Comments Sheet for DLN's submission ref: A-HAB-0803

Subject: AIL 462 - Reply to Comment R-to-C on Building Services for GA

HKADC's comments

Remarks:
Comments pending response
Latest Comment

No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)

refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response

A. General Comments

AR1 ArchSD 6/12/2018 1. Height of tall equipment (chiller plant, LV switchboard, motor control center & etc.) against door 1. Height of tall equipment (chiller plant, LV switchboard, motor
Comment access shall be reviewed to ensure that delivery route is in place. control center & etc.) has been reviewed against door access to ensure
(A1-03-6) 2. Delivery route of aerial platforms to Store (Aerial Platform) shall be provided.] that delivery route is in place.
2. Please refer to Appendix BS-01 Delivery Route and Swept Path of
Aerial Platforms.

AR2 ArchSD 6/12/2018 Sunken slab is provided for separation of water containing pipe and rooms with water containing pipe Please refer to the B.S. Drawings submitted on 30 Sept 2019 (DLN
Comment above the water-sensitive area, layout of sunken slab should be provided for clarity] Letter ref. A-HAB-0803) and attached updated B.S. Drawings, there is
(A1-06-12) no sunken for the drainage design for GA area.

AR3 Summary of 6/12/2018 Pls ensure no emission of unpleasant smell and cause nuisance at around proximity Please refer to the B.S. Drawings submitted on 30 Sept 2019 (DLN
CMD2 of Letter ref. A-HAB-0803) and attached updated B.S. Drawings, there is
ArchSD no sunken for the drainage design for GA area. Therefore there shall be
Comment no futher odour issue.
(A7-02-5)

A1 1 21/3/2018 The floor layout has not yet been approved and further submission for BS Design would be required. Noted.
BS drawings will be updated once floor layout confirmed.
A2 1 21/3/2018 BS provision to any user studio should not pass through other studio, e.g. Drawing No. Noted. BS provision to any user studio will be minimized to avoid
8660/ADC/MVAC/2007 and 8660/ACD/MVAC/2008 passing through other studio
Shared Primary Air Duct / Refrigerant Pipe / Condensate Drain Pipe is found in B-12, B-13, C-1, B-1,
B-17 and B-18.
Drawing No. 8660/ADC/PL/2008
Shared CL Pipe is found in A-6, B-12, B-13, B-14 and B-15.
Drawing No. 8660/ADC/DR/2008 and 8660/ADC/DR/2009
Shared Floor Drain Pipe / Waste Pipe is found in B-17.

1.1 15/8/2018 Please specify the location and type piping/studio involved for our further consideration. 5/F Studio B12: CWPs and FWP (See Drawing:
8660/ADC/PL/2008&2009)
1.2 6/12/2018 8660/ADC/D Soil pipe/waste pipe inside studio (Studio B-11 and B-12) is not acceptable. Please be clarified that the soil pipe/ waste pipe are running in the
R/2008&2009 (Should refer to 8660/ADC/DR/2008&2009) bulkhead above Studio B-4 & B-12 (previosly Studio B-11 & B-12).
Please refer to Detail A & Detail B for the detail section of pipe
routing.(See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/DR/2008)

A3 1 21/3/2018 AP to demonstrate CCTV system could fully cover the area as camera capability varies from equipment To be submitted separately.
to equipment.
1.1 1/3/2019 Pending submission Please refer to Appendix Appendix BS-02 CCTV Coverage.

1 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response
A4 1 21/3/2018 According to Clause 23(o), two CCTV systems shall be provided, one for office and the other for the Clause Noted.
remaining part of GA. The monitoring station of the prior system could be placed inside Server Room 23(o) Schematic Diagram for IPCCTV is revised.
on 4/F while the monitoring stations of the latter system should be provided in Back-of-Centre Area of (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/1006)
Arts Information System and Room for Temporary Office / Storage.

A5 1 6/12/2018 Please provide mapping of CCTV coverage for the whole GA and moveable CCTV arrangement for Please refer to Appendix BS-02 CCTV Coverage. The CCTV are
Exhibition Gallery mounted on the pipe grid system and be easily relocated within 2m.

A6 1 21/3/2018 Please be reminded that door monitoring function shall be provided for Exhibition Gallery and Arts Noted.
Information Centre according to RDS. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/1005)

A7 1 21/3/2018 Telephone port of Front-of-Centre Area of Arts Information Centre should be relocated nearby the door Noted.
connecting Front-of-Centre Area and Back-of-Centre Area for the provision of reception counter. (See Drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2002)

1.1 15/8/2018 DLN’s floor layout has changed and please revise the provision accordingly. Noted. See Dwg. no.: 8660/ADC/EL/2002

1.2 6/12/2018 Additional telephone port should be provided in screening room.
Telephone, fax and LAN outlets of Back-of-Centre Area of Arts Information Centre should be relocated
nearby the window facing Yip Hing Street, or the wall connecting the escalator.
Additional provision for telephone port with concealed adaptable box
will be provided in screening room.
Telephone, fax and lan outlets have been relocated nearby the window
facing Yip Hing Street. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/EL/2002)

A8 1 15/8/2018 Please clarify the location of Central BMS system. Please refer to drawing no.: 8660/ADC/EL/1005

1.1 6/12/2018 Should be placed in Temporary Office/Storage 1 if it could not be placed inside management office. The Central BMS System will be relocated to Room for Temporary
Subject to further discussion with the landlord. Office/ Storage 1 (GA). (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/EL/1005 & 2002)

A9 1 15/8/2018 TV outlets should be provided at both floor and ceiling level and some of them should be Ethernet port Noted. TV outlets should be provided at both floor and ceiling level
in order to support live time broadcasting and details shall be updated in later stage and some of them should be Ethernet port in order to support live time
broadcasting and details shall be updated in later stage

A10 1 6/12/2018 Please provide softcopy of all related drawings for future R-to-C response Attached a CD with softcopy of all related drawings
A11 1 6/12/2018 It is noted that numbering of floors was revised (4/F is obsoleted). Please ensure all submissions reflect Please be confirmed all submission now reflects the change of
the changes for clarity. numbering of floors

A12 1 6/12/2018 For App BS-01, Delivery Route Drawings: 1. Hositing hook has been provided inside the AHU Room. Please refer
1. Plant Room access is 2 m above L/UL Area. Please consider the lifting method in delivery. to the Appendix BS-02 Delivery Route submitted on 30 Sept 2019
2. Please provide swept path analysis of aerial platform (DLN Letter ref. A-HAB-0803)
3. Review height of door access along delivery route of tall equipment, e.g. Emergency generator: 2759 2. Please refer to Appendix BS-01 Delivery Route and Swept Path of
mm (H) Aerial Platforms.
3. Height of tall equipment has been reviewed against door access to
ensure that delivery route is in place.

A13 1 6/12/2018 For Appendix BS-02 Acoustic Design Report: Please refer to Appendix BS-06 Acoustic Report.
1. Please include the specifications of room for Senior Manager
2. Server Room is located inside Open Plan Office, please ensure noise from Server Room is controlled
to acceptable level
3. Please specify the reverberation time limits of Exhibition Gallery, Temp. Office / Storage, AIC(FOC),
Artist Studios.

