./1439+2018 '(
 ,2030    !

"#
 $%   ,3 
 ,30  ,

 
 
1658−7677:3 ./1439+2018 ,508 − 479   ,2030    !"#
 $% ,3 
 ,30  ,

 
 

&
'( #$% !"       
 
 5 23 4 /01 . 2030 )* + , -
8$9% 2* .+ .* .+ 67
<1:

:; ; "3789 36

./1439+09+07 < =;
@A> ;./1439+06+19 < =;
>

." (
 . .(
""I

.8O P./L M.N < ,EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI JAG#3 K CD 8
 B/ :=3*
a.%A
 .# Pb `/ "T_#
^JAG# ]I MN < (G#
 "
R S
T3 UI VN ,
 !"I < WUUX# (YE Z[ \3 2030 Q

,"Q.#
 J""I
.8O ,i.#_ ,P./L .
 HZ;.3 J.E .#I  g Qh \3 BEI EA#8 !"UI !I ,d_Q def
 HZ; c
.;" c. .ZT"AGI !.I ,2030 .(
""I
8O P/L MN < JE ]I (GI JAG# #I JA 105 c B#k ,!T#
 ,GjEL
< .8
 .Z#%
> d.#
 (.G#
 JAG#3 c [ :nA$ [ ;"
 (o T3 Hp#;
 J(Zqo ,
 !"I < U#l
m 92 \3 BEI d#
 8

o u;.6 Jn.v# iw.I T [ < 
 x ( [  ,4.56−4.43 W T [

 r8# !"> B% (I a"% ,Qs  _ V"t
< J d.#
 ""I
.8O P/L MN < Q"p(
 ""AG
 
 H/;3 JE3 (GI "e"
S
T U#
 M;A a%A
 > ]
y MN < ^e"q

{`.
 S
.T U#
 \3 :e#8O ,2030  P/o MN < ""AG
 
 H/;3 (G#
H3( VN MA
 : z 8
 Bf o ^2030 
^|;3 3
 :e#8O "T_#
UUX#3 ;6 @A> \3 }(GI |#[(3 |""TI :D 8
 |#N(

^2020 d;~
 _#


€ H3E( ,H/; (GI ,
 HZ;3 JE3 ,
 uI :? @,
_________________________________________________________________________________

A Suggested Proposal for the Requirements of Developing Secondary-Grade Natural-

Science Curricula in the Light of the Strategic Aims of Saudi Arabia Vision 2030
According to Science-Teaching Specialists
Ali Hasan Hussein Alahmadi(1)
Islamic University of Madinah
(Received 07/03/2018; accepted 22/05/2018)
Abstract: The main intent of the present study was to determine the requirements for developing natural-science curricula in the light of
the strategic aims of Saudi Arabia vision 2030 according to natural-science-teaching specialists, and to set a supposed prospect for
development in the light of such requirements. In order to render such a purpose, the researcher employed the descriptive approach to
conduct a five-section questionnaire related to components of natural-science curricula (aims, content, teaching strategies, activities and
evaluation). The questionnaire contained 105 items related to the requirements for developing natural-science curricula in the light of 2030
vision. The questionnaire was administered to 92 natural-science teaching specialists. Statistical analyses of the available data proved the
participants' consensus as per the proposed development requirements. Mean scores of agreement among participants ranged between 4.43
and 4.56. No statistically significant differences were detected in the rate of agreement due variables of gender or employment. Consequently
the researcher designed the proposed development prospect including all major components of natural-Science curricula in the backdrop of
strategic aims of the 2030 vision. The study recommended the necessity of conducting curricula-development prospects particularly in
natural sciences in the light of 2030 vision, benefitting from the present proposal, revising and evaluating it by a committee of specialists in
order to make the utmost use of it.
Key words: science teaching, science curriculum components, curricula development, national transformation program 2020.
_________________________________________________________________________________
(1) Associate Professor in Curricula and Methods of Teaching Science,
^"3789 36 ,:
 "$ ,"

 !Q> ,
 uI x(~ H/;3 < j y#8L 1
Education Department, College of Dawa, Islamic University.
41452 {ƒ
 w3(
 ,6959 ‚  ,Q
 " (
  ,:; ;
Madinah, Saudi Arabia, P.O. Box (6959) , Postal Code: (41452)

e-mail: ahha555@gmail.com:„

9 ƒ


– 479 –
 ^^^EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI JAG# S
T3 UI :{†L WQ% \ \Q% \ …

< u".
,Z" `[ Jn"vI ˜%D /(GI 7 :$

< @ ,rT |If (/Y
 ™
 HZ; J"k €
(.GI ,d."#
 .Y;
 S7.fD 
ˆQ3 @F‡
|..#>7 ,|.. Wv#j..  o ,"..88L |..IE3 .;# < ".88o "‰.> ,"
 |I" |IE3
{..‘ ’(..T
 J..AG#3 .._E |..Z"[I ,V#.. .."‹#[O U..#>O Jn..v#
 Z#..N( ,Š..
^|j"E {`
 \=
 |.InI Œ.
 `./  !Q# d#
 "TF
 "8"Q

d#
 H/; ”( o \3 ""AG
 
 H/;3 I
€ J_#
 I ^# :
 |Inv#3 ,Q#
.
 r.  P. (G#
 J"
(#8 V‰š \..3 |..#Ž%o ..3 ,.."
 ,.."[
;#
 ,.."(
….._ ..# ,|..#œ" ,’Q..E9 :.."_ ..›T"AGI Jƒ.3 i.>o \.3 ,:Š. J.# < JnvI
,}‰.> |I7j.3 @.% < ./  @"eI ,d
 ,J_#
 ]I Z[ ,"8
 H/; (GI "
\.3 |.;‡ d.#
 pU.s ]. {`.
 (.e
 M; ‚"#..8 @..F3 ‰..> c.. w.."$

 J.. !..Ž \..3
^|.Inv#3 |." ž" {`
 Œ
 P (q V3 Ÿ"#

€ €
,:."‘ J.Z3 .";I ,.Z;3 \#.
 "[
;#

‹.$ .
 !".I < "AT#Q. JZ[#
 ’o f ,..Ze"qI ,..Z[#ED .."e"$ ,..( J o ’..TID
d.‹#[O x"Q.
 c $¡I BI 2016 !E  ($`I m
\.3 .p73 :[ ~‹Eo W W# ‚Q$D
J.Z ‚7G
 ‚Q$D ,
 !"I < …3#
 ,"fL !"T
 c "$ˆ#
 ,ne#
 “"
8o JZ
$j. ,:."‘ i3 !#
 Ze3 ~D < ,;# H/.; (.GI .; ._3 .
o ;~ ”w#O
^|" ‹L JO ,V# < 
e
 ’
.8 "j.I o ;2004 ,!"/(. D :8 "8

< ,".8
 |./;3 .
 !"I Zk > d#
 J_#
 ]I \N •; ^2004 ,{w;"$3
S7.f9 J" \3 
 Q
 " (
  !".T
 {.K ,fU.
m . –(.
 —
 |[I
.. ".
€ .8(
 ..""#
 ..$(‘ :ˆj..E `..;3 ,(.G#
 ‹F#.8O ,( W~I ,(R TŽ !Z ,b
d..#
 ,1408 WU..‘ ($`.. ‹..$ 1925+.../1344 ..";#
 ..3 < d..
 a.._A
   @.."eI ,..Z"
P. .GAI(3 Bq ¢o OD ,ZA"
8o ›  B;I ^2002 ,‚% ;2004 ,!"#
 :”  ";~

B.8 d.#
 ,3j.
 ";#
 P/o "TK / u"p ..;/;3 < (..Y;
 :..D |..$ ]..
y “[#Q..
V.# (e
. '.Z;
;ZQ."8ˆI `.;3 .b 

 \.3 ,J._#
 ].I .Z[ .

€ :ˆ$ ,"8


– 480 –
 ./1439+2018 '(
 ,2030    !"#
 $%   ,3 
 ,30  ,

 
 

m .EF
 .%( < BTA~¨

™.
 .
 \.3 M. ^3T#  
 “$( x_
 ,{Q

^../1395+1394 d..#
 ..(G#
 @..%( }`../ !"Q..TI \..
.";~
 ©L E#8O %(3 :F
F
 %( V.. o CD .. < ..""AG
 ..
 H/..;3 ›Z..k
< ";~ Jƒ JMe$ !‰I ,UUX#3 ’6 d/ ;2015 ,{.†L ;1436 ,dF_A
 w"#

€ w$(3 @%(3
(.G#
j#8 J;T$ B ,JUUX#
 Ÿ#l ;2004 ,H"s  
–(
 "

 “#3 ;2011 ,!F
V# J[% V3 e# ‹ ,ZTI "8
 H/; :1984 ,(Gs ;1408,WU‘
< ,Œ
 P (q ";~
 ";#
 JAG#3 {Q
 MjED V3 Jo u"8ˆ#
 %(3 :C L %(
" (
 
:w"# "‹#[O ";
 B F
 @q £..373 ”(.. o B..F‡ ,.../1344 .. P.. ..(3
\.3 ,.
 (.G#
";~
 :©L BE$ ,Q
 ,".8
 .Gs \.N 
HZ;3 (>D < (G#

’.$ ,../1399 . Z"j.I !I d#
 ©L }`/ C o ¦..A3¤ ,¥_U..
 M"..kL¤ :..#3 M‹..8o B..K
:. ".8
 r.Gs @I [(3 ›3Z8D ”( o P (.q B.N( .> ,¥_U.
 .
¤ ,¥

P`.‘ (.G#
 ,""#
 @%( Ÿ#l < 
 B.o ,." (   \.3 H/.; E#8O JA

VN ,H/; i#_ nˆ#
 !T#
 ,A#8O `./ (#.8 ,Q
 œ"A
 “8;#
J7I Z"
!Ž ,
 d3 Mo (G#
"A#
 H3ƒ
 rGs a."% ,../1373 . P :” MjED §#% VN

”.ED \. (Žo {`
 H/; (G#
@3j
 ª = G < 
 “"UE ” H/; (G#
’6 Bk
^J"N(
 
 H/;3 pŽ ^@%( V"6 8

H/.;3 (.GI ª =.3 .%(3 : (
 %( P.. :” B..3> a.."% :.."EF
 ..%(
“.#3 P«D B.K Jo. d#
 J"N(
 
 (.>D V.3 .7" J;"AQ
  < "
%
m !"#

V.3 "Q.;#
 ’ .#
 ,H".s  .
–(.
 "

 w$(. E#.8O ,.";#
"Q.s .ZGG 


E#8O ,M‰L  
 < !"#
 "

 J” ."(3L 3
V #
 J"N(
 
{


J.>I a."% ,U.UX#3 ."g " :ƒ J"A ..
:..[ “..#$ H/..;3 M..; < ,J n.. <
,.";~
 J$=.
 i%D V3 Q
 !"#
 :” ,. < !".#
 .8"8 c. w.I(I ,J"N(

Q..Q
 ].. {`..
 d..A;[L ]=..
..F$ , .8o
m :.3
m .F‘ "
 JTG; c #I

– 481 –
 ^^^EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI JAG# S
T3 UI :{†L WQ% \ \Q% \ …

P/L \3  d"I

8 P/ @$ \3 BTFAE . ./"# M[ d#
 ,McGraw-Hill "(3L
27 /. „F
 i#Q P/o | GAI( "(e
 ."#O (T#Q"
;@87Q
 \3 
,‰"e#Q3 8
\.3 . d( P/ @$ \3 rA;#8 ,"( m
­ / a."% J".N(
 
