Professional Documents
Culture Documents
on
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the project report entitled “CASE STUDY OF IMPROVING
TURBINE EFFICIENCY OF 20 MW STEAM TURBINE” is the bonafide work Mr.
M.ADITYA KUMAR, Roll No (08023A3008) submitted in partial fulfillment for the award of
BACHELOR OF TECHNOLOGY IN MECHANICAL ENGINEERING during the
academic year 20112-2013.
The results embodied in this project report have not been submitted to any other
University or Institution for the award of any degree diploma.
CHAIRMAN
PROJECT REVIEW COMMITTEE
JNTU COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING,
KAKINADA-533 00
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Electricity plays a vital role in our daily life. The power demand is not constant but varies
with time because of increase in population and development of nation. Our country mainly
depends on thermal power plant for electrical supply. In thermal power plants turbine is
considered to be HEART of the plant.
This project involves the construction features, start up, shut down, trouble shooting and
maintenance of the 20 mw turbine. During overhauling period, a crack was identified on the
upper casing of gear box at HSS bearing housing and removed by grinding with depth of 15 mm
and welded by the LH 115 and LH 117 electrodes to fill the crack. The scaling on the blades is
removed by alumina-sand blasting process. Turbine efficiency is calculated by heat rate method
and heat loss method and obtained overall plant efficiency. Results are validated with plant
efficiency before maintenance. A method was suggested to increase turbine efficiency by
optimize the extraction flows of steam turbine and validated these results with earlier.
.
CONTENTS
Page No
1. A BRIEF VIEW ON STEAM TURBINE
1.1 Definition of steam turbine
1.2 Development of steam turbine
1.3 Working principle
1.4 Classification of turbine
1.4 Governing of steam turbine
2. ABOUT 20MW TURBINE
2.1 Details of 20MW steam turbine
2.2 Components of Steam Turbine
3. START UP AND SHUTDOWN OF TURBINE
3.1 Startup of turbine
3.2 Shut down procedures
3.3Types of speeds in start up
3.3 Types of running modes
4. PROTECTION OF STEAM TURBINE
4.1Turbine protections
4.2 List of turbine protections
5. TROUBLE SHOOTING
6. OVER HAULING
6.1 Over hauling
6.2 Problems identified in over haul period.
7. TURBINE CALCULATIONS
7.1 Turbine efficiency
7.2 Efficiency of 20MW steam turbine at 19.5MW load.
7.3 Optimize the extraction flows to increase the efficiency.
8. CONCLUSION
9. BIBLIOGRAPHY
NOTATIONS
Process 1-2: The working fluid is pumped from low to high pressure by the isentropic
compression process. As the fluid is a liquid at this stage the pump requires little input
energy.
Process 2-3: The high pressure liquid enters a boiler where it is heated at constant pressure
by an external heat source to become a dry saturated vapor.
Process 3-4: The dry saturated vapor expands through a turbine by isentropic expansion,
generating power. This decreases the temperature and pressure of the vapor, and some
condensation may occur.
Process 4-1: The wet vapor then enters a condenser where it is condensed at a constant
temperature to become a saturated liquid.
ηThermal Thermodynamic efficiency of the process (net power output per heat input,
dimensionless)
η Thermal Isentropic efficiency of the compression (feed pump) and expansion (turbine)
processes, dimensionless
h1,h2,h3,h4. The "specific enthalpies" at indicated points on the T-S diagram.
