayov YlSis ovv, (j)dvai, S) 'AAKt/3t(i8i/, iroiovp.iv;

OVT(t)S OVT TL X^yOfXV iirl Trj KVkLKL OVT Tt. abofXV, dAA.' b
aTfxvias (oo-TTep ot bL\lru>VTS TTLOfx^Oa;

Tbv ovv 'AAKt/3td8rjy etTreti' ^H 'Epvfijuaxe, /3e'Arto-re

jSekTC^TTov TiaTpos KoX (r())(ppov(TTdTov, )(atpe.

Kal yap o-v, (pdvaL tov ^Epv^Cpiaxov' aXka tC iioL&fXiv; 5

"Ort av (Tv KeAevT??. 8et ydp (tol ixiidia-daL'

IrfTpos yap dvi]p iroAAcSy dyrd^tos dAAay

iiTLTaTT ovv OTi /3ovAet.

Akovo-oi' bi], etTTeti' tov 'Epv^Cfxaxov. iffxlv Trplv re

eto-eA^ety eSo^e XprjvaL (ttI 8e^td cKacrTov v fxip^L koyov 10

TTepl 'Epcoros etTreti' o)? Swatro KaAAto-roi', Kat eyKco/xtdo-at. c

ot /jtey ovv dkkoL TrdvTis rjfKxs lpriKafi.V' ot> 8' e7ret87) ovk
etprfKas Kal iKTT^ircoKas, StKatoy et eiTreti', etTrcoi' 8e eTrtrd^at
2a>K/)dret ort dy ^ovkrf, kcu tovtov rw eirV 8e^td Kat ovtc
Tovs dAAou?. 5
'AAAd, (fidvaL, 2 ^Epv^Cfxax^, tov 'AAKt/3td8r/y, Kak&s fxkv

kiyeis, fxcdvovra 8e dvbpa iiapa. vrf^ovTOiV koyovs Ttapa-

(iakXLV fxrf ovK e^ to-ou rj. Kal dfxa, od fxaKdpL, Tret^ei ri
o-e ScoK/adrTjy (Sy dprt etTrei'; */ oto-^a ori TovvavTCov eo-rt d
KCLV rf 6 kyv; ovtos ydp, idv TLva eyco eTratyeVco rovrou

en tKTrcDMo TW Oxy. (Knofia B a^ biro&ov BT Oxy.

W
:

n6(Tov KtAeyj; B Oxy. /ctAewj; T W b i o(/t tj ^Sofitv

;

W
:

T : oi/T' iir^Sofjitv B b 6 &/ T W 8' & T b7 irirphs T ;

W
:

larphs BW c8 ti' BT : ts
PLATO, VOL. il. li .
214 d riAATXlNOS
irapovTOs rj dcov rj avdpiDTTov akXov rj tovtov, ovk a(f)^eTaC
fJiOV TO) x^^P^-

5 OvK (vcfyrifxria-eLs; (pdvaL tov '^ioKpaTr].

, Ma Tov no(rei8(S, ctTreiy tov 'AAKi/^iaSr/y, ixr]bV Xeye

TTpos TavTa, b)s eyo) ovb' av iva aXkov kTTaivia-aifxi a-ov

TrapovTos.
'AA.A' ovTOi TTotet, (f)dvat. tov ^lipv^ip.ayov, et ^ovkw
lo 'SiOiKpaxy] fTTaCvea-ov.
e n<as \4yts; eJirety tov 'AXKt/StaSrjy 8oKet xprjvai, Z)

Eput)aa)(e; kTiidCijxai rw drSpt Kat TLp,oi)pri(T(i)iiai vp.S)V

kvavTiov;
OvTos, (f)dvai Tov ^o)KpdTr], rt ey vio ixeLs; eTTt ra
5 yeXoLOTepd /xe kiraivia-ai; r] tC 7rot?7o-ets;

TdAvj^^ epw. dAA.' opa et Traptrjs.

'AWa jxevToi, (f^dvai, rd ye dXr]6rj trapCr^iJit, Kal KeAevto

Ae^yeiv.

OvK dy ^Odvoiixi, direiv tov ^A.\Ki^idbr]v. Ka\ p.ivToi

lo ovT(i)a-\ TToCr^aov. edv rt pLT] d\r]6s Ae'ya), /u,era^ eTnka/Sov,
av ^ovkri, Ka\ etTre ort tovto ^evbofxai,' eKoov yap eivai, ovbev
215 ^eva-o]j,at. edv ixevTOi dvaixi[xvr]a-K6]ievos dXXo dkko6ev
keyo), fxr]bev 6av]xda"rjS' ov ydp tl pabLov Tr]v (rr]v dTOirCav
S)b^ ^XPVTL evTTopo^s KOL e(j)e^s KaTapL6pi,riaaL.

'Eo^KpaTr] 5' lyo) eTTatvetv, o) dvbpes, ovto)s eTrtxeip^crco,

5 8t' etKWcoy. ovtos ]x\v ovv tcrcas olr](reTaL eTrt to, yekoLOTepa,
^a-TaL 8' r] elKO)V tov dkr]6ovs eveKa, ov tov yekoCov. (})r]ix\

yap br] ofxoLOTaTov avTov eXvaL rois o-tATjrots tovtols tols

b ev rois epixoykv(f)eCoLs KadrnxevoLS, ovaTLvas ipyd^ovTaL ol
br]]XLOvpyo\ avpLyyas r] avkovs exoVTas, ot 8txd8e Stotx^e^i^re?

^aCvovTaL ^vbo6ev dydkfxaTa Ixo^^^^^ ^e&v. Ka\ (prifx\ av

koLKevaL avTov roi o-aTvpco rw Mapo"va. ort ixev ovv t6 ye

62 Ttfj.ci!p{i(rofiai W 65 enaivtffai scripsi eiraiveVetj BTW;

W
:

iiraiuf(rei Bekker a7 <Ti\rivo7s BT (ti supra i W)

 2TMU02I0N 2i5b

eidos ofxoioi ei tovtol9, oi Sw/cpares, ovb' avros av ttov 5

aix(pL(Tj3r]Tricrais' s 8e Kai rSAAa eotfca?, /xera rouro aKoue.

vl3pL(rT7]s et' ?) ov; eai^ yap p; 6/aoXoy^s, fxdprvpas iTap-

c^oixai. dAA' ovk avATjrTjj; ttoAi; ye 6avfxa<TL(aTpos Klvov.

6 p.v ye 81' dpyaz/coi' eK7;Aci tovs avOp^airovs Tfj 0.176 tov c
(TTopiaTos bvvdixL, Kal TL wv\ hs av TCL
KLvov av\fj b, yap
"OkvixTios r\vkL, Mapa-vov Aeyo), rovrov hlbd^avTos to. ovv
(KLvov idvT dyados avXrjTris avXfj idvTC (\>avX.r] avKr]Tpis,

fxova KaT)((r6aL Troiei kcll StjAoi tovs T(av 6<av re Kai 5

reAeraii' bOfXVovs bLo, to ^eia cTvai. a-v 8' Klvov to^tovtov

fxovov bLa(j)pLs, otl dvv 6pydv(tiv \/^tAors Ao'yots tovtov
TovTO TTOtets. ?7/ixets yovv oTav fXV tov aAAou dK0V(afXv d
Ae'yoyros Kat Trdvv dya6ov prfTopos aAAous Adyovs, ov8ey
fX\L ws Ittos etVety ovbvi kir^Lbdv 8e aov rts dKovr\ rf t&v
(T&v Adycoy SAAou Ae'yoyros, Khv Trdvv <j)av\os fj
6 X4y<ov,
dvT yVVr] aKOVr] dvT dvi]p idvT fXLpdKL0V, KTT1T\ri- 5

yfXVOL (TfXV Ka\ KaTx6fX6a. eyo) yovv, u) dvbps, et fxrj

e/oteAAoy KopLLbfj b6^LV fX6vLV, ilTTOV dfxoaas av vfxlv ota 8t)

TTTT0v6a avTos VTTo tS)V tovtov X6y(i)v Kat 7rao"x<w ert Kat

vvvL. oTav ydp aKovo), ttoKv fxoL fxdX\.ov 7) t&v Kopv^av- e

TL(j)VT(>)v rj T Kapbia TTr]bq Kal bdKpva eK^etrat vtto r&v
\6yo)V t5)V tovtov, 6p& 8e Kai aAAovs Tra/ixTrdAAous Ta
avTa TTda")(ovTas' IleptKAeovs 8e aKOvcov kol d\\o)v dya65>v
pr^TOpcov V fXV riyovfxriv Aeyeii', tolovtov 8' ovbv iiTaa^ov, 5
ov8' T6opv^r]T6 fxov rf "^XV ov8' r)yavdKTL ws dvbpaiTobd)-
8a)s 8taKei/xe'you, dAA' vtto tovtov\ tov Mapaijov TroAAaKts 8f;

ourco bLTi6r]v &aT fxoL bo^ai fxr] ^uaTov eii^ai li\ovTL ws ai6
)(0). KoX TavTa, S) SwKpares, ovk epets ws ovk d\r]6fj. kol
TL ye vvv avvoLb' e/xairrai drt eZ e^e'Aot/jtt Trape^xety tcl S)Ta,

oi/K dv KapTprfa-aLfxi dAAa raura dv TrdayoLfXL. dvayKaQ^L

hs y 1T0V Baiter : S^ vov BTW G3 o^v B T: 7' oiv W

e I vvvi. B vvv T W e 3 rwv tovtov T W tovtov B
: aa
W
:

T W : om. B a^ ifiavT^ BT: ifiavThv (o in ras.)

14*
 ;

2i6a nAATilNOS
5 yap /xe 6}xo\oyiiv oti ttoAAov ivbei^s oov avros eri enavTov

fj.V djaeAw, to, 8' W.Orivai(x)v npa.TTOi, jSiq ovv axTTTcp a-no
T&v "SiCLprivoov iTna-xdp-^vos to. wra oX\oixai (f^fvya^v, Xva pj]

avTOV Ka6^p.Vos Trapa tovtio KaTayiipaa-u). TiiTtovOa 8e

b 77/305 TOVTOV pLOVOV av6p(01T<i)V, O OVK aV TLS oloLTO kv (jXol

(Vfivai, To ala-)(yva-6aL ovtlvovv iyoi be tovtov fiovov

ala-yyvopuaL. avvoLba yap ep.avTG) avTLX^yiLV p.\v ov bvva-
jueVa) ws ov Sei Troieiy h ovtos KeAevei, (iKLhav 8e aTriXdai,
5 rjTTrjiiivM Trjs ri/ix^s Trjs virb t&v 7ToXk(av. bpaTTfTCVCo ovv

avTov Kal (f)vyo), Ka\ oTav Xbo), ala-yyvofxaL to. ft)/xoAoyr//xe'ya.

C KOL TToKkaKLS ixkv r]b4o)s av iSoi/xt avTov /x?/ ovra iv av6p(aTT0LS'

ei 8' av TovTo yivoLTo, eS oiSa ori ttoAv pid^ov av a)(6oLp.r]v,

U)(rT ovK Ix.'^ ori xp^qcr^ap.aL rovro) rai av6p(aTT(o.

Kai VTTO /jtey brj tu>v avkriix(XTO)v kol eyco Kal aAAot ttoAAoI
5 roiavra TTeTTovdaaLV vtto Tovbe tov aaTvpov' aAAa 8e efxov

aKov(raTe <ws ofxoLos t ecTTlv ols eyo) rjKaa-a avTov kcll t7]v

bvvaixLV 0)5 6avixaa-Lav ex^i. ew yap taTe otl ovbels vp.5)v

d TOVTOV yLyvdio-KH' akka eyo) ^t/Awcto), eTretTrep rjp^dixriv.

opcLTe yap otl Sco/cparr/s e/jcortxws StaKetrat rwy KaAwy Kai

det Trepi rourous eo-ri Kat iKiTiiTkriKTaL, kol av ayvod iTavTa
Kal ovbcv olbev. ws t6 (r)(rjp.a avTov tovto ov (rikriviabcs

5 a-(f)6bpa ye. tovto yap ovtos i^o)9V TT^pLfii^kriTaL, wo-Tre/)

6 yeykvixixivos ctAr/yo'?* evbodev 8e dyotx^eis tto^o-tjs oteo-^e

yefxeL, S) a.vbpes crvixTTOTaL, cro)^po(Tvvris; Xa-Ti otl ovt eX tls

KaAos eo-rt /xeAet avT^ ovbiv, akka KaTa(f)povX ToaovTov
e oaov ovh' av eXs olrideLri, ovt et rts 7rAovo-toj, ovt et akkriv

TLva TLixriv XO)V tS)v vtto TTkri6ovs ixaKapLCopi.V()V' fjyelTaL

b TTavTa TavTa to. KTrJixaTa ovbevos a^La kol r)ixas ovbev
eivat Ae'ya) vixiv Lp(i)Vv6p.Vos 8e Kat Trat^o)!' TTavTa tov

5 ^toy TTpos Tovs av6p(a7rovs 8tareAet. o-TrovSdo-ai^ros 8e auroS

a5 f T T W Ti B b4 ovtos BT : aMs W _ 03 xpv-

TW
:

rrwiJiai corr. Ven. 185: xP^o-o^uai BTW ds a5 B: om.

d6 ffyKvtt.fi.tvos BT ; iyytyKvnixivos W
 :

STMnOETON 2i6e

Koi avoi\6ivTo^ ovk otba et rt? k^paKiV tcl ivToi ayaAjuara*

dAA' eyu) Ijbt] Tror' c7bov, KaC juot (bo^ev ovtoo deTa Kal
Xpvara civai Kol irdyKaka Koi davuaa-Ta, wcrTe iTOiqTCOv (tvai 217
ip.^payy oti KfXevoi ^(aKpaTr^s. r]yovp.ivos b\ avTov (criTov-

baKvaL e77t Trj pi.rj &pa ep/xatoy r]yri<rdp.riv etvat Kal iVTVXf]p-o.

i]wv Oavfxaa-Tov, ws vTrdpxov ixol xapLaafxivio 2ft)/cparet Trai^r'

dKOva-at 0(raTTp ovtos 7?8ef <pp6vovv ydp br] e77i r^ &pa 5

Oavjxda-iov oaov. raCra ovv bLavorjOeCs, Trpb tov ovk etco^wy

dvev dKo\ov6ov juoVo? juer' avroi) yiyvea-^aL, t6t dTTOTrifj.TToyv

Tov dKdkovdov jxdvos a~vvyLyv6[xr]v 8et ydp iTpos vfxds Trorra b
TdXr]6fj LTTLV' dAAa TTpoaiy^T^ tov vovv, koX ei yjr^vbofxaL,
SwKparey, e^e'Aeyxc crvvyLyv6ixr]v ydp, Sz^Spey, jiioVo?

]x6v(a, KOL ^]xr]v avTLKa 8iaAe'^eo-^at avT6v ]xol diTp dv

ipacTTT^s TratStKots v pr]]XLa StaAex^eiJ?, fat iyaLpov. tovt(ov 5
8' ov ]xd\a iyiyvcTO ovbdv, dAA' &cnTp l(a6L SiaAex^fi? cti'

/zot Kai (Tvvr]]Xpvaas yx^''" aTrtwi'. fxera raura (rvyyv]xvd-

^(T6aL 7TpovKakovixr]v avTov kol crvvyv[xva(6]xr]v, ws tl c
VTavda TTpavS>v. crvvyv]xvd(To ovv fxoi Kal TTpoa-TTd\aLv
TToWaKLS ovbvbs TTapdvTos' Kal TL 8et \yLv; ovbv ydp
]xoL tt\Ov r]V. TTLbr] 8e ovba]xr] TavTr] '^vt/rov, ibo^i ]xol
ttl6Tov XvaL rw dvbpl KaTa to KapTpbv /cat ovk dvTOv, 5
TTLbr]iTp VKyjLpr]Kr], dWd l(TTOV r]br] TL crTL Tb TTpdyfxa.
TTfioKa^ovjxaL br] avrbv TTpbs Tb crvvb^LTTV^lv, dTXV&s U)CnTp
paa-Tl]S TTaLbLKoXs TTLJ3ov\V(t)V. Kai ]XOL 0vb TOVTO Ta^V
VTT1]K0Va-V, OJUO)? 8' OVV Xpdvdi 1TLa-6r]. TTLbl] bk d(f)LKTO d
Tb TTpGtTOV, bL1TVr]araS dlTLivaL ^0V\T0. Kal t6t IXV
aLa-)(vv6]XVos d(\>r]Ka avTdv av6LS 8' TTLfiov\vaas, eTretS?/
e8e8et7n^Ke)itey 8teAeyo'firjy del iroppca t&v vvkt&v, Kal e7ret8?/

e 7 Kai fioi T W : Koi f/io\ B Ka/j.o] Hirschig

: a2 ffifipaxv
Cobet: ^j/ /Spaxf? BT W a5 5^B: jJSijTW ba ra\r,ev
BT : ixrieri W b6 5' 01-] 817 Oxy. ./ B T W : a5 F. A. Wolf
S^ Saiippe c I Kal ffvviyvfiva^6/i7\u secl. Sauppe d4 iie-
Sefirv-fiKefifv scripsi : 'SeSfirrviiKftfiev Usener : SeSenrv^Kafxev Photius
eSfSeiirvriKeiBTW dfl add. Photius : om. BTWOxy. iireiS))]
erraSr, ye Oxy.
217 d nAATI2N0 2
5 e/3ovAero aitUvai, (TKr^TTToiJievos utl o^jre Lrj, Ttpocrr^vayKaa-a

avTov jxiveLv. avTravTO ovv iv Ty kyoyuivy ifjLOv kXlvi], (v

qirep eSeiVyei, Kal ovSels iv t& oiKT^/xari aXAos Kadrjvbev 17

e fjfx(LS. M^^ ^^^ ^^ bevpo Tov Xoyov KaAws av (xol

H-^XP''
Kal TTpbs OVTLVOVV X4yLV' TO 8' VTvdV OVK av [XOV riKOV(raT
\iyovT09, ei [xr] TTp&TOV fxiv, to ky6iXVov, olvos avV Te
TTaihoiV Kal fXTa TraCbcov ^v akr]dris, eir^LTa a(f)avL(raL Sco-

5 KpcLTovs pyov VT:pr\^avov ets TraLvov kkdovTa abLKOv fxoL

(f)aivTaL, ^TL 8e t6 tov brjxdivTos virb tov exewy irddos

Kafx exet. ^ao-t ydp irov TLva tovto TiadovTa ovk kdikeLV
kiyeLv olov rjv TtXrfv tols bbr]yp.VOLS, ws jxovols yv(t)(roiXVOLS

218 re Kat (rvyyv(x)(To\xVOLS et 'nav iTokfxa bpav re Kat kiyeLV

VTTo Trjs obvvrjs. eycb ovv bebrjyfxivos re virb dkyLVOTipov

Kal To dkyeivoTaTov Stv dv tls h]\diri Trjv Kapbiav ydp
rj -^vxw V oTL 8et avTO dvofxd^raL iTkrjyeis re Kat brjxOels

5 VTTo tG)V V (f)Lkoao(f)i(i koycov, ot iyoinaL ixibvrjs dypL(aTpov,

viov "^vxv^ P-V d(f)Vovs oTav kdji^ovTaL, Kal ttolov^tl bpdv
T Kal kiyLV oTLOvv fcai opHv av ^aibpovs, ^Ayd6(avas,
b 'Epv^Lp.dxovs, Tlav(ravias, 'ApL(rTob-qfxovs re Kat 'Apto-ro-

(f)dvas' ^ooKpdTr] 5e avTov Ti 8et kiyLV, Kal 6(tol dkkoL;

TTdvTS ydp KKOLV(avrfKaT Trjs (f)Lko(T6(f)ov fxavias re Kai

/3aKxetas 810 TTdvTs dKOva-(Td' (Tvyyv(a(Ta-6 ydp rots re

5 roVe TTpaxdeLCTL Kal rots vvv kyop.ivoLS. ol 8e oWiTaL, Kai
ei rts dkkos ecrriy /3e'/3rjXos re Kai dypoLKOs, TTvkas Trdw
fxeydkas tols wo-ty TTi6a-6.
'E7ret8?/ ydp ovv, o) dvbps, 6 re kvxvos dTTa^rfKL kol

C ot TraiSes e^w ^aav, eSo^e' fioi XPV^^'- /A^jSer TrotKtAAew' iTpbs

avTdv, dAA' ikv6ip(as etTreiy d fxoL e8o'Kef Kai etTTOv KLvrja-as

avT6v, 2wK/3ares, Ka^eu8ets;

Ov brfTa, "rf
8' os.

e I H B et in marg. T om. T W a2 re B T Oxy. t koL W

T W Oxy.
: :

a3 5jjxei'ij T W Oxy. : Scix^p B yi^p t) ^puxhf

W :
ij xf/vxh"
BW
yap B ipvx^v secl. Usener) a 6 ^vxv^ B T \pvxi)f /t^
{fj
W
:

Oxy. Kol /u^ T a7 /cai ante 'Ayaeaij/os add. b^ re TW:

W Oxy,
:

om. B b6 Tis T : ti B C2 Kiv7)<Tas'] Kai Kiivr\(Tas Oxy,

 STMnOSION 2i8c

Oio-^a ovv d ixoi biboKTai; 5

Ti juaAto-Ta, e^?/.

2u (fxol boKeis, t/v 8' ey(a, ejxov epaa-T-qs a^tos ycyov^vai

fxovo^, KaC fxoL (f)aCvt] OKvelv fxvT]a-6r]vaL iTpos fx. eyo) 8e

ovTMcrl ex^' '^^^'^ av6r]Tov r}yovp.ai. elvai (ro\ jxr] ov Kat

rouTO yapiC^crOai koX et rt oAAo 7/ ti]S ovcrCas Trjs ifxrjs 10

8eoio 1] T(av (f)C\(t)V tS)v k]X(iv. e/xot fxkv yap ovhiv kcTTi, d
TTpe^r^VTepov tov (us ori ^kXTLCTTOv e/xe. yv4cr6aL, tovtov 8e

otjuat piOL (rvX\r]TTTopa ovbeva KvpKaTepov elvaL o-ov. kyoi) 7/

T0L0VT(a avbpL iroX.v jxakkov av [xr] xapLCofxevos aL(ryyvoC]xr]v

Tovs ^povCfxovs, T] xapL^ojxevos tovs re ttoXXovs Kal a(f)povas. 5
Kat ovTos aKOiKTas jxdiXa etpcoi/iKcSs cat a(j)6bpa kavTov re
Kat etco^oVcos eXefey 'i2 ^tAe 'AAKt/3td87j, Ktz^Swevei? rai
ojTt oi (pavXos (LvaL, (t-nep aXr]6r] Tvyyav^L ovTa k Xeyeis
Trept kixov, KaC rt? i(rT kv ipi.ol bvvap.LS 6t' 7;? av (rv ydvoLO e
a]xiCv(DV' aixr]yav6v tol koXXos 6p(ar]s av iv kfxol Kal Trjs

irapa (to\ vpop(f)Cas ti6]xttoXv bLa(pepov. et 87/ Ka6op5)V

avTo K0LV(t)a-a(r6aC re' fxoL eTTtxei/aets Kat dAAd^ao-^at KdAAos
di^rt KdAAov?, ovk oAtyo) fxov TrXeovcKTelv biavofj, dAA' 5
drrt b6^i]S aXr]6(.Lav KaXatv KTa(r6aL ('m\(LpHS Ka\ rw
oi^rt " \pv(ra \aXKiCo)v" bLafXC^(r6aL voiis. dAA', Z) 219
fxaKapL, ap.Wov o-KOTret, /xt/ ore Xav^dvu) ovb\v &v. rj tol

Tijs bLavoCas o\frLS dpx^TaL o^v /SAeVety orav rj t&v dixjxdTOi^v

TT/y dKfxrjs Xr]yeLV eTTtxeip?'/* (rv be TOVT(i)v tTL Tr^ppoi).

Kdyo) aKovtras, Td /xer Trap' ifxov, l^7jr, TavTa ka-TLv, S)V 5

ovbiv dAAcos iLpr]TaL t] u)s bLavoovp.aL' (rv b\ avTos ovT(t)

^ovXfvov OTL (roC re dpLcrTov Ka\ e/xot r]yf].

'AAA', e<^7/, tovt6 y eu Ae'yets' kv ydp ro) hiLOVTL \p6v(^

^ovX(v6pLvoL TTpd^op.cv 6 dv (f)aCvr]Tai v^v TT(pC re tovt(*)v b
Kat Trept tQv dXXcov dpLo-Tov.

c9 B Oxy. fxw' T
tx<^ W
c lo xp(cac0<" Oxy. rf t B
Oxy. TTt W
:

d l Seoio] hit^i (ow S. v. W) d 2 &s ot W

W
:

T W Oxy. Utp riB d 3 /io< Oxy. (ut vid.) al. /wi/ B T :

62 To BTW Oxy.
:

: Tt al. Bekker e 4 re BT Oxy. om. W

W
:

a2 7J To W : ^Toi BT a5 e>oC T Oxy. ^/toi B

: a 7 8t<
ante li.pi(TTov add. Oxy.
219 b nAATHNOS
'Eyo) jjiev by Tavra aKova-as re Kal elTnov, Kal d^ets
uxnrep /3eA?;, TeTpdaOai avTov &fxriv' Kal avacrTas ye, ovb^
5 TTi.Tp4y}/as TovTia fliTeiv ovhev 4ti., aix(f)L4cras to i/jiartoi;

To p.avT0v TovTov Ka\ yap r/y XL[j.u)V vtto tov TpLj3(t)va

KaTaKXLvels tov tovtovl, itepLfiakcbv ro) TOVTUi tCl

X^^'^
C baLp.ovL<a b)s aXrjOais Kal 6avp.a(TT<^, KaTKeLfJt.r]v ti]V vvKTa
oXrjv. Ka\ ovbe raura av, w ^coKpaTes, epds otl \l/vbop.aL.
TTOLTjcravTos be bi] TavTa eyiou ovtos toctovtov TTepLeyevsTo

T Kal KaT^p6vr}crV kol KaTeyiXaaev Tijs ejur/s &pas Kal

5 vf3pL(rev Kal TTepl (kcIvo ye u)p.r]v tI (tvaL, S) ai>bps bLKa(rTar

bLKaa-Tal ydp (rT ttJs ^(OKpaTovs vTTpr](f)avLas eS yap

LCTTe fxa Ocovs, ju.a deds, ovbkv TrepLTTOTepov KaTabebapdrfKcos
d dv(rTr]v juera ^coKpuTovs, r) et iJi.Ta TraTpos Kadi]vbov y
dbeXcpov iTpa-^vTpov.
To hi] fjLTa TOVTO TLva oUaOi fx bidvoiav \lv, rfyov-
fJi,Vov pLV TfTLfxda-daL, dydfXVov 8e Tifv tovtov (J)V(tlv re Kal
5 a-(t)(j)pocrvvr]v Kal dvbpeCav, ivTeTvx^fKOTa dv9p(airu> T0L0VT<a

ot(f) eycb ovK dv wjurjy Tror' ivTVxe^LV ets (f)p6vr](rLV Kai ets

KapTepCav ; u>(rT ov&* ottoos ovv dpyL^OL]xrfv eXxov Ka\ dno-

(rTpr]dLrfv TXfS tovtov avvova-Las, ovt otti] TTpoa-ayayoLfxrfv

e avTov rfVTTdpovv. v ydp rjbrf otl xpiffxaai ye ttoXv fxdXXov
uTpcoTos ^fv TTavTaxf] V o-tSj/pw 6 Aias, 6 re uifxrfv avTov
fx6v(o dX(aaa6aL, bLTT(j)vyL fxe. rfiT^povv brf, KaTabe-
bovX(i)fXvos re vtto tov dv6pu)TT0v w? ovbels vtt' ovbi'6s

5 dXXov TTepLrja. TavTa re ydp fxoL aTravTa TTpovyeydveL, Ka\

fXTd TavTa aTpaTeia rffuv ets riore^Saiay lyiveTO kolvi}
Ka\ avvaLTOV[XV eKei. ttp&tov fxev ovv rot? iToims oi
fx6vov ejuou TTpirfV, dXXd koI tuiv dXX(jt)V dTrdi>T(av oiror'

dvayKaaOelfxev d7ToXr](j)6VTS ttov, oXa br] tt\ aTpareias,

b 4 ^e\r) B : Oxy.
j8/\ej T W
b 5 Tovrep T rovro B W
W W
:

b 7 TovTovi T B e 2 o5 B om. T
: TovTov 05 [/coJ] irept
W
;

tKftvo Oxy. Katirep tKuv6 T

: Kaiirep Kelvo B d i ^ i B Oxy.
W
; :

^ TW d7 /fapTpiW B T [^iy]K par e tav Oxy. :ei 7 TW

Oxy. re B: 63 5^ B T Oxy. re e6 K0iv)j B TW Oxy.
: W
Koiv^ v\i\g. e8 oitJt' iiroTo;' B T Ox^'.W : 69 airo\rj<t>6fvTei
:

Cornarius : &iro\(t(t>BevTes BTW (deest Oxy.)



STMn02;iON 220 a

aaLTeiv, ovbev i^crav 01 akkoL TTpbs rb Kaprepdv V t av 220

rais cva))(iai? fxovoi aTTo\avtv olos t' riv to, t aXXa Kal

Ttivuv ovK k6i\(av, 6tt6t avayKaa-Qiir], TrdvTas iKpaTet, Kal

b TTdvToyv Oavfxaa-TOTaTov, ScoKparrj p.i.6vovTa ov8els tkottot^
(c6paKv dvOpcaiTcov. tovtov fxkv ovv juot boKei Kal avTiKa 6 5
iXiyXps a-a-6ai. irpbs Se av ray tov xf^M^^^os Ka/3Tfp7/<reis

Seirot ydp avTodi x^iixMves 6av\xda-ia r\pydCiTO Ta re

aAAa, Kai ttot ovtos iTdyov oiov becvoTdTOv, Kal TrdvTMV ij b
ovK (^iovTOiv vbo6ev, 7/ et Tiy (^ioi, fifx^Lio^y.i.voiv re
6av}j.aa-Ta brj oaa koI vTTobebefx^vwv Kal ivt\iyfx4voi)V tovs

TTobas ets TriAov? Kal dpvaKibas, ovtos 8' iv TovTots e^/et

X!^v lixdTtov pikv TotovTov oXdvTTep Kat irpoTepov (l(a6et 5

(fjopelv, dvvTTobriTOS 8e 8ia tov KpvaTdWov paov fiTopeveTO

7) ot aAAot vTTobebeixivot, ol be crTpaTtGiTat vtt((3X7tov

avTbv ws KaTa^povovvTa (T(f)&v, Kal TavTa [xkv br} Tavra' c

otov 8' av Tob^ ^pf^f KO'^ ItAt; KapTepbs dvrip

ecet TTore eTrt o-TpaTtds, d^tov aKovaat. crvvvoriaas ydp

avT66t (b)6iv Tt eto-r^jKei a-KoTT&v, Kal iTTCtbr] ov iTpovxjcapct
avT(a, ovK dviet dAAa cicr^/Ket Cv'''^^' 'f^' V^V W
M^<"7/^" 5
I3pia, Kal dv6po)TTot ria-6dvovTo, Kal 6avixd^0VTS aAAos aAAw
eAeyey ort ScoKpar^js e^ k(i)6tvov (f)povTi^oov rt ^aTrfKe.
TeAeirrfiyres 8e' riyes Toiv ^l(avo)V, firetbri^aTTepa rfv, betirvr]-

aavTes Kal ydp 6epos TdTe y ryv xafxvuvta k^eveyKdfxevot d

ajua [)kv ev t& "^x^t Ka6rivbov, dfxa 8' e(\)vkaTTov avTbv et
Ka\ TTfv vvKva karfi^ot. 6 be etoT7jKet fxexpt ecos eyevero
Kal 7/Atos dvecrx^ev' ^Tretra w^eT' dirtcav TTpoaev^dixevos rw
^Aifa). el bk (3ov\ea6e ev rais fxdxctts tovto ydp 87) 5

8iKato'y ye avrw dT7o8owat oTe yap ri [xdxv V^ ^i V^ ^H-^''

a 4 fe irdvTuv TW Oxy. : 6ir6rcw B OavixauTiirarov Oxy.

di 5 kwpaxfv T W Oxy. ktapoMfi B bi irayov B Oxy. rov vdyou
W
: :

TW ^BOxy. :om. TW b3 Oxy. ^ B b^S'

S^ T
W
:

oin.Oxy. b5 oUwtp B Oxy. oTov TW C3 oS roB'

:

Oxy. avTO B : T ?ppe|c B C 3 ffrparias Oxy. aTpanias :

BTW 04 irpoxtipet B c6 avepu)TroiHc\\\er &vBpu-K0i BT V^ :

07 lAeyei-BTWOxy. e^e^ofMehler 6|l&y^|0xy. c8 tA.i/-

W ^
:

TWJ/Tts] Knl TeA.urwj/T6j d 3 m/xP'^ d 5 ^c] itai iv Oxy.



22od nAATilNOS
Kal TapL(rTia eboa-av ol (TTpaT-qyoC, ovheh aWos e/xe efrcofrey

e av6f)(aTT(ov rj ovtos, rerpto/i/.eVoy ovk iOeXcov aTToknrelv, aXka

(rvvbiea-(oa- Kal to. OTiXa Ka\ avTov e/xe. Kal eyo) fxev, co ISw-

KpaTS, Kol t6t k4\V0V (TOt btbovat TapLO-Teia TOVS (TTpaTl]-

yovs, Kal TOVTo ye' /utoi ovtc pieiJLyl/i] ovtc epets oti \f/evboiJ.ak'

5 akka yap t&v o-TpaTrjyoov Trpos to efxbv a^L(ii\xa aTToj3\eTr6vTOi)v

Kal j3ovXoixev(t)v epiol bib6vaL TapLo-Tela, avTos TrpoOvp.^Tepos

eyevov t&v a-TpaTr]yu>v efjie XajSeiV rf cravT^v. eTL toivvv,
o) avbpes, a^Lov rjv Oeacraa-QaL ^(OKpaTrf, otc aTto Arjkiov

221 0uyf; avexf^p^i' t6 aTpaT^Trebov eTvxpv yap Trapayevofievos

Xttttov ex<j)v, ovTOS be oiTka. aveya)peL ovv ea-Kebaapiev^av
Ijbr] tS)V av6p(3)iT())V ovt6s re afia koX Aayjfs' kcu eyo) Trept-

Tvy)(avo), KoX Ibodv evdvs TTapaKeXevofxaL re avTolv dappelv,

5 Kttt ekeyov otl ovk aTTo\eL\}ro) avToi), evTavda 8t; Kal Kak-

Xlov e6eaaafir]v '2,o)KpaTr\ rf ev rioreiSata avTos yap rJTTov

ev (j)6j3(o rj bLCL to e<^' lttttov elvai Trp&Tov fiev ocrov TTepLrjv

b Aa^j/ros rai efjt.(f)po)v elvaL' eTretra efxoLy* eb^Kei, co 'Apt-

aT6(f)aves, to abv br] tovto, Kal e/cet biaTTOpevecrdai &cnTep

Ka\ ev6abe, fipev6v6fievos Ka\ TO)(f)daKfjLO) napa^ak-

Xo)v, i]pefj.a iTapaa-KOTT&v Ka\ tovs (f)ik.Lovs Ka\ tovs TTokefXiovs,

6 bijkos o)V TTavT\ Ka\ iTa.vv 7T6ppo)6ev otl et ns axfreTaL tovtov

Tov avbpos, fxdka eppo)fievo)s api.vvelTaL. 8to /cat aacf^akws
aTrryet >cai ovros Kat 6 eTalpos' a-xebbv ydp tl t(ov ovto)
bLaKeLfxevo)v kv t(o 7Tokefi(o ovbe aTTTOVTaL, dkka tovs TTpo-

C TpoTTdbrfv (f)evyoVTas bL(0K0va-LV.

Ylokka fiiev ovv av tls Ka\ dkka exot ScoKparjj eTraivecrai
Ka\ 6avfLdcna' dkkd t&v fxev dkko)v eTTLTr]bevfxdT(ov Tdx dv
Tis Ka\ Trepi dkkov TOiavTa eXiTOi, to be fxr]bev\ dv6p(OTT(ov

6 dfLOiov elvai, fxi]Te t(ov TTakai(ov fxi]Te t(ov vvv ovto)V, tovto

e 1 rerpwfiivou ovk B W Oxy. ovk 46f\aiv rfrpufievov T

^BeKocv :

a7^B:^TW:rj hs rio h<f>OdKiiw T Oxy. ru (jteaXfxcji B

Oxy. :

W
:

t" cKpOaXfjiii) W b 4 TTfpKTKoirwv Ast <pt\iovs B T (pi\ovs Oxy. :

bs arpaiTO Ox.y. b6 a/ui/i/erroiTW Oxy. d/uwTjTotB b? ovros :

BTW: ofTosOxy. Ta7pos Aristides eVepos BTWOxy. C4 8 :

BT W : Sf S-n Oxy. C 5 ehai u^jts T W Oxy. : elvai /nt B

 ;

STMnOSION 22IC

a^iov iravTos davfxaTos. olos yap 'AxiAAevs kyiv^To, aTrei-

fcatretey av rts koX ^pacrihav Koi aXXovs, Koi olos av

YlipLKkr]s, Kol N4a-Topa koI ^AvTrivopa eio-t hi KaX (Vfpoi
Kai Tovs aX\ov9 xara raiJr' av riy aTretKa^bf olos be ovroa-l d
yeyove Tr}V aTOTrtav avOpooTTos, Kal avTos Kal ol XoyoL avTov,
ou8' iyyvs av evpoL tls C^roiy, ovtc t5>v vvv ovt t&v
iraXaLOiv, et fxr] apa ei ols eyo) Ae'ya) d7rci/ca{bt rts avTov,

av6p<aTroiv [xv fxrjbcvL, tols 8e a-LXrjvoLS /cat (vaTvpoLS, avTov 5

Kat rovs Aoyous.
Kat yap ovv kol tovto V rots Trpwrot? TrapiXLTrov, otl
Kal OL XoyoL avTOV oixoLOTaTOL etcrt rots o-tXrjyois rots 8toiyo-

ixevois. et yap eOeXoL rts rwy Sw/cpdrovs aKovcLV Xoyoov, e

(f)aveL(V hv Tidvv ycXoloL to irpoiTov' TOLavTa Kal ovofxaTa
Kal prjfxaTa f^a^Oev iiipLap.TrlyovTaL, (raTvpov br} TLva vj3pL-
o-Tov bopdv. ovovs yap KavOrjXCovs Aeyet Kai xaXK^as TLvas
Kal a-KxrroToixovs Kal (3vpa-ob\f/as, Kal det 8ta t&v avT&v rd 5

avTCL (f>aLVTaL X(yLV, c3(rre dTretpos Kat di'o'Tjros av6po)Tros

Trds dy T&v Xoyoov KaTayeXda^L^v. bLOLyoixVovs 8e iboDV dv 222
ris Kai evros avr&v yLyv6ixVos irp&Tov ixev vovv exoz^ras
fvbov ixovovs Vpria-L t&v X6yo)v, eTretra ^etordrous Kat
TrAeto-ra dydXpLaT dpfTrjs V avTols iyovTas Ka\ eTrt irXet-

o-roi; re^voyras, imXXov 8e eiri Trdv oa-ov TTpoariKiL aKonelv 5

ro) ixiXXovTL KaAo) Kdya65) aa-6aL.
Taur' ka-TLV, S dvbp^s, h. eyo) ScoKpdrTj eTrati^w* Kat av
h ixix(f>op,aL avixixd^as vixlv etiroy d jLtc v(3picrV. Kal ixiv- ^**;^

rot ovK c/xe ixdvov TavTa TrcTroLrjKcv, dXXd Kal XapixLbrjv b

Tov rXavKoovos Kal F,vdvbr]ixov tov AlokXOvs Kal dAAovs
Trdvv iroXXovs, ots ovtos i^aTrar&v ws ipaaTrjS TraiStKd

IxdXXov avTos Ka^to-rarat dvT epaa-Tov. h br} Kal aol

dI Toi/r'] Taih' B tovt W d 2 HvOpoDiros B T d 4 &pa el W

W
:

B : &pa TW Oxy. K(ya) T Oxy. A.7a>;/ B

: e i ^eeXot B :

iOeXfi T W tcSj/ . . . XdT-wj/ T W Oxy. Thu :\6yov B e a ko.vv

. . .

TWOxy. : om. B e 3 8rj Baiter:_fi.' TW: om. B Oxy.

ai hioiyovpitvovs B ij/ BTW Oxy. : al Bekker as rHiv
\6y<i>v T W Oxy. : rhv \6yov B a5 rtlvovTas T W : Tivovras Oxy.
Tflvcwras B ttI T W Oxy. : tj B b 3 iraj/i; om. Oxy.
222 b nAATi2N02
5 Aeyo), w 'Ayddcav, /x^ k^aitaTaa-dai vtto tovtov, dAA' d-no
T&v T)fjLTp(av TiadriixdTCtiv yvovTa ivka^r]6r]vai, Koi p; KaTa
TTjv 7rapoi.iJ.iav axnrep vi]tti.ov iraOovTa yvG>vai.

C EtTToVros 8?/ TavTa tov ^ kkKi^idhov y^kcaTa y^vicrOai

CTTt T?] TtappTf](Tia. avTov, OTL ihoKet. hi epcoriKws <^X(.iv tov
^ooKpdTovs. Tov ovv "H^iOi
K pdrr] , Ni](f)LV p.01. 8oKeis, (pdvaL,
0) 'AAKi/3ta87/. ov yap dv TTOTe ovT(a KOfx^&s kvk\(o irfpi-

5 l3akX6p.(vos d(f)avC(rai, eyexetpfis ov cveKa TavTa iidvTa

itpr]Kas, Ka\ ws kv TTapepy(a bi] k4ycov (ttI reAeurT/s* avTo
i6r]Kas, ois ov TrdvTa tovtov VKa dpr]K(os, tov e/xe Kal
d 'Ayd6(ova Sta/SaAAeti^, ol6p,evos beiv e/ue pikv (rov epdv Kal

ixr]bv6s dkkov, 'Ayd6aiva 8e vtto (tov kpdcrdai koX /x?j8' v0'

kvos aAAou. dAA' ovk ikadcs, dAAd t6 (raTvpLKov (tov

hpdfxa TovTO koa. cnkr\viK6v KaTdhr]kov iyiv^TO. dkX\ w

5 ^tAe 'Ayd^wr, ixr^hev TTkiov avT(^ y^vrjTai,, dkkd iTapa-
(TKivdCov 077WS e/ixe Kat (re /x>/8ets Sta/SaAei.
T6v ovv 'Ayd6(ii)va diT^lv, Kai p.i]v, S SwKparey, Ktvhv-
e i^ei^ets dkridrj k4yei,v. TK\xaipo]xaL he Kal ws KaT^Kkivr] kv
fx(r(^ ijxov re Kal croS, iva x^P'S 57/^ds hLakdjSr]. ovhev ovv
TTkeov avT(a ^crTaL, dAA' eyco Trapd o^e ik6(i)v KaTaKkLvr]crop.aL.

Yldvv ye, (f)dvaL t6v ^coKpdTr], hevpo VTTOKaT^t) ]xov

5 /caraKAtVou.
'Q, ZeS, etTTeti' t6v 'AAKt/3td8r/y, 0!^ av 7rd(r)(a) vtt6 tov

dv6p(o7Tov. oierat /aou 8ety Trarrax^ TTepLelvaL. dAA' et

fx-q TL dkko, S) 6av]xdcrL, iv fx4cr(a f]]xS>v ea 'Ayd^coya

KaraKetcr^ai.
1 'AAA' dhvvaTov, (pdvaL t6v ^ooKpdTr]. crv fxkv ydp e/;ie

eTTT/reo-as, 8et 8e e/*e av t6v em 8e^t" eTratretr. edi' ovv

vit6 (Tol KaTaKkivi] 'Ayd6(i)v, ov h-qiTov e/xe TrdAti' eTrat-

b5 4^airaTa(r6f B b 6 yi/wvto B C 4 o/u<|/wy pr. B C5 ov

eVeKa TW : ovyeKa corr. Oxy. ovS' tveKa B pr. Oxy.
: d6 Sia-
)3oA Oxy. : Siafid^V BT W 67 Trepiievot Oxy. e lo y&p i/j.f

B Oxy. : ydp /ue T W

e 1 1 08 rhv Bekker : av tov B Oxy. avTov
W
:

T e 12 KaTaKKiBi) Oxy.


STMnOSION 222e

reVerat, Trplv v'n ifxov fj.ak\ov kiraLvedrjvaL; aX\' iacrov,

S) 8at/;ioVie, Kal /j,t) (f)dovri(ri]9 ro) ixt,paKi<a v'n ifxov 223
iTTaivfOrjvai' Kal yap ndvv knxiOvixG) avrov eyKco/xiao-ai.

MoO lov, <\>dvai Tov ^Aydditiva, 'AAKt^iaSr/, ovk (r6' OTrcoy

av h'6dh ixdvai\xL, dXXa TravTos /xaAXoy ixeTCivacrTifcrofxai,

LVa VTTO ^(OKpaTOVS (TTaLV6S), 5

Taura e-zceira, (f)dvaL tov 'AkKLj3Ldbr]v, tcl eito^oVa*

2<oK/3drou9 TTapovTos t&v Kak&v [xeTakajBiLV dbvvaTov dkk(o,

Koi vvv ws iVTTopcDS Kal TTLdavbv koyov rjvp^v, coore Trap'

eairro) rovroi^t Karaxetcr^at.

Tbv fxv ovv 'Ayd6(t)va ws KaTaKna-ofXfVov Trapa rai b

ScoKpdret dvL(rTa(r6aL' i^aL(f)vr]s b^ Kw/xao-ras i^Kcty 7ra/x-

7ro'AXous eTTt ra? ^vpa?, Kai iiTLTvxdvTas dv(^y[xevaLs e^toVroy

rti^os ei? ro dvTLKfws TT0p(Vcr6aL Trapa acf^d? Kal KaraKAi-
vea-daL, Kal dopv^ov /xeo-ra Trdi^ra etvai, Kat ovk4tl iv 5

Koa-fxio ovbevl dvayKd^icrdaL ttlvclv TTdfXTTokvv dlvov. tov

fxkv ovv 'Epv^Lfxaxov Kal tov 4>at8poy Kai dkXovs TLvdi icf)r]

6 ^ApLa-Tobrjfxos oixeo-^at dTTioVra?, e 8e vttvov Aa/Sety,

Kal KaTabap6tLV Trdvv TTokv, dT p.aKp&v tS>v vvKTcav ova&v, c

e^eypiadaL 8e Trpbs rffxipav ijbrf oXiKTpvovoiV abovTcav, e^e-
yp6fXvos 8e tSeiy tovs /*ey dAA.ot;s Ka6vbovTas Kal olxo-
/jieVovs, 'Ayd^coi^a 8e Kai 'Apio-ro^dyrj Kat ScoKpdrT/ ert

/xoVouy kyprfyopivaL koX TTLve.LV eK (f^Ldkrjs fxeydkrfs eTri 8e^td. 5

roi' oSv SojKpdrT/ avrots StaAeyeo-^at* Kal ra /xev dAAa o

^ApLOTobrifxos ovK (f)ri fXifxvqa-daL t&v koyoov ovt ydp e^ d

dpxrjs TTapayevicrdaL VTTOWaTd^HV re to fxivTOL K(f)dkaLOV,

^(f)r], TTpoaavayKd^iLV Tbv ScoKpdrrj ofxokoydv avTOVS tov

avTov dvbpbs eirat Kco/jKoStay Kai rpay<o8iay iiTLa-Taa-dai

TTOLflv, Kal Tbv Ttx^rj TpaycdboTTOLbv ovTa (Kat) KO)fX(aboTTOLbv 5

etrat. rairra 8t/ dvayKa(ofxVovs avrovs Kal ov (r(f)6bpa

kTTOfxivovs wcTTa^iLV, Kat TTpoTcpov fxkv KaTabapddv Tbv

b7 &\\ovs] Tovs aWovs Oxy. b8 e Se B W (I W) ; favrov Se

Oxy. : o5e T C 4 awKparrj Kai api(TTO<pavr] Oxy. C 5 7
iif^aATjs <f([A.]oX7;s Oxy. ds Kal Vind. 21 om. : BTW Oxy.
d7 irp^Tipov T W Oxy. irpuTov B
:

PLATO, VOL. H. 15
223d nAATIiNOS 2TMn02I0N
ApLcrTo^avrj, 7)817 ^^ rjfx^pas yiyvoiiivr\<i tov 'Ayd^com. tov
ovv ^coKpaTr], KaTaKoi}xiaavT eKcivovs, avaa-TavTa aTrUvai.,
10 Kttt (e) &cnrep dcaOei (Trea-Oai, Kal kkOovTa eiy AvKiiov,
aTTOVi^dixevov, coa-irep akXoTC ttjv akXrjv fjfxfpav biaTpi^eiv,
Ka\ ovTO) biaTpC^^avTa ei? ka-TTfpav olkol avaTraveaOai.

b9 KaTaKoifiiffavT B W Oxy, : KaTaKoi/ji.-f,<TavT T b ro I add.

Hermann: om. BTW Oxy.
 T^-vN"

$AIAP05

2f2KPATH2 4>AIAP0S

2i2. 'X2 (f>i\ 4>ar8pe, ttoi St) Koi iToOiv; a

<t>AI. riapa Avaiov, S SwKpares, rov Ke(/)aAoi, iropev-
ofxai. 8e Trpoy Trep/Traroi; c^o) reixous* (tv\vov yap eKei

hUrpLy^a yjiovov Ka6rifj.vos e^ eco^iz^ou. ra> 8e o-ai Kal

e/A^ kraCpio Tret^o/xeros 'AKOvp.^v^ Kara ras oboiis noi.ovixaL 5

rovs TreptTrdrous' <^rjo-l yap aKoimTipovs elvai. tG>v V rois

bp6p.0Ls. b
2i2. KaAws ydp, eraipe, A.eyei. drap Auo-ids rjy, ws
eoiKei', (V do-rei.
4>AI. Nai, -Trap' 'ETriKpdrei, iv Tfjbe Trj TTkqa-iov tov
'OXvpiTTiov otKia Tjj MopvxLq. 5

2i2. T^s ovy 8^ rjv rj 8iarpi/37/; ^ 8^\oi; 6tl tS)V XoyuiV

vfxas AvarCas eloria;
4>AT. ndja-rj, ei o-ot ax^^Xrj TtpoXovTL aKovdv.
Ti 8^; ovk av otet /le Kard n^r8apoy " Kai aarxo-
2X2.
Atas VTTpTpov" TTpayfxa TTOLrfo-aa-daL to Ttrjv re Kai 10

Avo-iou bLaTpLJSrjv aKOvaaL;

<I>AI. ripdaye 677. C
2i2. Ae'yots av.
4>AI. Kat nrfv, a> SwKpares, TTpoa-rfKOva-d yk o-ot ?/ dKOij*

a5 hjKovyukvif BT (cf. Symp. 1 76 b, 6) b6 o?! 8^ B : abv T

b 10 iroi-f}<raff6ai Par. 181 1 : woffifffffOai BT re^i/ G : cr^v BT
PLATO, VOL. II. 15**
227 c nAATi2N02
ydp TOL \6yos 7]v, irepl bv huTpi^op.iv, ovk otS' ovTiva
5 TpoTTov epooriKoy. yiypa<^e yap brj 6 Ava-Cas Treipatfxevov
TLva T<av Kak&v, oiy)( vtt' (paarov b4, dW' avrb brj tovto
Kal KeKopiA^evTaf \4yei yap m yapicrriov p.T] ip&vTL fmWov
rj fp&VTi.
2i2. *i2 yewaioy. eXOe ypa\\ruv m \pi) TrhvTi fm\-
lo kov ^ TT\ov(rC<a, Kal irpea-^vTipia rj yecorepfa), koI oaa aWa
d iixoi re jrpoo-eori Koi rots iroWols r]p.&v' ^ yclp &y doreiot
Kal 8?7/Lia>^eA.ets eTei' ot Xoyot. iyu)y' ovv o^tuis kmTed-6-

fxrjKa aKOvaat, <3ot' eay ^abi^cav TroLrj tov TTepiiraTov Me-

yapaSe /cai Kara 'Hpo^StKoy 7Tpo(rj3as rw TeiyjeL ttoXlv aTrCrjs,

5 ov /Li?7 o-ou aTTokeL<^dS>,

4>AI. ricas Xe'yei?, S ^ikTLore 2<tfKpare9/ otei /xe, a

228 Auctas ey iTokk^ XP^^^i KaTO. crypkriv <Tvvi6r]K, beLVOTaTos

obv T<av vvv ypd^CLV, raura tStcorrji' ovTa aTToixin]]j,oveij<rLV

a^Coos eKeCvov; TTokkov ye beco' KaCTOL ej3ovk6ixr]v y' hv

IxakXov 7] [xoi TTokv xpv(rCov yevia-daL.
5 212. '12 ^atSpe, el eyo) 4>at8poy ayvooi, Kal ifxavTov
eTTLkekr^aixaL. akka yhp oi/beTepd ea-TL tovt^hv' eS ot8a 6tl

Ava-Cov k6yov aKoij<av eKetyos ov fx6vov ^iTa^ rJKOva-ev, aXka

TTokkdKLS eTTavaXaix^av^Jiv eKikevev ol kiyeLV, 6 be eiTeCOeTO
b TTpoOvfxois. rw be ovbe Tavra ^v iKayti, akka Tekeirr&v
TTapaka^oiv t6 ^i^kCov h. fxdkLcrTa eTTeO-ufxeL eiTea-K^TTeL, Kal
TOVTo bp&v e^ e(a6Lvov Ka6rJixevos aTTeLTTOiV els iTepCTTaTov

peL, 0)5 ]x^v iycb otfxaL, vr] tov Kijva, e^eiTLaTdpLevos tov

6 koyov, el fxr] iTdw tl ^v ]xaKp6s. eiTopeveTo V eKTos TeC-

Xovs tva [xekeT<a(r]. aTTavTr]a-as be r5 i^oo-^Sz^ri Trept Aoycov
aKorjv, lbd)V ixiv, lb(av, rja-dr] otl i^OL Tov avyKOfwjBavTLOiVTa,
C Kttl TTpqdyeLV eKikeve. beofxivov b^ kiyeLV tov t&v k6y<iiv

epaarov, e6pfUTTTeT0 ws 87) ovk erTLdvfx&v kiyeLV Tekevr&v

C9i^W:&T:5B a^ iroXhB : iro\\)v T a6 5 B : eS

S' T b5 itivv Tt Schanz : irivv ts BT b6 r^'] T<p ci. Stephanus
b7 lSi)v ^i^v tSiiv BT : lSd>v fifv Hdv G : ISinv /xiv ISvra vulg. : alterum
lSi)v del. t Hermann : om. Schanz
 4)AIAP02 228C

b^ e/xeA.Ae Kot d ^xfi rts kKoiV clkovol j3(a kpiiv. crv ovv,

S ^aihpi, avTov 8e7y^?/Ti oiTep ra^a TrdvTcos 7roirj(rei vvv ijbr]

TTOLHV. 5
<i>AI. 'E/ioi &)S dAjj^ws iroXv KpaTLo-Tov ((ttlv ovtoi)^

oTTO)S bvvajJLaL XiyiLV, &j fxoL boKels <tv ovbaixds /xe d((>rj<reLV

TTplv av eiTTco dfj.&s yi iTats.

2X2. Hdiw ydp <tol dXrjOrj boKot.

4>AI. OvT0i)(rl Toivvv TroiTjo-o). ru) oi^ri ydp, S Sw- d

KpaTis, TtavTos fxdkkov Ta ye prjfxaTa ovk c^cfxaOov' Tr^v

fxivTOL bidvoLav (rx^bbv dirdvTOiv, ots i(f)r] bLa(\>^puv tcl tov

(pQvTos rj TCL Tov fxr], iv Ke^aAaiots iKacTTov e^e^s bL(L[xi,

dp^dp.vos aTrb tov Trpwrov. 5

212. Aet^as ye TrpQTov, S> 0tAo'r7jy, rt dpa kv Tr] dpL-
(TTipa excts VTTo rw t/xarto)* roTra^o) yap o-e ^x^'^ '"^^ Aoyoi;
avTov. ei 8e rovro' ((ttlv, ovtoxtI bLavoov irepi ejmoC, d>s
eyw o-e Traru /xey ^tAw, irapovTos b\ Ka\ Av(tlov, cfxavTov (tol e
e/ii/xeAeray irapixfLV ov Trdvv 8e'8o/crat. dAA' i^t, SctKrve.
4>AI. Ilave. (KKiKpovKds /xe eAirtSos, oi 2()K/)ares, 17^

etxoy hf (Tpl a>s kyyvp.va(T6]Xivos. dAAd ttou br] ^ovXiL

KadL^6]xivoL dvayv&ynv; 5
2X2. AcCp' iKTpaTT6]XV0L /card Tbv 'lAio-dy tw/xer, etra 229
OTTOV dv 8d^r/ ey ri(TV\i(i KadL(r](r6[X6a.

<i>AI. Eis KaLp6v, 0)5 ioLKev, dvvndbr^Tos tav tTvyov (tv

fXV ydp br] deC. pd(TT0v oJjv rjixlv Kard Tb vbdTLOV ^piyovcTL
Tovs TTobas UvaL, Kal ovk dr^bis, dAAco? re xai rrjvbf Tr]v 5
copav Tov ^Tovs T Kal Trjs f]]Xpas.
2X2. r7po'aye 87/, xat (tk6ttl a]xa Sttov KadLCr](T6fXda.
4>AI. 'Opas ovv iKeCvrjv Tr]v v\jrr]\oTdTr]v iTXdTavov;
2X2. TC ixr]v;

d4 l/cao-Toi/TW: om. B d6^yB:ft^/T e i 5^ koI

Kvffiov B : Se \vaiov T :
5' iKtlvov Badham e2 Se/^ffu Hirschig
e5 Kaei(6fj.fvoi B T": Ka9(C6ixfvoi Vind. 89 Stallbaum a 2 >faft-
(r}ff6fjif0a BTW Bekk. Anecd. i. loi : Kadi^dfitda Stephanus
izagb nAATONOS
b 4>AI. 'Ekci aKtd r' ((ttIv koI TTvevixa y,iTpiov, koL irga
KaOiCco-Oai ^ ^v jSovkcaiJLeda KaTaKkLvi]vai.
2X2. TipoayoLs av.
4>AI. EiTre fxoi, w 1,(aKpaTs, ovk kvOevhe fievToi Tro6ev

6 aTTo Tov 'lAio-oS Aeycrai 6 Bopeas r^y Q.peidvLav apTrda-aL; ^

SX2. Aeytrat yap.

4>AI. 'Ap' ovv kvdivh^; \apUvTa yovv kol Kadapa Kal
bLa<f>avrj tcl vbaTUX (f>aCvTaL, xal e7rtrrj8eta KopaLs iraCCfLV
TTap* aVTCL.

C 2X2. OvK, dAXa Karto^ci' o(rov bv rj TpCa o-rdiSia, t^

Trpos ro V "kypas bLa(3aCvopi,V' mt Trot/ rts eo-rt ^oj/aos

ovtoOl Bopeov.
4>AT. Ov "Trayu vevorjKa' dAA' etTre irpos Atoy, S 2w-
5 KpaTcs, (Tv TOVTo To fj.v6oX6yrip.a ir^Cdr] dArj^cs eti^ai^J
2X2. 'AAA' et aiTL^rToCr^v, uxnrep ol (ro(f)oC, ovk hv aroiroy
Lr)v, etra (ro(f)L(i6fxevos <f)aCr]v avTrjv Tryeu/xa Bopeou /cara

T&v TrXrja-Cov TTCTp&v (tvv ^apfxaK^CcL iraCCov^rav axrai, Kal

ovTd) brj reAeur^o-ao-ay X^x^fjvaL vtto tov Bopiov dvapTraa-Tov
d yeyovivaL r) e^ ^ApeCov TTdyov Ae'yerai yap av xai ovtos
6 \6yos, 0)5 ^KcWev dAA' ovk kvd&be rjpTrda-dr]. cyo) 8c,

S) 4>at8pe, ^AAojs fAcy ra TOLavTa yapCevTa r^yovfxaL, XCav 8c

Sctrou KCi ttltt6vov Kal ov Trdvv evTvxovs dvbpds, K(jr' dAAo
^
5 pLV ovbiv, OTL 8' avT& dvdyKr] fxera tovto to twv 'iTrTroKCv-

Tavp(j)v ct8os kiravop^ova-daL, koI av6LS to rrjs XifxaCpas, Kal

TTLppL b^ 6)(Xos TOLovToov Topydvcdv Kttt ITrjydo-coy Kai

e dAAcoy d]xr]ydv(j)V iTkrj^r] T Ka\ dToiTCaL TpaTo\6y(i)v tlv&v
(^Tu(T(t)V' ats e? ris diTLaTSiv Trpocr^L^q. Kard to ctKos ^Kaarov,
. arc dypoCK(^ tlvI a-o(f>Cq Xp(t)]xevos, ttoXXt^s avT(a axoXrjs
berjaeL. ^ixol 8e Trpo? avTo. ovbaix&s co-rt o-xoA?7* TQ^^be^

b2 ^ W ^ B T 0ov\(i/xtea T W /3ouA(J-
W^
i^ &J/] ^ctj/ : &J' : e'a/ :

/utOa B KaraKKiOrjvai BT Oa rh iv "Aypas scripsi (ri ^/

"Aypas Bratuscheck) : rh rrjs Hypas BTW: rh rrjs aypalas rec. b
Eustathius ris T rl B 07 (&i/) avriiy Ast d i ^ ^f .
W
: .

ripvdcrOri secl. Bast e i irA^fltj . . . oTOiriaj BT : wX^flf j . . . aroTria

Athenaeus vulg. e 4 ouTa B W : ToDTa T
 *AIAP02 2296
oiTioy, S)
(f)(\(,
TOVTov Tobf. ov bvvayi.aC ttco KaTct t6 Ae\-
(fnKbv ypifiixa yv&vai cixavTov yeXolov b^ /xot <f>aCvTai

TOVTO ^TL ayvoovvTa to, akkoTpia a-KOTrdv. 66iv 8t) yaCpiiv 30 >

i&a^as Taxrra, 7T(i66pLVOi 8e ro) vop.i(pp-iv(a irept avT&v, o ,

wvbrj ^Xcyov, a-KOTTUt ov TavTa aAA.' efxavTov, etre tl dr]pCov\

IV
ov Tvyxdvu) Tv(f)(ovos TToX.vnkoKtaTfpov Ka\ fxakkov (TnTedvp.-'
fivov, eire ^/xe/atorepoV re Kal aTrkova-Tcpov C^ov, diCas Tivb^
Kal dTV(f)ov fjLoCpas (f)V(ri, [j.Txov. aTdp, S) eraipe, pi.Ta^v
T&v k6yo)V, dp ov T6b qv To bvbpov e<^' OTrep T^yey 17/u.a?;

4>AI. Touro p.v ovv avT6. b

2X2. N^ Tr]v "Hpav, Kak-q ye i) KaTay(oyrj. i) re ydp ^
T!kd.Tavos avTr] jaaA' ^/x<^Ac^()r/y re Ka\ wfrr}kri, Tod re ayyou'^'^,^;^
Tb v\(fos Ka\ To evfi-Kiov irdyKakov, Ka\ ojs dKp.r]V e^^ei Trjs ..-^V

dv6r)s, o)s ai;' evoj^eVrciroy 7rape'xoi Tbv t^ttov 7; re av 5

^'jy^ X<^P'^^''"^^ ^''''^ TV^ TrkaTavov pi fxdka yfrv\pov vbaTos,

&(TT ye rw ttoSJ TKp.ripa(r6aL. NviJ.(f)&v re riycoy Kat 'A^e-

Aidou lepoy aTro rwy KopS)v re Kat dyaA/uarcoi' OikV etrai.

ei 8' au /SouAet, ro cvTryow rou roTTou ws dyaiTrfTbv koX C
(T(f)6bpa r]bv' d^pu^ov re Kat Atyupoi' vTnjx^et roi rwy TTTCy(t)v

Xopw. Trayroji' 8e KopyfroTaTov Tb Trjs 7ro'a?, ori ey r]p]j.a

TTpocrdvT^i iKavT] TT(f)VK KaTaKki.VVTL Tr]V K(f)akr]v TTayKdkcos

exety. coo-re dpLa-rd croL ^vdyr]TaL, 2> ^tAe fi^aiSpe. 5

<I>AI. 2v 8e' ye, S 6avpidaL, dT07T(oTaT6s tls (f>aCvi].

dTxv&s ydp, b Ae'yets, ^vayov]XV(a tlvl Ka\ ovk TTLxo)pC(o

OLKaS' OVT(aS K tov da-TOS OVT ets Tr]V vTTpopCav diTO- d

brf]XLS, ovT ^(t) reixoDS e/xotye SoKet? Tb TTapdiTav ^LvaL.
S12. ^vyyCyva)crK4 fxoi, S dpLaT. (f)Lkofxa6r]s ydp lfXL'

Ta pLV ovv X(pCa koI Ta bivbpa ovbev fx e0e'Aet 8i8ao-Ketr,

e 6 8^ B T W
Proclus (in Alc. p. 289, 5) 5e Vind. 80 : a 4 6j/
TW om. B 4/ vulg.
: iirtT(dv/jifj.evov B T W
(sed /x prius in ras.
W
:

B) ^Tt TtOvixfxivov ci. Ruhnken

: b 4 koI iy B T koJ oSrws ci. :

Heindorf koI Schanz

: b^ Sffxf^tBTW: Sy -ye Aristaenetus
vulg. C 2 r)hv T <J5; B W ^ittjx*' t^) T 6ir7JXTO B W
W
: :

C 4 Trpo(TdvTi T W
irpoaavrt B : C 6 (ri ou B T :
23od nAATX2N02
01 8' (V T(a aoret avOpcoTTOL. (tv boKfls ttjs
5 fJ.4vToi. fxoi

ciirjs ^6bov t6 (^apixaKov y]vpr]Kivai. &a-'jTp yap oi ra

TTiivSiVTa 6pip.\xaTa 6a)0^ov i] Tiva KapTtov Trpoa-iiovTes

ayovcrcv, crv cixol AoyoDs ourco TTpoTtCvcov kv ^i/3\fois Trjv re

e 'ArriKTJy (f)aCvv TrepLa^dv airaa-av Kal ottoi hv aWocrc ^orvKr\,

vvv 8' ovv fv rw TTapovTi bcvp' a(\iiK6p.ivos eyo) p.iv /uoi

hoKot KaTaKCa-e(r6ai,, crv 8' (v OTTOtw cr^?7fiari oiet pacTTa

avayv(aa-a-6ai, Tovd' kX.6pL(vos avayCyv(aa-K,

5 <i>AI. "AKOue 877.

ITepi fjikv T&v kp.G)V TTpayiJLa.T(av kTTiaTaaai, Ka\ s yo/xt^(o

a-vpL(f)epLV rjixlv yevopLivodv TovT(av aKrjKoas' d^tw 8e /urj 8ta

231 TovTO aTVxr]a-at &v 8e'o/i/.at, ort ovk pa(TTr]S a)V aov Tvy-
Xavoi. o)s (KcCvois fJLkv t^tc /iAerajoie'Aet &v av ev, Troi^o-too-iy,

e7ret8ay Trjs iTTidvpLias TTavcr(ovTaL' tols 8e ovk icrrL xfi^vos

kv w p.Tayv&vaL Ttpoa-qKiL. ov yap vtt* avdyKrjs dXA'
5 kK6vTS, b)S av apLora iTepl t&v olKeCoDV ^ovkevaatVTO, TTpos
Tr]v bvvapLLV Tr]V avT&v ev TtoLova-LV. TL 8e ot ]j.V ep&vTes
(TKOTTOVa-LV O. T KaK&S bLe6eVT0 T&V avT&v 8ta TOV p(OTa
Kal h TTeiTOL-qKaa-LV eu, Kai ov etxov tt6vov TTpocrTL6kvTes
b r]yovvTaL TrdAat Tr]v a^Cav a.TTobeb(>)Kevai \apLv rots epco-

fxevoLS' ToXs be ju^ ep&a-LV ovTe rqv t&v olKeC(i)v apAX.eLav

hia tovto ea-TLv iTpo(f)acrCCea6aL, ovTe tovs 'nape\r]kv66Tas
tt6vovs VTToXoyCCea-6aL, ovTe tcls iTpbs tovs iTpogrjKovTas

5 bLa(f)opas aiTL(xaaadaL\ S)aTe TTepir\pr]]iev(t)V to(^ovtoi)v KaKa>v

ovbev VTToXeCiTeTaL dAA' r] TTOLelv TTpo6vfX(j)S otl h.v avrms

OLoovTaL TTpd^avTes yapteladaL. eTL be et 8ta tovto d^Lov

C Tovs ep&VTas iTepX iroXKov iTOLeLadai, otl tovtovs /xdAio-rd

<f)aaLV (f)LX.eiv S>v av epwaiv, kol eTOLfxoC eio-t Kat ck tS>v X.6yo)v

6.5 ah recc. : ow B : 06 T Sokus T : Soku B d6 fnfjs T W

W
:

om. B d7 irpotreioyres t recc. : irpoffiovTts BT e2 5' oZv

T : ovu B 63 KaraKfia-fa-Oai T
KaraKfiadai (sic) B
:
67 yevo-
fxtvuv Toirtiov B : rovruv yevofifvaivT a 2 fierafieKei wv T :

Hera/j.e\eiciv B b 5 aiTid<ra(rdai] alriatrOai Cobet C i rohs

T : rov pr. B 02 erotfioi tlai koI T W et in marg. b : om. B
 <I>AIAP02 231C

Kai (K tSiv cpyoiiv roiy ctAAots aTT\6av6ixVot, toIs ipcofxivois

yapC^(Tdai, pqbi,ov yvS^vai, d a\r]6r] keyovcnv, otl 6(ra)V hv
vcTTcpov kpa(T65i(rLV, iKcivovs avT&v Trepl TrXeCovos iroiria-ovTaL, 5

Kal bfjkov OTL, iav (kcCvols boKrj, Kal tovtovs KaK&s 'noL'q-

(TovtTLv^ KaLTOL TTCis fiKos eoTi TOLovTov TTpayp.a TtpoicrdaL

TOLavTTjv ^xovTL (Tvp.(\ii>pav, r\v ovb' av iTrL\Lpr]a-iV ovbeh d
fj.TTipos oi)v aTTOTpiTTiLv; Ka\ yap avroX 6ixo\oyov(TL voa-dv
IxaXXov rj (TOi<l>poviiv, kol ^lbivaL otl KaKws (f)povova-LV, aX\'
ov bvvaa-daL avT<av KpaTelv &aT ttcos h.v eS <^povri<ravTis
TavTa KaXSts X(lv rjyrja-aLVTO ir^pl &v ovt(o bLaKiC\iivoL 5
^ovXivovTaL; Ka\ p,kv brj et fxev ex t&v (p^avTcov tov /3eA-

TLo-Tov aipoLO, e okCyoiV av orot t) iKkf^LS etrj' et 5' fK r&v

aXK(x>v Tov o-aurw eTrtrrjSetoVaroi/, eK iTokk&v' cSoTe iroXv
ttX.(C(i)V eATTis fv TOLS TTokkols ovTa TvxcLV Tov a^Lov Trjs a^s e
<f)LkCas.

Et ToCvvv Tov vopLOv Tov Kad^cTTT^KOTa biboLKas, fxrj

7Tv6ofXV(i}V t5>V av6p<i>TT(i>V OViLboS crOL yVr]TaL, (IkOS i(TTL

Tovs fx\v fpS>VTas, oZrois hv olofxivovs Kai vtto rwy akkdiv 233
^XoCo-^at &<T'iT(p avTovs v(j)' avTS>v, iTTapdrjvaL rw Aeyety
Kat (f)LkoTLfxovfXVovs iiTLbeCKVVcr^aL TTpos aTTavTas otl ovk
akX(j)s avToXs TTeiToinjTaU tovs b^ fxr] kpSnrras, KpeCTTOvs
avT&v ovTas, t6 ^ekTLo-Tov avT\ Trjs bo^rjs rifS TTapa tS>v S
av6p<aiT(t)v atpeto-^at. ert 8e rovs fxev ep&vras TTokkovs
"^
avdyKr] TTV^ecrdaL Ka\ i8ety aKokov6ovvTas rois p(Ofx4voLS
Ka\ (Qyov TojjTo "TTOLOvfiivovs, ooaT oTav d<\)6S>a-L 8ia\eyo'-

fXiVOL akkrfkoLS, t6t avTovs oioyrai rj yey^vrffxivrfs rj fx(k- b

kova7]s (^aicrdaL TrfS (7TL6vfiCas awiivaL' tovs 8e fxr] fpS>vTas
ovb' airtao-^at 8ta 7-^1; o-wou<rtav eTrtxetpouo-ti', etSoVes ort
dyayKatoy co-rtr rj 8ta <f)LkCav ro) 8taAe'yeo-^ai rj bi akXrjv

C4 3t Sffwj' T W : Sir6<Toy3: n1 y' S<t<iov Hermann 05 iroff^aovrai

B : irofl^tTuvTai oirw rec. b oSrot B T
T d5 d. 6 fiovXwovrai :

Stephanus: fioiXovrai BTW:

$f$ovK(vvTai Heindorf d^ alpoio
T aipoTro B
: a 2 t^ Ktyfiv B T t^ f^tyftv t t^ Xtyetv D : : :

T$ X*"' Badham alii alia : a 3 ovk liWws T ov koXus B W :

a 5 avrl T av B : b 4 t^ b t t^ B T :
aaab nAATX2N02
5 Ttva rjbovriv. Kal ixev 8r) ei (tol bios TrapiaTrjKev rjyovfj^vu}
XaXeTTOV etvaL (^iXiav (TViiy.ivHV, /cat ^AXo) ixkv TpoiTia bia-
(popas yivoixivr]s Koivr]v {av) aiKpOTepois KaraoT^mi rrjy

C crvixipopdv, TTpofixivov 6e crov h TTp\ Trkeio-Tov Trot^ ji/,ey(iArji>

&v (Toi ^X6.^r]v hv yivicrdai, elKOTOis &v tovs ip&VTas ijmK-

Kov hv (f)oj3oio' TToXka yap avTovs kcm to. XvTTOvvTa, koll

ttAvt TtI Trj avT&v ^kd^r\ voiiC^ov(ri yiyvicrdai.. bcoTTcp

5 Kal Tas TTpos tovs dWovs Totv epco/xei/coi; (rvvov^rCas diTOTpi-

TTOVcnv, ^o^ovp.voi Tovs ixkv ova-Cav KKTr}pLvovs /xr)
XPV~
ixacnv avTovs VTTCpjSdkoovTai, tovs be neiTai.bevixevovs ixrf
(rvvi(Ti. kp^Cttovs yivcovTai'^ Totv 8e aXXo tl KKTriix4vcov

d dyadov Trjv bvvapiiv Kd(rTov (f)v\dTT0VTai,. TTC(TavTs ixev

ovv aTT^xOicrOaL (T tovtols LS pr]p.Cav (f)CKa>v Ka6La-Tda-LV,

iav 8e rS a^avTov (tkottS)V dixLvov KCv(t)V (f^povrjs, r]^Ls

avTols eis bLa(f)opdv' ocroi 8e /xr) p&VTS Tvxpv, akXd bC

5 dper^i; ^irpa^av S)V kbiovTO, ovk dv toIs a-vvov(TL (f>dovoLV,

d\ka Tovs, ixr] iOikovTas ixlctouv, r)yovixVOL vtt' ck^Cvcov ixV

VTTpopdcr6aL, vtto tS)v ctvvovtoov 8e o)(f)XLa-6aL, &crT ttoXv
e irA.eicoi; kkiTLS (f)LkCav ovtols k tov iTpdyixaTos r/ c^dpav
yVa-6aL.
Kal ixv bi] t5)v jxv epcovTcov irokkol iTpoT^pov tov o-w-
ixaros TT6vp.i]aav rj tov TpoiTov yvo)a-av kol tCov dKk(j)V
5 OLKcCooV IXTTLpOL yVOVTO, &a^T dbr]koV OVTOLS L TL t6t
^ovXr^aovTat (ftCkoL clvaL, TTLbdv Trjs iTTL^vpiCas TTava-oovTaL'
333 rois 8e /xr) ipcoaLV, ot Kal TrpoT^pov dXkr]\oLs (f)CkoL ovtS
TavTa TTpa^av, ovk e^ &v dv V TTddooarL TavTa etKos ikdTTOo
Tr]V (f)LkCav avTols TTOLrjcraL, dkkd TavTa ixvjiixcla KaraAet-

b8 &i/ add. Hirschiges &f a-otBT S^ <roi Schanz & :

yfveadai B yev4aOai
: (Ik^tws h.v B T T (Ikotus 8^ Schanz :

fiaWou h,v B ixaWov T C5 Tas

: ttjs corr. Ven. 184 tuv BTW:
ipwfievwv^l "^^" ipdfifvov Heindorf d. 2 airexOfaOai . . tovtois^ .

airfx^fcOai . tovtois B T
. &-ir(Xf<rdai
. W
tovtois vulg. Airex*'^'
: . . . :

. . . TovTuy al. Stallbaum d6 vir'] a vv Schanz auctore Heindorf

e 2 yfveaOai T : yfvfia-fffOai B 65 aiiToTs fi (ti B : d ti avTo7s T :

t Hti Hermann t6t( T : om. B a3 nv7iix(7a'] ar]fi(7a ci.

Heindorf
 *AIAPOS 233a

(j^d^vai. T(av fXXk6vT<t)v l(re<r^ai. Kttt fxev 8t) ^iXriovi (tol

TTpoariKei yeviaOai. fjJLol TTidofxiv<a rj (paaTjj. fKflvoi pikv 5

yap Kal irapa to ^iXTicTTov to. re \y6p.iva Kal to. TrpaT-

TOfiiva iTtawovcnv, to. p.\v 8e8tores p.r\ a.'neyd(i)VTai, to. 8e

Ktti auToi yiipov 8ia ti]v eindvfxiav yiyv^cTKOVTis. ToiavTa h
yap 6 epcoy e7n8eiKrvraij bvcrTvxovvras p.iv, h jxr} A.vTnjy

rois aWois Jiapiyei, aviapa Trotei vop.i^iiv' iVTvyovvTas 8e

KaX To. p.rj rjbovrjs aia ira/a' e/ceircoz; iiTaivov avayKd^ei.
TvyxdveLV u>aTe 7toX.v p.aX\ov eAeeiy rocy ipcopievoLS rj s
^rjKovv aiiTovs TrpocrqKet.. fav 8e fioL TreiOr], Tip&Tov fxkv ov
Trfv Ttapovcrav rjbovrfv OcpaTrevoiiV avvecrofxai croi, oKka koX
Trjv fx4k\ova-av d>^eXiav eaeadai, ovx vtt' epctiTos r]TT(ap.evos C
dAA' efxavTov KpaTu^v, ovbe bia (rp.LKpa ia)(ypav i\6pav avaL-j
povfxevos dAAa 8td fxeydXa jSpabecos dXiyrjv opyrfv ttolov-

fxevos, T&v fxkv dKOva-i(t)v avyyvdopLrjv ex^coy, tcl be kKovaLa

7TeLp<jifXVos aTTOTpeTTeLV TavTa- ydp ecrTL </)tAias ttoKvv xp6- 5
vov icroft.evr]s TeKfxrjpLa. et 8' apa aoL tovto TTapeaTrjKev, ws
ov^ ol6v re lcrxypav (\>Lkiav yeviaOaL eav fxrf tls epS)v Tvyxdvrf,

(vOvfxela-daL xpij otl ovt av tovs veis Trepi ttoAAou eTTOtov- d

fxeOa ovT av tovs Trarepas Kal tcls fxrfTepas, ovt av iTLaTovs
<f)i\ovs eK(KTi]p.e9a, 0% ovk e^ eTTLdvfxias TOLavTrfs yeydvaaLV
dAA' e^ eTepo)v eTTLTr]bevp.dTO)V.

