Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BASIN, VIETNAM
Keywords
Flooding depth, inundation map, flood damage assessment, flood hazard, risk
Abstract
Hoang Long is the largest river in Ninh Binh province, Vietnam. This province
is frequently affected by flooding due to heavy rainfalls in the river basin.
Rainfall frequency analysis was done to obtain a maximum 7-day rainfall for
various return periods, and to construct design hyetographs corresponding to
5, 10, 20, 50, 100 and 200-year return periods. Design flood hydrographs
corresponding to different return periods are obtained by using rainfall-runoff
model (MIKE-NAM). These results are input to MIKE 11 hydrodynamic model
to simulate flood flow in Hoang Long basin. The NAM and MIKE 11 models
were calibrated and verified using past flood data. Using the maximum water
levels computed by MIKE 11 model at different locations along the rivers and
floodplains and digital elevation map (DEM), flood inundation maps were
developed for Ninh Binh province. Flooding depth and inundation area
corresponding to various return periods were determined. From the inundation
maps and field survey data, damage curves for residential, agricultural and
roads damages were developed. Flood hazard and flood risk maps were
constructed typically for the flood of 20-year return period. For flood hazard
and risk assessment, the combined effects of flood depth and flood duration
were considered. The flood hazard and flood risk maps were determined for
each community in Nho Quan and Gia Vien district. These maps are useful for
flood risk zoning and flood mitigation planning for the Ninh Binh province.
INTRODUCTION
P033-1
river is higher than +4 m at Ben De and Gian Khau stations, the government
require some parts of riverbank along Hoang Long river to be broken to reduce
flood flow in Day river, to protect Ninh Binh city and other downstream areas.
Thus, some communities of Ninh Binh province may be become flooded
storage areas, with the flooding return period from 3 to 5 years. Flooding in
2007 inundated 11 of 26 communities of Nho Quan district and 4 of 20
communities of Gia Vien district (People’s Committee of Ninh Binh province,
2007). These flooding storage areas are separated into two parts, Duc Long –
Gia Tuong and Lac Khoai (Figure. 2). The total submerged areas was around
12 km2, the number of building was submerged in water around 14 thousands
of 18 thousands household , the water depth in the flooded areas varies from
2 to 4 m. Total losses/damages estimated about 15 million USD. Besides,
flooding affected to human living which can not be estimated in terms of
money. Local people are always worried about the damages of flooding, their
life, and their properties.
The overall objective of this study is to (i) simulate and determine the
magnitudes of flood flow along the rivers and floodplains for different return
periods; (ii) develop inundation maps in flooding areas; (iii) estimate tangible
impact on resident, agriculture and infrastructure for various return period
floods; and (iv) develop flood hazard maps and flood risk maps.
Ba
Tha
N
N
Phu
PhuLy
Ly
Nam Dinh
Day
10 Km Sea
Port
Figure 1: Hoang Long, Day, Boi and Dao Rivers and Flood Plains
P033-2
Upstream
Upstream
Boi River
Day River
Ba Tha
Hung Thi
Boi
Day Phu Ly
River
River
Ben De
Upstream
Hoang Gian Khau
Long R. Nho Hoang Long
Quan River Dao
River Upstream
Dao River
Legend Doc Bo
Nam Dinh
Hydrological station
Meteorological station
Nhu Tan
Hydromet station
Day Sea
Port
METHODOLOGY
Daily rainfalls, flood flow data and river basin geometry were collected for
model simulation. By frequency analysis, maximum daily rainfall data is
analyzed to determine design maximum rainfalls for different return periods.
From measured daily rainfall data at Hung Thi, Ba Tha and Nho Quan, the
design rainfall corresponding to 200, 100, 50, 20, 10 and 5 year return
periods at each station were estimated. In this study, Pearson type-3
distribution was used for rainfall frequency analysis. Choosing an actual
(measured) hyetograph which has total rainfall is close to design rainfall. The
design hyetograph was obtained by multiplying the ratio between actual
rainfall in a period and design rainfall in the same period to actual hyetograph.
Corresponding runoffs were calculated using NAM model. The computed
runoffs were input into MIKE 11 hydrodynamic model (DHI, 2003) for flood
flow simulation. Questionnaires on affected population, economic values of
flooded properties, flood depths and duration and flood damages were
distributed and data are collected. Flood damages for various return periods
and vulnerability of the flooded areas are estimated. Flood hazards are
estimated based on flood depth and duration. Flood risks are then computed
as product of flood hazard and vulnerability for different locations in the
flooded areas.
