Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Bronze to Iron Age briquetage found in the northern Mekong Delta has an appearance similar to anal-
Received 12 March 2008 ogous material from Europe and Asia; however, the orientation in which the briquetage was employed
Received in revised form 14 July 2008 during the production of salt is still under debate. As a consequence of the heating and subsequent
Accepted 24 July 2008
cooling of the briquetage during the evaporative recovery of salt, the magnetic mineral particles within
the ceramic formed a stable thermoremanent magnetization in alignment with the Earth’s magnetic
Keywords:
field. It thus becomes possible to find the orientation in which the ceramics were last fired by aligning
Salt production
their recorded archaeomagnetic signal with estimates of the Earth’s ancient field direction in Vietnam.
Briquetage
Archaeomagnetism The archaeomagnetic directions obtained from 22 samples taken from five different briquetage artefacts
Vietnam are somewhat scattered, but they reveal a consistent orientation and thus the mode in which the bri-
quetage was employed can be reconstructed.
Ó 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction for example in the Halle/Saale area of Germany and the Moselle
basin in France (Alexander, 1982). With the commencement of the
The Vietnamese archaeological site of Gò Ô Chùa is situated in Iron Age the importance of these large inland salt-production
the north-eastern Mekong Delta, close to the border with Cambodia centres seems to have declined as a result of the establishment of
(11000 N, 105 460 E; Long An province; Fig. 1). The site consists of various coastal sites where salt was extracted from sea water
three northeast-southwest directed hilly structures that rise up to (Alexander, 1982). Many salt-production sites along the southern
4 m above the ground, which itself has an elevation of w1.8 m and eastern coast of England have been dated to this period, with
above modern sea level. During the first excavation in 1997 and larger complexes in Hampshire (Cunliffe, 1984), Essex (deBrisay,
subsequent campaigns a large quantity of pottery sherds and baked 1974), and Lincolnshire (Baker, 1974). Furthermore, sea salt
material was found (Reinecke and Nguyen, 2008). The main portion production is reported from the coasts of France (Tessier, 1974) and
of the ceramic remains has been identified as briquetage (a term Belgium (Thoen, 1974). In addition to these smaller, wide spread
that describes the pottery used for salt production). The briquetage coastal sites, new inland salt-production sites such as Haute Seille
was recovered from cultural layers that have been radiocarbon in France and Schwaebisch Hall in Germany were also active during
dated between 2900–2200 cal yrs BP, classifying the settlement as the Iron Age (Olivier and Kovacik, 2006).
late Bronze to early Iron Age (Reinecke and Nguyen, 2008). At the In contrast to this well documented European activity there are
present time this specific, briquetage producing culture from the few Bronze to Iron Age salt-production areas known in Asia.
Mekong Delta has no formal name and is simply referred to here as Localized exploitation of brine springs including the heating of the
‘‘pre-Funan’’ (Funan: the first state established in the greater brine to drive evaporation is reported from Zhongba (central China)
Mekong Delta region in the early centuries AD (Higham, 2002)). where salt production during the Neolithic and Bronze Age was the
Briquetage from the Bronze and Iron Age has been identified at key to the development of the Upper Yangtze region (Flad et al.,
a number of archaeological sites particularly in Europe. Large-scale 2005; Flad, 2007). Along the coast of the Yellow Sea settlers in the
salt production in the Bronze Age was based on two main tech- region of Shandong were producing sea salt since the Late Shang
niques, the mining of stone salt, in the Hallstatt area of Austria for phase (1250–1046 BC) (Underhill et al., 2008). Furthermore,
example, or the refinement of brine gathered from saline springs, ancient salt production including the heating of the brine is
described from various locations along the shores of Japan (Kondo,
1974). Hence, the discovery of Gò Ô Chùa and its identification as
* Corresponding author. a large-scale salt-production area is an important contribution to
E-mail address: uproske@uni-bremen.de (U. Proske). our understanding of the history of salt production in Asia.
0305-4403/$ – see front matter Ó 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jas.2008.07.012
U. Proske et al. / Journal of Archaeological Science 36 (2009) 84–89 85
Fig. 2. Example of the briquetage found at Gò Ô Chùa. The pottery is approximately
25 cm high and 12 cm wide at the cup-shaped end.