"Ert 8e et \pr] rois beofievoLS fxdkLaTa yapi^ecrdaL, 5

TTpoa-rfKeL koX tols dAAots fxrf tovs ^eArtVrous dAAd tovs
dTTopci)TdTovs ev TTOielv fxeyia-Toov yap diTaWayevTes KaK&v
TT\eia-Trjv x^P''^ avTols etaovTaL. Kal fxev bi] Kal ev raty -

^Stats baiTdvaLs ov tovs (f)i\ovs d^LOV TTapaKa\eLV, dAAd e

rous TTpoaaLTovvTas Kal tovs beop.evovs iT^r^afxovrjs' eKelvoL
yap Kal dyaTTr](rovaLV Kal dKO^ovO^qa-ovcrLV Kal em tcls Ovpas
ff^ovaL KaX fxd\LaTa r]adr]aovTaL koX ovk i\axiaTr]V X^P*^
.

b 5 rois ip(i)fi.4vois B T Stobaeus to\js ipeefifvovs vulg.

: b 6 av-
rohs B Stobaeus avro7s T
: S4 fioiBT 5' 4tiol Ven. 184
: 6.6 koi
ro7s &\\ots B T koI rwv i.\\<iov Aldina
: Kii.v rols li.\\0is Badham
:

e 2 Trpuaairovvras B T 7rpo<raipovvras G
:
2336 nAATaN02
5 iL(T0VTai KaX TToXAa ayada avTols (v^ovTai. dXA' tcroos

TTpoa-riKCL ov rois (T(\)6hpa 8eo/Aerots yapi^icrdai., aXXa tois

fid\L(rTa airobovvai. \api.v bvvap.vois' ou8e rois irpocraiTov^n

234 p.6vov, oKXa Tols tov 'npayp.aTos d^iois* ov8e oo-ot r^y o-^y
wpa? aTTokav^rovTai, dAA' olViz^es Trpe(rlBvTp(a yevoixevd) t&v
(r(f)Tp(t)v ayadS)V pLTab(o(rov(nv' ovbe o\ bi.aTTpa^dp.evoi

iTpos Tovs dAAoi? ^iKoTip.iq^TovTai., dAA' oirti^es al(ryyv6-

5 /xeyoi TTpos diravTas (XKaTtri^rovTaL' ovb\ rois okLyov \p6vov

(n:ovbd^ov(TLV, aXKd roiy o/aoicos 8td -Trayrds roS /3ioi (pLkoLS

i(T0fXV0LS' ovb oiTLVS Trav6p.V0L Trjs kiiLdvp.Las '

y6pas
TTp^cj^a^TLV QriTri(Tov(TLV, dAA' ot TTava-afxevov ttjs &pas t6t
b T^y avrwi; dpeT-qv eTTLbfL^ovTaL. av ovv t5)v re elprffxevcov

p.flVri(TO Kal KlvO v6vp.0V, OTL TOVS fJi.V ip&VTaS OL (f)L\OL

V0v6eT0V(TLV a)S OVTOS KaKOV TOV 7TLT1]bVfJ.aT0S, TOLS 8e firf

pS)(rLV ovbns Trwirore tG)v OLKcmv ip.p.\l/aTO b)s 8td tovto

5 KttK&s ISovkevofxivoLs TTepl eavrwyj

"{(Td^s av ovv poL6 fx et diTaaLV ctol TrapaLvG) tols fxrf

ep&a-L xapCCfo^^aL, eyco fxkv oXfxaL ovb' &v tov ep&vra

TTpbs diTavTds ae Kekeveiv tovs epdvTas TavTrjv Ix^'*' ''"'l^

C Stdrotai^. otrre ydp rw kap.(3dvovTL -xdpLTos tarjs d^LOV,

ovre o-oi ftovkofxiv(^ tovs dAAou? kav6dviLv ofioLoos bvvaTdv
b(L 8e ^kd(3rfv /xei' dTr' avTov p.rfbfXLav, b)(j)kCav 8e dfxcf^olv

yCyviadaL. eyo) pikv ovv LKavd fxoL vofxC^(o Ta LpripLva'

5 et 8' ert (ri) av irodds, rfyovp.vos TTapakkL(f)6aL, ipcaTa.

^AI. Tt o-ot (f)aCveTaL, a> ScoKpare?, d Ao'yos; ov^

VTTp(f)va>s Td re dAAa cat rots 6v6fxaaLV eipffa6aL;

e8 irpoffaiTovcri Ast : irpofffpwffi B : epStffi T W a2 yepofievcf) T :

yerffjUej/oj B a6 ffirovSd(ovffiv] ffirovSdffovffip ci. Stephanus {colertt

Ficinus) a8 iravffafi.4vov G. Hermann : Troixrctjitevoj BT : iravofi(vr]s
Laur. 2643 : navffa/xfvois Winckelmann : alii alia b6 &!/ odvT :

H(v olv B b 7 iifv T 5e B c i t^j T t^ \6y<f B

: : W Xffiis

T 010-775 (sic) B oXaeis

: : 03 Sei T aU\ BW dTr' B : : eir' T
C5 5' 6T1 Ti Heindorf SstiBT o-u iroflf?s Ven. 189: ffv
: vvoOfis
T : vTTod^s B
(Ti ipdra T tpwra B :
 <I)AIAPOS 234d

Sf2. AaLfjiovCois im^v ovv, S kToipe, u)aT [jl (KTrkayrjvai. d

Kol TovTo eytt) cTTaOov 8ta (re, a> ^^aiSpe, Trpos (re aTro-

^KiiTfav, 8ti ^[JLol eboKds ydvva-Oai. VTrb tov Xoyov ixiTa^v

avayLyv<a(rKcov' f^yovfx^vos yap (re ixaXKov rj e/xe kiraiiiv

nepl T<av toiovtmv crol eiiro/xrji^, Kal eW/xevos (rvvcjSaKX^evaa 5

fiiTa a-ov Trjs Oiias K(f)aXr]s.

4>AI. Eiei^* ovTCi) bi] 8oKet TTaL((Lv;
212. AoKOi ydp ctol TraCC^LV Kal ov)(l fcnrovbaKivaL;

J^AI. Mrjbafjiws, S) ^(OKpaTS, oAX' wy dkr]6cis eiTre e

TTpos Aios (j^lXlov, ote6 ar rtm exfii' etTrety aAAoy t&v
'EkXriVdov eVepa tovtoov /xet^to /cat "TrAetca 7re/ot ro! avTov
iipdyixaTos;
2i2. Tt 8e'; at ravrTj 6et ^tt' e/iow .re xat (tou roy 5
Xoyoi^ (TraLvedrjvaL, ws ra biovTa ilprfKOTOS tov Trotrjrou,

a\A' ov/c (KLVi] iiovov, OTL <ra(f)r] Kal aTpoyyvka, Kal aKpL-
/3ci)? iKaa-Ta t&v 6vop.dTo)v diroTeTopvevTaLij et yap 8et,

avyx(opr]Tov ydpLV (Tr]V, eTret e/xe' ye ekaOiV vtto Trjs e//r/s

ovSeyias^ rw yap prfTopLK^ avTov ij.6v(ti tov vovv Trpoa- 235

eiXoy, tovto 8e ov8' {av) avTov Avaiav oteadaL LKavov
<a]xriv

etvai. Kal ovv p^oL bo^v, w 4>at8/3e, et ixrj tl ai) akko

keyfLS, bls Kal Tpls Ta avTo. dpr]K4vaL, cis ov irdvv evTTop&v
Tov TTokka keycLv Trept tov avTOv, r; ta^os ovbev avTia iiikov 5
Tov TOLOVTOV Kal i(f)aLV(To b-q p.0L vavLvcadat eTTtSeiKn;-
lxVos a>s olos T a)v ravra ere'pa)s re Kat Tp<as kiycov
dlX<f)OTp<i)S IttIv dpLaTa.
4>AI. OvbV Ae'yets, S) SwKpares* avTo yap tovto Kal b
fxdLkioTa 6 koyos XL. tG)V yap v6vt<x)V d^tcos pr]6rjvaL

d3 e5o/cetj T: SoKus B d^ 8^5orTW: 5^ B: 51? Schanz

e 3 rovrccv fj.el((o B : fitl^v Toxnuv T 67 koI aKpt$ws fort. non
legerunt Plutarchus Hermias e 8 a.iroreT6pvVTai B airoreT^pvurat :

T a I fi6v(p B T ix6vov : W
a 2 &/ ante outJ;/ acJdidi ante :

^/jL7}v add. Thompson post oUaBat add. Ast a 3 koI oSv Her-
W
:

mann koI Si/ oZv Stephanus: ZtKatovv B StKatov oiv T

: a^ \iytts
:

T Aeyps B
: a 7 Tavrh. Heindorf TaSro B T b a A{/ws]
:

a{(wc Madvig
235 b nAATIiNOS
ev T<a -npayixaTi ovhiv 'napakikon:iv, &a-Ti Trapa to. e/cetV^

flprjfi^va fxrjbiv^ {av) TTOTe hvvaa-dai dirdv akka TrAeto) Kal

5 TrkeCovos a^ia.
2X2. ToCro eyco croi ovKTt, olos t eo-o/xai Tndea-Oai'
TTakaiol yap Ka\ a-o(f)ol avbpis t Kal yvval^Kes irept avrcav
cipjjKoVfs Kal yypa<f)6TS e^eAey^ovo-i /ue, idv trot xctpiCo-
pLCVOs a-vyxbipSi.
C <J>AI. TtVes ovToi; /cai ttoi) ffv jSekTLco TovTiav aKrJKoas;
212. Nw /xey ovTcas ovk exco et^Trety 8^Aoi' 8e oti tivcSi'
aKTjKoa, ij TTov '2a'ncf)ovs Trjs Kakrjs rj ^AvaKpiovTos tov
a-o(j)ov r) Ka\ a-vyypa(f)(av Tiv&v. iToOev brj TiKp.aip6p.ivos
5 Aeyo); iTkrjpis Trcus, a baip.6vi(, to a-Trj6os yu)V ala-davop.at.
TTapa TavTa hv exety eiTreti' eVepa p.r] xeipcai otl /aei' ovv
TTapa ye p.avTov ovbev avT&v evvevorjKa, eS ot8a, o-uz^etSws
ep.avT(a dp.a6l.av AetTreTat 8^ ot/xat e^ dkkorpmv iTO^ev
d vap.dTO)v bid Trjs dKorjs TTTTkr]p&a-6ai p. bUr]v dyyeCoVi
VTTO be vo)6iCas av Ka\ avTo tovto iTnkikr]a-pML, 6tto)s re
Kai &VTLV(i)v r]Kova-a,
<I>AI. 'AAA', 2 yevvaL^TaTf, /caAAKrra etprjjcas. av yap
5 e/xot &vTLV(i)v pikv Ka\ otto)? rJKOvaas /xtjS' az' KeAeuco ei^Trr;?,

Touro 8e avro 6 Ae'yeis TTOLr^crov t&v kv ro) l3LJ3kL<a ^eArto)

re Kai yx?) eAarro) erepa vTria-yria-aL diTeLV tovtuiv diTexd-
jxevos, Kai aoL lyco, &(nTep ol evvea dpyovTes, VTTLa-yvovp.aL
Xpva-rjv eiKoVa La-op.eTprjTov eis AeA^ouy dvad-qa-eLV, ov
e p.6vov ep.avTov dkka Ka\ a-r]v.\

212. 4>tATaTos ei Kai ws dkr]6(as xpy^o'^? ^ <J>ar8pe,

ei /Lte otet keyeLV o)S Avo-ias tov TTavTos rip.dpTr]Kev, Ka\ ol6v
re br] TTapd iTdvTa raCra aAAa eiTreii'' tovto be oX]xaL ovb'

5 dv Tov (f^avkdraTov iraOeXv a-vyypa(f>ea. avTLKa Trept o5

6 Aoyo?, rtVa otet keyovTa a>s XP^/ M^ ^P^vtl p.dkkov rj

b4 nriSfv' &v Aldina : fj.7}dfua BT (yUTjS' iy marg. t) b6 t' B :

ye T TTiOfffdai B : veiOecrOai T C5 ra>s] 7rp Aldina d7 eVt/ja

6Trfffxv<^ai scripsi (Ttpa inr6ffx^^ Badham (secl. fl-nelv): er4pc(,
: viroffx^(Tfi
BT erfpa iirixeipfi Schanz alii alia
: e 4 irdvra ravra
: B : ravra
Trdvra T TaOTo G
: e 6 TVa B T ti vulg. :
 cl>AIAP02 235e

IpdvTL \apiCicr6ai,, Trapivra tov fxev t6 (f)p6vLiJ.ov (yKU)-

fjLLdCfLV, Tov be To a(f)pov \jriyeLv, avayKala yovv ovTa, iLT 236

&AA' &.TTa ^^LV \iycLv; dAX' oi/jiai tcl fx^v roiaura earea
Ka\ (TvyyvaxTTea X^yovTL' Kal tQ>v p.\v tolovtcov ov rrjv

vpa-LV akka ttjv bLadearLV 7TaLVT4ov, tS>v 8e /x^ ava-

yKaCcov re Kal X!'^^'^'^^ evpeiv Trpbs rfj biadia-eL Kal ttjv 5
(ijpea-LV.

^AI. Svyxwpo) 6 Xeyeis' fxeTpms ydp \jlol hoKeXs dpr]-

Kivai. TTOiTycrco ovv Ka\ eya) ourcos* to piev tov ep&vra
Tov fir] ep&VTOs pLaXkov vocreTv bcicrai (tol VTTOTLdea-^aL, rc5i> b
8e koLTT&v Tpa TTkeLOi) Kal TTkeLOVos ata eliTobv rwrSe
[Avortou] Trapa to Kv\j/kLb&v avdOrjixa a-({)vp-qkaTOs iv
'OXr/iTTta a-TaOriTLj^
2X2. ^Ea-TiovbaKas, w ^albpe, 8tl a-ov t&v 7rai8i/cc3i' 5

^TTekal^opLriv pa^r}k&v a-e, Koi otei 877 /ixe ws dkr]6&s eirc-

XeipTfo-eiy eiTreii' Trapa ttjv Klvov a-o(f)Lav irepov tl ttol-

KLk(aTpov;
4>AI. Ilept p.V TovTov, S) (^ike, ets Tas 6p.oLas ka^as
krikv6as. pr]Tov {XV ydp aoL TravTos iidkXov o^Tcas SiTcas C
olos T et, tva fxri ro t&v kco/xwSwi' (f^opTLKov TTpdyfxa
dvayKa^(ap.6a TTOLeZv dvTaiTobLbovTes dAATjAoty [evAa/3^0j/rij,
Ktti y.r] j3ovkov fx dvayKdaaL keyeLV eKetro to *'
et eyo,
ScoKparey, SwKjodrTji; dyvo&, Kal eixavTov eiTLkikr]- 5
(TfiaL," Kal OTL " 1T6vpL pL^V kiyHV, i6pVTTTT0 b4'"
dkka bLavoridr]TL otl evTevdev ovk diTLfxev TTpXv dv crv LTTr]s

h i(f)ria-da v T(a arq^eL iyeLv. ia-fxev b^ fxovca V eprffxici,

la^vpoTepos 8' iyoi) Kal V(OTpos, iK b^ aTTdvTOiv to^vtoov d

" a-vves S TOL kiyoi)," Kal p.r]bap.oiS TTpbs /3iW l3ovkr]6fjs

fjjdkkov r] KO)V kiyLV.

ba TwvSeT^ tlir6vrosB: (liriivTSiv rovfecitt

flviiv : bs Avcrlov
seclusi b 4 o-ToflijTj B T iaTaQ-n Photius ^ffTadi Cobet
: c i ^A.^-
:

\v0as T i\ii\v9a B
: c 2 Jva B ha Sh T C 3 avayKa(<iiJ.($a
:

B avayKaC6fx.fda T
: uAojSyjflrjTj secl. Cobet C 7 Siavo-fiOriTi T :

Siavo-fiOriTe B e 8 ix6vw B fM^vto fjilv T W d 2 3 roi] S ffoi

W
:

hoc loco B T (at cf, Menon. 76 d) filav T filas B :

 236 d nAATi2N02
211. 'AAA', S) fj.aKapLe 4>albp, yeKoios eo-ojoiat Trap'

5 ayaObv TroLrjTrjv tStwrtjs avToarx^bLaCoiiv Trepi t&v avT<av.

4>AI. Ola-d* d)s ex^' '"aSo-ai w/aps /i>te KaWooTn^ofxevos'
a")(^bov yap 1^^ o elirciyv avayKacru) cre Xeyeiv.
212. MrjSa/xois tolvvv etTrrjs.

4>AI. OvK, d\Aa Kal 6^ Aeyto* 6 8e /xot Xoyos SpKo?

lo (TTaL. oixvvfXL ydp (TOL TiVa ixivToi, TLva deciv; rj ^OV'
e Aei Tr]v irkdTavov TavTrjvC; ?/ fjn^v, idv }xol p.r] etTnj? tov
Xoyov (vavTLOV avTrjs Tavrqs, p.rfbiiroTi croi ^Tepov koyov
pLTjbeva firjbfvbs firJTe kitLbd^eLv fxrjTe e^ayyeAeti^j

2X2. Ba/Bal, S) fXLape, ws eS dvrfvpcs Trfv dvdyKrfv dvbpl

5 ^tAoAoyo) ttolLV b av Kekevrfs.

^J^AI. Tt 8^ra exwy a-Tpic^rf;

212. OvSey ert, eiretST/ (tv ye raCra ofxcafxoKas. tt&s

yap av otos t etrfv TOLavTrfs doCvrjs diiiyicrdaL;

237 *AI. Aeye brf.

212. Oto-^' ovv 0)9 Trot^o-to;

( <I>AI. Tou Trept;

212. 'EyKaAirv/rti/xeyos epw, tv otl Tdyji.a-Ta bLabpdfxu>

5 Tov koyov Kal fxrf ^kiiroiv Trpbs ae vtt^ alaxvvrfs 8ta7ropa)/xat.

4>AI. Ae'ye fxovov, to. 8' ^Aa ottcos /3ovAet Troiet.

212. "Ayere 8^, Mouo-at, etre 8t' (Lbfjs elbos kCycLaL,

eire 6ta yivos fxovaLKov to ALyuuiv TavTrfv ia-x^er eTTcoru-

fxCav, " ^vfx fxoi kd^ca-de" tov fxvOov, ov fxe dvayKdCei

10 6 ^ikTLaTos ovToa-l kiyeLV, tv 6 erai/aos avrou, Kat TtpoTepov
b 8oK<3y rovro) arocf)bs etrat, vvv tl fxdkkov bo^rf.

Hv ovTO) brf TTOLs, fxdkXov 8e fxeLpaKLo-Kos, fxdka Kakos'

TovTi^ b\ rjaav ipaaTal Trdvv TTokkoL. ets bi tls avTcav

e3 (i.riZevhs /i-fjTe T : fi7}Sev6i r' B

i^ayye\e7v i^ayyeWeiv G :

BT a7 \iyetai T ; \iyiai B a8
yeyos rh Aiyiwv ixovffMhv
Dionysius : yevos n fiovffiKhv Heraclitus yevos /lovffiKhv rh \tyv hv
:

Stobaeus ^ffxer eirwvvfiiav BT Stobaeus : effxere ri]V evwvvfiiav

Dionysius, Heraclitus b2 /xeipaKiffKos BT :ixeipaKiffKos aTra\hs
vulg.
 *AIAP02 237b

alixijkos rjv, bs ovbevos tjttov ip<av 7re7rei/cei tov TTaiba ws

ovK kpiat). Kai ttot avrov aW&v lirei^ei' roSr' avTo, a>s /x^ 5
epQvTi TTpb Tov kp&VTOs hioL \api^icrdai, <[kiyiv re cS8e
ITepl TTavTos, 2> Tral, p.ia apxv ^01? ix(kkovcn Kak&s
^ovkivaecrdai' dhivai 8et Trepi ov hv ri tj ^ovki], rj TravTbs C
ap.apTaviiv avdyKr}. tovs 8e irokkovs kikrjdcv ori ovk
Xa-acri ttjv ovcriav kKacTTov. coy ovv eiSoVes ov bLOfxokoyovvTai
iv dpxr] Tj]s a-Ki\j/eoi)S, TrpockdovTes 8e rb etfcos dirobLboaa-LV
ovT ydp kavTols ovt dkkrjkoLS 6[xokoyov(nv. eyo) ovv 5
Kttt av ixrj TTddo)p,ev b dkkoLS kiTLTLp.Sip.iv, dAA' eTreiST/ a-o\

Ka\ ifxoL 6 koyos TTpoKiLTaL TTOTepa ipSiVTL 7] fxr) fxdkkov ils

<f>Lkiav hiov, Trept epcoros oto'y r' eo-rt Ka\ rjv exet bvva-
fXLV, ofxokoyia OcfxevoL dpov, ets tovto aTTO^kiiTOVTis Ka\ d
dvacj)ipovTS rrfv a-Kiyl/LV TTOLcafxeda LTe ux^ekiav ilTe
^kdjSrjv TTapix'^^' otl fxv ovv brf iTTL6vp.ia tls 6 ipoos,

&TTavTL brjkov OTL b' av Ka\ p.rf ip&VTfs iTTLdvfxovaL t&v

Kak&v, ta-fxev. rw brf Tbv ip&vrd re Kol fxrf Kpwovfxev; 5
/8et av voifcraL otl r]p.(av cv eKcicrra) bvo tlv4 ecrrov Ibia
dpxovTi Ktti dyovTe, oXv kiTOfxeOa ff
dv dyr]Tov, 7] p.\v e//-

<j)xrros ovaa iiTLOvfxia rfbovQv, dkkr] 8e iiTiKTrfTos bo^a,

i(f)LfXin] Tov dpia-Tov. tovto) 8e iv rjfXLV TOTe fxkv bfxo-
voLTOv, ia-TL bi OTS (TracTtci^eroi;' Kat tot p.v 7] kTepa, e
dkKoTi 8e r] erepa KpaTCL. b6^r]s fxkv ovv iirl rb dpicTTOV
k6y<a dyovcrris Ka\ KpaTo{iar]s T(a KpdTCL a-o)(f)po(rvvri ovofxa'
tTTLOvfxias 8e dk6yo)s kkKovarfs tt\ rfbovds Ka\ dp^dar^s iv 238
^jLtii; Trf dpxr} v^pLS iTTOiVOfxdcrOr]. v^pLS b\ br] TTokvcavvfxov
TroAv/xeAes ydp kol TTokvfxepis Kai tovto)v t&v Ibe&v

h 5 cdrwv T
Heraclitus 4puvW : B c i Pov\ev<re(r0ai T : /3ov\ct^
rOai B Se7 B & 5? T : irayrhs B Simplicius : S.irapros T
C 4 irpo(\06vrfi t : irpo(rf\Q6vris B T C 5 a\\j)\ois B : &\\ois ex
oAX^Aojy T C 7 v6r(pa T : it^rtpov (sed a s. v.) W : om. B
C8 oUv t'] ot6v ri ci. Heindorf ^x" T: e7x ^ d6 o5]
8)) Schanz d8 ^Soi/wv T: Si/Xoc wi' B as iroAUjueAis
. . . KoJ iroAw/iepcs scripsi : iroAi;/teAis . . . /co2 iroAuf iSfS B Stobaeus
itoXvix(p\s . . . Kol -iroXvfiih T : iroAveiS^s . , . koI iroAwyueAes V
338 a nAATliNOS
eKTT/aeTr?)? ^ av Tvyy) y(Voy.ivrj, ti]V avrrjs eTTCdVVfxCav ovo-

5 fxaC6]Xvov tov txovTa Trapix^Tai, ovtc tlvcl Ka\rjv ovt

kiia^iav KiKTr\(T6ai. irepX \xkv yap ebcobriv KpaTovaa tov
Xoyov re tov apiaTov Ka\ t5>v aXku>v iTndvp.i&v kTtiOvixia
b yaaTpnxapyia re Kal tov ^xovTa TavTov tovto K(K\r]fXVov
iTapi^Tat.' irepl 6' av ixiOas Tvpavvevaraa-a, tov KKTr]}xivov
TavTr] ayova-a, bfjXov ov rev^erat Trpocrp^/xaTOs* xai raWa
br] TO, TOVTOiV ahfX(\>a koX abek(f)(av eindvixMv ovofxaTa Trjs

5 aet 8vvaa-Tvovar]s npoa-r]Ki KaXela-Oat, Trpobrjkov. rjs b'

f]

^vcKa irdvTa to. Trpoa-Qev ipr]Tai, crxebov ]xkv rjbrj (f>avp6v,

kexdcv bc r] fxr] k^x^^v TTavTo^s cra(f>ia-Tpov ^ yap avev
k6yov bo^s cttI t6 opOov opp.dta^r^s Kparqaaa-a iTTiOvixia
C TTpos r]bovr]v dx^etcra Kokkovs, Ka\ vtto av t&v kavTrjs avy-
yevSiV 7TL6vixL(av eTri cr(o]x(!LT(t)v Kdkkos ippo)]xivo)s poxxdeLaa

VLKr](Taa-a ayooy^, o.tt' avrrjs Trjs pdtfx-qs iTToovvixiav ka^ovaa,

ipois Kkr]dr]^

5 'Ardp, ai (pCke ^albpe, boK& tl aoi, cocrirep e/xaurfi,

^eioy tt6,6os TTfTT0v6ivaL;

^AI. Hdvv ]XV ovv, 0) 2(()K/3ares, irapa t6 eioo^os evpotd
rts o-e Lkr](j)V.
212. ^Lyfj Toivvv fxov &.kov. t<o ovtl yap delos ioLKCv
d 6 T^TTOS LVai, U>a-T iaV apa TTOkkdKLS VV]X(f)6kr]TTT0S ITpoX^VTOS
Tov k6yov yivo)[xaL, ]xr] 6avixda-r]S' tol vvv yap ovKiTL iT^ppo)
bLdvp6]x^o)v (p6iyyopLaL.
4>AI. 'Akr]6iaTaTa kiyLS.

a> 4 Stobaeus
4ieovo(ia^6fi,evov a 6 KfKrrjcrOai B KK\TJffOai T :

-^
a7 T6 T
Stobaeus om. B b 5 ^ B T ft Stobaeus
: b 7 vivrws :

Stobaeus Ven. 189 irav irws B T : b 8 t5 opdhv B T Dionysius

ad Cn. Pompeium rkyaOhv in marg, B* Dionysius de Demosthene
:

c I axOfiira B T pr. loc. Dionysius Hermias &yov)Ta in marg. B'^ alt. :

loc. Dionysius {nrh o5 om. marg. B'^ alt. loc. Dionysius kavriis
B* T Dionysius Stobaeus kavr^ B C 2 ippufxtvus B^ T Dionysius
:

Stobaeus ipd/xfvos pr. B

: ippwfJLfvus viiciiffaira secl. G. Hermann
. . .

O 3 ayuy^ B T ayuy^ Dionysius

: ivuvviiiav B T pr. loc. Dionysius
iiri&vfilav marg. b alt. loc. Dionysius
 ^I>AIdP02 238d

212. TovT(i)V ix(VToi (Tv atrio?. aWa to. KoLira aKov' 5

trrcDS yap kuv aTTOTpaTTOiTO to eTrioV. TavTa jxh' ovv deia

fxekricrcL, 7jfuv de TTpos tov iralba TraAty Toi Xoyto hiov.

Eier, S (f)epL(rT' o p.^v bt] rvyxai^ei oy irepi ou ^ou-

Afureoi;, (XprjTaC re Kat <opt(rrai, /SXeTrorres 8e 8?) irpos avro

ra XotTra \iyo)p.ev tC^ w(\)e\La t/ ^XdjSr] aTTO re (pcovTOS e

/cai jtA^ ro) )(apLQ3p.iv(^ i^ (Ikotos (TvpL^^q^riTaL. rM 87)

vTTo iTri,6vfiCas apxo[x^v(a hovXevovTC re rjbovfj dvayKrj ttov

TOV fp(t)p.(V0V WS 1]bL(TT0V kaVT(a TTapa(TKevd^iLV' VOCTOVVTl

8e Trai' 7/81; ro /otr) dvTLTiivov, KpelTTov 8e Kat i(roi' kyOpov. 5

oure 87/ KpfCTTO) ovT lcrovfxfvov ckmv e/)aoTT)y 7rat8tKa 239
dv4^(TaL, T/rrca 8e /cat VTTobeecrTepov aet aTrepya^erat^ i]TT(DV
8e d]xa6i]s (to^ov, 8etA6? dvbpeCov, dbvvaTos etTretf /57/ro-

pLKOv, ^pabvs dyyCvov. to(tovt(i)V kaK&v fcat crt TrAetoraji'

ara ttji' 8tayotay kpa(rri]v epco/xeVw dvdyKr] yLyvo]xev(t)v re 5

Kat (j)V(rL v6vT(i)v [t&v] fxev i]b(rdaL, tcl 8e -jrapao-Keud^et^',

7/ (TTip((r6aL tov TTapavrCKa r^beos.^ (})6ovep6v 87/ ardyK7/

etjmi, Kat TToAAwy pikv akkcov crvvovcrL&v direCpyovTa koi b
o)(\)\C]X(t)v o6ev av ]xdkLcrT dvi]p yCyvoLTO, ]xeydkr]s oltlov
et2'at /3Ad/37/s, ]xeyC(TTr]s 8e tt/? o^ey ai^ (\)povL]xb)TaTOs eu/.

roCro 8e r/ ^eta ^Lko(ro^Ca Tvyydv^L ov, ?/y ipaa-Ti]v 7rai8tKa

dj'dyK7/ TT6pp(x)6ev cXpyeLV, TTcpC^pofiov ovTa tov KaTa(f)poi'r]- 5

6i]vaL' Ta re dAAa ]xi]\avd(rdaL ottcos ar f/ Trdi^ra dyrocSy
Kai Trdyra dTTo^XiiTcav eis roi' ipa^rTrjv, oXos obv rw /jtei/

7/8to-ros, eauro) 8e ^Xa^^pcaTaTos dv etr]. rd ]x(v ovv KaTO.

bLavoiav iirCTpoTT^s re Kat kolv(dvos ovbafxf] Auo-treA7/s dvi]p c

eX'^1' epwra.
T^i' 8e rou (r(a]xaTos t^LV re koi ^epaTTiCav otav re Kat
wv 6paTT(V(r(L ov dv yevr]TaL KvpLO^, os 7/8v irpo dya^ov

d6 Kav B: &i/T 63 SouXfiJorT B : tj iovXfvovriT 65 /u^

T om. B
: a2 fjrrut' B T ^ttoi/ V
: a 6 ^vivrwv T Stobaeus
tv ovrwv B Twj' BT Stobacus : secl. Nutzhorn : To7y Heindorf
b8 favTc^ T Stobaeus : T(f dt^ B &>' V : om. BT
239C nAATHNOS
5 r)vdyKacrTai bKaKCiv, bel jjLCTa ravTa ibeiv. 6(f)$i](reTaL bi}

fxakdttKov Tiva koI ov orepeoi' bt^K(ov, ovb^ kv r)\C(o KadapQ

TeOpajxixivov aXKa vT:b o-u/x/xiyer crKia, TTOvuiv pikv avbpeioov

Kal lbp(aT(ov ^rjpQ>v aTreipov, fXTTi.pov be aTraXrjs Kal avdv-

d bpov bLaiTri^, dXKoTpioLS xpw^acrt Ka\ K6ap.0LS xr\TiL oiKL(t)v

Koa-fxovpi.Vov, oaa re dXka tovtol^ eTrerai TtdvTa eTriTij-

bevovTa, a brjXa Kal ovk d^LOv TrepaLTepoi} Trpo^aLVCLV, dkXa

ev K(l)d\aLov opLo-apiivovs eir' dXXo iivaL' to yap tolovtov

5 o-(S/xa v 7roA.e'/jia) re Kal dXXaLS xpeiaLs 0(raL fxeydkaL ol

fuv kyOpoX 6appov(TLV, ol 8e ^tAo6 Kat auroi ot kpaaTaX

(pofiovvTai^
Touro fxev ovv ws brjkov eaTOV, to 8' e^e^s prfTeov,

e rtm rjfxliv oxfieKiav rj Tiva fikdjir^v Trept Trjv KTrjiTLV rf tov

epQvTOS opiLkia re Kat eTrtrpoTreta irapi^eTaL. a-a(f)es bif

TovTo ye Trai^rt fxev, fxaKLa-Ta 8e rw epaa-Trj, otl tQ>v (pLkTa-

Toiv re Kat evz^ouo-rarooy Kat OiLOTdTUiv KTrjfxdTOJV 6p(j)avbv

6 Trpo iravTbs tv^aLT dv etvaL Tbv p(afXVov' TraTpbs ydp kol

fxrfTpbs Ka\ crvyyevSiv Ka\ (f)ik(ov a-Tepea-daL dv avrbv 8e'fatro,

240 bLaKooXvTas Ka\ eTrirtjUTjras rfyovfxevos Trfs fjbia-Trfs TTpbs

avTbv ofXLkias. dkka fxrfv ovaiav y l^^pvTa xpvaov r) tlvos

dkkrfs KTrfa-(i)S orjTC evdkoiTOV ofxoiois ovtc akovTa ivp.(Ta-

yjeipL(TTOV ^yj/o-erat* e S)V Trao-a dvdyKr) kpaaTrfv TraLbLKols

5 (f)dovdv fxev ovaiav K^KTrffxivoLS, dTTokXvp.4vr}s 8e xaipeLV.

TL Toivvv dyafxov, dTTaiha, doLKov otl TTkelarov \p6vov

TTaLbLKa ipaaTrjs eii^atr' av yeviaOaL, Tb avTOV ykvKV m
TTkeiaTov xpovov KapiTOvadaL kiTLdvfx&v.
*'Eo-ri fx\v brf Ka\ dkka Ka^d, dXkd ns baifxxav ifxeL^e rots

b TTkdaTOLs iv tQ) TTapavTLKa rfbovqv, oXov KokaKL, bLV(a dr]pi(o

Ka\ ^kdjSr] pLcydkrj, dpLO)s eTTifxeL^ev rf (fivaLS rfbovrfv TLva ovk

C5;uTaT: ^ue B S7;Hirschig: SeBT di /c({(r/ioiy BT

ffXht^o.<^i-v Plutarchus d 3 & S^Aa b t 245ij\a : BT d 4 *v
Ke<pa.\aiov'\ h Ke<pa\aicfi Ast e 3 Se T 75 B : 65 ev^atr
T eV^fT
: B e6 /iiirphs Ka\ T Stobaeus : ^irirphs B a 5 airoA-
\vfx4vvs BT : airo\\vfji.vois vulg. a6 &otKov T Stobaeus :

oIkov B
 (i>AIAP02 240b
aixova-ov, KaC Tis cTaCpav ws ^Xa^cpbv v|^e^eiey av, Kal aXka
TTOAAa T(i)V TOLOVTOTpOTTOiV dpfXp.dTOiV T Kttl fTnTrjbcVfxdTMV,
ots t6 ye Kad' rifjifpav j/8i<rro6(ny eii;ai VTrdp\i.' TratSiKOis 8e 5

epaoTTJs irpos roi ^Xa/Sepai Kat ets ro (rvvr]p.cpVLV TrdvTMV

drjb^a-TaTov. ^AtKa yap 87/ Kat 6 7raA.atos Aoyos Tiptmv tov c
7/AiKa ^ ya/5 otju.ai yfiovov i(rorrjs ^tt' to"as ^Soyas iyouo-a
bi opiotoTriTa (f)i,kiav itapi^eTai dAA' o/xcos Kopov ye Kat ^

to{)T(ov (Tvvovcria exeij Kat fxrji; ro' ye dyayKatoi; av fiapv

Trairrl Trepi iray k4yTaL' o brj iTpos rrj dvofxoLOTriTL jxdkL^rTa 5

(paoT-qs "npbs TraiStKa e)(et. z/ea)re'po) yap iTp^^rjivTfpos

(Tvvuiv ovd^ rjfjLepas ovt vvKTbs kKMV aTroAetTrerat, dAA' utt'

dydyKijs re xal oioTpoi) eAavrerat, 6s CKfCv^o fxv rjbovas det d

StSous dyet, opStvTL, aKovovTL, ainop.ivoi, koX Tiacrav at(r6r}(riv
aL(r6avoixV<a tov ipcofxevov, a>(rT fx6^ rjbovrjs dpapdrcos avr^
inrqpeTiLV rw 8e brj epcojue^yo) ttolov TrapafxvdLov r) TCvas
rjbovas bLbovs TTOt^o-et Tbv lcrov y^povov avvovTa fxrj ovxl eir' 5

icryaTov k\6LV drfbCas bpStVTL fxkv 6\j/LV TTpicr^VTipav Ka\

ovK V a)pa, kirofUvoiv 8e tS)V dXkoiv TavTr}, h Kal Adyo)
eo-rti' dKovety ovk e7rtrep7re's, fxrj otl bif epy(a dvdyKr^s det e
"npo^TK^Lfxivrfs fXTayjiLpC^(T6aL, (f)vkaKds re 8^ KaxuTroroTrovs
<f)v\aTT0fx4v<a 8td Trayros Kat Trpos aTrarras, aKaCpovs re
eTratrous Kat vTre/)/3dAAoi;ras dKovoj^ri, ws 8' avrcos \j/6yovs
vriipovTos fxv ovK dvcKTOvs, cls 8e fxidrfv idvros irpbs roi 5

fxrf dveKT^ CTrato-xcis, Trapprjo-ia KaTaKopel Kal dvamTnafxivrf

Xp()fXVov;
Kat ip&v fxiv /3Aa/3cpds T Kal dr;87js, Arj^as 8c tov
p(i)T0S ils tov ^Tif.LTa yji6vov dTrioTos, eis hv 'rroAAd Kat
/nerd TTokk&v opKOiv re Koi berfcreoiv VTTL(r-)(vovfXVos fx6yLs 0

b5 fiSi(rroi(riv fiSicTTois T Stobaeus

B : C i 5^ Stobaeus
.

Aristaenetus : BT
om. ripvnv B ex emend. T Tepirtt T :

C7 cK6[>i/ airoA.ciircTat B iuKoXiliarcu. tKwv T

: d.5 StSoi/s T &iSovf :

B SiatSoCs
: W e 2 <pv\aK<is T (/>t;\aKas B (coxi^OT^Jirous T
: :

Kaxvirh rSxovi B KOxwr<^7rT0i;s vulg. e 3 ajcaipovs rt iiralvovs T :

W
:

oKarpoiis re Kal iiraivovs B iwaivovs re Kol aKaipovs

: 65 v(i<f>ovros
T i/T^c^oi/Ttj B
: e 6 ^irojo^x*! ci. Heindorf ^ir' aXffxa B T :

PLATO, VOL. II. 16

241 a riAATflNOS
241 /caretxe Tr\v y kv r&i Ton crvvovcrCav kitiTtovov ova-av (f)pLV
8t' cXirCba ayadavj t6t brj biov iKTCvciv, piera^aA.cbi' akkov
apypvTa iv avTut xat TTpoa-TaTr^v, vovv /cat (Tu>^po(rvvr]v avT
fpcoTos Kal jxavCas, aWos yeyovcos AeA.Tj^ey to. 7rat8t/ca. xat

5 6 fiev avTov y&piv aTrairet tS)V totc, vTToixLfMvpa-Kcav to,

TTpaxdevTa Kal KeydivTa, s t&j avrai StaA.eyo/xeyo?* 6 8e iwTr'

atcrx^vi'?7? ovTe eiTrety ToXjxa otl oAAos yiyovev, ovd^ ottcos to,

ttJs TTpoTpas avorjTOV apxrjs 6pKO>p.6(rLd re Kat VTroo-x^eVeis

b e/x.7re8(0(r?/ exeij yoCy ?/8rj ea-x?]Ka)s /cat a-(r(ji)(f)povr}K(as, tva
fxr] 7rp(XTT(DV TavTCL T(o 7rp6a-6ev ojxolos re ^KeCvio Kal 6 avTos
TTO.kLV yevrjTaL. (})vyas br} yCyvcTaL ex tovt(i)v, Kal aTre-
, (rTpr]K(i)s vtt' dvdyKr]S 6 iTplv ipaa-Trjs, da-TpaKov jxeTa-

5 tt(t6vtos, terat ^vyr] fXTaj3ak(ov' 6 8e drayKa^erat StwKety

dyavaKT&v Kal eirt^ed^coi', -^yvorjKoos to diTav e dpxrjs, otl
ovK dpa eSet Trore p&VTL kol vtt' dvdyKr]s dvor]T(a yapCC^^rOaL,
C dAAd TroAu ixdKkov jxr] epStvTL Kal vovv eypvTL' et 8e ft?y,

dvayKalov et?y eySouvat avTov diTCaTia, Suo-koAo), (f)6ovp^,

dr]bL, ^Aa/3epo) /uiey Trpos ovaCav, ^kafSeplo 8e 7r/3os r?)y

roS a-(oixaTos e^tv, TroAv 8e l3ka^p(t)TdT<a TTpos Tr]V Trjs

5 "^vxijs 7TaCbva-LV, ^s ovt dv6p(aTT0LS ovt ^eots r?) dkr]6L(i

TLpi.L(aTpOV 0VT a-TLV OVT TTOT a-TaL. TaVTa T OVV XPV>

6) Trat, (Tvvvoelv, Ka\ ^lbivaL TrjV kpaa-Tov (j)LkCav otl ov p.T

evvoCas yCyvTaL, dkka ctltCov Tpdirov, ydpLV TTkrja-ixovijs,

d &)s AuKot dpvas dyaTT&a^LV, ^s 7rat8a (f)Lkova-LV kpacTTaC.

TovT KLVo, S) J^aiSpe. ovkt dv To TTcpa aKova-aLS ifxov

kiyovTos, dAA' ^br] croL Tckos XT(i) 6 kdyos.

a.i y' T: om. B odffay T : om. B as iKTiveiv B : eKrei-

veiv pr, T iKreivei G iiieTa$a\oi>v BT : ixeTa\a$(i>v corr, Coisl.
W
:

a 7 Sti T
oHt' ei B
: b i efnreSdxTri B T ifj.ireSd)<Tei vulg. :

b 3 aireffTepriK^s B T aTreif)riK&>s corr. Coisl. a.ire(rTvyr\K(iis G. Her-

: :

mann b^ SidiKeivT: SidiKwv B C2 Sv(rK6\(e (pOoveptp secl.

Spengel c 4 tov B T Stobaeus : om. vulg. d i &pvai
a.yaira)(riv BT
&pva ^tAoOff' vulg. : aiy' ayairSxTiv schol. Hermogenis
:
:

&pv ayaTrSxr' Bekker d 3 dA\' ^Srf B dAXo 5^ T re^os B T : :

vepas Vulg.
 *AIAP02 24id

4>AI. Kairot M/xTjy yi fjLCcrovv avTov, koX cpdv ra Xcra

nepl Tov fjir] (pQvTos, ws 8et KCv(d yja.pi^iadai pjakXov, 5
Kiyctiv oaa av exft ayadd' vvv be Sj/, &) SwKpares, rt

dTTOTraujj;

212. OvK -pa-Oov, S pLaKapLc, oti 7/817 Itttj cj)diyyofj.ai. dAA' e

ovk4tl hL6vpdp.^ovs, Koi TavTa \f/eyoiv; mv 8' k-naivilv tov
fTcpov dp^ciHxaL, tC pLC oiet TrotT/o-ety; dp' oto-^' ort vtto

rwi; Nu/x06iy, als jue o-u 7rpov/3aXe? e*c Txpovoias, (racfi&s

ivdovcTLdaro); Xe'y6o oui' ei^t A.o'ya) ori oo-a tov (Tepov AeAot- 5

bopriKap.V, rw eTepca rdvavTia tovtmv dyaOd TrpocrecrTLV. kcCl

Ti 6et fxaKpov Xoyov; irepl ydp dp.(f)OLV LKav&s etprjTaL.

Kal ovTco bi] 6 pLvOos otl TrdcryeLV TtpocrifKeL avT<a, tovto

TTeicrcTaL' Kdyci) tov iroTafxov tovtov bLa[3ds dTiipyofxaL irpXv 242
VTTo crov TL fxelCov dvayKacrOrjvai.

<i>AI. M?77ra> ye, u> ^<aKpaTs, irplv dv to Kavfxa TrapeA^rj.

rf ovy opqs o)s crxfbov j;8r/ fxecrrjfxlSpLa XcrTaTaL r} 8r) KaKovfxivr)
(TTadepd; dAAd irepLfxeivavTes Kal dfxa Trepi t&v lprffxV(i)V 5
StaAe^^eVres, Tdxa. eTretSdi; dTTO\jrvxr} LfXV.

212. 0etds y' et Trept rovs Adyou?, S) 4>at8/)e, Kat dT\v&s

OavfxdcTLos. oXfxaL ydp eyo) Tcav ttI tov crov (Biov y^yovoTcav
koycDV fxrfbiva TrAeious 7; o-e ireTTOirfKcvaL yyvrj(rdaL ^rot b
avroi' kdyovTa rj dXXovs kvi ye ro) rpoTro) TTpocravayKaCovTa
'SiLfXfxiav rf^alov e^atpai Adyov t&v 8e dX.X.o)v TrdfXTioXv

KpaTLS KCil vvv av SoKety atridy fxoL y^y^vrfcrOaL Adyo) rtrt ,

prfOrjvai. 5
<|)AI. Ov TToX^fxov ye dyye'AAety. dAAd tt&s brf koj. tlvl
T0VT(a;

d4 ye fJ.f(Tovu avrov V : ye fiiffovv avrov BT : cre fxtffovv avrov Her-

mann d6 \eya>v BT: Xe-yoj/Ta Stephanus : xiyovff Schanz
e5 ivOovaii.(ra) T : ivdvffidtru B a4 ^ 5)j t Suidas : ^^St; BT
^ 5^ . . . ffradf pd secl. Ruhnken a6 iiro)^i;xr?M' (^i'^) ^ *

airoifi;|j7 feojuej/T : dTroi|/ux; i^Trjyue' Phrynichus bi \SyaivT: om. BW

irciroiriKfvat Bt : Trfiroj/rjAcerot pr. T yfyfvrjffBai] ytviffOai H. Richards
ba T^BT: om. vulg. bs ^|ojp Heindorf f^aipuBT \6yov
W
:

B T Toi; \6yov
: b4 ytyfvrjffdai] yevi]ff(ff6ai Badham
16*
24ab nAATX2N02
2X2. 'HviK eixeXXov, wyaOi, tov TTOTafiov bLajiaivcLv, to
batn6vi.6v re Kal to do)6os (rrifjLH^v fxoi yiyv^crOai kyiviTo
C .det hi jix.e i-ntcryjii o av fxcXkoo irpdTTeLV KaC Ttva
(p(ovi]V ebo^a avT^Oev aKOucrat, r} fxc ovk ea aTrieVat TTplv av
a^o(n(aa-()i\j.aL, ws 877 tl rjfJLapT-qK^Ta ets t6 deHov. et/utt 8);

ovv jjidvTLS fjL^v, ov Tidvv 8e (r7roi8atos, dAA' &a-n(p ol to.

5 ypdp.pi.aTa (jyavXoL, ocrov piev p.avT& piovov LKavds' (ra(f)&s

ovv ijbrj p.av6dv(o t6 ap.dpTr]p.a. ws 87/ rot, oi kTcupi,

p.avTLK6v yk tl kcil r\ \jrvxV' ^M^ V^P ^6pa^ p.iv tl koX
TrdAat XiyovTa t6v X6yov, /cat ttcds bva-(aTT0vp.r}v Kar "IjSvKov,
p.ri TL TTapa Ocols

d dp.^XaK(i>v TLp.dv TTpos dvdpcaTTCov ap,i\j/(ti'

vvv 8' fja-6r}p,aL t6 dp.dpTr]p.a,

4>AI. Ae'yei? 8e 8^ rt;
212. AetyoV, Zi 4>at8/3e, biLvov Kdyov avTos re eKo'/xi(Tas

5 e/xe' re rjvdyKaa-as etVety.

*AI. n&)j 8^;
2X2. Ev-^6r] Kal vtt6 tl da-^ri' ov tls hv etrj 8etvo'repos;
^jAI. Ov8ets, ei ye av dXr]6ri Ae'yeis.

2X2. Tiovv; rw^Epcora ovk 'Ac^po^trTjs Kat 06vTiva riyfj;

10 ^AI. AiyiTai ye 877.

2X2. Ov rt vtt6 ye Auctou, oir8e vtto tov (tov Koyov, 6s

e 8td Tov p.ov crT6p.aTos KaTa(f)app.aKev6VT0S vtt^ aov eAe'x^>].

ei 8' ecTTLV, wo-irep ovv ea-TL, 6e6s r/ rt ^eioi; 6 "E/jws, ovbev

dv KaK6v eXr], ro) 8e Adyco ro) vw8r/ 7re/3t avTov eiiTeTrjv ws

roiovrou ovtos' TavTj] re ovy rjp.apTavTr]v iTepl t6v "EpcoTa,

5 Iri re ^ euij^eia avTolv Trdvv da-Teia, t6 /x)/8ey vyies KeyovT^

b 9 T Kal B T : del. ci. Schanz : /tot al V (om. mox fxoC) : koX Proclus

ri B T Proclus : om. al. c i &el . . . irpdrreip secl. Heindorf,

at legit Proclus 6 BT : & Proclus Proclus om. B T
038^ :

C5 M-^i' B : om. T IkolvSs T iKavZs

: B c 6 ws 61^ toi 5 T W :

Sos B W^
5e voiou (e et ir s. v.) d i a/n$\aKii!V B: anTrKaKuv T
riixhv T rifiav B
: d7 o5 tjs T : oij rts B : o5 ti (et mox Seiv^rfpov)
Proclus dii oi; Tt T: 6ti B : oHroi Heindorf es rw 5ii Xoyt
Tcii T T^
: 8i \6y<f rf B 65 ^ti rt T ; elVt B
 4>AIAP0S a43a

/XTjSe aX.rjdS crnwvvicrQaL ws tX ovt, ei apa avOpcDTria-KOVi 343

Ttvas i^aTTarqa-avTi vboKLfxri<rTov kv avTols. e/xoi pikv ovv,

w (f)Lk, KadrjpacrdaL avdyKrj' ^(ttlv toIs ap.apTavov(TL Trepi

fivOokoyCav KoJdapfws dpyjXLOs, ov "Ofxrjpos /xei' ovk fj(r6eTo,

^TTicrLxopos bi. tG)v yap ofXjxdTcov (TTeprfdels bLO, Trjv ^EXivrjs 5

KaKrjyopCav ovk riyv6rj(r(v uxnrep "Ofjiripos, dAA' are /xovcrtKos

o)v yv(o T7]v aLTLav, KaX Troiei evOvs
OvK iCTT iTVfXOS KoyOS OVTOS,
ovh^ ejias Iv vrfvarXv evaeXfXOLS,

ovb^ LKo Uipyafxa TpoCas' b

Kal TTOLrjcras brf irdcrav Trjv KaXovfxivrfv YlaXLVi^bLav irapa-

X/)^/xa dvl3k\l/V. eyo) ovv ao^dtTepos KLV(av yevrjcrofxaL

KttT avTO ye tovto' irplv ydp tl Ttadelv bLO. rrjv TOV^EpooTos

KaKrfyopiav TTLpd(rofxaL avr^ dirobovvaL Trfv TrakLV^obiav, 5
yvfxvfj Trj K(f)akrj Kal ov^ wo-Trep t6t vtt' al(r)(yin]s

yKKakvfXfXVOS.
^AI. TovT(f)VL, S) ^(aKpaTs, ovk (ttlv dTT dv fxo\ ctTres

rjbid).

212. Kal ydp, wya^e 4>at8pe, ivvoets tos dvaLb&s Xprf<T0ov c

Tob k6y<t), ovTos T Kal 6 K Tov ^L^kiov prjdeis. et ydp
aKovcDV TLS TvyoL rjfx&v yevvdbas kol TTpaos t6 ^Oos, Tpov
8e rotouTou ep^av rj Kal i:p6Tp6v ttot kpacrdeis, ky6vTO)v
U)S bLa (TfXLKpa fXydkas ^\6pas oi pa(TTal dvaLpovvTaL koX 5
i\OVCrL TTpoS Ta TTaLbLKa (f)d0Vp&S T Kal ^ka^p&S, TT&S OVK
dv olei avTov rfyelcrOaL dKOVLV v vavTaLS ttov T6pafXfXVa)v
Kal ovbeva kv6pov l/acora eojpaKOTO)!;, iTokkov 8' dv 8etv
rjfXLV bfxokoyew d \jryofXV tov "Epo^Ta; d
<J>AI. "l^Tcos vrf Ai\ S) ScoKpaTes.
2X2. TouToV ye Toivvv eycoye al(T-)(yv6fXvos, Kal avrov
Tov "EpcoTa bebLCJS, TTL6vfx5) 7roTi/xa> Aoyo) oXov dkfxvpav

a r /xriSh T : ju^jtc B a^ iroi(7] ivoiti H. Richards ap oW

(fias T : ovhf fias B b 6 tt} om. B T : c 2 ri> \6yu T : Ty
K6yif) B c 7 TfOpa^fjitvtnv corr. Coisl. T(0paixfji(vov B : T
243<i nAATnNOS
5 aKorjV aTT0K\v(ra(r6aL' arvfx^ovkevoi} be Kal Avcria ori. TdxKTTa
ypd\jraL o)9 XPV ^pcicrrTj fxakXov 7/ fxtj kpGtvTL K rG>v 6fio[(t)v

Xapi^ecrOaL.
JjAI. 'AA\' eS lo-^t OTL ^^L rovd^ ovrc)}' arov yap etTroVro?
roj; rou epacrrov (TraLVov, Trdcra dvdyKr) Avcriav v-n iixov

e dvayKa(rdr]vaL ypdyjraL av irepl rov avrov Koyov.

2X2. Touro /xey Trio-revo), eui^nrep &v qs 6y ei.
<J>AI. Aeye roivvv dappSiv.
2X2. Ylov 8?7 juoi 6 Trais Trpoy 6y eXeyov; tva Kal rovro
5 dK0V(rrj, Kal jxr] dvrjKOOs cov (f)dd(rri xapL^rdpLevos r<a fi?/

ip&VTL.
<I>AI. Ovros Trapa o"ot pidKa 'nkrfcriov det TrdpfarLV, orav
(Tv (3ov\r].

2X2. Ourcoo-t roivvv, S Trat KaXe, kvvorjijov, wy 6 /xev

244 TTporepos rfv Aoyo? ci^atSpoi; roC nu^oKA.e'ovs, MvppLvovcriov

dvbpos' ov 8e //e'AAa) Ae'yetr, ^TTjo-txo^pou roi; Ev(f)rjp.ov,

T/xepaiou. AeKre'os 8e c58e, ort Ov/c ((tt ervfMos Aoyos os dv

TTapovTOS kpacrrov r5 jxrf kpSiVTL fj.dkX.ov (f)rf 8etv x^P^C^'^^^'-'

5 Stort brf 6 fiev fiaiveraL, 6 8e a-^txf^poveZ et /xey ydp -^v

diTkovv rb fiaviav KaKov etrat, KakS)s dv ik^yero' vvv 8e rd

fxiyLcrra rQv dyaO&v rifuv yiyveraL 8ta fxavias, dcicL fxivTOL

bocreL bibofx4vrfs. 17 re ydp brf iv AeA<^ots TTpo(f)rfrLS aX t kv

b A(t)b(iivrf ie/)etat fxavela-aL fxev TroAAa brf Kal Kakd Ibiq. re xat
brifxo(ria. rrfv EAAciSa rfpyd(ravro, a(t)(f)povov(raL be ^pax^a rf

ovbiv^ Kal idv 87) keyonfxev 2t)8uAAaz; re /cat aAAovs, oo-ot

fxavTLKff xfi^P-^voL fvd(o TTokkd brj TToAAots TTpokdyovres ets

5 rb fxekkov &pd(t)(rav, fxrfKvvoLfiev dv bfjka TTavrl keyovres.

ro'8e ixrfv d^Lov kiTLfxaprvpacrOaL, otl Kal rwv TTakaL&v ol rd

d. 8 otro' aov Schanz : oStws ffov t : oSrws ou BT 64 toCto

B : rovrov T 67 vdpa Cobet (secl. mox ndpfariv) as XfKrtos
TW: om. B x6yos B: 6 \6yos T a8 yiip 5^) T yhp * B
: : ycip
Aristides b^ ^j/flfVT: iv e^oTs
. B bs &pOa>(roi/ Ven. 189
corr. V
Aristides opOus B T :
 *AIAP02 a44b

ovofxaTa Tidffxcvoi. ovk alary^pov rjyovvTo ovbe oveibos fxaviav

ov yap hv TTf KaWicTTri Tiyvr], jf to fiiKkov KpiveTai, avTo c
TOVTO Tovvoyia e/xTrAe/coires jxavLKrjv e/caAecrai^. dAA' ws
KaAou ovTOs, oTav Oeia ixoCpa yCyvr]Tai, ovro) voixCcravTes

idevTo, ol be vvv dTreipoKaAcos t6 tov eTreju/SdAAoires

}xavTLKr]v eKdAeo-ay.j eTrei kol Trjv ye t&v (ix(f)p6va>v, 5
(rjTrjCTLV Tov fxikkovTOS bLOL re dpvC6u>v iT0L0V]x4v(av Kal t&v
akXcov a-rjfxeCoiv, dr' eK biavoCas 'nopLQ)p.ivu>v avOpcoTrCvri

olrjo-fL vovv re koX ioTopCav, oiovoCa-TLKrjv 7r(ov6[xa(rav,

rjv vvv olcovLo-TLKrjv rw (b (refxvvvovTes ol vioL Kakova-LV d

6(r(^ br] OVV Tk((aTp0V Kal ivTL]x6TpOV fXaVTLKr] ol(OVL<TTLKi]S,

t6 re ovofxa tov 6v6ixaTos epyov t epyov, T6(r<a K<xkkL0V

]xapTvpov(rLV ol nakaLoX [xavCav a-oi(\>poavvr]s rqv ex ^eoC Trjs
TTop' avOpcaiToov yLyvojxevr^s.j akka ]xr]v v6(r(i)v ye Kai tt6v()v 5
T(av ixfyCcTTcov, h br] TrakaLcov k ixr]VLixAT()V irodcv V tl^tl
TStv yeviov rj fxavCa eyy^voixivr] kcCl T7po(pr]TV(Tacra, oXs fbcL
aTrakkayi]v r]vp(T0, KaTa(f)vyova-a TTpos Oe&v (vxas re Kal e
Aarpeias, o6(v br] KaOapixGtv re Kat reAerwr Tvyovaa k^avTi]
fTToCri^re tov [kavTrjs] \ovTa iTp6s re tov TTap6vTa KaX tov
iTTiLTa xp^vov, kvcTLv rw dp65)s fxaviVTL re Kal KaTacryofxiv^^
t&v TTap6vT(i)v KaK&v vpoix4vr]^ TpCrq 8e diro Movcroiv 245
KaTOKO^xi] re Kal fxavCa, kaj3ovcra aTTakr]v Kal a^aTov y^^rjv,
eyeCpovaa Kal kK^aK\(.vova-a Kard re wSds Kat Kard Tr]v

&kkr]v TToCr]crLV, fxvpCa rStv iTakaL&v (pya Koa-fxova-a tovs

TTLyLyvoixvovs TTaLbevfL^ os 8' hv &v(v ixavCas Movacav (TtI 5
TTOLr]TLKas 6vpas a(f)CKr]Tai, ttL(t6LS ojs apa k Tx^r]s LKavos

c4 iTrefiPa\6yTes Aristides c6 votovfjLeywv secl. Schanz :

Koiovft.ivr)v Stephanus C7 vopi^ofxivwv'] iropt^ofievriv Stephanus

avOpwvivp olijfffi pr. B Aristides : avdpwirivriv oliiaei corr. b (voi}(rei
voluit) : avdpwKivr) voifaei T C 8 oiovoCariK^v W
Aristides : olwvi-
ariKijv B oTov voiariK^v
: T d5 -ye BT : tc Aristides d7 ytj/cD',

^ BT : 7e'w' ^v Hermann e2 5^> T : om. B 63 eavTTJs

exovTu BT : eamTJs seclusi (glossema e^o)
avTijv ^xo''''^ Aristides :

&TT]s fuisse suspicor) a 2 KaTOKOixh KaroiKwxh B /caraKwx^ W : :

T KaToxh vulg.
: a 6 iroiriTiK^s B T Aristides Stobaeus (poeticas
Seneca) iroi7]TiK7Js Proclus Synesius secl. Cobet
: ireiadels B T :

Stobaeus secl. Cobet : ws &pa B T &pa ws Stobaeus :

34Sa nAAT12N02
TTOirjrljs icTofKvos, areAijs avros re Koi ij Tro^rjoris vtto r^s
roii' iJiaivoix4v(t)V rj tov auxf^povovvTos Tii^avCcrdt],

b Too-aOra p.iv <toi, koI ctl TrAeio) lx<" ixavCas yLyvofjLivrjs

aTTO 6iu>v \4yeLV KaX.a ipya. uxttc tovto ye avTo ixi] ^o/3w-
/u.0a, /XTjSe ris ^/:xas Xoyos 6opvj3dTOi) 8e8irro)u,6yos ws irpo

rou KiKLvy]\xivov tov (rco^poya Sei TrpoaipeLcr^aL (f)CX.0Vj aWa

5 ro8e Trpos iKeCv<f beC^as (f)pa-6(t> tcl VLKrjTijpLa, a>s ovk eTr'

((i(^eA.ia 6 epcos ro) kp&vTL koX roi epco/xeVcp eK ^ewy eTTLTTefnreTaL.

rjlMV 8e aTTobeLKTeov av TOVvavTCov, ws eTr' evruxia Tr/ /Aeyicrr?/

-Tra/^a ^eoiiy ^ TOLavTT] jxavLa bCboTaL- rj b\ br] aTTobeL^LS ea-TaL

bcLVOLS jxkv &1TL(rT0S, (TOCpols bc TTLaT^ Sei OVV TTp&TOV 'v/^X^*

(})V(r(as TTcpL dcCas re cai avdpcoTTCvrjs ibovTa TTadr] re Kat

e/oya rdXrj^es i^o^o-ai* dpx^ ^^ dTToSei^ews ?/8e.
5 ^ux^ Trdfra d^di^aros. to yap aeLKCvrjTov addvaTOV to
8' ttAAo KLVovv KOL vtt' oAAov KLVovfXVov, TTavXav ^x^^
KLvri(re(os, iTavXav exei C^fjs. fxovov bi] t6 avTo klvovv, aT
ovK aTTokiLTTOV kavTo, ovTTOTe Ar/yei KLVovfxevov, dAAd Kal
rois dAAots 6(ra Kiyeirat tovto iTr^yr] Kal dpxv Ktrr/o-ecos.

d dpxi] 8e dyivr]Tov. e dp\ris ydp dvdyKT] iTdv to yLyvofxevov

yCyv(r6aL, avrrjv 8e /ur/8' e^ kvos' et yd/a e/c rou dpx^
yCyvoLTO, ovK dv tl dpxv yCyvoLTo. eiTCLbi] 8e dyevrjTov
fOTLV, Kal dbLd(f)dopov avTo dvdyKrf etmt. dpxijs ydp bi]

5 aTToXofxivrfs oi/re avr^ Trore ex roi ovre dAAo ef eKetVr/s

yej^r/crerat, etTre/o e^ dpxv^ 8et rd -Trdyra yLyv(r6aL. ovto)

brf KLvrj(r(t)s fx\v dpxh t6 avrd avro kivow. roOro 8e or5r

d^TroAAvo-^at oiJre yCyvo-6aL bvvaTov, rj TrdvTa re ovpav6v
e TTa^rdv re y^y ets kv (rvfXTTe(rov(Tav o-r^vat Kai fxrfnoTe av6LS

eX^'^ d^ei/ KLvrf6ivTa yei^r/crerat. d^ai^drou 8e TT(f)acr]xivov

b T Aristides: nfuroi B
I yuei' ero b 6 d om. V Stobaeus d 3 Irt
Buttmann (et sic ut videtur lamblichus cf. Timaeum Locrum ap.
&p;t)j :

Theodoretum e/ yiip dyevero, ovk hv fjv eri apx<i) o-pX^h Vind. 89 Cicero '

(ut videtur) : 4^ apxvs BT Simplicius Stobaeus d4 aSid^Bopov T

Proclus : aSidpopov B
Si^eopw.Stobaeus
: e Philoponus
7^ els tv
i

yivfffiv BT Hermias Syrianus Stobaeus : e 2 *x*"'

yriv in marg. t
Stobaeus : ex*'" (rTVvai BT 5 T Alexander Stobaeus om. B :
 *AIAP02 2456

Tov v(f>' kavTov KLVOvixivov, \f/vxrji ovcriav re Ka\ \6yov

TovTov avTov ris Aeycoi' ovk atcr)(i;z;etrai. TTav yap croifia,

& fikv e^u>6v To Kiveladai., a^lrvxpv, ^ bi lEvbodcv avr^ 5

6^ avTov, iiy\fvyov, ws raurrjs oucnj? ^va-coas yfwxrjs' (i
8' (OTiv TovTO ovTOiS ^yov, 111] aXKo tl eiz^ai to avTO kavTO
Kivovv ri '^xqv, e^ avdyKijs dyivrjTov re Kai dOdvaTOv V^ux^ 246
av eiT/.

riept fjikv ovv dOavacrias avTrjs i/cayws* irept 8e Trjs Ibias

avrrjs 58e Aefcre'oy. otoy fxiv iari, jrdyr?; iTdvTOos deCas

etrat Kat fjiaKpds SiTjy^o-eo)?, w 8e eotKey, dvOpMirivrfs re 5
Kat eA.drroyos* TavTj] ovv kiycofxcv. eotJceVo) 8^ (rv[x(f)VT<a

bvvdfxei vTTOTTTipov C^vyovs re Kai rfvioyov. OiCiv fiV ovv

tTTTTOt re Kat rfvioyjoi irdvTes avToi re dya^oi Kai e^ dyaOQv,
t6 6e Toiv d\X(t}v //,e'/LtetKrat. Kat TrpooTov fXV rffxGiV 6 dpyoiv b
(rvv(apibos rfvtoxel, etra rwi' tTnroiv 6 fxiv avroi KaAds re Kat
dya^os Kat eK tolovtu>v, 6 8' e^ ivavTiodv re Kai ivavTios'
XaXeTTrf bif Kal bv(rKo\os i^ dvdyKrfs rf Trept rffxds rfVioxrf^ris.

TTfl brf ovv OvrfTov re Kai dddvaTOV C^ov iKkrfdif iTiLpaTiov 5

eiTrety. "^vyjf Trdo-a Traj^ros c7rtp.eAetrat tov d^f/v^^ov, TrdvTa 6e
ovpavbv TTepLTToKeL, dAAor' iv dAAots ei8eo-t ytyvofxivrf. reAea
fxiv ovv ovcra KaX iTTTipoofxivtf fxeT(opoTTopiL re Kat irdyra C
Tov KO^Tfxov bLOLKL, rf 8e TTTpoppvrf(racra (f)ipTaL ecos dv
crTepov TLVos dvTLkdjSrfTaL, ov KaTOLKKrOtL^ra, crSifxa yrjivov
Ka^ovcra, avro avTo boKovv ki,Vlv bid TrfV iKcivrfs bvvafXLV,
CStov t6 (TVfXTTav iKkrfdrf, \f/vxrf Kal croifxa Trayiv, BvrfTov t 5
crxv iTToovvfxiav dddvaTov 8e ov8' e^ v6s \6yov AeAoyt-
(rfXvov, dAAd irAdrro/xey ovt lb6vTS ovre LKav&s vorf^ravTcs

a6 ioiKfTw 5^ yp. t Hermias Stobaeus : ioiKf ry 8)? T HoiKe r^ 5^ :

B (01X6 S'^
: T^ V : ?oic 5'}j rfj vulg. a8 Trdvns avroi re T ol :

wdvTfs avTol B b 2 a^T^ B T : avTuy al. b 5 t T om. B :

b6 <|'i'X'^ woo-a Simplicius Trao^a t) ^vx^l B t) ^vx^l iraaa T

: y^vx^ 7f> : :

woffo Eusebius b 7 ovpavhv B T &v0puirov oSi/ Hei werden : V : :

secl. Badham e i ovv T om. B fifTeupoiro\f7 Syrianus

:

irdvra B SirovTa
: T
C 7 jrXaTTO/itj' Proclus corr, V irKarrofifvov :

B T of<Te ISSvTfs T
oCr' flSdres B Proclus
:
246d nAATaNOS
d deov, adavaTov tl (faov, ^xov fxkv '^vxw, ^XPV 8e r&i/xa, tov
au he xpovov Tama aviJiTrecf^VKOTa. aWa TavTa fx(v 817,
OTTT} Tw ^eo) ^i\ov, TavTT] ix^Tco Te Kol AeyeV^o)* tt^v 8e
ahCav Trjs tS>v ttt^p&v aTTo(3okrjs, bC ^v "^vxvs airoppei,

5 \6.^(>p.v. eo-ri 8e tis roiaSe.

H(l)VK(v 7} TTTcpov bvvap,LS To e/i/3/)i^es &yiv &v(a juere-

oipL^ovcra 17 to tQv Oe&v yivos oiKei, KCKOLVtavriKe 8e irr]

IxaXLCTTa T&v Trept to <r&\m tov diCov [^'^'X'^]

''^ ^^ ^eioy
e KaAoy, (TOipov, ayadov, koX ttclv otl tolovtov tovtols brj

Tp4(f)TaL re Kat av^erat /itiAia-rti ye to ttjs 'ylrvxrjs iTTepoiixa,

ato-xpw 8e Kat KaKw Kai roi? fvavTLOLs (fiOLvei re Kal 810A-

Avrai. 6 //ey 8t/ p,iyas rjy^ixoiV kv ovpav& Zet;?, eAavrojy
5 TTTrjvbv 6.pp.a, iTpSiTOS TTopVTaL, 8taKO(r/x.(3y iTAvTa Kal kiTL-
/xeAov/xeros' rai 8' TTTaL o-TpaTLa de&v re Kftl 8at/iiorctir,

247 Kara evbeKa piepr] KKocrp,r]ixivr\. //.eyet yap 'Eoria kv Oecav

OLK(o ixovr}' tS>v 8e aAAoji' oo-oi Iv rS tG>v 8w8eKa apLdfx^

TTayp.VOL dol 6.pxovTS rjyovvTaL KaTo. Ta^LV ^v iKaaros
Ta)(dr]. TToAAai p.\v ovv koll p.aK(xpLaL deaL re Kai 8ieo8oi

5 ivTos ovpavov, hs deSiv yivos vbaL]x6v(av TTL(rTp(f)eTaL

TTpaTT(i>v ^Kaaros avT&v t6 avTov, 7TTaL 8e 6 det idekd^v

re Kal bvvdfx^vos' (f)66vos yap l^o) ^etou xo/sou taraTaL.
OTav 8e 8^ iTpbs balTa kol (ttI doCvrjv Xoxtlv, aKpav iiTL Tr]v

b VTTOvpdvLov a^lba iTOpevovTaL irpbs avavTcs, rj brj tcl piev de&v

6xr]p.aTa L(ropp67T(i>s ^xrqvLa ovTa paStoos TTOpiVfTaL, to. 8e
aAAa fxoyLS' jSpCdeL yap 6 ri^s KaKrjs tTTTTOS [X(Texo>v, em
Tr]v yrjv piiTOiv re Kai ^apvvoiv w /x^ KaAus ^v T6paixp.ivos

5 t5>v ^vl6xo>v. iv6a br] 7t6vos re Kai ayo>v i(rxaTos "^XV

diriT-.rhB d2 T
S-f, : fjS-n B d8 f/ux^ BT: om.
Plutarchus e 2 aS^erai BT : HpSerai Proclus ij.d\t<rrd ye b :

jn.d\i(rrd re B : fid\i(rra T e 3 /col ro7s 4yavriois secl. Schanz

a 5 evSat/Mdywv BT Syrianus Damascius koI Satfi.6vwv Badham evSai-: :

jj.6vws Schanz a 7 Oelov x^P"^ ^ Alexander xop"^ deiov T

M Tsupra
:

a8 KoJ B : T Koi T Proclus virh B b i vtrovpdviov B

W (sed
:

Proclus : vvovpaviav e v) : ovpdvtov T ^ S); Proclus : I^St;

BT b3 KcJfojs T : kok^ j B b 4 ^i/ recc. :

'^ BT
 *AIAP02 247b

irpoKd.TaL. ai /xey yap a6dvaT0L Ka\ovixvai, rfviK av irpbs

aKp(a yiVMVTai, l^co TTopevdeTcrai, i(TTy]<rav CTrt rw tov ovpavov
v<oT<a, arda-as 8e avras Treptayei ^ iTepi(f>op6., ai 8e Oidopovcri c
ra e^o) rou ovpavov.
Tov be vTTepovpdviov tottov ovt tis vjxvrja-^ ttci) tS>v Trjbe

TToiT/TT/s ovTc JTOTe v/xr^cTfi /caT* d^iav. liyjei 8e (Sdf ToXp.i]-

Tcov yap ovv t6 ye dAr/^es eiTreiy, aAXcos Te koX Trepi dATj- 5

^eiay kiyovTa fi yap axp<ap,aT69 Te Kal d(r-)^rjpLdTia-Tos Koi

dvacf^rjs ovaCa ovtms ova-a, ^vxrjs Kv^ipvriTr] pi.6v(o OeaTrj
vio, Trept rjv t6 t^s dATj^oCy iTnaTrjpris yivos, tovtov iyjeL

Tov t6ttov. &t^ ovv Oeov Stdrota yo> Te /cat kTna-Tr\p.r] aKT]- d
pdTfc) Tpi^op.ivr], KaX dTrdcTTjs y\rvyris oar] hv /xe^AT/ to
TTpoa-rJKov hi^aa-Oai, Ihova^a hid xp6vov t6 ov dyaiTa Te fcat

Oeodpova-a TdXr]6r\ Tpe^eTai xat evTTadel, ecos di/ kvkAo) ^

TTepi,<f)opa els tovt^v TTepceveyKr]. ev he Trj TTepL6h<a Ka6op& 5
(jiev avTr]v htKaLO<Tvvr]v, Ka6opd he a(t)(f)po<Tvvr]v, Kadopa he
eiTLcn-qp.rjv, ovy^ 17 yeVeo-is TTp6a-ea-TLV, ovh^ rj eaTLV ttov eTepa
iv Tep<o ovaa S)V rjp.els vvv ovTcav Kokovixev, dAAd TTjy ev e
rw o ecTTLV ov ovto)s eTTLaTrip.r]v ovaav Kal TaAAa d)(ravTOi)S

TCL ovTtt ovT(t)s deaaap.evr] kcu eaTia^elaa, hvcra TrdAii' eis

To eXar^a tov ovpavov, oiKaSe TJA^ez^. eXdova-qs he avrfjs 6
r]vioyos TTpos Tr]v (f)dTvr]v tovs Xttttovs CTT/o-as iTapejBaXev 5
dpL^poaiav re Kat e7r' airr^ veKTap eTroVto-ey.

