You are on page 1of 8

This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal.

Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON SUSTAINABLE ENERGY 1

A Three-Phase Grid Tied SPV System With Adaptive


DC Link Voltage for CPI Voltage Variations
Chinmay Jain, Member, IEEE, and Bhim Singh, Fellow, IEEE

Abstract—This paper deals with a three-phase two-stage grid case the grid is present. The grid acts as an energy buffer, and
tied SPV (solar photo-voltaic) system. The first stage is a boost all the generated power can be fed into the grid. Several grid
converter, which serves the purpose of MPPT (maximum power interfaced SPV systems are proposed in past addressing various
point tracking) and feeding the extracted solar energy to the DC
link of the PV inverter, whereas the second stage is a two-level issues related to islanding, intermittency, modeling etc [7]–[9].
VSC (voltage source converter) serving as PV inverter which feeds With growing power system, the attention is moving from
power from a boost converter into the grid. The proposed sys- centralized generation and radial distribution to distributed
tem uses an adaptive DC link voltage which is made adaptive by generation. The distributed generation can bring in several
adjusting reference DC link voltage according to CPI (common advantages such as reduction in losses, better utilization of dis-
point of interconnection) voltage. The adaptive DC link voltage
control helps in the reduction of switching power losses. A feed for- tribution resources, load profile flattering etc [10]–[12]. The
ward term for solar contribution is used to improve the dynamic SPV systems provide a good choice for distributed generation
response. The system is tested considering realistic grid voltage system considering small scale generation from rooftop solar,
variations for under voltage and over voltage. The performance modularity of power converter and static energy conversion
improvement is verified experimentally. The proposed system is process.
advantageous not only in cases of frequent and sustained under
voltage (as in the cases of far radial ends of Indian grid) but also The initial investment in SPV systems is high because of
in case of normal voltages at CPI. The THD (total harmonics dis- high cost of solar panels [13]. Therefore, considering the ini-
tortion) of grid current has been found well under the limit of an tial investments for any installed plant, the aim is to extract
IEEE-519 standard. maximum energy output from the given capacity.
Index Terms—Adaptive DC link, MPPT, overvoltage, solar PV, To accomplish the objective of extraction of maximum
two-stage, three phase, under voltage. energy from an installed PV array several techniques are pro-
posed in the literature [14]–[18]. A review of MPPT (Maximum
I. I NTRODUCTION Power Point Tracking) techniques is shown in [14]. An incre-
mental conductance (InC) based MPPT technique is shown in
T HE electrical energy has a vital role in development of
human race in the last century. The diminishing conven-
tional primary sources for electricity production have posed an
[15]. An ANN based MPPT algorithm is shown in [16]. The
application of sliding mode controller to MPPT algorithm is
energy scarcity condition in front of the world. The renewable shown in [17]. A combination of fractional open circuit volt-
energy sources such as solar, wind, tidal etc are few of such age and fuzzy based MPPT technique is shown in [18] wherein
options which solve the problem of energy scarcity. The cost a constant offset is added at the output of fuzzy controller to
effectiveness of any technology is prime factor for its commer- improve the MPPT performance. The incremental conductance
cial success. The SPV (Solar Photovoltaic) systems have been based MPPT is fast, accurate and easy to implement. In this
proposed long back but the costs of solar panels have hindered paper, a composite InC based MPPT method is used. The com-
the technology for long time, however the SPV systems are posite InC method is a combination of fractional Voc and InC
reaching grid parity [1], [2]. based method. The proposed MPPT technique limits the area of
The solar energy based systems can be classified into stan- search for MPP point hence improves the MPPT performance.
dalone and grid interfaced systems. The energy storage (con- The tripping of the plant causes generation loss in case of
ventionally batteries) management is the key component of grid tied PV generation system. In general, grid tied VSCs
standalone system. Various problems related to battery energy have under voltage and overvoltage protection. The nominal
storage standalone solar energy conversion systems are dis- range of set point for under voltage and over voltage is around
cussed in [3]–[6]. 0.9 pu and 1.1 pu [19]. This range is very narrow because
Considering the problems associated with energy storage of reasons such as converter may lose control, increase in
systems, the grid interfaced systems are more preferable, in converter rating, and converter losses at low voltage etc. In
case of weak distribution system, a wide voltage variation is
Manuscript received February 04, 2015; revised June 24, 2015; accepted
August 22, 2015. This work was supported by the Department of Science and
observed. During peak loading condition, a sustained voltage
Technology (DST), Government of India, under Grant RP02583. Paper no. dip or under voltage is observed commonly. The practical range
TSTE-00078-2015. of voltage variation is about ±15% of the nominal voltage.
The authors are with the Indian Institute of Technology Delhi, New Delhi Normally in such wide variation of distribution system the
110016, India (e-mail: chinmay31jain@gmail.com; bsingh@ee.iitd.ac.in).
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available online
shunt connected converter trips frequently. However, in case
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org. of tripping of converter the PV generation is lost even when
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TSTE.2015.2496297 PV power is available. Therefore, minimizing converter trips
1949-3029 © 2015 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.

