Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 7
Contraception and Abortion
Lecture Outline
Questions are posed regarding alternatives to birth control pills, including vasectomies,
mifepristone, and male hormonal contraception methods.
I. Hormonal Methods
• Hormonal methods of contraception are highly effective and come in a number of forms:
the pill, the patch, the vaginal ring, and injections.
• Several terms are used in communicating data on the effectiveness of contraceptives:
o Failure rate, or pregnancy rate, is the percentage of women using a particular
contraceptive method who will be pregnant after a year of use.
o Effectiveness is 100 minus the failure rate; thus, a contraceptive with a 5 percent
failure rate is said to be 95 percent effective.
o There are two kinds of failure rate: the failure rate for perfect users and the failure
rate for typical users.
• Combination birth control pills work mainly by preventing ovulation.
o They are one of the most effective methods of birth control.
o The perfect-user failure rate is 0.3 percent (i.e., the method is essentially 100 percent
effective), and the typical-user failure rate is 9 percent.
o Among the serious side effects associated with use of the pill are slight but
significant increases in certain diseases of the circulatory system.
o For women who have taken the pill for more than five years, the risk of benign liver
tumors increases.
o They do not interfere with intercourse, as do some other methods—the condom and
foam. It is not messy.
o Some women experience a brief delay (two or three months) in becoming pregnant
after stopping the pill, but pregnancy rates are about the same as for women who
never took the pill.
o They may increase the metabolism of some drugs, making them more potent.
IM – 7 | 1
II. LARC
• LARC stands for long-acting, reversible contraceptives; it includes implants and IUDs.
• Implants are thin rods or tubes containing progestin. They are inserted under the skin in a
woman’s arm and are effective for three years.
• The intrauterine device (IUD, also called intrauterine contraceptives or IUCs) is a small
piece of plastic and may also contain copper or progestin. An IUD is inserted into the
uterus by a doctor or nurse practitioner and then remains in place until the woman wants to
have it removed. IUDs remain effective for 3 to 12 years, depending on the type.
III. Condoms
• The male condom (“rubber,” “jimmies,” “safe”) is a thin sheath that fits over the penis.
o It may be made of latex (“rubber”), polyurethane, or the intestinal tissue of lambs
(“skin”). Latex and polyurethane are the effective ones.
o The perfect-user failure rate for condoms is about 2 percent. The typical-user failure
rate is about 18 percent, but many failures result from improper or inconsistent use.
o The condom has no side effects, except that some users are allergic to latex.
o A major advantage of condoms is that they provide protection against many sexually
transmitted infections.
• The female condom is made of polyurethane and resembles a clear balloon.
o It works by preventing sperm from entering the vagina and by blocking the entrance
to the uterus.
IM – 7 | 2
• The diaphragm is a circular, dome-shaped piece of thin rubber with a rubber-covered rim
of flexible metal.
o It is inserted into the vagina and, when properly in place, fits snugly over the cervix.
o The typical-user failure rate of the diaphragm has been estimated to be 12 percent.
Most failures are due to improper use.
• FemCap is a vaginal barrier device similar to the diaphragm. It is shaped like a sailor’s cap,
is made of silicone, and comes in three sizes.
• Similar to the diaphragm, the sponge is made up of polyurethane, it is small, and is shaped
like a pillow with a concave dimple on one side.
V. Spermicides
• Contraceptive foams (Delfen, Emko), creams, and jellies are all classified as
spermicides—that is, sperm killers. Most contain nonoxynol-9 (N-9).
• Failure rates for spermicides are high, and spermicide use is not recommended as a birth
control method by itself—only in conjunction with a second method like a condom.
VI. Withdrawal
• In withdrawal, the man withdraws his penis from his partner’s vagina before he has an
orgasm and ejaculates outside the vagina.
o The failure rate is around 22 percent.
• Rhythm (fertility awareness) methods involve abstaining from intercourse around the
time the woman ovulates.
• In the calendar method, the woman determines when she ovulates by keeping a calendar
record of the length of her menstrual cycles.
IM – 7 | 3
VIII. Sterilization
IM – 7 | 4
• Each year in the United States, 600,000 teenagers become pregnant. The great majority of
these unwanted pregnancies occur because sexually active persons fail to use
contraceptives responsibly.
• Factors that experts believe are crucial for teens to be consistent users of contraception
include:
o Access to contraceptives and a belief that one has access
o Knowledge about sexual and reproductive health and contraception
o Strong motivation to use contraception, rather than having excuses such as “it’s too
much of a hassle” or “it interferes with sexual enjoyment.”
• Fantasy may also play an important role in contraceptive behavior. Fantasy is often
influenced by media, which rarely depict contraception or the consequences of failing to
use it.
X. Abortion
IM – 7 | 5
• To deal with the problem of allergies to latex, polyurethane condoms have been developed.
