THERMOTECH SYSTEMS LIMITED

AHMEDABAD, GUJARAT

COMMENTS RESPONSE SHEET (CRS)

Job No. 1920-77 P.O. No. SIPL/TSL/1501/19-20

Project Thermic Fluid Heater Package
Customer Name M/s. Sunita Impex Private Limited
End User Name M/s. Super Petro
Document No. TSL-SIPL-E&I-004 & 521 076 20 02 Rev. No. R01
Document Title PLC Panel Documents
Date 04-07-2020

Sr.
Comments Response SPPL Comment
No.
Please confirm that the PLC Panel will be IP 66 certified and Provide us Certificate and
panel is NEMA 4X, explosion- purge controller from P&F which catalogue for Control
proof and certified by will be Atex certified. The Panel
ATEX/IECEx. Provide us the considered purge controller is
Model and Data Sheet. suitable to mount and operate in
Zone 2 area.
1
As per contract there is an
option for the IP 66 or NEMA 4X
standard with purging. We are
providing IP 66 with Purging.

2 Request you to use Compactlogix As a package supplier normally,
PLC (1769-L24ER-QB1B with we supply Micrologix 1400 from
1734 Point IO as reference) Rockwell.
instead of Micrologix 1400.  Even in contract there was no
reference of Compactlogix, we
had not considered the same.
Kindly give confirmation on
Micrologix as already our
procurement of parts is
completed.
Till now we have
procured, installed and
used a lot of heaters from
different vendor of
different country but
none provided Micrologix
instead of Compactlogix
for heater. That is why we
only mentioned vendor
name as Allen Bradley.

If you want Compactlogix, there However, Micrologix

will be price implication of Rs.
1,44,800.
You are requested to confirm the
same to enable to proceed
further.
memory is only 10KB,
normally it is used for
very small project. If you
think it will work for this
project without interrupt
than it is ok.

Page 1 of 2
 Micrologix 1400 can be used for You are requested to confirm We need Modbus RTU for
Modbus RTU communication point no 2 for proceed further. DCS Communication,
3
with DCS. please confirm.

Please use the Safety During our discussions, client Use fuse instead.
barrier(pepperl-fuchs) for all had not mentioned any safety
instruments connection. barrier requirement.

If required, there will be price

implication of Rs. 4,55,000 as
4
there will be increase in panel
size due to addition of barriers.
You are requested to confirm the
same to enable to proceed
further.

There is no AO connection from
PLC. Please confirm that the
Control Valve can be controlled
(Manual setpoint of Valve
5
opening percentage) from HMI
and also can set the media
temperature Setpoint at auto
mode from HMI.
There is no BMS connection in
the Panel. Please provide details
6
Connection drawing including
instrument connection to BMS.
Provide us Control system
architecture with details
connection drawing, logic, and
interlock diagram.
7
Burner control valve will be Confirm that the Control
operating via burner sequence Valve can be controlled
controller. (Manual setpoint of Valve
Burner modulation set point opening percentage) from
given through communication HMI and also can set the
between PLC and Burner seq. media temperature
controller, hence no need for AO Setpoint at auto mode
connection. from HMI.
BMS connection diagram will be
shown in complete panel wiring
diagram.
Complete wiring diagram will be
submitted once point no 2 is
clear.
Cause n Effect and control
philosophy will be submitted
instead of interlock diagram
once P&ID will be approved.

Prepared by,

Daxesh Patel

Page 2 of 2