Professional Documents
Culture Documents
THESIS PROPOSAL
Submitted to the English Education Study Program of Al-Washliyah
University of Labuhanbatu in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirement for the
Degree of Sarjana Pendidikan (S. Pd)
By:
ARINI NOVITA SARI
Register Number: 1824051011
THESIS PROPOSAL
By:
ARINI NOVITA SARI
Register Number: 1824051011
Advisor I Advisor II
Approved By:
Advisor I Advisor II
RIZKI LESTARI,S.Pd,.M.Pd
NIDN.01.231092.01
LEMBAR PENGESAHAN
NIM : 1924051011
Disetujui Oleh :
Pembimbing I Pembimbing II
Mengetahui
Kepala Program Studi
1.1 BACKGROUND
That is, speaking is a person's skill to produce sounds that have meaning and can
speaking is the use of language to communicate with others (Fulcher. 2003: 23).
That is, this activity involves two or more people in which the participants as
listeners and speakers must react to whatever they hear and make their
intentions that he wants. So, English teachers should activate students' speaking
classroom and then giving them the opportunity to practice their speaking skills as
much as possible. In order for students not to get bored when learning English, the
teacher must use interesting and trendy methods so that the child asks more often
because if they often ask about the media made by the teacher, it means that the
student really wants to learn English, and if possible the teacher makes props that
the speaker intends to construct meaning through the production of receiving, and
skills are related to communication. Speaking is the skill of using the right
language to express one's ideas, opinions, or feelings to give or get information
and knowledge from other people who communicate, and the communication that
conversations, conversations that mothers and children and many more of our
communications in everyday life, and when speaking we must better choose the
tasks. People differ in relation to a number of abilities, but can be grouped in two
them that in Intellectual abilities include making various cognitive tasks. and by
having the ability we can be more confident in doing everything, such as for
example we want to speak in public but we do not have the ability to speak
because we are shy to speak in public, therefore we must have the ability so that
we dare to speak in front of many people. According Robbin (2004: 45) states that
abilities, because if we have physical abilities, of course we can be relied on, and
the talk, for transmitting energy and enthusiasm, and for capturing and responding
this day and age everyone is required to be skilled in speaking (Bill Scott, 1987:
5). When we have the ability to speak, we can certainly express words, and
convey what is in our minds. Moris in Novia (2002:54) states that speaking is a
that the purpose of teaching English today is to speak. By using this speaking
students have good English speaking skills, then students will find it easy to
interact with English teachers in class. In addition, nowadays the ability to speak
will need a tour guide who can help us to get knowledge about the tourist
researcher found a problem in class X, they are not able to describe a tourist
attraction that they have visited, because they have not been able and not
confident to communicate using English, and they feel shy and nervous to speak
to teachers and other students, it seems that they have never practiced speaking
(2012: 5) is everything that has uniqueness, beauty, and value in the form of
diversity of natural wealth, culture, and man-made products that are the target or
is a place visited with various beauties obtained, a place to carry out tourism
activities, a place to have fun with a long enough time to get satisfaction, good
service, and beautiful memories at tourist attractions. And a place to unwind after
a day's work, visiting tourist attractions is also good in reducing the risk of heart
potential and driving force for the presence of tourists to a tourist destination. And
tourist attractions have tourist attraction with their cultural diversity in the area
and can be made into tourist attractions that can be visited by tourists. Forms of
tourism known to the general public, among others According to the Number of
People Traveling:
people in conducting their own tourist trips and choosing tourist destinations
along with the program and its implementation is carried out alone.
b. Collective tourism, namely a tourism business that sells its packages to anyone
travel business that sells its packages to anyone who is interested, with the
learning model that uses projects/activities as media. This learning model uses
problems as the first step in collecting and integrating new knowledge based on
their experience in real activities. Using this pjbl technique can help students to
students are free to plan learning activities to carry out projects, and produce work
products that can be presented to others. Reporting from the book Mendesain
innovative learning that is learner-centered and sets the teacher as a motivator and
construct their learning. This model becomes a learning that involves many
experiences for students. Learners' learning experiences and concepts are built
applying this
PJBL can make students responsible for their tasks and can work together in
teams.
