Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.emeraldinsight.com/1363-951X.htm
Critical review of
A critical review of psychological psychological
instruments used in police instruments
officer selection
Jonathan Lough and Kathryn Von Treuer 737
Psychology, Deakin University, Burwood, Victoria, Australia
Received 1 November 2012
Revised 22 April 2013
Abstract 9 May 2013
Accepted 13 May 2013
Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to critically examine the instruments used in the screening
process, with particular attention given to supporting research validation. Psychological screening is a
well-established process used in the selection of employees across public safety industries, particularly
in police settings. Screening in and screening out are both possible, with screening out being the most
commonly used method. Little attention, however, has been given to evaluating the comparative
validities of the instruments used.
Design/methodology/approach – This review investigates literature supporting the use of the
Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI), the California Personality Inventory (CPI),
the Inwald Personality Inventory (IPI), the Australian Institute of Forensic Psychology’s test battery
(AIFP), and some other less researched tests. Research supporting the validity of each test is discussed.
Findings – It was found that no test possesses unequivocal research support, although the CPI and
AIFP tests show promise. Most formal research into the validity of the instruments lacks appropriate
experimental structure and is therefore less powerful as “evidence” of the utility of the instrument(s).
Practical implications – This research raises the notion that many current screening practices are likely
to be adding minimal value to the selection process by way of using instruments that are not “cut out” for
the job. This has implications for policy and practice at the recruitment stage of police employment.
Originality/value – This research provides a critical overview of the instruments and their validity
studies rather than examining the general process of psychological screening. As such, it is useful
to those working in selection who are facing the choice of psychological instrument. Possibilities
for future research are presented, and development opportunities for a best practice instrument
are discussed.
Keywords Management, Selection, Psychology, Screening, Validity
Paper type Literature review
The MMPI
Instrument overview
The MMPI has been used in more police-related selection research than any other
instrument (Aamodt, 2004). The original MMPI was designed in 1940 as a measure of
psychological maladjustment for assessing patients seeking psychiatric help (Butcher,
2005). The test was revised in 1989 and re-issued as the MMPI-2. Both versions consist
of 567 items to which the respondent is required to indicate either “true” or “false.”
The instrument’s ten clinical scales measure various types of pathology. Any “T-score”
(standardized score) above 70 (or above 65 in the MMPI-2) indicates the likelihood of
psychological maladjustment. Three other non-clinical scales indicate how honest the
subject was in answering the questions. These scales seek to indicate if the respondent
was attempting to appear better adjusted than he or she actually was (faking good);
was manufacturing or exaggerating symptoms (faking bad, or malingering); or was
responding candidly.
More recently, a number of Restructured Clinical (RC) scales were developed to
correct for some overlap in the original clinical scales (Graham, 2006). This was
followed by the MMPI-2 Restructured Form (RF). Consisting of 338 items, this is
described as more statistically rigorous and is considered to be based on well-established
theoretical models of personality and pathology (Ben-Porath and Tellegen, 2008). At this
stage, the RC scales and the MMPI-2 RF have had minimal research attention in the field
of police applicant screening (Sellbom et al., 2007).
References
Aamodt, M.G. (2004), Research in Law Enforcement Selection, Brownwalker Press, Boca Raton,
FL.
Aamodt, M.G. (2010), “Predicting law enforcement officer performance with personality
inventories”, in Weiss, P. (Ed.), Personality Assessment in Police Psychology: A 21st Century
Perspective, Charles C. Thomas, Springfield, IL, pp. 229-259.
Azen, S.P., Snibbe, H.M. and Montgomery, H.R. (1973), “A longitudinal predictive study of
success and performance of law enforcement officers”, Journal of Applied Psychology,
Vol. 57 No. 2, pp. 190-192.
Barret, G., Polomsky, M. and McDaniel, M. (1999), “Selection tests for firefighters: a
comprehensive review and meta-analysis”, Journal of Business and Psychology, Vol. 13
No. 4, pp. 507-514.