Fig. 5. Reconstructed palaeoinclinations from the CALS7K.2 global field model for the calibrated 2s radiocarbon age range of the Gò Ô Chùa site (2900–2200 cal yrs BP). The mean
model inclination during this time interval is 12 3.3 , which is shallower than the inclination of 21 expected for a geocentric axial dipole.
U. Proske et al. / Journal of Archaeological Science 36 (2009) 84–89 87
Fig. 6. (a) NRM magnitude, M, normalized by its initial value, M0, as a function of peak demagnetizing field for the 22 briquetage samples. The black line corresponds to the sample
whose demagnetization is plotted in the orthogonal plot in (b). The orthogonal plot reveals a univectorial remanence decaying towards the origin after the removal of a weak
viscous component. Solid and open symbols denote projections onto the horizontal and vertical planes, respectively, and numbers next to the data points represent the peak AF
values in mT.
88 U. Proske et al. / Journal of Archaeological Science 36 (2009) 84–89
Fig. 7. (a) Normalized hysteresis loops (divided by the saturation magnetization, Ms) for magnetite-rich (solid line) and hematite-rich briquetage (dashed line) samples; note the
strongly wasp-waisted form of the latter which is indicative of a mixed magnetic assemblage containing both low and high coercivity minerals. (b) Normalized IRM acquisition
(divided by the saturation IRM, SIRM) curves for the same samples as shown in the first panel, the low coercivity magnetite-rich sample (solid line) is almost saturated at a field of
0.1 T, in contrast the second sample (dashed line) shows a strong change in slope as the magnetite component saturates and acquisition commences in the hematite component.
Based on these observations a modified form of the S-ratio is calculated comparing the magnitudes of the remanences formed at 0.1 T (IRM0.1) and 0.3 T (IRM0.3).
The IRM acquisition curves of typical magnetite-rich and The univectorial nature of the ChRM indicates that any rema-
hematite-rich briquetage samples show the shift from IRM nence formed during the manufacture of the briquetage, either
acquisition in magnetite to acquisition in hematite as a change in during natural drying or initial firing, has been erased by subse-
slope at w0.1 T (Fig. 7b). Based on this observation the rema- quent heating during routine use. Thus the ChRM direction corre-
nences selected for the S-ratio determination were those formed sponds to the orientation of the briquetage artifacts with respect to
at 0.1 T (IRM0.1) and 0.3 T (IRM0.3). S-Ratios close to a value of 1 the field on the last occasion on which they were employed during
indicate a mineralogy dominated by magnetite and decreasing the salt-production process.
numbers demonstrate an increasing contribution from hematite. The ChRM inclination angles determined from the 22 samples of
A plot of the S-ratio versus the MDF of the NRM reveals a statis- briquetage are surprisingly scattered (Table 1 and Fig. 9), but do
tically significant negative correlation (Fig. 8), demonstrating that reveal a consistent pattern with 21 normal directions and a single
as hematite abundance increases the NRM becomes harder to reversed direction (considered to be simply part of the natural
demagnetize. dispersion). Using circular statistics (de Sa, 2003) it was found that
When displayed in orthogonal plots (Zijderveld, 1967), the the mean inclination for all 22 samples is 27 with a standard
stepwise AF demagnetization procedure revealed that all of the deviation of 21.6 . Given the very clear demagnetization charac-
samples carried a small viscous remanent magnetization, which teristics of the individual samples it is apparent that the dispersion
was fully removed by the 20 mT treatment, Fig. 5b. Subsequent in inclinations does not originate simply from noise in the rema-
demagnetization to higher fields yielded univectorial remanences nence measurements. Intriguingly, a comparable archaeomagnetic
heading towards the origin, from which the characteristic rema- analysis of British briquetage also produced highly scattered indi-
nent magnetization (ChRM) and its maximum angular deviation vidual palaeoinclinations, but yielded a reasonable mean direction
(MAD) could be quantified using principal component analysis over the sample set as a whole (Borradaile et al., 1999).
(Kirschvink, 1980). It is important to keep in mind that because the We believe that the scatter in the determined inclinations may
samples were not orientated with respect to the horizontal, only originate from a number of different sources, the first of which
the inclination component of the recovered ChRM is meaningful. stems from the difficulty in obtaining accurately orientated
samples from the briquetage, however, orientation errors are only
expected to be in the range of 5 . Second, shape effects due to the
irregular form of the individual samples will result in an inhomo-
geneity of magnetization within the measurement space of the
magnetometer. These shape effects are, however, expected to be
random within the sample set and therefore will only act to
increase the scatter of the measured directions without causing
a systematic offset in the mean inclination (Collinson, 1983).