2 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON SUSTAINABLE ENERGY

indirectly increases energy yield from the installed plant. The


proposed system is capable of working with wide range of
voltage variation hence avoids the generation loss.
The use of two stage SPV generation system has been
proposed by several researchers [20]–[23]. Conventionally a
DC-DC converter is used as first stage which serves the purpose
of MPPT. The duty ratio of DC-DC converter is so adjusted that
PV array operates at MPP point. The second stage is a grid tied
VSC (Voltage Source Converter) which feeds the power into
the distribution system. A single phase two stage grid tied PV
generation system with constant DC link voltage is shown in
[20]. Moreover, the three phase grid tied PV generation system
Fig. 1. System configuration.
with constant DC link voltage control is also shown in [21],
[22]. The concept of loss reduction by adaptive DC link voltage
for VSC in hybrid filters is shown in [23], [24] wherein, the DC shown performance for such wide range of CPI voltage vari-
link voltage is adjusted according to reactive power requirement ations (350 V to 480 V for nominal of 415 V). The operation of
of filter. However, in the proposed system the DC link voltage the system for a wide range of CPI voltage variation increases
of VSC is made adaptive with respect to CPI voltage variation. the rating of the VSC and further the cost. However, small
Moreover, the circuit topologies in both the systems are differ- increment in the cost of VSC can be justified on account of
ent. Therefore, the work presented in [23], [24] is very different large initial investment on PV array. The THD of grid current
from the proposed work. and voltages has been found well under IEEE-519 standard
For proper control of VSC currents, the DC link voltage ref- (less than 5%) under all operating conditions [26]. Moreover,
erence is set more than peak of three phase line voltages. The it should be noted that none of the ratings of the power devices
limitation for current control in single-phase grid connected are compromised in the proposed system as compared to con-
converter is shown in [25]. Considering the variation of CPI ventional system, as in both the cases the ratings are decided
(Common Point of Interconnection) voltage, the reference DC based on worst case scenario. Therefore, the system with pro-
link voltage is kept above the maximum allowable CPI voltage. posed control approach yields more energy output with the
Therefore in case of fixed DC link voltage control for VSC, the same hardware resources.
system always operates at a DC link voltage corresponding to
worst case condition. II. S YSTEM C ONFIGURATION
In this paper, a simple control scheme is presented for grid The system configuration for the proposed system is shown
interfaced PV system with adaptive DC link voltage structure in Fig. 1. A two stage system is proposed for grid tied SPV
for CPI voltage variation. A boost converter is used as the first system. The first stage is a DC-DC boost converter serving for
stage and a two level VSC is used as the second stage. Unlike MPPT and the second stage is a two-level three phase VSC.
the earlier work with constant DC link voltage for VSC, the The PV array is connected at the input of the boost converter
presented work proposes an adaptive DC link voltage struc- and its input voltage is controlled such that PV array deliv-
ture for the VSC and associated benefits. The adaptive DC link ers the maximum power at its output terminals. The output
voltage mainly reduces switching losses in all power devices of boost converter is connected to DC link of VSC. The DC
and high frequency ohmic losses in the interfacing inductor. link voltage of VSC is dynamically adjusted by grid tied VSC
The maximum benefit of proposed DC link voltage structure on the basis of CPI voltage. The three phase VSC consists of
is found not only during under voltage (common in far radial three IGBT legs. The output terminals of VSC are connected to
ends) but also under nominal grid voltage condition as the DC interfacing inductors and the other end of interfacing inductors
link voltage is kept just necessary for proper current control are connected to CPI. A ripple filter is also connected at CPI
not according to worst case scenario. The claimed benefits of to absorb high frequency switching ripples generated by the
the system are verified experimentally along with comparison VSC. The values of various components and parameters used
with conventional system. Moreover, the feed-forward term for in simulation and experimentation are given in Appendix A.
PV contribution is included to improve the dynamic response.
The PV feed forward term includes the effect of both CPI volt-
age variation and PV power variation. A linearised model of III. C ONTROL A PPROACH
DC link voltage control and effect of PV feed forward compo- The basic control approach for the SPV system is shown in
nent on the same is also analyzed in this paper. In the proposed Fig. 2. The control of the system can be divided into two main
system both the input and output voltages of DC-DC boost con- parts, which are control of the boost converter and control of a
verter are adjusted in real time while keeping the objective of grid tied VSC. The input voltage of a boost converter is adjusted
MPPT intact. The performance of proposed control algorithm according to MPPT algorithm and the output voltage of boost
is satisfactory under insolation change and sudden variation of converter, which is also the DC link voltage of VSC is also
CPI voltage. kept adaptive according to CPI voltage condition. In overall,
The two stage grid interfaced three phase systems are pro- the proposed system is operated such that both the input and
posed by several researchers, however, none of them have output voltages of boost converter are adjusted according to
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.

