The Effectiveness of PhET-Assisted Inductive Thinking

Learning Models on Students’ Critical Thinking Skills and

Curiosity Attitudes
Wildan Navisa Barra1, a) and Supahar2, b)
1
Magister Program of Physics Education, Faculty of Mathematics and Science, Yogyakarta State University,
Yogyakarta, Indonesia
2
Department of Science Education, Faculty of Mathematics and Science, Yogyakarta State University,
Yogyakarta, Indonesia
a)
Corresponding author: wildanbarra.2017@student.uny.ac.id
b)
supahar@uny.ac.id

Abstract. This study aims to determine the effectiveness of the PhET-assisted inductive thinking learning model on
students' critical thinking skills and curiosity attitudes. This study is a quasi-experimental study using a pretest-posttest
control group design. The study population is the entire 10 th grade for the department of mathematics and science at
Senior High School State 1, Jetis, Bantul, Yogyakarta which amounts to 160 students. The study sample used a cluster
random sampling technique. Data collection uses test techniques and questionnaires using description questions and
questionnaires. The General Linear Model is used as a data analysis technique. The results showed that the PhET-assisted
inductive thinking learning model: (1) effectively improves students' critical thinking skills and curiosity attitudes
simultaneously with a large effect size. (2) effectively improve students' critical thinking skills with a large effect size. (3)
does not have a great effect on the student's attitude of curiosity. In addition, judging from the improvement of critical
thinking skills and students' curiosity attitudes, the inductive thinking learning model is more effective with a large effect
size.