2 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response
A14 1 6/12/2018 Refer to Appendix BS-03 Cleaning Eye System: Please refer to the B.S. Drawings submitted on 30 Sept 2019 (DLN
1. water-proof membrane shall cover the concrete slab under end cap of cleaning eye Letter ref. A-HAB-0803) and attached updated B.S. Drawings, there is
2. Please clarify if any protective finishes will be applied on the water proof membrane in the recess of no sunken for the drainage design for GA area. The previously
clean eye system. The concern is the membrane will be damaged after repeated screwing of end cap submitted Appendix BS-03 Cleaning Eye System is now invalid.
3. Details of matching cover and sealant should be reviewed to ensure the water-tightness after repeated
open/close operation
4. Consider if it is feasible to position cleaning eye system on wall instead of floor

A15 1 1/3/2019 Please submit reflected ceiling plan for review layout of air grille, light fitting and other ceiling mounted The Reflected Ceiling Plan is under Architect's preparation. The
services Reflected Ceiling Plan showing the layout of air grille, light fitting and
other ceiling mounted services will be submitted separately.

A16 1 1/3/2019 General Notes of Building Services should ensure compliance of prescriptive codes such as Energy Noted. General Notes of Building Services will ensure compliance of
Efficiency Ordinance, Design Manual of Barrier Free Access, etc. prescriptive codes such as Energy Efficieny Ordinance, Design Manual
of Barrier Free Access, etc.

A17 1 1/3/2019 Strength of flooring in 5/F File and Storage Area should be reviewed to support the weight of Noted
Compactor Storage System for storage of document. Should take note on routing of service under raised
floor

A18 1 7/11/2019 Acoustic AP to confirm if the wall finishes / material comply with TS Plesae be confirmed that the wall finishes / material comply with TS.
Report
A19 1 7/11/2019 Architectural layouts are not updated; Services routing and position of equipment are subject to plant Please be confirmed all architectural layout are updated.
room layout and coordination drawing

A20 1 7/11/2019 AP to revisit swept path of aerial platforms. Store Room (Aerial Platform) should be so arranged to Please refer to Appendix BS-01 Delivery Route and Swept Path of
accommodate parking of two aerial platforms without clash along the swept path Aerial Platforms.

M/J

B MVAC Drawing
BR1 ArchSD 6/12/2018 1. Refer to Appendix BS-03 of submission dated 13 July 2018, please clarify whether fresh air load of Please be clarified that fresh aur load of Exhibition Gallery 1&2 and
Comment Exhibition Gallery 1&2 and Temporary Office / Storage 1&2 is considered. Temporary Office / Storage 1&2 has been considered and 20% spare
D (C1-01-12) 2. 20% spare cooling capacity shall be provided for Exhibition Gallery cooling capacity has been provided for Exhibition Gallery in the
Appendix BS-03 of submission dated 13 July 2018.

BR2 ArchSD 6/12/2018 Please clarify whether “Excellent Class” of IAQ objectives of EPD can be achieved Please be confirmed "Excellent Class" of IAQ objecyives of EPD can
Comment be archieved.
(C1-12-12)

BR3 ArchSD 6/12/2018 Refer to Appendix BS-03, ACMV system of Exhibition Gallery, Studio and major plant rooms relies on 2 nos. of AHU are provided for Exhibition Gallery and 2 nos. of AHU
Comment operation of particular PAU/AHU and ventilation fans. Please advise whether backup provision in are provided for Temporay Office/ Storage.
D
(C1-19-12) system design will be provided in case of downtime for maintenance or equipment failure.

BR4 ArchSD 6/12/2018 Humidity control of Temporary Office / Storage shall be provided. Section Humidity control has been provided for Temporary Office/ Storage.
Comment 23 (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/3001)
(C1-37-12)

B1 1 6/12/2018 8660-SK- Please ensure maintainability of the FCU installed in fire exit Please be confirmed the FCU installed in fire exit can be accessed at
D MVAC-01 Please maintain. any time for maintenance

3 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response
B2 1 6/12/2018 8660-SK- 1. Please provide more details of FCU installation for water sensitive area as shown in the elevation 1. Details of FCU installation has been revised. (See attached B.S.
MVAC-02 drawing for consideration Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/2006)
2. Please clarify whether Meeting 1 & 2 will be served by the same FCU installation 2. Please be confirmed Meeting Room 1 & Meeting Room 2 are served
by two individual FCU. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/2006)

B3 1 6/12/2018 8660-SK- Position of external louvre at 3/F - 7M/F is indicated. Please also review the fresh/ exhaust air grille Please be confitmed the fresh/ exhaust air grille separation of GA Area
MVAC-02 to separation of GA Area between those air grilles in GA Area and non-GA Area if any between those air grilles in GA Area and non-GA Area are adequately
05 separated.
B4 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/M Please indicate installation of HEPA filter HEPA filter has been indicated in the Equipment Schedule drawing.
D VAC/1001 (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/3001)

2 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/M Please advise if any MVAC provision for Fire Control Room (ADC) Split type air conditioning unit is provided in Fire Control Room
VAC/1001 (ADC) (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
D 8660/ADC/MVAC/2001)

3 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/M Please advise backup provision in system design will be provided in case of downtime, refer to 2 nos. of AHU are provided for Exhibition Gallery and 2 nos. of AHU
D VAC/1001 Comment A2 are provided for Temporay Office/ Storage.

4 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/M Arrangement of FCU in UG/F AIC Area and 5/F Office Area is discrepant to that indicate in MVAC Schematic diagram has been revised. (See attached B.S. Drawings
D VAC/1001 Layout I.U. of A/C unit is shown 6/F Cleaner's Store . Please clarify. drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/1001)

5 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/M Please clarify if "Air Duct Plenum (ADC)" and "Exhaust Air Plenum" are parts of GA's MVAC System The "Air Duct Plenum (ADC)" and "Exhaust Air Plenum"is part of
VAC/1001 which are not shown in schematic diagram and any ductwork connecting the plenum. GA's MVAC System and is shown on the revised schematic diagram.
D (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/1001)

6 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M UG/F Store Room (AIC): Two sets of split type a/c indoor unit in future installation shall be provided Please be confirmed provision and space have been provided for future
VAC/1001 for the room installation of two sets of split type a/c indoor unit in the UG/F Store
Room (AIC). (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/2002)

7 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M Screening Room (AIC): Provide two FCUs for alternative operation as per water side schematic diagram Please be clarified that only one FCU shall be provided in Screening
VAC/1001 Room (AIC) as per the air side schematic diagram. The water side
schematic diagram is revised. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/1001)

8 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M Exhibition Gallery: Consider to provide alternative air duct arrangement for the entire Exhibition Due to the space constraint it is not feasible to provide alternative air
VAC/1001 Gallery in case of downtime of AHU serving either Hall 1 or Hall 2 duct arrangement for the entire Exhibition Gallery in case of downtime
of AHU serving either Hall 1 or Hall 2
9 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M Air Side Schematic Diagram: Provide individual transfer air duct for both halls of Exhibition Gallery, Transfer air duct for both halls of Exhibition Gallery, 5/F Conference
VAC/1001 5/F Conference Room 1-3 and Meeting Room 1 & 2 Room 1-3 and Meeting Room 1 & 2 have been provided in the air side
schematic diagram. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/1001)

10 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M Air Side Schematic Diagram: Transfer air duct for AV Room and SI Room are missed Transfer air duct for AV Room and SI Room have been provided in the
VAC/1001 air side schematic diagram. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/1001)

11 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M Air Side Schematic Diagram: The arrangement of schematic diagram is not reflected the recent location The air side schematic diagram now reflects the the location of plant
VAC/1001 changes of plant rooms in MVAC Layout. Please rectify rooms in MVAC layout. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/1001)

4 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response
12 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M Item 4 of Notes: Provision of transfer air duct with silencer is specified for CE/ Chairman Office. Please Please be clarified that the provision of internal lining or silencer in 6/F
VAC/1001 consider if the same requirement of TAD applied to Director Office and SI Room with similiar acoustic & 7/F Studios has been included in item 7 of Notes of previous
and reverberation time requirements as stated in Acoustic Report submission drawings. Item 4 and item 7 of Notes is now deleted and is
now shown in item 6 in this submission drawing. (See attached B.S.
Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/1001)

