Criteria 4 3 2 1 Exceeds Meets Standards Needs Does not meet Standards Improvement standards Main Idea -The main idea -The main idea is -The main -The main Topic is strong. adequate. idea/topic idea/topic Sentence sentence is sentence is -The topic -The topic unclear. unclear. sentence is sentence is clear. restated in the -The topic -The topic closing sentence. sentence is sentence is not –The topic weakly restated restated in the sentence is in the closing closing sentence. restated in the sentence. closing sentence. Supporting -Each paragraph -Each paragraph -Each paragraph -Each paragraph Details has 3 or more has 2 supporting has 1 supporting has no supporting supporting details that relate detail that relates details that relate details that to the main idea. to the main idea. to the main idea. relate to the main idea. Basic -There are few, -There are -There are many -There are many Writing if any several errors in errors in errors in Convention punctuation, punctuation, punctuation, punctuation, s capitalization, spelling, and/or spelling and/or spelling, and/or and spelling grammar that do grammar that grammar that errors. not interfere with interferes with make the piece meaning. meaning. illegible. Neatness -The piece is -The piece is -There are 3-4 -There are 5 or legibly hand legibly hand distracting errors more distracting written or typed. written or typed. that make errors that make portions difficult the piece illegible. -There are no -There are 1-2 to read distracting distracting errors. errors.