Professional Documents
Culture Documents
to optimize the mechanical properties of blown films. It was zation causes discoloration when it is heated near its melting
found that the preferred inorganic filler is CaCO3 for the point about 200 8C. Therefore, PVOH is normally considered
PVOH stickiness reduction. The filled PVOH films were found as non-thermoplastic (Hodgkinson and Taylor, 2000).
to have delayed or reduced water solubility. It takes about 7 In order to resolve the issue related to the direct melt extru-
to 10 minutes for the filled PVOH films to dissolve in water sion, A. Schulman plasticized PVOH using proprietary formu-
whereas the neat PVOH films are soluble in water instantly. lations and made it available in a pellet form (Aqua-sol 116)
The delayed water solubility may be desirable for certain spe- for melt extrusion processing of neat films or blends (Wang
cialty applications such as packaging of pesticides during ship- and Funk, 2009). Whitchurch and Cooper (2006) reported
ping and storage. With improved processability by incorporat- advances in polyvinyl alcohol formulating and processing
ing filler, the melt extrusion produced PVOH film should cost technology that have enabled a family of water-soluble, biode-
less than the solution-cast PVOH films. gradable PVOH-based thermoplastic materials such as film,
sheet, fiber, foam, tubing, and molded article to be produced
without undergoing thermal or shear degradation. US Pa-
tent 7279510 to Stevens (2007) described melt extrusion of
1 Introduction PVOH-containing composition, which can be manufactured
on conventional extrusion equipment. The compositions in-
Water soluble polymers such as polyvinyl alcohol (PVOH) are clude a lubricant such as a fatty acid amide, inorganic filler,
one of the important commodity polymers for a variety of in- glycerin, and zinc stearate. In some cases, sorbitol or mannitol,
dustries. For example, they are used in adhesives, thermal-sen- etc. has been used as well to thermoplastically process PVOH
sitive papers, gas barrier coating, building materials, packaging in EP 0635545 to Famili et al. (1995). However, it has been
films, polymerization, and textile sizing (Deboer and Yahl, found that melt extrusion of PVOH becomes very unstable
1985; Sewell, 2004; Herman, 2007). Kuraray, DuPont, and and significant residues adhere to the surface of the extrusion
Celanese are the major manufacturers of PVOH resins. Within apparatus, requiring very careful control of processing condi-
the area of film applications, polyvinyl alcohol is processed tions, specialized extrusion equipment and frequent shut down
through a solution casting method by companies such as of the extrusion process and purging of the equipment (Wang
Monosol in Merrillville, IN, USA, or Aicello in Toyohashi, Ja- et al., 2000). In addition, the use of sorbitol results in plastici-
pan. However, the solution process has a high processing cost zer migration such as white spots on the film surface during
due to the energy required to evaporate large amount of water aging, reducing the PVOH appealing to the potential users
* Mail address: Bo Shi, Corporate Research and Engineering,
(Meisel and Wang, 2007).
Kimberly-Clark Corporation, 2100 Winchester Road, Neenah, A few examples of blends comprising PVOH and plant poly-
WI 54956, USA saccharides such as pectin or starch were documented by Mao
E-mail: bshi@kcc.com et al. (2000), Ke and Sun (2003), Fishman et al. (2006), and
Intern. Polymer Processing XXVII (2012) 2 Carl Hanser Verlag, Munich 231
B. Shi et al.: Improving the Processability of Water-soluble Films
Dean et al. (2008), respectively. Glycerin was used as a plasti- 2.2 Equipment
cizer for producing these blends. In addition, reactive extrusion
of polyvinyl alcohol and starches was carried out using ammo- ZSK-30 Twin Screw Extruder (Werner and Pfleiderer Cor-
nium persulfate as an initiator and reported by Willett and Fin- poration, Ramsey, NJ) is a co-rotating, twin screw extruder.
kenstadt (2006). With the presence of starch, material sticki- The extruder diameter was 30 mm with a screw length of
ness was greatly reduced during processing of biodegradable 1 328 mm. A 3-hole die was used to form strands for pelletiz-
and water-sensitive films in comparison to the plasticized ing. The pellets produced from ZSK-30 were then made into
PVOH alone (Wang and Shi, 2008). The recent approach is to blown films using HAAKE Rheomex 252 Single Screw Ex-
create bio-nanocomposites using PVOH, starch, clay and plas- truder with a die attachment.
ticizers for packaging film applications (Alavi and Tang, Göttfert Rheograph 2003 capillary rheometer (Rock Hill,
2009; Majdzadeh-Ardakani and Nazar, 2010). SC) was used for melt rheology of the filled PVOH pellets.