Kai ovTos piev 6e&v /3tos' ai 8e dAAat yfrvyai, r] p.ev 248

apLcrra 6e(a e7Top.evr] Kal eLKa(r]xevr] vTTeprjpev eis t6v I^co
t6ttov Tr]v Tov rjVL^xov Ke(f)a\rjv, Kal (rvixiTepLrjveydr] Tr]V

7TepL(f)opdv, 6opv^ov]xevr] vtt6 tS)V Xtttto)V Ka\ ]x6yLS Kadop&aa

C I vwTCf <rTti<roj Proclus : ydraii* ardaas T : ytirooi t<TTd<ras B

dfODpov<rt corr. Ven. 189 : Ofwpovcrai BT 07 o2<ra ^vxn^ T Sim-
plicius :
\pvxy odcra B : ^j/vxv^ Stobaeus : oS<ro Madvig dtaTi} v^
Clemens Proclus : fleoTfj v<f B : fleoT^ vtf xPV^rai TW d i r6vov T
Simplicius : rp^irov B ajcj)pdr(p rpfcponfVT] W Damascius : aK-fiparos
T
aTppo/x(V7} B et os s. v. : W^
a.Kr)pdr(i> vel ajcf^paTos <rTpi(pofjLVT\
da go-j; B: T
3<rj; fiix-q G: ntWri BT d^ Sefo^rOoi T:
iflrdat B d6 Kadop^ fitv T : KaOopSofitv B d7 ou5' I) B : ou
8?; T : ovi' fj
vulg.
248a nAATi2N02
5 Ta ovTtt' 7} 8e tqt fxkv ^piv, tqt^ 6' eSi, jQta^ojueVojy 8e TCiv

X7CTT(ov TCL jjiiv tiSei', To, 8' ov. ttl 8e br] akkai. ykLxofXfvat,

fx^v ^Traaai tov &v<jii ^irQVTai, abvvaTOV(rai. 8e, VTrQ^pv\t.ai

<rviJi.TTpL<f)pQVTai, TTaTova-ai aXX.ri\as Kal e7n/3aXAou(rai, kTpa

b TTpb TTJs (Tipas TTapuifJ.ivr] yeviadai. dopvjSQS ovv Kal

ap.ikXa KoX iSpcos ^o-yaTos ylyverai, ov hr\ KaKia rjvioyoiv
TToKKal iikv xcakevovTat, iroAA.at 8e TroAAa irTepa OpavovTai'
TTacrai. 8e ttoKvv i\ovcrai. ttovov dreAets Trjs tov ovtos 6tas
5 aiTipxovTai, Kal dTreAdoCo-ai Tpocpfj bo^aa-Tfj xptavTai. ov
6'
^vx V TroAA^ o-ttouS^ to aX.r]deLas Ibelv irebiov ov eaTivJ\
rj Te br] TTpocrqKQva-a '^vxrjs rai apiaTio voixrj ex tqv exei
C \eip.&VQS Tvyxo.veL ovaa, i] re rou TTTepov (f)va-is, u \l/v\ri
'
KOU(/)tXfrat, rovro) Tpe^eTaL. Oea-jxos re ASpaqr etay obe.

rJTLS av ^vxv Oe^ crvvoTTabbs yevofxevr] xartST/ rt t&v dArj-

6&V, {xexpi' Te Trjs eTepas TTepLobov eirat airqfxova, Khv det

5 TovTo bvvr]TaL iTOLeXv, det d^Aa/3^ etmf oTav be abvva-
T-qaaaa eTTLaTTea6ai Kai tlvl a-vvrvxia XPV^^I^^V
]xr] Xbrj,

X.r]6r]s re Kat Ka/ctas TrArjo-^eto-a ^apvv6f], (3apvvdeLaa be

TTTepoppvr^crr] re Kai eTTt Tr]V yfjv iTear], TOTe voixos TavTr]v
d fxr] (fiVTevaaL els ]xr]be]xiav 6rjpeLov (f)vaLv ev Trj iTpooTr]

yevea-et, dAAd Tr]V [xev TrAeto-ra tSoSo-ay ets yovr]v avbpbs

yevr]aro]xevov (f)LXoa6<f)QV r] ^tAoKdAou rj ]xov(rLKOv tlvos Kal

ip(i)TLK0v, Tr]v be bevTepav els (BaaLkeodS evv6]xov rj TTokeixLKOv

5 Kat apxi.KOv, TpiTr]v els ttqXltlkov r/ rtyos qIkqvo]xlkov rj

XPVP-OTLa-TLKOv, TeTdpTr]v els cf^Lkomvov {rf) yvpiva(TTLKQv t]

TTepl a(a]xaTQS taa-iv tlvqs eao^xevov, TTepLTTTVV ]xavTLKbv ^iov

e rj TLva Tekea-TLKbv i^ovaav eKTT] TTOLr]TLKbs rj t&v irepl

lxi]xr]aLV tls dAAo? ap]x6aeL, e/38o'/x77 br]pLLOvpyLKbs rj yea^pyLKOs,

6yb6r] ao(pLaTLKbs r] br]]xoKOTTLK6s, ev&rr] TvpavvLK^s. ev br]

b 2 ov 5^ T : ouStj B b5 o5 S' evex V corr. D : ovSiv ex< B :

oS 5^ eVcx' ^ T b6 o5 secl. Madvig c 3 t^ux^ ^

^^XV ^
C 4-5 Khv aUl rovro . . . aJel a0\afirj T W : / toSto . . . /cA;/ alel fi\dfirj B
^^ Xpri'^o.t'-^V7]T : xp'')<Tafxivri'& dI 6-fipeiovT : dnpeiavB d6 ^
add. Badham d? rivos Hermann : TiraBT 63 Srj/xoKoinKSs
T : SvtioTiK6s B 5^ : 56 B T
 4)AIAP0S 3486
TovTOts aTTa(TLV os [XV av 8iKaift)s bLaydyri aixHvovos fxoipas
fX(Ta\afx^dvi, bs 8' av dbiKMs, x^Cpovos' cis fxv ydp to 5
avTO odev iJKCL tj yl/vxt] eKda-Tr} ovk d(f)i,KVlTaL (t&v fxvpibov
ov ydp TTTepovTai Trpd ToaovTov yjpovov TrXTJy 57 tov (jiiko<To- 249
(f)i]cravTos dboKcos rj 'naib(paaTi](TavTos /xera (/)iAo(ro06as,

aSrai b\ TpiTr] 7re/oto'8a) ttJ yj.kuT^i, idv ^koovTai Tpls ((j)^rjs

Tov l3iov TovTov, ovTco TTTpo)6t(raL TpLcr)(^ikLoa-T(a T(L dirip-

yovTaL, aX b\ dXkaL, oTav tov 7rp<aT0V ^iov T^kfvnficrca^rLV, 5

Kpi<r0)s iTvyov, KpLOda-aL be al ^xkv ds Ta imo yr}s StKat-
(t)Tr\pLa kkOovcraL biKrjv iKTivovcrLV, al 8' ds Tovpavov TLva
TOTTOV inrd Trjs Aifcrjs K0V(f)La-6LcraL bLdyova-LV d^i(t)s ov (v
dvdpcaTTOv (IbeL (^i(x)(rav l3iov.\ tS be yLkLoa-T& dix(p6TpaL b
d(f)LKvovixvaL itI Kkr]p(i)(riv re Kat aLpe^TLV tov bevripov
^iov alpovvTaL ov dv 6ikr] kKdaTr]' 4v6a kol ils 6r]piov

j3iov dv6po)TTivr] \frvxr} d^tKi/etrat, Kat k 6r]piov oy Trore

dv6po)TTOs rjv TTdkLV ets dvdpo)TTov. ov ydp i] ye jUTjTrore 5
Ibovcra Tr]v dkr]6Lav ets Tob^ rj^^L to axrjfxa. 8et ydp dv-
6pu)TTov crvvLvaL Kar etSos k(y6]XVov, eK TTokk&v ibv al-
cr^Tjo^^coy ets kv koyLcr]x(a (TvvaLpov]XVov' tovto 8' eo^rty C
dvd]xvr]a-LS Kivo)V d ttot etSei' r]]xS)v r] yfrv)(r] crv]XTTopev6Lcra

^ew Kai VTrept^ouo-a h vvv cTvai (f)a]Xv, Kal dvaKvyfraara els

To ov ovTO)s. 8to 8t/ StKaicos jUoVrj Trrepoihrai r] tov (f^Lkoad-
(f)0v bLdvoLa' TTpos ydp (KiivoLS dci icrTLV fxvrffxy] Kara bvvafXLV, 5
Trpos olaTTcp ^eos o)v ^etos ia-Tiv.\ rots 8e 8t) rotovrots dvrfp
VTTOfxviffxacrLV 6p6S)s \p(i)fXvos, Tfkeovs det reXerds Tekov-

fXvos, Tfkfos 6vT0)s fx6vos yiyvTaL' i^LcrTdfXVos 8e t&v

dv6poi)TTiv(i)V o-TTOvbacrp.dToov Ka\ TTpos rw ^etfc) yLyv6fhVos, d
rou^eretrai fXV vtto tG)V TTokk&v ws TrapaKLV&v, iv6ova-LdCo)V
8e kkr]6V TOVS TTokXovs,

b3 0t\r) BT : efleX; Eusebius b4 $iou T : filov B b7 (t^)

Kar elSos Heindorf Ihv BT : otov rec. b : 16ut' Badham C i ^vvai-
B T ^vvaipovfjLfvwv Heindorf
povixfvov : C 6 Bths B : d Oths T
(utrumque traditum fuisse testatur Hermias) Oti6s BT : fledi
quoque traditum fuisse testatur Hermias
a49d nAATHNOS
"EoTt bt] ovv bevpo 6 ttcls iJKiov koyos TxepX r^s reraprijs
5 jxavCas ^v orav t6 Trjb^ ris 6pS>v /cdAAos, tov aX.r}dovs
avap.ip.vria-Ko^iiVos, TTTpS>Tai re koX avaTTTepoviJ.evos Ttpo-

Ovixovixevos avaTTTia-dai, abvvaT5>v bi, opviOos biKrjv /SXeTTCoz;

avoi, Ta>v KaTOi 8e d/xeAcSi^, alTiav exfi <us p.aviKS>s 8iafcei-

e ixevos 0)? apa avrij iraa-Qv t(dv v6ov(nda-(t)v apCa-Trj re

Kat e^ dpiaT(t)v rw re cxovti, Kal ro) kolvcovovvtl avTrjs
yCyveTaL, Kal otl TavTrjs ii(.T\(iiv Trjs fxavLas 6 ip&v TStv

Kak5>v paa-Tr]s KaAeirai. KaOaTTep yap Lpr}TaL, TTaaa p.V

5 dv6p(i>TT0V "^vxv (\>vaeL Ti6iaTaL to. ovTa, rj ovk av rjX6ev
250 f^s 7'o8e t6 C^^ov dvap.Liivj^a-Kia6aL 8e eK T&vbe kKuva ov
pqbLov aTrdarf, ovt oa-aL /3pax^(t>s elbov t6t raKet, ov6' dt
bevpo ire^rovaaL ebvaTvxricrav, c3o-re vtto tlvcov 6p.lX.lS>v eirt

tq abiKov TpaiToiiivaL Xri6r]v Stv t6t elBoy UpS>v yLV.

5 oAiyat 8^ XcLiTovTaL ats t6 Trjs ixvqixris LKav&s TTdpeaTLV
avTaL bi, oTov tl tS>v eKCL 6ixoi(p.a XboicrLv, (KTTkriTTovTaL
Kal ovKiT (ey) avT&v yCyvovTaL, b 8' eort t6 TTddos dyvo-
b oCo-i 8td t6 ixri iKavSis bLaLa6dva6aL. foLKaLoavvris ixkv oZv
KoX a-od(f)poaijvris kol oaa dkXa ri/jita^i/a^xctis ovk eveaTL
<f>eyyosi ovbev kv roiy r^8 6ixoL(i>ixaaLV, akXa bC dixvbpS>v
opydvcov /xoyis aurwy Kai oAtyot eTTt tcls clKOvas iovTes

5 de&VTaL To Tov eLKaa6ivT0s yivos' KaAAos 8e tot qv ibelv

XaixTTpdv, OTe avv evbaip.ovL x^P^ ixaKapiav o^j/LV re Kai
6eav, eTToixevoL /xerd ixev Al6s rjixels, dAAot 8e p.eT dAAou
6e&v, elbov re Kai ereAoCyro twv TeXerS^v rjv 6ep.LS KeyeLV
C {xaKapLiaTaTriv, rjv cipyLd^oixev oAoKATjpot /xey avroi ovtcs Kal

aTTadeLS KaK&v oaa rnxds ev vaTep(a XP^^^ viTeixevev, 6X6-

KXripa be Kal aTTXd Kal aTpeixi] Kal evbaiixova (f>dap.aTa

lxvovp.evoi re Kai e-TTOTrreuoyres ev avyfj Ka6apq, Kadapol

d5 ^i/ BT
Stobaeus ^ al. ^v vulg. : d 6 re koIBT StobaeUs
: :

secl.Schanz d 9 fiaviKws T fnaviKhs B 64 KoXurai B T

:

yiyverai Stobaeus a 3 SxTTf B yp. t oijre T a 7 ovKiT :

iv a&rwv Hirschig ovKir avruv B T ovKeO' airwv vulg.

: b 4 oXiyoi
:

B t oXiyois T b 8 rZv B om. T %v recc. ^ B : ^ T : :

W
:

C I upyidiofifv bpyii^ofxiv B T
: c 4 oiryp T outj? B :
 <l>AIAPOS 250C

ovTes Kal a(rrifxavTot tovtov o vvv hrf (rw/xa 7TpL(f)povTs 5

6vofxdCoiJ.V, ocTTpiov TpoTTov bebccrpLfvpifVOL.

Tavra /xer ovv ^tvriiJ.ri KexapicrOoi, hC rjv tto^ci) t&v t6t

vvv pLaKpoTcpa ftpr\Tai.' irepl bc KaXKovs, cocnrep (iTTOjjLev,

fjiT KbV(ov re iXapLTTev ov, bevpo t ekdovTes KaTCLXrjcpapLev d

avTo bLCL TTJs kvapyicrTaTrjs ala-Oria- eoos t&v ripLTpu)V cttlK^ov
(vapy^cTTaTa. o\(/ls yap riiuv 6^vTaTr\ Ta>v 8ta tov crcopLaTos
epXCTaL ala-diicr(it}V,
f]
cppovr^aLS ov\ opaTaL beLvovs yap av
TTap^Lxev ^p(OTas, el tl tolovtov (avTTJs ivapyes (tbodXov 5
TTapdyjETo LS oyjrLV iov Kal TaWa ocra kpacrTo.' vvv 8e
K6.Xkos p.6vov TavTr]v ^cryje fxoTpav, a>a-T^ CKcpaviaTaTov LvaL
KaX epaa-pLLcaTaTOV.
6 pLv ovv //r) veor^^s i] bLcp6apixVos e
ovK o^eojs evdivbe eKetfre (\>ipTai TTpos avTO to KaXXos,
decopLevos avTov ti^v TT]b iTTOivvixiav, &ctt ov cri^iTaL iTpocr-

op5>v, oAA' r]bovfj TTapabovs TeTpdiTobos v6ixov ^aCveLV

7TL\LpL Kal 1TaLbocnTOpLV, KoX v/Bp^L TTpOO-OfXLX&V OV bi- 5

boLKev ov8' aia-)(yvTaL TTapa (f)va-LV rjbovifv bL(oKO)v\ 6 bk 251

apTLT\r]S, 6 T&V t6t TTokvdedfXOiV, OTOV 60Lb\s 7Tp6a-0}7TOV

tbr] KaXXos v fXfXLfxr]p.vov 7/ TLva crcafxaTos ibiav, TTpGtTov

fXV (f)pL^e KaC TL tS>V t6t VTTTJkd^V aVTOV bLfx6.T0)V, ^LTa
TTpOCropioV ci)S 60V aJ3TaL, Kal L fXr] ibbLL Tr]V TTJS (r(f)6- 5
bpa fxavCas b6^av, 6vol hv o>s dydXfxaTL Kal 6(o tois iTaL-
bLKols.j Lb6vTa 8' aVTOV olov K T
TTJS </)pl/C7]S fl.Ta^oKrf
Kal 18/30)9 Kol 6pfx6Trfs dri6r]s kafx^dvcL' b^dfXVos yap tov b
KoXkovs Ti]v aTTOpporfv 8ia t&v ofXfxaTcov 6pfxdv6r] 17 rf

Tov TTTpov cftvaLS dpbTaL,\ 6pfxavdVT0s 8e era/CT/ to. Trept

TT]V K(pvcrLV, h TTdkaL vtto crKkr^poTTjTOS arvfXfx^fxvKOTa ^Xpye

fxrf (3kaa-TdvLV, iiTLppv^Ccrqs 8e ttjs TpO(f)fjs uibr]a- re Kol 5

(opfxr]a- (\)Vcr6aL aTTo Tr]s pCCv^ o tov iTTpov Kavkos vtto
TTOLv t6 TTJs V^^x^^ ei^os* TTCLaa yap T/y to iroAat Trrepcor^.

C 5 cur-fifiavTOt'] fort. kwfinavroi H. Richarcls vvv 8^ T yvv B :

C 6 SfSforfifvfJLfvoi T S(Sfcrfj.(vfifvov B
: a 5 /i)> iSfSUi Cobet fiii :

^StSUi Schanz fii) SeSiefTj B (sed tli] punctis notatum)

: /lij StSUi T :

ba ^ . &pSeTai ante iBfpfiavOri transp. ci. Ast

. . ^^ T ^ B :
25IC nAATHNOS
C C^i ovv kv TovTio oXf] Koi avaKr]KiL, Kal ofrep to tov obov-
TO(f)VovvTa)V Trddos Trept tovs obovTas yCyvcTai oTav 6,pTL

(f>V(t)(Ti.v, Kvf](rCs T Kal dyavaKTrja-cs Trept ra ovXa, Tavrov

br] niTtovOiv fj tov iTTepo(f)Vlv dpyo^iivov '^vxv' C^^ ''f ko-i-

5 dyavaKTel Kal yapyakiCeTai, (j)vov(ra Ta TTTepd, oTav ]ikv

ovv l3\Trov(ra TTpos to tov iTaibbs KdXkos, CKeWev p.ipr\ eTri-

ovTa Kal piovT h bf] bid TavTa tjxepos KaAeirat bexopLevr]

[tov tixcpov] dpbr]Tai re Kat 6ep]xaivr]Tai, X(o(f>q re ttjs 6bvvr]s
d Kat yiyr]$v oTav be x^pts yevr^Tai Koi avxH-WV' ''^ '"'^^

bi.e^6b(t)V (TTOjxaTa rj to TTTCpbv opixq, avvavai.v6p,va fxva-avTa

aTTOKX^pei, Trjv ^XdcrTr^v tov TTTpov, fj 8' ivTos fierct tov
lp.4pov d7T0KKkr]fXvr], 7Tr]b&(ra otov Ta cr(f)v^ovTa, rf) bi.^6b(o

5 cyxptet kKd(rTr] rf) /ca^' avTr]V, uxtt^ iTda-a KVTov]xivr\ KVKk(o

V "^XV oi<rTpq koI obvvaTai, ]xvr]]xr]v 8' aS ^x"^""^^

'''^^

KoXov yeyr]6v. ck 8e dix(f>oTep(ji)v ]Xixiy]xivu)V dbr]fxovi re

Trj dTOTTiq tov TTa^ovs Kal dTTopovcra Xvtto,, Kal ix]xavf]s

e ov(ra ovT vvktos bvvoTai Kadevbctv ovt /ute^' fjjxepav ov dv

17 ]XViv, 6t 8e 7To6ova-a ottov dv oirjTai o\f/a-9aL tov ^xovTa
t6 KoAAosj Ibova-a 8e Kat TT0X(Tva-afXvr] tfxepov eAu(re jxkv

TO. t6t a-vfX7T(f)payfXva, dvaTTVoffV 8e A.a/3o{)cra KVTp(av t

5 Kat i)biv(i)V Xr]^V, f]bovf]V 8' av ravrtjy yAuKurarTji; ev T(o

252 irapdvTL KapTtovTai. odv bff kKovaa etvat ovk aTroAetTrerat,

ovbi TLva Tov Kakov TTp\ TrAetoyos Trotetrat, dAAa fxr]Tpa)V

T KaX dbk(f)&v Kal Taipu)V TTovTOiv kikqa-TaL, Kal ovaias

bi dfXkLav dTTokkvfxivTfs irap' ov8ey Ti6TaL, vop.ifx(t)V 8e
5 Kal Vaxr]]x6vu)v, oXs irpb tov eKaAAtoTTt^ero, TTdvTO)V KaTa-

(f)povif(racra bovkVLV Toifxr] kol KOLfxda^aL ottov dv iq rts

eyyvTdTOi) tov Trddov iTpbs ydp rw a-ij3a-6aL Tbv Tb KaAAos
b xovTa laTpbv r]vpr]K fx6vov t&v fi.yicrTO)v tt6vu)v. tovto

C I ^f7 t : ^^ B :
f f) T hZovTOipvovvTwv Bt : 6S6vtci)v (pvovTuv T
C3 tpvwaiv B: (piuxTi T: ipvwffi Bekker Kvrjffis T : Kivrjeris BV/
G4 (i7T: (rjB c 8 rhv 'l/xfpov secl. olim Stallbaum d5 kKaffTti
Ruhnken : eKdffTri BT 64 ffvij,irf<ppayij.fva T : ffvfirrtirpay/Mfva B
es wSlveov^ oSvvwv Badham a6 hv T : iiiv B
 cI>AIAPOS 252b

b^ To TTaOoi, S) TToi KoAe, Trpoy ov brj \xoi. 6 \6yos, avdpo)TTOL

fxkv ipodTa 6vo[ia(fiV(nv, diol 6e 6 KoKovcnv aKovara^ ctKoVcoy

bia vcoTryra yfXda-rj. \iyov<n 8e oijLiat riycy 'Ofirjpih&v (k

T&v aTTodeTiav cttQv bvo Itttj ety tov "Epoora, <Sy ro ^Tepov 5

v^piariKov Trdvv Kat ov (T(\)6hpa tl l/ixfterpov viwovctl 8e

<S8e
rw 8' ?;rot ^i^rjrot jLtey "Epcora KaXova-L TTOTrjvov,
aOdvaTOL 8e Orepcora, 8ta TTTfpo^vTop dvdyKrjv.

TovTOLs brj l^eo-ri /Ltey TT([6fa-0aL, l^eorty 8e /xt]* o/izws 8e 77 c

ye atrta Kat ro Tra^os t&v (pdvToov tovto exetro rvyx*^^^^ ^y
Ta>y /btey ovy Aios" oTraSwy 6 Arjc^^et? k\x^pLB^aTepov
bvvaraL (pepHV to tov TTTepiovvfxov a\dos' oo-ol h\ Ap((as
re ^epairevrat xai //er' ck^lvov TT^pLiTToXovv, oTav vir' 5

"Epwros oAwo-t /cai rt olrjddinv dStKeto-^ai vtto rou epa>/xe'rov,

({iovLKol Kal eroi/xot Ka6Lep(V(LV avTOVi re /cat ra TratStKo.

Kal ovro) Ka^' ^KaaTov 6i6v, ov (KaaTos t]v ^.opevrT/s, e/cet- d

vov TLjjLiav re Kai }XLp.ovp.ivos eis ro bvvaTov Cfh ^^^ ^^ ?/

dhLd(pdopos KOL TrjV r^8e TTpdoTrjv yiviaLV j3L0T(vr], Kal

TOVTif T<a Tp6lT(a TTp6s T( TOVS ^pdipAvOVS KaX TOVS dXKoVS

6fXL\(L re KOL TTpoa-^l^ipeTaL. t6v re ovv 'E/xora rwy KaXQv 5

Trpos Tp^TTov iKkiy^TaL (kocttos, Kal ws ^eoy avroy eKetroi'

Sirra (axyr& olov dyaXfxa TCKTaCveTaC re Kal KaTaKO(rpLU, o)s

ri/i?/o-cor re /cai dpytdio-toi;. ot /xey 8?; oily Atos 8toV rw;a e

ctyat ^rjTovcTL ti]v ^vxi]V tov v(pi' avTS>v epctf/xei^oy (tko-

TTOv<riv (niv el (f)LX6a-0(j)6s re Kai r]y(\xovLKos Tr]v (f)va-LV, Kal

oTav avTov (vp6vTes (paa-B&ai, ttclv TTOLOvaiv otto)? tolovtos

eo-rat. edv ovv p.i] TTp6T(pov e/x/Se/Swo-t rai eTTtrrj^et^/xart, 5

rore ^Trixcipj/^^cn^T^s fxav6dvov(rC re o^ey ^y ri bvvoiVTai. Kal

avTol ixcT^pxovTaL, lxvvovt(s 8e irap' (avTS>v dvivpCa-Kiiv i

b4 olfiai T : ol /leV B b6 vfipKrriKhv irdvv B : iroj/y v$pi<TriKhy

T Stobaeus b 8 8' ^toi T 5^ to B Stobaeus : b9 irTfpo^pinop'
Stobaeus irTfp6<pvToy B itTfp6<poiTov T
: d2 : ^jj recc. : ^^/ BT
d3 Piorevri corr. Coisl. : fiioTevfi BT d^ /cal rovs B : koI Trpby
Toiis T '
d5 prius t B : yt T e i d76y D : 5i* 3;' B : Su6v T
rLATO. voL. n. 17
 253a nAATXlNOS
253 Tr}V TOV (T(f)TipOV O^OV (ftVCTtV VTTOpOV(rL blO. TO (TVVTOViDS
^vayKacrdat Trpbs tov Oeov /3Ae7r6iy, koi e^aTrro/iej^ot avTov
t'^ livrj\xij ivdov(n&VTes e^ iKiCvov Xafx^dLvov^TL tcl edr} Kal
TCL iTTLTrjbevfJLaTa, KaO^ ocrov bvvaTov Oeov av6p(oTTio /lera-

5 (Tx^eLV KOL TOVTOiiv brj Tov epcapievov alTL(afjLV0L ^tl t [jJaXkov

ayaTT&<TL, Kb.v k Alos apVT(ti(TLv &(TTTp al ^aKXp.1, km Tr]v

TOV kp(i>}xivOV \j/VXriV ilTaVTkOVVTiS TTOLOVCTLV 0)5 bvvaTov

b opiOLOTaTOV T& (T(f)Tp<a 6iQ). o(TOL 8' av fxfd^ "Hpas ("ttovto,

/3ao-lAtKOy CV^OVCTL, Ka\ Vp6vTS 1Tp\ TOVTOV TT<XVTa bp&CTLV

'
TCL avTa. ol be Att6\X.(i)v6s tc Kal kKd(TTov t&v 6u>v ovt(o
KaTCL TOV debv 16vTS ^TjrOUOrt Tbv cr(f)TpOV TraiSa TT(f)VKVaL,

5 Kal OTOV KTri(TCdVTaL, IXLlXOVjXeVOL aVTot T KoX TCL TTaLbLKa

7Tl60VTS Kal pv9p.LCoVTS LS Tb KLVOV CTTLTrjb^VfXa Ka\

ibiav ayov(TLV, ocrr] K(X(tt(o bvvafXLS, ov (f)66v(a ov8' dveA.ev-

6p(a bv(TfXVC(JL Xpf^l^^VOL TTpbs TO, TTaLbLKd, oAA' ei? OfXOL^TrjTa

C avTols KOL rw ^ew bv &v TLfX(a(TL TTacrav TT6.VT(t)S otl fxdXLo-Ta

'JTLp(ii)ft.VOL ayLV OVTCi) TTOLOVCrL, TTpo6vfXLa fXV OVV T&V 0)9

aXri6&s p(0VTu>v Ka\ T\Tr}, idv ye SiaTrpa^corrai 6 TTpo6v-

fxovvTaL q Aeyo), ovro) Kakrf re Ka\ vbaipLOVLKr] vtto tov
5 bi ^p(ji)Ta fxavVT0s (f)L\ov rw <f)L\r]6VTL yiyveraL, kav
-^ alp6f}' a\L(TKTaL 8e 8?/ 6 aipe^ets rotwSe Tp67T<f.

Ka6dTTp v dp\i} Tovbe tov ixvOov TpL)(j} bLLko}XV yfrvx^v

Kda-Tr}v, iiT7TOfx6p(f)Oi) fxkv bvo tlv Lbr}, TfVLoyjLKbv 8e etSos

d TpLTOV, Ka\ VVV TL rffXLV TaVTa fXVT(t). T&V 8e br} tlTTTOt^V

6 fxv, (f)afxv, dya66s, 6 8' ov' dpTr} 8e rt? tov dya6ov

7} KaKOV KttKLa, OV bLL7T0fXV, VVV 8e kKTOV. 6 fXV TOLVVV
avTolv v TT} KakkCovL (TTdcrL o)v t6 T et8os dp6bs Ka\
5 bLr}pdp())fXVOs, v-^av)(r}v, iTCypvTTOs, AevKos i8etr, fxkav6fx-

a 5 TovTuv recc. : tovtov B T a 6 kb.v~\ x^" Madvig b i ^ipas

t : ^juepas BT C3 tA6t^ corr. Par. 1808 TXeiT^j : BT idv

C 7 ii(l\Qfi(v Heindorf : St(i\6fj.7}v BT d i ^rrvwv T : ?irir B

d4 aiiToTv T : avTwv B
 ^AIAPOS 253d

fxaro^, ri/xT/s epao-r/? fXTa (r(t)(f)pO(rvvr]s re /cai albovs, Kai

aXridi,vrjs 8o^?js kraLpos, aTt^rjKTos, KeAevo"/xar6 ^iovov Ka\

6 8' av (tkoXios, ttoXvs,
X6y(o rivioyjdTai.' elKrj (rviJ.TT((f)opr]- e
fx4vos, KpaTfpavxrjV, ^pa^VT pdxrjkos, (n/iOTr/>o(rci)7ros, fxekdy-
Xpois, yX.avK6fxp.aTos, v(f)ai,fxos, v/Speo)? Kal dAa^oj;eias eratpoy,

irepl S)Ta Ad(rio?, K(t)(f)6s, fx&crTiyi fxtTO. KivTpoov fx6yLs VTTfC-

K(t)V. oTav 8' oiii; 6 rjVLOxos ibcbv t6 kp()TiKov ofxfxa, iTd(Tav 5
ala-drfcrei bLadepfXJfvas ti]v \f/vxw> yapyaXLapiOv re Kal tt^Oov
k4vtpo)V VTT0TTX.rf(r6r], 6 fxev vttl6i]S rw rfVL^xdi t&v Xttttoov, 254
dei T Kal t6t albol ^La(6p.evos, kavTov KaT^yj^L fxrf ttl-

TTrfbdv T(a ip(i)p.iv(^' 6 8e ovtc KVTp(i)v r]VLoyjiKQ)V ovTi

fxd(TTiyos ^Ti iirrpTTeTaL, crKLpT&v 8e /3ia (f>epTaL, Kal Trdrra

TTpdyp.aTa Trapixutv tQ (Tv^vyi re Kal rfVLdx"^ dvayKdC^t 5

livaL re irpos Ta 7rai8tKd Kal p.vLav Troieio-^ai rr^s Toiv

d(f)pobL(TL(t)V xdpLTOS. TO) bi KaT dpxds fX^V dvTlTLV(TOV

dyavaKTovvT, o)s bLvd Kal irapdvofxa dvayKa(pp.V(' reAeu- b
t5>vt 8e', oTav p.r]bV
f]
TTpas KaKov, TTopVa-6ov dyQp.V(t),
i^avT Kal 6fxokoyrfaavT iroLrfcreLV to Kkv6pLvov. koll

TTpos avT^ T yV0VT0 Kal etbov rr]V o\frLV Tr]V tG)V TTaLbLK&v
d^TTpdtTTOVcrav. ibdvTos 8e tov ifVL^xpv rf p.vr]p.r] TTpos Tr]V 5
Tov KdAAous (f)V(rLV -qvexdr], Kal iTdXLV elbev airrqv /xerd
a-(a(f)pocrvvr]s V dyv(a (3d6p(o ^^5>aav' ibovaa 8e tbeLai
T Ka\ aecf^^elaa dviTaV viTTLa, kol dp.a rjvayKda6r] eiy

ToviTLa(a kkKvaaL rds rfvias ovTOi a(p6bpa, &aT Tt\ rd C

icrxia &fx(f)(i) Ka6iaaL rco iTnro), tov p,V kK^VTa 8id rd /xf/

dvTLTivLv, Tov 8e v^pLaTrfv p.dk^ aKovra. dTTk66vT Se

dTTQ)Tpot), 6 pikv VTT^ ato^WT/S' T Ka\ 6dp.^ovs LbpG)TL TTaaav
l/Spe^e r^y yf/vxWf o 8e kr]^as Trjs 6bvvr]s, rjv virb tov 5

d6 /cal secl. Badham d^ aXriOivrjs om. Heraclitus Kt-

XfvafittTi t Heraclitus : KfXd/iari BT e 2 ^paxvrpdxv^os B T :

Papvrpdxv^os V
64 irepl &ra Xicnos Kcxphs T irtpX Sira \a(TiOK<ii<pos
:

B Photius Synesius irtpiwrdKffios: vir6Ko><pos HeracHtus e6 aia-6-fi(ret

dub. Heindorf secl. Herwerden
: a i Kfvrptav^ irrfpuv Herwerden
as ^Ty) ^i/K^xv Herwerden bi r(\fvr&vre T : reXfvrwvrfS 3
17*
254 c nAATONOS
\aXtvov T t(T)(jiv Kol Tov iTT(afji.aTOi, /xoyis i^avaiTveva-as
^\oLb6pr](rV opyfj, TTokXa KaKi^cov tov T r]V{,oyov Kal tov
ofio^vya d)S 8et\ia re koX avavbpCa XnrovTc ttjv t6.^iv Ka\
d ofJLoXoyCav Kal TrdkLV ovk iOeXovTas TTpoa-Uvat avayKdC(v

fxoyis (rvvix^pr](r(v beopi^vdiv ds avdis V7re/)/3aAe(r^ai| eX-

66vT0s 8e Tov a-vvTcdevTOS xpdvov \ov\ d]ivr]iiov(iv irpoa--

TTOLOVfJ.evd) dva]ii]xvria-K(t>v, ^ta^ojxevos, \pe]XTi^(tiv, tkKOiV

5 rjvdyKaar^v av TTpocreXdelv tois TTai.btKoHs TtI tovs avTOvs
Xdyovs, Kal e7rei8r/ iyyvs -qa-av, yKV\ffas Kal eKTcCvas Tr]V
K^pKov, (vbaKcbv Tov ^''^^"'oV, ]XT dvaibeCas eA/cei* 6 8'

e r]vio)(os (TL ]xdXkov TavTov TTados TTa6(av, a>a-TTep aTTo va--

TrArjyos dvaTTa-(6v, Irt juaAAo^' tov v^pkttov 'lttttov K tZv

6b6vTOi)v j3i(t OTTicroi) (TTTda-as tov xaKwov, rrfv re KaKr]y6pov
yXSiTTav Ka\ Tas yvd6ovs Ka6^pi.a^ev kol to. a-K^kt] re Ka\
5 TCL la-)(La TTpos Tijv yfjv epeCcras obvvaLs eSco/cer^ oTav 8e
TavTov TToWdKLs Trda-yoiv 6 iTovrjpos Trjs vjSpfcos kr]^r],

TaTTLVOid\s TTTaL l^br] Trj TOV 1]Vl6)(0V TTpOVOL(l, Ka\ OTaV

tbr] Tov Kak6v, (f)6^(o SioAAurat* uxrTf (JvpL^aCvfL t6t rjbr] Tr]V

Tov epacTTov -^vxr^v toIs iraLbLKols albov]xivr]v re fcai behLvZav

255 TTa-daL. CLTe ovv Trdcrav 6pa7TLav ws icro^eos ^epaTreuo-
]XVOS OVX. ^TTO a-)(r]]XaTLCo]XVOV TOV pQ>VTOS dAA' d\r]66is
TOVTO TT^TTOV^dTOS, Ka\ aVTOS OiV <f)V(rL (fiCkos ro) 6pa-
TTVOVTL, av dpa KOL V T(a TrpoV^ef VTrb crv]X(f)0LTr]T&v ?/

5 TLVOiV aAAcoy bLaj3J3\r]]Xvos rj, Xy6vT0iv ois ala-)(pbv pS>VTL

TTXr^a-LdCcLV, kol 6ta tovto diTOidrj Tbv kpCivTa, ttpo'l6vtos

be rjbr] tov )(p6vov ^ re f]kLKLa Ka\ to )(j)0iv ijyayev ets

b To TTpocr^a-^aL avTov et? ofitAtai'* ov yap Sr/Trore ijxapTaL

e8 \iir6vT( T : Ktw6vTa B d.2 SfOfievaiv BT : SfOfj.evoiv Hein-

dorf d3
o5 secl. Heindorf d 6 eiretS^ T iirel Se : B
eKTelvas T
ivTeivas B
: e 8 <p6fiii> T ^6fiov B t6t' B icot' : : T
e 9 5eSiv7av Bekker SeSvTav B (sed kvi supra versum) : SeSotKvTav
: T
aa vifoffxrilJ.aTiCoiJ.evov T: viroffxrifievov B {ffxVl^f^^riCo '" marg. b"!

as <l>'i\os BT : <pi\os eis Tavrhv &yet Tr\v tpt\iav vulg. a6 airuOfj

corr. Coisl. : diraifler BT epvvTa t : epaiTa B T b i irpoaecrdai
corr. Coisl. : irpoecrdat BT
 <^AIAPO: 355 b

KaKov KttKia (f)Ckov ovb' ayaOov fxij (f)i\ov ayad(o eirat.

TTpo(T(fj.4vov 8e Ka\ Xoyov Kal djXLkCav h^^ap.ivov, lyyvQi.v

1] (vvoia yiyvofxivy] tov ipS)VTos (KTrXifTTet tov epaixevov
hiaKrOavoyiivov otl ovb' ol <Tvp,7TavTs aAAot (pCXoi. re Kal 5
oIklol fiolpav </)iAtas ovbepXav Tiape\ovTai. Trpbs tov evOiov

(f)Ckov. oTav 8e )(^povC^r] tovto bpStv kox Ttkr^^na^rf p.eTa

Tov aTTT(rdaL ev T yvp.vacrCoLS /cat er raty aAAats 6/w,tAtais,

TOT^ ijbr] r/ Tov pevp.aTos (KfCvov Trrjy?/, ov Xp.pov Zeus' C

Yavvp.i]bovs (pcov b)v6p.aae, ttoAAt) (\)ipop.ivr] Trpos tov
epaoTijv, pikv etj avTov ebv, r]
8' a'no\J.(TTOV]xivov e^a>
7)

aTroppL'. Kal oXov TTVV]xa ij tls '^x^ ^''^^ keCcov re xat

(TTepe&v akkop.vr] TrdkLV oOev ^p]ir]dr] <^e/)erat, ovrco to 5
Tov KakXovs pvp.a irdkLV ets roy KaAoi^ 8ta tS)V 6pL]xdT<i)v

i6v;
f]
iT(f)VKv eiri rqv ^l/vxqv Uvai a(\)LK6]XVov koX dva-
TTTcpwarav, Tas 8to8oi's tQv TrrepcSy ap8ei re Kat o)p]xr](T d
TTTepo^pvelv re Kal rrjv tov ipoi)]xdvov av yj/vxvv (pcoTos
ivTTkr](T(V. (pa pkv ovv, otov 8e aTropet* Kai ovd^- otl

TTeTTOvdfv olbfv ovb' e^et (/)pa<rat, dAA' otoi; djr' aAAoi

6(f)9akp.Cas aTTokekavKoos TTpd^f^ao-LV Ittlv ovk e^ft, uxnTep 5
8e iv Karo7rrp<j> iv roi ep&vTL kavTov 6pS)V kekr^dev. k(u
OTav fxev eKelvos TTapy, Ar/yei Kard TavTO, KCv(o ttjs 6bvvr]s,
oTav 8e aTTfj, Kard ravrd av TTodeX Kal Tro^eirat, etScoAoy
epcoTos dvTpo)Ta ex<)y KaAet 8e avTov Kal oterat ovk po)Ta e
dAAd (fiLkCav etmt. eiTLdv^xd 8e KCv(o TrapaTTkrjcrCcos ]XV,
a(rdVa-Tpo)s 8e', opdv, d7rre<r^at, </)tAeti', (TvyKaTaKL<T0aL'
Kal 8r/, oroy euo'?, Trotet rd ^xerd tovto Taxv TavTa. iv ovv
Trj <ruyKot/>t?/<ret tov ]Xv ipaa-Tov 6 dKdkaaros lttttos ^x^' 5
ort Ae'y7/ Trpds tov rjvCoxov, KaX d^LoZ drrt TroAAaii; tt6vo)v
(T]XLKpd d-TTokava-aL' 8e tS)V TratStKwy ex^t pXv ovb\v etTreiy, 256

b 3 irpofff/jLfvov T : vphs ifie vov B \6yov Kol B \iyov t* koI T

:

b 8 ToD Eusebius : rovrov B T e i t6t' ijSrj B T T^re SJ) :

Eusebius C 4 airoppf? T anopft B Aefwv] (TK\ripwv Herwerden

:

<i 3 oM' B T oW Buttmann

: d 5 6<pda\fji.(av Ast d 6 alterum
tV sccl. Cobct e 6 Ae-yj; Bckiicr AcyttBT: At^oi Euscbius A'|t(
: :

Hcrwcrdcn
254 c nAATflNOS
^akwov T ^(T)(ev Kal rov TrTiofjiaTOi, ^ioyi^ i^avaTivevcras
kkoi,h6pr\<Tiv opy?], 7ToXX.a KaKL^oov tov re r]vioyov xat tov

oiio^vya ws SeiAia re koX avavbpCa XnrovTe ttjv tA^lv Kal

d oixokoyCav Ka\ TraXtv ovk (diXovTas Trpocnivat. avayKA^div

fioyL^ <xvveybipr](T(v beoixdvoiv eis avOis VTtep^aXia-OaLi eA,-

OovTos 8e Tov avvT^BivTOS xpovov [ov\ ap.vr\p.ov(lv irpoa--

Trotouju.eVo) avafXLpLv^crKcdv, j3LaC6p.vos, xp^ixiTiduiv, kKO)v

5 j]vdyKaa-V av TTpocreX.deXv rot? TratSt/cot? eTrt rovs avrovs'
\6yovs, Kal eTretS^ eyyvs ^crav, (yKV\l/a9 /cai eKretra? Tr]v
KepKov, ivhaKcctv tov \aKLv6v, ix^t avaLbeCas e'A/cef 6 8'

e r]VLO-)(os TL puWov TavTov TtaOos TraOcav, cSo-Trep aTro vo"-

TrAT/yos avaTrea-cav, (tl fxaWov tov v/BpLo-Tov LTnrov e/c T(av

6b6vT(ji)V jSLa oTrto-ft) o-Trcio-as tov xaXLv6v, Trjv re KaKrjyopov

yk&TTav /cat tcls yvaOovs Ka6-p[xa^ev Kal tcl crK^kr] re Kat
5 TCL la-\ia TTpbs Trjv yrjv epeto-as obvvaLS iScoKei'^ OTav 8e
TavTOV TTokkaKLS TT(!La\(ov 6 Trovr]pbs Trjs vfip^bis krj^ri,

TaTTLV(id(L9 TTTaL 7/8); Trj TOV r]VL6ypV TTpOVOLa, Kttl OTaV

tbr] Tov Kak6v, ({)6l3(o 8toAAi>raf a>a-Te a-vp./3aLVL t6t r^jbr] Tr]v

Tov epaa-Tov '^vxv^ TOts TratSiKoiy albovp.ivr]v re koi 8e8ti;ta2'

255 eTT(r9aL. aT ovv TTaa-av depaTTeCav ws la-66os dpaTTv6-

fXVOS OVy VTTO (ryj]]XaTL^Opi.VOV TOV ipCdVTOS dAA' akrjObiS
TOVTO TT^TTovO^Tos, Kal avTos oi)v (f)vcrL <f)Lkos rw dfpa-
TTVOVTL, kav Ctpa KoX V rw TTp6a-dV VTTO a-V]J.(pOLTr]T(JiV ?/

5 TLVoov akk(ji)v 8ta/3e/3AT//jie'vos rj, ky6vT0)v o)? alcrxpov ip&VTL

TTkrjcrLdCeLV, Kal 8ta tovto diTo^Or] tov ip&VTa, ttpo'l6vtos
8e 7/817 '''ov \p6vov
T r]kLKLa kol to xP^^^ rjyayV ets
ij

b t6 TTpocriarOaL avTov eis oy.tAtai'* ov ydp br]7T0T ^ifxapTaL

C 8 \tTr6vTe T \iir6vTa B : d2 SfOfievayv BT : heoixevoiv Hein-

dorf ds o5 secl. Heindorf d6 6irt5^j T: iirel S^ B
iKTfivas T 4vTeivas B
: e 8 <p6P(p T : tp^fiov B t6t' B : vot' T
 4>AIAPO:i: 255 b

KaKov KaKw (f)ikov ovb' ayaOov /x?/ (fyiKov ayaO(o eirat.

TTpo<TfXivov 8e Ka\ Xoyov Kal ojXLkCav Se^a/xeVou, iyyvdev

?/ vvoia yiyvo[i^vr] tov fpQvTos (KirkijTT^L tov cpcaixcvov

bLai.(rdav6ij.Vov oti ovb' ol crv/xiraires aAAoi (fyiXoi, re Kai 5

oixeioi fxolpav </)iAias ovb^fxiav 'napiyovTai. tt/jos roy h'6eov

(\)(Xov. oTav 8e y^poviCr] tovto bpGtv Kat TrATjo-ta^T/ juera

roS aTTT(rdaL tv re yvp.va(rioLS Kal kv tols aXkaLs ofXLkCaLs,

tot 17817 r] Tov pfvpLttTos (KCLVov TTrfyri, ov tfxepov Zevs C
raw/>i7/8ovy ep&v (avofxaae, ttoAAt/ ^epofxcvr] ttpos tov
cpacTTrfV, r] fxkv eis avTov ebv, rj
8' airofXi^TTOVfxivov c^w
aTToppL'i Kal oXov TTvevfxa ?/ rts i^X'^ ^'"'^ k(L(ov T kul

OTepewy akkofxhr] TrdkLV odev oipfxrfdrf (pipiTaL, ovT(t) Th 5

Tov Kakkovs piVfxa TrdkLV ets roy KaAoi; 8ta tQv dfxfxdTdiV

Lovi rj TTi^pvKev eTTt Trfv '^vxqv Uvai a^t^LKOfXfVov Kal dva-

TTTipGxrav, tcls bcobovs t(ov 7TTp&v ap8et re Kat &pfxrfa-i d

TTTpo^v(LV re Kal Tifv Tov p(ofx4vov av v//vxV ^p(>>Tos

iviirkrfaiv. (pd fxkv ovv, otov 8e aTropet* Kat ovd- otl

TTiTTovOev olb(v ovb' exet (f)pd(raL, dAA' oroy aTT aAAou

6(f>6akfXLas diTokikavKODS TTp6(f)acrLv etTreiy ovk exet, SxnTip 5
8e ev Karo-n-rpw kv rw epcovTL kavTov 6pS)V kikr]6iv. k(u
OTav fxkv eKeiros TTapfj, A?/yet Kara ravTa (KLV(a Trjs 6bvvr]s,

oTav 8e aTTrf, KaTa Tavra av tto6l Kal iro^etrat, ei^cwAoi'

e/3ft)ros dyrepcora exwv KaAet 8e avTov koi oierai ovk epcora e

dAAd (f)LkLav eimt. eTrt^v/xet 8e eKetVa) iTapaTTkrf^rms fxiv,
d(r^eye<rrep(os Se, opdy, aTTTfcr^aL, </)tAetr, oryKaraKeto^^af
Kat 8?/, otoy e^Ko'?, iroiet ro /lAerd roCro raxv ravra. ey ovy
Trj (rvyKOLfxr'](rL tov fxkv kpa(rT0v 6 aKokaaTos lttttos exet 5

ort Ae'y?7 Trpds rdy j]vlo\ov, Ka\ o^lol dvT\ iTokk&v tt6v(ov
(TfXLKpa dTTokav(raL' '6 8^ rwv Trai^iKwv exei /xey ov8ey eZireii', 256

b 3 irpocreiLifvov T : vphs i/xe vov B \iyov ko2 B kSyov re koI T

:

b 8 ToD Eusebius : tovtov B T C i rdr' ^Sr) B T r^re Si) ;

Eusebius C 4 aieoppei T a.iropel B Xelwv^l arKKrjpwv Herwerden

:

d 3 oCd' B T ovS' Buttmann

: d 5 6<l>da\ixlav Ast d 6 alterum
eVsecl. Cobct e6 Ae'7}; Bekker At-yetBT: At-yot Euscbius Aefei
; ;

Hcrwerdcn
fi56a nAATiiNOS
(r7rapyci)i4j6e Kal aTTOpcov 7repi/3dAAet tov ipaa-Trjv Kal (^iAei,

<as (T(p6hp' (ijvovv a(nTa(6ix(vos, orav re (TvyKaTaKccovTai,

ol6s ecrri fxr] av aTrapvt^dfjvaL t6 avTov ixepos yjxpi(Ta(rdai

5 r(3 epwvri, et bcrjdeCt] TvxeTv 6 8e opLoCv^ av ftera rou

TjVL^x^ov TTpbs TavTa p.iT alhom Ka\ Koyov avTiTeivei.
iav pikv brj ovv ets TiTayp.4vr\v re hiaiTav KaX (f)iko(ro(f)[av

viKria-ri to. /3eA.rta) r^s Stai^otay ayay6vTa, }xaKapiov fikv

b Kai 6p.ovor\Ti.Kov tov ivOdbc ^Cov bi(xyov(nv, eyKparets avT&v

Kal Ko'(j-ju.tot ovTes, SouAw^rdjuewt /lAei' w Ka/cta ^vxv^ (V(-
yiyvcTo, ikevdep^ixravTcs 6e w d/jer?;' reAeur^^rai^res 8e 8?)

vtt6tttpol Kal eAa^pot yeyoi^oVes rwr rptwy TTakaL(rixaTO)V

6 rwy <ws akr}6(as 'OkvfXTTLaK&v kv vevLKrjKacTLV, ov juet^or

ayaOov ovt^ (r(0(f)po(rvvr} avOpcaTrivr] ovt deia p.avia bvvaTr]
TTopi(raL avdp(a7T<a. kav 8e 8r/ Statrr; (f)opTLK(OTp(i re Kai
C a(f)Lko(r6(p(a, (f)LkoTipL(o 8e xp^/^'>^'"ci'> ^t^x' ^^ "^^^ ^^ ]iiOaLS

7/ rtf t dAA?7 ajj.ki(i ro) aKoAd^rrto avTolv VTToCvyioi) kaji6vTi

TCLS \f/vxas a(f)povpovs, (rvvayay6vT eis ratroV, r^y vtto

roir; ttoAAwi' ]iaKapL(TTi]v atpecTLV etAeV^rjp re /cat 8te7rpa-

5 ^dcr6r]V' Kal StaTrpa^a/meVft) ro koLTTOv rjbr] ^p^Srrat /xey

avr^, a-TTaviq bi, &t ov TTaa-r] bboy]x&a Tjt bLavoiq TrpaT-

T0VTs. (f)ik(t) fxev ovv Kal tovto), ^]ttov 8e iKeiva^v, dAAr;-
d Aoti' 8td re tov epcoros kci e^co yevopLcv^a bLciyovcrL, TrtVrets
Tas fxeyia-Tas f]yoviXV(o akXrjkoLV 8e8coKeVat re Kai 8e8e'x^at,
hs ov dejXLTov etyat Awayray ei? ixdpav Trore eA^etr. er
8e rr/ reAevr^ aTTTepoL ]xiv, oip]xr]K6Ts be TTTepovadaL CK^ai-
5 youcrt tov a-(a]xaTos, coo-re ov a]XLKp6v a6kov tijs epcortK^y
fxavias (f)povTaL' eis ydp (TKcJroi' Kai Tr]v vtt6 yrjs iTopeiav
ov v6p.os (o-tIv ^tl eA^etr rot? KaTr]pyfxivoLS rfbr] rr/s vttov-

a 4 &i/ T : om. B Eusebius a 6 Ao^ov corr. Coisl. : \6yovs BT

a 7 ^iv T & B a8 viKi^ari T viK-fjcrei B ba /x^j' ^T yuev B
ws
W
: : :

b3 S^ ^ T Sf 01 B
: Se 5e B S^ T : e i roix ' B T raxa:

C 3 ^vvayay6vrt B (ruvo^a^tJvTts T
: ri)v virh B : rijv inrh ri)v T
C 4 et\ecr07]v Eusebius fiK4ry\v B T : Steirpa^dadriv EusebiusSiewpd- :

^avro BT 07 4>(^'k> M*''

"^ <ptKwiJ,fv B d 2 rjyovfifvw recc. :

Tjyovfievwv BT ScSex^a' T ; ddxOai B d 7 virovpaviov B T

Eusebius : iirovpaviov Ven. 184 : virtpovpaviov Buttmann
 *AIAP02 256d

paviov TTopeiay, aXKa (f)avbv jSiov bidyovTas fvbaifxovelv

/xcr' aWriko>v Tropvofx4vov9, koI 6fjLOTTTpovs epcoros X'^P''^>
orav yV(i)VTai, y^via-dai.

TavTa Toa-avTa, Si iral, Kal OiM ovtco o-ol Scop^o-erai 17

Trap' kpaoTov <f)i\ia' 57 Se ctTro tov ixr] ep&VTOs olK^LOT-qs,

(ro)(f)po<Tvvr] OvrjTrj KiKpap.ivr\, OvrjTa T Ka\ (f)(Lb(aXa oIkovo- 5

fwva-a, dvckevOfpiav vtto ttAt/^ous iTTaLVovfifvrjv ws dp^TrfV
Tjj <f)i\.rf \frvxii ivTiKovcra, ivvia X'"^'-'^^^^ ct&v TTcpl yrjv 257
KvKLvbovfxfvrfv avTrjv Kal vtto yif9 dvovv Trape^ei.
AvTrf aoL, o) (f)iX. "Epo^s, eis rffXTpav bvvafiLv otl KaK-
\i(TTr] Ka\ dpiarrf beboTai t Ka\ iKTTL(rTaL TTakLv^obia, Ta
T dkKa Ka\ rots ovofxaa-LV rfvayKaa-fiivrf iTOLrfTLKoXs tlo-lv bLa 5

^aibpov dpfja-daL. dkXd tS)V TTpoTpo)v re (rvyyvtafxrfv koX

T&vbi X^P'-^ ^X^^> ^W^vrfs Ka\ tk0)s Trfv ipo)TLKrfv fxoL
T^xvrfv rjv bo)Kas fxrfTi d^ikrf fxrfT TTrfp^oa-rfs bC opyrfv,

bibov T TL fxdkkoV rf VVV TTapd TOLS Kakols TlfXLOV LVaL.

iv T<a TTpo^rOev 8' ci rt Aoyoj o"ot dTTrfx^s (tiTOfxfv J^atSpo'? b
re Kat eyw, Auo-tay tov tov koyov TTaT^pa aLTL(afXvos Traue
T&v TOLOVTo)v k6yo)v, eTTt (f)Lko(ro(f)iav be, &(nTp dbk(f>bs
avTov TlokfpLapxos T^TpaiTTaL, Tp\f/ov, Xva kol 6 ipaaTrfs
obf aVTOV fXrfKTL TTafX(f)OTpiClf Kadd-TTcp vvv, dkk' aTTk&s 5

Trpos "Epcora fxcTa (f)Lko(r6(f)0)v k6yo)v tov ^iov TTOLrJTaL.

4>AI. '!2vvVxofxai ctol, S) Sw/cpares, eiTre/) dfXLVov Tavd^

rffXLv LvaL, TavTa yiyviadaL. tov koyov bi crov TraAat C
6avfxa(ras ^X^' ^^^ Kakkio) tov TTpoTipov diTrfpydao)' 0)(rT

6kv& fxrf fxoL 6 Avaias raireiyos (f>avff, idv dpa Ka\ i6krfa~rf

d 8 Siaryay6i>Tas Eusebius e 2 yiyvwvrai H. Richards e3 0(ia

oStu B oSru 0(7a T : a, i x*^*<^5o$ : T
x*^"^5ey B yrjv corr.
Coisl. : Trjv B tV T
: a 2 Ka\tvSovfievr)u Herwerden yrjs T
rrjs B a4 SeSoTol T : SeSoKrai B a 7 rijv ipuTiKi\v fjLoi B :

r-fiv fjLoi ipwTiK)]v T a8 SfSwKas T

eSwKas B : a9 t' T :
5'B
bi eVT: om. B airrixfs Hermias airrivlsBT : h 3 aSe\<phs
Bekker : o5A.(^J>y B T b 4 rfrpaTrrat T W : ytyparrTai re ri-
rpavTai B
257 c nAATiiNOS
TTpos avTov aWov avTnrapaT^ivaL. koI ydp tis ai/rov, a>

5 6avp,d(ne, evay\os t&v 7to\i.tlk&v tovt avTo KoihopQiV

wretSi^e, Ka\ bia Tidanris Ttjs KoibopCas CKaAei Xoyoypd<^ov'
Td\ ovv hv VTTo (\)i\oTip,(,as kiria-yjai rjfuv hv tov ypdcfxLv.
2i2. rfkolov y, S) veavCa, to boyfxa Aeyeis, Kal tov
d eTaCpov evyvov 8ta/xa/)Tayet?, ei avTov ovro)? r]yi] Tiva
\lfo(f)obea. icra)s 8e Kat 701^ koLbopovp.vov avT^ oUi oveibC-
^ovTa X.iyLV h eAeyer.
4>AI. *E(f)aLVTo ydp, a> SwKpaTes' Kai avvoLcrOd ttov
5 Kal avTos OTL ol ixiyLo-Tov bvvdpievoC Te Kai crefxvoTaTOL iv
Tats 7t6\(tlv alaxvvovTaL koyovs Te iipd(f)LV Kal KaTaXiCiTLV
(Tvyypdp,p.aTa kavTS)v, bo^av (f>o^ovp.ivoL tov eTretra yjpovov,

fiT] o-o^iorat KaXcSi^Taij^

211. rXvKvs dyKu)V, a> I>at8/)e, kiXrfdev ore otl cltto tov
e fxaKpov dyK(avos tov KaTa NetAoy Kkr]6r]' Ka\ TTpos tw
dyK&vL kav6dvL o-e oTt ot p.iyLa-Tov (f)povovvTes t&v iTokL-

tlkS>v juaAto-Ta kpGxTL koyoypa(f)Cas Te Kat KaTakeC^coos

(rvyypafxp.dT(i)v, ot ye Kat eTreiSai' Tira ypd(f)coa-L koyov,
5 o{/Ta)s dyaTTwo^t tovs iiTaLveTas, &aTe TTpoaTrapaypdcf^ovaL
TTpcoTovs ot hv kKaa-Taxov TTaLvG)(TLv avTovs.
4>AI. riws Ae'yets tovto; ov yap fxav^dvd).
258 2X2. Ov ]xav6dvLs otl iv dpx^ dvbpbs TTokiTiKov [avy-
ypa/x/AttTt] TTp(oTos 6 iiTaLviTrjs yiypairraL.

4>AI. UQ)s;
"
2i2. ""Edo^e"' TTOV (f)r]a-LV " Trj ^ovkfj" 17 " roi S^/iiO)
rj dfx(f>oTpoLS, Ka\ " os {kol os) eiTrey
" tov avTov bri kiyo)v
5

fxdka aefxv&s Ka\ kyKOifXLd^a^v o a-vyypa(f)vs eTretra Ae'yet

C 4 avrhv B T avruu vulg. avr^ Heindorf

: : d i riye7 riva B :

rtyh ^7? T d 2 oi/eiSlCovra Postgate oveidlCovra vo/xiCovra B : :

vo[iL(ovra TW dg
Srt . e i iK\i)dri secl. Heindorf
. . 65 itrai-
veras BT: iiraivovvras V 67 \fyeis rovro B: rovro \eyfis T
a I dpx^ secl. Madvig avSphs secl. Herwerden (et mox (rvyypdfj.fxaros)
:

iTvyypifiiuLari' seclusi avyypafjiixaros vulg.

: a^ ^)j<n B ^rjtrl' :

auTWj' rb (Tvyypafxfia. T W : <\);i(riv avrh rh <rvyypaft.fi(i vulg. a 5 Kal

tis add. Winckelmann
 ^AlAPOii; 258a

br] ixeTa tovto, (iTi.bd.KVviMivos rois eTrati^erats Tip kavTov

(ro(f)iav, kvioTi iravv fxaKpbv 7T0i.r](rdfjLVos o-vyypa[j.ixa' ?/ aoi
dWo TL (paiviTai to toiovtov ^ Xoyos (Tvyyeypap.iJ.ivos;
4>AI. OvK p.oLye. b
2X2. OvKovv iav piev ovtos ip.p.ivT^, yiyr\6^s di^epxeTaL
K Tov OeaTpov 6 TTOLr^Tris' fdv 8e e^a\L(f)6f} Kal dp.oLpos

yivrjTaL \oyoypa(f)Las re Kal tov d^ios ilvaL (rvyypa(f)LV,

TrevdfL avTos re Kal oi eratpoi. 5

4>A1. Kai p.dX.a.

Sii. Arj\6v ye otl ovx ws uTrep^porowres tov eirtrJjSei;-

p.aTos, dAA' 0)9 T(6avp.aK6TS.

4>AI. Udvv p.ev ovv.

2X2. Tt bi; oTav LKavos yivr\TaL prJT(op tj ^aaikeus, axTTC lo

Xa^(i)v rqv AvKOVpyov rj 'EoXoovos rj AapLov bvvap.LV d6d- c

vaTos yevicrdaL Xoyoypd(f)os iv tt6X(l, dp' ovk l(r66OV

^yetrat avro's re avTov ert C^v, Kal ol eTretra yiyro^jiAerot

Tavrd raura Trept avTov vop.LCov(n, ^ew/xerot avroO Ta avy-

ypdp.p.aTa; 5
4>AI. Kal p.dXa.
2X2. Otei rtva ovv t&v tolovtoov, ootls Kal oTrcoo-riow
bv(rvovs Arcrta, oretSt^eti' avro tovto otl (rvyypa(f>eL;
<i>AI. OvKOW etKo's ye ef cSy o-i; Ae'yets* cai ydp dv Trj

kaVTOV iTrL6vp.L(l, &)S COLKV, ovetSt^oi. lO

2X2. Touro p.(v dpa iravTl brjXov, ort ovk al(TXpbv avT6 d
ye ro ypa</)ety Xo'yous.
<I>AI. Tt' ydp;
2X2. 'AAA' K(Xvo o1p.aL al^ryjpbv rjbr), Tb p.i] koX&s XiycLV
re Kat ypd(f)(LV dAA' ato-xpws re Kat KaKws. 5
4>AI. ArjXov b^q.

2X2. Tts ovv 6 Tpdms tov KaX&s re Kat p.r] ypd(f>Lv;

b6p.(6d TL, 0) 4>at8pe, Av^rCav re Trept TovT(t)V e^erdo-ai Kal

a7 (tJ) /terA Krische b3 4^a\ei<pd^ T : i(a\i<p^ B C 7 T^va

oiv B : oSi/ Ttj^o T C8 oiiTb] owt^ Ast d4 o?^at B : otfuii
fff T : oImoi ye vulg. d8 ti BT : to vulg.
258d nAAT12N02
aWov ocTTis TTWTrore n yiypat^av rj ypdyj/ei, ctre TroAtriKoy

lo (rvyypap.pxi etre tStwriKoV, kv ixirpio ws TrotJjr^s 17 6.VV

fXiTpov 0)s IbKaTrjs;

e 4>AI. 'Epcoras ei 8eo'/ixe^a; rtvos /itey ovr^ eveKa K^y

ris m (iTTelvC^ ^X/C q t&v tolovtujv fjbovoiv (vcKa; ov
ydp TTOV eKetVcoy ye wv TTpoXviT-qOfjvai 8et 17 /lAT/Se fj(r0rjvai.,
1 o 8^ oA.tyov Trao-at at Trept to aSifxa T]bovaX ^ypva-i' bio Koi

5 StKatcos dvbpaT:ob(abLS KKXr]VTai.

212. 2)(oX^ jutei' 87/, ws eotKe* Kai a/xa juoi 8oKoo-ti' ws

ey ro) irviyei, VTrep K(f)aXr]s fjpi&v ol T^TTLyes aSorres Kat
259 dAA^Aois 8iaA.eyoftei'ot Kadopdv koI fjixds. ei ovv tbouv koI
vu) KadaTTep tovs TToXkovs ev ix(rrip.l3pi(i p.r] bLaXeyofxevovs
dkkd vva^Ta^ovTas Kal Kr^kovfxevovs v^' avTwv bi dpyiav
Trfs biavoCas, StKaio)? aj;' KaTayek^ev, f^yovfxfvoL dvbpdiTob^
5 CLTTa a-(f)La-LV kkOovTa eis to KaTay(ayLOV ooa-TTfp TTpojSaTLa

}Xa-r]fx^pLd(pvTa Trept rr/y Kpr]vr]v evbfLV idv be opSicrL

bLokiyofxivovs KaX TrapaTTkiovTas a-(pas wcrTre/a ^Lpf]vas

b aKrjkr^Tovs, o yipas TTapd d(ov \ova-LV dvdpdiitTOLs bibovaL,

Td\ dv boLiv dyaadivTes.

4>AI. 'Exovo-t 8e 8t/ ri tovto; dvqKoos ydp, ws eotKe,
Tvyxavoo a>v,

5 2i2. Ov fxev bf] TTpTTL ye (^LkofXfyvaov avbpa t&v toiovt(ji)V

dvqKoov (IvaL. kiycTaL 8' c5s Tror' ^aav ovtol dvdpcoTTOL tS)V

irpXv Movo-as yeyovivaL, yV0fx4v(t}v 8e Mova&v Kal (f^avcLarfs

(hbfjs ovT(as dpa tlvs Toiv t6t ^TTkdyr]aav v<f)' f]bovfjs,

C c3o-re a8ovres fjixdkr^aav trtro)!' re Kat TrorcSy, Kat kadov

reXeur^o-ayres avTovs' e^ o)v to TTTLy(t)v yivos fXT eKeti^o

(f)VTaL, yipas tovto napd Mova^v kajBov, fxrfbkv Tpo(f)fjs

bL(r6ai. yv6]XVov, dXA' dcrLTdv re Kai diroTov v6vs qbLV,

d 10 &s irojTjT^s et mox ws lStiirr)s secl. BacJham e i eVe/ca Koiv

B : &y T eueKa Stobaeus
eVe/c' : e 3 /xTjSe B T fiij V Stobaeus :

a I Kcd rjfMas T
Stobaeus om. B koI vi> Stobaeus
: Koiyw B T :

b 5 "ye T Stobaeus om. B :b 6 5'] 8i> malit Heindorf c 4 ytyo-

fievoy post Sf7(rdai B T Stobaeus post evOhs transp. Badham
:
 ^AIAPOS 259C

ecos av Tek(VT7](r7], Koi fXTa TavTa (Adov napa Movo-as 5

aTrayyeAAeiy ris Tiva avT&v ri/ixa t&v cvOahi. Tepxj/Lxopa

fxkv ovv Tovi iv rois xppols TfTLfxrjKOTas avTr]v airayyik-
Aorres Tioiovai iTpo(r(f)LXcrTpovs, r?/ 8e 'Eparoi rovs ev rois d ""

(p(DTLKoi9, Kal rais aAAai? ovro)?, KaTo. to ci8os Ifcao-rrjs

TLixrjs' rfj bf npicr^vTa.Tr] KaXkLOTrr] kol ttj /xer' axfTrjv

OvpavLCL Tov^ V (f)LX.o(ro(f)L(t, Siayoi^rds t Kal TLfx&VTas Tr]V

iKLV(DV jxov(TLKr]v ayyiKkovcTLV, oll 8t) fidAio-ra t&v Mouo-<Si; 5
Trepi re ovpavov kol koyovs oxxraL Oitovs re KaX avdpo^TTLVovs
tao-ty KoAAtVrTji; (f)()vr]V. iroXXoiv br] ovv (VKa \kt4ov tl
KOL ov Kadvbr]T(ov V Tf] f.i(rr]fx^pLq.

4>AI. Ae/creoy yap ovv.

2X2. OvKovv, oTTcp vvv TtpovdiiXida (rKi\f/a(T6aL, tov koyov e
oTtr] KokS)^ )(L kiyiLV rc Kat ypa(f)(LV Kal oTrq fxr), (rKeTTTcov.

<I>AI. A^Aoy.
212. 'Ap' ovv ovx inrdpx^eLV bd rots ev ye Kat KaAws
pr]6rf(rofXVOLi rifv tov kiyovTos bidivoLav dbvlav t6 dkr]6(s 5
wy hv pLV TtipL fxikkrj;
4>AI. Ovrcoo-t 776/31 TOVTOV dKr]Koa, 2 ^tAe 2Kpares, ovk
etrat dvdyKr]i;rw fxikkovTL prJTopL e<re(r0at rd rw orrt StKata 260
fxav6dv(Lv dkka Ta bo^avT dv TrAr/^ei otTrep dtKdo-ovo-tr,
ov8e rd 6vT(i)i dya6d rj KaAd dAA' 6(ra Sd^et* eK ydp tovt(ov
eiyai rd Tret^eii; dAA' ovk eK r?}? dkr]6e(as.
2i2. " Ovrot d7rd/3A?jroy cttos " eirat 8eT, o) ^albpe, 5
o dy erTTwo-t (ro(f>OL, dkkd (TKOiTfLV fxr] tl Ae'ya)0-f Kai 8^
Ktti rd vvv Aex^ei' ovk dcfxTeov.
4>AI. '0/3^ws Aeyeis.
2i2. *"X28e 8?/ cnTOTTaifxev avTo.

4>AT. 17(5 s; 10

C 6 Tfp\fiix6pa B T Stobaeus : Tfp^ix^pri vulg, d3 juer' oiiT^)'

B Stobaeus /terA Tauri/i' T
: d7 tao-iv B Xa(Tiv T (corr. t
W
:

TtiH.irov(n suprascr. b) 5)) oZv %vfKa : 8ij ovvfKiv B 8J) oJf

:

fvfKev T e4 7B:TeT a5ST:6B a6 Ae^oxr

BT : \fyovai Schaefer

V
a6ob nAATilNOS
b 212. Ei (re 7rt^ot//t eya> iTokeixCovs aixvvei.v KTri(rdfj.evov

iTinov, d[X(()0) 6e tTnrov dyvooLfj.V, rocrovbc \xivTOL Tvy\dvonxi.

et8a)S 7re/)t crou, ort 'i>albpos iintov TjyHTaL to t&v r^fxipdiv

C^oiV iiiyicTTa exoy ZiTO'

5 4>AI. reAotoV y dv, S) ^(aKpaTes, etrj.

212. OiJTTO) ye* dAA' oTe bi] cniovbi] cre Treidoifjn, (rvvTidels

\6yov eiiaivov Kara tov ovov, iTnTov eTTovop.d^o)v koI keyoiv ws

TiavTos d^iov To 6pep.p.a oXkoi re KeKTrj^rOai koX em or/aartas,
diTOTTokep.elv re \pricn\j.ov koI TTpos y kveyKeiv bvvaTov
C (TKevrj Kal aAAa TToAAa a)0e'At//oi'.

<I>A1. nayye'AotoV y' ay 7/8>/ etrj.

212. 'A/)' owy ov KpeiTTOv yeAotoy Kai (f)CKov rj bcLvov re

Kat k\dpov [eti^at ^ ^tAoy];

5 *A1. 4>atVerat.
212. "Oray ovv 6 prjTopLKos dyvo&v dyadbv Kal KaKov,
X.a^d)v ttoKlv 0)(ravT(ii)s expv^rav TTeCOy, /a^ Trept ovov (TKias
b)S ITTTTOV TOV iTTaLVOV 7T0L0Vp.eV0S, oAAa TTepl KaKOV b)S

dyaOov, bo^as be 7Tki]dovs /xe/xeAerT/KO)? ireCa-rj KaKa TTpdrreLV

lo dvT dyadQ)v, ttolov tlv d{v) otet pLeTo. raSra rr/v prjTopLKrjv

d KapTTov &v ecTTTeLpe OepC^eLv;

<I>AI. Ov irdvv ye eirtetKT/.j

212. 'A/j' ow, 0) dyaOe, dypoLKOTepov tov biovTos AeAot-

boprjKaixev rrjv t&v koyodv Te^vr^v; r} 8' l^toos dv eiTTOf " Tt
5 TTor', S) 6avp.d(TL0L, krjpelTe; eyo) ydp ovbev dyvoovvTa
TdkrjOes dvayKdC(^ [xavddveLV keyeLV, dAA', ci rt e/X7/

(Tvix^ovkri, KTrja-djxevov eKelvo ovt^os efxe kap.^dveLV' Tobe

8' ovv p.eya keyo), ws dvev ep.ov rw Ta ovTa et8ort ov8eV tl

{xdkkov ecTTaL TTeCdeLv Teyvr).

bs elfjj TW : om. B b6 o^iroi ye T : oSiroTe B Sr; T : om. B

b9 irp6s y (vtyKfTv Thompson : KpofffVfyKiiv BT 03 yi\o7ov
Koi <pi\ov legit Hermias : yf\o7ov BT C 4 dvai fi <pi\ov BT :

non legit Hermias c 10 ti/' tiv Hirschig :rtva B T d i Sv

T W : &;/ B d 2 -ye B : om. T d 5 ou5eVa T
T
: oi-S^' B
d6 y Tt B : r Tts T fii}) tfjfjifiov\i\ B : eV^ |y^/3ovA^ : eVf? |um-
fiovK^ XPVTai Stephanus d 7 KTV(rdfj.ivov Vahlen : KTV(rdu.ivos BT
\afifidvuv BT : \an0dvet al.
 *ATAP02 26oe
4>AI. QvKOvv biKaLa ipei, K^yovcra Tavra; e
2X2. ^r]fj,C, iav 01 y eTnoVres avrfj XoyoL yiaprvpGxnv
tXvai TexyV' ooarirep yap ctKOveiy boK(a tlvoov TTpoa-LOVTOiv Kal

hiaixapTvpop.iv(i)V X.6yu>v, otl \(/(vbTai Kal ovk ^ort Te)(yr]

dAX' aTe)(yoi Tpi^iy tov 8e Xdynv, (p-qalv 6 AaKcav, err/uos 5
Ti\vr] avV tov dArj^eiay rj(f)6ai, ovt' cmv ovt fxrj Trore

vcTTepov yivr\Tai.
(|>AI. TovTciiv Sei TUiv koyoiv, S) Sco/cpare?* dAAa bevpo 261
avTovi TTapayoiv k^iTa^e tC Kal tt&s Xiyovcriv.
2X2. ndpire h], dpip.p.aTa yevvala, KaAAiTratSd re 4>ar-

bpov iT(CdT 0)9 iav fxi] iKavois (f)i.\ocro(f)ricry], ovbe LKavos

TTore kiyfLV ((rraL TTpl ovbcvos. a-TTOKpLvicrOoii br] 6 ^aibpos. 5
<I>AI. 'Epcordrej
SX2. 'Ap' ovv ov t6 fxv oXov rj pr]TopLK7] av eti; t^X^V
\frv\ay(i)yCa ris 8td Adyooy, ov fxovov iv StKacrrjptois Kai do-oi

dAAot briix6(rL0L (rvXXoyoL, dAAd Kai iv tStots, fj avTi] (T]XLKp5>v

re Kat fxeydkcov Trept, Kai ovbcv iimfxoTepov t6 ye dp66v Trepi b

o-7rov8ata 7; Trept (f>avka yLyvofxevov ; r] TrcSy crv TavT aKr]Koas;
<I>AI. Ov fxa t6v At" ov TravTaTTacrLv ovtods, dAAd /xdAtora
jLtey 7ra>y Trepi rds bC^as Aeyerat re Kai ypdcfxTaL Txvr],
Ae'yerai 8e Kai Trepi br^fxrfyopCas' eTri tt\Ov 8e ovk dK?;Koa. 5

SX2. 'AAA' ^ rds Neoropo? Kai '08i;o-o-e'cos re')(yay fx6vov

Trepi Adycoy dKrjKoas, ds ey 'lAtw (r)(oAd^oyres crvvypa\ffdTr]v,
tQv 8e riaAafiT/Sovs di^T/Koos yiyovas;
<I>AI. Kai mi /xd At" eycoye rwy Ne'oTopos, ei /u,^ c
ropytW NfcrTopd TLva Karao-Kevd^ets, r/ rti^a &paa-vfxax6v
re Kai edScopoy 'OSucro-ea.
2X2. "lo-cos. dAAd ydp Tovrovi i&fxiv (tv 6' eiTre, fv

e 5 rov 5i e . . .
7 ^ei/Tjrai secl. Schleiermacher e5 (/^ijffli/ SAaKuv
secl. Voegelin trvfxos TexvrjTW: tTotfios B a i Se? T : 5^ B
\6ya)V (^a,Kpoa(rda.i) H. Richards a^ KfiOfre T: ireitfeTO B j
tck' B tfy &/ T b4 t'x>'? T rixvri B b 6 al B : Te
W
: :

<f aJ T b7 irepl secl. Thompson ffxoKa.Covrfs B T <rxo- :

XaCovrf corr. Coisl. c i tifffropos (/col '05u(r<rws) Herwerden

c 2 KOTO(r(Cva^is T : KOTO(r>c6uctf?y B c 3 t T : 5 B
26ic nAATiiNOS
5 biKaa-TTjptoLs ol avTLbiKOi, Tibp&a-Lv; ovk avTiXiyovcriv ixivToi;

1} 71 ^qaoy.fv;

<I>AI. ToiSr' avTo.

2X2. rTept Tov bLKaiov re koX abUov;

<^AI. Nat.
lo 212. OvKOW 6 Tx,vri tovto bpu>v TrotTjcrei (f)avrjvai ro
d avro rots avrots rore fxcv btKaiov, oTav 8e jBovkrjTat, abtKov;
4>AI. Tiju?!';
2X2. Kat ei; br]}xr)yopia bi] ttJ TroAei boK^Xv to. avTa tot
8'
Hv ayaOd, TOTe av TavavTta;
5 4>AI. OvTOis.
2X2. Toy ovv EXeartKoy naAa/x7/8rjr Xeyoi^ra ov/c icr/xey

Ti^vr), (oore <f)atv(rdat rots aKOVouo-t ra avra o/xoia Kai

avoixota, Kal ^v Kal TroKXd, [x4vovTd re av Kat (f)p6p.va;
<i>Al. MaXa ye.
lo 2X2. OvK dpa y.6vov Tiepl 8tKao-r^pia re' eo-riy 57 arrtAoyiK^
e Kai Trept br][xr]yopCav, dAA', ws ^olkc, irepl TrdvTa to. Key6]xeva

jxta Tis riyvr], etTrep iortv, aikr] av eirj,

fj
ris oto? t eo-rat

TTctv TravTl ofxotovv T&v bvvaTiHv Kal oXs bvvaT6v, Kat dWov
OfXOlOVVTOS Kal aTrOKpVTTTOfXfVOV (Is <f)(is &ytv.
5 <I>AI. H&s br] To TOtovTov kiyas;
2X2. Trj8e boK^ Cv^ovcrtv (^aviicrdat. aTtdTr] TroTepov kv

Ttokv bi,a(f)pov(Tt yiyvcTat fxaXXov rj dXiyov;

262 <I>AI. 'Ev rots oAtyoi^.

2X2. 'AAAd ye 8j) KaTo. (T]xtKpov fxeTaftaivoiv fxakkov

kT^a-ets k9o)v eiri t6 kvavTiov r] Kara jn^ya.

<I>AI. UG)s 8' 0;

5 2X2. Aet dpa tov ]xikkovTa diraT-qa-etv jxev dkkov, avrbv
8e [xr] aTTarqa-ea-dat, ttjv b]xoi6Tr]Ta tG)V ovTiav Kai dvofxot6Tr]Ta

aKpijS&s 8tei8emi.

c 10 rex^V '^ '

rfxvti B (et mox) PovMirai &SiKoy B
d. i :

&S1K0V $oi\riTai pr. T d7 <paivf(r0ai BTSoKf7v ipaivearBai vulg.

:

d8 fifvovra T : ju*i/ 6vra B e 2 ^ tis corr. Coisl. ij tis : ^ tjs B

: T
6 3 Kav vavr\ T : ird/jtirav ri B '
a,2 ye S^ B Sij : : T
ixi]v Galenus
 *AIAP02 2623

4>AI. ^AvdyKri fih> ovv.

2X2. 'H ovv olos T ((TTat, aKriddav ayvo&v ^KaaTov, Tr]v

Tov ayvoovfjiivov oixoLOTrjTa a-fXLKpdv re Kal [Xydkr}v iv rois lo

aAAois diayLyv(aa-KLv;
<I>AI. 'AbvvaTov. b
SX2. OvKOvv TOLs irapa tcl ovTa bo^dCova-L Ka\ aTraTioiJLfVOLS

brjXov wy to irdOos tovto 8t' 6fxoioTr]T(t)V tlv&v daeppiirf.

IjAI. riyveTaL yovv ovTOis.
2X2. "EoTty ovv ott<i)s rexi^ifos eo-rai ixTa(BLl3d^Lv KaTo. 5
(rpLLKpov 8ta roii^ 6fj.0L0TriT0iv diTo roC ovtos kKdcrTOTe 771

TovvavTLOV ditdyoiv, rj avTos tovto bLa(f)vyLV, 6 /x^ iyv(i>pLK(os

b ioTLv ^KaoTov T&v SvT(ov;

<i>AI. Ov fxrj iTOT.

2X2. A6y(>)v dpa T^xvriv, Si (TOLpe, 6 Tifv dXrjOeLav /xrj c

(lh<as, bo^as 6e T(dripVK(as, yekoiav TLvd, ws loiKe, Kat
aTexyov i:api^TaL.
<I>A1. KLvbvViViL^
2X2. BovAet ovv iv rw Auo-iou Xoyo) hv (f>ipLS, kol iv 5
ols rjfxcLS L7rofx(v Ibflv tl &v (\>ap.iv aTiyy^av re xat ivTiyjxjnv

eirat;
4>AI. YldvT(av yk ttov fxdkLcrTa, its vvv ye \j/Lk&s Trcoy

XiyofXfv, ovK )(0VTs LKava TrapabeLyfxaTa.

2X2. Kai fxrfv KaTO. TV)(riv yi TLva, b>s ioLKiv, ipp/rfOrfrtfv 10

ro) Aoyw i)(pvTi tl TtapdbiLyfxa, wy &y 6 ei8a)s ro dATj^ey d

TTpoa-TTaL^oiiV iv \6yoLS iTapdyoL tovs aKOVovTas. Kal eyuiyc,
S) <I>ar8pe, atrta)/u.at tovs ivTOirCovs Oeovs' ta-cos 8e Kat 01 t&v
Mova-(av TTpo(f)rJTaL ol viTep Kec^aA^j (abol eTTtTreTryevKores &v
rffXLv iXiv TovTo To yipas' ov ydp ttov eyo^yi Tiyvrfs tlvos 5
Tov kiyeLV fxiToxps.^/
<I>AI. *'Ecrra) o)? Ae'yets' fLOVOv b^qk^acrov h </)t/s.