13 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M Item 4 of Notes: Provision of transfer air duct with silencer is specified for Exhibition Gallery Hall 1 & Please be clarified that the provision of internal lining or silencer in 6/F
VAC/1001 2. Please consider if the same requirement of TAD applied to 6/F & 7/F Studios with similiar acoustic & 7/F Studios has been included in item 7 of Notes of previous
and reverberation time requirements as stated in Acoustic Report submission drawings. Item 4 and item 7 of Notes is now deleted and is
now shown in item 6 in this submission drawing. (See attached B.S.
Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/1001)

B5 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/M At 5/F - 7/F, please place DDC controller to plant room area rather than Office Area / Studio DDC controller has been relocated. (See attached B.S. Drawings
D VAC/1003 drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/1003)

2 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/M Please clarify if the CO2 sensor is incorporated into control of MVAC system for Exhibition Gallery CO2 sensor has been incorporated into control of MVAC system for
D VAC/1003 Exhibition Gallery

3 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M Control Schematic Diagram: DDC panel shall be located at Plant Room Area rather than Studio / Office DDC panel is now located at Plant Room Area rather than Studio /
VAC/1003 Area at 5/F - 7/F Office Area at 5/F - 7/F. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/1003)
4 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M Control Schematic Diagram: Advise control logic of water leakage detection system and AHU w/ heat The control logic will be submitted separately upon MVAC contractor
VAC/1003 reel submission and approval.
B6 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/M Screening Room should be served by multiple FCU as per schematic diagram Schematic diagram has been revised. (See attached B.S. Drawings
D VAC/2002 drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/1001)
B7 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/M Please clarify if location of air grille at perimeter zone of Exhibition Gallery is so arranged to tackle Please be confirmed that location of air grille at perimeter zone of
VAC/2003 solar heat gain through curtain wall Exhibition Gallery is so arranged to tackle solar heat gain through
D curtain wall

2 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M Exhibition Gallery: Arrangement of transfer air duct is deviated from MVAC Schematic Diagram (Dwg. The arrangement of transfer air duct is now aligned from MVAC
VAC/2003 Ref.: 8660/ADC/MVAC/1001) Schematic Diagram. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/1001 & 2003)
3 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M Exhibition Gallery: Provision of external louvre shall be avoided to minimize the potential water Please refer to Detail A for additional concrete plenum provided under
VAC/2003 damage and noise transmission from outdoor the external louvre at the high level of Exhibition Gallery to minimize
the potential water damage. Also silencer is now provided for the air
duct to minimize the noise transmission from outdoor. (See attached
B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/1001 & 2003)

4 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M UG/F Store Room (AIC): Position of future installation of outdoor a/c unit shall be at high level of Please be confirmed that space has been reserved for future installation
VAC/2003 adjacent common area of outdoor a/c unit at high level of common area adajent to UG/F Store
Room (AIC). (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/2002)

5 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M UG/F Store Room (AIC): Reserve spacing and CDP connection for future installation of two indoor a/c Please be confirmed that space and CDP has been reserved for future
VAC/2003 units at high level installation of two indoor a/c units at high level. (See attached B.S.
Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/2002)

B8 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/M Arrangement of FCU for office rooms of executives is deviated from recommendation of Noise and The arrangement of FCU for office rooms of executives has been
D VAC/2006 Vibration Specifications in previous submission revised. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/2006)
2 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/M Any MVAC provision for common area between Meeting Room 1 and PAU Room Additional FCU has been provided. (See attached B.S. Drawings
D VAC/2006 drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/2006)

5 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response
3 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/M Please review location of 4 x local control panel above Lift Lobby The location of local control panel above Lift Lobby has been revised.
D VAC/2006 (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/2006)

4 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M Provide transfer air duct in 5/F Pantry, Between Corridor and Office Area / Lift Lobby Transfer air duct has been provided in 5/F Pantry, Between Corridor
VAC/2006 and Office Area / Lift Lobby. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/2006)

B9 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/M Heaters for ADC office rooms should be included as per schematic diagram Refer toArchSD Comment (C1-01-44), duct heaters for ADC office
VAC/3001 rooms should not be prvoided and are now omitted. (See attached B.S.
Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/2006 & 3001)

B10 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M Studio B-6 & B-12: Around 20 nos. vertical refrigerant pipe and major air duct penetrated the ceiling Please be clarified that the refrigerant pipe and major air duct are
VAC/2007 slab from 7/F A.D.(GA), turned and congested at the high level of the rooms. Consider to conceal the running in the bulkhead above Studio B-6 & B-12.
pipes and major air duct from sightline in the Studios Please refer to Detail A for the detail section of pipe routing. (See
attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/2007)

2 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M Provide transfer air duct in 6/F Multi-purpose Room, Shower Room (Male) Transfer air duct has been provided in 6/F Multi-purpose Room,
VAC/2007 Shower Room (Male). (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/2007)
3 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M 6/F Male Toilet: Separate external louvre for exhaust air and fresh air as far as possible The external louvre for exhaust air and fresh air has been relocated.
VAC/2007 (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/2007)
B11 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M Water Side Schematic Diagram: Indicate location of energy meter in major branch pipe if any Energy meters are now provided in major branch pipe. (See attached
VAC/1002 B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/1002)
2 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M UG/F Store Room (AIC): Provide CDP connection point in AIC (Store Room) for future connection CDP connection point has been provided in AIC (Store Room) for
VAC/1002 future connection. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/2002)

3 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/M 7/F: F&E Tank is indicated in VRV Platform and deviated with 7/F MVAC Layout (Dwg. Ref.: The F&E Tank has been relocated to the 7/F PAU Room (GA) for
VAC/1002 8660/ADC/MVAC/2001). Please clarify Studio and is now aligned with 7/F MVAC layout. (See attached B.S.
Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/1002 & 2008)

C Electrical

CR1 ArchSD 6/12/2018 1. “AC load” between Appendix BS-03 and BS-07 of submission dated 13 July 2018 is discrepant. 1. Please refer to Appendix BS-04 Loading Calculation for the revised
Comment 2. Please clarify whether electricity consumption for air-cooled chillers, mechanical ventilation system, AC load.
(D1-03-12) water heaters, server racks, BMS and security system already considered. 2. Please be confirmed electricity consumption for air-cooled chillers,
3. Refer to comments for item C1-01-12 mechanical ventilation system, water heaters, server racks, BMS and
security system have already been considered.
3. Please be clarified that fresh aur load of Exhibition Gallery 1&2 and
Temporary Office / Storage 1&2 has been considered and 20% spare
cooling capacity has been provided for Exhibition Gallery in the
Appendix BS-03 of submission dated 13 July 2018.

C1 1 21/3/2018 32AMP TPN could be provided for all Type B and Type C studios. Please check if the electricity Noted. Electricity provision is sufficient for Exhibition Gallery
provision is sufficient for Exhibition Gallery (Drawing No. 8660/ADC/EL/1001).

6 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response
C2 1 21/3/2018 Smart Card System is only required for office floor (Drawing No. 8660/ADC/EL/1005). The Electronic Card Access Control System has been provided for UG/F
workstation should be installed in Server Room on 4/F. “Art Information Centre”, “Temporary Office/Storage Room” as per
TS.
(See Dwg no. 8660/ADC/EL/1005)

C3 1 21/3/2018 According to Clause 23(u)(ii) of S, the proposed Wifi containment could not meet the coverage Sufficient Wi-Fi access points have been provided in Exhibition
requirement. There is only one Wifi access point found on UG/F. Gallery, Arts Information Centre and Artist Studios.

