Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. Introduction
Porous media combustion has some unique characteristics. It is
totally different from conventional combustion devices; it gives rise
to high radiant output, low NOX and CO emissions, high power
density and modulation. The difference between combustion in
porous medium (PM) and a conventional system arises because of
better and more efficient heat transfer from burned gases to
unburned mixture. In a conventional combustion system, convection
is the dominating mode of heat transfer (since gases have very low
thermal conductivity and are less participating in radiation) from the
burned to the unburned. On other hand, in porous media
combustion, the conduction and radiation mode of heat transfer are
also significant. In addition, the convection heat transfer is also
improved, because ofincreased surface area within the porous
matrix. There is better homogenization of temperature across the
porous matrix and a presence of a significant amount of radiation
help to preheat the incoming air-fuel mixture upstream, thereby
Fig. 1.Schematic diagram of two layer porous burner.
improving the combustion efficiency. Fig. 1 is the schematic of a
media is desirable. A brief account of some basic parameters is
two-layered porous burner. In order to have better control over
presented as follows.
flame stabilization, PM burners are constructed with two different
1.3.1. Peclet number
materials, forming two zones. The first is the preheating zone, made
The modified Peclet number Pe is the deciding factor to specify the
of low porosity and less conducting materials and the second is the
combustion region. If the Peclet number less than 65, the flame is
combustion zone, made of highly radiating and conducting
unable to propagate and quenching occurs. Alternatively, for Peclet
materials. The pore size is also large in combustion zone. The
number greater than or equal to 65 flame propagates. The modified
reason for choosing a material of low thermal conductivity and
Peclet number is defined as,
small porosity in preheating zone is to avoid combustion and the 𝑆𝑙 𝑑 𝜌 𝐶𝑝
resultingflashback. Proper selection of porous material (both for Pe = (1)
𝑘
preheat and combustion zone) allows thecombustion start at the Where Sl is the laminar flame speed, d is the equivalent diameter of
interface of two zoneand spread over the entire volume of the the average hollow space of the porous material, Cp is the specific
combustion zone. heat of the gas mixture, k is the thermal conductivity coefficient of
1.2. Combustion in porous media the gas mixture.
When compared to conventional free flame burners, the novel 1.3.2. Equivalence ratio
porous burners present several advantage. There principle of The equivalence ratio is defined as the ratio of the actual fuel/air
operation is based on the fact that combustion takes place inside a ratio to the stoichiometric fuel/air ratio. Stoichiometric combustion
solid matrix of open cavities big enough to sustain combustion, the occurs when all the oxygen is consumed in the reaction, and there is
porous medium. It is the presence of the porous medium that offers no molecular oxygen (O2) in the products. If the equivalence ratio is
the advantage to PMC. The most common porous burner work with equal to one, the combustion is stoichiometric. If it is <1, the
a steady, premixed flames. In this case, a mixture of fuel and combustion is lean with excess air, and if it is >1, the combustion is
oxidant enters the solid porous matrix where they burn, forming the rich with incomplete combustion.
combustion products that leave the porous matrix on the other side. 1.3.3. Turn-down ratio (TDR)
The thermal energy released during the combustion process heat by It is the measure of the capability of a burner to modulate through
convection the solid matrix that subsequently radiates and conducts a firing range or it is the measure of flame stability of a burner and
heat up stream. As a consequence, the incoming fuel and oxidant are is defined as the ratio of maximum firing rate to minimum firing
preheated. rate of a burner. Typical values of TDR for industrial heating
1.3. Governing parameters operations are in the range of 3:1 to 6:1.
When dealing with this topic, knowledge of some parameters that 1.3.4. Optical thickness (OT)
influence the performance of liquid fuel combustion in porous Defined as the product of refractive index (n) and thickness (t), i.e.
*Corresponding Author, OT = nt
E-mail address:viju180193@gmail.com; Refractive index (n) of a medium is the ratio of the velocity of
Phone No--+91-9056310975 propagation of an electromagnetic wave in vacuum to its velocity in
All rights reserved: http://www.ijari.org the medium.
