The Philippine Social Science Journal │ ISSN 2672-3107 (P)  ISSN 2704-288X (E)

Published by Recoletos de Bacolod Graduate School

University of Negros Occidental-Recoletos, Bacolod City, Philippines 6100
Email: rbgs2018@yahoo.com │Tel. #. +63 (034) 433-3990 local 152

REVIEWER CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENT

I agree that: (Please check the appropriate box)

 The manuscript I received for review must be treated as a confidential document and it
must not be shown or discussed with others except authorized by the author/ research
director /editor.

 Any ideas obtained during the peer review process will be kept confidential and will not
be used for personal advantage.

_________________________________________________________
Reviewer’s Signature above Printed Name

Date: _____________________________
 The Philippine Social Science Journal │ ISSN 2672-3107 (P)  ISSN 2704-288X (E)
Published by Recoletos de Bacolod Graduate School
University of Negros Occidental-Recoletos, Bacolod City, Philippines 6100
Email: rbgs2018@yahoo.com │Tel. #. +63 (034) 433-3990 local 152

PSSJ REVIEW FORM

Instruction: Please accomplish this form correctly and legibly. Your comments and suggestions will be consolidated with
the other Peer-Reviewers/ Evaluators with the end view of refining the paper being evaluated and come up with a quality
publishable article.

Title of the Article: Implementation of Primary Healthcare Services in Community Health Stations in Highly
Urbanized City

Date of Review:

Please check the appropriate box.

PART I. ABSTRACT Complied Not Complied Not Applicable
A. Title and Scope
1. Number of Words – (12-15 words)   
2. International Character (words are
  
understandable universally)
3. Catchy/Interesting   
4. Scope: Relevance to an international
  
audience
B. Word Count (150 words; never too short or
exceeding)
C. Keywords must contain FOUR components:
1. Discipline of the study   
2. Concepts studied   
3. Methods/process   
4. Geography (country/continent)   
D. Structure
1. Topic introduction: Presents conditions
  
that propelled the conduct of the research
2. Chief Purpose/Aim: States what the study
  
intended to explore
3. Method: Mentions how the study was
conducted in terms of:
Research Design   
Respondents and Sampling Technique   
Research Instrument   
Statistical Treatment (if applicable)   
4. Results: Presents the salient findings; a
  
sentence or two only
5. Conclusions: Directly answers the chief
purpose; your most important discovery
which contributes to new knowledge;   
supports or negates previous conclusions;
validates theory used
6. Recommendations (if applicable)): Tells
what can be done next to effect the
  
necessary changes desired; has
international application or relevance.
 The Philippine Social Science Journal │ ISSN 2672-3107 (P)  ISSN 2704-288X (E)
Published by Recoletos de Bacolod Graduate School
University of Negros Occidental-Recoletos, Bacolod City, Philippines 6100
Email: rbgs2018@yahoo.com │Tel. #. +63 (034) 433-3990 local 152

PART II. FULL PAPER

A. Suitability of Topic
1. Is the topic appropriate for publication in the Philippine Social Science Journal?
 Yes
 Perhaps
 No

2. Is the topic important/relevant to colleagues working in the field?

 Yes
 Perhaps
 No

B. Content and Presentation

1. Is the coverage of the topic sufficiently comprehensive and balanced?
 Yes
 Important information is missing or superficially treated.
 Treatment somewhat unbalanced, but not seriously so.
 Certain part significantly overstresses.

2. How would you rate the overall organization of the paper?

 Satisfactory
 Could be Improved
 Poor

3. Are the title and abstract satisfactory?

 Yes
 No

4. Are symbols, terms, and concepts adequately defined?

 Yes
 Not Always
 No

5. Rate the Bibliography.

 Satisfactory
 Unsatisfactory

C. Overall Rating
1. How would you rate the contents of the paper?
 Excellent
 Good
 Fair
 Poor
 The Philippine Social Science Journal │ ISSN 2672-3107 (P)  ISSN 2704-288X (E)
Published by Recoletos de Bacolod Graduate School
University of Negros Occidental-Recoletos, Bacolod City, Philippines 6100
Email: rbgs2018@yahoo.com │Tel. #. +63 (034) 433-3990 local 152

2. How would you rate the novelty of the paper?

 Highly Novel
 Sufficiently
 Slightly Novel
 Not Novel

3. How would you rate the clarity of the presentation of the paper?
 Totally Accessible
 Mostly Accessible
 Accessible
 Inaccessible

D. Recommendation
 Accept without revision(s)
 Accept with minor revision(s)
 Accept with major revision(s)
 Reject with the option to resubmit

SPECIFIC COMMENTS & SUGGESTIONS

Please state why you rated the paper as you did in Sections A, B, and C. If you have indicated that revisions are required,
please give the author specific guidance regarding those revisions. Feel free to attach extra sheets of comments and to make
notes on the manuscript. Return this form with any manuscript pages on which you have made notations. Kindly write your
comments/reasons/suggestions below:

Would you like to review the paper after revision?  Yes  No

___________________________________________________________
Reviewer’s Signature above Printed Name