2X2. "IOl brf fxoL dvdyvo)6L Tifv tov Avo-lov kdyov dpxrjv.

b5 fierafitPd^fiv T Galenus : fieTafiipd^ft B C 6 aTXVi/ . . .

imixvuv Heindorf : irtx*'^*' ffrtxvov BT d i ri A<Jya> T

T^ AiJyy B
2626 nAATONOS
e 4>AI. "rTfpt /xey rSiv ijJL&v TrpayixdTcav eTriorao-at, Kai ws
vojxCCoi (TViJ.(Pepi.v ijiuv tovtcov yVOiJ.V(ov, dKrjKoas, d^iw
be ixi] 6ta TOVTO dTvyjicTai &v hiop.ai, otl ovk epacrr^? oiv (TOv
"
TVy\dv(0, WS K(CV0LS fJiV t6t JXTa[JL4Xl

5 2Ii. riaOcrai. tC brj ovv ovtos dfjxipTdvei Kol aTe^vov

TTotet \KTov 7/ ydp;
263 IjAI. Nat.
212. 'Ap' ovy ov TravTl brjXov t6 ye ToiwSe, ws rrepi

//ey erta rcSy ToiovTOiv 6]xovor]TiKQ>s ixoy.iv, Trepi 8' ei^ta

OTao-tcoTt/co)?;

5 (i>M. AoK(a [XV o \ym \xav6dviv,Ti. 8' etTre (Ta(f>e(rTpov.

212. "OTar Tts 6vo\xa eiTrry o-t8?/pou ?/ dpyvpov, dp' ov to
avTo TrdvTcs btcvorjOrjixcv;

(t>Al. Kat [xdka.

212. Tt 8' oTai' biKaCov rj dyadov; ovk aAAoj aAAt/

lo </)epeTat, /cat dpi(f)L(rj3riTovfXV dXXrjkois Te Kat ?//ity avToi?;
<I>AI. ricij/v />iey oSi'.

b 2i2. 'Ey /Aei dpa toIs (rvn^fxovovfxcv, (v 8e Tots ov,

<I>AI. OiJtco.

212. rioTepco^t ovv vaT:aTr\T6TepoC e(rp.v, Kal r} priTopiKrf

iv TTOTepoLS ij.lCov bvvaTaL;

5 4>AI. ArjXov OTL ev ots irkav^aiXfOa.
2X2. OvKow Tov fxikkovTa Tiyvr\v pr\TopLKr\v /xeTtemt
TTp&TOv \xev 8et TavTa obS) bLriprj^rOaL, kol Lkr\(p4vaL tlvo.

\apaKTr\pa kKaTfpov tov ^tbovs, (V <S Te dvdyKr\ to TrkrjOos

TTkavd(r0aL Kal kv w fxr].
C <J>AI. Kakov yovv dv, o) 2coK/)aTe9, etSos ei?/ KaTavVor\K(i)S

6 TovTo ka^(av.
2i2. "ETretTa ye oT\xaL Trpos eKcxo-Tcp yLyv6\xvov ixr\

kavOdviLV dkk' oieojs aWOdve^rOaL Trepl ov dv \x(kkr\ kpiiv

5 TToripov ov Tvy\dvH tov yivovs.

e 2 Tffiiv T vfuv B : a3 roiovrcDv B T ovruv corr. Coisl. fort.

: :

ovondrwv H. Richards 6fxovorirtKoisT Galenus ov jxSvov woiririKus B

:

b7 5e7 B : S)> T b8 irKrjdos T : 75os B c i (ISos addubitat

H. Richards
 tAIAPOS 263 C

<I>AI. Ti iJ.i]v;

212. Ti ovv; tov epwra Trorepov (^wfxiv eirai Twy

aix(pi(rl3riTri(TiiJL(ov rj twv ^ii];

(\>\l. Twy afX(f)L(rl3rjTr]crtfj.(av b^qiTOV' r/ oUt av roi fyX'^-

pij(raL diTLV h vvvbi] Ltts 776/06 avToC, ws iSkdjSr] Tc eo-Tt 10

ro) fpco/ueVfa) xai epuivTL, koI av6Ls ojs ]j.iyL(TTov (pv) tGw
ayaOSiv TvyyavcL;
21X2. ^Apio-ra Ae'yeis' dAA.' eiire kcCl Tobc eyw ydp tol d
Sca ro v6ov(TLa(rTLKbv ov Trdvv /ue'/xyTj/xat ei u)pi(rdiJi.r]v epcora

dpx6pi.(vos Tov koyov.

<I>AI. Nt; Ata dfxy]\dvoi9 ye ws (r(})6bpaj

2i2. <I>e{!, 00-6) Ae'yeis TCx^viKcaTepa^ NvjU(/)a? ray 'AxeAwoD 5

Kai riaj^a roy ^Epixov Av(rLov tov Ke^dAou Trpos Ao^yous etrac.

?/ ov8ey Ae'yco, dAAd Kal 6 Auo-tay dp^^ojxevos tov p(aTLKov

r]vdyKa(rv rjfjMS vTToAa/Seiy tov "E/Jcora er n rwi' ovt(ov o

airrbs e/3ovAT/^?7, Kat Trpos rovro 7)81/ (rvvTa^dp.Vo^ irdvTa tov

v(rTpov koyov btiTrepdvaTo; (3ov\l TidkLV dvayvS>p.V ttjv

dpxi]V avTOv;
<I>AI. Ei (Tot ye 6o/<et' o /xe^rrot fr/reis' ovk eo-r' avTodt,
2X2. Ae'ye, ?m dcoiy(rci) ai^rou Klvov. 5

*I>AI. " riepi /xei' rwv e/xciy Tipayp.dT(t)v TTi(rTa(raL, Kal iws

voixC^oi (rvp.(f)4pLV r]p.lv TOVT^av yVofXVO)v, dKijKoas. d^LU)

8e 1X1] 6td rouro dTV\rj(raL S)V biofxaL, otl ovk e/sao^rl/s o)v 264
(Tou 7T;yxdi^a). coy Klvols fxkv t6t /xera/>ie'Aet wy di' ev
TrotT/o-coo"^, e7ret8dy tt/s (TTLdvjXLas TravcroovTaL'"
2X2. 'H TToAAou bdv eotxe ^rotety o8e ye 6 ^r]TovixV, os
ovbi aTr' dpxrjs dAA' dTrd reAevr^s e^ viTTLas dvaTraAty ^tarety 5
e7rixtpct rdi Ao^yor, Kai apxiTai d<^' wy TTCTTavfxevos hv rjbr]

C 9 ^^xwp^ffot codex Marcianus Galeni : avyxfprii^cti BT o n hv

a(]di(ji auctore Heindorfio (dyaOaJj/ Stv infra Hirschig) j T
d4 :

om. B d6 B T dcl. t b t
riara] trivTa : \6yovs T \6yov B
: :

\6yov al. e 6 iTfiara.aai B iniffrafjiai T : a 2 Tore T t^ :

TOTt B a 4 (riTovfiiv ^s T (Tjrovfji.ivos B

: a 5 Siavuv B T :

Siaci/eii/ rec. b
PLATO, VOL. 11, 18
264 a nAATXlNOS
ipaa-Tijs Aeyot lipos ra TraLbiKa. r/ ovb^v elTTOv, ^l^albpe,

^iAtj Ke<f)aXrj;

b 4>AI. "Ea-Tiv ye roi Si/, S) SwK/oares, reAevr?/, Trept o5 tov

koyov TTOieirai.

2X2. Tt 8e raAAa; ov x'^^'?^ 6oKei (Bej^Xija-Oai Ta tov

Xoyov; r\ (paiv^Tai to bevrepov dprjixivov K tlvos avdyKrjs

5 btVTepov belv TeOijvai, ij rt aAAo t&v prjOsvTCtiv; e/iAot p.(v

yap ibo^ev, ws /x7/8ey etSoVt, ovk ayevvfas to CTn.bv (IprjaOaL

rw ypd(j)0VTt,' (tv 8' exeis rtya avdyKrjv \oyoypa^iKi)v ?/

TavTa Kivos ovTcos (f)^rjs Trap' aAAr/Aa (9r]Kv;

I>AI. XpTjo-ros ei, ort /ue ^yr/ tKai^w etz^at to. iKiivov

C ovTds aKpijBcos 8tt8etiy

SX2. 'AAAa Tobe ye ot/uat o-e (f^dvai av, belv TidvTa koyov
MCTTTep C^ov a-vvea-Tavat. a-(api.d rt tyovTa avTov avrov, foo^re

p.r}Te dKi(f)akov etyat /x?/re aTTOvr, dAAa /^ieVa re ex^ety Kat

6 a/cpa, TTp^TTOVTa dAA?/Aots Kat rai oAo) yeypa/x/AeVa.

<I>AI. ria)? yap ov;

Sli. 2Ke'\//^at ToCvvv tov tov kTaipov a-ov Koyov eire

ovro)? etre aAAcos cxet, Kat evp?/o-et9 rou kTTi.ypdixp.aTos ovb\v

bia^pepovTa, b Miba T<a 't^pvyi (f^aaiv Tives TTLyeypd(f)0ai,.

d 4>AI. ITotoy roSro, Kat rt 7Tttov66s;

2X2. ^Eo-rt jMv tovto ro8e

XaAK^ TTapdevos elfxi, Miba 8' eTri a-rip.aTi Ket/xat.

o0p' ay vScop re z^ct?/ Kal bivbpca p.aKpa TeOrjkr],

5 avrov r?/8e pLevova-a TTokvKkavTov eirl tvij.(3ov,

dyyeAe'ft) TrapLova-L Mt8as ort r?/8e TidaiTTaL.

e ort 8' ov8ep bLa(f)epeL avTov iTp^Tov rf vcrTaTov tl KeyeardaL,

ivVOCLS TTOV, b)S (yutfxaL.
4>AI. SKw-Trrets tov Xoyov rni&v, w ^(aKpaTiS.
212. Tourov ixkv Toiwv, Xva p.r] (tv a)(6rf, edo-co/iey ^
a7 ipaxTr\)s recc. : ipaffeih BT b5 Sei/ secl. Madvig : 5r;

Schanz b9 ;u T : ;u^ B C3 trw/iia rt t : ffdl!p.afi BT

C 4 yu^re iiKi^paXov T :
fj,^
to aKi<(>a\ov B d3 /utSa T : ^tSa B
e 3 r^ij.an' B : om. T
 tI>AIAPOS 2646

KaiTOL (rvxi>d ye (X^lv ixol boKeX Trapahdyixara Ttpos u ri? 5

^kiiKnv ovLvaLT av, fj.Lp.ela-OaL avra iTTLx^Lp&v jxr] irdvv tl

t9 8e Tovs (Tepovs Xoyovs Lit)p.V. -qv ydp tl kv avrols, u)S

SoKo), TTpoa-iJKov Ibelv Tols j3ov\o[jih'OLS Trept XoyoiV a-KOTrelv.

4>AI. To TTotoy 87) Aeyeij; 265

2i2. ^EvavTLCt) TTOV Tja-Tr]v 6 fjikv yap ws ru) ip&VTi, 6 f
u)S rw [xi] 8et xapC^ea-OaL, ik(yTr]v,

4>AI. Kat /xdA' di>bpLK(as.

^1. "ihp.rjv ae TakrjOcs ipeXv, otl fxavLK(as' o fxevTOL 5

(CvTovv ia-TLV avTo tovto. jxavCav ydp TLva i(f)i]a-ap.(v etmt

Tov (po)Ta. 7] ydp;
^kl. Nai.
212. Martas bi ye etS?; bvo, Tr]v p.V virb voa7]fxdT(i)V

uv6pot)TTLV(>)v, Tr]v 8e vtto Oiias i^aXkayrjs tS)V do^doTo^v 10

vojXLixo^v yLyvofxivrjv.

4>AI. ndvv ye. b

Si2. T?/9 ^ctas TTTdpo)v 6iG>v TiTTapa fxipr] bLfkojxcvoL,

lxavTLKr]v fxv iTTLTTVOLav ^ATTokko^vos divTis, Alovvctov b^

Tekfo-TLKrjv, Mova-u)V 8' av TTOLr^TLKrjv, TTdpTr]v be 'A(^po8tr?js
Kat "Epo^Tos, ipo)TLKr]v fxaviav i^pifo-afxiv re dpCaTi^v etz^at^ 5
Kai ovK ot8' Stt?/ to ipo)TLKov Trd^os diTeLKd^ovTes, iceos

^V dkr]6ovs TLVos i(\)aTTT6fxevoL, Td\a 8' dv kol dXkocr^

TTapa(f)p6p.(V0L, KpdaavTS ov iravTdTTaaLV diTL^avov kdyov,
fXvdLKOV TLVa VfXVOV TtpoaiTTaLaafXiV fX(TpLO)S T Kul V(f)rifXO)S c
Tov ifxov re /cai aov beaiTOTr^v "EpoiTU, o) ^albpe, Kak&v .

TTaiboiv (f)opov. yp<ifti&>

4>AI. Kai fxdka fxoLye ovk dr]b&s aKovcraL.

SI2. To'8e TOLWV avTo^ev kd^o^fxcv, o>s aTTo tov yf/iycLV 5

TTpos t6 iTTULveLV e(r)(ey 6 Ao'yo9 /uera/S^mt.

4>AI. riws 8^ ovv avTo Ae'yei?;

e6 fixiieuv {tiev) . . . /jnfiuaeai (5') Herwerden e 7 iripovs

T : iraipovi B b2 rfTToipwv Bfwv secl. Schanz b5 t
BT: om. Stobaeus b8 \6yov corr. Par. 1808: \6yov BT
C4 ffxoiye B : ^fiol fiiv T
265 c nAATilNOS
Sfl. 'E/xol jjiev (})aCvTai. tu ixh> uAAa tw oi>tl iraiSia
TreTrato-^ai' tovtmv 8e tlvcov e/c r?/)(^s pr]64vT(i)v bvolv elbolv,

d ei avToZv ttjv hvvafj.tv Ti\vri kafidv bvvaLTo tls, ovk a\apL.

<I>AI. Tiycor 8r/M
212. Eis /ijttaz' re tSeay crvvop&VTa ayeLV tcl 7roAXax>;
hLcnrapjxiva, tva eKaa-Tov 6pt^o//i'os 8i/Aoy iroir; Trepi ov av
5 aet 8t8ao-Keti' i64X.i]. axnrep tcl vvvbi] irepl "EpoiTos o eorti'
opLcrdev etr' eS etre KaKSi^ kkiydr], tq yovv <ra(})(s Kal to
avTO avT(a 6]ioXoyoviievov 8ta Tama ecryj^v il-netv 6 Xoyos.
<I>AI. To 8' Tcpov bi] etSos rt Ae'yets, w ^(tiKpaTes;
e 2X2. To TrdX.LV Kar etbr] bvvaa-daL bLaT]Ji,VLV kut ap6pa

fj
TTecfiVKev, Kal /x?/ e7rixet/)eti' KaTayvvvaL ]xepos p.r^blv, KaKov
IxayeCpov TpoTtco ^pcti^xevov dA.A' (ticnrip apTL ro) Xoyco tu
]XV a^pov TTJs bLavoCas (v tl kolvT] etSos eAa/3e'r7jr, o^cnrep
266 be a-cofxaTos e^ kvbs 8t7rAa Kat ofx^avvfxa Tr(f)VK, orKatd, tcl 8e
Se^ta KXr]6VTa, ovtu) Kal to Tys TrapavoCas ws {kv) kv rjjxlv

Trecj^VKbs cTbos i]yr]cra]XVO) tu) koyo), 6 jxcv to iir' .apLo-Tepa

TIXv6lXV0S IXepOS, TToXlV TOVTO TjXV(t)V OVK TTavi]KV TTplv (V

5 avrots (})vp(i)v 6vo]xa(6]Xvov crKaLOV TLva epcoTa \oLb6pr](TV

/xoA' V 8tKr/, 6 8' ets to. ev Se^ifi ttjs [xavCas ayaycbv rjixas,

6]X(OVV]XOV ]XV KCv(p, delov 8' av TLVa pO)Ta (j)VpCDV KOL

b TTpoTLvaixVos TTfjVa-V 0)9 ]XyCcrTO)V aLTLov 7]]XLV ayadu>v.
4>AI. 'AAr/^e'o-rara Ae'yets.

212. Tor;rcoy 8?/ eycoye avT6s re ipacrTrjs, S) ^albpe, rwr

bLaLpa-0)v Kal a-vvayo)yS)v, Iva ol6s re 2 KlyeLV re Kai
5 (\>povLV av T TLV (xkKov r]yr]a-(i)]xaL bvvoTbv ets V koX 1x1

C8 iraiSiS. T : iraiSio B e9 ireTraiffQai T : irfir4<rdai B rivSiv

'
... pr/^fWwv] Ti '<pi' . . . ^fjOfi' rh roiv Badham et5o?j/] ilSSiv
Galenus di axnolv BT : oiit^' vulg. d5 to BT : rh Schanz
d8 5^ T : yu?; B e r ot* BT : Ka\ ra Madvig SiarffjLvtiv T
. Stobaeus Galenus re/nveiv B a 1 (rdiixaros B T (rdfiart Stobaeus
: :

ir4<pvKe (TKaid T Stobaeus irt^pvKis' Kai & B to 5f .Stobaeus

:

Ta5 ^ BT a2 vapavoias BT: irapoivias Stobaeus tv fv

Heindorf fj/ B T tv al. om. Stobacus
: : Tjfxiv T Stobaeus
:
vfiiv B :

a 3 tJ) B T om. .Stobaeus

: a 4 (iravTiKfv B T avrJKtv Stobaeus :

fV auro7s B T eouTors Stobaeus

: a 7 /fol secl. Badham
 <i>AIAPOS 266b
TToAAa TT(f)VK66' Opav, TOVTOV dtCOKCO ** KaTOTTLCrOe [XeT

IXVLOV u)(rT deoLO." Kal \jAvtol kox tov^ bvvafjiivovs avTo

bpav d fi(v 6p6S)s 17 fir) Trpoo-ayopivco, 6(69 ot8e, KaX& 8e
ovv p-^XP'' Tovb^ bLa\KTLKovs. TCL 8e vvv Ttapa (Tov re koX c
\v(rLov fxa66vTas etTre tl xpr] Kakilv 7; tovto iKLv6 ((ttlv 7}

\6y(tiv T^xvrj, fi
(dpacrvixaxps re Kal ol aWoL xp(ap.iVOL o-o^ot
p-ev avTol \^yLV y^y^vacTLV, aKkovs re Troiouo-ir, 01 av
b<Dpo(f)op(LV avTols ws /Sao-tAeCo-ti; e^e'A(ooti'; 5
4>AI. Bao-tAiKot /u.ey avbpes, ov p.\v br] iirKTTrifxov^s ye &v
epcoras. aWaTovTO fXV to etSos opdats ifxoLye boK^ls KaXiiv,
bLoXcKTLKOV KakoiV' TO 8e prfTOpLKOV b0KL fXOL bLa(f)VyLV i6'

rjfxds.

2X2. YlSts ^779; Kak6v t:ov tl hv eiJj, o rovrcoi; aTro- d

\L(f)6V 6fX(i)s Tex^ X.ap.j3dvTaL; 7t<xvt())s 6' ovk dTLfxaa-T^ov
avTO (Toi re Kai e/xoi, KtKTiov 8e rt fxivTOL Ka\ <rTi to
X.LTT6p.eV0V TTJS pTfTOpLKrjS.

<I>AI. Kat fxdka ttov arvxvd, S) SwK/aares, Td y kv toXs f,

^l^Xlols tols Trept k6y(ov re'xi^s yiypap-fxivoLS.

2X2. [Kat] KaAws' ye imepivrfaas. iTpooLfiLov p.\v ot/xat

TTp&Tov &)s 8et Tov k6yov k4ycr6aL iv dpxfj' raura Ae'yets

rj ydp; ra Kopi^a Trjs Tiyyrfs;

4>AI. Nat. e
2X2. AVTpov 8e 8?/ bLrjyrjcrLV TLva fxapTvpias t ctt'

avT^, Tpirov TCKfxrfpLa, TTapTov clKdTa' Koi Tr((rT(aa-iv

otfxaL Kal TTLTTicrT(oa-LV kiycLV t6v ye ^ikTKrrov koyobai-
baXov Bv^dvTLov dvbpa. 5
^AI. Tbv XPI^^^ kiyLS &6b(opov;
2X2. Tt fxrjv; Kal ekeyx^v ye Kal eTre^e^Aeyxoy o)s 267
TTOLrfTiov kv KaTrfyopici re >cai aTroAoyta. tov 8e KaAAtoroy

b 7 irf(pvK6Q''\ iffipvKhs BT Stobaeus : vt^pvKdra vulg. b9 ^ /*^

T : fl /j.ijB C I 5e vvv B : vvv 5 T C2 fjiadSvTas B : /j.a06vr(s T
fjia$6vTa c 6 S^^Spes Bekker Si/Spes B T
H. Richards c 7 rb : T
om. B At
Hirschig d8 V apxf) T iw' apxy
Koi secl. : B
secl, ci. Schanz e 4 \oyoialda\ov T (et legit Cicero) \6yov :

deuSa\ov B Ai^wi/ Aalda\ov Winckelmann

:

IS *
PLATO, VOL. u.
267 a nAATflNOS
TldpLov Evrjvov h \x^crov ovk dyoii^v, os v7ro87;A.cocrii; re
TTpwTos rjvpcv Kal TtapeTtaivovs o\ 8' avrov Koi Trapayj/o-

5 yovs (f>a(rlv ev ixirpio Xiydv p.vqp.r^s xdpiv (ro(f>bs ydp dvrjp.

Teicriav be Topyiav re kd(Top.iV evheiv, (A Trpb tS>v dkrjOoiv

Ta eiKora eiSoy ws TifxrjTia pMXkov, Td re av a-fxiKpd ixeydka
Kal Ta pieydka (rpnKpd (j^aivea-dai iTOi,ov(rLV 8ia p(dpLr)v koyov,

b Kaiya re dpxaim Td t ivavTia Kaiv&s, (TVVTop.iav re koycav

Kal aiTeipa p.riKrj ircpl irdvTOiv dvr]vpov; TavTa hi aKovoiV
TTore ixov Tlp6bi.Kos eyeka^rev, Kal p.6vos avTbs r]vpr]Kivai ^(jii]

S)V 8et Aoycoi; Ti\vy]V' belv 8e ovt^ fxaKp&v ovt j3pax^(av

5 dkXd fxeTpioiv.

<I>AI. "SiO^^aTaTd ye, aj IlpdbiKe.

212. 'limiav 8e ov keyofxev; olfiai ydp dv (rvpi.^r](f)ov

avTU) Kal Tov 'HXeioy ^ivov yivi(rdai.

4>AI. Ti' 8' o^;
lo 2X2. Ta 8e Yliakov ttws (f)pd(T(oixev av fxova-eia kdytav ws
C SiTrXao-ioXoy^ai; Kal yv(a]xokoyiav Kal iiKOvokoyiav
ovoixdTODV re ALKVixviatv h iKeiv(^ iboipria-aTo iTpbs iToir](rLV

veTTcias;
4>AI. IT/acorayo^/oeta 8e', oo SoaKpares, ovk rjv fxivroL

5 TOLavT aTTa;
212. ^OpOo^TTeLd ye' ris, a> jrai, Kal dkka iTokkd Kal

Kakd. tS>v ye ixr]v olKTpoy6o)v ^ttI yrjpas Kal iTCviav

kkKoix4vo>v k6yo>v KiKpaTr]KvaL T^xvr] ixol (f)aivTaL to tov

XakKr]boviov a-Ocvos, opyia-ai re av TTokkovs dixa bcLvbs dvi]p
d yeyovev, Kal iTdkLV oi>pyL(TixivoLS (TTabo^v Kr]kuv, w? i(f>r]'

bLaj3dkkLV re Kal dirokva-aaOaL bLajBokds oOevbr] KpdTia-Tos.

a3 ^s B y T
: a 5 avnp Bekker aviip B T a 6 5e in
:

ras.T b 4 rexvriv B T rfx^V Stephanus

: 5?' corr. Par. 1808 :

Seiva B T b 7-8 iiririav rhu ii\e7ov T Ivirelav

. . rhv 9i\iov B: . .

b 10 (ppdffwfiev B (ppda-o/nev T (^ovy ippdffofxev Schanz

: : as B &s T :

C2 Ast
AiKvnvieiaiv & eKeiv<f eSwp^fiaaro secl. Ast irphs iroirifftv
B T irpoffeiroiijffev Cornarius
: C 3 eveireias BT : eveireiav Schanz
e 9 KaXxv^oviov Herwerden opyiffai re T : hpyiffairo B avrip
Bekker : hvhp BT d2 mv h^ Par. 1808 : gOev le7 B T
 *AIAP02 267d

To 8e 7/ t4X.os T(av Xoyutv Koivi] Tiacnv eotKe (TVvh(.hoy^iivov

flvai, bi TLV(S /xei' iTTavobov, aAAot 8' aAAo TiOevTai ovoixa.

4>AT. To ei' K(j)akai(a (Kaa-Ta Ae'yeis VTTOfj.VTJcrai. eTrt 5

TeAeirrys roiis d/covoyras' Trept T(av ^lprj^iiviav

lil. Tairra Ae'yco, Kat et rt (tv aAAo e^^ets eiTreiy Adycoy

Ti)(Vr]S TTCpi.

<I>AI. '!2iJLiKpd ye Kai ov/c afta Ae'yetr.

2X2. 'Eci)//ey 8?/ t<x ye (Tp.iKpa' TavTa 8e vtt' avyas pLaXkov 268
tSwjuer, rii/a /cai TroV Ix^' '^^ '"^^ t^xvv^ bvvafji.iv.

<I>AI. Kat /xaAa (ppoifxivT}v, a> SwKpares, ey ye 8t/

ttA^^ovs trwo'8ots.
2X2. "Ej^et ydp. dAA', oj 8at/bio'yte, t8e Kat (tv et apa xat 5

(Tol (f)aivTai ^ieorrjKos avT&v to iJTpiov uxnrep kfxoi.

<J>A1. AeiKwe fxovov.

2X2. Etire 8?/ fxof et ris TrpoceA^cby roi kTaip(a crou

'Epu^t/xdxw >? Tw TTaTpl avTov 'AKovp.v^ etTrot ort " 'Eyo)

iiTio-Tap.aL TOiavr drra (r(iip.a(rL 7Tpo(T^pLV, &(rTe depfxaivLV lo

r' ^dy ^ovXcojxaL Kal ylrv\LV, Kal edr jotey 80^7/ /xot, e/xety b
Troteii', edf 8' av, KdTOj 8ta)(copeti/, Kat dAAa Trd/XTroAAa

roiairra' cai eTrttrrd/xeiros avrd d^to) tar/)tKos etrat Kat

dAAoj; Troiety J) dy TTjy TOVTOiv kTTLCTTrfp.rfv iTapabSi" Ti av
oiet dKOvaavTai lttlv; 5
4>AI. Ti 8' dAAo ye 7/ kpecrOaL et TrpocreTTicrTaTaL koX
oixTTLvas Sei xai d7ro're KacrTa TovTOiv ttolcIv, Kal fxiyjn
oTToa-ov;

2X2. Et ovv etTrot drt " Ovbap.cis' dAA' d^tai rw raura

Trap' efxov fxaOovTa avTov oXov r' etyat [Trotetr] d e/acoras; " c
^AI. EtTreiy av olfxaL otl fxaivTaL dvdpoiiros, Kal K ^

d4 rldd/TaiT: riflfWes B ai vir' avyhs naWoy T : vnavya(rfia W

Ka\hv B a 2 ir(jT' B T iror' vulg. a 8 eiVe T b yirep pr. B
: :

a 9 'AKovyue'^)] aKov/x.(V(fi B T a ro adfia^ri B T ffcifiari V :

b I /xti/ T /t^ B (in ras.)

: bs iin<Trdfi(vos b iiriaTafitvovs : BT
laTpiKhs B larphs T
: b 6 5' SA\o 7 T 7 iAAo B C r iroie?;' :

secl. Buttmann i-iraifiv Schleiermacher

: C2 *Vri/ scripsi
tiiroKV Stephanus : eiiroi BT Sivdpaiiros Bekker : &c0paviros BT
268c nAATi:2N0S
(Bl^Klov TToOev aKovaas r) iTipiTvyoiv <j)ap[xaKCois iarpos
oteroi yeyovivai, ovbiv ^Tratcov rijs Txyr]s.

5 2i2. T6 8' ct So^oKXei av TrpocreXOcav KaX.YiVpmihi tis

A,eyot fa)S kiiia-TaTai. iTipl (Tp.i.Kpov 'np6.yp.aTOS prjo-^LS TTap.p.r]KeLs

TTOLelv Kol Trept /leytiAou Traru (rp.LKp6.s, oTav re ^ovXrjTaL

olKTpds, KOL TovvavTiov av </)0j8epas Kat d7retAi;rtKas oo-a r'
d dAAa rotaSra, Kat bLbAcrKOiv avTo. Tpaycabias TToirjoLV oterat
7rapa8t8oVat;
4>AI. Kat ovroi av, a> SwKpares, ot/xai KarayeAwey et

rts oterat Tpay(abiav dAAo rt etrat ^ r^v roi^rcoy oT;o-raati'

5 TTpiTTovcrav dAAT^Aoi? re Kai roi oAo) (rvvLOTap.4vr]v.

212. 'AAA' ovK di' aypoiKcos ye otjuat Aoi8opr/o-etay, dAA'

uxTTTep dy p.ov(rLK6s evTvxoiV avbpl oiop.iv(^ app.ovLK(o etmt,

ort 8rj rwyx^^f 7TL(rTdp.Vos i>s otov re o^VT&Tr^v koX ^apv-

e rdrrjy x^^pbr^v Trotety, ovk dypioos (Xttol av "^Q. p.o\6rjpi,

/xeAayx^oAas," dAA' dre p.ov(TLKos cov TTp^ioTepov otl *"i2

cLpL(rT, avdyKrj pikv Kal Tavr iiTio-TacrOaL tov /ue'AAo:^ra

app.ovLKov ea-ecrOaL, ovbev fxr]v KcoAvet /jtr/8e arp.LKpbv appovias

5 e-Tratety roi' rrjv o-r/y e^tv ixpvTa' rd ydp Trpd app.ovias

dvayKota p.aOrip.aTa iTTiaraaai dAA' ou rd app.ovLKa.

4>AI. 'Op^oVard ye.
269 212. OvKoSi' Kat d 2o0okA^s roV o-^to-ty iTTLbeLKVvp.evov
To. TTpb Tpaycabias dv cjiair] dXA' ov rd TpaycKd, Kal 6 'Akov-
fxevbs To, TTpb iaTpLKrjs dAA' ov rd tarptKa.
<i>AI. riayrdTrao-t p.v ovv.

5 212. Tt 8e rdy ]iiXiyr]pvv "Abpaa-Tov oiopieda 17 Kai

ITeptKAe^a, et aKovcriLav S>v vvvbr] 17/xets 8tr//xei' t&v TTayKaXdov

T(yvr]p.dT()iV ^payjvkoyL^v re Kai etKoi^oAoyitoi' Kat oa-a
dAAa 8teA^o'yres vtt avyds e^ajuev etvat crK^iTTia iTOTepov

b xaK^TTds av avTOVs, &a-TTp kydi re Kat crv, v-n dypoLKias

e 8 o5 W
Ka\ o5 B T : ocro toAAo (sic) tojoCto koI StSatXKaiv
T : toWo (sic) TotoCTO SiSdtrKwv B
Kol 8(ro d.5 irpeirovffav T:
rpewovcav B d.6'yB:TT ei &ypolKOi>s Osann e 5 vph
t: TTpbs BT as oiSfXiQ' (h.v) Hirschig a8 avyh.s T; outoj B
 a>AIAP02 269b

prjixd TL dTrelv aTraCbevTov eis rovi ravTa yeypacpoTai re Kal

bibdcrKOVTas o)? prjTopiKrjv Tlyvr\v, ?/ aTe. rjix&v ovTa^ (T0<j)()i-

Tcpovs K^v v<av kTnTtkrj^ai dirovTas' '"12 ^albp^ t Kal

2()Kpare?, ov XPV XoXiTraivHV dXXa (Tvyyiyv(t)(yKiv, ei rii^es 5

/X7/ eTrioTajnei^ot bidkiyea-Oai dbvvaToi kyivovTo 6pi(Ta(rdaL

tC ttot (ttlv prjTopLKrj, Ik 8e tovtov tov Trddovs tcl Trpo

Tr]9 re'x2'rjs dvayKaLa p.a6rip.aTa ^yovTi^ pr]TopLKi]V <hi]$rj(rav

r]vpr]KvaL, Kal raura 8t) bLbdaK0VT9 dKkovs -qyovvTaC a-(^L(TLV c

reAccos pr]TopLKr]v bebLbd\6aL, tq 8e ^KacrTa TOVTUiV TtL6av5><i
XiyiLV re Kai to 6\ov (rvvL(rTa(r6aL, ovbev tpyov {ov), avTovi
bdv TTap' (avTQv rovs ]xa6r]Tds (T(f)0)v T:opL^(T6aL iv rots
Aoyots". 5
4>AI. 'AAAa fxrlv, 2> ^(aKpaT9, KLvbvvVL ye tolovtov
TL elvaL To Trjs re'xi-'rjs rjv ovtol ol avbpei ws pr]T0pLKr]V
bLbda-KOva-Lv re Kat ypd(f)OvaLv, Kal p.0Ly SoKets dXr]6r] elpr]-

KvaL' dAAd bi] Tr]v tov Tta ovtl pr]TopLKov re Kat Tridavod
T\vr]v TTws Kai TTodev dv TLS bvvaLTO TTopCaaadaL; d
212. To juez' 8wao-^at, S) <i>albp, &aT dyo)VLaTi]V Tk(ov
yvia6aL, etKo's to-cos 8e koi ayayKator
^X^'^ (So-Trep raAAa*
ei juey o-ot VTrapxet (f^vaa pr]TopLK(a elvaL, ear] prjTcop eAAo-
yt/uos, TrpoakajBoov iiTLaTriixriv re Kot ixekcTriv, otov 8' av 5
eAAetTTr/s TovTcav, TavTj] dreATjs Io-tj. 8aov 8e avTOv T^yvr],

ovx r/ Avo-^as re Kat &paavixa\os TropevTaL 8oKet /xot

(})aCva6aL 17 /xe'^o8os.

4>AI. 'AAAd TTT/ 87/;

212. Kti^Surevet, S dpLaT, etKoroos 6 riepiKA^s Trdi^rwy e

reAewraros eis rr/y pr]TopiKi]v yVa6ai.
*AI. TUt/;
212. nSo-at ^o-at ju.eydAai rwy tXV&v TtpoabiovraL

b 2 ^^/t( Ti T ^iiixaTi B : b 7 p-qropiK^ B ^ ^rjropiK^fj T :

C3 owS^/ ^p^oj' 01/ Heindorf: ouS^/ ^p^o/ BT: ws ouS^j/ ^p^o' ov

Hermias 04 o-^wj/] ^<^cD' B a(puiv T c6 7 T: om. B
:

C 8 SoK7s T SoKt7 B : d 4 ^riropiK^ T (inropiKhs B d 5 2tou ;

BT: 3irou Aldina d6 * AA.r7r?;y T Aristides : ^AAjVj/s B areXiii

T dTeAf j B
: d 7 Aucrtas] Gorgias Ficinus : Tkt/oj Schaefer
27oa nAATllNOS
270 dSoAfo-xiay Koi //erew/aoAoytas ^wrrecos Trepi* to yap vxj/rj-

Xovovv TOVTO Kal TTavTi] TfXecnovpybv olkV evTcvdev irodev

elcrUvai. h Kal ITepiKX^s iTpbs rw V(f)vr]s eimt e/cTrjo-aro*

TipocnTecTbiv yap otfxai tolovt(o ovtl ^Ava^ayopq, fxeTe(opo-

5 Aoyias 6jU7rAT/o-^ei9 Kat ctti ^vctlv vov Te Kat Stavotas ck^lko-
ficvos, &v. hi] TTept Tov Ttokvv Koyov i7T0LLT0 ^Ava^ayopas,
evTevOcv etXKVcrev em T7]v tG>v Xoyuiv Te)(yr]v to iTpoa-cf^opov
avTrj.

<I>AI. YI&s TovTo Xeyeis;

b 211. *0 avTos TTov TpoTTOs T^yvr^s laTpiKrjs Bcritip KoiX

prjTopLKrjs.

*AI. n&s bri;

212. 'Ev afxcpoTepats 8et SteXeV^at (f)va-LV, (rcafxaTos fxkv

5 ey Trj Tpq, v//-ix^? ^f ^^* t^ (T^pq, et jue'AAei?, /lit) TpLJ3^

fxovov KOL kfXTTupiq aXKa Tiyyrf, to) juey (f)apfxaKa koI Tpo(f>r]v

TTpocr(f)p(>)V vyUtav Kal pcafxrfv fX7T0Lr]a-Lv, tj/ 8e Xoyovs Te

Kai e7rtTr;8evofet5 vofxifxovs Tret^o) ^v ^i' jSovkr] /cat apTr]v

TTapabcocreLV.
^o <I>AI. To yow etKOs, oj 2w/cpaTe9, oiJtcos.

C 2X2. ^vx^s ovi^ (f)va-LV d^tcos Aoyou KaTavorja-aL otei

Sui^aToy eii^ai ^yeu t^s tou SAou (f)va-(t)s;

4>AI. Ei jixei' 'iTrTTo/cpdTet ye to) TcSy 'Ao-K\?77rta8a)i'

Sei Tt TTLOiadaL, ovbe Trepl crcafxaTos avev tt/s fxeOobov

.'? TaVTTJ?.

2i2. KaA.a)9 ydp, S) kTOLpe, Kiy^L' XPV P-ivTOL Trpos tw

'iTTTroKpdTet Tov \6yov e^eTd^ovTa crKOiT^lv et crvfxcfxaviL.

*AI. ^rffxL
2i2. T6 tolwv TTcpl (f)va-e(t)s o-Koiret Tt TTOTe Aeyet iTTiro-

10 KpdTrfs Te Kat 6 d\r]6r]s Ao'yo?. dp' ovx wSe 8et dtayoeto-^at

a 2 /caJ B Kal t^ T
: rfXeffiovpyhv B Plutarchus : rfXfcriovpyiKbv
T: re\((rUpyov Badham a4 roiovT<f T : t^ B a5 Smcofas
V Aristides awias B
: T ivvoias al. : a 6 Si/ T b .
6v pr. B
b4 iv T: om. B b7 t$ 5e T: t^; 5e B C2 g^ou TW:
AeJ-yoi; B C3 7 Heindorf re BT: om. Galenus : rwv BT:
om. pr. T 04 iridfO-Oai T Trtt^eo-Oai B :
 ci>AIAP02 * 270d

TTfpl oTOVovv 0v(rea)s* TTp&Tov pi4v, aTTkovv 1] TToXveibis d

ioTiv ov TripL ^ovkqa-ofxeda elvat avTol txvlkoI Kal 6Xkov '

bvVaTol TTOLlV, TTLTa b4, OLV pieV CLTtXoVV ^, (TKOITeTv TrjV

bvVapilV aVTOV, TLVa TTpOS tC TTecf)VKV eiS TO bpav ^XOV 1] Ir

TLva iU To TTaOiLV VTTO Tov, kov 8e TTkfm dbt) exji, TavTa 5

<*
apLdfjLrja-dfXfVOV, OTTep e(^' hos, tovt^ Ibelv e<|)' cKaoTOU, r&) tC oj ^*<--

TToictr auro TTfcpvKev 1) tcotl iTaoeLV vtto tov;

$AI. KLvbvvevi, S SwKpares.
212. 'H yow areu tovt(ov ixiOobo^ IoCkol hv uxnTcp
TV(p\ov TTOpeCci. dX.k' ov /xr/y diretKaoreoi' roV ye Tix^JI e
IxeTLovTa oTLovv TV(f)X^ ovSe K(o(()S), dXXa brjkov ay, ay |

ru rt? re'^!'?/ Ao'yovs 8t8oi, r^y ovcrCav beC^eL d/cpt/3cSs rT/y ^)

r^ t/

(j)V(rOi)S TOVTOV TTpbs b TOVS XoyOVS TTpOCroCcriL' t(TTaL 8e ttov

^VXV TOVTO. 5
4)AI. Tt /x?;y;

212. OvKOvv rj a/LttAAa avrai reVarat 7r/)6s rouro Trdcra' 271

Trei^o) ya/) ej; rovrfa) iroieiy eTTLX^LpcL. ?] ydp;
cI>AI. Nat.
2X2. ArjXov dpa otl 6 Qpa^rvixaxds re Kat o? ar dAXos
(TTTOvbrj Tix^W pflTopLKr]v 8t8<j), TTp&TOv Trdo"?/ dKpL^eCcL ypd\\rL 5
re Kai TrotT/o-et ylrvxjiv Ibelv, TTOTfpov '(v Kal dp.oLov iT(f)VKv

rj Kard a(aixaTos ixop(^i]v TToAvetSes* rovro ydp (f)aiXV (pvcrLV

(TvaL bcLKVVVaL.
<I>AI. riarrdTrao-t ixV ovv.
212. Aevrcpoy 8e' ye, oT^a tC Troteti/ rj iTadelv vtto tov 10

TT((I)VK(V.

*AI. Tt>?7i^;
212. Tptroy 8e 8?/ 8tara^d/xeros rd Adycoy re Kat -^vxvs b
y^in/ Kat rd rovrcoy iradriixaTa 8teio-i Trdo-as atrtay, iTpocrap-

Ix6ttu)v fKacTTOv KdcrTi^ Kal bLbd(rK())V ota ovcra v(f> OL(t)V

d5 rov T : rovSf B
d 6 a.pidfJiff(rdfifPOP Galenus dpifl/urjcra/Uf voy :

BT: api$firi<ran.fvovs Stephanus d^ avTb recc. avr^ BT: :

oStw V e i jeB: om. T e 3 T<f) T om. B e4 & T : :

om. B a 10 T T om. B : ba irdffas T ras B W :

271 b nAATIiNOS
koyoiv 6t' r/v alTiav e^ avayKfjs r/ fxkv TTeCOeTai, rj Se

5 aTretOet.

4>AI. KdkXia-Ta yovv av, ws Ioik', Ixoi oiJrft)?.

2f2. Ovroi iJiev ovv, Si (f)C\, aAXcos cvbeiKVVfJievov rj

keyofxevov Tix^JI Trore Aex^?jo-erai ^ ypa<^r\(reTai ovTe rt

C aAAo ovre rovro. dAA' oi vvv ypd(f)0VTS, S>v (tv dK7/Koas,

rexi'as Aoya)i; iravovpyoC ela-iv Ka\ d-noKpviTTovTai, eiSores

^vxrjs Tripi TrayKaAcoy Trpii' dv ovi; rw Tpoirov tovtov

XiyuxTi re Kat ypd(f)(0(ri, fxr] Tret^w/xe^a avrois Tix^JI ypd(f)iv.

5 <i>AI. Tti^a roCrov;

212. Avrd fjikv to. pr\p.aTa etireti^ ovk euTreres* ws 8e Sei

ypd(f)eiv, ei /iAe'AAet rexi^tKws exeti' Ka^' oo-oi; ei;8e'xerat,

Aeyety e^e'Aco.

4>AI. Aeye 8?/.

lo SH. 'E-TretSr/ Ao'yov bTivafJns Tvyxdva \f/vxay(yio. ov(ra,

d roy /xe'AAoi;ra pr^TOpiKov eo-eo-^at drdyKi/ etSe^rat ^/^vx^ oo-a

eiSrj Ix^'* l''"T'ii' ovi^ rorra Kat roo-a, Kai rota Kat rota,
o6(V ot /xey rototSe, ot 8e rototSe yCyvovraf tovtu)V 8e 8r/

ovrco bir]pr]pLvo)v, Aoycoy av roo-a Kat roVa eo-rty et8r/, rotwSe

5 iKa^TTOv. oi ixV ovv TOioCbe VTTO t5>v TOiS>vb XoyoiV
bid TT/ySe Tr]v ahCav es rd rotdde evTreiOets, ol 8e rototSe
bid Tdbe bv(nTi6el9' 8et brj raura tKarws vor](ravTa, /xerd

raiJra dedixevov avTa ev rais TTpd^ea-iv ovTa re Kal iTpaTTo-

e /xeya, o^e'a)s rf/ ato-^r/o-et bvva(r6ai eTTaKoKov6eiV, r/ p.r]bev

elvaC TTUi TTXdov avTSt S)V t6t i^Kovev koyuiv (rvviav. orav
be eiTrety re iKai^ws ^XV ^^^ ^^' ^'''^'^ iTeCdeTai, Trapayiyvo-
p.ev6v re Swaros f] biai(T6av6[xevos eavT& evbeCKvva-6ai ort
272 oilrds' eo-ri Kat avTr] rj (^vo-ts Trept rjs TOTe ^](rav ol Adyot,

b7 oijTOi] ovTCii B : oStoj T d. 3 roiolSe . . . rotoiSe T Galenus :

Tolot . . . rotoiSf B : rorot . . . rorot Hermann Sc S^ B : Se T

Galenus d 4 oStco T Galenus om. B ad rScra T avrhs & : : B
rot6ySe B T rot^vSf Se Galenus
: d 5 yuei/ oZv T Galenus /Mfv : B
d6 ej B iy T
: d8 avra recc. avrhv BT avrh Galeni cod. : :

Marc. e T fiijSfv that Galenus

i^ yu^ elSevai B ^ firfSe elSevai : 1* :

T 6 2 auT^ B T avrZv vulg. e 4 tc T Galenus 5^ B

: :
 a>AIAP02; 27aa

vvv ipy(^ -napova-a oi,

f\
TTpoa-ot.(TTOv TOv<rb cSoe tov^
\6yovs eiTL Ti]v Tu>vb Tret^w, Tavra 8' ?/8?/ TiavTa iyovTi,
TtpOCrka^OVTl KaipOVS TOV TTOTC \KT0V KOl fllKTyiTiOV,
^paxyXoyia^ re av Kal kkuvokoyias KaX Setrwo-ecoy eKdorcor 5
Te oora hv efSrj p.a6rf X6yu)V, tovt(dv Tr]V iVKaipiav re Kal
aKaipiav htayv6vTi, KdKSts re kox reAe'<oy eo-rty ^ Tiyvr}
aTTetpyaa-piivr], irp^Tepov 8' oil* dXA' ort &i' avrc3i^ rtj
eAAetTHj Xiyoiv ^ 8i8do-Kcoi' 17 ypa(f)0)V, (f)f]
8e Ti\vr] \4yeiv, b
6 /x^ ttl66ixvos KpaTil. " Ti 8^ ovv; ^r]a-L la-oas 6 avy-
ypa^vs, S) <l>at8/oe re xai ScoKpare?, 8oKet ol/rcos; /x^ dAXcos
"
TTCos aTTobKTov XyopLvr]s X6y(it)v re^xvTjs;

4>AI. 'A8vmrdy ttoi, S ScaKpares, aAAcos* Kairot ov 5

ap.LKp6v ye (f)aivTaL pyov,
2X2. 'AArj^T/ Ae'yets. rovrou rot ereKa XP^ irdyras tovs
Adyous dvco Kat k6.tid p.Taa-Tp4(f)0VTa (ttlo-koitcIv ei ris tt?/

/5aa)y Kat ^pa\vTpa (f)aivTaL iir' avTr]v 68ds, tm /u.^ p.dTr]v c

ttoAAt/i' aTTtr/ Kat TpayjElav, k^ov oXiyqv re Kai AetW. dAA'
ei rtyd ttj] (3oi]6Lav ^X^'-^ eTraKT/KOcbs Auo-iov ?/ rtz^os dAAov,
TTLp5) kcycLv ava]XLp.vr]aK6p.vos.
tI>AI. "EreKa ixkv TTcipas exot/u,' av, dAA' oiJrt rw y' 5

ovrcos e^co.
2Ii. BovAet ovv eyco rty' etTTco Adyoy ov t5)v Trepi raurci
TLV(*)v cLK-qKoa;

<t>AI. Tt fxr/y;

2i2. Ae'yerat yovv, S <l>at8pe, 8tKaioy etrat Kai to tov 10

AvKOu eiTreiy.

4>AI. Kai (Tv ye ovto) Troiei. d

212. ^acri Toivvv ovbev ovtoo raOra 8ety (rfjLVVVLv ov8'

av(tyLV avci) p.aKpav TrpL(3aX.\o]jLvovs' TTavTaTraaL yap, o

a 2 oi D: aot Galenus : om. B T a 3 ravra S' irivra B

tjSt] : T
TTavra Sh Taxn Galenus a 6 ^aa B Galenus fts T : rt Ka\ oKatpiav
TWGalenus: om. B hz (prifffiT : ^pvffeiB bs /i^scripsi: ^BT
e2 airjT? BT : i.virj Stallbaum : irfpitr} Badham : Jj; Schanz C 3 <^
rivos T: etnvos B C5 ^xcf-' ^" ^ '

^X"'/*"" ^ '
Af^of/x* &v Schanz
C 7 \6yov T K6y<DV : pr. B c8 rivwv BT: StivQv corr. Ven. 184
a72d nAATIlNOS
Kttt KUT apxas iiiToixev rovh^ tov \6yov, ort ovhev aXrjdeCas

5 jJieTixeLV 8eot bLKaCcov rj ayaOGiV Trept TTpayixaTOdV, rj Kal

avdpcaiTOiV ye tolovtcov (fivcrei. 6vt(hv rj Tpo(f)fj, tov fxeWovTa
iKarws prjTopiKov ecrecrOaL. to 'napa.TTav yap ovbev kv toIs
StKafrrrjptots tovtcov aXrjOcCas /xeAety ovbevC, aXXa tov irt^a-

e vov' tovto 5' etz^at t6 etKos, w beiv TTpocreyetv tov p.iKkovTa

Te\vi] p(LV. ovbe yap avTO, {to) TrpayOivTa betv kiyeLV ivCoTe,
eav p.r) elKOTOis 17 TreTrpayixiva, aWa tcl etKoVa, (V re Kar?;-
yopCci Kal aTToKoyCa., kcll TrdvTOiS XiyovTa to bi] etKos bL(aKTiov

5 etz;at, iroKKa clTTovTa )(aCpeLV roi aKr^Oei' tovto yap 8ta

273 Trarro? tov koyov yLyv6pt.evov Tr]V aTTa^rav rixvrjv TTopCCeiv.

<I>AI. Avra ye, w "SicaKpaTes, SteAr/Au^as h KiyovcrLv ol

TTp\ Tovs X6yovs TeyvLKoX TTpocnroLovjxevoL eXvaL' avixvr]a-dr]v

yap OTL iv t(o iTpoa-Oev jBpaxio^s tov tolovtov i(f)r]\f/d[xe$a,

5 8oKet 8e rovro TTd]xp.eya eXvaL tols iTepl Tavra.

212. 'A\Aa fxrjv t6v ye Teto-tW avTov TreTrarrjKas dKpt/3&)?*
elTTiTOi ToCvvv Kal Tdbc rjfxlv 6 Tei(rtas, /xtj rt aAAo Ae'yei

b To etKos rj to roi TTkrjdei boKovv.

a>AI. Tt yap aAAo;
2,12. ToOro brj, ws eotKe, (TO(f)ov vpoi)v &fxa Kal TexyiKov

iypaxfrev wy idv tls a(r6vr}s Kal avbpLKOs la")(vpbv Kal

5 SeiAoz; a-vyKoyfras, ijaartoy rj tl &Wo a(f)X6ixvos, els bLKa-

(TTripLov ayr]TaL, bel br] rdArj^es jxrjbiTepov kiyeLV, akXa rov

[xev SetAof /x,r) vtto ix6vov (f)dvaL tov avbpLKOV a-vyKeK6(f>0aL,
Tov be TOVTO fxev ekiyxav o)s [xovot) r]aTr]v, eKeCv(a be Kara-

C XPW^^^^^'- '"'{> nws 8' &v eyo) rotoo-8e roioiSe eire-

X^Cprjcra; 6 8' ovk epel br] rrjv eavTov K(iKr]v, akkd tl

akko \f/evbe(rdaL eiTLxeLp&v tAx &v ekeyxov TTr] TTapaboCr]

ro) dyrtStKO). Kat Trept raAAa 8r) rotavr' arra eari to.

5 Tixyr] key^jxeva. ov ydp, S 4>at8pe;

d.8 /x(\eiv Stephanus e Ficino ^Aej ea ouTct ri Hein-

: BT
dorf awrA B o5 Tci T
: : &4 i<pri^diJ.(daT: ^}f/ri<(>i(Tdfxf0aB a,6 riffiav
Tb: Tiffiv pr. B a^ \4yeiv Par. 1826: Xiyei bs ij ti BT
T (ex emend.) ? ti B :
 a>AIAP02 273C

4>AI. TC jxijv;

2i2. 4>e5, beiViDS y eoLKev aiTOKeKpvfjLixivqv Tiyjfr\v aviv-

piiv o Teio-tas' t) ^AAos oorts 8?; ttot' wr Tvy)(6.v(i Ka\
oTToOev yaipet 6vop.a^6p.vo^. oTap, cJb eratpe, rovro) ^/aety

TTOTepov Ae'ya)/Xy ?/ ju,?/ lo

<I>AI. To TTotor; d
2X2. "Ort, S Teto-ta, TraAai ^juets, Trpty Kai (r^ irapfkdeiv,

TvyxdvoiJ.V kyovTs 0)s apa tovto to etKos rots ttoXXoXs

bi ofxoioTr^Ta tov akrjOovs Tvyxavet (yyiyvofxcvov Tas 8e
ofxoLOTrfTas apTi hirfkQofxev oti iravTaxov 6 Tifv akifdeiav 5

etScbs KaWLo-Ta (TTLo-TaTaL evpCcTKiLV. uiCTT et fx\v oKXo TL

TTpl T)(vrfs koyatv X4yLS, CLKOvoifXfV av et 8e fxrf, oXs

vvvbrf bLrfkdopifv iTiLa-op.eOa, wy kav fxrj tls t&v re clkovo-o-

fxivdiv Tas <f)va-(LS bLapLdfxrfa~rfTaL, Kal Kar etbrf re Stat/aeto-^ai e

TOL ovTa Kttt jtxiS Z8e'a Svi^aroy rf Kad^ kv Kaa-Tov TTcpLkapL-
j3dvLV, ov TTOT (TTaL T^xvLKos koyutv TTCpL Kad^ o(rov

bvvaTov dv6p(aiT(a. Taura 8e ov fxrf ttotc KrT/oT/rat dv(v

TTokXrjs irpayfxaTeCas' rjv ovx ^VKa tov kiyiLv Ka\ TTpdTTCLV 5

TTpbs dvOpuiTTovs 8et StaTOi^eto-^at roi^ a-dix^pova, dkkd tov

OeoXs K\apL(Tfxiva fxkv kiyeLV bvvaa-daL, Ke^apLo-fxevcjos 8e
TTpdmLV To TTav ets bvvafXLV. ov ydp bif dpa, a> Teio-ia,

(f)a(rLV ot (ro(f>(i>TpoL rffiQv, 6p.obovkoLS 8et yapL^eaQaL

fxekeTav Tov vovv eyovTa, otl fxrf Trdpepyov, dXkd bea-JTOTaLS 274
dyadoLS re Kai e^ dyaOStv. <3ot' ei fxaKpd rf TTfpiobos, fxif

6avfxda~>fs' fXydk(av ydp VKa TnpLLTiov, ovx ^^ ^^ 8oKets.

io-TaL fxrfv, ws 6 Aoyos (f)rf(rCv, cdv tls iOikrj, Kat ravra

KdkkLCTTa e^ (KeCvoiV yLyi/ojXfva. 5 i--. ;

tI>AI. riayKaAcos ^fxoLye 8oKet kiyecr^aL, a> SwKpares,

eiTre/) otos re rts etr/.

C 7 7' T : t' B c9 To-ln(f BT : toOto corr. Coisl. : fort. toDt'

axir^ Thompson d3 tJ T : om. B d7 e 5'^ T : 18t; B
d8 vvv 8^ T W : vvv B 69 rifiSiv Heindorf ^ B
: : ^ T
iifiSiv :

T)nS>v n^ vulg. a2^T:^B a3 ovx s B T : ovx ^f <^''

Heindorf a7 oT6s re Heindorf : otos B : oT6s ye T
274a nAATllNOS
SI2. 'AAAa Kal kTTiyeipovvTi toi tols KaAois koAoi' koI
b 7rao-)(fii' OTL av r<j) (rv^i^f] iraOcLV.

*AI. Kat fiaAa.

SX2. OvKoOz; ro juei' Te^^-qs re Kat drexi^icts Aoycoy Trept
iKai^cSs X<eT(o.

6 *AI. Tt>?;y;
212. To 8' evTrpeTreta?
8^ ypa(jirjs Trepi Kal aTrpeTreta?, Tr?/

yLyvoixevov koX&s av expL Kal OTrrj dTrpeTrws, AotTroV. ?] ydp;

^Al. Nat.
212. Oio-^' ovv oTTrj /xdAto-ra ^eoi xP'^ koyoiV iripL

lo TTpdTToiv 1] kcycov;
<t>AI. Oii8a]u,(Ss" o-u 8e';

C 212. 'Ako^v y* exco kiy^LV t&v TrpoTepoiiv, t6 8' dArj^e?

avrot to-ao-tr. et 8e tovto vpoLpLV avToi, apd y av e^'

TjpXv iJ.4X.0L TL tS>v avOpcaTTLVOiiv bo^acrixdTO)V

4>AI. reAoioy tjpov dAA' b. (jifjs aKrjKoevai Aeye.

5 212. "HKOVcra tolvvv iTepl NaijKpaTLV ttjs AlyviTTov ye-

vicrOaL tG>v eKei TraAatwy rti^a deoiv, ov kcu to opveov Upbv
o br] KaAoSo-iy 'I/3ti'' avT^ 8e ovop.a rw baCpiovL eiyat &eu6.
TovTov brf TTp&Tov dpL6p.6v re Kai koyLcrfxbv evpcLV Kal

d yecofxeTpLav Kal darpovofXLav, ^tl 8e Trerretas re Kal KVjScCai,

Kal br] Kttt ypdfXfxaTa. ^ao-iAe'(as 8' aS rore wros AtyvTrrou
oA?js Qapiov Trept rTjy /lAeydArjy TrdAti' roi5 dvo) tottov r\v ol
''EAATjyes AtyuTrrtas 0?j/3a? KaAoi5o-t, Kai tov 6ebv "Apifxoiva,

5 Traiod tovtov i\6o)v 6 &vd tcls Ti\vas eTre^Setfey, Kai e^?;

buv bLabo6r]vaL rot? dAAots AtyfTrrtots* 6 b\ rjpcTO rjvTLva

kKaa-Tr] ^\ol oxftekLav, 8te^toWo? 8e, ort kciAws rf ju?;

e KaAws 8oKot XiycLV, Tb /utev ei/^eyey, Tb 8' eTr^/ret. TroAAd

bi Stj T gry B : b6 5^. . . airpevelas om. Stobaeus

b 9 Oey Stobaeus 0ewv B T :
03 fi4\oi B : fi.(\\oi T c 6 /epfjj/
Stobaeus Hermias rb Up6v B T : 078^ Stobaeus 5e B T :

d 3 %vV tvBT Stobaeus

: d 4 Qehv'] Qafiovv Postgate d 5 rov-
rov T rovrwv
: B ineSti^fv T fireSfi^e Stobaeus aveSet^e B
: :

d 6 ^vriva B T ^iv Sii Stobaeus: d 7 6x<" ^ ^ ^X*' Stobaeus '

e I SoKo7 B T SoKoiri Stobaeus

:
 274 6

[kkv 8t; Trepi ecao-r7j? r?^s Tiy^r\<i kii' a\i.(^6T(.pa &a^ovv rai

ev^ A.eyerat aTro^Tjyacr^ai, & Aoyos ttoAi/? ar et?; SieA^eiv

eTretS); 8e eTri rots ypdfjLfxa(ri.v 'qv, " Touro 8e', w ^ao-iXeu, t6

fxd6r]ixa" i(f)r] 6 &(v9, " (ro(f)(DT(povs AiyvTTTCovi Kal fxvrnjLo- 5

viKOiTepovs Ttapi^ei' iJ.vrifj.ris re yap Kal (ro(})Cas (f)dpfJ,aKOV

ifvpidrf" 6 8' etTrei;* " '12 T\viK(aTaT &(v6, aWos (ikv

TK(lv bvvaTos Tct re^i^Tjs, aWos 8e Kplvai riV e^et fxolpav

/3Aa/3r}s re xai b)(f)eXtas toIs fxekkovcn XPW^^'-' '^^"^ ^^^
o-y, TTaTrfp a)v ypafXfxaTcov, bi vvot.av tovvovtCov iXitis rj 275

Swarat. tovto yap tS)V fxa66vTO)v Xrf6r]v fxkv iv \}rv\aLS

7rape'^et fxvrffxrfs dfXkTrfa-C<i, aTe bi.a hC^ttlv ypa(f)fjs i^(s)6v

VTt' dXXoTpCo)V TVTT(t)V, OVK &bo6V avTovs v(f)' avT&v dvafXL-

fxvrfo-Kopiivovs' ovkovv fxvrffxrjs dXXa vTTOfxvrf^reats ^dpfxaKov 5
ifvpes. (ro(f)Cas 8e rots fxa6rfTaLS bd^av, ovk dA^^eiai' Tropt-
^ets' TToAvT/Koot ydp croL yv6fXV0L avev bibaxrjs TToXvyv(a-
fxoves elvaL b6^ovcrLV, dyv(afxovS ws em t6 TTXrj^os dvTS, b
"
Kat x^aXiTTol avvclvaL, bo^6a-o(f>OL yyov6TS drrt cro(f)(av.

<I>AI. '12 Sw/cparey, p(ibCo)S (rv AlyvTTTiovs Kal OTTobairovs

dv ideXrfs Aoyouy Trotets'.

212. Ot 8e' y', co 0tAe, V rw tov Alos tov A(t)bo)vaCov 5

tepo) 8puos Ao'yovs (f)rfcrav fxavTiKovs TTpo)Tovs yVcr6aL.
rotS fXV OVV t6t, dT OVK 0V(n 0-0</)OtS &a-TTp VfXLS 61 VOL,

diTexprf bpv6s Kal 7re'rpas dKouety vtt' evr/^eta?, et fx6vov

dXrf6rj Xe'yotey o-ot 8' t(ro)s 8ia<^e'pei riy 6 Xiyoov Kal TTobaTTds. C
ov ydp cKeiyo fx6vov o-KOTrets, etre ovrws eire aAAcos exet; '

4>AI. 'Op^ais TTTTXrf^as, naC fxoi SoKei Trepi ypafxfxdTOiV

\LV yTTp 6 &rfl3aLos Ae'yet.

63 & X(fyos . . . Sie\ef7i/ om. T

B W Stobaeus
e6 irapefe Sto- :

baeus : wape^oi B : e 8 txi^s T Stobaeus t^s TexfV^ B

rrapf^eit' T :

aa yufi/ otn. Schanz IvSoOei' T Stobaeus

a^ ^vSoyB outoTs :

. .a,vafji.ifj.vri<rKoix(pois H. Richards
. a6 Spes T eSpe B b i rb :

B T om. Stobaeus
: h 3 koI B re Kal T b 5 ol St y' S>T
: :

olS' iyii B oi/Sf 7' 5 V

: (to\ S' iyin Stobaeus
: b 6 t(t>i)<Tav B Sto-
baeus t^avav T : b 8 Spvhs T b Sihi pr. B c r S^Xams : TW
Stobaeus om. B :
275C nAATI2N02
5 2X2. OvKovv 6 riyvriv ol6ixvos iv ypcnnxa(n KaTaX.LTrelv,
Kal av 6 TTapab^xojjievos a>s ti aa^is Ka\ fii^aiov (k ypap.-
jiaTcav ka-ofxevov, ttoXXijs av evrjOcCas y^fxoi Kal t^ ovti Tr]v

"AfXfxo^vos fxavTeCav ayvooi, TrX.iov tl ol6p.ivos eirai X6yovs

d yeypaixfxivovs tov tov eiSoVa vTTOixvrj(rai Trepl &v av fi
Ta
yypa[xix4va.
<J>AI. 'Op^oVara.
2X2. Aeivov ydp ttov, Sj <^albp, Tour' e^^^ yP^^^Vf '^^'-

5 ws akrjOuis ojxolov ^<aypa(f)Lq, Kal yap to. iKeCvrjs Kyova

ia-Tr]K ixV 0)5 ^iavTa, iav 8' aviprj Ti, a-ffxvais Travv a-iyq.

TavTov b^ Koi oi \6yoL' b6^aLs fxkv hv &s tl ^povovvTas

avTOvs XeyeLV, eay 8e tl eprf tS>v Xeyofxivcov f3ovk6fXVOs
jxadelv, V TL (Tr]fxaLVL fxovov tovtov aeL. otov b\ aira^
e ypa(f)fj, KvkLvbdTaL pikv TravTaxov iras koyos ojao^tos Trapa
Tols (TTaLOVa-LV, b)S 5' aVTOiiS TTap' ols Ovb\v 7rpO(r7]KL, Kal
ovK (TTLo-TaTaL kiy^LV oh bd ye Kal fxr}. TTkrjp.pi.ekovp.evos

8e Ktti ovK iv bUr] koLbopr^Oels tov TraTpbs dei deirai ^or]dov'

5 avros yap ovt dfxvvaa-OaL ovre ^orfOrjcraL bvvaTos auro).

4>AI. Kat raurd troi opd^TaTa eXpr^TaL,

276 Si2. Ti 8'; 6,kkov op&fxev koyov tovtov dZek<j)ov yvq-

(TLov, r&) TpoTTio T yLyvTai, Kal 0(r<i) dixeCvcov xal Sui^arw-
repos TOVTov (})VTaL;

4>AI. Tii^a TovTov Kai tt&s kiyeLs yLyv^jxevov;

5 2X2. Os [xeT TTLa-Tr][xr]s ypd(f)TaL ev Trj tov fxavOdvovros
"^vxfj, bvvaTos fxev dfxvvaL kavT<a, iTTLorrffxoiv 8e keyuv re
Ka\ (TLydv Trpbs ots 8et.
4>AI. Tov Tov etSdros k6yov Ae'yets ^coi^ra Kat ifx\(/vxov,
ov 6 yeypafxfxevos etb^okov dv tl keyoLTo StKatws'.

C 5 Kara\nre7v BT : KaTa\fiireiv Stobaeus C 7 &j/ T Stobaeus :

om. B c8 ?i/at] ex*'" Heindorf : Trojcri' Stallbaum di rov

rhv BT : koI tovtov Stobaeus : f) rb rhv fuisse susp. Wachsmuth
d4 ypa^p^fi b : ypa^p^fiv pr. BT d 6 8' avepp T 8' a' ipt] B 5e epy : :

Stobaeus e i KvKivSeTrai B T KaXivBe^rai. V : 63 76] re

Hirschig ir\7ift./jieKovixevos T 7r\rinfievos B
: a i dpwfjiev B T :

ipovfiev V yrfiffiov corr. Coisl. yvi\<rios B T

:
 *AIAP02 276b

2i2. riavTaTTaa-i. juey ovv. Tob^ bri fJLOi, ctTre* 6 vovv b

excoi' yecapyos, wy a-npixaT(av KriboiTo Ka\ tyKapi^a ^ovkoiTo
yev^adat,, TroVepa cr7rou8r; ay Oipovs ets 'ASwi/iSos ktjttovs

dpwy \aipoi Oeoypuiv Kakovs Iv r)p.ipai(nv okto) yiyvop.ivovs,

1] TavTa /Acy b-q iraiSias re Kai eo/arTys ^dpiv 8p^rj w, ore 5
Kat TTOiol' e</)' ois 8e eor7ror;8aKei', rf; yicopyiKrj yj}(l>p.ivos av
Ti\vr\, a-ireCpas ets ro TrpoarJKov, ayaTTiarj hv iv 6yb6<a ixt]vI

oaa (a-TTLp(v rc'Aos ka^6vTa;

JjAI. OvToi TTov, 0) SwKparcy, ra fxkv (riTovbfi, to, 8c ws c
crepoos ay 17 Ae'ycis ttoioi.

2i2. Toy 8c SiKa^toy rc Kat Kak&v Kal ayaO&v e7ri(rr?//u,as

\ovTa Tov yioapyov (^5i[iiv rJTTOv vovv '^yjii-v cts Ta kavTov

(TTrep/xara; 5
4>AI. "HKto-ra ye.
2ii. ,0^ jajoa ^TOySn QW^a ^y vart ypayjffi, fxikavi.

a-TTeCpoiV bi.a Kakdfxov fxeTa koyoiv abvvdTOiV txV avTols

k6y<^ $(n)6iv, aZvv&Tayy bk iKav&s rJLkriOri bibd^ai,
<I>AI. OvKow br] t6 y cZkos. ic

SX2. Ov ydp' dkka tovs fXV kv ypdp.p.a(n Kr\TTOvs, ws d

eotKc, 7rai8tas xdpiv cnTipii re Kat ypdyj/ei., oTav [8e] ypd(pri,

(axjTi^ re vTTop.vrfp.aTa difa^avpiCdfXiVos, cis to krfdrfs yijpas

dv tKrjrat, Kai 7rayri roi TavTov txvos /xcrtoVri, rfcrdrf-

(TiTal re avTovs deuipwv (pvofxivovs aTrakovs' otov (8c) 5

oAAot ^ratStais aAAats yj)G>VTai, crvp.T!oa-Cois Ti apbovTcs av-

Tovs ere'pots re ocra tovtohv dbekcfid, t6t cKcti^os, ws OI,kV,

dvTi TovTOiV ots Aeyco 7rat^coy Std^et.

4>AI. IlayKciAijj; Ae'yets 7rapa ^avkrfv TTaibidv, a> Sco- e

b I vovv T : vvv B baSj^TrcuBt&vV b^ dpw' B T :

bpwv V : ffiriipas Herwerden b6xP^^M-^^os hv Tex''V ''*'

XP<^' ^

ficfos rixvri &>' B C7 -ypc^i^et (^j/) Badham C8 /leTtk]

ffvepftaTa Badham aSvvaTwv (bis) B aSvvaT&v (bis^.
: (et sic Hein- T
dorf omissis juerd \6y(Dv) C 9 TaA;6^ B : t' dA7;0^s d 2 5^ T
om. Bekker: t Heindorf 76 Schanz : ds5e add. Par. 181 1 t :

Stephanus om. B T : d 8 ofj \7 yp. Par. 1812 oTs Ktytev B: T :

iv oh \iyu Heindorf ov Ktyu Schanz : 5ta{et T : 8ie'{t B

276e nAATi2N02
Kpares, tov kv Aoyots bvvajxevov Traifetr, bLKaLocrvvris re Ka\
aXX(i)v &v Aeyeis 7re'pt /jtu^oAoyowra.
212. "EoTi ydp, S) <^tAe 4)at8pe, ovto)' ttoXv 8' oifiaL

5 fcaXA.tcoi' o-7rou8^ 7re/ot avra yiyv^Tai, oTav tls tjj StaAeKrtKf/

Txvrj )(j)(aiJ.Vos, kafSoov yj/V)(j]V TrpocrrjKova-av, ^VTvr\ re Kat

(TTTeipr} fjLeT e7rto-r^/xrys Aoyov?, ot eavrots ro) re (jiVTeva-avTL
277 ^or]6LV Uayot Kat ov)(t CLKapTTOL aXXa \ovTes (nrepfxa, odev
^AAot ev aAAois r/^eo-t <f)v6[XVoi tovt^ det aOdvaTov Trapix^LV
LKavoL, Kal Tov ^)(0VTa evbaLfxoviLv TTOtoSrre? ets oo-oy

av0p(aTT(^ bvvaTov ixakLcrTa.

5 4>AI. rioAv yap tovt (tl K(iAAioy Ae'yet9.

SX2. NCy 8^ eKetm ijbr], o) 4>at8/3e, bvvdfxcOa KpLveLv,

T0VT(t)v a)fxoXoyrnxiv(t)V.

4>AI. Ta TTota;

Si2. ^i2v 8^ ir^/Ji ^ovXrjOivTis Ibiiv a^LK6p.i6a eis ro'8e,

lo oTrcos To Avaiov re oyet8os i^eTda-aLfiev ttjs tG)v K6y(v

b ypacfyfjs TTepL, Kal avrovs tovs X6yovs o\ Teyjvri koX avev

TXyr]S ypdcj^OLVTO. TO fXV OVV iVTiyjfOV Kat fXT] 8oKet fLOL

bebr]KG)(r6aL fXTpL(t)S.

4>AI. "ESo^e' ye 877* TrdAtr 8e VTT6fxin]a-6v fx tt&s.

5 2i2. Uplv &v TLS t6 re dXrfdes kKdcrTo^v elbfj iripL &v

Ae'yi rf ypd(f)L, Kar atrrd re Trdy 6pi^(a-6aL bvvaTos yvr]TaL,
6pLadp.v6s T TToKlV KaT elbr] fxiyjpL TOV aTfXrfTOV TfLVLV
TTLa-Tr]6fj, TTpL T 'v/^^ux^^ (f)va-0)S StiScby Kard TavTd, rd
C TTpoaapfx^TTOv Kda-Tr] (\)VcrL et8os dvevpiaKu^v, cnjT<a TL6fj

Kat bLaKoa-fxf] tov Kdyov, TroLKiKj] p.V TTOLKiKovs ^/n^xf? '^t

TTavapfxoviovs 8t8ous Adyovs, aTrAoSs 8e aTTKfj, ov 7rpdre/)oy

' ^uyaroy T\vr] icra-6aL Ka6^ ocrov tt(\)VK fXTayLpLa-6r]vaL

5 To K6y(av yivos, ovt tl Trpbs to 8i8d^at ovre rt Trpos rd

Treto-at, s 6 fXTTpocr6V ttols fXp.r]VVKv rjfuv Adyos.

4>AI. riayrdTrao-t p.V ovv tovt6 ye ovrco Trcos (f)avr].

a I /cai B : Te ol T a3 Koi om. Schanz b 5 tlSy corr.

D : :8p (sic) T: iSpB b6 re B T : -y* vulg. b 7 Kar tWr
T : /cotiStj B
 4>AIAP0S 277d

212. Ti 8' av TTepl tov KaXov 1] ala")(^pbv eHvai to Aoyovs d

Acyeu' re Kal ypd(f)i.v, Kal ottij yiyvo^^vov iv 8ikj/ Aeyoir' |

av oveibos i] /X7/, apa ov 8e8?/A(OKey ra Ae^^eVra oAiyoy

inrpo(r6iv
<I>AI. Ta TToZa; 5
212. 'X2y eire Auo-iay 7/ ris aAAoy -TrwTTore iypa^ev ?*/

ypcv^ei IbCa ?; brjixoa-Ca v6p.ovs tlOcCs, (rvyypapiyia TTokLTiKOV

ypd(^(iiv KCLL pieydXrjv tlvo. iv avT^ jSfjSatoTrjTa r)yoviJ.VOS

Kal (Ta(^r]VLav, ovro) /uey oyei6os roi ypd(f)ovTL, etre rty

(pr](TLV eire /m?/' ro ya/) dyroetr virap re Kai ovap btKaCcov 10

Kat ddtKcor 7re'/)t Kal KaKwr Kat dya^&iy ovk (K(f)evyL ri/ e
d\i]6(Ca 1X1] ovK ii:oviChL(TTov eti^at, ovh\ av b ttSs o>(Aos
avrb (TTaLViiTi].

4>A1. Ov ya/) ovv,

212. *0 8e' ye er /ier rw yypa]i]xiv(^ Ao'y6) irept eKao-rov 5

TratStdy re rjyovjxevos tto\X.i]V dvayKOLOv iXvat, Ka\ ovbdva
7T(aTT0T koyOV iv IXTp(a Ovb^ dvV fXTpOV ]Xydkl]S d^LOV
(TTTovbi^s ypa(f>r]vaL, ovbe X)(di]vaL ws ot pa\ff(obov]XVOL dvv
dvaKpC(T(t)S Kal bLbaxijs ttl6ovs VKa eAe'x^?/o-ar, dAAd rw
o7'rt avTMV Tovs ^\tC(ttovs Lh6T(i)v VTT6]xvr](TLV yyovvaL, 278
iv b rot? 8t8ao-Ko/xe'rots Kat ]xa6i](r(t)s )(dpLV Aeyo/Ae^i^ois Kat
rw wrt ypa(f)0]XVOLS iv "^vyi] iTpl bLKaCo)v re Kat KaAwr
Kai dya6Qv [iv] ixdvoLS r]yov]Xvos t6 re ivapy^s eirat Kai
T\ov KOL d^Lov (TTTOvbrjS' bLV 8e rovs TOLOVTOvs Ao'yovs 5
avTov Xy(T6aL oXov mls yvr](rCovs eti^at, TTpQtTov ]XV tov
iv ovtCo, iav vp6ls ivf], TTLTa et rtres tovtov KyovoC

T Ktti d8eA</)ot dfxa iv dAAato-ty dkkoov \frvxa'Cs KaT* d^Cav b

V(f)V(Tav' Tovs 8e dAAovs yaCpLV i&v ovtos 8e d tolovtos

d r rov T : rh B d2 Xfyoir' itv T : \fyfi rav B CI3 ^

corr. Par. 1812 fj : BT d^ ypd\p(t B : ypd<f>(i T i/<{/xoi;s Tjfl(j
secl, Schleiermacher d 10 SiKalwv nal B : SiKalcDV rt koI T
e8 01(5 . . . eg Schanz
f\4xOr)trav secl.
dij ol f\(xOv<r<if secl. : . , .

Ast d)s 0] 8(ro4 Schleiermacher a i avruv T avrt^ B :

a4 fV secl. ci. Heindorf rtyovfifvos TW: om. B a^ tv avri^

B : (avrtp T
278b nAATXiNOS
avTjp KLvbvveijei, S) 4>at8pe, eirat 0102^ eyw re Kal crv ev^aifxe^'

ai' (Te' re Kai e/ie yevicrdaL.

5 4>AI. riai^raTrao-i /u.ey ovy tymye j3ov\ofiaC re Kai evxojuai

^ Ae'yety.

2X2. OuKoSi' 7/8r; TT7iai(T6(a fj.TpC(as rjjuv ra Trepl Ao'ya)i'*

Ktti crv re eA^cby (ppd-C^ Aro-ia ort r^o) Kara^ayre es ro

Nvpi(f)civ vap,d re Kai fxovcrtiov -^KOvcrapiev X6y(av, 0% eire'-

C arTeXkov Xdyetv Auo-ta re Kat et ris aAAos crvvTiO-qcri Xoyov^,

Koi 'O/XT/po) Kai et rts aAAos av iroCrjo-iv ^ikriv ^ iv <Lbfj

crvvTiOrjKf, TpiTov 8e SoAcovt Kat oo-rts kv TrokiTiKoTs Xoyoi^

voixovs ovoixdCcov avyypdp,p.aTa eypa\j/V' ei fxkv elbuis ij to
6 dArj^es ex^t a-vvldr]Ke TavTa, Kal excor /SoTj^etr, ets eAeyxoy
tojy Trept wi; eypa^/^e, Kat Ae'ycor avro? bvvaTos ra yeypap,-

lj.4va (f)avka diTobel^ai, oij rt rwrSe iTTOivvfxCav eyovTa 8et

d kiyea-Oat tov tolovtov, dkk^ e(/)' ots eo-77ov8aKey iK(Cv(t)v.

4>AI. Ttms ow ras eTTOiWixCas avT^ veixeis;

2i2. To /xer aocfiov, S) 4>at8pe, KaAety eixoLye ixiya

ctmi 8oKet Kai ^ew /Ao'i/a) TTpiTTeLV to 8e 7/ cf)Lk6a-o(f)ov ?/

5 rotovro'i; rt ixdkk6v re ai' avrw Kai apixoTTOL Kai e/x/ieAeo-rc-

/30)5 exot.
4>AI. Kai ov8e'r ye diro Tpoirov.
2X2. OuKow aS rw /xt) ix^vTa TLixL(aTepa S)V <rvvi6r]Kev

^ iypa\frev av(*) Karo) aTpicf)(t)v iv yjpovai, TTpbs dkkrika

e KoAAwi' re koi dcf)aLpS)V, iv 8ikt/ ttou iTOLr]Triv rj k6yo)V

(rvyypacf)ia rj vopioypdcf^ov Trpoo-epets;

*AI. Tt/x7/i;;

2X2. TaSra toCvvv rw kraCp^a cf^pdC^.