QQ
 }`/ c Z;
 <
¯.. a..
F
 i#Q.. P../o ""U..e#
 P../L V."t < B.TA~ ,.""#
 ./3 3M3 t(I !I
J«¡. . F d/ ,""UeI
­ m 96 …
 Z
/ +1429 .
 \.3 M.
m ,"¬.I
­ 
 !"#
 @%(3
.GAI( J = rGs H3ƒ
 `"e;I |[I
€ d#
 ^./1430
^2016b ,2030  (
d379 w$( (
 W. "Ž
 ®AIO i3  Q
 '(
 ”ƒ¨
..."(e
 ""I
...8O P.../L }`.../ Jw..."‡
€ (..GI J.." ,.. < ..";~
 ..";#
 r..G
(G#
 `"e;#
 °"T
Z#" > Z#E ( ""Ue#
 ]I ’o A# ,
 H/;3 Z" ‹ ,"8
 H/;
""I
8O P/L @F#I ,(
 H3( 7 \3 S.;
.
 :w.e_ @.3
 ƒ$o \3 J"

"3789 !"T
 wwI < BF‡ P/o #8 < ,Q"p(
 € rGs ]I
^Z/o TK
.";I ,"_.f :(3. :."% W.‡ ,";~
 b Q..
 .." (
 .. .. JM..[ ..>
w.wI ,Ÿ."q#
 JO.3 :.” ,U.#>O V;I .GX$ ,2016 +../1438 . .Z; \o d#
 ,2030
^"‹#[O "
¡Q W‡ ,3‘ " <  3% Z#;AI ,:[ 3k ;I "%7fD
< }  !".#
 ."±o (
 }`/ J”( o > ,|.Inv#3 Œ
 “
G3 A$ ‚ 
 Z"8 ~D
W3‰. \.3 .
 B;‰.I a."% ,Z/o "TK ˜7Ž CD ;#8O 7 \3 @AT#Q CD :T 

€ #
 (G# U
 Jy J«¡
B.v ,!".#
 ! d3789 –(
 
 d/   #š !p
""_ {(¬#
 8 Jko ‹$ «¡3
m 26 A(TI d.#
 wp$(
 d/ ,‹F#8O :T
 ,<(v6 V>
 o V"t B
;I ,2017 „(/w
 8 2017 ,{."‘ V.# ,˜7F.
 .(
  .g Z"
D ;#QI
V# (
 {g BK Jw$(I ,""#
 3Y; d.379 w$( SG
 \~
 ,(/w U#>O
.(
 }`/ A$ Z"8 < ^(/w3 U#> {"% ^2016a ,2030  (

”(. o ._# !".#
 :” B3> ,%G
 Z( ""I
.8 P./o #.8 c (
 B#k
.." (
 .. < !"..#
 |..[I d..#
 J.._#
 €
,.Ž7F
 ./ g \.3 T#j.3  L i#Q P/o

– 482 –
 ./1439+2018 '(
 ,2030    !"#
 $%   ,3 
 ,30  ,

 
 

W/..[ <(..G ..3% ..8 J..[ ,".8
 H/.; :.[ „.I

€ /”( o \3 ,Q

@"U.K i#Q.3 '.eXE 2012 ´A€U.
 –(‘ Ÿ..N ,.."T#
 u..#
 x(..~ c.. ‹#..O
@...% n...e#
 °..."T3 < ...A#O < ‚7...G
 ^2017 ,!".#
 :”  W i
!T#
 JZ3
 .f ,.e
 .% \ "
  < J7j ""I
..8O Z../o \..N :”..
 J..% `..

`."e;I  .f ,H/; ]I i#g JN3 µ (.GI P/ ,2020 d;~
 _#
 H3E( < !"#

."A#
 H3ƒ.
 ŸN ,HZ;
A%U GjEL d.379 w.$( !.T#
 !".#
 “"
8o H/;
^
 d 3T ^63^ ,2016c ,2030  (

’o 2014 ..3% \Q..% ..8 J(..Zqo TAG ""AG
 
 H/;3 Ž% \3 ! (

J_GU.. !"/..e VAj..3 H/..; }`../ i..#g CD ./(GI . (² ;#.8 ,.EF
 .%( < "
%
­
,/`."e;I “U. HZ;. GjEo µ ’o ‹$ ,‰3v
 € OD ," "[(3
d.#
 ."T#
 J.8
 Hp#E ’o

 d d;Z (G#
 9 ŸN \ 7‰ J.> \3  \ Bej$ H/; }`/ c B([o
^H/; }`/ `"e;I c WpT
 J(.Zqo T ,/`"e;I "
³ |[I d#
 UT
 d%E
MN < ""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI ’¶ ;/ \3 CD B./ d.#
 1436 d.F_A
 w."#
 w.$(3 8
i..%D .. a..%A
 i(.. ‹..$ ,2030 .. .. 
 !"#
 J"N(
 
 (GI ª =3 !TI
;.Z[ \3 H/; }`/ (GI S7f9 3b JGs „‹.9 “E6 wwI CD 
 H/;3 [% ,
}`./ J.[(l H3ƒ. S7.f9 `/ r  A$3 i..#_ r..  ..";~
 !"..T
 w..wI ,i..#_ <
M.A
 .GTE ,i(o Z[ \3 "AT#Q ";~
 (
 .";~
 .Z6 ”(. D ,|I7j3 V# J[_
:.D ,H/.; }`/ (GI [(3 7 \3 ’I . Ÿ.(#
 ,V.# .3 < !ZQ.I d.#

^(
 JAG#3  ›E3  "f CD .[_ H/.; ’o ‹$ ,Z>3 
""AG

:,B $$A @."eI ,/`."e;I < ;" ";T#
 U @"eI !
,2030 . ’7¶ 

·‘ |[#
 @q < ‚7.G
 "U.Xk ”(. 9 ;HZ;.
A%U GjEL
V."t ’o c. /."$ˆI ,"AT#Q.3 ";~ @ GX$ a_A
 ’ #
 @f#
 !"Y;#
 JZ3 !Q$D
7. Q.
 ." (
  < "AT#Q Vj ^Œ
 Jnv#3  !›A  !b"3 “8; ‹

– 483 –
 ^^^EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI JAG# S
T3 UI :{†L WQ% \ \Q% \ …

%
¸ c ’R §#% 
 H/;3 (GI 2030  W .(
 }`./  .g CD ;#Q.I ’o “¬ ,AT J;Q

^a%A
 ! y..šO d..[( ..~9 ’#..8 d..#
 ,Z../o
a%A
 i
A (
 [‘ J(Zq T ;/ \3 w.$( /`."e;I bA> Vj ]I % J(T

. (
""I
8O P/L W  T3 M; < ,2030 Q..
 .." (
 .. ..(
d..379
,..EF
 ..%(
..
 H/..;3 J..E3 2030
.(
 }`/  ,JE }`/  "f :D (GI
`/ ¦ "e
 "88L JAG# K "AT#Q
\. S
€ ’L ^13^ ,2016a
B..
;I J..8
 \..3 ..>
< ‹.$ ,’R §.#% "8
 H/; 2030  >7
8 2017 !"% 8 2017 {A
 8
.T3 UI VN 7 \3 , T #
 !"#
 < "8
 H/; ’o J[ 2017 „(/w

^Z"eI  T ]I £"NI < !ZQ ’o .A$3 c. :> n  ,·‘ ZN ,d36 

:'
$ C'D (..G#
 CD ..Z#[% ,..";~
 2030 .. W3‰..3
.8
 œ.8o ’¶. ,8
 j3 MN < ^(
 JGI P/o A$
:·#
 < _#I
€ "
‘ p.Ž
[(3 \3 a%A
 | > 3 7 \3
.""AG
 .
 H/.;3 (GI JAG#3 3 − 1 .8"8 .T"Ž ,2030 Q.
 ." (
  
.(
""I
8O P/L MN < EF
 %(
..
 H/..;3 (..GI ª =..3 ..T"Ž ,!"..#

!"..I < WU..UX# (..YE ..Z[ \..3 2030 .. W. $
j.3 ®.TE [ Bej$ d#
 ,J"N(

?
 .3 M.N < ,
 H/;3 JE3 (
 W3‰3
i#Q.3 ; "pU%D
­ 
 x ( [I @/ − 2 .
 H/;3 V> B
;I d#
 J8
 |; Bej$
J.AG#3 c. WU.UX# .T3 [ < α=0.05 8 1436 dF_A
 w"#

€ w$(3 8 @F3 :G
M.N < EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI ,2014 3% \Q% 8 2012 \(³ 3%
iw..I 2030 .. ..(
""I
..8O P../L \3 
 < ,(G#
 [( CD H/; }`/ [%
?e"q
 u;6 Jnv# .TF H/.; }`./ r (. .# .3 .f ,ZAE[
.
 H/.;3 J.E S
T U#
 3 − 3 ..";#
 J..AG# ..Z#>7 ,|I7j..3 ,V..#
.(
""I
.8O P./L }`./ M.N < ""AG
 .>7
 B.
;I J8 [  @q < ,";~


– 484 –
 ./1439+2018 '(
 ,2030    !"#
 $%   ,3 
 ,30  ,

 
 

J.AG#3 JŒ.#> a."% ¥œ"A
 ! 'L ! ?2030 Q
 " (
 
i.#_ P./L¤ Q."p(
 .›E3 c. (G#
 :' $ #$D
...""#
 Gj...EL "Q...#
 J""I
...8O :CD 8
 }`/ B/
^¥!T#
 H/.;3 JE3 (GI JAG#3 ”( o K − 1
7. B.‡ .8
 JM([D :G )1$F P./L M.N < .EF
 .%(
.""AG
 

H./1439 +1438 ™
 
 ^2030  (
""I
8O
:' $ I .
 HZ;.3 JE S
T3 UI !TI − 2
n.v#
¤ |Eˆ 2010 e"s |( :/  P.../L M...N < ...EF
 ...%(
...""AG

o Z‰. < o "(e
 HZ; JE3 %o < de"
 ^2030  (
""I
8O
."TK < HZ;. :M.e$ V. CD {¡. {`
 ,Z"t :' $ ED
^ ¥3j.
 ";#
 @[o \3 d"#
 Y;
 J  .
g .¢$ < .8
 }`./ ."±o ”ƒI − 1
^286 Ÿ..""I 2030 .. .. @.."e#
§Q..I .."F_
2017 !E.  .Z(I :J   ..%(
..""AG
 ..
 H/..;3 (..G#
Z;"3‰..3
."
 i#Q. .GAI( J._ \3 ¤ ¢ˆ ^ EF

d"#
 Y;
 \3 :j; J[(X "TK < H/; c WpT
[ `vI nI < !ZQI > − 2
eQ. @j.I ,".8 J.Z[ @.A> \3 N {`X#3 \G3 \3  < ""AG
 
 H/;3
GjEL !#
 !"#
 x(~ }#g |/o HZ; ^
 H/;3 < (
 P/o W‰I < Q ,(>
^12^ ¥!T#
 x(~ ""#
 U − a%A
 ! % c − 8
 }`/ I − 3
Jƒs W3‰ ¢ˆ "p([D
­ a%A
 Z( .
 H/.;3 (GI  ;#I d#
 C L J8
 \3
." (
 . .( U.
 Jy 

 ""#
 ^2030 Q
 " (
   MN < ""AG

J.E3 < .Z"eI Z;"‰I S
T 2030 Q
 :' $ )1$
V.3 Q; EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 ";
€ ""AG
 