INTRODUCTION

The development of education affects economic growth. Economic improvement in a country is generally
followed by the success of the education of its citizens. Education is very important for a country as a means to
improve people's welfare and economic growth in a country [1]. Education improves the quality of life of citizens so
that it has a positive impact on economic growth [2]. Education is a form of effort made by the government to
improve the quality of life of the people. Education helps people to improve their social position, have a higher
income, be happier, and have better physical health.
Education plays an important role in ensuring future generations are well educated in the face of the challenges
of the 21st century. Today, students have developed into active learners and are good at using digital technology,
electronic devices, and internet accessibility as their learning tools [3]. An effective teacher is a teacher who can
respond to changes, meet the needs of students as learners in the 21st century, establish social interactions with
students, and can use information and communication technology for teaching. The goal is that students are science-
capable, able to use technology, communicate effectively, think critically, and be able to work together [4]. Students
are equipped with a variety of knowledge, skills, and educated to have a good character so that they become highly
competitive human resources and can adapt in a complex and fast-changing environment.
One of the 21st-century skills needed by students as the successor of the Indonesian nation today is critical
thinking skills. Critical thinking skills as a person's response to seeing and solving problems wisely by using
reasoning and logical inquiry based on experience [5]. Critical thinking skills are used in making decisions by
reviewing problems based on different perspectives [6]. Critical thinking skills require a thorough analysis of
existing information [7]. Thus, critical thinking skills are thinking skills by reviewing problems based on different
perspectives, then conducting logical investigations and analyzing information thoroughly so that a person can make
decisions appropriately. There are four aspects of critical thinking skills, namely: 1) providing basic explanations
with indicators of asking questions and analyzing arguments; 2) establishing basic skills with indicators assessing
the credibility of data sources; 3) making conclusions with indicators of deduction or induction and; 4) provide
advanced explanations with indicators identifying assumptions or conjectures [8-10].
Critical thinking skills are so important and needed by students in life in a society that teachers must provide
teaching that focuses on student interaction. But ironically, students' critical thinking skills in Indonesia are still
relatively low [11,12]. This is in line with the results of research by Sulisworo, Daimah, Toifur and Suryadi at
Senior High School State 1, Jetis, Bantul, Yogyakarta which shows that the average score of students' critical
thinking skills in physics learning is still below 70 so it still needs to be improved [13]. The low critical thinking
skills of students are caused because students do not have good argumentation skills in using critical analysis, are
embarrassed to ask questions, and are less skilled in solving problems [14]. On the other hand, the education system
is slow in responding to a changing environment and still emphasizes the transfer of information rather than the
development of skills [15].
The results of observations and interviews with one of the physics teachers at Senior High School State 1, Jetis,
Bantul, Yogyakarta, namely Mrs. Daimah, M.Pd, obtained information that physics teachers use a learning model
that stimulates students to be active in activities by the 2013 curriculum, one of which is the two stay and two stray
learning model. Students are formed in groups, after which the teacher explains the subject matter of physics. Then
some of the students in each group met each other and exchanged ideas. This is done because usually, students are
embarrassed and reluctant to ask the teacher if there is physics material that is difficult to understand so through
these learning activities, the process of transferring knowledge becomes easier. However, the obstacle for teachers in
using the two-stay and two-stray learning model is that during the meeting activities, each student who meets has
different abilities in teaching other students when discussing. Therefore, when it is about to change with other
guests, the discussion time is up. Although the two stays and two stray learning model is oriented towards student
activity, it has not facilitated students to develop their curiosity in studying physics subject matter. In physics
learning, an attitude of curiosity is needed so that science in the field of physics continues to develop. Alger defines
an attitude of curiosity as an action that is accompanied by an impulse to explore without having a purpose that still
highlights the human side in terms of science [16]. Hardy, Ness, and Mecca argue that an attitude of curiosity will
force individuals to adopt a focus of attention to expand the horizons of information for the formation of students'
ideas so that it is useful to turn potential into skills [17]. Hochberg, Kuhn, and Müller define the attitude of curiosity
as the human act of seeking new information or experiences whose results can be satisfactory or unsatisfactory and
correlate with the efforts that the individual makes [18]. Thus, an attitude of curiosity is an individual response that
involves the five senses, will, and mental, to know something.
The aspects of curiosity are: 1) searching for information with indicators of reading, asking, and discussing; 2)
observation to learn with indicators of observing objects, phenomena, behaviors, or situations in a focused manner;
3) enthusiastic in learning with indicators of enthusiasm to find answers or solutions to problems and; 4) interest
with indicators of having an interest or interest in learning activities [19,20]. It should foster an attitude of curiosity
begin to be encouraged in the school environment. Educators need to know how students' attitudes of curiosity are
while studying at school and outside of school so that educational goals can be achieved.
In this digital era, a teacher is required to be able to operate technology. This is intended so that students have
digital skills. Some software can be used as a medium for learning Physics by teachers, for example, Physics
Education of Technology (PhET). PhET simulation media applies learning based on the Virtual Physics Laboratory.
Learning with the help of PhET makes students enjoy a fun physics learning process to encourage students' curiosity
to conduct various variations of experiments independently [21]. Animation in PhET simulations presents Physics
phenomena that can captivate students to form students' curiosity attitudes by encouraging students to conduct
investigations through virtual experiments [22].
In addition, the results of research by Stiawan, Liliasari, and Rohman show that learning using PhET media can
improve students' critical thinking skills, namely on indicators of making induction and considering induction
results, focusing on statements, and analyzing arguments [23]. Other studies have shown that students who are
taught using PhET media-assisted learning tend to have better critical thinking skills [24]. Students have scientific
activities such as hypothesizing, experimenting, and synthesizing in solving problems related to physical
phenomena. Thus, the use of PhET in physics learning facilitates the improvement of students' critical thinking skills
and curiosity attitudes.
One of the teacher's efforts is to shape students' critical thinking skills and curiosity attitudes by using inductive
thinking learning models. This inductive thinking learning model is designed so that students' reasoning can develop
through observation, comparison, inference, and generalization [25]. The inductive thinking learning model directs
students to apply principles through the formation of concepts ranging from special things to general things. The
inductive thinking learning model is characterized by students being given special cases to solve and the solution
can be generalized and applied to solve other similar cases. The implementation of inductive thinking learning
model activities is carried out sequentially consisting of 3 phases, namely concept formation, data interpretation, and
principle application [26,27]. The implementation of the three phases is: 1) concept formation carried out by data
collection activities by grouping data obtained from observation results; 2) data interpretation carried out in 3 stages,
namely: a) data testing, b) analyzing the relationship between information, c) concluding in the form of concepts,
principles, laws or theories; and 3) the application of principles, namely applying principles, laws, concepts or
theories in solving problems or analyzing certain circumstances.
The inductive thinking learning model is known to be able to improve student's critical thinking skills because
students are trained to be more critical in solving problems by observation, comparing, finding patterns and
generalizing [28]. The inductive thinking learning model trains students not to be shy about asking arguments,
questions, responses, conclusions and responses so as to facilitate the development of student's critical thinking
skills [29]. The inductive thinking learning model encourages students to be more active in asking questions and
conveying arguments through discussion activities so that their curiosity towards the information they want to know
becomes better [30]. The inductive thinking learning model makes students more challenged in observing data in the
form of images, original objects or videos about the subject matter so as to increase student curiosity [31].
This study aims to determine the effectiveness of the PhET-assisted inductive thinking learning model on
students' critical thinking skills and curiosity attitudes. The benefits of research include theoretical and practical
benefits. The theoretical benefit is as study material for other researchers who want to conduct similar research
related to inductive thinking learning models, PhET, critical thinking skills, and curiosity attitudes. The benefit of
practice is to get a fun and meaningful Physics learning experience that improves critical thinking skills and an
attitude of curiosity. For teachers as material, consider improving the quality of learning in schools.

