20.09.

2022
To,
The Chief Engineer-II,
Rural Water Supply & Sanitation (RWS&S),
Bhubaneswar, Odisha.

Sub: Review of Structural design & drawings of ESR’s of Telkoi, Patna, Harichandanpur & Ghatagaon block at
Keonjhar District as submitted by M/s L&T Construction as per observation letter number
TUV-SUD/BBSR/AE/Keonjhar.2022.237.

Dear Sir,

With reference to the above captioned subject regarding the review of Structural design & drawings of ESR’s at
Telkoi, Patna, Harichandanpur & Ghatagaon block at Keonjhar District as submitted by M/s L&T Construction. The
structural design & drawings has been reviewed and all the observations given by TUV-SUD has been marked by the
Agency in drawings.

220 KL-ESR at Budhipadakha

220 KL-ESR at Budhakhamana
200 KL- ESR at Dhenikikote
170 KL-ESR at Toranipokhari
70KL-ESR at Dalki
50KL-ESR at Patulikota
120KL-ESR at Manoharpur
290KL-ESR at Khuntapasi
150KL-ESR at Balbhadrapur
180KL-ESR at Bandhubeda

General observations for ESR’s of Different Staging’s.

1. Grade of concrete considered in design for water retaining-M30.
2. Grade of steel considered in design -Fe500.

220 KL-ESR at Budhipadakha

1 In Walkway slab distribution reinforcement provided at as 8@300mm c/c, whereas recommended

8@200mm c/c instead of provided.
2 In Conical dome reinforcement provided at as Y16@170mm, each face along hoop direction whereas
recommended Y16@150mm c/c instead of provided.
3 In Column ties C1 reinforcement provided as Y8@190mm c/c, whereas recommended Y8@175mm c/c
instead of provided.
4 In Beam PB1, TB1, TB2 at support and mid span stirrups provided as 2L-Y8@130mm c/c, whereas
recommended 2L-Y8@125mm c/c instead of provided.
5 In staircase main reinforcement provided as Y12 @ 150mm c/c, whereas recommended Y12@125 mm c/c
instead of provided.
220 KL-ESR at Budhakhamana
1 In Walkway slab distribution reinforcement provided at as 8@300mm c/c, whereas recommended
8@200mm c/c instead of provided.
2 In Conical dome reinforcement provided at as Y16@170mm c/c, whereas recommended Y16@150mm c/c
instead of provided.
3 In raft shear link provided as Y8@250mm c/c, whereas recommended Y8@200 mm c/c instead of provided
4 In Column ties reinforcement provided as Y8@190mm c/c, whereas recommended Y8@175mm c/c instead
of provided.
5 In Beam PB1, TB1, & TB2 stirrups provided as Y8@130mm c/c, whereas recommended Y8@125mm c/c
instead of provided.
6 In ring beam RB1 stirrups provided as Y10@175mm c/c, whereas recommended as Y10 @ 150mm c/c
instead of provided.
.

200 KL- ESR at Dhenikikote

1 In cylindrical wall distribution reinforcement at 2.7m provided as 10@190c/c , whereas recommended as
10@175 c/c instead of provided.
2 In cylindrical wall distribution reinforcement at 1.2m provided as 10@120 c/c , whereas recommended as
10@100 c/c instead of provided.
3 In Walkway slab main reinforcement provided at as 8@200mm c/c, whereas recommended 8@150mm c/c
instead of provided.
4 In Walkway slab distribution reinforcement provided at as 8@300mm c/c, whereas recommended
8@200mm c/c instead of provided.
5 In Conical dome reinforcement provided at as Y16@200mm, whereas recommended Y16@175mm c/c
instead of provided.
6 In raft shear link provided as Y10@110mm c/c, whereas recommended Y10@100 mm c/c instead of
provided

7 In ring beam RB1 stirrups provided as Y10@190mm c/c, whereas recommended as Y10 @ 150mm c/c
instead of provided.
8 In Column ties reinforcement provided as Y 8@190mm c/c, whereas recommended Y8@175mm c/c
instead of provided.
9 In Beam PB1, TB1,TB2 & TB3 stirrups provided as Y8@145mm c/c, whereas recommended Y8@125mm
c/c instead of provided.
10 In raft top face distribution reinforcement provided as 12@110mm c/c whereas recommended 12@100mm
c/c instead of provided.
11 In staircase main reinforcement provided as Y12 @ 140mm c/c, whereas recommended Y12@125 mm c/c
instead of provided.
170 KL-ESR at Toranipokhari
1 In Walkway slab main reinforcement provided at as 8@190mm c/c, whereas recommended 8@150mm c/c
instead of provided.
2 In Walkway slab distribution reinforcement provided at as 8@300mm c/c, whereas recommended
8@200mm c/c instead of provided.
3 In cylindrical wall up to 1.5 m provided as 10@140 c/c , whereas recommended as 10@125 c/c instead of
provided
4 In Beam PB1, TB1,TB2 TB3,TB4 &SSB1 stirrups provided as Y8@140mm c/c, whereas recommended
Y8@125mm c/c instead of provided.
5 In raft top face distribution & bottom reinforcement provided as 16@160mm c/c whereas recommended
16@150mm c/c instead of provided.
6 In raft shear link provided as Y8@160mm c/c, whereas recommended Y8@150 mm c/c instead of provided
7 In ring beam RB1 stirrups provided as Y10@240mm c/c, whereas recommended as Y10 @ 200mm c/c
instead of provided.
8 In Column ties provided as Y8@250 mm c/c, whereas recommended as Y8 @200 mm c/c instead of
provided.
.
9 In staircase main reinforcement provided as Y12 @ 140mm c/c, whereas recommended Y12@125 mm c/c
instead of provided.