h4s. The final "specific enthalpy" of the fluid if the turbine was isentropic
p1,p2. The pressures before and after the compression process
`
W Turbine
η Thermal = --------------
Q in
1.4 CLASSIFICATION OF STEAM TURBINES:
1. According to the principle action of steam:
a) Impulse turbine
b) Reaction turbine
2. According to the no. of cylinders:
a) Single- Cylinder turbines
b) Double-Cylinder turbines
c) Three-Cylinder turbines
d) Four-Cylinder turbines
3. According to the method of governing:
a) Turbine with throttle governing
b) Turbine with nozzle governing
c) Turbine with bypass governing
4. According to the direction of steam flow:
a) Axial turbine
b) Radial turbine
5. According to the heat balance arrangement:
a) Condensing turbine with regeneration
b) Condensing turbine with extractions
c) Back pressure turbines
d) Topping turbines
6. According to the steam conditions at inlet to turbines:
a) Low pressure turbines
b) Medium pressure turbines
c) High pressure turbines
d) Turbines of very high pressures
e) Turbines with super critical pressure
7. According to steam arrangement:
a) Tandem compounded turbines
b) Cross compounded turbines
1.4 GOVERNING OF STEAM TURBINE:
Governing of steam turbine is the procedure of monitoring and controlling the flow rate
of steam into the turbine with the objective of maintaining its speed of rotation as constant. The
flow rate of steam is monitored and controlled by interposing valves between the boiler and the
turbine. Depending upon the particular method adopted for control of steam flow rate different
types of governing methods are being practiced. The principal methods used for governing are
described below:
In throttle governing the pressure of steam is reduced at the turbine entry thereby
decreasing the availability of energy. In this method steam is allowed to pass through a restricted
passage thereby reducing its pressure across the governing valve. The flow rate is controlled
using a partially opened steam stop valve. The reduction in pressure leads to a throttling process
in which the enthalpy of steam remains constant.
Low initial cost and simple mechanism makes throttle governing the most apt method for
small steam turbines. The valve is actuated by using a centrifugal governor which consists of
flying balls attached to the arm of the sleeve. A geared mechanism connects the turbine shaft to
the rotating shaft on which the sleeve reciprocates axially.
With a reduction in the load the turbine shaft speed increases and brings about the
movement of the flying balls away from the sleeve axis. This result in an axial movement of the
sleeve followed by the activation of a lever, which in turn actuates the main stop valve to a
partially opened position to control the flow rate.
Throttle governing – large turbines:
In larger steam turbines an oil operated servo mechanism is used in order to enhance the
lever sensitivity. The use of a relay system magnifies the small deflections of the lever connected
to the governor sleeve. The differential lever is connected at both the ends to the governor sleeve
and the throttle valve spindle respectively. The pilot valves spindle is also connected to the same
lever at some intermediate position. Both the pilot valves cover one port each in the oil chamber.
The outlets of the oil chamber are connected to an oil drain tank through pipes. The decrease in
load during operation of the turbine will bring about increase in the shaft speed thereby lifting
the governor sleeve. Deflection occurs in the lever and due to this the pilot valve spindle raises
up opening the upper port for oil entry and lower port for oil exit. Pressurized oil from the oil
tank enters the cylinder and pushes the relay piston downwards. As the relay piston moves the
throttle valve spindle attached to it also descends and partially closes the valve. Thus the steam
flow rates can be controlled. When the load on the turbine increases the deflections in the lever
are such that the lower port is opened for oil entry and upper port for oil exit. The relay piston
moves upwards and the throttle valve spindle ascend upwards opening the valve.
In nozzle governing the flow rate of steam is regulated by opening and shutting of sets of
nozzles rather than regulating its pressure. In this method groups of two, three or more nozzles
form a set and each set is controlled by a separate valve. The actuation of individual valve closes
the corresponding set of nozzle thereby controlling the flow rate. In actual turbine, nozzle
governing is applied only to the first stage whereas the subsequent stages remain
unaffected. Since no regulation to the pressure is applied, the advantage of this method lies in the
exploitation of full boiler pressure and temperature. Figure shows the mechanism of nozzle
governing applied to steam turbines. As shown in the figure the three sets of nozzles are
controlled by means of three separate valves.
Fig. 3 Schematic of nozzle governor
Occasionally the turbine is overloaded for short durations. During such operation, bypass
valves are opened and fresh steam is introduced into the later stages of the turbine. This
generates more energy to satisfy the increased load. The schematic of bypass governing is as
shown in fig.4
Manufacturer:
SHIN NIPPON MACHINERY CO.LTD
Model no:
C8-R14-ER
C--- Condensing
8---Rotor diameter
R---Ratue stage
14---No stages (14 no’s)
E---Extraction type
R---With reduction gear coupled
Type of steam turbine:
Horizontal, Impulse, multi-stage, multi- valve, axial flow, condensing turbine with
1 uncontrolled+1 controlled extractions
Operating conditions:
Output (rated) ---20000kw
Speed (turbine/generator) --- 6194/1500rpm
Inlet steam pressure/temperature---85 kg/ cm2 A/510oc
Outlet steam pressure/temperature---0.1 kg/ cm2 A/45oc
Max. Inlet steam flow---100000 kg/hr
Max. 1st extraction pressure/flow---8.6kg/ cm2 A/16550 kg/hr
Max. 2nd extraction pressure/flow---3kg/ cm2 A/75790 kg/hr
Max. Exhaust pressure/flow ---0.1kg/ cm2 A/62920 kg/hr
Direction of rotation (view from the turbine front):
Turbine ---clock wise
Generator---counter clock wise
Speed governor:
Type---electro hydraulic governor
Model--- 505E
Make ---Wood ward
Adjustable speed --- 95-105% of rated speed
Range--- 109% of rated speed
Type of governor valves:
Type---throttle valve (quantity governing)
Description--- bar lift and multi-valve type
Over speed governor:
Mechanical eccentric trip--- value 115% on rated speed (7123 rpm)
Electrical Trip (signal from governor) --- value 114% on rated speed (7061 rpm)
Bearings:
Journal bearings (2 no’s)
Type---multi segmental tilting pad type
Material---carbon steel lined with Babbitt material
B) Thrust bearing (1 no’s)
Type---multi segmental tilting pad type (double side)
Material---carbon steel lined with Babbitt material.