METHOD

RESULT AND DISCUSSION

FIRST, SECOND, AND THIRD LEVEL HEADINGS (FIRST LEVEL HEADING)

(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 1) or (Use Times New Roman Font: 12 pt, Bold, ALL CAPS,
Centered)

This document was prepared using the AIP Conference Proceedings template for Microsoft Word. It provides a
simple example of a paper and offers guidelines for preparing your article. Here we introduce the paragraph styles
for Level 1, Level 2, and Level 3 headings. Please note the following:

 In this template we note whether each heading is Level 1, 2, or 3 – for example, “(Second Level Heading).”
This is for guidance only; your article headings will, of course, not need those notations.
 Under each heading we have noted which paragraph style to use – for example, “(Use the Microsoft Word
template style: Heading 2).” Again, those notes are not part of the headings. Their purpose is to advise you
of the name of the style defined in the AIP Conference Proceedings Word template.

To format a paragraph, use the Microsoft Word template style: Paragraph or Times New Roman Font: 10
pt, Indent: First line: 0.2", Justified.
 How to Apply the AIP Conference Proceedings Template Paragraph Styles (Second Level
Heading)
(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 2) or (Use Times New Roman Font: 12 PT, Bold, Centered)

Here is how to display a pop-up window from which to select and apply the AIP Conference Proceedings
template paragraph styles:

Click here to display the

Styles window – making it easy
to choose and apply the AIP
Conference Proceedings
template styles.
To apply a style to a
paragraph, click anywhere in the
paragraph text then click on the
appropriate style listed in the
Styles window.

How to Use this Template (Second Level Heading)

(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 2) or (Use Times New Roman Font: 12 PT, Bold, Centered)

You can edit or delete the content provided in this template and replace it with the text and figures of your
article. Please be sure you do not accidentally leave any of this text as part of your paper!

Heading with Each Initial Letter Capitalized (Second Level Heading)

(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 2) or (Use Times New Roman Font: 12 PT, Bold, Centered)

Apart from prepositions and articles, all words in second and third level headings should have their initial letters
in uppercase. Prepositions are words like “for,” “from,” “with,” “in,” “off,” and articles include words such as “an,”
“a,” “the.”
This is the paragraph spacing that occurs when you use the [ENTER] key.

