1

E


.

[ : ] {.}72:

.

[
] { . }2:
[ ]
{.}111:


.



[ ] {. }12:
 4

[ ]

{.}11:
[ ] {.}141:


" : "
!
5

Creed or Chaos

"
".
 6

Creed or Chaos
Richard Dawkins

.
" :
()1
" .

.

.

[ ] [.]04 :
.
.
.
" :
()2
" .

(1) It is pretty hard to defend absolute morals on grounds other than religious

)ones. (The god Delusion, p.232

(2) What's to prevent us from saying Hitler wasnt right? I mean that is a genuinely

difficult question.
 7

.
!
:

.

!


"" !
" :Carl Sagan ...
()1
" .
George Gaylord Simpson
" :
()2
" .

http://byfaithonline.com/richard-dawkins-the-atheist-evangelist/

(1) Essentially the same laws and conistants are required to make a rock

Carl Sagan, Pale Blue Dot: A Vision of the Human Future in Space.

(2) Man is the result of apurposless and natural processthat didnt have him in min.
 8

- !-
!

!
.

.
" :Stephen Gay Gould
.
()1
" .
.
[ ]
{. }11:
!
!

.

Simpson, George Gaylord. 1794. The Meaning of Evolution. New Haven, CT: Yale

University Press, P.303.

(1) The meaning of life: reflctions in words and pictures on why we are here, 1771,

p.3.
 9

.

.
!



()1
- !

.

. Arthur Allen Leff
" :
()2
" .
.

(1) One man said he didn't sleep for three nights after reading The Selfish Gene. He

felt that the whole of his life had become empty, and the universe no longer had a

poin.

Reinventing the Future, p.112.

(2)there is today no way of proving that napalming babies is ba Economic Analysis

of Law: Some Realism about Nominalism (1790).

 11

.

!

Czeslaw
Milosz " "The discreet charms of nihililsm
" : "

.
!
.

" :
()1
" .





!
:
.
.

.
!

(1) Your belief that rape is wrong is an arbitrary conclusion From an interview with

Justin Brierley of unbelievable.

 11

!
.

!
.
!
 12

Creed or Chaos

.

.


!

()1
.

.
.
!
.
.
Jean-Paul Sartre

" :
()2
" .
!

( )1 pigeon feathers

( )2 )Jean-Paul Sartre, Nausea (novel)( .

 13

mayflies
()1
). (Chet Raymo

()2
). (Richard Dawkins

.
[ ] {.}6:

.
"".
!

(1)We are small, contingent parts of something that existed long before we

appeared on the scene. . . . We are as incidental to the cosmos as are ephemeral

mayflies to the planet Earth. At first glance, this was shattering news. Indeed, the

majority of us have not yet come to terms with it. . . . Our lives are brief, our fate is

oblivion.

Raymo, Chet. 8991. Skeptics and True Believers. New York, NY: Walker, p.222.

(2) ""has shown higher purpose to be an illusion.

"A Scientist's Case Against God,

 14

.

-
-


.


()1
" : " .
-
.
:

.
.
Cytoplasm .
()2
. -

(1) Descartes, principes de la philosophie, p.22

" . "97

(2) merely a computer made of mea

Raymo, Chet. 8991. Skeptics and True Believers. New York, NY: Walker, p.811-811.
 15

-
()1
). (almost a truism
.
.
" :
()2
" .
.
!
()3
" : " . .

" :
()4
" .

( )1 .892

(2) The universe we observe has precisely the properties we should expect if there

is, at bottom no design, no purpose, no evil and no good, nothing but blind, pitiless

indifference.

River out of Eden, p.131-132

(3) The god delusion, p.279, 27.

(0) - Selfish Gene, p. 7.

 16

Sam Harris
" :
()1
" .


()2
. -
!
.
!
!
!
.



- Prometheus - .
-
!

(1) -Some propositions are so dangerous that it may even be ethical to kill people

for believing them.

The End of Faith, p.32

(2) -Harris, S. (2442) the End of Faith, the Free Press, P.127.
 17

!
!
.
!

!


!
. !
[ ] {.}131:


.
Victor Hugo
Javert Jean
Valjean .

!
!
 18

.
.
!

!


-


.
! ...
19

"
"

 21

!

.



.


!
!


!
. " :

()1
" .

( )1 " . ".
 21

: -

Stephen Hawking
" "the Grand Design

!
[ .
]
{.}121:
)1239( Descartes

-cogito

.
David Hume .
Immanuel Kant
.post-modernism
.. .. .
.
 22

- - " :
()1
" .
Andr Gide
:
()2
" .. " .
.
-
.-

" :

()3
. " .

