You are on page 1of 7

t h e o rc h ard

PISTACHIO ROOTSTOCKS

Louise Ferguson, Blake Sanden, Steve Grattan, Lynn Epstein, and Bill Krueger

C hoosing the rootstock is one of the most


important decisions in
development. This chapter will present the
orchard
Integerrima, PG I, has become the dominant
rootstock of the California pistachio industry.
Interest in increased vigor and early
current body of knowledge relating to pistachio production, and research on the effects of
rootstocks in California. In California, and rootstock on yield, Verticillium wilt and
other pistachio growing areas in the U.S., the salinity tolerance led to the increased use the
nut producing species Pistacia vera is grown hybrid rootstock, UCB I. The other hybrid
on seedling rootstocks of different Pistacia rootstocks, PG II is no longer commercially
species or interspecific hybrids. There are five available having been demonstrated to have
rootstocks which have been used by the poor Verticillium tolerance.
California pistachio industry, three different The following discussion summarizes the
Pistacia species and two interspecific hybrids. specifics of these rootstocks and the recent
The rootstocks are P. terebinthus, P. atlantica, research results
P. integerrima and two hybrids of P. atlantica
pollinated by P. integerrima. The first two are PISTACIA TEREBINTHUS
referred top by their proper names, Terebinthus While P. terebinthus was commonly planted in
and Atlantica, and the latter three are known by the early days of the California pistachio
their trade names or abbreviations thereof: industry, it has fallen out of favor because: 1) it
Integerrima is Pioneer Gold I (PG I) and the is susceptible to Verticillium wilt; 2) it was
hybrids are Pioneer Gold II (PG II) and UC generally perceived to be more difficult to bud
Berkeley I (UCB I). All have characteristics than P. atlantica or P. integerrima; 3) its use
which make them more or less suitable for often resulted in less uniformity than the other
specific planting situations. Understanding rootstocks; and 4) it is less vigorous than the
these differences will allow you to match the other commonly used rootstocks. Currently, it
rootstock with your specific growing is seldom used. P. terebinthus does have
conditions. some characteristics which may make it
During the early years of the pistachio useful in specific situations, and it may be
industry in California, because P. vera cv.
valuable in future breeding programs. Of
‘Kerman’ had no resistance to nematodes or
Phytophthora, Atlantica and Terebinthus were
the five rootstocks, P. terebinthus is the
the rootstocks of choice. Atlantica was most cold hardy. Pistachios growing on this
generally favored over Terebinthus due to rootstock have been reported to withstand
greater ease of budding and uniformity. The temperatures as low as 15oF with no
bulk of pistachios were planted in the San damage. In nutritional studies where
Joaquin Valley where both rootstock species nutrient levels of ‘Kerman’ cultivar on
proved to be very susceptible to the soil-borne different rootstocks were compared at
fungal disease, Verticillium wilt. A small test seven locations throughout the state, P.
planting of Integerrima in Verticillium infested terebinthus was never the lowest and often
soil in the San Joaquin Valley was found to be the highest. In these studies it was the most
tolerant of the disease. This discovery allowed
efficient for absorption of zinc and copper,
planting of pistachios in Verticillium-infested
soil. Since then, the commercial production
micronutrients which are known to be
deficient in soils of some California