(See the wifi point location in Dwg no.

8660/ADC/EL/2002, 8660/ADC/EL/2006, 8660/ADC/EL/2007 &
8660/ADC/EL/2008
and the catalogue in Appendix BS-09)

1.1 15/8/2018 The provision is insufficient. Please provide mapping on antennae coverage. Please find the Wi-Fi coverage drawings no. 8660/ADC/EL/2002,
8660/ADC/EL/2007, 8660/ADC/EL/2009 & 8660/ADC/EL/2010

C4 1 21/3/2018 According to Clause 23(u)(iii) of TS, the conduit containments for signal provision for Wifi shall be Clause Sufficient Wi-Fi access points have been provided in Exhibition
connected to the Server Room on 4/F. (Drawing No. 8660/ADC/EL/1004) 23(u)(iii) Gallery, Arts Information Centre and Artist Studios.
of TS
(See the wifi point location in Dwg no.
8660/ADC/EL/2002, 8660/ADC/EL/2006, 8660/ADC/EL/2007 &
8660/ADC/EL/2008
and the catalogue in Appendix BS-09)

1.1 15/8/2018 The provision is insufficient. Please provide mapping on antennae coverage. Please find the Wi-Fi coverage drawings Dwg no. 8660/ADC/EL/2002,
8660/ADC/EL/2007, 8660/ADC/EL/2009 & 8660/ADC/EL/2010

1.2 6/12/2018 Noted

C5 1 15/8/2018 Please indicate the location and details of WiFi trunking across different floors The CAT5E cables for Wi-Fi System are running in 100 x 100 ELV
trunking. (See drawing no. : 8660/ADC/EL/3002, 8660/ADC/EL/3006)

1.1 6/12/2018 Please indicate the exact ELV trunking/riser reserved and clarify if it is an exclusive one for Wi-Fi There is no exclusive trunking reserved for Wi-Fi System. The cable of
System. Wi-Fi System will be contained in the ELV trunking.

C6 1 6/12/2018 8660-ADC- Number of wifi access point and port for smart switch should be review accordingly (Annex I refers) The number of wifi access point and port for smart switch has been
EL-1005 Please review. revised. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/1005,
2002, 2007, 2009 & 2010)

2 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL Wifi System Schematic Diagram: Ensure sufficient number of wifi access point for proper wifi signal The number of WiFi access point has been review to ensure proper wifi
/1005 intensity in GA Area signal intensity in GA Area

C7 1 6/12/2018 8660-ADC- Regarding the power layout for wifi access point. The quantity is too conservative that obstruction due The number of wifi access point has been revised. (See attached B.S.
EL-2002, 07, to wall etc. is not addressed. Please find the mark up power layout for wifi router from our IT specialist Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2002, 2007, 2009 & 2010)
09, 10 for your reference. Please advise.

C8 1 1/3/2019 For Wifi coverage in electrical layout, please review number and coverage of wifi access points due to The number of wifi access point has been revised. (See attached B.S.
depreciation of Wifi intensity by obstruction of building elements. Refer to Comment C6 & C7. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/1005, 2002, 2007, 2009 & 2010)

7 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response
C9 1 21/3/2018 For Exhibition Gallery, the 32A(W) sockets should be provided at the corner of wall. Having consulted Noted.
expert’s advice, the distance of the grid pattern socket on floor should be revised to around 6m, single The socket layouts are revised.
socket only. Please be reminded about the concealed cover and flush flooring requirements under TS (See Drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2002)
(Drawing No. 8660/ADC/EL/2002)

1.1 15/8/2018 1. Please provide details of socket finishes/covers for consideration as it would affect the number of 1. Catalogue of socket outlet for the details of socket finishes/ cover is
socket to be provided. attached. (See Appendix BS-04)
2. Both dimmable sockets and non-dimmable sockets would be required. For dimmable sockets, they 2. Both dimmable and non-dimmable lighting switch are provided for
should be connected to dimmer to be purchased by HKADC and placed inside Temporary ADC Area
Office/Storage. 3. Please see enclosed proposed installation detail.
3. Please show details on the sockets finishes/layout of socket panel at the ceiling, the relationship with (See refer to Appendix BS-06)
the pipe grid system for further consideration.

1.2 6/12/2018 Please be reminded that the socket should match the floor finishes. JRP to demonstrate. Besides,
dimmable sockets should be provided for the installation of dimmable lighting system while lanterns and
dimmer to be provided by HKADC. The dimmer shall be placed in Temporary Office/Storage 2.
Catalogue of socket will be submitted upon Electircal Sub-Contractor
submission and appoval. Dimmable socket and dimmable lighting
system layout will be provided by AV and specialist lighting
consultant.
The dimmer would be located in Temporary Office/Storage 2.

C10 1 15/8/2018 Electricity socket is not found in multi-purpose room on 6/F Electricity socket has been provided in multi-purpose room on 7/F
(previously 6/F)
(See drawing no. : 8660/ADC/EL/2010)

1.1 6/12/2018 Please provide details of socket on movable partition Please be clarified that no socket will be installed on movable partition.
(See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2002)

C11 1 6/12/2018 SK-02UG Location of socket outlet should not be obstructed by service running when s/o are positioned above Noted. Location of socket outlet will not obstructed by service running
E&M zone. And length of wiring to equipment with flexible conduit should comply with prescriptive when s/o are positioned above E&M zone, and length of wiring to
code equipment with flexible conduit complying with prescriptive code has
been provided.

C12 1 6/12/2018 32A(W) of Exhibition Gallery should not be positioned at the centre of the wall and should better placed The location of wall-mounted 32A socket has been revised. (See
next to column or corner of the Exhibition Gallery. attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2002)
C13 1 6/12/2018 Refer to drawings (APP BS-04), Please refer to Appendix BS-05 Floor Box Catalogue for multiple
The submission contains only floor box for single socket outlet. Please provide the floor box selection sockets.
for multiple sockets

C14 1 1/3/2019 Floor box and associated under-floor trunking (or conduit) should be provided for power and data Noted. Under-floor trunking and conduit will be provided for power
outlets in office area and Exhibition Gallery. Details and configuration of floor box is required. and data outlets in office area and Exhibition Gallery. Please refer to
Appendix BS-05 Floor Box Catalogue for details and configuration of
floor box.

C15 1 21/3/2018 Public Address System / Intercom System for TRS should be connected to the building management Public Address System will be connected to UG/F Temporary Office/
office (Drawing No. 8660/ADC/EL/1004). Details of Central Building Management System should be Storage Room as per TS.
shown so that location of such device could be commented. (Drawing No. 8660/ADC/EL/1004)

Intercom System for TRS will be connected to the building

management office

1.1 15/8/2018 Please clarify if Public Address System is part of the FS system and please show details of installation The Public Address System is not part of the FS system.
on the drawings. For Intercom System of TRS, it is preferred to connect with the building management For Intercom System of TRS, the signal shall be monitored by ADC
office, same as other provision of the building. personnel due to the building management office staff access limitation
to ADC Area

8 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response
1.2 6/12/2018 TRS arrangement subject to review after confirmation of the GA demarcation. Public Address system Please be clarified that TRS is now under the development common
(AV and PAE) as marked in the back-of-centre area of AIC should be provided in Temporary Office / area, CCTV system for GA area will not include TRS. Public Address
Storage 1 if it could not be placed inside building management office. Subject to further confirmation System has been relocated in Temporary Office / Storage 1. (See
with landlord. attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/1006 & 3002)

C16 1 6/12/2018 Please provide equipment details on PA system and clarify: Please refer to B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/1005 & 2002
1. the number of input
2. if additional playback device/input, computer playback, wireless microphone input available
3. if multi-zoning playback could be provided
4. if audio tie-lines available in the Exhibition Gallery
5. location of loudspeakers in Exhibition Gallery.
Please clarify

