Renovation of Pocket Bell House

COMPARATIVE COST ANALYSIS

June 24, 2021
Plumbing and Fire Protection Works - Design, Supply & Installation

DELTA DESIGNS + CONSTRUCT ARDHEE BUILDER AND TRADING CORPORATION

Description Total Cost Description Total Cost

1. General Requirement PHP 4,468,800.00 1. General Requirement PHP 2,161,600.00

2. Plumbing, STP and Sanitary Works 2. Plumbing and Sanitary Works

a.) Sewer, Vemt and Waste Drainage System 394,770.00 a.) Sewer, Vent and Drainage System 375,504.27
b.) Storm Drainage System 398,940.00 b.) Storm Drainge System 381,995.45
c.) Condensate Drainage System 455,730.00 c.) Condensate Drainage System 405,859.85
d.) Water Distribution System 941,926.00 d.) Water Distribution System 924,330.68
e.) Drain and Accessories 926,250.00 e.) Drain and Accessories 911,125.00
f.) Valves and Accessories 2,105,800.00 f.) Valves and Accessories 2,020,320.00
g.) Plumbing Fixtures 145,750.00 g.) Plumbing Fixtures 143,000.00
h.) Pumps, Accessories and Controllers 2,640,000.00 h.) Pumps, Accessories and Controllers 2,580,000.00
i.) Tanks and Accessories 795,000.00 i.) Tanks and Accessories 713,000.00
j.) Testing and Commissioning 410,000.00 j.) Testing and Commissioning 400,000.00
k.) Dismantling of existing Tanks and Pipes, Fittings 420,000.00 k.) Dismantling of existing Tanks and Pipes, Fittings 400,000.00
l.) Sewerage Treatment Plant System 3,400,000.00 l.) Sewerage Treatment Plant System (w/ 1M Discount) 8,948,650.00
PHP 14,598,265.92 PHP 18,464,401.48

3. Fire Protection and Fire Supression Works 3. Fire Protection and Fire Supression Works
a.) Pipes and Fittings 2,557,000.00 a.) Pipes and Fittings 2,356,000.00
b.) Valves and Accessories 1,371,100.00 b.) Valves and Accessories 1,224,400.00
c.) Sprinkler Heads 185,900.00 c.) Sprinkler Heads 169,500.00
d.) Fire Hose Cabinet 228,000.00 d.) Fire Hose Cabinet 204,000.00
e.) Fire Department Connection 280,000.00 e.) Fire Department Connection 268,000.00
f.) Fire Pump 660,000.00 f.) Fire Pump 620,000.00
g.) Jockey Hump 220,000.00 g.) Jockey Hump 200,000.00
Fire Suppression System 950,000.00 Fire Suppression System 920,000.00
Testing and Commissioning 380,000.00 Testing and Commissioning 380,000.00
PHP 7,651,840.00 PHP 7,102,928.00

FINAL TOTAL COST Php 26,718,905.92 FINAL TOTAL COST Php 27,728,929.48
NOTES: NOTES:

1. Unidentified Values in the computation. The summation in their Plumbing and

1. Wrong Excel Computation. The original bid is PHP 43,929,220 but by checking of
Sanitary works with STP computation is Php 18,742,055.54. The computation in their
their proposal, wrong summation formula in excel was done. All in all, there's a Php
Fire Protection and Supression Works is Php 7,293,185. All in all discrepancy is Php
17,210,314.08 discrepancy.
467,911.06. Original bid is Php 28,196,840.54.

2. VAT Excluded 2. VAT Included

3. Exclusion in the securement of Permits 3. As built plans excluded. Revision of plans WIHTOUT sign and sealed is included.
3. No discount given. 4. Total discount, included in the computation, is Php 1,850,000.
Remarks
a.)The only difference thay have is, in Sewerage Treatment Plant, Ardhee Builders will use an additional mateirals such as 30 CMD MBR System with chemical treatment
process, a Hollow fiber MBR module, Permeate Pumps, Roots Blower and Chemical Dosing Pump.