67
pistachio orchards. Results of a rootstock respectively Pioneer Gold II (PG II) and UCB
trial in soil infested with Armillaria root rot I. PG II is the result of open pollination in an
in Yolo County have indicated that P. isolated situation with multiple P. atlantica
terebinthus is more resistant to this disease trees as the female parent and multiple P.
integerrima trees as the pollen parents. UCB I
than are the other rootstocks.
is the result of a closed pollination with a single
tree of the same parents. (P. integerrima pollen
PISTACIA ATLANTICA is introduced into a closed greenhouse in which
Until P. integerrima was discovered to be
the P. atlantica tree is grown.) Thus, both are
tolerant of Verticillium, P. atlantica was the
the same interspecific hybrid but are produced
most common rootstock. P. atlantica is more
from different seedling parents and therefore
cold hardy than P. integerrima and the two
both exhibit seedling variability. Both of the
interspecific hybrids, but less cold hardy than
hybrid rootstocks have increased vigor
P. terebinthus. It is susceptible to Verticillium
compared to P. atlantica, and generally equal
wilt. It is less vigorous than P. integerrima and
or greater vigor compared to P. integerrima.
the two interspecific hybrids, and slightly
Ongoing statewide rootstock trials have
slower to come into production. P. atlantica is
demonstrated UCB I has the best yields
more efficient at uptake of zinc than P.
through year 13 followed by PG I, PG II and P.
integerrima and UCB I, and has less copper
atlantica.
uptake than P. terebinthus or PG II.
Laboratory screening tests and early field
Because of greater cold tolerance than P.
studies indicate the two hybrids differ in
integerrima and the low incidence of
resistance to Verticillium. P. integerrima
Verticillium wilt in the Sacramento Valley, P.
appears to be the most tolerant, and P. atlantica
atlantica was the most common rootstock in
the most susceptible; UCB I is tolerant to
this region. Since 1981 the desire for greater
moderately tolerant; and PG II is moderately
vigor has led to increased plantings of P.
susceptible to susceptible.
integerrima, and in the 1990s, the interspecific
Nutritional studies indicate PG II is
hybrid UCB I (P. atlantica x P. integerrima)
relatively efficient in zinc uptake, compared to
in this region.
P. terebinthus; P. atlantica was intermediate;
and UCB I and P. integerrima were the least
PISTACIA INTEGERRIMA efficient. PG II was slightly less efficient than
After P. integerrima was discovered to be P. integerrima and slightly more efficient than
tolerant of Verticillium wilt, it became the most UCB I for uptake of boron. UCB I was similar
widely planted rootstock in California. It is to P. atlantica and P. terebinthus in terms of
vigorous, buds easily and results in a uniform boron uptake. Preliminary results indicate PG
tree stand. It is the least cold tolerant of the II and P. atlantica are superior to Integerrima
commonly used rootstocks and can be damaged and UCB I for absorption of copper.
by winter freezes and early frosts, particularly Some evidence of incompatibility with
if they occur when the tree is young. Results of Kerman and UCB I has been observed in some
the statewide rootstock trials terminated in locations in California and Arizona where 25 to
2002 indicated it has growth rates and early 35% of the trees have shown incompatibility.
production superior to P. atlantica and 19.1% It is believed that this incompatibility was
less than UCB I equal to or slightly less than related to a single maternal tree used in the
the two interspecific hybrids. early breeding program. It is also believed that
Nutrient studies have shown P. integerrima the problem has been corrected and should not
to be less efficient than P. atlantica for boron, be seen in future plantings. Variability in vigor
zinc and copper uptake. among UCB I rootstocks has also been
observed. However, as nurseries continue to
INTERSPECIFIC HYBRIDS improve their seedbed rogueing this problem
Of the two interspecific hybrids, only one is has dissipated.
currently available commercially. They are

