THE HONG KONG PALACE MUSEUM

Contract No. CC/2018/04/068

Equipment & Material Submission

for

Washable Panel Type Air Filter

of

HVAC Installation

(Ref. No. MS-AC-005)

Rev. 2
Revision Record

Date Rev. Description of Revision

18 Dec 19 0 First Issue
24 Feb 20 1 Second Issue
02 Aug 20 2 Third Issue
CONTRACT TITLE: The Hong Kong Document No. EQ-AC-005
Palace Museum
CONTRACT No.: CC/2018/04/068
Description : Washable Panel Type Air Filter
List of Content

Description Remark: Page No.

(1) Manufacturer’s Catalogue Attached P.1 – P.2
(2) Test Report Attached P.3 – P.13
(3) Job Reference Attached P.14 – P.18
(4) List of Compliance Attached P.19 – P.25
(5) Response to ARUP’s Comment Attached P.26 – P.27

* Delete / Tick as appropriate

 CONTRACT TITLE: The Hong Kong Document No. EQ-AC-005
Palace Museum
CONTRACT No.: CC/2018/04/068
Description : Washable Panel Type Air Filter

(1) Manufacturer’s Catalogue

Item Material Description Brand/ Model Country of Test report / Certification no. Location of Use
Origin
Washable Panel Type Air Filter
1. Washable Panel Type Air Filter Wing Shing/ PRC Report on Filter Test Whole building
WAF-25-6LHD & No. RALC00183
WAF47-12L (Page 4)

Report on Filter Test

No. RALC00188
(Page 7)

ASHRAE 52.2 Test Report

No. BX07291401
(Page 10)

Page1/27
Page2/27
CONTRACT TITLE: The Hong Kong Document No. EQ-AC-005
Palace Museum
CONTRACT No.: CC/2018/04/068
Description : Washable Panel Type Air Filter

(2) Test Report

Page3/27
Page4/27
Page5/27
Page6/27
Page7/27
Page8/27
Page9/27
 3040 Cornwallis Rd. PO Box 12194 Research Triangle Park, NC 27709
Telephone 919 541 6941 Fax 919 541 6936 www.rti.org

ASHRAE 52.2-2012 TEST REPORT

Manufacturer: Wing Shing Air-Flow Co.

Product Name: WAF25-6LHD

RTI Report No. BX07291401

Test Laboratory:
RTI
3040 Cornwallis Road
Research Triangle Park, NC 27709
919-541-6941
mko@rti.org

Page10/27
 ASHRAE Std. 52.2-2012 Air Cleaner Performance Report Summary
This report applies to the tested device only.

Laboratory Data
RTI Report No. BX07291401 Date 29-Jul-14
Test Laboratory Research Triangle Institute
Operator Pope Supervisor Owen/Hanley
Particle Counter(s): Brand Climet Model 500 Spectrometer

Device Manufacturer's Data

Manufacturer Wing Shing Air-Flow Co.
Product Name WAF25-6LHD
Product Model
Test requested by Wing Shin Air-Flow Co.
Sample obtained from Wing Shin Air-Flow Co.
Catalog rating: Airflow rate NA Initial dP (in. wg) NA
Specified test conditions: Airflow (cfm) 1180 Final dP (in. wg) 0.48
Face Velocity (fpm) 295

Device Description
Nominal Dimensions (in.): 24 x 24 x 1 (height x width x depth) 610 x 610 x 25 mm
Generic name flat panel Media color silver
Amount and type of adhesive NA
Other attributes NA

Test Conditions
Airflow (cfm) 1180 Temperature (F) 76 RH (%) 44
Face Velocity (fpm) 295 Final Pressure Drop (in. wg) 0.48
Test aerosol type: KCl
Remarks

Resistance Test Results

Initial resistance (in. wg) 0.18 Final resistance (in. wg) 0.48

Minimum Efficiency Reporting Data

Composite average efficiencies E1 0 E2 6 E3 26
Minimum efficiency reporting value (MERV) for the device: 5 @ 1180 cfm
Air cleaner average Arrestance (A AVG): 63%
Dust Holding Capacity (DHC) 149.5 g

Page11/27
 Report No. BX07291401
Research Triangle Institute

100

90 Initial Efficiency

After 1st loading

80
After 2nd loading

70 After 3rd loading

Filtration Efficiency (%)

After 4th loading

60 After 5th loading

50

40

30

20

10

0
0.1 1 10

Particle Diameter (µm)

(fpm) (m/s) (in. H2O) (Pa)

Minimum Composite Curve Resistance to Airflow

100 0.5
90
80 0.4
Filtration Efficiency (%)

(in. H2O)
Resistance (in. H2O)

70
60 0.3
50
40 0.2
30
20 0.1
10
0 0
0.1 1 10 0 500 1000 1500
Particle Diameter (µm) Air Flow (cfm)

Page12/27
 TABULATED DATA SUMMARY
Report No. BX07291401
Research Triangle Institute

Summary of Test Conditions:

Product Manufacturer Wing Shing Air-Flow Co.
Product Name WAF25-6LHD
Nominal Dimensions (in.) 24 x 24 x 1
Airflow (cfm) 1180
Final Resistance (in. H2O) 0.48

