Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FINALS Goodluck!!!
10: ASSESSMENT IN EDUCATION this by determining whether training
could improve test performance.
THE ROLEOF TESTING AND
ASSESSMENT IN EDUCATION FEUERSTEIN’S
Educators are interested in answers to efforts focused on the extent to which
diverse questions as students progress teaching of principles and strategies (or
through school. mediated learning) modified cognition.
A small sampling of those questions Based on this research, he and his
might be: colleagues developed a dynamic system
o How well have students learned the of assessment tasks called the Learning
curriculum? Potential Assessment Device. The LPAD
o How well can students apply what was designed to yield information about
they have learned to novel situations? the nature and amount of intervention
o Are students ready to move on to the required to enhance a child’s
next level of learning? performance.
o Which students have the skills
VYGOTSKY
necessary for independent living?
introduced the concept of a zone of
o What is preventing an individual
proximal development - “the distance
student from meeting learning goals?
between the actual developmental level
o How effective are teachers in
as determined by individual problem-
assisting students to master specific
solving, and the level of potential
curriculum goals?
development as determined through
o Do passing test scores on a
problem-solving under adult guidance or
curriculum-specific test genuinely
in collaboration with more capable peers”
reflect the fact that the testtakers
The “zone” referred to is, in essence, the
have mastered the curriculum?
area between a testtaker’s ability as
measured by a formal test and what
DYNAMIC ASSESSMENT
might be possible as the result of
Although originally developed for use with
instruction, “guidance,” or related
children, a dynamic approach to
intervention
assessment may be used with testtakers
of any age. It is an approach to
ACHIEVEMENT TESTS
assessment that departs from reliance on,
Achievement tests are designed to
and can be contrasted to, fixed (socalled
measure accomplishment. Achievement
“static”) tests.
tests are designed to measure the degree
Dynamic assessment encompasses an
of learning that has taken place as a
approach to exploring learning potential
result of exposure to a relatively defined
that is based on a test-intervention-retest
learning experience.
model. The theoretical underpinnings of
“Relatively defined learning experience”
this approach can be traced to the work
may mean something as broad as what
of Budoff (1967, 1987), Feuerstein (1977,
was learned from four years of college, or
1981), and Vygotsky (1978)
something much narrower, such as how
BUDOFF to prepare dough for use in making pizza.
explored differences between deficits In most educational settings,
identified by standardized tests that achievement tests are used to gauge
seemed to be due to differences in student progress toward instructional
education versus mental deficiency He did objectives, compare an individual’s
accomplishment to peers, and help
determine what instructional activities greatly affecting the extent to which
and strategies might best propel the he was financially able to go to
students toward educational objectives. school.
b. Red: He was adopted as a 5-year-old
MEASURES OF GENERAL ACHIEVEMENT
when both of his parents were
Measures of general achievement may
arrested for distribution of illegal
survey learning in one or more academic
drugs, using him as a front for
areas. Tests that cover a number of
distribution.
academic areas are typically divided into
c. Marcie: Her grandmother has PTSD
several subtests and are referred to as
due to her experiences during WWII.
achievement batteries.
She did not receive reparations nor
WECHSLER INDIVIDUAL ACHIEVEMENT social assistance from the
TEST–THIRD EDITION (WIAT-III) government.
popular instrument appropriate for use d. Pat: They have an uncle living with
with persons ages 4 through adult (age them who has generalized anxiety
50 is the age limit) disorder. Pat ran away from home
after multiple heated arguments with
MEASURES OF ACHIEVEMENT IN their father regarding Pat’s academic
SPECIFIC SUBJECT AREAS dismissal
Whereas achievement batteries tend to
be standardized instruments, most APTITUDES TESTS
measures of achievement in specific The primary difference between
subject areas are teacher-made tests. achievement tests and aptitude tests is
Every time a teacher gives a quiz, a test, that aptitude tests tend to focus more on
or a final examination in a course, a test informal learning or life experiences
in a specific subject area has been whereas achievement tests tend to focus
created. on the learning that has occurred as a
Tests of English proficiency or English as result of relatively structured input
a Second Language (ESL) 3. A correlation of .7 between variables X
ACHIEVEMENT TEST ITEMS and Y in a predictive validity study
Achievement test items may be accounts for what percentage of the
characterized by the type of mental variance?
processes required by the testtaker to a. 7%
successfully retrieve the information b. 70%
needed to respond to the item c. .7%
d. 49%
FACT-BASED ITEMS e. 25%
1. One type of item that could be used in an 4. o is to O as x is to
achievement test is an item that requires a. /
a. remote memory b. %
b. rote memory c. X
c. memory loss d. Y
d. mnemonic loss The label achievement or aptitude for a
test may depend not simply on the types
CONCEPTUAL ITEMS
of items contained in the test but also on
2. According to the diathesis-stress model
the intended use of the test. It is possible
which of the following would be most
for two tests containing the same or
likely to develop a psychological disorder?
similar items to be called by different
a. Gary: His mother and aunt were
names: one could be labeled an aptitude
clinically addicted to gambling,
2
test while the other is labeled an designed for use with members of the
achievement test same grade.
Aptitude tests, also referred to as
READING TESTS
prognostic tests, are typically used to
make predictions. Some aptitude tests THE WOODCOCK READING MASTERY
have been used to measure readiness to: TESTS–THIRD EDITION (WRMT-III;
WOODCOCK, 2011)
o enter a particular preschool program
paper-and-pencil measure of reading
o enter elementary school
readiness, reading achievement, and
o successfully complete a challenging
reading difficulties takes between 15 and
course of study in secondary school
45 minutes to administer the entire
o successfully complete college-level
battery. can be used with children as
work
young as 4½, adults as old as 80, and
o successfully complete graduate-level
most everyone in between
work, including a course of study at a
professional or trade school SOME SUBSETS OF THE WRMT-III ARE:
Letter Identification: Items that
DIAGNOSTIC TESTS measure the ability to name letters
Today a distinction is made between tests presented in different forms. Both cursive
and test data used primarily for and printed as well as uppercase and
evaluative purposes and tests and test lowercase letters are presented.
data used primarily for diagnostic Word Identification: Words in isolation
purposes. arranged in order of increasing difficulty.
Evaluative information tests or test The student is asked to read each word
data that are used to make judgments aloud.
