Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ir
https://www.tarjomano.com/order
Received 5 June 2006; received in revised form 11 October 2006; accepted 12 October 2006
Available online 7 November 2006
Abstract
A new concept of a liquid fuels-fired porous combustor-heater (LPCH) without atomization is proposed. Basic experimental study
was conducted with liquid kerosene on a down-flow LPCH to prove its concept and evaluate its performance. Effects of dominating
parameters, i.e. mass flow rate of the cooling water, equivalence ratio and input thermal power, on temperature profiles within the
LPCH, thermal efficiency and pollutant emissions (CO and NOX) under different conditions have been investigated and compared with
those of the conventional free flame combustion system. The LPCH proved very effective in increasing thermal efficiency (up to 28% with
respect to the conventional system) with a manageable level of CO emissions but low NOX emissions. The dominating parameters have a
significant effect on flame location, combustion temperature and pollutant emissions. Operating the LPCH at optimized operating con-
ditions is important for the requirement of low CO emissions without compromising thermal efficiency and NOX emissions. Practical
applications of this LPCH are suggested.
2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0016-2361/$ - see front matter 2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.fuel.2006.10.007
Downloaded from https://iranpaper.ir
https://www.tarjomano.com/order
Nomenclature
for practical utilization could be achieved through a direct cement lining and the PB so as to prevent the liquid fuel
removal of heat within the porous matrix of the PE and flow pattern within the PB from being disturbed by protru-
removal of heat that transfers in the lateral direction of the sion of the thermocouple junctions. The thermocouple
PE . signals are digitized by a general-purpose data logger,
Fig. 2 shows the corresponding experimental apparatus and then transmitted to a personal computer.
for the down-flow LPCH. It consists of two main cylindri- The thermocouple readings can represent the solid phase
cal porous media, i.e. an upstream one (PB) and a down- (or porous medium) temperature since the thermocouples
stream one (PE). The PB is made of a packed bed of are also solid by themselves. This simplifies the analysis
metallic wire screen with mesh size of 100 mesh/in., greatly, and the price we pay for this convenience is some
whereas the PE is made of a packed bed of inert solid loss in accuracy due to error arising from several effects,
alumina spheres with average diameter of 19 mm. A small such as heat transfer effects caused by conduction and radi-
space separating the two porous media serves as a mixing ation, etc. In order to know the true gas temperatures, the
chamber for homogeneous mixture of fuel vapor and the thermocouple readings have to be corrected but this was
swirling air. The water coil having inside diameter of not performed because radiation error involves many
6 mm is embedded within the PE for extracting heat within unknown due to the complex radiative field around the
the PE, whereas the water jacket is for absorbing heat that bead particularly when the thermocouple is inside the por-
transfers in the lateral direction of the PE. The location of ous matrix. Moreover, the uncertainty in the results is high
the water coil xc = 225 mm is used throughout the experi- due primarily to the lack of reliable interface convective
ment and is judged by experience. heat transfer coefficient and also the lack of reliable data
The combustion characteristics are determined from for thermophysical/chemical and radiative properties of a
profiles of the temperature along the burner axis and the porous matrix.
composition of the combustion gases at the exit of the Uncertainties in the intrusive thermocouple measure-
LPCH. In order to know the temperature profiles, N-type ment are of concern. However, thermocouple is the only
thermocouples (0.25-mm diameter) of T1 to T16 (repre- technique available at present to measure temperature
sented by solid circles in Fig. 2) were used and inserted inside a porous medium burner. Repeated measurement
through small ports in the burner wall. Each thermocouple shows an uncertainty of about 10% for the temperature.
wire was insulated with magnesium oxide and the entire The results of the measurement are instructive, but should
assembly sheathed in 1.5-mm diameter. These thermocou- be interpreted with proper caution regarding the limita-
ples were inserted normal to the axis of the burner and tions of the experimental technique. Upon steady state con-
can be positioned at any radial position depending on sec- dition for each experimental condition was reached,
tion (Fig. 2). In the PE section and mixing chamber, the thermocouple reading for each location was almost flat
thermocouples (T5–T16) were positioned at the centerline with relatively small perturbation. Then the temperatures
of the burner, whereas in the PB section the thermocouples were averaged over a specific time interval and plotted on
(T1–T4) were positioned at the interface between the a graph.
