You are on page 1of 7

Magnetic Leviation Train

Maglev train, magnetic guidance, magnetic levitation, magnetic propulsion,advantages,working principle,advanvanced technology.

Abstract— A high-speed magnetic levitation vehicle MAGLEV is more preferred, although the cost of
(MAGLEV), promises a high-speed transportation system of manufacturing is more the maintenance cost is low.
500 mph speed with low cost for maintenance and operation.
The proposed system is also said to be environmentally
friendly. The goal of this paper is to investigate whether
MAGLEVs is feasible and safe to use. The concept of
MAGLEV TRANSPORT SYSTEM IN WORLDWIDE
MAGLEV is already introduced in several countries, Maglev The proposed MAGLEV system in Korea uses LIM as the
trains use magnetism to levitate above the tracks on which they thrust and electric suspension as the levitation. It is stated to
travel. They are faster, more efficient, and more have a semi-high speed of 200 km/h, a high speed of 550
environmentally friendly than modern wheeled trains. It may km/h, and a low speed of 110 km/h in urban areas.
be that one day soon, maglev technology will be commonplace
Maintaining the Integrity of the Specifications. Since the
throughout the world. This article reviews the history of these
trains, how they work, as well as their benefits and drawbacks. Maglev train has been studied and developed from
It also discusses the importance of electrical engineering in the 1960s, both German and Japanese Maglev trains have
developing maglev, and how electrical engineers can make this reached industrial levels and test tracks are experienced. In
technology the next transportation revolution. As we progress the1990s, the USA Inductrack, the Swiss Swissmetro, and
further, we will know more about MAGLEV and its operation. Korea’s UTM have been intensively studied and some
component prototypes have been built. The Transrapid in
Shanghai, China and the HSST (High Speed Surface
Transport) in Nagoya, Japan, have been in public service
since December 2003 and March2005, respectively. Some
I. INTRODUCTION projects (Pittsburgh or Baltimorein USA, Seoul in Korea,
MAGLEV is a transport system, which uses magnetic London in England, and so on) area waiting approval, and
fields to transport vehicles and other people without any the Munich project in Germany was approved in September
physical contact with the ground. This uses lift and 2003 with public service possible from 2009.
propulsion to reduce friction and to travel faster in a short
time. They are noiseless and are not affected by the
weather. The power needed to operate these vehicles are
relatively low compared to traditional wheeled trains.

Figure: Levitation and guidance system for semi high speed


MAGLEV train

Magnetic Levitation trains overcome air resistance due to


their design. The problem with the wheeled vehicle is that,
because of the friction, wear and tear occurs at the wheels, Figure: Two systems of MAGLEV semi high speed
thus reducing the speed with the ‘hammer effect’. Therefore,

1710994/1610315/1720912-Autumn-2021/EEE 313$XX.00 ©20XX IEEE


The magnet is placed near the Electromagnetic levitation,
for which the power applied is distributed among the magnet
and the electromagnetic levitation, and the mutual magnetic
flux interference provides the overlapping of the rail. As the
magnet and the levitation is placed closer to each other, there
is a coupling effect between these two.

The figure below shows the levitation and guidance


system of the semi high-speed MAGLEV train. This is
classified into two steps depending on the direction of the
current exerted by the electromagnet.

Figure: Levitation electromagnet with LSM core

MAGNETIC LEVITATION AND PROPULSION SYSTEM


The development concept of the magnetic
levitation and propulsion system is

Figure: Two types of system


STRUCTURE OF LEVITATION ELECTROMAGNET

The coils are made under levitation current and,


made up of aluminum sheets for less weight and better
heat dissipation ability. These coils carry DC-excitation
current under levitation control and, for the levitation
sheet; coils are preferred because, in the case of round
coils, insulation materials are not suitable for heat
release and the heat will be gathered instead. The stator
is set along the guideway. This stator has 3 phase
waveform coils. The propulsion is the main component
for providing levitation and is related to the levitation
force and thrust force. The force ripples should be kept
relatively low to stabilize the levitation and propulsion.
Force ripples are created from the differences between The electromagnets are located on each side of the vehicle.
the fiber core and the stator coil. If there are gaps Each of the electromagnets contained a permanent magnet
between two force fields, irregularities show up which that generated a nominal magnetic flux for the required
levitation force and a coil that perturbed the magnetic flux
causes less cogging force and levitation ripple. This also
and varied the magnetic force to adjust the air gap length.
softens the end effect. On the other hand, if the cores are There are slots and coils for the linear generator on the top
close to each other, the flux density is more, which of the core. Long-stator LSM core and windings are
results in high flux density due to the end effect. This arranged along the double-side track. Table I lists the
effect produces core saturation and unbalanced flux specifications and design parameters of the small-scale
density distribution. magnetic levitation and propulsion system.

