Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Debate
Debate
Defence
Revenge is justifiable: One argument in defense of Medea's actions is that
revenge is justifiable in the face of betrayal and abandonment. In the play,
Medea has been betrayed by Jason and cast aside, and she may have felt that
her actions were a legitimate form of revenge against someone who has
wronged her.
Rebuttal: While revenge may be a natural human reaction to hurt and betrayal,
it is not necessarily justifiable from an ethical perspective. Revenge often
involves hurting others and can lead to a cycle of violence that can cause
further harm. It is important to seek non-violent solutions to conflicts and to
avoid actions that may cause harm to others.
Protecting her children: Another argument in defense of Medea is that she was
motivated by a desire to protect her children from the consequences of Jason's
actions. In the play, Medea is depicted as a devoted mother who is willing to
do anything to protect her children.
Rebuttal: While protecting one's children is a noble goal, it does not necessarily
justify harmful or violent actions. It is important to consider the potential
consequences of one's actions and to seek non-violent solutions that do not
cause harm to others. Additionally, the act of killing one's own children is
considered morally reprehensible in many cultures and is not a justifiable
means of protection.
Mental distress: Another argument in defense of Medea is that she was driven
to her actions by mental distress, possibly caused by the trauma of Jason's
betrayal and abandonment. In the play, Medea is depicted as a woman who is
overcome by emotions and unable to control her actions.
Rebuttal: While mental distress can certainly have a profound impact on one's
actions, it does not excuse harmful or violent behavior. It is important to seek
help and support when struggling with mental health issues, rather than
turning to harmful or violent actions. Additionally, it is the responsibility of
individuals to control their actions and to seek help when needed, rather than
allowing their emotions to dictate their behavior.