CIVIL PROEDUR E CODE

OPIC RES TUDCATA AND RES-SUB-TUDI CE

Jctiom lo k o u1.

Auloitto To Submittrsl hs: Mancui Bhati

.Xanan Nawauda Clou: b-Com hL.b (H).
wbon C
Rall ne 6a/1+.
 ABLE OF CONTENTS
Res &ub- Juslce Ls.10] Menm o comptent o
Cbutiudie Ecpkanaion (I.
) Nou dcope ecplonalion ()
Cordtions. Ecplaatio (V
Tout
et o Contouwentim 3) Conclusian
mum otdU.
hunt Powu to stoy4 4) bibeioq ape
ReL Tudicata [A. I
Mnnino
) b Rs-Tudicata
ReA- ub- Tudice
-)Buk lolw 3. U utoppel
Condiiow Ra-udicata
Ecplasation ().

Ecpanation N
Mott dinctyvwbatantialy

MDing u
Mearne AAoune Paties
Ra-uoicalh bw D-dopendanta
Ecp onatig L)
 0at2-
Pig?

TDfIC: RES SUBTUDICE AND RES-TUDICATA

RES SUBTUDiCE. STAy OF SuIT : SECTION o.

Objuctie Prevent LOuds Con unt jurisdictbm om

Aimultaneouy Antvutauning and ouolicotine
upew ATvo panallel itioIion in upwr a
&ome Coue ctiom he a m u o j t watton
some eliey

uotu k tapPples o tHial_ a uit Ond nmot tha

scope a t o dou mot HLclude a cout o v

wtvunm d d
Eg. Gnont ijunciom o tay
ppaintmunt o uceii

7 applu to2ppels HwiALOs.

v tu gthur
Conditioms1) uit ne phHviDusy intiluhd
uAeguntty istiutid

uut Mut
AuL in the AubAqunt
n
a).MMot
) at
in issue w
he diurty pnd &uwhtantially
Awit
pAiou
RetureM the ome
uit mut be
otn t
 iigotn o J m ille >
Oomnd honA
be the Jame quality in the d ut
Data.
Page

potiey o thu HpHsentatiuu

4).*TAL pHiouuky unitutid Auit muur plding
Un tu &em Lout_in wucm
Ait M oougnt
ttl ublequent

Cowt Tnoia
n Qy cot busond the ltit o ndia
talslshed comticontimud y t Luntnal qot.

Bekoe t uphemL CQut.

5). Lount wwicln punow ut u imtitutod

w t have jwiudiction qont tt uliak
claimuA in the ubltgunt uit

6&ucA panties Mut Rse igating und t

ame titlw jn bott tteuia).

Auction io a mandatoy_phovULm Nodis CHLLO

i ent wit tu cowt. TL
pHocerdings un t uubuquu uit cav
wade ot ANy STA

Whto i e deciiiom in aa_pmerOUAl institutid

it wwouta vopettodi as RLA- Juditat u tu
ubeg unt uitt
ThhvunE
PouDL t o
tuwn uskuw pnoviuonl o destion o do ot icty

apply tivl couT hau nhww o e

&ut te asbieue
5 t o touy a iw
justic.

Eeet Not a wliy and caor oe diuganded in

ContYauerton exoutiow PocLedies..
3t i Dwy o tiual_wicw s lavud ond Moot

th inititition tuuo
i a xul _oceduxeweich Can b
uoied by ay

0d o tay u i t do o t tok auay

mtium
ORANL J powUu t count Lo possing wtim

RESToDICATA SECTiON

&ub j t Nattoy ospuL douladBucidia

oM a itgotiomamut com Tean end

9ehes KingsTont OoLe
RES TUD CATA 1S BASED ON THREE NAXIMS

Nane b e t Lsis exai pAO una et wadlem

juti
N9 o n ould b ueced tuice
&orn Cauue.
 Dat2
Pa

untnust aeipuslicae t it fis litiu

t s wwteneut juticL stat hat
hoe ehould lse an end te linqatiom

) A udicata pre Jitat ociptiu

i t o mut cceptedu v0s t.
octxi t Tuelicata is NOT ExHAUSTINE LILLUSTRAT*VE

eanyas V. totu o U.P_ 196

Rule Ru-Juctatou applis olao_ to o pttion
petction A dismud O mwia,
i t wiu Aperat 0 Ra Tuciecata
DIFFERENCE b]w RES-SU6TUDICE RES-JUDICATA
RES-JUDICATA RES- SUBTUDICE.

Appliu to matt Appeiuto mathu funslunq

odjudicoiLd upOw tial

Aans the tiol a Ban tht tial o a &uit

i t whic has bn whica is punding deciionw
drcidnd in o me a prewiouly unstitutd
uit. uit
 Data
Page

IS.52 9TRA
RES UDICATA k AIs PEN DENS WAL a conit wusu
bw th a, R uoiealo wi0 puwnil.

DIFFERENCE B] RES TUDICATA AND ESTOPPEX.

