Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/359821239
CITATIONS READS
0 265
3 authors:
Brijesh Singh
National Council for Cement and Building Materials
82 PUBLICATIONS 212 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Studies on mechanical and time dependent properties of Very High Strength and Ultra High Strength Concrete. View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Brijesh Singh on 26 April 2022.
T
at the anode and cathode are combined with an electrical current
he performance of structure is its ability to meet functional
through the steel and through the concrete. Damages to the concrete
and time requirement. Concrete deteriorates with time
due to freezing and thawing, creep, shrinkage, thermal cracking,
and results in gradual decrease in performance over time.
abrasion, erosion, impact or excessive loading are generally clubbed
The time dependent degradation of concrete can be intrinsic to the
into the second category which is physical in nature. Damage due
concrete or induced by the interaction between the service condition
to vegetation and biological growth, dirt and rubbish deposits etc.
and the concrete. Durability design is by nature is a multilevel task:
are biogenic in nature and are clubbed into third category.[2-6]
at whole structure level, at a level of structural elements and at
The very reason of concrete deterioration stems from the fact
a material level.[1] At level of structure as a whole, durability design
that concrete is a porous material and through the pore network,
is about selecting a service life of structure for given environmental
aggressive agents can enter inside the concrete through various
action and arriving at rational structural element assemblage and
transport process. Transport mechanisms (Ionic transport, Moisture
their layout so that the transient performance of the structure can
transport, Electrochemical potential, Temperature distribution)
always be maintained to an expected level. At the level of structural
govern the rate of ingress of the deterioration inducing species
element, the durability design is about fulfilling the selected design
in concrete and its understanding is fundamental to developing
service life through more specific technical requirements such as
service life prediction model of reinforced concrete structures.[4]
section details, concrete cover thickness, material properties etc.
Understanding the transport mechanisms helps in transfer of lab
Technical requirements from other structural design considerations experiments on accelerated durability tests to the actual behaviour
such as design for structural loads or fire etc also interferes at this of structures under field exposure. Transport mechanism explains and
level in the selection of section details, concrete cover thickness, provides ways and means to quantify the deleterious effects, helps
material properties etc. Then at third level, concrete mixture is in developing mitigation strategies and assists in material selection
designed appropriately both in order to satisfy the specific material and their quality control testing. Principal factors involved in transport
properties transferred from durability consideration and other process in uncracked concrete are summarized in Fig. 1.[7] In cracked
structural design considerations such as design for structural loads concrete, more complex transport mechanisms are involved and are
or fire etc. still not clearly understood.
leading to deterioration of concrete and embedded steel. Concrete Reliability and failures are addressed either in probabilistic terms
structures are designed in accordance with national or international or through partial factor of safety.[11, 14] Common step in durability
codes and standards such as Indian standard IS 456, Eurocode design are:
EN 1992-2004, Eurocode EN 206, ACI 318-2011, RILEM, JSCE etc.
Step-1
The structural design focuses on the structure’s ability to resist the
mechanical load imposed on the structure whereas durability design Selection of realistic model describing the process (to quantify
focuses on structure’s ability to resist the environmental impact and the deterioration and resistance provided by the concrete):
associated deterioration and degradation imposed on the structure Model should incorporate the environmental actions with statistically
during its entire life span. Service life design methods are similar to quantified environmental parameters (e.g. temperature, relative
the load and resistance-factor design procedure used for structural humidity, splash rain events etc.). From resistance side, model should
design. Modeling of environment and deterioration mechanisms is be able to be validated by realistic laboratory experiments and by
being developed on a probabilistic basis allowing reliability based practice in the field.
service life design. Step-2
Approaches to Durability Design of Concrete Structures Definition of limit states: against which the structure should be
The service life can be designed by using two principles: designed for. Such as depassivation of reinforcement caused by
deem-to-satisfy rules, and performance-based design. The deem-to- carbonation, cracking due to reinforcement corrosion, spalling of
satisfy rules are based on specifying a certain concrete composition concrete cover due to reinforcement corrosion, collapse due to loss
and concrete caver, but the result is not a specified service life. of cross section of the reinforcement.
