Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1964 National Incinerator Conference 29 PDF
1964 National Incinerator Conference 29 PDF
VIGGO WESTERGAARD
COllSulting Engineer
Larchmont, New York
! JAMES A. FI FE
Metcalf & Eddy
Boston, Massachusetts
170
---""'"
�oo ,--�-�-i-r-�
the use of the high temperature alloys are not generally
......-COOLING WITH
available this paper is based upon the exit temperatures WATER SPRAYS
stated above. .:
.
The two agents commonly used as cooling materials
� I)OO�-��-r�-4--1
are air and water. Both have advantages and disadvan w
�
tagcs. Generally, a combination of the two is found most
900 I---ICl-J'--+--\+---l
aCfeptable. However, they must first be considered
separately, so that the characteristics of each may be
700 U'-L-_--'-_-'---'---'
. properly evaluated. r
5 O
}
�ooo \500
In many ways, this appears the simplest method. Air FIG. 1. VOLUME OF 1000 CU FT GASES AT 1500 F COOLED
is available at no cost. Its introduction into the gas BY VARIOUS METHODS. INLET AIR TEMPERATURE
·
stream is simple. Instrument-controlled louvered open - 80 F; INLET WATER TEMPERATURE - 70 F.
BASED ON 100% EFFICIENCY.
ings with or without com " pressed air injectors may admit
the cooling medium to the gas stream. Mixing cold air The reduction of fly ash density per unit of gas
wit'h the hot gases is a continuous operation, thus the volume, for some types of collectors, may reduce collec
temperatures of the surrounding refractories remain reIa- tion efficiency. Since it is the total quantity of matter
. tively stable, and thermal shock damage is minor. emitted that is circumseribed, this may pose a problem.
It is only when the designer considers the quantities
of combined combustion gas and cooling air that the Cooling by Water Admixture
high cost of this method becomes evident. Though the
gas volume contracts as the cooling progresses, the As contrasted to gases cooled by air dilution, the
cooling air adds another stream of gas of such a quan volume of the combined cooled gases and superheated
tity that the total volume of the combined gas increases vapors - when water is the cooling medium - is consid
(see Table n. CooJing by this method from, for example, erably smaller than the volume of the gases before cool
1500 F to 700 F results in a combined quantity 142 ing (see Table n. In this case, when cooling from 1500
per cent of the volume of the combustion gases before to 700 F, there is a reduction in volume of 27.3 per cent.
cooling. Since the enlarged quantity of the combined gas This is economically reflected in smaller equipment.
stream demands increased sizes of cooling chamber, Against this saving, there must be charged the increased
ducts, fly ash separation equipment, induced draft fan maintenance costs of refractories and equipment, due to
and chimney, the increase in plant construction costs' corrosion and abrasion, plus the cost of pumps, piping,
may be considerable. nozzles and waste water treatment, if such is required.
TABLE I
** By dry gases are meant the combustion products contoinlng the moisture of the refuse but not including moisture added
by the cooling process.
17 1
Most incinerator plants are charged regular water rates. g) temperature at exit from cooling chamber
Il not the cost to the community to provide the water is a h) volume of flue gases entering cooling chamber
fair charge and should be part of the cost comparison il volume of fl tiC gases leaving cooling chamber
estimate. j) size of fly ash collector
(� Table I shows that with 100 per cent efficiency, 2.88 k) size of ducts and chimney
pounds of water is required to cool 1000 cubic feet I) static pressure of induced draft fan
0500 F) from 1500 to 700 F or approximately 274 gallons m) size of induced draft fan.
of water is needed per ton of refuse hurned. Assuming Items a) to e) inclusive are familiar to the incinM
65 per cent efficiency, this becomcs 420 gallons per ton erator designer. Consideration of these does not belong
.
of refuse. At a cost of $0.25 per 100 cubic feet, the under this subject.
water cost per ton burned would be $0.14 or between 2 Items £) and g), the gas temperatures immediately
and 4 per cent of the total burning cost for an efficient before and after the cooling process, must
and well-run plant; This cost may be reduced by settling be established. The cooled gas temperature depends
the slurry and treating and recirculating the waste water. upon the tolerance of the materials containing the gas
Recirculation often becomes attractive if untreated fluid stream. As this normally will be a low alloy steel plate,
waste cannot be disposed of. This may be the case a top temperature of 700 F is safe. The temperature at
where a s�wer i s too far away or too high to make conM the cooling chamber inlet depends upon furnace tempera
nection practical, or where the nearest stream cannot ture and excess air, but it may be taken to average
safely alisorb the untreated waste water. Further, the 1700 F. An average temperature must be chosen since
local water pollution control plant may not be able to it will detennine the annual quantities of water con�
handle the additional load or the sewers may be too flat sumption and the cost of electric power to operate the
to assure that the solid matter will not settle and
seriously reduce the flow in an already-inadequate Tabulation of Estimate
system.