 H/;3 :7" )1$F
^›Z[I (
 }`/ P/o M""
 Mw"e
 M"%L¤ H/;3 d/ 8
 }`/ <

– 485 –
 ^^^EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI JAG# S
T3 UI :{†L WQ% \ \Q% \ …

o ."pw[ Jn."vI ˜.%9 .[‘ i.3 o VN
 :2030 JJ, JJ- &
JJ'( #$JJ%
^|" "88o `"e;#
 °"T
 > E(3 Q"p P/o #8 \ :A
:/71 ' $ KL :  @.$ < ./(GI !#. ,.(
 H3(. 7. \3
!"..I < WU..UX#
€ 
< .8
 V..# @.F‡ ."T_#
J.A \.3 .3w% \‰#I ,"Qh r"Gš
.;" .8
 :L ‚#.8 a"% , < 
 ].I .TK CD Z < {¡I d#
 H3ƒ
 J[(l
u#
 œ"/ M‰o Bk ,V# `/ \3 "pj ,2030 .(
d379 w$( ""I
8O P/L
J.36 < .
 uI x(~ H/; Uš < H2016b
‰.o
m B.k ‹.$ ,‰.
m 54 !/ ¯ ,Q
 :' $ /
JD < W3
 \3 
 H/; W

 W= {`.
 ,d_Q def
 HZ; 8
 BAI
m
\ …
 
 £AU"
,=3 38 !/ ¯ !"#
 HZ;. |.Eˆ 1999 .‘ A ° J"A |(
1 .6 ,U.UX#3
m 92 .8
 :».
 #8 o :(/.q \. JE" J33 Vt c # {`

^8
 ;" (o V”I £N c. P(.#
 |.
·.‘ VN
 K UT ;3 V>
`./ "%7.f i.3 ( |" Ÿ‰
 :T
 “E[

HNO1 ?P QR1  )RD KS H<1: M1$0

Y& 8+ #X VW $7* T'D U B T'D T'D ?P

68 35 2 9 16 6 ($y
u;6
24 3 − 7 11 3 §FEo

92 38 2 16 27 9 ª

™8L |[ BE$ d#
 ,2030   pŽ :' $ Z)D
‰..o ,EA#..8O J..A  ..g M..; < a..%A
EA#.8 !"U.I !.I ,.8
 '(.  "T_#

..8 @..F3 T Q..
 J..8
 µ.. CD ª..[(
 :·#
$ , g Qh \3 E3
^2017 „(/w
 8 2017 ""_ {(¬#
 J.E3 c. B#k "
o EA#8 D − 1
;W."
 X#8 :L xf \3 T_#
 − 2 CD ª[(
. ].
y ,(G#
. ."; "Q."p(
 HZ;

– 486 –
 ./1439+2018 '(
 ,2030    !"#
 $%   ,3 
 ,30  ,

 
 

ZT"AG# ]
y ,…
 xQIO X#8 xU
 \3 { y \.3 W.g Q.h c ZN( 7 \3 :‹b o

m 15 \.3 "pj. .;" c

@.33 .K !.I ,(. ,.
 u.I x(.~ H/.;3 < UX#
 :ƒs
Q.s  ._ \.3 .g @.$ r.8#3 W ®AIO 7. \.3 @#
 !I ,JY%7 µ   o a"%
^2  6 £N ‹$ ,@$ EA#8O r8#3 T_#
 :‹Z"EŽ ^Z‰ @I JA
 µ P`%

H' $ Z)D 1I [ ( \ 5] H<2: M1$0

5  B% N $ _`1 &
'( ^I #$% I
**0.95 **0.96 **0.97 **0.96 **0.84 ®AIO @33

 
 
 
 
 ** ∞=0.01 
O
 i#Q3

J73..3 !"..> 3  ..6 £..N ,J..AF
 ‚Q..‘ !.I a"% ,/ g :L JAŽ \3 T_#
 − 3
^JAF
 Cronbach Alpha ½..AE ($ ..e
o @..33 X#..8

H7?  1W1 ' $ Z)%  a 5] H<3: M1$0

6, 5  B% N $ _`1 &
'( ^I #$% I

105 18 22 10 27 28 JA
 

0.99 0.98 0.99 0.98 0.99 0.98 JAF
 @33

,.[
m .3 ™‹.s J(."
°."T3 .  [9  ._
J.AF
 J733 !"> B% (I a"%
(.T#
^.[
m .3 n  ,3 n  ,g ,3 @$ :»
J.AF
 @33 "> Bv ,0.98-0.99 W
.# ,@.$ ._ J.A
 c. .T [ ^:L TF
 ”wI "
 "> d/ ,0.99
£.N ‹.$ "AQE ’” o CD Jœe
 !"QTI c a%A
 \.3 ."pZ;
 ›U. 8
 :o BEI − 4
^4  6 @p. Bv".f > , g Qh c ”3 :A 105

H'(  7 b7  )RD R 0 ) $ H<4: M1$0

$0 QR cd QR cd $W QR $0 QR R 0 )

1.80 \3 @>o – 1 2.60 \3 @>o – 1.80 3.40 \3 @>o – 2.60 4.20 \3 @>o – 3.40 5 − 4.20 i

– 487 –
 ^^^EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI JAG# S
T3 UI :{†L WQ% \ \Q% \ …

, (Cronbach Alpha) .e
o ½.AE ($ @33 X#8 ƒ "E


D EA#8 CD EA#8O @K !I − 5
…
 xQIO JAF
 ¬9 ’8n ®AI @33 !.I a."% V> c BYe% Google drive 3
,T#Q J;"
J A# X#8 ,/ g :»
< WU.UX# \3 8
 ;" c "E­

D Z”I
JOO .8
ANOVA {.%L \A#
 @"K :r (
 ƒ 
 !"I
^;"
 (o W x (e
 ^https://goo.gl/forms/eZ0A9OXmPDAR6uzC3
:/B]1 /A1 ' $ e h7 U.#
 !"_#
>G !"U# a%A
 > − 6
J J   :M1% Mi* +0j < WU..UX#3 W.g Q.h c. B.N( ,S
.T
#$JJ% !JJ" JJ JJ JJ JJ .> ,|.
% !Zp³ `L 
 uI x(~ H/;3
JJ4 JJ/01 .JJ 2030 JJ, JJ- &
JJ'( µ.. ..No J..Y%7 µ.. ’.._ i.. o
? 5 23 ^ZpN < @#
 Z‰A `L !I ,J%
T
–Q..‘ r..8# ‚Q.._ .. [9 B..‡ :ef g'%
c. .;"
 (.o .T3 [
{" P(_EO € ¨
”(..
 H3..E( X#..8 J..E"A
 B..%
:… ‹$ ,’3 @ T# JAG# MU...%9 “"
...8o B...TA~ ,SPSS "pU...%9
." J.(_EO " Q‘ JG8#$ def


^’ `/ JAG#3 _E ;"
 (o  #8 Hp#E 5  [ £N :#$% −
H   #$D   b7  )RD R 0 $ 8  #I(1 m*F n' H<5: M1$0
0 )
g
 #I( n'  
R
[ 3 1 0.52 4.77 ^Q
 " (
 
";~
 b /”( D 4
[ 3 2 0.63 4.77 ^!# i
"I"‘ "UXj
 JZ ";I c /"$ˆI 10
[ 3 3 0.59 4.75 ^"ej

€ 

 ®A‰EO ’TI9 £3Q#
 !"> c /"$ˆI 3
[ 3 4 0.54 4.73 ^"AT#Q ;/(
 {Q
 !# J[‘ ›(3 9
[ 3 5 0.72 4.69 ."G8
 HZ;3 c /"$ˆI 2
[ 3 6 0.81 4.68 ^d3789 \
 ¦A3 c /”I 1
[ 3 7 0.70 4.64 ^W# i
"‹#[O JZ ";I c /"$ˆI 11

– 488 –
 ./1439+2018 '(
 ,2030    !"#
 $%   ,3 
 ,30  ,

 
 

H<5: M1$0 oK+

0 )
g
 #I( n'  
R
[ 3 8 0.61 4.63 ^T
 T
 < |IAG#3  < {"‘ V# !p
ZX"8(I 8
[ 3 9 0.69 4.63 ^( V# J">7o JAG#3 !"T
/”( D 12
[ 3 10 0.70 4.60 ^@
 x8 J["#% JAG# Z~AI 17
[ 3 11 0.67 4.59 ^"AT#Q U#>O  JZ[I c /"$ˆI 16
[ 3 12 0.78 4.55 ^V"
"_U
 :"‘ nI JAG#3 Z 19
[ 3 13 0.88 4.54 ^d3789 –(
 d
 ˜9 ”w#O (/Y3 c /"$ˆI 7
[ 3 14 0.82 4.54 ^:"‘ i3 (#Q ¾`
 !#
 ¦A3 c /"$ˆI 27
[ 3 15 0.97 4.53 ^"8 v$ " (
 v
 E3 c /"$ˆI 5
[ 3 16 0.70 4.51 ^"
 — < Š d
 d">9 V>
 :(3 14
[ 3 17 0.78 4.51 ^3#Q ";#
 ¦A3 P/o V3 ZTI 18
[ 3 18 0.83 4.51 ^V# < ";~
 :%
 r   ! @"eI 24
[ 3 19 0.88 4.51 ^8‹ @
 !#
 ¦A3 c /"$ˆI 25
[ 3 20 0.86 4.50 ^"
 "‹#[O JQ8¡ HZ; < ""#
 GjEL W >7
 /”( D 28
[ 3 21 0.83 4.49 ^"e"q
 "
 "EQE9 ( JO /"# 13
[ 3 22 0.94 4.43 ^2030  Q
 " (
 
"AT#Q JZ[#
 /”( D 15
[ 3 23 0.89 4.41 ^{©L \3L J>7
 r  (
 Z 20
[ 3 24 0.93 4.41 ^V# < dG#
 @
 TŽ wwI c /"$ˆI 23
[ 3 25 0.95 4.34 ^d‹#[O \3L J>7
 r  (
 Z 21
[ 3 26 0.96 4.33 ^HZ; GjEo `"e;I < :©L V# «D \3 Z;"‡ 22
[ 3 27 0.93 4.27 ^"EŽ " v$ w"E9 v
 c /"$ˆI 6
3 28 0.98 4.19 ^£

 |"

 !#
 ¦A3 Z"eI 26
[ 3 0.79 4.54 …
 r8#

.(
 \.3 V. (
  L d"I

.8O P.b BK JA % ;"
 M³ ’o 5  6 \3 £‰#
JO3 :” ";~
 b "3789 !"T
 wwI a."% ,[ 3 [ Z < JM[ _ `/

 !"I < WUUX# ‹#/ (ZY ¿ ,Ÿ"q#
 ’o  ..6 £..N ‹..$ ^4.54 …..
 r..8# ¯..
!/.D ‚7.G
 ";I ,";~
 b wwI "±ˆ V.. L “..I( c.. BU..% 9 ,3 ,10 ,4 J..A

H/.;3 7. \.3 ,."">
­ .Z3
­ "(3
­ @AT#Q
•.;I d./ ,^4.77−4.73 W. S (I r8# C L

– 489 –
 ^^^EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI JAG# S
T3 UI :{†L WQ% \ \Q% \ …

c. .
 H/.;3 < ";~
 b "3789 !"T
 < !"#
 8"8 T"Ž <  3 V3 e# `/ ,

{.A
 .8 J".fI V3 !Q; ,“"I

 
o :w"# "UXj
 c 28 23 ’I J$o yD ;
m
< e..N I..[ W..#
 2017 !"..% 2017 !"#
"88L v
 c Q
 " (
 

,.."
‘ "..8
 H/..; < !"/..e }`../ W‰..I m
. wI ,73.#3 m
_"_.f m
‹.Z 7.89 !.Z d/
‹". ./(GI H/.; ].I [(3 : z #f o P. | Q.$D ,"37.89 !"
#
 !"T
 “
G

^“E6 }` # ,:M;A
 "$Q
 J/²O ";I ,e#X JZ
26 ,6 ,22 ,21 J.A
 ’o 5  6 (ZY ‹$ m
:”  |.# M.; < .E m
‰ ’"
(e
 œ"›
,:n..L V.. L “..I( < ·..#
 c.. JM..[ ^1416 ,!"#

.T3 .[ 4.34 –4.19 W. B% (I JG8# .

