Professional Documents
Culture Documents
____________________
____________________
March 2019
ATENEO de DAVAO UNIVERSITY
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
Jacinto St., Davao City, Philippines
APPROVAL SHEET
Has been prepared and submitted by Angellie Mae B. Placido, Keith Marie
B. Yee, Johanna Gabrielle T. Afable, Isiah John N. Palangpang, Nina Valerie
L. Dela Peña, Sienna Leian Q. Dubal, and Cherry Mae L. Sison who are
recommended for the CULMINATING PERFORMANCE TASK.
_________________________________________
Engr. Ottoman Montani, Jr.
Chairperson – STEM
ii
Assistant Director for Academics
Senior High School Unit
Republic of the Philippines
Ateneo De Davao University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
Jacinto St., Davao City 8000
Declaration of Originality
iii
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
First and foremost, the researchers unconditionally and highly thank our
Almighty God for guiding and giving the researchers enough strength, wisdom and
The researchers would like to express their deepest gratitude to Mr. Ricardo
P. Enriquez, the Ateneo de Davao Senior High School director, for giving the
researchers the opportunity and blessing to conduct the study as a part of shaping
The researchers are deeply thankful to Mrs. Aujefel Amor Y. Lee, the
Assistant Director for Academics, for giving us permission to conduct this research
Moreover, the study would not have been possible without the help of the
research advisers, who were always there to guide and give the researchers
intellectual comments and pieces of advice that were essential in making the study
successful.
Last but not the least, the researchers would also like to extend their heart-
felt thanks to their parents for the financial, moral and emotional support and their
Placido, A.M.
Afable, J.G.
Palangpang I.J.
Dela Peña, N.V.
Dubal, S.L.
Sison, C.M.
Yee, K.M.
iv
ABSTRACT
This quantitative experimental study was conducted to measure if there was a significant
difference between the durability of a paper bag made from corn husk and a commercial
SOS brown paper bag in terms of weight capacity. The experiment was conducted in the
Physics lab of Ateneo de Davao University. Using an electronic scale and weights
weighing 500 grams, the corn husk paper bag and the SOS brown paper bag were tested,
each with 3 trials. On each trial, the researchers added one weight until the paper bag
was torn. The independent t-test was the statistical tool used to obtain the results. The
results showed that the corn husk paper bag has a higher weight capacity than SOS
brown paper bag. This study is deemed significant to the institution of Ateneo de Davao
University and the data gathered was based on the findings which were obtained from
Keywords: Corn Husk, SOS brown paper bag, Paper bag, Paper, Quantitative
v
Page
TITLE PAGE i
APPROVAL SHEET ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT iv
ABSTRACT v
TABLE OF CONTENTS vi
LIST OF FIGURES ix
CHAPTER
Conceptual Framework 4
Definition of Terms 7
Paper 9
Corn Husk 15
Paper Bag 19
3 METHODOLOGY
vi
Research Design 21
Research Locale 22
Materials 26
Experimental Procedure 27
Ethical Considerations 29
Summary of Findings 38
Conclusions 39
Recommendations 39
REFERENCES 41
APPENDIX
A. Letter
CURRICULUM VITAE 52
vii
LIST OF TABLES
Table
Weight Capacity
Capacity
viii
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure
ix
CHAPTER 1
contributed to the generation of paper waste in huge quantities from day to day. A
number of paper wastes were generated daily through human activities in relation
to the progress of civilization. During the present electronic age, individuals began
to think about going paperless. Be that as it may, there is as yet far to go before
losing the reliance on paper. From daily papers to paper wrappings, paper was all
over and the vast majority of them were winding up in the landfills making a
staggering amount of paper waste. As the way as it has been, wood has
traditionally been the most widely used lignocellulosic matter in the production of
pulp, furniture, and boards of diverse types, as well as being a source of energy.
The increasing demand for these raw materials, together with economic and
had reached 398 million tons per year. Comparatively, as the global demand for
consumption had increased by about 400 percent in the past forty years (Martin,
2011). With current technology, paper has become a cheap commodity. Its
enterprise program of the country, adding to the development of the economy and
also conjointly contributed to the waste generation in the country. According to the
Asian Development Bank (2004), waste paper was the second most produced
solid waste in the Philippines, contributing nineteen percent of the total municipal
solid waste production. It has been ranked to be the second most produced solid
waste, waste paper contributes to 19% of the total municipal solid waste in the
Philippines. The paper industry in spite of the generation of high amount of waste
was still considered as a large net importer of waste paper products as its primary
raw material.
