SCRIPTORUM CLASSICORUM

BIBLIOTHECA OXONIENSIS

OXONII
E TYPOGRAPHEO

CLARENDONIANO

LONDINI ET NOVI EBORACI

APUD GALFRIDUM CUMBERLEGE

VLATO
<
PLATONIS OPERA

RECOGNOVIT
BREVIQVE ADNOTATIONE CRITICA INSTRVXIT

IOANNES BURNET
IN VNIVERSITATE ANDREANA LITTERARVM GBAECARVM PROFESSOR
COLLEGII MERTONESSIS OLtM SOCIVS

TOMVS II
TETRALOGIAS III-IV CONTINENS

OXONII
E TYPOGRAPHEO CLARENDONIANO

OXONI1
Excudebat Joannes Johnson
Architypographus acadetnicus

FIRST EDITION igOJ

REPRINTED IQIO, 1921
1928, 1933, I94I. 1946

PRINTED IN GREAT BRITAIN

PRAEFATIO
IN tetralogiis III-IV recognoscendis eandem fere
rationem quam in prioribus secutus sum; cum autem
nee Parmenidem nee Philebum ediderit M. Schanz,
in illo viam monstravit vir doctus W. W. Waddell,
qui Clarkianum (B) et Marcianum (T) in suam editionem cum pulvisculo excussit, in hoc ipse Marcianas
lectiones primus in lucem protuli.
Quod ad recensionem attinet, fateor mihi codicum
lectiones perpendenti in dies magis probari quae in
prioris voluminis praefatione breviter exposui, unam
eandemque recensionem omnes quotquot extant libros
exhibere, alterius recensionis vestigia tantum apud
antiques scriptores et in codice Vindobonensi (W)
inveniri. omnes libros ad unum eundemque archetypum referendos esse, eumque post sextum saeculum
exaratum, certissimum est et ab Alphonso SchaefFer,
qui acerrime Schanzianas rationes impugnavit, conceditur 1> cui quidem ego ita adsentior ut negem ulla
vestigia recensionis in Clarkiano (B) extare, quippe
cuius errores calligraphi sint diligentissime litterulas
exscribentls, sermonem et doctrinam parum callentis.
neque hoc mihi probavit SchaefTer, in libros alterius
familiae lectiones ex antiqua recensione inrepsisse,
quod in Vindobonensi (W) et adfinibus eius ipse factum
esse contendo. scio equidem vel in deterrimis libris
optimae notae lectiones passim inveniri, sed plerasque
1

Quaestiones Platonicae (Argentorati M.DCCC.XCVIII).

PRAEFATIO
a viris doctis post renatas litteras inter legendum
adscriptas. qui Venetum 189 (S) et Coislinianum 155
(F), ut his utar, corrigebant, permultas Heindorfi
aliorum emendationes praecepere, quibus ut suum
cuique tribui debet, ita coniectura non memoria niti
eius modi lectiones fatendum est.
Quod mihi obiecit censor benevolentissimus H. Diels,
me testimonia antiquiorum scriptorum parum respexisse, id cuius modi sit alio loco exponam, in hoc
volumine viro humanissimo, ut par erat, satis facere
studui. quamquam non me fugit quam lubrica res
sit eius modi testimonia adhibere. licet enim scriptores
saepissime ex antiqua recensione veram lectionem
servaverint, at certum est codices Procli Olympiodori
aliorum ex libris Platonicis interpolatos esse. non
satis est igitur eorum testimonia ex optirnis editionibus
descripsisse : ex ipsorum verbis, si qua fieri possit,
lectio quam quisque habuerit eruenda erit. nunc
autem si hie ilHc antiquioris recensionis sinceram
memoriam reciperare contigerit, content! esse debebimus.

IOANNES BURNET.
Scribebam Andreapoli
e collegia S. Salvatoris et D. Leonardi
mense Martio M.DCCCC.I.

In Convivio et Phaedro lectiones Oxyrhynchitas

commemoravi, et in Convivio codicis Vindobonensis
(W) collationem a viro doctissimo Hermanno Schoene
confectam adhibui.
Andreapoli
mense Aprili M.CM.X.

IOANNES BURNET.

DIALOGORVM

ORDO

TOMVS I
ED. STEPH.
I. pp.
2-16

TETRALOGIA I
EVTHYPHRO .
APOLOGIA SOCRATIS
CRITO .
PHAEDO.

I. pp.

17-42

I. pp. 43-54
I. pp. 57-ii8

TETRALOGIA II
CRATYLVS
THEAETETVS .
SOPHISTA
POLITICVS

I. pp. 383-440
I. pp. 142-210
I. pp. 216-268
II. pp. 257-311

TOMVS II
TETRALOGIA III
PARMENIDES .
PHILEBVS
SYMPOSIVM .
PHAEDRVS .

III.
II.
III.
III.

TETRALOGIA IV
ALCIBIADES I
ALCIBIADES II
HIPPARCHVS .
AMATORES

II.
II.
II.
I.

pp. 126-166
pp. 11-67
pp. 172-223
pp. 227-279
pp.
pp.
pp.
pp.

103-135
138-151
225-232
132-139

DIALOGORVM ORDO

TOMVS III
TETRALOGIA V
THEAGES
CHARMIDES
LACHES
LYSIS

I.
II.
II.
II.

TETRALOGIA VI
EVTHYDEMVS
PROTAGORAS.
GORGIAS
MENO .

pp.
PPpp.
pp.

121-131
i53-!76
178-201
203-223

I. pp. 271-307
I. pp. 309-362
I. pp. 447-527
II. pp. 70-100

TETRALOGIA VII
HIPPIAS MAIOR
HlPPIAS MINOR

lo .
MENEXENVS .

III.
I.
I.
II.

pp.
pp.
PPpp.

281-304
363-376
530-542
234-249

III.
II.
III.
III.

pp. 406-410
pp. 327-621
pp. i7-I05
pp. 106-121

TOMVS IV
TETRALOGIA VIII
CLITOPHO
RESPVBLICA .
TIMAEVS
CRITIAS .

D I A L O G O R V M ORDO
TOMVS V

TETRALOGIA IX
MINOS .
.
LEGES
EPINOMIS .
EPISTVLAE
DEFINITIONES

D E IVSTO .
DE VIRTVTE
DEMODOCVS .
SISYPHVS
ERYXIAS
.
AXIOCHVS .

.
,

.
.

.
.

.
.

II. pp. 313-321

II. pp. 624-969
. II. pp. 973-992
III. pp. 309-363
III. pp. 411-416

N00EYOMENOI

. III.
III.
. III.
III.
. III.
HI.

p p . 372-375
pp. 376-379
p p . 380-386
pp. 387-39i
pp. 392-406
pp. 364-372

SIGLA
B = cod. Bodleianus, MS. E. D. Clarke 39 = Bekkeri 31
T = cod. Venetus Append. Class. 4, cod. I = Bekkeri t
W = cod. Vindobonensis 54, suppl. phil. Gr. 7 = Stallbaumii
Vind. I
C = cod. Crusianus sive Tubingensis

= Stallbaumii Z

D = cod. Venetus 185

= Bekkeri n

G = cod. Venetus Append. Class. 4, cod. 54 = Bekkeri A

V = cod. Vindobonensis 109

= Bekkeri $

Oxy. = Papyrus Oxyrhynchita (Grenfell et Hunt

V, pp. 243 sqq.)

Recentiores manus librorum BT W litteris b t w significantur

IIAPMENIAHS
St

KE4>AAOS

*
p. '126

Ge OIKO&CV IK KAao/Mez;a>i> a</>iKo/Ae0a, a

jcar' ayopav fVTv\pfj-v 'A8eijx(W<}> re xat FAa^Kwyf Kat
TT/? \fi.pos 6 'A8ei/Aazm>s, Xaip', I^>TJ, a>
rou 8erj T&V r^8e c5y ^/txers 8uyarot, <pp6.t.
'AAXa /xei; 817, et'jroi; eyco, jrtipeijiAt ye eir' avro roirro, 5
Aeyou ay, e^r/, ri]
Kal !ya> etiroj;' T aSeA^fi vjuwy rw o/xojmrjrpia) TI TJZ; b
Svopa; ov yap ju^jm^jaat. irars 8e 'TTOU 77^, ore ro
-a Sevpo e/c
, rS ju,ei; yap TrarpC, 8oKa>, HupiAti/xTr^s ovopa.
Haw ye, e^>rj.
5
AvrS 8e ye;
'AvTi,<p&v. dAAa rt /owiAtora irvvOavri;
OflSe, enroy eyco, TroAirat r' e/xoi eitri, juaAa (piXocrofpoi,
re on ovros 6 'Ayrtoiwy Ili>0o8w/3&> rtyt Zr\vu>vos
TroAAa eyrervx??*6* KOI roi/s Aoyous, ovs irore Sco- C
Kal Zyvtov Kat HapiMevibrjs
aKOUcra? rou Ylvdobtapov
HAPMENEIAHS constanter B
b 5 e^Tj T Proclus : om. B
b6 avTtf Se 76: avTKp&v' B: avripSfye anTi^uf T Adimanto tribuens
b 8 T' ^/tol ci. Stephanas : re' juoi T : /tot B
PLATO, VOL. II.

126 c
5

10
127

IIAATQNO2
'AX7J077, I^PTJ, Ae'yeis.
Tovro>y Toivvv, ITTOV, Seop;e0a bianovcrai.
'AAA' ov x^677^ /} fj.fip6.Kiov yap a>z> avrovs ev
p.dA.a 8te/xeAerT]<rey, eirel y{5i> ye Kara TOV Tiasmrov re *cai
Trpos ITTTHKT} rot TToAAa 8tarpi/3et. dAA' ei 8eT,
Trap' auroy apri yap ey0ey8e oftcaSe o?x.eTai, oiKei 8^
eyyiis ey MeAtrr;.
TaSra eiTrwrey ej8a8i^bp;ei', Kat KareAeJjSojuei; roy 'Ai>oi/coi, ^aXiyor riya xa^-K^ eK8t8oVra o-Keuao-ai'
e fKfivov aTrrjAAciyrj o? re a8eA<poi eAeyov avrw
Trapeifiey, avtyvtopurev T /ixe e*c T^S Trporepas
KOI p,e TjcnraCero, Kat b0fj.evu>v JHJ.&V bifXOelv TOVS
Xoyovs, TO fji,v Trp&Tov &KVt.TToXii yap e^)Tj epyov
trjyeiro. l^)?] 5e 8rj 6 'Az>ri$<3
on atpiKoiuro Trore eis Haya^vata ra p;eyaA.a
Z?7z;a)y re Kat riapjueyiSrj?. roy /u.ez/ ovy IlappveyiSTjy eS
r)5r] Trpea-fBvTrjV
elvai, crfyobpa iroXiov, KdXbv 8e
oy TT\V o^nv, Trepl errj ju,d\tcrTa Treyre *cai
8e eyyiy rwy rerrapaKo^Ta rdre etyai,
8e Kai x.apievra t8eu;, Kal Xeyecr^at avrbv iraibiKa TOV
v yeyoyevat. KaraXveiy 8e aiiTovs Icjir] Trapa rw
KTO? retxovs ev Kepa/xetK&i' ot ST) Kat af
TOV re ScoKpdrrj Kat aAA.ous rtyas /xer' a^rou
eTrt^v/xoCyTay aKoucrat T>V TOV Zrjvcovos ypa/x/Lidrwyrore
yap avra Trpwroy VTT' eKeu>a>i> KOfjucrdfivai2a)KpdrTj 8e etyai
rore cr<|)o8pa veor. avayiyvaxrKew ovv O.VTO'LS TOV Z-r\V(>vo.
Ov, TOV be Ylap^evibrjv TVX&V ea> ovTa" Kat etyat
ert Aotiroy rwy Aoywi' dvayiyi>co<TKO|u,eycoz>, rf
atiro's re e7rei(reA0ety l^r; 6 riv^oScopos egooOev Kat
IIap//.eyt8rjy /u.er' awrou Kal 'AptcrroreArj roy rfiy
c 5 8iaicovffa.i B Proclus : axovffcu. T
c 8 Se?] SoKfl Heindorf
a 4 ira.peifji.ev B : Trapti^^iei/ T : iropij/tev G
a 5 jue B : om. T Proclus
a 8 a.$[ttoivT& B : a.<f>tKovr6 T
b 2 ^87; T : 5$; B
b 4 -rSiv
G : ITW^ B T
rerrap^KOVTa T : TeyffapJaiovTa. B

IIAPMENIAHS

I27<1

oVra ert
TQ>V ov pjy amos ye, dAAa Kal Trpo'repoz; aKijKoeVat rov
ZTJV<MZ>OS.
5
Toy ovv SooKparrj dKovVavra TtaXiv re KeXeOtrat rrjv
itp<aTt]v vTToOfo-iv TOV irpdrov Ao'yov avayv&vai, Kal avayvuxrdfCa^s, TISts, (fravai,, ai Z^vutv, TOUTO A.eyeis; et 7roXA.a 6
eort ra ovra, a>s ei/oa 8et avr^ o/xoid re eiyat /cat dro/uota,
TOVTO 8e 8r) dSvvaroy oi/re yap ra avofjioia o^oia ovre ra:
o/xoia avo^oia. olov re etyat; ov^( oC/rw Aeyeis;
Ovrco, <f>6,vai. TOV Zrjvava.
5
Ov/couy ei aMvarov ra re dyojuioia o/xota etyat Kal ra
o/io la avofMia, abvvarov by Kal iroA-Aa eii>ai; ei yap iroAAa
eirj, iratrxoi ai/ ra d8^z;ara. apa roi5ro ecrrii' 6 fiovKovTai
crov ol Xoyot, OVK aAAo ri r) 8tajU(ixfa'^<)tt irapa Travra ra
Aeyop-ei'a ws ov -TroXAci etrri; Kai rowou avrou oiet <roi 10
TfKfjiripLov etvaL eKaffTov T&V Aoyoov, wo-re Kat ^yr) rocraGra
re*cjui]pia irape-)((<rdai, oo-ouo-'Trep Aoyous yeypa<pas, ws OVK
e<rri TroAAci; ovrco Aeyeis, ?) eycb O{IK op^ws Kara^avOAvto ; 128
OVK, dAAa, <f)6.vai TOV Zrivava, KaX&s crvvrJKas o\ov TO
MavOava), elirflv TOV ScoKparrj, S> Tlap^fvibr],
on
o8e ov IAOVOV rr) o:AA^ o-ot; (piXiq /3ovAerat a)Keta)(r0ai, dAAa 5
/cat ra> o-vyypdju,f>tart. ravrw yap yeypa^e rpOTroy
oTrep o-v, ju,eraj3aAAcoy 8e ^ju,as Treiparat e^airaraz; a>
rt Ae'ycoy. (ru p.ey yap > rois Ttot^fjiacriv fv <j)fjs elvm TO
irav, Kal rovrcov reK^pia Trape^r] KaASs re Kat eS- o8e 8e
av ov TroAAd (pt]o-t.v eT^at, reKja?]pta 8e Kal avros irafwroAAa
Kat Tra^f-yedrj 7rape)(erat. ro ovv rov fxei> Iv (pdvai, TOV
be fxri TroAAa, Kal oC/rws eKarepov Aeyety <2o-re jjLtjbfv T&V
e g ffou ot B et in ras. T : ffot of G
a 5 ffoul fort, ffot Heindorf
ot6Jw<rOat pr. B pr. T (corn B2t) : oiKeiovtrGcu al. Proclus
a 7 3irep Proclus : Svtrep B : o*irep T
fjifTaft<i\\fav
B : /j.eTa./3a\ut>
T Proclus
a 8 Iv (/)fjs T : Ij/ l^rjs B Proclus
b i re B : -ye T
b 2 Kal T : om. B

ia8b

HAATilNOS

5 avr&v etprjKeVat boKelv <r)(8oy n Xeyozmxs TOVT&, vritp

fifJMS TOVS aXXous epaiyeTat vfuv TO. etpr/jxeVa dprja-Qat.
Nat, ty&vai TOV Zrivava, co ScoxpaTes. try 8' oSv TTJP
aXi]0eiay TOV ypa/x/iaros ov wavTaxov r\a-Qr)(ra,i.
/cai-roi
C <So"jrep ye at ActKeuiai o-fcuXaices eu fxera^eis re KCU fyvevcis
rh Xex.^eyra* dAAa irpStrov \iv (re rovro Xavdclvei, on ow
Travrdiramv ovrco o-fp,jn>vTai TO yp6.fj.iw, <Sore aTrep oa>
5 ju-eyoy &s TI jueya 8taTrpaTTojiA6z>oy dXXa <n>
o-ujm/3e/3i7KOT(oy TI, eVn 8e TO ye dXrjfles /3o?70eid Tts
[TU ypaftfiaTa] T<j> ITap/xeytSou Xoyw irpos TOWS
d awbv K<o/AO>8ety s ei ey eort, iroXXa Kat yeXota o-vju.j8aiyet
Trao-^ety TW Xoyw Kai eya^Tta OVT&. d^TtXeyet 8?) GUI;
TOUTO TO ypanfjia Trpos TOT>S Ta iroXXa X^yo^Tas, Kat O.VTairoSiSwo-t TavTa Kai irXetco, TOUTO )8ouXoju,eyoy SrjXouv, a>s
5 CTI yeXoioTepa irao-x.oi av avrStv f) virodecns, et iroXXd
eo-Ttv, 17 ^ TOU ey eZrat, et Tts uavfis eire^iot. ; 8ta TotatJTtjy
VTTO yeou oVTos e/uou eypd^rj, Kat Tts OVTO
ypa</>ev, wore o^Se j3oi)Xevo"a(r5at e^eyeyeTo etT*
aiiTo ets TO <|)5s etTe jui?]. Ta^TTji ovy o~e Xay^dyet,
S Sw/cpares, OTI ov^ VTIO vtov (ptXortKtas olet avTo yeypd^>dat, aXX' virb irpeo-/3uTepoi; <^tXoTtp,ias' liret, chrep y' etiroy,7 ou KCIK<SS aTnjKaaas.
I*
5
'AXX' dTroSexo/ijiai, (fravai TOV ScoKpaTrj, fcal ^youp-at G>S
Xeyets f\eiv> To8e 8e p,ot e^Tre* ov yop,teis eti/at avTo Ka0'
129 avrof et8os Tt 6/utotoTT)Tos, Kat TW TOIOWTW av aXXo TI eyayTtor, & lo-Tty avofjioiov TO'VTotv of bvotv OVTOIV Kai ejue Kat
o-e Kai TaXXa a 8?) iroXXa KaXoup.ey /meTaXaf/,j3(
Ta fiev T^S 6/AOtoTr]Tos ju,eTaXap,/3dyovTa ojnoia
5 Tavrrj Te Kat^KaTa TOO-OTOI; ocroylay p,eTaXajn/3dvT), TO
b -7 8' o3> B T : YOVI/ Heindorf
C 7 T& ypdpnara om. Proclus
d 4 Tau-r& Schleiermacher : raSro B : om. T
d 5 i B T Proclus :
2
il et vulg.
d 7 veou ^VTOS B T : vetovTos pr. B
e I o5v
T Proclus : 7' oSv B
a i a3 B Proclus : om. T

IIAPMENIAH2

iaga

rijs oyo/iotdrtjros duo/mota, ra Se dju</>orepop d/m</>oTepa; ei

8e Kal irdrra eVavruoz; OVTO>V dp,(porepa)z> p,eraAap,/3di>et,
KOI loTt TO) fxere)(e> d/u,<(HV op;oid re /cat duodena avra
avrots, rt 6avp.a<TTOv; ei p,ez> yap avra ra o/zotd us air- b
(j>cuvV d^o/xota yiyvoptva, ?/ ra dfojaota op-ota, repay &v
oiftat 7)y ei 8e ra roiJrcov /iere^ovra djtx^OTtpooz; d/x^)orepa
a,TTO(f)aCvi TieTTovOoTa, ovbev e/xotye, S Z^cov, aroirov 8o*ce?,
ov8e ye ei Ir airavra aTro^aivet ris ro> fiere)(eti; roi5 eyos 5
Kal ravra raOra -jroAAa TO) -TrX^ous oS nerfyfiv.
dAX' el
6 lorrti' ^y, avTo rouro TroAXa a7ro8etet Kat av ra TroAAa 8^
Iv, TOWO ^8rj dav^atrofJiaL.
nal irepi TWZ> SAXcoy dTrdrrcoi; C
wcravrcos1 ei juey avra Ta yevrj re Kat 1819 ez> avTots aTro(fraCvoi To.vo.vrlo. TCLVTO. TraOrj "nacr^ovra, aiov
et 8' ejxe ey Tts a7ro8et^et wra Kat iroXX.6, ri
Aeycoy, orav fjitv /3ot;\rjTat iroXXa d-TTo^yat, &>s erepa jmev 5
ra eTrt 8e^td [j.ov fcmv, erepa 8e ra eif dpto-repd, Kat erepa
ju.ez> ra TrpocrOfv, ^'repa 8e ra oirtcr^ey, Kal avw KO! Kara)
o>crat/r<os7rA.7]0ous yap otp-at //.ere^a)orav 8e er, epeT a>s
eirra fifj,&v OVTMV et$ eyw etfit avOpwos jaerexwi' Kat rou d
(wore dAi)^ aTrotyaivei dp:^)drepa. eay ovz; rts rotauTa
TJ TroAAa Kat ev ravTW diro^atpeiy, Aitfous Kat ^iJAa
Kal ra iWavra, rl (prjcrofjifv avrov iroAAa Kal ty aTro8etKin;yai,
ov ro ezX^roAAa o^8e ra iroAAa ev, ovbe rt 6avfj.a(TTov 5
Aeyetr, dAA' airep ay Trdyres 6p,oAoyotp.ey ear 8e TW 5v
yuy8^ eyw eAeyoy irpwroy jaei' StaipTjrat )(copis avra Ka^'
avra ra et8rj, otoz; ojuotorrjra re xat dyop-otorrjra Kat irA^os
Kat ro ev Kal ordo-iy Kat Kivrjffiv KOI iravra ra rotaCra^ e
etra ev eaurots raCra 8uydp,ez;a crvyKepax>w<r0ai Kat 8ta<B
1) I aire<f>aivev T : airc^aivero B
b 4 Soicer T : Sotce? e?i/at B
Proclus
C 4 ical TroXAet evra. pr. T
05 owro^ijcat Simplicius :
inroQalvfiv B T Proclus
d i ^/iw^ ju^i/ Simplicius
fyd> om.
Simplicius
da airo^mtVei B : oTro^afj/oi T
d 3 TauTb/ scripsi :
naiiTii Simplicius (TUTW D) : rauret B T
d 4 rl Simplicius : om. BT
d 6 5v B T : & Simplicius
e i rb om. Simplicius

iage

ITAATilNOS

ravra 8e dySpeicos //.ey TTCLW rjyovjoiai

5 re<r0ai* /TroXv /u-eyray <S8e jxaXXoy, ws Xeyco, dya<r0eiTjy ei
ris exoi ^^ avrrjy raTjrrjy airopiav kv avrois roi? ei8e(ri
130 iravToftair&s TrXeKO/^ie'yijy, ooo-Trep ey rots opco/xeyots
-. oUrcos KCU ey TOIS \oyio-/uS Aaja/Sayo^evots eiuSei^cu.
Aeyoiros 8??, I<|)TJ 6 IlufloSeopos, rou ScoKparous
avros [&V (civ) oteo-^at e^>' eKacrrot; axOea-Qai TOV re Ilap5 ju,ezn8r]z> Kai roy ZTjywya, TOVS 8e irayu re aiirS irpoo'extw'
Kal 0a/xa ets dAXrjAous /SAeTroyras /u,et8iay &>?
roy ScoKpdr?]. oirep oSy Kat Travorajuieyou avroS
roy E[ap/x,eyi8r]y 9li S()Kpares, <f>&vai, o>s ^tos e*
b &ya<rdai rfjs 6pfj,r)s rfjs ITT! rows Xoyous. | xat JAOI
avros (TV oi/ra) ftir/pTjcrai ws Xeyeis, x^P'5 M^y ^^
arra, x^P'^ 8e ra rovrtoy au /uer^e \pvra; Kai rt troi
eTyai avrr) 6p,oiori)S x^P'5 ^s ^els o/iocorrjros exofxey, Kat
5 ly 87) Kat TroAXa cai Trayra oo-a yuySrj Z?]ya)yos
"Ep;otye, fyavai TOV ScoKparr].
*H Kai ra rotaOra, eiTrety roy Ilapjbtey^Tjy, otoy
n ei8o? avro Ka^' avro Kat KaAou Kat ayadov (cat
a3 ra>y rowurcoy;
10
Nai, <f>avai.
C
Tt 8', avOpwTrov etSos xwP's W^1' ^^ r'*i; *ot W
Trdyrooy, avro rt eZ8os avOptoirov rj Trupos 17 Kai i!8aros;
'Ey aTropia, tyavai, iroAAaKis 877, a> HapjaeytSr/, Trepi
yeyoya, irorepa xp^j ^>ayat wcnrep irept eKeiycoy 7)
5
*H Kai Trepi rwySe, 2 Sc^Kpares, a Kat yeXoia 8oeiey ay
etyat, otoy 0pt^ Kat irrjAos Kat pvnos rj aXXo rt drijaoraroy
re Kai ^auXoraroy, onropers etre XP^J <f)avai Kat rot/rcoy
d eKao-roi) et8os eiyai \<DpCs, oy aXXo av r) 5y (ri)
fire Kai j;
e 6 T5rijj/ T : om. B

a 4 &v addidi

as re B : 75 T

b 4 o8ri) ' d^.oi6rijs B : auToojuoKjTijs T

b 7 romvra B : roittSe T
Proclus
rbv T : T^J/ re B
C 2 TI B : ri> T
e 6 rt T : <!TI B
d i a5 ^ Tt scrips! (o5 TWV 5v Heindorf ) : av-ruv* % &v B T Proclus

HAPMENIAHS
i&s, <f)<3.vai TOV StoKparTj, ctAAa ravra pey ye &7rep
6p<3ju,ey, ravra KCU efyar flbos oe n avr&v olr]Bfjvo.i elvai
fj.r) Aiay fj aroTroy. 9j6r/ jj-evToi irore p.e Kai e0pae p,?7 rt 5
17 Trept iravTtav TCLVTOV eTretra oray ravrrj or&i,
] -TTOTC ets rtra pv6bv <}>Xvapias
8' ovu dc^tKo/xevos, eis a
Neos yap et en, (frdvai rbv Tlap^evibf]v, a SwKpares, 6
cai OVTTCO (row aiTeiATjTrrai (^)tAo(ro<|)ia ws ert dvTiA.7]T^erat
Ka/ e/A^y 8o^ai>, ore oiiSey am&v drtf/,d(rets' vw 8e ert
Trpos avOp<airo)V aTro^A-eTreis 8oas 5ta rrji; ^AiKiav. " rd8e
8' ovy fAOi etire. SOKC? (roi, a>s ^>?fs, etrat ei8^ arra, &v rdSe 5
ra aAAa p-eraAa/ajSavoyra ras e7rcoyv//,tas avr&v ICT-^LV, olpv
optotoTTjTos /mey /xeraAa/Sdyra o/xota, p,eye#ot;s 8e pteydAa, 13
/cdAAov? 8e Kal SiKatoo-i/yTjs 8iKaid TC Kat KaAa
Ildyu ye, $avai TOV ScoKpdrrj.
OvKoCy 17701 oAou ro5 etSous ^ p,epous l/caoroy ro
Aap,/3dyoy p,eTaAaf*/3<iyei; r) aAA?j rts S
Kai TTWS ay;
ndrepoy ouy SOKCI trot oAoy TO etoos ey eKaoro) etyat
rwy TroAAwy ey oy, ^ TTWS;
Ti yap KcoAvei, ^)dyat rw ScoKpdrrj, w Ilapp-eyiSTj, [ey 10
etyai]; **Ey apa oy Kat javroy ey TroAAoTy Kat ^pls ovcriy oAoy b
eyeorai, nal O^TCDS awro avrov \capls ay etr/.
Ov/c ay, et ye, <j>avai, otov [et] ?jp,epa [en]] p,ia Kai 77
oScra 7roAAa\oi5 ap,a eorl Kal ou8ey rt fxaAAoy
d-3 p.4v B : om. T
d.6 <rrwT: jtrrw.B
d.7 rifafivQbvB : rtca
T : TIV &fjaj6ov Aldina : riv' &pvQov Stephanas
<j>\vapias Par.
1836, Procli CD, Synesius Origenes: <p\vapiav BT
63 aiirbi/ pr. B
6 5 8 ' oSi/ Proclus : olv B T
eTj/at e1fS?j B Proclus : eYSij eT^ai T
a 2 5e T : re B
, a 10 ev elj/ai seclusi : sveivai Schleiermacher
W S
W S
ID i cal X P^ ^ X P^ ^
^3 fveffTUi pr. T : Iv fffrcti B t
b 3 eY ye B Proclus : e!j/ai T
el om. Proclus
eftj seel. Heindorf

i3ib

OAATftNOS

5 avrr/s \(api$ eortz;, ei oirrw Kal ef/caaroz; T&V fib&v ti>

'HSeco? yf, <f>dvat, <w 2<o/cpares> tz> ravrbv ap,a

eis, otoi> el toriw KaTcnrerao-as iroAAovs avdp&irovs
7ri TroXXor? et^at oXov ^ ov TO TOIOUTOV 7777) Aeyety;
"Itrcos, (fr&vai.
'H owy oXoy e<^>' tK(i(rra) TO torioy et?j ^ty, ?/ /xepoy avrou
Mepo?.
Meprra 5pa, tyavai,, & Scta/oares, lortv avra Ta

i ra /Aerexoira avrStv /nepous &v /xerexoi, Kal

eKaarw oAoy, dA.Aa /utepos eKaorou &v eii).
" 4>atyerat ovra) ye.
'H oSy e^eXijo-eis, a> 2()Kpares, </>ayai TO
10 r^ a\r]Qeia, juieptfecrflai, Kal en Iv l(TTat;
"Opa yap, <$>avai' et avTo TO /xeye^os /xepteZs al
d Taiy TToXXwy jueyaXcoz; (AtyfOovs /j,^pet o-^iKporepw aurov TO>
juieye^ous fxeya eo-Tai, apa OVK SXoyoy ^ayeiTat;
Haw y', e^rj.
Tt 8e; row to-ov /^epos e/cao-Tov a-^LKpov airoXaftov TI
5 eei w eXaTTovt oyri aurou TOU t(rov 'TO l)(ov taoy TO> ecrrai;
'AAXa TO (TjniKpou f/,epos TIS ryfifiv efei, TOVTOU 8e awou
TO (r/xiKpoy jaeiCoy lorai Sre fxepous lauTov WTOS, /ca! ol/TO)
ST) avTo TO orjuuKpou /jtei^bv <TTCU' w 8' Si* 7rpo<rre0Tj TO
e atyaipedev, TOVTO (r^iapor^pov ItrTat dX\' ou /u,etby 17 irpiy.
OVK o;y yeVoiTo, (pavai, TOVTO ye.
TCva ovv TpoTroy, eiTrely, S Sto/cpaTes, rwy etSwy (rot
&
7 7 e : 6
c 7 &/ 6^]
C 9 ^] ei B : ^ T
da ^awelrai T : ^ati/erot B
d 4 j^epos Proclus :
Hfpovs B : fiepovs T
d 7 oAAa . . . e a ToDr<{ -ye spuria iudicabant
nonnulli apud Proclum
d 7 avroG BT Proclus : uvrb Heindorf :
a3 Schleiermacher

TIAPMENIAHS

i3ie

ra #AAa /tAeraAijx/ferai, /UTJTC Kara /xe'prj /^rjre Kara oAa

Ov /ma Toy Aia, <j>avai, ov /mot 8oKa evKoAoy etyai TO
TOIOVTOV o-ySa/uuSs Siopfrrao-0ai.
Tt 8e 8rj; -Trpos To8e irSs exets>
HP V
**
lo Trotoy;
Oijixat o^e ex rou Toto8e %v HKCHTTOV et8os otecr^at etrat' 132
OTCU> TroXA.' aTTa fxeyaXa (roi 80^17 tluai, /xta Tts tcrcos SOKCI
i8ea ^ auT^ etyai eirl irdvra Ibovri, odev %v TO /ut^ya ^yr)
Aeyeis, ^>arat.
8' awe TO /xeya xai raXAa ra fxeytiAa, eay

V TI av

AA.Ao apa eiSos /ueye^ou? ava^avrfa-fTai, Trap' amo re TO 10

s yeyovos KOI TO. /txere^oyTa avroS- ' Kai CTTI TOVTOIS au
frepov, w TOUTC -Travra /oteydAa lo-Tar Kai OVKCTI 8rj b
cfcaorov o-ot TWI; eiSwz; fcrrai, aAAa aTretpa TO
, /jirj TO>I>
rv
'AAA(i, <j)avai, 3)
Trpocr^Kf] eyyi, Kai ov8a/uou
TOVTC&V
aAAo^i 17 ly i|wxats* ol/Tco yap ay ev ye fnaarov fit] 5
i o/c ay In irao-^ot a Z>WT) eAe
Ti owy; Q&vcu, tz;
eo-Tt TWV
, vdrj/xa 8e
'AAA' d8t;yaroy, eiiretv.
'AAAa Tiyos;
Nai'.
ov*c oVros;

a a rot 8(5|}7 B Proclus : 8^17 ffoi T

a 3 ij a^r^ B Proclus :
a&ri) T
a 7 a5 T Proclus : auroO B
a 8 it&vra. B :
fodyicri T Proclus
b 4 $ rotrwv B Proclus : TO^TWV p T
Proclus : vpocr-fjKfi B T
' b 5 ye B : re T

I32C

ITAATilNOS

O^x evos TWOS, & fTcl irao-iv eKeivo TO yoTJjma ezrdv voei,
fJiCav TWO. ovo~av iSeay;
5
Nai.
Etra OVK ei8os ecrrai TotJro TO voovpevov %v etvai, del &v
TO OVTO 6771 TTaeriy;

10

'AyayKrj av < aiyeTat.

Tt oe 877; eiTreiu roy FlapjuieviSrjv, OVK. dray/crj 17 raXAa
0^s TWI; db&v juerexeiy ^ Soxei <rot IK yorj/xarcov
Kat Tr&VTa voelv, rj vor^ara OVTO. dyorjra
.' ov8e TOVTO, <f>dv(u, f\i Xoyov, dAA',
/xdAta-ra l/Aoiye Kara^aiverat <38e fyeLV TO. fjiev fibrj raura
wcnrep TrapaSeiyfxara eorayai ey TT) (jbucrei, ra Se aAAa TOVTOIS
Kat etyai 6/x,otc5/Liara, Kal r; fjAOfi.s a^rrj rois
i T&V eib&v OVK aXXrj ns ^ eiKacr^yat avrots.
Ei ow rt, I^>T), eo6Kez> rw ei8ei, otoV re eKeu;o ro
/xr) ofAOioy etvai TW ciKao-^evri, Ka^' So-oy avrw
^ l(rri ris i^^avr] TO opoiov /XT) o/^iota) ojuotoy
OVK lort.
To 8e opoiov TW ofxota) ap* ov /^eyaArj dvayKTj Ivos TOU
avroij [etSovs]

Ov 5' ay ra o/xota ^erexoyra ojmoia ?}, OVK eKeiyo eo*rat

avro ro eT8os;
5
riayrdirao-t /mey ovy.
Ov/c apa otoy re n rS etSei ojaoiov eTvat, ov8e ro eT8os
aAAft)1 ei Se JXTJ, Trapa ro et8os det aAAo dya^ayrjcrerai et8os,
133 Kai ay eKeiyd rw o/xotoy T], erepoy au, Kat ovSeirore iravo-erai
del K.O.IVOV eTSos ytyyojuteroy, eay ro etos rw eaurou
yiyyrjrai.
C 3 iirbv roe? Procli B : ^irbi/ voeTv T : erirov voerr B
09
tf Waddell : avdym] y B : avdyKii y T : avd.yK'n el Proclus
C 10 So?
B T Proclus : SoKetv vulg.
d 2 e^ B T Stobaeus : om. Proclus
d.6 '6fjLOiov elvai B Proclus : elvai ti/xotoi/ T
e i eWous seel. Jackson
a I ^/cetW Tip T Proclus : eitfiv<f rb B (sed y in ras.)
$] ^ B T

TIAPMENIAH2

133 a

Aeyeis.
OVK apa Ojuiotorrjrt raAAa r&v ei8coi> /^eraXa/i/Savei, dAAa, 5
rt aAAo 8eZ 0]Te?i; co
'Opa? ovV, </>ai>at, & SwKpares, o<n/ T) diropia eciv TT? cos
et8rj oz>ra avra Ka0' aura 8iopirjrat;
Kat iaXa.
10
Ev TOLVVV icrOi, (fravai, on <as e'Tros eiTretr owSeirco
f] airopLa, et e"y etbos eKaoroy rcoy oVrcoy b
i u dcpopt^cfyieyos Berets.
Hois 817; eiTrety.
IToAAa i&v Kal ctAAa, cpciyat, //.eytoroy Se ro8e.
et rt?
7rpocr?7Keiy avra yiyvuxrKecrdai ovra rotavra otd
c^a/Aer 8eu> etvai ra et8r/, rco ravra Aeyoyrt OVK ay e)(ot rts
eySetgacr^ai ort v/AevSerai, et /x^ TroAAcoy /u,ey TV\
coy 6 df/.c/)t<rj8Tjrcoy Kat JXT) afaris, e^e'Aot 8e Trayv TroAAa
TTOppcaOev Trpayjixarevopieyou rou ey8etKyu/ieyou en
etTrt^ayos etrj 6 ctyycocrra dyayKa(a>y avra etyat.
UTJ 877, a> Ilapftevibrj; <payai roy 2a)KpdrT7.
Ort, cb 2coKpares, oTjuat &y Kal ere Kat aAAoy, ocrris
avr^y rtra Ka^' avrrjy 6KdVrou ova-Lav rtt^erat et^at, f 6/x.oAoy^crai ay TrpcSroy jxey fxrj8e)ixtay avruy eTyat ey ^juuy.
ricos yap ay avrrj Ka0' avrriv ert etrj; (pavcu TOV
- KaAcos Aeyets, ei7reu>.
(cat ocrat rcoy t8ey Trpos aAA?7Aas eio-ty a t
Trpos avras r^y ovcrtay f-^ovcriv, dAA' ov Trpos ra Trap
etre 6p;otco/ixara etre OTTTJ 817 rts avra rt^erat, <Sy r^fiets
eKacrra fTTOvo^a^of^eOa' ra 8e Trap Tj/ity
raura 6p,cjyv/ijia oyra eKetyots avra av Trpos avrci eariy
dAA' ov Trpos ra et8rj, Kat eavrcoy dAA' OVK eKetycoy ocra av

5
^
,

."
5

5
a 8 <5>s T Proclus : om. B
b i et' T Proclus : ^ B
b 7 jufcv T :
om. B Proclus
C I tfrj B Proclus : &i> ?TJ T
cw/fry/catW auri
B Proclus : avroi ava.yKa.fav T

04 eKaa-rou B : ainov eKacrrov T

HAATilNOS

5
134

10

TIcos Aeyeis; tpdvai TOV ScoKpdrrj.

Qlov, (pdvai TOV nap/xenSTjy, ei ris T/piSzJ TOV SecrTrcmjs 77
SoSAos ttmv, OVK avrov becriroTOV brjirov, o ecrri bwnoTrjs,
e/ceivou SoSAos ecmv, ou8e aurov cwvAou, 6 eort 8<n5A.os,
8e<T7roTT]s 6 8e<T7roTr)s, dAA' frvOpatTios ooi' avdputTtov a^oTepa
raOr' farCv avrrj 5e Secnroreta avrijs SouXeiay l<rriy o eori,
Kai SovAeta axravrcos avrr) SouAeia avr?7S Setrrroreias, dAA' ov
TO. tv fifuv Trpos l/ceiya TTJV bvvafAiv e)(et oiiSe e/cetra TT/SOS rjf/.as,
dAA', o Aeyco, aura am&v KCU Trpbs avra eKetra re eo-ri, KOI
ra irap' T^jbuv wcraurcos Trpo? aura, r/ ov fxav^dvets 5 Aeyco;
Haw y', etTreZv roy ScoKpar?}, fjLav9avu>.
OVKOVV Kdl eTrioTTj/ixTj, (frdvai, avTij /xey o eort eTrioTT^/Arj
7775 6 lorti; dA^eta avr^s &v eKeiyrjs eir] eTrtor^fXTj;
IlctM) ye.
'E/cacrrTj 8e av T&V (TTLcrTrjfji&v, rj fora?, eKciorov T&V
OVTU>V, 5 lariv, ettj civ emcmjjoiT]' ^ 01;;
No(.
*H 8e irap' ^/xiy ki:i<Trf\^t] ov rrjs Trap' fjfuv av d
e^i), Kal au e/cdcm? 17 -Trap' ^/xtj; eTTicrr^juwj T&V Trap*

tlvai;
.'AAAa JXTJV auTcl ye. TO eiSrj, cos 6/^oA.oyets, ovre
ovre Trap' ij/uuv otoV re eivai.
5
Ou yap oSv.
rtyvcocricerat 8e ye TTOU UTT' avroi) rou eifiovs rou
e7Ttcrr?]fATjs aura ra yeyrj a e<rriv eKatrra;
Nat'.
*O ye ^ju,eis OVK e
10
Ou yap.
UK apa U7TO ye 77
aur^s eTrior^jarjs ou
e i & JOTI T : 3ffn
e B ; o^oi'Tot T

a 6 aS TW> B : ainwv T

b 4 <S

HAPMENIAH2
OvK eWey.

*Ayycooroy apa Tj/uy Kal avrb TO KaAoy & lort nal

TO ayaObv Kal irdvra a by ws iSe'as avras ovo-as TjiroXa/A/Sci- C

"Opa 817 en rovrou 8ew>orepoy ro8e.

To irolov;
4>airjs ay irov, etirep ecrrtz; airo rt ytvos
awb eiKptjSeo-repoy eu>ai ^ rr)v Trap' 57/1x1^ e
/cat raA.Aa TroWa oilro).
OVKOW eTirep ri tiAAo aur^s e7rt<rr?7/xTjs fjL(T\fi,

OVK av nva 10

*Ap' oiiy otos re au ^arai 6 #eos ra Trap' ^jaiy yiyp<0cnceu> d

TC yap ov;
"On, I(|)T7 6 ITap//,eyi8T]s, a)/moA.oyrjrat ^/ity, S Sco
fKftva TO. t8r] irpos TO. Trap' ^/xiy r^v bvvanw C\LV fjv 5
exet, ju^re ra Trap' ^rv Trpos eKflva, dAA.' avra Trpos avra
exaYepa.
yap.
et Trapa rw 0e5 OVTTJ eoriv 77 aKpi^Seo-Tarr;
Seo-Troreta Kal avrrj 77 aKpij8e(rrarr7 eTrtorrj/AT/, oi/r' ar 77 10
8e(TTroreia 77 Kiva>v fjp.&v Trore ay SetrTrocreiei', oi/r' ay
ITTICTTIJUAT} 77fxas yyoti7 ou8e ri aAXo Twy Trap' Tjjuty, dAA.a C
opotcos 77/xeIs re e/ceiya)y OVK ap^Ojixey rr) Trap'
yytotrKo/^ey roS 0eiou ov8ev r?) ^jbterepa
re au Kara rw avroy Xoyov OVTC oeo"noTai fj
fldlv OVTC y6yyco(TKOi)(rt ra dy^pcoTreia Trpayjmara ^eol 5
OVTGS.

b 14 ^/^Tc B :tyiu/ffrt T Proclus

c 6 wow T : ^ oft B
B : Sx\rj T
d n otfr' &v T : o#r' &y ^ B Proclus

C 10tfAAo

1346

135

IIAATflNOS
'AAAa fXTj Aiay, tyrj, <$) flaujmaoTo? 6 Ao'yos, et TIS Toy
0e6y cbrocrrepTTVei TOV elbevat.
TaOra /xeVrot, & 2a>Kparey, er</>rj 6 Ilap/jieyiSTjs, Kai In
aAAa irpos rovrots iravv TroAAa avaynaiov lxety ra *^T), ei
eioru> avrat at iSeat r<3y OVTODV Kai optetrat m avro n
wore anoptiv re rov aKovoyra Kai d/x^)t<r/3rja>s ovre eon rai)ra, e^ re on ^aXitrra etrj, TroXA.
avra e?vat rrj avQpunrivri (ftvcrfi ayvcoara, Kal rairra
re ri Ae'yety Kai, o apn eAe'yojaey, Oavfiaar&s ws
Kai avSpos 7rayu fxey ev<uoSs rou
&>s eari yevos n eKacrrov /cat ovcria avrrj
*ca0' avrTjy, en 8e ^au/xacrrorepou row evp?](royros Kat
8i8a^at raura Traura iKarws bifVKpLv^a-df
ci) o-oi, e(J>T7, ai Tlap/^eytSTj, 6 ScoKpdrrjs' Trdru yap
t Kara youy Aeyeis.
'AA.Aa /xeyrot, etirey 6 Hap juteu 18175, et ye ns 817, a>
s, a5 /AT) eacrei et8rj rwy oyrcoy etyai, eis TTavra ra
ij Kat aAAa rotara aTrojSAei^as, ju,rj8e n optetrat eZ8o?
eKacrrou, ov8e cnrot rpex/^et r^y 8tayotay e^et, /J,T) efiy
t8eay r3y wrcoy eKacrrou rrjy avri)v det eiwi, *cat ovrcos rrjy
rou 8taA.eye<r0ai bvvafMV TravTCLTracn 8ta^>0epet. roC rotot/rou
^ey owy p,ot Soxets Kat
'AArj^ Aeyety, cpayai.
Tt ouy 7rot7](rets <piAocro<tas irept; TT^ rpe^r/ a
TOVTGOV;
Ov Trayu /u,ot OKW KaQopav ly ye r5 irapovn.
Ilp&) yap, etTreiy, Trpty yv/xyao-^yat, a> SwKpares, opt^eo-^at e-Trtxetper? KaAoV re n Kai 8tKatoy Kat ayadbv Kat |y
enaa-Tov T>V elb&v. fvfv6r)<ra yap Kat Trpiprjv <rov
e 7 77 add. Heindorf
e 8 ewroo-rep^ffei Stephanus :
BT
as eKaerToi/l an 4/c<i(rTOu Heindorf
a 7 ew<J>t>of)s (Se?i/^
Heindorf
b 2 dvvT)cr6fj.fvov pr. T
ravra. vdvra, B Proclus :
irdvra ravra T
b 5 -ye rts S^ B Proclus : 8^ ye TIS T
b 6 eocr?;
BT
b 7 ^ Sert B : ^8' fat T
c 5 irp B T : irot Proclus
C 8 irpip B T : irpcprjv Proclus (et mox &rexefy>en) : yp.

ey0d8e 'A/uoroTeAet rfiSe.

KaA?) juey ow Kat
0eta, eu t(T0t, 77 oppir) rjv 6pp,qs e^ri TOVS Aoyovs* $kKV(rov be
(ravTov Kal yuiivacrai fiaAAoy 8ta TTJS SOKO^OTJS d^p^orou
elvai Kal KaAou/4ei>?]s -into rS>v iroXXS>v d8o\eo'^ias, ecos en 5
veos el* et 8e /XT], <re 8ta<^ev^erat 7} dArj^eia.
T^s ovz> 6 rpoVos, (fxivai, a> Ylap^vCbr], TTJS yv^vao-tas;
QVTOS, etTrev, ovntp TyKoucras ZTjytoyos.
^A-^v roiird ye
<rou Kal Trpos rouroy riy&a-Orjv eiTroyros, on OI/K eias ey TOIS 6
ov8e Trepi raSra r^y TrA.cii'Tjy eTrio-KOTreZi', dXAa
ju-dAiord TIS &v Aoyw AajSot Kat eT8?j
elrat.
Aoxet y&p fxoi, e^rj, ra^TT; ye ov8ei> xa^7roy etyai *cal 5
o^ota Kat drojuoia Kal aAAo 6uoi)i> Ta orra
Kat KaAws y', e^rj.
xP^ ^ K
x^ jmoyoy et ecruy ZKCUTTOV v^oTiO^vov <rKoireiv TO,
(rvp,/3aCvovTa IK rrjs imoOeirtuts, dAAa Kat et JLIT^ eort TO awro 136
TOVTO viroTiQea-dai, et /3oiAet fxaAAoy yvp.va<rdfjvai.
ITws Aeyets; (fravai.
Olov, e^Tj, et jSovAei, Trept ra^rr)? T^S v-Tro^eo-ecos 771;
Zrjyaw vTre^ero, et TroAAci etrrt, rt XPT) (rv^aivfiv Kat a^rots 5
rot's TroAAots irpos avTa Kat irpbs TO v Kat T<3 eyi Trpos re
auro Kat Trpos ra TtoXXa," Kal av ei \M] ecrTt TroAAd, TrdAty
(TKOTtttv TI o-uju,j877(reTat Kat TW eyt Kat Tots TroAAots Kat irpos
avra Kat Ttpbs aAArjAa' Kat aS^ts av ear VTroOrj et etrTti; b
ojuotoTrjs r/ ei fjirj fcmv, ri ecp' eKaTepas TT^S inroOf<r(jos
(ru/j,/3?7creTat Kat a-uTOts Tots {nroreOflcnv Kal rols aAAot? Kat
Trpos avTa Kat Trpos aAArjAa.
Kat Trept avojAoiov 6 avTos
Ao'yos Kat Trepl Kivri<r(t)S Kat Trepi oTao-ecos Kat Tre/H yeye<rea)S 5
Kal (pdopas Kal ?rept a^Tou TOU etvat Kat TOU p-r) slvai' Kat
d.4 -y^voo-at B Proclus : yvfj.va.ffov T
oSrws B
?// B T : ctvetc Proclus
63 elfSTj BT Proclus: #5j vulg.
b i o30(s T : owrots B

d.8 oSros T Proclus:

e i etas ev T : e?a<rej> B
a 6 re T: ye B Proclus

136 b

IIAATI1NOS

tvl Aoy<i>, irept orou av ad vxodrj o>s OVTOS Kal &>s OVK owos
Kal 6novv &XXo Traces iratr^oyros, Set CTKOTTCIV ra o-u/x/3aC VOVTO. irpos avro icat Trpos ti> cjcaoroir rwj; aXA.a>z>, on az>
-TrpoeAr), Kai irpos TrXetco Kal irpos (rupnavra ftxravrws* *cal
raAA.a av irpos aurd re Kal irpbs tlAAo on av TTpoaipy dei,
edire ws or vitoQy o virer^etro, arre ws JUT) oy, et
5 TeXeoos yu/ii'a(ra/ix,6i'os KVpCats 8io\/re(T0ai ro aArjfles.
'A/xi7xa^ov y' I0i), A^yeis, 2) Hap/xey 1817, Tr
Kat ov (r^)o8pa p.av6dv(d. dAAa /AOI rt ov 8t^X0es avros
VTfodffj,ev6s TL, tva paXXov Karafta^w;
d
IloXt; !pyoz>, tyavai., a> 2a>Kpares, Trpoarrarrets ws rrjXtKGSe.
'AAAa (TV, eiireZy TOI> ScoKpdrr), Ziji'coy, TI ov
Kai rw
5 2(oKpares, 8e(op-ea apjuieyiou* ju, yap ov
Aeyei. ^ ov)( opas ocroi; epyov Trpoorarreis; d jaei^ ovv
TrXeious ^/uei^, OVK &v a^ioy TJV SeTcr^ai* airpeTriJ yap ra
Toiaura iroAAwz; kvavriov Xeyet^ aXXcos re Kal rrjXiKovnfr
e dyyooScru; yap ol -roAXol ore Si'eu rcnmjs T^S 8ia iravrutv
re *cal TrXayi? dS^yaroz; eyTvoiTa rfi

Kat avros SiaKovcrcrt 5ia \p6vov.

TaSra 8rj elirovros TOV Zrivtovos, l(pr) 6 'A.VTi<pG>v ^xivai
TOV HvQobcopov, avrov re beta-Oat. TOV Tlap^fvibov KCLL TOV
'ApiorroTeAi] Kat TOVS aXXovs, ez;8eia<r0at 6 Xeyot Kat
JUT) aXXws Trotety. roy ovz; nap/xeytSrj^' 'AvayKTj, <pavat,
TieCdeo-Oai. Katrot SOKW f/,oi ro rou I/3uKetou tirTrov
137 Qevai, <2 eKetvos d0XT)rT) oyrt Kat Trpeo-jSurepa), v0'
dycoyietcr^at Kat 81* e/xiretptay rpe/xoyrt ro
5

b 7 ft? B : o?v T
e 3 fey T : oSr B
vpoaipy alel B Proclus :
alel irpootpfj T
04 ufl-erfOeffo T : viroriOetrBf B
05 S{^6(r0ai T :
8i<tye<r0e B
c 6 -y' T : om. B
c 8 rt ?va T : T'lva. B : rf^a al.
d 5 8e<6/0a T : 8e<J^e9a B
63 (rxery T : exeiv B Proclus
e 4 8mB Proclus : OKO&TW T

IIAPMENIAHS

i37a

oy aTTfiKd<ov CLKO&V H<pr] Kal avrbs OTJTO) TrpetrjS^TTjs coy

cis Toy Ipcora avayK.a&vQai teyar Kayw f/,oi 8oKa> /x,ep.y7ip,e'yos
jjuiXa <po/3eio-0ai TTWS x/3*) TfjAtKoySe orra 8tayeiio-at rotoCroy 5
re Kal TOCTOVTOV TreAayos Aoycoy opxos 8e 8et yap \ap[^fcrOai,
/cat, o Zr^yeov Aeyet, avroi e(rjuiey. TroOev ovv STJ
Kai rt Trp&rov fnroO'qcrofjLfOa; r) fiovXea-Qe, e?rei- b
8?j7rep 6oKei Trpay/jiaretcoSrj rraiStai' Trai^etr, UTT' e/ixaurcw
/cat T^S e/xavrou V7ro0e(rea>s, irepl roS evo?
s, etTe eV ecrriy etre jurj eV, rt xp
Tldvv /xev ovy, tyavai TOV Zrjvcava.
Tis ovv, eiireiy, /xot ctTTOKpi^errat; ^ 6 rewraros;
yap ay TtoXvTTpayfj.ovo'i, Kal a oterai fxaAiara av
*at a/jia e/xot di'a'TrauAa ay eirj 77 eKeirou airo Kpi<ns.
"Eroi/ios o-oi, a) napjueyiSr], (fravai, TOVTO, TOV 'Apioro- C
e/u,e yap A.eyeis TOV vecorarov Ae'yooz;. dAAa Ipcora ws
Etev 877, (p&vai.' cl 'iv \vriv, aAAo TI o^/c ay etrj iroAAa
ro ^y; ITws yap ay; Ot/re apa /xepos avrov oiire oAoy 5
avro 5ei etyai. Ti STJ; To p-epos TTOV oAou /xepos eoriV.
Nat. -Tt 8e ro oAov; o^xt ov &y juepos ^rjbev airfj oAoy ay
etT]; Haw y. 'A/x^orepcos apa TO ey eK /xepwy av et?j,
oAoy re ov Kal p.ep?] exoy. 'AvdyKTj.^ 'Ajw^orepcos ^y apa
oura>s TO ly TroAAa etrj aAA' o^x eV.-'AA^^r^.- Aet 8e ye d
^ iroAAa aAA' ty avTo etyat.^ Ae. ^OVT' apa oAoy la-Tat
OVT fxep?7 ^et, et ey eo-Tat TO e'y. Ov yap.
OwKouy et p^Sey ex" fiepo?, O{!T' ay apx^jy ovre TeAeuT^y
/j,eo-oy exoi* fiep?} yap ^y 77877 avTov Ta TotauTa etTj. 5
. Kat /xT^y TeAei)T77 ye xat dpx^ irepas l/coa-rov.
IISs 8' OTJ;^ATretpoy apa TO ey, et ja77Te dpxTJy ju.77Te TeAeuTT)y excl> -"ATretpoy. Kat ayev o-x7)p-aTos apa- OVTC yap
a 5 StoveSffat T : Siavvffai B
a 6 veKayos Stephanus e Ficino
et sic Proclus legisse videtur : ir^Bos B T
a 7 & Bekker : 6 B T
b i ap|<5/i0a T (sed o ex a>) Proclus : apci>iif6a B
c i roOro B T :
TOVTOV vulg.
e 6 '6\ov jjiepovs B : ^tepos H\ov T
d. 4 e^et T :
B
fyri B
d 8 ?x T : IXP
?etp B T : 7ap &y vulg.
PLATO, VOL. II.

137 e

HAATiiNOS

e o-rpoyyvAov ovre evfle'os juerexet.Ucos;SrpoyyiiAoy ye* TTOV

eort roCro ov ay ra eVxara Trayraxfj aTro TOT) fxeVou tcroy
aTre'xT).Nat.Kat p.r)y evfltJ ye, ov ay ro jaeo-ov dp.<poty
roty ecrxdroty eTTiTrpoo-fley 77.Ovrtos.OVKOVV /xeprj ay
5 ?xoi TO ty Kat -jroAAa ay euj, etre tvOzos (rx^aros etre
jrepwpepoi;? p.erexot.Hca'u /xey o?!y.Ovre dpa eii^v ovre
138 ireptc^epes ecrTty, e-rreiTrep ovSe jieprj exei.^'Op^fis.
Kal fXTjy Toiovroy ye 8v ov8a/xoC ay eir]' ovre yap ey
aAXfa) o#re ey eavrfi etrj.TIG>$ 877;-'Ey a\A<i> p-ey oy
KVKA.&) TTOU ay Treptexoiro VTT' eKetyou ey w eyeti], *cat
5 TroXAaxoS &y avrou aTirotTo TroAAors- TOU 8e lyos re Kat
dp-epous Kat KuicAou p,^ perexoyros dSvyaroy TroAAaxfj KVKAw
aiTTecr^at.^'ASwaroy.'AAAa fjyv aiiro ye ey eaurfi oy
Kay eauTW etTj Treptexoy OUK aAAo ^ avro, etirep Kat ey
b eatww etr]' ey rw yap rt eTyat fj^ Treptexoyrt dSvyaroy.-.
'A8waroy yap.OvKoSy erepoy p,ey ay rt etrj avro ro
Trepte'xoy, erepoy 8e ro Treptexopeyoy ov yap oAoy ye ap-</>a>
ravroy ap,a ireto-erat Kat Trotter Kat oiirco ro ey OVK ay
5 etrj en ty dAAa Svo.'Ov yap ovy.OVK apa eo-rty TTOU
ro ey, p;?)re ey avrw /xijre ey aAAa> eyo'y.OVK ecrrty.
"Opa 17, oiirft)5 exoy et otoy re etrrty e<rrdyat rj KtyetcrQai.Ti 8^ yap OTJ;^'Ort Kivovpevov ye ?) ^>epotro ^
C dAAoioi/ro ay avrat yap poyat Kiy?]creis.Nat.
p-eyou 8e ro ly eawrou a&uyaroy TTOV ly en etyat.-'
yaroy.OUK apa Kar' dAAotco(rty ye Ktyet^rat.Ov
rat.'AAA' apa roi ^)epeo-^at;^lacos.Kai p,^y et (pepotro
5 ro e'y, ?jrot ey rw avrw ay irept^epotro KikAw 17 /xeraAAdrrot \a>pav erepay e^ erepa?.^'AydyKrj.OVKOW KVKAa)
p^ey 7rept(/)epop.eyoy eTrt p,eo-ou /3e^8r]Keyat avdyKt], Kat ra
e i jueTe'x Proclus : perexoi B T
63 aire'x*? T b : &j> exi? Pr- B
e 4 jf T: eft) B
a 4 evetrj Heindorf: &c ev efoj B : &j/ efoj T
a 8 4auT^ B : eatrrb T Proclus
avr6 Diels : a,vr6 B T Proclus
b i fivcu T : frj B
b 2 ourb] auroD Schleiermacher
b 6 *v6v
T : %v ov B
b 7 CITTU' T : om. B
b 8 y* b Proclus al. : re pr.
B T Stobaeus
C 2 irov ev tn elvai B : en irov etvcu T

HAPMENIAHS

1380
ety

irepi TO fj.(rov <pp6fj,eva &AAa p^pTj ^X

caurou* &> 8e
p^re yA<rov /xijre pepStv i:po(rr\Ki, TIS ivqyjxvr] roCro KVKAo> d
iror' em roC p,eo-ov eve^0^yai; Ov8epua. 'AAAa 8rj \topav
d/uei/3o/> aAAor' aAAofli yiyrerai *cai oimo Kireirai; Eforep
ye 877. OVKOVV ttvai p-ey TTOV <-v run avrw dSvWroy
tfpavrj; Nat. 'Ap' ovv yiyvevQai. en dSuvarwrepoy; 5
OVK VvoG> oTrry.- Ei Ir r<a ri yiyverai, OVK avdyKrj p-^re
etyai ITI kyyiyvopevov, p-^r' ert e&> eKtivov
ftirep ^8r/ eyyiyyercu;^'Aydy/CT;.. Et apa Tt
aAAo Trettrerai rouro, e/ceu>o ay povov Tfdcr^oL ov p-eprj etij' e
TO fiey yap &v rt avrou ^817 ev e/ceii^tp, ro 8e e^w ej a/xaoXov ap,a ^re eyros etyai riyos fjMjre e^co. ^"AXrj^r). OS
p-ep?] etcrl p^re oAov ruyxyet oy, ov TroAv er6 5
lyyiyyecr^ai TTOU, p77Te Kara p-eprj p?]re Kara
o\ov tyyiyvopevov; ^ai^erat. Ovr' apa TTOL Ibv not Zv
r&> yiyv6\ievov \a>Pav ctAAdrret, OVT ev rw am& Trept^epo- 139
fj-fvov OVT aXXoiovjAfvov. OVK eotKe. Kara iracrav apa
K.(vri<riv TO v aKivrjTov.- 'Attivr\Tov. 'AAAa fj.r]V Kat fivaC
y <pap.fv f v TLVI avro abvvaTov. 4>ap,ev yap. Ov8' apa
Trore fv roi avrw ecrriy. Ti 8^/'-"On 77877 av ev eKeiro) 5
flrj f v & r avrw kcrriv. Havv pey oSv. 'AAA' ovre ey
avrS ovre ey aAAw otor re %v OVT& Zveivat. Ov yap
vvv. OvSe-TTore apa kcrrl TO V fv rw avrw. ^OvK loiKer.
'AAAa [j/r)v ro ye pirj^eirore f v r5 avrS oy ovre T](rv\iav b
ayet ov^' $<rn)Kfv. Ov yap olov re. To ey apa, a>y loiKev,
ovre fcrrrjKev o!5re Kiz^e^rat. OVKOVI> 8r^ (pairerat ye.
OvSe ptrjy ravroy ye ovre ere'pw ovre eavrw eo-rat, ov8'
av erepoy ovre avrov ovre ere'pou ay eirj.'HTJ 877; ^Erepoy 5
d 3 o-iifl^ov T : aneificM B
d 4 aur^ pr. B T : OUT?) b vulg.
d.6 ^T6 ir<a B : /ArjSeTra) T
d 7 jtsfj-r' er Heindorf : /^ren B T :
/t^T6 TI vulg.
d 8 ^87? T : 8)j B
fyyiyverai T : Iv y^veTai B
6 5 etVl] eo-rl Heindorf
a 6 vy O,VT$ B T Proclus : rb aurJi al.
a 7 ^yetwt b : ev elvai B T
b I tj/ T : om. B
b 5 TT) T : rivi B

Iggb

140

FIAAT&NOS
\iAv irov eavrov &v Ms erepoi> av elrj KOJ. OVK. av elr\ tv.
'AXriOrj
Kat JU.TJI; TOVTOV ye erepy ov eKeivo av elrj, airrb
8' owe av elrj- (Sore ovb' av ovrtas fir] oirep earw, ev, aXX'
eYepor evos.Ov yap ovv.Tavroi> pev &pa eTe'p<j> rj erepw
eavrov OVK laraiOv y&p."Erepov 8e ye ere'pou oiic
larai, Icos tiv r} tv ov yap f v l irpooTjicei ^r^p<o TLVOS
flvai, dAAa \j.6vu> Irepw Irepov, 5XA.O) 8e ovScvt.'Op0fis.
Tfi /iei Spa ev ewai OVK larai eYepoir ^ oiei;Ov
.^"AXXa pr\v d JJ.TI rovro), ofy favr& torai, fl oe M
rfcj, ovbt avro- avrb be /ir)8ap.?j civ erepov ovbevbs lorat
erepov.'Opff&s.Oiibe priv TOVTOV ye eavr& lorat.Has
8' ov;Oix ^firep roC Ivos <j>v<ns, avni briTtov KOI TOU
ravroC.Ti bri;"Ori OVK, eireibav TO.VTOV yevrfTai r<j> f t ,
Iv yiyverai.'AAAa TI /xijv;Tois iroXXois Tavror
fierov iroAAa dvtiyKTj yiyve<r0ai ctAA' oix <
'AXA.' el TO Ir KOI TO raw-dp /xr/Sap.?) Sia^e'pei, owdre TI
Tavroi> eylyvero, &el ar Iv eyCyvero, Kal owore Iv, TOWTOP.Ildw yeEi Spa T^ li> !avr$ TavTov eorat, aux
Iv eatrr^ lorar xal ow-w Ji> ov oi/x %v larai. aXAo priv
rovr6 ye abtivarov abvvarov &pa Kal rip evl ij erepov erepov
elvat TI lavrSt TavrbV.'Abvvarov.O%ra> 8tj trtpov ye
TI ravrov TO ev ovr av avrip OVT' av er^p<f elf\.Ov yap
ovv.
Oi8e fwjv 8fj.oi6v TIVI larai oi8' av6fj.oiov ovre avrip ovrt
.Tf 817;^On TO ravr6v irov Tteirovdbs Sp.oiov.
.ToC 8^ ye evbs \wpls e<pdv7} TT)I tyvcnv TO ravT&V.^'E<pavrj yap^"AXAa p^v el TI -neirovBe x<*pis TOU
tv elvai TO ev, itKfLto av elvai "neisovQoi rf ev, TOVTO 8^
tibvvarov.Nat.Ov8ap.a>; etniv apa ravrbv irfitovOos
elvai TO ev ovre a\\tf ovre eavrip.Ov <paiveTai.Ovbt
O 5 t-rifov T Proclus: om. B
07 Tobrif T: oSru B
di ye Proclus: om.'BT
da avr^i Proclus: e&rii B: oM) T
roS ToiroC T : roiroC B
64 )] 8<) ^ Heindorf: ' ^ Waddell
e 7 ofrr' iavrif T: oiTiky oi/Tif B

HAPMENIAH2
apa bvvarbv avro flvai ovre dXAo) owe eaurai.'OVK
. Ov8e /utrjy eYepoy ye irfTrovdev etuai TO ev KCU yap
oUrco TrXeuo ay it^novdoi eiyai r/ e'y. IlAeico yap. To ye
erepov TTTrov6b$ i] eavrov ?? aXXou avop,oiov ay etrj 17 e
^ ^AAo), e^Tre/) TO TOVTOV TtcTtovOos o/uoioy. 'Op^ws. To
8e ye eX a>s eoi/cev, ovSajaais erepov TTSTtovObs ov$ap.Gts
avojJ-Oiov eariy ovre awai oi/re erepo).^Ov yap ovy.
Ovre ^ipa o/xoioy ovre avopoiov ovO* erepw ovre eavToi &y ei?]
ro ^v. Ov (pairerai.
Kai jUT/y rotovroy ye ^v ovre 10-01; ovre O.VKTOV eo~rat
odre eaurS ovre aAAw. HT]; ?l(rov fjtei; oy ry avrfiy
jmerptoi; eo-rat eKeiyo) ^ &y &roy ^. Nai. Meibi> 8e TTOU
^ eXarroy ov, ots /u.ev ay orv/Afxerpoi' 17, rSj; fxey eAarroixoy
TrAe&o fterpa e^et, rwy 8e pfi^ovav eXarrto. Nai. Ots 8'
^y /x^ o-v/xjaerpoy, raw jaey o-jaixpoTepcoy, rwy 8e //.ei^oycoz/
juterpcov ea-rai.'IIo)? yap ov; OvKovy dSvyaroj; ro JIXT)
ju,ere)(oy rou atirou T/ p.erpwi' raiy avrwi; etyoi r) aXXcov
wvrivcoyow rwy avrGtv; ^'ASwarov. -wlo-oy /Aei> apa ovr'
ay eavrS ovre aXXa> eaj ja^ rfiy avr<Si> p-erpcoy oi;. OVKOW
tpaiverai ye. 'AXXa fx^y TrXeto'ycoy ye fxerpcoy oy 17 eXarroycoy, ^(rcoyirep jaerpcoy, roo-ovrcoy /cat jxepaiy ay etrj' Kal
ovrco av ovxert ey eorat dXXa rocraura oo-aTrep Kal ra
/xerpa. 'Qp6S>s. Ei 8e ye eyos /xerpou eu], tcroy ay ytyyoiro rw //.erpw- roCro 8e dSvyaroy (pavrj, Icrov r<o avro
eTyai. -'Ecpayrj yap. Ovre apa eyos /xerpov p.re\ov ovre
TroXXwy ovre dXtycoy, ovre ro irapdiray rou avroi5 /xere)(oy,
ovre eauro) irore, &>s eotKey, eVrai To-oy ovre dXXa)- ovre av
/y.ei^by ov8e eXarrov otJre eaurov ovre erepov. nayraTrao-t
fxey ovy oiiJrco.
Ti 8e; Trpeo-jSvrepoy r) yewrepoy ^ rrjy avrrjy r/XiKiay
e^ety ro ly 8oKet ro> Svyaroy etyat; Ti 8r) yap ov; ?Ort
b 7 irfj ; B T : add. 8^ in marg. t
62 T(J>] T<J)

BT

d 3 ry] ain<p B : ry T

!4oe

UAATHNOS
TTOV JjXtKtay p.ey TT\V avrr/y fyov rj avr&> 17 aXXo> i(rorTjros

5 roi) eyt, ovre o/xotorrjros ovre i(rorrjros.'EXe'yop,ey yap

ovy.Kat p,T)y Kat on ayo/xotoreros re Kat dytcrorTjros ov
p;erexei> Kat rovro eXeyo/xey.Udyv jmey ovy.Tl&s oftv
141 otoy re eo-rat rtvos rj 7rpea-/3vrepoi; r) yewrepoy elyat T) rr^y
avrrjy ^XtKtay exetj; ro) TotoSroy oy;Ov8ap,s.OVK apa
ay etrj yewrepo'y ye ovSe 7rpeo-/3vrepoy ov8e rrjy avTrjv
5 'Ap' oSy ovot ey xpdvui TO napa-nav 8vyatro ay etyat ro e'y,
et rotoi)roy etrj; rj OVK avaynr), edy rt i] ey \p6vu>, det
avro avrov 7rpeo"j3vrepoy yiyv<rOai;^'AyayKTj.OvKOvy
ro ye 7rpeo-/3vrepoy del yecorepov irpeo-jSvrepoy;Tt p-^y;
b To irpeo-jSvrepoy apa eaurou yiyyojixeyoy Kat yewrepoy
eauroS ap,a ytyyerat, etirep fxeXXet ex^ty orov 7rpeo-/3vrepoy
ytyyrjrat.Iloiis Xeyet?;?H8e* 8ta<popoy erepoy erepov
ov8ey 8e? ytyyeo~0at ?j8rj oyros 8ia<popov, dXXa rov jixey
5 77817 oyroy 17817 etyat, rov e yeyoyoros yeyoyeyat, rov 8e
jueXXoyroy p,eXXety, rov 8e ytyyo/x^yov ovre yeyoyeyat oOre
p,eXXety ovre etyat TUO 8td^>opoy, dXXa ytyyeo-^at Kat aXXtos
c OVK e?yat.'AydyKij yap 877.'AXXa p.T)y ro ye Trpecr/Svrepoy
Sta^oporrjs yeoarepov eo-rty Kal ovSeyos aXXov.-"Ecrrt yap.
To apa -7rpeo-/3^repoy eavrov ytyyo/xeyoy avaynr) nal
yecorepoy a/xa eavrov ytyyeo-0ai.-"EotKey..'AXXa pvjy Kat
5 /XTjre irXetco eavrov yfyyetr^at \povov /A77re eXdrra), dXXa
roy ?o~oy \povov Kat ytyyeo-0ai eavrw Kat etyat Kal yeyoKat p.eXXety eo-eo-^at.'AydyKT7 yap ovy Kat raura.
apa eo-rty, w? eotKey, oo-a ye ey xpdvcp eo-rty
d Kat /xerex^i TOU rotovrov, eKacrroy avrwy rr^y avrriv re
e6 OI/KT^TIJTOST Proclus : jVorijTos B
as T<$>] Tq5 BT
a3 76
T : om. B
t) 3 /yi<yvi)Tai scrips!: yi-yj/eTeu B T
Sidcpopov
TW: Sia^fpov B Proclus
b 7 St^opovB: rbSta^opocT
CI 7&p
5^ Schanz : "yap &v B : ^(ip 'T
0 5 yiyvecrBai \pbvov B : -%p&vov
yiyveirdai T

atro avT<5 rjXiKiav X.iv /cat 7rpeo-/3uTepoV re a-uroCi ajua Kat

Vf&repov yiyvear6at. KtvSwevet. 'AAAa p-rfv T<O ye fvl T&V
TOIOVTMV ira0r]fj.aT(i)v ov5ez> /jier^y. Ov yap jxeTT/y. OuSe
apa xP^0^ avT& fj.T<TTiv, ov5' ecrriy lu run xpoVa>.' 5
OVKOVV brj, &s ye 6 Aoyos atpeu
Ti ovy; TO r\v Kal TO yeyove Kal TO eytyyeTo ov \povov
fj.eOff;iv 8o/cei a-r\\iaiv^iv TOV TTOTC yeyo^oTos; Kal /xaA.a.
Tt 8e; TO ecrrai Kal TO yei^crerai KOI TO -/fvr]6r)arfTai
ov e
TOU CTreiTa [TO( /j,eXAoyTos]; Nai. To Be Sr) Zan Kat
TO ytyveTai ov TOU vvv irapovros; Ildm> /xei^ ovv. Et
apa TO li; /xrjSajurj ^rjbevos /xeTe')(et xpo^01*' ^Te 7rorf
ylyovzv OVT' fyiyvero OVT' ^y -TroTe, ouTe ySv ykyovev ovTe 5
ytyverai oi;Te lo-rty, ovr' ^Tretra yein^o-eTai o^Te yevrj^(reTat ovTe ecrTai.'' AXr^OearaTa. -vEo-Tii> ovy ovo-ias OTTCOS
av Tt fAeTatr^ot aAAws ^ *caTa TOVTMV Tt; OVK eo-Ttr.
OvSajuoos apa ro ey owtas jbteTe^et. OIIK eoiKer. Ov8afAQ)s
apa lo-T6 TO eV.<Ov ^atyeTat. Ov8' apa OVTCOS IITTW; 10
(wore tv flvai' eti; yap az> ^677 ov Kat ovo-ias jxeTexozr
dA.A' <as eotKey, TO ti> o^Te eV eo*Tti; O-VTC ICTTI^, et Set TO>
TotS8e Aoy<j> irto-Te7;ety. KtySwevet *O 5e /mrj IOTI, 142
TW fi^ O^TI etrj av Tt avT&i ^ avToC; ^Kat irciis;
' cLpa ovofj.a eo~Tty avTw oi8e Aoyo? ov8e TIS eTriov8e ato-^crt? ovde 8o^a. Ov ^aivtrai. Ot8' oyoapa ov8e Xeyerai o{i8e 8oaeTat oi8e ytyycoo-KCTat, 5
ou8e Tt T&V ovT(av OVTOV alcrdavfrai,. OVK eotKey. ?H
bvvarov ovv irept TO %v ravra ovras e^ety; OVKOVV Ifxotye

ovv eTrt TTJI> VTro^eo-tz; 7rdA.tv e^ apx^s eTraueA- b

fdv TI ^juTy eiraytoSo-ty dAAotov <^avrj;: I
d.6 aff)6? B T : 6pe?apogr. Stud.
ei yevfiO-fifferat]
yeyevrtarerai
Schleiermacher, at vide Proclum
6 2 rov /teAAoj/ros seclusi : TOV
seel. Heindorf : irov G. Hermann
e n tv] ev bv legendum susp.
Heindorf
jnere'xov] [terexoi legendum susp. Heindorf
a 2 avT<p
B T : ^ aiiT^i vulg.
b 2 </>ai/fj T : fave/Tj B

EIAATHNOS

ovv /3ovA.o|iai.Ovjcovy y ei IcrTty, </>a/xey, ra <rvjut/3avovra Trepl avrov, iroid -Trore Tvyyjivzi oVra, Stoju.oA.oyrjTea
Tavra.' ov\ ovVa>;Nat.f/Opa 8?) e dpx^s. ey ei
apa oto'y Te avTo etyat nxe'y, ovarias 8e /XT) ^ri\fiv
otoy Te.QVKOVV Kal 17 OVCTLO, TOV eyos fir] ay ov TO.VTOV
ov(ra rai kvi' oi) yap &v fKcCvq ^v eneivov oixria, ovb' ay
e/ceiyo, TO eV, eKetVT]? jmeret)(ey, dXX' o/xotoy &y ^y Xeyeiy ey
re etyat Kat ly ^y. yuy 8e ov)( avrrj lorty ^ vTro'fleo-tj,
e t l y ey, ri xprj (ru//j8aivety, dAX' et |y e < r r i y ov^
o^ra>;'ITayu //,> ovy.OVKOUZ; cos &AA.O rt (rTjjmaZyoy TO
?<TTI TOU e'y;'AydyKTj.?Apa ouy aAAo ^ OTI ovcrtas
ro ey, TOT' ay eirj TO Aeyo/Aez/oy, e-TretSay TIS
CITTTJ OTI |y eartj;;.ritiyu ye.FIoAty 5^ Xeycoet eo-Tty, rt (ru/x^oreTat. (TKOTret o2y et OVK avayKt]
rrjy vTr66f(riv TOLOVTOV ov TO ly o-Tj/xatvety, otoy
^ety;TTSs;?H8e* et ro l(TTt row euos SVTOS
Aeyerat Kat TO ly TOU WTOS evos, eo-Tt 8e ov TO avTo ij Te
owta Kat TO ey, rou avTou 8e eKetyou ov v^fOe^Oa, TOV
evbs OVTOS, apa OVK ayay/aj TO ju,ey oAoy ly 6V etyat
TOVTOU 8e ytyyeo-^at jjiopia TO Te ey Kal TO etyat;'
-TloTepoy oSy e/caTepoy Twy ju,opta>y To^Tcoy /xoptoy juoVoy
TrpOCT-epoC/xey, r) TOU oXov /xdptoy TO ye fj.6piov
irpoo-pr]Teoy;^Tou oA.ov.Kat oA.oy apa etrTt, o ay ey ^, Kat
p,optoy e^et.-Ildyv ye.Tt ovy; Twy fxoptcoy
TouTcoy TOU eyos OVTOS, TO Te ly xat TO oy, apa
r) TO ey TO etyat fxoptou ^ TO oy TOV eyos jutopiov;OVK
ay etrj.-ITdA-ty apa Kal To>y juoptcoy eKaTepoy TO Te ly
b 4 ouToO B T : avrt Stephanus
b 8 -y^p &v T : yetp B
03 ev
?j/, T(] li' fvn B : Iv rt T
c6 TIS T: TI B
C8 e B: om. T
da \fyerai Kal T : \eyerai Kal rb Iv roO Svros \eyerai Kal B
oir B :
om. T
d 4 aiiro B T: aiirov vulg.
d 8 &i/ B : &i/ T
!/ ^ T :
eVfi pr. B
d 9 /x^pjoc] /*<fy>ia Heindorf
e 2 e?j/a] OVTOS elvcu
Bekker
ftopiov pr. T : pApiov B t Simplicius : seel. Schleiermacher
Mopiou B T Simplicius: n6piov vulg.: seel. Schleiermacher

HAPMENIAHS

1436

al TO oy, Kal ytyyeTai TO t\a\urTov IK bvolv aZ

TO jmopioy, not Kara rov avrbv Xoyov OVTWS dei, 5
onTrep ay fjiopiov yeyTiTai, TOVTOO TO> /xopuo del former TO
re yap ty ro oy del forget Kal TO 01; TO ef wore dydyKTj
81? del yiyyojueyov ju.rjSeVoTe ey eiyai. nazrra7ra<ri jxey 143
ovy. OVKOW aTretpoy ar TO 77X77^0? OVTCO TO lz> oi> etrj;
y

Wt 8rj Kal Tr)8e ITI riTj; OixrCas (pafjikv jaeTexety TO

, 8 to <-CTTIV; Nat. Kal 8ta TaCra 8rj TO ev 5y iroAAa
j. OvT(t>. Ti 8c; avTo TO tv, o brj ^>a^ev oixrias
lay avro TTJ 8tayoia povov KaO* ai>To
TOVTOU ov <a|u,ez> /uerej(fi^j apa ye ^y JJLOVOV
o"erai 77 Kal TroAAa TO avro ro)ro; -"Ev, ot)u.at eycoye.
"IScoftez^ 877* aAAo ri erepoy /xey dydyKij TT^Z; ov<riav avTov
etrai, erepor 8e avro, enrep ^ ova-La TO eV, aAA.' &>s ey
oixrCas i*.T<r\ev, 'AvdyKij. OVKOVV ei e'repoy /xei' 77 ovaia,
Hrepov be TO tv, OVTC TW Iv TO ey TTJS ovcrias eVepoz>
ovTe ro> ovo-ia flvai r) ovo-ia TOV evo? aAXo, dAAa TW erepw
re Kal aAAw eTepa dAATjAcov Ildi'Tj jaev ovy. -"ilo-Te
ov Tavrov IffTtz; OVTC TW 1^1 ovTe Tr) ovo-ia TO Tpov.
ITws yap;
Ti ovy; lay 7rpoeA<6//.e0a avrwy eire jSoiJAet TTJZ; oixriav
Kal TO eYepoy etTe r^i; ovcriav Kal TO ev e^Te TO ey Kal TO
erepoy, ap' OVK ez> eKaarT) TT) Trpoaipecret Trpoatpovfxe^a Tire
A op0<5s e^ei KaAeto-0at djix^oTe'pa); Ilws; -TH8e- eoriy
ovo-iav eiireiy; -"Eo-rir. Kal aSflis etTret^y eV; Kal
TO)TO. -'Ap' ovy oix eKarepoy avrolv etp^Tai; Nai. Ti
8' oraz> eiirco ovo-ia Te Kal eV, apa OVK dju^oTe'pw; Ddrv
ye. OvKoSr Kal lay ovcrta Te Kal erepoy T) erepoy Te Kal
ey, Kal OVTCO TrayTa^ws 1^)' eKcto-Toi> a/i^co Aeyco; Nai.
. e 6 Tovry -rif fj.opicf> B pr. T
as toiKtv B : eoiKe' ye T
a 6 ri
8 B : TI S^ T
b i ?5o>|iiev] etSw/iev B T
b 2 ovaia B : owerios T
Iv oufftas B T : |j/bs ou<n'a vulg.
c 3 rive &> T : rt vey B
04 o^tQoTfpta T : a.fj.(f)6rfpa B
09 eKciffrou B : eKcurTov T

143 d

nAATHNOS

d *il 8' ay a/xcpco opflcos TrpocrayopetJ^crfloy, Spa olov re afjt</>a>

/j,ey avrco tlvai, bvo 8e JA?]; Ov\ otoy re. *H 8' ay 8&>
Tyroy, ecrrt rts /ATjxayr) /XT) ov)( eKarepoy avroty ty eTyat;
Oi8e|uia. Tovrcoy apa eTreiTrep cruySvo eKaora <ri>/u,/3aiyei
5 etyat, Kal ez> ay eirj efcaoroy. 4>aiyerat. Et 8e ey eKaorou
awcoy eon, (r^yre^eyro? lyos OTTOIOUOW ^nytow <rvvyia.
ov rpia yiyyerai ra -navra; >Nai. Tpa 8e ou TreptTTa
Kal 8vo apria; Hwy 8' ov; ^Ti 8e; bvolv OVTOLV OVK
e dydyKi) eTyat Kat 8is, Kat rptwy oyra>y rpts, etirep
rw re bvo TO bis ev K.CU r5 rpia TO rpts $v; '
Avolv 8e OVTOLV nal bis OVK ayayKTj bvo bis fivai; Kal
TpiStv Kal Tpls OVK dyeiyKi] av rpta rpts etyat;IIGs 8'
5 ou; Ti 8e; rptwr OVTMV Kal bis oyrcoy Kat 8rory OVTOLV
Kal Tpls OVTOLV OVK dyay/o] re rpta ots etyat Kal 8vo
Tpis; HoAArj ye. -v Apria re apa dprtaKts ay etr; Kal
144 ireptrra TrepirraKis cat aprta TreptrraKt? Kal Treptrra dprtdKts. -"Effriy OVTCO. Et ovv ravra otircos exet ^ct Tlz;^
apLOnbv v7roAetire(T0ai oy OVK dyayKTj eTyat; OvSapxos
ye.^Et apa etrrty ey, dyayKTj Kat apifyxoy etyat. ^*Ay5 ayKT]. 'AXAa /x^y apiQ^ov ye oyro? TroXAa ay etr; Kal
TiXfjOos a,TTLpov T&v ovTu>v rj OVK aiTfLpos dpt^p,os 7rA?j0et
Kal /xere^coy ova-Las ytyyerat; Kal irayu ye. OvKovy et
iras dpt^/jtos ovtrtas /uerexet, Kal ro //.optoy eKacrroy roii
dpiflpxw /xere'^ot ay a^r?]s; Nat.
b
'E-rrl irdyra apa iroAAa oyra 77 owta yeye/xrjrat Kal
ov8eyos aTroo-raret rwy oyrcoy, ovre row cr^iKpordrou ovre
roC p;eyt<rrov; ?; rouro /xey Kal aAoyoy epeV^at; TTWS yap ay
8rj ovo-Ca ye rcoy oyrcoy row cbrocrrarcH; Ov8ap;cos. Kara5 KeKep/xdrtarat apa cos oloy re o-fiiKpo'rara Kal /xey terra Kal
Suo Stephanus : o3i/ 5uo B : erfo' Suo T
e 2 re . . . e 4 oS om. pr. T
e 6 re rpia B : rpia re T
Jivo rpts in marg. b et legit Procl. suppl. :
rpia Sis B : Sis rpia T
a 6fareiposB : ireipov T
a 7 oucrios T :
oucrfa B
' 1) 4 5); B T : ^ Stobaeus
TDK T : roO B
airoStobaeus : airotrraTeT B : airoffToret T

nAPMENIAHS

144 b

ovra, KOI /xe/xejOiorai TTCLVTMV ju,dAtora, KOL ecrri

cnrepavra rfjs overlay. "E^ei OOTCO.' IIAeroTa apa eort C
ra p-epr? a-uT??s. nXeiora jueVTot. Ti ovv; eo-Tt rt avr&v b
e<rrt p,V juepos TTJS ov<rtas, ov8ez> JJI&VTOI //.epos; Kat TTWS
&v [rot] rouro yeroiTo; 'AAA.' eiTrep ye ot/xat etrrtz;, avayKi]
avro ati, ea)(T7re/) &i^ ^, ey ye Tt ewat, fjirjbfv 8e dSwaroy. 5
'Ai>ayKij. IIpos airavrt apa [e/cdVro)] rw T^y o^crtas /xepet
ro ey, OVK aTroAeiTronxefoz; ovre (rp,iKpoTpov ovre
epODS oiire aXAou ovSei'os.^ Oura). -'Apa o%v fv
ov 7roAAa)(oO ajua oAoy ecrri; rouro a#pet. 'AAA' d^pw d
not opa) on dSvyaroy. Me/mepioT/.ei'oy ^pa, etirep fi
aAAcos ycip TTOU ovbajj.&s ap.a aTrcuri rots r^s oiicrias
Trapecrrat ^ jue/xepto-/x,eVoi;.' Nai. Kat j/Tjy TO ye /jieprrov
iroAArj avayK.r\ etz/at roo-awra oo-airep p-epi].''ArayKr;.^ Oi//c 5
apa dArj^r) aprt eAeyo/xei' Aeyoyres &>s TrAetora /AepTj ?/ ovcria
revest] ju,ez/rj e^rj.
o-ySe yap ^Xeta) rou eroy i>eye)x?]Tai, dAA'
t(ra, ws eoiKe, r<S ert' ovre yap TO oV TOU ei'os aTroAeiTreTat e
TO ly TOU OVTOS, dAA' t^uTova-Qov 8^0 o^Te det Trapa
. Ilai'TaTrao'ti' oi'rco (paivtrat. To ei> apa avro
KKpfJ.aTlcrjJiVOV

VTTO

TTJS

OlKTtaS

TToAAd T KOt

CLTTfLpa

TO

TT\.rj66s <TTIV. 4>atyeTat. Ov p,6vov apa TO ov ev TroAAa 5

eo-Tty, dAAa Kat avTo TO ez; ^TTO TOU OTTOS ^>Lav^v^r]^vov
TToAAa avd"/Kij etuat. navTaTrao-t juey ovv.
Kat /u.T)y OTt -ye oAou Ta /xopta juo'pta, n^'n^pacr^vov ay
117 /caTa TO oAoy TO eV- ^ ov ^eptexeTat VTTO Toi; oAou Ta
ju-opta; 'AydyKTj. 'AAAa p-^y TO ye Treptexoy ?repas ay eaj. 145
II<3s 8' oi!;-To ey apa oy |y TC eo-Ti TTOV Kat TroAAd, Kat
oAov Kat /xopta, Kat Tre/7repao7xeVoi> Kat aTretpof TrATy^et.
4>atyeTat. ?Ap' ovy OVK, eTreiVep ireTrepao-juei'oi', Kai
C 4 rot ToCra B T : T}> TOtoCro ci. Hermann
eftrep B : eireiirep T
C 5 eooffirep B : Sxrirep T
c 6 eKoffTtp vel delendum vel eitdffTore
scribendum Susp. Stallbaum
d 3 TTOU T : irais B
a^uo wairj

malit Heindorf
S/ Stallbaum

65 6^ 1^ B Prod, suppl. : Iv T : / W Thomson :

a 2 $/ seel. Heindorf

IIAATGNOS

5 e*xpy;'AydyKrj.Tt be; ei oAoy, ov KOI apxyv ay e\oi Kal

\t<jov <al TeAevrrjz;; rj otov re rt oAoy etyat ciyeu rpi&v
TOvYcoy; KCLV TOV ey oTLOvv avrStv aTTOOTaTTj, e0eArjo-et en
oAoy etvat;OVK efleArjo-et.Kai ap^rfv 8rj, &s eotKey, Kat
b TeAevrrjy Kal p,e'o-oy exoi ay TO e'y.yE)(oi'AAAd [i^v TO
ye fjLcrov Ivov rStv eo-)(aT(OP direxft" ov yap bv aXXcos
etr;.'Ou yap.Kat (r^/xaTOS 817 TIVOS, a>5 eotKe,
ov fj,TXpi &v TO Zv, Tf\TQi evOfos rj (TTpoyyvXov r\ Tiros
5 /ixeiKTOv f apfyotv.MeTe^ot yap &v.
*Ap' ovv OVTCOS l)(oy OVK auro re kv eavrSt lo-rat Kal kv
S\Xa>;IIws;T&v [ifp&v TIOV tKacrrov kv T& oXw ecrTl Kat
ovbev IKTOS TOU oXou.OVTO).Yldvra 8e TO. /xeprj V-TTO TOU
C o\ou -rcpiexeTai;Nat.Kal JU,T)Z> TO. ye ir^yTa fxepr; Ta
avrou TO i-v eo-Tt, Kat ovre TI TrXeoy OVTC eAarroy TJ iravra.
-Ov ycip.QVKOVV Kat TO oXov TO |y ecrTti;;Hois 5' ov;
Et apa iravra TO, /xep?) ev oAw Tvyxa^fi wTa, e<rTt 8e T< Te
5 Tra^Ta TO %v Kat avro TO oA.oz>, 7repte)(eTat 8e VTTO Toi; oXov
Ta ira^Ta, VTTO rou ez^os ay Treptex.017"0 T ^> Ka^ OVTO>S ay
7787; TO ly avTo ey eauToi etrj.4>atz>eTai.'AXXa /^eyTOt TO
ye oA.oy av OVK ey TO?S jaepeo-ty eo-Tty, OVTC ey Tracrty ovTe
d ey Tizn.
et yap ey itacnv, dyayKrj Kal ey eyt- ey Ttyt yap
eyt fj.ri 5y OVK ay ITI TTOV bvvatro ey ye aTtacnv etyat- et 8e
TOVTO jixey TO %v T&V cnravrutv ecrTt, TO 8e oAoy kv TOVT&)
fXT) eyt, TI&S eTi ey ye TOIS mta-iy eyeo-Tat;OvSajuifis.
5 Ovoe /^.Tjy ey Tto~l TaJy fjLfp&v
et yap ey Tto-l TO oAoy etrj,
TO TrXeoy ay ey TW eXaTToyt etrj, o eo-Tty dSvyaToy.'A8vyaToy yap.Mr) oy 8' ey TrXeoo-ty jarjd' ey eyt jmr]8' ey a7rao-i
Tots /Aepea-t TO oAoy OVK dyayKrj ey eTepw Ttrl etyat T/ fxrjSa/xov
6 en etyai,1.'AydyKrj.OvKoSy /Arj8ap,oi) p,ey ^y ovSey ay fir],
oAoy 8e oy, e7ret8r) OVK ey avrw eo-Tty, dyayKrj ey aAAa>
a 5 8e; et] Sai in ras. B: 5' ei T
ou Kal T : OUK B
a 7 TOV
Schleiermacher : TOW B T
b i ex0' &" .. . Xot ^ : ^Xot &" X6' T
C 2 Tt T : TO B
d i Tivi] riffi Schleiermacher
d 4 evi corr.
Yen. 189 : evl B : ej/l T
ei/eVrat Par. 1836 : $y &rrat BT

IIAPMENIAHS

1456

ivai; Tlavv ye. ?Hi fjv apa TO ty oAoy, ey

if 8e TO, Travra /xeprj ovra rvyx&vei, avrb ey eauror Kai
OVTCO TO ey dyciyKij avro re ey eaurw etyat /cat ey erepo).
'AydyKT],
Oirrco 8r) ire<vKos TO ey ap' OVK avayKj] Kai
Kai eo-Tavai; ITf); ^'EcrTTjKe fiey TTOV, eforep OVTO
ez> yap evi oy Kal e<c TOVTOV p.r) peTafiaivov ev TO> 1
y 117, kv eauTto. -VE(TTI ytip. To 8e ye ev TW avroi
ciei Sz; ecrToy STJTTOV ardyKTj del elyat. Haw ye. Tt 8e; TO
V eTep(o del oy ov TO zvavTiov avayKrj pTjSeTTOT5 ev TairrQ
etrai, ju,rj8e'7roTe 8e 6V e^ TW avTw p.Tj8e eoraWi, ju,^ IO-TOS 5
5e Kiv^iaQai; OVTCOS. 'Aray/crj apa TO ly, avTO Te eV
w det oy Kat eV eTepw, det KivzlffOai Te /cat e0rdi>ai.
Kat

p-rjy TavToy ye 8et etyat ai>To eauTfi Kat

, Kai TOIS aAAots wo-avTcos TavTw Te Kat eVepoz; elvat,
enrep Kat Ta Trpoa-Qev TreirovOev. Ilfis; Hav TTOV irpos
aTray w8e ^xet> ^ TCLVTOV fariv ^ eVepoy ?) eau /AT) TaiiToy
^ ^178' eVepozJ, fxepos &y etTj TOIVTOU Trpo? o O^TCOS e)(et, r) ws
irpos p:epos oAoy ay etrj.'4>atveTat. -'Ap' ovv TO %v avro
avroti fxepos karlv; Ovda/xws. Oi;o' ^pa <ws 'Trpos piepos
avTo a'WTou oXoy av eaj, Trpos eavTo fxepos oiy. Ov yap otoy
Te. 'AAA.' apa eVepoy eo-Tty tvbs TO eV; Ov B?jTa. Ov8'
apa eairroC ye eTepov ay et?]. Ou IA^VTOL. Et ovv /m?]Te
[jitfTe o\ov IJL^T fxepos avTO Trpos eauTO eonr, OVK
77877 TO.VTOV etyat avTO eauTw; ^*Az;ayKT7. Tt 8e; TO
, 6V avTo eavToS ey T OVTW OVTOS eaurfi OVK dydyK?]
avro eavTOTj eTepoy eTyat, etTrep Kai eTe'pco^t eTTat; -"Efiotye
8oKet. OVTCO ju,T)y ecpctrTj e^oy TO ey, aiTO Te ev eauTW oy
ap,a Kai ey eTepw. 'E<|)dy77 yap. -"ETepoy apa, a>s eotKey,
etrj TaiJTrj ay eavTov TO ey. "EotKey. Tt ovy; et TOV TI
eTepoy e(TTiy, ov^ eTepou WTOS eVepoy IcrTat; 'AyayKTj.
as eorbs BT : Iffris vulg.
b4 ^ T : om. B
B : OIIK T
d. I ef Tot5 rt G : et rovrl B T

C i ou5'

IIAATilNOS
QVKOVV o<ra JIATJ <lv eo-ny, anavd' eYepa TOU tvos, Kal TO ty
T<Sy /A?/ ey; IISs 8* ou; "Erepoy apa ay ej TO ey rGtv
5 aAAcoy. "ETepoy. ?Opa 617' avro re TO.VTOV KOI TO eYepoy
ap' OUK eyayTia dAA^Aois; Hois 6' ou; ?H our e$eA?jo-ei
TCLVTOV ey TO) erepo) 77 ro eYepoy ey ravrw Trore etrat; OVK
t. Et cipa ro erepov ev rai avrco p,r/8e7rore lorai,
lort r&)i> ovrcav ev ai IOTIV TO eVepoy yjpovov
ei yap o^TiyoCz; eirj |y T<O, CKflvov av TOV -)(p6vov kv
tit] TO eVepoy. ov)( OVTCOS; Ovrcos. 'ETretSrj '
ey TW avTa) e<TTiy, ov8e7TOTe ey Ttyt T<Sy OVTGOV &y eirj TO
. 'AXrj^r;. OWT' apa ei> TO?S ju,^ ly o#re tv TW eyi
&v TO eVepoy -- Ov yap ovz;.^OVK apa TW eTepw y' ay
e^rj TO ly Twy fx^ ez> ov8e Ta /ix,rj ey TOV 1^6? eTepa. Ov yap.
Ovoe p.riv eavTor? ye eVep' ay etr; dXX?]A.coy, fj.r)
147 TOU eTepou. Hois yap; Ei be ^-qTe CLVTO'IS eTepci. e(TTi
T^ eTepw, ov TravTri qbt] av K<j)vyoL TO f/,^ eVepa
dXA?]Xa)y; ^'EK^evyot. 'AAAa /x^y ovoe TOU cvos ye
Ta ju,^ eV ou yap ay fx,^ ly ^y, dXXa TTT/ ay ly ^r. '
5 O{i8' ay apt-OfJibs fir] apa TO. p,rj ey ovoe yap ay OVTCO p-r) |y
r\v iravTCLTracrLV, apidfjiov ye e^oyTa. Ov yap oSr.'Tt 8e;
Ta p,^ |y TOU eyos apa /u,opia eo"Tty; 77 Kay O{/TCO /^eTe^xe TOU
evos Ta jurj e'y; MeTe^ey. Ei ^pa TrayTTj TO p,ey e'y eo-Tt,
b Ta 8e p,^ ey, OUT' av popiov T&V jar) Iz; TO ey eirj ouTe oAoy
a>s jutopiaiy ouTe au TO, p,r) |y TOU eyos /xopia, ouTe o\a a>?
iw TW eyt. Ov yap.'AAAa ju^y e^a/xey Ta ju?]Te p.opia
oAa p;?7Te eVepa dAA^Acoy TauTa eVeo-flai dAA^Aots.
v
5 E^a/xey yap. 4>copiey apa Kat TO ty irpos Ta /x^ ey OTJTMS
\ov TO avTo etyat ai/ToTs; ^wp^ey. To |y apa, ws eotKey,
eYepoy Te Twy aAAcoy eo~Tty Kat eauTOu Kat TO.VTOV e/cetyots Te
Kal eavTW. Kty8uyevet (/>atyecr0ai eK ye Toi) Aoyou.
d 7 rb B : om. T
65 ^ehj] ^ eYij B : eft? T
as ^Srj &i/
eitcjievyoi B : &i/ 5/Sr/ tif>-6yoi T
a 4 ^c o\A.a B : ^ a\\d. T
8. 8 Travrri B : iraj/rl T
bs fj.opi<av corr. Ven. 189 : /j.opiov BT:
fj.6pi.ov vulg.
/xo'pia T : /mopiov B
b 5 ret T : rb B

IIAPMENIAHS

147 C

*Ap* ofiv Kal o/xotoy re /cat dyo'p-oioy eaivra) re nal rols c

aAAots; vl<rcos. 'E7reto"T) yovv eVepoi> T&V aAAcoy ecpdVrj,
Kat raAAa TTOV eYepa ay CKCIVOV eft]. Tt ju,?^; OVKOVV
ovTOts erepoi; rS>v aAAcoi>, axnrfp Kat TaAAa eKetyou, Kat cure
jiaAAoy oi/Te rjrrov; Tt yap ay; Et apa pt?jre jaa.AA.ov 5
/MjTe r\rrov, ojutouos. Nat. OVKOVV f/ Zrepov elvat, ireTrovOev
T&V ^AAa)i> Kal raAAa eKeiyov c*)<ravTU>s, ravrrj ratiroy ay
wirovOoTa tlev TO TC ly TO?? aAAois Kai raAAa rw |yt.
Hois Aeyets; -?il8e- eKacrroy rwz^ dw/^.arcoi' ow eirt rizn d
; -"Eycoye. Tt ovv; TO awo oyojua etTrots a^
?) a-Tra^; -"Eycoye. Ilorepoy ow eay fAey a?ra^
OVK Kivo; ^ eayre a7ra eayre TroAAaKis TQLVTOV ovo/j-a
(j)0yr), TroAArj dydyKrj (re raiirov Kat Aeyeiy det; Tt fi^y;
OVKOUV Kal TO erepov orojud eo-rty eirt rtyt; Haw ye.
"Orav apa avro <f)6tyyri, eavrf airat; cavrf TroAAaKis, OVK
CTT' aAAa) ov8e aAAo Tt dyo/xa^iets' ^ eKeiyo ovTtfp r\v oro/ua.
'AyayKrj. -"Orav 8r) Aeycop-ey on erepoy p,ey raAAa TOU Iros,
fTfpov 8e TO ey T<Sz> aAAcoz;, 8ts TO eTepov etTroyres ovSey Tt
/j,aAAoy eir' aAArj, dAA' CTT' fKfivy rrj (frvcrci, avro det Aeyo/xey
ijOTrep ^y rovvo^a. ITayi) jmey ovy. ?Ht apa erepoy rail'
aAAwy TO ey Kat T&AAa TOV eyd?, KaT5 aiiro TO eVepoy TreTroy0eyai OVK aAAo aAAa ro avro av TTfirovBos etrj ro ey rots
aAAots* TO 8e TTOU TO.VTOV TreTroy^os ojaotoy o-u)(i> Nat.
?
Hi 8r) TO ty erepoy Tfiy aAAwy 7rem>y0ey etyat, KUT' OVTO
TO{)TO airay aTracrty o/xotoy ay etrj- a-Tray yap cnrdvTwv eVepoV
<TTi.v.--"EotKey. 'AAAa /ATJZ; TO' ye opotoy rw dyop-otw
fvavrCov. ^Nat. OIIKOW Kat ro trepov TW TatiTw. Kat
. 'AAAa p.rjv Kat TOVTO' y' efpavrj, ws apa TO ey rots
05 &v B : om. T
62 ?/?i/o B : Ktivo T
e6^]^B:^T:el
vulg.
a i JC<ZT' airJi rb Thomson : Kara Taurb BT : /caro T& raurb
Heindorf: /caret Taurbi/ ri> Stallbaum : /caret T' aS TO Waddell
ireTroz/Qevai B T : irfirovBev flvui in marg. rec. t
a 2 / B T : ev vulg.
a 6 a\\k /JL)JV B : aXA.' 3\v T
ry dro/xoi'^ TIJJ o/uoiqj B : TWV avofnoiwv T
a 7 Tafiri? in marg. T : airy B T

5
148

IIAATJiNOS

b a\\ois Tavrov.'E<pdvr) yapTavvavrlov be ye irdOos earl

TO elvai TO.VTOV TOIS #AAois T<3 frepov elvai T&V a\\<av
Haw ye ? Ht ye JU.T)I> eYpoi>, opoiov ftpdvrj
Nat. Hi
apa Tavrov, OVOJMIOV forai KOTO TovvavTiov -ndOos T<?
5 opoiovvrt Trd6ei. <af*otoi> be Ttov TO tTfpov;Nat..'Avofxot(d<ret apa TO TOVTOV, rj oiiK evavTiov lorat T& erepu
c "EoiKfv."Opotov apa Kal az>o/iouw ^crrat TO ev TOLS &\\ois,
17 iJ.ev erepov, opoiov, if be ravroV, avopoiov.-'Exet yap ovv
STJ, u>s eoiKev, Kal TOIOVTOV Kayov.Kal yap Tovbf exfi-'
Tlva;'Hi TOVTOV ireirovOe, pr) a\Xoiov -neitovOfvai, w
5 dAAoww be TtenovObs p-ft avopoiov, firj avopoiov 8e SfMiov
elvai' 8' aXXo -neitovQev, a^Xoiov, dXXotoi' be ov avdpoiov
(Ivai.'AA.7)07j Xeyets..Taiirov re apa 6V TO Ir TOIS
Kal on frepov e<m, KOT' anQdrepa KO! Kara tuarfpov,
d Te av eft; KO! avopoiov TOIS a\Xois.Haw ye.OVKOVV
Kal eavrw axravra)?, eireftrep erep6v Te eawoC Kal Tavrov
eavT^i f<t>dvr), Kar' afj.<j>OTfpa Kal Kara (Rarepov Sfioiov Te
Kal av6jj.oi.ov ^avrjcrerai;'AvayKi).
S
Ti 8e 8ij; irepl TOV fiirreo-flat TO fv avrov Kal TU>V SAAaw
Kal TOV ^ij) Sirreo-flat ire"pi wws lxet> o"Koirei.SKoiroS.Airo
yap TTOV ev 4aw5 oktp TO ev e<pavi] 8v 'OpflcSs OVKOVV
Kal tv TOIS iXAois TO tv;Na..*Hi i^ev apa ev rots
e T&V &\\tov awroiTO av ft be avro ev eavrut, T&V pev
iateipyoiTo Hinea-dai, airrb be avrov awroiTO av ev lai/rip
ov.<I>afoeTai.OCrw p'ev 8^ oVi-owo av TO ev avrov Te
Kal T&V a\\atv.-"ATTTOITO.TC be Tfjbf; ap' ov nav TO
S pe\\ov atyevQai TWOS e<perjs 8ei (ceiotfai exetvif ov fx^AAei
airrecrdai, Tavrrjv rt]v ebpav KaTexov fj av fteT* eKflvyv jj
[?8pa] fj av KeijTai, ameTai;'AvdyKrjKal TO ev apa
el fte'AAet airo avrov atyeo-flai, e(perjs Set evOvs fxera eavrb
bs anolov B : tfiotov T

b6 T& taHntvl: ralirtr B

ds KO!

KoriT: KOI B
e6 KOT^XOK T: om. B : add. in marg. b
6 7 itpa
om. Bekker: ?8pai/ Heindorf
^ B : ^ T : fort. V
ftrrrrai]
ol
i Heindorf

IIAPMENIAHS

1486

Kfl(rdai, rrjy f\ofJivrjv ^(apav KCLT\OV fKivi]S tv jf airo

fortv.Aei yap ovv.OVKOVV bvo /Aez> ov TO tz> TrotT/o-etey 10
av ravra xat ev bvolv y&paiv aju,a yeVotro' ecos 8' av 77 eV, 149
OVK e0eA?]o-ei;Ov yap ovv.'H avrrj apa avayKrj r<S kv\
8vo etzmt /txijre a7rreo-0at avr& avTov.'*H avrri.'AAX'
/XTJV TWJ; aXXcoy a^erai.Tt 8?];-"On, ^ajuey, ro
<rOai \<apl$ ov f(f>^ijs 8e? e/ceivw etvat ov /xeAAet 5
i, rpirov 5e avrwy er f/,e<r<j) /u,7j8ey eT^at.'AArj^.
Avo apa 8ei ro oAtytarov eZfai, ei /^eAXet ai/rts etrai.'^Acu
'Ear 8e roty Suoiy opoiy rpirov TrpocryevriTai fr)s, avra
p.fv Tpia ecrrai, at 5e ci^eis bvo.Nat.Kat OVTO> 8?) b
del ei>os Trpocryiyvo^vov fxta /cat a\//ts irpo(rytyz>erai, Kat
(n;/ui/3atfet ras ai^ets rou 7rA77^ot;? rwy apiB^Gtv fxta eAarrous'
cti'ai. w -yap ra Trpwra 8vo e7rAeoye/crTj(rey TWZ; ax/^ecoz; et?
TO irAeico eTrat TOZ/ apiOp-ov rj ras a\^ets, r^ tcrw rovrw Kat 5
6 tTretra apiOpos iras irao~G>v T>V ax^ecoj; TrAeoveKret1 ^77
yap ro AOITTOV a//,a e'y re rw apt0p,(5 Trpoo-ytyyerat Kat /jita c
&/as rats a^rfcriv.'Op^ciis."Ocra apa ftrrlv ra oz>ra roi'
apiOfJiov, det p;ta at aijfeis eAarrou? eto-ii' avrcSi;.'A\r]6rj.
Et 8e ye %v fj,6vov e<rrtv, bvas 8e JUT) lorty, a\/Ats OVK ay
etTj.Ows yap;OUKOW, (pa^fv, ra aAAa roi; w ovre 5
ey etrrty ovre fxere^et avrov, etirep aAAa eariy.'Ov yap.
OVK apa evecTTLv dpt^ju,os ey rots aAAots, eros /jir) eyovros tv
avTolsriws yap;Ovr' apa e'y eort ra aAAa oi/re 8vo cure
aAAou apiO^ov fyovra ovofj.a oiibev.Ov.To f v apa fj.6vov d
etrriz; ei>, /cat bvas OVK av fLt],Ov ^atyerat."A^is apa
OVK farnv bvolv JU.T) OVTOIV.OVK eo-rty.Our' apa ro Iv r<av
aAAcoy airrerat ovre ra aAAa rov tvos, CTretTrep a\^ts OVK
eg wT : om. B
e 10 ycbpoSvT : -ycbp B
Trot^jirejej'T : iroi^ffei
ev B
a 5 ctyeffflai B : o^afffloi T
a 6 S^efffloi B : &irreo-6ai T
a 7 oXiyiffrov T : o/Uyoorbi' B
a 8 gpoii' B T Procl. suppl.: OVTOIV
(om. ToTv) Heindorf: del. Bekker: 6fi6potv Turicenses 4|i)s T: e' ^s B
bs Tail/ api0/mwv B T : rbc upiOp.'bv Heindorf
1)4 ItyeuvT : &\\uv B
C i e/ B : ev T
07 svecrriv b : eV 'O'T' T pr. B
fv&vros b :
ev ovros pr. B : ^I/TOS T
d 2 eV seel. Schleiermacher
PLATO, VOL. n.
3

OAATiiNOS
5 IOTW. Ov yap o5i>. Oi!ra) 8rj Kara itavra rafira TO f v
T&V re aXXcov Kal (avrov Sirrerai re KOI ov

10
15

'Ap' ovv Kal l<rov earl Kal &vurov a{rr(p Tf Kal roiy
dXXois; rioiis; El fxeifoy fltj TO tv TJ raXXa fj IXarrov,
17 a5 ra aXXa TOV tvbs f*iC< ^ eXdrrto, Spa OVK fti> TG> ftev
w etvoi ro %v Kal roXAa &XXa roC evbs otire n fieifw
oiiTe ri iXaTTco iv eiij aXA.^Xo)!' o^rais yf Tavrais rais
ow<riais; a\A' ci fiev irpos T rotawa elvai eKarepa Jcrorr/ra
f^pifv, foa av eirj irpos aAAjjAer el bf TO, fj,fv ptyedos, ro
8e (TfiiKpo'Trjra, ^ /cai ptyeBos ptv TO ev, 0-fu/cporr]Ta 8
TaXAa, 6iroT^p(i> fi^v T elSei jj^yedos irpoo-e^ij, neiov av
flrj, u 8^ o-piiKporrjs, !Aarroj>; 'AvayxT). Oi/cow eoroV
y^ Ttve Tovrto et8i), TO T ptyfOos Kal TI 0-fj.iKporqs; ov yap
&u irov f^Tj oire y ^vavr^co re oAAijA.ou' efrr)i; Kal fo rois
oj><rw eyyiyvofo&rjv. H&s yap av; EJ apa tv r fvl
/s lyyfyvtrai, JJTOI ^r S\<j) aw T} Iv ju^pei avroC
r). 'ArdyKTj.Ti 8' d kv SX<j> fyylyvotTo; oiiyl TJ ^
av r^i 4i>l 81' oXou avroC rera/ui^vTj el?) TJ wepi^ovo'a
avrrf; Ar;\oi> 817. -*Ap' oBv OVK l foov i&v o5o-a r; o-ftiKprfrr/s ry (vl IOTJ av airy <l;r;, Tftpi^ovtra 8^ fj-etfav;
IlcSs 8" oiJ; Awaror o5i> o-jMKpoYrjra IOTJV r<[> elrai rj fiftfo
TWOS, Kal irpaTTfiv TO. pfytOovs Tf Kal IfforrjTos,
a\\a
fw) ra tavrfjs; 'ASifoaror. 'Ev fj&v o\<f apa ry tvl OVK
av tit] (rpiiKpo'rjjs, a\\' rfirep, Iv fxcpei. Na(^Oi8^ y 4v
08 ry jLicpcr Z 8^ firj, ravri Troujcret awtp Trpos ro
to-T) IOTOI r; pttfav TOV ptpovs tv <f av del ivy.
"AvdyKi;.Oiibfvt wore apa tvta-TOi T&V 8vr<ov o-fxtKpdrrjs,
ev fxe'pei fxrjr' ^v 0X0) tyyiyvo^vrjoiibt ri lo-rai
d 8 post Itrov rasura quattuor litterarum in B
airi &A.Aa B
63 ^TTU T : tXXo, ^TTW B
/x^vcnxra B
Heindorf

e I oJ rjx\n T :
6 5 rii 8i Par. 1810 :

b a oiS^ yt Hermann : otrt yt B : oSri yt T : O<!TOI

b 3 iroi^im T : Toi^trp B
b 5 <K<ffTai T : tc ?OTOI

IIAPMENIAHS
7rA.T)y avrfjs cr^tKpoVrjros. QVK eoiKey. Ot8' apa
eyeorat ey avT<S- ^tlCpv yap av TL euj aAAo Kat
TrArjy avTou p,eye0ovs, eKeu>o ey w TO jueyefloy eyetr/, /cat c
ravra cr^LKpov aiirw OVK OVTOS, ov avayKr] vTrfpf^fiv,
fdvnfp
ri p-eya* TOVTO Se dSwaToy, en-eiS?) or/u,tKporrj9 ovba^ov eyi. .
'AArjtfr/. 'AAAa JUTJZ; avro fAeye^os OVK aAAov jj.eiov T]
avrrjs o-^iKpor-qros, ow8e cr/xtAcpor?]? aAAov eAarroy T) airo{5 5
. Ov yap. Ovre apa ra aAAa juet^a) rou eros
eA.arrco, ju?]re p-eye^os f>i?jre crjjLiKpoTrjra f\ovra, ovre
ai>TU> TOVTCO TTpOS

TO fV %\tTOV TT]V

^VVa^LV Tr)V TOV

fX<eiv Kal VTrp-)((r6ai, aAAa Trpos dAA^Aa), ovre av ro

TOVTOLV

OV$ T&V

ttXXutV

fJifl^OV

&V O^8' i-kdTTOV

yre er/xtKpor^ra e'xov.^ OVKOW <j)aCvTai ye. ^"

ei /u?jre ^fl^ov pr/re eAarroy TO ey Tw
TO ye JUTJTS vTTfpl^ov /XTJTC inrfpf^ofjifvov
TroAArj
t(rou e?yat, e^ i<rou 8e w lo-oy eTyat. IT<3s yap
ou; Kal JU,T/Z> /cat avro ye TO ty Trpos eavTO OVTCOS av e^otjUTjTe p^eye^o? ey eavTai p,?7Te o-p,tKpoTrjTa exor ovV ai' inrep\OLTO OVT' ai> virepe'x^ot eavToS, dAA' e ifcrov or taoy ay etr]
eavTw.- ITaw p,ef ovv. To ly apa eauToi Te Kat TO^
aAAots tcroy ai> etr;. 4>atyeTat. Kat fj,r]v avro ye fv eat>T<S
ov /cat Trept eavro av fir] e^co^ev, /cat ireptexoy p,ey fjielfav
av eavTov etrj, ureptexop.ei'oi' 8e eXarrov, /cat OVTCO ^ei^by ay
Kat eAaTToy eT?7 avTO eauTou TO eV. Etrj yap ay. OVKOW
Kat To'8e avayKf], p^Ser ewat eKToy TOU eyo's Te Kal T<Sy
aAAcov; YLG>s yap ov; 'AAAa fj/qv Kat eTi^ai irov 8et TO ye
oj; det.''Nat.-OVKOVV TO ye eV TO> oy ey p;et{byt eo-Tat
eAaTToy oy; ov yap av aAAco? eTepoy er eTe'pw etrj. Ov
yap. 'E7rei8r;| 8e oi/8ey eVepoy eon x^P'5 y aAAcoy Kat
b 7 auTijs B : avrrjs Trjs T
C 2 OIIT^ B T : auroD vulg.
d i aiiT& rovro! T : avrqU rovrcf pr. B
X*T'' T : %era> B
d 2 /cal B T : T ral vulg.
S rb !/ T : avr$ fv B
e 3 &y elf?) B :
ai'el elyT
e 5 -ye T : re B
as T(55e B T : rb vulg.
a 5 ev
ry B : Ij/ TIJJ pr. T

5
151

[a

IIAATflNOS
TOV evos, Set 8e ovra tv r<j> elvai, OVK avayKt) -fibr) ev oAAjAots ftvai, TO. re #AAa ev ro> evl Kal TO ev ev rots #AAots,
Jj iJ.rjbaiJ.ov eivai; <I>aiz>erai. "Ort p,ev apa ro ev ev rols
aAAots eveori, juefa> av fir] ra #AAa TOV evos, Tsepif^ovro.
avro, TO be li> f\a.Trov T&V &\\a>v, TTfpifxoufvov
OTL be ra
aAA.a ev T& evi, TO ev T&V &\\ci>v KOTO TOV avrbv \6yov
fj.fifyv &v etrj, ra be aAA.a TOV evbs eAarrto. "EoiKev -- ^To
ev apo t<rov re Kal fiei^ov /cat lAarrw eo-rtv avro re airoS
xat rSv iiAA.a)!'.<J>atWrai. Kai firiv enrep /neifoi' Kai eAarroi' KOI to-ov, t(ra)j av ei?/ jueYptov icat irAeiwcor xai eAarrwaiz;
avr$ xat rots ^fAAoty, eireiSr; 8e ptrpatv, Kal nep&v IISs
8' o{!; "\<T(H>V fj.tv apa juerpa>v ov Kal TrXeiovtav Kal eAarroviov, (cat dptd/ia> lAarroi' aj; <cat TrAeov el?j avro re avroC
Kal T&V a\Xiav Kal foov avrio re Kal rots aAAots Kara
ravrd.Flais;*lvirep /xetfow ^art, irAeiwcov irov ical
perputv av ftrf airr&v, otrcav 6e )jrpua>, Kal jj-ep&v Kal &v
i\aTTOv, VHraijrw Kal ols foov, Kari ravrd.Ovrtos.
OVKOVV eavroC jnetfoi' Kal lAarroy 3v (cat 1<rov tatav av etr;
litrpatv Kal it\fi6vu>v Kal e\arr6va>v avrip, ^18^ be
Kal fj,fp&v; n&s 8' ov; "lo-<av fj.ev apa fj-fp&v oV
law av TO TrXfjOos avroi eit], Tt\fiov<av 8e irAeW, i\aTr6vtav
be lAarroi' TOV dptd/otov avroS. <I>afoerai. OVKOVV Kal
irpos raAAa axnumos ((a TO tv; OTI jnev nelov avr&v
<pa(veTai, avdyKi) ir\eov flvai Kal TOV api.0ij.bv airr&v 5rt
8^ o-piKpoTepov, lAarrov OTI 8e lo-ov pc/eOfi, Icrov Kal ro
iT^Oos dvai rots SAAots; 'AvdyKij. Ovrw 87; av, is
looce, ro ev Kal lo-ov Kal it\eov Kal ekarrov TOV apiOpov
avro re avrou Icrrat icai T&V 2AAa>i>. "Eorot.
*Ap' ovv Kal xpovov /xerexei ro Iv, Kal e<nl re Kal yiyveTat veiaTepov re (cat irpeo-fivrepov avro re eavroC xal T&V
&\Xoav, Kal ovre ve<aTepov ovre irpfo-(3vT(pov ovre eavrov
\povov nfT^\ov; Dais; >EZfat fieV irov
C 2 /iiy B : om. T

07 raimi T : TOUTO B

I1APMENIAHS

1516

avr<S u7rapxei> enrep ey eorty.-Nat.'To be elyat aAAo rt

eariy 17 p-e^e^ts owta? /uera \povov TOV rcapovTos, coo-irep
TO r\v fxera TO> TrapeArjAufloro? Kat av TO co-rat juera roC 152
jueAAoyros oicrta? eort K0tya>yta; v Eort yap.Merest Mei*
Spa xpoyou, enrep /cat TOV eiyat.Haru ye.OVKOVV iropeuo^icyou TOU yjpovov;Nat.'Aet apa Trpea-^vrepoy ytyrerat
laurou, eiTrep Trpoep)(erai Kara xpovov..'AyayKrj.?Ap' ovv 5
jue/x,v?j/ue0a on vecoTepou yiyyo/xeyou TO Trpeo-^vTepoy npzcrfi'vTfpov yiyycTat;Me/x,i'77/Jie^a.-Oii/cow eireiS^ TTpecr(3vTepov
yiyveTcu TO ey, vecoTepov ay yiyvo^vov kavrov irpeyiyvoiro;.'Ayay/oj..Fiyj^eTai /zey ST) veatrtpov b
T Kat irpetr/Bi/Tepoy avToi5 OTJTCO.Nat.-vE0Ti 8e irpea-fivrepov ap oi^ oTay Kara Toy yy \povov 17 yiyvo^fvov TOV
fj.fTav TOV r\v TC Kat lorai; ov yap -TTOU TropevojueroV ye
eK TOU -TTOTC ets TO eTretTa v7rep/3?]o-eTat TO yuy.Ow yap.. 5
*Ap' oSy OIK e-Tj-icr^et ToVe TO ytyyeo-^at irpea/SvTepoy, eTret6ay Toi yy fvTv^rj, Kat ov ytyyeTat, dAA' eo-Tt TOT' ^877 c
Trpeo-^Tepoy; Ttpoibv yap OVK av wore Xrj^^etrj VTTO TOU
z>Sy. TO yap iipo'iov OVTCOS e^et w? dp,<poTepwy e<pa7rTeo-0at,
TOU Te yuz; Kat Toi; e-^etTa, TOU /xey rw a^te^teyoy, TOU 8'
eVeiTa e-TrtXa/xjSai'o/ixeyoy, jueTa^u d/AtpoTepcoy yiyvo^vov, 5
TOU Te eTrerra Kat TOV y{5y.^'AXr^..Et 8e ye avayM] JUT)
TrapeX^ety TO yCy iray TO yiyvofjifvov, eTretSay Kara TOUTO 17,
e7rio-)(et ael TOU yiyye<r#ai Kat eo-Tt Tore TOUTO OTI ay rvx?7 d
ytyyofxeyoy..4>atyerai.''Kat ro ey apa, oTay Trp<rj3'VTfpov
yi.yv6iJ.fvov eyrux.2? T^> y^y> Treo-\V TOV yiyvecrOai Kal eo-rt
Tore Trpeo-jSurepoy.'Uayv ju,ey ouy.OVKOW ovTrep eytyyero
7rpeo-/3t;Tepoy, TOVTOV Kat ecrny eytyyeTo Se avToi;;'Nat. 5
^Eon 8e TO 7rpea-/3^Tepoy yecorepov irpecrfivTtpov;
Kai yecorepoy apa Tore auroS ICTTI TO e'y, oray
Tepoy ytyyo/xeyoy eyrv^rj rw yuy.^'AyayKrj.-To ye
fta Koivwvia. BT : /coivoiviax vulg.
/xTx B:
b a auToO] iv TOO B ; auroS* T
d 3 T^? WK T : rb, yvj/ B
Tcp T : ov irepi B

jjifrexft
d4

1526

IIAAT&NOS

e vvv del vapecm TO> eyl oia TTCLVTOS TOV eiyar eort yap ael
vvv oTavTtep r],Hats yap ov;'Ael dpa eari Te Kal yiyyeTat
y eaurou Kal yewTepoy TO ei>."EoiKey.IlAeico 8e
OVTO eavTOv eoriy rj yiyyeTai, rj Toy to-oy;.Toy uroy.
'AAAa /XTJy roy ye itroy yjpovov r\ ytyyo'jaeyoy ^ ^z; rr)y
r\XiK.iav e^ei..Hfis 8' ov;'>To 8e rrjy avrrjv ^AiKtay
ovre 7T/>e<r/3vrepoz; ovre yewrepoy ecrrtyOv yap.
To ly apa Toy uroy yjpovov avrb eauTW Kat yiyyojueyoy KOI
oy ouTe yewrepoy ovTe 7rpo-/3vrepoy eauTou eariy oi8e ytyye10 Tai.-Ou juot 8oKei.Tt 8e; Taiy aXXcoy;OVK e^.00 Aeyeiy.
153 To8e ye //.^y ^xfts Aeyety, <m Ta ^AA.a row eyoy, enrep
eVepd e(TTty, dAA.a /x^ eVepoy, TrXeico ecrTty eyos- eVepoy juey
yap 5y ey Sy ?jy, ^Tepa 8e oyra irXetco eyos eo-Ti Kai irXrjdos
5

ay ex.01-'"^X01 7P ^v"'nA^os 8e oy apiQpov TrXeioyo?

CLV fjLT\oi rj TOV eyo?..Dais 8' ov;.Ti ovy; api.6iJ.ov
<|7(ro/xey Ta 7rA.eiaj yiyyecrflai Te Kal yeyoyeyai TrpoTepoy, rj
ra eAaTToo;^-Ta eAaTrco.To oAtyterToy dpa TrpWToy TOWO
8' ICTTI TO e'y. ?j yap;Nai.HdyTcoy apa TO |y TrpwToy
yeyoye TWI* api6\wv tyjjvrw
e^ei 8e Kal TaA.Xa irdyra
enrep aA.Xa /cal jw,^ ^AA.o eoriy.^E^et yap.
8e ye ot/xat yeyoyos TrpoYepoy yeyoye, Ta 8e aAAa
vorepoy, Ta 8' vcrrepov yeyoyoVa yewTepa TOU TrpoTepoy
yeyoyoTos- Kal OVTCOS &y et)j TaAAa yewTepa TOU eyos, TO 8e
ey TrpecrjSvrepoy Twy dAAwy.117 yap ay.
Ti 8e To8e; ap' ay etrj TO ey Trapa tyvcnv Trjy awoS
yeyoyo's, ^ dSvyaToy;..'ASvyaToy.''AAA,a p-^y jaeprj ye exoy
<pavri TO e'y, ei 8e fxep^, Kai dpXTjy Kat TeAeDTrjy Kal p;eo-oy.
Na.^-OvKOuy TrdyTtoy irp&Tov ap^y yiyyeTat, Kal a^ToS
TOV eyos Kal eKaaTov Twy &AAa>y, Kal p-eTa T^y dp^y Kal
TaAAa TrdyTa p-expt TOU TeAous;-Tt ^v;.Kal ftrjy /mopid
ye <pri<roiJ,fv TO.VT' etyat -Trdyra raAAa TOV oAov Te Kal eyd?,
e 9 ouSe Heindorf: oSre B T
a 7 oAryiaroj/ T b : o\iyocrrbv pr. B
Procl. suppl.
b 5 T& 5' iia-Tfpov B : T& 5' lia-repa. T to 6 r5AA.
delendum ci. Stallbaum

IIAPMENIAHS

1530

OVTO 8e eKeu>o ajua TT; TeXeuTrj yeyoi/eVat fv re nal

4>J7(ro/xey yap.'TeAeurr) Se ye oijmai ija-Tarov yiyverai, rovro>
8' $jua TO iz> Tre^UKe yiyye<r0ai* <w<rr' enrep avayKr] avro TO d
&> /LUJ Trapa </>vo-> yiyv(T0ai, apa Tf\fvrfj ai> ycyovbs vcrrarov
ai> T&V aXXaw Tfj)VK.bs eir) yiyvf<r6ai.' 4>aiverai. Newrepoy
apa rr aXAcor TO eV eo-Tt, Ta 8' ^AXa TOV eyos 7rpecrj3vTepa.
av //.ot <f>a.LVTai. Ti 8e 877; ap\r]v r) aAAo fxe'pos 5
TOU ei>oy 77 aXXou OTovoOi/, etiyTrep fxepos ^ aXXa /^,T)
OVK drayKaroy ey etyai, juepos ye or/'.'ArtiyKTj.^.
OVKOVV TO ey ajaa Te TO> -jrpcoTO) yiyvojme^&) yiyj/oiT5 ay Kai
ajma T 8eWpa), Kai ovSevo? diroXeiTreTat TOOV aXXcov ytyuo- e
oTiirep ai> TrpofryiyyrjTac OTWOW, e'tos &r irpos ro
SteX^oy 5Xor ey yeVrjTai, ol/Te jueo-ou ovTe irpdrov
afire fo-^arov ovre aXXou oi>8ey6s a7roAei<0ey ej; TTJ yeveeret.-
'AXrj^^. Ilacrii; apa Tols aXXtus rrjv avTrjV fikiKiav tercet TO 5
fv
COQ-T' ei /mi) jra/oa <f>v(riv 7re(puKey avTo TO Iv, oi/Te
TTporcpov OVT %<JTpov T&V aXXojz; yeyopos ay fin], dXX' Sjixa.
Kal KOTO TOVTOJ; Toy Xoyoy TO ly T&V 'aXXcoy ovre -7rpeo-/3vTepoi; 154
y eir], ov8e TaXXa TO{) Iros* KOTO 8e TOI>
TrpecrfivTfpov
Te Kat recoTepor, Kai TaXXa eKetrou
s. Hdvv i&v ovv. ?EoTi fjitv br] OVTMS fxov T Ka'
yeyovos. dXXa TI av ?repl TOU yiyvevOai, amb TrpfcrfivTepov
5
Te Kai Vftarepov T&V #XA<oz> Kai TaXXa TOI) tvos, Kai p.^T
7rpeo-/3vrepoz; yiyvea-Oai; apa aJo-Trep irepi TOV
i, OVTCO Kai Trepl TOU yCyvfcrdai, e)(ei, ^ eTepco?; OVK
e)(<o Xeyety. 'AXA' eya> Totroyge ye' ei Kai eoriy TTp<rj3vTepov b
eTepou, yCyvfcrdai ye avTo jrpecr/SvTepoi' eYi ^ w? TO
evdvs yevoptvov Siij^eyKe TTJ ^XiKta OVK av ITI
ov8' av TO vf&Tfpov
$v ITI ve&Ttpov yiyvfcr9ai'
avCcrois yap iora irpocrTidep-cva, xp6v<$ T Kai aXX<o OTMOVV, 5
C 8 Se ye oljuat T : Se o?yua 7e B
d i rb * post aurb seel. ci.
Heindorf
d 2 TA.trrfj B T : TTJ TeAet/rf) al.
e 3 ly -yej/ijToi
T : tyytvijTai B
irpi&rov ovre fffxdrov B : effxdrov otire irp&rov 1
b I ei /cal eerrtj/ scrips! : 8rt et Ki ecrrti/ T : el Kai ZffTiv 8n B
b 2 -ye T : re B
b 4 oS rJ. T : aurit B

nAATJlNOS

155

i(7<i) irotei buuf>eptv del oVwirep av TO Trp&Tov 8iei>ey(aj.

YI&s yap ofl; -Owe &pa TO ye ov TOV [evbs] Jiros ytyvocr'
av irore irpe<r/3vTepov ovbe vetarepov, flirep f(ra> 8uz(pepet del
TJJZ' fi\iKiav dAA' IOTI <cal yeyovf Tspetrfivrepov, TO be
ve&Tepov, yiyveTai b' oiJ. 'AArjfl?;. Kal ro ev apa ov T&V
aAAa>i> ovrtav ovre irp(r/3vTep6v irore ovTe vedtTepov yiyverai.
Ov yap ovv."Opa be el tfibe irpeo-fivTepa KOI vevTepa
yiyverai. Ilr; 8^; .'Hi TO re $v T&V aAXcoi' e<pdvr) irpeafivrepov KO.I raAAo TOV evos.Ti o5r; "OTUV TO ev T&V
a\\(av itpea-fivrepov 77, -nKeiu) TTOV \povov yeyovev t] TO.
clAXa.Na..IIaA.ir 8^ <r/co;rer eav Tr^eovi ical eXarrovt
XpoV(|> irpo<mO&iJ.ev TOV lo~ov \povov, apa T& liry Capita
Sto^cret TO itKlov TOV e\aTTOvos rj o-piKpoTepip; "
OiiK apa <?arai, oTiittp TO Ttp&rov iji> irpoy raAAa
bia(t>fpov TO tv , TOVTO Kal els TO IwetTa, dAAa Icrov Kapfiavov
\povov rois iAAois (Karrov del rjj ^Ai<c^ Sio/fcrei avroii' ^
npfctpov
$ oi; Naf.Ov/cow Trf ye AOTTOI> bia<j>(pov
^\x^f woe's n ^ is(t6r(pov vt&rtpov yfyvoir' Sv ^ ^v T^
irp6<r0(v irpbs eKeiva irpds & ijv itptafivrtpov nportpov;
Njairepov El be enelvo vetartpov, oiiK (Ktiva a? ra &\\a.
irpos TO tv apeo-pIjTfpa rj irpfcepov; Haw ye. Td p^v
vttoTepov apa yeyov&s tipeafivrepov ylyvtTai irpos TO wprfrepoi' yeyoro'y re xal irpeffftvTepov
ov, IO-TI 8e ovbeTfOTf
npeo-fivrepov, dAAa yiyveTai del (Keivov TTpe<r/3v'Tepov eKeivo
fier yap eirl TO vetarepov embtbuxnv, TO 8' ewl TO irpea-ftvrepov. TO 8' a3 irpeo-fivTepov TOV vemTtpov vetaTepov yiyveTai.
ZoiTe yap avrorv eJs TO evavTtov TO evavrlov
yiyvevBov, TO /j.ev ve<arepov -rrpeo-^vrepov TOV
npetTJBvTfpov, TO 8e irpe<rj8vTepoi' ve<i>Tepov TOV veotTepov
yevevOai 8e OVK ar o?o> re elrrjv. ei yap yevotvTO, OVK
av fTi yiyvoiVTO, dAA' eTev ai>. yi3j> 8e ylyvovrai jjjtv
b 7 tv in ras. B
c^; seel. Schleiennacher
O i ovti B :
otrf T
C2 ri Si T : ro'Se B
03 ylyverat T : om. B
aa ri
bis scripsit T : semel B

IIAPMENIAHS

I55a

dA.ATjA.coi' Kal yewrepa- TO nev %v T&V a\Xa>v

vewrtpov yiyverat, on 7:pe<r/3vrepoz> <f>avr] ov Kat TTporepov
yeyovoy, ra 8e aAAa TOV fvbs irpe(r/3vTpa, OTL vorepa b
ytyov. Kara e TOV avTov \6yov Kal raAAa OVTU> irpos
TO V tercel, e-TretSTfTrep avTOV Trp<r/3vTpa <f>avr) KOI irpoTfpa. yeyovoTa. 3>aii>erai yap ovv ovrcos. OVKOVV 17 [J,V
ov8ey fTfpov erejoou TTpecrflvTzpov ytyverat ov8e i>e(6repoz>, 5
Kara ro Icra) apifyi<5 aAXT^Acoy det 8ia<f>epiv, OVTC TO Iv
rwy aAAcov TrpcfffiiJTepov
ylyvovr av oiibe v(&Tpov, evre
T&AA.a rou cvoy ^ 8e aAAa> del //.opiw 8ta^>epety dyay/crj
ra Trporepa ra)!; varfpatv yfv6/j.eva /cat ra vcrrepa rwz; C
nportpow, ravrr/ 8rj avayK-q irpeo'/Swrepa re /cat rewrepa
yiyvfcrOai, ra re aAAa roi; eyos Kat ro ey roiy
; Haz>u /^ei' ovr. Kara ST) Trdz^ra ravra ro ei> avro
re avroS Kat " r<Sz> aAAcoy irpftrfivTepov
Kal vecorepoy eo-rt 5
re Kal ytyz>erat, Kai ovre <77peo-/3tJrepo^ oiire rewrepoy ovr'
ecrri/; ovre ytyverat ovre a-uro{5 ovre rS>v aAAcoy. ITayreA<3s /xev ovy...'ETrei&Tj 8e \povov juere'xet ro |y Kal rou
irp<Tf3vTp6v re Kal yecorepoy ytyreo-^at, ap' OVK avdyKrj Kal d
rov Trore /xere^ety Kal row eTreira Kal roC iCv, eiirep \povov
juere^ei; 'AvdyKrj. ?Hy apa ro ey Kal ecrn Kal eorat Kal
eytyyero Kal ytyyerai Kal yeyTycrerat. .Ti jaTyv; ^Kal etr; ay
u KiV(p Kal fKtivov, Kal ?ji> Kal eo-rty Kal ecrrai. TIdvv 5
ye. Kal eTTKmjjuT} 8^ eir] ay avrov Kal So^ia Kal atcr0r]<ns,
etirep Kal ^v rj^fls Trept avrov Trdvra raura -Trpdrro/xey.
Aeyets.^ Kat ovopa by Kal Ao'yo? etrrty avrw, Kal
rat Kal Aeyeraf Kal 6Va/n-ep Kal irepl ra aAAa T&V e
TOIOVTMV Tvy^dvfi, OVTU, Kal Trepl ro ev Z&TIV. riapreAais
fxey ovv e^ei oilrcos.
"Ert 8r) ro rptroy Aey<u//,ei>. ro ey et ecrrty otor
y, ap' OVK avdyKrj OIVTO, ev re 5r Kal TroAAa Kal 5
b 2 o0Tw B : TotJry T
B

e I irepl rit &\\a b : irepl rS\Aa T :

IIAATI1NO2

10
156

ey /j"?re TroAAa Kai /xerexoy xP0'1'01'* on fxey eoru> ey,

owtas juerexety irore, on 8' OVK eon, jj.rj /xerexeiy av wore
owtas; 'AydyKij. *Ap' o$y, ore f/ere)(ei, otoi> re eo-rai
rore /AT) ptere'xew', r) ore juu] p;ere)(eij /xere'xety; O^x otoV
re.' 'Ev aAAco apa xpo*'*? MTexet Ka^ ey ^^'p
oijTto) yap av fj,6v(as TOV CLVTOV p,erexoi re Kat ov
'Op^ws.'QVKOVV etrrt Kal oSro? x.poyos, ore
row eti'ai (cal ore cnraAAarrerai avrov; TJ TTWS otoV re eo-rat
ror^ /xey exLV T a^ro, rore 8e /AT) exety, eay p,?j irore Kat
Aa/x/Sayrj avro Kat d(ptTj; OwSajuuo? -- ^To 8rj owtas fxera\afj.j3avi.v apa ye ov yiyve<rQa.i KaA.eis>'-"Eycoye.^T6 8e
aTraAXarrecr^at ovcrias apa OVK a7roAAt;(r0at;'Kal Trdyu ye.
^To ti> 877, ws eotKe, Xafx/3dyoy re /cat do^tei; ovcriav yiyrerat
re jcat diroAXurat. ^Ayay/a]. *"Ey 8e Kat TroAXa 8v Kat
ytyro/xeroy Kat aTroAAv/uieyoi' ap' oi/x> orav /xe^ yfyyrjrat ev,
TO iroAAa etyat oVrroAAurat, QTO.V 8e TroXAd, ro %v etvat
aTToAAurai; Haw ye. -*Ey 8e yiyvopevov Kal iroAAa ap'
OVK avayKt] faaKpivfcrOai re Kat cruyKptyeo-^at;'TIoAA?j ye.
Kat ftfjv avojAOwv ye Kat o/xotoy orav ytyrrjrat, o/xoioCcr^at
re Kat azJOjuotowflat;' .Nai. Kat orai> jaet^oy Kat eAarrov
Kal t<roi>, av^avtcrOai re Kat <p$u>etv Kat t<ro{i(r0ai; Oi5ra)s.
?Orau 8e KLVO^^VOV re tcrrrjrat Kat oray eoros em ro
Ktyeto-^at /ixera^3dAATj, 8eZ O^TTOU avro ye //rj6' ey eyl XPV<$
etyat. ITfis 17; ^'Eo-ros re Trporepoy vorepoy Ktyeto-^at Kat
irporepoy iavovp,evov {Jcrrepoy kcrravai, avtv /x,ey roC p,era/SdAAety oix otoy re ecrrai raura Trdcrxety. IIws yap;-:
Xpo'yos 8e ye ov8eis IOTIV, ey w rt otoy re ap,a jATjre KtyeZcr^ai
/ixrjre eo-rdyat. Ov yap ow.^.'AAA' oi8e /xrjy p.eraj8dAAet
ayeu rou p,era/3aAAeiz>. -O^K etKo?. YI or' oiiy /xerajSaAXet;
ovre yap e<rros oy ovre Ktyoi5/j,eyoy piera/3dAAei, ovre ey
oy. Ov yap ovy. ?Ap' ovv lart ro aroTroy rouro,
e ii ou/ierex*" B : ov ^uerexe'T
as 7eT : om. B
a 7 yijverai
re B : yfyyerai T
64 fj&v] fn^v Heindorf
C 9 fci/ . . . /teTaB : & ! / . . . f4.era&<i\\ei T : &)/ . . . ^txeTa/BcUAoi corn. Par. 1809

OAPMENIAH2
|y w roV ay etrj, ore juera/QaAAet; To Trotoy by;-To
e^atqbyr/S1. ro yap e^aic^yrjs rotoVo'e rt eouce a-rjp,aivfiv, ws
e eKetyoi; juera/3aAAoy ets eKarepoy. ov yap IK ye TOI!
ecrrdyat eoTcoro? en ^era/3aAAet, 0118' IK TT/S Ktyijcrecos'
KivovfJtvrjs ert juercijSaAAei' dAAa ?/ eat</>yTjs a^TTj <j>varis
CLTOTTOS ri? yKa6r]Tcu. fjLeTav rfjs KivrjacfJos re Kat (rracrecoy,
ey XP^? ^^ej;t oi!o-a, KOI eis Tavrr]V ^TJ Kat ex raT/njs ro re
Kivovfj.vov /u,era/3aAAe6 eiri ro k(navai KCU ro eo-ros 67ri ro
KiveicrOai,, 'Kivbwefiei.- Kat ro %v 8?j, etirep eo-rrjKe re KCU
Kivetrai, p:era/3aAAot ay e^>' eKarepO'juortos yap ay
d/x^)orepa Trotor /y,eray8aAAoi; 8' e
ore /uera/3aAAei, er o^Seyt \PV<P
rore, oi>8' av oratr]. Ol; yap. -*Ap' o^y oi'r<o Kat -Trpos ras
aAAas /xera/3oAas e)(fi> oray e*c ro{5 etvat ets ro diroAAvtr^at
TJ eK rov jurj eti'at ety ro yiyvecrOai, /xera^u
rore yiyrerat kivrjcre^v re Kat o-rdo-ecor, Kat oiire
lerrt rore oiire OVK eo-rt, ovre ytyrerat ot!re diroAAvrai;
."EotKe yow. Kara 8rj roy avrov Koyov Kal e^ eros
em TroAAa toy Kat eK -TroAAcSy *<$> %v ovre ey eo-rii> o(!re
TroAAd, oi5re StaKptyerat ovre (ruyKpiyerat. Kat e^ 6/moiov
eirt avofjioiov Kat e^ avo^oiov eTrt o/xotoy toy otire o^xotoy
oi!re avop-OLOv, ovre ojuotovjaeyoy ovre avofj.oLovfj.fvov
KCU
eK o-^tK/aou ITTI fxeya Kat eTrt tcroy Kat ets ra eyayrta
tor oi!re (r/xtKpoy oi!re jaeya ovre icroy, oi;re avav6[ji(vov
OVT fydlvov ovTf. to-o^eyoy etr; ay. OVK eotKe.<Tavra
O"T) ra 7ra07]juara Trdyr' ay Tracrxoi ro ey, et eo-rty.'.Ilws
5' oi5;
Tt 8e rots aAAots Trpoo'TjKOt ay irdtrxety, ey et
apa ov o-Ke'Trreoy; SKeirreoy. Aeya>p;ey 877, ey et eVrt,
raAAa rou eyos rt x/"7 TreTroy^e'yat ; Ae'yco/xey. OVKOVV
e B : roiovrov T
d.4 -yeB: reT
ei ovSevl T : ouS*
B (et mox)
a i ^erojBciAATj B : juerojSa^ pr. T (ut videtur) :
al.
b 4 et ^O-TIJ/] li/ el ecrrf Heindorf

157

157 b
eirenrep aAAa TOV eyos eony, oure TO e'y eon raAAa' ov
c yap ay aAAa rou eyos r]y.'Opflws..Ov8e fxrjy oreperat
ye TravTairaai. TOV kvbs raAAa, dAAa fxerexet TTJ--Hr) 877;.
r
'Ort TTOU ra aAAa rou eyos jsxo'pia exoyra &AAa eo-rty ei yap
/xopta /XT) ex<H, irayreAws ay ty etrj.^.'Op^ws.Mopia 8e
5 ye, <f>a^fv, TOVTOV kfrrlv o ay 0X01; r\.&a\ikv yap.'AA.A.a
priv TO ye oXov ey e/c iroA-AcSy ayayKrj eTyai, o5 earat fxopia
ra /uiopia' e/caorov yap rwy /xoptcoy ov TroXXwy p,opioy ^P^
ctvai, aAXa oA.ou.HcSs roSro;Et TI iroAAwi' popiov etrj,
d ev ots avro etrj, eaurou re STJTTOU /Jiopioy eorai, o eorty
dSuyaroy, /cat T&V aAAcoy 8rj eyos licao-rou, eiirep Kai it&VTcov,
vbs yap fj.rj ov fj.6pi.ov, irXriv TOVTOV T&V aAAcoy ecrrai, xat
ovrcos fvbs fKacrTov OVK ecTTai fiopioy, JUT) oy 8e jaoptoy
5 oiiSeyos1 rfiy uoAAwy lorai. ju,T)8eyos 8e oy Trctyrcoy
TI etyat, JJy ovSeyos o^8ey eon, Kat juopioy /cat aAAo OTIOW
[eZyai].4>atyerat ye 817.OVK #pa T&V iroAAoiy
Trayrcoy ro /xoptoy fxoptoy, aAAa fxias nyos ideas Kat
e eyos rtvos & KaXovpev oAoy, e^ aTrdyTcoy ly re'Aetoy yeyoyos,
rovrou liopiov ay TO jnoptoy CITJ.'Tlayrairao-i fxey ovy.Et
apa raAAa ^.opta ex^tj Kay row oAou re Kat eyos /xere^ou
Tlayu ye.^-*Ey apa oAoy reAetoy jutopta %\ov avAyKrj etyat
5 raAAa TOV eyos..'AyayKTj.'.Kat p)y Kat Trepl TOV juoptou ye
eKaorov 6 avros Aoyos* Kai yap TOVTO avayKrj /ierexfiv
158 TOV eyos. et yap ^Kacrroy avrfiy jaopioy eari, ro ye eKaoroy
eTyai |y OTJTTOU ^jaatyet, d^wptcr/xeyoy fxey roSy aAAwy, Ka^'
auro 8e 6V, et-Trep ^Kaoroy ecrrat.^'Op^ws.Merexot 8e ye
ay roC eyos S^Aoy on aAAo 6V ^ ey ov yap ay fieretxey,
5 dAA' ?jy ay avro ey. yuy 8e tvl /mey etyat -TrA^y avrw rw eyl
dSvyaro'y -TTOU.'ASuyaroy..Merex^iy 8^ ye TOV eyos dyayKi)
TO) re oA<o Kai ro> fxopt&>.
ro juei; yap ^y oAoy ecrrat, ov
b 9 otire] (ot>re rSAXa eo-rl T}> Iv) oiJrc Buttmann: oiiSe Stallbaum
02 /terexetT: jueTe'xeTa^B
C 5 & &i/T : e^B
d6 S^T: tvB
d 7 ?veu seel. Heindorf
64 ev T: ^v B
e 6 TOVTO B: robrov T
a i ye T : re B
as aurb ^rb) Heindorf
a6 -yeT : om. B

IIAPMENIAH2

I5

p,o'pta ra \iopia.' TO 8' av eicaoTov y /uo'ptoy TOV oXou, & ay 77

jxopioy oXou.Ovrcos.OVKOVV e'repa oyra row evbs p.e0eet b
ra /xerexoyra avrov;HcSs 8' OTJ;Ta 8' erepa row evos
TroXAd TTOTJ ay efy- ei yap //.Tjre ey f^re eyos TrAeuw etrj
raXXa rou eyo?, ovo*ey az/ eti).-Ov yap ovv.
'Eiret 8e ye 7r\euo Iro's ecrrt ra re rou ez/os [lopLov K.OLL ra 5
. row eros oA.oi> /xerexoyra, OVK drdyKTj 77877 7rA?70ei aTreipa
eii'at avra ye eKeu/a ra /xeraA.ajuj3ayoyra rou ero's;^IIws;

Ii8e i8cojaey. aXXo rt oix. ^y ovra o?j8e fj,T\ovTa TOV cvbs

rore, ore /z.eraA.a//,/3az>ei aTjroC, jueraXaja/Sarei;-A^A.a 877.^
OVKOW '77X77077 6Vra, ey ots ro ey OVK ert;.17X77^77 juterrot. C
.Tt OTJX;; ei e0e'Aoi//,ei> r7/ 8iayota rwy Toiovrav
oioi re fcrfj.fv ou oAiyio-rop, OVK drdy/CTj *cat ro d<
, etwep rou ei>6? JUT^ juterexoi, 77X77^09 et^ai /cat OTJ^ ev;
j.^-Qvitovv oijrcos det (TKOTrowres aTjr^y Ka^' amrjv 5
rTjy erepay (pva-iv TOV eibovs o<rov ay avr^s del 6pcS/xey cnreipoz;
l<rrai TrX^et;IlayraTrao-t f*ey ow.Kat fi^y eireiSay ye
|y J-KCUTTOV fjiopiov fjiopiov yeyrjrai, rrepa? 7)877 exet irpos d.
a Kat Trpos TO oAoy, Kat ro oXoy Trpos ra fxo'pta.
ovy.^Tors aXAots 87)TOTJe^os o-u/xjSatyet eK jixey
rou eyos Kat e^ eavrwy KOiva>vrjcravTu>v, &s eotKey, erepoy rt
yi'yye(T0at ey eavrots, 6 8r) Trepas TrapeV^e irpos aAXTjAa- 77 5
8' eavrwy <pv<ri.s Ka0' eaura aTretptay.c^atyerat.'Ovra) T)
ra aXXa row eyos Kat oXa Kat Kara joto'pta aTretpd re ecrrt
Kat Treparos juerexet.ITdyu ye.
OTJKOW Kat o/xotd re Kat avop-oia dXXTjXot? re Kat eaurots; e
Tli) 877;?Hi p,ey TTOJJ ckreipd e(rrt Kara rrjy eauraiy (pv<riv
Travra, ravroy TreTroyflora ay etTj TavTy.ndyu ye.'Kat p.7)y
t} ye cbrayra Treparos p;erexet, Kat ravrTj -TroW ay etTj ravroy,
a8 ft] o5 al. Bekker
"b i p.6piov oA.ou] /j.opiov vel fj.opicav 8\ov Schleiermacher
b 3 &>/ efr) B : e^jj &j/ T
b 6 ^8r? B : Si] T
irA^Oej
&7ipa B : &7reipa it\^6fi T
b 8 YSw/uev] eiSeu/nfv B T
03 oAtyi(TTb> (sic) B (cf. 149 a, -7) : oA.fyfo-Toi' T
05 (ncoirowTes pr. T
Damascius: (TKOVOWTI B
d. t ^tdpiovbisB: semelT
d.6 ei.Tteipia.ti
T : inreipiaB
G2$T:elE
e 4 $ T : ei B

I58e

ITAATJINOS

5 TreirovOoTd. TIcSs 8' ov; ? Ht 8e ye TreTrepacr/Lieya re etyai

Kat airetpa TrsirovOev, eyayrta Tradrj dAA^Aots oyra ravra ra
159 Traflry TrsTrovdev. -Nat. To. 8' eyayrta ye ws oto'y re dyo,,
/zoiorara. .Tt pjy; .Kara juey apa eKoVepoy ro Trdflos
o/xota ay eir? avr<i re avro? Kat dAA^AotS1, Kara 8* d/x<|>orepa
dju(porepcos eVazmcorara re /cat dyo/iotorara. >Kiz;wetfci.
5 Ourco 8^ ra aA.Aa avra re avrot? Kat dA.A?]Aots o/xotd re /cat
ay e?rj. Otfrcos. .Kat ravra 8^ Kat erepa d
Kat eorcora, Kat iravra ra evayrta Trc
7re7roi>0o'ra ra\A.a rou eyos, eTretTrep Kat
b rai5ra <f)6.vr] TtrnovdoTa. -'Opflws Aeyets.