• Male hormonal methods suppress the production of LH and FSH by the pituitary, so that
sperm would not be produced or would not develop properly.
o Unfortunately, many of the hormone preparations that have been tried shut down
sperm production but also shut down the user’s sex drive, making them unacceptable
to most men.
• RISUG is the name for Reversible Inhibition of Sperm Under Guidance, a method that has
been developed mainly in India. It is under trial in the United States.
• Microbicides are substances that kill microbes (bacteria and viruses) and, preferably,
sperm. Experts had hoped that current contraceptive foams and gels, which contain
nonoxynol-9 (N-9), would be effective microbicides, but it turns out that N-9 is ineffective
and may actually make women more vulnerable to infection by irritating the vagina.
• A new pill is being developed that adds an androgen to the combination pill, which will
hopefully address the issue of lowered testosterone levels caused by the combination pill in
some women.
• One company is developing a ring that contains both contraceptive hormones and
tenofovir, an antiretroviral that protects against HIV.
• Research is being conducted on sperm-binding beads that will attack sperm and prevent
them from going after eggs.
• The Reversible, Nonsurgical Sterilization method involves injecting liquid silicone into the
fallopian tubes that hardens and forms a plug.
Lecture Extension
Infanticide as Abortion
Many students misperceive abortion as primarily a contemporary issue and as the only venue to
terminate an unwanted pregnancy. Few consider that infanticide historically has been a very
common means of population control and handling unwanted pregnancies or infant
abnormalities. Females, because of their innate reproductive capacities, generally have been at a
higher risk for such practices than male infants. In ancient Greece and Rome, infants with
IM – 7 | 6
Sources:
Gauthier, D., Chaudoir, N., & Forsythe, C. (2003). A sociological analysis of maternal
infanticide in the United States 1984–1996. Deviant Behavior, 24(4), 393–405.
Milner, L. (1998). A brief history of infanticide. Available online:
www.infanticide.org/history.htm.
Lubricants are used in sexual activity for a variety of reasons. They can increase pleasure when
used with sex toys or when a little extra lubrication is warranted (e.g., when a woman’s vagina is
a little too dry). However, knowing what kinds of lubricant are available is important because
some can be used with contraceptive devices such as condoms and others cannot. Virtually all
lubricants on the market today fall into one of three categories:
• Water-based
• Silicone-based
• Oil-based
Water-based lubricants are just that: water-based. They tend to be fairly thin and are easily
removed from the skin with a little water and soap. Because they are water-based, they tend to be
absorbed into the skin and mucous membranes easily, and if intimate behavior continues for a
significant time, reapplication may be necessary. The main advantage of water-based lubricants
is that they are completely compatible with condoms.
Silicone-based lubricants are similar to water-based lubricants, but they are generally a
lot greasier and last much longer than water-based products. Their main advantage is that there is
virtually no need for reapplication because they do not dry out as quickly as a water-based
IM – 7 | 7
Despite the popularity of the birth control pill, it is important to have detailed knowledge of how
to use it and to know when to use a backup method to prevent pregnancy. If the birth control pill
is your contraceptive choice, read this information for guidelines to help ensure its effectiveness.
1. Start your first pack on the first Sunday after your period begins. If your period begins on
Sunday, start your pills that day.
2. Use a backup method (foam, condoms, sponge) with the pills for the first month.
3. Take a pill every day until you finish a pack, then start a new pack. Do not skip any days
between packs.
4. It is very important to take your pills every day at the same time. If you miss or take any pills
late, you may spot or bleed and should use a backup method until you start the next pack of
pills.
5. If you are late with a pill by 4 hours or more, be sure to use a backup method until you start
the next pack of pills.
6. If you miss one pill, take it as soon as you remember it, then take today’s pill at the regular
time. Use a backup method until you start the next pack of pills.
7. If you miss two pills in a row, take two pills as soon as you remember and two pills the next
day. Example: If you forget pills on Monday and Tuesday, take two pills on Wednesday and
two pills on Thursday to catch up. Use a backup method until you start the next pack of pills.
8. If you miss three pills in a row, start using a backup method right away. Start a new pack of
pills on the next Sunday after the last pill you took. Use your backup method until you finish
the new pack of pills. If you have been sexually active before starting your new pack of pills,
you must wait for your next period before starting. You need to use another form of birth
control for the month and for the next cycle of pills.
9. Missed periods:
o If you have taken all pills correctly and have a very light period or miss a period,
keep taking your pills.
o If you miss two periods in a row, call your health-care provider.
IM – 7 | 8
From the University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics. (2004). Birth control pill fact sheet:
http://www.uihealthcare.com/depts/med/obgyn/patedu/birthcontrol/pillfacts.html
Many people believe that breastfeeding acts as a contraceptive; interestingly, this is found cross-
culturally. The Kung Bushmen of southern Africa believe that breastfeeding delays conception.
