Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The telecom industry has grown significantly in the past, and emerging markets have
significant potential for future growth. Due to the similarity of services offered by
operators, the sector is characterized by fierce market competition. As a result, price
wars are common, despite the fact that companies must invest in their network in
order to provide high-quality service to their subscribers. There has also been a clear
trend in the shift from voice to data revenue. The Nigerian Communications
Commission fined MTN Nigeria USD1.7 billion in 2015 for failing to meet the
deadline for disconnecting 5.1 million unregistered SIM cards. As a result of
decreased subscribers and restricted tariff plans, cash flows in all units were impacted,
causing the stock price to fall. Nonetheless, MTN has a strong recognizable brand and
knowledge in emerging markets, allowing it to overcome the minor issues.
MTN is expected to keep investing in its infrastructures and further success will be
dependent on further network rollout and how the company deals with price tariffs
managing subscribers’ retention and acquirement. The company has levered up in the
past years and we believe it will not require further significant debt issues.
2
CONTENTS
Project Deliverables..................................................................................................................1
Executive Summary..................................................................................................................2
INTRODUCTION........................................................................................................................4
Swot analysis....................................................................................................................4
Competitive positioning....................................................................................................4
Pestle................................................................................................................................5
REFERENCES.............................................................................................................................7
3
INTRODUCTION
MTN dominates market share in a large number of its operations throughout Africa.
This is according to the mobile behemoth’s own statistics, which were released as part
of the company’s financial results for the six months ended June 30, 2019. This is
because, according to data sheets published alongside the results, the group has a
market share of more than 50% in ten African and Middle Eastern markets and more
than 30% in another six. Only in South Africa does the operator’s share fall below
30%, at 26.27 percent. ESwatini (84.72%); South Sudan (60.64%); Guinea-Bissau
(59.78%); Ghana (55.97%); Uganda (55.13%); Rwanda (54.61%); Benin (54.60%);
Congo-Brazzaville (54.24); and Nigeria (50.49%) are the Countries where MTN has a
particularly high market share.
1
https://www.jobzilla.ng/mtn definition#:~:text=MTN%20stands%20for%20Mobile%20Telephone,in
%20African%20countries%20including%20Nigeria.
2
Gilbert, Paula, “MTN aims for 300m group subscribers by 2020,” Itweb, Aug 07, 2017; 2) “Africa’s
Top 100 Brands in 2019 – Global brands dominate Africa,” African Business Magazine, May 30, 2019
3
Ashita Chopra (19 August 2020). “MTN appoints Ralph Mupita as the new group president and CEO”.
Daily Monitor. Kampala. Retrieved 22 August 2020
4
Figure 14
4
https://www.connectingafrica.com/author.asp?section_id=761&doc_id=753808
5
https://www.mtn.com/mtn-group-reports-strong-2021-results-enhances-financial-guidance-on-
accelerating-data-and-fintech-services/
5
INTERNAL STRATEGIC AUDIT
MTN Africa’s vision is to lead the way in bringing a bold, new digital world to its
consumers, and its mission is to make their lives BRIGHTER. This is accomplished
by providing them with relevant, accessible, and high-quality telecommunications
solutions that put them in command.6
Since MTN is primarily based in Africa, it faces issues unique to the social,
economic, and political settings of such African countries. Some of the markets of
these countries are for example, are sanctioned, while others have long-running civil
and political upheaval.
In Nigeria, the fine imposed on MTN’s local unit in 2015, the largest ever imposed on
a mobile provider anywhere in the world, is public knowledge. As a result, MTN has
had to strengthen its controls and create dedicated divisions to provide advice and
support to its operations both centrally and regionally.
MTN pushed the continent’s adoption of mobile and, with it, mass communication. In
Africa , the next revolution is delivering the internet to the masses. The corporation
has had to rethink its business model due to the shift from speech to data, which
generates less revenue, and packaged digital services that include heavily discounted
voice.
MTN has made some strategic decisions in order to compete in the data and digital
market, including expanding its products to include mobile financial services, e-
commerce, and other services. This means that, in addition to OTT players, they now
compete directly with banks in terms of mobile money.
