Professional Documents
Culture Documents
In Partial Fulfilment
of the Requirements in the Course
Practical Research 2
by
Christine Mae Besagas Espinosa
October 2021
i
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
INTRODUCTION
1
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
after year. The pulp and paper sector, which is currently more
profitable than ever, generates around P30 billion in domestic sales
value each year which saves the government $700 million in foreign
cash by avoiding the importation of paper and board. The country's
recent excellent economic performance has driven the demand for
packaging materials including corrugating container boards and carton
boards, which can be related to the rising export sales of electronics,
fresh fruits, clothing, handicrafts, and furniture. The need for packaging
processed foods, appliances, tissue, publishing, and printing paper, as
well as other consumer items, are driving strong growth in the
domestic market. The improved living standards, increased disposable
income, refined welfare, tourism, and manufacturing activity in the
Philippines are the sources of this demand (DTI, 2021).
2
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
3
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
The Philippines produces 14.69 billion husks each year, with over
5 billion of them being used as firewood during copra drying. (PCA,
2015). The residual husks are used as farm waste, and enormous
quantities are dumped in the field, either with or without the shell. The
Philippines' Department of Agriculture (DA) estimates that 9 billion
husks are discarded or burned in the field (DA, 2014). This vast volume
of husks could be a valuable natural resource (Greer, 2008). Fibers are
extracted from the coconut husk and used to make geotextile and a
variety of manufactured items such as ropes, bags, mats, rugs,
carpets, and a variety of other products (Kavitha, 2016). Furthermore,
organic plant media fertilizer is made from coconut peat (the non-
fibrous component of the husk). (Nazari et al., 2011). Despite all of the
current husk applications stated, the Philippines' estimated husk
consumption is 334 tons per day (about 120,000 tons per year), which
is only a tiny proportion of overall husk production (PCA, 2015).
There are two types of coir fibers. The difference between ripe
and immature coconut husks is one of the distinctions. Brown coir is
4
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
The argument over logging and the use of non-tree fiber remain
contentious. Non-wood plants and agricultural residues sparked
increased attention in the face of a shortage of conventional pulp
suppliers (Ververis et al., 2003). Furthermore, environmental concerns
have raised the demand for non-wood pulp as a low-cost papermaking
raw material (Mahale and Goswami-Giri, 2015). This research will look
at the viability of using banana peels (fibers) and coconut husks, which
are non-wood plants as alternative raw materials for paper production.
It will focus on the long-term viability of banana peels (fiber) and
coconut husks as an environmentally beneficial raw material for
creating paper, in order to mitigate the negative and dangerous effects
of the use and illegal use of wood in the production of paper. Aside
from that, we considered its yielding ability, pulping quality, and
adaptation to the prevailing climatic conditions and possibilities of
5
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
6
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
found out that several factors affect the durability and the quality of
the paper.
Figure 1
Environmental-friendly Papers
7
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
Figure 2
SET A SET B
Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel Coconut (Cocos Nucifera) Husk
Analysis on the
Properties
Eventual
Outcome
8
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
1. How does the quality of paper made from the banana peel in terms
of:
Surface Texture
Visibility in Writing
Grammage
Folding Endurance
Biodegradability
Weight
Water absorption
Flammability
2. How does the quality of paper made from coconut husk in terms of:
Surface Texture
Visibility in Writing
9
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
Grammage
Folding Endurance
Biodegradability
Weight
Water absorption
Flammability
Set A
SET A1
• ½ tbsp (7.4 ml) of Banana peel
SET A2
• 1 tbsp(15ml) of Banana peel
Set B
SET B1
• ½ tbsp (7.4 ml) of Coconut husk
SET B2
• 1 tbsp (15ml) of Coconut husk
Null Hypothesis
10
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
Hypothesis Testing
conducted through burying the paper in the natural soil or compost soil
and observing the changes on the appearance of the eco-friendly
paper throughout the course of various days.
Definitions of Terms
These are the terms that will provide clear interpretation and
insight on the study. For a better understanding, the following terms
are conceptually and operationally defined:
Coir - the fibrous material or layer that lies between a coconut's hard
interior shell and its outer coat.
12
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
Raw Materials - refers to the use of banana peel and coconut husk as
a component for paper making.
Visibility Test- measures how vibrant and visible the images and
words appear when written on the paper.