(such as pass–fail and admit–reject Word Attack: Nonsense syllables that
decisions). incorporate phonetic as well as structural
Diagnostic information as used in analysis skills. The student is asked to
educational contexts (and related phrases pronounce each nonsense syllable.
such as diagnostic purposes) is typically Word Comprehension: Items that
applied to tests or test data used to assess word meaning by using a four-part
pinpoint a student’s difficulty, usually for analogy format.
remedial purposes. Passage Comprehension: Phrases,
Diagnostic test - a tool used to identify sentences, or short paragraphs, read
areas of deficit to be targeted for silently, in which a word is missing. The
intervention. student must supply the missing word.
Diagnostic tests do not necessarily Three subtests new to the third
provide information that will answer edition are Phonological Awareness,
questions concerning why a learning Listening Comprehension, and Oral
difficulty exists. Reading Fluency.
Other educational, psychological, and All of the subtests taken together are
perhaps medical examinations are needed used to derive a picture of the testtaker’s
to answer that question. reading-related strengths and
In general, diagnostic tests are weaknesses, as well as an actionable plan
administered to students who have for reading remediation when necessary.
already demonstrated their problem with The test comes in parallel forms, useful
a particular subject area through their for establishing a baseline and then
poor performance either in the classroom monitoring postintervention progress.
or on some achievement test. For this
reason, diagnostic tests may contain
simpler items than achievement tests
3
MATH TESTS Solving, Reasoning and Proof,
The Group Mathematics Assessment Communication, Connection, and
and Diagnostic Evaluation (GMADE) Representation.
and the KeyMath 3 Diagnostic Test protocols are scored using software.
System (KeyMath3-DA) are two of
PSYCHOEDUCATIONAL TEST
many tests that have been developed to
BATTERIES
help diagnose difficulties with arithmetic
Psychoeducational test batteries are test
and mathematical concepts. Items on
kits that generally contain two types of
such tests typically test everything from
tests: those that measure abilities related
knowledge of basic concepts and
to academic success and those that
operations through applications entailing
measure educational achievement in
increasingly advanced problem-solving
areas such as reading and arithmetic.
skills.
Data derived from these batteries allow
KEYMATH 3 DIAGNOSTIC SYSTEM for normative comparisons (how the
(KEYMATH3-DA) student compares with other students
A standardized test that may be within the same age group), as well as an
administered to children as young as 4½ evaluation of the testtaker’s own
and adults as old as 21. strengths and weaknesses—all the better
The test’s development included “a to plan educational interventions.
review of state math standards and
National Council of Teachers of
Mathematics publications,” which led to
the creation of “a comprehensive
blueprint reflecting essential mathematics
content, existing curriculum priorities,
and national math standards”
The test comes in two forms, each
containing 10 subtests.
Test protocols can either be hand-scored Many psychoeducational batteries also
or computer-scored. KeyMath3-DA is measure specific subject knowledge in
individually administered. the sciences, social studies, and the
GROUP MATHEMATICS ASSESSMENT humanities.
AND DIAGNOSTIC EVALUATION Psychoeducational batteries are designed
(GMADE) not only to measure academic skills and
A standardized test that can provide knowledge but also more fundamental
useful diagnostic insights with regard to abilities that might explain why a student
the mathematical abilities of children just performs well or poorly in school.
entering school to just entering college. These cognitive abilities include aspects
The test is available in different forms, is of attention, perception, memory,
amenable for group administration. reasoning, language, and knowledge.
The test was designed to measure math
THE KAUFMAN ASSESSMENT BATTERY
skills listed by the National Council of FOR CHILDREN, SECOND EDITION
Teachers and Mathematics, including NORMATIVE UPDATE (KABC-II NU)
Number and Operations, Algebra, the KABC-II NU was designed for use
Geometry, Measurement, and Data with testtakers from age 3 through age
Analysis and Probability. 18.
In addition to these content areas, the The original K-ABC had two primary
GMADE measures several mathematics scales designed to measure individual
process abilities including Problem
4
differences in simultaneous and o and a fluid/ crystallized composite
successive processing of information. (Gf-Gc).
Because the test minimized the need for Using the Achievement, Cognitive, or Oral
verbal knowledge, test score differences Language batteries, the examiner has the
between ethnic and racial groups were flexibility to administer either a standard
smaller on the K-ABC than they were for or extended battery.
other standardized tests of intelligence In general, the extended battery will be
(Wilson et al., 1989). used to obtain the most comprehensive
This feature of the K-ABC was particularly and detailed evaluation of an assessee’s
attractive to examiners who worked with strengths and weaknesses or educational
students from diverse backgrounds. progress.
When the KABC-II was revised, it The standard battery will typically be the
borrowed from PASS theory to measure measure of choice for brief screenings,
planning and attention, in addition to periodic re-evaluations, and relatively
simultaneous and successive processing pinpointed assessments designed to
abilities. address specific issues related to
In addition, the KABC-II was aligned to instruction, performance level, or RtI.
the Cattell-Horn-Carroll (CHC) theory of
cognitive abilities. PASS theory and CHC OTHER TOOLS OF ASSESSMENT
theory have many similarities such that, PERFORMANCE, PORTFOLIO AND
roughly speaking, planning ≈ fluid AUTHENTIC ASSESSMENT
intelligence, attention ≈ processing Performance Tasks – a work sample
speed, sequential processing ≈ working designed to elicit representative
memory, and successive processing ≈ knowledge, skills, and values from a
visual-spatial processing. particular domain of study.
This dual theoretical foundation provides Performance Assessment - an
the examiner with a choice as to which evaluation of performance tasks
model of test interpretation is optimal for according to criteria developed by experts
the particular situation. from the domain of study tapped by
those tasks.