And the stakes are constantly mounting. There are new potential for 4G data, and
demand for connectivity in both urban and rural locations is soaring across Africa.
6
https://ng.linkedin.com/company/mtn-nigeria
7
https://www.dukece.com/insights/how-mtn-group-grappling-with-uncertainty/
6
This is happening at a time when several cities in the United States are already getting
early 5G networks hence meaning that in is still backward in terms of network.
Swot analysis
A SWOT analysis is a basic yet effective method for developing your business
strategy, whether you’re starting a business or leading an established one. Strengths,
Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats (SWOT) are acronyms for Strengths,
Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats. Internal to your firm, strengths and
weaknesses are factors that you have some influence over and can modify. Who is on
your staff, your patents and intellectual property, and your location are all examples.
External opportunities and dangers are things that are happening outside of your firm,
in the bigger market. You can seize chances and defend against threats, but you can’t
change the situation. Competitors, raw material pricing, and client shopping
tendencies are all examples. Your top strengths, weaknesses, and opportunities are
organized in a SWOT analysis8
Figure 2
8
https://www.liveplan.com/blog/what-is-a-swot-analysis-and-how-to-do-it-right-with-examples/
7
The table below shows the MTN SWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities,
Threats)9
MTN Threats 1.An excessive number of expansions can cause a loss of focus.
Table 1
Competitive positioning
MTN Group’s top ten competitors are Vodacom, Airtel, Cell C, Millicom, Telkom,
Telefonica, Liquid Intelligent Technologies, Econet Group, Safaricom, and Vodafone.
They have collectively raised more than $19.6 billion among their estimated 351.1K
employees. MTN Group employs 19,295 people and is ranked sixth among its top ten
competitors. The top ten competitors have an average of 26,453 votes. In the table
below am going to assess MTN Africa’s performance against it’s top five
competitors10.
9
https://www.mbaskool.com/brandguide/telecom-service-providers/521-mtn.html
10
https://www.owler.com/company/vodacom/competitors
8
Competitors Market share Sales or Revenue or
profitablity (2021)
11
https://techcentral.co.za/mobile-market-share-in-south-africa-vodacom-mtn-telkom-and-cell-c/
207433/?amp=1
12
https://www.telecompaper.com/news/mtn-group-underlying-service-revenue-rises-18-in-2021-
customers-up-nearly-3-mln--1416952
13
ibid
14
“News releases | Vodacom Group”
15
https://techpoint.africa/2021/05/13/airtel-q1-2021-financial-report/
16
https://m.economictimes.com/markets/stocks/earnings/airtel-africa-q3-results-net-profit-up-54-to-
180-mn/amp_articleshow/89352484.cms
17
Ibid
18
https://m.engineeringnews.co.za/article/cell-c-shows-improved-h1-2021-10-27#:~:text=With
%20the%20implementation%20of%20a,in%20the%20prior%20corresponding%20period.
19
https://www.millicom.com/media/4849/millicom-earnings-release-q4-2021_final.pdf
20
https://companiesmarketcap.com/millicom/revenue/#:~:text=According%20to%20Millicom's
%20latest%20financial,sale%20of%20goods%20or%20services.
21
Ibid
9
Table 2
MTN Africa . MTN Nigeria, MTN Africa's largest revenue generator, is expected to
increase service revenue by at least 20% over the previous mid-teens target. 22
Vodafone. According to the Economics global macro models projections and analysts
expectations, Vodacom has gained 8.24 percent in the last four weeks. Its value has
increased by 29.21 percent in the last year and it is now expected to be priced at
15,399.25 by the end of this quarter and at 14,119.78 in one year. 23
Airtel. With a young population and rising smartphone affordability, as well as low
data penetration at it’s early years, Airtel hopes that the next five years, the telecoms
market in its footprint is expected to grow at a CAGR of 10.1 percent since most of
the problems it faced at it’s start are being resolved.24
Millicom. Over the next three years, this aims for organic operating cash flow growth
of around 10% per year on average. This reflects expected annual organic service
revenue growth in the mid-single digits and annual CapEx of around $1.0 billion.
