Pa-No opi OaLine End Term Gxamnation CNov- Dec 202oDate 1.12.

20
iopi

Paper-
Famil Lau-
Park-
Aas. 3
a) I . Latoduc

he sence aCo-pat Cenery tem Ls Uasty L Canbnuanc

Ownership. he enkire atereat eotea L à deperderl on

he ucceive deaths un a a l

For the his park we Ahal_asgume a Mitakihera

purpores
oYajaaalka
Co-pareenary Jit ai enanateyro the code
obdinajr parks oTda induding B.hat, Benaras, 3orla,e.

The basis or aher Lance The rnupleppna.whch

eManates the Cons anguine bloa relation3

The mtats to this xiciple are -that. the dearespat cenar

under
ecopatin ony exkends to our deqtea) descendarts
kara Lau, LNok:- It a aune or ths queation that the Hindu
taks
not ice u e a all
Suceaioo Aet ,19S H.S.AJ does aply
dstincE.
diuxqplabes oM.bkskarn 2 ayalkaga as
nade out de to lack
h te prexent Case, tuD Abatua ore
brothers.
ecbin whether they are Sons or
.No ate

I G&ual Aasus

he eence oCofarcenery elatoshp u de pendant on the

Aurvia o male Momeu un a a i . tr the parpo sea

ths quoties t shall La asuned that A,8, c.0.e ,F.S, H,I,TL

K are Males, as this a caLe a pre- 1956 chana2 oo5 artendet
LArata Shankaç Ax 1g3 1a.

Due to te abiena pecftio, tao madels o Ca-parcenay

relatos oposed The cst one
are here all partes
ary
&xcept A, 1,J/k are adunme e bothecs k Secordy.
ohere all are Codee to e in a Jucusion esl deaandats.

Rdel
A_LConon Aoceator
Oinal Coparce nar ts

3 E F H

TO
K

It dear m this diagram that IFZK are thin

3 geretate dineal desent uith A lCuNON Ancab
and Cinc death Mal is a Suuenie ashiontheir shae
e Cotarenacy yaen Hidu Jout aly LuTF]
acied di
P- No (ate
Topi
3

add 2
A LCommon Ancotoc

D
E

I this Coe he Far-egc woul have to be

e
aacectaine dlbonty 0 tou are lo Juceve generatos

Sice A died eoce B ,2 8 die beoe C 2 So on

0otil Etheour qeneratn emain On E'Sleatn
ole F-G-H{I I - k.

-
Pa.No.
iopic Date

HowoereaCen alter death o , H2

the the dole burviuors
LDould have gauned an interest y det. Anca they
wth te goneataona tndard oitt F & mureve, he
deceaed pnpoety kad paaged on to Hhen Ihis wos a
Aimlar Coseeore the Covi Moro Vchwanath v. aras
Vthal I LR C1813) lo Bom L4]2 was deeded in
a Simlar Mannec.

Decsan
Thsia ia lakt thee authorhes Circunstancoa TNanu
Chap- Ix) the nemes F, I K woud be Coparanu
J tost ModelA len in t Recbd Model hooeres
the Coparseratsp k nay le chalenged as ein the
& u Coxtain Cirtumttarces OtouweLae Shall be a
peumpkionJontes ot eack urthau atleast Vsaa.

I. Tabroducevon
Lder ayalkga Sueten timanly llae)in Wet Berga
there u o teret by hurth apoperty l qacua
Tere thus, a denegar oprapertgkick
ostunu 3uceb00
ko o kechaio Coparenaa Jetweon athuu L sor
due to ahene
due bith iykt n ancastrprpo
The Omery i abo Aaeor Kelyp d adan ac
spnual lendt
 Date