Fathurrohman (2016: 119) argues that project-based learning is a learning
something but can also produce meaningful and useful products, pjbl can build
students to apply concepts and projects to produce and explore so that students
study can be identified as follows problems in this study can be identified that:
(1) Students still have low motivation, especially in speaking activities; (2)
students do not understand many aspects of English speaking; and (3) students do
1. Theoretical Significance
2. Practical Significance
valuable for both teachers and students. For teachers, the findings of this study are
students to be able to communicate well. Meanwhile, for the students, the findings
of this study can encourage them to study harder and practice to improve their
2.1. Speaking
information from the speaker to the listener with the aim of changing the
language media. Speaking is a form of speech act in the form of sounds produced
definitions have been put forward to give meaning to speaking. According to its
which includes:
communication;
speaking, the limbs spontaneously take part in expressing and emphasizing the
simultaneously build a unity of expression following the speech that comes out of
the speaker. and in the form of speaking must have a distinctive structure in the
conveying ideas and messages to The interlocutor and at the same time the
speaker will get the ideas and messages conveyed by the interlocutor.
The eyes, nose, lips, eyebrows, and so on build their own meaning. Bulging eyes
can be interpreted as angry, sad eyes can be interpreted as sad. Lips, face, and
nose can give the meaning that someone is quite serious, sad, or happy. In
speaking activities humans also function other organs in the body to express the
meaning of speech. And of course using expressions when we speak other people
back and forth between the speaker and the interlocutor. This means that speaking
occurs in exchange for speaking. When the speaker speaks, the listener acts as a
listener, and vice versa when the listener takes over the speaking activity, the
previous speaker turns into a listener. The point is that when we want to
This reciprocal form forms a conversational activity that gives and receives
speech responses. The speaker provides information and the interlocutor receives
communication process. And when speaking we must know the speech of our
the difference is the speech material of each different speaker. Speakers and
interlocutors will react to the information received. The conversation will end
them believe in the perception that they consider to be correct. This form of
the speaker has argued to his interlocutor it can trigger the courage to express
eyes, clenched fists, bowed bodies, and so on are done by the speaker without ever
thinking about it. The same thing also happens to how the speaker gets ideas,
ideas, vocabulary chosen in giving his speech, all take place without realizing it.
However, different things can happen to people who have been trained to speak,
will be able to regulate their speech acts through more temporal control. What will
be spoken is thought out in advance. This is what distinguishes someone who has
then how to respond must be good even though sometimes the interlocutors reject
through this thinking process, humans can optimize the quality of life. In other
to others. This is where the transfer and productive process of knowledge takes
place. That is, personally speaking activities like this embody individual activities
behavior. This means that one's speaking is always followed by what is inside the
speaker, and this is shown in behavior. an illustration of speech, "Ah, you always
deceive, nothing you say is true!". This speech implies that the radiance of
incompatible with the behavior shown. Personality and behavior can be seen from
able to speak well. Starting from the pronunciation of vowels, increasing to the
communicate with others in a more complex form that can be developed through
training efforts.
Tarigan (2015: 16) argues that speaking is the ability to utter articulated
sounds or words that express, state, or convey thoughts, ideas and feelings.
people consider that a person's English language ability or skill is shown by that
person's speaking ability. This view is reasonable considering that the most
teaching, especially English, speaking is one of the basic skills that must be taught
from the beginning. In the real world, speaking skills can be seen in formal and
learner about the material submitted, knowing how far the student can
a. Vocabulary
b. Fluency
c. Accuracy
2. Attitude Aspect
3. Behavioral Aspects
Behavior and traits are not much different. A teacher must observe
namely: (1) the speaker, and (2) the listener. Both factors will ensure the
success or failure of the speaking activity. Below the two factors will be
activities happen. And, there are some things that must be considered by the
speaker to carry out his activities, namely: Subject matter The content or
knowledge.
(b). The subject matter should be a little bit already known and material to extend
(c). The subject matter is interesting to be discussed both by the speaker and to the
matter that is being discussed in the community or a problem that rarely occurs,
(d). The subject matter should be consistent with the listener's capacity to
understand, not exceeding the listener's intellectual capacity or vice versa, easier.
Speaking class remains a big problem for students because this productive skill
The environment is not favorable for them to use English in their daily lives.
They prefer to use their mother tongue to communicate, instead of using English.
and also they feel shy and lazy to learn English. Many of the students cannot
speak clearly, when they talk to foreigners because they do not know how to
pronounce what they want to say and how to say it. in addition, they experience
miss communication.
