Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Review.
Job Order Project Topic Rev.
I. Table of Contents
1. Introduction………………………………………………….3
1. Introduction
This report is prepared to present our technical review for the SAP model and the connections
design received from H.F.P. (Horizon Fourth Pyramid) regarding the ministry of culture
warehouse in Riyadh. The contractor made some changes to the SAP2000 model which
obligates us to recheck the model and verify the safety, stability and adequacy of the new
model. Also, the connections design as well as the shop drawings shall be reviewed in details.
In the following sections, the review shall be presented.
MOC Warehouse
Job Order Project Topic Rev.
In this section of the report, the model issues shall be shown. After reviewing the model, the following
changes were sighted and were refused for the following reasons:
A) The secondary beams on the edge of the mezzanine cantilevers are UNSAFE in terms of
deflection. Thus, the secondary beams to be changed back to moment connections. The edge
IPE300 shall also be reverted back to IPE270 as per the initial model. The contractor to clarify
why he did such a change?
B) The Beams of the elevator shaft shall be reverted back to moment connections. using shear
connections will induce a leaning effect between the elevator shaft and the main mezzanine
roof which is not preferred in terms of structural vibrations. However, The contractor to clarify
why did he make such a change.
The connections design is received from the contractor as PDF reports and soft copy for the
IDEASTATICA. However, the following issues were sighted.
A) The model needs to be rectified satisfying the requirements presented in the above section.
Then the internal forces to be rechecked by the contractor to cover any impacts on the
straining actions.
B) Buckling check was not run. We need the buckling check to be activated to ensure the stability
of the connections plates as well as the local buckling for the member elements.
Job Order Project Topic Rev.
C) Some connections show obvious clashes. That proves low quality of the submittal. Kindly do
not provide clashing connections details.
Job Order Project Topic Rev.
D) Use Minimum two bolts in any beam connection. This to satisfy the requirements of chapter F
of the AISC360-16.
H) Clear Key Plan shall be provided to link between the design calculations and the submitted
shop drawings.
We are expecting a well-coordinated, complete and clash free package in the next submittal.
Job Order Project Topic Rev.
The shop drawings were thoroughly reviewed and the comments shall be summarized on the
drawings as follows.
GENERAL NOTES:
SUBMITTAL
REV . DATE BY . DESCRIPTION CHKD . APPD .
COORDINATION
PREPARED BY ENGINEERING DEPT . DRAWN BY :
SIGNATURE :
KEY PLAN
REFERENCES
CONTRACT DRAWING
3d SHOP DRAWING
DISCIPLINE :
DRAWING TITLE :
SAL 1
GENERAL NOTES:
GENERAL COMMENTS:
34076.5
7347 7899 5128 5217 5755.5 2084.5 645.5
+10.00
5500
CLARIFY
THE SUBMITTAL
6 M 20 2 M 16
HATCH? REV . DATE BY . DESCRIPTION CHKD . APPD .
2 M 16 2 M 16
2 M 16 6 M 20 14 M 20 2 M 16 14 M 20 2 M 16 14 M 20 2 M 16 14 M 20
6 M 20
8 M 24 2 M 16 2 M 16 6 M 20 2 M 16 8 M 24 2 M 16 2 M 16 6 M 20 6 M 20 8 M 20 6 M 20 2 M 16 2 M 16 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 8 M 24
+4.50
11500
COORDINATION
PREPARED BY ENGINEERING DEPT . DRAWN BY :
2 M 16 PL13*170 L= 2871
6 M 20 6 M 20 2 M 16 6 M 20 6 M 20 2 M 16 2 M 16 6 M 20 2 M 16 CHECKED BY: ARCHITECTURAL STRUCTURAL ELECTRICAL MECHANICAL SECURITY SYSTEM
2 M 16
IPE360 L= 2524 6 M 20 PL13*170 L= 2672 6 M 20 PL13*170 L= 1784 PL13*170 L= 2871 SIGNATURE :
KEY PLAN
HEA240
HEA240
HEA240
HEA240
HEA360
HEA360
D20 D20 D20 D20 D20 D20
D20 D20 D20 D20 D20
0.00
150
550*550
550*550
550*550
550*550
550*550
-1.50
Grid A
REFERENCES
CONTRACT DRAWING
SHOP DRAWING
DISCIPLINE :
DRAWING TITLE :
SAL 1
GENERAL NOTES:
GENERAL COMMENTS:
34076.5
7347 7899 5128 5217 5755.5 2084.5 645.5
+10.00
5500
6 M 20 SUBMITTAL
6 M 20
14 M 20 6 M 20 14 M 20 6 M 20
REV . DATE BY . DESCRIPTION CHKD . APPD .
