Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1E5 Glass Structures L1 ME
1E5 Glass Structures L1 ME
Introduction
• Introduction
Experimental
research
• Experimental research
Elements
subjected to
bending • Elements subjected to bendings
Lateral torsional
buckling • Lateral torsional buckling
Design methods
• Design methods
2
CTU in Prague
Practical examples
Objectives
Introduction
Museum of glass - Kingwindford, United Kingdom
Experimental • structure of extension: length 11,0 m
research
• distance 1,1 m
Elements
subjected to
• height of column 3,5 m, depth 200 mm
bending • span of beam 5,7 m, depth 300 mm
Lateral torsional
buckling • columns, beams – laminated
Design methods glass
• snow load 0,75kN/m2
• roof, walls: insulated glass
units
Design methods
4
CTU in Prague
Practical examples
Objectives
Introduction
Experimental
research
Elements
subjected to
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
5
CTU in Prague
Practical examples
Objectives
Canopies – Nijmegen, Netherlands 1999
Introduction
Experimental
research
Elements
subjected to
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
Cross section
1 – clamped steel column HEB300
2 – horizontal steel beam HEA300
3 – continuous glass beam – 3x
10mm, float glass
4 – glass roof panels – 2x 10mm,
float glass
5 – vertical glass panel in gutter
6
CTU in Prague
Practical examples
Objectives
Glass canopy at the underground station – Tokyo, Japan
Introduction
1996
Experimental
research
Elements
subjected to
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
• built-up beam
• size 10,6 x 4,8 m
• height 4,8 m
• length of cantilever 9 m
• beam composed from
triangular fins
7
CTU in Prague
Practical examples
Objectives
Glass canopy at the underground station – Tokyo, Japan
Introduction
1996
Experimental
research • panes with length 1,9 – 2,5 m
Elements • toughened glass 2x 15 mm
subjected to
bending
• bolted connection
8
CTU in Prague
Practical examples
Objectives
Glass roof of interior courtyard, commercial building in
Introduction
Munich, Germany 2003
secondary
Experimental
research beams
Elements
subjected to
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
primary
Design methods beams
Elements
subjected to
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
10
CTU in Prague
Practical examples
Objectives
Glass roof for refectory at the TU Dresden, Germany 2006
Introduction
Experimental
research
Elements
subjected to
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
11
CTU in Prague
Practical examples
Objectives
Glass roof for refectory at the TU Dresden, 2006
Introduction
Experimental
research
Elements
subjected to
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
13
CTU in Prague
Practical examples
Objectives
Glass roof for university of Glasgow, 2002
Introduction
Experimental
research
Elements
subjected to
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
14
CTU in Prague
Practical examples
Objectives
Glass roof for dry dock – Bristol, 2005
Introduction
Experimental
research
Elements
subjected to
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
• historic passenger liner built from iron special dry dock to protect ship hull
• plates 2x 10mm heat-strengthened glass with size 4,35 x 1,5m – at waterline
• area 1000m2, 50mm of water weighing about 50 t – illusion of the dock
• the ship expand, contract and bend sideways in response to shifts in
temperature junction between the waterline plate and the ship had to
accommodate movements flexible collar
15
CTU in Prague
Practical examples
Glass roof for dry dock – Bristol, 2005
Introduction LTB
Experimental
Experiments
research
Elements
subjected to
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
17
CTU in Prague
Experimental research
Objectives
Introduction LTB
Experimental
Experiments
research
Elements
subjected to
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
18
CTU in Prague
Experimental research
Objectives
Introduction LTB
Experimental
Experiments
research
Elements
subjected to
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
19
CTU in Prague
Experimental research
Objectives
Introduction