THE WOODCOCK-JOHNSON IV (WJ IV)
Portfolio – synonymous with work
The WJ IV consists of three co-normed sample in the language of psychological
test batteries measuring broad cognitive and educational assessment
abilities, oral language skills, and
Portfolio Assessment - refers to the
academic achievement.
evaluation of one’s work samples
The WJ IV tests measuring language and
Authentic Assessment – also known as
verbal knowledge can be given in English
performance-based assessment. In
or Spanish.
educational contexts, this refers to
According to the WJ IV manual, the
evaluation of relevant, meaningful tasks
battery may be used with persons as
that may be conducted to evaluate
young as 2, and as old as 90 (or older). learning of academic subject matter but
Based on the Cattell-Horn-Carroll (CHC)
that demonstrate the student’s transfer of
theory of cognitive abilities, the WJ IV that study to real-world activities.
yields a multitude of measures including Authentic assessment is thought to
o a measure of general intellectual increase student interest and the transfer
ability (GIA), of knowledge to settings outside the
o a measure of fluid abilities (Gf),
classroom.
o a measure of crystallized abilities Peer Appraisal Techniques Peer
(Gc), Appraisal – a method of obtaining
information about an individual by asking
5
that individual’s peer group to make the Habits, Teacher Approval, Education
evaluation. Peer appraisals can help call Acceptance, and Study Attitudes.
needed attention to an individual who is The test yields a study skills score, an
experiencing academic, personal, social, attitude score, and a total orientation
or work-related difficulties—difficulties score
that, for whatever reason, have not come
11: PERSONALITY ASSESSMENT: AN
to the attention of the person in charge.
OVERVIEW
Peer appraisals allow the individual in
charge to view members of a group from PERSONALITY AND PERSONALITY
a different perspective: the perspective of ASSESSMENT
those who work, play, socialize, eat Personality
lunch, and walk home with the person o An individual’s unique constellation of
being evaluated. psychological traits that is relatively
MEASURING STUDY HABITS, stable over time.
INTERESTS, AND ATTITUDES ACADEMIC Personality Assessment
performance is the result of a complex o the measurement and evaluation of
interplay of a number of factors. Ability psychological traits, states, values,
and motivation are inseparable partners interests, attitudes, worldview,
in the pursuit of academic success. A acculturation, sense of humor,
number of instruments designed to look cognitive and behavioral styles,
beyond ability and toward factors such as and/or related individual
study habits, interests, and attitudes have characteristics
been published.
PERSONALITY TRAITS, TYPES, STATES
For example, the Study Habits Checklist,
Traits
designed for use with students in grades
o Any distinguishable, relatively
9 through 14, consists of 37 items that
enduring way in which one individual
assess study habits with respect to note
varies from another.
taking, reading material, and general
States
study practices.
o is indicative of a relatively temporary
THE SURVEY OF STUDY HABITS AND predisposition
ATTITUDES (SSHA) AND THE STUDY Types
ATTITUDES AND METHODS SURVEY o Define as a constellation of traits that
combine the assessment of attitudes with is similar in pattern to one identified
the assessment of study methods. The category of personality within a
SSHA, intended for use in grades 7 taxonomy of personalities
through college, consists of 100 items o Ex: MBTI (Extroverted, Sensing,
tapping poor study skills and attitudes Thinking, Judging, Introverted,
that could affect academic performance. Intuitive, Feeling, and Perceiving),
Two forms are available, Form H for Type A & Type B Personality, MMPI
grades 7 to 12 and Form C for college,
each requiring 20 to 25 minutes to PERSONALITY ASSESSMENT: SOME
complete. BASIC QUESTIONS
Students respond to items on the 1. For what type of employment is a person
following 5-point scale: rarely, with this type of personality best suited?
sometimes, frequently, generally, or 2. Is this individual sufficiently well adjusted
almost always. for military or police officer service?
Test items are divided into six areas: 3. What emotional and other adjustment-
Delay Avoidance, Work Methods, Study related factors may be responsible for
6
this student’s level of academic d. Self-concept differentiation
achievement? 2. Another person as the referent
4. What pattern of traits and states does a. Leniency error or Generosity error
this psychotherapy client exhibit, and to b. Severity error
what extent may this pattern be deemed c. Halo effect
pathological? d. Error of Central Tendency
5. How has this patient’s personality been 3. The cultural background of assesses
affected by neurological trauma? a. Cultural Diversity
SELF-CONCEPT MEASURE
is an instrument designed to yield
information relevant to how an individual
sees him- or herself with regard to
selected psychological variables
Ex. In the Beck Self-Concept Test (BST;
WHO?
Beck & Stein, 1961), named after senior
Who is being assessed, and who is doing
author, psychiatrist Aaron T. Beck,
the assessing?
respondents are asked to compare
Some methods of personality assessment
themselves to other people on variables
rely on the asesse’s own self-report such as looks, knowledge, and the ability
By contrast, other methods of personality to tell jokes.
assessment rely on informants other that
the person being assessed to provide SELF-CONCEPT DIFFERENTIATION
personality-related information Refers to the degree to which a person
1. The self as the primary referent has different self-concepts in different
a. Self-report roles (Donahue et al., 1993).
b. Self-concept People characterized as highly
c. Self-concept measure differentiated are likely to perceive
7
themselves quite differently in various The rater may not have the proper
roles. background,experience, and trained eye
Ex. A highly differentiated businessman in needed for the particular task.
his 40s may perceive himself as Judgments may be limited by the rater's
motivated and hard-driving in his role at general level of conscientiousness and
work, conforming and people-pleasing in willingness to devote the time and effort
his role as son, and emotional and required to do the job properly.
passionate in his role as husband. The rater may harbor biases concerning
various stereotypes.
ANOTHER PERSON AS THE REFERENT
Subjectivity based on the rater's own
In some situations, the best available
personal preferences and taste may also
method for the assessment of
enter into judgments.
personality, behavior, or both involves
reporting by a third party such as a DIFFERENT RATERS MAY HAVE
parent, teacher, peer, supervisor, spouse, DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES ON THE
or trained observer. INDIVIDUAL THEY ARE RATING
Ex. The assessment of a child for BECAUISE OF THE CONTEXT IN WHICH
emotional difficulties. The child may be THEY TYPICALLY VIEW THAT PERSON.
unable or unwilling to complete any A parent may indicate on a rating scale
measure (self-report, performance, or that a child is hyperactive, whereas the
otherwise) that will be of value in making same child's teacher may indicate on the
a valid determination concerning that same rating scale that the child's activity
child's emotional status. level is within normal limits. Can they
Raters may vary in the extent to which both be right?
they are,or strive to be, scrupulously Different informants may have different
neutral, favorably generous, or harshly perspectives on the subjects being
severe in their ratings. evaluated. These different perspectives
Generalized biases to rate in a particular derive from observing and interacting
direction are referred to in terms such as with the subjects in different contexts.
leniency error or generosity error and
THE CULTURAL BACKGROUND OF
severity error. ASSESSEES
Error of central tendency Regardless whether the self or another
o A general tendency to rate everyone person is the subject of study, one
near the midpoint of a rating scale. element of any evaluation that must be
In some situations, a particular set of kept in mind by the assessor is the
circumstances may create a certain bias. cultural context.