Heading with Each Initial Letter Capitalized (Third Level Heading)

(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 3) or (Use Times New Roman Font: 10 pt, Italic, Centered)

As with first and second level headings, all words except prepositions and articles (see above) should appear
with initial letters in uppercase.
This is the paragraph spacing that occurs when you use the [ENTER] key.
 MATHEMATICS (FIRST LEVEL HEADING)
(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 1) or (Use Times New Roman Font: 12 pt, Bold, ALL CAPS,
Centered)

Here we provide some basic advice for formatting your mathematics, but we do not attempt to define detailed
styles or specifications for mathematical typesetting. You should use the standard styles, symbols, and conventions
for the field/discipline you are writing about.

A Note on Microsoft Word’s Equation Editors (Second Level Heading)

(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 2) or (Use Times New Roman Font: 12 PT, Bold, Centered)

From Word 2007 onwards, Microsoft Word provides two “Equation Editors,” which, for ease of reference, we’ll
call “Old Style Equations” and “New Style Equations.”

 “New Style Equations” (Word 2007 onwards): With Word 2007 Microsoft introduced a powerful new
built-in Equation Editor that enables input of sophisticated mathematics typeset (usually) in the Cambria
Math font. You access it from the Insert menu.
 “Old Style Equations” (Word 97–Word 2003): For versions of Microsoft Word between Word 97 and
Word 2003, mathematical input was created by an add-in: Inserting and editing a “Microsoft Equation 3.0
object,” typically by Insert  Object and selecting “Microsoft Equation 3.0.”

Newer versions of Microsoft Word (Word 2007 and onwards) still support the original “Old Style Equations”
method of creating mathematics by inserting an equation via Insert  Object and selecting “Microsoft Equation
3.0.” Whatever method is used, please make sure the equation is clear and readable.

Which Microsoft Word Equation Editor Should I Use? (Second Level Heading)
(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 2) or (Use Times New Roman Font: 12 PT, Bold, Centered)

Due to technical requirements of OpenType font technology, Microsoft Word’s “New Style” Equation Editor
works only with fonts specially designed for mathematical typesetting. Unless you have obtained and configured
new OpenType math fonts, it is highly likely that your installation of Word will use the Cambria Math font for all
mathematics created with the “New Style” editor. Using the Cambria Math font for mathematics and Times Roman
for your text will cause a mismatch in the visual appearance of your article, so, for consistency, we prefer authors to
use the “Old Style” Equation Editor because it is straightforward to amend the size/style of the fonts it uses.

Formatting and Inserting Equations (Second Level Heading)

(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 2) or (Use Times New Roman Font: 12 PT, Bold, Centered)

Equations should be centered with equation numbers on the right-hand side (flush right). Achieving a pleasing
layout of equations can be tricky in Microsoft Word, so here are some tips. You can either:
1. Copy, paste, and edit the sample equation provided (recommended), or
2. Manually insert an equation and equation number

Copy, Paste, and Edit a Sample Equation (Third Level Heading)

(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 3) or (Use Times New Roman Font: 10 pt, Italic, Centered)

To use this “Old Style Equation” as a “template,” highlight the entire line, then use cut and paste to the new
location. Note that the equation number will automatically update (increment).
 Manually Inserting an Equation and Equation Number (Third Level Heading)
(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 3) or (Use Times New Roman Font: 10 pt, Italic, Centered)

If you prefer to manually insert and number equations, follow this step-by-step guide:
1. Make sure you can see “hidden characters” by switching on “show invisibles” from the Home menu (it
looks like this: ). This allows you to see paragraph markers (¶) and tab characters ( ), which are usually
hidden from view.
2. Create a blank paragraph by pressing [ENTER].
3. Format your new blank paragraph by applying the Microsoft Word template style: Equation. The Equation
paragraph style sets up the tabs so that you can center the equation and have an equation number appear at
the right.
4. Place your cursor at the start of your new paragraph and press the [TAB] key twice.
5. Place your cursor between the tab characters ( ) and insert your equation using Insert  Object  Microsoft
Equation 3.0.
6. To add an equation number, place your cursor at the end of the paragraph (just before the paragraph markers
(¶) and after the second tab character ()).
7. On the Insert tab, in the Text group, click Quick Parts and then click Field:

8. A dialog box should appear:

9. From the list of Field Names on the left of the dialog box, select ListNum.
10. From the list of Field properties on the right, select the “Equations” List name and click OK. You should
now see an equation number in parentheses: e.g., (3).
 OTHER SPECIFICATIONS (FIRST LEVEL HEADING)
(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 1) or (Use Times New Roman Font: 12 pt, Bold, ALL CAPS,
Centered)

Figures, tables, and equations must be inserted in the text and may not be grouped at the end of the paper.
Important: A miscount of figures, tables, or equations may result in revisions. Please double check the numbering of
these elements before you submit your paper to your proceedings editor.

Figures (Second Level Heading)

(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 2) or (Use Times New Roman Font: 12 PT, Bold, Centered)

If you need to arrange many figures, a good tip is to place them in a table, which gives you additional control of
the layout. Leave a line space between your figure and any text above it, and the figure description and any text
below it, like this one:

(a) (b)
FIGURE 1. To format a figure caption, use the Microsoft Word template style: Figure Caption or Times New Roman Font: 9 pt,
Centered. The text “FIGURE 1,” which labels the caption, should be bold and in upper case. If figures have more than one part,
each part should be labeled (a), (b), etc. Using a table, as in the above example, helps you control the layout

Cite all figures in the text in consecutive order. The word “Figure” should be spelled out if it is the first word of
the sentence and abbreviated as “Fig.” elsewhere in the text. Place the figures as close as possible to their first
mention in the text at the top or bottom of the page with the figure caption positioned below, all centered. Figures
must be inserted in the text and may not follow the Reference section.

Color Figures (Third Level Heading)

(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 3) or (Times New Roman Font: 10 pt, Italic, Centered)

Authors are welcome to use color figures within their article. For online publication, there are no costs added for
color figures. However, for printed proceedings (if requested by your conference organizer), there is an additional
cost. Please consult directly with your conference organizer. If your conference organizer has asked AIP Publishing
to produce printed copies (many ask AIP Publishing for online-only publication), then all figures will be printed in
black-and-white unless you make specific arrangements with your organizer(s) to include color figures in your
article and pay to them the associated fee(s) they request. We advise that many color figures can be printed in black-
and-white with no loss of information; however, some figures do lose information when reproduced in black-and-
white. Check your figure legends carefully and, if your figures are to be printed in black-and-white, remove from
your text/descriptions any references to color.
 Tables (Second Level Heading)
(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 2) or (Use Times New Roman Font: 12 PT, Bold, Centered)

Due to the wide range and complexity of tables, we simply offer an example for guidance. Please follow the
style for table (and figure) captions.

TABLE 1. To format a table caption, use the Microsoft Word template style: Table Caption. The text
“TABLE 1,” which labels the caption, should be bold and all letters capitalized. Center this text above the
Table. Tables should have top and bottom rules, and a rule separating the column heads from the rest of the table
only.
Column Header Goes Here Column Header Goes Here Column Header Goes Here
Row Name Here x x
Row Name Here x x
Row Name Here x x

FINAL KEY POINTS TO CONSIDER (FIRST LEVEL HEADING)

(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 1) or (Use Times New Roman Font: 12 pt, Bold, ALL CAPS,
Centered)

Here are the main points you need to follow (the AIP author template package contains comprehensive
guidance):

 Write and prepare your article using the AIP Conference Proceedings template.
 Create a PDF file of your paper (making sure to embed all fonts).
 Send the following items to your conference organizer:
o PDF file of your paper
o (If it applies) Copies of any permissions to re-use copyrighted materials in your article (e.g., figures
from books/journals)

Font Embedding (Second Level Heading)

(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 2) or (Use Times New Roman Font: 12 PT, Bold, Centered)

As the author and creator of your article PDF, you have the most intimate knowledge of exactly what the PDF
should display. We ask all authors to carefully check their article PDF prior to submission. Perform visual
inspections to detect subtle font errors and ensure that all fonts are embedded. With the wide range of tools and
software that authors use to create PDFs, and the number of devices and platforms that readers use to view/print
them, font embedding by authors is not only “nice-to-have”; it is essential.