LTB
Experimental
Experiments
research
Elements
subjected to
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
Introduction
LTB
Experimental
Experiments
research
Elements
subjected to
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
DESIGN METHOD
• design according to the elastic stability
• finite elements methods
• tests 1:1
Introduction
• it is possible to use for checking of buckling for glass fin with free
edges (without intermediate buckling restraint)
22
CTU in Prague
Lateral torsional buckling
Objectives
Introduction
LINEAR THEORY OF ELASTICITY
Experimental
• perfect elastic beam without any imperfections with rectangular cross-
research section is subjected to an increasing load – bending moment M
Elements • instability (combination of lateral deflection and twisting) occurs
subjected to
bending suddenly when a critical load is reached M = MCR, where critical
Lateral torsional
torsional buckling moment is
buckling
23
CTU in Prague
Lateral torsional buckling
Objectives
Introduction
LINEAR THEORY OF ELASTICITY
Experimental
• perfect elastic beam without any imperfections with rectangular cross-
research section is subjected to an increasing load – bending moment M
Elements • instability (combination of lateral deflection and twisting) occurs
subjected to
bending suddenly when a critical load is reached M = MCR, where critical
Lateral torsional
torsional buckling moment is
buckling
23
CTU in Prague
Lateral torsional buckling
Objectives
Introduction
LINEAR THEORY OF ELASTICITY
Experimental
• perfect elastic beam without any imperfections with rectangular cross-
research section is subjected to an increasing load – bending moment M
Elements • instability (combination of lateral deflection and twisting) occurs
subjected to
bending suddenly when a critical load is reached M = MCR, where critical
Lateral torsional
torsional buckling moment is
buckling
23
CTU in Prague
Lateral torsional buckling
Objectives
Introduction
LINEAR THEORY OF ELASTICITY
Experimental
• perfect elastic beam without any imperfections with rectangular cross-
research section is subjected to an increasing load – bending moment M
Elements • instability (combination of lateral deflection and twisting) occurs
subjected to
bending suddenly when a critical load is reached M = MCR, where critical
Lateral torsional
torsional buckling moment is
buckling
23
CTU in Prague
Lateral torsional buckling
Objectives
Introduction
Critical torsional buckling moment depends on:
Experimental • different moment distribution over the beam
research
• boundary conditions
Elements
subjected to
bending • distance between the centre of gravity and the point where the
load is applied
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
Influence of following aspects on behaviour of glass
beams must be taken into account:
• glass thickness
• initial deformation – float x tempered glass
• laminated glass: shear modulus of PVB foil temperature
• load duration
• damage of glass surface
• tensile strength of glass
24
CTU in Prague
Lateral torsional buckling
Objectives
Elements
• simple supported beam, concentrated load at mid-span
subjected to
bending • stress distribution is nonlinear over the beam height
Lateral torsional • lateral torsional buckling resistance is not limited by the critical
buckling
torsional buckling moment
Design methods
• tensile strength of glass is determinant for the buckling resistance
• influence of elastic interlayer (PVB foil) on the buckling strength –
temperature, load duration, thickness of the glass as well as
thickness of the interlayer
25
CTU in Prague
Lateral torsional buckling
Objectives
A) Monolithic glass – Analytical model
Introduction
Experimental
research
Elements
subjected to
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
2
EI z GI L2 Critical LTB
2
M CR C1 2
C2 z a 2 t
C2 z a Moment
L EI z
• Ci, za …take into account different boundary conditions, different bending
moment, distance between the centre of gravity and the load point
• LTB formulas for steel are valid, e.g. EC3
26
CTU in Prague
Lateral torsional buckling
Objectives