Bartol, C.R. (1982), “Psychological characteristics of small-town police officers”, Journal of Police
Science & Administration, Vol. 10 No. 1, pp. 58-63.
Bartol, C.R. (1991), “Predictive validation of the MMPI for small-town police officers who fail”,
Professional Psychology, Vol. 22 No. 2, pp. 127-132.
Bartol, C.R., Bergen, G.T., Volckens, J.S. and Knoras, K.M. (1992), “Women in small-town policing:
job performance and stress”, Criminal Justice and Behavior, Vol. 19 No. 3, pp. 240-259.
Ben-Porath, Y.S. and Tellegen, A. (2008), “Empirical correlates of the MMPI-2 Restructured
Clinical (RC) scales in mental health, forensic, and nonclinical settings: an introduction”,
Journal of Personality Assessment, Vol. 90 No. 2, pp. 119-121.
Bernstein, I.H., Schoenfeld, L.S. and Costello, R.M. (1982), “Truncated component regression
multicollinearity and the MMPI’s use in a police officer selection setting”, Multivariate
Behavior Research, Vol. 17 No. 1, pp. 99-116.
Beutler, L.E., Storm, A., Kirkish, P., Scogin, F. and Gaines, J.A. (1985), “Parameters in the
prediction of police officer performance”, Professional Psychology, Vol. 16 No. 2, pp. 324-335.
Blau, T.H. (1994), Psychological Services for Law Enforcement, John Wiley and Sons,
New York, NY.
PIJPSM Blau, T.H., Super, J.T. and Brady, L. (1993), “The MMPI good cop/bad cop profile in identifying
dysfunctional law enforcement personnel”, Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology,
36,4 Vol. 9 No. 1, pp. 2-4.
Brewster, J. and Stoloff, M.L. (1999), “Using the good cop/bad cop profile with the MMPI-2”,
Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology, Vol. 14 No. 2, pp. 29-34.
Brough, P. (2005), “A comparative investigation of the predictors of work-related psychological
748 well-being within police, fire and ambulance workers”, New Zealand Journal of Psychology,
Vol. 34 No. 2, pp. 127-134.
Burbeck, E. and Furnham, A. (1985), “Police officer selection: a critical review of literature”,
Journal of Police Science & Administration, Vol. 13 No. 1, pp. 58-69.
Burkhart, B. (1980), “Conceptual issues in the development of police selection procedures”,
Professional Psychology, Vol. 11 No. 1, pp. 121-129.
Butcher, J.N. (2005), A Beginner’s Guide to the MMPI-2, 2nd ed., American Psychological
Association, Washington, DC.
Byrne, K. (2001), Research into the Effectiveness of the AIFP Critical Character Assessment
System for Screening New Custodial Correctional Officers, AIFP Australia, Clifton Hill.
Byrne, K., Guller, I. and Guller, M. (2002), “Slashing sick leave/attrition rates through new recruit
screening”, Corrections Today, Vol. 64 No. 5, pp. 92-95.
Caillouet, B., Boccaccini, M.T., Varela, J.G., Davis, R. and Rostow, C. (2010), “Predictive validity of
the MMPI-2 PSY-5 scales and facets for law enforcement officer employment outcomes”,
Criminal Justice and Behavior, Vol. 37 No. 2, pp. 217-238.
Casey, S., Dollard, M. and Winefield, T. (2001), Selection of Correctional Service Officers. Work &
Stress Research Group, University of South Australia, Adelaide.
Castora, K., Brewster, J. and Stoloff, M.L. (2003), “Predicting aggression in police officers using
the MMPI-2”, Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology, Vol. 18 No. 1, pp. 1-8.
Choy, J. (1998), Reducing Sick Leave in Correctional Officers: The Role of Psychological Appraisal,
New South Wales Department of Corrective Services, Sydney.