It also intends to generate cumulative equity free cash flow2 of $800 million to $1.0
billion over the next three years, with a near-term goal of reducing leverage to 2.5x by
2025. 25
22
https://www.reuters.com/business/media-telecom/africas-mtn-resumes-dividend-after-bumper-
annual-profit-2022-03-09/
23
https://tradingeconomics.com/vod:sj
24
Airtel Africa plc is a multinational company that provides telecommunications and mobile money
services in 14 countries in Africa, primarily in East, Central and West Africa. Airtel Africa is majority
owned by the Indian communication services company Bharti Airtel.Wikipedia·
https://airtel.africa/assets/pdf/Airtel_Africa_AR2020.pdf
25
https://millicom.gcs-web.com/news-releases/news-release-details/millicom-tigo-unveils-three-
year-operational-financial-and
10
Telkom. This telocom’s revenue being 2.3% per year, it is forecasted to grow slower
than 20% per year.26
Cell C
Despite having over 140 percent penetration of mobile services in South Africa,
particularly in the prepaid market, Cell C’s growth continues apace. Cell C currently
has over 16 million customers.27
Airtel
26
https://simplywall.st/stocks/za/telecom/jse-tkg/telkom-sa-soc-shares
27
https://www.cellc.co.za/cellc/shareholder-information
28
Vodacom Consolidated Financial Report 2018” (PDF). 31 March 2018.
29
"Airtel, Millicom ink pact to merge in Ghana - The Economic Times"
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/companies-a-z/corporate-trends/airtel-millicom-ink-
pact-to-merge-in-ghana/articleshow/57456883.cms
11
Cell C
Millicom
Telkom
30
Cell C 2020 Report” (PDF). Cell C. 2020.
31
https://www.forbes.com/companies/millicom-international/
32
https://www.bloomberg.com/press-releases/2021-02-11/millicom-international-cellular-s-a-
resilient-cash-flow-and-customer-growth
33
https://www.forbes.com/companies/telkom/?sh=12a4e3d7512f
12
EXTERNAL AUDIT ANALYSIS – ENVIRONMENTAL
The PESTEL analysis is used in this case. This is a framework or technique that
marketers use to examine and track external marketing environment aspects that
affect a firm, organization, or industry. It investigates the external environment’s
political, economic, social, technological, environmental, and legal elements. A
PESTEL study is used to identify threats and vulnerabilities, which are then used in
the SWOT analysis that we discussed earlier.34
Figure 4
34
https://libguides.libraries.wsu.edu/c.php?g=294263&p=4358409#:~:text=A%20PESTEL%20analysis
%20is%20a,organization%2C%20company%2C%20or%20industry.
35
https://www.mbaskool.com/pestle-analysis/companies/18044-mtn.html#:~:text=MTN%20PESTLE
%20Analysis%20examines%20the,the%20business%20of%20the%20brand.
13
A stable and pleasant business climate with predictable market growth trends is
provided by high political stability. When there is political chaos, however, investors
are put off and stakeholders’ faith in economic and organizational performance is
harmed. MTN Group Limited is currently present in a number of nations, each of
which has its own set of political problems. Growing tensions and instability in the
global political climate may have an impact on the gold industry’s growth and limit
MTN Group Limited’s growth potential.36
As previously stated, MTN has roots in a number of African, European, and Asian
countries. In comparison to African countries, which confront it with challenges such
as being accused of significant corruption in Nigeria, European and Asian countries
today have more political stability. In 2018, the Nigerian Central Bank ordered the
telecom business to repay a huge sum of $8.1 billion that it illegally moved out of the
country. Furthermore, the Attorney General of Nigeria believes that the corporation
owes nearly $2 billion in taxes. MTN has recently had challenges with license
renewal in Uganda, which accounts for about 4% of its total income. Although the
situation in European countries has been positively good on MTN Group, the
Ukraine-Russia war has forced MTN to provide free services to the people affected by
war in Ukraine such as free International calls hence this will call for profit declines
in this financial year.37 The paragraph above shows that MTN Africa has had to deal
with threats in Africa most especially in Nigeria and Uganda rather than
opportunities.