In order to reduce the mistakes and get good communication with native
speakers or not, learners must know and understand the use of facial expressions
a. Inhibition
overcome it. Learners are often inhibited from speaking in a foreign language,
they are worried about making mistakes, afraid of being criticized or losing face,
b. Nothing to say
Learners sometimes protest that they can't think of anything to say. This leads
Only one learner can speak at a time if he or she wants to be heard, and in
large groups, this means that everyone has very little speaking time. This problem
is compounded by the tendency of some learners to dominate, while others speak
Most learners tend to use their mother tongue because it is easier, and more
challenge for English teachers, to come up with the best strategies to improve
not easy. It requires appropriate learning materials and learning strategies. in order
follows:
(1) Learners talk a lot. In classroom speaking learning, the time allocation while
learning is used for students to speak as much as possible, this is not interrupted
(2) Thorough participation. In class discussions, all students have the opportunity
to speak. So that it is not only controlled by students who are good at talking.
(3) High motivation. The students are eager to speak. because they are interested
in the topic and have something new to say, and because they want to participate
language accuracy.
strategies and models during the lesson. Harmer (1991: 16) reveals that reading
and listening are receptive skills, while speaking and writing are productive skills.
Therefore, the students are expected to master these skills. teachers can apply
three namely:
(2) practice,
(3) communicative activities. This theory means that teachers should teach
students about the basic knowledge of the language (English) such as the elements
of the language that must be learned by students. Then, the teacher should ask the
students to practice after that, the teacher should ask the students to practice the
language by using the language. In order for students to become familiar with the
new language, they must use the language in everyday life in the form of various
communicative activities.
following stages:
the purpose of the current lesson, Requiring them to explain their background
knowledge on the topic. For example, if the topic of the lesson is buying airplane
b. Presenting the task. At this stage, what we want the students to do should be
clearly explained. For example, if the teacher wants the students to create a dialog
with their partner on a certain topic, (the teacher) can create the same dialog with
a student as the first step. To check if the task is clearly understood by the
students, they can be asked to repeat the process. This can be done in English,
related to the level of the students. Then, the students should also be provided
with all the necessary role cards, pictures, listening and reading texts, etc. required
c. Inspection. The teacher records the activities that take place in the classroom.
class. The teacher intervenes whenever necessary. These interventions are not
activity. In this part, feedback on the content of the activity would be more
them what they have achieved is better than telling them what they have failed.
confidence. This will also have a positive effect on the low affective filter which
construct their own learning activities, and produce student work products.PJBL
provides contextual and meaningful learning for students. PJBL requires students
to work on projects that give students the opportunity not only to learn and
communication. As a result, students are able to improve their English and present
The students are required to collect and discuss problems together with their
friends before they consult with the teacher. Then, they have to present their final
practice to speak English with their surrounding environment so that they can
involvement and enjoyment. In the PJBL technique, students sit together, face to
face, and talk freely about the problem. They sit in a circle discussing the problem
that needs to be solved. This condition creates free communication where students
skills. Working in groups also helps students learn about speaking or about how to
talk about. Discussing with a group requires students to have the opportunity to
give and various information orally for group members. At this point, intensive
material at the high school level, there is material about writing simple dialogs.
opinions on a particular topic between two or more readers. From the explanation
or understanding above, the author can conclude that simple dialogue is the
exchange of thoughts between two or three individuals on the topic they are
talking about, dialogue occurs in two processes, namely the process of listening
familiar or not familiar atmosphere both at the age of children and adults. where
students will make a dialogue that describes a tourist attraction and then practice it
with their benchmates in front of the class, and after the students practice it, the
have their own advantages and disadvantages. The advantages of a learning model
will of course always have a positive impact on students and educators. The
project-based learning are "(1) Increase motivation; (2) improve problem solving
skills; (3) improve library study skills; (4) improve collaboration; (5) improve
provide their own advantages, especially for students who run them. Quoted from
the experience conducted by Intel Corporation through the Intel Teach Program
towards learning;
2. Provides academic gains equal to or better than those produced by other
models, with learners involved in projects having greater responsibility for their
own learning;
learners.
d. Enhance collaboration
and making allocations of time and other resources such as equipment to complete
tasks.
h. Provides learning experiences that engage learners in complex ways and are
j. Make the learning atmosphere fun, so that students and educators enjoy the
learning process.
project-based learning model also has some weaknesses. Those weaknesses are as
follows:
c. Requires educators and students who are both ready to learn and develop;
d. There is a concern that learners will only master one particular topic that they
work on.
