Professional Documents
Culture Documents
aDepartment
of Pharmaceutical Biology, University of Tübingen, Tübingen, Germany; bDepartment of
Phytochemistry and Plant Systematics, Division of Pharmaceutical Industries, National Research Centre, Cairo,
Egypt; cInstitute for Drug Discovery, University of Leipzig, Leipzig, Germany
Keywords Introduction
Nocardia · Natural products · Pathogenicity
Infectious diseases caused by bacteria, fungi, parasites
or viruses are still a significant cause of death worldwide
Abstract [Dye, 2014]. Interestingly, the therapeutic agents to com-
Nocardia spp. are filamentous Actinobacteria of the order bat such infections are also predominantly derived from
Corynebacteriales and mostly known for their ability to microorganisms. One of the most important producers of
cause localized and systemic infections in humans. However, small molecules with pharmaceutical values, such as an-
the onset and progression of nocardiosis is only poorly un- tibacterial, antiviral, anticancer, antiparasitic, and immu-
derstood, in particular the mechanisms of strain-specific pre- nosuppressing activities, are filamentous Actinobacteria
sentations. Recent genome sequencing has revealed an ex- [Mann, 2001; Barka et al., 2016; Lee et al., 2020]. The bio-
traordinary capacity for the production of specialized small synthesis of these natural products is governed by defined
molecules. Such secondary metabolites are often crucial for sets of genes organized in biosynthetic gene clusters
the producing microbe to survive the challenges of different (BGCs), encoding, e.g., polyketide synthases (PKS), non-
environmental conditions. An interesting question thus con- ribosomal peptide synthetases (NRPS) and hybrid NRPS/
cerns the role of these natural products in Nocardia-associ- PKS machineries. Genes that mediate expression control,
ated pathogenicity and immune evasion in a human host. In self-resistance or export are typically clustered together
this review, a summary and discussion of Nocardia metabo- with these biosynthetic genes in the BGCs [Walsh and
lites is presented, which may play a part in nocardiosis be- Fischbach, 2010; Medema et al., 2015]. Such compounds,
cause of their cytotoxic, immunosuppressive and metal-che- produced as secondary metabolites, are often crucial ele-
lating properties or otherwise vitally important functions. ments in bacterial survival strategies, e.g., as “defense
This review also contains so far unpublished data concerning weapons” against other microorganisms or within a host
the biosynthesis of these molecules that were obtained by organism. Additionally, these molecules can mediate in-
detailed bioinformatic analyses. © 2021 The Author(s). ter-species and intra-species communication or provide
Published by S. Karger AG, Basel an advantage in nutrient acquisition [Netzker et al., 2018].
Brasilinolide A
Nargenicin
Fig. 1. Natural products from Nocardia
spp. with immunosuppressant activity.
ing the Mycobacterium avium complex, Mycobacterium munosuppressive, metal-chelating properties or vitally
kansasii, Mycobacterium abscessus and Mycobacterium important functions, which may play a part in nocardio-
ulcerans. The common aspects of Nocardia and Mycobac- sis, will be summarized and discussed. So far unpublished
terium pathogenesis have been attributed to a shared cell data concerning the biosynthesis of these molecules ob-
wall physiology containing layers of mycolic acid and ara- tained by detailed bioinformatic analysis will also be in-
binogalactan as well as more general virulence factors, cluded.
e.g., catalase and superoxide dismutase enzymes, inva-
sion-like proteins, phospholipase C, haemolysin and the Metabolites with Cytotoxic and Immunosuppressive
cord factor [Beaman and Beaman, 1994; Vera-Cabrera et Properties
al., 2013; Zoropogui et al., 2013; Ji et al., 2020]. However, For a long time, it has been speculated that cytotoxic
major parts of Nocardia infections remain poorly under- and immunosuppressive properties of Nocardia second-
stood, including strain-specific virulence and progres- ary metabolites may play a role in infection, immune eva-
sion of nocardiosis. It is noteworthy that a number of sion and clinical manifestation of the disease. Mikami
molecules, which are considered to be essential for sur- and co-workers have been the first to systematically ex-
vival and pathogenicity of Mycobacteria, are synthesized ploit clinical Nocardia isolates as a source of pharmaceu-
by biosynthetic machineries, which are usually associated tically interesting natural products [Mikami, 2007]. Based
with the secondary metabolism, i.e., PKS and NRPS. The on this assumption and by similar efforts of other re-
main examples are mycolate-, phthiocerol-, tetrapeptide- search groups, a number of bioactive molecules could be
and mycoketide-based cell wall glycolipids, various sid- isolated and characterized.