Air Water
Cooling Cooling Est. Cost
Quantities ancl Dimensions
P.er cent of each X X A B'
The two decisions which must be made before the de Quantities X X
sign may proceed are as follows: Combined Quantity X
1) re-circulation or 100 per cent make-up of spray Dimensions Cool. Chamber X X
water; Dimensions Duct to fly ash coli. X X
2) proportional division of cooling load between air Dimensions Duct to induced
and water. draft fan X X
These go hand in 1land since an increase in air Dimensions Duct to Chimney X X
cooling load reduces the quantity of water available for Fly ash coli. and assoc, equip. X X
reMcirculation - possibly to a point where reMcirculation Induced draft fon X X
becomes unnecessary. I t i s generally advisable to make Chimney X X
several cost estimates to detennine the least expensive Louvered air inlets and inlet nozzlets X X
and least troublesome proportion of the cooling agents. Inlector piping X X
Estimates may be tabulated as shown in the .next Air compressor or shore in
column. Items given provide an illustration. Items may plant compressor X X
be added and subtracted, and the list should not be con Water pumps X X
sidered definitive. Piping, nozzles and valving ·X X
After the first estimate is made, it is less timeM Metering X X
Cool. Chamber drain X X
consuming to follow up with additional estimates for
Water Treatment and seHling X (X)
different conditions. The investigation of three different
Re-circulation pumps and.associated
proportions will probably make it possible to settle on
equipment X (X)
the answers to 1) and 2) above.
Fly ash disposal X X (X)
Certain basic data must be developed in order to
Automatic control and instru ..
make ihe estimates discussed. These are�
metntotion X X X
a) burning rate
Water cost per yetar X X
b) refuse composition
Power cost per year X X X
c) theoretical air for combustion
Maintenancet pett year X X X
d) excess air before cooling chamber
Operation cost por yoar X X X
e) quantity of combustion products
£) temperature at entrance to cooling chamber .. Add B to the amortized annual cost of A.
172
---
auxiliary equipment and the induced draft fan, A maxi . and maintenance of the spray nozzles. For a well
mum temperature must, however, also be selected to designed layout, it may be taken at 65 per cent. How
determine equipment and duct sizes and the capacity. of ever, more spray water capacity should be added to as
a system to supply sufficient quantities of cooling agents sure safety in operation under unusual condition until
to assure that the selected cooling chamber outlet more operating data is availahle. It is recommended that
/
temperature will not be exceeded, the total nozzle capacity, including a hand-opel'ated
Usually 2000 F should be satisfactory, especially bank, he based on 33 per cent efficiency and a total
'when an alarm is incorporated in the system. An addi cooling gap from 2000 to 700 F,
g tional hand-operated bank of spray water nozzles will be Fig, 2 and Table II may be used for the trial estimates
provided by a conservative designer. The remaining suggested above, assuming that Ti is 1800 F and Tm is
items listed may be determined by well-known methods. noo F. Fig. 2 will provide the answer that 741 pounds
There remains to establish the quantities of cooling of air and 76 po�nds of water are requ.ired, and that the
air and water. These may he calculated by the formulas: final volume will be 54.470 cubic feet at 700 F for 1000
lb of gases. Fig. 2 is based on Table II in which addi
r,
Qg (Ti - Tml Cpg tional details are given. l3y subtraction and addition,
,I Qa =
"H"x" -'
"f -+'(T
"
' .--'-_,r.n'."') "O'--f"')
The East 73rd Street incinerator in the City of
where New York has been in operation since September, 1957.
Qg quantity flue gas - pounds per hour
=
It was constructed in the expanded structure of an exist
Qa quantity cooling air - pounds per hour
=
ing plant. In three furnaces of 220 tons per day it burns
Qw quantity spray water - pounds per hour
=
660 tons per 24 hours. The general arrangement of a
" Tj temperature of - flue gas at inlet to cooling
=
furnace unit is shown in Fig. 3.
chamber Furnace and Cooling Chamber. Each furnace is
•
o
T3 == temperature f - waste water at cooling
I
chamber drain � 1,00
H heating value in I3tu per pound of steam from
=
�
173
1
I
oi
0
t-
«
'"
w
Z
U
i!:
:r.