OVKOW, et raura jutey 17817 e<3ju.ev a>? c/>az>epa,

8e iraAty ly et eorrty, apa Kat ovx. ovrcos ex TO ^AAa rot)
eyos ^ ovrco JJLOVOV; .ITayu fxev oSi/. -Aeycofxey 8ij e^ dpx^Js
ev et eart, rt XP^? ra ^AAa rou eros ireTrovOevai. 'Aeya)jx,ei>
yap. ^Ap' ovv ov x<wpt? jaey ro ev rcoy aAAcoy, x^P'? 8e
raAAa row evos ewat; Tt STJ; ."Ort TTOV OVK eo-rt irapa
raura erepov, 6 aAAo jLte'y etrrt roC evos, oiXXo 8e rr aAAooy
irayra yap etprjrat, oray prjOrj ro re ly Kal raAAa. ITayra
yap OUK apa er' ea-rty erepoy rovrcoy, ey w ro re ei> av
eti] rai avr Kat r&AAa. .Ov yap.' OvSeVore apa kv raurw
eori ro |y Kal raAAa. OVK eoiKey. .Xcopts apa; Nat.
Ou8e fj,r}v /xopta ye exeiy (Pa/Aey T0 s aXr]9&s &.IT<3s
yap; .Ovr' &pa oAoy etrj ay ro |y ey rots ^AAots ovre /xopta
avrou, et \o)pis re eon rwy aAAooy nal //.opta /^.T) exet.'
yap; OuSeyl apa rpoVw niere'xoi &y raAAa roi; eyos,
/cara /xo'ptoy rt avrou jiijre Kara oAoy juerexoyra.
eotKey.'.OvSajarj apa ly raAAa fcrnv, ov8' ex^i eV eaurots
ey ov8ey Ov yap ovy. Ov8' &pa TroAAd eo-rt raAAa- ey
e 5 77 T : tl B
a i ireirovOev. vat. B : ireTrovfleVaj T
a 5 ra
tf\\a ouTci re B : rS.\\a ravrd re T
ba OVKOW] fort, rf oSrHeindorf
etBT: om.al.
ey/iei/] eoJ/xev B T
firifrKoiroipev BT: cirnco7rcDjue>/ al.
b 7 elvai B : om. T
07 CXEI] exj? BT
d i 7^ B : y&p oC T

UAPMENIAHS

I5gd

yap &v 3\v (Kacrrov avr&v p,optoy TOV oXov, el TroAAa r/v 5
vvv e ovTf fv ovre TroAAa ovre oAoy oi/re /xopta eon raAAa
TOV evos, e7retT7 avrou ovSajxrj /txerexet. 'Opflws.'Ov5' apa
8vo ovSe rpta OVTC avrd eort ra aAAa ovre lyecrriv ey avroiy,
etirep rou Iros Tra^raxfj oreperat.'Oi'rcas.

o/xota apa KCU drojuota owre awrd eort r<5 evt ra

^ecrrty ev avror? OJUOIOTTJ? Kat avopoioTris' el
yap o/xota Kat dvo'/xoia avra e] ^ lxot ^ eavrory 6/oiotorTjTa
Kal dvo^otorTjra, 8vo TTOU ei8rj tvavTia dAAT/Aots ex.ot ay ^ 5
lavrois ra aAAa ro{5 eyos. <I>au>erai. .7Hv 8e ye abwarov
bvoiv Tivotv fj,fTe\W a /x,Tj8' evbs HTf\oi. 'A6vyaror. .
Ovr' apa o/xota oflr' avo^oia tcmv ovr' a^orepa raAAa.
o/xota /xey yap az^ oura rj av6fj,ot.a tvbs av TOV erepou etSous 160
dju,^>orepa 8e wra Svoty roiy zvavriow raCra 8e
e(pai>r]. ^'AArj^Tj.
apa ra avra 0^8' erepa, o^8e Kivov^fva ovbe eo-rwra,
vofAfva ov6e aTroAAv/xezJa, ov8e /xei^io ov8e eAarrco 5
ov8e Ttra- ov8e aAAo oiibev ireTiovOe T&V TOLOVTCOV et yap
n TOIOVTOV TTCTTOvOzvai wojueyei ra aAAa, Kal fvbs mal bvolv
Kat rpi&v Kal Treptrrou Kat dpriou ^te^e^et, wy avroZs a8waroi>
tfyavr] /uterexety roS eros ye -Trarrrj Trayra)? (rrepo/xevots. . b
'AAr/^ecrrara.^.Ovra) 8^ tv et ecrrty, nayra re eerrt ro ^y
Kat oi8e ev ecrri Kat Trpos eauro Kat Trpbs ra aAAa axravrcos.
Ha^reAws /xey oSy.
et 8e 8^ /XT) eari TO ey, rt XP^? o"Uju/3atyety ap' ov 5
jaera rouro; E/ce7rreoy yap. .Tts ovy ay etr/ avrr)
rf VTro^ecrts, et ey /^,T) etrrty; apa rt 8ta</)epet rrjcrde, et p-r)
^y JUT) I err ty; Ata^epet /ue'yrot. .Auupepei JJ.QVOV, ^ Kat Tray
eo-rty etirety et JXTJ ly /x^ eo-rt rou et ly fxrj C
d.8 freffriv] (v effTtj/BT
63 ei/eo-rirB: Kv effric T
j^ T
a i yctpftyT : yhp B
a 3 aSfoarov T : oSiWra B
?? T : owSeV B
T& iiAAa] rSAXa, al rSAAa Heindorf
T : roura B

64
b3
b6 T

i6oc

IIAAT&NOS

e<rrtz>; Hay Tovvavriov.' Ti 8' ei rts Aeyot ei

/XT) fffriv T) o-jxiKpOTT/s /XT) ecrrif i; TI aAAo TOW
apa e<p' (KaffTov az> drjAoT on erepoi; TI Aeyot TO JUT) oi>;
5 Tlayii ye. OVKOW Kai i>Ci> 877X0? 6Yt erepoi> Ae'yet TG>I> aAAc
TO /AT) w, 6Vay ettfTj Iv ei /XT) eo-Ti, KCU to-/xey 6 Aeyei;
v
lo~/xez>.''npfiroy pier apa yvuxrrov TI Aeyei,
T<5i> aAAcoy, oray etirr; ^'y, el/re TO eTvat OVTW
d TO /ixi) etyai' ovSei* (yap) T^TToy ytyvcoo-KCTai, TI TO
/XT) etyai, Kat OTI biatyopov T&V aAAcoi'. TJ o$; ^'
apa Ae/creW e^ dpx^s, ly ei /^T) ea-Tt, TI
/xev OTJJ; avT&i TOVTO virap^w 8ei, w
5 avTou eTTKTTij/ixTjj;, T; /XTjSe on AeyeTai ytyycocrKecr^aij oTar
|y et /XT^ eo-Tir. .'AATj^r). OVKOW Kat ra aAAa
flvai, T) jurjSe enelvo f-Tfpov r&v aAAcoy
Tldvv ye. -Kai eTepotoTijs apa eorty avrw Trpos TTJ
e ov yap rrjv T&V aAAcoy eTepotoTT/Ta Aeyet, orav TO ey eVepoj;
TCOI; aAAcoy Aeyr;, aAAa Tr)y tKcivov. -<I>au>eTai. Kal JW,T)I;
TOTJ ye eKetvou Kat Toi) TIVOS KOI TOUTOU KOI TOVTW Kal TOVTCOI;
Kat TravT(i>v rStv roiomfov /xeTex_ei TO /XT) 5y ey ov yap av
5 TO |y eAeyeTo ov8' ay TOV evos eTepa, ov6' exeiya) av TI T]J>
ov8' eKetyov, ov8' av TI eAeyeTo, ei /xrjTe TOU TWOS amu /xeTT^v
/ATjTe T&V aAAcoy Towwr .'Op^ws.'.ETvai /xev 8i) TW tvl
ovx oloV Te, eiTrep ye /XT) eo-Tt, /xeTe'x^^ ^^ iroAAwy ovSey
161 KcoAvet, aAAa Kat avaynri, etjrep TO ye !z> eKeiyo Kat UT^ aAAo
JU.T) eo-Tty. et /xe^TOt /XTJTC TO IP /XTJT' eKeiro /XT) eo-rai, aAAa
irept aAAov TOU 6 Aoyos, oij8e fyQtyyta&ai 8ei oiibev et 8e TO
|y eKeivo Kal //.TJ aAAo TjiroKetTai /XT) et^at, Kat TOU CKetrou
5 Kat aAAcoy TroAAtSy dz;ayKrj avTai /xeTetrat.^Kat Trayu ye.
Kal dyo/xotoTTjs apa eo"Tty avrai Trpos Ta aAAa1 Ta yap
aAAa ToC evbs eVepa oi>Ta eTepoia Kat etTj av. Nat. Ta
C 3 TJ &\\o B : &\\o nT
04 \eyoi B : \67i T
05
T : \eyoi B
d i ouS^v . . . d a tlvai T : om. B (add. in marg. b)
7&p apogr. : om, T b
e 4 IV B : om. T
a a ^ COTOH B :
T
a, 6 effrlv aur^i B : aii-rcf! ecrTic T

IIAPMENIAH2
8' erepota OVK aAA(Ha;ITcSs 5' ov;Ta 8' dAAota OVK
av6p.oia;'Avop,oLa p,ei> ovy.OVKOVV eforep TO> eul avo/xotd
eari, S7;Aoz> on dz>ojuoia> rd ye avopoLa avo^oia hv fir)..
AT/AOV.EITJ 8r) az> Kal r& evi a^ojuotorrys, Trpo? ^v ra
aAAa dvo/xoia avrai eariy.YEotKez>.Et 8e 8r) roil' aAAwi;
erriy avr<3, ap' OVK avdyKr) kavrov ojuotorTjra
fivai;ILSs1;Ei Iws dyojuotorrjs cart rw ei't, OVK
^v irou TTfjOt ToS rotowrou 6 Aoyoy et7 ofov rou evo's, ovS' &i>
^ V7To^e<ns etr; irepi ez/os, dAAa ^ept aAAou r) eroy.ITayu
ye.Ov Set 8e ye.Ov bijra..Ael apa 6/xoiorr;ra r&> tvl
avrov eaurai eTz^at.Aei.
Kal /jL-qv ovb' av larov y eort rots aAAoi?' et yap e7
i<rov, et?j re av rjbt] Kal opoiov &v etrj aiirors /cara T^
i<rorrjra. raura 8' d/x^)oVepa d8wara, etirep /AT) eorty e'y.'
*Abvva,Ta.>-'ETre^T) 8e OVK e<ru ro?s aAAots icrov, apa OVK
avcLyKf] Kal raAAa exeiva) JUT) fora etvai;'AvayKij.Ta 8e
JU.T) t(ra OVK avi(ra;^Na^.^Ta 8e avi<ra ov rai d^iV<u
&vura;^ITais 8' ov;JKat dvto-o'r^roj 8r) /Aere'xet TO er,
IT/JOS ?;y raAAa avr<S eo-ny aritra;.Mere)(fi.'AAAa juievrot
dwcrorr;roy ye eorl /xeye^os re Kat (Tfjn.KpoTr]s>-"Ecrrt yap.
^E<rriz; apa Kai /xeye^os re Kal o-jLHKporrj? rai rotovrw
fvi;Kwbvvevei.Meye^os IM\V Kal cr^iKpoTrfs del d^>ecrraTov dAATjAoii;.Fldw ye.Merav &pa rt OVTOW dei
eariy..vEarty.^E^et? ovv rt aAAo etireiy i^era^v avrolv
r) tVoVryra;O#K, dAAa roiiro.-"Orw apa earn /xe'ye^os Kal
(TjuiKporrj?, etrri Kal itror^s avrai ju,erai> TOVTOLV ovo~a.'
4>aiz;erai.Toi 8r) erl jit^ oi>ri, cos loiKe, Kal lo-orryros az;
jMereirj Kal jweye^ous Kal cr/x,tKporrjro9.
Kal /ATJZ> Kal ovcrias ye Set avro
8r;;-.vEj(eii' avro Set ovrcos ws Aeyo/xev et yap JU.T) ovrto? ex^i
b 4 ef T: ^ B
c a efroiT: om. B
C 3 y T: om. B
d6 fort,
din-oil/ (6/) Heindorf
e i ^ Par. 1810 Heindorf e Ficino : Se B T
e 2 yuere/ij T: /*Tij) B
63 *coi juV Kal B : /cal ^v T
64 ex*i]
*XJ? B T : f%oi Coisl,
PLATO, VOL. H.
4

i6ia
b

i6ie

HAATilNOS

5 OVK ay aXijdrj Xe'yoi/xey Tj/xeis X^yoyTes TO $y JXT) etyai- e

5e dXT)0Tj, dTj\oy OTI oyra aura Xeyo/xey. TJ ov)( ovYais;
OVTCO /xey ovy.'EireiT) 8e <pa/xey dXTj0Tj Xeyeiy, dydyKTj
162 rj/xiy <f>dyai Kal oWa Xeyeiy.'AydyKTj."Eoriy dpa, a>s
eoiKe, TO ey OVK ov ei yap /XT) earai /AT) oy, dXXd -TTTJ TOV
etyai ayjjVei irpos TO /XT) etyai, ev0vs eorai o'y.IlayTdTrao"!
/mey ovy.Aet dpa avro Secr/xoy e)(fty TOV /XT) etyai TO etyai
5 /XT) o'y, ei /xeXXei /XT) etyai, o/xoicos (So-Trep TO 6V TO /XTJ 6y
l^eiy /XT) etyai, tya TeXewy aS [etyai] TJ- OVTCOS yap ay TO Te
6y /xdXior' ay eirj Kal TO /AT) 6y OVK ay e^Tj, /xeTe^oyTa TO
fxey oy ovo-ias TOV etyai oy, /XT) ovcrias 8e TOV (/XT)) etyai /XT)
b oy, et /xeXXei TeXecos etyai, TO 8e /XT) 6y /XT) ovvias /xey TOV /XT)
etyai [/XT)] o'y, owias 8e TOV etyai /AT) oy, ei Kal TO /XT) 6y aS
/AT) eo-Tai.''AA.Tj0e<rraTa..OvKovy iTreiTrep T Te
TOV /XT) etyai Kal TO> /XT) oyTi TOV etyai /xereoTi, Kal TW
5 kvl, eTrei^T) OVK IO-TI, TOV etyai dydyKTj /xeTeiyai eis TO /XT)
j.'Kal oiivia, T) (ftaivfTat
T eyi, ei /XT)
i.Kal /AT) ovo~ia dpa, eiuep /AT)
IIws 5' ov;
Otoy Te o3y TO e^oy TTCOS /AT) lxeti; ^ra>> M
10 IK TavTTjs TTJS ^ea)s;'Ovx otoy Te.Hay dpa TO TOIOVTW
C /AeTajSoXTjy o-rj/Aaiyei, 6 ay OVTO) Te Kal /XT) ovYoos Ixi?
Hois 8' ov;^MeTa^oXT) 8e Kiinjo-is' TJ TI ^)Tjo-o/Aey;.1
(ris.OvKoi5y TO ey oy Te Kal OVK 6y e<pdyTj;Naf.(
dpa Kal ovx OVTCOS exoy (paiyeTai.^EoiKey.Kal
5 /Aeyoy dpa TO OVK $y |y ire^ayTai, eireiirep Kal
IK TOV etyai em TO /XT) etyai exoy..Kiydwevei..'AXXd
ei /ATj8a/xov y^ eon Twy o'yTwy, ws OVK eariy eiTrep /XT)
ov5' ay /xeflioraiTo TtoQ4v iroi.IlcSs yap;OVK dpa TW ye
d /xeTa/Saiyeiy KiyoiT5 dy.Ov yap.^Ov8e /AT)y ey TW
a 2 TOW im Procl. suppl.: TTJS roO B : n TOV Ba T
a 6 eli/ot secludendum vei Sv scribendum ci. Shorey
a 8 jut? Sv B : i^v T
/tij add. Shorey
b a ju)) seel. Shorey . b 9 irws T : v<a B
c 5 $j>
jre^cwTai] ^uire^ai'Tai B : lvire^>arrai T
07 ye] T^ B T
C 8 jueOf<TTair6 T : juTjfl' T(TTWT(5 B
ry T : rb B

HAPMENIAHS
OLV orpecpoiro* ravrou yap ov8a/xo?3 aTrrerat. ov yap eort
ro ravTov TO 8e /AT) 6V eV r&) r<2z> ovTcav abvvaTov eluat.
'ASvVaroy yap.' OVK apa ro eV ye /XT) 6V o-rpe<pe<r0at ay
SvVatro ez> eKetW ez> w /XT) lorir. Ov yap ow. Ov8e /XT)Z>
dAAoiovrai TTOU TO ev eaurou, ovre ro ^y ovre ro /XT) oy
ov yap av rjv 6 Aoyo? en irepl TOV tvos, ecTrep r/XXoiovro
avrb eaurou, dAA.a Trepi aAAov rti^os. 'Qpd&s. >Ei 8e JIAT^T'
dAAoiourai /j,Tjre kv ravrw orpe^erai //Tjre /j,era/3aiyet, ap'
5r ITT/ en KIVOITO; Hois yap; ^To ye )M]v a.K.ivr)Tov avctyKr]
Tl<ru\(.av ayeiv, TO 8e ^o-vxd^by kvravai. 'AvdyKTj. .To ev
apa, &>s loi/cey, OVK 6V eVrryKe re /cat Ktyerrat.^-"EoiKey.
Kat /xr)y eiirep ye KivtiTai, /AeyaAr; avdyKt] avrw dAAotou07TT7 yap av rt KivrjOf}, Kara roo-oCror ovKtQ* wcravrcos
&>? e?Xez;' dAA' erepcos.'.Ovrcoy. Kipoujueyoy STJ ro ey
dAAotoiJrat.^Nai.^Kat JUT)Z> ^rj8a/x,T/ ye Kivovjjifvov
ay dAAotoiro.^Ou yap. ?Hi /Aey apa Kivevrai ro
OUK oi Ir, dAAoiourar if 8e /XT) Kiyei^rai, OVK dAAowwrai. .
Ou yap.'To ly apa /AT) ov dAAotoSrai re Kai OTJK dAAotourat. 4>atVerat. ^To 8' akXoio-v^vov ap' OT!K dydyKTj
yiyvccrdat /Aer erepou T^ irporepoy, diroAAvcr^at 8e eK r^s
irporepas Ifecos' ro 8e /AT) dAAoiov/Aevor /AT^re yiyvfffdai
d-TroAAuo-^at; 'AvayKrj. Kai ro ly apa /XT) 6V dAAoiov; ytyyerai re Kat aTro'AAurat, /AT) aXXoi.ovp.evov 8e
owre yty^erai ovre aTroAAvrar Kat ovrco ro ev /XT) ov yCyverai
re Kai aTroAAurat, Kai ovre yiyverat ovr' aTroAAvrat..Ov
yap ovv.
A.V0LS by em rr\v dpXTjy fa>/xey TraAiz; d^o/xerot et ravra
T//AII; (fraveiTai airep Kai vvv y erepa. 'AAAa x/37?- OVKOW
f v et /XT) eo-rt, <rja/xez;, rt x/37^ '"'fj0' avroi; (rviifiaivtiv ;<
Nat...To 8e /AT) eo-rty oray Aeyco/xer, apa /XT; n aAAo
a2 e ?x6j/T: ex B
H Heindorf e Ficino : 5* B T
a
om. B
^ T : et B
a 5 f T : el E
b 4 otfre -yiV-ai T : 06
Tfiyvtrai B*
b 6 7ebp o/ B : jdp T
c 2 TI S\A.o B : &\\o ri T

i6ad

163

i63c

164

IIAATflNOS
r/ ovo-ias imovaiav TOVTU &> ai> <pS>fJ.(V fit) elwi;
Ovbtv &AAo __ Uorepov ovv, orav <t>&i*ev ftrf Aval rt, TTO>S
OVK elvaC (pap.tv avro, ir<os 8 (Ivai; rj TOVTO TO jwj Ion
\ty6fj.(vov airASs <rr\\i.aivei on ovSa/Mfis ov8ajUT} lortv ov8e
irj/ HfTf\ei ova-ias TO ye JUT; oV; ^"AwAotJoTaTa ^iei> ovv.
Otfre apa eivat SiWtro &i> ro JUTJ ov ovre aAAtos oi8o/xus
ovcrias ^erexe"'- Oi yiip -- To 8e yiyvfffBai nai TO aTroA./XT/ n SAAo ?)j> ^ ro ftev owias fieraA.ajoi/Jttoeii', ro
diroAAwai ova-iav;Ovbev aAAo..'lit 8e ye ftrjS^
eoTiz', ovr' &D \afjL/3a.voi ovr airoAAuoi avro.'
IISs yap-,' To> Ivl apa, eireiSr) ov8a/^.|j IOTIV, oirre ticrtov
ovrf diraAAa/cTfov oi!re fifTaXrjTrrfov
oixrias ovbafi&s.
ElKos. .Oiire apa diro'AAwai ro pr] ov ti> oUre yiyverai,
t-nttirfp oiSa/xrj juere'xei ova-fas Oi (paiVfTai. .(M8' Sp'
dAAoiowrai ov5a/xrj- rjSrj yap av yiyvoiro re /cal diroAAvoiro
TOVTO irdaxor 'AArjflTj. EJ 8e fxij dAAotoCrat, ovc
KtvtlffOcu,; 'Avdtyioj.Ov8^ /XTJK earaVat
6V TO yap loros ^i r$ avr^ TWI 8ei del flvai.
TTWS yap o{J; OvVto 8rj a5 TO fxrj 3v /ij}re TTOT^
fiijre xweia-dai Aeyatyiev Mr) yap oBi; __ 'AAAa
HT)V ov8' lari ye avr<p TI TUV 3vr<av ^8rj yap ii> TOI/TOV
/wrexov [O'ITOS] ovcrfas /ueT^x0'-' A^Xor.CKiTe 4po fi^yeflos
ovre o-^iKpor)s ovre Zo-rfrr/s avrfi !oru>. Ov ydp. Oi>8fc
y.i\v ofiotoTrjs ye ov8e erepoiorrjs ovVe wpos avr6 oi/re wpos
TaXAa d-q &v avry Ov tpaCvTai.~~T[ 8^; raXXa 10-0'
oircos ai elr; avrtp, d /xr;8ei' avry 8eT tlvai;Ov/c
Ovre Spa o/xoui ovre (ivo'/xoia ovre TOVTO oiid" ?repd
avr<j> ra aXAa.Ov y&p T( 8e"; TO eVefoov ^ TO
7J TO T\ Tj TO TOVTO Tf TO TOVTOV rf

SAAoV T) AA(d i/ WOT^ T)

03 ^ B : T
c8 eTvoiT: om. B
d2 fy Heindorf :
^ BT
64 tu> AO^KOI T: 4^oAaM3<"oi B
64 J7 41 BT:
ifl Jt? vulg.
e 5 T$ air^' B T (alteri tribuit B) : ri aM. al.
e 7 roi/Tou B : roGro T : rov al. Heindorf
a i iWor seclusi
roD iicToj Stallbaum
as yt B : T T ouS> T : ort B
a 4 rjAAo
r7/ T : iAAa ctn B

ITAPMENIAH2
rj vvv r) eTrior^/jiT] r) 8oa r) atcr&jcm r) Aoyos T/ b
ovop.a T/ aAAo oYtovy T<y OVTMV irepl TO prf ov Icrrai; OVK
i. OVTCO 8r) ey OVK 6V OVK e^ei ?ra)? ov8ap-T). OvKovy
ye
"En 877 Ae'y<oju,ey, ly ei /XT) eori, raAAa TI XP*) '7rc- 5
L Aeyco//ei> yop.^^AAXa /xey TTOV 8ei avra etrat*
ti yap fXT^Se aAXa terra?, OVK av irepl T>V &X\u>v Xeyotro.
Ovrco. Ei 8^ Trept rutv aAAcoy 6 Aoyos, ra ye aXXa erepd
ty OVK eTTt TW avrw KaXeis ro Te aXAo Kai TO
."Eycoye.^''Erepoi' be ye irov ^ajuey TO eVepoy ewat c
eTepou, /cat TO aAAo 8^ aAAo e>ai fiAAou; Nat.^'Kat TOIS
aAAois apa, ei jue'AAei aAAa eti'at, eo"T6 Ti ov aAAa eo-Tai. .
'AvayKrj.-.Tt 8^ oSi> az> etrj; TOU jaei^ yap ei>6s OVK ecrTat
aAAa, /x,^ oWo? ye. Ov yap.''AAA7]A<oz> apa eaT^1 TOVTO 5
yap avrots CTI AewreTai, rj ^bevos slvai aAAois. 'Op0c3s.
^KaTa TrA^rj apa e/caara dAAT^Aa)!; aAAa eorr icara %v
yap OVK ay ota Te fir], JU.T) o^Toy ei'os.
dAA' eKao-Tos, &>s
, 6 O-/KOS avr&v airetpo's eo-rt TrA^et, Kay TO o-/xtKpo'- d
SoKoiiy etyat Aa^Si] ris, axnrtp ovap tv VTTVW tpaivtrai
fa(<pvt]$ avri eyo? bo^avros eTvat TroAAa Kat ayrl <rfj.iKpoTOTOU 7ra/xju,eye0e? Trpos Ta KepfAaTi^o/^eya e^ avToi).-'Op0oraTa.'.ToiovTCoy 8rj oyKcoy aAAa dAA7)Acoy af eirj TaAAa, 5
ei eyos JUTJ o'yTos aAAa <rriv.- Kofxi8r) p.ey ow. .OvKow
'TroAAot oyKOt HcrovTai, ets eKacrros <pai,v6fj.i>os, (ov 8e ov,
ewrep z> ju,r) eo-Tat; OVTCO.'at dpt^/xos 8e eiyai O.VT&V
So'fei, etTrep Kai |y eKaorov, -TroAAfiy OVTMV. Ildyv ye.. e
Kai Ta fj*v brj apTta, Ta 8e -jreptTTa kv avrots ovra OVK
&s (j)a(v6Tai, eiirep ev /J,TJ eo-rat. .Ov yap ovy. Kat
/cat o-fitKpoTaTo'y ye, </)ajae'y, 8det ey avrois eyeiyatb 5 rt B : om. T
b 6 &\\a pey irov T : a\\a /JL^V vov B
ci '
T: om. B
c6^T:et'B
d 8 o0ra> T : om. B
e i 8<ft
T: $6fifv

63 Qalverai] (^ave'iTui Thomson

Heindorf: 5<{|iev B T

fVew-ai] ev ?i/at B : e?y<u T

e 4 5<$|et

IIAAT&NO2
5 <j)a[vTai 8e TOVTO TroXXa Kai /xeydXa irpbs ^KCLCTTOV
165 TroXXfiy a>s (r^iKpwv

oyrcoy.Hois 8' ov;Kat Icros

TOLS TroXXoi? Kat arfMKpois

d.

(KaffTos

#y/cos

etyar ov yap ay ju,ere/3atyey e/c fxei^byos1 eis eXarroy <patyd}j.vos, Trply eis TO p;erau 5oetey eA0ety, TOUTO 8' etrj ay
</>dyrao-p,a icrdrijros.^EtKo's.OVKOUI; Kai Trpos aA.Xoy oyKov
Tiepas tyu>v, avros ye irpos avrw ovre apyj]v ovrt Trepas
oure fxecrov <z\<&v;'111] 817;-"On del avrS>v orav TIS TI
Xa^3r; TTJ 8iai>ota (2s n rovrcoy ov, Trpo re TTJS d
det fyaivsrai apx^j jutera re TTJZ> TeXeDTTJy erepa u
reXeur?], ey re TW p.eo-<) aXXa /jiefrairepa roiS
repa 8e, 8ia TO fxr) 8i;ya(r0ai lyos avTaii' eK
veo-^at, are CWK oyros rou lyos..'AA.i70eoTara.8?) otjuat Kepjuan^o/xeyoz; drayKT] Tray ro ov, o ay rts A.a/3?)
r^ Stayoia.' oy/cos ydp TTOV &vev evbs del Aa/XjSdyotr' ay.^.
Haw jney ovv.OVKOVV TO ye Touwroy Troppco^ey /^ez;
op&VTi KCU afx^Xv ey <j)aiv<r6ai, dyayKrj, eyyvfler 8e Kat 6v
vooSyri irAijflei airetpoy |y eKao-roy <^>ay^yat, etrrep o-reperat
rou eyos p,^ OVTOS;.'AyayKaiorarov p,er ovy.^Ovra> 8^
&Tretp(i re Kat irepas exoyra Kat ly Kai iroAAa eKao-ra raAAa
8et (patyeo-0at, y et /x^ ecrTty, raAXa 8e roC eyo's.AeT
yap.OvKouy Kai O^OLOL re Kat avopoia 8o'^et etyat;-111)
877;'.Otoy eo-Ktaypa<^rjpteya aTrocrrdyrt p-ey ey irdyra
p.eya ravroy ^atyeo-^at TreTroyfleVai Kai o/xoia etyat.
ye.-ripoo-eX^oyri 8e ye TroXXa Kai erepa Kai rw rou erepou
^>ayrd(rp;art erepoia Kat dyopiota eavroTs.'Oirno.Kat
6ju,oious 8r) Kat dyop,otovs roi/s oyKors awovy re avrofe
dydyKT/ </>atyeo-0at Kai dXX?jXois.Ildyu piey oiiy.OvKovy
Kai TOVS avrovs Kai erepous dXX?7Xa>y, Kai aTrrop^eyous1 Kai
a aff/j.iKpoisT:ff/u/cpbsB
a 4 Soletev T : 8<Jeii/ B
a 6 'ye
Hermann: reBT
9.7 TtT: om. B
b 2 /teffaiTepa T:
f^effaiffpa
TctB
bs Se'T: om. B
b5S^B:SeT
b6 at'ei T : om. B
b 7 ir6pp<09fv lAfv B : voppatOtv T
C i ti> (paiveffOai b : e/x<f>aiVecr0ai
T pr. B
o|i ^ooD^Tt T: o|iWi/Ti B Procl. suppl.
c 5 8e? ^atVeo-flat
T: 8$} ^aii/eo-flat B
rSAAa corr. Ven. 189 : &\\a B : a\Aa T

HAPMENIAH2
eavrcoy, Kal Kivovpevovs Tt&cras Kty^o-eis Kal
rj, Kal yiyyojueVous1 KOI aTroXXv/ieVovs1 Kal
TTOV ra rotaCra, a 8teX0eu> eweres TJTJ ?7p.u>, ei eyos
rj OVTOS TToXXa e<rriy. 'AXrjfleVrara p,ez> ovy.
"En 8rj &jra eX0o'yre? TrdXiy em rrjy
ei ^,rj eori, raXXa 5e rot; evos, rt X
yap ovv. OVKOVV V fjiev OVK etrrat raXXa. TlSts yap;
Qvb* fj-rfv TroXXa ye' ev yap TroXXots ovcrt^ evetrj av Kai !z>. 5
ei yap //.rjSe^ avrSv eorty ei', a'Travra ovSev <TTIV, uxrre
oiitf ay -TToXXa eirj. 'AXrj^. M^ ezwros 8e evo? ey TOIS
#XXois, oUre TroXXa oiJre eV eon raXXa.'Ov yap. Oi8e
ye ^aiyerat |y ov8e TroXX<L ^Ti 817; -"On raXXa T>V pr) 166
TI rwz; /IAT) wrcoy -Trapa roiiy aXXcoy r<j> eo-rti'* ov8ey yap
^pos eorl ra?s ja^ ova-ii; 'AXrjfl^.^ Ovb' apa 8o^a TOV
/j.^ oifros Trapa TO?S SXXois early oi8e rt (pdyrao-jua, ov8e 5
8o^d^era6 ovSajw.?) oi8aju,ws ro \ii\ ov firl T>V aXXcov.'Ov
yap ovy. -*Ey apa et f/.^ eonr, ov8e 8oa{erat ri rwi/
aXXcov |y etyat ov8e TroXXa1 civev yap ez^os iroXXa 8o^a(rai b
. 'A8vyaroy yap. *Ez> apa ei p.^ eon, raXXa oure
ci<[erat ey oiiSe TroXXd. OVK e"oiK>. Ov8' apa
o/xoia oii8e avo^oia.-Ov ydip. Ov8e p.rjy T" O.VT& ye ov8'
^repa, ov8e airro^va ov8e \<apts, ov8e aXXa ocra ey rois Trpo- 5
cr0ei> StjjX^o/xez; a>s <f)aiv6fj.va avra, rovrcoy ovre ri eo-rty o!5re
</>au;erai raXXa, ev ei p:rj eVrip. .'AXrj^Tj.' OVKOW Kat
et etirotp.er, ly et JU-T) eo-rty, oiSeV eo-riy, 6pOG>s C
;^Uayrcnrao-i /xey ovy. Etp?](r0a) roivvv TOVTO
re Kal on, cos eoi/cey, ey e^r' ecrrty etre p.^ eoriy, avrd re Kal
raXXa Kal -Trpos avra Kal Trpos dXAr]Xa ?rayra Trayrtos eo-ri re
al OVK ecrrt Kal (pat'yerat re Kal ov (paiyerat. 'AXrj^eVrara. 5
d 7 ireJcrj; B : iravraxfi T
d 8 ^877 ^Ii/ B : ^jim/ ^81) T
62 ird\iv
B: om. T
63 Ta\\o B : SA.\a T
65 ^v(ij] !>/ eftj B : sftj T
as ouSc rt T: ou8' Irt B
a 6 eVl Schleiermacher : uirb BT
a 7 ouS^B: o^re T
b5 i\\a B : r2\Aa T

SiiKPATHS

IIP12TAPXO2

4>IAHB02

St. II
p. ii

212. "Opa by, n/)0)rapxe> T'iva hoyov pte'AAets Trapa 4>iA?7- a

/3ou bfyfcrdai. vvvl /cat Ttpbs rCva TOV Trap* JHUV ct/x,<icr/377reu>,
fav fJLri croi, Kara vovv y Aeyo/xeyos. /3oi;Aei crvyKe^aAatco- b
kaarepov;

u fj.v ovv.
212. <i>iX?j/3os /xev rolvvv ayaQov tlvai <j>t)(ri TO yjiLpeiv
7ra(rt ^({iots Kai T^y ^bovrjv KOL Tp\jfi,v, Kal ocra row yewuy 5
e<rri TOVTOV <rvfj.<f)a>va' TO be trap' fj^Stv d/x<j()ta-^3?;rrj/x,a eort
fi^ raura, dAA.a ro typovelv KO! TO voelv Kal fjLfpvfjcrdai, KOI
TO, TovTo>v av (ruyyez;^, $6av re opOrjv Kal ahrjOels Aoytcr/uovs,
T^S ye f]$ovf)s d/xeiyco xat Aaia) ytyyecr^ai a-vp-TTacrLV oo-airep
avrcSy 8wara )ueraAa/3erv 8warcus 8e /nerao-xew &)^>eAt/ji(>- C
rarov a.Tr&VTU>v flvai Tratrt TO?S ovcri re Kat (ro/u,e'vois.
o^x ovrco TTCO? Aeyojaei', S <l>tA?7/3e, eKarepot;
4>I. Ilayrcoy ju,ey ovy /xaAtora, S 2&>Kpares.
212. Aexj? 8r) rouroy roy yuy bibo^fvov, u>
Ao'yoy;
<I>tA?]/3os yap

a 2 i/uj/l B : yOy T
rbv Schleiermacher : TWV B T
vT
\3 7 fj.efjivriffQa.1 T : rji [J.tiJ.vricrQa.1. B

b i eAv B

nc

HAATiiNOS

2X1. Ae? bri nepi airStv rpoira) iravn rdXrj^es 1717 irepay10 07jyat;
d
nPH. Aa yap oSy.
2il. "Wi. 877, Trpos TOUTOIS SiojutoXoyrjo-cojae^a Kal ro'Se.
TIPI2. To Timor;
211. 'ils yw> ?7fjioi>y eicdrepos ety iffvyijs Kal biaOto-Lv
5 a.TTO<paCveiv nva eTitxetpT^a-ei r^y 8wap,eyr]y avOpvirois iracri
roy j3ioy ^8at/utoya Trape'xeiv. ap' o^x ovrcos;
HPIi. Otfrco fjtew OVP.
SU. OwKoSy fy/,ets fxei; TTJI; TOV xat/Peti; W^ 8' a! r^y
TOU
typovftv;
10
nPH. "Eo-Ti ravra.
2Ii. Ti 5' ay a\A.7j rts Kpetrrcoy TOVTMV tyavri; jawy OVK,
e ^y f*ey ^Soyfj /xaXXoy (pa^Tjrai o-vyyeyTjs, ^rrw/xe^a ,w^y
12 ? / o y r s roy rts
IIPfl. Nat'.
Sii. *Ay 8e ye ^)poy77<ret, yiKfi /xey <ppovr]<ns rrjv f)$ovr)v,
ff be ^rrarai; TaC0' ovrtos o/AoA-oyov^eva <pare, TJ
5
IlPii. 'Ejaol yowy SOKCI.
2H. Tt 8e 4>tA7]a); n
ITpci)rapxe> airo
IlPii. ITapaSoiJs, Si 4>iArj/3e, r]fuv TOV Xoyov OVK ay
10 lYi Kvpios ecr)? T^S irpos StoKparT] optoAoyias r; /cat TOVvavriov.
b
^1. 'AArj^ Aeyets1 dAAa yap d<^oo-touju,at Kat /maprvpo/xai
yuy avr^y r^y 0eo'y.
IlPIi. Kal finds (rot rovrcoy ye am&v (rvp-^aprvpfs av
, &>s ravra lAeyes a Aeyets. dAAa 8?) ra /u,era ravra
d 4 rtfj.Sov B : avruv T
e i ^Sovfj] r)5ov)i B T
a 3 76 B T: '.
om. al.
a 4 6fjto\oyov/jLeva. T : &/j.o\oyov(Ji(v & B
a 7 Se B : |
8' S T
a 9 <()i\r}^e T : ^>fxijj3os B
b 3 76 B T : om. vulg. i
b 4 ft/j.fv corr. Ven. 189: ^ev BT
j

4>IAHBO2

iab

rjs, oo ScoKjoares, cfyicos Kal /xera ^lAiy/Sov eKoWos TJ OTTGOS 5

efleAr/ Tretpw/xefla irepaiveiv.
2t. IIeipaTeoi>, air' ourr)? 8rj TT}? 0eoS, ??y o8e '
ai <p?jo-i, TO 8' dArj^eVraToy aiiTrJs ovo/xa
10

2t. To 8' e/iozj 8eos, > ITpwrap^e, det Trpos ra T&V dc&v
ovo/nara OIIK eon Kar' avOputirov, aXXa irtpa TOV
<j!)0/3ou.
Kat I'w TTJI> /lAey 'A^)po8trTjr, OTTTJ
ravry Trpoo-ayopevco* r^y 8e fjbovrjv oT8a ws ea-rt
/cat 6Vep et-TTOi;, aTr' eKeiyrjs ?7ju,as ap\ofj.vovs tvQvpziaQai 8et
Kal cr/coiTai/ T]VTiva <f>v(nv e'xei. eWt yap, CLKOVZLV fj&v omcas
dirA.<Ss, e'y rt, poppas 8e 8177701; ircuToias etXrj^e /cat rtra
rpoTjw avo^oiovs dXA.7]Aats.
i8e yap1 $8eo-0ai juey Rafter
Toy aKoAao-TatyoyTa avOpatirov, ijfacrOaL 8e xat Tor crdcxfrpoVOVVTCL avTai TO) (TaKppovf'lv' rl$crOai 8' aS Kat TW avorjraivovra Kat OVOYITMV boa>v KO! eA7rt8coy /ieo-Toy, ^'8eo-0at 8' av
TOI> (ppovovvra OVT& TO> <f>pove'iv Kat TOVTOO^ T<Sy fibov&v
WS av TIS 6/xotas dAA^Aats eT^at Aeycoy OVK dyorjTos
IlPii. Eio~i /xev yap aTr' evavriatv, w
y, oi> /^p avrai ye dAAijAat? kvavrLai.
r) ye f)bovri [/mrj] ov^( ojuotoTaToy av etrj, TOI)TO

TT&S yap

211. Kat yap x.pwju,a, 3> Satftofte, yjpw\i.a.Ti' Kara ye airo

TOUTO oi/8ey StotVet TO xpcojma ftz/at Tray, TO ye JU.T)Z; /xeAay
TW Aet;KW Tra^Tes ytyvwo-Kopiey ws Trpos TO> biatpopov elvai 5
Kal tvavTi&TaTov ov Tvy\avi.
KOI Srjf Kat

b 7 S); T : 5 B
06 ^x BT : ^X" G
.d
om. Galenus
d 2 8' oS T Alexander Aphrodisiensis : Se B
d 3 8' o5 B : 8' a5 al T
d. 4 <f>povovvra . . . (ppoveiv T : ff(a<$>povovvra.
. . . autypovelv B
d 8 adrai T : aSraf B
e i ^Sor?; 76 ^8ov^
scrips! : ySovliv 76 ^80^ B : ^Sovir/ 76 ^Soj/^ T
^ seel. Badham
TOUTO aurb] ri 7' ovrb ci. Stallbaum
6 3 xpA/jLan B T : ^pdsp.a.Tos
al. Ast
e 4 oii0j' T
Trav B T : rb way vulg. Galeuus

we

IIAATHNO2

Kara ravrov yeVei \iiv earn Trav Zv, ra 8e /xep?j roTs p.e'pe<m>
13 avrov TO. (j,ev fvavTKarara aXXr^Xots, ra 8e 8ia<popdrT]r'
TTOV ruyxayei, Kal TroXXa erepa ovrcos c^ov
wcrre TOVTW ye TW Xdyw JATJ morreue, ra> udura ra
y TroioCyri. q[)Oj8o{5/iat 8e ju,^ rivets
5 7780^01? evpTjfrof/.ei' erazmas.
TIPIl. "lo-ws- aXA.a rt roufl' 77/1x0)^ jSXax^ei roy
2,0,. "Ort Trpoo-ayopeveis avra dyojaota ovra
(rofj,fv, dyojuart* Xeyets yap dya^a Travr' etyat ra 77ea. ro
/utey o^y jurj ov^l r)5ea eT^at ra TjSea Xoyos ovSets aii$i(r{$T}Tt'if
b KaKa 8' oi^ra avratv ra iroXXa Kal dya^a 8e, a>s 77/xets
o^cos iravra <ri Trpocrayopeueis dya^a aiira, 6/j,oXoywy
etuai, rw \oya> et ris ere. 7rpoowayKaoi. Tt oSv 5^
cv rais KaKats ojmotcos at ey dya^ats ei^oi; Trdcras
5 dya^oy etyai Trpoo-ayope^eis;
IlPii. IIws Xeyets, a> SwKpares; otet yap
<re(T0at, Oepevov f]bovr)V et^at rayadov, etra
C Xeyovros ra? juez> ei^ai rwas dya^as 7780^01?, ras 8e
erepa? avrcSv ica/cds;
2H. 'AXX' ovy dyojmoious ye <p?j(reis a^ras dXXtjXais
/cat rivas eyayrias.
5
IIPI1. Own, Ka^' oo'oi' ye fjbovai.
2fi. ndXw; eis roy a'&roi' (/>epO]u,e0a Xoyov, S
ov6' apa TjSoyrjv 7780^775 bia<j>opov, dXXa irdcras ojmoiay et^ai
</)77<roju,ei', Kal ra irapaSeiy/xara ^/u,a? ra
ouSei> rirpcoo-Ket, Treio-o/xe^a 8e Kat epoC/xev aTrep ot
d c/xxuXorarot re /cat -Trepl Xoyovs a/xa veoi.
IlPil. Ta Trota 8rj Xeyets;
ft 5 efipficroft fvavrlas B : vp-f)(ro/j.fv fravrtcus pr. T
a 6 ^/u.iv
B T : rjfjLiv vulg.
a 9 ouxl T : oux B
b 2 S^tws] 6/uoio>s Hermann
TrcJj'Tct T : om. B
(fev) aj/({juoia Hermann
b 3 irpotfafa7K(^ci Jackson
b 4 ej/bi'] evopav Thompson : tvvoiav Apelt
C T ^8oi/as B T : om. al.
07 ijSov^v T G: ^8oj/fy B
?/at B T :,
om. G
c 8 T& vvv S); B : S^ ra vvv T
09 ouScc rt rp<bfffi
Jackson
Vfnr6pf6a Badham : ireip6nf6a. B : irpatrd^e0a T

4>IAHBO2
212. "On <re fxtjuovjueyos eyco Kai afj,vv6p.vos eav roA/u.<5
ais TO avopoioTaTOV eon ra> dw/xoiorara) TTCIITCOZ;
Ojuotorarov, ea> ra avra erot Aeyetr, Kat <pavovp.f6a ye.
VftoTfpot, TOV beovTos, Kal 6 Aoyos Ty/x^y eKTiccrwv olyjjcrtTai.
itaXiv ovv avTov avaKpovatfjifOa, kal TCC av lovres els ras
o/xoias itrcos av TTCOS dAA?jAots crvyx^p^o-at/jiei'.
IIPI1. Aeye -jrcSs;
212. 'E/^e 6es VTTO <rov TraXiv epcarfa^fvov, & Hp&Tapxf'
HPii. To irolov by;
2H. <$>povr)(rCs re Kat eTUOT^jurj Kai rous Kai Tray^' oTTdVa
8^ Kar' ap\as eya> Qipevos fiTrov ayadcL, Stepcorcojueyo? OTC
JTOT' ecrrty ayaOov, ap ov TCLVTOV ireicroyrat rouro oirep 6 trbs
Aoyos;
HPli. Hfis;
212. HoAAai re at (rvya'Trao-at emoTTj/Aat b6ov<riv fivai.
KOL dyojuotot rives avr&v dAA^Aais- ei 8e Kat fvavriai TTTJ
yiyvovrai Tives, apa a^tos av et^y TOV 8iaAeyecr0ai z/Cr, et

10
14

yiyvecrOai, KaTret^' ?7/uy ovrcos 6 Aoyos axrirep

fjLvOos aTroAo/xe^os 0^01x0, avrot 8e o-<pbi//,e#a e?rt rtvo?
dAoyta?;
5
IlPil. 'AAA' ov ^y 8et rovro yevecrOai, TiXrjv TOV (ratOrjvai.
TO ye jutT^z; fxot ttrov row o-ou re Kat e/xoC Aoyou dpecrKei*
woAAat juev ^8oj;at Kai drojixotot yi.yvecr6u>v, TroAAat 8e
ai 8id^>O|OOt.
rotuw 8ta^>oporrjra, S> IIjO(i)rapxeJ [TOU ayaflou] b
rou r' ejotov Kat row trou /x^ airoKpVTTTOfjLfvot, KaTartfleWes 8e
ets TO fjLecrov, ToXfjiStfjifv, av Trrj
d6 ^r^ (Kirfffttjv B : eOTreffii/ ^yur^ T
d 7 &j/ lovres Ven. 189:
ayjoVres B T
6 5 a7aOd B T : a.ya06v per errorem Bekker
6 6 terrl? a-ya^or B : cirri rd^aOov T
e 10 avopoioi T : avopoiai B
ft 2 JK)) 8e ^iiaj/ B : /it)S^ /uiav T
ai>6/j.oiov B T : &^ UVO/JLOIOV vulg.
a 3 otrrcus B : OUTOS T
a 6 5e? T G : Setv B
a 8 yt
ylyvf<rOov B T
b i roS ayadov seclusi auctore Bury
b3
6 0
B T : tKeofjLtvw Grouius : eA.ex^M '' " Stallbaum

i4 b

HAAT&NO2

rayadbv Set Ae'yety TJ ^pdyrjcriy 77 u rpiroy aAAo eTyai.

5 vvv yap ov STJTTOU Trpos ye avrb TOVTO (ptAoytKoCpvey, OTTWS
ayo> Tt0ejmat, raw' lorat ra yiKwyra, TJ rav0' a (rv, r(S 8'
dArjfleardra) 8e? TTOU a-v^a^lv rjpJas a/x^)co.
IlPflt. Aet yap ow.
C
212. Touroy TOLVVV rov \oyov en /xaXAoy 81* 6/xoAoyias
HPii. Tw Troioy 677;
SH. Toy iratrt Trapf\ovTa ay0pw7rois irpayjutara eKoucri re
5 /cat aKoucriy ertots Kat eyiore.
IlPIi. Aeye o-a^eorepoy.
2Ii. Toy yuySrj TrapaTreo-dyra A.eya>, ^>wet TTOOS irefyvKora
ey yap 87) ra iroAAa etyat Kai ro ly iroAAa
Ae^e'y, Kat paStoy a/x^)to-j3rjTrjcrat rw TOTJrcoy
to oirorepoyouy ri^ep-eyco.
I1PI1. *Ap' ovy Aeyets oray ris e/xe (pr) ITpcoTap^oy eya
d yeyoydra ^>i;crei TroAAov? etyat iraAty TOVS Ijute /cat eyayrtous
dAATjAots, //.eyay Kat (TjuuKpoy rt^efxeyos1 Kat /Sapvy Kal KOTJ^O^
Toy avroy Kat aAAa
5 0aujuao"r<Sy irept ro ey Kat TroAAa, crvyKe^prj^va 8e ws eiros
etTTety wo Trdyrcoy ^TJ p,?) 8e?y rwy roiowrcoy
iratSapiwSrj Kat pa8ta Kat o-(|)o8pa rois Ao'yot?
ij7roAap;/3aydyra)y yiyvtcrdai, eiret p;Tj8e ra rotate, oray ris
e eKao-rou ra p.eA?j re Kat ap,a p,epr] 8teAa>y ra> Adyw, Trdyra
raCra ro ly eKeiyo eTyat StopvoAoyrjo-aju.eyos', eAeyx^] KarayeAwy on re'para 8i7]ydyKa<rrat (payat, ro re ly a>s iroAAa eo-rt
Kat aTretpa, Kai ra TroAAa ws ty p,dyoy.
5
ITPH. 2v 8e 8r; Trota, a> SwKpares, erepa Aeyets, & /XTJTTCO
8e877f/,evrat Trept roy avroy rovroy Adyoy;
b 4 rt T : om. B
b 5 TOWTO corr. Coisl. : TOVTO & B T
i-yw B : ft 'yk T
b 7 SeT B : 5^ pr. T G
eg a/x(i<r/37)T7)crcu
B : & oju^)tcrj37jT7/(rat T
d 2 Tiflt^tecos B : T0ejuei/ous T
e i S^ua
B T : SAXa Badham

4>IAHBO2
212. 'OTroVay, a> irai, TO ti> /XT) rwv yiyvopzvwv re Kal 15
rts ri^rai, Kadairep dpTicos ^j
yap Kal TO ToioCrov ev, oTrep ei7rop,ez>
^ eAeyxew 6Yaz>
?) TiOffrdai KOL fiovv f-va Kal TO KaXor ly /ecu TO ayaBov 5
, Ttepl TovTcoy Twy eydScoy (cat rS>v TOIOVTOOV rj
rouS^ /ueTa Staipeo-etos d/A^
. IIpwToy /xey ef rtyas 8ei TotavTas eti^at
aA.r)6&$ o^o-as- e?Ta TTWS aw
ovcrav del T^y avTrjy Kal /IXIJTC yeve(riv ju,?]Te
au Kat cnreipois etTe Siecrira- 5
o-juevrjy Kal iroXAa yeyownay Oereov, eW oArjy aiiT^y avr^s
\a>pCs, o br] Tr&VTUtv abvvaT&Tarov (paivoi.f'
v a/xa ey eyt Te Kat TroAAois yiyvcvOai.

av, ravTov Kal

ravr* IO-TI Ta

Trepl Ta TotauTa ey Kal TroAXd, dAA' OIK fKflva, IIp^Tapx^j

airdoTjs diropias atTia p,^ Ka\5? 6/xoAoyr;^ez/Ta Kal euTroptas
r* i
\ ^
[ayj av KaAws.

IlPIi. OvKouy xP^? fov6J fjjMs, 2> Sw/cpaTes, ey T<S vw

-np&rov
faaTTOvrjo-aa-Oai.;
5
2Ii. 'Us yow eycb (^airjv av.
I1PI1. Kal ird^Tas Tot^uy rj/xas VTroXafte <rvyx<Ji>piv o-ot
Ta TOiauTa- 4>iX>7/3oy 8' to-coy KpaTiaroi> ev T y{)y
2fi. ETezr Tr66fV ovv TIS Tavrrjs ap^rjTat 7roAA.?7S
l Ttavrotas Trepl TO. dp.^)torj8TjTOV]aei'a jj.d\rjs; ap'
y TTOU ravrov v Kal TroAXa VTTO Aoycoy yiyyoa 3 vG/ 5)j T : yDj/ Seti/ B
a 7 o-TrouS)) seel. Badham :
R. G. Bury : irow S)j J. B. Bury : irov fjSii Apelt
b 4 post irpoo-'SfXonevriv lacunam statuit Hoffmann
o/xws] o\<as Badham : fortes
Susemihl /itov] fort, ^cv Zeller
c 3 &v seel. Badham
c 4 -rovff
B : irou rovff T
d I oSy B : oSi/ Sv T
da tj/OevSe iroOev
Socrati tribuunt BT
d 4 irov B T : irot vulg.

15 d

IIAATilNOS

5 fj.fva Tre/Hrpe'xeiv iravrrf naff <-Kacrrov T&V Xeyo/ieVa>i> dei,

Kal Tra\ai Kal vvv. /cat TOUTO ovre JU.TJ TratJtrTjrai Trore ovre
Tjpfaro vvv, dXX* Itrrt ro roiouroi>, as e/^ot (patverat, rah;
)y avroSv aOavarov rt Kal ayripatv TrdOos ev f/iMV 6 8e
avrov yewafxevos eKao-rore TcSy vccov, fjcrOfls &s
^ias rjvpr]K(as 6r](ravp6v, v^>' ^8ovrjs -ty^ouo-ta Te /cm
Xoyoi> &cr^,evos, Tore ju,ez> eirl Qarepa
f l s Hv, rore 5e irdXty dyeiXirTcov Kal
eis airopCav avrbv ptv TTpStrov Kal /AaXiora
5 Se^repoi; 8' act TOZ> fxppevov, avre vetarepos Syre
^ire ^Xi a>v Tvyx^Jjj <pib6[ji,evos ovre irarpos
16 cure aXXou T&V aKovovrutv ovbevos, oXtyou Se Kat T>V aXXcoy
^o toy, ov juoVoy rcSy avdptoirav, eirel J3apf3dpa>v ye ovSeyos
ay </>et(rairo, ewrep p-ovov epjurjyea Tro^ez/ ^XotHP!},. 'Ap', & StoKpaTes, o^x opas ^jaciii' ro irA^os, Srt
5 veoi Tra^res k<r^v, Kal ov ^>o/3rj ^17 (rot jutera <I>iX7]/3ov
(rvveiridtoiJifOa, tav rmas XotSoprjs; ojaoos 8e pavOavoiAzv yap
6 Xeyetj, et rts rpoTros lo-rt Kat ^\avr] rrjy /^,e^ roiavrrjy
rapaxjiv r^M.v e^co roC Xoyou ev/xeyfi? TTCO? aTreX^er^, 686y 8e
b rtua KaXXtco ravrrjs eirt roi> Xoyoy avevpttv, a~u re Trpo6vjj,ov
TOVTO Kal ^615 (TuyaKoXoD^crojbiey ets bvvajjuv oil yap
6 irapcby Xoyos, S^Kpares.
Sli. Ov yap ouy, S iraTSes, ws ^rjcrty vjoias Trpoaayo4>iXTj/3os. ov /i^i; iVn /caXAttoy 68os ov8' av yevoiro
^s eya> epao-TTjs fxev et/ut det, TroXXaKts 8e f*e 77817
yovtra eprj/xov Kal cnropov Kareo-rrjcrez;.
IIPH. Tts aClr?]; Xeyr0a> povov.
SH. *Hy 8rjX<3o-at |uey ov
eTroy iravra yap 6Va
8ia ravrrjs (pavtpa yeyore. o-K07ret 8e ^v Xey&>.
d 7 e<m T : eirl B
d 8 Hyqpuv (sic) B
6 3 avti\irr<av B :
eX/TTWv T
a s ju(J/ov epfjujvea B T : epfj.7)vea p&vov vulg.
b 5 ytvoiro B : '/(yj/otro T
b 6 ^s] (if)} ^j Madvig
C i XP*J~
trOot T : x^^w* B
C 2 aveved B : &v eueO?} T

4>IAHBO2

i6c

ITPIi. Ae'ye povov.

Sli. e<3zj fj.ev ets avOpdirovs bdcris, &s ye Karacpatverat 5
e/uoi, 7ro0h> ex 0e<Sz; tpptyil ^ TWOS ITpo/z7}0ecos ajua
<az>oraY<j> run -Trvpi- xal ot /xey naXai.oi, Kpetrroyes ^/xwy
KOI eyyurepco #e<3z> otKOW>re9, Tavrrjv <prnj,riv -napebocrav,
a>s e f^os /uez> Kat 7roAA<3z> ovratv rStv det
irepas 8e Kai aireipiav zv avrofs crv[j.<pvTOv t
ovy ?7juas TOVTCOV OVTCO StaKeKoo-jurj/ueya)!; del ju,tay t8ea^ Trept
navTos Ixao-rore df/Aevovs r)Tiv (vpria-eiv yap evovarav
eav ovv yL*eraAa^3a)ju,ev, /xera /itay 8^0, et ira)? etcri,
el be fJii^, rpei? ^ TWO. aAAor apL0p.6v, KCU rS>v iz> e/
enacrrov iraXti; aral;Ta)s, jute^piTTtp &y TO xar' ap^as ez> p^ 5
OTI ey Kat TroAAa KOI airetpd eart p,6vov 1877 rts, dAAa Kat
oTjwra' r^y 8e rou aireipov i8eaz> Trpos ro irA-^^os p,^ Trpotr<f>fptv Trplv av TLS TOV dptfyxoz/ avroS Trcif ra Kart8rj ror
TOU aireCpov re Kat rov ez;o9, rore 8' ^877 ro ey 6
T&V TrdvTutv eis TO a^etpo^ p,e0>ra \aipLV eav.
oi /xey oSz> ^eot, oirep eliroi', oi;ra)s ^//,?2; 7rape8oo-ai'
Kat JLav6<ivfLV /cat 8i8cicrKeii> dAA?7Aous' ot 8e
<TO(f>ol

V JJLV,, OTTCOS ^V rVX^O-l, Ktt TToAXa OaTTOV

IJ

fipabvTfpov TTOtouo-t roii Seoyros, jixera 8e ro ey airetpa

a 8e /ueo-a avrovs eK^)et;yet ots
rdAty Kal ro epto-riKwy r}/xas Troieio-^at Trpo?
rows Ao'yovs.
5
ITPil. Ta /xer mos, ai 2ci)Kpare?, SOKW o-ou pavdavfiv,
ra 8e ert tra^eo-repoy Seojuai a Aeyets aKoi;crat.
212. 2a<pes ju?7y, S n/acorapxe, ecrrty ez> rots ypd/xC 7 <j>avordr(f> T (sed o in ras.x' : <f>avcardry B
Kpeirroves (#i/Tes)
Badham
c 8 ^>^^M;V B : (/J^JUTJ T
c 9 /col T : ai ^/c B
d a VjTeiV T : ^rjTwy B
ivovarav T : l/oi3(raj' B
d 3 /teraXe(j8w/iei' B T : Ka,Ta\a.l3ci>p.ev Stephanus : XajSw/tey Badham
d 4 ti/
^K^I/CO'] / fKelvtf Ast
d 7 irpo(T<f>epeiv T b : irpotyepeiv B
e i S*
ijSij T : 8^j Se? B
a i /cal iroXAi seel olim Stallbaum : T& iroA\A
Dindorf
a 2 ftpaS^rfpov^ /3pa.xvr*poi> Badham
ri>] rcfc Jackson
a 4 epiffriKus T : opiffriK&s B
a 7 (rcupea-Tepov Seo/nai B : SGO/JLCU
tfutyeffTepov T
a 8 ypdfifiaffiv
B : ypd/j.fj.affiv T : vpAynacriv G
PLATO, VOL. II.

17a

IIAATGNO2
o Xeyw, Kal \dpftav

avr6 Iv rot/rots ot<rwep

DPil. ILSs;
er jj/tuy iarl -nov pta 8ia
o3 7r\)j0ei, irdz>ra>i> rf Kal
5
nPI2. Ttfxjjz;;
2ii. Kal ovbev Irtpo) ye TOVTCOI' tvii.iv Ttut (ro<f>oi, ovre
on TO &Tifipov avrijs la-fj.ev ovt)' ort TO ev aAA' ort iroVa
T' eorl Kal oiroia, TOUTO eori TO ypa^iMTinbv (KO.<TTOV
iroiovv
10
n
211. Kal /iTJr Kal TO povaiKov 6 Tvyx^"t woiow, TOT'
TOVTOV.

2ii. <i>wi^ /ieV irov KOI r6 icar" fKfbn]v

Ilia ev avrrj.

TTJV

IlPii. n&s 5' otJ;

2ii. At;o 8^ O&IKV fiapu Kal o6, Kal rpirov OIMTOVOV.
i y TI&S;
nPIi. Ovraiy.
2ii. 'A\X' ovira) o-o<os ar tlTjy T^V ^ovartK^r {8a>s
raCra fn&va, pr) 8^ f8a>s <5s v' liros ciircw fls TaCra
10

FIPJ2. Oi yap oSv.

2ft. 'AAA', at 0i\(, lirtiSav Ad/3;s TO dtaonj^iara
^irrl rov apiBfjiov r^s (pwinjs 3^vrjT(5s re Wpi Kal )3api/T/Toj,
d xal owota, Kal TOVS Spons raif 8ta<rTrj/xdTwr, Kal Ta ^K rovTcor otra (rvoTTjjiiaTa ylyovtv & Kart8oVrs ol itp6<rdtv trap(bovav riplv rots tTioyiivois luttvois KO\dv aira lipfj.ovia';,
Iv Tf raiy Kurf\<rt(r<.v av TOV trafjuiTos ?Tpa ToiaOra Iv6vra
b 3 r),uu< T : om. B
b 4 feropoi B : larttpovt T
T : oiit' Ir B
C i /ta! ri, T : om. B : xal Hermann
B T : om. G
J> .(Jis B : (Jii Si T

b 6 aiiic
O B fdva

TrdOrj ytyz>o/u,ez>a, a by 81' apiO^&v f/,erpi]$eVra 8eu> av <pa.(ri 5

pvdfJiovs Kal //.erpa enwojua^etzJ, Kal a/xa evvoe'iv a>s ovrco
8ei irept irayros evbs KOI TtoXX&v cr/coireiz; orav yap avrd
TC Ad/Sr;? OVTOO, rare eyeVou <ro<p6$, orav re aAAo rwi' If 6
6uoSz> ravTrj a-KOTrovjjLevos eXr/s, ovrto? Ifi^pcoy irept roiiro
' ro 8' cnreipov <T eKcxcrrfoz; Kai ev eK(i(rrots 7rA.^^os
K<i<rTOT TTote? row (frpovflv Kal ovK eAAoyifxoy 0118'
, ar OVK ets apiB^ov ovbeva h ovbevl TT&TTOTC 5
. KaAAiora, a> <&{\r)pe, ljuotye ra y
4>I. Ka/uoi ravrd ye avrci' dAAa rt 877 Trore TT/)OS ^ju,as 6 18
Aoyos OVTOS yw et/or/rcu xat rt Trore
2H. 'Op6G>s
IT<iz>u /xey oSv, Kal airoKpivov ye cwr<S.
ravra 8ieA^a>z; o-jmi/cpoy ert Trept
axnrzp yap ey ortoSv e? rts Trore Aci/3oi, roSroy, cos
, OVK. eir' aTretpov <pv<nv 8e? fiXtirziv fvOvs dAA' eTTt
api$iJi6v, OVTM KCU TO fvavriov orav TIS TO a-ntipov
avayKao-0rj Trp&rov Aa//,/3oyeii>, ja^ eTrt ro er evOvs, dAA' [eir'] b
api0fj.bv av nva TtX.f]6os e/cao-roy e^ovra rt Karavodv, reAeuray re e* Trdyrcor eis eV. TrdAiy 8e ey ro?y ypa/ix/uao-t ro

S12. 'ETretS^ (ptovrjv cnttipov Karerorja-ey etre ris

etre /cat 0eto? av9po)TroS' -co? Ao'yos ev AtytJirrcj)
d.5 T(0Tj] ju.^??s Poste
oS B : aurA T
d.6fivBfjiobsT: opiffMois B
afia. T :' ^AAa B
d 7 aura pr. T G . Tavrct B t
e i grew
re B : grav 8 T
li/ B : gj/Twi' T : 'OVTWV Ij/ Wohlrab
e 2 eAps]
^?)s Adam
TOVTO T : roiircav B
64 ouS' eva.pi0fji.oy T : ovSei''
dpifljitjij/ B
a i Ka/iol Badham : Kal /j.ol B : Kal e/tol T
as rovO'
T : To50' B
a 7 e? T : ev e? B
a 8 ^uo-ti/ Set B T : Set ^(riv
vulg.
b I rJ> If B T : TCI. / G
eV seel. Liebhold
b 2 /cara"0?i/] Kara vovv Apelt
b 7 6evG T :fle^OB : in G lacuna

FIAAT&NOS

TOVTOV yeyeVflat Xeycoy, 6s Trpwros ret c^coyijeyra tv r<5

aTreipa) Karei>OT]<rei> o^x. ty oyra dXXa TrXetco, Kat TrdXtv
C erepa <p(avfjs /xey ov, <f)06yyov 8e
8e rtya Kat rovrcoy etyai, rpirov
orrjcraro ra i>{5v Xeyo/^eva a^coya ^ju,tv ro /utera rouro
rci re a<p6oyya Kat frffxava jU^XP1 ^^s eKaorou, Kat ra
5 eira Kat ra jtxecra Kara row avroy Tpowov, eW dpi0ju,oy
Xa^3a)y evt re eKacmp Kat crtJ/onrao-i
KaOoputv 5e <ws ouSels rj/zcoz; 0118' ay ey avro Ka0' avro
Trdyrooi; avrwy pciOoi, TOVTOV TOV 8eo-/jioy aS Aoyicra^ievos ws
d wra ^ya Kat irdyra raSra ev TTCOS TTOIOVVTO. jj,iav CTT' atirots
W9 ovcrav ypa^aTiK^v Ttyyr}v eTre^^e'y^aro Trpoo-enrwy.
!. TaSr' ert o-a<pe<rrejOoi' e/cetvcoy a^rct ye Trpos aXArjA.a,
aj Ilp<rirap)(e> fpaOov TO 8' avro jutot row Xoyov vCy re Kat
5 (r/jttKpoy e/x.7rpocr^ey eXXetirerat.
Sii. Mfiy, S 4>t'X?]|3e, ro rt Trpos I-TTOS au raur' e<rrti>;
4>I. Nat, rour' larty o TrdXat {VjroC/xey ey<^ re Kai

H /x^y eV aiirw ye ^8rj yeyoyores (rjretre, ws

Sil. *Ap' ou irept <ppoytj(rea)? ^y Kat

6 Xoyos, oirorepoz; atirotv atpereoy;
5
4>I. Floi)? yap ov;
SI1. Kat /uiTjy e'y ye eK(irepoy avroty etyat c|)a/xey.
4>I. ITdyi) fjtey oiiy.
SH. Tour' avro TOIVVV ^as 6 Ttpoa-Ozv Xoyos airairet,
TTWS earty ly Kat TroXXa ai>r<Sy eKarepoy, Kat TTWS ju,^ cnreipa
IQ eii^v?, dXXd rtya irore apiO^ov eKarepoy e/x7rpoo-0ey KeKrrjrat
row a-Tretpa avrwy eKacrra yeyoye'yat;
b 8 &s T : &j B
C 5 apiQ/uibv aiiruv B T : auTwi/ dpiO/tb)/ vulg.
C 8 TOVTOV B T : TOVTOV 8e G
d I ir^i/rct ret ravra B : raura irdi'Ta T
d. 4 re T : 76 B
d 9 ^i)TtT B : ^^rjTeTre T
a 2 ourrov T :

avrbv B

4>IAHBOS

19 a

. OVK f l s (fiavXov ye epwTTj/xa, a> 4>iArj/3e, OVK 018'

TpOTrov KUKAa> TTcos '7reptayaya>i' ?yjuas e/x/Se'/SArjKe
KCU o-KOTrei 8rj TroVepos ^/xwy cnroKpivflrai TO 5
i/. urcos 8r) yeAotou TO e/xe TOV Aoyou 8taSoxou TravTeAak VTiocrTavTa 8ta ro /^.r/ bvva<rdai. TO vvv
pu>Tr)6\v aTTOKpivacrOai (rot waXiv TOVTO TrpocrTaTTfLv yeXoio'Tfpov 8' otjtxai TroAi; ro fj,r]eTfpov fifAatv bvva&Oai.
8rj ri bpcLo-o^fv.
et8r; ydp /uio6 Sofcei ySv epcorar
ScoKpaTTjs etre IOTIJ; etre /niy, /cat OTroVa eort Kat
r av (ppovYja-fcas Trept Kara ravra axravrcos.
H. 'AATj^eo-rara Aeyet?, Trai KaAAiov jar) yap bvv&- 5
rovro Kara TTCLVTOS tvbs KCU o/utoiou /ca! ravrou Spaz;
i rou fvavTiov, a>s 6 TTapckOu>v Aoyos k^vvy^v, ovSets ets
I1PI1. 2)(e8o2; eoiKfv ovrcos, S SwKpares, ^\iv. aAAa c
TO <rvp.TTavTa ytyycoo-Ketr TW (rc><ppozn, 8evTepos
8' elvat TrAovs SOKCI /XT) Aay^aveiy avTov avTov. TL 877 ju,ot
TOUTO etprjTat Ta yw; eyco (rot (f>pacru>.
&v T7]y8e Ty/xly T^y
crvvovtriav, a> 2coKpaTes, CTreScoKa? Trao-t <cat o-eavTW -Trpos 5
TO 8teAeo-0at TI rSy avdpunrivuiv KTrj/xaTcoy apicrrov.
<&i\r)j8ou yap etiroyTO? rjbovriv Kal Teptytv KOL \apav Kal rnkv&>
oirocra TOtaST* ecrTi, crv irpbs avra aVTeiTtes ws ov Tairra
aAA' cKelva fcmv a TroAAci/as TI/JMS avTovs
, 6p6G>S

$p>VTS,

tv

[i.VT}\M]

t. fyfjs 8', &>s eotKe, o-v TO 7rpoo-pi]0?7crojuiez;oi>

opO&s apfivov ybovrjs ye aya#oz; eZi'ai yow, eTrto-TT^jur/y,
(n;ye(riy, T^vr]v KOL -navTa av ra TOVTUIV crvyyevij, (&) KTatrOai 5
ety aAA' ov^t eKeiz/a. TOVTOOV 8r) JU.CT' ap:(pi(r/3?]T77o-e6i)S
e^ei'Ttoy 77p,eis <roi fxera 7rat8tas r}'7retA?jo"aju,ei'
OVK acpTjcro/iey o^Ka8e o-e Trpiy az/ TO^TCOZ; Twy Aoycoy e
b 2 ^Sovf)? T : ^Soi'^j' B
C i ^etj' B T : oSrcos ^XeH/ ^*
63 aurbi/ aur^c T: auT^v B : aurjy Hermann
d.5 & Ven. 189 :
om. B T
d 6 SeTi/ B : Se? T
d/i^KrjSijT^trews B : ajt</
(rewj/ T
d 7 iratSms T : TroiSetos pr. B

ig e

5
SO

b
:

HAATiiNOS
wepas iKavov yewjrai n biopi(r6evTtav, (ri) 8e <rvvr)(<apr)<ras Kal
I8a>/ca? tls Tav0' f)jjM> travrov, Tjp-eiy be 8r) \e'yo/xei>, KaOdirep
ol iraibes, on T&V 6p6&s boOevTtav a(palpe<ns OVK !<m- Trava-at
8jj roz> TpoTrov fiiuv aTtavT&v TOVTOV em ra i>Cz> A.eyop.ez>a.
Sli. Tu>a \fytis;
ITPii. EJs ajioplav e/n/3aAA.<oi> /cat avfpcaT&v &v ^ bvvaipfff av iKavr\v airoKpuriv ev T& Trapovri bibovai croi. fir)
yap ola>fj.e6a Te\os THUV eivai T&V vvv T^V -navriav f]p,&v
cmopCav, dAA.' el bpav ToC0' filets abvva.ToviJ.fV, <roi bpcurTfov
vveoyov yap. /3ovA.wv 8r) irpos raCra avros iiorepov fibovrjs
elbrj <roi Kal ^TrurrTjp-rjs biaipfTeov rj Kal eaTeov, ei irj/ Kaff
$Tepov Tiva Tpoirov olos T ei nal /3ov\ei SjjAwtra^ irias oAAaiy
ra rCv an^.(rftr\TOv\i:eva Trap' ^jiu'.
2ii. Aetroj' jj.ev TOIVVV ITL irpo<rboKav ovbev bei TOV (pe,
(TTfibri Tovd' ovr<as elms' TO yap el /SovAei pr)0ev \vet irAvra
tfiojBov fK<i<rT<ov Tttpi.
irpbs bf av rois /w'Tj/onji' TWO, boxei
rls y.oi 8f8ajVat deuiv iip.iv.
IlPIi. I15s 8^ Kal rlvunv;
Sil. Adycov ITOT^ TIVCOV TraAat aKov&as Svap fj Kal
iypTjyopobs vvv ivvo& ttepi re Tfbovrjs Kal <ppovricrf<as, is
ovbfTtpov avToiv fart, T&yaOdv, d\A.a aA.Ao rt Tptrov, tTtpov
Tovriav, &fj.fLvov b^ afi<j>oiv.
icafrot roCro ye ai> ^vap<f>avf) vvv, dTrrfXAaxrat fxer fjbovr) TOV VIKO.V TO
yap ayadov OVK av In TOVTOV avrrj ylyvovro. r\ TI&S;
OPIl. Ovrias.
2H. T&v b ye els TTJV bia(peira> elb&v f/bovrjs ovbev In
7rpo<r8eTj(ro'p.e0a KOT' epjz; 8o'ar. -npo'iov 8' In o-a

e 2 Si T : Si; B
65 inravrav TOVTOV B : oWcTcor Toinwv pr. T G
a 4 dAA' / T : 4\A), B
b I Sei riyl Stiroi' B T
b 3 a? TOIJ B :
auTois T (a? TodTois t)
b 8 &rrl Ta.yaH6v B : ^irrlv iyaBov T
TI
B t : om. pr. T
b 9 Kairoi ToBr<{ ^e ii/ Badham : /col TOIOUT<( 75 Sv
2
B : Ka( TOI O&TU ye &>/ in marg. B : Kairoi TOVTO iia> T
c a yiyvoi.ro
B : 71-yytrai T G : j./7>/7)Tai vulg.
c 5 ?rpoi!' B T : irpoi&v (et mox
!e({ i A^os) vulg. : TrpaUrri Badham

4>IAHBO2

aoc

IIPO. KdXXior' fliriov oHma KOI SiaWpotve.

2O. Mi/cp' &TTO. TOIWV enirpoa-dev In 8iofioXoyi)o'
IIPO. To woia;
2O. Trjv rayaOov \uilpav vorepov av&yKi] rtXeov Jj

tov flvai;
,
IlPil. ndw-wv 817^01; T\ri)Tarov, a) iwicpares.
.
^; IKOVOV rayaflo'r;
^
HPO. Hois y^p o(5; KO* miin-i ye eS ro.ro
ye

Kal pl a

. OiK lari.Trtfrow imi.

20. Sxo

8W7S

fiiov

nPO.
2O. 'Airoftpfoou 8jj.

rjSoiw ras
d5 8 . ^ BT:
e S WrPoV B : Vf">*
, 4*^ B T = W"^1

BT: Wrtpoi'vulg.
<ri B : aai vptl>rafXf

TG

'

dg
?Tl T : T. B
BT :,'{
:%,'{ vulgBT

2i a
io

riPH. Ti 8' ot;;

211. 'Ap' ovv ITI TWOS &v (rot irpoa-bfiv r/yoio, ei TOUT'

IIP11.
211. "Opa STJ, TOU typovflv Kai ro{i yoeiy Kai Aoyieo-0ai
b ra Seoyra Kai ova roijTtov d8eA(|>a, JJL&V JUT) 8eoi' av TI;

riPH. Kai TI; Tsavra yap exL

211. O^KoCv OVTO> S>v del /ixe
^Soyais x.atpois ay;
5
DPI!. Ti' 8' o#;
211. Nouy 8e ye Kai i^vrj^v Kai ITTKTT^TJV Kai 8o
, avdyKrj

8777:01; ere dyyoeiv, KCVOV ye

io
C

IlPil. '
SH. Kai
STJTTOV p,?]8' on TTOTC exatpe? /xep-vrjo-^ai, TTJS T' ey T TrapaTrpotrTTiTTTOvo-Tjs jurjS' yvTWovv ^VTIIJUJV VTTO8' av /xrj KfKTrj^vov aXijOf} jj/q Sodfeii; x.a^PLV
5 ^aiporra, Aoyicr/jioi) 8e o-Tepop,eyov /u,r]8' eis roy lireiTa XP^voi; wy x.01^7?0"61^ 8waToi> eiyai Aoyifea-^ai, ^y 8e OVK
avdpu>TTOv jBiov, ctAAa Tiyos TrAetfyxoyos ^ Twy o<ra ^aAdrTia
JUCT' oo-Tpefocoy ejixi/ruxd eaTt (rcop,aTcoy. eori TauTa, 7^ irapa
d raura exopey aAAa Siayorj^rjyai;
OP11. Kai TT<SS;
211. TAp' ovy alperos ^ju,iv ^ios 6 TOIO^TOS;
ITPH. Eis a<f>a(rCav Travrdnravt p.e, 2wKpaTes, O^TOS 6
5 Aoyos l//,^e/3A7]Ke ra
a 12 ?x ei *BT: ?^ois al.
a 14 TOU VOG'IV B : <oelv T
bi ^
Scot' Si/. Klitsch : Mr)8 ^pai/ B T
b 7 el T : eft) B : om. G
c 2 jurjS'] n-fiff Stallbaum
C 3 /tr/S* fynv oiiv fnvfip.-nv B : nv-fiMv
/nTjS' iJj/TH'' oS/ T
04 xai'p"] M^) Se suprascr. b : ^}8^ xa'lPflv a^
C 8 b&rpeivtov B T : ocrrpfltav vulg.
d I exojuev SMa scripsi :
B : f-ofjifV SA^ws was T

$IAHBO2
212. Mrjira) TOIWV ^aKdatn^a^Qo,, TOV 5e TOV vov
^leraAa/Soires av /3iov iSa)/xey.
IIP12, Tbv itoiov 8r) Aeyeis;
212. Ei TLS 8e'aiT' ay at) fjv fifj,&v typovrjcriv i&v KOI
vovv Kal tiri<TTriiM}v KCU juyTj/zryy irao-av Travrav /ce/crT^eVo?,
rjoovTJs Se /uteTe)(a>i> /XTJTC /xeya p,rjre cr^LKpov, /ixTj8' ai!
dAAa ro TrapciTTav aTraOys TTCLVTUIV r>v TOIOVTUIV.
IIPI2. OvbfTfpos 6 (3ios, a) 2w/cpares, e/xotye
aipero's, owS' aAAw jix^ Trore, <us eywjuat, (pavrj.
Si2. Ti 8' 6 (rvvafjupoTepos,
S npc5rapxfj ff a^olv
KOIVOS yevo^evos;
8oy^s Aeyets Kai pou xat ^po^crecos;
Si2. OVTO) Kat rail' rotovro)!' [Aeyco] eycoye.
IlPIi. ITas Sij'Trou roCrdy ye cupTyo-ercu Ttporepov TJ *Keii>coz> oTTOTfpovovv, Kal TTpbs TovTois [ye] oii}( 6 //,ey, 6 8' ov.
212. Mav0dvo/x.ey oSy ort yui' ^/uiy eori TO <ru/u/3au>oi>
ev row irapovo-i Aoyois;
ITP12. riayv //.ey oSv, on ye rpets fiey /3toi irpovTeOrjcrav,
roiv bvoiv 8' ovbeTfpos IKO-VOS ovbe aipero? ovre av6p<air<av
ovre fwwv ovftfvi.
2H. Mcoy oily OVK ^8r; TOVTMV ye Trept 8^Aoy ws ouSerepoy avroiv et^e raya66v; r)V yap &v IKCLVOS KCU reAeos
KOI mia-i tyvTots K.CU fwots aiperds, ourrrep Swaroy T^V oiJrcos
del 8ia ^iov f^v et Se ris aAAa j^peW ^cor, Trapa (pvffiv
&v ryv TOV dAT70<Ss alperoi; eAa/x/3ayey a/ccoy e^ dyyotas ^
TWOS drayKTjs OVK evSai/iioyo?.
ITPI2. "EotKe youy TaC^' OVTMS exeiy.
212. '12s /xey roivvv rrfv ye <l>iA^/3ou ^eoy ov Set 8iavoelcrOai, TCLVTOV Kal rayadov, iKavSts elpfjcrOai JJLOI 8oKe?.
d.6 roO T : vw B
d8 rJu/ T : om. B
62 iravrtov ($>v)
Badham
a I TI S* T : roS" B
a 4 TOJI' TOIOVTWV B : rbv TOtoCroj' T
Xe^yo) seclusi : 7co7e om, B T : add. in marg. T
as irp6Tepov T b :
t&repov B
Ketvcav T : eKfivcav B
a 6 TOUTOJS 76 B : TOVTOIS T
a 7 gri T : ert B
a 9 ye T : om. B
b i ouSe'repos T : ouSerepot B
b 4 avrotv T : avTwv B
b 7 oAij0<s B : a\y9ovs T

21 d

10

22

aac

[IAATONO2

<J>I. Oi8e yap 6 o-oy vovs, Si 2<dKpaTe?, IOTI Taya66v, aAA'

e"ei ifov Tavra tynXriiuiTa.
5
211. Tax' av> < *&;/3, 3 y' e>o'y oi /^.eWoi ToV ye
a\r]Bivbv a/M Kal tfeiov oTf*ai vovv, aAA'
To3z> fiev o5v viKijTripuav Trpoy TOI> KOLVOV fiiov ova i
iro) virep roS, TWI' 8e 8^ 8eurepia>i' 6pai Kal o-Koirerv \prj
d T^ bpda-ofj^v Ta\a yap av TOV KOLVOV TOVTOV jSiav aiTupfttB
av (Karepos o ptv TOV vovv afaiov, 6 8' fi&ovfiv flvai, Kal
ovT<a TO fjiev aya6bv TOVTQUV ap.<f>OTfp<av ovberepov av flrj, Ta\a
8' av aiTiov TIS irnokafioi irorepov avr&v fivai. TOVTOV br]
5 wepi Kal jja\\ov ITI irpoy <l>iAT/^oy 8tafiaxoifiJji' av u>s ev
T& pXlKT& TOVTta /3lO>, OTt ITOT* loTl TOJTTO O Aa^OaV 6 /3lOS

5
33

oCros yeyovev aipeTos apa Kal dyafloy, ox ybovr) dAAa voCs

Toruria <rvyy(Vf<rrfpov Kal opMiorfpov eori, Kal Kara TOJ;TOI>
TOV \oyov OVT av T&V Tfp<oTfi<av ovb' av T&V bevrfpftoiv
fibovrj jLieroj' a\7j0G>y av ITOTC Aeyoiw iroppajTepw 8' eVrl
TJ/ TpiTftuv, el TI rS ejtfl vS 8ei Trwret/ew fifJMS TO. vvv.
nPIi. 'AAAa firiv, 2> 2(5KpaTes, l/xotye 8oMi wv fx^
^8oi>Tj trot ireimoKeVai xadaTrepel irAT/yera viro T&V vvvbrj
\6yo>v T&V yap viKrjTrfpltov Tiepi naxo^vrf xeirat. TOV be
vovv, u>s eouce, AeKTe'oi' iy ^/x^>pora)y OVK drTewoteiTO ry
viKijTrjpi<av TO. yap avr' tvaBfv av. T&V be 8^ 8euTepewoi>
tTTfprjdfio-a f)bovri Travrairao-iv av Tiva Kal aTipiav <r\olri
wpoy T&V avn/y }pao~r&v oi8e yap iKftvois IT' av ofiofais
(palvoiTo KaAjj.
2ii. T( oCy; OVK aptivov airnjv lav ijbrj Kal fit) rr)v
dxpi/SeoraTJ)!' avr^ irpoffiptpovTa
ftatravov
\VTreiv;
nPIl. OWev Ae"yeiy, w 2(KpaTes.
211. *Ap' OTI TO dSiyyaTor eiwoi1,
C 4 rat/rA B : TOUTO ri T
d 3 o&8^Tcpov T : oi'8T/pwi' B
d 4 Ttbrtfov B T : irtlntfav vulg.
8 I ofr' &y B : oKr' oZ T
o48*
aZ T : oiS' 4v B
64 fikv T : om. B
e 6 fia

4>IAHBO2
l. Ov IJMVOV ye oAA.' on Kal ayvoeis ws oiibeis ti<a
<re r)fj.&v f/.e0Tj<ret -nplv tiv f l s TeA.os f7refe'A.$?js TOVTU>V r<j>
Aoyu.
2ii. Ba/3ai apa, OpcdTapxf, oTJXi'oC \iev \6yov roC 5
A.OIWOU, (r^fbov be oiibe pafitov wai'ii ri yw. xol yap 8?)
(f>a.iveT<u bflv aAA?js p.r;)(av^s, eirl ra 8vrfpeia virtp voC
iropev6iJ.evov olov /3e\7j ^X*'" *rePa T'i'J' efiTrpoa-dev Koyiav
lort 8e Tcrcos evia Kal TO.VT&. OVKOVV X/"?>
IlPIi. TI>s yap ov;
10
2ii. T^j> 8e ye apxhv avrov SieuXa^eia-flai ireip<afi,f6a c
DPii.
8', ei /3ov\ft,
OPli. Kafl' ort,
211. Ad.j3(oij.fV firra rfiy vw8^ Xd'yaw.
RPIi. Ooia;
6tbv IMyoptv irov ri> p^v fadpov 8Tat r&v

?j r&v db&v TO 85o

v Tt <n>imury6mvov. flpl 8', o>j toiKtv, d
ou ye\<no's riy &v0p<aTros KOT' tlbri buaras

i. Tereiproti noi yevovs aC

A^ye Tiros.
2Ii. T?js o-D/iifiet^ews Toifrwi' wpos oXXrjXo TTJZ> ainav Spa,
Kai Tiflet jitoi irpos rpiirlv fKeivois reraprov TOVTO.
t> 6 ^o5(ou e faStov fecit pr. T :fid$u>i>B
b 9 <TTI] ?O-TIU Jackson
rauToBT
c i 5Ku\oj8ir9ai BT: euAopfiffSoiG
C5^oXA.ov...
C 7 \dfju/ifv om. B : add. in marg. B* e 12 TOTB Stallbaum : TOUTBI'
BT
d a Tit Mpuiros Badham : TIS iicavlis B : TIS iVayws T : ra Kal
Svouj Apelt
KOT' T : ri. T' B
d 5 (fxifff rai T : om. B

3d

TIAATHNOS
IIP.Q. Mwy ovv VOL Kal TT^TTTOV TTpo<rbe/i(TL

8iaKpt<riy

e <ruyyvto<rTj TTOV jiot cru /xeraStcdKoyTi Tre'ju/Trroy [j3iov].

IIP!!. Tt jwjv;
2ii. TlpS>Tov [J.V STJ rwy Terrapcoi' TO, rpta
ra 8vo TOVTMV Treipw/xe^a, 7roAA.a eKa
5 Stecriracr^eyoy iSorres, ets ey TraAiy eKarepov
vorjcrat irf) Trore ^y aiirwy ly /cat iroXXa eKa
. Ei fiot cratyea-Tepov en Trepi aiiraii' enrols, rd)('
24

211. Aeyco roivvv TO. 8vo & TiporiOe^aL ravr* clvou aTrep
vw^T], ro p,ey aveipov, TO 8e Trepas exoy ort 8e Tpoirov
TLVCL TO &TTipov 7roXX' e(rrtj TTeipciaofxai ^pdfeiy. TO 8e Trepas

SH. Sxe\/Aai 817.

o KeA.V6o (re (TKOire'ii', o/xcos 8e crKOTrei. OeppoTepov Kal
^XpoTepou Trept irpwroy opa Trepas et TTOTC TI yo^crats ay, rj
TO /xaAXdy Te Kat ^TTOy kv avrots oiKow(Te) TO"IS yerecrti',
b e'axnrep av lyoiKTjToy, TeAos OIIK ay eTrtTpe^atTrjy yiyye(r0at*
yap

Sii. 'Act 8e ye,

5 TO fxaAAoy T /cai ^TToy eyi.
nPil. Kai p-aAa.
Sli. 'Ael TOLVVV 6 Aoyos ^p,Ty crr]jaaiyet TOVTCO fxr) TeAos ,
aTeArj 8' oyTe 8771701; irairrcnrao-u; aireipw yiyve<rOov. ,
. Kal cr<|>o8pa ye, a> 2wKpaTes.
i
6 I <ri fueraSitaKovTi T : avfjLfj.eraS^KOtni
B
jSfoi' seel. Schtitz :
/8f^ Apelt
e 5 crvva/yovrGs T
a i TU{;T' scripsi : ravr' B Tj
a 9 oiKouvT6 rec. Coisl. : ot/coCj/BT
b i evoi/c^roc B T : evoiKetrov\
vulg.
oi>K &/ T : om. B (add. in marg. b)
b 4 -tyvxpoTepcp B :|
/u
OT6
T^ 4 XP 'P'P ^
^ 7 ^ju?!/ffrj/xaiVetT : irrj/j.cui'ei B :
vulg.
b 8 are\^ S' ovre T : are Srj\6v re B

<MAHBO2

34 b

511. 'AAA' ev ye, S <jfuAe IIp&>Tap)(ej v^eAa/Ses /cat 10

aV6i*-vr}<ra.s on Kai TO o-<oo"pa TOVTO, o cri) PUT; e<p0e'y<o, c
Kat TO ye r\pe\ui rqv ai>Tr]v bvva^LV I^CTOZ/ TO> juaAAou Te KCII
ffTTOv OTTOU yap ay fvrjTov, OVK karov elvai TTOCTOV
aAA.' det cr(j)o$p6Tpov ricrv^air^pov KCU rovvavriov
Trpa$;<nv l/XTtotowTe TO irXeoi' KOI TO eAaTToy a
TO 8e iro<rbv acpavL&rov. o yap eAe^^ vwSrj, ^ cxpavi<ravT TO TTOo-oV, dAA' fa<ravT avro Te Kai TO jueVpioy ei> TT)
TOW /xaAAoy KCU -^TToy Kat o-^>o8pa KOI i7peju.a ^'8pa eyyeveV^at, d
awa eppei Tavra IK T?)S avr&v ^tapas v y fvfjv.
ov yap
en OfppoTtpov ov8e ^v^poT^pov eirrjv &v AajSovTe TO Trocrov
yap Kai ov fieyet TO Te OepiJ-OTepov det Kat TO
tocraijTGos, TO 8e TTOO-QV IO-TT] Kat Ttpoibv eTravcraTO. 5
Kara 8^ ToCToy Toy Aoyou aiseipov yiyvoiT3 ay TO
Kai rovvavTiov apa.
IlPii. 4>au>eTai yovv, S ScoKpaTes* IO-TI 8', oirep
oil pa8ta Tawa o-uyeTreo-^at. TO 8e et? aS0is TC Kai avOis
l<ra>$ Xe%6fVTa TOV TC epcoTwyra Kat TOV fpaoT^fvov IKO.V&S e
av (rvfji,(pa>vovvTas aTtotprivaiev.
2Ii. 'AAA' ev ju,ey A^yets Kat iretpaTeoy o{JTft)
0pet T^S TO d^eipou ^)vo-ea)9 et TOUTO
iva IJ.YI iravT* eTre^toWe? p,r]Kwcojuey.
. To TTotoy 8rj Aeyet?;
H. 'OTTO'O-' az> 77juty fyaivrjTai /xaAAoV Te Kat
Kat TO o-^)o8pa Kat i]pejaa Se^o/Aeya Kai TO Aiay Kai ocra
TravTa, ets TO ToC aTretpou yeyos ws ets ^y 8ei Tra^Ta 25
TiOevaL, KCITO. TOV ejuiTrpoo-^ey Aoyoy ov e'<a^iev oo-a
8teo-7rao-Tat Kat Sieo-^ierrat o-wayayoWas ^pfjvai KOTa bvvafuv
eTTto-Tj/xaiWa-flai' Tira tyvo-iv, et jjif^vrja-ai.
DPIi. Me'ja^jaat.
5
512. O^Kouy Ta /XT) Sexo/jieya ra^Ta, TOVTU>V e Ta kvavria.
C 2 juaAAoV re B T : re /JLU\\OV vulg.
03 &y B T : om. vulg.
ds efr-rji' T : ea-TTji/ B (ij suprascr. rec b) : ^ri]v vulg.: ^arqv Vat.
6 2 airo<j>-{)vaiev B T : airo<pr]Viev vulg.
a i yevos T : -yewus B

35 a

IIAATQNO2

navra ^e\6n(va, irp&Tov fjifv r& la-ov Kal la-orrjTa, p.eTO. 6e TO

Itrov TO biitXaviov Kal Ttav ornrep av irpos apid^ov aptffytos
b ^ fxerpov T; irpos tuerpov, raura crv^TtavTO. (Is TO ire'pas
i KaA.fis Sz> boKolfjigv bpav ToCro. Jj irfis ffii
IlPii. KtiAAiorii ye,
2ii. Etfy TO 8e rpirov TO JJ-GIKTOV (K Tot/roti>
Tiva iSe'ar (jtricrofiev tyfiv;
IlPIi. St> Kal e/xol Qpaireis, o>s oifu.
2ii. 0eos juev oSv, canrfp ye e/iiais evxois
ytyirjTcu ns 0ej'.
10
IlPii. Eii^ou 8^ Kat (TKoirfi.
Sli. 2/coirS' Kaf /ioi 8oxei riy, a> Ilp<aropxe, carr&v (pi\os
f/fuv ztwSrj ycyovtvai.
C
ITPii. Ilfis Aeyeis ToCro Kat r6i
) 8^X01; STI- OT> 8e fi
5

i. Aeye ptrfvoj'.
21i. fpfn6Tfpov
ty0fyy6iJ.fda
vvvbrj wow TI KOI
rtpov. fj yip;
HPfi. Naf.
2Ii. Hpoo-fles 8r) ^ijpJrepoi' Kai vypfofpov avrois KOI
jrAeW xal (\UTTOV Kal darrov KOI flpabvTfpov Kal
10 Kal trfjuKpoTepov Kal oitova. Iv TUI iip6<rQ(v T^S TO
re Kal ijTTor b(\o^vriy Mdfptv els $v <f>^<ras.
d
FlPIi. T^s roS amtpav X^yy;
2Ii. Na. (rvmi.(tyw bi ys tls aiirrjv TO fieTa Tawa TTJV
av ro) TrepaTos ytvvav.
OPii. noiar;
5
2H. *Hv Kal wwSjj, 8^or ^/^ay KaOdvtp TT)I> TOJ) aireipov
(rvvrj-yayrofjifv fls Hv, ovrto Kal r^r TOU wepaToetSoOs (rvva5

b 8 t ii T : $ 9(ij B
c r iris B T : irwi H G
B : ffvun'iyvvt T
d 3 o5 TOU Coisl. : etlnov B T

da

*IAHBO2
yayiiv, oil (rvv^yayoj^fv.
oXX' itrcos KOI vvv TO.VTOV 8pd(rei,
(fl) TOMTOM aiAfpOTtpiov a-vvayo^vtav Karcupavris KaKeivr)
yewjcreTai.
I0
IlPil. Ylotav Koi irias Xeyeis;
212. TT)I> TOV la-ov KOI 8wrXao-fot>, xal owoVrj -navel irpos
aXXqXa ravavrta 8ia<o'p<os e\ovTa, tnVp-erpa 8e /cal o^/x^cora e
evfleicra api.9iJ.bv aTrepyafcrai.
ITPii. Mav^ava)- ^afor; y(ip fiot X^yew pfiyvvs ravra
yfvfcreis Tiras e^>' exaorcoj' awr ffvufiaivfiv.
5
2ii. 'Op6&s yap <j>a(vop,ai.
riPil. Ae'ye rofow.
2Ii. 'Apa oiiK (V iJ.(v voffois ft TOUTUIV op&r] Kowavia r^v
vyiflas <pH<Tiv fy{vvT\<Tfv;
a6
IlPii. UavraTraffi pev ofo.
211. 'Ev 8e oer ical /3apeT /cal raX *ai ^pa5 i, dueipoty
, Sp' ov TO.VTO. [lyyiyvfyeva]
raCro- ^a Wpay T
'
<.Ta(rav
TeXtoirara
(rweo-r^o-aro;
Am/pydtraro Kol juovo-iici' <ru\j.Tta(rav
5
OPii. K(iAAiord ye.
<7
ltai
211. Kol priv tv yf xM*> "'
dmjpydo-aro.
OPil. Tr^;
211. OVKOW */c rcw'rwr 5pa^ r KO! (ro xoXo irdiro b
V rt airflpuv Kal T&V wfpas t
. Ofis 8' oii;
2H. Kal AXXa ye 8^ firpfa ewtXeforo X^ytov, otov /fl 5
<cdXXos K a ^ Kal er v a l s a5 wdp-woXXa Irepa
d, ixx'.. . dg 7^r0l post e 2 '" tra,nsPd 7 gpto, <> Vahlen : aMbr B T : Spa, I Apelt
d8
d
r-' ^.^Wv Jackson Kfat(m T : *"^ B
' "<
B T : t vulg
e 3 ^.7ri,5 B T : M,7>.5<n Khtsch
e 4 ^J - C
airv T : om B
i 3 raWk (roSro fait) . . . r-r. B : T.T. . . . r
4rl T
^,7^Mex seclusi
a5
vulg.
a 6 Irytvorfw T G : ^a-rf/wro
b 5 7 T : om. B

10
C

OAATGNOS
KOI irdyKo\o. vj3piv yap irov Kal crvnTia<rav Tfdvriav irovr)piav avrrj KdTioovara y deos, Si Ka\f 4>t\7jj3f , Tt^pas OVTC
fibov&v ovbfv ovre nX.rja'iJ.ov&v Ivbv tv avTols, vofjMV Kal
rdu' vepas \OVT' Itfero- Kal <rii p.ev airowawm <pys
avn\v, lya> 8e rowavriov fatovSta-ai Ae'ya>. <rol 8^, Si
Tlp<aTap\f, irias (fiaivfrai;
FTPli. Kal fiaXa, Si ScdKparej, ffwi/ye Kara vovv.
2H. OVKOVV ra fjLtv 8r) rpia raura fiprjKa, d (rvvvods.
IlPli. 'AXA.' oifjMi Karavoelv $v fxtr y&p JMM. boKfis TO
Hireipov \eyeu>, li> 8e Kal btvTfpov TO Wpas %v rois oS<riTpiTov 8e oil (rtpobpa KaTe^ta ri fiovXei <f>pd^fiv.
2ii. To yap ir\rj66s o-e, S> Oav^ao-if, e^eirXjjfe TTJS TOV
rpiroi) yevfo-f<os' KO.ITOI noAXa ye xal ro airfipov irapt<T)(fTo yfvrj, Sfuos 8' ^iritrtppaywfl^zTa T& TOV /xaXAov KOI
b>avriov ytvd $v f<pdvr).
OPIi. 'AXrtOfj.
2ii. Kal fi^r TO ye irepas o&re iroAXa ?xa' ^T>
Aau'Ofiej; a>s ow fjv $v <pv<rei.
UPQ.. n&s yap av;
SH. OvSajiifis. aAAa rptrov <f>dOi /*e X^yeti', li> TOVTO
TO TovTdiv ^Kyovov &TTO.V, yevetriv (Is ov<rCav IK
T&V peTo. TOV TtfyaTos
aTT(ip-yaa-fj.(vtav
211. 'AAXa 8^ Trpoy rpiirl r^raproV Tt rrfre tyafKV tlvai
ytvos o-Kfirreov Koivr) b' q o-Ktyis. opa yhp el o-oi 8oKi
flvai irawro ra yiyvopfva, bid riva ahiav
b 8 otrf Tiftovuy oMv B : olifkv afrt fitoyav T
b IO t\ovr' T :
B
i-roKyalaai <f[)i vir doctus in Kidd. Misc. Person
aiaai

p. 265: 4iro/ti/os ?07ji Par. 1811 : iiroKran f^iji BT: ATI-OKI- . . . tipufi
G : ImoKvav /S^rjs corr. E vulg.
04 !J) B : om. T
0 6 \iytiv
T : Kiym B
d 4 oft- B T : trt Apelt : or <4j> SchOtz : or
(Ti) Bury
otrt B T : e6 Apelt
d$ tvT: irB
d 7 tv
ToSro T : TI rairruv B
d 8 (xyovov T : tyyovor B
e I (rorj)
rpiffl Badham
rifre T G : r6yt B : or t vulg.

4>IAHBO2
IIPO. "EfJMiyr TI&S yap &v x<apls TOUTOV ylyvovro;
5
2O. OVKOVV ft TOV TTOIOVVTOS <f>v<ns ovbiv irATJr 6Vo'p.aTi
rrjs airias 8ta<pepei, TO 8e woiow KOI ro alriov 6p6&s to
elr; \ey6fj.(vov ev;
HPii. 'OpO&s.
2ii. Kal fXTjr TO ye Ttoiavpevov oS> KCU. ro yiyvopevov 37
, KaBAtrtp TO vwSr,, biatfpov evpTjo
T) irfis;
DPii.
.
2ii. *Ap' miv riydTai jxer TO TTOUJVV ael Kara <#)t5crir, TO 5
iroun5/xei>oi> ewaicoXov^i yiyroVerox infivif!
HPii. Haw ye.
SO. "AXAo apa (cal oi Tavror aWa T tori Kat rd
ds ytvt(nv ahiq.

. Ti
SO. O^KOW TO MV ytyvrf/**^ wl f 5f yfywrai
ro Tpfo irapiirxero inu.v yivi);
OPO. Kol flXa.
vra btovow
SO. To 8> 8r> wawa Tovra
bwtovpyow ^yo^v Tiraprov, o
T^V alrlav, As l/covfis frepov K^WV o o ? t t J w ;
HPO. "Erepoi' yap o5v.
(
SO. 'Opflws ,xV l\' ^uapariUimv r&v Terrdpcoi/, erds
exdorou iu4m, (veto iJK&t atrb KaTapt^(Ta<rflat.
5

UFO. TC MV;
20. UP&TOV

8e T^ pfr** alrta* !
apa p.^ ir\rjjuijLieXo^v ar TI;
Kal TT$;
e S ,^ B :

o\oue? B
/. T

a 1 1 ^| &" T : H B ,

b 2 tlS-nXuptvOV

^M T : A*-, G

BTG : A^-o, vulg.

PLATO, VOL. II.

T : l,X/W.l' B

b 7 - B : om. pr. T

2pa ^ T : Spa B

Seweoi; 8e

37 c

IIAATi2NO2

211. <l>e"p{ 8ij, TO fitra rovO' fiftiv TS & \6yos, xol rl

TtoTf /3ovX?j6Vi>Tes fls TaCro a^tiKo^Oa; ap' ov robt fy;
5 favrepfia l(flToviJ,fV irorfpov rjftovrjs yiyvoir av TJ <ppovy<rf<i)s.
ov\ ovrtos Jfv;
HPil. OVTOJ per ovv.
2ii. TAp' ovv to-coy jw, lir8^ Tairra OI!TO)
10 Seur^pov, irepl 3>v 8^ TO irp&rov ^fi^eo-jSrjTTjo-afiti;;
HPii. 'I<r<os.
d
2i2. "lOt 817- viK&vra fifv tdepiv ttov rbv peua-ov /3ioi>
vijs T Kal <f>povri(Tf(as.
ijr oi5T<os;

OPQ. 'HV.

211. OvKoOi' ToBroi' fiev TOP /3ioj op&fiilv irav rfc T

Kal owotot) ytvovs;
IIPH. FISs yap ov;
2G. Kal fxc'pos y' avrw 0i}(ropiev etvai TOW rptrov o?/tai
yevovs' oil yap [6] bvoiv nvolv tori [fuxros (Ktlvos] dXXa
<n>niravr<i>v T&V aweipcoi' viro TOU ir^paTOs btfaftlvfov, <Sor
10 opO&s o viKr)(p6pos OVTOS fiios ftepos eKed'ov yt-yvotr' av.
flPil. 'OpdoVara fiev o5v.
e
211. Etcv ri 8 6 cros, S <t>t\t)/3, ^8vs Kal a;xeiKTO$
X/yotro; u8e 8' aTroKpii'ai /xoi irplf airo
<tl. A^yt (wvov.
5
2Ii. 'H8oi^ Kal AI/TTTJ w^pay l\frov, rj T&V TO jxaXXov
T< Kal ^TTOJ> 8x/x^J"01' tor6v;
4>I. Nat TWI> TO fxaXXof, a> SaJ/cpaTej- oi yap or 77801^
c8 r<ri ci. Stallbaum : ii BT
09 KAxioy &cB :
T : /faAAJoi-a &v fffaii vulg.
d I piy B : om. T
d 4 T^ B : om. T
d 7 7' o6riK ip^ffofJLH' T : ravr^y iijrfiiranev B
d 8 4 T : om. B :
j . . . ^IKT&I ^K?yo! seclusi auctore Jackson
^IKT^V Ixtiyo SchOtz
rmlr T : nnv B
ix\A B : 4AA' T
d 9 rioi' B : om. T
d 10 op5 T : opObs B
e I leal &/UIKTOI T : KO) ^IKT^I B
03 4<fnfivtti M"i T : airoitpd'o^ai ^tai B
e 6 im6t B : iirr/c T
6 7 rat'
r&y rb T : vai' rbi> rb B

4>IAHB02

37e

irav ayaObv ty, el pj faeipov eTvyyave irec^uKos KOI wXij^ei

KO.I T<3 pM\\OV.

211. Qvbe y av, S 4>\r;/3e, A.vm) vav KO.KOV <UOT' a\\o

TI i>Si> crKeTiTeov ?j TTJI> TOV cmeipov <f>v<ru> o>s Trape^erai ri
(xe'pos raw f]bovais ayadov. rovrto 8?j (rot T&V aTrepavrutv
ye yevovs lortov <$>p6vri<ra> 8 xai 7710-717^7)1) KUI i>oCi> eJs
T^ wore T&)I> -npoeipr]\i.evtav, 2) Ilpwrap^e re KOI 4>fA.Ti,/3e, iSi
OeiTfs OVK &v do-e/Soiftei'; 011 y<ip fiot SOKEI cr/xiKpoy ^jxi
ewai 6 /ai>8wos Karop0o<ratri Kal /XTJ i7epl ro znii; k(Ki>T(a^i.evov.
4>I, SefxrtJi'eis ydp, 2) S&>Kpors, TOP o-eauroC 0eoV.
Sii. Koi yap tru, at eraipe, TTJJ; o-avroC1 ro 8' fpiaTtapievov
DIMS fifj.lv XeKTeov.
IlPii. 'Opflfis TOI X^yei Sw/cpdrrjy, S 4>^XTjj3e, xal avru
iteurreov.
4>I. Oi/coCi; vir^p ffj.ov <rd, Hp<Lrapx(> irpo^pj)<rai \fyav;
nPIi. Ildvii y- wv pevroi a-\ebbv airopfi, xal btopai
/(, w SxuKparts, oiTtJi' ere ^jxiv yt^o-floi i7po</>JTr;v, Zvo
<roi irepl TOV &ytavurrr)v ^afiaprdfoirts irapa
Aos <j>Oeyu>jjLf66. ri.
Sii. neiar^ov, S Flpwrapx*' ov8i yop \aXettbv oiibev
. aXA' o'lrms crt ^y<, Kafldirep the
tv T$ irateu> 0opi5/37)<ra, voCv KO!
6i7ofov yevovs elev;
. nai>rd7ra(r ye, a> S<tfKpOT6S.
211. 'AAAa p.T)v pafiiov i7dvrs yap trvfj-^xavoww oi
<ro<pot, eavravs OVTUIS a-e^vuvovres, i? wCs IOTI /3a<ri\eiis ^fxir
oipavoi) Te ical y?js. xal Icrcos ? \eyovo-i.
8', ei ^ovXei, rTji> a-Keijnv avrov TOV yerovs
e 8 irai'^afloi' et mox a i TT^KOKOI/ ci. Bekker
eg TV T : ri> B
a i oiSc 7' T: oiS* B
a a is] 4 corn Par. 1814: Paley
a 3 Tofrra scrips! : ToiiTaii/ B T : TOVTO corr. Yen. 189
a 4 -ye 7eVous
scrips! : -ye-covis B T
tffTuv scrips! : faro B T
a 7 elroi 4
KtfSuvoj Ka.top6taaa.in B : 6 xfyBvixu tTvai al KaTopSdiaiuTi T
b4 5
*i\T)fle T : om. B
b 7 /! jueVroi T : ^ roliniv B
b 8 <re T :
7 B
0 7 ivrus B T G : o0T vulg.
c 8 re B : om. T

28

10
c

a8d
d

OAATHNO2
IlPii. Aey' oircas j3ov\et, juT]8ei>
3> ScoKpares, &>s OVK
. KaAwy et^es. d c o j i e 0 a 6e mos <S5e
211. noYepov, a> ripwrap^e, TO, o-v/xirayTa Kai To8e TO
K.oXo{>^vov oKov eTrtrpoTrevetv (pa>ju,ei> rrjv TOU dA.oyo-y /cat
eixfj bvva^tv KOL TO 07777 Irvx^j ^ ravavria, Ka6airep ol
fnj.S>v eA.eyoy, roSi; Kal fypovria-iv TWO. Oav^acrrrjv
riPIi. Oi8ei> Twy am&v, u> 0avju,d(rie 2coKpaTes*

TrayTa 8iaKOo-/xay atrra tyavai Kai TTJS

Kai T/A.IOU Kai (reA.i]i'T]s Kai dorepooy Kai
5 irepopas aioi>, Kai OIIK aAAcos eycoy' ay TTOTC
et7roip.t ovS' ay 8o^a(raijai
2Ii. BovA.ei 5rjT^ TI K
39 fievoy (TV^rjcr^tAfV
ws rat)y" oDrcos
TaAXoTpta ayeu Kiy8vi;(
Kai jLieTexw/utey TOU \|Ao'you, oTay
<|>77 Tawa p,rj oi;T6os dAA' aTctKToos
5
ITPil. nSs yap OVK av

6\|fea)s TOV
7rd(rrjs TT}S
Trepl aid

dy^f

a^pei.
IIPI2. Aeye p.6vov.
SH. Ta Trepl T^y Twy o-aijuaTcoy tfjvtnv CLTTCLVTOOV T&V
10 {idcuy, irSp Kai i;6a)p Kai 7n>eCp.a Ka9op&fj.ev TTOU Kai yTjz>
Ka^aTrep 01 x.^iMaC('/;jtei;ot5 <pa(rty, eyoWa ey TTJ o-vo-Tao-ei.
b
IlPii. Kai fxdA.a- \i\io.^6^Qa yap oyTcos VTT' aTropta?
ey TOIS vvv Xo'yois.
d.5 Wrepov T : vp6repov B
TO B : om. T Eus
d.7 TO BT:
om. G : T& vulg.
6 I ovSev T&V O.VTUV B T Eus. : oil 8eT TOW evavriiav
Apelt
6 2 vvv Ae-yeis T G : vvv 8?) Aeyets B : \e-yets i/Sj/ vulg.
e 4frffreptovB : &trrp<ev T
67 5fJTt TI B : Srjra T
Sfn.o\oyov(ji.evov
B T : 6fio\oyov/j.evois vulg.: &fjLo\oyr)/j.fvois Theodoretus
a i raSO"
B T : ToOO' G

4>IAHBO2

agb

212. 4>epe 877, Trepi eKdorou rS>v Trap' fjjMV Aa/3e TO

Toiovbe.
IIPJ2. Ylolov;
5
212. f/On juKpoV re Toirrcoy S-KCUTTOV Trap' TJ\JAV eVeori
teal <paAoy Kal ovba/Jifl oiibafj.S>s elXiKpives ov Kal TT\V
bvvaiAiv OVK a^Lav rijs ^(rea>s XOV' *v ^ ^ Aa^Scov Trepi
TTCLVTOtV

VOfL

TdVTOV.

OLOV TTVp

!0Tl JJ,V

TTOV

TTap' ^J

eon 8' ey rai iravTi.

riPll. Ttx juiji;;
SH. OVKOVV <Tfj.LKpov jj,fv TI ro ;rap' ^/x^ Kai
Kat <j>av\ov, TO 8' ey TO> Trayri TrA?70ci re Qav^aa-rw Kal
K(iAA.ei Kal Traor^ 8uz;a)txei TTJ Trepi TO -Trvp ovtrrj.
IlPfi. Kal f/,dA' dXrj^es 8 Aeyets.
SH. Ti 8e; rpe^erai Kal yiyyerat eK rovrou Kal avferai 5
TO Toi) irayTos iryp VTTO TO Trap' ^p.?y irupos, ^ TOVVCLVTWV
fnr' zKfivov TO T' efxoy Kal TO <rbv Kal TO TWI* aAAcov tytov
xfi TO.VTO.;
IlPIi. TOUTO fjifv ov8' aTTOKpia-ecos a^tov epcoras.
212. 'Op^wy Tavra yap epei? o?/xai Trepi Te T?JS ev rots d
y^s TTys er^d8e Kal T^S e^ T<3 TravTL, Kal Twy aAAcoz; 8r/
V offcav i7pwTij(ra oAtyoy eju/7rpocr0ei>. OVTCOS aTroKpi^TJ;
IlPii. Tis yap airoKpivofAfvos aAAw? vytaiyooy av TTOTC
5
212. 2)(e8oy ov8' oo-Tto-oCy dAAa TO jaeTa TOVTO l^s
irdyTa yap Tj/xeis TauTa ra yuySr) Ae^^e^Ta ap' OVK
is ey crvyKeifjLzva IbovTcs eTrcoyo/xao-a/xey o-w/w,a;
211. TavTw 8^ AajSe Kal irepl Toi38e ov Kocr/xoy Aeyojixey 6
[8ia] Toy awToy yap Tpovov &v eir] TTOV o-&fj,a, (rvvdfTOv ov
b 6 wap" seel. Klitsch
%veari] fort, /tev ^<TTJ
b 9 lo-rt /u^v
T Eus.: jueV ^ern B
05 atf|wat Jackson : Hp^erat B T
d i 70-.
B Eusebius: 7' &^ T: y' aS Ast e Ficino (quoqui)
d 3 ircij/Tcc
B : om. T Eus.
e 2 8i seel. Badham

I1AAT12N02
IIPi2. 'Opfldrara Aeyeiy.
212. Tlorepov ovv IK TOVTOV TOV <rw/iaros <5Aa>y ro Trap
iuv <T&\M rj $K TOV irap' T)[uv rovro Tpttfxrai re nal oira
Wvbri irepl O.VT&V fllTOfJifV

IJP12. Kai ravff

(I\rj<p4v T( KO.I <l\fi;

tTtpov, 3> 2aKpares, OVK &iov

fpurfi-

<retos.
30
212. Ti 8^; To8 Spa a^iou; ^ wuy fptls;

10
b

ITPIi. A'y< To woibi>.

212. To irap' fnj.lv tr&fw. Sp' av \lru\T]v <pri<roij.(v l\fu>;
IIPI2. A^Xov Srt tp^a-ofifv.
212. no'tfev, S 4>^\e Ilp^rapxe, Aa/3oV, eiirep jx^ TO yf
TOV iravrbs o-fi/xa (ivjruyov ov ervyxai'e, Tavrd ye ^X0*7
Tovrfc) KOI Irt travrri KaXAiova;
IlPIi. AT/AXW a>s oiibaiu)0ev a\X.o6fV, S 2a/cpaTey.
212. Ov yap TTOU boKovpfv ye, S ITparapxe, TO reYrapa
e/cfiya, irtpas ical aireipov KO.I KOIVOV KOI TO TTJS airias yevos
ev airao-i reVaprov evor, TOUTO er /ner roiy irap' ^/
re irapf\ov Kal O-IOIUUTKUIV ipiroiovv KO.I irraia-caTos
iarpuciji' xai ey iXAoiy aXAa omiTidei' Kai aKOVfj.evov nairav
Kal Ttavroiav <ro<plav liriKa\fi<r&ai, T&V 8' avraiv Tourtav
3vra>v iv 3X<j> re ovpav> Kal Kara /xeyaAa fi^pjj, Kai
Ka\ui> KOI d\iKpivu>v, f v TOVTOIS 8' OVK a pa
n\v riav Ka\\iaT<av Kal Tijj.uoTaTtav (pviriv.
I1PI2. 'AAX' ovSa/xais- roCrJ y av AoyOi' <l\oi.
212. OVKOW (I pi) TOVTO, \J.T lutlvov TOV Aoyov av
i fiiKTiov A^yoi/xev <5>s loriv, a iroAAdxts eJpjjKa^tv,
re Iv T!J> Tiavrl ito\ij, Kal ir"pas \Kav6v, na( rts
eir' avrots aJria oi <pav\r), Koirfjavtrd re Kal <rwrdrrot)cra
eViawous re KO! (Spas KOI nfjvas, <ro<pia Kal vow
Swcaiorar' av.
e 7 rXfi T Eus. : rffxi B
a i 2pa T : &fa B
a6 tv T Eus. :
W B
a 7 TrdvTji B T : om. vulg.
a 10 ^pos T : om. B
b 3 irapx<"'] tttftx'H' Beare
auntutitltui Eus. : rapa ffniix B T
b 3 (ri-Ti9ev B : ammtlr T G
b 7 rijv T Eus. : Jio B

4>IAHBOS
IlPil. AiicaioYara 8?}ra.
SO. So<pi'a fx^
DPil. Ov yap otv.
212. Oiicow & pfe rf) rov Aios < &

'<r

^
XiBjy d

eicdoTOi?

HPii. M<iA.a ye.

SO. ToC 8^
P^eVal( dXX' Icrrc roT,
roC mwrAj wSs *pX" WXOT eUWMS'
IlPli. *Eori yap ovv.
SO. Trj8^yelMli
H}. roi)
rdpa,,, W ^
IlPii. '

. Kal
d 3 a f l ( ! T ,TEu, : ^B
e ^phyrius Proclus Olymp.odorus Hesych.us
Bekker
x f^ifmv . . .rovro sec
B T : add. in marg. T
* m. GI . <O^
o u ,

rrv

Xws Hermann
a ' ""' "I T"
Bekker
oS T : ot B

^
T

ea

. ^ ^^

e5 TT)J
B . ,,

3 ia

10
b

10

IIAATi2NO2
212. Mefipca/xeda 8?/ Kal ravra Ttfpl hptyolv, 5n vovs
fuv curios ty ovyytvris xal TOVTOV (r^ebbv TOV ytVous, fibovr]
8e aiffipos re avrrj ical rov ^r\rt aPX*lv M^Te M^<7a tulTe f^Xos
fv avrai a(f> tavTov ^XOVTOS M^ eovr6s irore yfvovs.
ITPIi. Me/xvjjo-o/xefla' TT&S yap ov;
2fi. Ae! 8^ ro jixera roCro, !i> co re eoru' eK(iTepoj/ avTolv KCU. 8ta ri iraflos yiyvftrQov oTrorav yiyirqcrBov Ibtiv
^/xaj. itp&Tov rr\v rftov^v &(nrfp TO ytvos avrrjs irporepov
(f}a<ravi<ra.[jifv, ovrta KOI Tavra Trporepa. A.UUTJS 8e av x^P'^
i-^i> ribovrjv OVK &v irorf SwaC/ieOa IKOV&S
IlPii. 'AA.A.' i rat/rjj XP^ iropoJeo-^ot, Tai/rj;
SI2. *Ap' o5i crol Koddmep ffiol (pawfrai. TTJS yfVf<rf<as
avr&v irepi;
HP12. T6 woioi';
212. 'Ej> T^> /coti'i fiot yivn apa ($>aLvr6ov \VTTT) re xal
^80^ yiyvta-Oai Kara tf>ij<nv.
nPil. K.OIVOV 8^ ye, a> (pi\f Swicpares, vtrofi.Cfa>ri<rKf
ua$ rf irore rwv irpoeiprjfji^viuv /3oi;\et
2. "Eorat raOr' eis Swa/xii', S
i. KoXSs eiires.
212. Kowov roivvv vTraKOvcapfv 6 Sr; rr
rpirov l\tyojj.fv.
I1P12. *O /xera ro &Ttnpov Kal ir^pas ^Xeyes, ev <f cal
vyifiav, ot/iat 8e col dp^oviav, Mdtvo;

212.

HP12.
212. A^yto rotwv r^s appovlas
5 Toiy ^Jots fyia At/(ru> r^s (pvcrfuts Kal yivtcru> &\yrjb6viov tv
Tta rore yiyvf<r6ai
a 9 af<T^ T : oSrT) B
a 10 ^i/ our<p 4*' {avrov B T : lap' lavrov
iv laur$ vulg.
b 3 <teo T : xAijeoi B
yf^vijirdoi' B : ytyifta9ot'T
On MStffo: nd\\urr' T : WSfil t {\Ai<rr' B

$IAHBO2

31

I. YIdvv A^yeis etKo's.

Sil. IIaAtz> 8e ajojuorrojue'zn/s re Kat ets Trjv avTrjs (pvviv
amov<rr]s ^bovrjv yCyvfcrOai AeKreov, et 8et 8t' dAtycoy irept
fjLfyC(TT<av on r<i)(icrra pyOijvai.
10
i4v o~e 6p6S>s Aeyew, S 2<yKpares, efj,(pavfe
8e ert ravra ravra iretpw/ue^a Aeyety.
ra 8rj/Aocrta TTOU Kat Ttepupavrj pqarrov
DPIi. Dota;
Sli. Fle^T] ^iey TTOI; A.WIS xal
. Nai.
IIP!!. Nat.
Sli. Ai\/ros 8' av <f)6opa Kal Xvirr] [nal Avaris], rj 8e roC 10
vypov iraXiv TO r]pav6tv TT\r]pov(ra bvvajJLis fjbovr)- bid- 33
Se y av Kal 8iaAv<ns 97 -^apa <pvcriv, TOV irviyovs
Kara <f)V(riv be TIO.\IV airobocris re Kat -^svts

ElPIi. Haw jbtez; o^y.

5
2H. Kat pCyovs fj jjiev napa tyvcriv TOV {iuou riys vyporrjros Trfjis AVTTJJ' -rrciAiv 8' eis TO.VTOV aTTLovTutv Kal biaKpivofjL^vcav 77 Kara fyvviv 686s ^80^77. Kat evt Ao'yo) (TKOTret
et o-ot fxeVptos 6 Aoyos 6s az; ^>rj ro eK r^s diretpou Kat
jreparos Kara <pij<riv ^i^v\ov yeyoros etSos, oirep eAeyoy ev b
rw Ttpoa-Ofv, OTav p.V TOVTO (pOfiprjTai., T-TJV p.v (frOopav
AvTrrjy etvai, TTJV 8' ets r?^y avrwz; oixriav obov, Tavrrjv 8e
av TraAtv r^ ava\(apr](nv iravTcav f]bovr]V.
d 8 auTTjy B T : avT^v Stobaeus
d 10 2rt rA^iffTO. vepl p.eyiffruv Stobaeus
e 2 ravrh B : ra aurefc T : om. Stobaeus
e 6 ireij/ij
B Stobaeus : ire'ivy T
e 8 eSwSi] B Stobaeus : eSwSij T
e 10 /cal Au<m T Stobaeus : seel. Schleiermacher : Kal \vcris B : Kal
alffis ci. Bury
& 2 y' B T : re G : T' Stobaeus
^ om. Stobaeus
as Se Stobaeus : $}j BT : 5' % Heusde
a9 TT/S
B T Stobaeus : TOV Stallbaum
b i tv vy -irpoffBev e\fjov Stobaeus
ba fjikv om. Stobaeus
b 3 a.v-rS>v T : avrcov B Stobaeus

IIAATGNOS

riPii. *E<mo' 8oxeT yAp p-oi TVTSOV yi riva 2xel"'

211. TOUTO fikv rolvvv ei> eSios TifWp-efla ATJWJJS re /col
i> Totirois rols TtdQfiriv fKdTepois;
OPI2. Keio-fto.
211. Ti0et TOIVVV avrrjs rf/s \j/v\f)s Kara TO rovra)i> TOW
jraflijp.aYa)!' irpoo-So/ajpxi ro fxer irpo raiv rjbf<av f\m6iJ.evov ^811
icat QappaXeov, rb be -npo r&v \\rm\pG>v <j>o/3(pbv KO.I aXyfivov.
IIPQ. 'Earl yap ovv roCfl' fjbovrjs KCU Xwirrjs trepov
eiSos, TO x^P'* roi3 frcafMTOS avrijs rrjs ^fvx^s 8ia TrpocrSoKiay
yiyvoptvov.
212. 'OpO&s vire'Xa.fiJfs.
ev yap TCVTOIS oT/nat, Kara ye
T7)i> e/x^v &6av, elh.iKpive(ru> re exarepots
So/tel, KOI dfxetKrois ATJTTIJS re Kat ^8oi<^s, e)i<pai>es
ro irepi rrjz> ^Sowjj', tiorepov o\ov eori ro yevoy dtnraarojj,
rj TOWO p-ev erepu nvi rfir irpoeiprjfj^vtov boTtov fifuv yev&v,
rjbovfi be KOI XlJinj, Kaddirep Sfpnut KOJ. \(rvxp<p Ka' wo<rt TOIS
TOIOVTOIS, ror fiev denrooreoj' airel, rore 8e OVK do-Traoreoj',
a>$ dyada ^xev OVK ovra, iviort 8e xal Ivta
TOW dyafltSv lorir ore tyviriv.
IlPfl. 'OpOJrara X^yeiy, STI ravrri m) Set
TO wi> p;era8ia)Kop.evoi'.
2ii. Flpcaroj' juei1 roivw rJ8e <rvv&<oiuv [a>j] eftrep
OVTCOS Icrri TO \eydftevoi', bia(p6fipo[jdv<i>v /*ei> avroSi' dAyjSwr, ara<r<poidv<ov 8e ^801^, TUV fnjre
TOIJ C' 0 '^! Sraf oCrtos

o 2 \\ntT\fSiv T : Xuirav B Stobaeus

c 4 TpO(r8o/c(as B T Stobaeus : irpoffSoKtav vulg.
da ni/I T : om. B
ds 8J B : rt T
d 4 i-cire !i T : ri rl Sf B
d 6 gr] JITJJ Badham
d 7 SiawopijBrivtu Solomon : SiavopfvOijytit
B T : SittOijptvOrivai Stephanus
d 9 4s seel. Badham
e i 4A77|5i/' iimffio(opjrtii> T :
Siaffwfaptvuv B

<J>IAHBO2
nPli. 'Azxiyxtj i&v ovv.
212. OVKOVV IOTI TIS Tpfrr/ fjfj.&v % TouivTrj
bui6f<ris
napa Te T^V TOV yalpovros nal irapa TT\V TOV XwnovpLtvov;
33

nPii. Ti jmtv;
212. Aye 8T) TOIVDI', ravrrjs itpoOvji-ov fj,fj,vfi<TOa.i.
irpos
v^n T^y r^s ^Soi'Tjs Kpio-iv 011 o~[jiLKpbv ^e^vfjo-Bai Tavrriv
fifuv r) HTJ.
/3paxti oe TI wept avnjs, et j3ov\fL, S
ITPii. Aeye Troioi>.
SG. [Tw] TOV TOW Qporelv [f\ofj,fv<f]

fiiov

ola-ff

&s

TOVTOV TOV TpoTrov ovbfv diTOKtoXvet f\v.

IlPii. Tov ToS fit) yalptiv p.r)o XuTreio-flot \tyets;

2Ii. 'EppTjflr, ydp irov TO'T er TT) Trapa^oXjJ TOJV
ical Qpovfiv
OPii. Kal
2Ii. OIIKOW

filov

TS&VTUV T&V

\alptu> 6to^ oiirt TO

avra)tl I0

aMis Jm<ricf^/M0a. ^av wpos Ao'yov n fi, al T ^ irpos

nP12. 'OpfloVaTO A^yeiy.

^
SO. Kal jaV TO' ye trepov e78os raiv r/Sovfiv, O^TT/S 5

, ts OIMV, Tt TTOT ffTi TroT^

e 9 4^Sr B T : ,* al.

ava-

a 4 r^,v B T : ^T,r recc .!Bekker

r*.

Bekker :

OAATflNOS

33C

\r)irr{ov, Kal mvSvvfijfi ira\iv Irt irpo'repov aWrjviv iJ.vrnj.rjs,

10 i p,e'AA.ei TO. irfpl ravO' THUV Kara rpo'uw <pavfpd wj)

. n<3s <frfr;
2fi. @es TO)!' irepl TO ax5/ia r^Siv fKaoroTe iradrnj,dTU>t>
TO fib; &> ro> o-w/xari Ka.Ta.a-fifvvviJ.fva irpiv fm rriv tyvxyv
biff\dfu> a.Tra.Orj fKftvrjv (ao-avra, TO. 8e 81' ap.^)ofv lovra.
5

Ktt TWO &0"JIfp

O-fUTIMV

fVTlBfVTO,

IblOV

Tf

KO.I

KOIVOV *

Ta f*h> 8rj ^ 81' an<polv lovra lav TJJ

&Hfv \avOavf u>, TO 8^ 8t' a^olv /xrj Kavdavtiv, ap
10 dpdoTara ipovpfv;
e
nPIi. IIus yap oi!;
To To^vf \f\ri6evai /X7)8a/i<2s inro^d/Brjs us
vraCdd irov yivtvur fori yap \7J0rj fxi'^Tj
d' jp ry \(yoniv<f vvv oforw yiyovf.
TOV 8r) ju^re oiros
'i'"* yryovdror ira> ylyvtvOu (pavai nva airo/3oti)v aroirov.
yap;
Ta roiVw dvJ/iara fxera/3aA< pdvov.
Hwr;
10
Ii. 'AiTi |uh> rot) XeAT/^vat T^J/ V^X7?"
afar] yiyvrirai r&v (Tfur^&v T&V TOV fft&^MTos, fjv vvv
34 (taAfis avaia-dritrtav fttovoftwrov.
UPQ.. "EpaOov.
212. To 8' tv tvl itadfi TT\V ^tvyj\v Kal TO ff&fia. KOIVTJ
yiyvofifvov Koivfj Kal Kivflvdai, Tajurrjv 8' a5 TTJV K[vr)triv
S OVOIM&V aMrja-iv OVK avb Tpoirou <p0^yyoi av.
o 10 r4 irepl B : irtpl T : om. Stobaeus
d a rar T Stobaeus :
rtK B
d4 Si' T Stobaeus : om. B
d8 SJ) BT : om. Stobaeus
fi^ om. G
6 4 TDK 8j| B : TOV * T : TOV Sou D : 068" oi Stobaeus
05 irw Stobaeus : rui B : TTOJS T e 10 fi^K om. Stobaeus
as TO
B T G Stobaeus : T$ vulg.
a 4 ' aS B T : 5J) Stobaeus
a 5 4wo
T Stobaeus : STO B

*IAHBO2
i. 'AAr)0e'o-raTa Aeyew.
211. OVKOVV ?;8r; fj.av0dvoij.fv

84 a

& ySouAoVxeda KaAeu TTJV

211. 2a>r?7piai> roivuv ai<rOy<reios TT)I> p-njprji; Aeya)i 10

#G>s az> rts Aeyoi Kara ye TT)J> e/itji> boav.
nPii. 'Opflajs yap oSi>.
b
SO. Mvi}jLi7;9 6c ava^j-vria-iv ap' ov
HPii. 'lo-coy.
Sii. *Ap' oSi> ov rofie;
nPii. To itoiov;
2Ii. "Orav a p.cra TOI) <ra>fiaTos titaayiv iroff TJ
rot! o-oifiaroj avr
f favrp 3ri ^uiAiora Ara\afj.fidvr], ro're avafj.ifj.v^o-Kfcrdai
irov Kiyofj.tv.
] yip;

i. ndw n^v oCi>.

1. Kal ji7)j (coi Sroi* airoX^irao-a fJ-vri^ni' tlr'
crews (fr' a8 fiadr;piaro aS0iy ra5rr;i' avoiroAjjirj)
aiiTj ^i< ^awr^, xal ravTa (rv^vavra. ava/ntir}(rtv [Kai /xi/;^as] C
wow

21i. OJ 6?) x^P11* Awayr' *l/">'rat TOUT', fort To8t.

T woior;
6
011' <als <r.aToj 8rt
. Iva
ra KOI eVapyeWara Aci^oifiti', Kal fip.a ImOviiiav 8ta
yap TOVTQIV irws ravra a^orepa loiKtv 5jjAoCo-0ai.
I1PG. A(-yiap.fv rotwv, aj 2<i)Kpares, ^87; TO fiera rairra.
2H. IIoAA(i ye wept ytvtaiv r/8oj^s KOI irairav [rT>] >o
Mop^f avTT}y ai/ayKaJov, us eoiKe, Ae'yowas (TKOireir. Kal
yap in5v Trporfpov en (paiveraj, AT/nreoi' f-ni6v\i.iaa> (ivai TI
iror' eort KOI iroC
b a \4yofifr T : \tyuptv B
b 6 inf^ * T : Wfl); B : Wr( fl Turr.
ci ol /uv^/ioj seel. Gloel
06 117 Schfltz : S^ Grouius : $(87)
c8
Hermann : ^ B T
^ux^s T : *** ^Xl* B
*<" T:
TS B
o 10 T> seel. Badham
d i ofrrS* T : air^v B

34<1

TIAAT12NO2

IIP12. 2KOirfi/wi' Toivw ovbtv yap

212. 'AiroAoC^ei' p^v ovv [KOI] ravra ye, oo
etSpoires o PW ^JjToCju.ei', diroAoC/uez' r^v irepl aira raCra
airopiav.
DP12. 'Op^Ss TIIMVW rb 8' f<j)erjs TOVTOLS ireipa>/^e9a
Aeyeiv.
10
212. Oi/coCz' vuvS^ Tteivr]v re KOI Styes Kal iroAAa erepa
e roiaCra e^a^tv etvai Tiros eiridujnias;
IIP12. 2^o'8po ye.
212. Ilpos TI iroTe apa TOW-OP ^Ae^aires oCVa) iroAv
biafyepovra ravff tvl Trpoo-ayopevofjLev oi'onaTt;
5
IIP12. Ma Ai' ov pqbtav rcos eiireii', S> 2oJ)cpaTes, dAX'
5

10

35

2Ii. 'EneWev 8^ l/c TUV avrwv irdA.u'

HPii. no'flej; 877;
2J1. Aii|oj y^ irov Xeyofifv fK&aror^ n;
nPIi. Das 8' oti;
2ii. TovVo 8^ y' ^orl icevovrai;
212. *Ap' ov)' TO 8^os farlv
nPii. Na^ irco^iaro's yt.
212. Flto/aaros, ^ Tr\rjp<airos irai/xaros;

212. 'O Kfvovfj.fvos rm&v &pa, us toucev, firiOvfjLfl r&v

evavriutv ^ iracrxsi' Ktvovpevos yap epa irhrjpovfrdai.
S
OP12. 2a<^tVrar<l ye.
212. Tt o5v; o rd vp&rov Ktvo'iiJ.fVos Utrriv &Tt60ev elr'
ai(T07J(rei 7rAr/p((Te<os ^dirTotr' Sv elre \j.vr\^.rj, rcfurov &
JLITJT' ev Ttf vvv xpovf Ta<r\ei PJT' ev Tip -npAirdev ir<oirore
AS iilv B: om. T
xal seel. Badham
d6 &TTO\OV/KV B :
om. T
e ^ ix Tuv aiirav ird\iv B : irc(\iv <K rail' airwi' T
e 9 Snl/ji T : Sft^T) B : tt^f/v vulg.
7^ ou B : irou T
ixdcrrttri Tt T :
IK&OTOV iri B : ixdtrrorf TIJ al.
6 14 jtii/urros BT : iniyuaros vulg

*1AHBO2
I0
IIP12. Kal TT&S;
212. 'AAAa fi/qv o ye ^in.0vfj.&v Tiros fTn6vfi.fl, <pa.fj.ev.
b
DPil. Flfis yap ofl;
212. OVK apa o ye -nda^fi, TOVTOV em0vfj.fl.
Sii/oj ydp,
ro5ro 8e Kevoxris' 6 8' tindvfji.fi ir\.rip<a<rf(as.
DPIi. Nat.
5
2il. n\T)p()<re<Bs y' apa WTJ TI TSv TOU 8

IlPii. 'AvayKaiov.
2ii. To f/,ev 8^ (T&IJM abvvaTov Kfvovrai yap TTOV.
RPii. Nai',
2Ii. TTJI> >/WXT)" 5pa r^s irXtjpriSo-eais t(p<iiiT(r0
rrj fxvijfirj 87JXoi> on- ry yap ai< IT' AXXy t^ax/'atro;
2ii. Mavfldvoxej' oSv ft
OPii. To iroioi;;
8
11. <4/Aaros iwidvfxfov oi5 </>t)(Tii> t/jiiv oJros 6 Aiiyot
ylyvurOai.

i. Hwy;
i. *Ort TOW licttvov TtaOJHJMcrw ivavrlav Atl rravrds
IIPIL Kal n<iXa.
212. 'H 8' 6pfi?j ye eirl rovvawioz' ayowa ff
iraOijjxara 8rj\oi irov /xnjpv7)i; ovo-ai' rfii; TOIS TtaOrff

ra

DPI2. ndw ye.

'5
212. TV apa eirayov(rm> em TO eiriflwftovfxei'a diro8eias
fiwjpji> 6 Xoyosr i/^x^s oT5fX"'a(r<'
nai. T-ffv dpxV ToC fuou warros
b 6 y Spa B : Spa T
vulg.
IT' B : om. T

c i T$ B T (T(FI in marg. t) : T$ T
C 3 ofa B : ToCi- T

IIAAT12NO2

212. &i\j/fjv apa THJ.&V TO o-<2;ua rj Trewfjv i] TI T&V

TOiovTotv Trda'Xfi'V ovdaftfj 6 Ao'yos alpel.
IIP12. 'AAT/tfe'o-rara.
212. "En 8r) /cat ro'Se ircpl ravra ravra Karai>o?7cra)juei>.
fiiov yap flbos rt /xot (paivcrai fiovXeo-dai 8r;Aow 6 Aoyos
rji^lv ev TOVTOIS avroTs.
HP12. 'Ev ritrt /cat TTOIOU 'Tre/Jt /3tou <j)pd&is;
212. 'Ez> rw TrXtipovcrdcu KOI KfvovcrOai Kal iraviv ocra
<To)Tripiav re eori raiy ^<aa)f Kal rf]v (pBopdv, KCU el TLS
v e/carep&) ytyyo/xe^os ^/*<3i> dAyei", rore 8e xaipei.
xara ras /weray3oA<ij.
OP12. "Eo-rt raura.
212. Tt 8' orav ev jueo-w rourcoy y(yvt\ra.i;
IIP12. 175s1 ey /ixecrft);
212. Ata jtiev ro TrdOos a^yrj, /xejtx^rat 8e rw^ fjbtuv (&v)
yfvo/jLfVtov TiavoiT* av rrjs aXyrjbovos, TrA^peUrat 8e JU^TTO)- ri
rore; (pStpev rj IM] <<2ju,er avrov tv /ueVw rcoy Tra6rjfjidr(i)V etyat;
ITP12. <$>ti>ij.v fj.lv ovv.
212. IIoTepoy dAyoui;^' oAco? ^ \aipovra;
ITP12. Ma Ai", aAAa StTrArj ri^t AVTTT; kwovfjievov, Kara
/uer TO crw/za > rai -Tra^/xan, Kara 8e rr/z> ^v^rjv Trpo<rboKias
TLVL irodto.
212. II<3s, a) TIpd>Tapx_, TO bnrXovv rrjs \.virri$ elves; ap
OVK eort p,v ore rt? fjn&v Kevov/jifvos ev fXmbt. <f>avpd, TOV
TTXrjpa)0ii<T(r6ai Kadfa-TrjKf, rore 8e rovvavriov

10
e

10
36

HP12. Kat /xaAa ye.

212. Mwz> ovv
<rot xaPfi^> M e Kevov^fvos fv TOVTOIS
[rots
d 5 ^H^V . . . veivriv T : 8^j/ . . . ireivrtv B
^y ri>ffo>/u.aB : T^>
<r/ta ^/iwv T
e i Trep' /St'ou B : y8/ou Trept T
64 TOT Stallbaum :
r6rt B T
69 a.\yri E : aAyet'' T
Sv add. corn Ven. 189 : om. B T
e 10 Tr\ripurai B : veTT^pcarai T
b 6 rols x^vois seel. 'Badham

4>IAHBO2

36b

212. Tore ap' cLvOptoTtos not TaAAa Sa AuTremu re a/u,a

xat \aipei.
IIP12. Ka>8wevei.
10
212. Tt 8' 6Yay dyeAiHorcos ex?? Keyovpveyo? T
; ap' ov Tore TO StTrXoSv yiyyoir' ay ire/at
o o~u rw8^ KaTt8o)y <pridr]s duAws e
C
Ta, > 2coKpaTes.
. Tavrr; 8?) rrj o-Ke^ei Tovrcoy TW^ Tra^rjfxaTcoi' To'8e
ITPil. To irolov;
Sli. IToTepoy ctATj^e?s TavTas ras AiJiras Te Kal ^
ij ew;at Ae^o/xev; ^ Tas /xeV Tiyas dArj^eij, ras 8' ov;
IlPil. IIws 8', co Scofcpares, ay eTey v/reuSers rjboval ?)

?) TrpotrSoKtat dA^^eis r) fx?7, ^ 8o'at dArj^els

IlPii. Aoas p-ey eycoy' ay TTOV o-uyx^opofyy, ra 8' eVepa d
511. Hws ^s; Ao'yoy /Jie'yrot Tiya KtySnyevo/jiey ov
v eireyetpeiy.
. 'AAT)0r? Xeyew.
5
212. 'AAA' et Trpos Ta TrapeATjAv^oVa, aj Trai 5Keiyou
irpoo-TjKoyra, TOVTO o-KeTTTe'oy.
. "l(Tu>s TOVTO ye.
512. Xatpety roivvv 8ei Ae'yety rois aAAots /x^Keo"ty ^ Kat
Trapa TO TrpoirrJKOV Aeyop-eycoy.
10
212. Ae'ye 877 poi- OavfJia yap jue' ye e'xet 8ta Te'Aou? del 6
b 13 wv 5); B T : j/Ov vulg.
c 6 ras T b : om. B
c 8 S" T :
om. B
^ T : at B
d 6 Kfivov ravSpds B : Keivov TOV avSp6s T
6 I ^ap jti 76 B : -ycis/> e/ue -y' T
PLATO, VOL. II.