In the local context, about 35% of the country’s forest cover – that is
6,066,160 hectares – were found in Mindanao, which was the second largest
island in the Philippines (Tacio, 2018). The City Council of Davao City cut down
on its use of paper during its regular sessions, as stated by the third district
Councilor Bernard Al-ag (Vega, 2017). According to Vega, Councilor Bernard Alag
stated that the cutting down on paper served as a preparation for the next year
wherein the council will no longer be using paper for their sessions. On the other
hand, white corn and yellow corn production in Davao Region increased by
15.61% and 24.22%, respectively, as of the 3rd quarter of 2017 (Arado, 2018).
inspiration from it. In order to help conserve nature, alternative source of making
2
a paper instead of trees should be used. The researchers of the study aimed to
examine the potential of Corn husk (Z. Mays) as an alternative source of paper
and control the ecological threat on trees. Through the use of corn husk as an
utilization of waste corn husk that gradually reduced the amount of solid waste in
the country and at the same time lead in a major breakthrough in our economic
consumption and raw-material availability have increased for the paper industry, it
food crop residues including rice husk, corn straw, okra stalks, corn stalk, banana
bunch, pineapple leaf and corn husks which do not have immediate beneficial
pulp (Kamoga, 2013). Among these agricultural residues, corn husks have been
the subject of a very limited amount of research interest as a fiber source. Statistics
have shown that in the year 2016, the corn production in the Philippines amounted
to approximately 7.22 million metric tons as opposed to 6.97 million metric tons in
2011 which corresponded that more corn husk waste were generated. Through
this, corn husks were chosen as it may be reused in producing paper in a cheap
3
Conceptual Framework
bag was made from corn husk through pulp making process having water as the
positive control and the sodium carbonate as the negative control. Quantitative
analysis was taken through assessment of the quality of the paper bag by weight
capacity test.
Positive Control:
Corn husk paper Pulp
Water
bag making
process
Negative Control:
Sodium Carbonate
Experimentation
Quantitative Analysis
Figure 1. The effects of the corn husk fiber to the quality of corn husk paper bag
as compared to the quality of SOS brown paper bag.
4
Statement of the Problem
The main objective of this study was to determine whether the corn husk
1. What is the durability of the corn husk paper bag in terms its weight
capacity?
2. What is the durability of the commercial SOS brown paper bag in terms of
husk paper bag and the commercial SOS brown paper bag?
Research Hypothesis
H₀: There was no significant difference between the weight capacity of the
corn husk paper bag and the commercial SOS brown paper bag.
Paper is a material that is used pervasively for printing, writing, books, and
advertisements. Over 40% of the world's cut timber is used for paper production,
and it requires millions of trees to be cut down and uses a lot of water. In that case,
corn husk can stand to be potential sources for pulp with lesser environmental
degradation threat than wood which is traditionally the most widely used ligno-
5
cheap and environmentally friendly way. In line with the study may help the
following:
Farmers. This study will be to the farmers as this may serve as a new income
source. Since the corn husk is already available in the farm, farmers may make a
paper bag out of the fibers of this corn husk and may sell it to the market.
alternative material for making paper bags instead of trees. Thus, it may lessen
who will be conducting similar studies. The ideas presented would give them
The goal of this study was to create corn husk paper bags and compare its
weight capacity to the commercial SOS brown paper bag. The study was
conducted in the second semester of the school year 2018-2019. The raw material
used was native corn (Zea mays). The researchers gathered information by
bags. The processes for creating the corn husk paper bag and comparison
between the commercial and corn husk paper bag were done within Davao City,
This study was only limited to the use of corn Z. mays in the city of Davao.
6
techniques and did not involve advanced machinery in both creating the desired
material and in comparing it with the commercialized paper bag. In addition, the
study was only limited to measuring and comparing the weight capacity of the corn
husk paper bag and the commercial SOS brown paper bag and did not dwell on
bags created, cost efficiency, and many others. Furthermore, the study did not
take into consideration other factors concerning the production of the raw materials
used in creating the paper such as the growing environment of the corn, the overall
Definition of Terms
These terms were commonly used in this study and the researchers have
this study.
foods to be steamed or baked; Corn husk fibers have a high cellulose content of
80%-87%.
Native Corn. Also known by the scientific name Zea mays. Considered as
the second most important crop after rice in the Philippines; could either be white
or yellow.
7
Paper. Material manufactured in thin sheets from the pulp of wood or other
material.
on one side. They are renewable, recyclable, reusable and compostable because
they are commonly made from renewable resources such as trees; ideal
Weight Capacity. An amount that something can hold; maximum load that
8
CHAPTER 2
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
related to concepts and variables related on the use of corn husk fibers as an
alternative paper bag such as papers, non-wood cellulosic fibers, corn husk, and
paper bag.
Papers
Paper is a material that has been around for about 2000 years. It was
developed in China in the first or second century AD, and it is made by pressing
the fibers of cellulose derived from plants and then dried to result in sheets. Today,
there was an increase of demand for papers around the world that was used for
developing into various materials such as money, toilet tissues, paper bags, and
Koppelaar (2009) stated that paper could consist of non-wood fibers as well
as wood fibers that undergoes pulp making or the papermaking process. Non-
wood fibers originated from natural sources such as food crop residues and cotton.