JAIN AND SINGH: A THREE-PHASE GRID TIED SPV SYSTEM WITH ADAPTIVE DC LINK VOLTAGE 3

ΔIP V −IP V
< , Right of MPP on PP V v/sVP V curve (2c)
ΔVP V VP V
The reference PV array voltage (VP V ref ) is estimated using
(1) and (2). In order to keep the search in a limited region, the
VP V ref is bounded by corresponding upper and lower satura-
tion values (0.7Vocmax to 0.9Vocmax ). The output of that satura-
tion block is designated as new PV array voltage (VP V ref n ),
which is then used for estimation of reference duty ration.
The reference PV voltage (VP V ref n ) and sensed DC link
voltage (VDC ) are then used to estimate the duty ratio for the
boost converter. The governing equation for estimating duty
ratio is as,
VP V ref n (k)
Dref (k) = 1 − (3)
Fig. 2. Block diagram for control approach. VDC (k)
This reference duty ratio is compared with saw-tooth wave-
sensed variables of the circuit. The boost converter feeds the
form to generate switching logic for the boost converter.
power to the DC link of VSC, which then feeds that power into
the three-phase grid at unity power factor with respect to CPI.
A composite InC based MPPT technique is used to estimate the B. Control Algorithm for VSC
reference PV array voltage and a PLL-less control is proposed
for the control of the VSC. The amplitude of the refrence grid The control approach for VSC is demonstrated in Fig. 2. The
currents is estimated using a PV feedforward (PVFF) term and main objective of the control algorithm for VSC is to regulate
a PI controller DC link voltage error. A set of unit vectors is the DC link voltage to the set reference value and to inject the
estimated from grid voltages to synchronize output currents of extracted power from PV array into the grid at unity power fac-
VSC. The estimated reference grid currents are compared with tor with respect to CPI. In order to control the output currents
sensed grid currents and a hysteresis current controller is used of VSC (or grid currents), the appropriate reference grid cur-
to generate switching logic for VSC. The detailed formulation rents are estimated. At first the amplitude of grid currents is
for control algorithm is presented in the later half of this section. estimated and the estimated amplitude is then multiplied with
in-phase unit vectors (synchronization signals) to keep the grid
currents balanced and sinusoidal.
For control purpose, the CPI line voltages (vsab and vsbc ), DC
A. Maximum Power Point Tracking
link voltage (vDC ) and grid currents (iga and igb ) are sensed.
A composite InC based MPPT algorithm is used. A range The phase voltages are estimated from the line voltages. The
of voltage for peak power is known with the knowledge from in-phase unit vectors are estimated from the estimated phase
fractional Voc MPPT, which is 0.7Vocmax to 0.9Vocmax , where voltages. For estimation of unit vectors (za , zb , zc ), the phase
Voc is open circuit voltage and Vocmax is maximum open cir- voltages are divided by amplitude of three phase voltages (Vz ).
cuit voltage. The voltage for peak power is always searched in The amplitude of CPI voltage is estimated as,
this range for fast search of Vmpp . The InC algorithm works in 
2 + v2 + v2 )
2(vsa
order to minimize the difference between the incremental con- sb sc
Vz = (4)
ductance and the conductance offered by the PV array. At first, 3
the reference PV array voltage is estimated based on the InC
The unit vectors for all three phases are estimated as,
principle then that reference voltage is used to estimate the duty
ratio of the boost converter. For calculation of an incremental vsa vsb vsc
za = , zb = , zc = (5)
conductance ΔIP V and ΔVP V are estimated as, Vz Vz Vz
For proper control of VSC output current, the DC link volt-
ΔIP V = IP V (k) − IP V (k − 1) (1a) age of VSC should be greater than amplitude of line voltage.
ΔVP V = VP V (k) − VP V (k − 1) (1b) Moreover, in order to adaptively adjust the DC link voltage with
respect to CPI voltage variation, the reference DC link volt-
where IPV (k) and VPV (k) are the instantaneous sampled current age is adaptively adjusted with amplitude of CPI voltage. The
and voltage of the solar array. reference DC link voltage is estimated as,
The governing equations for InC based MPPT algorithm √
is as, VDCref = µ 3VZ , where µ> 1 (6)
ΔIP V −IP V For proper current control the DC link voltage must be higher
= , at M P P (2a)
ΔVP V VP V than the amplitude of CPI line voltage. Therefore, reference DC
ΔIP V −IP V link voltage is kept around 10% higher than the peak of CPI
> , Left of MPP onPP V v/s VP V curve (2b)
ΔVP V VP V line voltage, considering the drop across switches, interfacing
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.