5 4>AI. Ti 8e aij; -Trws 7rot7/o-et9; oiSe yap ovbi tov ctov

eTalpov bel TTapek6elv.
2X2. Ttm roOroi';

b8 4s T : jj B rb T : rhv B b9 fiovtruov T : fiov(Tiov

B: /iouffa)' vulg. ^irf(rTA.Aoi/ B : ^ireAXovT di ^(^' B : v^'
d. 5 toiovtSv ti B : tj toiovtov T auT^' aJ T ; avT^ B d8 06
TJ>j/t: ouTii/BT e I ^j/Si/cpT: Si/cijB iroyB:oni, T 64 iToipy
T : krtpff) B
 <l)AIAP02 278e

<i>AI. 'lcroKpaTri tov Ka\6v' <I) rt aTrayyfkus, o) 2w-

KpaTfs; Tiva avTov (\)ri(Top.(^v ^Xvai;

2X2. Neos cn, w ^alhp^, 'la-OKpaTrjs' o fiivToi, fxav- lo

Tevop.ai Kar' avrou, Aeyetr (di\(o. 270
fl^AI. To TTotoy 8?;;

2X2. AoKCt /xot ap.iiv(jiiv ?/ Kara rou? Trept Auo"tai' eimt 1

\6yovs To. Ti)s (f>V(r(x)S, ert re ^^et yevvi.K(OTp(o K(Kpa(r6aL' /

ojo-re ovSey ay yivoiTo 6avp.a(jTov TTpoLov^rrjs Tijs 7/\tKtas et 5

TTept avTovs re tovs k6yovs, oXs vvv eTrt^eipet, itkiov 17

7rat'8a)i' 8ieye'yK0t rwy TrwTTore a^aixdvoov k6y(ov, eri re e^

avro) //t; aiTo^rj(raL TavTa, kin ixlC(jo 8e' rt? avTov 6.yoL

opfiT} dfLOTcpa' (f)va-L ydp, <^iA.e, ^V(rTL tls ({)Lko(ro(f)La

Tf] Tov avbpos bLavoLq. rarra bi] ovv eyo) p.V Trapa T&vbe b
Tiiv 6e(av 0)5 TTaLbLKOLS 'l^TOKpaTeL e^ayyeAAo), o-u 6'
(fxoLS

iKfXva wy o-ots Auo-ia.

<t>AI. Tairr' i^rraL' dkka ico/xer, eTretST/ Kat ro wtyos

r}TrL(aTipov yiyoviv. 5
2X2. O^KOw ev^apte'va) TrpeTrei Toio-Se TTopeveardaL;

cI>Al. Tt/xT/y;
2X2. 'X2 0tXe riai' re cat aAAot oo"ot rT/8e ^eot, boirjTi

p.0L Kak(a yV((T6aL Tavbo^ev ^o)6(v 8e 6(Ta e)(co, rots ivTos

(XvaC p.0L (pCkLa. TTkoxxrLov 8e vop.LCoLp.L Tov (ro(J)6v' t6 8e c
\pV(rov 7Tki]6os etT/ [xol 6(tov /xT/re (j)pLV /XT/re ayety Swairo
oAAos T/ 6 cr(a(f)p(av.

'Er' oAAou rou 8eo'/xe6^a, oi (I>at8/3e,* e/xot /xey yap /xerpio)?

T/J/crai. 5
0AI. Kal e/xol rai3ra o-wevxou' Koiya ya/j to. t&v
(f)Lk(OV.

2X2. "Ico/iev.

a4 T B : Se T a5 t^j f]\iK(as T : tffr]kiKlas B a6 To{;s

T : om. B 7 ^ri rea T : JfTs B a8 ivififi^wv 5e tj avr^
B : ^iri fifi^wv Se Tty auToi/ T ag ^pyuf) Bfiorfpa. B b2 ^la-y-
yeAw Stallbaum b6 fv^a/xfvw Bekkcr c i <pi\ia B : (pl\a T
0\
 I^

AAKIBIAAH2
St. II
SilKPATHS AAKIBIAAH2 p. 103

SH. 'X2 Trai KKaviov, olfxaC re davixdCav otl Ttparos a

ipacTTi^s aov yv6fXVos t&v aXX(ov TreTravjwerooy fiovos ovk
3,TraXKaTT0ixai, Kal oti ol /xey aAAoi bi o^Xov ^yivoi^To (tol

StaAcyojuerot, eyw 8e too-ovtwv ItS)V ovhi Ttpoa-flTTOv. tovtov

5e to aiTiov yiyoviv ovk dvdpu>TTtiov, dXXd ti baifioviov 5
erarruojua, ov <tv ti]v bvvapi.t,v Kal va-Tcpov Ttiva-r}. vvv b\
ovk^ti ivavTtovTai, ovtod 8'
i-rrdbif Ttpoa-ikrfkvOa' eueX-n-ts b
nyX Koi To Aoittoi' /otr/ ivavTMO-eadaL avTo. axfbbv ovv
KaTavv6r]Ka (V tovto} rw xp^vta o-KOTTOVfx^vos a>s irpbs tovs

(paa-Tas a")(S' iroXKbiv ydp y(vofXV(ov Kal fXyaXo(j)p6v(av

ou8eis os ovx vTT^pjBXridds T(a (^povrffxaTL virb aov iT^vyV. 5

Tov 8e k6yov, o) vTTpTT(^p6vr]Kas, iOiKoi 8ieA.0etr. ovbv6s 104
(f)f]s dv6p(aTT(siV vbr]s etrat ety ovbiv Ta ydp VTTapyovTd
aoL p.ydka etmi, wore fxrjbv6s bLcrdaL, dm tov adtfxaTos
dp^dp.va reAevraiyra (Is tt]V ^x^v, otL ydp brf etmi
7TpS>TOV fi.V KaAAtoTo's re Kal fxiyiaros xat tovto fnkv bif 5
Trayrt 8^Aoy ibLv otl ov \f/vbr] ^Tretra i^eaj/tKwraror yVovs
v rrj a-avTov 7ro'Aei, ovo-tj fx^yCarri r&v *EXXr]vCbo)v, Kal
kvTavOa irpos 7rarpo's re' o-ot ^lKovs koX (TvyyVLS ttK^C^ttovs b

as or^pwircjo' B Olympiodorus : avQpwirivov T\^ bi ovKiri

BT : oiiK Proclus a 3 liari . . . hu(T9ai sccl. Cobet
PLATO, VOL. II. 19
I04b nAATilNOS
etvai. Koi apicrTovs, ot et rt 8eoi VTrqpiToiiv av croi, TOVTcav
8e Tovs TTpos fJLtjTpos ovbfv )(^eCpovs ov8' eAarrov?. o-u/xTrayrcoy

8e wy eiTToi' //,eiX<w otet orot hvvaixiv VTrap^^iiv Yl^piKXia tov

5 Har^tTTTTOV, OI^ 6 TTaTl^p (TTLTpOTTOV KaT^klTTe (Toi T Kal T(D

d8eA(^w' os ov p.6vov Iv rf/Se t?) 7ro'Aet hvvoTai. irpaTTuv oti

ay jSovkrjTaL, dAA' ei' Trdo-?; t?} 'EAAdSt /cat rwy ^apfiapcov

fV TToAAots Kat /xeydAots yiv^cnv, Trpoa-Orja-o) 6e Kat ort rwy

C TTkovaCcav 6oKets 8e' juot eTri T0VT(a iJKLo-Ta fxiya (jypoveiv.

KaTO, TTavTa 87; TavTa (tv re p.i.yakavyov\x(.vos K(.KpaTr\Kas t5>v

(paa-T&v KivoC re vTTobe^a-TepoL ovts iKpaTrj6r]a-av, KaC o-e

raCrr' ov k^krjOcv 69ev brj ev otSa ort 6avfxdC(LS tC biavoov-

5 ixv6s 77ore ovk dTraAAdrro/xat rou epooTos, Kal rjvTiv' excoy

eATTiSa vTTOfXV(o tS>v dAAcoy Tre^evydro)!^.
AA. Kai io-(os ye, w Sw/cpare?, ovk oto"^' ort a-fii,Kp6v

d /bte ^(})di]s. eyo) ydp rot ey rS eixoy TTp6Tp6s aoi 7Tpo(r(\6(ov

avTa TavT kpiar6ai, tC 7Tot /So^Aet xat ets Ttm eATrtSa /3Ae'7rft)i;

eroxAets /ae, dei ottov av co cTTLfxckio-TaTa TTap(av' T(a ovti

yap 6avixaC(a 6ti ttot eo-rt to abv TTpayfxa, koI rjbi,a-T av

5 TTv6oCfxrjv.

212. 'AKOvarf fx\v apa fxov, ws t6 hkos, npodvp.oiis, etrTep,

b>s (pfis, iindvfxus ei8e'mt rt Staroou/u.at, Kai cos aKOva-OfXivtf

Kol TTepLfxevovvTi kiyoi.

AA. ndw fxkv ovv dAAd Ae'ye.

e 212. "Opa brf' ov yap tol (Xrf av 6avfxa(TTov et, uxTTTep

fxoyLS ifp^afxriv, ovTOi p.6yLS kcu. TTava-aCp.r\v.

AA. 'i2ya^e Ae'ye* cLKOva-OfxaL ydp.

212. AeKre'oy av etr;. xaAeTror fiXv ovv TTpbs dvbpa ovy^
5 rjTTOva ipaarSiv TTpoa-(f)(p(a6aL epaaTfj, d/utos 8e Tokfxr]Ttov
(f)pda-ai Trfv ifxrfv bLavoLav. eyo) ydp, S) 'AAKt^td8?j, et p.^v

b3ovSfu B W
Proclus oiSl T b 4 {/vdpxfty^ ivapKuv Ast
:

fort. wapfXfiv Stallbautn C i /xtya (ppovfiv B Olympiodorus

/x(ya\o(ppovuv T Proclus d 2 ouTct ravr' B TavTo. Tavr' T tovt : :

Proclus d 3 Sttou B T '^irovntp Proclus ; d 7 (pys T Proclus :

e0rjj B (tSfvai Proclus eiSeVoi ol oKovffaj B

: tlSfvai aKov(rai T :

e 2 fxoyis Ka\ TW
o! /uoyiy B
: Priscianus Trav^roi/nriv Cobet
 AAKIBIAAH2 I04e

<r ktiipuiv h. vvvhi) bLTjkOov ayaitoiVTa kuI olofxevov bilv fv

TovToii KaTa^L&vai,, TrciAai hv aTrrjAAay/irji' tov e/icoros, wj
ye br] kiiavTov iTid(' vvv 8' iTcp^ av KaTriyopri(r<a biavor]- 105
/xara (ra TTpos avrov (ri, ^ kcu yvaxrri 6ti Trpoaiyuiv yi (toi
TOV VOVV bLaTT\Ka. boKLS yap jXOL, Cl TLS CrOL (LTTOL Oe&v
"'il 'AAKt/3ia877, rroTepov (3ovX.l (rjv ix(ov h vvv cx^'^ V
avTLKa TeOvdvaL ci ju?; (tol e^icTTaL /xet^o) KTri^racrOaL; "
5
boKils &v fxoL kkia-daL T(9v(xvaL' akka vvv CTrt tlvl br] Trorc

eAiriSi Cv^> ^7'^ (^pacroi. rjyfj, iav OaTTOv ets tov ^Adr]vaL(t)V

brjpLOV irapikOr^s rovro 8' ea-ea-OaL ]xaka okLyoiV r]fx(pm'

b
Trapekdwv ovv ivbL^((r6aL AOr^vaCoLS otl &^los ' ct ri/uao-^ai

ft)? ovT YlepLKkfjs ovT oAAo? ov8cis T(av TTWTrore yero/xeVcor,

Kal TOVT vbiL^(iixVos p.yLa-Tov bvvr]a-a-daL V rr) wAet, eay
b' v6ab ]XyLcrTos r]s, Kal v tols aAAois "EAAtjo-i, xai ov 5
pLOVov V "EkkrjcrLV, akka Kal V rots ^ap^dpoLS, oaoL V rj/

avTf] r^jxlv olKOVcrLV ijTretpo). Kai ei av aoL eiirot 6 avroy

ovTos ^eos ort avTov a 8et 8vm(rreueir iv Trj Evp(aTrr],

bLa{ir]vaL 8e ets Tr]v ^Aaiav ovk i^aTaL aoL ov8e irrL^da^aL c

rots e/cet Ttpayp.aaLv, ovk av av fxoL 8oKets idkLV ovb^ em
rot;roty fxovoLS ^rjv, et fxr] fXTrkr]aLS tov aov ovojxaTos Kal
Trjs ar]S bvvdfX(os irdvTas ws eTros eiTreti' dvdpcoirovs' /cai

dtfxai a itkrfv Kvpov /cai s.ip^ov ffyela^aL ovbiva d^Lov 5

kdyov yyovvaL. otl fxv ovv excts TavTrjv Tr]v ikTTiba, ev
oI8a Kat ovK etKti^co. to-a>s av ovv etTrots, aTe et8a)S ori
dkr]dr] ky(o, " Tt 8?/ ovj',iaTL aoi Trposo) ^(aKpaTS, tovt
koyov; [hv (f>r]a6a ipLV, 8to ifxov ovk aTraAAarrT/;] " eyob 8e d
o-ot y ip5), Zi (f)Lk TTal KAetrtou /cai A^LVOfxdxrfs. tovt(i)V

ydp aoL dTidvToov t&v bLavorjfxaTcov re'Aos iiTLT6r]vaL dvV

e 7 Si^Adov B Proclus SiiiKOofieu T : T Proclus re koJ B /ca2 :

Olympiodorus b i dKiywv rjfitpwv Proclus TjfKpuv o\iyov T B :

b 2 o5i/ B 8 T Proclus
: dvSd^ftrdat B ^i'Se((a(r9ai T Proclus :

b 4 fifytffTov SvvfifffcrOai B T fifyKrros yfvfiffri Proclus

: C i affiav
T affiriv
: B C 7 8ti B T y Proclus d i tv . diroA-
: . .

AoTTjj seclusi tv] hs Cobet Sii B T Proclus Olympiodorus

5(' tv recc. Se B 5i; T Proclus : d 2 Sffvojutix;? T W
Olympiodorus SfivofifvTjs B t et j/ supra /*ox
: Proclus W
i05d nAATXlNOS
ffxov abvvarov TOcravTi]V cyo) bvvaixiv oijuat \eiv eij Ta aa
5 irpdyixaTa Kal fls fre, bib bi] Kal TraAai otojuai /xf tov deor
ovK iav bLak4y(rdaC (roi, ov ^yo) Trepieixevov OTrr^viKa kd(T(L.

&cntep yap a-v (Xiribai exety fv Tfj irokei, efSet^ao-^ai otl

e avTrj iravTbs d^Los ei, ei^Sei^ajueros b^ [ori] owdey ori ov
napavTLKa bvvricrecrBaL, ovrco Kayo) wapa aol e\7ri^<u ix4yLa-Tov
bvvi](re(r6aL ey8ei^a/xew? ori Trai^ros afio's etfit o-oi Kal ovtc
fTTLTpoTTos ovT (Tvyyevris ovt' dWos ovbels iKavbs TrapabovvaL
5 Triv bvvap.LV ris iTTLdvp.eLS Trkriv p.ov, )u,era tov Oeov ixivTOL,
vecaTipia pikv ovv ovtl (tol koX Ttplv TOcravTris kKitibos yeixLV,

ot)s fixol boKeX, ovK eta 6 ^eos 8iaAe'ye(r^ai, tva ixri ixdTr]v

I06 bLakeyoLixriv. vvv 8' e^prJKCv vvv ydp dv p.ov aKOv^raLS.

AA. IToAv ye /xoi, ai Sw/cpares, vvv aTOTT^aTepos av (paLVi],

(TTeLbi] rjp^oo XeyiLV, rj 8t aLyStv eiTTov KaiTOL (r(\>6bpa ye

7/0-^' IbiLV Ka\ t6t tolovtos. ei ixv ovv iyui TavTa 8ia-
5 voovixaL 1] p.!], 0)? OLK, bLyvot}Kas, Kol edv //t) (jioi, ovbev
IXOL eo-rai Trkeov vpos to TreCdeLV (re. etev ei 8e bi] otl
/xoAtcra Tavra 8iai'eror//xat, 'n-o)? 8ta crov ixol ecTTaL Ka\ dvv
crov ovK dv yivoLTo; eyeLS XeyeLv;
b 2i2. 'A/)' e/)ft)raj ei rty' ex^ eiTrery Aoyoy jxuKpdv, olovs
br] dK0VLV ei^to-at; ov ydp (ttl tolovtov to p.6v dAA'
evbeC^aaOaL ixev croL, ws y^p.aL, ol6s r' dv eXr^v otl ravra
ovrcos ^X^* ^^^ ^'^ ix6vov ixol ideXrj^rtis ftpo-x^ vTTripeTfjcraL.
5 AA. 'AAA' et ye 8?/ /x?/ xciAe7ro'i' rt Ae'yets to vTTr]pTr]ixa,

$Koi.

2i2. 'H )(akTTov 8oKet tq diTOKpCvacrdaL tcl ipooToiixeva;

AA. Ov xaAe7ro'i'.

d. 4 Svvafj.iv oi/xai B : oT^at Svvafiiv T Proclus d7 ivS(l(a<T6ai

...62 Svv-fifffcrdai TW Proclus : om. B 6 i Srt om. Proclus
63 B Olympiodorus iravrhs fiaWovTW: Kot avrhs fiaWov Pro-
TToyTJir :

clus aoi B om. T Proclus

: e 4 jKavJiy B Proclus iKavui T :

5 ToCBWProclus Olympiodorus om. T ai (<prjK(vBT: :

iupvKt Proclus aa a5 B Olympiodonis om. T Proclus W :

b 4 fOeK-fifftjs T Proclus 0 Ajjs B Olympiodorus

: b 7 ^ Butt-
mann *? B T: airoKpivaffOat T Proclus Olympiodorus: aroKpivfffdai B
 AAKIBIAAH2 io6b

212. ' ATTOKplVOV 87/.

AA. 'E/)(ora. 10

2X2. OvKovv ws bLavoovixivov <tov ravra ipbirSi, a (f^rjfii are

biavoc^ia-Oai; C
AA. "EoTco, ei /3ovAct, ovrcoj, tva Kal ct8w ori Kai
epety.

2X2. 4>epe 8t;' Staro'^ ya/a, o)? eyo) (fyrjfxi., i:apdvai avixjSov-
keua-uiv *A6i]vaCois ivrbs ov ttoWov yjtovov ei ovv [xiWovTos 5
aov Uvai eTTi rb ^TJp.a Xa/3o')ueros epoLfxrjv "'X2 'AA.Ki/3ia8?j,

eTretST/ Trepi riros 'A^Tjraioi Staroowrat ^ovX.V(r6aL, avC-

cTTacraL crvfxjBovXcvcTiov ; S/)' eiretST) irepl c5y (rv e^Triorao-at

^ikTLOv 1] ovtol; " rt Si' cnroKpCvaLo;

AA. Ei^TToiju.' ay St/^jtou, Trept wi' oii8a (3iX.TLov r/ ovrot. d

2X2. rTepi &v ap et8<i)s TvyxaviL^i, ayaOb^ (rvfx^ovX.os et.

AA. riaiy yap ov;

2X2. OuKow raura fxovov o7(rda, a Trap' aAAcoi' (fxade^ i]

avTbs i^vpes; 5

AA. riota yap aAAa;

2X2. 'Etrrti^ ovv oircos ay irore ^fxadis tl rf (^rfvpes /XTjre
fxavOav^Lv iddKcav /x?/r' airos ^rjretr;
AA. OVK iCTTLV.

2X2. Tt 8e'; 7/^e'A?/o-as av ^rfTrfcraL rj fxaOeiv h. T:Ca-Ta(r6aL 10

(^v;
AA. Ov 8^ra.
2X2. *A &pa vvv rvyxarets eTrto-ra/xei^os, rjv xpovos ot ovx
rjyov ei8e'rat;

AA. 'Avoy/CT/.

2X2. *AAAa fxrfv a ye fXfX(x6rfKas cr\b6v tl Kal eyd) oiSa*

et Se' ri e/^e k4\r]6V, eiTre'. ^fxades yap 8t) o-u ye Kara 5

fxvTffxrfv TTfv ifxrjv ypdfxp.aTa Kal KL^apCC^LV Ka\ TrakaCcLV ov

yap bif avk(LV ye i^^eAes fxadiiv. raSr' ka-Tlv h. av (TrCaraaai,

C2 2tj al T : 8t B Proclus e i & Hpa B : 2p' & T Proclus

84 4yu BT : avrhs Proclus e6 t^i/ B : om. T : ri^v 4fii)v om.
Proclus
19**
*"
PLATO, VOL. II.
io6e nAAT12N02
et /iTj TTOv Ti fjiav6dv(i)V ejue AcArj^as- oi/xat 8e yc, oure
vvKTuip ovre jxeO^ rjixepav e^ioiv evbodcv.
lo AA. 'AAA' ov TrecfioCTriKa ei? aAAcoj; 17 tovtohv.

107 Si2. IToVepoi; ovi^, oray Trepl ypap.p.6.T(x)V 'AdrjvaloL j3ov-

kevoovTai, TTm av 6p6&s ypd^oiev, t6t dvaa-Tr]crr] avTols

orvii^ovkf.vauiv;
AA. Ma Ai" ovK eyoiye.
6 212. 'AAA' oray Trept KpovpidTOiv ev kvpq;
AA. OvbaixS>s.
2X2. Ov8e /x?)y oi8^ iicpl TTaXata-p.dTOiv ye cJw^ao-i
^ovXevea^aL kv r^ (KKkqaLq.
AA. Ov jXeVTOL.

iQ 2X2. "Orar oSy Trept rti^os ^ovXevoDVTaL; ov ydp ttov 6Tav

ye TTepl otKoSo/xtas.

AA. Ov brJTa.

2X2. OiKo8o'jiAos ydp TavTd ye o-oC 134\tiov a-vii^ovkfvacL.

b AA. Nat.
2X2. Ov8e pirjv oTav Trept ixavTLKrjs fiovXcvoiiVTai;

AA. Oi;.

2X2. Marrts ydp av raCra d\xeLVOv rj crv.

5 AA. Nat'.

2X2. 'Eay re' ye a-fxLKpos ^ p.iyas 17, e(iv re KaAos ?/

ato-x/)o's, ert re yciraros ^ dyevin/j.

AA. riciis ya/) ov;

2X2. Ei8o'ros yap ot/xat Trepl eK(icrrou ^ avfx^ovXrj, kol ov

10 TrAoirrowros.
AA. ndis ydp ov;
2X2. 'AAA' edrre TTevrjs idvTe TTkova-ios fi
6 TTapaLvStv,

ovh\v Sio^o-et 'A^jjratois ^Tav Trept t5>v iv ry iroAet j3ov-

e8 B : oiATC 76 T Proclus oiire Olympiodorus

7 o{;t a 10 fiov-
:

\(v(Dvrai Proclus Olympiodorus fioiKuvrai B

T ta 4 o5 T
: &' :

B om. Proclus
: b 6 ^^ fifyas T Proclus /col fieyas B b 8 vws :

. b 10 irAowToCvTos post e 2 (Tvfj.$ov\ov transp. Apelt

. . b 9 /col
ov ttKovtovvtos secl. Schanz b 13 jSovAc^VTat T Proclus :

^ovKoivTai B
 AAKIBIAAH2 i07 c

KfvcavTat, TrCoi av vyi.aCvoi.ev, uAAa (ijTiia-ovcnv laTpov etvai c

TOV (TVfX^OvXoV.
AA. EiKoVto)? ye.

2X2. "OTav ovv irepl tIvos a-KOTT&VTai., t6t <rv aviaTaixevos

<as crvp.^ovXiva-U)V 6p6S)S avaaT)]a-r}; 5
AA. "Orai' Trepl tQv kaxrriav irpayp.a.TUtv, w SwKparey.
2X2. TQiv irepl vavmjyias Aeyety, diToCas Tivas XPV o.yTOvs
Tas vavs vavTniyela-Oai;
AA. OvK eycoyc, S) ^wKparey.
212. NavTTtiyelv yap oi/biai ovk iTriaraa-ai. tovt atTiov 10

17 ^AAo Ti;

AA. OvK, aWa tovto.

2X2. 'AAAa Trepl "nomv tQv kavT&v Aeycts TTpaypLaTUiV d
oTav l3ovkV(i)VTai;
AA. "Orai Trepi TTok(fxov, S) 2wKpaTe9, */ Trept elprjvris fj

aAAoi Tov tG)V tt/s TroAecos iTpayp.aTO)v.

2X2. 'Apa Ac'yf ts orat' ^ovkfvoovTai TTpbs Tivas XPV f^PV^^ 5
TTOtetrr^at Kai rtVti' TroAe/ixeti' xat rtya TpoiTOv;

AA. Nai.
2X2. Xp?; 8' ^4\tiov;
ovx ots

AA. Nai.
2X2. Kai t66' oiroVe /3e'Artor; e
AA. riayt; ye.

2X2. Kai Toaovrov xp6vov oaov afxcivov;

AA. Nai.
2X2. Ei oSz; /SovAevotrro 'A^jjmtot ritrti' XPV itpo^nra- 5
Aaiety Kol rtVty aKpoxe*-pi^ea-6ai. koI Tiva TpoTTOV, av afxeivov
av a~vfx^ovXvoLS if 6 TTaihoTpi^rfs;
AA. 'O TTaiboTpi^rfs brjirov.
2X2. "Exeis ovv elTTelv iTpbs ri {hv) ^XiiTcav 6 iratSorpi/Sjjs

c I ftjT^iroucrii' T W : ^TjTovcr/i/ B Proclus c 7 tuv B Olympio

dorus rhv T Apelt

fiS>v d4 iAAou B Olympiodorus irtpl
W W
: : :

&X.\oiv T d 8 ohx B : om. T e9 S>/ addidi : post (rvfifiov

Xfianfv Ast
107 e nAATf2N02
10 (rvixl3ov\(V(r(iv oh Sei TTpoa-TTaXaUw Kal oh jU7y, Kal 6tt6t
Kai uvTtva TpoTTOv; keyoi be to roio2'6e' apa tovtols 6et
TTpoa-TTakaUiv oh ^ikTMv, 1] ov;
AA. Nai.
jo3 212. ^Apa Kal To<ravTa oa-a aiJLdvov;
AA. To(TavTa.
212. OvKovv Kal t6t otc afxdvov;
AA. Yldvv ye.
5 2X2. *AkXa firjv Kal abovra Sei KiOapi^iLv ttot^ irpos Tr]V
(Lbrjv Kal ^aCvav;
AA. Aet ydp.
2X2. OvKovv t6t oTToVe ^ikTiov;

AA. Nai.
lo 2X2. Kal roo-aud' 6(Ta ^ikTiov;
AA. <I>i7fii.

2X2. Ti ovv; eireiST) /3e'Xrioy /xey ww/iia^e? eir' dpL<f>o-

b TepoLS, rw re KcOapLC^tv tt/jos r^z/ wSt/i' xat roi TTpoa-TTakaULv,

tL KaXiLS To iv ro) KLOapLC^tv ^ikTLov, oicnTep eyo) ro ey roi

TTaXaUw KakOi yvfxvaa-TLK^v a-v 8' iKiivo tl KoXiis;

AA. OvK ivvo<a.

5 2X2. 'AXAa 7ret/oc5 e/xe fXLixda-daL. cyo) ydp Trou dire-

KpLvdjxr^v t6 8ta Trai^ros 6pd(as ix^^> opd&s 8e S^ttou Ix^^ ^^

Kard r^y Ti\yr]v yLyv6fX(vov rj ov;
AA. Nat'.

2X2. 'H 8e Tiyyr) ov yvfxvaa-TLKrj ^v;

lo AA. Uvs 8' ou;
C 2X2. 'Eyo) 8' etiroy ro ei raJ irakaLeLV fiikTLov yvfxva-
a-TLK6v.

AA. EiTre? ydp.

2X2. OvKouj; /caXcSs;
5 AA, "E/xotye 8oKet.

as ^Sovra T : rb iWra B : rbi' i^Sovra Ast ba KiOaplCfiy B :

opO&s KiOapl(fiv T
 AAKIBIAAHS io8c

212. "IOl bi] Koi (Tv TTpiTTOL yap av ttov Kal troi rb KoX&i
StoAeyeo-^ai ei-Tre TTpwrov ris rj Tixyrj rjs rb Kidapi^iiv Ka\
To adciv Kal To ip.^a[vfiv opd&s; (TVvaiTacra tCs /caAeirai;
ovTToi bvvaa-ai, ciTrety;

AA. Ov bijTa. lo
211. 'A\A.' <58 TTnpSi' Tives al dfot (av f} T\vri;
AA. Tas jVIov(ros, cb 2wKpare?, Aeyeis;
212. 'Eyfoye. o/>a 87/' riVa aTr' avrGtv iTTcavviiiav fj d
rexi^ exft;
AA. Mouo-iK)/y fioi SoKcis Xiyav.
212. Ae'yft> yap. ri ovv to Kara TavTtjv 6pd&<i yiyv6p.iv6v
c<mv; bocTTTep eKei eyw o-o6 to KaTo. ti]v Ti\vriv (\eyov 6p65>^, 5
Tr)v yvp.va<TTiKi]v, koX (tv hi] ovv ovrcoj ivTavda tC <f)rjs; tt&s
yiyvia-dai;
AA. Mouo-iKws p.01. boKii.
212. E5 Ae'yeis. i^i 8?/, xat Tb (v rw TroAe/aeiy ^e'A-
rioy Kat To iv rw (lpTi]vi]v ayav, tovto to ^iXxiov ri 10

ovofxaCcis; axTTTcp eKet e^' Kd(rT(^ eAeyey ro ap.iLvov, oti e

lxova-i.K(aTpov Kal (ttI rw (Tp(o, ori yv]xva(mK(tiTipov'
Treipo) 8r) Kat erraii^a Ae'yety ro ^ikTiov.
AA. 'AAA' ov Traru ri Ix*^-
212. 'AAAa fxdvToi alayj)6v ye et /i>ie'y rts o"e kiyovTa 5
Kai aviM^ovXfvovTa Trept aLTi(v otl ^ikTLOv T6b Tovb^ kol
vvv Kal ToaovTov, liretra epcorT/o-etei; " Tt ro afxeLvov Ae'yety,
o) ^A\KL(3L(i.br]; " Trept /ixey roi^rtoy exeii^ etTrety ori Tb vyLd-

voTipov, KaLTOL ov TTpoa^TTOLr] ye laTpbs eirat* ire/ai 8e ov

TTpoa-TKLfi (TTLa-Tripi.(ov etmi Kai o-v/x/SouAevo-et? dyioTti/xeros 109

c6 Wi BTW Olympiodorus : Proclus

f(rtf C9 oihro) . . . d2
X secl. Hermann d4 /caTci ravrnv T kot'
8^ : auTiji' B d6
oiv T : 5' oZv B e i ^4>' t^ &ju(ii'ov
kKa<TT<f secl. Schanz
Proclus : r<f afieivovi BT
64 Proclus ov irikvv B
06 irdvv ri T :

e 9 Koiroi ov T Proclus koI toioGtoi' B : 76 Proclus om. B T : :

T al. a r <rvfiPov\fv<r(is BT W
(sed <r puncto notatum in T)
<rvft.$ov\tvfis Proclus vulg.
loga nAATXlNOS
ws flbios, TOVTov b\ <ws eoLKas, Wpt eptori/^ets car fxrj

iXV^ ^iTTclv, ovK alcrxyvr]; r/ ovk alcryjpov (^ayeirai;

AA. Ylavv ye.

5 2Xi. SKOTTft 8?) Kat TrpoOvixov etTrety Trpos rt reirei ro

y rw (Ip^^vqv re ayetr ajx^ivov Kal t6 iv rw TroXe/^cii'

ot? 8et;

AA. 'A\Aa (TKOTTwv ov hvvafxai fvvorjcrat,.

2X2. Ov8' oXcrda, iiTCLbav 7r6X.fxov Trotw/xc^a, ort cyKa-
10 Aowrej d\A^\ots TrdOrjfxa p\6fx6a eis ro TroXe/uieti', xat
ort avro dyojix.a^oyres ipx6fx(6a;

b AA. "Eycoye, ori ye e^aTrarw/xei^ot rt ^ j3ia(6pi.voi ?;

aTroo-re/^ow/^tey o t

2X2. "E^e* Trcos eKacrra rovrcoi; Trao-xoi^res; tt^tpi^ iliTiiv

tC bia(f)pL To w8e 7/ c58e.

5 AA. 'H t6 <S8e Ae'yeis, S) 2(ocpare9, ro StKaicos ?; t6

abiKcos;

2X2. Avro roOro.

AA. 'AXAa fxrjv tovto ye 8ta^e'/3et oAoi; re Kat Tray.

2X2. Tt ovv; ^Adrfvaiois (rv Trpos iroTipovs (rvfx^ov-

10 Aevo-et? TToXcfx^lv, tovs abiKovvTas rf tovs to. bUaia irpa.T-

TovTas;
C AA. Aetroy tovt6 ye e/)coras* ei yap Kat Stai^oetrat rts

ws 8et 7r/)os rovs ra StKata TTpaTTOVTas TroAe/xety, ovk ay

6/>toAoy?;o-ete'y ye.

2X2. Ov yap v6fxi.fxov tov6^, ws olkV.

5 AA. Ov 8?/ra* ov8e' ye Kak6v boKel eivaL.
2X2. IT/jos ravr' apa Kal av [t6 SiKator] rovs X6yovs
TTOLrj(rr\;

AA. 'ArciyK?;.

as <pavurai T Proclus : (paivirai B a6 rb BT om. Proclus :

a8 eWoTjcroj T Proclus : voljffai B ag Srt T Proclus ti B :

Olympiodorus biyeTW: om. B bs ^ corr. Coisl. :

ei BT : il 8e Proclus c6 TaDr' BT Proclus : toGt' ci. Stephanus

rh SiKaiov secl. Narnberger
 A'AKIBIAAHS logc

21X2. "AXXo ri ovv, o vvvbrj ^yo) ^piaroiv ^iXriov Trpos

To TroAejueiy koX \iri, KaX ol^ Sei kolL oXs ixrj, Koi ottotc Kal lo
/LiT/, To biKaLOTcpov Tvyx<i.vL ov, 7] ov;
AA. ^aivfTaC ye.
'
2i2. ITdis ovv, S) (f)Ck A\k 1/3 laSr;; TtoTipov (tovtov d
XeArj^as ori ouk e7rioTa<rai roirro, 17 e/ue i\a6is p.av9dvoiV
Kol (f)OLTwv ei? 8t8ao-KaAou os crc e6i8ao-Ke bLayLyv(a(rKiv
t6 bLKaioTcpov re Kal abLK(aT(pov; kcil tls ((ttlv ovtos;
<f)p(X(rov Kal p.0L, Xva avT(a (f)OLTriTr]V TTpo^(vi]a->]s Kal e/ote'. 5

AA. EKWTrrets", cb ScoKparej.

212. Ov /ua rw ^iXioy tov fx6v re /cat o-w, ov eyo)
rJKLOT h.v eTTtop/cr/o-at/xf dA\' eiTre/^ exet?, etTre rts ^<ttlv.
AA. T^ 5' et juf/ ex^co; ouk az^ otet //e aAAoo? etSeWt ^
Trepi T(av bLKaLcov Kal abLK(av;

2i2. Nat, et ye eu/aots.

AA. 'AAA' ovK av evpnv /xe rjyfj;

2X2. Kat /xdAa ye, et Cv'"'!^^''^' 6

AA. Etra Cv^V^o.'- ^vk dr^ otet /xe;

2X2. "Eycoye, et ot?/^etr/s ye />tr/ ei8e'rat.

A. riitra ovk r)y ot (l^ov ovto);

2X2. KaAws Ae'yets. e^ets ovv clirelv tovtov tov xpovov
6t ovk wou etSe^z^at rd StKata Kat rd d8tKa; <^e'/)e, Tr4pv(rLV iio
e^r/ret? re Kai ovk wow et8e'yat; rj &ov; Kal TaXrjdij

aTTOKpivov, Xva pi] pdiTriv ol 8tdAoyot yiyv^ovTaL.

AA. 'AAA' w/xr/y et8e'yat.

2X2. TpiTov 8' Tos Kat T^TapTov Kal 'nip.Tnov ov\ 5

ovT(i)s;

AA. 'Eycoye.
2X2. 'AAAd /xr/y ro' ye tt/jo rou Traiy rjo-^a. 17 yd/3;

AA. Nai'.

d3 B Proclus Olympiodoriis 5iSa<TKd\ovs T

SiSaffKaXov d 5 Kal :

ifiiB : i^ie T
Proclus Olympiodorus d 7 ou /uct Proclus )ui B T :

6 5 7 om. Stobacus a 2 tc B Proclus om. T as SiaAo^o] :

Ao'701 Cobct a 8 ToD T Proclus Toin-ou B Olympiodorus :

noa riAATilNOS
lo 212. ToVe ixkv tolvvv (v olba on ^ou flb^vai.

AA. rTws ew oTa-Oa;

b Si2. noAA.aKts (ToC ev StSacr/ctiXcoy iJKovov 7rai8os oyros

Kttt aAAo^i, Kai OTroVe dorpayaAiXois i? a\X.r]v riva Traibixiv

iraC^oii, ovx s airopovvTos iTfpl t&v biKaCoiV Kal abiKuiV,

akX.a fjidka fxiya koI 6appa\4o)s XiyovTos -nepl otov tvxols
5 Ta>v TTaiScoy &>? iTovrjpos re Kat aStKos etTj Kai ws d8tK0t'

?7 ovK a\r]6rj \eyco;

AA. 'AAXd Tt ^jueAAoy Trotetr, w SwKpare?, oTToVe rts

/jte dSiKot;
2X2. 2v 8' et riJx.ots dyyocSi/ etr' dStKoto eire /ut/ roVe,

lo Ae'yets, rt o-e XP^ Troieti';

C AA. Md At" dAA' ovk 7)yv6ovv cycaye, aWa (Ta<j)ois

kyCyv(t)(TKOV ort r\biKovp,r\v.

212. ""l^tou dpa eTTtVrao-^at Kat Traty wr, ws ^oiKe, rd

6iKata Kai rd ddtKa.

5 AA. "Eytoyc* Kai r}T:i(TTdp.r]v ye.

212. 'Ey TTOto) xp6v(a e^ev/owi'; ou ydp dT/TTOu ei' w ye
wov etSeVat.

AA, Ov brJTa,

212. rioVe ovv ayvoHV fjyov; o-KoVet' ov ydp ev/j^cets

lo roSroi; tov xp6vov.
AA. Md roy At", a> 2()Kpares, ovkow ex<) y eiTreiy.

d 212. Ev/9a)y pikv ap' ovk ol^rda avTa.

AA. Ov TTavv (\>aivop.ai.

212. 'AAAd p.i]v dpTi ye ov8e [xadutv e^r/o-^a etSeVaf
ei 8e /ATj^' Tjvpes /ujjr' ]xads, ttws oto-^a Kat 7t66(v;

5 AA. 'AAA' to-o)? roCro' o-ot ovk opd&s dTT(Kpivdixr]v, to

(f)dvaL dbivaL avTos e^evpdv.
212. To 8e TT&s etxer;
AA. *'E//,a0oi' oi/xai Kai eyw uxriTep Ka\ ol dAAot.

a lo fj.iv Toivw BT : /utVroi Proclus b i ffov om. Proclus

C6 iroiij) Dobree : BT
diroicii d 5 atrtKptvdfnriu B T awtKpiOriv :

Stobacus d7 rb 8e B T : ro U wSt Coisl. rh 5e ovt Proclus

:
 AAKIBIAAHS iiod

Si2. \ld\LV eiv Tov avTov rJKOfji.iV \6yov. Ttapa tov;

(fypdC^ Kdp.oL lo
AA. Ylapa t5)v TtoXK&v. e
2i2. OvK eis (TTiovhaCovs ye hihacrKdKovs KaTa(j)vyi,s

eis Tovs TToX.kovs dva<j)(p(jiiv.

AA. Tt 8e'; ovx^ i/caz^ot 8t8a^at ourot;

2X2. OvKOvv Ta jrerreurtKa ye Kat ra fx^* Katrot 5

(fiavkoTepa avTo. ot/xat rwi> 8tKai(oy etrat. rt 8e'; crv ov\

ovTcos otet;
AA. Nat.
2X2. Etra Ta fXV (f>av\6Tpa ovx otot re 8t8acrKeir, to.

8e o-novhaLdTepa; 10

AA. Ot/aat eycoye' aAAa youi; TToAAa otot r' etcriy 6t-

8ao-Kety cnrov8aiorepa tov irerreuety.

2X2. noia TavTa;
AA. Oioy cai ro eXATjyi^ety Trapa TovTiov iyuiy fxa6ov, iil

/cat ovK ay lx.ot/xt etTTety e/xauroi) 8t8cicrKaAoy, dAA' ets

Tovs avTOvs dva(f)p(a ovs (tv (f)^s ov cnrovhaCovs eti^at

hi,ha(rKd\ovs.
2X2. 'AAA', w yermte, rourou /xey dya^ot 8t8do-KaAot ot 5
TToAAoi, Kal 8tKatcos iTraivoXvT hv airr&v ets St^ao-KaAtay.

AA. Tt'87?;
2X2. "Ort 4\ov(n Trepi avrd d xp7] tovs dyadovs 8t-
8acr/cdAoi>s l^.eti'.

AA. Tt roiJro Ae'yets; *o

2X2.OvK oto-^' ort xpi] tovs fxeWovTas hihdcrKLV otiovv

avTovs -npCiTov et8e'rat; 77 ov; b
AA. YlS)s ydp ov;
2X2. OvKoiJy tovs et8dras 6/xoAoyeti' re dAA^Aois Kai
/x^ hia(f)^p<r6ai;

e2 KaTa<^ei^6(; T : KarcKpfvyd B e9
oro/ t Proclus ooi B : :

o7oi T a2 &' T Proclus om.: B uiruv i/xavrov B ifiavrov :

fliruv T Proclus a 3 auTouj T : (navrovs B a 6 VaJi^orj/T*

&'... j 5i8a<rKa\taj' BT : firaivolr' hv .
ri itia<rKa\ia Proclus
. .

avTwv sccl. ci. Stallbaum

mb nAATXlNO^;
5 AA. Nai.
212. 'Ey ots 8' av hia^ipoiVTM, ravra (f^-qa-^LS dbivai
avTovs;
AA. Ov brJTa.

212. TovTOiv ovv bibda-KaXoi tt&s hv eUv;

lo AA. Ovbajx&s.
212. Ti ovv; boKova-C (tol bia^ipiaOai oi TroAAot 'nolov
eoTi kidos rj ^kov; Koi idv Tiva ipuiT&s, ap^ ov to, avTa
C oixokoyova-LV, Kal fTTL TavTa opfx&a-LV oTav ^ovkoovTaL ka^elv
kidov r\ ^vkov; wo-avrcos koX Trdvd^ oa-a TOLavTa' a-x^bov
ydp TL ixavddvoi t6 kkkr^vLC^LV kTTLo-Taa-dai otl tovto kiyiLS'
r) ov;
5 AA. Nai.
2X2. OvKovv ds p.\v Tav6\ Mo-Trep (tiTop.ev, dkkrjkoLs re

dpiokoyova-L Kal avTol kavTOLS IbLa, kol brjpioa-La al TroAets

TTpos dkkrjkas ovk dpL(f)La-j3r]Tova-LV al pikv Tavd^ ai 8' aAAa

<f)da-Kova-aL;

10 AA. Ov ydp.
212. EiKoVo)? hv dpa tovtcov ye Kal SiScio^KaAoi eiey
dyaOoL.
d AA. Nat.
212. OvKovv et /xei^ ^ovkoLp.f6a TroLrja-aC TLva Trept avTMV
ilbivaL, 6p6&s hv avTov nifXTroLp.iv eis StSao-KaAtW TovTiov
T<av TTokk&v;

5 AA. Yldvv ye.

212. Tt 8' et ^ovkr]6iL}XV ilb^vaL, p.r] \x6vov ttoIol

dv6p(tiTToC ucTLV r] TTOLOL Xttttol, dkkd Kal TLves av-

T&v bpojXLKoC re /cat jxrj, dp ert ot ttoAAoi tovto LKavoX
bibd^aL;
lo AA. Ov brJTa.

2X2. '\Kav6v 8e' a-oL TKixr]pLov otl ovk eTT^oTayrat ovb^

b 12 ovT: oZu B c8 HWa (puffKovaai T Proclus &\\ai

:

(pdffKovffivB . Cii 7eB: om. T Proclus cl2 Pov\olfi(6a

B Proclus : /SouAo/ms*' &' T
 AAKIBIAAH2 iiie

Kp/yvoi bibua-Kakoi (i<nv TovTiov, iiTiibr] ovb(V oixokoyovcrLV e

eaurois iTepl avr&v;
AA. "E/xotye.
2ii. Ti 8' (i ^ov\r)BuiX(V dhivai,, fxrj fiovov TTOiot

av6pa>iToC da-Lv, dAA.' ottoioi vyLLvol rj voartabeis, ap iKavoX 5

hv rjpXv ^aav bLbacrKaXoL ol TTokkoL;

AA. Ov brjTa.
2Ii. 'Hy 8' av <tol TKfxr]pLov otl fxoyOripoL i<TL tovtmv
bLbda-KakoL, d kdpas avrovs bLacftepojxivovs;

AA. "E/xoiyt. 10

2X2. Ti 8e 87/; vvv Trepi twv bLKaicov Kal dbLKOiV dvdp(o-

TTMV Kal TTpayixaTcav ol TTokkol boKOvcTL o"06 o/xoAoyeiy avTol 112
kavTois r/ dAA?/Aois;
AA. "HKLcrra vr] At", o 2(ri/c/)are?.

212. Tt 8e'; /idAio-ra Trept avT&v bLa(f)peadaL;

AA. HoAv ye. 5
2X2. OvKOur olofxai ye TTcoTrore' o-e tSeiy ouS' aKova-ai.
a(j>6bpa ovTti) bLa<ppofxivovs dvdpcaiTovs iTepl vyLLvS)V KaX
fxr], S)cm 8td raCra fxd^^jeadai re Kai diroKTiLvvvaL dXk-qkovs.
AA. Ov bfjTa.

2X2. 'AAAd Trept t&v 8tKata)i; Kai dStKcor eycoy ot8' ort, 10

Kal (l fxi] ((apaKas, dKr]Koas yovv dkk(i)v re TTokk<av Kal b

'Ofxrfpov Kal 'Obvaadas ydp Kal 'IAtd8os aKrjKoas.
AA. YldvT(i)s bi]TTOV, S) 2wK/)are9.

2X2. OvKOw raura 7rot7//jiard eari Trepl bia<f)opas biKaCoov

re Kat d8tK<oy; 5
AA. Nai.
2X2. Kat at /xdxat ye Kat ot OdvaTOL 8id ravrijy r7/r

bia<f)opdv TOLS re 'Axaiois Kat rois oAAois Tptoo-iy (yevovro,

Kal Tols fxvrfaTTJpaL roty r^? nT/yeAo^Trrj? Kal rw '08i;o-o-et.

AA. 'AAt/^t/ Aeyets. C

e 1 1 Koi iilKODv B : om. T W Proclus a 2 iw^Aois Proclus :

&\\oiT BT
iiac nAATI2N0S
212. Olfxai 8e koI tois fv Tavdypa ^AOrjvaicov tc Kal
AaKeSat/uovtcoi' Kal Boimt&v aTToOavova-i,, Kal tois va-Tepov
V KopoovcCa, iv oXs Kal b a-os iraT-qp [K\(Lvias] T(\(VTr]a-fv,
S ovb Trept (vbs aAAou 7/ 8ta</)opa 7/ TTfpl tov biKaiov Kal
a^LKOv tovs OavoLTovs Kol TCLs fxdxas TmroLr]KV rj ydp;
AA. 'AKrjOfj Xeyets.

212. TovTovs ovv <\)5>iiiv (TTLO-TaadaL Trepl Stv ovtoos

d a-(f)6bpa bLa(f)ipovTaL, wore dix(f)La^riTovvT(s dWrjkoLS Ta
a")(aTa a-(f)ds avTovs cpyd^ovTaL;
AA. Ov (f)aLveTaL ye.

2X2. OvKovv (is Tovs tolovtovs bLbaaKdkovs dva(f>pLS

5 ovs 6/uioA.oyets avTos /x^ dbivaL;
AA. "EotKa.
212. ITws ovv (Ikos ae etSeVat Ta bi^aLa Kal to. dbLKa,
rrepl &v ovtoo Trkava Ka\ ovtc p.aOu)V (f^aivrj TTap" ovbcvbs
OVT avTbs i^Vp(av;
10 AA. 'Ek ixev &v (tv Aeyets ovk eiKo?.
e 212. 'Opds av tovO' ws ov Kak&s etires, S) 'AXKi^Ldbr];
AA. To TToXov;
2i2. "Otl e/Lte ^r\s ravra \.iyiv.

AA. Tt 8e',* ov oo Ae'yets ws eyo) ov8ey ^itia-Taimu irept

5 rc3i' StKaticoy Kai dbiKoov;

2i2. Ov fxivTOL.

AA. 'AAA' lyriJ;

2X2. Nai'.

AA. nws 8?;;

10 2X2. *X28e eto-r;. edv o-e epoD/xat to ly /cal Ta 8vo TTdrcpa

TrAeio) eoTi, <^^o"ets ori ra 8vo;
AA. "Eycoye.
2X2. rfoo-o)

C 4 post Kopuvfla add. ffvfiPacnv Proclus ef ofs BT : 3t Proclus

KKiiviasB T om. Proclus : c 5, 6 ^ Sm^opci . . . irciroiriKiv B t^v:

Sia<t>opav . . . imroirfKtvai T
Proclus d^ avrhs'] avrovs Hirschig
4 ovSfv iiri(TTaft.ai Vcn. 184: (rvvtiriffTa/xat BTW: ovk f-iriffTa/xat
Proclus
 AAKIBIAAH2 ii2e

AA. 'Ei^i.

2X2. rioVf/jos ovv Tjfx&v 6 Xiyoiv otl ra hvo tov kvos 15

kv\ "nkiUn;

AA. 'Eyw.
2X2, OvKOvv iyo) /xey rjpdtTinv, <rv 8' aTTCKpivov;
AA. Nai'.

212. Ilfpi 8^ TOVToov p.G)V eyo) (f)aCvofxaL keycav 6 (paiT&v, 113

7/ (ry 6 aTTOKpiv6pLVOS
AA. 'Eyo).
212. Ti 8' ay eyco p.V epco/xat Trota ypdfxnaTa 'ZcoKpdTovs,
aif 8' i-TTr/y, TroTipos 6 kiyoiv; 5
AA. 'Eyoi.
2X2. "101 brj, kvl Ao'yft) eiTre* orai; e/acoTTjo-i? re Kal
aiiOKpLcn.^ yCyvrjTaL, itOTepo^ 6 keyoiv, 6 kpo)TS)V y) 6 0.1:0-

KpLv6p.Vos;
AA. 'O aTT0KpLv6p(V09, p.0Ly 80/cet, S) 2<i>K/3ars. 10

2X2. OuKoCi' apTL 8ta Trarros eya> /-lei' 7/ 6 epcorwy; b

AA. Nai.
2X2. 2u 8' 6 dTroKpLv6y.ivos;

AA. Ilcxru ye.

2X2. Ti ovv; to. XexdivTa TT^Tcpos r)ix&v (tprjKcv; 5
AA. i^a^^ojLtat fieV, o) ^coK/^are?, ex rwi; w/xoAoyT/jueVcoy

^yci.

2X2. OuKow ekix^V t^^P^ 8iKata)y Kai 081^0)1 ori 'AA,Kt-

fBLdbrjs 6 Kokbs 6 KkcLvCov ovk kTrCaraLTO, oXolto 8e, Kai

fxikkoL et? (KKkrja-Cav kkdihv a-vp.^ovkf.va-LV ^AdrjvaCois 7re/)i 10

uv ovbfv ot8er; ov Tavr 7/y;

AA. <l>atyerat. C
2X2. To Tov EvpLTTCbov dpa avp.l3aCvL, S) 'AAKt/3t(i87j*

a-ov rdbf KLvbvvevfLS, ovk kfxov dKr]KolvaL, ov8' ky<a elfJLi 6

a 4 fpufxai Olympiodorus tpS) koL vota B T tpwru Ka\ Kola

iroia : :

Proclus bl TarrisTWProclus; Ttavrhs rovXiyov^ 1)8 8ti

post oSiKmv B ante ittpi T
: C 3 ouk Proclus (cf. Eur. Hipp. 352) :

oAA' ovk B T
II3C nAATi2N02
ravra \iym>, akka (rv, e//c 8e atnS ixdrriv. Kal ixivToi
5 Kttt iv Acyeis. ixavmov yap kv v(a exets Tnxdpr)fia iin-
Xeipelv, S) ^ikTL(rT, hihAcrKHV a ovk o1(r6a, djixeXrjo-a?

IxavddveLV.
d AA. OijLiai ixiv, 0} 2,(aKpaTs, 6kt.ydKLs 'AdrivaCovs fiov-
kevecrdaL Kal tovs dkkovs "EAArjya? iroTepa bLKaLOTfpa
7] dStKwre/aa* tcl ixkv yap rotaOra riyovvTai bi]ka LvaL,

idcravTes ovv Trepl avTUiv crKO-novxTLV oiroTepa (rvvoCaei

5 Ttpd^acTLV. ov yap TavTo, oTixaL ecrrlv Td re bC^aLa Kal rcL

(rvix(fi4povTa, dkka irokkols br} ikv(riTkri(rV d8iK7j(racrt fxe-

ydXa dbiKijixaTa, Kal erepot? ye oijijiat 8tKata ipyacraixivoLS

ov crvvqveyKV.
2X2. Ti ovv; et ort /xdAio-ra (Tcpa ixev to. 8tKata
e TvyxdvL ovTa, erepa 8e to, (rvix(f)povTa, ov tC ttov aS (tv

otet TavT eiSeVat a (rvix(f)pL rot? dv6p(aTT0LS, Kal bC ort;

AA. Tt ydp K(jiikvL, w ^(aKpaTs; et /x^ /xe ai! ipri^ri]

TTap OTOV ^ixa6ov r) ottoos avTos r]vpov.

5 212. Otoi' TovTo Trotet?. ei rt ixr] 6p6&s Ae'yets, n;y)(dret

8e bvvaTov ov dirobel^aL 8t' ovirep kcCl to TrpoTepov koyov,

otet bi] KaLvd aTTa belv dKOveLV d7ro8et^ets re erepa?, ws'

roiy TrpoT4p(t)v olov crKevapCcov KaTaTTpnxixiv(tiv, Ka\ ovk4t

av (rv avTa dixTtCcryoLO, et /x?/ rty o-ot TKixr]pLov Ka6apov

114 Kat dxpavTov oio-ei. eycb 8e ^aCpuv edcras tcls (tcls irpo-
bpoixas Tov koyov ovbkv rJTTOv pi](roixaL iTodcv ixa6iov av rd
(rvix(j)povT kiTC(rTacraL, Kat oo-rts eo^riy d StSdo^KaAos, koi
iravT KiLva to, TTpoTcpov epcor&i /xta kp^arqcr^L; dAAd yd/)

5 brjkov 0)9 ets ravrdi; i^^eis Kai ovy^ e^ets d7ro8etat ou^' wy
i^(vp(i)v oto-^a rd a-vix(j)4povTa ovd^ w? ixa6(av. eTretS^ 8e

Tpv(f)ds Kal ovKT av f]b(ji)s Tov avTov yevcraLo koyov, tov-

Tov fxkv i& yaCpLV, eir' oXcr6a eire /x^ rd ^A6r]vaCoLS crvix-

C 4 ^/ti S^ cuTi? T /u StaiTjfli B ^fik 5 Stairt^

om. T Proclus
:

e 7 5); B 56? T
: e 6 J>/ B W :

oTro5ti|is t T*/>ay secl. Cobet

:

e 9 TeKfjffiptov om. Ficinus, secl. Ast a a ir<{ef B Proclus dir60(i' ;/ :

T Olympiodorus a 3 6 B Proclus om. T :

 aakibiaah:;: ii4b

<f)pOVTa' TTOTCpOV TaVTO. ((TTt St/Catdl Te Kttt avp.(f)povT b

17 Irepa, tC ovk aTrdbei^as; ei /xey ^ovkiL, pa)T&v p.e. uxnrep
iyui o-f, et 8e', xai avros TtI crfavTOv koyta 8te'^eA0e.
AA. 'A\X' ovK oi8a et otos r' av (trjv, Si ^<aKpaTS, Trpbs
cre SieA^err. 5
2X2. 'AAA', u>yadi, e/xe kKKkr^criav vopiLcrov /cat brjpiOV'

Kal e/cet rot cre 8e?jo-ei iva Kaa-Tov Tr^Cdnv. 7/ ydp;

AA. Not.
212. OvKoui' Tov avTOv em re oto'y re ctmt xara fxovas
TTcCdeiv Kal crvpLTT6kX.ovs Trept cSy ay ei8TJ, u>cnTp 6 ypap,- c
fxarioT^s eva t4 ttov jrei^et 'irepi ypapLpMT(av Kal ttoKXovs;
AA. Nat.
212. 'Ap' ovy ov Kat Trepi dpiOpov 6 avTos va re Kat
TroAAouy ireio-et;
5
AA. Nat.
2i2. Ovros 8' eo-rat 6 eiSwj, dpiOpriTiKos;
AA. Ilciyii ye.

212. OvKovv Kal crv diTep Kal ttoWovs otds re TTcCddv

et, raCra Kat iva; 10
AA. EIkos ye.

212. *'Eo-rt 8e ravra 8^Aor 8tl h olcrOa.

AA. Nat.
212. "AAAo rt ovv toctovtov povov 8ia0e'pet rou kv rai

^Tjjixo) prjTopos 6 kv Ti] rota8e crvvovaCq, ort o /uer ddpoovs d

TTiCdci Ta avrd, 6 8e Ka^' em;
AA. Kti^^ui/evei.

212. "I^t vvv, TTibi] Tov avTOV (f)aCvTaL TToAAovy re Kai

cz^a TT^CO^Lv, v p.0L p.p.\Tr)(rov Ka\ TTLXCpr]<Tov e7ri8et^ai 5

0)S TO bCKatOV VC0T OV (rvp.(f)pL.

AA. 'T^pKTTTjs ei, w 2(tfKparey.

C 2 Tf iroi; irfldd B Proclus re : Hirfidfv irov T : re irtidti irov W

c 4 ow B om. T Proclus
: c 9 Ka2 (r{> T Proclus : o-u B c 14 Sia-
ififpfi T Proclus : Sia<t>(p(iv B d 4 yvv BT : rolwv Proclus : Si/
yCi' ^'Ulg. d5 iftfieKfTriffov T Proclus : ej' pi.f\4Triaov B
114 d nAATilNOS
2X2. Nvv yovv v</)' vj3pe(t)i /xeAAco o-e Tiddav TavavTCa
ols (Tv ifie ovK fOeKets.
10 AA. Aeyf H-
212. ATTOKpCvov fjLovov Ta epcorco/mem.
C AA. M^, dAAa cri avTos Aeye.
2X2. Ti 8'; ovx ort /xciAio-ra (Sovkei TT(i<r9i]vai,;

AA. ITcirrcos St/ttoi;.

2X2. Ovfcow ei Ae'yets ort Tav6^ otiToos Ix^i, fxdXiar' av

6 etijs TTeTTeta-piivos;

AA. "E/xotye 8oKet.

2X2. ^AiroKpCvov St/* Kal ear /u^ avTos (tv (ravTov aK0V(ri]s
ort To. bCKaia Kal crvfi(]i4povTd kaTiv, dKKia ye kiyovTi fxi]

TTKrTevcrrfs.

10 AA. Ouroi, dAA' aTTOKpiTiov koI ydp ovhev oXofxat

/3Aa/3^(re(r^ai.

115 2X2. MarrtKos ydp ei. Kat //ot Ae'ye' tQv biKaCoov 0^s
erta fxev (rvfX(j)4pLV, ^via 8' ov;
AA. Nai'.

2X2. Tt 8e; Ta fjiev KoXd avT&v eiyai, rd 8' ov;

5 AA. nws roiJro ep(aTds;

2X2. Ei ris 7;8?7 crot ebo^ev aio^/)d /x^r, S^KOta de

TTpdTTCLV;
AA. OuK efxoiye.

2X2. 'AAAd TTovTa rd bCKaia Kal KaXd;

10 AA. Nat.
2X2. Tt 6' au rd KoAd; TTOTcpov TTavTa dyadd, ^ rd fxiv,

ra ov;
AA. Olofxai ^yoiyf, S) 2ctfKpares, erta t&v Ka\&v KaKa
etvai,

67 irain-oCTWProclusOlympiodorus: om. B aKovffrjs B Ol^rmpio-

dorus Stobaeus oKovris T Proclus
: e8 Ka\ add. Stobaeus om. :

BT ye add. BW
Proclus Stobaeus om. T Olympiodorus :

4 t( 5 T (ri Sai) Proclus om. B avTuy tlyai B ?> avruv T

: :

Proclus a6 ^JSij T Proclus Olympiodorus 5^j B ag /cai :

T Proclus om. B
: a r i i^ T Proclus om. B :
 AAKIBTAAH2 ii5a

212.'H Koi ala")(pa ayadd; 15

AA. Noi.
2i2. ^Apa Acyets ra TOLabe, otov ttoW.oI kv 7roXe/Lto) b
j3o-qd-)](ravTi (Taipia t/ oiKtiw TpavixaTa (KajSov /cat aTtidavov,
ol 8' ov /SoTj^Tjo-arres, 8eW, vyiets anrjKdov;
AA. Hayw /xey ovr.

2X2. OvKOvv Tr}v TOLavrqv fto-qdetav KaXrjV fxev Ae'yeis 5

KaTo, TTjv einxcCpr^a-LV tov (r&crai oi/s e8ei, tovto 8' eo-riy

avbpeia' r/ ov;
AA. Nat'.

2X2. KaK^y 8e' ye /cara rovy ^ardtrous re Kat ^A.Krj* ^ yap;

AA. Nat. 10
2X2. 'Ap' ovv ovK aWo fxh' rj avhpiCa, aXXo 8e o ^aj'aro?; c
AA. Hari; ye.
2X2. OvK apa <cara tovtov y ((ttl Kakbv Ka\ KaKov to
Toli (fjikoLs ^orjdcLv;
Ai\. Ov (f)aLVTaL. 5
2X2. "Opa TOLWv et,
f]
ye KaAor, Kai ayaOov, uxnrep Kal
irrav6a. Kara ti]V avbpiiav yap a)/uoAo'yets KaAor etrai r?/r

jior]9eLav' tovt ovv avrb (tk6t>l, Tr]V avbpeCav, ayadbv 7)

KttKov; (S8e 8e o-Ko'7ref ot) TioTip ^v 8e'^aio' o-oi etrat,

dya^a 7/ KaKci; 10
AA. 'Aya^a.
2X2. OvKovv Ta ^iiyLtrra /btaAiora. d
(AA. Nai.)
2X2. Kai r]KL(rTa t&v TOLovroiv 8e'^aio tv oTe'/jeo-dai;
AA. ns yap ov;
2X2. Oais oJi' Ae'yety Trept avhpfCa^; Iwt iroo-o) &y avroi) 5

8e'^aio (rTfp(rdaL;

b2 kralpif T Proclus It*/^ B b 3 o< T ov B b 9 ?Aotj ;

W
:

T Proclus ra f\Kt] B
: C I oS/ oiiK T Proclus ouk B :

C 3 KOTci ravrdv T Kar' aiiriv B Stobaeiis

: C 6 5<riro aJ B
Stobaeus &air(p T Proclus
: C 9 ri ir6rfpa tiv T iri^fpa &v Prcxrlus :

vSrtpov iLV Olympiodorus n&rtp' %lv Stobaeus itoripav B

: d a vai :

add. Dobree
115 d nAATHNOS
AA. Ovbe Cv^ "^ ^y^ b^ainr]v 8etAos <av.

2i2. "Ea-xaTov apa KaK&v (Tvai (tol 8oKet rj bciXCa.

AA. "E/xoiye.
10 SH. 'E icrou Tw re^mrat, ws eot/ce.

AA. <t>rjjui.
SIl. OvKoCy dav6.T(o re Kai 8et\ta IvavTi^TaTov (oiiir\ koX

avbpcCa;
AA. Nat.
e 2i2. Kai to, [xev p.akL(rT hv eimt j3ovKoi6 aoi, Ta be
i]Ki<TTa;

AA. Nai.
2i2. 'Ap' ort Ta pikv api(TTa rjyff, ra 8e KdKiara;
5 (AA. riai^u ye.

212. 'Ei rots api(TTOis apa (tv ^y?) avbpdav etmi Kar
rots KaKtVrots OavaTov.)
AA. "Eycoye.
212. T6 apa ^or}d(tv kv 7roAe'/Li(i) rots (f)CKoL9, ^ /uei'
10 KaXov, Kar ayadov Trpa^LV Ti]v rrji avbpLas, Ka\6v avTo
npocTfLTTas

AA. ^aLvoixai ye.

212. Kara 8e' ye KaKov irpa^iv Tr]v tov OavaTov KaKOv;
AA. Nat.
15 212. OvKovv (S8e biKaLov TTpo(rayopevLV kKd(TTr]v Tm>
TTpd^cuiv' etTTep ^ KaKW aTrepydC^TaL KaKi]v KaActs, Kai ^
116 ayadbv aya6i]v KkqTiov.
AA. "E/xoiye 8oKet.
2i2. 'Ap' oi!y Kal f/ dyadov, Kokov' if 8e KaKov,

alpryjpov;

d7 ^7ci) BT : ^T-ory* d 8 Ka.Kwv elvai (roi ^oku

Stobaeus
B : ffoi KaKhv ftvai SoKf7T Proclus
aoi SoKf7 KaKhv tlvai Stobaeus
;

e I fxa.\KTT' tiv B fia\i(Tra T Proclus

:
Stobaeus 64 cfT B T oiv :

Stobaeus 65 iravv yt ... 67 QdvaTov Stobaeus om, BT Proclus :

e8 tyuiyi B iravv 76 T : Proclus W

e 13 5e 7* T Proclus 5e :

B Stobaeus e 15 wSt SUcaiov B T SiKaiov 5 Stobaeus :

e 16 airepya.((Tai B Stobaeus fpyd^tTai T Proclus:

 AAKIBIAAH2 ii6a

AA. Nai. 5
2X2. Trjv ap' iv rw TroAe/ito) Tots (/)i\ois j3oi]diav Aeycoy
KttAj/y juer eirai, KaKi^v be, ovbcv biacfxpovToo^ Aeyets ?/ ei

TTpoaelTTCS avTi]v ayaOijv p.h', KaKi]V bi.

AA. 'AA.r;^^ ixoi SoKei;? Ae^yeir, w Sw/cpare?.

2!12. Ou8ei' apa tmv KaAwr, fca^' oo-oi' KaAo'r, KaKov, lo

ov5e rwi/ al(r\p5>v, KaO^ oaov ai(r\p6v, ayadov,

AA. Ov (f)aiVTai. b
2X2. "Eti Toivvv koX w8e (TK^xj/ai. oVrts xaAws Trpcirrei,

oux* fat ev Trpcirrei;

AA. Nai.
2X2. Oi 8' ev Trpcirroyres ovx (vbaCfxoves; 5
AA. riws yap od;
2X2. OvKoCr ivbaip.ovS bi ayadwv KTrja-iv;

AA. MciAicrra.
2X2. KroJyrai 8e raura roi eu Kat KaAws irpcLTTdp;
AA. Nai. o

2X2. To eS o/oa wpcirreii' ayadov;

AA. Ila? 8' ov;
2X2. OvKow KaAoi' 17 iv-npayia;
AA. Nai.
2X2. Tavroi apa ((f)dvr] rnxiv TrciAty aS KaAoV re Kat C
dya^c)!'.

AA. ^aCvfTai.
2X2. "Ort &y &pa ivpoijxfv koAoV, Kat aya^oy evprj^rofKV
Ik ye rovrov rou Xoyov. 5
AA. 'ArciyKT/.

2X2. T^ 8e'; ra dya^a (TV]i(^ipu r] ov;

AA. 2u/x(/)e'pei.

a8 irpofffjirejB Stobaeus irpouires T Proclus

; post xaKT)!'
ie add. oiiSa/tws Stobaeus b 3 ovxl koI B T ouk Olympiodorus :

b n tJ) yovy KoAwj irpa.miv Stobacus 04 /ca2 B Olyrapiodorus

Stobacus : re krJ T C 5 ^0701; B T irapaieiyixo.Tos Sto.
:

bacus
ii6c nAATX2N02
wXi. Mvr}ixov(Vi,s ovv irepl rSiV hiKamv 77ws <w/xo\oy7/-
10 (rafj.v;

AA. Ot/uat ye tovs to. hUaia Tipa.TTovra^ avayKalov

flvaL Kaka npaTTHv.
212. OvKovv Koi Tovs Ta Koka ayadd;
AA. Nai.
d 2ii. Ta bk ayada (rvfx^epdv;
AA. Nai.
2i2. Ta SiKaia a/)a, w 'AAKt/3ta8rj, (TVfX(p(povTd coTty.
AA. *'EotKey.

5 212. Tt ow; raura ov (tv 6 Key^av, y(o 8e 6 ipdiT&v;

AA. (PaCvofxai, ws eotKa.

2X2. Ei ow rts dvicrTaTai (TVfi^ovXiv^roiv etre 'A^i/vatots

6ir rieTrapr/^tots', olojxevos yiyv(acrKiiv Ta dtVaia Kai ra
a8tKa, ^T/o-fi 8' etyat ra dtKata KaKa ivCoTC, akko ri ^
10 KarayeA.({)?j9 av avTov, ^TretSr/Tre/) ruyxai^ety Kat (rv kiyaov
e ort ravra eo-rt 8tKata re Kal (rvp.(\)ipovTa;
AA. 'AAAa /xa rovs ^eovs, S 2&)Kjoare?, ovk otS' iyoiy^

ov8' ort \iy(ti, aAA' drexrcos eotKa droTTO)? iyovTi' tot^

ixiv ydp fxoL ^Tfpa 8oKet crov p(OT(avTos, tot 8' dAAa.
5 212. Etra tovto, w </)tAe, dyyoets ro Trddr]fj.a rt ((ttlv;

AA. ndw ye.

2X2. 0?et dy ovy, ei rts ep(aT(or] o-e 8vo d(/)^aA/xovs r/

r/oets exets, Kat 8vo x^^P''^? ^ T^TTapas, rj dAAo ri rwi'

rotovrcov, rore /xey ^repa av aTTOKpCvacrOai, tot 8e dAAa, f/

10 det rd avrd;
117 AA. Ae'8otKa /xey iy(ay rjbrf TtfpX ifxavrov, oljxai fxivToi

To. avTd,
212. OvKow 5ri oio-^a; tovt avriov;

09 o);uoA.(f7Tj(roj Stobaeus c 11 o?jua^ yc otn. Stobaeus rek

iiKaia B Stobaeus : SlKaia T C 13 koI B : om. T otiKoi/i' koI to{j ri
Kalpia Xtyovras Stobaeus (om. mox duobus versibus^ d5 xiywv B
Olympiodorus : Aeywi^efT d9 (/)^o-6j] </)?j(rl ci. Stallbaum tlvai
B : ciScVat T a 3 oI(rflo b t : olcrdas BT
 AAKIBIAAHS wj a

AA. Oljjiat iyioyc.

2X2. ITept wy apa aKoov TavavTia aTTOKpCvri, brjkov otl 5

Trepl TOVTUiv ovk otaOa.
AA. EiKos ye.

212. O^Ko2^ Kal Tt^pX T&v biKaC(i)v Kal abCKOiv Kai KaXciv
Kal alayjpGtv Kal KaKQtv Kal ayaOGtv koX avfji.(pp6vT(av Kal
/xt) aTTOKpivop.ivos (t>fis Trkavaa-OaL; eira ov brjkov ort 8ta 10
To pLT} dbivac Tiepl avToiv, bia Tavra Trkava;
AA. "E/AOiye. b
2i2. 'Ap' ovv oTJTco Kal ^x^^' ^T^^i-bdv tCs tl /xt) dbfj,
dvayKOLOv Tre/at tovtov irkavda-daL ttiv ^yjiv;
AA. YlSts yap ov;
2X2. Tt ovv; oXada ovTLva Tpoirov dva^rfa-rf ds tov ovpavov; 5
AA. Ma At' ovK ^y(oy.
2X2. 'H Kat TTkavdTaC crov 7/ 8o'^a Trepi ravra;

AA. Ov brJTa.
2X2. To 8' atrtoy oio-^a rj eyo) (\)pd(TOi;

AA. (ppdcrov. 10
2X2. "Ort, w (^iAe, ovk oiet avro kitCcrTaaOaL ovk cttl-

VTdpLVOS.
AA. Odis av TovTo Ae'yets; C
2X2. "Opa Kat ot> Koti'^. & fxrj eirtorao-at, ytyvcoo-Kets 8^

ori ovk iiTCa-TacraL, iTkava ircpl to, TOLavra; ooa-TTep -ffepi

3yf/ov a-KivaaCas oTada b-qTTOv ort ovk OLcrda;

AA. Yldvv ye. 5
2X2. noVepoi' ovv avTos TTpl ravTa bo^dCfts ottws \piri

a-K(vdC(LV Kal Ttkava, rj roi iTTLa-Tafx^Vio iTTLTpiiTiLs;

AA. Ovrws.
2X2. Tt 8' et kv vviX TTkioLs, dpa bo^dCois &v TT&npov
yjn\ Tov oXaKa eIff(o dyiLV r) ^fco, Kai 5re ovk et8a)S -TrAavSo d
&.V, r) r&) KV^ipvrirq iiTLTpiy^as dv rfovyCav dyoLs;

b a (fal (iel) ?x** Schleiermacher b3 toj5tou] toCto Ast

b 9 iyin T om. B : c 2 5i 8t T : 8<Jtj B
PLATO, VOL. II. 20
117 d nAATIlNOS
AA. Tu KVjQepyTjrrj.
212. OvK apa Trepi h ixrj oXffda Ttkavd., avirep dbfj^ on
5 ovK olcrBa;
AA. OvK lotKa.

2i2. 'Eyyoets ouy ori koX tcl ap.aprqp.aTa iv tt/ irpd^ei

8ta TavTr]v ttjv 6.yvot.av ecrrt, rrjy rou /x^ eJSoVa oieo-^at
i8emi;
10 AA. riwj au X^yets roCro;
212. ToVe Tiov T[i.\ii.povp.iv Ttp6.TTi.v, Srav ol(i>p.i6a

fibivai 6tl 'np6.TTop.iv;

AA. Na^.
e 22. "Oray 8e yi iToij tivS p.rf otoavTai elbevai, tlXAots

TrapaStSoacrt;
AA. U&s 8' ov;
212. OvKoCy ot rotoiJrot t&v pr} dhoTCov avap.ApTt]Toi
5 C^a^L hia To aAAots Trepi avTGtv kinTpiiTiiv;
AA. Nat'.

2X2. TtVes ovv ot ap.apTdvovTis ; ov ydp ttov ot ye eiSores.

AA. Ov brJTa.

212. 'E7ret8?) 8' ovd* ol etSoVes ovd^ ol t&v p.r} dboToiv

Il8 etSoVes ori ovk ta-aa-LV, ^ dK\oL kiiirovTai rj oi prj etSoVes,

ol6p.evoL 8' (ibevai;

AA. OwK, dAA' oSrot.

212. AvrTj apa r} dyvoia tQ>v KaK&v atrta Kai ?/ (TTOveC-

5 8torros dp.a6ia;

AA. Nat.
212. OuKOW Srai; 77 'Tre/si to. p.eyt.ara, t6t KaKOVpyoTdTr)
Koi aia-x^Carri
AA. HoXtl) yc.
10 212. T^
ovv; ^x^^^ /otetXw eiwetv biKalotiv re Kat KaAwv
Kai dya6S>v KaX (Tvp.(\>ep6vTUiV

e I 5e 76 T Ae^e B
: a 4, 5 Kol . . . d/xaOfa secl. Hermann
a4 Kal secl. Schleiermacher ^ secl. Buttmann
 AAKIBIAAH2 ii8a

AA. Ov brJTa.

212. OvKovv TTfpl ravra <rv (j>fis TrXavaa-dai;

AA. Nai.
2i2. Ei bi TT\av&, ap' ov brjXov (k tS>v qx7Tpo<rdV oti 15

ov [xovov ayvoeis to. ixiyiara, aXka Kal ovk etScbs otec avTa b
dbivai;
AA. Kivbvvcvoi.
212. Ba/Sai &pa, w 'AXxtjSifiSTj, oroy Tra^oy TtiirovOas'

6 eyo) dro/xa^e^ /xey okvw, o/xfos" hi, iTTei.br] ixovai ia-p,iv, 5

prjT^ov. afJLaOCa yap (rvvoiK^ls, oi /SeAriore, rr) eo^drr/, ws
6 Adyos o-ou KaTrjyopH Kal av aavTov' bto Kal arrety apa
TTpbs TO, TTOkiTlKa TTplv TTaLb^vdijVaL. TT7TOv6aS 8e TOVTO
ov av iMovos, aXXa Kal ol iroXAoi t&v TTpaTTovTOiv tcl Trja-be

Trjs TToXfOis, TTkr}v oXiyuiv ye Kat lo-cos tov aov iiTLTpoTTOV C

neptKAe'ov?.
AA. Ae'yerat ye' roi, o> 2<)cpares, ovk oiro tov avTop.6.Tov
a-o(f)6s yeyovivaL, dAAa TroAAoiy Kat o-o^ots a~vyyyov4vai,
Kal nvOoKKeCbrf Kal ^Ava^ayopa' Kal vvv Iri rr/At/coiSros 5

ciiv Adp.oiVL aijVa-TLV avrov tovtov ^vcKa.

212. Ti ovv; rjbri tlv etSey ao^ov otlovv abvvaTovvTa
TTOLrjaaL &kXov a-o(f)bv ^Trep avrds; c3o-7rep os (re ib^a^ev
ypdp.p.aTa, avTos t rjv cro(f)6s Kal ae eTTOtijo^e t&v re &AAcoz;

ovTiv' e/3oi/Aero* t/ ydp; 10

AA. Nai.
212. OvKOvv Kal oo 6 irap' iKfCvov iiadoiv ^AAov otds d
xe eoT/;
AA. Nat.
212. Kai 6 KLOapLarTr]s 8e xai o TraLboTpC^ris (aa-avrois;

bI ofi TW : om. B B toOto T

atrrei : b4 oTov T Olympio-
dorus iro7ov B
: b5 uivu] avrol Cobet b6 iffx^Tri B
Olj'mpiodorus : odtrxlcrri T b7 Kariryopf7 BT : /coTo/xoprvpc?
Olympiodorus b8 irphs BT : ^-ttI Olympiodorus c i 76 B
Olympiodorus : tcT 03 to B Olympiodorus om.T : c6 odrov
TouTow T : oirrotn-ov B C 7 iJSrj T S^ B : c 8 &<rKep B iffvfp T
:

c 10 81/TJJ'' B : 6i^a T c 11 vo/ Bt : om. T

20*
ii8d nAATilNOS
5 AA. Yldvv ye.
2ii.KaXoy yap brjTTOv riKfx-qpiov tovto rGtv fTna-Tafxivoiv
OTiovv Sti iiria-TavTai, imLbav Kal (i,\X.ov otoC t Si<nv
aTTohei^ai fmaTdfxivov,
AA. "EjLcotye SoKei.

lo 212. Ti ovv; cxeis eZTreiy UepiKXijs TLva iTTOLrja-ev a-0(f)6v,

aTTO T&v vioiv ap^dixvoi;

e AA. Ti 8' ei TO) UepLKkiovs vei ^\i6ia) iyevia-dr^v, S

S()K/oares/

212. 'AAXa KkcLvCav tov abv dSeX^w.