Emission analysis of the dry combustion products at the
LPCH exit is carried out by using the Messtechnik Eheim
model Visit01L, which is a portable emission analyzer
designed especially for quasi-continuous measurement. A
gas processing system of NOX and CO is especially tuned
for electrochemical sensors, ensuring long-time stability
and accuracy of measurement. The measuring range of
the analyzer is 0–4000 ppm for NOX and 0–10,000 ppm
for CO with measuring accuracy of about ±5 ppm (from
the measured value) and resolution of 1 ppm for both
NOX and CO. All measured emissions in the experiment
are those corrected to 0% excess oxygen and dry-basis.
Repeated measurement shows an uncertainty of about
10% for the species concentrations.
The experimental procedure as well as other measuring
devices for various values, i.e. fuel flow rate, air flow rate
and pressure difference DP, remain the same as those
employed in the previous work [7] except measuring devices
for the water flow rate (m_ c and m_ j ) and bulk mean tempera-
tures of water at the water coil (Tc,i and Tc,o) and at the water
jackets (Tj,i and Tj,o) were added by standard laboratory
devices. After a preheating phase with non-premixed lique-
Fig. 2. Experimental apparatus for the LPCH. fied petroleum gas (LPG)–air combustion the operation
Downloaded from https://iranpaper.ir
https://www.tarjomano.com/order
NO X (ppm)
CO (ppm)
3. Results and discussion a
η (%)
50 1500 100
η (%)
tion within the PE can be considered homogeneous because 50
of complete separation of the evaporation zone (PB) and
the combustion zone (PE). The more homogeneous the
combustion is, the smaller the amount of NOX emitted [17].
Since combustion within the PE simultaneously with
heat transfer produced a relatively strong quenching effect
0
resulting in a marked increase in CO emissions as occurred 0 1 2. 3 4 5
in case c, determination of favorable operation ranges with mc (kg/min)
acceptable emission of CO is important, and will be
Fig. 6. Effect of m_ c on g of LPCH (d) as compared with case a (+).
described in the subsequent section.
2500 2500
150
2000 2000 x
NOx (ppm)
CO (ppm)
CO (ppm)
x
1500 100 1500 x
x
1000 COmin
1000 x
x x xx
50
500 500 ΦCO min
0 0 0
0 1 2 3 4 5 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0
.
mc (kg/min) Φ
Fig. 5. Effect of m_ c on CO (d) and NOX (+) of LPCH (solid line) as Fig. 7. Effect of U on CO at CL = 10 kW (+), CL = 12 kW (·) and
compared with case a (dotted line) at CL = 13 kW, U = 0.6. CL = 15 kW (d).
Downloaded from https://iranpaper.ir
https://www.tarjomano.com/order
x x x xx xx x
x
U increases, with an initial increase in its value until a max-
100 imum value gmax is reached. Then a decreasing in g was
observed in the final variation in U because of incomplete
combustion with steep increase in CO as shown in Fig. 7.
50 However, gmax is further increased as CL increases and is
shifted toward higher equivalence ratio U because of
increase in combustion temperature.
0
0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0
Φ 4. Conclusions
Fig. 8. Effect of U on NOX at CL = 10 kW (+), CL = 12 kW (·) and
CL = 15 kW (d). 1. The LPCH proved very effective in increasing g (up to
28% with respect to the conventional system; case a)
with a manageable level of CO emissions but low NOX
the flame location to move towards the water coil, resulting
emissions. The LPCH can provide the basis for further
in an increase in the quenching effect and thus the subse-
development of the state-of-the-art technology of a
quent incomplete combustion.