Ex. A teacher might be disposed to Test developers and users have shown
judging one pupil very favorably because increased sensitivity to issues of cultural
that pupil's older sister was teacher's pet diversity. A number of concerns have
in a prior class. This variety of favourable been raised regarding the use of
response bias is sometimes referred to as personality tests and other tools of
a halo effect. assessment with members of culturally
NUMEROUS OTHER FACTORS and linguistically diverse population
CONTRIBUTE O BIAS IN A RATER’S
RATING WHAT?
The rater may feel competitive What is assessed when a personality
with,physically attracted to, or physically assessment is conducted?
repelled by the subject of the ratings. 1. Primary Content Area Sampled
2. Testtaker Response Styles
3. Impression Management
8
1. PRIMARY CONTENT AREA SAMPLED Overly positive Claim extreme
Personality measures are tools used to virtue through
gain insight into a wide array of thoughts, self-presentation
feelings, and behaviors associated with all in a superlative
aspects of the human experience. manner (Butcher
Some tests are designed to measure & Han, 1995)
particular traits (such as introversion) or 3. IMPRESSION MANAGEMENT
states (such as test anxiety), whereas A term used to describe the attempt to
others focus on descriptions of behavior, manipulate others' impressions through
usually in particular contexts. “the selective exposure of some
Ex. An observational checklist may information (it may be false information)
concentrate on classroom behaviors coupled with suppression of [other]
associated with movement in order to information"
assess a child's hyperactivity. Responding to a personality test in an
inconsistent, contrary, or random way, or
2. TESTTAKER RESPONSE STYLES attempting to fake good or bad, may
Response Style affect the validity of the interpretations of
o Refers to a tendency to respond to a the test data.
test item or interview question in Because a response style can affect the
some characteristic manner validity of the outcome, one particular
regardless of the content of the item type of response style measure is
or question. referred to as a validity scale
o Ex. An individual may be more apt to Validity Scale
respond yes or true than no or false o we may define a validity scale as a
on a short-answer test. This subscale of a test designed to assist
particular pattern of responding is in judgements regarding how
characterized as acquiescent. honestly the testtaker responded and
TEST RESPONSE STYLES whether observed responses were
products of response style,
Response Style Explanation: A
Name Tendency to… carelessness, deliberate efforts to
Socially desirable Present oneself in deceive, or unintentional
responding a favourable misunderstanding
(socially
acceptable or WHERE?
desirable) light Where are personality assessment
Acquiescence Agree with conducted?
whatever is o Schools
presented o Clinics
Nonacquiescense Disagree with o Hospitals
whatever is o Academic Research Laboratories
presented o Employment Counseling
Deviance Make unusual or o Offices of Psychologist and
common Counselors
responses
Extreme Make extreme, as HOW?
opposed to
How are personality assessment
middle, ratings on
structured?
a rating scale
1. Scope and Theory
Gambling/cautiousness Guess-or not
guess-when in 2. Procedures and Format
doubt 3. Frame of Reference
9
4. Scoring and Interpretation Q-sort technique-originally developed
5. Issues in Personality Test Development by Stephenson (1953 ) is an assessment
and Use technique in which the task is to sort a
group of statements,usually in perceived
01 SCOPE AND THEORY
rank order ranging from most descriptive
The scope of an evaluation may be very
to least descriptive.
wide, seeking to take a kind of general
One of the best known application of Q-
inventory of an individuals personality.
sort methodology in clinical and
The California Psychological
counseling setting was advocate by the
Inventory (CPI 434) is an example of
personality theorist and psychotherapist
an instrument with a relatively wide
Carl Rogers (1959)
scope. This test contains 434 true-false
items. 04 SCORING AND INTERPRETATION
It was originally conceived to measure Personality measures differ with respect
enduring personality traits across cultural to the way conclusions are drawn from
groups and predict the behavior of the data they provide. For other
generally well functioning people (Boer measures, a computer programmed to
et.al., 2008) apply highly technical manipulation of the
Locus of Control - Locus ( meaning data is required for purposes os scoring
"place or "site") of control is a persons and interpretation.
perception about the source of things Nomothetic approach-assessment is
that happen to him or her. characterized by efforts to learn howna
Internal Locus of Control limited number of personality traits can
External Locus of Control be applied to all people.
Idiographic approach-assessment is
02 PROCEDURES AND ITEM FORMATS
characterizer by efforts to learn about
Personality may be assessed by many
each individuals unique constellation of
different methods, such as face to face
personality traits, with no attempt to
interview, computer administered tests,
characterized each person according to
behavioral observation, paper and pencil
any particular set of traits.
test,evaluation of case history
The idiographic approach to personality
data,evaluation of portfolio data and
assessment was describe in detail by
recording of psychological responses.
Allport ( 1937; Allport & Odbert 1936).
Measures in personality vary in terms of
Normative approach- a testtakers
the degree of structure built into them.
responses and the presumed strength of
For example, personality may be
a measured trait are interpreted relative
assessed by means of an interview,but it
to the strength of that trait in a sample of
may also be assessed by a structured
a larger population
interview.
Ipsative approach - a testtakers
Aggressive may be defined in ways
responses, as well as the presumed
ranging from hostile and assaultive( as in
strength of measured traits are
the "aggressive inmate" ) to hold and
interpreted relativeto the strength of
enterprising (" aggressive salesperson).
measured traits for that same individual.
03 FRAME OF REFERENCES
05 ISSUES IN PERSONALITY TEST
Frame of reference-may be defined as DEVELOPMENT AND USE
aspects of the focus of exploration such Many of the issues inherent in the test
as the time frame as well as the other
development process mirror the basic
contextual issues that involves questions just discussed about personality
people,places and events.
asssessment in general.