 J.Z[#
 V3 "#;
 }`/ !Q;I ‹$
\.3 ].
y @.T O ,3 [ 3 W B% (I "j..I o ..8 ($`..I ‹..$ H/..; (..GI < ..F‘
P.b < ;‰.#3 JM.[ d.#
 J.AG# }`/ "±o ”w..#O J"$..8 J..% d..#
 2004 \(..³
"37.89 !".T
 w.wI „.F
  L d"I
8O 
% ,(e
"‹#[O "
¡Q …_#
 ,;~
@j. "_.f :(3. :."% W‡ ";~
 b ,P7#.O @.ATI
€ ª;#
 (TI ,GQ
 ,\(R
\.3 (ˆ.# ZA"I(I a%A
 Àe ,«A3 n  «A3 ”(.. o \..3 ../A# ,3T#..8O xU..
 ..8¿
d.#
 J.AG#
"AQ.;
 ."±»
,.;"
 (.YE Z[ ’(..T
 < ‚7..G
Q..$D d..vA; d..#
 J"$Q..

^ ET3 ,Z#TA8 ^\=
 {‘
w.w# .GAI( J.A
 }`./ U.% ’o ‹$

^’ `/ JAG#3 _E ;"
 (o  #8 Hp#E 6  [ £N :^I −
H  ^W +   b7  )RD R 0 $ 8  #I(1 m*F n' H<6: M1$0
0 )
g
 #I( n'  
R
[ 3 1 0.79 4.57 ^""AG
 J (F
  œ"A
 † x(~ @p8 |;‰I 14
[ 3 2 0.82 4.54 ^ < |Eo Ÿ#X ˜#
 \3 ‘ “"
8o |;‰I 13
[ 3 3 0.83 4.50 ^"
 "_ “
G
 œ" < "I"‘ Ÿ> |~AI 2

– 490 –
 ./1439+2018 '(
 ,2030    !"#
 $%   ,3 
 ,30  ,

 
 

H  ^W +   b7  )RD R 0 $ 8  #I(1 m*F n' H<6: M1$0
0 )
g
 #I( n'  
R
[ 3 4 0.90 4.50 ^/"k(I “"
8o ›T"AGI  < ;# >G
 U3 }”( D 11
[ 3 5 0.79 4.49 ^";T#
 "
 JO <  < {‰‘ G#
 }”( D 7
[ 3 6 0.83 4.48 ^3#Q ";#
 P/o ¦A3 !"/e3 |;‰I 15
[ 3 7 0.86 4.48 ^ < ";T#
 "
 JQ8¡ }”( D 9
[ 3 8 0.99 4.47 ^T;
 ª 9 ’TI9 F9 ’ #
 JZ3 !"T
}”( D 27
[ 3 9 0.84 4.46 ^"_U
 >
 x(~ “"
8o |;‰I 17
[ 3 10 0.92 4.46 ^ < ›T"AGI :# >G
 !"/e3 |;‰I 12
[ 3 11 0.86 4.43 ^d
 d3789 –(
 ˜

 c Y_ !"> !"/e3 |;‰I 6
[ 3 12 0.90 4.42 ^";T#
 
  < 8 •y‹E J"UXj
}”( D 10
[ 3 13 0.90 4.40 ^"‹#[O (e
 "
¡Q !"/e3 |;‰I 3
[ 3 14 0.85 4.39 ^
d
 d;~
 ˜

 c Y_ !"> !"/e3 |;‰I 5
[ 3 15 0.92 4.37 ^"
 JO < (‘ d;Z @
 JT"AGI !"/e3 |;‰I 26
[ 3 16 1.03 4.37 ^";T#
 "
 2030  W3‰3 }”( D 1
[ 3 17 0.94 4.36 Á
^^^dp ,dp`v
 ,dœ"A
 ,{;#
 }f §#j \3L !"/e3 |;‰I 25
[ 3 18 0.88 4.32 ^3T J3s "_U
 (
 JQ8¡3   }”( D 16
[ 3 19 0.95 4.27 ^dG#
 @
 !"/e3 |;‰I 4
[ 3 20 1.03 4.27 ^p7 ";U
 U#>O !"/e |;‰I 23
[ 3 21 1.09 4.23 ^}f §#j  < {‰‘ G#
 }”( D 8
[ 3 22 0.97 4.20 ^

 Z3TI d#
 "
 "‹#[O J3s }”( D 22
3 23 1.04 4.18 ^HZ; `"e;I < :©L   ”ƒI !"/e |;‰I 19
3 24 1.14 4.11 ^ ( 37Q
"88L !"/e |;‰I 18
3 25 1.15 4.01 ^HZ;
p73 "N GjEo |;‰I 20
3 26 1.10 3.97 ^HZ; "# |"

 “"
8o W >7
 }”( D 21
3 27 1.19 3.95 Á
 ^^^^"Ž

 ,"œ"A
 ,"
 ,""AG
 ,";
  < %"Q
 !"/e3 |;‰I 24
[ 3 0.95 4.34 …
 r8#

H/.;3 i.#g r  ,œ"A
 † JAG# #I d#
 JAG#3 c T [ ’o 6  6 £N
€
.>G
 U.3 ,."
 "_ “
G
 œ"A 
 a"% ,[
m 3 [ Z < JM[ ,_ `/
 L V. L “.I( < JM[ ,/"k(I ›T"AGI JA
 ’o £‰# ‹$ ^4.34 …
 –Q‘ r8# ¯

– 491 –
 ^^^EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI JAG# S
T3 UI :{†L WQ% \ \Q% \ …

H/; i#g < Z;"‰# i; (GI J/² I r.8# !".> B.% (I ,.[ ."
 .T3 [
.8 B.f o ‹.$ \=
 {‘ ’(T
"8
 !.I “.E6 }`./ V."t ,^4.57–4.50 W b –Q‘
\.3 .I B.>
 Jy < ,2004 \(.³ "j.I o (
""I
8O P/L < Z" "$ˆ#
 /”( D
!".% 8 J[ ‹$ ";~
 b wwI JAG#3 :(3. :."% W.‡ a.
F
 „.F
 Wb f
^2017 ^U#>O V;I ";I "_f
d#
 JA
 |#;‰I 3 V"t ’o a%A
 i( c. BU% d#
 JA
 ’o  6 (ZY ‹$
< .Z[D ,.[ .3/ .I _ `/ BK J ./ .Z" .$o .3/ !"/.e3 B;‰I 3 [
,.(
 P/o "T_#
_3
€ :G  H/; i#g "
¡Q W‡ °Q
 Pb a
F
 „F
 (

7.. \..3 }`.."e;I CD !"..#
 :” §Q..I ..3 ../ ,d..G#
 @..
 @..F3 £..N @j.. .."‹#[O
^2020 d;~
 _#
 H3E( < ›A3 ." < :©L $j.3 w.wI ,. ( 37Q

!"/e }`/ V"t ^";~
 %"Q
 ,|"

 ,!"#


^’ `/ JAG#3 _E ;"
 (o  #8 T# Hp#;
 7  6 £N :N $ _`1 &
'( −
HN $ &
' +   b7  )RD R 0 $ 8  #I(1 m*F n' H<7: 5] M1$0
0 )
g
 #I( n'  
R
[ 3 1 0.66 4.68 ^ne#
 ";I c pT
 u#
 J""I
8 "AGI 4
[ 3 2 0.77 4.63 ^8 • @ 8‹ @
 !#
 J""I
8 "AGI 2
[ 3 3 0.74 4.61 ^J7j @% MUT#8O Pj#$O c !pT
 !#
 J""I
8 "AGI 10
[ 3 4 0.76 4.61 ^¾`
 !#
 c pT
 u#
 J""I
8 "AGI 5
[ 3 5 0.858 4.58 ^# O a_A
@
 x( „" @
 c pT
 J""I
8O "AGI 8
[ 3 6 0.77 4.57 ^!"#
 ";T#
 H3 c pT
 !#
 ""I
8 "AGI 9
[ 3 7 0.76 4.55 ^J = c pT
 !#
 J""I
8 "AGI 6
[ 3 8 0.93 4.51 ^rj;
 !#
 eQe GAI( x(G
 J""I
8O "AGI 1
[ 3 9 0.82 4.51 ^{ƒX @
 c !pT
 !#
 ""I
8 "AGI 7
[ 3 10 0.87 4.35 ^£

 |"

 !#
 r (I d#
 x(G
 J""I
8O "AGI 3
[ 3 0.79 4.56 …
 r8#

– 492 –
 ./1439+2018 '(
 ,2030    !"#
 $%   ,3 
 ,30  ,

 
 

À.e ‹.  `./ ^2008 ,!"#
 :”  "
%

­ AG `./ c. T [ ’o 7  6 \3 £‰#
< 
L c F
F
 "EF
 C L JA
 U% r8# ¯ a"% ,[ 3 BE$  @j _
^;"
 (YE Z[ \3 “"I

 `. .T# JA
 V"t ’o ‹$ ^4.56 …
 –Q‘
@..
 ,¾`..
 !#..
 J""I
..8 ’o ‹..$ x(.~ J""I
.8 (.GI JAG# rAI( _
< /. JM.[ J =. !"U.I ,.( \N ."
 T3 [ c BU% 
 H/;3 uI
™.
 HZ;. Je.f3 V.3 # `/ ,“"I

 \. ^4.68 – 4.35 W. JG.8# !".> B% (I
\(.³ "j.I o ($`.I ‹.$ \=.
 {‘ ’(T
x(..G
 J""I
..8O ’.. .."#;
 }`../ nQ..eI
\.N @.
 ,:"‘ i3 !#
  a"% ,2004 J.Z[#
 V.3 .#I ,;/ ZN( !I d#
 "Q#

\.3 ,J =.3 CD HZ;. .Z3 µ @K ,( 
 H/;3 < "
­ ZT"AGI o d#
 ,F‘ 


:©L c.. “..¬ d..#
 J"$Q..
 J..Z !../o {.;I d.#
 ,".N ."T
 J;Q
 < , <
!".#
.ZT"AGI ,Z.8(  V# HZ; 8 @j. |.$«D ,!".#
 ." g “
G
 @
!".#
 :” B.N `
,‚7G
 \3 T
 @"6 :.6 Jƒ.s M; ,!#
 J‹Z3 `"e;I < dT"T%
J.A3 :. 2020 d;~.
 ._#
 H3.E( \N CD .ND ,."p;A
 T Q.
 |IƒX ZG  7 \3
i.3 !#.
 :.A3 .Z;3 J""I
8O }`/ @"e#
.."T"AG#
 .."pL n..e#
 .."T
 |..IZ3 ..";I
^3#8O :"‘ .Z" .> d.#
 ¦.A V3 # 3 / ,8‹
.""AG
 .
 J".N(
 H/.;3 (.GI ª =3