!

.

" : -

( )1" : : ".

( )2 . " " 3 .1703

( )3 .317
 23

()1
" .

!
- " :-
()2
" .

()3
.
. .
" :
()4
" .
.

. .

.
!

( )1 .10

( )2 .92

( )3 .92

( )0 .27-2
 24

" :
()1
" .

.
[ ] {.}11:

. .
:

!
.
- " :-
()2
. "-
.
.
!


:
!
- - " : ...

( )1 .232-2

( )2 .391
 25

()1
" .
!

:

( )1 .037

: ""

. "
 26

.
star-stuff
()1
.

()2
.
!
.

[ ] {.}131:
" :





.

(1) Video Source: The Shores of the Cosmic Ocean [Episode 1].

Some part of our being knows this is where we came from. We long to return. And

we can. Because the cosmos is also within us. We're made of star-stuff. We are a

way for the cosmos to know itself. 42 min 40 sec.

(2) cosmically inconsequential bundles of stardust, adrift in an infinite and

purposeless universe.
 27

[ :
] {.}177:

.
" "
[( :
] {.}27:
()1
" .

!

. .

: !

""
" " "" " ".
!

!

( )1 .7370-17
 28

!


.

.

. .

- -
.

. .


" :


()1
" .
:
[ ] {.}44:
.

( )1 .79
 29

.
!
!
" :
()1
" .
-
- -

" :

()2
" .
" :


.


...

...

( )1 .

( )2 .090
 31

.




()1
" .
.


!


.
" "

" "
()2
.
- -

[ ] {.}61:
!
- .

( )1 393

.317

( )2 [ ] {.}714:
 31

-
- - " :
()1
" .
" "
- - -

!

( )1 17.11
 32

!
.
: .
!
.
.

.



.
- [
] {.}1:
- -
.
-
!

- - .

- -

- -
- .-
 33

- .-

.
- -
" :
.



.
.


.




.




 34

.













.


()1
" .


" :


()2
" .

( )1 .2227-2

( )2 .03-2
 35

.


-
.-

- - .
- -
.
.
[
- -

] {.}32:
-


-
!-


-
- -

[ ] {.}43:
- - .
 36



[
] { .}11:
( : )
( ) ( ) ( )
( ).
- -
[

] { .}16:
-
.
.
[ :
] {
.}61:
: -
:
: :
()1
! .

( )1 .
 37

!

!

: !
[
] { .}21:

.
[ ] {.}71:
( ) ( )
()1
.

!

( )1 .
 38

- -

.




-









-
!


- -
.
-

. - -
" :


...
()1
" .
- -

" ." :

( )1 :

.
 39

()1
! .


- - -
- .-

-

()2
.


. - -

.
-
- .
.



.

.
.

( )1 242 /1 : .

( )2 .
 41

.
-
()1
! .





[
] {.}46:

()2
.

- -


-

()3
. -
:

( )1 : (.)2147

( )2 " . ".

( )3..
 41

.
- " : -

()1
" .

!
!

- - .

- .

" : -


()2
" .


.

-
!
- -

( )1 (.)2092

( )2 .
 42

.
()1
- - .
()2
.

- -

- - -
.
:
: . - : -



()3
.


()4
.
.
.

- -
: - -

: : ! !

( )1 (.)0733

( )2 .

( )3 : ( )0713 ( .)1097 : (.)244/1

( )0 : ( )2712 (.)1243
 43

.


- -


:
()1
.


- - :
.
()2
- - .
.


.
- -


.
()3
- - .

.

( )1 (.)701

( )2 ( ) 0992 (.)0993

( )3 " . ".
 44

- -
- -
.

- -

.
!
:

.
- -
.

()1
.


[
] {.}12:
- - !

( )1..
 45

- -
- -
.
!


()1
.

()2
! .

- -
" :
()3
" .
- -
()4
.

-
- -

( )1 . ( )2262 (.)8982

( )2 ..

( )3 .18-2

( )0 (.)881
 46

- .

- -

- :-



()1
.

- -

.

- - :
.

-

:
: -

-

-
()2
. . -
- - :
:
.

:
:
- .-
- - " : :

( )1 .2019

( )2 ( )122/3 ( .)193 : .
 47

:


()1
" .


- -
- - :
:

()2
. : .

- -

- :- -
()3
- .

-
: .
: .

()4
- . -

- -
- : - -

: . -

( )1 : ( )3220 (.)2034

( )2 .772

( )3 (.)1230

( )0 (.)1997
 48

: :
: !

: .
: . :
.
- -

: :
()1

.


! - -
. - :-
.


.
- - :
()2
.
()3
- .