10
As previously noted, personality To aid in the identification of the
assessment that relies exclusively on self- minimum number of variables or factors
report is a two eyed sword. that account for the intercorrelations in
Building validity scales into self-report observed phenomena.
tests is one way that test developers Example: “the most important individual
have attempted to deal with the potential differences in human transactions”
problems. How many primary factors of personality
In arguing the case of the inclusion of are there?
validity scales, it has been asserted that" o Raymond Bernard Cattell (1940s)-16
detention of an attempt to provide factors
misleading information is a vital and o Surface traits-personality elements
absolutely necessary component of the that can be directly observed
clinical interpretation of test results and o Source traits-must be inferred
that using any instrument without validity through statistical methods.It is the
scales runs counter to the baic tenets of building blocks or sources of human
clinical assessment(Ben-Porath & Waller personality.
1992). o Sixteen Personality Factor (16
PF) Questionnaire-Raymond Cattell
DEVELOPING INSTRUMENTS TO ASSESS (1949)
PERSONALITY o Eysenck(1991) -three
1. Logic and Reason primary factors
2. Theory o Church and Burke(1994) - maybe
3. Data Reduction Methods four,five, or six factors
4. Criterion Groups o Waller and Zavala(1993) -seven-
factor model
01 LOGIC AND REASON
o Costa and McCrae (1992) -five-
Content or content-oriented approach
factor models
o Example:True-False Test of
Extraversion THE BIG FIVE COMPARED TO CATTELL’S
o “I consider myself an outgoing FIVE
person" The Big Five Cattell’s Five
Personal Data Sheet (circa 1960)
o Robert S.Woodworth (1917) Extraversion Introversion/
o Woodworth Psychoneurotic Inventory Extraversion
o Contained items designed to elicit Neuroticism Low Anxiety/High
self-report of fears,sleep Anxiety
disorders,and other problems deemed Openness Tough-Mindedness/
symptomatic of a pathological Receptivity
condition referred to then as Agreeableness Independence/
psychoneuroticism. Accommodation
Conscientiousness Low Self-Control/
02 THEORY High Self-Control
Personality measures differ in the extent 04 CRITERION GROUPS
to which they rely on a particular theory May be defined as a standard on which a
of personality in their development as judgement or decision can be made
well as their interpretation. Empirical Criterion Keying
o scoring or keying of items has been
03 DATA REDUCTION METHODS
demonstrated empirically to
Include several types of statistical
differentiate among groups of test
techniques collectively known as factor
takers.
analysis or cluster analysis.
11
PERSONALITY ASSESSMENT AND Describe yourself in the way that you
CULTURE think most other people would describe
ACCULTURATION AND RELATED you. How would you say your own self
CONSIDERATION description would differ from that
ACCULTURATION - is an ongoing description?
process by which an individual's thoughts, Describe yourself in the way that you
behavior, values, worldview, and identity think most other people would describe
develop in relation to the general you. How would you say your own self
thinking,behavior,customs,and values of a description would differ from that
particular cultural group. description?
The process of Acculturation begins at
birth. Instrumental Terminal Values
Value
Agents of Acculturation -this are the
Are guiding Are guiding
individuals or institutions who serve as
principles to help principles and a
source of consumer information and/or
one attain some mode of behaviour
model of Consumption behavior. objectives. that is an endpoint.
VALUES-are that which an individual Ex. Imagination, Ex. Comfortable life,
prizes or the ideas an individual believes ambition, and exciting life,
in. cheerfulness accomplishment,
ROKEACH (1973) - differentiated what self-respect.
he called instrumental from terminal Ex. Happiness is a terminal value, where as
values being ambitious to earn a million dollars is a
way to get happiness for some people.
SOME SAMPLE QUESTIONS TO ASSESS
ACCULTURATION Personal Identity-is intimately tied to
Describe yourself. the concept of Acculturation.
Describe your family. Who lives at home? IDENTITY - is defined as a set of
Describe roles in your family, such as the cognitive and behavioral characteristics
role of mother, the role of father, the role by which individuals define themselves as
of grandmother, the role of child, and so member of a particular group.
forth. IDENTIFICATION - a process by which
What traditions,rituals, or customs were an individual assumes a pattern of
passed down to you by family members? behavior characteristics of other people
What traditions,rituals,or customs do you and referred to it as one of the “central
think it is important to pass to the next issues that ethnic minority groups must
generation? deal with.
With regard to your family situation, what WORLDVIEW - the unique way people
obligations do you see yourself as interpret and make sense of their
having? perceptions as a consequence of their
What obligations does your family have to learning experience, cultural background,
you? and related variables.
What role does your family play in
everyday life?
How does the role of males and females
differ from your own cultural perspective?
What kind of music do you like?
What kinds of foods do you eat most
routinely?
What do you consider fun things to do?
When do you do these things?
12
12: PERSONALITY ASSESSMENT Necessitates ample self-knowledge
METHODS The forced choice approach leaves no
space for elaboration or contextualization
OBJECTIVE METHODS
Objective methods of personality PROJECTIVE METHODS
assessment typically: PROJECTIVE HYPOTHESIS
o Are administered by the means of The projective hypothesis holds that an
paper-and-pencil or computer individual supplies structure to
o Contain short-answer items for which unstructured stimuli in a manner
the assessee’s task is to select one consistent with the individual’s own
response from the two or more unique pattern of conscious and
responses provided unconscious needs, fears, desires,
o Are scored according to set impulses, conflicts, and ways of
procedures (with little to no judgment perceiving and responding.
from the scorer involved)
o May include items written in a PROJECTIVE METHOD
multiple-choice, true-or-false, or A projective method is a technique of
matching format personality assessment in which some
judgment of the assessee’s personality is
NOT ACTUALLY OBJECTIVE made on the basis of performance on a
There are no right or wrong answers task that involves supplying some sort of
But a true response is referred to as structure to unstructured or incomplete
indicative of the presence of a particular stimuli.
