01 Urban Context 15% The urban context is The urban context is The urban context is The urban context is

and Site Planning unaddressed, and the inadequately addressed, somewhat adequately addressed
site planning has and the site planning is acknowledged, and the and the site planning is
numerous deficiencies somewhat practical site planning is thorough comprehensive
02 Design Rationale/ 10% The concept lacks clarity The concept has clarity; The concept has The concept is well
Concept and fails to address the however, it does not fully originality and articulated and creatively
project goals capture the project goals reasonably captures the captures the project
project goals. goals.
03 Design and 30% The design is not The design could have The design is somewhat Design is very innovative,
Innovation innovative and lacks been more innovative, innovative, and spatial and spatial articulation
originality and spatial articulation articulation addresses creatively addresses the
does not fully address the use of space functional use of space
the design brief somewhat adequately
04 Form and 20% The three-dimensional The three-dimensional The three-dimensional The three-dimensional
Structure form lacks articulation, form somewhat lacks form is well articulated, form is well articulated
however, the structural articulation, and the and there is a clear parity and supported by an
system is functional. structural system is between form and the innovative structural
workable structural system. system.
05 Climatic Design 25% Lacks sensitivity to The design somewhat The design creatively The design creatively
and Sustainability climatic design and does addresses the addresses the uses technical analytics
not address sustainability imperatives of natural imperatives of natural of natural ventilation,
issues. ventilation, solar control, ventilation, solar control, solar control, daylighting,
daylighting, and daylighting, and and utilizes energy-
sustainability issues. sustainability issues efficient strategies and
addresses sustainability
issues.