AA. Ti d' &v av KkcLvCav Ae'yois, p.aiv6iivov avdpanrov;
5 212. 'ETTetS^ tolvvv KXfLvCas piev ^iaCviTaL, roi) b^ Ucpi-
Kkiovs vL riKtdCo) iyeviadr)v, a-o\ rCva ahCav avaO&fxev, hi
Stl (re o^T(as eyovTa itipLopa;
AA. 'Eycb oi/xai airios ov iTpocriyjjiv tov vovv.
Iig 212. 'A\A.a t&v &Xko)v ^kdr^vaCcav 17 tG>v ^ivoiv bovKov
^ kkivdepov eiTre oorts ahCav Ix^* ^^^ '^^ IlepiKAe^ouy
a-vvov(rCav (ro(f>(aTpos yeyovivaL, &(nTp eyo) exw roi ei^Treiy

8ta rTJi; Z^^voivos TIv66bo)pov tov 'Io-oAoxou Kat KaAA^ay

5 Tov KakkLAbov, S)V kK(i,Tpos Z-qvoiVL fKaTov fxmy reAeVas
cro(j)6s re Kat ikk^ytjxos yiyovev.
AA. 'AAAct fxa AC^ ovk exo).
212. Etey rt ovv Stai^o^ Trepi a-avTov; iroTcpov iav ws
vvv ^x^'^ V iTTLfxikeLdv Tiva TroLHcr^aL;
b AA. Kotv^ ^ovk-q, o) 2<0K/)ares. KaCroL ivvo& arov

Itt6vtos kol (Tvyyu)pG)' boKovaL yap fxoL oi tcl ttjs TroAecoy

TTp6.TT0VTs fKTos 6kCyo)v aiTaCbevTOL ctyat.

212. Etra rt brf tovto;
6 AA. Ei fxiv TTov -^a-av TTeiraLbevfxivoL, ibiL hv tov im-
\LpovvTa avTOLS ain-aya^vCCfadaL fxad6vTa Kcn aa-Krf(ravTa

d6 TfKfx^fipiov TovTo B TOVTO TfK/jiiipiov T Olympiodorus

: e 4 &
secl. Schleiermacher et mox Xfytis e6 iiXielu BT: \i6ot Olympio-
dorus a 8 ^Si' B ihy Olympiodorus &/ T
: :b r Koiyi)
fiovX-fi Stephanus Koiy^ /3oi;\p B T
; b 5 &v rhy T : wTby riy B
 AAKIBIAAH2 iigb

UvaL 0)5 eir' adXrjTas' vvv 8' kitii.hr] koI ovtol IbLOiTiK&s

^XOVTii cXrjXvOaa-LV ^iri ra ttjs Ti6\m, tC Set aarKciv Koi

fxavdavovTa TTpdyixaTa ^x^lv; fyo) yap v oi8' otl tovtcov

Trj ye <pV(rL Trdvv ttoXv TKpiicroimL. C

212. Ba/Sat, olov, S) dpLare, tovt etprjKas* a>s dvd^LOV
Trjs ihfas KOL T&V dkko^V T&V (TOL VTTapXOVTOiV.
AA. T^ ndKLara Kal Trpbs tl tovto \4ycLS, o) SwKpares;
SX2. 'AyavaKT(a vtr^p re aov KaX tov e/xaurou p(t)Tos. 5

AA. TCb^;
2X2. Ei ri^L(a(ras tov dy&vd a-oi eivai iTpbs tovs (vOdbe

dvdp(a7Tovs.
AA. 'AXAa iTpbs TLvas ixrjv;

2X2. "A^ioy TOVTo ye Kal epia-daL dvbpa oioixevov fxcya- d

k6(f)pova LvaL.
AA. nSs Xeyeis; ov Trpos rovrovs /xoi o dyfav;
2X2. 'AAAa Koy ei TpLTjpr] bLvoov KV^epvdv /xe'AXov(ray
i;avjua)(ecy, r/pKet ar o-oi t&v avvvavTwv j3XTLa-T(o eirat tcl 5
Kv^pvr]TLKd, 17 raura /nei/ wou ay Seii' VTrapx^'^' dW^Ae-TTCS
8' ai' eis rovs a>s dAr/^ws dyraycoi^io-rds, dAA' ov^ ws rCy eZs
rois o-ui^aytorio-rds; &v brjTTov TTfpLycvfo-OaL ae ^ei toctovtov
&aT \xr] d^Lovv dvTayo)VL^(a6aL, dAAd KaTa^povr]6iVTas (tvv- e
ay(*)vCC(a-daL aoL TTpbs tovs TroAe/xtous, et 8t/ rw wri ye KaAdy rt

epyov dTTobfC^acrdaL bLavor] Kal d^Lov aavTovTC Katrr/s TrdAetos.

AA. 'AAAd fxkv br] Staroov/xat ye.
2X2. Yldvv aoL dpa d^Lov dyaTTav et t&v aTpaTicoT&v 5

/3eAri(oy ei, dAA' ou Trpds rois t&v drrtirdAcor r]yep.6vas

aTTo^XiTTCLV et Trore iK(Cv(av ^fXTCo)V yiyovas, a-KOTTOvvra

Kal da-KovvTa iTpbs (KiCvovs.

C 5 T6 BT : om. Olympiodorus troO Olympiodorus : rov trov

BT B Olympiodorus ifiov T
ifiavrov d.4 dAAt T
: &pa B :

d7 B
8' &;/ T e i a^iovy avraywvl^fcrdai B (ri'o'Ta7'if*<''^*
5e
: :

T ffvvayavi^fffdai
: (a;/T s. v. w")W 65 irot ipo B &pa (rot T :

Olympiodorus e 7 r iroTe scripsi 6ir6rf B T Sitj? Te Heindorf : :

(7fl ratione Ficinus) rl vort Ast : Yryoi^ar B T yfvoio Heindorf :

Stallbaum cum Ven, 184

i2oa nAATilNOS
120 AA. Aeyeis 6e rivas tovtovs, a> StoKpares;
Si2. OvK oicr^a ^juwy r?/!; hoKlv AaKe6ai/xoyiois re Kat
To) nydk(a /3a<nX.(l 'noXiiJ.ovcrav kKaa-TOTc;

AA. 'AXrjOfj Aeyet?.

5 2i2. OvKow eiTrep er j/ft)

^x^'^ r^ye^mv elvai Trjabe Tfjs
7ro'Aeos, Trpos tovs AaKebaLjjiovCoiv ^acnX.4as Kol tovs
Ilp(r&v Tov dyuiva riyovfxevos croL eii^at 6p6a>s hv rjyolo;
AA. KLvbvvVLS dXrjOfj kiyeLv.

2i2. OvK, tiiyadi, aAAa irpos MetStW ce 8et tov opTvyo-

b KOTTOV dTTO^XeVeiv Kat aWous rototJroi;? ot ra r?7s Tro^Aecos

TTpaTTeLV (TTLx^tpovaLV, iTL Tr}v dvbpaiTob^abri, <f)alV av

al yvvaLKs, Tpiya exoz^res kv ttj "^vxfj vtt' dixova-ias Ka\
ouTTco dTTOjSe^XriKOTes, ^tl 8e jSapl^apC^ovTes iXrjkvdaaL
5 KoAaKewoi^res Tr}v ttoXlv dAA' ovk dp^ovTes TTpos tov-
Tovs (T 8et, ovcnrep kiyu), jSkeirovTa cravTov brj dpLekelv,

Kal ixriTe p.av6dveLV ocra p.aOr\(Te(i)S e^erat, pAkXovTa Tocrov-

Tov dyStva dyonvLCecrdaL, pj}Te daKelv ocra Seirat da-Krja-eoos,

C Kai Trdaav TrapacKeurjy TrapeaKevacrixivov ovTUis UvaL im

TCL Tris TTokms.
AA. 'AAA', S) 2wK/)ares, SoKets /xeV /xot dkriOrj keycLV,
olixaL iievTOL tovs re AaKe8ai/xoyttoy (TTpaTriyovs kcCl tov
5 Ylepacav /3a<rtAe'a ou8ei' bLa(f)epLv' t&v akk(i)v.

2i2. 'AAA', S) dpLaTe, rr/y oXriaLV TavTriv crKoiTeL otav

exet?.
AA. Tov TTepL;
212.Hp&Tov iJLV TTOTepois dv OLL aavTov pidkkov ilTL-

d ixekriOrivaL, <\)o^ovixev6s re Kai olojxevos beivovs avTovs

etvaL, ri ixr};

a 6 tr6\im B ir^Mais &is T

: /cal touj] kqlI rhv Cobet
a9 opTvyoKdirov Olympiodorus Athenaeus scholiastes 6pTvyoTp6<t>ov :

BT b 2 ert T Olympiodorus evl B b 3 ^v B Olympio-

:

dorus ^irl T
: b 5 KoXaKiitrovTfs T KoXaKiiovns B :b 6 5i)
Madvig Se B T om. al.
: C i irapetrKevaa^/jifvov B irapa- :

W
:

(TKevaffdfjievov T Olympiodorus irapaa^Kevaff/xevov

: C 4 Tbj/ T
T&v B c 9 iroTepus B Olympiodorus : ir^Tepos T
 AAKIBIAAHS i2od

AA. AijKov OTL et bfLVovs oloCfj.r}v.

2i2. M&v ovv otet tl ^Xa^ricnaOaL eTri/xeAr/^els (tovtov;

AA. Ovhayi.<as, aXXa Kal yL^yaXa 6vr\(r(<T6aL. 5
212. OvKOVV kv ix\v TOVTO TOa-OVTOV KaKOV exL 7} oXt]<tls

aVTT}.

AA. 'AX-qOij Xeyets.

2X2. T6 hiVT^pov TOLVvv, OTL KOL \(/cvbris ka-TLV, K T&V

iLKOTUiV aK\j/aL. lO
AA. nws bri;

212. TIoTcpov etfcos afx^Cvovs yCyv^adaL (pvacLs iv yV-

vaLoLS y4vaLV rj fx^q; e
AA. AijKov oTL kv toIs yfvvaCois.
212. OvKovv Toiis v <j)vvTas, iav fcat ev Tpa<^G>aLV, ovrao
TfKiovs yCyviadaL Trpoj apTrjv;
AA. ^Av^iyKT]. 5
212. ^K\(/<aix6a brj, tols kKiCvonv to. ffp.Tpa clvtltl-

6ivT(s, "npGiTov /xer et boKOvaL <^avkoTip(iiv yev&v etmt ot

AaKbaLpLOvC(av kol Ilcpa&v /3acrtA^y. rj ovk tapifv ojs ot piiv

'HpaKAe'ous, ot 8e 'Ax^at/xe^i^ovs ^KyovoL, t6 8' 'HpaKkcovs T

y^vos Kal t6 'Ax^atfteVous ets nepcrea t6v Al6s ava(f)pTaL; 10
AA. Kat yap to fjfJXTcpov, S) ^WKpares', ety E,vpva(i.Kri, 121
t6 5' EvpvadKovs cty Ata.
212. Kai yap t6 rjixiTepov, S) ycvvaX^ 'A\KLJ3Ldbr}, eis
Aa^oAoi', 6 bk AaCbaXos ls "Hc/^atcrroy t6v Alos. 6XKol
To. pikv tovtoov aTr' avT&v dp^6.p.va (3aaL\rjs elaiv K /3a- 5
aLk(tiv p.\pL Alos, ol [Xv "Apyovs T Kal AaK^baCixovos,
OL Se TTJs n.paCbos ro dci, TToWdKis 8e Kat rTjs 'Aa^ay,
(So-Trep Kat vvv fffxcls 8e avroi t ZStoSrat Kai ol TiaTcpcs.
ct 8c Kai roi? 7rpoyo'i;ous a 8e'ot Kat Tr}v iraTpCba Evpvad- b
Kovs e7ri8etfat ^aAa/xiya rj rqv AlaKOV tov TL iTpoTepov

ds B : Ktt\ flT d 12 yiyvf<T0ai BT : yiviaBai Olympiodorus

3 rpaipuaiv T : yp<L<po><riv B 64 dptT^ji/ (^avayKtty Cobet 690/
5i ... e 10 ytvos Kcu T b (in marg.) : om. pr. B hi <re T
om. B
121 b nAATilNOS
Atyivav 'Apro^^p^ tw "Eip^ov, ttocrov h.v otet yeXoira
oi^kiiv; aA.A' 6pa fxri tov re yevovs oyKia ekaTTiapicOa t&v
5 avbp&v Kal Trj ^AAr/ r/)o0f}. r] ovk pa-OrjcraL roi? re AaKf-
baifxovLcov l3a(rLkva-LV &)? p.y&Ka to. viiap-^^ovTa, &v al
yvvaXKS brjixoa-Cq (f)vX.dTTOVTaL vtto tS>v ((popcov, Sttcos ds
bvvapLLv fxr} \d6r] e^ dXXov ycvopavos 6 ^aaLXevs 17 e^
C 'HpaKkeLboiv; 6 be Uepa-civ Toaovrov VTTcp^dkkeL, &a'T
ou8eis VTTo-^Cav cx^ei o)? e^ dkkov hv jiaa-Lkevs yivoLTo 7) e^
avTov' 8t6 ov ^povpeLTaL r/ /3a(rtA.ea)y yvvr] dA\' ^ vtto
cf)6j3ov. 7rLbav 8e yivr^TaL 6 Trat? 6 Trpca-jiijTaTos, ovTTfp

5 ^ dpyji, Trp&Tov pikv eoprcifouat Trarres ot ei/ rf/ jiacrLkccos,

wv av dpyri, etra ets tov dkkov yj>6vov TavTj] tjj rifxipq

/3ao-tAe'a)s yeviOkLa Tracra 6vl Kal eo/ard^et r) 'AcrLa' r}p.utv

d 8e yivofxivoiv, to tov KOiifxcoboTTOLOv, ovb' ol yLT0Vs (r<f)6bpa

TL ala-6dvovTaL, S) 'AA.Ki/3t(i8r;. fXTa tovto Tp(pTaL 6

TTOLS, ov^ VTTO yvvaLKOs Tpo(f)Ov okCyov d^Cas, dAA' vtt'

VVOV)(Oi)V ot hv boK&CTLV T&V TT^pL ^aCTLkia dpLCTTOL LVaL'

5 ols Td re dAAa Trpoa-TiTaKTaL TTLfXk(r6aL tov yV0fXV0V,
Kal oTToos OTL KaAAtoTos lorat fLr]yavda-6aL, dvaiTkdTTOVTas
TCL fxikr) Tov TTaLbos Kol KaTop6ovvTas' Kal TavTa bpSivTcs
e V fXydkrf TLfxr\ clo-lv. iiT^Lbav 8e eTrreVets yeVwj^rat 01
TratSes, eTrt tovs Xttttovs Kal ttl tovs TovTcav bLba^TKdkovs
(poLToia-LV, Kca ^ttI Tas difpas dpyovTaL livai. bls CTrra 8e
yv6p.vov t5)V tov TTaXba TTapakafxjSdvovcrLv ots Klvol
5 ^ao-tAeious iTaLbayct)yovs ovofxdCova-Lv eio-l 8e ^LkyfXV0L
Tlpa&v OL dpLO-TOL b6^avTS iv rjkLKCq Tirrap^s, 6 re cro-

cfxaTaTos Kal 6 bLKaL^TaTOS Kal 6 croi)(ppoviaTaTos Kal 6

122 dvbpeLOTaTos. S)V 6 fxv fxay^Cav re StSdo-Kct Trfv Zcopo-

b3 iprof epf 7 re vera B T &/ B T 5^ Stobaeus : b4 rov

BT : TtpTov Stobaeus c 2 &r Pa<ri\evs B Stobaeus : Pa<ri\fvs ftr
T C3 &\\' ^] aWi) B ^ T (suprascr. dAA.') : C7 ytve6\ia
T Olympiodorus yevtffia B : vaara T aTrao-a B /col eopTd(fi :

secl. Cobet da ti T: om, B ds t( t iAA.o T: toAAo B

d 6 Stj T om. B : e i evTeTfts (sic) B eireTtii (sic) T :

e 4 yfv6/j.evov Buttmann yevofievuv B T :

 AAKIBIAAH2 I22a

darpov tov 'HpofxdCov eori be tovto deav dfpaTTcCa

bibaa-Kei, 8e Kal to, ^aa-iXcKa, 6 be SiKaioraros dXr]6(V(iv
bia TTavTos Tov ^Cov, 6 be (Tia^povia^TaTos fJLr)b^ vtto fjLMs
dpyjiordai tG>v rjbov&v, tva eXevdepos elvai idCCvTai Kal 5
ovTOis ^aa-LXevs, dpyoiv TrpcoTov Totv kv avT^ dXX.a /x?)

bov\V(t)v, 6 8e dvbp(i,6TaTos d(f)ol3ov Koi dbed Trapaa-Kevd-

Coov, ws oray 8eto-r/ bovXov oirra' aol b\ a ^A\Kij3i.dbr],

UfpiKkrjs eTreoTTjo-e iTaibaycoybv tQ>v oIk^t&v tov d\p(.i6- b

TaTov VTTo yrjp<i)s, Z<aTTvpov tov &paKa. bifjkdov bc Koi
TTjv dXXrjv dv croi. tS)v dvTaycovLa-T&v Tpo^f^-qv re Kol TTat-
b^Cav, ei p.i] TTokv ipyov r\v koX dpi.a TavB' iKavd br]\S)aai
K(u, ToXKa oaa tovtois dKdkovOa' t^s be aijs yereo-eft)?, 5
0) ^AXKi^idbr], Kal Tpo(f)rjs Kal TratSetas, r] dkkov otovovv
Adr]vaC(i)v, wy Ittos et7reti> ovbivX \xi\iL, et /xt/ et ris
ipaarrjs aov rvy^arei (av. ei 8' av e^eAets eis ttXovtovs
diToj3K\ffaL Kal Tpv(j)as Kal iadrJTas Ip^aTCcav &* eA^eis kol c
]xvp(t)v d\oL(f)ds Kal OepaiTOVToov TTk-qdovs dKokovOCas Trjv

re dkkrjv djSpoTr^Ta Tr]v Ylpa-&v, aio-^vr^etT/j dv im o-eairru),

ala-66fX(vos daov avToiv eAAetTrety. et 8' av e^eAT/o-ets eZs

(r(i)(f)po(rvvr]v re kul Koa-fjLL^TrjTa dTTOJBkiyf/aL Kal ivyip^Lav 5

Kai evKoAtay Ka\ fX(yako(f)poavvr]v Kal cvTa^Cav kol dvbpeCav
Koi KapTepCav Kai (f)Lko7TovCav Kal (f)LkovLKCav Kal (f)ikoTLp.Cas
Tas AaKfbaLfiovCoov, 7rat8' dv r]yr](raLO a-avTov iTdaL Tols
TOLOVTOLS. et 8' av tl Kal TrAovro) irpoo-exeis xai KaTa d
TovTo oiet rt eti^ai, /x7/8e tov6' rjfxlv dppr]Tov eoro), idv iTios

aXa-6rj ov et. tovto p,v ydp et e^e'Aets (ets) tovs Aaxe-

baLfxovCoov TTkovTovs Ibdv, yv(a(rr] otl TTokv Tdv6db t5)V
(KL eAAetTret* yrjv fxkv ydp da~r]v i\ovaLV r^s 0' cavrwy 5

Kat Meo-o-T/i^r/s, ovh* dv iXs dfX(f)La-^r]Tr]a-iL TU)V rrjSe 7rA7/^et

a 7 irapa<TKfvd((Dv] vapaffKfvd^u Schleiermacher b7 jueAet B :

/ucAAci T b
8 ideKfis T
Olympiodorus : i$f\o(s B 040?-
ffd6fifvosTW: (U(Tday6/jL(vos B iB f\iiff tts BT : ^flf A,^<rioj Olympio-
dorus idfKfis Heindorf
: d3 ds add. Schneider d5 7^1'
T Olympiodorus : rijv B : yrjs ci. Stallbaum
I22d nAATiiNOS
0116' dperf), ovb' av avhpa-nohbiv KT^qcrci. rSiv re aKKoiv koX
Tutv l\(t)TtKa)V, ovbc ixrjv tTnrcav ye, ovb^ ocra aXXa jiocrKri-

e juiara xara MecroT/yrjy i;e'fierai. aXka ravTa fxiv iravTa ec3

yaip^LV, yjpva-Cov 8e koI apyvpiov ovk eoTLV (v Tia(ri.v "EA-

\r}a-i.v ocrov iv AaKe8at/xori ibtq' TroAXas yap rySrj yeveas
kla-ipy^Tai fxkv avTocr^ e^ a-nAvTbiV t&v '^Ekkrivcov, irok-

5 koLKLs 8e Kal ex rcui; ^apjidpoov, ^4p\(TaL 8e ovba\x6a-i,

123 dXA' drex^rtSs Kara ror Aio^wttou fxvdov ov rj dXwTrrj^ Trpos
Tov kiovTa eiTrey, Kat rou eis AaKe8ai/xoya vofji.La-fw,Tos eio--

loi/ros juei' ra t;(rrj ra eKeio-e TTpafxfXva 8^A.a, k^LovTos

8e ovbafxfj av tls 1801. too-re e3 yjnj eiSeVai ori Kat ypva^
5 Kai dpyvpia ol iKei 7rAouo"Wdraroi eto-ty rcSi; 'EAATjycoy, Kat
avT&v (KCLVoov 6 /Sao-iAeus* Ik re ya/) raii' tolovtociv fxiytaTaL
krj^CLS Kal 7rAeto-rat eto-t rots ftaaLkevcrLv, tl 8e Kai 6

jSaa-LkLKos (f)6pos ovk okCyos yCyvTaL, bv reAouo-iy ot AaKe-

b baLfxovLOL rots jSao-iAeucrty. Kai to, /xer AaKe8at/u,oytcoy ws
TT/aos 'EAArjvtKovs fxv TrkovTOvs p.iydka, o)? 8e Ttpos tovs
Ilepo-iKous Kat roC iK^Cvcov fiaa-Lkiois ovbev. eiret iror'

eyto) ^Kovaa dvbpbs d^toTrto-rov rwy dva^e^rjKOT^av napd

5 ^acTLkia, 65 e(/)T7 irapekdeLV \(apav Tidvv TroAAr/y Kat dya^Tjy,
eyyii? rifXpr}(rCav 6b6v, rjv Kakclv tovs k^nLyoipCovs (f^vrfv

Trjs jSacriAecos yui^atKos* etmi 8e Kai dAArji^ ^y av KaAeio-^at

C KakvTTTpav, Kal dAAous ttoAAous roTrous KaAous Kai dyaOovs
ils Tov Kda-fxov ^ripr]fXVovs tov ttjs yvvaLK^s, Kal ovofxaTa
exety Kda-Tovs tS>v t6ttu)V dTTo kKdaTov t&v Kda-fxoov. &aT
olfxaL eyw, et ris etirot rrj ^acrLkiiiiS fxr]TpC, S^p^ov 8e
6 yvvaLKL, ^Afxrfo-TpLbL, otl v via Ixet aov ro) vet dvTLTdT-
Ta-6aL A^LVOfxdxrjs v6s, ^o-tl KoV/aos to-cos d^tos Plv5>v
fj

iTVTr]K0VTa et Trdvv ttoAAou, roi 8' vet aur^s y^s Tvk^dpa

e3 . yeveks T iroWats .
KoXKa.s . . yevea7s B
: 64 avrotre B . .

avrhs Tavro7s Olympiodorus

: a i tv . . . Sbz eiirtv secl. Schanz
a 3 Ta iKutre rerpanfiiva secl. Hirschig rerpaixfi.eva : yeypafi/xfva T
B a 6 ouTwi'] ad Schanz rt yap r&v re yap wv pr. B T : ;

rfrrdpaiv D C 5 ?x** ""O" T x*'* "^ ^ :

 AAKIB1AAH2 123C

^EpxM(Ti.v ovbi rptaKocria, Oavixdarai av oTia Trore 7Ti(rTV(ov

iv Via iyj^i ovTOS 6 'AkKi^tdbr]^ Toi ^ApTO^ep^rf biayaivi- d
^eo-^ai, KOLL olfxai av avrqv e^-Treiv otl ovk ^0-0' ora> aAAw
TTia-TCVuiv ovTOS dvTfp iTivyjEi.pei irkrjv kTiip.^Kiia re Kat

O"o0ia' raSra ydp p.6va d^ia koyov kv "FtXkrja-LV. eirei et

ye TTvdoiTO OTi ^AkKLJSLabrjs ovtos vvv eTTixftpei Trp&Tov 5

)uey errj ou8e7rco yeyoyws (rcfiobpa itKoo^LV, eTretra Trai^ra-

TTaa-LV aTTaLbevTos, TTpos 8e rourots, rou ipaaTov avT(o

\4yovT09 oTi XPV TtpS>Tov ixaOovTa Kal iTLp.\r]6VTa avTov

Kal dcTKricrairra ovTdis UvaL bLay(avLovp.Vov /Sao-tAei, ovk e
e^e'Aei, oAAa (()r](TLv k^apKilv Kai ws ^X^*' 0'/^^ ^^ avTr]v
6avp.d(TaL re Kai kpicrdaL' " Tt ovy iror' eoriy orw Trto-revet
To p.(LpdKLovr ci ow X4yoLfj,ev ort KaAAet re Kat jxeyeOiL
Koi yiv(.L KoX TTkovT(o Kal (f>v(TL TT]S ^jrvxv^' r]yr]craLT dv 5

f]]w.s, w 'AAKtj8ia8?7, fiaLVicrdaL Trpos tcl irapa a-(f)La-LV diro-

^k^yj/aa-a TrdvTa to. TOLavTa. o7ixai b^ Kav Aa/u7rt8w, Tr]v

A(>}Tv\Lbov ixV dvyaTfpa, 'Apx.t8a/xou 6e yvmtKa, "AytSos 124
8e ]xr]Tipa, o\ Trayres /3ao-tA^s yeyovaa-LV, Oavfxda-aL dv Kal
TaTjTi]v ets Ta TTapa (T(()L(tlv vTrdpyovTa diTO^ki-^aa-av, et av
kv v(a e^ets rw vei avTrjs bLayoavL^ea-^aL orjTca KaK&s r]y]xlvos.

KaiTOL ovK aiaxpov boKet etyat, et at t&v TTok[x[(av yvvalKes 5

^fkTLOV TTcpl r]]X(av btavoovvTaL, oXovs XP^l ovTas cr^picrLV

CTTLX(i.p(LV, r] f]]X'LS TTpL f]]x5)V avTcov; dkk\ 6i ]XaKapL,

ttl66]Xvos (]xol re Kat rai iv AeA^ots ypdju/xart, yvS>6L

(ravrdv, otl ovtol f]]xlv (iaLV dvTiTTakoi, dAA' ovx o{>s av b
oief &v dAAo) fxkv ov6' dv kvl TTepLyV0L]X6a, et /xt/ Trep

TTL]XkC(i ye dy Kal TxviI' ^v av et dTTokL(f)6r]a-r],

Kal Tov 6vo]xaaTos yVa6aL d7TokL(f)6r]a"r] V "EkXr^ai

dI ovros B : ovrws T d3 d)/rjp B : S ii^p T d 5 oKKiPidSris

T : j a\Ki$idSr}s B ea out^' B : om. T 63 ina-Tevfi recc. :

vKTTevoi BT a I \e<i)TvxiSov T :
5' vrux^Soi; pr. B XtvTvxiSov b
:

a5 Ii/oi 1 ot T Olympiodorus : flvai B a6 irepl fiij.uv Stapoovvrai

B : Siavoovyrai irepl r]fiwv T b i riM-^v T Olympiodorus : om. B
b2 eJ 8'' wep B: el fjLijT b3 7 &/ scripsi : re tivBT : re Schanz
b4 ovofiaffrhs T Olympiodorus : 6v6fiaros B
I24b nAATXlNOS
5 re Koi ^apl^dpoLS, ov fj.01,
boKels epav ws ou8cts ^Wos
akXov.
AA. TCva miv xpri ttiv k-ni.p.iXiiav, S) "^ciKpaTcs, ttol-

eiaOai; Ix^*^ (^yi^a-acrdai; iravTos yap pJaWov (oiKas

aXrjOrj elprjKOTi,.

10 Si2. Nai* aWa yap koivt] j3ovkri ^tivl TpoiTia hv otl

C j34\TL(rT0L yVOLp.da. eyo) yAp tol ov Trept ixkv (tov Xeyoo ws
Xpr] TTaLbivOrjvaL, TnpX ipMV 8e ov' ov yap eo"^' oTta (tov

bLa(f)poi ttAtji/ y' kvi.

AA. Tlvl;
5 2X2. *0 (TTLTpOTTOS 6 e/jtOS ^i\TL(t}V ioTL Kal (ro<f)(OTpOS

7/ ne/3lKA.^S 6 (TOS.
AA. Tts ouTos, o) SwKpares;
212. 0eos, aj 'AAKt/3ta8rj, ocnT^p (tol /xe ovk eta TTpo
T^(r8e T^s rifiipas bLoXiyOrivaL' & kol TTLcrTV(av kiyui otl ?/

lo iiiL(f)aveLa bC ovbcvbs aAAou o-ot eorat r/ 8t' e/xou.

d AA. riat^ets, S ScoK/aaTes.

2X2. *'Io'a)S' Aeyo) fxivTOL akriOr], otl eirt/xeAeias deofieda,

/xaAAoy /xey TrdrTes 6.vdp(iT0L, aTap v(a ye Kai /xoAa (r(f)6bpa.

AA. "OTt /Aey eyw, ov \//^ev8r/.

5 2X2. Ov8e /x^f oTt ye eyw.

AA. Tt ow ay TTOtot/xey;
2X2. OwK aiToppriTiov ovbi ixakBaKL(rTiov, S) eTat/oe.

AA. OvTot bri TTpiTTL y 0) 2(tfK/)aTes. ,

2X2. Ov ydp, akka (TK^TTTiov KOLvr}. KaC p.OL Ae'ye*

e (^a/xei' ya/3 8?/ ws dpto-Tot ^ovkicxOaL yeyec^at. ^ y(i/);

AA. Nat.
2X2. Ttra dp^Triv;
AA. Arjkov OTL rjvTTep ot avbpes ol dyaOoL

b lo Kon/^ jSovX^ Stephanus : Kotvfj /3ov\$ BT c6 6 o-(Js BT

6 <rbi flroj Proclus d5 ^70; B : iyii Stofiai T (sed Seo/tot extra
versum) (16 &y iroto7/ic>' BT
voiwixfv Cobet
: Sij iroioifjiev Schanz
W
:

d7 OKoppriTtov corr. Ven. 184 iiropriTtov T Olympiodorus &jro- :

W
:

KvrtTfov B et in marg. ixaXOaKiffTfov T Olympiodorus /xoAa- :

KiffTeov B e I 5^ B Olympiodorus om. T &>j T Olympiodorus

: :

B
 AAKIBIAAH2 w^e
212. 01 tC ayaOoi; 5
AA. Ar]kov OTL oi TTpaTTdV to. TTpdyixaTa.
2X2, Uoia; apa ra iTrwi/ca;

AA. Ov hi]Ta. _

2X2. ITapa tovs iinnKovs yap hv fjixtv;

AA. Nai. 10
2X2. 'AAA.a to. vavriKa keycis;
AA. Ov.
2X2. ITapa tovs vavriKovs yap hv fjpiev;

AA. Nai'.

2X2. 'AXAa irola; h tCvs Trp6,TTov(riv 15

AA. "AiTip ^A6r]vai(av 01 koXoI KayaOoi.
2X2. KaXovs 8^ Kayadolvs Xeyeis tovs (f^povifxovs rj tovs 125
a<f)povas;
AA. Tovs <f)povifxovs.

2X2. OvKovv h (KatrTos <f)p6vifxos, tovt ayados;

AA. Nai'. 6
2X2. *0 8e a(f>p(jiiv, Trovrjpos;

AA. Ti(as yap ov;

2X2. 'Ap' ovv 6 (TKVTOTOfxos (Ppovijxos ets vTTo8r]fxdT(av
pya(riav;
AA. Yldw ye. 10
2X2. 'Aya^os ap' eiy avrti;

AA. 'Aya^os.
2X2. Ti 8'; eis l/Liaria)y ipyacriav ovk a(pp(tiv 6 (rKv-
TOTOjXOS;
AA. Nai. 15
2X2. KaK09 &pa cls tovto; b
AA. Nai.
2X2. *0 avros &pa TOVT(a ye rai Aoy<i) KaKOS T /cat

dya^os.
AA. 4>a^yerai. 6

e6 01 T Ol^rmpiodorus ; oloi B a 11 ai>rd B : toSto T

t25b nAATilNOS
212.'H ovv kyL^ Tovs ayaOovs avbpas eTvat mi KaKovs;
AA. Ov 8r/ra.
212. 'AAAa Tivas ttotc tovs aya6ovs Aeyeis;
AA. Tovs hvvafiivovs iycoye 6.pxi.v (v Tjj 7ro\i.

lo 212.Ov Stjttou iTnT(av ye;

AA. Ov brJTa.

2X2. 'AXA' avdpiairuiv;

AA. Nat'.

212. 'Apa Kapi.v6vT(av;

16 AA. Ou.
2i2. 'AAAa TrXfovroiv;

AA. Ov (^rj/xi.

2i2. 'AWa 6cpi(6vTOiv;

AA. 0(5.

C 212. 'AXA.' ovSev -noiovvTmv ^ ti iroioijvTaiv;

AA. IIoLovvToiv \4yo).

212. Ti; -ireipci) Kal e/xoi STjAwo-ai.
AA. OvKow T&v Kal (Tvp.^dK'K6vT0iv kavTois koI \poi-

5 fxivoiv dXATjAois, &cnTcp rjfxeTs ^<a\xev h Tois ttoX^tiv.

212. OvKovv av6p<aiT0iv Xeyets apx^LV avdpiaiTOLs XP^"

jueVcoi';

AA. Nai.
212. 'Apa iceAeuo-TcSy xpoipAvoiv epeVais;

10 AA. Ou 8?7ra.

212. Kv^epvrjTtKri yap avrr] ye dperTj;

AA. Nai.
212. 'AAA' av6p(aTT0iv Ae'yeis &px^*^ avkqT^v, avdpiaTTOis
d rjyovjxdvoiv (abrjs Kal xRf^H^voiv xopeurats;

AA. Ov 8^ra.
212. Xopo8i8aa-KaAiKT) yap a^r] y av;
AA. Hdvv ye.

b6 ^ BT : T? Olympiodorus AeVtis BT : Ka\o7s Olympiodorus

c4 T&jc Kol BT : Koi ruv Olympiodorus c 1 1 KvfiepyrjTiKii B :

KvfiepvriTMTJs T
 AAKIBIAAH2 lasd

2X2. 'A\A.a ri Trore Aeyeis yjponiiixav avdpdiTrm' avdpta- 5

TTois olov T (XvaL ap)(jEiv;

AA. KoLVitiVovvTOiv eyuiye A,ey6o TroAireias Koi (rv[i.-

^aXK6vT0}V TTpos dAAr^Aous', tovt(*)v apy^iv tG>v (v ttj

tt6\l.

2X2. Tis ovv avTT] rj Tiyyr]; axnrep av (i cre epot/xTjr 10

iraAiv To, irvvbr], KoivoiVovvTcov vavTiXias (TiCcrTaa-dai. ap\(iv

tCs TToifi T^xyr};

AA. KvjSepvrjTiKrj.

2X2. KoivoivovvTOiv 8' <^rjs, b>s vvvbr] kkiyiTo, tis Itti- e

a-T-qjjLr] ttokl apyiiv;
AA. "WvTTip av apTL lAeyes, ^ xopohLhaa^KdkCa.
2X2. Tt 8e; TroAtreias kolvo}vovvto)v Tiva KaAeis eTTi-

a-Tr]fJLr]v; 5
AA. Ev^ov\Cav fyo)ye, w ^wKpares.
2X2. Ti bi; ]x5iv aj3ov\Ca boKcl eimi rj t&v KV^pvr]T!av;
AA. Ov bfJTa.

2X2. 'AAA' v^ovkCa;

AA. "E/ixotye SoKet, eTs ye ro o-w^eo-^ai TTk^ovTas. 126
2X2. KaAws Ae'yets. ri 8^; ^i^ o-i Ae'yets rvjiovkCav,
eis rt ioTLv;

AA. Eis ro afxeivov rqv 7t6Klv bLOLKHV Kal a-taCia-OaL.

2X2. "A.p.^Lvov 8e 8io'iA:etrai /cai o-oi^erat rtr^os iTapa- 5

yLyvofjJvov rj aTToyLyvofiivov; ooa-iTep hv ei ou //e epoto-

""AfjLeLvov bLOLKUTaL a-Qifia KaX a-(^(TaL tCvos TTapayLyvofiivov

fi aiToyLyvofiivov; " eCiTOLfx hv otl vyL^Cas /xev iTapayLyvo-

fXvr]s, v6a-ov 8e aTToyLyvofiivrfs. ov Ka\ crv otei ovToas;

AA. Noi. b
2X2. Kai et fi av fpoLO' " TCvos 8e "napayLyvofiivov
&fi(ivov ofjLfjMTa;" otaavTOis elTTot/x' hv 5tl 6\(r0)s fxkv iTapa-

yLyvofjxvr^s, ru^Ao'r7/ros 8c aTToyLyvofiivrfs. kol ojTa 8e

e2 rotc7 B : iroiuv T a7 ^ioiKfirat . . . (r<p(frai B : SioiKt7adai

. . . <T(^if<r$ai T ff(&ijiara T : ffufia B b2 Kapayiyvontvov B :

om. TW
I26b nAATilNOS
5 K(ti(f>6Tr]T0S ixV aTtoyiyvoixivqi, aKorjs 8e iyyLyvofjJvrjs
)3fXTui) T yCyvTai Kal 6,ixlvov depaTTcijeTaL.

AA. 'Ope&9.
212. Ti 8e b-q; irokis tlvos TrapayLyvofievov xat aTto-
yLyvofxivov ^eXTLCov re yCyvcTaL Kal (ifjieivov depaire-^eTaL
lo Kal bLOLKelTaL;
C AA. 'Ejbtol ixev boKeX, w ^(aKpaTcs, otov (pLkCa fiev
avToXs yCyvrjTaL Trpbs aXXrfkovs, to fXLoreLV b^ koI crTacrLaC^Lv
&,TroyCyvrfTaL.

2X2. 'Ap' ovv ^LkCav kdycLS ofxovoLav rj bLxovoLav;

5 AA. 'OfxovoLav.
212. Aict tCv ovv Texvrfv ofxovoovcrLV ai TT^kfLS irepL

apLdfxovs;
AA. Aia Trfv apL6fxr]TLKrjv.

2X2. Tt 8e ol i8ic5rai; ov 8ia 7^y avTrjv;

lo AA. Nai.
2X2. OvKouy Kal avrbs avrZ iKa^rros;
AA. Nai'.

2X2. Ata TtVa be Ti\vr]v eKaaros auros ovrw ofxovoeL

d TTepl (TTrLdafxrjs kol Trrixcos oiroTepov fxeiCov; ov bia rrfv

fxerprfTLK-qv;

AA. Ti fx-qv;

2X2. OvKovv Kal oi tSiwrat dAATjXots ai ot 7r6kLs;

5 AA. Nat.
2X2. Tt be; Trepl crradfxov ov\ dxrat/rtos;

AA. <l>jj/xt.

2X2. ^Hi 8e brf (tv keyeLS 6fx6voLav, tCs ecrrL koll Trepl

Tov, KOL tCs avT-qv T^xyr) irapairnevd^eL; xat apa iJTrep TroAei,

lo avTrj KOL LbL(oTr), avT& re Trpbs avrbv Koi irpbs &kkov;

Ca rh iiiffuv 5^ B rh Se ixiffflv re T
: C 13 %KMTros avrhs avrf
B : atnhi air^ eKaffros T : ahrhs kavrQ Olympiodorus d 6 (rraOfiov
T : <rra0fiohs B d 9 avriiv T Olympiodorus : oS t^v B tx>^
Olympiodorus al. rexi^f B T ^irp (vel <Jirep) 7r<JA.i T Olympio-
W
:

dorus Trcptfl-oXct B ffwfp ir6\ei

: d 10 airii
: ci. Bekker : avrii
B ouT^ T Olympiodorus oSttj vulg.
: :
 AAKIBIAAH2 I26d

AA. EIkos ye roi.

212. Tis ovv iari,; fxri Ka/Ar/s airoKpivofJLfVOs, aXXa
npodvfxov (Itklv. e
AA. 'Eyo) fj,v o7fmL <f)ik(av t Aeyew^ Kal ojxovoiav,
ijvnep TTaTrjp re vov <f)LKa>v oixovo^l kox fXT^rqp, Kal abk<f>6s
abeXcj)^ Kal yvvr] avbpl.
212. Otet hv ovv, S ^ AKKL^Laht], avhpa yvvaLKL Trepl 5
Takaa-Lovpyias hvvaa-daL ofxovoeLV, tov fxrf iTtLaTap.^vov Trf

iTtLorafxivri;

AA. Ov hrfTa.
212. Ovbi ye 8et ovbiv yvvaLKilov yap tovto ye fxdOrffxa.

AA. Nat. 10
212. Tt 8e'; yvvrf avbpl Trepl oTrAirtK^s bvvaiT av 127
6fxovoLV fxrf fxadova-a;
AA. Ou 8^ra.
212. 'Ai;8petoy yap TodTo ye ta-(i>s a5 </[>afr;s &y eimt.
AA. "Eycoye. 5
212. *EoTiy &pa tcl fxev yvvaLKeta, tcl Se dySpeta fxaOi^-
fxaTa KaTa tov aov koyov.
AA. nws 8' oil;
212. OvK &pa ly ye rovrots lo-rti; ofxovoLa yvvaL^l Trpbs
avbpas. 10
AA. Oi.
212. Ov8' ^pa </)tAta, etTrep ^ <^t\ia ofxovoia rjv.

AA. Ov (f)aCvTaL.

212. *Ht apa at yvratKes ra avrwv TTpdrTOvarw, ov

(^Lkovvrai VTTO t&v avbp&v. 15
AA. OVK ^OlKV. b
212. Ov8' apa oi &vbpS vtto T(av yvvaiK&v j| ra
avrSi'.
AA. Ov.

6 2 Te] crt ci. StaUbaum : re (^x*'") Schanz: fort. 7^ eg ;y B

Olympiodorus om. T :

PLATO, VOL. II. 21

I27b nAATilNOS
5 2X2. Ov8' ev 6,pa TovTri otKowrai al Tro^Aeis, OTav to.

avT&v Ka(rTOL irpATTUicnv;

AA. 07/xat ^yooyc, S) SwK/aares.
212. n&)s Xeyeis, </)tAtas /ix^ irapoija-rjs, rjs ecj^afxev ky-

yiyvop.ivr]s eS oZKeto-^at Tas jroA.ets, 6.KkoiS h ov;

lo AA. 'A\A.d juot SoKet koX Kara tovt ovtoIs (f>i\ia

kyyCyvio-daL, otl to, avT&v kK&TepoL TrpaTTova-LV.

C 2X2. OvK apTL yv vvv 8e Ttm av kiyeLs; 6p.ovoLas f*??

kyyLyvopAvris <})LXia cyyCyveTaL; rj olov 6' 6p.6voiav kyyC-

8' ov;
yvio-daL [Trept TOVTOiv] Stv ol p.v ta-aa-L ircpl tovt(ov, ot
AA. ^AbvvaTOv.
5 2X2. AtKata 8e TrpaTTova-LV v abLKa, otov to. ovt&v
iKaa-TOL TTpdTTOia-Lv;
AA. AiKata* Tr&is yap ov;
2X2. Ta StKata ovy TipaTTOVTOiV kv ttj 7ro'Aet rwy 7roA.trd)y

^iX^a ovK kyyCyv^TaL iTpos aXXT]\ovs;

lo AA. 'AvdyKr) av fxoL SoKei etyat, a> 2wKparey.
d 212. Tiya ovv Trore Aeyets Trjv ^LkCav rj 6p.6voLav TnpX

ris 8et rjpjds ao<f)ovs re etmt Kat v^ov\ovs, Lva dyadol

avbpcs 2/xey; ov ydp bvvapML fxadelv ovO' rjfrts oilr' iv

ola-TLaLV TOT ixev ydp kv tols avroXs ^atrerat evovaa, tot

5 8' ov, 0)5 eK rou croii Aoyor;.

AA. 'AAAa jota tovs deovs, S) 2a)K/)arey, ov8' auros ot8'

ort Aeyco, KLvbvvevo) 8e Kat TrdAat XeXrjdevaL kixavTov

aXayji.aTa eyo^v.

2X2. 'AAAd XPV Oappeiv. d /xey ydp avTo fiaOov TreiTOvOoiS

e TTevTTjKOVTaeTTqs, ^^ ^^ ^^^ eTTLjxekqdrjvaL (rav-

x^^^''^^^
Tov' vvv 8' 171; e^ets ^AtKtav, avTTj eo-rii; kv fj
8et avro
ato-^eV^at.

bs Olympiodorus oS BT
eS b8 ^antv T: <^a;ite' B:
:

^A.eyo/xe' Olympiodorus ^TYiyvo/ieVTjsTW Olympiodorus yiyvofifvvs :

B b 10 toOtoBT: ri outA Olympiodorus b 11 Kpdrrovffiv

B : irpirrwinv T C i /ij) B Stobaeus om, T 2 iyylyvtcreai :

TW: yfYj/eo-ffoi B 03 irtpl roxnaiv S>v 01 fifv iffoffi irtpl rovruv B :

itepX rovrwv &v ol fiev i<ra<Ti T

 AAKIBIAAH2 w^e
AA. Ti ovv Tov al(r6av6fj.evov XPV ttouXv, w SwKpares;
2X2. ^ X-noKpiv^a-dai, to. e/aoorw/iteya, w 'AAKt/3ia8rj" Kat 5
cay TOVTo Ttoifis, av Ofbs Oikrj, et rt 8et Kat r?) ejn^ fxairr^Ct^

7rio-reuiy, o-u re Kayo) ^(X.tlov ayjicroixiv.

AA. "Ecrrat Tavra ^veKa ye tov e/ue aTT0KpiVcr6ai.
2X2. <i>e'pe 8r/, rt ^crrti' ro eauroO e7rt/xeAer<r^ai /x^ iroA-

AaKis \d6o)ixV ov^ 7]fx<av avr&v eTTt/xeAov/xeyot, oloixevoi, bi 128

Kat TToV a/)a avTo Trotet av6po)TTOs; ap' otov t&v avroC
ewi/xeA^rat, ro're Kat avTov;
AA. 'E/Lioi yow SoKei.

2X2. Tt 6e'; TroScSy avdpoDTTOs' Trore ^Tri/xeAerrai; ap' 5

oray kK^ivoav eTri/xeA^rat a eo-ri rwv TroSoii;;

AA. Ov [xav6dv(ti.

2X2. KaAeiy 8e' ri yjeipos; oXov haKTvkiov tcTTiv oto^} hv

aAAou t5>v tov dv6p(aTT0V (j)airjs r} baKTv\ov;

AA. Ov brJTa, 10
2X2. OvKovv Kal TTobbs vTrobrffxa Tbv avTov Tpoirov;
AA. Nai.
(2X2. Kat i/xaria Koi crTpdiixaTa tov aAAou (rdtpjxTos

opLoiois;

AA. Nat.) b
2X2. 'Ap' ofiv oTav V7roSr//xara)y eirt/ieAw/xe^a, TOTe TTobS>v
iiTLixcXovfxeda;
AA. Ov Trdvv \xav6dv(a, w 2()Kpares.

2X2. Ti 6e', S 'AAKi/StaSr;; op^ws kTnixiKii(r6ai. KaAets rt 5

oTOVovv TTpdyixaTos;
AA. 'Eytoye.
2X2. 'Ap' ovv oTav rij rt /3e'Arioz; Trotr/, tot op^V
Ae'yets (TTtfxiXfiav;

e 4 cucrBavififvov T Olympiodorus al(r66fievov B : e 5 iiroKpivacrBai

Olympiodorus o 6 OtAp Olympiodorus ^fleAp B T 07 fifKriov
:

B T $(\Ti6v(t)s Coisl.
: a 2 airb iroiu B Stobaeus iroje? awrb T :

&vdpuTros Schanz (et mox) &v0puiros B T

: a 13 Koi Ifiarla . . .

b I vai Stobaeus oni. B T: b 8 tj T om. B Olympiodorus :

21*
I28b nAAT^NOS
lo AA. Nai.
2i2. Tis ovv riyvr] viioh-qiiaTa (3(\tC(o Troici/

AA. SKuriKT;.
SX2. ^KVTLKrj apa v7Tobrifji6,T(av (TTLixckovfxcda;

C AA. Nat.
212. 'H Ka\ TTobbs o-KurtKfJ; 17 eK^ivrj 17 irobas fiekTiovs
TTotou/xey;

AA. 'EKtVr/.

5 2i2. BeArious 8e TroSas ov^ ^TTfp Kal to aAXo cr&fia;

AA. "Ejijiofye SoKei.

212. AvTt] 8' ov yvfxvaa-TiK^;

AA. MaAto-ra.
212. rv/xmo-rtKfJ /xei^ apa Trobbs jrtjLieAou/xe^a, crKunKfj
10 8e T&v Tov TTobos;

AA. riayv ye.

2i2. Kai yv/uiyao"riKfJ /xey \HpSiv, baKTxAioyXvcfiCq. 8e rwy
r^s X^^i-pos;

AA. Nar.
15 212. Kal yvjixvao-rtKT/ fx^v o-w/xaros, v^avTLKfj Se Kai rats
d aAA.ais tS>v tov (rwjuaros;
AA. YlavTaiTaa-i, fxcv ovv.

212. /AAAr/ fxer apa Texyil avTov eKaarov kTTHiikoxni^Oa,

aXK.r\ b\ T<av avTov.
5 AA. <I>atVerai.

2X2. OvK &pa oTav tS>v a-avTov eTri/xeAr/, aavTov eTrt/xeAr/.

AA. OvbafxGts.
2i2. Ov yap 57 avTr] Tixvrj, a>s eoiKev, 17 rts hv avTov re
eTTt/xeAotro Kai t&v avTov.
to AA. Ov ^atyerat.
2X2. <l>e/)e 8^, Troia Tror' hv rifx&v avT&v kTTiyLikr]6dr]ixiv;

AA. OvK i-)(jji k^ycLV.

C13 dcMrv\ioy\v<pla T : SaKrv\oy\v(pia B 6.2 fifvodvB: om.

TW d6 ffavrov corr. Coisl. tavrov
: B : avrov T d8 j; tjj
Stobaeus : ^ns B T d 1 1 iroia T : om. B
 AAKIBIAAH2 I28e

212. 'AA.Aa rocrovbc ye <wjuoAoy?;Tat, otl ov\ ij av t&v e

i)lx(Tpa)V Kal otlovv fiikTLOV TroLolfxcv, dAA' 17 fjfMs avTovs;
AA. 'A\r]6rj Aeyeis.
20. 'H ovv yv(t)ix(v av irore tls Tiyvr) vttohifixa ^iXxLOV
iroiei, /xt) ciSoVes VTTobrifxa; 5
AA. 'ASumroy.
2i2. Ov8^ ye ris T-exr?; SaKrvAious /3eArioD9 Troiei,

dyi^oowrey SaKTvAioi;.
AA. 'AAt]^^.
212. Tt 8e'; rts T^xvr] /3eAri<o Trotei avTov, ap' av Trore 10
yvoLfXv ayvoovvTes tl Tror' icrfxev avToi;
AA. 'ASvraroi^. 129
2X2. noVepoy ovf 8t/ paStoy rvyxdi^ei to yv&vaL kavTov,
KaC ris Tfv (pavkos 6 tovto avadds ety tov kv nv^ot rewr, i]

yaXmov TL KoX ovyX TtavTos;

AiV. 'E/uot /AeV, co 2<yK/3ares, TroAAdxts /uei' iSo^e TTavTos 6

etmi, TroAAdKij 8e Tray^dAeTror.
212. 'AAA', a> 'AAKt/3td8r;, eire pabLov etre /a?; iorLv, ofxois
ye 7;/xty w8' cxet* yvovTis fx(v avTo Tax ^i* yvolpLfv tt]V

mfx4\Lav r]fxS)V avT&v, ayvoovvTs 5e ovk av iTOTe.

AA. "EoTi raura. 10

2i2. 4>e'pe 87;, rty' hv Tpoirov (vpeOcLr] avTo ravrd; ovrco b

fXV yap &V Td)(^ VpOLfXV TL TTOT k(TfXV aVTOL, TOVTOV 8' |ri

ovTS kv ayvoL(L dbvvaToC ttov,

AA. 'Op6(as Ae'yet?.

212. ^'Exe ovv Trpos Alos. rw 8taAe'yT; o-i z;Cr; dAAo ri 5
r] fxoL;

AA. Nai.
212. OuKow KoX iyoa croC;

e I roadvSf ye B Stobaeus Toaovrov 5e 7 T : 6 2 iro<o7/ii'

Struve iroiufjitv B T
: 64^ otv Olj^mpiodorus tl oZv B T a 2 8j> :

B &/ T
: a 3 ^i/ secl. Cobet b 2 &/ tox' B T rdx tiv :

Olympiodorus b 3 6vres B ovroi T b 4 bpO&s Xtytn T

:

om. B b 5 SaAo Ti B T &K\(f ry Stobaeus :

lagb nAAT12N02
AA. Nai.
lo 2i2. Sco/cparrjs ap ka-Tiv 6 hLakiyoixiVOs;

AA. Wavv ye.

212. 'AA.Kt/3ia87/s 8' 6 aKovoav;
AA. Nar.
2X2. OvKow Aoyo) StaXeyerat 6 "ScoKpaT-qi;
C AA. Tt /xTji;;
212. To 8e 8iaAeyeo-0at Kai ro \6y<a xprjadat, Tavrov ttou
KaA.eis^.

AA. Hdvv ye.

5 212. 'O 8e xP^l^^^os Kal S)

xpW* "^'f ^Ao;
AA. Ylm Aeyets;
212. "ila-ncp <rKVTOT6p.oi re/xvet irou rojuet Kai (rp.Ckr\ koI
^AAois opyayots.
AA. Nat.
lo 212. OvKow aAAo pkv 6 rejuycoy Kat xptap.ivos, akko 8e
ols TifxvoDV x/o^Tat;
AA. U&s yap ov;
212. 'Ap' ovi; ovrcos Kat oTs 6 Ki6apiarr]i ndapi^H Ka\
avTos 6 KidapiaTrjs akko av eirj;

15 AA. Nat.
d 212. ToSro tolvvv apTim r\p<aT(av, et o xp<aixVOS Kal (5

XP^TaL dei 8oKet iTepov HvaL.

AA. AoKet.
212. Tt ow ^S)p.v Tov (TKVTOT^fxov ; re/xyetr dpycirots

5 ix6vov rj Kal x^pf^iv;

AA. Kat x^po""^*
212. Xp^rat a/sa Kat TavTaLs;

AA. Nai.
212. 'H Kai rots d^^aA/xoty xP^l^^vos crKVTOTop.iL;
10 AA. Nai.

e 7 TOjue? B^TW Olympiodorus : to/x^ pr. B (ut videtur) Stobaeus

c 10 xp^l^^^vos Stobaeus
dI icaJ B :
xp^l^^fos
Te al T
: <J BT C 11 ofy d W : oh BT
 AAKIBIAAH2 ragd

2i2. Tbv he yj)^y.evov koI ots \pfJTaL Tepa ofiokoyovfiev;

AA. Nat.
2X2. "Erepoy ^pa a-KVTOTOfios koI KidapLarrjS xctpSi' Kal
6<f>6aXiJL&v oXs kpy&^ovTai; e
AA. 4>aiyerat.

2X2. Ouicouy Kat Trarrl t& crdfiaTi xprJTaL &v6p(0'jros;

AA. ritiw ye.
2X2. "Erepoy 6' rjv t6 re yjifap.ivov Ka\ w yjyriTai.; 5
AA. Nat.
2X2. "Erepoy apa &vdp(aTr6s eori roG <r(afxaTos tov kavTov;
AA. "EotKei'.

2X2. Tt JTor' o5v 6 &.vdp(aT:os;

AA. OuK exco Ae'yetr. 10

2X2. "Excis /xey ovv, ort ye ro ra> o^wjutart xpdfxevov.

AA. NaC
2X2. *H ovv aXXo rt XPV'''^'- <*^'"^ ^ "^XV' ^**
AA. OvK dAAo.
2X2. OvKoSy 6.pyov<Ta;
AA. Nai.
2X2. Kai /A^v ro6e y otiiai ovbiva av oAAws otTj^rai. 5

AA. To TtoXov;

2X2. M^ ov rpiwr ^v yi tl etvoi tov &v6p(ti'JT0v.

AA. TLV(av;
2X2. ^uxV V trwnAa ^ (Jvvap(l>6Tpov, to oXov tovto.
AA. Ti/x^i^; ^

2X2. 'AXAa p.rjv avro' ye to rov cr(ap.aTos apyov w/xo-

Aoy^crajuiey 6.v6p(aTTOV eirat;

AA. *X2/xoAoy)j(ra/:xev. b
2X2. 'Ao' ovy o-di/xa avrb avrov &PXfL;

e 3 &y9punros Schanz &yOp<i>iros B T

: e5 5' ^i/ B : 8^ T
e 7 ivOputros Bekker Avdpuvos B T: toC ffdfxaTos rov iavrov B :

rov iavrov crdifjiaros 1 696 livdpayiros BT : avQpuKos Bekker

aii}]^T:s/B ^BT:<|i7W bi i/ioAoy^o-a/ue;' B :

aifioKoyffcra/xfv ris oZv i ivOpoyiros TW b2 Jipx^' BT: &p^fi

Olympiodorus
130 b nAATI2N02
AA. OvSa/xws.
212. " Apyjeadai. yap avTo etTro/xey.

.5 AA. Nat'.

212. OvK hv brj TOVTo ye eir/ 6 ^rjTovixiv.

AA. OvK ioiKev.
212. 'AAA' apa to crvvajJLcfyoTepov tov (r<ap.aTos ^px^* '^"^

loTt 8?j TovTo &vdp(OTros;

10 AA. "lo-o)? b^Ta.
212. n(ii>ra)y ye ^/ci(rra' /x^ ya/a o-vycitpxo'^'''^? tov (Tfpov
ovbcixCa TTOV fjLr]-)(avri to avvafxcfiOTepov apyiiv.
AA. 'Op^ws.
C 212. 'E7rei8?/ 8' oure trw/xa oilre ro <rvvaix<})6Tp6v kanv
avdpoiTTOs, Aeiirerai ot/Aat 17 fxrjbev avr etrat, ^ etire/) rt eo-rt,

fxrfbev &XXo tov &v6pb)TTov a-vfxjiaCveiv r/ \jrv)(T^v.

AA. Ko/>tt8r/ ftey ovy.

5 212. "Eri ovv rt a-a(f)4a-Tpov Sei aTToSetx^^yat o-ot ort rj

^vxv ^a-TLV avOpoiiTos;

AA. Ma Ata, dAA' ifcayoiis /xoi 8oKet exeir.
212. Ei 8e' ye />ir/ aKpijS&s akka koI fXfTpim, e^apKet
^/xii'' aKpij3&s fxkv yap t6t (ia-^fxeda, orav vp(t)fXV wvhr]
d TTapr]K6ofXV 8ta to TToXkfjs etmi a-Ki\f/(t)s.

AA. T^ rouro;
212. *0 a/)rt ovtco Tro)? ppr]6r], ort iTp&TOv a-KiTTOV ftr]

avTo To avTO' vvv 8e arri roS avrou avTo eKaa-TOV ia-Kfxp.6a

5 ort eo-rt. Kai to-ft)s e^apKiaei,' ov yAp ttov Kvpi.(!)Tep6v ye
ovSey av r]fx5)V avT&v (prfaaifxiv rf Trfv yfrvyr^v.

AA. Ov 8^ra.
212. OvKOvv KaXQ>s exet ovrco vofxi^i.v, e/xe Kat o-e irpoar-

b9 fffTt 5ij TovTo B Stobaeus ^ctt*' toStJ ye T

: b ii arvvdpxovTos
B : o8j/ 6pxovTos T W
((rw' s, v. W) c i iruna B tJ o-wjuo T :

ca prius^T: om. B 05 tiBT: om. Olympiodorus c8 oAAo

Kol fKTpiws
B
: T
om. W B d4 5 B : S^ T ovtJ T b oi t :

pr. ovtoC] ouToiJ ovToC Schleiermacher : o6to5 Kaff airb Stallbaum

oiiToi; oiiTb Stephanus : ovtoO ovtoi' BT d =; 3tj B Stobaeus :

tIT
 AAKIBTAAH2 I30d

o/xiAfiy dAA7^A.bts roi? Aoyot? yjpia^xivov^ rj/ ^/^vxf) ''^P^^ "^)^

y\fvyj]v; lo

AA. rTain; /iey oSr. e

212. To{5r' apa r\v o koX oXfyo) ^fnrpocrOev eXTTOjxev,

ori 2a)/cpar?js 'AA.Ki/3ia87j SmXeyerai Xoyw xpcapLevos, ov

Ttpbs To (rbv npocrcnTTOV, ws eoiKev, aWa Trpos tov
^AkKi^idbrjv TTOiovp.evos tovs koyovs' tovto 8e eo-rii' i} 5

AA. *'E)[iotye 8oKet.

2X2. "^vyjiv apa rjpMS KeAeuei yvoapia-ai 6 eTrtraTTcov

yroiiyat eavroV.

AA. "Eoifcei'. 131

2X2. "OoTis 6.pa r<av tov (TiapiaTos ti yiyv(a(rKei, to. avTov
dAA' ovx avTov iyv(OKv,
AA. OvToos.
2X2. OvSets &pa t&v laTpStv kavrov yiyvdxTKd, Kad^ 5
o(rov iarpos, ovbe rStv TiaLhoTpi^&v, KaB' o(rov TratSo-

rpL^-qs.

AA. OVK ioLKV.

2X2. rioXAoi) dpa 8eovo-ti' ot yecopyot Kai ot dAAot br]-

pLiovpyol yiyv(ii(TKiv kavrovs. ovhk yap ra kavr&v ovroi ye, 10

b>s 0LKV, dAA' ert Troppcorepa) t&v kavrwv Kard ye rds
re^xi^as hs iyovcrLV ra yap tov (r(ap.aTos yiyv(a(rKOV(rLV, oXs b
rovro dfpaTTeveraL.
AA. 'AAjj^i; Aeyets.

2X2. Ei dpa (r(x)(j)po(Tvvr] ecrrt rd cairroy ytyyctfo^xety,

ovSeis rovrciiv (r(a(f)p(av Kard rrjv Ti\vr]v. 5

AA. Ov fXOL b0KL.

2X2. Atd raura br] kol /3drauo-ot aSrat at riyyaL boKOV(TLV

LvaL KOLL ovK dvbpos dyadov p.a6r]p.aTa.
AA. Yldvv pikv ovv.

dg rfi il^vxfi] rijv ^vxh'' Dobree 63 \6ytuTW: oin. B aa t

Stobaeus om. : BT a 5 yiyvticrKu T : ytyy^<rKfiv B b1 &y
T om. B
: b7 ravra Tb : rav pr. B
I3ib nAATilNOS
lo 2X2. OvKovv TrdkLV octtls av a&fxa ^epaTrevet, ra tavrov
aXk' ou^ avTov OepaTTiv^i.;
AA. KLvbvvev(L.
2i2. "Ocrris bi ye ra xprjiJLaTa, ovd' kaxrrov ovt tcl

C kavTov, dAA' ert TTOp/Jcorepft) roiy eauro{5;

AA. "'Ejutoiye SoKei.

2i2. Ow TCL avTov &pa ^tl irpaxTU 6 yjprjixaTL<TTri^.

AA. 'Op^ws.
5 212. Ei apa rt? yiyovev epaa-Tris tov 'AXKt^ta6ou
o-w/xaros, ouK 'AAKt/3ta8ou 6,pa r\pd(T6rj akkd tlvq^ tS>v
'
AXKLJSLdbov.
AA. 'Ak7]dr] kiyeLS.

212. "Oo-rts 8e' a-ov r^s v/o^x^s f/53,*

lo AA. 'Az^ayK?] ^atVerat e/c to{5 Aoyou.

2X2. OvKouz; 6 /xey rou a-^aixaTos aov kp5>v, iiTCLbr] AT/yet

dvOovv, aTTLODV otx^TaL;

AA. ^atrerat.
d 2X2. 'O 8e y ttjs yfruxvs ^pS>v ovk a7rei<rty, etos hv eirt ro
^ikTLov h);
AA. EtKo's ye.

2X2. OvKoSy eyol) ei/xt 6 ouk dTrtwy dAAa irapaixivoiv

5 ATjyoz/ros roC ciiiixaTo^, TUiv dAAcoy dTreATjAv^ortor.

AA. Ev ye ttol&v, S) 2wK/)ares* Kot /xrjSe direA^otS'.

2X2. Ilpodu/xoi} TOLVVV otl xdAAto-ros etyat.

AA. 'AAAd TTpoOvfx-qa-ofxaL.

e 2X2. *X2s ovtod yk aoL exet* our' eyived', m ioLKev,

'AkKL^Ldbrf T<a KkeLVLOv ipaa-Trjs ovt earLV dAA' rj els

jxovos, Kal ovTos dyairqTos, 2a)K/)drrjs 6 liUicf^povCa-KOV Kal

^aLvapiTJfS.
5 AA. 'AAr/^^.
2X2. OvKOW i<f)rfa-6a a-fxLKpov ^6fjvaL fxi TTpoa^kdovTa aroL,

biOTctBiTiT bii ovx eavrhv T Stobaeus : ovk aiirhv B

o6 &paT : om. B d6 ^ij5J T : ju)? B 6 2 A\' ^ T
a\\*B
 AAKIBIAAH2 I3ie

^TTft TTpoTepos 6,v fxoL Trpo(Tekdiv, ^ovXoixfvos 7rv6(rdai 8t'

5ti fxovos oi/K a.Tiipyop.at.;

AA. 'Hy yap ovtu>.

2i2. ToOro Toivvv oItlov, otl /otoVo? epaaTrjs ^v cros, ol lo

6' aAAot T&v aG>v' to. 8e a-a Xrfy^L utpas, a-v 8' ap)(r] avdiLV.
KOL vvv ye hv /bt?} bLatf^dapfjs vtto rou 'AOrjvaLOiv bi^fxov Kal 132
aicxto)!; yerr/, ov /xt^ o-e d-TroAtirca. tovto yap br] /ixdXioTa

eyo) (po^ovjJML, firf brjfxepaa-Trjs rjfxlv yevofxcvos 8ia^0apr)y

TToXXoi yap rjbrj Kai ayaOoX avrb TTCTTOvOaa-LV ^A6r\vaioiV.
evTTpoaoiiTTos yap 6 tov fxeyakriTopos brjfiLOs 'Fipe^Oio^s' 5
dAA' aiTobvvTa XPV o-^tov deda-aa-daL, evka^ov ovv Trjv

(v\6.^eLav rjv eyco Aeyco.

AA. TtW;
212. TvfxvaaaL iTp&Tov, S fxaKapLe, /cai fx6.de h. 8et fxaOovTa b
tei^at iTTi TCL Trjs TToKeois, jrpoTcpov be fxrf, lv dk^L(f)dpfxaKa
^Xiav trfs Kal fxrfbev irdOrfs beLvov.
AA. Ev juot 8oK6ts Aeyety, S) SwKpares' dAAd TTeLpGt

e^rfyeladaL ovtlv av TpoiTov eTTLp.ekrfdeLfxev fffxStv avTutv. 5

2i2. OvKOVV TOaoVTQV fXV fffXLV ftS TO TTpOadfV TTCTTepaVTaL
h yap iafxiv, eTrtetKcSs a)/xoAo'yrjTat (f)o(3ovfxc6a 8e fxif

TOVTOV (T(j)a\4vTS kd6o)fXV tTipOV TLVOS iTTLfXikofXiVOL dAA'

ovy^ rffxGiV.

AA. "EoTt TavTa. 10

2X2. Kat /xerd tovto brf otl y^vyjfs fTTLfxekrffiov xai ets C
rovro ^kcTTriov.
AA. Aifkov.
2X2. 2(o/itdrcoy Se Kai yjirffxdruiv vifv iTTLfxikeiav erepois

TTapaboTiov. 5
AA. Ti fxrfv;

e 10 Stallbaum
it6s] ffov a a iwoXlwu B T iwoXdiru Olympio- ;

dorus a 3 fifui' yevSfitvos B yei>6ix(vos rj/xtv T: b 5 Svriv'

ftt/Bekker: SvrtyaBT b? 4ipo$ovfi(0a T <po0ovfi(eaB C i S^:

liri Stobaeus 5e 8ti T IJStj B

:
^vxv^ T Olympiodorus Stobaeus
:

Trj9 ^vxvf B
I32C nAAT12N02
2X2. TCv^ ovv av rpoTtov yvolfxev avro kvapyicrTara;
eTTetS?) TOVTO yvovTes, o)? koiK^v, kox rjixas avTov9 yvo)-
aojjLcOa. apa Trpbs 6e&v eS kiyovTos ov vvvbr) eixvrio-Orjixev
lo Tov Ack(f)i.KOV ypap.p.aT0s ov (rvvip,v;

AA. To TTolov 74 bLavoovfxevos Xeyeis, 2 ScoKpare?;

d Si2. 'Ey{o croi (f^pdcro), 6 ye VTTOTTTevoi Xiyciv Kal (tv\x^ov-
Keueiv rjixlv tovto to ypdixpLa. KLvbvvevct yap ovb^ TToWa)(ov
(IvaL TTapdbeLyixa avTov, dAAa Kara Trjv o^frLV p.6vov.

AA. HSis TovTo Ae'yet?;

6 2jQ. 2K07re6 Kat (tv. ei fipi&v tQ op.ixaTL axriTep dv0p(aTT<a

(TvpilBovkevov cLTTev " i8e cravTov," ttQs av VTTekdjSoixev tl

TTapaLvelv; dpa ovxi. eis tovto j3\eTTLV, eis 6 ^kiiTbov 6

6(f)6akpi.6s e/xeAAey avTov IbcLv;

AA. Arjkov.
10 Si2. 'EwocS/xez^ 8?; eis ri j3kfTT0VTs t&v ovtcdv (Kelvo
e re op^ixev dp.a dv Kal rjixds avTOVs;
AA. A^Aoy brj, a> SwK/aares, ort ets KdToiTTpd re Kai ra
rotaura.
SX2. 'Op^cos Aeyeis. oukow Kat rw 6(f)dakix(a w op&piev
5 eveari {tl) t&v tolovtcov;
AA. ndi^u ye.
SX2. 'Eyz;eyo'/jKas oSy ort rou epL(3keiT0VT0s els tov
133 6(f)6akix6v To TTp^^TdDTTOv ep.(f)aLveTaL ev Trj tov KaTavTLKpv
oyfreL uxriTep ev KaTOiTTpoi, h bri Kal Kopriv Kakovpiev, eLb(i)kov
ov TL Tov eixjBkeiTOVTos;
AA. 'Akri6fj keyeLS.

5 2i2. '0(f)6akix6s dpa 6^6akix6v 6e(aixevos, kol ep.^keTT^av

els TOVTo oTTep ^ekTLCTTov avTov Kai <S dpfl, ovrcos av avTov
IboL.

e 7 aurb Schleiermacher ainh. : BT c8 /caJ T : om. B

C 10 ^vviejxiv B Stobaeus ^vvicrfiev : T d6 aviJ,fiov\evov Apelt
avfjL^ov\evo)v B : ^v/jifiov\evov T elirei' T : direTv B ffavrhv BT :

eavrhv Stobaeus d7 p\eireiv B : fi\eirei T ^ om. T

B :

6 5 Tt add. F. A. Wolf aa t . . . Ka\ov/jiev secl. Schleiermacher

K(Jpi;j' B Stobaeus : Kopvtp^v T a3 ^r ti B : Sv T
 AAKIBIAAH2 133 a

AA. ^aCverai.
2X2. Ei 8e y' ils aWo t&v tov avOpiairov /SActtoi 17 ri

T&v ovTODV, TrXrjv ets iKelvo <S rouro rvyxarei ofioiov, ovk 10
o^iTaL kavTov.
AA. 'AArj^T/ X^yeiff. b
212. 'Oc^^aA/xos ap' ei /xeAAet iSeiy avTov, ets 6(f)6ak-
jjLov avT(a /3Ae7rre'oy, /cat rou oju.jU,aros eis iKcivov tov tottov
iv <S riry)(ai;et 17 o^^aA/iAOV d/aer^ iyyiyvoixivr]' icrTL 8e
roirro ttou o\/^ts; 5
AA. Ovrws.
2X2. 'A/s' ovi^, a <^tAe 'AAci/3id8j7, xat v//^ux^ ^^ /xe'AAei

yv(a<r(Tdai. avrrjv, ets ^vxw o-vrfj /3Ae7rre'oy, cai /idAtor'

eis rouroi; avr^s ror tottov iv w iyyiyv^Tai rj yj/vxfji apTrj,

(ro<^ia, Ka\ eis dAAo <S rorro ruyxdyet ofWLOv ov; 10

AA. "E/iotye Sofcet, w 2<riKpares.

2X2. "Exo/Aei' ovi/ etTreti' otl eo-rt r^s V^vx^s dcLOTfpov c

7/ rouro, Trepi o ro etSe^rat re Kai (fypov^lv ia-TLv;
AA. OvK ^xop.v.
2X2. To) ^ew d/)a rour' olkV avrijs, KaC tls ets rouro
^kiTTOiv Kal irav to 6iXov yvovs, deov re Kat (f)p6vr}a-LV, 5
ovT<a Kol kavTov &y yyot?j /xdAto-ra.

AA. 4>atVerat.
(2X2. 'Ap' ovy, o^' &cnTp KaTOTTTpd etrrt a-a(\>i(TTpa tov
iv ro) 6(f)6a\p.(a ivoTTTpov Kal Ka6ap(aT(pa Kal Xap.TrpoTepa,
ovT(t} Kttt 6 ^eo? Tov iv Tjj r]iJ.Tpq "^XV /3eAr^oTou Ka6a- 10

p(aTcp6v re Kat Xap.TTp6Tipov Tvyx6.VL 6v;

AA. "EotKe' ye, 2<oKpares.
2X2. EJs roy ^ew dpa iBXiiTOVTes iKCv(a KaAAto-ra>
iv6iTTp(ii XP^^^^ ^^ '^'^^ "^^^ av6p(t}TTCvo)v LS Ti]v yjrvxvs .

a 10 Tovro] avrh Ma<ivig b4 ^ B : om. T : fj rov Stobaeus

b5 6rf/is T B
10 ffofpia secl.
{] ^Tpis b Heusde e i OeiSrtpoif
W
:

T vofpdoTfpov
: KvpiuTfpov Cobet B : C 2 re] ye B : to T
tVrn' B Stobaeus om. T 04 0t^ B :
: Bdci) T 05 0(6v re Kcd
<pp6i/r)(nv om. 01ympio<lorus C8-17 ^Ap' oSi/ . . . No( Eusebius
om. BT (se<l talia fere legerunt lulianus Stobaeus)
I33C nAATi2N02
15 aperriv, Kal ovTcas hv /^xaAiora op^n^v koI yiyv<aa-Koifiv

Tjims avTOVs.
AA. Nai.)
2X2. To 8e yiyvdta-KCLV avrbv w/ixoXoyoS/biey o-ox/^pooT/yrjy

(tvai;

20 AA. Udvv ye.

212. 'Ap' ovv firi yiyvdtaKOVT^s rjfias avrovs ixrjbe (r<o-

(f)povS ovTes bvvaCixed^ &v clbivai to. ^/xeVepa avT&v Ka^d

re Kol aya6,;
AA. Kal TT&s hv TovTo yhoLTo, 5 ^wKpares;
d 2i2. 'ASwaroy yap laois (toi. (^aiveTai /xt) yiyv(a<rKOVTa
'AXKi.(3i.dbr]v To. 'AAKt/3ia8ou yiyvdxrK^iv 8tl 'AXKLJSLabov
kariv.
AA. 'Ahvvarov fxivTOL vrf Aia.

5 2i2. Ovb' S.pa ' tcl fjfiiTepa ori rifxiTipa, ei fir)b' rffMS
avTOTLis;

AA. ITws y<i.p;

2X2. E2 8' apa urfbe tcl fifihepa, ovSe tcl t&v fifX(Tep<ov;

AA. Ov (f)aiv(TaL.
10 2X2. OuK apa ttclvv tl 6p6&s b}fxo\oyovfXV 6fxbX.oyovvTs
6.pTL Lvai TLvas 0% kavTovs fXV ov yLyv(aa-KOV(rLV, tcl 8' avTav,
&\Xovs be TCL T&v kavT&v. OLK yhp TrdvTa raura eiyai

e KaTLbcLV v6s T Kal fXLClS T)(yr}S, aVTOV, TCL aVTOV, TCL T&V
kavTov.
AA. KLvbvViJL.

2X2. "Oo-rts 8e tcl avTOv ayvoL, koX tcl t&v 6.\k<ov ttov

5 hv dyvooX fcara ravra.

AA. Ti fxrfv;

C 18 wfio\oyovfiev T : i/toAo^oS/xf' B Stobaeus C22 SvvaifjifO'

hv B: Svvalfieea T: SvvdneBa Stobaeus di yhp TW: om. B
Olympiodorus <roi B Olympiodorus : om. T W d. 5 3tj Tjfxerfpa
TW: om. B d8 ^rjSe Stobaeus : om. BT d 10 ufj.o\oyovfJLfv
T 6fto\oyovfi(v
: B Olympiodorus d la &\\ovi Se Stobaeus :
a\\' ou BT e 5 &i/ ayvoo7 T : d^root B : ayvou Sto-
baeus
 AAKIBIAAH2 1336

2X2. OvKovv 6 To, tS>v aXkoiv, koX to. t&v TToAecoy dyyo^o-ei.

AA. ^AvdyKrj.
2i2. OvK ap h,v yivoiTo 6 toiovtos avr\p ttoKixlkos,
AA. Ov hr}Ta. lo

2X2. Ov }u]v ovh^ olKovofjLLKos ye.

AA. Ov brJTa. 134

212. Ovbi ye to-erat ort TrpaTTet.

AA. Ov yap ovv.

2X2. 'O 6^ fxri elbois oi>x afxapTrja-fTaL;

AA. nayu ye. 5

2X2. 'E^aiJ.apTdv(}v 8e ow /caKws 7r/)dfei i6ia re Kal
8?;jLioo-i9;

AA.' nc3? 8' od;

2X2. KaKws 8e Trpdrrwy ouk d^Aios;
AA. 20o'8pa ye. lo
2X2. Ti 8' ots ovros Trpdrret;
AA. Kat ovrot.
2X2. OvK dpa oXov re, edy fAT/ rts (rca^ppoiv Kal dyados rj,

cvbaCfxova cTvai.
AA. O^x otoV re. b
2X2. 01 &pa KaKol t&v dv6p(oTT(av adkioi,.
AA. 2<^d8pa ye.
2X2.OvK dpa ov8' 6 'rrAovr^rras d^Atdnjros d-jraAAdrrerat,
dAA' 6 cr(i)(f)povri(ras. 5
AA. 4>a^z;erat.