36e

IIAAT12NO2

iTfpl ra avra a wvbrj itpov64^fda airopijfMTa.

ir<as 8?) (prjs;
tyfvbf'is, al ' a\.r)0fis OVK flaw fjbovai;
IIP12. n<3s yap av;
5
212. Ovre br) ovap ov(? vvap, a>s <f)^s, [fcrnv] OVT* kv
pavtais OVT kv 7rapa(j)po(rvvais ovbels e<r#' OOTIS Trore 8o/cei
jaei' xa^Plv> X0'/36' ^^ ovdafJi&s, ov' au dojcei /txez
Au-jreirat 8' ov.
TIPQ. ndvO' ovTQ) Tavra, a> Stoxparey, fxfiv
10 vTretA^apiey.
212. 9A/o' ow opd&s; r) a-Kerrreov etr' opOGts eire JLI^
ravra Aeyerai;
jQPIi. 2/ce7rreoz>, <3? y' eya) (pafyv av.
37
212. AtopL(T(afj.f6a by crcKptorepov ert ro
re :rept Kai 8ot]s*
eortz; yap irov rt
HPI2. Nai'.
212. Kat
HP12. Naf.
212. Kai fjj}]v Kai TO bo^a^p^vov (<TT( rt;
nPH. n<Ss 5' ov;
211. Kat ro ye w ro ri^o^vov i^'Serat;
nPi2. Kat Trciz/t; ye.
212. OVKOVV TO 8o&ov, arre opO&s avTf IMI opd&s
T
y* So^a^ety OVTUS ovSe'irore aTro'AAuo-ty.
nP12. Has yap av;
21L OVKOVV Kai TO rj86p.vov, aWe opO&s &VT /x^ 6p6&s
;rat, TO' ye oWcos i]e<rdai brj\ov a>s ovbfTTOT' aTroAet.
ITP12. Nai, Kat TOI;^' oi/rcos exet.
212. "Or<y Trore ovv 8?) rpoVw So'fa \/reu8^s re Kai a\.r)dr]s
es r& avrii] ravra Badham
irwr S^ <^j/s; alteri dant B T : Socrati
continuavit Badham
65 e'<m/ seel. Stallbaum
e6 irapa(ppocrvvats e Ttto-ais afypotrvvais fecit B : 7re((ra<s aQpofffocus T
6 13 5s
y T : &y B
a 2 TI T : om. B
a 7 T< T : periit in B
ag$
T : is B Td T : periit in B
a 12 So|<% T : So^crj, B
b 4 rovO'
B : raSfl' T
b 5 Srv B T : Ty t vulg.
Sj) B T : 'om. vulg.

3>IAHBO2

37b

fifuv <tA.et yiyvtvQai, TO be Trjs fjbovfjs JJLOVOV dA?]0es,

f>odeiv d' ovT(a? KOI yjnipeiv d/x^oYepa 67x010)9 (ZXrixev
((TKCTTTfOV).

ITPI2. SKCWT&V.
212. *Ap' 6Yt 8or; ^\v CTriyiyvecrdov \^eu8os re /cat
ahrjdfs, Kal lyeWro ov JAOVOV 8o^a 8ta raura dAAa /cat Trota
ns e/care'pa, crKtirrfov tprjs roSr' fivcu;
DPil. Nat.
212. IT/)os Se ye rovrot?, ft Kat TO Trapdirav fifj.lv ra fj,V
etm TToC a,TTa, fjbovT] 8e /cat XvTrrj fj,6vov c^Trep ecrrt, Trotco rive
8e ov yiyvevOov, Kat Ta0' ^/x,ry biop.oh.oyr]Tov.
nPli. Ar/Aoy.
212. 'AAA.' ovSey roSro ye xa^-e'"'oz> t5eti<, ort Kat Troi<a
Tivf waXat yap etTro/xey on /u,eyaAat re Kat (TjutKpat Kat
(T(f>6bpa eKarepat yiyvovrai, XVTTCII re Kat rjbovaL
IIP12. IlayrdVao-t /^,ey ovy.
212. *Az; 8^ ye Troyrjpta TOVTU>V, oo IlpciJrapx^ TTpocryCyvrjTai
nvi, irovrjpav fjiev (^Tycrojuey ovrco ytyyeo-^at boav, Trovrjpav
8e Kat ribovr/v;
HP12. 'AXAa Tt jn^y, a) SwKpares;
212. Tt 8', Sy opdorrjs rj rovvavrLov dpOorrfTi nvl TOMTOM
TTpo<ryLyvr]T<u; p&v OVK dpOvjv /xez> 8o^ay fpovpev, av opOorrjTa
'"X??>
IIP12.
212. ^Az; 8e ye a^apravo^evov TO bo^a^6fj,fvov fj, ryv boav
Tore afjiapTavovcrdv ye OVK 6pOr]V ojaoAoy^Te'oy 0^8' opdGts
ITP12. ITws yap ay;
212. Tt 8', az; a5 kvirriv tf nva fibovrjv Trept TO
b 7 e*Xi?xe Stallbaum : efarjQfv B T
b 8 a-Keirreov add. Baiter
b 10 Sp' grt T : 5pc TJ B
C i iroia B : ^Trofa T
C 5 8e B :
re T
TTotco rfj/e t : irotwj' rtye pr. T : irouav' TIVG B
C 8 TTOIOJ
TIJ/S B T
c 10 crQdSpd] ffQotipal Kal r)ffvxaiTpat Cornarius e Ficino
65 $ T : ft B

10
c

10
d

37e

10

38

IIAAT12NO2
Aweirai rj rovvavriov h^apravovaav (<popG>nev, opOrjv rj
Xpri(TTTjv Tr\ TI T&V KdXGtv ovo[j.aTO)v awrf) 7jpo<r$?7<TO/Aez>/
IIP12. 'AAA* oi>x oldv re, et7re/> a/>iapr?7a-erai ye
5780^77.
212. Kai {J.rfv loifcer ye fibovri -jroAAa/cis ov /oiera 8o^?jy
opdijs dAAa fiera \jfevbovs fifuv yiyve&Oai.
IIP12. 11(3? yap ov; Kai r^z/ /xer boav ye, a> 2wKpares,
ez> roi rotovro) KOI rore Aeyo/xei* i^euS^, r?)z; 8' rfiovT]V avTrjv
ovbels av irore irpoo-eiTroi tyevbrj.
212. 'AAAa TipoOv^s apyveis T& rrjs fjbovrjs, w Ilp^rapxe,
Aoyw ra yw.
ITP12. Ovbev ye, dAA' aTrep axotya) Aey<o.
212. Ata0epet 8' ^/AIV ovbev, 3> Iratpe, 57 fierce bor)s re
opdfjs Kal jixer' e'TrKrr^rjj fjdovr} rfjs yuera rov i^etJ8ovs ical
ayvoias TroAAaKtS1 e/caorcHs T/jixS]
ITP12. EIKOS yoCi> /x^ (r/xt/cpt
212. T?]y 817 bia<popas amolv eTrl deapCav eAfto/Aez>.
IIP12. vAy' oir?; <ro6 <aiz>erat.
212. T^8e 8^| 5yco.
CPU. 11^;
212. Ao'^a, (paptv, fjfuv eo-rt /xey \jtfvbrjs, IOTI Se

IIP12. "Eortz;.
212. "ETrerat /x^v ra^raty, wz>8^ eAeyo/ixev, ^
10 AUTTTJ -TToAAdxts, dArj^et Kal \lsfvbei 8or/ Aeyw.
OP12. ndvv ye.
212. O^/cow ex [jivriiJi.r)s re Kat aiV^o-ecos 8o'^a 57^12; /cat
TO 8ta8oa^etf eyxetpeiy yfyveO'
C
HP12. Kat
e 6 ^ T: /t^ B
e<f>opufj.f v] (pupa/net, Badham
67 ^ rt] ^ ri Stallbaum
a i \eyonev Stallbaum : e'Aeyo/tsy B T
^SovV T : ^Sofj.fvr>y B
a 3 Tip T : rb B
a 8 07^0/05 Cornarius : avoids B T
b 4 r^Se
T : T??S B : vrj Se vulg.
b 9 ^8o/^ . . . AUTTT, T : j,8ovri . . . \fap E
bl
3 fyx*'P*w B T ' 67XP" corr- Ven. 184 vulg. (V&V
Apelt)
yi-yveff Vat. : ^{yi/eo-e' B : ytyverai T

380

Sil. *Ap' ovv ?}/xa$ <S8e Trept raura d

HPQ. IlSs;
2H. HoAAaKlS IboVTl Tivl TTOpptoOev fJLT] TTO.VV CTCUpO)? TCt 5

-vufiaiveiv /3ovAe<r0ai npiveiv <pa6?s &v ravO'

opfy;
HPIi. 4>air)y av.
2i2. OVKOW TO /u,era TOVTO airrbs avrbv oSros ay^potr* &i>
58e;
10

npii. nss;
Sli. Tt TTOT' ap' IOTI ro irapa r^y itirpav roS^' !orraz>ai
<f)avra^6fj.vov VTTQ rivi 8e^8pa>; raur' eiTreti^ ay rts Trpos d
kavrov boKfi aot, rotaSr' arra fcartScbi' (pavTCKrOtvTa awti
Trore;
ovy /xera raura 6 roiouros a>s
irpos auroy enroi rovro, ws ecrriy
HPii. Kai wciw ye.
Sli. Kai irapeyex^eis y' av Ta^' y ws eort
vtov fpyov TO na0opd>ij.vov aya\/jia Trpoo-etTroi.
10
. MaXa ye.
Sil. K^y ju,ey ris y' avr&i iraprj, ra re Trpos avrbv priOevra e
eis <$>toVT]V irpbs rbv irapovra avra r-aCr' &y
, Kctt Aoyos 8r) yeyoyey o^rws 6 rore
nPli. Tf/wji;;
5
SH. *Ay 8' apa fxoVos ^ rouro ravroy Trpos avrbv biavoovuevos, ertore KCU TrXeico ^poVoy e^coy ly avrfi Trope^erai.
C 9 aurbs aurb^ T : ovrb ffavrbv B
ovros avepoir' &v T : oSrws &i/
epoir' &v B
d 2 SoK6?(ro( Coisl. : SOKI? ffoi T : 8oKr,ffoi B
d. 6 rovro
T : om. B
cTrtruxws T : eirirvx ws B
e i fi4v T : om. B
e 2 irii\w T : ir<i\ai & B
63 oSrws B t : OUTOS pr. T
e 6 &j/ S1
T : aAA" B
aurbv] awrbj' T : aurb B

38 e

ITAA-mNOS
IIP12. Ildvv (j.ev ovv.
212. Tt ow; Spa a-ol (pafoeTCu TO Kepi rofaav oirep
i;
IIP12. To Ttolov;
212. Ao/cei /^06 rore rj^v rj i/a>x?7 /3t/3Ata> rt^i irpoo-eot-

IIPi2. ILSs;
212. 'H \Lvr\\LT] TCUS ala-dya-fan a-v^TTLTrTovcra efs TOVTOV
a nepl TOVT eort ra Tra^/zara fyaivovTai poi
olov ypd(f)iv fjp&v ev TOLS ^fv^ai^ Tore Xo-yovs' KOL
OTO.V [&.V aXrjdij ypa(f>ri [TOVTO TO Trct0r)fj.a], boa re a\r]0r]S
5 Kal Aoyo6 O.TT' O.VTOV crvfj-^aivovcrtv aXrjOefs ev rjfuv ytyvofj-evoc ^vbrj b' orav 6 TOLOVTOS 'nap' rjiuv ypa/z/uarevs
ypdijrrj, ravavrLa. rots a\f]6e<riv aTTffir].
b
IIPI2. Haw fjifv ovv 8oKet p,oi, Kal cnrobex^0-1 Pld^vra

39

OVTUIS.

Sli. 'AiroSexof 877 Kal J-Tepov brjijuovpybv f)fj.&v v TOLS

is fv T& ro're yjpovu yiyvopevov.
nPli. Tfva;
212. Z(0ypd(pov, os jwera roz/ ypa^arifrn\v r5>v AeyoetKoVa? 7^ TTJ ^vxfl r^^v ypdfai.
IlPIi. 115? 8^ TOVTOV av /cat TroVe Aeyojuer;
212. "Gray air' oi/^eco? ^f rtvos aAA.?7? atV07/o"etoy ra rore
10 So^a^b'/Aeya /cat Acyo/xera cnrayayriv TLS TO.S T&V 8oa(r0evTwv
C Kal Aex#eVrcoz; elKovas fv avr& opa ircas. rj TOVTO OVK e<rrt
yiyvofifvov Trap' r^uv;
IIP12. ^(pobpa fj.ev ovv.
212. OVKOVV at /*> rwz^ aX-r]Q&v bog&v Kal Xdycw elKoves
5 aXrjdeis, at 8e rwv \jsevbav tyevbfis;
ITP12. TlavTaTracrtv.
e 9 ir(pl robriav T : irepl rovrwv yiyv^^tvov B : vepl rovrov yiyvoftevov Apelt
e 12 /j.oi T: om. B
a 4 TOUTO ri> irdOrj/jia seel.
Badham
a 7 ypdcpp T : ypdtyri B : ypcujyfi Apelt
b 8 \eyopev
B : Kewev T

<I>IAHBO2

39C

SH. Ei by TOUT' 6p6G>s eip?jKa//,ez>, ?n Kal rd8e eiri

rovYois (TKev/^to/xe^a.
IlPfi. To TTOIOV;
Sfl. Ei Trepl p,v T&V OVTMV Kal T&V yeyovoTUV ravra 10
fjiMV ovrco irda-xeiv avaynaiov, Trepl 8e rS>v jueAAoyrcoy ov;
FlPii. ITepi aTTcii'Tcov pev ovv r&v yjpovw axravrcos.
a? ye 8ta r?7S \|/-ux^s a^r^s ^8oial Kat AU-TTOI d
fv rots Trpo<rOev ws irpo rwy 8ta rot) (rco^aros
AinrcSz; TrpoyiyvoLvr' av, &cr$' f]inv (ru/ji/Saivet ro
ipeiy re Kai irpoXvTreto-^at ?re/)t Toy /xeAAozmi \povov
yiyv6fj.vov ;
5
. Ilorepoy ow ra ypdt/x/xard re Kat {/uypa^/xara,
TOV

yeyovora Kal TOV Ttapovra \povov Itrrtv, wept 8e TOZ; /xeAAozra

OVK
ye.
2H. ^Apa <r<pobpa Aeyeis, on 'Trdyr' eori raura
eis roy e-Tretra \povov ov<rai, ^/Aeis 8' aw 8ia 7rai>ros rou 5
jSiou ael y^o^v eATri'Scoy;
IlPii. Hayra-Tracri ju,ey ovv.
SO. vAye 817, irpos rots vw eiprjjue'yois Kat ro'Se airoKpivai.
DPil. To irotor;
SO. Ai/catos dyrj/) Kat evcre/S^s Kat ayaflos Trd^rajs ap' 10
ov 6eo(j)iX.ris eoriy;
riPH. Tt fX7]y;
Si2. Ti 8e; aSixos re Kai TravTairaffi KaKos ap' ov
TovvavrCov eKetya>;
4
nPll. Heos o' o{/;
Sil. noAASy p,T)y lA-jrtSajy, ws eAeyop:ez; apri, -Tray
avBpomros yep;et;
d i aiir^s B T : om. vulg.
d 2 irp6<rOev T : vp&ff&tv
B : Stfuirpoa-Btv Coisl.
d 3 irpoyiyvowr' recc. : vpoyiyvoir' B T
d 4 irpoAuirej<r0ai T : rb irpoAtnre?<r9at B

a 4 7eV' T : 7^ A101

40 a
5

nAATi2NO2
ITP&. TY 5' ov;
2X2. Ao'yot //?;/>

IlPfl. Nat'.
212. Kat brj KOI TO. 0airacr//,ara {faypaffrrjfAevcf
/cat
10 rts opa TroAAa/as1 eai>r<3 yjpvcrbv yiyvo^vov a<p6ovov /cat eir'
awrw TroAAos fidovas' /cat Sr/ /cat ve<a-ypa<f)rmvov avrbv
f(f>' avrto yaipovra <r<j>6bpa Kadopq.
b
nP12. Ti' 6' o{!;
212. TOVTOIV ovv irorepa ^>5>^v TOIS pfv ayaOols ais TO
iroXv TO. yeypa/ijueVa irapaTidea-dai akrjOrj 8ia TO
eivai, Tols be KaKols a>s av (TO) iroXv Tavvavrlov,
5
ITP12. Kal jj-dXa ^areoy.
212. OVKOVV Kal TOW KdKols fjbovat y ovdev T\TTQV
^a>-ypa(f)rjfj.evai,
\jsevo(i$ be aSrat' TTOV.
C

212. fyfvbta-iv &pa rjbovais TO, TroAAa 01 irovrjpol %aipov<nv,

ol 8 ayaOol T&V avQpdmu^v aXyBzinv.
I1PI2. 'ArayxaioVara Aeyety.
212. Etcrty 8^ Kara TOVS vvv Aoyous \{sV?)eis zv rats T&V
5 avQptoTrutv \l/vx<us fjbovai, //e/xt/xr/^eVat fJLfvroi ray
em ra yeAotorepa, /cat AvTrat Se w
212. OVKOVV r\v oodCfiv pLtv OVTU>S aet rw ro
10

ye.
212. Kai rawra ye r\v o?/wat ra aTTp-j/a(6/j,eva
/cat ro \j/fv8&s 8odeiv. fj yap;

ooav

a 9 (pavrtitrnara (TO) Bury

a 10 eavr^ T : eavTp B
ail
faypa.Q-nti.evov B : efaypa.fyrifj.fvov
T
a 12 x^pofra. T : xa

ras B
b 2 TJ> T : od B
b 4 g B T : 5 (Ti>) Stallbaum
c8 O^TCDJ B: ogrws T
09 ^i-own pr. BT et mox
(irf<ro/u.fvoi$

4>IAHBO2

4od

. Nor.
Tt ow;

OVK dira-TToSoreW rats AvTrats re *al

eiz> ev

211. elis rjv jjJev \atpfiv ozmos dei ra> ro Trapairav OTTCOOTow Kal eiKTJ \aipovTi, JUT) IJ.ZVTOI em rors oSo-t //i)5' eTrt
rofc ycyov6<nv eytore, TroAAaKis 8e KCU tcrcos TrAetcrraKts ITTI
rots /xrj8e //,eAAouo-i irore ye^o-ecr^at.
IlPil. Kat raC0' oiiircos avayKalov, Sw/cpares, e^eiy.
21i. OVKOW 6 CLVTOS Aoyos ay etrj ?rep6 (froficov re Kai
dvfji&v Kal TT&VTMV T&V TowvTUVy 09 ecrrt Kat \j/evbi] TiavTa
TO. TOiavra eytore;
IIPH. Havu JAW ovv.
2Ii. Ti 8e; Trovypas bdas nal xprja'Tas aAAcos f]
yiyvo^va's e^o/x,ey
OPIi. OVK aAAcos.
2ii. O^8' fjbovas y ot//,ai
iiov elcrlv TTOvrjpal TrArjv rai \fffvbf1s ivai.
10
IlPil. ITayu juey ovy rovvavriov, a> SwK/oares, eipi]Kas. 41
oy yap roi \jffvbfi juey ov Trayu Trovrjpas av ris Av?ras
re Kai ^Sopas ^eir;, /xeyaArj 8e aAArj Kat TroAArj
2Ii. Tas f/.ey roivvv Ttovrjpas f)$ovas Kat 8t
ovaas roiavras oAtyoy v&rzpov epovfjiev, &v ert SOKT) vG>v
ras 8e \^eD8ers /car' aAAoy rpoirov ev fifjuv TroAAas Kat iroAAaKts evovcras re Kal eyyiyi>o/u,ems Ae/creoy. rovrw yap b
icrcos \pr]cr6^6a Trpos ras KpiVeis.
ITPIl. ricos yap OVK; enrep ye eta-i'y.
2H. 'AAA', & ITpwrap^e, et(rty Karci ye
& i ai/oyKawj' 3 S^Kpares B T : Sco/cpares O.VO.JKOUOV vulg.
e 6 ical
XP^JITT^S olim seel. Stallbaum : /caxp^fTOus Apelt
69 7" B : S T
e lo e?j/e B : y' elvai T
a I irai/u] Tra;/ Badham
{^) fipT]Kas
Paley
a 2 iJ/etfSet B T : ^euSe? Badham
as re T : om. B
8e T : Se /tai B
a 6 ttffrepov epovfiev T : vcrrepov/jiev B
T B T :

om. al.

b 3 76 T : om. B

4ib

IIAAT12NO2

5 TOVTO 8e ro Soyjua eW az> /ce'^rat ira/o' ^/xtiM, d8

dz>eAey/croi> ST/TTOU yiyvtffOai.
IIP12. KaA<Ss.
212. ITe/oaoT&i^e^a 8r/ KaOdirep ad\r]Tal Trpbs TOVTOV cn5
roz> Ao'yoz>.
10
ITP12. "Itoftev.
212. 'AAAa jur)i> etTro/xer, ewrep ^\wf\\i.^6o., oXCyov tv
. c TOIS Trpdcrdev, ws- ora^ at Afyo/xera4 k-jndv^iaL tv rifuv Scrt,
pa ro're ro o-wjua Kai xwP's r^y faxys rols

10

10
e

HP12. Mffj.vijfj.tda
/cat trpoepprjOr] raura.
212. OVKOIW ro jue^ 7riQvfj,ovv rjv 77 i/^vx^ TWZ/ roi;
(Tco/xaroy IvavTioiv e^eoiv, TO 8e r^v dAyrjSoVa ^ nra 8ta
irddos ydovriv TO o-w/xa 17^ ro irape\6yi.fvov ;
OP12. *Ht y^/o oSz;.
212. 2vAAoy^ou 8^ ro yiyvopfvov ev TOVTOIS.
HP12. Ae'yf212. TCyvfTai roCvvv, oiroTav fi raura, a/x,a Trapa.KL<rdai,
AvTras re xat ^Sovds, /cat TOVTMV alcrdrja-ets dfj-a Trap'
aAATjAas fvavTMV ovcr&v yiyveo-dai, o /cat vvvbr] <
IIP12. (fraCvfTcu yovv.
212. OVKOVV /cat ro'8e etp^rai /ca6
S-fj,7rpocr6e /cetrat;
nP12. To irotor;
212. '12s ro juaAAor re /ca^ ^rrov a/a^co rovra)
\VTTT] TC /cat ffbovri, /cat ort r<3z> aTteipav. (iTr)v.
HP12. EtpTjrat. TL ^v;
212. Tts ow fj.r]xavri rai5r'
IIP12. Dfj 8^ /cat
b 8 vfpium&neOa B : irpo<ri(rr<&/j.eda T
e i trp6ff6ev B : e/j.irpoff8tv
T
^ij STOJ' B : eais STor T : fa>s vulg.
e 5 TW^ T b : T^V B
C 6 1-5 8e T b : robs B
0 7 vdBos T b : 7rA?}0os B
irapex^^"ov
B : Trapa$ex6[j,fvov T
d.5 OVKOVV T : om. B
dp efr?;!' BT :
^TTJJ/ vulg.
d r i TIS] rls Stallbaum
e i w^J iroia Heindorf

<I>IAHBOS

4ie

211. El TO fiov\r)[j.a rjfj.lv rfjs Kpurecos rovriav fv TOIOVTOI.S Ticrl biayv&vai /3o7?A.erai e/cdcrrore TLS TOVTOIV TTOOS
aAA.?]Aas jjieifav Kal rts eAaTTooi> KOI ri? /xaAAoy Kal ris
fftyobporepa, Aum/ re Trpos ybovriv Kal \virt] irpbs Xvirrjv Kal 5
ffbovri TTpos ybovrjv.
. 'AAA' eari Taura re rotaCra KOI ^ /3ovA.Tj(rts rr}s
211. Tt oSi'; ev /xei^ otyei TO TioppuiOfv KO! eyyvQtv opav
TO. /J,fy46r] TT\V aXijOeiav d<ainei KCU \jsevbfj voiei $oaeiv, 42
(V XvTrais 8' apa Kal fjbovais OVK eort TOVTOV TOVTO
. IToA.t) //,ey oi
2H. 'Eyayrtoy 8r; TO yw TW 0-p.LKpov l/xirpocr^e yeyovev. 5
ITP11. To Trolov Aeyets;
2H. ToTf /uey al 8oai v^eufieis T Kal aArjfleis avTai
ras \viras Te Kai T/Sovas ^a TOU nap avrats
IIPil.
2il. Nw 8e ye awal 8ta ro iroppcofe'y Te Kal
Ka.(TTOT fj-fTa^aXXofJifvai,
6ea)pel(rOaL,
Trap' dAA^Aas, at juey ^Soz^al Trapa TO \wmqpov
vovrai Kal <r<^)o8poTepat, AuTrat 8' av 6ta TO Trap'
TOVVaVTIOV

fKCLVaiS.

HPil. 'AvdyKrj yCyvecrdai ra roiavTa bia TCLVTO..

2H. QVKOVV oo*to jjifC^ovs T&V ov&Stv eKaT6pat /cal eAarTOUS (fraivovrai, TOVTO aTTOTep-o/ieros eKarepooy ro (^aivofMfvov
dAX' OVK or, ovre avTo 6p6S>s <f)aLvonVov epeiy, 0118' av C
irore ro CTTI rovrw p-epo? TT^S ^8oy^s Kal \virris yi.yv6fj.evov
dpdov re Kal aArjfles roA)u,?j(reis Xeyety.
e 2 ] eo-Ti Apelt (post Titri distinguens)
eg ^v p.ev T :
B
a i iroter T : iroietv B
a 5 ry B t : rb T G
a7
B : o5re T : aural al.
a 8 /cal ^Sopets fi/io B : o/ua Kal rjSovcts T
awTcus B T : ouTois Coisl.
b 2 aural] avrai B T
b 9 l/corepwr
Schleiermacher : eitdrfpov B T
C a TOVTW B T : roCro vulg.
C 3 ro\fjL-f)fffis T : roX/^o-eje B

42 c

nAAT12NO2

IIP12. Ov yap ovv.

212. 'TovT(i)i> Toivw er)s 6\lf6fj.e6a iav rfjbe a
rjbovas Kal \vvas i/reuSei? en /xaAAoy rj Tavras
re /cat ovcras ev rots {wot?.
IIP12. Tloias br] Kal TT&S Xeyets;
212. EtprjTai TTOU TfoXXaKis cm r^9 ^vcrecos CKCL
10 bta<t)0(LpO[ji,evr]$ /xe^ (rvyKpLcrecri /cat 8ta/c/)tcre(rt /cat
d p<&<rc<ri Kal Kevua-ecrt nai ntnv avais /cat <0icre<rt Awat re
/cai irdvd' oiroo-a roiaur' ovo^ara
5

ITPil. Na(, raura efpTjrat TroAAd/ciy.

212. Ei'? 8e ye TT)I> avr&v (pvcriv orav /ca^tcrr^rat,
av rrjv /cardcrracrty fjbovr\v a7re8eajae0a
HP12.
212. Ti 8' orav 7re/n TO o-w/xa //r/8ey TOVTWV
77;
IIP12. rtoVe 8e rovr' ay yivoiro, S> 2w/c/9ares;
e
212. OvSef 7T/)os \6yov eorty, S IT/)c5rapxe
57001; ro eptorrjp.a.
HP12. Tt8^';
212. AioVt TT)Z> e/A^v p<aTrj<riv ov /ccoAvets /xe
5 o-e TraAiv.
HP12. Hotai;;
212. Ei 5' ouz> /ix,^ yiyvoiro, S IT/xarapxe, C/>T?CT&>, ro
TOLOVTOV, rt TTore avaynaiov e amov crv^aivfiv f) fj.lv;
I1P12. M^ KIVOV^VOV TOV
10
212. Dim*)?.
ITP12. A^Aov 8r) rouro ye, 2c5/cpare?, ws ovre 77
yiyvoir' av Iv rw roto^ra) Trore ow' ay rt? \V7rr).
43
212. KaAAtcrr' etire?. dAAa yap ot)uai ro'8e Aeyeis, ats
C 5 ff^s T : <f ^s B
oif-^/ueffa B T : oij^yuefla vulg.
dtaKplfffffi
T : om. B
e i eVriy B T : om. vulg.
/us scripsi : K(o\vei e/te B : /cwAuirets fie T

c 10
e 4 KcoA

4>IAHB02

43a

avaynalov r^iiv ot>ju/3aa>e>, ws 01 (ro(f>oi

dei yap airavra aVco re Kat Kara) pei.
IIP12. Aeyouo-t yap ouy, Kal SOKOUFI ye ov (pavAeos
eiv.
5
2H. 115? yap ay, jar) <paa)Aot ye cures; dAAa yap
TOV Xoyov eTH^epojueuoy rouroy )8ovAo/u,at. r?]8'
. Aeye OTTT/.
. Taura fxev TQ'WVV o^rcos eo-ro), ^xSfiey Trpos rovrous* 10
iroTfpov det Trtivra, biiocra Travel rt rwy b
avrovs o^/re rt rwy TOLOVTU>V ovbcv
rj irav Tovvavriov.
IlPil. aA.Trav brj-nov Tovvavriov dAtyou yap ra ye 5
rotaura \.f\.rjOe Travd' 7y/x,as.
2H. Ov rolvuv KaAfi? 77/^0?^ etprjrat ro yuySi) pr]Qtv, ws
at |u,era/3oA.aJ Ktira) re Kat arco yiyvo^vai Xviras re Kat
fjbovas cbrepyabzmii.
I0
nPH. Ti fwj;
211. ^128' ewrai KaAAtov xai dveTriATj'Trrdrepoy ro Aeyo- C
pevov.

SH. *>Qs at /u,ez> /ueyaXat /xera/3oAat A^Tras re Kat ^8oyas

Troio{5(Tty ^/xiy, at 8' au p-erptat re Kat <r/u,iKpa! ro Trapairav 5
ovSerepa TOTUTMV.
IIPIl. 'OpOortpov oijTtos ri 'Keuws, o> SwKpares.
S12. OVKOW et raura ovrco, TraAtv 6 iw8r) prj^ets /3tos
ay T/'KOI.
ITP&. noios;
10
SI2. *0
a 3 ^eT] peiv ci. Paley
a 10 TOVTOVS T : TO^TOJS B
b i 6?r<{<ra
BT: Sira vulg.
b 5 Hirav 5^) irou Tovvavriov add. in marg. T : om.
B T : post b 6 THJ.S.S add. vulg.
04 <5>s B : om. T
C 9 &>
$}KOI T : avtiKoi B

43 c

I7AATI2NO2
nP12. 'AAijtfeVrara Xeyeis.
212. 'E/c brj TOVT&V Tid^ev r/nrrouy fjfuv fitovs, Hva
V TI^VV, TOV 8' av Xwnrjpov, TOV 8' eVa ^Serepa. 77 TTWS
(^airjy <ru Tre/ot TOVTWV;
ITPH. OWK aAAcos eywye ^ rawr?/, rpe?s eti;at rows fiiovs.
2O. OVKOVV OVK CLV fit]

10
e

10
44

TO IM] \VTTl(rdai 7TOT TOVTOV T<p

ITPI2. Ows yap ay;

212. 'OTTOTCIV ovv anovcrris ws rjburTov Travraw ecrrlv
a\vTT(as StareAeir TOV fiiov airavra, ri Tod' viroAa/xyS^ets
Aeyety rov TOIOVTOV;
I7PI2. 'H8v Aeyety ^a^erat ejuotye owros ro /A^ Av7ret<r^at.
212. TpiS>v OVTU>V ovv f/ijuv, &VTIVMV /3ovAet, ri^ei, KaA\Cocriv tva ovopacn xpw/xe^a, ro /xev \pvcrov, TO 8' apyvpov,
TpiTov 8e ro yw?j8ere/9a TOVTGOV.
HPi2. Keirat.
212. To 8^ fj,r]bfTpa TOVTUV e<r^' ^/mlz; OTTWS Odrepa
yevoiTo &v, \pv<ros % apyvpos;
IIP{2. Kai ircos ^y;
2i2. Owf ^pa 6 fj.<ros ySioy ^8is ^ Avjrr/pos Xfyopevos
6pO&s av Trore oi/r' et 80^^01 ris, 8o^ci{biro, ovr' ft Xeyoi,
Aex$ei?7, Kara ye roy opdbv Xoyov,
HPI2. ns ya/) av;
212. 'AAAa jix^y, & IraZpe, Aeyo'yrcoy ye ravra *ai

. rToVepov ow xat xa'Peiz; otorrat rore orav jot?/

ai;
E[P12.
d 3 OVK &\\ws T : ov KO,\&S B
^ T : om. B
d4
T : \wrijfftti B
d 7 nKovcrps us T : aKofap V<r<as B
d8
8jaT6A6?i/ B : Stare\fTv a,\farus T
e i &VTWV ovv B T : oS
a
le 3 rb ^Serepa T : ^nSertpa B
e 5 5^ B T : Se vulg.
e 9 5o#< B T : So&Cet vulg.
a 4 /coJ B T (sed punctis notavit t)

4>IAHBO2
211.

OVKOVV OIOVTO.I Tore xatpfiv

ov yap av eAeyoV TTOW.

I1P1L Ktu8wevet.
211.

tyfvbf)

ye JUT/P 8o<i<*bt>o-i 'Trepi TOV yaipeiv, etTrep

is1 TOV JUT) At)7reTcr0ai KOL TOV \aipeiv fj Averts e/carepov.

10

IIPI2. Kat fjLrjv \copis ye ^y.

2H. Ilore/aoy ow alpcojue^a Trap' ^/uy raCr' etrat, KaOaTrep
5pn, rpta, T/ 8vo juoya, XVTTTIV

juey KCLKOV rots avOpuirois,

TT/y 8' aTraAA.ayr)y r<Sv XvTrwy, avro TOVTO ayaBov ov, fjbv
TrpocrayopevecrOat,;

nPil. ITwy 5r) ySy TOVTO, co 2criKpare?, fpu>T(afj.eOa

f]fj,&v avT&v; ov yap [Aav6ava>.

v(f>>
5

2H. "Ovrcos yap rows iroAe/xtou? 4>iA.??/3ou ro{)8e, a> IIp<)fj ov p.av6avei.s ;

. Aeyets 8e avrovs rivas;

211. Kat joiaXa 8etyovs Xeyojuevovs ra Trepl (frvcnv, ot TO
vapairav fjbovas ov <f>a(nv elvai.
10
IlPil. Ti fi^;
211. AvTrwy TaijTas ftvai. Tia<ras cnro(pvy&s, as vvv ol Ttepl c
ITPH. TOTUTOLS ovv ?//u,as Trore

211. OVK, dAA.' tocrirep ndvTfcrt Trpocr\pr](r6ai THTI, pav- 5

rfuofiez/ots ov Tf\vri aXXd TIVI bvaytpeiq (pvcreas OVK. aycvvovs
\iav ju-ejutcrrj/corwi' T^I> r^s fibovrjs ovvajjuv KOL V^VO\IIK.OTU>V
ovbfv vyifs, &O-TC /cat avro rouro avrrjs TO kitayayov yo7jreu/>ta,
ov)( fjbovriv, fivai. TOVTOIS [jiev ovv raCra az^ Trpoo-^p^craLo, d
<TK\lra[j.evos en Kat ra aAAa OVT&V Sua^epacrjiAara' /zera 8e
rai5ra a? ye /u,ot SoKovcrti' ^So^at dATj^els elvac ireijcrri, *iva
e afjifpolv TOLV \6yoiv (TK^a^voi r^y bvvapiv avTrjs Trapa/cpicru>.
Aeyetj.
a 9 -ye /*);' B : /ie/ T (^ti)*' t)
b 9 ot r6 vapdirav T : i
. ot rd iropdwa* B3) d i oux T : a\A* oi>x B
riSov^v recc. :
BT
d 3 at . . . 5o/cou<rty B T : & / . . . $OKW<TIV vulg.

44d

OAATflNOS
Sil. MeTa8i<6ica>fiei> STJ rofcovs, &ffirep (Tvp-fxdxovs, KOTO
TO TJJS Suo^epefas a^Tui; i\vos. olp.ai yap Toioi>5 Tt X^yeu>
avroi;s, dpx0^1""^ tioQtv &va>6fv, us fl /SowXrjfleifiey OTOVOSK

C ttSoVS TTJI' <f>VCTlV

l^ftV, OtOV Tf]V TOV <TK\t]pOVt

TTOTfpOV

CtS Ttt

/ irpos TO iroXXoora <rK\7jpoTT)Ti; 8ei 817 <re, co Ilp<>Tapxe,

KaO&irfp Ijxoi, cal TO^TOIS TOIS Swa^pta-iD cmoKpivdrdai.
5
IlPii. Ildwj /*h> oSr, KOI Xcyto ye avrots on wpos ra
npcara p.y#ci.
,
Sli. OUKOW t icol TO T^S J78oi>7Js yevos i8eu> Tjirii'd
iror' l)(ei <j>ti(Tiv f3ov\.t]6ftij:fv, OVK eis ras iroXXooras 7/Sopos
45 diro^XeTtr^op, d\X' eis TOS oKpoTdtTas Kal o-<^>o8poTaTO$
IlPIi. lias Hv <roi Tafcri <rvy\<apo(ri ra vw.
Sii. *Ap' o5i>, ai trp6\(ipol ye atirep ica! /^
5 ^doi'wi', 6 \(yofj.fv TToXXixis, ai Trepi TO a-ufxa eZo-tr avrat;
IIPG. Ilfis yap or!;
Sli. HbVepov o5v Kai ^eCCoDS cJiri ical yiyvovrai wepl TOWS
KafxvofTas ev Tats vrfaois ^' wepl iryiaCvovras; eiXa^rj^Sfxei'
6i fx^ irpowfTws airo/cpivd/xevot irra(<T<a\iAv try. r&xa 7"P
b io'ias ipal^ev af Trepl vyta^ofTas.
IlPIi. EJico's ye.
Sfl. T( 8'; owx aCrat TWV r/boviav vn-ep/3aXAovo-u>, uv a^
cai eiridvju^ai f^yiorai Ttpoytyixavrai;
S
IlPil. Towo fih- aXTj^^s.
2Ii. 'AXX' oix ol imp^TTOVTes xal tv TOWVTOIS roirjjfiairu'
fiaXXor 8i^u<rt ical piyoCo-t xal Tikvra. oirdo-a 8ia
s tl(a6a<ri
fffn1 T : 8ua'x<f>ci(i'av<rii/ B
e 5 iiri T : om. B
e 6 My9" B T : peylfat vu'g8, 4 y T : om. B
olirp] fP
Madvig
a 7 Kal ntlfous T : ^.(fouj B
a 8 iyia(i>ovTaf B : roiis
vytalvorras T
a 9 irp B : jj; T (alteri tribuens) vulg.
riixa
yip T : rA -yckp B
b 4 irpoyiyvwvrai Stephanus : lepoffyiyvovrcu B 1
b 6 4\V oftx B T : Jp' olv ot>x' vulg.
o! B : compendium T : 8r'
apographa
b 8 r' B : 8t T

4>IAHBOS

45b

ictfavs fjbovas fo\ov(nv; r/ TOVTO ov

eii>at;
IlPil. Havv fjiev ovv vvv pf]6\v (jxiCvcTai.
Si2. Tt ovv; 6p0G>s &v (atz>oip,e0a Aeyoyres &>? ei TIS
ras pey Coras fjbovas tSety (3ov\oiro, OVK eis vyfaav dAA.' eiy
vocrov lovras Set (r/coTrety; opa 8e ^77 jae ^yrj bLavoov^fVov
epcarav ere et TrAeuo x.aipov(riv ol a-tyobpa vocrovvTes rS>v
vyiaivovToiv, dAA' oiou jixeye^os jute ^jjreiv 7780^9, Kat ro
(T(f)6bpa -Trepi rou roiotJroi; TTOU Trore yiyyerai eKaorore.
vorja-cu yap 8ei ^ajoiey fjvTtva <pv<riv e'x6' Kat riya Xtyovanv
ol (pa(rKovTs /xr^S' eT^at ro Trapdirav aiiri^v.
nPIi. 'AAAa <rj(e8oy eTrojaat r&> Aoyw (rou.
212. Tci^a, S n/awra/a^e, o^x VJTTOV Seieis. aTTOKptyat
y(ijO* ey i5j8pet /xei^bv? ^Soyas' ov TrAetous Aeyco, rw o-(f)6bpa
8e /cal r<S fiaAAoy v'ntpe'xp'ticra.s opas ?^ ei; rfi <T<a(ppov<, /3iw;
Aeye 8e Tipoo-tyav TOV vovv.
FlPil. 'AAA' HfJiaOov 6 Aeyets, Kat -jroAv ro bi.a(ppov
6p<S. rovs fiey yap a-(^(ppovas TTOV Kat 6 Trapotjuta^o/xeyo?
Aoyos eKaorore, 6 TO " p^Sev ayay " TrapaKeAevo'w TreiOovTdL' TO be T&V a(pp6ix>)v re Kat v^
fjiavias f) o-^obpa rjbovrj Kare'^ouo-a
d'Trepya^erat.
SI2. KaAws' Kal e^ ye ro{;0' ovrcos -xet> ^77^OJ; ws ey
rim irovrjpia ^v^s Kat rou o-wp^aTos, dAA' OVK ey dperrj
fxeytcrrat jaev fjbovat, /xeyto-rat 8e Kat AvTrat yiyvovrai.
Sli. OVKOW Tovrwy uz>as -npotkoptvov 8et
irore rpoirov ex.0^"a? eAeyojaev avras ewat p^eytoras.
b ii o5/ vDi/ B : oSr T
03 ^yfj] ^yer B T
07 8e? T :
Seii/ B
da 8et|ts] 8et|t Heindorf
airfapivou Schleiermacher : airoKpivel: B T
d 6 SiaQepov B : 5id<j>opoi> T
d 76
B T : om. vulg.
e 2 vfiBovrai T : ireidovre B
e 3 ^ T : et B
65 roue' T : TovO' B
e/ BT : om. vulg.
e 10 eAyo/tev B :
\f'yo/ji.ev T
PLATO, VOL. II.

10
c

46a

IIAAT12NO2

46

IlPfl. 'AvayKrj.
212. 2KoVei 8r/ ray raw roi&ySe vooTj/tarcDi/ ^8owis, ru>a
Trore e^oim Tpoirov.
IIP12. Iloiaw;
5
211. Ta? r<2z> aayyuovav, ay o$

IIP12. IToiay;
212. OToz> ray TT/S i/^wpas ia<reis rw rpifieiv Kat
rotaura, OVK SAA.?;? bfopeva ^apj^^fcoy rouro yap 8^ ro
10 -TTfi^os ^/xu;, S Trpos Oe&v, ri Trore <f>&p.V e
Ttorepov fjbovriv rj Xinrr}v;
yiyvzcrOai TL KCIKOV.
2fl. Ov /xev 8?) <l>iA^ou ye evexa Trapedefj.^ TOV Koyov
avfv ToijTMV, 3> Ylpu>Tapx^> T&V fjbov&v Kal T&V ravraiy
<3<n, (rebbv OVK &
ro vvv
5
ITPI2. OVKOVV Ireov firl ras TOVTMV (rvyyevels.
211. Tas fv Trj /Aei^et Koivavovoras Aeyets;
IIPH.
C rots a-^fjiaa-iv, al 8' avn/s r^y ^vxns & rrj ^fvxfl' ray 8' aS
/cat ro{5 o-wjixaroy avevpyo-ofjifv Av?ray fjbovais
rore /*ey ^8oz>ay ra (rvvafjufroTfpa, rore

. ny,212. 'O-Tro'ray ez; rr) /carao-rtio-ei rty r/ rrj bia<p0opa ravavria

-naOi] ^dcrxiJ, Trore ptyaij; dfprjraL Kal 0pp,aiv6fj.vos
nraL, &T&V ot/xat ro fj.v <?xfiv> Tv 8f a7raAA(irT<rOai, TO 8?) Aeyo'/^eyoy TrtK/aai yAvKV ;u,e)uety)ueVoy,
a 5 o6s T : om. B
a 12 ff^^Mrov B T : efufniKrov vulg.
-y*
fip' B : -ye T
b 2 rai^rats T : Tovrrjs B
c i OUTTJS T^S T : aS
rrjs B
o? TIJJ B : ai/rrjs T
07 TTOTC friywv T (sed add. signis
transpositionis) : vor^ piy&v irort B

4 6d

bv<ra.7rah.\aKTias Ttapov, oyavaKT^a-iv /cat varepov <rvvraa-iv

ay pica? TTOKL.
'
nPI2. Kat jj,dXa dAryfles1 TO vvv Aeyo/xez/oy.
212. OVKOVV al roiavrai jueifeis ai /uez> e fcrcoz; et<rt
XUTTWI; re Kat TiovG>v, at 8* eK TWZ> Irepcoy irXewvatv;
IIP12. ITais yap ov;
212. Aeye 8r) ras /xev, oraz; TrAeiovs XvTrai rail' TySoi'ci)!'
yCyvatvrai ras r^9 i/^wpas Aeyo/xez^as ywSr) ra?;ras etz/at
Kat rqs rwy yapyaXifr^atV' oTroray (Iz; rots) tvros TO 4ov
fi Kat TO (frXeyiAOivov, TTJ T/sti/^et 8e /cat T?7 KyTja-ei /x^ {(piKVrjrai
Tts, TO 8' eTTtTroA^s fj-ovov bia^er], Tore (f)povTs els irvp ama
Kat ets TovvavTiov irvpiais /ueTa^aAAoyTes evtoTf a^-^avovs
fjbov&s, Tore 8e Tovvavriov Tots ez>Tos Trpoy Ta TW^ ea>, AVTTOS
^8oya?s (rvyKepao-Oficras, els OTroYep' ay ptyy, Traptcryovro
T^> Ta (rvyKKpi,fJLfva fiia bia^fiv rj TO, 8taKeKpt/xeya o-vy^ery
[KOI] 6/ixoS AvTras 7780^0^ i:apari6^vai.

10
e

5
47

212. OVKOW oirorav av -TrAetcoy f/bovr] Kara (TO) roiama

iravTa o-v/n/Aetx^^, TO /xez> imo^^iy^vov rfjs X.virr]s yapyaAtet Te Ka^ Type/^a dya^aKTer^ Trota, TO 8' av T?/S fjbovrjs 5
TroAt) TrAeov ey/ce^uju.eyoj' (rvvreivfi Te Kat eytoTe 7rrj8az/ irotei,
Kat iravTcna [j,ev y^p&paTa, Travrola 8e (r^juaTa, Travrola 8e
TTVfvuaTa a7rfpya(6fj,vov
Tracrav eKTrArjfiy /cat ySoas fxeTa
afppocrvvrjs
fvepya^frai,;
nPH. MaAa ye.
b
212. Kat Aeyety Te, S kraipe, amov Te Trept eauToi; jrotet
d. I Sffreppv T : om. B ffvvra,(Tiv B t : j^trraffiv T
d 3 i/w
B : j'Oi' 8^j T
d 9 tV TO?S addidi
d 10 Kvfifffi Heusde : Kivhaei
BT
f<j>LKvrjrai T : f<piKve?rai B
e i T& S' eirl TTOA^S B T : T& 8'
6ir(7roA.97s Schiitz
e 2 Trvptcus scripsi : airopiais B T
63 jrpbs
rek TUV Wohlrab : irpoffTaT Tiev B : irpbs rets rojy T
a i oi
seclusi
as Teb add. Par. 1809 : om. B T
as al rijs B T:
avTjjs vulg.
a 6 ir\4ov T : tr\tia>v B
eyKexvpevov B T : /c/cexuHGVOV vulg.
a 8 a.irepyaty/j.ei'ov Buttmann : ewrep'yafj/uej'a BT
S'Q fvepydftTcu T: airep-yci^eTaj B
IDS Ae'yetr TP T: Aeyeiv ye B

Kal a\\ov to? ravrats rals f]boi>cus repTrofjievos olov

07cer Kal ravras ye 8?) TtavTomainv dei />tera8i<y/cei rocrovrw
paXXov oar(d hv aKoXacrrorepos re Kal a^povecrrepos o>v
Tvyx&vr], /cat /caAet 8?) jueytoras ra^ras, /cat rov ez> avrals
ori jaaAtoV aet ^cSyra vbaijj.ove(rTaTov KarapiO^lrai.
ITP12. Ilavra, S 2wKparf?, ra (rv^aivovra Trpos r&v
7ToAA<Sy avOptoirwv els boav bi7Tfpavas.
2Ii. Ile/H ye rwr fjbov&v, w UptoTapx*, T&V ev rols
Koivols Tra6rifj.a(rLV avrov rov (rco^aros T&V eTTiTroX^? Te KOI
evros Kepao-OevTW Trepl be y &v ^v)^! <rw/u,art ravavria
o-u/>t/3aAA.eTai, AVTTTJZ/ re a/xa TT/JOS rjbovriv Kal T]$OVT\V irpos
, WOT' eis ju-tar a^orepa Kpacriv ttvai, ravra e/>i7r/)0o-#e
v, as, OTTOTCLV [av] Kev&Tcu, -TrA^/awo-ecoy eTrt^u/xet,
yi/,er \atpei., Kfvovnevos be dAyei, raura 8e rore
I&V OVK ffj,apTVpdfjLfOa,
vvv 8e Aeyo/uey a>s ^vx^js Trpos <rw/xa
bia(f)epopievr]s fv Tratrt rovrots TrA^ei afj^avois ovm //ei^tj
juia AvTrrys re Ka6 ^Sov^s (rujUTriTrret yevo^vr],
IlPil. KiySuyevets opdorara Aeyety.
212. "Ert TOIVVV fjiuv rwz; jueifecop Aw^s re /cat fjbovfjs
AotTTT/ /Xta.

DP12. Data, <^y;

2Ii. *Hz; avrr)v r^y \}w)(riv av-rf) TroAAa/cts hapfiaveiv
crvyKpacriv e^ajuei'.
10
I1P!2. riws oSv 8^ roi5r' avro Aeyo/xey;
e
2H. 'Opyrjv /cat <po/3ov /cat iroQov Kal dprjvov Kal epcora
/cat (fj\ov Kal <f)06vov Kal ocra roiavra, a/)' ov/c avr^s r^s
r)s Ti0(rai, ramas Away rtrcis;
b 3 Kal #A.Aoc T : /col irepl ^AA.ou B yp> t
b 5 &)/ T : om. B
b 6 aurais T : raurajs B
b 7 fid\iffr' alel T : fid\tffTa fl B
b 9 e/s SJfa*' secluserim
03 Se y' 3>v Badham : 5e TUV B T ^ux^
scripsi : eV ^i/xp B T
c6 05 sed. Wohlrab
Kevurcu B t :
KfKfvtarai T
07 rat/rot Se T : ravra S^ B
d 3 yiyi/ofnevi)
Badham
d.6 \oiir^T: \vTrrjpr. B (ut videtur)
dg ffvyKpafftv
B T : ffiiyicpKfiv vulg.
e^>ayuj'] tysz/jitv Bury
d 10 OUT&] aS
Ast

4>IAHBO2

476

ITP12. "Eycoye.
212. OVKOVV avras rjbovwv /zebras fvp^(rofj.V a^ri^avcav ; 5
r) 8eo/xe0a VTro/xi/mfo-Keo^ai [TO (ez>) rcus dvpo'is KCU rai?
opyafr,] ro
os T (f)tr]K TToXv^povd Trep \aXeTrrjvat.
os T TTO\.V yXvKioov /xeXiro? KaraA.ei/3ojLie'i>oio,
Kat ras ev rots fl/M^oty Ka^ Tro^ois fi^ovas kv AvTrais o{5(ras 48
TlPil. OVK, dAA' oi;rco ravrci ye Ka OVK aAXco? Sy
ivot, yiyvo^va,
. Kat ^7)y Kai ras ye r/oaytKas ^ecop?]<Tets, ora^ a/xa 5

. Ti 5' ov;
212. Trjy 8' ev rats K(o/x,a)8tat? 8ia0e<riy ^wy T?jy
ap' oT(r0' ws Iff-rt Kay rovrois /xeifis XVTT^S re /cai ^fi
IIPH. Ov TT&VV KaravoGt,
212. HavTcnraa-i yap ov pqfaov, co Tlp^rap)(, ev rovra>
crvvvoetv ro roiourov eKacrrore ira^os.
ITP12. OVKOVV &s / eoiKei' e/xot.
212. Aa/3(0HV ye jotrji' aro roo-ourw /xaXXoy ocrw (r/coretvorepov (mv, tva Kai ev ciAAois pqov KaranaOeiv ris otos r'
irys re KOI ^5oy7/s.
. Aeyots av.
212. To roi vuy8^ pf]B\v ovo[j.a <$>66vov wrepa XTJTT^V
nva -tyv-xfls ^o-ei?, ^ TTWS;
HPI2. OVTCOS.
212. 'AXXa fj,rjv 6 (pOovQv ye eirt /ca*cois rois rSv weXas
HP12. 2<|)o8pa ye
e 6 rJ SOT' eQeijitev rots Ovpo'is Kai rats opycus T)> vo\-lifypova. irt
ir^i/at B T : verba transposuit Stephanus : TOIS . . . T^ del. Fischer :
v addidi
e 8, g 8s re Homerus (II. xviii. 109) : Sore B T
a i TToQois Par. 1812 in marg. : TT^TOJS B T to 5 ffiov B : pdSiov T

10
b

10

480

IIAAT12NO2
212.

KO.KOV p.r)v ayvoia KOL rjv by Ae'yo//,ez> d/3eAre//aai' iv.

ITP12. TC rfv;
,212. 'EK br] TOVTGOV i8e ro yeAoibv fjvTiva fyvcriv
5
ITP12. Aeye povov.
212. vE0rti> 8r/ Trovrjpia \i.tv TLS TO Ke^aAatop,
Ttyos TTLK\r]v Aeyo/xev^' r^s 8' aS Trda-rjs irovrjpias
rovvavTiov irddos fXolf

^ Aeyo/ieroi' VTTO rwy e

ITP12. To " yv&Qi a-awov " Aeyei?, oo Sw/cpares;

212. "Eywye. TOVVOVTIOV i*r)v KLV(t> bfj^ov ort TO
vaxTKeiv avrbv Afyojuei'ov T^TTO rou y/oa/x/xaros

HP12. TC rfv;
212. *12 ITpairapxf. 7rei/>5 8e auro ToiJro rpt
ITP12. HT; ^r/s; ov ya/j ^ Swaros S.
212. Aeyeis 8^ Seti' l/xe rowro SieAecr^at ra yuy;
I1P12. Aeyco, /cat 8eo/>iat ye TT/JO? ra> Ae'yei^.
212.
Ap' ouy ov rcoz^ dyyoowrco^ avrov? Kara
TOVTO TO irddos Travyjeiv Znao-rov;

to

rpia.

HP12. U&s;

212. TIp&Tov fj,fv /cara yjpriiMTa, bodetv ttvai TT\ovcn(arepov rj Kara TTJV avT&v ovcriav.
I7P12. IToAAoi yovv elfriv TO TOIOVTOV irddos Ixovres.
212. ITAetouy 8e ye ot /xet^bvs fcal /caAAtous a?5roi>s 8o^a5 &VCTI,, Kat 7raz>ra oora Kara ro oxS/xa etyat dia^epoyrajy r^s
oij(rr]s avrois dA^^eta?.
HP12. Flaw ye.

212. IloAi/ 6e irAercrrot ye ot/uat Trept ro rpirov elbos ro

rwy er ra?? \jsvxals St^/xa/ori/Kao-ty, dper^
10 ^SeArious eaurovy, ov/c
C 2 Hyvoia Cornarius : Sj/oza B T
afe\Tepav~] a0e\reptay Jackson
c 4 5^/ T : Se B
d 4 Se B Stobaeus : SijT
d 7 Ae'-yw B T
Stobaeus : om. vulg.
63 r b B T : om. Stobaeus
e6 awrors
B T Stobaeus : avrris vulg.
e 8 T& rwy eV raTs ^uxJ Badhara :
ro&rcav fv rais \j/vxcus B Stobaeus : tv rais tyvxats rovroov T
69 a/jerp
Stobaeus : aperrjs B T : aperfy al.

4>IAHB02
ITPii. 2<pd8pa uei> o%v.
2H. T<2i> apfT&v 8' ap' ov (ro<ptas Trept ro TrXijOos irdVroos

486
49

epidcou Kat $oo<ro(j)ias e<rri \//~eu8ow;

ou;
2fl. Ka/cw /xei> 6rj Tray ay rts TO TOIOVTOV CITTOIV 6pd&$
civ eiTroi -Traces.
5
2Ii. Touro Toiwv ert &iai/>ereoi>, &> Opwrapxe, 8txa, ei
jxeAAojuev TOI; TraiStKoi/ iSoirey tyOovov aroirov rjbovrjs Kal
O'TTOO-OI ravrrjz; r^v x/fevS?} 8d^ay Trept laurwy a- b
8o|ia^bu(ri, Ka^aTrep aTtavrtdv avdpdfnu^v, Kat rovrcoy
rto-Oai rols jotey pcojur^y avr&v Kal bvvafj.iv,
TOLS 8e otp.at Tovvavriov.
Kij.
5
. Tavrr; roivvv 8ieA.e, Kai oaot p.er avrav eicri /xft'
roiouroi /cai d8vyarot KarayeAco/ieyoi rt^topeicr^ai,
yeAotous rotm>us (pAcrntoV etvai TaXrjOri (^Of-y^r]TOVS 8e
era^at KOI i<r)(i>poi;s ^t>o/3epoi)s Kat ex^pov?
opdorarov TOVTCDV craurw Ao'yoy diroSwo-ets. c
ayvoia yap 77 ptey T<Sz> icrxupwy ^X^/3^ Te Ka' aio"Xpci
,3Aaj3epa yap Kat roiy ireAas avr^ re Kat oo-at etKo
aw^j etcriy17 8' do-^ei'^s ^juty nji' rwy yeAotcoy
rci^tv re Kal
HPii. 'Opflorara A^yets.

ty-vviv.
5
dAAa yap ^ r<3i> ^So^Sy Kat

wy /act^ts ey rotJrots
a i irdvrtas B T : irav Stobaeus
a 2 tyefoovs (sic) B T: Kal
4/58ows vulg.
a 9 ir&s . . . Aeyeis Socrati continual T (post
\eyeis add. va.1 supra versum t) : Protarcho dat B
r^vofj^v B T :
refjLvtafjLfv vulg.
b i travres K.r.e. eidem continual Stallbaum :
alteri dant B T
"b 2 rovrcav T : rovrov B
b 9 KCU Iffx^poiis
<t>ofiepoi>s Vahlen : cpoQepovs Ktd Iffxvpovs B T: <f>o&epuvs na.1 cdaxpovs
Schiitz
C i TOVTUV B : rovrov T : TOVTO vulg.
C 2 &yvaia.
Cornarius : &vota B T
03 aur'fi Heusde : O.IJTT) B T
0 4 avrris
B : ravr-ris T
05 rd^iv ye (sic) /cat B : om T
0 7 ovirca T :
nta B

4QC

I1AAT12NO2

212. Tr]v roivvv TOV <f)06vov Aa/3e

IIP12. Aeye [I.QVOV.
d
212. AvTnr) ns abiKOS eart TTOV /cat rj
nP12. ToSro ^ey avdyKrj.
212. OVKOVV em fj.ev TOIS r<3i> fyOp&v KCIKOLS oi/r'
ovre <f)6ovepov eori ro xaipfiv;
5
HP12. It i^v;
212. Ta 8e ye rc3y <f>&o>v op&vras f(mv ore /ca/ca ^
A.i>7rei<r0cu, yaipeiv be, apa OVK abiKov ecrrt^;
HPI2. HcSs 8' ou;
212. OvKoOy T7)v ayyoiay ei7ro/xei> ort KdKov Ttainv;
10
DP12. 'OpB&s.
212. T^y ow rc5z> ^iXcoy boocro(piav Kal booKa\iav KCU
e O(ra wr6^ Si^A^o/^ez;, ez/ rpicrlv Aeyoires1 etdetrtz; ytyvecrdai,
yeXoia fj.v dirocra a.(rdfvrj, ^icrr\Ta 8' oirocra tppca^eva, {^)&)/Ue^) ^ JU^

(j)&fJ.fV

OTTfp

ITTOV

OLpTl,

T"T]V

T&V

^)tAcoy

^IV

Tavrt]v orav exp TLS rrjv afi\.a/3rj rols aAAots, yeAoiiav

5
IIP12. Hai/u ye.
212. Ka/coz/ 8' ov^ 6/ioAoyov/^ei' avrrjv ayvoi&v ye oZc
ctvai;
nP12.
212. XatpojjLfv 8e ?; \v7Tovfj,e6a, orav ew' avr?)
5
ITP12. A^Aoy on ^atpofiev.
212. 'HSoz/T/z; 8e e^ rots raiz; <^>iA(oy Ka/coiy, ov <f)0ovov

HP12. 'Az/ciyKiy.
212. FeAwiras a/)a ^/>tas em TO?S raw <pi\oov yeAotots
rlv 6 Aoyos, KepavvijVTas fibovyv av (frdova, AVTTI/ T^y
C 8 AojSe Mra/Mif B T : SvvafJ.iv \a/3e vulg.
d i TTOU B : om. T
d 6 Se B T : om. vulg.
d 9fcyi/oiai'Cornarius : &voia.v B T
d it rV B T : T/ vulg.
e i j/Sr 5^ B : /Cj/ T
e 2 birfoa.
B T : (5Wira /xi> vulg.
Q&fufv add. corr. Ven. 189
e6 ^yvota?'
Cornarius : &voiav B T
-ye T : om. B
67 ?/< B et (compendio) T : om. vulg.
a 3 eQapev B T : ^a/x^ Stallbaum
a 6 aS
B : om. T

4>IAHB02
i' TOV yap <)vov
IH&V TraXat, TO 8e yeXaz> fjbovriv, ap.a ytyvtfrBou be
kv TOVTOLS rots \povois.
I1P11. 'AAijfli;.
212. MrjvUjft 87) vw 6 Xo'yos ^juiy ev Oprivois re KOI ei>
rpaywSwus (xai K0)/A&)8iais), /XT) rofc 8pa|ua<rt povov dAAa
xal rry ro ^Siou (T7;/^Tra<rr/ rpayw8ia K
rjbovais a/ua KepavvvvOai, /cat eu aXAois
FTP!},. 'A8ui;aroy ^ 6/^oXoyety Tai5ra, a> SwK/aares, ei
Kai rts <$>iXoviK.oi Ttavv Trpbs ravavria.
211. 'Opyr/i> /u,?)y Kat iroOov /cat 6prjvov Kal (frofiov KOI
epcora Kat rj\ov KOL (f>0ovov irpovOf^Oa Kal o-nocra rotaura,
ez> ois e^a/xey evp^o-ety ju,eiyw/xera ra
Xeyo/xera. 17 yp>
211. May^ciyojuei' ovz> on dpyvov Tiepi Kal (frOovov Kat
opyrjs iravTa eorl ra ruy8^ biomfpavOevTa;
IlPii. II<3s yap ov jj,av0dvofj.ev ;
212. OVKOW -n-oXXa ert ra AotTra;
nPIl. Kat waw ye.
212. Ata 8^ rt /i/,dXtcr0' yiroXa/x/3(ii'ets /ue 8et^a( trot r^v
xe^tv; ap' ov TrtVrecos \apiv, ort T?JZ> ye ey
KOL epcuxn Kal TOIS aXXots /3a8toi> Kpaa-tv eirtAa/3oVra 8e *Toi)ro Trapa travrw a<pclvaC fie
eir' eKelya tovra 8e?v iM]Kvveiv TOVS Xoyovs, dXX' a
eiv rouro, on Kat <r5jua Syev ^vx^ ^a' V
Kat Kotyrj juer' dXX?}Xcoz; ev rot? Tra^juao-t /xeora
eort o-uyKeKpa/AeyTjs ^80^179 XvTrats; ruy ovr Xeye Trorepa
/u,e(ras 'Trot^o-et? vvKras; etTrcoy 8e 0-ju.tKpa oT/u,at
a 8 Jwx*)s T : T*)s 4"*X^S ^
ytyveffdai tie B : Se ylyveaOai T
a 9 TO^TW Badham : TOVTO B T
b i S^ B T : Se vulg.
b 2 al
KcafiySiais add. Hermann
d\Aa /cal T : aAAa B
b 4 ^So^als
B : ^Soj/ets T
b 6 Trtii'u B T : irdvrri vulg.
C 2 i^a^v T :
<f>a.fjLfv B
d 2 (rouTiji T : rawnp B
d. 6 <TvyKfKpa,/jLfvi)S
B.*
Stobaeus :ffvyKeKepaffpeviisT
d. 7 cuplr)s T : a<f>fli}s B

5oa

10
b

10
d

Sod

IIAATI2NO2
<rov ret>e(T0ai /xefleirai /xe- TOVTMV yap cnrdvTMV avpiov
fdeXijarut (rot Xoyov dovvai, TO. vw be eTTt ra AotTra /3oi;Aofiai
0TeAAe<r#at Trpos TTJV K.picriv fjv 4>tA^os eirtraVrei.
IIP12. KaAais eiTres, a> 2to/c/3ares' dAA' 6Va AoiTra ^/xiz>
8teeA0e oirr/ <rot (f)C\ov.
212. Kara (ftijcriv TOLVVV juero ras nei^dficras rjbovas VTTO
bij rtvos avdyKt]s till ras apeiKTOvs Tropeuoi^ie^' Sy ez> TO>

51

nPIi. KaAAior' elves.

212. 'Eycb 8r)
rols yap <f>d<rKov<n Xvir&v tlvai irav\av Tra<ras ras
ov irdvv TTCOS Trei^ojuai, dAA' oirep eiTroy, iiaprvvi
ro rtyas 7780^0? e?yai 80x0^0-0?, oi/eras 8'
erepas rtyay a/>ta Kat iroAAas (pavra(rdfi(ras, flvai 8' avra? crviJ,Tre(f)vp[Ji,vas 6fj.ov Xvirais re /cal
avairavcrefnv obw&v T&V /xeyiorcoi' Trepi re (rco/xaros KOI
tyvxfjs airopias.
b
IIP12. 'AAr/^et? 8' aS rfoas, S Scoxpares, v
6p6&S TLS buLVOOLT1 O.V,

212. Ta? TTfpC re ra KaAa Aeyo/xez^a x/>w/xara Kat ir

ra (r^Tj/xara /ecu rcSy dcr/xaly ra? 7rAetorras *at ras
5 (j)doyy<i)v xat o<ra ras e^Seias avaKrdrjrovs
a\.TjTrovs ras TrA^c^crets ato-^ras Kai r/beCas
XvnG>v\ Trapabiduxnv.
I1P12. Il(3s 8^ raura, a> 2w/cpares, av Aeyo/ner
212. IldVu /xey oSv OVK evflvs 8^Aa eoriy ^ Aeyw, iretC pareov p,rjv brjXovv.
tr^rj/iarcoi' re yap /cdAAos ov^ oirep
av inroXafloiev ol iroXXol ?rei/><S/xai vvv Aeyetz^, ^ ^wz; $
Ttvtov fa)ypa^)T//xaT&)y, dAA' ev^w rt Aeyco, (frrjcrlv 6 Aoyos,
a a yuerajSaA&p B T : /j.eTa\afi&v
t
rifilv B T : V/JH/ vulg.
as irpbs B : compendium T : eirl Coisl.
rb T: re B
a 8 (T<>juaros T : (Tw^ua B
b 2 TIS T : om. B
b 6 Ka6apks \vvwv
seel. Badham
b 9 o3v seel. Badham
c i KO.\\OS (compend.)
T : KoAws B : Kd\\ovs vulg.
c 2 ^ ^y B : olov Cyw T

4>IAHBO2

Sic

-Jrept^epes Kal OTTO TOIJTUIV 8r) T& re TOLS ropz/ois yiyvorfafba re /cm orepea /cat ra rofc Kauotri Kai yc0z;ais, 5
ei JIAOU juayflduets. raCra yap ov/c eii>ai irpos rt KaAa A.eyco,
aaOairep aAAa, d\A' del /caAa Ka^' avra Tre^UKerat Kai
ybovas oi/ceias lxelz;' ov8ev rais rwy /cy?j(rea)y
Kat yjp&iiaTa 8^ roi)roy rov rtrroy e^oira [KaXa Kat
dA.A' apa fj.avOavo[j.ev, ?) -^cSy;
ITPQ. Hetpw/xat jixey, w SwKpares- Tretpa^rjrt 8e /cat
ffa<f>f(TTepov en Xeyeiv.
211. Aeyaj 8rj i)x"s r^y $Q6yy<*>v fas Xeta?
Trpas, ras ez> rt Ka6apbv tetcras /xe'A.os, oi Trpos e'repoz; KaA.as
avras Kafl' a^ras etyat, Kal rovrwy (TV^VTOVS fi
IlPil. vE<rri yap ovy Kal TOUTO.
2Ii. To 8e rrept ras otr/xas rjrTOV fj.ev TOVTWV 0iov ye^os
f)bovu>v TO 8e ^ (rvfj.jj.efjifl'xdai.
ev avrais drayKatovs Xwas,
Kal OTTTJ rovro Kat eV orw Tvyxd^ei yeyovos rjjj.lv, rovr
(KeCvoLs TL6rjfj.t avTiorpo(j)ov airav. dXA.', ei Karayoeis,
raiSra etdrj 8vo (c5y) Xe'yojuei' ifiov&v.
DPil. Kara^ow.
2ii. vErt 8r) rotfuy TOVTOIS Trpoo-^wjmey ras irept ra
jj.a6riiJi.aTa fjbovas, el apa boKovcnv TIIMV avrai Tretvas jmev /Jt^
rou xu0dWiz> ur8e 8ta

10
e

5a

I1P12. 'AAA' OVTCO <ruz;8oKet.

Si2. Tt Se; /ua^rj/xdrtoy Tr\r]pto6(l(riv lay ijffTepov CLTTO- 5
/3oAat 8ta r^s A-T^rjs yCyvatVTai, KaOopas Ti,vas fv OVTOIS

d i Kwhffewv Heusde : Kiv^ffeoav B T

d 2 8$) B T : S^TTOU vulg.
/Ai al ^Soj/os seel. Stallbaum
d 6 ^x^s c'- Bury : rciis B T
T&S \eias T : Ta\eias B
d 7 tetVas (sic) T : iotffas (sic) B
KoAets
T : om. B
e i TOUTOJJ/ BT : om. vulg.
62 avayitaiovs B T :
ora^Kafos vulg.
e 4 eKetvois B T : eKelvys vulg.
e 5 Sy
\fyofnev Jackson : \tyofji.evcav B T
as ytyvouevas T : ytvofuwas B
8 5 irXojpwfleTfftv Schiitz : irArjpwfleKrcSi/ B T

ITPli. Oil TL (pvo-fL ye, dAA.' IV rto-t Aoytff-juots row

b TraOrjfAdTos, orav TIS (TTfprjdels XwrjOr) bia TTJV xptiav.
212. Kal ntfv, &> /jLCLKapie, vvv ye finds avra TO. rfjs
<bv(T(i)$ fj.6vov 7ra$?7/xara x<*>pi-$ Tv Aoyt<r//,ov
ITPI2. 'AXrjdrj roivvv Aeyeis on xa>P<-$
5 yiyvcTai eKaorore ez; rots /ua^fiacrtz;.
212. Tavra? TOIVVV ras rG>v jua^Tj/xdro)!' ^8ovay d/xet/crou?
re eTi'at Awats prjTtov KOL ovba^Qs T&V TroAAwr avOpuiTutv
dAAa TWV cr(p6bpa dAtycoz;.
ITP12. Ilciis yap ov prjreoi^;
212. OVKOW ore /xerptcos 77877 8ia/ceKpi/xe#a X'0/0^ r^s'
re KaOapas fjbovas KOL ras o-^eSov anaOdprovs 6p0&$ av
?, Trpocr^w/xey ra> Aoy&> rats juez^ tr^oSpats fibovcus
, rats 8e /x^ rovvavrCov e/x/xerptav Ka^ (ras) ro
5 /xeya /cat ro <r(pobpov av (8exo/xeva?), /cat -TroAAd/cts /cat
oAiya/as ytyi'o/xeya? rotavras, r^s row arreipov ye e/cetvou
/cat r^rroy /cal /xaAAoz; Std re (rci))uaros /cat
d [TrpotrJ^w/xey avras e?vat yez/ous1, ras 8e p)
DP12. 'OpOorara Aeyets, S Sw/c/aares.
212. "En TOIVVV Ttpos TOVTOLS juera raSra roSe avr&v
c

HP12. To
212. Tt irore x/w/ ^ai'af TT/OOJ dA^etay etvat; ro Kadapov
re /cai etAt/cptves T) ro o-c/>o'8/9a re /cat ro TroAv Kat ro jiteya
/cat ro tra/xoV;

10

I7Pi2. Tt Tror' apa, w 2ci>K/)ares, epcoray /3ouAo'jueyos;

212. M?/8e'i', ai ETpwrapx^ emAetTreti'
b I irad'h/J.aros G t : fnaO-fifnaros B T
b 2 ri B T : oi rA vulg.
b4 A^T; T : dA.^ B
bs yiyvercu T : yfj/ea-e' B
b 7 A.i5wws B T : \&njy G
C 2 &j> T : om. B
c 4 T&S add. Stallbaum
c 5 Sexo^as add. Stallbaum e Ficino
c 6 T^S B T :
seel. Stallbaum auctore Stephano
ye Bt: re T : re y* vulg.
d i 7rpo<r seel. Stallbaum
avriis corr. Ven. 189 : aii-rais B T
ris T: rats B
^ T : om. B
d 4 5ta0eaTeo' corr. Ven. 189:
Hia6erfotf B T
d 8 lrap.6v scrips! : IKO.V&V B T : fort,
Apelt

re Kal eTTiOTT^irjs, el TO p.fv op' aiiT&v eKare'pot) KO.6a.p6v e

ecrri, ro 8' ov KaOapov, rlva nadapov eKarepoy lov eis r)i>
npicriv fj,ol Kal (rol Kal ovvdnrcKn rotcrSe paoo irapf\rj rrji;
npiffiv.

IIP&. 'Opflo'rara.

Sii. V10t by, irept 7ravT(v, ova KaOapo. yey

biavorj6S>fj,v
TrjooeAo'/xevot TrpStrov avr&v cv
IIP&. Tt ovir TrpoeX^/xefla;
53
Sii. To Xeu/cw ev rots Trp&rov, et /3oijh.i, Ofacrta^fOa
yevos,
. Haw /uey ow.
. n<Ss ovy ay Xeu/coS Km rts Ka^apoVrj? ^/xry etrj; 5
ro //eyioTo'y re Kat TrXetoroz; ^ ro d/cpareo-raroy, ev
ITPii. A^Xoy on ro ^d
SH. 'O/>0(3?. ap' oSy ov rouro aXyOta-TaTOV, a>
, /cat cfyxa 8?) KO;XA.t<rrov ry AeuKcSy irayrcoy 6i](ro[j.fv,
dAA' o^ ro TrXeto-roy ov8e ro
ye.
Sil. 2/itxpoy apa Kadapbv XZVKOV juep^etypeyov TroXXou
XevKorepoy a/ia Kai /caXXtoy Kat aXf]6i(rrfpov
eay
ytyz>eo-0ai, Travrd^acriv fpov^fv op6G>s.
IlPii. 'Opflorara /^,ey ot!y.
Sil. Tt ow; ov ST^TTOU iroXXwy Serjo-o'pe^a irapaSetyp.arcoi; ToioijTutv ITT! rw r?/9 ^8oy?js wept Xoyoy, dXX' apm
avrodev a>s apa Kat o~y/x7rao-a f)bovri o-/itKpa
Kat dXtyr/ TroXXrJs, KdOapa X^Trrjs, fjbiutv Kat
dXrjfleoTepa KOI KaXXtcoy yiyvoir av.
es ibr T : tcljr B
63 ai'w B : fiaitas T
e 7 IV Tt T : /
rfffi B
e 8 <rKoirci)jU6>/ B T : SiaffKOTrw/j.ei' vulg.
a a irpurov
B : irpdirois T
a5&j/B:aST
a6 aKpareffraTov B T :
a.Kp6raTov (sic) marg. t
a 7 &AA.IJ T: aA\ct 71 B : JtAAou Badham
ei/e^Tj B : &v efj T
a 9 ou B : om. T
b 5 Aeu/coC T : icaffoPOV B

10
C

53C

ITAAT12NO2

IIPi2. 2$o'8/)a jj,ev ovv, KOI TO ye

212. Ti 8e TO Toiovbe; apa irepl rjbovrjs OVK a
5 &s del yeVeo-is1 eorir, owta 8e OVK l<rn ro Ttapairav
KOfj^rol yap 8?; rives av TOVTOV TOV \6yov
fj.r]vvei.v fjp.lv, ols Se? yfipiv
fyfw.
nPH. TCtj;
212. AiaTrfpavovfAai
<roi rour' avro
IIP12. Aeye /cal ep(ara povov.
212. 'EoToi' 8^ Ttye 8iJo, ro /xey avro <ca^' ai/ro, ro 8'
aet <piefj.vov &XXov.
ITPiL IIc3s rovrto /cat rtvf Xeyeis;
212. To /uey cre/uz>o'raroi> aet TreQvKos, ro 8' eAAtTTes

10

54

TTPI2. Ae'y' en crafyecrrcpov.

212. ITatStKa TTOU KaAa KOI ayada
KCU tpaoTas avbpeiovs avr&v.
ITP12. 2$o'o'/>a ye.
212. Tovrot? TOIVVV eoiKo'ra bvoiv overt 8vo aAAa
/cara Trdvd* Sera Aeyoyuev eirat.
nP12. To rpirov eV e/ow; Ae'ye (rafyeaTepov, S 2<K/)ares,
6Vi Aeyety.
212. Ovbev TI TTOIK.(XOV, S TIp(arap-)(' aAA' o Ao'yo?
pe<r%r]\t v>v, Aeyet 8' ori ro )Me^ eWfca rot r(3r OVTCOV
IOT' det, ro 8' ov \apiv e/cdo-rore ro riios ere/ca yiyvopcvov
del yfyverai.
IIP12. Moyts f![j,aOov 6ia ro TroAAd/cts \.yj)?ivai.
212. Tdxa 8' tcrcos, S TTOCI, /xaAAoy fJiaO^o-ofjLfda
TrpocXdovros TOV Ao'you.
I1P12. Ti yap ov;
C 7 5e? B : S^ T
Cp TOI/T' aurJi T : rovro B
d 5 rot/rw
ex roCrw (sic) T : TOUTO B
d 8 Ae'y er* B : \eye til
B2 rb
Tpirov 6T* tyu Badham : rb rpirov ereptf B T Socrati continuantes
e 5 TOI/ ruv T : roiirwv B
e 6 o5 T : ov B

4>IAHBOS

54 a

2fi. Avo STJ Tabe erepa Xa/3co/>tey.

HPfi. Hoia;
211. A Ey /ueV ri yeVeo-ty TTOVTCW, rrjv oe ovtrCav erepov ev. 5
ITPil. At?o a7roe)(0p:ai crov ravra, oiicrLav /cat yivecriv.
2H. 'O/300Tara. Trorepoy ovz> rovrwz; ei>e/ca vorepov, TTJV
yevecriv oixrias eveKa <f>&[j.v rj rrjv oixriav euxu
ITPI1. TOUTO 6 irpoorayopeverat ovcria et yeyeorews eyexa 10
' eorti' oire/) eori, yuv TrvvOcLvrj;
Sli. 4>a^yo/xai.
. IIpo? 0er ap' [av] eTravepcoray /me roto'ySe rt; b
>fis yiyvecrBai ju.aAA.oj> ^ TrA-ota eVexa vavTrrjyCas, Kal
Sii. Aeyco TOUT' awo, S I
HPli. Ti ow OVK avro? aTtfKpivu) o-aurw,
2fi. Ov8ev art ov' OT> /XCVTOI TOI! A.oyou
IIPX1. ITaw juev ow.
2H. 4>T)/ix,t 8r) yeyeVecos fxey e^exa (pap/xaxa Te Kai
op-yava Kal Tracrav iJArjy TrapariOfcrOaL Tta(nv, eKaoT7]y 8e
yivtviv cLXXrjv aXXrjs ovo-ias TWOS eK(i(rrrjs ere/ca
ITPii. 2a<^earaTa juer oSy.
5
1780^77 ye, etirep yeve&Cs <TTIV, $VKa TWOS
yiyvoiT av.
Sli. To ye ju^v oS erexa ro eyeKa TOU yiyvopevov del
av, fv rfj rou ayafloi) fj.oipa e/ceTro eo-ri' TO 8e 10
ylyv6jj,evov els aAXrjv, S aptare, /xoipay 0eTeov.
b i &/ B T : seel. Badham
firaveptarys B :
. . . b 4 6(TT/i/ Protarcho dedit Badham, Socrati dant B T vulg.
ba Ae'y' Badham : A e y w S B T
^ o f B T : troj vulg.
bs eVe/ca
ante j/ouTrijyios B T : om. al.
b 7 a-v/jL/j-erexe B : perex* T
b 9 /*&>
T : ^' B
03 yf^j/eo-eoj . . . C 4 eVefta T : om, B
04 {u^wao-iis
T : ^vf^irdffT) B
C 9 rb eVe/cd B t : ry eVe/to T

54 c

HAAT12NOS

I1P12. 'AvayKaioTarov.
212. ^Ap' ovv rfbovq ye (imp yevcais eo-Tiv, els a\Xr]v
t] Ti]v TOV ayaOov polpav avrriv TiOivres opO&s Orjcrofjiev;
IJPJ2. 'Opedrara /xey ovv.
212. OVKOVV Sirep apyofAtvos (ITTOV TOVTOV TOV Xoyov, rfi
5 p,r)vvcravTi, Trjs rjbovrjs Trepi TO ytveviv ju.eV, oixrCav be fAtfb'
JIVTIVOVV aiiTfjs elvat,, yjapiv e^etv del' br}\ov yap ort OVTOS
T&V <pa<TKOVT(ov fjbovriv ayadbv elvai /carayeAa.
OP12. 2<f>obpa ye.
C
212. Kal UTJZ> avTos OVTOS e/cdcrrore Kal T&V fv Tals
d

ITP12. IT<Ss 8^ Kal Troicov Aeyets;

212. TSy oa-ot ei<afj,(vot, rj Trtivrjv rj

btyav

5 ToiovTtov, o<ra ytvea-is e^tarai, xa^POV(ri OL<* r

fjbovfjs ov<rr]s avTrjs, nai (pacri r\v OVK &v
bi\jsG>VT(s re *at Treiv&vrfs KCU TaAAa a TLS av etTrot
ra e7ro/Aez^a rots rotovrots Tra^Ty/xacrt /XT) ira<r^oyres.
55
IIP12. 'EoiKacri yow.
212. OVKOWZ; rw yiyvttfdai ye TOVVCWTIOV airaVTes TO
(j)dip(T0ai (pcufj-fv
av.
HP12. 'AvayKoiov.
5
212. T-qv br] (frdopav Kal yeW<nz> alpoiT av TIS TovO'
aipov[j.vos, dAA' ov TOV Tpirov K.elvov fiiov, rbv f v w ju^re
fj.r)T \VTrela-Oai, (frpovdv 5' r\v [bvvaTov] us olov re
ITP12. IIoAA?7 TLS, ws eotKei', ai 2coK/jare?, dAoyta <rt>jui10 paivti yCyverrBai, kav TLS rr)y rjbovrjv <s ayadbv ^
212. IloAA^, tTret fca rr)8e e*rt Aeyco/xev.
DP12. Ilrj;
d 6 extl/ Se? T : exetv Sety B : 8e? exeir vulg.
d. 7 K
B T : -yp. /caTayeAefffeTai t
e i o^ris scripsi : ouris B T : 6 avrbs
Bekker
6 4 ^ vfivrjv T : irejyjjj/ B
a 2 T< T : rb B
T: om. B
a5-mB:<5T
a? Su^arbv seel. Bekker

4>IAHBOS

55b

212. Tl&s OVK akoyov e<rrt /urj8ei; ayaOby eTyai ju,r)6e

KaXbv prJTe h or<6ju,a(ri ju^r' kv TroAAois #AAois TrXrjv ev
tyvxfi, Kai evTdvda fjbovriv povov, avfipeiav 6e r)
77 vow ^ ri T&V aAAcov otra ayaOa e?Arjj(e
TOLOVTOV tlvai; irpbs TOVTOLS 8e en rw fxr) yjiipovra, aXyovvra
8e, dz;ayKa^ecr^a6 (fravai Kattbv elvai Tore orav aXyfj, Kav rj
apicrros -navTcav, KOL TOV ^aipo^ra av, ocrw juaAAoy yj&ipa,
rore oray -)(aiprj, TOCTOVT<I> 8ta0epetz^ Trpos aperiyy.
IIP12. riavr' earl raOra, a> 2coKpare?, &>s 8vyar6y
aAoywrara.
21i. Mr) Toivvv -fjbovrjs ^v iravrcDS f^raaiv Trao-av einTionicracrQai, vov 8e Kai e7no-r7}jw.rj? otoy
a (j>avG>iJ,V' yevvaiws 8e, et TIT/ rt aaBpov e^ei,
, a>s ort K.a0apd>TaTOV ear' awwy (pvaret, TOVTO
ets r^i; Kpicriv xp^Me^a T*)y w-vyv rots re TOVTMV
i rois r^9 ^8oy^s fj-epecnv aAijfleorrarois.
HPIi. 'Op^ws.
21i. OUKOW i7ju,ti> ro /u,ey otjuat Sij/xtoupytKoz; eort T?ys
ra fji.adriij.aTa 7710-777^9, ro 8e Trept TratSetar Kat
r) irG>$;
Ovrcos.
Sii. 'Ez^ T) rats x6^07"^^1^01''5 Sta^OTj05//ev Trpwra ei
ro jmey CTricrTTjjixijs avrutv p.a\\ov \6jj.vov, TO 8' TJTTOV HVL,
KOI Set ra /u,ez> w? Ka0ap<arara vojj,itiv, ra 8' a>s anadaprorepa.

10
d

Owow XP1?. Tas TOLVVV r/ye/jioyi/cas StaArjirreoy eKaorrcoy OVT&V 10

C i Toffovrip B T : roffovTov vulg.

C 4 /iei/ TT^J'TWS B : juej/Toi T
C 6 ^xe'l 7>Xe^ Wyttenbach
e 7 is Apelt : ews B T
c 8 Kpf<ri'"j
Kpacriv Schleiermacher
ToTs re t : rfjs re B T (sed mox al TOLS B T)
d 2 Kai B : ^ T
d 6 T& . . . evi B T : rb . . . 4<rri Schleiermacher :
evi Baiter
d 7 Se? T : 8^ B
a.Ka9apT6repa. B T :

vulg,
PLATO, VOL. II.

DAATIiNOS
ITPi2. Iloias /cat TT&S;
212. Olov Tiacr&v TTOV re\v&v av rt? api0iJ,r)TiKr)v
KOI fAtTpriTiKrjv /cat <rra.Tinr\v, co? ITTOS eliifiv (pav\ov TO
KaTaXenrdfjicvov exaorrj? civ yiyvoiro.
IIP12. QavXov i*ev 8/7.
5
212. To yovv /xera raur' ei/ca^eiy AeiVotr' &v feat ras
/carajueAerav ejwTretpia /cat rtyt Tpi(3fi, rals TTJS
TpocrxptofJitvovs bvvd[j.(nv as TtoXXol
56 firovofjidCovo-t,, jueAeYr/ Kat TroVo) r^y ptofjy
FIP12. 'AyayKatorara Aeyeis.
e

2i2. OVKOW jueor^ jueV TTOU p-ovo-iKy 7r/><3roi>, ro

(fxovov apfJiOTTovcra ov yuerpw dAAa //eAer^s aTo^atr^, /cat

5 0-vfj.Trao-a avrrjs aiiXrjTiKri, TO peTpov e/caorr/y xopbrjs roi
e^et^ ro /x^ (ra</>es, a-fj.iK.pbv 8e ro fitfiaiov.
HP12. 'AA?70eWara.
212. Kat JUT)^ tar/H/cTjy re /cat yecopytai' /cat
/cat orpaTrj-yiKriv axra^rcos vp^trop,fv fyV(ras.
IIP12. Kat Trayy ye.
212. Te/cro/n/a/y 8e ye ot/xat TrAeurroiy /aerpois re
ra
fiy TroAAcSy eT

OP12. Hrj;
212.

Kara re vavnr]yiav

/cat /car' ot/co<5o/u,taz> /cat ei

TroAAoty aAAots r?/s ^nAoupyi/c^y.

M \pfJTai, /cat dt,aj3r]Tr)

mvovi yap

/cat crTa6fJLp

ot/xat /cat

/cat rtvt 7T/30o-ayooyt&)

HP12. Kat Trarv ye, a> 2co/c/)ares, op^ws Ae'yets.

212. >fjLv ToCwv bixfj ra? Aeyo/xeW? Te%vas, ras /iei
e 4 ^ey 8^ B T : /teWot vulg.
a i aTreipyafffievas B T : diretpyo<r/j.fvovs vulg.
a 5 auT^s post a 3 irow transponendum ci. Bury
/coJ KiOaptcrrtK-fi post auAr/rj/c^ add. corr. Ven. 189 ('z/s pulsandi facultas
Ficinus : aS V\I\KTIK^ Heusde)
c i irpoffay<oyi<p rec. t Hesychius
Suidas : irpoffaywyeiy B : irpoaycoyiy T

4>IAHBO2

560

ri (rvvTTOfj,vas ev T<ny epyoty eAarroyos' d/cpt|8eia? 5

, ray 8e
I3P12. Kefo-0a>.
212. Toirrcoy Se ravras aKpi/3eoraras etz^ai T\vas, as
vvvbrj irpuTas ei7ro//,ezJ.
IIP12. 'Aptfl/xTyriKT/y (fraivri jnot Aeyety Kai oo-as jLtera 10
Tenures T\vas l<^^eyfa) znwSi/.
211. Ilayu ju,ey ow. aAA.', S IT/)ci)rapxfj p' ^ Strras d
aw Kai ravras A.e/creoz>; ^ TTWS;
nPIi. noias Sr) Aeyeis;
212. 9ApL0^-r]TiKrjv irp&rov ap' O^K aAArjy /iez; rt^a
TJ]V T&V TioXX&v (partov, aXXrjv 8' av rrjv rS>v (piXocro- 5
. 11^ Trore biopLcrd^evos ovv aXXqv, TTJV be
TLS av apiOiM]TLK.riv;
212. Ov 0-jj.LKpbs opo?, S IIpc)Tapxe'
^ P*v y<*P ^ov
povabas avicrovs KarapiOiAovvTai rStv irepl apiOpov, olov 10
(TTpaTOireba bvo Kal flow 8vo Kal bvo ra o-ju-iKporara rj KOL
ra TrdvTtov ju,eyto-ra' ot 8' OVK av Trore avroty (ruz;aKoAou^?j- e
cretay, ei /x^ povaba p-ovabos eKa<rr?]S rwi' /iuptcor p.r]bffj.Lav
rjs Sta^eponcray rts 0?jo-et.
IlPi2. Kat /x,aAa eS Aeyets oi> crfJUKpav $ia<popav r&v
l apiO^ov TVTa6vT(t)V, cocrre Xoyov e^et^ 8v' avras 5
212. Ti Se; Aoyt(rrtK^ Kai juerpTjTtK^ (^7) Kara T^K.TOVIKT]V
/cat /car' ep.TropiKr)v rfjs Kara 0tAocro^)iay yfco/uerptas re Kat
Aoyio7/,a)Z> Kara/xeAerco/ieywyTrorepov &s ju.ta eKarepa Aexreoy 57
77 8vo rid&fjifv;
OP12. Trj irpocrOev Tr6fj.Vos ey<oy' az^ 8?;o Kara
TiOffyv eKarepay
e 6 T&J T : T& B
T

e 8 &s T : om. B

efaofjiev T : efaoi/nev B

T : rt B
om. B T

c 9 vSc S^ B : 8^ wj/

e 2 /.Lvp'tuv B : /j.opi<ov T

63 TJJ

e 4 e3 B T : 7' e Vat.
6 7 ^ add. corr. Ven. 189 :
a 3 TI) B T : T^S Coisl. : rors Bekker

nAAT2NO2
5

212. 'Qpd&s.
ov o* eWfca ravra TtporjveyKdneOa els TO
, apa evvoe'is;
. "Icrais, dAAa ere /SouAotjUT/v hv a,Tro(j)r]vao-daL TO
vvv eputT&nevov.
2f2. AoKef Toivvv e/xoiye owes 6 Aoyos, ov)( rJTTOv t\
10 ore Aeyeip amov rip\6fj,e0a, rcus TJOOVOLS {YJT&V
(frov evTavda Trpoflef3\.r]Kfvai
(TKOTrutv apa ecrrt rt? e
b aAAr; /ca^apcorepa emcm/ju^s ^Trto-r?///?;, Kadanep fj
HPi2. Kat /xaAa (ra<^e? rouro ye, ort ra{5^' ei/eKa TOVTCW
5

211. Ti oSy; ap' OVK ey jaez^ rors eft7rpo<r0> ITT'

Tfxvnv ovcrav avrjvpriKeiV cra(p<rTpav Kal acra<p(TTepav
aAAr;?;
I1P12. Ilciyj; jixey ow.
212. 'Ev Tovrot? 8e ap' ov rtya Te^vrjv a>s 6fJ.'vv[Jiov
10 (frdey^diJLfvos,
els boav Kara0T?jcras w? /ita?, -jr<iAty a>?
C Swoty eirayepcora TOVTOLV amoiv TO craves Kai ro naQapov
nepl raOra TroTepov fj T>V fyiXo&otyovvTUtv T) /x^ (piXocro-

10

ITP12. Kat //,aAa So/ce? //.ot rouro

212. TiV oSy, ITpcorap^f, avr<S
els (ra^veiav irpoe\.ri\.v0afj,v e7rtcrr?j//,(3y.
212. Ov/cow aTfOKpivov^Ba pqov;
IIP12. Tt /^fy; /cat etpT/cr^co ye ort TroAv /xev avrat
aAAcoz/ rex^wy Sta^epoixrt, TOVTMV 8' avr&v at 7re/ot
a 5 TrporivfyKa/ufOa T : irpoa"riJ'eyK<ifj.e6a B
a 7 T& T : T^y B
a 11 TrpojSejSArj/ceWt"1 irpojSejSTj/ceVat Schleiermacher
er/coTreSi'] ffKoweiv
corr. Ven. 189 : a-Kowbv Apelt
b 5 &\\ois B T : #AA/>7s vulg.
b 6 avnvpfiKeiv scripsi (drrjup^/cet corr. Ven. 189^ : avevplffKeiv B T:
cutevpicricei Schiitz
*coi BT : oS(rav/cetl vulg;.
b TO ,u.tas ^tas^oS(Tr;s}
Stallbaum : fj.(av Badham
c i Svoiv (OVTOIV) Badham
avroTv]
fort. OVTOIV Stallbaum
02 irepl BT : rb irepl Ven. 189 : re irepl
vulg.
^ T: ^ B
05 SiSo/j.ev B : SiSupev T
C 8 cwroKpivov/j.e6a T : airoxpivov Kada B

4>IAHBO2

57d

iq Trtpl p,erpa re KOI api6p.ovs

212. "Eoro) ravra Kara ere, Kat <rot Sr) Tnorei/oyres 0apairoKpLVopeda rots 8ea>ot? Trept Aoycoy oXKTji;
IIPi2. To Ttolov;
5
212. '12s ei(r 8vo dpi^/xrjrtKat
ravrais aA.A.at rotavrat avv^'no^vaL (rvyyai, TT)V
IlPIi. At8<Sju,ey TV^TJ dya^r) rovrot? o^s ^775 8etvovs e
avTijv rr\v aTTOKpunv, u> ScoKpares.
. Tavra? owi' Xeyo/xe^ e7jwnj|u,as aKpi/3e?s

. Haw /Aev oSz;.

5
212. 'AAA' rji^as, S Ilpwrapxe, avaivoir' &v f] TOV
8taAeyecr0at bvvaius, ei Tiva Trpo aw^s a\\t]v Kpivai^v.
E[PI2. Ttya 8e ra^TTjy av Set Aeyeiv;
212. A^Aoy OTIT) Tras &v TTJ^ ye z>w XeyofAevriv yvoii}- 58
r^y yap irept ro oy Kat TO WTCOS Kal ro Kara ramov
det TtetpvKos TravTitis eycoye oTjuat ^yei(r^
ocrois vov Kat crfJLLUpbv Trpocr^pTrjTat
jj,aKp&
yv&crlv. <rv 8e ri; TrcSs rouro, a> Ilpcorapxe, 8ta- 5
IIP12. "HKODOZ; jjxv eycoye, w 2a>Kpares, iKdarore Fopyiou -^oAAaKt? ws ?; row Tif.iQe.iv TtoXv 8ta^>epot Trao-fiy rexv&v
TTavra yap iu^>' avrfj bovXa 81' fKOVTiov aAA' 011 8ta /3tas b
ro, Kai ju,aKpw apioTT) Trafrwr etrj roil'
'
(rot ovre 8 fKeiix S o v A o i y ay evavria
d i &"ra>s secludendum ci. Stallbaum
Kal T : re /ecu B
da /xeVpa
B : TCII fierpa T
d 4 ai!OKpiv6fjiQa. B T : airoKpiv<iifj.e6a Steplianus
8\icfit> BT : ^p. CLKO^V t
d6 /cal 8i;o fueTpyrtKal Tavrats B : al

raurats T

d 7 S\Aat B T : \\ai 8vo vulg.

d 8 St B : om. T

KfKoivwfj.eva.1 B T : KfKoivvvmj.eva.1 vulg.

a i 6rt)j Thompson : orti)
B : ort $) T
TTS &/ Madvig : iraffav B T
a 4 irpoaiiprnTM T
Stobaeus : Trpoff^prjrat B
as post T^ distinxit Hermann
TOUTO
B T : om. vulg.
a 8 Siatptpoi B : Siatpfpet T
ba apiffrv)
iraa&v B : iratrwy aplffTt) T

58b
212. " Ta oTrAa " poi boKfls fiovhyOeis
5 airoXi-neiv .
IIPXL vEo-o vvv ravra ravr-p OTTJ/ croi
2X1. *A/>' ow atrtos eya> row fw) KaA<3? v7roAa/3eu> (re;
ITPii. To TTolov;
2X1. OVK, S <t'Ae n/xorapx.6* rowro eyajye e^rouy TTCO,
C rty Ttyy-r] rj rts eTUfrr?//^ Tracrwy 8ta^e/aet roi /xeyiVrr/ /ecu
apicrrr] K.OL TrXelo'Ta ftx^fAovcra 57/xas, aAAa ris Trore ro
(racf>e$ Kal rd/cpt/3es Kat TO aXrjdeo-Tarov eTrta-KOTret1, /cSy ei
cr^iKpa Kal (T/jiLKpa ovivacra, TOVT' tla-riv o vvv 8ri
5 a/\A' opa ovSe yap aTrex^o"?/ TopyCq, rfj ^v
inrdp'^fLV Texvri bibovs irpbs yjpeiav rots avdptoirois
rj 8' e?7roy eycb yw Trpay/yiaret'a, KadaTrep TOV XCVKOV
ro're eAeyoy, K&V ei cr^iKpov, KaOapbv 8' etrj, row 7roAA.ow
d Kal JUT) TOLOVTOV bicKpepetv, TOVTM y' avr<3 rw d
Kat yw 8r) <r(p6bpa biavorjdtvrfs Kal t
aAA' el rts TT(pvK TTJS
5 epav re rou a\r]0ovs Kal -navra eW/ca ro?;rov
TavTrjv iTT(i)fJi,v Stefepeui'r/cra/xeyot ro KaOapov vov re
(f)povrj(rta>$ el ravTtjv judAtcrra e/c
av ^ rtya krtpav Tavrrjs KvpiaTepav fi
AAAa O"/COTTW, Kat xa^e7roy otyu,at
TWO, a\Xrjv eTrio-r^/xryy r; rl\vt]v Trjs aXqOtia
fj&\Xov rj Tavrrjv.
SI2. 9Ap' oily ivvoya-as TO rotoVSe etprjKas o Ae'yets
5 a>s at TroAAat re'x^at, /cat o<rot Trept ra{;ra
C i ^ T : om. B
C2 apiffrr) (eTvat) corr. Ven. 189
03 et
B T : 77 Cornarius
C 4 oyji/Sira Bekker : bv^vaffa B : bvivacra. T :
oi/^jtratra t
C 6 W7rapxell/] vittpe-^etv Badham (post avBpclnrois
distinguens)
Kpareiv. y 5' B T : Kparfiv S' ^ Badham
C 7 e'-yci)
B : i/t/j' eyi) T
d a wv S^ B : 5^ wv T (sed add. signis trans1
positionis
d 4 dAA f TIS T : SAA.TJ rw B t
d 6 StelepewTjcrdfjievoi T : SiepewTfiffdfj.fi'oi
B
d 7 eKrrjffOai B : KeKTrjffOai T
e 5 g<r<H Ast : oVot B T
raura] rii evravQa. Schleiermacher : ravras
Badham

5ga
TTp&TOV

fJ.V

8oai? -)(p&VT(U

Kal

TO. TTept b6av ^TOVCTL

59

crwrerajxeVios ; ei re KCU 7re/u ^vcrecos T/yeirat ris fyrflv,

or0' on ra ire/at TOV K0(rp,ov rcVoe, OTTTJ re yeyovtv KOL
OTTTJ 7rd<rx.t ri Ka' ^J? Troiel, raura f^re? 8ta )8io
&z/ ram a, r/ TT&S;

nPli. Otmos.
212. OVKOW ov irepl ra ovra aci, irepl 8e ra
Kal ytvr)a6iJ.fva KOL yeyovora f)jj.>v 6 TOIOVTOS
TOV TTOVOV;

avijpr)T(u

vv rt traces az> <^cn^V rr) aKptj8e(rrar?7

ia yiyz;e<r0ai, <3y ^t?]re ecr^f /xrjSei' irwirore Kara ravra b
eei /A?7re eis ro yw Tiapbv fXft>
. Kai TTWS;
511. ITepi ovy ra /AT) Ke/crrj/xeW )8e^8atorrjra jarjd' fjvrivovv
av Trore flefiaiov y(yvo\ff r/juv feat ortow;
5
ITPli. Or/xat jmei> ov8a/xw?.
512. Ou6' a/ia vovs oi5e rts e-TTto-rij/xT] irepi avrd eorty
ro a\.r]6(TTaTov J-\ov(ra..
riPH. OI/KOUV eiKoy ye.
21i. Toy jj.fv 87) o-e Kat e/xe Kal Topyiay Kai <3?ikr)l3ov 10
^^ r(^e ^^ biafj,apTvpao-6ai r5 Aoyo>.
. To TTOIOI;;
c
Si2. 'lis r/ irepl exetz/a ^cr^' 17^11; ro re fStfiawv KOL ro
KaOapov KCU aXr/des Kal o br] Aeyo/jtey eiAtK/ati/es, ^repi ra
del Kara ra avra <acravra>s d/xeixrorara ^ovra, $ [Sevrepos]
Kfiv(DV ort /iaAtcrra eo"rt o-vyyez^e's* ra 8' aAAa Trdvra 5
8evrepa re Kai wrepa
r B : 8<$|as T
a 2 o-ui/Tera^eVcos corr. Ven. 189 : ows B : IwreToy/tej'ws T
eT re] et 8e Schleiermacher
a 3 re B : om. T
a 4 irc<rx B: Trairx]? T
a n oSi/ BT :
om. al.
b i TOUT& T : roCra B
b 1 1 T({Se Se T : TO 8e B
c 2 % Stephanus : ^ B T
03 aArjfles T : T& oAT?0 B
c 4 ret
B : ri> T (sed mox exoyra) : rJ vulg. (et mox exov)
SeiJrepos seel.
Hermann : Seurepcos corr. Ven. 189
05 T& 8' &A\a T : aAA.a B

5gc

IIAATX2NO2
IIPXL 'AAr^e'orara Aeyet?.
212. Ta T) T&V 6Vo/xcmoy Trept TO roiama /caAAiora a/)'
OV TOLS KaAAlOTOtS blKaLOTttTOV CnTOVfjAflV

10
d

IIPX2. Ei/cos ye.

2X1. OVKOVV vovs eort KCU (ppovrjffis

',

a y OLV TLS

HP12. Nat'.
212. Tavr' ^pa ez/ rais Trept ro 01^ ovrcas fvvotais
6p6S>s Ke
2X2. Kai /ur)y a ye ets r^y Kpicriv eya> rore
OVK aA.A' eorty r/ roura ra
ITPX2. Tt /xTjy, S 2wKp
10
2X2. Eier. ro jaey 8r) (f>povrj(T(as re /cat ^
e irpos TT]v dAA^Acoz; pti^iv e rt? <^>atr; KaOcnrepcl
fjjjiiv e &v r/ ev ots 8ei
^y rw Aoya) a
HPX2. Kat
5
2X2. To 8^ /xera raura ap' ov
HPX2. Ti//^/
2X2. OVKOVV raSe Trpoenroucrt KOI avap,vr]<ra(nv fi
avTovs 6pdoTpov av ext;
ITP12. Ta 7ro?a;
10
2X2. *A Kat Trporepof /j.vri(rdr]fj.fv
eS 8' ^ 7rapot//,ta
60 8o/cet
T> Aoyw
2X2. 4>epe 8?) Trpos Atos1 ot/^at yap ovraxri mos ra TOTC
5 \X.Q*VTa pfjOrjvat.
HPX2. n<3s;
2X2. <J>tA?j^o? ^tri rr)y fibovrjv CTKOTTOV opOov
d 10 8)j T : ^ yty B

a i KcH, Sis B T : Sis vulg.

e 2 Se? B : S^ T

e 10 5' ^ T : 5^ B

a 4 ovraffi T : otfrco B

4>IAHBO2
yeyoveVat KOI $fiv irdvTas TOVTOV oro)(decr0ai, KOI
817 Kal rayaObv rovr' avro elvai (rvp.'nacri, Kat ovo 6Vo/xara,
ayaQov Kal f]$v, kvi rtw icai (pwet JJLLO. rovra) 6pd&$
re0eW fyziv Scoxparrj? 8' ey /uta> ov (prjo-i ro{)r' eu>ai, ST;O
8e KaOanep ra ovo^ara, KOL TO re ayaObv Kal fj?>v biafyopov
j)vcnv X.LV> pa^ov 8e /^ero^oy elmi r^s rou
C /xoipas TTJZJ fyp6vr\(riv rj Trjv ybovyv. ov ra{5r' eorty
re jcat ?fz> ra rore Aeyo/xera, w ITpcorapxe;
nPll. 2^>o8pa jaey ow.
Si2. OVKOW Kat roSe Km rore Kal vvv fip.lv hv crvvo/xoAoyotro;
. To Trotov;
. Tr)y rdya^ot; biatyepeiv tyvcnv rw8e rwi' aAAwz;.
. Tti;t;
. ?lit irapei'Tj rour' del rwi; C^^ ^l<* reAous
dvTrj, juu]8ez>os Irepou irore ert iffpo(r8ero'0at, ro
ov reAewrarov exety. 01% ovrtos;
HPll. Ovrco /ixez; ovv.
212. O^KOUI; rw Ao'ya> TTeipdOr][j.ev ^(apls eKarepoy e
repou OevTes els TOV fiiov eicacrrooj;,

6oa

10
b

10
C

HP12. 'Hy raSra.

1
212. M5v ovy 57/j(,ty CLVT&V rore Trorepoy imvov e8oez>
etrat rw;
d
nP12. Kat 3s;
211. Et 8e ye Traprjvf'^O^ij.fv
rt rore, vw oo-rtcrow
(TravaXa(3u>v dpOortpov etTrdrco, //.y^jarji; Kat ^pwrjcrtr Kat
Kat aXridi) Sofay r^s avTrjs tSeas rt^e'jaez/os 5
a 10 TOUTW bpQSis reOevr Heindorf : rovro opO&s redev B T fc i /
Badham : Trpwrov B T
b a T<{ re B T : rrfre rJ) t
al T : /col
rJ> B
b 3 fjLTo^ov B : /j,fTfxot/ T
^ 7 Ka' rrfre T : r^re B
b 10 T<p8e T : T(58e B
TOJ*/ B T : ^SA.A.oi' rwi' vulg.
C 8 &<rauT&ij
Sov^s B : ri$ovrjs wcravrus T
d 4 <pp6vr)(Tiv Kal eiuffT-fifj.yv B : ^ITJT

6od

ITAATJINOS

/cat cTKOTrwy ei TLS oVeu TOVTOIV Sefatr' av ol /cat OTIOVV

eu/at 77 /cat yiyvecr6ai, ^ on 77 ye f]bovr]v (W a>s
eW cos o~(f)obpoTa.Trii>, rjv ^Tf aXr]6G>s 8oa
TO Trapa-nav yiyvwo-KOt ri irore 7reTrov0 Trddos \J.T\T av
e \wf\\i.f]v TOV TtaOovs ^8' OVTIVOVV yjpovov ex.01' Tavra 8e
Aeyerco /cat Tre/n (j)pov^cre(as, el TLS avev 7rao-r]S fibovfjs Kat
r^s fipaxyTdrrjs 8eair' Sy typovrjcriv e\iv //aAAoy ?/ /^era
TIVGW f/bovStv rj Tracra? fi$ovas \u>pls (frpow/io-tcos juaAAoy r/
5 /itera (f>povr)(Ta>$ av TWOS.
ITP12. OVK (TTIV, ) 2<&KpaT$, aXA' ot8ei' Set1 ravrd ye
6l

21i. OVKOVV TO ye reAeov /cat iraa-w alpfTov Kal TO

TravTcnrao-w ayaOov ovoeTepov &v TOVTMV et?j;
IIP&. OcSs yap ay;
212. To roivvv ayaObv ijTOi o-acp&s r; /cat Ttra ruitov avrov
5 \rjTTTeov, 'Lv , oTTep eAe'yojuer, Seurepeta oro> o<ao~oiJ.v
IlPIi. 'OpfloYara Aeyety.
212. OVKOW o86f //.eV rtz^a eirt ra.ya.Qov

212. Ka^aTrep et rty rtva avOpcoirov (JTIT&V TTJV

b TTp&Tov 3p65)s 1v oiKet TTvOoiTo avTov, \iAya TL brjiTov irpbs
Tr)v evpeo-tv av e'^ot TOU ^TOV^VOV,
nP12. Hois 8' ofl;
212. Kat yw bij TLS Aoyos f^vvcrfv rjfuv, uxnrep Kal
5 /car' dp^as, /X.T) ^rer^ ey ro> a/xet/crw /3to> Tayadbv dAA' ei;
r5 ju,ei/cr<3.
DP12. Hciw ye.
212. 'EAirts jUTJy TrAeioov er rw jueix^eWt /caA&iy TO
ecretr^at
d? ^ KI T : if) B
d8 V T: yv B : ^ vulg. : ft Bekker e Ficino
Sod(oi T : 8ofa(>i' B
62 \f-yerco Vahlen : Ae^w B : \e-y6 T
?
TIS T : ^rts B
e6-yeT:T6B
as TT&S yAp Sv B t : om. pr. T
a 5 iKeyonev T : \eyo/j.ev B
b i owce? T : o/c^ B
ireiOoiro B
b 2 &j> exoi T : avfxot B

irvQoiro T :

<J>IAHB02

6ib

OP12. IIoAv ye.

10
212. Tots 8ij Owls, oo HpdtTap-fct, ev^o'jue^ot KepaiWcop-ei>,
e Aiovvcros e'ire r/H</>ai(rros et0' oorts Oe>v ravrrjv TJ\V C
lXrj-^e rrjs <rvyKpd(Tu>s.
IIPil. Haw; fjJev ovv.
212. Kat ^y KddaTrep rjfuv oivo\6ois ricrl Trapeoracn
Kpfjvai /xeAtros jaey ^y aTreiKa^oi rts r?;y T^S fjbovfjs, 5
rrjy 8e r^s <ppovri(Tu>s vrj(pavTiKr]v KOI &OLVOV avcmjpov
KOL vyieivov TWOS vbaros as TrpoOv^T^ov w? KaAAtcrra
. TlG>s yap ov;
2Q,. 4>epe Sr) Trporepov a/oa
fj.iyvvvTes TOV KaX&s ay /jiaAtcrra t
'AAA' OIIK dcr^aAes. ^ 8e aKivbvvoTfpov
civ
, bdav {JLOL 8oKW nya cnrofprivaa-Oai av.
5
HP12. Aeye rtra.
Sflt. 'Hz; ^/Arr rjbovri re aA?]0<3s, ws oiojote^a, /^taAA.oi'
ere/oay aAArj KO^ 81) Kat rexyrj re'x^s aKpt^Qea-repa;
ITPH. rico? yap ov;
212. Kat eu-toT^fxr) 8^ e-TrtcrrTj/x?]? bi,a(popos, f) /jter em 10
ra yiyvo^va K.al airoXXv^va aTro/SAeVowa, ^ 6' eirt ra e
/^?7T6 yiyvopeva ^re a7roAAv//eya, Kara ravra 8e KOI
wcravrcos on>ra det. ravr^y ets ro dArjfles k'
eKetVrjs dArj^ecrrepai' eii>ai.
212. OI/KOW et rdArj^ecrrara rfXTj/xara eKarepas
TrpG>Tov <rvp,[j,fi^avTs, apa iKava raura crvyKSKpaueva TOV
ayaTrrjTOTaTov /3tov aTrepyao-d/xeva Ttapi\iv rjfuv, r) TWOS
ert 7rpoo-ed)ixe^a Ka6 rcoy /x^ TOLOVTU>V;
b 1 1 Kfpavvixafnev T Athenaeus : KepavvvofjLev B
04
iraptffTaffi
B T Athenaeus : Trapetrrwo-J vulg.
C 5 yueAtros B T : Kai fjLe\iros
Athenaeus
07 &s T Athenaeus : om. B
d 7 /AU\\OV T : om. B
d 8 $; al B T : 8^ vulg.
e 4 aJu/iQeffrepav T : ocr^aA.eo'Tepai' B

6aa
62

nAATI2NO2
nPf2. 'E/^iol yovv ooKet bpav OVTCDS.
212. vEcrra) 817 ris i7/uz> <ppov&v avdpwTros avrfjs
on eVrtf, Kat Aoyo/; e^ow eirofjievov r<5 voeiv
Kal Trepl T&V aAA.coz> TravT&v T>V OVTMV
ITPH. vEtrno yap oSv.
212. ^A/)' oi>v OVTOS iKavSis eTTicrrT^/xr;? efe6, KTJK\.OV fxey
l o-^>aipas avrrjs rfjs Oeias TOV Koyov t\<i>v, rr]v 8e avdpaiTavrrjv 0-<paipav KCU TOVS KVK\OVS TOVTOVS ayvoStv,
K.a\ ^pw/xeros er oiKo8ojuaa Kal rols aAXois 6/xotcos Kav6(n
KCU rots KVK\OIS;
ITPli. FeAotay Sta^ecrtr fm&v, 2 ScdK/jares1, ez> rats
p,6vov ema-TTj/Aais Aeyo/xe^.
^s; ^ rou tyevbovs KCLVOVOS a//,a /cat roC
]v ov /3e/3atoi' o^8e Kadapav
Kat vw/KpaTeov;
'A^ay/catoy yap, et /xeAAet rts
eKaorore ^vp^cr^w olKaSe.
212. 'H Kal iJbovcrLKTjv, f)v 6\iyov HfJiTrpoo-Oev e^>a/x,ey arore Kal /ujuTjcrecos juecrr^y ovcray KadaporrjTos evbelv;
ITP12. 'A^ayKatof <paivTai e/^-otye, etirep ye ^iwy 6
s ecrrat Kal omoo-ow irore jStos.
212. BovAet 8^ra, uxnrep Ovp&pbs VJT* o\\.ov TIS udovKal /3iab'|uei'osi, ^rrrj^els dyaTrerao-as ras Oijpas d^xS
ras eTrtcrrTj/xas elarpziv Kal ^iyvvcr6ai 6/xou Kadapa

IlPfl. OVKOVV eycoye ot8a, S 2coK/)arey, ort rts cu>

/SAairrotro 7rd(ras Aa/3a)f ras aAXas e77to-r?jju,as, ex^v ras

2i2. Me^ta) 6?) ras (rv^Trdaras ptlv els rrjv rrjs '
5 Kal /xaAa -TrotrjrtK^s /xKryay/ceiW i
1 4 TrdvTcav B : airdvToiv T
a 9 ra.vTfjv T : Ta,'fni\v T}\V B
b 2 /col TO?S] Kaivols Kal Wohlrab
c 5 TIS B : rtvos T
0 7 iracros
TO;S T : 7rd<ras B
d 4 5^ T : 8 B
d 5 7roi7)Tj/ajs T : TrojTt/cws B

4>IAHB02

6ad

IIP12. Haw jj,V ovv.

21. Me0eurrar KOI TiaXiv eirt rrjy rcoz; rjbov&v TnjyTjz;
treoy. ws1 yap 8tei>o?70T7ju,ez; avras i^tiyvvvcu, ra raw a^rjO&v
/xopta TTpG>Tov, OVK eeyeW0' ^piy, dAAd Sta ro Tracrav
ayanav emcrr?]///^ eis ravrbv ^Q^i^v aOpoas /cat Ttpoardev 10
e
2Ii. "ilpa 8rj /BovXevecrdaL v>v /cat Tre/at raiy fjbov&v,
irorepa Kat rauras micro? aOpoas atptreov rj KCU TOVTOW
Trpcoras jtxe^ereoy ^ju,ry ocrat aXydds,
i. IToAv rt SicKpepei irpos ye dcr^aAetav Trpcoras ras
?s afalvai.
. Me0et<70a)y 817. rt 8e /xera raCra; ap' ov/c et jmeV
dyay/cawu, KaOdircp eKet, o-ujajuet/cTeoy /cat ravras;
nPi2. Tt 8' ov; ras ye dyay/catas SijTrov^e^.
SH. Et 6e ye /cat, /caflcnrep ras T^vas Tracras d/3Aa^3e?
re /cat a>c/>e'A.tjuoz; ^y eirtcrracrflai 8ta ^Stou, Kat i^Sy Sr) ravra
Aeyojuey Trept rwv fjbov&v, et'Trep Trdcras fjbovas r)'8ea-^at 8ta
/3tou crviJ,(f)epov re ^//w ecrrt /cat dj8Aa/3es a7ra(ri, Trdcra?
(njy/cpareoi>.
. ITws oi!y T) Trept avrwy rowrco^ Ae'yco/xey; Kat
511. O^x. ^ds> w Hpcorapxfj Stepcordy ^P^ Ta?
8e avras Kat rds cppo^Tja-ets ^t,aTrvvOavo^vovs ro
dAA?7Aft)y irept.
nPH. To TTOIOI;;
512. "9I2 cpi'Aat, etre 7780^0? v/
d 7 fiedeivTai T : /jLedeivre B
d 8 aur^s B T : BUT& Apelt
d 9 eleyeVefl' Stallbaum : f^eyevf]dr) B T
63 &pa T : uara B
64 acpeTeov T :ffcwpfffTfpovB
e6 rt B : ye T
e8 /j.fdeiffd<av
T : ^0610-60) B
8e T : S^j B
69 rtj/es T : riz/bs B
^K? B :
enfivcu T (sed j/at punctis notatum^
a i ras ex at fecit T : at T&S
B
8.3 \eyo/u.ev corr. Ven. 189 : \eyco/^.ev B T
a 6 Keyca^ev
Ven. 189: \eyopev B T
b a <^>tAai corr. Ven. 189: <fuAe BT
uuas rec. t : ^as B T

i
63

I0

riAATiiNOS

5
6

dAAo> 6r<povv oW/xart, //.aw OVK av 8efat(r#e

(j>povri(rfu>s Trda-rjs T} \topls TOV fypoveiv; " ofyxat p.V Trpos
raura ro'S' aura? dvayKato'raroy etrat Aeyety.
I7P12. To TTotov;
2X1. "Ort Kaddirep eju/7rpo<r#ei' eppijdr], " To JJLOVOV /cat
etAiKpwe? elvai rt ytvos ovre Trayw rt ftwarbv OVT'
irdvT(av ye JU.TJV rjyov^Oa ytvGtv apivTov ev avO'
fvbs crvvoLKelv fjfjuv TO TOV yiyv<i*<TK.ti.v raXAa re Traira /cat
[aS TTjy] avTY]v fifji&v reA.ea)s ei? ovvafj.iv f
DPI2. " Kat KaAcSs ye etpi/Kare ra yw
2i2. 'O/)0<3s. TraAiv TOLVVV juera rouro rr)y (frpovrjcriv /cat
roy z/oyy dzJepcor^re'ozr " 'Ap' fjbov&v rt 7rpoo-6"etcr0e ey r^
hv av TOV vovv re /cat rr)y (frpovrjo-iv
<palev av ttrcos, " f]bov>v; "
Et/cos.
212. 'O 8e y' fifjifTepos
Aoyo? /x,era rour' eo-rty o8e.
" flpos1 rals aXr)Q<nv e/cetrats 7780^0^," ^rfcro^v, " ap ert
Ttpocrbe'Lcrd' vfjuv ra? />ieyt(rras rjbovas (TVVOLKOVS et^at /cat
ray o-<pobpoTaTas; " " Kat TTW?, S 2w/cpares," to-<os
ay, " at y' e/A7ro8tVju.ard re fx,upta ^ry e'xoucri, ras
als oiKovfJifv rapdrroucrat 8td pavias [fjbovds], /cat
re ^/xa? r^y a-pyj]v OVK *&(ri> Ta Te yiyvopeva fjfjiSiv re/cz^a ws
ro TroAv, 8t' d/ueAetay X-r\d-r]v IfiTrotoCcrat, irayraTrao-t biCHpOeipov(nv; dAA' as re ^8oyas a\r]6eis Kat Kadapas [as] etire?,
(rxfbov oiKeias f]iuv vop.L^, /cat TT/OO? ravrat? ras /xe^' wytetas
/cat row (ruxj)povelv, Kat 8r) Kat trvju.Trdo-^S' dper^s OTroVat
Kaddirep deov OTraSot ytyydjueyat avrr;
b 3 OVO/J.O.TI. fjiiav B : ovofna. rifj.>v T
Se|ai(r0 corr. Vat. : 5e|a<r0<u
T (sed i erasum) : $ereai B
C 3 o3 TV T : rV B : seel. Wohlrab
C 6 irpo<r5e?(T06] TrpoffSe?ff0ai B T
07 (f>at/j.ev T :fyafiikvB
C 8 iroicev
T : -jrotov B
(pdiev B T : (f>a?/ufv vulg.
d 4 i<rws T : om. B
d 6 fj.avias scripsi : fiavucas ySovtis B T : /jiaviKas eiri6v(Ji.ta,s ci. Stallbaum
e 3 dA.A' os (secluso mox os) Hermann : &\Aas B : a\Aas T
re
B T : ye Hermann
6?rres T : efrre B
64 TatJrats B T : rat^ras
vulg.
e6 Traj/Tj? T : Tra^r! B

636
Tavras pfiyvv

ras ' dei /u,er' a<j)po<ruvf]s KOI rijs aAA?]s

TroAATj TTOV dAoyia r<S y<5 pziyvvvai roy
OTI KaAAuTTijy iSorra KCU acrracrtaoTOTdrrjy fAei^iy
Kai Kpacnv, fv ravrr/ fj.adf'iv Treipacr^at ri Trore ey T' avOptinrto 64
/cal T Trayri irttyvKev ayaObv /cat rtW i8eav avryv ftvai
TTOT fJ,ClVTVTOv"

O.p' OVK

jJ.(f)p6vU>S

TaVTCL

KGU

I^OiTCOS

roy z/oSf <pri(ro^ev vTtep re avTov Kal fj.v^r]s /cat

6p9rjs airoKpivaarOai TO. vvv prjdevra;
ITP12. Ilai'ra'7ra(r6 juey ovi/.
212. 'AAAa nrjv KCU ro8e ye avaynalov, Kal OVK aAXws ay
rrore yeroiro ov8' ay ey.
IIPH. To TTOLOV;
212. ?iii /x^ /xei^ojuev aXriOeiav, OVK av TTOT TOVTO
aX.rj0&s yfyvoLTo ovb' av -yevopevov eTrj.
nPa. US>s yap av;
212. OvSajLAws. dAA' et nros en Trpoo-Sei rfj (rvyKpavti
Tavrr], Aeyere o-u Kat 4>tArj/3os. ejuoi joiey yap KaflaTrepet
KOO-JUOS rts do-aj/jiaros apa>v KaAws ^^rv\ov <r(ap.aTos 6 yw
Aoyos aTretpyacr^ai </)aiyerat.
OPI2. Kcu l/xot ToLvvv, S 2c5Kpares, ovra) Aeye 8e8o)(^at.
212. *Ap' ow eirt /uey rots row aya0o{5 y{5y ^8?j TrpoOvpois
[Kat] TTJS otKTyo-ecos <p<TTavai [r?js rou rotovrov] Aeyorres
i(rcos 6p6G>s av nva Tpdirov (pafyev;
IIPI2. 'Ejixoi yow SoKel.
2i2. Ti ?)ra tv rfj (rujujuei^ei Tim^Tarov a/xa c
etvai 8o^eter ay ^ju.^ roi) Ttacriv yeyovevai
TOiavrrjV bidde(riv; TOVTO yap lbovTS jaera TOUT'
&& rjfiovfj
etre rw rw -Trpoo-^ueorepoi'
y rw Trayrt
e 7 Tauras B T : TOI^TTJS t
/miyvv' ras Heusde : j^iyi/foras B T
a I &/ raiJTj? (lade'iv B : fj.a6fiv tv Tavrrj T
a 3 e%6vTcas T : e^ovros
B
b 2 n'l^ofjiev T : fi.l^<afiv B t
b 2 &/ T : oa?' B
b 6 /col
T : re /cal B
b 7 Sp|oi' . . <rd>/j.aros B : om. T
C 2 /col et mox
TTJS TOW TOIOUTOU seel. Badham
C 3 opQcos B : opObv T
<pai/u.fv T :
<l>a/j.fv B
c 7 fintrKf^6fjLe6a B : eiriffKt\f/(&fj.eda T
C 8 ^Soi'Tj T : ^8oj/))
B
rip " B T : v$ vulg.
Trpo<r<pvea'Tfpov Heusde : irpovtpvfs re B T

nPIi. 'Opd&s-

TOVTO -yap ds rf)i> Kpfow TIIUV

ern

212. Kol wv KOI trvn'nA.arris ye fxeieioy oil \a\eirbv ibtiv

Tt]v alriav, bC rjv r) -navrbs dui yCyvtrai firurovv T) TO
5 Trapdircai ovbevds.
HPii. n&s \fyis;
211. Ovbeis TTOV TOVTO av6p<a-niav ayvoti.
nPfl. To Ttowv;
212. "On fitTpov KOI r^s <rv^i/xTpot; (frvcreois firf TV10 \ovcra ffrurovv KOI oTruxrovv avyKpao-is -nao-a if droyiCTjs
aTroXXvo-t T&. T Kepavvvfjifva
Kal irpdtinjv avnjf ovb(
C yap (cpa<m dAA.<i rts 5/cparos <rvnirf<poprjnevr)
dXr;6fis
^ Toiavrr) yiyvfTai Ixaorore ovr<os rots (ceKnjfi^i'ois <ru/x-

i. 'AAr/fle'orara.
Si2. NSr 6^ icaraiT^evyei' ^a> ^ TOU dyafloC
Js rrjv rou xaAoC ffrvfftv
fxerpidrr/s yap Kal o
KaAAos- d^irou xal dperr/ iravraxoii ffvpfiaivfi ytyvfaIlPii. ndiw fih> o5v.
212. Koi f*r/y dXi)deidi> ye l</>a/*o> avrols tv TT)

HPI2. ndw ye.

212. OwoSi; eJ /i^ ^iifl Swdfteda i8^a TO ayaflov ^7jpeC<rai,
ow rpto-i \aj36vTfs, KaAXei Kal o-tiju^eTpfa Kal
\iya>IJv as TOVTO olov ei> opfloVar' av afriaerafyiefl' a
^v T^ (rvju/iclc(, Kal 810 TOUTO ij dyadov iv Toiavrrjv
5 yeyoreVai.
nPG. 'Op^Tara /itv oJv.
212. *H8)j Tofwf, a. ITpwrapxe, kaios ^tr y^voir' iv

65

OffTUTOVV

KplTrjS

TJOOVrjS

Tf

Tfipl

Kal

<f>pOlrf(TfU>S,

OTt6TfOOV

d 3 xal /iV /ta! B : o! ^v T

d4 < T: ^ B
oiTi T:
irdvras B
d 7 TOU B : irw T
d 9 utrpov B T : /t4rpor vulg6 I <rvnw(ipvpniyr) Liebhold
e 5 ^IK B : i)/i' T
69 OUTOIS T :

lavrors B

a i fojptvffcu B yp. t : Ojjffavpltrat

4>IAHBO2
OVTOLV TOV apiffTov truyyeWorrepw re Kai rijuuwrepov ev b
avOpawois re eori Kal Oeols.
IIPt. AT)AOZ> jue'v, ojuuos 8' ovv TW Aoyw eTre^eAflety
/3eArioi>.
SH. Ka0' Iv eKaoroy TOLVVV T&V rptaw irpo? rrjv f]bovr)v 5
Km roy voCj; fcpiya)/jiey SeT yap t8ery irorepa) (a>s)
IlPIi. KdA.Xous Kat dA^^eias KOI /Aerptorrjros
A^yets;
Sii. Nai. Tip&Tov 5e ye aXr)6eias \aj3ov, a Hpcorapx6' 10
3Ae\^as eis rpta, i^ouy /ecu dX7]0etay Kai c
(rvyyevecrTepov rj vovs
I1PH. Ti 8e xpo^or Set; iroXv yap ot/uai
,V yap aTrayrcoz; dAa^byicrTaroz;, &>s 8e Xoyos, xat ey 5
rats fibovals TOLS irepl rd<po8una, at 8r) ^yicrrai boKovviv
elval, Kal TO fTnopKetv crvyyvw^riv eiArjcpe -Trapa OeG>v, a>s
KaOairep naibwv T&V fjbov&v vovv ov8e TOV oXlyicrrov /ceKrrj- d
jaeycoy voOs 8e Tyrol ravrw Kal dA.9]0eia l
6/xoidraroV re ical dAr/^ecrr
SI2. O^KOW ro [if.ro. TOVTO rrjr /Jterptorrjra o
(nttyai, irorepoj; ^Soyr) ^po^aecos 77 <ppoz>r]cris ^801^775 TrAeico 5
IlPil. Evo-Keirro'y ye Kal ravrrjv (TKC'^I
jLai yap rjSozn/s /xey Kat Trcpi^apfias ovbev rS>v OVTU>V
d/uterpwrepoy evpety eh; riya, yoS 8e Kat TT LOT/I fj,rjs
0118' &y er Trore.
10
b 3 oSv B T : aS vulg.
e'lre^eXeeTv T : eVeA.ee?*' B
b 6 &s
addidi auctore Badham
bio Aa/3o? BT: eS \o3oi! vel e>Aa|8oC
Stobaeus : o-i; A.aj8oO Biicheler
c 5 aA.ofoi'firTaToi' B Athenaeus
Eustathius : oA.aCoj'eerTaToi' T Stobaeus Eusebius
d i T&V
B T : om. Stobaeus
ybov&v B T : ij5ofi.ev<av Eusebius Athenaei E
d.4 uffavTws B Stobaeus : us oSrus T
dp, 10 a.[j.vTp<S>repov . . .
e/ijiieTpe^Tepov B T : a,/j.erp6rfpov . . . e/ijUeTprfrcpov Stobaeus Eusebius
vulg.
PLATO, VOL. II.

10

IIAATX1NO2
Sli. KaA<3s ftprjKas.
o/xcos 8' en Ae'ye TO rpirov. vovs
v xaAAou? /jtereiArjc^e TrAeZoi' 17 TO r?/? fjbovijs yevos, wore
etvai /caAAia) vovv 7780^77 s, 17 TovvavTiov;
IlPil. 'AAA' ow <ppovr]criv fjifv Kal vovv, 3) S(tiK/oares,
5 ovSeis irwTrore 0$$' VTrap ovr' oWp alcrxpbv ovre eZSev ovre

ovre yiyvo^evov ovre ovra ovre

10
66

Sfl. 'OpO&s.
I1P12. 'HSovas 8e ye' TTOU, KCU raura crxeSoy ra? /oieytorras,
oray rdcojutev r)bop,vov OVTIVOVV, rj TO yeAowr eTr' aura's 17 ro
Trayrcoi; a?crxto-roy kiropevov o/xSyres avroi re ala-^vvo/jLcda
KOL a(f>aviovTs KpvTTTO^Lfv oTi /xaAitrra, WKrl iravra ra
rotavra 8tSoVres, &>? ^)ws ov Seoz; opav avra.
2fi. ITayr?; 8r) (p-tja-eis, o> ITpcora/a^e, VTTO re ayyeAtor
Tiefj.'ntov Kal irapovffi
typafav,
a>s f/bovr) KTrjfj,a OVK eori
irp&Tov ov8' at! bevTepov, dAAa Trp&Tov \iiv Try Trepl fttTpov
Kal TO pcTpiov Kal Kaipiov Kal Ttawra. oTroaa yjn] TOiavTa
vopifav, Trjv "^afoiov fipf)o-0ai.
ITP12. 4>atyerai yovv fK T&V vvv AeyojueVcop.
Sii. Aevrepoy /LIT)^ Trepl ro o-v/xjaerpoi; jcat KaAov KCU
ro reAeor Kai tKaz/oy Kai Trayfl' o7roo-a r^s yereas av raurr^s
ecrriz;.
riPO. "EotKe yow.
212. To Toivvv TpiTov, cos TI [j.r] pavTfia, vovv Kal
<ppovr)o-iv TiOtls OVK av /xeya rt Trjs aXrjQfias 7ra/3ee'A0ois.

e 2 yevos B T : /iepoy t
64 dAA* Stallbaum : 3p' T Stobaeus :
i{p' B
oSv T Stobaeus : odv ^ B
e 6 firevAriffev B T : virev6ii<rev
Stobaeus
ovSa/u.^ B T Stobaeus : ovSa/*oS Eusebius
eg 8e 76
irow B T : 8e irou Stobaeus : 8e ye 8^ wow Eusebius
raDro B T : rat5TOS vulg. Stobaeus Eusebius
a 7 xpb TOIO.VTO. B Eusebius : roiavra
^pjj T Stobaeus
a 8 alSiov] fort, /u^ vel vptSiri^v itieav
ypriffOai
Stobaeus : ypr)<rdai B : flpJjcrBat (fidffiv T : flprjff6ai tyfoiv vulg. : jjfyjTjfffleu
fyvfftv Badham
a 9 yoCi' B T Stobaeus : o3/ vulg.
b 2 y evens
B T : yeveffews Stobaeus
aS rauTjjj B T Stobaeus : Tu4ri}S uS
vulg.

4>IAHBOS

66b

212.

*Ap' ovv ov rerapra, a rijs \ISV~XTJS avTrjs

T /cat re'x^as /cat 8oas opOas Aex0euras, ravr'
ra irpos rots rpicrl rerapra, enrep row dya0oO ye eari C
ov \ji] TI/S f]bovT]S (rvyytvij;

. Tax' y212. ITe/xTrras roivvv, as ^Soyas fOe^ev aXijirovs opicrdpevoi, Ka6apas fTrovofJidcTavTts rfjs \lfV)(fjs avTrjs, eTriorTj/xcus1, 5
ras 8e alcr
212. ""EKTT] 8' er yerea," (pt](Tlv 'Op<pv$, " Karairavcrare Kocr/xor aot8^s-" drap K6z;8urei;ei /cat 6 ^erepos
Aoyo? > e/cr7j /caraTreTraup.ei'os etrat /cpitret. ro 81) p.era 10
i/dey AOITTW TrA^y uxnrfp Ke^aAr/y a7ro8owai d
T1P12. Ov /
.
212. V10i 77, ro rpCrov rfi orcor^pi roz> airrbv StajuaprvpaAoyoy e7reeA$<oju,ei>.
5

npii. notov 877;

212.

4>tA?3os raaOov ert^ero r ^ i y fovrV eZvai Tra<rav

ETP12. To Tpirov, 2) 2ci)/cpares, ws eotKas, eAeyes dprtcos

roy e apxys tTTavaXafitiv deiy Aoyov.
10
212. Nai, TO 8e ye p,era rouro aKovfo/xey.
eya> yap 8r) e
Kari8a>y S-Trep z>w8r) SteATjAvfla, /cat SvaAo'yoy ow [Jiovov dAAa /cat aAAwy TroAAa/cis
f)bovfj$ ye rous eTi] ju,a/cp<S jSeArioV re Kat a^wov r<5 rwy
tw.
5
zl raCra.
b 8 Sp' oSv ou rerapTa T : ap' ou rerapTa, B : dp' o6i/ oi>8' Jackson
oirrijs ede/j.fis B Stobaeus : 0e/tej/ KUTTJS T
C i Tcropra T Stobaeus : rerrapa B
ye T : om. B
C2 ^ seel. Stallbaum
C 5 fTri(j-TT]/j.a.is corr. Ven. 189 : emirr^as B T
c 6 Ts Badham : TaTs B T Stobaeus
eno/ievas T Stobaeus : evofufvai B
e 2 j/vv S^ B : vvv T Eusebius : vvv\ vulg.
SieXfavda T : Sucrxep^as
u0a B
e 4 eft; B : 65^ tiv T
jnoKp^i T : yua/cpbs B

66e

HAATi2NO2
212. TiroirreiKoi' 8e" ye ical aAAa elimi iroXAa tlvov &s
el tpavefy TI TOVTOIV &p<poa> /Se'Arioi', virep T&V oevrepelow
v& irpos nbovTjv owbio.jJiCwoiiJt.ijVt fjbomj 8e ical 8cvrepcwov

10 orep7}<roiTO.
67
IlPii. Eiires yap ow.
Sli. Kai jiero raiJrd ye ir&vrtov Uaixsrora ra&roiv ov&trepov IKOVOV
5

212. O/cow iraDTairao-ij; er rot/ro> ru Xoyw ical

aT)7AA.ajcro ical 17801^ ]a\ TOI rayadov ye anno /i?j8' Urtpov
oxroiv flvai, a~r(pofj.fvoiv avTapKfias KOI TT/S roii ixaroC xai
reAeov 8wa/j.ea)s;
DPIi. 'Op06rara.
10
2Ii. $ar^vTos 8^ ye aAAw rpirov Kptlrrovos TOVTOIV
exar^pov, /xvpi&) y' 08 wws ^801^9 oi/ceiare/K)!' cal irpooxfwe'artpov TTf<pavrai vvv TJJ roS VIKWVTOS JSe'a.
RPli. Da? yap o;
212. OvKOVV TtifOTTOV

KO.TO. TT]V

KpC<TU>, fjV

VVV 6 \OJOS

S dire^jraTO, yfyvotr' ii ^ r^s

b

212. Ilpurov 8^ ye ov8" ir ol iraWes ^oes re cal

ical TaXXa oT//xiravra ftjpfc ^<ri Tip TO
ols irioret/oj>res, (Scrirep /xdweu tipvurw, ol iroXAol xptvovffi
Tas fibovas tls TO fiv fipiv e5 Kparforas etpai, ical TOVS
5 drjpiiav epcora; otorrai xvpiovs ftvai pjiprvpas
TOVS T&V iv p.ov<rrf (pi\o
\6yu>v.
IlPi2. 'AA7)^<rrara, a
f v &TTOVTCS.

<icpary, t o - a <rot

e 8 TI B : T& T
roirroiK T : ro^rw B
a 9 /(tov^raTo T :
/KoyiSraToi' B
Ta^raiy T : rolnuiy B
oMnpoy T : ot Stir'f""'
a 3 Ifxfo'i) B T : iyt$6vTi Eusebiui
a 7 imponJvon> corr. Ven.
189 :ffTfpoftJrarBT
a 10 rodroiv T : roimxr B
an 7
oZ T : a? B
b i oiiS' B T Porphyrius : obr vulg. Eusebius
bs Ipuratt: ^KrajBT
b 7 x<iyr T : A^o* B

2il. QVKOVV Kal d<iere /xe;

10
IIPI2. 2/uKpoz> en ro Konrov, u> iSw/cpares' ov yap
o~6 ye airepeis irporepos fjn&v, yTro/xyTjfrco 8e ere ra

b ii rb \oiir6v B : AoJirrfv T
faralpeis corn d : airapeis vulg.

b 12 direpels T: airopeTs B :

2TMHO2ION
AIIOAAOA12PO2

ETAIPOS

AIIOA. AOKUJ fxot Titpl >v TrvvOdv(r6f OVK d/xeAerrjTos a

flvat. Kal yap truyxavov Trp^rjv ds aarro oinoBev aviu>v 3>a\r\poOfv T&V obv yvoopfatov TIS oTna-dfv Kar&riv /ixe Troppadev
fn6Xf<T, Kal Tratfcoy afj.a TTJ KA.?7(rei, "*H <&a\r]pvs" <j)r],
"otros rA7roXA.d5oo|Ooy, ov Trepipeveis;" Kdyco eTritrras TTC/OI- 5
epfiva. Kal os, " 'A7roAA.o8a)pe," e^r;, " <cat pyv KOL Hvayxps
o-e e^Tjrow /SouAojuevos Stairu^eo-^ai r?)y 'Aya^coyos <rvvov<r[av
KOI StoKparovs Kal 'AAKtjStadou Kal rwi> aXXav rS>v rore ev b
TrapayVO[Ji.V(i>v, irepl TWI; epwriKwr Aoycop
yap rts /u,oi Strjyetro aKrjKocos 4>otytKos
TOU 4>tAiinrou, l^)?] 8e Kat (re etSerai. ctAAa yap ovbsv e?x.e
<ra<pfs Aeyeu>. o-i oSy /Ltot StTyyT/oraf StKaioraros yap et 5
TOVS rov eraipou Aoyous aTrayyeAAeiy. irporepoy 8e juoi,"
^ 8' os, "eiTre, <rv avros irapeyevov rfj (rvvova-iq ravrp rj ov; "
Kayo) etTTov on " ITavrd'Tracriy COIK^ o~ot ov8ei> 8trjyeZ(T0at
<ra(pes 6 StrjyotJ/uteyo?, e6 refoort T/yfj TTJU (rvvov(rCav yeyovcvai c
ravrrjy 771? Ipcoras, ^ore Kat l/ie 7rapayeye<r0ai." " 'Ey() ye
a i ow/c B T W : /w OWK Methodius al.
a 4 5 B T W : 6 al.
a 5'AiroAAfJSwpos seel. Badham
irepijueVejsTW : Trept/tevetj B : irepi/t'e?s al.
b 2 (ru!/8ei7rj'<j> B Methodius : irvv^enrvelv T : ffi/vSeiirvy
W
e 2 Kal V B T W : /ca/xe Athenaeus
e^cc 76 8^, e</>ij scripsi :
7&>7 3^ B T W : fyi yap e^(j/) Athenaeus : 7017', e<j>tj Badham

v, rjv b' iy<a, u> T\O.VKU>V; OVK oto-0' STI

iroAA&>i> fT&v 'Ayd0a>v ivO&be OVK emSeSjjp.ijKei', a<p' ov 8'
5 ey<u 2a>/cpdret ow8iarpi/3<o KOI e'mjueAes irfiroCrifjMi IKOOTTJS
f][j.epas flotvcu. STI ai> \eyrj rj irpdrrr/, ov8e7ro> rpfa Irrj etrrlv;
173 irpd roO 8e irfpiTptytov OTTTJ TTJ\OIIJLL Kal otdpfvos rl iroiflv/
O0\ll&TfpOS

TJ OTOVOVV, OV)(

JJTTOI> ^ (Til wvl, Ol6fJVO$

bflV

/LiaXAoi' irpaTTfiv ^ faKoa-ofytiv." Kol 3y, " M^/

'," l<^)7j, " dAA' ets-e fiot wore lyevfro r) <rwov<r[a
KdyweiTror oTL"Tla&>a>vovT<avTHJ:&vfTi, orerjjirpurj;
fViKrja-fv 'A-yddotv, rfj v<rrepa(q r\ if ra eiwucia
fi' avrds re Kat ot \opevrai." " Tldw," tyfj, " &pa 116X0.1,
a>s ioiKfv.
dXXa rty trot 8i7/yeiro; ^ avrbs 2a)Kpdr7js;
b " Ow /xo TOV Aia," ^v 8' tyna, " dAA' oo-irep 4>oijiKi. 'Apioro'8r)/iOf ^v ris, KuSoflT/raitvy, a-fUKpos, oinnto^rjros afi' irap8' ei/ T^ <rwou<ri^, IxoxparoDS epaorijs &v er TOIS
T5i> TdVe, is ^f*ol SOKCI. ov I^VTOL dAAa ical
5 2a)Kpdrj) ye Ivia 7/817 avrjp6y.^v &v tutivov fjnowra, KaC juoi
8t7jyeiro." " T^ o5v," I^J/i " ov
i ^ 68oy ^ eZ
iropeuo/xeVots xal X^yetv icat ^Koveu'."
Oi/ro) 8^ ZoWes 5fia TOWS Arfyous wept avrfij'
C <3ore, 3*7rep apx^evos eriror, OVK d/neA.er7jra>s ex. ' ^
8ei Kal vfuv &irjyrjcraa-0ai, TO.VTO. xp^l iroieii'. Kol yap lytoye
Kal aAAco?, oraj' ptv nvas trtpl (piXocrotftias Xrfyovy ^
TOV ot(
rtvas, aAXtos
rois vpfTtpovs TOVS T&V TtKowltav Kal xp^arKTriKwr
re cfx^ofiai ifias re roi/s eraipors l\e, 5ri olecrde rl iroieti>
oiSer TTOIOVVTS.

Kal ItTCOS O.Z VfJLflS

IfJ.^ ijytlfrQf

KOKobaClMVa

o 4 Ivitit om. Athenaeus

a a ij Tb : jji pr. B : )) W t
cw( B :
TOi/TW as irpiiryom. Athenaeus
a6 ^TW: A B: J) Schanz
a 8 rtt B : r(T W
b I &\\o<rwtp B T W
b a wapayty^ti B T W
b 4 /ta! B W : om. T
b 6 tnry^aa B T : 81^,07 W : 8rxw - v
b 7 * /j B T : fI, W
d i ;Mi ^.Ifffla, B T :' 7?ff. ij< W

2TMIIOSION
flvat, Kal oiojLiai v/ixas a\i]drj ote<r0at* eyco /neWoi v//,as OVK
oto/xai dAA' eS oloa.
ETAI. 'Ael ofjioios eT, 'AiroAAo'^oope- det yap VOVTOV
TC KaKrjyopfis Kal TOVS aAAouj, Kal SoKefc fxoi drexixSy 5
dflAious fiyficrdai TrXyv 2coK/)arous, diro craurou
os. Kal oirodev wore ravrrjy TTJZ/ ^(avv^iav eXa/3es
ro /xaAaKos KaA.ei(T^at, OVK ot^a lycoye- ey /ixei' yap TOIS
det rotouTos t, o-aurw re /cat rois aXAois aypiatvcis
riv 2a>Kpdrous.
10
AITOA. *Ii <j)i\TaT, Kal 8^Xw ye 8^ ou ayrco 8ia- e
voovfj,fvos Kal TTtpl ffjiavrov Kal irepi vp,S>v [laivo^ai. Kal
TrapaTratco;
ETAI. OVK CLLOV Trepi TOVTW, 'A7roX\o'8cope, i>i> fp(eiv
dAX' OTrcp e8eo'f>te^d cnw, /x,^ aAAcos 7roi7j(rrjs, dXXa StTjyryo-at 5
ot \oyoi.
AFIOA. "^Ho-ay roivvv ZK&VOI rotoi8e rtyespaXXov 6'
a>s eKeivos dajyem) Kal eya) Tret/adorop-at 174

ydp ol ScoKpdrrj tvrvyj&v \f\.ovp.vov re Kal ras

jQAairras inrobebf^fvov, a eKeiz/oy oAtyaK6? enwer Kal epecr^at
avroz; OTTOI n oiiJrco KaAos -yeyfvrj^vos.
5
Kal rov etirery on 'E^rl 8ennw ets 'Ayd^coros. X^^s y^P
aiirbv bityvyov rot? fTrtVLKtots, (pofirjOels TOV
Aoyrjtra o' f l s r^fJifpov vapea-fcrOai.
rama 8r) e
, tva KaAos irapd KaAov fco. dAAa crv, ^ 8' os, TTW
ro e^eAeir av lei^at aKArjros em
Kdyw, e^>Tj, ewroz> ort
/xera/3aAovres, ws dpa Kal 'Ayd^coy' ITU Sairas ia<rii
d8 /iaAa^s B : /ic^o/cbs T W
^p] 76 Badham
as faoi BT :
oirij W
b i eOf\eiv kv seel. Cobet
&y leVai Stephanus avievai
B TW
b 4 tierafiaXovTes T W : fieTaftd\\ovrfS B Athenaeus
'A700WJ;' Lachmann : a7a9wy B T W

ITAATiiNOS

5 aurrffiaroi ayaQot. "OfHjpoy p.ev yap KivbvveUfi oil povov

biatpQeipai, dAAa Kal v/Bpio-ai, fts TavTrjv TTJV napoifj.iav
iroHjtras yap TOV 'Ayap-ffivova 8ta<pepwra)s ayaQov avbpa
C TO. Tro\efUKd, TOV bf Mevt\f<ov " pa^OaKov atXM7?1''?*''"
Ovo'iav voiovufvov Kal fari&vTos TOV 'Aya^f^vovos &K\TJTOV
fisoir}fftv e\06vTa TOV Mfv&euv em Tt}v 6oivr\v, \((p<0 ovra
em TTJV TOV apeivovos.
5
Taur' aKovtras flirfiv l<^/ "la-tas /ieiroi Kt,vbvv(ij<ru> KOI
yo> ov\ o>s ail \4yeis, a> SwxpaTes, aAA.a Kaff "Op/rjpov
<j>av\os $>v iirl <ro0oC avbpbs levai BoCvriv &K\r]Tos. Spa ovv'
&ya>v fit ri AiroAoy^oT/, us eyia f*h ovx ofio\oy^(ra)
d rJKeiv, aAA' into a-ov K(K\rndvos.
" "S.VV Tf ov," tyi], " Jpxofxe'va) itpo 6806
OTI ipovpev.
dAA' Itapev.
Toiavr' ana <r<pas l(^>7j %ia\(x84vTas Uvai. TOV
vr<j> TTWS irpo<r4\ovTa TOV vovv KOTO
vno\fi.Ti6iJ.(vov, Kal ittpi^vovros ov
npo'Uvai (Is TO irpdotiev. iitfibti b% ytvfodat, M rr} olic^
e T$ 'Ayad<avos, avfifyptvipi KaraAofi/Sdi'ftv T^V Mtpav, KO.[ rt
I<^>TJ mrr6Qi. yeAouw Trofltij;. ol jn^v y&p ev&vs valba Tiva
T&V ivboBfv Airavnjo-owa aytiv ov (car^<cUTo ol &AAot, Kal
KaTO\afj./3iivfiv
rjbr) ^AAoi^ras bftirvfiv
evBvs b' ovv is
S f5e' TOV 'Aydflcovo, *ii, (pdvai, 'Apiaro'Sij/af, eis /caAov
3ira>s ovvbdmrrio-ris- (I 8' iAAot; TOIOS $vt/ca
avapaXov, IBS Kal x^s C7?7"^" ^f ^a KaA.^<rat^i, o^x olos
fj Ibfiv.
dAAa Saxcpdrq ^juiv irfis OVK Syets;
Kal tytit, <pr), /xeraoTpf^o/xfvos ovSapiov 6pc5

_,

WIJ

. , .,.,,,

ea of Photiu

B T: T)>V W
03 TWP ei-Sofley Porson : Tay fvtov Photius :
BTW
es3TW:,B
e6 (rwSt,7r^<ri;s B T W : o-war(Ttu Laur. xiy. 85
evr'JiTWiTjB
e 9 r$7, B : lfyt\v T W
ovSa/tou B : nv8afj.ri T W

2TMOO2ION

1746

etirov ovv on Kat avros //.era ScoK/odrov?