The PVOH polymer has been reported to be biodegradable MTS Sintech 1/D Tensile Tester is an apparatus from which
(Bastioli, 2005). There are several studies on biodegradability film mechanical tensile data was obtained together with the
of PVOH in composting (Fishman et al., 2006) and aqueous TestWorks 4 program.
media (Larking et al., 1999). Normally PVOH material de- A \slosh box" is a standard device made at Kimberly-Clark
grades faster in the composting environment than in the water to test film, fiber, and tissue water disintegration (Wang and
International Polymer Processing downloaded from www.hanser-elibrary.com by Kungliga Tekniska on August 14, 2015
environment. The rate and extent of PVOH biodegradation can Funk, 2009; Shi and Wang, 2009; and Dyer et al., 2010). It
be increased by Pycnoporus cinnabarinus, followed by preoxi- has a physical dimension of a 120 cm · 46 cm · 30 cm
dation of PVOH with Fenton’s reagent. Celanese Chemicals, plastic box on a hinged platform. The one end of the platform
one of the PVOH manufacturers, confirmed PVOH biodegrad- is attached to the reciprocating cam. The typical amplitude is
ability, and the specific PVOH biodegradation information can 5 cm (10 cm range), with sloshing occurring at
be found at its corporate website (http://www.celanese.com). 0.5 * 1.5 sloshes per second. The preferred action is
The date to access the information was December 10, 2010. 0.9 * 1.3 sloshes per second. The time is recorded and re-
To improve the melt processing issues of PVOH, we found ported when film is dissolved in water.
that inorganic fillers such as calcium carbonate and talc,
respectively, were able to resolve the pronounced adhesion
and fogging of volatile plasticizer during the melt extrusion of 2.3 Plasticizing
PVOH to form dispersible resin pellets and conduct film cast-
For personal use only.
ing. In practice, sodium aluminosilicate is also used as filler, PVOH was supplied as granules. The first step in the melt pro-
together with crosslinking agents such as maleic acid and glu- cessing was to convert it into pellets using glycerin as a plasti-
taraldehyde to produce PVOH membrane (Singha, et al., cizer. The operational setup temperatures on ZSK-30 from
2009). Filled PVOH is also less expensive and a cost reduction zones 1 to 7 were from 100, 160, 185, 190, 180, 170, and
depends on the amount of the filler integrated. On the other 165 8C, respectively. The screw speed was set to 190 min – 1,
hand, film mechanical properties decrease as filler increased. with a melting temperature range of 155 to 165 8C and a pres-
Therefore, a good balance is desirable in order to tailor the sure range of 1,378 to 3,447 KN/m2 observed during the extru-
need of film physical properties and film cost. This paper ad- sion process. The torque was approximately 40 %. The higher
dresses the compositions, processing conditions, and properties the percent of glycerin used, the lower the torque became. Gly-
of the PVOH films from these studies. The final selection has cerin was pumped at 10, 15, and 20 %. It was found that glycer-
been made according to several comparisons of CaCO3 and in at 20 % was the best to pelletizing PVOH for water-soluble
talc filled water-soluble films for additional processing and film applications, which was a level of plasticizer used in all
commercial scale-up operations. experiments. A three-hole die was used throughout the com-
pounding process. The resin strands produced by the ZSK-30
were cooled on a cooling belt by a series of fans. Once the resin
2 Experimental had cooled, it was pelletized and stored in plastic bags.
2.1 Materials
2.4 Compounding
Celvol 523S was PVOH purchased from Celanese Chemicals
(Dallas, TX). The degree of hydrolysis for Celvol 523S is A similar process as PVOH plasticizing was done during
88 %. The number and weight averaged molecular weights are PVOH compounding. The PVOH component was run through
61,900 and 148,300 g/mol, respectively. The polydisperity in- a feeder manufactured by K-Tron (Pitman, NJ) and the filler
dex is 2.4. The melting point is 180 * 230 8C. Glycerin was (2sst CaCO3) or talc was fed into the extruder via a side-feeder.
used as a plasticizer and purchased from Cognis Corporation The feed rate of the side-feeder was adjusted to change the
(Cincinnati, OH). Two filler materials were used: 1) Omyacarb amount of filler present in the final blend.
2sst grade of CaCO3 was purchased from Omya, Inc. (Proctor, The temperature profile was similar to those used in PVOH
VT). It has a 2.0 lm median particle size and is well coated plasticizing operations shown above. The screw speed for
with a stearic acid treatment, and 2) talc was purchased from ZSK-30 was set to 140 min – 1. The melting temperature ranged
Barretts Minerals (Bethlehem, PA). It is known as from 170 to 190 8C, the pressure ranged from 1,654 to
H2Mg3(SiO3)4, which corresponds to 4.8 % H2O; 31.7 % 1,861 kN/m2. The torque for the converting screw fluctuated
MgO, and 63.5 % SiO2. around 30 to 40 %.