C17 1 6/12/2018 8660-ADC- Please clarify if trunking will be provided between Temp. Office /Storage and Exhibition Gallery 1 & 2 Additional power trunking and ELV trunking has been provided
EL-3002 Please advise. between Temp. Office /Storage and Exhibition Gallery 1 & 2. (See
attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2002)

C18 1 6/12/2018 8660-ADC- Control panels for LSP, BMS, MON, SAC, IN, AV, PAE are located at AIC (BoC) and reduce the floor Control panels have been relocated in Temporary Office / Storage 1.
EL-7001 area available for AIC staff. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2002 & 7001)
Please relocate and spatial requirement for those control panels

C19 1 6/12/2018 8660/ADC/EL Lighting fixture is not shown The Lighting Layout is separated from the Power & ELV Layout for
/2007 clear presentation, please refer to B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/EL/2006

C20 1 6/12/2018 8660-ADC- Please clarify if trunking will be provided between Conference Room and Audio Visual Room Additional power trunking and ELV trunking has been provided
EL-3006 between Conference Room and Audio Visual Room. (See attached B.S.
Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/3006)
C21 1 6/12/2018 Cable containment layouts for G/F, 1/F, 3/F are not provided. Please provide. Please refer to B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/3001, 3002
& 3005

2 1/3/2019 For cable containment layout please ensure cable containment for power and ELV system is available for The size of power trunking and ELV trunking have been revised. (See
plant rooms, rooms in office and studio floor attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/3001 to 3008)

3 1/3/2019 For cable containment layout please verify labeling and identification of different types of ELV system Please be clarified that cable of all ELV System are contained in the
and ensure proper sizing and quantity for every ELV system ELV trunking. Size of ELV trunking has been revised. (See attached
B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/3001 to 3008)

4 1/3/2019 Size and routing of above-ceiling / under-floor cable containment for various purpose of ELV system Please be clarified that cable of all ELV System are contained in the
(PA/ Wifi/ BMS/ FS/ IPCCTV/ Security/ CABD/ Telecom./ Intercom and etc.) should be indicated on ELV trunking. Size of ELV trunking has been revised. (See attached
cable containment layout for review. Sizing of those cable containment for Server Room should be B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/3001 to 3008)
reviewed.

C22 1/3/2019 Schematic diagram for telecommunication system (broadband and telephone) and associated cable Schematic diagram for telecommunication system (broadband and
containment is required. telephone) and associated cable containment will be provided once the
broad wiring coordinator is available.

C23 1/3/2019 Please prepare the security system including the door lock and CCTV in separate set of drawings for Please refer to Appendix BS-03 Security System & CCTV Layout for
ease of checking. security system including the door lock and CCTV location

9 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response
C24 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Provide schematic diagram of Central Battery System and Earthing System Schematic diagram of Central Battery System and Earthing System
/1001 will be provided separately upon Electrical Contractor submission and
approval.

2 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please ensure separated power distribution system for Exhibition Gallery 1, Exhibition Gallery 2, Please be clarified that according to Technical Schedule 23e (ii), one
/1001 Temporary Office / Storage 1 and Temporary Office 2, with individual energy meter individual energy meter is provided for Exhibition Gallery, and the
power supply for Temporary Office / Storage 1 & 2 is fed from the
MCB Board "GAUN" for public normal lighting and small power at
UG/F.
Individual digital meter is now provided for Exhibition Gallery 1,
Exhibition Gallery 2, Temporary Office / Storage 1 and Temporary
Office 2 instead of HKE energy meter. (See attached B.S. Drawings
drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/1001)

3 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please also ensure provision of metering devices for monitor of power consumption and efficiency in Metering device has been provided for pumping services and public
/1001 pumping services and public lighting lighting. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/EL/1001)
4 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL 5/F Server Room: Provide individual MCB Board for the room Individual MCB Board "ADCS" for small power for 5/F Server Room
/1001 is now provided. Please note the lighting power for 5/F Server Room is
still fed from the MCB Board "ADCL".
(See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/1001)

5 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL Electrical schematic diagram: MCB boards 'GA5N' & ' GA5E' for 6/F and 7/F should be separated and MCB boards for 6/F and 7/F are now separated from MCB boards
/1001 relocated to Meter Room of the respective floors from MCB board of 5/F for maintenance purpose 'GA5N' & ' GA5E' and relocated to Meter Room of the respective
floors. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/1001,
2007, 2009 & 2010)

C25 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Any CBMS system provision for G/F Plant Rooms Additional CBMS system provision has been provided for G/F Plant
/1005 Rooms. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/1005)

2 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Refer to Comment C6 & C7., please review number and coverage of wifi access points due to The number of wifi access point has been revised. (See attached B.S.
/1005 depreciation of Wifi intensity by obstruction of building elements Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2002, 2007, 2009 & 2010)

C26 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Any access control system for exit doors communicating GA and staircases of Non-GA Area Please be clarified that no access control system for exit doors
/1006 communicating GA and staircases of Non-GA Area is provided
2 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Any access control system for doors communicating GA and Non-GA Area at 7/F Please be clarified that no access control system for exit doors
/1006 communicating GA and Non-GA Area at 7/F is provided

3 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Refer to Comment A5, provide mapping of CCTV coverage for review of CCTV layout Please refer to Appendix Appendix BS-02 CCTV Coverage.
/1006
4 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL 2/F & 5/F GA Area: Provide provisions of card access control system for the doors:- Please be confirmed that concealed conduit and concealed junction box
/1006 - Entrances for Reception provision for future installation of card access control system for the
- Entrances of Office Area doors will be provided.
- Conference Rooms
- Toilets
- Server Room
- Door between AIC Front of Centre and Back of Centre

5 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL UG/F Temporary Office and Exhibition Gallery: Schematic diagram of PA system for the rooms is Noted. PA system for UG/F Temporary Office and Exhibition Gallery
/1006 subject to coordination with the respective AV and specialist lighting consultant will be further coordinated with the respective AV and specialist
lighting consultant

10 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response
C27 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL For electrical layout of AIC Area, Exhibition Gallery and Temporary Office / Storage, please provide Please refer to B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/7001
/2002 details of layout and panel arrangement drawing for consideration
2 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please provide 2-way light switch at each door of Temporary Office/Storage 2 2-way light switch has been provided at each door of Temporary
/2002 Office/Storage 2 ((See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/EL/2002)

3 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please ensure power points are provided for electrical curtain and security system Please be confirmed that general socket outlets have been provided for
/2002 electrical curtain and fused connection unit have been provided for
security system.

4 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please ensure lighting is provided in Pipe Duct for maintenance purpose Additional lighting has been provided in Pipe Duct. (See attached B.S.
/2002 Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2001 to 2010)
5 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please indicate location of MVAC controller/ switch Please be clarified that the MVAC controller/ switch is shown on the
/2002 MVAC layout. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/2002)
6 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL 4-5 floor power sockets are on the same location. Please clarify if floor box will now be installed. Please refer to Appendix BS-05 Floor Box Catalogue for multiple
/2002 Please show details. sockets.
7 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Access card reader should be provided for Temporary Office/Storage 1 & 2. Please be confirmed that concealed conduit and concealed junction box
/2002 provision for future installation of card access control system for
Temporary Office/Storage 1 & 2 will be provided.

