Republic of the Philippines

REGIONAL TRIAL COURT

11th Judicial Region
JUSTICE ON WHEELS
Malapatan, Sarangani Province
o00o

THE PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, CRIM. CASES NO. 150-93

Plaintiff,
- versus - - for -

NIDAL LILAYA, ET. AL., ROBBERY WITH HOMICIDE

Accused.
X - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -X

COMMENT

ACCUSED, through counsel and unto this Honorable Court,

most respectfully submit his comment/objection to the exhibits
offered in evidence by the prosecution, to wit:

EXHIBIT - “A” and its sub-markings:

NATURE - Ante-mortem statement of Emilio Laguayan
COMMENT/OBJECTION:
a) Inconsistent with the testimony in open Court;

EXHIBIT - “B” and its sub-markings:

NATURE - Supplemental statement of Emilio Laguayan
COMMENT/OBJECTION:
a) Inconsistent with the testimony in open Court;

WHEREFORE, it is most respectfully prayed that the evidences

and exhibits submitted by the prosecution and objected/commented
by the accused be denied admission for the purpose it was offered.

Alabel, Sarangani Province.01 August 2013.

PUBLIC ATTORNEY'S OFFICE

Department of Justice
Sarangani District Office
Alabel, Sarangani Province
BY:

SALVADOR G.TALAMAYAN
District Public Attorney
Roll N0. 43509
MCLE COMP. N0.1V-0010737
21 Dec 12
Copy furnished: PPO
 NOTICE OF HEARING

ATTY. ANDRES MISSION

Clerk of Court
RTC - Justice on Wheels
Sarangani Province

G r e e t i n g s:

Please submit the foregoing Comment on the Formal Offer of

Exhibits on May 13, 2011 at 9:00 o’ clock in the morning for consideration
and evaluation of the Honorable Court.

SALVADOR G. TALAMAYAN
HON. FELIPE VICENTE VELASCO
Provincial Prosecutor’s Office
Sarangani Province

G r e e t i n g s:

Please take notice that the foregoing Comment on the Formal Offer
of Exhibits shall be submitted at 9:00 o’clock in the morning of May 13,
2011 for consideration and evaluation of the Honorable Court.

SALVADOR G. TALAMAYAN

Copy Furnished:
PPO

“E” and its Ante mortem statement Inconsistent with the testimony in open
sub-markings of Nenita Orlino court;

“F” and its Death certificate of Admitted the fact of death and the
sub-markings Isaias Orlino cause of death;

“G” and its Post mortem report Failed to indicate the entrance and
sub-markings exit wounds of the victim;

“H” and its Medical Certificate of Admitted as appearing in the

sub-markings Nenita Orlino in the document;

“I” and its Ballistic report Hearsay, the examiner failed to

sub-markings present photographs of similarities
and dissimilarities of the evidence
and specimen;
“J” and its Pictures Not properly authenticated
sub-markings

“K” and its Armalite Rifle Admitted as to the existence only

sub-markings M-16 Sn. RP 057830

“L” and its Empty shell for Cal. Not properly marked and identified
sub-markings 5.56 mm

Page-1

Cont.comment/carbonell…………….Page-2

“M” and its Memorandum Recipt Admitted;

sub-markings of M-16 Cal. 5.56mm

“N” Broken water meter Admitted as to the existence only

“O” and its Anatomical sketch Admitted as to the existence but not
sub-markings the locations of the injuries indicated
therein;

“P” Request for ballistic Admitted as to its existence but not

Its content:

“Q” and its Affidavit of Ezrael D. Admitted as to its existence only;

Sub-markings Lantingan

WHEREFORE, it is most respectfully prayed that the evidences and

exhibits submitted by the prosecution and objected/commented by the accused
be denied admission for the purpose it was offered.

Alabel, Sarangani Province.19 August 2010.

PUBLIC ATTORNEY'S OFFICE

Department of Justice
Sarangani District Office
Alabel, Sarangani Province
BY:

SALVADOR G.TALAMAYAN
District Public Attorney

Copy furnished: PPO

“Q” Certificate of custody Admitted

“R” Firearms Inventory Admitted

“S” Memorandum Receipt Admitted

of Alexander Gamueta

“T” Memorandum Receipt Admitted

of Erwin Loyloy

“U” Assorted empty shells Failed to prove that the shells recovered
of Cal. 30 Garand and were ejected from cal 30 garand and
cal 7.62 cal 7.62 issued to the herein accused.

WHEREFORE, it is most respectfully prayed that the evidences and

exhibits submitted by the prosecution and objected/commented by the accused
be denied admission for the purpose it was offered.

Alabel, Sarangani Province.29 July 2009.

PUBLIC ATTORNEY'S OFFICE

Department of Justice
Sarangani District Office
Alabel, Sarangani Province
BY:

SALVADOR G.TALAMAYAN
District Public Attorney

Copy furnished: PPO