and sometimes require a lot of money in realizing the project. To make a good
finished project, learners and educators need various components that support
according to the project that will be designed. Obstacles will also come for
much about the aspects of speaking English, because these students are not
often use Javanese in their daily activities rather than using Indonesian, because
English properly or often make oral grammar mistakes. and the most common
problems that occur to students in this speaking activity are, they are not able to
to learn, and social circumstances are less supportive, then students lack practice
and teachers do not use many activities in English classes because teachers
use very few special programs in using English and always center on what will be
tested in the UN (national exam), and students are really bored in learning English
in a monotonous way.
and how to solve these problems, the researcher found that this PJBL
technique is a solution to overcome the way students speak, using PJBL is very
been distributed after they have worked on the project, this project-based learning
technique offers many advantages in the learning process and there are several
advantages that can be obtained from this pjbl first of all they can increase student
topics and problems, then they search for possible solutions. By participating in
real-world connections with context for students, and students conduct using
various sources of information they get, after that find the resources themselves,
4. PJBL improves students' collaboration in the sorting stage, after which students
create and organize their own groups and arrange their own groups so that later
they are more comfortable when choosing their own groups, and they share
beach potential for beach tourism development in Bantul regency", beach tourism
level of potential of each beach tourism object in Bantul Regency and understand
the direction of its development based on the level of potential of beach tourism
objects in Bantul Regency. By using secondary data analysis method and survey
using census, questionnaire, indepth, interview with key person. The results of
this study indicate that the existing beach tourism objects in Bantul Regency are
included in the class of developing beach tourism potential. Beach tourism objects
that are classified as high / fast development levels include Parangtritis Beach and
Parangkusumo Beach and the development pattern used is a tourist attraction that
has low development potential especially followed by objects that have medium
The link with PJBL is a researcher named choirin nisak (2012), he uses a
survey, if you want to survey there must be an interview using this PJBL must
groups so that the results of the interview can be discussed, because PJBL can
techniques, the first of which is: There have been many researchers who make
of the study show that the application of the PJBL technique can improve
cycle
2. the students' test result in the second cycle post-test was 79, an increase of 8
from the first cycle post-test which means that the success indicator of 76 for this
learning activities increased gradually from the first cycle to the second cycle.
Furthermore, for the Results indicator of students' responses to the PPA technique,
responses, this technique can make students more motivated, happy, and confident
to speak English.
Pasundan 3 Cimahi High School". The results showed that there was an influence
Pasundan 3 Cimahi High School by 58.4% and 41.6% was determined by other
factors.
1. The research that has been done, and the research that will be done both use a
2. The research that has been done, as well as the research that will be done, there
implementation of the research that has been carried out at Pasundan 3 Cimahi
High School, while the place of implementation of the research to be carried out at
SMK Negeri 3 Bandung, Variable X in the research that has been done is a model,
contextual learning, while the research to be carried out uses variable X project-
influence of the PJBL (Project Based Learning) model so that it can improve
student learning outcomes, can reach This can be seen in the percentage of
by researchers in 2014, carried out with three cycles. In cycle I, 77.2% has not
88.6% in the activity of students in learning activities more actively, the attitude
ideas to fulfill information to complete their tasks. In the first and second studies,
it can be seen that the PJBL (Project Based Learning) model has an effect on
learning process, seen from each cycle carried out by researchers, there is a very
confident attitudes and student learning outcomes can be seen and increased.
PJBL, of course the students are not bored in learning because pjbl uses exciting
techniques, and when they describe their tourist attractions who were silent in the
classroom become active by always asking questions, this can make them more
DIALOGUE
PJBL SPEAKING TOURISM SPEAKING
FIGURE 1.1
RESEARCH PARADIGM
Hypothesis
action research method can improve the speaking skills of X grade students of
SMA N1 Silangkitang.
CHAPTER III
RESEARCH METHOD
This research will be carried out in the second semester of the 2022/2023
the educational academic calendar and does not interfere with the teaching
certainly have high, medium, low, and very low abilities. Meanwhile, in terms of
social, cultural and economic aspects of the community, students are very diverse,
there are those whose economic status is high, medium and less.
PJBL technique students can improve their speaking skills in class X SMA N 1
Silangkitang.