On the other hand, wood fibers came from trees and was mostly used in today's
paper products.
different forms of papers or the different paper grades include bond paper, book
paper, bristol, groundwood, and newsprint papers, kraft wrapping, paperboards,
and sanitary papers. The durability distinguished bond paper for repeated handling
and filing, a degree of stiffness, and the resistance to the penetration and
spreading of ink. On the other side, book papers are made of various combinations
of chemical pulp and also have various properties depending on the type of book
to be made. Moreover, the general term of bristol refers to a group of stiff, heavy
papers with thicknesses ranging from 0.15 millimeter and upward. Groundwood
and newsprints, on the other hand, are printing and converting grades containing
pulp for strength and durability and tend to be bulky and are receptive to printing
ink. These papers do not have high whiteness and tend to turn yellow when
exposed to light and after long aging. For the kraft wrapping papers, these pertain
to the heavy stock used for paper bags and was in greater volume than all other
made from softwoods, usually pine trees. Moreover, the process for manufacturing
kraft paper involved the exposure of wood chips to intense heat, which breaks
them down into solid pulp and byproducts. This pulping process made kraft paper
particularly strong and ideal for carrying heavy loads due to its reduced lignin
content and high sulfur ratio. On the other hand, paperboards are paper products
which have thicknesses of 0.30 millimeters and above and commonly made from
wood pulp. Lastly are the sanitary papers which are relatively weak because of its
10
Furthermore, Britt (2012) also explained the properties of papers such as
the substance and quantity measurement, strength and durability, and optical
properties. The substance and quantity measurement referred to the basis weight
and the caliper or thickness of the paper. Moreover, strength and durability of the
paper was determined through the combination of the factors such as the strength
of the individual fibers of the stock, the average length of the fiber, the inter fiber
bonding ability of the fiber which was enhanced by the beating and refining action,
and the structure and formation of the sheet. Lastly, the optical properties of the
capacity of the paper such as the tensile strength, bursting strength, tearing
resistance, and folding endurance. Tensile strength dealt with the stress-strain of
the paper. As stress was further increased, the point of failure was reached, and
the paper strip ruptured. This maximum value of the stress at failure if the tensile
breaking strength of the paper. In the bursting strength, the stretch was the limiting
factor because as the paper bulges, it was strained equally in both directions until
it reached its strength limit. However, tensile breaking strength and bursting
strength exhibit good correlation. Regarding the tearing resistance of the paper, it
is a measure of the force perpendicular to the plane of the paper necessary to tear
a single sheet through a specified distance after the tear has already been started.
With the folding endurance, it was a test used to measure the ability of a paper to
maintain its strength after repeated folding (Caulfield & Gunderson, 2000).
11
Also, Shen (2002) revealed that the rupture capacity of the paper was not
controlled by the mean strength but by the minimum strength regions in the sheet.
process of papermaking thus, affecting the overall strength and opacity of the
paper. Therefore, the mechanical and strength properties of paper reflect the
the network structure of the paper predicting strength, printability, and appearance
With that said, a study of Kang et al. (2006) presented that using an ultra-
fine friction grinder, it was attainable to strengthen mostly the external fibrillation
while maintaining the internal fibrillation of the paper. This then made it feasible to
investigate the effects of the external fibrillation on the strength of the paper.
However, the sheet identity was highly reliant on the internal fibrillation, by mostly
utilizing the external fibrillation, sheet density could also significantly increase. Be
that as it may, this study also revealed that the breaking length of the paper was
highly reliant on the internal fibrillation of the fibers and the amount of fines added
to the furnish, but there was no significant effect seen on external fibrillation even
though the sheet density increased. Moreover, the external fibrillation was closely
related to the formation of fines and the external fibrils which were attached to the
fiber is expected to have a similar role as the fines in a fiber network which
12
Non-wood Cellulosic Fibers
The increasing demand for wood fiber consumptions especially in pulp and
paper making has pushed forward the search for alternative fiber resources. Non-
wood cellulosic fibers such as agricultural residues were good candidates because
waste fibers. Some of the regions that showed the greatest change in the volume
of non-woods used in the paper-making process were the Asia and the Pacific
and fines on the drainage of kraft pulp suspension and paper strength by Taipale
et al. (2010) explained that the diverse types of microfibrillated cellulose or MFC
properties of hand sheets made thereof. The effects of salt concentration, pH,
investigated. The article states that all the MFC and fines samples produced had
13
different properties because of their contradictory production procedures and they
paper. The study also added that generally, the addition of MFC decreased the
drainage rate of pulp suspension and significantly increased the strength of paper.
However, the data has shown that by optimum selection of goods and process
such as Maize husks and stalk were used in pulp and paper production.
Furthermore, Maize husk is 1.37mm in fiber length while the Maize stalk is
1.52mm, in which a fiber length controlled the physical and mechanical properties
Runkel ratio or Runkel’s proportion was used in determining the thickness of the
fibers’ wall and cellulose; greater than one (1) being the less suitable, equal to one
(1) being satisfactory, and less than one being the most suitable for paper
production.
analyzed the effects of cellulose fibers utilizing the precipitation in-situ of calcium
carbonate over printing paper properties acquired from softwood and hardwood
fiber mixtures. By the addition of precipitated calcium carbonate into fiber stock,
the effects of fibers with in-situ loading were analyzed through comparison
respectively with the standard paper loading. Using different investigations and
14
analyses such as the optical and mechanical properties of the paper sheets, X-ray
these effects, it was concluded that higher opacity and brightness was produced
by the in-situ loading method than the standard methods at the same filler content.