In their culture, the space between the births of siblings is about every 4 years, which tends to
support this belief (Shostak, 1991). The Sambia of Papua New Guinea likewise believe that
breastfeeding delays pregnancy. Also, like other groups, they have a postpartum taboo of sexual
activity that lasts for the first 2 years of a child’s life as well as during nursing (Herdt, 2006).
The American Academy of Pediatrics (2011) states that under certain conditions breastfeeding
can be effective in preventing pregnancy. Here are the conditions:
• If you are exclusively breastfeeding.
• If your menstrual periods have not resumed.
• If your baby is less than 6 months old. Once your baby is 6 months old and has begun
sampling solid foods, breastfeeding is no longer a reliable form of birth control.
If you do not want to become pregnant, you will need to consider what kind of contraception you
will use. It’s best to consult your gynecologist for advice on which types to use while
breastfeeding, but in general, condoms, a diaphragm, a cervical cap, and spermicidal are
considered the most preferable forms of birth control for a breastfeeding mother, because they
are least likely to interfere with milk supply. Low-dose birth control pills should not have a
significant impact on your milk supply when begun at this age.
IM – 7 | 9
Despite the wide availability of emergency contraception (EC), many women know little about
it. This may help explain why the incidence of unintended pregnancies in the United States is so
high compared to other nations. Recent studies found that 60–80 percent of pregnancies in
women aged 18–24 were unplanned (Vahratian et al., 2008). And it has been over 10 years since
the FDA approved two different forms of EC: mifepristone (RU-486) and Plan B.
In fact, women have only a general awareness about the existence of EC and approve of
it as a means to prevent unintended pregnancies. They do not know about its effectiveness,
safety, availability, and side effects, however. Also, in findings from previous research, it is clear
that many women don’t know the difference between Plan B and mifepristone, an oral
medication that can induce spontaneous abortion in the first trimester of pregnancy (Hickey,
2009).
It is also clear from these studies that health-care providers have not received adequate
information and counseling about EC. Many women reported that their information about EC
came from friends, peers, or the Internet and that they would be more likely to use EC if a
health-care provider had informed them about it. Women’s knowledge, perceptions, and use of
EC have not been adequately investigated since it became available over-the-counter in 2006
(Hickey, 2009). The research done on EC highlights both the need for health-care professionals
to share their knowledge of available resources and the need for women to be proactive about
their own health care.
Contraception is any method that we use to prevent conception and unintended pregnancy.
Additionally, many contraceptive methods prevent the transmission of STIs. Because
contraception is used to prevent pregnancy, abortion does not fit the definition of contraception.
It may seem obvious, but it is important to underline that only after conception has occurred can
abortion take place. The purpose of contraception is to prevent conception. Abortion is among
the biggest and longest running controversies in all of sexuality in the United States. Abortion is
a painful and personal decision, and none of the groups in the debate over abortion recommend it
as a birth control method. Abortion decisions sometimes come into play late in the process of
pregnancy and may result from a true lack of sexual literacy, including the absence of positive
resources, such as quality health care, that might have resulted in the use of contraceptives in the
first place. Healthy sexuality and sexual well-being depend on understanding these processes.
IM – 7 | 10
How the Pill Works: What three things does the birth control pill do to prevent pregnancy?
What hormonal manipulation is needed for each effect? What state does the pill mimic?
LARC: What does LARC stand for? Why do family planning experts prefer it as a method of
contraception?
Failure Rates: What is the difference between a perfect-use failure rate and a typical-use failure
rate? Which rate is the most useful in evaluating different methods?
Risky Business—Why Couples Fail to Use Protection: Indicate what “costs” are at work to
prevent people from (1) acknowledging contraception, (2) obtaining contraception, and (3)
planning and continuing contraception. Are the anticipated benefits of pregnancy as strong a
factor as the costs in discouraging contraceptive use?
Withdrawal: What is the typical failure rate for withdrawal? What other birth control methods
have similar typical failure rates? Is this surprising news? Why might someone recommend
certain devices but not withdrawal?
Contraception Decisions: Should the use of contraception be a decision that two people—or
one person—make? Does it depend on the relationship involved or the type of sex involved?
The Male Pill: If the male pill were available, do you think it would be popular among men?
What psychosocial barriers might make men reluctant to use it? How might it change the face of
contraceptive use in America?
IM – 7 | 11
Note to the instructor: After a vasectomy, sperm are reabsorbed, just like they are reabsorbed if a
man who has not had a vasectomy does not ejaculate. Sperm comprise less than 1 percent of
semen. The rest of the semen, fluid from the prostate and seminal vesicles, is still ejaculated
during orgasm after men have undergone vasectomy.
Sterilization: Would you ever consider surgical sterilization as your method of birth control?
Why or why not? Might your decision change in the future?
Thinking Sociologically: How has the advent of consistently effective (assuming perfect-user
practices) contraceptives changed the nature of intimate relationships in the past 50 years? What
are the social implications of separating sex and reproduction?