"
:>
0
'"
X
t-
Z
0
6
w
VI
..
Ii
II.
.174
burning grate. The drop between the two grates is four
feet.'
I
When air admixture is insullicient, the highest bank
of water spray nozzles is automatically activated,
1
From the furnace, an nverage of 92,000 pounds per followed by the second and third banks, as needed. The
hour of combustion gases enter the cooling chamber fourth bank is manually operated, and is for emergency
through a throat 14 ft high by 8 ft wide. Each side wall use in case the automatic cooling system fails to keep
of the throat has 10 air ports located in a vertical Hne, the temperature at the desired level. The cooling
for introduction of cooling air. This air is aspirated chamber is constructed of high heat duty refractories.
through 9 in. x lOY, in. rectangular air ports by a iet of The floor slopes to a center drain which terminates under
compressed air at 30 in. water column. The jet has a the water surface of the residue conveyors below.
1/2 in. nozzle centered in the air inlet casting. The air . Fly Ash Collectors. From the top of the second pass
jets. also create turburence and therefore a better mixing of the cooling chamber, the gases - reduced to tempera
of the cooling air with the combustion gases. The air tures between 600 and 650 degrees - pass through a
inlet ports on each side wall are connected to a com horizontal metal flue into the fly ash collector. Each
mon plenum chamber. The air quantity admitted through collector consists of 336 cyclones with 8 in. diameter
the ports to the throat is controlled by louver dampers inlet tubes and 6 in. diameter outlet tubes, and -is
on the front walls of the plenum chambers. The dampers divided into four separate sections of equal size, with a
are positioned automatically at any required opening common discharge hood connected to the induced draft
from fully closed to fully opened. fan.
The mixture of flue gases and cooling air then enters The efficiency of the multi-cyclone type of collector
the cooling chamber structure in a sudden expansion of is related to the velocity of the fly ash-laden gases
width of structure from 8 ft to 20 ft- 2 in. The change in passing through it. In order to keep this velocity from
dimensions aids in mixing the combustion gases and the dropping below the proper value, each of the f�ur
cooling air so that hot zones due to stratification in the sections is preceded by a vertical louver damper in the
gas flow may be avoided. Three horizontal banks of inlet duct. These dampers are operated by air cylinders,
water spray nozzles are located in vertical succession controlled by push-pull buttons on the operating instru
in the cooling chamber wall facing the furnace. A fourth ment board. They are either fully open or fully closed.
horizontal bank of water spray nozzles is located in the This permits varying the capacity of the fly ash collector
far wall. by 25, 50, 75 and 100 per cent of full utilization.
Each of the four collector sections has its own fly
1 For a more detailed description of the double traveling grate incin�
ash hopper, sealed by a rotary star feeder. The four
erator, sce V. Westergaard. "Traveling Grates Find a New Field of rotary feeders for each collector are operated by a con
Usefulness" by Combustion, Vol. 26, No. 12, June 1955. p. 40. tinuous shaft and a single electric motor drive mechan
ism. All fly ash hoppers discharge into a single scraper
TABLE II
"
Additional
Water Cooling Total Gases
Air Cooling Lb Air Total to 700 F Total Cu Ft.. Total Cu FI and
to Required Lb Combined Required at 700 Dry Gases Vapor Vapor
(T emp. OF) at 80 F Gas and Air (700 F) (700 F) Cu Ft
Lb Gal. (700 F)
175
conveyor system. This delivers the collected fly ash to 4) The air signal from the "Slave Draft" Controller
a bifurcated chute, each leg of which empties into a adjusts the position of a piston in the control drive.
residue conveyor. A flap gate in the chute is pneumatic 5) The position of the pistOil in the control drive,
ally operated and connected electrically to the residue through a linkage system, adjusts the output speed of the
conveying equipment so that the conveyor system empties fluid drive unit in the drive of the induced draft fan.
into the operating residue conveyor. 6) The fan speed adjusts the negative pressure in
The rotary feeders and the scraper conveyors may be the furnace, and the cycle is completed.
operated manually or by an automatic device which starts B) Summing up the operation of the temperature con
the conveyors at set intervals and operates them for a trol system:
length of time which is adjusted to suit the need. The 1) The temperature of the com·bustion gases is
conveyors and feeders are electrically interlocked and measured in four locations, in front of the inlet of the
start sequentially, beginning with the one which dis sections of each fly ash collector. Temperatures are
charges to the residue conveyor. translated into air signals in the pneumatic transmitter.