4 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON SUSTAINABLE ENERGY

Fig. 3. Simulated performance for, (a) change in solar insolation without feedforward for PV contribution, (b) change in solar insolation with feedforward for PV
contribution, (c) normal to under voltage (415 V to 350 V), (d) CPI voltage variation from normal to over voltage (415 V to 480 V).

inductor, resistance of interfacing inductor and proper current grid currents. The reference and sensed grid currents are then
control under DC link voltage dynamics. Hence, the selected given to current controller. The output of current controller is
value of µ in the proposed work is 1.1. the switching pulses to the VSC.
A PI controller is used to maintain the DC link voltage to
reference DC link voltage. The sensed DC link voltage is passed
through a low pass filter to suppress the switching noise. The IV. S IMULATION R ESULTS
output of low pass filter is designated as VDC . The difference Fig. 3 shows the simulation results for different operating
between VDCref and VDC is the input to the PI controller. condition. The simulation results for change in insolation level
The amplitude of grid currents consists of two main parts and voltage variation at CPI are shown. The simulations are car-
which are the loss component and the contribution from the ried out in MATLAB simulink and sim power system tool box.
PV array. The output of PI controller can considered as loss The SPV array of 25 kW is considered for simulation study.
component in steady state condition. The loss component is Other system parameters are given in Appendix.
estimated as,
Iloss (k) = Iloss (k−1) + Kp {ve (k) −ve (k−1)} + Ki ve (k) A. Performance Under Sudden Change in Solar Insolation
(7)
Figs. 3(a)–(b) show performance of proposed system under
A PV feed forward (PVFF) term for PV array contribution to sudden change in insolation from 1000 W/m2 to 500 W/m2
grid current is also estimated to provide fast dynamic response with and without feed forward compensation respectively.
for changes in solar insolation and grid voltages. The PV feed- Before time t = 0.3 s, the system is working under steady state
forward term is estimated as, condition with SPV insolation at 1000 W/m2 . The grid currents
are balanced and sinusoidal. At time t = 0.3 s, the insolation is
IP V g = (2PP V )/ (3VZ ) (8)
decreased from 1000 W/m2 to 500 W/m2 . The PV array cur-
It can be observed from the above equation that in case of rent decreases due to decrease in insolation and so is the PV
insolation variation, the PV power (PPV = VPV ∗ IPV ) changes array power. It can be easily observed that the dynamic response
and the instantaneous effect can be observed on PV contribution for sudden change in insolation level is better for proposed sys-
term. Moreover, the in case of voltage variation at CPI, the grid tem. The DC link voltage for only PI controller based system
currents need to be adjusted to feed same solar power, which shows more deviation and longer time to settle as compared to
eventually is adjusted due to term Vz in the PV contribution proposed system with feed forward compensation based con-
term. trol approach. The system with proposed control approach soon
The grid currents are assumed coming out of CPI terminals reaches the next state and it feeds the reduced power into the
and considering the direction of grid currents, the losses are grid. No appreciable effect is observed on the DC link voltage
drawn from the grid whereas the PVFF is fed into the grid. of VSC.
Therefore, net amplitude of grid current is estimated as,
Irg = Iloss − IP V g (9) B. Performance for Under Voltage Operation
The estimated amplitude of grid current Irg is then multiplied Fig. 3(c) shows the steady state and dynamics performance
with unit vectors of corresponding phases to estimate reference of the system for under voltage operation at CPI. Before time
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.

JAIN AND SINGH: A THREE-PHASE GRID TIED SPV SYSTEM WITH ADAPTIVE DC LINK VOLTAGE 5

Fig. 4. Experimental data recorded by PV array simulator at (a) 1000 W/m2 ,


(b) 500 W/m2 .

t = 0.35 s, the system is operating at CPI voltage of 415 V. The


CPI voltage decreases from 415 to 350 V during 0.35 s to 0.4 s.
The adaptive nature of DC link voltage can be observed. The
DC link voltage also decreases with the decrease in CPI voltage.
The grid currents are maintained balanced and sinusoidal all the
time however, an increase in grid currents is observed to feed
the same PV power at reduced voltage. No appreciable effect is Fig. 5. Steady state performance (vsab with isa , isa harmonics spectrum,
observed on PV array voltage (vpv ), PV array current (ipv ), and vsab harmonics spectrum, power fed into grid respectively) for different CPI
voltage, (a)-(d) at 350 V, (e)-(f) at 415 V, (i)-(l) at 480 V.
PV array power (Ppv ).

C. Performance for Over Voltage Operation


Fig. 3(d) shows the steady state and dynamics performances
of the system for over voltage operation at CPI. Before time
t = 0.35 s, the system is operating at CPI voltage of 415 V.
The CPI voltage increases from 415 to 480 V during 0.35 s
to 0.4 s. The DC link voltage also increases with an increase in
CPI voltage, which shows the adaptive nature of DC link volt-
age. The grid currents are maintained balanced and sinusoidal
all the time however, a decrease in grid currents is observed to
feed the same PV power at the increased voltage. No appre-
ciable effect is observed on PV array voltage (vpv ), PV array
current (ipv ), and PV array power (Ppv ).