Translator Part Long-Stator Part


Item Value Item Value
Pole Pitch 78 Slot Pitch 52
mm mm
Num. of 12 Slots/Poles 3/2
Poles
Stack Length 50 Nominal Air 3 mm
mm gap
Initial Air 5 mm Min. Air gap 1 mm
gap
toward the rail from below. The system is typically
arranged on a series of C-shaped arms, with the upper
ANALYTICAL DETERMINATION OF ELECTROMAGNETIC
CAPABILITY
portion of the arm attached to the vehicle, and the lower
inside edge containing the magnets. The rail is situated
Open-Circuit Equivalent Magnetic Circuit Mode lFig. 2 and
inside the C, between the upper and lower edges.
3 show the design parameters of the unit module of
magnetic levitation electromagnets at the aligned and Magnetic attraction varies inversely with the cube of
unaligned position, respectively. distance, so minor changes in distance between the
The permanent magnet was made from neodymium-iron- magnets and the rail produce greatly varying forces.
boron alloy and provides the nominal magnetic flux for the These changes in force are dynamically unstable – a
levitation force. The magnetic forces could be calculated slight divergence from the optimum position tends to
analytically using a magnetic circuit instead of numerical grow rather, requiring sophisticated feedback systems to
methods such as the finite element method. However, the
leakage of the flux and the fringing field around the corner maintain a constant distance from the track,
of the iron cores in the air should be considered to obtain (approximately 15 millimeters (0.59 in)). The major
results that are more accurate. The magnetic fluxes around advantage to suspended maglev systems is that they
the magnet were assumed as illustrated in Fig.2. Fig 2 shows work at all speeds, unlike electrodynamics systems,
the design parameters of small-scale magnetic levitation and which only work at a minimum speed of about 30 km/h
propulsion system. (19 mph). This eliminates the need for a separate low-
speed suspension system and can simplify track layout.
On the downside, the dynamic instability demands fine
track tolerances, which can offset this advantage. Eric
Laithwaite was concerned that to meet the required
WORKING PRINCIPLE OF MAGLEV tolerances, the gap between magnets and rail would have
to be increased to the point where the magnets would be
unreasonably large. In practice, this problem was
A MAGLEV train floats 10 mm above the guide way addressed through improved feedback systems, which
of the magnetic field, and is propelled by the guide way support the required tolerances.
itself. When it reaches to the next station, the magnetism
is changed so that the train is pulled on. The
electromagnets run along the guide way, and the
electromagnets located under the train levitates the train
by pulling it up to the ferromagnetic stators. The magnets
on the side keeps the train stable along the guide way.

A computer changes the amount of current to keep


the train 1 cm from the track. The operation is very
smooth and does not create any noise. Electrodynamics
involving the interaction of electrical currents and
magnetic forces, state-of-art computers, and
microprocessors maintain guidance (vertical and
horizontal spacing) during travel. Low-speed Maglev
travels up to 60 mph. In Pittsburgh's case, the top speed
will be about 40 mph.
Figure: Working Principle
The factors of MAGLEV train, which needs to be
Tracks: The tracks are specifically made for
considered, are as follows:
MAGLEV levitation trains and are not compatible with
traditional wheeled trains. They are designed for
Electromagnetic suspension: Electromagnetic
magnetic levitation and propulsion. As this vehicle runs
suspension (EMS), electronically controlled
to magnetism, uses of wheels are not required as they are
electromagnets in the train attracts it to a magnetically
designed to work as a standalone function.
conductive (usually steel) track. Electromagnetic
suspension (EMS) is used to levitate the Transrapid on
Propulsion: EMS systems such as HSST/Linimo
the track so that the train can be faster than wheeled
can provide both levitation and propulsion using an
mass transit systems. In electromagnetic suspension
onboard linear motor. However, EDS systems and some
(EMS) systems, the train levitates above a steel rail
EMS systems such as Transrapid levitate but not propel.
while electromagnets, attached to the train, are oriented
Such systems need some other technology for energy used for acceleration might be considerable. The
propulsion. A linear motor (propulsion coils) mounted in power used to overcome air drag increases with the
the track is one solution. Over long distances, coil costs cube of the velocity and hence dominates at high speed.
could be prohibitive. The energy needed per mile increases by the square of
the velocity and the time decreases linearly.) For
example, two and a half times as much power is needed
to travel at 400 km/h than 300 km/h.