RES-JUDICATA ESTOPPE d

Reults a deciiow FlousK Monm t oct

Lount pantis.
PHOLuds prom 9octrin2
Baud ow publie poliey
CThwu Aould be a t aVu t
lboptiom

Ousts the fuiudiction

PMonibits a mev AUAHÄng

the ome tine itce Aouing n tning Aat
tiqctions. Ond time 2nd
opposit a t anotiha.

WNDITIONS OF REG -JODICATA.

1)TL
1) Th wotu dinicty and ubtanaLly un w e
in e uhwnunt uit t Be the same
wwot whih wns dinuctty nd &ubitaiay
lt
 Date
Page

8). eometsuit muu hue erv auit blu

dhe kame paxties Between onties wnd
shom oy

3 Pantie mut he tioating wndr the tam

titk.

) Th count uic decidd the uuitE i t

muut a cout competent te t Sucw
uogunt ui
5 . Lhemattu in iauue in ttu ubuqunt uit
mmuut oue beev uand and deidsd
ky the cowrt_i the fotme Suit
Suit

EXPAANATION).

e t ot t _dat
h o t wouttws kut tue d a t on wuic
uit dectded

EXPLANATIoN () L (IT)
Mattu u isue

Molte diiutu whsturall in isua Matter collatrly

o wnciduntolly

cuay n Constuuctively
n
 Date
Pag

MATTER DiRECTLy SUBSTANIALy TSSUE

iuctky At Oc mmudotely
Subltanially . ssentually |matoually

att t Can ki 80idto be dubitanially

duciuo thu caue
Nunivwal ul application
doumo it.
()._ A wes B o Ont_du. Re dukre q
that me Hent iu duv. Hoe h claim
Hnt 8 thwrone, matt diHuctly an
wstcntiolly un iuu

ANL&etetal indings Lwal

isus, t e ndinge alls iuu w b
H Aubicota.
wwottu A ACTUAAY IN 1SSUE WHEN IT IS
ucty ubtantialy
 Data
Pag:

MATTER CONSTRUCT*VEAY N iSsuE ex. ).

Hanig s h a mattu in iue MlqHT OOqHT

to ha b2t mode quoud s djue o
tack uit u calllA
Not Constuctivu in umue.

Printiple whew t partiu haue bad a ppuntunt

contHOinq a matte that ould be
talken to ee &ometeing aw ig the moutter
and ducided.
on aduolly contoudteh

Cojct To compul the ptaintitdspnoant te take

aRl the ounods o drhunce L attac usich
www ope to im.

Ecomple A u 6 jo pasieuion pHOpU,

bauis UDnuAAip. Th ut
dismiised A connot theat cloaiw _possOLiOn
pHopty asmoutgpgR asthat 4 Hound

ottock

Cae &tatu e 0.P V. Nauale Hussaiw, 19*+

Fouts A Ub inspeto polue ua dismilsed O m

D. 1. H challenged ttau oLoliu A
 Datz
Page

dismisscA y ing a uHib

cout petiitiow
wwau mot alhotdud
w e
und that h
NOOACMallu oppurtunty
heonol buyoe t pasing t
ThL contntuovm wsas oweRA
ta petion uas dismisseo.
u i t am Koised O
mol OULNd dnat addhio
by
inceA uau appointed
t qP t e DI4 bad mo
dismiss im pouve to

LontertiOn tate The uit wns JaNtd hs

constuelu Hjuolicata
HO &d i t wuDv mot hawwe by Ris Judicata
SCHokd, uit was bad by constuuetiie Re-Tudicata
was wiuinttue Rnowllolge
pointty n d LOuld wwell haue keen takon
Rondw wib
putition.

t : Wth y noiLiug tne Questio tt

d w i c JÄSOS poALid
peDUS uit
2uA thau suer daatud vaw iw
wo kted
 0at2
Pag

SSUE -NEANIN G.

uw oftous Micd iu A toe

DAd Jour.

Adcisiow Tuuu 0fout" hauD

UOneOuy it wouy b opeHaly os u Tueicota

A mined o foor tauo"_aluD yon w

opluats RA -Tudiata

But t a con{ieting Vieux onntuw Aution

uoiuiow
Lous wwwld opatu o Rs-Tuaicata

Mathuxa Praias RoLilai N.B Teeobhay, 1170

Hu qumal, a duciiow o competint coutt

saint o law cpunates vas
R Tudicato.
HOww b u uution a loue wwlalid to
wwich u i te a tiqut dou
kouta
04 judicata
Tbs when t h cau aetion us dteXxnt
ushen he lou has uncl t eamier
duouo bew altoxed competnt authonily
 Dit2
Pag2

whuw he deisiovw pelates te t e wididn

CouNt to tHy t er poceiding
Hhe duion dLos mot opuot a Ru Tuaicato
ulogunt
V
puoceedng

Avtor singu v. Jogb ingu

u iuuit
t wasita by A w a i v l Loult
PHeliminay vojertio ai hy
t e plouunt ay nutunud 4a_prosiutano
Ruueue Cout
wh A AppHchid thu Rueu Coutt
ta pethitiom holding Lthat ReweLL
count bad ne wisdictiom
PhoLg0u , dl a i i uit in the
cul sbut
Contuutze by 6 t h a ti t wa
Jawee by RuJudicota
accepiud the contintiow and
dusmino The &uit

Hels & u deerdant doe mot appla Ond tue

Ow t um etiusnuth plaint
MOUndock Jwusdiction, the
Ud w ubuquunt uit ay ot perote
judicata But i the endant appecs
Dnd ow u u haissd and duciduoL, n
H coinow wil opoate a R Tudicato
 .

altnoug t n eLOAOn fo t dciion may ot

.