Contraception in the United States Today: In the 19th and early 20th centuries, those who
opposed the use of contraceptives passed federal laws making it illegal even to distribute
information about it. Some people were brave enough to oppose this law despite the threat of
being imprisoned, but believe it or not, that law was not repealed until 1965. In past elections,
this was one of the hot issues. Republicans called women “sluts” for using birth control, argued
that insurance companies shouldn’t have to pay for birth control, and tried to cut funding for
Planned Parenthood. Many felt this constituted a war on women. Based on this, how do you see
the history of contraception in the United States affecting how we think about contraception
today? In what ways do you see contraception and sexual health care changing in the future?
Sex and Popular Culture: How is contraception treated in soap operas, in television, in films,
and in reality shows? Is a connection made between pregnancy and failure to use contraception?
Identify a show that does a good job at discussing contraception. Share myths about
contraception you have heard about or even used, such as douching with Coca-Cola. What might
the appeal be? What impact do these myths have? How can you educate others about their
ineffectiveness? How is abortion handled in television dramas and shows? Are the media pro-life
or pro-choice? Give examples.
Governmental Intervention: What role should the government have in the types of
contraception that are available in this country?
IM – 7 | 12
Russia and Contraception: The former Soviet Union (now Russia) was committed to being a
global superpower, and its domestic policy reflected that in its total lack of support for
contraceptives. Many Russian women during the Soviet era had five or more abortions as a
functional way to cope with the lack of access to condoms and other forms of contraception
(Kon, 1995). Since the fall of the Soviet regime in 1991, abortions have fallen but the abortion
rate in Russia remains very high.
Human Rights: Should men and women continue to be allowed to sue contraceptive
manufacturers when their device causes health problems? What effect has this type of litigation
had on the availability of devices currently on the market?
Health Considerations:
• Imagine that a man or woman comes to you for contraception. They live in different cities
and only see each other one or two weekends a month. How would you help them chose a
contraception method? Consider issues such as cost, reliability, and irregular frequency of
sex.
• Imagine that a man or woman comes to you for contraception. In the course of the
conversation, the person shares that they are bisexual. What form of contraception would
you recommend? Why?
Morality and the Study of Abortion: Because abortion is an emotionally charged issue, many
find it difficult to study scientifically. Approach the issue as objectively as you can, regardless of
your beliefs. Discuss the relationship, if any, between scientific findings and moral stands on
abortion. For example, what is the moral significance, if any, of the empirical findings that most
women express relief following abortion? Does this finding have any bearing on the belief that
abortion is murder?
IM – 7 | 13
Access to Contraception and Abortion Services for Minor Adolescents: The question of
whether contraception should be freely available to adolescents without parental consent has
been a hot topic for years for parents, teachers, health practitioners, and health educators. In fact,
many states allow adolescents to acquire contraceptive care without parental consent. However,
many states do not allow minor adolescents to undergo an abortion without the consent of a
parent or legal guardian. It appears that even though many lawmakers agree that minors should
have privacy for contraceptive care, they want parents involved in an adolescent’s decision about
abortion. The question we consider, then, is this: Should minor adolescents have access to
contraceptive and abortion services without parental consent? How might we strike a balance
between parents’ desires to be involved in their minor teen’s health care while ensuring safe
options for sexual health care for them?
Bodily Autonomy: Many pro-choice advocates argue that a woman has a right to control her
own body. Right-to-life advocates often disagree. In a case of life or death, is an American
citizen forced to donate blood? An organ? If a person dies and a doctor could save a life by
harvesting an organ, is it ethical from the doctor’s perspective? If yes, under what conditions is it
ethical? Does the heavy emphasis on bodily autonomy, even when a life or death situation is
involved, support a pro-choice view?
A Rock and a Hard Place: Pro-choice groups opposed legislation that would allow people who
hurt pregnant women and kill the fetus to be prosecuted for murder. Why did the pro-
choice/right-to-life debate put choice advocates in such a sticky situation?
Kinds of Abortion: What percentage of abortions are done in the first 14 weeks of pregnancy?
What kind of abortion is done in this case? Is this contrary to the picture of the “typical abortion”
that is highlighted by right-to-life groups? How is it different? How do the statistics affect the
right-to-life argument, if at all?
Abortion in Greece: How have abortion rates in Greece been affected by the country’s
pronatalist culture, which provides little support for contraceptive use? How have doctors’
interests played into it? How has the media participated? If we think about abortion in America
in these terms, can we come to any interesting insights?
IM – 7 | 14
Polling Questions
How many of you use birth control? Do you think use of birth control connotes that you are
“easy” or a “slut”? Do you think that birth control should be available over the counter?
The question of whether contraception should be freely available to adolescents without parental
consent has been a hot topic for years for parents, teachers, health practitioners, and health
educators. In fact, many states allow adolescents to acquire contraceptive care without parental
consent.