P033-3
DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS
There are four rainfall stations in the study area which measured hourly or
daily rainfall at Ba Tha, Hung Thi, Phu Ly, Nho Quan. Water level measuring
stations in the study area are: Hung Thi, Ba Tha, Ben De, Gian Khau, Phu Ly
and Doc Bo. In addition, Ba Tha and Hung Thi stations also measured
discharges. 135 cross sections along the river of Day, Boi, Hoang Long and
Dao river were measured in 2001. Digital Elevation Map (DEM) of 90 m x 90 m
for Hoang Long basin. Reports on flood losses/damages due to flooding in
2007 and answers to questionnaires on information and data about flood
losses in 2007 and 2008 are collected from Nho Quan district people’s
committee and Gia Vien district people’s committee (Ninh Binh Statistical
Office, 2008).
Based on the data collected, the average annual rainfall of Hoang Long basin
is 1925 mm (Nho Quan station). 85% of rainfall occurs in the flooding season
(June to October). Heavy rainfalls normally occur in August or September.
However, there are several years that heavy rainfalls occurred in October. The
period of heavy rainfall is normally from 3 to 5 days, sometime up to 7 days.
Hoang Long is the biggest river of Ninh Binh province; its flood regime and
drainage are influenced by Day river and Dao river. The time to peak at these
rivers normally different from several hours to few days depend on the
position along the river. From the data collected at Hung Thi station (Boi river
– upstream of Hoanglong river) and Ba Tha (Day river), the time to peak in
Hoang Long river is sooner than Day river by 1 to 3 days.
Questionnaires were distributed to local people in Nho Quan and Gia Vien
districts to get information of flood damages per household, agricultural
damages and road damages in the study area caused by floods in 2007 and
2008. In addition, all flood damages reports of provinces, districts or
communes related are collected also. The interview and responses are based
on floods occurred in 2007, 2008. This study focuses on estimating residential
damages, agricultural damages and roads damages as described by Dutta et
al (2003).Following responses of affected people, the average flood depth
which does not effect to building and their activities is found to be 0.24 m. If
the flooding occurs, the average duration of flooding is 7 days. In general, if
flooding depth is under 0.6 m, the level of flooding impact will be not much for
buildings as well as human activities. The duration of flooding is generally
under 3 days. Most of the buildings are slightly affected in range from 0.5 to
1.5 m of depth and from 3 to 7 days of flooding duration, while some of the
other areas have higher impact for 1.5 to 3.0 m of depth and 7 to over 20
days duration. The area which has flooding above 3.0 m is agricultural land
and flooding duration is normally more than 3 weeks.
P033-4
respectively (Figure 3). The difference between the computed and observed
peak discharges is 0.65% for calibration and 10% for verification. The time to
peak of the simulated hydrograph is sooner than the observed one by 1 day in
calibration while there is no difference in verification. Both of calibration and
verification have correlation coefficient (R) higher than 0.94.
400 140
350 120
300 100
250
80
Q (m3/s) 200 Q (m3/s)
150 60
100 40
50 20
0 0
8/11
8/13
8/15
8/17
8/19
8/21
8/23
8/25
8/27
8/29
8/7
8/9
8/7 8/9 8/11 8/13 8/15 8/17 8/19 8/21 8/23 8/25 8/27 8/29
Time Time
For Hung Thi sub-basin, the peak discharges of observed hydrograph are
higher than simulated hydrograph in both calibration and verification with
difference ranging from 5.6% to 10.5%. However the times to peaks match
very well. In addition, the correlation coefficient is very good, above 0.9.
1400 4000
1200 3500
3000
1000
2500
800
Q (m3/s) Q (m3/s) 2000
600
1500
400
1000
200 500
0 0
ep
ep
ep
ep
ep
ep
ep
ep
ep
ep
ep
ep
ep
ep
ep
ep
ep
ep
ep
ep
p
p
Se
Se
Se
Se
Se
Se
Se
Se
Se
Se
-S
-S
-S
-S
-S
-S
-S
-S
-S
-S
-S
-S
-S
-S
-S
-S
-S
-S
-S
-S
1-
3-
5-
7-
9-
1-
3-
5-
7-
9-
29
11
13
15
17
19
21
23
25
27
29
25
27
21
23
11
13
15
17
19
T=5 years T=10 years T=20 years T= 50 years T=5 years T=10 years T=20 years T= 50 years
T=100 years T=200 years T=100 years T=200 years
Three large floodplain areas along Hoang Long river named Gia Tuong, Duc
Long and Lac Khoai are modeled as FP4 method. The exchange of water
between river and floodplain is simulated through weir structures. Only
maximum water level are available in floodplains, so calibration in floodplains
is done by comparing observed and simulated maximum water level in
floodplains. The exchange of water between river and floodplain were
considered as flow through weir structures. The measured weir lengths were
adjusted by trial and error to match the calibration (Vu, 2009). The bed
resistance coefficient (Manning n) is adjusted for the rivers from upstream to
downstream. All hourly rainfall, discharge and water level data at upstream
and downstream boundaries observed from 6-Aug to 30-Aug-1996 is used for
calibration; and from 1-30 September 2000 is used for verification (Figure 5).
