Round 5 September 28, 2018
This house stops the production of drinking alcohol and cigarettes.
Opening Government
Prime Minister:
Naraga
 Parameters
 Philippines alone
 Increasing of tax is applied due to
majority of the people being able to
afford these items
 Physical aspects or the body
 Being abused by the teens
 Said that he will accept 2 points
only
 Definition
 Alcohol-hard liquor
 Arguments
 They are bad for the body. Organs
are being damaged by the
substances of these alcoholic drinks.
Resulting to kidney diseases or
kidney malfunction
 Will result to lung cancer
 Would decrease the physical fitness
of the body. It contributes to
malnourishment and bad
metabolism of the body
 Endurance of the body will be
lessened
 Body will not be suited to be called
physically fit
 Waited for points
 3:01
Deputy Prime Minister:
Genita
 Bad to the teens
 Lung cancer, liver failure, heart
problems and many more
 They shorten their own lives
because of the diseases caused by
these items
 It is unfair for those who are not
smoking because they can
experience the side effects of
smoking
 The teens who are supposed to be
the future of the country have
reduced their chance of helping the
country
 To save the future of the teens
 1:20
Closing Government
Opening Opposition
Leader of the Opposition:
Balahay
 Arguments
 Many people do it for leisure. With
proper exercise and balanced diet,
you can maintain a healthy body.
There are those who smoke and
drink but can keep themselves
physically fit
 It is part of the our practice of
celebrations that people drink and
smoke
 What we are used to during
occasions as found in our traditions
is going to be affected
 It will affect the economy
 There are sellers in the streets
 Manageable production and
consumption
 1:36
Deputy Leader of the Opposition:
Apale
 Filipinos are in the tradition of
drinking alcohol. In celebrations
like weddings, feasts, they drink
alcohol
 Alcohol is good for the body, but in
moderation
 The smoker produces the CO2 that
will be absorbed by plants and trees
 The tax in cigarettes is higher than
other items in the market
 1:21
Closing Opposition
Member:
Peligro
 They have many negative effects in
the body
 Liver cancer
 Affect the kidney
 Second hand smoking, affecting
other people
 Those who have difficulty in
talking, those who have holes in
their neck
 They can have more negative effects
in the body (like asthma, etc)
 Stop the production today.
 1:22
Whip:
Dapar
 Summary
 Went with the person to person
mentioning of the arguments
 Explanations are provided by the
speaker
 What if these teens will not be
managed in taking these items?
 Rebuttal
 Stopping the production is the way
to manage these teens
 They cannot be managed because of
their irresponsibility
 Those who did not smoke will be
affected
Member:
Loquias
 The voice tends to be soft
 There is a tendency to eat words in
the delivery
 He needs to open his mouth more
 Removing it from the daily life of a
person (traditional manner)
 It contributes to fun, like when
foreigners come to a place
 It can affect the economy of the
Philippines
 Taking away their vices is like
putting a dolphin in an aquarium. It
is not about taking away the
product. It is about managing the
use of the product.
 Drinking helps lessen chances of
heart attack
 With these being bought by
majority of the population, it is like
taking away something that is
beneficial
 Naraga: parameter which states that
these items are abused by the teens
—
 Naraga: can you manage them if
they are already abused by the
teens—how can you actually say
that majority of the teens are into
smoking and drinking
 Dapar: the focus of the debate is the
physical aspect—the physical health
contributes to the whole person
 Dapar: we are particular with the
physical aspect—they would be abe
to take care of themselves
 6:15
Whip:
Labasan
 Informed that he will not accept
points in the duration of his speech.
Failure to follow it means that
opposing debaters have poor
listening skills
 Arguments were reiterated
 Went with person to person
mentioning of arguments
 It will affect tourism here in the
philippines (he mentioned this
though the Member was not heard
clearly about it)
 Dapar: what is more important: the
health of the people or the wealth of
 He is just looking at loquias the country? Health is wealth; there
 Loquias: why did they have to be is no assurance that if you can
managed—even a simple afford, you are going to be healthy –
instruction, they cannot follow. I am just worried about the
That is a proof that they need to be economy and the youth. I am not
disciplined taking any side
 Loquias: is it not possible to  6:49
manage them in terms of the place
of smoking (as to where to smoke)
—though there are signs, there are
people who don’t follow
instructions
 Is that what we call management?
How much more for those we call
teenagers? (teen-eegers) hihihihih
 To the LO: it would be better if they
stop the habit of drinking or
smoking. There is then a decrease of
body functionality if they indeed
smoke or drink
 DLO: occasions and weddings—the
focus are the teenagers. Those who
go to these events are mostly adults
 Consumed his time