B) Laminated glass – Analytical model
Introduction
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
2 E g I z eff 2 GI
t eff L 2
M CR C1 C2 z a 2 C2 z a
L 2
E g I z eff
27
CTU in Prague
Lateral torsional buckling
Objectives
B) Laminated glass – Analytical model
Introduction
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
2 E g I z eff 2 GI
t eff L 2
M CR C1 C2 z a 2 C2 z a
L 2
E g I z eff
27
CTU in Prague
Lateral torsional buckling
Objectives
Introduction
B) Laminated glass – Analytical model
Experimental • it is possible to use same formula for MCR
research
• lateral bending stiffness EIz and the torsional stiffness GIt are replaced by an
Elements equivalent stiffness (EgIz)eff a (GIt)eff (determined by sandwich theory)
subjected to
bending
Wölfel
Eg Wt g t g tint
E I
g z eff E g I z ,lower Bs Bs
E g t g tint
2
1 12 2
Gint 2 L
28
CTU in Prague
Lateral torsional buckling
Objectives
Introduction
B) Laminated glass – Analytical model
Experimental Effective torsional stiffness (GIt)eff
research
Elements Luible GI t eff GI t glass1 GI t glass 2 GI t comp
subjected to
bending Glas
PVB
Glas h
Lateral torsional tanh
buckling
GI t comp GI s 1 2
Design methods h
MT
hB
z
2
x
y
Gint t g1 t g 2
t1
t PVB t
tg1 tint 2
tg2 G tint t g 1t g 2
Scarpino GI t eff GI t f
Gint
6t g3 tint
Gg
W 2 4tint
2
6t g tint 3t g2
f
Gint
2
t 6t g tint W 2
g
G
g 29
CTU in Prague
Lateral torsional buckling
Objectives
Introduction
Interlayer shear stiffness - Gint
Experimental • Influence of the shear modulus GPVB on the critical lateral torsional buckling
research load Mcr,LT
Elements
• The curves ratio Mcr,LT / Mcr,LT, without PVB
subjected to
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
30
CTU in Prague
Lateral torsional buckling
Objectives
Introduction
B) Laminated glass – Analytical model
Experimental • Stress problem is not solved analytically
research
Elements
subjected to C) Non-linear buckling analysis – second order calculation
bending
31
CTU in Prague
Lateral torsional buckling
Objectives
D) Laminated glass – Numerical model
Introduction
glass
Bonding condition:
x u=0, φy=φz=0
z y
z y
My 44
Introduction
Only existing code:
Experimental Australian Standard AS 1288: Glass in Buildings – selection and
research
installation
Elements
subjected to Appendix C: Buckling of glass fins
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling M cr
Design methods
M Ed Simple approach
1,7
33
CTU in Prague
Design methods
Objectives
Introduction
determination of the lateral and torsional buckling
resistance
Experimental
research
Lateral torsional
2) buckling curves
buckling
• slenderness ratio depends on tensile strength of the glass
Design methods
p ,t 2 p ,t I y
CR MCR h
where
σp,t - tensile strength of glass,
σCR - critical lateral torsional buckling stress,
Mcr - elastic critical moment
34
CTU in Prague
Design methods
Objectives
Design – buckling curve
Introduction
• Slenderness DLT
Experimental 1.2
research p ,t
p ,t 2 p ,t I y 1.0
LT
D
cr , D
Elements LT
subjected to CR M CR h D y
bending 0.8 LT p ,t
Lateral torsional
buckling
• Reduction factor LTB 0.6
Design methods
LT f LT 0.4
0.2
• Bending strength taking into 0.0
account LTB 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5
coefficient d’élancement
2I y slenderness
au déversement LT
D
M Rd LT p ,t LT p ,tW y
z
• Verification
M Rd M Ed
35
CTU in Prague
Design methods
Objectives
Design – buckling curve
Introduction
• Slenderness DLT
Experimental 1.2
research p ,t
p ,t 2 p ,t I y 1.0
LT
D
cr , D
Elements LT
subjected to CR M CR h D y
bending 0.8 LT p ,t
Lateral torsional
buckling
• Reduction factor LTB 0.6
Design methods
LT f LT 0.4
0.2
• Bending strength taking into 0.0
account LTB 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5
coefficient d’élancement
2I y slenderness
au déversement LT
D
M Rd LT p ,t LT p ,tW y
z
• Verification
M Rd M Ed
35
CTU in Prague
Design methods
Objectives
Design – buckling curve
Introduction
• Slenderness DLT
Experimental 1.2
research p ,t
p ,t 2 p ,t I y 1.0
LT
D
cr , D
Elements LT
subjected to CR M CR h D y
bending 0.8 LT p ,t
Lateral torsional
buckling