These results show that, the parameters of MIKE 11 for flood simulation in
Hoang Long river network is acceptable. The Manning (n) values are
determined for each river, ranging from 0.012 to 0.030.
Considering that the return period of rainfall in upstream and of water level at
downstream are the same design floods in river networks were calculated. The
period of flood simulation is one month, assuming that flood occurs from 1 to
30 September using 1-day time step. The design hydrographs at Hung Thi, Ba
Tha and Nho Quan obtained from NAM and the design water level hydrograph
at Nam Dinh station are input as upstream boundary conditions of MIKE 11.
The design water level hydrograph at Nhu Tan station is input as downstream
boundary condition. Design water level hydrograph at Nhu Tan station is
determined by considering past water level hydrographs which have the worst
situation for drainage (October, 1978). MIKE 11 computes water levels in
rivers and flood plains for design floods at various stations as shown in Tables
1 and 2.
P033-6
4.5
4.0
3.5
3.0
H 2.5
(m, MSL)
2.0 a) Phu Ly
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
6/8/1996 10/8/1996 14-8-1996 18-8-1996 22-8-1996 26-8-1996
01:00:00 01:00:00 01:00:00 01:00:00
Time (hour)
Computed Observed
5.5
5.0
4.5
4.0
3.5
H 3.0
(m, MSL) 2.5
2.0
1.5
b) Gian Khau
1.0
0.5
0.0
6/8/1996 10/8/1996 14-8-1996 18-8-1996 22-8-1996 26-8-1996
01:00:00 01:00:00 01:00:00 01:00:00
Time (hour)
Computed Observed
P033-7
Table 2: Maximum water level at various flooded storages corresponding to
different return periods of flood.
The computed maximum water levels along the rivers and flood plains by
MIKE 11 and digital elevation map (DEM 90m x 90m grid data for land
elevation) were used for constructing inundation maps by MIKE-11 GIS (DHI,
2001). Based on the total rainfall observed at Hung Thi station and maximum
water level at Ben De station, flood occurred in October 2007 is approximately
has 20 year return period. The maximum of observed and simulated water
levels at Ben De in Hoang Long river are respectively 5.17m and 5.19m. From
maximum water depth data in floodplains in October 2007, the total flooding
area in 2007 was estimated to be about 10,533.3 hectares. The difference of
inundation area in 2007 and that of 20 year return period of flood is 6%
(Figure 6). Overall, the result of comparison between the computed and
observed maximum water depths, inundation areas in the floodplains are
found to be close. The maximum of water level in flooding area can reach over
6.5 m when return period of flood T ≥ 100 years. The areas which have
flooding depth over 6.0m are over 0.55% of total flooding area. While, the
area which has flooding depth less than 4.5 m is about 80%, and 3.9% -
12.8% from 4.5 m to 6.0m. For the case of T ≤ 50 years, most of flooding
areas having flooding depth is less than 3.0 m while maximum of depth can
reach 6.4 m.
P033-8
20-year return period
P033-9
Table 3: Total damages due to flooding in Nho Quan and Gia Vien districts.
Hazard index
Depth (m) Category
Alternative 1 Alternative 2
0.0 < d ≤ 0.5 1 1 1.5
0.5 < d ≤ 1.5 2 2 2.0
1.5 < d ≤ 3.0 3 3 2.5
3.0 < d 4 4 3.0
Hazard index
Duration ( t days) Category
Alternative 1 Alternative 2
Short ( t ≤ 3) 1 0 0.5
Medium (3 < t ≤ 7 ) 2 1 1.0
Long (7 < t ≤ 25 ) 3 2 1.5
Very long (t > 25 ) 4 3 2.0
To select hazard index value, a trial and error method suggested by Islam and
Sado (2000) is used. There are two alternative sets of hazard index
established for depth and duration of flooding. Hazard index represents the
level of flooding impacts. There are four case studies done for hazard
assessment using alternative hazard index values given in Table 6. Weighted
hazard index indicates the resultant effect of all hazard categories for each
community. Various flooding depths and flooding durations could occur in the
same community, so that it is necessary to estimate the weighted average of
hazard index (WHI) for each community:
where WHID is weighted area average hazard index for flooding depth, WHIT is
weighted area average hazard index for flooding duration, a and b are
weighting factors for flooding depth and duration.