^’ `/ JAG#3 _E ;"
  #8 8  6 £N : B% −
H B% +   b7  )RD R 0 $ 8  #I(1 m*F n' H<8: M1$0
0 )
g
 #I( n'  
R
[ 3 1 0.78 4.63 ^8‹ @
 !#
 r (I " rjEo !"UI 1
[ 3 2 0.73 4.57 ^œ"A
 † !I HZ; < " GjEo !"UI 18
[ 3 3 0.83 4.55 ^STEM |[I c pT
 
 J =3 "AGI !"UI 12
[ 3 4 0.82 4.53 ^8 • ;# @
 JQ8¡ HZ; r (I " GjEo !"UI 2

– 493 –
 ^^^EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI JAG# S
T3 UI :{†L WQ% \ \Q% \ …

H B% +   b7  )RD R 0 $ 8  #I(1 m*F n' H<8: M1$0
0 )
g
 #I( n'  
R
[ 3 5 0.78 4.53 ^3#Q ";#
 P/o !I HZ; < " GjEo !"UI 15
[ 3 6 0.86 4.51 ^STS V# ";T#
 
 |[I c pT
 
 J =3 "AGI !"UI 13
[ 3 7 0.81 4.5 ^"E" Jw
 J7%(
 c TI " GjEo !"UI 3
[ 3 8 0.83 4.5 ^!# i
"
 !"T
 d;I "p(ŽD " GjEo "AGI !"UI 9
[ 3 9 0.83 4.5 ^
 < ";~ "g "83 JT Q3 !"UI 11
[ 3 10 0.79 4.5 ^"E

9 !#
 V>3 JU; !# r (I " GjEo "AGI !"UI 22
[ 3 11 0.78 4.49 ^!# i
¾`
 !#
 ”wI " GjEo "AGI !"UI 8
[ 3 12 0.84 4.48 ^"
  #
 JZ3 d;I GjEo !"UI 21
[ 3 13 0.88 4.47 ^STSE |[I c pT
 
 J =3 "AGI !"UI 14
[ 3 14 0.84 4.47 ^";Z ‹L ”ƒI HZ; < " GjEo !"UI 17
[ 3 15 0.82 4.43 ^{U#>O d
 d;I HZ; < GjEo !"UI 19
[ 3 16 0.97 4.42 ^!#
 < ( " GjEo "AGI !"UI 7
[ 3 17 0.94 4.39 ^!#
 < "‹#[ GjEo "AGI !"UI 10
[ 3 18 0.87 4.36 ^""#
 "Z"

 d‘ Eˆ HZ; r (I " GjEo !"UI 4
[ 3 19 0.89 4.35 ^©L J>7
 !I HZ; < " GjEo !"UI 16
[ 3 20 0.95 4.33 ^"G#
 V# JQ8¡ 8 r (I " GjEo !"UI 6
[ 3 21 1.03 4.26 ^"G#
 ‹L ”ƒI HZ; < " GjEo !"UI 5
3 22 1.00 4.17 ^(Z6 #3U
 :M(T
 JZ3 d;I GjEo !"UI 20
[ 3 0.86 4.45 …
 r8#

Z3X#8 j#E \3 K "; 3 J>3 \3 „I c. .T r.8#3 ’o 8  .6 \.3 £‰#
./g < 2030 . "$ˆI @q < `
,;83 < CD nj.I ."> d./ ,4.45 ¯. ._ `/ JAG#3
d.vA; ,@.
 !#
 r  c (/w3 U#> „F
 ..;"
 (..o .."# M..[ ..> ^.."
 ..T3 ..[
Gj..EL (.G#
;J.A3 S(..~ !".#
 :” c. ,..
.."T"AG#
 ..8‹ U..
 Jy Gj..E»

.3
­ Z ,|[#
 `/ V3 #I ,H/; GAI( .."EF
 C L ..AI( < ..œ"A
 ..GAI( Gj..EL
^Pb `/ "T_#
;";
­ "±o u `/ ,·#
 c 4.57 4.63 ¯ r8#
2020 _#
 H3E( \N :”
 :A3 I w.I O d.#
 .
 GjEL "
 “E6 @"eI

– 494 –
 ./1439+2018 '(
 ,2030    !"#
 $%   ,3 
 ,30  ,

 
 

@"U.._#
.."
 J«¡.. < .

€ .T#3 Ÿ";U..I "
o :G ° ‚7G
 “#
"; Â n#
..
 J.Z[#
.."

 .8
 ¾ˆ..I ,d."#
 .# “.G# M.[ ‹.$ ^].
y ."T_#
[ A8;3
# ‹" JT Q }`/ ”( ˆ$ TIMSS J"N(
 (.YE m STEM |[I c p> J =3 "AG#.
m ;F
Ž
. 
 < ";~ JT Q3 3>D ’¶ `
,
 o d#
 "3#
 JZ[#
 ”( o \3 |[#
 `/ ’

,‚7G
 i#Q3 V < !ZQ ‹  ,:6 "
 n3 :” "> {o(
 `/ ! ,
 !"I < Z3X#8
].I CD .f
 \3 !Z;‡ d#
 Jƒs !/ wI S(.G 2020 d;~.
 ._#
 H3.E( \.N !"#

\.3 11 9 J.A
 |#;‰I 3 / ,"
 J«¡ ."[
;#
 .
 !".I (GI w$(3 MjED :A3
JT Q.3 .3>D ,."p(ŽD " GjEo !"UI 7 ,|.[#
 `./ !.
(STEM) J"N(
 8;b
^
  < ";~ "83 Ã%7 ^
 H/;3 c  ¬D
m u;"8 {`
 (3L
B
;I d#
 J8
 ’o CD ;/ a%A
 nj $j.. "‰..> c.. Jw..$ 2030 .. P../o ’o
w."#
 w.$( ."T#
 8
$ "
‘ 
 H/;3 Gj..EL ,..""#
 .."
 < .."# ..©L
Bej$ 2012 \(³ 3% 8 1436 dF_A
 ..3 ../ ,.."
 ,..";Z ,.."Z"

 ,.."G#

..""#
 Gj..EL `.."e;I V..;‡ ,J..>3 ..[ \.. ,.._ `../ \..N J d..#
 J..AG# |#;‰..I
}`b "
‘ (G#
 "
³ ’¶ `
,H/; }`b A%U 3 3 W B% (I T3 [ c BU%
,HZ;. < Gj.EL }`/ !"UI :D w#QI GjEL u3.s d"I
.8O P.b |.3 # `/ ,[
V.3 ,Q.
 .œ"A
 ªG#Q > ZG  ZG"QAI c. ;. {`.
 d;~.
 _#
 H3E( < :”

`.."e;#
A..8; \$..3L ..¬D °. ..œ"› :.D 7. \.3 ,‚7.G
"88L JZ !"T
 wwI
].
y !.
€ ,;"  J3w#Q nI ,GjEL .Eo "eU.
 n.  Gj.EL < $j. “Q.E V
c.{."% V#  L /g < 2030  "$ˆI ^%25 %57 v
A
 "
 J«¡ CD M"%L
Gj.EL c. w"$

. .

 .3Y; (.GI "±o !"#
 :”
V (
 d"I
8O Pb $o ‹$
“..
G
 "U..Xk ..";I < !ZQ..I d..#
 ,..;# V.(
dQ
 "±o c 2020 d;~
 _#
 H3E( <
^{Q
 ."

 J.A#O < ‚7.G
 Hp.#E r.8#3 Hp#E
c U‘ ,· 
 Hp#;
 r8# ET3 TIMSS

– 495 –
 ^^^EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI JAG# S
T3 UI :{†L WQ% \ \Q% \ …

^’ `/ JAG#3 _E ;"
  #8 Hp#E 9  6 £N :5 g'D −
H5 g'D +   b7  )RD R 0 $ 8  #I(1 m*F n' H<9: M1$0
R 0 ) g
 #I( n'  
[ 3 1 0.84 4.61 ^^%#e3 ¢ ,"N3 ,|"
T3 HZ; < œ8L ®‹Eo V;I 2
[ 3 2 0.87 4.60 ^p73 ;#3 !TI “"
8o x(~ X#8 1
[ 3 3 0.70 4.59 ^[(
 `v#
 J" HIE \3 :e#8O 15
[ 3 4 0.80 4.58 ^dT"T‘ @A
 !T#
 “"
8o "AGI 10
[ 3 5 0.73 4.5 ^HZ; < "U"XjI JA# "AGI 5
[ 3 6 0.83 4.5 ^d
 ML Y%73 °"> c # !T#
 “"
8o "AGI 9
[ 3 7 0.86 4.5 ^ej
 JA#7
;;T3 
 !TI “"
8o "AGI 3
[ 3 8 0.85 4.49 ^"
 " °"T
!TI “"
8o "AGI 14
[ 3 9 0.79 4.49 ^!T#
 J o JAŽ xf \3 T_#
 < " “"
8o "AGI 18
[ 3 10 0.87 4.48 ^œ8»
"3 ; MjED 4
[ 3 11 0.80 4.48 ^"
 J/²O °"T
!TI “"
8o "AGI 13
[ 3 12 0.83 4.44 ^8 i#Q3 c HZ; < ;;T3 JA# "AGI 6
[ 3 13 0.89 4.44 ^!#
 < ¾`
 !T#
 “"
8o "AGI 12
[ 3 14 0.92 4.42 ^HZ; < TIMSS @F3 "

 JT Q œ8o F#8 8
[ 3 15 0.95 4.39 ^" "E

9 !T#
 “"
8o d;AI 16
[ 3 16 1.00 4.36 ^!#
 < ’(>L !TI “"
8o "AGI 11
[ 3 17 1.05 4.33 ^

 i#Q3 c %( # < w$(3 ;;T3 JA# "AGI 7
[ 3 18 1.00 4.28 ^A8_ JA#O "AGI 17
[ 3 0.87 4.48 …
 r8#

U.T
 .k `"e;#
 "
³ ’o OD ,"
‘ 
 H/;3 T BE$ WUUX# M³ ’o 9  6 WA
€
}`./ X#.8 c. W. :.>  Z;3 ‚A8L ¯. a."% ,. @j. ._ `/ c "
 [
`..
,!Å..
!..T#
 J..Z3 Ÿ..N ,“"
..8L J..A
 V.."t ’o ‹..$ ^4.48 …..
 –Q..‘ r..8#
“"
.8o H/.; (.GI P/ !"#
 :” BN ."
 .T3 .[ c. BU% _ ` T#
._#
 H3.E( < JZ#Q %ˆ$ !T#
 !"#
 ! (
. ^4.61 – 4.28 W. JG.8# !"> B% (I
^2017 ,!"#
 :”  2020 d;~
 #I JAG#3 \3 _ `/ |;‰I 3 µ ’$ \3
;J..AG# \..3 .
m . J..A
 B;‰..I ‹..$ < |.
;I !#. ,.""AG
 .
 H/;3 !TI “"
8ˆ

– 496 –
 ./1439+2018 '(
 ,2030    !"#
 $%   ,3 
 ,30  ,

 
 