1. Do you believe that teenagers should have access to contraceptive care without parental
consent? What about access to abortion services?
2. Do you believe that granting teenagers confidential contraceptive and reproductive care
encourages sexual activity and promiscuity?
Activities
Note to the instructor: Any classroom activity requires careful ethical reflection by the instructor
before assigning the exercise. Some of these principles parallel those in human subject research.
Students should have a basic right to privacy about their own sexuality. They should not be
coerced into revealing private information if it is identifiable.
Condom Buying: Require each student to purchase/acquire a condom. This can be at the local
drug store, bathroom vending machine, or through a local clinic such as Planned Parenthood. In a
one-page, anonymous response paper, ask them to briefly describe the experience and their
feelings about doing so. (You may have them write their name on a cover sheet that is removed
IM – 7 | 15
Using a Condom: Bring condoms to class and a demonstration device. Ask one or more students
to demonstrate how to put on and take off a condom properly. After one student has
demonstrated, ask the other students to point out any details the demonstrator may have
forgotten. Ask other students to demonstrate until the demonstration is perfect.
Condom Commercials: Divide your class into small discussion groups to produce their own
condom commercial. You could have them present short commercials using humor or some
other device regularly used by advertisers (e.g., emotional appeals such as fear or guilt,
eroticism, romance, appeals to masculinity or femininity). Try assigning each group a target
audience. Among the potential targets are gays, lesbians, heterosexual college students, single
career men or women, and married couples.
Contraceptive Risk Taking: Ask students, if they are (or have been) involved in sexual
intercourse, to indicate anonymously on 3 × 5 cards the last time that they did not use
contraception. Ask them to describe why. If students have not been involved in sexual
intercourse, ask them to indicate factors that might discourage them from using contraception.
Randomly distribute the cards and have students discuss these factors and the implications for
education and prevention.
Choosing and Acquiring a Contraceptive Method: Have students complete Handout 1: Facts
About Contraception and Handout 2: Which Contraceptive Method Is Right for You and Your
Partner? Discuss in small groups the reasoning behind choosing the best method for yourself and
your partner. Does the length or type of relationship matter? Individual reflection: If you are not
currently using or inconsistently using contraception, what steps will you take tomorrow to
insure your health and contraceptive planning?
The Cooperative Classroom and Contraception: Have students form groups and assign each
group a particular contraceptive method. Ask the groups to outline the salient points of each
method, such as effectiveness, ease of use, cost, reversibility, etc., during the next class meeting.
Request that they bring a photo or physical example of the contraceptive device.
IM – 7 | 16
Note to the instructor: Some of the surprises you might encounter include: how similar the
failure rate of withdrawal is to some contraceptive methods, the failure rate of condoms (which
are commonly used by students), and the big jump in effectiveness that begins with hormonal
contraception and LARC. In conducting this exercise, you need to decide whether you will go
with typical-user failure rates or perfect-user failure rates. The order of effectiveness will be
different depending on which you choose. This also provides a teachable moment in which you
can emphasize the importance of being a perfect user.
STI Protection: Have the class brainstorm a list of all the contraceptive methods that also offer
some protection against STIs. How much STI protection does each option offer? Is the list long
or short? Why might that be the case?
Note to the instructor: The male condom is the obvious choice; however, make sure to point out
female condoms and the newly developed microbicides.
Contraceptives Hands-On: Buy or borrow a contraceptive kit with an example of each of the
commonly used contraceptives available in America today. Many students have never seen or
handled most birth control options. Demonstrate the use of and pass around each device as a way
to stimulate interest in and discussion about each method.
Campus Contraception Resources: Check with your campus student’s services or student
health to enquire if they do lectures for classes on campus on contraception use. Many campuses
not only talk about contraception but also provide free condoms, lube, and dental dams to
students. Check with student health services to see if they can come to your class and
demonstrate proper use of contraception.
IM – 7 | 17
Pros and Cons of the Pill: The birth control pill is one of the most common contraceptives used
by college-age women. Have the class brainstorm a list of advantages and disadvantages of the
pill. Which of these pros and cons are most salient to the typical college student. Why?
Why People Don’t Use Birth Control: First, split the class into small groups. Have each group
create a list of reasons why students don’t use birth control, and rank the reasons from the most
frequent or likely reason to the least likely. Have the groups share their conclusions with each
other. Next, return to the small groups and have each group create a list of strategies to improve
the rate of birth control use on campus.
Note to the instructor: Make sure that the following points come out: double standard,
ambivalence about sexuality, inability of people to admit their sexual activity, belief that it is the
other person’s responsibility, lack of communication, lack of availability of contraceptives,
concern over health risks, spontaneity, and lack of information.