V. E XPERIMENTAL R ESULTS
The experimental results are shown in Figs. 4–7. A total
of seven quantities are sensed which are vpv , ipv , vDC , vsab , Fig. 6. Dynamic performance for change in solar insolation level from
vsbc , iga , igb . The Hall-Effect voltage (LV-25) and current sen- 1000 W/m2 to 500 W/m2 and vice versa (a)-(b) decrease in insolation level,
(c)-(d) increase in insolation level.
sors (LA-55p) are used. The sensed signals are conditioned
and given to ADC (Analog to Digital Converter) of controller
processor (dSPACE-1103). The outputs from controller are the experimental results. The experimental parameters are given in
switching logics for all controlled switches. These results are Appendix A.
captured using power analyzer (Fluke 43B) and four chan-
nel digital storage oscilloscope (DSO6010A). Fig. 4 shows
A. Steady State Performance Under Full Voltage Range
readings  recorded by PV array simulator at different
 inso-
lation 1000 W/m2 and 500 W/m2 respectively . The MPPT Fig. 5 shows the experimental results for complete range of
efficiency is found of order of 99.8%. Different other steady voltage variation under steady state condition at insolation level
state and transient performances are demonstrated in the latter of 1000 W/m2 . Figs. 5(a)–(d) show the operation of proposed
half of this section. The steady state results show the magni- system at CPI voltage of 350 V. The CPI voltage (vsab ) and grid
tude of various voltages, currents, powers and power quality current (iga ) are shown in Fig. 5(a). Only one of the grid cur-
indices for full range of voltage. Moreover, the dynamic perfor- rents is shown, as under steady state operation, the magnitude
mances for all salient disturbances (insolation change and CPI of other two currents are equal hence they are not shown here.
voltage variation) are also demonstrated as important part of Moreover, they can be observed in DSO waveforms in Fig. 6.
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.

6 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON SUSTAINABLE ENERGY

and (d) show the performance for an increase in solar insola-


tion level from 500 W/m2 to 1000 W/m2 . Fig. 6(c) shows the
line voltage and three phase grid currents. A uniform increase
in grid current is observed for increasing insolation condition.
The grid currents are maintained balanced and sinusoidal even
under transition period. An increase in PV array current is also
observed during increasing insolation level. The DC link volt-
age is maintained well regulated at set reference value despite
of huge power change in incoming power at DC link of VSC.
Fig. 7 shows the performance of the system for variation
of CPI voltage. During this study, the PV array insolation is
kept constant at 1000 W/m2 . Figs. 7(a)–(b) show the perfor-
mance for CPI voltage changing from nominal to under voltage
(415 V to 350 V). Fig. 7(a) shows that the grid currents are
increased for decreased CPI voltage. The decrease in CPI volt-
age is conformed from decrease in magnitude of vsab as marked
in Fig. 7(a). However, the grid currents are maintained balanced
and sinusoidal throughout. Fig. 7(b) shows the DC link volt-
Fig. 7. Dynamic performance for CPI voltage variation (a)-(b) decrease in age and CPI voltage along with PV array voltage and current.
voltage from 415 V to 350 V, (c)-(d) increase in voltage from 415 V to 480 V. It can be easily observed that DC link voltage also decreases
with decrease in CPI voltage unlike constant DC link voltage
Fig. 5(b) and (c) show the harmonic spectra of grid current (iga ) for all CPI voltage. This demonstrates the adaptive nature of
and CPI voltage (vsab ) respectively. The THD (Total Harmonic DC link voltage. No appreciable effect is observed on PV array
Distortion) of grid current is found around 1.2% (within limit voltage and current. Figs. 7(c)–(d) show the performance for
of an IEEE-519 standard of 5%). Fig. 5(d) shows the power fed CPI voltage changing from nominal to over voltage (415 V to
into the grid. The negative sign of power shows that power is fed 480 V). Fig. 7(c) shows that the grid currents are decreased
into the grid and the DPF of −1 confirms the unity power fac- for increased CPI voltage. However, the grid currents are main-
tor operation with respect to CPI. Similarly Figs. 5(e)–(h) show tained balanced and sinusoidal throughout. The adaptive nature
operation of proposed system at CPI voltage of 415 V. At nom- of DC link voltage with CPI voltage can again be verified from
inal voltage operation, the grid current is comparatively lesser Fig. 7(d).
than under voltage operation, as the lesser current is required to
feed the same PV array power. The THD of grid current and CPI
C. Comparison of Proposed System With Conventional System
voltage is well within limits under nominal voltage operation.
The power fed into the grid remains approximately the same. The two-stage grid tied SPV systems have been proposed by
Similarly Figs. 5(i)–(l) show the operation of proposed system several researchers. Conventionally, the first stage is a DC-DC
at CPI voltage of 480 V. At over voltage operation, the grid converter which serves purpose of MPPT. The output of DC-
current is comparatively lesser than under voltage and nominal DC converter is connected to DC link of VSC. The DC link
voltage operations. The power fed into the grid remains approx- voltage of VSC is kept constant and the reference DC link volt-
imately the same. The THDs of voltage and current are less than age value is decided on the basis of maximum CPI voltage. For
5% under all these operating conditions. proper control of VSC currents, the DC link voltage should
be greater than the peak of maximum allowed grid voltage.
Therefore, the reference DC link voltage is kept around 10%
B. Salient Dynamic Performance higher than the peak of maximum allowed grid voltage, consid-
ering the drop across interfacing inductor, switches and proper
The dynamic performance of proposed system is shown in current control under DC link voltage dynamics. Considering
Figs. 6–7. Fig. 6 shows the performance of the system for a weak AC grid (far radial end) the over and under voltages
changes in solar insolation level. Figs. 6(a)–(b) show the perfor- are quite common. Considering the range of voltage variation
mance of the system for a decrease in solar insolation level from of ±15%, the AC mains voltage may vary between 352 V to
1000 W/m2 to 500 W/m2 . Fig. 6(a) shows line voltage and grid 477 V approximately for a nominal voltage of 415 V. The fixed
currents. The decrease in insolation causes the PV power to DC link voltage for operation under such a voltage range is
decrease, which can be observed from decrease in magnitude estimated as,
of grid currents. The grid currents are maintained balanced and
sinusoidal even under transition period. Fig. 6(b) shows other vDC = 1.414 ∗ Vg max ∗ 1.1 = 1.414 ∗ 477 ∗ 1.1
salient variables such as DC link voltage, PV array voltage = 742.40 V  740 V
and PV array current. The PV array current decreases due to
decrease in insolation level. A mark-able amount of power is The adaptive DC link voltage structure helps in reducing the
changed due to change in solar insolation however, no appre- power loss of the system. The two main parts of power loss
ciable effect is observed on the DC link voltage. Figs. 6(c) which get affected by DC link voltage are the switching losses
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.