.A"b 3Œ.
 :D (e
 ¡I 

 "TK .."AGI ..Z;3 ,H/..; }`../ !..TI “"
..8o (..G#

.> M(.[9 }`./ @.F3 ’o .f ,""#
 "
,œ8»
"3 ; MjED ,"U"Xj#
 JA#O
m :”
 |#TA~
. |.TD @.A> {EF
 !"#
 < T 8 B..% (I .."
 ..T3 ..[ B.."Y% ..Z"t
^1429 "AGI “G#3 ’o Ã%7 ‹$ ^4.50–4.48 W ›G8#3
$J7 J) _1JR $0 a :p Mi* +0j "AGI “G#3 ,%( # < w$(3 ;€;T3 JA#
2J3 R 0 ) α=0.05 ($ ^* ,."
 T3 [ c 7U% ,A8_ JA#O
J J J J   b7 U.
 Jy J«¡. ."$ˆI @q < |Eo a%A
 i(
J, J- &
J'( #$J% !"  Ÿ."q#
 JO3 :” V (
 d"I
8O Pb
??P1 NO cr ^G 2030 ¡.I WQ.K ,"88L !"#
 J[(l WQK c
J ..A# X#..8¨ ¡Q..
 c.. .. [Æ
:.D !".#
 :”.
\. |.E¶ ,!"#
 < (e

J.[ ’D − x (e
 JOO _#
;T#Q J;"
..%( < ..ZT"AG# M..A
 ,W..AG# \`../ ..8
^10  6 £N ‹$ §FEo −($y u;6 nv#3  − ,J.[(X .² < !ZQ."8 ].
y ’.$ yD ,EF


HNO cr QR1   b7  )RD R 0 ) _1? (() $$I <: s e H<10: M1$0
($ ^*  ] 8  #I( m*F n' NO 

0.59 4.47 ($y

*0.047 -1.89 P/L
0.49 4.73 §FEo

0.77 4.29 ($y

0.97 -1.08 i#_
0.76 4.49 §FEo

0.72 4.48 ($y

*0.022 -2.01 u#
 J""I
8
0.48 4.80 §FEo

0.75 4.38 ($y

0.131 -1.61 ""#
 GjEL
0.60 4.66 §FEo

0.76 4.37 ($y

*0.023 -2.38 !T#

0.51 4.77 §FEo

0.67 4.40 ($y

0.064 -1.93 …

0.51 4.69 §FEo

α=0.05 () ^* $7 ej () T _1R )01 u*

– 497 –
 ^^^EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI JAG# S
T3 UI :{†L WQ% \ \Q% \ …

c.. ..T ..[ < P7#.. ..[ ’o ‹..$ .
 x (. .[ . 10  6 \3 £‰#
,T Q.
 .Ž7F
 ."(e
 JE
(G#
 JAG#3 (G#
 JAG#3 c ;"
 T3 [ <  @j
\3 WUUX# i
"
 ;> [ a%A
 }Àe < .
 x (. J.[ W.% < ,u;.6 n.v# iwI
,.Ž7F
 JE < (G#
 JAG#3 \‰#
Ç ,˜E9 P./L¤ d/ HZ; JE3 µ (GI JAG#3
V#.. :«..A3 ..f Jy HZ;.. < ..3/ “..E[ £
U.
¥!.T#
 “"
.8o u.#
 J""I
8
@.F3 :.[ !"/.e3 “E[ c /"$ˆI ,:©L ’$ CD  @j "#;
 }`/ a%A
 w ^˜E9
/"$ˆI ,"I"‘ JZ ,"UXj
 JZ ";I ."> JM.[ ‹.  J.E }`. GAI( JAG#
JA#O |"

 !#
 ªG#
 ¾`
 !#
 c < J# d#
 (G#
 ¦A3 J[% V3 Q;3
d.#
 !.T#
 !#.
 “"
8o \3 /n  "U"Xj#
 .Z" BU.E d#
 ,"
‘ 
 H/;3 (GI ª =3
Z;"‰.I ."±ˆ ‹.  ’T# 3/ (GI d%E I Q;3 ,2004 ,–(
 "

 “#3 ª = T"Ž
X#.8 !.I ^.""AG
 
 H/;3 < ƒ$o [ !"..#
 B..
o d..#
 2030 .. J..Z[I V..3 ‰..o
JOO ._#
ANOVA {.%L \.A#
 @"K .3 ./ ,Z" nA$
m AE[
m ,fU
m "8
 H/;
^11  6 £N ‹$ e"q
 nv#3  x (e
 ^;"
 (o V"t |" eI

H?P cr QR1   b7  )RD R 0 ) _1? (() $$I . aA e H<11: M1$0
aA #X T'D T'D
VW T'D
. 8+ $7* U B

#I(

#I(

#I(

#I(

#I(
n'

n'

n'

n'

n'

($ #

0.43 0.96 0.60 4.52 0.73 4.23 0.33 4.73 0.59 4.56 0.77 4.30 P/L

0.16 1.6 0.66 4.46 0.45 4.46 0.55 4.41 0.84 4.33 1.16 3.74 i#_

0.44 0.94 0.69 4.58 0.57 4.60 0.31 4.80 0.79 4.47 0.77 4.30 u#
 J""I
8

0.32 1.1 0.71 4.48 0.45 4.68 0.38 4.67 0.81 4.41 0.93 4.05 GjEL

0.46 0.91 0.70 4.44 0.16 4.56 0.32 4.71 0.80 4.48 1.06 4.15 !T#


0.35 1.1 0.62 4.49 0.47 4.51 0.32 4.66 0.74 4.45 0.83 4.11 
 r8#

– 498 –
 ./1439+2018 '(
 ,2030    !"#
 $%   ,3 
 ,30  ,

 
 

T Q
 J8
 Hp#E | Bf o 3 V3 T#3 JM[ .
 x (. .[  11  6 (ZY¨ a"%
w."#

€ w.$(3 8 /”( o H/; }`/ B
;I d#
 J.AG#3 c. .;"
 (o T3 [ <  @j
.8 1436 ,J".N(
 
 !"I < dF_A
 ,#.X Zvj. d.#
 .e"q
 n.v# iwI (G#

^2014 3% \Q% 8 2012 \(³ 3% w ^’3 @$ i#Q3 c 
 r8# < ]
y
,
   :v Mi* +0j \.3 .;"
 (.o V."t ’.$ CD ."#;
 }`/ a%A

, - &
'( #$% wx !" / ."
 :ƒ.s ’.# {`.
 W/¡ WUUX#
?2030 )* + .."$L !Z#..8¿ V..> \..3 ,..""#
 .."

S
..T3 U..I M..; !..I ¡Q..
 c.. .. [Æ
«A !Z$#% ,H/; ’"3 < "
 "F_A

£.N 1 @j.
 ,.""AG
 .
 H/;3 JE !Z7~ ,Us |[ c :G 
 H/;
^|IE3 S
T U#

 •y;
 CD .ND ,H/.; }`.b 3b (G#
 J["#% c
.
 H/.;3 (.G#
J.AG# }`/ |#;‰I 3 ’$

– 499 –
 ^^^EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI JAG# S
T3 UI :{†L WQ% \ \Q% \ …

8 < ‹$ H/; }`/ B3>

€ d#
 T Q
 J8
 :
  !+ N'D
r.  CD .[‘ ‰.o ,1436 d.F_A
 w"#
 w$(3 .""_#
 [( CD S
T U#
 M; ;#8
2030 . W3‰.3 JAG# H/; }`/ JE3 .T"Ž ,2030 Q.
 ." (
 .  pŽ

^ < ";#
"AT#Q @
 G ƒ#I d#
 J"..N(
 H/..;3 (..GI ª =..3 !"..#
 ..8"8
:
  x? { ..;" M³ £Q.  .."E" Hp..#;
 ,..""AG
 ..

;!".#
 :” \.3 UUX#3 ;6 @"jI − 1 ^
 !"I < WUUX#
,.. G . ,$j.. ."; J..Z6 ._#
:zR1)1
   y
G  @
 @%(3 (>D ,Z#Q J[(X ’o c. .$o {`.
 

d8(
 |[#
 − 1
^:g ";3” ’o “¬ ,AT J;Q
 7 "AT#Q Vj V"t
."(e
 ""I
.8O P./L [(3 − 2 d.[( .~9 ’#.8 d.#
 2030  CD ;#QI
."
 U
 Jy 2030  \3 TFA; J«¡ w..$( /`.."e;I ..bA> ..b% J(..T
 y..šO
(..GI J..A3 (..>9 .."Z‡ ;..›E3 ..""#
 ,2030 Q..
 .." (
 .. ..(
d..379
^"8
 H/; ^2016a

€   :..A3 (.>D − 3
(..GI :.A3 !..8 .K Z..../o \... !"...#
 :” ’7...D − 2
d;~.
 ._#

€ H3E( \N ""AG
 
 H/;3 ."T_#
2020 d;~.
 _#
 H3E( < ""I
8O
."
 J.Z6 $j. !"#
 :” Z" P=I c. V. (
 d"I
.8O P.b .$o yD ;2030 
^UUX# \‰.I !.T#
 !".#
 “"
8o H/; (GI
(GI :A >7
 Jy J«¡ K − 4 ".8
 H/.; "; < [ •yE (G#
:A3
..K V..3 ,..ZT"TK J.."
³ ..""AG
 ..
 H/.;3 :.A3 ,“.
G
 c. .# !".#
 _E _#

^:A `"e;I @%( ML °"> J«¡3 !"I (GI w$(3 MjED < BF‡ 
 !"# f
,(
 W3‰3 W J>7
 K Œ% − 5 ^STEM J"N(
 8;b ";T#
 

^""AG
 
 H/;3 JE3 < .."
‘ ..""AG
 ..
 H/..;3 ..[% − 3
W3‰.3 W. .3M H3
 " `"e;I − 6 J"..fI ]..
y B_..N o ‹..$ (..G#
 CD ,..

– 500 –
 ./1439+2018 '(
 ,2030    !"#
 $%   ,3 
 ,30  ,

 
 

:
  *e , ^""AG
 
 H/;3 JE3 ,(

H/.;3 (G#
%
T P/L :#$% − 1 ..
 H/..;3 :..A J..#;3 .."AGI − 7
,2030 . M.N < EF
 %(
""AG
 
 ^2030   :G ""AG

P./o  "U.
.G;3 ’#.8 ,i :" P/o ”....E9 i#Q....3 !....TI ....[(3 − 8
^Ÿ..f @..$ < ..
 H/..;3 "..8
 PeU..
 ..[( !..T#
 ..G .. ..TT_# J..[(X
^%
T 
 H/;3 P/o £N 12  6 ^(
 H3ƒ
:#

H2030 - &

'( #$% !"      
 #$% H<12: M1$0
#$%

   #$D 
&
'(
’Q.E9 ’.
.E”# 3j
 "G8
 |I(YE d3789 \
 JTG;3 ¦A3 CD ;#8O È ’‹9 B"AFI Á"8(I 1−1
^:"‘
°.eE < ./w;
 .

 ij.
 ®A‰.EO ’ #
 ’TI9 £3Q#
$ "fL "3789 J">7L !"T
 °(  2−1
^
 !"I !I < p J"$Q$ ZT"AGI /”( D ,‚7G

d.#
 .w c !Z7~ 7 \3 ,‚7G
 °eE < \~
 `b fs b "$ˆI ,Q
 " (
 
M‹#EO wwI 3−1
€ 7 \3 !Å
\~
 “% !"/e …
 Á"8

 ,7A
 }`/  È 
^
 !"I !I
5 GG
< M‹;.
 .T#
 :nQ.3 (#.8O 3”7
 ";T#
 "
 JAG# ,}GI @%(3 ,{Q
 V# pUX Ÿ(#
 4−1
|1 \'f 1
^@AT#Q
H`
!"I < Z3X#8 wwI ,";T#
 "
 Œ
 Jnv#3 A$3 c :> |"%
€ "fo "8 v$ Z;"‡ " (
 v
 ”( D 5−1
^