8 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL UG/F Temporary Office and Exhibition Gallery: Power and ELV layout shall be subject to coordination Noted. ELV layout for UG/F Temporary Office and Exhibition Gallery
/2002 with the respective AV and specialist lighting consultant will be further coordinated with the respective AV and specialist
lighting consultant
9 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL AIC Area: Provide socket outlets and telecommunication ports for floor level of AIC Front of Centre and Concealed conduit and concealed junction box provision for future
/2002 Back of Centre installation of socket outlets and telecommunication ports will be
provided at floor level in AIC Front of Centre and Back of Centre.

10 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL AIC Area: Provide minimum provisions of power sockets and ELV ports as per the mark-up on the The location of power sockets and ELV parts now follow the mark-up
/2002 proposed furniture layout from AIC's operational point of view (refer to Appendix 1). AP to further on the proposed furniture layout from AIC's operational point of view.
review and coordinate for overall design Provisions of power sockets and ELV ports will be provided in AIC
Area as per the mark-up. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/EL/2002)

11 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL UG/F AIC Area: Please provide power points of the FCU for this area which shall be installed out of The power points of the FCU has been relocated. (See attached B.S.
/2002 AIC Area Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2002)
12 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL AIC (Store Room): Provide power point above common area adjacent to the room for future installation Power points are now provided above common area adjacent to the
/2002 of two sets of split type a/c unit serving the room AIC (Store Room) for future installation of two sets of split type a/c
unit. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2002)

13 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL AIC (Store Room): Provide CCTV camera Please be confirmed that concealed conduit and concealed junction box
/2002 provision for future installation of CCTV camera will be provided in
AIC (Store Room).

C28 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please ensure lighting is provided in Pipe Duct and Concrete Air Plenum for maintenance purpose Additional lighting has been provided in Pipe Duct and Concrete Air
/2005 Plenum. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2001
to 2010)

2 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please ensure power points are provided for water leakage detection system Please be confirmed power points have been provided for water
/2005 leakage detction system.
C28 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please relocate light switches at strategic location and consider the circulation flow of staff Light switches have been relocated. (See attached B.S. Drawings
/2006 drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2006)

2 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL 5/F Reception: Indicate light fittings of reception counter if any LED lighting panels are installed above reception counter. (See
/2006 attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2006)

11 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response
C30 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please indicate location of MVAC controller/ switch Please be clarified that the MVAC controller/ switch is shown on the
/2007 MVAC layout. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/2006)

2 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please ensure location of power points for MVAC equipment and office desk in line with MVAC layout Noted. Please be confimed the location of power points for MVAC
/2007 and furniture layout equipment is in line with MVAC layout. The location of power points
for office desk will be in line with furniture layout once the furniture
layout is finalized.

3 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please review if power / data outlet in common area between Meeting Room 1 and PAU Room Additional power / data outlet has been provided in common area
/2007 between Meeting Room 1 asnd PAU Room. (See attached B.S.
Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2007)

4 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please ensure power points are provided for electrical curtain, water detection and security system Please be confirmed general socket outlets have been provided for
/2007 electrical curtain, and fused connection units have been provided for
water detection and security system.

5 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL 5/F GA Area: Provide socket outlets and telecommunication ports :- Please be confirmed that concealed conduit and concealed junction box
/2007 - Under raised floor of Server Room provision for future installation of socket outlets and
- The area at the corner of Lift Lobby outside PAU Room telecommunication ports will be provided for future installation.
- File and General Storage Area in open plan office
- High level on wall in the Corridor outside Conference Room
- Both ends of CE's Office

6 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL 5/F Accessible Toilet: Provide emergency call point and buzzer Emergency call point and buzzer has been provided for 5/F Accessible
/2007 Toilet. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2007)

7 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL 5/F Server Room: Provide individual MCB Board for the room Individual MCB Board "ADCS" for small power for 5/F Server Room
/2007 is now provided. Please note the lighting power for 5/F Server Room is
still fed from the MCB Board "ADCL".
(See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2007)

C31 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please ensure arrangement and orientation of light fittings is well coordinated with framing plan and Please be confirmed the arrangement and orientation of light fittings is
/2008 room layout well coordinated with framing plan and room layout.
C32 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please indicate location of MVAC controller/ switch Please be clarified that the MVAC controller/ switch is shown on the
/2009 MVAC layout. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/2007)

2 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Review location of MCB boards of Studio clashed with door swing MCB boards of Studio have been relocated. (See attached B.S.
/2009 Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2009)
3 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please ensure power points are provided for security system Please be confirmed power points have been provided for security
/2009 system.
C33 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please indicate location of MVAC controller/ switch Please be clarified that the MVAC controller/ switch is shown on the
/2010 MVAC layout. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/MVAC/2008)

2 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please ensure power points are provided for A/C equipment VOU(ADC) and security system Please be confirmed power points have been provided for A/C
/2010 equipment VOU(ADC) and security system.

12 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response
3 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please relocate the MCB board for Studio C-1 MCB board of Studio C-1 has been relocated. (See attached B.S.
/2010 Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2010)

C34 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Any cable containment for FS Control Room Concealed conduit has been provided for FS Control Room.
/3001
C35 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Any cable containment for panels of ELV system and Temporary Office/ Storage Concealed conduit has been provided for panels of ELV system and
/3002 Tempeorary Office/ Storage.
2 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL UG/F Temporary Office and Exhibition Gallery: Trunking routing for AV, specialist lighting and Noted. Trunking routing for AV, specialist lighting and auxiliary system
/3002 auxiliary system should be indicated after coordination with the respective consultant in future for UG/F Temporary Office and Exhibition Gallery will be further
coordinated with the respective consultant.
3 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL UG/F Temporary Office: Provide MCB Board serving Exhibition Gallery according to electrical Please be clarified that the MCB Boards serving the Exhibition Gallery
/3002 schematic diagram (Dwg. Ref.: 8660/ADC/EL/1001) are now relocated to the new Meter Room adjacent to Storeroom (AIC)
(See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/1001 & 2002)

4 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL UG/F AIC (Back of Centre): Relocate MCB board Please be clarified that the MCB Board serving the AIC (Back of
/3002 Centre) is now relocated to the new Meter Room adjacent to Storeroom
(AIC) (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/1001 &
2002)

C36 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Any cable containment for Exhibition Gallery and Plant Rooms Concealed conduit has been provided for Exhibition Gallery and Plant
/3003 Rooms.
C37 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Any cable containment for Chiller Plant Room Concealed conduit has been provided for Chiller Plant Room.
/3005
C38 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Any cable containment running under raised floor Concealed conduit has been provided under raised floor.
/3006
C39 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Please relocate the electricity trunking and cable containment not solely used by Studio B-12 from Please be clarified that the electricity trunking and cable containment
/3007 Studio B-12 for ease of maintenance are running in the bulkhead above Studio B-6.
Please refer to Detail A for the detail section of electricity trunking and
cable containment (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/EL/3007)

C40 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/EL Any cable containment for plant rooms and outdoor A/C units Concealed conduit has been provided for plant rooms and outdoor A/C
/3008 units.

13 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response
C41 1 1/3/2019 Location and quantity of switches, power/ data points, lighting, air grilles should be further coordinated Location and quantity of switches, power/ data points, lighting, air
with final layout plan of office area, AIC Area and Exhibition Gallery. Please ensure location of MCB grilles would be further coordinated with final layout plan of office
Board in Arts Studio will not clash with door swing. area, AIC Area and Exhibition Gallery. Please be ensured that location
of MCB Board in Arts Studio is now reviewed and will not clash with
door swing.

C42 1 1/3/2019 Mapping of CCTV Coverage and Access Control Plan should be provided for review. Please refer to Appendix Appendix BS-02 CCTV Coverage.