erophores and the toxin mycolactone [Portevin et al., In the realm of immunosuppressants, N. terpenica
2004; Stinear et al., 2004; Chopra et al., 2008; Matsunaga IFM 0406 (formerly referred to as N. brasiliensis) was
and Sugita, 2011; Yu et al., 2012]. Recently, the analysis of found to biosynthesize brasilicardins (A–D) as remark-
the first Nocardia genome sequences showed a high di- able immunosuppressive entities. This unique molecular
versity of PKS- and NRPS-containing gene clusters, some family is characterized by featuring a diterpene skeleton
of them appear to be conserved in all analysed strains, decorated with N-acetylglucosamine (GlcNAc), L-rham-
some of them are unique [Komaki et al., 2014]: the num- nose, pyruvate and 3-hydroxybenzoate (3-HBA) units
ber of secondary metabolite pathways in Nocardia species [Shigemori et al., 1998]. Outstandingly, brasilicardin A
is roughly similar to Streptomyces with an average of 36 (shown in Fig. 1) selectively revealed antitumour activity
BGCs per genome [Doroghazi and Metcalf, 2013; Män- with a striking pattern of differential cytotoxicity (IC50 =
nle et al., 2020]. How the encoded chemistry exactly con- 0.22 – 100 µg/mL) against a broad panel of various tu-
tributes to the general and strain-specific pathogenicity of mour cell lines [Komaki et al., 1999; Komatsu et al., 2005].
Nocardia spp. is a focus of ongoing investigations. In the Moreover, via a mouse mixed lymphocyte reaction as a
current review, Nocardia metabolites with cytotoxic, im- simulating setup for allograft rejection, brasilicardin A
OH
H 3C OH
O
O NOCAP aglycone
N
NH N O O
O
O NH NH
H
O N
O
NH Nocardiolactone
O
O
N
O N O
H
O
Fig. 3. Recently identified bioactive mole-
Nocarjamide
cules isolated from Nocardia spp., NOCAP
(NOCardiosis-Associated Polyketide).
able to completely reconstitute and deorphanize a 3-MDa et al., 2014]. Whereas lipstatin is an acylated nocardiolac-
trans-AT PKS system that is predominantly found in tone derivative with potent activity against the pancreatic
clinical Nocardia isolates. The PKS was hence termed no- lipase, other β-lactone-containing compounds are inhib-
cardiosis-associated polyketide synthase (NOCAP) [Kuo itors of proteases, e.g., the proteasome [Kaysser, 2019].
et al., 2016]. They were the first to describe the full in vitro Given their lipophilic nature, it is likely that nocardiolac-
reconstitution of an assembly line PKS that mainly con- tones are components of the bacterial cell envelope and
tains trans-AT modules. The thereby synthesized com- might thus contribute to the interaction with the host
pound consists of a substituted resorcylaldehyde moiety during Nocardia infections. Notably, the respective path-
linked to a 15-carbon chain with 2 conjugated all-trans way has been found to cumulate in clinically relevant No-
trienes separated by a stereogenic hydroxyl group. This cardia strains.