3.3 Types and Research Approaches
classroom.This research will use the Classroom Action Research (CAR) method.
educators because it provides more benefits for teachers and students, especially
In addition, the same opinion comes from Costello who defines CAR as a
This indicates that CAR as a research method is not concerned with complex
statistical analysis, but is more concerned with solving problems using strategies
raised and occur in a class together. The action is given to the teacher or with
direction from the teacher carried out by students. reflection of practice. Rust
emphasizes CAR in reflection on practice. This means that the effectiveness of the
focus of the research. In conducting research using CAR, researchers should pay
more attention to the reflection of activities when they provide action to students.
From some of the definitions above, it can be concluded that CAR is a
professionalism in teaching and also to pay more attention to the reflection of the
activities carried out when they provide actions to students. Researchers will use
CAR as the method of this research. this research is to improve students' speaking
1. CAR should not interfere with the learning process and teaching duties of the
teacher,
2. CAR should not be too time-consuming, therefore CAR must be designed and
3. The implementation of the action should be consistent with the design that has
been made,
4. The problem studied must be a problem that really exists and is faced by the
teacher.
5. The implementation of CAR must always follow the applicable work ethics
8. CAR also aims to familiarize or teach teachers to write, making notes, and
9. CAR should start from simple, real, clear, and sharp problems. As a teacher,
you must pay attention to the stages in class action research, so that teachers are
able to improve the learning process through an in-depth study of what happens in
results emphasize meaning rather than generalization. The natural object referred
researcher so that the conditions when the researcher enters the object, after being
in the object and after leaving and the object is relatively unchanged. This
qualitative method is expected to improve students' speaking skills in describing
analysis method by calculating data that is proof of the problem. The use of
overview through the calculation of the data obtained regarding students' speaking
techniques.
namely: observation checklists, field notes, and interviews. The first data will be
taken from the observation checklist and field notes. The collaborator will observe
the teaching and learning process by using observation and field notes at each
meeting. The researcher will collect them in each cycle. The second is the
The researcher will interview all all students. Interviews will be conducted at the
oral tests to collect quantitative data in this study. The material will be discussed
with the collaborator about the level for and its suitability to the research subject.
In this study, the test will be conducted several times, namely: in the pre-research
test, until a certain number of students can reach the research target. In the oral
speaking test, the students will show their English performance to measure their
documentation. To analyze this data, researchers will use the interactive model
data analysis put forward by (Hendryadi, et. al, 2019: 218) is a naturalistic inquiry
process that seeks a deep understanding of social phenomena in a natural way. and
the early stages, it occurs through editing, sorting and summarizing the data. In
the middle stage, it occurs through coding and memoing, and related activities
such as finding themes, clusters and patterns. In the final stage, it happens through
reducing data.
b. Data Display: Data display organizes, compresses, and structures information.
In this research, how to display data through graphs, charts, and diagrams to make
c. Drawing and verifying conclusions: reducing and displaying data aims to assist
reduction and display. Then, possible conclusions can be noted and need to be
verified.
Quantitative data will be obtained from the oral speaking test. To assess
the students' oral speaking test, the following description of the assessment
e. Pronunciation
Then, the results of this study will be interpreted by using a score interval
school year and the rubric for oral speaking assessment. After that, to find out the
pre-assessment test.
The first procedure that will be carried out by the researcher is to conduct
a pre-assessment test. In the pre-assessment test, the researcher will give a test to
attractions using an instrument that has been prepared by the researcher. The score
will be the basic score of students' ability to speak describing before they get
several cycles of action from the researcher. before they get several cycles of
action from the researcher by using the Project-Based Learning Technique. Then,
the researcher will provide actions to students for improvement. Then, the
researcher will give several cycles to treat the students to solve their problems and
planning, action implementation, observation, and reflection. For more details can
Figure 1:
Ideal Action Research Cycle
Kemmis and Taggart
1. Action
person who has a lot of experience in a particular field always has a ready
response in a situation to solve a problem. to solve their problems and make some
follows Procedure:Cycle 1
a. Planning
Planning is the first step taken by the researcher. This is related to good
carried out by researchers in planning are: (1) identify the problem to be changed.
