Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: The bending strength, stiffness and energy absorption of corrugated sandwich composite structure were
Received 7 March 2013 investigated to explore novel designs of lightweight load-bearing structures that are capable of energy
Accepted 7 May 2013 absorption in transportation vehicles. Key design parameters that were considered include fibre type,
Available online 18 May 2013
corrugation angle, core-sheet thickness, bond length between core and face-sheets, and foam inserts.
The results revealed that the hybridization of glass fibres and carbon fibres (50:50) in face-sheets was
Keywords: able to achieve the equivalent specific bending strength as the facet-sheets made entirely of carbon fibre
Corrugated sandwich structure
composites. Increasing the corrugation angle and the core sheet thickness improved the specific bending
Hybrid composite
Bending
strength of the sandwich structure, while increasing the bond length led to a reduction in the specific
Energy absorption bending strength. The hybrid composite coupons with foam insertion showed medium energy absorp-
Lightweight tion, ranging between the glass fibre and the carbon fibre composite coupons, but the highest crush force
efficiency among all designs.
Ó 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0261-3069/$ - see front matter Ó 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2013.05.018
768 J. Zhang et al. / Materials and Design 52 (2013) 767–773
Table 1
The fibre types and geometrical dimensions of corrugated sandwich composite coupons for parametric investigation.
Influencing Corrugation Core sheet thickness Face-sheet Adhesion length Adhesion length Total height Fibre type of face-
factor angle (h, °) (tc, mm) thickness (tf, mm) (l1, mm) (l2, mm) (h, mm) sheets
Corrugation 35 3 3 30 28 60 Chop strand glass fibre
angle 45 3 3 30 28 60 Chop strand glass fibre
75 3 3 30 28 60 Chop strand glass fibre
90 3 3 30 28 60 Chop strand glass fibre
Core sheet 45 1.8 3 30 28 56 Chop strand glass fabric
thickness 45 3 3 30 28 60 Chop strand glass fabric
45 4.2 3 30 28 61 Chop strand glass fabric
Adhesion length 90 3 3 30 28 61 Chop strand glass fabric
90 3 3 50 48 61 Chop strand glass fabric
Fibre type of 45 3 3 30 28 60 Woven carbon fabric
face sheets 45 3 3 30 28 60 Woven glass fabric
45 3 3 30 28 60 Carbon/glass (50:50)
woven fabric
J. Zhang et al. / Materials and Design 52 (2013) 767–773 769
Fig. 3. Loading curves for bending tests on corrugated sandwich coupons affected by corrugation angle, core sheet thickness, adhesion length and fibre type in face-sheets.
70 0.30 0.42
Weight specific strength
50
(kN/mm)
(N/g)
0.18
(N/g)
0.24
40
0.12 30
0.18
30
0.06 20 0.12
20
0.06
o o o o
35 45 75 90 1.8 mm 3 mm 4.2 mm
0.30 50 0.18
Weight specific strength
Weight specific strength
50
0.24 40
(kN/mm)
(kN/mm)
0.12
0.18
(N/g)
40
(N/g)
30
0.12
30 20 0.06
(c) 0.06 (d)
20 10
30 mm 50 mm Carbon Glass Hybrid
Fig. 4. Specific bending strength of corrugated sandwich coupons affected by corrugation angle, core sheet thickness, adhesion length and fibre type in face-sheets.
cured at room temperature overnight before they were bonded to- Composite sandwich coupons with two corrugation cells were
gether using epoxy adhesive Techniglue CA. Table 1 shows the manufactured for compression tests. Specimens with dimension
material constitution and geometric dimensions for each type of of 214 mm 66 mm 31 mm were prepared with corrugation an-
sandwich coupon for bending tests. gle of 45° and tested under compression in a MTS 250 kN servo
Three-point-bending tests were performed using an Instron hydraulic tester at loading rate of 2 mm/min (shown in Fig. 2b).
5569 universal tester in accordance with the ASTM D 7264 stan- For compression specimens, the same glass woven and carbon wo-
dard, with a crosshead speed of 1 mm/min. The fibre reinforcement ven fabrics as those employed for bending tests were used as rein-
types and geometrical dimensions of different coupons are sum- forcement but with vinyl ester resin being the matrix for both the
marised in Table 1. Three rollers with diameter of 50 mm were core and face-sheets. Two-part polyurethane expanding foam Eco-
used for the bending tests, with a span length of 190 mm. The Foam GP330 was employed as filler for improving the energy
experimental set-up for the three-point-bending on composite absorption of the panel. Three specimens were fabricated and
coupons is shown in Fig. 2a; this loading configuration is represen- tested for each type, i.e. the glass fibre, carbon fibre and hybrid
tative of the impact loading by a blunt body of dimension similar to (carbon/glass = 50:50) fibre composites with and without foam
the corrugation cell width. inserts.