Regardless of whether they are softwood fibers or hardwood fibers, using cellulose
fibers with in-situ loading as an additive was shown as an alteration of the ratio
between fibers with in-situ loading and without loading allows for the optimization
of printing paper properties, especially with regard between the optical and
strength properties.
Overall, there are more non-wood cellulosic fibers that can be an alternative
raw material in making a paper. However, the abundance and availability of these
available around 9 million tons every year in the world. It is the second largest
source of natural fibers preceded by cotton and followed by jute and is the most
low-cost source of natural cellulosic fiber. Moreover, it has great potential for high
value textile applications and has better process than natural fibers extracted from
the process of the fiber extraction from corn husk required less energy and is eco-
15
friendly compared to the regenerated and the synthetic fiber production process
From there, an article by Taiwo et al. (2014) entitled Pulp and paper-making
potential of corn husk from the International Journal of AgriScience cited that the
research regarding how suitable several agriculture waste materials are for pulp
and the production of paper. With this, the study investigated the potential of corn
husk in Nigeria for paper making. Also, the evaluation of the fiber structure of the
corn husk validates that it contains short fibers resembling that of various
hardwoods with has the length of <2 mm. The results from testing the strength of
hand sheet acquired from corn husk showed that corn husk paper has
strength and tearing resistance can be enhanced by incorporating corn husk pulp
producing quality paper from corn husks and snake plant (Sansevieria zeylanica)
experiment and sensory evaluation, the qualities of the paper created from the
fibers while utilizing an experimental design in making the paper. According to the
results, pure corn husks garnered the closest standard measurement for the basis
weight. On the other hand, pure snake plant fibers, 75% corn husks and 25%
snake plant fibers, 50% corn husks and snake plant fibers, and 25% corn husks
and 75% snake plant fibers adhered to the standard measurement for the
16
thickness. Additionally, all treatments adhered to the standard measurement for
the tensile strength while all the treatments except 50% corn husk and snake plant
fibers followed the standard measurement for folding endurance. Aside from that,
the study showed that among all the treatments, 75% corn husks and 25% snake
plant fibers was the most acceptable based on the sensory evaluation. There is a
significant difference in the color of the paper with one another by the evaluation
significant difference on the level of acceptability of utilizing corn husks and snake
plant fibers as raw materials for producing paper in accordance to the texture,
among agricultural wastes is corn husk. In his study, the corn husk was treated
(TEM), the investigation on the morphology of the fibers was conducted. The
progressive removal of materials apart from cellulose was shown by the Fourier
transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy. Also, X-ray diffraction analysis (XRD) was
used to investigate the crystallinity of the corn husk and CNCs. For this study,
treatments on the mechanical properties of corn husk fibers by Yilmaz (2012) that
17
fibers from the corn husk are obtained through water retting, alkalization, and
chemical aspects of the corn husk fibers were investigated. The chemical
formations of the fibers were examined through IR measurements. The finest and
stiffest fibers are created by water retting followed by an enzymatic treatment. The
article states that the maximal breaking strength and breaking tenacity are
treatment duration was obtained on the mechanical properties of corn husk fibers.
treated ones. Lastly, the article stated that enzymatic treatment and alkalization
With that, corn husks could be of great help especially when it comes to
Furthermore, in using these, the result would more likely depend on the type of
corn husks used. In terms of the color, it was mentioned from Storm the Castle
(n.d.) that the paper would more likely appear based on the dominant color of the
corn husk used. Its texture, length, and thickness would depend on the process
18
since it can be handled physically. Thus, corn husk as a potential raw material in
papermaking, can also be turned into something more useful such as paper bags.
Paper Bags
Paper bags have been of great help to every human being since their
Packaging, n.d.). Moreover, according to Paper Mart (2018), the most popular
material used in making paper bags is kraft paper which is manufactured from
wood chips.
professional appeal, versatile, and it benefits a lot of users. Paper bags are eco-
friendly as this is made from renewable natural resources and can be used
repeatedly. In fact, minimal energy is used in making paper bags. In the aspect of
paper bags are versatile as it can be used as packaging for a broad range of
products.
many ways, such as a mode for carrying things. These are usually seen in malls,
where people can use it as a big sack, shopping bag, or for packaging.
Furthermore, paper bags are made up of different varieties of kraft paper or other
19
materials, in which their sizes and designs will depend. In addition, using paper
With these literature and related studies presented, the study of corn husk
as an alternative raw material in making a paper bag can be supported. The above
how these properties are measured and the standards and mechanisms that are
applicable in testing paper quality. In line with this study, related studies which
involved the use of non-wood cellulosic fibers in creating paper were also cited,
which mainly focused on the analysis of such fibers and proved that fibers that are
studies on corn husk fibers were emphasized. Corn husk, being an abundant
source of natural fibers, was subject to various studies which involved the analysis
of its properties as a potential source material for papermaking. With this, corn
husks were proven to be potential substitutes for crafting paper. Lastly, the subject
of paper bags was integrated and justified paper bags being the end product of
this research. Among the reasons cited are that paper bags are versatile and eco-
conclude, the accumulated sources gave insight as to why and how this study can
be supported.