Traditionally, national and international concrete
standards give requirements to achieve the
desired design service life based on the ‘deemed
to-satisfy’ and the ‘avoidance of deterioration’
approach.
The performance–based design is based on
requirements of performance of the structure,
and the result will be a long specified service
life with limit states. Service Life Design (SLD)
or Limit State Design (LSD), also known as Load
and Resistance Factor Design (LRFD) is based on
approach to resist (not to avoid) deterioration
caused by environmental actions. For SLD,
quantifiable models should be available on the
Load side (Environmental Actions) and Resistance
side (Resistance of Concrete) i.e. Deterioration of
concrete, its impact on physical performance
of structure and associated uncertainty and
variability should be quantifiable. [11, 14]
Limit
State of Durability is defined as:
Class Description of the Informative Examples In its most recent version of ACI 318 -11, environmental actions
Designation Environment are classified into several categories. Eurocode and ACI 318 strictly
No Risk of Corrosion or Attack follow a prescriptive approach of durability design, however certain
X0 For concrete without Concrete inside buildings provisions for performance based design is also there. Unlike Eurocode
reinforcement or for with very low air humidity
very dry concrete and ACI 318, the JSCE guidelines adopts mainly a performance based
with reinforcement approach for durability design. ISO 16204: 2012 which is based on
Corrosion Induced by Carbonation the principles given in ISO 2394, General principles on reliability
XC1 Dry or permanently Concrete inside buildings for structures, ISO 13823, General principles on the design of
wet with low air humidity;
Concrete permanently structures for durability and fib “Model Code for Service Life Design”
submerged in water treats design for environmental actions leading to deterioration of
XC2 Wet, rarely dry Concrete surfaces subject concrete and embedded steel.
to long-term water contact;
foundations Durability Design Concrete against Carbonation Induced
XC3 Moderate humidity Concrete inside buildings Reinforcement Corrosion
with moderate or high air
humidity; External concrete The decrease in pH of the concrete interstitial solution linked to
sheltered from rain the penetration of atmospheric CO2 into the porosity of the concrete
XC4 Cyclic wet and dry Concrete surfaces subject is carbonation and the induced corrosion is carbonation induced
to water contact, not within
exposure class XC2 reinforcement corrosion. For the purpose of durability design,
Corrosion Induced by Chlorides Other than from Sea Water the ingress of the carbonation front is assumed to obey the following
XD1 Moderate humidity Concrete surfaces exposed equation:
to airborne chlorides
C (t) = W. K. tx
XD2 Wet, rarely dry Swimming pools; Concrete
exposed to industrial waters Where C is Depth of carbonation in mm at a given time t (in years)
containing chlorides
W is weather coefficient takes into account the varying
XD3 Cyclic wet and dry Parts of bridges exposed to
spray containing chlorides. meso-climatic conditions for the specific concrete member during
Pavements, Car park slabs the design service life, such as humidity and temperature.
Corrosion Induced by Chlorides from Sea Water
K is carbonation coefficient, a factor reflecting the basic resistance
XS1 Exposed to airborne Structures near to or on the
salt coast
of the chosen concrete mix (like water/cement ratio, cement type,
XS2 Permanently Parts of marine structures additions) under reference conditions and the influence of the basic
submerged environmental conditions (like mean relative humidity and CO2
XS3 Tidal, splash and Parts of marine structures concentration) on ingress of carbonation. It also reflects the influence
spray zones
of the execution.
Freeze/Thaw Attack
X is the exponent indicating change of rate of carbonation w.r.t
XF1 Moderate saturation, Vertical concrete surfaces
No salt (rain and freezing ) binder type.