14 M 20
6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20
6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20
14 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 4 M 20 8 M 24
6 M 20 6 M 20
IPE400 IPE400 IPE360 IPE360 IPE400
+4.50
11500
COORDINATION
6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20
6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20
6 M 20
6 M 20 6 M 20
6 M 20
6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20
PREPARED BY ENGINEERING DEPT . DRAWN BY :
PL14*180 L= 2524 PL14*180 L= 2672 PL13*170 L= 1784 PL13*170 L= 1784 PL14*180 L= 2524 PL14*180 L= 2524
CHECKED BY: ARCHITECTURAL STRUCTURAL ELECTRICAL MECHANICAL SECURITY SYSTEM
HEA240
HEA240
HEA240
HEA360
HEA360
PROJECT MANAGER ENG.MAHMOUD HANAFY
DETAIL AND
D20 D20 D20 D20 D20 D20
0.00 D20 D20 DESIGN. TYP. D20 D20 D20 D20
150
-0.15
D20 D20 D20 D20
D20 D20 D20 D20 D20 D20 D20 D20
1350
550*550
550*550
550*550
550*550
550*550
RIYADH, KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA
-1.50
Grid B
REFERENCES
CONTRACT DRAWING
SHOP DRAWING
DISCIPLINE :
DRAWING TITLE :
SAL 1
GENERAL COMMENTS:
GENERAL NOTES:
34076.5
7347 7899 5128 5217 5755.5 2084.5 645.5
+10.00
5500
SIGNATURE :
HEA240
HEA240
HEA240
HEA240
HEA240
DEPARTMENT HEAD ENG.AHMED ELSHERBINY
KEY PLAN
-0.15
D20 D20 D20 D20 D20 D20 D20 D20 D20 D20
1350
D20 D20
500*500
500*500
500*500
500*500
500*500
500*500
-1.50
MOC Warehouse Project (SAL)
RIYADH, KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA
Grid C
REFERENCES
CONTRACT DRAWING
SHOP DRAWING
DISCIPLINE :
DRAWING TITLE :
SAL 1
GENERAL NOTES:
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
34076.5
4 M 20 7347 7899 5128 5217 5755.5 2084.5 645.5
4 M 20 4 M 20 4 M 20 4 M 20
4 M 20
5950
4 M 20 SUBMITTAL
12000
COORDINATION
PREPARED BY ENGINEERING DEPT . DRAWN BY :
SIGNATURE :
6050
Plan 0.00
REFERENCES
CONTRACT DRAWING
SHOP DRAWING
DISCIPLINE :
DRAWING TITLE :
SAL 1
GENERAL NOTES:
8 8 M 16
7 14 M 20
4 M 20
8 M 16 8 M 16
6 8 M 16
8 M 16
4 M 20
6 M 20 6 M 20
6 M 20 8 M 16
10 M 20
8 M 20 14 M 20
5
14 M 20 8 M 24
6 M 20 4 M 20
6 M 20
6 M 20 4 M 20
6 M 20
4 8 M 20 6 M 20
8 M 20
14 M 20 10 M 20 14 M 20
10 M 20 8 M 24
6 M 20 6 M 20
6 M 20 6 M 20
3 10 M 20
6 M 20
14 M 20
8 M 20 2 M 16
6 M 20 10 M 20 6 M 20 6 M 20 8 M 20 2 M 16
6 M 20 6 M 20 2 M 16
6 M 20 SUBMITTAL
14 M 20 2 M 16 REV . DATE BY . DESCRIPTION CHKD . APPD .
4 M 16 6 M 20 8 M 20
8 M 20 6 M 20 2 M 16
2 8 M 20 10 M 20
6 M 20 8 M 24 6 M 20
10 M 20 14 M 20
14 M 20
6 M 20 COORDINATION
6 M 20 PREPARED BY ENGINEERING DEPT . DRAWN BY :
2 M 16
14 M 20 6 M 20 14 M 20 SIGNATURE :
8 M 20 2 M 16
10 M 20 POSITION NAME SIGNATURE
10 M 16 2 M 16
8 M 20
8 M 24
6 M 20 8 M 20 2 M 16
A 2 M 16
8 M 24
6 M 20
6 M 20 2 M 16 6 M 20
6 M 20
6 M 20
Plan +4.50
REFERENCES
CONTRACT DRAWING
SHOP DRAWING
DISCIPLINE :
DRAWING TITLE :
SAL 1
GENERAL COMMENTS:
GENERAL NOTES:
SHS100*4 SHS100*4
IPE360 SHS100*4 IPE360 IPE360
C IPE360
IPE360
IPE240
IPE300
IPE240
IPE240
IPE240
IPE240
IPE240
IPE240
IPE240
IPE240
IPE200
IPE240
IPE240
IPE240
IPE240
IPE240
IPE240
IPE200
UNLESS VERIFIED BY
IPE240
IPE240
SHS100*4
THE ANALYSIS
5950
IPE200 MODEL.
IPE200
IPE300
IPE240
IPE300
IPE300
IPE200
12000
B SUBMITTAL
REV . DATE BY . DESCRIPTION CHKD . APPD .
IPE270
IPE270
IPE270
IPE270
IPE270
IPE270
IPE270
IPE270
IPE270
IPE270
IPE270
IPE270
IPE270
IPE270
IPE270
IPE270
IPE300
IPE300
IPE300
IPE300
IPE300
COORDINATION
PREPARED BY ENGINEERING DEPT . DRAWN BY :
CONNECTIONS
6050
DEPARTMENT HEAD
NAME SIGNATURE
ENG.AHMED ELSHERBINY
IPE360
IPE360
KEY PLAN
IPE360
IPE360
IPE360
A IPE360
IPE120
IPE120
IPE120
IPE120
IPE120
IPE120
IPE120
IPE120
IPE120
IPE120
IPE120
MOC Warehouse Project (SAL)
IPE120
IPE120
IPE120
IPE120
IPE120
IPE120
IPE360
IPE120
IPE120
IPE120
IPE360
IPE360
RIYADH, KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA
IPE360 IPE360
IPE360
IPE360
IPE270 IPE300
IPE270 IPE270 IPE270
Plan +4.50
REFERENCES
CONTRACT DRAWING
SHOP DRAWING
DISCIPLINE :
DRAWING TITLE :
SAL 1
GENERAL COMMENTS:
GENERAL NOTES:
34076.5
7347 7899 5128 5217 5755.5 2084.5 645.5
C
8 M 16
8 M 16
8 M 16 4 M 16
IPE200 8 M 16
IPE200 IPE200
4 M 16 6 M 16
IPE200
5950
6 M 16 4 M 16
WHERE ARE SHS100*4 8 M 16
THE 4 M 16
IPE200 8 M 16
DIMENSIONS?
8 M 16 SHS100*4 SUBMITTAL
8 M 16 REV . DATE BY . DESCRIPTION CHKD . APPD .
12000
COORDINATION
PREPARED BY ENGINEERING DEPT . DRAWN BY :
SIGNATURE :
KEY PLAN
Plan +10.00
REFERENCES
CONTRACT DRAWING
SHOP DRAWING
DISCIPLINE :
DRAWING TITLE :
SAL 1
GENERAL COMMENTS:
GENERAL NOTES:
12000
6050 5950 12000
+10.00 6050 5950
+10.00
SUBMITTAL
REV . DATE BY . DESCRIPTION CHKD . APPD .