Marketing the Male Pill: Imagine that a pharmaceutical company has developed a male pill and
that it has been approved by the FDA. Assign your students the job of marketing executive. As
homework, ask them to design (in groups or as individuals) a marketing slogan, campaign, or
commercial for the male pill. Present the ideas in class.
Male and Female Sterilization: Encourage students to compare and contrast issues of
invasiveness and reversibility of sterilization by gender. Which option is most common? Discuss
the psychosocial factors that make vasectomy a daunting prospect for many men.
Critical Thinking—Probability: The critical thinking skill for this chapter is understanding the
concept of probability. Read the following brief scenario to students and ask them to identify
how the concept of probability should play a role in Marisol’s decision.
Marisol is a 21-year-old college student and it is very important to her that she finish
college and get her degree in journalism. She and her boyfriend Arcadio enjoy sexual
intercourse about 3 or 4 times a week. They have been using a condom for birth control,
but Marisol thinks that she needs to start using a more effective method. She is trying to
decide between the IUD, the birth control pill, and rhythm. What should she choose?
Access to Contraception and Abortion Services for Minor Adolescents: It appears that even
though many lawmakers agree that minors should have privacy for contraceptive care, they want
IM – 7 | 18
Yes:
• Allowing minor teenagers access to contraception may help decrease the number of
unintended pregnancies that occur every year in the United States.
• Granting access to contraception allows teens to be proactive in their sexual health and can
have the effect of preventing abortions.
• Minors may not seek health services if they are required to inform their parents (Dailard &
Richardson, 2005).
• Allowing minor teenagers the right to have an abortion without parental consent may mean
they can have an abortion earlier in the pregnancy, which poses less serious risks to their
reproductive health, for two reasons:
o They may detect pregnancy earlier than they currently do.
o They may face fewer legal obstacles earlier in the pregnancy.
• Forcing minor teens to inform parents that they are seeking an abortion may place some at
risk of physical violence or abuse (Dailard & Richardson, 2005).
No:
• Teens with access to birth control think they have a ticket for sexual freedom.
• Many parents believe that they need to retain the legal authority to make medical decisions
for their minor teens because teens often lack the maturity and judgment to make fully
informed decisions (Dailard & Richardson, 2005).
• Laws requiring parental consent or knowledge reduce abortion and pregnancy rates among
teenagers for two reasons:
o If parents are able to guide their pregnant teens, more would choose childbirth (and
potentially adoption) over abortion.
o Teenagers who have to inform parents about a pregnancy to obtain an abortion will
think twice before having sex in the first place (Dailard & Richardson, 2005).
You can then assign students to write a brief paragraph describing their perspective.
1. Do you believe that teenagers should have access to contraceptive care without parental
consent? What about access to abortion services?
2. Do you believe that granting teenagers confidential contraceptive and reproductive care
encourages sexual activity and promiscuity?
3. How might we strike a balance between parents’ desires to be involved in their minor teen’s
health care while ensuring safe options for sexual health care for them?
IM – 7 | 19
IM – 7 | 20
Ask students: Did you previously believe any of these myths? Which ones did you have incorrect
information about? Myths about birth control are common, and it is easy to believe something
that we hear from media or from peers. It is important to make sure that we use trusted resources
when considering any form of contraception to make sure we understand the method fully so we
can use it correctly.
Internet Activity: Contraception Education in School: Should schools teach students about
contraception? Should schools distribute or make available condoms to students? Have students
find a website that presents material on this subject and answer the following questions:
• What elements would you want to see included in a school curriculum? Why?
• At what age would you recommend students learn about contraception? Why?
• What contraceptives, if any, should be available at schools? Why?
IM – 7 | 21
Taking Action: In coordination with campus productions of Vagina Monologues and your
campus heath center, provide a series of peer-led workshops on contraception.
Guest Speakers/Panels:
• Invite a health-care worker from the college health clinic or local Planned Parenthood to
demonstrate on a pelvic model and discuss birth control methods and services available in
your community.
• Invite a panel of females and males to discuss their personal experiences with abortion,
focusing on the decision-making process, their feelings, and consequences. (The panel may
come from the student health service, Planned Parenthood, or other reproductive health
organizations that tend to emphasize positive outcomes. To achieve balance, you might
also try Birthright or conservative religious groups, which oppose abortion; they tend to
emphasize negative outcomes for women.)
The Story of Rebecca Bell: Pass out and discuss Handout 5: The Story of Rebecca Bell. See the
critical thinking questions on the handout.
Scavenger Hunt: Medical abortion (long known as RU-486 and marketed as Mifeprex) is
available in the United States. What is this treatment and what is it designed to do? How does it
work? What is the controversy surrounding its use? Would you consider the use of this drug
IM – 7 | 22
Suggested Media
After Tiller (2013; PG-13; 1 hr 28 min). Documentary that interviews the only doctors in the
United States willing to perform third-trimester abortions.
