Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Adiabtic Cooling Fims For Energy Savings Part 3
Adiabtic Cooling Fims For Energy Savings Part 3
M&V Option – IPMVP Option A (One-time measurement for 24 hour (3-days average)
Savings Summary:
# With reference to the above table, Reduction in temperatures (< 82.4 Deg F against the target of 86 Deg F) are achieved more than expected values. hence
targeted savings are considered as achieved for all the conditions.
Page |1
Measurement Details:
Table-A
9-Jun-23 20:00 32.5 90.4 32.5 90.5 63 6-Jun-23 20:00 25.0 77.0 30.5 86.9 45 63.5 3.5 3.5
9-Jun-23 21:00 32.6 90.7 32.0 89.7 53 6-Jun-23 21:00 24.8 76.6 29.1 84.4 44 63.5 3.5 2.9
9-Jun-23 22:00 31.6 88.8 31.4 88.6 55 6-Jun-23 22:00 24.3 75.7 27.9 82.2 44 63.5 3.5 3.0
9-Jun-23 23:00 31.0 87.8 30.3 86.6 54 6-Jun-23 23:00 24.4 76.0 27.4 81.3 44 63.5 3.5 3.0
9-Jun-23 18:00 35.9 96.7 37.0 98.5 49 6-Jun-23 18:00 26.1 78.9 35.4 95.7 46 63.5 3.5 2.7
10-Jun-23 0:00 30.0 86.1 29.6 85.3 51 7-Jun-23 0:00 24.2 75.6 26.8 80.3 43 63.5 3.5 2.8
10-Jun-23 1:00 28.8 83.9 28.6 83.4 49 7-Jun-23 1:00 24.2 75.5 25.9 78.7 37 63.5 3.5 2.7
10-Jun-23 2:00 28.3 83.0 27.8 82.0 49 7-Jun-23 2:00 23.7 74.6 25.9 78.6 36 63.5 3.5 2.7
10-Jun-23 3:00 27.6 81.7 27.2 80.9 47 7-Jun-23 3:00 23.8 74.9 25.4 77.8 36 63.5 3.5 2.6
10-Jun-23 4:00 26.8 80.2 26.5 79.8 48 7-Jun-23 4:00 23.2 73.7 24.9 76.8 36 63.5 3.5 2.6
10-Jun-23 5:00 26.2 79.1 25.9 78.7 46 7-Jun-23 5:00 23.5 74.4 24.5 76.1 31 63.5 3.5 2.5
10-Jun-23 6:00 27.4 81.4 26.7 80.1 46 7-Jun-23 6:00 23.2 73.8 25.2 77.4 35 63.5 3.5 2.5
10-Jun-23 7:00 29.2 84.6 28.7 83.7 46 7-Jun-23 7:00 24.3 75.8 27.0 80.6 31 63.5 3.5 2.5
10-Jun-23 8:00 31.4 88.5 31.6 88.8 46 7-Jun-23 8:00 24.6 76.2 29.7 85.4 36 63.5 3.5 2.5
10-Jun-23 9:00 33.4 92.1 34.4 93.9 48 7-Jun-23 9:00 25.0 77.0 32.6 90.7 32 63.5 3.5 2.6
10-Jun-23 19:00 33.8 92.8 33.9 93.0 68 7-Jun-23 19:00 25.2 77.4 32.5 90.4 46 63.5 3.5 3.7
10-Jun-23 20:00 32.6 90.6 32.2 90.0 54 7-Jun-23 20:00 24.9 76.8 30.4 86.8 45 63.5 3.5 3.0
10-Jun-23 21:00 30.9 87.5 30.8 87.5 52 7-Jun-23 21:00 24.6 76.2 29.1 84.4 45 63.5 3.5 2.9
10-Jun-23 22:00 29.9 85.9 29.6 85.3 50 7-Jun-23 22:00 24.3 75.7 28.1 82.6 43 63.5 3.5 2.8
Page |2
10-Jun-23 23:00 28.9 84.0 28.6 83.5 49 7-Jun-23 23:00 24.6 76.3 27.4 81.3 44 63.5 3.5 2.7
10-Jun-23 10:00 35.5 95.9 37.1 98.7 51 7-Jun-23 10:00 25.8 78.4 35.2 95.3 39 63.5 3.5 2.8
10-Jun-23 18:00 36.7 98.1 37.5 99.6 57 7-Jun-23 18:00 25.8 78.4 35.6 96.0 46 63.5 3.5 3.1
11-Jun-23 0:00 28.1 82.6 27.7 81.9 43 8-Jun-23 0:00 24.1 75.4 26.5 79.6 42 63.5 3.5 2.4