68
CALIFORNIA PISTACHIO ROOTSTOCK Trees on the other four rootstocks
TRIALS demonstrated the relative cold tolerances given
Rootstock selection for most tree crops is in table 1. Trees on Terebinthus are more cold
generally a history of the limiting factors of tolerant than trees grown on Atlantica,
producing a crop in a given location. followed by trees on or UCB I and PG II.
Pistachios are no exception. The Pistacia vera Scions on all rootstocks suffered freeze damage
cv. ‘Kerman’ female cultivar that is currently but recovered readily. Similar temperatures are
the sole nut producing cultivar in California is not as damaging to a mature orchard as the
not grown on its own roots because it is rootstock is less exposed, and as the scion
susceptible to nematodes, Verticillium wilt, and cultivar ‘Kerman’ is much more cold tolerant
the soil borne fungus Phytophthora. These than these rootstocks.
susceptibilities are unfortunate, because on its
own roots, it is more cold tolerant than most of Table 1. Relative cold tolerance of 2 year old
our current rootstocks. Terebinthus and budded rootstocks.
Atlantica, the industry’s first rootstocks were
replaced by Integerrima when the latter Cold
Rootstock Tolerance
demonstrated superior tolerance to the soil
borne fungus Verticillium. The Atlantica and
P. terebinthus *
Integerrima hybrids were developed for greater
P. atlantica **
yield and vigor but are now demonstrating a P. integerrima ****
salinity tolerance that would allow orchard PG II ***
establishment in marginal ground and use of UCB I ***
marginal quality water. From Most * to Least ****
From 1989 through 2002 in three long term
field trials and, in 1999 a single greenhouse
trial, we investigated the cold and salinity Soil Borne Fungal Disease Tolerance
tolerance, Verticillium tolerance/resistance, and Table 2 contains the relative soil borne fungal
yield and alternate bearing behavior of trees disease tolerance rankings of the current
grown on Atlantica, PG I and the two pistachio rootstocks. A recent long term
interspecific hybrids of Atlantica X Verticillium research trial demonstrated that
Integerrima, UCB I and PG II. These 13 years while trees on both PG I and UCB I survived
of data collection and unexpected freezes have well in a heavily infested plot, the two
delineated the relative merits of the four rootstocks had different defense mechanisms.
rootstocks now used in California. The Trees on PG I rootstocks, while heavily
following tables detail these results and infected with the pathogen, tolerated it well.
incorporate results from earlier trials and other Trees on UCB I rootstocks were much less
researchers. The information will be presented likely to become infected, but, when infected,
in the order of most limiting factors first; sites displayed decreased vigor. The fact that trees
limitation of cold, disease and salinity followed on PG I rootstocks are easily infected with
by horticultural effects, micronutrient uptake Verticillium suggests that, as they age, they
and effects on scion yield, quality and alternate might have decreased vigor. Trees on both
bearing. Atlantica and PG II rootstocks were easily
infected by Verticillium, suffered marked
Cold Tolerance declines in vigor and yield, and high mortality.
Table 1 gives the relative cold tolerance of Surprisingly, trees on PG II rootstocks were
budded rootstocks less than two years of age. more susceptible than trees on Atlantica
This data was obtained in the winter of 1989 – rootstocks. Verticillium infection was probably
1990 when the newly planted rootstock trials the reason for the poor performance of trees on
experienced freezing temperatures down to PG II rootstocks when they were commercially
ranging from 4-12 º F for 11 nights. In our released in the early 1990s. The trees were
trials 41% of the trees on PG I rootstocks died. quickly infected with Verticillium.

69
Phytohpthora is currently not a problem Phytophthora rankings given in Table 2. were
except in saturated situations. However, as produced by an Iranian colleague.
more rootstocks are planted in marginal ground Armillaria has not proven to be a problem
and irrigated with saline water, Phytohpthora in pistachio production. However, if declining
could become a problem. The results relative almond orchards are replaced with pistachios,
Armillaria could become a problem.

Table 2. Relative disease tolerance of the five budded pistachio rootstocks.