13
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
The researchers believe that this experiment will not only yield a
product that will be valuable to the learners, but also to the
educators. The students will be equipped with the knowledge and
strategy of creating an alternative paper that they can use for
educational purposes.
14
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
15
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
have come up with the idea of using alternative raw materials such as
banana peels and coconut husks for making paper since these two are
also considered as a waste.
The study is only limited to the use of banana peel and coconut
husk in making the products. There are numerous variables that are
needed in considering the quality of a paper, but only Surface Texture,
Visibility in Writing, Grammage, Folding Endurance, Biodegradability,
Weight, Water absorption, and Flammability are tested in this study.
The evaluation on the quality of the product will be known based on
the process and result of the test conducted.
16
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
Sampling Techniques
17
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
Research Instrument
18
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
unwanted particles away from the other materials. The oven was
needed for controlling the temperature in drying or testing the papers.
Furthermore, mould and deckle are one of the primary materials
needed in executing the experiment. It is a frame-covered tool used to
form and create straight edges on the paper sheet. Lastly, the visibility
of the writing will be observed if the writing is legible, or not. On the
other side of the coin, the surface texture of the paper will be analyzed
and evaluated based on categories: too rough, smooth. The following
figure shows the tables that will be used to evaluate the visibility of the
writing and the surface texture. These will also serve as tools for
accumulating data.
Surface Texture
Samples Rough Flaky Smooth
Set A1
300 ml of water and ½
tbsp (7.4 ml) of
banana peel
Set A2
300 ml of water and
19
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
1tbsp (15ml) of
banana peel
Set B1
300 ml of water and ½
tbsp (7.4 ml) of
coconut husk
Set B2
300 ml of water and
1tbsp (15ml) of
coconut husk.
Figure 2: Surface Texture
20
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
l. Set A
Set A1
Set A2
ll. Set B
Set B1
Set B2
21
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
The banana peel and coconut husks were obtained at the local
traditional market. Then, these will be washed with clean water before
being shredded to small pieces in a mixing blender. The researchers
construct two (2) set-ups that have been labeled with A and B. Set A
includes Set A1 and Set A2 in which Set A1 contains 300 ml of water
and ½ tbsp (7.4 ml) of banana peel while Set A2 contains 300 ml of
water and 1 tbsp (15ml) of banana peel.
On the other side of the coin, Set B consists of Set B1 and Set B2.
B1 contains 300 ml of water and ½ tbsp (7.4 ml) of coconut husk.
However, Set B2 contains 300 ml of water and 1 tbsp (15ml) of coconut
husk.
22
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
Data Analysis
23
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
Surface Texture
Samples Rough Flaky Smooth
Set A1
300 ml of water and ½
tbsp (7.4 ml) of
banana peel
Set A2
300 ml of water and
1tbsp (15ml) of
banana peel
Set B1
300 ml of water and ½
tbsp (7.4 ml) of
coconut husk
Set B2
300 ml of water and
1tbsp (15ml) of
coconut husk.
Figure 2: Surface Texture
24
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
Grammage
Formula:
where:
Ns = number of sheets
Folding Endurance
Formula:
F = log10d
Where:
F= Folding endurance
d= number of folds
Weight
25
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
Samples Weight
Set A1
300 ml of water and ½
tbsp (7.4 ml) of
banana peel
Set A2
300 ml of water and
1tbsp (15ml) of
banana peel
Set B1
300 ml of water and ½
tbsp (7.4 ml) of
coconut husk
Set B2
300 ml of water and
1tbsp (15ml) of
coconut husk.
Figure 3: weight
Biodegradability Test
Water Absorption
26
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
papers were put into a tray immersed in distilled water for 24 hours.
Within 5 days interval, each sample was weighted, and data was
recorded. The following equation was used to calculate water
absorption:
Formula:
Where:
Flammability Test
In order to examine the flammability of the product, each sample
was cut with the same dimension of 100mm x 100 mm or 10 cm x 10
cm. Then, they were burnt, and the researchers recorded the burning
time.
Testing Parameters
Folding Water
Samples Grammag Biodegradabil Weig Flammabil
Enduran Absorpti
e ity ht ity
ce on
Set A1
300 ml of
water and
½ tbsp
(7.4 ml) of
banana
peel
Set A2
300 ml of
27
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
water and
1tbsp
(15ml) of
banana
peel
Set B1
300 ml of
water and
½ tbsp
(7.4 ml) of
coconut
husk
Set B2
300 ml of
water and
1tbsp
(15ml) of
coconut
husk.
