Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract: As proven by service experience, GIS show a good 60 and 70 % of the failures could have been detected by a
long-term performance. To exploit the service life as far as possi- monitoring system with a sufficient sensitivity partly dur-
ble an assessment of the insulating condition of the equipment in ing its development partly directly after occurrence.
question can be done using the UHF PD measuring technique. Nowadays, deficiencies in design or manufacturing pro-
However, GIS of early designs are not equipped with any provi-
sions for insulation monitoring so that two different types of non- cess can most probably be excluded so that the part of de-
conventional UHF sensors were developed which are applicable tectable failures is much hgher. The remaining failures are
from outside the enclosure. The first sensor makes use of a field mainly caused by particles, which can mostly be detected
grading electrode inside a barrier insulator of a three-phase GIS. by a sufficiently sensitive monitoring and diagnostic tech-
The second sensor is designed to be mounted outside the inspec- nique. The failure frequency for dielectric failures related
tion window of a single-phase GIS. The sensitivity of the new to 100 bay years depending on the age of the station when
non-conventional UHF sensors is compared to the conventional the failure occurred is shown by the gliding mean value for
IEC 60270 method and to standard type UHF Sensors according to three years and the mean value related to the total time
the verification procedure proposed by CIGRE WG 15133.03.05. period [l] (Fig. 2.1). The total period of time in concern is
from 0 up to 30 years of service and the variation of the
Keywords: GIs, PD diagnostic, UHF sensor, Sensitivity
number of bay years in the course of time is considered.
I. INTRODUCTION
+mean value
Gasinsulated switchgear (GIS) has attained a very high 0.4 -mean value of 3 years
degree of reliability and availability. As shown by service h
IEEE
O-7803-6338-8/00/$10.00(~)2000 1395
junctions, etc.) cause standing waves and complex resonant Insulation monitoring of GIS using the UHF PD meas-
patterns. The measurable UHF PD signal depends strongly uring technique is generally used for the detection of in-
on the setup, type and position of the defect, and the sen- cipient faults as well as for the exploitationof service life.
sors. Thus, a calibration of the UHF method similar to PD- Despite GIS have a very low failure rate the users are
measurements according to IEC 60270 is not possible. endeavoured to reduce it further to decrease the outage
The sensitivity of the UHF method is comparable to the time as far as possible, since a failure in GIS during opera-
conventional method according to IEC 60270 [2]. Since tion mostly causes a longer outage time and more cost
corona discharges do not create interfering signals in the expenditure than in AIS. The ability of monitoring a com-
UHF range onsite measurements on partially open test plete station by UHF sensors enables the user to find de-
setups become possible. Measurements can be performed viations in the service performance and to detect irregulari-
either in the frequency-domain (narrow-band method) with ties. The PD pattern and frequency spectra recorded make
a bandwidth of a few MHz or in the time-domain (broad- it possible to recognise defects in an early stage. An as-
band method) over a broad frequency range up to 2 GHz sessment of the reliability and availability of the station can
(Fig. 3.1). PD detection using the narrow-band method is be obtained and repair works or an exchange, if needed,
done with a spectrum analyzer and low noisehigh gain may be initiated before a breakdown or an outage occurs.
UHF preamplifiersand results in the frequency spectrum of Thus, the knowledge of the insulating condition enables the
the PD signal. For the broad-band method PD signals are user to achieve a better utilisation of the equipment and an
detected from an UHF peak detector. A suitable PD meas- adoption of the maintenance strategy, which are of in-
uring device displays a PRPD pattern similar to those ob- creasing importance in the deregulated electricity market.
tained with the conventional method. The service life of GIS will be much longer as expected
PD when the first installations were taken into service. Even at
the oldest stations no ageing effects can be recognised so
i 0 1 2 10 20
far (Fig. 2.1). Since insulation monitoring gives extensive
information on the insulation condition of GIs, a qualified
f 4 GHz t. Ar ...-
mc assessment of its dielectric properties is made possible. If
weak points in the insulating system will be detected in
-
+ J I future by insulation monitoring the components in question
Highpass Peak PD Measuring
can be exchanged. Then, the GIS in concern is available for
operation again without any limitations, so that a life exten-
sion of the equipment can be achieved. Furthermore, often
the knowledge of the insulation conditions gained in the
stations fitted with sensors can also be transferred to other
Fiz.3.1: Principle of narrow-band (left) and broad-band (right) UHF
method with typical signals obtainedfor a moving particle stations and possible weak points can be removed before
causing an outage. In total, a more intensive exploitation of
Many of the new GIS installations, in particular in the the equipment is accomplished and considerable savings in
higher voltage range, are equipped with UHF sensors. GIS investment and maintenance costs are attained.