20
CHAPTER 3
research locale, the instruments used, the data gathering procedure, and the
Research Design
used in this study to determine whether the corn husk (Z. mays) can be used as
collecting data and in examining the relationship between variables that was
(Mitchell, 2015) also defined experimental design as the study which was centrally
concerned of being high in causal validity which pertained to the accuracy of the
cause and effect of the relationships of the variables. Thus, this research design
was the best approach to determine whether the corn husk was an effective
alternative for paper bags as this research focused on the durability of the corn
paper bag.
Research Locale
MacArthur Highway GSIS Heights Matina, Davao City as the place had a large
area and had available utensils that were suitable for the process of pulp making.
The place was just along the highway which was convenient for the researchers
22
Figure 2. Map of Research Locale
23
Moreover, the paper bag test was conducted within the premises of Ateneo
de Davao University Jacinto campus. This was where the researchers made most
of the study. The Physics Laboratory in the campus was utilized because it had
24
Figure 3. Map of Research Locale
25
Subject of the Study
The subject of the study was the corn husk as an alternative substance in
making a paper bag. Greenish brown corn husks from sweet corn was used since
Furthermore, it was not necessary to use pure green colored corn husk since it
affected the color of the paper. According to Storm the Castle (n.d.), the paper’s
color depended on the dominant color of the corn husks used. Thus, if the husk’s
color was greenish brown, the paper would also appear greenish
brown. Moreover, these fibers from the corn husk were boiled in water and mixed
with a chemical which was sodium carbonate to be broken down and was then
dried in a silkscreen. In addition, commercial SOS brown paper bag was used as
the standard paper bag in order to compare the durability of the corn husk paper
bag.
Materials
● Weights. The equipment placed inside the paper bags to test for its weight
● Ruler. This was used in measuring the breaking length of the paper.
● Weighing Scale. This was utilized in measuring the total weight of the coins
placed inside the paper bag. For this research, the domestic platform
26
Experimental Procedure
Pre-experimentation
1. The needed tools and equipment for the experiment were prepared. Soda
ash, silkscreen, measuring cup, blender, and stainless steel pot and corn
husk were the constituents that were used in the experiment. Proper attire
2. The materials required for the experiment such as the corn for the corn
husks, soda ash (sodium carbonate) and silkscreen may be bought at the
local market. The utensils that were used in the experiment were stainless
steel because one of the materials that was used was soda ash (sodium
During Experimentation
2. Right after rinsing, four (4) cups of water were boiled in a stainless steel
pan.
3. (1) tablespoon of soda ash was put for this will help in breaking the fibers
4. The husks were place in the boiling water with soda ash (sodium
carbonate). A stainless steel utensil was used to push the corn husk down
27
5. After boiling the husks for a minimum of two hours, the researchers placed
it in a, container and rinsed it properly with water to remove the excess soda
ash on it.
6. The husk was used and placed in the blender to mix and grind the husks.
7. Silkscreen was dried under the sun within two hours, until the paper is dried
out.
8. The researchers cleaned the area where the experiment was conducted.
Washed the utensils and cleaned the equipment that were used.
9. When the paper is already dry, three papers were cut with a dimension of
10. After preparing the papers in making the paper bag, a dimension of seven
(7) inches in length and two (2) inches in width paper bags were made out
of it.
Post-experimentation
1. The three corn husk paper bags and three commercial SOS brown paper
bags were prepared for the data gathering of the weight capacity. There
2. In testing for the weight capacity of the paper bag, weights weighing 500-
28
3. Put a 500-gram weight inside the corn husk paper bag and the researcher
held the paper bag in the air for twenty seconds to determine if the paper
4. Another 500 grams of weight were added if the paper bag did not break.
The weight was recorder and this step was repeated until the paper bag
5. The weight capacity process was repeated using the remaining five paper
bags.
In treating the data, the researchers identified the mean of the weight
capacity of the corn husk paper bag and the commercial SOS brown paper bag to
determine which of the paper bag had the greater durability. In determining
whether there was a significant difference between the means of two groups, the
statistical tool that was used was T-test Thus, it was easy to identify whether the
Ethical Considerations
Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research (1974) stated that ethics were
the standard for conduct that assorted acceptable and unacceptable behavior
29
when doing or conducting a research. The researchers conducted a quantitative
people involved voluntarily agreed to conduct this research and accepted their
roles in the study. Mutual respect was shown between the researchers all
throughout the conducting period. The researchers were also made aware of the
situation that they were in and was made fully informed of the whole process of
the study.
Justice. The tasks and responsibilities were equally and fairly distributed
were also put into consideration thus, the researchers were assigned tasks that
were inclined to their skills and strengths. Recognition for a job well done was also
given to those wholly deserving. The researchers were recognized and graded for
30
CHAPTER 4
This chapter presents the analysis of data and the discussion of the
research findings in a tabular and textual form. The findings relate to the statement
of the problem and the gathered data were analyzed and interpreted to identify
Weight Capacity
Table 1 presented the data gathered on the durability of the corn husk paper
The table revealed that the second trial had the greatest weight capacity of
seven and a half (7.5) kilograms among all of the trials. On the other hand, the first
In general, the mean for the weight capacity of the corn husk paper bag
was six (6) kilograms. This denoted that corn husk paper bag can carry a minimum
of five (5) kilograms and a maximum of seven and a half (7.5) kilograms.