Why Should I Care About Font Embedding? (Third Level Heading)

(Use the Microsoft Word template style: Heading 3) or (Times New Roman Font: 10 pt, Italic, Centered)

Embedding fonts into your PDF file is critically important for two reasons:

1. Commercial printing companies are unable to print PDFs without the correct fonts embedded.
2. To ensure that your online article PDF file displays and prints correctly for everyone who wants to read your
work.

Readers of scientific articles use an ever-increasing range of devices and applications to access, view, and print
PDFs – from smart phones and tablets to desktop computers running any one of a number of operating systems. To
ensure that readers of your article can display and print it correctly, it is important for your article’s PDF file to be
truly portable: Your PDF file needs to be fully “self-contained.”
 CONCLUSION

PhET-assisted inductive thinking learning model: (1) effectively improves students' critical thinking skills with a
large effect size. (2) does not have a big effect on increasing students' curiosity (effect size is relatively small). In
addition, this study also obtained results that inductive thinking learning models are more effective in improving
students' critical thinking skills and curiosity attitudes with a large effect size.

REFERENCES

1. C.-H. Lu, Econ. Theory 69, 637-666 (2020).

2. N. Powdthavee, W.N. Lekfuangfu, and M. Wooden, Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics 54,
10-21 (2015).
3. D.F. Antiado, M.I.M. Tawadrous, and R.P. Sergio, IJLTER 20, 275-291 (2021).
4. Y.S. Sari, M. Selisne, and R. Ramli, J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 1185, 012096 (2019).
5. J. Haber, Critical Thinking (The MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 2020), pp. 102.
6. A.M.S. Atabaki, N. Keshtiaray, and M.H. Yarmohammadian, International Education Studies 8, 93-102
(2015).
7. P. Parlan and O.D. Fernanda, “Profile of 11th grade students’ critical thinking skills in the reaction rate topic
and their relationship with learning outcomes,” in The 4th International Conference on Mathematics and
Science Education (ICoMSE) 2020, AIP Conference Proceedings 2330. (AIP Publishing, Melville, NY, 2021),
pp. 020034-1–020034-7.
8. D. Rear, “Critical thinking, language and problem-solving: scaffolding thinking skills through debate,” in
Essential Competencies for English-Medium University Teaching, 1st ed., edited by R. Breeze and C. Sancho
Guinda (Springer International Publishing : Imprint: Springer, Cham, 2017), pp. 51-64.
9. S.Y. Seventika, Y.L. Sukestiyarno, and S. Mariani, J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 983, 012067 (2018).
10. Y. Hidayati and P. Sinaga, J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 1402, 044075 (2019).
11. A.R. As’ari, A. Mahmudi, and E. Nuerlaelah, Journal. Math. Edu. 8, 145-156 (2017).
12. S.S. Nurhijah, A.R. Wulan, and S. Diana, J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 1521, 042021 (2020).
13. D. Sulisworo, S. Daimah, M. Toifur, and A. Suryadi, J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 1088, 012065 (2018).
14. S. Wahyuni, I.G.M. Sanjaya, E. Erman, and B. Jatmiko, Int. J. Emerg. Technol. Learn. 14, 98-110 (2019).
15. T. Tang, V. Vezzani, and V. Eriksson, Thinking Skills and Creativity 37, 100696 (2020).
16. B.E. Alger, Defense of the Scientific Hypothesis: From Reproducibility Crisis to Big Data (Oxford University
Press, New York, NY, 2020), pp. 249.
17. J.H. Hardy, A.M. Ness, and J. Mecca, Personality and Individual Differences 104, 230-237 (2017).
18. K. Hochberg, J. Kuhn, and A. Müller, J Sci Educ Technol 27, 385-403 (2018).
19. D.N.S.P. Ernawati Khumaedi Ani Rusilawati, Phen 6, 10-17 (2016).
20. N. Haryanti, I. Wilujeng, and S. Sundari, J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 1440, 012045 (2020).
21. N. Hilalliati, Jumadi, I. Wilujeng, and H. Kuswanto, J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 1233, 012050 (2019).
22. P.S. Mahulae, M. Sirait, and M. Sirait, IOSR Journal of Research & Method in Education, 7(5), 24-29 (2017).
23. E. Stiawan, L. Liliasari, and I. Rohman, JPMIPA 19, 257-265 (2014).
24. D. Sulisworo, T. Handayani, and D.A. Kusumaningtyas, J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 1157, 032003 (2019).
25. I.A.A.L. Putri, I.K. Ardana, and N.N. Ganing, Jurnal Mimbar PGSD Universitas Pendidikan Ganesha, 2(1), 1-
11 (2014).
26. Bindu, Science Education: Techniques and Methods (Laxmi Book Publication, Solapur, Maharashtra, 2019),
pp. 209-210.
27. S.K. Mangal, Learning and Teaching (PHI Learning Private Limited, Patparganj, Delhi, 2019), pp. 428-429.
28. Muliana, Yusiran, Agustinasari, Asriyadin, E. Susilawati, F. Sarnita, Siswanto, S. Gumilar, Gustina, A.
Erwinsyah, L. Utami, A. Amiruddin, and Syahrir, J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 1280, 052035 (2019).
29. S. Kosmita, S. Sukarno, and S. Salamah, Indones. j. Integr. Sci. Educ. 2, 63-74 (2020).
30. Zulhelmi and M. Nur, Journal of Educational Sciences 1(1), 56-68 (2017).
31. R.I. Listyaningrum, Sajidan and Suciati, Pendidikan Biologi, 4(1), 56-67 (2012).
32. Ggg
33. Ggg
34. Ggg
35. Fff
36. Fff
37. Fff
38. Fff
39. Yyy
40. Yyy
41. Jj