VTT' fKfivov SeOp' eirt bftnvov.
KaA<Ss y', I^TJ, TrotcSi' (TV- dAAa TTO{) eoriy ovros;
O-7ncr$ei> e/mou aprt etcn/er aAAa 0avp,da) KCU avros TTOU 175
Ov
arrj; o-j> 5', ?f 8' 09, 'A/)taTo8rjju,e, Trap' '
5
Kal e /xey e<j!)J7 dTroyt^ety roy 7rai8a iVa /caraKeotro1 aAAoy
8e rtya rwy Trat'Sco^ ^Kety dyyeAAoyra ort " ScoKpaTr/s ovros
ayaxwp'jo'tts ez> rw rwy yfirovutv Trpo^vpw eWrj/cey, KO^IOV
naXovvros OVK e^eAet etcrievai."
"Aroiroy y', e<^rj, Ae-yets- OVKOW KaAeis avrov Kcii p.rj 10

Kai oy l^r; et7reu> MrjSa/xws, dAA' lare avrw. e0os yap b

ri roCr' exer f y t re aTToo-ras OTTOI ay rvx?] lorijKez;. ^'^ei
5' avTiKa, &s eyco o?juat. fxr) ow Ktyetre, dAA' lare.
'AAA' oura) xpr) Trotet^, ei (rot 8oKet, eepr] (fravai TOV
dAA' q^as, S> Traces, rov? aAAous ecruare. 5
irapari^ere ort ay /SovArjo-^e, eTretSdy rts
eytb ovSeuwTrore eTrotrjcra^>yw oily,
Kat ejue i5^)' v/xwy KK\fj(r9cu ITTI Sa-Tryoy Kat row8e rovs
aAAous, ^epaTrevere, tV v/ias eTratyw/xer.
Mera rawra ^77 o-<pas juer SetTryeiy, roy 8e ScoKpdr?]
OVK etcrteyat. roy oSy 'Ayd0a)z>a TroAAaKts KeXevety p-eraroi> Sco/cpdr^, e 8e OVK ear. rjKeu; oSz; avrbv ov
e 10 jj/cot/" B2 T W : f}/cot /XTJ B
e 12 7' T W : om. B
a 6 I /tev
Bast (I Stephanus) : e> BTW
^ B : ^v T W
a 8 /ca/ioG
W : Kal ov B T
a 10 KoAe?s B T : /caA.o?s W in marg. T : Ka\ei
rec. b
auTbi/] aSfljj Herwerden
an a(j>-f)creis B W : wp^ffys T
b 2 TOI/T' B : rovro T : TOIOVTOV \V
b 4 ec^r; T W : om. B
b 6 Travres W (sed ai S. v. )
eVeiSav Tiy . . . /i^j B T : eiret rts. . . ou
M^ L. Schmidt : eVel ou STJ TIS . . . ^ Hug : eirtl S^ rts . . . oi- ^
Schanz : fort. eireiS&v aurbs . . . (jd)
b 7 ffyeffr-fiKri T : a^eeTT^/o;
W : e<t>fffr-fiKfi
B
c 4 I Se B : 4 Se W : *** T (r'bv Se fuisse
videtur) : oi/rbj/ Se vulg. : f 5e ci. Bekker
OVK eav B W : OVKO.V T
o3i/ om. W

I75c

IIAATilNOS

5 woXw xpovov &s el<a0ei biaTptyavra, d\Aa pxiAtcrra <r$as

peaovv bfnrvovvTas.
ZayaTov K.aTa.Keifj.fi>ov

TOV oZv 'Ayadiava Tvyx&veiv yap

povov ASp', l(prj <p<ivai, 2c*/cpar,

Trap' efte icoraKfio-o, tva, Kal TOV <ro<pov airrop.ez'os

d diroAav<ra>, o (rot wpoo-eorTj ez roiy Trpo&vpois.

bfj\ov

ffov
yap

OTI rjZpes airro KOI i\fis' oil yap av irpoaireaTTjs.

Kal TOV 2<uKpdrr] K.a6(fo-0ai KOI f'nrfiv OTI E5 av <=xi,
<t>dvai, S 'Ayddtov, f l TOIOVTOV et?j rj <ro<pia &OT /c TOV w
5 or^pov is TO KfV&Tepov peu> TIH&V, av

10
176

airTtofjtfOa

&o"irtp TO h> TO.IS KV\IW Hbwp TO OM TOV tptov pVof K TTJS

wAjpoWpas tls Tr)v Kfvwtpav.
fl yap ovr<as lxel Ka^ '
o-otjtta, TroAAoC rt/x/xat r^f irapa trol xaTaKAto-iv oi/^at yap
fit irapa <roi5 woXA^s ai KO\rjs o-ofaas jrXrjptufl^o-ecrflai. ^ fitv
yap i^ <pav\r) TIS av dt}, r) Kal a^io-ft^T^o-inos &vitfp ovap
ovtra, TJ bt ay Xay.it p& re icol iroXX^v Mboo-iv t\ovffa, fj y(
vapa orov viov OVTOS ovrut o-<p6bpa ^Xajui/rfV Kal iKtjxivi)?
Iv /idprutri T&V 'EA\7ji>a>i> tt\iov rj rpwrfivpfois.
(7, {<), a; SuKpares, d 'Ayaduv. Kal ravra
fv Kal o\tyov tcrrtpov biabiKaa-fyfBa iy<& Tt Kal <ri> ttfpi
rijs <ro<f>(a.s, Stxaerrj) xpiaptvoi r^ Aiovvvip- vvv 8< irpos TO
Sfiirvoi' irpura Tpinov.
Mrri ravro, $j, KoraK\w>^rroy roO 2(OKpdrovs tol
8f tiri'^o-ai^-os Kal rc3j> ^XXcor, cnroi'Sds re crcpas Ttoa)<raa6ai,
Kal fyravTas TOV dtov Kal Ta\\a ra vofj.i6fj.eva.,
TpitrfffSai
irpos TOV ttorov TOV oZv Tiavcravtav l<pj \6yov TOIOVTOV
TIVOS KaT&p\fiv.
Elfv, avbpts, Qavat, Tb>a Tp6nov pqcrra
Tri.6ij.f6a;

!ya> /xei ovv A^yoo iifj.lv OTI T^ &TI iraVv xaArfis

^X"1 vffo roC x^ey irdrov Kal Seo/xai ava\jrv)(ijs TIVOS ot/uat
8^ al vp.iiiz' row TroXAorfs- Ttapijorf
yap
b oi/v rij'i rpoiro) &y (us p'^ora
C 6 rvyxivetv B T : TUX*"' W
c 8 airriiuv6s aov T W : om. B
d l TfXHreWi) T W : itfoata-riv B
ds r4 B T W : Tiy corr. Coisl.
Ktvtln-fpov re vera B T W
e I rifiuiuu T W : riuuuer B
e 3 ))
KolTW.-KaJB
04 J j 7 e T W : f r > B
eS^Jv/colBT:
/J W
as ^<rra B T W : jj J^rra 7(). t
a 8 K^ffrt B T W :
in marg. rec. b

STMIIOSION

I76b

Tov ovv ' Api(rTO(pdvr) elTrtiv, Tovro /xeVroi fv Aeyeis, &

YIav(ravia, TO itavrl TpoTrw Trapaa-Kfvdo-ao-Oai pq&T&vriv Tiva
rijs TTdVecos' KOL yap avros et/u T<3z> x^? /3e/3a7mo7AeV(op.
ovv OVT&V e</>T7 'Epvt)uaxoz> TOP 'AKovpevov 5
i, Aeyere. Kat en
irpoy ro kppGxrBai itlvfiv, '
eirj ^/xry, ^ 8' os, ws eoiKfv, ef/,oi TC Kal
'A/n<rro8?7jua> xai 4>ai8p(j) Kat rourde, ei v/xcts 01 Suz^arwrarot
irCveiv vvv aTretp^Kare1 17^6^9 /uey yap det dSwarot. 2coKpdrrj 8' ecup<S Aoyov tKayos yap /ecu d/m^)orepa, 5or'
e^apKeo-ei avrw oTrorep' Sy 7ro6ci)ju,ei/. 7rei8^ oiii' /xoi 8oK6i
ov8ets rwy TTapovrav irpoOvfjLoos extz; '"'pos TO TroAw
olvov, t(T(as av eya> irept ro [Af&ucrKecrOai. olov ecru
Xeytoy rjTTOv av etr)v arj^rjs.
fj.ol yap 8^ roSro ye
KardSrjAoz; yeyoyeyat eK r% laTpiKrjs, on \aXfTrbv ~ois
rj fj.^0r] Icrriv /cat oi!re avros IKCO^ eTvat Troppco
Trter^ ot/re aAAw crv/A/BouAevo-ai/xt, aAAcos re
/ca KpatTraASyra ert ex 7775 irporepai'as.
'AAAa /ATjy, I^>TJ <pdvai vTroAa/SoVra ^aiSpoy Toy Mupptyov<rioi>, eywye croi eico^a -Tret^eo-^ai aAAtos Te Kat O.TT' az^ Trept
AeyTj?' vu^ 8', az> ev ^ovAevooyTat, Kat ot AOITTOI.
8^ aKovcravras <rvyxa>ptiv irdvTas /tx^ 8ia /Ae^Tjs
Troi^cra<r6ai TJJV cv T&> Trapovn crvvovo-iav, dAA' OVTCO irCvovras
TTpos fjbovriv.
^ TOLVVV, (pdvai rov 'Epnt/xaxoz;, TOUTO fjifv blocrov &v eKacrros ovArTat, eTrayafces 8e fj.r]bev
b 3 vapcurKfvdffcurdai T W : irapaa'Kevd&o'Oa.i B
b 5 avruv T W :
<JLVT}>V B
'EpvlfJ.axov T: Evpvi/j.axov W: T-bv 'Epv^ifnaxov B
O.KOVHfvov B T W
b 7 'Ayde<avos Vahlen : aydOcav B T W
04 Qatpw
Heindorf: e|aipa> BT W
08 aTjS^j TW : CWJATJS B
d4 Kpanra^.uvra T ^V : Kpoi7raA.oCj/Ta B
d 5 <pcu8pov T W : cf>ai$pcai> B
M"P~
ptvowriov B : invpivovaiov T \AT
d 7 Aeyjjs B \V : Afyeis T
S &i/
e5 T W : 8' aS eS B
povtetwvTai corr. Coisl. : jBo^Awyrai
BTW

I7 6e

IIAATI2NO2
flvat, TO pera TOVTO etcnjyoC/nat TTJV fj,ev aprt fltrf\6ov(rav
avArjrpi'Sa \aipfiv ear, av\ov<rav eavrfj fj &v (SovArjrat rats
yvvail Tais evbov, r^Ms 8e 8ia Aoycoi' dAA?jAoty a-vvelvai
TO Trjpepov Kal 81' oiatv \6ytav, el flovKeo-Qe, tOe\ta

177

4>di>at 8r) Tt&vras (cat /3ov\e(r6ai Kal Kf\eveiv avrbv

eioTjyeio-fltu. ffaflv ovv TOV 'Epv^faaxov Sri 'H fi.lv fioi
dpx^ TV XoyOU ^OTt KOTO TT\V EvptTTlSoD MfXaVLTTTTr]V

Oil

yap Iftos 6 fj.v6os, dAAa 4>ai8pow roC8e, ov p-e\A,(o Aeyew.

4>ai8pos yap fK&oroTf vpos pe dyavaKTuj' Aeyei Oi Sfivor,
fyqiriv, on 'Epv&paxe, aAAois /i^i> rri fleui' {//*z>ous (cat
iraCatvas eu>ai iiro TO>Z> jrowjrfii' Trewoir/p-erouy, T^i 8e Epton,
rrjAiKovr^) owi (tal TO(TOOT<J> dfia, /i?j8e eVa T7(dTrore TO&OVTWV
ytyovoTiav TtotrjT&v TrfTroirjKfvai pr)fev tyiuapiov; fl b( /3ov\fi
aZ trictyaardai TOVS \prjoTovs iro(f>i<rr<is, 'HpaxXeov? fjiev Kal
iiraCvovs (cara\oy<i87)j> <rtryypd^>eu>, too-jrep 6 fjehrurros
s Kai roCro fxiv jj""0" 'ca^ Oo.Vfia.<n6v, dAX'
tobpbs <ro<j)ov, Iv $ Ivrjcrav
&\\a TOMVTO.
?8ois av ^yKf/cw^iair^e'ra ^r^ o5r Toioj/reoi' ^iv w/)i
^i' <nr<w87/i> iroiTjo-atrflat, 'Epeora 8^ nrjbfva wa> &vQp<aira>v
(Is Ta.vnr\vl TTJV fiptpav d^co; vnvrjcrai- dAA*
o#ra>y ij/uAT/rai roeroCroy fleo's. rairra 817 poi boKei fv
\tytw <baibpos. tyia ovv l-ni6vjj.S> a|ia fv Tofctp Upavov
fltrevtyKfiv KOI xapicravOai, &jj.a 8' tv Tip -rrapovTi. itptitov
fwi boKfi elvai THMV TOIS irapovo-i icocr^o-at TOV 0f6v. el ovv
a-vvooKfi /cat iifuv, ytvon' o.v fnuv tv Xoyots IKOV?/ Starpi^1
So/ctt ydp /xot xprjvcu Ixaoroi' jj/ii> Aoyor eJirtrr Hiraivov
&p\fiv bf
e 7 aii\irrpl$a T : ouAirpi'Sa B W
i)lv B : j) eay W : ^ T
a i Hal prills seel. Hermann
a 7 irafaras W : iraiovaj B T :
iraiai/as bt
b i juTjiei'] /i7)8* Valckenaer
bs 4v8pJ>$ iroifoS
T W : om. B
b 6 <i</>e \iav T : ai^e Af lav B W
03 alien; T W :
oJiS B
d 3 x<i\\i<rTov B T : K<AATTa W

2TMIIO2ION

177 d

<f>ai8poi> irp&Tov, fTreiSr) /cat irp&Tos Karamrai Kal

cLfjM Trarrjp TOV Aoyov.
QvbeCs <roi, a> 'Epufifia^e, (fravai. TOV SooKpcrnj, f
etrat. ovre yap av TTOU eya> a7ro(/>?7<rai/H, 6s ov8ez>
aAAo e7rtcrra(r0ai 17 ra epcortKa, oure TTOV 'Aycifl&w Kal
p.r)y 'Aptoro^ai'^s, a> -rrept Aiovv(rov KOL e
77 8iarpi/3?7, o^8e aAAos ov8ets rourcoi't <5i>
eya) opw. /cairot O-WK e forou yiyverat ^/xw rots vorarois
dAA.' ear 01 TTpocrOev iKavGts Kal KaX&s
^apK(reL JHJLIV.
a\Xa rvyri a-yaOfi Karap^era) 5
4>at8/>os Kat ey/ccojuta^erto roy "Epcora.
Tavra 8r) /cat ot aAAoi Trdyres Spa (rvvtyafrav re Kai
airep 6 ScoKparTjS'. iravruiv /xe^ ow ^ eKaoros 178
TICWV 6 'Apto-roSrj/jtos fjLfp,vt]TO
OVT aS eya>
eAeye Travra" h 8e /LKiXtara Kat wf e8o^e
TOTUTMV vfjfiv
ep> eKaorou TOP
5
ov fxev yap,
TioOev AeyeiP, on p;eyas ^eos etr/ 6 "Epcos Kat
Oav^acrros tv avdpanrois re Kat 0eois, TroXA.axf) Mff Kat aAAjj,
ov)( ^Ktara 8e Kara rT)i> yevtcriv. TO yap ev ro?s 7rpe(r/3vraroy e^at roy ^eoy Tifjuov, tf 8' oj, reK^ptor 8e rovrov b
yap "Epcoros oi!r' etaty ovre Aeyo^rat VTT' ovSe^os ovre
o{!re TroiT/roC, dAA' 'H(rto8oy irp&Tov fjiev Xaos
avrap eiretra
dcr<^aAes atet,
178' "Epos
e 2 TJ B Aristaenetus : om. T W
6 7 Spa] o/xn Wyttenbach
a i & B T W : offa. in marg. t
a 4 a^iofj.vr;/u.6vevTov B : a.io/u.vt]ndvfvrov eli/oi T W : a^ionvtifnov^vrwv b
a 9 irpffffiiiTaTOv , . . T^V
9fbv W : irpttr^vrarov . . rcav Qeav B : irpecrySurctTots . . . TWJ/ 6eG>v T
b a yoy^s B T W : yoval Stobaeus

I78b

IIAATliNOS

'H(rie{8<j) 8 KO.I 'A.Kavtrfa.as oT>fi<p?jo"ii> fj-tra TO Xcios 8i5o

TVUTIO ytvea-Oai, Trjv re Kal "EpcoTa. Happfvibr)? 8 TTJP
10 yeve<ra> Aeyei
nptoTioTov pfv "EpcoTtt dcwr juijTraro n&vriav.
C ourco 7roAAax<>0H' ojioAoytmu 6 "Epa>s ei Tots irpecr/3vroros tfzxu. irpe<r/3l;TaTos be cov \L'.yl<nu>v &yad&v
alrios larnv. ov yap fy<ay lx&) eiTeiv on
ayaOov evOvs v4<a 6Vri ^ epaor^s x/")*""0*
5 7rai8tK(i. 8 y^p XP*) avOp&iiois fiyda-Gat iravrbs TOV
rois (XAA.oi)(ri KaAaiy /3ua<re<r6at, TOVTO ovrt <rvyyfV(ia oio
re tpnoitiv avTto xaXws oure Tifiol oiire IT\OVTOS oi!r' 5AAo
d ov8> is Ipcos. A^yco 8e 8rj ri roCro; r^v firl fv row
aJcrxpois aitrx^i'T;!', 7rt 8e TOIS (caXois (^iXon/xiav ow yap
Itrru' SMU roiJraji; otJre ?roAu> ovre KI^TTJI; /xeyaXo icat
KaAa Ipya etpydf(rOa.i.
</J/xi rofvuv ya> &vt>pa Saris
5 ^p, ft TI alaypov itoi&v icorciSrjXos yiyvovro fj TiAa\<av
into TOV 61 bvavftptav pr) ^vvo^fvos, ovr' &v vnb irarpos
6<f>0tvra o5r<os AAyjjaai ofJre fab kratputv ovre vif
e ovStviy is inrb TtaibiK&v. Tairrbv 8^ roirro Kal TOV
ftfvov 6p&fj.tv, 6Yt 8(a</>epJirra>s TOWS ^paor
Srav 6<p6fj Iv aia-xpia TIVI 8>v. (I oZv v.i\yairfi ns ytvovro
&<TTf itoKiv yfvf<r0ai tj oTpaTdirtbov fpaor&v Tf ical Trot5 biK&v, oiiK $<TTU> Sirais &v apeivov oixTjo-eiai' TTJV atwwv ^
Awex^M*1101 wdirrwi' rfir al<r)(pG>v Kal (piAorinovufVoi irpos
J?9 oAA^Aous, (col fMxA^voi y' &r fier' d\A.?j\a>!> ol rotoSrot
vtKyev iv oMyoi oVrts cos Iwos tZTrtiv iraWas &v0p<avovs.
ipSiv yap &vr)p intb iraitiK&v 6<f>0fjvai f[ \iiriav r6a> i
' ijrroi' J> 8ijirov btaiTO ij fab itavrtov T&V
b 8 'HffiiiJv Si ral '\KiVffl\ius ^o\wyT add. BT W post b T I irirrat' '
hue tranaposuit Schanz auctore F. A. Wolf
avfi^niaiv] tv/iQW*
Stobaeus : Ao\o-yi H T W
ante fura. add. <f>ijo-l B T W : (8s) ^"I'1
Schanz : post avfitf>r]aif omisi
C I Trprffflfa-uros
B T W : rpfffP"'

rdroit Stobaeus
e 5 ^ seel. Rttckert

C 6 airyyivtM B T W : riylwia Wyttenbach

a i 7' ii/ B T : 8' i>- W : 7' 08 Vcrmehren

STMI1O2ION

i7ga

#AA<oi>, /cat Trpb TOVTOV redvavai &v TroAAdKts e'Aotro. /cat 5

fjajv eyKaTaAt7re> ye ra -rraiSi/ca ?} /AT) ftorfOfjo-ai Ktvbvv?6ovTi
oirno Ka/co? ovnva OVK. hv ambs 6 "Epco?
Trpos aptrriv, oo<rre o/xotoy etvat rw dpto-rco
/cat arex.^s, o ecjfnj "Onrjpos, fjitvos fj,irvtv<rai, tviois b
rw^ yptawv TOV Oeov, TOVTO 6 "Epcos rots epaio-t Tr
yiyvo^vov Trap' avrou.
Kat ju,rjz> vTTfpaTToQvficrKeiv ye /xovoi e^eAoucrti' 01
ov /^ovoz/ ort aySpes, dAAa /cat at yuyai/ces. TOVTOV Se Kal 5
^ rieXfou Ovydrrjp "AA/crjcrris Uay^y [i-apTvpiav
uirep roCSe roi; Aoyou eis TOVS "EAXr^va?, e0eA?7(ra(ra
vrrep TOI; avr^s avbpbs cnrodavetv, OVTMV avrS Trarpos re
/cat p,r]Tp6s, o$s fKeivr] TOCTOVTOV wepe/3aAero TT; ^>tAia 8ta c
rw epwra, <2crre aTrode^at avrovs dAAorpious ovTas rw ve?
/cat dvojoiari povov Trpoo-^/cozras', Kat roCr' fpyaa-a^vt] TO
fpyov oijTO) Ka\bv foogw epyd<ra<r0ai ov ^ovov avOp^Trois
dAXa Kat 0ecus, wore TroAAwy iroAAa Kal KaAa epyacra/^eycov 5
evapt^/xrfroty 877 rt(ru> i-oocrav TOVTO yepas ot ^eot, e^ "AtSou
avelvai TraAiz/ r^ \l/vxtfv> dAAa r^y fKeCvys avflvav aya<r6evTS rw epyar o{fra) Kat ^eol r^y irept TW epcora 0-7:01)877^ d
re /cat aperr)y /aaAtcrra TLJJL&O-LV.
'Op<ea 8e roy Otdypov
"At8ou, <pdo-/xa bfi^avTes rr/s yvvaiitbs
8e ov 8oyres, on ju,aA0aKieo-0at e8oKet, are ^>v Kt0ap<j)8os, Kat ov roA/x,ay ereKa row epcoros 5
dAAa biafj.ri'xavao'Ocu G>v
et? f/At8ou. rotyaprot 8ta ravra otKTjy avrai eTreOe<rav, Kal fTrofyo-av TOV OdvaTov avrov VTTO ywaiK<3i>
roz> r?s ertSos voy e r t , r - e
a 6 |it^v B : yti^ T W
b 5 ou /j.6vov Sri] ov /jidvov ol ci. Stephanus :
ou% STJ ci. Fischer
o B : om. TW
b 7 wep roCSe roS Ajyou del.
ci. Stephanus
c 6 8^ post Utioffav iterant T W
07 ai/emn]
uvifvcu Hommel
d\\A T^JI/ eKe/vTjs] aAA.' 011^1* eKfivrjv Earle
di T< p7<j> seel. Baiter
ds <co>ia B: tydvTacrna TW
d 6 8fa;itT7x<wa<r0ai B T : Sto/itTJXa'^<ra<r^at W
(wi/ ela-Uvat B : ?}j/
fcVot T : (*wi/ teVat W
PLATO, VOL. II.

11

HAATliNOS
<rav Kal fls iMKapuv vjo-ovs aTtfTtf^av, Sri
irapa rfjs /wjrpos <as birodavoiTo airoKTfivas "EnTopa, jut)
woi7j<Tos

rovro

5 IroA/iT/o-ei; lAf(T0ai

of/caSe
j8or;fl?jo-as

IA0a>i>

y^paids

T& ipaorrj

180 ri/jia>p?jeras ov jiovov virfpaTroOavtiv

reAfunjcnn,

ITarpoKAw Kal

aAAa /cat tTra.Ttoda.vtlv

rereXeDrijicrfri' o0z> 8^ xol vTrfjxtyairfltvres

ol 6(ol 8ia</>p6vr<os avrov ^ri/xrjo-ai>, on rov lpairrr}v o&rta irtpl iroXAoi;

^iroteiro. AJ(7)(t/A.os 8e <t>\vapfi (fxio-Ktw "AxiXAeo Do5 r/xjKAou Ipav, Ss ^v KaAX^wv ov povov TlarpdicXov AAX
&/ua KOI rSi> fjptaiov ait&VTutv, KM. iri aytvaos,
V(aT(pos iroAJ;, tus <^r/<rii> "OfiTjpos. d\Aa yap r
judXiora ^h> ravriji; r^i UpeTTjv ol Otol TipSta-iv TTIV ittpl
b rdi> ?pa>ra, fxaAAoy ^tvroi 0avfj,dfov<ru> Kal ctyairrcu Kal
<5 TTotoua-u' Srar 6 tpuncvos rbv lpaoT7)v &-/air^, tj orav
& Ipao-riis ra TraiSiKti. dtidrtpov yap ipcurnis imtoiK&v
tvOtos yip iirrt. bth ravra Kal rov 'A\i^Xia rrjs '
5 ri8os fxaXXov Mfj.r)(rav, tls
OCrw 8r) fywy^ 0jf*i "Epwra
ri/uu^rarov xal Kvpt<raroi> c?va fiy dper^s Kal evbaipavlas
Kol fw<ri Kal rAmj<rao-u>.
.^v roioMv riva \6yov
<I>a?8pov &\\ovs rivas ilvai &v ov irdvv
Ttaptis TOV liawravtov \dyov Stjjyetro. ditfiv 8' avrov
3ri Ow KoAws /MI bom, 3> <J>ai8pf, irpo/3e/3A^o-flai ^iv
6 Aoyoy, ro airA&>9 oi/rws irapjjyyfAflat ^yKcojuwifeiy "Epwra.
i p,r yap tls fjv 6 "Ep<as, KO\&S ttv eix<, vvv 8^ o y<fy>
ely p.^ wros 8e has 6p66r(p6v ^ari irpoVepor irpopai oiroiov 8et ^waiwi'. ^y&> 081' iretpdo-opiat
e 3 4Tofti<oiTO (sic) T W : inro9iit>oi B
64 ro4<fa.s Se TOVTO T W :
iaroKrfivas Si TOVTOH B
ofxaS' TW : ofcaSe 8' B
85 ^oriHiffas
1
B T : /8oi)j<rai W
a 5, 6 4AX SMa scrips! : iAAi if a T W : AAA* B
b 6 KOI vpfffflvTaTov
B : rpevfivTaToy T W
Kai rt/iuaraTOV B W :
om. T (add. in marg. t)
&7 icvpi.6ra.Tov B : Kvpidrtpov TW
d i troTov] Inrbrffov Hermann
8f 1 B T W (scd S ex JJ) T)

SYMOOSION

i8od

i, irp&rov pev "E/xora (ppdvai bv 8ei TTCUvelv, eTretra eTraweo-ai duo? TOU 6eov. Ttdvres yap ur/xey
OTt

OVK

eCTTlV

O.VCV

"EjOCOTOS

'A<f)po8l,Tr).

[AIMS

fJifV

OVV

els av rjv "Epw e-nel Se 8r) Suo karov, Svo avdyKrj

?z>ai. Trws1 8' ov 8vo ra> ^ea; r\ [j.fv ye TTOV
KOI d)U7jr<op Ovpavov dvydrrjp, -TJV Sr; nal
Ovpaviav fTtovo^a^o^v ; 8e recorepa Atos Kat Aiw^rj?,
r/y 8^ Ilay8?7/>io^ KaXov^fv.
avayKaiov Srj xat "Epwra Tor
jj.ev Trj Irepa crwepybv Hav^^ov opd&s KaA.eio-0ai, rov 8e
Ovpdviov.
eiraivtiv juer ow 8et irayras Oeovs, a 8' oSy
eK(irepoy etA.rj^e Tretpareoy eiTreif. 7raa-a ya/) Trpai$ <i58'
l^ei' aur^ e^>' eaurrjs TrpaTTOfj.ewr] ovre /caXr) cure alcrxpa.
otoy 6 wv ^eis TroiovfAev, y TTLVCIV r) a8eii> 7) StaAeyecr^ai,
OVK etrrt roijTtov avrb Kah.bv ovbev, dAA' ev rr/ Trpd^ei, <?
ay Trpaxdrj, TOLOVTOV a.TTe/3rj' kak&s pev yap TrparTo^evov
Kal opO&s KaXbv yiyvtrai, /x,rj 6p6&s 8e ala^pov.
oi/rco 8^
xal ro epav Kal 6 "Epas ov iras eori KaAo? ov8e a^tos
eyKft)juuae(T0at, dXXa 6 KaXws TtpoTpcTTUtv epav.
C
O /xey oSy 777? nay877jw,ou 'A^poStrr/s ws dAr/^ws 7raz>bt]p.6s ea-ri Kal e^epyd^erai on av Tvyri' Kal ovros ecrTiv
bv ol (fravXoi T&V dv6p(&7ro>v ep&cnv. epGxn be ol TOIOVTOC
irp&rov jj,ev ov^ TJTTOV yvvaiK&v r/ iraiScoy, eTretra 3>v KOI
T&V o-co/xtircoy fjLaXX.ov r) T&V \jrv\G)V, eTretra ws av
dyorjrorarcoz/, Trpos ro 8ta7rpdao-^at ^ovov /3X.e/AeAouyre? 8e rou KaAw? 17 /XTy1 o^ey 8^ cru/>t^3atyet
avrols OTI av Tvyjatri TOVTO Trpdrreiv, O/AOICOS /aev dyaOov,
ojuoticos 8e rovvavTiov. ecrn yap nal airo r^? ^eou yecorepa?
re ovo-Tj? TToAv ^ r?;s erepas, Kal fj,Te-^ovcrr]S ev rf) yevtcrei
d4 o5c B T W : om. Stobaeus
ds 5^ 5^ BW: Se T Stobaeus
d6 gporre B T W : ^pwras Stobaeus
ri Bed B T W : ra flea Stobaeus : riflecoCobet
d 8 Stcoyrjs T W : Stdvris B
65 irparrofievn
B T W Stobaeus: om. Proclus
as aM B TW Stobaeus: aui-2
a0' ofirb t
Tji B T W : om. Stobaeus
a 5 /coXis B W : KU\WS T
b8 avb seel. Schanz

5
181

i8ic

6
182

OAATIiNOS
KO.I flrjAeos nal Uppevos. 6 be rrjs Ovpavias Ttp&Tov fttv ov
/j.ere\ov(n]s 07jAeos dAA' appevos [novov Kal e<mv OVTOS 6
T&V TtaCbow ep<as limra irpe<r/3vrepas,{;/3pe&>s apoipov SOev
87) eirl TO appev TpeirovTai. ol IK TOVTOV TOV Ipajroy iiriirvot,
TO <f>-u<rei. epptapxvearepov Kal rovv ^iaXXov Hx.ov ayav&vres.
xai TIS &v yvoli] Kal kv avTrj TTJ iraibfpa<rriq row el\i.Kpiv&s
viro Tofcov TOV !p<oros aipjbu/fWi>ov$* ow yap fpaxri
aAX' lireiSav 7y87j &p^a>vrai vovv "i<ryfiv, TOVTO be
T& yfvei&a-KfLV.
irapea-KevcurufVoi yap ot/xai eio'tz' ot VTevOfv op^o/nevoi fpav as TOV ftiov Siraira
o-vvftrofjifvoi
Koi Kotvij <n>fi/3i(o<ro'/it>oi5 dAA' OVK ^awarTjo-airey, 6V
&<$>poiruvy Xa/Soires us Wov, KarayeXtJo-ozres ol\^<rf(r6ai
^ir' SXXoi; diroTpe'xovTes. XP^" ^ Ka' vopov tlvai M tpav
wo^8a)i') fro ^ els &bri\ov iroAA^ mrovd^. drr/Xfo-Kero- ro
yap T&V iraCbvw Te\os ^SrjXov ol Tehevrq KOK^OS Kal operas
^X^S rt ff^P' Ka^ <rdlMTOs. ol [lev ovv ayadol TOV v6ft.ov
rovrov aiirol airois hdives TlOevrai, XP^" 8^ tal TOVTOVS
Toiiy TrovSij^oiis ^paoras irpoo>avayK<iieii> TO roiovrov, <u<rir<p
Kal T&V e\fvOfp<av yvvaiK&v irpoo-avayKd^o/ufv avrovs Ka0'
Sffov bwiifjieda jui) ^pav. OVTOI ydp f2iru> ol Kal TO
&<rrt rivas roAjuay A^yftv wj aio^poi'
^paoraiy A^youcn 8i fis rot/rovs
airSv TT)I bnaipCav Kal aointav, firel ov b^irov
KO<r/xia)9 ye KOI VO/A^KOS oriow (irpayfxo) irpaTTdpevov \lrdyov
av biKaicos <f>tpoi.
Kal 8?j Kal 6 Trepl TOV lpa>Ta vofiof lj /i^v rais iAAaw
iroAeo-t i>o^crai paStoj, aTrAus yap aJpiarar 6 8' IvdiiSe
Kal li AaKeSatjuoDt wotK^Aos. i *HAi8t /x^u yap Kal ev
KOI ov pr) trotfrol \eyeiv, airASs
03 Kal ... ?>a)s seel. SchQtz
da oA\'] oAX' ^ ci. Stephanus
d6 olxtffBiu Herwerden
ea TAos seel. Badham
64 XC?'
T
B : xfh
W
a 2 Tii/tis B T W : nyo vulg.
a 5 irpaypa >n
marg. t : om. B T W
b i KO! In Atac(tai/wvi seel. Winckelmann
6 supra <V AaKiSalfwvi add. T
b 3 o? /J) T W : ow yu^ B

STMHOSION
KaAoi> TO -^apC^arOaL epaoraTs, Kat OVK av rts enrol o#re
veos ovTf TraAatoy a>s alcr^pov, 'iva oi/x,at /ar) irpdy/jiar'
l^oxriy Aoyo) Tretpcd/Aeroi irciOfiv TOVS veovs, are d8warot Aeyety rr/s 8e 'lawtas /cat aAAoflt TroAAaxoS al<ryj)bv
i, ocroi into papflapois oiKovcriv. TOLS yap fiap8ia ras TupazwtSas alcrxpbv TOVTO ye Kat 17 ye
<^tAo<ro^)ta Kat ^ ^uAoyu/AZJaorta' ov yap o?juat (ru/x<pepet
Tots ap\ov<n <|>poyrjjuara /xeyaAa eyytyyecrflai
l>,eva>v, ovSe <iA.tas to-)(i;pas xat KOLVdovias, o 8
^lAet rd re aAAa Trdvra Kal 6 epcos ejuwrotety.
rouro ffjMOov Kal ot ei^0d8e rvpavvoi' 6 yap 'Apioroyetroyos epcos Kal ^ 'ApfioStou </>iAia /3e/3atos yeyojueVr/ Kar&v TJ]V apyrjv. o^rcos ov jaey al<ryj)ov ere'0?)
epacrrais, KaKia rwz^ Oepevow Ketrat, rwy fx,ey
TrAeoye^ta, rwy 8e ap\o^vutv avavbpLq.' ov 8e
airAws cvo^crdr], 8ta r^y rcoj; Oe^vcav rfjs \l/v^rjs
apytav. evddfa 8e TroAu rovrwy /cdAAtoi; yero/w,o0er?]rat, Kat
owep elTroy, ov pqbiov Karavorjo-ai. v9v^f]0^vTi yap ort
Aeyerat KaAAtoy ro tyavepfas epav TOV XaOpa, Kat p-dAtcrra
rwy yei>yaiorarcoi> Kat apicrTutv, KO.V alcr\iovs
ort aS rj TrapaKeAevo'ts rw epwyrt -Trapa Trdyrcoi;
ovx ws rt alcryjtov noiovvn, Kat eAovrt re KaAoy SOKC?
Kai P.T) eAovrt alcr^pov, Kal Trpos ro e7ri)(eipety eAeiy eou<rtiay 6 vofjios 8e8coKe rw epacrrr; 0ai^acrra epya epyafo/Aeyo)
t,, h et rts roA/iwr; irotety dAA' ortow SKOKCOV Kat
7rpd^ao-^at TrAr/y roi)ro, t<ptAocro(ptas ra jute'yiora Kapirotr' ay dyet8rj ei yap 17 -yjprjfjjara /3ouAo/j,eros
Trapd rou X.aj3elv rj apxriv dp^at ^f rtya dAAr]y bvvafj.iv
otaTrep ot epaorat Trpos ra -TratStKa, iKeretas
bs r b B T W : del. t
c7o5B2TW:ovB
d
ou 5e B
d4 8e B : om. TW
ds ^evunOfVTi BT W : 7p. al

ivf6vfj.-fi&riv in marg. W
dg re T W : om. B
e 3 & ' T W :
otel B : ^p. Kal aW in marg. W
a i (f>i\ocro<f>ias seel. ci. Schleiermacher
aa/BT:^W
a4 efleXot B : ^fleA.et T W

i8ab

.
5

183

,a

FLAATilNOS

5 Tf Kal avTij3o\^a-fis tv raw 8e?;<re(ni> itourvpevoi., ical UpKovs

duvvvres, Kal KOip-Tjo-eis firl dtipais, /cat e0e'Aoi>res 8ouXfoj V.-1
oovXevfiv ofos ovb" av 8o!Aos ovbeis, fjj,iro%i(f>iTo
av pr] **
irpaTTflV

OVTU TTJV TTfM^LV

Kttl VTTO <lXa)I> K.OI VTTO

(\6p&l>,

b T&V pfv dv(&i6vT<av KO\a.KeCas Kal avftevOtptas, T&V 8^

vovdfTovvT<av Kal al<r^yvoy.fvu>v inrkp avr&v rfi 8' (p&vn
irdvTa ravra TTOLOVVTI \iipi-s l-neari, Kal 8e8orai into TOV
VOJJ.QV &vtv ovf&ovs irparTfiv, ws -nayKaXov TL Trpayjua
5 8iairparrofi'(m< o 8e bfivoTa/rov, cos ye \eyovtriv ol iroX\oC, art Kal OILVUVTI fj.6v<a ovyyvdifjtr] irapa 6e&v fKJ3dvri
/
T&V opKO>v aQpobtviov yap SpKov oij <pa(Tiv flvar ovrta \
C Kal ol 6tol Kal ol avOpmiroi. irairav eov<riav TreirotijKoui T&
ip&vri, <as 6 vofj,os (f>t]<rlv 6 evOabf ravrr] f&v ovv oir\6tb)
av rts irayKaXov vofj,ieo-0ai ev rfjbe rfj -noKfi Kal TO ipav
Kal TO <f>i\ovs yiyvfa-dat rois tpaorais.
trrfibav 8^ iroi5 8ay<oyov? ^jrio"nj<rajTfs 01 iroWpes roiy cpco/x&'ot? pr) i&fft
rois Ipaorai?, Kal Tip TraiSaycoyal raBra npo<rt/, ^Xtxtwrai 8^ Kal Iraipoi ^vei5^wo'u' ^" Tl
opGtcnv TOIOVTOV yi.yvop.fvov, Kal TOIIS dveib((oirras a5 ol
d irpr/3vT(poi fj.r) btaK(\v<a<ri fj.r)b% \oibopSxnv <as OVK
Myovras, (It be Tavra TIS o5 /3X^i/ras ^y^croir' &v
al<r\UTTov TO TOIOVTOV ivOabf vo/t^eerfloi. TO bl olpai <58'
lx' o^x airXoSj' ^orti', o-ntp i ap\fjs i^X^t ^Tf Ka^v
5 elvai avTo Kad' avrb ovrt al<rxpdv, dAAa KoAais ptii' irparKa\6v, alo-xp&s 8 altryj>6v.
al(rxj>&s fxev ovv
itovrjpia Tf Kal irowjpwy xapt{r6ai, KaXwy 8^
re Kal xaAoos. Trovrjpos 8' eorlv exfifoy 6 Ipaor^s
a6 j/u>wr seel. Hertz
iQtxovrts B T W : tfrXovrif vulg.
ba airK] OUTOU OrcIIi
bs WITO raCra B : raBro wctcra T W
tTfO-Ti T W : tirertu (sic^ B
b 7 TSi Spv T W : TO>V tpnov B : fttf
Spxov al. Spxov (8pKoc) Hertz
eTroi BTW Stobaeus Cyrillus: tlrai
iprolift/iov Osann e schol.
c i of (bis) BT : om. W
c6 xoJ
...07$ seel. Jahn
07 jj T W : ol B : J of al.
irorpoi Heindorf :
?Tpoi B T W foeiSffoixrii' W
d7 KoXas Si Par. 1810:

STMHOSION

r<
b

8f]fJios, 6 TOV (Tw/xaros ^aXXov T) r?js ^UXTJJ ep&v Kal yap

ovbe |u,ozn|u,os eoriv, are ov8e /uoz;ip.ou ep&v Trpdyfiaros.
yap r<5 TOV cr^fnaTos avdfi Xrfyovrt, ovirep fjpa, " ol," TroAAoii? Xoyovs not vTro(T\cris /caraio"xyva$' 6 be TOV tfOovs ^pr/orou OVTOS epaoTrjs 8ia (3iov
are /loin/Aw crwraKeis. TO^TOUS 8^ /3ovAerai 6
cat KaA<Ss /Satrayt^eiy, Kal rot? fxey
e 8ta^>evyetv. 8ta raiSra oSz; rois /^ef
-Trapa/ceAeverat, rois Se ^>et;yeir, aycoyo^ercSy Kat
ov iroTepatv Trore eo-rty 6 epwr KCU Trorepcov 6
'. ourco 8^ VTTO Tavr?]s r^s atrias Trp&rov fjv TO
ra)(l atoyjibv z/evdjaio-rai, iW ^povos eyyeV^rat,
8?j 8oKe ra TroAA.a KaXws Pairavi&iv, eTretra TO VTTO
Kal VTTO TroXiTtK&v bvvd[j,ett>v aAwrai alcr-^pov,
av re KaKW? 'jraor^toz; TTTTJ^TJ Kal ju^ Kaprep7](rry, az> r'
ewepyerovjaevos is j(p?j/xara ^ eis ^aTrpd^ets iroAiriKas ju^
KaTa(f)pov^(rri'
ovbev yap So/cei rovrwy ovre fiefiaiov OVTC
fJLOVi[J.ov flvai, )((>> pis TOV /xr]8e TTf<pVKvai air' aiirai^ yeyiXiav. p.Ca orj Aeiirerai TW ^/xere'pa) vo/xw 68os, ei
KaAcos x.api.flo-dai e/saarr/ iraiStKci. e<rr6 yap
v6fj,os, uxnrfp eiri rols pa<rrais tfv bov\.V
TJVTIVOVV bovXfCav -7rat8tKors p.^ /ccAa/caW eivai /irjSe eiroyei8ioror, ovrco 8^ xat aAA?] /ixia p-w?] SouAeta KOt;crios
Aeiirerai OVK eTro^eiSicrTos* aTij 8' eorty ^ Trcpi TT)I;
vei'Ojuio-rai yap 8^ 77)1x11;, edy ris e^f AT; riz>a
81' fK&vov a^fCvatv H<re<T6<u ^ Kara cro<piav Tiva
e i ^ T^S xf'uX'JS' 6p<i< B : e'pwy ^ rfjy ^ux^s T W
62 Sre ouSe
TW : are ou B
a i Kal . . . SicHptvyfiv seel. Badham
as 877
B T : 5r; icol W
b I &v T' evpyeTOi>/j.evos B W : avrevepyeTov/nevos T
ba jy xp^/*ara ToAiTt/cas seel. Hirschig
b6 effrt . . . yo/uos
om. Schanz auctore Vermehren
b? SrnrepTW: 8(nrep B Stobaeus : &ffirep ykp Vermehren Schanz
edeXovra, B T W : e8f\ovra.s
vel 0e\oi/Tis Stobaeus
C 2 yiua ^cJvij] ^it'a (JLO>V B : ^fa /MVOV T W :
/tJi'r; ftta Stobaeus : fj.ia (po>jjLfv(f Usener : /u (TWJ/ fpu/j.ei/a>v ry iifj-erfpy
v6)f4.tf> Schanz : ^.to vewv Hug
C 4 TIS e6e\.-r) nva. B T W : rfs riva
Qe\y Stobaeus
C 5 titeivov T W Stobaeus : e'/ce?j/o B

1836
e

5
184

OAATiiNOS
TJ Kara aXAo OTIOVV fiepos aperT/s, avrt] at rj e'fleAoo'oiiAeia
(tvai ovbf KoAaxeia. 8e? 8rj r<u vop.ta rovr<a
els ravrov, TOV re irepl TTJV traibepatrrtav Kal
d

TOV irepl T7\V

<pl\0<TO<pfa.V

Kal

TT]V ttAA.TJJ' apfTTjV,

(I

fi^AAet (rvuftrjviu KdXbv ytvea-Oai TO tpaor^ TraiStKa

tracrftu. Srar yap eis ro avro l\6<a(riv epaor^s re
iratduca, VOJJMV Hyoiv eKarepos, 6 /nei; ^apta'afj-fvois
5 vTnjpfT&v anovv buaibas &v VTnjptTfiv, o 8e r
awrdv (ro<p6v re ical dyaflii' Sixauo; aS OTIOVV av insavpy&v {virovpyfiv), KOI 6 fjxv Swa/xej-'os eis (ppoirrjcriv Kal n\v

e aAAiji' aperrfv <rup;j3<XAe<rflat, 6 8e deo/iez'o; eis -aaibtvcrw

Kal r^i> aXAr/f crofyiav Kra<r6ai, rare 8^ Toj5r<oi trvviovriav
eis ravTov TO>V v6jj.wv fj,ova\ov Zvravda (TDfxirforei TO icaXof
dvai ifatbiKO, ^paoTij yapitraffQai, aAAofli 8e oi8a/iot). ^w'
S Totfr<j> Kal ^airaTjjSijj'ai ovfiei' aio^pJi;' ITT! 8e TOW aAAois
irao-i Kal ^ajraraj/xeW aJoxtJvjji' 0^pei Kai fifl. ei yap TIS
185 ipatrnj &>s irXovo-^ TrXovrow IveKa xapurajuei'os ij-aitarqOtii)
Kai /i^ Xa/3oi xpjj/xara, ava<pav4vros TOV ^paoroS WvrjToSi
OV aJo^prfv Soxei yap 6 ToioOros TO ye avrow
6Yi Ivexa xprmdriav oVtpw av OT<I>OW virjjperot,
5 rovro 8e ov KO\OV. Kara TOV avTov 8?) Xo'yoi Kav el TIS
is dyad$ yapura^vos Kal avros <!>s apftvtov ^o-J^evos 8ti
T^V <p&(av ipaorov laiiQTr)6elri, ava(pavlvros lueivov KOKOU

b KOI ov KtKT^vov dpeTjjr, Spvcos KaX^ ^ diraTTj- 8oKei yap

av Kal oCros ro Kafl' avrov 8e8t)\<DK^va(, STI apeTrjs y
$vtK.a xal Toi; pfhrUav ytviaBai irav av iravrl i!po6v^r)Q(if\,
TOVTO 8e a5 vdvr<av KaAXiorov oiJrw irav ir&vTios yt KaAo>
OT fit i>6/ia rouru apographa : rf v&fUf roinu B T W
d a rJ T :
ds ty T W : oZv B
d6 iv T W ; oC B ftiroi//!?^
inrovfyetv Baiter : {iirovpyuv B T W : VTrovpydv vulg.
e I {u^/3iiAAfirSoi T W : {u/j0;uVfl<u B
fi del. SchOtz
ea KTaffflai]
lo-Toirfloi Schanz
e 3 run/ vifnuv del. Bast
a 7 ipaffrov B I W :
roC ipaaroZ al.
bi ^ BWt: om. pr. T
b4 jrai> Stobaeus:
T^ B W

om B T W

STMOOSION

1855

y eW/ca xapifea-dai. OVTOS fcrnv 6 rrjs ovpavias Oeov 5

epcos /ecu ovpdvios /cat 77oAAo7j aios /cat 77oAei KOI tSicorais,
77oAA7)z> e7Ttp;eAeiay avayicdfav 77otetcr0ai 7rpos aper^y TOV
re tpGtVTa avrbv avrov KOL TOV epai/xeyozr ol 8' erepot C
irdvTfS TTJS fTtpas, rrjs Travbrjfjiov.
ravrd aoi, I^TJ, ws e/c
TOV Trapaxp^a, S 4>ai8pe, nepl "Epcoros cri;p,/3dAAo/>iat.
8e Trava-apevov StSacrKoucri yap /xe icra
ovroxrt ot crotpoi f(prj 6 'Aptcrro8r/p;os 8eiy juev 'Apioro^xii;?/
Aeyety, ru^ery 6"e at/roi rtz;a ^ TVTTO TrXr](rp,ovr)s rj VITO TWOS
aAAou Awyya eTTtTreTrrcoKfrai' Kai ov^ olov re eiz>ai Aeyetr,
dAA' etTreiy avrov ey rry Karco yap amov TOV laTpbv 'Epuifia^ov Kara/cetcr^ai '"il 'Epv^LfJ-a^f, OIKCUOS f t rj iravcrat
p. rrjs Auyyoy ^ Ae'yeti' uirep ep.oi), ecos ay eycb 7rai;cnio//,ai."
KOI roy 'EpD^ijua^oz; etirety " 'AAAa Trot^o-a) d/jicporepa raCra*
eyco jmey yap epw ey rfi (rw /^,e'pet, <ri/ 8' e7rei8ai> Travtrr/, ey
roi ep,<3. ey <S 8' ay eyco Aeya), eay /xeV (roi e^eA?j aTr^evtrrt
avea-Oat ^ Avy- ei 8e ^77, f8ari
ei 8' apa Traru la~^vp<i ZCTTIV, ava\af3u>v
ri roio{5roz> oiw Kty?j(rais ay r?)y plva, Trrape' Kat eay roCiro
770477(7179 aTraf 7^ 8is, Kat ei Ttdvv ivyvpa. eo-ri, 7ravo"erat."
" OVK &v (pOdvois Aeycoy," (pdvat. TOV ' Api(rro(pdvr)' " ey<J>
8e raSra 770177(760."

87) roy 'EpTj^t/xaxor, AoKei TOIVVV fj.ot ava.yK.alov

ftvai, ^7761877 riauo-ayias opprjcras e77t roy Ao'yoy KaAcos ov^
iKa^wy a77ereAe(re, 8e^y e/ue 77etpao-0ai reAos e77i0etyai r 186
Ao'yw. ro p,ey yap 8t77AoOi> etya6 roy "Epcora Soxet p;ot
KaA5? SteAeo-^af ori 8e ov xo'yoy ecrrty e?7t rats
b5 apeTijs y' eveKa TAV: dper^j evena B: tveita aperfis Stobaeus
03ffvnfta\\ofj.aiTW: cruyUjSaAAoyuec B
0 7 A e y e t ^ B T : om. W
d I rbv larpbv T W : TaJv Iwrptov B
d 6 ir**y xpo^oj/ aTrj/eixTri
lyovri W
e a (j/^(rats B T W Stobaeus et legit Athenaeus :
Kvijirais Wyttenbach
e 4 <>apai (sic) B : elv^iv T W

IIAATilNOS

T&V avOp&'ntov irpos rovs KoXovs dXXa nal irpos aXXa iroXXa
5 Kal (v rois aXXot?, rots re traSfxatri T&V TTUVTUV <!j>u>v nal
TOIS (V Ty yfj

.1

<f>VOfJ.VOLS

KOI

US

IwOS flvflV

fV

TfatTl

TOtS

o5o-i, KaOfwpaKfvai pot SOK (K rrjs larpiKrjs, TIJS rjnerepas

T\WIS, u>s fieyas <cai flaujxaoros Kal eirl irav 6 6fos
Kal KOT" avOpdiriva KOI Kara fleia wpay/xara. ap^oftai
duo r^s iarptK^s Ktytav, Iva Kal Trpf(rftfv<afj,V
TTJV
fl yap <l>v<ris T&V <T<ap.a.T<av TOV SiirXow 'Epcora rovrov
T^ yap vyifs TOV (rtafuiTos Kal TO vo<rovv ofioXoyoufi
$Tfp6v re Kal avofMiov %<rri, TO be avopotav avo\u>iuiv
6vfj.fi Kal lp. aAXoy ptv ovv 6 iwl r vyiewS Ipcoj, aXXos
8e 6 ^irl Tip voa-<abfi.
Itrrtv 8^, &<nr(p &pTi
IXeyer rois /iei; dyadoi? KaXov xa.pCrdai T&V
rois 8' dKO\aaro($ aJo-xpo'v, ovrto Kal tv avrois TOIS
rois f&v ayaQols IKOOTOV TOV craj^iaros xal vyietwois
Xapffr0ai (cal 8, Kai rouro' oru> (S o'vopia ro larputtv,
rois 8i KOKOIS KOI voo-^Seo-iv afo-xpoV re Kal 8 a\api<rreiv,
fl /xcAAct ns Te^viKOS flvat. tori yap larpiKri, is fV
K((j>a\at<f flittiv, imar/mri T&V TOV a-cofiaros fpa>Tin&v irpos
eal Kfviomv, Kal 6 biayiyv<&o~K<av iv rol/rois TOI'
re Kal al<r\pbv ^pcora, oCrrfs o-r> 6 ZorpiKciraros,
Kal 6 /icra/SdAAeu' TTOIQJI', wore dj^rl rot) ertpov Ipcoros rov
fTtpov KTaffOai, Kal ols /xj tvfaTiv Ipais, 8i 8' fyyfVfo-6ai,
tiSKTr6.ii.fvos tp.voirjo-a.1 Kal tv6vra $f\fiv, ayaBos av eltj
brjiJ.u>vpy6s.
bfi yap 8r) ra Ix^wrra oVra ^v r$
(^)^Xa oUv T" flvai ttoitiv Kal Ipav dXX7}Xa>v. tori bf
ra ^aiTtc^rara, \l/v\pbv dfppSi, viKpbv y\VKfl,
irdvra TO, Totavra- TOVTOIS tmoTrjGfls Ipcora ^fxiroi^o'at KOI
6fj.ovoi.av 6 fi^Tfpos irpdyovos 'A(rK\rjTn6s, <3s
b 3 KOTO Tai-Spartrifa Stobaeus
itari rifltTaStobaeus
b 3 Kul
B T W : om. Stobaeus
b 4 ?x" T W: <xp B
T>5 yuoXo7o/ici/oii B : ^oAffyoS/iti- <ij T W Stobaeua
b 7 vytfivcf (pus T W :

fryiti yatpos B
d s Kraiifloi B: nrfaaatiu TW
Usener
d 4 /^al . . . l^e\(li> seel. Schanz

{pas *cL

SYMDOSION
TTonf]Ta\ Kat eycb 7ret0o/jiai, crvvea-Trjcrev rrjy ^/
fj re ovv tarptKTj, axnrep Ae'yco, mitra 8ta roi) 0eot> TOVTOV
KU/3epyarai, axravrcos 8e Kai yu/^aoTtK?) Kai yecopyta1 /WOUO-IKT)
8e Kat Trayri KaraSrjAos1 r<3 rat a-junKpor ttpocrsypvTi TOV vovv
x.e6 rot^roi?, <2<r7rep ?(ra>s xal 'Hp^KAeiros
Aeyety, e-^ei roiy ye pr^ao-iv ov KaAws Aeyet. ro
er yap $170-1 " ^la^epo^vov aiirb avr&
" (3o"7rep apfj.ovCav TOOV re Kai Ai/pa?." eon 8e
dAoyia ap^oviav (pdvai ^ta^epea-Oai rj eK biafapofjfvtov
ert
eT^ai. dAAa ttrcos ro8e e/3o^Aero Ae'yety, on eic 8ia(/>epo/xera)2'
irporepov TOV 6eo$ K.CU /3apeos, eVeira varepov o/xoAoyT;(ravTwv ykyovtv VTTO rfjs fxoucrtKr/s Tf^vrjs,
ov yap O-^TTOV
IK bia(f)poiJ.V(t)v ye ert rou d^e'os Kat /3apeos aphonia hv
etrj' ^ yap appovia. o-uju^ajyia eo-rtr, o-vfAffxavia 8e 6/xoAoyia
rts- 6fj,oXoyiav Se e/c bia<pfpo^v(^i>, ecos av 8ta<pe/3a>imu,
dSwaroi' etyat- ^ia(pp6fj.vov be av Kai ^ OjaoAoyoSz; d8vvarov appocrai ajp-irep ye /cat 6 pvG^bs eK rov ra^e'o? Kai
/3/)a8eos, e*c Ste^vey/xei'dJy irporepoy, vcrrepov 8e 6/ixoAoyr]o-aVrfoi> yfyov.
ryv 8e 6/xoAoyiaz; iraou rourot?, wo-7rep
eKet ^ larpiKT), evravda f) ^ovcriKt] evTiOrja-iv, epcora Kat
opovoiav dAA?jAa)y e//,7rot7jcra(ra' Kat eariy aS JU,OI;O-IK^ Trept
a.p\ioviav Kai pvd^bv epa>rtK(Si' e7rt(rrrj/>i7/. Kat ez> /uei' ye
avrr/ r^ o-wcrracrei ap[j.ovias re Kat pvdpov oiifev xa\.irbv ra
epcoriKa Staytyywo-Kety, ove 6 StTrAoSs epcos eira{55a TTOO
dAA' e7rei8az> 8er/ Trpos rovs av0p<airovs KaTa^pijo-Bai
re Kai appoviq rj Troiovvra, o 8r) /xeAoTroa'ay KaAo{5o-iz>,
dpO&s rot? ireTToirjuevois /xeAecrt re Kat jtxerpois,
6 8^ Trat8eta K\r)6r], evravOa 8r) Kat \aXeTrbv Kdl ayaQov
87j//,iovpyou Seu TraAty yap i^Ket 6 avros Aoyos, on rots /*>
Koo-jLttoty rwy avOpdircav, Kat a>? ay K0o-p,twrepot yiyvoivro
ol pt^Tro) ovres, 8e? yjapi&a-Qai KOLL ^vAarretv rov
asffiuKfibvB T : (T/jLiKp<f W
0 4 a\\faw B: oAA/jjAois TW
d 2 /jierpois B T : f>v8nois W

C i e / c B T W : om. Vindob. 21
c 7 TTW Badham : TTCOS B T W

i86e

187

I/Mora, KOI DITTOS timv 6 KaAoy, 6 ovpdvios, 6 TTJS OvpavCas

e fxoTJoTjs "Epaiy 6 8 IIoAt>/jii>ias 6 Trdvbrjfj.os, ov 8ei fvXaflotfifvov TrpO(T<pfpfiv ols av irpo<r<pfprj, OTTCOS av TTJV fj.fv fjbovriv
avTov KapirwoTjrai, dicoAa<riai> bf fj.rfbffj.Cav ffj.TTOirj(rrj, &trmp
fv rfj rjfifTfpq Tf\vrj fteya fpyov rats irtpl TTJV fyo-nowariv
5 Tf^vrjv findvfj:Cais KO\.&S -xjnja-Oai, COOT' avtv voa-ov TTJV
rjbovriv KapTT(acra(rOai:. Kal fv /XOIXTIKT} 87) Kal tv larpiK^
Kal fv rois &AA.OIS irao-i Kal rots avOpa>TreCoi.s Kal TOLS Of Con,
KaO' O(TOV irapfCKfi, (pv^aKTfov tKarepov TOV "Eptora- Zvtarov
188 7&P- fad Kal 77 r&v a>p&v TOV fviavrov o-^oracrts fieim;
afj.<poT(piav Tovriav, Kal tirfibav (J,ev irpos ^AA7)A.o row
77 Ipwros a wvbri tyut !A.fyoi>, T& Tt 6tpfM KM
rh \lrvxpa Kal fapa Kal vypd, Kal apftovCav Kal Kpa.<ru> A.4/3J)
5 <T<atppova, fJKd <f>fpovra fVfrripCav Tt Kal vyitiav avOptatrou
Kal Tots fiAAots fyots Tf Kal tpwofs, /col ovbtv rftiKr\<Ttv
Srav bf 6 fitra TT^S #/3pea>s "Epcos fyKpaT^artpos irtpl ras
rov fVMvrov <3pay y/i^jrai, bi(<f>6ti.p^v re woAAa Kal ^bCKrjffiV.
b oZ Tt yap Aoi/xol <pi\ovcn yCyvfo-dai i* T&V rotovriav Kol
4AAa avdpoia voAAa voffr^aTa xal roTy 6r/pCoi.$ Kal Tols
Kal yap isayyai KO\ \a\a^ai. KOI Ipwo-i/Sat fK
s Kal aKoff^las Trtpl AAATjAa T&V Towuratv ylyveTai
8>v fTturrfifj.r) vfpl atTTptav Tt (papas Kal fVMVf&v
upay a<rrpovofj.Ca KoAeirai. tri ToCvvv Kal al Ovo~Cat Tracrat
KOI ols navTiiai fmoraTflratira 8' ^orlz; 7; irtpl Otovs Tf
C Kal avOpwirovs irpoy aAArfAovs Koiviaviaov -ntpl AAAo rl
fariv r) Trtpl "Epcoroy oJuAaKTyr r KOI lavw. iraa-a yap
ao-f/3fia (piXfi yCyvfa-Oai tav [u\ rty T& Koarfj,C<f
64 ipyov TOIS B 2 TW: ipy&vrts B
e 8 vaptticei Wt :
BT
ivtffroe T: tvearof B : Ji ^ffrii/ W
as naaplov Bt
Stobaeus : ic6aiu>v T
yi fXc-yox] A7ai Stobaeus
f
Stobaeus
a 7 irtpi] Kal ircp! Stobaeus
a8
TW Stobaeus: Jm<#>p B
b a ToXAi] wa! iroAA.i Stobaeus
b 4 7(7^701] -yfyyoKrai Canter
b 5 (popas W Stobaeus : <popas B :
^opSsT
b6 ai'TW Stobaeus: om. B
traacu B Stobaeus : &murat
TW
b 7 ^rio-TOTti] twuTTaTi'i r4x<^t Stobaeus
03
cuffftf"
Stobaeus : y lurifcia. B T W

2TMIIOSTON

i88c

/x?j8e n^a re avrbv not irpeo-/3ev?7 eV Travrl epyw,

aAAa TOV erepoy, Kal Trept yoyeas KOL ^cSyras nal rereAeu- 5
TTjfcora? KOL irepl 6eovs~ a brj TrpooreraKrai TTJ jjiavTiKfj
Tovs pG>VTa$ Kal laTpefaiv, Kal eorty av f]
^)tAias ^ecoy Kat avOptoiriDv Srj/xtoupyos rai CTTI- d
0TCur0ai ra Kara avOptoirovs epcoriKa, ocra reti;et irpos
Oi)'rco
(rt;AA?7/38ijz> jixey 6 Tras "Epcos, 6 8e Trept rayaOa jotera o-co^po- 5
o-vvrjs Kal SiKawcrvvrjs a7roreAoi/xevos Kat Trap' ^/xty Kai
Trapa 0eoi?, OVTOS rrji' //eytorr/v b^va/AW exL Ka' "nacrav
Kat <tAous e?z/at Kat rots KpeCrTocnv rip-S>v Oeois. tcrws j^ey
oiw Kal eya> rwvEpC()ra tiraw&v TroAAa TrapaAetTra), o^ /xerrot e
ye. aAA' et rt eeAi7roz/, croy epyov, a> '
ai.' rj et TTCOV SAAcos ez> y
0eoV, eyKco/xta^e, eTretSrj Kat r^s Avyyos

u,/

ovv e<rj etTrety rov 'ApKrrocpoVij ort Kat 189

L' eTravo-aro, ov /xeVrot Trpiv ye TOV irrap/xoy Trpcxreve
avrr}, coore jae Oav^d^fiv et TO Kocrjutoy TOV oxojuaTO?
^v/xet ToiovTotv \lrocpu>v Kal yapyaAtcr/xwi', otoy Kat 6
Trdvv yap evOvs (irava-aro, eTretS^ avTW TOV Trrapjuoy 5
Kat TW 'Epv^ifJia^ov, 'iiya^e, tyavai, 'Apioro<ai>e?, opa
rt TToias. yeAcoroTTotets jueAAcou Aeyety, Kal (^uAaKcx /^,e ro>
Aoyou di'ayKa^ets ytyyeo-^at roii <reauro{5, eay rt yeAotoy b
^oV (rot ey dprjvri Aeyetr.
Kal rof 'Aptaro^dyiy yeAdVavra etTrety ES Aeyets, S
C 5 rJ>i/ Stobaeus : ?rep! rii/ B T W
C 6 irpoffTeraKTai B T W :
TrpoTeraKrai Stobaeus
c 7 fpSivras W Stobaeus : (punas B T : TOWS
epwras seel. Hermann
6.3 fvffe&eiaj/ Stobaeus : dtre^ejac BTW
d 8 $vva/j.vovs . . . <}>i\ovs B T W. Stobaeus (sed ex Swct/tej/os fecit T)
a 7 Sya0e (fxivat T W : ^7a0e <pavai 3>ya6e B

riAATllNOS
KaC f*oi lorco apprfra ra elprjiJtva. dAAa \n\ fie
5 tpv\a.TT(, <is lya> </>o/3oC//at irepl r3y p.eXA.oVrwi' prjdya-fffdai,
o$ TI fwj yeAoia eiTrtoroCro fief yap &i> Kfpoos efy Kal rijs
^fterepay furftnis firtxt&piov dAAa fiy KarayeAaora.
Ba\tav ye, <f>dvai, S 'ApiaTO(paves, oifi
i<(pfvfor6(U'
dAAa irp6<re\f rbv vovv Kal o^rcos Xeye as 8(o<ra)i' Aoyoi'.
C to-<Bs jtevroi, &v 8of?/ /^ot, &<pri<ra> <re.

Kal ^v, S 'Epv^LfJM^f, flTtfiv TOV 'ApiaTotpdvr],

ye* TTJJ ei> vfi lx<o Aeyeu; ^ j5 oT; Te cal
^/uol yap 8oKot5(ru; &vOpu>itoi Trcumiirao'i. rrjv TOV lpa>ro$
bvvap.iv OVK pardfja-ffai,
^irel ola-Qavofifvol ye /x^ytor' ay
auroC iepa /cara*(r/cfuttcrat /cal p<afj.ovs, Kal 0tMrai$ &f iroieii'
fieyforay, oij( &a-itep vvv rovrotv ovfiev yiyrerai irepl avrov,
8e"oi> Trdvrnv judXiara yfyvfo-dai.
lort yap flea^ ^>t\aiOpunroraTos, MKOV^OS re (ttr ri/ &vdp(atr<av Kal iarpos
rojJrwi/ cSr laBivruv ntyhrrri (vbaifj.ov(a &v ry
yeVel elr/. ^yai ovi>
bwap.iv airrov, vp.(is 8e
8ei Se irp&rov VIMS fxaOefr r^v avOpiatrtvriv <pv<riv Kal
avr^y. ^ yap waXai 17/itwv ^j/o-iy o^
vw, d\A.' dAAofc. irp&rov j^ev yap rp^a ^j> TO
ra TWV av9pa>iT<av, ofy &(rnfp vvv bvo, Uppev Kal
a\\a Kal rptrov Trpoarijv KOIVOV 8v d/x(porc'pa>i' TOVTIOV, ov
vvv wo/xa XoMttfo, avro 8e q^tivcoTaf tobpoywov -yap ev
rore ftev jji* xal elSos Kal wo/iia 1^ dju<^orepa>i' KOIVOV TOV
Tf apptvos Kal ^Xeos, wv 8e OVK lorw dAX' ^ ^v die^8et
wo/xa Kttjj.tvov. Iwetra 3\or ^v eicdorou roi) avdp&tiov TO
b 5fa&fiveffSatT W : JTmjfl^owSai B (sed ^r extra versum) : )?!i)
fii)9-/)crfrr8ai Rettig
o 4 KrOpanmi Bekker : &v0ptairoi B T : of
tu>9f<**m W
d 4 r<rr0c B : r<rcireai T
d6 avr)) B : afo-i; T:
i airi) Eusebius
j)y BT : om. W
d 7 irpSroy BT: irpwro W
d 8 ri TO>V B T : TWV W Eusebius Stobaeus
e a li> B W : om. T

Eusebius Stobaeus

e 4 (v foiitei T W : iy ti> fttti B

STMHOSION

i8gc

elbos (TTpoyyv\.ov, V&TOV Ka

oe rerrapay et)(e, KC" ^^eXrj ra fora rats \ep<rCv, Kal TrpoVooTra
8v> eV av\evi KUK Acre/set", o/zota Trdvrrj' KetyaXyv 8' err' 190
dp-^orepoty TOIS Trpoo-aiirois evavTiois Keipevois fuCav, KOL
aira rerrapa, /cat atSota 8vo, Kai raAAa iravra wj duro
TOVT(t)V &v rts etKafretev. (TropeveTo be Kal opdov uxnrtp
vvv, oTroTepaxre fiovXydeiri' KCU OTTOTC ra-^v oputfa-eifv delv, 5
axrvep ol KvfiicrT&VTes KCU ets 6p6bv ra a-KfXrj
TttpifapoKVK\ti),

0/CTft)

TOTC OVCTL

TO??

fJi\<nV

f(ppovro KvicXw. Tjy 8e 8ta ravra rpCa

ra yez^r/ Kat roiavra, OTL TO pev appcv 3\v TOV T]\(.ov TTJV b
apyjiv f-Kyovov, TO 8e OfjXv Trjs yijs, TO be
TIJS <r(\tfvr)s, ort /cat f] (reX?7V?j ap.<poTp<a
8e 8?) ^ Kai avra /cal ^ Tropeta aw&v 8ia ro rors yovevviv
o/xota etWi. ^y oSy r?]y t(r^iy Set^a /cat r?)y pw/xTjy, Kat
ra (frpovrinaTa /xeyaXa et^oy, e7re\Lpr]o-av 8e rots
Kat 6 Xeyet "O^rjpos Trepl 'E(jbtaArov re Kat "jQrou,
kudvutv Aeyerat, ro ets roy ovpavbv avdfiao-iv
iroif'iv, &$ indr](roiJi.fi>a>v rots Scots. 6 ovv Zevs /cat ot C
aAAot ^eoi ffiovXeuovTO OTL -^prj CLVTOVS Troirj<rai, Kat 77770^ pouy o^re yap omo? aTtoK.Teiva.Lev el\ov Kal uxnrep TOVS
^ $" ytya^ras Kepavvd>o-avTes TO yevos a())avio-aiev at rtpat
yap avrot? Kat tepa ra irapa T>V avdp(07r<DV i7</>aznero 5
v ,IA

ome OTTCOS e&ev ao-eXyaivew.

jw,oyts 8^ o Zei/s
\ '
" (i \
^
" j
ff "
/
<

,,. \ Aeyet ort

AOKCO joiot, f0J7> e X ety P-7?Xu;77z;> ^
re avdpanroi KCU irava-aivTO TTJS aKoAao-tas
yevo^evoi. vvv fjiev yap O.VTOVS, e^)r/, 8tare/A&j 8t)(a enacrTov, d
Kat a/ia p-ey acrOevea'Tepot eo~ovTai, ap,a be \pr](ri]j,<aTepoi.
8ia ro -n'Aetous TOV apiOyibv yeyovevai' Kat
a 5 Oeiv B Stobaeus : eXflerc T W
a 7 o/cri rJre B : rrfre
T: oKTi . . . a 8 KVK\CJ> om. W
a 8 airfpetSofifvoi T W : fiirep ej'SJwef ot B
b a a/j-Qorepoav B W : a/t^xfrepoi/ T
b 7 re al B T :
/co! W
0 3 , 4 aTtoKTfiveitv . . aQaviffeiev W
C 5 yap (&K) Ast
6
i'epct B T W : TO jepo Stobaeus
C 7 ^rj ex "* ^ ^ : Xet'
C 8 av6pwjroi Voegelin : &t/6p<airoi B T W

DAATIiNOS
opQol em bvolv <TK\OIV.
KCLl JUWJ

igi

vA.O)O"tV Tj(TVVlGLV

eav b' In boK&<nv d(rXyau>eu>

Q."yLVf

Jtu/vti' u.(/j ^i^/i/j 11^*/

vt^*j

oSor* e<^>' efos TTopeva-ovTcu <TK\OV$ aa-KtoXtdfovTcs."

ravro.
^eiTiiav ere^ve TOVS avQpdnsovs Si^a, uxnrep ol TO. oa rejivovTts Kal jicXAorres Tapiyeufiv, rj (Stnrep ol TO, <aa rais N
6piiv ovriva be re/uot, rov 'AiroAAa) eKetevev TO re . ^\
irp6<rtTrov iJ.fTa<TTpe<peiv KOI TO TOV av-^evos TJUKTV irpos
T7)i Topnv, tva Oeiapfvos TTIV O.VTOV Tpfjcriv
KOcrpKaTepos
elrj 6 &vOp<oiro$, Kal T&AAa lao-flai eKe\evfv.
6 be TO re
TTpdo-ayrrov fj.eTf<rrpe(f>f,
KO! <rvvf\K.<av -navTayoQev TO bepiM
fal TT)I> yairrfpa vvv KaXov^ev^v, &tntep TO. (rvo-jraaro K A
/SaXXdzTio, tv oro/xa iroifir dTr^et Kara ivipr\v rt\v yacrTtpa, ''^
ft 8^ TOV 6p<pa.\bv KdAoCcri. /cat raj ^v AAXas pvr^oas ^j^-1
ray TroAAas (fe\4atve Kal TO. orijflr) Swjpflpoi),
rotoSroj' Spyavov olov ol (TKiirorrf/xoi irtpi TOJ'
ras TUV O-KVTUI' pvrftas1 dX^yos 5
irpi oirr)i; Trjv yaor^pa Kal riv
roO iraAatoG wd^ous. iiri8r)
^fjniffv T& airoC irwnfet, KO
ras x('Pa$ (co^ o'f/affXfKrffxtvot dXXTJXow,
vfjupvvai, &irt0vri<rKov {mb X(/xoC cal TTJS
dpy(as 8ta TO itijbev lOfafiv \<apls aXXjjXwr irotfiv.
Kal OTroTf TI avoddvoi row fjnio-ewv, TO be \.fi<pOeiri, TO
\et(pd(v ctXXo ^^Ti Kal <rvvcrr\tKfTo, etre yuvaiKos TTJS
oX?)s evrvxpi. fip-fofi o 8^ vvv ywaixo KaXoi5fXfi; efr*
avopos- Kal ovr<as oTrwXXwro. \eijo-as 8^ 6 Zevs
fiv ra ai8oia
d 4 5' ?TI Stobaeus : 8 TI B T W
d 5 6f \aatv B Stobaeus :
^flfAwirij'T: ft>i\ov<Tiv W
d6 iurio\uiovTe s W : affKcuAi'^roTes BT
d 7 oa Ruhnken ex Timaeo s. v. : o?a W Stobaeus : iii BT
e i o"
T W Stobaeus : om. B
04fleiJjuei-osW
e 8 0a\\dvrta T :
Pa\dTia W :flaAAovTaB
a s KaXairoSa T : icoAdiroSo B W
a 6 un)et T W Stobaeus : f weiyai B
a 8 At/tou B : ToO A.I/XO" T
Stobaeus: TTJsAj/toSW
b4 !))TOyBT: /utjSJW
bs lnril>\\vvTo
T W : oiroXXurro B

STMITOSION

ro TrpoaOev re'cos yap KOI raCra IKTOS l\ov, Kal eyevvcav

KOI ertKroy OVK els dAAifAous dAA' eis yf}v, uxnrep ol rernyes./xere'flrjKe re ovz> o#r&> OVT&V els TO TrpocrOev Kal
ota TOVTMV rr)z> yt.Vf.viv kv dAAr/Aots (Ttofycrfv, 8ta row
appevos ev r<3 drf\ei, r<3z;Se eWfca, tva ey r^ crv^Ti\OKTt
Upa [J.V el avrip yvvaiid tvrvypi, yevv&ev Kal yiyvoiro TO
yevos, ajua 8' et KCU apprjv appevi, TrXqcrfjiovri yovv yiyvovro
TTJS crvvovcrias Kal bicnravoivTO Kal eirl ra epya TptTroiVTO
nal TOV aAAou j3iov emfj-f^olvTo.
eWi 8^ ovv CK TOO-OV
o epd)s ejOK^uro? aXXrjXav rot's avOpt&Trois Kal Trjs ap^atas
crvvayayevs Kal f'niyjtip&v iroifj&ai ev fK bvo'iv /cat
TTJV (f)V(nv ri]V avdputirivriv. e/caaros ovv
avOpcaTtov (TV^oXov, are rer/A^/xero? uxrirep at
e e^os 8^0* ^r/rei 8^ det ro avTov e/caorros cn;ju/3oXoy.
o<roi /iey ouy rfiy avbp&v TOV K.OIVOV Tfj-fj^d
elcriv, o 8r/
rore avbpoyvvov exaAetro, (/uAoyiWiKe's re etcri Kat ol
iroAAot rwy /xotx<y e/c TOJJTOV TOV yevovs yeyovaffw, KCU
o(rat av yv^arKes <f)i\.av?)poC re Kat jixot^e^rptat ex TOVTOV
rou yevovs yiyvovTai.
ocrat 8e rwy yvvaiK&v yvvaiKos
d(Tiv, oil TTO.VV aSrat rot's avbpacri TOV vovv TrpocrdAAa paXXov Trpos ras yurai/cas rerpa/^i/xeVat
eto-t, Kat at IratpiVrptat eK TOVTOV TOV yevovs yCyvovTai.
o(rot 8e appevos r/u^fici etcrt, ra appeva 8tcoKou(rt, Kat retos
/liey ay TrarSe? So-ty, are reua^ta oVra roi5 appevos, (j)L\ov(ri
TOVS avbpas Kal \aipov<ri (ruyKaraKet/xevot Kat o-DjUTreTrAeyiievoi rots dy8pao-t, KOI etVtv o!rot /3eArto-rot rwy 7rat8toy
Kal juetpaKtcoy, are dy8peto'rarot wres (pvarei. (pao~l 8e 8rj
avrovs dz/ato-^curroDS etvat, ^ewSoueyof ov yap VTT'

192

C 2 avrav B : avTuv T W : at5 Schanz

irpoaQev B T W : fyirpoffOev
Stobaeus
C 3 yevefftv'] yewi)triv Vermehren
SiA . . . 6ii)A.et seel.
Jahn
05 rJ> B T W : del. Usener
c 6 %r/v B T W : Spper
al. Stobaeus
ds SJ; BT: Se W
fKcurros TW: eKatnov B
Stobaeus
e 2 yupoiiciy B T : yvvaiKtav W
e 5 at B T : om.
W Stobaeus
e6 rews BT W Stobaeus : e'ws Ast
PLATO, VOL. II.

12

FIAATilNOS
a.vaio~xyvTtas TOVTO pG><riv dXX' inro dappovs Kal avbpfias
5 Kal appfvatmas, TO op.otoi> avrols a.cnra6ij.fvoi. p-eya 8e
TfKfj^piov
Kal yap reXeo>0eVTes JJLOVOI a7ro/3aii>ou<ru> eis
ra iroXiTiKa avbpts ol TOIOVTOI. eimSai' 8e avbpiaOGxri,
b Trat8epaoToC(ri KOI irpoy ydfjavs Kal TraibcmoiCas ov irpofffyovtri rbv vovv <f>v(Tfi, a\X' vvb TOV vopov avayKaovral'
dXA.' fapKfi avrols fj.fr' dAAjjXa)z> Kara^v ayapois. iravrtat
fj.fi> ovv 6 Totovros 7rai8epa<JT7js re Kal <iAepaorr)s yiyvfrai, ( > ,>*|,
5 del r6 oryytves do-TraCoMEi'os. OTOV /xer oSv Kal iawru i^.^i
^Kfiru] ^VTUXJ/ rS awoC fmio-ei Kal & iraiSepaoT^s K<M *
fiAAos was, Tore Kal #av|ua<rra iKirA^TTOirrat (f)i\ia re xai
C ojKeio'rrjri KOI Ipam, OVK i04\ovrfs <as ^TTOS eJimv
^e(rdai aAA)j\a>i' oifie rpnepbv ~)(povov. Kal ol
IJ.fr' dAXjjXwr 8ia /3tov ouro^ eZo-w, 0*1 oi8' &v Ixot
8rt jSovAovrat o-0io-i (Trap* AAA.7J\a>i> ytyvf<r0ai.
5 yap ai> drffetev roCr' etvat ^ rci> &<ppo5to-fa>i> (TDV
Apa roiJrou tVexa trtpos frtpy xa^Pfl a"uv^>v oi/rws
f*yd\T/y ffwoufi^s- AX\' a\Xo Tt j3ov\o^tvr] fKartpov q
d 8^\j orfo, 8 ov Swarai dirtiv, d\\a navrevfrai, ft /3<"^
Xerat, Kal alvirrtrai.. Kal fl airots ev ry airrip Kafaxfif*^voiy m<rras 6 "H^aioros, tx<av ra Jpyara, Ipoiro- " Tt
lo-f)' o /3oi5Xe<r0e, S avdpiaitoi, VIMV trap' dXX7jXa)i' V'"^'
5 crflai;" Kal eZ aTropowras avrotiy irdXii' fpoi.ro- "'Apd y<
roCSe f-ni.0viJ.fiTf, ei> T^ auru ytv^o-dai on fidXiora dXX?)Xois, (wore Kal vvKra Kal fiptpav pi?) diroXeftreo-0ai aXXi)Xeor; eJ y^p TOVTOU tmOv^flrf, Of\a vpMS ovvrrjat.
e o-tyt^wri/o-ai eiy TO awo', &art btf Svras tva yfyo
Kal e<oy r' av ^re, <os era owa, KOIKT) a^ortpovs
Kal fiTfibav a.TToda.vr)Tf, fKfl a5 tv *At8ov dirl ovolv tva.
flvai Koivy Tfdvt&Tf
dXX' opaTe tl TOVTOV epare "<'
b 7 AtTA^rroiTai T W : AnrA^Troi, B
C 4 oiSei-l Stobaeus :
oiSJx B T W : 068 J scr. recc.
e 6 vofpti T W : yaioctr B
d 6 8"
. . . d 7 4,\[rai om. W
d 8 & B : e'\a> T W
aw"!*"
BT: JvrqCW
e i crv^i/o-ijcrai B T W : avputwaiu b t
ea w"
isTW: ^T^creas B

2TMIIO2ION
fi i>iuv hv TOVTOV TV^rr rar ' aKOvaas tcr^ey ort
ov8' ay els ^apvi]ddr] ow5' aAAo TI ay (payeti] /SovAo'/xeyos,
dAA' drex^w? ototr' &y aKT]/coeyai rouro 6 TraAai apa eVe0TjlJ.fi, (rvv\0u)v Kat oTjyra/cets rw epco/meyco IK 8i;oiy eis
yez>ecr0ai. TOVTO yap ecrri ro atrtoy, on rj ap^aia Averts
avrr] KOL rjfJLfv oAoi TOV oAou ovv TTJ 7ndv^(a
t Ipcos oyo/xa. Kai Trpo rou, uxnrep Xeyut, tv
t 8e 8ta rr)z> dStKtay bt<i)KLcr6rifj,fv VTTO TOV 6fov,
'ApKaSe? wo A.aKfba^ovLoov ($>6(3os ovv i-cmu,
eav [J.ri KOO-JJLLOI S/xey Trpos- rows Oeovs, OTTOS /x,^ /cat aS^ts
KO! Trepu/xey e^ovre? uxnrep ol fv rals
KreruTrcojueyot, 8ta'7re7r/)t(rju,ei'ot Kara
ras plvas, yeyovoVes &(nrp Kicnrai. aXXa TOVTCOV eve/ca
Trazr' &v$pa \prj anavra TrapaKeXeweo-^at eva-efle'iv irepl
deovs, Iva ra jotey eK^yw/u-ey, rwy 8e rv^uifjifv, ws 6 "Epcos
^yejucuy Kai orparrjyos. to ju,?j8ets evavria Trparrerco
8' tvavria, ocrrty ^6oty dTre^ayfrat -<tA.ot yap
Kat StaAAayeyres rw ^eoi tt;tvpr}<TO}j,V re /cal
-evreu^o/xe^a rot's TratStKoty ro?s ^//.erepots avr&v, o rS>v vvv
dAtyot TTotoCcrt. /cat p7 /xot VTroXaftrj 'Epvifj,ayos, K&)ju&><Sv
ror Ao'yor, ws rTaixraznay /cat 'Ayd^coya Aeya) uroos juey
yap Kat oSrot rovrcoy ruy)(ayou(rty oires Kat etfrty dju,</>orepoi
r^y <f)ijcriv &ppeves Aeyw 8e ovv eycoye
avbp&tv Kat yw>at/c<Si>, ort ovrco? ay fifji&v TO yeros
o, et e/creAecratju,ei> roy epcora Kat rwy ira&iK&v
S eKaoros ryx.oi ets TTJV ap\aiav aTTfXOav (frvaiv.
et
8e rovro apicrTov, avayaalov Kat raiy yw napovTav ro
rovrov eyyurdrto apto-roy etyat* roSro 8' ecrrt
6 6 SA.A.O rt B : i\A.o on T W
67 TOWTO &] roO o5 Badham
69 TOUTO] TOUTOU Bast
8.5 Siaffxi<rdri(r6tLe6a T W^ : 8iacr^;r;(r0rj(rcAt0 B
a 6 /caraypa^V B T W : KaraypaQf) Schneider : /cora
"ypaffiv Ruhnken
Stan-eTrpKT/u.ej'ot T W : SioireTrprjir^eVoi B
b i cos
B T W : wj/ recc.
b 6 /uoi B : yttou T W
05 rv^ot B T : TUXJ? W
C 6, 7 rb . . . fyyvTotTW B T : T . fyyvrdry W
C 7 TOWTO T W :
TOVTOJ/ B

igae
5

10
IQ3

I93c

OAATilNOS

Kara vovv(avT<p/npvK6r(av' o5 brf TOV atrtov dtbv v^

d 8iKaiws av VIOHHIKV "Epcora, 8s tv re ru -napovri ^f.
irXeio-ra 6vurr]<nv ets TO oiKfibv aytav, Kal fls TO eireira
^XiriSas p.yioras Trape^erai, fifj.<av irapexo/nei'aji' Trpos fleows
evvefidav, Karaorrjo-as Tjfxas ets rTjz' ap\aiav (f>v<nv Kal
. 5 iaardp.cvos fjMKapiovs Kal eubaifMivas
OUTOS, I<^J}, a> 'Ept)^ifxa)(e, 6 e^tos Xoyos tori -itfpl
dXXotos ^ 6 <TOS. uxmtp ovy ebf/idrjv (row, JXT)
avroy, ira xal rui' A.onrSi' aKofoutpfv ri eicaoTos
e fp, f*aXXoi> 8 rf e/direpos' 'AyA0<ov yap Ka
"AXXo irei<ro/xa{ troi, e$rj (^di/ai rov 'Epu^ip-axov (tai
yip JLUH 6 Xoyos ^B^cos ^ppTJOr;. Kat et fx^ o-uv^Srj Sa>5 xpcirct T Kal 'A.y&0(ovi beivols ova-i irtpl TO. Ipconitti, irdvu
JUT) Airoprjo-coo'i Xoycov 5ia r6 iroXXa KCU
- vCi 8i 8j*s 8app&.
r' ,
194
T6i> o8w Sawcpdrrj <Jiriv KaXis yap avros
2> 'Epti^ax<' <i 8^ y^foio ov vvv fyoi J^i,
Iffws o5 ^a-ofxat ^7Ti8ai/ ical 'AyAOuv ttirri tv, Kal fiX' ov
<f>o/3oio Kal Iv trawl eljjs &<rittp kyta vvv.
v\f't
5
Iva 0opvf3tjOS> oia TO olfo-Oai TO Otarpov trpoo-boKtav jjLtyaXrjv
i4* j
uts S ^powros IjxoO.
b Kpdnj, f l Ibtav Tr\v <ri)v avbpfiav Kal fxeyaXo<ppoo-i5i'r)i' J
avafiatvovTos %Ttl TOV oicpi/3aira /xera rfiv u
/3Xe\^az/ros evavria rocrol/T<j> fledrpcj), jue'XXoi
o-avrov Xoyovs, Kal ovb' OTrourTiovv iKirXayevros,,.
S olr]6(ir\v ire Oopv(3ri<rr0ai fvtKa r\^.S>v 6\iyo>v avGpanriav.
diTtTW:om.B
d 7 4\\oToj T W : 4\V o?os B
e6
3-wo-i TW : iatofffffu B
a 2 o yvv T W : av cvi/ B
as fcraJ *
T W : teas ou B : oS tffws Schanz
post ? dist. Vahlen
b a oP[T W : lutptfavra B
ba 6riSff{w8at B : ^in5f({o(rflai T W
TW: 0opv0i)9^<rraiu B
>

r
STMHOSION
Tt be, S) 2o6fcpares; rbv 'Aydddova <pdVeu, ov brftrov ju.e
ovYco Oedrpov pea-rov ^yf) wcrre /cat dyvoety on vovv e\ovri
oXtyoi ^(ppoves iroAA<3z> afypovutv <po/3ep&)repoi;
Ov jueyrav KaA<Ss Trototrjy, fyavai, u> 'AyaOoov, Trepl <roC c
Tt eya> aypOLK.ov bo^&fav dA.A.' eS ot8a ort ei rt(rty eiT7;)(ots
av avr&v (frpovTifyis rj T>V
<ro(f)ovs,
ak\a JUTJ 01 ovrot ^/xeistofxev^juei? fxe^ yap
exet TrafAtv KCU I^V T&V TtoXX&v tl 5e aAAots 5
rax v ottorx.vvoto arrows, ei rt
ototo aff\pov ov
rj TT&S Aeyeis;
'AkrjOrj Xeyets,
ato-)(i;yoio e! rt ototo
Tovs 8e 7roAA.ois OVK
10
d
Kat
en
Cy r3i; ev0a.be OTIOVV yiyvevOai, eay povov f
StaAeyrjrat, aAAcos re Kat /caAw. eyw 8e ^8ecos ju.ei>
2coK/)arous 8taAeyo//,e^oi;, drayKatoy 8e /utot
row eyKco/juov T "Epton KOI diroSe^ao'^at Trap' Iros
roy Aoyov a7ro8ous ow eKarepos TO> flew ovrcos
'AAAa KaAws Aeyfts, 4>at8pe, tpavai rbv 'AydOava, e
jji Ka)Ai;et A^yety SooKpfiret yap /cat a0iy earat

'Eyco 8e 8
eVenra eiTretv. 8oKoS(rt yap fxot Travres ol TTp6(r6ev etp]Kores 5
ov TOV debv eyKcojuta^ety dAAa rov? av6pu>TTovs evSai/xovt^ety
Twy dya^oSv >v o debs avrois OLTLOS' OTTOIOS be n? avros &>v
ravra fbutprfa-aro, ovSets etprjKey. els 8e rpo'Tros dp^os Travrbs 195
eiraivov Trepl iraz/ro's, Ao'yw 8teA0ety otos oiav atrtos cov
C 6 Jfffws seel. Schanz : TTWS Usenet
C 7 S/ seel. F. A. Wolf
eg ofoio T W : oloiro B
e 4 w s B T W : ^ vulg.
a i op0bs B :
om. TW
aa oTs o^wv ex emend. T : olos &v BT W

I95a

OAATliNOS
ttfpl o5 av 6 Xoyos y. o#rco 8?) TOV "Epcora Kal
btmiov eirai.vf(rai irp&Tov avrbv olos Itrriv, lireira
ray 8oVeis. <r)fil ovv fya> mivrtai' (9e(3i> e
"Eptora, et 0p-is (cat oue/xeaTjroif fnreii',
flvai avT&v, KaXAioroi' ovra Kal apt<rroz>. IOTI 8e K(l\A.to-Tos
a)i> rotdo-8f. irp&Tov /J,ev vetararos OeStv, S> 4>at8pe. /xeya
8e TfKfj-ripiov
rif A.oyu airos irape'xerat, favyuiv <f>vyfj TO
yfjpas, Ta^ii ov brj\ov on* flaiTOj' yow roii 8eoz>ros 7/fiu'
irpo<r^p\eTai.
& 8^ itffpVKtv "Epeos fj.i(Tflv KCU oi/b' 6im>s
TToAXov irXT)(7iaC'. ftera 8e vetav atl <ruve<rri re *
6 yap iroAaioy Aoyoj e5 lxet> ^"s OJMIOV 6p.oi<a afl
lya> 8^ 4>a8po> TroXAo aAA.a d/xoXoywi; rouro ov\
us 'Epcos Kpo'vou /ecu 'laireroii dp^atorepos eoru', d\\a
<^>7)/4t V(OTaToi' airov eTz/at Ofutv KOI ad vlov, ra 8e TraAaia
irpciyjxara 7rpl OsoiJj, & 'H<rio8os KOI n
'Avdyicr/ ical OWK "Epwri yeyovfvai, d ^Ktwoi a\r]0rj
ov ydp &v ^Krojual oi8^ 8o-ju,ol oXXTJAa>i> lytyvovro K
iroAAa Kal {Maia, tl 'Epcos Iv avrols ^v, ciXXa <^>tX^a xal
Jpi}vrj, Sxrittp vvv, i( 08 'Epcos rcov 6t5i
fjiij' oBv ^OTI, irpis 8fc ry v^(p ciiraXo's^f8)s otos fjV "O/^Tjpos wpt^s TO ^TTtSetfoi Ofov
"Opripos yap "ATTJ^ 0eo'i> r^ (^T/O-II/ eZvat Kai airaX^^r
yovv Tro'Sas avrijs airaXovs fivaiXtyiav
rrjs nv0' aTraXol woSes' ov yap ^TT' o{/8eos
it(\varai, dXX' apa rj yf KOT' avbp&v Kpaara ftalvd.
icaXco o5i> 8oK /LCOI TKp.7jpi6) r^j aToXo'rrjTa aiio<f>aivfiv,
on oiiK (irl crKXjjpot) ftahrti, dXX' ?rl /xaXflaKoC. rS avrfi
bs Jv BW: oJT
bs ?pais T W : IpuTos B
oi5' ^T!J Stobaeus: ou Sifvroj B: ou5' CVTOI TW
b4 TAi)(rii(C<iv TW Stobaeus:
ir\i)<rui(ti B
effriy] ?(TTI yeos Sauppe : Ztrrat Diels
02 irpii7MTa T W Stobaeus : ypafipaTa B
irap/ieviSiis T W : iropjiei-f (8t|s B
d 3 e?yai B T W : ^rjcriy *?vni Stobaeus
d 4 TTJS B T W Stobaeus :
TTI Aristarchus Homeri codices ;T 92)
oflStos B T: oilliei W Homeri
codices
d 5 mAi/arai W et ex irfSvarai T : irijSiiaTat B
d 7 T$
OUT$ T W Stobaeus : ri> aiirb B

STMHOSION

8rj Kal TJ/xet? xpryo-o/xefla TeKjurjpuo Trepl vEpa>Ta on aTraAos.

ov yap eTrl 777? /3aiyei oi>8' em Kpayicoy, a eariy ou Tiavv
jxaAaKa, dAA' ey TOIS /xaAaKcorarot? Twy ovr<av Kal /3atyet
Kal oiKei. ey yap r/0e<n Kal \l/v^ms 0ea>y Kal av6p<*>iru>v T/jy
olKY](TLV IbpvraL, KOI OVK av cfjs kv TrdcraLs rai? v/ff^aT?, aXA'
r\TiVL &v CTKXrjpoy yOos IXOVCTTJ e^r^xry, aTrep^erat, T) 8' ay
. a-nro^vov ovv del Kal Trocrlv Kal TraVrrj
rwy fxaXaKcorarcoy, diraAwraroi' dfayKTj
yewraros /xey 877 ecrri Kal aTraXcoraro?, Trpos 8e
TOTJTOIS vypbs TO eT8os.
ow yap ay otos r' ryy iravri] TTfpiKTij(r<T(r6(u oti8e 8ta Traori]? ^T;^T)S KOI elcn&v TO Trpwroy
Xai/daveiv Kal eiwy, ci (rKAT]pos r]y.
cruju/xeTpou 8e Kal
vypas t8eas /xeya reK/xyypioy 17 e^o-^juocrwrj, o 8r) 8ta-

igse
e

196

yap Kal "Epam Trpoj aXX^Xous del Tro'A.e/xos'.

KaAXos 77 Kar' az^^rj Siatra TOU ^eo{) o-Tj/xatyei- dyay^et yap
Kal aTrrjvOriKOTi Kal (rw/xart Kal 'v/'i'X^ Kat aAAw orwoTjy OVK
eyi^et "Epco?, OTJ 8' ay evay^?]? re Kal evcoSrjs TOTTOS T},
eyraSfla 8e Kal i'^ei Kal fxeVei.
Ilepl fxey oi!y KaXAous rov 6eov Kal ravra Uaya Kal en
TroAAa AeiT7erat, Trepl 8e dperr^s "Epcoros /xera raura AeKreoy,
ro p.ey /xeyicrro^ 6'rt "Epcos ovr' d8t)ceT OTJT' dSiKeirai ovre
VTTO 0eou ovre 0eoy, oiire vir' dy^pcoTrov OTJTC avOpooTtov. ovre
yap avros jSta Trdo-xei, et rt 7rdor)(ei flia yap "Epcoros o^x
ovre iroicoy -TroceTTray yap lKo>y "Epcort Tray
e'i, a 8' ay eKcoy eKo'yri 6/xoAoyr/o-rj, <pa<rlv " ol TroAeco?
i" 8iKata etyat. tfpos 8e TTJ 8iKaioo-7jrrj craxfrpoTrAetarrj? /merexet. etyat yap OjmoAoyetrai crco^poorvyrj
f)bovG>v Kal em0u/Ai<3z;, vEpa>TOS 8e p-rjSe/xiay
ra

>

e i xW^M^a W Stobaeus : xP l '<' iieQa B T

65 4|^r T W : e^
^s B
as Kol (ante cfViebi/'i B T : om. W
a 8 roO B T : om. W
b 3 8e Stobaeus: om. BTW
c a & j / B T W Stobaeus: &/ rts
vulg.
ir6\f<os B T W : ruv v6\tav Stobaeus
c 4 ir
tcXeiffTov Cobet
flvai B T : om. W

nAATJINOS

5
197

Kpefrro) eivar tl 8e ^frrous, Kparoivr av v

6 8e Kparoi, Kpar&v 8 fibov&v Kal em#tip.io>v o *Ep<os 810(^epovrcus av (T<a<ppovoi. Kal /XTJV ls ye dv8pet'av Epom
"ovS' "ApTjs dv#fo-rarai." ov yap lx "Epajra Apj/s,
aAA'vEp<osyAp7j 'A<ppobiTr]s, (is Xo'yosKpfirruv 8e 6 exa>v
TOV tyoufvov TOV 8' drSpetoraTot) T&V &\X.a>v Kpar&v Tfavriav
&v avftpdOTaros fir], irepi p.ff ovv 8iKaio<rwijs xal trax^poenJi^jy Kat avbpetas TOV Otov eipTjrai, irepl 8 cro<ptas
o<rov o%v ItwaerAv, itfipar^ov py eAXefefw;. Kat Trp&rov
Iv1 av Kal iyib, T-ffv rj^tr^pav Tfxyrjv rt/x7j<ra> &a-nep '
TTJV avrov, iroiTjr^s 6 fleos (ro<pbs oCrcos <Sore Kal
iroi^frai' was yow TTOIJJT^S yiyverai, " K&V &jj.ova-os
^ TO Ttpiv," av av "Epcos ai/njrat. y 8^ Trp&ret
HaprupCy -xpfja-Oai, STL woMjrrjs 6 "Ep<os oyaflos
irao-av woijj(7tv r^v Kara juowiKJjir a ydp ns rj p.?)
fx^ otbtv, oi/r' av 4r^p<|) 8o^?j our' a
|ufci> 8^ T-IJP y T&V (fyav ito(r\<rw irairwi' r^s IvavTuacrtrai.
/XT) ov\i "Epcoros clvat vo<p{av, ft ytyvtrat re <cal (^
TroVro ro flia; a\Xa r^v T&V Tt\v&v brojuovpyCav
frrjxty, Sri o5 ^y av 6 0eos ofros 8t8(io-KaAos
lAA.o'ytfios Kal ^ai'ds iasifir], o\i 8' av "Epcos
\fn)Tai, trKOTtivds; Tofu^jv ye JXT)V xal {arptK^v Kol
'Aird'AAwv dvr/Cpev ImOvntas Kal lpa>ros ^yefxovei?<ravros,
(u<rre Kal olros "Epcoros av fcj /xa^Tjr^s, Kal MoC<rai
fioutrtK^s Kal *H(/)ai(rros x^fefaj Kal 'A07jva to-rovpy^as
Kal Zis Kv/3pvav fleflv re Kal &v6p<&Tt<av. Sdev by
Kal KaTf<rK{vd<r6r) T&V Oe&v TO. irpiyjuara "Epwros eyyevopevov, brj\ov on /caAAousalo^ei yap OVK lirt epa>$ irpo
roi; 8^, &<nrep ev apx^ tlirov, iroAAa Kal 8eiva deois tyiyvero,
&4 ta> TW: om. B
d v fo' oJTW: a! B: V oly Stobaeus
e a K & i /BT W i K a J B
64 xp^^ai B T W . xp'fl<raffea' Stobaeus
es fx W : XP TW
a i n*v BT: /)), W
bs 6ri scrips!
et sic fort. pr. B (fort. TI Schanz : limy apogr. D) : l*e<TTO> T W
Stobaeus : (n coir, b : OUK trtimv in marg. rec. b

STMIIOSION

I97b

o>s Ae'yerat, OLO, rrjv rrjs 'Av&yKrjs flcunheiav eTretS^ 8' 6

0eoy OVTOS e<u, e/c TOV epav T&V KaXStv TrdVr' ayaOa yeyovtv
/cat Oeois /cat avdptiirois,
Ovru>s fj.ol boKet, to <&albp, "Epcoy irputTos avTos atv c
KaAAtoTos Kal apioros //.era TOUTO rois aAXot? aAXcoi' TOLOVTMV
atrios e?vai.

e-7repxrat ^e' V-o>{-

TL Ka

' *weTpov dTTfiv, STL

OVTOS l(TTW 6 TTOL&V

dprjvriv /jiev kv avOpuTrois, ^eAayei 8e yakf\V(\v

vr)Vp.iav, avefjiotv Koirrjv VTTVOV r* erl K^Sei.

OVTOS 8e Tyjuias d\Xor/)ioTTjros juev Kfvol, otKeiorrjros 8e TrXrjpol, d.

ras rotao-8e o-DroSovs //r' dAA?/Aa)y Trao-as rt^ets crvvitvai,,
fv topTois, lv Copals, f v 6v<Tiai<Ti yiyvofjifvos
riye^v
irpaorrjra juev TropCfav, dy/)torrjra 8' eopiu>v (j)i\6ba>pos
ei>IJiveias, abapos bvcr/j-fveias' tAecos dya^o's' ^earoy (ro(pois, 5
dyacrros ^eo^s' fTjAcoros d/xoipots, KTTJTOS v^oipois' Tpv<pr)$,
aflpoTriTos, xXt8^s, yjupiTtov, iptpov, TroOov iraTrip' eTrt/AeA^y
ayaO&v, djaeA^y KO.K&V ev TTWW, ez> <^o/3a>, ey TTO'^O), ez/
Aoyo> Kvfiepw/iTrjs,
eTrt/Sarrjs, Trapaorarr;? re /cat (TCOTT)/) e
KaAAtorros xat apttrros, w x/)*) fVeo'^at -Trarra &vbpa
vovvra KaAws, w8^y ^T^OVTCL rjv a8et ^eAycoy Travreoi'
re Kal avdpfaTtav vor^a.
OSroy, e<r/, 6 Trap' ejuou Aoyo?, & 4>at8pe, rw
avaKficrda), ra /uer iratStay, ra 8e
ocroi' eycb 8
63 e^fierpoy BTW Stobaeus : f^erpus Hermogenes
C6 avepotv
BTW: T' avf/j.<Dv Stobaeus : 5' avepois Hermogenes
icotr^j/BTW:
Kolrriv T' Stobaeus : KOI'TT? 6' G. Dindorf
T* efi K^Sei Stobaeus
Hermogenes : re viKySei B : re vrj/cTjS^ T : re vtK^Sei W (in marg, -yp.
tcxJ j/Tj/crjSe?)
d 3 Ovffiatffi
W : Bvariais B T : evOvptais Stobaeus
ds '/\ecy 070^$ B T W : '/Xews wyaGols Stobaeus : iKeias ayav6s Usener
d 7 xA.t'5)s (sic) T (sed I ex ^j) : xx*75^ ^ : X^^S^s W
1/j.fpov T W :
TlHepov B
ir66ov om. Stobaeus
d.8 d/teAV T W : dreX^s B
iv <f>6@<p ev iroQff fv irdvcp ev p.ay<p Schiit2 : tv ir6v<f ev <p6^(fi ev fj.66cp
eV p&ytf Jahn : V ir&vt? ev (f>6&<p ev fn66y ev ^XV Rettig: alii alia
e a Kal B T : om. W
6 4 KaXws B T W : /caA^s Stobaeus : KO\WS
KoA^s vulg.

ig8a

ITAAT&N02

198

EiTroyros Se TOV 'Aydflcoyo? Travras f<pt] 6 '

avcidopvfifjfrai.
TOVS Ttapovras, cos TrpeiroyrcoS' TOV veavio-Kov
etpTjKoros Kat avrGt KOL rco 0e. TOV ovv 2ft)KparTj eiTmy
/3Ao//ayra ei? TOV 'Epv^Cfj.a\ov, 'Apd crot SOKCO, <pdvai, u>
5 Tra? 'AKOu/jteyou, a8ee? TrdAat 8eo? SeSievat, aXX5 oil /xayriKfis
e\eyoy eiTreuJ, on 'Ayd^coy Oavfj,a<TT&s fpol, eyw 8'

10
b

5
d

To /jiey fTfpov, (frdvai. TOV '

8o/cei? etprjKe^ai, ort 'Ayd^coy ev eper ro 6e (re a
OVK ot/jiai.
Kat TTWS, a> fj.aKa.pLe, eiTreiv Toy ScoKparrj, ov jaeAA.co
aTropeiy KCU eyco Kat aXXo? oo-rto-oCy, ju.eAA.coi> Ae
KaXbv ovrco (cat irayroSaTroy Aoyoy prj^eWa; Kat ra
ov)( 6//,otcos /xey Oav^acrTa- TO 8e eTrt reAew?}? TOU KaAAous
rwy oyo/Aarcoy Kat p?]//,dr(oy rt? ov/c ay I^CTrAayrj aKO^coy;
eirel lycoye fvdv^ov^evos on awoy ov^ otos r' eo-oju,at ow6'
eyyvs Tourcoy ovSez> KaAoy etTrety, VTT' ato-^wrjs dAtyov
airobpas fyoWV' ^ 1r?? et^oy. KOI yap /ue Fopytou 6 Xoyos
wo-re arex^s ro roC 'O/x^pov
//,ot reAeuraiy 6 'Aya0coy Fopytou
Xeyeiv f v rw Aoyw ITTI roy e/xor Ao'yoy 7re/x,\^a9 amov
/ue XiQov TTJ a(p(viq irot?](retey. Kat ez/eyorjcra ro're apa
KarayeAaoros coy, rpuca i;/x,ry co/zoAoyoi)y ey rco /xepet /x.e^'
v/xcoy eyKcojtuacrecrflai roy vEpcora Kat ec^rjy etyai Setyos ra
epcoriKa, o^Sey etScos apa ro{5 7rpdyp,aro?, a>?
ortow. eya) juey yap VTT' d^SeAreptas cojutrjy Sew
Aeyety Trcpt eKacrrou roC eyKco/xia^b/xeyou, Kat rouro
virdp-^eiv, e^ ai/rcoy 8e ro^rcoz^ ra KaAAicrra eKAeyofxe
w? etiTrpeTrecrrara rtfleyar Kat Trdw 8^ /xeya e<pp6vovv to? eS
epcoy, cos etScby Trjy dA?]0eiay rot; eiratyety ortoCy. ro 8e apa,
as irp7rJPTCOS b t : irpeirovTos B T W
a 8 ^uot 8oKf?s B : Sonets
fioi T W
Tb 3 oi?Tfti Kal travTo^airbv B : Kal "ira.vTofta.irbv O^TCO T W
b4 j u e v B T W : om. Vind. 21
bs CLKOVUV B T : om. W
1)6 ofo's
T' B T : ofos W
C 4 Iv Tea Xoy<p seel. Usener
d 3 ajSeAre/oias
B: afc\rn(a.s TW

STMnOSION

198 d

as HoiKtv, ov TOVTO j\v ro KaAws firaivelv OTIOVV, dAAa ro <*>s

p,eyi<rra avariOfvai ra> Trpdypxin Ka w? mAXtora, ear re ?}
otfrcos exoyra eaz> re fxrj' et 8e \jsevft-rj, ovoev ap' T]I> Trpayjua.
yap, <ws eotKey, OTTCO? e/caoros rypwu roy "Epcora
i' oa, ov^ OTTCOS eyKcojutauerat. 8to raura 6^
ot/xat Trdvra Aoyoy Kiz>owres d^art^ere rw ^Epcori, xai
<^>are avrbv TOLOVTOV re etVat Kat rocrovrwy atrtoy, OTTCOS av
a>s KaAAto-ros Kat apiaros, 8^Aoy on rot? /x^ yiyvfi)ov yap SIJTTOU rots ye etSoo'ti' Kal KaAais y' e^et
6 i-Traivos.
dAAa yap eya> OVK ^817 apa TOV
rpoirov TOV (Traivov, oi> 8' eto"a>? v/Aty (WjaoAoyrjo-a Kat euros
ey rw //.epet eTraiyeo-eo-^at. 77 yAwo-(ra ovy VTr(T\fTO, f] 8e
(j)pT]V oil' yaiptrut 877. ou yap ert eyKO)/xta{co rovroy roy
rpoiiov oil yap az> ^vvai^v ov /AeVroi dAAa rd ye aXrjOrj,
d /3owAeo-0e, e^eAco eiirety Kar' l/j,auroV, ov irpos roi/s
v/xerepovs Ao'yous, ?ra /u^ yeAcora o</>Aa). opa oSv, S 4>ai8pe,
ei rt /cat rotovrou Ao'you 8e'r/, 7reptvEpa)ros rdAr^^ Aeyo/^eya
aKovew, ovofJidcreL 8e Kat ^eo-et pry/xdrcor rotavrTj OTrota 8ay
rtj rv^r/ eVeA^ouo-a.
Toy ovy $at8poy e^rj Kat rovs aAAous KeAevety Aeyew,
OTTT) avrbs ototro 8ety etTretu, ravrrj.
v
Ert TOLVVV, (j)dvai, 2> 4>ar8pe, -Trapes fxot 'Ayd^coya a-pAp'
arra epeo-^at, tVa avofJ^Xo'yrjcrdfj.fVos
Trap' avroii o-0rcos 77877
Aeya).
'AAAa 7rapt7]//.t, (pdvai TOV <&aibpov, dAA' epcora.
raftra 87) roy 2coKpdrrj e^>rj ey#er8e TtoOev apacrdai.
Kat p,7yy, co ^)tAe 'Ayd^cov, KaAws /uot edo^a?
crao-Oai TOV Aoyou, Aeycov ort Trpwroy juey 6eot avTov
OTTOIO'S rt? etrrty 6 vEpcos, va-repov 8e ra epya awrou.

TavTrjv

e 4 8o'ei Stephanus : 8J|? B T W

as -yP S^irou Cobet : 70^ ir
iroi; T W : yap TTOU B
a 3 77877 Spa T : 77 S?j B W
a 5 yXSxrffa W :
7\WTTa B T
lb 4 ovopoKrei W : ovdpaari B T
5Si/ Usener (5^ &v

Stallbaum) : S' & B : 5' ^ T W

5
199

ro

199 c

riAATHNOS

TTJV apx'hv irdvv aya/xat. IBi ovv jj,oi irept "Epooro?,

Kal raAAa KaA<Ss Kal //.eyaAoirpeTrcos dti/A^es otos ecru, KOL
d i~o<5e eiTre- n'orepoV eVn rotovros otos eTvat TWOS 6 vEpcoy
epcos, T) o^Seros; epwT<2 8' OVK et fj,r]Tp6s TWOS rj
ytXolov yap av ctrj TO epwrrjju-a et "Epcos eoTJ Trarpos dAA' &cnrp av et avro rouro
, apa 6 irarrip ecrri irarrip TWOS ^ ov;
ftot, ei e/3ovAou KaXcSs aTroKpivatrOai, on earn;
ye ^ dvyarpos 6 jraTrjp Trar^p1 ?) ov;
ye, (frdvat. TOV 'Aya^cova.
Kat 77 {J-TrjT-qp axravrcos; '0/x.oAoyeur0ai /cat roro.
v
Eri roiVw, eiTrely roi; SwKparTy, aTTOKpivai dAtyw irAeia),
tz^a /aaAAoy Kara/xa^rjs o /3ouAo/zat. et yap epot/Aryy, " Ti
8e; d8eA^)os, avro rou^' oirep HO-TIV, H<rTi TWOS d8eA</>os 77
01;;
ITetpw 877, tpdvai, KCU TOV epcora etTrery. 6 "Epcos epws
eorw ovde^os ?) TWOS;
Haw p.fv oSf eorty.
2OO
Tovro //,ey TOIVVV, eiiretr roy ScoKptirrj, <$>v\aov Ttapa
oi jJ,iJLVr)iJLvos OTOV Tocrovot 8e eiTre, Trorepoi; 6 "Epcoy
ov eoT> epcos, eirt0i)/x,e? avrou T) ov;
ye, (pdvai.
ITorepoy exa>^ avro 01! eirt^Tjjoiet re Kat epa, ecra eTTi^ujuet
re Kat epa, r) OVK ex^v;
fxu>v> &s TO etKoy ye, (pdvai.
?;, et7reu> roy ScoKparrj, dyri roC etKOTOS et
oi/rcos, ro emflup-ow kiriBvyi^iv ov ev8ees eorty, 77 JUT)
ay /UT) evSees J; ep;ol /uey yap
w 'Aya^wy, a>s dvdyKT] elvai' crot 8e
Kdjaot, (pdvai., 8oKet.
07 o?<fcB: o f o y r ' T W
d i epcspwjBW: epwj T
Xoyeja-flaiBTW: 5yuoAo7^(rat vulg. : 6fio\(yyfiJ' Stallbaum
B T : ffKoifiiv W
(IKOTOS B T : eiKOTws W

dp
a8

STMHOSION

200 b

KaAoos Aeyets. ap' owy /3ovAotr' ay rts fxeyas a>y f>ie'yas

etyat, 17 loyvpbs <wy tcr^upos;
5
'ASvyaroy eK r<Sy oopoAoy^peycoy.
Ov -yap TTOV eySerjs ay etT] TOVTMV o ye <ay.
'AAT1077 Ae'yets.
Et yap Kat Icrxypbs u>v ^SovAotro tcr^upo? etyat, 0ayat roy
SwKpdrij, KOI rax^s &>^ rax^s, Kal i$yi7)s a>y ^yt77?^ttrcos 10
yap ay rty rai)ra olrjOeirj ml irayra ra rotai;ra TOVS OVTO.S
re rotovroDS Kat exoyras ravra TOVTWV airep lxor(rt Ka' c
fy' oSy p,r) ea7rar?]0<3p,ey, rovrou e'yeKa Aeyco
yap, 'Aya^coy, ei eyyoet?, exeiz; Mez; ^Kd-crT^
TOVTatv ey rw Trapoyrt dydyK/j ^ <-\ov(riv, eayre jSovAcoyrat
edyre jw,?y, Kat rovrou ye 8r/7rou rts ay eTTt^vp-rjcreiey; dAA' 5
oray rts Aeyr; ort eya) vytatycoy ^SovAojuat Kat vytatyety,
Kat TrAourwy /QovAo/mat Kat TrAovrety, Kat eirt^v/xS avr&v
rovrcoy a ^X^ e^Trotuey ay avrS on o~u, <J) ay^ptoTre,
irAovroy KeKrrjju.e'yos Kat vytetay Kat to^y j8oi;Aet Kat ets d
roy e?retra -^povov raiira KKTfj<T0ai, eTret ey rfi ye y{5y
TrapoVri, etre fiovXfi, etre /U.T/, ?xeis' fKOTret oi!y, oray
roCro Ae'yTjs, on Tn0vp,& rwy Trapoyrcoy, ei aAAo rt Aeyets
^ roSe, on /3ovAopat ra yuy irapovTa Kat ets roy eTretra 5
Trapetyat. aAAo rt op^oAoyo? ay; 2up,(/)ayat 1^)77 roy
Etirety 8^ roy Sco/cparrj, OvKouy rouro y' ecrrty
epay, o OVTTO) erot/xoy aiirw eo-rty ov8e e^et, ro ets roy
euetra yjpovov raura e?yat atr5 o-w^o/ieya Kat -zrapoyra;
10
Ilayr; ye, (pdvcu.
e
Kat ovros apa Kat aAAo? mis 6 fTnOvpStv TOV ^7) erotjaou
Kat row P.TJ uapoyros, Kal o p,^ lxet Ka* o
b 6 &>iJLO\oyr]^.4vi>)v B T W : 6/jio\oyovfji.fi>cov vulg.
b 9 (cat B T :
om. W
b 1 1 TOI/TO B : ravrl T W
03 e/ca<rTo B T W : fKacrrov
vulg.
C 7 /ccd TrAourerc B : TrAoureri' T W
d.3 ?x*is T W :
(Xys B
d. 8 OVKUVV B W : OVKOVV 5^ pr. T
d 9 rb . . . d 10 TrapoWa
seel. Badham
dgrbTWiraB
d 10 *al TW : juot B : ra
vC^ al. vulg.
e 2 &\Aos B W : 6 &\\os T

20oe

nAATONOS

avrbs Kol ov vber]S eort, roiaur' arra eariy <Sz>

5 re /cat o epcos
IIan> y',
V
10t 877, c/>dz>ai TOV SooKpdn;, dyo|ixoAoyr7<r<>p,e0a ra etprjju,ei>a. aAAo rt lortv 6 "Epcos irp&Tov /uey rtywy, eiretra
TOVTOOV 8>v av e^8eta Trap^ avr<3;
2OI
Nat, (fravai.
'Em S?) rouroi? ava^vfi<rBr]Ti TLVU>V ttyiqcrOa kv rai Xoyw
eTyai roy "Epcora' et Se fiovXfi, lyw ere dya;ui^cra). oijuai
yap <re oircocri TTWS ei7reu>, on TO^ ^eois KarecrKeuacr^rj ra
5 Trp^yjuara 81' epcora KaXwy alcr\p)V yap OVK eirj epcos. ov^
TTCO? eAeye?;
yap, (pdvat TOV 'Ayadcava.
Kal eTTteiKwy ye Aeyets, S erape, (frdvai TOV ScoKparr/'
Kat et rouro oiJrcos e^et, aAAo rt 6 "Ejocos KaAAous ay eirj
10 epcos, ato-)(ous 8e ov; CvQ/x,oAoyet.
b
OVKOVV wfioAoyryrat, ov ey8e?js eari /cat /x,r) exet} TOUTOU
epay;
Nat, etiretv.
'EySe^s ap' eo-rt Kat OVK e^et 6 "Epco? KaAAos.
5
'AvdyKrj, <p&vai.
Tt 8e; ro evdees /cdAAovs /cat p^ajuij Ke/cr^eyoy KaAAo?
apa Aeyets crv /caAoy eTyai;
Ov Sr/ra.
v
Ert ovv o^ioAoyers vEpwra KCL\OV etvai, et ravra ovrco?
10 ex;
Kat rov 'Aya^coya etirety KtySurevco, Sco/cparey, ovSey
etdeVai c5y rore e?7roy.
C
Kat fjJriv KaXSts ye et^rre?, fyavai, o> 'Ayd^coy. aAAa
0-p.iKpbv ert etire0 raya^a ov Kat KaAa SOKCI crot eivai;
"Ejuotye.
65 re om. W
67 avofJto\ojit<r<i/jLe6a
o ep&js W
a 9 T<- i] 77 s. v. Oxy.
C I i7ras Oxy.

a 5 epws BT Oxy. :

STMIIOSION

20IC

Et &pa 6 *Ep(o$ TK>V /caA(3z> tvbeys tort, ra 8e &yaOa

/caAa, K&V T&V ayaduiv (vberjs efy.
5
'Eyco, (pdvai, Sco/cpares1, crot OVK &v bwai^r/v O.VTLAe'yetz;, aAA' OVTMS e^era) s a^ Aeyets.
Ov juey ovv rf] aA.?70eta, (fravai, S
bvvaaai, avriXtyew, eTret 2co/cparet ye
Kat o-e //ey ye 57877 edo-w roy 5e \6yov TOV Trept rot;
"E/KJoros, 6V TTOT' r//coucra yvvaiKos MazmifiKT/s Atort/ias, 77
raSra re cro^r/ r]y Kai aAAa TroAAa /cat 'AOrjvaiois Trore
6v(ranfvois irpo TOV XOL^OV bzKa errj ava/3oA.r}v eTrotrytre T^S
voffov, 77 77 /cat e)ue ra epcort/ca fbibafev '6y oSz^ eKtivr]
eAeye Aoyoy, Tietpacro/Aat vnAty SteA0eiy e/c rwr w/xoAoyrjjj,vu>v ejuot Kat 'Aya^wyt, avros ZTT' f^avrov, OTTMS av
8wft>/x,ai. Set 8r/, S 'Aya^a)y, (acnrep (TV biriyrjaro), SteA^eif
avrov TrpStTov, rts e<rru> 6 "Epcos /cat TTOIO'S rty, eTretra ra
epya avrou. 8oKet oSy /^tot pqvTov etmt OTJTCO 6teA^ety, o')?
Trore jae T/ ^eVr7 avaKpLvovcra 8tr/et. o"xe8oy yap rt Kat eya>
avrr]v erepa rotaura lAeyor otciTrep wv Trpo? ep:e
, &>9 et?j 6 "Epcoy peyas ^eos, e'try 8e rwy /caAwy
877 /ue rovroty rots Aoyots otcnrep eyco TOVTOV, w?
/caAo? etr; /cara ror e/^of Aoyor ovre ayafloy.
Kat eyw, IT<3s Aeyets, f(f>rjv, S Atort/xa; al(r\pbs apa 6
"Epcos eort /cat Ka/cos;
Kat 77, OT}/C V(pr]iJiri(Ti.s; <-<pr)' 77 o?et, ort az^ p.7) /caAoi'
17, avayKcuov amo eti>at atcr^poV;
MdAiora ye.
'H /cat ay p:^ cro<pov, d//,a0es; 7^ OTJ/C TjV^Tjo-ai on eoriz>
rt p,era^7j (ro^ta? /cat
Tt TOTJTO;
c8 ^)i\e Oxy.
da
.
traro (rns s. v."i Oxy.
d.5 Aoyoi/ fKfivri t\eyev Oxy.
Gxy : OTT' B T V V
O.8 Se? 5^ TW Oxy.: SSI'ATJ B
B T W Oxy. : S^ fiyfja-co Schanz
e r OTTOIOS Oxy.
Sf Oxy.
e8 TTtaa- fQij \eyets Oxy.

63

e
,

10
2O2

202 a

IIAAT&NO2

To opQa bodtv Kal avev TOV \tiv Xoyov bovvai OVK

otcrO', e<pr?, OTL OVT emVracrflcu eortu aXoyov yap irpay^a
TTWS av tfr) fTTKTT'rifj.r] ; ovre afjiaOia ro yap TOV OVTOS
Tvy\dvov TrcSs az; eir; djuaflia; e<rrt 8e bi^irov TOLOVTOV r)
6p9r] 8o^a, juera^u ^poi/Tjo-ecos /cat a//,a0tas.
10
*AXr}6r), T\V 8' eyw, Ae'yets.
b
M?) roiwv avayKa^e o pr] KaXov t(mv olcryjpbv
/urj8e 6 /XTJ ayadov, mKov. OOTCO 8e Kal TOV "Epwra
avTos dfj.oX.oyels pr) zlvai ayadov jurjfie KaXov, {j,r]bfv ri
lJ.aX.Xov oiov 8eu> avTov altr\f)bv Kal KO.KOV elvai, aXXd ri
5 fiera^w, H(f>r], TOVTOIV.
Kat jowjy, r/y 8' eycoj o//,oAoyerrat ye Trapa irdvTcav //.eyas
/XT) etSoTwi', eqbrj, Trayrcor Aeyet?, 77 Kai rail'
10
Kai ^ yeA.d<ra<ra Kat irwy ay, e^>?7> w
C 6/xoXoyoiro /xeya? 0eos ctyai Trapa TOVTUIV, 01 <acriz; avTov
ovbe deov elvai;
Tivcs OVTOI; rjv 8.' eyw.
Eis /xey, I0r], CTTJ, )uta 8' eyw.
5
Kayo) etTroy, IIcos roSro, ^r\v, Xeyets;
Kat T)', 'PaSta)?, e<^rj. Xeye yap JJ.OL, ov Trdvras Oeovs
^)r)s evbaifj-ovas tlvai Kal KaXovs; ^ TaX^r/crais av Tiva JUT)
(f)dvai KaXov re Kat cvbaifjiova 6&v eimi;
Ma At' OUAC eycoy', e(prjz>.
10
EvSat/xoyas 8e 8r) Ae'yets ou TOVS rayaOa Kal ra KaAa
ye.
'AAAa /xr)y "Epcord ye

cop-oAo'yrjKas 81' erSetar TCOZ;

as T?> B T Oxy. : ret W

opfla 5o|ciC' T W Oxy. : 5p0o5of a&'" B
ical om. Oxy.
b 5 rovroiv e^>7j Oxy.
b 6 ye B T Oxy. : pot W
2
c 8 fle^ BT W Oxy. : Oei>v W (o s. v.)
C 10 Tayafla B T Oxy.
Stobaeus : ayaQovs Kal varya-fa W
TO E Oxy. : om. TW Stobaeus
d I, 2 rwv KO.\&I> ical TWV a.ja.0uv Stobaeus

aoad
ayad>v

Kal

KaX&v

fiudvpelv

avT&v TOVTMV

&v

fffTLV.

'i2ju,oAoyrj/ca yap.
Ilws ay ovv 0os etrj o ye T&V Kak&v Kal ayaO&v ajj.oi.pos;
*Opqs ovv, f(f)fj, 6'rt KOL cry "Epcora ov Oebv
Tt ovv av, <j>r]v, etrj 6 "Epco?; Bvrjros;
ye
"AAAa ri
ra Trporepa, <pr], /x,era^r> Ovrjrov /cat aOavarov.
Ti oSy, a) Aiort/xa;
s, S Sc^/cpares' Kal yap Trap TO bat-noviov
kern Oeov re Kal OvrjTov.
e
, rjv ' eyco, bvva^iv Zyov;
Kal ^iai^op6^vov Scots ra Trap' avOp<6ir<iov
Kal avOp&TTOis ra ?rapa 0ewr, rwy /^tey raj 8e?7a-eis /cat
GvcrCas, T&V 8e ras e7rtraeis re /cai djixoi/3ay ry 6vo-i)v, 5
f.v p.e(r<o 8e or ap-^ore'pcov 0-vp.TTXrjpot, wcrre ro Tray avro
avroi cri)^8e5ecr6ai.
6ia rowrou /cat 77 /uarri/cr) Tracra X^P^
Kal rj T&V tepecoy re^y?] r<3z> re Trept ras ^ucrta? /cat re/Veras
Kal ras eTrwSay Kat TTJV fJ.avTiav Ttacrav Kal yo?]retay. Oebs 203
6/xtXta Kat r/ SiaAeKros 0eots Trpos avOpticnrovs, Kal eypryyopo<rt Kat Ka^evSoucrf
Kat 6 p,ey Trept ra rotaura o~o(j)bs
8atp;oVto? dz;7]p, 6 be aXXo rt <ro(pbs &v rj Trept re'x^as 5
i? x.eipovpyia$ Tivas
fldvavcros.
OVTOI br) ol
d 5 &/ B Oxy. Stobaeus : 8' hv T W
rwr T W Oxy. Stobaeus :
7' &v B
d 6 &s 7' B T : wo- 76 Oxy. : y' y W : S<rr' Stobaeus
dn ^77 T W Oxy. : I^T/y B Stobaeus
e i re BT Oxy. : om. W
Stobaeus
e 8 TeA.eras T W : ras re\eras B Oxy. Stobaeus
a i fjLavreiav BT W Oxy. Stobaeus : fj-ayyaveiav Geel : fj.ayeiav Badham
a 4ffoQbsB T W Oxy. : <r^oSpk Stobaeus
as &v E T W Oxy. :
om. Stobaeus
a 6 ^ B T W : ^ wepl Oxy. Stobaeus favavaovs
Oxy.
PLATO, VOL. n.
13

203 a

IIAATGNOS
TroAAot Kat TravTobairoC tlcnv, els e TOVTCDV lort Kai 6
"EpCDS.

Ilarpds be, rfv ' y, TLVOS e<rrt Kai /UTjrpos;

MaKporepoz> pev, f<prj, Strjyj/o-ao-flar ojucos' 8e erot epfi.
ore yap eyeVero ^ 'Ac^poStrrj, fja-Ti&VTO ol 0eot ot re aAAot
Kai 6 rjjs M^riSos1 vos Hopos.
eTretSr) 8e ebfiTTV^crav,
Trpoo-aiTrfcrovcra. olov brj euco^ias ova-rjs a<piKTo f) Yievia, Kai
5 r\v irepl ras Ovpas.
6 ovv Ylopos jue^uo-^ei? rou venrapos
o?vos yap OVTTW r\vet? rov TOV Atos KTJTTOV elaeXd&v
vbev. fj ovv ITevta e7j-t/3ovA.evouo-a 8ta T^y
a-TTopCav ira&iov 7ro7<ra<r0ai e/c rou IIopou, *caraC fcAiyerai re Trap' avrw Kai fKvr](Tf TOV "Epcora.
810 8?) Kat
r?Js 'A<^po8tr?]? aKoXovdos Kai Oepcnratv ytyovev 6 vEpa>s,
ets ey rot? eKetyrj? yeye^Xtots, /cat a/xa <pv<rei epacoy irept ro KaXbv Kai Trjs 'A0po8tr?7S KaA^? ovcnjs.
5 are owv ITopou Kat ITe^ias vbs hv 6 "Epcos ly roiavrrj r^x^
Trp>rov fj,ev TrevrjS aet eorc, Kat TroAAou Set
re Kat KaAos, olov ol TroAAot otoz^rat, dAAa

av)yj.t]pbs Kai avvTrobrjTOS Kai aoiKos, xalJ'aL'7TfT'ns

Kai aorpcoros, e-jrt 6vpais Kai ev obols inraiOpios
, rrj^ r^y jJ.r]Tpbs <f)V(nv tyjuv, det eyfieta CTUZ/OIKOS.
Kara 8e av rov Trarepa eTrtySouAo? eori rot? KaAots Kat rots

5 ayaflot?, avopelos a>y Kat mj? Kat O-VVTOVOS,

bftvos, det rtz/as 7rAeK6oy fj,r]^avds, Kai

Orjpevrrjs

^ujurjrrjy Kat 7ropt]u,os, <iA<Kro(<3z> 8ta

8eiz>os yo?]? Kat (papfjiaKfvs
Kat crcxpKm/s- Kat owre
6 afldVaros1 TT<f)VKV ovrt wy Ovrjros, dAAa rore jue^ r?ys
7yp;epas ^dAAet re Kat ^r), oray e-uTropTja-r/, rore 6e a
a 7 al prius B T W : re KCU Oxy. Stobaeus
a 9 rkos eirrl al
fjLttrpbs B W et corr. T: al /jTpbs T^I/OS *<rTi(v} T Oxy.
b 2 ^O-TIWJ/TO
2
B T : ela-Ti&vro B W t : iVrnwiTO Oxy.
b 4 vpocratr^s o5<ra B
Origenes
b 6 f^\duv Oxy.
c i 8)? <cal B T Oxy.: 5); W
C 6 ireyfys B
Set B T Oxy : ty W
da viraiOptos B W Oxy. :
uTraiflpi'ois T
d 4 TO?S alterum om. Oxy.
d 7 irdpi/jios (pi\oaro<pwv
T W Oxy. : iropia-fios <pi\o<r6<pcov B
d 8 /col prius om. Oxy.
6 i COITUS om. Oxy.
e 2 re T W : om. B Oxy.

SYMIIOSION

2036

cruel, TtaXiv 8e dm/SiwcrKerai 8ta TTJV TOV Ttarpbs (frvcriv, TO

8e iropiop,ez>oz> dei VTTtKpe'L, wore ovre d-Tropei "Epcos -rrore
irAoTjret, cro^tas re aS Kat ap.a6[as kv p,eVw eoTiV. 5
yap <5Se. $ea}y o^Sets <ptAoo-o<^>e? o?jS' em07jp,ei (rcxpbs 204
ai. eon yap 0^5' e? rts aAAos <ro(p6s, ov (f)i\oaro<f)el.
ov8' av ol a^adeL^ <tyi\o(ro($>ov(Tiv ov& em^fjuowt (ro^ot
yevecrdai- amb yap TOVTO eart xa^e7I"oy ap-adia, TO ^77
KaAoy KayaOov ^r]8e (ppovi^ov boKflv amS> tlvat 5
6 7 olovos vbfrS zlvai ov &v
TCves ovv, e(f>rjv eyw, S A6ori)ua, 01 <tA.ocro<powrey, ei
ot crotyol //,7jre ot djua^er?;
877, e<ij, roCro ye r;8rj Kat TratSt, ort ot juera^i
dju^ore'pcoi', <yy ar ei?7 Kat 6 "Epcos. ea-Tiy yap 81)
77 (ro^)ta, "Epcos 8' eo-rty epco? Trepl TO
ware ayayKmoy "Epa)ra <tAocro(poz> ewat, tyiXovotyov 8e
f/,erav ewai (rotyov Kat apaQovs. atrta 8e a^rw Kat 5
77 yevecris' Trarpos /xer yap <ro(pov eort Kat timopov,
8e o'w crotyrjs Kal a-nopov.
77 p,ey ow Averts TOU
^>tAe 2coKpares, ai/rr?' 6y 8e <rv (prjOrjs vEpcora
et^at, 0av[J.a(rTbv ovfiev eVa^es.
(1)77^779 8e', ws ejaot 8oKet c
reKp.atpo/xe'yrj e wy (ri/ Aeyets, ro tpto^evov "Eptora eT^at,
ov ro epwy Sta raCra trot oT/xat irciyKaAos e^atfero 6
*Epco9.
Kat yap eort TO epaor6z> ro r5 oz/Tt KaAw Kat
a/3poi> /cat Te'Aeoy /cat /[/.aKaptoroV' ro 8e ye ep<3y aAArjy 5
Kat eyco elTrov, Etev
TOIOUTO? &v 6 vEpa>s Ttz/a
TOUTO 8r^ jixera raSr',
8t8aat.
eo"Tt p-ey yap

8ij, S ^'^77, KaA<Ss yap Ae'yets'

\peiav e'x" TOS av6pa>Trois;
<prj, & ScoKpares, Tretpao-o/ixat (re d
8rj TOIOUTOS Kat ovra) yeyo^cos 6

63 irctAiv S. v. Herat corr. Oxy.

65 re oS fi T W : re /cat B :
KO.I (av s. v. ) Oxy.
as KUT (aur^) B 2 TW Oxy. : aurb B
b i 5fy
T W Oxy. : '6ri B
b 2 a/ efy Oxy. : &/ B T W
c 2 eAe7e(r
Oxy.
e4TO( epwro Oxy.

I1AAT&N02
Epcos, eort 8e rS>v naK&v, 019 crv ^rfs.
a 8e rts
epotro' Tt r<3z> KaAaiz; eoriy 6 "Epoos, co Sw/cpares re
5 KOI Atori/xa; e58e 8e o-a^o-repov epa 6 epStv rS>v KaAwv
TI epq;
Kat eya> etTroz^ ou Fei'ecr^at a-yrai.
'AXA.' Irt iroOf'i, e(f>r], r] cnroKpLtns epwrrjcriy roiaz^e' Tt
eorat eKetyw w ay y^vqrai ra xaAa;
10
Ov Trayi) e^r/y Irt e)(eu; eya> -Trpos ravrrjv rrjv e/)ci)T7j(riz;
6

'AAA.', e^>rj, &(TTTfp av et rts juera^SaAcoy dz^rt roi) /caXoi)

rw ayada xP^A^os irvvOdvoiTO' ^epe, a Sco/cpares, epa 6
epwy ra>y ayaO&v rt epa;
YtvzcrQai, rjv 8' eyw, aww.
5
Kat rt earat eKetVft) w ay yevrjTai ra-yadd;
Tour' ewopwrepoy, ^v 8' eyc), l)(a) aTTOKpivacrOai, on
V$aifji(DV lorat.
205
KrTycret yap, e^)?], ayaO&v ot ^8at)aoye9 evbai^oves, /cat
ov/cert 7rpoo"8er epecr^at "Ira rt 5e /SovAerat
6 (3ovk6fj.evos; dAAa reA.os
5

Tawrrjy 8r) r^y ftovXrjcriv Kat roi' epcora roSroy Trorepa

KOIVOV otet etyat -Trayrcoi' av6p(&Tru>v, Kat Trayras raya^a
^ovAecr^at avrofc etyat det, 77 TTWS Aeyeis-;
O#ra>?, -ijy 8' lyw' K.OLVOV eirat TTCIVTOOV,
Tt 81) ow, IcpTj, cio Sc)Kpares', ov Traz^ras epay (pajaey,
b etTrep ye Trazres rwy avr&v epcS(rt /cat det, dAAa rt^as cpa/nev
epay, roiis 8' ov;
@au/xa^co, ?fy 8' lyco, Kat avros.
'AAAa /U.TJ davfj.aC, Ifprj1 d^eAoVres yap apa roi) epcoros
d4 re B Oxy. : om. T W
ds ^9 BTW Oxy. : ^ b vulg.
d 8 en iro0e? T W Oxy. : eVtTroflel B
e 2 ep? B T W Oxy. : <=p<2
vulg.
a ifrya&oj'B
a 5 8^) T W : S^ B Oxy.
a 6 ofet el^ou
BT: eTi/otoret W
b4 Spa T Oxy. : om. B W spcoros B W :
epwvros T

2TMI1O2ION
TL elbos oz>opvdb//,ei>, TO TOV oAov eTrtrtfleWes ovo/xa, epcora, 5
ra 8e aAAa aAAots Kara\pd>^6a 6Vo/jia<riz>.
' flcnrep ri; -fjv 8' eyco.
''Qcnrtp ro8e.
oto-0' on TToirjcris eort rt TroAv' T/ yap
TOl eK TOV JUT/ OTTOS CIS TO 0V lOVTL OT(j>OVV

ttlTta

TTCLCTa

fCTTL

o)crr6 Kai at VTTO 7rd(ratj rat's Ttyyais Ipyacrtat C

eto-t Kat ot TOVTOOV br)fj,iovpyol TravTfs Trotrjrat.
'AXrjOfj Aeyets.
'AAA.' o/^cos, ^ 5' T)', oto-^' on ov KaAowrat Trotrjrat dXAa
-^ovo-iv ovo^ara, cnro 8e iracrrjs T^S TrotTycrecos fv 5
a(f)Opi(r6V TO Trept r^v ^ov<TLKt]v Kat ra /u,erpa rw
roC oAou ovonaTi Trpocrayopeverat.
Trotrjcris yap roSro
IJLOVOV KaAerrat, Kat ot e'xoires roCro ro popiov TTJS TrotT^o-ecos
Troirjrat.
'AA?7^ Aeyet?, e^rjy.
10
Oi)Vco roivvv Kat irept roy epcora. TO /xey Ke^)aAatw eart d
Tracra ^ T&iy dya^w^ zTiidv^ia Kat rou eiioaifj-ovflv
6 /xeyio-ro's Te Kat SoAepos e p w s TTCLVTL' dAA' ot ju,ey
O.VTOV, rj Kara \pf]^aTi<r^ov r]
rj Kara fyiXovofyLav , ovTt kpav KaXovvTai 5
owe ZpacrTai, ot 8e KaTa eV rt eZ8os t'oVres re Kat eo-7rou8aKores TO rou oAou ovo^a la-^ovaiv, epcora re Kat e/aay Kat
epao-rat.
Kt^8vz^ei/ets aXrjOfj, efyrjv eya>, Ae'yety.
Kat Aeyerat /xer ye TIS, e'(/)Tj, Aoyos, w? ot o:z> ro rjuKrv 10
eaurwy (^TWO-IZ;, oSrot epSxriv 6 8' ep,os Ao'yos ovre ^/xto-eos e
fprj(TLv elvai TOV eptoTa ovre oAou, lay p-^ rvyx^arry ye TTOU,
w eratpe, ayaObv ov, ewet O.VT&V ye Kat iro^as Kat \"ipas
ot avOpaiiroL, eai^ avror? SOKTJ ra
b p TOI Vind. 21 : rt B T W : TO> Oxy. (in marg. )
04 TJ 5 77
Oxy. : ^5j BT W
ou BT Oxy. : om. W
05 exotxrty T W Oxy. :
e|ou<nj/ B
C 6 popiov B T Oxy. et <yp. W : /j.6voi> W
d. 3 So\fpbs
BTW Oxy.: irpooTos ci. Schanz
d 7 !o'xoi'O''' B T W : fff-^ov
Oxy.
d 10 favTW B T Oxy, : OVTWV W
63 eVei T W Oxy. :
ME

IIAAT12NOS
5 eavT&v irovrjpa elvai. ov yap TO kavruv OI/IACH eKacrrot,
dtnrd^oyrai, d pj et ri? ro /u,ev ayaQov OLKCLOV KaAe? Kal
kavrov, TO 8e KO.KOV dAAorpiozr &s ovoev ye aAAo early oS
206 epSxnv avOptoTTOi ?/ TOV ayaQov. r) crol SoKOikrty;
Ma Ai' OVK l/ioiye, ^y 8' eyw.
?
Ajo' ovy, ^ ' ^f, ovrcos aTrAow eori Aeyety ort 01
av6panroi TayaOov fpGxriv;
5
Nat, !</>r]z;.
Tt 6e; ov Ttpoa-OzTeov, <pr], ort Kat eTvat TO ayaQov
avrots
'Ap' ovv, f<pr], KOL ov p,6vov et^at, aAAa KOL aet
Kal ro{Sro TTpotrdfTeov.
"Eortz; apa crv\Xrjj3or]v, (prj, 6 epco? row TO dya^
ctvaL det.
'AAr/^earara, e^brjy eyoo, Aeyets.
b
"Ore S^ roCro 6 epcos ecrriy dei, 77 8' 77, rwy rwa
8uo/coz>rcoi> awo *cal ey TI^I irpa^ei ?} CTTTOU^J/ Kal
epws af KaAotro; TI roCro ruy^a/^et ^y ro epyoy;

10

Ov fj.VTciv (re, e^rjv ey<w, S Aiort/ua, kQav^a^ov eirt

<ro<p[q Kal <J)OLT(V Ttapa tre avra raCra ^a^rjcro/xeyo?.
'AAAa eyw crot, 10?], epw. eari yap rouro TO'KOS ey
KaAw Kal Kara ro o-ai/ua Kal Kara rrjy ^V\TIV.
Mavrtias, r]y 8' lyco, Setrat 5rt irore Aeyets, Kal ov
10 [j.av6dvu>.
C
'AAA' eyai, 77 8' r/, o-a^>e(rrepoy epai.
jcuoScrti; yap, e^rj,
a> ScoKpares1, Trd^res avOpwnoi Kal Kara TO craijua Kal Kara
e 6 Ka\6? W : KaA.f} B T
a i avBpwiroi Bekker :foBpairoiB T :
of &v0pwirot W
a 3 ^ S' f{ Bekker : ?jS?j BTW
a 4 rd/yo^ou
T W : TOV ayaOov B
a 9 oSr B T Oxy. : om. W
a n TOV rJ>
W : TOV rb* T : TOVTO B
awri^ T W Oxy. : ain-2> B
Tb i S?;] Se
2
Oxy.
TJ S 17 Oxy.: ^8i) BTW
rwv TW Oxy.: rbv BW
b 2 curb B W Oxy. : avTbv T
^ tnrouSfi B T W
crvvracris B
Oxy. :ffuo-rao-jsTW
e i ^ 8' 7} Bekker: ^Srj B T W ; 8?; Oxy.
02 KOI prius TW Oxy.; om, B
..'.->*'

STMHOSION

2060

K.CLI tire&av v TLVI ^Ai/a'a yev&vrai,

77 (fyvcris.
TLKTCIV 5e v p;ei> alcr^pSt ov
tv 8e T KaAfi.
f) yap av$pb$ Kal ywatKos 5
awowia TOKOS fcrriv.
eon 8e TOVTO Qciov TO
Kal

TOUTO kv OWYJTU) OVTi TO) ^(t<0 a^ayttTOV V(TTLV,

7]

Kal T] yvvr]<n$. TO, 8e ev TW a^ap/ioo-Tw aSwaToy yei^eo-^at. avapfAOcrTov 5' ecrrt TO ato-xpoi; irayTt TW 0euo, TO d
Se Kakbv appOTTOv.
Mo?pa ovy Ka6 EtAet^rta 77 KaAAw'T]
ecrTi T^ yeyeVet. Sia ravra orav i^kv KaAw -7jy)oo-7reAaTj
TO Ki;oCi', lAewy Te -yiyverai Kat e{/(/>pat^ojuevoz; Sta^eTTat
Kal TiKTet TC Kat yeyva' oVay 6e at(rxpw, a-Kv9pu>Tr6v Te 5
Kat XvTTOVUfVov crucnreipaTat Kat diroTpeTreTat Kat ct
Kat ov ytvvq, aAAa to-^oy TO Ki/T/juta ^aAeTrws (/>epei.
TO) KuoSi'Tt Te Kat r)8rj (nrapy&vTi. TroAAr) r; 7rrotr](rts
irept TO KaXov 8ta TO /jteyaArjs wStyos a,7roA7;eiy TOI;
f(mv yap, a) SwKpaTes, e<pTj, ov TOU KaAoC 6 epcos, &>s
<rv oiet.
'AAAa Tt ju,?;^;
Tijs ytvvrjo-ftos Kat TO TOKOU kv TW KaAw.
5
8' eyco.
y ovv, I^>TJ. Tt 8r) ow TTJS yeyvrjo-eco?; OTI
aetye^es eo"Tt Kat aOdvarov ws 0yrjTw ?; yeWrjo-ts. d^aTnQv^lv pera ayaOov CK TW^ w/xo- 207
TO) dya0oi5 eauTw etrat det epcos tffriv.
avayK.OA.ov 8r) CK TOVTOV TOV Aoyou Kat TT/? d^avao-tas TOP
etvat.
Te o$V ira^Ta e8i8a(TKe' /xe, oTroVe irept TW^ epco- 5
c 3 TV B W Oxy. : om. T
c 5 rq> om. Oxy.
c 7 Hvetrriv B
Oxy. : effriJ/ T W
C 8 T^ B Oxy. : raOra T W
d i airaj'Ti Oxy.
flfiy TW: 0< Bt Oxy.
d6 oWTrejparai TW : |u[j/](T7ripaTO
Oxy. :ffuctnrei'peTOjB W2 (e s. v. )
iu/eiMeTai B W : avei\\^7rai T :
aveiAerrat t : oj/iAAerat Oxy.
d.8 jTroiTjcrts T W Oxy. : irof^irts B
ei airoA.ueiJ'TWOxy. : diro\aiiew' B
67 yereaewx Oxy.
e8 det7yey] net yei'eerts Oxy.