C43 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL UG/F Temporary Office and Exhibition Gallery: Schematic diagram of CABD system for the rooms is Noted. CABD system for UG/F Temporary Office and Exhibition
/1007 subject to coordination with the respective AV and specialist lighting consultant Gallery will be further coordinated with the respective AV and
specialist lighting consultant

C44 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL General Notes: The Sub-contractor shall coordinate and provide power point and cable containment of General Notes has been revised. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing
/0001 electrical and ELV system for future installation of F&E item by End User no. 8660/ADC/EL/0001)

C45 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL Notes of Luminaries Schedule: UV filter shall be provided for luminaires in Exhibition Gallery Notes of Luminaries Schedule has been revised. (See attached B.S.
/0002 Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/0002)

C46 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL Door Access Control & Door Monitoring Details: Provide emergency door release button nearby push Please be clarified that break glass unit is provided for doors with
/4001 button access control. The Door Access Control & Door Monitoring Details is
for showing the installation detail for the Door Access Control & Door
Monitoring System. Please refer to the attached B.S. Drawings for the
location of break glass unit.

C47 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL Details of Floor Mount Socket Outlet c/w Concealed Cover: Provide details for multiple outlet Details for multiple outlet arrangement will be further coordinated with
/4003 arrangement subject to approved material submission the respective AV and specialist lighting consultant.

C48 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL Cable Fixing between Suspended and Wall Mounted Cable Tray: Rubber protection should be provided Rubber protection has been provided at the sharp edge of suspended
/4004 at the sharp edge of suspended cable tray cable tray. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/EL/4004)
C49 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/EL Fixing of Trunking: Mushroom head screw should be installed in the orientation that screw thread Mushroom head screw is now installed in the orientation that screw
/4005 project out of the trunking thread project out of the trunking. (See attached B.S. Drawings
drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/4005)

C50 1 7/11/2019 G/F-3/F EL Duct, AC Duct Water Meter Cabinet, Pre-action Sprinkler Cabinet, SL-03 Lift Shaft, above Please be clarified that lighting has been provided inside SL-03 lift
water tank of Portable and Flushing Water Tank Room : Provide lighting for maintenance use shaft provided by the lift sub-contractor.
Lighting is now provided for G/F-3/F EL Duct, AC Duct Water Meter
Cabinet, Pre-action Sprinkler Cabinet, and above water tank of
Portable and Flushing Water Tank Room. (See attached B.S. Drawings
drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2001 - 2010)

C51 1 7/11/2019 Re. submission A-HAB-0798. Please ensure exit signs are duly provided in GA area. They are missed in The layout have been approved by FSD. Sufficient number of exit
some rooms, e.g.:- signs are provided.
UG/F - Temporary office / storage 2
5/F - Server Room, Conference Room 1-3
6/F - Arts Studios

D Fire Service Drawing

D1 1 21/3/2018 There should be no false ceiling in Exhibition Gallery (Drawing No. 8660/ADC/FS/2002) Noted.
FS Drawings will be revised and incorporated.

14 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response
D2 1 6/12/2018 Pre-action sprinkler system - Risk of water damage due to fault alarm and collision to sprinkler pipe is Type A sprinkler installation is adopted. The pre-action sprinkler
much concerned on IT equipment and exhibits. Please ensure the control logic and configuration of pre- comntrol valve set is only activated by an automatic fire detection
action sprinkler system get rid of the risk. system but not by the operation of sprinkler heads. Water will only be
Please advise. discharged when both fire is detected under sprinkler head and smoke
detector is activated.

D3 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/FS Refer to item 14.7 of General Notes. Please indicate provision of fire shutter if any Fire shutter is provided at B3/F to G/F which is therefore not shown in
/ 0001 this submission.

D4 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/FS Pre-action sprinkler system should be provided for each of Exhibition Gallery 1 & 2 Pre-action sprinkler system is now provided for each of Exhibition
/ 1002 Gallery 1 & 2. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/FS/1002)

D5 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/FS Any detector and FS provision at 7/F ADC Floor Schematic diagram is revised with detector and FS provision provided
/ 1003 at 7/F ADC Floor. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/FS/1003)

D6 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/FS Any detector in G/F plant rooms FS layout is revised with detector and FS provision provided G/F plant
/ 2001 rooms. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/FS/2001)

D7 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/FS Any detector and FS provision in Pipe Duct and Exhibition Gallery Please be clarified that no detector and FS provision is provided in Pipe
/ 2003 Duct. Please be confirmed that detector and FS provision is provided in
Exhibition Gallery.
2 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/FS 1/F PAU Room: Consider to relocate the hose reel to conspicuous location of the room The hose reel has been relocated outside the 1/F PAU Room. (See
/2003 attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/FS/2003)
D8 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/FS Pre-action sprinkler control valve should be removed from circulation towards File Storage area. The pre-action sprinkler control valve has been relocated. (See attached
/2006 B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/FS/2006)
2 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/FS 5/F Office Area outside CE Office: Relocate hose reel cabinet further away from CE Office The hose reel has been relocated away from CE Office. (See attached
/2006 B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/FS/2006)
D9 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/FS Any detector and FS provision in Pipe Duct Please be clarified that no detector and FS provision is provided in Pipe
/ 2007 Duct.
2 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/FS Any detector and FS provision in Genset Room Additional detector and FS provision has been provided in Genset
/ 2007 Room. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/FS/1003
& 2007)
D10 1 1/3/2019 For 5/F Server Room, Simultaneous Interpretation Room and AV room, measures to address the Type A sprinkler installation is adopted. The pre-action sprinkler
concern on the risk on water damage to electronic equipment in case of activation / mal-function of pre- comntrol valve set is only activated by an automatic fire detection
action sprinkler system is required. system but not by the operation of sprinkler heads. Water will only be
discharged when both fire is detected under sprinkler head and smoke
detector is activated.

D11 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/FS Exhibition Gallery Hall 1 & 2: Ensure remote indicator, breakglass unit and alarm bell are provided in Please be ensured that remote indicator, breakglass unit and alarm bell
/2002 the individual halls have been provided in the individual halls. (See attached B.S.
Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/FS/2002)

D12 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/FS 2/F: Fire detection and alarm system is missed Please be clarified that there are only pipe ducts and air duct belongs to
/2004 GA at 2/F, no fire detection and alarm system is required for those area.

D13 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/FS 3/F Air Duct Plenum (GA): Remote indicator and fire detector at high level plenum are missed Please be clarified that heat detectors have been provided at high level
/2005 plenum, and remote indicator is now provided outside the plenum.

15 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response
D14 1 7/11/2019 Re. submission A-HAB-0798. Please ensure portable fire extinguishers are duly provided in GA area. The layout have been approved by FSD. Sufficient number of portable
They are missed in some rooms, e.g.:- fire extinguishers are provided.
UG/F - Store Room (Aerial Platform), Temporary office / storage 1 & 2, AIC Area, Exhibition Gallery
5/F - Office Area, Server Room, Audio & Visual Room
6/F - Meter Room, Store Room, Multi-purpose Room, Refuse Storage
7/F - Meter Room

E Drainage Drawing
E1 1 21/3/2018 Please relocate the Waste Pipe outside the exit of Exhibition Gallery (Drawing No. 8660/ADC/DR/2003) Noted and revised.
[See Drawing no. 8660/ADC/DR/2003]

1.1 15/8/2018 The revised location is still too close to the exit of Exhibition Gallery. 2 nos of surface channels are provided at the entrance of the Art
Gallery. (See Drawings no.: 8660/ADC/DR/2003)
1.2 6/12/2018 Surface channels are not required. Please clarify if the waste pipe in previous drawing has been Please be confirmed the surface channels are deleted.
relocated.
E2 1 6/12/2018 8660-ADC- Please provide floor drain in G/F PAU Rm Floor drain has been provided in G/F AHU Room. (See attached B.S.
DR-2002 Please provide. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/DR/2002)

