SENEG PROPJECT ENGINEER'S COMMENT SHEET SENEG PROPJECT ENGINEER'S COMMENT SHEET SENEG PROPJECT ENGINEER'S COMMENT SHEET

To Mr. Kwan Woo Kim E-mail: apollo@hyosung.com To Mr. Kwan Woo Kim E-mail: apollo@hyosung.com
To Mr. Mohammed Shikur E-mail: nebil218@gmail.com CC Mr. Mohammed Shikur E-mail: nebil218@gmail.com CC Mr. Mohammed Shikur E-mail: nebil218@gmail.com
Transmittal Sheet Title: [HS-EEP-TRE-TEC-001]Submit the Protection and Metering 132kV Single line diagram Transmittal Sheet Title: Protection and Metering 230kV Single Line Diagram Transmittal Sheet Title: Protection and Metering Single Line Diagram
Revision A Revision B Revision C
[HS-EEP-TRE-E0001] Transmittal; [HS-EEP-TRE-TEC-001] Submit the protection and Attachment 11. [HS-EEP-TRE-E0397] Transmittal; Attachment 10. [HS-EEP-TRE-E0397] Transmittal;
metering 132kV; Attachment 12. EEP-SENEG-AM2-SS-02- Attachment 11. EEP-SENEG-AM2-SS-02-
Attachment 1. EEP-SENEG-AM1-SS-02-SL01_A_Protection and Metering 132kV; SL01_C_Protection and Metering 230kV Single Line SL01_C_Protection and Metering Single Line Diagram; [HS-
Attachment 2. EEP-SENEG-AM2-SS-02-SL01_A_Protection and Metering 230kV; Diagram; [HS-EEP-TRE-TEC-0200] Document EEP-TRE-TEC-0325] Document submission for approval;
Attachment 3. EEP-SENEG-AM2-SS-02-SL02_A_Protection and Metering 132kV; submission for approval; Attachment 13. CS-TRE- Attachment 12. CS-TRE-E0397-Rev.C; Attachment 13. CS-
Attachment 4. EEP-SENEG-AM2-SS-03-SL01_A_Protection and Metering 33kV; E0001,E0393 to E0403 TRE-E0397-Rev.C [OLD E0410]; Attachment 14. CS-TRE-
Attachment 5. EEP-SENEG-AM2-SS-03-SL02_A_Protection and Metering 15kV; E0397-Rev.C [OLD E0411]; Attachment 15. CS-TRE-
Document submitted contains Document submitted contains Document submitted contains
Attachment 6. EEP-SENEG-SH-SS-02-SL01_A_Protection and Metering 230kV; E0397-Rev.C [OLD E0412]
Attachment 7. EEP-SENEG-SH-SS-02-SL02_A_Protection and Metering 132kV;
Attachment 8. EEP-SENEG-SH-SS-03-SL01_A_Protection and Metering 33kV;
Attachment 9. EEP-SENEG-TI-SS-02-SL01_A_Protection and Metering 132kV;
Attachment 10. EEP-SENEG-TI-SS-03-SL01_A_Protection and Metering 33kV;
Attachment 11. EEP-SENEG-WS2-SS-02-SL01_A_Protection and Metering 400kV;
Attachment 12. EEP-SENEG-WS2-SS-03-SL01_A_Protection and Metering 230kV
This Document is Submittted for For Approval This Document is Submittted for For Approval This Document is Submittted for For Approval
Hyosung headed letter No. HS-EEP-TRE-TEC-0200 Hyosung headed letter No. HS-EEP-TRE-TEC-0325
Document No. EEP-SENEG-AM2-SS-02-SL01 Document No. EEP-SENEG-AM2-SS-02-SL01