I1AAT&NO2
TLK&V \6yovs Troioiro, KOI TTOT jjpeTo Ti oiet, ft> S&>Kpares,
ainov ttvai TOVTOV TOV epcaros KCU rijs eiri^Ujtuas; ?) OVK
alcr0dvr) w? SetyoS? o*iart0erat TraWa ra Orjpia fTreibav yevvav CTfiOv^crrj, Kal ra 7rea Kat ra Ttr^va, VOCOVVTO. re
b Trarra *cai epcortKws1 6au0ejuez/a, TrpG>TOv /xez/ irept ro
j,iy^at aAX?7Aot?, eTretra Trept r?)i> rpoffrrjV TOV
Kal eroi/ua eo-riy VTrep TOVTCW KOC bLa^a^fcrdai, ra acrdeve(rrara rois icr^fporarots xat inrcpaTtodvficrKfi-v, KOL ama r<5
5 A.t)ua) irapaTfivofAeva wcrr' fK&va fKTpetyeiv, Kal aAAo Tray
TTOIOVVTO,.
rovy /xey yap avOpdtirovs, e<?7, ototr' ciy rt? CK
Aoyt(r/io{) ravra Troteiy ra 8e Orjpia ris airta oi)'rcos e/3a>C rtKwy ^lariOeo-Oai; exets ^eyety;
Kat eya> av eAeyov ort OVK dbefyv r) 8' e
oi!i' Setvos Trore yer^o-eo-^ai ra epcoriKa, eay rai;ra
5

'AAAa 8ta ravra rot, Atortjua, oTrep yv^S^ etTroz;,

(re ^'/ca), yrovs ort Si8a<rKaAcov 8eo/xat.
dAAa /xot A.eye
Kat TOVTCOV rrjv alrlav KCU r&v aAAcoy rwi' Trept ra epcortKa.
Et TOLVVV, tyrj, mo-revets Kivov ftvai (frvcrti, TOV epcora,
ov TToAAa/cts wjuoAoy^Ka/xev, /^i?) 0at;/xae. VTavOa yap
d roy avroi> eKetz/a) Aoyor ^ OvrjTT] <f>vcrLS ^ijrei Kara ro Su^aroy
aet re eu/at Kat d^avaros. Swarai 8e ravrrj p,6vov, rrj
ye^eo-et, on aet KaraAetTret erepo^ z>eoz> d^rt roS uaAaiou,
eiret Kat eV w If Kao~Tov TOIV <pu>v r}v KaAe?rat Kat etz/at
5 ro avro otov IK iraibapiov 6 avTos Aeyerai ecos ay TrpeyeVr^rar o^ro? jaeyrot ovSeVore ra avra e^coy ey
o/icos 6 avros KaAetrat, dAAa yeo? det ytyvo^evos, ra
6e duoAAvs, Kat Kara ras T/jt^as Kat (rdpKa Kat do-ra Kat
at)za Kat trvfj.iTav TO o-<o/>ia. Kat p) ort Kara ro o-<S/>ia,
dXAa Kat Kara r^y \jrvxyv ol rpoVot, ra ^r;, o'ai,
to3 Kal alterum BT Oxy. : om. W

aura] avria Oxy.

cs oS

f\tyov b : a.vfKejov B : &i/ t\eyov T W : eAe-yov Oxy.

C 9 &/j.o\oyi]ffa^tv Oxy.
d 2 re T Oxy. : Ti B W
K2 T W Oxy. : om. B
d 3 TTJ yevearei B T W Oxy. : seel. Vermehren
e 2 Tp6irot T W
Oxy. : ToVot B

STMHOSION
p,iai, T]bovaC, Xvirai, (pofiot,

TOVTOM

2076
exacrra ovbeiroTe

TO.

avra Ttapecmv eKaorw, dAAd ra fj.ev yiyvtrai, ra Se aTroAAurat.

TTO\.V 8e TOVTCOV dro7rc>repoi> en, on Kat at eTriorr/juai 5

JUT) on at p,ez> yiyvovrai, at 8e aTro'AAwrat TJIMV, Kat o^8eTrore ot cairot to-fjiev

208

ovbe Kara ra? e7rior?7juas', dAAa Kat

T>V eTrtcrrTy/xwi' rambv Tracr^et.

eort

r^s

6 yap KaAelrai

eTrtoTTy^Tjs1

A?7^r;

yap

Se TrdAtv Ka,Lvr]v f^iroiovcra avrl 5

cofet r?)y
etyat.

tTiUTTr\\M}v,

cocrre T7)f

roww yap rw rpo-Trw Tray ro 6vt\rov

t, ov rw 7raz>ra/7ra<r> ro atro det e^rat axnrep TO

Oflov,

dAXa rw ro

OLTHLOV

Kat TTakaLov/jievov

eyKaraAetTrety oroi> avro 771^.

ravrrj

erepov z>eoz> b

rr\ jurj^a^r;, w 2w-

Kpares, e^irj, QvrftQV adavacrias /xere'x^t, Kat crw/xa Kat raAAa

TrdVra- d^dyaroy 8e aAAry.
a7TO/3AdoTT?ju,a <pvcrei TTO.V TLJJLO,-

/XT) ow Oav^a^t- et ro a^ro?3

adavatrias yap yapiv Travrl 5

77 o"TTOi)8T) Kat 6 e/aco? ezrerat.

Kat eyw aKova-aj rw Aoyoy tOav^aaa re

Kat erTroy

;y 8' eya>, S (ro^xwrdrr; Atort/xa, raCra ws aXri6G>s

Kat

77, axrirep

ot reA.eot (T0(pt<rrat,

ES tcr^t, e^T/, &j C

eTret ye Kat rcoy avOpunrutv et e0eAet? ets rT)y

/3Ae\^at, 0ai;p;abiS' ay rr^s dAoytas irept a ey&>
ei /uir) eyi/oets, tv6viJ,r)9el$ cos 8etycos 8taKetyrat epcort
roO dz^o/xao-rot yeyeo-^at Kat K A e o s es roy det \povov 5
d0ai>aroi>

K a r a ^ e V ^ a t , Kat v-jrep rowrou Kivbvvovs re

erotjuot

et<ri Travras en

Kat ^p^ara

p:aAAoy r} vTrep rwy

ava.XicrK.eiv Kat TTWOUS Trovftv

Tivaa-ovv Kat virepaTroOvycrKfiv.

over- d

firel o?et o-v, I0T7, "AAKTjcrrtv

65 en B Oxy. : f'o-Tii/ T W
a 6 /iHj/nji'] p.vnttfl Oxy.
a 7 ft/ijroy] OVIJTOV B
a 8 oi> r^l OI/TW B
b 3 u-frexei Oxy. : ^erexfiv
B TW
b 4 aBdvarov B T W Oxy. : dSu^aToi' Creuzer
c i ^77
om. W
c 2 ye T W : om. B Oxy.
05 ds B : ets T W Oxy.
C 7 iraj/res W
ua\\ot> B W Oxy. : om. T

ao8d

5
209

'AouTjrou aiToOavfiv av, TJ 'A^tAXea IlarpoKAa) fir, rj Trpoa.7ro6aviv TOV r>juerepoy KoSpoy VTtep rrjs
/3a<riAetas r<3i> TratScoy, /XT) olopevovs a6dvarov fWtyfiTjy
dperr}? Trept eavrwy eVeo-0ai, rjv vvv ?jues f)(ojix,ez>; TtoXXov
ye bfl, e^r/, dAA' ot/xai VTrep aperrjs aOavarov KOI
Sogtjs evKXeoCs Travrcs1 Tra^ra TrotoScriy, oo~<> a^
Sxri, roo-ovra) /xaAAoy roS yap d^ayarou fpSxriv.
s, ffyt], Kara ra crw/jxara oyres irpos ras
rpeTTOvrat /cat ra^r?] epcortKot eto-ti;, 6ia
adavacrCav Kal fjivri^v KOL evbauwviav, w? otoyrat, amols
ets roy liretra -^povov Trdvra Ttopi^o^voi' ol 8e Kara rrjz;
v^i'X.^'io"i yap ovv, e^>rj, ot ev rai? \lnj^ais Kvovcnv en
tv roi? <rco/j,aa-ii;, a ^vxf) Trpoa-jiKet Kal Ki;^<rai
ri ovy Tipoo-TyKet; <f)povri<riv re Kat rrjy aXXrjv
dperrji'(Sy 817 etcrt Kat ot Trotrjral Tra^res yeyy?]ropes Kat
r5>v Srj^xtoTjpywy ocrot Aeyoyrat evpertKoi elrat1 7roA.v 8e
e^)?], Kat KaAAtcrrrj r?js ^po^crecos ^ Trept ra rwy
re Kat otKijtrecoy 8taKO(r/j,rjo'ts, 17 8r) 6i>o/>ia eo"rt
cr(o(ppocrvvr] re Kat 5iKato(rwr]rovrcay 8' a3 oray rts IK
reou eyKu/xcoy 17 rrjy ^u^rjy, fjOeos coy Kat TyKovcrrjs r^s
^AtKtay, rurety re Kat yei^yay ^7] indv^fj,
^rjrei 8rj
ot/xat Kat oSro? Trepttcby ro KaAoy ey a> ay yer^cretey ey
rw yap ato-^pfi ov8e7rore yeyvrjcret. ra re ow <rwuara ra
KaA.a /xaAAoz; TJ ra atcr^pa d(nraerai are KDW^, Kat ar
vru')(r] ^Ifv^rl KaXf) Kat yzwaiq Kat eiKpue?, irdyu TJ d(T7raerai ro (rvvapfyoTspov,
Kat ?rpos rowroy rov
evdvs evTropet Aoycoy Trept apfrijs Kal Trept oloy ^prj
roy aySpa roy ayadbv Kat a e7rm]8eveiy, Kat e7rt)(etpet
,03 &t/. . . 04 irpoairoQa.ve'iv om. W
d6 wepl B T W
62 TO
Oxy. : om. BTW
as :ai] rfale ai Oxy.
as reKf?^ Oxy.:
Kueti/ B T W
a 6 ra Sommer : rets B T W Oxy.
a 7 8ia/c({ff/trjo-is BTW Oxy.: Sicucoa-^creis al.
a8 S' aS TW: aS B Oxy.
b i ^eos Parmentier: 06?os BTW Oxy.
ba 4in6vnr) Oxy :
e'0JjU6T BTW
S^jSeW
bs irepl Sy (i. e. Trepjiy) B
b 5 are
. . . 1b6 owriraCfTai om. W
b8 irepl alterum seel. Stephanus

209 c
cnrro^evo's yap oi/xat rov KaAou /cat 6/iuA<3y
avr>, a iraAat eKvet rucret Kat yevvq, Kal Traputv KOL a
^e/xy^eyos, mi ro yevvrjOev <n;yeKrpecpet Koivrf /uer'
<2<rre TroAv /^etft> Kotycoytay Tr)s rS>v muScoy Trpos aAA^Aous
ot TOLOVTOL luyjovcri /cat c/uAiay /3e/3atorepay, are KaXXiovoov
/cat a^ararcorepcoy TratScoz; Ke/cotvwi'rjKores.
Kat Tras ay
8eatro lairrw rotovroi;? TrarSas juaAAoi* yeyo^eVat ?) rovs
avdpcmrivovs, Kal els "O^rjpov aTro^Aei^as Kat cH(rio8o^ /cat
aAAouy Trotrjras ro^s dya&ws ^rjAaii', ota e/cyoya eavrcoy
, a e/cetz/oty adavarov KAeos /cat juz>i?ju?]z> Trapavra roiavra oyra- et 8e /SovAet, e^r/, OIODS Au/co{5pyos
/careAtTrero ey AaKeSat/xoyt au>Trjpas Trjs Aa/<e8atfjiovos Kat w? eVo? ei7reu> r^j 'EAAaSos. rtjuto? 8e Trap'
/cat 2o'Aa>y 8ta TT/Z> rcSv v6fji(av y^vvrjaiv, Kat aAXot
7roAAa)(o{5 avbpes, Kat ez> f/ EAAr^o-t Kat ez/ (3apj3dpois,
a Kat KaAa aTTO(pr]vap.fvoi tpya, /fvvrjcravTfs
Travroiav
riv $>v /cat tepa TroAAa r/8rj yeyore 8ta rovs Totot/rous
s, 6ta 8e roi/s avOputirivovs ovbevos TTCO.
Taura /xey ovy ra epcortKa itrcos, d) StoKpares, Kay o~i/
ra 8e reAea Kat eTTOTrriKa, cor e'feKa Kat raCra
f(mv, edv rts 6p6G>s p-ertry, O^K otB' et oto? T'
epco juey ot/y, Icpr;, eya) Kat Trpodv/jiias ovbev
TrapG> be e-Trecrtfat, ay oto? re 77?. 8et yap, ecpT], roy opO&s
to'yra eTTt rouro ro 7rpay//,a apyjecrQai /w,ey Wov o^ra teyat
eTrt ra KaAa o-0/xara, Kat Trpcoroy /^ey, lay dp6G>s fiyiJTai

d.

5
210

o f)yoviJ,evos, evbs avrbv crcojutaros epay Kat evravOa yeyyay

Ao'yoDS KaAovy, eTretra 8e avTov KaravofjcraL ort ro KaAAos
ro e7r orwovy crwju,art rw e7rt Irepw (ra)p;art abe\(pov ecrrt, b
Kat et 8et tWKety ro eV et8et KaAo'y, TroAA?) ayota /AT) oix
C 3 Trapiy ical oirtwc B W Oxy. : ainW KaJ Trapeby T
C 6 Ka\\i6vcav
T W Oxy. : /caAAiW 3>j/ B
d 5 KaTfAiVeTo b Oxy. : Kare\nrev . . .

ri B : Kare\eiirTo T W
d 7 i/jU(i/ T W : ^luc B Oxy.
o croXcav
Oxy.
e i / prius om. Oxy.
e 2 /caAo] aAAa Oxy.
ep-ya /cat
Oxy.
a 4 Se] 5e /cai (ru Oxy.
a 7 ouriy T W Oxy. : avrwv B
b i Tb B Oxy. : T^5 T W
eVl erepy B W Oxy. : trepy T

aiob

FIAATllNOS
v re /cat TOVTOV qyeicrOai TO em Ttaviv TOIS crw/xao-t
TOVTO 8' fvvor\<ravTa, na/racrTrflxii iravT&v rutv KaA<3y <ra)/xdr(oy

5 epacrTijy, iyos 6e TO o-fyobpa TO>TO xa^

crarra /cal cr^iKpov 77777 o-a/uei>oy /uera Se raCra TO ei>
\jfvx<us

KaAAoy npuwTepoz; r]yr\(racrQai rov ev TW trcojaart,

a)(TTe Kat eay eTTietK^s a>y T^y \^ux^ TIS /cay (TjjLiKpov avOos
^TO) Kal epav /cat KTySecrflai /cal TiKTeiv Aoyous
KOI

(J)T&V,

olVtyes

TTot^o-ouo-t

/3eA.Tious

, iia avayKacrdr) av Ofacracrdai TO tv rols e-r

TO?? vop.ois naXbv /cai TOWT' iSeir OTI Tray
ecrTty, iW TO Trept TO (rw/^ta /caAoy crp.iKpdy TI
f)yri<rr]Tai etyat* /xera 8e Ta eTTtTTjSe^aTa eirt Ta? eTrio-T^ay
dyayety, ?ya i8rj aS e7rio-Ti]/x3i; xaAXos1, Kai jBXeTrwv

irpbs

d TToAi) r;8?j TO KaAoy ju?]/ceTi T^ Trap' evi, axnrep

ayair&v 7rai8apiou KaAAos r) avdp&Trov TLVOS T] eT
[AdTos tvos, $ov\ev(av (fravXos
TO TroAv TreAayos TfTpa^^vos

r\ Kai a^LKpoXoyos, dAA' e

TOV naXov /cat 0up&v

5 Aois /cal /caAous Aoyous Kai /xeyaAoTrpeTrer? TI/CTTJ /cai

$iAoo-o<|>ia a(f)06va>, ecos ay fVTavd
KttTiSr/ Tiya eTTKTT^rjy jutiay TOLaijTrjv, rj eo-Tt /caAoC
6 TotoSSe.

TretpcS 8e JACK, ^</>^, roy yow Ttpocrty^iv

co? oto'y

Te jUciAtora.
6s yap ay ^\p<- fVTavda irpbs TO, e
TratSaycoyTj^Tj, ^ew/xeros lepers Te Kat dpflcos TO. KaAa,
TeAos ^8rj toay Twy eparriKwy e^atyvqs KaTo^eTat TI 6av5 jucurrov Trjy (frvcriv

KaXov, TOVTO e/ceiyo, S Sw/cpaTes, ov 8r)

eWxev Kat 01 e^TTpocrOev irayTes Trdyot ^<ray, TrpfiToy jney

211 del ov /cai oi/Te yiyvo^vov ovTf airoXkv^vov, OVTZ avav6Htvov owe (frQivov, lireiTa ov TTJ p,ey KaAoy, TI] 8'
oiibe TOTC [iev, TOTS 8e ov, ovoe irpos /^.ei' TO KaAoV,
b 4 TOVTO B W Oxy. : Tot5r<jj T
b 8 K&J/ Hermann : Kai ehv B T
Oxy. : al &p W
02 /cal seel. Badham
o'lrivts BT Oxy. : elf
m/es W
07 ft/a IfSr; T W : 'lv otSrjt B : iva. i8rj Oxy.
d I rbl
ry Schleiermacher
d 5 T'IKTITJ corr. Coisl. : TI'KTCI B T W
d.6 peoflels W
as Tore Se] r^Se'Se Oxy.

2TMITO2ION

ana

8e ro aloypov, ovb' fvOa jaey KaXov, ilvOa 8 alcr^pov, &s

ricrl juer c>v KaXov, uo-i 8e al(ryjp6v* ov8' av <$>a.VTacr6ri<reTai 5
avr<5 ro KaXov otov Trpoo-cmrov rt ov8e X6''/969 ov8e aAAo
Stv o-<3ju,a ju,ere'xet> ovSe rts Aoyo? ov8e rts emo-Tr/jari,
TTOI; ov ey Irepw riz^i, oroy er ^iww rj v yfj rj ev ovpavti
rj V rw aAAa>, dAA' avrb Kad* avrb f/,e^' avrou /uoyoet8es aet b
oy, ra 6e aAAa Trayra KaAa fKeivov [JifT^ovra rpoirov TLVO,
TOLOVTOV, otov yiyvofjizvav re rS>v a\Xa>v KCU c
bev. orav 877 TLS O-TTO rco^8e 8ta ro 6p6)s TTai- 5
bepa<rTiv Travi(i)V (Kelvo ro K.a\bv apyjirai KaOopav, oyebbv
av TL CLTTTOITO Tov reAov?. roirro yap br/ lo-rt ro 6pdG>s ITTI
ra epcortKa lez'at r) VTT' aAAov ayeo~0at, ap\6fjivov aiio C
raiySe rwy KaAwy kuzivov eyeKa roii KaAoi) del
wcnrep eTrayajSacrjuoi? \p<a[Jifvov, O.TTO tvbs cirl 8
8voti> e^i Trarra ra KaAa crw/xara, Kat OTTO
em ra KaAa eTTtrrjSev/xaraj /cat aTro rwy e7rir7j8ef- 5
eTri ra xaAa ^aQru^ara, /cat di70 rw^ [j.a6r]^dT(av eTr'
e/ceujo ro /xa^rj/Aa reAeur^(rat, o ecmv OVK aAAou TJ avroS
CKtivov TOV KaXov /xd^Tj/ua, Kat yy<S aiiro reAeurwy o eo-rt
KaAoV. fVTavda TOV fliov, u> (piXe SwKparey, e^ry 17 May--d
TiviKT] evr], e'hrep TTOV aAAo^t, /3icoroz> avOp&irti), ^eco/xeyq)
avro ro naXov.
o fdv Trore 1877?, o?j Kara -^pvcriov re Kal
etrdrJTa Kal TOVS KaXovs TraiSas re Kat veaviffKovs 8ofet O-QI
eii>ai, oi)s yi5v 6/)5v eKTreTrAr^^at Kat e'rotjuos el Kai crv Kal 5
aAAoi TroAAot, opwrres ra 7rat8tKa Kat crvz/oz;res' det CLVTOLS,
et TTCOJ otoy r' T]I>, /jir^r' eo-^tety ja?jre triveiv, aAAa 0eao-0at
povov Kat crvvzlvai. rt 8^ra, e^rj, oto/xe^a, et ra> yevotro
avro ro KaXov t8etz> etAtxptve's, KaOapov, a/xetKroy, aAAa 6
a 4 ei/0aSe Se Oxy.
cos ... a 5 <d<rxpbv seel. Voegelin
a6
oiirJ* W
a 8 iroul ir&> W to 2 rpSirov nva B Oxy. : TIW rpoTrov
TW
b4 e'/cer^B Oxy. : e'/cetVy T W
b 5 S^ B : Se STJ T W
C 3 eTravapcurfjiois T Oxy. : eiravajSaftytoTs B W
C 7 TeAeurrjo-ai
Usener : TeAevHjerp BT W (?? in ras. W)
d i /xotj/ri/c); W (K^ in
ras.)
ds Trore t8??s W Oxy. : 7roT(e) e/Sjjs BT
xpvffov
d 7 6faa-6ai T W : 06a(rao-eat B Oxy.

ane

212

nAATHNOS
JU.TJ avcnrXecav crapK&v re av0po)7rivu>v /cat xpoojuarcoy Kat
aAArj? TroAA^s (pXvapias dv^rfjs, dAA' avro TO delov KaXbv
Swairo /xoyoeiSes KartSeti>; ap' otet, e^, tyavXov fiiov
ytyyeo"0ai eKeure /SAeVoyros avdpu>Trov Kat eKeu>o CD o"ei
fleco/xeVov Ka (ruyoyro? avr&; rj OVK ^vdv^fj, e<^r/, ort evravOa
CIVT> [j.ova\ov yez^rjcrerat, 6pG>VTL & oparov TO KaXov, TLKTCIV
OVK et8coAa apcTrjs, are ov/c eiSwAoi; e^a'Trroju.erfe), dAAa
fj, are row dArj^oi;? e^aTrro/xevw reKoyri 8e
ai Opf\jrap.V(f VTrap^i, ^eo^tAet ytvtcr&ai, KCU
r&) aAAa) avdptaTiutv d^amrw Kat e/ceiyw;
Taura 77, a> 4>ai8pe re Kat ot aAAot, e<pTj /jtev Atort/xa,
7re7ret(r/>iai 8' eyoir Treireifrjueyo? 8e iretpw/^ai Kat row aAAous
TTL0iv ort rovrou roS fcr-^/xaros r?) av6punre(a (frvcrei crvvfpybv d/xet^co "Epcoros OVK ay rts pqoicos Aa/3ot. 8to 8?;
eywye qf)i7jmt \privai TrdvTa avbpa TOV "Epcora Tipav, KOL
ambs rt//w ra epcortKa Kat 8ia(epozmos dcrKO), Kat rors
aAAots 7rapaKeAevo/x.at, Kal yuy re Kat det eyca>//td{a) r^y
ovvajjuv Kal avbpfiav ro{5"Ejoa)ros Ka6' ocrov otos r' etju.6. rouroy ow ror Aoyoi', a> ^atSpe, ei /ney jSovAet, a>s ey/cwyMtoy et?
v
Ep<wra vofucrov elprjcrOcu, et 6e, ort Kat
rovro
'
8e raCra rou ScoKparovs rous juev cTiaiveiv, TOV
8e ' Apio-T0(pavr] Aeyety rt iri)(ipelv, ort e^vr/a-Orj amov
Aeycov 6 ScoKparrjs 7rep ro{5 Aoyov Kat e^at^yrjs rrjy auAetoy
Otipav Kpovojjifvrjv TtoXvv tyotyov Trapao-y^fiv w? Kcojuacrrwy, Kat
aitXrjTpioos (pcavrjv aKOveiv. TOV ovv 'Aya0a>z>a,
oi> crK\ls<rO; Kat eay /^,ey rts rair eTTtrrjSet
et 8e ja?7, Aeyere on ot TrCvo^v dAA' avcvnavo^eOa T]or].
e 4 (77 B W Oxy. : om. T
a i < 5e?] & Se? B : d>8i B : ^ 8e?
TW
a 6 eeo<t>i\f~t rec. t Oxy. : 0eo<iAjj BT W
b i 5 om. Oxy.
05 7r<Xf'P' teyew TI Oxy.
c6 av\ewi> rec. t Oxy. : aij\iot>
B T W^ ,
c 7 Kpovofj,evr]v B \V Oxy. : KpoTov/j.evijv T
da aAAa
0a] Oxy.

STMHOSION

2i2d

Kat ov TroAv vcrrepov 'AAKi/3tdSou rr)y (pcavriv aKovew kv

rr\ avXfj <r(pdbpa j^edvovros KCU joteya j3oS>vros, fpatr&VTOs
OTTOV 'AydQcov Kat KeAewyros ayeiv Trap' 'Aydflcom. ayeti> 5
ovv avrbv Trapa oxjbas Tr\v re avArjrptSa inroXafiovcrav KCU
aXXovs rivas T&V d/coA.ov06oi>, Kat eirta-Trjvai firl ras Ovpas
f(TT(f)aV(a^VOV

aVTOV

KiTTOV

T6

TIVL

(TTf(f)dvU>

^afffl

KCU 6

ia>v, Kat Taivias e^oyra TTI rfjs K(f)aXrjs ndvv iroXXds, KCU
Avbpes, x.ai/)ere' ^fOvovra avbpa irdvv (rtyoftpa
r) aTncojueu dva^rjcravrfs (JLOVOV 'AydOa>va,
lya) yap rot, (pdvai, \0fs p.ev ov\ 5
oto's r' Zyevofjiriv d</)tKeV^at, vvv 8e ^'KO) e?rt r?j
f^/MV ras rati>tas, t^a diro r^y eju?;? KffyaXfjs TJ]V TOV
rarov Kat KaAA.tcrrou Kf)aXr)i> lay etirco oircoo-t
apa KarayeA.d(recr0e {j,ov a>9 fj.0vovTos; eyw Se, K
yeAare, O/ACOS eS ol6' ort aXrjOfj Aeyto. aAAa fiot Aeyere 213
avroOev, tirl pryrots et<rta) ^ JU.TJ; oruju/TTtea^e ?) 01;;
ITayraj ovy dvaOopv^rja-at Kat KeXevtiv etcrteyat Kac
KaraKA.u>e<r#ai, Kat roy 'Ayd^cora KaAe^ avrov. Kat rw
lerat ayo^evov VTTO T&V av6p(&Tru>v, Kat TrepLmpovfJievov ajua 5
ras ratrias cos di>a8?7owra, fTTLTrpoaOe T>V otyOaXn&v e^ovra
ov KartSety roy "ScoKparr], dXXa Ka6if(r8ai Trapa roy 'Ayd0ft)^a ez> /^,e(r() 2coKparous re Ka^ ZKC
yap roy ScoKpdrr; ws eKeryoy KartSety.
8e O.VTOV a<nta^f(rOai re roy 'Ayd&oya
Et^ery oSy roy 'Ayd^wya 'TTroAvere, TratSes, 'AAKt/3i8rjy3
tya eK r/otrajy KaraKerjrat.
ndyu ye, etTrety roy 'AAKi^3td8rjy dAAa rts ^?y o8e
rpiros crujHTrorrys; Kat ay^a /Aera<Trpe^)oyixeyoy avrbv opav
e 2 Taivias T W Oxy. : revlas B (et mox)
e 4 St'leo-ee B Oxy. ;
S^ao-fle T W
$Vep B Oxy. : fortp T W
^A(9o/*6y T W Oxy. :
tej
Jfa0A ' B
e,v0es Oxy.
e 6 ofo's T' T W Oxy. : o'ts T' B
e 8 eoi/
i'ir&) ouTWffJ B T Oxy. : eav tlira ovrcacrl Ke^aA'^y W^ : ayeiTrwi/ of>T(ii(rl
Winckelmann
as Ke\eveiV T W Oxy. : Kftevei B
bs /cortSef?*']
Oxy.: Ka6ieiv B T W
b 6 o'Se Tpfros W Oxy.: $8e Tpiros B :
TP/TOS gSe T
b 7 6pav T W Oxy. : 6p$ B

213 b

ITAATflNOS

roy SojKparrj, Ibovra be avcnrribfjcrai Kal elirelv '-Q '

rourt rt r\v; ScoKpdrrjs ovros; eAXo^wz; aii f/,e eyraOfla KareC Ketcro, ooa-Trep etcoflets l^aupznjs ava^aivetrOaL OTroveya) UJUTJZ;
ere eVecr&u.
Kal rSi' rt r/Keu; Kai rt av evra{i0a
pa 'A/n<rro(pdz/ei ov8e e? rts aAAos
ecrrt T Kat /3ovXerai, dAAa Ste/i^^ay^o-co OTTCOS irapa
5 TW KaXAiVro) rSy li^Soz; KaraKeio-rj.
Kai TOV 2coKparrj, 'Aya^cor, (frdvai, opa et /zoi eTra^wets1
6 TOVTOV epcos TOU avOp&Trov ov (pavkov irpay/^a
air' kneivov yap rov -^povov, a(f>* oS rovrou
ripd(T0r]V, oiiKtTt e^eorty jixoi oi/re Ttpoa'jBXf^fai
ovre buakvl, r) ovrocrl fi]Aort;7r&)y /xe /cai (f>6ovS>v
at AotSopetrat re Kat ra> xeVe MVts
opa oSy /arj ri Kal z^Cy epydcrrjrat, aAAa 6taAmxetpT] /3ta{eor0at, eTra/xwe, ws eya>
r^y ro-yrou paviav re Kat (j!>tAepacrrtai; Traz^v 6ppw8<S.
'AAA' OIJK ecrrt, <pdv<u rov 'AAKt/3td8rjy, l/xot Kat crot 8iaAAayij.
dAAa TOVTOOV /xei' ets aS^is <re rt/uwp^a-o^af yw
e Se /mot, 'AyafltozJ, (fravai, ^erd8os rwy rawi&v, '(va dya8?jo-&)
Kat rr)y rovrou raurrjyt rrjz; Oav^aa-T^v Ke<^a\rjV, Kat fx?] ju-ot
/ieju(/>rjrat ort ere /uey dyeSTjcra, avrbv 8e VIK&VTCL kv Adyots
Tra^ras dy^pcoTrous, ov JJLOVOV TTputr/v uxrirep <rv, dAA' det,
5 cTretra OVK dyeT)cra.
Kat d/u,' avrbv Xaj3ovra rS>v
avafielv rbv ScoKpdrry Kat
'EireiS^ 8e KarfKXivr], etTreur
yap /jtot vrityziv.
OVK eTTtrpeTireoy ow v/u,ry, dAAa TTOTCOV
ft)//,oAoyrjrat yap raC0' ^/xry.
ap-^ovra ovv atpovp,at r?]?
ecos av vp.ds IKCIV&S Trtrjre, f^avTOv. dAAa (peperco,
b 9 Tourt TI ^j/ T W Oxy. : TOUT' eiirtlv B et ^p. W
e\\ox&v T W
Oxy. : 4v\oxiav B
03 ws BTW (deest Oxy.) : K! Hermann
oiiSe B Oxy. : ofrre TW
04 T[J] e/j.Trixo-vn<r<e Oxy.
c 7 6 B : ou
TW
d a ovTOffl B W (sed o> supra o) Oxy, : ovToal *** T (ouroer/ irws
Coisl.)
ds Bavfjiaa-Ta B Oxy.: 0aujn(;jaTW
ds fird/Awai B
e i di/aSVw f al T W Oxy. : avaSyffw/jieda, B
e 8 olv T W Oxy. :
om. B
e 10 post ^epe'rw distinxi

STMnOSION

2136

, ei rt IOTIZ; e
dAAa cpepe, TTCU, (pdvcu, TOV \l/VKTr)pa eKeu>oy, Ibovra OVTOV
irAecw rj OKTCO KorJAas x&>powra. rouroy Ipi/TrA^crd/jieyoy
p,ey avTov CKTTiflv, eVeira T Scoxparet KeA.eveii'
Kal a/xa ei77eu>' Opos fx-ev ScoKptir?;, w ay&pes, ro
//,oi ovbtv oirocrov yap av /ceAewTj ris, rocrovroz;
[jiaX\ov IMI Trore ^6v<r6rj.
Toy juey ovy SdOKpdrr) ey^eayros TOU iratSo? nlvf.iv TOV
8' 'Epu^tjua^oy Hois ovi>, <f>avai, a 'AA/ct/3ta8?7, TTOt-ov^ev ;
ovT<as ovre Tt Xiyoptv ITTI rrj KvXiKi ovre rt abofJLfv, aAA'
crirep ot bi\}sG>vT$ Trtojue^a;
y 'AAKi/3iaS7]ir etTreiy 'ii 'Epv^ax^> /SeArtore
irarpos Kat o-co^)poi;e(rr(irou, \alpe.
Kal -yap a~v, (^dvai TOV 'Epvfijuaxozr dAAa rt 7roiS/x,ey;
f/
Ort ay aa; K\evps8e? yap

214

IrjTpbs yap avrjp TroAAwy dyrd^tos

eTTirarre ovy ort fSovXfi.
"AKOVCTOV 877, eiTreiy rw 'Epu^tjuaxoy. ^/jiiy Trpty ere
eiVeA0eii> eSofe \privai ITTI 8eia S-KCUTTOV ev y^iepet Aoyoy 10
irepi "Epwros etirety a>s Svycuro KaAAioroy, Kat ly/cto/xtao-at. C
ot /u,ey ovy aAAot Trdyre? Typas dpj]K.a^v crv 8' eTret^T) OVK
Kal eKTreircoKas, SIKOIOS eT etTre^y, eiTrooy 8e eT
et ort &y ^SovAry, /cat rowror ro> eirt 8eia Kat
5
'AAAd, (pdvai, S 'Epv^t/u,axe, roy 'AAKt/3td8?jy, KaAws p-ey
Aeyet?, ^eOvovra 8e avbpa Trapa yry^oyrcoy Aoyous irapa/3aAAeiy p,r) OVK e^ tcrov 17. Kai dp;a, S paKapte, 7rei'0ei ri
ere ScoKpdrrys cSr aprt e?Trev; rj olcr6a ort TovvavTiov ecrrt d
iray ^ o eAeyey; ovros yap, edy rtz^a eyco eiratyecrco rovrou
e 1 1 ?KW<jUo T W Oxy . : ^iro.uo B
iroow W

Ke\evri B Oxy.

a 4 d-iroa-ov B T Oxy. :

: Kt\evcrri TW

T W : otfr' 7ro'5o/*ey B
b 6 &j/ T W : S' &y T
wrpbs B W '
c8 rf B T : re W
PLATO, VOL. II.

Tb I oirre TI aSofJ.ev

b7t
14

TTapovros 17 Ofbv r) &v0p(07rov aAAov ^ TOVTOV, OVK d$e'erat

fJ,OV

TO)

XfW'

OVK ewpTj/xijo'eis'; <pdrai rbv ^co/cparrj.

Ma TOV Hoo-eiSci), enreiz; TW 'AA/a/SiaSrjp, p^Sev Aeye
Trpos Tavra, <s ey<w ov5' ay era aAAoy eTraiyetrat/At (row

'AAA.' o^rco irotet, <f)avai. TOV 'Eput)aa>^ov, ei

10 ScoKparr] 7raiv(rov.
e
OS? Aeyeiy; eiirerz; TOI> 'AAKtjSta^
rw dz;5pi Kat
Owroy, Qavai TOV ScoKpartj, TI ey ya> ex^t?; eirt
5 yeAotorepci p* eiratyeo-at; ^ rt 7roi?jcreis;
TdArj^ epfi.
dAX' opa et irapirjs.
'AAAa nfVTot,, <])av(u, rd ye oXn]Qrj Trapir/jat Kal
Aeyetv.
Ov/c ay (f)OAvoini} eiTrety TW 'AAKt/3td8?jy.
Kai
10 ovraxrt irofy(rov.
fav rt //,TJ dArj^es Xeyoo, p.era^v ei
^y /3ovArj, Kat eiire ore rouro ^/fvbo^aL' Koi)V yap etvai ovbev
215 v^eucrop:ai.
eav p,eVroi dyap.ip.frjcrKo'p.ei'O? dAAo
Aeyco, p,rj8ey ^aup-dcrT/s' ov yap ri pa8tov r^ (rr)i> d
KCU efa^fjs

Ka.Tapi9fj.fj(rai,.

8' eya) e-n-aiyeiy, S avftpes, ovrws eT

5 8t' eiKoywy. ovros ju.ez> oSy icrcos otTjcrerat eirt ra yeAocorepa,
earat 8' ^ et/ccoy rou dAr/^ou? eyexa, ov rot) yeXoiov. <^}]p;t
yap 8r) 6p.otoraroy avrbv elvat, TOIS ortArj^oi? TOVTOIS rot?
b cy rois eppoyAtxpeiois KaOrj^voLS, ovcrTivas epyd^byrai ot
8rjju,ioupyot (rvptyyas T) avAous f\oVTas> ^ 8ix<i8e 8ioix^e^Tes
Hvbodev dydAp-ara H\OVTZS Oe&v. nal (f>rnj,l av
rw trarvpa) r<S Mapo-^a.
on fxey ovy ro' ye
e 2 Ti/uap^a'ofj.at

rcuvftffi

Bekker

e 5 firaiveffcti

a? o-jArji/otj BTW

scripsi : fireuvi iff is B T W :

(et supra j W)

STM1I02ION
o/uoios et TOT/JTOLS, 3) 2coKpares, ov8' auro? ay TTOD
djUKpta-yS^rTyfrats' &>s 8e /cat raAAa eot/cas, p,era rouro aKOue.
v/3ptoTT)s er 77 o#; eaz> yap JUT) o/AoAoyr/j, juaprupa? Trap^o/xat. dAA' ov/c avArjrjjs; TrcAt; ye tfaujiiacrtcorepos1 kneivov.
6 jJ-ev ye 81' opydvdiv e/cTyAet TOT)? avd pdimovs TTJ aTro roti
(rro/x.aros 8wa;uet, Kat ert z^uyt 6j az^ ra Kivov at'Ar) a yap
y
OAi;p/7ros rfv\L, Mapcrvov Ae'yco, rovrou Slaaz>T09 ra ov^
edvre dya^os a^Aryr^? atrAr? ea^re <pavkr] a-yAr^rpis,
-Troiei /cat Sr/Aot roiy raiy 0e<Sy re /ecu
Sia ro ^eia elyat. (rw 8' e/cetf ot> roaromov
Sia^epets, on areu opyavuiv tyiXols Aoyots ramov
TOVTO -TToiets. 77/xer? yoCy oray /x,ev rov aAAow aKoijcap-ev
Kat Trayi) dya^oi; p?jropo? aAAous Aoyous, ov8ef
e'Troy etTrer^ ovSert* 67ret8ay 8e (row rt? aKovrj T/ r<3z>
Aoycoy aAAou Aeyo^ros, /cay Trayu ^aSAoy 17 6 Aeywz/,
eaz^re yvr^ d/covr; edyre din/p earre /xetpaKtof, e/cTreTrA?;ecr/xey /cat Kar^o^Qa. eyco yoyy, S avfipes, ei /A?)

6.

TTtrrovOa avrbs inrb T&V TovTov Aoycoy Kat iracrxco ert /cat
zwt. oray yap d/covco, TroAv juot paXXov rj T&V Kopv(3av- e
rtwyrooy ^' re KapSta -mjSa /cat Sd/cpua eK^e^rat VTTO r<2y
Aoycoy rwy rowrou, opw 8e Kat aAAous Tra/x.Tro'AAous1 ra
atra Trdcr^ovras' ITepiKAeous 8e anovatv Kat aAAcoy ayaQ&v
prjTopo)v eS /xey ^yov/xr^y Aeyety, TOIOVTOV 8' ov8er e7racr)(oy, 5
8>s StaKeijixeyoi;, dAA' T/TTO rovrout rou MapoT^ot; TroAAa/cts 8r)
owrco Stere^ryy cotrre /xot Soat )ur/ ^Stcoror eTrat f\ovTi ws 2l6
exw. Kat Tavra, co 2co/cpare?, OVK epeZs ws OVK aXrjOrj.
/cat
ert ye y{!i> crwotS' e/iavrw ort et efle'Aot/zt Trape^ety ra Sra,
ov/c az> Kaprep?7crat//,t dAAa ravra av
b 5 Si/ TTOU Baiter : 5^ irou B T W
03 o5i/ B T : -y' oSy W
e I i/upi' B : j/Dc T W
63 T^J/ TOVTOV T W : TO-JTW B
a25
T W : om. B
a 3 fp.avrcf BT : ffj.avrbi> W (o in ras.)

ai6a

IT A AT JIN OS

5 ydp /tie 6p;oAoyey on TroAAou ey5eTjs o>z> auros en e|uatrro{5

fzey d/AeAw, ra 8' 'Aflrjyatcoy 7rpdrra>. /3ta ovy axnrep airo
ry Setprjycoy lmo-)(o'/xeyos ra Sra oi)(o//,ai (pevyooy, tya ^r)
avTOu KaO^evos Trapa rovrw Karayrjpdo-a). TriirovOa 8e
fo Trpos TOUTOZ^ \iovov avdptoTtutv, o oiK ay Tts olotro ey ejuol
ro aicr^vi;e(r0at oz'rii'oSz;' eya> 8e roSrov
<rvvoiba yap e/xaura) ayrtA.eyeti' jaey ov
ei iroiflv h OVTOS KeAevei, e7rei8ai> 8e
5 77TTTjju,eya) r?ys ri/x^s TT}S VTTO rwy TroAAxoy. SpaTrerevco
aiiTov Kal (frevyu), KOI orav tSco, atcr^vyofxai ra
C Kat TroAAaKts ju,ez; ^Secos ay iSot/xt avrov p) oira ei> a
ei 8' au ro{5ro ye'yotro, eu o$)a on iroAv fj,eiov &v a\6o[[j.r]v,
<2ore OIIK e^co on xP'f7<ra)/j!'at TOUTO) rai av6 panto.
Kai UTTO jmey 8^ rwy avArj/xarcoy Kal eyco Kat aAAoi TroAAot
5 roiaSra Ti^-n6vQd.(riv VTIO roCSe rou craTvpow aAAa 8e e/xov
ws o/xotos r' lorty ots eycb fjKaa-a avrbv Kal rrjv
d rouroy ytyywcrKei' aAAa eycb 8rjAco(ro, eTreiTrep ^
opare yap on ScoKpdrrjs epcortxws Sta/ceirai rwu KaXSiv
det rrepl TOT/TODS eort /cal eK-TreirA^Krai, Kat av dyyoet
5 cr(^o8pa ye.
ro'uro yap ovros e^co^ey 7rept/3e/3Ar]rat, &<
6 yfy\vfJL^evos (rtArjyos- tyboOtv 8e drot^ets TroV
yejtxei, S ai;8pes o-Vjuirorat, (ra)(^pocrvyr]s; tare ort ovre et n?
KaAos eort /ixeAet avrw ovbtv, aAAa Karatppoyet roorovroy
6 otroy 0118' ay eT? otrj^eirj, ovr' et rts TrAovo-to?, oi!r' et aAArjy
Ttya rtjurjy l^coy rwy VTTO TrArj^ous fxaKapt^bp,eywy ^yetrat
8e TraWa raura ra KTTj/xara ov8eyos aia Kat ^ju,a? ovSey
eZyatAeya> v/^ity-.eipa>yeuo/xeyos 8e Kat irat^ooy Trayra roy
5 |3toy Trpos TOVS avOp&Trovs SiareAet. (nrovbacravTos 8e av
a 5 en T W : rt B
to
4 OUTOS B T : aurbs W
03 -%(r{\<rufjiai corr. Ven. 185: xp^ojuot B T W
d 3 aS B : om. TW
d 6 yey\viJ.fJi.fVOs B T : fyyfy\v/j.iJ.evos W

STMIIOSION
KOI avoL)(9fVTOs OVK olba ei rts fatpanev ra euros dyaA/mara'
dAA.' eya> 77817 TTOT' et8or, Kai //ot I8oey ovrw 0eta Kai
etrai Kai TraymAa Kat dav^aa-rd, oo<rre Trotr/reou eti>ai
OTL KeAevoi 2a)/cparTjs. fjyovpfvos 8e avrov ecnrovkm. rrj e/x^ wpa epnaiov ^yrjfrci/xrjy eTyat Kat zmvyyua
v dav^acrrov, a>s \map\ov /xot ^apto-ajueya) 2(OKpdret TTCLVT'
omos ^8ef <ppovovv yap T) e?ri TT; wpa
6avy.a<Tiov ocrov. ravra ovv biavoriQeis, Ttpb TOV OVK
aveu a,Ko\ov6ov povos jmer' avroG ytyreo'^at, Tore
ror aKoAou^ov /JLOVOS a-vveyiyv6iM]v Set yap -rrpos v/xas Trayra
Ta\.r]dij etTrety dAAa Trpoae^ere roy roCj;, Kat a ^ev8op,at,
iyyojurjy yap, a> avbpes, /J-ovos
Kat W/X.TJZ; avrtKa 8iaAe'^eo"^ai avrov juot a?rep &y
ez; eprj/x,ta 8taAex^et7j, Kat \aipov. TOVTMV
8' ov />wAa eytyyero ovbev, dAA' &<nrep et(>0ei StaAex^ets "f
juot /cat (rvvrjfjiepevcras w^67"0 aTncav. p.era raura truyyu/wei^ea-^at iipovK.aXoi>iM]v avrov Kat (rvvfyv^va^p^v,
cos rt
errata Trepav&v. a-vv^yv^va^TO ovv fxot Kat 7rpo(re7raAatey
ovbevbs Ttapovros' /cat rt 8a Aeyeti'; ovSey yap
oi8aju7j raurr; fjvvrov, e8ofe //.ot
eti^at rw aySpt Kara ro Kaprepw Kat OVK avertov,
e7rei8?j7rep eyeKe)(etp7/K7], dAAa ta-re'oy r/8?7 rt ecrrt ro 7rpay/x,a.
7rpOKaAoi)/x,at 8r) avrbv Trpos ro (riwSeiTn'etz', dre^ais uxrirep
TratStKots ein/3oi>Aewa)i>.
Kai /xot oi/8e roCro ra^y
(j> TTeLcr6r]. eiretS^ 8e d(ptKero
ro Trp&Tov, 8et7ry?](ras cmiivai e/So^Aero. Kai rore fiei'
a aiirov av6is 8' e7rtj8oi)Aewas,
det Troppto r<3y VVKT&V, Kai
e 7 Ka/ /tot T W : al e'^ol B : /cayitol Hirschig
a2
Cobet: tv fipaxetBTW as Sfy B: ^ TW
ba
BT : a\770^ W
b 6 S' <w] Sij Oxy.
&/ B T W : 5 F. A. Wolf:
8^ Sauppe
C i /cai a-weyvfj.va6/u.i)v seel. Sauppe
d 4 eSeSftirv^KffJifv
scrips! : 'Sf5eiirvfiKei/ji.ei> Usener : SfSeiirvliKafji.ev Photius :
tieSewflKfi B T W
ael add. Photius: om. BTW Oxy.
eVe^]
eTrejSrj ye Oxy.

2i6e

217

OAATIiNOS
5 fflovXfro
amevai, o-Krj7rro/u,eyos 6Yi dxjre eir/,
avrbv fjievciv.
dz^eirauero ovy eu rrj \ofjfvr} ep,o{5 KAtyr/, ei
e8ei7n>et, Kat ovSets ez> TO> oiK77/j,aTi aAAoy KaOyvbev 17
p-^XP1 ^v ^v ^ tvpo T> Adyou
Kat Trpos dvTiyoSy Aeyeiv TO 8' evrevOev OVK av
Xeyozros, et JUT) Trp&rov IACV, TO Aeyo/jtevoy, oTros az/ev re
TratScoz; /cal juera TratScoy ^y aXr}Qr\s, e-Tretra d<cu>i<7ai Sco5 /cparous l/oyoy im^pr\^>avov els eiraivov cXOovra abiKOv /xot
<^aiz/erat.
In 8e TO TOU 8r]x^e'y'ro? ^73"^ roS *X(O
et
Ka/a' ex ^><*o"' yp TCW Ttya TOUTO TraOovra OVK
Aeyeiy otoy r)y TrA^y TOIS 8e8rjy/jteyois, ws fj.6vois
2l8 re KOI (ruyyvcoo'Ofxei'ots et Tray eYo'/V/ua 8pai/ Te Kat Xeyetv
j;7ro TJJS 68wr]s. eycb oyy 8e8i]yjueyos Te VTTO dXyetyoTe'poi;
Kat TO dXyetyoTaTor <Sy ar TI? b?j)(6etrjT^y Kapbiav yap
*7 tyvXJlv *) OTI bfl avrb di'o/xdcrat TrAjjyets Te Kat
5 wo Twr ei> <^)iAo(ro<^ia Ao'ycoi'j ot e')(oyTai e^tdrrj? d
i;eoi> 1^1)^5 /xr) a<pvovs orav XaficovTai,

Kat TrotoCfft 6paz;

Te Kat Aeyetz; OTIOWKat opwy aS $a^8povs, 'Ayaflcovas,

b 'Eputju,ax.ous, ITava-avtas, 'Apto-ToSr/jLtous Te KOI 'Apioro(frdvas' ScoKpaTij 8e avrbv TI 8et Aeyetv, Kat 6Vot aAXot;
yap KeKOtyaw^KaTe Tr]s ^tAocrd^ou pavCas Te Kat
s8to TrafTes aKOweo-0e' o-wyyycoo-eo-0e yap Tot? Te
5 ToVe Trpa^etcrt Kat TO?S yw Aeyo/j,e'yot5.

ot 8e otKeTat, Kat

et TI? aAAos eo-Tty /3e/3rjAos Te Kat aypotKos, irvAas Train;

fxeyaAas TO?? wcrti' eirC6ecrOe.
'EireiS/) yap ow, S az/8pe?, o Te Av^os a7re(r/37JKei Kat
C ot TratSes e^co rjvav, !8oe //,ot \pr\vai jarjSey TrotKtAAety
avrov, dAA' eAev^epws et-zrety a //ot edoKec Kat etiroy
avrov, 2cf)KpaTes, Ka^evSets;
1

y~v > ^ ^
r'
Uu
OTjTa, T)S o;> os.

e i S); B et in marg. T : om. T W

a 2 re B T Oxy. : re wal W
as SrixOfi-n T W Oxy.: Seixdfj B
7^ ^ >|'wx^' T W Oxy.: ^ tfwxV
yap B $ if/wx'/1' secl- Usener)
a 6 jf'ux^s B T : '/'"XV W
^ E! W
Oxy.: ical ^ T
a 7 al ante 'A.y&Bcai'as add. W
b 4 re T W :
om. B
b 6 TIS T W Oxy.: TI B
02 Kj^ffas] /cat Ketj/ijeros Oxy.

2i8c
Ol<rda ovv & pot
Tt /T.dAto-ra, e^r/.
2v e/uot o"oKets, ^y 8' eya>,
fj,6vos, Kai jitoi <j>aivr) oKveiv fj.vr]<rdfjvaL
Tipos
ovrcocrt e)(<o' miyt> avorjTov TyyoCjuai etWt crot p) ov Kat
rouro ^api^trdai Kat et rt a\Ao ^ r^s ov(Tias rfjs ffj.rjs 10
8eoio ^ r&v 0iAcoi; roiz; e/xtoz/. e/uoi /u,ez> yap ovSeV eari d
irpecrfivTepov row ws ort /SeAricrroz; e/Ae yev<rdai, TOVTOV 8e
o?/xai //.oi (rvXA.7j7rrOjoa ovftzva Kvpiatrepov flvai o~ov.
TOVS (f)poviiJ.ovs, t\ -xapifyiJifvos rovs re TroAAoi/s Kat atypovas.
Kai ovros aKOwcray /xaAa etptoiHKcos Kat cr(f)6bpa kavrov re
Kal eia>0ora)s eAe^ey 'H ^>iXe 'AAKt/Btd^, KtrSvyeveis rw
ov tyavXos clvai,, etTrep a\rj6fj Tvy\avei ovra a Aeyets
l e/u,oi), Kat us ear' ev e/xot byvap-is 8t' ^s ar cri yeVoio
d/u,?jxai;oy rot KaAAos opwrjs &v er e/uot Kat rijs
napa crot fvpoptpCas Tnl/UTroAD btatpfpov.
et 8?) Ka6op>v
avrb Kotfeocracr^at re juot eirtxeipeis Kat dAAaa<r0at KaAAos
ovrt Ko:AAovs, OK dAtyw jixou irAeoveKTerz; Stayorj, dAA'
ctrrl borjs aX^Oeiav KaX&v Krao-^at e7rt)(etpets Kat roi
OVTI "xpvtrea x.Xfetft)j; " biap.ij3f(r6ai. voels. dAA', co
/uaKapte, apavov o-KoVet, ^77 (re XavBdvcD ovbev &v. i] rot

5
219

<rv e rovrfov en
Kayo) aKovcras, Ta jixev irap' e/^oC, e^rji', raCra fcmv, <av 5
6:AAcos etpryrat ^ a>s Sta^ooCpvat* (ri> 8e avros ovrco
ort o-ot re apurrov Kat e/^ot ^yjj.
'AAA', t(^rj, roCro y' eS Ae'yety li; yap roi erncim XPV<P
ftovXfv6p,voi Trpd^o/xev o ay ^)aifr]rat rwy irept re TOVTMV b
Kat irept rwz; aAAa>r apitrrov.
c 9 ?xw B Oxy. : xft"' ^ W
c 10 xaPlffaff^at Oxy.
e? rt B
Oxy. : TI T W
d I Se'oio] Se'jjj W (oio s. v. W)
da is Sri
TW Oxy.: g<r rt B
da juot Oxy. (ut vid.) al. : Mou B T W
62 TOI BTW Oxy. : ri al. Bekker
e 4 re BT Oxy. : om. W
as ^ TO: W : tyroj B T
as e>oO TW Oxy. : e>oi B
a 7 frrt
ante &piirrov add. Oxy.

IlAATflNOS

'Eycb juez> 8r) ravra aKovcras re KOL elTtwv, KCU

uxrirep /Se'Arj, rerpfi(r0ai aiirbv &fj,rjv nal di>aoras ye, ov8'
emrpe^as rovra) eiTreTy ov8ei> eu, ajUK^teo-a? ro l/xdrtoi>
ro eymawou roCroz* /cat yap ?fz; x.ei/xwyVTTO ror Tpi/3a>va
KaraKAwet? TOV rovrow, /7rept/3aAft>z> ra> Xe'Pe TOVT&> r^
8ai/jioyu> ws dArj^ws Kat 0aiYxaara>, KaTKLfj,rjv rrjv VVKTO.
o\t]v. Kal ovbe Tavra av, S Sw/cparey, epets on
Trot77o-ayro? 8e 8rj ra{5ra e/!zo{5 o{!ros TOCTOVTOV
re /cat KaTf^povrjcrfv
Kat KareyeAacrev T^? e/x^s wpas cai
vfipLfrev feat Trept fKetvo ye w/xjy rt elmi, S aySpe? StKacrrai8tKa(rrai ydp lore r?)s ScoKparovy VTreprj^aytas ev yap
tore p-a Oeovs, ju,a 6ecis, oi8ey Treptrrorepoy Kara8e8ap0TjKcbs
avecrTriv /xera ScoKpdrovs, r) et /xera Trarpos Ka6rjvbov 17

To 8^ juera rowo riya oieo-^e f>ie 8iawuay exetz;' ^

jj.vov jj.v ^rt/jtdcr^at, ayd^vov 8e T^I; rovrou (JJTLHTLV re Kat
5 cro)(ppoo"vvr]v Kat avbptiav, eyrerDx^Ko'ra av6p(aTr<j> TOIOVTW
ofta eyoo O^K Sv wp-i]^ TTOT' evrDxery eis (ppovrjcrLV Kat ets
Kapreptar; ^o-re 01!^* OTTCOJ oi!i> dpyt(bt/x,r}y eixoy Kat aTro(TTpr]9fir]v TTJS TO^TOV crvvovo-ias, o-yre cm/ Trpocrayayot^Tji;
6 aiirov rjvTTOpovv.
ev yap ^f8rj on \prnjLacri ye 7roA.7> p^dAAoi;
arpcoros ^y iravraxfj ^ <n8?7p(i) 6 Afas, w re w/^rjy aiiTov
juoVw dAo6(reo-0ai, 8te7re<pevyet p.e. rjTropovv by, Kara8e8ouAa)jmeros' re VTTO rou avOp&irov ws ovSets VTT' oi8ews
5 aAAov TrepiTja. rard re yap /aot cnravTa Trpovyeyovei, Kat
/xera raSra <rrpareta TJ/XU' e^s IIoreiSaiai> eye^ero KOtr^
Kat oT)ye(rtroi)p;ey eKet.
Trpcoroy /otey oiy ro?s TTWOIS ov
ILOVOV ep,o) irepirjv, dAAa Kai rwv SAAcoy am&vr<dv oiroV
TTOV, ota TJ eTrt arparetas,
b4 /Se'Ar? B: ^SeAet TW Oxy.
bs TOjJrif) T W : TOUTO B
b 7 rovrovi T W : rofaov B
C 2 au B : om. T W
05 [ai] Trepj
fueivo Oxy. : Kaiirtp eiteivd T W : Kaiirep \tfivo B
d I ^ et B Oxy. :
iftTW
d.7 KopTepiV BT W: [eyJ/cpaTeiaj/ Oxy.
e I ye T W

Oxy. : re B
Koii/j? vulg.

03 5tf B T Oxy. : re W

e6 /coji/i? B T W Oxy. :

6 8 OTTO'T' W : 6v6rav B T Oxy.

Cor'narius : airo\ei<t>8ei>Tes B T W (deest Oxy.)

e9

STMnOSION
v, ovbev ri<rav ol #AAot irpos TO KaprepetveV T' aS
rat? evco)(tats juoVos a7roAaveiz> otos r' T/V ra r' aAAa Kat
irivftv OVK e#eAo)Z>, OTrore avayKacrOeCr], Ttavras eKparet, Kal
o TrdvTuiv OavfJiacrTOTaTov, 2o)Kparr] jj.fdvovTa ov8ets ircdTrore
rovrou ju,ev oSy p,ot 8oKet Kat avriKO. 6
Trpos 8e av ras TOV xetp-wvos Kaprep?j(reis
.8et^ot yap avroOt xetju,wz/es6avfj,acria 77pyaero ra re
aAAa, Kat irore orros nayov oiou Set^oraroD, Kat Travraiv r]
OVK eftoVrcou HvooOev, T) et rty etot, ?7p;^)tecrju.eya)j' re
a 87) 6Va Kat vTrobebe^v^v Kat ei'etA.typevwy rovs
ets TriAou? Kat dpyaKtSas, oSros 8' ev rovrots e^Tjet
l/jiaTiov fj,ev TOIOVTOV olovirep Kat irporepov eW^ei
L, dwTToSTjros 8e 8ta row KpucrraAAou paoy eTiopevero
ot aAAot -inrobfbffjfVOL,
ol 8e o-rpartairat VTre/3Ae7roi'
&) 5 KdTcuppovovvTa (r(f)&v.
KOI TavTa ^\v 87) raSra'

220 a
220

otov 8' au ro'S' Ipe^e Kat ^rA?7 Kaprepos di>r/p

irore eTrt crrpartaj, aftoy aKoCcrat.
o'Ui'^OTycras yap
eto^eV rt etOTTyKet (TKOTT&V, Kat e>7rei87) OTJ ^pou^pet
avrw, OTJK dz^tet aAAa etcrrTjKet fyr&v. KOL 7/877 ^ p-eoTjp;- 5
jSpta, Kat avdpatiroi yo-Odvovro, KCU davfJ-d^ovres aAAos aAAw
ort ScoKpdrTjs e^ eco^troi) ^povri^v rt
8e rtz^es rSy 'Iwz^coy, eueiSr/ eo"7re'pa T]^J
sKat yap 0epos rore y' 771;^a/wewta e^ereyKd/jieyot d
, p;ev ey rfi ^v^i naOyvbov, (ipa 8' f^vXarrov CLVTOV et
r7)y VVKTO. e(TTrioi.
6 be eto-r?7Ket p-e^pt ews eye^ero
fiXi<t>.

et 8e f3ov\.(rde & T<US /uaxaisTOTJTO yap 877 5

ye avrw d-7ro8owatore yap 77 /Ma^T] 7/y e rjs ep:ot

a 4 ft WI'TWU T W Oxy. : 6ir6rav B

eav^aundira-rov Oxy.
a 5 ecepaKfv T W Oxy. : ecapaicei B
b I irayov B Oxy. : roO irdyov
TW
^ B O x y . : o m . TW
bs 8); TW Oxy. : $ B
b4 8'
om. Oxy.
b 5 ol6virep B Oxy. : oTov T W
C 2 o5 ro8' W
Oxy. : aurb B T
lppc|6 B
03 ffrpanas Oxy. : ffTparetas
BTW
C 4 irpoxpet B
C 6 avOpwiroi Mehler : &/0pw7roi B T W
C 7 e\eyei> BTW Oxy. : ^A-eyoj/ Mehler
c 8 Te\eue'|] wy ^ Oxy.
TwvTej] at TeAet/TWKTes W
d 3 UfXPls W
d. 5 e^] a e v Oxy.

aaod

nAATJINOS

Kal Tapioreux i-bocrav ot o-rparrjyoi, ovbels aAAos ep,e e'craxrey

e avdpdiraw rj OVTOS, TfTpa^vov OVK e0e'Aa)i> cmoXnrfiv, dAAa
arvvbiea-axre Kal ra oirAa Kal amov ejue. Kal eycb p,eV, 2> 2wKpares, /cat rore CKtXtvov <rol Stoo^at Taptorera rot)?
yovs, Kal TOVTO ye /AOI oUre /ze/xxp-r/ o{/re epe?? on
5 dAA.a yap raw orparr/ycoi' Trpos ro e/xof aia)/xa a.Tro
Kal fiovXojjievtov l/xot St8oVai Taptoreia, avros ir
eyeVou TWZJ orpar^ycox; l/xe Xa/3eiv 17 cravTov. Irt TOLVVV,
a> avSpes, $ioz; ^y OeacracrOai Sco/cparrj, ore OTTO
TO errparo-jreSor' tTV)(ov yap
, OVTOS 8e oTrXa. avexwpei oSy
?/6rj Twy av6ptoitu>v OVTOS Te a/xa Ka^ Aax^js* Kat eyw TreptTvyxayco, Kat t8a>y ev0i)s -TrapaKeAevop^at Te avrolv dappelv,
5 Kal eAeyov 6Yt OVK aTroA.eti^a> avrat. evravda 8rj Kat KaA.Atoy e^eacrajarji; ScoKpaTTj -^ ey IToTetSata awos yap
ey <po/3a> 77 8ta TO e^>' tinrou etrat -Ttp&Tov p,ev o<rov
b Aa)(rjTO? TW fj,(f)p(ov elyat' eTretTa e'p-oty' eSoKet, (b 'Apio-Totyavfs, TO crov 8r) TOUTO, Kal exe^ 8ta7rope7;ea'^at &cnrep
Kat ez>0ae, fipevdvonevos Kat T&x^^aA/xa) 7rapa/3aAAcoy, ?7pep-a TrapacrKOTr&v Kat rovy (f)i\iovs Kat TOVS 7roAe//.tous,
5 87?Aos coy Tra^Tt Kat Traw TiopputOev OTI et Tts a^eTat
TOW avbpos, p-aAa eppcop,ei>a>s ap,WiTat..
810 Kal dc
Kal OUTOS Kal 6 eTatpos* o-xeSof yap rt r<Sy ovra)
kv TW TroAe'f/,0) oi8e aTiTOVTai, dAAa TOWS TrpoC TpOTradrjv tpevyovTas $HI*K.OV<TIV.
UoAAa p,ey ouy ay Tts Kal aAAa l^ot ScoKpaTrj
Kal 0aup,acria' dAAa rwy p,ev aAAcoy e7rtT
Tts Kal Trepl aAAou Tota^Ta etTrot, TO 8e
5 ojj.oi.ov ttvai, /x?]Te Twy TraAaiiSy p:?jre T(Si> vw OVTOIV, TOVTO
e I rerpcafjLevoif OVK e0f\wv B W Oxy. : ou/c fOt\<ov rerptanevov T
a 7 ^ B : ^ T W ; i j Oxy.
b 3 rci) o<t>6a,\^ T Oxy. : TW <t>0a\ju.$ B :
T' o(t>da\/j.b W
b 4 <irept<ntoir>i> Ast
<pi\iovs B T W : <t>i\ovs Oxy.
bs aif/atroOxy.
b6 a/tureTrat TW Oxy. : a/ivcrjrai B
b7 OUTOJ
BTW: auTosOxy.
IraTpos Aristides : e'repos BTW Oxy.
04 Se
B T W : Se STJ Oxy.
C 5 ?j/ot Mijre T W Oxy. : e?j/oi ^ue B

STMHOSION
a&ov Travros Oav^aros. olos yap 'A^XXfvs eyeWro,
Kacretey av rts Kat Bpavibav /cat aXXovs, Kat olos av
TlepiKXrjs, Kat Neoropa Kai 'AvTrjvopa etVt 8e Kat eYepot
Kat TOVS aAAous Kara ravr av TIS aTretKa^bf otos 5e oi/rocrt
yeyove rr)z> droTuW avdpanros, Kat a^ros xat ot Ao'yot amov,
0^8' eyyi)y a> evpot rts fy}TG>v, ovre T&V vvv omt r&v
TraAatwy, et /x^ apa et ols eya> Aeya> airetKa^bt rts amov,
av9p<fnr(tiV pev fj-rjbevi, rols 8e a-iXyvols Kat crar^pois, a^roy
Kat TOVS Adyous.
Kal yap ovv Kat roCro ey ToTs TrpdroLs TrapeAtTroy, ort
Kat ot Aoyot amov o/xotorarot etcrt rots o-iXrivots rols 8totyoet yap e^eAot ns rwy ScoKparot;? aKoveu> Adycoy,
av irdvv yeAotot TO Trpuirov roiama Kat 6Wp,ara
Kat pijjuara eco^ey Trepta/u.ire^oi'rat, aarvpov 877 rti'a vfipicrrov ftopav. ovovs yap Kav6r]Xiovs Aeyet Kat ^aXKeas rti'a?
Kat <TKVTOTop.ovs Kat (3vpo-oo\l/as, Kat aet 8ta rwr aiirwr ra
avra ^atVerat Aeyetz/, wore aTretpoy /cat d^o'^tos avOponros
lias av T<3y Xoyutv KarayeAacretey. Stotyo/xez^oys 8e ^obr ay
rts Kal euro? avrutv yiyvouevos Tip&Tov ^fv vovv fyovTas
tvbov povovs evp77(ret raw Ao'ycor, eiretra ^etordrous' Kat
TrAeurra dyaAjuar' operas er awrots e^oira? Kat eTTt TrAe?oroy T6LVOvra$, uaXXov 8e em -Tray 6Voz> Trpoo-^Ket ffKoneiv
TW ju,eAAoyrt KaAS Kaya^w ecreo-^at.
TaCr' ko-riv, a aydpe?, a eyco SooKpan] eTrat^w' Kat av
a ju,e/>i<po/xai crvufjizi^as vfjilv ?TTOV a p,e vj3pL<Tv.
Kal p.evrot OVK ejue JJLOVOV ravra TTernoir\K.v, aXXa Kat Xapjjiibrjv
roy FAa^Kcovos Kat Ev^Srj/^ov roy AtoK'AeoDS Kai aAAo^s
TroAAovs, of/? ovros f^aTtar&v ws epao-r^s 7rat8tKa
a^ros Ka^iVrarat dyr' epaarov. & 81) Kal O-QI
d. i Tai/T'3 raGr' B : TO>T' W
d 2 &vQptoTros B T W
d 4 Spa ej
B :fy>aTW Oxy.
A.eV> T W Oxy. : A^v B
e i ^cAot B :
fde\ei T W
T&JV . . . \<fya' T W Oxy. : TOP . . . \6jov B
62 irevv
T W Oxy. : om. B
e 3 817 Baiter : &v T W : om. B Oxy.
a i Sioijovfjievovs B
Sr B T W Oxy. : a Bekker
a 3 TWJ/
Arf-ycoc T W Oxy. : rbv \6yov B
as reivovras T W : TLVOVTO.S Oxy.:
Tsivavras B
eirl T W Oxy. : eri B
b 3 7raj/u om. Oxy.

22ic

5
222

222b
5 Ae'yco, 2) 'Ayadav, prj f^airaTacrdaL VTTO TOVTOV, dAA' diro
T&V rjfJLfTepcDV irafl^judrcou yvovra fV\aj3rj6fivaL, KCU /XTJ Kara
ri]V Trapot,fj.Lav oScnrep vriinov iradovTa yv&vai.
EtTToVros TJ raCra TOV 'AAKt/3tdSoi> yeAoora
I TT) Ttappr)cr{q
.
S 'AA.K6^3ia8r/.

CLVTOV, OTL eSoKet en

ov yap ay Trore ovrco KOJU^WS KV/cAa>

5 /3aAA.o/xcz/os afyavicrai

6pcoTiK3s

roi> oSr HcoKpdrr], N?7<^etv fAO6 Soxas, <pavcu,

eve^eipeis oS eVcxa ravra

fiprjuas,

Kai &>s ev Trapepyw 8rj Xeycoy TTI reAeur^s avro

f9r]Ka$,

ws ov 7rdz;ra rovrou CVCKO. elprjKc&s, TOV efx,e Kai

'AyaOaiva SiaySdAAet^, otojae^os 8av e/xe /xev crou e/)ai> Kat

fj,i]bevbs aAAou, 'Ayd^coya 8e wo (rou epao-#ai KOI jurjS' vqf)'
aAAov.

dAA' OVK

eAa^es, dAAa ro aarvpiKov

TOVTO Kat <ri\r]ViKibv

Kard^Aoy eyevero.

crov

dAA',

5 <tA.e 'Ayd^coy, /w,r]8ev TrAeoy a^rai yeyijrat, dAA.a

Trapa-

(TKvaov OTTCOS f/xe Kat (re //,^8eis 8iaj8aAeu

Toy ovi' 'Ayd^cora eiTmi/, Kat JUT^Z;, S Swxpares, KivSv6 revets aXrjOij Aeyety.
reK/xatpo/uat 8e Kat o>? KareKAtz/rj ev
e/xou re Kai om>, tya x.wpts T^/xas StaAd/STj.

ovdey oSy

avrti ecrrai, aAA.' eycb -Trapa (re eA^coy KaraicAiz;?j(ro/>tai.

ye,

(fravai

TOV 2coKpdrjy,

5epo

vTro/cdrco

e/xow

*Ii Ze5, etTrety roz^ 'AA/a/StdSr^, ota av Trdo-^co ^TTO rot)

av0pd>Trov.
oterat fxov 8eiy Trayrax^ Treptetyat.
/i?j rt aAA.o, S ^aujudcrie, ev /xeVa) ^/xwz; ea
'AAA' dSwaroy, fyavai TOV ScoKpdrrj.
(Trfjvecras,

dA.A' et

(TV /aey yap e)u.e

Set 8e e/xe a? roi> eTri Se^t" eTiaiveiv.

eav ovv

inrb crol KaraKAtyij 'AyaOatv, ov ftr/nov e/xe TrdAty

b 5 'airaTS<r0e B
b 6 yvuv-ra. B
04 o^ws pr. B
05 ov
fvtKa T W : oweita corn Oxy. : ouS' eVeico B pr. Oxy.
d 6 5ta/3o\ct Oxy. : Sia0d\y B T W
67 Trepite^oi Oxy.
e 10 y&p e>e
B Oxy. : y<ip fieTW
e 1 1 aO r\>v Bekker : ecu rov B Oxy. : aiirbv
TW
e 12 KaraK\i6t) Oxy.

STMTTOSION
reVerat, Ttplv VT? ^ov fjiaXXov
o>

Satjudzne,

Kal

/UTJ

22a

fTTaiveOijvat,;

<pOovrj(rris

ro>

dAA' taarov,

jxetpaKtw

vif

ep-ov

223

eTraiveOrjvai- Kal -yap TTO.VV e7rt0i>ju.<3 ainov lyKcojoudVat.

'lou tot), cpdvai TOV 'AydOava, 'A\Kifiidor],

OUK eo-0' OTTCO?

&y ei>^a5e /Aeiz^at/^t, dA.Aa Trayro? //aAAo

tya VTTO 2a>K/3aroDS eTratre^ft).
Tavra

e^Ker^a,

(fxivai

TOV 'AAKtyQtdSrjy,

SooKpdrous Tiapovros T&V KaXG>v fjifraXa^elv

ra

abtivarov dAAa>.

cai yuy ws evTrdpoos Kat in6avov Xoyov rjvpfv,

wore Trap'

eauroi rovroyt KaraKcio-^ai.

Toy [j,v

ovv 'Ay&6(i)va

ScoKpdrei avia-racrOai'

&s KaraKetcrd/xeyoy Trapa

rai

e^atyvris 8e KcojLtaords

TrdAAovs eirt ras 6vpas, Kat eTTiTT;)(dvras dyewy/^eVat

eis TO avriKpvs TTOpfvecrOai
Kat

Oopvfiov

Trapa o-(jbds Kat

/ue(rra -Trdrra

ii8ert dyayKae<r0at TTLVZLV

etyai, Kat ovKert

Trd^TToXw

olvov.

ey 5

TOV

ovv 'Epv^t/xaxov Kat TOV <J>ai8poy Kat dAAous Ttz/ds I0r]

pt(TTd6i7/Aos otxea~^at dirtdrTas,
Ka.Tabap6fLv
yp6fj.vos
JJAVOVS,

I 8e virvov Aa^Setr,

iravv iroAiJ, are ^aK.pS>v T>V VVKT&V ovcr&v, c

8e tSe^ TOV? /jtey dAAous Ka^edSoi'Tas Kai

'AyaOuiva

fj-ovovs fyprjyopevat

8e

Kal ' ApitrTOfpavrj

Kat ScoKpaTi) ITC

Kat Tiive.iv IK <pia\r]s p,ydXr)s

TW ow 2a>KpdTrj avTo^s dtaAeyeo-^af

eut 8e^td. 5

Kal rd juey dAAa 6

'Aptord8rj/xos OT;K e^>r] /ne/uy^cr^at TW^ Adycoy.owe yap e^ d

ap-^rjs TrapayevtcrOai inrovvcrTa&iv Terd //.e^Tot
eq!)7], TtpocravayKd&iv

TOV ScoKpaTrj 6/xoAoyetv

avroi) dr8pds eZrat K<o/i(p8tay Kat rpayo>8taz>

Trotery, Kal Tor Texyri rpayo)8o7rotdv oifTa (Kal)
etVat.

TauTa 81) dvayKa^b/xeyous avrovs Kal ov

z>u<rTaeiv, Kat

irpdrepoy /xey KarabapOflv

TOV

b 7tfAAovy]rows aAAovs Oxy.

b 8 e 8e B W (I W) : eauroi/ Se
Oxy. : eaSe T
0 4 crcaKpari} KOI apiTroQavr) Oxy.
C 5 7
U67A.r)s ^)i[x]a\i7s Oxy.
ds ol Vind. 21: om. B T W Oxy.
d 7 irpfcepov T W Oxy. : irpwroc B

223d

nAATHNOS

STMOOSION

8rj be ^juepa? yiyvo^vr)? TOV 'Aya&oya. TOV

ovv 2coKparrj, KaraKOt/^icra^r' fKeivovs, avacrravra aTTLevai,
10 Kat (e) uxnrep et<)^ei H-Tieo-dai, KOL f\66vra tls AVKCLOV,
cnrovi^ra^vov, a)(nre/> ^A.Aore r^y aAArjy ri^
/cat ovro) biarpfyavTa eis tcnttpav ouot
b 9 KarctKoi/jLlffavT' B W Oxy. : Kara/coi/t^owr' T
Hermann: om. BTW Oxy.

to

10 I add.

2&KPATH2

<&AIAPO2

St. Ill

p. 227

212. 9f2 </uAe <J>ai8pe, -TTOI Sr) /cat TtoOzv;

a
. Flapa Au<riot>, cb 2toKparej, roC Ke<^>aAou, iropevSe irpos TiepCTraTov e^co ret^ovs' vvyyov yap eKe?
^a yjpovov Kadr]fj.evos e^ ku>divov. TU> be cr<S Kai
eratpa) irfidofjifvos 'AKou/xez>&> Kara ra? 6801)? TrotoC/xai 5
-TreptTTtirous' <^?](rt yap aKomorepous el^at rwy ey ror?
b
. KaAcS? ycip, co kraipf, Aeyet. arap Aucrias ^r, 0s
, f v acrret.
<f>AI. Nai, Trap' 'ETrtxparet, ey rrj8e rr/ TrX^criov rov
Xvuiriov ot/ua rr; Mopv^ta.
5
212. Tis ovv 8r) ?)y ^ 8iarpt/3?7; ^ 877X01; ort rwy Aoy<ou
Aixrt'as eicrrta;
ITeTKrrj, et (rot o-^oAr) TipoiovTi aKoijew.
212. Tt 5e; OVK av oiei /ute Kara nirSapoz; " Kal acr^oAias V T r e p r e p o v " upayfia 7T06?jcra(r^ai ro re?jy re Kal 10
Aucrtoi; 8tarpi/3^y aKoCo-at;
4>AI. ITpoaye 8?].
C
212. Aeyoty ay.
<I>AI. Kat /x?]i;, a> 2coKpare?, irpoo-^KOixra ye croi 77
a5 axovfjiei/if B T (cf. Symp. 176 b, 6)
bio irot-fiffcurOai Par. 1811 : irot^irecrflat BT

b 6 oSj' 8^ B:
reVji/ G : er^v BT

227 c

HAATiiNOS
6 ydp rot Adyos fy, Trept bv 8terpt/3o//ez;, OVK oZ8' ovrtva

5 rpoTtov

epcoriKoj.

yeypct^e yap 5?) 6 Aucrtas Treipw/ueyoz;

rivet T&V /caA<3i>,oi!% VTT* epaoroi) 8e,)dAA' avro 8r) rouro

Kat KfKofJ.\lfVTai-

Aeyet yap

obs xaptcrreoz> JU.TJ ep<Sz>rt jutaAAoi;

.TJ epwzm.
10 Xoy ^ TrAowo-iG), /cat Trpecr/Surepw i) recorepw, Kat ocra aAAa
d

//,O6 re Trpooreori Kat 701^5 iroAAots ^jawy 77 yap &v dcrrerot

Kat S^/AOXpeAeis eTey ot Aoyot.
fjir]Ka

eycwy' ow ovrco? TTiTe0iu-

aKOvcrai, war' eay /3a8t{cop 'Trot^ roy TreptTraroy Me-

yapa5e Kat Kara 'HpoSiKoz; 7rpO(r/3as rw ret)(et TraAtv aTUTjs,

5 ou //?) o-ou airo\i<pO&.
$AI. Hw? Aeyets, S /3eAricrre EcoKpares;
228

V<

Kara

otet fxe, a

Aucrias' ey TroAAS XP ?
crx ^^ <
a>y TOW yuz; ypatpetv, raura i8twrr)y oyra a
dtcos KLVOV;

TToAAoS ye 8eco-

Katrot

jLtaAAoz; ^ /xot 1:0X7) \f>v<riov yev^vOai.

5

211.

O ^atSpe, et eyco ^arSpoy dyrow, Kat

eTTtAtArjcr/xat.

aAAa yap ovderepa ecrrt rovrcov ev o?8a ort

Auo-tov Aoyoy aKovav Kfivos ov JJLOVOV a?ra^ ^Kowcrev, aAAa

iroAAaKis e'TraraAajUjSai/coi' eK^Aevey ot Aeyeu^, 6 8e eT
b Trpo^vfAO)?.

ra> 8e o^8e raSra ^y kavd, aAAa

TrapaAa/3a)y ro /3i/3Atoi> a //.aAtcrra e-Tre^/Aet eTreo-Koiret, Kat

roi5ro 8pwv e^ eco^tyou Kafl^evo? aTrenrcby ets TreptTraroi;
jfet, a>s j^ei1 eyo) otjuat, rr) roz> Kwa, IfeTrtcrrdjueyos rov
5 Aoyoy, ei ju^ Trdyu rt rfi> p;aKp09.
tra fj.f\T(p].

eTropevero 8' CKTOS ret-

aitavrricras 8e rw rocroCyrt Trept Aoyoor

8^>y /zev, t8(oy, 170-^1) ort e'oi roy a-vyKOpv^avT

C KOL Ttpoayeiv eKeAeue.

btofjievov

8e Aeyetv roS rwv

epaoroS, eOpVTTTCTO ws 8^ OI/K inOvfj,S>v

Aeyeizr

C9^W:&T:5B
a4 TO\{; B : TTOA.WI/ T
a 6 e5 B : eS
8' T
b 5 Wi/u TI Schanz : iroi/w rts BT
b 6 T<] T^> ci. Stephanus
b 7 B&i' /t^v J5ci>j' B T : tS&j/ /xev Z^y G : iS&v ptv lovra. vulg. : alterum
IScbi> del. t Hermann : om. Schanz

4>AIAPO2

2280

8e ejueAAe /cat ft p-r; Tts e/ca>i> O.KOVOL /3ta epetu. rrv ow,
oTrep ra^a irarrcos irotTjo-et vCi; 17877
.
5
4-nJ ",
. 'Ejuot <s a\.r)6&s TroXv /cpdrto-ToV ecrrw ovrcoy
oira)S bvvajJiai, Xeyetv, cos jw,06 80x6^9 cri; ovda/xws /ue a(f)^creiv
trplv &v eiTro) a/mcSs ye TTCDS.
211. Ilayv y&p (rot aXrjOi) 8o/ccS.
4>AI. Ovraxrt roivvv Trorfarw.
rw ovrt yap, a 2w- d
s, Trayros juaAAoz/ ra ye p^ara OVK f^fjjiaOov
rr\v
biavoiav a-^bbv airavTow, ols tyrj 8ta^>epety ra TOV
fp&vros rj TO. TOV jut?7, v Kec^aXatots fKacrrov <J)ffjs Stet/xt,
ap&ij.vos cnrb TOV TT/XOTOU.
5
S12. Aei^ay ye TtpGtTov, u> </>tA,or?7s, ri apa ey r^ dptVTTO rw t//,aria)' ro7r(i^co yap (re e^ei^ TOV Xoyor
ei 8e TOUTO' eorir, ovrcoo-t 8iai>oou Trept e/xou, a>s
eyed ere 7raz>u /xev <j)L\&, vapovTos 8e /cat Av<rtou, epavTOV (rot e
e6y
^ ^^^^ 8e'8o/erai.
I. IlaOe.
croi <as eyyv/xvao-oji/.eyos1.) dAAa irov 8^
avayv)fj,ev ;
5
S12. Aevp* eKTpaTro/xerot KaTa TOV 'IAio-oy tcojmey, eTra 229
O-TTOU ay 80'^ ev }]<rvyiq
^AI. Ets Kdipov, a>s
(AW yap 8r) det. p&a-Tov ovv fjiJ.iv Kara ro v8aTtov
rovs 7ro8as terat, *cat OIIK dijSe'?, aAAtos re KOI nyySe TT/I> 5
TOI) Irou? re /cat TIJS ^epa?.
. ITpoaye 817, /ci o-KoVet a/ua OTTOV
. 'Opas ow fKivr)v Trjv v\

212. Tt
d 4 ettaa-rov T W : om. B
d 6 eV B : S eV T
e I Se (taZ
Awfou B : 8e \vffiov T : 5' ^/ceii/ou Badham
e 2 Se'tKvv Hirschig
e 5 Ka8i^6/u.(voi B T : KaQt^ofntvoi Vind. 89 Stallbaum
a 2 icofli(n<r6f*.fOa B T W Bekk. Anecd. i. 101 : Ka6i^(a/j.f0a Stephanas
PLATO, VOL. II.
15

4>AI. 'EKei CTKLU T' eVriP KCU TTVfVfJLa

ptTplOV,

KO.I TTOC,

Sii. Ilpodyois ay.

4>AI. Enre p,oi, a> SwKpares, ovu
5 OTTO TOV 'lAtcrou Ae'yerai 6 Bopeas r?)i> 'QpetOviav dp7rd<rai;
211. Aeyerai yap.
4>AI. 'Ap' ovz; cvOcvbe; yapievra yovv nal Ka6apa KCU
bia<t>avfj ra vbaTta Qaiverai, /cat emr^Seta Ko'pais Trat^eiz;
Trap' avrd.
C
2fi. Ov/c, dAAa /carcoflei; oo-oy 8rJ' ^ rpta oraSia, if
Trpos ro li^ "Aypas Siafiaivoptv' K.OA. TTOV TLS eo-rt /3(o/x,os
avTodi Bopeov.
4>AT. Ov irayu vtvorina.' dAA' et'Tre irpos Atoy, S 2a>5 /cpares, <ri> rouro TO /^u^oAdyrjjaa TreiOy a\r)6es elvai;
2Ii. 'AXA' et aTTKTToirjv, &<nrep ol vofyoi, OVK av O.TOTTOS
ftra (ro^i^p^vos (f)aCrjv avrrjv TrvevfJ-a Bopeou Kara
ST) reAeuTT/oraff'ai' Aex^^^at VTTO ro) Bopeou av
yeyovfvai T) e^ 'Apetou irdyou* Aeyerai yap av KO! ovros
6 Aoyos, a>s fKeWev dAA' ot/x cvOevbc rjpTrdcrdri.
eycb 8e,
S <arSpe, aAAcoy p-e^ ra rotaCra yapievra T/yoSp-at, Aiay 8e
bcivov KOI CTmrdvov Kal ov Travv VTV\OVS avbpos, Kar' aAAo
pey ovftev, OTL 8' avrw drdyKTj fxera roCro ro T>V 'iTnroKtve?8os Travop6ovcr6ai, KCU avQi.'s ro r^? Xtjuatpa?, KOI
8e o)(Aos roiomtov Yopyovav nal flrjyd(ra>y Kat
dAAcov a^r]\avu>v TT\^Orj re Kat dromat reparoXoycoy riycov
<j)Tu<rtav at? e rts cnnirT&v Trpoa-pifiq Kara ro etKos HKCUTTOV,
are dypouca> riyt (rotyiq XP^/xeyos, TroAA^s avrfi o"xoA^s
ep,ot 8e Trpo? avra ovbafjL&s eo-rt o-^oAT]' ro 8e
b 2 ^ &,/] ^ e'cbv W : ? ' & / B : ^ ^j/ T
^SouX^eflo T W : )8ouAoflo B
/cora/cA.j^i'at B T W
C 2 T& ^r "Aypas scripsi (ra e'c
"Aypas Bratuscheck) : ri T^S ^^pas B T W : rb T^S aypaias rec. b
Eustathius
TJS T : rf B
07 (&/) auT^j/ Ast
d i ^ e'f . .
. Bast
e i irA.^0??
.
. . . aroiriai B T W : 7rA.^0et . . . aroiria
Athenaeus vulg.
e 4 owra B W : ravra, T

22QC

o) <t'Ae, TOVTOV Tobf. ov bvvapai TTCO Kara TO AeA- 5

ypaij.ua yvG>vai e/uauroV yeAotoy 8?; jxoi cpatyerai
TOVTO ert ayvoowra, ra dAAdrpia crKOTreu;. o#ez> ST) \aiptiv 230
eaVas raura, TreiOo^vos 5e r<3 vofj.ifyjj.zvto
Tre/st OVT&V, 6
rwSr) eAeyor, CTKO-TTW ov raSra dAA' fyawov, etre rt Orjpiov
ov Tvyx.aV(t> Tv<pu>vos Tro\vTT\oKu>Tfpov KCU ju,aAAoy fTnTedv/j.pevov, eirc T^e/Korepoy re Kat a7rAov<rrepoy ^Sy> #etas
Kai arv(pov /xotpay (^vcrei /j,Tf\ov.
ardp, S ercupe,
ro'8e ?)y ro bevbpov e0' oTrep ^yes
Touro p.ei' ot!y avro.
b
212. NT) r^y "Hpay, KaAr; ye ?? KaraycoyT]. r; re yap
VAarayos avrr; /xaA' df>i^)iAa^)r/? re Kai v\jsr]\ri, TOV re ayyou
TO iJi/fos Kai ro CTVCTKLOV -TrayKaAor, Kat a>? aK/xr)y e^et r^s
avOrjs, ws ar evcoSeo-raroy Trap^oi. TOV TOTTOV fj re av 5
Trr/y^ xaPteoT"T7? ^^o r?js ^Aar<iyov pel /xaAa ijrvxpov vbaros,
co(rre ye rw 7ro8t reK/xr/pao-^at. Nu/x,^)a)y re TIVO>V KOI 'A^eAwou lepoy d-Tro rcSy Koputv re Kat dyaA/xarcoy eotKey etmi.
ii- 8' au /3ovAei, ro evirvovv TOV TOTTOV a>9 dya^roy Kat C
fjbv- depivov re Kat Kiyvpov vitriol rw rwy rerriycoz;
rcWcoy 8f Ko^oraTov ro riys Troas, ort ey i7peju.a'
iKavrj ire^UKe KaraKAt^evrt ri)y Ke<paAr)z> TrayKeiAcos
wo-re aptcrra o-ot f^vayr^Tai, u> ^>tAe cf>at8pe.^
5
2v 8e ye, 3> 6av^a<ne, droTrwraro's rts (fraivr].
yap, 6 Aeyets, ^vayovfj,vu> Tivl KCU OVK eTTt)(copi<w
vrtos eK rou ao-reos ovr' eis rr)y virtpopCav CLTTO- d
brifJifLS, OVT' ef&) retxous e//oiye 8oKe?s ro Trapcnrav e^te^at.
212. Suyytyvcoo-Ke juoi, w ^pto-re. (piXo^aOrjs yap et/u'
ra ^te^ ouy y^pia nal ra 8et8pa ov8ey /!/,' e^eAet 8t8a(TKety,
e 6 5^ B T W Proclus (in Ale. p. 289, 5) : 5e Vind. 80
a 4 Sj/
T W : om. B : &/ vulg.
eTnTeeu/i^eVov B T W (sed /t prius in ras.
B): ITI Te6vfj.fj.evov ci. Ruhnken
l>4 / c a l & s B T W : /col o^rajy ci.
Heindorf : /col Schanz
b 7 Strre 76 B T W: &s 76 Aristaenetus
vulg.
C 2 ^5w T W : ^STJ B
wTr^e? TIJ! T W : v7njxe*Vo B
C 4 irpoffdvTfi T W : irpoffavre B
C 6 ay W : ov B T

230 d

DAATilNOS

5 ot 5' (v r<5 aoret avOputiroi. &v /^euroi SoKets ju,ot rrjs

ed8ot> ro (pdp/j-aKov rivprjKfvai.
uxnrfp yap ol ra
Ope^ara 6a\\bv T/ nva napTiov irpoo-etozres
ayovinv, o~u Ijuot Ao'yous ovra> TrpoTLVu>v ev /3t/3Atots TT\V re
e 'ArrtKr/z; (pawy 7reptaeii> airacrav KCU onoi &v aAXocre (Sovkrj.
l
, vSy 8' ouy er rai Trapoyrt 8e6p' a</HKO/zeyos eya> /ixev j^tot
8oK&) KaraKeiVecrflai, o-u 8' ev OTTOIO) o-x^jwart oiet paora
avayv&crecrQai,, rovO' lAo/ueros a
5
4>AI. vAKoi;e 77.

231

eTTiorao-ai, Kat &>s

TOVTOOV aK7]Koas' afi<3 8e JU.TJ 8ta
roCro dru^o-at wz; 8eo/xat, ort OVK epaor^? wi/ crou ruyTore /xera/xcAet 5r av e> Troi?]<ra)(rti;,
az; 7779 inOv{j.(as Trawcovrai* roi^? 8e OVK Icrri ^povos
kv a> nfTayv&vai, irpocrT^Kei.
ov yap vu' drdy/crj? dA.A'
eKOires, cos ai> aptcrra Trepi rwy otKeicoy (3ovX.evcraivTO, irpbs
rrjy bvvajJLi.v T7]v CLVT>V eS Trotoucrtz;. ert 8e ot juei' tp&vres
(TKOTtov(nv a re Ka/ccos Sie^eyro riSy CLVT&V 8ta roy epcora
Kat a 7re7rot?7Ka(rii' ev, Kat 6y el^oy TIOVQV Trpocrrt^eVres
yyovvrai mi/Vat rr)y a^tar aTroSeSfOKeyat ^apty rois epcojueyots- ro^s 8e /XT/ tpSxriv owe r?]y rwy otfcetcoy dju.eAetai'
8ta TOWO eWty Trpotpacrife&Ocu, ovre TOVS
Troroi;? v7roA.oyte<r0at, owre ras Trpos rows
8ta^)0pa? atrtacracr^af wore Treptryprj/Aeyiai' TOCTOVTCOV KCIK&V
ovbfv ^TToAetTrerat dAA' ^ Troiety TrpoOvfj-o^s on ay avrots
otcovrat Trpdavres -^apLfiffOai.
ert 8e et 8ta roGro atoz>
rovs tpStVTds irept TroAAoi) Troteta'^ai, 5rt TOVTOUJ //.dAtora
(pa(riv (^tAetr (Sy ay tpGxriv, Kat erot/xot etat Kat e/c roi)Z> Adyooi;
d 5 aJ recc. : ou B : 06 T
So/ce?s T : 8o/ceT B
d6 e^s T W :
om. B
d. 7 irpofreiovres t recc. : -n-poffi^vres B T W
6 2 8 ' o?v
T: ouv B
63 KXTaKeiffetrOai T : Kara/cenrfioj (sic) B
6 7 7/o/teVwc rovrtav B : TOVTWV yei/ojiieVwj' T
a 2 /j.Tafif\ei
>v T :
fj.eTa./j.e\iav B
b 5 omti<rao-0ai] curiaffOai Cobet
c i roto
T : TOU pr. B
0 2 eVoj^oi ejVt KaJ T W et in marg. b : om. B

<I>AIAP02

231 c

T&V epycoy rols aAAots a.TTtyJdavoiJ.tvoi rots epco/xe'yois

i, pqbiov yv&vai, ei oX^Brj keyovcriv, OTL ocrcav av
va-Tepov fpairOoixrLV, e/ceiyovs avr&v Trept TiXtLovos TrotTjcroyTcu, 5
Kat 87/Aoy on,
(Tovcriv.

eay fKeivois

80*77, Kat rovrow KaK<3? 770177-

Kairoi TTW? eiK^as eort 7060^01; irpay^a

TOiavTr]v UXOVTI. crvfJifpopav,

!/x7m/oos a)f cnroTpeirfiv;

fjv ovtf

irpoeadai

civ tTtiyjuprivtitv

ovSets d

Kal yap aiirol 6/x.oAoyoCcri voartiv

p.aXXov TI cr(>)(ppovLV, Kal eiSerat ort KaK&s typovovcrw, dAA'

ou bvvavOai avr&v /cpareiir wo-re TTWS ay ev </3oy?ycraz>res
fyfi-v

rj-yrfa-aiVTO

Trepl

&v omu> 8ia/cet/^eyoi 5

K.OI /xei> 8?) et [ikv e/c TWZ; Ipwircoy Toy /3eAalpoio, ef "SAtycor ay (rot r; IxAe^ts efr;* ei 8' e/c
roy <ramG> eTTiTrjSetoTaToy, eK TroAAwy wore
eATrts ey Tots TroAAors oyTa rv^flv Toy aiov rrjs (rrjs
Ei ToCvvv

TOV v6fj,ov

Toy

KadecrTrjKOTa

beboiKas,

Tc5y ayflpwTray oz'etSo's cro6 ycvrjTai, eiKo's

ep&vras, OWTCOS ay olo/jLevovs
uxnrfp

avrovs vfi

Kat </>tAoTtju,otyxeyoi>9 fTTtbcLKwa-dai,

iiXXtoS

avTols irtTiovrjTai'

/cat VTTO Twy aAAcoy 2312

amStv, Trap6f)vai

TJOVS

TU> A^yety

irpos airavTas OTL OVK

6"e /x^ ep&vras,

Kpeirrovs

OVT&V ovras, TO fisXTicrTov avT\ rrjs 86rjs Trjs Trapa T&V 5

ayflpwTrcoy olp&crOai.
avdyKt]

TrvOlcrdat

eTt 8e TOW /xey ep&VTas

KOL ibfiv

aKoXovdovvTas

iroXXovs

Tols epco/x,e'yot9

Kat epyov TOVTO TTOLOV^VOVS, ooore oTay d(p$&(n

StaAeyo-

aAAr/Aots, TOTe aiiTovs otoyTat ^ yeyeyrj/xeyr^s 77 ju,eA- b

eo-eo-0ai 7775 TTi6vfj.ias

(rvvelvai-

TOVS be [AT) epoiyTas

ov8' aiTtao"^at 6*ia rr^y (rvvovaiav eTrixetpoScrty, etSoVes OTI

dyayKato'y eo-Tiy r^ 8ta (ptAtay TW 8taAeyeo-^at 7^ 81'
0 4 SrtStrwvTW: oirJcroyB: o^y Screw Hermann
05 iroii]ffovra.i
B : Tronijo'&H'Tai T
d. 5 OUTW rec. b : OUTOI B T
d. 6 /3ov\6vovTcu
Stephanas: $ov\ovrai B T W :fieftovXcvvraiHeindorf
d? a/poio
T : alpo?ro B
a 2 rijS \eyeiv B T : T^ \fjeiv t : rb Apyeti/ D :
Ttf exfiv Badham : alii alia
83 OVK &\\ws T W : OLI KO.\US B
as O^T! T : a^ B
b 4 T b t : ry B T

HAATilNOS
5 Ttva jovriv. Ka fxev y e <TOI
XaAe7Toz> clvai, t/uAiap criiju,joieVe>, Kai ciAAa) /xey rpoTrw 8ta(popas yevojueVrys Koivrjv (ai>) d/^ore/xn? Karaorr/yai TTJZJ
C cru/A<popai>, Trpoe/jieVou 8e crow a Trepi TrAeicrrou TTOITJ jueyciA?]y
az> <roi /3Ad/3?jy ay yevscrOai, eiKorco? &> rovs fp&vras fw.\~
hov av <^o/3oio* TroAAa yap avrovs eon ra XuTTOuira, /cat
Trdvr' fTTt rij avr&v fiXapy vo^iCpvcri yiyv<r6at.
Stoirep
5 Kat ra? -rrpos rot;s aAAous TWI> epcojaeycoy o-woua-tas dirorpeirov<riv, (f)o(3ovij.voi TOVS juer ovcriav
fj,a(nv airrovs vireppahatVTai, TOVS 8
crweo-et xpetrrov? ytvavrai- rS>v 8e aAAo Tt
d ayaObv rr]V bvvafjt,t.v fKacrrov (^vXarrovr
ovv aTre^ecr^at (re rot/rots; eis epr]/x,iay
-.-., eay 8e T^ (reaurou crKOTraiz; a^tvov Kivu>v (f)povf}$, ^
avro?s eis 8ia<popav ocroi be /XT) epatvTes TV\OV, dAAa
5 aperriv enpa^av 3>v e8eoyro, ov/c ay roi^s <rui>o{)(n
dA\a rows /u.^ efleAoiras nicroizv, rjyov^voL WTT' Kiv(av fjiev
virepopacrOcu, VTTO TWP (rvvovrcov 8e w^eAeur^at, wore TroAi)
eAirls <jf)tAtay avrois IK roC Trpdy/xaros 7}
Kal p,ey 8r) Twr jitey epwyrwy TroAAot Trporepoy rou a-w//.aros CTTfOv^crav rj rov rpoTrov eyyaxray Kat roiy aAAcoy
5 oi/ceuoy e/XTretpot eyeVoyro, cocrre. a8rjAoyfavrots ei en ro're
/3ouArjo-oz;rat (piXoi, elvai, eTretSay 7775 eTri^v/xtay Trav<r(ovTai'
233 TOIS 8e /AT) ep<3<ny, ot /cat ^porepoy dAArjAois </>iAoi oyres
raura Hirpa^av, OVK ! coy &y eu Trd^cocrt raura eifcos eAdrrco
rrjy (pL\(av avrols Troi?}<rai, dAAa raiira jurrj/xera KaraAeib 8 &j/ add. Hirschig
c a &/ croi B T : 8^ (rot Schanz
&F
yeveff6ai B : yevfaOai T
et/c^rws &j/ B T : ei/ciJrws 8^ Schanz
lici\\ov &v B : fia\\ov T
05 ras B T W : TIJS corr. Ven. 184
TCOV
fp(t>fj.ev<av] rbvty(o/u,evovHeindorf
d 2 cbrexOeo-ftai . . . TOI$TOIS]
airex^fff^eH TOIJTOIS B T W : air^fffQai . . . TOVTOIS vulg. : aire'xefffla'
. . . roiiTiav al. Stallbaum
d6 UTT'] o-' for' Schanz auctore Heindorf
e a yevecrBai T : yevfi<re<r9ai B
65 aiiTots et ert B : et ert auToTj T :
e Tt Hermann
rJre T : om. B
a3
Heindorf

4>AIAPO2

233 a

(f)6f}vai, rS>v /ueAAoVrcou e<reo-0at. KCU fjLtv 8?) /3eArioz>t (rot

TrpocTTjKei yeve'crflat e/xoi TretflojueW r) epaorr). eKeu>ot jxey 5
yap Kal irapa ro /3eAriorw rd re Aeyo/u,ei>a Kai ra Trparro'/xeva f-nawova-Lv, ra ^er ;8e8tores ju^ air^^Q^vr 0.1,^0. Se^
Kat avrot x.eipoy 8ia rr)j; k^idv^iav yiyv&ffKOVTfs.
roiaura b
yap 6 epws eTrtSeiKvurai' Suo-ruxoCvra? /jier, a JU.TJ
rols aXAoiy Trape'xei, aviapa Trote?
Kat ra jurj ybovrjs a^ia -Trap' tKeivaiv eirairoi)
wcrre iroA-i) juaAAor eXetty rcus Ipco/uewis ^ 5
po(T7]Ki. eav 8e jixot Trei'&j, irp&rov \&v ov
rr)V Ttapova-av f]ovT\v OepaTifvav avvtcro\Mi troi, aAAa Kat
r^y /xeAAoucray (JxpeAta^ e<recr0ai, ov^ VTT' IpcoTOs Tjrrwju.eros C
aAA* e/xauroii Kpar&v, ov8e 8ta cr^iupa la-^vpav \0pav avaidAAa 8ta /uteydAa /3pa8ea)s oAtyrjz; opyr^v irototJT>V ftez> aKOVxricoy (rvyyva>p.r]v fX(>)V' r" ^ e/covcrta
aTrorpe'Tretv raura yap ecru <iAta9 TroAw XP^~ 5
roz> (<rop.evr]s reKja^pta. et 8' apa <roi roSro TrapecrTrjKer, ws
o^x otw re i(rxvpay (j)i\iav ye^eV^at eai' fi?] rts ep<3z> ruyxai'r/,
fV0Vfji.L(r0ai XP^) ^Tt ^r' ^y TOWS vets Trept TroAAoC eTroto^- d.
/xe^a oiiir' av rows Trare'pas Kat ras juujrepas, ovr' ^y wtcrrovs
<^)iAovs fKKTrifjif6a, ot OVK
dAA' ef erepwy eTrtr^Seu/
"Ert 8e et XP^I ro''s Seop-erots /xaAicrra -^ap^fcrOai, 5
7rpocr?jKet KOI rots aAAots /xr) rovs j8eArto-rous dAAa rovs
aTropcorarous ev Trotery /xeytcrrcoi; yap diraAAayeVres KO.K&V
TrAeto-rrji; \apiv O.VTOLS etcroyrai. Kat /uei> 8^ Kat ey ras
tStais 8a7rai;ats ov rovs <tAous a^toy irapaKaXflv, dAAa e
rovs irpoo-atrowras Kat rovs SeojueVovs TrArjo-p.oi'TjS' eKeti^ot
yap Kal dyaTT^croucrty Kat aKoAou0?jcrov<ru; Kat eirt ras Ovpas
i]ov(n Kat p.aAt<rra r](r6ri(rovTai, Kat
b6 add.6 /cai
Badham

e 2 irpocratToCvTos B T : irpoffatpovvras

2336
5 tlcrovrai Kal iroAAa ayada avrols fv^ovrai.
dAA' to-coy
irpooTj/cet ov rols a(p6bpa beofJLtvois \api0'0ai, dAAa
/xaAtora d-TToSowat \apiv SwajueVots' ovbe rot's
234 povov, dAAa rots TOV Trpay/ixaros dtots' ovbe oo-ot rrjs o-fjs
&pas diroAavo-oyrat, aAA.' otrtyes irpe<r^3urep&
o-QtTfpcw aya0G>v /xera8wo-oi;(riy ovSe ot
irpos rovs aAAovs ^iXoT^ria-ovrai, aAA' oirtves
5 jj,(voi Trpos cnravras (rta)7r?j(rovraf owSe rots oAtyoy
, dAAa rots 6//,ot(os 8ia iravrbs TOV jSto
irp6(j)acri.v Qqrricrovcnv, aAA' 01 Travcra^vov rijs &pas rore
b rrjy avr&v dper^y eTriSei^oirat. OT) oSz; rwy re flpr]^ivu>v
/cat fKelvo ev6vp.ov, ort rois juey fp&vras ol ^>tAot
a>s oyro? Ka/cou rou eirtr^Sev/ix.aros, ro?? 8e |x?j
ep&criv ouSei? irwTrore rwy otKetcoy e)ueju,\^aro &>s 8ta rouro
5 KaKco? /3ouAeuo/xeyot? Tre/ol eaurwy.
av ow epoto /xe et aTratrty o"ot irapaivSt ro^s /x?/
aTrayra? o-e KeAevetv row ep&vras Tavrrjv %\ei.v rr)y
C dtafotar. cure yap ro> Aa/x^3aroyrt x"Ptros to-rys aiov,
ovre crol /3ouAo/xefo) rovy aAAous Aay^avety 6p,o[u>s bvvarov
Set 6~e /3Aa/3?jy p-ey aTr' a^roO fj,rjbf[j.iav,
^xpeXiav
yiyvtcrOai. eya> jixey, ovy tKa^a jaot po/ufa> ra
5 et 6' en (rt) o-u 770^^5, riyovntvos 7rapaAeAet^)0at, epwra.
<I>AI. Tt <roi <^atyerat, S ScoKpares, 6 Aoyos;
s rd re aAAa Kat rots OVO\LO.<JIV
e 8 irpoffairovtri Ast : irpoffepieffi
B : epicri T W
a a yevo/jLevif T :
jv6fj.evot B
a 6 crirouSaC0110'"'] <rirov5d<Tov(nv ci. Stephanus (colent
Ficinus)
a 8 vavtraiufvov G. Hermann : iravffd/j.fvoi B T : Trauo/AfVTjj
Laur. 2643 : vavaafievois Winckelmann: alii alia
b6 & j / o 3 y T :
jufj' oSv B
b 7 /tei/ T : 8c B
c i r^S T : T$ Ao-yy B W
)f<r;s
T : OKT77S (sic) B : ofcrew W
C 3 Ssi T : at'e! B
BTT* B : CTT' T
0 5 8 ' en rt Heindorf : 8e TJ BT
o-y TroffeTs Ven. 189 : o-ii virodeis
T : oru inroBys B
epiara. T : epwra B

. *AIAP02

234d

212. Acu/xozncos /xey ovv, w eratpe, cocrre /x,e eKTrAayr/yai. d

Kat ro{5ro eya> tTtadov 8ta ere, S 4>at8pe, Trpbs ere
jSAeVcoy, ort ejuot eSoKety yaz^ucr^at 7;7ro row Aoyou
avayiyvu(TKtt>v ^yo^ero? yap (re jixaAAoy ^ ejue
irept rwy rotovrcoy crot etTro'/xrjy, Kat eTro'/ieyos
jaera crou r^s Betas Kec/>aA?/s.
212. AOKW ycxp crot irai^eiv KCU
Mr/6aju,&5s, a) 2coK/)ares, dAA' a>s a\.r]6>s
Aios <f)iXiov, cuei ay rtya fXLV f^f^v aAAoy rail'
erepa rovrcoy /xei^a) /cat TrAetco Trept rou cwroi)
212. Ti Se; Kat ramp bel VTT> ffjiov re ai (rov rov
Aoyoy krna\,Vf.Qr\vai, a>? ra beovra etpr/KoYo? TO{) irotrjroi;,
dAA' o^/c fKfLvt] IJLOVOV, OTL (rcKprj Kal crrpoyyvXa, Kal d/cpt^Sais eKaora r<y ovo^aTutv d-Troreropyeurai; et yap 8e?,
\dpiv o-rjv, eTrei e/u.e ye eAa^ey ^TTO r^s e/x^s
rw yap pjjropiKoi amov nova TOV vovv Ttpoo-o 8e 0^8' (&p) avrov &^r]V A.vaLav ole<r6ai IKCLVOV
Kal ovv p,ot e8oa>, S ^a^Spe, et ^ n cri) clAAo
Ae'yeis, Sis /cat rpts ra awa dprjKevai, &>s ov Trayv evirop&v
TOV iroAAa Aeyety irept ro{5 a^roC, r) ^CTCOS o^8ey awT&i /^eAoz;
roi rotovrou' Kal e^airero ST/ p:ot veaviVf(r0ai fmbeiKVvp.vos w? 0109 re a>y ravra ere'/scos re Kat erepco? Aeycov
d//,<ore/30)s etTrew aptora.
4>AI. Oi/8ey Aeyeis, S 2coKpares' avro yap rouro Kat
6 Aoyos exeti r<^i; 7"P &OVTWV duos prjdrjvai
ds ^SJ/cets T: So/ceTs B
6 3 rovrcav fjLfifa

d? S^SoK6?TW: S^ B: Se? Schanz

B : y.ei<a rovrtev T

6 7 /cal a.Kpifi&s fort, non

legerunt Plutarchus Hermias

e 8 airoTeTtpvevrai B : airorerSpviarai
T
a i /iJi/y B T : juJyop W
a 2 &/ ante ewrbj' addidi : ante
$M?I/ add. Thompson : post oteadai add. Ast
a 3 KOU oSv Hermann : Kal Si) oSv Stephanus : SiKaiovv B : SiKawv ol>v T W a 4 Aeyets
T: \fyrjs B
a? raiiTA Heindorf : raDra B T
bs d|^wj]
o|ta)v Madvig

235

IIAATilNOS
ey T<S TrpdyjLiaTi oi>8ey 7rapaAe'A.oi7rey, wore Trapa ra c
etpr/jueVa jixrjo'eV (ay) Trore Swao-flat etirety dAAa TrAeuo Kat
5 TrAeiovos ata.
SI2. ToCro eyto 0-ot ovKeVt oto? r' eVojuuu iriOe<r6ai'
TraAatot yap Kat <ro<pol avbpts re Kat ywaiKes Trept ai/rwy
etprjKo'res Kat yeypa^ores eeAeyou<rt /xe, edy (rot
[JLfVOS

(TDy^COpW.

<i>AI. Ttves ovroi; Kat ?roC (TT> jSeXrtco rcnmoz; a

2O. NSy /^ev O#T&> OUK e^co et^ery S^Aoy Se on
aK?]Koa, fj TTOU 2a7T(/)oi5s rijs KaA^s T) 'AyaK/aeoyro? TOU
(rocfrov rj Kat <ruyypa<pecoy rtywy. TroOev 8^ reKjaatpOjaeroy
\eyco; TrATjpes ira)?, w Sai/xozue, TO (rr^os e^ooy al(rOavop.ai.
irapa ravra av %x.l-v e^e^ erepa JUT) -^ipd).
ort /u,ey ovy
Trapd ye l/xavroi; o^Sey OVT&V ZvvevorjKa, eS ot8a,
e/uauTw apaOiav' AetTrerat 8^ otp:at e dA.Aorptcoi'
va^arfav 8ta rrjs aKOTjs TrCTrArjpwcr^ai /xe SIKTJZ; dyyetou.
WTTO 8e rco^et'as at) Kat avro TOUTO eTriAe'Arjo-jaat, oircas re
Kat &VTIVMV TjKOvcra.
<I>AI. 'AAA', S yeyyatoVare, KaAAtora etprj/cas. <rv yap
ep,ot &VTIVOOV fjikv Kat OTTCOS ^Kouo-as p,i)8' ay KeAevco e^7r?]y,
rouro 8e auro 6 Aeyets Trotrjcroy; ,rci)y ey TO> /3tj3Ai&> /3eXrtw
re Kat /XT/ eAarrco erepa -yTreo-^rjo-at etweiy rovrcay
jueroy, Kat o~ot eyoo, wo~7rep ot eyyea ap^ovTz
Xpvcrrjv etKoVa io-6/iieTpr)roy ety AeA(pov?
jixo'yoy e/xaurou dAAa Kat o-jjy.
212. 4>tAraros et Kat ws dArj^Ss xpuo-oSs, a>
et pie otet Aeyety ws Avcrta? rou Trayros ^/ndprr/Key, Kat
re 8^ irapa miyra raura dAAa etTrety rouro 8e o?/xat oi8'
ay Toy (fravAoraTov TraOelv cruyypa^ea. avriKa irepl ov
6 Ao'yoy, Ttya otet Aeyoyra ws XP^ W epSyri jixaAAoy ^
b 4 ^tTjSeV Sy Aldina: ^ij5ei/a B T (^>)5' fiv marg. t)
b 6 T' B :
76 T
iri8ftT0cu B : Jrei0eer0ai T
05 TTCOS] Trep Aldina
d 7 IVepa
\>"Ktff-)(_t\ffo.i scripsi: eVepa uTrJirxes Badham (seel. elireTi/): fTtpq. uirocr^e<rJ
B T : erepa eirixe^pf Schanz : alii alia
e 4 TT^I/TO raOra B : ravra
irdvra T : raDra G
e 6 rii/a B T : T'L vulg.

2356

^.v; '
?rapepra

TOV

^r^(: ,
(ppovipov eyKO)-

jj.V TO
, TOV oe ro a<f)pov ^eyetv, avayKala yovv OVTO,, etr' 236
aAA' arra eeu>. Aeyetr; dAA.' otp;ai ra jueu rotavra earea
KOI (ruyj'j'cooTea Aeyoyrr Kat TO>V pev ToiovTtav oil Trjv
ctAAa TTJV biaveviv (iraiveTeov, T&V 8e /U.T) drare Kat -)(a\fTT&v tvpelv Trpbs rrj Sta^ecret KOI T^I/ 5
<I>AI. 2uyxco/)5 o Aeyeis1 juterpwo? yap juot
/cei>ai. TroiT^frco odv /cat 4ya> oUrcoy ro /xe^ rov
TOV JUT) fpSivTos jaaAAof vocrelv 8oo<no (rot viroTiOecrOai., T&V b
8e XOITTWV erepa TrAetco KOI irAetWo?
aAa ^^ flirutv
rw^8e
siO*"-M t:!..v -,."T
;
,
.
,. ,
; , ~
[Autriou] irapa ro KvtyeXio&v avaO^a cr(j)Vp^\aTos
ev
1

ta 0-TCL0r)Tl.

a ^ai^pe, on (TOV T>V 7rat6Kwy

<7e, Kat otet 877 /xe a>9 dArj^coy eiritlireiv Trapa Trjv CKZIVOV cro<p(av i-Tepov rt TTOIKtAcorepoy;
.
, ^AI. Ile/)t p,er TOVTOV, S <^)tAf, ets ray , 6ju,otas Aa/3as
\ri\v0a$. p?jreoy ju,ei ycip crot Trarroy /xaAAoy ovrcoy OTTCOS
olos re eT, ?z/a ju,^ ro T>V Kcoj/wSwy <f>opTiKov
avaym^toiizOa TTOI&V dyraTroStSoWey dAA^Aoty [evA
Kat /XTJ jSovAou /x,e dyayxacrat Xtyfiv fKflvo ro " et tyc^, a>
2ci)Kparey, 2co/cpdr?7y dyyow, Kat eftavTOV eTriAeA?;o-ju,at," Kat on "eTre^v/xet /xey Xeyeiz^, fdpVTiTCTo Se1"
dAAa SiaroTy^Tjrt ort eyreu^ey OUK airtjuey Trpti' av crv enrTjs1
a <-(pr]cr0a ev T> <rr?7$ei Hx.iv"
e(rju,ev 8e juovco ev e/jrjjuta,
pos 8' eya> Kat vewrepoy, CK 8e aTrayrcoy TOVTU>V
o r o i Aeyw," Kat jmrj8a/u,ci)S Trpoy yS

ba etirel)j/T(j'5eTW : ejir^rrosB: tHi-ciir rcDf roC fecit t

l>3
Seclusi
b 4 (rra^Tt B T : ftrradi] Photius : la-raft Cobet
Ci
A.u6as T : iXfavQa. B
c 2 '/W B : 'tva Se T
03 dc
B : avayKa.C6fj.e6a. T
i>A.a^0?jTi seel. Cobet
C 7 SI
8ta.vo-fi0r)Te B
e 8 /uJi/w B W : ^t^w pev T
d 2 8 rot] 8 ffot
hoc loco BT (at cf. Menon. 76 d)
jS^ T: jSi'as B W

36d

riAAT&NO2

2H. 'AAA', 3> /maKapte <l>ai8pe, yeAoioj e<roju,at irap'

5 dyaflo
4>AI.
(TXe8oz> yap e^w o ei7ra>y ayayKaVco ere Aeyety.
2fi. Mrj8a/iws Toivvv etTrr/s.
4>AI. Ov/c, aAAa Kat 8^ Aeyw 6 Se /xot Aoyos
10 ecrrai. o^wyn -yap croirtya /xeVrot, rira OfStv; rj j3ovQ Aet r^y TrAaraz^o^ ravrrfvi; '^ /xijv, eay fiot yn^ efirTys ro/;
Aoyoy fvavTiov amrjs Tavrrjs, //.TjSeirore <rot erepoy Aoyoz;
21i. Ba/3al, S //.tape, ws ev avrjvpfs rqv avaynT]v
5 ^JiAoAoyw Trotery 6 ai
-^
4>AI. Tt S^raClx40
211. O^Sei' ert, eiretS^ o-v ye raura
yap az^ otos r' etr^y rotat/rrj? BoCvrj?
337
4>AI. Ae'ye ??.

avbpl

Tou Wpi; ,-< * --"

211. 'EyKaAu^a/xeyos1 epw, ?y' on
5 TOP Aoyoy Kat /x^ ^3Ae7rcoy Trpos <re VTT' alvxyvris 8ta7ropc3juat.
4>AI. Aeye povov, ra 8' aAAa OTTCOS /3ouAet /Trotet.
212. "Ayere 877, MoScrat, etre 8t' wS^s e!8os Atyetat,
etre 8ia yei^os H.OVVIK.OV TO Aiyvav ra"vrr]v eerier' f
fjiLav, "^vp juot AaySeo-^e" rou ^vdov, ov jue
10 6 /Se'ArioTos o^rocrt Aeyety, tV 6 frcupos avrov, Kat irporepoz;
b 8oK<Sy Tovrw Cronos e>ai, yCy en p-aAAov
ot;ra) 8^ Trats, /AaAAov e /xet/saKicrKo?, //,aAa /caAos*
8e ^(rai; epacrrat -jrdyu n'oAAot. ets 8e rts avr&v
e 3 /u^Serbs ^t^T6 T : ju)Sej/(fe T' B
e|o<y7\e?' G :
BT
a 7 A.i-yeai T : \iyiai B
a 8 ytvos rb A.vyii<av /j.ovffiKbv
Dionysius : yevos n povaiKbv Heraclitus : yevos fj.ovo'iKbv rb At7i> t>v
Stobaeus
evxer' fira>vvfj.ia,v B T Stobaeus : cohere
Dionysius, Heraclitus
b a ^eipaxiffKos B T :
vulg.

4>AIAPOS

237 b

r)V, os ovbfvos rfrrov epcov e-TreTreiKet TOV Tralba o>s

OVK fpfff],

KdC TTOre O.VTOV dLT&V (-TTflOeV

TOVT* O.VTO, COS ^~f]

ep&VTt. TTjOO TOV ep&vTos 8eoi ^api^a-dai, e'AeyeV re <S8e

ITept 7raz>ros, Tra?, /xta
/3oi>Aeuo-eo-$af etSerat 8et Trept ov av fj r/ /3oi>A.rj, ?) irazros C
a^apravfiv avdyKrj.
TOVS be TroAAovs XeXrjdfv
OTL OVK
l(racn Trjv ovcriav e/cacrrov. ws oSy etSo'res ow 8to/xoAoyot>z;rai
ro
OVT -yap favrois ovre dAAr^Aots opoXoyovcriv.
ey&) ow 5
Kat crv fj,r] Trddu>iJ.fv o aAAois e7nn/ji<3/u.ey, aAA' eTretS?) (rot
Kat ejucu 6 Aoyos Trpoxetrat Trorcpa l/acozm ^ //^ paXXov ets
<jbiAiaz> ireor, Trepi epcoros oro'y r' IOTI Kat ^y e)(et
juiy, 6/xoAoyia Qf^voi opov, ds TOVTO a7ro/3Ae7royres
avatyepovTzs Tr\v (TK^LV Trotwjue^a are
&(f)fXiav
(3Xd[3r]v Trap^ei.
OTL jj,\v ovv or] eTri^ujuia rts 6 ep<os,
orjXov OTL 8' aS Kat /xr) Ipwyres TTLdv^ov(TL T&V
, io-/u,ey. rai 8r) rw epStvTa re Kat JIXT) KpLVOvpev; 5
aS voijcraL OTL ^juwy If eKaora) 8r;o Tire eo-roy i8ea
KOL ayovTe, olv eTro^eda fj ar ay^roy, ^ /xey ejoiovo~a TTidvfj.ia r]8ov>v, aXXrj Se
TOV apicrTov. TOVTO) e ev ju,v ''rore /x' //,ofcrTL c<5e ore (rrao-td^eroi'' Kat rore juez> ^ ere'pa, e ;
aAAore 8e 77 erepa Kpareu i do^rjs fxer oSy eTTt ro aptcrroy ^'
Aoyo) ayovo~rjs Kat KpaTOvo">]s rw kparet (rco^poo'vyrj ovofAa.'
8e dAo'ya)? eAKOwrjs ITTI rjoovas Kat dpfao-r]? ei> 238
ojuao"^?]. v(3pLs be or]
TroAu/xeAe? yap. Kat TroAvjuepes Kat roi;ra)^ rcou
b 5 otVwi' T W Heraclitus : epwj' B
C I /SouAevo-eo-flai T : /8oi;Xe56(T0at B
Set B : & Set T
Travros B Simplicius : airavros T
C 4 Trpoe\66vTfs t : irpoffe\B6vTfs
BT
05 a\\-fj\ois B : SA.AOIS ex
a\\-fi\ois T
07 ir6repa. T: irJrepop (sed a s. v.) W: om. B
08 ofoV T'] oT^ TI ci. Heindorf
rX T: e^e B
d6 aS]
S); Schanz
d 8 rjSovwv T : SijA.oj' wv B
a 3 iroA.VjueA.6s
. . Kal iro\v/j.epes scripsi : iroAu/ieAes . . . Kal iroAueiSes B Stobaeus :
T : iroAueiSes . . . (ci iro\v/j.e\fs V

fj av r^X?? ysvopcvr], rr)z> avrrjs eirooi>u/iaai> ovoTOV expz>ra Trape^erat, ovre Tiva KarjV our
KfKTrjffOcu.
irepi juiez; yap fb<tibr)v Kparovcra TOV
Aoyou re TOV a/norou /cai T&V aAAa>i> firiOv^
b \ yacrrpi/utapyia re /cai roy c^ovTa TOVTOV TOVTO
erar irepi 8' av fitdas rvpavvfva-ao-a, TOV
ayov(ra, bfj\ov ov rev^ereu Trpocrp^aTO?' xat raAXa
87) ra TOVTOIV abeXtya KOL dSeA^w^ fTtidvfAi&v oro/xara r^s
5 del 8wa<rreuov<r?7s ^ Trpoo-Tj/cet KaA.et(r^at TrpobrjKov.
^s 8'
iraVTa ra Trp6cr6ev et/orjTat,
be TJ JUT) Ae)(0ei> Trayrcos o-a^eorepoi'' 17 yap
Aoyou 8o^rjj e?rt TO 6p6bv
C Trpos fjbovrjv ayOziva KaAAous, xat TJTTO aS rwi' eaur^? cruytirl cratfjidTcav KaAAos eppco/ixeya)? poocr^eto-a
dycoy?), air' aur^s r??s pw/xrjs firutw^Cav Xaftovcra,
epcos
5

'Arap, S </uAe 4>at8pe, 8o/cw ri o-ot, wo-Trep e/xaurw,

oy TTO^OS 7TTtov6fvai,;
4>AI. riayv //.ev oSi', S Sco/cpares, Trapa ro etco^os evpoia
ns o-e
212. 2iy^ Toivvv p.ov aKove. rw oyri yap 0eos
d 6 TOTTOS eTyat, coare ear apa TroAAaKis
TOV Aoyou yeV<o/Aai, ju,^ OavfJ-da-rjs' ra vuv yap OVKCTI Troppo)
4>AL 'AArj^eVrara Aeyeis.
a 4 eirovo/uLa(6fj.fVov Stobaeus
a 6 KeKrrj<rdcu B : /ceKX^trflat T
a 7 T T Stobaeus : om. B
b 5 ^ B T : & Stobaeus
b 7 Wrroij
Stobaeus Ven. 189: irac TTWS BT
b8 rb op0ij/ BT Dionysius
2
ad Cn. Pompeium : rayaffbv in marg. B Dionysius de Demosthene
C i oxfertra B T pr. loc. Dionysius Hermias : &yovcra, in marg. B2 alt.
loc. Dionysius forji a5 om. marg. B2 alt. loc. Dionysius
IOUT^J
B2 T Dionysius Stobaeus : eavrrj B
c 2 epp<a/j.ev<as B2 T Dionysius
Stobaeus : epd/jievos pr. B
fppca,u.ev(as . vtK-fjffaa'a seel. G. Hermann
C 3 aywyri B T : ajtay^i Dionysius
eirowvpiav B T pr. loc. Dionysius :
firidvfj.ia.v marg. b alt. loc. Dionysius

<t>AIAP02
2H. TovTotv fjifVTOL
UTCOS yap

crv atrtos.

Kttf aTTOrpaTTOtrO TO TTLOV.

dAAa ra Aonra aKove1 5

TaVTd

fJV

OVV

Oftf

r<S Aoya> treW.

Eley, a> (pep'tre-

o fj.V

br] Tvy\dvi

ov Trepl ov jSou-

e?/>rjrat re KCU wpicrrai, /SAeTroires 8e dr) Trpos avro

ra Aotira Aeyco/xey rt9 a/)eAia ^ (3Xa(3r)
y<;)
ap-^ofMV<f

airo re fp&vros

e etKoros cru//,j3?7(rerat.
bovXfvovrC

re fjbovf}

roi S^

avayK*} TTOV

TOV Ipw/xeyoy ws T\KTTOV eavrw TrapacrKeua^eti'1

VOCTOVVTI,

be iiav f/bv TO pr) avTiTetvov, /cpeirroy 8e /cai t(roi; fyOpov. 5

ovre 8^ Kpetrrco ovre iaov[jLvov e/ccbf epao-r^s iraibiKa 239
av^Tai, f]TTa> 8e xai vTroSeecrrepoy del airepya^erar ^'rrcoy
8e a^aBrfs

(ro<pov, 8eiAos avbpiov, a8waros eiTretr pr\To-

piKov, fipabvs ay\ivov,

TOCTOVTCOV KCIK&V Kat en TrAeioVfoy

Kara ri)y 8tayoiay epaaTrjv e/jcojuevw avayKr] yiyvofjitvaiv

re 5

Kal <j)V(TCL tvovTcov [T&V] juey rjbecrOai, ra 8e TrapacrKeufx^eti',

^ crre/oefr^at row TtapavTina

fjbtos.

(pOovepov

iroAAdiy /xey akX.a>v vvvovfri&v

br) dray/crj

aTreipyovTa Kat b

o^e^ ch> /xaAtcrr' dr^p ytyyotro, jueyaA?]? atrtoy

/3Ad/3rj?, /xeytVrrjj 8e rr;? o^ey ay (pport/xwraros e^rj.
roSro 8e ^ ^eta (pi\o<ro(pia Tvy^dvei ov, ^s epa<rr?)y TratSiKa
TToppcodev etpyety, Trept^o^or orra rou KaTCKppovr)ra

l Travra a7ro/3Ae7rcoi> eis rw epao-Trfv,

s, eaurw 8e ^3Aa/3epa>raros ay etr7.
eTTirpoTroy re mi KOt^coyos ovbajjy

olos (av r3 /x,ey

ra /uey ow Kara
AucrtreArjs ayr/p c

epcora.
T^y 8e row (rw/maros e'^ty re Kat depanreiav o'lav re Kat
&>s

re aAAa jwrj^amcr^at OTTCOS az' 77 Trai'ra dyz/owv

flepairewei

oS ay y4vt]Tai Kvpios, bs fjbii

irpb ayaOov

d 6 /cav B : &j/ T
63 Sov\f6ovTi B : ^ SouAeuocn T
e 5 /*}/
T : orn. B
as ^TTMJ/ B T : ^TTOJ/ V
a 6 ev6vT<ov T Stobaeus :
ec ovTtui/ B
TW BT Stobaeus: seel. Nutzhorn : TO?$ Heindorf
b 8 ewr T Stobaeus : T eaury B
&v V : om. B T

239 c

IIAAT&NOS

5 rjvayKarrTai 8icoKeu% Set ju,era raCra tSeiv. dtpflr/crerai 8?)

fjioXdaKOV TWO. Kat ov crrepeoy StWKWi', ovS' e# ^At<u
T0 pa.fj.fj.evov dAAa VTIO (rvfj.iJ.iyfl ovcia, TTOVWV fj.ev a
KOI i$pU>T(l)V

frpStV

CLTTflpOV,

fJ.TTLpOV

aTTaXfj

d bpov Stairrjs, dAAorptots ^pw/xaat Kat KOO'JUOIS' X^?761 oi/cetcoz;

KO<rfj.oviJLevov, oaa re aA.Aa rovrots eTrerai TtavTa l e-Trtrrj 8ew^ra,)a 8^Xa xat O^K a^toy Trepacrepco irpoftawfiv, dAAa
ev K(pd\ai.ov 6pi<Tafj.evovs CTT' aAAo ifvai- TO yap TOLOVTOV
5 crw/xa ly 7roAe)u,(i) re Kat aAAats -^pfiats ocrat jueya/Yat 01
joiey ~)(0pol dappovcrw, ol 8e ^tAot /cat avrot ot epacrrat
Touro fxey ow ws 8^Aoi' eareo^, ro 8'
C rtz^a Ty/u^ co^eAiW i) rti;a /SAajSrjr Trept rr)y KTTJCTLV rj TOV
epwiros ojixiAia re /cat eTTtrpOTreta irape^erat. (ra^)e? 8^
roCro ye mwrt pey, p,aAt(rra 8e rai epa<rrr/, ort rwz; </>tArarcoy re Kat evi>ou<rrarcox> Kat ^etorarcoi; KTrjuaTaiv 6p(pavov
5 Trpo Trayro? evcur' ay elvat rw pd>fj.vov Trarpoy yap Kai
jurjrpos Kat (ruyyei/wr Kat <piku>v crrepeo-^at ay avTov
240 StaKcoAura? Kai e7rtrijx,T]ras r/yovpevos
avrov ojutAtas. dAAa /u?)y overtax y'
aAAr;? Kr7j(rea)y ovre e'uaAcoroi' opioiws o#re dAoi^ra ei>p;era^yija-erat- e wy irao-a avdyKrj epacrrrji;
j,fv ovcriav KeKrrjpeVoi?, aTroX\vfJ.fvr]$ 8
ert Toivvv ayafjiov, aTratSa, aotKoy/ ort TrAettrroy \povov
7rat8t/ca epa(rrT)s ei!^atr' az> yevtaOai, TO avrov yXvKV ws
TrAelcrroi; \povov KapirovcrOai fTuOvfi&v.
"Eori /xei/ 8^ Kai aAAa KaKa, dAAa rts gatjuwy e^et^e rots
b -tfAetorois ey rai irapaurtKa rfiovriv, olov Ko'AaKt, Setyw Orfpitp
Kat y3Aa^3rj p^eyaAr;, optoj e7re'p;eiez; ^ Averts ^8oy?jy rtz^a OVK
c 5 /leri T : ,U6 B
S)? Hirschig : Se B T
d i K^IT/HUS B T :
trx^lf-affw Plutarchus
d 3 & S^\a b t : SSrjAa B T
d 4 ev
Ke^Aaioi/] 6j/ Kt<t>a\aicf) Ast
e 3 8e T : -ye B
65 etf|aiT'
T : ei/ler' B
e 6 juijTpbs /cal T Stobaeus : /xT/rpbs B
as d?ro\hvtJieviis B T : a7roA.Xv/*eVots vulg.
a 6 Sot/co^ T Stobaeus :
O?KOJ' B

240 b

ap.ov(rov, KaC rt? kraipav o>s /3Aa/3epoi> \/fe'etez> av, Kal aAAa
TToXXa T&V ToiovTOTpoTtcov Ope^fjLaTcov re Kai eTrmjSet^anoi',
^ ots ro ye Ka0' ^epau ^(.CTTOKTIV elvai VTrdpxei' TratSiKot? 8e
epaaTrjs irpbs ra> /3Aa/3epa) Kat et? ro crvvrifj.epViv irdvTwv
drjSecrraroy. rjXiKa -yap 8r) Kai 6 iraAatos Aoyos repirety roy
f]XiKar] -yap olpai yjpovov Icror-qs ITT' tcras 7/8oz;a9 $youo-a
ra (friXiav Trape^eratdAA' o/xcos KOpoy ye Kat ^
crvvovcria e^ei. Kat ju^y ro ye di/aykatoy au /3apv
Trepi TTO.V Aeyeraf 6 8^ irpo? r?j dyo/xdtorrjrt //dAicrra
7rai8iKa e^et. yewre'pw yap 7rpeo-/3vrepos
oi!0' ^/xepas ovre VVKTOS CKWV O.TTO Aether at, dAA' VTT'
re Kai ola-rpov eAavrerai, 6s fKeiixa p.ev fjbovas del
81801;? ayei, 6pG>VTi, OLK.OVOVTI, aTrrop.ei'w, KOI 7rao-az> aicrOricfiv
TOV ep(a[j.vov, coo~re /^ie^' fibovfjs dpaporcos avroi
f rw 8e 8r) epoo/xeyw Trotop Trapa^vdiov 17 rtVay
fibovas 8t8ovs TrotTycret roy icrov ^povov crvvovra jj.rj ov^l ITT'
' arjbiasop&vri fj.V o^nv Trpeo-fivTfpav Kal
v &pa, TTO[j,eva>v 8e rwy aAAcoi^ ravrr/, a Kat Ao'ya)
aKovfiv OVK eTTirepWs, p-r^ on 8^ epyw dmyKrjs del
TrpocrKetjueyTjs jueraxetptfeo~^at, (pvXaKas re 8^ Ka^UTroroTrors
<pvXaTTOfjiv<f
8ta TTCLVTOS Kat Trpo? aTraz^raj, aKatpous re
firaCvovs Kal vTrep/3dXXovTa$ CIKOVOVTI., ws 8' a^rcos i/^oyovs
vrffpovros fj-fv OVK avfKTovs, els 8e fjifOrfV Idvros irpos rai
p-rj dyeKroi eTraio-^ers, TTapprj<rCq KaraKope? Kat
Kat epwv //.ez/ ^Aa/3epo? re Kat drfSr/?, Ary^a? 8e roS
epcoros et? roy euetra ^povov a-Trtcrro?, ety or iroAAa Kal
/xera TroXX&v opKcov re Kat 8e?7crea)y
b 5 f)$iffToiffu>
B : ^SiVrojs T Stobaeus
c i 5^ Stobaeus
Aristaenetus : om. B T
repireiv B ex emend. T : repirfi T
C 7 I/civ airoXeiTreToi B : a7ro\enr6TH J/ccoi' T
d 5 SiSoiiy T : aiSoDs
B : StatSoG? W
e 2 <f>tiAa/cas T : (f>v\a.Ka.s B
/caxwroT^Trous T :
/caxfT^i TATTOOS B : (ca%UTr(i7rTOi's vulg.
e 3 axaipovs re eiraivovs T :
aicaipovs re Kal eiraivovs B : eiraij/oi/s re /cal aitaipovs \V
e 5 vijtpovros
T: vtyovTes B
e6 eTraio-^ers ci. Heindorf : eir' afo-^ej BT
PLATO, VOL. n.
16

5
c

DAATONOS
241 Karei^e rj\v y' kv rw ro're crvvovcriav fTrCnovov ovcrav <e'peti;
81' eA7ri8a ayaOStv. ro're ?) SeW eKTivfiv, juera/3aAa)y aAAov
apxovTa ey ai5rw Kat TrpoordrTjy, row Kat (raxppocrvvrjv O.VT*
epcoros Kai jua^tas, aAAos yeyo^cb? AeA?]^ey ra TratStKa. Kai
5 6 /xei> OVTOV yjipiv aTratreZ rail' rore, VTro/xt/iyryo'Kooy ra
Kai Aex#eVra, ws rw o^ww SiaAeyo'/xezw 6 Se VTT'
ovre etTrer^ roAjwa ort aAAo? ytyovev, ovO* OTTCOS ra
r??? Trporepa? dpo^roi; dp^s 6pKft)//,oo-td re Kat V7roo-)(e(reis
"
b ljn7re8a)O'rj e}(ei, vow ^817 IO-V^TJKO)? Kai (T(T(i)(ppovrjKU>s, tva
JJ.TI Trpdrrcoy ravra rai irpoa-Ozv ofj.ot.6s re eKetra) Kai 6 airos
yey]rat. <pvyas 8^ ytyyerat eK rovrwi', Kai direVTT' dydyKr]? 6 Trpty epao-r?7s, oVrpaKOU /xeraterat (pvyi) /xera/SaAwy 6 8e dyay(cd{erat 8t<oKet^
Kai e7ri$ea(/wzY ^y^orjKcos TO aTray e^ apyj/s, ort
OVK apa e8et Trore ep&izrrt Kat VTT' dmyKrjs dyo?jra) y^api^eo'^ai,
C dAAa TToAi juaAAoi> fx^ epaiyrt Kai vow e^oyrt- et 8e /XT],
et?] evSoiiyat avrov ctTrtcrrw, 8uo"Ko'Aa), (fiOovepto,
ovcriav, /SAa^Sepu 8e vrpos rr)v
)e /3Aa/3epcordra) Trpos rr)y rr^s
7rat8euo~iy, r^s ovre avdptiairois ovre deois TT) aXrjOfia)
rt/txtwrepoy ovre eo-rty ovre Trore lo-rai. raurd re ow XP7?*
a) Tra^, crvvvotiv, Kai etSe^at rr)y epao"rou cptAiay on o{i /xer
evvotas yiyi>erai, dAAa o-trtou Tpoirov, \dpiv
ws AvKOt apvas ayaTr&cnv, ^s TraiSa qbtAoiSo-tz; epao-rat.
Tour' fKflvo, ) <l>at8pe. OVKCT' a^ ro Trepa aKovo-ais e
Aeyoyro?, dAA' r^87] o-ot reAosi IXCTCO 6 Aoyos.
a I -y' T : om. B
o5(ra' T : om. B
a 2 fK-rlveiv B : eVreivetv pr. T: ^Kreivfi G
p.eTa$a\i>)v B T : neTa\af3ii>v corr. Coisl.
a 7 on T : ofrr' et B
b i e^ire5coirj? B T W : 6>7re8ci(ret vulg.
b 3 aTreiTTcpijK&s B T : aireipriK&s corr. Coisl. : aTreffTvyjjKeijj G. Hermann
b 5 SiiS/cei*' T : Stdbiccav B
C 2 Sutr/cdAij) QOovepQ seel.
Spengel
04 TOU BT Stobaeus: om. vulg.
d i #/>i/as
<
r
u.yaTraio'jj' BT : &pj/a ^)i\oS(r' vulg. : o?y' d y' w(rji' schol. Hermogenis :
fy>i/' ayoirwo-' Bekker
d 3 aAX' ^STJ B : oA.Aa S^ T
T\OS B T:
irepas vulg.

<f>AI. Katroi wjurjy ye yuecroCz; avrov, KOL eptlv ra "UTO.

TOV p.?) epawro?, cos 8e? e/ceiVw yjapie<rQai fwXXov,
o<ra au e^et dya#df
SI2. OVK ycrdov, u> [MKapLf,

z^w 8e 77, 3> ScoKpares, ri

OTL 17877 777; <0eyyo/xai dAA.' 6

ov/ceri bi6vpdiJ,(3ovs, KCU ravra \jseyMv;

ear 8' eTraivelv TOV

erepov ap^cojuat, rt /xe oTei Tro^crfiv;

ap'

oZcr^' ort 7;7ro

rwy Nu/x^wy, ats //,e <TTJ TrpovfiaXes IK TrpovoCas, aa(p)S

evOovcnacrM ; Aeyco oSy e^i Aoyw ort oo-a TOV erepoy AeAot- 5
bopriKafJiev, T> ere/aw Tavavria TOVTOJV ayaOa TrpoVeorty.
ri 8e? [jiaKpov

Xoyov;

Kal ovTO) $r] 6 JJ.V00S

irepl yap

afj.(j)olv

iKavats

6Vt Trdcr^etz' Trpoa"riKL

Kat

etpTjrai.

awrco, rovro

TreiVerat- Kaycb roy Trora/xor TOVTOV 8ia(3a$ aTre/a^o/xat Trpw

VTTO crow rt fj,eiov
<f>AI.

242

avayKao-Gfjvai.

M?77rco ye, S SwKpares, rrplv av TO Kavjj,a

7^ ov% opa? cos o~%ebbv 7)877 /^eo^/x/Spt'a tWarat 77 ST)

crra^epd; dAAa Trept/^eu/ayres Kat a/xa irept rwf flprnj,tvo)v
Vres, rd^a eiretSay aTfo^rv^i]

fyev.

@etds y' et irept rows Adyou?, S <I>at8pe, Kat drex^ws

otjaat yap eyco r<3i> eTTi ro?j croC yStou yeyo^drwy
a -jrAeioD? 7^ <re TreTrotTjKeVat

yeyevf)<r6ai

avTov Aeyoyra r/ aAAous e^t ye rw rpoVw

Siju/uay r]j3aiov e^atpw Adyou- rcSz; 8e dAAcor
Kparet?' Kat pCy aS SoKets atrtd? /xot yeyevrjcrOai Adyw rt^t
prjdfjvat..
<I>AI. Ow irdAeju.di' ye ayyeAAeis.
rovrw;

dAAa TTWS 87) Kat rtVt

d 4 -ye /Afffovv avrov V : -ye fj-effovv avTov B T : <re /meffovv UVTOV Hermann
d.6 Ae'yojv B T : \fyovra Stephanus : \eyovd' Schanz
6 5 evdovo-idirca T : fj/9vffidff(a
B
a 4 ^ S); t Suidas : ^817 B T
^ 8)j . . . ffTa8epd seel. Ruhnken
a 6 diro^t/x^tyuei' (sic) B:
airo^v|?; Icafiev T : avoi^v^r) airi/j.ev Phrynichus
Ibi AoycoyT: om. B\AT
veiron)Kva,i B t : ireirovriKfvai pr. T
-ye-yev^erflai] yeveffdai H. Richards
b 2 rip B T : om. vulg.
b 3 ef ctipw Heindorf : e|aipo> B T
AJ-you
B T : TOV A(fyoi W
b 4 <y7e>'7J<r0ai] 7j/ii)crecr0at Badham

2426

HAATilNOS
212.
8ai/mo'zndV Te /cat TO euotfo? o-Tj/xetoV p-ot yiyye(r0ai e

C dei

8e

j^e

em<rxei 6

av /aeAAco irpaTTfiv (cat

<fyu>VT]v e8oa avToOev dfcovcrai, r\ /^e ov/c la d'TneVat 7rpti> ai;

d(pocricdo-a)p;ai, cos 877 u ^jaaprrjKora eis TO 0eu)i;.

etjut 8r)

ovv /AayTts /x,er, ov Trai^i; 8e (TTrouSaios, dAA' utcnrfp

5 ypd/i/xaTa tyavXoi, cxrov juey eju,auTa) ^JLOVOV IKCIVOS'
ovi' ?/8?] ^avOavat TO a^idpTij/xa.
ye Tt /cat 77 \frvyjl'

ff*f

oi TO,
cra^ais

ws 877 TOI, & kraipt,

yP edpa^e ^iv n /cat

Aeyorra Toy Aoyov, Kat TTCOS ISutrcoiTo^jurjy KaT'"I/3uKOz>,

/XT] TI Trap a ^eois
d

djujSAa/ccby TL^av irpbs avdpdirdov dfien//a>'

I'W 8' Tjcr07jjU,ai TO djixd/)T7]/j(,a.
$AI. Aeyets 8e 8^ TI;
212.

Aet^w, a 4>arpe, Setyof Ao'yov a^Tos TC eKo,uio-as

5 e/xe Te Tj^fiyKacras etTreiy.

4>AI. Rws 877;
212. EI/TJ^TJ /cat ^Tro Tt acrepfj'

ov Tts av etr;

4>AI. Oi>8as, et ye crv ahyOij Ae'yeis.

212. Ttovy; TwvEpcoTa oii/c'A^)po8tT7j? Kat
10

<I>AI. AeyeTai ye 877.

212. Ov Tt VTTO ye ATJCTIOU, ov8e VTTO TOV (TOV Aoyou, 6s

8ia TO?J [JLOV crrofjiaTos KaTa<pap[j.aK.vOVTos VTTO crov

ei 8' eariy, cocrTrep ovv eo-Ti, ^eos r/ TI detov 6 "Epco?,
ay KCLKOV fir], TOO 8e Aoyco TO) rwS^ irept avTov etTreTTjy ws
TOiovTou OTTOS' TavTrj Te ovv fjnapTavcTriv

irepl ToyvEpa)Ta,

5 ITI Te 77 evTj^eta aiiToiv TTO.VV do-Teta, TO ^Sey vyies

b 9 re /cal B T : del. ci. Schanz : /*oi ol V (om. mox juoi) : /cal Proclus
T& B T Proclus : om. al.
c i del ... n-p^Treii' seel. Heindorf,
at legit Proclus
& B T : & Proclus
c 3 8^? Proclus : om. B T
C 5 juev B : om. T
iica.v6s T : i/ccti/wy B
c 6 &s S-^ rot 5 T W :
2
ws 8e iroica B W (e et TT s.v.)
d i afjL/3\a.it(av B: oirAaKSc T
ri^ioo' T : rifnav B
d 7 o5 TIS T : ot; TIS B : ou rt (et mox SeivoTepov)
Proclus
d n ov TI. T: on B : ourot Heindorf
63 ri S^ Aityw
TCI> T : rip 5^ A^-yy TIJ? B
65 ert re T : eZre B

3433
aXrjOes crf^vvvecrOai, <l>y rt OVTC, ei apa dz^pomo-KOuy
ea7rar??o-ai>re tvboK.wrjcrtTov kv O.VTOLS. ep:ot p.ev ovv,
<pi\, KadrjpacrOai. avdyKrf eorty e rots a/j.apTavovo-1 irepl
Ka6apiJ,bs ap%ctios, bv "Opiijpoy fjikv OVK
8e. T&V yap d^/xdrcoy crrfpridels 8ta rrjv
OVK fiyvorjcrev axnrep f'Qp,r]pos, aAA' are
v alriav, KCU iroiti ev6vs
OVK ear' eTvp.os A.oyo? OVTOS,
0^8' e^3as ey vyvulv evo-eA/xoty,
0^5' I'Keo ITepya/xa Tpota?'