Rootstock Verticillium Armillaria Phytophthora

P. terebinthus *
P. atlantica *** *** *
P. integerrima * *** ***
PG II **** ***
UCB I * * *
From Most * to Least ****

Salinity Tolerance proliferating outside the saline wetted treatment


Two trials, an eight year field trial started in zone. For these reasons the results from the
1994 and a one year greenhouse trial in 1999, greenhouse trial are more reliable than the data
were done to determine the relative and from the field trial. However, results from both
absolute salinity tolerance of the three trials support the conclusion that all four
commercial rootstocks. PG II was eliminated pistachio rootstocks are tolerant of soil root
from the greenhouse trial as by 1999 it was no zone salinity up to 8 dS/M, or 5120 PPM TDS.
longer commercially available.
Table 3 integrates the results of these two Table 3. Relative salinity tolerance of
trails. The greenhouse trial used 2 year old pistachio rootstocks.
budded trees and the percentage decrease in
scion growth relative to the control treatment Salinity
was the measurement of salinity tolerance. In Rootstock Tolerance
the 8 year field trial yield decrease as a
P. terebinthus
function of irrigation water and root zone soil
P. atlantica *
water salinity was the indicator of salinity
P. integerrima ****
tolerance. Trees on all three rootstocks PG II
tolerated 8 sequential seasons of irrigation with UCB I **
water adjusted to 8 dS/m, equivalent to 5120 From Most * to Least ****
PPM TDS. Above this, at 12 dS/m or 7680
PPM TDS, all four rootstocks had yield Micronutrient Uptake Efficiency
decreases, but UCB I appeared the most Table 4 gives the relative micronutrient uptake
sensitive. However, in the companion of the five rootstocks. These results are a
greenhouse trial, trees on PG I rootstocks summarization of several trials and give only
demonstrated the most sensitivity to salinity, relative guidelines. Generally it demonstrates
losing a full 50% of their growth increase when that trees on the two most commercially
root zone salinities reached 8 dS/m. important rootstocks, PG I and UCB I, are
Salinity tolerance trials done in a prone to zinc and copper deficiencies and that
greenhouse sand tank have two advantages the latter also is prone to boron deficiencies. In
over those done in an orchard. The well older orchards established with trees on
drained sand tanks eliminate the soil saturation Atlantica rootstocks replants with PG I or UCB
that results as salinity increases, and, roots in I rootstocks can often be distinguished by the
the sand tank cannot avoid the salinity by

70
later breaking foliage that characterizes a zinc trees on PG I rootstocks to take up and
deficiency. translocate sodium and chloride to the scion
Nutrient uptake efficiencies of sodium and could be deleterious in saline conditions. In the
chloride given below were generated in a sand trial that produced the sodium and chloride data
tank trial. They demonstrated that trees on PG I below trees on PG I rootstocks had
rootstock had much higher uptake, and significantly greater decreases in yield relative
translocation to the scion, of sodium and to trees on Atlantica and UCB I rootstocks at
chloride. Interestingly, in this trial only boron the same salinities. At 8 dS/m trees on PG I
produced a specific ion toxicity in the form of rootstocks had a 50% decrease in growth
an even marginal leaf burn. Both sodium and relative to no decrease in growth for trees on
chloride partitioned equally into green and Atlantica and UCB I rootstocks.
necrotic scion leaf tissue. This tendency for

Table 4. Relative micronutrient uptake efficiency of the five rootstocks.

Rootstock Cl Na Zn B Cu

P. terebinthus ** ** *
P. atlantica ** ** *** *** **
P. integerrima * * **** * ***
PG II * ** *
UCB I *** **** **** **** ***
From Most * to Least ****