Plasticized PVOH pellets with and without inorganic fillers The rate of film disintegration in tap water was tested using a
were tested to attain material melt viscosity using a Göttfert \slosh box" (Wang and Funk, 2009). During a test, the slosh
Rheograph 2003 capillary rheometer (Rock Hill, SC). The box rocks up and down with the water inside, \sloshing" back
PVOH resin was added into the capillary rheomter when it and forth. This action produces a wave front and intermittent
was heated to 190 8C. A program was used to control the rate motion on a sample susceptible to dispersing in water. To
of the piston that pushes the PVOH material through a die and quantify a measurement of sample film disintegration in water,
the melt viscosity was recorded. without image analysis, simply timing is sufficient (Shi and
Wang, 2009; Dyer et al., 2010). Three liters of tap water at am-
bient room temperature (21 8C) were added into the slosh box
2.6 Blown Film and resulted in *14 cm water depth in the box. A frequency
of sloshing was 1.3 sloshes per second during the testing. Each
Blown films were made using the HAAKE Rheomex 252 Sin- film sample with its thickness at 30 micrometer was cut into
gle Screw Extruder fitted an annular film die to form a film 2.5 cm (W) · 7.5 cm (L) size. Three pieces were dropped into
the slosh box. The time to disintegrate the sample under the de-
International Polymer Processing downloaded from www.hanser-elibrary.com by Kungliga Tekniska on August 14, 2015
All tensile properties were tested on the MTS Sintech 1/D Ten-
sile testing apparatus. Samples were prepared for testing by
taking a portion of the film, and cutting five dog-bone shaped
samples in each direction (MD and CD). The test length of
each dog-bone was 18 mm, the width in the center was 3 mm,
and the thickness varied around 25 lm. Each dog-bone was
tested separately. During the test, samples were stretched at a
crosshead speed of 127 mm/min until breakage occurred. The
computer program TestWorks 4 collected data points during
the testing and generated a stress (MPa) versus strain (%) curve
from which a variety of properties were determined: modulus,
peak stress, elongation, and toughness.
All data represented the mean of five independent experi-
ments. Error bars shown in figures are standard deviations cal-
culated using a method outlined by Young (1996). Fig. 1. Melt viscosity of filled and unfilled PVOH
processing would be challenged for the talc filled PVOH be- to the PVOH film containing 10 % talc and more than tripled in
cause of the high melt viscosity value. comparison to the PVOH film containing 5 % talc, while the in-
The melting and glass transition temperatures for the filled crease in CD film modulus is also doubled. The PVOH film
PVOH blends are about 180 and 29 8C, respectively. These modulus is fairly stable when CaCO3 was used and the results
values are affected by amount of the plasticizer in the blends, are shown in Fig. 2. A higher film modulus generally indicates
with little effect due to the presence of different types of filler. a rigidity of the water-soluble films. The CD film modulus is
fairly stable, showing there is no difference in talc and CaCO3.
At 15 % talc, the deviation of the MD film modulus is the
3.2 Resolving PVOH Film Adhesion Issue greatest, which is more pronounced in comparison to the same
level (15 %) of 2sst CaCO3 as filler. The reason for this obser-
By extruding PVOH blends containing from 5 to 10 % CaCO3 vation is due to a particle size difference in mineral fillers. Talc
or talc, it was observed that the adhesion of the neat plasticized used for this study has an average particle size of 2.5 lm
PVOH film to process equipment surface was eliminated. One whereas 2sst CaCO3 has an average particle size of 2.0 lm.
of the reasons for adhesion elimination is due to the presence of Another factor to account for the deviation is that 2sst CaCO3
CaCO3 or talc filler on the surface of the films, resulting in re- is coated by an anionic dispersant at low levels so that PVOH
duced adhesion of the microscopically uneven surface. and 2sst CaCO3 is intermixed better than when talc was used,
International Polymer Processing downloaded from www.hanser-elibrary.com by Kungliga Tekniska on August 14, 2015
(MD) (left) and cross-direction (CD) (right) moduli of three CaCO3, regardless of whether it is the film MD or CD mechan-
different P-Celvol 523S blends with different percentages of ical properties. The maximum film peak stress was achieved at
talc or calcium carbonate filler. One standard deviation based 10 % filler except for the film with 5 % CaCO3 as filler in the
on five (5) dog-bone sample data was plotted and shown in film cross direction. The filled MD film peak stress is at 80
the chart as well. and 61 MPa for 5 % of CaCO3 and talc, respectively. At 15 %
A significant increase in the MD film modulus was observed CaCO3, the filled CD film peak stress decreases about 12 % as
at 15 % talc (p << 0.05). It is more than doubled in comparison the filler is increased from 5 to 15 %. Similarly, talc filled CD
film stress reduced about 14 %. Wang and Qi (2010) found the ever, film MD elongation when talc was present is inferior to
maximum peak stress occurred at 5 % CaCO3 filler and film those of CaCO3 filled PVOH films. At 15 % talc, the film MD
mechanical property decreases as filler increased. In this study, elongation reduced 52 % from the talc at 5 % level, and it is
the maximum MD peak stress is at 10 % filler level. The reason only 15 % reduction for the CaCO3 filled PVOH films in
is likely due to different grades of CaCO3 filler materials. machine direction. Therefore, the CaCO3 is the preferred inor-
Normally the desirable film peak stress requirement for ganic filler on a basis of elongation comparison of the filled
flushable products (an example of flushable product is the wet PVOH films.