42. M. P. Brown and K. Austin, The New Physique (Publisher Name, Publisher City, 2005), pp. 25–30.
43. M. P. Brown and K. Austin, Appl. Phys. Letters 85, 2503–2504 (2004).
44. R. T. Wang, “Title of Chapter,” in Classic Physiques, edited by R. B. Hamil (Publisher Name, Publisher City,
1999), pp. 212–213.
45. C. D. Smith and E. F. Jones, “Load-cycling in cubic press,” in Shock Compression of Condensed Matter-2001,
AIP Conference Proceedings 620, edited by M. D. Furnish et al. (AIP Publishing, Melville, NY, 2002), pp.
651–654.
46. B. R. Jackson and T. Pitman, U.S. Patent No. 6,345,224 (8 July 2004)
47. D. L. Davids, “Recovery effects in binary aluminum alloys,” Ph.D. thesis, Harvard University, 1998.
48. R. C. Mikkelson (private communication).
49. Jj
50. Jhh
51. Hh
52. Hgh
53. Uuu
54. Yyy
55. Gg
56.

REFERENCES – YANG BENAR

1. M. P. Brown and K. Austin, The New Physique, Publisher City: Publisher Name, 2005, pp. 25-30.
2. M. P. Brown and K. Austin, Appl. Phys. Letters 85, 2503-2504 (2004).
3. R. T. Wang, “Title of Chapter,” in Classic Physiques, edited by R. B. Hamil, Publisher City: Publisher Name,
1999, pp. 212-
213.
4. C. D. Smith and E. F. Jones, “Load-Cycling in Cubic Press” in Shock Compression of Condensed Matter-2001,
edited by M. D. Furnish et al., AIP Conference Proceedings 620, American Institute of Physics,
Melville, NY, 2002, pp. 651-654.