The evaluation of the fiber structure of the corn husk validates that it
contains short fibers resembling that of various hardwoods with a length of <2 mm
(Taiwo et al., 2014). The results from testing the weight capacity of the corn husk
paper bag showed that corn husk paper has considerable strength.
Table 1
1 5
2 7.5
3 5.5
Mean 6
32
Moreover, Kampeerapapapun (2015) had indicated that one of the
biomass among agricultural wastes is corn husk. Therefore, paper bags made
from corn husk would most likely cost less than the regular paper bag. With that,
corn husks could be a great help especially when it comes to making alternative
However, if utilized, the result will more likely depend on the type of corn
husks used. Storm the Castle (n.d.) presented that the paper will more likely
appear based on the dominant color of the corn husk used. The texture, length,
and thickness depended on the process since it can be handled physically. Thus,
corn husk, from the results, had a potential to be a raw material in papermaking
The table showed that the first trial had the greatest weight capacity of
four (4) kilograms among all the trials. Whilst, the last trial showed the least by
In general, the mean weight capacity of the commercial SOS brown paper
bag was three and a half (3.5) kilograms. This revealed that the commercial SOS
33
Table 2
1 4
2 3.5
3 3
Mean 3.5
34
brown paper bag can carry a minimum of 3 (three) kilograms and a maximum of
According to Paper Mart (2018) the most common type of paper used in
making a paper bag is a kraft paper. Britt (2012) further stated that kraft wrapping
usually pine trees. This pulping process makes kraft paper particularly strong and
ideal for carrying heavy loads due to its reduced lignin content and high sulfur ratio.
emphasized how the SOS brown paper bag could only carry less than four (4)
kilograms.
Table 3 showed the result for the difference in the durability of corn husk
The table stipulated that at 0.05 confidence level, the null hypothesis was
rejected, due to the calculated p-value, 0.038, being less than the 0.05 confidence
level. Additionally, the computed t-value of 3.062 exceeded the tabulated t-value
of |+/-2.776|, indicating that there was a significant difference between the weight
capacity of the corn husk paper bag and commercial SOS brown paper bag.
focused on the production of quality paper from corn husks and snake plant
(Sansevieria zeylanica) fibers, the results showed that pure corn husks come close
35
Table 3
Difference in the Durability of Corn Husk and Commercial SOS Brown
@ a=0.05 value on Ho on
Difference
Computed Tabulated
Weight Capacity
Commercial 3.5
36
to the standard measurement for basis weight and adhere to the standard
measurement for thickness. Additionally, Shen (2002) disclosed that the rupture
capacity of paper is not regulated by the mean strength but by the minimum
strength regions in the sheet. These regions can be characterized by the paper
papermaking process therefore affecting the opacity and overall strength of the
paper.
on the paper strength. The aforementioned study also revealed that the breaking
length of paper relies heavily on the internal fibrillation of the fibers. However, a
increase in sheet density. These studies alongside the obtained results stipulated
that a factor that while the corn husk paper bag produced is relatively thicker
study is the unequal distribution of fibers in the corn husk paper bag in which the
fiber distribution in the corn husk paper bag is more unequal than that of the
commercial SOS brown paper bag. In order to effectively measure the weight
capacity, the fiber distribution of the corn husk paper bag should be nearly the
same as the commercial SOS brown paper bag to rule out any additional factors.
37
CHAPTER 5
obtained conclusion from the gathered data, and the recommendations based on
the results from this research study. The study is on the difference between the
durability of a paper bag made from corn husk and a commercial SOS brown paper
Summary of Findings
The salient findings of the study that are gathered from the collected data
are as follows:
1. In terms of weight capacity of the corn husk paper bag, the overall mean was 6
kilograms. The least weight capacity measured was 5 kilograms on the first trial.
On the other hand, the greatest weight capacity measured was 7.5 kilograms on
2. In terms of the weight capacity of the commercial SOS brown paper bag, the
overall mean was 3 kilograms. The least weight capacity measured was 3
kilograms on the third trial and the greatest weight capacity measured was 4
3. In terms of the difference between the weight capacities of the corn husk paper
bag and the commercial SOS brown paper bag, at 0.05 confidence level, the
calculated p-value is 0.038 which is significantly higher than the confidence level.
The computed t-value which is 3.062 is greater than the tabulated t-value which is
|+/-2.776|.
Conclusions
Based on the findings of the study, the following conclusions are drawn:
1. The durability of the corn husk paper bag in terms of its weight capacity can carry
2. The durability of the commercial SOS brown paper bag in terms of its weight
kilograms.
3. There is a significant difference between the weight capacity of the corn husk
paper bag and the commercial SOS brown paper bag. This means that the corn
husk paper bag has a larger weight capacity than the commercial SOS brown bag.