Cortina, J.M., Doherty, M.L., Schmitt, N., Kaufman, G. and Smith, R.G. (1992), “The “big five”
personality factors in the IPI and MMPI: predictors of police performance”, Personnel
Psychology, Vol. 45 No. 1, pp. 119-140.
Costello, R.M., Schneider, S.L. and Schoenfeld, L.S. (1996), “Validation of a pre-employment
MMPI index correlated with disciplinary suspension days of police officers”, Psychology,
Crime and Law, Vol. 2 No. 1, pp. 299-306.
Daniels, S. and King, E. (2002), “The predictive validity of MMPI-2 content scales for small-town
police officer performance”, Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology, Vol. 17 No. 2,
pp. 54-60.
Davis, R. and Rostow, C. (2008), M-PULSE inventory: Matrix-predictive uniform law enforcement
selection evaluation inventory. Technical Manual, MHS Inc, Toronto.
Davis, R. and Rostow, C. (2010), “The use of the M-PULSE inventory in law enforcement
selection”, in Weiss, P.A. (Ed.), Personality Assessment in Police Psychology: A 21st Century
Perspective, Charles C. Thomas, Springfield, IL, pp. 5-28, 132-158.
Detrick, P. and Chibnall, J. (2002), “Prediction of police officer performance with the Inwald
personality inventory”, Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology, Vol. 17 No. 2, pp. 9-17.
Dralle, P. and Baybrook, R.M. (1985), “Screening of police applicants: a replication of a 5-item
MMPI research index validity study”, Psychological Reports, Vol. 57 No. 3, pp. 1031-1034.
Gonder, M. and Gilmore, D.C. (2004), “Validity study: personality profiles of police officers
who successfully complete academy training”, Applied HRM Research, Vol. 9 No. 2,
pp. 59-62.
Gough, H.G. (1950), “The F minus K Dissimulation Index for the MMPI”, Journal of Consulting Critical review of
Psychology, Vol. 33 No. 1, pp. 247-255.
psychological
Guller, I. (1993), A Follow-Up Study of Appointed Public Safety Officers and Relationship of
Performance to Measured Psychological Variables, Institute for Forensic Psychology, instruments
Oakland, NJ.
Guller, I. (1994a), Evolution of a Bio-Data Instrument for the Screening of Police and other Public
Safety Personnel, Institute for Forensic Psychology, Oakland, NJ. 749
Guller, I. (1994b), A Follow-Up Study of Appointed Public Safety Officers and Relationship of
Performance to Measured Psychological Variables, paper presented at the Annual Meeting
of the New Jersey Chiefs of Police, Atlantic City, NJ, June 22.
Guller, M. (2003), Predicting Performance of Law Enforcement Personnel using the Candidate
and Officer Personnel Survey and other Psychological Measures, unpublished doctoral
dissertation, Seton Hall University, South Orange, NJ.
Graham, J.R. (2006), MMPI-2: Assessing Personality and Psychopathology, Oxford University
Press, New York, NY.
Hargrave, G.E. (1985), “Using the MMPI and CPI to screen law enforcement applicants: a study
of reliability and validity of clinicians’ decisions”, Journal of Police Science and
Administration, Vol. 13 No. 3, pp. 221-224.
Hargrave, G.E., Hiatt, D. and Gaffney, T.W. (1986), “A comparison of MMPI and CPI test profiles
for traffic officers and deputy sheriffs”, Journal of Police Science & Administration, Vol. 14
No. 3, pp. 250-258.
Hargrave, G.E., Hiatt, D. and Gaffney, T.W. (1988), “F þ 4 þ 9 þ Cn: an MMPI measure of
aggression in law enforcement officers and applicants”, Journal of Police Science &
Administration, Vol. 16 No. 3, pp. 268-273.
Henson, B., Reyns, B., Klahm, C. and Frank, J. (2010), “Do good recruits make good cops?
Problems predicting and measuring academy and street-level success”, Police Quarterly,
Vol. 13 No. 1, pp. 5-26.
