Professional Documents
Culture Documents
processing plants
Case study of a butane treatment unit illustrates effective structural design procedures
and highlights construction challenges encountered in new and expansion projects
OSAMA BEDAIR
Consultant
N
atural gas processing sepa- process, mechanical, and structural time optimisation models in the
rates hydrocarbons and flu- engineering disciplines. The engi- gas processing industry. The con-
ids from pure natural gas to neering design is normally staged cept enables operating facilities to
produce dry gas suitable for pipe- into several gates that require the respond efficiently and effectively
line transportation. Raw natural gas owner’s approval for funding. to changing feed rates and compo-
is first collected from oil wells then Delays in construction projects due sition, equipment condition, and
processed at collection points using to engineering ambiguities may dynamic processing economics.
separator vessels to remove fluids result in substantial losses in the Liu, et al6 presented modelling and
and other impurities. Gas process- form of interest on construction optimisation tools for the petro-
ing plants convert natural gas to loans, management/staff time, and leum refinery process. Bulasara,
other products such as gasoline, an increase in commodities prices as et al7 presented a study to revamp
ethane, butane, and propane. In a result of the continuous inflation heat exchangers in process plants
some cases, hydrocarbon materials of material prices. to evaluate various commercial
such as ethane, propane, and butane Significant work has dealt with aspects. Lulianelli and Drioli8 pre-
must be extracted from natural gas chemical and mechanical design sented a review of recent develop-
prior to pipeline transportation. improvements compared to ments of gas separation technology
Fractionation converts raw material structural aspects. Patience and used in the petrochemical indus-
into refined products transported Bockrath1 presented a butane oxi- try and refineries. The review also
using pipelines to various process- dation technique used in circulating highlighted the importance of mem-
ing units for further processing. a fluidised bed reactor to produce brane reactors for fuel processing
Liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) anhydride from n-butane Wu, et and membrane-based pretreatments
refers to propane or butane (either al2 presented a study to enhance and integrated membrane gas sepa-
separate or in a mix), maintained catalytic performance for butane ration systems. Other aspects deal-
in a liquid state under specific pres- oxidation. Sáez, et al3 performed ing with process design or butane
sure/temperature within a vessel. experimental tests employing a process plants are presented by
LPG is a valuable energy source diesel oil burner to study the com- Gallagher9 and Meyers10. Bedair11-15
and is widely used as a chemical bustion process of liquid butane. A addressed various design aspects of
feedstock for the petrochemical dual pumping and injection system structural members used in heavy
and agriculture industries. Butane was designed to operate with pres- industry.
is a hydrocarbon gas (C4H10) that is sures varying from 0.8 to 2.0 MPa. Not much information is available
colourless, odourless, flammable, They also performed a feasibility on the structural design improve-
and can be easily liquefied. Butane study to modify the combustion ments of natural gas process-
is used as fuel for portable stoves/ technology of diesel oil burners to ing plants. Most effort is directed
barbecues, a propellant in aero- use liquid butane as an alternative towards process or chemical design
sols, refrigerants, and a feedstock fuel. Yang, et al4 presented a pro- aspects. Investigators and plants
to manufacture ethylene and buta- cess model that utilises n-butane owners have given barely any atten-
diene, a key ingredient of synthetic compounds to extract organic pol- tion to improving structural design
rubber. Butane extractions occur lutants from contaminated water. aspects of hydrocarbon facilities.
in a closed-loop extraction system. Removal efficiencies for hydropho- Minimal literature has addressed
These units are closed, devoid of bic pollutants were greater than structural engineering requirements
atmosphere, and recover the gas to 90%. Removal of residual butane of natural gas processing plants.
its original vessel. in treated effluent was achieved by Furthermore, most of the design
Design cycles of natural gas pro- depressurisation, air stripping, and provisions available in the North
cessing plants are complicated and elevating operating temperature. American codes of practice16-22 deal
require close interaction between Mokhatab and Poe5 introduced real- with residential structures.
