PLAGIARISM SCAN REPORT

Date 2023-11-27

13% 87% Words 930

Plagiarised Unique

Characters 7862

Content Checked For Plagiarism

Name : ANGELICA MAY C. CLARITO

Year & block : BPA-4B

I. INTRODUCTION
Quality public service has been the target of the government in the last decades
as it continually adopts to new public management and good public administration.
Public service is usually provided by government to people living within its
jurisdiction either directly or by financing provision services. Public sector reforms
have been forced through to enhance the administrative system due to
developmental constraints. The goal of reforms, particularly Public Sector
Governance Reform (PSGR), is to provide the public sector with high-quality
services and long-term performance. The government's efforts to modernize the
public service and make it more responsive and focused on the needs of the
citizenry remain largely dependent on these. Canlas (2018) stated that since 1986,
the Philippine government, under a succession of political administrations, has
pursued a structural policy reform program on several fronts, both economic and
non-economic that leads to inclusive development. This paper seeks to compare
the policy reforms of Benigno Aquino III Administration and Rodrigo Duterte
administration in improving quality services in the Philippines.
II. TABLE OF COMPARISON
Table 1. Policy reforms in the Philippines under Aquino and Duterte
administration
Policy Reforms to Improve the
Quality
of Public Services in the Philippines
Author: Maria Fe Villamejor-Mendoza
Administration: Benigno Aquino, III
Change without Transformation:
Social Policy Reforms in the
Philippines under Duterte
Author: Charmaine G. Ramos
Administration: Rodrigo Duterte
Tuwid na daan: “Kung walang corrupt,
walang mahirap"
Social policy expansion through
authoritarian leaders and ‘narrow
universalism.’
Open government that uses e-bidding
functions
Duterte's leadership in civil-rights
crushing "war on drugs"
Good governance and Anti-corruption
goals: Transparency, empowerment,

Page 1 of 3
public sector performance, anti-
corruption measures, policy
environment for good governance
Anti-drug operations as security
threats rather than public health issue
Good governance initiatives: Philippine
Government Electronic Procurement
System (PhilGEPS)
Use of public resources for social
spending: National health insurance
program, free tuition in public
universities
Bottom-up Budgeting Top-down approach
Improve Delivery of Public Service:
Seal of Good Governance, Anti-red
Tape, Citizen Satisfaction Index
Budgetary appropriations for country’s
conditional cash transfer scheme
Name : ANGELICA MAY C. CLARITO
Year & block : BPA-4B

The above table describes the different policy reforms undertaken by PNoy and
Duterte administration to improve the delivery of goods and services in the Philippines.
Both administrations have different strategies on how to cater developmental challenges
nevertheless seeks to be more efficient, effective and responsive. The first column shows
governance reforms of Aquino administration that focuses to combat corruption, improve
public service delivery to the poor and enhance business and economic environment of
the country as whole. This creates reforms in government procurement through
PhilGEPS, utilize bottom-up budgeting, good governance and anti-corruption goals and
use of open government. On the second column, the focus of the Duterte administration
is on social policy expansion that becomes a tool for political legitimation. This
administration focuses on expansion of access to social goods and services - the narrow
universalism spectrum. Ramos (2020) emphasized social policy reforms of Duterte that
includes “war on drugs,” free tuition fee in public universities, national health insurance
program and the conditional cash transfer scheme to cover the effects of higher indirect
taxes. Top-down process was utilized as mobilizational power of liberal middle classes.

III. PHILIPPINE POLITICS UNDER DUTERTE: A MIDTERM ASSESSMENT

David Timberman (2019) confirmed that the political economic dynamics of
Philippine politics impact the social changes that Duterte is pushing in his article,
Philippine Politics under Duterte: A Midterm Assessment. He talked about the three
tempered facets of Philippine politics: the uneven record of elite democracy from 1986 to
the present; the achievements and setbacks of the administration of Benigno Aquino III
(2010–2016); and the peculiarities of the 2016 presidential election. "Elites dominate
legislative and policymaking processes, successive governments have failed to adopt and
implement socioeconomic policies that address the needs of the poor and middle class,"
he notes in his study of the persistence of elite democracy since 1986. Timberman (2019)
also emphasize the notable policy reform of Aquino administration that was supported by
Mendoza. This entails enacting legislation pertaining to reproductive health and "sin
taxes," instituting a twelve-year basic education program, and continuing public financial
reform. Finally, Timberman and Ramos (2020) concurred that the lower middle class is
somewhat frustrated and dissatisfied with Duterte's social reforms, which is partially due
to the fact that the poorer classes are suffering the most from the drug war.
IV. CONCLUSION
The past 50 years of government reform in the Philippines have yielded mixed
results, including an unwieldy organization and structure with overlapping functions, red
tape, graft, and demoralization of the political and economic elite. To put it briefly, public
sector reforms are essential to the advancement of the country. Reforms are not
considered systemic and sustainable if they do not institutionalize new or altered

Page 2 of 3
behaviors and practices that produce these improved outcomes for citizens. This will
Name : ANGELICA MAY C. CLARITO
Year & block : BPA-4B

result in the rich getting richer, the middle class expanding but staying unstable, and the
poor getting poorer.

References:
[1] Canlas, D. (2018) . “Philippine policy reforms and infrastructure development: a
historical account.” The Philippine Review of Economics. University of the Philippines
School of Economics. Vol. LIV No. 2, December 2017 pp. 61-87
[2] Reforms to Improve the Quality of Public Services in the Philippines1 Maria Fe
Villamejor-Mendoza, DPA https://ncpag.upd.edu.ph/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/The-
Quality-of-Public-Services-in-the-Philippines_Villamejor-Mendoza.pdf
[3] Ramos, C.G. Change without Transformation: Social Policy Reforms in the Philippines
under Duterte https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/dech.12564
[4] Timberman, D. (2019) . “Philippine Politics under Duterte: A Midterm Assessment.”
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
https://carnegieendowment.org/2019/01/10/philippine-politics-under-duterte-midterm-
assessment-pub-78091

Matched Source

Similarity 5%
Title:Philippine Review of Economics (Online ISSN 2984-8156)

https://econ.upd.edu.ph/pre/index.php/pre/article/view/955

Similarity 4%
Title:carnegieendowment.org › 2019/01/10 › philippinePhilippine Politics Under Duterte: A Midterm Assessment
Jan 10, 2019 · Because elites dominate legislative and policymaking processes, successive governments have failed to adopt
and implement socioeconomic policies that address the needs of the poor and middle class. With a Gini coefficient of 0.43,
the Philippines has long been one of the most unequal societies in Asia, with one of the highest levels of poverty ...
https://carnegieendowment.org/2019/01/10/philippine-politics-under-duterte-midterm-assessment-pub-78091%27s/

Similarity 4%
Title:Reproductive injustice, trans rights, and eugenics

https://www.jstor.org/stable/48617639

Similarity 3%
Title:www.researchgate.net › publication › 338531805Change without Transformation: Social Policy Reforms in the ...
Jan 11, 2020 · Change without Transformation: Social Policy Reforms in the Philippines under Duter. te.pdf. Content available from CC BY-N
4.0: Ramos-2020-Development_and_Change.pdf.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/338531805_Change_without_Transformation_Social_Policy_Reforms_in_the_Philippines_under_Du

Similarity 2%
Title:Philippine policy reforms and infrastructure development

https://econ.upd.edu.ph/pre/index.php/pre/article/download/955/850

Page 3 of 3