Induced Draft Fan. The combustion gases are drawn 2) The four air signals are weighed in the high
through the cooling chambers and fly ash collectors by pressure selector relays which suppress the three lower
induced draft fans located above the fly ash collectors air signals.
(Fig. 3). The fans discharge into a common breeching 3) The highest air signal is transmitted to the re
above the roof which terminates in the chimney • . cording controller which records the signal in terms of
Each fan is capable of handling 190,000 cubic feet tempersture and supplies an output air signal.
per minute of gases at 700 F, against a static pressure 4) This latter air signal successively activates
of 5.5 in. water column. It is driven by a 300 hp motor (through mercoid switches)
through a variable speed fluid drive and a speed reducer. a) cooling air aspirator fan;
The variable speed unit is controlled by the negative b) cooling air inlet dampers;
pressure in the furnace in such a manner that a pre c) water spray solenoid valves.
determined draft is maintained in the furnace under the (This system described was furnished by The Bristol
varying operating conditions. Company' and is one of several different types of control
Cooling Agent Quantities. Because of the variability ·methods available in the trade.)
in quanti ty and temperature of the combustion gases, un
certainties in regard to the efficiency of the cooling sys
tem (and no experience to lean upon), liberal figures Suggest/ons
were used in detennining the maximum quantities of air
and water required. The quantities selected for a furnace, 1) Determine �ir and water requirements by assuming
and proven more than sufficient, were as follows: 100 per cent utilization of cooling air and a minimum of
cooling air 40,000 cfm at 100 F.
- 33 per cent of the cooling water, ending as superheated
cooling water 145 gpm.
- steam at the tempemture of the cooled gases. A tempers
Automatic Control2• The automatic control system ture rise in waste water of 50 F may safely be assumed.
performs two distinct functions: 2) Slope wall opposite sprsy nozzles so that the
a) it maintains a predetennined pressure in the sprsy water (by then quite acid) may not easily seep
furnace; through cracks to the metal back-up structure where it
b) it adjusts the equipment to provide a predetermined can be very destructive.
outlet temperature from the Cooling Chamber . 3) Slope cooling chamber bottom steeply fo" effective
draining of the slurry.
A) Summing up the operation of the furnace drsft con- 4) Place nozzles well inside the wall to protect them
trol system: .
/' from the strongly eroding effect of moist combustion
l) The negative pre�sure in the furnace is trans gases. Conical openings in the wall will permit this.
lated into an air signal in a "Master Draft" controller. 5) Experiment with nozzle metals to find the best for
2) The electric current demand of the induced draft prolonged use. A metal such as Carpenter 20 may be
fan motor is translated into an air signal in a current con found better than many of the stainless varieties.
verter/pneumatic transmitter combination. 6) Tilt nozzle supply pipes downward towards the
3) The air signal from the "Master Dmft" Con nozzle end to reduce water spillage outside chamber.
troller is modified by the air signal from the pneumatic 7) Arrange instruments so that the state of erosion
transmitter. Thus the fan speed will not demand an input of the nozzle orifice may be determined by observing
current above a pre-set maximum. This function is per changes -in water pressure and consumption.
formed by a : 'Slave Draft" Controller. 8) It was found that the outlet vanes in the cyclone
units easily clogged. They were removed without ob
2For details of the operation of the control system, seo Appendix. servable change in the efficiency of the fly ash collector.
i
176
9) A study to detelTIline the most suitable relractory
for the cooling chamber waIl opposite the spray nozzles
is recommended. Considerable spaIling has been ex
perienced. This may be reduced by a more suitable de
sign and material.
Appendix
Control System
\
'\'
Pk·1
�,
n'l
ill=lf tAw b
'ilOUUO
. ,
MOYOil
.T.
U �
./
'
. ,
,.,.,.,.,. '"'''''' nr";9 �- "lJl
r - - - - - - ..j.11
-
�T""
Y" ,,-;
III
LW II/
IL III
I 1 III
I I
I
I
I
I !(!, ' --'- '
L....r-----...
...J .
206"'40..,
10"·1
J I • '-..0.
-.J
m
_
--
TO rAN MOrol
- -
l!LJ�=�r-""r1c:J
-
T
'
LO 0
l U
.T. t.= == � = J = = =) , ..... " ,.,.