770 J. Zhang et al. / Materials and Design 52 (2013) 767–773
Fig. 5. Effect of corrugation angle on the failure modes of bending specimens. (a)
The top view and (b) the side view.
Sweight ¼ Pmax =m ð1Þ are used. Nevertheless, the results suggest that there exists an opti-
mum corrugation angle that will provide the highest load carrying
Swidth ¼ P max =w ð2Þ capacity for a unit corrugation cell.
In contrast, when the 3-point bending strengths are normalised
where the Sweight denotes the weight specific strength, Pmax the max- by the weight and width of the coupons, the weight-specific
imum load, and m the mass of the composite coupon. Parameter strength and the width-specific strength show an ascending trend
Swidth denotes the width specific strength, and w the width of the as the corrugation angle increases, as shown in Fig. 4a. This in-
coupon. As can be seen from Figs. 3a and 4a, the coupon with the crease in specific strength is due that both the weight and width
smallest corrugation angle 35° yielded the lowest bending strength of the corrugation unit cell, as shown in Fig. 5a, decrease with cor-
of 21 kN. As the corrugation angle increased to 75° and 90°, the cou- rugation angle.
pons produced similar maximum load of around 23 kN. The coupon For a constant corrugation angle of 45°, the influences of core
with h equals to 45°, however, achieved the highest failure load of sheet thickness on the bending strength and specific bending
28 kN. The experimental results may have been influenced by the strengths are shown in Figs. 3b and 4b, respectively. It is clear from
manufacturing processes. The aluminium mould with 45° corruga- these results that the bending strength increases proportionally to
tion angle employed to fabricate the core of the sandwich coupons the web thickness.
was the easiest to lay-up the chop strand glass fibre mats; as the Increasing the adhesion length (l1) from 30 mm to 50 mm pro-
corrugation angle increased to 75° and 90°, the wet lay-up process duced an increase in bending strength, as shown in Figs. 3c and 4c.
became more difficult, since the impregnation of long glass fibres However, due to the increase in width and weight, specific
with polyester resin matrix became difficult when sharp corners strengths actually decreased.
J. Zhang et al. / Materials and Design 52 (2013) 767–773 771
Load (kN)
12
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
Displacement (mm)
Load (kN)
12
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
Fig. 7. Effect of adhesion length on the failure modes of bending specimens. (a) The Displacement (mm)
top view and (b) the side view.
Fig. 9. Loading curves for compression tests on corrugated sandwich coupons
affected by (a) fibre type and (b) foam insert.
For a given core made of woven glass fabric reinforced vinyl es-
ter resin (corrugation angle = 45°, web thickness = 1.8 mm),
changes in face-sheets, from carbon woven fabric, to glass woven do not affect tensile properties when 50% carbon fibre and 50%
fabric and to the hybridisation of carbon and glass woven fabric glass fibre reinforcements were used. Based on this finding, the hy-
(50:50), resulted in a more complex behaviour, as shown in brid-material coupons were designed to achieve the best compres-
Fig. 3d. Coupons with hybrid face-sheets gave the highest maxi- sive strength of carbon/glass hybrid laminate in the top face-sheet
mum bending load of 25 kN, in comparison with the strengths of and the best flexural strength in the bottom face-sheet when the
coupons made with pure carbon and pure glass fibre reinforce- sandwich coupon was under bending. Specifically, the hybrid com-
ment, which produced similar strength of 22 kN. Our previous posite coupon prepared in the current work employed the lay-up
work on glass/carbon hybrid composite laminates [21] has re- scheme of (i) [C/G]5 for the top face-sheet and (ii) [G5C5] for the
vealed that the alternating lay-up of [C/G]ns can effectively enhance bottom face-sheet. The specific strengths shown in Fig. 4d are also
the compressive strength and the lay-up scheme using carbon fibre very encouraging results, i.e. the specific strength of the coupons
layers at the exterior [Cn/Gn]s can maximize flexural strength but with hybrid face-sheets made of carbon and glass at 50:50 ratio
Fig. 8. Effect of fibre type of face-sheets on the failure modes of bending specimens. (a) The top view; (b) the core failure in the coupon with hybrid composite face-sheets; (c–
e) are enlarged damage areas in the top face-sheet of coupons with carbon fibre, glass fibre and carbon/glass (50:50) face-sheets, respectively.