243

Kat TTOtT^cras 5^ Tracrav rrjv Ka\ov[j,vr]V HaXivatbiav irapaXPVlJ'a avf(3\\lsV.

eya) oSy (ro^wrepoy tutivutv ye^crojuat
Kar' avro ye roCro- Trpiz^ yap ri TraOtlv 8ta rryy rou^Epcoroy
Treipacrofjiai. am> aTrobovvai TTJV itaXivabiav, 5
T|J Kf(pakfj
Koi ov% ticnrtp rore VTT
. Toiirtort, a) Sco/cparey, O^K f-ariv arr' &z^ e/xot ei
212. Kat yap, wya^e Qatftpe, two^s ws dyatSws elprfa-Oov c
rob Aoyco, ovroy re /cat 6 e/c rou j3t/3Atov prj^ets.
et yap
anovaiv ris rvxi ?ilJ>&v ytvvabas Kat npqos TO tfdos, Irepou
8e rotovrou epwy ^ /cat Trpo'repo'y irore epacrflety, Xeyoyrcoz;
ws 8ta o-jutKpa /ueydAay e^^pay ot epaorat avaipovvrai /cat 5
e^oucrt Trpoy ra TraiStKa (frOovep&s re Kat /QAa/3epwy, 7r<Sy OVK
av otet avrbv r/yflcrdai aKOvav kv vavraLS irov re0pap;juei>a)i>
Kat oiibfva eXevOfpov epcora IcopaKortoy, TroAAou 8' ay Set!'
6//,oAoyeii' a i/^eyo/xer roy "Epcora;
d
4>AI. "Io-&jy z;?) Ai", a) 2wKparey.
2H. ToSro'y ye roivvv lycoye ato"xv^o/iieyoy, /cat avroz>
"Epcora 8e8tcoy, Tn0vfj.S> Trortjuw Aoyw olov
a i ^wjSe T : yu^T B
a 7 iroie?] eVoi'ft H. Richards
a 9 ou8'
e^os T : oii5 )8^s B
b 6 rfj T : om. B
C 2 rcb \<fyeo T : rf
Kdycp B
07 redpafjLfifvwv corn Oisl. : Tedpaftpfvov B T

243d

DAATflNOS

5 a.Kor]V aTTOK.Avcracr0aLm crvfj-^ovXevut 8e Kal ADO- to, on

ws x.pr) epao-rr) /u,aAAoz> ?) /x?) tp&vri e/c r<3
. 'AAA' eS la-fli on e'ei ro$' ovra)* crou yap enroVros
roy row epaaroi) Ziraivov, Tracra dfay/crj Avcrtai> vir' e/xoi;
6 avayKacrOfjvai ypa^at au Trept roS awou Xo'yoy.
2H. ToCro /^.ey Trtfrrewco, e'coo"7rep ay TJS 6s eu
<I>AI. Aeye TOIVVV dapp&v,
2ii. IIoi) 77 />tot 6 Trais TT/SOS oi; eA.eyoy; IVa Kai TOUTO
5 aKovvrj, KCU p
4>AI. Oi/ros Trapa <roi fxaAa TrXr^criov aet Ttapeanv, orav

SH. Ovraxri TOIVVV, u> TTOL KaXf, fvv6r](rov, a>s 6 jaev

Trpo'repos 771; Ao'yos 4>ai8pou row ITti^oKAeous, MvppiyoD(rioi)
avbpos" ov 6e jueAAco Aeye6Z>, Srrycrt^o'poi) roC Ev^>7]/^iou,
'1/x.epatot;. Ae/creo? 8e <SSe, ort OI/K ear' er^jaos Aoyos 6s az;
,. TrapovTos IpaoroC rw /X,T) epaiz/ri p,aAAoy ^)rj Sew yapi&vOai,
5 8tort 8r) 6 //,ef ^atVerai, 6 8e crtixppovtu
et /xey yap ^r
TO uaviav KO.KOV flvai, KaX&s &v eAeyero* rw 8e ra
J. 5
/
v
/
i-A" /* ^"
r<Sz^ ayaO&v r^iiv yty^erai 8ta pavias, Ofia /xez/rot
8oo-et StSo/xe^Tjs. r/' re yap 8?) ez> AeA^o^s Trpocp^ns a? r' Iv
b AcoSwyrj lepetai \j.avelcrai pJev TroAAa 8^ Kat KaAa t8ia re xai
drjjuocrta TTJJ' 'EAAaSa rjpydcravTo, craxfypovovcrai. 8e f3pa^a r]
ovbev* Kal kav ST) Aeycojmey 2t/3vAAa^ re KOI aAAovs, oo~ot
fAavTUcfj )(pwju,eyo6 eyfle'o) TroAAa Srj TIO\\OLS ^poAeyoires ets
5 ro /xeAAoy wp^cocray, pjKWotjaei' ay 8?}Aa irayrt Ae'yoi'res.
rode /xr)i> a^toy e7np,apr-upacr6at, ort Kal rwy TraAatwy ol ra

244

d.8 oSra)' <roD Schanz : of/rois VroS t : OUT&JS ou B T

64 TOI/TO
B : TOVTOV T
6 7 ircipa Cobet (seel, mox TrapecrTic)
a 3 \eKTfOS
T"W: om. B A.o-yos B : <5 \6yos T
a 8 -ycip S^ T : -yo;p * * B : -ya/>
Aristides
ij 4 ej/flep T : eV 0eots B
b 5 &p6<affa,v Ven. 189
corr. V Aristides : opflis B T

6v6fj.aTa Ti6ffj.VOL OVK alcr\pbv fjyovvTo ovbe oveibos paviav

ov yap av rrj KaAAtcrr?? rtyvy], J? TO jaeAAoy Kpiyerat, avrb c
TOVTO TOVVOfJ-a

(J.T7\KOVTS

{JiaVlKTJV

Ka\(TaV.

dAA' COS

KCL\OV OVTOS, orav 0eta jumpa yiyvrjrai, OVTU> vojj,icravTs

ol be vvv aTreipoKaAtos' TO rav e7re/>i/3aAAoi>res
eKtiAecrai'. eiret at TTJI; ye raw fj.^>p6v(tiv, 5
(rjTrjcnv TOV //.eAAorros 8ta re opviOaiv Troiou/xeywy xat
aAAcoy crri^fiatv, ar' ex 8taz;oias 7TopL^ojj.fV(av
olrjcra vovv re /cat icrropiav, olovo'io-riKrjv
TJV VVV oldOV KTTlKrjV

T> 0) <TfUrVVOVTS

OL VZOl

KoXoVfTlV

o(r&) 8?) ovy T\fu>Tepov Koi fVTLfJ.oTpov [Aav

TO Tf oro/xa roO oyo/xaros tpyov r' epyou, rocra)
p,apTvpov(riv ol iraAatol fjiavCav crco^poo'WTjs' TT)Z; e/c ^eov 7775
irap' avOptoTHav yiyro/xeVrjs. dAAa ^V vowv ye KOI TTOVWV
r3y /zeyurrcoy, a 5r) TraAatwy IK /ixTjjnjuicmoi; Tro^ev ei^ Trt
rwy ytv&v % jua^ta eyyeyo/xe^Tj Kat TTjOo^rjrevcrao-a, ots e5et
dTraAAayrjy yijpeTo, KaTcufrvyovcra Trpbs 6f&v ev^ds re Kai
Aarpetas, o^ey 8r) KaOapfj.>v re Kat reAerwy ru^oiScra e^avrrj
eTTotrjo-e roj; [eaur?)s] e^oira Trpd? re roi> TiapovTa KOI TOV
eVetra \povov, Xvariv rw op^w? /uayeVri re Kat Karao-^o/xeya)
rwy TtapovTMV KCIK&V fvpo^vt].
rptrrj 8e airo Moua-fii'
KaroKco)(ij re Kat //.aiaa, \aj3ovcra aTraA^y Kat a/3aroi> \ffv^v,
eyeipoixra <cat eK/SaKX^oucra Kara re wSa? Kat Kara r?)z>
Tfoir](riv, nvpia rvtv TraXai&v epya Koo-^owcra roi)s
iraiSei/er 6s 8' &v ayeu fiainas Mov<ro)y eTrt
Ovpas atytKriTai, TrticrOels cos apa e*
C 4 irefJL/3a\6vTes Aristides
C 6 voiov^evuv seel. Schanz :
iroiovtifvyv Stephanus
C 7 iropt^b/xej/wi'] iropio/j.fvriv Stephanus
avQpwirivri ol-fi<rei pr. B Aristides : avOpwirivriv ol-f)<rei corr. b (Vo^crei
voluit) : avOpuirivy vorjvei T
C 8 olovo'CffriK^v W Aristides : oltaviOTIK^V B : ofoj' vo'drriK^v T
d 5 76 B T : re Aristides
d 7 ytvcov,
ri B T : <ycvwv ^v Hermann
e a 8r; T : om. B
63 eairrfjs
fXovra B T : aurV CXOJ/TO Aristides : eaurijs seclusi (glossema |w
STTJS fuisse suspicor)
a a KOLTOKCOX^ W : KOTOJKWX^ ^ : KaroKtox^j
T : Karoxfl vulg.
a 6 voiriTiKas B T Aristides Stobaeus (poeticas
Seneca) : Trotr/Tt/cijs Proclus Synesius : seel. Cobet
ireio-fleh B T
Stobaeus : seel. Cobet
&s Spa B T : Spa ws Stobaeus

245

?45 a

IIAATflNOS

TTOirjTTjs e(ro/*ez>o?, dreAr)? avros re Kat 77 Truirja-is VTTO

r<Si> /xacz/ojuei>coy fj TOV (ruxppovovvTOs rj^avCa'Orj.
b
Too-avra /xeV crot Kat In TrAeuo f\(o /xaznas
airb 6e&v Aeyeiy KaAa epya. coore roiiro ye avrb /AT) </>o/3co/ue0a, |u,?]8e riy T/jutas Aoyos 0opu/3etr<o 6e8irroju,>os ws Trpo
Toi5 KKivr]iJ.evov TOV (Ttlxfrpova 8ei Trpoatpetcr^at <f)ikov aXAa
5 ro5e irpos eKe6vo) Setas <pfpcr6a> ra
ia 6 epcos r<5 epwz/Ti Kat rw epco/xeyw IK
roeiKre'oi> av rovvavriov, <w
C Trapa 0e<3z> ^ rotawrrj jj-avCa StSorat- ^ 8e 8^ a7ro8eit? eorat
Seiuots ju,ey ^TTIOTOS, (ro^o'is 8e ^KTTTJ. 8et ovv irp&rov tyv\r)s
(f)V<rea)$ vrept betas' re Kat av6p(*)TTwr]s Ibovra -nadr] re Kat
a0ai>aros. ro yap detKtvrjroy d^ayaroy ro
8' aAAo Ktvouz/ Kat VTr' aAAou KIVOV^VOV, irav^av *XOV
Kivrj&euis, Trav\.av fXeL C%' p-ovov by TO avTo KLVOVV, are
OVK duoAerTToy eavro, ovTrore A?7yei Kivovfjifvov, dAAa Kai
rot's aAAots ocra KtyeZrat roiJro 77777?) KOI ap^r]
dyeVrjrozJ. e^ dpx^s yap drayK?7 Tray ro
avrrjv be ^778' e^ l^o's' et yap CK rou
ytyvotro, OVK ay crt dpx?) ytyyotro. eireiSr) 8e
<TTLV, Kat abidtydopov O.VTO avayKrj flvai.
dpx^s1 yap
5 diroAo/xevrj? oi/re avr?7 Trore e/c rou ovre aAAo e
etuep e dpx^s 8el ra Trarra yiyvfcrOaL.
OVTU>
fj.ev dpx^ ro avro awo KLVOVV. TOVTO 8e ovr'
ovre yiyvecrOat. bvvaTov, rj iravra re ovpavbv
e Ttacrdv re yr^f ets 1^ o-D/x,7re(ro{5(ray crrT/yai Kat /UTjTrore
Kivr;^eWa yez^orerat. d^aydrou' 8e Trecpatr
b i [iev ffoi T Aristides: jmevroi B
b 6 6 om. V Stobaeus
d 3 Irt
apx^) Buttmann (et sic ut videtur lamblichus : cf. Timaeum Locrum ap.
:
Theodoretum et yap eyevfro, OVK kv fy en apx) fyxh Vind. 89 Cicero
(ut videtur) : e'J apx*?s ^ T Simplicius Stobaeus
d 4 a5id<t>0opov T
Proclus : a.5id<t>opov B : &<p6opov Stobaeus
e i 77}*' 's ev Philoponus :
yevetriv B T Hermias Syrianus Stobaeus : yrjv in marg. t
62 txeiv
Stobaeus : exfw ffrrjuai B T tie T Alexander Stobaeus : om. B

<I>AIAP02

2451

TOV v(f>' kavrov Kivov[j.evov, ifrvxrjs ovo~iav re /cat \6yov

TOVTOV avrdv TLS Ae'ycoy OVK atcr^Dz/etrai. irav yap crS>fj.a,
& jj-ev eco0ey TO KivficrOai, a\j/v^ov, (2 b'e ZvooOfv avrS> 5
ef avrov, ffj,\l/v\ov, a>s ravrrjs oixrrjs (^vcrecos ^t>x*?s' "^e'
6' (TTLV TOVTO ovTuis tXv, /XT) aAAo rt e^at ro avro tavTo
xivovv r] "tyvyjiv, e aydy/crjs ay^vr\r6v re xat addvarov ^fX^) 246
ay et?;.
riept /xey oSv adavaartas avrrjs iK.avG>s- Trept 8e r^s t8eas
avrijs c58e AeKreoz/. oroy /xeV eon, Travrp iravrats Betas
flvai Kal (JLdKpas Strjyjjo-ewy, w 8e ZoiKev, avdpcoTrivrjs re 5
/cat eAarrcwos- ravTrj ovv Aeya)jue^.
eotKerco TJ (ru/x^)vra)
viroKTzpov (evyovs re /cat rjvio^ov.
0tS>v p,V ovv ~
re Kat f)vio\oi Trtirres amoi re aya^ot /cat e aya6S>v,
TO Se raw aAAcor /xe'/xet/crat. /cat irp&Tov IACV fm&v 6 apyatv b
avvutpibos 7]VLo\i, flra TU>V LTriroav 6 i^v avrw KaAo's re /ecu
dya^os xat e/c TOLOVTOQV, 6 8' e kvQ.VTiu>v re /cat ez>ai>rtos"
XaAeTT?) 8?) /cat Sva-KoAo? e^ dyay/c?js 77 7re/3i ^/xas f)vi6\r]crLS,
irfi brj ovv 6vrjTov re Kat adavarov ^<Soy e/cA^rj Tretpare'oy 5
eiTretr. ^^x^ Taa-a iravTos eTrt/jieAetrat roC a^rv^pv, Tiavra 8e
ovpavbv Tre/anroAer, aAAor' ez> aAAots et8eo-t yiyvo^vr], reAea
/xey oSy owo-a Kat eTrrepco/xei'?; juerecopOTrope? re Kat TtavTa C
rov Kocr/xoy StotKet1, ^ 8e TTTepoppvrjcracra <^e'perai e'cos ay
orepeoi) rtz^o? dyrtAd/37jrat, ov KarotKtcr^et(ra, (r<3/xa yrjivov
Xa{3ovcra, aiiTo avrb SOKOVV Kivelv 8ta r^r eKet^jj? ovvafjuv,
<3oi> ro crv^Trav K\ri6r\, ^rvyj] /cat <r<2^a irayev, 6vr}Tov r' 5
ovv^iav aOavarov 8e o{i6' e^ |vos Aoyou AeAoyt, dAAa TrAdrro/xe^ ovre t'8wre9 ovre Uayoos vorj<ravTs
a 6 eoj/cTw 8^; 7p. t Hermias Stobaeus : eoi/ce T^) Si) T : eoi/ce rip S^
B : oi6 8^ ry V : eot/c? S-J) T^ vulg.
a 8 Tr^VTes- auroi T T : ai
vdvTfs avTol B
b 2 ewT<j3 B T : avToiv al.
b 5 re T : om. B
b 6 if i/x^ 5rS(To Simplicius : iraffa ^ 'I'ux^ B : ^ ^ux^ Taerct T : tyvx)] y&p
vacra. Eusebius
b 7 ovpavbv BT : &v0ptairov V : ouv Herwerden :
seel. Badham
C i o3j/ T : om. B
/j.eTewpoirohe'i Syrianus
irai'Ta B : airavra. T
07 TrXarroyuev Proclus corn V : irhaTrofitvov
BT
oi/re t'S^res T : O#T' et'SJres B Proclus

246 d

IIAAT&N02

d deov, aOavarov n (>ov, e^ov pev \l/v\^v, %xv ^e ^cSjua, TOD

dei be yjpovov raCra av^TrefpVKOTa.
dAAa ravra fj.ev 877,
01:77 T(5 0ea> (ptAoy, ravrrj ex.erco re /ecu Aeyecrflco' rr?y 8e
alriav rrjs rwy Trrepajy airo/SoA^s, 8t' 771; \^u^?)s airoppel,
ecrrt 8e rts roia8e.
77 TtTtpov bvvaiALS TO efjL^pi0s ayeiv av(a juere17 ro rwy 0ewy yeyo? otxei, KfKoiv(avrjK
8e TTT/
/xaA.t(rra rwy 7iep6 ro vSt^a. TOV dttov [^fv^ri}, TO be 6elov
KaAor, (ro(f>6v, ayaQov, K.OL TTO.V OTL TOLOVTOV TOVTOLS 8r)
Tpl<peTai re /cod av^erat /xdAto-ra ye TO rrjs \lsv\rjs Trrepco/na,
alcr^pia be KOL KaKw Kat ro?s evavTLOis (frOivei re Kal Sto'AAurat. 6 /uer 8?) /xeyas Tjyejtxcbv ly ovpavti Ztvs,
ap/xa, Trpwros Tropeverai, otaKO<r//,<2y Trd^ra
eroy r<o 8' eTrerat orparta ^ewy re Kftl
'\ 247 /cara evbeKa p-ept] KfKO<r^r]p:evri.
pvei yap 'Eori'a
otKO) fjiovr)' T&V 8e aAAa)y oo~ot ez> rai
reray/jteVoi ^eot ap^oyres r;yowrat Kara rdiz>
erd)(^?7, TioAAat juey ow /cat p;aKapta6 0eat re
5 ez^ro? ovpavov, as ^ewy yero? ei}ai\i,6v(*>v
Trpdrrcov eKaoros avrcoy ro avroS, eVerat 8e 6 dei e0eAcoz>
re Kal Suyd/xeyos' fydovos yap eco ^etou xPv Ararat.
oray 8e 8?) -rrpos 8aira Kat em Ooivr/v taxnv, attpav ITU rrjz;
b VTTOvpa.vi.ov aijs'iba TTOpevovTdi, irpos avavTes, 17 87^ ra /j,er ^ewz^
oTTMS eirr\via OVTO. pa8ta>s Tropeverai, ra 8e
/xdyts* (Spidei, yap 6 TTJ? KaKTjs ITTTTOS /xerex^wy, em
rr)y y?7y pe-natv re Kat fiapvvaiv & jar^ KaAw?
5 raiy r\vi6yj>v.
ev6a by TTOVOS re Kat d
d.8 |/vx^ BT : om.
Plutarchus
6 2 at^Tat B T : ^pSerat Proclus
fnd.\iffr<i ye b :
/laAtorci re B : /ioAtorra T
63 /cal TO?S fvavriois seel. Schanz
a 5 euSat/ioj'ai' B T Syrianus Damascius : ol 8atn6v<av Badham : euSai^oVtos Schanz
a 7 0dou xPw ^ Alexander : %opoC 0eiou T
a 8 Kl B : re al T
eirl T Proclus : wiri B
b i virovpdviov B
Proclus : virovpavlav W (sed e supra u) : ovpdviov T
p S3; Proclus : ^Sjj
BT
ba KCIKTJS T: /ca/c^s B
b4 ^v recc. : f BT

3>AIAP02
Trpo'/ceiTat.

247 b

at pev yap dOdvaToi KaXovpevai, Tjrt/c' ay Trpos

a/cpw yevcavTai, eco TTopevOetcrai ecrrrjcray em TO) TOU ovpavov

ycoT<p, (TTacras be avTas Treptdyei ^ 7reptc/>opd, at 8e 0ecopowt c
Ta efa> TOU ovpavov.
Toy 8e inrepovpdviov TOTTOV ome TIS v/^yrjcre TTCO Twy TrjSe
Teoy yap

oSy TO' ye dAr^e? etVeti', dAAcos Te /cat Trept dA?]- 5

0ias Aeyo^Ta^ yap d^pwp:aTo? re Kat do~^T7jaaTt(rTos /cat

dvacfrrjs

oixria OVTO>S ovara,

tyvxrjs

KV/BepvifTr]

/xoyw

i><3, Trept r}v TO T^? dAr^^oOs eTrKTTTj/x^s yeros, TOVToy

Toy TOTroy.

OT' oSy ^eov Stdyota ya> Te /cat ^TncrT^Tf]

(frofjizvr],

/cat

aTrdo'rjs' ^v^rjs

ocrrj

av

d/c?j-

p-eA?j TO

bt^acrdai, Ibovcra bia \povov TO ov dyaTra Te /cat

TaXrjOf]

Tpe'<peTat Kat ew7ra#et, e'a)? ay

et? TCLVTOV Trepteyey/CT].

avTrjv biKaio(Tvvr]v, Kadopa

/c^KAw 77

ei> Se TT) TreptoSa) KaOopq 5

be (rw<ppoo~vvr]v, Kadopa 8e

^X 2? yeyeo-ts TrpoVeorty, 0^8' ^' eo-Tty TTOU eTepa

ey eTepw ovo-a (5y f]p.eLS

vvv OVTU>V /caAoCjuey, dAAa Tr)y ey

TW o eariy 6y OVTUIS e7rto~T77^irjy ovcrav /cat TaAAa wo-avTO)?

Ta oyTa OVTWS ^eao-ap-ey^ /cat e<rTiadflcra,
TO eto"co TOU ovpavov, o<f/caSe ^A^ey.
TIVLO^OS Trpbs Ti)y (paTvyv
d/jifipocriav

TOVS

bvaa TrdAty ets

eA^ovtrrj? 8e avTfjs

fairovs

o-TTjcras 7rape/3aAey 5

Te /cat ITT' a^T?) venrap e7:oTt(rey.

Kat o^Toy p-ey ^ecoy /3toy

at 8e aAAat ^u^at, ^ /x,ey

aptora ^e<3 eTro/xeyrj /cat eiKao-fjievr]

TOTroy Tr)y TOV rjvioxv

KetyaXrjv,

VTtepTJpev

248

els Toy e^co

/cat (rv[jLTTepirjve')(Or]

TJ]V

7rept(popay, Oopv^ov^evr] VTTO T<Sy tTTTrwy /cat jaoytj nadopS>o~a

C I vdiTcp (TTdffas Proclus : vd}T<ai* crrtia'as T: j/cerwt jVT<{<ras B
Becapovcri corr. Ven. 189 : decapovcrai B T
0 7 oS<ra ^fxi5s T Simplicius : if>t>x?5 o3(ra B : vf/uxy)x Stobaeus : o5(ra Madvig
0ear}/ y^
Clemens Proclus : 0eaT7j yijJ B : eearfj vy XP'J T W
d i r6vov T
Simplicius : rpoirov B
aKijpdTCji Tpe^o/aevr) W Damascius : ccK^paros
ffrpe<j>o/j.evr) B et os s. v. W 2 : ajojparw vel ax^paros <rTpe<t>o/j.evr} T
d a 80-7; B : SITTJ T
^'A.?? G : ^eAA.?? B T
d 3 5e'|a<r0cu T :
Sel-effdctt B
d 6 Kadopa /J.ev T : KaQopui^v B
d 7 oii5' 5} B : ou
8^ T: oi>8' ^ vulg.

248 a

IIAAT&N02

5 ra ozmr f) 8e rore ju,er fjpev, rore 8' e8i>, /3iabju,ez>a>y 8e rcov

<
LTnru>v ra jueu et8ei>, ra 8' ou. at 8e 8?) aAAat
TOV avu> eVoimu, d8waroi>o-ai 8e, VT
t,, uarowat dAA?jAa? /cat e7ri/3dAAowat, erepa
b Trpo TTJS ere/ras Treipco/x.ei'j] ytv(r6ai. 06pvj3o$ ovv KOL
a/itAAa /cat tSpcos eo-^aros yiyvzrai, ov 8r/ Kaxta r]vi,6^u>v
zroAAat f/,ey xft)^e^oi;rat ToAAai 8e 7roAA.a irrepa OpavovraLTracrai 8e TroAvy e^oucrat TTOVOV areAets TT;? row wros 0eas
5 aTrep^ovrai, /cat a7reA.0o{)o-ai T/>o07) 8oaorr) -^pSivraL. oS
8' evex' ^ TroAArj a-7rouT/ ro dArj^etas iSet^y TreStov ov kcrnv,
i] re 8r) Trpocn^Koucra ^V^TIS rw dptcrro) ro/y,^ ex row e/cei
C AeijucoTOs ruyxaWi oSrra, 17 re rou TrrepoS Averts, w "fyvyv]
Kovc/)t{erat, rcwrw rpe^erai. Oea-fJLos re 'A8paorretay 6'8e.
w o-wovraSos yevo^fvrj Kart8r/ rt rwy dArj? r
f ^P a ? irepioftov eTrai airri^ova, xay det
5 rouro Swrjrai -noifiv, det d/3Aa/3?j eTz^at- oray 8e d
re Kat Ka/ctas TrArja^ercra fiapvvOij, flapvvOficra 8e
iTTepoppvrj(rr) re /cat em rrjz; -y^y Trecrrj, rore yo//,os
d ^ <f)VTfv<rai et? /xrj8e/itay dypziov tyvcnv fv rr)
yej^ecret, dAAa r^y /xei> TrAe^crra t8oi5o-ay ets yovr]v avbpbs
-yfvr)croiJ.firov (piXocrotyov TJ $i\OK.a\ov rj ^OV&IKOV TWOS Kal
epcortKoi;, rr;y 8e Seurepa^ et? /SacrtAecos fvv6jj.ov TJ TroAejutKoC
5 Kat dpxtKoC, TpiTrjv ets TroAtrt/coS -^ rtvoy OIKOVOIJ.IKOV 77
XprjlAaTianKov, TfrdpT^v et? (piXoTtovov {rj} yvfJ.vacrTiK.ov rj
Trepl (rcojuaros Ta(rty rt^os ecro/xeVou, Tre/x.'Tmjy ^avriKov (3iov
C ?/ rtva reAetrrtKoi' '^ovarav eKrrj 7rotj]rt/coj r/ rwy
rts aAAos ap/^too-et, e^SSojary 8rj/xtoupytKos ?)
o77 cro^LCTTLKOs ^ 8r7juoKO7rtK09, evaTrj TVpavviKos. kv brj
b 2 o5 5^ T : ouSij B
b 5 o S' eVcx' ^ corr. D : ouSev exei B :
o5 5)) eVex' ^ T
b 6 oS seel. Madvig
c 3 <|>i>x^ ^ : ^"X? ^
C 4-5 iv oi'el T00TO . . . oiel a^\a^rj T W : et TOUTO . . . K^V Oi'el 0\aij B
C 6 xpyff<*P*tf'rl T : xpnva-P-tvy B
d i Qiipeiov T : Qripeiav B
d6^
add. Badham
d 7 TIVOS Hermann : rjj/a B T
63 ^/JLOKOVM&S
1 : 5r)noriK6s B
8^ B : S^ T

4>AIAPO2
TOVTOLS cLTiacriv os jJLfV civ biKCLLtos biaydyrj
p.TaXap./3dvi.,

os b* av ddt/ccos, \fipovos'

dpieivovos
els piev yap ro 5

avro oOev rJKei, fj T/WXT? e/caorrj OVK a</>iKz>eirat fT&v p.vpiu>v

ov yap TTTepovTai Trpb TOCTOVTOV xpovov TrXrjv f) TOV (piXocro(ptfcravTos

ddo'Acos 77 TratSepacrrrya-airo? /xera

249

(piXocrotyCas,

avrai be Tpirrj 7re/Ho8a) TT) x.6Ateret) lay e\.u>vrai rpls

(f)^fjs

TOV (3ov TOVTOV, ovTO) TTTtputOeicrai rpt(rxiAtocrra) eret cnrepat 8e aAAat, orai' TOV 7ipG*Toi> fitov T\VTrj(r(t)(riv,

eru^or, Kpidacrai be at p,ev els TO. VTTO yrjs 8t/caieXOovcrat. 6t/cr/y tuTivovcriv, at 6' et? rovpavov Tiva
TOTTOV VTTO TYfs

AtKr/s Kov(pLaOel(TaL Stayowtz> d^icoy ov ey

efiiuxrav /3iovcirl K^puxriv

(3iov alpovvTcu ov av Oekrj

j3Cov avdptoTTivrj

\]sv)(r]

r<3 6e ^tAtotrro) dju^orepat

re

kKacrrt]-

atyiKvelTai,

evOa /cat ei?

ov yap rj ye )u.7j7rore 5

dA?j^etay ets Tobe rjei TO o"xfjfJ.a.

0pa)TTOv crvvievai /car' elbos XeyofjLevov,
els

ev Aoyta-juw

f] \jsvxy

6eS> /cat VTrepibovaa a vvv elvai (f)ap,ev,

TO ov ovTftis.

bel yap av-

e/c TroAAwy toy ai-

o-vvai.povp.evov'

avdp.vr]cns eKeivav a Tror' etBey fifjiQv

Orjpiov

/cat ex Orjpiov os Trore

r/v TraAtr ets avdpairov.

<r6ri<re(i>v

/cat aipecrw TOV bevTepov

TOVTO

8' eortz' C

crvp-TropevOelo-a

/cat avaKV\jsa(ra els

bio br] biKaitos p.ovr] TtTepovrai rj TOV fyiXocro-

(frov bt-dvoia' Ttpbs yap fKfivois dti eo~Tiv iJ.vrnj.rj KaTabvvap,t,v,

Ttpbs olcnrep Oebs &>v delos eo-Tiv.
vTTop.vrlp.ao- iv 6pOS>s \pu>fj.evos,
p,evos, TeXeos OVTUIS

rots be br) TOLOVTOLS

dvrjp

reAeovy del reAeras reXov-

p.ovos yiyverai'

eio-Tap:evos be TWV

dvOp(ti7riv(tiv crTTouSacrjuarcoz' Kat Ttpos ra> Oe'up yiyvo^evos, d

vovOeTeiTai p.ev VTTO TU>V TtoXXStv ws TrapaKiv&v, ev6ov<ru3.(<u>v
be XeXrjOev TOVS iroXXovs.
b 3 OtXri B T : Me\ri Eusebius
b 4 friov T : piov B
b 7 <ri>
/car' Z8os Heindorf
Ibv B T : ofov rec. b : j'Jj/r' Badham
C i vvaipovfj.fvov B T : ^waipov/nevcav Heindorf
C 6 6ebs B : 6 0ebs T
(utrumque traditum fuisse testatur Hermias)
6fT6s B T : 6e6s
quoque traditum fuisse testatur Hermias

"Eon 8r) ovv 8eCpo 6 iras rJKav Aoyos Trept r?}s rerdpr?]?
5 navias^v orav TO r?]e us 6p<3i> KaXAoj, row dA?70ous
avafJ-LfJivrjCTKo^vos,
Tirepcorat re Kat avaTrrtpovntvos TrpoOv^ov^fvos avaTTTtcrOal, abwarGiv 5e, opytfos 8tKT]i> /SAemoy
ai>a>, r<Sz/ Kara) 8e a/xeAwy, alriav e^et &>s IACLVLKUIS 8taKeie fj,evos &)? apa avrr] Ttaa-wv TU>I> fvOovcnao-(i>v aptorrj re
Kat e apicrTttiv rw re ^OVTL /cat r<S Koiyco^owrt avrrjs
yiyyerat, Kat on ravrrjs ^fT\u>v rrjs jj.avias 6 lp<Si> rwi>
KaA.wy epafrrr)? KaA.e?rai. KaOcnrep yap etprjrat, Trara p,ey
5 dy^pwTrov ^v^ntf>v<rfLre^earat ra wra, ^ OVK ay ^A^ey
350 e'S ro6 TO (,G>ow avajju^v^a-Kea-dai. 8e eK rawSe eKetva 011
cnracrri, o#re ocrat fipa^ais tlbov rare raKel, ov^' at
v rore
5 oAtyat 8rj Aei77ovrat ats ro rfjs juy^/Mrj
avrai 8e, oray rt rwr e/cei o/xotcojua t8co(ny,
Kat ovKe'r' (ey) avr&v yiyvovrai, o 5' eVrt ro Tra^os dyro8ta ro p,r) lnavS>s ftiaLaOdvecrOai. bLKaiocrvvr^s iJ.zv ovv
Kat 6Va aAAa rt/xta \lsv\als OVK
y ro^s r^5e 6/xot(6jaacrti', aAAa
avr&v Kat oAtyoi em ray etKoWs
5 ^ewrrat ro roS etKao-^eVros yeVos* KaAAos 8e roV ^
ore aw evbainovi XP? naKaptav O^LV re Kat
Atos f)[ji,ls, aAAot 8e jixer' aAAou
, eZ8or re Kat ereAowro rwy reAerwy ^v 0e'/us Aeyeir
/xaKaptcorarrjy, ^y wpyta^b/xey oAoKA^pot fxey avrot orres Kat
cnra^er? KaKwv oo-a ^//,a? ez> i(rre'p&) XPV(P vTre^evev, 6AoKAr/pa 8e Kat clTrAa Kat arpejur) Kat ei8atp,oya ^>ao-ju,ara
i re Kat eTTOTrrevoyre? ey a^yrj Ka9apa, Kadapol
d.5 ^j/ BT Stobaeus: 77 al. : ?/' vulg.
d.6 re /cal BT Stobaeus :
seel. Schanz
d. 9 [taviKois T : juavwcbs B
64 Ko\e?rai B T :
yiyverat Stobaeus
a 3 Sare B -yp. t : oure T
a 7 ovKer'
ev avriav Hirschig : obiter' avrcev B T : oviteB' avruv vulg.
b 4 0X1701
B t : 6\fyoty T
b 8 rwy B : om. T
V recc. : ^ B : f T
C i upyid^ofjifv W : 6pyido[i.ev B T
04 aii-y$ T : ovrp B

<AIAP02
ovres /cat acrrip,avTOL TOVTOV o vvv or) cr<w//,a 7repi</>e/>oi>res
6vofJ.d^ofJ.v, dorpeou rpoTtov SeSeoyxev/xezJoi.
Ta5ra /mer ow \WT]\M] Kf^apicrOa}, 01' 771; TTO^OJ raw rore
wi> jua/cporepa etprjrar Trep/, 6e KaAA
/xer' fKfiv(av re eA.aju.7rez> or, oevpo r' (\66vT(s
auro 8ta r^s eyapyeo-rarr;? aio'Otfo'eMS TWV
o\lsis yap r]juv d^vrdrri T&V 8ta rou <rajjuaro?
, fj typovrjcns ofy oparai 8ei^ois ya/> az'
e/3cora?, et rt rotouroz-' eavTrjs evapyes e?8a)Xoy
els o^iv lov KCU raAAa oo~a e/saara* z^ilz' 8e
/caA.Ao? p-ovov ravTt]v eo"Xe l^oipav, WOT' tK<pav(rTaTov civ at
Kat pa(r^L(j)Tarov.
6 ^kv ovv fj.r] feoreA^y ^ 8i(pdapfjii'os
OVK dea)y evOevfie twcre (peperai irpos avro TO /caAAos,
6f(ti[j,fvos avrov TJ]V Trjbe eTrcavvp-iav, WOT' o^ cre/3erat Trpocrop&v, dAX' ffbovii TTapabovs rerpaTroSo? vopov
fiaivtiv
Kat ira&ocnTopf'iv, KCU vftpft. Trpoo-ojutAwy ov 8e' ol<ry^>verai irapa (pvcnv f]8ovr]V $IK>KO>V 6 8e
, o rail' rore 'noXvd^a^v, orav $eoet8es
tSr/ jcaAAo? e5 jue^ut/xrj/xez.'oi' 57 rt^a (rco/xaroy Idtav,
jjiev e<ppie KO.L rt r<3y rore imrjXdev avrov Setjuarajy, eira
Ttpocroputv a)? ^eof <re/3erat, /cat et JUT) I8e8tet r^y r^s 0-^)08pa /xaytas boav, 6voi av wy dyaA/Aart KCU ^ew rots irat8tKor?. Ibovra ' avrov olov e/c r?;? (ppiKr]s /u,era/3oA^ re
Ka^ iopa>9 /cat ^epjuoVrys a^drjs XafJt,j3dveL' oe^a/xe^o? yap roS
KaAAous rr)i> airopporjv 8ta rwy djujuarcov fdep^avQn] fj q
TOV Trrepoy (pv(ns apSerat, depi^avdevros 8e era/cr; ra Trept
r^y <-K(pv(TLv, a iraAat VTTO o-/cArjpor77ro? (rv^e^vKOTa etpye
JUT) /SAao'rareii', eTrtpptieto-jj? oe r^s rpcxprjs wS^a-e re Kat
&pfj.r]cre (pvecrOai ano rijs pC0]S o TOV Trrepov KauAoy VTTO
Tray ro r^s ^fv^rjs tloos' iracra yap ?)y ro TraAat Trrepoon/.
c 5 acr^/uaj/TOi] fort, air^fjunvroi H. Richards
j/Di/ 8^ T : rCv B
C 6 eSe<r/ueuyue'ot T : SfSefffJ.evfu.evov
B
a 5 /t^ eSeStei Cobet : ^
'SeStet Schanz : ^ ScSieirj B (sed efy punctis notatum) : /t^ SeSt'ei T
b 2 ^ . . . fySerat ante fdep/j.di>6r] transp. ci. Ast
p ^ T: ^ B

2500
5

5
251

25i c

riAAT&NOS

C {ei ovv ev rovr<p oXrj /cat dz/aKrjKiet, /cat oirep ro r<3i> o8oyTO(pvovvT(i>v
(j)voo(nv,

TrdOos Trept ro-us dSoVray yiyyerat orai> aprt

Kvfj(rC$

re Kai ayayd/crTjo-ts irept ra ovXa, ravrov

brj TreTrovOtv i] TOV TTTepocp"vetv ap^ojjifvov ^vyjr

5 dyaya/cret Kat yapyaA-i^erat <f)vov<ra ra Trrepa.

Ce' re Ka'
oray /xev

ovy j3A.e7TOD(ra Trpos ro ro{5 7ratoy KaXXos, eKeWev jue'p?] eirtwra Kai peorr' & 8r) 8ta rawa ip,epos /caAetrat
[rbv t/Aepoy] apSrjrat re Kat ^ep^atVrjrat, Aco<^)a re
d

Kat yeyrjOw

OTCLV 8e )(copts ye'yrjrat Kat av^fjiria'rj,

ra

Ste^o'Scoz; trrojoiara ^ ro Trrepoy 6p/ua, awavatw/zew

aTTOK\rjL

rrjv ftXa.<rTr\v TOV irrepov, rj

8' evros jixera roS

rrjSwcra otor ra cr<pvovTa, rrj

rf) Ka0' avrr\v, a>crre iracra Kvrov^v
otcrrpa Kai duyarat, ^vr\n,r\v

8' av f\ov(ra TOV

8e d/x^oreptoy jue/xety/xeycoi' dSry/xoyet re

rrj aroma TOV TrdOovs Kal airopovcra Aurra, Kat IjUjuay^s
e ovo"a ovre vu/cro? 8warat Ka^evSety ovre /^e6' ^/xe'pau ov ay
T] jjifvfiv,

dsi 8e TToOovcra OTTOV av ot^rat otyecrOai TOV \ovra

TO KaAAos" tSoStra 8e Kal eTro^ereDcra/jiei'r] fyepov e^Aucre f*?y

ra rore or>/x7re</>payju,eVa, ava^nvo^v ot Aa/3o{5cra Keyrpa)^ re
5 Kai o)8tVa)z; eArj^ey, fjoovrjv
252

TtapovTL KapTtovTai.

8' aS TaijTf]v

yAvKurarryy ey rai

odev brj (Kovcra tlvai OVK aTroAenrerai, i

ov8e rtya rou KaAou Trept irAetoyos iroteTrai, dA\a p^re'pooy

re Kat abeX^&v Kal Iratpcoy Trayrcov AeArjcrrat, Kat ov<rias
8t' d//,eAetay aTroAXu^eyrjs Trap' ovSey ri0erai, vo[j.iiJ.<av

be

5 Kai VO"^rnji6va>v, ot? irpo ro{5 eKaAAft)Trt{ero, Trayrooy Kara(^pow/crao-a SouAewetv eroi/xr; Kai Koipxifrflai O'TTOU ar ea rty
eyyuraro) rou iroOow firpos yap r<S (re'/3ecr0atNroz' ro KaAAos
larpov rjijpr]Kf

JJLOVOV rwy /jteyto^rcoy irovcav.

TOVTO

C I iet t : f r) B : ^7) T
o^ovro<pvo'l>vrtv B t : oSfJvTwi' <pv6vrdif T
03 Qvcaariv B : tyvcaffi T: (j>vxri Bekker
/cyijo-is T: Kivt]<ris BW
C 4 e? T : ^7) B
C 8 -rbv IfjLtpov seel, olim Stallbaum
d 5 fnaffrri
Ruhnken : fKaffTji B T
e 5 5iVo>] oSuvwV Badham

64ffv(jnrf<f>pctry/j.evaT ;ffvfj.ire-rrpa'yfjLfi'aB
a 6 &>/ T : eAv B

4>AIAPOS

2525

8e TO irdOos, <w mu KaAe', Trpo? oz> 817 //,oi o Aoyos, avOpanroi

ptv epcora ovofjid^ovcnv, 0eot Se o KaAo<rty aKOUcras etKorcos
8ia yeoVijra yeAaV?7. Aeyoucri 8e oi/xat TIVZS 'Qfjuqpibuv K
T>V airoderutv zi:G>v bvo eTrrj eis TOV "Epoora, &v TO trepan 5
v/3picru/coz> Travv KOI oil <r(j)6bpa rt f^erpov vfAVovcri 8e
TOV 8' r^rot 9vr]To\ fjicv "Epcara Kakovcn iroryvov,
aOavaroi 8e Flrepcora, 8ta Trrepo^vrop' avdyKrjv.
TOVTOLS Sr) l^ecrrt fxey Tret^ecr^at, t-^ecmv Se ^77- o/xcos 8e ^'
ye atrta Kat ro 7ra#os rwz/ eptovrav TOVTO e/ceiz/o ruy^ayei oy.
Twy /^.ey oSy Aios O7ra8y 6 XTj^^et? typpiOea-Tepov
'ftvvarai tyepew TO TOV TTTep^vvfJiov a^9os' OCTOL 8e "Apews
re dfpcnrfVTai
Kat /xer eKetroi) Trepie-TroAow, orar VTT
"Epcoro? a/V<3(n Kat rt ol^OQxnv abiK.eta-6ai VTTO TOV epco/xez/ou,
(poviKol Kat erot/xot Ka^tepevetv O.VTOVS re KCU ra
Ka^ oi'rco Ka^' CKCKTTOV 6cov, ov Kao~Tos r\v xopeur
yoy rt//,(Sv re Kat jut|u,o?;/4ei>o9 eis ro bvvaTov {77, e'a>? ay ^
abid<pOopos Kat rrjy rr)8e Trp^Trjv ytvzaiv flioTcv'f], nal
rovrto rw rpoTrw Trpo? re rows epcojae^ot;? Kat rovs aAAous
ojuiAe? re Kat Trpoo'cpe'perai. roy re ow "Epcora rwy KaXStv
wrpos TpoiTOV eKAe'yerat eKacrros, /cat &>? fleoi' avTov tnzivov
ovTa eaurai otoy ayaA/j,a reKratVerat re Kat KaraKOcr/jiei, wy
rtjurjo'coy re Kat opyia<ra^, ot ju.ez' 8r) oSy Atoy 8tw rt^a
efvat (^rouo-t rr)y \jtvxjiv TOV v^ am&v epw/xe^oy <TKO'. O

vrfA

TTOV(TLV OVV el

(pL\6(TO(pOS

OTCLV aVTOV VpOVTS

Tf

KOI T]yt}JiOVlKOS

fpa^OSxTL,

TTttV TTOIOVCTIV

T1]V <pTJ(TlV,

e
,

KCU

07KOS TOlOUrOS

eo-rat. eay ouy fir) irpo'repoy e/i>i/3e^<S(ri rw eTrtrrjSev/xart, 5

rore eTTtxeip^crayres fjiavOdvovcri re o0ei> ay rt 8wa>yrat Kat
avrot jnere'pxoyrat, t^yevorres 8e Trap' eaurwy
b 4 oT/uai T : o jueV B
b 6 v/3pi(TTiKbi> irdvv B : irttvu
T Stobaeus
b 8 8' ?froi T : S^ rot B Stobaeus
b 9 ir
Stobaeus : irrepAfywrov B : irrepotyoiTov T
da f ?j recc. : ^iji/ B T
d 3 /SiOTfuj; corr. Coisl. : jStoreuei B T
d 4 at TOI<S B : Kal irpbs
TOUS T
' d 5 prius re B : ye T
e i Si6v D : 81' 6V B : 8tt 6v T
PLATO, VOL. II.

17

riAATilNOS
253

TTJV TOV o-<erepou Ofov tyvcriv eviropovcn 8ta TO <rt>yroya)s

rivayKcurdai Trpbs TOV Qeov /3Ae7reiy, Kat e<a7rro|aei>oi avrov
rr/ nvrjiJ.ri fvOovcri&VTfs e fKeivov Xa/j.j3dvov(n ra e&j Kal
ra ei;rir>]o'ev//,ara, Ka#' 6Voy Suyarw 0eoG av6pa>TT(p juera5 <r)(e ty Kat TOVT&V 8r) roy epcoyiteyoy cunw/xeixH In re /^aXXov
dyaTToio-i, Kay IK Aio? dpvrcoo-ty uxnrfp al jBa.KXO.1, em TTJZ;
ro{5 epa)/xeVoi> v^u^TJy e-TrayrAowyres TrotoCcny ws
b ofAoioTaTov rai cr^ere/ow 0e<S. ocrot 8' aS /xe^' "Hpas
/3a<n\iKov {rjroOcrt, Kat evpovres Trepl TOVTOV Tiavra bp&cnv
ra avra. ot 8e 'A'TroAA.coi'os' re Kat eKaorou rwy ^ea>y oimo
Kara roy ^eoy toyre? frjroucrt roy cr^>ere/)oy Tra^a ire(pvKfvai,
5 Kal oray Kr^orwyrat, ju,t/xo7;//eyot avrot re Kat ra 7rai8iKa
Tret^oyres Kat pvO^L^ovres et? ro (Keivov eTrtr^Seu^ia Kat
t8eay ayowty, oo-j; eKao-ra> byvapis, ov <$>06v<$ ov8' dyeXew-

^e/3<o dutr/xeyeta xiw/xei>oi Trpos ra TratStxa, dAX' ets 6//,otor?]ra

C avrots Kat roi ^eoi oy ay r I/LAW crt^racray^Trdyrcos ort ptaAto-ra
ayety ovrco 7roioC(rt. Trpodv^ia //.ey oSy rwy a>s
epcoyrwy Kat reAer^, eay ye StaTrpa^coyrat 6 irpodv/x.owrai j7 Aeyco, oura) KaA?/ re /cat evSat/xoytK?) VTTO rou
8t' epwra /xa^eyroy (friXov rw (friXrjOevTt,
ytyyerai, eav
alpfOfjdAuTKerat 8e 8r) 6 atpe^ety rotwSe rpoTrw.
ey dp^r/ roSSe rou p.v9ov rpt^rj StetAo/^ey ^v^qv
Tro/xop^co ^ey 81/0 rtz;e etSrj, TIVIO^LKOV 8e eto?
d rptroy, Kat yuy en ^/x^y ra(5ra jueyerco.
rwy 8e 8^ iTnrav
o jue'y, (pafj.ev, ayaOos, 6 8' oi!' dperr/ 8e rts rou dya^ou
T/ KCKOU KaKta, ov 8tet7roju,ey, yuy 8e AeKreoy. 6 p.ey TOIVVV
avrolv ey r^ KaAAtort ora<rei a>y ro re etSos opdbs Kat
, tyavyyv, eTTiypVTros, AeuKos t8ety,
a 5 rovToav recc. : TOVTOV B T
a 6 K&P! x^*7 Madvig
b i f}pas
t: rinepas BT
63 reAer^ corr. Par. 1808 : reXeur^ BT
eoJ'
7 SmTTpcif wj/rat Hermias : eciv T' ej/Sm7rpo|&)j'Tot B T : ^civ -y' eS 8iairpa|eei'Tai G. Hermann
C 4 jf Xeyw Heindorf : ^i/ Xeyw T : ijy 5'
e'yc!) B
05 7/'yj'Tot T : ylyvr)Tai B
C 6 5 aipeOels seel. Badham
C 7 Siei\ofi.ev Heindorf : 5iei\6/j.riv B T
d i 7ir7rcw T : '/TTITW B
d 4 avroiv T : avruv B

253d
epaorr)? juera <ra)^>po(rvi/ijs re /ecu ai8ow, Kal
bor)s ermpos, CITT^KTOS,

/ceAewjixari povov Kal

Ao'ya> T/znoxeirar 6 8' aS trKoAioy, TroAvs, ei/cf/

(rvfJ-Tretpoprj-

, yAauKo'/x/xaroy, v<paiij,os, vfiptcos Kal dAa^oyeia? eraipoy,

wra Aacrtos, KCO(/)O?, /^laortyt /xera Kcvrpctiv /xo'yts {nreiorav 6' oSy 6 rjvio^os ISuiv TO epa>TiKov op^a, Ttacrav 5
biaOfpfj.rjvas

TTJV "^rvyj]v, yapyaXifr^ov

re xat TtoOov

vTTOTrX.r]crOr), 6 /xey evTret^r)? rw ^yto^w rwr 'LTTTT^V,

254

det re KCU rore atSot /Sia^o/x.evos', kavTov Kare'^ei ju,^ eirtTrijSai' r<S pu>fj.fvu>'

6 8e owe Ktvrpcov rfVio^LKStv

ovre

ert evrpeTTerai, (riupT&v 8e y8ta ^e'perat, KCU

Traptyjav
re

r<3 o-?;{i)yt re

Kai

Trpo? ra 7rai8tKa feat jjiveiav

rjVLo^u
TtoiticrQai Trjs

T&V

ayava.KTovvT, ws 8et^a Kat Trapa^ojua dyayKa</)ju,ei>ar reAeu- b

, oray jurjSe^ ^ Trepa? KCLKOV, TropevecrOov d
Kal 6/xoAoy?]o-avre 7roi?j(reii> ro
avroi r' lyivovro KOL el8oy rr)z; o\^t
aa-TpaTTTovcrav.

Ibovros 86 rou f}Vi6\ov 77 \LVI\\M]

rou KaAAous (pv(nv

<T(i)(ppo<rvvr]s

^v^drj,

(v ayrw fidOpti) /3e/3<3crai''

re Kat <T(f)0ei(ra

avetrfcrfv

eA/cvcrat ray

irpos rrjv

Kal ird\iv et8ey avrrjv jixera

tSoScra 8e e'8ere

virria, Kal ajj,a

^ytas ovrco (T(j)6bpa,

-rjvayKdcrdr]
&XTT'

km

(Is
ra

Kadicrai ra> tVffco, rw fxey e/coz/Ta 8ta ro JU.T)

, TOV 8e v/3picrrr)z> /^aA' a/corra.
6 /u,ey ^-27' ala-^yvr]s re /cat Oapfiovs

tSpwrt

e/3pee rr)y ^v^v, o 8e A?jas r^s 08^779, ^y UTTO rou 5

d6 al seel. Badham
d ? dA.ij&j'fJy om. Heraclitus
KeA.i5(rp.aTi t Heraclitus : Kf\evfj.ari B T
e 2 )8po%uTpX7;A.os B T :
ftapvrpdx'nh.os V
64 irepl c5ra \acrjos Koitybs T : irepl 3>ra XcurioKcatyos
B Photius Synesius : irepiti>rd\(rios virdKaxpos Heraclitus
e 6 alff0-f;ffei
dub. Heindorf : seel. Herwerden
a i /ceWpwi'] irrepSiv Herwerden
8-5 (T^) ^j/io'x^ Herwerden
b i TeAeurcDj/Te T : TeAeur&jj'Tes B

2540

HAATGNOS

re eo-xey Km rov Trrco/jtaros, /xoyw eaya7ryev<ras

eAotopTjcrez> opyr), -TroAAa KCIKI&V rov re r]Vio\ov KCU TOV
6fj.6wya cos SetAia re /cat avavbpiq AiiroVre r^y raty Kat
d 6/jtoAoytay /cat TraAiy OVK efleAo^ras -npoa-itvai avayKau>v
jtxoyt? cri>yexcoprj(rez> 8eo/J.eVcoy ets aS^ts V7rejo/3aAeV0ai. eA8e ro5 crwyre^eyTOS yjpovov [ov]
5 rjvdyKao-ev av TrpocreWtlv TOLS TratSt/cots eTTt rovs aurcwj
Xoyous, /cat eTretSr) eyyis fjcrav, ey/cv\/ras Kat e/cretyas r^y
KfpKOV, ei'8aKa)i' roy xa^tz;oy, juter' aycuSei'as e'A/cei- 6 8'
6 rjVio\os en ju.aA.Aoy TO.VTOV ird6os iraO&v, uxnrep airb ij<ravaTTtfffav, ert /xaAAoy roC vj3pi(TTov ITTTTOU e/c rv
/3ta O7rura> cnrci(ras roy x.a^-ll;o'i;> 'T?1' re KdKr]y6pov
Kat ray yyaflous KaOyna^ev Kat ra (TKeAr; re Kat
5 ra to-)(ta TT/JOS r^y y^y epetVas 68wat? ecoKev. orar 8e
ravroy TroAAaKts -7ra<n(ft>y 6 Troyrjpos r^s -0/3pecos A?7^?j,
raTretyco^et? eVerat 7^817 777 roi; rjVLO^ov Trpovoiq, Kat orav
1877 roy Kakov, (poj3(i> StdAAurat- wcrre ((ru/x^Satyet ror' r^8ij r?)y
ro{5 epao-rou \lfv\riv TOLS 7rat8tKots atSou/xeyr/y re /cat
255 e7re<r#at. are ovi; Trao-ay OepaTteCav w? icro^eos
fjifvos ov)( -UTTO o"x/7/jiart^o/aeVo7j rou epwyros dAA' aArjflws
roCro TreTToy^oros, Kat auros a>y ^>wet (f)iXo$ rw ^epaTrewyrt, eay apa Kat ey r<S TTpocrOtv VTTO crujix^otrrjrfiy r)
5 riya)y aAAwy 8ta^8e/3Ar//u,eyos r}, Aeyorrtoy cos al(T)^pbv epcorrt
TrArjcrta^etz^, Kat 8ta ro{5ro 0,77(0^7^ rov epojyra, Ttpoiovros
8e 7^81} roi) \povov 77 re ?]AiKta Kat ro xpecoy r/yayey ei?
b ro Trpo(T(r0ai avrbv eis OfxtAtai'* ov yap STjirore et/iaprat
C 8 AITTOJ/TC T : XJ^OJ/TO B
da Seofj-evuv B T : Seo/j.evoiv Heindorf
ds og seel. Heindorf
d6 ^eiS^j T: <br6l 8^6
tKre'ivas T : e'l/Tefras B
e 8 </>oj3^ T : <f>60ov B
T^T' B : iror'T
e 9 SeSiuTai' Bekker : SeSurai' B (sed /cDi supra versum) : SeSoi/curai/ T
as uTrotr^rjfiaTf^bjUefou T : uTrotrx^/ueVou B (<rxT)/u.aT/o in marg. b)
a 3 cpiAos B T : 4>t\os 6?s raurbi' Syej rjV <pi\iav vulg.
a 6 cnruOfi
corr. Coisl. : aircoOe? B T
epwra, t : epcora B T
b I irpotreaBai
corr. Coisl. : irpoea-Bai B T

KCLKOV KaK<3 (piXov OV& ayadbv JU,T) <pt'Aoz> ayaOG> elvai.

TTpoa-ffjievov
8e Koi Xoyov not ofjuXiav SefajaeVov, tyyvdev
fj ewota yiyvopevr] TOV ep&vros eKTrAr/rret rov epw/uevoy
8tat(r$ai>o'/!/.ei>oi> on 0118' ot crv^iravT^ aAAot <piAot re Kai
oiKetot [j.oipav </>iAtas oi8ep.iai> Trapt^ovTai Trpos rov tvOeov
tyiXov.
orav 8e yjpoviCfl TOVTO bp&v Kal ^Arjtrici^ />iera
ToO aiTTeo^cu er re yv^vacriois KCU tv rai? aAAat? ojutAtais,
ror' 7/817 ^7 ro^ pevjuaros tKCivov irrjy?], 6z/ i//epof Zei/s
ous epwy wro'/xao-e, iroAAr) (pepo^fvr]
Trpbs TOV
rj ^fv f l s aiirbv e8i), ^ 8' a7ro/u,e<rrov/AeVot> e^co
Kal olov irv^v^a *] TLS flX&> CLTTO Aeuoy re Kat
aAAo/u,eV?7 7rdAii> o^er ^puriOrj (pcperai, ovrco ro
row KaAAou? peS//.a TraAii' et? roy KaXbv 8ta raw d^/jtdrcoy
loV, ^ TrtcpvKfv em rTji; \l/vxyv Uvai a^>iK.6^vov Kat ai>aTTTep&crav, ras StoSous rcov Trrepwy ap8et re Kat c5p/u,rj(re
irTpo<pveLV re Kat rr)z> row epto/xevou aS fyvyjiv epcoros
.
epa p,ey oSy, orov 8e aTropet' Kat ov^' on
ailbzv oi/5' e^et (ppdcrat, dAA' otoy dV aAAov
o00aA//,tas aTroAeAauKcbs TTpotpaa-iv etTret^ OVK e^et, a>cr7rep
8e ez; Karo7rrpa> er rai epwyrt eawroy 6p<3z> XeXrjOev.
KOI
orav jjJev Kivos Trapr), AT/yet Kara ravra eKeu>a> rr/s o8
orav 8e aTrrj, Kara ravra ai! -jro^er Kat 7ro0erai,
epcoros dyrepcora e^coy KaAet 8e avrov KOI oterat OVK epcora
dAAd (piXCav elvai. em^D^et 8e eKefoa) TrapaTrArjo-tcos p.eV,
do"0eyeo-repco? 8e, opay, a7rre(r^at, (biXely, o-vyKaraKflo-OaL'
\ S! '
f
'
- ^ ^ k** ^
*'"" ' V
-,
-?Kat or/, otoy etKos, Trotet ro /xera rouro ra^v ra^ra. er ow
rr/ (ruyKot)u?j(ret ro{i /u,ey fpacrrov 6 aKoAao-ros ITTTTOJ e^et
on Aey?/ Trpos roz; Tjvioyov, Kat d^tot dz^rt TroAAwy TroVcou
6 8e r<2i> TratStKwy e^et fjt^y ov8ey etTrety,
v?

>;

b 3 TTpoffe/Afvov T : Trpbs e/ie vou B

AcJyov /col B : \6yov re Kal T
b 8 TOW Eusebius : TOVTOV B T
C i T<{T' ^S>j B T : TOTE S)/
Eusebius
C 4 airoppe? T : oiropet B
Xeicoi/] <rK\rip>v Herwerden
d 3 o#0' B T : ou5' Buttmann
d 5 o<p0a\ij.iav Ast
d 6 alterum
fv seel. Cobet
e6 Ae^?? Bekker: \fyei B T : Ae^oj Eusebius: Ae|e/
Herwerden

5
256

IIAAT&NOS
(nrapy&v 8e /cat airopStv 7rept/3dAAa rov epaorr/z; Kat
ws <rco8p' fvvovv a(TTTa^6[ji.fvos) orav re
olds eon JUT) av aTrapvr]6i)vai TO avroS /[/.epos
TW fp&vn, 66 Serj^etrj Tw^ety o 8e 6p.dv av juera roi;
r]VLO)(ov Trpbs ravTO. /xer' aiSoCs Kat Aoyou
eay fxey 8^ ow eis reray/^eyTjy re biairav Kal
VLKT](rrf TO. /3eArtco r?y? biavoias ayayovra, /Jt-aKapiov /xev
/cat 6}j.ovor]TiKov TOV zvOabe /3toy 8tayouo-ty, eyxparet? avr&v
Kat KOOTUOI oires, SouAcocrd/xeyot fxey w /ca/aa ^vx^js eyeeu^epcoo-ayres 8e w dperTy' reAei)rrjo-ayres 8e Sr)
/cat eAa^pot yeyoyore? r<3y rpi&v /73-aAato-/Jtdrcoi;
&)? a\.rjOS>s 'OAi)/x,7rta/C(Sy er vtviKrjKaa-w, ov
ayaOov ovre o-ocxppo<rvvri avOpunrivr] ovre ^eta juayta
TTO/OUTCU dy^pcriTTfa). eay 8e 8r/ Statrrj c/)opri/ca)repa re KOI
atpiAoo-o'c/xd, (ptAortjaco 8e \prj<r(i)VTai, rd^' ay 77ou ev
^ rizn aAArj dp;eAeta ra> d/coAda-rco avroiv V
ray i/^uxas a<ppovpovs, crvvayayovTC ets TO.VTQV, TVJV virb
rStv TroAA.coi' /xa/captcrrr/r atpeo-ty etAecr^rji' re Kat Steirpaaa-0r]v /cat StaTrpa^a/xez/co ro Aotiroi' 77817 ^pStvrai, pev
avrr), (nravm 8e, are ou Trdcrr; 8e8oy^eya r^ biavoiq irpdrTOVTCS. cpt'Aco /zev oSy Kat roura), TITTOV 8e Ktivu>v, dAATJAoiy 8td re roi) epwro? Kat e'co yeyo/xeyo) 8tdyoi)o~t, Trtcrrets
ras /xeytVras riyov^vo) aXX.rjXoiv 8e8coKeyat re Kat 8e8ex^i>
a? ov Oefjurbv elyat Avo-a^ra? ets fyOpav irore eAflety. ev
8e rrj reAevrr/ ciTrrepot /xer, cop//,TjKores 8e TrrepoCcr^at eK/3atrou (rco/xaros, wcrre ov cr/iiKpoy a^Aoy TTJS epcoriKT/s
^>eporraf ets yap crKo'roy Kat r^y WTTO y?Js Tropetav
ov VO^JLOS ecrrty ert eA#eu> rots Karrjpy^vois r^Srj r?js VTTOVa 4 &i/ T : om. B Eusebius
a 6 A.o7oi corn Coisl. : Atfyot/y B T
a 7 f eki/ T : & B
a 8 viK^\<rri T : j/t/c^tret B
b a jitey i^ T : ywej/ ws B
b38^T:S6eoB
S^sVT:5eB
c i TX' ^y B T: T<*X W
C 3 luj/ay^J^re B : ffwayay^vres T
T^V uxb B: r^v vTrb T))I/ T
C 4 fl\effdi)j/ Eusebius : elXerriv B T
8teirpa,dff6r)i> Eusebius : SLf-irpdO,VTO B T
07 (j>tA.a> /xei' T : <pi\S}fj.fv B
d 2 fiyovfj.fi'co recc. :
fyyovfifi'wv B T
SeSex^ai T : Se'xflcu B
d 7 virovpaviov B T
Eusebius : siroiipaviov Ven. 184 : virepovpavlov Buttmann

4>AIAPO2

256(1

paviov TTopeias, dAAa (pavbv piov bid-yovras

jaer' dAArjAcoz; iropew/xeVou?, Kal 6/iOTrrepous epcoros1 x.dpiv,

oray yevwTai, yevtcrOai.

Tavra rocravra, 2> Tra?, Kat #eta ovrco <rot 8a)p?]crerai 77
Trap' epa(rro{; c^iAia' 77 8e OTTO rou /AT) fp&vros otKetorjjs,
(Tuxppocrvvr] dvrjrrj KfKpa^vt], 6vr)ra re Kat <ei8coA.a olnovojuoufra, avfXevOepiav VTTO TtXrjOovs fTtaivoviJ.evr]v ws aperr/i*
rrj </)iA?7 ^vyr\ (VTKov(ra, evvea xiXidftas erStv Trepl yi}v
T]v avTTjv no! into yrjs avow Trape^ec.
(TGI, $tAe "Epcos, ets ^/xerepay bvva^iv ort KaAKat a/Hanj 8e8orai re Kal eKrereiorai TraAtfwSta, ra
re aAAa Kat ro?s ovo^acnv j]vayK.a<T^vr] -Troi^rtKots rt(riy 8ta
i; elpfjcrdai..
dAAa roil; Trporepaw re (rvyyv(t)^r]v Kat
yapw XU>V> tv/xeyTj? Kat fAecoy rrjy epcortKijy /xot
fjv e8o)Kas ja^re acpfXri (j^Tf Tr^jococ
8t'8ot; r' en p.a\\ov TJ vvv Trapa TOLS KaAoI? TLJJUOV
fV T&> TTp6(rOev 8' et TI Aoya> crot aTTTj^es et
re Kat eyco, Avcriav rbv TOV \6yov irare'pa atrtc^jae^o?
rwy roiovrcoy Aoycoi', eTTt (pi\ocro<f)Cav 8e, atcnrep
avroi; iroAe/jiapxos rerpairrat, rptyov, Zva KOL 6
o8e avroO /uiT/Kert eTrajiK^orept^Tj Ka^aTrep yCi', dAA' aTrA&is
npos "Epcora //.era (j)L\o(r6(f)(t)v Aoycoi> rof /Stoi'
4>AI.
flv<u, ravra yiyveaOai.

5
25?

TOV Aoyoy 8e . crow TraAat C

/X77 p,ot 6 Auo-tas rairetros fpavfj,

eav dpa Kat e

d. 8 StaYa-ydvTas Eusebius
e 2 yiyvwrai. H. Richards
e 3 fleui
oSrw B : OUTW Oeto T
a i x'^'^^os T : x'^'^^es B
7^^ corn
Coisl. : TI}*' B : T);)' T
a 2 KaKiv^ov^evnv Herwerden
-y^s T :
TTJS B
a 4 Se'SoTOJ T : SfSoirrat B
a 7 T^V epoiriK^v juot B :
rt\v yuo epwriK^v T
a 8 eScuKas B : SeSwrcas T
a 9 T' T : 5' B
b I ec T : om. B
airrixfs Hermias : airrjyes B T
b 3 aSe\(f>bs
Bekker . a5eA^)bs BT
b4 TeVpairrai T W :^ye-ypa.-irra.i rt reTpairTai B

257 c

nAAT&NOS

irpos avTov aXXov avTiTraparelvau

KCU ydp rts avrov, oo
5 0av/iacrie, eVayxos v TroAirt/cwy TOUT' avro XoiopS>v
75 AotSoptas e/caAet. \oyoypd(pov
1
eTTtcr^ot ^ftiy o;y row -ypa<piv.
2.Q. FeAoioV y', 2* veavia, TO 8oyjaa Aeyety, /cat roi;
d. kraipov crvyyov Sta/xaprayet?, i avrov ovrcos ^yr) rii>a
ttrtos Se Kat rof AotSopo^evoi; avroi otet dvetStAeyet^ a eAeyey.
4AI. 'E(cuWro yap, S HwKpares" Kat (rvvoicrOd TTOV
5 /cat a'uro? ort ot /xeytoroy bvvd^evoi re /cat tre^orarot ev
rat's -n'oAecrty ai<ryyvovTai Xoyovs re ypa^ety /cat /caTaAewreu;
(ruyypaju,/xara eavrwy, 8o^ar (j)o(3ov[j.fvoi. TOV eTretra x/00'^0^*
/x,^ (ro<^t(rrat KaAwzrai.
2H. FADKi;? dy/coji', S 4>(u8pe, XeXrjOev (re ort 0.770 roD
e jj-aKpov ayK&vos TOV Kara NeTAoy e/cATj^rj- Kat irpo? r<3
XavOdva (rt OTI ol p.eytcrroz^ typovovvTes r&v TroAtjiaAtara epaxn Aoyoypa^tas re Kat /caraAet^ecos
(rvyypa\j,[t,aTU>v, ot ye Kat eTretSazJ rtya yp&fyacri, Xoyov,
5 ovrcos dyaTTwcrt roi9 eTratyeras, ware Trpocnrapaypd^ovcri,
Trpcurous oli av eKaoraxoi) tTTaivG><nv avrovs.
'I'AT. nws1 Aeyets roiiro; ov yap jjiav9dvh).
258
212. Ov fj.avOdvfis on ev dp)(f) avbpbs TToAtrtKou [<ri;yypaju/xart] Trpfiros 6 eTraw/errj? yeypaTrrat.
Sli. ""ESofe' " TTOV (prjo-ii; " 177 /SouAfy " ^ " TW
5 17 dju0ore'po69, /cat " os (KO! 6s) elTrer "roy ambv $rj Xeyiav
arfp:vS>y KCU eyKW/txta^wi; 6 (ruyypa^evs eTretra Ae'yei

C 4 avrbv B T : avT&v vulg. : aury Heindorf

d. i ^76? TJI/K B :
rt^a ^ye? T
d 2 oj/(8i^bvTa Postgate : ocetSt^oi'To vo^ovra. B :
vo^u^oi/Ta T W dg ort . . . e i e/cAirjfty seel. Heindorf
65 (braj6Tas BT: ejratz/oCi'Tas V
67 Xtyeis TOVTO B : TOVTO ^.76/5 T
a i apxfi seel. Madvig : dySpbs seel. Herwerden (et mox ffvyjpdfJiiJ.aTo
ffvyjpiLfj.fji.aT i seclusi :ffvyypdfj./j.aTOSvulg.
a 4 </>rj(Ti B : <pr}
avruv rb (rvyypam/jLa T W : (p-rjini/ avrb rb (rvyypafifna, vulg.
a 5 KO!
fo add. Winckelmann

<J>AIAPO2

258a

TOVTO,

(rofpCav, eytore iravv paKpov TroLricrdfjifvos

o~vyypanfj,a-

*] <roi

$AAo rt (patyerat TO TOLOVTOV rj Aoyoy <ruyyeypa)U./i>teVos;

4>AI. OVK e>oiye.

212. QVKOVV eav ptv OVTOS e/ujueVr/, yey^^ws ai
K rov Oearpov 6 TrotT/r^s" eay 8e fa\i(f)6fj
/cat
pa^tas re *at rou aftos ei^at o~vyypd<f)iv,
aVTOS T KCU 01 fTCLlpOl.

Kat /x,aAa.
f)\6v ye ort o^x ^s vireptypovovvres TOV e7rtr?/8ev, dAA' w? re^aDjuaKo'res.
4>AI. ITazn; juey oSy.
212. Ti Se; oraf l/cayos yeVrjrai prJTaip t] /3a<riAevs', ware 10
TTJV AvKovp-yov rj 2oAa>vos ^ Aapeiou bvvafjuv aOd- c
VO.TOS yevecrdat. Xoyoypdcpos V Tro'Aet, ap' ow/c IcroOeov
awos re avrov ert ^Sz;, /cat ot eVara yiyvo^fvoi
rept O.VTOV vofj.iovffi, dew^voi. ai/rov ra (rt>yy/oa/x/xara;
5
4>AI. Kat /naAa.
212. Otei rtra oSy T<MI> roioijTcav, OOTIS Kat OTTCOOTIOW
Aucria, ofetSt^eti' awo roSro ort <rvyypa<pei;
4>AI. Ov/couy et/cos ye e^ wj' <ri> Aeyety /cat yap ay TT/
q,, 0)S (OLKV, OVflbl&l.

19

212. TOVTO [j-ev apa Travrt 8^Ao^, on OVK alcr^pbv O.VTO d

ye TO ypcupeiv Aoyous.
4>AI. Tt yap;
212. 'AAA' e/ce^o oT/xat alcr^pbv tfbri, TO pr) KaXSts Aeyety
re /cat ypd(pLv dAA' alcr\pS>s re /cat /caKws.
5
4>AI. A^Aov 8?j.
212. Tts ow d Tpoiros rov KaAw? re Kat /XT) ypd<piv;
a rt, S 4>a?8pe, Auo-t'ay re Trept TOVTUIV eeracrai Kat
a 7 (T{>) yuer& Krische
b 3 e|a\i^)0fj T : e'|aA?>f7 B
0 7 TIVO.
ofiv B : owi/ TIVO. T
c;8 ourb] aur^5 Ast
d 4 o?/ta( B : olfj.at
ffe T : o?juat 76 vulg.
d 8 rt B T : rot vulg.

HAATiiNOS
ocrris TTWTrore TI yeypa<pv T) ypa\/m, etre
ctre i8t<OTtKoV, ey /xer/xo ws TrotrjTrjs T)
4>AI. 'Epwras ei 8eojue0a; Tiros ju,ey oiw eVeKa
TIS a>s eiTrerv ^iorj, dAA' 17 rGtv ToiovTutv ybov&v
yap TTOV (K^Cvwv ye 5v TrpoXvnfidijvai 8et T/ /x^S
o 8^ oXtyou iracrai ai Trept TO crw/ua ^Soyal exouo-r bib Kal
2Ii. S)(oX^ fxey 8?], ws eoiKe- Kat S/xa /utot boKovcriv ws
ey TW irviyei wep Ke<f)a\rjs fip&v ot TeTTtyes aoouTes Kat
259 dAA-TjAois 8taA.eyo'/xevot KaOopav KCU ^jutas. et oSy iboiev Kal
v<) KaOdirfp TOVS 7roAAoi)s *v /xeo-rjja^Spta JU.T) SiaAeyo/Aei/ous1
<zAAa W(TTa{byTa? Kal KrjXov^lvovs vfi avr&v 8t' apyiav
rrjs biavoias, SiKauos ai> KOTayeAoiey, ^you/jteyot d^SpaTroS*
5 aTTa (rtfrfoiv fXOovrd ets TO KaTaytoyioy (3o-Trep TTpofia.Tt.a
Tfpl TJ]V Kprjvrjv evbfiv
tav 8e op&cri
Kat TrapaTrAeo^Tas o^as &(rirp Setp^as
b ctKrjAijTovs, 6 yepas ?rapa ^eaiy \ov(nv avOpatTrois 8t5orat,
. vE)(oi>a-t 8e 8^ TI TOUTO; arrjKOos yap, ws eWe,
. Ov p.v 8r) Trpe-Tret ye cpiAo/xouo-oz> avbpa T&V TOLOVTMV
etyai. AeyeTai 8' <ws TTOT' ?)o-ai> OVTOI avOpomoi
Trplv Movo-as yeyoyerat, -/fvo^vutv 8e Moucrwv Kal
018775 OVTCOS apa TU'es TWf ToVe e^eTrAayr/o-ay v^)' 1780^175,
C (2<TTe a8oyTes ^eArjcray <riTcoz> Te Kat TTOTwy, Kat
vTovs* e^ coy TO TeTTiycoy yeyos jixeT
yepas TOUTO irapa Mouo-0y Aa/3oV, /XT)8ev
bei<r6at yevop-evov, dAA' acriToy Te Kat a-n'OToy ev&vs a8ew;,
d 10 &s irotijrV et tnox is tSjcSTTjs seel. Badham
e i eVewa Ktiv
B : !'/' itv T : gj/e/ca Stobaeus
e 3 /w?8 B T : ^ V Stobaeus
a i /cal yfi.as T Stobaeus : om. B
ical vci> Stobaeus : icaivob B T
b 5 ye T Stobaeus : om. B
b 6 8'] S^i malit Heindorf
C4
Hevov post Seiireat B T Stobaeus : post tiiOvs transp. Badham

<J>AIAPO2

ecos av reAeurT/crrj, /cat /x,era ravra fXdqv Trapa Movtras

aTrayye'AAeii/ rty rtW avrS>v rt/xa raw ey0d8e. Tep\/axopa
p.V ovv TOVS kv ro? Copals rert/^KoYas avrr]v aTrayyeAAorres 7roioy<rt irpocrfyiXta-Ttpovs, rr) Se 'Eparot rows > roi?
/cat rat? aAAaty ovrai?, /cara TO etSos l/caorijs
^ 8e Trpecr/Sirarr; KaAAtOTrr? /cat r?y /tier' avryv
QvpavLq rows' fy (/>iA.O(ro^Ha Stayoyray re Kat TIIA&VTCLS TI]V
(Kiva>v [j,ov(ri.Kr]v dyyeAAouo-tr, at Sr) jutaAto-ra rwy Mouo-wy
irepi re ovpavov KOL \6-yovs ovcrai Oeiovs re /cat avdpanrivovs
tao-ty KaAAto-r??y (pcavrjv.
TroAAcoy 8^ ow eve/ca Ae/creoi' rt
/cat ov KaOevbr]Tov ey rrj j.ie<nnj./3piq.
4>AI. Ae/creo^ yap ow.
212. Ov/cow, O7:ep y)z/ TrpovOtneOa o~/ce\^ao-0at, roy Ao'yov
TT? /caA<3s e^et Aeyet^ re /cat y/oa$etz> /cat 07717 ^, cr/ceTrreoi'.

5
\

ow ovx VTrdp^eiv 8e? ro^j ev ye /cat

~n\v TOV Aeyo^ro? Staj'otay etSuray ro
ay eperz/ Trept jueAA?/;
Ovrcoo-t Trept TOVTOV a/c?j/coa, S </)t'Ae ^w/cpares, ov/c
rw /xeAAoyrt prjTopi ccrea-dat ra ro> wrt 8t/cata 260
dAAa ra So'^ayr' az^ irA^et otVep St/cao-oDo-ti',
ov8e ra OVTMS ayaQa ^ /caAa dAA' orra 8o'et; e/c yap TOVTGOV
etvai TO TTfiOfLV dAA' OVK e/c r??? dAr/^eta?.
211. " Ourot airofi^rjTOV CTTOS " eTz/at Set1, <J>at8pe, s^f
6 ar etTTcocrt cro(po(, dAAa cr/co7reu> jw?/ rt Aeywcrf Kat 8?)
Kat ro rSf Aex#ez> ov/c a<pfTfov.
4>AI. 'Op^cSs Ae'yet?.
212. *I28e 8^ cnroTrw/xey a^ro.

C 6 reptyixfya B T Stobaeus : repfyixdpll vulg.

d 3 yue-r' auT^c
B Stobaeus : /xera ra,\>ri]v T
d 7 iaCT-iv B : Ifatrij' T (corn t :
ire/tTToua-i suprascr. b)
S^ owv eVe/ca W : 8^ oweitfv B : S^; o&v
fveicev T
64 76 B: re T
a5^T:&B
a6
B T : \eyovai Schaefer

a6o b
b

IIAATON02
2IL Ei (re iretdoifu ey<io
tinsov, afj.<j)(jo

8e ITTTTOV dyyooijueu, roo-ovSe /xeVroi

eiScos Tre/H vov, ori <J>ai8pos ?7r7roz> r/yeirai TO r<2y Tj/xep

(j>a)i> juteyKrra e^Of wra5

4>AI. reA<Ho'z> y' &i>, co Sco/cpare?, etrj.

2H. OVTTO ye- (dAA' ore 617 (TTrouSfj a-e Trei^ot/^t,j
Aoyor Zirawov Kara roC oyou, tTriroy e7roz;o/ia^a)i; KOI Aeycoz; a>s
os a^toy ro ^pe/u,/xa OKOI re KfKTijffOai

KOL fTfl orpcmas,

re x.P77"lMi; Ka^ ^pos y' e^eyKety Suz/aroi;

C (TK-vr] Kal aAA.a TroAAa w^eAi/xop.
<I>AT. Ilayye'AotoV y' ay r)8rj eirj.
2H. 9Ap' oSz; 011 Kpetrroy yeAoioz/ feat ^>tAoy ^ 8ea>oV re
1
^ I Katv e^apov
' / i v r[eivat
*
* j /\ i
r) <ptAoi'J;
5

4>A1. 4>aiVerai.
Sil. "Oray oSy 6 p?]ropiKOS ayvouiv ayaObv Kal KO.KOV,
Aa/3a)y iroAiz/ coa-avrcos ^xovcrav ireiGrj, ^ -rrept oi/ou o-Kias
ws ITTTTOU roy eiraivov Troiovjaevos, dAAa irept
dya^oC, 80^0? 8e TTXrfdovs

K.O.K.OV a>s

/xejueAerijKa)? Treicrrj Ka/ca

!o dir' dyadojz;, TTOLOV nv a(v) oiet /xera raura rrjr pr

d Kapirov wi/ e<T7reipe
^AI. Ov irdyu ye
2il. *Ap' ovr, S ayaOf, aypoiKorepov rov bzovros AeAotboprjKafjiev

rrjy TWI> Adya)!; re^vrji;; r/ 8' icrajs ay etTroi* " Ti

5 jror', S 6avfj,a(noi,

A^peire;
jj.av6a.veiv

eya> yap oidey' dyyoowra

Aeyeiy, dAA', et

rt

e/ut^

cKtlvo ovrcos ep,e Aa/x^Sayeti'' ro8e

8' ow peya Aeyco, &>s ayev ejuioC rS ra 6Vra etSo'rt ovfttv
i irtidfiv

TI

b 5 e* T W : om. B
b 6 o# 76 T : oiWe B
S)j T : om. B
log irpos y' fveyKeiv Thompson: irpotrei'eYKer)/ B T
03 yeKoLov
teal <j>i\ov legit Hermias : yeKotov B T
0 4 flvai fy <j>i\ov B T :
1
non legit Hermias
c 10 nv bv Hirschig : rtva B T
d. i oiv
T W : t>v B
d 2 ye B : om. T
d 5 ouSeVa T : oi-Sei' B
d.6 tt TI B : e? TIS T
e>ij ^v/m.ftov\-f) B : jufj |u^j8ouAfi T : >TJ |UM/3ouXp xP^rCLl Stephanus
d 7 Kri]ff^nfvov Vahlen : KTijai.iJ.evos BT
B T : \o.j.>Lvei al.

4>AIAPO2
<J>AI. OVKOVV b^Kaia epe, Ae'yoixra ravra;
212. f&ijjou, eai> o'i y firiovres avrfj Aoyot /uaprup<3crty
. <oo"7rep yap aKOveii> 8oK<3 TLVUIV TrpocrioVrajy /cat
bia[j,apTvpop,eva)v Aoyaw, on \//-ev8erat KCU OK eon Te^vrj
dAA' arexvos rpt/3?;' TOV 8e Xeytiv, (prjfflv 6 AO.KO>V, erujuoy
T)(vr] avtv rov dXr/^etas rj^Oai ovr' eortr ovre ^77 Trore
vcrrepov yeVrjrai.
<I>AL TOWTCO^ 8i rwz> Aoya>y, S 2w/cpares' dAAa 8eupo
Trapd-yav eerae rt Kat TTWS Aeyouo-tr.
212. Ilapire 8?j, Op^fjiara yevvaia, KaAAtTraiSa re 4>ate w j eay /x,^ tKai^cS? (piXoa-ofprjcrrj, ovfie inavos
TTOTC Aeyetr ecrrat Trept ovbtvos. aTtoKpivccrdo) brj 6 <f>m8po?.
<I>AI. 'Epcorare.
212. ^Ap' ovv ov TO fjLV oAoy TJ prjropiKr] av fit] Tyvr\
^rvyaytoyta TIS 8ta Xoyusv, ov povov tv dt-KaaTrjpLOts Kat ocrot
aAAoi S^oVtot o-vAAoyot, dAAa Kat kv ibiois, rf avrrj (ryn,KpS>v
re KOL /xeydAcoy Trept, Kat ovbev VTifj.oTepov TO ye opOov Trept
^ Trept <paCAa yiyvopevov; rj TT&S crv raCr'
Ov jj,a rov At" ov Tra^raTracrti' ovrcos, dAAa
fxey TTCOS Trept ras StKas Ae'yerat re Kat ypa^erat
Aeyerat 8e Ka Trept 8r;p,77yopias* em TrAe'oi; 8e
212. 'AAA' ^ ras NeVropos Kat 'O8i;<r(reW
Trept Aoycoy aK?/Koas, a? er 'IAia> crxoAd^bir
rwy 8e riaAa/u?j8ovs d^KOOs yeyovas;
4>AI. Kai rat /xa At" eycoye rwi; NeVropos, et /UT)
TopyCav Nearopa rtva Karao-Keud^et?, ^ rt^a &pa(rv^a^ov
re Kat 0eo8&>poz> 'OSvo-cre'a.
212. "lo-cos. dAAa yap rovrofs e&p,v o~v 8' eiTre, e^
e 5 rovtie. . . e 7 yfvnrai seel. Schleiermacher
e 5 ^rj
seel. Voegelin
ericas rexf!) T W : froi/nos B
a i Se? T : 8$J B
Aoywi/ (dfcpoSfrflai) H. Richards
a 4 Treiffere T: Tre^erat B
ws
v
:
eav B : ffiws &v T
b 4 Tex V T ^^"yj>f\ B
b 6 xal B : re
< re
Kal T
b? irepl seel. Thompson
<rxoA.aC "'' s B T W : <r%oA-a^ovre corr. Coisl.
c i NeVropos (al 'OSucro-ecoj) Herwerden
C 2 Ka.TcurKfvdeis T : KaTocrfceuafps B
C 3 re T : Se B

260
e

261

a6ic
5 8tKaoT77piots ot avrCbiKOi rt bp><nv; OVK avrikeyovcriv
17 rt </>?7o-ouez>;
4>AI. ToOr' avro.
212. Ilept roi) biKaiov re KOI d8iKOu;
4>AI. Nat.
10
212. OVKOVV 6 re^rj rouro Spoor irotTjo-et ^az^uat ro
d atiro rofc a^rofe rore /xey btKcuov, orav 8e /3ovA.rjrat,

10
6

'
5

262

211. Kat ey Srjjurjyopia 8^ rr; Tro'Aei SoKer/; ra awra rore

v dya^a, rore 8' au ravavrCa;
4>AI. O{;rcos.
212. Toy our 'E\eariKoi> riaXa/ii^STjy Xeyoi^ra OVK
wore <f>aive(r0ai rois d/covouo-i ra avra ojuota
dro/xoia, Kat ty Kat TroAAa, jxeroyra re aS /cat
<I>AI. MaXa ye.
212. OVK apa povov irept 8tKa<rr?jpia re eo-ny
/cat irept 8r///,rjyopiay, dAA.', a>? eotKe, irept Trafra ra Xeyo/xera
//ia rts T~xyrj, etTrep eoriz>, avrrj ay etrj, ^ rts oto? r' eorat
Tray Trazm ojuotow rwy 8ui>ar<Sy Kal ots SuraroVj Kat aAAou
6/^ioiowros KOI aTTOKpvnTOfjifvov els ty&s ayeiv.
<I>AI. riSs 8rj ro rotoGroy Aeyets;
212. Tr;8e boK& (flrovcriv (fravela-Qcu.
a-nart] Trorepoy ev
TTO\V 8ta^)''pouo-t yty^erat jixaAAoy r)
<E>AI. 'Ey rots oAtyoy.
212. 'AAAd ye 8r) Kara 0-ju.tKpoy
e\0u>v em ro cvavriov rj Kara
<I>AI. nco? 8' ov;
212. Aet dpa roi> jueAAoyra cnraTr](riv juey dAAou, aitrov
, 77/i> 6/xotdrrjra rwy OVTMV Kat drojuotorrjra
&s 8tet8ei>at.
C 10 Tfxvl> T : TX>'') B (et mox)
d i /SouArjTat ^St/cov B :
iSiKoc jSovAijTat pr. T
d. 7 <f>a.tveff6(U B T : SoKeiv (paivecrdai vulg.
d 8 nfvovra. T : /u.ei/ OJ/TO B
e 2 77 TIS corr. Coisl. : $ -m T : ^ TS B
63 war WWT! T : ira.fj.vav rlB
'a a 76 5$j B : S^ T : jtt^i/ Galenus

4>AIAPO2

a62a

I. 'AvayKt] juer ovv.

212. H ovv olos re eVrat, aXrjdeiav ayvoG>v e/ca<rrou, rrju
row ayvoov^vov o/uotorTjra <rju,i/cpaV re /cat /xeyaA??i> ey rots 10
aAAots
<J>AI.

212. Ov/cow ro?s irapa ra oz;ra 8oab

bfjkov &s TO Trades TOVTO bi 6fj,oLOT^T(i)v
^AI. Ftyrerat yoCy ovrcos.
212. vEcruz> ow OTTCO? Tf)(ViKos eorat //era/3i/3aeiz; Kara 5
(Tfj,iKpbv bia r&v o^oioTr\T(ji>v alto TOV OVTOS e/caoTore eirt
Tovvavriov ai.Tsa.ywv, T\ avrbs TOVTO 8ta0evyety, 6 ja?) eyrcojOt/ccos
O fCTTLV Ka<TTOV

T&V OVT(l)V /

^AI. Ou /i?/ TTore.

212. Aoycoi' apa TiyyT\v, a> erat/oe, 6 rr/y aA^eiay p) c
eiSws, ooas be re^iypevKtos, yeAoiW rti'ci, ws eo6Ke, nal

212. BovAet ovv ev TU> Avcriov Aoyw ov ^e'pet?, xal ev 5

oty 57/xeis etTTOfiey tSeiv rt w^ c/>ajuey aTeyvtov re /cal e
etz/at;
4>AI. HdvTtov ye TTOU //.aAicrra, ws rw ye
\tyofjiev, oiiK. e^oz/res tKara TrapaSety/xara.
212. Kat /xrp /cara rv-^rjv ye rtz/a, w? fOLKfV,ypprj6^Tt]V
10
ra> Aoyco e^ovre ri 7ra/od5ety/xa, ws ay 6 etSco? ro aArj^e? d
oz> ev Aoyocy na.pa.yoi TOVS attovovTas. /cat eycoye,
atn<3ju,ai rovs
rpo(f)fJTai ot
rouro ro yepas1 ou ya/o TTOU eya>ye re^z/Tjs ri^os 5
ro{5 Aeyeif joiero^o?.
'J'AI. "Ecrra) a>? Aeyety p.6vov f)r\\<acrov 6 <^>r;y.
212. V10i 8r; jLtot dyayz;a)0i r^y row Aucrtou Aoyou a
b 5 fji(Ta&ipdfiv T Galenus : fj.eTa$ipdfi B
Heindorf : &^fxy6v . . . ^VT^XVOV B T

C 6 wr^ixav . . .
d i ri \dyw T '

a6ae

IlAATiiNO2

4>AI. " Ilepi fjiev rwv e^Stv Trpayjutdrcoy eTriorao'ai, /cat cos
vojAifa <n;//,<pepeu> fjiJ.iv TOVTOOV yei>o|ueVcof, aKr/Koas.
di<3
Se H/.TJ Sea roSro druxwai &v Seojuat, on OIK epaorTjS1 &>v crov
Tvy\dvu>,
&>? fKivoi,s /xev Tore jaera/ieAet "
5
211. ITaCo-ai. r^ 8^ ovv OVTOS a^aprdveL not
TToieZ keKTtov ^ yap;
263
4>AI. Nai.
2ii. vAp' oSy ov irayrl 8r)Xoy ro ye roiovbe, &>
/xey eyta r&v TOLOTUTMV o/xororjrtKws e^o/xer, irepi 8' ezna
5

<I>AI. AOK&> /jiey 6 Aeyeis pavOaveiv, en 8' etire

SH. f/Oraz.' ns ovo^a CITTT] (n7]pou r) apyvpov, ap ov TO
. Kai
. Tt 8' oray St/cai'ou r) dya^ou; OVK aXA.os
ftr]Tov^v dA.X?]A.ot? re Km ^p,ry avrols;
ow.
2ii. 'Ev jmey apa Tot? ffv^u^vov^v, ev 8e TOIS ov.
4>AI. Ovrco.

ey Trorepots jw,e^oi/ Svyarat;

4>AI. A?jA.oi> ort ey oTs
Sii. OvKoy rw neXXovra rtyvriv prjroptK^y
irp&rov fiey 8ei raCra 68w biripfja-Oai, KOL et
e/carepou rou eiSov?, ez> w re dydyKrj ro
Kai ey w JUT].
C
4>AI. KaA.oz; yoSy ay, a> ScoKpares, eT8os eti]
6 rouro Aa/3wy.
SO.. "ETremi ye oifx,ai Trpos eKao-rw yiyvo^evov ju^|
Xavddvfiv dAA.' o^e'cos alvOdvecrOai irepi ov ay jneAXr/ epetf
5 irorepou 5y ruyxdyei rou yeVou?.
5

e 2 ^jur)/ T : u/ui' B
as TOIOVTWV B T : Svruv corr. Coisl. : fort.
bvofidroov H. Richards
6^oj/o7jTt/ca>s T Galenus : oi> fj.6vov -jroirjriK&s B
b 7 8e? B : S^j T
b 8 irA^flos T : eTSos B
C i eTSoj addubitat
H. Richards

*AIAPO2

2630

4>AI. Tt MV;
212. Tt

ovv;

TOV epcora

Trorepoy <<3p;>

etrat

dju.^to-ySrjrrjo-t/jicoi' ^ raw p-??;

<I>AI. T0y d/>i0tcr/3?]T7]crt/;xa)y Si/Troir ^ o?et ay (rot
pfjcrai

etireiy a yw8r) etTj-es1 Trept avroi;, co? /3Ad/3?] re ecrrt 10

rS epcop,ey&) Kat epwyrt, Kat aS^ts coy /xeytcrroi' (6V)

212. "AjOtcrra Aeyets* dAA.' eiTre Kat ro8e lyco yap rot d
8ta ro tvOovcriaa-TLKOv ov irdvv jue/xvTjjaat et &>/ot(raju7]z; Ipcora
dpx.o/xei'OS1 row Aoyou.
4>AI. N^ Ata d/x7])(aycos ye w? (rtyobpa.
212.

<t>ei!, oVw Aeyets re)(ytK&)Tepa? Nv/M<^as' ray 'A^eAwou 5

/cat rTara roy cEp/>ioS Au(rw ToO Ke^)dAou Trpos Aoyous

?/ ov8ey Ae'yco, dAAa Kat 6 Aucrtas ap^o^vos TOV
r/jjias

v-noXafielv

TOV "Epcora ei> rt rwy OVTWV o

Xridr], Kat Trpos TOVTO ^817 ffWTadfji.Vo$ TidvTa TOV Q

v<TTepov Xoyov SteTrepdz^aro; jSovAet TrdAtz; avayv&^v Trjv

CLVTOV;
<I>AI. Et crot ye 8oKer 6 p-ezrot ^rjrer? OVK ecrr' amoOi.
212. Aeye, tya aKovo"co avTov fKfivov.

Ilept jutey rwy ep:coi' Trpay/xdrco^ emcrrao-ai, Kat eo?

iMV TOVTO>V yevopevdov, a.Kr]Koa$.

aiS>

8e p,i) 8ta roCro drw^0"01 &v beop.ai, OTL OVK. epacrTris &>v
trov Tvy^dvoo.

264

w? eKetfots p.er rore pierajaeAet wy ay ev

7roi7J(rco(ny, fireibav rfjs

e7n0ityuas Travcrtoiraf"

212. TH TroAAcw 8ety eotKe Trotery 6'8e ye 6 ^TOV^V, 6s

ove cnr' ap)(j]s dAA' aTro TeAenr^s e viTTias av airaAty 8taye?y 5
Aoyor, Kat ap^erat d^>' <3y TTfTrav^vos

av ^877

e 9 eYxcop^at codex Marcianus Galeni : <rt'7xa'P^(ra' ^ ^

c n Sv
addidi auctore Heindorfio (kyaficov &v infra Hirschig)
d. 4 ws T :
om. B
d 6 nSva] -navra B T : del. T b t
Atfyous T : A. 6yov B :
\<5'yo^ al.
e 6 eTrtoTatrai B : eirtcrrayuot T
a 2 Tore T : rb
TfJre B
a 4farov/itei'f>s T :faTovjievosB
a 5 Siave"iv B T :
Sicwuet*' rec. b
PLATO, VOL. II.

18

264 a

IIAAT&NOE
6 epaorr/s Ae'yot irpbs ra TratStKa.

r) o-i>8h> elTrov,

4>AL vEo-riy ye rot 77, 2> Sco/cpares, reAevrrj, irept ov roy

Ao'yoy Trotetrat.
212. Tt 8e raAAa; ov ^vSTjy So/cei /Se/SAr/crflai ra row
Aoyou; rj ^atVerai ro $VTpov etprj/uteVoz; CK rivo? a^dy/crj?
Sevrejooy 8eti; redrjvai, % rt aAAo raiy priOevToov; e/xot /xey
-yap &oev, a>s ^r]bev eiSori, OVK dyervws ro eTrioy flpfjcrOai
rw ypdfpovTL- crv 8' ex^ts rtra avdyKrjv Xoyoypa(j)U<.r]V if
raCra K(ivos OVTCOS (perjs Trap' aAArjAa fdr/Kfv;
^AI. Xpj](rros el, ort /ne ^yrj IK<U>OZ; eZrat ra eKeivov
ovrcos aKpt/3wy 8tt8eTy.
Sfl. 'AAAa ro'Se ye ot)uai ere (f>avai av, Sety Trayra Aoyov
axnrep >ov (rvvecrravai crS>^a rt e^ovra avrov avrov, OXTTG
p,rjre aKtfyaXov etVat p:?jre aTrour, dAAa p,eVa re e'^ety feat
a/cpa, 7rpeirozn-a dAA?jAot9 Kat r5 oAw yeypap,jaeya.
4JAI, Ho)? yap ov;
Sil. 2jce'\^at TOIVVV TOV TOV eratpou crou \6yov etre
oi'rcos etre aAAcos- ex^ij KCII evpTjcrets TOU eTTtypa/Zjuaros
8ta</)e'poyra, o MtSa rw c^p^yi ^ao-ty rtye? emyeypa<0ai.
4>AI. rTotoy rouro, Kat rt -nfirovdos;
SH. "Ecrrt pei' ro{5ro ro'8e
XaAK?7 irapOevos eip,t, Mt8a 8' em <r?jp;ari
o(pp' av w'Scop re yarj Kat 8ey8pea p.aKpa
avrou r^8e ^evovcra TroAixcAavrov eirt
dyyeAea) TraptoScri MtSay ort r^Se

e ort 8' ov8ey 8ta<|)epet avrou 7rp<3roy ^ ija-rarov rt Aeyeo~0at,

evvoeis TTOV, ws eyw/xat.
212.

ToCrov juey TOLWV, Iva p.^ cr

a 7 6/>a<TT$js recc. : epao-0els B T

b 5 S^rv seel. Madvig : 5^
Schanz
b 9 /te T : ^ B
03 troi/ta rt t : <rui/j.aTi B T
04 ju^re a.Kf(pa\ov T: ^ TO o.Ke<f>a.\ov B
d 3 yu/8 T: /i(8oi B
63 ^/twv B : om. T

2646
/catrot (rvxya ye ^XLV A*01 &OK? 7rapa8ety/zara Trpo? a rts 5
(3\Tt(av ovivaiT1 av, ju,tjueicr$a6 aura firi^ip&v /XT/ Trow rt
eis 8e rows' erepous Aoyow o/iez\ r\v yap rt ey aurais, ws
8oK(3, TTpOO-fJKOV

Ibtlv TOLS ^OvXofJifVOLS

Tltpl AoyCOV

(TKOTtflv.

^AI. To TTOLOV br) Aeyets;

265
2H. 'E^a^rico TTOI; ^Vrr/y 6 juey yap ws- rw epStvn, 6 8'
W? rw //^ 8e?
^AI. Kat
212. "Llipjv (re TaX.r)Oes epelv, OTL /xaft/cws 1 6 [livroi 5
e$rovy ea-rty a^ro roSro. ^aviav yap TWO. etyrja-anei' tlvai,
TOV epcora. 77 yap;
. Nat.
. Memas 8e ye e?8j] 8vo, r7)y fxey VTTO vocrrmdrcov
, rqv 8e VTTO 0e<fas efaAAay^s riSi' etco^o'rcov 10
ye.
e 0etas rerrapa>i> ^e&)i> rerrapa
\i.o.VT\.K.j\v fjiev fTiiTrvoiav 'ATToAAcoyos Oevres, AIOVIXTOV 8e
-cor 8' aS 7rotrjri/c^, TtTapTrjv 8e 'Afppobirrjs
s, p(Ti.Kr]i> fj.aviav e^)7;o"a/>teV re apia'Tijv eZ^ac, 5
t OVK o?8' 07777 ro epcortKoz; 7ra0os aTretKa^brres, to-coy

tvos e^aTrro'/xeyot, raxa ^' ^y Ka' aAAoo~e

Kepacrarres o^ TravTaTrao-iv aTilOavov \6yov,
TWO, v[j.vov 7rpoo-e7rata-ap,ey pterptcos re /cat
e/iov re Kat aw SecrTroVrji' vEpcora, a)
<I>AI. Kat /idAa e/x,otye OVK dr
212. ToSe TOIVVV avrodev \d(3u>}Jiev, ws aTro rot)
ro tTraive'iv tcryjEv 6 Ao'yo?
. ETiSs 8?) ow awro Aeyets;
e6 fiXeircav </*/) . . . /j.iju,e?<r6ai (8') Herwerden
e 7 ertpovs
T : eraipovs B
b 2 reTrdpuiv 6ecat> seel. Schanz
b 5 T
c rr Par
B T : om. Stobaeus
b8 Aoyo" o - 1808: A^-you B T
C 4 ffj.oiye B : e'jitol /iff T

266

212. 'E/xoi fj^v (paivtrai TO, \i\v aAAa ra> OVTI

TifnalcrBai' TOVTMV be rivcav IK Tv^rjs prjOtvTdov ftvolv
ei airroiv rriv diW/uy re^rj Aa/3eiz> 8watro us, ot>*c a^api.
4>AI. TtW 877;
212. EZ? juuav re i5eay crvvop&VTa ayetv ra TroAAax?]
Siecnrap/xeVa, iW eKacrroy dpi^o^evos $rj\ov TOIT) Trepl ov ay
del 8i8d(r/cet^ e0eA.rj. wo-Trep ra i>w8r) Trept "Epcoros & e<rnz>
opiaOtv err' eS eire KaKws eA.e)(0rj, ro yotip (rat^es Kat TO
avro a^ro) o^oXo-yov^vov 5ta rct/Cra etr^ey eiTreT^ 6 A.oyos.
4>AI. To 5' erepoy 5r) eiSo? TI A.eyets, (b ScoKpares;
212. To TraAty Kar' ei^rj $vva(r9ai ^lar^veiv K.O.T apOpa
fi TT(pVKev, Kal pvr] Tn\LpiV naToyvvvai //.epos nybcv, KCLKOV
/xayetpoD rpOTrw yj>u>n,tvov dA.A.' wcnrep aprt TO> Ao'yco ro
jaei> atppov rfjs btavoias v ri KOW^ eiSos eXa^er^i/, axnrtp
8e o-wjuaros e^ eroj 8177X0, jcat 6[jLu>vvp,a irl(pvK, (TKatd, ra 8e
eta KXrjOevra, ovrco Kat ro r?7S Trapavotas ws (ey) er T7/mu>
eZ8os ^y?]o-aju,eyco rco Xo'yco, 6 /xey ro ITT' dptarepa
/x,epo9, TraAiy roCro re'jui>coi> OVK eiraviJKfv Trplv fv
cri/Tois e^evpoby ovo^a^o^vov (TKOLIOV riva, epcora eAot8oprjo-ey
8tKTj, 6 8' eis ra ey 8e^ta rTys fxartas dyaywy ^/Aas,
eKeiVw, 0etoy ' aS rtva epcora e^eupcoy KCU
Trporetya/jieros eTrrjvecrfv a>? pieytcrrcoy atrtoy
^AI. 'AA.r]0eo-rara Aeyet?.
S12. Tovrcoy 8r) eycoye a-yro's re epao-r?^?, S>
Siatpecrecoy Kat o-waycoywy, iW oto's re S Ae'yety re Kat
(ppovelv eay re rw' aAAoy ^yTyo-cojuiat Svi^aroy eis Iv /cat em
C 8 TroiStij T : iratSia B
09 TreTraTcr&u T : -rreTrecrOcu B
rtj/aii'
. - . ^riOtvTtaf^ n vipv . . . pr]8ev rb TO?!/ Badham
elSori/] etSic
Galenus
d i auroti/ B T : aiirV vulg.
d 5 TOI B T : rb Schanz
d 8 S)j T : ju$j B
e i /car' B T : /cal TQS Madvig
Siarf/nveiv T
Stobaeus Galenus : Tfj.veii> B
a i o-<^uaros B T : o-cfytcm Stobaeus
iretyvice (T/ccito T Stobaeus: irefyvxts' Kal & B
ra Se Stobaeus:
rctSe ^ B T
as irapavoias B T : trapoivlas Stobaeus
li/ eV
Heindorf : eV B T : ej/ al. : om. Stobaeus
fi/uv T Stobaeus : V/MV B
as rb B T : om. Stobaeus
a 4 7rai/rjKi/ B T : df^/cev Stobaeus
ev aurois B T : eavrots Stobaeus
a 7 Kal seel. Badham

4>AIAPO2

a66b

iroAAa TTtcjtVKod' opav, TOVTOV Stw/cco " KaroVitrfle />ier'

fymov &>are dtolo" Kat /JLCVTOI Kal TOVS bwajj-evovs avro
bpav et fjJev opd&s ~rj pr) Trpo<rayopevu>, Ofbs olbe, KaA<3 be
ovv fJ'fXP'- TO^e 8taAeKrt/coi;s. ra 8e vvv irapa crou re Kat c
Awtov fJiadovTas etTre rt XP^ KaAe?y ^ roOro eKeiW eorir 77
Aoya>y reyyr], p &pao-vfj.a^os re Kat ot aAAot ^putfJifVOL cro^ot
//.ev avrot Aeyeiy yeyoyao-tr, aAAot;? re TTOLOVO-IV, ol av
bcapocpopelv avrois ws /3acriAeu<ru> fdeXuiartv;
5
aAAa roSro i&v ro et8os 6p6S>s eyu,otye 8oKe
ro 8e prjropiKov boKel /xot Sta^evyetv
212. ETw? (frfo; /caAoV 'TTOV ri ay &r\, 6 TOVTCOV CLTTOev O/JLCDS Tex.vy Aaju/Sa^erat; Tra^rcos 6' CWK art/xacrreoy
awro o-ot re Kal e/^iot, Ae/cre'o^ 8e rt /xe^rot xat etrrt ro
r^s pr]TOpii<i]s.
. Kat //.dAa -TTOU <rv\vd, S 2co/c/9ares, ra y' ez/ rois
/3t/3Atois ro?s irept Aoytoy T^VIJS yeypa/^ieVois1.
212. [Kat] KaAws ye vTre/^o-as. Trpooifj-iov /xer oT/xat
TTp&rov &>s 8e^ roi) Ao'yov Aeyecr^ai ez> apxti' T^vra Ae'yets
77 ya/s; ra Ko/xi^a r?ys Tf-^vrjs;
4>AI. Nat'.
212. Aevrepor 8e 8^ liriyrja-iv nva papTVptas T l-n
avrr), rpfoov r e K j j i r i p i a , Ttraprov et/cora- xat 7rt<rra)o-ty
ot)uat Kat eTTtTrtorrcocrty Aeyetz/ roz> ye /SeArtoToy AoyoSat8aAoy BuaVrtoz> avbpa.
4>AI. Tor \prjarov Aeyets eoScopor;
212. Tt //,?^; Kal eAeyxov ye Kat e-Tre^e'AeyxozJ a>s
Trotrjreoz; ey Karrj-yopiq re Kat aTroAoyta. roy Se KaAAtcrroy
b 7 Tre^v/cJfl'] -ireQvicbs B T Stobaeus : jre^wcJra vulg.
b9 ^^
T : ef /u^ B
C i Se j/uj/ B : j/Cf Se T
C 2 /j.a66vras B : juadovres T :
fia66i>Ta H. Richards
c6 Sj/Spes Bekker : Si/Spes B T
07 rJ> T:
om. B
d 7 KO! seel. Hirschig
d 8 eV apxi? T:
seel. ci. Schanz
e 4 \oyoSaiSa\ov T (et legit Cicero) :

: \6joiv Aai5a\ov Winckelmann

5
267

267 a

10
C

IIAAT&NOS
ndptoy Evr]vbv s jue'croi> OVK ayojuer, bs vTiobij\a>criv re
TrpwTOs rjSpey Kat TraptTraivovs ot 8' avrbv KOI Trapatyoyovs <pacrlv eV fterpw Ae'yeiu JU^JWTJS X"Piy trotyos yap avr\p.
Teio-iav 8e Fopyiav re eda-oju,ei> eu'Seu', o't irpo r<Sz> dATjflcot;
ra eiKora ei8oi> ws ri/^Tjrea fxaAAor, ra re aS cr/u,iKpa /u,eyaAa
Ka^ ra jueyaAa cr/xiKpa (paivecrdaL TTOLOVCTIV 8ta pco/x,T]i; A.oyoi;,
Kaiya re ap^atco? rd r' evavria K.aivG>s> (rvvro^iav re A.oycor
Kat cnretpa /XT^KI; Trept irdvTcov avr/vpov; ravra 8e
TTOTC juou HpoStKOS lyeXao-ey, Kat
wy 8et A.oya>y ryvr]v' beiv 8e ovre
dAAa fj.Tpiu>v.
4>AI. 2o<pcorard ye, 2 IlpoStKe.
2H. 'iTnrtay 8e ou Aeyo/xev; oipxu yap ar <Tvpjrr](pov
avrw Kai TOV 'HXeioy vov yevfcrOai.
4>AI. Ti' 8' o{;;
212. Ta 8e IIcoXoi; TTWS <ppacra)jnez> at! ^ovcrela \6y(v a>s
SiTrXao'toXoytai' Kal yvut^oXoylav Kat etKovoA.oytai'
o^ojudroor re AiKD/junooy a eKeww e8copr/craro irpos
eveireta?;
4>AI. ripcorayopeta <, 2> 2a>Kpares, O{IK -^r
rotaur' drra;
2H. 'Op^oeTtetci ye rt?, w Tra?, Kal aA.A.a TroXAa
KaAd. rwy ye p)z> olnrpoyoatv em y^pas
oyaiv KeKparrjKeVat T\vr] p,ot (patVerai TO TOU
crOevos, opyto-at Te av TroAAov? ajixa Setyos ayrjp
yeyoyey, Kat TrdAty wpytcrjueyots eTTaScoy KrjAeu^, w? e(pr]'
8ta/3aAAety re Kai aTroA^tracr^at 8ta/3oAas o^eySrj KparicrTos.
a 3 <=s B : ets T
as ai/r;p Bekker : cb^p B T
a 6 Se in
ras. T to 4 T*yyi]v B T : Texvy Stephanus
Selv corr. Par. 1808 :
Seivct B T
1) 7-8 lirirtav . . Tbv fyte'iov T : nriretaj' . . . rbi/ TJAtoi' B
b 10 <ppa<T<afjiv B : <f>pa<rofji.ev T : (ou) <ppd.ffofji.ev Schanz
&>s B : 6s T
C 2 \iKvjiivieiwiv Ast
& enfivcf fScap-^craTO seel. Ast
vrpbs Troiyffu'
B T : irpoo-eiroirjffev Cornarius
C 3 euen-efas B T : tveirtiav Schanz
C 9 Ka\X'?8oi'ioy Herwerden
opyitrai re T : opyiffairo B
aHp
Bekker : ew/V B T
d a gflev 5ij Par. 1808 : 'oBev 5e? B T

<J>AIAP02

a67

ro 8e 817 reAos r<Sy Ao'ycoy KOIVIJ iraaiv eotKe <rw8e8oyp,eVoy

et^at, <u rtye? /iei eTrdyo^oy, aAAot 6' aAAo rt0eyrat 6vo[j.a.
<J>AI. To

ez> Ke(aAaia) ecaora Ae'yets VTro^vrjcraL

reAeur?/? rous aKovovras irepi ra>y

eiri 5

flpr]fj.fvu>v;

212. TaOra Ae'yco, Kat et rt (TV aAAo exet? f'71"^ Ao'y6oz>

TT pi.

a ye Kal o^/c af6a Aeyetr.

8r) rd ye o-/xt/cpd- raSra 8e i7r' avyas /x.aAAoz'
Tiva Kat TroV e^et r?)!' r^s re'x^rj? bvvaiuv.
4>AI. Kal /xciAa ejOpcoju-eVrjiJ, S 2a)K/oares, eV ye

268

Sr)

212. vE)(et yap. dAA', S 8ai/ioVie, t8e /ecu orv et apa Kal 5
(rot ^ati'erat StecmjKos amG>v TO rjTpiov uxnrfp

e/xot.

<i>AI. AeiKvve [JLOVOV.

212. Et-Tre 877 /xor et rt? Trpo<rek6(av rS> eratp<a (rou
'Epufijua^w ^ ro> irarpt atroi; 'Afcov/xei'S eiTrot ort " 'Eya>
eirtcrra/xat rotaSr' arra (rcojuarrt Trpoo-^epetz', (?<rre depnaiveiv

10

r* ear /SovAco/uat Kat ^nJ^ew;, KCXI ear /otev SO^TJ juot, e/xety b
Trotety, eav S' aS, KOTCO taxa>/)et'y, Kat aAAa Tra/XTroAAa
rotaura1

Kat eTrtordjueyos avra aia> tarptKos etrat Kat

aAAoy iroLeiv w ay r^r rovrcoy eTrioTTy/itrjy TrapaSw," rt ay

otei aKovcravTas etirety;

4>AI. Tt 8' aAAo ye ?? e/aecr^at et Trpoo-eTTtcrrarai Kat

ovortyas Set Kat oirore e/caora TOVTOOV Tioitiv, Kat y^e^pt
OTTOCTOV;
212. Et oSy e?7rot ort " Ov8a/nwy

!cf

dAA' d^tco roy raCra

Trap' e/uou ^adovra avrov olov r' ewat [Troter^] a epcoras; " c
4>AI. EtTrety ay o^at ort p;atyerat cLvOpwiros, Kat e/c
d.4 ridfvrai T : ridevres B
a I UTT' 011701? /taAAov TW: uTra^acTyUa
/caA.J/ B
a s irJr' B T : TTOT' vulg.
a 8 etVe T b : e^Trep pr. B
a 9 ' AKovfjievcf^ a.KovfjLfV(f
BT
a 10 crJi^acri B T : ff^juari V
b r yuei' T : ^ B (in ras. )
l>3 ^Tno-Tdpevos b : eTrto-Ta/xeVoi/s B T
larpiK^s B : larpits T
b 6 8' &AAo -ye T : ye &VA.O B
C I iroieiv
seel. Buttmann : iirateiv Schleiermacher
cs eiVerj/ scrips!:
tyTotey Stephanus : efrrot B T
Hvdptavos Bekker : &v6p<airos B T

268c

IIAAT&NO2

j3i/3X(ov TToOev aKov&as T/ TtepiTV)(u>v (pap^aKioLs tarpos

oterat yeyoz/eVai, oiibfv lira'tooy rTjs re^vr]?.
5
2H. Tt 8' ei 2o(poKAei av TrpocreAflaw Kal EvptirtSrj rts
ws emcrrarat Trept a-p.iK.pov Trpay/zaros prja~is Tr
Ka Trepi fxeyaAou iravu (r/xiKpas, orai> re
otlcrpas, Km TOVVCLVTLOV av (pofBepas Kal aTreiA^Tifca^ o<ra r'
d aAAa rotaCra, Kat 8t8ci(rKa)y avra rpayw^tas iroirjaiv oterat
Kat ovrot av, u> SwKpares, o?jaat KarayeAwer et
oterai rpaycoSiay aAAo ri
AA?}Aot? T6 Kttl T(S

2H. 'AAA' OVK ay aypoiKco? ye ot/icu Aot8op?|cretay, aAA'

wcnrep ay /xou<nKos evru)(a)y ay8pt oio/utei'a) apju,oytKw eimi,
on 8rj ruy^ayet iTTtorra/xeros &>? otoy re d^VTar^y KOI /3apurarrjv yppvi}V Trotety, OVK dypicos etTrot ay "
'
" aAA' a r e juovcrtKo? a>i> Ttpqotfpov ort
apicrre, avayKf] ^\v Kal ravr' eTTicrrao-^ai ror
appoviKov eo-ecr^at, oi/Sey urp KcoAvet /xr]8e
5 e7rcueu> roy rrjy crrjy egiy e^o^ra* ra yap
avayKcua jua^/xara eTTtcrracrat aAA' ou ra app.ovi.Ka
269

4>AI. 'QpOffra.T& ye.

2O,. OLIKOW Kat 6 Scx^oKAr/s roy crfyuriv e
ra irpo rpaya>8tas ay (/>ai?] aAA' ov ra rpaytKa, Kat 6 'A/covra Trpo larpiKrjs aAA' ov ra tarpt/cd.

2ii. Tt 8e rov jaeAtyr/ptJV "ASpacrroy olo^Oa rj Kal

IlepiKAea, et aKOvo-eiav &v vvvbr] ^ju-et? 8tr)//,ey rwy -jrayKdAcov
re^vrjjudrcoy ppay^vXoyi&v re Kat etKovoAoy'twz; Kat ocra
aAAa SteA^orres -WTT3 avya? e^)ap,ey el^at o-Keirrea.Trorepor
a2
' avrovs, wo-Trep eyoj re Kal crv, ^TT' aypoikids
C 8 aS W : Koi oS B T
S<ra ra\\a ' sic) roiaCra Kol 85tcrKa)i'
T : /cal Sera raA.A.a (sic) TOiaCTa SiSao-Ktov B
d. 5 irpeirovo'at' T :

Tpeirovffav B
t : irpbs B T

d6Y6B:TeT
e i aypoiitais Osann
e 5 7rp&
as oW/wO' <&>/> Hirschig
a 8 au-y&s T : OVT&S B

<I>AIAPO2

ai

a rt elire'iv cnrafoevTov eis TOVS raCra yeypac^ora? re Kat

StSao-Koyra? &>? pqropiKyy Ttyyriv, rj are f)p,tv ovras o-0(pcorepou? K&V v&v eTHirAT^ai etTiwra?' "M2 4>at8pe re Kat
OT; XP''? \aXtTraiv civ ctAAa o-uyyiyixocr/ceii', ei rive? 5
8taAe'ye(r^at dSwraroi eyevovro
prjropiKrj, e/c 8e roz^roi; roS Tra^ous Va
dyayxat'a jaa^/ixara e^ovre? pt}Topua]v arjO
KCU ravra 6^ dtSao-Koyres aXXovs fj-yovvrat oopiKr)v ^fbibd^Oai, TO 8e e/ca<rra rovrtov
A.eyeii> re xat ro 6'Aoy crtwo-racr&H, owSey e'joyoy (6V), avroi)s
8eu/ Trap' eaurwy roi)s //.a^rjras (npcov TropC^frdai V TOLS
Aoyots".
. , .,
<i>AI. 'AAAa /xT/y, 2> 2coKpares, Kivbvvevh ye rotouroV
rt ea>cu ro r^? T\vr]s rjv OVTOL oi avbpes w? pr]TopiKi]v
re Kat ypafyovcriv, /cat ejuotye 8oKet? aX.r)0r) dprjaAAa 8^ r?)y rot) r<3 6Wt prjTOpLKov re Kat TnQavov
TTWS Kat TTodev av rt? 8watro Tropto-acr^ai;
,
212. To jue^ SvvaaOai, 3> ^atSpe, a><rre aycoi'ta-r^i'rre/Aeoy
yeve'cr^at, etKosItrcos 8e Kat az/ayKatoy ^Xety &"Kp raAAav
et //ey o-ot wdp^et (frvcret. prjroptKO) etVat, eo-rj prjToop eAAoyt/xo?, 7rpoo"Aay8a)y eirto'rTjju,?;!' re Kat /xeXeY^y, orou 8' ay 5
eAAetTTTj? TOVTMV, ravrr) dreA^? ecrrj. 6Voz> 8e avrou
o^x $ Awi'a? re Kat pa<rvfj,axos Tropeverat SoKet /xot
f] /x,e0o&o?.
'AAAa TTT) 817;
212. KiySuyet/et, a> apto-re, etKorcos 6 HeptKA^s Trayrcov
reAewraros et? rr)y prjropLKrjv ytvecrQai.
4>AI. Tt 5?j;
212. ITafrat o^rat fxeydAai rcSr rex^wf 7rpoo"8eoyrat
b 2 ^^ TI T : p^juari B
b 7 ftrjTopiicr) B : ^ pt\TopiK.4\ T
03 owSe? epyof ov Heindorf : ouSev epyov B T : cbs oi>8ej/ epyov ov
Hermias
04ff<f>cav]sfyGiv B: CT^OJJI/ T
06 -ye T : om. B
C 8 5o/eejj T : So/ce? B
d 4 ^ropi/coS T : priropiKbs B
d 5 OTOU
B T : OTTOU Aldina
d 6 e\\etTrrjs T Aristides : eAAt'irps B
drcA^s
T : dreAes B
d 7 Au<rfos] Gorgias Ficinus : Tris Schaefer

270 a

HAAT&NOS
3ao~!t >..!:,'. , W t _ > c 3 ' . < * - i

.\{t).:'-:,.','-Tla'.j{ioV,^vcr,J^4.

,<

270 dSoAeo-xia? Kat ju.erecopoAoyia^' <pt;o-ea)? Trepr TO yap i>

AoVovy roCro Kal -jrayrrj reAeo-iovpyoy eot/cey fvrevOtv Ti
eio"ieyat. 6 Kai Hepi/cAr^s Trpos rai finpv^s etyat eKTTjo'aro'
Trpo(TTT(Tu>v yap ot/uai rotowrw oz>ri 'Ayaayopa, /xerecopo*
5 Aoytas e/xTTAT] crflets Kai em (pvanv vov re Kai 8iayoi$cis atyiKo&v ^ Trept roy 7roA.i;v Aoyoy eTrotetro 'Az^a^ayqpas,
ei'AKiicrei> CTTI rrjy rwi^ Aoycoy TeyvTqv TO Trpocrcpopov
avrfj.
4>AI. n<3s roCro Aeyeis;
2Ii. 'O avros irov TPOTTOS TeyvT]'S iar/n/c?7? ocrirep Kat

817;
2H. 'Ey d/ji^)orepats e SteAeV^ai (f)vcn.v, crco/xaro?
5 ez> rr/ erepa, v/n;)(^s ly TTJ erepa, ei /xeAAets, /xr) T
povov KOL e/A7reipta dAAa Tevrrj, TW /x,ev </>apjuctKa /cat
7rpO(r(f>fp(i)v vyieiav Kgl pco/XTj);"'eju7rot7]creti', r^ 8e Ao'yovs re
xat eTrmjSeuo-eis vojju^ovs TretSa) 7;y ay jSovX-rj Kat a
10

4>AI. To yow etKO?, S SwKpares, ovrcos.

212. ^i^s oSz; (^vo-tv d^co? Ao'you KaravoTja-ai otet
bvvarbv etvai. avzv rijs TOV oAou (^vo-ecos;
4>AI. Et /iey 'iTTTTOK/aciTet ye r<S rwy
8et re TnOecrOcu, ovbe itfpl a-cofxaros areu r?)s
. KaAcSs yap, S era^pe, Ae'yef XP^) p-fvroi Trpos rw
roz> Aoyoy e^erd^byra crKOTrety et

212. To roivvv Trept <pvcr<AS o-Koiret rt Trore Aeyei '

10 Kpdr]s re /cai 6 dArj^s Ao'yos. ap' o^x <S8e Set 8tayoeio-0at
a 2 /cai B : Kal ri> T
TeAeo-tou/rybc B Plutarchus : reKeaiovpyiiibv
T: re\effiepyov Badham
a 4 rojouTip T : rip B
a 5 Siavoias
V Aristides : dw'as B T : ewoias al.
a 6 3>v T b -. 6v pr. B
b4 eV T: om B
b? T S e T : T$ 8^ B
C2 3AowTW:
\6yov B
c 3 76 Heindorf : re B T : om. Galenus
rcav B T :
om. pr. T
04 irideaQai T : ire{0fc<r0ai B

,vu.
irept OTOVOVV <vcros" Trp&rov \t.iv, aTrAow 77 TroAvetSes d
etrrtz; oii Tre'pt /3oi>A.?j<TO|U,el9a eli>at airroi rexwfcot Ka' aAAoi>
Swarot 7Toteu>, e-Tretra Se, az> ju.ei' aTrAow 77, cr/co77ety rr]v
bvvap.iv avTOv, riva Trpos rt Trz^VKtv ds TO bpav t\ov rj
riva els TO iraOt'iv VTTO row, eay 8e TtXetco etSrj e)(7j, ravra 5
OTre/o e0' ei'os1, roi;r' tSely e^>' e/cdoroi;, TW rt
avTo TTf^vKev rj r<S rt Tra^eiy T;TTO roS;
ySv^ewt, a)
2H. C H yoSy a^ei)
TV(f>Xov TrtipeCq.
aAA' o-u JU,T)^ air^tkao-reoy rov ye
jaertoVra ortoSy rf^Aai o^Se jcto^w, dAA.a SrjAoy ws, av
rw rt? Tex.yrj Ao'yoi;? 8t8(3, r?jy ovcfiav Setfet aKptjSai? rTys
^wcreo)? rovrou Trpos 6 rows A.oyot>s 7rpb(roi(ref J etrrat 8e iron
T//I>)(T) rouro.
5
Ti MV;

,,;

. OvKoCi' 17 a/xtXAa atirw rerarat Trpo? roCro Tracra1 271

yap ey rovrSi Trote?^ TT^Lpe'i. rj "/dp;
4>AI. Nat.
212. A?jAoy apa on 6 0pao-?5ju,a)(09 re Kal o? ay aAAos
acrr/ a/cpi/3eta ypax/m 5
re /cat -Trotrjfret irt)^ry t e , TtoTepov ey Kat ojaotov Tt
i] /cara <rcop,aros jjLopfpyv TroAvetSes' roCro yap <j)a[j,ev (pvcriv

211.

. navraTrao-t /u,ey oSy.

Aevrepoy 8e ye, orw ri Trotety ^ iraOelv inrb TOV 10

4>AI. Tt
212. TpiTov 8e 8^ Stara^ajaeyos ra Aoytor re Kat \l/v)(rjs b
feat ra TOVTMV TtaQri^ara 8tet(rt Tracras atria?, irpo<rape'/cacrVoi' e/cacrno Kat StSdcrKcoy ota ovcra
d. 5 TOU T : ToOSe B
d. 6 apidiJiija'dfj.evov Galenus : ap
B T : apid/jL-rtffafj.evovs
Stephanus
d 7 aurb recc. : avr^J B T :
oSrco V
e i 76 B : om. T
63 T<J> T : om. B
e4 & T:
om. B
a 10 TI T : om. B
b 2 Trdcras T W : TS B

271 b

nAATHNOS

X6ya)V 5t' fjv alriav e avayKrjs 77 ptv 7rei0erat, ff Se

, ,'tiLa^ '_;:?::<..
5 cra-etc/ei.
4>AI. KaAAto-ra yovv av, ws eot/c', e^ot ovrcos.
212. Ovrot /jier ow, & </>tAe, aAAcoy evbakvy^vov rj
Xcyopevov T\vrj Trore Ae^^crerat $ ypa^Tjo-erat owe u
C ciAAo ovre rowo. dAA.' 01 rw ypa</>oi>res, wz^ <ri>
Aoycoy iravovpyov eicriy Kat aTTOKpvTTTOVTCu,
TTtpi jrayKciAcos' Trpti^ &z> ovy rov rpoTrov TOVTOV
re xat ypd</)ajcr
<AI. Tiya TOVTOV;
2O. Avra juei> ra
ypa(f>iv, d /xeAAei re^i/cais exeiv ta^' o<roz>
Aeyeti' l^e

10

212. 'EireiSr) Aoyou Swa/us ruyxa^fi ^n)\ayu>yi.a ovcra,

d toy /xeAAoira prjTopiKov ta-eaOai, avayKi] elbevai ^vx^? ^cra

et8rj exel eo'Ttv oSv rotra /cat roVa, KCU rora /cat rom,
o^ey ot /xer rototSe, 01 8e rotoiSe yLyvovTai" TOVTU>V 8e 81)
ovro) birjpr]ij.eva)v, Xoya>v av roVa /cat rotra etrrty et8?j,
5 e'/caoroz;. ot /xev oSr rotoiSe VTTO rwy rotwySe
6ia r?7f8e r^y aiTiav es ra roia8e WTTfiOeis, ol be rototSe
8ta ra8e SucrTret^ets" Se? Sr) raCra i/carwy yo?)(rai'ra, /xera
ratira 6e(afj,vov avra er ra^y Trpa^zcriv ovra re /cat TrpaTTO6 jaei'a, o^ecoj rfj aia-^a-et bvvacrOai, eiraKoXovdeiv, r) fj,rjbfv
tlvai mo i:\tov avrw wy rore TJKOVCV Xoycov (rvvdv. orav
8e eiTreiy re iKay&is ex^? otos v<' otcoy Tret^erat, irapayiyvopfvov re Swaros ^ Siatar^ai'Ofx.eyos laurw evbeiKVvcr9aL ort
272 owroy e<rrt /cat atfr?; 17 (f)V(ri.s Trept ^? rore ^o-ay ot Aoyot,
b 7 ofrroj] OUTOI B : ovroi T
d 3 roiofSe . . . roioiSe T Galenus :
roloi . . . ToioiSe B : TOIOJ . . . roTot Hermann
8e S^ B : 8e T
Galenus
d.4 otfreo T Galenus : om. B
S r^ffa T : avrbs & B
rot^Se B T : roidvSc Se Galenus
d 5 /j.ev o5v T Galenus : nev B
d 6 e's B : et'y T
d 8 at-rd recc. : aiirbv B T : avrb Galeni cod.
Marc.
e i if) /uT/Sep efrai Galenus : ct fify et'SeVoi B : ^ yur/Se ei'Serat
T
6 2 aury B T : avr&v vulg.
e 4 re T Galenus : 5 B

<t>AIAPO2
vvv pyu> Trapovaa ol, fj irpocroi,(TTov rovcr8e o58e TOVS
Xoyovs em TTJV rwz^e 7ra0cj, ravra 8' 7/817 -TrdVra
7rpo<rAa/3o/rrt Kaipovs rov TroYe AeKrecw Kal
/Spax^Aoyia? re at! Kat eAetyoAoyias Kat 8 e mo crews eKaVrcov
re ocra ay eTSrj /^IO^TJ Ao'ycoy, rovrcoi/ T^y tvKaipiav re Kat
biayvovTi, KctAws re Kat reAe'cos eortv 17 re'^Tj
Trporepov 8' oir dAA' ort ay aiiT&v ris
eAAetTT?; Ae'ycoz; ^ 8t8a(rKa>y ?} -ypatpoiv, ^>T/ 8e Te'^frj Ae'yeii*,
6 //.^ TTi.d6}j<evos KpciTfL.
" Ti 8^ oSy; ^Tycret tcrco? 6 (rvyypatyevs, a> ^aiSpe' re Kat 2co/cparey, 8o/cei ovrats; ju^ aAAcos
airobcKTeov AeyojueVrj? Ao'ycoy T^vrjs; "
'A8waroV 'TTOU, ScoKpares, aAAcos* Kairot ov
ye </>aiz>erat Hpyov.
212. 'AAr;^ Aeyets. rowou rot evfKa \pr] TTCLVTCLS TOVS
koyovs avo) Kal Karca jueracrrpe^oyra eTrtcrKOTretv et rts TTT;
Kal ftpa^vTfpa tyaiverai ITT' avrriv 686s, iva ju^ /xarrjy
Kat rpay^elav, fbv oAtyrjy re Kat Aeiar. aAA'
ri^a TTT; fioriOeiav e^ets eiraK^KOcbs ADCTIOD r) rtz>o? aAAou,
Ae'yety dra/xt/xi'Tjo'Ko/xei'os.
<I>AI. f/ EyeKa /xey Tretpas ^\oif^ av, aAA' ovri ^w y'
212.

BouAet oS^ eyw rty' etTrto Ao'yoy oz> rwz; -Trept rawra
a.Kr]Koa;
4>AI. Tt /x?7z/;
212. Ae'yerat yew, a cf>ai8pej 8tKatoz> e?^at Kat ro rou 10
. Kat (TV ye ovroo irotet.
212. fJ>a(ri TOIVVV ovbev ovrat ravra belv a-f^vvvav ovb '
avdyeiv ava iJ.aK.pav Trept/SaAAo/^eVou?' Tiavro.Tia.a-L "yap, o
&2 ol D : <roi Galenus : om. B T
as raCra 8" ^8; iravra B T :
7raj/TO S^ raOr' Galenus
a 6 Sera B Galenus : 6s T
re ai anaipiav
TW Galenus: om. B
b 2 ^o-et T : ^uoret B
b 3 /*}) scrips! : ^ B T
C 2 airiri B T : avfjj Stallbaum : Treptir) Badham : 1p bchanz
03^
rtj/os T : ef TIVOS B.
05 ex0'/4' ^y T : exoi/icw B : Xtyoifj.' &v Schanz
07 \6yov T : \6ycav pr. B
c8 Tt^wj/ BT: Seiv&y corr. Ven. 184

IIAAT&NO2

5
273

ap\as ei7rop;ey roSSe ro{5 Xoyou, on o>8ei> 0X77 0eta?

8e'ot OLKCLIOOV 77 dya0<3z> Tre'pt Trpay/^aTcoy, 77 Kat
avd ptoTTMV ye Totownoy (pwec OVTCOV 77 rpo<pf;, TOV fj.eXXovTa
l<avS>s pTjroptKoy eWcrflai. ; TO Ttapdirav yap ovbtv kv rots
8tKa<rT77piois rovrcoy aXyOfias jueAety ovftevi, a\.Xa TOV
z/ot>' roCro ' etyat TO ei/co's, w 8e^ TTpoa-^zw TOV fxe'A
T^x.vll *pv. ovbe yap aura (ra) TTpaj^dfVTa 8e^ Aeyetw eznore,
eay /x,^ etKOTcos 19 ireTrpay^va, aXXa ra etKOTa, ey Te KaTrjyopta Kat aTroXoyta, KCU Tra^Tcos XzyovTa TO ST) etKoy ^tcoKTeoz;
etvat, TroXXa eiTroVra -^aipeiv rw aXrj^er TOUTO yap 8ta
irayTos TOU Xoyou yiyv6fj.evov TT)V aTratrav
<I>AT. Awa ye, a> ISco/cpaTe?, 8teX?jXi^as' a
Trept TOW? Xo'yow? re^ytKot 'npocr^oiov^voi et^ar
yap on er TCO Trpoa-Otv (3pa\(a$ TOV TOLOVTOV
8oKei 8e TOUTO Tra/xjaeya eti'ai TOI^J TrejOt TaCra.
212,. 'AXXa ^y TOV ye TetcrtW avrov TreTraTrjKa? a
etTreTco TOLVVV Kat To8e 17/xt'y 6 Teto-tas, //,?] TI aXXo Xeyet
TO etKos r; TO TW 7rX?7^et SOKOW.
4>AI. Tt yap aXXo;
2Ii. TOUTO 877, &)s eotKe, (ro(pbv fvputv afjid Kat
eypax/^ey a>s eay Tts ao"^ez;T)? Kal dy8
SetXou (rvyKotyas, I^OLTIOV ij Tt aXXo CKpeXo^tvos, et? 8t/ca(TTripiov ayrjTai, 8et 8r) raX^e? //tjSeVepoi' Xeyeti>, aXXa TOI'
ju,ey 8etXoy //r) -UTTO jutoyou (frdvcu TOV avbpLnov
TOV be TOVTO fj.ev eXey^ety w? fj.6vu> 7/orrjy, eKeti^w 8e
xprjcrao-Oai TW H w ? 8' ay e y w r o t o c r S e rot&)8e e?reXetp?70-a; 6 8' OVK epeT 8?) TT)Z/ eauToC K.aKr\v, dXXd Tt
aXXo \lrevbfo-dai eTrt^etpw^ T(i)(' ay eAey^o'y TTTJ Trapa8otrj
TW dzmStKW. Kat Trept raXXa 8r^ rotayr' aTTa eort Ta
Xeyo'/xera. o^ yap, S 4>at8pe;
d.8 /j.e\eiv Stephanus e Ficino : jueAei B T
e 2 auT& ra Heindorf: aur^ B: aSr&T
a 4 6$ij|/c{(ii66aT: ^7j(J)i(ra/t9a B
a 6 Tiffiav
T b : Tjcriv pr. B
a 7 \4yeiv Par. 1826 : Ae'yei B T
b 5 ^ TI
T (ex emend.) : d TI B

*AIAPO2
212. Qtv, bfiv>s y eot/cey ci7roKe/c/)t>/>i//eVriz> T)(i>r]v avtvpeiv 6 Tetcrtas rj aAAos oVrts 877 TTOT' coz; ruy^dWi /cat
xai'pet, 6vofj.a^ofj.fvos.
ardp, eratpe, TOVTW ?//ue6s
Ae'yo)/tez> 77 /nr/
<I>AI. To TTOIOV;
212. r/Ort, S Teicrta, TraAat ^juety, 7rpti> Kat ere Trape\6tiv,
Aeyoyres co? apa roSro TO etKos rots iroXXols
TOV akrjOovs rvy\dveL kyyiyvo\i^vov ras 8e
o/xotorryra? a/m St?y\^o/xey 6Vt Tra^raxov o r?)z; aX^dfiav
KaAAtcrra eTrtorarat evpLffKtiv.
COOT' et /xey aAAo rt
Aoycoy Ae'ye6?, aK.ovoijj.tv av d 8e ju?/, ots
etcro/Ae^a, cos eai> /-i?j rts rwy re a/coixroras <pv(ris Sta/oitf/^OTjrat, /cat Kar' elS?] re bi.cupe'icrdat
ra oVra Kai /ua tSe'a bvvaros r\ KaO' ei> eKacrrov
(3dveiv, ov Tror' ecrrat rex^tKO? Ao'ycoy Tre'pt Ka0'
bvvarbv avdpto-na.
ravra 8e ov /u,?7 Trore K.rr}(rr\To.i avev
7roAA?ys Trpay/xaretas* 77^ o^x eVeica rou Ae'yety /cat TrparreLV
avdptoirovs Set StaTro^etcr^at roz; croHppova, dAAa ro{5
Ke^apia-fjifva
IJLZV Aeyety SvvacrOai, Kf^aptfriJifVMs
8e
TO TTCLV els bvva^iv. ov yap j] apa, u> Teio-ta,
<pa<rlv ol (ro(pti>Tpoi fjiJi&v, 6/xo8o?jAots 6et -^ap[^crOaL
jixeAeray roz> roSy e^ovra, ort ju^ Trdpepyov, aAAa Seo-Trorats
dya^ots re /cat ef ayad&v. a>crr' et /xotKpa r; TreptoSos, /XT)
Oavfjidcrps' jueyaAwi' yap e'ye/ca Trepttre'oy, ov^ a>9 o-i 8o/cets.
ecrrat /ATyV, ws 6 Ao'yos (prja-iv, fdv rts edeXy, KOL rama
/caAAiora e e/cet^a>y ytyy o'/xe^a.
<!>AI. Ilay/caAcos1 e/wotye So/ce? Ae'yeo-^at, > Sco
olo's re rts etrj.
C 7 7' T : T' B
09 TOUT<JJ B T : TOVTO corr. Coisl. : fort, TOUT'
auT^> Thompson
d 3 rJ> T : om. B
d 7 et 5*6 T : eJfS^j B
d8 /Si/ 8^ T W: I'w B
69 ^u<j/ Heindorf : ^ B : ^iwi/ ^ T :
w/xwv ^ vulg.
a2^T:^B
a3 ou% ws B T : ou^ S*' ci.
Heindorf
a 7 oT^y re Heindorf : oios B : oT!s ^e T

273 c

1
d

274

274 a

nAATX2NO2
212. 'AAAa Kal eTnxeipowrt roi rots KaAois KaAoy Kal

b Traa")(LV on ay r<o criyx/Sr} 7ra0eu>.

4>AI. Kal /xdAa.
212. Owow ro /x,ei> Teyyi)S re Kal aT\v[as Xoya>v Trept
e^erco.
212. To 8' evTrpeiretas 8r) ypa^T/s irept Kal aTrpeTreias, TTJJ
yi.-yv6fj.evov Ka\G>s &v e\oi Kal OTTTJ cntpeTT&s, Aonroy. ^ yap;
4>AI. Nat'.
212. O?<r^' ow OTTTJ /lidAicTTa 0ew xaPlf? A.oycoy wept
10 TtpaTTcav T) A.eycov;

^AI. OvSa/xSs- (TV 8e;

C

212. 'AKoyv y e)(co Xeyety rwy irporepwi', ro 8' ctArjfles

avrot tcrao-iy.
et 8e TOVTO evpoi^fv avroi, apd y' av efl'
ri r<Sy avOputmvuiv So^acr/xaTcoi';
eAoroy ^poir dAA' a c/)^s aKrj/coe^at Aeye.

212. "HKOutra TOLVW Trepl NavKparty TTJS Aiyi;7rrou yeyecrflat Taiy eKet TraAatfiy rtya Qe&v, ov Kal ro opveov izpbv
o 8r) KaAowtv vl/3iy avroi 8e oyo/xa rw bafaovi tlvai ev6.
TOVTOV

5r) TTP&TOV

api0}J,6v

re

Kai Aoytcrjaoy fvpe.lv

Kat

d yeco/merptaz; Kat acrrpovoniav, ert 8e Trerreias re kai Ku/3eia?,

Kat TJ Ka't ypd/A/xara.

/SacriAecos 8' av rdre OVTOS Atywrou

oAr;? @a/xou Trepl rrjy /jteydA?]y iroAu' ro{5 dyco roTrou ^y dt

"EAArjyes AtyuTrrias @?7/3a? KaAoucrt, Kat rw 0e6
5 Trapa roGroy \du>v 6 &evO ras re)(yas eTre'Set^ey, Kal
o^s dAAots AtyDirriois- 6 8e ?ypero
, 8ietoyros 8e, on KaAw? ^ /XTJ
KaASs 8o;cot Ae'yety, ro p.ey e^eyer, ro 8' eTTTjrei.

iroAAa

bi 8rt T : ftnp B
b6 SJ; . . . airpeireias om. Stobaeus
b 9 0eij) Stobaeus :flewvB T
03 /teAot B : jiteAAoi T
c 6 fepoV
Stobaeus Hermias : rb lepov B T
0 7 8 ) ; Stobaeus : 5e B T
d 3 ^j/ V : Sv B T Stobaeus
d 4 flebr] a/jiovv Postgate
d 5 ToOTOJ/ T : Toirrwi/ B
fireSfij-ev T : 7re86ie Stobaeus : aireSeif e B
01
el
d 6 Vrtva B T : V 8^ Stobaeus
d ^ ex ^ ^ ' *X Stobaeus
e i SOKOI B T : So/cofo) Stobaeus

<J>AIAPO2

2746

fj.cv br) TTfpl fKao-Trjs TTJS rexznjs eV dju$o'repa 0ap,ouz> ra>

0ev0 Aeyercu curotyyvacrOai, & Ao'yos 770X7)5 az> eu? 8teA#etz>'
^TrcLbrj 8e e7ri rot's ypa///xao-tz> rjv, "ToCro 8e, & /3ao-tAet5, ro
p,dOrjfj.a" e<?7 6 0ei/0, " <ro(f)(dTfpovs AtyuTrrtous /cat jj.vrjiJ.o- t,
ape{i' p.V7]fJ.rjs re ya/> Kai <ro(f)ias
"
6 8' e?7rey " '11 TeyviK.toTO.Te ev0,
bvvaTos TO, Tf\vr)s, aXXos 8e Kplvai riv* e^et
/3Aa/3jj9 re /cat oxpfXias rots /ie'AAoixri xprja-Oai- /cat z/w
(ru, Trarryp a>y ypafj.p.a.Tutv, 8t' tijvoiav TOVVO.VTIOV eTTres T) 275
8warat. rouro yap rwv fj,ad6vT(av X.r\Qr]v p,tv fv
Trape^et fj.vriiJ.rjs d/xeAerr/o-ta, are 8ta TTLCTTIV ypcuprjs
VTT' dAAor/atcoy TVTTMV, OVK HvboOfV O.VTOVS v<p' avr&v avafj.1,s' OVKOUJ; fj.vrnji.rjs dAAa v7TOfj.vrj(T(i)s (f)dpfj,aKov
5
. (Totyias 8e rots fJ.aOrjTOLs 8oav, OVK aXr}6eiav iropi7roAv?7/coot yap crot yeyo'/xevot ayeu 8t8ax^s TroAvyycoflvai boov<nv, dyrw/uoyes ws eTTt ro TrA^os oz^res, b
Ka^ x.a^e7ro' o-vvflvat, bo^ocrofpoi yeyoyo'res dz^rt o-o(p&v. "
<i>AI. ^il 2w/cpares, paStcos o-i) AtyuTrrtovs /cat oTroSa^ovs
&z> (OeXrjs \6yovs irotas.
212. Ot 8e y', ^>tAe, ez> rw roi; Atos rou Acobcovaiov 5
tepw 8/3UOS Ao'yous Htyrjcrav IACIVTIKOVS irptaTovs yevecrQai.
|u,ez> ow ro're, are OVK oiVt o-otyols &(mep vfj.e'is ot veoi,
bpvbs Kal TreVpas d/coi/eiy VTT' fiirjOeias, d \iovov
a\rj0rj Ae'yotef trot 8' T(rws o~ia<epet rts 6 Aeycov Kal 7ro8a7ros. C
ov yap eKetyo fj.ovov o-KOTTfls, etre ovrws etre aAAcos
I. 'OpO&s e7re7rA?7^ay, KCU //,ot 8oKet Trept
6 Srjfiaios Aeyet.
e 3 & A<yos . . . Sif\9e"iv B W Stobaeus : om. T
e 6 irapeei Stobaeus : irapegoi B : irapel-eiv T
e 8 re'x^s T Stobaeus : T?JS rex^r/s B
a 2 ^ey om. Schanz
a 4 ej/Sofley T Stobaeus : /8oj> B
aurots
. . . a.ua/j.ifjivrjffKOfj.ei'ois
H Richards
a 6 eSpes T : eSpe B
b i ri
B T : om. Stobaeus
b 3 ical B : re nal T
b 5 of 8e 7' 5 T :
oIS' tyfb B : ouSc 7' V : trol $' 7^ Stobaeus
b 6 t^aw B Stobaeus :fyatroi'T
b 8 Spubs T b : Sibs pr. B
c i S' fircos T W

Stobaeus : om. B
PLATO, VOL. n.