trait Providing structure to unstructured or
Involves self-reports / selfperceptions ambiguous stimuli Wilhelm Stern’s Cloud
(which make them largely subjective) Picture Test, in which subjects were
Some respondents may lack the insight to asked to tell what they saw in pictures of
respond in what could reasonably be clouds, was one of the earliest projective
described as an objective manner. measures
OBJECTIVE IN WHAT SENSE? NATURE OF PROJECTIVE METHODS
They employ a short-answer (typically The stimulus material is unstructured
multiple-choice) format The method is indirect
Scoring in these tests leave little room for There is freedom of response
emotion, bias, or favouritism Response interpretation deals with more
The selection of a particular choice from variables
multiple-choice items provides
information relevant to something about THEY ARE INDIRECT METHODS OF
the testtaker—such as the presence, PERSONALITY ASSESSMENT
absence, or strength of a personality- Assessees aren’t being directly asked to
related variable disclose information about themselves
Their task is to talk about or depict
ADVANTAGES something else (like inkblots or pictures)
Economical Through such indirect responses the
Relatively simpler to score and administer assessor draws inferences about the
Gives the appearance of objectivity and personality of assessees Minimizing risks
provides higher reliability in personality assessment
DISADVANTAGES The ability and inclination of individuals to
The same score in a test may have fake responses are minimized
several interpretations Reliance on verbal language is limited
Likelihood of faking responses due to the use of other kinds of stimuli
13
Proponents of projective measures argue length of time before responding, position
that a major advantage of such measures of the card etc.
is that they tap unconscious as well as The examiner does not engage in any
conscious material discussion concerning the testtaker’s
o “The most important things about an responses during the initial administration
individual are what he cannot or will of the cards.
not say” –Lawrence K. Frank Every effort is made to provide the
In contrast to methods of personality testtaker with the opportunity to project,
assessment that focused on the individual free from any outside distractions.
from a statistics -based, normative After the entire set of cards has been
perspective, projective techniques were administered once, a second
once the technique of choice for focusing administration, referred to as the inquiry,
on the individual from a purely clinical is conducted.
perspective —a perspective that During the inquiry, the examiner attempts
examined the unique way an individual to determine what features of the inkblot
projects onto an ambiguous stimulus “his played a role in formulating the
way of seeing life, his meanings, testtaker’s percept (perception of an
significances, patterns, and especially his image).
feelings” A third component of the administration,
referred to as testing the limits, may also
INKBLOTS AS PROJECTIVE STIMULI
be included.
THE RORSCHACH If, for example, the testtaker has utilized
Developed by Hermann Rorschach the entire inkblot when forming percepts
“form interpretation test” throughout the test, the examiner might
consists of 10 symmetrical inkblots want to determine if details within the
printed on separate cards inkblot could be elaborated on.
Five inkblots have only shades of gray. Other objectives of limit-testing
Two inkblots are black, white, and red. procedures are
The remaining three inkblots are 1. to identify any confusion or
multicolored. misunderstanding concerning the
The test comes with the cards only; there task,
is no test manual or any administration, 2. to aid the examiner in determining if
scoring, or interpretation instructions the testtaker is able to refocus
The system most widely used is the percepts given a new frame of
“comprehensive system” devised by John reference, and
Ernest Exner, Jr. 3. to see if a testtaker made anxious by
GENERAL ADMINISTRATION: the ambiguous nature of the task is
The inkblot cards are initially presented to better able to perform given this
the testtaker one at a time added structure.
They are then asked a question like In general, Rorschach protocols are
“What must this be?” scored according to several categories,
Testtakers have a great deal of freedom including
with the Rorschach. They may, for o Location - the part of the inkblot
example, rotate the cards and vary the that was utilized in forming the
number and length of their responses to percept
each card o Determinants - the qualities of the
All relevant information are recorded: inkblot that determine what the
verbatim responses, non-verbal gestures, individual perceives, including form,
color, texture, shading, and
movement
14
o Content - the type of object the 2. the clinician’s notes about the way or
individual perceives in the response the manner in which the examinee
o Popularity - the frequency with responded to the cards, and
which a certain response has been 3. the clinician’s notes about extra-test
found to correspond with a particular behavior and verbalizations.
inkblot Interpretation of TAT usually incorporates
o Form - how accurately the Henry Murray’s concepts of need, press,
individual’s perception matches or fits and thema
the corresponding part of the inkblot Need - determinants of behavior arising
from within the individual
PICTURES AS PROJECTIVE STIMULI
Press - determinants of behavior arising
Apperception - the process of making
from within the environment
sense of a current perception by
Thema - a unit of interaction between
assimilating it into previously acquired
needs and press In general, the guiding
ideas and beliefs.
principle in interpreting TAT stories is that
THE THEMATIC APPERCEPTION TEST the testtaker is
(TAT) identifying with someone (the
Developed by Christiana D. Morgan and protagonist) in the story and that
Henry A. Murray • originally designed as the needs, environmental demands, and
an aid to eliciting fantasy material from conflicts of the protagonist in the story
patients in psychoanalysis are in some way related to the concerns,
Consists of 31 cards with one card being hopes, fears, or desires of the examinee.
blank
The 30 picture cards are all printed in
black-and-white, containing a variety of
scenes designed to present the testtaker
with “certain classical human situations”
20 cards is the recommended number for
presentation
• Testtakers are introduced to the
examination with the cover story that it is
a test of imagination in which it is their
task to tell
o what events led up to the scene in
the picture,
o what is happening at that moment,
and
o what the outcome will be.
Testtakers are also asked to describe
what the people depicted in the cards are
thinking and feeling.
If the blank card is administered,
examinees are instructed to imagine that
there is a picture on the card and then
proceed to tell a story about it.
The raw material used in deriving
conclusions about the individual
examined with the TAT are
1. the stories as they were told by the
examinee,
15
WORDS AS PROJECTIVE STIMULI words that attract associative
Projective techniques that employ words disturbances” (e.g., love, girlfriend,
or open-ended phrases and sentences are boyfriend, mother, father, suicide, fire,
referred to as semistructured techniques breast, and masturbation
because, although they allow for a variety
SENTENCE COMPLETION TESTS
of responses, they still provide a
Sentence Completion - a task in which
framework within which the subject must
the assessee is asked to finish an
operate.
incomplete sentence or phrase
Word Association Tests
a semistructured projective technique of
Sentence Completion Tests
personality assessment that involves the
WORD ASSOCIATION TEST presentation of a list of words that begin
Word Association - a task that may be a sentence and the assessee’s task is to
used in personality assessment in which respond by finishing each sentence with
an assessee verbalizes the first word that whatever word or words come to mind.
comes to mind in response to a stimulus
word.
A semistructured, individually
administered, projective technique of
personality assessment that involves the
presentation of a list of stimulus words,
to each of which an assessee responds
verbally or in writing with whatever
comes immediately to mind first upon Sentence completion tests may contain
first exposure to the stimulus word. items that are quite general and
Responses are then analyzed on the basis appropriate for administration in a wide
of content and other variables variety of settings.