Efficiency (%) per Indicated Size Range

OPC Channel Number 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Min. Diam. (µm) 0.3 0.4 0.55 0.7 1 1.3 1.6 2.2 3 4 5.5 7
Max. Diam. (µm) 0.4 0.55 0.7 1 1.3 1.6 2.2 3 4 5.5 7 10
Geo. Mean Diam (µm) 0.35 0.47 0.62 0.84 1.14 1.44 1.88 2.57 3.46 4.69 6.20 8.37

Run No.
Initial efficiency BX07291402 0 0 1 0 3 5 7 11 21 25 31 28
after first dust load BX07291403 1 0 1 2 7 12 15 27 44 58 72 80
after second dust load BX07291404 2 1 4 7 16 23 29 39 55 65 79 86
after third dust load BX07301401 5 4 6 9 18 26 34 43 60 70 77 87
after fourth dust load BX07301402 3 4 7 13 20 30 41 50 64 73 83 87
after fifth dust load BX07301403 7 4 9 15 27 34 45 54 63 74 82 89

Minimum Composite Efficiency 0 0 1 0 3 5 7 11 21 25 31 28

E1 = 0
E2 = 6
E3 = 26

MERV = 5

Resistance to Airflow:

Airflow Airflow Airflow Air Velocity Air Velocity Resistance Resistance

(%) (m3/s) (cfm) (fpm) (m/s) (in. H2O) (Pa)

50 0.278 590 148 0.749 0.05 12

75 0.418 885 221 1.124 0.10 25
100 0.557 1180 295 1.499 0.18 44
125 0.696 1475 369 1.873 0.28 68

Resistance to Airflow with Loading at 1180 cfm

Resistance Resistance Dust Fed

(in. H2O) (Pa) (g)

Initial 0.18 44
After first dust load 0.19 47 30.0
After second dust load 0.25 63 101.1
After third dust load 0.33 82 46.6
After fourth dust load 0.41 101 31.4
After fifth dust load 0.48 120 28.5

Dust Holding Capacity (DHC) 149.5 g

Arrestance (AAVG) 63%
Page13/27
CONTRACT TITLE: The Hong Kong Document No. EQ-AC-005
Palace Museum
CONTRACT No.: CC/2018/04/068
Description : Washable Panel Type Air Filter

(3) Job Reference

Page14/27
Page15/27
Page16/27
Page17/27
Page18/27
CONTRACT TITLE: The Hong Kong Document No. EQ-AC-005
Palace Museum
CONTRACT No.: CC/2018/04/068
Description : Washable Panel Type Air Filter

(4) List of Compliance

Clause Ref. Description of Compliance / Deviations

AC GS – B1.2 Comply
AC GS – C1.3 Comply
MERV comply with ASHRAE 52 and EN779.
PS.BS01 – 3.5.3 Comply

Page19/27
Page20/27
Page21/27
Page22/27
Page23/27
Page24/27
Page25/27
CONTRACT TITLE: The Hong Kong Document No. EQ-AC-005
Palace Museum
CONTRACT No.: CC/2018/04/068
Description : Washable Panel Type Air Filter

(5) Response to ARUP’s Comment

From: ARUP’s Comment(s) Letter Ref.

Received on: /
CSHK’s Submission
on :

Item Comments: Response:

1. The pressure drop from the submitted test report cannot According to ACGS, the final
comply with General Specification. Please clarify. resistance for 25mm & 50mm filter
shall be 75Pa & 100Pa respectively.

From the test report, it is shown

that for 50mm filter, the resistance
at 100% capacity is 81Pa, which
does not exceed the 100Pa limit.

For 25mm filter, the resistance at

100% capacity is 42Pa, which does
not exceed the 75Pa limit.
2. Sample submission is required for approval. Sample will be submitted for
approval.

Page26/27
 WEST KOWLOON CULTURAL DISTRICT AUTHORITY
RESPONSE to CONTRACTOR’S SUBMISSION FORM
Contract No. CC/2018/04/068
Main Contract for the Hong Kong Palace Museum

RCS No. 0446A-CSC-BSE-MSU-0452-RDA-RCS (Rev 01) Date: 23 Mar 2020

Document Date: 24 Feb 2020

CSF No.: 0446A-CSC-BSE-MSU-0452 (Rev 01)
Receipt Date: 27 Feb 2020

From: Rocco Design Architects Limited

To: China State Construction Engineering (Hong Kong) Limited

Document Title: HVAC Installation – Material Submission of Washable Panel Type Air Filter

Responses/Comments by Engineering Consultants - ARUP

1. The pressure drop from the submitted test report cannot be complied to General
Specification. Please clarify.
2. Sample submission is required for approval.

Replied by (ARUP):___Patrick Huang______(Date)______23 Mar 2020 _

Contract Administrator Representative’s Responses/Comments;

- Please refer to the above comments by Engineering Consultants - ARUP

Status*: C

Resubmission Required: Yes

Signed by Contractor Administrator/Contactor Administrator’s Representative:

Signed by (CA/CAR):_______________(Date)_________________
*STATUS as per G.S. Clause 11.2.2. “A – Notice of No-Objection”; “B – Notice of No-Objection but subject to comments and no re-
submission is Required”; “C – Notice of No-Objection but subject to comments and a re-submission is required to address comments”; “D –
Notice of Objection, please resubmit” that he has objections, which shall be resubmitted.

Page27/27