of the early design are not equipped with sensors or other
provisions for insulation monitoring. In consequence other N.UHF SENSORS
solutions had to be found. In case of extensions of older
A. Standard type sensors
substations the new section can be fitted with UHF sensors.
An example is given in Fig. 3.2. With the sensors in bay Standard type UHF sensors are usually aluminum disk
no. 7 and 9 not only these bays but also the busbars and to sensors mounted fast to the GIS in existing flanges such as
a certain extent the neighbouring bays can be monitored. mounting or earthing-switch flanges. The sensors have to
1 ...... , 6 7 8 9 be considered as a circular disk antenna which is charac-
terized by its radius and gap width. Cone-type sensors are
also in use which can be described as cone antennas with
similar characteristics and sensitivity. The transfer function
of these antennas can be measured in an especially de-
signed test setup consisting of a GIS compartment with a
flange and conical pipings for proper matching (Fig. 4.1).
The transfer function measured with a network analyzer
h
v :-.mobile sensrx has the characteristicsof a high-pass filter.
-:A CIS after extensionfitted with conventional and mobile sensors
1396
B. Types of non-conventional sensors B.2 Mobile sensor
The installation of mobile sensors can be done without
B. 1 Integrated sensor any affections on the operation of the GIs. In GIS of older
In the considered three phase encapsulated GIs, sepa- design disconnectors possess pressure windows with a
rating gas barrier insulators include auxiliary potential pressure-sealed glass offering a possibility to externally
grading electrodes which support stress control (Fig. 4.2). mount UHF sensors. These windows served for an optical
During normal operation, each electrode embedded in the
inspection of the isolating distance and for installation
cast epoxy resin material is connected by screws to the
purposes. Window couplers consist of an aluminum disk
enclosure. Their peculiar purpose is to equalise and ho-
mounted against the window and a case to suppress exter-'
mogenise the electrostatic field distribution and to elimi-
nal noise and to mount the sensor to the GIS enclosure.
nate the dielectric effect of a possible air-gap between the With the same test setup as before the transfer function of a
epoxy insulator material and the aluminum flange. Even if
window coupler was determined (Fig. 4.5). The window
one screw is removed, these properties still remain. The
structure acts as a hgh-pass filter and has a considerable
generated loop retains zero potential, but gains an accessi-
effect on the coupler sensitivity and transfer function.
ble tapping point in the middle of its frame. Hence, it can 1 1 I 1
be used as an UHF antenna directed into the duct.
position of screws:
tapping points
a0
f:
Fiz. 4.2:Cross-section of a
conductor built-in gas barrier
insulator (illustrated
in principle)
= .60
-10
A1G 0z 0
n A3
d e
auxiliaryd 5 0
eleamde -80
03-1 15 3
r- GHz
The transfer function was measured between the auxil- Fiz 4.5: Transfer function of a window coupler (disk diameter 78 mm,
iary electrodes of two adjacent spacers in the test setup of flange diameter IO5 mm)
Fig. 5.4 using the tracking generator of a spectrum analyzer
(Fig. 4.3). The output power of -10 dBm is supplied to The window flange has to be considered as a circular
sensor A 2 on top of the vertically positioned insulator. waveguide where only higher wave-modes can propagate.