I.factu Analyes
The am dbckur a deacried in the quotion Laoude as

dllouos-
HLRte onaen
Ancesto

(SS) S3
Coarcee (SS)
SSS

Sica te derh the ArcLstor which Intuate he

Coartenansdi i balaga, in tapect o ec peun' s
Common hare, thee i n wnoukip &only actauntio
este_rgkt acbiad a ather's death. vil_partrtion
a ar a opara nac L aai v. hahlul AIR 19 P 147
n e abere a a parbuten, their Ua Copara aae rtoete.
I , DecISion

h, d the heea Case S SS2 SSS Can orm

a CopareAary relatunh betueen Uncde- Nephed 2
qtand Unde -Grand Neghe) relabons, beig Males 2
hau DmOr eteut kanay ak Aor
ertrtion thar
dekcraingd atetst al 4 tume uhih Aal le ou tant. u
the. eaa u Coent artiea Copartenrs.
g-No TopiC Dato-

I. Introducben

Expend.tue J Jot Fanub or educaton 1 Coparcanors

i Coaidered to sbe a daty /Dhacanor groobh

Sual a ccordin tp the lockrine Acceton an Prpert

GCqres hrouglh utilusatn Resourcs Toint aly
theont arlg
Nexus Presued to Je Joint FamulYropert which has
a stake al Copartenor)Jo t ukute ncma ch
UCAuSiklon

Pouaeo an accepted exception thu ode a ound i the

docktie Ganc kearnug hich Auggpat.s that 1ncare
QCqAircArough pexonas Akl elacouired uake any
other ulisatiun o Joiat poperky Letceptor educatnA shaos
the 1nCome uld CoAstituteo be
aeperate propec
This J SD, a an4 pmpery which w acquiedwibhaut
any detinent o Tot ger J eparate yety
CPlacrtum 1, Seeho Ahserk
epucposes h u queatton we. Qume a ta/glara
dstem eore repuduan the H.S.Aia lass.
 I. Fackul Ansdyas

HLfather

A C

Bters

the
Since, A,B 2C wcre qiven ane qlalbyeducaton,
Succes or ailure their prokisoPractce úottbtalle
T their pexbona sklls agphcatuon mincd.
Hind
Moreoren, 8. 20)A Ce) bhe,GaiDs o Learnin At,193o
Provi dedthat any intome earned by urte traia
any
euation kolely aratubtes deparate ropert e the acuir.

h La reattided o ny toade, uaduerfrofexion or

avocotlon 2 S.3 Oveuides all CuutOMD or aspets s
aVocation

1nduue mets or eletion by Jaut amy tunds.

VenfataSubramania v. swara, AiR 1266 Mad. a66

h e dsenca 0rdear Jearr

ny distiction Specialed f0rdinarg etr
the queeton, t sShdle aume that he gais Learnng
Aet phble.
 Date

Further, 8ina A J eaning thu income ram hiseparete

racrice L not on bJoint am.ly Poper by thea
o Colourrble l sqa Saads.
s , an A's Xearn utre ncona are not n

detrimet b» the Jost Faenuy Property. LNarayaslalL

V.

(onteler osute uey

(1a6 Andi eed esh
. Decision

ThJina the lncome inteut bA J acquured a

a egarate mpe-tunder the doctrine g s
eacningby Virt o O sklls &qualiattons , theð
B
B&CC 8hall have no clain Over Such Cone A
peoperky,

( I . htsoductim

Onder he Cancapt ratabaodha daya anCatl propesy

idevolved a3 Joint amly opedty
Howere, th tu lintruductn tha H.S.A, vndaw
Secsn 8 when a on Inleris Prope Itetrtet
e r aA a Jeperate Dervis a vis hú owo
heics due to Auch claucatbo
.No, Date

T. Analysi

oouldideallad t tto Conclusion tht e

devolution eperate fropetyoads to a reoatm
Coacoary test &':thus, lort evey letestate
death o Aa other, the Coparconarshi odd coma
Qn Qn Ond a held in te Cae
m
LCwT V. Chandra Sen, R 986 SC I153

p.ed in the Cae Yusaskter v Ashok,AIR1237 SC 5S3

Thus, it andd Jaad to the Concluuii that do eus Rta kakara
amais Create 2 would dad to dn okol.tion
Tt amues which ould AdSe tho Cata.
T rele e interpetative Conlict. He amondmeats to
S.6i 2o5 ratore the apect odstional parteton
2henca Ho Inplies celon a earlier tee a s
OuTVwoT o other Cogartanoeihau han Hers