XF2 Moderate saturation, Vertical concrete surfaces ( For the design of a new structure, the weather coefficient
Salt freezing and salt)
W can be taken in between from 0.9 to 1.25 depending upon
XF3 High saturation, No Horizontal concrete surfaces
salt (rain and freezing ) how the environmental action is conducive in the progress of
XF4 High saturation, Salt Concrete surfaces exposed carbonation front. The carbonation coefficient K might be derived
to direct spray from literature data or existing structures where the concrete
Chemical Attack
composition, execution and exposure conditions have been similar
XA1 Slightly aggressive Exposed to natural soil and
to those expected for the new structure. A relationship between
ground water
carbonation coefficient K and electrical resistivity of concrete made
XA2 Moderately Exposed to natural soil and
aggressive ground water with different type of cement may be developed experimentally
XA3 Highly aggressive Exposed to natural soil and and can be used for further design purpose. For very important
ground water
structures (Service life more than 50 year), carbonation coefficient K
shall be determined through accelerated carbonation test during For the design of a new structure, the parameters Cs, Ci, α and
the concrete mix design stage. Time for initiation of corrosion (ti) in Dapp (t0) may be derived from existing structures where the concrete
years, shall be calculated using the model equation. The propagation composition, execution and exposure conditions have been similar
time (tp), which is time from initiation of corrosion to initiation to those relevant for the new structure.
of crack shall be taken appropriately. It shall be ensured that, Design value of surface chloride content, Csd shall be taken for
tsl (design service life)≤( ti+tp). different exposure classes from the existing literature. Design value
Durability Design against Chloride Induced Reinforcement of threshold chloride content/critical chloride content may be taken
Corrosion 0.4% by mass of cement for concrete made with OPC and 0.3% by
The three most important variables that govern the chloride mass of cement for PPC and PSC as recommended in various existing
intrusion into concrete and the corrosion of the reinforcement literature. Initial Diffusion coefficient Da(t0) can be determined
are concentration of chlorides at the surface (Cs), concentration from established equation between Da(t0) and W/C ratio for OPC,
threshold value which initiates corrosion of steel, and the transport PPC and PSC and then a design value of chloride diffusion coefficients
rate of chloride ions in the concrete cover layer[16,17,18]. The penetration (Dd(t)) for service life (exposure period) t will be calculated. At concrete
of chloride ions into concrete is a complex nonlinear dynamic mix design stage, for a known w/c or w/cm ratio, performance based
phenomenon including several transport mechanisms (ionic diffusion, accelerated test such as RCPT/Electrical Resistivity shall be conducted
capillary sorption, permeation, dispersion, etc. The ionic diffusion is as applicable. For important structures, Da(t0) shall be determined
considered to have the most dominant effect under the assumption through unidirectional diffusion test, which is a long duration test.
that concrete cover is fully saturated. RCPT/Electrical Resistivity shall be conducted as for determining
the values to be considered for acceptance during quality control.
The ingress of chlorides in a marine environment may be assumed
The service life is determined on the basis of critical surface chloride
to obey modified Fick’s second law of diffusion.
content and threshold chloride content value. It will be ensured that
x Cx,t ≤ Cth ( threshold chloride content).
C ( x, t ) C s (C s C i ) erf
2 D (t ) t
app
For durability design of RC structures,
Where:
deterioration of concrete, its impact on physical
C(x, t) is the content of chlorides in the concrete at a depth
performance of structure and associated uncertainty
x (structure surface: x = 0 mm) and at time t [% by mass of binder];
and variability should be quantifiable. Reliability
Cs is the chloride content at the concrete surface [% by mass of binder];
and failures are addressed either in probabilistic
Ci is the initial chloride content of the concrete [% by mass of binder]; terms or through partial factors of safety.
x is the depth with a corresponding content of chlorides C(x, t) [mm];
Dapp(t) is the apparent coefficient of chloride diffusion through Durability Design against Sulphate Attack
concrete [mm2/year] at time t; Sulphate attack is the most common chemical form of concrete
t is the time [years] of exposure; erf is the error function deterioration. Sulphates are commonly found in soil, aggregates,
or surface coating based on asphalt, chlorinated rubber, epoxy; 2. Types of damage in concrete structures. By K Kovler and V.Chernov, Book:
or polyurethane materials have been recommended so as used to Failure, Distress and Repair of Concrete Structures, Woodhead Publishing
Series in Civil and Structural Engineering, 2009, Pages 32-56
prevent access by the sulphate solution. For durability design against
sulphate attack, national and international concrete standards 3. Concrete deterioration: causes, diagnosis, and minimizing risk. D.W. Hobbs,
International Materials Reviews, Volume 46, 2001 - Issue 3
and codes, presently adopts traditional way of design i.e. “deemed
4. Durability of concrete: Degradation phenomena involving detrimental
to-satisfy” or “avoidance of deterioration” approach.
chemical reactions, Fredrik P. Glasser, Jacques Marchand and Eric
Durability Design against Alkali Aggregate Reactivity (AAR) Samson, Cement and Concrete Research, Volume 38, February 2008, pp.