JAIN AND SINGH: A THREE-PHASE GRID TIED SPV SYSTEM WITH ADAPTIVE DC LINK VOLTAGE 7

Fig. 8. Switching transient for shunt grid interfaced VSC. Fig. 10. Grid currents for phase a with (a) conventional DC link voltage
structure, (b) proposed DC link voltage structure.

Fig. 9. Basic principle for reduction in ripple current by keeping DC link


voltage near to amplitude of grid voltage.

and the loss in the interfacing inductor due to high frequency


ripple current. The basic principle and its effect on performance
are demonstrated experimentally follows. Fig. 11. A comparision of power fed into grid at different CPI voltage by fixed
and adaptive DC link based system.
Fig. 8 shows basic switching transients and power loss in
switching for any shunt grid interfaced VSC. It can easily be
observed that the switching loss in any shunt grid connected voltage) method keeping the same power from solar array emu-
system depends on DC link voltage of the VSC. In case when lator. Fig. 11 shows the experimental comparisons of system
fixed DC link voltage is selected for VSC, the switching losses with fixed and adaptive DC link voltages. The solar insola-
are higher not only during under voltage (quite common phe- tion is kept at 1000 W/m2 for all these operating conditions.
nomenon in rural grid) but also under nominal grid voltage. The fixed DC link voltage is kept at 740 V. It can be observed
The switching power losses in all 8 power switches (6 for that during under voltage (350 V) the power fed into the grid
VSC and 2 for boost converter) are dependent on DC link volt- by a system with adaptive DC link voltage is approximately
age. Considering the above mentioned condition, an adaptive 6 kW whereas the system using fixed DC link voltage feeds
DC link voltage based control for VSC is proposed to reduce approximately 5.5 kW. Moreover, even under nominal voltage
switching power losses. In the proposed adaptive control, the condition (415 V) the system with adaptive DC link voltage
DC link voltage is kept just sufficient for current control. feeds more power into the grid. The power fed at 480 V is
Another advantage of keeping the adaptive DC link voltage almost equal as the DC link voltage for both the systems are
is the reduction in high frequency ripple current in the inter- almost equal.
facing inductor. Fig. 9 shows the basic principle for reduction
in ripple current by adaptive DC link voltage. The ripple in the
VI. C ONCLUSION
interfacing inductor depends on instantaneous voltage differ-
ence between the line voltage and the DC link voltage. For the A two-stage system has been proposed for three-phase grid
system with fixed DC link voltage based control structure the connected solar PV generation. A composite InC based MPPT
instantaneous voltage difference across the interfacing induc- algorithm is used for control of the boost converter. The per-
tor is higher as compared to proposed DC link voltage control formance of proposed system has been demonstrated for wide
structure. Therefore, high frequency ripple current is higher in range of CPI voltage variation. A simple and novel adaptive
conventional system. Fig. 10 shows the experimental compari- DC link voltage control approach has been proposed for con-
son between the current ripple with fixed and adaptive DC link trol of grid tied VSC. The DC link voltage is made adaptive
voltage structure. It can be easily observed that the high fre- with respect to CPI voltage which helps in reduction of losses
quency ripple content is higher in the system with fixed DC in the system. Moreover, a PV array feed forward term is used
link voltage structure. The high frequency ripple current is also which helps in fast dynamic response. An approximate linear
responsible high frequency ohmic losses. An overall experi- model of DC link voltage control loop has been developed and
mental comparison of losses between the two systems is shown analyzed considering feed forward compensation. The PV array
in Fig. 11. feed forward term is so selected that it is to accommodate for
In order to demonstrate the effectiveness of proposed control change in PV power as well as for CPI voltage variation. A
algorithm, the experiments are carried out for both conven- full voltage and considerable power level prototype has verified
tional (fixed DC link voltage) and proposed (adaptive DC link the proposed concept. The concept of adaptive DC link voltage
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.