19

2750

nAAT&NOS

212. OVKOVV 6 Tyvt]V olopcvos f v ypd/xf/ao-t

Kal av 6 Tfapabf\ofj,evos
&$ ri <ra(j>fs Kal /3e/3atoy e/c ypa/u,p,dra)V ecrojueyoy, 7roXA.7js ay evT/^etay y^jibi Kat TW oVrt rrjy
* Afj-jjitovos jxayreiay ayvool, TrAeoy rt otofieyos eiyat Aoyovs
d yeypajajueyot;? TOU rov etSo'ra virojj.vr](rai Trept wy ar '$ x ra

5
276

'OpOorara.
2Ii. Aei^oy yap -TTOU, w ^aiSpe, TOVT' e^ei ypa^r/,
w? dA.T7^ws 6'p.otoy {coypa^ta. *at yap ra fKivi]s
earrj/ce /^ey ws ^iSyra, eay 8' dyepr; rt, (T^vS>s iraw criya.
ravroy 8e /cat ol Aoyor bda.LS fJ.V hv &s n (frpovovvras
O.VTOVS Aeyeir, eay 8e n epr; rwy Xeyo/^eycoy /3ovA.op;eyos
padelv, V < Ti .(Trjpiaiyet juo'yoy TOVTOV det. oray 8e airaf
ypa^r), KuA6y6eirat /mey Trayra^oi; TTO? Adyoy ojnotco? irapa
ror? e7raiov(7ty, a>s 5' a#rcos Trap' ots ov8ey irpocrriKfi, Kal
OVK eTriorarat Aeyety ois Set ye xal ja?]. irATjpjueAo^jixeyos
8e xat OVK ey SIKT/ AoiSoprjfleis roS -jrarpo? dei 8eirat /BorjOov'
avros yap ovr' afj.vva(T0ai ovre Poridycrai. bvvarbs avr<a.
<AI. Kat raOrd o-oi opOorara dfpr/rai.
21i. Tt 8'; aAAoy opw^ey Aoyoy rovrou d8eA<^oy yy?jo-ioy, TW rpoTTft) re yiyyerai, Kat ocrw dp-etyioi' Kai Swarwrepos rovrou (pverai;
4>AI. Ti'ya rouroy Kat TTWS Aeyets yiyyop.eyoy;
2H. *Os />ier' e7rtoT?|//,T)j ypa^erai ci> TTJ rot; p.av6avovros
^fvxfj, bvvarbs iitv ap,vv<u eavrw, e7rt(TT?jfxcoy 8e Aeyety re
Kat trtyay Trpos o{)s 8eu
(
4>AI. Toy TOU eiSoros Aoyoy Aeyets ^Syra Kat
ov 6 yeypa/x/^eyos et8a)Aoy ay ri Aeyotro 8tKaicos.
C 5 Ka.ra.\nreiv B T : KoTaXeiireti' Stobaeus
O^ kv T Stobaeus :
om. B
c8 flvai] exfiv Heindorf : icoiCiv Stallbaum
d i roO
rJu/ B T : Kal TOVTOV Stobaeus : ^ TO T"OV fuisse susp. Wachsmuth
d 4 ypa<t>-li b : ypa<p-f)j> pr. B T
d 6 8' avepy T : S' ov epj; B : Se epjj
Stobaeus
6 i KuA.H/Se7Tcu B T : a\iv8errai V
63 ^e] re
Hirschig
irA.ijjtt/xeXotS/tej'os T : TrA/^juei/os B
a I opwfuev B T :

yvfowv corr. Coisl. : yv^ffios B T

<J>AIAPO2

2765

SI2. HavTaTTaa-i, juer ovv. ro8e . 6?/ juot eiTre1 6 vovv b

yeoopyos, &v <rirp}j.aTu>v KyboiTO /cat $y Kaffir a (SovhoiTO
yez>ecr0ai, Trorepa o-irovbf) av Oepovs els 'Abavibos KT/TTOVS
apaiv \aCpoi dfcop&v KaAovs kv rj^fpataiv OKTW yiyvo/j-tvovs,
r\ rama p\v br) traibias re K.OL foprrjs x<*PLV ?>P<?rl &v> ^'re 5
Kal TTOiol' <{>' ots 8e ecnrovftaKfv, rr\ yecopyixr; xpat/Jievos av
Tf\vr], cnreipas els TO Trpod-fJKov, dyaTrwiy av fv dy8oo)
ova i-ffireipev reAo? Aa/3oVra;
4>AI. OVTO) TTOV, S 2w/cpares, ra /u,ey (nrovbfj, TO, 8e
^ if Aeyeu irotoi.
2Ii. Toy 8e biKaCtov re /cat /caAaii' Kat aya6&v tT
TOV -yecopyov
. "H/citrrci ye.
OVK apa crTroMST] avra eV i;8art ypa^et
oia Kaka^ov /^era Ao'ycoy dSurarcoy jxez> avrois
Aoyw fiorjdelv, abwdrvov be iKavGts ra^r]9fj 8t8aai.
^AI. OVKOVV brj TO y ei/cos.
SH. Ov yap- dAAa TOVS fjiev kv ypa//ju,acri KTjTrous, ws
HoiK, Traibias yjkpw <nrepei re /cat ypd\j/ei., orav [8e] ypcKprj,
eavrai re vno[ivr]\iaTo. ^r;cravpt^o/Jcei'0?, et? ro \r[0r]s yijpas
eav jf/CT/rat, /cat Trayri rco ravrbv lx.vos IACTIOVTI., rjcrdricrerat re avrovs OcuipStv (f)vo^fvovs
aTraXovs' orav (8e)
aAAot TratStar? aAAats xp&vrai, O-V^OCTLOLS re apoo^re? avrovs erepots re oo-a TOVTOOV abeXtyd, TOT' fKflvos, cos e'oi/cezj,
t TOVTU>V ots Ae'yoo iraifav 8tdei.
. Ilay/caArjy Aeyets Trapa <$)(ivXr)v TratStar, w Scob i ro2y T : j/w B
b 2 / T : w B : &/ V
b 4 apaJv B T :
6pwv V : tnrelpas Herwerden
b 6 xp'>>lJLevos &v T*XVP "^ ' &v XP<&~
pews rexfrj &c B
0 7 yp^et (eV) Badham
C 8 ^era]
(nrep/J-ara Badham
itfivvanwv (bis) B : a5vi>aTS>v (bisN T (et sic Heindorf omissis /tera \6-ywv)
C 9 Ta\t]drj B : T' a\T]6es T
d 2 8
om. Bekker : re Heindorf: ye Schanz
d.5 5e add. Par. 1811 : re
Stephanus : oin. B T
d. 8 ofs \eyea yp. Par. 1812 : cits \tycav B T :
Heindorf : ov Xeyoi Schanz
idei T : Sit^et B

10
d

2766

277

10
b

KpaTfS, TOV fv Ao'yots bwapevov irai&iv, StKatocrwTjs re Km

aXXcov &v Aeyeis 7rep6 \w6o\oyovvTa.
SH. vE<m yap, a> <piXe ^cuSpe, oi/rco' TroXv 8' oi/xat
KaXXuov o-7rou5^ Trept avra yiyyerai, oray ris rr} 8iaXeKnKTJ
y \f/vxr)V Trpo<r^Kov(ravt (ftVTfvr] re xat
Xoyous, ot eavrors r<S re
(3or)delv iKavol KOI oir)(l aKapTtoi ak\.a f-^ovres (nrep/xa,
aAXot ey aXA.ots ^etrt ^uo/xeyoi rour' det addvctTOV
i, Kat roy \ovra fvbaifj.ovlv
-rroiowres ets ocrov
&TTto bvvarbv jU(iAt(rra.
4>AI. IToXv yap ro{)r' ert KaAXtoy Xeyets.
SH. Nw 8^ tKfiva ^fSrj, w 4>aZ8pe, bvvap,fda
TOVTGOV w/xoXoyrj/xeywi'.
<I>AI. Ta -Troia;
SH: ?Hv STJ Trept fiovXrjdevTfs Ibfiv a^)tKo/u,e^a eis
OTTCOS TO Aucrtor; Te oveiSos eera(rai/Jt,ei> r^y rwi' Xoycoz;
ypa<f)rjs trepi, KOL avrovs rovs Xoyovs ot Te\vri KOI
TO p,fv ovv evrexyov /cat /XT) 8oKei

<f>AI. vE8oe' ye 877* TtaXiv 8e wo'/x^r/troy /xe TTWS.

5
212. TLplv av TLS ro re dXrifles eKao-ro)i' et8^ ^e
Xeyet ^ ypa^et, Kar' avro re miz> opt^eo-^at 8waros
r
os re TraXty Kar' e?8rj /xe^pt rou dr/XTjroi) re/xyetz>
>i re \jsv)(rjs <pv(recos 8u8&>y Kara ravrd, ro
C 7rpo<rapfxo'rroy eKao-rr/ <pv(rei e?8os avevpicrnwv, o#r<o
roy Xoyor, TroiKtXrj )u,ey uw/ciXotJ
8t8ov9 Xoyoi)?, aTrXous 8e 0177X77, ou
5 ro Xoya>y yeVos, ovre rt Trpos ro 8t8aai ovre rt irpos ro
w? 6 ejuTrpocr^ey Tray /xefx^DKey ^/x?!; Xoyos.
. TlavTcnrcKri /xez> ovy roSro ye ovrco TTCOS e^a
a i /cal B : re al T
D : j'Sfj (sic) T : iSj; B
T : KartSjj B

as /coi om. Schanz

b 6 -re B T : 7 vulg.

b 5 eiSfj corr.
b 7 aV eWij

212. Tt 8' av Tre/u TOV /caAoy r) al<r\pbv tlvai TO \6yovs d

Aeyew re Kal ypdfaw, KOI OTTT/ yiyvoptvov kv 8t/cr/ Aeyotr'
av oVetSo? rj \M\, apa ov 8e8r/Aa>Key ra Xf^dfvra
oXiyov
4>AI. Ta Troia;
212. cls etre Avo-ta? ?/ ris aAAos TrwTroTe eypaifrev r)
Ibia y d?j//,O(rta vofj.ovs
Kal jueyaAr/p rt^a ez/ atrw /3e/3aior?)ra fj
Kal arafprjvfiav, otJrco /uezJ wetSos rw ypdtpovri, fire rCs
<pr](riv etre /u^- ro yap ayvoslv virap re /cat ovap biKaicov
ical a8t/ca>y ffe/n Kai KanStv /cat dya^wi' o^/c eK^evyet rry
a\rjdcLO. fj/f) OVK eTroretotcrToi' etz^at, ov5e ay 6 Tras
avro
yap ow.
2Ii. 'O 8e ye ey pJev TU> yeypaju/ieyw Aoy^ ^^P' e/cacrrou
re rj-yovfjLfvos TroAAr/u dyay/caroi ^ryat, Kat ovbfva
Aoyoy ev /xerpw 0^8' aVeu /txerpou jj.eydh.rjs aiov
cnrov8fjs ypatyfjvat,, oiibe XfyOrivai ws ot pa\l/(fbovp.voi avev
Kat StSa^s iretflow eVe/ca X.%Or]<rav, dAAa rai
avT&v TOVS ^eArtcrrous ftSorwi' vTs6\wr\(nv yeyovtvai,
ey 8e rot's 8t8ao-Ko;w,e^ois /cat ^aO^crfcos \apiv XeyofAtvois Kal
TW ovrt, ypa^o/j^fvoLS ev ^vx.fl 7rP^ 8t/cata)y re /cal /caASy
Kat aya6S>v [ev\ P.OVOI.S f)yovij.vos ro re tvapyes eu/ai Kat
re'Aeoy Kal atoy cnrouSr/y Sety 8e rows rotovrons Aoyous
ai5roi3 Aeyeo-^at otoy vet? yvrjcrCovs clvai, irp&rov fj,fv TOV
f v avrut, (av evpedfls ez>f), eTretra et rtyes rovrou e/cyoyot
re Kal dSeA^ol a//,a ez> aAAatcrty aAAcdy \j/vxals Kar' aiav
V(pv(rav TOVS 8e aAAous ^atpety ewyovros 8e 6 rotouros
d i ToC T : r6 B
d. 2 Xe^oir' &y T : Aeyet raj/ B
d. 3 ^
corr. Par. i 8 i a : 6 t B T
d ^ ypo^et B : ypaQfi T
vApovs n6fis
seel. Schleiermacher
d 10 Siicaicav Kal B : SiKaiW re /cal T
e8 oi>8^ . . . eg eAe'x^Ta*' seel. Schanz : &>s ot . . . (K^rjcrav seel.
Ast
oj of] Scroi Schleiermacher
a i avr&v T : avrcp B
a 4 v seel. ci. Heindorf
r)yovf4.et>os T W : om. B
a 7 eV aury
B : eavrf T

10
e

278

OAATllNOS

avr\p Kivbw&ijfi, o> <&albpe, elWt olov eyw re KOI crv e

&v ere re KCU e/xe yeuecrflai.
4>AI. rLarrdirao-t jixey oSz> efycoye /3ov\ofj.aC re Kat
ei Ae'yets.
212. OUKOW 1/817 TtfTTaicrOca /xerptcos TJJUZ; ra irept Adyaw
/cat crv re eWu>v <t>p&& Aixruz ort vcb Kara/3dyre e9 ro
Nv/x^wy va/^,d re Kat fjLOvaretov r\K.o-v(ja^V Aoycor, 01 eTreoreAAoy Aeyety Auo-ta re /cat ei res aAA.os crvvT(Or)(n Aoyow,
/cat 'O/XT^pw Kal et m aXXos av Trovqcriv \l/iXr)v T) e^ w8r)
jKe, rplrov 8e SoAcovi Kat oarts ey TroAtriKor? Xoyots
ovo^a^utv o-uyypa/x^ara eypax/^ey et ju,ey etSob? ^ ro
e)(e6 (ruve^Ke raura, Kat lx^y jBor^Oelv, ets eAeyxoy
Tiepl <5z/ ey/aa^e, Kat Ae'ycor avros bvvaros ra yeypa/x<pavX.a a7ro8et^at, oi; rt rw^Se eTrcovu/xtay e^ovra 8e?
Ae'yecr^at roy rotoi5roy, dXA' e<' ots eo-'7rov8aKey eKet^coy.
TYvay ovz/ ras eTrcoyu/^tas avrS ve/xets;
2. To /xey cro<p6v, a> ^atSpe, KaXe^y e^iotye /ueya
8oKet Kat ^ea> fj.6v(p irpeTreiv TO be rj (pL\6(ro(pov r/
rotoCroy rt /xaXAoy re az> at'rai Kat appiorrot Kat e/^ueAe<rrepcos e'xot.
4>AI. Kat ov8ey ye aTro rpoVov.
211. OuKoSv aS roy jixr/ e'^ovra rt/xtcorepa coy crvve0r]KV
^ <-ypa\l/ev avco Karco crrpe'^coy ey xporco, ^pos dAArjAa
KoAAwy re Kat d^atpwy, ey 8tKr/ TTOU Trotrjr^i; ^ Adycoy
arvyypa(pea r) vo}J,oypd<pov Trpocrepets;
4>AI. Tt>7^;
211. TaSra TOWVV rw eratpw <pde.
4>AI. Tt 8e <rv; TTCOS Trot^cret?; ov8e yap oiiSe roz; <ror
kralpov 8et 7rapeA0eti>.
211. Ttya rovror;
b 8 es T : eis B
rb T : rbv B
b g lAovfftiov T :
B: fjiovffuv vulg.
firecTT\\ov B : tvf\\ov T
d i 6<f>' B : v<J>' T
d. 5 roiovf&v ri B : TI roioiirov T
awry K al T : auT< B
d. 8
rbv t : atprbv BT
e i ev Si'/cr? T: SIKI} B TTOU B : om. T
64 frat
T : erec B

<J>AIAPO2
4>AI. 'lo-o/cparr/ TOV KoXov <S TI aTrayyeAei?, &> 2<oKpares; riva. avrbv ^cro/jtev eiWi;
212. Neos en, ^aiSpe, 'lo-OKpcmjy o juewot /i/.ai'revojuat /car' avrou, Ae'yeiv e0eAco.
<I>AI. To Timoy 8??;
212. Aoxet juoi ap.iv<av 77 icara rovs -^ept Avcriai/ etvat
Aoyous ra 777? 0weco?, ri re r/^et yevi;tKforep&) K.K.pa<rdai'
a>(TT ovbev av yivoiro Oav^acrTov Trpo'Cov(rr]S rijs r/At/ctay ei
Trept a^rov? re roiiy Aoyovs, ots rui' tTriyeipti, TrAeof r)
Traiba>v Stei'ey/cot raiv TrwTrore a^afjievuiv Aoycoy, ert re et
JUT) aTTOxptfo-ai ravra, eTTt juet^co 8e rts aiiTov ayot
xr; tfeiore'pa* (pvcret yap, a) <J[)tAe, eVecrri' ris (friXocro<pia
rrj TOV avbpos biavoiq. raCra 8^ ow eyco juey Tra/aa rcui>8e
s e/xots 7rat8i/coZ? 'IcroKparet e^ayyeAAco, (ri> 8'
ws (rots Avo-ia.
. Tai)r' lorai' dAAa ta>[j.v, eTretSr) KOI TO

2786

10
379

yeyovev.
. Ov/cow ev^a/Aero) Trpeiret roicrSe Troptveo-Oai.;
. Tt /x?jv;
212. '12 </nAe Oar re Kat aAAot 00-01 rrj5e ^eot,
t KaAai yevtcrdai r&vboOtv f(i>0V be ocra e^a), rot's eiro?
tAia. 7rAovo"ioy 8e zjo/ubi/i>u rov (rofyov TO be c
yjpvcrov irXrjOos elr] fj.oi ocrov jar/re <pepeiv ju?yre ayety Swatro
aAAoy 7) 6 (rw^pcoy.
v
Er' aAAou rou beo/ieOa, a 4>ai8pe; e;uol p;ey ya/o /xerpiico?
TjvKrai.
5
4>AI. Kal e/^ot raura <rwvxv* KOtva yap ra r<Sr
^)iAwy.
212. "Ito/xer.
a4 re B : 5e T
as rr}y faiitias T : IffyXMias B
a6 roij
T : om. B
a 7 er Tf T : efre B
a 8 <?iri/tefW S/ rts oury
B: en-} /j.e{(oi> 5e TS O.VTOV T
a 9 fyytfj Betorepa B
b 2 ^fa'y.
Aa> Stallbaum
b 6 fv|ateVw Bekker
c i (>tA.ia B : </>{Aa T

AAKIBIAAH2
212KPATH2

st ii

AAKIBIAAH2

p. 103

212. *12 irai KAetznov, oly^ai ere Oav^a^iv 6'ri Trpooros a

?pao-r?]s (rev yevojAfVos

rail' aAAooy ir^'nav^VMV pores OVK

aTraAAdrro/xai, /cat on ot /ixez> aAAot 81' o^Aou f-yevovTO (rot

Sia/Veyo/xerot, eyoo 8e TO<TOVTU>V ZT&V ovbe irpocrf'LTTOv.

TOVTOV

Se TO alriov yzyovev OVK avOptoTreiov, dAAa TL baifj.6vi.ov

fvavTiu>fj.a,
TTlbr]

OVKCTL

ov crv T-TJV bvva^iv nal vcrrepov Trfva-t].

kvaVTlOVTCLl,

elp.1 Kdl TO XOLTTOV

OVTO)

TtpOCTeXl^Xvda'

V\inS

/xr) (vavn,ti><r(r9ai, avro.

8'

o-^ebbv ovv

KaravevorjKa \v rovrw rw XPOV(? O-KOTTOVIJ.I>OS

ws Trpbs TOVS

cpaaras lores' iro\XS>v yap yero/xeycoi; Kat

p.eyaX.O(j)p6v(ov

ovbels os ofy vTrepjSXriOfls

r<5 <f)povrnj.aTi, VTTO crov irtfavyev.

roz> 8e A.oyoy, w vTTpTr(f)p6v'r]Kas,

(pr)s

avOptoTratv fvberjs

vvv 8e

e^eAco SteA^et^.

ov8ej/o? 104

ewat eis ovbev TO, yap V

(rot fAeyaAa eZyat, toare prjbfvbs

bela-dai,, OTTO ro5

dp^ajue^a reAeuTcorra ets T^y i^u^r.

oiet yap dr)

TrpStrov //.ey KaAAtcrToy re Kat jueyttrros Kat roCro /^iey 8^ 5

Traz^rt ST/AOZJ tSeli; on ov ^evbrj' eTretra yeayiKcordrou yevous
ey rr] o-eaurou TroAet, OVO-T; //eyto-rrj r<5z> 'EAAiyviStoi', Kat
fvravda Trpbs Ttarpos re trot ^)iAous Kat o-Dyyeyefc TrAeto-rou? b
a 5 arOpdnreiov B Olympiodorus : avBpdnnvov T W
B T : ow/c Proclus
as wo-re . . . Sf?<r6ai sec!. Cobet

b i ov

etyat /cat dpurrous, ot ei ri 8e'ot VTrrjpeToitv

av <rot, TOVTGOV

be TOVS Tfpbs [J.r]Tpbs ovbev -^eCpovs oi>8' eAdrrov?.

8e <5y eiiroy fietfa

oiei <rot bvvafj.iv

<rt>p-7rdyra>y

i$7rdp)(ety IleptKAea TOT

5 EayfltTTTTOu, ov o Traryp emrpoTroy KareAtTre croi re KCU r<3

d8eA</>(5' 6? ov fjiovov kv rrjSe r?) 7ro'A.et Swarai irpdrrfLV
av /SovArjrat, dAA.' ey iracrrj rrj *EA.A.a8i Kat TU>V
fV TroAAoty KOU fj.fydX.ois
C Tt\ov(ri(i)V'

boKfts

yevecnv.

on

(3ap/3dp(av

Tr/aoo-^croo 8e Kat ort

8e /xot eT7t TovTto rJKKTTa jixeya

Kara TraWa 8r) raSra (rw re ju,eyaAai>)(oi;//,e^o9 KeK/aarr/Kas

epa<rT)V fKivoi re VTroSeearepot ovres KpciTy6r](rai>,
raur' ov AeArj^ey

Kai ere

o^ev T) eu otda on ^aujud^ets rt

5 /xeyos ?rore OVK aTraAAarrojaai row epcoros, Kac

eATTtoa VTro/ieVco roiy dAAa)i> Tre^evyorcoi'.y
AA.

Kat

d /xe (f>9r]s.

to-<ws ye, a> 2a>K/3ares, OVK oTcr^' ort

<rfj.iKpov

eyco yd/3 rot ey ^ etxo y Trporepos croi irpO(r<A.0ti>v

avTa raSr' epearOai, rt irore /3ovAet Kat eis riVa eATTtSa ^SAe
eyo)(Aes /xe, det OTTOV af a e7rt/^eAe(rrara Ttapav

rfi

yap 0av/ida> ort Tor' eo-rt ro o-oy 7rpay/xa, Kat ^'8to-r' &y
5 7ru0oi//,Tjy.
2H. 'AKOVO-T; /xey dpa /xov, a>s ro etKo'y, TTpo6v[j,a>s, etirep,
ws 0j?s> e7ri0u/xets eiSerat rt ^navoov^ai, Kat ws a-KOvaro^v^
Kat irept/xevouyrt Aeyco.
AA. ITdw /^,ey owy dAAa Aeye.
e

2H. "Opa 87;' ov yap rot et?] ay Oav^atrrov et, uxnrcp

p.6yi.s ripd.p,r]v, oiUrco /xoyts KOI 7raucrat/j,rji'.
AA. '!2ya0e Ae'ye- anovcro^aL yap,
212. AeKreou ay etrj.

^aAeTroy /xey ovy irpos avbpa ov^

5 rJTTOva epatrrcor Trpoo-^e'pecr^at epao-rrj, ojuws Se roAjurjreor

<j)pdcrai rrjv e/x^y Stdyoiay.

eya> yap, S 'AAKt/3td8?j, et /mey

b 3 ouSev B W Proclus : ouSe T

b 4 vTrapxeiv] e-irapKew Ast :
fort, irape'xetv Stallbaum
c i /te'7 ippdveiv B Olympiodorus :
p.syaXo<ppoveiv T Proclus
d 2 owret raCr' B : ravra ravr' T : ravra
Proclus
d 3 Sxou B T : oirovirtp Proclus
d 7 (/>T/S T Proclus :
<tn)s B
elSfvat Proclus : ct'Se'i/at ol dfcoCtraj B : elSevat aicovffai T
e 2 fn6yis Kal T W : al ^t^is B Priscianus
vav<ro'i/j.iji> Cobet

AAKIBIAAHS

1046

(re e/oo)z> & vvvbr) bifjWov ayaTrw^ra KOL olofjLevov bdv fv

TOVTOLS Kara/3t<3i>at, iraAat av aTT^AXay/xrji; rov e/xoros, cos
ye 5r/ e^avrov ireiOw vvv 8' erep' av Kar?]yo/)?]crco 8taz>orj- JQC
//,ara era 71730? avrbv erf, <S Kat yvuxrri on Trpoae^aiv ye crot
roy vow 8tarere'AeKa. 8oKe?s yap juot, et rts o-ot eiirot
"*H 'AAKt/3taorj, irorepov /3ovAet ^^ exooi; " y^
avrt/ca Tfdvdvai, el pt] trot e^e'crrat ju,et^co KrijaracrdaL; " 5
8o/cei? ai> /MOI eAecr^ai TfOvdvai' a\Xa vvv eTrt rtrt 877 Trore
^rjy, ey<w </>pao-a). ^y^, eav Oarrov eis roy 'Adrjvaicw
$-ro(5ro o' e<reo-0at judAa oAiycoy r]fj,fpS>v b
ovv ey8eifeo-0at 'Adrjvaiois on a^tos et rt/xacr^ai
w? ovre ITeptKArJs ovr' aAAos oi'Sety rwy TrcdTrore yfvofj.tvutv,
KOL Tovr1 ei'Set^a/u.eros /xeytcrToy SwTycrecr^at ey TT) -rro'Aei, ear
8' ev^d8e /xeytaros TJS, /cat er ro^s aAAois "EAA?jcri, Kat ov 5
p.6vov tv "E\\r]criv, ciAAa Kat ei> TOIS fiapfldpois, ocroi ev rrj
avrr) ^juw ot/coucrti; ^Tret/ow. Kat et aS (rot etirot 6 avros
OVTOS 6fos OTL avrov ere 8et bwacrrevav tv rfi Evp^Trrj,
biaftrjvai 8e eis TT]V *A(rCav oiiK e^ecrrat (rot ot8e e7Ti#e<r$cu C
rots e/cet Trpay^acriv, OVK civ av poi fioKets efleAetv ov8' eirt
rovrots IAOVOIS fjv, et HX,T/ e/XTrATjcreis rov crew ovo/iaros *cat
r^s o-^s bvvdfj,eu>s rravras cos CTTOS etTrery av6pu>7rovs' Kal
oljj.ai ere TrA^y Kvpou Kat He'p^ou fj-yticrOai ovbtva atov 5
Aoyou yeyoyeVat. ort /zez> ow ^xei9 TavTrjv rr]v eAirtSa, ev
oZ8a Kat ov/c etKci</d. tcrcos ay oSy etTroiS1, aVe etScb? on
a\r)df) Ae'ya), " Tt 8^ ovy, a> 2coK/>ares, roCr' ecrrt crot jrpos
Aoyov; [ov e^ffOa epelv, 8to ejuou O^K ctTraAAarrT;;] " eya> 8e d
crot ye e/oco, c/>tAe Trat KAetvtou Kat Aetyofta^s. rovrutv
yap crot aTrdvTav rS>v Sta^orjjuaTwy reAos fTriTeOfjvai. arev
e 7 StTjAtfoj/ B Proclus : SifaOofjifv T
xal T Proclus : re oJ B
Olympiodorus
b i 6\(yo>t> yfiepuv B Proclus : tj/neptav bxi-yuv T
b a oSi/ B : 8^ T Proclus
tvtel&ffQai B : ^Se/|ao-eot T Proclus
b 4 fieyiffrov Svff)fff(r9ai
B T : fj.f'yiffros yev^crp Proclus
C I dtriac
T : affirjv B
0 7 OTJ B T : a>s Proclus
d i ^v . . . &ira\\drTri seclusi
&j/] 6s Cobet
Sib B T Proclus Olympiodorus :
Si' t>v recc.
8e B : 8^ T Proclus
d 2 Se
Olympiodorus : Seij/o^ueV?;? B t et / supra ^uax W Proclus

nAATJlNOS
e/xou abvvarov rotravrryy eyo> frvvafuv ofytat zyew els ra <ro
5 irpayp-ara KCU els ere, 8 to 8r) KCU TrdAai olo^ai p. rbv Oebv
OVK eav 8taAeyeo-0at (rot, bv eya> Trepteju.ei'ov OTrrptKa edcrei.
axnrep yap <rv eAiuSas exets ^y r?) ToAei fvbfia<rOai 6Yt
e avTTj irayros atos el, ez>8eta//,ez;os 8e [ort] ovSey on ov
irapavriKa bwrivecrOai, OVTM Kayo) Trapa a~ol eXTrt^co ^xeyiorov
ySet^ajixeyoy on Travros agio's et/xt o~ot Kat owe
ovT (Tvyyfvrj^ ovr' aXAos ov8ets tKayos irapabovvai
5 rr]v bijvaiJ.iv rjs fin6vij,ei$ Tt\r)v tpov, yu,era r
yecorepw f/,ey ovy wrt 0*01 /cai Trpif roo-avrr^s
ws e/xot SoKe^, OVK eta o 6fbs 8taAeyeo-^at, tva JUT)
106 8taAeyoijUtryi;. vuy 8' (prJKV vvv yap ay juou d/covoAA. rioAiJ ye /xot, 2> 2<wK/)ares, i>w droTTCdrepos av
Ae'yety, ^ ore cny&v eiTrov xairot crtyobpa ye
elf Kat rote rotoSroy. et //ey owi' eya> raura 8tavoov\j.ai ?) 11x77, ws eotxe, Stey^coKa?, /cat eay /u^ ^>w, ovSe'r
/ioi eo-rat TrAe'oy irpos ro irei^etz; o-e. etey et 8e 81) ort
/^dAto-ra raura biavevorjiJiai, TT>S 8ta o-oi; /xot eo~rat /cat avcv
(rov OVK av yevoiro; e)(ets Ae'yetv;
SH. 'Ap' epcoras et rtr' e^co etTreti* Aoyoy /na/cpoy, otovs
8r) aKovety et^to-at; ou yap eo-rt rotouroy ro f{j.6v dAA'
ey8eifa<r^at jueV o-ot, <ws eyw/xat, otoy r' &ZJ etrjy ort
ovrcos e'xei, eay ev IJLOVOV juot e^eA?7o-T/s
AA. 'AAA' et ye 8^ JUT) xaAeiroV rt Aeyets ro y
e^e'Aco.
212. *H x.a^frof 8o/ce ro a-noKpivacrOai ra e
AA. Ov
d. 4 SvvafJLiv ol/jLai B : o?/iai Svva/j.u> T Proclus

d 7

evSeil-affBai

. . . 6 2 Sw-fiffecrBai T W Proclus : om. B

e i on om. Proclus
e 3 Tta.vr'bs B Olympiodorus : -xavrls /J.a\\ot> T W: /cai aurbs fj.a\\ov Proclus
(Toi B : om. T Proclus
e 4 inavbs B Proclus : IKO.VUS T
e 5 TOU B W Proclus Olympiodorus : om. T
a i e^/cei/ B T :
o^>ijK Proclus
a, 2 o5 B W Olympiodorus : om. T Proclus
b 4 e'fleMjtrfls T Proclus : ede\ps B Olympiodorus
b 7 ^ Buttmann : el B T
avoKpivaffOcu T Proclus Olympiodorus : airoKplvtaQai B

AAKIBIAAHS

io6b

212. 'AiroKpLVov 077.

AA. 'Epwro.
jo
212. Ov/cow a>y biavoov^kvov (rov raura epoora), a cprj/u o-e
btavotfcrdai;
C
AA. "Ecrra), ei flovkei, OVTWS, tva /cat et8<S on /cat
epeis.
'AOrivatois erroy ov TroAAou yj)6vow d ovv jue'AAorros 5
wept rtVo? 'Adr/vaioi biavoovvrai {3ov\V(r0ai, aviorao-at o-v^ov\fva-(av ; ap* eTreibrj irepl &v crv eTTiorao-ai
jSeArcov ^ OVTOI; " rt &^ cnroKpivato;
AA. Efeotja' <!h> STJTTOU, Trept c5y ot8a /3eAnoz> ^ ovrot.
d
212. ITepi c5i> ap' eiScos ruyxoyets, aya#os crvju,/3ouAos ?.
AA. Ilws yap ov;
212. QVKOVV raura fjidvov OL<rOa, h Trap' aAAwy e^aOes rj
avrbs (r)vpes;
5
AA. ITota yap aAAa;
212. "Ecrriv ovv oircos &v Trore ep,a0e? ri ^ (fyvpes wre
v edfXcov \i.r\r aiiTos r]Tflv;
AA.

OvK (TTIV.

212. Ti Se; ^deX.rjo-as hv fyTrjcrcu rj i^adflv a tTria-racrOai 10

AA. Ov S^ra.
212. *A apa vvv Tvy%dvis eTTiora/xeros, ^f xpo'f os ore
A A. '
212. 'AAAa /AT)Z; a ye jue/xa^/ca? (T)(e8oV ri /cat eycb o^Sa'
ei be Ti fj.e Ae'Ar;^ei', etTre. ep,a0e? yap 8^ oiJ ye Kara 5
fwr/juTfy r^v ep;^y ypo/A/zara Kat m6api&iv KOI iraAateiy ov
yap 8r) avAety ye tfdeXes fJ-adtlv. ra(5r' eorty & crv e-juo

C 2 grt ical T : 2ri B Proclus

e 4 e'-yeb B T : avrbs Proclus
Proclus

6 i & fya B : 5p' & T Proclus

e 6 T^V B : om. T : r^v f^v om.

ITAA r mNO2

io6e

d pj itov n pavOdvav ejxe \c\rj6as- oijuai 8e ye,

10
107

AA. 'AAA' ov TretpoirrjKa els aXXav T) rovratv.

211. ITorepoy ovi>, 6Yaz> -Trepl ypa/ijmarco
t, TTWS ay dp6&s ypa<pos.fv, rore avao-rrja-rj auroij
AA.
2H.
A A.
2H.

AA.
2H.
ye Trepl
AA.
Sfi.
b
AA.
211.

10

Ma Ai' OUK eycoye.

'AXA.' 6'raz; irept Kpov^aTcav tv kvpq;
OvSajuwy.
OvSe ^y ovbe Trept TraAaKT/xaTcoy ye
Ov jueVroi.
"Gray o3y Trepl nVos jSouAevcoyrat; ov yap TTOU
ot/co8o/xias.
Ov 8^ra.
Ot/co5o'/xos yap raura ye <rou /3eAnoz>
Nat.
Oi/Se pyy oraz/ Trept JWVTIKTJS

AA. Ov.

211. Mazm? yap au raura aptivov r\ a~v.

5
AA. Nai'.
211. 'Ear re ye <Tfj.iKpos ^ /xeya? 17, eaz; re /caAoy ^
ato-^poy, en re yeyz/aios ^ dyey^s.
AA. ITeoy yap ov;
2H. EiSoros yap oi/xai Trepl exaorou 77 (rvufiovXri, Kal ov
10

TT\OVTOVVTOS.

A A. 17<i)s yap ov;

2H. 'AAA' eai^re Trevrjs ea^re TrAowios ^ 6 Ttapaiv&v,
ovbfv 8ioi<ret 'Adrjvaiois orav Trept rSy ev r^ Tro'Aei j3ov6 8 -ye oi/re B : oi/re 76 T Proclus : ovre Olympiodorus
a 10 /3ou\t5vTot T Proclus Olympiodorus :fiov\<avra.iB
b 4 a3 T : &v
as
B : om. Proclus
b 6 ^ peyas T Proclus : ol /u7 ^
^ ^ fl'*s
. . . b i o TrAovToOvTos post C 2ffvp&ovKovtransp. Apelt
b 9 /col
ou v\ovrovvros seel. Schanz
b 13 ^ov\fva>yrai T Proclus :
B

AAKIBIAAH2

1070

, 7T<3y av vyiaivottv, dAAa frjTrjcrovcrw larpov tlvai. c

TOV

AA. EiKorcos ye
212. "Orav ovv Trepl TWOS o-KOTT&VTai, rore crv a
AA. "Orav Trepl rwv kam&v
ras
AA.
SI2.
^ aAAo
AA.
212.

OVK lycoye, w 2&)/

Nai;7rr/yety yap otjuat ov/c eTTtorao-at. roCr' a^rtoy ro
ri;
OVK, dAAa TOUTO.
'AAAa 7re/ot TTOMV r5>v lauraJy Aeyets Trpay/xarcoy d

AA. "Gray Trept TTO\^OV, S Sco/cpare?, ^ wept dprjvrjs 17

aAAoi; rou rcSy r?/? TroAea)? TTpay^aTcov.
212. ^Apa Aeyets oray f3ov\ev<avTat. trpbs TIVO.S XPV ip^vr]v 5

AA. Nat.
212.

Xpry 8' ovx oty

AA. Nat'.
212. Kat ro^' oTrore fif\Tiov;

A A. Haw ye.
212. Kat rocroOroj' xpovov o<rov
AA. Nat.
212. Et oSv fiovXevoiVTo 'A^i/faioi nVty )(p^ TTpocnta,- 5
Aatety Kat ricrty aKpo-^eLpi^eaOai /cat rtra rpOTrov, crv aptivov
av (rv/u/SovAevots ^ d 7rat8orpt/3?jj;
AA. 'O TraiboTpifiris SI^TTOU.
212. "E^eis ovz; etTrety Trpos rt (&v) ySAe-Trwy 6
ci fyivfiffovaiv T W : friTovffiv B Proclus
07 TC^ B Olympic
dorus : T&V T : ,nwj/ Apelt
d 4 &\\ov B Olympiodorus : 7re/>l
B
iAAou T W
d 8 oux W : om. T
e 9 &v addidi : post ffv/j.0ov
ev Ast

10 o-v/u,/3ot>Aev'o-eiei> ol$ 8et Trpoo-TraAatetv /cat ots fxij, /cat oTrore

/cal ovnva TpoTrov; Ae'yco 8e ro rotoVSe' Spa TOVTOLS Set
TrpocnraAaiety ots /3eArtoi>, TJ ov;
AA. Na^.
108
2Ii. 'Apa /cat rocraCra o(ra
AA. Too-aCra.
SH. Ov/coCi; /cat rore ore
AA. Flaw ye.
5
212. 'AA.A.a pjv Kal abovra Set KiOapi^eiv Trore Trpos rr)i;

10

10
C

A A. Aet yap.
211. QVKOVV rore oTrore /3e'Artoy;
AA. Nat.
2H. Kai rotrai)^' o<ra /3eArtoy;
AA.
211. Tt
repots, r<S re KiBapl^iv irpos TJ]V (o6~T)y /cat rai Trpoo-TraAateti',
rt /caAets ro ey roi Kc6ap[eiv /3eArtoi>, axrirep eya> ro ey rai
TtaXaCfiv KaAw yv^vatrTLKov <rv 8' e/ceiro rt KaAels;
AA. Oik zvvoSt.
2Ii. 'AAAa 7reip<S e/ute /xt/xeia^at. eyw yap TTOU aTre/cptvajotT]^ ro 8ia Trauros 6p6&s *xov> dp6)S 8e Sijirou e^ft TO
Kara r^y re^vrjv yiyvo^vov rj ov;
AA. Nat.
212. 'H 8e re^rr/ ov yv^vaa-TiKY] riv;
AA. ns 8' ov;
212. 'Ey<*> 8' eiTroy ro ey r<2 iraAatetv jSeArtoy yv^va(TTLK.OV.

AA. Etires yap.

212. OIIKOW KaAcSs;
AA. "Ejuoiye So/cet.
&5 ^Soj/ra T : T^ aSoi/ro B : rbv ^Sovra Ast
o f l w s Kidaiiv T

b a KtOapi&iv B :

AAKIBIAAH2

io8c

212. "We brj Kal av TryoeTroi yap av TTOV Kal (rol TO KaA<3s
StaAeyecrflaienre irp&TOv rts rj reyvi} rjs TO Kidaptfav Kal
ro abftv Kal TO eju/3au>e> opO&s; <ruvaTTa.<ra rts KaAetrat;
AA.
212.
AA.
212.

Ov brJTa.
'AAA' <38e Tetpw- rtVes at
Tas Mowras, w 2ft>/c/oares, Aeyets;
y
Eya)ye. o/>a 877* riya CTT' am&v fTT^vvp-iav

rj d

AA. MouortK^y juot

212. Aeyaj yap. rt ovv TO Kara TavTrjv 6p6&$
zcrriv; axrirep e/cei eyw trot ro Kara T?yf r4yyr]v eAeyoz; 6p6>s, 5
riv, Kal o~v br] ovv OTJTWS fVTavda rt
AA. MOVCTIK&S fj.oi bond.
212. Ev Aeyety.
i^t 8^, Kal TO V TW TroAe/xeti' /3eArtoz; Kal ro ev rw flprjvrjv ayf.iv, roCro ro /3eArto^ rt 10
dz/ojixa^eis'; axnrep exet e</>' eKatrro) eAeyes ro a^fivov, on e
fj.ovcriK<6Tpov
Kal irl rfi erepw, ort
yvfjivao-TiKotTepov
iTip& by Kal fVTavda Aeyeiz' ro /3eArtoi>.
AA. 'AAA' ov Tra^u n exw.
212. 'AAAa JJ^VTOL al(r%p6v ye et fieV rts o~e Aeyo^ra 5
xat o-ujLt/3oi;Aevoyra Trept crtrta)^ on ^SeArtoi/ ro8e ro58e Kat
rw xat TOVOVTOV, eTmra ep<wr?7o-etey " Ttr ro apeivov Aeyet?,
a) 'AAKt/3ta8r;; " Trept /xer TOVTOIV f\eiv flirdv on ro vytetvoTfpov, Katrot ov Ttpocnroif) ye tarpo? e?vai* Trept 8e ov
Kttt (TVfJL(3oV\V(rLS

aVLffTa^VOS

c 6 Wj B T W Olympiodorus : Ifo-flt Proclus

c 9 oi/Trw . . . d a
eX seel. Hermann
d4 areb ra^nitv T: KT' aurV B
d6 S^
oSv T : 8' oSy B
e i ^' K^(TT^ seel. Schanz
rJ> fyeivov
Proclus : T a.fj.elvovi B T
e 4 ow wow rt T Proclus : ov ttavv B
e 9 KO.ITOI ov T Proclus : Kal TOIOVTOV B
76 Proclus : om. B T :
re al.
a i <rvfi.f)ov\evffeis B T W (sed <r puncto notatum in T) :

<rvju.f)ov\f6tis Proclus vulg.

PLATO, VOL. II.

20

IO9

ioga

TIAAT11NO2
&)S ei8ws, TOVTOV 8', ws eoiKas, Trepi epcorijfleis' eav /U.TJ
e^rys ei7reu>, ov/c alvyvvri; r\ OVK alo")(pbv cpavelrai.;

AA. Haw ye.

5

211. SfcoTrei 8r) /cat TrpoOvf^ov

V TM flprjvqv re ayety afj-eivov
ot? Sef;

elTtslv Trpos TI reivfi TO

KOI TO V TW TroXe/xetv

AA. 'A\A.a cTKOTrSv ov bvvafj.ai evvoijcrai.

211. Ow8' oio-0a, eTretSaf iroAejaov Trotw//,e^a, OTI eyxa10 Aowres aAA?/Aots ira^/xa ep^o^Oa f l s TO iro\[jLiv, Kal
b

AA. vEya>ye, on ye ea7rarci)ji>iei'ot ri T) /3ta^"o/xei;ot

2H. "E^e* TTcSs eKaora rovrcoy Tracrxovres; iretpw

ri Sia^e'pet ro <i58e r/ c58e.
5
AA. *H ro 58e Ae'yets, S 2wK/3ares, TO StKatcos T/ TO
212. Avro TOUTO.
AA. 'AXAa JUT/V TOUTO ye 8ta<e'pe6 oAoy re Kai
211. Tt ovy; 'A^rjyatois o-i 77065 Trorepovs o-u/j,|3ov10 Xevo-ets TroAe/xeiy, TOI? d8t/cowras r) TOVS Ta dixaia Trp&Trovras;
C
AA. Aetyoy TOVTO ye epcoras" et yap xat SiayoeiTat TIS
&>? 8et irpo? TOIS Ta Si'/cata TrpaTTO^Tas TroAejaety, ov/c av
o/AoAoy7)o-eieV ye.
211. Ov yap vofjupov Tovd', ws eotKey.
5
A A. Ov bfJTa.' ovbt ye Kakbv 8oKet ewai.
211. ITpoy TaSr' &pa Kal <rv [TO biKatov] TOVS Aoyovs

a 3 ^awrroi T Proclus : <f>aiverat B

a 6 ri> B T : om. Proclus
a 8 eVj/o^froi T Proclus : yorjcrai B
a g 8rt T Proclus : ri B
Olympiodorus
b i 76 TW: om. B
bs ^ corn Coisl. :
ct B T : ct Se Proclus
C 6 TWT' B T Proclus : TOUT' ci. Stephanus
rb SiKauov seel. Niirnberger

AAKIBIAAH2

logc

212. "AAAo rt ovv, o vvvbr] eyo> Typconoy /3eArtoz> rrpos

TO TToAejUety Kttl /iTy, KCU

OLS Ofl

KCU

ot? fiT), KOL OTTOTf

KOL

1Q

fj.t], TO oiKaiorepov Tvy^avft ov; r] ov;

AA. <I>aiyerai ye.
212. ITSs oSr, S (f)i\ 'AAKi/3ia8?7; Trorepov travrov d
\t\.r]0as on OVK eTriVracrat rouro, r; e/^e eAa^es
KOL <f)OiT&v fls 8t8a(T/caAou os <re e8i'8acrK
TO oiKaiorepov re ical aStKwrepoi'; Kat riy etrrty
(frpao-ov Kal fjjioi, 'iva cwrw (j)OLTr]Tr]v Trpoevr)(rr)s Kal e/xe.
5
AA. 2jc<a7rre6s, S 2coKpares.
211. Ov /xa rw ^tAtoy TOV ffjiov re Kat o-or, ov eya>
17/cior' &y e7Tto/)/c?;(ratjUf dAA' e??rep ^X6'^ e'/7r^ rt/? f"7"t1''
AA. Tt 8' ei //.T/ ex^>; O^K ay oiet /^e aAAws ec'Serat e
irept T&V biKaicov KCU abiKcav;
212. Nat, e<f ye evpots.

AA. 'AAA' OVK &v evpeTv /x,e ^yr};

212. Kai /naAa ye, et ^rrjcraiy.
5
AA. Etra {^TTJO-CU ow/c ay otet )ixe;
212. "Eycoye, et olrjdeirjs ye p/ eiSeVat.
A A. Etra O^K 17^ 6V elxoy ovrco;
212. KaA<3? Aeyety. ex^ts ow eiuety TOVTOV TOV \povov
ore OVK wou ei8eyat ra biKaia Kal ra abiKa; ^>e'pe, Trepvaiv no
egrets re /cat OVK wou etSeVat; ^ wov; Kat Ta\.rj6ij
cnroKpivov, Lva fj/fj fj,d.Tr]v ol 8taAoyot yiyvutVTai,
AA. 'AAA' w/Lt?]i; ei'SeVai.
212. Tpirov 8' eros Kat re'raproy Kat TT^TTTOV ofy 5
ovra)?;
AA. "Eycoye.
212. 'AAAa ju,?)y ro' ye Trpo rou TTOIS rjo-Oa. rj yap;
A A. Nat'.
d 3 St5ao-a\ou B Proclus Olympiodorus : SiSaa-Ka\ovs T
d 5 /coi
f/i6 B : ljue T Proclus Olympiodorus
d 7 ow yua Proclus : pit, B T
e 5 76 om. Stobaeus
a 2 re B Proclus: om. T
a 3 Sj
\6yoi Cobet
a 8 rot/T Proclus : TOVTOU B Olympiodorus

no a
10
b

10
C

riAATiZNOS
212. Tore fj.V TOIVVV ev 0180, ort MOD etSeVat.
AA. Ha)? ev otffOa;
212. rioAAaKt? (row kv SiSao-KaAoo;; ^KOVOV 7rat8o? orros
/cat aAAoflt, Kai OTroYe do"rpayaA.ibts t] aAA?]z> Tiva
-naC&is, ov\ &>s cnropovvTos irept rcSz; SiKcuW /cat dSi/c
dAAa /xdXa /jieya Kat OappaXtas \eyovros Trept oror
TWI' 7rai8coi' cos Trovrjpos re Kat aStKOS eaj Kat ws
r/ OVK. aXrjOfi Xeyco;
AA. 'AAXa rt 1/xeAXor Troterr, S SwKpare?, d^ore rts
/xe dSt/coi;
211. St 8' ei rv)(0t? dyyowi' etr5 dStKow etre ^ tore,
Aeyet?, rt (re x/3^? wotety;
AA. Ma At' aAA' OVK ijyi'o'ouy eya>ye, dXA.a cra(/><S$
lyiyvuMTtiov on ribiKovfjLrjv.
212. "Utou apa eTrtVrao-^at Kai wats &>i>, ws lotxe, Ta
8t'xata Kat ra aStKa.
AA. "Eywye- Kat Tjirto-rfi/xrjy ye.

Sii. 'Ei> TTOIW XPV(P *tvp(i>v; ov yap S^TTOU ev w ye

AA. Ov 8?)ra.
212. ndre ovv ayvoelv rjyov; crKOTrer ov yap
10 TOVTOV TOV xpovov.
AA. Ma roz; Ai", 2ci)Kpares, OVKOUZ; e)(co y'
d.
212. Evpa>y /xei1 ap' OVK oTo-0a avrd.
AA. Ov Trdi^u ^at^ojmat.
212. 'AXA.a ^y a/art ye oiiSe paOuv <-<j)ri<Tda
et 8e jw?j0' rjvpe? /xrjr' e/xa^ey, TTWS oia"0a Kat
5
AA. 'AAA.' tcro)? ToGrd o-ot ov/c 6p6G>s
(frdvat, et8ei>at auros f
212. To 8e 'TTCO
AA. wEju,a^oi' ot/zai Kai eyw wo-irep Kat ot aAAot.
a 10 ^t6i/ Toivvv B T : /jLevroi Proclus
b I <rou om. Proclus
C 6 irotij> Dobree : dvoicp B T
d 5 aveKpivtifM^v B T : omtKpiQ^v

Stobaeus

d 7 rb 8i B T : -rb Se 5Se Coisl. : rb S^ ogrw Proclus

AAK1B1AAHS

nod

212. TldAty els TOV airbv rJKO[j.v \6yov. Trapa TOV;

de /cdjuot.
10
AA. ITapa T&V TroXX&v.
e
212. OVK ets cnrovbaLovs ye 8t8ao"KaAoi;s Kara^evyets
eis TOVS KoXXovs ava(pp(i)v.
AA. Tt 8e; o^x t/carot 8i8aai owrot;
212. OijKOW ra 'jrerreuriKa ye /cat ra ^77' /catrot 5
ovrcos o?et;
AA. Nat.
212. Etra ra fJLV <auAo'repa ov^ otoi re 8t8ao-Keti', ra
8e o-7roi)8a6orepa;
10
AA. O?/j,ai eycoye* aXAa yoCy TroAXa otot r' eicrtz; 8tSacr/cety (rTrowJaiorepa TOW ireTrevfiv.
212. no^a ravra;
AA. Oioy Kat ro eAAT/in^eu' Trapa rovrcoy eytoy' Hp-aOov, III
Kat ow/c a^ e)(otju.t et7reu> e/xaurou 8t6a(TKaAoy, aAA' eis
rovs arrows dva^epco o^s o-v ^>TJS ov crTrouSatou? etz/at
212.
TroAAoi,
AA.
212.

'AAA', w yeyya^e, TOVTOU /iey dya^ot SiSao-xaAoi 01 5

Kal StKatcos fTrcuvoivf1 av avrS>v ds
Tt'Sif/
Ori

AA. Tt ro{;ro Ae'yeij;

10
212. OUK oTo-^' on XP^ '"o^s /jte'AAovras 8todo-/ceiy drtouv
Trp&rov etSe^at; ^ ov;
b
AA. ITcSs yap ov;
212. OVKOW roi/s etSoras o/^oAoyeii' re dAA^Aots Kat

e 2 /cara^eiryets T : KaraQeiryei B
69 ofoi re Proclus : o*ot B :
o?ot T
a 2 ttv T Proclus : om. B
tlireiv efjiavTov B : 4/j.avrov
eiireiv T Proclus
a 3 avrovs T : epavTovs B
a 6 eVcu^o?!/-?-'
&v . . . is StScwr/caA.faj' B T : eiraivo?T' Uv . . . i] SiSacTKa\ia Proclus
avrwv seel. ci. Stallbaum

mb

I7AAT12N02

AA. Nat'.
212. 'Eu ots 8' av Siac^epawrcu, raSra </>?]<reis etSe
amovs;
AA. Ov brjra.
212. Tovrcoy ovv 8i8a<TKaAot TTWS ay etez>;
10
AA. OvSajuws.
211. Ti ovv; SoKoGcrt crot (Ha<e'pecr0ai ot iroAAoi Ttolov
fcm Xt^os ^ QuXov; Kal tav riva epwras, ap' ov ra avra
C 6/xoA.oyowiy, Kal em ravra opfjiSxriv orav fiovXtoVTai.
\iQov ?) fcvXov; wcravra)? Kal iravd' ocra roiaurcr
yap ri jj,avOdv(o TO eA.A.rjyi^ety eTTio-racr^at ort rouro
V
77\ ov;
5
AA. Nat.
211. OVKOW els /x,ey raC^'j wcnrep etTro/xey, aAATpuns re
ojoioA.oyoCo-1 Kal avrol eawcHS t8ia, Kal 8r;//,o(ria at TroAets
os dAAr;Aas OVK a^itr^Tovtriv at jaey rau^' at 8' aAAa
5

10

AA.
212.
dya0oi.
d
AA.
212.

Ow yap.
EtKoVcoy ay apa roi/noi' ye Kal 6t8acrKaAot
Natr.
OVKOVV et /uey ^ov\OLfj.e6a Troiija-aL TWO. irepl avr&v
^ais az> avrov 7rex7roijiey ets

AA. Haw ye.

212. Tt 8' et POVX^O^IJLCV
ai'Op(i)TTOL

flfflV

TTOrot

ei'Se^ai, /x^ /JLOVOV

?7T7TOt,

dAAtt

KOt

TtVe?

TTOLOI
OV-

T&V bpop.iK.oi re KOI /XT/, ap' ert ot TroAAol rouro t

AA. Ov
212. l\K.avov 8e <rot T^Kiiov ort
b 12 ou T: oSv B
08 &\\a </>a<rKou(rai T Proclus :
<f>d<TKovffi.v B
C n ye B : om. T Proclus
d.2 ftov\oip.e6a
B Proclus : jSouAo//^ fej' T

AAKIBIAAH2

me

8i8acrKaAoi ettro' TOVTCVV, eVeiS?) ovbtv 6fj,o\oyov(nv

AA. vE/xotye.
212. Ti 8' i (3ovXr)OfliJ.fv
et8erat, /AT/ povov irdioi
a.2>0pa)TroC dariv, dAA' OTTOUH vyteti'ot 17 yooxoSei?, ap' txavot
ay fjfjuv fffrav 8i8a<TKaA.ot 01 iroXXoi;
AA. Ov 8^ra.
212. 'Hy 8' ar o-ot TfK[j.^piov on /uo^^r/pot et(Ti TOVTCW
bibdcrKaX.oi, et tdpas avrovs bia(j)spofji.evovs;
AA. "E/iAoiye.
212. Ti 8e 817; vvv Trepl rS>v biKaiuiv /cat aSt/ccoy avOpa>TTOIV KOL Ttpa-yfj,a.T(tiv ol 7roA.Aot boKovcrC <roi 6^oX.oyflv avrol
laurois ^ dAAr/Aots;
AA. "HKiara vrj At', S 2coKpare9.
212. Tt 8e; //.aAtora irepl avr&v 8ta^>e/)ecr^ai;
A A. IToAv ye.
212. OVKOW otoiuat ye ircii'Trore <re iSety otiS' aKoCcrat
<r<j)6bpa ovro) 8ta0e/30/uieVovs av0pd>irovs Trcpl vyiewGtv Kal
fj.rj, &aT Sta ravra fjni^fcrdai re Kal a-noKravvvai dAA?jAot;j.

10
112

AA. Ov 8r]ra.
212. 'AAAa Trepl rS>v StKatcoz; Kai d8tKcoy lycoy' 018' on, 10
Kal ei JUT) IwpaKas, aKTj/coas your aAAo)z/ re iroAAwy KCU b
'O^pov /cat 'O8uo-<retas yap KOL 'lAta^os1 d/oj/coas.
AA. riaWa>s ST/TTOU, a> 2a>K/3ares.
212. OVKOVV Tavra 7rotT//xara ecrrt Trept 8ta<Tjopas
re Kai d8tKO)y;
AA. Nat'.
212. Kat at judxat ye Kat ot 0dz;aroi 8ta ravrTjv
bia(f)opav TOLS re 'Amatols Kat roty aAAois T/xoo-tr eye
Kal rots /uvT/crr^ptrt TO?S rTys OT/^eAoTrrj? Kat r<3 'O8ucr(rer.
AA. 'AATy^r] Ae'yets.
C
e 1 1 /cal aSinuv B : om. T W Proclus
oAAojs B T

a a aA.AijA.ois Proclus :

IMC

10
e

11AAT12NO2
212. Otjuat 8e /cat rots tv "Tav&ypq 'AOrjvaiMV re Kai
AaKe8at/xozna>z> /cat Bota>r&ii> aTToBavovan, Kai rofe vcrrfpov
cv Kopcoz>eta, ez> ots /cat 6 <rb$ TTarrjp [KAetznas] ereAevrrjo-ey,
repl ei>os aAAou ^ Sia</>o/oa ^ 7re/)t roi) 5t/caiou KCU
TOVS davdrovs KCU ras ju,axas TreTroirjKev tf yap;
AA. 'AATjl??; Ae'yets.
212. TOVTODS ovv <j)G>iJ.ev eTnVraor^ai irept wy ovrco?
8ta^)epoz/rat, wore afJL<f)i(r(3T]TovvTfs
dAA?j\ots ra
cr^as avrow epya^birai;
AA. Ow (^atyerat ye.
211. OWKOW eis rovs roiourow 8i8a<r/C(iAovs
ava(f)fpis
ovy 6/AoAoyeis avros /u,^ etSeyat;
AA. "Eotxa.
212. II(3s ow etKos o-e etSeVai ra 5tKaia Kat ra a8tKa,
Trept wi' owrco 7rAai>a Kai oi;re p,adu>v (fraivri Trap'
ovr' avros e^eupwz;;
AA. 'Ex /xev c5y <rv Aeyeis OIK eixos.
22. 'O/aoy au roC^' a>s ov
AA. To irotoy;
212. "Ort e/ue ^>^y ratJra
AA. Tt Se; ov crv Aeyets &>s eya> ovSez; eTrtVrajaat
rwr biKaioov KCU
212.

10

AA. 'AAA' ^y&>;

212. Na^.
AA. ndis 877;
212. ?I28e eto-ry. eaV ere Ipw/^iat ro ey /cat ra 5vo worepa
eort, ^^(rets ort ra 8vo;
AA. "Eycoye.
212.
c 4 post Kopwveia add. <rvfj.$afftv Proclus
^ ofs B T : Sre Proclus
K\ewlas B T : om. Proclus
C 5, 6 TJ SiaQopk . . . TreiroiriKev B : T^V
Sicuftopatv . . . TreironiKfvat T Proclus
d 5 ouTJs] avrobs Hirschig
64 ovSev tirlffrcifjuu Ven. 184: (rvveirlffrafjuu
B T W : OVK
Proclus

AAKIBIAAH2

use

AA. 'Evt.
212. Tlonpos ovv fm&v 6 Aeyc*>z> on ra bvo TOV fvbs 15
AA. 'Eyo>.
212. OVKOVV ey&> //,> rjptoTiav, <rv b' direK/)u>ov;
AA. Nai.
212. ITejOj 8r/ rovrft>y /xaii' eya> (j)aCvop,ai, A.eycov o epwrwr, 113
r) (rv 6
AA. 'Eyw.
212. Ti 8' ai> eycb /xe^ epw/xat Troia ypa^juara 2a>K:/)arouy,
OT) 8' elTTi;?, Trorepos 6 Aeywi',*
5
AA. 'Eya).
212. "I^t 8?;, Ivi Ao'ya) eiW' oray eputTrjcris re KCU
aTroKpi,(ri.s yLyvrfTdi, Trorepos 6 \4ya>v, o fpoor&v rj 6 O.TTOAA.
212.
AA.
212.
AA.
212.
AA.

'0 aTTOKpivo/jievos, l/xotye boKfl, S 2wKpares.

QVKOVV CLPTI. 8ia Trairos eya) /uez/ 17 o epa>T&v;
Nai.
2v 8' 6 a.TTOKpLv6fj.Vos;
Ilaru ye.
Ti oSi'; ra Xe\9evTa -noTepos rjn&v eipijKev;
4>au>o/icu /xeV, S 2wK/?ares, e/c r<3

10
b

212. OVKOW f\e\0r] ircpl biKaCatv KOL abiKaiv OTL 'AX/ct6 KaAo? 6 KAeivtou O^K eTrto-Tairo, OUHTO 8e, xat
ets fKKXrja-iav (XOaiv o-i)ju/3oDAeweii' 'A^r/yatoi? 7re/)i 10
rev; ov TOUT' 77 z>;
AA. <f>atVerat.
C
212. To TOV Evpt7Ti8ou a/)a <nyi/3aii>ei, S 'AXKiftidbr]'
<rov rdbf Kivbvvevcis, OVK fp.ov aAcrj/coevat, 0^8' eyw et/jit o
a 4 epu/jiai iroia Olympiodorus : ^pw Kal iroia B T : eptaru Kal iroia.
Proclus
b l iraj'T&sTWProclus: iravrbs rov \oyov B
b8 STI
post aSiicwv B : ante irepl T
03 OVK Proclus (cf. Eur. Hipp. 352) :
&\A' ou/c B T

H3C

DAAT&NO2

Tavra Ae'ycoy, dAAa crv, ep,e 8e atria ju.arrji'.

KCU
5 Kai ev Aeyets. navuwv yap kv v& <Xa? e7rixeip?7/
, co /3eAri0re, 8iSao-Keu> a ot>K olcrOa, a
d

114

AA. Oijxai jue'y, S ScoKpares, dAiyaKts 'Adrjvatovs /3ouAeve<r0at Kat TOWS aAAous "EAA^a? Trorepa
^ dStKwrepa- ra jaer yap rotavra r\yovvra.i 8?jAa
eacrarres ow Trepl OVTWV (TKOTtovinv OTro'repa
irpda<riv. ov yap rawa ot)u,at kcrrlv ra re dtxata /cat ra
(rvfj-^povTa, dAAa TroAAor? 8rj eAu(rtreArj(rer d8tK77crao-i /x,eydAa dStKTy/iara, Kai erepots ye oljuiat Suata epyacra/xerois
ov (Tvvrjve-yKfv.
2il. Ti ow; et ort /xaAtcrra erepa juer ra Suata
Tuyxa^ft oira, erepa 8e ra (ruju^epo^ra, ov ri TTOU av crii
ofet raur' etSeyai a <rvfJL(pepi rots avOp&nois, /cat 8t' ort;
AA. Ti yap /ccoAwt, S SwKpares; et /x^ /ixe aw ep??o-?}
Trap' orou ZpaQov TJ OTTCOS avros rjvpov.
2H. Otoy rouro Troters. et rt /AT) op^wy Aeyets, rvyxyei
6e ftwaTov ov a7ro8e?^at 8t' ovTrep /cat ro Trporepoi; Aoyou,
otet 8r) Kai^a arra 8err aKOvety a7ro8eteis re erepas, ws
rwy Trporepaw otoy o~/ceuaptcoy Kararerpt/x/xevcoi', Kat ovKer
ay (TV aura d/x7rtcr)(oio, et /x?] rts (rot reK/x^ptoy Kadapbv
/cat ayjpavTov ottret. eya> 8e \aiptiv eao-as ras era? Trpobpofj.as TOV Aoyou ov8ei> TJTTOV ep?j(rop:at vodev naO&v av ra
(Tu/w^epoyr' e7rto"raa"at, Kai 6Vris ecrrty 6 StSacrKaAoy, /cat
iraW fKflva ra Trporepoy epwrw jtzia epcorTjo-et; dAAa yap
8r/Aoi> ws ets ravrbv ^ets Kai ovx e^ets aTroSer^at ov^' a>s
ol(r9a ra arv^fpovTa ovd* a>s fj.ad(ov.
eTreiS^ 8e
Kat ovKe'r' ay ^Secos rou avrou yeuvaio Aoyou, rouroz/ /xev ew ^atpety, etr' ourtfa etre /A^ ra 'A^rjyatots
C 4 M^ S^ am$ T : /te Stairj^ B : ^/te 8e Siajrj^ W
e 6 S> B :
om. T Proclus
e 7 8)? B : 8e?T
a7ro86i'eis re Irepoy seel. Cobet
e 9 TfK(jL-f)piov om. Ficinus, seel. Ast
a 2 jro'flcp B Proclus : 6ir60ei>
T Olympiodorus
a 3 d B Proclus : om. T

AAKIBIAAH2
(pepozmr vorepov 8e ravra e<rrt 8ucata re Kai criyxc^epoyr'
rj erepa, rt OVK aTreSeifas; et /u,ez/ fiovXei, epa>r<z> IMC &><r7rep
eya> ere, ei 8e, Kal auros em creavrov Aoya) 8teeA0e.
AA. 'AAA' OK ot8a et oto's r' av etrjv, S 2a)Kpares, TT/SOS
(re SceX^ery.
212. 'AAA', a>ya$e', e/xe e/c/cAiycrta^ vop.i(rov /cat brjfJLOV
KOI eKet TOI <re Seiycrei eVa HnacrTov ireiOeiv. y yap;
AA. Nat.
212. O^KOW TOU avrou era re otoz' re eu>ai Kara fjiovas
TTi0t.v Kal crv/x,/7roA.Aous Trept &v av ei8r), uxnrcp 6 ypaju,fxarioTTJy eVa re TTOD Tret^et irept ypa^aruiv Kal TTO\\OVS;
AA. Nat.
212. *A/)' oSy ov at irepl apiO^ov 6 avros era re KOI
7roAA.oi)? Tretcret;
AA. Nat'.
2i2. Ovros 8' ecrrat 6 etSwy, 6 apiOfJLrjTiKos;
A A. ITa^i; ye.
212. OVKOVV Kal <rv aTrep Kal TroAAoi)? oto? re ireCOciv
et, raura Kai era;
AA. EIKOS ye.
212. "Ea-rt 8e rai/ra 8^Aoy ort a ot&Oa.
AA. Nat'.
212. vAAA.o rt ovv TCKTOVTOV \i6vov 8ta^)epet rov fv rw
87^/10) prjropos 6 fv rr) rota8e (rvvovariq, ort d /xer aOpoovs
ra avra, 6 8e <ca0' eVa;
AA. Kt^SD^e^et.
212. "Wt vvv, eiretS?) roO a^roy ^att'erat TroAAovs re Kat
Tret^etr, ez> e/mot eju,/xeAerij(roi/ KOI Tn.xfipr]<TOv eTrtSe^at
ro StKatoi; ertore ov
AA.
C 2 re TTOU TTflQti B Proclus : re eiretOev irov T : re velOfi irov W
c 4 ou B : om. T Proclus
c 9 KOU av T Proclus : o-i B
014 SM<f>epfi T Proclus : SiaQepeiv B
d 4 ytJy B T : roivvv Proclus : 5^
vvv vulg.
d 5 ffifUfXerriffov
T Proclus : e>/ /teAeVryo-oj/ B

n4b
b

10

nAATi2NO2
212. Nw yovv v<fi vfipeas jue'AAo) ere ircCdeiv ravavria
ols crv e/x,e OVK efle'
10
AA. Ae'ye 8?/.
212. 'AiroKpivov novov TO. e
e
AA. M?;, dAAd a~i; avrbs Ae'ye.
211. Tt 8'; o^x on juaAiora /3ovAet 7rei<rdrjvai,;
AA. ITayrcDj STJTTOU.
212. OVKOW ei Aeyets on rau^' ovrcoy exet> /^^Aicrr' ay
5 efr;s n-eimo-jnei'oy;
AA. "E/xotye SoKet.
2Ii. 'AKOKpivov by' Kol eav py avrbs (rv cravrov aKovcrys
OTI TO, ftiKaia KOI (rv^(f>povTd fcrriv, aAA.a> ye Aeyoyri fj.r)

10

AA. OiJroi, dAA' aTTOKpireov

KCU yap

ovbev oio/xat

115

212. MOJTIKOS ya/a et. Kat juot Aeye* rw

evia /xev crvfji^epfiv, fvia 8' o#;
AA. Na^.
211. Ti 8e; ra //.ez; *caAa OLVT&V flvcu, ra 8' oil;
5
AA. IT<3s rouro epcoras;
212. Et rts ^8?y trot e'8oez> al(r\pa ^v, 8t/caia 8e

AA. OWK l/no6ye.

212. 'AAAa irdvra Ta SiKaia /cat KaAa;
10
AA. Nau
212. Tt 8' av ra KaAa; Trorepov Ttdvra ayaQa, rj ra /xeV,
ra 8' ov;
AA. Olo/^ai eya>ye, S 2w/cparesij eyia r<2y KaAwr xa/ca
67ffavrovTW Proclus Olympiodorus : om. B
a/cowa^s B Olympiodorus Stobaeus : axovys T Proclus
e 8 ol add. Stobaeus : om.
BT
ye add. BW Proclus Stobaeus: om. T Olympiodorus
a 4 T( 5e T (rl Sal) Proclus : om. B

avreav elvcu B : slvai avruv T

Proclus
a 6 tfSri T Proclus Olympiodorus : Sjj B
T Proclus : om. B
a n ^ T Proclus : om. B

a 9 /cal

AAKIBIAAH2
212. *H Kal alcrxpa ayaOa;
AA. Nat'.
212. ^Apa Aeyets ra rotate, olov -TroAAot kv 7roXe/x&>
vTfs eraipa> T) ot/cetw rpav/xara eAa/3oy /cat aTreOavov,
ol 8' ov /3or]6ri(ravTs, SeW, vyta? aTrijXOov;
AA. ria^u /^ey ow.
2H. OVKOW r^y roiavrriv [3or]0eiav KaXrjv juev Aeye6?
/cara r^y eTn^eipr/a-ti; roi; crwcrat ovs e6et, TOUTO 8' lorty
avbpeia.' TI ov;
AA. Nat.
SI2. KaK^y Se ye Kara rovs ^a^aroD? re /cat e'AKrj- ^ yap;
AA. Nat.
511. 'Ap' ovv OVK aAAo /iey ^ dr8peta, aAA.o 8e 6 ^araro?;
AA. Haw ye.
512. OVK apa Kara ravrov y' e<rrt KaXbv Kal KCLKOV TO
rols (f)i\ois flor]6ttv;
AA. Ov (fraCvfTai.
212. "Opa TOIWV el, y ye Kakov, Kal ayaOov, axnrep Kal
vrav6a. Kara rt]v avbpeiav yap w/xoAoyeis Kakov etWt rTjy
ro{)r' oSf awro o-KOTret, rr)y avbpfiav, ayaQbv i]
ov; cS8e 8e (TKOTref crv -Trorep' ay 8e'^ato (rot etrai,
ayada rj KaKa;
AA. 'AyaflcL
212. OVKOW ra p-eytcrra p,aAt(rra.
(AA. Nat'.)
212. Kat ^Kta-ra rwy rotourcoy 8e'ato Sy orrepeo-0ai;
A A. ITci)s yap ov;
212. ITwy our Aeyets irept avbpeias; em TTOO-O) &z> avroC
b a eraipcf T Proclus : Irepy B
b 3 ot T : ou B
b 9 eA/cr;
T W Proclus : ra e\Krj B
c i odv OVK T Proclus : OVK B
C 3 /caret ravrov T : /car' ouroV B Stobaeus
C 6 Sxrwep Kal B
Stobaeus : Sxrirep T Proclus
C 9 <ri< ir^repa &v T : ir6repa &v Proclus :
irdrepov &v Olj^mpiodorus : irorep' &v Stobaeus : irorepav B
d a i/af

add. Dobree

15
b

10
c

10
d

H5d

IIAAT11NO2

AA. Ov5e r)v av ey<w

211. "Eo'xaroi' apa KO.K&V flvaC croi SoKet 77 8eiA.ux.
AA. vE/uotye.
10
2H. 'E forou rw TtOvavcu, <*>? lotKe.
AA. <J>?7/At.
211. OVKOW flavored re Kat 8etA.ta eyayriwraroz; fca^ Kat
avbpeia;
AA. Nai.
e
2H. Kat ra pfv fiaXior' ^y etyai fiov\oio (rot, ra 8e
AA. Nat'.
211. 'Ap' ort ra //,ef aptora ^yrj, ra 8e
5
(AA. IldVu ye.
211. 'Ey rot? aptorois apa cri; ^yf/ avbpeuav ct^at Kar
TOIS /caKicrrotS' Odvarov.}
AA. "Eycoye.
211. To apa fiorjOelv kv 7roAe/u,o) rots (piXois, rj fjiev
10 KoXov, Kar' dyaflou Trpaiv rrjy 7779 avbpeias, KaXbv avro

AA. 4>atVo//at ye.

211. Kara 8e ye KOKOU 7rpaiv rrjv rou 6o.va.rov KO.KOV;
AA. Nat'.
15
211. OVKOW w8e StKatoi; TrpocrayopeveLV fK.dfrrr]v T&V
irpd^ftov etTrep ^ Ka/coy aTrepya^erat Kanrjv Ka\.els, Kat ^
Il6 ayaQov ayaOrfv KX^reor.
AA. "Ejuotye Soxei.
211. *Ap' ow /cat f) ayaOov, fcaXoy 17 8e KO.KOV,
d. 7 e*7ci> B T : ^0)74 Stobaeus
d 8 KO.KWV flvai trot So/ce?
B : trot KaKbv ftvai SOKC? T Proclus : <roi Sofce? Katfbv elvai Stobaeus
e i n<i\i(Tr' &v B : juciAnrra T Proclus Stobaeus
e 4 ort B T : oSc
Stobaeus
e 5 iraru 75 ... e 7 Odvarov Stobaeus : om. B T Proclus
e8 e-yuye B : iravv ye T W Proclus
e 13 Se 76 T Proclus: S
B Stobaeus
615 SSe 5iatov BT: 8i'/cioy 55e Stobaeus
e 1 6 airep7affTa B Stobaeus : tpydfaeu T Proclus

AAKIBIAAH2

n6a

AA. Nat.
5
212. Trjv ap* ev ra> TroAe'juto roi? (/uAoi? fioridfiav Ae'ycou
ey e>at, KCLKTJV be, ovbev 8ta(/>epoWa)? Aeyets T) ei
avrrjv dyadrjv p,(i>, KO.K.TIV 8e.
AA. JA\r]6f) /xoi 8o/cet? Aeyety, S 2a>K/)ares.
212. OvSey apa r<3y KaX&v, /ca^' oo-oy /caAoV, K.O.K.OV, 10
TSi> ala-^p&v, K.a.6* ocrov altryjiov, ayaOov.
AA. Ow c^atverat.
b
21i. "Ert TOIVVV KOI <38e crKeiat. OOTIS xaAw?
AA.
212.
AA.
212.
AA.
212.
A A.
212.
AA.
212.
AA.
212.

Nat'.
01 8' ev TT/aarroire? ov/c evat/Aoyes;
nSs yap ov;
Ow/coO^ evbaifJLoves 8t' aya&S>v KTrj(n
MdAiara.
Krcozrat 8e ravra rw e3 /cat KaAwy
Nat.
10
To eu apa TrpdrTfiv ayaOov;
Hois 8' ov;
OVKOW KaAw ^ evvpayia;
Nat'.
Tavror apa <f>di>r] fjiuv iraXiv av KaXov re /cat C

AA.
212. "Ort az/ apa d;p&>ju> KaAoV, Kat ayaOov ^vpr\
e/c ye TOT^TOV row Aoyou.
AA. 'AvdyKrj.
212. Tt 8e; ra ayada o"uju,^)epei r/ ou;
AA.
a 8 irpoff fives B Stobaeus: vpoeiirts T Proclus
post
Se add. ovSafn&s Stobaeus
bs owx^ K o t B T : OUK Olympiodorus
b i r T& yoGy /caAws irpdrrfiv Stobaeus
C 4 K} B Olympiodorus
Stobaeus : re /cat T
05 \6yov B T : irapaSelj/^aros
Stobaeus

n6c

IIAATJ2NO2
ovv irept T&V biKakov Trots &>/AoAoy?7-

10 tra/xez/;
AA. Ot/iai ye row ra St/cata TrpaTTovras avaynaiov
et^ai /caAa Trodrrety.
211. OVKOVV Kal rovs ra /caAa ayadd;
AA. Ncu'.
d
211. Ta 8e dyafla
(rv^fpfLv;
AA. Nat'.
211. Ta 8i/ccua apa, S 'AAKty8ta8rj, crvfJ-fjifpovTa.
fcrnv.
AA. "Eot/cey.
5
2H. Tt oSy; raura ov <rv 6 Aeycoy, eya> 8e 6 epcorcov;
AA. <l>aiVo/x,ai, <ws eotxa.
21i. Et ow rts driorarai <ru/x/3ouAewcoy eirf 'AOrjvaiois
etre TlTrapr]0iois, olo^vos yiyvuxrKeiv ra StKata Kat ra
a8t/ca, (prjo-fi, 8' eii>ai ra 8uata Ka/ca tvtoTe, aAAo ri ^
10 KarayeAa>?7s ay a^roi;, e7ret87jirep rvy^ayets xal o-v Aeycoi^
6 on Tdi>ra eori 8tKaia re /cat (rv/j-^povra;
AA. 'AAAa /x,a rovs 6tovs, at 2c)Kpares', OVK 018' eycoye
ov8' ort Ae'yco, aAA' drex^ws eotxa droTrcos e^oyrf rore
juev ycxp /ixoi erepa 8oxet erou fputrStvros, rore S' oAAa.
5
2H. EIra roSro, a 0tAe, dyyoet1? ro TrdOrjua ri
AA. ndi'u ye.
2H. Ofet ar ovy, e? rty epforoMj (re 8vo
rpels e^ets, /cat 8vo ^e^Pas *? rerrapas, 77 aAAo rt raiz/
roiovTMV, rore /^er ere/sa &y anoKpLvao-dai, rore 8e aAAa, 77
10 del ra avrd;
117
AA. Ae'8ot/ca //ev eycoye 7)817 '7re/)^ e/xaurou, otjuai jueVrot
V
5
/
ra avra.
2H. OW/COTJZ; ort o?(r0a; roCr'
c 9 <J>yuo\ ^ija-as Stobaeus
e n ol^of -ye om. Stobaeus
ret
5i/ca*a B Stobaeus : SiKata T
C 13 ical B : om. T
OVKOVV Kal robs ra
Kaipta \fyovTas Stobaeus (om. mox duobus versibus)
d. 5 K4y<ev B
Olympiodorus : \eycov el T
d p <^<m] ^""i ci. Stallbaum
elvoi
B : eJSeVoi T
as oJaOa b t : oTo-flos B T

AAKIBIAAH2

117 a

AA. Otjuat eyeoye.

212. ITepi 3>v apa aK<oz> ravavria aTTOKpwr], brjXov on 5
TTpl TOVTtoV OVK ol(r6a.

A A. E I/cos ye.
212. OVKOVV Kal Tiepl T>V 8tKautiz> Kat d8iKcoi> KCU KaA<Sz>
Kat aicrfcp&v Kal KO.K>V Kal ayaQ&v Kal cm/^^epoircoy Kat
/XT) airoKpivonevos (frfo 7rXava<r0ai; efra ov drjXov on 8ta 10
ro //?) tlbtvai Tttpl amS>v, 8ta raSra TtXava;

A A. vEju,oiye.

212. 9Ap' ovy ovTto Kal exei' ^ftSay rt? rt /x,^ et6f),
avayKalov irepl TOVTOV "irXavafrOai TTJV \jsvxjiv;
A A. Flo) 9 yap ov;
212. Tt ovv; otcrOa ovnva rpOTtov avafiricrr] ets rbvovpavov; 5
AA. Ma At' OVK lycoye.
212. 'H /cat TrXavaraC <rov fj 8ofa Tre/u raura;
AA. Ov S^ra.
212. To 8' a^rioy olcr6a T) eya> (ppdcro);
AA. <&pd<rov.
10
212. "On, a> ^>tXe, OVK otet avro emo-racr^ai OVK emAA. IIcSs aw rowro Aeyets;
C
212. "O/oa Kat crv KOivrj. & /XT) emaracrcu, yty^wcrKets 8e
ort OVK eTTtorao-at, TtXava, Ttepl ra rotaura; axnrep irepi
o^fov (TKevaa-ias olaOa brjitov ort OVK olarda;
AA. ITaz>u ye.
5
212. ETorepo^ ovv avros Trept ravra 8o^d{ets OTTCOS xp^
(TKeva^ety Kat TrAaya, 17 roi eTTtora/xez/a) eTTtrpe'Trets;
AA. OvYcos.
212. Tt 8' et ev yrjl: irAeot?, apa So^a^bt? af irorepov
Xpr] TOV olaKa etcro) ayetv ^ e^a>, at are OVK et8o)y TrAa^aio d
av, rj rai KV^eprr/rr; emrpe^as ay rjcrv^Lav ayois;
\32 Kal (aeJ) 6%t Schleiermacher
bs TOI^TOU] TOVTO Ast
b 9 e'^cb T : om. JB
C 2 Se STI T : Si JTI B
PLATO, VOL. II.

21

ii7 d

OAATilNOS

A A. Tw
212. QVK apa irepl & JAT) olffda ir\ava, avirep etSrjs on
5 OVK olcrOa;
AA. OVK &HKO.
212. 'Eyyoets o5z> on Kal ra ajotaprT/jaara ey TJ) Trpaei
Sta TavTV}v TT]V fryvoiav ecm, rr\v TOV jjj{ eiSora

10

AA. Ilws aS Aeyet? roCro;

SI2. Tore TTOU cin^ipov^v irparTfiv, orav
ort Trparro/xw;
AA. Nai.
212. "Orar 8e ye TTOV rires jtx^ otcoyrai eiSeVat,

AA. Hwy 8' ov;

212. Ov/coSy ot roiovroi T&V pr] eiSorooy d
5 S<rt 8ta TO aAAot? Trept airwy c-TnrpeTrety;
AA. Nat.
212. TtW? o?y ot afj.apTdvovTfs ; ov yap TTOV ot ye etSo'res.
AA. Ov 8?jra.
212. 'E7ra8rj ' ov0' ot etSo'res1 oU^' ot rcoz^ /u.^
Il8 etSores ort OVK Icrcunv, TI aXAot Aenroyrat ^ ot IM\
ol6fj,VOL b' eiSeVat;
AA. OVK, aAA' ovrot.
212. Avrij apa f) &yvoi,a T&V KCLK&V atrta /cat 77
ajj,aOia;
AA. Nat.
212. OvKoSr OTO.V fi irepl ra juteyto-ra, roVe KaKOUpyorarrj

10

AA. IIoAi; ye.

212. Tt ow; e)(fty fieta> etTrely StKatcoy re /cat
Kai ayad&v Kal
e i 5e 75 T : \c7 B
a 4 Kal seel. Schleiermacher

a 4, 5 al . . . a/*a(Ma seel. Hermann

^ seel. Buttmann

AAKIBIAAH2
A A. Ov brjra.
212. OVKOVV irepl TCLVTO, <rv (ftrjs

n8a

TtXavaarOai;

AA. Nai.
212. Ei be irXavq, ap ov bfjXov IK rG>v f^TTpoirdev on 15
ov JJLOVOV ayvoeis ra /neytcrra, dAAa /cat OVK etSws1 otei avra b
eieVai;

AA. Kivbvveva.
2H. Baj8ai apa, S 'AXKifiiabr], olov Trados
o eycb ovo^a^w fjv OKvG>, OJJLU>S 8e, eTrttb
prjreov. anadia yap (rvvoiKeis, S /Se'Ancrre, TT) fay^Tj], &>?
o Aoyos <rou Karryyopei Kat (TV craurou' 810 Kat arret? apa
irpbs ra TroAtrtKa Trpiy TtaibevOrjvaL.
TreTrovOas 8e ro{5ro
ow cru /uoVos, dAAa Km ot TroAAot ru>v TrparTovrcov ra r^o-8e
r^s TroAecos, TrA^r oAtycoz; ye Kat '(eras TOV crov eirtrpoTrou C
AA. Aeyerat ye rot, & SwKpares, OIK aTro row
<ro(f)bs ytyovtvai, dAAa TroAAors /cat cro^o'is crvy-yeyovevat,
L^r] Kal 'Ayaayopai Kat ruy ert rtjAtKoCros 5
crweo-rty avroS rovrou ereKa.
211. Tt oSy; ^817 rty' eT8ey crcxpbv OTLOVV abvvarovvra
irotr)(r(u aXXov crotybv cnrep avros; coo-Trep oy <re et8aez>
ypd^ara, avrds T r/v <ro(f)bs KCU (re eTrotgcre rcSi' re aAAcop
QVTIV e^o^Aero- ^ yap;
10
AA. Nat.
212. O^/cow Kat CTU o Trap' e/ceiz>ou (j,adu>v aXXov olos d
re |<rr/;
AA. Nat.
212. Kat 6 KiOapicrTrjs 8e xat 6 iratSorp 1/3779 <ao*at/ra)?;
b i ofoi T W : om. B
aura B : roCra T
b 4 ofov T Olympiodorus : 7ro?oi' B
b 5 u.6vu] abroi Cobet
b 6 eVxaTj? B
Olympiodorus : otVx^Tj; T
b 7 Kari\yopet B T : Karafj-aprvpe?
Olympiodorus
b8 ?rpbsBT: evl Olympiodorus
C i ye B
Olympiodorus: reT
03 TOI B Olympiodorus : om. T
c6 avrov
roiirov T : aurouTou B
07 IfSrj T : 8^ B
C 8 Hiffirep B : 'ocrirep T
e 10 gj/Ti>/' B : &i>ra T
c n ya( B t : om. T

n8d
5

IIAATilNOS
AA. Haw ye.
Sli. KaAoz> yap STJTTOU Te/c/u]pioi> TOVTO T>V
OTLOVV on ejriorazmu, eTreiSau /cal aAAoy otot r' axriy

AA. "E/x,oiye 8o/cet.

SO. Ti ovv; exei? ^^v Hepi/cA^s riva e770i?]crei> vofyov,
O.TTO T&V veutv dpfa/xcro?;
AA. Ti 8' ei rob HepiKXeoiiy ve? 7]A.i0uo tytvea-Qrjv, ai

Iig

Sli. 'AAAa KAetz/iay roi^ <rw afif\(j)6v.

AA. Tt 8' av a! KAeiznay Aeyots, /xat^ofie^oy av6pu>7tov;
211. 'ETretSr) roivvv KAetytas )uev ju-atverat, rco 8e Ileptvet i^At^tco eyeyetr^Tji', croc riya alriav avaOSt^v, 8t'
on o-e crurws zyjivTa Trepiopa;
AA. 'Eya> oTjaai atrtos ov Trpo(T\MV TOV vovv.
Sli. 'AAAa rwz; &AAa>i> 'Adrivaioov rj rS>v zvo)v 8oAoz;
17 eAeu^epov etTre oorts alrCav e^ei Sia rrjz;
(rvvov&iav cro^xuTepo? yeyoi'ei'at, uxnrep eyco e^co crot
8ta rr)y Zrjvavos TlvOobcapov TOV 'lo-oAo^ov /cat KaAAtW
roy KaAAtd8ou, wy eKarepos Z^rcoyt fKarbv jtxyas reAeVas
erodes re Kat eAAoyt/Ao?
AA. 'AAAa juta At' OVK
Sfi. E?ey ri oSy Starorj Trept <rai;ro{i; irorepov lay a>s
ySy e^et?, ^ eTTt/xeAeidi; rtra Troteicr^at;
AA. KOI^TJ /3ovA?7, S 2Kpares. Katrot eyyow <rov
etTToyro? /cat o-vy^copw- SoKowt yap juot ot ra riys TroAetos
irpa.TTovTS e/cro? oAtycoy a7rat8et)rot etfai.
2H. Etra rt 8r) TOVTO;
AA. Et p.ey TTOV ^crav 7reTrat8ei))u,e'yot, I8et ay TOV eTrtaurots avTatovi^ecrOai naOovTO. Kal
d. 6 TfKfi'hpiov TOVTO B : TOUTO TeK/j."fipiot> T Olympiodorus
e 4 &v
seel. Schleiermacher et mox \4yeis
e6 ^A.t6ia) BT: x/floj Olympiodorus
a 8 eSf B : / Olympiodorus : &i/ T
b t KOU^I
)8ouA^ Stephanus : KOIJ']) j8ouA.r) B T
b 5 &v rbv T . aurbi/ rbv B

AAKIBIAAH2
ievcu co? eir' dflArjras' vvv 8' eTretSr) /ca OVTOL iSicou/ccos
H)(OVTS kXf]\vdacnv em ra rr/s TroAecos, rt Set acrneiv Kal
fjiavOdvovra Trpayju.ara e^ety; eya> yap eS o?S' cm Toirrcoy
rr) ye t/>vcrei Trayu iroAv irepieVo/iat.
212. Ba^ai, otor, S apiore, roi)r' flprjKas' cos ai>aioy
r^s i8ea? Ka^ r<Sz> aAAcoy raiy crot VTrap^ovTcov.
AA. Tt jwaAt(rra /cat irpos rt roSro Aeyets, 2) 2wKpares;
212. 'AyayaKT<2 7;7re/) re <ro{; /cat ro{) e/xaurou epcoro?.

AA. Ti'5?7;
212. Et rj[(i)cras TOV ay&va (rot eTrat -Trpos1 roi>s
AA. 'AAAa TT/HJ? riVas
212. "A^iov TOVTO ye Kat fpzaOai avbpa ol6jj.evov

/xeya- d

AA. riw? Aeyei?; o-u ?rpos rotrrow juoi o

212. 'AAAa /cap ei rpirjpr] bievoov Kvj3epvav
fjilXXovcrav
vavfjta^elv, r^p/cet ay aoi T>V crvvvavT&v /SeAriorw elyat ra 5
/cu/3epyrjrt/ca, 17 raSra juev cooii ay 8ety inrdp^fLv, aTre/3Ae7re?
8' ay et? roi)s uts ahr)6>s avTa-yutviards, aAA' ov^ ws y{5y et?
roi>s (rvvaywviaTds; coy STJTTOU Tre/otyeyecr^at ere Set rocroCroy
wore JUT) a^touy dyraycoyt^e(r^at, dAAa Karac/ipoyjj^e'yras crty- e
aycoyi(fecr^at crot Trpos TOT)S TroAe/jitous, et Sr) roi oyrt ye KaXov rt
epyoy airobfi^acrOat 6tayof} /cat a^iov (ravrovre Kalr'rjs Tro'Aecos.
A A. 'AAAa juey 8^ biavoov^ai ye.
212. ndyir (rot apa aftoy dyaTray et rwy crrpartcorcoy 5
/3eArtcoy e?, aAA' ov Trpos rovs rcoy dyrtTraAcoy r}yejuo'ya?
a7ro/3Aeirety elf Trore e/cetya>y /SeArtcoy yeyoyas,
Kat dcTKouyra TT/SOS e
05 re B T : om. Olympiodorus
o-oS Olympiodorus : roi; troO
BT
6/uavroO B Olympiodorus : eyuoD T
d 4 aAAce T : Spa B
i
d. 7 8' &P B : Se T
e i o toC^ a.vra. y<avit<r6a.i B : <Tvj/afray(avi(f(r6ai
T: ffvvaytavi^fffdai W (OI/T S v. w")
65 <roi Spa B : &pa voi T
Olympiodorus
67 elf vore scripsi : 67r<}T B T: oV?; re Heindorf
(qua ratione Ficinus) : ri irore Ast
yejoyas B T : -yeVoio Heindorf
Stailbaum cum Ven. 184

laoa

IIAATONOS

I2O

AA. Ae'yets 8e Tivas TOVTOVS,

SO. OVK ol<rOa fjiJi&v Trjv -Tro'Aiy AaKeSaijUoyfots re Kal
r<2 jueyaAw /Sao-iAe? TroAe/xowaj; eKacrrore;
AA. 'AA.7707/ Aeyet?.
5
SO. OVKOW eurep ey i><3 e^ei? ?jyejuaw etVat T?jcre r?js
Trpo? rovs AajceSat/xortcoy fiacnXeas KOL rovs
roy dyaiya ^yotJ/xeyo? crot eu>at dp^ws ay fjyoio;
AA. Kiz>8we7;eis a\.r]6rj Aeyeiy.
SO. OVK, a>ya0e, dAAa irpos MetStay ere 8e roy opruyob KOTTOV a7ro/3Ae7rew> Kat aAAou? rotowrous ot ra r?)? Tro'Aeco?
In rrjy dr8paTro8co8rj, <paiV av
e^oyres ly r^ ^wx/? ^ a/Jiovcrtas Kat
5 KoAaKfvo-ovres r?)y 'TroAiy dAA' O^K apovTes Trpo? rourou? <re Set, ovcrirep Aeyco, ^AeVoyra (ravrou 8r)
Kat j^Tjre pavOaveiv ocra jua0?](rea)? e^erat, fieAAorra
TOV dywra ayu>vi(f(r6a,i, prJTe dfTKetv ocra 8e</rai
C Kat Tracray TrapacrKeu^i' irape<r Kevaa^vov ovrcoy te^at eTrt
ra 7775 TroAeto?.
AA. 'AAA', S> ScoKparey, doKet1? //,ey //,ot aX.r)6f) Ae'yet^,
ot/^at jueiTot row? re AaKeSatp-oytcoy crrpar^yoi)? Kat roz>
5 rTepcrwy jSacrtAea owSez; 8ia(pe'peiz> r<3y aAAcoy.
SO. 'AAA', a> aptore, T^y otrjcnv ravTrjv crKOTrei
AA. Tou
SO. ITpSroi' p,ey irorepcos az> o?et crauroi; ju,aAAoy e-jnL, </>0|8ov)ixez;os re Kat olo^vos bewovs avrovs
etvai, TI jj-ri;
a 6 Tr^Aews B : ir({Aews ois T
/cal roiisl al
ag oprvyoKdiroit Olympiodorus Athenaeus scholiastes :
BT
b 2 eTj T Olympiodorus : ETT! B
b 3 ev
dorus : &rl T
b 5 KoKaKtvaovres T : Ko\a.Kevoi>Tes B
Madvig : Se B T : om. al.
C i irapfffKeva.ffiJ.fvov
(ricevaardfjievov T Olympiodorus : irapaffKevaff/j.evoy
W
rwv B
09 TTOTtptas B Olympiodorus : Wrepos T

riy Cobet
6pTiryorp6tf>ov
B Olympiob 6 8^
B : wapa0 4 T^P T :

AAKIBIAAHS

wod

AA. A?/Aoz> on el beivovs oiotjurjz>.

212. M<3i; ovv otet rt /3Aa/3?7(recr0ai e7ri/xeA?]0ets cravrov;
AA. Ou8a/x<Ss, dAA.a xai /xeyaAa ovr)(Tcr&ai.
5
KO.KOV
AA. 'Mrj0rj Ae'yets.
212. To bevTfpov TOIVVV, OTI Kal
<rK\f/ai.
A A. Hws 877;
212. riorepof etKos a^fivovs yiyvtaQai 0i;(rets ey yeyyevwiv r) p.ri;
AA. A^Aoi> OTI ev rot? yewaioi?.
212. OVKOW TOVS fv (fivvras, kav fcai eS TpafyGxnv, O{TCO
yiyvzcrOai irpbs aperriv;
AA. 'A^dyK?;.
212. 2,K\l/ti>iJ.0a 877, TOIS fKeivav ra j/jueYepa avruriTrp&Tov ^\v el SOKOVCTI, (fravXoTeputv yevS>v eTvat ol
A.a.K?)aiiJ,ovL(t)v KCU Tltpcr&v /SacrtA^s1. r? O^K Icrpev ws ot juez>
?, 01 8e 'A^at/xeyous eKyorot, ro 8' 'HpaKAeous re
/ca6 TO 'A^atjixerot;s eis ETepo-ea rw Atoy aya^eperai;
AA. Kcu yap ro rj^r^pov, a> 2wKpares, ei? EvpucraKrj,
ro S' Evpt)(raKous eis Aia.
212. Kal yap ro ^/xerepor, yeyyate 'AAKiy8ia8ij, (is
AaiSaAoi;, 6 8e AaioaAos eis "H^atcrroy TOV Atos. dAAa
ra jixey rovrcoy air' avr&v apdp,eva /3a(rtA^s eto-w IK )8acriXftov /^e'xpi Aioy, 01 fiey "Apyovs re Kat AaKe8atjuoi/os,
ot 8e rr/s IlepcrtSos ro dei, TroAAd/cty 8e Kat rfjs 'Acria?,
(oo*7rep Kat z>w- ^jae?s 8e avroC re i8i<3rai Kat ot Trarepes.
ei 8e Kai rovs npoyovovs <re 8eot Kat r^y irarptSa EvpucraKOV? eTTtdet^at 2aAa/xtra 17 r?)j; AtaxoS rou en Trporepou
ds eZ B : /cal ei T
d 12 -yfyj/eo-flat BT : yeveffBai Olympiodorus
63 rpa<t>&ffii> T : -ypdQcaffiv B
64 aper^v (a.vd.yK'ri) Cobet
e g ol
5e . . . eio -yei/os at Tb (in marg.) : om. pr. B
b i <re T:
om. B

jo
121

iaib
Alyivav 'Aproepr7 r&> Se'pfou, TroVoy az> oei yeAcora
o^Xetv; dAA' opa /x?j row re yevovs oy/cw eAarra>jue<9a rwv
5 avbp&v Kal rij dAAry rpoc^Tj. rf OVK ^crQ^crai rols re AaKebai}jiovLU>v /3acnAei!o-ti> a>? jueydAa ra virap-^ovra, u>v at
z (pvX&TTOVTai virb T>V tffropcw, OTTCO? ei's
aAXou yei^o^eyos 6 (3acn\evs rj e
C 'Hpa/cAetSeoy; o 8e nepo-wy rocroSroy WTrepySaAAet, cocrr'
iro\l/[av <l\i, ws e^ aAAou af (3a(riA.vs yevoiro rj e
8to ov (ftpovpetTai, fj yQacrtAecos yw^ dAA' ^ WTTO
<^)0y8ov. eTretSay 5e yeyrjrai 6 Tims 6 Trpetr/Swraro?, ovirep
5 ?? opx7/' TTp&Tov IACV eoprdbu(ri Travres ol ey rr/ /SacrtAecoy,
yeveQ\ia Tiacra 0vei Kal eoprd^et ^ 'Acrta*
d. 8e yvofj.evtov, TO TOV KCo/iwSoTrotou, ovS' ot yetroyes cr<opa
rt alcrOavovTai, w 'AAKt)3td8r7. juera roCro rpe^erat 6
VTTO ywai/cos rpcxpov dAtyou aias, dAA' ^TT'
ot &z> 8o/cw(Tti' r<S^ Trept /SacrtAea
5 oly rd re dAAa Trpoo-rera/crat eTTi/xeAeo-^at roiS
Kat OTTCO? ort KaAAtcrroj eVrai [j,r]\^avacr6ai, avairXarrovTas
ra /AeArj row iratSo? /cat KaropOovvras- Kal raCra bp&vres
6 ey //.eydArj n//,T/ eto-;. eTretSaz; 8e e-Trrerets yeVcorrai ot
, eTTt rov? iVrroi)? Kat em rov? TOVTCOV StSao-KaAoi)?
, K.ai ITTL ra? Or/pas dp^ovrat te^ai. 8ts eTrra 8e
yi>6jJLVOV T>V TOV TTcfiba Trapa\afji,(3dvov<rtv oiis
5 /Sao-tAetous muSaycoyoi/S1 oyo/id^bucriy etcri 8e
ot apt<rroi boavTs V ^AiKta rerrape?, o re croKai 6 StKatoraros Kat 6 o-co^poyecrraros Kat 6
122 dySpetoraros. c5y 6 /x.ei' /xayetay re 8t6do"Ket r^y Zcopob 3 o/rro|e'p!?7 re vera B T
&> B T : S^ Stobaeus
b 4 roi)
B T : T roC Stobaeus
C 2 &/ fia<ri\ebs B Stobaeus : f3a<n\evs tiv
T
03 aAA' ^} d\X^ B : $ T (suprascr. dAA.')
C 7 yeveOXia
T Olympiodorus : -yeyeVia B
iraera T : an-ao-a B
al eoprdfa
seel. Cobet
da TI T : om. B
d 5 ra re #AAa T : raAAa B
d 6 gn T : om. B
e i irreTe?s (sic) B : eire'reis (sic) T
6 4 yev6fifvov Buttmann : yevo/j-evcav B T

AAKIBIAAH2
darpov TOV e.Qpo/xa<*bi>e<rri 8e TOVTO de&v O
8t8aVKei 8e Kat ra /3a<rtAtKa, 6 Se SiKatoraros
8ta Tra^ros TO{) /3ioi>, o 8e o-ax^poyeVraros ixrjb' virb jutas
apx^ea-dai r&v f]8ov)v, tva eXevOepos eii>ai efltC^jrai Kat
ovra>s fiacnXevs, ap\^>v Trp&rov T&V ev avrG> aXXa JUT)
bov\va)v, 6 8e avftpeioTaTos acpoflov KOI dSea
fy>v, w 9 orav beiay bov\ov ovro." aol 8', a>
ITeptxA.^? e-jrecTTTja-e TratSaycoyof r<3z> oiKerwj; roy a^peioTO.TOV virb yTjpa)?, ZtoTtvpov TOV QpqKa. ^LijXdov 8e Kat
r?)y aAAijv ay <rot rcav aiTaycoytcrrcSz; Tpo(p^v re Kat Trat8etay, et ^ TroAv Hpyov TJV KOL a/xa ra{5^' tKara Sr/Awcrat
KOI raAAa ocra rovrots aKoXovOa- rrjs 8e o-^s yereo-ecos,
cb 'AAKi/3ta8r/, Kat Tpotyrjs Kat TratSaas, T/ aAAof orovow
'A0r)vaia>v, ws eTros dntiv ovbevl /^eAet, ei /x,^ e<^ rts
crou rt;y)(ayet wv. et 8' aS e^e'Aets ets TrAotJroDs
e^at m Tpvtyas KCU ecrOijras l^arid^v 0' e'A^ets Kat
fj.vpa>v dAoi^as Kat BepcmovTatv 7r\rj6ovs d.KoA.ov0ias TT\V
re aXXrjv a/SpoTrjra rf]v Ylepcr&v, al<rxvv0ir]s av fm creavrw,
alcrdofjievos o<rov amStv eAAetirets. ct 8' aS f6f\^(reis f l s
cra(ppoa"vvr]v re Kat KoayxtoY^ra a7ro/3Ae'i^at Kat ev^fpetay
Kat fVKoXiav Kat fj,eyaA.o(ppo<rvvriv Kat evra^Cav KOI avbpeiav
Kat KapTfpCav Kat (piXovoviav Kat (piXoviKiav KCU ^)tAori/zias
ray AaKebcunovioov, mud' ay ^y?j(rato cravrbv Tracrt, rols
TOIOVTOIS.
et 6' au rt Kat TrAovra> Trpoo-e^ets Kat Kara
rouro o^et rt etz^at, ^Se rou^' ^jutz' apprjrov eVra), eay TTCOS
a'ia-dp ov eT. rowro )uey ya/o et e$eAet? (ets) rois AaKeTrXovrovs Ibe'iv, yv(&(rrj ort TroAi) rdzj0aSe rwy
eAAetTref y^ /xez> yap ocrijy ^OVCTLV rijs 0" eaur<3z>
Kat Mecro-r/yrj?, 0^8* Sy ets afj.(picr/3r]T-^(TfL
T>V rr/8e TrA^et
a 7 Trapoo'Keua^wi'] irapacntfvd&i Schleiermacher
Ib 7 ^teAet B :
/j.e\\ei T
b 8 e'0eAs T Olympiodorus : e6e\ois B
04 aiaOo/j.ei'os T W : aia-dav6ju.fi>os B
<=0eAr;creis B T : f0e\^<reias Olympiodorus : e6f\is Heindorf
ds et's add. Schneider
ds YTJ^
T Olympiodorus : T^ B : ^Tjr ci. Stallbaum

II A AT JIN O2

122 d

ov6' dperr), ovS' av avbpair6b<av Krrycret r&v re aAAcoz> <ai

T&V eiAcortK<3i>, ovSe JUTJU iTTTrcoy ye, ov8' o<ra aAAa /Sooveije /uara Kara MecroT^ijy yejuerai.

dAAa raCra /xez> Trazra e<3

, \pV(TLOv be Kat apyvpiov

OVK eVrti> fv itacnv "EA.-

o(rov fv AcueSaijiAozn i8t'a' TroAXa? yap ^77 yeveas

fj,ev

avroare e^ cnravToov rS>v

5 Axms 8e feat eK ry

fiapfidputv,

123 dAA' dre^(i'3s Kara roy Ai<r(07rou pvOov ov f/ d

TOV Aeoyra eiTret1, KOI rou ets AaKeSatjuora
IOVTOS jaez> ra ix^^ ^a eKeio-e rerpa/^iei>a 8?/Aa,
8e ovbany av ris t8oi.

a>crre ev xj*7 ftSeVat ort K

5 Kat ap~/vpu> ol fKel ir\ovcrK&TaroC dcriv T&V '

KLvu>v 6 ^SacrtAevs' e/c re yap rwi' TOIO\>TU>V /weytcrrat
s Kai TrAeiarai eio-t rots f3aan.Xev(riv,

en

8e Kat 6

/3acriAiKo? (popos OVK dAtyos ytyyerat, 6y reAoucrty ot Aaxeb Satjoto'ytot ro?? /Sao'tAeSo'ty.

Kat ra jaey AaKeSat/Aovtcoy a>s

Trpos 'EAArjytKoi/y juiey TrAowrou? fieyaAa, <ws 8e Trpo? rovs

Ilepo-tKoi/s Kat roS eKetVcoy

^Sao-tAeco? ovbtv.

eTret

Tror'

eya) 7/KOfa-a avbpbs d^tOTricrrou r<2y dya^e/SrjKorcoi; Trapa

5 (SacriXla, bs ffprj
fyyvs

TTapeXOtlv x.wpay irayu TroAA^y Kat aya6r\v,

r)^ep-r](riav

obov, rjv KaAetv rov? tTrLyaptovs

(avr]v

rrjs jSacrtAeco? yurat/cos- eTrat 8e Kat aAArjy r/i' av KaAeur0at

c K.aXvTtTpav,

Kat aAAous 7roAAoi)s roTrous KaAoi)? Kai dya^oi/s

ets rov KoVjuoy f^rjprnjievovs

TOV rrjs yvvaLKos, Kat oyo/nara

eKatrrous rwi' TOTTMV airb eKao-rou rwy KOCTJUCOI'.

eyw, et rts

e?7rot rrj

jSao-tAeco? /xrjrpi,

COOT'

Hep^ou 8e

5 yvvaiKt, 'A//,?jcrrpi8i, ort er rai ex

reo-0at o Aeivo)u,dx.^s vos, ^ eVrt Kocr/ioy Tcrcos a^tos
et Trdyv TroAAou, rw 8' ver avr^s yr^s Tr
e 3 iroAActs . . . 76^6^1 T : TroAAows . . . yeyeais B
64 auTotre B ;
ouris T : auTois Olympiodorus
a i Sv . . . a 2 eTirej/ seel. Schanz
8.3 rii fKeiffe rfrpafi/^eva seel. Hirschig
rfrpa/j./j.eva T : ycypa./j./j.eva
B
a 6 OUTWC] aS Schanz
re -yap TWJ/ T : re 7&p wr pr. B :
v D
05 e^et <rou T: e^fts ou B

AAKIBIAAH2
ot>5e rptaKoVta, Oavudcrat, av or<a irore
fv y<3 e)(ei o^ros1 6 'A\Kiflia$ris r<3 'Apro^ep^ Staycozn<feo-$at, KOI ot/xat ay avn)y etTrety on ot>K ecr$' oro> aAAw
TTjcrrewcoy ovro? ay?)p eTU^ei/ae? -nXrjv eTTi/AeAeta re Kat
<ro<piq- Tama yap /xoya ata Aoyov ey "EAA^ort^. e-Tret et
ye TrvdotTo OTI ^AXKiftidbrjs OVTOS vvv e77t)(ei/)er TrpStTov
juei' er?] ovbtTTM yeyoyws a-Qobpa flKocnv, eTreira TravrdTtacriv airaibevTos, irpos 8e TOVTOIS, TOV epacrTov avrw
Xeyovros OTI xprj TTp&rov fj-adovra /cat fTn^eX-rjG^vra avrov
/cat ao"Kr;crayra oiVcos te^at biaydoviovnevov (Baa'iXe'i, OVK.
e#eAei, dAAa <^r/criy f^apKelv KOL a>s e^ftj oijotat
6avp,a(T(u re Km epeV^ai* " Ti ot!y TTOT' ecrrtz^ 6V(p
ro /ueipaKtoi';" et ovi' Aeyoijuez* on /caAAet re Kat /*eye0ei
/cat yez/et Kat irAovrw Kat (pvcrei. rrjs \lfvxfis> ^y?7cratT' az>
77/x,a?, S 'AXKij3ia.br), fj,aiv(rdai Trpos ra Trapa cr^Lcnv aTro(3X\j/a(ra Trdvra ra rotaSra. ot/xat 8^ Kaz^ Aa/X7rt8co, T^V
/u,ey Ovyarepa, ^Apx^d/jiov 8e ywauca, "Ayt8os
o't Traz^re? /3acriA^? yeyovacriv, 6avfJLd<raL av KOL
ravrrjv ets ra Trapa o-(j)[<riv VTtap\ovTa aTro^SAe^acraz', et o"u
e^ iw e^fts rw vet avrrjs Staycort^o-^at ovrco /caKW? ^y/xezjos.
Katrot OUK alcrxpov 8oKet et^at, et at r<3i' 7roAe/i/,wwy ywatKes
6'iai'oowrat, ot'ovs XP^ ovras or<J)((riv
^f/3^ ^wy OVT&V; aAA', a) /xaKapte,
6juot re Kat TW ez^ AeA^KHS -ypa^aTi, yv&Oi
(ravrov, OTI OVTOL TJ/JLLV elariv az^rtTraAot, aAA' 01% O'&s o-v
otet- <5y ^AAa> /xer 0^8' ay ei> Treptyeyotjue^a, et /x,?7 Trep
tTTijueAetia ye ay Kat re^yry. <5y crt; et
a/noXi(pdria"r])
Kat row oyo/xacrros yfvz<r9ai aTroAet^^r/o'T/ ey
d i OUTOS B : o8ras T
d 3 * dj/^p B : d di/'J/p T
d. 5 a\Ki/3ta.8i)s
T: <5 a\K^idSt]s B
es aurV B : om. T
es 7n<TTei;i recc. :
TTiiTTevoi B T
a i AecoTVX'Soi; T : S' eiiruxiSou pr. B : AeuTux/Sou b
a 5 eli/at et ew T Olympiodorus : e?^at B
a 6 irepl ^Juoii' SiwooSvrat
B : Siavoovvrai irepl r]/j,wv T
b i TJ/LUV T Olympiodorus : om. B
11
b 2 et Se" Trep B : ei ^ T
b 3 ye &v scripsi : re &/ B T : re Schanz
lb 4 owjttoirrbs T Olympiodorus : bv^aros B

i*3C
d

124

IIAAT12N02

5 re /cat /3ap/3cpot?, ov \JLOL bonds epay us ovbels aAAos

o;AAov.
AA. TLVCL ovv xpr) rrjv emp-eAetazJ, > 2co/cpares, irottr)yricra<r0ai; iravrbs yap /xaAAoy eoiKas
10
212. Nat- aAAa yap /coiz^r) /3ou\?) wrt^i rpoVo) ar on
C ySeArtorot yevoiptOa. eya) yap rot ov Trept /xei; o-ou Aeyco ws
Xfnj iraibevOrjvai, Trepl e/aoi! 8e ov' ov yap eo-^' 6V(p crov
8ta0epco irA^y y' eyt.
AA. TCvi;
5

212.

'O (TTLTpOTTOS

6 6/XOS jSeArtCOy eOTt Kttl

(rO(f)(dTpOS

rj IlejOtKA^s 6 cro?.
AA. Tis ovro?, S 2w/cpares;
212. @eo?, S 'AAKt/3ta8i7, ocnrep croi )ue OVK eta irpo
r^(re r^y ^//.epas SiaAex^^at- a> Kat Trtcrrevcoy Aeyco ort rj
10 m<pdvia 8t' ov8ez/oy aAAou trot eVrat T) 8t'
A
AyV. Ilai^ets, w SwKpares.
212. "Icra)?' Aeya) fj.vroi a\rjdi], ort eTTt/u
ju,ey Travre? avdpaTroi, drap yco ye Kat /xdAa cr^oSpa.
AA. "On //.e^ eyw, ov ^fevbrj.
212. 08e /xr)y ort ye eyco.
AA. Tt ovy CLV TTOLOLIJLV;
212. OVK dTropprjreoy o^8e /xaA^aKtcrre'oy, w eraipe.
AA. OiJroi 8^ TrpeTret y', S 2<o/cpares>.
212. Ov yap, aAAa or/ceTrreoy Kowi\. /cat p;ot Ae'yeyap 8^ ws aptcrrot flovXtcrdai, yevtffdai. tf yap;
AA. Nat.
212. Tti'a dperrjy;
AA. Af/Aoi> ort yvirep ol ai>8pe? ot ayaOoi.
b 10 KOJ^ jSowX^ Stephanus : Kotvf) /SouATj BT
c6 d <ros BT :
6 0is 0?os Proclus
d 5 e'yw B : ty& Seo/uat T (sed Seoficu extra
versum)
d6 &j/ Troior/ue' BT : TroieS/iei/ Cobet : Sij iroi<ofj.ev Schanz
d 7 a.Troppi]Teov corr. Ven. 184 ; airopriTeov T W Olympiodorus : OTTOB et in marg. W
/jia\daKiffreov T Olympiodorus : ftaAaB
e i 5)j B Olympiodorus : om. T
a>s T Olympiodorus :

AAKIBIAAH2

1246

212.
AA.
212.
AA.
212.
AA.
212.
AA.
212.
AA.
212.
A A.
212.

Oi TI ayaOoC;
AijXov on ol irpdrrfiv ra TrpdyfAara.
Ilcua; apa ra iTnriKa;
Oi bijra.
Ylapa TOVS ITTTUKOVS yap av r\[*.ev;
Nat.
'AAAa ra vavTiKa Aeyets;
OD.
Hapa TOVS VCIVTLKOVS yap av p^ev;
Nai'.
'AAXa Trota; a rives TrpaTrovcriv;
"Airep 'A6r]vaiu>v ol KaXol KayaQoi.
KaXovs 8e /cdya^ows A.eyets roi/? (ppovfaovs

AA.
212.
AA.
212.

Tovs
OVKOW o cKaoros typoviiio.?, roi;r' ayaOos;
Nai.
A
O 8e a(pp(ov, Trovrjpos;

10

15
y TOVS 125

AA. 11(3? yap ov;

212.

'Ap' oSy 6

CTKVTOTOfJLOS

(ppOVl^OS

(Is

epyacriav;
AA. nd^w ye.
212. 'Aya0os ap' els avra;
AA. 'Aya^o's.
212. Ti S'; eis tp,aria)r epyacriav OVK a^pcoy 6 O~KVAA.
212.
AA.
212.
ay ados.
AA.

Nai.
Ka/cos apa ets rouro;
Nai.
*O avTos apa rovrw ye TW Xoyw KCKOS re
4>aiyerat.

e 6 of T Olympiodorus : oloi B

15
b

KOI
5

a n avrd B : ravra T

10

JIAAT12N02
212.
AA.
212.
AA.
212.
AA.

*H ovv Aeyets rows ayaOovs avbpas clvat nai KO,KQVS;

Ov brjra.
'AAAa rtvas TTOTC TOVS ayaOovs Ae'yets;
Tovs bwajjievovs eycoye ap^iv ev Trj TTO\L.
Ov 8777701; iTTTrwy ye;
Ov 8^ra.

21i. 'AAA' avOp(f>7ra>v;

AA. Nai'.
15

10

AA. Oi;.
2H. 'AAXa ir\ovTO)v;
AA. Ov (^/AI.
2i2. 'AAAa depi^ovrav;
AA. Ov.
211. 'AAA' ovSey Trotowrooy 77 rt TTOIOVVT&V;
AA. ITotorWaw Aeyco.
212. Tt; TretpcS KCU eju,ot 8rjA5(rat.
AA. OvKoOy T>V Koi (TVuflaXkovTutv eaurots /cat X/)ft)~
dAATyAots, cocrirep Tret's ^iSjuey ey ra^s iroAecrii'.
212. OVKOVV av6p(aTTMV Aeyets apyeiv avOpuirois
AA.
212.
AA.
212.

Nat'.
'Apa KeAeuo-rwv ~)^pu>fjiev(av eperats;
OTJ 8r]ra.
Kv(3pvr]TLK.ri yap avTrj ye aperry;

AA. Nat'.
212. 'AAA' avdp(j)ira>v Aeyets apyjeiv av\r]TG>v, a
d fjyovjjievdw w^s xat ^pa>fj.fV(ov xPfVTC^s>
AA. Ov 8r]ra.
212. XopoStSao-KaAtKi) yap aur?] y' av;
AA. ndznj ye.
b 6 ^ B T : T? Olympiodorus
Xe'yejs B T : KO.\OIS Olympiodorus
C 4 TWI/ Kal B T : /cal TeSy Olympiodorus
C 1 1 KvftfpvijTiKi) B :
tris T

AAKIBIAAH2
212.

iasd

'AAAa rt Trore Aeyets x/oco/xeVcoy av6p(aTra>v avOpca- 5

AA. Koircoz/owrcoy eycoye Ae'yco TToAiretas /cat

flaXXovTuv
TT/OOS aA.AijA.ou?, TOVTOOV apyjetv T&V v rrj
TroAei.
212. Tts ow a$r?7 ^ reyvT); uxrirep av ei <re
TraAiy ra ^1)^877, K.QIVU>VOVVTU>V yavrtAtas firia-Taadai
TLS Troi
AA.
2H. KoLV(tivovvT(av 8' wS^J, <? yw8r) eAeyero, rts eTrt- e
Troie? apy^iv;
AA. "Hrirep <ri; aprt eAeyes, 77 j(opo8i8acrKaAta.
2ii. Tt" 8e; TroAtretas K.OWU>VOVVTU>V riva
AA. EvySouAt'az; eycoye, 2
211. Ti 8e; juwy d/3oi;Aia 8o/cei eT^at 57
A A. Ow 8^ra.
212. 'AAA' ev(3ov\ia;
AA. "Ejuotye SoKe?, e?s ye ro (r<p^eo-0at TrXeovras.
126
212. KaAws Aeye6s. rt 8e; 77^ <rv Aeyets
ets rt <TTCV;
A A. Ei? ro afjifivov Trjv TTQ\IV o"totKeu> Kat ato
212. "A/j.eivov 8e Stotxetrat Kat trw^erat rtVos Trapa- 5
ytyyo/xevou r^ a-noyiyvo^vov ; &a-JTp av et av /xe epoio'
""A^ivov StotKetrat crai/xa Kat a-^eratTLVOS Ttapaytyvo^vov
rj aTToyiyvofjifvov; " e^Trotju,' Sv ort vyteias fx,h> -napayiyvofj,evr]S, vocrov 8e o.fnoyiyvo[t,ivt](s.
ov Kat <ri otet ovroos;
AA. Nai.
b
212. Kat et //,' aS epoto- " TtVo? 6e
TrapayiyvofjLfvov
a[jiivov OjW/xara;" axravrco? etiroifj? av on o\j/ea>s p.V Trapas, ru^Aorr/ros Se aTroytyyo/xevTjy.
/cat wra 8e
e 2 irate? B : TrotetV T
a 7 Siottce'irai . . . (r^ferat B : SioiKe'iffOat
. . . cr(feff6cu T
crca^ara T : craijua B
b 2 irapayiyvo/j.fvov B :
om. TW

I26b

IIAAT12NO2

5 KoxpoTrjros /u,ey aTroyiyvG[ji.vr]s, ctKofjs Se

jSeAruo re ytyuerat /cat aptivov depaireveTai..
AA. 'Op0<3s.
212. Tt 8e 8??; Tro'Ats rti>os TrapaytyyojueVou Kal CLTTOyiypo/AeVou /3eArticoy re yiyverai /cat apetvov 0epa7reuerat
10 KCU 8toi/ce?Tai;
C
AA. 'Ejuot j^ei' So/cei, d> Sco/cpares, oray
avrot? yiyvTt]Tai Trpbs aXXrjkovs, TO /xto-e^ 8e Kat
aTToytyi'i/rat.
2Ii. 9Ap' ovi; (f)ih.iav Aeyet? ojj-ovoiav r] bi^ov
5
AA. 'Ojjiovoiav.
2H. Ata rtV ovz> Tf^yr]v opovoovcriv al TroAet?
AA. Aia r^
211. Tt 8e ot t8twrat; ov bia rrjv
10
AA. Nat.
212. OVKOVV Kal euros
AA. Nat'.
212. Aia rtz/a 8e rtyvrjv HKCLOTOS avrbs avT& 6fj,ovofi
d Trept 0-mdaiJ.rjs /cat TTTJX^OS oTrorepov n&Cov; ov 8ia r^y
AA.
212. OVKOW /cat ot tStwrat dAA^Aois Kat ai
5
AA. Nat.
212. Tt 8e; Trtpl (rraQ^ov ov-% &<ravT(as;
AA. $?]]at.
212. *Hy 8e 8^ <ri Aeyets 6fj.6voi.av, TLS eort /cat
TOV, Kat rts awrjv re^yr] 7rapacr/eeuaei; /cat apa ^Vtp noAet,
10 avrrf /cat tStwrr/, avr&i re irpos amov Kat Trpos aAAov;
C 2 ri fiiarelv Se B : rJ 8e fuffeiv re T
013 e/cafrros oiiriis aurip
B : owrbr auT^5 e'/fa<rTosT : aurbs icwrip Olympiodorus
d.6 trra^oS
T :ffra.9jj.ovsB
d 9 auT^y T Olympiodorus : o5 T^J/ B
rex^i?
Olympiodorus al. : rex^v B T
7/Trep (vel ^Trep) ir^Aei T Olympiodorus : et irepHroAet B : eiVep WA.et W
d 10 wrfy ci. Bekker : aurrj
B : aurf? T Olympiodorus : a.Zrt\ vulg.

AAKIBIAAH2

i26d

AA. EIKO'S ye rot.

212. Tis ovv eVrt; /AT) /ca/xrjs cnroKpivo/jifvos,
dAAa
oOvfjiGv elirelv.
e
AA. 'Eya> /xez/ OI)A<U <ptkiav re Aeyeiy /cat ofjiovoiav,
itarrip re voz> <pi\G>v opovoel KCU p.rjrr]p, KCU a8e\(pos
> teal yvvri avftpL
2fi. Otec ^v oSy, 'AXKifiuiSr], avfipa -yvvaud Trept 5
raA.acriovpyi'a? bvvaarflai ofjiovoelv, TOV /xr) eTnara^vov rrj

AA. O
212. O^8e ye 8ei ovbtv yvvaiKflov yap TOVTO ye j^d
AA. Nat.
212. Tt 8e; ywr) dy8pi Trept oTrAtrtK?]? 8watr' a^
opovoclv JU,T) jj-aOovcra;
AA. Ov 8r]ra.
212. 'AvSpeioy yap roCro ye taws av <pair]s av flvai.
AA. "Eywye.
212. "Ecrrtz^ apa ra /xez; yvva.iK.eia, ra 8e ay8pe?a [J.adr]juara Kara ror <roy Aoyor.
AA. nj 8' ov;
212. O^K apa IV ye rovrots eortv 6/xoVota ywai$ Trpos
SySpas.
AA. O.
212. O^8' apa ^>tAia, efeep 17 <j)i\ia opovoia r\v.
AA. O (pafofTCLi.
212. T Ht apa ai yuyat/ces ra OVT&V TrparTovcriv, ov
(ftiXovirrai VTtb T&V avbp&v.
AA. OVK eotKey.
212. Ov8' apa ot aVSpes wo r<Sv yvvaiK&v p ra
avrwy.

AA. CM;.

e 2 re] fff ci. Stallbaum : re {exeiv} Schanz : fort, ye

Olympiodorus : om. T
PLATO, VOL. n.

eg ;ye B
22

10
127

10

15
b

HAATONOS
5

10
C

10
d

212. Ov8' ev apa ravrri otKowrat at TroAets, orai> ra

OVT&V e/caoToi irpdrTtixnv;
A A. Oijuat eycoye, a> 2&>Kpares
212. n<3s Aeyw, faXias /XT/ irapovart]?, rjs e<pafiev eyyiyvo^vr]s ev otaeio-0at ras -TroAa?, #AAa>s ' ow;
AA. 'AXX& /xot SoKe^ /cat Kara TOUT' avrots </>tAta
eyytyyeo-^at, ort ra O.VT&V eKfirepot Trpdrrova-iv.
Sli. OVK aprt ye- vw 8e ircSs au Xeyets; 6fj.ovoCas /AT)
eyytyyo/xeyTj? </)tA.ta eyyty^erat; T; oto'i; ^' opovotav eyytyv(rdai [n^pl TOVTMV] c5v ot /xe^ i(ra<n irepi rovrcoi', ot 8' o#;
AA. 'ASwaror.
2fi. At/cata 8e TrpdrrovcrLV r) abma, orav ra CLVT&V
e/cacrrot irpaTTuxriv;
AA. At/caia- TTW? yap ow;
2H. Ta biKaia ovv irparroyrcoy !z> rfj -7roA.ei rwz; TroAtrSy
</uA.ta OVK eyyiyrerat irpos dAAT/Aous;
AA. 'AzjayKTj av juot 8o/ce ewat, w 2w/cpares.
212. Ttva ovy irore Xeyets rT)y (piXiav rj o^ovoiav Trept
T]? Sei1 T/jutas (T0<f)ovs re etvai Kat ev/3ovA.ovs, fya dya^ot
juer; OTJ yap Svrajuat padflv ovO' r/'rt? ot;r' er
rore /xfy yap ey TCH? a^ror? (paiveraL kvovva, rore
8' ou, ws e/c roS (rou Ao'yov.
AA. 'AAAa jtta rows 0eovs, a SwKpare?, 0^8' avros ot8'
ort Aeyco, Kivbvvevto 8e Kat iraAai AeATj^eyat efj-avrbv
212. 'AAAa xp>7 Oappelv. et /ixev ya/a avro ^
aeT^s, x.a^f7rv &v ^lv <rot TrifJ,
8' 771; ^Xets ^AtKiay, avrT; ecrt^ Ir T^ 8et avro

b 5 eS Olympiodorus : 5 B T
b 8 e^a/iev T : tpa/uev B :
\fyo(n.fv Olympiodorus yyi~yvo/j.evris T W Olympiodorus :
B
b i o ToGroBT: rck ourck Olympiodorus
b ir
B . irpa.TTca<nv T
C i /iij B Stobaeus : om. T
C2
T W: 7(-yye(r0aj B
03 TrspJ rovrcav wv ol p.ev taroun Trepl Totrcav B
/ of p.\v Iffatri T

AAKIBIAAH2

isye

AA. Tt ovv TOV al(r0av6ij.evov \prj Tto^lv, 3> Sco/cpares;

Sfi. 'Airoi<piv(r0ai, TO. epwraj/ieva, 'AAKt/3ta8i7' Ka'
eaz; rouro TTOIT/?, aj> 0eoy 0eA?7, ei rt 8e? /cat rr) e/xr/ /xcureta
Trtcrrevety, (TV re Kaycb fteXriov (r^cro^ev.
AA. "Eorat ravra e'ye/ca ye TOU ejue aTTOKpive<rOai.
7, rt ear or TO eavrov eTri/xeXeta-^at //,r) ?roAfy rj^Gtv avr&v eTrt/xeXov/xez'oi, oto/xerot 6e
KOI TTOT' apa avrb Trotei avOpomros; ap' oray rcoz> avrov
e7ri/^eX?5rat, rore /cat avrtw;
AA. 'E/xot yo{5y SoKe?.
2H. Tt 8e; Ttob&v avOpairos irore eTrtjueAerrat; Sp'
oray K.dva>v eirtjoteA^rat a eort rwr 7ro8c5i>;
AA. Ov jj,av9dv(o.
SI1. KaAe?s 8e T6 %ipos; olov baKTijXiov fariv OTOV av
roS avOptoTtov <^atr/? ^ SaKrvAou;
AA. Ow STyra.
2H. OVKOW Kat 7To8os V7ro5?7jua roy OVTOV rpo'nov;
AA. Nat'.
. Kat ijutarta Kat orpc5//ara rou aAAou

AA.

128

10

Nat.)
, rore

A A.
2ii.
orouow
AA.
2ii.
Aeyets

Tt 8e, <u *AAKt/3ta8rj; opdas kiri^X^a-Oai KaAety ri 5

Trpay/xaros;
"Eywye.
*Ap' ovy orai^ ris rt /3eArtoz; -TTOIT/, rore op0j)z>

e 4 oltrBavAfixvov T Olympiodorus : alffQ&nevov B

65 onroKpivcurBcu
Olympiodorus
06 0eA.?? Olympiodorus : e'^eA?; BT
6 7 fieXnov
B T : jSeArj (W>s Coisl.
a 2 OUTO irotel B Stobaeus : Troier aurb T
avQpcairos Schanz (ct I.iox) : &v6pcairos B T
a 13 icof l/^arta . . .

b i i/of Stobaeus : oin. B T

b 8 TI T : om. B Olyropiodorus

riAATilNOS

128 b

AA. Nat.
2H. Tis ovv Tfxvrl V7ro8?7/uara /3eArta>
AA. 2/cvriKTj.
211. 2/ajriKfj apa ^TroSr/ju-drcoy
C
AA. Nat'.
212. *H mi 7ro8os (TKirrtKTj; 17
17 iroSay j
TTOLOVJJ.CV;

10

A A. 'EK61V7J.

2Ii. BeArtous 8e
AA. "Ejuotye 8o/ceu
211. A.mr] 8' ov
AA. MaAtora.
211. rv/AyaoTt/cf) f/,ey apa iroSos
10 8e Twy roi) TroSo?;
AA. ndw ye.
211. Kat

ro a\Ao erw//,a;

AA. Nai.
15
2il. Kat
d aAAats rSy row
AA. nairaTrao-t /xez> ow.
2fl. "AAArj /utey apa Tf\vrj avrov
eiAArj 8e
5
AA.
2H. OVK apa oTav T&V (ravrov eTi^ieATj, (rauroi)
AA. Oii^a^wy.
Sil. Ov yap f) avrrf ri^yt], ws eot/cer, ^ rts ay awou re
eTTtjiteAoiro /cat rfiy avrou.
to
AA. Ou ejbaiyerat.
Sil ^epe 877, Troia TTOT' ay fm&v avr&v
A A. OVK ex&> Ae'
C 12 8aKTuAJO7\w<^fa T : SaKTuXo^Xu^^ B
da
TW
d 6 <ravTov corr. Coisl. : eauroD B : avrov T
Stobaeus : fjris BT
d u irofa T : om. B

o5v B : om.
d 8 77 TIS

AAKIBIAAH2
Sil. 'AAAa T0(roi>8e ye <y/oioAoy?]rai, on ov^ 2? **v rv
fj/jiCT^pdiv /cat OTIOVV /3eAnoi> Trotoijuez', dAA' if rj/JMS avTovs;
AA. 'AATjfl?/ Ae'y*ts.
Sli. 'H ow eyyco/xei> ay TTOTC ris Tf^vrj vTroSrj/xa /3e'Arioi>
Trotel, /i^ et8ores inrobrjijia;
AA. 'A8waroi>.
SH. Ov8e ye rts Texvrl ba-KTvMovs /3eAri'ovs irotet,
ay^oowres 8aKrwAtoj;.
AA. 'AArj^.
22. Tt 8e'; riy TSXVT] fteXrio) Troiei avrov, ap av wore
ayvoovvres ri TTOT' e<rjuei> avToi;
AA. 'A8v^aroy.
SI2. ITorepoy oSy 8r) pqbiov rvy^dvcL TO yi^wrai eauroV,
/cat TLS r\v (fravkos 6 TOVTO avadels <<ls TOV kv Hu^ot veutv, r)
TI KOI ov%l navTos;
AA. 'E/xot juev, co 2wfcpares, TroAAaKts1 /xer e8o^e mures
t, woAAaKt? 8e Tray^aAeTro^.
SI2. 'AAA', S 'AAKt/3ta8rj, ere pqbiov eire /ix?] eortr, o/xcos
ye 77/xiy c58' e'xef yyoVres /xev avro ra)(' "y "yvoifj-fv ri\v
eTri/xeAeiaz; rjfj.&v avrS>v, ayvoovvrts 8e O^K ay irore.
AA. vEori raSra.
SI2. 4>epe br/, riv av Tpoirov tvpeOtir] avrb ravro; OTJTW
/xev yap av TCI^ (vpoi^tv ri Tror' eo^/xev avroC, TOVTOV 8' en
orres ey ayvoia abvvaToi TTOV.
AA. 'Qpd&s Aeyet?.
2O. "E^e ovy Trpos Atos. rw SiaAe'yr; crv vOy; SAAo n
?/ e/xot;

AA. Not.
212. OVKOVV Kdl eycb (rot;
e i TO(r6vSe ye B Stobaeus : TotrovTov 5e ye T
62 iroto't/j.ev
Struve : iroiw/xev B T
6 4 ^ oSj< Olympiodorus : 2 oSi/ B T
a 2 8)>
B : &i> T
a 3 ^ seel. Cobet
b 2 tu> r&x' B T : rdx &"
Olympiodorus
b 3 ^i/res B : ovros T
b 4 opBus \fyets T :
om. B
b 5tfAAort B T : Sx\y ry Stobaeus

ia8e
e

10
129

10
b

jag b
10

IIAAT12NOS

AA.
212.
AA.
212.
AA.
212.
AA.
212.

Nat.
Sco/cparjjs- ap' e<rrtz> 6
Yldvv ye.
'AAKt/3ta8r7s ' 6 O.KOVU>V;
Nat.
Ov/coui> Aoyw dtaAe'yerat o
Tt wv,
To oe StaAeyeo-0ai /cat TO Ao'yw -^prjardai TUVTOV TTOV

AA. Haw ye.

212. '0 Se
A A. ITws Aeyets;
212. r/12o-7rep arKVTOTo^os re^et irou rojue? /cat 07x1X77 Kat
aAAots dpyayoty.
AA. Nat'.
10
212. OVKOVV aAAo /weu 6 r&^vcav /cat \p(a^evos, aAAo 8e
ot? Tfj,v<tiv \prJTai.;
A A. ITws ya/) ov;
212. 'Ap' owy o{ra)s /cat ots 6 Kt0apK7rr)s KiQapifa KOI
airrbs 6 KidapurTris aAAo ay ej;
15
AA. Nat.
d
212. ToCro TOWVV aprta)? Typwrcoy, et o ^pw/xeyos Kat w
det 80/cet1 erepoy eZyat.
AA. Ao/cet.
212. Tt ovy ^cS/xey ror <TKVTOTOIJ,OV; re/x^eiz; dpydrots
rj Kal yjzpcrLv;
AA. Kat \epcriv.
212. Xp^rat apa Kat Tavrais;
AA. Nat'.
212. 'H Ka^ rot9 o(f>6a^fj.ols xp(ajj,vos <TKVTOTOjj.fi;
5

AA. Nat.
07 rojue? B 2 TW Olympiodorus : ro/*p pr. B (ut videtur) Stobaeus
C 10 xpti/Aevos Stobaeus ; d xp^evos BT
c n ofs o W: ofs BT
d i Kl B : re Kal T

AAKIBIAAH2
212. Toy 8e xp<a{Jivov nal cits XprJTai. eVepa ojuoAoyojuez>;
AA. Nat.
212. "E,Tpov apa (narroTo//,os /cat /aflaptorrjs
>OaXfj,S>v ols fpyaovrat;
AA. <t>atyeTat.
212. Ovuovv nal iravrl TO> o-co/xaTt xp^Tat
AA. ITayu ye.
212. "ETepov 8' rjv TO re yjxapevov /cat w yjprirai;
AA. Nai.
212. "ETepov apa &v0pa>Tr6s eort TOU o~co/xaTos ToO eawov;
AA. vEot/cev.
212. Ti TTOT' ovv 6 avOpoairos;
A A. OVK x<*> Aeyety.
212. vE^eis fjikv ovv, ort ye TO TW erw^iaTt yj><ji>ij.zvov.
AA. Not
212. 'H oSy aAAo TI ^pr/Tat avrfi ^ ^rv\ri;
AA. OVK ^AAo.
212. OVKOW Hpxovcra;
AA. Na^.
212. Kal )u^y To'Se y* otftat ovbtva av aAAcos olrjdfjvat.
AA. To irolov;
212. M^ ov TDI&V ev ye Tt eu>ai Toy avOptoirov.
AAo Tircoy;
212. 4/vxr)i> ^ ffSf*a ^ a-vva^orepov, TO oXov TOVTO.
AA. Ti wv;
212. 'AAAa /xrjy OVTO' ye TO rov crw/jiaTos apyov d)j
yi/frafiey avOpamov eirat;
A A. ei2/xoAoy7/(raju,ei'.
212. *Ao' ovy o-fiua avTo awou
e 3 Syf'pcoiros Schanz :ttj/epwirosB T
e 5 5' ^v B : 8)) T
6 7 &i>0t>wiros Bekker: &v8ptavos B T
TOV adj^mos TOW lawroO B :
roC eoi^rou ffc^/xaros 'A
6 9 6 livGpuiros B T : av6punros Bekker
a i ^ J ^ T : et'B
^BT:^^W
b i a>ijio\Qy^a.li.fv B :
io(i.o\oy}\ffa.p.ev -ris olv 6 fodpwiros T W
b a &pxel B T : Sp|ei

Olympiodorus

izgd

10

13

10

i 3 ob
AA.

211. "Ap-^f(r6ai yap avro

AA. Nat'.
211. OVK av 8r/ TOVTO ye
AA.

O^K OLKV.

211. 'AAA' apa ro (Twa^oTfpov rov crw/xaros ap^et, xal

ear i 8?) roCro az>0pa)7roj;
10
AA. "Icrco? 8r]ra.
211. ndiTtoz; ye fjKurra' JUT) yap crvvdpxovros TOV erepov
ovSejui'a TTOV /XTj^avr) ro (rv^a/tx^drepoi' ap^eiy.
AA. 'Op^ais.
C
2H. 'EiretSr) 8' owre crcS/^a ovre TO crvva^orfpov ea-riv
avdpatiros, AetTrerat oijuai r) jwrjSei' avr' etrai, r) etTrep rt eort,
/UTjSev aAA.o roz; frvdpanrov (rvfj-fSaivfiv
rj
AA. Ko/xtSrJ jMey ow.

2H. "Ert ow ri

AA. Ma Aia, dAA.' Ua^Ss //.ot 8oKe

2H. Et 8e ye jur) dxpt^Sajs dAAa Kat juerpico?, eap/cet
d/cptyQw? /xey yap rore et(rojue^a, oray evpco/xev 6 vvvbrj
ta ro 7roAA?ys etrat (r/ce\^ecos.
A A. Tt roCro;
211. AO aprt oi'ra) TTCOS eppr/^rj, on 7rpS>Tov (TMTTTZOV etrj
a^ro ro avro' vvv 8e drrt rou avrou airo e/caoroy ecr/ce/xfie^a
5 ort eori.
xal tcra)? e^apKeVef ov yap 7701; KUptcorepoV ye
ay r}/ji5y avrwv (pricraLp-fV rj rr)y ^rvyjjv.
AA. Ov 8r]ra.
211. OvKoCy KaAws e^et oi;ra) yo/u,iety, e/xe KCJ o~e Trpocrb 9 ecrrt }; TOVTO B Stobaeus : eorrjj' rovr6 ye T
b 11
B : 06^ &PXOVTOS T^V ((ri/j' s. v. W)
C i <rS>fj.a B : T^ crwfj.a T
cs prius ^ T: om. B
05 TJ BT: om Olympiodorus
c8 aA\a
ai /u-erpicas T W : om. B
d 4 Se B : 8^ T
a//rl T b : ai TJ
pr. B
auToD ' nvrov avrov Schleiennacher : awToO Ko6' avrb Stallbaum
avrov ourb Stephanus : O.VTOV avrov B T
d 5 6'rt B Stobaeus

AAKIBIAAH2

i3od

iv dAATjAoi? TOLS Aoyois \pa)[j-vovs TTJ tyvxfj Trpbs TTJV

10
AA. Haw fj.v ovv.
e
212. ToSr' apa fy 6 KOL oAiyw ejU7rpoo-0ez/ airo/Aey,
or6 2coKparr/? 'AAKi/3id8r/ 6aAeyerat Ao'yw ^p(afj.fvos,
oil
vpbs TO (roy TrpocrutTTov, us eoiKfv, aAAa Trpoy roy
TOVS Ao'youy roCro 6e eorty ^ 5
A A. "Ejuotye 8o/cet.
212. ^D^y apa ^/xas
yv&vai kavrov.
AA. "Eoixey.
212. "Ocris apa rwi' rou crw/xaros rt ytyywo-/cei, ra
dAA' oi>x O.VTOV eyyw/cey.
AA. Oii/ra)?.
212. Ovbfls apa T&V larpStv kavTov yiyv^o-Kei,
O(TOV iarpos, ov$ T&V TratSorpt/ScSi', KaO' ocrov

131

Tpi/3f]S.

AA. O^/c eotKey.

212. IToAAoi) apa 8eou(rty 04 yeutpyol KOI ol aAAot 877fjuovpyol yLyvu>crKiv laurov?. o^8e yap ra laurwi' oDrot ye, IQ
, dAA' ert Troppcorepco rwy eavrwy Kara ye ras
as tyovcriv' ra yap TOV o-wjuaroy yLyvf&a-Kovcriv, ols b
rouro 0pa.TTevTai.
AA. 'A\r]0fj Ae'yets.
212. Et apa fruxppoa-vvrj eort ro eauroy yiyy^o'Keii',
ovSets TOVTo>v o-w0pa)f Kara r^v Ttyviqv.
5
AA. Ou /xot 8oKei.
212. Ata Tavra. 5i) Kat fidvavcroi, avrai at re
/cat O^K avbpbs ayaOov
AA. ITayu /xer ouy.
dg rfj i^uxf?] T^J/ i|/vxV Dobree
63 Ao^ajTW: om. B
Stobaeus : om. B T
as 7j-yi><o-Ki T : -yiyv&ffKeiv B
T : om. B
b 7 roajra, T b : raw pr. B

0,2 n
b i &s

i 3 ib

nAAT12N02

10

212. OVKOVV TtdXiv 6<TTLS av o-<Sjua flepaireuei, ra tavrov

dAA' o^x avrov flepa-Treuet;
AA. Kivbvvevei.
212. "Ooris 8e ye ra ~xprifj.aTa, ovd* favTov ovre ra
C eaurou, dAA' In Troppcorepco rwy eauroC;
AA. "E/^otye SOKCI.
212. Ou ra avrov apa en Trparrei 6 xprj/iari<rr?j?.
AA. 'Op6&s.
5
212. Ei apa rt9 yeyorer epaorrjs roi; 'AAKi/3ta8ou
OVK 'AAKi/SiaSou apa Typao-^ dAA.a nyos r<i>

10

AA. 'AA^^ Xeyeis.

212. "Ooris 8e o"ov r?)? i/n^x?}? epa;
AA. 'Az/ayKT] (paCverai, K TOV koyov.
212. OVKOW 6 ju,ey rou crwp-aros <rot>
avdovv, aTnwv ot)(erai;
AA. 4>aiyerai.
212. 'O 8e ye r^s ^v\ijs fp&v OVK cnri,criv, eco? ch> CTTI TO
/3eArioz; Try;
A A. EIKOS ye.
212. O^/coCi' ey<0 et/xt 6 O-^K aTUtov dAA.a
A?7yoyros TOU (rwjuaros, rwy aAAcoy a
AA. Ev ye Trotwi', a> 2(rfKpares'
212. Ilpo^u/xoS roivvv on KaAAtoros ew;at.
AA. 'AAA.a ^po^Dju^o-o/xat.
212. C12s ovrco ye o-ot e^ei* ovr' eyez>e#', a>s
a8r/ roi KAeiznou epa(rr?j? our' COTI^ dAA' ?/ et
s, /cat oSros dyaTrrjro?, 2coKparijy 6
AA. '
212. OVKOW <-(f)r)(r6a vpiKpov QOrjvaC p,e -7rpoo-eA.0oVra (rot,

b 10 ret B : ri T
C6 ipa T: om. B

b n oi>x ewr&c T Stobaeus : o6/c ow-rbi* B

d6 ^Sc T : M^ B
ea i\A' ^ T t

AAKIBIAAH2
av
on fjiovos OVK aTt^
AA. *Hi> yap OVT&>,
212. TOWTO TOLVVV OLTLOV, on p.6vos epaarrjs r\v cros, oi
8' aAAoi roSf <r(Sy TO 8e o-a \riyet &pas, (rv 8' ap^rj avOfiv.
Kai vvv ye av ^ SuupBapfjs inrb TOV 'AflrjvaiW ^TJ/JLOV KOL
alffyjitov yfvrj, ov fji-rj (re aTroAtira). TOVTO yap br] /xaXtcrra
eya) <o/3ov//at, JWT) 8r][j.epaa-Tr]s fifjuv yez/o/xe^o? bicupdapfjs'
-TroAAoi yap ^1877 Kat aya#o avro TreTrovdatriv 'Adrjvaiwv.
evTtpoo-WTTos yap o TOV jaey a Apropos bfjpos 'Epe^OeuiS'
dAA' aTroSwra x/3^ avrbv Beda-aadai. evAa/SoS oSy r^y
rjv eya> Aeyco.
AA. TtW;
212. TvfjLvacrai irp&Tov, u> [JiaKdpie, /cat /^a^e a 8et piaOovra
eir^ ra rfjs TroAecos, irportpov 8e /A^, u>' a
??;s Kat /X7]8ey Trudys Sfivov.
AA. Ev fj,oc boKeis Aeyetr, a> 2coK/)are?' aAAa
yeto-^ai OVTIV' av rpoirov fTTL^X^Qfl^v rnj.S>v avr&v.
212. OVKOW TOCTOVTOV fJifv rjfj-lv fls TO Trpo&dev
$ yap f a f
a-<pakfVTfs XaQfjo^v trtpov TWOS em/xeAo/j(,ez;o6 d

1316

10
132

AA. vEart Tavra.

10
212. Kat /uera rouro 8^ ort ^VXTJS e7rt/jiA?jreoi/ /cat ei's C
AA. A??Aoz>.
212. 2co/xarcoz; 8e Kai \pi}^a.T<av rrjv
irapaboTeov.
AA. T^IJJ;;
e 10 erJs] (foD Stallbaum
a 2 airo\'nr<a B T : dffoAeiTro) Olympiodorus
a 3 iy/ili/ yev6(J.ej>os B : yev6i*.evo$ rifuv T
b 5 "&VTI.V
\v Bekker : cd/rtya B T
b 7 e<j>ofiov/j.f0a T : <j>o&ov/j.e8a B
C i 5^
8rt Stobaeus : 5e Srt T : ^877 B
i^wx^s T Olympiodorus Stobaeus ;

132 c

10
d

10
6

133

IIAATaNOS
Sfl. TiV ovv &v rpoTTOV yvofyev avrb euapyeorara;
fTtei.br] TOVTO yvovTes, w? eoiKer, Kal r)fjias avTOvs yvu>(Tojue^a. Spa Trpbs 6f&v ev Aeyoiros ov vvvbr)
TOV AeA<piKoi3 ypd/x/Aaros ov <rvvifj,v;
AA. To TTOIOV TL oiavoovfAtvos Aeyets, a>
SH. 'Eyw (rot <f>pacr(ti, o ye wTTOTrrevw Xeyety Kal <rv}J,(3ovrouro TO ypd/x/xa. KtySwevet yap oi/8e
7rapa8ety/*a avrot), dAAa Kara r^y o\/^ty povov.
AA. n<Ss roSro Aeyets;
212. 2KO7T66 xat (TV. ei rip.&v rw op,/xari wcrirep a
crv/ji/3ouA.e{;oi> ct'Trei' " i8e o-auroV," Trfis av vTreXd/Bofjiev rt
; apa ov\i eis roi5ro ^Xeircti', ets 6 ^Xeircov 6
jixeAAev avrbv Ibelv;
AA. A^Aoy.
S12. 'Eyvowjuey 8^ eis ri fiXeirovTes T&V OVTMV eKtlvo
re 6pS>p.v ap,a av /cat ?7juas avrovs;
AA. A^Aov 8??, w Se^Kpares, ort ets KaroTrrpa re xal ra
roiaSra.
Sli. 'Op^wy Aeyets. OVKOW icai r<5 d^^aAjotw w op&fjiev
eW(rri (rt) rwy roiovrcoi';
A A. Ilaz>u ye.
Sil. 'Ewei'orjKas oi/y ort rou eja/3Ae-7royros ets roy
o(p9a\.fJLbv TO 7rp6<r(tiTrov ep,^)aiyerat ev rrj rou Karai/rtKpi)
dx^et &<mep tv KaroTrrpa), 6 817 Kal Koprjy KaAoujL
dz; ri roii e/x/3Ae'7roi'ros;
AA. 'AArj^ Ae'yeiy.
212. '0<f>6ah.fji,bs apa 6(p0a\iJibv ^eco^ero?, Kal
ets rovro oTrep j8e'Ario-roy avrou Kal <S opa, ovrws av ambv

c 7 ourb Schleiermacher : aura B T

c 8 al T : om. B
C 10 ^vviefjiev B Stobaeus :faur/jLev1
d. 6 crv/j.fiovAevov Apelt :
(rvjj.0ov\evocv B : v/j.fiov\fvoi> T
elTrej/ T : tlireiv B
eratiTbv B T :
f avrbv Stobaeus
d 7 /3A.eVet' B : /SXeVet T
d B : om. T
65 rt add. F. A. Wolf
a a & . . . ita\ov/j.ev seel. Schleiermacher
K6(fi\v B Stobaeus : Kopv<p))v 1

a 3 <>/ ri B : Si/ T

AAKIBIAAH2

133 a

AA. <J>cuVe7ai.
212. Ei 8e y els aAAo r&v TOV avdptoTrov /3AeVoi ^ rt
r<3z> ovTdtVy TrXrjv els eKctvo <3 rovro ruyxdvei opoiov, OVK 10
AA. 'AXrjOrj Ae'yeis.
b
212. 'O(0aAf>io? ap el //.e'AAei tSeu; avrov, els 6<p$a\[JLOV ai>T(p fiXcTrreov, KOI TOV o^/JLaros f l s tKeivov TOV TOTTOV
ev w Tvy\dvL f) 6(pdaX[j.ov d/oer^ lyy\.yvo^vr\- ecrrt be
TOVTO TTOV otylS;

AA.

OVTMS.

2f2. *Ap' ow, S) ^>iXe 'AXKifttdbt], KCU ^wx^

yvutcrea-Oai avrr/v, els -fyvyriv avrfj jSAeTrreoi', Kai
ets rouroy O.VTTJS TOV TOTTOV kv (S eyyiyverai f] \jsvxfjs
aperf,
crcxpia, Kal els aAAo a> roiiro ruy^ai'ei o/xotoy or;
10
AA. "E/x-otye Soxe?, S SwKjoare?.
212. yE^ojuei' ow eiTre^ ort eart TT^S "v/^vx^s Oeiorepov c
rj TOVTO, irepl 6 TO etSeVat re Kat typovelv eariv;
A A. O^K Ixoju-ey.
212. T<3 ^ew apa TOUT' ZOIKCV avrrjs, KO.I ris ets rouro
fikcTTtov Kal Trav TO Oelov yvovs, Oeov re KCU (ppovr]<riv, 5
ovrco Kai kavTov av yvoif] ptiXurTa.