36
https://www.case48.com/pestel-case/3839-MTN-Group-Limited
37
https://www.vanguardngr.com/2022/03/russia-ukraine-war-mtn-compensates-affected-
subscribers-with-free-international-calls-sms/amp/
14
awareness of the economic climate, calculate the industry’s and organization’s growth
prospects.38
MTN saw a decline in the number of users in South Africa The users count dropped
to 30 million. One of the prime reasons behind this decline in users is MTN’s
incapability to retain its customers during harsh economic conditions. The
company’s overall outgoing call revenues and the data revenues saw a substantial
growth but its revenues from the digital mode declined by more than 41%. Also,
MTN has become a victim of the battery thefts from its facilities. Reports claim that
more than 700 batteries have been stolen from it’s site locations. This will increase
MTN’s cost to more than 7 million Rands. So, it should have strong security
measures to avoid such incidents.
The cultural norms, values, and trends have a significant impact on organizational
culture. MTN Group Limited can benefit from an understanding of demographic
trends, power structures, consumer buying patterns, and common views. PESTEL
analysis can help one create effective marketing messages and achieve your
company’s goals. MTN Group Limited’s marketing department can employ data
from social and environmental analyses to target certain customer groups and make
provided products more appealing to potential purchasers.39
MTN South Africa received multiple complaints from its customers about call and
internet difficulties after using pestle on social factors. This made the corporation to
issue a statement claiming that the problem was caused by technical difficulties. It
was later discovered that this was due to someone intentionally breaking a fiber.
Many people around the country were affected as a result of this, according to the
company. These types of situations might cause major issues in the long term
because they may cause a consumer to switch service providers. To make amends,
the business provided affected clients with 500 megabytes of data as a gift. MTN
also organizes monthly social campaigns to help the local community. Its Y’ello
38
https://www.case48.com/pestel-case/3839-MTN-Group-Limited
39
https://www.case48.com/pestel-case/3839-MTN-Group-Limited
15
Care initiative strives to empower youth by providing them with various educational
programs. This shows that the Company faces a number of threats socially but it is
able to resolve them using the pestle strategy.
40
ibid
41
https://www.case48.com/pestel-case/3839-MTN-Group-Limited
16
communication, allowing them to take use of cutting-edge technology. In Ghana, it
also ran a three-year program to empower women by providing them with new
technologies.MTN also contributes to seven of the seventeen United Nations
Sustainable Development Goals. The firm was also in charge of granting Anzali the
status of smart city. Its goal is to lend a hand by delivering the greatest digital
solutions for reducing traffic and lowering GHG emissions. This clarifies that MTN
Africa sees an opportunity in environmental factors.
MTN’s dispute against the Central Bank of Nigeria, in which the bank alleged MTN
had illegally transferred $8 billion outside of Nigeria, was one of its most significant
legal challenges. It was found guilty and had to pay a fine of $53 million for breaking
the rules. MTN’s stock plunged to two-thirds of its previous value shortly after the
penalty was imposed. In Nigeria alone, it has paid almost $15 billion in fines. This
shows that it might face more legal threats if it is not vigilant.
It is obvious that MTN is currently experiencing a very difficult period due to all of
the competitors, among other factors. Despite the difficulties, MTN Group’s value
remains significant. It is extremely well-positioned in Africa, with a highly
42
https://www.case48.com/pestel-case/3839-MTN-Group-Limited
17
recognizable brand and a sizable following in the lower income segments. Its main
advantage is its expertise in Africa, as well as its strong branch network and well-
established brand. Its subscriber base speaks for itself, establishing MTN as Africa’s
largest telecom. Nonetheless, in order to excel in this sector, particularly in emerging
markets where there is a higher level of uncertainty, companies must constantly strive
for simplicity while remaining organized and efficient in order to correctly face
competitive threats and regulatory changes.
MTN has clearly failed in terms of regulatory requirements, despite the fact that
overcoming these issues is critical. The company has made the necessary changes and
is now far more cautious and aware. In three to four years, I believe the Nigerian Fine
will be a thing of the past. Nonetheless, MTN is currently under pressure, and
competitors are attempting to capitalize on it. Its success will be determined by how
well it can deal with the constant competitive threats not only now, as it recovers from
the Nigerian Fine problems, but also in the future. Improved competitive price offers
and expanded Network coverage will be required for improved operational
performance.