Reduction gear box:
Type---horizontal, single reduction, double helical gear type.
Speed ratio---4.129:1
Lube oil system:
Kind of lube oil---Turbine oil ISO VG 46
Type of lubrication---forced
Min.oil flow required
Lube oil---651 lpm at 1.5 kg/cm2
Control oil---100 lpm at 14.0 kg/cm2
Trip oil---10 lpm at 4.0 kg/cm2
Material of steam turbine:
Casing:
HP---cast alloy steel (1.25cr-0.5Mo)
LP---carbon steel
Rotor--- Cr-Mo-V forged steel
Blades---Mo-13%Cr stainless steel
Nozzles--- Mo-13%Cr stainless steel
Diaphragm
HP---forged alloy steel
LP---carbon steel
Labyrinth packing---Ni-Pb bronze, carbon steel, stain less steel
Reduction gear box
Casing---cast iron
Pinion---forged alloy steel
Gear--- forged alloy steel
Base plate---carbon steel
Filters
Lube oil---40 microns (vertical, duplex type) made of stainless steel
Control oil---10 microns (vertical, duplex type) made of stainless steel
2.2 COMPONENTS OF STEAM TURBINE:
The main components in the steam turbine are mentioned below:
2.2.1Pedestal, Base Plate and Fixed Points:
The Turbines rest on the pedestals. The front pedestal houses the governor. The center
pedestal houses the combined journal and thrust bearing and the other pedestals contain one
journal bearing each. All pedestals are of fabricated construction. The front pedestal and the
center pedestal slide over their respective base plates, which are fixed to the foundation. While
the LP front and rear pedestals themselves are fixed to the foundation. On the rotating system the
fixed point is provided by the thrust bearing. The LP pedestals also carry the shaft seal housing
which is joined to the LP outer casing with compensators. Hence these gland clearances remain
unaffected by any deformation of LP cylinder during operation.
2.2.4Bearings:
The bearings are made in two halves and are all tilting type. The Rotor is supported by
two bearings. Bearing Babbitt temperatures are measured by the thermo couples directly under
the white metal. The temperature of the thrust pads is measured by the thermo couples in two
opposite pads on both turbine side and generator side. Lube oil is admitted in the oil spaces that
are milled into the bearing shells at the horizontal joint and are open to the shaft journal.
There are two types of bearings mostly used in turbine are
1. Journal bearings
2. Thrust bearings
Fig. 10 Journal bearing (segmental type) Fig. 11thrust bearing (tilting type)
Fig. 12 Arrangement of journal and thrust bearing of turbine
2.2.5 Rotor:
If the turbine is impulse type the rotor is disc type i.e. blades are carried in the discs,
which may be integral forged with shaft or shrunk on the shaft. Each rotor is subjected to 20%
over speed test and is balanced at 6194rpm. The rotors carry the moving blades. The shaft seals
are axial. All the rotors are dynamically balanced to every fine degree of precision; this ensures
that there are minimum vibrations and dynamic loading of bearings. Labyrinths with the sealing
strips caulked into the shafts. Sealing in turbine casings is provided to check steam leakage from
HP side and air leakage into LP side.