molecule likely represents the aglycon of a yet to be dis- In addition, Nocardia genomes are rich in monomod-
covered natural product which would be decorated with ular type I PKS. The clinically important pathogen N. cyr-
a 6-deoxy sugar (shown in Fig. 3). Further investigations iacigeorgica GUH-2, for example, harbours 5 BGCs with
of its biological role are underway [Yuet et al., 2020]. this organization (out of 19 predicted BGCs in total) [Zo-
ropogui et al., 2013; Komaki et al., 2014]. Similar path-
Putative Components of the Cell Envelope ways in Mycobacterium tuberculosis were determined to
Nocardia spp. encode a remarkable number of compa- participate in the synthesis of diverse surface-exposed
rably simple pathways driven by ketosynthase biochem- glycolipids including the assembly of mycolic acids, my-
istry. One such example is the gene cluster for the biosyn- cocerosic acids and pthiocerols [Matsunaga and Sugita,
thesis of nocardiolactones (shown in Fig. 3) which has 2011]. The most abundant of such glycolipids are
been found in 23 isolates [Mikami et al., 1999; Robinson trehalose-6,6′-dimyco-late (TDM), as well as the pthioc-
et al., 2020]. An NltA/NltB heterodimer of ketoacyl-ACP erol containing phenolic glycolipid (PGL) (shown in
synthase III (KASIII; FabH) homologs catalyzes the Fig. 5). Mycolic acid-containing glycolipids are known to
“head-to-head” Claisen condensation of two long-chain affect the host immune system, e.g. by stimulation of cel-
acyl-CoAs. Subsequent reduction by NltD generates a di- lular and humoral immunity, granuloma formation and
alkyl β-hydroxy acid which is converted by the adenylate- anti-tumour activity. TDM, also named the cord factor,
forming enzyme NltC to a di-alkyl β-lactone product. has been linked to intracellular survival of virulent Nocar-
Such β-lactone synthetases were associated with the for- dia strains, thereby constituting potential virulence
mation of various small molecules that act as inhibitors mechanisms. This may include favoured uptake into
of hydrolytic enzymes [Wolf et al., 2017; Robinson et al., macrophages by activating the alternative complement
2019]. A similar set of enzymes, for instance, is encoded pathway without triggering respiratory burst. And it was
in the BGC for lipstatin: LstA-D [Hochuli et al., 1987; Bai shown in in vitro systems that TDM potentially inhibits
Iva L-Thr L-Val L-NmLeu L-NmPhe L-Leu D-Phe D-Val L-Ala L-NmVal
N. vulneris W9851
L-Thr L-Val L-NmX L-NmX L-X D-X D-Leu L-Val L-NmLeu
N. suismassiliense S-137
L-Thr L-Val L-NmLeu L-NmTyr L-Leu D-Lys D-Val L-Ala L-NmVal
N. tenerifensis IFM10554
transvalencin A
Coelibactin
(proposed)
N. farcinica W6977
L-X L-Cys L-Cys L-mCys
N. nova SH22a
L-X L-Cys L-Cys L-mCys
S. coelicolor A3(2)
b Sal L-X L-Cys L-mCys
Fig. 4. Biosynthetic gene cluster analysis for the production of nocarjamide-like compound (a) and transvalencin A (b).
Nocardithiocin
Nocavionin
nocavionin have been reported, its structural variant mi- Peptidolipin NA is a cyclic lipopeptide from the ter-
crovionin exhibited strong antibacterial effects with MICs restrial N. asteroides in which cyclization is executed via
<0.46 and 0.15 μg/mL against MRSA and S. pneumoniae, an ester to an unusually long lipophilic tail. It was found
respectively [Wiebach et al., 2018]. to exert an antibiotic effect by interacting with the mem-
Nocardicins (A–B) from N. uniformis subsp. tsuyama- brane lipid bilayers, generating ion-conducting pores.
nensis are the smallest representatives of NRPS-based com- Recently, peptidolipins (B–F) were reported from a ma-
pounds containing a monocyclic β-lactam ring, alongside rine Nocardia strain WMMB215 with moderate bacterio-
an oxime and double p-hydroxyphenylglycine units. They static potency against MRSA [Maget-Dana et al., 1985;
exhibit moderate potency against a broad variety of gram- Wyche et al., 2012].
negative bacteria and some β-lactamase-resistant species. Furthermore, during our genomic and chemical ex-
Unexpectedly, the in vivo readings of nocardicin A were ploration of Nocardia spp., we and others [Navarro-Mu-
higher than in vitro upon its administration to mice infect- ñoz et al., 2020] became aware that the genome of N. ter-
ed with gram-negative bacilli [Aoki et al., 1976; Hashimoto penica IFM 0406 contains the BGC coding for the out-
et al., 1976; Mine et al., 1977; Nishida et al., 1977]. Townsend standing anti-antibiotic detoxin (Fig. 8). Subsequent
and co-workers conducted several studies on nocardicin chemical analyses of the crude extract of IFM 0406, using
biosynthesis, leading to a detailed understanding of the re- high-resolution LC/MS and MS/MS experiments
spective biochemical mechanisms [Hosoda et al., 1977; (Fig. 8a–f), confirmed that IFM 0406 is actually able to
Townsend and Brown, 1982; Townsend and Brown,1983; produce detoxin D1 and D3. The detoxin complex was
Townsend et al., 1983; Townsend and Salituro, 1984]. Ge- originally isolated from Streptomyces spp. and is a selec-
nome sequencing revealed the nocardicin A BGC, in which tive antagonist of the antibiotic blasticidin S [Yonehara et
the open reading frames to biosynthesize the nonproteo- al., 1968; Shimazu et al., 1981]. Thus, a subset of Nocardia
genic p-hydroxyphenylglycine precursor are arranged species do not only produce antibiotics, they are also ca-
alongside the NRPS for the assembly [Gunsior et al., 2004; pable to antagonize the activity of antibiotics from other
Davidsen et al., 2013]. organisms.