Thirdly, anisotropy resulting from a preferred alignment of the
magnetic particles in the briquetage matrix can produce TRMs
which are not exactly parallel with the ambient field during heating
(Rogers et al., 1979). In a previous archaeomagnetic study of British
briquetage, magnetic anisotropy was considered to be a possible
cause of the large scatter in measured inclination values (Borradaile
et al., 1999). Finally it is to be expected that the briquetage artefacts
were not heated in a perfectly vertical orientation, for example due
to uneven ground (Borradaile et al., 1999).
Bloemendal, J., King, J.W., Hall, F.R., Doh, S.-J., 1992. Rock magnetism of Late
Neogene and Pleistocene deep-sea sediments: relationship to sediment source,
diagenetic processes and sediment lithology. Journal of Geophysical Research
97, 4361–4375.
Borradaile, G.J., Lagroix, F., Maher, L., Stewart, J.D., 1999. Attempts to date salt-
making activity in Iron Age Britain using magnetic inclinations. Journal of
Archaeological Science 26, 1377–1389.
Collinson, D.W., 1983. Methods in Rock Magnetism and Palaeomagnetism: Tech-
niques and Instrumentation. Chapman and Hall, London.
Cui, Y., Verosub, K.L., 1995. A mineral magnetic study of some pottery samples:
possible implications for sample selection in archaeointensity studies. Physics
of the Earth and Planetary Interiors 91, 261–271.
Cunliffe, B., 1984. The Excavations 1969–1978. In: Danebury: an Iron Age Hillfort in
Hampshire, vol. 2. Council for British Archaeology, London. 564.
deBrisay, K., 1974. The Red Hills of Essex. In: Salt: the Study of an Ancient Industry;
Report on the Salt Weekend Held at the University of Essex, Essex. Colchester
Archaeological Group, pp. 5–11.
Fawn, A.J., Evans, K.A., McMaster, I., Davies, G.M.R., 1990. The Red Hills of Essex, Salt
Making in Antiquity. Colchester Archaeological Group, Norfolk.
Fig. 9. (a) Expected field inclinations for the Gò Ô Chùa site based on a GAD (dashed Flad, R., Zhu, J., Wang, C., Chen, P., Falkenhausen, L., Sun, Z., Li, S., 2005. Archaeo-
arrow) and the CALS7K field model (solid arrow with shading representing 1 circular logical and chemical evidence for early salt production in China. Proceedings of
standard deviation). (b) Inclination values (circular symbols) obtained from the ChRM the National Academy of Sciences 102 (35), 12618–12622.
determinations of the Gò Ô Chùa briquetage. Inclinations greater than 0 indicate that Flad, R., 2007. Rethinking the context of production through an archaeological study
the briquetage was employed in the orientation designated as ‘‘A’’ in Fig. 4, whilst of ancient salt production in the Sichuan Basin, China. Archaeological Papers of
inclinations less than 0 would indicate orientation ‘‘B’’ was used. The mean inclination the American Anthropological Association 17 (1), 108–128.
of the sample set is given by the arrow (with shading representing 1 circular stan- Gouletquer, P.L., 1974. Niger, country of salt. In: Salt: the Study of an Ancient
Industry; Report on the Salt Weekend Held at the University of Essex, Essex.
dard deviation), the length of the arrow representing the resultant magnitude of the
Colchester Archaeological Group, pp. 47–51.
mean direction.
Higham, C., 2002. Early Cultures of Mainland Southeast Asia. River Books Ltd.,
Bangkok.
achieved even given the scatter in the values. To support this Kirschvink, J.L., 1980. The least-squares line and plane and the analysis of
palaeomagnetic data. Geophysical Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society
suggestion we consider a hypothetical situation where the bri- 62, 699–718.
quetage specimens carry no meaningful directional information Kleinmann, D., 1974. The salt springs of the Saale valley. In: Salt: the Study of an
and the chances of obtaining a positive or negative inclination from Ancient Industry; Report on the Salt Weekend Held at the University of Essex,
Essex. Colchester Archaeological Group, pp. 45–46.
a given sub-sample are identical. Under such a scenario the prob- Kondo, Y., 1974. The salt industry in ancient Japan. In: Salt: the Study of an Ancient
ability of obtaining 21 or more samples out of 22 which all showed Industry; Report on the Salt Weekend Held at the University of Essex, Essex.
inclinations with the same sign is w0.001% (value derived from Colchester Archaeological Group, pp. 61–65.