8 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON SUSTAINABLE ENERGY

has been proposed for grid tied VSC for PV application how- [14] B. Subudhi and R. Pradhan, “A comparative study on maximum power
ever, the same concept can be extended for all shunt connected point tracking techniques for photovoltaic power systems,” IEEE Trans.
Sustain. Energy, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 89–98, Jan. 2013.
grid interfaced devices such as, STATCOM, D-STATCOM etc. [15] F. Liu, S. Duan, F. Liu, B. Liu, and Y. Kang, “A variable step size INC
The proposed system yields increased energy output using the MPPT method for PV systems,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 55, no. 7,
same hardware resources just by virtue of difference in DC link pp. 2622–2628, Jul. 2008.
[16] M. Farhat, A. Flah, and L. Sbita, “Photovoltaic maximum power point
voltage control structure. The THDs of the grid currents and tracking based on ANN control,” Int. Rev. Model. Simul., vol. 7, no. 3,
voltages are found less than 5% (within IEEE-519 standard). pp. 474–480, 2014.
The simulation and experimental results have confirmed the [17] J. Ghazanfari and M. M. Farsangi, “Maximum power point tracking using
sliding mode control for photovoltaic array,” Iran. J. Elect. Electron.
feasibility of proposed control algorithm. Eng., vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 189–196, 2013.
[18] M. Adly, H. El-Sherif, and M. Ibrahim, “Maximum power point tracker
for a PV cell using a fuzzy agent adapted by the fractional open circuit
voltage technique,” in Proc. IEEE Int. Conf. Fuzzy Syst. (FUZZ’11), 2011,
A PPENDIX pp. 1918–1922.
[19] M. E. Ropp, J. G. Cleary, and B. Enayati, “High penetration and anti-
Parameters for simulation: Three-phase grid voltage islanding analysis of multi-single phase inverters in an apartment com-
415 V, frequency = 50 Hz, supply inductance = 2.42 mH plex,” in Proc. IEEE Conf. Innovative Technol. Efficient Reliab. Electr.
and supply resistance = 0.76 Ω, interfacing inductor = 4 mH, Supply (CITRES’10), 2010, pp. 102–109.
[20] S. Deo, C. Jain, and B. Singh “A PLL-Less scheme for single-phase grid
ripple filter R = 5 Ω, C = 5 µF, Kp = 1, Ki = 21, PV array interfaced load compensating solar PV generation system,” IEEE Trans.
open circuit voltage: 500 V, PV array short circuit current: Ind. Informat., vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 692–699, Jun. 2015.
70 A, PV array peak power: 25 kW, µ = 1.1. [21] B. Singh, D. T. Shahani, and A. K. Verma, “Neural network con-
trolled grid interfaced solar photovoltaic power generation,” IET Power
Experimental Parameters: Three-phase grid voltage 415 V, Electron., vol. 7, no. 3, pp. 614–626, Jul. 2013.
frequency = 50 Hz, interfacing inductor = 6 mH, ripple filter [22] C. Jain and B. Singh “A frequency shifter based simple control for multi-
R = 5 Ω, C = 5 µF, Kp = 1, Ki = 0.1, PV array open circuit functional solar PV grid interfaced system,” in Proc. 37th Nat. Syst. Conf.,
2013, pp. 363–374.
voltage: 500 V, PV array short circuit current: 16 A, PV array [23] C.-S. Lam, W.-H. Choi, M.-C. Wong, and Y.-D. Han, “Adaptive DC-Link
peak power: 6.5 kW, µ = 1.1. voltage-controlled hybrid active power filters for reactive power compen-
sation,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 27, no. 4, pp. 1758–1772, Apr.
2012.
R EFERENCES [24] C.-S. Lam, M.-C. Wong, W.-H. Choi, X.-X. Cui, H.-M. Mei, and
J.-Z. Liu, “Design and performance of an adaptive low-DC-voltage-
[1] M. Pavan and V. Lughi, “Grid parity in the Italian commercial and controlled LC-hybrid active power filter with a neutral inductor in three-
industrial electricity market,” in Proc. Int. Conf. Clean Elect. Power phase four-wire power systems,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 61,
(ICCEP’13), 2013, pp. 332–335. no. 6, pp. 2635–2647, Jun. 2014.
[2] M. Delfanti, V. Olivieri, B. Erkut, and G. A. Turturro, “Reaching PV grid [25] Y.-M. Chen, H.-C. Wu, Y.-C. Chen, K.-Y. Lee, and S.-S. Shyu, “The AC
parity: LCOE analysis for the Italian framework,” in Proc. 22nd Int. Conf. line current regulation strategy for the grid-connected PV system,” IEEE