18
REFERENCES
Links
Definition#:~:text=MTN%20stands%20for%20Mobile%20Telephone,in%20African
%20countries%20including%20Nigeria.https://www.jobzilla.ng/mtn
Gilbert, Paula, “MTN aims for 300m group subscribers by 2020,” Itweb, Aug 07,
2017; 2) “Africa’s Top 100 Brands in 2019 – Global brands dominate Africa,”
African Business Magazine, May 30, 2019
https://www.case48.com/pestel-case/3839-MTN-Group-Limited
Ashita Chopra (19 August 2020). “MTN appoints Ralph Mupita as the new group
president and CEO”. Daily Monitor. Kampala. Retrieved 22 August 2020
https://www.connectingafrica.com/author.asp?section_id=761&doc_id=753808
https://www.mtn.com/mtn-group-reports-strong-2021-results-enhances-financial-
guidance-on-accelerating-data-and-fintech-services/
https://www.case48.com/pestel-case/3839-MTN-Group-Limited
19
https://ng.linkedin.com/company/mtn-nigeria
https://www.dukece.com/insights/how-mtn-group-grappling-with-uncertainty/
https://www.liveplan.com/blog/what-is-a-swot-analysis-and-how-to-do-it-right-with-
examples/
https://www.mbaskool.com/brandguide/telecom-service-providers/521-mtn.htm
https://www.owler.com/company/vodacom/competitors
https://techcentral.co.za/mobile-market-share-in-south-africa-vodacom-mtn-telkom-
and-cell-c/207433/?amp=1
https://www.telecompaper.com/news/mtn-group-underlying-service-revenue-rises-18-
in-2021-customers-up-nearly-3-mln--1416952
https://techpoint.africa/2021/05/13/airtel-q1-2021-financial-report/
https://m.economictimes.com/markets/stocks/earnings/airtel-africa-q3-results-net-
profit-up-54-to-180-mn/amp_articleshow/89352484.cms
https://m.engineeringnews.co.za/article/cell-c-shows-improved-h1-2021-10-
27#:~:text=With%20the%20implementation%20of%20a,in%20the%20prior
%20corresponding%20period.
https://www.millicom.com/media/4849/millicom-earnings-release-q4-2021_final.pdf
https://companiesmarketcap.com/millicom/revenue/#:~:text=According%20to
%20Millicom’s%20latest%20financial,sale%20of%20goods%20or%20services.
20
https://www.reuters.com/business/media-telecom/africas-mtn-resumes-dividend-after-
bumper-annual-profit-2022-03-09/
https://tradingeconomics.com/vod:sj
https://millicom.gcs-web.com/news-releases/news-release-details/millicom-tigo-
unveils-three-year-operational-financial-and
https://simplywall.st/stocks/za/telecom/jse-tkg/telkom-sa-soc-shares
https://www.cellc.co.za/cellc/shareholder-information
https://www.forbes.com/companies/millicom-international/
https://www.bloomberg.com/press-releases/2021-02-11/millicom-international-
cellular-s-a-resilient-cash-flow-and-customer-growth
https://www.forbes.com/companies/telkom/?sh=12a4e3d7512f
https://libguides.libraries.wsu.edu/c.php?g=294263&p=4358409#:~:text=A
%20PESTEL%20analysis%20is%20a,organization%2C%20company%2C%20or
%20industry
.https://www.mbaskool.com/pestle-analysis/companies/18044-
mtn.html#:~:text=MTN%20PESTLE%20Analysis%20examines%20the,the
%20business%20of%20the%20brand.
https://www.case48.com/pestel-case/3839-MTN-Group-Limited
https://www.vanguardngr.com/2022/03/russia-ukraine-war-mtn-compensates-
affected-subscribers-with-free-international-calls-sms/amp/
21
https://www.case48.com/pestel-case/3839-MTN-Group-Limited
https://www.case48.com/pestel-case/3839-MTN-Group-Limited
22