( )1 (.)3242

( )2 (.)2777

( )3 2.2 1.2 .

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_religious_populations
 49

()1
! .
-

- -

- - .

()2
.
- -
()3

.
- -
-

- .
" : -

( )1 :

- .

.
-
-
.

!.

( )2 .342

( )3 ( )302 ( )2307 ( )1903(.)147-2

 51

-
()1
" .
- -


- -
()2
.




" : - -
-
- -
()3
-17-. "-

()4
. .

- -

( )1 .117/3

( )2 (.)304/1

( )3 .31

( )0 ( )1219 ( )2217 ( )3397 ( )0141 ( .)2032

!.
 51

()1
.

.
- -
.

-
- !

- -
!

( )1 " :- " .

.- (.)3397
 52

"


"
 53

.


()1

.




.
.
[
] {.}36:


-
- .
!
.

( )1 " : . ".
 54

.

!



.




()1

. ! .
" :
:
.
.
.
()2
" .
""
[ ] {.}1:
: .

.

.

( )1 .139

( )2 .033 -3
 55

.
" :







()1
" .

.
.
.

.
" : -

()2
" .
- - " :
".

( )1 / .

( )2 .030 -3
 56

.


.
.
:
.
.
.


()1
.


.
[ :
]
{.}44:
[ ]
{.}113:
( : ) ( )

()2
.

( )1 " " ..

( )2 .
 57

" "
[
] {.}71:

Shall we
.compel you to accept it
. "
" [
] {.}77:

.

[ :
]
{.}39-33 :
()1
: ! .
!

( )1 .0341
 58

.
[ : ] {.}74:
.

()1
.
:


. " : - -




.
!





()2
" .

.

( )1 " " 323-1 .

( )2 . .03-00
 59

!
" :

!


()1
" .

.
[ ]
{.}76:

- -
-
- - - .

:

.



-

( )1 .!.
 61
()1
- .




.

-

.
" :

()2

" .


.
.


[
] {.}6:
!


!

- -
!

( )1 312/1 .372/1

( )2.2279 :
 61

.
[
]
{.}73:

()1
.
- [

] {.}11:
" :
" . .



.
- - .
[ ] {.}41:

- - :

( )1 " . ".
 62

- .

()1
.
!

( )1 . " :



- - .

- -

.

" .-
 63

.
.
.


.
.
.
!

.

. .
. .
!

.

.

:
. !
:

[ ] {. }3:
[] {.}76:

 64

. !
[ ] { :

.}13-12

- " :
".

. !
[
] [.]12-12 :
: . -
()1

.
- - .


.
. .

.
[ ]
{.}42:
.
[ :

( )1 .
 65

] {.}22:
.









!



-




[

] {.}9-2 :
-
.
" :
-
 66

.

()1
" .

[
] {.}17:
" : ...
".
:
[

] {.}12-11 :

.

!
-
.
[ :

( )1 011-2.
 67

] [.]3-0 :
.
!

()1
!
[
] [.]3-0 :
()2

!
.
. [ :

] {.}72:
. " :

(1) http://www.angelfire.com/nt/Gilgamesh/sasanian.html

https://goo.gl/GWGDyr :

( )2 .
 68

:
[
] { }72:
()1
" .

[
] {.}33:
!
.
[ ] {.}26:
- -
[ ] {.}12:
.
[ ] {.}71:
!
!

( )1 .07-07
 69

.
!
.
.
.
.
- -
.


" "




.

!
[
] {.}44:


!
:

 71

.
: .

!

- -
. " :
:
- -

.
:





.

:

:
[
] {.}112:

 71

.


[
] {.}16:

()1
" .

-

- -
- .


30.


.


.
.
.


.

( )1 . .04
 72

" "

:
!
!
()1
!

!
.

-
[]
{.}71:

.
!

- - Bucaillism

()2
1044 .
.

(1) http://chsi.harvard.edu/bok/42.html.

(2) Bucaillism at Wikipedia.

 73

. - !
! - -

:
: (.)1
(.)2
(.)3
(.)4

744
73 .
: (.)5

.

( )1 .12 1

( )2 .34

( )3 .03-33

( )0 .34

( )3 .77 1
 74

.
. " :

-

-






()1
" .

- -
" :-



- -



.

.

( )1 . .-
 75

- - [
]
()1
{. "}16:
:
.

( )1 .21
 76

3 ............................................................................................. E

5 ......................................................................
6 ................................................................................
21 ................................................................................

21 ..............................................................................
12 .........................................................................................
16 ...........................................................
31 .....................
- 33 ............................................................... -
- 55 ........................................................ -

51 ....................................................
53 ..................................................................