Stability: Earnshaw's theorem shows that no


combination of static magnets can be in a stable
equilibrium. Therefore, a dynamic (time-varying) Field flux and levitation force analysis:
magnetic field is required to achieve stabilization. EMS
systems rely on active electronic stabilization that To analyze the field flux and levitation force, modeling
constantly measures the bearing distance and adjusts the and FEM analysis are carried out. The fem modeling and
electromagnet current accordingly. EDS systems rely on mesh are shown in the figure below. The analyses of the
changing magnetic fields to create currents, which can levitation electromagnet with and without separation of the
give passive stability. Because maglev vehicles core are also performed for comparison.
essentially fly, stabilization of pitch, roll, and yaw is
required. In addition to the rotation, surge (forward and
backward motions), sway (sideways motion), or heave
(up and down motions) can be problematic.
Superconducting magnets on a train above a track made
out of a permanent magnet lock the train into its lateral Figure: FEM Model
position.

Guidance: Some systems use Null Current systems


(also sometimes called Null Flux systems). These use a
coil that is wound so that it enters two opposing,
alternating fields so that the average flux in the loop is Figure: Mesh model
zero. When the vehicle is in the straight-ahead position,
no current flows, but any moves off-line create flux that Core flux balance improvement: Unlike a rotary motor, a
generates a field that naturally pushes/pulls it back into linear motor has a limited length of mover and stator along
line. the air gap. It makes entry and exit end that cause the end
effect. In the entry and exit ends, the flux density is lower
Energy use Energy for maglev trains is used to than other poles. This flux unbalances leads to local
accelerate the train. Energy may be regained when the saturation of the core and it is transmitted pole by pole.
train slows down via regenerative braking". It also Electromagnetic field analyses of un-separated cores are
levitates and stabilizes the train's movement. Most of shown in the figure below. The entry and exit area yoke
the energy is needed to overcome "air drag". Some have a higher flux density in the un-separated cores.
energy is used for air conditioning, heating, lighting, However, the flux density of the separated core shows little
and other miscellanies. At low speeds, the percentage of difference. The magnetic circuit of the separated core is
power (energy per time) used for levitation can be divided throughout the poles. That makes different flux
significant consuming up to 15% more power than a paths and blocks the propagation of the end effect.
subway or light rail service. For short distances, the
un-separated core. The peak value of the cogging force is
reduced to 8.3%. Core segmentation reduces not only
cogging force but also thrust. Pole position change in the
regular repetition of pole position affects the current angle
in thrust control. However, the amount of thrust loss is
insignificant.

Figure: Close core

Figure: Separated core

Levitation ripple elimination: Most of the linear motor


has a normal force between mover and stator. LSM has an
attractive force and it is utilized by levitation force.
Analysis of levitation force according to mover position is
shown in the given figure. The un-separated core has
levitation force with huge ripples due to reluctance variation Figure: Comparison of cogging force
between LSM core and levitation magnet. Like cogging ADVANTAGES OF MAGLEV
force, the levitation ripples have to be minimized to achieve
the stability of the levitation system. Core separation can 1) Despite the speeds of up to 500 km/hour, passengers
reduce the levitation ripples. Separated core changes regular can move about freely in the vehicles at all times.
repetition of pole position. Irregularity of pole position can
reduce the force ripples. The force ripple of the separated 2) Maglev vehicle has no fuel
core is only 9.9% of Un-separated core.
3) The materials used to construct maglev vehicles are
non-combustible, poor transmitters of heat, and able to
withstand fire penetration.

4) In the unlikely event that a fire and power loss


occurred simultaneously, the vehicle is automatically
slowed down so that it stops at a predefined emergency
power station.

5) A collision between two maglev trains is nearly


impossible because the linear induction motors prevent
trains from running in opposite directions or different
speeds within the same power tectonically reduce travel
time.