772 J. Zhang et al. / Materials and Design 52 (2013) 767–773
8
upper roller contacted the specimen exhibited the most severe
damage. Both the top view and the side view (Fig. 5b) show crack-
6 ing of the top face-sheet and debonding between the top skin and
the core. With the increase of corrugation angle, the damage area
4 became larger, confirming the better support by webs perpendicu-
lar of the face-sheets. At the same corrugation angle of 45°, the
thicker the web is, the less damage was sustained by the web,
2
referring to Fig. 6. In the case of 1.8 mm thick web, extensive dam-
age of the web of the corrugated core is visible in Fig. 6a. The influ-
0 ence of adhesion length is shown in Fig. 7, where the coupon with
Glass Carbon Hybrid
longer adhesion length (5 mm) failed at the adhesion region be-
tween the top face-sheet and the core, with less damage observed
1.0 (b) on the top skin compared with the coupon with shorter adhesion
Specific energy absorption (J/g)
without foam
3.2.1. Load displacement curves
with foam
Fig. 9 shows the load displacement curves of the corrugated
0.5
(c)
sandwich coupons, without and with foam fillings, under compres-
sion as shown in Fig. 2b. In the elastic region of the loading curves,
Crush force efficiency
Fig. 11. Compression testing on (a) hybrid composite specimens and their (b) foam filled composite specimens.
J. Zhang et al. / Materials and Design 52 (2013) 767–773 773
impact. Three key parameters are average crushing load, specific References
energy absorption (SEA) and crush force efficiency. The average
failure load is the average value of the high and low peak load val- [1] Brylawski M, Lovins A. Ultralight hybrid vehicle design: overcoming the
barriers to using advanced composites in the automotive industry RMI, T95-
ues after the initial failure. The specific energy absorption is the en- 39. Rocky Mountain Institute; 1995.
ergy absorbed per unit mass of the materials, which is the most [2] Beardmore P, Johnson CF. The potential for composites in structural
relevant mechanical property to consider in order to improve the automotive applications. Compos Sci Technol 1986;26:251–81.
[3] Cramer DR, Taggart DF. Design and manufacture of an affordable advanced-
energy absorption and design more efficient mechanisms of col- composite automotive body structure. In: The 19th international battery,
lapse [23]. The crush force efficiency is the ratio between the aver- hybrid and fuel cell electric vehicle symposium & exhibition; 2002.
age failure load and the initial failure load [24]. If the efficiency [4] Zhang J, He S, Walton IH, Kajla A, Wang CH. Lightweight stiffened composite
structure with superior bending strength and stiffness for automotive floor
value equals to 1, i.e., the initial failure load is the same as the aver-
applications. In: The fourth international conference on sustainable
age failure load, then the passenger will not experience a sudden automotive technologies, Melbourne, Australia: Springer; 2012.
pulse during an impact. [5] Li X, Li G, Wang C, You M. Optimum design of composite sandwich structures
Fig. 10 shows the comparison between different fibre types and subjected to combined torsion and bending loads. Appl Compos Mater
2012;19(3–4):315–31.
the influence of foam insertion. The average failure load for the [6] Belingardi G, Cavatorta MP, Duella R. Material characterization of a composite–
coupons with glass fibre, carbon fibre and hybrid fibre reinforce- foam sandwich for the front structure of a high speed train. Compos Struct
ment were similar. With the foam insertion, a 37% increase (over 2003;61(1–2):13–25.
[7] Gustin J, Joneson A, Mahinfalah M, Stone J. Low velocity impact of combination
the coupons without foam) was realised for the glass and hybrid Kevlar/carbon fiber sandwich composites. Compos Struct 2005;69(4):
composite coupons and a 40% increase was realised for the carbon 396–406.
fibre composite coupons. The SEA values for the coupons followed [8] Chang WS, Ventsel E, Krauthammer T, John J. Bending behavior of corrugated-
core sandwich plates. Compos Struct 2005;70(1):81–9.
a descending sequence of the carbon fibre, hybrid fibre and then [9] Biancolini ME. Evaluation of equivalent stiffness properties of corrugated
glass fibre composite coupons. The carbon fibre coupon had a board. Compos Struct 2005;69(3):322–8.