Figure 4: Testing Parameters
The result from the test experiments will serve as the support of
the researchers from the product they made to find out if the amount
of the materials play a vital role in formulating an effective product. As
specified in the process of the experiment, the researchers argue that
in order to establish precise outcomes, it is significant to consider the
proportion of the various substances and materials in order to arrive at
the expected outcome.
Ethical Considerations
The researchers must foresee and address ethical difficulties and
dilemmas that may occur and arise during their studies while
conceptualizing the proposal writing process. (Hesse-Bieber & Leavey,
28
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
30
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
paper sheet from the set A1 and set A2 may serve their purpose as a
writing material in terms of the visibility of the writing on it.
1.2 Surface Texture
Surface
Texture
Samples Grammage
Set A1
300 ml of water and ½ tbsp 80 g/m2
or
7.4 ml of banana peel
Set A2
300 ml of water and 1tbsp or 106.67 g/m2
31
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
15 ml of banana peel
Figure 8: Grammage of the paper made from banana peel
Set A1
= (30 000)
375
= 80 g/m2
Set A2
= (40 000)
375
= 106.67 g/m2
Figure 8 shows the grammage of the paper produced from
banana (Musa Acuminata) peel. As stated on the table, Set A1 contains
300 ml of water and ½ tbsp or 7.4ml of banana peel. In contrary, Set
A2 is consist of
300 ml of water and 1tbsp o r ( 15ml) of banana peel.
In order to compute the firmness of the paper, the researchers
used the formula of grammage which is:
Grammage (g/m2) = (W x 10 000)
L x Swd x Ns
where: “w” refers to the weight in kilogram (kg), “L” make reference to
the length of the sheet in meter (m),”Swd” represents the width of the
sheet in meter (m) and “Ns” refers to the number of sheets.
which contains 300ml of water and 1 tbsp or 15ml of banana peel has
a grammage of 106.67 g/m2.
Set A1
Set A2
33
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
1.5 Biodegradability
Samples Biodegradability
Set A1
300 ml of water and ½ tbsp 5 days
or
7.4 ml of banana peel
Set A2
300 ml of water and 1tbsp o 4 days
r
15 ml of banana peel
Figure 10: Biodegradability of the paper made from banana peel
The diagram presented above shows how long does it take for a
specific type of paper to decompose in a natural soil. The researchers
observed the changes in the appearance of the paper over a period of
several days.
As stated in the figure 10, the paper produced from Set A1 which
contains 300 ml of water and ½ tbsp or 7.4 ml of banana peel is able to
be totally decomposed within five (5) days of being buried in
natural soil. On the flip side, the paper produced from the Set A2
which has 300 ml of water and 1 tbsp or 15 ml of banana peel had
been decomposed for four (4) days. In concordance with the figure
shown above, the paper sheet from the set A1 takes longer to
decompose or degrade than the paper sheet from set A2.
1.6 Weight
34
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
Samples Weight
Set A1
300 ml of water and ½ tbsp 3 grams
or
7.4 ml of banana peel
Set A2
300 ml of water and 1tbsp o 4 grams
r
15 ml of banana peel
Figure 11: Weight of the paper made from banana peel
The data indicated in the figure 11 shows the result in terms of
the weight of the paper sheets created from the set A1 and set A2. The
researchers used a balance scale in order to determine the weight of
the paper sheets.
With 300 ml of water and ½ tbsp or 7.4 ml of banana peel, the
paper sheet from the set A1 has a weight of 3 grams while in the
set A2, the paper sheet has a weight that equals to 4 grams. From
this, As it has been pointed out, the paper sheet produced from the
setA1 is lighter than the paper sheet from set A2.