70 KL-ESR at Dalki
1 In cylindrical side wall reinforcement provided 10@130 on both face whereas recommended as 10@125
c/c instead of provided
2 In Walkway slab distribution reinforcement provided at as 8@300mm c/c, whereas recommended
8@200mm c/c instead of provided.
3 In Column ties C1,C2 reinforcement provided as Y8@250 mm c/c, whereas recommended as Y8 @200
mm c/c instead of provided.
4 Staircase Design is attached in the design booklet & typical steps reinforcement mentioned in drawing
sheet.

50KL-ESR at Patulikota
1 In cylindrical side wall reinforcement provided 10@130 on both face whereas recommended as 10@125
c/c instead of provided
2 In Walkway slab distribution reinforcement provided at as 8@300mm c/c, whereas recommended
8@200mm c/c instead of provided.
3 In Column ties C1,C2 reinforcement provided as Y8@250 mm c/c, whereas recommended as Y8 @200
mm c/c instead of provided.
4 Staircase Design is attached in the design booklet & typical steps reinforcement mentioned in drawing sheet
120KL-ESR at Manoharpur
1. In Walkway slab distribution reinforcement provided at as 8@300mm c/c, whereas recommended
8@200mm c/c instead of provided.
2. In bottom dome both top & bottom reinforcement provided as 8@200 c/c whereas recommended
8@175mm c/c instead of provided.
3. In Column ties reinforcement provided as Y8@250 mm c/c, whereas recommended as Y8 @200 mm c/c
instead of provided
4. In raft shear link provided as Y8@300mm c/c, whereas recommended Y8@200 mm c/c instead of
provided.
5. In ring beam RB1 stirrups provided as Y10@270mm c/c, whereas recommended as Y10 @ 200mm c/c
instead of provided.
6. In staircase distruibution reinforcement provided as Y8 @ 200mm c/c, whereas recommended Y8@150
mm c/c instead of provided.
290KL-ESR at Khuntapasi
1. In Walkway slab distribution reinforcement provided at as 8@300mm c/c, whereas recommended
8@200mm c/c instead of provided.
2. In bottom dome both top & bottom reinforcement provided as 8@170 c/c whereas recommended
8@150mm c/c instead of provided.
3. In Conical wall main reinforcement provided at as Y16@160mm c/c, whereas recommended Y16@150mm
c/c instead of provided
4. In ring beam RB1 stirrups provided as Y10@270mm c/c, whereas recommended as Y10 @ 200mm c/c
instead of provided.
5. In Column ties reinforcement provided as Y8@250 mm c/c, whereas recommended as Y8 @200 mm c/c
instead of provided
6. In staircase distruibution reinforcement provided as Y8 @ 200mm c/c, whereas recommended Y8@150
mm c/c instead of provided.
 7. In Beam PB1, TB1,TB2 TB3,TB4 &SSB1,SSB2 stirrups provided as Y8@140/145mm c/c, whereas
recommended Y8@125mm c/c instead of provided.
8. In raft top face distribution reinforcement provided as 12@150mm c/c whereas recommended 12@125mm
c/c instead of provided.
9. In staircase main reinforcement provided as Y12 @ 140mm c/c, whereas recommended Y12@125 mm c/c
instead of provided.
150KL-ESR at Balbhadrapur
1. In Walkway slab distribution reinforcement provided at as 8@300mm c/c, whereas recommended
8@200mm c/c instead of provided.
2. In Walkway slab main reinforcement provided at as 8@190mm c/c, whereas recommended 8@175mm c/c
instead of provided.
3. In Column ties reinforcement provided as Y8@250 mm c/c, whereas recommended as Y8 @200 mm c/c
instead of provided.
4. In Beam PB1, TB1, TB2 at support and mid span stirrups provided as Y8@135mm c/c, whereas
recommended Y8@125mm c/c instead of provided.
180-ESR at Bandhubeda
1. In walkway slab distribution reinforcement provided as 8@ 300mm C/C whereas recommended 8@200
mm C/C instead of provided.
2. In conical wall main & distribution reinforcement provided as 16@200mm C/C in hoop direction, whereas
recommended 16 @175 mm C/C instead of provided.
3. In column, ties are provided 8 @'250 mm C/C whereas recommended 8 @ 200 mm C/C instead of
provided.
4. In raft Shear link provided as 8 @ 300 mm C/C whereas recommended 8@ 200 mm C/C instead of
provided.

Yours Sincerely, Yours Sincerely,

Rohit kumar Laganajit Das

Structural Engineer (Design cell, RWSS) Team leader (Design cell, RWSS)