• Reduction factor LTB 0.6
Design methods
LT f LT 0.4
0.2
• Bending strength taking into 0.0
account LTB 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5
coefficient d’élancement
2I y slenderness
au déversement LT
D
M Rd LT p ,t LT p ,tW y
z
• Verification LTB buckling curves need to
be established for glass
M Rd M Ed
35
CTU in Prague
Design methods
Objectives
Design – buckling curve
Introduction
• for different types of loading, glass geometries, shear modulus of PVB
Experimental
research
interlayer and initial deformations it is possible derived different buckling
curves reduction factor
Elements
subjected to • buckling curve (c) from Eurocode may be used as a conservative approach
bending
Lateral torsional
buckling
Design methods
slenderness LT
36
CTU in Prague
Design methods
Objectives
g
Elements
subjected to M CR 1
EI y GJ
0 ,5
bending Lay
Lateral torsional
buckling where MCR critical elastic buckling moment
Design methods g1 constant from table
Lay distance between effectively rigid buckling restraints
(EI)y effective rigidity for bending about the minor axis
GJ effective torsional rigidity
J torsional moment of inertia
db 3 b
J 1 0 ,63
3 d
d, b depth and breadth of the beam
37
CTU in Prague
Design methods
Objectives
intermediate buckling
Introduction side view of beam
y restraint
Experimental
M M
research
Elements z z
subjected to Lay
bending
y
Lateral torsional
buckling top view of beam x
Design methods
38
CTU in Prague
Design methods
Objectives
Introduction
Australian standard AS 1288 - 1994: apendix H
Experimental
research
2. Beams without intermediate buckling restraint
Elements
subjected to
bending
MCR g 2
0 ,5
EI y GJ 1 g 3 y h / Lay EI y GJ
0 ,5
Lateral torsional
buckling
Lay
Design methods
where MCR critical elastic buckling moment
g2, g3 constants from table
Lay distance between effectively rigid buckling restrains
(span of beam)
(EI)y effective rigidity for bending about the minor axis
GJ effective torsional rigidity
yh height above centroid of the point of load application
39
CTU in Prague
Design methods
Objectives
Condition of end Coefficient
Introduction Type of loading Bending moment M restraint against
rotation about y-y g2 g3
Experimental
free 3,6 1,4
research
wL2ay
Elements fixed 6,1 1,8
subjected to Lay 8
bending
free 4,1 4,9
Lateral torsional wL2ay
buckling fixed 5,4 5,2
Lay 12
Design methods
free 4,2 1,7
F FLay
fixed 6,7 2,6
Lay 4
free 5,3 4,5
F FLay fixed 6,5 5,3
Lay 8
free 3,3 1,3
F/2 F/2 FLay fixed - -
Lay 8
40
CTU in Prague
Design methods
Objectives
Introduction
Australian standard AS 1288 - 1994: apendix H
Experimental
research
3. Continuously restrained beams on tension side
Elements
subjected to 2
2 d 2
bending
La EI y y 0 GJ
Lateral torsional
4
buckling MCR
Design methods 2 y0 y h
41
CTU in Prague
Design methods
Objectives
42
CTU in Prague
References
Educational pack of COSTActin TU0905 „Structural Glass - Novel design methods and next generation
products“
HALDIMANN, Matthias; LUIBLE, Andreas; OVEREND, Mauro.
Structural Use of Glass. Structural Engineering Documents 10 , IABSE, Zürich:2008. ISBN 978-3-85748-
119-2
THE INSTITUTION OF STRUCTURAL ENGINEERS
Structural use of glass in buildings, London: The institution of Structural Engineers, 1999.
KASPER, Ruth.
Tragverhalten von Glasträgern, RWTH Aachen, Aachen: Shaker Verlag, 2005.
Australian Standard AS 1288.
Glass in Buildings – Selection and installation, Appendix C: Basis for determination of fin design to prevent
buckling, 2006.
AMADIO, Claudio; BEDON, Chiara.
Buckling of laminated glass elements in out-of-plane bending, Engineering Structures 32 (2010), 3780–
3788.
BELIS, Jan; MOCIBOB, Danijel; LUIBLE, Andreas; VANDEBROEK, Marc.
On the size and shape of initial out-of-plane curvatures in structural glass components, Construction and
Building Materials 25 (2011), 2700–2712.
LUIBLE, A.
Stabilität von Tragelementen aus Glas. Dissertation EPFL thèse 3014. Lausanne: 2004.
LINDNER, J.; HOLBERNDT, T.
Zum Nachweis von stabilitätsgefährdeten Glasträgern unter Biegebeanspruchung. Stahlbau 75(6) (2006),
488-498.
43
CTU in Prague
Thank you
for your kind attention
44
53