2. Literature review
122
IJARI
Volume 5, Issue 1 (2017) 122-126 ISSN 2347 - 3258
International Journal of Advance Research and Innovation
Jugjai and Sanitjai (1996). By utilization of porous medium from the hot combustion products to the combustion air resulted an
technology, new design for conventional open flame gas burner is efficiency increase of 12% further efficiency improvements are
made to increase the thermal efficiency of standard burner up to obtained when the burner presented in Fig. 3 is combined with a
10%. The modified design called Porous radiant recirculated burner swirling central flame technique. In this case slightly higher CO and
which uses porous media to transfer some of the hot gas enthalpy to NOX emission are observed.
premixed mixture. Unlike the porous burners described in the
previous section, the PRRB does not operate by stabilizing the
flame inside the porous medium. Instead, its flame is a free-flame
and the porous medium only promotes the heat recirculation from
the exhaust gas to the mixture of fuel and air. Fig. 2 shows the
proposed heat recirculating burner.
With the use of swirling central flame burner the heat transfer Fig. 5.SPMB developed by Yoksenakul and Jugjai (2011).
coefficient between hot flue gas and vessel increases thus thermal Patangi et al. (2011) deals with the performance test of PRB (porous
efficiency increases up to 15% compared to conventional radial radiant burner) used for LPG domestic cooking stove unlike the
flow burner. conventional LPG stoves for which the CO and NOX emissions
Jugjai and Rungsimuntuchart (2002). A novel semi-confined porous were found in the range 400-1050 mg/m3 and 162-116 mg/m3
radiant recirculated burner (PRRB) concept based on heat- respectively for the burn with PRB, the same burn in the range of
recirculating combustion using the porous medium technology was 25-350 mg/m3 and 12-25 mg/m3. The axial temperature distribution
developed for energy saving in domestic use and in a small-scale inthe burnershow that the reaction zone was close to the interface of
food processing industry. The proposed PRRB (SB) provide the thetwo zone and at a higher thermal load, it shifted towards the
maximum thermal efficiency of 60% with improvement in energy downstream. The surface temperature of the PRB was found to be
saving as well as environmentally compatible emissions. It can be uniform.
applied in the small-scale food processing industry. The design Makmool et al. (2007) cooker-top burner performance survey and
concept is similar in the two papers and a picture of the developed an implementation of a PIV technique to analyze the burner
burner .The use of porous media to promote the recirculation of heat performance as well as advising local manufacturers were carried
123
IJARI
Volume 5, Issue 1 (2017) 122-126 ISSN 2347 - 3258
International Journal of Advance Research and Innovation
out. The thermal performance parameters and dynamic properties of possible since all testing conditions details in the papers). The CO
the flow field at a flame impingement area, i.e. velocity magnitude, and NOX obtained with the newly developed porous burner were
turbulent intensity, vorticity and strain rate were also reported as a lower than that reported for conventional burner.
function of burner type which are radial flow burner, swirling flow In a different study Muthukumar et al. (2011) tested a similar LPG
burners, vertical flow burners and porous radiant burners. porous radiant burner. The diameter of the burner was equal to the
Kakati et al. (2007) incorporated porous medium inserts in a one that presented better efficiency in pantangi et al studies (2011).
conventional high pressure kerosene stove. The burners with or The combustion zone as the same characteristics; however, the
without porous materials were used for the study in terms of thermal preheating zone is now composed of a ceramic block of 10 mm
efficiency, kerosene consumption rate and emissions. The overall thickness and 40% porosity. Also the operating condition tested
decrease in fuel consumption was found to be 34% with 10-11% were different, since the equivalent ratio tested were significantly
increase in thermal efficiency. higher and the ambient temperature different. A maximumthermal
Pantangi et al. (2007) the performance of a LPG cooking stove by efficiency of 71% was obtained which is above the efficiency of
removing the head of the conventional burner and filled it with conventional LPG burners. Efficiency was obtained for an
different porous media thus forming the two-layer porous burner. equivalence ratio of 0.68, 1.24 KW power intensity at 31 0C ambient
The preheating zone consists of small pores porous burner while temperature. From a comparison of pantangi et al. (2011) result
combustion zone consists of large pores porous medium.In some of with those of Muthukumar et al. (2011), one can conclude that it is
the experiments, Pantangi et al. (2007). Insulated the bottom base better to use a ceramic block if 10 mm thickness and 40% porosity
and side of the mixing chamber using ceramic whool in order to as preheating layer than 5 mm diameter alumina balls forming a
minimize the heat losses and reduce the distance between the top porous media with 12- 15 mm thickness.