1.7 Water Absorption
Set A1
X 100
35
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
= (2.6699 grams)
X 100
3 grams
= 88.99666667%
Set A2
= (3.087381 grams)
X 100
4 grams
= 77.184525 %
Samples Flammability
Set A1
300 ml of water and ½ tbsp 0.903089986991
or
7.4 ml of banana peel
36
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
Set A2
300 ml of water and 1tbsp o r 0.778151250383
15 ml of banana peel
Figure 11: Flammability of the paper made from banana peel
37
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
REFERENCES
Agustina, W. E. S. & Susanti, V. H. E. (2018) Natural wrapping paper
from banana (Musa paradisiaca Linn) peel waste with additive
essential oils. Retrieved on October 27, 2021, from
https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1742-
6596/1022/1/012032
free.html&ved=2ahUKEwja9aOT5L_xAhUFL6YKHZnwA4AQFjABegQIH
RAC&usg=AOvVaw0yRw2qQWmmV7SIFLBqsFDo
38
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
https://industry.gov.ph/industry/paper/.
39
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
https://content.instructables.com/ORIG/FIZ/94CL/IBKMKPF2/FIZ94CLI
BKMKPF2.pdf
Haile A., Gebino G., Tesfaye T., Mengie W., Ayele M., Abuhay A., and
Yilie D. (2021). Utilization of non-wood biomass for pulp
manufacturing in paper industry: case of Ethiopia. Retrieved on
October 26, 2021, from
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/350133073_Utilization_of
nonwood_biomass_for_pulp_manufacturing_in_paper_industry_cas
e_of_Ethiopia.
40
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
https://ir.uitm.edu.my/id/eprint/15443
cd=&ved=2ahUKEwiwgPHmoejzAhXYCt4KHd4WC44QFnoECAIQAw
&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.impactjournals.us%2Findex.php
%2Fdownl oad%2Farchives%2F2-78-1426329522-4.%2520Manage-
%2520Production%2520process%2520%2520Kavitha.
%2520M.pdf&us g=AOvVaw1Ns4Sp030geEjfkDxf6UiL.
Kumar A., Gautam A., Dutt D., Yadav M., Sehrawat N., and Kumar P.
(2017). Applications Of Microbial Technology in The Pulp And
Paper Industry. Retrieved on October 26, 2021, from
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Amit-Kumar-
315/publication/317741039_Applications_of_microbial_technology_
_pulp_and_paper_industry/links/5a2bf3c2aca2728e05e07197/Appli
cations-of-microbial-technology-in-pulp-and-paper-industry.pdf.
41
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
Kumar A., Singh B. P., Jain R. K. and Sharma. (2013). Banana Fibre
(Musa sapientum): “A Suitable Raw Material for Handmade Paper
Industry via Enzymatic Refining. International Journal of Engineering
Research & Technology (IJERT) [online]. Volume 2. Retrieved on
October 26, 2021, from https://www.ijert.org/research/banana-
fibre-musa-sapientum-a-suitable-raw-material-for-handmade-
paper-industry-via-enzymatic-refining-IJERTV2IS100417.pdf.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/281410401_Chemical_Sc
ience_Review_and_Letters_Environmental_Friendly_Approach_in_Pa
per_Making_using_Natural_Organic_Waste.
Main, N. M., et al. (2014) Suitability of Coir Fibers as Pulp and Paper.
Science Direct. Retrieved on October 24, 2021, from
42
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2210784314000
448
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/283828530_Pulp_and_Pa
per_Evaluation_of_Solid_Wastes_from_Agricultural_Produce
https://helda.helsinki.fi/bitstream/handle/10138/20756/nonwoodp.pdf?.
..1.
43
Feasibility Study of Banana (Musa Acuminata) Peel and Coconut (Cocos
Nucifera) Husk as an Alternative Raw Material for Paper
https://pca.gov.ph/.
Saad, M. J., & Ibrahim, R. (2014). Effect of bleaching on coir fiber pulp
and paper properties. Retrieved on October 24, 2021, from
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/270886139_Effect_of_ble
aching_on_coir_fibre_pulp_and_paper_properties_Kesan_peluntura
n_terhadap_sifat-sifat_pulpa_dan_kertas_sabut_kelapa
Seminio, C. J., (2021). Feasibility Study of Coconut Husk and Corn Husk
as Alternative Paper. Scribd. Retrieved on October 24, 2021, from
https://www.scribd.com/document/422713612/feasibility-study-
of- coconut- husk-and-corn-husk-as-alternative-paper
Ververis C., Georghiou K., Christodoulakis N., Santas P. and Santas R.,
2003. Fiber dimensions, lignin and cellulose content of various
plant materials and their suitability for paper production. Industrial
Crops and Products [online]. Retrieved on October 26, 2021, from
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S092666900
3001171.
APPENDICES
44