2X2. OvK dpa ret)(wy ov8e Tpirip(ov ov8e v((apC(av b^ovTaL

ai TToAety, cb 'AAKi^td^r/, et /le^AAouo"/ evbaLfxoini^rcLV, ovbe
irXrjOovs ou8e fxeyiOovs dveu dpeT^s.

AA. Ou }XiVTOL. lO
2X2. Ei 877 )u.e'AAets rd r^s TrdAecos Trpd^eiy dpOSts koX
KoX&s, dperfjs croL fXTaboTov rots TroA^rais. C

a 2 -ye T oin. B
: a 13 ovk lipa . . b3 ff<p6ip<>. 7 Tb : om. B
W
.

b 4 i.0Ki6rriroi T Olympiodorus : fxarai6rT)Tos B

134C nAATHNOS
AA. riciis yap ov;
2X2. AvvaLTo 8' av tls /xera8t8oVat o /x^ ^X*
AA. Kat 'TTws;

5 SX2. AuTO) 5pa o-ot ttp&tov KTrjTcov ap^Trjv, Kal aAA.<j) os

/xeAAet /^t^ tdta jjlovov avTov re Kat rwy avroi) ap^eiv xat
aXXa TToAecos fcal rwy r^s 7ro'Aea)j.
TTt,^X.r]<r(rdat,,

AA. 'AAr/^^ Aeyets.

SX2. OuK apa k^ov^riav <to(. ovb^ o.p\r}v Trapaa-KcvacT^ov
10 o-aurw Trotety ort &y l3oijX.r), ovbc rrj 7ro'Aet, dAAa biKaioavvr^v
Kal a-(ti<ppoa-vvriv.

AA. JJati^erai.

d 2X2. AiKaCcos ixkv yap irpATTovTis KaX a-uxjypovois a-v re

Kai rf TToKis ^eo^tAws Trp&^eTe.
AA. EtKos ye.
2X2. Kat oTTep ye ey rots Tipoadtv eAeyo/btei', ets t^
S ^eioy ai kapLTrpov opSiVTes Trpa^ere.
AA. <i>atyerat.

2X2. 'AAAa iJirjv evTavOd ye jiXiTTOVTes v/xas re avrovs

Kat ra vpAT^pa dyaOa KaToyj/ca-Oe Kal yvdiaeade.

AA. Nat'.
lo 2X2. OvKow 6p6&s re Kai e5 Trpa^ere;
AA. Nai.
e 2X2. 'AAAa [j.r]V ovtoh ye TTpaTTOVTas vfJMS ideXco ey-
yuj/o-ao-^at ^ /X7)y ivbaip.ovr]a-HV.

AA. 'Ao-^aA^s yap ei kyyvr]Tr\s.

2X2. 'AStKcos 6e' ye TTpaTTovTcs, ets ro a^eov Kat a-K0TLvbv

5 ^kiiTOVTis, &)s ra elKOTa, op.oi.a tovtols iTpd^eTe dyvoovvTes

v/xas avrovs.
AA. "EoiKey.
2X2. ^'X^t ydp (av), a> ^tAe 'AAKt^ttiSrj, k^ovaia /xey f;

Troteiv o j3ovX.TaL, vovv be fxr] ex7, rt ro eiKos o-u/jt^atretr,

C3 exot T Olympiodorus :
^x' ^ Stobaeus 05 TrjTeo' T :

KKvTfov B d8 Kal B : T /col T e4 7 T : om. B Stobaeus

Koi T : Kai rh B Stobaeus e8 ^/ Laur. Ixxxv. 9 om. B T
:
 AAKIBIAAH2 I34e

IbttoTr} rj Koi TroAei; otov vo(rovvTi i^ovcrias ovo-rjs bpav b lo

j3ov\Tai, vovv laTpiKOV fxr) ^yovTi, TvpavvovvTi 8e w? /ur/Sey 135

eTri-jrXTjTTot ris avria, tC to (rvp.^r\<T6ixivov ; ap' ov\, s to
iiKos, bi,a(f)6apr}vai t6 (TG>p.a;

AA. ^AXr]dr] kiywi.

212. Ti 8' kv vr\i, ei t<i) k^av^ria eiTj 'jroieiy 5 Sokci, rou 5
Tc KaX apeTrjs KvfifpvrjTLKrjs k(TTpr)iJ.iv(a, Ka6opqs h hv
avyi^airi avr^ tc Kal toIs (TvvvavTai.s

AA. 'Eycoye, 6ti ye aTroAoii^To TrayTey ay.

212. OvKow wcrauTO)? er 7roA.et Te Kat 7rao"aty apxais Kal
^ov<riais aTroAetTro/xeWt? dpeTTjs iTT^Tai. to KaK&s TTpdTTCiv; b
AA. *AvdyKrj.
2X2. Tvpavviba xpV> ^ apiare 'AA.Kt/3t(i8rj, irapa-
OvK fipa

a-Kv6.C(a-6aL ov6^ avT(a ovt tt/ 7ro'A.et, et /xe'AAeTe (vbaLnovclv,

dAA' dpeTTji'. 5
AA. 'AAr;^^ Aeyets.
2X2. Ilpty 8e ye aperqv ^x^lv, t6 apx<e(r6aL a]j.LVov VTro
ToC j3eATioyos 17 t6 6.p\(LV avbpi, ov p.6vov TratSi.

AA. ^i^ati^eTat. 10

2X2. OvKow t6 y ap.Lvov Kai KakkLOv;

AA. Nat.
2X2. To 8e KaAAtoy npcnoibiaTepov;
AA. ncSs 8' oi!; C
2X2. ri/jeVet 5pa toj KaKw SouAeveiv a/xetvoy ydp.
AA. Nai.
2X2. AouAoTrpeTres dp' /7 KaKia.
AA. 4>aiveTat. 6
2X2. 'EAeu^epo7r/3e7re9 8e 17 apcrrj.

AA. Nai.

a I j] ffi(rT Schanz (et mox iviit\i,TTeiv cuiii Buttmann) /tijS^

iirivXiiTTOt Tis avT^ T : /utiS^' ^iriir\^TT tjs avT^! Olympiodorus : /i7j5'

iirneX-fiTTovTi iavrcf B a5 8o/cr T

hoKtiv B a7 ^vfifiaii)
W Stobaeus
:

: fu/i/Sa/i'? BT : ^vjxfiaivoi Coisl. a8 iv T : om. B

a9 irdffais B Stobaeus : airacrats T
PLATO, VOL. II. 22
I35C nAAT12N02 AAKIBIAAH2
212. OvKovv ^e6yiv xp-q, S) kraipe, Trjv bovXoTTpi-rrdav;
AA. MdXicrTd ye, a> SwK/aarey.
10 Sf2. AlcrOdvr} 8^ vvv ir&s ex^eis; fkevOepoTTpCTTOiS ^ o^;
AA. AoKO) ju.01 Kttt /xaAa a(^6hpa ala-QdvicrOai.
212. OTo-^' ouy Trws aTro^ev^r/ rouro ro Trepi (t^ puy;
tya /A^ 6vop.d(u)p.iv avrb (ttI Ka\<a dvbpC.

d AA. "'Eycoye.

212. ria)?;

AA. 'Eav IBovkji <rv, S '2<aKpaTs.

212. Oi /caXws Aeyeis, 'AAKi/3ia87j.

5 AA. 'AAAa irm XPV kiynv;

212. "On kdv Oebs iOikr].
AA. Ae'ya) 877. Kat Trpoy Tot^rots fxivTot. rdbe Kiyca, ort
Kiy8ui^io-o/xey f>iera/3aAety ro <r)(rjixa, S) 2<tfKpares, ro /xev

o-oy ey(d, o-y 8e Tovpi,6v' ov ydp ^(ttiv ott^os ov TratSaycoyT/tro)

10 <r diro T^o-8e Trjs ripApas, <tv 8' v-n e/xou '7rat8ayft)y7/o"rj.

e 212. '12 yevvalc, TreAapyou a/aa iixbs e/)cos ov8ey

Stoto-et, ei Trapa o-ot ei^yeoTTet/o-as' ^poaTa vTT^TTTfpov vtto

TOVTOV TTdklV dpaiTV(rTaL.

AA. 'AAAa ovT<as exft, Kal dp^ofiai ye VTvdV Trjs

6 8tKatoo-w?/s kiTipi.ik^crdai.
212. BovkoLiJ.r}v dv cr kcu biaT^kia-aL' 6ppoiib& 8e, ou rt

Tjj crfj (f)V<rL diTLa-T&v, dkXd ttjv Trjs TroAeo)? 6pS>v p<&fir}V,

jxri fJL0V T Kal a-ov KpaTT^arj.

d7 fxfvroi r6Se BT : fjih&Se Olympiodorus d 8 fierafioKfTv]

fi.era\afif7v Cobet e 2 ^vvfomiffas B ivveorrfiiracrt T
:
 /^''^^

AAKIBIAAH5 AETTEP02
St. II
SriKPATHS AAK1BIAAH2 p. 138

2X2. 'li 'AAxt^ttiSr/, apd ye Trpbs rbv Ofbv Trpoa-ev^ofxevos a

Tropcvrj;

AA. Tldifv pkv ovv, 0) Swfcpares.

212. ^aCvrj ye Toi i(rKvdpu)TTaK4vai re Kal eis yryy

QkfTTCLV, COS Tl CrVVVOOVlXVOS. 5

AA. Kat rt ai' rt? o-vi^wotro, S) 2wKpares;
2X2. Ttji; p,^y(.aTr]v, w 'AAKi/3i(i8Tj, avvvouLV, c5s y' e/iAoi

8oKt. 7ret ^^pe Trpos Ato?, ovk olet rous deovs, h b

Tvyxdvopiev ev)(6iJ.evot Kat i6ia Kai brjjxocrLq, ivLOT( tovtohv
Th ixv bibovai, To, 8' ov, koI iaTiv oh fxkv avT&v, 1(ttl
8' 0!? ow;
AA. Hajn; p.\v o^v. 5
2X2. OvKow 8oKet o-oi ttoWtjs Trpo/XTj^eiay ye Tipoa-hiia-Oai,
SiTcai jLtTJ AT/o-erat avroy evxo/xei^o? /izeytiAa KaKa, boK&v 8'

dya^a, ot 8e ^eoi Tvx<^cfiv iv TavTji ovtS rr) ^^ei, iv rf

8i8oao-ty avrot & rts cvxpixcvos ruyx^yet; wo-Trep rov OZ-

8t7row avTiKa cf)aalv eu^aa^Oai yaXKl^ 8teAeo-^at ra Trarpwa c
rovs veis* e^ov aurai rwr TrapovTuiv avT<a KaK&v diroTpoTTrjv

Kpoatv^oiMVos vopfOri T iropfv6fi(vos vpofffi^fi

aI : a 6 ts B
T : T B b
7 A^fffTo] A^(ri tj Bekker C i Tck iraTp^Ja
robs vU7s B touj vltTs Tck iraTp^^A
: T
C a vap6vTuv aini^ B :

irap<(i^wy T
22*
I38c nAATilNOS
Tiva (v^aa-Oai, erepa Trpo? toIs vTiapypvcnv KaTrjpaTO' toi-

yapovv TavT^ re ^eTe\4a-9r], Ka\ t/c ToijTcav &\\a TroXka Kal

5 bi.v6., h Ti Sei Kad^ ^Kaora Xiyeiv;

AA. 'AXAa av ixiv, S ^(oKpaTCS, fxaLVoixcvov &v6p(aTT0V
cXpr]Kas' eTret ris av a-oL 8oKet ToXpLrjcraL vyLaivuiV TOLavr
cv^aaOaL;
Si2. To ixaCvea-Oai apd ye inrevavTLOv (roi 6oKet ro)

lo (\>povelv;

AA. riayu /xey ovi;.

d 2X1. "Acf^poves b^ Kal (f^povLixoL boKovaiv &vdp(OTroL eivat

TLv4s (tol;
AA. Etrat p.ivTOL.

212. <I>epe 877, kitLa-K>^(i>p.eda rtres Tror' eio-iv oSroi. ori

5 iiiv y6.p eto-t riyes, w/AoAoyT^rai, a^povks re Kai ^p6vL\ioL,

Kai p.aLv6\i.(.V0L ^TCpOL.

AA. 'Il/xoAoyjjrat ydtp.

2X2. "Ert 8e vyLaivovTis dai tlvs;

AA. EtVti;.

10 2X2. OvKovv Kal aa-OevovvTes ^TepoL;

139 AA. Tldvv ye.

2X2. OvKoBi/ o^x ot avToC;

AA. Ov ydip.

2X2. 'Ap' ovy Kai ^repot riye'? da-LV, ol fxr}b4Tpa Toirruiv

5 TTeTTOvdaa-Lv;

AA. Ov bfJTa.

2X2. ^AvdyKr) y6p ^arTLV &v6p(t)'nov ovTa rj vocrdv rj ixrj

VO(TLV.

AA. "EjLtoiye SoKei.

10 2X2. Tt bi; Trept (f^povriareois Kal a(f)poailfvr)s Spa ye ttjv

avTriv ^X^'-^ ^ yv(ap.r]v;

AA. riw? Ae'yets;

C 4 T T : om, B c9 {po 7 T : itpo B &1 ydp i(TTiv T :

ip' B a 1 1 exfjy ru yv(S>ix-nv scripsi : ex* ' ('fTy''^^')'' ^

^X*'*
yvdifir}v Tb
 AAK1BIAAH2 AETTEP02 igga

SI2. E6 bdKi croL olov re cTrat rj (f)p6vLiJ.ov 7/ a(f)pova, 7]

(TTL TL 8ia [x4<T0V TpLTOV TTaOoS, TTOiet TOV avdpOiTTOV fJl.rJT(

<f)p6vLfjLov p/Te a(f>pova; b

AA. Ov brJTa.

212. 'AvayKr/ 5p' eort t6 Tfpv tovtoov TTCTtovdivaL.

AA. "E/ixotye 8o/cet.

2X2. OvKovv ixip.vr](raL dpioXoyq^ras VTrevavTLOv etvai 5

fxavCav (f)povrfau;
AA. "Eywye.
2X2. OvKovv Kal fxrfbcv eiyai 8ta fX((Tov TpLTov Trddos,
o Troiei Toi; avOpiairov fxrfT <f>p6vLfxov fxrfT a(f)pova eiyai;
AA. *X2/xoXoyrjcra ytlip. 10
2X2. Kai p.ifv bvo ye VTrevavHa hl TrpdyfxaTL TrQts hv eirj;

AA. Ovbafx&s.
2X2. ^ A(f)po<Tvvr] &pa Kal fxavia KLvbvvevL TavTov eiyai. c
AA. ^J^atWTat.
2X2. riayTa? ovv av (fxxvT^s, S) ^AXKL^Labrf, tovs a<f)povas
fxaLVicrOaL 6p65)s av (f>airffXV' avTLKa t&v cr&v ^AtKiwTwy
e? TLves Tvyx(xvov(TLV a(f)povS ovts, &(n:p (1(tl, Ka\ t&v 5
iTt TTpcr^xjTep(t)v. eTret (f>pe Trpbs Al6s, ovk otet t&v kv ttJ

TToAei oAiyovy fxkv eivaL tovs <f)povLfxovs, a(f>povas 8e brf

Tovs TToXXovs, oiis brf (Tv fxaLVOfx4vovs KoAety;

AA. "Eycoye.
2X2. Oiei hv ovv xaipovTas rffxas eimt fXTa to(tovt(>)v 10
fxaLVOfxiv<i)v iTo\LTVOfXvavs, kcll ovk av TTaLOfxivovs kcll /3aA- d
AojLieVous, Kat airep iL(i)da(TLV ol fxaLv6fXV0L bLaiTpdTTea-Oai,
iroAat 8^ biKrfv 8e6a)KeWt; dAAa opa, S) fxaKapic, fxrf ov\
ovT(as TavT exet.
AA. Yla>s av ovv ttot ^xol, o) 2(dK/)aTes; KivbvvViL yap 5
OV\ OVTOiS ^X^^^ SxTTT^p (hrfOrfV.

a13 (t SoKfts ot6v Te B hoK(i <roi oi6v re T : Soku <roi ayayKalov

:

Ast SoKf7 <roi fi6vov rivh. ci. Stallbaum

: a 14 iroift B iirolti : T
C3 iravTas T Tta.vTfs B
: c 7 5e 8^ B 5 T d 3 5^ B om. T
: :

iiWiL opa B aW' &pa T

:
i39d nAATX2N02
2i2. OvS' e/uioi SoKet. dAA.a r^8e 7rr/ adpTqTiov.
AA. rirj TTOTe Aeyets;
Sn. 'Eyo) 87^ (Tot ye ep(S. VTtokayi^avo^iiv yk TLvas
10 eu^ai vo(rovvTas' rj ov;
AA. ndi;i; yikv ovv.

e 2X2. 'Ap* ovv hoKii (Tot avayKaXov etrai tov vocrovvTa

TTobaypav r) TrvpiTTeiv rj 6(\)6dkixijav, rj ovk ^v Soxet o-oi Kat
/xrjdey TovTcav Tmrovdois erepay 1'do'oi' voaiiv; TToAAat ydp
hrj-nov ye eio-i, Kai ov\ avTai ixovai,,

5 AA. "Ep.ocye boKOvcrcv.

212. 'O0^aAjuta o-oi ovv SoKet Trao-a yoVos etmt;
AA. Nat'.

212. 'Ap' ovi' Kal iracra voa-os d<p6a\p,ia;

AA. Ov brJTa ^p.oi.yv aTiopGi fxivTOL ye tt&s Ae'yft).

140 212. 'AAA' edy ejuoiye TTpoa-ixjl^ tov vovv, crvv re 8vo

CrKiTtTOp.ivdi TV\OV vpi]a-op.V.

AA. 'AAAd TTpoa-iyjn, o) ^caKpaTcs, eis bvvaixtv Trjv kp.r}V.

212. OuKow a))u,oAoy7/^i7 ]7//,ri; 6cf)6a\p.Ca pikv iTacra voa-os

6 elvai, vocros /xeVrot ovk etmt Trdcra 6(f)6aXpia;

AA. 'D.poXoy^drj.
212. Kat 6p6(as yi p.01 8oKet bp.o\oyr\6r\va\., koi yap
ol TTVpTTOVTS TT<XVTS VOa-OVaLV, OV pLVTOL OL VO(rOVVTS
TTCLVTes TTvpiTTovaLV ovbi TTobayp&aLV ovb ye 6^6aXp.LS)crLV,
b olpaL' dAAd rdo-os fiey Trdi' rd tolovtov iaTL, biacf)pLV

8e (f^acTLV ovs br] KaXovp.V laTpovs Tr]V aTTepyaaiav avTwv.

ov yap TTacrLV ovt opoiaL ovt opoicos StaTTpdrroi^rat, dAAd
Kard Trjv avTrjs bvvaptv iKaaTri' voaoL p.VTOL TTaa^ai ^Wlv.
5 &(rTTp brjp.Lovpyo'6s TLvas vTTo\apj3<xvop.V' 7] ov;
AA. IlAvv p.V ovv,

212. OvKovv Tovs crKVTOT6p.ovs Kal TKTovas Kal av-

d. 9 "ye Tivas T nvai B

: e4 "ycT : tc B e6 aoi oiv B :

oZv aoi T e9 ixfVToi ye T : jui4vT0t B a 2 tvx^v B : erxfSb' T

a9 iroSaypcScrjj' B : nroSarypiu^riv T b2 Sc recc. : 5^ B T
b3 Tra^riv B : nairai T ofioiat T : {(juoioi B : oyuom J. G. Schneider
 ;

AAKIBIAAHS AETTEPOiS i^ob

bpiavTOTToi.ovs Kol kripovs Tra/xTrArj^ets, ovs ri 8et KaO^ cKacrra

Aeyety; exouo-i 8' ovv SieiAjj^oVes br]p.LovpyCas p-fpr], koI

TidvTes ovTOL L(rL br]p.LovpyoL, ov p.(VTOL ficrl TiKTovis ye c
Ovb\ (TKVT0T6p.0L Ovb' dvbpLaVTOTTOLOL, 01 OVp.liaVTis d(TL
brfpLovpyoL
AA. Ov d^ra.
212. OiJrcos /xey tolwv kol ttjv d(f)po(rvvr]v SietArj^oVes 5
eicri, Kal tovs pikv TrAeio-roy avr^s pUpos ix'^^'''^^ paLvo-
p.^vovs Kakovpiv, Tovs 8' okCyov (kaTTOv rjkLdLovs re koI
p.^povTriTovs' OL bi cv iV(f)r]poTdTOLS 6v6p.a(rL l3ovk6p,(voi,
KaTovop.dCiLV OL p.^kv p.iyako'^v\ovs, ol b\ (irqdcLS, er^poL 8e
UKdKovs Kal diteipovs Ka\ kviovs' evpTjo-ets 8e /cat Tpa d
Tiokkd dvaCr]T(av ovdpLaTa. irdvTa 8e ravra d(f)pO(TVvr]

kcTTLV, bLa(f)pL bi, UtaTTCp TXyr] T\Vr]S r]p.LV KaT(f)aLVTO

xal v6(ros v6(tov' tj Trciis ctol 8oKet;

AA. 'Ejuoi p.v ovT(as. 5
Si2. OvKovv dii^ kKiivov ttoXlv kTTavk6(op.v. rjv ydp
brjTTOv Kal iv apx^ tov kdyov, (TK7TTiov etvaL tovs a(f)povds
re Kal (f)povipovs, Tives ttot ^[(Tiv. b)pok6yr]To ydp uvai
TLvas' 7j ydp ov;
AA. Nai, C()fxoAo'yrjrat. 10
2i2. *Ap' ovv TovTovs (f>povipovs xnTokap.^dveLS, ot dv e
ib(a(TLV OLTTa biL 1TpdTTLV KCLL kiyLV
AA. "Eywye.
2X2. "-A^f^povas 8e TTOTipovs; dpd ye tovs pr]bTpa
T0VT(jt)v ei6oVas; 5
AA, Tovrous.
2i2. OvKovv ot ye p.r] etSoVes pr]bTpa tovtoov krj^Tov^TLV
avTovs Kal kiyovTes Kal TTpdTTovres drra pr] Sei;

AA. <I>aiyerat.

2X2. Tovrcoi; pivTOL ekcyov, oi 'AkKLJSLdbr], Ka\ tov 10

C 2 ovSf T : Kol B oi T : om. B d7 Kal B : om. T

dg oS del. Hirschig d 10 &fio\6y7}To Stephanus e8 \4yoyr(s
Kol irpdrrovrfs Stobaeus : \(yovras Koi irpdrrovras B T
141

141
a

OibiTTOVv ilvai tG>v avOptoTToov

nAATilNOS
vpqcrei,i 8' hi Kal t&v vvv
^
TToWovs ovK opyfj Kexpvt^^vovs, uxnrep (Kelvov, ov8' olo-
ixivovs KaKa crcf^LcrLv vx<T6aL, dAA' ayaOd. cKHVoi pikv

axnrep ovb^ r}v-)(^eTo, ov8' ^cto' eVepot 8e tlv4s fia-iv 0%

5 TavavTia tovtodv iie-novOaa-iv. eyo) pkv yap olnai cre

TTp&Tov, et <rot iix(f)avr]S yv6p.Vos 6 Oebs Trpbs ov Txryxavi.s

iropi.vopLevos, kp(xiT-q(Te.uv, Tiplv OTiovv (v^aaOaC cre, et ^ap-
KeVet croi Tvpavvov yev<r6ai Ttjs 'Adr]vat(t)v TroAetos* et

8e TOVTO (j)avXov r]yr\(raL0 Kal p.y] p,4ya tl, TTpo(rd([r] Kol

b TTavTdiv T(av ^FiXX.r]V(t)V' et 8^ re opcor] Tl (XaTTov boKovvTa
e^eti', el fir] Kal TTd(rr]s Evp(6TTr]s, VTTOoTaCr] (tol koX tovto,
(xat roSro) ]xr] }x6vov VTTOcrTaCr], (dAA') avdriixep6v aov ^ov-
kofxivov ws TTdvTas aia-dri^rea-^ai otl 'AX.KLJ3L(xbr]s 6 KX.lvCov
5 Tvpavv6s fOTLV avTov oTfxaL av ac &TTi(vaL iTipLyapr]

yv6fx(vov, b)S tG)V picyCarcov aya6&v Ke/crpr/KoVa.

AA. 'Eyo) ]XV oifxaL, & ScoKpares, Kav &kXov ovtlvovv,

eiirep rotavra a-v]xj3aCr] avr&J.

C 212. 'AAXa ]x4vtol civtC ye Trjs (rrjs '^vxrjs ou8' hv Tr]v

TTavTOdv ^EXXr]V(i)v re Kai j3ap^dp(i)V \u)pav re Kat TvpavvCba

Pov\.r]6iCr]s a-OL yeviadaL.

AA. OvK olfxaL y(oye. ttS>s yap av, ixr]6iv ye rt ]X\Xo)v

5 avrots xprja-eadaL;
2X2. Ti 8' d ixikXois KaK&s re Kai fi\a^cp&s xprjcr^aL;

ovb^ av ovToos;
AA. Ov brJTa.

212. 'Opas ovv b)S ovk do-^aAes ovt tcl bLb6]xeva etK^
10 8exeo-^at re oiire avTov evx.fO'^at yv4ar6aL, e? ye rts
d l3X.d'7TTecr6aL //.eAAot 8ia TavTa r] t6 TTapdiTav tov ^Cov
diTaXXayrjvaL. ttoXA.ovs 8' hv exotjaey et'7reti', oo-ot Tvpav-

aI 8' ?TJ KaX rwv vvv B Se Ka\ r&v vvv eri T

: a2 iKfTvov T : Ke7vov B
bI dp^Jrj B : iptpn T b2 Ka2 tovto bis scripsit Sauppe b3
a\\'
add. Dobree b^ al<T$iiafa0at B: aladearOaiT bs auT^'] avrav'
Dobree : irpcoTov Schanz c 2 tc Kal ^3. B /caJ : j8. T c 5 xp^""* <''^'"
B xp^""^*
: T c 6 fifWois B /jLfWfis T : e 10 Te oi/Te T :

T ou8e B 7 oSri corr. Coisl.

: : ae ovrt vulg. : oHrt J. G. Schneider
 AAKIB1AAH2 AETTEP02 I4id

vCbos fTTLdvixria-avTfs Tjbr] koI (nrovbdcravTes tovt avTols

irapayevicrdai, ws ayaOov ri Trpd^avTfs, bia Tr]v TvpavvCba
7TL^ovXevdVTs Tov jSCov d<^rfpi6r](Tav. oip.aL bi o-e ovk 5

dvr]K00v eimi eyia ye )(^ifa re Kal Trpcotfa yeycvr^fxiva,

0T ^Ap)(\.aov Tov MaKfbovoiv Tvpavvov to, TratSt/ca, epa-
a-6ivTa Trjs Tvpavvibos ov6V rjrrov rjTiip (k^Ivos tG>v iraL-
biKiiv, diriKTfLve tov kpaarr^v s Tvpavvos re Kat cvbaLpLoov
dvr]p iaofxevos' KaTaa-xonv 8e rpei? r] TtTTapas rjfxfpas Tr]v e
TvpavvCba TTakLV avrbs eTrijSouAeu^ei? v0' kTp(av tlv&v
eT(\(VTr]av. opas br] kol tG>v rj]XTp(av ttoXltGiv ravTa
yap ovk dXkoiiv dKr]K6a]XV, dAA' avrot 7rap6vT(s otbaixV
5a-oi arpaTryyCas (TTiOvfxrjaairres ijbr] Kal TVXpvTfs avTrjs ol 142
pikv TL Kal vvv (})xrydbS Trjabe Trjs TroAews eiaLv, ol Se
Tov ISCov ereXevrrjo-ay ot 8e dpiaTa boKOvvTS avT&v iTpdT-
Tiv bid TToW&v KLvbvvoyv k66vTs Kal (pojBoiV ov [x6vov
iv TavTT] Trj OTpaTr^yCq, dAA.' eTret ets rqv kavToiv KaTrjXdov, 5
virb T&v avKO(pavToiv TTokiopKOV]x(voL TToXLopKCav ovb\v
eAdrro) n/y vtto tS)V TToKefxCoov StereAeo-aj;, (oore ivCovs
avT&v vx(a6aL daTpaTr]yrjTovs etvai fxdXkov r] koTpaTr^yr]-
KvaL. et ixv ovv 7]aav ol KCvbvvoC re Kal tt6vol (f)povTs b
ets &)<^eAeiay, e?)(ey dv Tiva \6yov' vvv 8e Kat ^oAv tov-
vavTCov. vpr]aLS 8c Kat Tre/ai Tkvo)v tov avrbv tp6ttov,
v^afx4vovs TLvds Ijbr] yVa6aL Kal yvofXvo)v ei? avfxtpopds

re KOL XvTTas rds fxeyCaTas KaTaaTavTas. ol fxkv yap 5

p.oy6r]pS)v 8id re'Aous ovtoi)v t&v tkvo)v oXov Tbv (iCov

XvTTovfXiVOL bLrfyayov tovs b\ \pr]ar6iv fLiV yvofXVO)v,

avfx(f)opaLS 6e xpr]aafxivo)V (Sore aTpr]6r]vaL, Ka\ tovtovs C

ovbcv ets eAdrroyas bvaTV\Cas Ka^eorrjKoVas ijiTfp (kcCvovs
Kal ^ovXofXVovs dv dyvr]Ta fjMXXov etvaL r] yvia6ai.
dAA' ofxo)S TOVTO)v re Kai kTp(t)v ttoXX&v bfxoLOTp6iT(i)v tov-
TOLS ovTO) a(f)6bpa KaTabr]Xo)v 6vto)v, aiTdvLov evpety ooris 5

d4 Trpd^avTfs BT : irpd^ovTes recc. 64 o^iSafifv] ttSo/xev Hirschig

as Toirrp] oifT^ Dobrec (Ficinus) a6 iroXiopKiav recc. iroXiopKli^ BT :

ba Ix*"] *^X<"' Cobet 03 koIT: om. B d^fVTjToT: ^^''tjtoB

I42C nAATI2N02
av rj hihoiiiviiiv ai^ocryotTo rf [jlW<ov hi vxrjs Tiv^icrOai

iravaaiTO av evxPfxevos' ol 8e ttqAAoi oiJre av Tvpavvihos

hihoixivrjs aTroVxotrro hv ovTe oTparqyCas ovh^ (Tepcav

d 'ToXXiav, h irapovTa /3Aa7rret ixakkov rj dxjxkel, akXa nhv

fv^aivTo hv yevia-Oai, ei ro) iir) TrapovTa TvyxAvet,' okCyov
he kTTL(r\6vTes evCoTe 7TakLV(ahovcn,v, avevyoixevoL aTT hv
To Trp&Tov ev^uiVTaL. iyui pikv ovv aiiopGi /it) <? akr]6QiS

5 p.aTr)v Oiovs avdp<aTT0L airiaiyrai, e^ eKeCvaiv <\iap.evoL

Ka^d a-(fiL(rLV eTmt* oi 8e Kai avTol (r(f)fj(rLV etre aTa-

(rOakCaLCTLV etre cK^pocrvvaLS XPV et^Tetr, virep p.6pov
e aAye' Ixouo-t. KLvhvveveL yovv, Si 'AAKtj8td8?7, (pp6vni6s
TLS elvaL eKctyos 6 7rotr;r^s, os hoKel p.0L (fiCkoLS avorjTois

rto-t xprjadixevos, opSiV avTovs koI iTpATTOVTas Kal evxo-

jxevovs airep ov jSekTLOV rjv, eKeCvoLS he e8o'Ket, KOtvr) virep

5 a'iTdvToiV avT&v evxw 'JTOLrjaaaOaL' keyeL hi ttcos oihC

143 Zev iSaaLkev, tcl [xev eadkd, (firjaC, Koi evxoixivoLS
Kal avevKTOLs
&.p.p.L hChov, To, he heLka koI evxofxevois d.TTake^eiv

Kekevei. e/xot ixev ovv Kakm hoKel kol aa(fiak(os keyeLV 6

TTOLrjT-qs' av 8' ei ri ev via exfis Trpos raCra, /urj atwTra.
5

AA. XaAeTToV, S SwKpares, eoriy avTLkeyeLV TTpbs tcl

Kak&s elprip.eva' eKelvo 8' ovv evvoGi, oaoiv KaKwv ahCa rj

ayvoLa tols avdp(0TT0LS, OTToVe, ws eoLKe, kekr}dapi.ev rnms

b avTovs 8ta Tavrriv koX TTp&TTovTes kol t6 ye iaxarov evxo-
IxevoL rjpuv avrois to, KdKLOTa. oTrep ovv ov^ety hv olr]6eCr},

dkka tovt6 ye 'nds dv oiotro iKaz;os eiz^at, awro? avroi ra

jSekTLaTa ev^aadaL, dXA' ov Ta KaKLaTa. tovto nev yap
5 d)S dkr]6oiS KaTdpa tlvI dkk' ovk evxfj 6pi.oLov dv etr/.

C 6 neWwv B : fiiXKov T C8 ou5*] oijB' Bekker d3 TtaXiv

tpSovaiv T ird\iv oSovanv
: B avevxiiM-^yoi T : ttv evx^l^e^oi B
d6 aiiTol ffip^ffiv rec. t : avroh (prifflv B : avrol ff<plffiv T d 7 cuppo-
ffvvais T : acppoviatffiv B : acppaSlaiffiv Hermann e i yovv B y^p:

T aa Sft\a Buttmann
\vypit Proclus (cf. 148 b, 6)
: Sfivii, BT :

a 4 Kf\fvft secl. KCppen a 7 offuv KaKwv corr. Coisl. : Sffov Koxbv

BT b 2 &; add. Priscianus om. B T b 3 tKavhs B : tKavSis
:
T
 :

AAKIBIAAHS AEYTEP02 143^

2X2. 'AAA' lo-cos, S) ^tknoTe, (^ait] av tis avrip, bs

fjXOV T Kttt (TOV (rO(p(aT(pOS MV TXry)(aVOL, OVK OpOGiS rjlJMS

X.4ytv, ovTcas etKT/ \{/4yovTas ayvoLav, et ye ^rj Trpocrddrjixev c

Trjv icmv &v re ayvoiav Kal eoriy ots at ^yovcri TTUis

&yad6v, &(nTp iKfCvoLs KaKov.

AA. YlSts A.eyis; lort yap otlovv Trpayfxa oTca Sr)

oTToxrovv expvTL apiLvov ayvoiiv rj yLyv(acrKHv; 5

212. 'E/uotye SoKei' orot 6' ov;
AA. Oii fiivTOL fxa Ata.

212. 'AAAa ixi]v ovbi (Kdvo (tov KaTayv(acrofxai, kOik^LV

av (re irpos Tr}v kavTov p.r]Tipa hLaTmrpayOaL &iTp ^OpiaTrjv
<f)a(rL Ktti Tov ^AkKfxecova Kal et brj tlvS oAAot Klvols 10
Tvyx(xvovcn TovTa bLa-nTrpayp.VOL. d
AA. Ev^Tjjuet Trpos Ato's, oi ^WK/aares.
2X2. Ovrot Tov kiyovTa, a> 'AAKt/3ta8j;, ws ovk hv e^eAots
o-ot raiira n^TTpaxdaL, ev^r/ju.eii' 8et o-e KeAeuety, dAAa
fxakkov TTokv, ei rts tcl ivavTLa Ae'yot, eTretS^ ourco o-ot 5

8oKet (r(f)6bpa bcLvbv etmt to TTpayixa, axrT ovbe pr]TOV

ctyat ovTcos LKfj. boKLS 8' civ Tov 'OpeVrrjz;, et Tvy\av
cf)p6vLIX0S 0)V Kal lbu>S OTL ^ikTLOTOV r^v aVT& TTpdTTflV,
Tokjxrj^raL av tl TovT(i)v bLaTTpd^aaOaL;

AA. Ov brJTa. lo
2X2. Ovb ye aAAoy ot/ixat ovbiva. e
AA. Ov \XVTOL,

2X2. KttKoi' apa, o)s olkv, karXv fj tov /SeAriorou

&yvoLa Kol ro dyyoety ro ^ikTLorov.
AA. "E/iiotye 8oKet. 5
2X2. OvKow Kai KLV(f Kal rots dAAots aTra^TLv;
AA. <I)r///i.

2X2. "Ert TOLVvv Kal T6b TTL(TK^^(i)yi.da' el o-ot avTiKa

b 7 Tvyx***''" Stephanus : riryx"''^' ^ "^ '^ 4 ^"'"V '}) rec. t

2t9> 5? BT c 9 &>' t : ^a BT (re~\ aoi Cobet iaxnov

BT: ffavTod al. d 3 iOeKois T: i04\oi B ds ^ttciSJ)

(5) Buttmann ireiTa Stallbaum

: d 7 5' &>/ BT : S&i/ Schanz
e 8 iirt(TK(}}/(ine$a recc, f-iri<rKf\i/6iJ.(da B T
:
i43e nAATilNOS
jLtaXa Trapea-TaCrj, olr]6iVTi ^iXriov eimt, IlepuXea tov
lO (TiaVTOV (TTLTpOTTOV T Kal <f)Ck0V, (yyiipihlOV Xa^OVTOt
144 ikdovTa kirX Tas Ovpas, elirilv el evbov eo-ri, ^ovkop.^vov
aTTOKTiivai avrov iKdvov, aWov be fir]bva' 01 6e ^aiez;
vbov elvai Kal ov Xeyu kQik^iv av cre. tovto)v tl irpaTTiiV'
dXA.' 1, otfxai, b6^L (roi, oirep ovdev ku)\v1 St/ttov r&) ye
5 ayvoovvTL to j^ekTLcrTov Trapaa-TrjvaL iroTe bo^av, Sa-Te
olrjdrjvaL Kal t6 KaKLarov ttot^ ^ikTLaTov itvaL' rj ovk hv
boKL o-ol;

AA. Tidvv ixev ovv.

20. Ei ovv TrapekOoiV eicro) Kal Ibwv avTov kKilvov
b ayvoricraLs re kol olrjOeLrjs hv akkov ftvai Tiva, ap' tl av
avTov roAju^crats airoKTctvaL;
AA. Ov ixa Tov Aia, ovk av fioL boKw.
2i2. Ov yap br]7rov tov VTvy^6vTa, akk' avrbv Klvov
5 bv r}^ovkov. 77 yap;
AA. Nai.
2X2. OvKovv Ka\ et T:okkaKLS y\Lpols, aU\ b\ ayvoots
Tov HcpLKkea, 6tt6t /u,e'\Aots roirro irpaTTiLV, ovttot^ hv
TTl6olo avTta,

10 AA. Ov bfJTa.

212. Tt 8e'; t6v 'OpeVrjjy boKets av ttotc Trj ]xr]Tp\

TTLd4a-6aL, ei ye wo-aurcos rjyv6r]a-v;

C AA. OvK otfxaL y(oy.

212. Ov yap bi]TTov ovb^ iKetvos Tr]v TTpoa^Tvyovtrav yv-

voLKa ov8e Tr]v otovovv [xr]Tipa Stei^oetro dTro/creti^at, dAAd
Tr]v avros avTov.
5 AA. "EoTt TavTa.
212. 'Ayvoelv apa to. ye rotaSra ^ikTLOv rots ovro)
bLaKL]XVOLS KOL TOLavTas bo^as ^yWCTLV.

e9 irapeffrair} BT : irapoo-Tafrj t a3 Sc secl. Sauppe a4 5(i|ej

BT : SS^eif Buttmann b i &/ Struve
secl. b 3 ovk Hy fioi
SoKu T : om. B bs iv secl. Schleiermacher b 12 76 T :

ScB
 ;

AAKIBIAAH2 AETTEP02 144C

AA. ^aLVfTai.
212. 'Opas ovv on. rj lorty cSy re ayvoi.a Kal ^cmv oij koX

4xov<Ti TTOis ayadov, dAA' ov KaKov, uxnT^p apTt, (tol edofcei; 10

AA. "EotKev.
212. "Eti Toivvv et jSovXei to fHTa tovto (TncrKOTiclv, d
aTOTTOv av lo-co? ay (toi, b6^LV ctvaL.
AA. Tt ixdXLcrTa, S) ^wKpare?;
212. "Ori, 0)? Ittos eiTrety, KtvSwe^ei to ye roSy aXAcoz^
i7rL(TTr]}X(av KTtJixa, i<xv rt? 5yev rou ^iXTLcrTov KKTr\p.ivo'i 5
77, oAtyaKt? /Ltey w^eAeti', /3Ad7rretr 6e rd TrAetco tov eyovTa
avTo. (TKoVet 8e cS8e. ap' ovk drayKatdi' o-oi 8oKet eimi,
oTav TL ^\X(tifj.v ijTOL TTpaTTiLV 7] XiyiLV, olr]6rjvai bdv
TTpStTOv rjjjLas etSeVat 17 rw ovtl etSeVat Tovd^ 6 av TTpo\eL-
poTp(t)9 /Lte'AAa)ftey 17 KiyiLV 17 TrpaTTfLv; e
AA. "E/xotye 8oKet.
212. OvKow ot prjTopcs avTLKa ^roi ciSdres (TVfji^ovkcveLV
rj olrjOevTfS etSeVat (rvfi^ovXVov(TLV rffxlv kKdaroTe, ol /xei

TTepl TTokdfxov re Kat etpTji^rjy, ot 8e Trepi retxwy oiKo8o/Lttas 5

7; Kai \Lfx4v(*)v KaTacTKevrjs' kvl 8e Adyo), dtra 877 Trore ^

TrdAis 'jrpdrrei iTpbs &\Xr]v ttoXlv rj avrq KaO^ avTi^v, aTTo 145
Trjs T&v pTjTopdiv (TVfx^ovkrjs TT&VTa y[yv(TaL.

AA. 'AAt;^^ Aeyets.

212. "Opa TOLWV Kal tcl cttI tovtols.
AA. ""Av hvvr]65>. 5
212. KaAet? ydp ^TjTrov <f>povLfxovs re Kai 6,(f)povas;
AA. "Eywye.
212. OvKow Tovs fxev TroAAovy d<\>povas, tovs 8' oAryous
(\)povLp.ovs

c 9 T6 B : 7T d2 &>' tffus Sv B : tiv Xtrm 6.vT : 8^) fffws &v

Schanz d 5 toO] tijs toD Dobree ^v pr. T d6 ^] ^ pr. B :

d 7 aiiT(J Schneider aiiTd : (jiiWoifxfv T

BT /leAA!' /a^' B
d8 :

oltiQjivai B ^ oiT/fl^i^ot T
: Sfij/] 5^ Dobree dp KpoxfipoT(p<t)s'\
irpoxfipois Sauppe e i /jifWwfjLfv B fitWwfjLfv riT 63 : arvfi.-

fiovXevftv T ^vfifiov\tvov(riv B
: 64 i)T: om. B e6 ^koJT:
^ B a 2 jro;'Ta T Sirorra B :
 :

I45a nAATI2N02
lo AA. OvTois.
2X2. OvKovv TTpos TL aTTojiXfTroiv aixcf)OT4povs;

AA. NaC.
b 212. 'Ap' ovv Tov ToiovTov (rvp.^ovXiviiv et8ora, yoopXs
Tov TTOTepov ^ikTiov Ktti 6t ^ikTiov, <^p6vip,ov koKhs;
AA. Ov bijTa.

2X2. Ov6e ye oi/xai oo-tls to TToXeixetv avTo ot8e x^^P'?

5 ToS OTTOTe IBekTiov Kal too-ovtov yj)6vov oaov ^ikTiov.
^
yAp;
AA. Na^.
2X2. OvKOvv ovhe ei tCs Ttva airoKTeivTuvaL otbev ovbe
XPVP-aTa a(f)aLpL(r6aL Kal (})vy6ba ttoluv ttjs iTaTpibos, xwpts
lO TOV OTT^TC (SekTLOV KOL OVTLVa ^ekTLOV;

AA. Ov piivTOL.

C 2X2. "Oo-rtj &pa tl t&v TOLOijTcov oiSey, iav p.\v iTap^TTrjTaL

avT^ 7] Tov l3kT((rTov iTTLCTTriixr] avTT} 6' ^v r) avTT] briTTOV

rJTTcp Kai rj tov </)e\t)aou' ^ yap;

AA. Nar.
5 2X2. ^p6vLiJ.6v 8e ye aiiroy (prja-ofxev Kal aiToyjp&VTa (HjpL-
(Bovkov Kal rrj -TToAet jcai avTov avr&i* tov 6e fxrf tolovtov
TCLvavTia TOVTcav. rj tt&s boKd;
AA. 'EjOtOt fXV OVTCOS.

2X2. Ti 8' et ris ltt7TVlv rj To^eveLv olbev, rj av ttv-

lo KTeuiLV r} TTakaULv ^ rt Trjs 6,kkr]s aycavCas rj koi 6.kko tl

d T&v T0L0VT()V 6(ra Tiyyrj oXba\XV, tC KaXet? os hv elbfj to
KaTCL TavTrjv T-qv Ti)(vr)v ^ikTLOv yLyv6p,vov; Z.p ov tov
KaTCL TTjV LTTTTLKrjV ITnTLK^V;

AA. Ky(i)y.

5 2X2. Tov bi ye oiftai KaTO. Trjv TruKrtK^y 7tvktlk6v, tov

b2 Sre corr. Ven. 184 '6 yt t: & B T : Baiter : e 2 ahrtp

6ir6re
B om.
: T 055 ye] re 76 Sauppe C6
Tf) iroMi Koi avrhv koX
avr^ B :Ka\ avrhv avrtp Kal ttj wSKfi T roiovrov J. G. Schneider
iroiovvra BT C 9 irvKreveiv ^ vaKaUiv B 7raAa^6(i/ ^ irvKrfveiv T
:

dI rtxvri T : rexvnv B d 2 KaT^ TauT?;'] KaT* avri]v Apelt /caTck :

Schanz Sp' T : om. B

 :

AAKIBIAAH2 AETTEP02 145^

Se Kar avArjriK^y avXrjriKov, Kal raXAa b-qTTOV dva koyov

TOVTots' rj aWoDS mas;
AA. OvK, dAA' ovrcas.
2X2. AoKci ovv croi dvayKalov eiyat tov TTepl to^tohv ri
kinaTqiiova 6vTa &pa Koi avhpa <\)p6vip.ov eti^ai, ^ ttoKKov 10
<})rj(TOfXV (vbd^v; e
AA. noAAoi; ijl4vtoi vtj ACa.
2Xi. no^ay ovv oiei TToAireiai/ eirat to^ot&v re dyaO&v
KaX av\T]T&v, Irt 6e Kot ddkqTav re /cai t&v aAAcoy rexyt-
ro)!', dvap,pLiyiJ.(V(av 6' ey rotJrots o'0y aprt ilp-qKayav t&v 5
re avro to TroAe/xety etSorcoj; Kat avro t6 dTroKTt,vvvai, Trpbs
8e Kai dvhpGiV pr^TopiKGiV ttoXitikov <^v(rr]p.a (pva-ajrrctiv,

aTTdvTOiV 8e ToiuTCtiV oirroov avv ttjs tov ^eArtWou iTncrrri-

fxrjs Kal Tov eiboTOs, ottotc jS^Xtlov kvl fKdarta totutcdv

Xprja-dai Koi iTpbs TCva; 146

AA. ^a-vkrfv Tiva iyfaye., S) SwKpares.
Sii. 4>air;s ye dv oTp.ai OTTOTav 6p<ar]s ^va ^Kaarov avT&v
(f>iXoTiixovfJLv6v re Koi vifxovTa to TTXdarov Trjs TroAtreta?

TovTca piipos, 5
tv avTos avTOv rvyxdvci KpaTiaros &v'

Ae'y(o 8e Tb Kar airrrfv Trjv Tiyjfrjv ^ikTiarov yiyvofxevov

Tov 8e Trf TToAet re Kat avrbv avT(a (ieXTCa-TOV ovtos to,

n^oAAa bir\p.apTr]K6ra, ^re olfxai av(V vov b6^rf TreTTto-reuKoVa.

ovTdiS be TovTdiv i\6vT(iiv, dpa ovK dv opd&s XiyoifXv b
(f)dvTs TToWifS Tapaxrj^ T Kal dvofxCas ixearrfv (Ivai TrfV
Toiavrrfv TTokiTeCav;

d 6 /cal ra\\a B Koi kut liWa T : d 9 irtpl secl. Cobet rt T

om. B d 10 eiri(TT-{}fjLova T iiriffr-f^/xoya elvai B
: ipo] jua
Cobet e i ivStivl Sf7v Baiter e 4 5i koH T Stobaeus Se B :

re Kol T Stobaeus al B : e 5 6' B T om, Stobaeus rovrois

:

Stobaeus roiovrois B T
: ots (vel &v) Dobree ofs B T Stobaeus :

e 7 ^TopiKuv B TtoKiriKwv T : a 2 riva B om. T a 3 ^va T : :

?i/a Kol B a 6 rvyxdvei in Gorgia 484 e T rvyx^^i^V ^^^^ B T in :

Gorgia loc. cit. B rvyxo^foi ci.

: Hermann Kpdria-ros] fifKriaros
Gorg. loc. cit. a 8 Svros recc. oStois B T :
146 b nAATX2N02
AA. 'Op6&s ixivToi vi) Aia.
5 2i2. OvKovv avayKoiov rjfuv iboKH olrjdrjvai beiv irpCi-
Tov Tjjxas elbevai. rj rw ovtl t8eWi tovto o ^v Ttpoyjeipuii

^eAAa)/xey rj "npaTTHv r} kiynv;

AA. 'E8o/cei.

212. OvKovv K&v fxev TrpaTTri & ris otbcv r) SoKei (Ibevai,
lo TrapeTTTjrai be to (o^eAi/xft)?, Kal Au(rircA.owT(os rjiia^ e^eti'

C Kal Trj TToKit. Kol avTov avT^;

AA. ria)? yap ov;
212. 'Eay 8e' y' ot/xai TavavTiQ. tovto^v, ovre ttj Trokei.

ovT^ avTov avT^;

5 AA. Ov bfJTa.

212. Tt be; Kal vvv hi axravTMS <roi boKfl ^ 6,kkm ttws;

AA. OvK, ctAA.' ourcos.

212. 'Ap' ovi^ ((f)r]cr6a KaAety rou? jutev TroAApvs &^povai,

Tovs f okiyovs <f)poviixovs;
lo AA. "Eytoye.
212. OvKovv <f)ap.ev iraAty rovs TroAAoi? bvi]iiapTr]Kivai
Tov jSekTLo-Tov, m Ta iroAAci ye otfxaL avV vov bo^ ire-

TTLa-TfVKOTaS.

d AA. 4>a/>tei' ydp.

212. Auo-treAet a/)a rot? TroAAoty firjr* clbivaL fxrfbev fxrfT

oUa-6aL (Ibivai, etirep ye fxakkov iTpo^vfxrfcrovTaL irp&TTUv

fxkv TavTa &TT av elbaxrLV rj olr]6Q)crLV clbivaL, irpaTTOVTfS

6 8e /SAaTrreo-^at to. TrAeio) fxakkov rj w^eAeto^^ai.

AA. 'AAr;^e'oTara A^yet?.
212. *Opas ovv, 6t y (f)r]v KLvbvvevcLv t6 ye t&v &kX()v
e iTTL(JTr]fx(jv KTrifxa, kdv tls dvV ttjs tov j^ekTLorov (TTLaT-qfxr^s
KKTr]ix4vos r], okLydKLs fxev w^eAetr, ^kdiTTLV 8e to. TrAe^o)

Tov ^xpvTa avTo, ap* ovxl rw wrt 6p6S)S k(^aLv6fxr]v keyoov;

b 5 7JIJUV iS6Kfi B iS^Kei rifitv ehai T

; bgi^Ti^oBc^&b
b lo rrapfinirai B vapeirfrat T
: 5e T oiti. B d 3 vparreiv
:

fjLfv B : /t^y irpirrftv T d 7 Sre 7' T Sre B 8t' Stobaeus : :

KtrSwevetj' Stobaeus KivSvvfvft B T

: 6 2 oAiyt^KJs] ^xfya Cobet
 :

AAKIBIAAH2 AEYTEP02 1466

AA. Kat ei /x^ rore, dAAa yOy /xot Sokci, oi Sw/c/jarcy.

2X2. Aci apa Kal 7t6X.i.v Kal \frvx^]v ti]V iJ,iXkov(rav opOQs
j3t,aKT(T6aL Tairnjs ttjs finaTrjixrjs avTxe<T6ai, cltcxv&s 5
&(nTp a(r6vovvTa laTpov r/ riyos KV^pvi^Tov tov acr(f}a\&s
fi\\ovTa tt\lv, &VV yap TavTrjs, ocnoTT^p av Xafxirpo- 147
Tcpov iiTOvpCcrr] t6 ttjs rv-xrjs rj TTpl yjpr]p.AT(jiv KTrj(rt.v rj

acafjuiTos p(ji\xr]v r] Kal oAAo rt Toiv roiovrcoy, ToaovT^a /xet^o)

ajxapTrifxaTa dir' avT&v avayKalov (mv, a>s eotxe, yiyv(r6ai.

6 lik 8t) Tr]v KdkofVfXvr]v iTokvfia6iav re kclI TTokvT^xviav 5

KKTr]fiVos, 6p(pavos h a>v TavTTfs Tr]S cTTLcrrqp.rjs, ayo-
fiVOs 8e vTTo /Atds cKacTTris t&v &kk(ov, ap' ovxl rw Svti
biKaictiS TTokkia \i.fi5>vi \pr](TTai, &t oTfxai avv Kvfi^pvrfTOV
hiaT^kSiV v TreAdyet, xp6vov ov' fxaKpbv (3iov ^icov; &(tt b
(TVfx^aiviv fxoL 8oKet Kai erraS^a to tov TTOLrfTov, o kiy^L
KarrjyopSiV ttov tlvos, ws apa iTokka fXV qTi C(rTaTO
^pya, KaK&s 8e', (f)r]aiv, ?/7rto-raro iTavTa.
AA. Kat rt 87/ Trore (TVfx^aivL to tov iTOLrfTov, 2w- 5

KpaTs; ifxoL fXv yap ou8' ortow 8okl TTpos koyov lpr]KvaL.

2i2. Kat fxdka ye iTpbs koyov dXA,' alviTT^Tai, S) /3eA-

rtore, Kat ovtos Kal aAAot 8e Trotjjrat o-x6o'i; rt TTdvTS.

(rTLV T yap <f)vcrL TTOtrjrtK^ rf crvfXTTacra alvLyfxaTcabrfs Kal
OV TOV TTpOCTTVXOVTOS CLvbpbs yV(Opi(TaL' TL T TTpbs T& C
<f)TLi(TL TOLaVTTf LVaL, OTttV kd^TfTUL dvbpbs <f)6oVpOV T Kttl

fxrf fiovkofxivov rjfxiv vbiKvva-6aL dAA' diTOKpnitTT^cr^aL otl

fxakLcrra Tr]v avTov (To(f)iav, inTp(f>v6is br] to xprjpia cbs

bvcryv(i)crTov <f)aivTaL, otl Trore voov(tlv Ka(rTos avT&v. 5

e 3 SoKei] SoK(7s Sauppe a i Hvev yhp ravrris huc transposuit

Lennep ante ^ irpl xprif^''''^^ habent B T
: \aixvp6Tfpov Lennep
\a$p6Ttpov Sauppe /*)) irpSTepov B T :a 2 fTovplfft) T ivovp^fitrij B :

rixv^ ci. Stallbaum : tpvxv^ BT a4 afiapT^fifiara T : afi.dpT7]na

B a 5 woXvfjt.aOiav T <pi\ofiadiav B : iroA.wTex'^' B : ^A.otsx'"'*"'
T b I $iov Stephanus $iov B T : dftov Stephanus : Bfuv B
ediv T ir\iu)v Schanz
: b 8 Sa.Ao scripsi : &M01 B : 01 liWoi T
e I T6 B 8i T c 2 TotowTTj T tojovttji/ B
: : c4 SJ) T : 5e B
05 voovcriv T : vofi.i(fTai B
PLATO, VOL. II.
23
I47C nAATi2N02
ov yap 67)7701) "Ofxrjpov ye rbv OeLOTarov re Kat (ro(})(aTaTov
TTOtrjTrjv ayvotiv 8oKets &)s ov\ olov re ^v kTtia-TacrOai

KaKm -eKetyos yap eoriy 6 kiyoiv tov MapytVrjy TroWa

d iikv eTTto-rao-^at, KaKws hi, (jyrjcri, TtavTa riTTLaTaTo ak)C
aivLTTTa(. oijuai TTapdya^v t6 KaK&s [xv clvtI tov KaKov, t6
8e riTTL^rTaTo avT\ tov kTTicrTa^rOaL' yiyvcTaL oZv (rvvT(9^v
efco pikv Tov p.iTpov, ^cttl 8' o ye /3ovAerai, wy iroWa fxkv

riTTi(TTaTO pya, KaK6v 8' avT(a TrdvTa TavTa,

5 ify kTTLcrTacrOaL

hrjkov ovv 6tl (tiTep rjv aurai KaKoy t6 ttoXXcl dbival,

(fyavkos TLs oiiv Tvyxavv, e?7rep ye Trtoreveti' Sei rots
7TpoeLpr][XVOLS XoyoLS.

e AA. 'AAA' e/uoi /xei SoKei, oj SwKpares* q x^^^''^^^ 7

av dkkoLS rto-t iTLcrTivcraLp.L koyoLS, eiTrep /ixr;8e tovtols.
212. Kai 6p65>s ye o^oi 8oKet.
AA. riaAti' aS /xot 8oKet.

5 2X2. 'AAAa </)epe Trpo? Aio'? opfis yap hriiTov ti]v diTopiav

o(rri re Kat ota, TavTrjs h^ Kal crv fxoL boKis KKOLV(ovr}KvaL'

p.Ta^akk6p.v6s yi tol dv(ti Kat KdT(a ovb^ otlovv TTavrj,

dkk' OTL dv /xdtAtoTci o-ot bd^rj, tovto kuI (KbebvKevai av

148 Kat ovKCTL bxravTCiis boKLV et ovv (roi y tl Kal vvv
p.(pavris yv6p.vos 6 ^eos Trpos ov TvyyJw^Ls TTopv6p.vos
p(aTri(rL, TTplv OTLOvv v^acr6ai (rc, et e^apKeo-et o^ot cK^ivoov
TL yV(r6aL &VTTp Kal V dp-)(rj eAe'yero, eire Kai avT(a croL

5 TTLTp\frLV V^acr6aL, Ti TTOT dv OLL rj T&V TTap KivOV

bLbop.V(i)v kap.^dv(iiv ri avTos V$dfXVOS yVcr6aL tov
KaLpov TVX^Lv;
AA. 'AAAa /ua tovs 6v6s, kyu) piev ov6V dv lixoLfxi (roL

^liT^Xv, 0) ^(aKpaTs, o{>T(t)S' dkkd fxdpyov rt [xol boKL etz/ai.

C 7 &)j B : 3ti T C 8 kokus B /coAws

: T /iapylTTiv T :

tiopyelrriu B di i)iri<TTaTo Bekker : fvl(rraadai BT da KaKov]

kokSv Cobet d 3 fiiri^rraTO B iviaTaro T d 4 <( -ye corr,
:

Par. 1812 gre B grjT

: d? 5e?T: Seoi B
: e6 S^ T S^ :

B Kal av fioi SoKus B fioi Sokus Koi aiiT : e 8 8ti B 8vep T :

H' 3 ^apKeaei T ^lap/ceVete B : a 4 ipxr ^ ^PXV '''' ^ *''''*

Koi T Kol B
: ag fiApyov T napy6v B neya ipyov Dobree : :
 AAKIBIAAHS AETTEP02 i^Sb

Koi ws akrjd&i iroXXrji (pvkaKrjs, otto)? p/ A.7jo-ei ns avroi' b

VXp[M(vos nev KttKti, boK&v 8e rdya^a, eTreir' oAiyor e'7rio-)((tfi',

OTTep Kat av lAeyes, TroA.ti^wS?/, dreuxo/^ei^os arr' av t6

TrpZrov evr/rai.
2X2. 'Ap' ouy oux^ et8c)s rt irXiov rnxoiv 6 7roiJ/r^9, o5 5
Kat iv dpxf? Tou Aoyou (TTiivri(r9r]v, tcl b^iXa Kal ixr)(pixivois

aTToX^^dv eKeAeuey;
AA. 'E/Liotye boKei.

212. ToCror /uei' toCvvv, S 'AAKtj8td8j/, Kai AaKcSai-

fwvLOL Tov T70Lr\Tr]v ^^r^kitiKOTis, eire Kat avrot ouro)? eTre- C
o-Kefi/iteWt, Kat tSta Kai hr^ixoaia kKacTTOTe irapaTrkria-Lav

fvxrjv evxovTaL, tcl Koka ^ttI rots ayadoTs tovs Oiovs bLbovai
KekevovTcs av (r^Catv avToXs' "TrAeto) 8' ouSets hv kKeCvoiv
(v^afiivoiv aKov(TLv. roLyapovv ets ro TTapi]Kov rov xpovov 5
ovbivctiv rjrrov evTT^x^^^ et<rti' 6vdp(>)7TOL' et 8' dpa Kat or/i-

p4(3riKev avrots wo-re /z^ Trd^ra evrvxfi^ ^kk^ ouy (ov) 8td
r^y ^KeCvoiv evx^/y fTrt rot9 ^eot? 6' eorti' cSore oT/xat Kat d
8t8oVai B,rT &v tls evxopifvos rvyxo-V!! kcl^l ravavrCa rovroov.
(3ovkop.aL be (tol Kal erepov tl Str/yi/o-ao-^at, o Trore rJKovaa
[tSiv TTpecr^vTipoiv] TLVutv, b)s ^A&qvaCois kol AaKeSatjuoytots

bLa(f>opa.s yevopiivrjs (Tvvi^aLviv ael rfj TrdAet r}fx&v &are 5

Kat Kard yr]v kol Kara ddkarrav OTrdre fxdxv yivoLro
bvaTvx^LV Kal nrjbiTTore bvvaadaL KparrjaaL' rovs ovv 'A^r/-
yatous dyavaKTovvras r^ TrpdypxiTL kcu diTOpoviiivovs rCvt

Xprj ixrfxcLvfj rGtv TTapovroav KaKtav dTrorpOTTrjV evpeXv, ^ov- e

kivo\xivoLS avrols boKilv KpdrLarov etyat TTeix^avras Trpos

b I Kijffn Buttmann X-ficrri B T : b 2 tA iyaOii B ayaOii T :

b 3 ira\iP(f>Su h.vfvxififvos t KaKiv(fZiav evx^h^fos B T : Stt' hv B :

fiTTa T b 5 n^dov B vKelwv T b 6 5ei\A Buttmann

: :

Seivit T Sri\a B
: b 8 ^noiye B ifiol im4v toi T b 9 Aouce-
:

SaifiSvioi B ^a/ceSat/uc^ctot ot T
: c 2 ko2 /5/^ T /8/9 B C 4 aiJ] :

ael Buttmann irKflu scripsi irXf luv B irAeto' T : C 6 ovSfvcnv :

T oiiS^' ' B
: 070 add. corr, Laur. Ixxxv. 6 d i &o-t
oljuot B olfiai Sxrrf T
: d 4 ruv irpftrfivTtpoiv seclusi ruv :

irpfcrPvTfpwv Tivwv B if irpfcr^vTfpwv rivwv T

: ti/ vpf<TfivT(pwv TLvhs :

Cobet d 6 dTrtJTt B dir^Ttw T ;

28*
I48e nAATHNOS
"Afxfxoiva eK^lvov (TTepoiTav' tl 8e Trpbs rovrots raSe, [xat]

avd^ oTov TTore AaKeSat/iAoi^iots ot ^eot fxakXov viKrjv 8t8oWtj;

5 7] (r(j)(cnv avroLS, o% TrAeto-ras, (f)dvat,, [xev Qvcrias Koi koX-

KicTTas T&v 'EXA.rjvtoy ayofxcv, avaOiffxaa-i re K^KoarfxrfKafxev

To. Upa avT&v 0)? ovbivcs ^AAot, TTOfXTrds re iroXureXecrraras

Kat (TffxvoTdTas khcapovfxeOa rots ^eots dv Kaa-Tov ctos, Kal

149 eTcXovfxev \prffxaTa ocra ovb^ aAAot crvfXTravTes "FtkXrfves'

AaKbaLfxovioi.s bi, (j)dvai, ou8e7rw7ror' efxiKrjo-ev ovbev tov-

TOiv, dAA.' ovTOis dA.tyoi)/!)ft)? 8i(iKetyrat irpos tovs Oeovs, &crTe

Kcu dvdiTrfpa Ovovo-lv kKdcTTOTe kcu raXAa TrdvTa ovk dXiyo)

5 evbeecTTipcas tlpl&ctlv rfnep rffxets, XPW'^''''^ ovbev eAdrrci)

KKTr]fxivoi TTJs fffxeTepas iroXecos. eTrei brf dprfKevaL ravra

Kat eTTepctiTTfcraL Ti XPV TTpaTTOvTas avTovs tQ>v nrapovTcov

KaK&v diTaXXayrfv dXko fxkv ovdev aiTOKpLOrfvaL rbv
evpelv,

b 7Tpo(f)riTrfv Tov ydp Oebv ovk edv brjKov otl KaAeVarra 8e

avTov, ^AOrfvaioLS, (f)dvaL, Tdbe Kiyei "ApLfxcov (^rfa\v h.v

^ovkecrOaL avT(a TrfV AaKebaLfxovicov ev(f)rffxiav etvai fxdXXov

^ TOL crvfXTTavTa t&v 'EXkrfVcov iepd. ToaavTa eliTeLV, ovKeTL

5 TTepaLTepct). TrfV y ovv ev(f)rffxiav ovk dXKrfv TLvd fxoL SoKet
XeyeLV 6 6ebs rf Trfv evxv^ avT&v ecrrt ydp rw oiti ttoAu
C bLa(pepovcra tS>v dkkcov. ol fxev ydp dAAot "EAArjyes ot

fxev XP^^coKepoiS fSovs TrapacrTrfcrdfxevoL, erepoL 8' dvadrffxacTL

bcopovfxevoL tovs deovs, evxovTaL oltt dv tvxiI Tavra, dvTe

dyaOd dvTe Ka^d' jSkaa-^rffxovvTcov ovv avrSiV aKOVovTes ol

5 ^eot ovK diTobexovTai Tas TToXvTekeXs Tavracrl TTOfXTTds re

Kal Ovaias. dAAd SoKet fxoL TTokkrfS ^vkaKrjs beLaOaL Kal
a-Keyfre(as ori Trore prfTeov ea-Tl Kal fxrf.

63 T< T : Tj B TcfSe Cobet TaS : u koI B : TtfSe koI T : /col

TciSe Stallbaum e4 irorfT om. B

; e 5 outo?s secl. Cobet
e6 avad^i/jiaffi T : avaOtfiaffi B a i SaAoi scripsi : SAA.ot B : oi
&\\oi T a4 0A/7C0 t : oKiyoDS BT a 5 ijirep recc. : i) elvep BT
Xp^h/Ji^tira ovShv iKdrrw B : ovSiv iKdrrw xp^flM-^^ra T a6 iireiSij

B : ^Trei T : ivel 5' Schanz a7 koI : B

t /cal T b2 adr]vaiois
<l>dvai T <pavai : adrivaiois <pdvai B : 'Adrjvaiovs c/xivot Hemsterhuis
b 5 yovv B T S' : otv Sauppe b6 eo-Tt T : tj B c 5 towtoo'!
B Towos T
:
 AAKIBIAAH2 AETTEPOS 149 c

Ev/37Jo-eis be koI Trap* 'Ofxrjpc^ (repa TrapaTrAr/o-ia tovtols

flprm^va. (f>ri(rlv yap tovs TpS>as ^TiavXiv 7roiovp.vovs d
^pbe.tv a6av<iTot,(rL reXT^eero-as (KaTOfx^as*

Tr}v be KvT(rav k tov ireStov tovs avepLovs (pipeiv

ovpavov eio-ci)

r}biZav' Tr]S 8' ov ri Oeovs \xaKapas baTeea-Oai, 5

ovb^ ideketv fjAka yap (t(\>lv ainixOeTo "IkLos Ipi)

Kol YIpCaiJLOS KOL kabs eu/A/ueAta) npia/otoio* e

&<rT ovbev avToTs ^v irpovpyov 6vlv re Kal btapa TeAeiy
fidTrjv, 6(oXs aT:rjy6rip.ivovs. ov yap OLfxaL tolovtov ((ttl

t6 t&v 6e5>v &(rTe imo b(ap(ov 7rap<xye(r6aL olov KaKov

TOKL^rrrjv' akka Kal rjfxeLS evrfdr] koyov keyofxcv, a^LOVVTes 5
AaKbaLfxovL(av TavTrj iTepLeTvaL. kol yap h.v bcLvbv etrj et

Trpbs TCL b&pa kol tcls 6v(TLas aTT0^k(TT0V(TLv rffx&v ol 6(oX

akka fxrf irpbs TTfv yl/vxw> ^^ ^'s ootlos Kal bUaLos obv

Txr/x<xvy]. TTokk^ ye fxakkov oi/xat 17 iTpos tcls TToAureAets 150

TavTas 7T0fXTT<xs re Kat 6v(rLas, hs ovbev KwAt/ei TroAAa fxcv
(is 6(ovs, TTokka 8' ds av6p(aTT0vs rjfxapTrfKOTas Kal tSiwTTjy
Kat TToAti' ix^^LV dv' ^KaaTov ^tos Tikiiv ol bi, dT ov
boiipoboKOi ovTs, KaTa(j)povov(rLV aTrdvTcov tovt(ov, u>s (j)r]<TLV 5
6 ^eos Kai ^e&v Tr/ao^Tjrrjs. Kti^Swevei yovv Kal xrapa

^eots Kat Trap' dvdpcaTTOLs roi? vovv exovo-t bLKaLO(rvirr] re

Ktti (f>p6vr](rLS bLa(f)p6vT(t>s TTLpLrj(r6aL' (f)p6vLfxoL b^ Kal b
8iKatoi ovK ^AAot rti^e'y eto-ty [77] t&v eiSorcor h 8et iTpdTTfLV
Kai kiycLV Kal TTpos 6ovs Kal iTpbs dv6p(aTTovs. ^ovkoLfi,r]v
8' dv Kal vQ
(Tov Tn}6i(r6aL otl ttot kv ex^t? rrpbs ravra.
AA. 'AAA' e/ixoi fxiv, S> ScoK/sarey, ovk dkki] ttj] 8oKet ij 5
r}TTp (TOL T Kal rw 6&' ovbe ydp dv etKos etrj dvTL\l/r](f)0v

fX rw ^ew yVadaL.

e 2 ^v irpoif>yov B irpovpyov JjvT

: a i 76 B om. T a 6 (i^ :

de&v Buttmann irpo<fr{)Ti\s T vpoifyfiTaii B : vpoiprjTai Baiter :

b2 ^ del. Winckelmann b 3 AfVetj/ koI T \fyf ty B b 5 /teV :

T om. B
: b6 ^irfp t thep : BT
b 7 yiv4(rOa.i B ylyytodai T :
I50b nAATHNOS
2X2. OvKovv ixfjjLvr^aai h TtoXXfj aTTOpCa (\)a(TKOiV elvai,

C 0770)5 /at) kdOrjs (rmvTov v\6[ivos KaKd, boK<av 8e ayaOd;

AA. "'Eycoye.

Si2. 'Opfis ovy o)S ovk dcrcf^aKes (toC ecrriy eXOelv Trpbs
Tov Oiov v^oijJv(a, tva pirjb' hv ovtoo tvxJJ) ^ka(T(\)r]p.ovvT6s

5 (Tov dKOV(av ovd\v aTrobe^rjTaL Trjs 6v(rCas TavTrjs, tvxov be

Kal Tep6v TL TrpocraTToXavcrris. efxol pi.V ovv boKeX ^iX-
TLCTTOV etvaL f)(rv\Lav exeiy ttj piev yap AaKebaLpLOVL(i)v

evxf? ^i-d Triv n^yaXo^vxCav tovto yap fcdAXtcrroi' tSiv (v

d(f)pO(rvvri ye ovopidTOiiV ovk hv oTp.aL cre kOikeLV yj)ri(T6aL.

d dvayKaXov olvv ((ttl Trepi/xeVetr i(t)s &v tls lJ-d6r] o)S bel Trpbs

deovs Kal TTpbs dv6p(aTTovs SiaKeio-^ai.

AA. rioTe ovv TTapecTTaL 6 xpovos ovtos, S) SwKpares,
Koi tCs 6 TraLbevcrcov ; ^'8io-ra ydp &v jxol boK(a Ibelv tovtov

5 TOV dv6pO)TTOV tCs koTLV.

212. Ovros w p.eKeL iTepX (tov. dXkd boKeZ fioL, uxTTrep

rfc) ALop.rjbeL ^r/o-iv Tr^v ^A6r]vdv "Ofxrjpos dirb tS>v 6^6dknG)V

a^pekelv ttjv dxkvv,

o(f)p' ev yLyv(a(TK0L qfxev 6ebv rjbe Kal avbpa,

e ovTO) Kal (TOL beXv diro Trjs ^XV^ irpSiTov Tr)v dxkvv d</)e-

kovTa, fj vvv TTapovcra TvyxdveL, rb TrjvLKavT 7/8rj Trpoo-^epeiy

8t' wy p.ekkeLs yv(a(Te(r6aL ^p.ev KaKbv -qbe Kal e(r6k6v. vvv

piev yap ovk dv p.0L SoKeis bvvr]6fjvaL.

5 AA. 'A^atpetrco, ehe ^ovkeTaL Trjv dxXvv eiTC dkko tl'

b)S eyo) irapecrKe-vacTp.aL fxr]6ev dv ^uyety tS)V vtt' eKcCvov

TTpo(TTaTTOfxevo)v, oa-TLS TTOT 0-tIv dv6po)7TOS, et ye ixekkoLfxi

^ekTCo)v yevecr6aL.

C 4 6u|o|i'^ recc. : fi/xofievtp B (v^a/x(V(f) T

: C 6 $e\Ti<TTov B :

KpdTKTTOv T c8 ^/] iw' Sauppe Cg 76 T: om. B

d6 S /teA.e vapb, (Tol Naber 6 i a-olB: aov T tV X^i"'
cupf^SvTU B : h(pe\6vTa t^Jj' dx^^" ^ 3 /J-eWfiS B ix4\\i T :

e6 irapTK(va(Tfiat T : irapaffKevacTfxai B (pvye7v B : ^ei^yeij/ T

e 7 irpotTTaTTOft.evdiv T : itpaTTOfj.fvccv B avdpuiros Schanz : avOpti)-

vos B 6 ^i/Opwiros T
: jUeXXot/Ui T : fifWoi fiii B
 AAKIBIAAH2 AETTEP02 i5ia

2X2. 'AAAa /xrjy KaK^lvos davfiaarrjv oa~qv Trepl o-e 151

TTpodvixCav exet.
AA. Ets t6t tolvvv Ka\ ttjv Ovaiav ava^AWiadai.
Kp6.Ti.aTov ivat fjioi boKeX.

212. Kat opd&s yi (toi 8oKet* aa-(f)a\ia-Tpov yap kariv 5

t] TTapaKLvbvveveLV ToaovTov Kivbvvov.
AA. 'AAAa ir&s, o) 2<oK/5ares; Kal \xr\v tovtovX tov
aT(f)avov, CTTtb-q fxoL boKLS KakoJs a-vp.^^ovkVKvaL, aoX

TT^pLdrja-uf Toty dcoTs b Kal a-T(f)avovs kol raAAa Travra b

TCL vop.L^6yLva t6t b(a(rop.V, OTav KLvr]v ttjv rjfx^pav
ikOovaav Xbco. rj^L 8' ov 8ta [xaKpov TovToav OcK^VTcav.
2X2. 'AAAa b\op.aL kol tovto, kcu aXKo 8e av tl t&v
irapa aov bodivTiav rjbicos iSotjLtt b^ap.Vov kfiavT^v. waTTcp 5
8e Kai 6 Kpiojv FivpLiTLbrj TreTTOtrjrat tov Tetpeo-tay lba)v

\ovTa To. a-T(f)ri kol cLKOva-as cltto t&v TToX^fxCccv aTTapxas

avTov L\r](f)vaL 8ta Trjv Tyvr]v,

oioovbv kOifxriv, <f)r]aL, KakkCvLKa {(ra) (TT(^r]'

v yap KKvb(i)VL kC[X0', &(nTp otada aij' 10

ovToo Se Kayo) TTapa aov Tr]V b6^av ravrrjy olcovbv TCO^fxaL.

boK(a be fxoL ovK v cXdTTovL KXvboovL Tov KpiovTos etrat, c
Kat (3ovkoCpLr]v hv KaXkCvLKOs y^viaOaL tS)V awv ipaar&v.

aI KOKuvos T : fKuvos B a 8 ^vfi$fPov\evK(yat B cre avfi- :

$ov\(VK(vai T b 4 Jjj' Tt corr. Coisl. avrl B T b 7 oir^ T :

:

^h B b9 <rcb Euripides Phoen. 858 om. B T : b 10 Kfl/ifda B :

SiaKflfjifOaT bii 5J|aj/] Swpe^j' Ast : 5({(nf Buttmann oa ttv
T: om. B
 ;

innAPXos .v

V $IAOKEPAH2
St. II
p.225 212KPATH2 ETAIPOS

a 2i2. Ti yap to (f)i.XoKphis; ri Trore kcTTLV, koX tlvcs 01

(f^iXoKcpbds
ET. 'Eju,oi fj.ev boKova-Lv ot av Kephaivnv o^lQxtlv clttu

tS)V ixrjbcvos a^LU>v.

6 212. YloTepov ovv (Tol boKOvcriv yLyvtaa-KOvres otl ovbevos

icTTLV a^La, rj ayvoovvTcs; i yap ayvoovvTcs, avorjTOVs
Aeyeiy tovs (j^LkoKepbe^LS.

ET. *AAA' ovK avorJTovs Aeyo), dAAa Travovpyovs kol

b TTovrjpovs Kal rJTTovs tov Kipbovs, yLyvdocTKOVTas otl ovbevbs

ol^lA kcniv d^' &v ToXfx&arL KepbaLveLv, opxos ToXfmv 0iAo-

Kepbelv bi avaLoyyvTLav.
2i2. *Ap' ovv TOLovbe A^yety tov (f)LXoKpbrj, otov fav

5 (f)VTV(ov yecopybs avr}p Ka\ yLyvdcrKoov otl ovbevbs a^Lov

Tb (f^VTOv, a^LOL aTrb tovtov eKTpa(f>VTOs KCpbaCvcLv; apa
TOLovTov avrbv XcycLs;
ET. 'Atto TTavTbs 6 ye (fyLXoKepbrjs, o ^(oKpaTCS, oierat
betv KpbaLVLV.
o 212. M?7 fxoi ovT(os eiKTj, w(nrep tl -qbLKrip.ivos vtto tlvos,

C dAAa TTpoa-i^oiv p.o\ Tbv vovv aTTOKpLvaL, wo-irep hv ei ef

apxrjs ttoXlv r]pti>T(tiV' ovyX o/xoAoyeis Tbv (f>LXoKpbr] TTI-

aTrjpLova etrai Trept Trjs a^Cas tovtov odev KcpbaCveiv a^Lol;

9. 3 dfiwo-iv B : li^iiiffowriv T b5 ^ewp^bj T : yfupyiKhs B

 innAPXos aasc

ET. "Eyo^ye.
2i2. Tis ovv kTtKTTriixuiV Ttepl (f)VToiV TrJ9 a^Cas, kv oTToia 5

&^ia ^vTv6rjvai Kal &pa Koi X(opq; tva ti Kal ^/xfis TOiv
cro(f)<iiv pr^iMXTiiiV ip.l3aX(aiJ.iv, Stv ol 8e^tOi TiipX Tas bUas
KoXXi.eTTovvTat.