Exhib. Elect. Distrib. (CIRED’13), 2013, pp. 1–4. Trans. Power Electron., vol. 25, no. 1, pp. 209–218, Jan. 2010.
[3] H. Wang and D. Zhang, “The stand-alone PV generation system with par- [26] IEEE Recommended Practices and Requirement for Harmonic Control
allel battery charger,” in Proc. Int. Conf. Elect. Control Eng. (ICECE’10), on Electric Power System, IEEE Standard 519, 1992.
2010, pp. 4450–4453.
[4] M. Kolhe, “Techno-economic optimum sizing of a stand-alone solar
photovoltaic system,” IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 24, no. 2, Chinmay Jain (M’12) received the B.E. degree
in electrical engineering from Shri G. S. Institute
pp. 511–519, Jun. 2009.
of Technology and Science, Indore, India, and the
[5] D. Debnath and K. Chatterjee, “A two stage solar photovoltaic based
M.E. degree in electrical engineering from Indian
stand alone scheme having battery as energy storage element for rural
deployment,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 62, no. 7, pp. 4148–4157, Institute of Science, Bangalore, India, in 2009 and
2011, respectively. He is currently pursuing the Ph.D.
Jul. 2015.
degree at the Department of Electrical Engineering,
[6] S. Krithiga and N. G. Ammasai Gounden, “Power electronic configu-
Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi, India. His
ration for the operation of PV system in combined grid-connected and
stand-alone modes,” IET Power Electron., vol. 7, no. 3, pp. 640–647, research interests include power electronics, power
quality, grid interfaced solar PV systems, and design
2014.
of custom power devices.
[7] I. J. Balaguer-Álvarez and E. I. Ortiz-Rivera, “Survey of distributed gen-
eration islanding detection methods,” IEEE Latin Amer. Trans., vol. 8,
no. 5, pp. 565–570, Sep. 2010. Bhim Singh (SM’99–F’10) received the B.E. degree
[8] C. A. Hill, M. C. Such, D. Chen, J. Gonzalez, and W. M. Grady, “Battery in electrical engineering from the University of
energy storage for enabling integration of distributed solar power gen- Roorkee, Roorkee, India, and the M.Tech. and Ph.D.
eration,” IEEE Trans. Smart Grid, vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 850–857, Jun. degrees from the Indian Institute of Technology
2012. (IIT) Delhi, New Delhi, India, in 1977, 1979, and
[9] W. Xiao, F. F. Edwin, G. Spagnuolo, and J. Jatskevich, “Efficient 1983, respectively. In 1983, he joined, as a Lecturer,
approaches for modeling and simulating photovoltaic power systems,” the Electrical Engineering Department, University of
IEEE J. Photovoltaics, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 500–508, Jan. 2013. Roorkee, where he became a Reader in 1988. In
[10] P. Chiradeja, “Benefit of distributed generation: A line loss reduction December 1990, he joined, as an Assistant Professor,
analysis,” in Proc. IEEE/PES Transmiss. Distrib. Conf. Exhib.: Asia Pac., the Electrical Engineering Department, IIT Delhi,
2005, pp. 1–5. where he became an Associate Professor in 1994, and
[11] A. Yadav and L. Srivastava, “Optimal placement of distributed gener- has been a Professor since 1997. His research interests include power electron-
ation: An overview and key issues,” in Proc. Int. Conf. Power Signals ics, electrical machines and drives, renewable energy systems, active filters,
Control Comput. (EPSCICON’14), 2014, pp. 1–6. flexible ac transmission systems, high-voltage direct current, and power quality.
[12] K. A. Joshi and N. M. Pindoriya, “Impact investigation of rooftop Solar He is a Fellow of the Indian National Academy of Engineering; The National
PV system: A case study in India,” in Proc. 3rd IEEE PES Int. Conf. Academy of Sciences, India; the Indian Academy of Sciences; The Institution
Exhib. Innovative Smart Grid Technol. (ISGT Europe), 2012, pp. 1–8. of Engineering and Technology, U.K.; The Institution of Engineers (India);
[13] E. Drury, T. Jenkin, D. Jordan, and R. Margolis, “Photovoltaic investment and the Institution of Electronics and Telecommunication Engineers and a Life
risk and uncertainty for residential customers,” IEEE J. Photovoltaics, Member of the Indian Society for Technical Education and the System Society
vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 278–284, Jan. 2014. of India.

You might also like