Jung (1910) maintained that, by selecting Alternatively, sentence completion stems
certain key words that represented (the part of the sentence completion item
possible areas of conflict, word that is not blank, but must be created by
association techniques could be employed the testtaker) may be developed for use
for psychodiagnostic purposes. in specific types of settings (such as
Jung’s experiments served as an school or business) or for specific
inspiration to the creators of the Word purposes.
Association Test developed by Rapaport
et al. (1945–1946) at the Menninger ROTTER INCOMPLETE SENTENCE
Clinic. BLANK
Word Association Test by Rapaport et al. Testtakers are instructed to respond to
Consisted of 60 words (some were each of the 40 incomplete sentence items
“neutral,” some were characterized as in a way that expresses their “real
“traumatic”) feelings.”
Consisted of three parts: The manual suggests that responses on
o Initial presentation the test be interpreted according to
o Second presentation several categories:
o Inquiry o family attitudes,
Neutral words included: chair, book, o social and sexual attitudes,
water, dance, taxi o general attitudes, and
Trauma-related: “words that are likely o character traits.
to touch upon sensitive personal material
according to clinical experience, and also
16
Each response is evaluated on a seven- Subsequently, many clinicians will ask
point scale that ranges from need for questions about the drawings, such as
therapy to extremely good adjustment
These tests may tap interests, “Tell me a story about that figure,”
educational aspirations, future goals, “Tell me about that boy/girl, man/lady,”
fears, conflicts, needs—just about
anything the testtaker cares to be candid “What is the person doing?”
about. These tests have a high degree of
“How is the person feeling?”
face validity.
Sentence completion tests are perhaps “What is nice or not nice about the
the most vulnerable of all the projective person?”
methods to faking on the part of an
examinee intent on making a good—or a Responses to these questions are used in
bad— impression. forming various hypotheses and
interpretations about personality
THE PRODUCTION OF FIGURE METHODS functioning.
FIGURE DRAWING TESTS
a projective method of personality
assessment whereby the assessee
produces a drawing that is analyzed on
the basis of its content and related
variables.
17
THE CONS AND PROS (OR CONS manuscripts
REBUTTED) OF PROJECTIVE METHODS undergo critical
Lilienfeld et al. Hibbard (2003) in review and may be
(2000) on the Rebuttal selected or rejected
Cons for publication), and
Projective Lilienfeld et al. none of these three
techniques tend not presented an studies are bona
to provide outmoded fide test-retest
incremental validity caricature of reliability studies
above more projection and then With regard to the This assertion is
structured proceeded to attack TAT, there is no incorrect because
measures, as is the it. Dosajh has not point in aggregating “each subunit of an
argument of published on any of scores into a scale aggregated group of
proponents of the the coding systems in the absence of predictors of a
projective targeted for applying internal construct could be
hypothesis as stated criticism. None of consistency unrelated to the
by Dosajh (1996) the authors who reliability criteria. other, but when
developed cod ing found in
systems that were combination, they
attacked espouse a might well predict
view of projection important variance
similar to Dosajh’s. in the construct” (p.
Some of the 264).
criticized authors TAT test-retest “. . . higher retest
have even reliability estimates reliability would
positioned their have been accrue to motive
systems as “notoriously measures if the
nonprojective. problematic” (p. retest instructions
The norms for Evidence is 41). permitted
Exner’s inconclusive as to participants to tell
Comprehensive error in the norms. stories with the
System (CS) are in Observed same content as
error. They may discrepancies may previously” (p. 265).
overpathologize have many Various validity Lilienfeld et al.
normal individuals explanations. studies with (2000)
and may even harm Overpathologization different TAT misinterpreted some
clients may be a result of scoring systems can studies they cited
“drift” similar to that be faulted on and did not cite
observed in the methodological other studies. For
measurement of grounds. example, a number
intelligence (Flynn of relevant validity
effect). studies in support of
There is limited More cross-cultural Cramer’s (1991)
support for the studies do need to Defense Mechanism
generalizability of be done, but the Manual coding
the CS across same could be said system for the TAT
dif ferent cultures for most major were not cited.
tests.
Four studies are Only three of the BEHAVIORAL ASSESSMENT METHODS
cited to support the four studies cited The emphasis in behavioral assessment is
deficiency of the are in refereed on what a person does in situations
test-retest reliability journals (for which rather than on inferences about what
of the CS submitted
18
attributes the person has more globally 13: CLINICAL AND COUNSELING
49 ASSESSMENT
Behavior is the focus of assessment in
behavioral assessment— not traits, CLINICAL AND COUNSELING
PSYCHOLOGY
states, or other constructs presumed to
is the branch of psychology that has as
be present in various strengths—just
its primary focus on the prevention,
behavior.
diagnosis, and treatment of abnormal
Behavioral Observation – this
behaviour
technique involves watching the activities
of targeted clients or research subjects
CLINICAL ASSESSMENT MAY BE
and, typically, maintaining some kind of
UNDERTAKEN FOR VARIOUS REASONS
record of those activities
AND TO ANSWER A VARIETY OF
Self-monitoring – the act of IMPORTANT QUESTIONS:
systematically observing and recording 1. Does this patient have a mental disorder?
aspects of one’s own behavior and/or and If so, what is the diagnosis?
events related to that behavior. Self- 2. What is this person’s current level of
monitoring is different from self-report. functioning? How does this level of
Analog Study – a research investigation functioning compare with that of other
in which one or more variables are similar people of the same age?
or analogous to the real variable that the 3. What type of treatment shall this patient
investigator wishes to examine. be offered?
Situational Performance Measure – a 4. How can this person’s personality best be
procedure that allows for observation and described?
evaluation of an individual under a 5. Which treatment approach is most
standard set of circumstances. (e.g., effective? or What kind of client tends to
leaderless group technique) benefit most from a particular kind of
Role Play – acting an improvised or treatment?
partially improvised part in a simulated
situation THE DIAGNOSIS OF MENTAL
DISORDERS
PSYCHOPHYSIOLOGICAL METHODS
Reference: DSM by the American
Biofeedback – a generic term that may
Psychiatric Association or the ICD of the
be defined broadly as a class of
World Health Organization
psychophysiological assessment
Incidence rate: the rate of new
techniques designed to gauge, display,
occurrences of a particular disorder or
and record a continuous monitoring of
condition in a particular population for a
selected biological processes such as
given timeline
pulse and blood pressure.