!"I !I < J3Z89 }`/ \3 •y‹E £NI F3o !TI ”( D ,d3789 –(
 d;~
 d
 !ZŽ¶ ‚7G
 Ÿ(I 6−1
^d
 d">9 d;~
 i#Q c 

,‰.‘ .""AG
 .Z3 . ~.; Ÿ.(#
 7. \3 ,{Q
 V# < ";~
 :%
 r   ! @"eI 7−1
^"
 J"
e
 J"T# 3>D 
A# Jw
 V"jI
^V"
"_U
 :"‘ JAG#3 nI ! 1−2
^/n  JT Q ,"
 EL @F3 d
 ª Æ
:”w ""#
 œ"A
 nI ,
 < " 7G
 “/ V"jI ! 2−2
€ !"I 7 \3 ‚7G
"‹#[O "UXj
 "I"‘ JZ ";I 3−2
^
 !I Z7 Z 2,}
2
u".p j.$ "# "
 JQ8¡ W ,HZ; `"e;I \ 
¡Q3 ""I Q8¡$ 8 W >7
 ”(  @"eI 4−2 HI~1
^
 !"# U
 Jy $
j ""#
 GjEL 3>D 7 \3 ,P/L "TK `"e;#
 <
^
 !"I 7 \3 V# < dG#
 @
 TŽ ! wwI 5−2

– 501 –
 ^^^EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI JAG# S
T3 UI :{†L WQ% \ \Q% \ …

H<12: M1$0 oK+

#$%

   #$D 
&
'(
^
 !"I !I < 3#Q ";#
 ¦A3 P/o @"eI ”( D 1−3
!Z". .";I A.8; J(.T
 y.š < .Ze"qI \.3 !Z;.‡ d.#
 ,.p7 U#>O JZ !"/e ‚7G
  wI 2−3
^{U#>O
‚7G
;# "
 Jƒs @"/ˆ#
 “#
 ( nI 7 \3 @
 x8 J["#% JAG# 
 !"I r  3−3 K1 
3
^@
 xQ x_#
O \3 !Z;‡ d#
 8
 M;Žo H)](
^
 !"I < " " v$ w"E9 v
 c "$ˆ#
 V3 ( V# ZAG# d#
 "88L JZ ‚7G
 ‚Q$D 4−3
< !ZZ[.I d.#
 J7j. @.% "[#E9 :Me
 :w
J ˆ$ F‘ J";T#
d
 X#8O c ‚7G
 “I 5 −3
^!›"%
^"AT#Q @
 x8 J["#% 3M 3”7
 JZ P ‚7G
  wI 1−4
^"
 :"_
‚7G
 œ"Z#
(#Q “#
 ¾`
 !#
 x(~ @"eI 2−4
^
 HZ;3 7 \3 „" …
 "AG#
 8‹ c TI d#
 "Q#
 x(G
 J""I
8O "AGI 8¿ 3−4 ($ Z)S
4
< .
e
 $j. :Š. .";T#
 J.T"AGI V3 @3#
 c \> (o \I < !ZQI 3#3 }wZ "83 œ" nI 4−4 HP
^Z[#ED
^“8; d;Z !ZAT#Q3 "# K \3 !Z; ‹ e#X 
 JO _E !›/² !b"3 K < ‚7G
 :Q3 5−4
^
 8 7 \3 ‚7G
 °eE < "N A8_ E3L /w;
 !"> Á"8(I 1−5 7R GG
5
^/‹F#8 @A8 Z" Y_ x(~  < "‘  ‚7G
 Ÿ(I 2−5 H,F
^
 !I 8 7 \3 ‚7G
 < d# d
 ";I 1−6
1i* 2,}
V#. .8 r (.I d.#
 .""#
 Gj.EL Ÿ."FI 7. \.3 .©L ."‹#[O r  (
 J>7
 TI !"I 2−6 6
H7@0(
^d[s

,i(.o .Z[ \.3 .""AG
 .
 H/; "UUX#
 .T

€ .%
T P/L MN < :^I − 2
’.
 7. \.3 /`."e;I \. d#
 "
 d/ W3‰ U
 Jy ,""#
 JƒX
F3o U#

,(.G#
 ." \.3 %( }`/ ´ ; UUX# ,:.w
 (.G#
N Jƒs }`/ ,2030 
d[3..EO @.. X#..8 ..;/ a..%A
 S
..T !#. ’o “.¬ .""AG
 
 H/;3 < Z;"‰I ’o ‹$
£N 13  6 ^Jƒs }`/ W‰I < …3#
 V.3 ,Z" P# i#_ !"Y;I "# n3 
^S
T i#_ }`./ W. @.3#
 .#
 : É A#O < `L
d..
 i..#_ Jƒ.. W.. ,..Z[ \..3 Jƒ..s

– 502 –
 ./1439+2018 '(
 ,2030    !"#
 $%   ,3 
 ,30  ,

 
 

H2030 - &

'( #$% !"     
 € $ ^I H<13: M1$0
< y3 D:
 ^I
&
'( #$% 
(1 5  / # 
,.
 . < WQ. ‚(
 M‹
 Jw;3 ,!
 789
,’ .#
 ,"G8
 ,.." (
 .. #
 :M(..T
 J..Z3
.."
 JQ..8¡ ,..
 .. < WQ..
 M‹..
 Jw..;3 \'f 5 GG
“...~ ,’...TI9 J.Z3 ,M€;A
 T;
 ‘ JZ3
.;3 ,Q.
 J.36 ,Q.
 ";T#
 JQ8¡ ,Q
 H` |1 1
,®A‰..EO ,!..
 $j. ,"
¡Q @K
€ ®A‰EO
.`
 .>G
È .A ] ;3 ,";T#
 
ww
 A ]
,..w
 ,..F9 ";~
 JA8; < b
^˜_ L w$(3 ,:#
,xU..
 ,:( ..F
^˜#
 \3 ‘ œ"A
 † Vj3
M‹#..EO ,j..

^>G
 3 }" X#8 "k(I .";#
 ,."TF
 .";#
 ,."
 .";#
 ,3#Q. .";#
 ¦A3
....Ag ,d;~....

^(ZY "UXj
 ;
 .";#
 ,"w
 ";#
 ,";U
 ";#
 ,d‹#[O }(
 ,"_U

VQ...
 ,\~...

^'(3L \3 >
 ,"_U..
 .(
 ,. ( 37Q.
 ,{©L r".GX#
 ,."E(

,(3L ·
G

^ L X#8 d
 .._3 ,d..‹#[O \..3L ,..>
 “"
..8o ,d_U..
 ’‹‰..
 Z7 Z 2,}
,\~
.. ..X#O 2
^"
L J89 .A>(3 ,.œ"A
 U.3 X#8 @"TI ,œ"A
 3 † ,JX HI~1
,\~.
 \ ª

^J3”L (~X :D :.D , (_U.
 %"Q.
 ,."œ"A
 %"Q.
 ,{"‘ ª;#
 ,œ"A

,£3Q.#
 ,@#

^N(
 8¿ \..3L ,dp.. \..3L ,ÊL S7U..#8 ,( ..#
 ,X#..8O

..% ,ij..

‹F#..8 {©L r"..GX#
 J.Z3 ^"œ"A
 (~X ,{(‘ °A#%O ,(_U#
 ,dp`v


...% ,(...R
^B>

V....# ....TŽ
^@ \ a_A

,}.."
TI |..I ,@.
 ,.O ,7Z#.8O ,.s ª.GT
 ,d3‘ ªGT

^"I`
 :nQ
  #$
,M‹...
 
...% @.TE ,.( •.#ED ,<(. U#>O ,"#_#
 ";A
 ,· r"GX#

^· r"GX#

^
 Y;
 
% ,U#>O E , °o ,•#E9 3 ,ª
O # O ,";T#
 H)]( K1  3
^( \N @

( c Y_ JU.
 ,. < >G
 U3 ,e"Y;
 >G
 ,(e
 "
\(R V3 @f#

^3
 J# ^d;Z @
 ,#; ©L ,J ‹"$
A
 ,"Ge;

' e#
 JŒ
 :D
a._A
 J.">7o
,U.IO JZ3 ,# O JZ3 “.#
 ,¾`
 “#
 ,d;Z “#
 ,‹L : ,\Z ªEo ($ Z)S
J">7o ,d
 4
ne#
 JZ3 ,“8‘ JZ3 ^J`
 (GI ,de"U
 “#
 ,„

9 HP
J.">7o ,.";T#

,..O ·.. r"..GX#
 J..Z3 ,J”.
 ,J Œ ,J(9 V;I ,J(9 ,· r"GX#

^!

!"Y;#
 JZ3 \.3L ,";U.
 ’. ,."3‘ J$=.
 ,"E

9 3‘ H,F 7R GG 5
,..

 ,../w;

(T
 yš JZ3 ,:"T
 JZ3 dœ"A
 \3L ,dp`v
 \3L ,{;#

,: Q. ,A8_
,\(.R :Q.3 ªG#
 JZ3
E ( J.A[ x.T% ,."‹#[O "
¡Q ,(e
 "
¡Q ,;~
J3”L :D 1i* 2,}
...;Z J...">7o ª.;#
 ,W."T x.T% ,(.L x.T% ,V.# xT% ,;~ 6
"U....Xj
 "
¡Q.... J....Z3 H7@0(
^3
 e"q
 Qe
 _3 ,
  xT% ,<TF

^"‹#[O

– 503 –
 ^^^EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI JAG# S
T3 UI :{†L WQ% \ \Q% \ …

P..b ..$o ,!"..#
 :”..
2020 .._#
 H3.E( BJJJJ%1 _JJJJ1 &
JJJJ'( − 3
".88L J.Z !"T
 wwI c H3Eƒ
u3s J""I
..8 c.. S
..T U..#
 w..$ :*JJ $
."TF
 ."‹#[O Gj.EL c. w"$

. ‚7G
rj..;
 !#..
 eQ.. c.. ..pT
 u..#
 x(..~
HZ;..
A%U.. .."Z"

 .."G#
 "..N(
 ._$ “.
G
 c. $¡I /A# ,C L [

^]
y £N 14  6 ^Z" $j AQE :” d"I
.8O P.b V3 # 3 / ,!#
 "

}.% {`.
 !.T#
 !"#
 “"
8o (GI V (


H2030 - &

'( #$% !"      
 B%1 &
'( H<14: M1$0
  B% N $ _`1 &
' 
"
 J7%(
 "E" Jw
 rj;
 !#
 J""I
8 1
(T#
  #$ JOT ˜_A
 @ J = @
 !#
 J""I
8 2
“"$

 !"U#
 Vj3 J7j @% MUT#8O J""I
8 3
"
 "e"U
 J(Q ne#
 !"I J""I
8 4
@
 Â ";Z3 ," "A#
 J 
 …
 '(
 :$_  L “
J""I
8 5
"TF
 "
 ' EL ¾`
 !#
 J""I
8 6
JE[(Z Ÿ%# Gj;
 j>; 
 :É_ J""I
8 7
""#
 ‚
L "
 JT Q „