11-Jun-23 1:00 28.5 83.3 27.8 82.1 42 8-Jun-23 1:00 24.1 75.3 25.8 78.5 37 63.5 3.5 2.3
11-Jun-23 2:00 27.9 82.3 27.4 81.3 41 8-Jun-23 2:00 23.6 74.5 25.8 78.4 38 63.5 3.5 2.3
11-Jun-23 3:00 27.5 81.6 27.0 80.6 35 8-Jun-23 3:00 23.7 74.7 25.4 77.7 35 63.5 3.5 1.9
11-Jun-23 4:00 27.2 81.0 26.7 80.0 40 8-Jun-23 4:00 23.4 74.0 24.9 76.9 32 63.5 3.5 2.2
11-Jun-23 5:00 27.6 81.6 27.0 80.6 37 8-Jun-23 5:00 22.8 73.1 24.1 75.4 32 63.5 3.5 2.0
11-Jun-23 6:00 27.6 81.8 27.3 81.2 38 8-Jun-23 6:00 23.5 74.3 24.9 76.9 27 63.5 3.5 2.1
11-Jun-23 7:00 28.4 83.0 28.2 82.8 42 8-Jun-23 7:00 23.8 74.9 27.3 81.1 31 63.5 3.5 2.3
11-Jun-23 8:00 29.7 85.5 29.8 85.7 41 8-Jun-23 8:00 24.7 76.5 30.2 86.4 30 63.5 3.5 2.3
11-Jun-23 9:00 31.7 89.1 32.6 90.6 47 8-Jun-23 9:00 25.3 77.6 33.5 92.3 34 63.5 3.5 2.6
11-Jun-23 19:00 33.6 92.5 33.6 92.4 54 8-Jun-23 19:00 25.8 78.4 33.4 92.1 47 63.5 3.5 3.0
11-Jun-23 20:00 32.3 90.2 32.1 89.7 53 8-Jun-23 20:00 25.1 77.2 31.6 88.8 47 63.5 3.5 2.9
11-Jun-23 21:00 31.3 88.4 31.0 87.8 51 8-Jun-23 21:00 24.9 76.8 29.9 85.8 45 63.5 3.5 2.8
11-Jun-23 22:00 30.1 86.2 30.0 85.9 50 8-Jun-23 22:00 24.7 76.4 28.5 83.4 45 63.5 3.5 2.8
11-Jun-23 23:00 29.7 85.5 29.3 84.7 49 8-Jun-23 23:00 24.3 75.8 27.7 81.8 44 63.5 3.5 2.7
11-Jun-23 10:00 34.1 93.3 35.4 95.8 48 8-Jun-23 10:00 25.8 78.5 36.4 97.6 41 63.5 3.5 2.6
11-Jun-23 18:00 35.2 95.4 36.1 96.9 55 8-Jun-23 18:00 26.6 79.8 36.3 97.3 47 63.5 3.5 3.0
12-Jun-23 0:00 29.2 84.6 28.8 83.9 48 9-Jun-23 0:00 24.1 75.3 26.9 80.4 44 63.5 3.5 2.6
12-Jun-23 1:00 28.9 83.9 28.4 83.0 49 9-Jun-23 1:00 23.5 74.3 26.9 80.5 44 63.5 3.5 2.7
12-Jun-23 2:00 28.4 83.0 27.8 82.1 47 9-Jun-23 2:00 23.8 74.8 26.5 79.7 43 63.5 3.5 2.6
12-Jun-23 3:00 27.9 82.2 27.4 81.3 47 9-Jun-23 3:00 23.6 74.4 26.0 78.9 42 63.5 3.5 2.6
12-Jun-23 4:00 27.5 81.5 26.9 80.5 42 9-Jun-23 4:00 23.2 73.8 25.6 78.0 34 63.5 3.5 2.3
12-Jun-23 5:00 27.2 80.9 26.7 80.0 42 9-Jun-23 5:00 23.2 73.7 25.5 77.8 37 63.5 3.5 2.3
12-Jun-23 6:00 27.9 82.3 27.3 81.1 41 9-Jun-23 6:00 23.5 74.3 26.1 79.0 38 63.5 3.5 2.3
Page |3
12-Jun-23 7:00 29.7 85.4 29.3 84.7 39 9-Jun-23 7:00 23.8 74.8 28.3 83.0 32 63.5 3.5 2.1
12-Jun-23 8:00 31.8 89.2 31.8 89.2 43 9-Jun-23 8:00 24.4 75.9 31.1 88.0 36 63.5 3.5 2.4
12-Jun-23 9:00 33.7 92.7 34.2 93.6 48 9-Jun-23 9:00 26.0 78.8 34.1 93.3 44 63.5 3.5 2.6
12-Jun-23 10:00 35.5 95.8 36.6 97.9 50 9-Jun-23 10:00 26.9 80.5 36.6 97.9 44 63.5 3.5 2.8
Average kW per Hour 92.4 52.5 Average kW per Hour 77.8 90.1 42.1 2.9
# In above table A, Yellow highlighted cells are considered for calculations. Please refer annexure 2 for energy meter readings.
