By

Irma Yunita M,Pd

When REVIEWING scientific
articles/Journal ... Ask yourself
about the following:
 What is this about?
 Why the topic is important?
 what was done?
 key result?
Characters of a reviewer
 Objectivity,
 Fairness,
 Professionalism,
 Confidentiality,
 Honesty,
(Parberry, 1989)
As Reviewer…
• To show your understanding in this field (memperoleh
lebih mendalam mengenai topic Article or Journal yg di
review)
• Methodolgy (Pendekatan atau metode yang digunakan)
• Result (Hasil penelitian )
• Constructive criticism to improve the paper (meberi kritik
membangun dan terstruktur mengenai artikel tersebut)
• Confirm novelty (Novelty atau sumbangsih dalam
keilmuan)
• Conclusion (Penyajian kesimpulan)
 An Important Part in Writing a
Review
Introduction
 The introduction here can contain what is the
problem or information about the topic?, why the
article or journal must be reviewed.
Background
 The background about the research starts from the
research was conducted, when, the purpose, and the
participant in the research, methodology and result.
Excellence
 Excellence can be according to your own.
 An Important Part in Writing a
Review
Weakness/Deficiency
Each research has its weakness. Therefore, just insert a
few shortcomings and not too many shortcomings
written and give the solution to solve the weakness.

Conclusion
The result of the research and your suggestion
 Simple Sentences
 Simple sentence has the
basic element that make
it sentence.
For example :
 A simple sentence has one
• Ali plays football everyday.
independent clause and (Subject `Ali` dan verb `plays`.)
expresses one idea.
• The student often sleeps early
 A simple sentence contains at night. (Subject `the student`
one combination of Subject dan verb `sleeps`)
(S) and Verb (V).
 Simple sentence with
Compound subjects
 A compound subject
contains two or more
subjects that have the
same verb
for examples,
– A lovely boy and his mother are in the
house.
– A new generation tablet or computer
was launched yesterday.
 Simple sentence with
Compound verb
 A compound verb
contains two or more
verb that have the same
subject
for examples,
– Anton speak English fluently and can
write in Arabic.
– They worked hard and produced an
excellent display.
THANK YOU