RIYADH METRO PROJECT (RMP)

SUPPLIER/SUBCONTRACT TECHNICAL REVIEW SHEET (STRS)

PO/SO Number M-BCW-1F8000-CMEP-SUB-000003 PO/SO Title Zamil Projects
Supplier Transmittal Ref. BNR-STRAN-002126 STRS Identification M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-TRV-000027 Revision: 001

Transmittal / Document Title Shop Drawings Status Code Code 2

100% Design Package CRS

Document Type SDR Code & No.
Please Select
Submission
(Internal) 01
IFC Design Package CRS Number
Date 13/Feb/19 Code & No.
Please Select

Discipline Involved CELD Reviewed by (BACS) Sign

Prepared by (RMTC)
Location 1F8DS0 Reviewed by (RMTC)
Approved by (RMTC) Sign

Disclaimer : Permission to proceed does not constitute acceptance or approval of design details, calculations, analyses, test methods or materials developed or selected by the subcontractor/supplier and does not relieve subcontractor/supplier from full compliance with contractual obligations or
release any "holds" placed on the contract.

BACS Status Codes : 1 - Work may proceed; 2 - Revise and Resubmit. Work may Proceed Subject to Resolution of Indicated Comments; 3 - Revise and resubmit. Work may Not Proceed; 4 – Review Not Required. Work may Proceed; Rejected – Rejected. Work may Not Proceed

RMTC Status Codes : A - Reviewed; Work may proceed; B - Reviewed with comments; Revise & resubmit. Work may proceed subject to incorporation of comments; C - Objection; Revise & resubmit; Work not proceed; D - Rejected; E - Review not required; Work may proceed

Note to Supplier/Subcontractor: Approval coding by BACS is for information only. Final approval to be provided by RMTC.

BACS Review

No. Document Number Rev BACS Comments (Designer, ICE, other) Comments Made by Initial Status Supplier / Fabricator / Subcontractor Response Responded By Revised Status

In MCP-03, add the load for the FCU units near the "M" symbol as it
1 001 Najib Khneisser Code 2
was done for the rest of the items.
In MCP-05, add the load for the FCU units near the "M" symbol as it
2 001 Najib Khneisser Code 2
was done for the rest of the items.
Some of the mechanical loads in the latest load report submitted "1F8
3 001 Load verification 21.01.2019 modified" is not matching with the loads Najib Khneisser Code 2
shown in the MCC schematics. Ex: MCP-06, Fan-05.
In MCP-09, add the load for the FCU units near the "M" symbol as it
4 001 Najib Khneisser Code 2
was done for the rest of the items.
In MCP-07, add the load for the FCU units near the "M" symbol as it
5 001 Najib Khneisser Code 2
was done for the rest of the items.
In MCP-13, add the load for the FCU units near the "M" symbol as it
6 001 Najib Khneisser Code 2
was done for the rest of the items.
In MCC-15, add the load for the FCU units near the "M" symbol as it
7 001 Najib Khneisser Code 2
was done for the rest of the items.
In MCP-13, FCU 103, and FCU 112 are connected to the same circuit.
However, on the load report, it shows that FCU 103 and FCU 112 are
8 001 Najib Khneisser Code 3
on different circuits, with FCU 103 3 phase and FCU 112 single phase.
Clarify and rectify.
In MCC-15, FCU 102 is showing 0.27 KVA as TCL, while in the load
9 001 Najib Khneisser Code 3
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-010110 report, FCU 102 is showing 3.26 KW. Clarify and rectify.
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-010111 In MCP-17, add the load for the FCU units near the "M" symbol as it
10 M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-010112 001 Najib Khneisser Code 2
was done for the rest of the items.
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-010113
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-010114 In MCP-16 (E), Fan 29 is showing 13.2 KW (17.32 KVA) as TCL, while
11 M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-010115 001 Najib Khneisser Code 3
in the load report, Fan 29 is showing 8.66 KW. Clarify and rectify.
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-010116
In MCP-19, add the load for the FCU units near the "M" symbol as it
12 001 Najib Khneisser Code 2
was done for the rest of the items.

434211111.xlsx Page 1 of 2
 M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-010113
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-010114
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-010115
M-BNR-1F8DS0-CELD-SDR-010116
No. Document Number Rev BACS Comments (Designer, ICE, other) Comments Made by Initial Status Supplier / Fabricator / Subcontractor Response Responded By Revised Status

In MCC-18 (E), CWS-P-002/003/004 is not showing the total KW on the

13 001 Najib Khneisser Code 2
controller. To be added.
In MCC-18 (E), add the load for the ACE units near the "M" symbol as it
14 001 Najib Khneisser Code 2
was done for the rest of the items.
In MCC-23, add the load for the FCU units near the "M" symbol as it
15 001 Najib Khneisser Code 2
was done for the rest of the items.
In MCC-23, FCU 02 and FCU 03 are showing as 2 different circuits,
with 2.77 KVA load each, 3-phase. However, in the load report, FCU 02
16 001 Najib Khneisser Code 3
and FCU 03 are shown on the same circuit with 2.77 KW load for both.
Clarify and rectify.
In MCC-23, FCU 101 is showing 1.89 KVA as TCL, while in the load
17 001 Najib Khneisser Code 3
report, FCU 101 is showing 083. KVA. Clarify and rectify.
In MCP-21, add the load for the FCU units near the "M" symbol as it
18 001 Najib Khneisser Code 2
was done for the rest of the items.
In MCP-21, the loads of the FCU units is not matching with the loads of
001 Najib Khneisser Code 3
the same FCU units in the load report. Clarify and rectify.
Ensure that all loads shown in the schematics are as per the
19 001 Najib Khneisser Code 2
mechanical equipment selection.
Please
RMTC Review Required Yes/No
Select

RMTC Review

BACS Transmittal Ref. RMTC Review due by:

Responded By Revised Status
No. Document Number Rev RMTC Comments Comments Made by Code Supplier / Fabricator / Subcontractor Response

1 Please Select

2 Please Select

3 Please Select

434211111.xlsx Page 2 of 2