new version and a more advanced thermal system
As CL increases from 10 to 15 kW, favorable operating
fuelled by liquid fuels, such as highly efficient low-pollu-
condition of UCO min yields an increasing trend, whereas
tant-emission boilers, water heaters, and so on for both
COmin shows a decreasing trend. Meanwhile, the U-shaped
industrial and residential applications.
curve of CO emissions widens, yielding a favorably wide
2. Effect of m_ c , U and CL on g and pollutant emissions of
operating range. This is attributed to an increase in com-
the LPCH have been clarified. These parameters have a
bustion temperature and an improvement in mixing as
significant effect on flame location combustion tempera-
CL increases. However, the increase in UCO min is strongly
ture and pollutant emissions. Operating the LPCH at
dependent on the increase in CL, which is accompanied
optimized operating conditions is important for the
by very high combustion temperature. Therefore, no exper-
requirement of low CO emissions without compromis-
iment was conducted for CL over 15 kW so as to prevent
ing thermal efficiency and NOX emissions.
the system from overheating.
Fig. 8 shows the corresponding NOX variation with U at
various CL. Despite a marked increase in combustion tem-
perature with U in the initial stage at constant CL as References
observed during the experiment, NOX emissions were
almost insensitive to U. On the other hand, NOX emissions [1] Ravish MB. Gas and its utilization. Moscow: Nauka; 1974 [in
were slightly increased as CL increases. However, the max- Russian].
[2] Echigo R, Hanamura K, Yoshizawa Y, Tomimura T. Radiative heat
imum value of NOX does not exceed 140 ppm within the
transfer enhancement to a water tube by combustion gases in porous
media. In: Wang B-X, editor. Heat transfer science and technol-
ogy. Hemisphere Publishing; 1987. p. 1–99.
100 [3] Khinkis MJ, Kunc W, Xiong TY. In: International symposium on
combustion in industrial furnaces and boilers, The American Flame
Research Committee (AFRC), Short Hills, NJ, September 1989.
[4] Xiong TY, Khinkis MJ, Fish FF. Experimental study of a high-
xx
x x xx x efficiency, low emission porous matrix combustor-heater. Fuel 1995;
x x
74(11):1641.
η (%)
[9] Fuse T, Araki Y, Kobayashi N, Hasatani M. Combustion charac- [12] Takami H, Suzuki T, Itaya Y, Hasatani M. Performance of
teristics in oil-vaporizing sustained by radiant heat reflux enhanced flammability of kerosene and NOx emission in the porous burner.
with higher porous ceramics. Fuel 2003;82:1411. Fuel 1998;77(3):165.
[10] Trimis D, Wawrzinek K, Hatzfeld O, Lucka K, Rutsche A, Haase F, [13] Tseng C-J, Howell JR. Combustion of liquid fuels in a porous radiant
et al. High modulation burner for liquid fuels based on porous burner. Combust Sci Technol 1996;112:141.
media combustion and cool flame vaporization. In: Sixth interna- [14] Kaplan M, Hall MJ. The combustion of liquid fuels within a porous
tional conference on technologies and combustion for a clean media radiant burner. Exp Therm Fluid Sci 1995;11:13.
environment (Clean Air VI), vol. 2, Paper 23.1, Porto, Portugal, [15] Bernardin JD, Mudarwar I. Film boiling heat transfer of droplet
9–12 July 2001. streams and sprays. Int J Heat Mass Transfer 1997;40:2579.
[11] Trimis D, Wawrzinek K, Hatzfeld O, Lucka K, Rutsche A, Haase F, [16] Weinberg FJ. Combustion temperatures: the future? Nature 1971;
et al. A novel porous burner for liquid fuels based on porous media 243:249.
combustion and cool flame vaporization, combustion and the [17] Lee JCY, Malte PC, Benjamin MA. Low NOx combustion for liquid
environment. In: 24th Event of the Italian Section of Combustion fuels: atmospheric pressure experiments using a staged prevaporizer–
Institute, 16–19 September 2001, ISBN 88-88104-01-1. premixer. J Eng Gas Turb Power 2003;125:861.