Stimulated resonances exist within the measured frequency The cut-off frequencies of TE and TM modes depend
range up to 2 GHz. There is no significant difference be- strongly on the diameter of the window structure [4]. Be-
tween the transfer h c t i o n of the sensor of the phase the low cut-off frequency the signal is subjected significant
traclung generator was connected to (B2) and the one of an attenuation. The length of the window flange also causes a
adjacent phase ( B I ) (refer to Fig. 5.4). The sensitivity of high attenuation of the signal which is usually in the order
these sensors is comparable to standard type sensors [3]. of about 3 dB/cm. For sufficient diameters and short length
The PD spectrum measured with integrated sensors corre- the sensitivity for moving particles at frequencies above 1.3
spond very well to the spectrum obtained from a cone type GHz is as good as for standard type sensors (Fig. 4.6). The
sensor installed in an adjacent compartment (Fig. 4.4). cut-off frequency of the TE and TM modes can be lowered
-10
significantly by fitting a dielectric block inside the window
dBm
flange. While this affects normal operation of the GIS due
, , , I , , ,
the use of less high frequent measuring equipment and an
even higher sensitivity can be achleved.
S" ,Bin::
80
-70
-35
40
1:
50
-90
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 7.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 GHz 2.0
f c -55
Fig. 4.3: Transferfunctions measured at the sensors B2 and BI (Fig. 5.4) 60
0 ; ; : ; : ; ; -65
I I I I I I I
dBm --~:---j---
I I I I
:---.-.:.------:....--:----~--.---~------~-----.
I I I
I 1I : -75
0.3 1.15 2
f+ GHz
Fig. 4.6:Comparison of the sensitivity for moving particles of standard
type UHFsensor (disk) and mobile type (window coupler)
1397
V. SENSITIVITY OF CONVENTIONAL AND NON- In the frequency range between I.6 and 2 GHz, no more
CONVENTIONAL UHF SENSORS resonant frequency contents are stimulated by the artificial
pulse due to the limited rise time. The signal at measuring
As mentioned, the magnitude of UHF PD signals de- point MP2 is given in Fig 5.3. An attenuation between MPl
pends strongly on the setup, the location of the defect and and MP2 of about 5 up to 15 dB can be derived.
the sensor, so that a calibration of the UHF method similar
to the IEC 60270 method is not possible. To overcome this
short-coming the CIGRE WG 1Y33.03.05 has proposed a
two step procedure for a sensitivity verification which will -40
ensure that typical defects can be detected by an UHF
measuring device [5]. First in the laboratory UHF signals
are stimulated in a typical GIS arrangement by injection of s
I: -55
artificial pulses. The pulse magnitude has to be varied till -60
the spectrum is equal with that generated by a real defect, -65
e. g. a moving particle producing a PD quantity of 5 pC. -70 _...
L_
,
._
___*__
, ,
b&mmnonlspearbn+
, , ,
---,* -..._;
L
, .,
.--.
For the second step, the sensitivity verification on-site, the -75
,
,
'
I I
I
' .
I
I
I
.
I
I
'
I
.
I
I
'
I
~
.
I
I
02 06 08 2
same type of GIS design and test equipment has to be used 04
f -
1 12 14 16 18
Gnz
as during the laboratory test. Artificial pulses of the same Fin. 5.3:Movingparticle (5 pC) vs. artificial pulse (7y) for standard type
shape and magnitude are injected into a sensor of the GIS UHF sensors at measuring point MP2
on-site. If the signal can be measured at a neighboring
sensor, the sensitivity verification is successful for the GIS B. Integrated type
section between both sensors. The first step of the proce-
The same procedure was also applied on a three phase
dure was carried out in a number of laboratory tests on GIs
encapsulated GIS setup (Fig. 5.4) for the integrated sensor
arrangements of different design with sensors of standard
type. A pulse of the same characteristics was injected into
type and non-conventional type installed.
the auxiliary electrode A 1 at the vertical spacer and meas-
urements were done at sensor B l of the horizontal spacer.
A. Standard type
In this GIS arrangement and for the used integrated sensors
As an example for standard type sensors the results of a the spectra correspond best with a pulse magnitude of zi = 9
420 kV GIS set-up equipped with disk sensors will be V(Fig. 5.5).
illustrated (Fig. 5.1). The magnitude of the artificial pulse
(rise time 800 ps, repetition rate 50 Hz) injected into a
sensor at IP was varied until the best correspondence be-
tween the spectra of the moving particle and the pulse was
obtained. In this setup the magnitude was determined to 6
= 7 V(Fig. 5.2).
n
MP2
11 m
m p a m t wim
hee"gpaNde
/- MPl
bl
i Fie. 5.4:Experimental setup of three-phase encapsulated I70 kV GIs with
measuring point (MP) and injection point (IP)
dBm
-25
-30
1 p;lse (7 b)_____ ! _____
Fi--i--y;--: : i& '
,____ r! _____ f--L--Ti!E?-
I I
t .