Table-B
Pre-Retrofit (Without adiabatic cooling) Post-Retrofit (With adiabatic cooling)
11-Jun-23 11:00 35.6 96.1 38.2 100.8 50 7-Jun-23 11:00 26.5 79.7 38.0 100.4 44 73.2 13.2 9.0
11-Jun-23 12:00 36.9 98.4 39.3 102.7 52 7-Jun-23 12:00 27.2 81.0 39.5 103.1 45 73.2 13.2 9.4
11-Jun-23 13:00 37.7 99.8 40.0 104.0 52 7-Jun-23 13:00 27.1 80.8 40.1 104.2 42 73.2 13.2 9.4
11-Jun-23 17:00 36.8 98.3 38.9 102.0 55 7-Jun-23 14:00 27.3 81.2 40.4 104.8 44 73.2 13.2 9.9
12-Jun-23 11:00 36.9 98.5 38.9 102.0 52 7-Jun-23 15:00 27.1 80.8 40.2 104.3 46 73.2 13.2 9.4
12-Jun-23 12:00 38.0 100.4 40.2 104.3 53 7-Jun-23 16:00 27.0 80.6 39.7 103.4 47 73.2 13.2 9.6
Average kW per Hour 102.8 53.9 Average kW per Hour 80.6 103.0 45.2 9.7
Page |4
Table-C
Pre-Retrofit (Without adiabatic cooling) Post-Retrofit (With adiabatic cooling)
9 - 12 June 2023 6 - 9 June 2023 Target
Baseline Target Savings
Outside Outside Savings
Chiller kW @ @ Actual
Inside DBT DBT/Ambient: Inside DBT DBT/Ambient: Chiller 23001 @ 100%
23001 100% load Loading
(Hourly Average) Greater than 105F (Hourly Average) Greater than 100F kW per hour load
Date Time kW per hour Date Time
(Hourly Average) (Hourly Average)
deg C deg F deg C deg F A deg C deg F deg C deg F B kW kW kW
10-Jun-23 12:00 38.6 101.4 42.0 107.6 54 8-Jun-23 13:00 27.3 81.1 40.7 105.2 46 84.3 24.3 15.6
10-Jun-23 13:00 39.3 102.8 41.8 107.2 55 8-Jun-23 14:00 27.6 81.7 41.7 107.1 47 84.3 24.3 15.9
10-Jun-23 14:00 39.8 103.6 42.8 109.1 67 8-Jun-23 15:00 27.6 81.6 41.3 106.3 48 84.3 24.3 19.3
10-Jun-23 15:00 39.8 103.7 42.8 109.0 70 8-Jun-23 16:00 27.4 81.2 41.4 106.4 47 84.3 24.3 20.2
10-Jun-23 16:00 39.6 103.2 42.5 108.5 63 9-Jun-23 13:00 28.4 83.0 40.7 105.2 44 84.3 24.3 18.2
10-Jun-23 17:00 38.6 101.4 40.8 105.5 63 9-Jun-23 14:00 28.7 83.6 41.6 106.9 44 84.3 24.3 18.2
11-Jun-23 14:00 38.1 100.6 41.1 106.0 55 9-Jun-23 15:00 28.6 83.4 41.7 107.0 45 84.3 24.3 15.9
Average kW per Hour 107.0 58.5 Average kW per Hour 82.3 106.3 45.9 16.9
Page |5
M&V methodology and measured key parameters
Page |6
Annexure 1 - Post retrofit temperature inside and outside of the chiller-23001 recorded by data
logger.