ET. 'Eyo) fxev oTpiai yeoipyov. d

2X2. T6 ovv a^LOvv KepbaCveiv &Wo ti A^yety rj oU^rdai
8cii' K^phaCvuv;
ET. Touro A^yco.
212. M^ ToCwv [X emxftjPft e^aTraTav, avbpa irpicr^v- 5

Tpov rjbrj ovTUi vios oiV, aTTOKpivop.cvos axnrcp vvvbr] h ovb^ 226
avrbs oUi, dAA' ws dArj^w? ciTre* ap' eorty ovTiva oUl
y(s}pyLK6v avbpa yLyv6p.Vov, Ka\ yLyvdxTKOVTa otl ovbcvos
a^Lov (f)VTevL To (fiVTov, oUcrOaL diro tovtov KcpbaCvcLv;
ET. Ma At" ovK ^yoayc. 5
212. Tt 5e; i-TnrtKoz; &vbpa yLyv(a(rK0VTa otl ovb^vos
cL^La (TLTLa ro) iinr^o Trapix^i, ayvoLV avTov oUl otl tov
XitTtov bLa(f)6CpL;

ET. OvK eycoye.

212. OvK apa oUTaC ye dTro ToijTOiv KepbaCvcLV t&v b
o-trtwy rwy /xTjSeyos a^CoiV.

ET. Ovxt.
212. Ti 8e'; Kv^epirqTrjv firjbevos dta to-r^a koi TnjSdAta
Tjj vr]L T:ap(rKva(Tp.vov ayvoelv otet ort ^r][XL0i6rj(reTaL Kai 5
Ktv8vyevo-ei Kat avros aTTok(r6aL Kal ttjv vavv aTtokia-aL
Kal & hv 6,yr) TtdvTa;
ET. OvK ^ycoye.
212. OvK 6.pa oUraC ye KcpbaCvciv aTtb t&v (TKev&v tQv
[xribfvos a^Coiv. C

C6 a|fa B
S|(a b a^la,
: : T
S/)^ Kal X^P9 ^ X^^P? '"'^ ^P9 ^
e Su recc. ifjifia\o/jL4vuv B
7 ififidXuftfv : i/xfidWu/jKV W
d.z rh
: &vT
. . ii^iovv Etwall (ed. Oxon. 1771)
. rhv . H^iov : rh . H^tov
: . . BT . .

vulg. 5 /ue iirixdpfi B

d iirixelpfi /ue : a 2 tlvi' ip' Boeckh T
{rtsponcU . . . an Ficinus) : Ifirtp BT a^ ^utv Stephanus :

^vTct/cii' BT Ktpiavtiv Cobet (et mox b i) a 8 iiaipOfpu Cobet

226c nAATi2N02
ET. Ov ydp.
2i2.'AAXa a-Tparr^yos yiyviaaKcav 6tl fj crTpaTia avT<a
ovbevbs a^ta oTrAa ex^ei, oterat aTro TovTa)v KepbaCveiv Kal

5 dftot KcphaivHv;
ET. Ovhap.5)'i.

212. 'AAA' avXr]TT]^ avAous ovb^vos a^tovs ix<>>v rj KiOapi-

a-TTjs Xvpav tj to^ottjs to^ov rj aAAos oa-TLcrovv a-vkXri^br]v

T<av br]p.Lovpy&v r/ t&v aXXoiV t&v pL(pp6v(av avbp&v p.r]bvbs

lo ata opyava r] aXXr]v 7rapaa-Kvr]v f]VTLvaovv iyjxtv ^irb TovTOiv

oUTaL KepbaLVLv;
d ET. OvKovv (f)aLVTaC ye.

212. TCvas ovv ttotc Aeyeiy tovs (f)LXoKpbLS ; ov ydp ttov

TOVTovs yc oiis bLcXr^XvOafjiev, (dAA') otrtres yLyv(acrKOVTS tcl

ovbvbs a^La aTTo ToijTcov oiovTaL bdv KcpbaCv^Lv dAA' oijToo

5 fxiv, S) 6avp,da-Le, ws av Aeyets, ovk (o-t dvdp(aTT(t)v ovbels

(})LXoKpbris.

ET. 'AAA' iy(a, o) 2(0KpaTes, j3ovXofxaL Xiy^tv tovtovs

^iAoKe/oSets eiyat, ot eKdoTore virb dirXr^aTCas Kal Trdvv

e a-]j.LKpa Kal oXCyov d^ta Kat ovbvbs yXCxpvTaL v7rp(j)V(as Kal

<})LXoKpbova-LV.

2i2. Ov brjTTOv, S) ^XTia-T, yLyv(o(TKOVTS OTL ovbvbs d^td

laTLv TovTO ]iv yhp rjbr] f]]ids avTovs rw Adyw ^Xy^a[j,V
5 ort dbvvaTov.

ET. "E/xoiye SoKei.

212, OvKovv et [xf] yLyv(aa-KOVTS, brjXov otl dyvoovVTS,
ol6]j.vol 8e rd ovbvbs dta ttoXX.ov d^ia Lvai.
ET. 4>atyerat.
lo 2X2. "'AAAo rt ovv ot ye ^iAoKe/oSets c^tAoCo-t to Kpbos;
ET. Nat'.

2X2. K^pbos be Ae'yft? vavTCov Trj Cvi^^^!

227 ET. 'Eycoye.

e3 crrpaTik T : ffrpareia B d2 irov B : 5^ irov T d 3 iw'

add. Apelt e8 ovSfvits BT : fxnSevbs vulg.
 innAPXos 227 a

2i2. "EaTLv ovv oro) ayadov ecrn CrjixLovadai.;

ET. OibvL
212. 'AAAa KaKov;
ET. Nai. 5
212. BAaTTToyrai vtto r^s Cw^^^ ^P^ &vdp(i)TToi.

ET. BAtiTrroyrat.
212. Ka/coz' apa 57 CvH-^^'
ET. Nai'.

212. 'Emyr^oy 8e rr/ C^jMta r^ Kcpbof. 10

ET. 'Emn-ioi'.
212. 'Aya^oy apa t6 Kepbo^.
ET. Na^.
212.Tovs ovv To ayadov (fyiXovvTas <f)i\oKpbis KaXeiy. b
ET. "EoiKfv.
212. Ov ixaviKovs ye, S> erat/oe, Ae'yets rovs ^tAo/cepdet?.
dAAa 0T> avroy -noTfpov ^iAets 6 Sy dya^oy 17, 77 ov ^iAeis;
ET. "Eycoye. 5
212. *'EoTi 8e rt ayaOov, o ov (fiiXeh, dAAd KaKov;
ET. Md At" ovK ^ycoye.
212. 'AAAd Trdvra rd dya^d to-cos ^tAets.
ET. Nar.
212. 'EpoO 8^ Kat e/xe et ov Kal cy(a' 6poXoyq(r(a yap Kal 10
eyw (Toi ^tAety rdya^d. dAAd Trpds e/xot Kai o-oi ot dAAot C
&.v6p(aTT0i aTravTes ov boKov(rC (roi TayaOa ^tAetr, rd 8^ KaKa
/xto-eii';

ET. "EjLiotye ^atVerat.

212. Td 8e Kcpboi ayadbv &fw\oyq(raixv; 5

ET. Nar.
212. ndirre? aS (piXoK^pbds (fiaivovTaL tovtov tov TpOTrov
hv 8e rd TTpoTcpov iX^yofxcv, ou8eis qv (f)i\oKpbi^s. iTOT4p(o

ovv &v ris ro) Ao'ya) \p(api.Vos ovk &v e^a/xa/srdrot;

a6 uwi Tjjs Ctifxlas &pa B : Spa vwb t^s Cvi^las T SyOpwiroi] S.vQpa)iroi
Hirschig b3 76 B : St T b 8 Tet B om. : T b 10 ov Koi B :

ovK T 2 Siroi^Tey B : irdvrts T 09 r<^ \(Py<^] tw' ^({701/ Cobet

227 c nAATi2N02
lo ET. Ei TL9, S) Sw/cpares oljj.ai. 6p6&s \afxl3a.voL tov
8' eoTi TOVTOv riyeXa-OaL (jyLXoKcpbi], bs hv
d (})LkoKpbi]. opOGiS
a-'7Tox)d6.C'[) Tt\ tovtols kol a^LOL KepbaCvcLV aTr' avT&v, d0' &v
OL xPW^^ol ov ToA/Awcri KepbaivcLV.
212. 'AA\' opas, S) yAvfcvrare, to KepbaCvcLv &pTL oifji.o\oyri-

5 a^ap.iv eimi ax^eAeio-^ai.

ET. Ti ovv br] tovto;
2i2. "Otl Ktti ro8e awrw TTpoa-(aixokoyria-ap.V, ^o-uKiadaL
ayaOa iravTas koX &i.
tol

ET. Nat'.
10 212. OvKovv Kal ol ayadol TtavTa to. Kpbr\ jBovKovTaL
\LV, LTTp ayaOA yk (TTLV.

e ET. OvK d0' Siv y \i.k\ovcrLV, S) 2a)/cpare9, ^\a^r\aa6aL

T&V KpboiV.
2f2. Bka^rja-eaOaL 8e Aeyei? ^r]p.L(o(ra-6aL rj 6.kko tI;
ET. OvK, akka frj/xtcoo-eo-^at Ae'ya>.

5 2X2. ^Ttto tov Kcpbovs oSy 0]fXLOvvTaL rj vtto Trjs CTj/uiay

avdpcoTTOL;
ET. 'Ttto a]i(\)OTp(>)V' koI yap vtto r^y C^/x^a? ^Tj/xioCrrai

Kai viro roiJ Kep8ous roS iTOvr]pov.

212. 'H SoKei ovy tl aoL yjpr]arov koX ayadbv TTpayfxa
10 TTovr]p6v etvai;
ET. OvK l/iAOiye.

228 2X2. OvKow ti)p.okoyr](ra]iV okCyov TTpoTepov t6 Kipbos

Tfj C^/Aia KaKO) orrt evavTLOV elvaL;
*
ET. *r;/xr.

2X2. 'EvavTCov b^ ov KaKco aya66v elvai;

5 ET. 'Q,pLokoy^cra]Xv ydp.
2X2. 'Opas ovv, eTTLxcpe^LS fxe e^aTraTav, iirCTrfbes evavrCa
keycav oXs 6.pTL wfxokoyrfaafxev.

d2 dir' avrwv] airh twv Naber d 5 ftvai . . . d7 irpo(rwfio\oy{j-

aa/jLfpTb : om. pr. B d 7 avr^ h aiirh B T : d8 irdyras B :

Siiravras T e i ^t T b re B (ut videtur)

: 64 (itfjiiiifffffOai B :

(y\fjLiwd-!)<Tf(TOai T
 innAPXOS 228a
ET. Ov ixa Ata, S) 'EcoKpares, aWa TovvavTiov <tv jne

(^aiTaTds Kal ovk oi8a oirt) (v rois Aoyois avoi Kal K6.T(a
(TTp4(f)LS. lO
212. Ev(prip.(L' ov ixfVTav KaAois TroioCrjv ov TTdOotxfvos b
avbpl ayad^ Kal ao(j)&.
ET. TCvi rovrw; Kal tl p.a\i(TTa;

2X2. rioAtrTj piey e/xol re Kal <t&), rieicrioTpdrov 8e vei

ToC eK ^iAaiSwy, 'I^n-Trapx*!'^ ^? '"'^y Ileio-io-rpfitrov 7rat8cov 5
T]y 7rpeo-/3vraros Kat (ro(f)(oTaTos, hs aXka re TroAAa Kat KaAa
e/aya (ro(f)(as aTrtb^i^aTO, Kal to. '0[n^pov (ttt} irpCiTos eKo'/ixio-ey
eis T^y yr/y TavTrjvC, Kal rivayKacre tovs pa^(o8ovs ITaya-
OrjvaCois e^ v7ro\T^\j/(i)S e^e^y avTO. buivai, coo^Trep y{5y Irt
otbe TTOiov^ri.v, Kal eTr'
^
AvaKpiovTa tov Ti/toi' 'nevTrjKovTcpov c
ore^as iKoiiKTfV fls rrjy ttoXlv, ^ifxcovCbrjv 8e roy Ketor
det TTept avroy etxcy* /xeyciAots ixktOoIs Kal b(apoLS TTeCdoov'
Tavra 8' eTToiet j3ovX6p.VOS 7rat8euety rovs TroAfras, ty* wy
^eArtVTcoy ovtodv avT&v ^p\oi, ovk olopievos Seiy ovSeyt 5
(TO(f)Cas (f)Oovlv, 6.T o)V KoXos re KayaOos. eTretSTj 6e avro)
ot Trept ro aa-TV T&v ttoXlt&v TTCTTaibevixivoL ri^rav Kal
kOavixa^ov avrbv (TtI (TO(f)Cq, ^7rt/3ouAevcoi' av t(ws (v tols d
aypoLS TratSevo-at icrTriaV avroty 'Eppias KaTo. Tas obovs iv
/xeVo) Tov a(TTos Kal t&v bripxav eKaorrcov, KciTretra Trjs

(T0(f)Cas Trjs avrov, -qv t (ixaOev kol rjv avTos e^vper, eKAe^ci-
ixevos h fiyiLTo a-o(f)(aTaTa etyat, TavTa avTos evretvas ets 5
eAeyetov avTov Trot^/xara Kat e7rt8ety/ixara Trjs cro(f)Cas kir-

ypa\frV, Xva TrpaTov ixv to. kv AeAc^ots ypaixixaTa to, (ro(f)a e

"
TavTa fxri OavixdCoLV ol TroAtrat avrov, t6 re " FvoiOL (tovt^v
Kot To " Mribcv ayav " Kal rSAAa to. rotavra, dAAa ra
'I^TTrcipxov priixaTa ixaXkov (TO(f)a fjyotvTO, iiT^LTa iTapL6vTs

S,v(o Kal Kciirco Kai avayLyv(acrKOVTS Kal yvixa Kaixj3dvovTS 5

a 8 <rv fjLf B: tru ffxh T b 7 dire5e({aTo B T (sed i ex emend. T):

^e5({aT0 Coisl. iirfSd^aroW ^irij B om. C4 iraiSevcii'
: TW
W
:

B irflddv T
: C 5 ivTwv avruv B airruv ivrw T : d i aS
Toi>s T avrohs B
: d 3 4(rTes Schanz (et mox) t^j ffo<t>ias B :

wiri (To<pias T d 5 & T om. B :


228 e nAATi2N02
aiiTov Trjs (ro^Cas ^oiT&ev eK t&v ayp&v koL eTrt Ta A.oi7ra

TTaLbvdr)cr6fivoi,. e<rroy 6e bvo TUiTnypa}X}iaTV kv pkv rois

229 ctt' apicTTepa tov 'Ep/xoS kKdarov eTrtyeypaTrrat \iyo)V 6
^Epixrjs ort ei^ /ix,e'cra) roS aoreos Kai roO d^/xou <TTr]Kv, (V

8e rots eTTt 8e^id

fxvrjpt.a ToS' 'iTTTrdpxov' o-retxe biKaia (j)pova>v

5 ^r}(rCv. io-Ti. 8e rwy Trotrj/xdrcoy Kat oAXa ey aAAots 'E/)/xats

7roA.Xa Kat KaAa eTrtyey/ja/x/xeya* eo-rt 8e 8^ Kai roCro iin Trj

Sret/JtaKT/ 685, ey w Aeyet

b ixvrjpLa ro8' 'iTrTrd/axov ixrj <^Ckov k^aiTaTa.

eyo) ovy o-e e/;ioi oz^ra ^Ckov ov briTiov Tokixcorjv hv ^^a-naTav

Kd\ KCv<a TOlOVTia OVTl aTTKTTdv, OV Kal aTToOaVOVTOS TpCa
Tr) Tvpavvij0ria-av ^AOrjvaloL vtto tov ab(k(pov avTov 'iTnrCov,
5 Kat TrdvToov av t&v irakai.&v ijKOVcras ort TavTa jxovov to,

Trj Tvpavvh ^yiveTo ev ^A$rivai.s, tov 8' aAAoy \p6vov iyyvs

TL e^coy ^A6r]vaioi. Sa-iTep eTrt Kpovov ^aa-ikeijovTos. Aeyerat
8^ UTTO TMV -)(apiea-Tep(iiv dvdpdiTTOiV Kol 6 OdvaTos aVTOV
C yevia-dai ov 8t' h ol TroAAoi ^-qdria-av, Sta rriv rfjs abk<j)rjs

dTLiiCav Trjs Kavr](f>opCas eTret tovt6 ye cijr)9es AAa tov fxkv

'Ap/AoSioy yeyovivai TTaihiKd tov ^ ApiaroyeCTovos Ka\ TTCTTai-

bevadaL vtt' iKcCvov, fxiya 8' i(j)p6veL dpa kol 6 ^ApLaTO-
5 yetrcoi' eTrt rw 7rat8e{)o-at &v6p(aTT0v, Ka\ dvTayoiyvLa-Triv rjyeVro

etvaL Tov "iTTTTap^^ov. iv iKeCv<a 8e rw XP^^^ avTov tov

d 'Apix6bLov TvyxdvcLv ip&VTd tlvos t&v vi(ov re Kat KaAdiy
Kat yevvaCuiv tQv t6t Kat Aeyouo-t Tovvop.a avTov, eyc!) 8e
ov ixp.vriixaL tov ovv veavCcrKov tovtov Tiuis fxev davixdCcLV
t6v re ^ApixobLov KaX tov ' ApLcrToyeCTOva oas cro(f)ovs, iTreira

5 avyyev^ixevov ro) 'iTrTrdipx^p KaTa(ppovrjaaL KCvo)v, Ka\ tovs

TTepL^xkyria-avTas TavTrj rfj drt/jiia oifrcos dTroKretrat tov
"iTTTTapxov.

ai dirapicrrep^ BT imyeypavrai B; h i-Kiy4ypavrai TW

a 2 Srt B 8ri 6 T : a3 BT
iiriSe^i^ a 5 Se rwv irotrifidruv
B ruv KoirjiJ.druu Se T
: b 5 ndvruv tiv] irdvrus S)j Cobet /x6yov
B : fi6va T di koKuv koI yivvaiuv B yfvvaiuv koI Ka\uv T
:
 innAPXos 229d

ET. KivbvvVis Toivvv, S) ScoAcpare?, 17 ov (f)i\ov /x

rjyda-Oai ij, d Tjyfj (f)[kov, ov TrcC6<rdaL 'iTnrdpxi^' eyo) yap

OTTws ov (Tv p, (^aTiaTas ovK otS' ovTLva pivTOL TpoTTOv e
v Tols koyoLS, ov bvvafjiaL TTeL^rdrjvaL.

2X2. 'AAAa fxrjv Kal wcTrep TreTrevcoi' fOiko) aoL iv toIs

XoyoLS dvaOicrOaL otl (SovkfL t&v lprjp.V(t)v, tva fjLrj oXr]

(^aiTaTdaOaL. iroTepov ydp tovto (tol dvadS)p.aL, ws ov\l t&v 5

dyad&v TrdvTes eiiLdvy.ovKTLV avdp^oTTOi;
ET. Mrj p.oi ye.
2X2. 'AAA.' b)s To (jqixLova-Oai koi rj Cw^ ov KaKov;
ET. Mrj fxoL ye.

2X2. 'AXA.' 0)9 ov Tfj Cvi^^^ '^**' '"^ Cot^^-ovo-Oo.L t6 Kfpbos 10

Kol t6 KepbaCveLv kvavTLOv;
ET. Mrjde tovto. 230
2X2. AAA' fc)9 ivavTLOv ov t& KaK& ovk dyaOov cort t6
KpbaLVLV;
ET. Ovtl Ttdv ycTovri p.01 dvdOov.
2X2. AoKet dpa ctol, b)s eotxe, tov Kepbovs t6 fxfv tl 5
dyad6v etvai, t6 8e n KaKov.
ET. "E/xotye.
2X2. ^ AvaTidifiaL Toivvv croX tovto' 4<rT(o ydp brf Kepbos
TL dya06v kol tTepov Kepbos tl KaKov. Kipbos 8e' ye ovbiv
fwXkov ecTTLV avT&v t6 dya66v ?/ t6 KaKov "q ydp; 10

ET. Yl5)s fx po)Tas;

2X2. 'Eyo) (j)pda-o). a^iTiov iariv n dyaOov re Kat kokov;

ET. Nar. b
2X2. 'Ap' ouy /jtaAAoy rt avTStv karL t6 iTcpov tov kTepov
(TLTiov, Tf ofxoiois TOVTo ye, crtrta, eoroy dfKJ^OTCfta Kal TavTrf
ye ovbev 8ta</)epei t6 iTfpov tov kTipov, Kara t6 aiTiov etrat,
ctAAa ^ ro p-ev avr&v dyaOov, t6 8e KaKov; 5

ET. Nar.

d9 ^ c( Tiyei b :
^ ^e B :^ e! "yer T e 1 eri ^/tt W : <ri ^**/*^
B: ffv ixfT /ieWot B : om. T a2 tvT: om. B a la ^otC'
Tt T : iariv B b3 rovr^ B : Toirry T
230 b nAATI2N02
212. OvKOvv Koi TTOTov Kol Takka TrdvTa, ocra t&v
ovTcav TavTa ovTa tol iikv iriTTovdev ayada eivai, Ta 8e
KaKa, ovb^v kKiivrf ye biacf^ipet. to ^Tepov tov kTipov, jf to
C avTo kcTTiv; &(nTp avOpoiTTOs brJTTOv 6 piev xP^trTos iariv, 6
be TTOvqpos.
ET. Nai.
2X2. 'AAA.' avdpoiTTos ye oi/xat ovbiTcpos ovbeTcpov ovt

5 iXaWov ovT rJTTOV karTiv, ovT 6 \pr)crTbs tov TTOvrjpov ovtc

6 TTovrjpbs Tov yjpr\(TT0v.
ET. 'AXr]6r} Xiyns.
212. OvKovv ovTO) Kol TTipl Tov Kpbovs biavo(afX6a, cos

K^pbos ye opLoCois eort Kal Tb Tiovripbv koI Tb xprjcrTov;

lo ET. 'AyayK>7.
212. OvSey &pa fxaXkov K^pbaCvu 6 Tb xprjcrrbv Kcpbos
fXjav rj Tb irovrjpov' ovkovv pmWov ye Kspbos ^aiyerai
d ovbiTepov 6v, ws ofwkoyovixiv.
ET. Nai'.

212. OvbTep<a yap avT&v ovre Tb ixakkov otre rb rJTTov

TTpoa-ecrTLV.

5 ET. Ov yap brj.

212. To) brj ToiovT<a TTpdyixaTt tt&s &v tls fxakkov 17 rJTTOv
oTLOvv hv TTOLol rj TTdaxpL, w fxrjbeTepov TOVTcav TTpoaeCr};
ET. ^AbvvaTov.
212. 'EiTeLbr] tolvvv Kepbi] fxev 6/xoico? ecrrtv afxc^oTepa
10 Ka\ Kepbdkea, tovtX br] bel rjpns eTTL(TKey^a<T6aL, 6ia tl iTOTe
apL<f)6Tepa airra Kepbos Kakels, tl TavTov ev a]x<f)OTepoLS bpStv;
e &a-7Tep hv el [h] a-v fxe ripcaTas to. vvvbr], bia tl iTOTe koI t6
ayadbv ctltlov Kal Tb Ka^bv ctltlov o/xotcos d/x0ore/)a crLTia
KoXSt, eX-JTOv av o-ol StoVt afx^poTepa $r]pa Tpo(j)r] a-<ap.aT6s

Cg rh irovriphv Koi rh xprio^T^v B : t^ xpri^rrhv Koi rh iTovi]p6v

TW e 12 ^ ^i) rh Stephanus 0.3 oire .
. oSre B:
.

ovSk . oiSk T
. . d. 6 S^] 5e Ast d. 7 irpoaeiri B : irpoffy T
d 10 Tovrl B tovt' Iti T: e i & del. Schleiermacher e2 dfiolws
B : Sfius T
 innAPXos 230 e

kcmv, bia tovto iyuiyv tovto yap etrat crvTiov Kav av ttov

ijfxiv 6fxo\oyoL9. ?] ydp; 5

ET. "Eycoye.
2X2. Kat -Trept ttotov ovv 6 avTos av Tpoiros eXr] r^s
aTTOKpia-eoii, otl t^ tov (r(opxiT09 vypa Tp6(^r\, cdvTe xp^or^
idvTe Ttovrjpa fi,
tovto to 6vop.d eort, ttotov Kal rots 231
d\\oL9 oicravTCiis. TTeLpca ovv Kal (tv e/xe ixLpLela-daL ovtoi}s

diTOKpLv6p.evov. To \pr]crTov Kepbos xat to TTOvrjpov Kepbos

Kepbos (f)fis diicpoTepov eXvaL tl t6 avT6 ev avrols op&v, otl
br) Kal TOVTo Kepbos eoTLv; ei 8' av fxrf avros Ix^'^ diTOKpC- 5
vacrOaL, dAA' ejxov keyovTos aKoiTeL' dpa Kepbos \eyeLS Txdv
KTrjfxa h &v tls KTr\aif]TaL r] fxr]bev dvaX(aa-as, ^ ekaTTOv
dvakoja^as iTXeov kdj3r];
ET. "EfxoLye boKot tovto KakeLV Kipbos. b
2X2. 'Apa KOL Ta TOLdbe keyeLS, edv tls eariaOeis, jxr^bev
dvaX(oa-as dAA' evo)\i]6eis, voaov KTrjoT^TaL;
ET. Ma At" ovK eyoiye.
212. 'TyieLav be Krqa-dfxevos dTTO ^OTtdo-ecos Kepbos hv 5
KTTycrairo 17 ^rjfxiav;

ET. Kepbos.
212. Ovfc &pa TovTO ye kcnL Kip^os, t6 otlovv KTqfxa
KTrja-aa-dai.

ET. Ov fxevToi. 10

212. TloTepov ovk, kdv Ka^dv; 77 ov8' hv dya66v oriovv

KTTfa-rfTaL, ov Kepbos KT-qcreTaL;
ET. tatVerai, edv ye dyadov.
212. *Edy 8^ KaKov, ov CvH-^^^ Krqcrerai; c
ET. "EfioLye boKet
212. 'Opaj ovv ws TrdAty av TrepLTpixeLS els t6 avro; t6
fxkv Kepbos dyaB6v (j)aiveTai, rf be C^juia KaKoV.

e5 dfioKoyoTs T : 6fi.o\oyt7s B a5 8^ b : 5! BT b8 -y/

B om. T
: b9 KritffaaOfu Tb : KTf\<i(a6ai pr. B (ut videtur)
b 12 fcT^(rTai T : Kri\<TrYrai B
PLATO, VOL. II. 24
 ; ; ;

231 c nAATXlNOS
6 ET. 'Awpw eywye otl e?7r(o.

2i2.OvK abUois ye (tv airop&v. ctl yap koI robe aTTo-

Kpivai' kav rts ikaTTOv dvaAwcras Trkiov KTrja-rjTai,, (j}fis

Kpbos iXvai;
ET. Oiirt KaKOv ye Xeyco, dAX' edy )(pv<rCov rj apyupLov
10 ekaTTOv avaX(a(ras -nkiov kd^rj,
d. 212. Kat eyci) fxikku) tovto kpria-^crOaL. (jiipe ydp, edy rt?
Xpva-Cov (TTadixov rjpiLcrvv dvak(i)aas StTrAdcrtoi' Ad/Sjj dpyvpCov,
Kepbos rj
CvH'^^^ eCkri^ev;
ET. ZrjjxCav brjTTov, oo .'2i(aKpaTS' dvTi boobeKaaracCov

5 ydp Sto-rdo-toy avrai KaOCaTaTai to yjpvcrCov.

2X2. Kat p.i]v Trkiov y etkr](f)V' rj ov irkeov eorri t6

bLTTkd(rLov Tov r}]XL(reos

ET. Ovri Ti] d^C(i ye dpyipLov yjpv(rCov.

212. Aet dpa, ws Olk, tG> /cepSet tovto TTpoccLvai, ttiv

lo d^Cav. vvv yovv to fxiv dpyvpLov irkiov ov tov \pv(rCov ov

(pfis d^LOv iLvaL, To be xp^^f^^o^ ikarrov ov d^LOv (f)fjs eirat.

e ET. 2</)d8/oa* exet ydp ovTOis.

212. Td ixV d^LOV apa Kcpbakiov karCv, kdvT (TfxtKpbv

j7 idvTe ixiya, to 8e dvd^iov dKepbh.

ET. Nar.
5 212. Td 8e d^toi Aeyets d^LOV eivai dkko tl ^ KeKTrjaOai;
ET. Na^, KKTrjcr6aL,

212. Td 8e d^toi; av kiyeis KKTfja-6ai to dvco^cAes r} t6

d)(j)kLixov

ET. Td b)(})kLIX0V b-qiTov.

232 212. OvKovv rd oi^ikLixov dya66v iariv;

ET. Nar.
212. OvKOVv, S dvbpiLOTaTC irdvTo^v, ov rd Kfpbakiov
dya66v av TrdXty TpCrov rj T^TapTov rJKei ripuv oixokoyovixevov
5 ET. "EotKey.

C 6 yap B : S^ T C 7 ir\4ov kt^Ct/to t KT^jffrjTot B : wA.eofefnr^-

:

ariTai T d. i /xeAXw toCto B toCto fifWto T d 5 Sicrrdfftov T :

W
:

SiffTaffifiov B d 10 xp^clov ov : xpi'0'^oi/ o5 (ri/ B xp^^riov T :

 innAPX02 23aa

211. Mvrjfxovevcis ovv 5dv r}jxiv ovto^ 6 Aoyos ycyovev;

ET. OtfiaC y.
212. Ei 8^ fxrj, iy<a o-e imoixirqcrco. riix(f)(T^riTr}(Tds fxoi

rov^ ayaOov^ /x?) irdvTa to. Kephr) /SovAeo-^at Kephaivuv,

dXka T&v K(pb&v TayaOd, ra 8e Trovrjpa fxrj. lo
ET. Natxi.
212. OuKouy i/uy irdvTa Tct Kcpbr] 6 \6yos rjfxas i]vdyKaKc b
Kal <Tp.i.Kpd KoX fxeydka 6fxoX.oyiv dyadd eirai;
ET. 'HrayKa/ce ydp, u> ^(aKpaTcs, fi.d\kov efii ye rj

7r-nLKV.

212. 'AA.A' to-(os /xera toCto Kal TreiVeiei' ai;' inJi' 6' ovv, 5
etre iTfTTeKTat elre ottojo^S^ ^X^^^ (TVfx(f)-ps yovv rjfxiv TrdvTa
Tci Kipbr] dyadd (Ivat, Kal (TfxtKpd Kal fieydka.

ET. 'OjnoAoya) yap ovv.

212. Tovs 8e xP^^ovj dvOpdtTtovs ^ovkea-dai, Tayadd
ofxokoyds diravTa aTravTas' rj ov; lo

ET. 'OjuoAoyci).

212. 'AAAa fxkv brf roijs ye TTovrfpovs aifrbs eiTres on xai C

(TfxtKpd Kal fx^ydka Kipbrj (f)tkov(riv.

ET. EtTToy.

212. OvKOW KaTa tov (tov koyov "ndvTis dvdpoiirot

0tAoKep8ets dv eter, Kal ol \pr](TTol Kal ot TTOvrfpot. 5

ET. ^^aiyerat.
212. OvK dpa opOSts wet8t^et, et rtj ro) dz;ei8(fei ^tAo-
Kep8et etyat* Tvy^dvit ydp Kai 6 raCra dyei8iX<wi' avros
TOtOVTOS <av.

a 6 oiv B y' oS/ T

: a8 ii/j.<t>i(T$'(iTT](ras B W : ^ afi<pi(T$riri)ffas T
b 4 ireVciKe T irtirei/cet B
: c i auTiij Bekker : avToi5 BT : om.
vulg. c 4 vdyTfs B : S,iraPTfS T

24*
 A
\

EPA2TAI
st. I
p. 132

a Eis Alovv<tiov tov ypaixjxaTKrTov el<rj]\6ov, Koi elbov

avToOt TGtv re viuiv tovs eTrtetKeardTov? So/cowras itvai ttjv
Ibiav Kal TraTepcav ivhoKiixoav, KaX tovtcov ipaa-Tas. iTvy-
yaviTy]v ovv hvo t&v ixctpaKiaiv kpi^ovTe, Trepl otov 8e, ov
5 a-(f)6bpa KaTrjKovov. (f)aLVa-6r]v fxivToi rj irepX 'Ava^ayopov
b rj irepl OlvoTrCbov kpi^eiv kvkKovs yovv ypa^eiv k<^aivia6r\v
KaX yK\Ca-lS TLVaS ip.L}JLOVVTO ToXv ^(ipolv (TTLKkLVOVTe Ka\
juoA.' ca-TTovbaKOTe. Kayca Ka6rj[xr]v yap itapa tov (paorrjv
. Tov hipov avTOLV KLvqaas ovv airrbv rw ayK&VL -qpofxr^v

5 ori TTore ovtms ea-iTOvbaKOTe ro) fxeLpaKm cXrqv, Kal fTiTOV'

'H TTOV ixiya tl koX koXov kaTL irepX o Toaavrqv aTTOvbr]v
TTfTTOLTjixiva) ioTov;
*0 8' eiTre, llotov, f(f)r], fxiya Kal Ka\6v; abo\(a-xpvaL
fxev ovv ovToC ye iTfpl t&v /xerecopwy Ka\ <f)\vapova-L

10 (f)L\0<T0(f)0VVTS.

C Ktti eycb davfxdaas avTOv T-qv aTT^Kpia-LV fLTTOV *i2 veavCa,

aiaxpbv boKCL aoL etvat t6 ^L\oao<l)iLV ; rj tC ovro)? j^aAeirws

Xeyets;
Kai. 6 (Tepos iT\r]a-Cov yap Ka6r]]Xvos Tvy\avV oVtov,
5 avTpa<rTris &v .aKovo-a? iixov re ipoixivov kclkcCvov aiTO-

EPA2TAI BT: ANTEPA2TAI in marg. b bi ypd^pfiv B:

ypdcpovTes T W i<paivt(T0rjv B itpaivecrOov ex i(paivovTo T
: b 6 yueya
T B : T* fxfya T i T 8tov B
: b 9 "yc T om. B :
 EPA2TAI 132 c

KpLVofxevov, Ov TTpos (Tov y, (f)r], S) ^U)KpaTs, Troteis rb

Koi avpa-6ai tovtov ct ala^y^pov rjyeaai, (f)iXoao(f)[av eii^at.

^ ovK ola-da TOVTOV oti T/saxTjAt^o/xeros Kai ejaTrt/xTrXa/Afyos

jcai Ka6evb(i)v ird.vTa tov ^iov biaTeTiKcKev; coore crv tC

avTov 0)01) aTroKpLVta6aL dXA' r/ otl al(J\p6v (.(ttl (f)LXoo-o(})La; lo

'Hy 8e ovtos fuv toIv kpa(TTaLV Trepi p.ov(TLKriv 6ta- d

TTpL(p(as, 6 6' Tpos, ov eAotSopet, Trepi yvjiiyao-rtK^i'. Kat
/jtoi e8o^e \privaL tov p.ev tTepov a(})LvaL, tov po)T(aixVov,
OTL ovV avTos TipocrmoLUTo TTcpl Xoyoov (fJiTTeLpos elvac a\Xa
Trepi ipy(t)v, tov 8e (ro(f)(i>Tpov 'npoa-noLCfvp.evov etmt Sie- 5

p(t)Trja-aL, tva Kal ei tl hvvaLp.r]v trap avTov (i)(f)XrjdLr]V.

etTToy ovv OTL Eis KOLvbv fx(v To e/)wrr;jua r}p6p.r]V' et 8e o-i/

otet Tovt) koXXlov av a7TOKpLvaa-6aL, o-e kp(x)TG> to avrb oiTep

KoX TOVTOV, et 8oKet o-ot Tb <f)LXoao(f)(LV KaXbv etrai t/ ov.

Sx^Soy ovv TavTa AeyoVrcov ^/naiy eTraKovo-arre rw /xet- 133

paKLd) ia-Lyr](r(iTr]v, Kal avTO) iTava-ap.evco ttjs epLbos r]p.5)V

CLKpoaTal iyv4(r6r]v, /cat ort /xey ot kpacrToX (iTadov ovk

olba, avrbs 8' ovv e^eTrAayrji;' dei ydp Trore vtto tQv v(t)v

re Kai KaXQv K'nXr]TTop.aL. kboKit fxivToi fxoL Kat 6 iTepos 5

ov;( ^rroy e/^toC ay^avLav ov fxr]V dAA' aiTiKpLvaT^ ye' /xot

Kal /A(!tAa ^LXoTLfKDS. 'OTToVe ydp rot, e0r/, oj ^coKpaTes,

To (ftLXoaocf^dv al(T\pbv r]yr](raLfxr]v etmt, 01^8' ay av6p(DTTov b
vofxC(raLfXL (fxavTov etrat, ov8' aAAoi; roi' ovrco biaKeCfxevov,
evb(LKVvfXvos eis rw avTepaarrfv, Kal Aeycoy /xeydAr/ n/

(f)(*)inj, tv^ avTov KaTaKovoL rd TratSiKd.

Kat eyo) eiTroi;, KaAoy dpa 8oKet o-ot Tb <f)LXoa-o(f)Lv; 6

ndyu fxey ovv, e^rj.

C7 <pi\oao<plav elvai B eTvot <pi\o(ro<plav T

: C 8 rovrov B ai- :

rbi' T C 9 (Ti/ rf auT^j' ^ov B Sffrt Tt <roi oXft avrhv T C 10 iwo- W

TW
:

Kpivu<rdat B diro/cpfj-fo-eoi
: oAX' ^ B TW
&\\o ^ d 3 rhv :

(pairdfievov Schleiermacher (quem prius irtterrogavemm Ficinus) : rhv

(poixfvov b : rhv ipd/ifvov B T d5 <xo<p<Sirfpov T : <ropii>rarov B
(17 olv 1 : y oiv^Q d8 &/ aitoKpivaaOai. Laur. Ixxxv. 14 : tiv awo-
Kpivf<r9ai T airoKpivf<Tdai B oiroKpictrtrdot b a 4 5' o5' T y oiv B
W
: : :

b 3 yuf yoAj; B fitya T W : b5 (rot T : eroj ordi/ t' flvai B

 ;

133 b nAATr2N02
Ti ovv, eyo) e(f)riv' ^ boK.i (roi olov r' etvat eibfvai

npayixa otiovv eire KaXov etre al<T)(j)6v (cttlv, b ixri et6etrj

TLs Tr]v apx.^y otl icrTiv;

lO OuK 0rj.

C Oio"^' apa, ^y 8' eyw, ori Iotiz; ro c})Lko(ro(f)LV

Udvv ye, e^r;.

11 ovv ea-TLv; (pr]V eyw.

Tt 8' aAAo ye ^ Kara to 2o'Aa)yos; 2o'Aa)y y(ip ttov

5 etTre
yr]pdcrK(o 8' aZet TToAAa 8t8a(rKo')iAeyos*

Kai ejuot 8oKet ovT(t)s dei yj)r}vaL kv ye rt p.av6dviLV tov

fxiXXovTa cf)L)\.ocrocf)ricreLV, Kal vccoTfpov ovTa Kal 7rpe(rj3u-
Tepov, Xv' 0)9 TrAeicrra kv T<a /3tfa) fxddr]. Kai p.0L to p.\v

lo Trp&Tov ISo^e rt eiTrety, eiTeLTd ttcos ivvorjcras 'qpopir^v avTOV

eZ T7]v cf)LX.oa-o(f)Lav Tiokvixadiav rjyoLTO.

d KaKetro?, Udvv, ^(f)r].

*Hyry 8e 8t) Kakbv eiyat fxovov Tr]V (f)iko(rocf)Cav rj Kal

dyadov; r]V 8' eyo).

Kat dya^oy, ^^r], Trdw.

5 riorepor oui' ev (f)Lkocrocf)iq, tl tovto tbLov (vopqs, rj kol

v rots dAAoty ovtu) ctol 8oKet ^x^^lv; oXov ^Lkoyv]ivaaTLav

ov piovov r]yr] Kakbv etmt, dAAd Kat dyadov; r] ov;
*0 8e Kat ftdAa elpcovLK^as etTre 8vo' Hpbs ]xkv Tovbc
]xoL Lpr](r6(o OTL ovbeTcpa' Trpbs fxevroL cri, S) "ScaKpaT^s,

e opLokoyu) Kal Kakbv eii^at Kat dya66v' TjyovfxaL ydp 6p6(as.

'Hpwrrjcra ovv eycu, 'Ap' ovv Kal iv toXs yvixvaa-ioLS Tr]v

iTokvnoviav (f>Lkoyvixvaa-TLav riyfj Lvai;

Cl rhh: TiBT C2 ledvv ye B Kot fidKa

: f<t>v T W C4 tJ)

b Tov BT: Th tov t

: C6 5' aiel Solo o/l B : :
8' ael T SiSaa-K6-
fifvosT 5^ 5iSa(TK6fxevos
: B Cio eTrejTci B : thd T C 11 i^yolro
T : TtyeiTO elvai B d6 to7s B : om. T d 7 ^7 fcaA?' B :

Ka\hv TT/eT T d 8 elire T ^<pr) B : d 9 nevToi T 5t l^ :

e I bfxoXoyw Ka\ KaXhv elvai Kol aya66v B Ka\ Ka\hv KayaOhv dfioKoyo
W
:

flvai T rryovfjiai ...62 eyd B om. T : e 2 5p' odv T om. B W :

e 3 elva.t T ti elvat B:
 EPA2TAI i33e

KaKHvos (f)ri, Yldvv ye, uxnrep ye Kal iv rai (f)(,kocro(f)(LV

TTjV TroKvfxaOCav cf)iXo(TO(f)Lav r)yov[JLai, etrat. 5

Kdyo) (Tttov, 'Hyrj 8e 8?) tovs (fnkoyvfxvacTTovvTas aXXov

TOV Tndv^lV 7] TOVTOV, OTL TTOtTJCret aVTOVS iV X^'^ "^^

(TutfJLa;

TOVTOV, (f)r].

'H ovv ol TToAAot TToVoi t6 (T&^a, qv 8' eyo), TroioCo-ty lo

y 4xLv;
H&s yap av, i(f)r], airo ye dAiywi' Troycov ro (rcojaa rts ev 134
(Xoi;
Kai juoi (bo^cv rjbr} kvTavda KLvr]T^os eiyai 6 (f)L\oyv-

jUfaoTtys', iVa juot (3or]6riar} 8ia r^y e/xTretpiai' r?)? yvfxvacTTLKrjs'

KaTTetra -qpofj.riv avTov, ^v 8e 8^ rt myas i7/;xty, cb Awo-re, 5
rovrou raura Ae^yoz/ros; 7/ xat o-ot 8oKoi;o-ty ol dvdpcaiiOL V

TCL o-()/xara exeti^ aTro tu>v ttoX\.6)v ttovcov, rj diTO t&v

IXiTpMV;
'Eyo) [x4v, S) SwKpares, 4(pr], &]xr]v to keyofx^vov 6t) tovto
K^v vv yvdvaL otl ol [xiTpLOL ttovol v ttolov^tlv exeiy tcl io

(r(a]xaTa, tt66(v 8r) ov-)(l dvbpa ye dypvnvov re Kat ao-troy b

Kat aTpL^i] Tov Tpdyj]\ov \ovTa Kal KcnTov viro ]xipL]xvS)v;

koll avTov TavTa etTToVros i^o-^j] to. ]XLpdKLa kol e7reye'Aao-ei',

6 8' Tpos r]pv6pLa(T.
Kat eyw etTroy, Tt ovi^; o^ ^6rj o-uyxwpeis /XT^re iroAAovs 5

/x^re oXCyovs ttovovs ev iroiety e^ety ra a-^afxaTa tovs dv6p(a-

TTovs, dAAa tovs ju.erpious; 17 Sta/bidxT] bvolv ovtolv vQ>v Trept
rov Adyou;
KdKeiros, Ylpos ixev tovtov, ((f)r], k^v Trdvv rjbicos 8ta- c
yo)VL(TaC]xi]v, kol e3 ot8' ort iKai^os av y(voC]xr]v (3or]6rja-aL

Tf] viTo6i(TiL rjv VTT64]xr]v, Kal d TavTr]s (tl (f>av\oTepav

VTT6i]xr]v cvb\v ydp 1(ttl iTpos ]x(vtol o-e ovbev beofxai

6 4 7 B om. T : e 6 9i S^ recc. Sh Se? T 5^ B a i a.ir6

: :

yf dKlyccv B air' oXiycov 7 T

: a 4 /Sorjfl^cjj B fioriO-fitrfie T :

a 6 TovTov ravra B Tavra tovtov T : a 10 /c&v vy Hermann koI :

yvv B T b 3 iveyeKcurf B iytAaiTev T : ,

I34C nAATX2N02
5 TTapa bo^av ^iKoviKdv, dA.\' oixoXoyG) fxr] ra TToAXa dAAa
TCt, ixfTpLa yvp.va(Tia tt]V evc^Cav ifXTTOielv tois avOpMiTois.
Tt 8e rd cnTia; to, /xer/36a ^ rd TroAAd; ^tprjv ey<a.

Kat TO. aiTia w/xoAo^yet.

d "Ert 8e Kayo) iTpoa-rfvdyKaCov avTov opioXoyeiv fcai rSAAa
TrdvTa Ta iTepl to cr(ap.a 0i)(f)XLp.(aTaTa elvai rd p.eTpi.a ahka
1X7] To. TToAAd ixrjbe rd oAtya* /cat /xot w/xoAoyet rd fxeTpia.
Tt 8', (/)rji;, rd Tre/at Tr\v y^v\riv; to. /xer/)ta w^eAet 17

5 rd ajxeTpa t&v 7Tpo(T(pepop.4v(ov;

Td fxeTpia, e(/)r/.

OwKouv ty rwy TTpoa-cpepofxhoiv "^vxfj cort koI rd /xa^^-

/^ara;

'I2fioAoyet.

10 Kat TovT(t)v apa to. /xeVpta aq[)eAet dAX' ov rd iroAXd;

Swe^i/.
e Ttya oily p6p.V0L av St/catcos kpoCfxeda ottoIol fxhpLOL
TTOVOL Ka\ (TLTLa TTpos To aoiixd eaTLv;

*Q.fxoXoyovfXV piev rpets ovtcs, otl laTpbv rf TTaLboTpC^rfV.

TCva 8' av TTepl (nTpfxdT(ov a-TTopas otto^tov fxeTpLov;

5 Kat TovTOV Tov yeoopybv b)p.okoyovfxev.

TCva be TTepl fxa6r]fxdT0i)v els ^v^rfv (f)VTeva-e(os re Kat
(TTTopas ep(t)T(avTes bLKaC(os av epoCfxeOa OTToa-a Kal OTTola

fxeTpLa;

135 Tovi^reS^ey rfbrf aTTopCas fxe(TTo\ ^fxev aiTavTes' Kayo)

TTpoa-TTaC^oov avTovs rfpofxrfv, BovKeade, e(f)r]v, eiTeLbr] rffxeXs

ev CLTTopCq e(Tfxev, ep(opi.eda rauri tcl fxeLpdKLa; rf ta-oos

ala-yyvofxeOa, ooaiTep e^^r] tovs fxvrfo-Trjpas "Ofxrfpos, fxrf

5 d^LOVVT(ov etvaC TLva akXov oo-tls evreveX rd to^ov;

d.2 w(pe\ifi(iTara ehai ra fj.erpta Schanz : w<p\iij.<irara eli^ai /xerpia

B Ta fierpta fid\t(Tra d}<p(\e7u T
: d 4 oi>(p(\e7 Stephanus w^pe^e^v :

BT e I fifrpiot ir6vot B ir6vot /xerpiot T : 63 wfxo\oyovfjLev

B 6fxo\oyovfiev T
; fikv B T om. al. St B : T (seci irt s. v.) : i^ W
e 4 aiTfpfidrcov B (nrfpfiaros T
: e 5 Kal rovrov B T Kav rovr(p :

ci. Schanz 6fxo\oyovfjt(v pr. B T e 6 Trepl B om. T : W

a 5 a^iovvTbiv B T aliovvras b a^iovvns Cobet
: :
 EPA2TAI i35a

'E7rei8^ ovv ^ioi khoKovv advfJL^Xv irpos tov Xoyov, akXr]

TTLp(aixr]V (TKOTrdv, Kal (Ittov, Ylola 8e //aAtara arra to-
TTaCoixev eimi T<av iJi.a6r]p.dT0}v a Sei tov (j)i,ko(TO(f)ovvTa

fxavOdveiv, fTrctS^ ov}(t TrdvTa ov8e TroAAa;

'TTToka^itiV ovv 6 ao(f)o!>Tpos (Itt^v otl KaXAi(rra TavT^ b
fXr] T&v iJLa0r]iJ,(XT(t)V Kal iTpO(rr]KOVTa d</)' &v hv TTX.C(rTr]v

ho^av ^x^ot TLS ets (f)LXo(ro(j)Lav' TrkeLcrTr^v 8' hv ^x^'' ^o^o.v,

(l boKoir] tG)V tc^vQv i]i7TLpos cTvat iTacr&v, ei 8e ]xr], wy
TrAetWo)!; ye koX ]xdX.La-Ta t&v d^LoXoyoov, fxadatv avT&v 5

raCra h iTpocr-qKCL rots eAeu^epots fxadelv, ocra avvicrU)s

(X^TaL, fxr] oaa yjeLpovpyias.

'Ap' ovv ovTO) Aeyets, e^Tjv eyw, &(nT(p V Trj reKroriKrj;
Kat yap e/cet TKTova ]XV &v Trptato ttvt r] e^ fxv&v, aKpov c
dp\LTKTova 8e ov8' az^ ]xvpCo)v bpa\]xu>v okCyoL ye /xT/y Kai/

ey 7ra(ri rotj "EAArjo-t ytyyotrro. apa /U7/ rt rotoCroi' Ae'yeis;

Kat 6y dK0V(ras ]xov (rvvyo)pL Kal avTos XeyeLV tolovtov.
^Hpofxr^v 8' avTov et ovk dbvvaTov ei?/ bvo ]x6vas T4)(vas 5
ovTco fxaOilv Tov avTov, ]xr] otl iTokkds Kal ]Xydkas' 6 bi,
Mr] ovTO)s ]xov, e</)r/, VTTokdlSrjs, o) ^WK/aares, o)S kiyovTOS
OTL Sei KdcrTr]v tG)V Tyyo)v tov (f)Lkocro(f)ovvTa TTC(rTacr6aL
dKpL^as ot)(nTp avTQV tov Tr]v Tyvr]v XpvTa, dAA' &)s d
etKos dvbpa kv6p6v re Kat TTTTaLbV]Xvov, TTaKokov6r](raC

re rois Aeyo/xeyots vtto tov br]p.Lovpyov oX6v t eirai 8ta-

(f)p6vT0)S tS)v TTap6vT0)v, Kal avTov ^v]xl3dkk(r6aL yvcopir^v,

&(TT boK^lv xapL(rTaTov etifat Kat a-o(f)(aTaTov t&v det 5

TTap6vT0)v v rots Aeyo/xeVots re Kat TTpaTT0]XV0LS Trept ras

re^x^^as.

Kdyo), Iri ydp avTov r]]X(f>yv6ovv tov kSyov ort l/3ovAero,

a 7 fia\i(TTa avTO. Tovd^onfu B : /ioAtcTTa roira^oniv 6,ttcl T

a 8 (pi\offo<f)ovura B : <pi\6ffo(pov T a9 ^TreiS^ B : ^irl T
b3 8' &v BT
Schanz : b 5 7 B re T
5' fxaMffTa T ;u<{A.a : :

B . C2
c 3 yiyvoivro Schanz koI
K&i/ . . ylyvoivro B /col : . . . :

. ylyvovrai T
. . C 3 /i^ rt T /^^ B C 4 ouTis T owtoO B : :

\(yfiv rowvrov B roiovrov \4y(iv T : C 5 fiovas B fxSvov T :

c 6 /lo&e?' B T \aPuv ex emend. T: d 5 twj' oitl B aUl ruv T :

i35e nAATXlNOS
e 'Ap' ivvoa, e(f)riv, olov Aeyet? tov ^tX6(ro(f)Ov avhpa; boKcXs
yap \xoL kiyeiv oloi iv tt) ayoctvCa dalv ol iiivTaOXoi Trpbs
Tovs bpojx^as 7] Tovs TTakaicrTds. Koi yap iKelvoi tovtoov
fjikv XeiTTOVTat KaTa Ta tovtcov a6Xa Kal bcvTepoi eicrt iTpbs
TovTovs, t5)V 8' aXXoiv aOkrjTGiv TrpatTot Kal viKacnv avTovs.
5

Td)(^ hv tcrcos TOtovTov TL Aeyot? Kal to (f^Lkoa-ocjydv d-nep-

ydCecrOaL tovs iTTLT-qbevovTas tovto to eTrtr^Sen/xa' Tav pXv

136 TrpooToov eis crvveaLV TTepl Tas T^xvas eAAeiTrecr^at, tcl bev-
Tepela 8' e\ovTas t&v dXkoiv Trepietyat, Kai ovto^s yLyveaOaL
Trept iravTa v-naKpov Tiva dvbpa tov ire^Lkoaro^rjKOTa'
TOLOvTov TLvd p,0L boKels ivbLKVV(rdai.

5 KaAw? ye p.0L, (f)rj, S) SwKpare?, (f^aCvji vTroXa[M(3dvLv

Ta TTpl Tov (f)Lko(T6(f)Ov, dTTeLKdaas avTov TO) Treyra^Ao).
eoTti' ydp dT)(vcis tolovtos olos pi-r} bovkeveLV pirjbevl iTpd-

yiiaTL, iirjb^ ets Trjv aKpi^eLav p.r]bv bLaTTTTOvr)KvaL, ftjore

8ta Tr}v Tov kvbs tovtov iTTLfxekeLav t&v dkXo)v CLTrdvTo^v

b dTTokkL(f)daL, uxTTTep OL br]iiLovpyoL, akka TTavTCdV /xerptco?

(f)r](f)daL.

Mera TavTrjv 8r/ Trjv aTTOKpLcrLV eyo) iTpodvp.ovp.evos (ra(^Q)S

ilbevaL OTL keyoL, TTvvdav6p.r]v avTov tovs dyaOovs iTOTepov

6 xPV^i-H-^^^^ V dxp^qa-Tovs elvaL VTToka]i^dvoi,

Xpr]a-Lp.ovs brjTTOv, S) 2coKpares, (f)r].

'Ap' ovv, etirep 01 dya^ot )(jpr]aLixoi, ol iTOvrjpol

dxprjaTOL;
*I2//.oAoyet.

10 Tt 8e'; tovs (f)Lkoa6(povs dvbpas xPW^i^^'^^ VVV ^ ^'

c 'O 8e a)/xoAo'yei XPV^^^H-^^' '^^'' "^pds ye (f>r] XPW-I^^-
TdTovs elvaL rjyeladaL.
<I>e'pe 87) yvG>p.V, et av dkr]6r] Ae'yet9, ttov Kal XPW''I^<^'-

e 2 oToi corr. Coisl. : otov BT 64 KaTh ra T : /cori B

e 6 Keyots T \eyeis B : a i irpdruv T : irpSoTov B a4 SoKe7s
T :SoKe7 B a5 <(>alvei B : SoKe7s T vTroAa/ifioiveiv B : viro-
\aPe7v T a 7 oTos T om.
T a\\' (licr-nep ot STjfjkiovpyoi B
W : B b i l!i(rirep oi SriiJ.tovpyol aWa
B
: b 7 ^pijcrtiJtoi T : oi xpi1<r'M0'
03 (Tu T : om. B
 . ;

EPASTAI i3(

rifuv (ia-iv oi vTraKpoi ovToi; bijKov yap oti kK&a-Tov ye TSiv

Tas Tiyvas iyovToiv ^auAorepos k(m.v 6 (f)i\6(ro(f)os. 5
*i2/xoAo'yct.

<I>epf ^' ^y^) TvxoLS avTos aa-dcvi^cras

^V ^^> V^ ^' 7] rf

Twv (f)CX.(iL>v Tts T&v (xGiV irepl Stv (tv (TTTovbrjv p.eydkriv ^x^is,

noTtpov vyeCav ^ovk6p.(vos KT-qcraa-Oai tov vTraKpov (kcIvov

[tov (f)Lk6ao(f)Ov] dcrdyoLs av eis Trjv oiKtav ^ tov iaTpbv 10
kdjSoLs;
'ApL^poT^povs iy(i>y dv, i(f)r]. d
M77 fjLot, ilTTov y(o, dp.(f)OTipovs kiyi, dk)C oTToVepov
\idkk6v re Ka\ Trp^Tcpov.
Ovbels dv, i(f>r], tovto ye dfji.(f)ta-^r]Trja-tV, b)S ov)(l tov
iaTpov Kal p.dkkov Kal irp^Tepov. 5
Ti 8'; iv vr]l ^eLp.aCop.ivr] 'noTipia dv \mkXov (TrtTpiirots

(TavT^v re kcll Ta creavTov, rw KV^epvrJTr] rj rw (f)Lkoa6(f)(a

T(3 KV^epvr}Tr] eycoye.

OvKovv Kal Takka TtdvO' ovtcos, ecos dv Tts br]fxtovpy6s 17,

ov )(j)r]crty.6s kartv 6 (f>tk6a-o(f>os; 10

^aLVTat, i(f)r].

OvKovv vvv dxpr]aT6s Tts f^fxiv k^rrtv (f>tk6a-o(pos ; eicrt e

ydp fjixtv aei ttou br]]xtovpyo[' b)]xokoyriaa]XV be tovs fxkv

dyaOovs xprja-Lfxovs (tvaL, tovs be fxoxOr^povs dxpvorovs.

'HvayKdCiTO ojxokoyeLv.
Ti ovv juera rovro; p(afxaC cre rj dypoiK6Tp6v icmv 5

ip4a-6ai
'Epov oTt ^ovkci.
Ovbfv 6?;, ((f>riv eyw, ^r^rci) aAAo ry dvofxokoyriaa^rOat Ta

c 4 7 T T B : c 7 5^ B : 8^ T 08 &v B: oV T
C 9 fiov\6nevos KT-fiaaffdai B : Kriiffaffdai fiou\6fj.evosC lo riy T
<piK6(ro<(>oy T rhv (ro<php
: B : <pi\6(ro(pov Stephanus secl. Cobet fltr- :

dyois BT : eWarYiyois b C ii \d$ois B &j/ \(i$ois T secl. Cobet

: :

d I ^(pTi recc. ((pTjv B T d 2 e-yo) * B tytey' T

: d 3 t B ye T : :

d 7 rowTiJ' recc. eam6v B (wt6v T : t^ (rtavrov B Toy eouToC T

: :

d 10 i B om. T : e i i(rT\v 6 (pi\6cro(pos B 6 <pi\6(ro(pos 4(rTiv T :

e 2 ^^7i/ B om. T ael Hermann

: S^j B T 63 i.xp^(rTovs :

Byp.T i,xpelovs T
: e 5 ti B T t^ Baiter e 8 (,i\tS T (i)Tuy B : :
137 a nAATXlNOS
137 eiprj/xeW. ix^L 6e ttcos a>bi. o^ixokoyrjcraixcv KaXov eiyat
TTjv (f)Lko(ro(f) iav /cat avrol cf)i.\6cro(f)oi. elvai., tovs 8e (ptkoa-o-
(povs ayadovs, tovs 8e ayaOovs yj}r](riixovs, tovs 8e irovqpovs
axprjo-TOvs' avdis 8' av tovs (f>iX.ocr6(f>ovs o)fJLoXoyricraiJ.V, ecos

5 av ol br]fXLovpyol o)criv, ayjprjcrTovs eiyai, hr^iiLOvpyovs h\ aeX

eiyai. ov yap TavTa &)/xoAoyr;rat;
Ylavv ye, ^ 8' os.

'llxoX.oyoviJi.v apa, ws eotKe, Kara ye roy (roy Ao'yor,

eiTrep to (pLko^ro^f^elv eori Trepl tcls Ti)(vas iTTLa-Trjixovas

10 eu^at bv (tv Ae'yets roy Tp^irov, Trovr^povs avTovs etyat Kat

b a^^fi^qa-Tovs, e(>)S av iv avOpiaTtoLS TeyvaL Zio-Lv. aXKa fxi]

ov\ ovT(i)s, S) ^tXe, eyu)a-L, /xtjS'

f]
tovto (f^Lkoao^pHV, irepl

TCLS Teyvas ea-TrovbaKevaL, ovbe 'nokvnpayp.ovovvTa kvttt(x-

CovTa (rjv ovbe 'nokv}xa6ovvTa, dAA' aAAo rt, eiret eycb ^p.r]v

5 Kat oveLbos elvaL tovto kcll ^avavcrovs Kakela-Oai tovs Trepl tcls

Texvas ea^TTOvbaKOTas. w8e be cra^ea-Tepov ela-oixeOa et apa

akr]6r\ Aeyco, eay tovto aTTOKpCvr]' TLves lttttovs eTTLoravTaL

C KoAd^ety opd&s; 7ro'repoy otirep /SeArtVrous TTotoSo-iv t; dAAot;

OtTrep j3ekTLa-Tovs.
Tt be; Kvvas ovx 0% /SeArtWous eTTLaravTai TTOLeHv, ovtol
Koi KokdCeLV opO&s eTTicrayrat;
5 Nat.
*H avr^ apa Teyyr] fiekTLorovs re Trotet Kal KoAd^et
opd&s;
^aCveTaC [xol, 17
8' 6s.

Ti 8e'; iT^Tepov rjiTep j3ekTCarovs re TTOtet Kai KoAd^et

a I Ktt\hv ftmi B : ehai Ka\hv T a2 Koi avrol <^i\6ffO(poi fhat

secl. Schanz auctore Forster a5 ot del. Heusde a 7 7
B : om. T ^ 5' Sj B e<p7) : T a8 wfio\oyoviJi.ev T : 6fjio\oyovix(v
B Silo hv ah corr. Coisl. :^v &s (rh BT : &is arh vulg. Koi
axfyfl^rrovs . . . b i &ffiv secl. Schanz b2 exwct B : exovffi T
^ Mudge /t^ S^ B T
fjL-nS' : b 3 iffwovSoKfvai iro\vTTpayixov- . . .

ovvra secl. Cobet KvTrrd^ovra B KTvirdCovra T b 4 7^ ^ :

y' T e I irorepov B irporepov T fie\riffrovs B T: Be\riovs al. :

C 3, 6, 9 Pe\riffrovs B 0e\riovs T C 8 <f>aiverai noi B et in marg.

W
:

7p. T : (/)?j/il T C9 ^Trep] ^Trep T : om. B

 ; ;

EPA2TAI 137 c

opOQs, rj avTT] be Koi yiyv^aKH rovs xprjoTOVs Kol tovs io

fxo\6r]povs, 7} kripa tis;

*H avT-q, (f)rj.

'E^eXT^crei? ovv Kal KaT avOp^Ttovs tovto 6p.okoyiiv,

rJTTep j3eA.rioTous avdpcairovs ttouI, TavTr]v dvai Kal T7]v d
Ko\aCova-av 6p6&s Kal biayLyvaia-KOvarav tovs yjtr^crTovs t
Kal iioy6r]povs
Ylavv y, <f)r].

OiiKovv Kal rJTLs eva, Koi ttoXXovs, Koi rJTis ttoXXovs, Kal 5
(va;
NaC.
Kat Kad^ twTTcoy brj Kal t&v &\X.(dv aTrdvTcav ovrcoy;

^r]fxi.

TCs ovv kcTTiv r] iTncrr-qfxr], rJTLS tovs ev Tois ttoXco-lv lo

aKo\a(TTaCvovTas Kal TTapavofxovvTas 6p6&s KoAdfet; ov^ v

biKaoTiKi];
Nai.
'H aWr]v ovv Tiva fcaXeis Ka\ biKaiocrvin^v rj Ta^vTTfv;

OvK, aWa Tavrqv. 15

OvKovv fJTTcp KO^d^ovcriv 6p6<as, Tavrr] Kal yiyvcaa-KOvcn e

TOfvs yj)r](TTOvs koI p.o\6r]povs

TavTj].
"OoTts 8e va yiyv(aa-Ki, Kal ttoWovs yv(aa-Tai;
Nai'. 5

Kal ooTis y ttoWovs dyvo^i, koX tva;

^r]fxC.

Ei &.pa iTTTTOS ci)V ayvool tovs xpr^arovs Kol iTOvrfpovs

tiTTTOvs, K^v kavTov dyvooi TTOios tCs kariv;

Qio Tf avrij Si B : avrri TC ii kripa ris

: avrii Schanz
B et yp. T : &K\i) T avQpuirwv Stephanus
C 13 avOp<liirovs]
d. I fifXriffrovs B T: $f\rlovs al. d 3 Kal T al rohs B d 5 ovkovv :

Kal B : ovKOvv T fjrjs . . t)tjs T fi ris . . et ris B

. d 14 Kal B
: . :

om. T d 15 oAA^ ravrr}v B &\\riv T 6 2 rovs fioxOripovs

: W
B vovtipovs
: T e 8 ayvool B ayvofi T rovs xpri<^r-ohs Ka\
:

KovTipovs Xir-Kovs B rovs irovripovs koI tovs xCV'^^'''^ ^

: ^
 ; ; ;

i37e nAAT12N02
10 4>7]iLll.

Kai ei /Sous oi)V ayvooZ tovs Ttovrjpovs nal XPW''^^^

(jBovs), K-hv avTov ayvool TtoXos rts ka-Tiv;

Nat, <\>r].

Ouro) 8^ Ktti ei K6<av;

15 *12jUoAo'yet.

138 Tt 8'; eTretSav avOpo^TTos rts wy dyro^ rovs XP^^''^^^

Kttt fxoxOrjpovs av6p(i)TT0vs, ap' ov^ avrbv ayvod TroTepov
XprjcTTos iariv rj TTovrjpos, e7ret8^ Kai avTos avOpcaTTos iariv;
Swexwpei.
5 To 8e avTov ayvoclv (Tca^poveiv iaTiv ^ fj.r] a-(o(f)povlv

Mt) (r(i>(f)pOVLV.

To eavTov apa yiyvdtaKHV eo-ri adxf^povelv;

^r^fxC, (f)r}.

Tour' apa, ws lot/ce, ro ey AeX<^ots ypap.ixa TrapaKikeverai,

10 au)(\)poa-uvr]v aaKilv Kal biKacoavvrjv.
"EoLKCV.

Tfj avTTJ 8e raurr/ Kat KoAd^eii; op^ws (TrLaTdfxeda;

Na^.
b OvKoSy ^ /xey KoXd^eii^ opOoiS fTTLordfxeOa, biKaioavvr]

avTr] iaTCv, rj 8e ^taytyi/wo-Ketz; Kai kavTov kol aWovs,

a(t}(f)pocrvvr]

"EoLK^v, (f)r],

5 Tauroy &pa ^arl Kai bLKaL0(r6vr] Kal a-a>(f)poanuvr]

^aLVTaL.
Kai pL-qv ovTO) ye Kat at TrdAeis ev olKOvvTai, oTav ot

d^tKoSi^re? 8tKrjy bLb&aiv.

e 1 1 aypof7 B T iyvool-n : recc. xpitiTrohs BT : tovs xpricrols al.

e 12 Povs add. Bekker oyj^oor B : ayvooli) T irortJs tjs B :

volos T a I Tty 2' B : &V ris T a2 fj.oxOr)poxjs B tovs

:

fioxOripobs Stobaeus : vov-npovs T a^voe? T Stobaeus : ayvooi T

a3 vovnp6s BT : fiox^vp^s Stobaeus a5 ^o-tJv fi fiij (Toxppovetv;

fxil aaxppoveiv B : ^ ou (roij<ppovf7v iffriv; ov (raxppovfiv T Stobaeus

ai3 val B: <prifil TW Stobaeus hs &\\ovs B: &\\ov T Sto-
baeus D5 Ka\ SiKaiotrvvn koI (T(o<ppoa6vr) B : StKato(rvvri ffoxppo-

(xivii T b 7 Kal af : oi B T
 EPA2TAI I38b

^A\r}6r] Aeyei?, ((prj.

Kal TTokiTLKr] apa avTrj kaTiv. lo

SweSoKfi.
Tt 8e orav ets avr]p opOm 'noKiv hioiKfj, ovopA ye
rovro) ov Tvpavvo^ re Kat ^aixiXivs;
^rjfxL
OvKovv j3a<nXtK7] re Kal TvpavviKrj Texyjl SiOiKei; 15
Ovrcos.
Kai aurai 3p' al avrat re^xJ^at etcriy kKelvais;

^aivovTai.
Tt 8' oray et? oiy dvT/p oiKCav fttotK^ 6p9&s, ri oyo/xa c
rovr<i) iarCv; ovk olKOVofxos re Kat Seo-TTorT/s;

Na^.
IToVepoi' ovi; Kal ovros SiKaiocrvz^Tj ev &i' T^y oiK^y
StoiKOi 17 K&Wr} Tivi Tiyyri; 5
AtKatOOT^yT/.

"Eo-rti; apa tovtov, &)? ioiK^, ^acriXivs, rvpavvos, iroXt-

riKoy, olKovofjLos, Seo-TToVr;?, o-wc^pcoy, 8tKato?. Kat /x^a

Tixvr] eoTiy fta(nkiKri, TvpavvLKr], TroX.LTLKrj, bca-TTOTiKri, oIko-

vojJiLKri, bLKaLocruvri, (TU)(f)po(rvvri. 10

4>aiyerac, ^(f>ri, ovT(as.

TIoTepov ovv T(o (pLXo(T6(f)(o, STav ixV laTpos irepi t&v d

Kaiiv6vT(t)v TL ^.iyji, alcrxpbv iiriO^ eTreo-^at rois Aeyo/xeVots

8wao-^at /iXT/re avix^aXkicrdaL firibev TTcpl tS>v Xiyoiiiv(i)v

ri TTpaTTOixevoiv, Ka\ omTav &Wos rt? tS>v brnxLovpy&v,

cia-avT(as'oTav be biKaarris ^ ^ao-tAeus rj aAAos rts <3y 5
wvbri bi\ri\v6apiv, ovk aia-)(j)ov irepX ToijT^av [xrJT iiTea-dai
b-Cvaadai ixrJT^ avixjSdWcadaL iTcpl avT&v;

b 10 avT^fi Schanz : 1) avr)t B : aSrr? T b 13 7^ B : om. T

b 17 fiff\v iKflvais B: iKfivais elaiv T C2 ovk T : om. B
C5 K&Wrj B : &\\r} T C7 ravr^v^ ravrh B rovro T
:

C9 SfffiroTiK-fi TW: om. B e 11 e<pr} ovrwi B: om. TW

dI it6repov B
T^ : T larphs B 6 larphs T : d. 2 \fyofi4vois
Tb : Svva/xfvois pr. B (ut videtur) d 3 rrf pl d 4 irparroftfvcov . . .

B : om. TW d6 Sif\r)\vean.fP B Sff)\do/xfv T :

I38d nA.ATaNOS EPA2TAI
ria)? 8' ovK al<TXp6v, a> Sw/cpares, TrepC ye Toa-ovToiv
TtpayiiaTOiv fir^biv ^x^tv (rvixj3dkK<r6at;

e IIoTcpov ovv Kttt TTepl TavTtt Xeytoftey, ^(f)r]V, 'nivTadX.ov

avTov 8ety etrat xai vTraKpov, Koi TavTrjs pikv to. bevTepela

expvTa TravTOiv tov <I>iX6(to^ov, koX a^peiov eXvai lo)? av

ToijT(tiv rts fj, rj Trp&Tov jLtey ttjv avTov oiKiav ovk aAAw
5 iTfLTpTrTov ovbe Ta bevTepela iv tovt(^ kKTiov, dXX' avTov
KoXacTTiov biKa^ovTa opOQiS, et /Lte'AAet eS otKeto-^at avrou
7} oiKia;
'2,vvi)(jiipei brj /xoi.

*'E7retra ye b-q-nov idivTe ol 0tXot avrSt Siatraj iiriTpi-

lo TT(t)a-LV, idvT 7} TToAts rt TTpo(rT(XTTr} biaKpiveiv rj biKa^eiv,

139 ai(r-)(pbv iv tovtois, a> eratpe, bevTepov (paivea-Oai ^ Tpirov

Koi ixrj ovx TjyeX^rOat,;
*
AoKet fxoi.

IToAAoS apa 8et rjiuv, fSiXTiare, r^ (f)iKocro(f)iv iro\v-

5 p.a6ia re eiyai /cai ?/ 7re/)i ray Ti\vas TrpaypLaTeCa.

EItt6vtos 8' ^/xoS raura 6 /xey a-o(f)bs alcrxvvdels roty
TTpoeLprjfiivois ia-iyrja-ev, 6 8e d[xa6r)S i(pr] iKeCvoiS etvaL'

Kcu ol aAAot eTn^yeo-av ra lpr]p.iva.

e I e^T/i' T B e 2 oi to<5t?;s /iev ra Sewrepera B rh.

W
: i<l>ii :

SfVTfpf7a 5' T ; koI iv tovtois ra devTfpe7a Hermann koJ ...64^

secl. Schanz e3 ecoj &' B es T : e4 ^ ^ T ^ 6 :

a4 SerTW: om. B iroKv/Meia B: <pi\o/j.aeia T '

as ^'del.
Schanz a7 iKfivus b : iKeivos BT
 OXFORD
CLASSICAL TEXTS
The prices given of eopies on ordinary paper are for copies bound
in limp cloth ; uncut copies may be had in paper covers at 6d. less
per volume (Is. less for those priced from 6s. in cloth).

All volumes are also on sale interleaved with writing-paper and

bound in stout cloth ; prices on application.

April 1910

HENRY FROWDE
OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS
LONDON, EDINBURGH, NEW YORK, TORONTO AND
MELBOURNE
 Greek
AeSChyluS. A. Sidgwick. Ss. 6d. (India paper, 4s. 6d.)
AntoninuS. J. H. Leopoi,d. 3s. (India paper, 4s.)
ApolloniuS Rhodius. R. C. Seaton. Ss. (India paper, 4s.
AristophaneS. F. W. Hall, W. M. Geldaht. (Indla paper, 8s. 6d.)^
I. Ach., Eq., Nub., Vesp., Pax, Aves. 3s. 6d. (India paper, 4s. Gd.^i
II. Lys., Thesm., Ran., Eccl., Plut., fr. 3s. 6d. (India paper, 4s. 6d.)
BuCoUci Graeci. U. von WiLAMOwirz-MoELLENDoaFF. 3s. (India
paper, 4s.) ^l
Demosthenes. s. h. Butcheh. VI
I. Orationes I-XIX. 4. 6d. II. i. Orationes XX-XXVI. 3s. Gd.
Together on India paper, 12s. 6d.

Euripides. Gilbeht Muhray. (India paper, I-III, 12. 6d. ; I-II, 9s, ;

III, 4s. 6d.)

I. Cyc, AIc, Med., Heracl., Hip., Andr., Hec. 3s. 6d.
II. Suppl., Herc, lon, Tro., El., I. T. 3s. 6d.
III. Hel., Phoen., Or., Bacch., Iph. Aul., Rh. (In the prcss.)

Helienica Oxyrliynchia cum Theopompi et Cratlppi fragmentis.

B. P. Grenfell, A. S. Hunt. 4s. 6d.

HerodotUS. K. Hude. (India paper, 12s. 6d.)

Vol. I (Books I-IV). 4s. 6d. Vol. II (Books V IX). 4s. 6d.

Homer, 3s. per volume.

Iliad. (Vols. landlL) D.B.Monbo,T.W. Allen. (India paper,7s.)

Odyssey. (Vols. III andlV.) T. W. Allen. (Indiapaper, 6s.)

Hyperides. f. g. Kenyon. 3s. 6d.

LonginUS. A. O. Pbickard. 2s. 6d.
PhltO. J. BuRNEi-. Vols.I-III,6s. each(India paper, 7s. each), Vol. IV.
7s. (India paper, 8s. 6d.) Vol. V. 8s. (India paper, lOs. 6d.)
I. Euth., ApoL, Crit,, Ph. ; Crat., Tht, Soph., Polit.
II. Par., Phil., Symp., Phdr. ; Alc. I, II, Hipp., Ara.
III. Thg., Chrm., Lch., Lys. ; Euthd., Prot., Gorg., Men. ; Hipp. raa.,
mi., lo, Menex.
IV. Clit., Rep., Tim., Critias. Also Republic, separately, 6s. ; on quarto
writing-paper, lOs. 6d.
V. Minos, Leges, Epinomis, Epistulae. Definitiones, Spuria.
First and fifth tetralogies separately, paper covers, 2s. each.

Theophrasti Cliaracteres. h. Diels. 3s. 6d.

ThucydideS. H. Stuart Jones. (India paper, 8s. 6d.)

I. Books 1-4. II. Books 5-8. 3s. 6d. each.

Xenophon. E. C. Marchant. Vols. I-III. (India paper, 12s, 6d,)

I. Historia Graeca. 3s,
II. LibriSocratici. 3s. 6d.
III. Anabasis. 3s.
IV. Cyropaedia. 3s. 6d.
 ;

Latin
Asconius. a. c. Clahk. ss. ed.

Caesar, Commentarii. R. L. a. Du Poktet. (india paper, 7s.)

Bellum Gallicum. 2s. 6d. Bellum Civlle. 3s,

Catullus. R. Ellis. 2s. 6d. (With Tibullus and Propertius, on India

paper, 8s. 6d.)

CicerO, Epistulae. L. C. Purseb. (India paper, 21s.)

I. Epp. ad Fam. 6s. II. ad Att., Pars i (1-8), Pars u (9-16),

; 4s. 6d. each
III. ad Q. F., ad M. Brut, Fragm. 3s.

Orationes. (Rosc. Am. etc, Mil. etc, Verrinae, India paper,

18s. 6d.)
Rosc. Ara., I. Porap., Clu., Cat., Mur., Cael. A. C. Clark. 3s.
Pro Milone, Caesarianae, Philippicae. A, C. CrAHK. 3s. 4
Verrinae. W. Peterson. 4s.
Pro Quinctio, Pro Roscio Comoedo, Pro Caecina, De lege Agraria,
Pro Rabirio perduellionis reo, Pro Flacco, In Pisonem, Pro
Rabirio Postunio. A. C. Clark. 3s.

Rhetorica. A. S. Wilkins. (India paper, 7s. 6d.)

I. De Oratore. 3s. II. Brutus, etc. 3s. 6d.

Horace. E. C. Wickham. Ss. (India paper, 4s. 6d.)

LucretiuS. C. Bailey. 3s. (India paper, 4s.)

Martial. W. M. Lindsay. 6s. (India paper, Ts. 6d.)

NepOS. E. O. WlNSTEDT. 2s.

PersiuS and Juvenal. S. G. Owen. 3s. (India paper, 4s.)

PlautUS. W. M. LiNDSAY. (India paper, 16s.)

I. Amph. Merc. II. Miles fragm. 6s. each.

PropertiuS. J. S. Phillimoue. 3s. (India paper, see Catullus.)

StatlUS. (Complete on India paper. lOs. 6d.)

Silvae. J. S. Phillimore. 3s. 6d.

Thebais and Achilleis. H. w. Garhod. e.

Tacitus, Opera Minora. H. Furneaox. 23.

AnnaleS. C= D. Fisher. 6s. (Indla paper, 7s.)

Terence. R. Y. Tyrbell. 3s. 6d. (India paper, 5s.)

TibuUuS. J. P. PosTGATE. 2s. (India paper, see Catullus.)

Vergil. F. A. HiRTZEL. 3s. 6d. (India paper, 4s. 6d,)

Appendix Vergiliana. R. Ellis. 4s.

 BiNOINi m l 1943

PA