SEA value of 0.68 J/g, which was 33% higher than the hybrid cou- [10] Biancolini ME, Brutti C. Numerical and experimental investigation of the
strength of corrugated board packages. Packag Technol Sci 2003;16(2):47–60.
pon and 42% higher than the glass fibre coupon. After the foams [11] Allaoui S, Aboura Z, Benzeggagh ML. Effects of the environmental conditions
were inserted, a slight increase of SEA was resulted. The crush force on the mechanical behaviour of the corrugated cardboard. Compos Sci Technol
efficiency describes the ability for the structure to perform after 2009;69(1):104–10.
[12] Yokozeki T, Takeda SI, Ogasawara T, Ishikawa T. Mechanical properties of
the initial failure during the crushing process. It can be noted that
corrugated composites for candidate materials of flexible wing structures.
only the hybrid and the glass fibre composite coupons enhanced Composites Part A 2006;37(10):1578–86.
the crush force efficiency (>20%) with the addition of foam. The [13] Kazemahvazi S, Tanner D, Zenkert D. Corrugated all-composite sandwich
carbon fibre coupon, however, showed slight decrease in crush structures. Part 2: failure mechanisms and experimental programme. Compos
Sci Technol 2009;69(7–8):920–5.
force efficiency. To enhance the energy absorption, foams have [14] Lu TJ, Hutchinson JW, Evans AG. Optimal design of a flexural actuator. J Mech
been used to fill thin walled metallic tubes. Mamalis et al. found Phys Solids 2001;49:2071–93.
that the foam-filled tubes show more stable post-crushing behav- [15] Mosher SB. Advanced composite corrugated core panels: a building block of
the future. Planet forward; 2011.
iour than the empty tubes and the foams were found to smooth the [16] De Souza T. The lightweight modular vehicle platform (LMVP) project-
load displacement curves in the post crushing region [25]. In the lightweight design challenges. In: AutoCRC technical conference, Melbourne,
current work, the foam material did not show significant improve- Australia; 2011.
[17] Zhang J, Wang CH, De Souza T, Rolfe B, Niumsawatt P, Fiedler K, et al.
ment in crashworthiness in a similar manner except for the case of Lightweight composite vehicle floor structure, Record of Invention, AutoCRC,
glass fibre composite coupons, due to the foam’s low mechanical Australia; 2011.
property; therefore more rigid foam should be applied in future [18] Savage G, Bomphray I, Oxley M. Exploiting the fracture properties of carbon
fibre composites to design lightweight energy absorbing structures. Eng Fail
work. As shown in Fig. 11, the foam only showed limited support Anal 2004;11(5):677–94.
of the corrugated sandwich structure under compression loading. [19] Obradovic J, Boria S, Belingardi G. Lightweight design and crash analysis of
composite frontal impact energy absorbing structures. Compos Struct
2012;94(2):423–30.
4. Conclusions [20] Jacob A. Automotive composites – the road ahead. Reinf Plast 2001;
45(6):28–32.
Corrugated sandwich structure made form glass fibre, carbon fi- [21] Zhang J, Chaisombat K, He S, Wang CH. Hybrid composite laminates reinforced
with glass/carbon woven fabrics for lightweight load bearing structures. Mater
bre and hybrid (glass:carbon = 50:50) fibre reinforcement and Des 2012;36:75–80.
polymer matrix were investigated for their bending and out-of- [22] Jin F, Chen H, Zhao L, Fan H, Cai C, Kuang N. Failure mechanisms of sandwich
plane compression performance. Increasing the corrugation angle composites with orthotropic integrated woven corrugated cores: experiments.
Compos Struct 2013;98:53–8.
and the core-sheet thickness improved the specific bending [23] Hamada H, Coppola JC, Hull D, Maekawa Z, Sato H. Comparison of energy
strength of the sandwich structure, while increasing the bond absorption of carbon/epoxy and carbon/PEEK composite tubes. Composites
length led to lower specific bending strength. The use of hybrid fi- 1992;23(4):245–52.
[24] Ataollahi S, Eshkoor RA, Ariffin AK, Azhari CH. Energy absorption and failure
bre face-sheets (glass:carbon = 50:50) was found to yield compara-
response of silk/epoxy composite square tubes: experimental. Composites Part
ble specific bending strength as the carbon fibre coupons. The B 2012;43(2):542–8.
hybrid composite coupon with foam insertion showed medium en- [25] Mamalis AG, Manolakos DE, Ioannidis MB, Spentzas KN, Koutroubakis S. Static
axial collapse of foam-filled steel thin-walled rectangular tubes: experimental
ergy absorption between the glass fibre and the carbon fibre com-
and numerical simulation. Int J Crashworthines 2008;13(2):117–26.
posite coupons but the highest crush force efficiency among all
designs.