Screenshot of Temperature logger data
Page |7
Annexure 2 - Energy Meter Readings and Hourly Average Temperatures
Pre-Retrofit (Without adiabatic cooling) Post-Retrofit (With adiabatic cooling)
9 - 12 June 2023 6 - 9 June 2023
Outside Chiller Chiller Chiller Chiller
Inside DBT Outside
DBT/Ambient 23001 23001 Inside DBT 23001 23001
(Hourly DBT/Ambient
(Hourly (EM kW per (Hourly Average) (EM kW per
Date Time Average) Date Time (Hourly Average)
Average) readings) hour readings) hour
deg C deg F deg C deg F kWh A deg C deg F deg C deg F kWh B
Page |8
36.9 98.4 39.3 102.7 26.6 79.9 39.1 102.3
11-Jun-23 12:00 220424 52 8-Jun-23 11:00 216931 45
37.7 99.8 40.0 104.0 26.7 80.0 40.2 104.4
11-Jun-23 13:00 220476 52 8-Jun-23 12:00 216976 45
38.1 100.6 41.1 106.0 27.3 81.1 40.7 105.2
11-Jun-23 14:00 220531 55 8-Jun-23 13:00 217022 46
38.2 100.7 41.0 105.8 27.6 81.7 41.7 107.1
11-Jun-23 15:00 220586 55 8-Jun-23 14:00 217069 47
37.8 100.1 40.9 105.6 27.6 81.6 41.3 106.3
11-Jun-23 16:00 220641 55 8-Jun-23 15:00 217117 48
36.8 98.3 38.9 102.0 27.4 81.2 41.4 106.4
11-Jun-23 17:00 220696 55 8-Jun-23 16:00 217164 47
35.2 95.4 36.1 96.9 27.0 80.5 39.6 103.4
11-Jun-23 18:00 220751 55 8-Jun-23 17:00 217212 48
33.6 92.5 33.6 92.4 26.6 79.8 36.3 97.3
11-Jun-23 19:00 220805 54 8-Jun-23 18:00 217259 47
32.3 90.2 32.1 89.7 25.8 78.4 33.4 92.1
11-Jun-23 20:00 220858 53 8-Jun-23 19:00 217306 47
31.3 88.4 31.0 87.8 25.1 77.2 31.6 88.8
11-Jun-23 21:00 220909 51 8-Jun-23 20:00 217353 47
30.1 86.2 30.0 85.9 24.9 76.8 29.9 85.8
11-Jun-23 22:00 220959 50 8-Jun-23 21:00 217398 45
29.7 85.5 29.3 84.7 24.7 76.4 28.5 83.4
11-Jun-23 23:00 221008 49 8-Jun-23 22:00 217443 45
29.2 84.6 28.8 83.9 24.3 75.8 27.7 81.8
12-Jun-23 0:00 221056 48 8-Jun-23 23:00 217487 44
28.9 83.9 28.4 83.0 24.1 75.3 26.9 80.4
12-Jun-23 1:00 221105 49 9-Jun-23 0:00 217531 44
28.4 83.0 27.8 82.1 23.5 74.3 26.9 80.5
12-Jun-23 2:00 221152 47 9-Jun-23 1:00 217575 44
27.9 82.2 27.4 81.3 23.8 74.8 26.5 79.7
12-Jun-23 3:00 221199 47 9-Jun-23 2:00 217618 43
27.5 81.5 26.9 80.5 23.6 74.4 26.0 78.9
12-Jun-23 4:00 221241 42 9-Jun-23 3:00 217660 42
27.2 80.9 26.7 80.0 23.2 73.8 25.6 78.0
12-Jun-23 5:00 221283 42 9-Jun-23 4:00 217694 34
27.9 82.3 27.3 81.1 23.2 73.7 25.5 77.8
12-Jun-23 6:00 221324 41 9-Jun-23 5:00 217731 37
29.7 85.4 29.3 84.7 23.5 74.3 26.1 79.0
12-Jun-23 7:00 221363 39 9-Jun-23 6:00 217769 38
31.8 89.2 31.8 89.2 23.8 74.8 28.3 83.0
12-Jun-23 8:00 221406 43 9-Jun-23 7:00 217801 32
33.7 92.7 34.2 93.6 24.4 75.9 31.1 88.0
12-Jun-23 9:00 221454 48 9-Jun-23 8:00 217837 36
35.5 95.8 36.6 97.9 26.0 78.8 34.1 93.3
12-Jun-23 10:00 221504 50 9-Jun-23 9:00 217881 44
36.9 98.5 38.9 102.0 26.9 80.5 36.6 97.9
12-Jun-23 11:00 221556 52 9-Jun-23 10:00 217925 44
38.0 100.4 40.2 104.3 27.6 81.7 39.0 102.3
12-Jun-23 12:00 221609 53 9-Jun-23 11:00 217971 46
38.8 101.8 41.0 105.8 28.0 82.4 40.0 104.0
12-Jun-23 13:00 221655 46 9-Jun-23 12:00 218015 44
39.2 102.5 41.8 107.2 28.4 83.0 40.7 105.2
12-Jun-23 14:00 221719 64 9-Jun-23 13:00 218059 44
39.3 102.7 41.9 107.3 28.7 83.6 41.6 106.9
12-Jun-23 15:00 221779 60 9-Jun-23 14:00 218103 44
39.0 102.2 41.6 106.9 28.6 83.4 41.7 107.0
12-Jun-23 16:00 221833 54 9-Jun-23 15:00 218148 45
32.0
12-Jun-23 17:00 221898 65 9-Jun-23 16:00 Honey pad removed at 16:30 218195 47
Page |9