EXPERIMENT
Figure: Comparison of levitation force
Levitation force experimental equipment is shown in the
Cogging force elimination: The principle of cogging force figure below. For the levitation force test, cutoff sized model
and levitation force ripple is almost similar. Hence, the with 4 poles are manufactured. The Levitation magnet and
cogging force can be reduced with the separated core. The LSM core are placed on a freely movable shelf. For a load of
analysis result of cogging force according to mover position levitation force, the dummy masses are hanging beneath the
is shown in the figure. As in the figure, the cogging force of levitation magnet. The four load cells are placed between the
the separated core is significantly reduced than that of the LSM core and the top shelf to measure the force.
Figure: Levitation force with varying air gap

To verify the experimentation, the 4 poles FEM model is


also analyzed. The flux density distribution of the 4 poles
cutoff model is shown in the next figure.
Figure: Levitation force in position

EXPERIMENT

Maglev trains use magnets to levitate and propel the trains


forward. Since there is no friction, these trains can reach high
speeds. It is a safe and efficient way to travel. Governments
have mixed feelings about technology. Some countries, like
Figure: Magnetization as a function of applied field
China, have embraced it and others like India have balked at
The results are shown in the figures below. The levitation the expense. Other countries, on the other hand, have already
forces are measured according to current, position, and air been working on the project, like Korea.
gap. As in the figure, the finite element analysis result
shows good agreement with the experimental result.
However, in the high current region, the levitation force
shows an even higher force than expected. The levitation
force according to the mover position is measured to verify
the simulation. The experiment results at 10A, 10mm air
gap is shown of fig. 9. 4pole cutoff model still has the
levitation force ripples because it is designed for
minimizing levitation ripple of the full model.

REFERENCES
[1] K.C.Coates. "High-speed rail in the United Kingdom".
High-speed rail in the United Kingdom. Retrieved 2012-12-
13.
[2] "The magnetic attraction of trains". BBC News. 9
November 1999. Retrieved28 November 2010.
[3] "New plan aims to bring the Maglev back". Birmingham Circuit,” IEEE trans. Magn., Early Accept Articles, 2016.
Mail. Retrieved 1 September2006. [9] Aldo D’Arrigo, Alfred Rufer, “Integrated
[4] "Maglev: How they're Getting Trains off the Ground", electromagnetic levitation and
Popular Science, December 1973 p. 135. guidance system for the swissmetro project,” MAGLEV
2000, Rio de
[5] "Study of Japanese Electrodynamics-Suspension Janeiro, Brazil, pp.263-268, 2000.
Maglev Systems". Osti.gov. 31 August 2012. [10] Y.J.Kim, P.S.Shin, D.H.Kang, and Y.H.Cho, “Design
and analysis of
[6] H.-W. Cho, C.-H. Kim, H.-S. Han and J.-M. Lee, electromagnetic system in a magnetically levitated vehicle,
"Levitation and KOMAG-01,”
Thrust Forces Analysis of Hybrid-Excited Linear IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, Vol. 28, No. 5, pp. 3321-
Synchronous Motor 3323,
for Magnetically Levitated Vehicle,” Journal of Electrical September 1992.
Engineering [11] M. Morishita, T. Azukizawa, S. Kanda, N. Tamura, and
& Technology, Vol. 7, No. 4, pp. 564-569, 2012. T. Yokoyama,
[7] H.-W. Cho, C.-H. Kim, J.-M. Lee, and H.-S. Han. "3- “A new maglev system for magnetically levitated carrier
Dimensional finite system,” IEEE
element analysis of linear synchronous motor for Trans. Vehicular Tech., vol. 38, no. 4, pp. 230-236, 1989.
magnetically levitated [12] Takashi Onuki, and Tasushi Toda, “Optimal design of
vehicle," International Conference on Electrical Machines hybrid magnet in
and Systems maglev system with both permanent and electro magnets,”
(ICEMS), pp. 1555-1558, 2010. IEEE Trans.
[8] J. H. Jeong, C. W. Ha, J. Lim, and J. Y. Choi, “Analysis Magn., vol. 29, no. 2, pp. 1783-1786, March 1993.
and Control of [13] Yumei Du, Liming Shi, and Nengqiang Jin, “Analysis
the Electromagnetic Coupling Effect of the Levitation and of the three dimension
Guidance forces in a hybrid maglev vehicle system,” Proc. of ICEMS
System for a Semi-high-speed Maglev Using a Magnetic 2003
Equivalent
[14] https://sites.tufts.edu/eeseniordesignhandbook/2015/maglev-magnetic-levitating-trains/(abstract)
[15] https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/1644911(abstract)
[16] https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=magnetic+levitation+train+technology (information source)
[17] https://mybrowser-search.com/search?q=magnetic%20leviation%20train%20history&ac=1468047342 (History)

You might also like