Effect of Rootstock on Marketable economic production. Thus these results may


Yield only reflect the early bearing years. These trial
Table 5 demonstrates the effect of rootstock on orchards still exist. The only definitive way to
final marketable yield of ‘Kerman’ grown on the demonstrate if this difference in effect of
four different rootstocks. The data in this table rootstock on ‘Kerman’ scion productivity
was produced in three identical rootstock trials persists through the trees’ bearing life is to
grown in three different microclimates from 1989 again measure yield and quality in these trials.
through 2001. To reduce cultivar effect all the trees There was no significant difference in the
in these three trials were budded with buds from alternate bearing indexes among trees on the
the same male and female tree. The data in this different rootstocks. On a scale of 0-1 with
table is based upon the first five producing years. total alternate bearing being 1 and no alternate
The trees did not begin producing marketable bearing 0 the alternate bearing indexes ranged
crops until 1997. Alternate bearing commenced a from 0.66 to 0.68.
very low crop in 1999, the third bearing year. Within a crop year there were no consistent
Trees on UCB I rootstocks produced significant differences in nut size/weight
significantly better yields than trees grown on the among nuts produced from trees on the four
other three rootstocks in all locations and in all different rootstocks. Similarly, within a crop
years. Averaged over all five years of crop year there were few consistent, significant
production and all three trial locations trees on differences in the percentage of blank and non-
UCB I produced an average of 45.3% more split nuts produced by trees on the four
marketable crop than trees on Atlantica different rootstocks. Differences in nut weights,
rootstocks, 19.1% more than trees on PG I and the percentage of blanks and splits did
rootstocks, and 15.1% more than trees grown differ among years, but in a similar fashion for
on PG II rootstocks. It must be remembered ‘Kerman’ on all the rootstocks. For example,
that this was only the first five years of

71
on heavier crop years non-split percentages The data demonstrates that rootstock affects
would rise in trees on all four rootstocks. the vigor of the ’Kerman’ scion, producing a larger
An analysis of the components of yield, tree with more clusters. Rootstock obviously does
clusters per tree, nuts per cluster and nut size, not affect alternate bearing as the calculated
demonstrates UCB I yields better because it alternate bearing indexes were approximately
produces more clusters per tree than trees on equal, and independent of absolute crop load
the other rootstocks, not more or bigger nuts among trees on the different rootstocks. This
per cluster. This is reflected in the average supports the view that alternate bearing is a
relative trunk circumferences in trees grown on function of the scion cultivar alone and that
the different rootstocks. The more productive permanent elimination of this characteristic will
trees are generally larger trees. come from rootstock breeding.

Table 5. Effect of rootstock on cumulative yield of marketable dry, inshell, split nuts*.

County UCB I PG II PG I Atlantica

Average % increase in 15.1 19.1 45.3


yield produced by trees
on UCB I rootstocks
Alternate Bearing Index .67 .66 .68 .67
Cumulative Yield 1989 Fresno 11,095a 9,539b 9,442b 7,394c
through 2001
(lbs/acre @ 112 ♀ Kern 15,258a 13,301b 13,052b 11,418c
trees/acre)
Madera 7,170a 6,285b 5,643c 4,258d
*Values within a row followed by different letters are significantly different. Lack of letters indicates no
significant differences within a row.

In summary, the results of the rootstock UCB I produce the best yields among all the
trials discussed indicate the following major rootstocks, followed by PG II and PG I. All
conclusions. Atlantica is the most cold tolerant three produce better yields than trees on
of the currently commercial rootstocks Atlantica rootstocks. Table 6 gives the final
followed by UCB-I and PG I. PG I and UCB I summary of rootstocks relative characteristics.
are equivalent in their performance under
Verticillium pressure but appear to have Table 6. Relative yield ranking of ‘Kerman’
different mechanisms for coping with the female scion on four pistachio rootstocks.
disease. The PG I rootstock is tolerant whereas
the UCB I rootstock is resistant. Both are Yield
significantly more tolerant of Verticillium than Rootstock Ranking
Atlantica or PG II, in that order. All four
rootstocks tolerate salinity of up to 5120 PPM P. terebinthus
TDS or 8 dS/m in the root zone. Trees on PG I P. atlantica ****
are the most saline sensitive, and have a P. integerrima ***
tendency to take up and sequester sodium and PG II **
chloride more readily than trees on UCB I or UCB I *
Atlantica rootstocks, in that order. Trees on From Most * to Least ****

72
Table 7. Tolerance ranking of pistachio rootstocks in San Joaquin Valley, 1989-2002, from best (1)
to worst (4).
Limiting Factor (1) best worst (4)
Rootstock Frost Yield Salinity Verticillium
P. integerrima 4 3 3 1
P. atlantica 1 4 1 3
PG II 3 2 4
UCB I 2 1 2 2

73

You might also like