Transmittal Sheet No.(Old): HS/EEP/TRE/E0397/E0410/E0411/E0412

Transmittal Sheet No.HS-EEP-TRE-TEC-001 Comment Sheet No.: 001 Rev A Transmittal Sheet No.(New): HS/EEP/TRE/E0397 Comment Sheet No.: 0397 Rev B Transmittal Sheet No.(New): HS/EEP/TRE/E0397 Comment Sheet No.: 0397 Rev C
Transmittal Date: 27 Dec. 2022 Date:04 Jan. 2023 Transmittal Date: 26 May. 2023 Date:30 May. 2023 Transmittal Date: 19 Jul. 2023 Comment Date: 27 Jul. 2023
Receipt Date: 27 Dec. 2022 No of pages: 2 Receipt Date: 26 May. 2023 No of pages: 2 Receipt Date: 19 Jul. 2023 No of pages: 2
So. No Engineer's Comment Sheet 001 Rev. A So. No Contractor's Response Engineer's Comment Sheet 0397 Rev. B So. No Contractor's Response Engineer's Comment Sheet 0397 Rev. C
1 1 Transmittal title will be revised to suitable for all the 1
The title says 132kV single line diagram but the document is for all the substion. Correct the title. substations in next submission.
2 Attachment 1. EEP-SENEG-AM1-SS-02-SL01_A_Protection and Metering 132kV 2 2
2.1 2.1 As per site survey collected information, there is no busbar 2.1
Please check if Arbaminch-I SS has bus bar differential relay. If Arbaminch-I substation has bus bar differential relay it
differential protection relay utilized in the Arba Minch-I
should be provided for the extension.
substation.
3 General Comments 3 3
3.1 3.1 We confirm that all the Protection and Metering Devices meet As requested by client through its letter of Dec.28.2022, 3.1 We will submit the proposal for EEP review and approval. The
EEP's cyber security requirement submitted by EEP to please submit entire necessary proposal.Due to issues proposal will include Teleprotection compliance with Telecom
Hyosung dated Dec.28.2022. connected with Tele protection the relevant protection OTN, and Cyber Security compliance as introduced in EEP
Please confirm all the Protection and Metering devices meet EEP's cyber security requirement submmitted by EEP to The Cyber security is not the part of actual Contract should be compliant with the OTN to be introduced by requirement.
Hyosung dated Dec.28.2022. Document and taken as additional requirement which will be EEP. Thsese proposal requirements will also be mentioned in Notes of
applied after signing of the amendment. the Protection and Metering Single Line Diagrams.

3.2 3.2 The Protection and Metering (P&M) panel list comprising of Deviation from provisions from the contract agreement 3.2 We confirmed that the protection and metering panels shown on
all the protection and metering panels for 5 substations has should be notified and approval of the same be obtained. the drawings are in compliance with the contents as specified in
been included in Panel Arrangement drawings of each contract agreement.
The protection and metering panels and the contents shall be as specified in the contract agreement.
Substation EEP-SENEG-TI-SS-72-LO01, SH-SS-72-LO01,
WS2-SS-72-LO01, AM2-SS-72-LO01 and AM1-SS-72- We will provide the deviation list from provision of the Panel
LO01 as per MDR. Tagging mentioned in the Contract agreement.
3.3 All protection relay and meters functions shall be as specified in the contract agreement. The detail
3.3 Please referoftothe
theequipment willitem
response on be submitted
3.2. separately once 3.3
3.4 3.4 The revised protection and metering diagrams will adhere to 3.4
Relays are fed current from Current Transformers. In connection with their rated ratios & bus bar rating there are issues
the final single line diagrams regarding CT ratios and bus bar
commented in the single line diagram. Please clear all comments given for the single line diagrams.
rating.
3.5 3.5 Confirmed we will submit the related technical data sheets 3.5 The protection relay vendor and protection relays have been
The technical data parameters are to be approved by submitting the respective technical data of each relay and metering Please get approval for the protection relay vendor and
once the vendor approval process will be completed. approved by EEP vide letter Ref # TSPO-I PM-II/093/23.
device in the single line diagram. protection relays.