Fig. 17 Emergency stop valve (ESV) Fig. 18 Governor Valve (HP & LP)
CHAPTER – 3
START UP AND SHUTDOWN OF TURBINE
3.1 STARTUP OF THE TURBINE:
The turbine has to be stated according to the startup procedure to avoid the rubbing and
damage of the rotor and casing.
3.1.1 Types of Turbine startup:
There are three types of startup of turbine according to the time after shutdown of the turbine.
1) Cold startup (Over 8 hours after the shutdown)
2) Warm startup (Over 2-8 hours after the shutdown)
3) Hot startup (within 2 hours after the shutdown)
TROUBLESHOOTING
5. IDENTIFICATION OF TROUBLES AND THEIR REMEDIES:
c) Lake of performance of
GSC. d) Operate the purifier.
d) No operation of the
purifier.
8) Low lube oil a) High DP in filters. a) Change over the oil
pressure. b) Oil leakage. filters or elements.
b) Check the oil points
of lube oil, control oil
and trip oil.
TURBINE CALCULATIONS
7.1 TURBINE EFFICIENCY:
Efficiency of any plant or equipment is the ratio of output to its input expressed as
percentage; Output and input are expressed in same physical Units, The output is the electrical
energy sent out to the grid and input is the heat energy of the fuels fired in boiler. This is
normally termed as overall Station efficiency.
Thus Over all station efficiency= (Output of station/Input of station) X 100
= 75 X 1000 X (809-165)
Heat added = 48300000 kcal
48300000
So Heat rate = ----------------
19500
= 2476.92 Kcal/Kwhr
So,
Output
Turbo- alternator efficiency = ---------------
Input
(We know that, 1kWh = 860 kcal)
860
So efficiency = --------------- x 100
Heat rate
Heat rate = 2476.92 kcal/kwh
860
So efficiency = -------------- X 100
2476.92
Efficiency of turbine (η turbine) = 34.72 %
Over all station efficiency:
Energy sent out = 19,500 KWH
Fuel burnt= 16.0 MT/hr.
Calorific value of fuel = 4200 Kcal/Kg
(1KW = 860 Kcal = 3600 KJ)
Energy sent out (KW)
Over all station efficiency = --------------------------------------------------- X 100
Fuel burnt (kg) X GCV fuel (Kcal / Kg)
19500 X 860
= ----------------------------- X 100
16 x 1000 x 4500
In this turbine, the steam is removed from the turbine at two points B and B1.It is then
fed into two open feed water heater and to dearator. The steam (at pressure 85 bars) enters the
turbine at point A. Let a small amount of Steam after partial expansion (at pressure 7.8 bars) is
drained from the turbine at point B and enter the feed water heater. Similarly, let another small
amount of steam after further expansion (at pressure 2.1 bars) is drained from the turbine at point
B1 and enter the dearator. The Remaining steam (at pressure 0.09 bars) is further expanded in
turbine, and leaves it at point C.
The steam is then condensed in the condenser. The condensate from the condenser is
pumped into the feed water heater, where it mixes up with the steam extracted from the turbine.
Let,
h1 = Enthalpy of steam entering the turbine at A ----- (809 Kcal / Kg)
h2 = Enthalpy of steam bled at B ------ (658 Kcal / Kg)
h3 = Enthalpy of steam bled at B1 ------ (644 Kcal / Kg)
h4 = Enthalpy of steam leaving the turbine at C ----- (615 Kcal / Kg)
hf2 = Enthalpy of feed water leaving the feed water heater ------ (164 Kcal / Kg)
hf3 = Enthalpy of feed water leaving the dearator ----- (150 Kcal / Kg)
hf4 = Enthalpy of feed water leaving the condenser ----- (45.71 Kcal / Kg)
m = Amount of main steam -------- 75000 kg/hr.
m1 = Amount of steam bleed at B (1st extraction) ------- 7200 kg/hr.
m2 = Amount of steam bleed at BꞋ (2st extraction) ------ 112000 kg/hr.