The chemical reaction between alkali hydroxides from Portland 226-246
cement and specific category of aggregates is known as alkali 5. Durability deterioration of concrete under marine environment from
aggregate reaction. The swelling and cracking due to aggregate material to structure: A critical review. Fulin Qu, Wengui Li, Wenkui Dong,
alkali reaction appears after many years of construction. Even though Vivian W.Y,Tam and Tao Yu , Journal og Building Rngineering, Voilume 35,
March 2021
the deterioration due to it is a slow process but is progressive and
6. Concrete Repair and Maintenance Illustrated: Problem Analysis; Repair
combined with other causes can lead to complete failure of structure.
Strategy; Techniques. Book by PH Emmons, 1992
The AAR can be subdivided to two types viz, Alkali silica reaction
7. Transport Process in Concrete by Luca Bertolini, Bernhard Elsener, Pietro
(ASR) and alkali carbonate reaction (ACR). Currently, in IS: 456-2000
Pedeferri and Rob B Polder from Book- Corrosion of Steel in Concrete:
“deemed to-satisfy” or “avoidance of deterioration” approach is
Prevention, Diagnosis, Repair, Pages 21-48, Wiley VCH, 2004
recommended for durability design against AAR.
8. Durability design of concrete structures-Part 1: Analysis Fundamentals,
Durability Design against Freeze Thaw Radomir Folić, Facta universitatis - series Architecture and Civil Engineering,
Deterioration of concrete exposed to freezing generally occurs Vol. 7, 2009, pp. 1 – 18
when there is sufficient amount of internal moisture. The transition of 9. Durability design of concrete structures, Part 2: Modelling and structural
water to ice results an increase in volume. When the saturated pores Assessment, Radomir Folić, Facta universitatis - series Architecture and Civil
Engineering · January 2010
in the concrete freezes, it can cause severe cracking and disruption.
Widely accepted mathematical models exist for freeze thaw and 10. Structural durability and concept system of structural reliability, Yao
Jitao, Chen Liuzhuo, Gao Jun and Xin Ren, IOP Conf. Series: Earth and
Service Life Design (SLD) approach of durability design against
Environmental Science, 2019, Pages 1-10
freeze thaw can be adopted in IS: 456-2000 in similar lines to
11. ISO 16204: 2012, Durability- Service life design of concrete structures
ISO 16204 and fib MC SLD.
12. ISO 2394, General principles on reliability for structures
Conclusions 13. ISO 13823:2008, General principles on the design of structures for durability
In the recent decade, owing to the ageing and often premature
14. The fib Bulletin 34: Model Code for Service Life Design (2006)
deterioration of infrastructure in India, the durability design of
15. IS: 456-2000, “Code of Practice for Plain and Reinforced Concrete”, Bureau of
concrete structures has increasingly received attention. There is need
Indian Standards, New Delhi
for suitable and reliable performance based approaches which can
16. Future directions for design, specification, testing, and construction of
relate to the shortcomings of the traditionally prescriptive design durable concrete structures. R Douglas Hootan, Cement and Concrete
methods for concrete durability. The prescriptive approach therefore Research, Volume 124, October 2019
often fails to offer a rational basis for the selection of suitable materials, 17. Durability for concrete structures in marine environments of HZM project:
design procedures, quality assurance etc. which hampers the service Design, assessment and beyond,. Kefei Li, Dongdong Zhang, Quanwang
life of structure. The application of a performance approach for Li, Zhihong Fan, Cement and Concrete Research, Volume 115, January
concrete durability shifts a large portion of the responsibility from 2019
the design engineer to the concrete supplier and contractor, 18. Crack-altered durability properties and performance of structural
who have to work as a team to produce a structure that meets concretes. Kefei Li and Le li, Cement and Concrete Research, Volume 124,
October 2019
the required durability characteristics.