, , I I , ,
-35 j j j backbroundjnoise +ectrum
-70
-40 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 GHz 1.8
1s : f c
45
C. Mobile type
-70 ----- 1 ----.-
I
I
I
I
I
;-.*actgrotrn*"&e;mspscMn
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
---,
----- -____
I
I
~
I
L
,
I
1398
Measurements were done with an amplifier = 2GHz)
and a RV detector enabling the application of a conven-
tional PD measuring device with a bandwidth of 200 to 800
kHz. In accordance to the laboratory tests the amplitude of
the pulse was chosen to be 4 V equivalent to 5pC. Fig. 6.2
shows the difference between total signal and background
noise recorded with a mobile sensor in bay no. 6.
2 5 1 . I : i i i i I I
parlick 525 hV test Vansforme
I I
123 kV GIS 241582 kV GIS
0.4 0.6
, ,
0.8
,
1:O
f- GHz
I
i.2
,
1,4
,
1,6
,
i.8 2.0
injected into a disk sensor and recorded with the window Fip. 6.2:Spectrum recorded in bay 6.stimulated by an artijicial pulse of 4
V injected in bay 7
coupler which had a diameter of I23 m m (flange diameter
I43 mm) the spectrum corresponds with the real defect The attenuation in the other bays related to bay no. 6 is
only up to a frequency of about 1.5 GHz (Fig. 5.7). non-linear because of differences in the mechanical con-
-25 struction of the busbar and switchgear section involved
dBn
-30
(table 6.1). However, it can be stated that PD of 5 pC
-35
-40
caused in the busbar of bay no. 7 is detectable by mobile
-45 sensors in bay no. 3 and in all sections in-between.
T -50
-55
S 60
Table 6.I : Attenuation of the section of bay no.5...I related to bay no. 6
bay no. 5 4 3 2 1
-65 attenuation ldB1 -4.1 -9.5 -10.8 -16.1 -18.9
-70
related to bay 6
-75A.3 I I I 1.15
I ' I ' 1 B. Three phase encapsulated GIS
f 4 GHz
Fiz. 5.7:Moving particle (5 pC) vs. artifuzial pulse (4 PJ measured with a The results in the three phase encapsulated switchgear
window coupler
can be taken from Fig. 6.3. With regard to the longest dis-
tance between two gas barrier insulators of a typical bay
VI. MEASURING RESULTS ON 123 KV GIS
unit artificial pulses were injected in the sensors integrated
The results presented in the following were gained on a in barrier at compartment 4 (ZP).The emitted signal was
single phase encapsulated 123 kV substation with nine recorded at the sensors integrated in the busbar bamer at
bays, five of which were installed in 1968. The investiga- compartment 2 (MP). The artificial pulse of 9 volts
tion aimed on sensitivity verification of the laboratory equivalent to 5 pC can be measured in each of the four gas-
measurements onsite and on identification and location of compartments of the illustrated GIs section.
-20
defects found in connection with fmt periodic checks.
Similar measurements were also conducted on a three
i?
phase encapsulated 170 kV GIs.
f
Fir. 6.3: Signal recorded at measuring point (MP) in compartment 2
1.2 1.4
- GHz l.E
1399
00_12_I_GIS_SF6_CAM_01
IX. BIOGRAPHIES
Ralph Feger was bom on November 12th, 1969 in Sindelfingen, Ger-
many. He studied electrical engineering at the University of Stuttgart and
Grenoble. After receiving the Diplom-Ingenieur degree in electrical
engineering from the University of Stuttgart in 1996 he joined the Institute
00_12_I_GIS_SF6_CAM_03 of Power Transmission and High Voltage Technology of the University of
Stuttgart. He is working on the diagnosis of CIS using the UHF-method.
1400