wipe when it is after the use, it can be disposed into a toilet This investigation to resolve PVOH adhesion issue revealed
and flushed) ranges from 20 to 50 MPa. For all water soluble that P-Celvol 523S possessed the required tensile strength and
films based on filled thermoplastic polyvinyl alcohol, their film elongation for product applications. The film had the ten-
peak stresses meet the application requirements irrespective to dency to curl up on itself when it was cut. This made the test-
types of the filler. Therefore, the film peak stress information ing a daunting task. This curling behavior may be due to the
may not be critical in a final selection of the filler for additional film's low modulus (softness), which could be resolved if a
scale-up work. combination of plasticizers were used. In addition to the ease
of processing, preference is given to CaCO3 because the filled
PVOH film mechanical properties are not significantly af-
International Polymer Processing downloaded from www.hanser-elibrary.com by Kungliga Tekniska on August 14, 2015
blown film making process. The reduced stretching in the CD collection of plates. The presence of fillers and some filler ag-
masked the weakness even though the talc is increased from 5 gregates visible in the films led to tortuous pathway for water
to 15 %. A comparison of the film CD elongation to those of to penetrate to the interior of the film and thus delay the water
CaCO3 filled PVOH films, the CD elongations in Fig. 4 are solubility in comparison to the neat PVOH films that are dis-
similar at 5 and 15 %, but not at 10 % CaCO3 filler level. How- solved instantly upon contact with water.
Fig. 5. A Cross-sectional view of the PVOH film (MD) with 10 % 2sst Fig. 6. A Cross-sectional view of the PVOH film (MD) with 10 % talc
CaCO3 filler filler
3.7 Filled PVOH Water Solubility Larking, D. M., et al., \Enhanced Degradation of Polyvinyl Alcohol by
Pycnoporus cinnabarinus after Pretreatment with Fenton’s Re-
agent", Applied and Environ. Microb., 65, 1798 – 1800 (1999)
All three films disintegrated in the slosh box within 7 to PMid:10103286 PMCid:91256
10 minutes of contact with water. The pure PVOH film dis- Majdzadeh-Ardakani, K., Nazar, B., \Improving the Mechanical Prop-
persed immediately upon a contact with water. The delayed erties of Thermoplastic Starch/Poly(vinyl alcohol)/Clay Nanocom-
water solubility may actually be beneficial for certain packa- posites", Compos. Sci. Technol., 70, 1557 – 1563 (2010),
ging applications such as packaging bags for pesticide, herbi- DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.compscitech.2010.05.022
Mao, L., et al., \Extruded Cornstarch – Glycerol – Polyvinyl Alcohol
cide, fertilizers during shipping and storage. Blends: Mechanical Properties, Morphology, and Biodegradabil-
ity", J. Polym. Environ., 8, 205 – 211 (2000),
DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.1023/A:1015201928153
4 Conclusions Meisel, T., Wang, J. H., \Improvements to the Properties of a Water-
dispersible Film", Kimberly-Clark Internal Communication, Nee-
nah, WI, USA (2007)
Water soluble films based on polyvinyl alcohol were econom- Sewell, D. \Purging with Plastic Film – Water Soluble Plastic Film
ically produced through an extrusion technology. The PVOH Barrier Boosts Weld-Purging Efficiency", Welding Design and Fab-
material adhesion issue has been resolved by addition of the in- rication, 77, 30 – 31 (2004)
Shi, B., Wang, J. H., U.S. Patent 2009/0247036 (2009)
International Polymer Processing downloaded from www.hanser-elibrary.com by Kungliga Tekniska on August 14, 2015
which provides a good balance among film processability, cost Willett, J. L., Finkenstadt, V. L., \Reactive Extrusion of Starch–Polya-
and mechanical properties. crylamide Graft Copolymers Using Various Starches", J. Polym.
Environ., 14, 125 – 129 (2006),
DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10924-006-0002-y
Young, H. D.: Statistical Treatment of Experimental Data: An Intro-
References duction to Statistical Methods, Waveland Press, Illinois (1996)