Recommendations
Based on the findings and the conclusions, the researchers suggest the
following:
husk paper bag and the commercial SOS brown paper bag should have the
same thickness. On the other hand, tear strength must also be measured
in both variables.
39
3. For future researchers, it is necessary to maintain consistency during the
of the sample.
bag in order to produce more information in this area. Such studies may
change the data collection methods employed in the present study. Also,
further research might compare the outcome of the variable used in making
40
References
Arado, J. P. (2018, January 5). White, yellow corn Q3 production in Davao Region up.
Retrieved December 18 from SunStar PHILIPPINES:
https://www.sunstar.com.ph/article/412549
Aripin, M. & Zainulabidin, M.(2015). Cogon grass as an alternative fibre for pulp and
paper-based industry: On chemical and surface morphological properties.
Retrieved December 18 from: https://www.researchgate.net/
publication/278021196_Cogon_Grass_As_an_Alternative_Fibre_for_Pulp_and_
Paper-Based_Industry_On_Chemical_and_Surface_Morphological_Properties
Asian Development Bank. (2004). The Garbage Book: Solid Waste Management in Metro
Manila. Manila, Philippines: Asian Development Bank.
Basak, S., Deshmukh, R., Kambli, N., & Samanta, K. (2015). Extraction of natural
cellulosic fibers from cornhusk and its physico-chemical properties. Retrieved
December 15 from: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12221-016-5416-0
Caufield, D.F. & Gunderson D.E. (2000). Paper testing and strength characteristics.
Retrieved December 18 from: https://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/documnts/pdf1988/
caulf88b.pdf
Ekhuemelo, D.O., & Tor, K. (2013). Assessment of fibre characteristics and suitability of
maize husk and stalk for pulp and paper production. Retrieved December 18 from
https://www.ajol.info/index.php/jrfwe/article/download/91384/80880
Eurojute. (2018). Product groups/Paper bags. Retrieved from Eurojute - Association for
Textile Packaging Materials and Other Industrial Textiles: https://www.
eurojute.org/product-groups/paper-bags
41
Fortuna, M. E., Harja, M., Bucur, D., & Cimpeanu, S. M. (2013). Obtaining and utilizing
cellulose fibers with in-situ loading as an additive for printing paper. Materials,
6(10), 4532-4544. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ma6104532
Fiscal, R. & Dandan, K. B. (2016). Development and evaluation of paper from corn husks
(Zea mays L.) and snake plant fibers (Sansevieria zeylanica). International Journal
of Science and Research (IJSR), 5(8), 867-870. doi:10.21275/v5i8.3081601
Future Market Insights. (2017). Paper bags market: Building and construction end use
segment to grow at the fastest rate during the assessment period: Global industry
analysis (2012 - 2016) and opportunity assessment (2017 - 2027). Retrieved
December 15 from https://www.futuremarketinsights.com/reports/paper-bags-
market
Hughes, T. C. (2016, January 21). Do you know the difference between SWL / WLL /
MRC and when they should be used? Retrieved from LinkedIn:
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/do-you-know-difference-between-swl-wll-mrc-
when-used-hughes-cpeng
Jorge, G., Jesus, F., & Helena P. (2001). Cynara cardunculus L. — a new fibre crop for
pulp and paper production. Industrial Crops and Products 13:1–10
Kang, T., & Paulapuro, H. (2006). Effect of external fibrillation on paper strength. Pulp &
Paper Canada, 107(7), 51-54. Retrieved December 19 from https://search.proq
uest.com/docview/232817112?accountid=173015
Kirci, H. (2006). Pulping Industry. KTU Faculty of Forest Press, No: 86,Trabzon Majid
Kiaei, Ahmad Samariha and Jafar Ebrahimpour Kasmani 2011) Characterization
of biometry and the chemical and morphological properties of fibers from
bagasse, corn, sunflower, rice and rapeseed residues in Iran. African Journal of
Agricultural Research Vol. 6(16), pp. 3762-3767.
Koppelar, R.W. (2009). Properties of paper: The mechanical behavior of single paper
fibers. Retrieved December 19 from: http://www.mate.tue.nl/mate/pdfs/10509.pdf
Map of Ateneo De Davao University Jacinto St., Davao City. (2018, December 10).
Retrieved December 18 from Google Maps:
42
https://www.google.com/maps/place/Ateneo+de+Davao+University/@7.072314,
125.6107977,17z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m5!3m4!1s0x32f9115554d3f877:0xd50ec690
ed6db9b4!8m2!3d7.072314!4d125.6129864
Map of Davao City. (2018, December 10). Retrieved December 18 from Google Maps:
https://www.google.com/maps/place/Davao+City,+Davao+del+Sur/@7.8378497,
123.8530241,7z/data=!4m5!3m4!1s0x32f96d9f519e327f:0xb53a24589f79c573!8
m2!3d7.190708!4d125.455341
Map of Mindanao. (2018, December 10). Retrieved December 18 from Google Maps:
https://www.google.com/maps/place/Mindanao/@11.9033292,122.8621782,5z/d
ata=!4m5!3m4!1s0x3255e40590d9b7c3:0xc7b9f264ecd3cfb4!8m2!3d8.49613!4d
123.3034062
Map of Philippines. (2018, December 10). Retrieved December 18 from Google Maps:
https://www.google.com/maps/place/Philippines/@12.1313959,119.6767767,6z/
data=!4m5!3m4!1s0x324053215f87de63:0x784790ef7a29da57!8m2!3d12.87972
1!4d121.774017
Mitchell, O. (2015). Experimental research design. John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Paper Bag Facts . (2018). (American Forest & Paper Association) Retrieved December
15 from Renewable Bag Council : https://www.renewablebag.org/paper-bag-facts
Shen, B. (2002). Variation in the local structure and properties of paper. National Library
of Canada. Retrieved December 15 from: https://tspace.library.