Prevalence rate: the proportion of
o Plethysmograph – a biofeedback
individuals in a given population at a
instrument that records changes in
given point in time who have been
the volume of a part of the body
diagnosed or otherwise labeled with a
arising from variations in blood
particular condition or disorder.
supply.
Diagnosis must be weighed between its
o Polygraph – (lie detector) not
advantages and disadvantages
commonly associated with
psychological assessment but is the
BIOPSYCHOSOCIAL ASSESSMENT
best-known of all psychophysiological
is a multidisciplinary approach to
measurement tools
assessment that includes exploration of
relevant biological, psychological, social,
cultural, and environmental variables for
19
the purpose of evaluating how such o Judgment
variables may have contributed to the Regardless of the specific type of
development and maintenance of a interview conducted, certain “standard”
presenting problem. questions are typically raised, during the
initial intake interview, regarding several
THE INTERVIEW IN CLINICAL areas
ASSESSMENT Demographic data: Name, age, sex
TYPES OF INTERVIEWS and gender, religion, family composition,
race and ethnicity, occupation or grade
Stress interview
level in school, relationship status,
Hypnotic interview
socioeconomic status, address, telephone
Cognitive interview
numbers.
Collaborative interview
Reason for referral: Why is this
Mental status examination (MSE)
individual requesting or being sent for
STRESS INTERVIEW psychological assessment? Who is the
objective is to place the interviewee in a referral source?
pressured state for some reason. Past medical history: What events are
significant in this individual’s medical
HYPNOTIC INTERVIEW
history?
conducted while the interviewee is under
Present medical condition: What
hypnosis
current medical issues does this individual
COGNITIVE INTERVIEW have? What medications are currently
rapport is established and the interviewee being used?
is encouraged to use imagery and Familial medical history: What chronic
focused retrieval to recall information. or familial types of disease or other
medical conditions are present in the
COLLABORATIVE INTERVIEW family history?
allows the interviewee wide latitude to Past psychological history: What
interact with the interviewer. traumatic events has this individual
MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION suffered? What psychological problems
used to screen for intellectual, emotional, (such as disorders of mood or disorders
and neurological deficits. of thought content) have troubled this
MSE typically includes questioning or individual?
observation with respect to the following History with medical or
area: psychological professionals: What
o Appearance similar contacts for assessment or
o Behavior intervention has this individual had? Were
o Orientation these contacts satisfactory in the eyes of
o Memory the assessee? If not, why not?
o Sensorium Current psychological conditions:
o Psychomotor activity What psychological problems are
o State of consciousness currently troubling this person? How long
o Affect have these problems persisted? What is
o Mood causing these problems? What are the
o Personality psychological strengths of this individual?
o Thought content
CASE HISTORY DATA
o Thought processes
Biographical and related data about an
o Intellectual resources
assessee may be obtained by
o Insight
20
interviewing the assessee and/or When an interview is conducted in
significant others in that person’s life. preparation for counseling or
Additional sources of case history data psychotherapy, it may be useful to
include hospital records, school records, explore a number of culture-related
military records, employment records, issues.
and related documents. The misspelled ADRESSING (age,
disability, religion, ethnicity, social status,
PSYCHOLOGICAL TESTS sexual orientation, indigenous heritage,
Test battery: a group of tests national origin and gender) is an easy-to-
administered together to gather remember acronym that may help the
information about an individual from a assessor recall various sources of cultural
variety of instruments. influence when assessing clients.
Standard battery: is a group of tests
including one intelligence test, at least SPECIAL APPLICATIONS OF CLINICAL
one personality test, and a test designed MEASURES
to screen for neurological deficit ASSESSMENT OF ADDICTION AND
SUBSTANCE ABUSE
CULTURALLY INFORMED Exploration of personal history with drugs
PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT and alcohol may be accomplished by
an approach to evaluation that is keenly means of questionnaires or face-to-face
perceptive of and responsive to issues of interviews. However, such direct
acculturation, values, identity, worldview, procedures are highly subject to
language, and other culture-related impression management and all the other
variables as they may impact the potential drawbacks of a self-report
evaluation process or the interpretation of instrument.
resulting data.
21
PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT MODULE 10-14
FINALS Goodluck!!!
ELEMENTS OF PSYCHOLOGICAL
REPORT
Demographic data
Reason for referral
Tests administered
Findings
Recommendations
Summary
23
Historically, one variable considered Blank (SVIB), consisted of 420 test items
closely related to occupational fulfillment – by Edward K. Strong Jr. – Test items
and success is personal interests. probe personal preferences in a variety of
It stands to reason that what intrigues, areas such as occupations, school
engages, and engrosses a person would subjects, and activities.
be something good to work at. Newest version (SII Revised Edition
2004) added new items to reflect
THE STRUCTURE OF VOCATIONAL
contemporary career interests such as
INTERESTS
those related to computer hardware,
In the same way that the Big Five has
software, and programming.
emerged as a consensus model of
Respondents answer each of these
personality, Holland’s (1959, 1997)
questions on a five-point continuum that
RIASEC model has been the consensus
ranges from “strongly like” to “strongly
model of vocational interests for many
dislike.”
decades
Six clusters in the classification of broad MEASURES OF ABILITY AND APTITUDE
patterns of interest: Realistic, General mental ability tests predict a
Investigative, Artistic, Social, Enterprising, variety of job performance criteria such
and Conventional (RIASEC) as supervisor ratings, production records,
work sample tests, instructor ratings, and
grades
Although aptitude tests are fairly strong
predictors of on-the-job performance,
fewer employers use them today than
was common in the past
27
PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT MODULE 10-14
FINALS Goodluck!!!
SURVEYS
Surveys
o In consumer psychology, a survey is
a fixed list of questions administered
to a selected sample of persons for
the purpose of learning about
consumers’ attitudes, beliefs,
opinions, and/or behavior with regard
to the targeted products, services, or
advertising.
Poll
o a specialized type of survey
o an instrument to record votes and
usually contains questions that can
be answered with a simple yes/no or
for/against response.
Consumer Panel
o Commercial research firms maintain a
list of a large number of people or
families who have agreed to respond
to questionnaires that are sent to
them. Those included in the list are
also considered to be a part of their
consumer panel
Diary Panel
29