A A. 4>airerai.
(212. 'A/s' ovr, o^' uxnrep Karoirr/oa ecrrt cra^ea-Tepa TOV
ev rw d(0aA/>ia) evoirTpov Kal KaOap<aTpa Kal Xa^irpOTepa,
OVTU> Kal 6 0eb$ TOV f v rrj ^juerepa i/^xS /3eAriVrov KaOa- 10
p&Tfpov re Kat Xa^irpoTepov TvyyJLVti ov;
AA. "EoiKe ye, S 2ci)/cpares.
212. Eis rov ^eoy apa ^SAeTroire? e/cetVa>
V els TIJV
a 10 TOI!TO] atfrb Madvig
b 4 ^ B : om. T : ?) TOV Stobaeus
b 5 &J/is T : ^ t>^/ts B
b 10 arotpla seel. Heusde
c i Btiorfpov
T W : yofptarepov B : KvpiutTepov Cobet
C a re] "ye B : TO T

eo-Tti' B Stobaeus : om T

04 6e$ B : fiei'^ T

05 0eoV re /cal

<pp6i>Tiffiv om. Olympiodorus

08-17 TAp' oSv . . . Nat Eusebius :
om. BT (sed talia fere Jegerunt Inlianus Stobaeus)

I33C
15 dperr/y, Kol ovrais ay jxaAtora op&pev /cat
rj[MS avrovs.
AA. Nai.)
SO. To Se
elvai;
20
AA. IldVu ye.
2H. *Ap' ovr
(ppoves OVTS 8waijue0' ay eiSeVat ra ^/xerepa
re /cal dya^a;
AA. Kat TTws &v roCro yeVotro, S 2w/cpares;
d
212. 'ASwaroy yap urcos (rot 0ati;erat /XT^
'AA/a/3ta8i]i> ra 'AAKi/3ia8ou ytyycotrKety ort 'AA.Ki/3taSou
(CTTIV.

A A. 'ASwaroy fxeyroi vr) Ata.

S12. Oii8' Spa ra ^p-erepa ort ^/xerepa, ei M^S' ^as
avrovs;
A A. IIws yap;
2H. Ei 5' apa urjSe ra ^/Aerepa, ov8e ra rwy r/^erepcov;
AA. Ov <paivTai.
10
S12. OIK apa Traz^u ri
apri etrai riya? ot eauroi/s //.ey ov ytyvKXTKOviTLV, ra 8'
8e ra rwy eaurwu. eoi/ce yap Trayra raCra earn
iy Iros re Kat jaias T\vr]s, avrov, ra aiiTov, ra rwz/
eauroi;.
AA. Kiz>8weuei.
Sil. r/0o-ns 8e ra avrov ayvoei, KO! ra rwy aAA.coz> TTOU
5 ay dyyooi) Kara ravra.
A A. Ti xTy;
5

C 18 tL/xoA.o'yoCwei' T : 6/toAo/yoi/i6i' B Stobaeus

022 Svvat/j.eO'
&i> B : Sui/a(/i60a T: Svva.fj.e6a Stobaeus
d i yap TW: om. B
Olympiodorus
troi B Olympiodorus : om. TW
6.5 Srt ^/terepa
TW: om. B
d 8 ^r)8e Stobaeus: om. BT
d 10 &/j.o\oyovnfV
T : 6fj.o\oyovfiev B Olympiodorus
d la &\\ovs Se Stobaeus :
ctAA.' oil B T
e 5 &j> d-y^oo? T : ayvool B : dyj/oe? Stobaeus

AAKIBIAAH2
211.
AA.
211.
AA.
211.
AA.
SQ.
AA.
212.
AA.
212.

OVKOVV el TO, T&V aXKtov, Kal ra T&V 7roAe<o/J

'AvayKJj.
OVK ap av yeVotro 6 TOIOVTOS avrjp
Ov brJTd.
Ov /AT)I> 0118' oiKoyo/x-tKoy ye.
Ov Sr/ra.
Ov8e ye eto-erat ort
Ov yap oSz,'.
'O 6e pj] et8a)s o^x
Ilazw ye.
J
Ea//,a/)rai/coz> 8e ov fca/cws Trpa^et t8ta re

I33e

10
134

AA. ILSs 8'

211. KaKois1 8
AA. 2(f)6bpa ye.
211.

Tt 8' (US OVTOS

AA. Kat OVTOL.

211. OVK apa otoV re, eay /A?; rts cr^^p^v Kat dya^oy 17,
evSai/xoi'a ew/ai.
AA. Ovx oto'y re.
211. Ot apa KaKol rG>v avOp<a7ru>v aOXioi.
AA. 2^o8/>a ye.
211. OVK apa ov8' 6 7rA.ovr?7<ras d^Ator?jros diraAAarrerat,
dAA' 6 (ra>(ppovri<ra,s.
AA. ^atrerat.
211. OVK apa Tfi\S>v ovbf rpiriputv ov8e ve(t>pia>v
at TroAeis, S 'AAKt/3ia8r;, et ^XXovcnv eubainovricre
ov8e jueye^ouy areu dper^s.
AA. Ov /xeWot.
10
211. Et 8r/ /^eAAets ra r^s TroAecos Trpa&iv opd&s KOL
s, apeTijs <TOI juera8ore'oy rot's TroAtrat?.
C
as 76 T : om. B
a 13 OUK dipa . . . b 3 <T(j)68pu ye T b : om. B
4 d^AtJrTjTos T W Olympiodorus ; fiaTadrriTos B

134 C

IIAATi2NO2

A A. n<Ss yap ov;

212. AVVCUTO 8' av ris /xeraSiSduat o [Ay e)(ot;
AA. Kat Trwy;
5
212. AVT& apa croi irp&rov KrrjreW apeTriv, KCU aAAa> 6s
jixeAAet JU.T) tSta fj,6vov avTov re KCU r<Sy aurou cp^ety Kat
e7ri/>ieA?}cre<r0cu, dAAa TroAecos Kat rwy TT)S
A A. 'AAT]^ Xeyeis.
SI2. OVK apa e^ovcriav (tot ot>6' apxn
10 (ravrfi 7roieu> ort ay fiovXri, ovbe rr} iroAei, dAAa

AA.
Sli. AiKauos /^.ey yap Trparroyres Kat <TUtfyp6vu>s (TV re
Kat ?/ TroAis 6eo(f>L\)s Trpa^fre.
AA. EtKo? ye.
212. Kal ouep ye kv roty TtpocrOfv eAeyo^er, eis rt>
S ^etor Kai Xa^pbv op&vres n'pd^ere.
AA. ^atz/erat.
212. 'AAAa ^v hravOd ye jSAeVoyres vjuas re avrovs
Kat ra v/ixerepa dya^a Kardi^eo-^e Kat y^cacrecr^e.
AA. Natr.
0
212. OVKOW 6pO>$ re KOI ev 'Trpa^ere;
AA. Nat'.
e
212. 'AAAa JU,TJI> oi/ra) ye irpaTTOvras vp,as efleAco ey-

A A. 'Acr^aAr)? yap et eyyurjr?]?.

212. 'AStKcos 8e ye TrpdYrovrey, et? TO a^eoy Kat CTKOTCIVOV
5 /SAe'TTOires, a>s ra etKora, o/xota rotJrots irpa^ere d
avrovs.
AA. "EotKey.
212. ^llt ya/3 (dv), a) <ptAe 'AAKt/3td8T), e^ouo-ta
o ^SovAerai, yoCy 8e /XT) ex??, Tt ro etKos
c
3 eXot T Olympiodorus : e~x.fi B Stobaeus
C 5 KTyreov T :
K\i}reov B
d 8 KOI B : re Kal T
e 4 71= T : om. B Stobaeus
teal T : al rb B Stobaeus
e8 &y Laur. Ixxxv. 9: om. BT

AAKIBIAAH2
<arp rj Kal Tro'Aet; olov vocrovvn e^oixrtas ovcrrjs bpav o
/3ovAerat, vovv iarpiKov /XT) Hyovri, rvpavvovi'Ti be >s /urj8ev
eTTiTrA^TTOt TIS ai>Tu>, TI TO o-vp.firio-op.evov ; ap' ovfo a>s TO
etKos, buxpdapfjvai TO o-<3/xa;
AA. 'AXridfj Aeyecs.
212. Tt 8' ey z^r;t, a r< e^ovcrta etr; iroitlv o bonei, vov
TC Kal ctpfTrjs KvfiepvriTiKrjs
lcrrepr;/xeva), KaOopqs & av
trvfjifiaLr] avrw re /cat rcus (rvvvavrais;
AA. "Eycoye, cm ye aTro'Aoiyro Tra^res ai*.
212. O^KOW ft)(ravr(os ey Tro'Aei re KCU 7rd(rats ap^ais Kal
fov(riais aTroAetTro/xeWis apfrijs eTrerat ro KCLK&S TtpaTTeiv;
AA. 'Az/ayK?;.
212. O^K a/oa rvpavviba \p"r\, S aptore 'AAKi/3ta8r/, TrapacrKfvdCfo-Oai ov& O.VT& ovre rry TroAet, et jixe'AAere fvbaip:oi>iv,
dAA' apfT-qv.

1346
10
135

AA. 'AA?]077 Ae'yeis.

212. Ilpti; 8e ye apen]v f\eiv, TO apyjE<r6ai apeivov virb
TOV (SeAriWo? ^ ro ap^ftv avopi, ov IJ.QVOV 7rat8t.
AA. 'J'atyerat.
10
212. OVKOUZ> ro y' ftpeivov /cat KO.XXi.ov;
AA. Nat.
212. To 8e KaXXiov TT/oeircoSeVrepoi';
AA, IIws 8' ov;
C
212. HpeTret apa rw Kaxw bovXeveiv ap.et.vov yap,
AA. Nat.
212. AouAoTrpeTres a/)' ^ Ka/cta.
AA. 4>afoerai.
5
212. 'EAeu^epoTrpeTres 8e f) d

AA. Nat'.
a i wj] SirTe Schanz (et mox evnrK'fir'rfiv cum Buttmann)
eirtfl-A^TTot TJS awr^ T : /j.i)5^v eiriirA^Tret rty awr^ Olympiodorus :
fTriir\-flTTOVTi eavrcjj B
a 5 SOKS? T : So/cejv B
a7
W Stobaeus : |ujHj3oiV?7 B T : v/ufiaivoi Coisl.
a 8 S^ T : om. B
a 9 iratrats B Stobaeus : airaffais T
PLATO, VOL. n.
23

I35C

10

nAATONOS A A K I B I A A H 2
212.
AA.
212.
AA.

OVKOVV (pevyciv xpn> <*> ffaipf, ryv

MaAiord ye, a> 2a>/c/)ares.
Ala-Odvy be vvv TT&S exeis; eAev0e/)07rpe7r<3? T/ ov;
AOKCO /AOI Kai /xaAa <r<p6bpa ai<rOdv(rdai.

2Ii. Ol(T0' oSy TTWS aTTO(j)vrj

TOVTO

TO TTfPl

VVV,

Lva JU.T) 6vo{jL&(i(i)iJ,V awb enl KaAw avbpi.

d
A A. "Eya>ye.
AA. 'Eay ^ o v j ? (TV,
Sfi. Oy /caA.cl)s Xeyets,
5
AA. 'AAA.a TT>S xprj Aeyety;
212. "Ort tav 6eo$ 0&p.
AA. Aeyco 817. KOI Ttpos TOVTOIS /xeVrot ro8e Ae'ya), ort
KtySufevcro/xey /xera^aAet^ ro a-yji^a, S 2wKpares, ro ;u.ei>
(roy eyw, cri) 8e Tovpov

ov -yap HCTTIV OTTO)S ov

10 (re aTTo Trjcrbf Trjs ^/xe/oas, <rv 8' VTT' Ijuou 7ratSaycoy?/(rr/.
e
212. '12 yfvvalf, TreAapyou apa o e/xos epcos
8toi<ret, et Trapa crot evvforrevcras epcora vTroirrepov into
TOVTOV TraAir ^e/>aTrewerai.
AA. 'AAAa ovrcos exfi> Kai apo(j,ai ye fVTfvOev r^s
5 StKatoo-wT;? eTrt/ieAeo-^at.
212. BouAotjur/i; ay <re Ka6 8iareAeo-ar oppcabSt 8e, ou rt
rr) <rrj (^va-et a^i<rr&v, dAAa rr)
re Kat crov
d 7 ntvroi r6de B T : /uey &$t Olympiodorus
d8
6?p Cobet
e 2 evveoTTevaras B : tvvtOTrtvffaffi
T

AAKIBIAAH2

AETTEPO2

2HKPATHS AAK1BIAAH2

St. II
p. 138

211. *fl 'AAKt/3id8i7, apa ye irpbs TOV 6ebv

AA. ndvi fj*v ovv, a>
212. <&aivr\ yz TOI ffKv6p(oTraKtvai
re /cat ety y^
toy rt (rvvvoov^evos.
5
A A. Kai rt ay TI? o-ui^oorro, ai 2w/cpare?/
212. T7)y jueyiorr/y, S 'AAKt/StaSr?, crvvvoiav, co? y' l/zot
eirel ^>^pf Tr/ooy Ato?, OVK oiti TOVS Ofovs, a b
V\o^voi Kal i8ta KCU bri^oa-ia, ertore TOVTUIV
TO. //,> 8i8wai, ra S' ow, Kal HarTiv ots fJLtv avr&v, eari
8' ots oi/;
AA. Haw [Afv ovv.
5
212. OVKOVV 8o/cet o-ot TroAA^s irpo/zrj^eia? ye Trpo<rbf?cr()ai,
OTTCOS ft?) AT^crerat avrov v\6/j,evos jaeyaAa KOKa, SGK&V 8'
ayadd, ol 8e ^eot rvyjixnv kv ravrr) OVTCS rij eei, ey 77
8t8oacrty avrot a rts fi>xofj.evos rvyxavei; axnrep TOV 018i7row avTiKa <f>a<rlv e#a<r0ai xa^K^ 8ieAeV^at ra
rouy very e^ov avrw T&V Ttapovrtov O.VT& KCLK&V
a I irpocTu|o/xj'os iropfvri T : iropevo/^fvos irpoiretil-fi B
a 6 TJS
T : rt B
b 7 A^<rTt] \-fiffei ris Bekker
C i r& irarpQa
robs vlfts B : rovs vlf?s fit iraTpcpa, T
02 TrapdfTtav ainfp B :
T

I38c

IIAATONOS

va<rOai, erepa Trpos rots virdpxov<ri.v Karrjparo' rotyapovv ravra re e^ereAeo-flr?, /cat IK TQTJTMV aAAa TroAAa Kat
5 Select, & rt 8e? Ka0' eKaora Aeyeizj;
AA. 'AAAa o-v /ueX a 20Kpares, juatyo/xeyoy avOpaTrov
efrjKas- eiret rts ay (rot 8oKe roA/ATytrat iiyiaivtov rotai)r '
SO. To naCvfa-Oai apd ye virevavTiov croi SOKCI
10 (ppovttv;
AA. Flaru /ixe^ ow.
d
2O. "A(f>povs 8e
ri^e? o-ot;
AA. Ei^at jucerrot.
SO. <J>epe 817, e7rio-Ke\^co)ue0a rtres TTOT' eto-b; o^rot. ort
5 /xev yap eto-t rtyes, aijtxoAoyijrat, atypovts re Kat
Kat fj.aivo[jLevoi erepot.
AA. 'H/xoAoyijTat yap.
SO. "Ert 8e -vyiaivovres etcrt rtyes;
AA. EtViV.
10
SO. OIIKOW Kai do-0eyowres erepot;
139
AA. rhizn; ye.
SO. OWKOW
AA. Ov yap.
SO. ?Ap' ovy Kat erepot rtyes ft<riv, ot //rj8erepa rotf
5 TifirovOcHnv;
AA. Ov S^ra.
SO. 'A^ayKT] ytip eo-rty &v6p<airov ovra TJ i/oa-eiy ^ p/

10

AA. "E/^totye 8o/cet.

SO. T 8e'; irept (ppoinjaecos Kat a^)poavvr]s apd ye rr)i>
AA. Il<Ss Aeyets;
04 T T : om. B
09 itpa 7^ T : Spa B
a 7 7<fy> eoTt^ T :
fip' B
a n ex6S """ yvdafjiriv scripsi : e^et ffvyyvfafiiiv B: xts
Tb

AAK1BIAAH2 AETTEPO2

I3ga

212. Ei boKtl (roi olov re elvai rj <$>povi\i,ov rj a<f>pova, T)

eari rt bia jueVou rpirov ird6os, o iroiet TOV avdpawov jWTjre
(ppovi/j-ov p,ijT( a<ppova;
AA. Ov brJTa.
212. 'AvdyKrj ap' eart ro trepov rovrtov TrenovQevai.
AA. vE/xotye So/ceu
212. OVKOVV /xe/x^frat ojwoAo-yrjcras virfvavriov ftvat,
(ppovrjcrti.;
AA. "Eycoye.
212. OVKOW Ka6 fjLrjbev tlvai 8ia p.ecrov rpirov iraOos,
Troiei TOV avOpooTtov jixTyre </>poz;i//,oz> ju^re acppova ewat;
AA. MljuoAoyT/cra yap.
212. Kat /UT)I 8i/o ye vTrevavria evl 'npay^an TTW? ay et?j;
AA. Ov5aju<3s.
212. 'AQpcxrvvi] apa KCU jaazn'a KtrSvi'evet raiirov clvai.
AA. 4>atVerai.
212. Ilavra? ow av (pavrts, S 'AAKt/3ta8?j, rots a(ppova$
i 6p6S>s av ^>ai?j^ey avriKa rwy crwy ^AtKtcorwy
e^ rtyes ruyxa^oi'O'ii' atppoves OVTZS, wcnrfp etcri, Kat rwy
en 77/3e<r/3t>repa>y. eiret ^>epe Trpos Aios, OVK otet rwi; ey TT/
iroAei oAtyous1 /xey eT^at rov? (ppovifjiovs, ucppovas be br]
TOVS TroAAovs, o$s brj &v fJiaLVO^vovs KaAefc;
AA. "Eycoye.
212. Otet av ovv yjOLipovras ^/xa? et^at /a,era TOcrovTutv
fJLO.lVOIJ,VU>V

TTO\tTfVOfJ.fVOVS,

KCU OVK ai/ TTaLOjJ,VOVS

KOL /3aA-

10

10
d

Ao/xeVou?, Kai aTrep fltodacriv ol ^aivo^evoi biaTrpdTT(rOai,

TraAai dry StKTjv 8e5o)Kei'at; aAAa opa, /xaKapte, /xr) o^x
ovrcoy raw' e^ei.
AA. Ilcoy ar ow TTOT' e^ot, S ScoKpares; KtySwe^et yap 5
ovx ovrcos e'xeu' oocnrep
a 13 e SoKfTs ofov re B : 8o/ce7 troi oWc re T : So/eel (roi
Ast : So/cet trot yU^j/ov TI^ ci. Stallbaum
a 14 irate? B : ^7ro(et T
C 3 ITOI/TOS T : TracTes B
c 7 St S)/ B : Se T
d 3 8$; B : om. T
opa B : aA\' Spa T

OAATIiNOS

10
e

140

dAAa rf/8e Try adprjreov.

A A. ITrj TTore Ae'yet?;
2O. 'Eyo> bij (rot ye epo>. V7roAaju./3dVof/,eV ye
eiyai voo-ovvras' rj ov;
AA. Ilari; jjiev ovv.
211. 7Ap' ovv ooKft <rot duayKauw etyat TOV vocrovvra
irobaypav rj TrupeTreiv 17 otyOaXniav, r) OVK av 8o/ceT crot Kal
/x,rj8ey rovrcoy irtTrovd&s krtpav vocrov voo-ftv; TroAAat yap
ST/TTOU ye eieri, Kat ov\ amai
AA. "E/xoiye 8o(coij(r6y.
2fi. 'O(/)^aA//,ta troi ow
AA. Nat.
2Ii. 'Ap' ovy Kal Trao-a
AA. Ow S^ra e/xoiye' cnropG) ^VTOL ye TTWS Aeyw.
2fi. 'AAA* eay e/xotye irpoa-f-^s TOV vovv, a"6v re
AA. 'AAAa Trpocre^o), u> ScoKpares, eis bvvafj.iv

rrjy

5 eiyat, yocros /uezroi O K eiz/at Tratra

A A. 'lijuoAoy^rj.
2il. Kai opO&s ye juot SOKCI 6ju,oAoyrj^7jvat.
xal yap
01 TivpeTTovres iravres vocrorxriv, ov [ikvroi o\ vocrovvres
TtvpfTTova-iv ovbe 7ro8aypw(rty o8e ye d
aAAa yocros ju,e^ Traz^ ro roioOroV eori,
8e (pao-LV oiis or] KaAou/xey larpovs T^y a7repya<riaz>
ov yap Tracriv ovre o/xotai ovre ojuotcos 8ta7rpdrrovrat, aAAa
Kara rrjz; avrijs 8wajuiy eKao-rrj- i/oo-ot jueyrot Tracrat da-iv.
5 6oo"7rep ornjuovpyovs rivas vTroAa/x/Sdyojaey ^ ov;
AA. ndi'D aev o3z>
2ii. OllKOW

TOVS CTKVTOTOlJiOVS

Kdl

TCKTOVCiS

KOI

O.V-

d. 9 -ye rtz/as T : rti/as B

e4-yT:TB
e6 trot our B :
Sj> <rot T
69 jueWoi -yf T : juerroj B
as TUX^"' B : (rxeSbv T
a 9 TroSaypiaffiv
B : iroSaypitaffiv
T
b 2 Se recc. : 8^ B T
b 3 iracrij' B : TrSerai T
O/J.OMI T ; o/xoioi B : tJ^toia J. G. Schneider

AAK1BIAAH2 AETTEPO2

I4ob

bpLavToiroiovs KCU erepous ira/uTrATjflei?, oiis ri 8et Ka0' e/cao-ra

Xeyeiv; tl\ov<ri 8' ovv 8teiA?)<ores S^iovpyias /xepTj, /cat
aSroi eurt brjp-iovpyoi, ov /ueWot eicrt re/croWs ye c
ovcuroro'juoi oS' avbpiavTOTroioi, ot a~vjj,7ravrfs elcri
AA. Ov 8^ra.
212. Owcoy ^ey TOIVVV KCU ri}V a(f>pocrvvr)v bii\rj<f)OTfs 5
eieri, KOI roi/s /xe^ ^Aer<Troy avrrjs juepoy \ovras fj.at.voKaXovufv, TOVS 8' oAiyoy fXarrov r\\i6iovs re Kal
'

OL be

V tV(f)r]IJ.OTG.TOI,S

OVOfJ.a(Tl

/3oV\6fJifVOl

ol fjiev /ueyaXo^v^ous', ot Se ev^ets, erepot 8f

icat aTreipovs /cat ei^eovj- evp?j<reis 8e Kat ere/sa d
ovofj-ara.
-navra 8e rawra a(j>poo~uvr]
Kal vocros vo<row rj TTWS <roi bowl;
AA. 'Ejuot /xey o{/ra)s.
5
212. OIIKOVV aTr' ZKCLVOV iraAtu fTrave\.6(afj.v. tfv yap
ST/TTOI; K<H ey opx^J r^ Aoyot, ovceTrWor eTrai TOVS a(ppovds
re Kai ^povifjiovs, TLVCS TTOT' tlcriv. &p.oX6yrjTo yap flvat
nvas' % yap ov;
AA. Nat, a)ju.oAoyrjTat.
10
212. 'A/)' ovy rovrovs </>/30z>t}uovs vTroX.ap,j3avis, ot Sz^ e
et8a><riy arra 8et TTpdrreiv Kal Aeyeir;
AA. "Eycoye.
212. *A(frpovas 8e Trore'pouy; apa ye rovs
AA. TovYovs.
212. OvKoOy ot ye /HT) e^Sorey ^berepa TOVTMV
avrovy Kai Aeyoi/re? Kai -Trparroyre? arra fir) 8e?;
AA. 4>atVerai.
212. Tovraiz; /txe^rot eAeyoi>, S 5AAKi/3ta8?7, Kal TOV 10
c 2 oiS'f T: Kal E
ot T : om. B
d 7 aJ B :. om. T
dp oJ; del. Hirschig
d 10 &/j.o\Ayijro Stephanus
e8 \4yovTfs
Kal TrpaTTOvrts Stobaeus : Aeyovras oJ irpdrrovras B T

I4ia

HAATiiNOS

141 Oi8tVot>z> elvai T&V av6pa>Tr<DV ev/OTjcreis 8' en not T&V vvv
TtoXXovs OVK dpyrj Kf\pr]ij,fvovs, cocnrep fKelvov, 01/8' otoptvovs KCLKO, crc/Hcny V\e<rd(u, ciAA' ayaOa. eKeu>os /xez>
o)CT7re/3 ovd' rjvyjtTO, ov5' o>ero' erepoi 8e rive's etcrtz> ot
5 ravavria TOVTWV ire'novOacri.v. eyo> /xev yap otju,cu ere
, el CTOL ffj.(pavi]s yeyojuei'os 6 ^eos Trpbs ov rvy\aveLS
pcoTTjo-etey, irplv OTLOVV evaar6aC (re, et ea/aKecret croi Tvpavvov ytvea-Oai rrjs ' A.6n]vaia)i> TroAecoy et
Se ro{5ro (fravXov r}yf]<raiQ Kat JUT) /^eya rt, TtpocrOeCri KCU
b irazmoy r<Sy 'EAXTjvcoy et Se <re opwrj ert eAarroy SOKOWTCI
, et JUT) Kat micrTj? EvpwTTT;?, wocrratrj (rot Kat TOJJTO,
I roijro) /XT) \LQVOV virocrrcuT/, (aAA') avOrjpepov <rov /3ovTrairas ala-Orjcrfcrdai on 'AAKt/3iaTjj 6
5 rvpavvos fcrTLV
avrov ol^ai av ere aTTieWi
yev6fj.fvov, ws rcoy /xeyi'crraz> ayaO&v KeKVprjKora.
AA. 'Eyco /xei' ot/xat, w 2w/</)ares, KO^ aAAoz>
eiTrep TotaCra cr?j/x/3atTj awco.
C
2ii. 'AAAa /aerroi dirt ye TT^S CTT;S \//V^T]S 0118' ay TT)^
Travrtoi; 'EAA^ywy re Kat /3ap/3apa)y yj&pav re Kat Tvpavviba
(3ovXri6e{r]s crot yei^e'cr^ai.
AA. OVK ot/xat eycoye. TTWS yap ar, p,t]6^v ye' rt fjieXXcov
5 avrols xprja-ca-OaL;
211. Ti 8' et /ueAAots KaKws re Kat /3Aa/3epw? \prja-0Gu;
AA. O^ 8r]ra.
2ii. 'Opas oSv ws OTJK dcrc/)aAes ovre ra StSo/uera
10 8e)(ecr$ai' re ovre avrov eil^eo-flat yevf(r8ai, et ye rts
d /SAaTrrecr^at /ueAAot 8ta raiira T) ro TtapaTrav TOV /3tou
TroAAovs 8' ay exot/ixey etTrety, ocrot rvpava I 8* erx al Twy vvv B : Se /cat TWI/ wj/ ert T
as SKGIVOV T : Keicoi/ B
b i dp^i; B : epcfijT
\)2 Kal TOVTO bis scripsit Sauppe
bs a\A'
add. Dobree
b 4 alaQiiaea'Qa.i B : alirOeffOai T
b 5 aurbvl avrtav'
Dobree : irpwrov Schanz
C 2 re /cat J3. B : /cal #. T
05
xpJiffeffBtu
c
B : XP*?0"^ T
6 /U\AOJS B : /xeAAeis T
C 10 re o#re T :
T ouSe B : -ye otfrt corr. Coisl. : a-e o(?T vulg. : ovre J. G. Schneider

A A K I B 1 A A H 2 AETTEPO2

I4id

7TiOvfJii/]cravTs rjorj Kal cnrovbacravTes TOVT' avrois

TiapayevecrOai, w? ayaQov rt TrpdavTes, bia rr/y rvpavviba
fTn/3ov\v0evTs rov fiiov dipriptOrjo-av.
ot/xat 8e (re OVK 5
av^KOOv etWt eytd ye \0ia re Kai irpu>'ia yeyeyrjp-e'ya,
ore 'Ap^eAaoy rw Ma/ce8ofo)^ rvpavvov TO. iratSiKa, epaa-Ofvra TT/S rvpavvibos oiiOlv rJTTov rJTrep e/cet^os
8tK(Sy, aTtCKTeive Tov fpcKTTrjv as Tvpavvos T Kal
avrjp farofAfvos' Karaa-^Mv 5e rpei? -^ rerrapa? ?;/>ie'pas rr)y e

yap ov/c aAAcoy aKrjKoajaey, aAA' avrol Trapoires ot8a/xei'

o-rpar?]yias Tri6vfj<ri(ravTS r/8i) Kai ruxoVres avr?J? ot 142
ert Kat rw tpvydbes rijcrbf Trjs Tro'Aecos eiVty, ol 8e
^3toy eTeXfVTrj(rav ol 8e aptcrra SoKoDire? aiiT&v Trpar8ta TroAAwy Kivbvvtev e\66vTs KOL cpofiatv ov ^ovov
tv ravTTi rry arparrjyta, dAA' eirei et? T?V eavraiy Karfj\6ov, 5
1)770

T(3z;

CTVKOffraVT&V

TTO\

eAarrco r^y -UTTO r<Sz> iroAe/Atcoy StereAecray, ojore erio

avrStv fv^ecrOai. doTjoarrjy?jroi;s et^at //aAAof 17 eorparTjyr}Kfvai.
d fjfv ovv rjcrav ol Kivbvvoi re Kat Troyot ^e'po^res b
eis a></>eAeicw, e?^ey ay rtz^a Ao'yor* zn;y 8e
vavTLOV. typr/atis 8e Kat Trept TCKVCW TOV avrov
va[j,vovs Tivas tfor] yevfo-Oai Kal ye^op,era>y ets
re Kal AWTTO? ras /ueytoras Karacrrdi'Tas. ot /^ey yap 5
OVTU>V
oe yjpYjvaiJLtvutv wore crTfprjdrjvai, Kat rovrous c
ets eAarrofas 8uaruxt/as Kafleorrj/coVas
/cat jSouAojue'^ovs ay dyeyj]Ta fxaAAoy etrat
dAA' ojucas TOVTMV Te Kat erepcor iroAAwy op.oiorpO'Trcoy rovrot? ovra) o-0o8joa KaraS^Acoy OVTMV, cnrdviov fvpetv OCTTIS 5
d-4 irpdj-avrfs B T : 7rpa|oyTes recc.
6 4 ofSa/tev]tfSofjievHirschig
&5 rauTj;] OUT?} Dobree (Ficinus)
a6 iro\iopKiav recc. : jroA.iop/cio B T
1)2 eTxev] elxoy Cobet
03 /coJT: om. B

I42C

DAATHNO2

av ?) bibojAfvaiv cnrocr-^oLTO r] /zeAAo>j> Si' ev^rjs

iravcraiTo &y evxo/xeyos1 ol be -TroAAot ovre ay rvpavvibos
StSojueyrjs dirocrxoiyro ay ovre orparrjyias ov8' Irepwy
d ToAAwy, a irapoVra /3Aa7jrei /^aAAoy r) a><peAer, dAAa Kay
evai.VTo ay yeyeerflat, d rw /x^ TrapoVra rvyxdvei' oAtyoy
8e eTrtcrxoyres eytore 7raAtya)8oi5(rty, avfv\6^fvoi
arr' ay
ro irp&Tov vu>vTai. eya) /xey oSy airopat jar) a>s a\r]0u>s
deovs avOpairoi. o t r i w y r a i , e Ixeiycoy <a/ueyoi
(r<f)i(ri.v elvai' ol 8e (cat a v r o t cr<^TJ(rti> etre araetre a<ppocrvvai$ \pr] enreiy, virep popov
e aAye' ex ol)(rl< Kivdvvevei. yovv, S 'AAxt/StaSrj,
rt? etyat e/cetyos 6 iroinrTj?, 6s 8o/cei /xoi <^>iAots
ritrl x/ar/o-ajueyoj, opwy avrov? /cai Trpdrrovras KCU
fj.vovs cforep ov fitAriov TJV, eKeiyot? 8e e8oKet, KOIVTJ
5 airdvTwv avr&v ev-^v Trotijtrao-^af Aeyet 5e TTCOS w
143

Zeu j3acri\v, ra /ixev eo-^Aa, ^)r;art, Kat

Kal avevKTOis

e/xot /ley oSy KaAws Soxei xat d(r<aA<3s Aeyeiy o

5 irotr/TijS" cru 8' et rt ey y<S e^ets Trpos ravra, /x^ ortwTra.
AA. XaAeTToi', S SwKpares, eortz; dz^rtAeyeiy Trpos ra
KaA<3s flprj/jLtva.' e/ceiyo 8' owy evvoG>, o<ra)z> KCLK&V atria ~q
ayvoia rols avOp&irois, OTro're, <y? eot/ce,
b avrois 8ta Tavrrjv Kal Trparroires1 Kat ro ye
77/xty avrols ra KaKtcrra. onfp owy ovSets1 ay
dAAa rowro ye Tray ay o^otro kayos etyat, avros avrai ra
/3e'Art(rra eva<r0ai, dAA' ov ra KaKurra, rovro juey yar
5 a>s dA?7#<3s Kardpa rtyt dAA' OVK ev^T) opiotoy ay et?7.
c6 pf\\ii>jf B : fie\\ov T
c8 ouS'] oSd' Bekker
d
tpSovffiv T: irdKiv bSovtriv B
avev%6iJLevoi T : &> ev\6fnevot E
d 6 auTolff(f>rj<nvrec. t : auroistyrja'lvB : aurol fffyiaiv T
d 7 a^>poffvvais T : a</>popianp B : a.fypa$iai<Tiv Hermann
e i yowr B : -yaf
T
as 5eAa Buttmann : Seiva BT : \vypa Proclus (cf. 148 b, 6)
a 4 KeAevei seel. KOppen
a 7 o<r<av KO.KWV corn Coisl. : '6ffov Kcucbv
BT
b 2 &j/ add. Priscianus : om. B T
b 3 lieavbs B : IKO.VWS T

A A K I B I A A H 2 AETTEPO2

1430

212. 'AAA' urcos, S> /Se'Artore, <f>air) av TLS avrip, os

fjiov re /ecu crov (rcxptoTepos u>v rvyyjavoi, OVK. opd&s rjpas
Ae'yety, ovruts eiK?] \fse-yovTas ayvoiav, el ye /XT) 7r/>oo-0ar7jiiey c
TT]V

<TTLV

(Sy T

ayi'OiaV

K.OLL <TTIV

ols

ayadov, &tnrep fKeivois KO.KQV.

A A. TIcos Aeyeis; eort ya/t OTLOVV
O7rco(roiiy fyovTL afjifivov ayvotiv r]

KCU

Trpay/xa ora>

AA. Ov jj,evTOL jjia Ata.

212. 'AAAa fj.T]i> ovbe tKetfo crov /carayycotro/xat,
ay (re irpos r^y eauroS jurjrepa 8ta7re7rpax^ai aire/) '
^)ao-t Kai ror 'AX/cjuecova Kat et 8?/ riyes aAA.ot exeiVoiy
ruy^ayot)^ TCLVTCL biaTreirpayfJifvot.
AA. Ev0^ju.ei Trpos Atos, 2wKpaTes.
212. Ovrot roi> Aeyoyra, 'AAKt/3ta8r;, w? OVK ciz> e^eAois
trot raura Trfirpa^Oai,, fixprjfjifiv
8ei (re KeAevety, dAAa
TroAv, et ri? ra fvavria Aeyoi, eTreiSr) oura) (rot
<T(f)6bpa bfivov etwi TO irpay^-a, <2<rr' O'ySe prjTfov
etrat ovVw? etKrj.
8oKe?s 8' ay roy 'Ope'crr^y, et fTvy\av
(f>p6vifj,os
a>y /cat ei8a)S on /3e'ATtcrroy ^y awoi Trparretr,
roA//,?7<rai ay rt rovra>y 8ta7rpa^ao-0at;
AA. Ov 8^ra.
212. OvSe ye aAAoy ot/ixat ovbfva.
AA. Ov jue'yrot.
212. Ka/coy apa, a>s eotxey, eorty ^ rou
ayyota /cat ro dyyoety ro ^QeArtcrroy.
A A. "Ejuotye Soxet.
212. OVKOW Kat eKetyw KOI ro?? aAAots aTratrty;
AA. 4>r/fxt.
212. v Ert TOIVVV KOI ro8e eTTKrKeicdLie^a* et croi
c
"b 7 Tvyx^voi Stephanas : -rwyx^1'6' ^ T
4 ^T^
Sry Se? B T
C 9 &/ 1 : eciv B T
ire] <roj Cobet
B T : <rai/Tou al.
d 3 f'fle'Aots T: efleAoi B
d
(S^) Buttmann : firetra Stallbaum
d 7 6' &)/ B T : 5&j/ Schanz

e 8 firi(TKe\l/ct>iu.f0a recc. : firurKf\l/6/j.Oa

BT

10
d

10
e

i486

F1AAT&NO2

7rape<rrat?7, olr]0evri fieXnov etvat, fTepi/cAea rbv

10 aeavTov liriTpOTrov re Kal tyiXov, eyy^ipibiov Aa/3oWa,
144 fXOovra em TCLS Qvpas, et7reu> ei tvoov eori, f3ovX6jj.vov
aTTOKTttvcu avTov fKflvov, aXX.ov 8e fj-rjbfvaot be (])(UV
evbov ctvai Kat ov Aeyco tOtXeiv av (re TOVTMV TL irpdrTfiv
d\A' ei, oi/zai, 8o^et aoi, oTrep ov^ey KcoXvti brjTTov TW ye
5 ayvoovvri TO /3eArtcrroy Trapao-rfjvaC
Trore $6av, cocrre
Kal TO Kama-Tow Trore ySeArtcrroy etraf 17 OVK ^y
croi;
AA. Flam; /xey oSy.
212. Ei ovv T:apt\.0u>v eicrco /cat t8a>z; avrbv fK.ei.vov
b ayroijo-ats re Kal oirjOeiris av aXXov etvai nva, ap ert civ
avTov roA./u?/crais aTroKTrfvai;
AA. Ow ji/,a TOV Aia, ov/c ai' /xot 8o/c<S.
212. Ov yap S^TTOU TOV evTv^ovTa, dAA' avrbv fKtivov
5 oi> fiftovXov.
TI yap;
AA. Nat'.
212. OWKOIW Kal ei TroXAaKts ey^etpor?, aiet 8e ayvodis
TOV ITepiKAe'a, o-jroVe jueAAots rouro Trparret^, oi/Trore ay
AA. Ov 8?7ra.
212. Tt 8e; roy 'OpeVrrjy 8oKe? av irore rr)
e7rt0e0"$at, el ye axravrcos fiyvorjcrev;
AA. OVK ol/^at eycoye.
212. Ov yap 8777701; ov8' e/caVo? r^i' Trpo(rrv\ov(Tav yvva'iK.a ovbe rr)y orouow /xjjrepa Stez/oerro aisoKTeivai, dAAa
r^y avros a75roS.
AA. "Eon raura.
212. 'Ayyoeiz; apa rd ye rotawra /3e'Arioy rots
/cat rotavra? 8 d a
e 9 vapvrra(i\ B T : ira.pa.ffTa.ii) t
a 3 c seel. Sauppe
a 4 5^t
B T : 8<fc(6 Buttmann
b i &r seel. Struve
b 3 OVK &v /not
SOKCO T : om. B
b 5 v seel. Schleiermacher
b 12 -ye T :

A A K I B I A A H 2 AETTEPOS

1440

AA.
212. 'Opas ovv on rj I-O-TIV &v re ayvoia /cat ecrriv ols KCU
i mo? ayaQov, dAA' ov KCLKOV, ooo-Trep apri voi e8oKei; 10
AA. "EoiKtv.
212. "En TOIVVV et fiovXei TO jnera rowo fTncrKOTTflv, d
CLTOTTOV

O.V to-0)S CLV

<TOL

AA. Ti //aA.60ra, a>

211. "On, a>s CTTOS diTtiv, Kivftwevei TO ye rwy
kav TIS avfv TOV /3eA.rfcrrou /ceKTTj/xeVos
eA.eu', (3\aiTTiv 8e ra irXetft) Tor e\ovra
aiiro. (TKOTTfi 8e c58e. ap' OVK drayKaToV croi o"o/cet etyat,
OTay TI /xeAXw/^ey ^TOI TTpdrTew rj Ae'yetz^, olijdrjvai beiv
TrpGtrov rjfj.as eiSeVai ^ TO> wrt etSerat roi;0' o av -npoytipoTepcoy jue'A-Aco/jiey ^ Ae'yeiz; 17 irpaTTeiv;
AA. vEju.otye 8o/ceu
212. OVKOW ot p7jTo/>e9 aurt/ca ^TO{ eiSoVes (rvufiovtevfiv
77 otrj^e'rTe? dbevai vv}j.flov\VQV(nv rjfuv e/caoroTe, ol fiey
irept iroXe'jLiou re KCU etpTj^r;?, ot 8e Trept Tet^wy oiKo8ojuias
^ /cat \ifj.fvu>v KaracTKfvrjs' fvl oe Ao'ya), ocra 877 Trore ^
7ro'A.ts Trparrei TT/SOS aXXrjv TTO\IV rj avrr] KO^' avrTjv, OTTO
r?)s rwr prjropcoi' cruja/SouA?}? Trayra yiyrerat.
AA. 'AAr]^ Xeyet?.
212. f/0pa roivvv KCU ra em ro^roty.
AA. *Ay 8wr/^w.
212. KaAeis yap 8777:0^ typovLfjiovs TC Kal atypovas;
AA. vEya>ye.
212. OvKouy TOI)S /u.ei' TroAAovs cuppovas, TOVS 8' oAtyous
C 9 re B : -ye T
d 2 &(/ ^crax ^j/ B : Si/ fcrws Sv T :
Schanz
d.5 roD] T?JS TOU Dobree
d.6 ^] ^ pr. B : ^i/ pr. T
d 7 airrrf Schneider : avrd B T
d. 8 /ie'AXwjuej/ T : /te'AAwi' ^.ev B
B : -^ otTj0^vat T
Sew] Si] Dobree
d 9 Trpoxeiporepas]
as Sauppe
e i /ueAAaytei/ B : jueAAw^teV rt T
63 tru^tT : vfj.@ov\vovffiv B
e 4 ^ T : om. B
e 6 ^ /col T :
f) B
as TravTa T : aTfavra B

5
145

ITAATJiNOS
10

AA. OvTtos.
211. OVKOVV rrpos n d7ro/3AeV&)z> d/>orepous;
AA. Nai.

2X1. *Ap ovv TOV TOIOVTOV o-vju/3ouAeve> eiSo'ra, x.(pls

TOV TioTfpov /3eArioz> Kal ore fif \TIOV, (ppovijjiov jcaAeis;
AA. Ov 8^ra.

212. Ove ye oi/wu ocrns ro 7roAe/>t,eu> avro o78e x^P^5

5 rou OTrore fiehriov KOL roaomov \povov ocrov
fithriov.
TI

yap;

AA. Nai.
211. OvKoSr ov8e et TIS rwa aTTOKTfivvvai oldev ovde
X/>7)uara a<patpi<r6ai Kal (f>vydba TTOICIV rfjs Ttarptbos, \apls
10 rou oirore fi\Tiov Kal OVTWO. ^SeArtov;
AA. Ov pevToi.
C

211. "Ocrrts1 ^pa ri rw^ TOLOVTCDV otbev, eay //.ey irap^TT^rat

avra) ^ rou /3eArio-rou eTrto-rrj/xr; avrij 8' ^y ^ avr^ 8777701;

?ji7re/> xa^ r; rou 0eA.fiorr ^ yp/

AA. Nai'.
5
2H. ^povijj.6v 8e ye avrbv ^rjtronfv KOI aTfo^pGt
/3ouAoy Kai rf) Tro'Aei /cat avTov avroi' roy 8e JUT)
rdravriia TOVTO>V.
r/ TTWS 8oKei;
AA. 'Ejuoi ftey ovrcos.
2H. Tt 8' rts iTTTreweti' ^ To^etieiv otbev, rj av TTV10 Kreuetz' rj TraAatetv ^ ri r^? 6:AAr;s dyco^ias r/ /cai aAAo rt
d rc3y TOIOVTMV ova re^vr/ olSajiiez/, r^ KaAet1? 6s civ ei8r/ ro

Kara Tavrrjv Tr\v rtyviqv ySeArtof yiyvo^vov; ap' ov roy

Kara r?)y iTTTrtx^v ITTTTLKOV;
AA. "Eycoye.
5
2H. Tov 8e ye oi/uat Kara TTJV TrvKTiK.r]v TWKTIKOV, TOV
b 3 8re corr. Ven. 184 : Sye t: S E T : djnfo-e Baiter
c
B : om. T
C 5 Se 7^] re ye Sauppe
C 6 ai rp TroXet ol avrbv
avrif B : /col avrbv avrcp Kal TTJ WXet T
roiovrov J. G. Schneider :
voiovvra B T
09 iruKTW6/ ^ traKaieiv B : 7ro\^(i' ^ 7rwicTj5ej' T
d i reyvri T : fi-)(yi\v B
da KTO ravrrjv] /car' aur^ Apelt : KOTO

Schanz '

5p' T : om. B

A A K I B I A A H 2 AETTEPO2
8e K.ar avArjriKTjp av\.r]TiK.6v, /cat T&AAa 8777701; ava \6yov

rj aAAa>s Trias;
AA. Ov/c, aAA' OVTCOS.
S!2. Ao/ce? ovv <rot avayKaiov elvai TOV Trcpl TOVTWV TL
ovra apa /cat avbpa (ppovipov eivai, 77 TroAAoO 10
evbelv;
e
AA.

IToAAot; /xeuroi vrj Aia.

211. ITotar ovv otet ^oAtreiay eiyai TOOT&V re aya6G>v

Kal avXrjT&v, In 8e /cai d^ATjreSr re Ka6 rwr aAAcop rex^trwy, dva/zejaety)ueV<ov 6' eu rcT;rots o^s apri flp-^Ka/JifV

T&V 5

re avro TO TroAe/neri' eiSo'rcov /cat avro TO airoKTeivvvai, Trpbs

8e Kat avbp&v

prjTopLK&v

TroXiriKov

(pvcrrjua

(pvcruvroiv,

8e TOVTCO^ OVTU>V avev rrjs TOV ySeATtcrTou eTTio-T?jKOL

TOV

eloOTOS,

O7TOT6

fitA.TlOV

kvl

1/CaCTTO)

TOVTWy

/cat irpos Ttva;

146

AA. 4>avA?]y TLVO. eywye, S ScoKpaTey.

212. cfaujs ye az^ ot/^at OTTOTUV 6pu>r]s eva fnacrTOv avT&v

Te Kal V^OVTO. TO TrAeierTOV Trjs TroAtTetas
TOVTO)
avTOU Tvy)(ayet KpancrTOs w
Aeyco 8e TO KOT' avTrjv TJ]V

T\vrjv /3e'ATtaroz;

TOV be Tr} TroAei Te Kal avrbv avT& fieXTicrTOV OVTOS TO.

TroAAa 8irj/bta/OT7joVa, aTe o?juat avev vov 80^77 TreTTicrTeuKOTa.
ovrwy be TOVTMV tyovTuv, apa OVK av opO&s Aeyot/xey b
(pdvTfs

TroAArjs Tapaxfjs

Te Kai ayo/xtas /jteo-Tr/i' etrai T?)y

Toiavrr\v
d.6 ai TOA.AO B : al /car' S\AT
dg Trepl seel. Cobet
rt T:
om. B
d 10 firiffTiifjiova
T : firiffr^fj-ova. elvai B
ipa] a/ia
Cobet
e i ^j/Setc] 8e?i' Baiter
e 4 5e icol T Stobaeus : Se B
re Kal T Stobaeus : Kal B
e 5 S' B T : om. Stobaeus
Tot5ror
Stobaeus : TOIOVTOM B T
o&s (vel Sv) Dobree : ofs B T Stobaeus
e 7 priToptKwv B : iroAiTt/caii/ T
a 2 rtpa B : om. T
a 3 fva T :
Iva al B
a 6 ru7x<i't in Gorgia 484 e T : rvyx^V hie B T in
Gorgia loc. cit. B : "rvyxjivoi ci. Hermann
Kpdriffros^
Gorg. loc. cit.
a 8 faros recc. : O&TQJS B T

I46b
5

10
C

10

TIAAT12NO2
AA. 'OpO&s PCVTOI vrj A to.
212. OVKOVV avayKatov rifj.lv eSoKei olr)dfjvai belv irp&TOV rifjias eiSeyat 77 r<3 OVTL ei'Seyai TOVTO b av 7rpox.ip<os
jmeAAco/x.ei> 17 irparreiy r) Aeyeiy;
AA. 'ESoKei.
212. OVKOVV /cay i&v TTparrrj a TLS olbev r/ bonel dbevai,
7rape7rr/rat 8e TO &x/)eAt/^cos, /cai AucriTeAowrcos i7fxas eety
Kat rrj iro'Aet Kat avrbv cwr<3;
AA. rici)? yap 01!;
2fi. 'Eav 8e y' o?//at ravavria TOVTOIV, ovre rrj iroAei
ovr* avTov avrw;
AA. Ow 87)ra.
212. Ti 8e; /cat in;!* ert wo-avrcos crot boKfl r) aAAws TTCOS;
AA. OVK, dAA' ovrcos.
211. ?Ap' ovv (j)r](r6a /caAeiy Toi9 /^ey TroAAow atypovas,
TOVS 8' oAiyous </>poz>ijWOi>s;
AA. "Eywye.
212. OuKouy (pa^fv uciAir rous iroAAovs 8i?jju,aprrjKeVat
roS /3eAr^<rroi;, ws ra TroAAci ye ot/u,at aveu z'oi; 80^77 ire-

AA. ^a/xey yap.

212. AimreAet apa 70?? TroAAoi? /xjjr' dbfvat nqbe
olecrOat, elbevai, e?7rep ye fiaAXoi' TrpodvprfcrovTai Tr
/xe^ raura arr' ay db&crLV r/ olrjdSxnv eiSevai, Trparroires
5 8e fiXaTTTfa-Qai ra irAeuo /xaAAoy ^ ax^eAeio-^ai.
AA. 'AATjtfeorara Aeyet?.
212. 'Opa? ovy, ore y' e^y KtySu^evety ro ye r<Sy aAAcoy
C e7rtoT7jju,z/ KTT7//,a, ear ris ayeu r^s ro jSeArio-roi; fTTto-T^iJirjs
KCKTrjpzvos rj, oAiya/as jt/,ey w^eAe^, ^SAairreiy 8e ra TrAeico
roy e^oyra avro, ap' o^xt TM wrt 6pOG>s
b 5 ^tv '8<fo B : ^8({/ci ^?j/ efrai T

b g ^ T r ^ & B t ^ a b

b 10 irapeirrjrot B : vapeverai T
8e T : om. B
d 3 vpdrrfiv
fiiv B : juey irpdrTfiv T
d 7 Sre 7' T : gre B : #T' Stobaeus
Stobaeus : KivSvveva B T
e 2 6\iyd.Kis] o\iya Cobet

A A K I B I A A H 2 AEYTEPO2

1466

AA. Kat d p-j) roYe, dAAa vvv fJioi boKfl, a> 2w/cpares.
212. Aei apa KCU 7ro'Atj> Kat tyvyyv TTJV p.4Xkovcrav opd&s
/3i&>o"eo-0ai TavTrjS TTJS emcm/juT;? dn-e'xecr0ai, arenas
uxnrcp aa-Oevovvra larpov *] rivos Kvfipvr)TOv TQV dcr^aAws
f/,e'AAoz>ra irAeii>. avev -yap ravTrjs, oVwTrep av Aa/iTrporepov CTTOvpioy TO rrjs Tv^rjs y Tifpl xPrl^TU>v KTrjcriv rj
ro5//,aroy pwyixrji' 77 Kat aAAo rt ry TOIOVTOIV, rocrovrto
d)uapr7j//.ara aTr' COT<Z> avaytunov eorty, ws eotxe,
6 8e 8^ T?)Z/ K.a\ov^vt]v -noXv^aOiav re Kat irokvTtyviav
6p(pavbs 8e wr TCWTTJS r^s fTnor^fJirjs,
ayo8e VTTO /xtas eKa<TT77s rcoy aAAaw, ap' ov^t rw dirt
TroAAw ^et/xaJyt ^prjcr^T<u, are o?/x,at a^eu KvfBfpvrjrov
ireAayet, \povov ov juaxpoy /3iou 64u>v; &CTTC
[J.OL boKfl /cat tvTavda TO TOV iroiTjrou, o Aeyet
TTOW TWOS, ws apa -TroAAa /xev ^TTtcrraro
epya, KCIK&S 8e, (prfa-Cv, ^Trierraro Trd^ra.
AA. Kat rt 877 Trore (ruju,/3atVet ro roii Trotryrou, cb 2wKpare?; e/xot ju.ez' yap 0^8' ortouv Soxet irpos Aoyoz/
212. Kat /xaAa ye Trpos Ao'yoy dAA' atVtrrerat, S
rtcrre, Kat ovros Kat aAAot 8e Troi^rat <rxe8oV rt Tr
l(rrty re yap (pvcrti Trot?jrtK^ ^7 (rvfjuraaa atvty/xarwS?]? Kat
ov roS TrpO(TTV\ovTOS avopbs yi/coptcraf ert re irpos rw
^>wet ToiavTrj etyat, oray Ad^Srjrat avbpbs tyOovepov re Kat
pir) (3ov\ofj,evov rip.lv evoeiKWcrdai dAA' avoKpvTiTecrdaL OTI,
J a-yroC (roifyiav* virep(j)v&s d?) ro
<f)aivTa,i., ort Trore voovcriv fKcurrgs

5
147

e 3 So/cet] So/cejs Sauppe

a i ^f ev y^p ravtis hue transposu,it
Lennep : ante /) irepl ~x_prn>.aTaiv habent B T
\afnirporepov Lennep :
\aftp6fepov Sauppe : /j,^ irprfrepoj/ B T
as eirovpta'p T : iirovp^ffy B;
rv^s ci. Stallbaum : i|/u^^s B; T
Si 4 a/tapT^^aTa T : o/xaprr;a
B
&5 no\vfjLa.Qia.v T : (j>i\o/jiaOia.v B
iroA.wTexj'fai' B : ^xAoT6X"'>'
T
b i jStou Stephanus : j8io' B T
0eW Stephanus :flecm/B :
flewv T : v\fiev Schanz
b 8 SAA.OJ scripsi : &\\oi B : ot &\\oi T
C i re B : 5e T
02 TOIUVTI) T : Toia.irri]v B
04 5^J T : 5? B,
0 5 voovaiv T : vof.'.ifTo.i B

PLATO, voj.. II.

34

147 c

148

OAATllNOS
ov yap OT^TTOV "OjurjpoV ye TOV Ofiorarov re KOI
jv ayvoelv OOK&S o>y ov\ olov re TJV em'crracrflai
vos yap eariy 6 Aeycuu TOV Mapytrrji/ TroAAa
/xey e7rt(rra<r0at, Ka/cc5s 8e, c/>J7<n, TrdWa ijTrtorarodAA'
aiytrrerai ot/xat Trapdywv TO /ca/c<3s /^ei> dirt row KaKov, TO
8e rjTrio-TaTO avTi TOV zirCcrTacrOai' yiyverai ovv
lco juez> rou /uterpou, l<rrt 5' o ye /3ovA.erat, <u
TjTTioraro epya, Kaxoy 8' rjv fTtLCTTaa-OaL avrw Travra raura.
fiijXov ovv on eiirep fjv avrw Kaxoy ro 7roAA.a eideWl,
n? a>y Tvy\avev, etTrep ye irto'reveiy 6ei ro?s
i.s Aoyoiy.
AA. 'AXA.' e/mot /ixey SoKeT, S SwKparey 7^ )(aAe7rcSs y'
ay aAAots ria-i Trto-ret/o-atjui Ao'yoi?, etirep fATj5e rovroty.
212. Kat op^ws ye <roi SoKeu
A A. rTaAty aS /AOI Soxet.
2H. 'AAAa <epe Trpbs Aiosopos yap 8177:01; rfjv airopCav
oo-t] re mi o?a, TavTrjs be /ecu (rv /AOI SoKer? KtKot.va>vr)Kcvai.'
ju,era/3aAAo/^ez>os ye rot Syoo xat Karw ow8' ortow wavy,
dAA' ort ay juaAtcrra crot 8o^rj, rowro /cat eK8e8i)KeVai av
Kat ovKfTL wo-avro)? Sojcety et ovv crot y' ert Kat vvv
fj,<pavr]s yevopfvos 6 0eos irpoy ov rvy^avfis
epcori/o-eie, trplv OTIOVV efi^acrOai o~e, et e^apKeVet crot e
rt yei>ecr0ai wvTrep Kat ey dpxj? eAeyero, eire Kat avrw o-ot
eTTtrpe'x/^etev vao-0aL, rt ?ror' az> otet ?/ rwy Trap' CKCIVOV
8t8o/xeya)y Aa/x/3dycoy 77 avros evd/xei>os yereo-^at rou
Katpov TV^flv;
AA. 'AAAa //a rov? QCOT/JS, eya> )mey ov^er ar exoi/xt crot
, ai 2<wKpare?, o^rcos' dAAa p.dpyov ri /itoi 8oKet etrat,
C 7 cos B : efrt T
C 8 KOK&S B : KaXws T
napyiryv T :
uapytirriy B
d i ^7rf(TTOTo Bekker : ftrlffratrBai B T
d 2 KaKov]
Ka Jr Cobet
d 3 ^vicrraro B : eirlffTaro T
d 4 8 76 corr.
Par. 1812 : Sre B : SrtT
d-y SeiT : Seo* B
e 6 8e T : Si,
B
/col ffi5 /not SoKf'is B : jitoi SoKeTs KoJ ffw T
e 8 Sri B : Sirep T
T1
a 3 tapice<rei T : ea/>Ke<reie B
a 4 apxp T : opxp
B
efrc
teal T : /cal B
a 9 fidpyov T : ft.a.py&v B : /ueya epyov Dobree

A A K I B I A A H 2 AETTEPO2

i48b

KOI (as aXrjO&s iroXXrjs (pvXaKrjs, OTTCO? fj-rj A?/<m TLS avrov b
e Ta.ya.Qa, eTreir' okiyov iricr%(&v,
a.VV)(O^VOS
TtpTOV

&TT

O.V

TO

vr)TO.t.

212. *Ap' oiiv oi>xl db(f>$ TL TT\ZOV rj^&v o troirjTrjs, ov 5

KCW tv apxf) TOV Xoyov (ireiJivtfa'Oriv, ra SeiAa KCU
AA.
212. Tovrov /uef roivvv, w 'AA/a/3ia8i7, Kat
/uortot roy TToiijTrjv e^ijAfOKore?, etre at cwrtH ovrw? 67reKdl Idiq Kal brj/jiocriq e/cdcrrore
i, ra KaAa em roiy dya^o?s roi
av (rfftfoiv avrols" TrAetco 8' ovSety
aKova-fifv.
roiyapovv els TO TrapfJKOV TOV \povov
rJTTov evTV'^f'iS tlcrw avOpanroi' et 8' apa /cat o-yjuavrols wcrre ju^ Travra vrv\eli>, dAA' ovy (ov) 86a
Kiv(ov evyjiv, eiri TOLS deo'cs 8' fcrrlv coore oijuat Kat
&TT' ai> TLS ev^ofjievos Tvyy&vt] KCU TavavTia TOVT&V.
8e (roi Kal eTfpov n birjyrjaracrOai., 6 Trore rjK.ov(ra
[T&V irpfa-flvTepatv] TIV&V, wy 'AOqvalois Kal Aa/ce8cu//o/nois
dia(j)opas yevofj.fvrjs o-vvtficuvev det TTJ TroAei ^juwy a><rre
KOI Kara y^y /cat Kara OaXaTTav OTroVe /^a^ ye^otro
8v(rru}(f^ Ka' jUTjSeTrore bvvao-0ai KpaTrj<rai' TOVS ovv 'Adrjvaiovs ayavaKTovvTas rS Trpay^an KCU cnropovnevovs rlvi
\prf [j,rj\avfj T&V TrapovTcov KaK&v aTTOTpoTrrjV tvptiv, /3ovavTots boKftv KPO.TLCTTOV flvai 7reju\/^afras
b I A.^o-61 Buttmann : A^ffj? B T
b 2 TO ayaOa B : aya$ct T
b 3 irah.ivcpSf'i a.vewx6[jLvos t : ira.\iv<ffiiav ev^fievos B T
TT' ta> B :
otTTa T
b 5 ir\6oi/ B : Tr\eicat> T
b 6 SeiAa Buttmann :
Secret T : Sfj\a B
b 8 e/iorye B : eyitol /tev TOI T
Tb 9 Ao/fe5aifJ.6ftoi B : \aKeSat/J.6vwi ol T
C 2 /cal t'Sict T : /Sios B
04 a5]
del Buttmann
ir\flca scripsi : wAeiW B : irAeroi' T
C 6 ovSevuv
T : owSei' we B
C 7 ou add. corr. Laur. Ixxxv. 6
d i ^So-re
olfnai B : oT/j.ai Strre T
d. 4 TCOJ/ irpffffivrepoiv
seclusi : TaJv
irpearfJuTepuv ij TIVWV B : irpeff^vrepcav Tiviev T : TWP itpffffivrfpav
nvbs
Cobet
d 6 5Wre B : dxtrkv T

I48e

149

5
C

I1AATJ2NOS
eirepoorazr eu 8e irpbs TOVTOI.S ra8e, [KOI]
avff1 OTOV TTOTf AaKe8ai/xoz>tois ot 0eot paXXov VIKT\V biboacnv
T/ <r<f)icriv avrofc, (A irAetaras, <f>avai, //,ei> OvtrCas Kal KaAXicrras rwf 'EAATyrcoy ayoptv, avaOrj^aa-i re KeKoo-pj/ca/x.ei'
ra lepa avrStv a>? ovSeVes aAAot, TTO^TTO-S re TroAvreAeardras
Kat o-e/u,yorara9 e8a)pO7;jU,e0a roi? ^eo?? ar' ZKCLO-TOV ero?, KCU
ereAoC/Mey ^p^^ara oaa ov5' aAAot (rw/nrarres "EAArjrey
^>avat, -ovSeTrtriTror' k^Kri<rfv ovbtv rov, dAA' ovrco? dAtywjocos (kaKeitrai Trpos rovs ^eov?, ware
/eat avdirrjpa Ovovcrw eKaorore Kat raAAa Trai^ra OVK dAtyw
ei>8ee<rrepa>s rtjawcrtr ^Trep r/fJ-^s, \p^fJ.aTa ovbev eAarra)
KC/CTTj/xewi T?/? ^jaerepa? Tro'Aetos. eiret 81) flpr]Kvai, raura
/cat TTpu>T?j(rai TI )(pi) TrpaTTOvras avrovs T&V Trapovrcov
KCIK&V cnraXkayriv evpeiv, dAAo /u,ey ov^ey ttiroKpi^rJvai roi>
Trpo(priTi]V rov yap 0eoy ov/c eay S^Ao^ ort KaAecra^ra 8e
avrov, 'Aflrj^atots, (pavai, rdSe Aeyet "A^)U(oy <pr)(rlv av
/3owAeo"^at avrw rrjy AaKeSai/uoyuoy V(pr]fjiCav flvai //.aAAov
77 ra (rvnTravTa T&V 'EAA^vcoy iepd. roo-awra
irepairepw. njy y' oSr ev<p?7/ixt'ay OIIK aAA^y rtrd />iot
Aeyecz; 6 $eo? T) r^y tvyj]V avrQv IOTI yap roi oi'n
$ia(pzpova-a T>V aAAcoy. ot />tey yap aAAot r/EAAijyes ot
fiey j(pucro/cepa)s ^SoSs Trapacrrrjcra/xei'oi, e'repot 8' a
b(opov[j.vot TOVS Qeovs, fv^ovTai arr' ay rv^
dya^a ayre /caKa' jB\acr(f)r^j,ovvTu>v ovv avrS>v CLKOVOVTCS ot
0eot OVK aTroSex.0^1"0" T"^? TroAureAets rairacri Tro/ATrds re
/cat dvcrias. dAAa SoKe? /^ot TroAA^s <fev\aKr]s bfia-Oat KCU
(TKex/feco? OTI Trore prjreor eort Kal fx?].
63 eri T : rt B
rc&e Cobet : raS et Kal B : TciSe /cal T : al
raSe Stallbaum
e 4 irore T : om. B
65 auroTs seel. Cobet
e 6 ava6^fj.a.ffi T : avaBe/nairt B
a i SAA.OJ scrips! : &\\oi B : of
&\\oi T
a 4 o\i'70) t : o\i7&)S B T
a 5 tfirep recc. ; ^ etirep B T
"XpilHOLTa. ovftev eAoTTW B : ouSfj' ^Actrrw xP^IILia'ra T
^^ eVeiS^r
B : eVei T : eVel 8' Schanz
a 7 al B : re Kal T
b 2 adrivatois
fyavai T : <pavai a.8i)va.iois <f>dvai B : 'Adyvaiovs (fxivai Hemsterhuis
bs -yoCv BT: 8' ovv Sauppe
b6 (TTJ T : ert B
C$ rauraffi
B : ravras T

A A K I B I A A H 2 AETTEPO2

149 c

Evp?jcreis 8e /cai Trap' 'OjUTjpoo erepa irapairATjo-ta roimns

(p-qcrlv -yap TOVS Tpeoas eTrauAty Troiovp,ei>ovs
d
io-t TeArjeorcras eKaro'/^/Sas'
rrjy 5e Kyio-ay e/c ro{5 ireStou rows dyejutovs <pepetz>
ovpavov eio-&>
TTJS 8' ov TI 0eovs /xa/capa? Sareetr^at,
/xaXa yap
KOI ITpia/xo? >cai Xao? 6u/x/xeAuo rTptaptoio-

wore ov8ey avrois r\v irpovpyov 6veiv re KCU

/^aTTji', ^eoi? a7rrj-)(0riiJi,Vov$.
ov yap oi/xai TOIOUTW eori
ro rwy 06SP (Sore VTTO ba>pu>v TtapayecrBai olov KO.KOV
aXXa Kal ^et? fyr/dri Xoyov Aeyo/uez^, a^iovvres 5
i'tcoir ravrr] Trepielyat.
Kal yap ay Seiyoy eirj et
Trpos ra Saipa Kat ras Puerto? aTrofiXtTtovcnv r?ju,<3z> ot ^eot
aAAa jn^ irpos rrjy ^u^^j ^ TIS ocrtos /cat Suaios coy
ruyx^dyi]. TroAAw ye paXXov ol/xai ^ Trpos ras -jroXvreAeTs
ravras Tro/XTrds re /cat ^v<rtas, as oiibtv KcoA^et TroAAa fxey
ets #eovs, iroAAa 8' et? avOp&Trovs ?7fAapr?7Koras Kat i8tcoTi}v
Kat TToAty %iv dv' Ka<TTOV eros reAeZy ot 8e', are ov
8copo8o/co6 oyres, Karatppovovanv aiiavTutv rot^rcoy, cos fyrjcriv
6 ^eos Kat 0eooy Trpo^Tjrrjs.
Ktr8uyevet yow Kat Trapa
Kal Trap' avOputTrois rots yow exono-t StKatocrwi] re
p6vT(s rert/x7j(r0af ^poVtjuot 8e Kat
OVK ciAAoi rtyes eto-ty [r)] rcov et8ortoy a Set Trpdrrety
.Kat Aeyeiy Kat Trpos ^eovs Kat Trpos avOputirovs. jSouAot/xrjy
.8' ay Kai o-o Tru6<r6ai on TTOT' ey yco e^ets irpos rai)ra.
AA. 'AAA' ep.ot ^ey, co ScoKpares, OVK aXXy TrTj-SoKetr;
(rot re Kal rai 0ear ovSe yap ay etKos e?rj
rw 0e
e 2 ^v trpo^pyov B : vpovpyov ^v~T
a r 76 B : om. T
a 6 (6)
06&JJ' Buttmann
Trpo^rrjs T : vpo^Ttus B : irpo^rat Baiter
b a ^ del. Winckelmann
b 3 \tyetv Kal T : Aeyeir B
b 5 /ler
T : om. B
b 6 fjirep t : tfirep B T
b 7 -yej/ecrOai B : -yf-yj/eirflot T

150

150 b

HAAT12NO2

212. OVKOVV lAffjLvrja-ai

cv Tro\Xfj airopiq. fyacrKtov tlvai,
C OTTWS fir/ hdOys crfawbv e^xo/zevos KUKU, SOK&V 6e ayadd;
AA. "Eycoye.
212. 'Opas ovz/ a>? OVK d<r<aAes o-ot^ eariy eA0eu> Trpo?
5 (Tou aifovtov ovOev diroSe^ryrat r^s dvcrias rat/n/s,
/cat eTfpov n TrpocraTTO^avcrrjs.
ejuoi jney owy 8oxei )8eArioroy eTvat f]<rv%(av c^ftv
rfj /*ez> yap
ev^ 8ta r7)z> ^yaXo^v\iav royro yap
a(f>po<Tvvr} ye ovofjidrutv OVK ay o?/xa6 <re
d avayKalov ovv lort zrept/xe^eu' ecos ay rts /na^?/ <as Set Trpos
fleovs1 /cat irpos avdpuTrovs StaKeta-^at.
AA. Efore ow Trapeorat 6 -)(f>6vos QVTOS, ft) 2w/cpares,
xat n's 6 TratSe^o-a)^; fjbta-Ta yap av /uot SOKW tSety
5 TOP aV0p(l)1TOV TIS kfTTlV.
212. Owros &> /xeAet Trept <ro. dAAa 8o/cet /oioi,
rfi Ato^Set ^rycrty r?)y 'Adrjvav "OjjLrjpos O.TTO T&V d
d^eAety rr/z> dxA^y,
o^>p' ev yiyvto(TKOi rii&v Beov ?}8e Kat avbpa,
e OVTW /cat (rot 8e?y airo 7^9 \lw\rjs Trp&rov rrjv d^Ai^ d^>eAorra, ^ z;w Trapovcra rvyxdvei, TO Tt]V i/caur' 778?; Ttpocrtytpeiv
81' <i5v /xeAAety yv<!><r<rOai ^fj.v KUKOV TySe KO^ etrOXov. vvv
[j.V yap OVK av JJLOI 8oKels bvvrjOrjvai.
5
AA. 'A^atpetrco, etre ^owAerai r^y ax\vv etre aAAo rf
ws eya> 7rape<rKe7;a(r/>tai fAijOev av tyvyeiv rS>v VTT' fueivov
Trpo(rTaTTOjjLva)v, O&TIS TTOT' earty avOpcoTros, e? ye p:eAAot/x,t
<3eArtcor
C 4 evl-ofievip recc. : euxofieftf B : ei>l-a./u,evq> T
C 6 j8eA.TierT0/ B :
Kpdriffrov T
c8 /] V Sauppe
09 76 T: om. B
d 6 3 /teAe Trapci <roi Naber
e i <rol B : ffoS T
T^J/ dx\i''
a.<pe\6vTa B : a<pt\6vra T^V ax\bv T
63 fie^\ets B : /leAAei T
e 6 ira.pf<TKeva.<Tfj.ai T : irapaffKevafffjiai.
B
(t)vye?t> B : <t>fijyeii> T
e 7 Trpoffrarrofji.fvtav T : vparrofietxiiv B
8.i/6puiros Schanz : &y9po>iros B : ^ &vOpa>iros T
(it\\oi/j.i T : /xeAAoi ^ B

AAKIBIAAHS AETTEPO2
'AAAa ^v KaKflvos

6avfJ.aoTr)v

oa"rjv

Trepl (re 151

AA. Eis roVe TOLWV KCU rr)j> OvcrCav dz>a/3aAAeo-0at

KpaTHTTOv ftvaC p,oi 8oKei.
Sii. Kai opO&s ye <roi 8oKei' dcr^aAearepoy yap eorii' 5
17 TTapaKivbvv?Uiv Toaovrov Kivbvvov.
AA. 'AAAa TTIMS, S SwKpares; KCU fjw)v TOVTOVL rov
crTffpavov, fireibri /utoi boKfis /caAws crr;/ji/3e/3ou\ev/ceyai, crot
TTpt.Or\<r(io' rois ^eot? 8e KCU ore^ayovs Kat raAAa irdrra b
ra vofj.i6iJ.fva rore 8(o<ro/xe^, orai> eKfivrjv TT]V
f]fji.(pav
fhOovcrav ia>. ^et 8' o^ 86a p,a.Kpov romtov QfX6vTu>v.
2ii. 'AAAa 8e'xo/xai Kat rovro, Kai aAAo Se ay rt rwy
Trapa (row 8o#eWa)i> ^Secos t8o(/u,i bf^ap-evov e/xaDrw. uxrirep 5
8e Kai 6 KpeW EvpiTriSr; Tre'TroujTai roy Teipecriav i8a)i>
f \ovTa ra crTf<f>rj Kai aKOvcras duo rcSv iroAe/itcoj;
avrov etArj^eWt 8ta T^V Tf-xyrjv,
olavbv e^e'/u,Tjy, ^)ijo-i, KaAAtVi/ca (o-a) ore^rj
ev yap KAvScovt Keip.e0', &cnrp oicr6a cryovrco 8e Kayo) uapa o-ou rrjy boav TOVTYIV olatvbv
8o/S 8e pot OIIK ey eAarrovt KAvScoi't rou Kpeovros etvat, c
ay KaAAiriKos yeveVflai rcoy o-y epaoraiy.
a i Kautfivos T : IKSIVOS B
a 8 v/j.f3ffiov\evKeva.i
B : <re cru/*fiovXtvKfvai T
b 4 &P T( corr. Coisl. : avrl B T
b 7 airb T :
uiri B
bg <rct Euripides Phoen. 858 : om. BT
b 10 /ce^efloB :
StaKelfieOa T
b n 8<{{ay] Swpeaf Ast : 5cW Buttmann
Ca &v

T : om. B

HiriAPXOS

rj

$IAOKEPAH2

st. n
p. 225
a.

2J2KPATH2

ETAIP02

211. Ti yap TO 0iAo/cep8es; n' irore Itrrty, xal r(ye? ol

lo/tep&ets;
ET. Epot jLtev ooKouo"ty o* ai> KfpSaiyeiy a^iGxrw CLTTO

2H. norepo^ ow troi boKovviv ytyvtocrKovTes OTL ov8evo$

foriv aia, rj ayvoovvTfs;
d yap ayvoovvres, avotfrovs
Aeyet? TOVS (f>i\OKpbe't$.
ET. 'AAA* OVK avotfTovs Aeyw, aAAa iravovpyovs KCU
b Ttovripovs Kal fJTTOvs Tov Kepdovs, yiyvtocrKOVTas OTL ovfavos
' 5>v
211. *Ap' ovy roiorSe Aeyets rov (piXonepbrj, olov eav
5 (f)VTV(ov yewpyos dy^p Acai ytyyco(TKco^ ort ovSeros aiov
TO (frvTov, a^ioi OTTO Tovroi; KTpa(j>evTos KfpfiaiVftv;
Spa
TotoSrof avTov Aeyets;
ET. 'ATTO Trazrros o ye 0iAoKep8?j?, ai 2(/cpares, o^erat
10
2t. M?7 /not ovrws eiKTj, c5(nrfp rt ^StK^jweVos wo rtros,
C aAAa Trpocrexcoy e/xoi roy row airoKpivai, axnrtp ay ei e
aAiy ?7pwra)y ov)(i o/noAoyei? roy <j)i\oKfpbrj eirieivai. irtpl Trjs aia$ TOVTOV odfv Kepbaivctv a^iot;
d|ta)<rij/ B : a.^i<affovffiv

bs ytwpybs T : yewp7K5s B

mnAPXO2

225 C

ET. "Eya>ye.
212.

Tl? OVV fTTKTTrifJLtoV

ata (pvTevOfjvat.
cro<f)G>v prjfjLaTCDV

TTfpl

<f>VT&V Trj$ O^idS, fV OTTOLO,

va TL Kf

Kal &pa Kat x^P?>' ^

" W
e/x/SaA.atyiez', &v ol deiot Trept ray Su

ET, 'Eya> /xer ot)uai yetopyoz;.

d
2H. To ovy aiovv Kepbaiveiv aAAo rt Aeyei? fj otea-Oat
ET. Touro Aeyw.
211. M?j roivvv [J, m\tipei e^aTrarav, avbpa irpfvfiv- 5
repov "fir] WTO) vos &v, aTTOKpiv6iJ.vos axnrep vvvbr] a ovf? 226
avTos old, dAX' wy aA?]^s etTre* ap' ecrny ovrwa o^et
yecopytKoy avbpa yiyvo^evov, /cat yiyy&)<r/<oz>ra ort ovSet'o?
a^toy <f)VTVL TO <pvTov, oi(rQai aTTo TOVTOV Kepbaivcw;
ET. Ma Ai" OVK lywye.
5
212. Tc 8e; 67T7rt/co^ avbpa yiyvtoa-KovTO. ort ov8eyos
a^ta o-trta rw tTTTrw itaptyjei, ayvotiv avrov oiet ort TOV
ET. O^K ey<oye.
2il. OVK apa oterat ye COTO roijTtov

KepbaCvav TU>V b

ET. (%
212. Tt 8e; Kvf3epvriTr]v fj.t]bvbs aia icrr^a Kat Trrjd'aAia
r?J yrjt Trapfo-Kfvaa-fjL^vov
ayvoiv o?ei ort ^Vj^tw^trfrat Kat 5
wet Kai avros aTroAecr^at Kat rr)y
KOI & av a.yr\ Travra;
ET. OWK eywye.
212. OWK apa oterat ye Kfpbaiveiv CLTTO rS>v <TKV&V rutv
.
c
C 6 &|ja b : a|ta B : a.l-iq. T
Spqi Kal x^/3? ^
07 fV(3^ft)/tl6l'S!'recc-: e/u.pa\ofj.evcov B W : e/j,^d\\ca/j.ev &v T
. . . a^ovy Etwall (ed. Oxon. 1771) : rby . . . &%wv BT : rii . . . iJftoi'
aa
vulg.
d.5 fie evix^P*1 -^ eirixe'P6t M T
*T6' 5/)' Boeckh
(responde . . . an Ficinus) : eiWep B T
a 4 Qvretfi Stephanus :
<fuT6i5e/ B T
KepSavf'iy Cobet (et mox b i)
a 8 SiaQOepf? Cobet

aa6 c

OAATI2N02
ET. Ov yap.

212. 'AAAa oTparrjyos1 ytyv<a<TK(av on 77 crrparia avrai

ovbevbs aia 6VAa e^et, oierat dm* To^rcoy KtpbaCvfLv Kal
5 dio K
ET.
211. 'AAA' avArjTT/s' avXovs ovbevbs atovs ex.0)V "n
(TTrjs \vpav rj TO^OTTJS TOOV r) aAAos otmcrovv crv\Xi]/3br]v
T&V brmiovpytov rj T&V ^AAaiv T&V f^povcav avbp&v jbujSevos
10 afia opyava rj aAA.?jy irapao-Kfvriv fjVTtvaovv fx(av &Trb TOVTMV
d

ET.
2Ii.
TOVTOVS
oitbfvbs
5 /xer, ai

OvKouy (paivfraC ye.

Tiya? ovy Trore Aeyeis rovs (piXoKcpbfis ; ov yap TTOV
ye o^s SieXrjAv^ajuev, (dAA') oirtyes yiyycoo-Koirts ra
ata aTro TOVTOW otovrai Seu> Kepftaiveiv dA.A' ovrto
6av[j.a<rif, a>s crv Aeyets, OVK lor' avOp&TTtov ovfcls

ET. 'AAA' eyw, a> Sw/cpares, jSovAo/xat Aeyety rovrous

<pi\oK(pbels eivai, ot l/caorore ^770 aTrA^o-rta? /cat
(TfJUKpa Kal oAiyou ata Kal ovSeyos yAi)(ovrai i>TTp(pvG>s
2ii. Ov ST/TTOU, ai ySeAriore, yiyvucrKOVTfS on ovoeros aftd
(TTLV' TOVTO fj.V yap 77817 T^juas avrovs rai Aoyu e
5 on
ET.
211. OVKOW et /x^ yiyrwo-Koyres, o^Aoy on dyyoourres,
oiojnei'04 8e ra
ET. <J>aiWai.
10
21i. "AAAo rt ovv oL ye ^>iAoKe/)8eis ^)tAouort TO Kf
ET. Nair.
212. Ke/oSoy 8e Aeyets fvavriov rrj
227
ET. "Eycoye.
C 3 ffrparia, T : trrparela B
d a iron B : 5V; irou T
add. Apelt
e 8 ovSec&s B T : /jnjSevbs vulg.

d 3 oA.\'

mnAPXO2
212. VE0T4Z> oSy OT(J> dya0oV ecrrt
ET. Ofei.
212. 'AAAa KO.KOV;
ET. Nai.
212. BAaTTTOUTai VTTO TTJS ^fjiias apa
ET. BAaTrroyrai.
212. KaKoy a/aa 77 rip:ia.
ET. Nof.
212. 'Evayrtoy 8e TT; ^?7/>ita TO Kepbos.
ET. 'EvayrtW.
212. 'Aya^oy apa TO Kepbos.
ET. Nai.
212. Tovs ovi; TO dya^oi> (friXovvras (friXoKepbets KaAels.
ET. vEoucez>.
212. Ov naviKovs ye, w tra^pe, Aeyets TOVS
dAAa crv avros Trorepov ^lAels 6 &z> ayaQov y, $ ov
ET. "Eycoye.
2i2. "Eon 8e Tt ayaOov, o ov (piXels, dAAa KO.KOV;
ET. Ma At" OVK eycoye.
212. 'AAAa travra ra ayaOa t(rcos (juXeis.
ET. Nai'.
212. 'Epou brj KOL e/xe t ov /cat eyco- o/uoAoyTjo-co yap /cat
eyco o-ot <ptXeiv rayaOa. dAAa irpos e/xot Kat erol 01 SAAot
airaz/Tes ov OOKOVO-I croi Taya^a (piXflv, TO. 8e *ca/ca

ET. "Efioiye
212. To 8e nepbos ayaObv w

ET. Nai'.
212. Havre? av <f>iXoKfpbels (fraivovTai TOVTOV rbv Tpoirov
ov be TO irpoTepov eAeyo/xev, ov8eis fjV
ovv &v TIS T&) Aoyw
a 6 uTrb TTJS fafJitas &pa B : &pa virb T^S (mlas T
SvfywTroj] &vdp<airot
Hirschig
b 3 76 B : 8^ T
b 8 Ti B : om. T
b 10 ou ol B :
OUK T
02 airaj'Tes B : irdvres T
69 ry \6y(f\ T&V \6y<av Cobet

10

i
C

227 c

IIAATJ2NO2

10
ET. Ei TIS, 2(6/cpares oijucu 6p0&s Aa/x/3aVot rov
d <|>iAoKep077. opO&s 8' ecrrt rovroi; ^yeurflai <j)L\OKpbrj, bs av
ol \prjOTol ov roA/xdicrt Kz
2H. 'AAA.' opas, 2> yA.wKvrare, TO Kepbaiveiv aprt
5 <ra.fj.fv elvai w^eAeia-^ai.
ET. Ti oSi^ 8rj roi5ro;
212. "Ort Kai ro8e avrai Trpo<ru>fj,o\oyrifrafjiv,
(3ov\(rOai
TO. a-yada TtavTas nal deu
ET. Nat.
10
212. OVKOVV KCU ol ayaOol TravTa ra
t\$iv, eiTrep ayaOa ye fcrnv.
Q
ET. OVK afi o)v ye //eAAowu;, S 2(UKpare?,
T&V

Kpb>V.

212. BAa/3?j(recr0at 8e Aeyei? (^/xiWfrecr&u ^ aAAo rt;

ET. OVK, dAAa ^rj/Atwcreo-^ai Aeyco.
212. 'TTTO roS Kepbovs ovv ^/uowrai T) VTTO

ET. 'Tiro afj,<poTep(av KOI yap WTTO T?}?

KOL virb TOV Kfpbovs TOV Ttovrjpov.
2i2. TH 8oKei oSv rt (rot x/}7?"roi; K
10 Trovrjpov elvai;
ET. OVK e/Aoiye.
228
212. OVKOW w/j(,oAoyrj(ra|uey dAiyoy irporepov TO
rrj (j]nlq KOKW ovrt ZVCLVTLOV tlvai;
ET. ^rj/xt. .
212. 'Ei>ai>rtoz> 8e ^ Kaxu ayaObv tlvai;
5
ET. t12/vtoAoy?j(ra^ey yap.
2O. 'Opfts oSv, eTTtxetpe?? /xe
\eyu>v ols ct/m
d 2 air' auTwi/] airi rcDr Naber
d 5 elvcu . . . d 7 irpoff<a(t.o\oy!\<ra/u.ei> T b : om. pr. B
d 7 alrip b : aur^ B T
d 8 ircJi/Tas B :
airavras T
e i 76 T b : (re B (ut videtur)
e 4fa/j.t<a<rGff6aiB ;

mriAPXOS

228a

ET. Ov pa Aia, 2a>Kpares, dAAa rovvavrCov vv /ue

Kat OVK otba OTTT] kv rols Aoyot? aixo Kal Kara)
2. Ei><?7juer ou pevrav KaAcos TTOIOLTJV ov TTfi.06iJ.evos
ayadti Kal <ro<p<5.
. Tin rovrw; (cat rt /xaAtora;
2H. IToAiTrj /xey e/xw re Kat <r<3, Ileco-io-rparou 8e rei
TO{> e/c 4>tAa68wi', 'iTrirapx*?* ^s rwv Ilei(ri(rr/oarot> TraiScov
.^y irpea-fivTaTos /cat tro^coraroy, o? aA.Aa re TroAAa /cat KaAa
epya cro^)ta? cbre8aaro, Kai ra 'O^pof ITTTJ irp&Tos eKO/xtcrei;
ets r?)r y?yy Tavrrjvi, Kal fivdyKacrz row? pa^wSovs Ilai'aOrjvalois f VTroA^eco? e^e^ijs ai>ra StteVat, &crnep vvv en
o5e Ttoiovaiv, not CTT' 'Aya/cpe'o^ra roy Tijtoy TrevrriKOVTCpov
o-retAas eKo'/xt<rez> ets r^y ^oAty, 2t/xo)^t8rjy 8e r
det irepi avrbv LX.fv> M^yaAot? fucrdois Kal bapois
raCra 8' eTrotei ySouAo/xeyos' iratSeweti' rous TroAira?, tz;' cos
/3eAricrra>i> OVTOOV OVT&V hpyoi, OVK ol6jj.(vos btlv ovbevl
cro(f)[as (frOove'iv, are 0)^ KaAos re /cayaflos. e7ret8^ 8e awroi
01 Trept ro acrrt; rwy TroAtrwy TreiraiSeu/Aeyot ^cray /cat
avrov fTrl (ro<j)(a, fTrifiovXevav av TOVS kv roi?
7rat8eS(rat ecrr^crev amols 'Ep/xas Kara ras 68ois e^
/xecra) ro{5 ao-reos Kat rwy lr\fj.u>v eKacrro)^, Kcbmra r?js
(ro(f)[as rrjs avrov, i]v r' fj,adev KCU fjv O.VTOS ffyvpfv, exAe^aa r/yelro cro(/)corara elz^ai, ravra ambs erreiVas eis
avrou 770177jxara Kal e7rt5eiyp-ara r^s cro<pias CTTtVa irp&rov /^ey ra ey AeA^oIs ypa/xjuara ra cro^a
rawra jur) $at>|uabiez> ol TroAirai avroC, ro re " Fyw^i o^avroz^"
Kai ro " MiySey ayay" /cat raAAa ra rotaura, aAAa ra
c
l7T77ap)(ou prj^ara jixaAAoz; o-o^a yydivTO, eiretra TraptoVres
ayco Kat Kara) (cat avayLyvKXTKovres Kal yevpa AaM/3ayoyres
a 8 <ri; jue B : (ri( 6/te T
b 7 oTreSf^oro B T fsed d ex emend. T N :
vTre$fia.TO Coisl. : 67reSet|aTO W
em? B : om. TW
64 iratSeueu'
B : ireiOeiv T W
C 5 ovrcav avTuv B : ainoav ftvrtav T
d I aS
rows T : O.VTOVS B
d 3 ^o-recos Schanz ^et mox)
TJJS crocpias B :
frirb cro<pias T
d 5 & T : ora, B

5
e

228 e

riAATIiNOS

avrov rijs (ro<pias (poiT&fv K T&V ayp&v KOL eVi ra Xoma

Traibv6rjo-6[JLfvoi.
eoroy 8e bvo rcoTrtypa^juare' ey p.ev rots
229 eu' dpi<rre/>a TOV 'Ep/xoS eKacrrov e7T6yeypa7rrat Aeycoy 6
'E/s/ix^s on ey fjLeo-<j> ro aVreos KCU rou
8e rois eirt 8e^ta
fjLvrjfJ-a ro'5' 'iTT'Trapx01'* oTf^X6 StKata (fjpov&v
5 (pr)<rtv. <TTL 8e T<3z> TrotrjiActrtov Kal aAAa ev aAAots
iroAAa Kal KaAa Imyeypaju/Aez/a' etrrt 8e 8^ xat roOro eTrt TTJ
5, et> w Aeyei

5
d

To'8' 'I-7ri7rcipxou' M
(re e//oi ovra ^iAor ov
KOI e/ceiva) rotovro) oWi amore'tv, ov KOI airoOavovros rpia
err; (Tvpavvevdr](rav 'AOrjvcuoi inrb TOV aeA</xn5 avroy 'iTrmov,
/cat irdvTGov ctv r&v TraXaiSv rjKov(ras OTI rama \iovov TO.
err; rupayyty eyez/ero ey 'A^r^yats, roy 8' ^AAoy yjpovov eyyvy
rt ea>z> 'A^jjyaiot axnrep eirt Kpovov (3a(ri\evovTos. Aeyerat
8e VTTO r<3z> xaPia"r^P(OV avdpunroiv KCU 6 ddvaros avrov
ytveo-Oai ov bi h ol TroAAot wtfOrjcrav, 8ta r^y T?;? abe\.(prjs
drijuiar rr/s Kavr](popia$eTret rouro ye vt]dfs.aAAa TOV [AV
'Apfjiobiov ycyovevai TraibiKa TOV 'Aptoroyefroyos Kat TreTratbfvcrOai VTT' CKCIVOV, /xeya 8' e^poret apa ml 6 'Aptoroyeircoy e:ri rw TratSevcrat avOpanrov, /cat dz>raycozn<rrr/z/ r;yetVo
etyat rov "iTnrapxov. tv eKe^yw 8e rw XPV(P -VTOV TOV
'ApjjLobiov Tvyx&veiv e/xwura nvos rwy vecoy re *at /caAwy
xat yevvaitov T>V roreKat Aeyoutrt roi/i/o/xa avrou, eya> 8e
ou /ute/xyr/^atroy ovy veavio-Kov TOVTOV recos /xer dav/J-a^ftv
TOV re 'Ap/jiobiov /cat roy 'Apttrroyeiroya a>s (roQovs, liretra
(ruyyeyojueyoy roi 'Iir-Trapx^ *cara0poy^erat eKetywy, xat rows
TrepiaAyr/o-ayras raurr; rr; driju^a oi/rcoy a7ro/creu>ai roy
"\Tnrapyov.
a i IvapiffrepS; B T
a 2 #TI B : STI 6 T

firiyeypaTrrat B : & firiyeypairrcu T W

as tiri8ei B T
a 5 8e TWJ/ itoirjfidruv

B : TWI/ iroiTj/tarwi/ 8e T
b 5 vavrtav &] irtivrws fy Cobet
fj.6vov
B : yuJfct T
d. i Ka\S>i> ical ytwaiuv B : yevvaitav Kal KO.\WV T

mnAPXO2

aagd
i

ET. Kivbvveveis TOLVVV, o> 2o>/cpares , r) ov (f)t\ov jue

fiydo-dai t"], ei fjyrj <pi\ov, ov ireiOfcrOai 'iTnrdpxy ^y<*> yap
OTTOS ov o~v e//e efaTrarasOVK olb* OVTIVO. /xerrot Tpoirov
ey TOIS Ao'yoi?, ov 8wa/xat Treio-Oijvai.
212. 'AAAa JUTJV Kat wo-Trep ^errevcoy e^eAw o-ot ey rots
Ao'yots avaO<r6ai on ^ovAet rwi^ eipi/jaeycof, tVa /u^ 0177
e^aTraracr^at. Tro'repoy yap rouro' o~ot dvad&jjiai, a>s ov^t rwy
dyaO&v TraVres fTTLOvpovcnv ay^pco?rot;
ET. MT/ juoi ye.
212. 'AAA' ws ro ruj,iovo~0ai, Kat ^ O?/01'01 ov KCLKOV;
ET. MT; /xot ye.
212. 'AAA' a>s ov rty C^M1'? Ka' T^ CriiJiiovo-6ai TO KepSos
Kai ro KfpbaCvetv evavTLOv;
ET. Mrj8e TO^TO.
212. 'AAA' a>s kvavriov ov roi KO/CW OVK dyadov eon TO
ET. Ovrt nav ye'Tovri {J.OL avdOov.
212. AoKfl apa VOL, ws eotKe, rou Ktpbovs TO fj.tv TI
ayaObv flvai, TO 8e TI KO-KOV.
ET. "E/xoiye.
2i2. 'Ayariflejuat Toivvv crol TOVTO' ecrrw yap ST) Kep8o?
n ayaObv KOI e'repoy Ktpbos n KOLKOV.
Ktpbos be ye ovSev
o'y eo-ui> avr&v TO ayaOov r\ TO KO.KOV q yap;
ET. nSs /xe epcoras;
212. 'Eyco 0pd(rco. <TITIQV <TTLV TI ayaQov re Kat Kanov;
ET. Nat.
212. 'Ap' ovr /xaAAoV ri avr&v eort ro erepoy rou erepou
iov, rj ojuoticos roCro' ye, o-tria, ecrror djut^o'repa Ktt6
ye ov8ey 8ta<pepet ro erepoy rou erepou, Kara ro vvrlov ti
dAAa ^ ro juey amG>v ayaQov, ro 8e KaKov;
ET. Nat.
dp ^ el ^-ye? b : 77 ^761 B : $ e< ye? T

6 I oru /*e W : ffi e**/*^

B: <ru ^i T
^vroi B : om. T
as fc^ T : om. B
TI T : eariy B
b 3 ToCro B : ro^ry T

a 12

10
230

230 b

I1AAT12NO2

212. OVKOVV KCLI TIOTOV Kal raAAa iravra, ocra

OVTMV ravra ovra ra fj.fv Trfirovdtv ayaOa flvcu, ra o"e
KaKa, ovbzv eKfivrj ye 8ia$epet TO erepoy rov erepou, if ro
C avTo tcmv; ajcnrep ayflpooiros br/Trov 6 ju,ev x/)?] OTTOS ecrny, 6

ET. Ncu'.
212. 'AAA' avdpaTTos ye oi/xai ovbfT^pos ovberepov ovre
5 juaAAoy ovre J\TTQV fcmv, ovre o xpr^oros row Trovrjpov ovre
6 Trovr)pos TOV yjpf]<TTov.
ET. 'AAi?0?7 Aeyei?.
212. OvKouy otmo Kat Trepi rou Kepbovs biavoatfjifOa, ws
Ktpbos ye 6p.OL(as corl KOL TO Tiovt]fibv Kat ro
10
ET. 'ArayKrj.
212. OvSev apa \m\\ov Kepbaivet 6 ro
<-)((t)v r) TO Trovrjpov OVKOVV imXkov ye KepSo?
d ovofrepov ov, MS ofAokoyovpev.
ET. Nat'.
212. OwSere/oo) yap avr&v ovre ro paXXov ovre ro
ET. Oy yap 877.
212. T<5 8^ rotowrw Trpayjuari TTWS ay rts f>iaAAoy ^
ortoCSi; ay iroto? ^ Tracr^ot, <S //7;8erepoj; rovrcoy Ttpocreir] ;
ET. 'ASwaroy.
212. 'E7rei5r7 TOLVVV Kfpbrj fjiev O/AOICOS eoriz> dp.^)orepa
10 xat Ke/o8aAea, roirrt 8r) 6e? ^/xas fTno-Kf^aa-Oai, bia rt Trore
afj,(poTpa avra Kepbos KaAels, rt TO.VTOV v aju<ore'pois opatv;
e <uo-7T6/j ay et [a] (rv /xe Tjpwray ra yi)yo?j, 8ta rt irore xat ro
ayaOov CTLTLOV Kal ro KO.KOV crmov 6jj,oia>$ a/x(/)orepa (rtrta
icaA<S, flTTQv a,v (rot Start a^ff^oTepa ^pa rpcxpr) crw/xaros
5

B: r
TW
C i 2 ^ (^) rb Stephanus
ou5e . . . owSe T
d 6 S^] 8e Ast

d 10 Tourl B : ToOr' ert T

B, : SU? T

0.3 o/re . . . otfre B :

d 7 irpofffiri B : wpoirf T

e i $, del. Schleiermacher

e 2 6/uoiws,

innAPxo2

2306

, bta TOVTO eyooye- TOVTO yap elvat a-niov <av o~v TTOV
6|uoAoyo?s. ?? yap;
5
ET. "Eycoye.
212.

Kai jrept TTOTOV ovv 6 CLVTOS av rpoiros fir] rrjs

-ecos, OTI ry TOV cr^jj-aros vypa rpo^f), eayrt \prjcrTr]
TTOvrjpa ff, TOVTO TO ovop.d ecrri, TIOTOV /cat Tols 231

TO \prjarov Ktpbos Kal TO Trovrjpbv Kfpbos

(j>r]s afMfroTfpov
clvai TL TO avTo kv avTols op&v, OTI
8^ Kal TOVTO Ktpbos fa-Tiv; fl 8' av JU.T) ambs e^eis aTro/cpi- 5
vaa-Oai, dAA.' e/Aou Aeyoiros (TKOTret* apa Kepbos Aeyets Tray
o ay Tty /crr/oTjrai ^ )U?j5ey avaAwo-as, ^ eAarroy
eoy Ad/Sr;;
ET. vE|noiye SOKW rouro KaAery xepSos.
b
SH. *Apa /cai ra rotate Aeyei?, edy ris ecrna^ets, /x,7j8ey
dyaAo>cras dAA' evw^Tj^ets, vdcroz; Kr^crTjrat;
Err. Ma At" OVK eycoye.
212. 'Tytetay 8e Krr}o-afji.vos

CLTTO ecrrtd(rea)S nepbos av 5

ET.
SO. OVK dpa roi;ro ye eart Kepbos, TO OTLOVV
ET. Ov /uteVrot.
10
212. ITorepoy OUK, eay KUKOV; y 0118' ay aya6bv OTLOVV
KrricrrjTai, ov Kepbos KT^trerat;
ET. 4>atVeTat3 lav ye ayadov.
212. 'Eaz> 8^ KUKOV, ov r]p.(av KTjJcrerai;
C
ET. "Efxotye 8oKeu
212. 'Qpqs ovv &S Tra\LV av ireptrpexeis ets TO avro; TO
juey Kepbos ayadbv (paivtTai, 77 8e ^?]/jtta KCLKOV.
e 5 (^0X070?* T : 6/j.o\oye'is B
a 5 82? b : Set B T
b 8 -ye'
B : om. T
b 9 icT^<ra<r0aj T b : KT^(re<r0at pr. B (ut videtur)
b 12 KT^fffTCU
PLATO. VOL.

T : KT^lTTJTOt B
II.

25

OAAT12NO2
5

10
d

10
e

ET. 'ATTOpw lycoye on

212. OVK d8iKO)? ye o-i airopatv. Irt yap /cat TOO~e aTroKpivai' fdv ru eAarroy dpaA<>(ras' TrAeoy KTrjfrrjTai, <pr)s
ntpbos elvai;
ET. OVTI ttanov ye Ae'yco, dAA' eay xjiwrCov rj apyvpiov
lAarrov dyaA.wo-as TrAeoy Xa^Sr/.
212. Kal eycb /ixeAAco ToSro e/3?](re<r0ai. </>e/>e yap, ear TIS
Xpuo-iou crraOfjibv -fj^Lavv avaXtocras SiTrXao'toi' Aa/Srj apyvpiov,
Kepbos r) fynCav aA^ey;
ET. Zrjjataz; STJTTOU, a Scoxpares- drrt Sa)5e/cao-Ta(riou
yap SiaraVioz; avrw Ka^iorarai ro \pvcriov.
212. Kai /xi)z/ -TrAe'oy y' L\.rj(j)v rj ov TrAeoy ecrrt TO
8f7rAa(rtoy TOW ^/ixt(reos;
ET. Ovri TIJ d^6a ye apyvpiov yjtvcriov.
212. Aet apa, &>s eoiKe, roi /ce/)8et TOUTO Trpotrclvai, -rrjv
aiav. vvv yovv To ftey apyvpiov TrXzov o~v TOV ^pva-iov ov
<pfis aiov etyai, TO 8e xpvo-iov lAaTToy oi> a
ET. 2<j(>o8pa' e^et yap OVTCOS.
212. To //,ez/ ator apa KepSaAeoy (TTIV,
17 eai>Te /ueya, TO 8e ava^iov aKepSe's.
ET. Nai.
212. To 8e a^toy Aeyeis a^toy eiyai aAAo TI r/
ET. Nai, KCKTrjo-dai.
212. To 8e a^toy au Aeyeis KCKrrjcrOai TO dyaxpeAes 17 TO

ET. To
212. OVKOW TO ftx^eAt/xov ayaOov eorii>;
ET. Nat.
212. OvKoS^, oo dySpeioTaTe TravTcav, ov TO K6p8aAeor
ayadbv av ndXiv rpfcov rj rfrapTov rjnei rnj.iv 6/jioAoyo^/xeyor;
5
ET. "EotKez>.

232

C 6 -yap B : Se T
07 ir\eov KT-fi<ri)Tcu t : KT-fia"i}rai B : TrKeoveK.r'ii(rrjrat T
d i /j.\\<a TOVTO B : TOVTO /j.e\\eo T
d. 5 SiffTdffiov T :
SiffTa.<rifjLov B
d 10 xpvff'lov v W : xpvfflov ov ffb B : xpvaiov T

mriAPXos
212. ^/[vrjfj,ovVis ovv 66ev fifuv OVTOS 6 Aoyos yeyovev;
ET. Ofytat ye.
212. Ei 8e pri, eyw <re VTro/ixw/crco. jJju^
roi/s dyatfovs p) Trdwa ra fce/>877 (3ovk<T0ai
d\Aa rcSy KepSSz/ rdya^a, ra 8e Ttovripa jn^.
ET. Nat'xt.
2fi. OvKouy z/w TrdvTO. TO. Kpbrj 6 Ao'yos ^/xas y
Kat <rp,iKpa KCU /xeyaAa o/xoAoyerv dya^a eirat;
ET. 'Hydyxa/ce yap, S> SwKpares, jmaAAoi> e/xe ye
212. 'AAX' i(rco5 /uera roSro Kat 7ret<mei> di>- fw 8' ovv, 5
eire ireireto-at eire OTraxrS?) ^Xets' o-w/x^rjy yow ^/wiy TrdVra
ra Kep8r; ayada etvai, /cat o-juixpa Kat /xeydAa.
ET. 'O/ioAoyw yap ovr.
212. Tovs 8e \pr]<rTovs avOptib-novs (3ovkcr0ai. Tayada
6ju,oAoyets airavra a-navras' y ov;
10
ET. 'O/xoAoya).
212. 'AAAd jzez> 8^ rovs ye Trovrjpovs avrbs elircs ort Kat C
(T/^i/cpa Kat />teyaAa K^pbrj (piXovfnv.
ET. EITTOI;.
212. OVKOW Kara TOV crov Xoyov Tra^re?
<iAoKep8er? av etey, Kai ot xpijcrrot Kat ot Trovrjpot.
ET. ^aiWrai.
212. OVK apa 6p6S>s dvetSt^et, et rts ro> dvet8t
Kep8et etVaf ruyxdyet yap rat 6 raSra weiSt^cor avros
rotouros &v.
a 6 Sj/ B : -y' oSj/ T
a 8 ^/u0i<r/8^T'?<''< BW: ^ a(upiff&iiT-f)ffas
T
b 4 iFfireiKe T : n-eirel/cei B
C i ourbs Bekker : avrovs B T : om.
vulg.
C 4 iroLvres B : cEiroj/Tes T

EPA2TAI

St. I

P. 132
a

Ets Aioznxnov row ypajuju,ancrrou tlvrjXQov, KCU

r<3y re i>ecoz> rows e7rieiKeoTaroi>s 8oKo!yras etWt rr)y
Kat Trarepcoy e$>OK<fia>z>, KOI TOVTU>V epaoras. ervyovv 8uo rwy )u,e6paKtcoi; ept^oyre, 'Trepi orou 8e, ov
5 (T(pobpa Kar^Kovov. (paive(r9r]v /xeirot ^
b ^) irept OtyomSou ept^eiy KVKAouy' youy ypafaiv <
Kat ey/cA.i(re6s rtya? k^i^ovvro roiv y^poiv
/xaA' eo-7rou8a/core. Kayw Ka6rnj.r)V -yap Trapa TOV e
rou erepou avroiy Kivrjcras o%v avrov roi) ayK&m
5 ort irore ovroo? (T7rou8aKore ra> /xetpaKico flrr^v, KOL
?
H TTOU fxey rt Kat KaAoy eori Trepl o T0<ravrr)v
TreTrotTjjaeya) earoy;
C
O 8' ewre, riorov, (^77, joteya Kat KaAoV;
ju,ey ouv ovrot ye ^epl TI> /Lterewpcov Kat (j)\vapov<ri
Kat eya> 0avfj,a<ra$ avrov TTJV aTTOKpicriv fiTrov vli veavia
(rot e?iat TO <f)ih.cxro(plv ; rj ri ovrcos
Kat 6 ereposmX^a-Lov yap Kad^^vos fTvy^avev atrot),
5 ayre/oaoTTj? wr-.aKOuo-as e/io re epo/xeyou KO-Keivov O.TTOEPA2TAI B T : ANTEPA2TAI in marg. b
b i ypdjew B :
ypdtyovres T W f<f>cuvfffdi)v B : etyaiveaQov ex etfxilvovTo T
b 6 /te'ya
TJ B : T Me'ya T
& T : STOW B
b 9 >ye T : om. B

EPA2TAI
Kpivojj,evov, Ov Trpbs o~ov ye, f(j)f], 2&>Kpares, Troieis ro
Kai avepecrOai TOVTOV el alcr^pbv Tyyetrat <tAo<ro<ptaz; flvai.
r) OVK olcrOa TOVTOV 6'n rpaxr?Ato/ueyos Kai ep,iH/jnrAdfiei>oy
Kal KaOevbu>v TTCLVTU TOV fiiov Starere'AeKev; coo-re <rv ri
avrbv (Sou aTTOKptveicrOcu dAA' 77 on alcr^pov eart <piXo(TO(pia;
'Hy 8e ovros /xef T0?y epaoratz; Trept fj.ov(riKrjv 8iaTrpi(f)a>s, o 8' Irepos, ov eAotSo'pei, wept
fxoi e8oe xpyvai TOV fj,ev erepoy d^te^a
on ovb' airrbs Trpoo-e'Troteiro irept Aoycoz; e/u,7retpos eTyat dAAa
irepi epycov, TOV be (roffx&Tfpov
irpoo-noLov^vov eu/at 8iepcor^crat, ira /cat ei T6 bvvai^v Trap amov &)</)eArj^etrji'.
et-TTOi' ovy OTI Eis Kotror ju,ev ro epwr7]/iia rjp6fj.r]v
ei 8e (ru
otei rov8e KaAAtoy av aTtoKpivacrQai, ere epcorco ro avro oirep
V ^ %
5
^
^
V l \
i*->
x V ' ? '
* v
/cat TOVTOV, et oo/cet <rot ro <ptAo(ro<peiy KaAov eivai r/ ov.
S^e8w ovv raura Aeyoyrcor 77/^<3z> fTranovo-avTe rw jwetpa/aa> eo-iyiyo-ar?]^ Kat avrco Traucrajixeyco r^s IptSos ^joiwi'
d/cpoarat -yVfo-6t]v.
/cat on /^ey ot epacrrat f-nadov OVK
otba, avrbs 8' oiw e^cTrAayrji'' del yap -Trore VTTO r&ij; ye'ooy
re /cai KaAwy eKTrAT^rTO/i^ai. e8o/cei fxeVroi juot /cat 6 erepo?
o^x ^rrov ejuou aytoVLav ov ^r\v dAA' aTreKptraro ye /mot
Kat juaAa <ptAori/xcos. 'OTro're yap rot, e^rj, w 2(oKpares,
ro <piXoo-o<pfiv al<r)(pbv T\yr}(TQ.(.\tt}v ftvai, ov8' ar/ av6pu>Trov
lvai, ov8' aAAov roy ovrto StaKet/xeyoy,
ets rw avTepaa-Trjv, Kat Aeycoz> /neydAr/ rrj
ailTOV KCLTCIKOVOI

13

10
d

133

TOL TraiblKO..

Kat eycb ewroy, KaAor apa 8oKet o-ot ro (piXoo-otpelv ;

/lev GUI',
C 7 <j>i\offo<t>iav elvai B : cleat <pi\ocro($>ia.v T
C 8 TOVTOJ' B : aubyT
09 cri) TI aurbj/ i^ou B : &<rre ri ffoiofei aurbj'TW
C 10 diroB : airoKpiveo-dai T W
oA.A.' ^ B : \Ao ^ T W
d3
, --, . , . . . _
-_ _
TroKpiva.ffda.1 Laur. Ixxxv. 14
Kpivf(rdai T : a.iroKpivfffQai B : airoKpivfLffOai b
a 4 S' oiiv T : y' oiiv B
b 3 fj.fyd,\ri B W : /te-ya T
b 5 ffot T W : trot oT6v T' elvau B

133 b

IIAATX1NOS
Ti ovv, eyo> H<f)r]v T] 8o/cei (rot otoV r* flvai
OTIOVV eire KaA,oi> eire alaryjpov eorii>, 6 /AT)

Or0' apa, 7]y 8' eyw, on eoriy TO <piA.oo"o<peu> ;

Tidvv ye, l^r;.
Tt ovv f(TTiv; Z<f>r]v eyw.
Ti 8' aAAo ye ^ Kara ro SoXcoyos; SoAtoy yap TTOV
5 enre
y?7pacrKco d' aiet 7roA.Aa 8t8acrKO/xevos'

10
d

Kal e/txoi 8oKet OVTCOS det XP^vai %v 7* TL P-avOdvfiv TOV

//.eAAoi/ra (f)L\o(ro(f)r}(rei,v,
Kal vedrepov ovra /cat irpe(T/3vTfpov, iy' &>y Tr\fl<rra V r5 ^3ia) /ua^rj. /cai' JMOI ro /Aev
irp&rov I8oe rl eiirely, eiretra TTCOS ey^or/o-as ^pofxrjy airoy
ei T?JZ> <j>i\o(ro<j)iav TroXv^adCav rjyolro.
Kd/ceiros, Ilayu, ^r/.
'Hyrj 8e STJ KaXoy etrat jnoyoy r^v (pi\o<ro(f)Cav r) Kal
ayadov, r\v 8' eyw.
Ka6 ayadov, e^rj, TT&IW.
Tlorepoy ovr er <piAoo"o<ia ri rovro iSioy fvopas, 77 *cai
ev TOIS aXAois OVTM (rot 8oKei e\tv; olov (j)LXoyufJ,va<rTiav
ov povov 77777 /caAoy eiixu, ctAAa Kal ayadov; r) ov;
'O 8e Ka6 jixaAa eipoovt/cws etire Svo* Hpos juey roV8e
fj.oi dp-fiord on ouderepa- irpos /xeyroi ere, S SwKpares,
6jU.oA.oyci) /cal /caXoy eTyat cat dya^oy rjyovfj,ai yap opO&s.
ovy eyco, *Ap' oSy not tv rots yv{j.va.(riois rrjv
CiTJb:nBT
02 vdi/v ye B : /coJ /xaAo ^rj T W
C 4 TO
b : TOV B T : rb TOV t
C 6 8' ale! Solo : aUl B : 8' ael T
8t8arr/cJjue^osT : 5); 5t8a<TK<J/xej/os B
C 10 eirfiTa. B : ?TC T
c n fiyo'iro
T: ^7?ro elrat B
d.6 TO?S B: om. T
d. 7 ^<y6?KoA.bc B :
ica\i' iryei T
d 8 e?TT T : e<f>ri B
d p fj.fi/roi T : Se B
e i 6no\oyS> Kal Ka\bv eJvai Kal a.ya.Q6v B : nal Ka\itv Kayaffbv
dfj.o'A.oy&
elva.i T
riyovftai . . . 6 2 eyci> B : om. T W
e 2 3p' oSv T W : om. B
6 3 elrat T : TL eZWt B

EPASTAI

1336

Kd/<eu>09 1077, Yldw ye, cocrrrep ye xat ey rw

TT)Z> TTO\v[JiaOCav fyiXocrofyiav r^yov^ai etyat.
5
Kdy&> etTroy, 'Hyrj 8e 87) TOTJ? ^lAoyu/xyacrroCvras' aAAou
TOU eirt#ufie> 77 TOVTOV, on TrotT/crei airois eS e;(u> T0
Tovrov, e^>r;.
'H ovv ol TroAAot TTOVOI TO <r<3jua, ^y 8' eyco, TTOIOVCTIV
II(Ss yap $i>, f<^>^j ttTO ye oAtywy TTOVMV TO cr&fjid TIS ev 134
Kat //ot eSo^ey 77817 evravOa KivrjTfos dvai 6
)u,ot fiorjOi/icrri 8ta rijy e/m7retpiay 7775 yv^vacrriK.^'
O.VTOV, 2v 8e 877 ri crtyas Tyjuiy, S Awcrre, 5
rowrou ravra Aeyoyros; rj Kal (rot 8oKoi5o-tz; 01 avflpcoTToi e
ra crwx,ara e e i z ;

< iro r

^z; "TO^^wz; TTOVWV, T airo

'Eya> /Aei', a> 2ci)KpaTes, ^ry, w/xrjy ro Aeyo/ueyoy 87^ roi5ro

Kay ?jy yv&vai. on ot /xerptot Troyot ev TrotoiSo'ti' ^Xli1' T^ I
o-(o/xara, irodev br] ov^l avbpa ye &.ypvnv6v re Kat a<rirov b
Ka

'
/cat avroii TaiiTa etuoVTos T^V^rj Ta juetpaxta xat
6 8' eYepos ripvOpiacre.
Kat eya> etTroy, Tt ovy; OT> 77877 trTjyx60/^5 p-77Te TroAAovs 5
jUTjTe oAtyoTjy TTOVOUS ev iroieiv tx.iv ra o-<d|uaTa TOVS avdpaTTOVS, dAAa TOWS /xeTptouj; 77 bia^axjl bvolv OVTOLV v&v irept
TOW Aoyov;
1
, TTpo? /uey ToCToy, e</>7j, Kar TTCIVU 7}8ea)s 8ta- c
018' OTI iKayos ay yevoi\M]v f3or)0f)<rai.
TTJ VTToOecret. rjv VTTfO^rjv, Kal et Tavrf]s eVt <^auAoTepay
e/iTji;.ovSey yap eort Trpos \tAvroi <rk ovbfv 8eop.at
e 4 76 B : om. T

e 6 8^ 8^ recc. : S Se? T : 8^ B

a i ewrd

ye oA^wi/ B : air' 6\iytav ye T

a 4 fioriQ'fiO'r) B : f)or}6ii(rfie T
a 6 TOVTOV TOMTO. B i TauTa TojjTou T
a io /c&v Sj/ Hermann : /col
yOv B T
b 3 ^ireyeXacre B : eyf\ao~ei> T

I34C

OAATilNOS

5 Trapa boav <p" lAoptKeuJ, dAA' 6/AoAoy<S fir) TO, TroAAa dAAa
ra /xerpta yv^vaa-ia TT\V fveiav (fATrotelv rots avdp&TTOis.
Ti Se ra <riria; ra fxerpia T) ra TroAAd; I^TJV eya>.
Kat ra curia a>juoAoyei.
d
"Ert 8e /cdya> TT poo-quay naov avrbv 6/xoAoyeu' Kat raAAa
iravra ra irtpl TO cr<3^ia w^eAt/xwrara e?yat ra /^,er/3ta dAAa
/i*r/ ra TroAAa /xijSe ra dAiya- xat jixot a)/xoAoyei ra /xerpta.
Tt 8', (>rv, ra ireal r?z/ viv; ra
5 ra a/xerpa
Ta
ral' T r o ( r c o x e y c o i '

10

u ?

OTt Ka

Ta

Kat rovrcoy apa ra />terpta ax^eAei dAA' ou ra TroAAa;

Tira ow epo^te^ot ay StKatcos epotjixefla 6770^06

wyot Kat ortria Trpoy ro o-w/xd ecrrty;
'il/xoAoyoujuey jue^ rpeis wres, ort larpov rj
Tiya 8' av Trepi cnrepnaTcw <nropas oiroaov
5
Kal rovrou rov yecopyoy cb^oAoyoO/xey.
Ttya 8e Trepi fia6ty/^araw ets 'tyvyjiv (pVTfv<re<as re /cal
<nropas

135

TovyreS^ff ^Sry cnropias /iecrrot ?7/xez> aTravres* Kayo)

irpoo-Trai^y avroi)s ?7po//,?jy, BovAeo-^e, e^rji', eireiSr) ^/xeis
ei' cnroptq ea-fjifv,
epw/xe^a rauri ra /xeipd/cta; ^
ala"xyvo[ji.da, axrirep I0rj rovs jj.vr)o-Tijpas
5 aiovvT<av elvai riva a\Xov OCTTLS evrevft ro TOOV;
d. 2 utyeXifj.&ra'ra. elvai ret fj.erpia Schanz : a><f>e\ifMi>TaTa flvcu fierpia
B : TO fuerpta fn.d\i<rra 6xf>\fiv T
d 4 oi^eAe? Stephanus : u><pe\e'iv
BT
e i jjLfTpioi ir6voi B : 7r<{j/ot (jLtrpioi T
63 &fj.o\oyov/j.ev
B : 6fj.o\oyovjmev T
juev B T : om. ai.
6Vt B : ^ T W (sed ort s. v.)
e 4 a"irfp/j.d,Ta>v B : (TTrep/ttaTos T
65 /cai TOUT on B T : Ka/ rovry
ci. Schanz
6fio\oyov/j.ev pr. B T
e 6 Trepi B : om. T W
a 5 afyovvTtav B T : d|jou'Tas b : |joi5'T6s Cobet

EPA2TAI
r) ovv poi. ZboKovv aOvfJLtiv Trpbs TOV Aoyop, aAAr/
O-KOTTC'LV, KCU euroi>, Yloia be /idAtara arra roetvat r<Sy fj.aOrjfj.aTU>v
a bel TOV <j)LXocro<f)OvvTa
, e^reto"?) ov^t irdvra ov8e iroAAd;
ovz> 6 cro</><orepos eliTey on KdAAtora ravr'
etrj rwy jua^rjju.drwi' /cat Trpocr^Koyra d(|)' tSr az> TrAetcrTTjy
8ofay e^ot TIS els (^lAcxro^i'ay TrAeiorrjy 8' &y e^ot boav,
ei boKoCrj T&V T^V&V l/iiretpos etvat Trao-aiy, et 8e /^?7, cos
TrAeicrrft)!' ye /cai /xaAiora rwy d^ioAo'ycoi', padutv avr&v
raura a irpotTT^Ket rots eAevtfe'pois jua^eir, o<ra
ex^rat, fx^ ocra -^tpovp-yias.
9
Ap' (wr ovrco Aeyets, e^Tjy eyw, tfxnrep ev rfj
Kal yap CKC? TfKrova /xey &v Trpiaio ireire ^ e^ JJLV&V, aKpov
ap\iTfKTova be ovbi* av pjptatv bpa^&v oAtyoi ye JU,TJI> /cay
ey 7ra(Tt rois "EAA?7<n yiyvoivro. apa ja^ rt roiovroy Aeyeu;
Kat os aKoi5o-as JU.OD cri>ye)((opei /cat airos Aeyety roto{5roz>.
'Hpoju?jy 8' CLVTOV et OK dSwaroy ei?7 8vo /xovas Terras
OVTOJ p,a6eiv TOV OVTOV, [ir\ on TroAAa? Kat /ueydAas* 6 8e,
Mr) ovrcos fj,ov, (pr], yiroAajSr/s, a ScoKpares, ws Aeyo^Tos
ort 8er eKao-rrjy rcov Teyy&v TOV fyiXoffotyovvTa eTti(rraa-6ai
a.Kpi(3>s axnrep CLVTOV TOV rrjy Ttyvr]v e^oyra, dAA' &>s
etKos avbpa eAev^epoy re /cat 7re7rai8et>/xei'oz>, e7r
re rots Aeyo/xevots inrb TOV bri^wvpyov olov r' etmt
7rap6vTu>v, Kat avTov vfJL(3aXXecr
8o/cetv ^apteoraroy etyat Kal (rofyc&Tarov T&V det
Trap6vTu>v ev rot? Aeyo//,eVois re Kat Trparrop-eyots Trept ras

issa

Kdyco, en yap atirou rmfayvoovv TOV Xdyov on e

a 7 juaAicTTa avra roirdfofjifv
B: /j.d\Lffra
Toircio/j.ev &TTO. T
a 8tyiXoffofyovvra.B : <j>i\6<ro<f>ov T
a 9 evretS^ B : rel T
b 3 5' &P B T : 8' Schanz
b 5 ye B : re T
p.d\iffra T : fj.d\a
B
C a &/ . . . 0 3 yiyvoivro Schanz : Kal . . . yiyvoivro B : Kal
. . . yiyvovrai T
03 fvlf TI T : ^ B
04 avrbs T : avrov B
Aeyety TotoOroj' B : TOIOVTOV \eyfiv T
05 /JLOVO.S B : \LOVOV T
C6 nafteiv B T : AajSelV ex emend. T
d.5 ray atel B : atel ruv T

35e

IIAATNO2

e *Ap' kvvoSt, e<prjy, olov Aeyeis roy <pi\6(ro<pov avbpa; boKis

yap |u.oi Aeyety otoi ey rr) dyojyia zia-lv ol irevTadXoi. irpbs
TOVS bpofj.4as rj TOVS TraAatoras. /cat yap e/ceiyot TOVTMV
fj.fv XeCirovrai Kara ra TOVTCQV aOXa Kal Sevrepoi fieri irpbs
5 TOVTOVS, rStv 8' aAA.o>z> a6Xr)TG>v irp&roi, Kal VIKOHTIV avrovs.
TO.)( av to-coy TOLOVTOV TL Aeyois Kai ro
yd&crOat, TOVS fTTiT^bfvovTas TOVTO TO eTTtrTySev/ixa' T&V
136 Trpcorcoy ets (ruvfcnv irept ras Te%vas eAA.e6rca-^at, ra
repeia 8' e^oyras TWV aAAfoz/ ?repteu>ai, KOI ovrcos
jrept Travra OiTraKpov Tiva avbpa TOV
ToioCSroy rtyci /iot SOKCI? fvbeiKvvcrOai.
5
KaAws ye juot, e^r/, co 2coKpares, (paforj vft
TO. Trepl TOV (f)ikocr6<pov, aTTfiKacras awov T&
fanv yap a.T-)(yS>s rotouro? otoy ^ SouAevety fMrjbevl
y/^art, /Arj8' ets Trjv aKpififiav pybev btaTT7rovr)KVai, wore
8ta r^y rou evos rovrov em/xeAetay raiy
b a.TroXe\.fi(p6ai, uo-Trep ol brifjuovpyoi, clAAa TtavTcw
f(prj(f)0ai.
Mera ravrr/y 8?) rr)y airoKpia-iv eycb TTpoOv/JLOVfjifvos <ra<<Ss
eiSeyai on Aeyot, TruvOavofj,r]v avrov TOVS ayaOovs irorepoy
5 \pr](riij,ovs y a\pr]aTOvs
Xpr/a-ijixovs STJTTOV, co
^Ap' oSy, et'Trep ot clya^oi x/37?07'/*04' ^ Trovrjpol

10
C

Ti 8e; rovs (piXocrotyovs avbpas xprjcrifjiovs fjyri i] oi>;

*O 8e w/ioAo'yei ^pn](ri^ovs, Kal Trpos ye e0rj
Tarou? eiycu rjyticrQai.
^ yywjuey, ei o-ii aX.rjdfj Aeyets, TTOU /cat
e 2 ofoj corr. Coisl. : o!W B T
64 /cra T^S T : Kara B
e 6 \tyois T : Ae-yets B
a r irpcbrcav T : irpSnov B
a 4 So/eels
T : So/ce? B
as <t>a.lvei B : 5oKe?s T
viro\a.[j.$o.viv B : wroXafieiv T
a 7 olos T W : om. B
b i &<rvep ol Srifuovpyol
T : a\\' &ffirp ol Srtmovpyoi B
b 7 xp^ffj/iot T : ol xPlhfflf-01
03 <ri T : om. B

EPASTAI

1360

r\[u.v f.l<riv ot vTraKpot. otiroi; brjXov yap on e/cd(rrou ye T&V

ras Tf-^vds kyovTuv (pavXoTtpos fornv 6 <pt\oo-o<pos.
5
4>epe br) a~v, TJI> 8' eyoi>, ei TT^^OIS r/ awbs aa-Qevriffas TJ
V <piX<ov rts raw <ra>y Trepi &v OT> (TTrouSTjy iJ,ey6Xr]v exets>
Trorepoi; vytiav /3ouA.oju,eyos fcrT^o-ao-^at TOZ; vTranpov cutivov
[TOV <f)i\6(TO(f)Ov] eitrayots az> eis TTJy olKiav y TOV larpov 10
povs lycoy' ay, e<^rj.
d
fxoi, eiTroy eyw, dfx^orepovs Xeye, aAV oTrorepoy
Qvbcis &v, $<pr], TOVTO ye d/u,<|>i<r/3T7T?]creiey, ws oii)(l roy
larpov Kat juaAAoi; Kai irporcpov.
5
TY 8'; ey yi]6 yfiii.ao\i.v'r\ Trorepw ay /xaAAoy eirirpeTrois
o*auroz; re Kat ra (reaurov, rw KUjSepy^rrj 17 rfi (piXocrotpu*;
Toi KU)8epvi]rrj eya)ye.
O^Koi;i; Kat raAXa Traz^^' ovrcos, ecos ay rts 8rj/jiioupyo9 17,
I0
- o s ecrrty 6 (iXoaroos;
rts pli> ecrrtz; (pi>Xcro<pos; ei<rt
yap ^p-ti/ det TTOV Srjjxtoupyoi' wfx.oXoyijo-a/utez; 8e rovs /mey
flvai, TOVS 5e
Tt ovy /x,era roCro; epcojixat ere ?/ dypotKorepoy eorty 5
'EpoC ort
817, e^rjr eyoj, C1?1"'* aAAo 77 di/o/ixoXoy?70-acr0at ra
c 4 7e T : re B
c 7 8)? B : 8 T
c 8 &/ B : oS T
C g jSouA^juews KT^<raerflai B : Kr-ijffaffOai $ov\6/Ji.evos T
C 10 rbi/
<f)i\6(ro(t>ov T : rbi/ <ro</>6i' B :fyi\6ffo<povStephanus : seel. Cobet
eiV(701$ BT : elffaydyois b
c n \dfiois B : &v \dfiois T : seel. Cobet
d i $7} recc. : ^)TJI/ B T
da e-ytb * B : e-ya^y" T
d 3 re B : -ye T
d. 7 (ravrdv recc. : latT<{^ B : O.VT&V T
ra <reai/ToS B : ras eavrov T
d, 10 d B : om. T
e i effT\v o <f>i\6ffo<j>os B : d <piX6ffofyos tffr'iv T

e 2 ^/j> B : om. T
B yp. T : oxpej'ovs T

aei Hermann : 8^ B T
63 a
e 5 ri B T : Tb Baiter
e 8 fijrw T :

137 a

ITAATilNOS

137 etprjjiAeVa.
exei 8e TTMS a>8i. <w/AoAoy?j(rap,ei> KaAov etvai
TTJZ; ^>tAo(T00tay Kat avrot (ptAoVocpoi etvai, roi/s 8e <ptAoo-d$ODS ayaOovs, TOVS 8e dyafloiiy xprycri/xow, TOVS 8e irovypovs
a\p^arrovs' avOis 8' av row (piXocrocpovs a>/xoA.oy7jcra/>iei>, etos
5 ay 01 STjjiuoupyoi (rty, dxpT/aroDs e?yat, brjiuovpyovs 8e del
ov yap ravra w/ixoAoyr/rai;
ye, ^ ' o?.
apa, ws eoce, Kara ye ror' (roy Aoyor,
eiirep TO ^)tAo<ro<^ei^ eort irept ra? re^va? tisiaTri novas
10 ea>ai or (TV Aeyeis rov rpoirov, Trovrjpovs avrovs elvau Kal
b d^p?jo-rous, eoos ay ev avOptoirois re^vai Sxriv. dXAa /AT;
ov^ OVTCOS, oj ^>tAe, %(O(n, /ArjS' ^ TOUTO (piX.o<TO(pflv, irepl
ras rex^as ecnrovbaKfvai, ovbe TroAuTrpay/xoyowra
^o^ra ^r]y ov8e TroAu/xaflowra, dAA' aAAo rt, eiret eya> wj
5 Kal oyeiSos eu>ai TOVTO Kat fiavavcrovs KaAeto-^ai rows Trept ras
eo-7rou8aKoras. (SSe 8e o-a<peorepoy eto-o/xe^a ei apa
Aeyco, eay roirro airoKpivrj' rives fTT'jrous eTTtcrrayrat
&s; Tro'repoy oiirep /SeAriorous iroiov<nv rj aAAoi;
OtTrep ^3eAriVroi;?.
Tt 8e'; Kvz/as ov)( ot /SeAriarow eTrioraz^rat irotflv, OVTOI

Nat.
*H avr^ apa re'^yjj ySeAriorous re Trotei Kal
dp^ois;
4>atWra p:oi, 77 8' o?.
Tt 8e; Trdrepoy r/Vep /3eAriorous re Trote? Kat
a I Ka\bv elvou B : sTrat KaA.^!/ T '

seel. Schanz auctore Forster

a 2 ol awrot (f>i\6ffo(t>oi

a 5 of del. Heusde

e?/at

a 7 75

B : om. T
^ 5' els B : e07j T
a 8 &fjio\oyov/uifv T : 6fjLO\oyov/ji.fv
B
a 10 &j/ <r{; corn Coisl. : w^ (is <ri; B T : cos <ri> vulg.
icoti
axp'fjff'rovs
. . . b I 5<rj>' seel. Schanz
b 2 e;x(rt B : exovffi T
/urj5' ^ Mudge : ^ S^ B T
b 3 t<nrovSaKevai . . . vo\\mpayiJLOvOVVTO. seel. Cobet
KuirTafavra, B : Krvird^ovra T
b 4 e-yeb B :
y' T
c I ir^Tepov B : irpoTfpov T
/3eA/r/0Tovs B T : /SeArfous al.
c
6
3> , 9 &e\Tl<rTovs B : 0e\riovs T
C 8 Qaiveral poi B et in marg.
y/>. T : ^rjjui T W
0 9 ^?rep] ^Trep T : om. B

EPA2TAI

i37 c

6pO<as, "f) avrrj 6e Kat ytyyoSovcei TOVS ^YJOTOVS Kai TOVS 10

fjLO-)(6rjpovs, ?} ere'pa TIS;
'H avr?7, !0Tj.
E^eArjcreis ovz> Kai *car avOp&irovs TOVTO o/xoAoyeii',
/SeXrioTous avOpa>7rovs irotei, TCWTKIV e;ai Kat r^y d
-ai' op6S>s Kal StaytyvwcrKOiKray rows XP1?0"1"0^5 T
KOI jixox^Tjpovs;
Ilain; y', e<^>?].
O^KoSy Kat TJTIS eya, Kat TroAAovs, Kat fjris iroAXovs, Kai 5
fva;
Nai.
Kat Ka0' linruv 8r) Kai raw aAXcov ai7rayra)z; ovrcos;
Tis ovy 6(rriy ^ eiricrnj/ATj, ^Vts TOT)? er rat? TroAecrtv 10
aKoAacrraa'oyras Kat irapavofj,ovvTas 6p6>s KoAafet; ov^ ^

Nat.
"*H aXXrjv ovv TWO, KaAets Kat bt,K<uo<n>vr)v y
OVK, dAAa raurTjy.
15
OvKoCy $7rep KoAa^bucrty dp^ws, Tat/T?j Kat yiyycocrKoucri e
rovs )(/)7j<7roi)s Kat
"Oorts 8e e'ya ytyz^avcei, Kat iroAAovs yyw<rerat;
Nat'.
Kat oari? ye TroAAovs dypoel, Kat eVa;
Et apa tTTiros coy dyvooT roii? XJOTJOTOWS Kai
ITTTTOUS, Kay eavrov dyroot Trotos rts e
C 10 TJ atir^ Se B: avrtj T: WT)J Schanz
e n Ire'pa rts
B et yp. T: ^AA.:; T
013 avffpdiirovs] a.j>6p<airioi> Stephanus
d i pf\riffTovs B T : Pfkriovs al.
d 3 (cat T : Kal TOIIS B
d 5 OVKOVV
Kai B : OVK.OVV T
TJTJS . . . $}-ns T : e? rts . . . tl TIS B
d. 14 al B :
om. T
d 15 aA\a ra^TTjc B : #AAijj' T W
e 2 TOVS poxQilpofa
B : -irovripovs T
e 8 a^voo? B : ayvott T
TOVS xPT>(rTO^s Ka^
irovripovs lirirovs B : TOVS iroi'rjpous Kai TOVS xpiqffTobs T W

IIAAT&NOS
10
Kal el /Sous a>v ayvooi TOVS Trovrjpovs
(/3oi>s), KCLV avrbv ayvooi Ttolos TIS e
Nat, e(prj.
OVTCO brj KOI el K.v<av;

KCU

xprjorovs

15
138

Tt 8'; eTreibav avdpatTros TIS &>v ayvofj TOVS xPrl<rrovs

Kai p.o-^drjpovs avOp&Tiovs, ap' ofy avrbv ayvoei irorepov
os1 fcrriv ^ Troirrjpos, e-TreiSr)" Kat avros avOptoiros e

To 8e avrov ayvoeiv o-axppovfiv <TTIV rj JUT/ <ra>(J)poviv ;

M^ o-(o<ppoviv.
To eavTov apa ytyvoxTKeiv eort (

Tour' apa, a>s eoiKe, TO e^ Af\(pols ypa/u/Lta

10 o~a>(ppoo~vvrjv aa-Kfiv /cat
Tjj avrfj
b

be TavTy Kat KoA.a^eti' dpO&s

OVKOVV 17 /u,ei> KoA.a(etv 6pO&s

avrr] eo-Tiv, f) be biayiyv&o-Keiv Kal kavrbv KOI.

Tavrov apa eori KCU biKaiocruvi] Kai o~u>(ppoo~vvr] ;

^atVerai.
Kat fjfffv
ovrco ye Kat at iroAety ev otKOi5yrat, OTCLV 01

e 1 1 o-yj/oer B T : ayvooit] recc.

xPW'oi's B T : TOWS xP1tffro^>s a^e 12 /Sous add. Bekker
ayvooi B : ayvooiri T
TTO^S TJS B :
Trotbs T
a i ris $>v B ; #j/ TIS T
as fjiox^ripotis B : Tois
(noxOripovs Stobaeus : irov-ripovs T
a7oer T Stobaeus : ayvoo? T
a 3 irovrip6s B T : fjiox^Tlpos Stobaeus
a 5 eVrlj/ ^ ^ o-ta<j>povety;
(jdl aufypoveiv B : ^ ou <r<a<ppoi>eiv effriv; ov <ra><j>pove?v T Stobaeus
a 13 ra B: tprj/jLt TW Stobaeus
ba i\A.ous B: &\\ov T Stobaeus
b 5 Kal SiKaioffvv-rj /colffoctppocrvirr)B : SiKaiofffoy (rcaippoffvvt) T
b 7 al at B : Kat T

EPA2TA!

138 b

'AA?707/ Aeyeis, <f)rj.

Kai -rroAiTiKr/ apa avrri eoriy.

10

Ti 8e oray els duTJp op^ws -TroAty SIOIKT/, ovopd ve

rovrw ov Tvpavvos re Kai /3ao-iAei/s;
/3ct(riAiK7] re Kal rvpavvixy TtxyQ ^I-KL;
15
Ovrcos.
Kat awrai ap' ai avrat Tf^vat fltrlv *Kivais;
Qaivovrai.
Tt 8' oray ets cov dy^/3 olniav OIOIKTJ 6p6S>$, TL ovopa c
T(f ZCTTW; OVK oiKoyo/xos re Kai bftnroTris;
NaL
ovv Kai OVTOS biKawa-vvri eu av Tqv OLKICIV
rj KaXXrf rivl reyvri;
5
apa ravrov, ats eotxe, flao-iXevs, rvpavvos,
,

Seo-irorr;?,

<r<a(f)pMv,

binaios.

Kat jixia

eoriy /3a(riA.iK?/, TVpavviKr), woAiTtKr/, 8e<r7ror6K?7, OIKO-

10

ouf rw (piXocr6<p(j), orav ju,ey larpos Trepl T>V d

TI Aeyrj, aiffyjpov frfd' tirecrOai rols Aeyo/mevots
, Kai oirorav aAAoy TIS
orav be SiKaar^? ^ (3acriXevs rj dAAo? TIS wr 5
Z>W&T) bie\.r)\vOaiJ.V, OVK alcr^pov ire
bvva.(T0ai /xTyre (tu//,j8dAAe<r^at Trept avr&v;
b 10 au-rtj Schanz : ^ aur^; B : a?rr; T

b 12 ^e B : om. T

b 17 etVlf enelvcus B : ^Kfivcus slffiv T

C 2 OUK T : om. B
C 5 K#AA,?7 B : #A\j7 T
07 ravr6f~\ raii-rb B : TOUTO T
eg Sea-TroTiK'fi T W : om. B
C n ^77 otirus B: om. TW
d. I jr^repoi' B : rt T
iarpbs B : 6 larpbs T
d. 2 \eyofj.evois
T b : Svvafj.ei'ois pr. B (ut videtur)
d 3 TrepJ . . . d 4 TrpaTTo^tectuj/
B : om. T W
d 6 8i\i)\vea.Mev B : Si-fi\0ofj.fv T

I38d

riAATHNOS EPA2TAI
YI&s 8' OVK alcr^pov, o> 2ci)Kpares, irepi ye

TOO-OVTMV

Horepov ovv Kai Trcpl Tavra Aeyoojuev, (pt]v, ire

avrov 8eu> etvat Kat vitaKpov, nal ravrr/s juey ra 8eurepeia
< \OVTCL irdvToov rov <j)iX6<ro(f)ov, Kdl a\ptiov eivai. ews a^
TOVTOOV

TiS

f],

?7 TTpS>TOV

fJ,V

Tt]V

O.VTOV

OLKL(W

OVK

aAAfa)

5 (TTiTpeiTTeov ovSe ra 8eirre/3eia kv TOVTW kuTeov, aAA' avrov

xoAaareW SiKa^byra d/o^ws, et /tx^AAei e3 ot/ceto-^at
<pet 877 /xot.
ye STJTTOU eayre 01 ^>iAot avrw 8iatras eirirpe'10 TT<D<riv, edvTe fj TToAt? rt wpocrraTTr/ biciKpivfiv rj 8iKaeiv,
139 al&xpbv V TOVTOIS, S eraipe, 8evTepoy <pafoe(T0at rj rpirov
KO.I {JLrj ov^ rjycLcrOat;
AoKe? /xot.
IloAAoS apa Set T/JIUZJ, ai /SeAnare, TO </>iAo<ro<eTz> iroAu5 /ma^ta re eii>ai Kai r/ Trepi ras rf\vas
TrpayfMaTfCa.
8' e/Ao{5 raura 6 /bcez/ cro(f)bs atcrxvvOcls rols
(rfyrjaev, 6 8e dji>ta0rj
i ot aAAot kv^crav ra
e I <T;I' T : <>?; B
62 /cal Tafaris fiev TO, SevrepfTa B : TCI:
Seurepera 8' T W : Kai ev ro6rois TO. Sevrepe'ta Hermann
KOI . . . 6 4 ^
seel. Schanz
e 3 etos kv B : ecas T
6 4 ^ ^ T : ^ B
a 4 SelTW: om. B
iroAu/taft'a B: (j>i\ona.0ia T
' a s ^'del.
Schanz
a 7 e/ceiVws b : tneivos B T

O X F O R D CLASSICAL TEXTS
All prices are subject to alteration without notice
GREEK

All prices are net

Cloth India Paptr

AESCHYLUS. G. G. A. Murray
ANTONINUS. J. H. Leopold
APOLLONIUS RHODIUS. R. C. Seaton
ARISTOPHANES. F. W. Hall, W. M. Geldart
I. Ach., Eq., Nubes, Vesp., Pax, Aves, Second edition
II. Lys., Thesm., Ran., Eccl., Plutus, Fragmenta. Sec. ed.
ARISTOTLE. I. Bywater, F. G. Kenyon
De Arte Poetica. Second edition
De Caelo
Ethica
Atheniensium Respublica
BUCOLICI GRAECI. U. v. Wilamowitz-Moellendorff
DEMOSTHENES
I. Orationes I-XIX. S. H. Butcher
II. i. Orationes XX-XXVI. S. H. Butcher
II. ii. Orationes XXVII-XL. W. Rennie
III. Or. XLI-LXI; Procemia; Epistulae. W. Rennie
EURIPIDES. G. G. A. Murray
I. Cyc., Ate., Med., Heracl., Hip., Andr., Hec.
II. Suppl., Here., Ion, Tro., EL, I.T. Third ed.
III. Hel., Phoen., Or., Bacch., Iph. Aul, Rhesus
HELLENICA OXYRHYNCHIA cum ,Theopompi et\
Cratippi fragments. B. P. Grenfell, A. S. Hunt
J
HERODOTUS. K. Hude. Second edition
I (Books I-IV), II (Books V-IX)
each
HOMER
I-II. Iliad. D. B. Monro, T. W. Allen
Books I-XII. Second edition
Books XIII-XXIV. Third edition
III-IV. Odyssey. T.W.Allen
Books I-XII. Second edition
Books XIII-XXIV. Second edition
V. Hymns, &c. T. W. Allen
HYPERIDES. F. G. Kenyon
LONGINUS. A. O. Prickard. Second edition
June 1947

8s 6d
6s
65
6s
6s
35 6d
6s 6d
45 6d
6s
30*
75 6d
6*
6s
75 6d
21*
6s
6s
6s
I<W

7* 6d
30*
15*
55
5*
15*
55
55
7* 6d
6s
5*

GREEK (cont.)

All prices are net

Cloth India Papa

LYSIAS. K. Hude
6s
PINDAR. C. M. Bowra. Second edition
IDJ
PLATO. J. Burnet
I. Euth., Apol., Crit., Ph.; Crat. Tht., Soph., Polit. Ed. 2 7* 6d\
II. Par.,Phil.,Symp.,Phdr.; Ale.I,II,Hipp., Am. Ed. 2 7* 6d\
III. Thg., Chrm., Laches, Lysis, Euthd., Pro/., Gorg., \
,, I
Meno, Hp. Ma. et Min., lo, Mnx.
I '
)
IV. Clitophp, Respublica, Timaeus, Critias
ios\
Respublica separately, 7* 6d
} 255
V. Minos, Leges; Ep., Epp., Def., Spuria
ios>
SOPHOCLES, Fabulae. A. C. Pearson
8s 6d
THEOPHRASTUS, Characteres. H. Diels
6s
THUCYDIDES. H. Stuart Jones and J. E. Powell
15*
Books I-IV
6s
Books V-VIII
6s
XENOPHON. E. C. Merchant
I-V
35*
I. Historia Graeca, Ed. a
51
II. Libri Socratici and III. Anabasis
each 6s
IV. Institutio Cyri and V. Opuscula
each is 6d

LATIN

ASCONIUS. A. C. Clark
CAESAR, COMMENTARII. R. L. A. Du Pontet
I. Bcllum Gallicum
II. Beltum Civile
CATULLUS. R. Ellis
CICERO
EPISTOLAE. L. C. Purser
I. ad Fam.

6s
12$ 6d
'

5;
55
4 j 6d
ios

II. ad Alt., Pars i (1-8), Pars ii (9-16)

each 7* 6d
III. ad Q. P., ad M. Brut., Fragm.
5*
OHATIONES. A. C. Clark and W. Peterson
I. Rose. Am., I. Pomp., Clu., Cat., Mur., Gael. Clark 51
II. Pro Milone, Caesarianae, Philippicae. Clark. Ed. 2 5*
III. Verrinae. Peterson. Second edition
6s
IV. Quinct., Rose. Com., Caec., Leg. Agr., Rob. Perduell., \ s,
Place., Pis., Rob. Post. Clark
I *
V. Post Reditum, De Domo, Har. Resp., Sest., Vat., Prov. \ 5
Cons., Balb. Peterson
/ *
VI. Tull., Font., Sull.,Arch., Plane., Scaur. Clark
4* 6d

LATIN (cont.)
All prices are net
Cloth India
CICERO (cont.)
RHETORICA. A. S. Wilkins
I. De Oratore
II. Brutus, Sec.
6s
HORACE. E. C. Wickham. Ed. 2. H. W. Garrod
6s
6s
ISIDORI ETYMOLOGIAE. W. M. Lindsay. Two vols. 30*
LIVY. R. S. Conway and C. F. Walters
Books I-V
8s 6d
Books VI-X
85 6d
Books XXI-XXV
7* 6d
Books XXVI-XXX. R. S. Conway and S. K. Johnson
los
LUCRETIUS. C. Bailey
6s
MARTIAL. W. M. Lindsay
ics
NEPOS. E. O. Winstedt
4* 6d
OVID, Tristia, Epistulae ex Ponto, &c. S. G. Owen
6s
PERSIUS and JUVENAL. S. G. Owen. Second ed.
6s
PHAEDRUS, Fabulae. J. P. Postgate
7* 6d
PLAUTUS. W. M. Lindsay
I. Amphitruo-Mercator
ios 6d
II. Miles Gloriosus-Fragmenta
ios 6d
PROPERTIUS. J. S. Phillimore. Ed. 2
5*
STATIUS
Silvae. J. S. Phillimore. Second edition
6s
Thebais and Achilleis. H. W. Garrod
TACITUS
21J
Annales. C. D. Fisher
8s 6d
Historiae. C. D. Fisher
6s
Opera Minora. H. Furneaux
5s
TERENCE. W. M. Lindsay and R. Kauer. Second ed.
7s 6d ios
TIBULLUS. J. P. Postgate. Ed. 2
3* 6d
VELLEIUS PATERCULUS. R. Ellis
VIRGIL. Sir Arthur Hirtzel
6s
7s 6d
APPENDIX VERGILIANA. R. Ellis
6s
The Oxford Greek Testament, los 6d net (I.P. ias 6d net); Dr. Souter's
Pocket Lexicon to the above, 6s net; The New Testament in Latin,
5s net.

OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS

Amen House

Warwick Square

London, E.G. 4

LATIN (cont.)
All prices are net
Cloth India Pap r
CICERO (cont.)
'
RHETORICA. A. S. Wilkins
I. De Oratore
jsbd
II. Brutus, Sec.
6s
HORACE. E. C. Wickham. Ed. 2. H. W. Garrod
6s
6s
ISIDORI ETYMOLOGIAE. W. M. Lindsay. Two vols. 30*
LIVY. R. S. Conway and C. F. Walters
Books I-V
8s 6d
Books VI-X
8s 6d
Books XXI-XXV
7* 6<*
Books XXVI-XXX. R. S. Conway and S. K. Johnson
ios
LUCRETIUS. C. Bailey
6s
MARTIAL. W. M. Lindsay
ios
NEPOS. E. O. Winstedt
4* M
OVID, Tristia, Epistulae ex Ponto, &c. S. G. Owen
6s
PERSIUS and JUVENAL. S. G. Owen. Second ed.
6s
PHAEDRUS, Fabulae. J. P. Postgate
7* 6rf
PLAUTUS. W. M. Lindsay
I. Ampkitruo-Mercator
ios 6d
II. Miles Gloriosus-Fragmenta
ios 6d
PROPERTIUS. J. S. Phillimore. Ed. 2
5*
STATIUS
Silvae. J. S. Phillimore. Second edition
6s
Thebais and Achilleis. H. W. Garrod
TACITUS
2is
Annales. C. D. Fisher
8s 6d
Histariae. C. D. Fisher
6s
Opera Minora. H. Furneaux
5s
TERENCE. W. M. Lindsay and R. Kauer. Second ed.
7s 6d ios
TIBULLUS. J. P. Postgate. Ed. 2
3* ^
VELLEIUS PATERCULUS. R. Ellis
VIRGIL. Sir Arthur Hirtzel
6s
^s 6d
APPENDIX VERGILIANA. R. Ellis
6s
The Oxford Greek Testament, ios 6d net (I.P. ias 6d net); Dr. Souter's
Pocket Lexicon to the above, 6s net; The New Testament in Latin,
5s net.

OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS

Amen House

Warwick Square

London, E.G. 4