Hazard index
Case study
Depth of flooding Duration of flooding
Case 1: Alternative 1 Alternative 1
Case 2: Alternative 2 Alternative 1
Case 3: Alternative 1 Alternative 2
Case 4: Alternative 2 Alternative 2
* Alternative 1 and 2 are defined in Table 4 and Table 5
P033-11
To determine weighting factors for flooding depth and duration, sensitivity
analysis is done. There are three sets of weighting factors considered: (i) Set
1: a =0.5, b =0.5; (ii) Set 2: a = 0.7, b =0.3; (iii) Set 3: a= 0.3, b = 0.7. The
three sets yield nearly the same result. For simplicity, the weighting factors
are taken as 0.5 for both depth and duration of flooding. The hazard factor is
normalized by dividing HF by maximum hazard factor HFmax, i.e., HFn =
(HF/HFmax) x100%. Tingsanchali and Karim (2004) suggested five levels of
hazard zone to represent the hazard magnitude. These levels are categorized
as: Very low (0% < HF ≤ 20%), Low (20% < HF ≤ 40%), Medium (40% < HF
≤ 60%), High (60% < HF ≤ 80%), Very high (80% < HF ≤ 100%). Case 1
has the area under medium and high hazard levels equal to 63.7% (Figure 8)
which is very close to the actual flooding area of medium and high depth of
flooding which is 67% of total flooding area. In case 2, 3 and 4 the area under
medium and high hazard levels are 40.2%, 40.2% and 19.9% respectively.
Therefore, case 1 is selected for further analysis in this study.
Risk factor (RF) = Hazard factor (HFn) x Vulnerability factor (VF) (2)
Risk factor is normalized as: RFn = (RFi/RFmax) x 100, where RFn is normalized
risk factor, RFi = risk factor for land unit i and RFmax is maximum risk factor for
all land units. The risk zone is determined from risk factor are used to
represent the risk level. The level of risk is categorized as: Very low (0% <
RFn ≤ 20%), Low (20% < RFn ≤ 40%), Medium (40% < RFn ≤ 60%), High
(60% < RFn ≤ 80%), Very high (80% < RFn ≤ 100%). The result of risk zone
and percentage of flooding area and number of affected household
corresponding to levels of risk zone is shown in Table 7. Figure 9 shows the
flood risk map for 20-year return period for Ninh Binh Province.
Number of Number of
Risk zone community household Area (%)
Very Low 2 532 10.1
Low 12 5,067 49.5
Medium 7 4,629 31.6
High 2 1,138 5.9
Very high 2 7,22 3.0
P033-12
Figure 8: Flood hazard map for 20-year return period flood, Ninh Binh province
Figure 9: Flood risk map for 20-year return period flood, Ninh Binh province
P033-13
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Inundation maps for various return periods developed for Ninh Binh province
are checked with observed flooding depths at some locations. Flooding extents
are quite comparable to flooded area which achieved from field survey.
Tangible damages due to flooding on household, agriculture and roads
corresponding to various return period floods were determined based on
questionnaires and field surveys. Damage curves for residential, agricultural
and roads were also developed. For hazard and risk assessment, the combined
effect of flood depth and flood duration is considered by weighting factors for
both depth and duration of flooding. Flood hazard and flood risk maps were
developed for various return periods. The levels of hazard and risk were
presented for each community in Nho Quan and Gia Vien district.
REFERENCES
DHI (Danish Hydraulic Institute) (2001) MIKE 11 GIS – User Guide. MIKE
Package Software
DHI (Danish Hydraulic Institute) (2003) User guide to MIKE 11: A modeling
system for rivers and channels. DHI Software Manual, 460p.
Dutta, D., Herath, S., Musiake, K. (2003) A mathematical model for flood loss
estimation: Journal of Hydrology, vol. 277, pp 24-29.
Vu, T.T. (2009) Flood inundation, damage and risk assessment in Hoang Long
Basin, Vietnam; Thesis. Asian Institute of Technology, Thailand.
P033-14