9 H3 !#
 J""I
8 8

‹.$ .""AG
 .
 H/.; !#.
 i#g !TI “"
8o ”( o S

T U#
 '( :5 g'D − 4
^15  6 £N
H2030 - &
'( #$% !"      
 5 g'D H<15: M1$0
‚ )+D
/'] 5' u 5 
 5 g'D 
„[
 iZ <( A
 ”E9 Je3 1
{Z <( A
 ML u"T3 ,(T#
 u"T3 ,ne#
 u"T3 2
{Z <( A
 Y%7 >G 3
„[
 A
 " }²O u"T3 4
{Z <( A
 ;;T ej
 ((_#
 JA#O 5
{Z <( A
 A8_ JA#O 6

– 504 –
 ./1439+2018 '(
 ,2030    !"#
 $%   ,3 
 ,30  ,

 
 

…3#
 @ E#8O ,S

T U#
  2030 (.G#
JM(.[9 \3  U#
 S
T ‹$
i..#g < Jƒ..s }`../ W‰..#
“..8;3 ‚..8ˆ$ .; MjED :Z;3 ""AG
 
 H/;3 !TI "
^H/; J.A#O ."AGI ,.""AG
 
 œ8L "3
!"..#
 c.. 2030 .. W3‰..3 J..$o − 4 .# < .w$(3 .;€;T3 JA# "AGI ,"U"Xj#

c. w"$

. 8
 ËI `
,“
G
 c # ^

 i#Q3 c EF
 %(
.";I .8‹ c. TI d#
 u#
 J""I
8 :' $ )1$W
 ,/n  rj;
 ¾`
 !#
 MUT#8O ne#
 .(G#
 .(
 }`./ M.; < a.%A
 Œ#>
^"
‘ 8
 |#N( 3 P./L u".p @j. .ZG  c. ,.
 H/;
@."e#
.
 J.A \3 w S(~ − 5 .8
 Hp.#E µ ’L ,2030 (
""I
8O
,.""AG
 .
 H/.; A%U. .""#
 GjEL m JM[ "
‘
.
 H/.;3 (GI c Œ#TI O 3
|.[I
€ @.F3 .F‘ J.Z[#
 .Z;3 rAI( 3 f .(GI “.E[ .;/ ’ˆ. (.T
€ a.%A
 ’¶. ,rT
.."G#
 ..";Z Gj..EL ..3>¶ ..;
 STEM — ,.
 H/; "
 ( "AG #I "UUš
^…_ d;~
 i#Q c "
 JT Q \3 w
[_ d/ ,SN "
‘ 8
 /(ZYI
WQ.K c 2030  P/o "$ˆI @q < − 6 m
^7AT#Q3 a_A

.."
‘ ..8
 Ë..I ,..""#
 .."
 J..[(l :~
""AG
 
 H/;3 !TI JM([D “"
8o (G# !..I {`..
 S
..T U..#
 \..3 :e#..8O − 1
,@.A
 !.T#
 “"
.8o ."AGI < V8#
 7 \3 @.A> \.3 }(GI |#[(3 |""TI :D ,;/ |TI
œ8»
; (GI ,;;T "U"Xj#
 JA#O ^!"#
 :” \3 UUX#3 ;6
^S
T U#
 < |N( !I 3  /n  .""AG
 
 H/;3 P/o (GI :D − 2
*** .(
""I
8O P/L MN < EF
 %(

^S
T U#
 < '( 3  ,2030
..""AG
 ..
 H/..;3 i..#g W‰..I − 3
( U
 Jy "E[
 Z "( Jƒs

– 505 –
 ^^^EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI JAG# S
T3 UI :{†L WQ% \ \Q% \ …

Z/o "TK \3 
 J"N(
 < :G H/; K01 ) e]

. < G.8# .%( W. (YE Z[ \3 :+ K0 :ƒ(1D
!. ."

 < " ( J8  ^Q
 " (
 < .
 HZ;.3 i.#g (.GI ." ^2015 c ,{†L
^108 −87 ,50 ,ue;
 d;T#
 €;#
 ";I < :Š ";T#
 JO µ MN
(.3(3 :'(
 ,1® ^
 uI ^1408 È A ,WU‘ i.
.F‘ .";T#
 J.T"AGI X#.8 ._E }²O
^AG
.3 ,1® ^:; ; r8# a
F
 ŸU
 ‚7~
< .";~
 .b w.w#
S
.T3 U.I ^2017 Ho ,!"% ^i(T
 o 3[ V G3 :3(
.. ^2030 .. .. M..N < .."36 H/..; ^2004 .# ,{w;"$.3 ;W.3 ,’
8 ;E  ,"jI o
^142 −121 ,227 ,u#
 x(~ H/; < J8 .g .t(I ^\=.
 {.‘ ’(T
`"37#
 D
,|Q8o ,|3Ze3 :Š ™ HZ; ^2010 \Q% ,e"s ^"E;A
 Π
 ::(/T
 ^@E
^k(
 A#3 :'(
 ,10® ^|IE3 ..v
 “..#$ < ..";~
 W3‰.. ^2017 EG..8 ,{..A

 ^P :” ";~
 ©L ^1984 ww
 A ,(Gs ^2030   MN < EF
 %(
w"EO
^111−115 ,25 16 ,{

 "Ž#
 ^592− 567 ,1173 ,(/”L 3 "

 "$ 
."TK < .w"E9 .v
 d3   ^2017 E ,„(/w
 S
..T3 U..I ^2017 ’G..8 ,..""_ ;..†o ,{(¬..#

=..E ..
.." (
 .. ^2030 .. .. . . M.N < !. .D H3(. J[(X
^111−126 ,1 1 ,˜_ L Q.
 J36   (‡¡3 ^2030 Q
 " (

™.. HZ;. ^2004 È .A ,!"/(.. D ;J.[ ,:.8 ,!"U.T
 ^256 −201^  ^2030  @"eI <
€ ,4® ^Š
^(e
  :’‹ ^!"UT
 3[ :Q
 " (
 
..$ ,..‘ ..A ;\†(..
 ..A ,°.. ;’..> y ,J.."A V ^@AT#Q !"I !"#
 @AT#Q3 ^2002 "8 ,‚%
^|A"
.8o – |.I o −|.3Ze3 d.
 a_A
 ^1999 ^dAq  o :<TF

^V”#
 =;
38o  :'(
 ,3® ;7~ ,–(‘ ;t ,W/[ ;’k ,<(G ;g ,3%
Gs JAG#3 "T_#

 HZ;3 (GI ^2017 }"eI ,!E  < :..G H/..; (..Žo ^2012 {..† ,´AU..

. o M.N < ™.8L !"#
 %(3 < ""I
8O @"U._#
 .";I c. .""AG
 .
 J".N(

`.."37#
 ‚Q..$D < |..#" .."E "
 H/..; :. [ ^.EF
 %( ‚7~ i
J7j @% ne#

,."
 "

  ^( V# !"> "
 !"/e ,2 26 ,ue;.
 !. ."

 < ." ( J8 
^66 − 1 ,8 20 ^116 −81
a.
F
 ŸU.
.
 < S
.T3 HZ;.3 ^2016 }"eI ,!E  x.I d.#
 J._#
 ^2014 „./ ,.3% ;:† ,\Q%

– 506 –
 ./1439+2018 '(
 ,2030    !"#
 $%   ,3 
 ,30  ,

 
 

^1436 J"N(
 
 !"I (GI < dF_A
 w"#


€ w$(3 ‚Q#$ < |#" "
 J/²O MN < dp# O
.
 J".N(
 (.GI ª =. "T#
 8
 ."

 . ^."I"‘ ."
 JZ µ `"37#

^Q.
 ." (
 . .
 !"#
 d. ""AG
 ^112− 61 ,4 19 ,"

\3 V[
8
¨ \.3 .";~
 ©L Ÿ> "TpŽ 8 ^2011 
 ,!F
https://ecsme.ksu.edu.sa/ar/node/1035
(GI < UUX# "
 :ƒs J"A E#8O :(
ƒ
:0% K0 :„
^Q.
 ." (
 . 
 J"N(
 H/;3
Al bediway, S. (2017). National implications implied in
english books of secondary stage in light of K.S.A
vision 2030. College of Education Journal at
^500− 469 ,1 146 ,(/”L 3 "

 "$ 
Alazhar University (in Arabic).173 (1)469-500.
Q.
 " (
   ^2016a (
d379 w$(
Al muathem, K. (2011). A documentary study of the position
of national families on the idea of using international \3 V[
8
¨ ^2030
expertise houses specialized in the development of
math and science curricula in the Kingdom of Saudi http://vision2030.gov.sa/ar/media-center
Arabia. College of Education Journal at Alazhar Q.
 " (
   ^2016b (
d379 w$(
University (in Arabic).146 (1), 567-592.
Al quwiter, A. (1984). National families of curricula. ^.(
 ."TK H3(. ""I
.8O P/L :2030
Educational Documenting Journal. (in Arabic), 16
(25), 111-115. http://vision2030.gov.sa/ar/media-center \3 V[
8
¨
Al zahrani, N. (2017). The Role of English Teachers to ^2020 d;~
 _#
 H3E( ^2016c (
d379 w$(
Achieving 2030 Vision of Saudi Arabia. Arab
Journal of Science & Research Publishing. (in
Arabic). 1(1),111 – 126.
\3 V[
8
¨
Gaanim, T. (2016). A Proposed Curriculum in science for http://vision2030.gov.sa/ar/media-center
the third grade in the light of global trends and its H/;3 (GI ª =3 ^2004 H"s  
–(
 "

 “#3
effectiveness in acquiring students some scientific
and life skills. Journal of Science Education.(in ."

 “.# M‰.L  
 < J"N(
 

Arabic), 19 (4). 61-112.
Gaanim, T. (2017). Development of science curricula to  
–(
 "

 “#3 :'(
 ^H"s  
–(

achieve requirements of strategic plan in the basic
education grade in light of dimensions of Japanese ^H"s
curriculum quality and its effectiveness in
providing students scientific concepts and ..." (
 ... < !"...#
 ...8"8 ^1416 !"...#
 :”
knowledge society values. Journal of Science
Education. (in Arabic), 20 (8).1-66. ^!"#
 8"Q
"
 ;
 :'(
 ,4® ^Q

Hakeem, A. (2017). A proposed perception for promoting
national identity in university curricula in view of
.. ^!"..#
 (..G#
"AT#Q..3 .. ^2004 !"..#
 :”
Saudi Arabia vision 2030. Journal of Studies in
curricula & teaching methods. (in Arabic). 227,121 ^125 .102 ,94 ,(
– 142.
..
 J"..N(
 (..GI ª =..3 ^2008 !"..#
 :”
Hamid, M., Almutrafi, R., Jaheen, G., Alharbi, T.&
Alssabbg, H. (2012). The effect of curricula ^'(
 ^Q
 " (
  d. ""AG

developed in mathematics and sciences on
achievement, thinking and problems solving at ¨ ^2030  !"#
 ^2017 !"#
 :”
\3 V[
8
secondary school students. Journal of Arabic
Studies in education and Psychology (in Arabic). 26 https://www.moe.gov.sa/ar/Pages/vision2030.aspx
(2), 81-116.

– 507 –
^^^EF
 %(
""AG
 
 H/;3 (GI JAG# S
T3 UI :{†L WQ% \ \Q% \ …

Hassan, H.& Hamid, H. (2014). Challenges Hindering the

Goal Achievement of Improved Mathematics and
Science Curricula from the Point of View of
Intermediate School Teachers in Saudi Arabia.
Journal of Arabic Studies in education and
Psychology (in Arabic). 50 (1), 70-108.
Ministry of Education (2004). A Future Vision to
Development of Education. Almarefh Journal (in
Arabic). 94,102-125.

***

– 508 –