177
providing a maximum current of 5 amperes (TCC-l and
CT, Fig. 4). ..; i -';L �:::,�f('(".;'; hJrl;-,>:iJ1.>/ljr.:,,; <:{':)l
00- -
.{ ,
178
\
w
,
"4�."�"" :,(;"�, ,:=
,, " " ��20
DR"'"
, ,
' ' . r·_',
.
"
PISTON '''--..1
[,
.-<i BE'"
�-l"''',", "'-lOWS
' "
. ,; ,
'
115TON, CYLUf()[ft
.
"
I '. ' .
"
"
. j '
DRIVE.
essentially, of two opposing forces, maintaining a piston transducer (Tl:r-lA to 10, Fig. 9) located on the furnace
position tllat depends upon the magnitude of the forces instrument board (Fig. 5). The operation of this instru
(Fig. 8). The positioner is balanced when the force ex ment has been'described in the section "Control of
erted upward on a balance beam by bellows is equalled Furnace Draft". The output air signals from these four
by a force exerted downward by the positioning spring. instruments, each varying proportionally with the changes
The force exerted by the positioning spring is modified ' sensed by its thermocouple are piped to
in temperatures
by the location of the piston in the cylinder through a three High Pressure Selector Relays (RIa to RIc. Fig. 9).
lever, gear and cam arrangement. When the forces exerted These select the highest pressure air signal from the
by the bellows and by the spring are in balance, the four transducers and thus signal the highest temperature
balance beam holds the pilot valve in its "neutral" posi sensed by any of the four thermocouples in the cooled gas
tion; the pressures on either side of the piston are then stream. .
equal and the piston is held in position. A change in Th� High Pressure Selector R� la); functions as fol
pressure in the "Slave Draft" control output air signal lows (Fig. 10). The two input pressures apply their re
will thus cause the fan speed to change until balance is spective forces on opposite sides 'of a neoprene dia
again restored. phragm. The higher of tbese pressures Causes the dia
B. Conlrol of Flue Gas Temperalure. The control phragm to cap the output nozzle of tbe lower pressure
system is arranged to admit cooling air first. As the de line. This leaves the higher pressure directly connected
mand for cooling increases beyond what can be provided to the output port and seals off the I �wer pressure input
source. , .
by the, cooling air, the three banks of water sprays are . _
successively activated. The automatic system controlling The selected air signal is transmitted to the coqling
the cooling process is shown diagrammatically in Fig. 9 chamber recording controller. This Proportional Air
and operates as follows. Operated Free-Vane Controller has been described in the
Four thermocouples are installed in the inlet flue in preceding section. It records_the highest of the four
front of each of the four louver dampers of each dust sensed temperatures of the cooled flue gas on a circular
collector as described above (Fig. 3). Each of the four chart. It also supplies an output air signal varying in '
thermocouples is wired to an indicating potentiometer pressure proportionally with the gas temperature.
•
179
'
merit to the bellows which is in proportion to the pressure
",of the signal. This movement is transmitted to the pilot
" valve'through lever (H). As the operator responds to the
change in air pressure over the diaphragm, valve stem
(AE) moves. This motion is transmitted through levers
(AC) (BB) and (Q) to the floating lever (H) through the
adjustable pin (J) and lever (Z). This Jatter movement of
lever (H) readjusts the position of the pilot valve until
equilibrium is re-established and the control system is
stabilized. The operator stem is directly connected to
the air inlet louver by a linkage system.
'< '
Acknowledgment'
,�.
, '
.,
The following equipment is activated by the output
signal from the cooling chamber recording controller:
1) One mercoid switch (Fig. 9) which starts the
,
("
cooling air aspirator fan when the air signal reaches ,
"
2 psi pressure. The fan remains in operation as long as
the air signal pressure does not go below 2 psi.
2) Two positioners and damper operators (DOl and
D02, Fig. 9). The louver dampers begin opening at 3 psi
and are fully opened at 9 psi. The method of operation
of this equipment is discussed below.
3), Three mercoid switches (PS2, PS3 and PS4, Fig. 9)
each connected to a solenoid valve (S. Fig. 9) controlling
a bank of cooling water nozzles. These are activated
successively as the air signal pressure increases above
9 psi pressure.
The damper operating mechanisms each consist of two
units, the positioner and the operator. They operate in
the following manner (see Fig. 11).
,-,-
Power air at 15 psi is let through pipe (R) to pilot
valve (00) which controls the flow through pipe (AX) to
the diaphragm of the operator. The pilot valve is operated
by spti�g (TT) and the movement of floating lever (H)
, -.
'
180
...,