TLoeort, the Aature otanj has Changed as a e

Clo I heis uexA rtkas art Clax - ,ts

abo alhet ts the Advidua Share. Ad Hase
rgh wou aCqeat tha te eueu
artiton
Tuis Chuer aecs e sttenent ubich gats dtoei chnye.
 Topic

. Hutration

A LCoon Anctotor

Beloe e pang R.S.A. 00 the deat A he

pestuas dvulgedg urshvarshp to alspartres
ncwdny 8, CL S. Ho»ee i J t e provstors8,9
L lo r 9.( the SA No the intetate
SuCcelon LODald ags bn pom A, o SL S rst
beinCla I Leirs
beina ating a hghea slare Howere,dua
to Motion lartton thair shauo (26 a resewed.
t te itroduction oCenda Neutra Anadnerts, Ju2eadion
j adbo Chan Vis
avimalea. Clasia Hnda Law mtebued.
N. Gnclukon.

Dve tp Notoal farttion Cheracter

hbtly Cheagu sbt at tho dascreho
prop eeb
0, th har
a h eqarade popet artk ab sokte kales._

TAushetabewat J Ooly tr inot

Dart
P No.
Topic Date

Part-A
I. Iat roduction

Ike Propertj dulges eqHallexcot ukoe dsyualfsahas

Onder S.26 the H.SA apply
H= W

S (Sa
S
Hpe H i ta Hndu Ancastor 4 under S.a6 the
S.A7 a deacendastt
ay ea Convete Hiudu
okisualued on a share. Snca S, Conexted Jepac Sas
WG orn
LSh anbl hunarR,v. Su kurar
Cos 1TCC 230(C)
Thu e Anare Propertulle diwided oto 3
eaa aks where e pexonu ull et the eloug
I . Caleulaton

SShare Ld

) W's Skase ed
. No.
Topic Date-

GR) 0's ghare=rd

kud thewdo Son dauglte Loould eot sd ega skars

each as S2 Convete to ChnstaAtA ku re-deceApd Son
disguLod Us 26.

I. Tetreduetion
According to otterHedaya Rbaalt in Molareden Lau)
Ja0 n Cad.tona toneu ownership made wbouk
Cons ideration
Thu, the eaentuels a 9 t are i
)volytary ncodundLd,atsh Mulim
Latlet eaz Constderatn
Ci) At e aceptel l in reltin te rperty
whle a Cond tion 2t uoidalle to the extent t h e
Condstuonbeng noperstve Contuneat t akrh
O l t s el tie on tha hagpening a n e e t
oid.
The eserhals are Mandatory to de lled2
ay digrehn Joads to nvalid Hiba.
AD dulv. Filt AdL Aa 1118 A0 LT 543
Pg.No
13 TopiC Date-

T.fact Ansdygis
Siice in e pebent ae Ns GE t only
e comO lective on 4he kafpei n erent
when S At Can be
1 ter pcede ceased
held to be a |ContiagaE e a

SiaCa a Contuaprt 9t void as per the dicta

i Asac y. Moharved Ae 19u Bom 22), this H.ba
Lill also be electedunder Sunai La

T ecso ancluioe

bepad the loncapt oUet, Suka Ledece

Snca this 9t
nealed perid it s also nalid 9h Law

hus he Contligent nature of a t Only eetve i

N
he hqpeai eOrent devoids peceisar oestalsor
Lhehaqpein
HibaTu S t t a to 8 JVoid undas `a
Aa aleing
en Codibonaly Contin gent. He may ue Vayat
oftewoue haht o the Asaru Cae
eae Hba Voio L electueInyald