3.6 3.6 The drawings were prepared in reference with the EEP past
project as reference named as " Plant Design, Supply and
Installation of Sululta-Gebre Guracha Power Transmission
Project" and we followed the same pattern.
Please kindly be noted that each single protection and
For a single substation some of the connections are running from one page to the other. Complete the single line diagram
metering diagram already adopted A2 size drawing border
on one page for every substaiotn. Use A1 or A0 paper size as required.
and was fully filled. By using A0 or A1 Size drawing borders,
will not be possible to show all contents of the drawings. So it
is recommended to keep current design of using A2 drawing
border.
It is customary to use good practices from previous 3.6 We agreed to show One Substation Protection and metering
projects but this piece wise presentation(divding it into Schemes of all voltages on multiple pages in one drawing.
230kV, 132kV, 33kV etc) of protection and metering
scheme of a single substatin is not good practice and it is
not acceptted. Engineer keeps on adivsing to submit
complete protection and metering scheme for the
complete substation as a single file on one page or if this
is reasonably difficult due to too much congestion, at least
on multiple pages.

3.7 Please get approval for the short ciruit study. 3.7 The short Circuit Study documents for all substations has
been submitted for approval. For all the parameters regarding
the short circuit ratings, we will follow the final approved
short circuit study.
4 Protection coordination & selectivity study
4.1
3.7
4
As per clause A3.22.2 of the contract agreement, the 4.1 We will submit Relay Setting Calculations for each Substation as
Contractor shall prepare relay settings, protection co- per MDR, and the relay setting documents are separate documents
ordination and selectivity studies supported by design from P&M SLDs.
calculations for all protective equipment being supplied
and for associated substations existing protection systems,
and submit for review three (3) months before the site
commissioning tests begins;

Status - RAR - Revise and Resubmit Status - RAR - Revise and Resubmit Status - AP - Approved
Yours sincerely, Yours sincerely, Yours sincerely,

Sin je, Cho / Team Leader Sin je, Cho / Team Leader Sin je, Cho / Team Leader
SENEG Project Consultant SENEG Project Consultant SENEG Project Consultant
Byucksan Power Co., Ltd. Byucksan Power Co., Ltd. Byucksan Power Co., Ltd.
NOTES: NOTES: NOTES:
1. Contractor shall provide his response within 07 days from the date he receives this form. 1. Contractor shall provide his response within 07 days from the date he receives this form. 1. Contractor shall provide his response within 07 days from the date he receives this form.
2. The comments provided in this transmittal shall not relieve the Contractor of any of its obligations to meet all the requirements 2. The comments provided in this transmittal shall not relieve the Contractor of any of its obligations to meet all the requirements 2. The comments provided in this transmittal shall not relieve the Contractor of any of its obligations to meet all the requirements of the
of the Contract or relieve the Contractor/Vendor of the of the Contract or relieve the Contractor/Vendor of the Contract or relieve the Contractor/Vendor of the
Responsibility for the correctness of his drawings/documents. The Contractor/Vendor shall make any changes that are necessary to Responsibility for the correctness of his drawings/documents. The Contractor/Vendor shall make any changes that are necessary to Responsibility for the correctness of his drawings/documents. The Contractor/Vendor shall make any changes that are necessary to make
make the work confirm to the provisions and intent of the make the work confirm to the provisions and intent of the the work confirm to the provisions and intent of the
Contract. Contract. Contract.
3. Contractor to ensure that procurement of all equipment / components meets the requirements of the Contract. 3. Contractor to ensure that procurement of all equipment / components meets the requirements of the Contract. 3. Contractor to ensure that procurement of all equipment / components meets the requirements of the Contract.
4. Approval or comments does not relieve the Contractor of all obligations covered under contract 4. Approval or comments does not relieve the Contractor of all obligations covered under contract 4. Approval or comments does not relieve the Contractor of all obligations covered under contract