surface of the mixing surface and the bottom surface of the pan. As In their work, Muthukumar et al. (2011) investigated the influence
an example, Fig. 6 shows one of converted LPG cooking stoves, of the ambient temperature on the thermal efficiency of the porous
where 3 to 4mm diameter pebbles were used in the preheating layer burner and concluded that for the same operating conditions, and
and mild steel chips in the combustion zone. efficiency improvement of 10% was achieved for varying the
ambient temperature from 18.5 to 350C therefore when comparing
the thermal efficiency of the burners the ambient temperature is the
parameter that has to be taken into account.
In a recent study, Muthukumar and sham kumar (2013) extended
pantangi et al.’s (2011) and Muthukumar et al.’s (2011) works.
They tested the performance of a two layer porous burner see Fig 7.
In this case, the diameter of the porous matrices was chosen to be
120 mm. like in Muthukumar et al. (2011) the preheating zone
consists of ceramic matrix with 40% porosity and a thickness of
10mm and a combustion zone a Sic zone with a thickness of 20mm.
however, in this steady the porosity of the SiC was vary from 80 to
90 %. The thermal efficiency and CO and NOX emissions were
experimentally obtained for equivalent ratios and power ranging
from 0.542 to 0.7 and 1.3 to 1.7 KW, respectively.
124
IJARI
Volume 5, Issue 1 (2017) 122-126 ISSN 2347 - 3258
International Journal of Advance Research and Innovation
experimental test prove that the porous burner is more efficient and
less pollutant than the correspondent commercial LPG cooking
stoves. The author demonstrated that thermal efficiencies decreased
with an increase in thermal load.
125
IJARI
Volume 5, Issue 1 (2017) 122-126 ISSN 2347 - 3258
International Journal of Advance Research and Innovation
specific heat input rate lower than 154kW/m2, the upper and lower [11.] MA Mujeebu, MZ Abdullah, MZ Abu Bakar, AA Mohamad,
equivalence ratio on the stability limit follow approximately a linear MK Abdullah. Combustion in porous media and its applications –
trend, as well as the wide of the range of stability remains constant. A comprehensive survey. Journal of Environmental Management,
M. Sharma et al. (2016). The concept of PMC has been employed 90(8), 2009, 2287-2312.
in kerosene pressure stove to investigate the efficiency and
[12.] Namkhat, S Jugjai. Primary air entrainment characteristics for a
emissions. Further the condition of optimum efficiency and
emissions are find out with different burner geometry. It is found self-aspirating burner: Model and experiments. Energy 35, 2010,
that the highest efficiency of the stove with porous media is found to 1701-1708.
be 10% higher than stove available in Indian market. [13.] MA Mujeebu, MZ Abdullah, MZ Abu Bakar, AA Mohamad. A
1. By use of different porous material to find out the thermal Mesoscale premixed LPG burner with surface combustion in
efficiency. porous ceramic foam. Energy Sources, Part A: Recovery,
2. Varying the size and shape of porous material. Utilization and Environmental Effects, 34(1), 2011, 9-18.
3. Use different fuel to compare the thermal efficiency. [14.] MA Mujeebu, MZ Abdullah, MZ Abu Bakar, AA Mohamad.
4. New design of burner. Development of premixed burner based on stabilized combustion
3. Conclusions within discrete porous medium. Journal of Porous Media, 14(10),
Porous burners are one of the possible available technologies for the 2011, 909-917.
development of energy efficient and eco-friendly household [15.] MA Mujeebu, MZ Abdullah, MZ Abu Bakar, AA Mohamad.
appliances. The low emissions and high efficiency that characterize Development of energy efficient porous medium burners on
porous media combustion are by now well established; however, surface and submerged combustion modes. Energy, 36(8), 2011,
practical studies that focus on household applications of this 5132-5139.
technology are not so common, even though large possibilities of [16.] P Muthukumar, P Anand, P Sachdeva. Performance analysis of
improvement of such systems exist. This paper reviews the studies porous radiant burner used in LPG cooking stove. International
dedicated to the development of porous burners for cooking. Journal of Energy and Environment, 2(2), 2011, 367-374.