Korte, M., Constable, C.G., 2005. Continuous geomagnetic field models for the past 7
a binomial distribution). Such a low probability indicates that our millennia: 2. CALS7K. Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems 6 (2), doi:10.1029/
data set must contain coherent directional information at least at 2004GC000801.
the level of the sign of the inclination (which is all that is necessary Korte, M., Constable, C.G., Genevey, A., Frank, U., Schnepp, E., 2005. Continuous
geomagnetic field models for the past 7 millennia: 1. A new global data
to reconstruct the up-down orientation of the briquetage).
compilation. Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems 6 (2), doi:10.1029/
This mean inclination from the samples (27 ) is slightly steeper 2004GC000800.
than the values expected from a GAD (21 ) or the CALS7K field Merrill, R.T., McElhinny, M.W., Mcfadden, P.L., 1998. The Magnetic Field of the Earth:
Paleomagnetism, the Core and the Deep Mantle. Academic Press Inc.
model (12 ), but indicates clearly that the briquetage specimens
Nishimura, M., 2003. A minor excavation at Co Son Tu in the upper Vam Co
were last fired in an orientation similar to that shown as Orientation Tay River, Long An, Vietnam. Journal of Southeast Asian Archaeology 23,
A in Fig. 4. This orientation of the pedestals with the finger-like 113–142.
protrusions to the top has been observed in the context of modern Olivier, L., Kovacik, J., 2006. The ‘Briquetage de la Seille’ (Lorraine, France): proto-
industrial salt production in the European Iron Age. Antiquity 80, 558–566.
salt production in Niger (Gouletquer, 1974) and thus seems to be Reinecke, A., Nguyen, T.T.L., 2008. ‘‘Salz so weiß wie Schnee’’ – Auf den Spuren
a convenient shape to employ in salt production. früher Salzsieder in Südvietnam. Archäologie in Deutschland 3, 12–17.
Roberts, A.P., Cui, Y., Verosub, K.L., 1995. Wasp-waisted hysteresis loops: mineral
magnetic characteristics and discrimination of components in mixed magnetic
Acknowledgements systems. Journal of Geophysical Research 100, 17909–17924.
Rogers, J., Fox, J.M.W., Aitken, M.J., 1979. Magnetic anisotropy in ancient pottery.
Nature 277, 644–646.
We would like to thank Andreas Reinecke, the corresponding de Sa, J.P.M., 2003. Applied Statistics Using SPSS, Statistica and Matlab. Springer-
archaeologist from the Deutsches Archäologisches Institut Bonn for Verlag, Berlin.
Tessier, M., 1974. The protohistoric salt making sites of the Pays de Retz, France.
the supply of briquetage and information. Furthermore we thank In: Salt: the Study of an Ancient Industry; Report on the Salt Weekend
Mr. Diem from the Archaeological Museum of Long An as our Held at the University of Essex, Essex. Colchester Archaeological Group,
partner archaeologist in Vietnam. We are grateful to two anony- pp. 52–56.
Thoen, H., 1974. Iron Age & Roman salt-making sites on the Belgian coast. In:
mous reviewers whose constructive comments helped to improve Salt: the Study of an Ancient Industry; Report on the Salt Weekend
the manuscript. This study is part of DFG project HA4317\2-1. Held at the University of Essex, Essex. Colchester Archaeological Group,
pp. 56–60.
Underhill, A.P., Feinman, G.M., Nicholas, L.M., Fang, H., Luan, F., Yu, H., Cai, F., 2008.
References Changes in regional settlement patterns and the development of complex
societies in southeastern Shandong, China. Journal of Anthropological Archae-
Alexander, J., 1982. The prehistoric salt trade in Europe. Nature 300, 577–578. ology 27, 1–29.
Baker, F.T., 1974. Salt making sites on the Lincolnshire coast before the Romans. In: Zijderveld, J.D.A., 1967. A.C. demagnetization of rocks: analysis of results. In:
Salt: the Study of an Ancient Industry; Report on the Salt Weekend Held at the Collinson, D.W., Creer, K.M., Runcorn, S.K. (Eds.), Methods in Palaeomagnetism.
University of Essex, Essex. Colchester Archaeological Group, pp. 31–32. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 254–286.