e f
Detoxin D1 Detoxin D3
Fig. 8. Biosynthetic gene cluster of detoxin in S. mobarensis NRRL 0.7 ppm) could be delineated, which were in perfect agreement
B-3729 and N. terpenica IFM 0406 and proof of production of de- with those of detoxin D1 and D3, respectively. Further tandem MS
toxins by N. terpenica IFM 0406. LC/MS-extracted-ion chromato- experiments (c, d) and their interpretation (e, f) corroborated the
grams for the pseudomolecular masses of detoxin D1 (a) and de- chemical structure of detoxin D1 (e) and detoxin D3 (f). The bold-
toxin D3 (b), respectively. From accurate mass measurements, the ed green line (e) highlights the structural difference between de-
sum formulae C28H42N3O8 (measured m/z 548.2964 [M + H]+, D toxin D1 and D3.
0.5 ppm) and C26H40N3O6 (measured m/z 490.2905 [M + H]+, D
References
Anada M, Hanari T, Kakita K, Kurosaki Y, Kat- Bai X, Guo H, Chen D, Yang Q, Tao J, Liu W. Iso- Bauermeister A, Zucchi TD, Moraes LAB. Mass
suse K, Sunadoi Y, et al. Total synthesis of bra- lation and structure determination of two spectrometric approaches for the identifica-
silicardins A and C. Org Lett. 2017; 19(20): new nosiheptide-type compounds provide in- tion of anthracycline analogs produced by ac-
5581–4. sights into the function of the cytochrome tinobacteria. J Mass Spectrom. 2016; 51(6):
Aoki H, Sakai H-I, Kohsaka M, Konomi T, Hoso- P450 oxygenase NocV in nocathiacin biosyn- 437–45.
da J, et al. Nocardicin A, a new monocyclic thesis. Org Chem Front. 2020;7(3):584–9. Beaman BL. Mechanisms for the virulence of No-
beta-lactam antibiotic. I. Discovery, isolation Baltz RH. Genetic manipulation of secondary me- cardia. In: Kado CI, Crosa JH, editors. Mo-
and characterization. J Antibiot (Tokyo). tabolite biosynthesis for improved produc- lecular Mechanisms of Bacterial Virulence.
1976;29(5):492–500. tion in Streptomyces and other actinomy- Developments in Plant Pathology, vol 3. Dor-
Arai MA, Ebihara I, Makita Y, Hara Y, Yaguchi T, cetes. J Ind Microbiol Biotechnol. 2016;43(2– drecht: Springer; 1994. p. 561–72.
Ishibashi M. Isolation of nocobactin NAs as 3):343–70. Beaman BL, Beaman L. Nocardia species: host-
Notch signal inhibitors from Nocardia farci- Barka EA, Vatsa P, Sanchez L, Gaveau-Vaillant N, parasite relationships. Clin Microbiol Rev.
nica, a possibility of invasive evolution. J An- Jacquard C, Meier-Kolthoff JP, et al. Taxono- 1994;7(2):213–64.
tibiot (Tokyo). 2021;74(4):255–9. my, physiology, and natural products of Acti- Bentley SD, Chater KF, Cerdeno-Tarraga AM,
Bai T, Zhang D, Lin S, Long Q, Wang Y, Ou H, et nobacteria. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev. 2016; Challis GL, Thomson NR, James KD, et al.
al. Operon for biosynthesis of lipstatin, the 80(1):1–43. Complete genome sequence of the model ac-
beta-lactone inhibitor of human pancreatic li- Barry DP, Beaman BL. Nocardia asteroides strain tinomycete Streptomyces coelicolor A3(2).
pase. Appl Environ Microbiol. 2014; 80(24): GUH-2 induces proteasome inhibition and Nature. 2002;417(6885):141–7.
7473–83. apoptotic death of cultured cells. Res Micro-
biol. 2007;158(1):86–96.