The researcher should have a good discussion with the teacher about the students'
(2) informing: the researcher should inform the lesson plan to the collaborator of
the collaborator so that it can be assessed for reliability; (3) organizing, the
researcher should organize several types of activities that are considered very
b. Implementing Action 1
make improvements for them. In this study, the researcher used Project-Based
descriptive text. In this study, the researcher taught students The researcher taught
the students descriptive text by applying the detailed teaching procedures of the
c. Observation
The researcher should do some activities in this step: (1) analyzing: analyzing
evidence and compiling findings; (2) reporting: discussing findings with co-
researchers and or interpretation colleagues, and then writing a report; (3) sharing:
supervisors.
d. Reflection
activities to be carried out as if controlling teacher actions, teachers can see what
be carried out when the teacher as a field practitioner has completed the action,
experiences that have been carried out to be discussed with the researcher, the
teacher conveys everything that has been felt and conveys the extent of progress
evaluating: evaluating the first cycle process. The researcher evaluates the actions
that have been given to students, including evaluation of the quality, quantity and
time of each action. In this process, the researcher will conduct a discussion with
the researcher will conduct a discussion with the collaborator about what the
the results and experiences in the first cycle in order to provide significant
progress in the teaching and learning process during the action; (2) implement:
implement new findings or strategies; (3) look back: look back at the process that
has been done Next Cycle The next cycle will be carried out as well as cycle 1,
and will be carried out based on the results of the previous cycle.
Pre Test (Initial Test)
The initial test or pre test is a test used to measure the position of students
in the class and to determine the level ofreadiness of students in learning the
c) To find out the initial abilities that students have regarding the teaching
material that will be the topic in the learning process learning process.
d) To find out where the learning process should process should begin.
Learning Technique. In this class action research, the speaking test will be given
after the action is given, namely at the third meeting in each cycle. The criteria for
Accuracy Fluency
accent dimengerti
Adequate but not rich vocabulary, Conveys ideas, but hesitantly and
accent
foreign accent
80-100 Excellent
70-79 Good
60-69 Moderate
50-59 Poor
step level. Good, Most of what the speaker says is easy to follow followed. His/her
attention is always clear but some interruptions are needed to help him to get the
message across or seek clarification. On average, the Listener can understand much
of what is being said, but he/she must continue to seek clarification. He cannot
listening to the speaker. Poor, Only a small part (usually short sentences and
phrases) can be understood and then with considerable effort by someone who is
accustomed to the language. small (usually short sentences and phrases) can be
to the speaker almost nothing is understood. listening to the speaker almost nothing
of what is said can be understood.Very poor Even the listener tries hard
interrupting, the speaker is unable to clarify anything he or she seems to have said.
Specifically, all of these phenomena are called research variables. In this study,
researchers will use five instruments to collect data. The instruments are: speaking
test, observation checklist, interview, field notes, and observation. interview, field
assessment in the form of tasks that students must do. The test conducted in this
study is a speaking practice test, which is through the task of telling stories in front
of the class. The speaking test will be designed as the main instrument in this study.
The researcher will choose five popular tourist attractions in Bengkulu, and will
ask the students to describe them to measure their ability. These tourist objects can
2. Observation Checklist
Observation is also not limited to people, but also other natural objects. The
student conditions and to find out students' difficulties with the material and what is
collaborator (English teacher at the school). The researcher will observe what
happens in the classroom during the lesson from the opening to the closing of the
teaching and learning activities. Then, the researcher also observed what happened
in the classroom and observed the effect of the teaching to improve students'
speaking ability. in describing local tourism objects. Then, it is also important to
describing local tourism objects. The main aspects of observation in this study can
be explained as follows:
Then, the researcher will also prepare an observation checklist for the
ability in describing local attractions. The overall observation for both teachers and
students will be carried out at each meeting in cycle I and subsequent cycles.
3. Interview
The researcher will ask the research subject some questions related to what
based on what happens in the classroom to get in-depth data needed to interpret in
this study.
4. Field Notes
in the field. In this study, researchers will use field notes to collect data related to:
(1) students' active involvement in the classroom process; (2) students' ability to
follow the new learning technique during the lesson; (3) students' advantages and
5. Documentation
Documentation can be in the form of all documents collected as data, such as:
student worksheets, field notes, interview transcripts, and photographs during the
process during the research process. In other words, documentation in this research
https://repository.ump.ac.id/9683/3/Dian%20Setyo%20Nugroho_BAB%20II.pdf
https://educhannel.id/blog/artikel/kesulitanbelajar.html#:~:text=Menurut
%20Mulyadi%20(2010%3A6),giat%20lagi%20untuk%20dapat%20
https://ariermawan.blogspot.com/2012/09/keterampilan-berbicara.html?m=1
http://eprints.ums.ac.id/30695/2/BAB_I.pdf
http://repository.unpas.ac.id/30815/6/BAB%20II.pdf
file:///C:/Users/GIGABYTE/Downloads/UTARI%20DWI%20SARTIKA.pdf