The literature review presented in this paper shows that there is
considerable scope for the development of enhanced porous burners [17.] VK Pantangi, SC Mishra, P Muthukumar, R Reddy. Studies on
for household applications. The effects of fuel type, burner porous radiant burner foe LPG (liquefied petroleum gas) cooking
geometry and size, porous media materials and structures and applications. Energy, 36(10), 2011, 6074-6080.
catalytic combustion are yet to be thoroughly explored as far as [18.] M Sharma, SC Mishra, P Mahanta. An experimental investigation
porous burners for household applications are concerned. on efficiency improvement of a conventional kerosene pressure
References stove. International Journal of Energy for a Clean Environment,
[1.] S Jugjai, S Sanitjai. Parametric studies of thermal efficiency in a 12(1), 2011, 79-93.
proposed porous radiant re-circulated burner (PRRB): a design [19.] W Yoksenakul, S Jugjai. Design and development of a SPMB
concept for the future burner. RERIC International Energy (self-aspirating, porous medium burner) with a submerged flame.
Journal, 18(2), 1986, 97-111. Energy, 36(5), 2011, 3092-3100.
[2.] Malico, JCF Pereira. Numerical prediction of porous burner with [20.] K Ismail, MJ Abdulla. Application of porous medium burner
integrated heat exchanger for household applications. Journal of with micro cogeneration system. Energy 50, 2013, 131-142.
Porous Media, 2(2), 1999, 153-162. [21.] P Muthukumar, Shyamkumar. Development of novel porous
[3.] SJugjai, STia, W Trewetasksorn. Thermal efficiency improvement radiant burners for LPG cooking applications. Fuel, 112, 2013,
of an LPG gas cooker by a swirling central flame. International 562-566.
Journal of Energy Research, 25(8), 2001, 657-674. [22.] CY Wu, KH Chen, SY Yang. Experimental study of porous
[4.] S. Jugjai, N Rungsimuntuchart. High efficiency heat-recirculating metal burners for domestic stove applications. Energy
domestic gas burner. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science, Conservation and Management, 77, 2014, 380-388.
26(5), 2002, 581-592. [23.] S Panigrahy, Niraj Kumar Mishra, Subash C Mishra, P
[5.] Thomas Fend, Bernhard Hoffschmidt. Experimental determination Muthukumar. Numerical and experimental analysis of LPG
of thermo physical and heat transfer properties. Energy 29, 2003, combustion in a domestic cooking stove with a porous radiant
823-833. burner. Energy 95, 2016, 404-414.
[6.] S Kakati, P Mahanta, SK Kakoty. Performance analysis of [24.] L Eral. Performance study of an induced air porous radiant
pressurized kerosene stove with porous medium inserts. Journal of burner for household application at high altitude. Applied thermal
Scientific and Industrial Research, 66(7), 2007, 565-569. energy 83, 2015, 31-39.
[7.] U Makmool, S Jugjai, S Tia, P Vallikul, B Fungtammasan. [25.] B Herrera, K Cacua, L Olmos-Villalba. Combustion stability
Performance and analysis by particle image velocimetry (PIV) of and thermal efficiency in a porous media burner for LPG cooking
cooker-top burners in Thailand. Energy, 32(10), 2007, 1986-1995. in the food industry using AL2O3 particles coming from grinding
[8.] S Wood, AT Harris. Porous burners for lean-burn applications. wastes. doi:10.1016/j.applthermaleng.2015.08.079.
Progress in Energy and Combustion Science, 34(5), 2008, 667- [26.] M. Sharma. Usability of porous burner in kerosene pressure
684. stove: An experimental investigation aided by energy and exergy
[9.] MA Mujeebu, MZ Abdullah, MZ Abu Bakar, AA Mohamad, M K analysis. Energy 103, 2016, 251-260.
Abdullah. A review of investigations on liquid fuel combustion in
porous inert media. Progress in Energy and Combustion Science,
35(2), 2009, 216-230.
[10.] MA Mujeebu, MZ Abdullah, MZ Abu Bakar, AA Mohamad, M
K Abdullah. Application of porous media combustion technology
– A review. Applied Energy, 86(9), 2009, 1365-1375.
126
IJARI