Hiatt, D. and Hargrave, G.E. (1988a), “MMPI profiles of problem peace officers”, Journal of
Personality Assessment, Vol. 52 No. 4, pp. 722-731.
Hiatt, D. and Hargrave, G.E. (1988b), “Predicting job performance problems with psychological
screening”, Journal of Police Science & Administration, Vol. 16 No. 2, pp. 122-125.
Ho, T. (2001), “The interrelationships of psychological testing, psychologists’ recommendations,
and police departments’ recruitment decisions”, Police Quarterly, Vol. 4 No. 3, pp. 318-342.
Hogan, R. (1971), “Personality characteristics of highly rated policemen”, Personnel Psychology,
Vol. 24 No. 1, pp. 679-686.
Hogg, A. and Wilson, C. (1995), Is the Psychological Screening of Police Applicants a Realistic Goal?
The Success and Failures of Psychological Screening, National Police Research Unit,
Payneham.
Hooke, J.F. and Krauss, H.H. (1971), “Personality characteristics of successful police sergeant
candidates”, Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science, Vol. 62 No. 1,
pp. 104-106.
Inwald, R.E. (1988), “Five-year follow-up study of departmental terminations as predicted by 16
pre-employment psychological indicators”, Journal of Applied Psychology, Vol. 73 No. 4,
pp. 703-710.
Inwald, R. (2010), “Use of the Inwald Personality Inventory, Hilson Tests, and Inwald Surveys for
selection, fitness for duty assessment, and relationship counselling”, in Weiss, P.A. (Ed.),
Personality Assessment in Police Psychology: A 21st Century Perspective, Charles C.
Thomas, Springfield, IL, pp. 5-28, 91-131.
PIJPSM Inwald, R.E. and Shusman, E.J. (1984), “The IPI and MMPI as predictors of academy performance
for police recruits”, Journal of Police Science & Administration, Vol. 12 No. 1, pp. 1-11.
36,4
Kleiman, L.S. and Gordon, M.E. (1986), “An examination of the relationship between police
training academy performance and job performance”, Journal of Police Science &
Administration, Vol. 14 No. 4, pp. 293-299.
Lough, J. and Ryan, M. (2005), “Psychological profiling of Australian police officers: an
750 examination of post-selection performance”, International Journal of Police Science and
Management, Vol. 7 No. 1, pp. 15-23.
Lough, J. and Ryan, M. (2006), “Psychological profiling of Australian police officers: a
longitudinal examination of post-selection performance”, International Journal of Police
Science and Management, Vol. 8 No. 2, pp. 143-152.
Lough, J. and Ryan, M. (2010), “Research note: psychological profiling of Australian police
officers: a three-year examination of post-selection performance”, International Journal of
Police Science and Management, Vol. 12 No. 3, pp. 480-486.
Lough, J., Wald, E., Byrne, K. and Walker, G. (2007), “The impact of psychological profiling of
Australian correctional officers”, Corrections Compendium, Vol. 32 No. 4, pp. 1-6.
Macintyre, S., Ronken, C. and Prenzler, T. (2001), “The MMPI-2 as a tool for preventing police
misconduct: a Victorian (Australian) police study”, International Journal of Police Science
& Management, Vol. 4 No. 3, pp. 213-229.
Meier, R.D., Farmer, R.E. and Maxwell, D. (1988), “Psychological screening of police candidates:
current perspectives”, Journal of Police Science and Administration, Vol. 15 No. 3,
pp. 210-215.
Merian, E.M., Stefan, D., Schoenfeld, L.S. and Kobos, J. (1980), “Screening of police applicants:
a 5-item MMPI research index”, Psychological Reports, Vol. 47 No. 1, pp. 155-158.
Metchik, E. (1999), “An analysis of the “screening out” model of police officer selection”, Police
Quarterly, Vol. 2 No. 1, pp. 79-95.