6 M 20 14 M 20 14 M 20 10 M 16 12 M 20
IPE360 IPE360 IPE240 6 M 20 14 M 20 14 M 20 10 M 20 10 M 20 14 M 20
+4.50
IPE360 IPE360 IPE300
+4.50
8 M 24
COORDINATION
L80*8 8 M 24 PREPARED BY ENGINEERING DEPT . DRAWN BY :
L80*8 IPE300 L80*8 CHECKED BY: ARCHITECTURAL STRUCTURAL ELECTRICAL MECHANICAL SECURITY SYSTEM
HEA240
IPE300
HEA240
HEA240
KEY PLAN
0.00
-0.15
0.00
-0.15
MOC Warehouse Project (SAL)
-1.50 RIYADH, KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA
-1.50
Grid 1
Grid 2
REFERENCES
CONTRACT DRAWING
SHOP DRAWING
DISCIPLINE :
DRAWING TITLE :
SAL 1
GENERAL COMMENTS:
GENERAL NOTES:
12000 12000
6050 5950 6050 5950
+10.00 +10.00
6 M 20 14 M 20 14 M 20 10 M 20 10 M 20 14 M 20 8 M 24 14 M 20 10 M 20 10 M 20 14 M 20
14 M 20
IPE360 IPE360 IPE300 IPE360 IPE360 IPE300
+4.50 +4.50 SUBMITTAL
REV . DATE BY . DESCRIPTION CHKD . APPD .
8 M 24 8 M 24
L80*8 6 M 20 L80*8
3 M 16 L80*8 IPE300 L80*8 IPE300
COORDINATION
3 M 16 PREPARED BY ENGINEERING DEPT . DRAWN BY :
ANGLES.
IPE300
ANGLES.
IPE300
HEA240
HEA240
HEA240
HEA240
SIGNATURE :
KEY PLAN
-1.50 -1.50
Grid 3 Grid 4
REFERENCES
CONTRACT DRAWING
SHOP DRAWING
DISCIPLINE :
DRAWING TITLE :
SAL 1
GENERAL COMMENTS:
GENERAL NOTES:
A B C
A B C
12000
12000
6050 5950
6050 5950
+10.00
+10.00
4 M 20 4 M 20
IPE200
5500
5500
4 M 20 4 M 20
SUBMITTAL
REV . DATE BY . DESCRIPTION CHKD . APPD .
4 M 20
14 M 20 8 M 24 14 M 20 10 M 20 10 M 20 14 M 20 8 M 16
2 M 16 6 M 20 6 M 16 8 M 16
IPE120 IPE200
IPE360 IPE360 IPE300
+4.50
11500
11500
3 M 16 COORDINATION
4 M 16 2 M 16 6 M 20 4 M 20
6 M 20 L80*8 8 M 24 PREPARED BY ENGINEERING DEPT . DRAWN BY :
4500
DEPARTMENT HEAD ENG.AHMED ELSHERBINY
HEA360 TECHNICAL MANAGER ENG.AHMED HAMDY OMAR
IPE300
KEY PLAN
0.00
150
-0.15 0.00
150
-0.15
IPE300
IPE300
1350
1350
MOC Warehouse Project (SAL)
RIYADH, KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA
D20 D20 D20
-1.50
-1.50
D20 D20 D20 D20
400*400 D20
400*400
Grid 5 Grid 6
REFERENCES
CONTRACT DRAWING
SHOP DRAWING
DISCIPLINE :
DRAWING TITLE :
SAL 1
GENERAL COMMENTS:
GENERAL NOTES:
12000 12000
6050 5950 6050 5950
+10.00 +10.00
4 M 20 4 M 20
5500
5500
14 M 20 14 M 20 8 M 24 8 M 16 8 M 16 SUBMITTAL
REV . DATE BY . DESCRIPTION CHKD . APPD .
IPE360 IPE360 IPE200
+4.50 +4.50
11500
11500
8 M 16 4 M 20
L80*8
3 M 16 COORDINATION
L80*8
PREPARED BY ENGINEERING DEPT . DRAWN BY :
3 M 16
4500
4500
CHECKED BY: ARCHITECTURAL STRUCTURAL ELECTRICAL MECHANICAL SECURITY SYSTEM
SIGNATURE :
HEA220
DEPARTMENT HEAD ENG.AHMED ELSHERBINY
150
-0.15 -0.15
IPE300
IPE300
D20 D20 D20
1350
1350
D20 D20 D20 D20
400*400
-1.50 -1.50 400*400 400*400 MOC Warehouse Project (SAL)
RIYADH, KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA
D20 D20 D20 D20
Grid 7 Grid 8
REFERENCES
CONTRACT DRAWING
SHOP DRAWING
DISCIPLINE :
DRAWING TITLE :
SAL 1