utoronto.ca/bitstream/1807/15585/1/MQ58719.pdf
43
So. (2016). Dead trees: How much are we consuming?. Retrieved November 29 from
https://www.manilatimes.net/dead-trees-how-much-are-we-consuming/246383/
Statista. (2018). Corn production in the Philippines from 2011 to 2016 (in 1,000 metric
tons). Retrieved November 29 fromhttps://www.statista.com/statistics/751372/
philippines-corn-production/
Storm the Castle. (2018). How to make paper from corn. Retrieved December 15 from
http://www.stormthecastle.com/paper-making/how-to-make-paper-from-corn.htm
Taipale, T., Osterberg, M., Nykanen, A., Ruokolainen, J., & Laine, J. (2010, October).
Effect of microfibrillated cellulose and fines on the drainage of kraft pulp
suspension and paper strength. Cellulose , 17(5), 1005-1020.
doi:https://doi.org/10.1007/s10570-010-9431-9
Taiwo, K., Fagbemigun, Fagbemi, O. D., Otitoju, O., Mgbachiuzor, E., & Igwe, C. C.
(2014, April). Pulp and paper-making potential of corn husk. International Journal
of AgriScience, 4(4), 209-213. Retrieved December 15 from
https://s3.amazonaws.com/academia.edu.documents/49498406/PaperIII.pdf?A
WSAccessKeyId=AKIAIWOWYYGZ2Y53UL3A&Expires=1543641283&Signature
=IJunsz6PDieSKodSs%2BII8WZFvOI%3D&response-content-
disposition=inline%3B%20filename%3DPulp_and_paper-making_potential_of_
44
APPENDIX
45
DOCUMENTATION
Pre-experimentation
(NaCo2)
46
During Experimentation
Figure 3. Corn husks after thorough rinsing. Figure 4. Boiling of four (4) cups
Figure 5. Addition of one (1) Figure 6. Cutting the corn husk into
47
Figure 7. Draining and rinsing of boiled
cornhusk.
cornhusk.
48
Figure 9. Spreading of blended Figure 10. Corn husk paper in
appropriate size.
49
Post-experimentation
test.
Figure 12. Placing of weights into Figure 13. Weight capacity test of
bag.
50
Figure 14. Placing weights inside Figure 15. Weight capacity test of
51
CURRICULUM VITAE
Personal Data
Name : Johanna Gabrielle Tumbali Afable
Nickname : Hanna
Birthdate : July 10, 2000
Place of Birth : Davao City, Philippines
Address : Blk. 58, Lot 9, Gulfview Homes, Bago Aplaya, Davao City
Religious Affiliation : Roman Catholic
Parents’ Name : Nestor Sangalang Afable
: Marybeth Tumbali Afable
Siblings
Name Occupation: Student
1. John Gabrielle Tumbali Afable
Educational Background
Name of School Year
Graduated
Pre-School: Precious International School of Davao 2007
52
CURRICULUM VITAE
Personal Data
Nickname : Val
Siblings
Name Occupation
Educational Background
53
CURRICULUM VITAE
Personal Data
Nickname : Siensien
Siblings
Educational Background
54
CURRICULUM VITAE
Personal Data
Nickname : Isiah
Siblings
Educational Background
55
CURRICULUM VITAE
Personal Data
Name : Angellie Mae B. Placido
Nickname : Anj
Birthdate : 11/29/00
Place of Birth : Baguio City
Address : Suraya Homes, Cabantian, Davao City
Religious Affiliation : Roman Catholic
Parents’ Name : Anthony V. Placido
: Elaine B. Placido
Siblings
Name Occupation
1. N/A
Educational Background
Grade School: San Lorenzo Ruiz Center of Studies and School 2013
56
CURRICULUM VITAE
Personal Data
Name : Cherry Mae L. Sison
Nickname : Cherry
Birthdate : April 21, 2000
Place of Birth : Davao City
Address : 3 Malasugue St., New Salmonan, Agdao, Davao City
Religious Affiliation : Roman Catholic
Parents’ Name : Arcilie L. Sison
: Samuel B. Sison
Siblings
Name Occupation
1. Nicole L. Sison Junior High School Student
Educational Background
Name of School Year Graduated
Elementary : Holy Cross of Davao College 2013
Secondary : Holy Cross of Davao College
57
CURRICULUM VITAE
Personal Data
Nickname : Kit
Siblings
Educational Background
58