Vw tokenv by Sc w Atan Snge

enoneOus nd does moT touy dousw t e
coUt ow.

Ruule Rs-udicata , tm a ule e pHoCLduRL

ConQ2t Supuud te las o Land

SAMG PARTIES.

Genmal Prineißtu : Tudamanty k ALcnOR bind the

pantes and piwis.

RA
R n oios Octa alteni nocene non deloet "

Thiny don ketwun Ctange ourt met to

Onyon.

A whoul noume apptans On

co at u tun A thL decigim .
J AL name oppea tonLouly
 [Punsons wo ckaim udu 13.
Pouuting
PHiVis
Ps ons not clawwng din the

panties pesintud by t
OTHER PERsONS. tetvenu
mino

RES JUDICATA bETUJEEN C-DEPENDATS

COnditi
T
deendontu
b NLay to ecioe_that comlict in ordu to
jve Hlie to Pan
TL A4 bw o-Apndant w t neuu
tinally duidd

Lo-deenoant panties.

Cos potungham v. al uwwsbwy , 1843.

e n u : > Pmn uSe ntwens uv a Cwitt

whidh he wal mot ouginally a party.

banty
ponbiiipotnk w a
uto, wwitth
laue u i t i
ycowt's
buuni w
iroptin, eter foudng witu e e plainti o

lndart
Partlunol JusAom th o u o e m clain

tt o m u ui
Paxties actuallw
Pantie claiming de th postios to ttu
Suit Cprivie
Posony upusetod a pates POdy
the om it Eplanotien T
REPRESENATiVE SoÍT LEXPAANAT*ON I J
www the puu0ns itigate bona dle in ruupee
publio Hignt tecianbd a piusdte
Higlt cloirnsel iv cornmon o w s l u sa n
Ound aA the
Hignt, ha o t pwpos S . I
dadmao to ai uweln w e u r the psons
ibgaino
tis One ALpLct _Conbuciu Hujudicata

ONDITIONS.

Piopt rloimid by ene 0 mo pUu ons Lommov

thurs luu Vottwu mot
ecpressly amd in
th it

The pariu mot ecpreuy mamia in L it

 15
Mult bentHLLLLA wcl uuyt

iigotion mut hawe baw Conduuotud bowa i d

O b thal e all panbiey iarutd.

t uit u w d u L Rul b, OL Comolitons

Woid doum wt hau kum stnicty conblisd with.

CoMpETENT COURT.

Olbt. TA dcisiony the Couxt nidtadjrisdetiom

OULout na te a knal nd indiq On
on a
unlinmtu juilietion.

TYPES Of CoURT.
Coust s eoclui juiselietion
Lou o initnd wuudicbion
Cout o ConeuLL_]wuudictuOw.

Tswhut tu d could
hawe bin
didd Cowd qes tte ducisLo
i) opOL Hs judicata ottuuoiun MOt.

RiGHT Of APPEAL EXPXANATION (

Ppition piom to ie L Positiow a u beiounatien T

 6

(A) PaitiomPion te Eeplarodien (II) .

bombay, MouaAs k Pualo

HC Prion duuisiom
w c me ucond bpal Roy, Could mMot
RLsTudicoto U ublgusnt
Cut in sidw due appLal uas woiwtaual.

HC Caeutto Cotray Äeur S u cdeiio

wuldshenate RLRTudiratw

Ecplanabon) Aos aismd Caleutta HC

viw.
tmoku it clan AotAOA t putpoL
RA Judicata, t competenc COut
oe detimiusd inspctiae CUMy pHoviis
04
t igt oappeal om he diciuon
c t OWt

ExPAANATON ) 3 aelle is claima wwa

ut u Mo
ercpnusaly t
dorxol itwl b oleemed to aue see
moutt un HLpuct wAit
cloimed www bhe u judirata
EXPAANATION (YIT). Armerdeo Act lo4
446, Ec (VIT)now upoekcal prOULds that
th pHevistOns Auction 11
Retion pHoceedinge ole

CONCLUSlON.

TL oin punpoL thu doctin to

uoure th unolw t hthe cowiti3 uor
aburnoluce caAAA. lundn
panties te addus wnitew
di t cout
conlicting ocisions are maku
w te w i i m i the

T seopk uhs ty_ misuw

in d te double benit
pxinciplu
 biB Lio GRAPH Y
Takusan , c K , i v i l PDcLduM w n iritalio, A
.
1963 ughntditon o )
2.Ra t , ivil PMDLdw tode1108