Grandma (2015; R; 1 hr 19 min). Temporarily broke, Grandma Elle and granddaughter Sage
spend the day trying to procure funds for Sage’s abortion; looks at abortion through a
contemporary, yet cross-generational lens.
IM – 7 | 23
The Operation: Vasectomy/Tubal Ligation (1994, 58 min, VHS, Films for the Humanities).
One out of four American families chooses a vasectomy or laparoscopic tubal ligation—
currently our most reliable forms of birth control. This video shows the actual surgical
procedures being performed.
When Abortion Was Illegal: Untold Stories (1992; 57 min). Award-winning, independent short
film that discusses abortion laws and experiences prior to Roe v. Wade.
Internet Resources
APA
http://www.apa.org/
IM – 7 | 24
Bedsider
http://bedsider.org
Operated by The National Campaign to Prevent Teen and Unplanned Pregnancy, this site
exclusively focuses on birth control with articles, interviews, resources, and reminders. The site
includes informational and testimonial videos about contraceptives.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Reproductive Health Information Source
http://www.cdc.gov/reproductivehealth/index.htm
Provides information, research, and scientific reports on men’s and women’s reproductive health.
FDA
http://www.fda.gov/ForConsumers/ConsumerUpdates/default.htm
Offers current research on various forms of birth control including methods that have been
recalled for various problems.
IM – 7 | 25
Population Council
http://www.popcouncil.org
An international, nonprofit, nongovernmental organization that conducts biomedical, social
science, and public health research on such topics as family planning, contraceptive
development, and abortion.
Planned Parenthood
http://www.plannedparenthood.org/
This website contains extensive information on many different issues about contraception, birth
control, sexual health, and other issues regarding planning parenthood.
Power to Decide
https://powertodecide.org
IM – 7 | 26
Bancroft, J., & Sartorius, N. (1990). The effects of oral contraceptives on well-being and
sexuality. Oxford Review of Reproductive Biology, 12, 57–92.
Battaglia, C., Battaglia, B., Mancini, F., Busacchi, P., Paganotto, M. C., Morotti, E., & Venturoli,
S. (2012). Sexual behavior and oral contraception: A pilot study. Journal of Sexual
Medicine, 9(2), 550–557.
Bearak, J. M., & Jones, R. K. (2017). Did contraceptive use patterns change after the Affordable
Care Act? A descriptive analysis. Women’s Health Issues, 27(3), 316–321.
doi:10.1016/j.whi.2017.01.006.
Birnbaum, S., Birnbaum, G. E., & Ein-Dor, T. (2017). Can contraceptive pill affect future
offspring’s health? The implications of using hormonal birth control for human evolution.
Evolutionary Psychological Science, 3(2), 89–96.
Burrows, L. J., Basha, M., & Goldstein, A. T. (2012). The effects of hormonal contraceptives on
female sexuality: A review. Journal of Sexual Medicine, 9(9), 2213–2223.
doi:10.1111/j.1743-6109.2012.02848.x.
Guttmacher Institute. (2018). Insurance coverage of contraceptives. State Laws and Policies,
New York: Guttmacher Institute, https://www.guttmacher.org/state-
policy/explore/insurance-coverage-contraceptives.
Lindberg, L., Santelli, J., & Desai, S. (2016). Understanding the decline in adolescent fertility in
the United States, 2007–2012. Journal of Adolescent Health, 59(5), 577–583.
doi:10.1016/j.jadohealth.2016.06.024.
Mathlouthi, N., Jarraya, M., Bengharbi, A., Dhouib, M., Chaabene, K., Trabelsi, I., . . .
Guermazi, M. (2013). Impact de la pilule oestroprogrestative sur la sexualité: étude
prospective à propos de 85 cas [Sexuality and contraception: A prospective study of 85
cases]. La Tunisie Médicale, 91(3), 179–182.
Pastor, Z., Holla, K., & Chmel, R. (2013). The influence of combined oral contraception on
female sexual desire: A systematic review. European Journal of Contraception and
Reproductive Health Care, 18(1), 27–43. doi:10.3109/13625187.2012.728643.
Schaffir, J. A., Isley, M. M., & Woodward, M. (2010). Oral contraceptives vs injectable
progestin in their effect on sexual behavior. American Journal of Obstetrics and
Gynecology, 203(6), 545e1–545.e5. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2010.07.024.
Sonfield, A. (2017). Why family planning policy and practice must guarantee a true choice of
contraceptive methods. Guttmacher Policy Review, 20, 103–107.
IM – 7 | 27
IM – 7 | 28
To help you choose the best method of contraception for you and your partner, you both must
first be familiar with the advantages, disadvantages, and effectiveness ratings of the different
methods. Fill in the space below with the appropriate comments, using your text if necessary. If
you are currently sexually active, consider sharing this activity with your partner.
