Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Power Structure/Agency Debate
Power Structure/Agency Debate
Structure/Agency debate
How sociologists attempt to understand the relative balance between society's influence on the
individual (structure) and the individual's freedom to act or shape society (agency)
Key theoretical concepts
Functionalism
Class and capital
Medicalisation
Feminist and gender theories
Symbolic interaction
Surveillance and discourse
Risk
All ways of thinking about power and structure/agency
Class and capital
Key sociologists (among others):
Karl Marx 1818-1883
Pierre Bourdieu 1930-2002
Marx: key concepts
Class
Capitalism
Alienation
Marx: Class (upper, middle, lower)
Bourgeoisie- owners of means of production (upper class)
Proletariat- labour force (working class)
Marx: Capitalism
Capitalism is the primary mode of production ($$$)
Pursuit of profit
Exploitative
Distribution of resources is unequal
Marx believed capitalism would be overthrown
Marx: Alienation
Alienation results from capitalism
Workers are alienated from:
o Labour power
o Products of labour
o One another;
o Species essence
Marx and Health - discussion points
Capitalism and alienation create ill health
Health and economic status (class)
Are linked
o Poorer people = poorer health
Ill health as a result of capitalist social structure is inequitable
Profit motive dictates delivery of care
Illnesses are medicalised for profit
Medicine is an institution of social control
Bourdieu: key concepts
Capital
o Economic
o Cultural
o Social
o Symbolic
Field
Habitus
Bourdieu: capital
For Bourdieu capital is made up of not just economic resources, but also social, cultural and symbolic
resources
Power = negotiated/exchanged
Power is negotiated through ongoing struggle
Structure and agency are intertwined not opposing
Advantage and disadvantage are relative and contextual
Bourdieu: Field
A sphere of life or realm of society
Can be micro or macro e.g.
o Lecture theatre
o Coffee shop
o Paramedic practice
o Biomedicine
o Education
Bourdieu: Habitus
Embedded, internalised ' ways of knowing' enabling us to understand and 'practice' in the
fields we move in and between
Understanding the 'rules of the field' (doxa)
Product of significant periods spent within that social world drawing on capital