E3 1 6/12/2018 App BS-05 Sufficient number of pipe brackets should be provided to secure the tightness of pipe joints until Noted.
concreting
E4 1 6/12/2018 8660-ADC- Please provide floor drains for the portion of OU Platform Area exposed to weather Please be clarified that all OU Platform is now under cover. (See
DR-2009 & attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/DR/2009)
2010

E5 1 6/12/2018 - Drawing ref: 8660-ADC-DR-2004 - 2007 (1/F-5/F) are not provided. Please ensure floor drains are Please be confirmed floor drains are provided for all plant room for
provided for all plant room for A/C system A/C system. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/DR/2004 to 2007)

E6 1 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/D Drainage pipe from 6/F Accessible Toilet runs at 5/F high level next to Office Room for CE. Review 6/F 6/F Accessible Toilet has been relocated. (See attached B.S. Drawings
R/2007 & Layout for Accessible Toilet, Studio B-1 and B-11 drawing no. 8660/ADC/DR/2007 & 2008)
2008
2 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/D Relocate down pipe from 6/F Multi-purpose Room right above Reception Area The drainage pipe from 6/F Multi-purpose Room has been relocated
R/2007 & and run through the pipe duct adjacent to Reception Area. No drainage
2008 pipe is now running above Reception Area. (See attached B.S.
Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/DR/2007 & 2008)

3 1/3/2019 8660/ADC/D Soil/waste pipe at close proximity to Chief Executive Office is not ideal. AP to relocate the disabled 6/F Accessible Toilet has been relocated and no soil/waste pipe is
R/2007 toilet on 6/F. JRP to relocate the Soil/waste pipe. running at close proximity to Chief Executive Office. (See attached
B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/DR/2007 & 2008)

4 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/D 5/F Lift Lobby and File and Storage Area: Drainage layout of 5/F is deviated from that of 6/F. Drainage The drainage layout has been revised according to the updated
R/2007, 2008 pipe and soil pipe should be relocated from 5/F Lift Lobby and File and Storage Area architectural layout. Drainage pipe and soil pipe have been relocated
away from the lift lobby. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/DR/2007 & 2008)

5 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/D 5/F Office Area outside CE Office: Relocate the drainage down pipe at high level; Floor drain of hose The drainage layout has been revised according to the updated
R/2007 reel cabinet should be relocated as the cabinet was requested to relocate further away from CE Office architectural layout. Hose reel cabinet is relocated. (See attached B.S.
Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/DR/2007)

16 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response
6 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/D Office Area: Review arrangement of 6/F Universal Toilet to relocate soil pipe running from high level of The 6/F Universal Toilet has been rearranged and the soil pipe has been
R/2007 Office Area relocated away from high level of Office Area. (See attached B.S.
Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/DR/2007 & 2008)

7 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/D P.D. in Office Area: No access door shall be provided. Ensure access for maintenance / cleaning of the According to BD regulation, the P.D. shall be completed with access
R/2007 drainage pipe is not required at 5/F panel.

E7 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/D Draignage system schematic diagram: Revise provisions of water sink and drainage pipe from 7/F The layout and schematic diagram has been revised. (See attached B.S.
R/1001 Studio B-20 to 6/F Studio B-1 to match architectual layout of 6/F & 7/F Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/DR/1001, 8660/ADC/DR/2008)

2 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/D 5/F Lift Lobby: There should be no water sink provided in Lift Lobby The schematic diagram has been revised. (See attached B.S. Drawings
R/1001 drawing no. 8660/ADC/DR/1001)

E8 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/D UG/F Store Room (AIC): Provide CDP connection point in the room for future connection of split type CDP connection point has been provided in UG/F Store Room (AIC)
R/2003 AC unit future connection of split type AC unit. (See attached B.S. Drawings
drawing no. 8660/ADC/DR/2003)
E9 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/D 7/F Studio B-20: Floor drain and drainage pipe shall be removed when no sink is provided in the room The drainage layout has been revised according to the updated
R/2009 architectural layout. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/DR/2009)
2 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/D 7/F PAU Room: Review the two floor drains located quite close between each other in the room The two floor drains in 7/F PAU Room are bounded by the beams on
R/2009 6/F high level, Studio B-12 & B-13. They are now located away from
each other as far as possible. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/DR/2009)

E10 1 7/11/2019 A.C. Duct (GA): Provide floor drain in the pipe duct with AC water pipe from UG/F-3/F Floor drain is now provided in the pipe duct with AC water pipe from
UG/F-3/F. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no.
8660/ADC/DR/2002 to 2006)

F Plumbing Drawing
F1 1 3/1/2019 8660/ADC/PL F&E Tank and pipework for A/C system is missed. Please provide. F&E Tank and pipework for A/C system is shown on the Water Side
/1001 Schematic Diagram for MVAC. See attached B.S. Drawings drawing
no. 8660/ADC/MVAC/1002)

2 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/PL 6/F Studio B-1: Revise provisions of potable water supply from 7/F Studio B-20 to 6/F Studio B-1 to Plumbing layout and Schematic diagram have been revised. (See
/1001 match architectual layout of 6/F & 7/F attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/PL/1001,
8660/ADC/PL/2008, 8660/ADC/PL/2009)
F2 1 3/1/2019 8660/ADC/PL Any cleansing water point is provided at 7/F Outdoor for cleaning of A/C outdoor units Additional cleansing water point has been provided t 7/F Outdoor for
/2009 cleaning of A/C outdoor units. (See attached B.S. Drawings drawing
no. 8660/ADC/PL/2009)

F3 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/PL 6/F Cleaner's Store: Cleaner's sink and potable water pipe are missed The potable water pipe is now provided in 6/F Cleaner's Store. (See
/2008 attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/PL/2008)

F4 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/PL Plumbing installation details: Secure pipe at pipe bracket with double lock nuts Plumbing installation details has been revised. (See attached B.S.
/3001 Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/PL/3001)

F5 1 7/11/2019 8660/ADC/PL 5/F Water Meter Cabinet Details (Section B-B'): Metering for Lactation Room and Studio B-1 is Water Meter Cabinet Details has been revised. (See attached B.S.
/3002 required. No potable water supply is required in Lift Lobby and B-20 as per plumbing layout Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/PL/3002)

17 of 18
 No. Ref. Date Drawings Grantee/Purchaser/Trustee Response-to-Comment (R to C)
refer to
HKADC's Comment TS Ref. DLN's Response

G Lift
G1 1 21/3/2018 PL-09 (Disabled lift) should be regarded as common facility (Drawing No. 8660/ADC/LT/001). Noted. . Lift PL-09 will be a shared lift and maintained by developer.
(See attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/1001)

G2 1 21/3/2018 CCTV System / Lift Supervisory Panel / Intercom System for lift should be connected to the building CCTV System will be connected to 4/F Server Room and UG/F
management office (Drawing No. 8660/ADC/LT/2001) Temporary office/ storage room as per TS.

Lift Supervisory Panel and intercom system for ADC lift will be
connected to Arts Information Center (Back of centre area)

Lift Supervisory Panel and intercom system for ADC lift will be
1.1 15/08/2018 Lift Supervisory Panel and Intercom System should be placed in the building management office, same connected to ArtsPanel
Lift Supervisory Information Centersystem
and intercom (Back of
forhouse
ADC area)
lift will be
as other lifts of the building. connected to Arts Information Center (Back of centre area)

1.2 6/12/2018 Please place the equipment inside Temporary Office / Storage if it could not be placed inside building The equipment has been relocated to Temporary Office/ Storage 1. (See
management office. Subject to further confirmation with landlord. attached B.S. Drawings drawing no. 8660/ADC/EL/2002)

18 of 18