Oral contraceptives
Implants
Injectable
contraceptives
IUD
Male condom
Female condom
Diaphragm with
spermicide
IM – 7 | 29
Cervical cap
Contraceptive sponge
Spermicides
Fertility awareness
Withdrawal
Male sterilization
Female sterilization
Emergency contraception
IM – 7 | 30
If you are sexually active, you need to use the contraceptive method that will work best for you.
A number of factors may be involved in your decision. The following questions will help you
sort out these factors and choose an appropriate method. Answer yes (Y) or no (N) for each
statement as it applies to you and, if appropriate, your partner.
____ 1. I like sexual spontaneity and don’t want to be bothered with contraception at the time of
sexual intercourse.
____ 2. I need a contraceptive immediately.
____ 3. It is very important that I do not become pregnant now.
____ 4. I want a contraceptive method that will protect me and my partner against sexually
transmitted diseases.
____ 5. I prefer a contraceptive method that requires the cooperation and involvement of both
partners.
____ 6. I have sexual intercourse frequently.
____ 7. I have sexual intercourse infrequently.
____ 8. I am forgetful or have a variable daily routine.
____ 9. I have more than one sexual partner.
____ 10. I have heavy periods with cramps.
____ 11. I prefer a method that requires little or no action or bother on my part.
____ 12. I am a nursing mother.
____ 13. I want the option of conceiving immediately after discontinuing contraception.
____ 14. I want a contraceptive method with few or no side effects.
IM – 7 | 31
If you answered “yes” to the statements listed on the left, the method on the right might be a
good choice for you.
1, 3, 6, 10, 11 Oral contraceptives
1, 3, 6, 8, 10, 11 Implants
1, 3, 6, 8, 10, 11, 12 Injectable contraceptives
1, 3, 6, 8, 11, 12, 13 IUD
2, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 12, 13, 14 Condoms (male and female)
5, 7, 12, 13, 14 Diaphragm and spermicide
5, 7, 12, 13, 14 Cervical cap
2, 5, 7, 8, 12, 13, 14 Spermicides
5, 7, 13, 14 Fertility awareness methods
Your answers may indicate that more than one method would be appropriate for you. To help
narrow your choices, circle the numbers of the statements that are most important for you. Before
you make a final choice, talk with your partner(s) and your physician. Consider your own
lifestyle and preferences as well as characteristics of each method (effectiveness, side effects,
costs, and so on). For maximum protection against pregnancy and STDs, you might want to
consider combining two methods.
IM – 7 | 32
Please write an answer to each question. Do not write your name on the survey.
1. As you were growing up, did your parents share their opinion on abortion with you? What
did they say about it?
2. Did you accept your parents’ view of abortion at the time? Do you still? If not, what made
you change your mind? If you still agree with your parents, what have you learned, since,
that has made you more confident in their view?
3. Have you ever known anyone (including yourself) who experienced an unintended
pregnancy? If yes, what decision did she make? Do you think it was the right one for her?
Did she share her reasoning with you? What was her thought process?
4. Do you feel that abortion should be legal under any circumstances, legal under some
circumstances, or always illegal? Why? If you think abortion should be restricted, what
restrictions would you recommend? Why?
5. Should abortion be legal or illegal if there is a possibility the baby will have a serious birth
defect? If the woman’s life is endangered by the pregnancy? If the pregnancy is the result of
rape or incest?
6. Should abortion be legal or illegal if the parents don’t want a child? If the woman’s health
would be impaired by pregnancy or childbirth? If the woman is not married? If a woman
can’t afford a(nother) child?
IM – 7 | 33
Each of the following statements suggests that one or more contraceptives would be a poor
choice. For each, think of at least one method of birth control that should NOT be recommended.
6. Although you aren’t ready for a baby, you would never have an abortion.
9. You don’t want a method that will interfere with the mood.
13. You’ve never reached inside your (or your partner’s) vagina, and you’d rather not.
14. Your partner does not want you to use birth control.
IM – 7 | 34
IM – 7 | 35
Some girls tell their parents, usually their mothers, before they have an abortion. But some girls,
such as Rebecca Bell, do not. In 1988, Rebecca was a 17-year-old Indiana teenager. She died
from an illegal abortion. Her state required written parental notification for a minor to receive an
abortion, but Rebecca did not want her parents to know about her pregnancy. She could have
used the judicial-bypass provision in the law, but she was told that the judge was anti-choice. She
could have traveled to the next state, Kentucky, but she had no transportation. No one knows
what Rebecca did to attempt abortion, but she died from her attempt, as did hundreds of
thousands of American women before abortion was made safe and legal in 1973.
Should the risk that women will die from abortions they attempt themselves or illegal abortions
play a part in the debate over its legality? Similarly, are outcomes such as the one above a reason
for making abortions more accessible for minors? Should teenagers be able to get abortions
without their parents’ knowledge? Do women have the right to an abortion that is cheap and
easily accessible? Explain your answers.
IM – 7 | 36