Connecting pipelines
Z Elevated Equipments
Horizontal vessels Z Horizontal vessel
Electrical boxes
Heat exchanger
Y
X
Junction box Y
B
(O)
(O) 2
(a)
A 1
(b)
Fig.(2) SM01 snapshot with installed pipes/equipments
Figure 2 SM01 snapshot with installed pipes/equipment
Pipeline system B
X
(O)
Fig.(5) Snapshot of SM02 with showing installed pipes and cable trays
Figure 5 Snapshot of SM02 with showing installed pipes and cable trays
in the analysis. The allowable pile ment was installed and commis- imum SLS column reaction for
compression capacity in this case is sioned in the fabrication yard and SM-02 was computed as (P)max=526
(P)Cap =2200 KN and shear capacity then transported to the site. KN, maximum shear reaction (Q)max
is (QH)Cap =240 KN. The maximum =68 KN, and (T)max =0. For operating
pile lateral deflection was limited SM-02 numerical simulation and testing conditions, (P)max=851
to 6mm. After casting the concrete, Equipment and piping vertical KN, maximum shear reaction (Q)
the pile head is restrained against loads for empty, operational, and max
=89 KN, and (Tmax) =0. The max-
rotation. The pile lateral capacity testing conditions for SM-02 were imum ULS column reaction for the
for fixed condition is (QH)Cap =231 idealised at five nodes. Horizontal steel module was found to be (P)
KN. The pile group reduction factor friction and anchor forces at max
=1070 KN and the maximum
is 2.1. Figure 4c shows section B-B start-up and shutdown conditions shear reaction (Q)max =115 KN. The
details through the pile. The recom- were considered. The structure was vertical pile reinforcements are
mended vertical bars are 20-30M, modelled using 307 elements with projected into the pile cap. Upon
and spiral reinforcement is 15M @ a total of 1368 DOF. The maximum installation, the pile head is treated
200mm. beam vertical deflection is calcu- as free headed in the analysis. The
lated as (δmax) =8.5mm. The allow- allowable pile compression capac-
Steel module SM-02 able beam vertical deflection was ity in this case is (P)Cap =2200 KN
Steel module SM02 is used in the limited to (δv) =15mm. The sway and shear capacity (QH)Cap =240 KN.
BTU to support pipes, electrical deflection was calculated at several After casting the concrete pile cap,
cable trays, and mechanical equip- elevations to assure compliance the pile head is restrained against
ments. The module size is 10m x with the serviceability limit state. rotation. The pile lateral capac-
6m x 10m and consists of four lev- The maximum sway deflection was ity for a fixed condition is (QH)Cap
els and two bays. Figure 5 shows found as (δH)max =47mm. The allow- =323 KN and the pile group reduc-
a snapshot front elevation for the able sway deflection was limited to tion factor is 1.5. The maximum
steel module SM-02. Cable trays are (δH)Limit =67mm. The maximum SLS (FE) pile cap moment is (Mmax)
shown in green and the structural unity index was found as (UI)SLS =140 KN-m/m. The recommended
steel is red. Some equipment is not =0.67 and the (UI)ULS =0.69. pile cap reinforcement =15M @
shown to maintain clarity of the fig- A pile cap size of 12m x 8m x 150mm (each way). The pile cap
ure. In this module, most pipelines 0.6m with six concrete piles was shear resistance is (Vc) =1703 KN
are located on the upper elevation used to support the structure. >1070 KN.
(Z)=10. Note that vertical cables The lower steel skid of the steel
trays are supported by horizontal model is partially embedded in Pump and compressor house (PCH)
projections from the primary beams. concrete to minimise the vibration The pump and compressor house
The structure was divided into two effect induced during operation. layout is shown in Figure 6a. The
sub-modules and assembled on-site The nominal pile diameter used is primary framing system consists of
using heavy lift cranes. Pipelines, 750mm and the pile length is 20m. four bays and houses four pumps
cable trays, and mechanical equip- For erection conditions, the max- varying in size. The steel framing is
3m Conclusions
0.6m
Current design guidelines for natu-
B ral gas processing plants overlook
15M @ 200mm critical structural aspects. This arti-
A A
cle describes cost-effective meth-
odologies to design the steel and
7m
B B concrete members required in natu-
(b) Section A-A ral gas processing plants. Simplified
models are described to idealise
load transfers. Horizontal and ver-
15M @ 200mm
tical springs along the pile length
simulate soil structural interactions.
A 20-30M
Numerical results were discussed
3m for the design of pumps and com-
X
pressors located at the BTU. Results
(c) Section B-B
also presented modular steel struc-
4m (a) Pile-cap layout tures required in the BTU. The
procedures are computationally effi-
cient and can be used by the oil and
Figure 7 PCH Support plan and details gas industry.