13915600
= ---------------------X 100
48375000
Taking
The boiler efficiency is 85.00% from indirect method (ASME PTC 4.0)
The generator efficiency is 98.00%
The overall efficiency is = 0.85 X 0.28766 X 0.98 X 100
= 23.96 %
= 14082900
---------------------X 100
49084500
Taking
The boiler efficiency is 85.00% from indirect method (ASME PTC 4.0)
The generator efficiency is 98.00% the overall efficiency is
The overall efficiency is = 0.85 X 0.28766 X 0.98
= 23.96 %
In this turbine, the steam is removed from the turbine at two points B and B1.It is then fed into
two open feed water heater and to de-aerator the steam (at pressure 85 bars) enters the turbine at
point A. Let a small amount of steam (say m kg) after partial expansion (at pressure 7.8 bars) be
drained from the turbine at point B and enter the feed water heater. Similarly, let another small
amount of steam (say m2 kg) after further expansion (at pressure 2.1 bars) be drained from the
turbine at point B1 and enter the de-aerator. The remaining steam equal to (1-m1-m2) kg (at
pressure 0.09 bars) is further expanded in turbine, and leaves it at point C.
The steam is then condensed in the condenser. The condensate from the condenser is
pumped into the feed water heater, where it mixes up with the steam extracted from the turbine.
Now consider 1 kg of steam entering into the turbine at A.
Note: neglecting the heat losses in line and efficiency losses of heater.
Let,
h1 = Enthalpy of steam entering the turbine at A ----- (809 Kcal / Kg)
h2 = Enthalpy of steam bled at B ------ (658 Kcal / Kg)
h3 = Enthalpy of steam bled at B1 ------ (644 Kcal / Kg)
h4 = Enthalpy of steam leaving the turbine at C ----- (615 Kcal / Kg)
hf2 = Enthalpy of feed water leaving the feed water heater ------ (164 Kcal / Kg)
hf3 = Enthalpy of feed water leaving the dearator ----- (150 Kcal / Kg)
hf4 = Enthalpy of feed water leaving the condenser ----- (45.71 Kcal / Kg)
m1 = minimum Amount of steam bled at B per kg of steam supplied, and
m2 = minimum Amount of steam bled at B1 per kg of steam supplied.
As the that heat lost by bled steam at B = Heat gained by feed water
m1 (h2-hf2) = (1-m1) (hf2-hf3)
m1h2-m1hf2 = hf2-hf3-m1hf2+m1hf3
m1 = (hf2-hf3) / (h2-hf3)
164-150
m1 = ----------------
658-150
m1 = 0.028kg/hr.
So the m1 is 0.0295kg/hr.
Similarly, heat lost by bled steam at B1 =Heat gained by feed water
m2 (h3-hf3) = (1-m1-m2) (hf3-hf4)
m2h3-m2hf3 = hf3-hf4-m1hf3+m1hf4-m2hf3+m2hf4
m2 = ((1-m1) (hf3-hf4) / (h3-hf4)
(1-0.028) X (150-45.71)
m2 = --------------------------------
(644-45.71)
m2 = 0.169kg/hr.
So the m2 is 0.169kg/hr.
We know that Amount of steam (m) of turbine is 75000 kg/hr.
So the m1 &m2 for 75000 kg/hr. steam flow is
m1 = 75000 X 0.028
= 2100 kg/hr.
m2 = 75000 X 0.169
= 12675 kg/hr.
14092125
= ------------------- X 100
48375000
= 29.131 %
Taking
The boiler efficiency is 85.00% from indirect method (ASME PTC 4.0).
The generator efficiency is 98.00%
The overall efficiency is = 0.85 X 0.29131 X 0.98
In this project, the study constructional features and maintenance of steam turbine for
increasing the performance and safe running of turbine. We also studied the starting, shutdown,
overhauling, protections, troubles and their remedies.
Those are:
1. Crack was identified on the upper casing of gear box at HSS bearing housing, and removed
by grinding with depth of 15 mm and welded by the LH 115 and LH 117 electrodes to fill
the crack.
2. The scaling on the blades is removed by alumina-sand blast cleaning during overhauling
period.
3. Also thermal calculations are carried out on the turbine to know the efficiency of the turbine
by different methods and finding the actual efficiency of the turbine and overall efficiency
of the plant, before and after overhaul conditions.
4. And found that the efficiency of the turbine was increased by 0.08%, so that the overall
plant efficiency is increases 0.07%.
5. And made calculations to increase the plant overall efficiency by optimizing the extraction
steam flows.
6. And found that the efficiency of the turbine was increased by 0.361%, so that the overall
plant efficiency is increases 0.31%. But the actual efficiency of the turbine is nearly equal to
designed efficiency for satisfied extraction flows.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
4. www.power-eng.com/topics/boiler-and-steam-turbine.htm
5. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam turbine
6. www.energy-tech.com › Columns