Mufson, D.W. and Mufson, M. (1998), “Predicting police officer performance using the IPI:
an illustration from Appalachia”, Professional Psychology Research and Practice, Vol. 29
No. 1, pp. 59-62.
Murphy, K. and Davidshofer, C. (1994), Psychological Testing: Principles and Applications,
Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
Pugh, G. (1985), “The California psychological inventory and police selection”, Journal of Police
Science and Administration, Vol. 13 No. 2, pp. 172-177.
Sarchione, C., Muchinsky, P., Nelson, R. and Cuttler, M. (1998), “Prediction of dysfunctional job
behaviors among law enforcement officers”, Journal of Applied Psychology, Vol. 83 No. 6,
pp. 904-912.
Saxe, S. and Reiser, M. (1976), “A comparison of three police applicant groups using the MMPI”,
Journal of Police Science & Administration, Vol. 4 No. 4, pp. 419-425.
Schoenfeld, L.S., Kobos, J. and Phinney, I.R. (1980), “Screening police applicants: a study of
reliability with the MMPI”, Psychological Reports, Vol. 47 No. 1, pp. 419-425.
Sellbom, M., Fischler, G.L. and Ben-Porath, Y.S. (2007), “Identifying MMPI-2 predictors of
police officer integrity and misconduct”, Criminal Justice and Behavior, Vol. 34 No. 8,
pp. 985-1004.
Shusman, E.J., Inwald, R.E. and Landa, B. (1984), “Correction officer job performance as predicted
by the IPI and MMPI”, Criminal Justice and Behavior, Vol. 11 No. 3, pp. 309-329.
Simmers, K., Bowers, T. and Ruiz, J. (2003), “Pre-employment psychological testing of police
officers: the MMPI and the IPI as predictors of performance”, International Journal of
Police Science and Management, Vol. 5 No. 4, pp. 277-294.
Smyth, B. and Byrne, K. (1994), “The Use of Specialized Psychological Assessment Methods in Critical review of
the Selection of Applicants to the Victoria Police”, unpublished manuscript, Australian
Institute of Forensic Psychology, Melbourne. psychological
Super, J.T. (2006), “A survey of pre-employment psychological evaluation tests and procedures”, instruments
Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology, Vol. 21 No. 2, pp. 83-90.
Surrette, M.A., Aamodt, M.G. and Serafino, G. (2004), “Using MMPI special scale configurations
to predict performance ratings of police officers in New Mexico”, Applied HRM Research, 751
Vol. 9 No. 2, pp. 71-72.
Weiss, P.A. and Inwald, R.E. (2010), “A brief history of personality assessment in police
psychology”, in Weiss, P.A. (Ed.), Personality Assessment in Police Psychology: A 21st
Century Perspective, pp. 5-28, Charles C. Thomas, Springfield, IL.
Weiss, P.A. and Weiss, W.U. (2010a), “Using the MMPI-2 in police psychological assessment”,
in Weiss, P.A. (Ed.), Personality Assessment in Police Psychology: A 21st Century
Perspective, Charles C. Thomas, Springfield, IL, pp. 5-28, 59-71.
Weiss, W.U. and Weiss, P.A. (2010b), “Use of the personality assessment inventory and police and
security personnel selection”, in Weiss, P.A. (Ed.), Personality Assessment in Police
Psychology: A 21st Century Perspective, Charles C. Thomas, Springfield, IL, pp. 5-28, 72-90.
White, M. (2008), “Identifying good cops early: predicting recruit performance in the academy”,
Police Quarterly, Vol. 11 No. 1, pp. 27-49.
Winters, C.A. (1990), “Problems of variance in the utility of the MMPI in the selection of
metropolitan police”, Police Journal, Vol. 63 No. 2, pp. 121-128.
Wright, B.S., Doerner, W.G. and Speir, J.C. (1990), “Pre-employment psychological testing as a
predictor of police performance during an FTO program”, American Journal of Police,
Vol. 9 No. 4, pp. 65-84.